7/11/12

The Evolution Of American Orthodoxy: An Interview with Yeshiva University Librarian Zalman Alpert | J

Home InDepth Interviews

The Evolution Of American Orthodoxy: An Interview with Yeshiva University Librarian Zalman Alpert
By: Elliot Resnick
Published: July 11th, 2012
Zalman Alpert

Books. Some people love them; others claim they can do without them. For Zalman Alpert, they are essentially his life. For the past 35 years, Alpert has served as a reference librarian at Yeshiva University (YU). Educated at Columbia Universitys School of Library Services and New York Universitys School of Education, where he attained a masters degree in Modern Jewish History, Alpert is one of those individuals who knows a little (sometimes a lot) about everything. Over the years, he has contributed articles to such works as Encyclopedia of Hasidim; Jewish American History and Culture: An Encyclopedia; Encyclopedia of Jewish American Popular Culture; Midstream; and The Jewish Press. The Jewish Press: In your three decades as a YU librarian, what would you say was your most interesting

experience or encounter? Alpert: Well, one recent one took place last summer when I noticed a Catholic priest in the library. I started talking to him, and through conversation it became clear that his mother was a little girl during the Holocaust, was hidden by non-Jews, and never came back to Judaism. She adopted the Catholic religion and eventually married a Catholic in Poland. For some reason, however I guess because of the pintele yid inside her she and her husband moved to Israel in the 1960s or so. This young man was born there and attended Israeli schools, but the family later left Israel and moved to a Polish enclave in New Jersey. Subsequently this young man returned to Poland, studied for the Catholic priesthood, got a doctorate in Old Testament studies using the Hebrew he had acquired in Israel, and is now a professor at a Catholic theological seminary in Poland. I couldnt really get this priest to admit he felt Jewish although he knew the halacha and didnt deny he was Jewish. He said he came to the library to familiarize himself with midrashic literature because he wanted to see how the Jewish rabbis interpreted the Bible.
jewishpress.com/indepth/interviews-and-profiles//0/?print 1/5

7/11/12

The Evolution Of American Orthodoxy: An Interview with Yeshiva University Librarian Zalman Alpert | J

Have you ever met people in the library who would otherwise never dare step in YU due to ideological reasons? Absolutely. In fact, many of the more interesting people I have met over the years are chassidic rabbis from Williamsburg. The Pupa dayan, for example, was here, as was the spiritual head of the Organization of Young Satmar Chassidim. They come because everything is in one place, and many of them dont want to go to the library of the Jewish Theological Seminary (JTS) for theological and halachic reasons. In recent years, though, theres been a marked decrease in the number of chassidim who come here because of the availability of such databases as HebrewBooks.org, Otzar HaHochma, etc. Many people claim JTSs library is far better than YUs. True? If youre doing research that requires use of old manuscripts, JTS is better. But if youre doing research that involves books published in the last few hundred years, I would say YU compares favorably to JTS and in some areas is even better. Why does JTS have a better manuscript collection? They started building their collection a lot earlier than YU. When Solomon Schechter took over the seminary in 1902, he brought part of his library with him, which included a lot of Cairo Geniza fragments. Also, Schechter brought faculty members with him who were very interested in creating an academic library, and they went to Europe actively seeking manuscripts and rare books. In contrast, YUs college was first created in the 1920s and the Jewish studies graduate school only started in the late 1930s. YUs library only really became very professionalized after World War II. How many Jewish books does YU own? I would say 300,000-400,000. We also have something like 50 incunabula, which are books printed before 1500. You possess something of an interesting family background. Can you share? My parents were Holocaust survivors from Lithuania/White Russia. In Europe, my father was part of the Lubavitch community, but my mother came from a misnagdic background. I attended Lubavitcher school in New Haven for many years growing up, and then went to YU later on. Do you consider yourself Lubavitch? The sixth Lubavitcher Rebbe, Rabbi Yosef Yitzchok Schneersohn, said there were three sorts of Lubavitcher chassidim: chassidei hageza, i.e., people descended from Lubavitcher chassidim; chassidei hanusach, i.e., people who live their lives according to Lubavitcher minhagim; and chassidei Lubavitch, which I imagine means people who study Chabad chassidus and have a personal connection to the Rebbe. I would put myself in the first two categories. Why not the third? I felt a disconnect in my younger years between Lubavitch and the Holocaust experience. To most other chassidic groups, like Satmar, Bobov, and Ger, the Holocaust was the main to use Zalman Schechters phrase Sinai event of the 20th century. Everything happening in the United States is, in a certain sense, a reaction to it.
jewishpress.com/indepth/interviews-and-profiles//0/?print 2/5

7/11/12

The Evolution Of American Orthodoxy: An Interview with Yeshiva University Librarian Zalman Alpert | J

In Lubavitch, I never found that. I went through the Lubavitcher school system for nine years, and I can honestly say the Holocaust was never mentioned. Do you think the seventh Lubavitcher Rebbe perhaps intentionally avoided stressing the Holocaust because he felt the topic too depressing or paralyzing? I think so. I think the Rebbe had an upbeat message for American Jewry that things would be good, and I think getting stuck in the Holocaust was not the message he wanted to give. Why then are you so focused on the Holocaust? Because both my parents went through it. My father was in German imprisonment and concentration camps from November 1939 to April 1945, and my mother was in German camps from September 1941 until the end of the war. To me, the Holocaust was the formative event in my life. Over the years, you have written on American Jewish history in a variety of publications. How do you explain a phenomenon that intrigues many people, namely American Orthodoxys turn to the right in recent decades? I think a lot of it had to do with the Holocaust survivors. Not all of them were Orthodox, but the small group who were included many chassidim, as well as Lithuanian yeshiva students who became roshei yeshiva and teachers. Plus, there were Holocaust survivors who werent necessarily haredim but were committed to preserving Judaism, even if only to fulfill Emil Fackenheims eleventh commandment, Thou shalt not give Hitler a posthumous victory. But the children of these survivors are even frummer, at least outwardly, than their parents. How did that happen? Thats the reaction. People overdo it and try to become more Catholic than the pope. It happened in every segment of Jewish society in the Modern Orthodox world, in the yeshiva world, even among chassidim. Until the 1970s, Bobov, for example, was fairly modern. Most Bobover chassidim did not dress in the complete chassidic outfit. In the 1950s, they didnt wear the kapote, and even in the 60s, when many adopted it, they certainly didnt wear the white socks or the half shoes. Many of them also didnt wear shtreimlach, and many had trimmed beards. But then things changed. Do you see this rightward trend continuing in the future? Thats a good question. To a certain extent, I think the world is a spinning wheel, a galgal hachozer. At YU, for example, there are many students who are a lot frummer than anyone in the 1960s and 70s, but there are also some who are a lot less frum than anyone back then. I think it was Rabbi Bernard Poupko of Pittsburgh who said: Today, more Jews in America eat shmurah matzah, but fewer Jews eat matzah. I think thats a very valid point. Take New Haven, for example. When I was growing up, there were 10-12 Orthodox synagogues, which were packed on major Jewish holidays. Until the mid-1960s there were also 20 kosher butchers, so most non-Reform Jews kept a kosher home. Today, Orthodoxy in New Haven is limited to probably 200 families out of a population of 25,000. Some people credit the black power movement in the late 1960s with giving Jews the strength and pride to assert their Jewishness. Do you agree? Before the black power movement, there was only one legitimate cultural path in the United States, which
jewishpress.com/indepth/interviews-and-profiles//0/?print 3/5

7/11/12

The Evolution Of American Orthodoxy: An Interview with Yeshiva University Librarian Zalman Alpert | J

was basically the man in the gray flannel suit middle-class America. The black power movement gave the idea of being different legitimacy, and it had a tremendous impact on young Jews. They were no longer embarrassed about their Judaism. They started using Jewish first names, for example. When I was growing up, almost no one used their Jewish name. Everyone was Brian or Phillip. Today, I see little Modern Orthodox kids, and theyre all Eitan, Avi, or Noam. Or take another example: when I was growing up, no one wore a yarmulke in the street; today its an accepted norm. All this because of the black power movement? That, plus the Vietnam War and this whole counterculture movement. The Vietnam War was also responsible for making learning in yeshiva after high school a legitimate option since you suddenly had tons of young men attending yeshivas to avoid the draft. Prior to Vietnam, very few graduates even of high schools like Torah Vodaath or Chaim Berlin went on to study in a beis medrash. The war in Vietnam changed that. The Six-Day War also had a big impact. Jews started coming out of the closets; they were proud to be Jewish now. Finally, the Lubavitcher Rebbe and the baal teshuvah movement also played an important role. Hundreds, if not thousands, of peoples lives were affected by the Rebbes message. You mentioned that American Jews used to use their secular names. Did you especially since Zalman sounds so Jewish? I have an English name, but I always went by Zalman. Did you ever consider dropping Zalman and using your English name? Not in the last 30 years. But when I was younger, sure. I was named after both the first Lubavitcher Rebbe and my uncle who was the rosh yeshiva of the Lubavitcher yeshiva in Nevel, Russia until the Soviets closed it in 1929. So there was a pride in whom I was named after, and it was important to me. Who was your uncle? Schneur Zalman Alperovitch, but in Lubavitch people refer to him after his hometown: Zalman Kurnitzer, from the town of Kurnitz. He later moved to Leningrad and died of starvation during the Nazi siege of the city.
About the Author:

2012 JewishPress. All rights reserved. Printed from: http://www.jewishpress.com/indepth/interviews-and-profiles/the-evolution-of-americanorthodoxy-an-interview-with-yeshiva-university-librarian-zalman-alpert/2012/07/11/ Scan this QR code to visit this page online:

jewishpress.com/indepth/interviews-and-profiles//0/?print

4/5