Professional Documents
Culture Documents
2004 Election Fraud - Full Presentation 22 Oct 05
2004 Election Fraud - Full Presentation 22 Oct 05
1
PURPOSE
2
AGENDA
4
Precinct Following the vote
City / Municipality
BY PRECINCT
Province
BY MUNICIPALITY
Legend:
Congress
ERs – Election Returns
SOV – Statement of Votes
COC – Certificate of Canvass
5
Irregularities
and Anomalies
6
Page number is printed but
serial number is stamped.
9
Page 1
Page 2
Page 3
of the Provincial
Certificate of
Canvass (COC) of
Agusan del Norte
Page 2 and Page 3 have
serial and page
numbers with uniform
gaps.
Page 1 is different.
Note how the serial number of
Page 1 does not align with the
other pages.
Page 1 shows the list
of candidates for
President and Vice-
President.
Compared to this
ER from San Juan,
can you spot the
differences?
Floridablanc
a
23
How was these done:
Iloilo
Pampanga Cebu
Bohol
2. Inflate the number of expected registered
voters from 38.8M to 43.5M to conceal vote
padding.
Total Registered
Year Population Voters % Increase / Decrease
1992 65,338,989 32,141,079 49% (1989)
+ 4,203,024
1995 68,616,536 36,415,154 53% + 4,274,075
1998 73,130,985 34,136,193 47% - 2,978,961
2001 77,898,184 36,611,363 47% + 2,475,170
2004
Expected Registered 81,357,479 38,807,518 48% + 2,196,155
Voters
In the Project of
81,357,479 43,536,028 54% + 6,924,665
Precincts
Dagdag
Plus
136,659
In the Province of Cebu, the expected number
of registered voters for 2004 was 1,299,612.
Addition / Dagdag
481,096
In Cebu City, the expected number of
registered voters for 2004 was 377,637.
But in the CCoC, the number of registered
voters was padded to total 464,802.
Dagdag Plus
87,165
In Iloilo, the expected number of
registered voters for 2004 was 787,580.
But in the PCoC, the number of registered
voters was padded to total 923,262.
Dagdag Plus
135,682
In Iloilo City, the expected number of
registered voters for 2004 was 191,620.
But in the PCoC, the number of registered
voters was padded to total 240,153.
Dagdag Plus
48,533
In Bohol, the expected number of
registered voters for 2004 was 556,579.
But in the PCoC, the number of registered
voters was padded to total 619,139.
Dagdag
Plus
62,560
Thus, in Pampanga, Cebu, Iloilo and
Bohol, there was an increase of
951,695 registered voters.
951,695
GMA: Hello…Garci.
Garci: Hello, Ma’am, good morning …
GMA: So, will I still lead by more than
1 M overall? ...
Garci: Pipilitin ho natin yan ...
GMA: Ah, ok, ok.
48
Mrs. Arroyo called Garcillano 15 times
from May 26 to June 10, 2004.
81%
75%
56%
44%
25%
19%
88%
62%
58%
42%
38%
12%
FPJ GMA FPJ GMA FPJ GMA
73,274 10,198 74,884 53,495 48,685 79,702
88%
62%
58%
42%
38%
69,504
12%
FPJ GMA FPJ GMA FPJ GMA
73,274 10,198 74,884 53,495 48,685 79,702
62%
56% 56%
44% 44%
38%
ER PCOC
79%
60%
40%
21%
ER MCOC PSOV
93% 93%
56%
44%
7% 7%
FPJ GMA FPJ GMA FPJ GMA
5,376 4,082 545 7,100 545 7,100
DISCREPANCY 7,859
KALA MA NSI G, SU LT AN KUD AR AT
ER MCOC PSOV
90%
78% 79%
DISCREPANCY 15,395
LEB AK , SU LTA N K UDAR AT
ER MCOC PSOV
85%
73% 73%
27% 27%
15%
FPJ GMA FPJ GMA FPJ GMA
14,458 5,265 14,664 5,333 2,678 15,621
DISCREPANCY 22,136
PA LEMB AN G, S ULTAN KUD ARA T
ER MCOC PSOV
95%
71%
55%
45%
29%
5%
FPJ GMA FPJ GMA FPJ GMA
4,486 5,460 3,776 9,127 566 11,723
DISCREPANCY 10,183
TA CU RONG CI TY, SU LTA N K UDAR AT
ER MCOC PSOV
89%
78% 77%
22% 23%
11%
FPJ GMA FPJ GMA FPJ GMA
14,734 4,160 15,226 4,577 566 4,577
DISCREPANCY 14,585
SU LTAN KUDA RAT
ER MCOC PCOC
76%
68%
62%
38%
32% 24%
DISCREPANCY 151,971
COTABATO
ELLEN PERALTA May 26, 2004
Executive Assistant
Office of Commissioner Garcillano
16 days AFTER elections
Len: Hello.
Garci: Hello, Len. I-remind nga sila kung
nakapagpadala ba sila ng SOV 15 to 18 sheets
sa kwan, sa Cotabato.
Len: Dito, sila ano, sila Ester?
Garci: Yung pang switch. Kung sinabihan sila ni
Chairman kasi nagsabi raw si Chairman
kagabi…
Len: Itatanong ko kay ano, kay Ester ho.
Garci: Ok
85
Registered GMA
Region Voters Total Votes % Votes FPJ Votes GMA Lead FPJ Lead
9 1,619,151 1,114,341 69% 537,838 441,799 96,039
10 2,067,109 1,492,414 72% 642,488 630,059 12,429
11 2,134,415 1,500,265 70% 618,110 626,786 8,676
12 1,867,539 1,266,799 68% 405,282 496,942 91,660
ARMM 1,095,441 889,827 81% 549,944 272,715 277,229
CARAGA 1,163,142 878,416 76% 477,461 266,706 210,755
86
But if we look at NAMFREL’s count, we
see some interesting items.
GMA Votes FPJ Votes GMA Lead FPJ Lead
Congress 9 537,838 441,799 96,039
NAMFREL 84% 430,200 383,526 46,674
Congress 10 642,488 630,059 12,429
NAMFREL 87% 529,641 569,030 39,389
Congress 11 618,110 626,786 8,676
NAMFREL 87% 527,984 543,812 15,828
Congress 12 405,282 496,942 91,660
NAMFREL 50% 150,949 280,375 129,426
Congress ARMM 549,944 272,715 277,229
NAMFREL 52% 167,065 249,767 82,702
Congress CARAGA 477,461 266,706 210,755
NAMFREL 72% 337,733 194,209 143,524
87
How were the fraudulent results
legitimized? Noted
• Congressional dismissal of
objections. “Noted” … “Noted.”
3:38 a.m. June 24, 2005
House of Representatives
Recording of Votes on ER
Precinct
98
Election Returns (ER) 99
District
Superintend Election
ent Officer
City /
Municipal
Treasurer
Provincial
Fiscal