!

+lzi
i;EzIti{7
:tzall:tlii?
?1
t=!t{?vz?t7;i?
*
:ilzl;?i
tt1t:iitZ
i1iZ ?
;=ztEi:;J'
;iia;
tii.i=z
i t /?=t,t!

ilir
i.cl

:z?+{zat=1!?!l?1t11i{,Z
i
+
=ri7.1-;{??'
i
{t?11
2;:i??
12;:
z;1!t =?z{r
+;f,{,1

i ?t:|?ii:;
iii;si,li=! =
i9i!?i{zt

!!?i?,;tiz!
i
ri:i;i!::E Iilliiiif

,'\,

:+i;;,iil1?iar{iii:i
!1:::!?
r
ii

r iiii!u{;?a?i,;
ii::!ilz
:;fiii

;
a!;!t:{?
i
1!?z
EE?:
Iii;
*i!,i
+r
i
ri!*;t
ri
; :

r"l

i i - . ! 7 z - a r = = . t 7 ? t a .

ri?i;:i+!zi!:;!t!:
tiii

i ii:
:itiiitrlE:li;
z;+i
ii
:
i;
:!iti?i+;li;r,
i
;zi?
ii?i#

fi'l

ij,?i=1i7:z-111111,::1
ir,t,Ftiiltii:ii
ii=;i:1:'r=11=111=*i'+
-+e:1ii!::1=111;s;z
=:=:a==

;;
?:i|+ztizi=
=
ii..i1i
:
;
'
=
z
i
: : ; E ilai = = ! i t
: 1 i . i , i . i a , = : = i i 1 2i z: t T l z ;

;::ii+='
lZltl=zi
1i111
;Zat
1izr=i=z;,tiiliiii
;i==:=,;21=z
ta,==
zzizl:
z=zt:
;,1
:i1i1lzzj:
;'ii:i+zi
.
iil'=t='
;1*1{=iz:zzzz;E1i;ii
Eiji!iiiif
;1.*,,.ji:E
i
=,7,=,',2,12'
jizzzza,2izz==i*11*|ziZlizE
j1*"1,1i281i;;i;iEiEii,z|;ji!:Z,
r; ;:;:i! ;eii:
=";=
rlilzi+tiiizzEtl

::=iizlizt
=r:
;|j+=
1t=

:I
t;1
E\tzli
:2, :.:z:z

11=i1z=i
::1
ii::=
z
:itZ=i;z:==i?:i"ilZiii+z=;
=iz
+

i! 1::
i+1
z1:
v1izlZZ;++
Iti+1,1t,7,
1:iiZ,=
1;,i
a
tii*:
iilii r3!=ut
1
l+Z?:
i1*i;tz=tiZAeZiz
:1tn1,,Z7iZii
;ii z;1t,E
:
;l;Ttz;lE
iz2iz=:{:1:lZ
,1,,1iiiilz{E{:
i
zltzzi,
=a7iz+i1|:ti1???ia1z1tit3+

'
=iit|i:i'i:i:i,tzzi<ililgzzZEz*zZzz'
i,
ziitiziiz;z
ial;tr11z\Elti;;,ti

Z12i,1j,1.1:i+-z;zi::f

A
lcl

:,,:=',!z?TziliaAllitl#{
? i?t r ,i l Ei =

tit?4tlu:;iit?!i
:,t=,
*j\?l:*iizzizT,;=
717?it.T?
irIz
i:ie1

ztllilifzitTlAlil?:trEz,,?Et

=tiiii
ri7
=,zii\?;1?7:i:ZiE;I;E
;
:
ti
z1
tzi
F
=
t;?
i
Z
tl
:;iii
="2
==1): "
7'7-7'=
i';=!'Vt7i t?7:i7'=
'+?!?i+?iE
17i?1uiiu=Z?t1i?i7Et
I
'=;
=;1
iirrt=?i
i?i7iz+i=r7;1:ii;!z:?zi
1 7:=:?:
i:r:==r

z=ii1,:
=?i:
t
,1;+litziZielAz+?12
lzllt1lll
E
=
1
z
1
l+; ;i =
=; = , i 7
' +77
; ? = ; l ;i'i27==i =t 7; iiaz1i 71 7r =:-n
;i=t2=zil?1?,?,
V7\:=++=*1==82t,*
+ll?ZiZ1i7z;ilZi..7 + 7i ri ? l i l , ig i ?g + l t t a ; t 1 ; i 7+i a i i ? i ? r ; i i ? : 7 : i ! i
'i 3 "

s ^\Q =

i*;E;s=: i'
h

T -

l - :

2iii;t'=ei

= Z Z + : * i -! {
c

'

E
: : : 1 i !+
' =; ii =
? 3 l i
.

. . - . - '

i .

1 i

: d Z'
= ' = L d . '^l
'<'

='

!a:?-ii:=
a
.it:=\i
2 . ; ; a a \ 3
1

2 L't'=- 5 ;: .i :'

i . ; 3 = ; i : - :
-

'!!r rii
iiiri;si;7i::zl;:!iz;
zz!,t!
i:;is
:j .. =
; i = =
: ' a : _ t a
s

: ' A

:
-

i= =.

=1 = :

i = :

^S:;;=?::,?7=2===
r,i;:2=i7===-:7=?=

ii:;:;t'lli?;:j';

tiltii
i: ttti+?*zltii,rt
i
; l == ;) z i : 1 :r . =
! . > -+ Z = Z

-';

=?'_= : - i ?

7-= a = ;7

?E
liii;;ii +?i?i
|iiE?i ; i i i n; ? : z ! : i
sE;:e:

?=='::71;

-Zi
1!.7=?Z=,EiE??E7i'=-7
z =i i ' z : i i i a ? =i l; i ? ' - = =
;=tt:?:,;=7_:?li:t=:

;a:lt
i
s,
i
;
F
i
?iii
E
iF
r?{u!v*i:gig
jaf:i?t#:i{i;;?irii!;;ti#,:'1
ii
'=i
i
Z; ? 1 " V i :E1 ; 4 ' ; i =E' ;
,z i??
=?
- z;ia, ?
7 :; i i i i =+ i:

=+ !: "l i; i = =7 . ==;: . .

1 1 ? =. r ?

=i ,

;=
: = i 1i ; i
E ; : j Z ' r ' i ? 7 ? = : ? = .7 V ' ;- i i

;t1tli1lz;E??:i?t?liir1i1i{iil
r
= a ; - j = ' =z?: =
? !=; l = =2 i F

'

=
==: :
l
I
z
?
?
:
=
':it; :=. :: ?
1
1
=
=' - =: i i = , 3 1 - =1. :=: ;
t < = . -= =
E d ? , .
_ i

iil:iz!::12;tzltz{=z1a
rt11:it:1*jizt+11u'zz
'4r:=14;
t t i
=

2 ^ , 7 !

=..2- :aa,a
^
' -

' ==

:
a

"

't

"

; . = : :
t - -

t =

- =

. ,

= l - z
2
1

a
;

=
=

=-

A
2

! -

2 = - : / =
: - =

= =

= !
a=

=
-

- . =

2 2 ) ) i = Z ? ! 7 , i o ! ,

=+ z=E

l-1 ' = =

i : = ' . ' ;
=

' - =
!

. = u
:

: 2

= =
)=t.-7.
' == -

7 . = - =

= -

'

= =

E==vi E!-=z
j=. :1 ,
ii+ltiziE'z=;iizi
1
;
!
=
:
i
i
t
E
l
=
,
==1==21!i.iizi =ei EE

t _ =

i , 7 : i t ;j - i + z r i = = - ; : ' =

= ; - - 1 : ' . 7i zi ;Z=zi i = =ii,?. iei;=i=z, i7. 73t: ii i=I == ==_i ;=z- =, zZ: i i = =
zV
+ ti z: : Z j:i . z ii'':2 2

+ziui;=,iii=:Z
;izz;=1=E
ii 211+
+,
i zi i -=
!
Z=,
4,
t=z
z1:11:1=ii:Ztit?1ZiZ1EE
Eiiiiiiz!aZii!zi
z
=
3 j 7 " , 7 2 z ' - . i i + - - = 7 t = it = '

i=r:i;zzzrz
1i11i1
EZilEEt
i'EZ+zi12Et_iiE=

i : +;,1 : t1 i ; ; ;i i i l E i z ;:r;z;i i i l = i i E l 1 ii : i = :

ilzii;te:zz:
1=!t==11
EliEit,lll
Ii;*
=i
;
i#:.{;
: 1i
zi:z
7jt :;+iz;::21
:a#
1i;zi
ii
zii;il,,i;11,7
zzi=,

+z
zi1=i*i
: ;!liili;;:iiEi
a:**
=:i!;1Z:giEii
i i,,;z

.lilli\i\1fti:iutt,iltiil+E

t==;ii:=1i:11i;;j
li+i'li:t1
:. i,i:iiiit?i=Eizzi;j
E

"'ittzTTt:x:?tzttl:{tTf7
'?!;781i'=11'77i11t
z
?
= i t t ! 7 1; 1
1
=
=
1
l
i
'
,
r
1
!
?
!
- = 2 7 = . = . = - ! Z :
i!=lE;=?;==;=-zz=:
: ' i = ; = = : . = l 2 . ' i- E = = = 3 2 4
:= =77:r;,i=!7lZ::
=jt
=
a_
=?2-*2i aa=-=
+Zi i ? ::i,
''=.=
i ; _ i .= r Z2 , 1 1 + : =; '-i Z
Q1,=-.2?=.77i2

l1

"=

= 7 -'"

; :'F-'\':

- , <

= -

= . = . -

^ j a . = = - = ' r = =

- i, .F .' G 7 1 , ;

.. =
- a i z i ' - ' r
: = ?= ;. 4
' .- ' . - . + v
= ;
. - L -

a '

c .i

=.=-

? a - t a = _ ; 1 . i == ;=- 7 v z 1 ;=

=,

' . ? = i . a i a * V - a

i:::i?;z!;+:zi;t:i;?
{,

= : . : " . = 2 = = ' = : .
?

2 + " i ' -

a-

=*i,=1i?i?l1:=t?it7+
{

>

?,7 ? 7 !r ! i;=i l i
= Z =i ;:,ir2

t ii=i:l=1;Z
i.?tZi t
: ti i"=

,e
riiii#i

i
=
=

F
=
=

+ + =
7 ;

a
a
=

;
i

a
)

-= i a = 4 . t

a
- t
- 4

?
7

c
t

a
?

. zi = i | - . - .7 . = 2 .
?+ti=a'-l'.=-=1.
? ? = = , j i ' t r 7 c L

; ; : L
7 a = = a
a : . . = a -- a - . . 4 , 7
7 . = - : 2 i- ? = - . _
. , = t
= .
\
a
4
=
a..j Z.-_.7=.?,2,_ i

= ' ? -=? ; = :
? 1 = : t ' =- '. , =

==:=?
:+i:-,==?i
?- =
i :?, 2
,; it ?==1t nL :: 1 2 7
i

- -

= A ; . ? : ^ . 1 L a ' .: )
=
i. .-.
-=
T

...;

i:

: =

= =

- , -

- ' -

- , >

,;:1i;r::

:- ar ; = =
1 = ,- = :- ;. =2 i
- = i =

iiii;tzt
: tzt:1ii\zE=,i;:tz
!!iE:i:,1;;t
iizlitiiii;=i
\1

Ei

: zi;
lialEi;ii
;:tzit =
;:1zz;1':=1:iii:11;lizlifiiXiE:
i1iu=i
iizTi
zzzi:i?
::izEiza
,
Zi

iz1==,i1:'i
r ltr;t1:Zt,:*=iliiiE;IEiE
tz=1'=
iEi
ar i i i i Z = Zi zZ- ;1-. . i =: Z t ! = i;ii i = =i i: Z z: i i i? Z z+ .i; _
i i:
z
=
;
1
=
7
i
:
=11i
=i
ii
ii
ii
:1
i=21:z
z=1
ir+i=r,==
lii
ulir;=i
;itii::i11:
iiir+:==zz:::z;z irtZi
=_t
==;=?i,'ii
i
,i:,li:z
1,-E
:?zizlti?Zlta:z=i;Eizz+iiirlizz
1u=,
i i, z ;
t +i si i:=iEt
i : : 17= :

:
i : zi :=:Zlji? :Zi i =i= i : E
13=
ii
7
i:
7'=
=
i i zi: t 1i=,
=
zi itu'=z=ri=2l
+:;'z::1z:; ilei li:z
z
zE
=
;=
ii
zi
:zz
:
iitzlE
iil
:
-,i t t ?z=*r, i' =iii13 iltii aEi E
r'=4=,,2
I zEaz i.
= i

a
i
:=.:i
tE=
!i\=z-;?:
E
EE
tizE,ii
E
,tjiiili:aZ11\ti\1zi
;
i
=
=E4 iz=
' t=
?
E
=
= - = = i i i e zzTz "i i: "Ei i7i
;
;i, i
:i:

z!=,=;t1E==t:=:
=2ElE=;ziii

t
:i:zi:izi=i=,i
:=
:
i
zE
z1
:1
i'::
:
:1
:2
+
z
i
12
= :i ,; i7: =z=z+
a i i i i ; = , i : r = , ; z *: 2
z : i Z t i E iZE: i = :;;i 1: u =: 2 2 '! = i l i i , ii ;

!,i ?7,ii
Iz2; i 11
z
:z
l:
#
i
::i ::;It =:11:j
i
:i-tE
I
z=.
z
' .= i
i
i=:i1
i,aij: ' i e ? i i = ,=?^z-lE i z3 E E = = =i =i : E:=:;

z:ji7.t12 :il1E:11i;zi;*1r
lZZi;+
;=:;1:
| =+zz
. i i : i ;i

i;=zi!=;iiz
7az1.i
il; :z;+lirli

?i::iE
Et.t;32
1iii1ii17
i::
tz\ili
l;tt;
i;:
I
Xi;:zizi :g1;zE
: ;;ii;s2111i,i,tii11izi1

iut;tzi*lt,!{{?liil?ii#7{,f,{1
'*Zilizztt$=E+ttlit+l;1iV
: = = / :t i : = a : + :
r' / = - -

: , 4
-

= =

7
-

=
=

1 =
=
) . ' l

'

4 : j T ;

'

. =. . = .
-= ' - =
: : ;" ; -.
J I =..8 -

-' == ' := =a i - = r=.

=-7 ?
j '-.
= = = = =

z*zzi?l,Z\artzzEzz
1=:1\?=zti?
==7_7
;=t

. i = ' = . ' 1 7 .. i 7 = . . ?
=

'

r: ,
!
^ ;
= 7,n
L 7 a 4 . 1 t _ . ) . 4 ^ 4

i' -= . .= = = - = - - Z . . 2
= . = =
a L

: ? ' _ = ? + ; - - = ? ' i
t

=j

=
2
a
= =

' - . '
-

<
^a

?
i=

'
=
IL

'

' - J

"

)C

,
2=

- :
i :

! i = = = - ? - ^ 2 ? - = =
?
7
- , ' _* c ' E tx ' |a , '= a
- : . * -6 ? V4 . =
.
-

1 F
t \

=.^:
=

=
.

a
7

-.fr
=
=

= . = =
= ,
L
a a :

- .

=
-

-- =-17
1
-

\ ' =-

=
=
=- .= r

=.'
-'/

?z?1;ii3:17i
7??!'
=t;z

i ;i?,
i; Z1=1
I???i
+t,jZz
Zfi7tit!z;1t7:'t

?ev
iil*;z
?vl;itt
+\iiiEE?zt!E:t?z?

siillctt?7jir
i!t?iii!?!tE:
iii .??I
: 2+o?Z:;;?7lZ=
\

i==i,==7=";L_;=1

t
:

- : i . : : - = i - = ' - a ' = t Z
= a 74 = - = = 1 -., - ;

i
iit/i;
i :i3
i
t;?!i.'
v:
i?itzti
?!11!ii
i
; i ;',! t:;l l

:
ii==i=?-i:: =;
?
=;7*z:{i i;i.:
i iii i:Ztz?
:ii;;iii:?iiiililiil:if i???vltli
i

*lii:t!!iti;:;;11+
;it+
i?:lizi!

= : . ; ' =1 =
.= :7 l : i1 - . = = l
j i
1 = . : . : = ; - - = i : - .
: - : : 2 ' - = = ' .

'
:
1
-

:
l
:- -

= 1 7 = ; 1 1 . - i -:= :i .
_=7lrl:_=;-l!
7 a - :'1. j ? =.? ?.

:z?;
??;t
ziisiiiiii til?tlEi!1:,!: a a : = = 7 : i===
,

'

===Ei:,il: 7:
' - 1 = = ; - : _ aj
7

; ;

##*i ; : i ;i +; ? ; ?z: li i ;t : t i l i
:#*Ei*#5

ii +r i:t:;i?'i:*'i1
e=, : . , ,
=I I=F! ,?;iii:ri:!li:5
:: l +? a a
?, : :i
: ; ; i ; ; i : i i ? : ? i j 1 : ;'.i

=;+;,i ,i;::;z ri
??:
Iii
F

i : ; : r l ; ? i +i :i :i i . - ; . : r

; zj1;il::I! tzz!,
l zz = l i ; ? I i t 1 i ;1: i ;e ?. := ;Y
1::!z?z
= 7 ! i : : ) ' i l ? z : : ? i : 2 4Z
;i

i,=,_ ==ii1
ti1=,
=1lr11Z-=121Eiii;Zti1i
='it t . a
t
,
==
i:__,21=12::iZ
4 a - t : ; i i = tr t 2 1 =i7
=1+tz;zzz:?i;i:;
/

,/

I
I

sl
c'

o\

. : : = 1 +, i1z:: = i\ a' : =
tz1 2 ; Z ; r V t l z
i '=z=i jri T
===
a;, :121i|i==i=.rt=i
:i ==:.
7?zZl1::::+?iZ=t;Z
= 7 i:i=+
:=.
lx

o / u

\\ =J \ (
\

iil :liiu=7
, : 111
zz,:i Z}rE
1;i1i;Z
i z2 =z i :

,/
\ :o,/
=uz
,/
-c ., / /
./
,/

z {

^,

tJE
f

, ^ o
-75

1 t =t = ; 1 1 i v 1 1 i Z
,'Z1=u:

i;;1'_7.+a
x*}1+r1T1ziz:X
1l?
,1=
11
i1=t=1:.*1z11i7Ez1
=
1=?i
1z
;
1t
i;
73

zz
i ::i:|iiitzzlazllzzlzzxfiE'*t

1
ti
i. ,t, : ;riz=i,i1:
11
:+i
1i:i
iL',
'
=
!
i
=
i
r1l
rl+;.
iZ1=
:i:i:Z?i*ai
Z
'j=; 1' !Z I = Zzi::iii i z Z Z ; l i = , i Z i ' zz ;i iz7
i -i :
Z
;
!;;
ii=,?
=:
+:1:
i1zI1;TZri,!
zz
r::: =,:jit*l}
zllllzillZlz=i,tZ{:
1=
;4i:, i,::1:i:,Tli
=
1i
:
:=
lit11
;1
=i11i11
111=zi=+Z!.;;111.
2 2= 7

,1iiivi''

=1iziztl;aiz#iZ*;zzZl1li

'l

l alllc l.

hc irLunrcol lirr rlroectlurrl rlcrnocrlcv in schcrrrlticoutlinc

Then procedurestor makingbinding

decisionsmust satisfythe followingcriteria

l f o n e b e l i v e st h a t :

A s p e c i f i c o l l e c t i oo
n f p e o p l eh a s
a n c e df o r b i n d i n gd e c i s i o n s .

A.1

C . 1 .P o l i t i c ael q u a l i t y
C.2. Eifectiveparticipation

B i n d i n gd e c i s i o n si n v o l v el w o
stages:
S e t t i n gt h c a g c n d a
I n c d c c r s r v cs l a g e

T o l h e e x i e n t t h a t p r J c e d J r e s s a t i s f yl h e
- - ^'^ tchcs:

C . 3 . E n l i g h t c n eudn d c r s t a n d i n g

Procedural dcnocracy in a narro', ; scr-,:e

F u l l p r o c c d L r a ld c m o c r c c y , ! , i h r c 5 p c c t
to an agcnda and in relatron to a dcrnos

A . 3 . B i n d i n gd e c i s i o n o
s u g h tt o b e
made only by personswho are
s u b j e c t o t h e d e c i s i o n s( i . e . ,b y
memoers)
E q u a l l yv a l i dc l a i m sj u s i i f y
e q u a rs n a r e s .

4.4

A . 5 The preferencesof a significant

n u m b e ro f m e m b e r sa s t o t h e
d e c i s i o na r e e q u a l l yv a l i da n d
no member'spreferencesare of
overridingvalidity.
A . 5 . 1 .T h e f u l lc o n d i t i o n
of equal
LiudililLdLrurI

The good ol each memberis

entitledto equalconsideration,
and eachmemberis assumed
t o b e t h e b e s tj u d g eo { h i s o r
h e r o w n i n t e r a s t isn t h e a b s e n c e
of a compellingshowingto the
contrary.

A.6

C.4. Finalcontrolof the agenda

F u l lp r o c e d u r adle m o c r a c iyn r e l a t i o nt o
r t so e m o s

C . 5 .l n c l u s i v e n e s s

Full proceduraldemocracy

e^rrrr.

: - ' : i ? i t L t + i i ; ; ! ; .=i ?i :z; 7! =t3 :=

; ; ? =t ; i : = ;?t +7t ' : 4 7r Et ? ? i + -+Z+! :
i : ,7
i i z- ;=!=t:1
: i ? ?=?i : i 1=iZ' r1 !t t; i?!i :' =i E
i;i;i+
; ? =; t l
: ; - 3 - 3

l q

:t::!it:rli1=
:i,i:?=,
Ii ;i=t!;,
t
;Zi
+:z;z:i
;t,11
ilt\t|:it
t,
r:t*++!zt
1u?;
::i! :i !! ;
ta?7

lTEV

; = ;;.l \ 3 i r z i ? - ; i = ? .
_= 1 :- =. ^ ' : : i =

lt?,=i
;
?
t
?;
==1'":i;?a7.==i

; = i 7 7? ;; l z : :i : 1 1 3 i 7 ? u==iii!Zz :

i ? i + =i 7 i 't,

1t

it=
:ti=it??i?
litiii:z;it?i*il+i,1!:::z1r?Ji;+

. _ : 7 : = ; , =
=

= -

'

' :

a =

. . , ' - ) : = "
7

j . . , . ' t

- - :
'

= . =

- , i
=
' : . = ; z - = '- : : ;

-- ==.-

::
-

=
z

'

'

. =: =2; ; {

r = 1 i' . = - a t

7'

=. 1
'

F.
= --

a. -

= = = ; ^ - . = '

i ; ; 2 . 7 -^ = =
- - ' a c - 'J= ' ' :- .
1--

= := ' = - : 2 = ! :- . i - =
= =
=:
= a
;,n

j =+r=? E7 a
= r , i _ l ; 1 1 7

ili! i z

rzzTl:liSxii*'*lilii
lixx?::!ii::1tzii1t;

t )
=

=t=

!
t
= u=
=

7==Z

t2 it =a
:=1- 14 a
?22
2 = )

l: i =i -=i :- .t =i -= : ' 2= _, - : . 1 2 4
9
i ' i' = i V i _ T l _ r
==;";,.2

=1 =
; =,J2
= :1:
i

:i i= Z]
z = a

i!=|i;iz\=z;i!i:ziiz
j+:
,11,rt1:rl\,1iii1;:

=
2 " i '- ,. '- ii :== -= i' '== :' . ' = a = , i :
z= ?l ii - .: ,: i r r = - = = i t i ! + i
=/=::;)==i-ti:Zl2
;i7
. = , ir= ; 1 4
i , 1 t, E

=I ?

:
d

=ZZ

==i:a1e'!.2i.1';
z,i:itj,=-7i'--==
:: :: ' 1, j: i 1t L= t :a' -z. ;: :, : Z =

= : _i t _ a i 2 a 7 <

===?=.i_i+1ii':=,=+::
::_zzi=i=;1izi:,=Z

i:

/ -

=i44i,:=;.'-Z).:72L=

*i r-

:-=:1:-)'-l=:t-.7

ri
c..