Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Critical Reasoning
Critical Reasoning
Critical Reasoning
Identify:
Premise Conclusion Where they are positioned How they are related Cue words Type of logic
Unstated Conclusions
Identify the main premise look for links between the premises look for the answer choice that links the premises verify the conclusion against the premisesit must be supported by all of the facts
Unstated Conclusions
When we regard people to be morally responsible for their actions, we regard them as being the object of praise or blame with respect to those actions. But it seems evident that people cannot be the object of praise or blame for their actions unless they performed them of their own free will. Therefore, -----
Unstated Conclusions
People are morally responsible only for actions that they perform of their own free will. People are not morally responsible for actions they did not perform People can be blamed or praised for actions that they perform of their free will People are morally responsible only for actions for which they can be blamed or praised People who are not morally responsible for their actions cannot be blamed or praised for their actions.
Making Inferences
If all the statements are true which of the following must be true? Which of the following conclusions is most strongly supported by the statements can be properly inferred from the passage? With must be true Q, use deductive reasoning With may be true Q, use inductive reasoning
DEDUCTIVE ARGUMENT
INDUCTIVE ARGUMENT:
Answer should be supported by all the premises Remains within the scope of the argument. The scope of the argument is defined by its limits, its boundaries. Linked to the argument
INDUCTIVE ARGUMENT:
Freshmen usually find economics I difficult Jones is a Freshman Therefore Jones finds Economics I difficult
INDUCTIVE ARGUMENT:
Argument by Example
Argument by Analogy
Argument by Example
The US gives billions of dollars in foreign aid to Balonia. Leaders of Balonia resent foreign aid. The US should discontinue direct foreign aid to developing countries.
Argument by Analogy
The conservative and labor parties support a viable economy, including economic growth, industrialization, a fair wage policy and unrestricted immigration. The Conservative Party endorsed free trade. Therefore, the labor party will endorse free trade.
Argument by Analogy
France and England have the same population size France has fluoridated drinking water England will have fluoridated drinking water.
Weeds
Plants Daises
All weeds are plants; all daisies are weeds. Therefore, all daisies are plants.
Plants Weeds Daises
Because all dollars are money and all Yen are money, then all dollars must be Yen.
Money
Dollar
Yen
Dr. Deutchs economics class is difficult. Dr. Jacks economic class is difficult
Difficult J D
Strengthening an argument
Support one assumption Provide additional facts to support the conclusion
Strengthening an argument
It has recently been proposed that we adopt an all volunteer army. This policy was tied on a limited basis several years ago, and was a miserable failure. The level of education of the volunteers was unacceptably low, while levels of drug abuse and crime soared among the army personnel. Can we trust our national defense to a volunteer army? The answer is clearly no.
Strengthening an argument
The general level of education has risen since the first time an all volunteer army was tried. The proposal was made by an organization called Citizens of Peace. The first attempt to create a volunteer army was carried out according to the same plan now under proposal and under conditions as those that exist today. A volunteer army would be less expensive than an army that relies on the draft. The size of the army needed today is smaller than that needed when a volunteer army was first tried.
Weakening an Argument
The recent turnaround of the LEX corporation is a splendid example of how an astute chief executive officer can rechannel a companys assets towards profitability. With the new CEO at the helm, LEX has gone, in only three business quarters, from a 10 million dollar operating loss to a 22 million dollar operating gain.
Weakening an Argument
The passage assumes the the new CEO was the only factor that affected the corporations recent success. The recent success of the corporation may be only temporary. The chief executive officer may be drawing a salary and bonus that will set a damaging precedent for this and other corporations The author does not define probability. Rechanneling assets is a short term solution.
FALLACIES:
Guilt by association Faulty analogy Causal fallacies Post hoc ergo hoc You too
Faulty Analogy:
Tariffs on textiles benefit the textile industry Tariffs on steel benefit the steel industry A tariff on every imported product benefits the economy.
Causal Fallacies:
Roni develops a rash whenever exposed to cactus weed. On his way home from a hike, he breaks out in a rash. Upon applying some ointment, he exclaims, I must have brushed by a cactus weed.
Argument:
Rashes are caused by cactus weed
I have a rash
I must have touched a cactus plant.
YOU TOO:
You assert not to do x But you do x I can ignore you advice not to do x
More Fallacies
STATISTICAL: data is drawn from a sample not representative of population or too small a sample is used to generalize findings. UNWARRANTED ASSUMPTION: has no basis or merit IRRELEVANT APPEAL: Validity is judged based on the the belief of very few people.
More Fallacies
REFUTATION ERRORS: attacking the author of the argument or any piece of information irrelevant to the argument
CIRCULAR REASONING: A premise is restated as the conclusion, or premise presupposes the conclusion