Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Entrance To The Stratigic Think by Salah Nayouf 2505008
Entrance To The Stratigic Think by Salah Nayouf 2505008
.
.
""
. .
""
. " "
""
" "
" ".
.
" " .
.
.
!
.
.
.
"
" .
.
.
. "" .
"" .
.
.
.
1
.
.
.
.
.
.
1
" " 1022
. .
"" .
": ".
. . " "
.
" ":"Sun Zi
" .
"
" . " " "
".
""
"" . ":
".
.
. ":
") . .(Lewal " " :
"
" ) . 1814(.
":
" ) . " "
.(1955
. ""
.""
.
" " ": ".
:
.
"." " "
. .
. Clausewitz " " " :
" 1 1815
.
:
. Puysgur
":
" . 2
"" "
" "
1
Raymond ARON, Penser la guerre, Clausewitz , tom I, lge europen, Paris, Gallimard 1976, P.31.
? Marchal de PUYSEGUR, Art de la guerre par principes et par rgles , Paris, chez C.A. Jombert 1748
P.26.
2
.
".3
Ernst Jnger
. . ) (
) ( .
.
": Schaumburg -Lippe
.
" .4 .
. ": Julien Freund
" " 5
".6
Mmoires de M. le marquis de Feuquire, London, chez Pierre Dunoyer 1736 ? PP. VII-VIII.
Comte de Schaumburg-Lippe, schriften und Brief P.158.
5
Julien FREUD, Que veut dire :prendre une dcision ? , Nouvelle cole, 41,automne 1984 ,P.54.
6
Herv coutau BEGARIE, Trait de stratgie , conomica, paris, 1999, PP.36-37.
4
/ . strategie strategija
. strategi ) (stratos agein
" " . stratos agein
strategos " " strateg
strategikos strategika
. 1
.
. stratos
.
. stratos :
) (gia ) (agein .
.
"" " ".
strategia strategema
.stratagme ) De Puysgur ( ":
:
" ) . Herv coutau Bgarie ( . ) stratagme
( "" .
.
1
L.Wheeler, stratagem and the vocabulary of military trickery , Leyde, Brill, Mnemosyne supplement 108,
1988, P. 3.
. stratge "" " " .
.
.
.
.
strategema
Xnophon Clment
Alexandrie . strategika
.Demetrois de Phalre
.
"" " " .
strategema
strategika "" . strategeo
Onosander " " .
" " ) : (.
" " strategema
) dolus ,ars ,astutia,
.(sollertia
) (scientia rie militaris .
10
strategos stratge "
" . Syrianos
Peri strategikes .
" " .
" " Taktika
.
.
Zun zi ) ( bing-fa
.
""
Zun zi .
":
.
" .1
) (
.
. Mathey
stratge Oceana Harrington 1656
.strategns strategy 1688 Geography
Morden 1810
1
- Guang Zi, les sept mthodes du gouvernement , cit dans Xu Zhen Zhou ( lArt de la politique chez
lgistes chinois , Paris, Economica 1995, P.229.
11
12
13
-1 :
.
taxinomie
-.
- trilogie
:
.
taktika . strategia Dietrich von Bulow :
.
.
:
:
.
: Clausewitz :
. :
.
.
14
) Moltke 1866 ( . :
. .
.
Lewel
. paradigme .
Joffre
. 1915
Ludendorf
. )(
:
.
) ( ) ( .
Poirier .
.
: 1830 - 1820
.
Marmont
Clausewitz .
.
.
.
15
.
( - Ruhle Von Lilienstern ) Clausewitz
:
.
action
.acte
Blume . .
Lewel Bonnal
: .
Grouard Castex
:
.
.... .
. Castex
.
:
. logistique
.
:
. .
Joly de Maizeroy
Jean de Vignay . -
1310 1320 . mestres darmes
16
: - tactice- . 1570
Paul Hay du Chtelet . 1968
Furetire .1690 . 1766 Mesnil Durand
: 1770 ..
.
Clausewitz .
. Antoine Grouard
: - - 1895 :
) (
.
: .
.
Malplaquet
. 1709 Jean Colin -
-Transformations de la guerre
.
.
Bir-Hakeim Stalingrad . Budapest
17
Logistique :
. Guibert
.
logisteuo . xviii
) ( .Trvoux Jomini
.
) ( )
( .
.
18
. James A. Huston -
- The sinews of war
: logistics
. :
- - .
: Clausewitz
Nockern de Schorn xviii
) (
:
.
- -
1870 Lewel Organisation
: rationnelle 12 .
.
Partie organique
Giovani Sechi organisation
.
.
19
: :
: - .
.1813
Culmann
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
industrialisation
.
. :
.
20
: : .
. Herbert Rosinski
.
- 1
.
.
Liddell Hart strategy
.
.
.
.
1959 1984
.
. Jacques Laurent
outil pour la pense militaire sovitique
.
.
21
- 2
.
.
.1
:
:
.
:
.
: opratique art opratif
.
Richardo Burguete - -
-
.
.
:
.
. )
- 1 : Globale
. . le Glossaire interarmes , 1995
22
( Alexandre Svechin :
. .1
) .(... :
.
1982
: vision : A Navy for the 21st Century 2020
.
.
Beaufre - - .
. Poitier -
- . opratique Francart
Objectif 21 ) 2 (1996
.
.
23
...
.
24
.
.
1.
Lewal Iung ":
".
"
" 3 . :
.
. :
.
) (.
) (.
) (.
. Poirier
":
".
.
1
- Gnral LEWAL, Etude de guerre. Tactique de mobilisation. Tactique de combat , Paris, Librairie militaire
Dumaine, 1875, pp. 32-33.
2
. - Gnral IUNG, Stratgie, tactique et politique , 18
3
- Jacques LAURENT, Un outil pour la pense militaire sovitique . p. 87.
4
- Lucien POIRIER, les Voix de la stratgie .
25
.
.
) ( .
.
. " "Sun Bin
" :
. .
".
.
. " " ""
.
2 .Herv Coutau Bgarie
Blow
Jomini .
. ":Jomini
. 3"..
paroxystique :
.Leipzig
26
Antoine Grouard " " . "
" " "
1 . Iung ":
. . .
" .2
.
3
Foertsch .
27
28
.
.
:
.
.
.
Thucydide Csar .Tacite Turenne
.
: Von
(Manstein ( Verlorene Siege 1955 1958
"" Rommel .
.
.
.
.
" " ) ( "
" ) ( " " ) ("
") ( . :
29
.
2 .
.
.
" " .
.
.
Grard Chaliand
" " ) 3 .(lAnthologie mondiale de la stratgie
.
) 2000 (
.
30
".
Royaumes Combattants
.Ploponnse .
Hoplomachoi
Sun Zi .Sun Bin
1 "Everett WHEELER " The Origins of Military Theory in Ancient Greece and China
5 1980 .75
31
2
.
.
.
3
.
.
.
4 .
.
.
.
5 "" .
. .
.
" "
" " . rationalisation
32
.
.
.
saint
Bonaventure saint Thomas dAquin .
.
:
Herv Coutau ). .(150
.
1 .
.
.
1.
" " "Hsn .Kuan" Lao Zi, Mo Zi
Sun Zi .
.
: " "
.
Sun Zi Sun Bin .
" " .Song
1972 "
" . .
1 4000
.1911
2 " " " " Flammarion .1981
33
.
.
.
Sun Zi . Cao Cao
Han Li Quan
Tang He Yanshi Zhang Yu
.Song Royaumes Combattants
:
""
.
Shen Zong " "
Herv Coutau ): (156
Wu Zi Bingfa
.
Sima Fa "
" .
.
Wei Liao Zi
.
San le " " Huang Shegong
.
Tai Gong Liutao " " Taigong
.
" Tang Li Wendui Tang Taizong "Li Weigong
.
34
.
.
.
.
Amyot
" "
.1779
Sun Zi 1860 .1889
Calthorpe .1
19501957 .1950
.
2 .
.
.
. 2 ""
) . 57
(.
1 "Frank A. Kierman and John K.Fairbank" Chinese Ways in Warfare : .1974
2 " Flavius Vgce ".Bordeaux Ulysse 1998
35
Ene .
. .
Ene .
Asclpiodote . Alphonse Dain
" " 326 ": Asclpiodote
".
Onesandros
. Elien
"" .
. Xnophon .1Thucydide
Thucydide " "Ploponnse
. Xnophon
" "
.
.
" " Reichel ":
" .2
.
":Polybe
" .3
.
.
Caton " "De Re militari . Polybe "
1 "Xnophon " M. Bizos and E. Delebecque 1971 .1978
2 "Daniel REICHEL" 1984 .38
3 William V. HARRIS" War and Imperialism in Republican Rome 327 370
.Clarendon Presse 1985
36
"Taktika .
Frontinus " " . Arrien
" "
.1
Brian
":Campbell
".2
.
) Alexandrine
( .
.
.Tacite
.
.
.
.
Syrianos
Constantin Polyen
.Syrianos
.Syrianos
1 "P .A . STADTER " The Ars Tactica of Arrian .Classical Philology. 1987
2 "Brian CAMPBELL " Teach Yourself to Be a General " " 1987 .22
3 "Pierre LAEDRICH : "Tacite
Economica .2001
4 .Constantine ZUCKERMAN" The Military Compendium of Syrianus Magister" 1990 :
37
. " "
.
3 /.
.
.
) (
.
":
. " ).
Grard Chaliand " " .(499
" " " ")
( .
.2
" " " "
" " .
).
" " 484 486
519 .(522
.
1 Walter E. KAEGI" Some Thoughts on Byzantine Strategy" Brookline The Hellenic Studies :
.Lecture1983
2 Vassilios CHRISTIDES " Ibn al-Manqali and Leo VI : New Evidence on Arabo-Byzantine Ship :
.Construction and Naval Warfare" Byzantino-Slavica LVI 1995
38
.
.
") "Libro de la Guerra ( 1420
Vellena " ) "le Tratado de la PERFECCIN del triunfo militar
( 1459 .Alfonso Hernandez
Robert de Balsac " "
1502 " " Braud Stuart
") "Kriegsbuch ( Philippe von Seldeneck
. " "Semideus liber tertius de re militari 1438
Catone Secco " "De Re militari Roberto Valturio
.
: .
" Larte della
) "Guerra ( .
"" "
" .2 " " ":
.
1546 1536 1560
1623 .3"1610 .1839
:
: :
: . ""
39
" "
.
.
" "
.
" "
. "
" .1
John Smythe " " 1590
Roger Ascham Matthew Sutcliffe " The Practice, Proceedings and
"Laws of Arms .1593
:
Roger William (A Briefe Discourse of Warre, 1590).
Humphrey Barwick (A Briefe Discours, concerning the force and Effect of all
manual Weapons of Fire, 1594).
Thomas Smith ( The Art of Gunnery, 1600).
Robert Barret ( The Theorike and Practike of Moderne Warres, 1598).
.
40
" " 1502
1510
" " . "
" Rmy Rousseau 1548
.
.
. "" Clves Flammand
Habsbourg 1508 " 1516 ".
Reinhard Solm
1544 1549 L. Fronsberger " Fnff
) "Bcher von Kriegsregiment und Ordnung
( 1554 1556 .
Lazarus von Schwendi
) Kriegsdiskurs (
1571 1577 .
.
41
.
.1 "" ) mercantilisme
(
.2 "
" "" .1576 Mendoza
": "cu
".
.
42
.
.
Maurice Nassau .
.
Antonio Espino Lopez ":
". 1
.
" "
/ .2
Johan Jakob von Wallhause .
Jean Nassau 1615
Herv BEGARIE ).
(.
"
" " The principales of the art
"Militarie .
.
.
: Francisco Barado
Antonio Espino Lopez .
Fernando Alvia Castro Cristobal de Rojas .Luis mndez de Vasconcellos
1 " Antonio LOPEZ " .77
2 Herv BEGARIE 180 .190
43
Francisco Melo 1638 " Politica militar y avisos
) "de generales (.
.1 Giorgio Basta
" "Il maestro di campo general 1606
" "Del governo dellartigliera .1610
.
Louis de Montgomery Maurice de Nassau
Jrmie de Billon " "
. 1612162216361641 Rohan
" " 1636 "" .
1663 " " Aurignac )
: ( .
.
Montecucculi .
2 Montecucculi
)
( .
" " 1653
1693 .
1712 .1760 " "Della Guerra col Turco in Ungheria
.
1 Gregory Hanlon " The Twilight of a Military Tradition : Italian Aristocrats and European Conflicts :
1560-1800 .UCL Press Taylor and Francis1997
2 Jean Thiriet " "Montecucculi : ""
60.1995
44
.
.
.
.
.1 .
" " 1724
" "Polybe 1727 1730 1753
1774 " 2 ."Folard Maurice Saxe
1756 " " .
":
.
".
1770 1780
. .
.
.
.
Folard, Feuquire , Puysgur . Feuquire
Folard Puysgur .3Logistique
" ".
1 :
45
.
Henry Lloyd "A Political and Military
"Rhapsody on the Invasion and Defence of Great Britain and Ireland
1 "Joly de Mazeroy : " Leclerc1777 .18
2 Curd Ochwadt .
46
.
1789 1815 .
. Lazare Carnot
1 "D. GRUBER" British Strategy : the theory and practice of eighteenth century warfare :
.Greenwood Press 1978
47
. :
" " 1809 .
: " "
Roche-Aymon 1802 1804 "
" Simon-Franois Gay 1805 .
Reveroni de Saint-Cyr "
" 1808 "
" .1826
Prussien Dietrich
" ) "Geist des neuern Kriegs Systms (
1799
.
" Lehrstze des neuen Krieges oder reine und
) "angewandte Strategie (
.1805
Charles Grundstze der grosse " :
) "Kriege ( 1808 " Grundstze der Strategie erlutert
) "durch die darstellung des Feldzugs von 1796 in deutschland
1796 ( .1813
.
Jomini
48
Henri-Antoine Jomini
. .1
1779 Ney .1805
" "
Tempelhof 1783
Lloyd " ".
Jomini
. "
" 1816
1869 90 ) . Herv Bgarie
200 .(210
" : "
" " 15.
. 2
.
William Duane John
Armstrong Dennis Hart Mahan West Point Alfred Thayer
) Mahan (Dennis
.
. 3Jomini
.Clausewitz
49
. Vom Kriege
""
. Clausewitz .41780
. " von
.Blow 1806 1815
.
Turenne, Frdric II
. opus magnum
: .
Clausewitz .
" " . " "
Kriegsakademie .1810
" " :
.
10 1827 Clausewitz
. Clausewitz
.
"" " " .
.New- clausewitziens
4 .Peter Paret " Clausewitz and the State" Princeton University Press1976
50
Clausewitz
.
1832 .1837
1500 15 .
. 1880 le Spectateur
militaire . Louis de Bystrzonowski
1870 Clausewitz
. Sadowa 1866
Sedan 1870 Jomini
.
Clausewitz .
. Clausewitz .
Clausewitz Vom Kriege Schlieffen
.1905 Clausewitz
.
.
Clausewitz .1870/1871 1880 1905
.Clausewitz Cardot"
" Clausewitz 1884
Georges Gilbert .1887
.Clausewitz
Clausewitz
.
51
.1Clausewitz
1834
.Vom Kriege Graham 1873
F.N Maude .1908
69 12
.
Clausewitz . Corbett
Clausewitz .
Fuller Liddell Hart Clausewitz .2
Jomini
. " " 1976 ":
Bernard Brodie
Clausewitz ".3
Clausewitz .
Emilio Canevari " Clausewitz e la guerra
odierna" (Clausewitz ( . 4 Banus Comas "Es
"trategia 1887 .Clausewitz
1908 .
. Clausewitz .1970
52
.
. 1
.
.
Jomini Bavarois Xylander, Wurtembergeois Theobald,
Mller, Valentini, Decker, Hoyer
.Hheren Kriegskunst
Clausewitz Von Lossau Rhle
.2von Lilienstern Clausewitz
.
.
. Joseph
Pougni-Guillet " " 1832 Paul
Racchia " " .1832 Enrico Giustiniani
" " .1848
Luigi Blanch
.
Scolastiques Lac
" " .
1 Olaf ROSE " Carl von Clausewitz, Wirkungsgeschichte seines Werkes in Russland und der :
"Sowjetunion 1836-1995 Oldenbourg Verlag 1995 (Clausewitz (.
2 Herbert ROSINSKI :" the Rise and Decline of Germn
"Military Thought Naval War College Review 1976 .83
53
.
.1
Nicolas Medem " ) "Obozrenie isvestnjchich pravil i sistem strategii
( 1836 Lloyd,
Blow, Jomini, Clausewitz Taktika 1837
Souvorov . M .I Bogdanovich
) Zapiski strategii ( 1847 .
Astafev " "
Dimitri Milioutine
1861 .1881 Okounieff
" " 1831 1812
1841 .1876
.
Marmont
" " 1845 .1865
.2 1815 1870
.3 .
.
1 "Carl Van DYKE" Russian Imperial Military Doctrine and Education : Westport Greenwood
Press 1990 "Walter Pinter " Russian Military thought :the Western Model and the Shadow of Suvorof
.Makers of Modern Strategy
2 Bruno Colson " Marchal Marmont, De lesprit des institutions
"militaires Economica .2001
3 : Sainte-Hlne "
" .1867
54
.
.1870
" "
.
. 1870
.1
.
.
1880
.
Colmar von der Goltz " Das Volk in
) "Waffen ( 1883 1884
1887 .1887 Wilhelm von Blume " Die
Strategie" 1882 1884 1887 .1899
"
" Hans Delbrck
. 1910 Friedrich von Bernhardi
" ) "Vom heutigen Kriege (
1912 1912 1912 1913 .1914
:
W.H. james " "Modern Strategy 1904 H. Tovey " Elements
"of Strategy F.N Maude " The Evolution of Moderne Strategy from the
"XVIII Century .1905 John Bigelow "
"Principles of Strategy 1891 Arthur Wagner " "Strategy
.1903
1 " " " " " 1871
" " 1899 " " .1907
55
.
1914
. 1
. .
.
Charles Times
. Spenser Wilkinson 1909
" " " First lessons in War
"1914 " ."Gouvernment and the War 1918
Lucia Frost Clausewitz
. " La Revue des deux-
. mondes La Revue de Paris La Revue universelle
Ferdinand Feyler )
1915 .(1918
" " "
".
1918 .
.
1 Lucas " 1914
"1918 .Berger-Levrault 1924
56
.1
: .
.
Visconti-Prasca " ) "La Guerra decisiva
( 1934 .1935
.
Chauvineau " "
1939 .
Wilhelm :
.Reinhardt, Alfred Krauss, Waldemar von Erfurth, Herman Foertsch
. Azar
. 2 Gat .
Alexandre Svechin " "Strategija .1926
. ""
"" ": ".
Mihail Frounze
Toukhatchevski " " "
" . Toukhatchevski
.Svechin 1939
1914
.
1 . Barry R. Posen" The Sources of Military :
.Doctrine, France, Britain and Germany between the World Wars" Ithaca Cornell University Press 1984
"Brian Holden Reid" Military Thinker .Macmillan 1987 Camon" La
"Motorisation de lArme et la manuvre stratgique .Berger-Levrault1926
2 "? Azar GAT " British Influence and the Evolution of the Panzer Arm : Myth or Reality .
57
.
1939
.
.
.
.
.
.
.Mahan
.
: Edward Mead Earle
" "Makers of Strategy 1943
1982 .
Stephen Possony .
.
.
. .
58
59
1 .
.
.
.
.
Jomini .
" : " " ".
Clausewitz . Jomini
.1914
.
. von
der Goltz " " .
)( . 1945
.
.
2 .
60
.
.
Clausewitz
.
.
.1
. ""
.
.
.
3 .
61
:
1
: .
.
2
.
.
.
Castex Bernard Brodie
Beaufre .
3 .1945
.
.
Thomas Schelling
Lucien Poirier .
.
.
62
.
.
Foch .1
1 .
.
. .
.
.
.
.
.
":
.
" .2 : 3
. .
.
. .
""
.
. .
1 "Foch " Des Principes de la guerre .94
2 " Jean-Louis SEURIN " .1989
3 Karl Popper " Konard Lorenz et Karl Popper " Flammarion1995 .117
63
. /
.
.