Archive of SID

./01%+%.23%+%.'3
45*06*%78'9:1%7*03%'"50";%7/'<=>";%?2@*%!A5%+%45*2BC'3
%v&P-FPM8% +?Mw%2"2#:+
vv<2"L%x"PYy%&P:+P)Q+
34uzu{%|}#$~H%I$'(9%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%34uu{%|W0($'2%I$'(9

!"#$

!"#$"%&'()*+%,+(-./0%12
34%5(678(9%1%'(:8%;%4%<'()=

%1%5"#$"%&'()*+%>?@"%A(!%,8%B'C8%2'1(6D2%12%E5"#$"%&'()*+%5(F1GH%I$'(9%J$#9%,67K#8%L"%E(M!#MH%N$#OP)Q+
%<P=%,6R"2#H%% !"#$"%&'()*+%&"#8%1"%&2(:-SMH%>?@"% D'#8%,8%E,T(U+%J$"%'2%VW="2% !"#$"%&'()*+% D(-=%XYD
%1"%JZD%[\D%E<P=%<2"2%5(S!%5(+L% ]%'2%1"%^!(_%`-H%>?@"%aM)b9%1%J$?b9% c!?cd%"P68"%E'?e-+%J$"%,8%VWD"
%<P$2#_%5(M8%Nf7-+% !(8L%,8%1%&'1g%h)K%aM@"%h8(-+%L"%EWD"%<P-O"#H%5?_(!?_%h8(-+%'2%,O%(F%a@"%X$(b$%i'(8'2
%VWD"%<P=%<PMf-D%% !"#$"%&'()*+%JMMY9%&"#8%(F%5g% c67$(=%1%Ea+j9%>?@"%J$"%k(M.O%'2%E,T(U+%^+"2"%'2%VWD"
%PU!%"'%(F%5g%1% D'#8%"'%(F%5g% -)l%&(F%WTm2%1%k(l1#n+%CM!%1%(F%5g%o#]%L"%"'%(M!#MH%&(F%<CMc!"%E5(_P!'(c!
%pD(-6+%(F%5g%#F(q%V2'"2%&#F(q%1%J](8%E>?@"%J$"% !?-O%&"?6Q+%1%pMO#9%,O%<P=%<2"2%5(S!%5($(H%'2%VP!"%<2#O
%(F%5g%J](8%(+"%EP=(Y!%#Y6*+%1%P$(M!%5"#$"%&'()*+%5(UUQ+%'(O%,8%<L1#+"%WD"%Jb)+%1%WD(M!#MH%^!(+L%&(FL(M!%(8
%>?@"%5"?9% +%Ek'?@%J$"%'2%VWD"% !"#$"%r-F#0%#678%'2% !"#$"%&'()*+%N:0%1% $(D(-=%&"#8%<P!L'"% $(F'"C8"
V2'1g'2%5"#$"%&'()*+%I$'(9%'2%sMUQ9%sM)*9%W+PR%'2%1%2#O% !"?RL(8%"'%(M!#MH

%&'(% )*+!",-

V(M!#MH%N$#OP)Q+%E !"#$"%#-F%E&'()*+%PU!%E&'()*+%>?@"%E&'()*+%I$'(9%E +tD"%&'()*+%E !"#$"%&'()*+

m;qayyoomi@sbuVacVir%u 6S:8%PM:=%<(cS!"2%E&L(D#:=%1%&'()*+%iPbS!"2%EW+#+%1%&'()*+%I$'(9%<1#_%'($2(6D"%v
6S:8%PM:=%<(cS!"2%E&L(D#:=%1%&'()*+%iPbS!"2%E&'()*+%&#6O2%&?fS!"2%vv

www.SID.ir

Archive of SID

%E(+F;%7'(%EG0;

W7Md%5"#$"%&'()*+% F1GH%I$'(9%'2%(M!#MH%N$#OP)Q+%A?#+%&(F2'1(6D2%J$#9%N:+%V4
%,d%>?@"%J$"% $(D(-=%1%W7Md% !"#$"%&'()*+%&"#8%(M!#MH%&2(:-SMH%>?@"%L"%X$#F% .O%5?)+%V
2'"2%5"#$"%&'()*+% F1GH%I$'(9%#8%&#Mj9
!(+'g%1% $(S!"%($%EWD"%,!"#c='"C_%1%&'(YR"%(M!#MH%>?@"%V
%'(_L1'%>"?"%1%(l1"%(8% ](Y9'"%,d%1"%'(O%1%2?8%,d% !"#$"%&'()*+%>?@"%o#]%&"#8%(M!#MH%&(F%<CMc!"%Vz
W="2%1"
%&"#8%>?@"%J$"%1%k(l1#n+%5g%L"%5"?9% +%,!?cd%1%W7Md%(M!#MH%>?@"%%[H%'2%,6n:!%k(l1#n+%V
W0#_%<#:8%(M!#MH%<"'%^+"2"%1%5"#$"%&'()*+%I$'(9%'2%,$#e!%J6R"2#H

D1!A1

%JM67Z!%i#+L%'2%1"%VWD"%5"#$"%&'()*+%I$'(9%5(UUQ+%J$#9%R(=%L"%}4{44%(M!#MH%N$#OP)Q+%A?#+
%5g%i'(8'2%1% D'#8%"'%5"#$"%^6=~_%&'()*+%EP$PK%5(8L%1%(F%<(_P$2%L"%&#M_%<#:8%(8%P!PM=?O%,O%WD"% !(UUQ+
%5"#$"% 6-D%5"'()*+%2C!%'2%1"%|WD"%<2#O%L(6)+%!"#w"%L"%"'%1"%,O%2'"2% !?_(!?_%&(F% _G$1%(M!#MH%VP--O%#e!%'(:q"
%&(Y$L%&(F#-F%iPbS!"2%%5"#$"%&'()*+%P$PK%^D'P+%JMT1"%5($?fS!"2%JM67Z!%L"%E#c$2%&?D%L"%2?8%<2#O%&2#_(=
%9(yt]"%i2#67_%^-+"2%,!%1"% _G$1%J$#9%N:+%(+"%4VP=%(-=g%CM!% F(cS!"2%5(8L%(8%(f!g%'2%1%2?8%%5"#:9%<(cS!"2
%I$'(9%^*T(+%'2%,$#e!%WM)F"%#8%1"%?w1%,b.8%EL1#+"%&'()*+%5(8L%(8% $(-=g%,!%1%5"#$"%^6=~_%&'()*+%i'(8'2
%1" %"PF" %,O %W7!"2% + %1" %VWD" % !"#$" %r-F#0 %(8 %P!?MH %'2 % !"#$" %&'()*+ %^*T(+ %k'1#l %1 %5"#$" %&'()*+
%L"%&#M_%<#:8%1%&'()*+%J$"%i'(8'2%sMUQ9%}#67_%1%E5g%&(F%}L'"%1%5"#$"%&'()*+%'2%a+j9%,8%5(Y](Z+%k?y2
%1%&'()*+%J$"%L"% .O%>?@"%"C6!"%1%5"#$"%&'()*+%i'(8'2%,$#e!%J6R"2#H%51P8%L1#+"%&'()*+%'2%5g%&(F2'1(6D2
%&'()*+%WD'2%N:0%,O%2?8%PU6*+%CM!%V2?=% )!%sUQ+%(F%XYD%pT(w%'2%(F%5g%&P-8%,UY]%1% .O%&(F% _G$1% $(D(-=
VWD"%Jb)+% !"#$"%r-F#0%(8%5g%&(FP!?MH%WR(-=%(8%5"#$"
%A(e!%'2%5"#$"%&'()*+%I$'(9%^*T(+%#_L(g% y?!%,8%1"%V2'"2%(R% 6M*w?+%5"#$"%&'()*+% F1GH%I$'(9%'2%(M!#MH
%5(-)F%1"%'(g%1%"'g%VWR"2#H%5"#$"%'2%E5"#$"%&'()*+%I$'(9%51 P+% D'#8%,8%,O%2?8% 7O%JM67Z!%1%E F(cS!"2
%P-+L(M!%(M!#MH%i1#H%52#8%MH%1%(M!#MH%'(O%^+"2"%VWD"%5"#$"%&'()*+%I$'(9%^*T(+%h8(-+%J$#9%,*K"#+ #H%1%J$#9%N:+
%1"%i'(8'2%,!g%#6SM8%1%P!"%<PM=?O%#6)O%1"%sM)y%PU!%1%WR(-=%'2%E5?-O(9%>(%J$"%(8%VWD1"%PU!%1%sMw2%WR(-=
VWD1"%&"'g%#$#U9%1%@1%'2%($%$(6D%'2%E,60($%'(S6!"
%(M!#MH%#c$2%5(UUQ+%(8%#6S+%(6O%X$%1%E'2%&(F%tO%1%(F%,T(U+%pT(w%'2%"'%$(F%,60($%1%(F%,S$P!"%(M!#MH
% D(-=%XYD%1% !"#$"%&'()*+%>?@"%E,-M+L%J$"%'2%(M!#MH%&(F2'1(6D2%J$#9%N:+%zV2#O%#S6-+%4%#70"%1
%h8(-+%#8%(b9"%(8%"'%% !"#$"%&'()*+%>?@"% -*$%2'1(6D2%12%J$"%L"% b$%N$"%<PM=?O%%,T(U+%J$"%'2%VWD"%5"#$"%&'()*+
VNM-O%a+j9%(F%5g%'2%1% !"?RL(8%EWD"%#9%X$2C!%1"%2?R%5(8L%,8%,!g%1% .@"

!"#$"%&'()*+%,+(-./0%12
34%5(678(9%1%'(:8%;%4%<'()=
!

www.SID.ir

Archive of SID

?2@*%H62#I%JK

!"#$"%&'()*+%,+(-./0%12
34%5(678(9%1%'(:8%;%4%<'()=
"

%,6R"2#H%1%W0#_%A"?w%1"%JF%'2%,60'%,60'%,b.8%E<'(Yb$%,!%>?@"%J$"%,O%2?=% +%A?.*+%(M!#MH%'(g%1%>"?w"% D'#8%L"

%1"%,O%22#_% +%ZS+%5g%J6R(D%t+#8%1% f$'P9%J$?b9%J$"%L"%"#$L%EWD(M!#MH%L'(8%k(n@%L"% !(S!%CM!%J$"%VP=
%EPMD'% +%,O%&"%,fM6!%#F%,8%1%2?Y!%'(d2%EWD"%,60#_%"'% !"#$"%5(UUQ+%L"%&'(M78%J+"2%,O%A?F?+%>()O%&'()M8%,8
%5($?fS!"2%1%5(UUQ+%'(M6R"%'2%#921L%"'%$(F%,60($%NF%E<"'%J$"%L"%V2#O% +%#S6-+%"'%5g%Eh+(K%1%a+(O%5"P-d%,!%?T1
%P-+%<#:8%5(!g%#e!%L"%1%W="~_% +%5"#c$2%&"'g%#*+%'2%"'%(F%5g%NF%21C0"% +%(F%5g%#Mj9%#)y%#8%1%W="~_% +
%#8%1%2P-Y8%>2%(F%5g%^MT1"%pM9#9%,8%,b!g% 8%"'%>?@"%W0($% +%W@#0%2?R%NF%1%E2#O% +%ot@"%"'%>?@"%1%P=% +
VP-O%#9%,6R"2#H%1%#6:8%,60'%,60'%E2L'1%p/*9%(F%5g
%[H%1%E}443%44%<PbS!"2%L"%MH;%N$?=%a(w%N:+%^F#8%,D%(M!#MH%&"%,0#%1%&#b0% _P!L%&"#8%#_"
%L"%[H%i'12%'2%W7Z!%"'% !"#$"%&'()*+%>?@"%}4{%4%tU!"%L"%[H%E}4%4z%<PbS!"2%L"
%>?@"%J$"%E<'12%5g%'2%1"%&(F%,Y(/+%1%(F%,T(U+%#6SM8%'2%V2?Y!%a@"%`-H%L"% -ZD%EL(g%'2%V2#O%,l#y%<PbS!"2
+%WnKPH%1%WnK%1%E}'(M!%1%5?)MH%1%&'"1%A2#+%E $"#_%51'2%5?d% T?@"%'(:d%L"%2?8%k'(Yy
%t
%L"%E,6=?!%5"#$"% !(6D(8%'(g%Wq(n% .+%5(+L(D%'2%WMT(*0%5(+L%'2%E4%>(D%'2%,O%,D?6+%i'12%#-F%(6O%'2
%&'"1%A2#+%^T(U+%'2%E4%>(D%'2%%E4%(M!#MH%VWD"%<2#8%A(!%WnKPH%1%WnK%1% $"#_%51'2%a@"%12
%{z%{%E5()F%VWD"%WnKPH%1%WnK%1%5?)MH%E $"#_%51'2%E&'"1%A2#+%>?@"%J$"%E5"#$"%&'()*+%'2
%<P=%'"#b9%E5"#$"%'2%&'()*+%5?-0%1%(F%<?M=% D'2%i1CK%'2%E4%>(D%'2%>?@"%JM)F%z4%E%(9% 8%?)F
%A(!%,8% !"#$"%&'()*+%'2%&"%,8(l%($%a@"%L"%'(/6R"%%,8%2'?+%12% b$%'2%EJ$"%#8%<1ty%%z%E4%?)F%VWD"
%E%(9% 8%?)F%VWD"%,6n_%JZD% !"#$"%&'()*+%'2%2(/6w"
%>?@"%J$"%2?R%(+"%z%E4{z%?)F%2#O%WMY9%"'%%a@"%`-H%%>?@"%J$"%#MR"%'()=%4{%^F2%'2%'(8%JM67Z!%(M!#MH
%i'(8'2%1%2#O%2($%aU67+%a@"%12%5?d%CM!%5?)MH%1%}'(M!%L"%E,F2%J$"%'2%5(-ZD%JM67Z!%'2%V2?8%#MM9%'2%5(-)F
%1%2'1#H%"'% !"#$"%&'()*+%'2%2(/6w"%?l?+%E&P*8%&(F#$#U9%'2%{%E5()F%V2#O%Q8%,!(_"PK%CM!% $"#_%51'2
%}'(M!%1%2#O%~%>?@"%L"%"'%WnKPH%1%WnK%2#O%o#+% _2?:M8%L"%CMF#H%1% _P-782?R%a@"%12%pT(w%'2
%%{%E4%%%ET"4%3%ET"%(9% 8%?)F%V2#)=%a@"%X$%NF%(8%"'%5?)MH%1
%CMF#H%Vz% _P-782?R%V% $"#_%51'2%V%&'"1%A2#+%V4%|WD"%JM-d%4%^F2%'2%>?@"%J$"% $(:!%pM9#9%1%5"?-y
%4{%k(01%5(+L%(9%(M!#MH%{{%E4%%ET"4%3%1%%ET"%(9% 8%?)F%5?)MH%1%}'(M!%V% _2?:M8%L"
VP-O% -%>(+%1%Ml?9%(8%"'%(F%5g%1%PF2%5(S!%"'%(F%5g% 6D'2%PM=?O%,6D?MH%1%2#O%n%"'%>?@"%#MR"%pM9#9

?2@*%45*2BC'3%JL

%[\D%ENM-O% +%?_L(8%aM@"%h8(-+%&(-Y+%#8%"'%(M!#MH%&2(:-SMH%>?@"%L"%X$#F%'2%,$(H%&(F%<'"C_%W)7w%J$"%'2
%VNM-O%a+j9%a@"%#F%&(FP+(MH%1%(-*+%'2%NM=?O% +
78*+%./01%JKML
%a@"%J$"%,O%2?8% yP+%1"%VWD"#MH%1%WR"2#H%"'%5g%5($(H%(9%1%2(:!%MH%(M!#MH%,O%WD"% T?@"%JM67Z!%L"%&'"1%A2#+
%VWD"%,6R?+g%5"#$"%i2?+Lg'(O%5"'()*+%L"%"'
%ET"4%?)F%P=(8%<P=%W$(y'%?.+%?Q!%,8% !(7!"%(MU+%E5g%'2%,O%WD"%'"1%A2#+%<(c!g%(-8%E1"%#e!%,8
%JM-d%,8%5PMD'%&"#8%3{%E4%?)F%VP=(8%,6="2%pD(-9%1"%&(FL(M!%1%5(7!"%&(F%A"P!"%(8%(-8%&(F%A"P!"% -*$%
+(O %5?_(!?_ %&(F%,@#y %'2 %"' %1" %&(FL(M! %1 % !"#$" %5(7!" % _P!L %W7$(8 %'()*+ %E&2?/U+
%?)F %VWR(-=% + %t

%E&'2%,D%t+%EWR(D% +%<2"?!(R%'(*6+% _P!L%&"#8% w(9"% 6w1%,O%2?8% 6R(-=%JM-d%&(-Y+%#8%4%ET"4

%2(*8"%1% $(-=1'%1%2#O% +%<2'1g#8%"'%1"%&(FL(M!%E$?67H%1%'%1%,w(]%1%2?8%pD(-6+%<2"?!(R% _P!L%(8%}2(*8"
+(O%!L1'
%P!?MH%,8%NF%,!(R%L"%#9"#0%(MU+%'2%{%E4%{%E4%?)F%V2?8%<2"?!(R%&(FL(M!%iL"P!"%,8%t

www.SID.ir

Archive of SID

%1%2?=%n%(F%,!(R% @?/R%N$#%NF%P=% +%pK?+%,O%2?8%a@"%JM)F%VW="2%,K?9%(F%5(7!"%&(FL(M!%1%(F%,!(R

%,6="P!%#YR%,$(7)F%>(%L"%,$(7)F%,O%2L(78%5(-d%"'%,!(R%E'()*+%#_"%VP-=(8%,6="2%#YR%NF%>(%L"%5(c$(7)F%NF
+%P=% +%5?_#_2%2(*8"%J$"%E2#O% +%(6w"%(FL(M!%1% _P!L%#_"%%E4{z%?)F%VW7M!%'"1%A2#+%,!(R%5g%EP=(8
%'2%t
%&'"1%A2#+%&(6U+%CM!%J$"%VP=(8%P-.8%'(M78%UD%,O%2#O% +%(6w"%<(=%<?b=%$()!%1%'(M78%WM*)K%EA(y%'(8%'m(9
+(O% !"#$"%'()*+%ECM!%,D'P+%J6R(D%'2%{%E4%?)F%VWD"
%,Y.]%V2'~_% +%,D'P+%'2%,O%2?8%&"% _P!L%,K?6+%t
%&?D%1%Jb6R'%$?D%X$%5(7!"%L(M!%iL"P!"%,8%WD'2%&"%<#f%|2'"2%L(M!%5P!"?R%'2%1%J67$L%&"#8% w(9"%,8
%NF%1%<#f%&"#8%WD"% $(0%MH%NF%,O%WD"%&"%,!"?$"%E<#f%#F%?.K%'2%V?67H%6SH%1%&'(Z8%&(K%}#c$2
% F"?Z!% F"?R%?fS!"2%1%P-MS!% +%,!?_%(8% -Q@%2#_%#8%(F%<#f%V!(6D12%1%?fS!"2%^(Y+%&"#8%WD"% $(K
%1%z%E4{z%?)F%VP-O% +%"?w%P$Pf9%1%2'~_% +%(Y$L%^]?Q+%5g%L"
%pD(-6+% -*$%WD"% !(7!"%(MU+%EP8($% +'2%&'"1%A2#+%a@"%L"%5'P+%&'()*+%NMF(n+%(8%?!j+%JF%,!g
%5(-d%a@"%J$"%L"% F(_%(M!#MH%VWD"%J$"%L"%#9"#0%&'"1%A2#+%L"%(M!#MH%2"#+%(+"%5(7!"%5P8%&(F%<L"P!"%(8%(-8%PYT(O%52?8
%(Y-6D"%% !()7K%1%&PYT(O%&#+"%U0% -*$%%5(7!"%&(F%A"P!"%(8%(-8%&(F%A"P!"%pD(-9%U0%E5g%L"%,O%P$?_% +%JZD
%VP!"2% +% !()7K%pD(-9%L"%M8%"'%pD(-9%J$"%1"%,O%NM8($% +'2%Ea@"%J$"%i'(8'2%1"%JZD%^)F%^*T(+%(8%(+"%E2?=% +
% )$Pw%(9"%X$%'2%P$#8% +%"'% )$Pw%'()*+% 6w1%1%P=(8%pD(-6+%1"%>"?"%1%5(7!"% _P!L%(8%P$(8%(-8%P$?_% +%&1
%'(60'%1%>"?"%pD(-+%,O%WD"%5g%2"#+%E2'"P!% !(7!"%(MU+% -*$%W7M!%'"1%A2#+%P$?_% +%EVVV%W7M!%pD(-6+%,O
%52?8%,D'P+%'?R'2%(-8%5g%($%EW7M!% _P!L%pD(-+%(9"%J$"% -*$%W7M!%P=(8%(f!g%'2%PF"?R% +%,O% +2g% _P!L%1
%1%'?!%WMnMO%1%'"PU+%L"%E&'"1%A2#+%$#*9%'2% 6%44VW7M!%5g%5(-O(D%1%(F%,Y.]% _P!L%1%>"?"%'?R%'2%W7M!
%,8%VP=(8%pD(-6+%5g%51'2%'2%5(7!"% _P!L%(8%,O%WD"%'"1%A2#+% $(-8%[H%VP$?_% +%JZD%CM!%T(/+%[-K%1%?!
%pD(-9%5(7!"%&(F%A"P!"%(8%,b!g%(8%"#$L%EP!"2% +%'"1%A2#+%NF%"'% S-+(ZF%P-)F?b=%1%P-.8%(O%(M!#MH%EpYD%JM)F
%&(F(-8%"#d%W7M!%A?.*+%E,)F%J$"%(8%V2'"2%pD(-9%'(8%A(c-F%'2%<(=2(H%<?b=%&(6w"%1%5g%51'2% _P!L%(8%E2'"P!
%51'2% _P!L%'?R'2%CM!%(F%5g%<?b=%P$(=%,O% T(%'2%EWD"%<PMF?b!%52?Y!%'"1%A2#+%pYD%,8%"'% 9'(H%i?M=%ENMey
VP=(8%<2?8%(F%5g
%5(7!"%>"?"%(8%,O%WD"%&"%&'()*+%E?.+%&'()*+%,O%P-O% +%5(M8%"'%2?R%2(U6y"%J$"%a@"%J$"%5(M8%(8%(M!#MH
%1%5(7!"%,8%,K?9%EWD"%a+j9%'?R'2%a@"%J$"%'2%CMd%#F%L"%M8%,!g%VP=(8%pD(-6+%5g%51'2%'2%5(7!"% _P!L%1
%VWD"%,6D?MH%&#+"%E _P!L%1%&'()*+%VWR(-=%5g%51'2% _P!L%(8%P$(8%"'%&'()*+%E(M!#MH%#e!%L"%VWD"% _P!L%,8%,K?9
%L"%&'()*+%,8%P$(8%CM!%5(UUQ+%EP!'1g#8%(-8%51'2%'2%5(7!"% _P!L%1%5(7!"%(8%pD(-6+%"'%(-8%P$(8%5"'()*+%,O%5(-)F
VP+(f!"% +%&'()*+%L"%w(!% 6R(-=%,8% _P!L%L"%aU67+%&'()*+%,8%J6R"2#H%1%P!#c-8%NSd%J$"
+ %P-O% +%o#+ %&'"1%A2#+%a$%"' % _P-782?R%,8 %?8#+ %PF"?= %1 %k(y?l?+% 6 %<(_%,_ %(M!#MH
%i'(8'2 %t
|P$?_% +%N$Pw%&(F%,!(R% +?8%T(/+%1%(F%(9"%P-8%8(9%1%5L1'%i'(8'2%Ml?9%L"%[H%E&'"1%A2#+
%(8%1%P!"%,6="2%2?R%,d#F%L"%VP!'1(M8%P-F%L"%"'%8?d%1%r!#0%L"%"'%}"%,SM=%,O%P!"%,67S-!%<"'%,8%NSd%1%VVV
%,O%P!"%,6R(D%5(-d%1%P!"%,6R(D%2?R% !(_P!L%'?R'2%1%2?R%&"#8%&"%,!(R%EWD"%<2?8%5(SD#6D2%'2% !(Dg%,8%,d#F
%'2%,O% $(F%,$(+L(D%L"%&#M_%<#:8%(8%1%2?R%WD2%,8%EWD"%<2?D#0% +%5g%L"% +"P!"%1%,67b=% +%5g%L"%&"%,=?_%#_"
%&"%&'"1%A2#+%WD"%J$"%VP-F"?Z!%,!(cM8%L"%"'%2?R%,!(R%&'"P:c!%1%P--O%&L(DL(8%"'%5g%EP-!"?68%P!"%,6="2%2?R%5?+"#MH
%E43%?)F%V2'1g% +%5(8L%#8% _2(D%%,8%<2?+Lg'(O%i2'?ZT(D%2(6D"%,O
46*0N%O+8/%JLML
%EXYS+% 7nw%P-!(+%"'%(-8%<(_%V"#_%51'2%1%"#_%51#8%|WD"%,!?_%12%#8%L(8%1%,678%&(F(0%A(e6!"%#e!%L"%5(:K%&(F(-8
%1%P!'1g% +%(-8%51'2%,8%"'%L(8%^]?Q+%<(_%P!#c!% +%"'%51#M8%1%P--MS!% +%5g%51'2%1%P-:!% +%L(8%^]?Q+%5(M+%'2
%JM+L%#+%&(F(-8%L"%&'(M78%VP--O% +%L(M!% 8%(-8%51#M8%,8%J67$#c!%L"%"'%5g%1%P-!(S!% +%5g%2#_%#8%"'%,678%^]?Q+
%(F(-8%#6SM8% -*$%WD"%[by#8%WD'2%5"#$"%'2%VWD"#_%51#8%E5(S-M+L#D% *MY]%hl1%,8%(-8%E'12%#=%1%P-F%1

!"#$"%&'()*+%,+(-./0%12
34%5(678(9%1%'(:8%;%4%<'()=
#$

www.SID.ir

Archive of SID

!"#$"%&'()*+%,+(-./0%12
34%5(678(9%1%'(:8%;%4%<'()=
##

%J$"%2#_%#8%"'%(-8%&"CK"%'()*+%%ET"4%?)F%V2#M_% +%}?g%'2%"'%L(D%WD2%L(8%^]?Q+%(-8%1%WD"#_%51'2
3%E4%?)F%VWD"#_%51'2%E1'%J$"%L"%1%P$"#_% +%1%2#c!% +%2?R%51'2%,8%(-8%[H%VP-Md% +%L(D%WD2%i#e-+
%&(F2(8%1%XSR%&"?F%WD"%XSR%1%A#_%5"#$"%#6SM8%&"?F%1%%g%VWD"%5"#$"%NM.w"%L"%,6D(R#8%E $"#_%51'2
%CYD%&#e-+%P!"?68%,b!g%&"#8%'()*+%V2'"P!%<2#67_%1% *MY]%#q(-+%1%2'"2%5"L?D%(60g%1%5"1'%&(F%J=%1%<P-F2%'"Lg
%'?/Q+%1%21PQ+% 6*D1%'2%"'%5g%,O%WD"%'(d(!%E2'1g%P$PH%A#_%1%XSR%#$?O%5(M+%'2% 6S:8%5?d%EP-$(=?R%1
%#c$2% $"?F%1%%g%,O%5"#$"%L"% $(F(K%'2%,O%WD1'%JM)F%L"%L(8%%E4%%ET"4%{%E4%?)F%VP-O
{%E4%?)F%VP!L(D% +%NF%"#_%51#8%&(F%,!(R%E5(6D#T%1%5(6D2#O%1%>()=% "?!%P-!(+%E2'"2
%,60($%'?:q%"#_%51'2%&'()*+%'2% !"#$"%r-F#0%L'(8% _G$1%,D%VW7F%NF% !"#$"%r-F#0%L"%,6D(R#8% $"#_%51'2
%5"'()*+%1%5(M!"#$"%2C!%'2%51'2%'2%a+j9%,8% !(0#y%aM+%(F%5g%JM67Z!%VN$#%(f% !(0#y% $"#_%51'2%|WD"
%,K?9%51'2%,8%#6SM8%P$(8%,O%2?8%,60#_"#0%'(y%5?)F%1%2?8%"#_%51'2%E !"#$"%'(y%P-!(+% !"#$"%'()*+%VWD"% !"#$"
%E5(M!"#$"%VWD"%5g%A(y%&(-*+%,8%(f%E !"#$"%r-F#0% _G$1%JM+12%4{3%%ET"4%?)F%V51#M8%(9%W="2
%aM+%J$"%VP!'"P8%?nQ+%A?)y%P$2%L"%"'%5(=% @?/R% _P!L%P-6="2%WD12%E5g%L"%[H%NF%1%AtD"%L"%MH%'2%NF
%(f%n%,O%WD1'%JM)F%L"%%ET"4%?)F%VWD"%<P=%51'2%,8%52#O%&1'%1%51#M8%L"%5P!"2#_%&1'%pK?+
%!?+"#MH%'2%(-8%&"CK"%#c$2%1%(F%(9"%1%5(M+%'2% ](M%(8%W0($%5"?9% +% +tMy%&'()*+%'2% 6%"'%WM+#Q+%1
%E(='($(SR%&?bS+ %($%A#%,.)K%L"%EPMS)K%WZ9%&(F(-8%^)F%'2%WD"%JM-)F%V5L1'% 8%1%<2(D% K'(R%&()!%1
%A?D% _G$1%44%E4%?)F%VWD"%<P=%k(y"#+%#6SM8%&#M_%WZD%(8% 6%EA?)y%P$2%L"%51'2%n%(F%5g%'2%,O
%'2%a+(O%>tU6D"%1%&2"Lg%pT(]%E !"#$"%VWD"% /Z=%N$#%n%E,60($%'?:q% $"#_%51'2%'2%,O% !"#$"%r-F#0
%5g%&(F22#9%1%#:=%L"%"#_%51'2%^!(R%VP$g% +%WD2%,8%,!(R%L"%"P68"% _P!L%>tU6D"%1%WD"% /Z=%N$#%1% _P!L
%"'% $"#_%51'2%4%ET"4%?)F%VW7$L%'(M"%NSd%L"%'12%E'(M6R"%1%>tU6D"%,8%1%2?Dg%5"?9% +%5g%'2%1%WD"PK
%(8%,8%WY7!%(8%5(M+%X=?O%VWD"#_%51'2%E51#M8%MQ+%,8%WY7!% !"#$"%(8%VP$2%5"?9% +%CM!% !"#$"%&(F%(8%'2
%5g%'12%,8%"'%$"CK"%,O%2'"2% !(M+% $(0%2?R%51'2%'2%L(8%"#$L%EWD"#_%51'2%}2?R%,8%WY7!%(+"%EWD"#_%51#8
%4%?)F%VP!"%<PMd%5g%,8%1'%1

%(8%"'% $"#_%51'2%WY7!% $(K%'2%t+%WD"%#+%&'Pw%5g%a.y%1%(YD"%1% $"#_%51'2%i'(8'2%(M!#MH%JZD

% $(K%'2%1%WD"%NM.w"%L"%<P+g#8%( 0#@%&#+"% $"#_%51'2%P$?_% +% $(K%'2%Vk(Y"%#c$2% $(K%'2%1%P-O% +%'(b!"%J$2
% f$'P9%J$?b9%,8%,K?9%1%(M!#MH%'(g%'2%a+j9%(8%E>(%J$"%(8%4zV2'()=% +%NM.w"%,.)K%L"%a+(y%P-d%a@(%"'%5g%#c$2
%,67!"2% +% !"#$"%&'()*+%5P=%"#_%51'2%pK?+%"'%a+(y%,D%1"%,O%W0($'2%5"?9% +%E>?@"%i'(8'2%1"%&(F%,S$P!"
%WM)F"%1%5?-O%(9%L(8#$2%L"%5(M!"#$"%2C!%'2%(f%WM)F"%V%2?R%[n!%1%>2%1%51'2%,8%5(M!"#$"% -](8%aM+%V4%|WD"
V )M.w"%a+"?y%V% @?/R%i21PQ+%>tU6D"%n%1%N$#
|aMYw%L"%2'"2% ):+%&(F%WTm2%a@"%J$"%E !"#$"%&'()*+%'2%a@"%J$"%>?)=%5"CM+%L"%,6=~_
%iP!L(D%5(7!"%Wn@%V2"2%WY7!%% $"#_%51'2%% !(7!"% 6n@%&'()*+%,8%5"?9% +%VP!"%aMYw%X$%L"%&'()*+%1%5(7!"%
%VPD'% +%'?:q%,8%&'()*+%'2%%A2#+%,d%1%'()*+%,d%(-8
%5(!g%&12%#F%,8%5"#$"%JM+L#D%1%r-F#0%"#$L%E'(y%^D"1%,8%,!%2?8%#j6+% !"#$"%r-F#0%L"%2?R% !"#$"%'()*+%
%JM+L#D%1%r-F#0%(8%5(S6Y7!%#e!%L"% !"#$"%'(y%1% !"#$"%'()*+%E#c$2%JZD%,8%VP-=(8%"#_%51'2%,O%2?8%,6R?+g
%VP!L"#9%NF%5"#$"
%1%W:K%NF%AtD"%1%WD"%5(M!"#$"%^-$#$2%Wn@%,b.8%EW7M!%5(!().7+%6Z+%N$#%1%(f%,8%52"2%WM)F"%
%VWD"% !"#$"% _P!L%i?M=%L"%<P+g#8%&#+"% $"#_%51'2%VWD"%<2?8%5g%P$+
%,8%,O%P!"?RL(8%1%WR(-=% 6D'2%%,8%5"?9% +%<(c!g%"'% !"#$"%&'()*+%'2% 6n@%,b-$"%#9%N:+%1%#9m(8%,)F%L"%
%&(M0"#K%1%5"#$"%JM+L#D%1%5(S$"% _P!L%i?M=%1%5(!g%WM/Z=%1%5(M!"#$"%P$(Uy%1% !"#$"%r-F#0%1% !"#$"%5(7!"
VP=(8%,6R"2#H%( +?9%1%5(+L%NF%5g

www.SID.ir

Archive of SID

4N!=P3/2B%JQML
%P!'1g%WD2%,8%aQ+%J$#9%X$2C!%L"%"'%5g%T(/+%1%2"?+% -*$%E(-8%&(F%,$(+%WR(D%P!PM=?O% +% !"#$"%5"'()*+
%,O%P!2?8%'1(8%J$"%#8%5(!g%4%E4%?)F%VP-=(8%<P-782?R%P!PM=?O% +%P-=(Y!%#c$2%&(F%aQ+%P-+L(M!%1
%<#:8% .Q+%k(!(b+"%L"%EJb)+%P%(9%P$(8%(-8%J6R(D%'2%1%P=(8% $(f-$"%&'P$"%($%2'1g%A?8%P$(8%,$(+%WR(D
%'2%NF%1%2?=% +%#9'(_L(D%!?+"#MH%W*MY]%(8%NF%1%P8($% +%$"C0"%J6R(D%Wy#D%NF%Ek'?@%J$"%'2%"#$L%EW0#_
%a@(%(R%L"%<2(n6D"%E _P-782?R%&(F%,!?)!%L"%4%E5()F%VWD"%#6D2%'2%,SM)F%$(F%,$(+%WR(D%E(-8%#M)*9
%'2%#6='(R%L"%<2(n6D"%WD"%JM-)F%3%ET"%(9% 8%?)F%WD(-8%5()F%J6R(D%1%52L%WSR%&"#8%&'"2#8%(R%L"
%4z3%%E4{z%?)F%VW7M!%#6D2%'2%<(O%,O% $(K%'2%EacF(O
%L"%,!g%(8%k1(n6+% :K1%2?=% +%#F(q%(M!#MH%&(F%}t9%1%(F%,S$P!"%L"%#c$2% :K1%E _P-782?R%a@"%5(M8%'2
%>1"%abS+%VP-O%<P-78%E2'"2%#6D2%'2%,!g%,8%'()*+%,b-$"% -*$% _P-782?R%P$?_% +%VNM8($% +'2%JMSMH%a@"%12
%'()*+%k(n@%L"%&'"2?)!%1%#:e+%,6YT"%,O% $(F%Wn@%2#O% +%WTm2%(-8%&(F%Wn@%#8%JMSMH%a@"%12%,O%WD"%J$"
%5"?9% +%,b.8%EWD"%<P-782?R%(-8%5t0%Wn_%5"?9% )!%VWD"%'()*+%&?R%1%Wn@% _P-782?R%E(f-$"%'2%(+"%V2?8%NF
%5"#$"%&'()*+%#8%a@"%J$"%>?)=%E,6=~_%J$"%L"%VWD"%<2#O%(n6O"%,6="2%,!g%,8%1%WD"%<P-782?R%5g%'()*+%Wn_
% _P-782?R%(F%5g%'2%,O%2'1g% +%5"#$"%&'()*+%&(F%XYD%L"% $(F%>(+%(M!#MH%2?R%VWD"%MH%a@"%12%L"%#6)O%'(M78
% !(:K%#8%5g%(D"%,O%5(:K%&'?9"#\+"%JM67Z!%XYD% -*$%WD"% D'(H%XYD%(F%5g%J$#9%N:+%VWD"%<PS!%k(y"#+
V(F%,$(+%WR(D%1%2"?+%52?8%&'P$"%1%2'1g%A?8%,!%EWD"%52?8
%,8%,O%PF2% +%5(b+"%5(UUQ+%#c$2%1%(M!#MH%,8% _P-782?R%a@"%V2'"2%<P!L'"%&2'1(6D2%a@"%J$"%E,)F%J$"%(8
%>2%'2%&"%,U-+%1% .Q+%&(F%,Y-K%,8%Ea@"%J$"%(8%1"%E#c$2%JZD%,8%VP--O%,K?9% !"#$"%&'()*+%'2%<P$2(!% F?K1
% D(-=%XYD%'2%"'%(F%5g%m ?)*+%,O%E(F%,$(+%WR(D%1%2"?+%,8%,K?9%WD"%JM-)F%VP-O% +%,K?9%JM+L%5"#$"%&'()*+
%5($#K%'2%(+%'(_L1'%'2%,O%WD"%&CMd%L"% +?8% $(-*+%J)6+% _P-782?R%EJ$"%#8%<1ty%%VP!'()=% +%NO%&'()*+
%EP=(8%<2#\D%>2%5g%L1'%(8%&(F%<?.K%,8%1%P=(8%h.+%5($#K%J$"%L"%,b!g% 8%(M!#MH%VWD"%<2#O%'?:q%'"P$(H%&'()*+
VWD"%<2#O%5(M8%a@"%J$"%'2%"'%'"P$(H%&'()*+%iP!L'"%&(F%,Y-K%L"% R#8
4N/2<"3%C*%R"(0;%JSML
%VP-F2%A(f!"%?Q!%J$#6:8%,8%E2?8%,67$(8%"'%,!g%P!PM=?O% +%AtD"%L"%[H%<G$1%,8%E !"#$"%5"'()*+%1%5"P-+#-F
%VP!#8%'(O%,8%<2?:M8%&CMd%1%P-F2%A(f!"%<2?:M8%&'(O%E(F(-8%J$#9%N:+%'2% 6%EP!2"2% )!%<L(K"%2?R%,8%C_#F%5(!g
%'2%(+"%P!#)=% +% -MC9%#-F%"'%% ="#9%r-D%1%&#_'(c!%P-!(+%%&'()*+%,8%,678"1%&(F#-F%E#c$2%&(F%JM+L#D%'2
+%VW="2% 9'1#l%X$#F%WMnMO%1%2?K1%1%2?Y!%Q+%J$g%,$"#MH%(:-$"%L"%X$%MF%E !"#$"%&'()*+
%&PY-_%#_"%t
%V2?8%PY-_% 9'"#%1% 68?]'%s$(y%A(-H% =(O%,b.8%E2?Y!%Q+%JMC9%&"#8%EP!2#O% +% =(O%'(O(H%(9%<CM9%L"%"'
%r!'%X9%#_"%1%WD"%<(9?O% =(O%#)y%"#$L%EP!()8%5(:-H%<P=#M)*9%&(K%E#M)*9%A(c-F%'2%(9%P!2#O% +%U-+%"'% =(O
%,b-$"%&"#8%EP!2#O% +%#*+%"'%
=(O%V2'1g'2%W7Z!%hl1%,8%1%2#O%#M)*9% !(Dg%%,8%"'%5g%5"?9% )!%EP=(8%WDPb$%1

%'2%A12%=?H%^TC-+%,8%,O%E(-8% .R"2%}?H%1%&P-8'(O%4%E4%?)F%V2#O%$?*9%1%#M)*9%"'%9(*w%5"?68
%'2%EJ$"%#8%51C0"%VP-O% +%2(f$"%(+#D%1%(+#_%#8"#8%'2%s$(y%1%<'"PK12% S=?H%E2#M_% +%'"#w% !1#M8%1% .@"%PY-_%#$L
%P!"?9% )!%1%P-O% +%&1#MH%5?)MH%L"%#$C_(!%(-8%(n9'"%'2%'()*+%"#$L%EP$g% +%'(O%,8%NF%(-8%(n9'"%L"#0"%52#O%A"P!"%%,8
%(8%E2?8%ALm%"'%,!g%'()*+%E#c$2%2'"?+%1%2'"?+%J$"%^)F%'2%VP-O%NMe-9%1%<(9?O% .R"2%&(0%&"#8%<"?ZT2%%,8%"'%5g
{%E4{z%?)F%%E5()F%VWD"%<2"2%k'?@%?Q!%J$#6:8%,8%1%&P-+#-F
%'2%"'%5g%P-O%C:f+%&#6SM8%&(F%>(+%,8%1%PF2%Ml?9%#6SM8%"'%a@"%J$"%,O%W0(M!%W@#0%(M!#MH%,!(nDj6+
%a@"%5(M8%'2%2?R%"'%,!g%N$#$C_(!%VP8(M8%,67$(=% $(F%ID(H%(FPU!%&"#8%1%PF2%'"#w%5"#c$2%&'1"2%1%PU!%#*+
%&#$?/9%a@"%J$"%,O%Wn_%P$(8%Ek'?@%J$"%'2%VNMF2%'"#w%&'1"2%&(-Y+%1%t+%EWD"%,6n_% _2?:M8%L"%CMF#H
%#8"#8%'2%5g%h0"P+%,8% !"#$"%r-F#0%#678%'2%5"#$"%&'()*+%JMMY9%&(K%,8%1"%|PF2% +%WD2%,8%(M!#MH%L"%#c$2

!"#$"%&'()*+%,+(-./0%12
34%5(678(9%1%'(:8%;%4%<'()=
#%

www.SID.ir

Archive of SID

!"#$"%&'()*+%,+(-./0%12
34%5(678(9%1%'(:8%;%4%<'()=
#&

%&'()*+%L"%M8% !"#$"%&'()*+%,O%PF2%5(S!%P=?O% +% $?_%VWD"%<P=%>P8%&'()*+%'2%5'P+%Y-K%&(F%}L'"

%<2?:M8%"'%Q+%JMC9%E5'P+%Y-K%5"#Y+(MH%P-!(+%,O%WD1'%J$"%L"%VWD"%<2?8%PMU+%5'P+%&'()*+%>?@"%,8%5'P+
%CK%1%aO%^)F%Ea@"%J$"%L"%MH%,O%1"%VP-O% +%"#Y+%JMC9%r-!%L"%"'%
!"#$"%&'()*+%J+"2%1%PF?b!% +%1%2'(c!"% +

% !"#$"%&'()*+%'2%JMC9%(f-$"%'2%E2#O% +%JMMY9%1"% _P!L%i?M=%1%r-F#0%1%5(7!"%(8%WY7!%'2%"'% !"#$"%&'()*+

%A(-H%P-!(+%E(-8%'2%&2(+%&(FL(M!%Q+%52'1g#8%&"#8% $(F%,D"1%P%(9%EP$()!% +%JMC9%"'%,!g%1%P-O% +%'(b!"%"'
%5g% ).y%&(F%,Y-K%1% !"#$"%&'()*+%k(MCK%,8%(M!#MH%,K?9%5(S!%CM!%a@"%J$"%E>(%J$"%(8%4{VPF(O% +%1#0%Es$(y
%VW0#_%<#:8% !"#$"%&'()*+%L"%<P$2(!% $(F%,Y-K%W"#w%&"#8%5g%L"%1%2#O%a$P*9%"'%a@"%J$"%5"?9% +%VWD"
O29";%+%T8'"5%JUML
%^)F%,8%}'(M!%V(-8%J6="2%,c!%(H#8%N.y% -*$%}'(M!%N.y%1%{%E4{z%?)F%2'"2% +%,c!%"'%(-8%,!g% -*$%}'(M!
%N.y%,D%a@(%1%a+(=%1%{%ET"4%?)F%2#M_% +%A(f!"%(-8%&'"P$(H%1% $(67$"%&"#8%,O%2?=% +%,6n_% $(F'(O
%2#8'(O%1%J6R(D%ET(/+%[-K% D(-=%T(/+%(-8%A(bQ6D"%1%(F1#M!%^YD(Q+%1%aM.Q9%1%<L(D%XM9(6D"%|WD"
%5"'()*+%2C!%}'(M!%44%?)F%V $"#K"%1% !()6R(D%k(MCK%1%#@(-y%5()6R(D%J0%VVV1%(F21P!"%1%(FP!g
%&(F%,Y-K%1% -0%a(7+%1%=?H%,8%CMd%#F%L"%M8%E $(H1'"%5"'()*+%tR#8%5(!g%VW="2%WM)F"%'(M78% !"#$"
% $(Y$L%(D"%V2#O% +%(Y$L%1%PMSZ8% +%A"?w%"'%5g%,O%2?8%(-8%52?8% U-+%,8%,K?9%JM)F%VP-6="2%#e!%o#]% .)y
%ET"4%?)F%VWD"%2?R%&(K%'2%CMd%#F%J60#_%'"#w%1%52?8%pD(-6+%1%52?8% U-+%E5"#$"%&'()*+%'2% _P-Y$L
%44{3%{
%P-O% "#]%,!"2"Lg%'()*+%,O%2?Y!%JM-d%V2?Y!%"PK%#c$Pb$%L"%<L(D%1%&'()*+%1%"#K"%1%o#]%E !"#$"%&'()*+%'2
%J$"%,b.8%EP-O%,YD(Q+%}"% $(H#8% c!?cd%&"#8%1%2L(D%<2(+g%"#K"%&"#8%"'%5g%#c$2% 7O%E#c$2%&"%,.#+%'2%1
%sU Q+%5?)MH%<(c6D2%L"%&#M_%<#:8%(8% c6ZM+g%J$"%4{3%?)F%VW0#_% +%A(f!"%NF%,8%,6ZM+g%1%<"#)F%2'"?+
%2?=% +%(R%pK?+%&'()*+%'2%2Py%1%<L"P!"%,8%J6R"2#H%,O%P!2?8%5g%#8% !"#$"%5"'()*+%%ET"4%?)F%VP=% +
%#y%E?w%CMR%EL#K%W+(Zl%E1#F"'%#y%5(M+%WY7!%5?)MH%VP-6R"2#H% +%(F%WY7!%,8%<L"P!"%&(K%,8%E1'%J$"%L"
+%WD"%(9"%^!(F2%L"% 6Y7!%L#K%#F%W+(Zl%iL"P!"%E5?)MH%'2%43VP-O% +%ZS+%"'%VVV1%(0%2(*8"%E(F?=L(8
%t
%(F?=L(8%P-!(+%E"CK"%#c$2%1%(FL#K%2(*8"%E(9"%2(*8"%52#O%A?.*+%1%#c$2%&(F%5?)MH%1%5?)MH%J$"%J67!"2%(8%VNf-H12
%L"%%&'()*+%s-+%?)f+%VWD"%,6n:!%CM!%}'(M!%E5?)MH%J$"%'2%,O%WD"PMH%V2?=% +%ZS+%EVVV%1%,!(F2%CMR%1
%J$"%i'(/y%1%2'1g% +%P$PH%"'%?.+%pD(-9%,O%WD"%% _P!L%&(FL(M!%1%}'(M!%(9%,60#_%5()6R(D%2"?+%k(!(b+"
%<2?+Lg'(O%'()*+%k'(:+%1%!"2%5()F%(F%5?)MH%^y?)f+%#8%'()*+%?w1%VP=% +%'P-+%5?)MH%'2%?.+%pD(-9
%L"%,O%W="2%5(-M)]"%1%2"2% +%5(+(D%1%2#8% +%MH%5(+L%NF%"'%"#K"%1%,YD(Q+%1%&'()*+% "#]%E<"'%J$"%L"%1"%V2?8
%'2%WD2%<#Md%5"P-d%,!% $(- 8%E<"'%J$"%L"%%E5()F%V(Y$L%NF%1% .)y%NF%1%(67$"%NF%1%WD"%P+g'(O%NF%o#]%E<"'%J$"
%WZ6$(H%2(6D"%1%<2?+Lg'(O%'()*+%,O%2L(78%,!?_%5()F%E#9%Xd?O%&"%<L"P!"%'2%"'%&PY-_%W7!"?9% +%<2(60"'12% $(6D1'
%($%2'?R12L%(8%<'"?)F%5?)MH%2#8'(O%{%E4{z%%E4%?)F%VP=(8%5g%&'"?6D"(!%($% $(Y$L(!%5"#c!%,b!g% 8
%VWD"%#c$2%&(K%,8%521C0"%1% $(K%L"%J6D(O%&(-*+%,8%21C0"%W7O%V2?8%<"#)F%521C0"%1%J6D(O%21C0"%W7O
%E>(%J$"%'2%V&P-8% )D'%1%&P-8'(O%'2%<G$1%,8%P$g% )!'2%'(O%L"%WD"%<2?8%#e!%'2%,O%5(-d%5g%"#K"%'2%k(YD(-9%<(_
%E4%?)F%V2'1g% +'2%pD(-6+%"'%'(O%1%P-O% +%#/9% OP!"%(F%WY7!%5g%'2%2 1C0"%W7O%(8%E"#K"%A(c-F%'2%'()*+
4%E4{%z
%,8%"'%&'()*+%&(F% _G$1%WR(-=%'2%1"% _P!L%i?M=%1% !"#$"%r-F#0%1%1%,8%,K?9%E#c$2%>?@"%'2%,O%(M!#MH

%&'()*+% $(67$"%&(F%,Y-K%5(M8%'2%1"%VWD"%<2'"C_%CM!%"'%&'()*+% -0%&(F%,Y-K%s%}'(M!%a@"%'2%E<P!(D'%>()O

%L"%5"?9% )!%"'%5"#$"%&'()*+%'2% $(67$"%,O%WD"%,6b!%J$"%,K?6+% 8?R%%,8%EP-O% +%#MY*9%}'(M!%,8%(F%5g%L"%,O
%($%(Y$L%"'%5g%[\D%1%WR"P!"% +'2%P+g'(O% #]%E !"#$"%'()*+%,O%WD"%<2?Y!%JM-d%V2#O%"PK%}#c$2%&(F%,Y-K
%V .)y%NF%1%(67$"%NF%1%(Y$L%NF%1%P=(8%P+g'(O%NF%,O%2L"P!"'2% #]%W7!"?9% +%<2?+Lg'(O%'()*+%V2#O% +%(67$"

www.SID.ir

Archive of SID

%1"%k#=(*+%VWR(-=%P$(8%,O%5(-d%5"?9% )!%}"% -0%>?@"%,8%,K?9% 8%"'% -M+L#D%MF%&'()*+%,O%W7!"2% +%(M!#MH

% !"#$"%&'()*+% -0%&(F%,Y-K%(8%1%P8($%?w1%>?@"%J$"%#8% 8?R%%,8%,O%2?8%<P=%pYD% )$Pw%5"'()*+%1%J0%aF"%(8
%&'()*+% -0%&(F%,Y-K%L"%1"%#M7n9%EpYD%JM)F%,8%V2'()S8% !"#$"%&'()*+%>?@"%1CK%"'%(F%5g%1%2?=%(-=g%51'2%L"
+(O%5"#c$2%(8% !"#$"
%E $(67$"%%&'()*+% -0%^Y-K%,D%E5"#$"%&'()*+%5(F1GH%I$'(9%#6SM8%tR#8%1"%V2?8%k1(n6+%t
V}'(M!%|2(:!%P"1% +(!%(F%5g%#8%1%2#O%,et+%NF%(8%"'%% !()6R(D%k(MCK%1%#@(-y%E D(-=%T(/+
%P!(D'% !?)+%,8%"'%(M!#MH%,O%2?8%&'()*+%&(F%,Y-K%#c$2%(8%5g% c6ZM+g%1%}'(M!%5(M8%'2%,6b!%J$"%,8%,K?9
% 6D'2%%,8%5?-O(9%5?)MH%L"%(M!#MH%2?/U+%,O%Wn_%5"?9% +%k#K%,8%V5?)MH%|P!"?R%1"%'(bF(=%"'%5g%5"?9% +%,O
%'(-O%'2%"'%}"%&#e!%<(c6D2%N:+%JO'%1%a@"%J$"%,O%P=(8%(M!#MH%2?R%E :K?9%NO%J$"%a+(y%P$(=%VWD"%<PS!%'2
%>1P+%(8%5g% Y$#U9%52#)=%#8"#8%1%5?)MH%i'(8'2%(M!#MH%J$L(g%5(-ZD%VWD(O%6M*+(K%1%WM)F"%L"%1%P!(S!%}'(M!
VW=(c!"% b$%>1P+%(8%"'%5?)MH%1%P+g%5'P+%Y-K%&(F%,S$P!"%,8%<2?Tg%5(F"%&'($%,8%CM!
%1%J=1'% YT(w%'2%,O%2?=% +% .)y% +(c-F%}'(M!%,8%,K?9%(8%<"#)F% !"#$"%&'()*+%k(n@%^)F%E(M!#MH%#e!%L"
%Pnb=% +%&'()*+%,O%WD"%WZ6$(H%'2%1%JM+L#D%J$"% c-F#0%CO"#+%'2%U0%E2?S!%JM-d%#_"%VP8($%'?.Y9%>(U6!"%a8(w
%E(F(6D1'% 6%EWD2'12%(U!%&'()*+%E1"%#e!%L"%(+"%2?=% +% !"#$"%&'()*+%>?@"%PK"1%1%PD'% +%>()O%,8%1
%1%2#R%L"%E5"#$"%&'()*+%&"CK"%1%(FP"1%X$#F%,b-$"%V5(!g%r-F#0%1% _P!L%i?M=%1%A2#+%'?R'2%WD"%&"%&'()*+
%L"% $(F%,y?)f+%'2%EP=(8%($(H%1%(67$"%E>(%5()F%'2%1%P=(8%A2#+%>"?"%1%,S$P!"%1% _P!L%(8%pD(-6+%,!?cd%E5tO
%&(F%<L"P!"%J60($%,8%,O%2?8%&"%<2?+Lg%&(F%WY7!%>?/Q+%E5?)MH%VP=% +%sUQ+%5?)MH%A(!%,8%k(YMO#9%1%k(YD(-9
%2'1g% +#8%"'% $g'(O%NF%,O%WD"% $(F%<L"P!"%EWD'2%&(F%<L"P!"%VPM+(f!"% +%(-8%iL(D%1%&'()*+% "#]%'2%WD'2
%#MY*9%4?cT"%,8%5g%L"%'P!(7bT"%#0?67$#O%,!g%aMYw%L"%2?8%&CMd% $?_%E5?)MH%V"'% $(67$"%NF%1% $(Y$L%NF%1
%(8%1%WD"%#9($?_%1%#9%h+(K%E'P!(7bT"%&?cT"%L"%(M!#MH%5?)MH%,O%2#O%(y2"%5"?68%P$(=%,b.8%433%'P!(7bT"%VP-O% +
V#9%pD(-6+% !"#$"%r-F#0

?2@*%/2;%+%8'I%8/%4,1VI%&DW"X5%JQ

%k(l1#n+%1%(F%<CMc!"%L"%,6R(D%&2?H%1%'(9%2'"2%,6n:!%&2?H%1%'(9% !"#$"%&'()*+%>?@"%JMMY9%1%JMM*9%'2%(M!#MH%'(O
%EP=(8%Jb)+%#_"%E(F%5g%'2%a+j9%1%k(l1#n+%1%(F%<CMc!"%J$"%,8%(-6y"%51P8%1"%>?@"%PU!%1% 8($L'"%1%N:0%1%WR(-=%V1"
%1% -)l%&(F%WTm2%EWD"%,6n_%$#/9%%,8%,!g%L"%,6=~_%E>?@"%J$"%i'(8'2%1"%JZD%EJ$"%#8%<1ty%VWD"%w(!
%1%(Y-6D"%1"%2?R%5(-ZD%L"%"'% -)l%&(F%WTm2%1%k(l1#n+%1%(F%<CMc!"%J$"%NM=?O% +%(f-$"%'2%V2'"2%NF% Q$?.9
VNMF2%5(S!%5"#$"%&'()*+% F1GH%I$'(9%'2%"'%(M!#MH%&"'g%<(c$(K%1%NM-O%J=1'
'(% R"Y5*%JKMQ
%X$%1"%,O%WD"%5g%<"?_%% D'2%&(F%<1CK%E'2%&(F%tO%' "?!%E(F%,6=?!%%WD"%<P!(+%(K%,8%(M!#MH%L"%,!g%^)F
%V&'()*+%J$"%A(e!%&(M"%'?e-+%,8%5g%'2%a+j9%1%5"#$"%&'()*+%,8%,K?9%,8%k?y2%|W="P!%#6SM8%<CMc!"%1%,6D"?R
%&'()*+%'(O%#c$2%VP.7_% +%NF%L"%,!(cM8%&'()*+%#8"#8%'2%5"#$"%^T(D%5"'"CF%&'()*+%A(e!%,O%P$2% +%NSd%,8%1"
%5"#$"%1%(H1'"%'2%&'()*+%5'P+%'"P+%5(c6R?+g%!"2%,8%,b.8%E&'()*+%J:O%A(e!%'2%,6R?+g%5"2(6D"%,8%,!%"'

%&"%&'()*+%,8%1%E5"#$"%NM.w"%1%(M0"#K%L"%NF%1%2?8%<P+g#8% !"#$"%1%L"%NF%,O% +(e!%P$2% +%"'(b=g%VP!'(\D% +

%#_"% 6%#c$2%,O%W7!"2% +%XM!%1"%V2?=% +% =t6+%1%2#M+% +%1#0%,60'%,60'%EP=% +%#f-+%(67$"%1%(Y$L%1%P+g'(O
%PF"?Z!%a%abS+%EP!#M_%<#:8% !"#$"%&'()*+%&(F%k'?@%1%"CK"%L"%(F(-8%'2%($%EP!'(\78%NF%5"'(O2(6D"%,8%"'%'(O
%2?8%5"#$"%&'()*+%A(e!%,8%,K?9%1"%k?y2%E1'%JM)F%L"%VP$2% +%5"#$"%&'()*+%A(e!%J6ZM7_%'2%"'%abS+%1"%VP=
V5g%&(F%<'(H%1%"CK"%,!
%1%(F%k'?@%1%5?-0%1%2"?+%(9%,60#_%5"'()*+%1%5t+(y%L"%%5"#$"%&'()*+%&"CK"%,O%2?8%,60#$~H%,!(-M8%hw"1%(M!#MH
%1%2?=% )!%<P!L%(+%'(_L1'%'2%EPMSZ8% +%(-*+%1%WD?MH% +%NF%,8%"'%(F%5g%,O% +(e!%L"%,677_%1% $(:-9%,8%E(F%ab=

!"#$"%&'()*+%,+(-./0%12
34%5(678(9%1%'(:8%;%4%<'()=
#'

www.SID.ir

Archive of SID

!"#$"%&'()*+%,+(-./0%12
34%5(678(9%1%'(:8%;%4%<'()=
#(

%5(S!%A(e!%5g%'2%"'%5"#$"%&'()*+%<?K1%1%"CK"%&(K%P=?b8%1%P!(D(-S8%1%PD(-S8%"'%A(e!%5g%WD"?R% +%1"%VP$(H% )!
%&"CK"%,!%EWD"%5g%A(e!%i#+L%'2%( YT(E2'1g% +%PF(=% !"#$"%&'()*+%L"%,!g%E1'%J$"%L"%VP-O%J=1'%"'%5(S$(-*+%1%PF2
%VPMSZ8% +%(-*+%5"#$"%&'()*+%A(e!%'2%(F%5"P8%,!g%L"% -*$%WD(F%5g%W)b%L"%EP$?_% +% -ZD%"CK"%L"%#_"%V5g
%JD(Q+%E#c$2%&?D%L"%1%P-6="2%2?R% +?8%1% -$2%P$(Uy%1#_%'2%>2%?D%X$%L"%,O% !(7O%E1"%'(_L1'%'2
%E5(!g%^!?)!%VP-F2% 6=g%JM+L%#+%5P)9%&(F(yP+%1%2?R%P$(Uy%JM8%P!PM=?O% +%EP!2#O% )!% n!%"'%L1#+"%5P)9
%h8(-+%'2%,!g%,O%P-F2%5(S!%P!PM=?O% +%5(!g%VP!"% 6*$#=% .y%1% 8(QD%x"P$%1%5(_'L(8%&P:+%5?d% !"P-)S$P!"
%%I$'(9%1% D(-=%,*+(K%E D(-=%W7$L%EXM+(-$2?+#9%|5(!g%/Z9%&(F%<L?%<G$1%,8%P$PK%N.y%(8%E<P+g% +tD"
%,8%,MY=% !"#$"%&'()*+%,8%(M!#MH%J6R"2#H%VP-F2%5(S!%"'%AtD"% c!"21(K%1%WM!(U%E<"'%J$"%L"%(9%WD"%r-F()F
%<L1'#F%(+%'(_L1'%'2%,O%5(:K%&'()*+%&(F%p6b+%L"%&CMd%5"#$"%&'()*+%,O%PF2%5(S!%PM=?O%1"%V2?8%5(S$"%}t9
%1% $(D(-=%E5"#$"%&'()*+%&"#8% T?@"%PM=?O%1"%EP!'"2%W7nM!(+%&L1#+"%&(F%p6b+%#_"%V2'"P!%NO%EP!'1g% +#8%#D
%(F%5g%P!?MH%1%PD(-S8%"'%5"#$"%&'()*+%&(F%XYD%PM=?O%E2'"2%p6b+%1%XYD%JM+L%#+%&'()*+%#_"%VP-O% 0#*+
%&'()*+%,O%P!"%5g#8%E2?8%.7+%^S$P!"%1"%'(_L1'%'2%,O%5'P+%Y-K%aF"%#_"%VPF2%5(S!%JM+L%5"#$"%r-F#0%(8%"'
%'"P+2#O'(O%E}"% !m?]%I$'(9% ]%'2%5"#$"%&'()*+%,O%PF2%5(S!%PM=?O%EWD"% ).y%1%'"P+2#O'(O%&'()*+%E?R
%1% .)f9%&CMd%,!%"'%5"#$"%&'()*+%k(-MC9%EP!PMF?b!% +%"'%(-8%#8%<21C0"%JMC9%(F%W7M!'P+%#_"%VWD"%<2?8% ).y%1
%&'()*+% 0#*+%(M!#MH%'(O%^)F%E&'(8%V2#O% 0#*+%&2(+%&"%<P$(0%(8%PMn+%&CMd%,b.8%E(-8%WR(D%#8%<21C0"%1%<P$(0% 8
%&(F%p6b+%(8%P!"?68%,O% F(c6D2%WD"#K"%1% "#]%1%,S$P!"%&(F%<L?%^)F%'2%P+g'(O% F(c6D2%^TC-+%,8% !"#$"
VP-O%&2'1()F%5(:K%L1#+"%&'()*+
%N6D%2?R%,8%1%1"%,8%WZD%ENMF(O1#0%5"#$"%&'()*+%&"#8%5'P+%&"%,M!(M8%J6R"2#H%P%(9%"'%1"%'(O%#_"%E>(%J$"%(8
%s)y%1%P$(H% )!%,$#e!%51P8%&'()*+%I$'(9%'2%sMUQ9%,O%W7!"2% +%XM!%E2?R%5"#w"%#6SM8%tR#8%(M!#MH%VN$"%<2#O
%E2#M_%'"#w%5"#$"%&'()*+%'2%sMUQ9%&(-Y+%P!"?68%,O%&"%&#e!%<(c6D2%,O%W7!"2% +%VWR"2#H%,$#e!%[H%2#M_% )!
%1%L"%5g%'2%5"?68%NF%,O%P=(8% F(c6D2%P=(8%,6="2% $(K%5g%'2%&'()*+%J$"%5tO%1%2#R%,O%P=(8%5(-d%P$(8
%JZD%,8%%WR"2#H%1"%,O%&"%&#e!%<(c6D2%VWn_%JZD%2"?+%1%<L(D%$"#q%1%5?-0%L"%NF%1%E !"#$"%r-F#0%1% !"#$"
%2?=% +%(-6y"%5(M+2g%2"#0"%,8%NF%5g%'2%,O%E !(7!"%WZD%WD"%&"%<1#H%%5"#$"%&'()*+%&"#8%(M!#MH%i1#H%E#6:8
%^)F%E(M!#MH%i1#H%'2%V5(Sc-F#0%,8%NF%1%&2(+%&(FL(M!%,8%NF%E5(!g%5(K%,8%NF%1%J9%,8%NF%E5(!g%h)K%,8%NF%1
%V2'"2%(K%5()Dg%(9%JM+L%L"%E5"#$"%JM+L#D%&(F% _G$1
Z'[+0\1%JLMQ
% 6MF(+%2?K1%,8%1"%,O%2?=% +%A?.*+%<'(8%J$"%'2%(M!#MH%5(-ZD%^y?)f+%1% !"#$"%&'()*+%>?@"%k'(Yy%L"
%I$'(9% ]%'2%,O% !"#$"%&'()*+%A(!%,8% -6R(-=%1%aU67+%&2?K?+%WD"%a(w% !"#$"%&'()*+%&"#8%aU67+
%&(F%,/ZS+%1%WR(-=%"'%2?K?+%J$"%5"?9% +%E1"%#e!%,8%VWD"%,60($%sUQ9%5"#$"%A2#+%WD2%,8%5"#$"%JM+L#D%'2
%(F%5g%s.*9%i'(8'2%1%,l#y%>?@"%J$"%,8%"'%&'()*+%5?_(!?_%&(F%,!?)!%<(c!g%2"2%MZS9%"'%5g%>?@"%($%E .O
%&"#8% -6R(-=%1%aU67+% 6MF(+%2?K1%(M!#MH%1#n+%J$#9% .O%1%J$#9%N:+%EJ$"#8(-8%V2#O%&'1"2%5"#$"%&'()*+%,8
V !"#$"%&'()*+%<(_%1%WD"%<2#O%#MY*9%5"#$"%&'()*+%,8%2?K?+%J$"%L"%<(_%1"%VWD"%5"#$"%&'()*+
%&'()*+%E1"%#e!%L"%V2#)=% +% !"#$"%r-F#0%L"%<P+g#8%"'%% !"#$"%&'()*+%% -6R(-=%1%aU67+%2?K?+%J$"%(M!#MH
%VWD"%JM-d%CM!%5"#$"%&(F#-F%#c$2%VWD"%5"#$"%&(M0"#K%#678%'2% !"#$"%r-F#0%1% !"#$"%1%a)y%a@(% !"#$"
%hl1%,8%,O% -$2(M-8%1%,MT1"%>?@"%P!'"2%#6S+% T?@"% !"#$"%&(F#-F%#c$2%1% !"#$"%&'()*+%E1'%JM)F%L"
%>?@"%E5?)MH%1%}'(M!%CK%,8%E !"#$"%&'()*+%>?@"%1%%E%(9% 8%(M!#MH%V2?=% +%?8#+% !"#$"%^UM.D%1% _P!L
%L"% !"#$"%&'()*+%,O%WD"%J$"%(M!#MH%A12%1#n+%[H%z%E4{z%%ET"4%?)F%VWD"% !"#$"%&(F#-F%^)F
%&(F#-F%#c$2%1%&'()*+%VWD"%<2"?!(R%NF% !"#$"%&(F#-F%#c$2%(8%W:K%J$"%L"%1%WD"%<P+g#8% !"#$"%r-F#0%1%1
%1%"?F%1%%g%&(F% _G$1%1%5(M!"#$"%&(F% _G$1%i2"L%2?R% !"#$"%r-F#0%V !"#$"%r-F#0%|P!'2(+%X$%5"P!L#0%5"#$"

www.SID.ir

Archive of SID

VWD"%5"#$"%&(M0"#K
%?.+%&"%&'()*+%EWD"%<P+g#8%5"#$"%&(M0"#K%1% !"#$"%r-F#0%L"% !"#$"%&'()*+%5?d%,O%WD"%PU6*+%(M!#MH
% U-+%&'()*+%1%zWD"%2"#6+% U-+%&'()*+%(8%?.+%&'()*+%1"%#e!%L"%E#c$2%JZD%,8%VWD"% U-+%1
%k(M6U+%1%5(!g%r-F#0%1%1%L"%1%A2#+%&(F%,6D"?R%1%(FL(M!%L"%,b.8%E5g%1%J$"%?F%#D%L"%,!%,O%WD"%&"%&'()*+
VP=(8%'(_L(D%JM+L#D%k(!(b+"%1%"?F%1%%g%(8%1%<P+g#8% -M+L#D
?2@*%?29]%^06*/%+% 'YXG'B%JQMQ
%L(g%L"%E5"#$"%&'()*+%'(g%^y?)f+%L"%"'% !"#$"%&'()*+%>?@"%1"%,O%2L%P%JM-d%5"?9%% +%(M!#MH%&(F%,6n_%L"
%PF"?=%(+"%EWD"%<2'1g%WD2%,8%N$Pw%5"'()*+%(8% -MS!%NF%1%E5($'(K(w%i'12%(9%JM+L#D%J$"%'2%J6R(D%1%W!?bD
%#/9%2?R%&(F%W="2#8%'2%E>?@"%^)F%L"%#9"#0%1% .O% .@"%(8%&1%PF2% +%5(S!%,O%W7F%1"%5(-ZD%'2%&'(M78
% .O%&(F% _G$1%#c$2%(M!#MH%VWD"% !"#$"%&'()*+%52?8% U-+%E#$~H(!#MM9%1%N.7+%1% .O%a@"%J$"%VWD"%<2#O
%1%<PMf-D%aM@"%a@"%J$"%(8%2?R%W0($'2%1%aUy%(8%E2#O%(Y-6D"%5"#$"%&'()*+%^*T(+%L"%5"?9% +%,O%"'% $(H#$2%1
%&'()*+%'(g%L"%&'(M78%'2%E<2'1g%>?@"%i#+L%'2%1"%,!g%L"% R#8%,O%WD1'%J$"%L"%VWD"%<2'1g%2?R%>?@"%i#+L%'2
%^y?)f+%,8%,O%P=(8%5"#$"%&'()*+%'(g%L"%&'(M78%5(M+%'2% O#6S+% .O%&(F% _G$1%(78%,d%1%2?=% )!%W0($%5"#$"
%VWD"%,60(M!%<"'%1"%>?@"
%&'()*+ %&"CK" %}#$~H %&"#8 %&?w %^)l(F %E1(D#8 %1 %"C6!" %E c!"#y(= %5?d % ):+ %&(F% _G$1 %(:-$" %^!?)!
%4%E4%?)F%<2#O%2($%$(F%,6n_%1%(F%,6=?!%>tR%'2%(:!g%L"%(M!#MH%,O%WD"% Y.]%?-9%1%E#c$2%&(F%r-F#0
%(:-$"%L"% R#8%(M!#MH%P$(=%VWD"%<2'1(M!% !"#$"%&'()*+%>?@"%i#+L%'2%"'%(F%5g%C_#F%(+"%z%E%(9% 8%%1%%E4
%"'%5(SM6D'2%1%2#)=%W8(%>?@"%i#+L%'2%"'%5g%5"?68%,b!g%L"%#9%>(MD%"'% R#8%1%W7!"2% +%>?@"%P%L"%#92#R%"'
Yw%V2"2%5(S!
%&"%,M!(M8%W7$#c!% +%&'()*+%^M!(M8%^TC-+%,8% !"#$"%&'()*+%>?@"%^y?)f+%,8%1"%,O%P=%,6n_%t
%5PMf-_%&"#8%ALm%WMY.@%1%WM*w%E5(S6M)F"%N'%,8%E(F% _G$1%J$"%P$(=%VJ6R(D%#6:8%1%J67$L%#6:8%&"#8% !(:K
%VW="P!%"'%1"%&'()*+%^M!(M8%'2
%>?@"%E5?)MH%1%}'(M!%CK%,8%E"'%>?@"%J$"%1"%,O%P=(8%J$"%(M!#MH% !"#$"%&'()*+%>?@"%L"%#MY*9%J$#6:8%P$(=
%&'()*+%L"%(F%5g%"C6!"% 6D'2%,O%W="P!%&L(M!%EpYD%JM)F%,8%VW7!"2% +%5(:K%^)F%'2% U-+%1%?R%&'()*+
%&(F%,!?)!%J$#6:8%L"%1%sY-+%>?@"%J$"%#8%2'"?+%#6SM8%'2%5"#$"%&'()*+%,O%PF2%5(S!%2?8% 0(O%VPF2%5(S!%"'%5"#$"
%VWD"%5(:K%'2%&'()*+
%_'`=XG*%0"P1%+%V>=1%Jab*
%1% !"#$"%&'()*+%'(g%'2%a+j9%L"%JZD%<(_%VWD"%<2'1g%WD2%,8%,!?cd%1%(fO%L"%"'%>?@"%,O%,6n_%#6)O%(M!#MH
+%WD"%,6n_%JM+L#D%J$"%5"'()*+%(8% -MS!%NF%L"%<(_
%5"'()*+%(8%5?d%|P$?_% +%&'"1%A2#+%a@"%?/R%'2%t
%'"1%A2#+%P$(8%'(O%P-$?_% +%ENM-MS!% +%?_1%Wn_%,8% +2#+%1%C!%#-F%J$"%J:O%&(F%<?M=%i'(8'2%5"#$"%i2?+Lg'(O
%(8%E !"#$"%r-F#0%(8%[!"%1%'(g%p!"?K%^)F%'2%Ww2%1%5"#$"%5?_(!?_%(U!%,8%#nD%(8%1"%{%E4%?)F%VP=(8
%(M!#MH%V2?8%<2'1g%WD2%,8%5"#$"%&'()*+%'(g%#6S+%WMF(+%L"% .O%&'?/9%E&'()*+%&?w%^+(=%1%,e0(%#8%(b9"
%'(Y6y"%k(Y"%PMw%'2%VPF2%5(S!% F(cS!"2%&(F%<?M=%,8%"'%>?@"%J$"%'(Y6y"%1% 6D'2%,O%W7!"2% )!%q?+%"'%2?R
%&'(O%1"%^.7+%V2?8%&2?8(!%^!(6Dg%'2% !"#$"%&'()*+%^)69%,O%W7$L% +%&"%,!(+L%'2%V2?Y!%CM!%2?R%sMUQ9%}1'% ).y
%L1#+"%&'()*+%'2%"'%5"#Q8%1"%2?Y!%5"#$"%&'()*+%I$'(9%J6R(-=%&"#8% ).y%J-n9%#D%L"%(+"%,!(UUQ+%1% F(cS!"2
%'2%&"%,8(R%1%2($#0%,O%EXM+2(Og%1%A"'g%&'(O%,!%1"%'(O%VW7K% +%,6=~_%'2%"'%.%<"'%1%T"4z%?)F%P$2% +
%WD2%,8%#M7+%52"2%5(S!%V2'1g% +% $(F%>(+%1%PF"?=%E&'%J$"%&"#8%1%2?8%&'%p(@%1"%V2?8%XM+2(Og%pT(w
VW="P!%"'%6@#0%($%E2#)=% )!%2?R%'(O%"'%&'%5g%5P+g
%&"%<2?+Lg'(O%5"'()*+%V2?8% b6+%#$?O%^M=(%&'()*+%#8%#6SM8% !"#$"%&'()*+%A(!%,8% 6MF(+%L"%1"% .O'?/9% $?_
%VP!2?8%5"#:9%m ()6"%1%EL"#M=%E5(:n@"%EJM(!%E2C$%5"#$"%CO#+%L"%#6SM8%E2?8%,67S!%?_1%Wn_%,8%5(!g%(8%,O%NF

!"#$"%&'()*+%,+(-./0%12
34%5(678(9%1%'(:8%;%4%<'()=
#)

www.SID.ir

Archive of SID

!"#$"%&'()*+%,+(-./0%12
34%5(678(9%1%'(:8%;%4%<'()=
#

%,)F%E2#O%2'"1%(+%&'()*+% //Z9%5(8L%,8%1"%,O% $(F%<"1%1%2#O% +%N.b9%5"P8%1"%,O%NF%&'()*+% //Z9%5(8L

%%5"#$"%CO#+%&'()*+%E1"%#e!%L"%PD'% +%#e!%,8%V2?8%&?.:H%5(8L%L"%<P=(M"%&"%<"1%($%&2C$%^f:T%L"%,60#_#8%($
%JM)F%L"%VWD"%&'()*+%J$"%#8%&"%,M=(%#c$2%s](-+%&'()*+%1%WD"%5"#$"%&CO#+%&'()*+%#$?O%^M=(%'2
%&"?F%1%%g%L"% =(!%a@"%J$"%P$?_% +%E $"#_%51'2%a@"%k(YK?+%L"% b$%^TC-+%,8%"?F%1%%g%JMMY9%'2%,O%WD1'
%1%5(6D2#O%1%>()=% "?!%P-!(+%E2'"2%#c$2% $"?F%1%%g%,O%5"#$"%L"% $(F(K%'2%1%WD"%JM+L#D%J$"%XSR%1%%A#_
{%E4%?)F%VP!L(D% +%NF%"#_%51#8%&(F%,!(R%E5(6D#T
'>5*%'6%8'`Bc *%Jd
%<#:8%5"#$"%&'()*+%'(g%PU!%&"#8%>?@"%J$"%L"%"#d%,O%W0($'2%5"?9% +%CM!%"'%J$"%>?@"%(Y-6D"%&"#8%(M!#MH%#M7+%L"
%>CTC6+%"'%(F%5g%(D"%P!"?68%(F%5g%#8%&'(g%52?Y!%s8(+%(9%2?8%,60#c!#8%'(g%L"%<#7b$%"'%2?R%>?@"%1"%VW0#_% +
%&#MT2%J$"% 6%P-O%PU!%"'%5"#$"%&'()*+%'(g%(F%5g%(8%2'"2%s%,O%2#)=% +% .Uy% T?@"%"'%2?R%>?@"%1"%VP-O
%s8(+% !"#$"%&'()*+%>?@"%L"% b$%(8% !"#$"%&'()*+%&(F%XYD%L"% bYD%($%<?M=%'(g%#6SM8%P$?c8%,O%W0(MM+%"'
% !"#$"%&'()*+%'(g%i#+L%'2%(-8%5g%E2?=%k(y"#+% $(-8%'2%>?@"%J$"%CM!%L1#+"%#_"%P$?c8%W7!"?9% +% 6%W7M!
%($% $(-8%&'()*+%,d#F%,O%WD"% $(F'(M*+%(F%a@"%J$"%3%1%%ET"4%{%1%z%E4{z%?)F%VWD"% +tD"%($
VWD"%#9% !"#$"%E2?=%#9%X$2C!%(F%5g%,8%&"%<?M=%($%&"%<'12

%>?@"%(:-$"%P$?_% +%1"%VW7M!%NF%(F%5g% $(S!"%1%&'(YR "%5(M+%CMM)9%P-8%'2%(M!#MH%EWD"% .Uy%>?@"%J$"%5?d

%L"% !"#$"%&'()*+%,O%WD"% $(F%,S$'%WD"%<P=%(-8%(F%5g%#8% !"#$"%&'()*+%,O%WD"% $(F%,$(H%WD"% !"#$"%&'()*+
%PF2% +%#YR% !"#$"%&'()*+%'2%&CMd%L"% -*$%WD"%&'(YR "%>?@"%J$"%,O%P$g% +%#e!%,8%(f-$"%(9%VWD"%,6D'%(F%5g
% T?@"%1"%,b-$"%VWD"% $(S!"%<(_%1%&'(YR"%<(_%>?@"%J$"%,O%P$g% +%WD2%,8%JM-d%(M!#MH%5(-ZD%'2%a+j9%L"%(+"
%<2#O%aM)Q9%'(g%#c$2%#8%1%<PMf-D%"'%(F%5g%2?R%aUy%(8%1%<2#O%"C6!"%'(g%L"%&'()=%L"%,b.8%E'(g%#6SM8%L"%,!%"'
%<2#O% U.9% $(S!"%>?@"%"'%>?@"%J$"%E F(_%NO%WD2%E1"%,O%WD(-*+%J$P8%WD"%<2#O%PU!%(F%5g%(8%"'%'(g%#c$2%($

%'2%,O%WD"%#$PU9%^67$(=% !"#$"%&'()*+%1% !"#$"%'()*+%1%EWD"% !(+'g%1%?.+%&'()*+%>?@"%

>?@"%J$"%VWD"

% !"#$"%&'()*+%L"%,O%W7M!% T?@"%(:-$"%E#c$2%JZD%,8%VWD"%sY-+%>?@"%J$"%#8%I$'(9% ]%'2%$(F%,!?)!%#6SM8

%'"?y%L"%NF%(S!"%1%'(YR "% c6ZM+g'2%J$"%VP=(8%P$(8%,d% !"#$"%&'()*+%P$?_% +%,O%WD"% T?@"%,b.8%EPF2% +%#YR
%VW7$L% +%5g%'2%1"%,O%WD"%5(+L%L"%&"%,F#8%'2%1"% y()6K"%^nMq1%1% 8(R%JQT
?2@*%O/23%45*06*%Je
%>?@"%E5?)MH%1%}'(M!%1% _2?:M8%L"%CMF#H%1% _P-782?R%1% $"#_%51'2%1%&'"1%A2#+%P$?_% +%(M!#MH%,O% +(c-F
%"PK% !"#$"#M%&'()*+%L"%"'% !"#$"%&'()*+%,O%WD"% T?@"%(:-$"%,O%WD(-*+%J$P8%WD"% !"#$"%&'()*+
%<P=%k(y"#+%5g%'2%>?@"%J$"%,O%P$2%P$(8%E,!%($%2'"2%s.*9% !"#$"%&'()*+%,8%&#"%,b-$"%MZS9%&"#8%1%P-O% +
%#c$2%L"% !"#$"%&'()*+%iP--OC$()6+%1%a@(0%>?@"%J$"%WD"%PU6*+%(M!#MH%,O%P$()!% +%JM-d%>1"%#e!%'2%V,!%($
% !"#$"%&'()*+%,8%-6="P!%($%J6="2%s.*9%,8%1%PMf-D%>?@"%J$"%(8%WU8(+%#e!%L"%"'%&#"%5"?9% +%VWD(F%&'()*+
%J$"%L"%<L"P!"%,d%(9%&"%<?M=%($%&"%<'12%($%&#"%E&'()*+%'2%#_"%|PMD#H%5"?9% +%,O%WD"%(D"%J$"%#8%V2#O%Nb
%E&'()*+%'(g%#6SM8%'2%E(M!#MH%2?R%#e!%,8%N$'()=% +% !"#$"%&'()*+%i#+L%'2%"'%5g%5(-)F%P=(8%<P=%>1Py%>?@"
%JM-)F%N$'()=% +% !"#$"%&'()*+%i#+L%'2%"'%(F%5g%"#d%[H%WD"%<P=%U!% _P-782?R%a@"% D'(H%XYD
V 9'(H%XYD%'2%&'"1%A2#+%a@"%($%5"#$"% !(67F?O%s](-+%&'()*+%'2% $"#_%51'2%a@"%U!%WD"
%&#/-y%5(=#F?_%1%k"%'2%P$(8%EWD"% !"#$"#M%&'()*+%(8% !"#$"%&'()*+%iP--OC$()6+%1%a@(0%E>?@"%J$"%#_"
%5?d% T?@"%VP$g% )!%WD2%,8%<'(8%J$"%'2%h+(K% -ZD%E,6n_%>?@"%?/R%'2%(M!#MH%,!g%L"%VP=(8%,6="2% !"#$"
%WY7!%CM!%&#c$2%'()=% 8%&(F%JM+L#D%&'()*+%W- D%,8%P!"?9% +% _2?:M8%L"%CMF#H%1% _P-782?R%1%&'"1%A2#+
%5"?68%P$(=%NF%"'%5?)MH%1%}'(M!%VW7!"2%5"#$"%&'()*+%,8%#/Q-+%5"?9% )!%"'% $"#_%51'2%a@"% 6%2?=%<2"2
%WD2%,8%5(=2#8'(O%EP-O% +% !"#$"%"'%>?@"%J$"%,!g%%VW0($%r-F#0%5g%2?R%&(6U+%,8%E5'P+(!%r-F#0%#F%'2

www.SID.ir

Archive of SID

%,K1%WD"%Jb)+%CM!%#c$2% 6:K%L"%>?@"%J$"%(+"%WD"%5"#$"%&(M0"#K%1%r-F#0%#678%'2%5(S$"%1%(8%1%5(M!"#$"
%&'()*+%#"%X$%'2%#_"%,O%NM-O%'?/9%WD"%Jb)+%VNF%(8%(F%5g% F"#)F%|P=(8% !"#$"#M%(8% !"#$"%&'()*+%C$()9
%W="2#8%J$"%(M!#MH%2?R%(+"%E2#)=% !"#$"%&'()*+%,8%s.*6+%5"?9% +%"'%#"%5g%EP=(8%,60'%'(O%,8%NF%(8%>?@"%^)F
% !"#$"%&'()*+%&(F%XYD%J$#9%N:+%L"% R#8%'2%>?@"%L"% R#8%ENM6n_%,O%5(-d%E1"%#e!%L"%"#$L%EWD"%<2#O% n!%"'
VWD"%<P=%U!
%X$%MF%'2%(M!#MH%VP$g% +%WD2%,8%>?@"%L"%#c$2%&#$?/9%E(M!#MH%&(F%,S$P!"%1%5(-ZD%^)F%'2%#6SM8%a+j9%(8
%WD"% !"#$"#M%&'()*+%L"% !"#$"%&'()*+%CM)+%1% !"#$"%&'()*+%(R%>?@"%J$"%,O%WD"%<2#b!%(y2"%}'(g%L"
%#$C_(!%EP=(8%,6="2%"'%(F% _G$1%J$"%&#"%#_"%,O%2#O%(Y-6D"%5"?68%5g%L"%,O%WD"%,6nc!%&CMd%CM!%$?.9%%,8% 6

% !"#$"%&'()*+%W-D%
MF%(M!#MH%VW7M!%&#c$2%&'()*+%5g%L"%1%WD"%
!"#$"
>?@"%J$"%(8%,O%2#b!%(y2"%($%}t9%<(_%

%L"% b$%'2% 6%W="P!% 6M.8(w%1%W./R%JM-d%CM!%T?@"%,6YT"%1%P-O%"PK%(F%5P)9%#c$2%&'()*+%W-D%L"%"'

%5(7b$%(K%,)F%'2%#-F%&(F% _G$1%L"% *8%|WD"%,6n_% !"#$"%&'()*+%>?@"%Ml?9%&"P68"%'2%E$(F%,Y(/+
%ET"%(9% 8%?)F%VWD"% )M.w"%#c$2% R#8%1%WD"
%5"P$1(K% T?@"%,8%E2#)=% +%5(7!"%&'()*+%&(F2'1(6D2%J$#6:8%L"%"'%5g%,O% !"#$"%&'()*+%(8%W7!"+%L"%(M!#MH
%&'()*+%>?@"%E(M!#MH% !"#$"%&'()*+%>?@"%VWD"%'(0%5(b+%1%5(+L%L"%(F%5g%#6SM8%,O% T?@"%PMD'%&'()*+%&"#8
%(F%<?M=%1%(F%<'12%#6SM8%'2%EI$'(9% ]%'2%1"%&'()*+%,O%PT(Y8%2?R%,8%P$(8% !"#$"%E1"%#e!%,8%VWD"% U-+%1%?R
% $(F% _G$1%P=%pK?+%,O%WD"%>?@"%5(+L% 8%^Y-K%L"%1"%'?/9%JM)F%VWD"% -6Y+%>?@"%J$"%#8%E(F%,!?)!%#6SM8%1
%PU!%&"#8% $(F'(M*+%^TC-+%,8%>?@"%J$"%L"%2"2%5(b+"%1"%,8%CM!%VP-O%~%>?@"%L"%"'%WnKPH%1%WnK%5?d
%s$#]%,8%"'%>?@"% 6D'2%,O%P!"P!%q?+%"'%2?R%1"%P=%pK?+%,O%2?8% U.9%JM)F%L(8%VP-O%<2(n6D"% !"#$"%&'()*+
VPF2%5(S!%"#U6D"
45*06*%7'(0=(%f9(%7*03%4b2@*%J/
%1"%VWD"%2(@% !"#$"%&(F#-F%^)F%'2%E5?)MH%1%}'(M!%Nf-H%a@"%CK%,8%E>?@"%J$"%,O%WD"%,6n_%(F'(8%(M!#MH
%52"2%5(S!%&"#8%E>(%J$"%(8%V{5"#$"%&'()*+%I$'(9%#c$2%sUQ+%#F%L"%M8%P$(=%2?8%(-=g% !"#$"%#-F%1%r-F#0%(8
% c!(c$%PMf)9%1%,8(R%P%L"%<'(8%J$"%'2%"'%&1%JZD%#_"%VWD"%<2'1(M!%&PF(=%1%aMT2%2?R%>?w%J$"% 6D'2
%"#_%51'2%5"?9% +%,6YT"%VN$?=% +%,K"?+%abS+%(8%hw"1%(8%5g%WU8(+%1%'(Y6y"%'2%EN$'()S8%#9"#0% !"#$"%&(F#-F
%1%&'"1%A2#+%(+"%2#O%'2%"'% !"#$"% UMD?+%5?d%&#-F%($%E 7$?-=?R%1%&#_'(c!%5?d%E(6O%&(F#-F%'2%52?8
'?d%"'% _P-782?R
%r-F#0%(8% !"#$"%&'()*+%'"?6D"%P!?MH%52"2%5(S!%&"#8%(M!#MH%}t9%EWD"%5(SR'2%5(M+%J$"%'2%,!g%E>(%J$"%(8
% !"#$"%r-F#0%L"%&#:e+%E !"#$"%&'()*+%,O%P-O%p.K%N:+%J$"%,8%"'%!(Y](Z+%,K?9%WD"?R% +%1"%VWD"% !"#$"
%,8%5"#$"%&'()*+%,8%,O%21'% +%WD'2%<"'%#8%<(c!g%5"#$"%&'()*+%sUQ+%V !"#$"% UMD?+%1% =(U!%,O%5(-)F%EWD"
V2#c-8%<2"?!(R%J$"%L"%&?y%^TC-+
%,b.8%1% !"#$"%r-F#0%>?@"%E !"#$"%&'()*+%>?@"%VWD"%,6D(R#8% !"#$"%r-F#0%L"% !"#$"%&'()*+%E1"%#e!%L"
%,O%'(O%#F%1%2CMF#H% +% _2?:M8%L"%WD"%<P-782?R%1%"#_%51'2%1%'"1%A2#+%2 ?R%E !"#$"%VWD"% !"#$"%5(7!"%>?@"
%&'()*+%#"%'2%E5"#$"%A2#+%,d%1% !"#$"%'()*+%,d%E !"#$"%k(n@%V2L(D% +%pD(-6+%1%'"?6D"%1%WD'2%"'%5g%EP-O% +
%?70"%VPD'%'?:q%,8%NF% !"#$"%&(F#-F%#c$2%'2%k(n@%JM)F%,O% 6nc=%&(K%,d%[H%VPD'% +%'?:q%,8%5(!g
VWD"%<2#b!%5(M8%(F#-F%#c$2%'2%>?@"%J$"%'?:q%L"%"'%2?R%2?/U+%(M!#MH%,O
?2@*%Hgb%+%O'3C%J(
%^!(cM8%k(t@"%&"#8%PM=?O% +%1"%V2?Y!% ]"#0"%1"%a$()9%J$"%(+"%EW="2%aM+%<#D% D'(0%&(F%<"1%2#8'(O%,8%(M!#MH
%'2%,O% $(F%<"1%V2?+g%5?F#H%pMF#H%1(D#8%L"2#H%1%&#8#8%P-!(+%P8(M8%
D'(0%#8"#8%L1#+"%&'()*+%5(8L%'2%`$"'

%(S!"%1%'(YR"%J6ZM+g%?/R%'2%,!g%aMYw%L"%&"% c6n=g%(+"%EWD"% D'(0%,)F%CM!%<2#8%'(O%,8%2?R%>?@"%5PM+(!

!"#$"%&'()*+%,+(-./0%12
34%5(678(9%1%'(:8%;%4%<'()=
#!

www.SID.ir

Archive of SID

!"#$"%&'()*+%,+(-./0%12
34%5(678(9%1%'(:8%;%4%<'()=
#"

%($%WD"#_%51'2%($%WD"%'"1%A2#+% !"#$"%&'()*+%Wn_%5"?9% +%V2?=% +%<P$2%>?@"%J$"%&(F%<"1%'2%ENM6n_

VWD"%5?)MH%1%}'(M!%Wn_%5"?9% )!%(+"%EWD"% _2?:M8%L"%<P!CMF#H%Wn_%5"?9% +% 6%WD"%<P-782?R
%1%}'(M!%L"%#9"#0%'(M78%(+"%EP$g% +%(-8%}'(M!%'(O%,8%EP$?_% +%5?)MH%a@"%?/R%'2%(M!#MH%,!g%E,6=~_%J$"%L"
%s$#]%L"%#c$2%>?@"%^)F%,O%Wn_%5"?68%P$(=%VWD"%#c$2%>?@"%^)F%#F?K%&1(%E5?)MH%VWD"% $(67$"%Q+
%aU67+% .@"%"'%5g%1%<P!(S!%}'(M!%'(-O%'2%"'%5?)MH%1"%E>(%J$"%(8%VP-8($% +%WM-My%1%P!?=% +%sUQ+%5?)MH
VWD"%<2#)S!
Oh%^!=6h%+%'"50";%8'3+8'-%J+
%5g% -My%1% -F%&($(U8%1%2?8%,6ZM7_%NF%L"%P$PK%&'()*+%A?fF%'2% !"#$"%&'()*+%A(e!%,O%&'(_L1'%'2%(M!#MH
%V2?8%<2"L%"'%5g%,O%P+g#8% c-F#0%J8%L"%&'()*+%J$"% 0#*+%1% $(D(-=%2P@'2%E2?8%a+(O%?Q+%^!(6Dg%'2%CM!
%J$"%,O%PF2%5(S!%W7!"?9% +%(+"%EP-O% +%W$(nO%L1'%&(FL(M!%&"#8% !"#$"%&'()*+%,O%PF2%5(S!%W7!"?9% )!%1"
%pD(-6+%5(!g% _P!L%i?M=%1%1%1%5(M!"#$"%o1'%(8%NF%E>(D%5"'"CF% ]%'2%1%,6D'% !"#$"%r-F#0%^w(D%L"%&'()*+
%'(_L1'%J$"%'2%ENMD(-=L(8%"'%5g%>?@"%#_"%,O%pfy%,d%[H%VWD"%<2'1g#8%"'%5(!g%&?-*+%1%&2(+%&(FL(M!%NF%1%<2?8
% T?@"%W="2"1%5"#$"%&'()*+%W8(%>?@"%&?K1%W7K%,8%"'%1"%<CMc!"%J$"%VP$g#8%5(M!"#$"%iL(9%&(FL(M!%iP:y%L"%CM!
VW0#_%<P$2(!%1%2#O%'(b!"%L1'%>"?"%1%(l1"%&(6w"%,8%"'%(F%5g%5"?6!%,O%5(b+%1%5(+L%L"%'(0
%L"%"'% !"#$"%&'()*+%&(F2'1(6D2%PM=?O% +%&1%VW="2%L1'%5P)9%,8%#e!%1% !"#$"%&'()*+%1%r-F#0%'2%(H%(M!#MH
% !"#$"%&'()*+%5"P$1(K%&(F%}L'"%,8% F(_%E'(O%J$"%&"#8%VP-O%'12%JM+L%5"#$"%&'()*+%1%r-F#0%,8%#c!"#$1%A?fF
%5(S!%E?D%X$%L"%V2L"2#\8%5'P+%&'()*+%&(F%}L'"%(8% !"#$"%&'()*+%^U8(+%,8%E.b9%%,8%?T1%E F(_%1%2L% +%r-d
%X$?T?P$"% .M+%(8%E#c$2%&?D%L"%1%2'"2% !"#$"%r-F#0%L"%<P+g#8%1% UMU%&(F%}L'"%E !"#$"%&'()*+%,O%2"2% +
%L"% !"#$"%&'()*+%EWD()=%?.+%5'P+%&'()*+%#_"%,O%PF2%5(S!%5(!"?K%,8%PM=?O% +%E2?8%1"%^!(+L%&(6U+%,O
VWD"%<2?8%5'P+%"P68"
%&"%,$(+%WD2%"'%(F%5g%5"?68%,O% T?@"%2#O%J$1P9% !"#$"%&'()*+%&"#8% T?@"%E(F%<CMc!"%1%(F%,S$P!"%J$"%(8%1"
%J$"%WYD(-+%VP+g#8%,6D(R?!%1%r!'(c!'%&(F%p6b+%(8%&2'1()F%iP:y%L"%1%2#O%&'()*+%^+(!%A"#+%J6R"2#H%&"#8
%>?@"%r!'%(F%5g%,8%1%2#O%'(R%I$'(9%L"%'(YR "%1%}'"C_%WT(%L"%"'%1"%>?@"%,O%2?8%X$?T?P$"%^+(!%A"#+%(8%>?@"
%WO#%(F%5g%&?D%,8%P$(8%5(7!"%&'()*+%,O%Wn_%JZD% $(F%5(+'g%L"%2?R%>?@"%(8%(M!#MH%VPMSZ8% !(+'g%1% $(S!"
%VWD"%<PMD'%(F%?.+%J$"%,8%1%,60($%WD2%(F%5(+'g%J$"%,8%2'"?+%#6SM8%'2% !"#$"%&'()*+%,O%P=% yP+%<(c!g%VP-O
%V5(7!"%2?K1%2"P6+"%'2%&"%&'()*+%2#)=% +%A?8%#F%'2%5(7!"%(8%pD(-6+%&"%&'()*+%"'%?.+%&'()*+%(M!#MH
% !"#$"%r-F#0%L"%EP-O%"#Z6D"%5"#$"%&'()*+%'(g%L"%"'%>?@"%,b!g%&(K%,8%1"%,O%NM!"P8%#_"% 6nc=%&(K%,d%[H
%5(+L% 8%>?@"%J$"%,8%k?y2%&1%'(O%2#O%W$?U9%'(g%L"% $(F%,!?)!%(8%"'%(F%5g%1%W0#_#8% !"#$"%5(7!"%k(n@%L"%1
%'2%2?R%^nMq1%"'%#c$2%&(F%r-F#0%&'()*+%>?@"%(8%(F%5g%a/0%52"2%5(S!%1%>?@"%J$"% U-+%&'"?6D"%1"%V2?8
%2?8%<(_g%E +tD"%&(F%JM+L#D%<G$1%,8%E#c$2%&(F%5P)9%1%(F%JM+L#D%&'()*+%L"%(M!#MH%VW7!"2% )!%5(+L%L"%,F#8%5g
%#c$2%&(F%JM+L#D%&'()*+%L"% !"#$"%&'()*+%CMM)9%1%XMbn9%^M%,8%(+"%EW="2%(F%5g%i'(8'2%NF% !(-ZD%1
%&(F'(O%^)F%&(F% _G$1%L"%,!(+L%&(FL(M!%1%(l1"%,8%A(9%,K?9%1%XM+2(Og%&(F#M7+%,8% $(-6y"% 8%J$"%VPS!%2'"1
VWD"%X$?T?P$"
%N:0%1%<2"'"%,8%2'"?+%L"%&'(M78%'2%1%E5(M!"#$"%^UM.D%1%WD"?R%,8%"'% !"#$"%&'()*+%k(n@%(M!#MH%EJ$"%#8%<1ty%
%P$PK%'(_L1'%,8%1"%,K?9%&(FP+(MH%L"%CM!%'()*+%k(n@%1%WM/Z=%1%'()*+%#8%1"%PMOj9%J$"%V2"2% +%WY7!% !"#$"%'()*+
V2?8%5"?K%5"'()*+%&"#8% !"#$"%&'()*+%i'(8'2%X$?T?P$"%^8(R%1%,M!(M8%J6R"2#H%&(F%,+Lm%L"%1%5g%k((6w"%1
%L"%#9"#0% 6%WD"%&'()*+%^-M+L%'2%X$?T?P$"%a)y%($%&L"2#H%,$#e!%L"%#9"#0%p9"#+%%,8%1"%'(O%E,)F%J$"%(8
%APU9%a0%(8%L"%U0%"'%1"%,O%WD"%5g%L"%#9%B'C8%1"%'(O%VWD"%5"#$"%&'()*+%'2%P$PK% F1GH%I$'(9% +(cSMH
%r-F#0%(8%&'()*+%P!?MH%1% !"#$"%r-F#0%,8%5"#$"%&'()*+% !"#$"%1% 8#%5(F1GH%I$'(9%L"%M8%'(M78%(M!#MH%VNM$(678

www.SID.ir

Archive of SID

%'(M78%&'()*+% Z$'(9%&(F%,S$P!"%'2%EN$#c-8%1"%'(O%,8%I$'(9%&#e!%&(F%5($#K%#e-+%L"%#_"%VW="2%,K?9% _P!L%1

V2?8%2?R%^!(+L%L"%#9?.K
%EJ6R"2#H%a)y%,8%#e!%L"%WO#%^+Lm%V2'"~c8%#"%2?R%^*+(K%'2%WD"?R% +%"#$L%E2#b!%(n6O"%&L"2#H%,$#e!%,8%1"
%(M!#MH%&(F2'1(6D2%1%(F%,S$P!"%,8%E5"#$"%&'()*+%I$'(9%'2%sM)y%F1GH%&"#8%<L1#+"%V2?8%&'()*+%&?T?P$"% y?!
%$(F2'1(6D2%1%(F%,S$P!"%L"%"'%1"%'(_L1'%'2% .)y%aK(y%&(FL(M!%r!'%WD"% 0(O%E'(O%J$"%&"#8%VN$P-+L(M!%WZD
%JM+L%5"#$"%#D(9#D%'2%1%(F%5(+L%^)F%'2% !"#$"%&'()*+%>?@"%1"%^!(_%`-H%>?@"%,O%"'%(y2"%J$"%WD"% 0(O%VNM$"2C8
%Ek'?@ %J$" %'2 %VN$#c-8 %5"#$" % Z$'(9 %&'()*+ %WR(-= %&"#8 % $(F'"C8" %^TC-+ %,8 %(F%5g %,8 %1 %N$'"~c81#0 %EWD"
%,K?9%,8%"'%(+% $"#_%51'2%P!"?R%PF"?R%"#0%&'()*+%'2% !"#$"%5(7!"% _P!L%1%5(7!"%,8%,K?9%,8%"'%(+%&'"1%A2#+
%1 % _2?:M8 %L" %CMF#H %1 % _P-782?R %2#O %PF"?R %k?y2 %&'()*+ %(8 %5(M!"#$" %k(M1' %1 %k(n@ %5(M+ %WYD(-+ %,8
%E#9m(8%,)F%L"%V5"#$"%&'()*+% ).y%5?-0%1%(F%W0"#q%1%#8%1%A?8%1%2"?+%'2%a+j9%&"#8%P=%PF"?R%&'"C8"%E}'(M!
%E(:-$"%^)F%1%V2?S_%PF"?R%5()$1'%,8%}"%,60'2($L"%5(8L%1%5"#$"%&'()*+%&'(6R(D%N:0%&"#8%<L(9%&"%,$'2%E5?)MH
V2"2%PF"?R%WD2%,8%5"#$"%&'()*+%&(F%XYD%1%(F%<L?%MZS9%&"#8% $(F'(M*+%EWD"?R% +%(M!#MH%2?R%,O%5(-d%5g
%(+%VP$(S_% +%(+%&'()*+%^6781#0%'(O%L"% F#_%1"%$(6D%,!%1%WD(+%$(6D%P-+L(M!%(M!#MH%,!%E'(_L1'%J$"%'2
%}t9%1%5"#$"%&'()*+% -0%1% c-F#0%p!"?K%^)F%,8%,K?9%'2%(F%5g%&(M"%NM$(M!#MH%k($#e!%1%'(g%&(M"%P-+L(M!
VJM+L%5"#$"%&'()*+%^Y!(K%,)F%WR(-=%1%&'()*+%I$'(9%'2%&L"2#H%,$#e!%&"#8
'(%i]25%4;
V4{%4%T"4%4{z%44%?)F%T"4%(M!#MH%44%<(M7).w%|V'%(M!#MH%>"?"%1% _P!L%i'(8'2%V4
%|V'%VP!"%,60(M!%(M!#MH% F1GH%I$'(9%aM.Q9%'2%&"%,!?)!%E D'2%'(*6+%sMUQ9%12% b$%1%a$%^!?)!%12%CK%,8%E5(_P!'(c!%V
4% 0(!% 7M'%4z%&P-FPM8% +?Mw
%&'(b)F%U-T"#F(+%2?)Q+%1%&L"#M=%<2"L%x"%W$g%#w(8%(8%CM!%5(:n@"%h+(K%Pf7+%|5"#$"%h+(K%PK(7+%(6O%J6=?!%'2%1"%V
%^T(U+%'2%EJ$"%#8%51C0"%VWD(M!#MH%2C!%'2%&2#_(=%a@(%CM!%&#:)_'C8%<#FL%&P-8'(O%1%&'()*+%'2%,DP-F%&(F%(6O%V2#O
%PMD#!%(d%,8%C_#F%(6O%J$"%VWD"%,6n_%JZD%JM+L%%5"#$"%'2%&#c$L"'%A(!%,8%'(S6!"%WD2%'2% 8(6O%L"%E'12%%?w%%<C$?9
VW7M!%WD2%'2% yt]"%CM!%5g%[$?!%WD2%L"%1
V43%<2"L%x"PYy%CM!%1%#l(%^T(U+%^+(!%(6O%|V'%EP!"%<2'1g%2#_%5"#c$2%($%,6=?!%2?R%,O%(M!#MH%'(g%i'(8'2%Vz
% -*$%WD"%<2?8%#9%X$2C!%(M!#MH%A?#+%N.w%1%>?w%,8%,O%WD"% *8(-+%#8%#6SM8%(+%^Mb9%E D'#8%J$"%#6SM8%5(U9"%&"#8%V
%P-!(+%"'%1"%'2%k(7.K%L"%<P=#S6-+%&(F%J6+%1%5(6D12%1%5"2#_(=%>?w%V1"%&#$?/9%1% 9?@%&(F'"?!%($%1"%2?R%&(F%,6=?!
%'(*9%,MT1"%h8(-+%J$"%(8%,O%N$"%<2#)=%P-67+% 9'?@%'2%U0%5"#$"%,6=~_%&'()*+%'2%sMUQ9% !"#$"%&'()*+% D(-=%XYD
%VWD"%,6="P!
%=%"'% !"#$"%&'()*+%1%#-F%>?@"%E,6=?!%%1%4% +tD"%&'()*+%'2%o#=%JMMY9%&"#8%(M!#MH%,O%&"%,+(!%'2%E>(%J$"%(8%V{
z4%ET"4%(M!#MH%VWD"%&'()*+%6Z+%#Rg%&(9%12%1%W7F% !"#$"%&(F#-F%^)F%'2%(F%5g%&(9'(:d%,O%E<2#)=#8%a@"
%P$(8%'(O%P-$?_% +%ENM-MS!% +%?_1%Wn_%,8% +2#+%1%C!%#-F%J$"%J:O%&(F%<?M=%i'(8'2%5"#$"%i2?+Lg'(O%5"'()*+%(8%5?d%V
VWD"% 6-D%5"'()*+%(8%(M!#MH% -MS!%NF%Ea@"%J$"%hY-+%,O%W0($'2%5"?9% +%W$"1'%J$"%L"%{%E4%?)F%VP=(8%'"1%A2#+
V'"1%5(7!"% -*$%'"1%A2#+%1%"PZF2%^+(!%WT%WD"%5(7!"%1% +2g%&(-*+%,8% D'(0%5(8L%'2%A2#+%V
%(+%"#d%V2L(D% +%$?R%L(M!%'?R'2%1%2?R%iL"P!"%,8%"'%2?R%^!(M=g%1%,!m%E&"%<P!L%iP$#0g%#F%E&"%<P!#H%#F%E&'"P!(K%#F%V3
%<P+(M!% !"#$"%'()*+%X$%Ww1%%MF%%E43%{%E4%(M!#MH%WD(+%&(F%<L"P!"%L"%51#M8%,O%N$L(D% +% $(F%,!(R%A2#+
%VP-O%,$#_%}2?R% Y$#%,8%1%}"%,=?_%2'"~c8%"?R%WZ9%X$%VVV%"?R%(9"%2'"~c8%"'%)D"%1%2L(78%()-MD%JT(D%X$
4{3%%E4%?)F
%P!"%<P!(8"?R%NF%MH%"'%#F?=%1%5L%,b-$"%a+%WD'2%#6+%%u{%%%u%WD"%&CMd%X$%,O%EP-M8% +%VVV&'2%,D%X$%V4

!"#$"%&'()*+%,+(-./0%12
34%5(678(9%1%'(:8%;%4%<'()=
%$

www.SID.ir

Archive of SID

!"#$"%&'()*+%,+(-./0%12
34%5(678(9%1%'(:8%;%4%<'()=
%#

%ZS+%"'%(F%,8%&L(8%&(K%5(S$?.:H%P!"%,6="~_%"'%VVV1%,!(=%1%,-M$g%VVV1%L()!(K%1%EJcT%,8(60g%E(F%,w(]%&m(8%1%(F%,w(]
% -*$%WD"%<PMSO%5(='12% R%'()*+%EW$(:!%'2%VP=(8%P$(8%(fO%WD"%A?.*+%(:-$"%^)F%E?67H%' 2%E&21'1%' 2% 6%P!"%<2#O
z%E4{z%4{3%?)F%V2'"P!%2($L%1%%NO%<'%X$
%(8%(F%JM+L#D%#c$2%&'()*+%L"%M8% !"#$"%&'()*+%1%E#c$2%&(F#-F%L"%M8%&'()*+%,O%P-O% +%PMOj9%(M!#MH%E1'%JM)F%L"%V44
VWD"%<2'?R%P!?MH%A2#+% _P!L
%&'?]%%,8%E2?8%#9%,!"#M_%WZD%AtD"%L"%p9"#+%,8%EAtD"%L"%MH% !"#$"%r-F#0%'2%WM+#Q+%1%(f%&"#8%&#M_%WZD%V4
V D'(H%i?M=%QY+%E4{%?)F%|V'%JM-)F%%E4%?)F%VJMS!%<2#H% -*$%P-+(!% +% _2#H% D'(0%'2%"'%5L%,O
%&m(8%1%5"'1(M!%'2%E5"#:9%>()=%'2%5m"%VP-O%F(c!%9?.R%'2% 7O%PF"?R% )!% !"#$"%W7M!%(f%(:-9%?l?+%V4
% K'(R%5(S!"#7)F% 6%1%,6=~_%(H1'"%1%(b$#+g%'2%#6SM8%5(SM_P!L%E5g%5(bT(+%,O%P!P$#R%1%P-6R(D% $(F%(O%E5"#M)=
%1%P=(8%,6="P!%?O#D%,O%P-8?O% +%&CMd%($% Y.%"'%,!(R%?.K%EP-67F%,UM.D% 8% .MR%,O%(F%Ww1% *8%EJ$"%2?K1%(8%VP-67F
%,O%P=(8%,6="P!%,U8(D% $(K%MF%P$(=%VVVV%2#O%<(c!%5"?6!%&'(-O%^!(R%L"%,O%P!L(D% +% $(F()!%(]%EP-=(8%#9%,UM.D%}?R%#_"%($
%P$(8%( )6%NF%5(=#7)F%?.K% 6%(F% $(H1'"%VP-=(8%$?.:H%NF%#n!%P-d%1%P-MS-8%,!(R%'2%&'"?.=#$L%1%JF"#MH#$L%(8%#n!%X$
%CMd%J$"%1%W="P!%NF% YMy%MF%1%51#M8%P+g% +%'"2P-8%&(F%5(Y-9%5g%(8%k(w1"% F(_% 6"'%>()O%(8% !"#$"% T1%EP-=?\8%'"?.=
T"4%|V'%CM!%z%E4%?)F%VP!(=?H% +%"'%#$L%(YT%(Yy%(8%1%W="2%=?H%EJ$"%2?K1%(8%V2?8%ND'%5?d%E2?Y!% ):+
+%V4z
% .MR%(F% !(b="%1%5(MS-+(ZF%5(+L%'2%,O%(f%"#$L%EWD"%J$2%#](R%,8% $"#_%51'2%P-$?_% +%(F% *8%VVV%t
%(+%'()*+%,O%<2#O% +%(6w"%(f-$"%NM.w"%W7M!%'?]%J$"%(:-$"% T1%VWD"%(f%#](R%,8%P-$?_% +%E2?8%AtD"%L"%P*8%L"%#9P$P=
4{3%?)F%VP!2"2% +%WM)F"%#6SM8%51'2%,8%1%EP!2?8%"#_%51'2%E5()$(0#y%a+%E(F'()*+% -*$%P=(8%"#_%51'2
%>(D%WSF%,O%"'%&"% =(O%,b-$"%&"#8%2#O%?0'%"'%5g%5"?68%,O%<2?8%J$"%&"#8%NF%5g%,6R"P!"%U!%"#d%P-$?_% +%VVV%V4
+%2#O%NM+#9%5"?68%E2'"P!%A"12%#6SM8
%m(8%E2L"P!"% +%P-)O%&'()*+%EP60"% +% 6w1%x"%T%IM=%PY-_% =(O%L"%&"%,*w%t
%a+%P!(+% +%$(K%#D%<2"2%5g%P-:+%JMT1"%,O%
#]%5()F%(8%,SM)F%J$"%VPF2% +%'"#w%$(K%#D%"'%,*w%5g%1%21'% +

%WD2%X$%J9(D%X$%P!"?9% )!%(F#_?0'%J$#9#F(+%m"%1%2#O%?0'%sMw2%"'%5g%5"?9% +%EP=(8%,6="2%U!%#_"%,O%E T(w%52#O%?0'

{%E4{z%?)F%VP-O%?0'%"'%<2(D%1
+%V4{
%V2CM+g% +%NF%'2% $(Y$L%(8%,O%WD"%k'1#l% y?!%,b.8%EW7M!%#@%JMC9%(:-9%2?+g%,O%P-O% +%PMOj9%(M!#MH%t
%4%E4%?)F
%(8%&"%<2(+%^TC-+%,8%(F()MH(0%'2%XM+"#D%L"%<2(n6D"%,8%<'(8%J$"%'2%1%P-O% +% 0#*+%(-8%'2% ):+% 9'"#%s$(y%"'% =(O%1"
%5g%#M)*9%aM:79%NF%"'%#*+% =(O%W)b%4%ET"4%44%?)F%VP$()!% +%2(-6D"%k'"#%#8"#8%'2%'(M78%W+1(U+
{%E4{z%?)F%VP!"2% +
%&'(O%L(!%($%JMC9% -*$%VVV1%[!#U+%E =(O%E<#_%1%&'(O%WnD%($%<L(D% -*$%VVV1%L#K%1%PY-_%1%(]%?l?+%12%#F%}'(M!%V4
44%43%&#:)_'C8%VWD"%,60#_% +%#8%'2%"'
@"%VWD"%<2?8%5(+?9%J0%(8%,SM)F%1%<2?Y!%T(R%#-F%X$%<(_%MF%EP--O% +%(y2"%(F% *8%,b!g%N'%,8%E5"#$"%&'()*+%V4
%t
+%EP-6="2%'(O%1%#D%N.y%(8%,O%"'% $(F%5g%1%NM$?_% +%#c6*-@%(F%5g%,8%5m"%(+%,O%P-6n_% +% !(7O%,8%P-+#-F
%1CK%EXM9(6D"%t
+%h!(@%P-6n_% +%[by#8%(:-$"%,8%1%P-67!"2% )!%#-F
%#c6*-@% b$%|P-6n_% +%h!(@%1"%,8%<2#O% +% =(U!%?R%,O% 7O%t
%1%P--b8% 6*-@%'(O%,O%P-6n_% +% !(7O%,8%P-+#-F%VP-6n_% +%#c6*-@%(F%5g%,8%V2"Lg%$?R%L"% T1%?9%At%u2(F#0%A(!%JMd%L"
{%E4{z%(M!#MH%VP!2"2% +%WM)F"% .MR%J$"%,8
T"44%4%?)F%V5?)MH%<2#R%1%EXd?O%5?)MH%EB'C8%5?)MH%|WD"%,!?_%,D%#8%5?)MH%V43
20. Christopher Alexander
21. pattern

V%()-F'%4% 6*$#=%4z{%E5(_'L(8%4z{% 8(QD%|V'%,!?)!%&"#8%<'(8%J$"%'2%V

%L1#+"%&'()*+%( 9Py(w%#MY*9%J$"%V5"#$"%JM+L#D%,8%s.*6+%&'()*+% -*$%WD"% 0(l"% YMO#9%5"#$"%&'()*+%pMO#9%V

www.SID.ir

Archive of SID

%?@?+%&'()*+% -*$%WD"% n@1% YMO#9% !"#$"%&'()*+%pMO#9%VWD"%<2?Y!%(M!#MH%'?e-+%,O%E2?=% +%a+(=%NF%"'%5"#$"

%k'(Yy%E2#)=% +% !"#$"%r-F#0%L"%,6D(R#8%1% !"#$"%Wn@%,8%?@?+%"'%5"#$"%^6=~_%&'()*+%(M!#MH%5?d%V !"#$"%Wn@%,8
VWD"%#9%X$2C!%1"%^S$P!"%,8% !"#$"%&'()*+
%52?Y!%($%52?8% U-+%L"%E,6n_%JZD%5g% 8?.+(!%($% 8?.+%1%% !"#$"%&'()*+%,.)K%L"%%&'()*+%1%#-F%i'(8'2%(K#F%(M!#MH%Vz
%J$"%L"%%E4%?)F%VP!"2% +%5g%'2%,6n:!%s-+%"'% !"#$"%&'()*+%#F?_%1"%4{3%z%E4{z%(M!#MH%VWD"%<2#O%2($%5g
VW7!"2%(M!#MH%&#e!%<(c6D2%&(F%<"1PM.O%L"%P$(8%%?F%#8"#8%'2%%"'%s-+%EM
+%V
%5g%&(F(-8% $?K%W)ey%1%CM+g'1#%k1#YK%1%CMc!"%"#F%(n9'"%L"%?D%X$%L"%E 9'(H%XYD%JMMY9%'2%t
%<'(="%|V'%JM-)F%z3%1%z%E4z%?)F%VP!"2% +%'"P$(H%5g%'2%5(-)F%"'%&'"1%A2#+%#c$2%&?D%L"%1%P$?_% +%JZD
4z%E4%?)F%V !(D"#R%i?M=%^+PU+%'2%&'g%1%&L"'%i?M=%'2%&'"1%A2#+%L"%5P=%'12%1% 9'(H%i?M=%'2%&'"1%A2#+%,8
%&'()*+%P-!(+%JM+L%#+%5(UUQ+%'(g%J$#9%,67K#8%(8%(M!#MH%'(g%WD"%,67$(=%V4%4{3%?)F%|V'%>(+%&"#8%V{
%5"#$"%&'()*+%i'(8'2%E5(!(Z.$"%<'12%'2%5"#$"% +tD"%&'()*+%5"'?9%1%5"#$"%'2%&'?)M9%&'()*+%r!'%1%ab=%&L1#MH%|5"#$"
%V22#_%'(b=g% ).y%(Y!"%'2%1"%&(F%*l%CM!%1%E5g%'2%s)*9%1% !"#$"%r-F#0%(8%[!"%#e!%L"%(M!#MH%&(F%k?w%(9%2?=%,7$(U+
%p9(b+%i'(8'2%1%2#O% +%[$'P9%CM!%5(:K%&'()*+%E !"#$"%&'()*+%o#]%^+PU+%'2%E2?R%'2%&(F%tO%L"% *8%'2%(M!#MH%V
43%APU+% 6$"'%VW="2%<2#67_%k(yt]"%CM!%AtD"%5(:K%&'()*+

j3'=1
8%<"'%| c!"21(K%L"'%1%&'()*+ %V433%V#0?67$#O%E'P!(7bT"%;
%|5"#:9%V4%V&P-FPM8% +?Mw%2"2#:+%^)K#9%VJ6R(D%5(+L%

V 6S:8%PM:=%<(cS!"2
V#bnT"'"2%|Nw%V5g#w%'2%5"'(8%1%2(8%V4z{%V&P:+%E5(_'L(8%;
V&#:)_'C8%P-:+%^!(R%|5"#:9%V 9?@%'"?!%<2"L%x"PYy%&P:+P)Q+%(8% /Z=%&?_1%Wn_%V43%V<#FL%E&#:)_'C8%;
V'?SO% c-F#0%"#M+%5(+L(D%|5"#:9%V&'()*+%'2%,DP-F%V44%V%%;
V T1(7$%|5"#:9%V4{%V#70"%x"%W+"#O%^)K#9%Vr!'%1%ab=%&L1#MH%|5"#$"%&'()*+%V43{%V'?9'g%E?H%;
%&(F#:=%1%(F(-8%W+#+%'(-M)D%JMT1"%km(U+%,y?)f+%'2%V>2%&(F%,!(R%($%A#_%&(F%}?g%VT"4%VN$#OP)Q+%E(M!#MH%;
V(!% 8%|5"#:9%V{u4z%4u4z%E b+t0%'?/-+%^6D"#$1%E(Y$L%&(F#-F%iPbS!"2%E Z$'(9% !?b7+%CO"#+%iP-$g%1%2?K1%| Z$'(9
V4%%|%V}%E c-F#0%5(:MO%V5"#$"% 6-D%&'()*+%>?@"%1%(M!#MH%N$#O%P-:+%2(6D"%V4{z%V%%;
%3%|%V}%E5(!"?K?!%&"#8% ).y%5(:MO%V5"#$"% 6-D%&'()*+%#MH%|(M!#MH%N$#OP)Q+%P-:+%2(6D"%VT"4%V%%;
Vz
V4%4%|<G$1%V}%E(M!#MH%N$#OP)Q+%2(6D"%5(+2($%|(Y$L%&(F#-F%V2L%P$(8% F#_%"'%,677_%,6='%J$"%V4%V%%;
V{%%|4%V}%E&'()*+%1%#-F%VWD"% c-F#0%&(F%,+(-D(-=%Nb%'2%'?SO%#F% Z$'(9%&(F(-8%V4%V%%;
Vz%%|4%V}%E#"%VJ$#0g% 67F%'(_2'1#H%A(!%,8%V43%V%%;
V%43%|441%4%V}%E&'()*+%1%#-F%V5"#$"%#-F%WR(-=%|"PR%A(!%,8%V4%V%%;
Vz%3%|{3%V}%EA2#+%1%#-F%V'"?T?8%&'()M8%VT"4z%V%%;
V4%{%|z%V}%E!"2%#602%V5"#$"%&'()*+%#-F%,$(H%`-H%VT"%(9% 8%V%%;
V(M!#MH%A?#+%2(M-8%|2C$%V3%%E<(M7).w%#YO"%^6D"#$1%E(M!#MH%N$#O%2(6D"%,+(!2($%'2%V%(M!#MH%5(8L%L"%(M!#MH%V44%V%%;
V5"#$"%W*-@%1%N.y%<(cS!"2%|5"#:9%V5($'()*+%JM7Q+t%J$1P9%V5"#$"%,6=~_%&'()*+%'2%sMUQ9%VT"4%V%%;
%<(cS!"2%|5"#:9%V43{%;4%E5($'()*+%JM7Q+t%J$1P9%E5"#$"% +tD"%&'()*+%(8% $(-=g%'2%V,!(R%VT"44%V%%;
V5"#$"%W*-@%1%N.y
V4%z%|4%V}%E&2(8g%V5"#$"% 6-D%&'()*+%1%&L(D#:=%i'(8'2%VT"4%V%%;
%V5"#:9%<(cS!"2%|5"#:9%V 9?@%'"?!%V(Y$L%&(F#-F%iPbS!"2%&(F%'2%V4%V%%;

!"#$"%&'()*+%,+(-./0%12
34%5(678(9%1%'(:8%;%4%<'()=
%%

www.SID.ir

Archive of SID

!"#$"%&'()*+%,+(-./0%12
34%5(678(9%1%'(:8%;%4%<'()=
%&

V5(:n@"%[$2#H%iPbS!"2%E 8"'(0%<(cS!"2%|5(:n@"%V 9?@%'"?!%V[$2#H%iPbS!"2%&(F%'2%V4{%V%%;

V%|%V<PS!#S6-+% !?$C$?.9%^Y(/+%V 9'(H%XYD%V%(9% 8%V%%;
Vz%z%|4%V}%E5"#$"%#-F%1% D(-S!(6D(8%V5"#$"%&'()*+% D(-=%XYD%V4z%V%%;
V<P-F1GH%|5"#:9%V5($'()*+%JM7Q+t%J$1P9%V !"#$"%&'()*+% D(-=%XYD%V4%V%%;
%#S6-+%|5"#:9%E YK'% .yP)Q+%1%'(*+%(YyPMD%(8% @?/R%&?_1%Wn_%V !"#$"%&'()*+%i'(8'2% -ZD%V4{3%V%%;
V YK'% .yP)Q+% /Z=% !(c$(8%E<PS!
V%|%V(M6="1%P)@%1%PU6*+%JD?D%J$1P9%1%Yl%V D'2%i1CK%V5"#$"%'2%&'()*+%5?-0%1%(F%<?M=%V4%V%%;
V%|%V<PS!%#S6-+% !?$C$?.9%^Y(/+%E5"#$"%&'()*+%8"?l%V%(9% 8%V%%;
V{%{%|z%V}%E _P!L%1%r-F#0%V5"#$"%&'()*+%'2%&'"1%A2#+%V4%V%%;
V4%%|%}%E5"#$"%#-F%1% D(-S!(6D(8%V#:0%h+(K%Pf7+%V4z3%V%%;
% c-F#0%"#M+%5(+L(D%|5"#:9%V&#:)_'C8%<#FL%sM.*9%1%J$1P9%V2?+g%E21P!"%EP!g%| !()6R(D%T(/+%V4%V%%;
V'?SO
V%|5"#:9%V .M:D%PM)% !"2#_'(O%,8% !?$C$?.9%&?c6n_%V&#$?/9%'"?!%V2(6D"%#Q+%'2%| !"#$"%&'()*+%V4{%V%%;
%&'()*+%5(//Z6+%(8% $"#Z0#M+%aMy()D"% !?$C$?.9%&?c6n_%V&#$?/9%'"?!%V2#_CM+%| !"#$"%&'()*+%V44%V%%;
%%V%|5"#:9%V .M:D%PM)% !"2#_'(O%,8%E !"#$"
%'(g%Wq(n% .+%5(+L(D%|5"#:9%V&#:)_'C8%<#FL%J$1P9%V#"%iG$1%i'()=%5"#$"%&'()*+%'2%,DP-F %V4{%V%%;
V !"#$"% !(6D(8
V}'1#H%1%}L?+g%|5"#:9%V5"#$"%&'()*+%k(M@?/R%,D?6+%<'12%#-F%V4%V%%;
V D(Yy%(l'%<L?+%|5"#:9%V5(:n@"%h+(K%Pf7+%V4%VU-T"#F(+%2?)Q+%1%E&L"#M=%<2"L%x"%W$g%#w(8%1%%;
V !(6D(8%'(g%Wq(n% .+%5(+L(D%|5"#:9%V(8'%1%<"'%V4%V#70"%x"%W+"#O%1%E%;
VAPU+% 6$"'%P-:+%'(O%#602%|5"#:9%V 9?@%'"?!%V<2"L%x"PYy%&P:+P)Q+%(8% /Z=%&?c6n_%V43%VJM7%EAPU+% 6$"'%;
%|5"#:9%V44%V?.w#w%#+?MO%^)K#9%V 6*$#=% .y% D(MD%^+(-M_P!L%|2(8g(fO(!%&?f67K%'2% !().7+%V%V .y%E()-F'%;
V?!%A(_
%<(cS!"2%|5"#:9%V&'()*+%&#6O2%i'12% D'2%^T(U+%V5"#$"%&'()*+% D(-=%XYD% S$P!"L(8%V4%V&P:+%E 0(!% 7M'%;
V'P+%WM8#9
V(!% 8%|5"#:9%V5(7!"%WU.R%V4z{%Vx"P$%E 8(QD%;
%#6O2%PM:=%N.*+%'(g%,y?)f+%NMe-9%1%J$1P9%#602%NMe-9%1%&'1g2#_%V2(='"%&(F%'2%| D(-=%AtD"%V4%V .y%E 6*$#=%;
VN.w%|5"#:9%V 6*$#=% .y
%V5"#$"%&'()*+%&'(c!%I$'(9%#e-+%L"%(M!#MH%N$#OP)Q+%'(g%1%>"?"% D'#8%|,D'P+%L"%'"#0%V43%V&P:+P)Q+%E<2"L%x"PYy%;
%E 6S:8 %PM:= %<(cS!"2 %|5"#:9 %V&P-FPM8 % +?Mw %2"2#:+ %|()-F"' %2(6D" %V5"#$" %&'()*+ %k(*T(+ %P='" % D(-='(O %^+(!%5($(H
V&L(D#:=%1%&'()*+%iPbS!"2
V(M!#MH%A?#+%2(M-8%|2C$%V(M!#MH%N$#O%2(6D"%^+(!2($%V44%VV1%#YO"%E<(M7).w%;
V{%;z%|4%V}%E>(MR%V5"#$"%&'()*+%^+(!%I$'(9%'(:d%&2(U6!"% D'#8%V4z%V2"2#:+%E&P-FPM8% +?Mw%;
%V4z%V !(MO%D?$P)Q+%1%#70"%x"%W+"#O%^)K#9%V5"'?9%1%5"#$"%'2%&'?)M9%&'()*+%V43%V#Y.$1%PT(!12%1%E"CMT%EXY)._%;
V'?SO% c-F#0%"#M+%5(+L(D%|5"#:9
V c-F#0%1% ).y%|5"#:9%V4{%V'($#0%x"PYy%^)K#9%V5(!(Z.$"%i'12%'2%5"#$"% +tD"%&'()*+%V43{3%VPT(!12%E#Y.$1%;

www.SID.ir