Streetwise
Cross-ventilation, espionage, and other routes to urban immortality.
Essay by Judith Dunford
New York City's famous excess in all things applies also to its street names. I started to
notice this last spring when I left the Conservatory Garden in Central Park and saw that I
was passing R. Lonnie Williams Place, not just plain old East 104th Street. After that
honorary signs popped up at me everywhere I looked—streets named Lee Strasberg,
United Jerusalem, Big Brothers and Big Sisters, Isaac Bashevis Singer, Leonard
Bernstein, even Nelson and Winnie Mandela Comer, where the sign has outlived the
marriage. Smaller and easier to erect than equestrian statues, they were a quick and
easy Way to honor heroes and heroic ideas. What they weren't was used or even meant
to be used—I can't imagine any New Yorker who would be caught dead giving his address
as 783 Big Brothers and Big Sisters Street. Manhattan's most notorious example of an
unused name is Avenue of the Americas, which has become a shibboleth for identifying
tourists, and which even cabbies don't recognize. But there it is on the signs.
Nowhere are there more of these
honorary names than on a very short
stretch of Grand Street on the Lower
East Side where, looking out the
window of an M14A bus one day, I
counted five in about as many blocks.
Tcopied them down as I passed:
Samuel A. Spiegel. Rheba Liebowitz.
Samuel Dickstein, Abraham E.
Kazan, william "Bill" Sicklick
(nickname included, a rare
distinction). Who were these people
and why were they being honored in
this way? The next day I went to look
them up.
Samuel A. Spiegel, it turned out, had
been a State Assemblyman, later a
judge, who sponsored a bill that
rotected tenants on public assistance
rom eviction. Rheba Liebowitz, alas,
has nearly disappeared from the
record except as "community activist."
Born in Vilna in 1885, Samuel
Dickstein was for many years a UnitedStates Congressman remembered =
principally for his work on immigration; in a twist right out of John Le Carré, he was a
member of the notorious House Un-American Activities Committee, and also, according to
recently opened KGB files, a Soviet spy. William "Bill" Sicklick maybe the Sicklick who
once ran a fabric shop on’Grand Street—I couldn't be sure.
Except for the espionage moment,
none of this was very exciting until
got to Abraham Kazan, in my admiring
judgment a certifiably great man, the
fathier of cooperative housing in
America. In the 1950s, Kazan and his
colleagues from the Amalgamated
Clothing Workers Union decided to
parlay the experience they had
amassed running their credit union
into borrowing enough funds to build
housing on a large scale. Their radical
idea was that they could sell individual
pieces of ownership to union
members, who would then become
their own'landlords while living in clean, well-lighted apartments. Thus was born the
Amalgamated Houses in the Bronx and a new era in housing.
{he site was picked to be near the bosky pleasures of Yan Cortiandt Park (and also near
the Jerome Avenue subway). Fresh air was a big thing for a population not long out of
tenement railroad flats. Each apartment in this workers’ paradise had cross-ventilation.
(When T was growing up I though the phrase was Yiddish.) The buildings sat on a grassy
campus of walkways, open spaces, and benches—amenitiés commonplace today but
radical at the time.
Ten years or so later there were
between 40,000 and 50,000 union-
sponsored apartments in New York, in
complexes that had sprung up
everywhere—Big Six Towers for
printers, Electchester for the electrical
trades, Concourse Village for meat
cutters, and many others. One of
them was the Seward Park Houses
along Grand Street, also for garment ‘
workers. Kazan served on its Board, along wi e Alex ROSe,
Harry Van Arsdale, Jr., and the legendary David Dubinsky.
Since Kazan's time, thoughtful urban planners like Jane Jacobs have changed people's
ideas about massive high tise buildings by suggesting that these may not always be the
right answer, that they can destroy a neighborhood's integrity, remove the vitality of its
street life, and worst of all, merely create a vertical slum that replaces the horizontal one.
Some of these criticisms surely apply to Kazan-era housing; no one can look at the rather
featureless stretch of Grand Street where Seward Park Houses stand and see it as
picturesque, or perceive anything like front-stoop socializing on the street (maybe it
exists on the benches). As my bus went by I noticed a woman spread-eagled on Seward
Parks lawn in a very, very small garment, probably made these days in Bangladesh, to
sun herself. Street life has moved on—or moved in, maybe—to community raoms in
these buildings.
Yet surely even Jane Jacobs would
agree that people who were crammed f
into places like the Lower East Side's !
Tenth Ward, bounded by Rivington,
Division, Bowery, and Norfolk, might
have found such ‘buildings an earthly
Eden. The smail Tenth Ward, aroughly six-square-block area on my
stréet map, the most congested place
on earth in'1900, packed 15,000
families totalling '76,000 people into
1,179 tenements. The streets may
séem picturesque now in photographs,
and the life remote when you visit the
Tenement Museum, but they were
neither picturesque nor remote to the
people who had to cope with
conditions there, They would have
moved to Brooklyn or the Bronx as
soon as they could, and in turn their
children and grandchildren to the co-
ops, and glad to be there.
=]
Oddly enough—ah, History!—the Tenth Ward fess where the current
gentrification of the Lower East Side is taking place. The loft-Menschen who now vie for
Reighborhood apartments and coolly shell out for a ‘meal at one of its pricey restaurants
what not too long ago would have bought the building in which they sit—these people
might not choose Seward Park. But unlike their forebears they do have a choice.
I went back to see how, specifically,
my list of people had béen honored
and returned unimpressed. No bronze
horses, no abelisks, not even a
plague. Samuel Spiegel gets a bleak
ittle triangle where Madison Street
runs into Grand; Rheba Liebowitz
Square is an otherwise ordinary,
unadorned slab of municipal asphalt;
the fanciest thing about Samuel
Dickstein Plaza is the word "plaza." My
hero, Abraham Kazan, gets his name
on Columbia Street, not nearly as ;
impressive as the big red Seward Park
buildings directly across the street that to a far greater extent immortalize him.
So my tour left me wondering what, exactly, was the point of giving places honorary
names, especially places like the ones I had just seen. They weren't really destinations
("Meet me at Liebowitz Square"? I doubt it.) The names weren't on parks, like Bryant, or
buildings like the Javits Center, where they would be uttered by everyone who went
there. They weren't even the streets’ real names. They would never be used.
Of course any street with a proper name honors someone—a president like Jefferson or
Madison, a rich family like Rutgers or Delancey, an American hero like Pike (for Zebulon,
of the Peak). These names, all in the neighborhood, have acquired an in-place
authenticity over time, and have become their streéts.