Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Eckhard Höffner
Pictures: Wikipedia, Geschichte und Wesen des Urheberrechts
Comparison between a System with and without Copyright The Long History of Copyright and Its Consequences
History of Copyright
Copyright and Its Consequences
Some Economic Problems
Table of Contents
1 History of Copyright
Comparison between a System with and without Copyright The Long History of Copyright and Its Consequences
History of Copyright
Copyright and Its Consequences
Some Economic Problems
Comparison between a System with and without Copyright The Long History of Copyright and Its Consequences
History of Copyright
Copyright and Its Consequences
Some Economic Problems
Population
Great Britain (wealthy country)
1770 – 8.4 millions
1800 – 12 millions (50 % living in towns)
1830 – 22 millions (incl. Ireland)
Population
Great Britain (wealthy country)
1770 – 8.4 millions
1800 – 12 millions (50 % living in towns)
1830 – 22 millions (incl. Ireland)
Population
Great Britain (wealthy country)
1770 – 8.4 millions
1800 – 12 millions (50 % living in towns)
1830 – 22 millions (incl. Ireland)
Great Britain
1710 – Statute of Anne: 14/28 years copyright from the time
of the first publication.
1801 – The effect of Statute of Anne was extended to Ireland.
1814 – Prolongation of copyright duration to 28 years or
lifetime of the author.
Germany
The Holy Roman Empire of the German Nation was divided in
over 300 states (having legislative power).
1805 – Napoleonic Wars.
1815 – German Confederation consisting of 35 states, 4
towns. No wars for half a century.
Pirate publishing was virtually allowed until about 1835/40.
Comparison between a System with and without Copyright The Long History of Copyright and Its Consequences
History of Copyright
Copyright and Its Consequences
Some Economic Problems
Great Britain
1710 – Statute of Anne: 14/28 years copyright from the time
of the first publication.
1801 – The effect of Statute of Anne was extended to Ireland.
1814 – Prolongation of copyright duration to 28 years or
lifetime of the author.
Germany
The Holy Roman Empire of the German Nation was divided in
over 300 states (having legislative power).
1805 – Napoleonic Wars.
1815 – German Confederation consisting of 35 states, 4
towns. No wars for half a century.
Pirate publishing was virtually allowed until about 1835/40.
Comparison between a System with and without Copyright The Long History of Copyright and Its Consequences
History of Copyright
Copyright and Its Consequences
Some Economic Problems
Comparison between a System with and without Copyright The Long History of Copyright and Its Consequences
History of Copyright
Copyright and Its Consequences
Some Economic Problems
Comparison between a System with and without Copyright The Long History of Copyright and Its Consequences
History of Copyright
Copyright and Its Consequences
Some Economic Problems
Comparison between a System with and without Copyright The Long History of Copyright and Its Consequences
History of Copyright
Copyright and Its Consequences
Some Economic Problems
Zahl
13000
Copyright in Germany
12000
11000
10000
9000
8000
Germany
7000
6000
5000
4000
3000
2000
Great Britain
1000
70
80
90
00
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
17
17
17
18
18
18
18
18
18
18
18
Comparison between a System with and without Copyright The Long History of Copyright and Its Consequences
History of Copyright
Copyright and Its Consequences
Some Economic Problems
Significant dates
Copyright Law shows no positive impact
Comparison between a System with and without Copyright The Long History of Copyright and Its Consequences
History of Copyright
Copyright and Its Consequences
Some Economic Problems
Comparison between a System with and without Copyright The Long History of Copyright and Its Consequences
History of Copyright
Copyright and Its Consequences
Some Economic Problems
Comparison between a System with and without Copyright The Long History of Copyright and Its Consequences
History of Copyright
Copyright and Its Consequences
Some Economic Problems
High prices
Comparison between a System with and without Copyright The Long History of Copyright and Its Consequences
History of Copyright
Copyright and Its Consequences
Some Economic Problems
Comparison between a System with and without Copyright The Long History of Copyright and Its Consequences
History of Copyright
Copyright and Its Consequences
Some Economic Problems
Pin Makers
Adam Smith’s example of the pin makers: If the pin makers had all
wrought separately and independently, and without any of them
having been educated to this peculiar business, they certainly could
not each of them have made twenty, perhaps not one pin in a day.
On the other hand, with education and division of work it was
possible to produce four thousand eight hundred pins in a day.
Comparison between a System with and without Copyright The Long History of Copyright and Its Consequences
History of Copyright
Copyright and Its Consequences
Some Economic Problems
The Costumers
Comparison between a System with and without Copyright The Long History of Copyright and Its Consequences
History of Copyright
Copyright and Its Consequences
Some Economic Problems
Comparison between a System with and without Copyright The Long History of Copyright and Its Consequences
History of Copyright
Copyright and Its Consequences
Some Economic Problems
Germany
Comparison between a System with and without Copyright The Long History of Copyright and Its Consequences
History of Copyright
Copyright and Its Consequences
Some Economic Problems
Economic Problems
Economics deal with money, distribution of income . . .
In the long term, copyright (as we have it now) does not help
the authors or readers. It is a distribution rule resulting in
high incomes of the leading publishers and some best selling
artists or writers. It harms the average intellectual producer
and the consumers.
What is the »natural price« of a book or the performance of
an author? Economists don’t like Adam Smith’s term natural
price, because it includes also a fair value idea. When we talk
about a fair system, this question must be answered.
Today, authors are not the real reason for copyright, since
most have to be modest in financial terms. They are satisfied
with an apple and an egg (peanuts) and often lucky if they do
not have to pay for the publication.
Comparison between a System with and without Copyright The Long History of Copyright and Its Consequences