TI LIU HNG DN T NH GI CHNG TRNH THEO B TIU CHUN AUN

B 15 tiu chun ca AUN sa i thang 6/2011

(Ti liu ny c Trng i hc Cn Th bin dch t bn gc)

MC LC

B 15 TIU CHUN CA AUN

Tiu chun 1. Kt qu hc tp mong i Cc tiu ch (03) 1. Chng trnh o to c xy dng nhm thc y hot ng hc tp, vic hc phng php hc tp v to cho sinh vin thi quen hc tp sut i (v d: tm hiu mang tnh ph phn, pht trin cc k nng hc tp v x l thng tin, sn sng th nghim v vn dng cc tng mi.) 2. Chng trnh o to rn luyn cho sinh vin tt nghip kh nng thc hin cc hot ng nghin cu chuyn su, pht trin nhn cch ca h, gip h c quan im hc thut v c nng lc trong lnh vc chuyn mn. Sinh vin tt nghip cn c cc k nng c th chuyn i, k nng lnh o, bit hng ti th trng vic lm cng nh pht trin ngh nghip. (1.9) 3. Chng trnh o to cn nu r kt qu hc tp mong i, phn nh c yu cu v nhu cu ca tt c cc i tng c lin quan. (1.2) Gii thch Sinh vin n trng i hc hc c mt iu g y. V vy, chng ta cn xc nh r chng ta mun sinh vin s t c nhng khi kin thc, k nng, thi hoc nng lc no trong qu trnh hc tp cng nh sau khi tt nghip. Kt qu hc tp mong i l im xut pht cho qu trnh t nh gi. Ngoi ra, chng ta cn phn bit nhng k nng chung v k nng c th. Hoc tp sut i bao gm vic theo ui kin thc va hoc tp lin tuc sut i. Qu trnh hc tp ny phai din ra trn c s khng ngng nghi t nhng hoat ng tng tac trong i sng hng ngay vi ngi khac, cho n vic t c trnh chuyn mn. Cu hi: Tai sao chung ta thc hin chc nng gio dc ao tao? Chng trnh o to c xy dng trn c s trit l gio dc no? Cc kt qu hc tp mong i cn t c l g? Kt qua hoc tp mong i ca chng trnh o to c xy dng th no? Kt qua hoc tp mong i co phan anh muc tiu cua nha trng khng? Th trng lao ng c a ra nhng yu cu c th i vi sinh vin tt nghip hay khng? Chng trnh o to c iu chnh ra sao ph hp vi nhu cu ca th trng lao ng?

 Chng trinh co ban m ta ngh nghip (job profile) khng? ( giup sinh vin tt nghip hiu r nhng ngnh ngh cua ho) Mc tiu v mc ch ca chng trnh c ph bin n cc ging vin v sinh vin nh th no? Kt qua hoc tp mong i co th at c ti mc nao? Nhng kt qua hoc tp mong i co c xem xet lai? Kt qua hoc tp mong i ca chng trnh c chuyn thnh nhng yu cu c th i vi sinh vin tt nghip nh th no? (vd: v kin thc, k nng v thi , va ao c ngh nghip). Ngun minh chng: Chng trinh chi tit T bm, t quang cao, gii thiu hoc phn. Bang biu ma trn cac ky nng (skills matrix) Y kin ng gp cua cac bn lin quan. Tiu chun 2. Chng trnh chi tit Cc tiu ch (03) 1. i vi mi chng trnh o to, nh trng cn cung cp mt chng trnh chi tit trong c th xc nh c cc im dng (1) c kh nng, v ch r kt qu hc tp mong i ca chng trnh v cc phng din: a. Nhng kin thc v s hiu bit m sinh vin s t c sau khi kt thc chng trnh b.Cc k nng then cht: giao tip, tnh ton, s dng cng ngh thng tin, k nng hc tp c.Cc k nng nhn thc, v d s hiu bit v phng php lun hoc kh nng phn tch c ph phn d.Cc k nng c th, chng hn k nng lm vic trong phng th nghim, k nng lm sng, v.v. (1.10) 2. Chng trnh chi tit cung cp li m t chnh xc nhng kt qu hc tp d kin ca chng trnh o to bc i hc, cng nhng phng tin nhm gip t c v chng minh c nhng kt qu ny. (1.11)
1

Trang web trng, khoa. Phng tin va cac k hoach giao tip, lin h vi cac bn lin quan. Bin ban, vn ban hop nh gi chng trinh giang day. Bao cao kim inh, i sanh.

im dng (potential stopping off point): thi im sinh vin hon tt hoc tch ly c khi kin thc trong chng trnh o to, m bo cho sinh vin (c khi nu c tm ngng vic hc) c kh nng hc tip tc chng trnh o to.

3. Chng trnh chi tit cn nu r nhng kt qu hc tp d kin trn cc lnh vc kin thc, s hiu bit, k nng. Ti liu ny cn gip cho sinh vin hiu c phng php ging dy v hc tp cn thit t c kt qu d kin; phng php kim tra nh gi gip ch ra kt qu hc tp; mi quan h gia chng trnh hc v cc yu t hc tp i vi quy nh v bng cp ca mi nc thnh vin; cng nh mi quan h gia chng trnh hc i vi kh nng chuyn mn hoc con ng s nghip sau ny ca sinh vin . (1.1) Gii thch Cc kt qu hc tp v mc tiu d kin ca chng trnh o to cn c th hin vo chng trnh. iu quan trng l cc mc tiu v mc ch ny phi c ph bin n tt c mi ngi. V vy, nh trng cn cung cp chng trnh chi tit. Chng trnh chi tit cn c nhng chc nng sau: L mt ngun thng tin gip cc sinh vin ang hc cng nh cc sinh vin tim nng hiu v chng trnh. L mt ngun thng tin dnh cho cc nh tuyn dng, c bit l cc thng tin v k nng v cc nng lc tr tu c th chuyn i c pht trin trong chng trnh. L c s c cng nhn bi cc t chc ngh nghip v cc c quan php lut c chc nng kim nh cc chng trnh o to bc i hc. Chng trnh chi tit cn ch r nhng lnh vc m cc c quan ny yu cu. L c s cc nhm ging vin v cc nh qun l xem xt, trao i v thm nh cht lng i vi nhng chng trnh ang thc hin cng nh cc chng trnh mi, v m bo rng mc tiu ca chng trnh cng nh nhng kt qu hc tp d kin u c mi ngi hiu r. Chng trnh chi tit cn phi c xy dng sao cho nh trng c th hi lng v bit rng ngi thit k chng trnh bit r cc kt qu hc tp d kin l g, v cc kt qu ny c th t c v chng minh c. Chng trnh chi tit cng c th c s dng nh mt im quy chiu thm nh bn trong cng nh gim st nhng hot ng ca ngnh o to. L mt ngun thng tin cho cc thm nh vin v mt hc thut v cc nh gi vin bn ngoi nm c thng tin v mc tiu v kt qu d kin ca chng trnh. L c s thu thp s phn hi t sinh vin hoc cu sinh vin va tt nghip v nhng cm nhn ca h v c hi hc tp c kt qu ti nh trng xt theo nhng kt qu hc tp d kin. Chng trnh chi tit thng bao gm nhng thng tin sau: Tn n v cp bng/tn trng Tn c s o to (nu khc vi mc trn) Thng tin chi tit v vic kim nh chng trnh do cc t chc ngh nghip hoc c quan php lut tin hnh Tn vn bng s cp khi kt thc chng trnh
5

 Tn chng trnh Kt qua hoc tp u ra cua chng trinh. Cac tiu chi hoc yu cu nhp hoc cua chng trinh. Cc mc chun (benchmark) so snh vi cc n v khc cng nh cc im tham kho trong v ngoi khc thng tin v kt qu ca chng trnh. Cc kt qu ca chng trnh nh kin thc, s hiu bit, cc k nng v thi cn t c Cc chin lc ging dy, hc tp v kim tra nh gi t c v chng minh kt qu t c Cu trc chng trnh v cc yu cu bao gm trnh , n v kin thc (m-un), tn ch Ngy vit hoc iu chnh chng trnh chi tit

Ngoi nhng thng tin trn, cc c s o to c th nu thm: Cc quy nh v kim tra nh gi Cc ch bo cht lng Nhng h tr c th cho vic hc tp Cc phng php c s dng nh gi, ci tin cht lng v cc tiu chun hc tp Cu hi - Cc kt qua hoc tp c th hin trong chng trnh o to v trong cc hc phn nh th no? - Nh trng c chng trnh chi tit no c xy dng da theo cc tiu chun cht lng AUN khng? - Chng trinh chi tit co c ban hanh va ph bin n cac bn lin quan khng? - Qua trinh nh gi chng trinh chi tit nh th nao? Ngun minh chng: Chng trinh chi tit T bm, t quang cao, gii thiu hoc phn. Bang biu ma trn cac ky nng (skills matrix) Y kin ng gp cua cac bn lin quan. Trang web trng, khoa.
6

 Phng tin va cac k hoach giao tip, lin h vi cac bn lin quan. Bin ban, vn ban hop nh gi chng trinh giang day. Bao cao kim inh, i sanh. Tiu chun 3. Ni dung va cu truc chng trnh. Cc tiu ch (06) 1. Chng trnh o to c s cn bng gia ni dung chuyn mn, kin thc tng qut, v cc k nng cn thit. Chng trnh phi c thit k nhm ap ng nhu cu ca cac bn lin quan.(1.3) 2. Chng trnh o to c tnh n v phn nh c tm nhn, s mng, mc ch v mc tiu ca nh trng. Tm nhn, s mng, mc ch v mc tiu ca nh trng c ging vin v sinh vin bit r. (1.1) 3. Chng trnh o to th hin c nng lc ca sinh vin tt nghip. Mi hc phn phi c thit k r rng ch ra c kt qu mong i. thc hin iu ny, cn xy dng mt s chng trnh o to.(1.5) 4. Cu trc chng trnh o to c thit k sao cho ni dung cc hc phn c s kt hp v cng c ln nhau. (1.4) 5. Cu trc chng trnh o to phi c xy dng nhm th hin c v chiu rng, chiu su, tnh cht ch v tnh c t chc ca cc hc phn. (1.6) 6. Cu trc chng trnh th hin r cc hc phn c bn, cc hc phn c s ngnh, hc phn chuyn ngnh v tiu lun hoc lun vn tt nghip. (1.7)

Gii thch Chng ta buc phi t cu hi rng: cc mc tiu phi c th hin trong chng trnh nh th no. Chng trnh c cht ch v cp nht khng? Cac hoc phn gp phn nh th no cho vic hon thnh s mng chung ca nh trng? Cu hi Ni dung chng trnh o to co phan anh s mang va tm nhin cua trng hay khng? Ni dung chng trinh ao tao bc i hc c phn nh kt qu hoc tp mong i khng? Ni dung ny c gip ngi hc t c kt qu d kin khng? Cc hc phn trong chng trnh o to c mi lin h r rng vi nhau hay khng? Chng trnh o to c c xy dng cht ch khng? Cac hoc phn ai cng va chuyn nganh co c cn i phu hp khng?
7

Ni dung chng trinh ao tao co c cp nht? Cu trc chng trnh c la chn trn c s no? Cu trc chng trnh o to c thay i trong thi gian gn y hay khng? Nu c, xin cho bit ti sao? kh ca cc hc phn c tng ln qua thi gian hay khng? Vic thit k cc hc phn c phi tun theo yu cu g t c s cht ch trong cu trc chng trnh hay khng? Ai t ra nhng yu cu ny? Chng trnh hc ca nm u c c thit k nhm gip sinh vin hiu c phn cn li ca chng trnh o to l g khng? S kt ni gia chng trinh ai cng va chuyn nganh co chinh xac khng? Cu trc chng trnh gia cc chuyn ngnh khc nhau c hp l khng? Mi lin h gia phn cng (bt buc) v phn mm (t chn) ca chng trnh o to c hp l khng? Chng trnh o to c gy ra tnh trng nghn c chai (bottlenecks) khng? Chng trnh o to s dng cch t chc nh th no (mt nm ba hc k-trimester, mt nm hai hc k-semester, hc theo mun-modular, hay hc theo vn - problem oriented)? Cch t chc ny c nhng bn c lin quan nh gi ra sao?

Ngun minh chng: Chng trinh chi tit T bm, t quang cao, gii thiu hoc phn. Bang biu ma trn cac ky nng (skills matrix) Y kin ng gp cua cac bn lin quan. Tiu chun 4. Chin lc ging dy va hc tp Cc tiu ch (06) 1. Ging vin c khuyn khch s dng phng php gip sinh vin hc tp bng hnh ng. Hc tp bng hnh ng l mt qu trnh hc hi v suy ngh, cn nhc lin tc, c s h tr ca bn cng hc, nhm mc ch to ra vic hc tp c cht lng sinh vin. Thng qua phng php ny, cc ging vin c th chia s vi nhau thng qua vic gii quyt cc vn thc t v thng qua kinh nghim ca bn thn. Vic xy dng chng trnh hc tp bng hnh ng l nhm vo mc ch ci tin vic hc tp cng nh mi trng hc tp ca sinh vin. (2.14)
8

Trang web trng, khoa. Phng tin va cac k hoach giao tip, lin h vi cac bn lin quan. Bin ban, vn ban hop xem xet chng trinh giang day. Bao cao kim inh, i sanh.

2. Hc tp c cht lng c nh ngha y l s ch ng tm ti kin thc do chnh sinh vin thc hin, ch khng n thun l s tip thu nhng kin thc do ging vin cung cp. y l mt quan im hc tp c chiu su, qua sinh vin t to ra ngha v s hiu bit v th gii. Theo quan im ny th vic ging dy ch ng vai tr h tr v to iu kin cho vic hc tp.(4.1) 3. Mc ch ca gio dc bc i hc l hng vo sinh vin. Cht lng hc tp v th ph thuc phn ln vo phng php hc tp ca sinh vin. Cho nn, iu ny li ph thuc vo quan nim ca ngi hc rng h bit g v vic hc ca mnh cng nh nhng chin lc hc tp no m h s s dng. (4.2) 4. Cht lng hc tp ph thuc vo vic p dng cc nguyn tc ph hp cho vic hc tui trng thnh. Ngi hc trng thnh hc tp tt nht trong mi trng thoi mi, c s hp tc, h tr v thn thin. l mi trng ph hp gip cho ngi hc tui trng thnh hc tp mt cc su sc. (4.3) 5. thc y tinh thn trch nhim trong hc tp, cc ging vin cn: a. To ra mt mi trng ging dy-hc tp sao cho mi ngi hc u tham gia vo qu trnh hc tp mt cch c thc. b. Cung cp nhng chng trnh o to linh hot nhm gip ngi hc chn la ni dung hc phn, th t cc hc phn trong chng trnh, phng php kim tra nh gi, phng thc v thi gian hc tp sao cho c ngha nht i vi tng ngi. (4.9) 6. kch thch s say m v cc gi tr i vi vic hc tp, ng thi to c hi pht trin tr tu cho ngi hc, cc ging vin cn to ra nhng c hi hc tp v giao lu trong ngi hc c th tham gia ht mnh c v tr tu ln tnh cm. (4.10) Gii thch B Tiu chun cht lng AUN m t mt cch chi tit lm th no xem xt mt qu trnh hc tp, xem xt cc yu cu ca chin lc ca vic dy va hc. Mc ch ca gio dc i hc l nhm pht trin kh nng tri thc ngy cng cao trong sinh vin, v th cn lu cc c im sau m bo cht lng hc tp: Kh nng t khm ph tri thc. Ngi hc cn c k nng nghin cu, phn tch v tng hp cc t liu do chnh mnh thu thp, ng thi hiu c cc chin lc hc tp khc nhau c th la chn chin lc ph hp nht cho tng nhim v hc tp c th. Kh nng ghi nh kin thc. S dng phng php hc tp nhn mnh hiu bit hn l tr nh s gip ngi hc nh kin thc lu hn. Kh nng nhn bit mi lin h gia kin thc c v mi. Cht lng hc tp lun lun i hi ngi hc phi tng hp thng tin t nhiu ngun khc nhau. Kh nng sng to s hiu bit mi. Mt ngi hc t cht lng phi bit nhn ra mi quan h gia khi kin thc ca ngi khc hc vi kinh nghim ca chnh bn thn mnh, cng nh vi nhng g mnh c hc trc hnh thnh nn nhng nhn thc mi.
9

 Kh nng vn dng kin thc vo vic gii quyt vn . Kh nng din t kin thc ca mnh cho ngi khc. Vic hc tp t cht lng khi ngi hc c kh nng hnh thnh cng nh din t mt cch r rng v cht ch nhng suy ngh v hnh ng c lp ca mnh. S say m hc hi. Vic hc tp t cht lng khi ngi hc c quan im hc tp sut i. Nhng iu kin cn thit gip cho vic hc tp t cht lng: Cht lng hc tp ch t c khi ngi hc sn sng thc hin nhim v hc tp c v mt nhn thc ln tnh cm. Cht lng hc tp ch t c khi ngi hc c l do hc. Cht lng hc tp ch t khi ngi hc bit lin h vi cc kin thc hc. Cht lng hc tp ch t c khi ngi hc ch ng trong sut qu trnh hc tp. Cht lng hc tp ch t c khi khi ngi hc c hc trong mt mi trng hc tp vi y s h tr.

Tt nhin l s khng c mt chin lc day va hoc no l hp l nht cho tt c cc trng hp. Nhng d vy, mi chng trnh cng phi c t nht mt chin lc day va hoc cho mnh. Cu hi Cc ging vin ca khoa c chia s cng mt chin lc day va hoc hay khng? Chin lc nay c ph hp khng? Khoa co tng cng s a dang cua mi trng hoc tp khng, bao gm ca vic trao i chng trinh? Vic giang day do cac khoa/b mn khac am nhn co at yu cu? Cc phng php ging dy/hng dn hin ang s dng (t chc vic t hc cho sinh vin, s s lp, t chc cc seminars, cc bui thc hnh) c mang n s hi lng hay khng? Cng ngh c s dng h tr ging dy nh th no? Cc chin lc day va hoc c nh gi nh th nao? Cc phng php c la chn c ph hp vi kt qua hoc tp mong i ca cac hoc phn khng? Cc phng php s dng c a dng khng? C bt c kh khn no (v s s lp, ti liu hc tp, k nng ca ging vin) gy cn tr nh trng trong vic p dng cc phng php giang day m nh trng mong mun p dng hay khng?
10

Nu hot ng nghin cu khoa hc l hot ng ct li ca trng: Sinh vin thc s bt u nghin cu t lc no trong chng trnh hc? Mi lin h qua li gia hc tp v nghin cu c th hin ra sao trong chng trnh? Kt qu nghin cu c a vo chng trnh nh th no?

Mt kha cnh c th ca chin lc day va hoc l to iu kin thc hnh cho sinh vin. Hy m t vai tr ca thc tp/thc t trong chng trnh o to: Thc tp-thc t c phi l mt phn bt buc ca chng trnh o to hay khng? S tn ch dnh cho vic thc tp-thc t? Vic thc tp-thc t ca sinh vin c cn tun theo cc tiu ch c th c nu r t trc hay khng? Vic chun b cho thc tp-thc t trong chng trnh (c v ni dung, phng php ln k nng) c thc hin nh th no?. Mc yu cu ca vic thc tp-thc t c chp nhn c khng? Vic thc tp-thc t c b nghn c chai khng? Nu c th nguyn nhn l do u? Sinh vin c hng dn thc tp nh th no? Sinh vin c nh gi ra sao? Ngun minh chng: Chin lc day va hoc Minh chng cho vic hoc tp bng hanh ng chng han nh an, tai, thc tp, bai tp nghin cu, tham gia thc t tai c s, v.v Y kin phan hi cua sinh vin H thng hoc trc tuyn Ban cng chi tit hoc phn (module specification)

Tiu chun 5. nh gi sinh vin Cc tiu ch (10) 1. Vic kim tra nh gi bao gm: a. nh gi vic nhp hc ca tn sinh vin bng kt qu u vo. b. nh gi s tin b trong hoc tp ca sinh vin thng qua mt ma trn im s/biu /h s hc tp nu r nng lc ca sinh vin v thng qua chng trnh o to c thit k da trn kt qu u ra.
11

c. nh gi bi thi cui kha/tt nghip ca sinh vin bng Bng Danh mc kim tra nng lc sinh vin tt nghip (Graduate Competency Check-List) hoc bng mt k kim tra tch hp v ton din. 2. Theo nguyn tc hc tp tui trng thnh, cc hc vin trng thnh thch c nh gi bng cc phng php da trn tiu ch v thng qua s kt hp gia t nh gi, bn b nh gi, v ging vin nh gi.(3.1) 3. Ging vin cn cung cp nhiu hnh thc nh gi a dng thng qua cc phng php t nh gi, bn cng hc nh gi v ging vin nh gi da trn nguyn tc minh bch, linh hot, c cn nhc, v hng n kt qu. Cc tiu ch nh gi cn c thng lng r rng vi mi thnh vin tham gia hc phn. Cc chin lc nh gi phi ph hp nhm nh gi c kt qu hc tp mong i. 4. Vic thc hin nh gi tng ng vi mi mc ch v mi lnh vc dy trong chng trnh. (3.3) 5. Ging vin cn s dng nhiu phng php kim tra nh gi khc nhau phc v cc mc ch nh gi khc nhau nh chn on/kho st, nh gi tin trnh hc tp, v nh gi kt thc hc phn hoc kha hc.(3.4) 6. Phm vi v trng s ca cc k hoch kim tra nh gi phi r rng v c ph bin n mi i tng quan tm. (3.5). 7. Cc tiu chun p dng trong cc k hoch kim tra nh gi phi minh bch v nht qun trong ton b chng trnh o to.(3.6) 8. Thng xuyn p dng cc quy trnh bo m n mc ti a rng cc k hoch kim tra nh gi u c gi tr, ng tin cy, v c thc hin mt cch cng bng. (3.7) 9. C nhng quy nh hp l v th tc khiu ni kt qu nh gi sinh vin s dng khi cn. (3.9) 10. tin cy v tnh gi tr ca cc phng php kim tra nh gi c ghi li bng vn bn v thm nh thng xuyn; cc phng php kim tra nh gi mi thng xuyn c pht trin v th nghim. (3.10) Gii thch nh gi sinh vin l mt trong nhng yu t quan trng nht trong gio dc i hc. Kt qu nh gi s nh hng su sc n s nghip ca sinh vin sau ny. V vy, vic nh gi cn c thc hin mt cch chuyn nghip trong cn tp trung nhiu vo nh gi kin thc thng qua qu trnh kim tra v thi c. nh gi cng cung cp cho nh trng cc thng tin c gi tr v hiu qu ging dy v cc hot ng dch v h tr ngi hc. Cc nguyn tc nh gi sinh vin cn c cc yu cu sau: Cc th tc nh gi phi o c kt qu hc tp mong i v cc mc tiu khc ca chng trnh;

12

 nh gi phi ph hp vi mc ch, c khu chn on/kho st, bt u hay tng kt; c cc tiu ch xp hng/cho im r rng v c thng tin t trc. nh gi cn c thc hin bi nhng ngi hiu r vai tr nh gi c th nh gi c nhng kin thc, k nng v nng lc ca sinh vin, v trong iu kin cho php, khng nn ch da vo quyt nh / nh gi ca ch mt ngi; Tnh n tt c cc hu qu c th c do quy ch thi c; Cn c nhng quy nh c th v vic ngh hc ca sinh vin, bnh tt v cc trng hp khc; m bo vic nh gi phi ng tin cy c da trn nguyn tc ca nh trng; nh gi cn c kim tra v mt hnh chnh nhm m bo s chnh xc ca cc nguyn tc; Sinh vin c thng bo r rng v cch thc nh gi kim tra, h s tri qua cc k thi g hay c nh gi bng cc phng php no, h s t c g v cc tiu ch no c p dng khi nh gi h. Cu hi: Tn sinh vin c c nh gi lc nhp hc hay khng? Sinh vin c c nh gi lc ra trng hay khng? Vic kim tra v thi c ph kn ni dung v mc tiu ca tng hc phn cng nh ton chng trnh n mc no? Vic nh gi c c thc hin da trn tiu ch hay khng? Cc phng php dng nh gi c a dng khng? Cc phng php l g? Tiu ch cho u/ nh trt c r rng hay khng? Cc quy nh v kim tra thi c c r rng khng? Cc quy trnh kim tra, thi c c r rng, c ph bin cho mi ngi, v c tun th cht ch hay khng? C c ch no nhm m bo tnh khch quan trong kim tra, thi c hay khng? Sinh vin c hi lng vi cc quy trnh ny khng? Sinh vin c than phin g khng? C cc quy nh r rng v vic thi li hay khng? Sinh vin c hi lng vi nhng quy nh ny khng?

Mt phng php nh gi hc phn thng dng l thng qua bi tiu lun cui hc phn/kha hc. Cch nh gi ny cn phi c c bit lu . Trong bi tiu lun cui hc

13

phn/kha hc, sinh vin cn phi chng t kin thc v k nng ca mnh, ng thi phi cho thy kh nng s dng cc kin thc/k nng trong tnh hung mi. C nhng quy nh c th no cho vic nh gi thng qua bi tiu lun hoc n cui hc phn hay khng? C nhng tiu ch nh gi bi tiu lun hoc n cui hc phn/kha hc hay khng? Tiu lun hoc n cui hc phn c chun b nh th no (v mt ni dung, phng php, k nng)? Mc yu cu i vi bi tiu lun hoc n cui hc phn/kha hc c ph hp khng? Vic thc hin bi tiu lun hoc n cui hc phn/kha hc c gp phi tnh trng nghn c chai hay khng? Nu c, nguyn nhn l do u? Hy m t vic hng dn sinh vin.

Ngun minh chng: Vi du v anh gia trong qua trinh hoc, an, tai, bai thi cui ky H thng cho im, thang im Quy trinh iu chinh im Quy trinh khiu nai im cng hoc phn, chng trinh chi tit Quy inh kim tra, thi c

Tiu chun 6. Cht lng i ng cn b giang day Cc tiu ch (10) 1. Ging vin bc i hc phi c nhng kh nng sau: a. Thit k c mt chng trnh ging dy v hc tp cht ch, ng thi thc hin c chng trnh ny; b. p dng nhiu phng php dy v hc,v chn la phng php thch hp nht t c kt qu hc tp mong i; c. S dng v pht trin nhiu loi phng tin truyn thng trong dy hc; d. S dng nhiu k thut khc nhau nh gi vic hc ca sinh vin ph hp vi nhng kt qu hc tp d kin; e. T gim st v nh gi vic ging dy cng nh chng trnh ging dy ca chnh mnh;
14

f. C suy ngh, cn nhc k v vic thc hnh ging dy ca chnh mnh; g. Xc nh cc nhu cu v xy dng cc k hoch pht trin lin tc. (2.13) 2. C s lng ging vin thc hin chng trnh o to ph hp vi yu cu, xt theo cc yu cu tng hp c v bng cp, kinh nghim, kh nng, tui tc, v.v. (2.1) 3. Vic tuyn chn v nng bc cho ging vin da trn cc tiu chun v nng lc nh ging dy, nghin cu v phc v. (2.3) 4. Vai tr v mi quan h ca cc thnh vin trong i ng cn b c xc nh v c mi ngi hiu r.(2.4) 5. Vic phn cng nhim v da trn c s bng cp, kinh nghim v kh nng ph hp ca cn b.(2.5) 6. Vic qun l thi gian v c ch khen thng nhm n mc tiu thc y cht lng ging dy v hc tp.(2.6) 7. Mi cn b u c trch nhim gii trnh vi Ch s hu ca nh trng (Chnh ph, Hi ng Qun tr, T chc sng lp), thng qua Hiu trng v cc i tng c lin quan, c lu n quyn t do v hc thut ca cc ging vin. (2.9) 8. C s chun b d phng i vi nhng vn nh thm nh, t vn, v sp xp li nhn s.(2.10) 9. Nhng quyt nh v nhn s nh cho thi vic, ngh hu, v cc phc li x hi u c ln k hoch sn v thc hin tt. (2.11) 10. Vic nh gi cn b c thc hin thng xuyn da trn mt k hoch xy dng t trc v s dng nhng bin php cng bng v khch quan trn tinh thn hng n s ci thin. (2.12) Gii thch Ging vin l ti nguyn hc tp quan trng nht v c gi tr nht i vi sinh vin. iu quan trng l cc ging vin cn c kin thc v hiu bit y v b mn mnh ang ging dy, c cc k nng cn thit v kinh nghim ging dy truyn t, trao i nhng kin thc v hiu bit cho sinh vin mt cch hiu qu trong mi trng dy hc, v c th ly kin phn hi ca sinh vin v vic ging dy ca mnh Cht lng cua trng/khoa khng chi da vao chng trinh ao tao, ma con phai da vao cht lng cua giang vin. Cht lng cua giang vin bao gm trinh bng cp chuyn mn, thanh thao v mn hoc, kinh nghim, ky nng giang day va ao c ngh nghip. Can b giang day bao gm tt ca giao s, giang vin, giang vin thinh giang ca ban thi gian va toan thi gian. B hng dn am bao cht lng AUN (AUN-QA guidelines) t ra cac tiu chi am bao cht lng can b ging day. Chung ta phai xem lai rng trng a ap ng c cac tiu chi nay ti mc nao. Vi th, chung ta phai nhin lai lc lng can b (s lng) va cht lng bng cp chuyn mn cua ho.
15

S lng cn b / ging vin v bng cp S dng Bng 1 di y, hy nu s lng cn b, ging vin ca n v. Nu c nhng v tr cn khuyt, hy nu trong mt bng ring, v nu r ngy m cc v tr cn c b sung. Nu r t l ging vin/sinh vin v t l ging vin/hc vin cao hc theo Bng 2. Bng 1: Bng thng k cn b, ging vin (Xin nu r ngy cp s liu). Cn b ging dy Nam N S lng Tng s (FTEs)* T l c bng tin s

Gio s Pho giao s Ging vin ton thi gian Ging vin bn thi gian Ging vin/giao s thnh ging Tng cng (*) FTE l vit tt ca Full Time Equivalent: s lng CB ging vin quy i thnh ging vin ton thi gian. y l mt n v tnh mc u t thi gian vo cng vic. 1 FTE tung ng vi 40 gi lm vic mt tun (tng ng thi gian lm vic ton thi gian). Mt cn b ging vin lm vic 8 gi/tun s tng ng vi 0.2 FTE. Bng 2: T l ging vin/sinh vin v t l ging vin/sinh vin cao hc (nu ro nm) Tng s FTE cua giang vin (*) Tng s sinh vin Tng s hc vin cao hc Tng s sinh vin tnh trn mt FTE cua giang vin Tng s sinh vin cao hoc tnh trn mt FTE cua giang vin

(*) c lng thc t s FTE cua giang vin S sinh vin: ly s liu ng k theo chng trnh vo u nm hoc. Nu s liu ca nm va qua khng mang tnh i din th nn nu r s ai din phai la nh th nao. Tai sao? Cu hi Cn b ging vin c phm cht v nng lc cho cng vic ca h khng? Kh nng v trnh ca i ng ging vin c thc hin chng trnh khng? Khoa/n v c cm nhn kh khn no lin quan n nhn lc khng? V tui ca cn b ging vin? Nhng v tr cn khuyt nhng kh tm ngi? T l v s lng cn b ging vin c trnh Thc s v Tin s ra sao? Nhng kh khn trong vic thu ht cn b c trnh l g? Khoa/n v c chnh sch g trong vic s dng i ng cn b ging dy v nghin cu?

16

Khoa/n v c c gng mi cc gio s tham gia ging dy trnh c bn hay khng? Khoa c chnh sch g thu ht s tham gia vo cc seminars, hng dn tiu lun cui hc phn/kha hc, v thc tp-thc t hay khng? S tit dy bnh qun ca ging vin? T l ging vin/sinh vin? T l ging vin/sinh vin sau i hc?

Qun l i ng can b Vic qun l i ng ca Khoa c c nu ra thnh nhng quy nh c th v r rng hay khng? Vic tuyn dng ging vin c da trn c s kinh nghim ca h trong vic ging dy v nghin cu khng? Khoa/n v c h thng nh gi ging vin hay khng? Bng cp v cc hot ng ging dy ca ging vin ng vai tr nh th no trong ngh nghip ca ging vin? Khoa/n v nh gi ra sao v chnh sch nhn s ca mnh cho n nay? Trong tng lai d kin s c nhng pht trin g? Ging vin c chun b ra sao thc hin cng vic ging dy ca mnh? Khoa/n v c thc hin hng dn v nh gi cc hot ng ging dy ca ging vin hay khng?

Ngun minh chng Tiu chi tuyn dung ging vin Cht lng/ bng cp giang vin Nhu cu va k hoach ao tao H thng anh gia thng qua ng nghip K hoach ngh nghip Phan hi cua sinh vin H thng cng nhn va khen thng Khi lng cng vic cua can b S phn b vai tro va nghia vu K hoach, chinh sach thi vic, nghi hu

Tiu chun 7. Cht lng can b h tr Cc tiu ch (01) C i ng cn b phc v ging dy nh nhn vin th vin, nhn vin phng th nghim, nhn vin hnh chnh v cng tac sinh vin.
17

Gii thch Cht lng chng trnh ph thuc phn ln vo mi quan h, tng tc gia cn b, ging vin v sinh vin. Tuy nhin, i ng cn b ging dy khng th lm vic tt nu thiu i ng cn b h tr c cht lng. Nhng cn b ny l nhng ngi lm vic th vin, phng th nghim, phng my tnh, phng hnh chnh. Cu hi: i ng nhn vin th vin c kh nng v lm vic hiu qu khng? i ng nhn vin phng th nghim c kh nng v lm vic hiu qu khng? i ng nhn vin phng my tnh c kh nng v lm vic hiu qu khng? i ng nhn vin hnh chnh c kh nng v lm vic hiu qu khng? Ti l gia can b giang day va can b h tr? Can b h tr co u nng lc va s lng h tr cho cc can b khac va sinh vin khng?

Ngun minh chng: Tiu chi tuyn dung ging vin Cht lng/ bng cp giang vin Nhu cu va k hoach ao tao H thng anh gia thng qua ng nghip K hoach ngh nghip Phan hi cua sinh vin H thng cng nhn va khen thng Khi lng cng vic cua can b S phn b vai tro va nghia vu K hoach, chinh sach thi vic, nghi hu

Tiu chun 8. Cht lng sinh vin Chinh sach thu nhn sinh vin va cac tiu chi nhp hoc ro rang, c xem xet iu chinh inh ky. Giai thich Cht lng ca u ra ph thuc nhiu vo cht lng ca u vo, ngha l cht lng sinh vin ly vo rt quan trng. Tuyn u vo: - Hy nu tm tt s lng sinh vin tuyn mi nm th nht, s dng Bng 3. - Hy nu tm tt tng s sinh vin ang theo hc trong chng trnh, s dng Bng 4. Bng 3: Sinh vin tuyn mi nm th nht
18

Nm hc

Nam

Ton thi gian N Tng cng

Nam

Bn thi gian N Tng cng

Bng 4: Tng s sinh vin (5 nm gn nht) Nm hc Nam Ton thi gian N Tng cng Nam Bn thi gian N Tng cng

Cu hi S lng sinh vin tuyn mi ca Khoa/n v ang pht trin ra sao? C g ng lo ngi? Nguyn nhn? Nhng hng pht trin trong tng lai? Vic tuyn chn sinh vin vo hc din ra nh th no? C nhng yu cu g? Chnh sch tuyn sinh ca Khoa/n v l g? Khoa nhm n vic tng s lng sinh vin tuyn mi hay gi nguyn mc hin ti? Ti sao? nng cao cht lng v m bo s lng sinh vin tuyn mi, Khoa/n v ang thc hin nhng bin php g? Nhng bin php ny c hiu qu ra sao? Chng trnh o to ca Khoa/n v tnh n cht lng u vo ca sinh vin nh th no? Mi lin h gia chng trnh o to v chng trnh hc bc trung hc ph thng l g?

Khi lng hc tp Khoa/n v c s dng h thng tn ch hay khng? Cc tn ch c tnh ra sao? Khi lng hc tp trn thc t c trng vi khi lng hc tp theo yu cu ca chng trnh khng? Khi lng hc tp c c phn b u trong cc nm hc hay khng? Khoa thc hin nhng bin php no lin quan n vic xy dng chng trnh v c vn hc tp khi c nhng hc phn trong chng trnh o to khng trng vi khi lng hc tp theo yu cu ca chng trnh (vd: qu d hoc qu kh)? Cc bin php ny c hiu qu hay khng? Mt sinh vin hc lc trung bnh c th hon tt chng trnh trong khong thi gian d kin ca chng trnh o to hay khng?
19

Ngun minh chng: Cac tiu chi va quy trinh tuyn sinh Xu hng cua sinh vin u vao H thng tin chi Khi lng hoc tp vin S tham gia vao cac hoat ng hoc thut va phi hc thut, hoat ng ngoai khoa, thi ua Bao cao kt qua hoc tp cua sinh

Tiu chun 9. H tr va t vn sinh vin Cc tiu ch (02) 1. Qua trinh hc tp ca sinh vin c gim st v ghi nhn mt cch c h thng; thng tin nh gi c phn hi tr li cho sinh vin v nhng gii php ci thin c a ra ngay khi cn thit.(3.8) 2. Nhm cung cp mt mi trng hc tp thun li, m bo cht lng hc tp ca sinh vin, ging vin cn c gng ti a trong kh nng ca mnh to ra khng ch mi trng vt cht h tr ph hp vi cc hot ng hc tp, m cn ch trng c mi trng tm l v x hi. (5.1) Gii thch Vic gim st v h tr sinh vin nh th no s rt cn thit cho ngh nghip sau ny ca sinh vin. B Tiu chun cht lng AUN xc nh rng nh trng phi m bo c cc mi trng vt l, vt cht, x hi v tm l tt. Cu hi o o Khoa co hinh thanh h thng : Ghi nhn s tin b cua sinh vin Theo doi sinh vin tt nghip (VD: khao sat) D liu cua h thng giam sat c s dung nh th nao? Cc cn b v ging vin ng vai tr nh th no trong vic cung cp thng tin v hng dn sinh vin? Cc cn b v ging vin ng vai tr g trong vic khuyn khch sinh vin tham gia vo cc hot ng ca Khoa/n v? Thng tin cung cp cho cc sinh vin tng lai (sinh vin tim nng) c thit lp ra sao? Khoa/n v c ch trng n nhng yu cu lin quan n qu trnh o to ca ngi hc trc y hay khng? Cc chng trnh o to c gy n tng cho cc sinh vin

20

tng lai khng? Nhng thng tin ny c c nh gi hay khng? Nu c, kt qu dng lm g? Sinh vin c cung cp thng tin v cc iu kin v thit b hc tp nh th no? Vic cung cp thng tin ny c lin quan cht ch n chng trnh o to ra sao? S tin b trong hc tp ca sinh vin c c ghi nhn hay khng? Nhng kt qu c ghi nhn ny c ch ra nhng vn m sinh vin cn ch trng hay khng? Nhng trng hp c vn c Khoa/n v tip cn ln u tin l vo lc no? S tip cn ny c dn n vic ph o v/hoc nhng hot ng ngn nga i vi tng sinh vin hoc i vi vic xy dng chng trnh hay khng? Vic hng dn sinh vin nm th nht c c c bit ch trng hay khng? Nu c, iu c thc hin ra sao? Khoa/n v c ch trng n s tin b trong hc tp ca sinh vin hay khng? Khoa/n v c nhng thit b/iu kin h tr hc tp c bit nng cao k nng hc tp ca nhng sinh vin gp kh khn trong vic hc hay khng? Nhng thit b ny do Khoa/n v qun l, hay c qun l cp cao hn (cp trng chng hn)? Thng tin v nhng thit b/iu kin h tr hc tp ny c thit lp ra sao? Khoa/n v c quan tm n vic hng dn ring cho cc sinh vin nm cui (senior students) hay khng? Khoa/n v c h tr g cho sinh vin trong vic hon tt n tt nghip? Mt sinh vin gp kh khn trong qu trnh thc tp-thc t hoc thc hin n tt nghip s c gip ra sao? Sinh vin c c vn ra sao v nhng vn nh la chn hc phn, thay i hc phn, tm ngng hc hoc thi hc? Sinh vin c c cung cp thng tin v trin vng ngh nghip hay khng? Sinh vin c iu kin lm quen vi th trng lao ng thng qua thc tp-thc t, cc kha hc ng dng, hoc nhng bin php tng t hay khng? Cu trc chng trnh o to gp phn vo thi hc tp ch ng ca sinh vin mc no? Chng trnh o to thc y s u t ca sinh vin vo vic hc mc no? Khoa/n v c hi lng vi cc cng c sn c dng ci thin s tin b trong hc tp ca sinh vin hay khng? () Cc cng c c dng nh th no?

Ngun minh chng: B may/c ch bao cao va phan hi v s tin b cua sinh vin. S cung cp cac dich vu h tr sinh vin cp trng va cp khoa
21

K hoach ren luyn, t vn cho sinh vin Y kin phan hi cua sinh vin

Tiu chun 10. Trang thit b v c s h tng Cc tiu ch (07) 1. Nh trng phi c cc ti nguyn vt cht phc v cho vic thc hin cc chng trnh o to, bao gm thit b, ti liu hc tp v cng ngh thng tin.(6.1) 2. Cc thit b cn c cp nht, sn sng s dng, v c s dng c hiu qu.(6.2) 3. Cc ti nguyn hc tp phi c chn lc v ph hp vi mc tiu hc tp.(6.4) 4. C th vin in t p ng s pht trin v cng ngh thng tin-truyn thng. (6.5) 5. C cc h thng cng ngh thng tin v cc h thng ny cn c cp nht.(6.7) 6. Cc trung tm my tnh ca nh trng phi c sn cc my tnh v h thng mng cho php cng ng nh trng khai thc cng ngh thng tin phc v cho ging dy, nghin cu v pht trin, dch v v qun l.(6.8) 7. Cc tiu chun v an ton v sinh mi trng p ng c mi yu cu ca a phng v moi mt.(5.2) Gii thch Trang thit b v ti nguyn hc tp cn ph hp vi cc mc tiu v mc ch ca chng trnh. Trang thit b cng lin quan n chin lc ging dy v hc tp. V d, nu mun dy theo nhm nh th ch cn s dng phng hc nh. Hoc khi mun ging dy bng my tnh th cn phi c my tnh cho sinh vin. Cc ti nguyn hc tp chnh bao gm sch, s tay thng tin, tp ch, bo ch, tranh nh, internet v intranet, CD-ROMs, bn , nh chp t khng gian, v cc ti nguyn hc tp khc. Cu hi Phng hc Khoa/n v c ging ng, phng hc, phng th nghim, phng c sch, v phng my tnh khng? Nhng phng ny c p ng nhng quy nh hin hnh khng? Th vin c thit b v ti liu phc v chng trnh o to hay khng? Vic s dng th vin c c tin li khng (iu kin phc v, gi m ca)? Khoa/n v c thit b phng th nghim hay khng? C cn b phc v phng th nghim khng? Phng th nghim c p ng nhng quy nh hin hnh khng?
22

Cc dng c v thit b h tr dy hc Khoa/n v c cc thit b nghe-nhn phc v dy hc khng ? C my tnh phc v hc tp khng? C cc chng trnh v phn mm ph hp (cc chng trnh bi dng k nng s dng my tnh, phn mm tnh ton, phn mm thit k, v.v.) khng? iu kin c s vt cht v thit b hin nay thc y hoc cn tr vic thc hin chng trnh o to nh th no? Kinh ph cho c s vt cht v thit b c p ng c nhu cu khng?

Tiu chun 11. m bo cht lng qu trnh ging dy va hc tp Cc tiu ch (03) 1. Chng trnh o to phi c thit k bi mt nhm trong c i din ca B phn cht lng, Hi ng khoa hc, i ng lm chng trnh, sinh vin v cc i tng c lin quan trong cc lnh vc cng nghip, chnh ph, v cc t chc ngh nghip. 2. Chng trnh o to c thm nh v nh gi tnh hiu qu nh k, c iu chnh sau khi c s dng trong mt thi gian hp l. (1.8) 3. iu kin c bn gip nh trng ci tin hot ng ging dy v hc tp l phi thc hin mt quy trnh nh gi thng xuyn v c k hoch. V phng din ny, cc ging vin nn to ra mt mi trng khuyn khch sinh vin tham gia vo vic nh gi hot ng ging dy cng nh kt qu hc tp. Gii thch Thit k (khung) chng trinh ao tao phai bt u bng vic xy dng kt qua hoc tp mong i. Cu hoi k tip la nhng hoc phn nao la cn thit at c kt qua hoc tp mong i o?; va cu hoi sau cung la ai se la ngi giang day nhng hoc phn o? iu quan trong l phi xem vic phat trin (khung) chng trinh ao tao nh la mt nhim vu chung. Nim tin ca sinh vin v cc i tng c lin quan khc trong gio dc i hc s c thit lp v duy tr thng qua cc hot ng m bo cht lng hiu qu. Mun th cn m bo rng chng trnh c thit k tt, c h thng gim st v thm nh thng xuyn qua lin tc m bo s thch hp v pht trin. m bo cht lng chng trnh v bng cp nh trng cn: Xy dng v ph bin nhng kt qu hc tp d kin t c; Quan tm su sc n vic thit k chng trnh v ni dung chng trnh;

23

C cc yu cu c th cho cc phng thc ging dy khc nhau (vd: ton thi gian, bn thi gian, hc t xa, e-learning) v quan tm n cc loi hnh gio dc i hc khc nhau (hc thut, hng nghip, chuyn nghip); C sn cc ngun ti nguyn hc tp thch hp v c gi tr; Cc nguyn tc ph chun trong chng trnh chnh thc cn c thc hin bi mt c quan hn l bi nhng ngi tham gia ging dy chng trnh ; Gim st s tin b v cc thnh tu ca sinh vin; nh gi chng trnh nh k (bao gm nh gi ngoi).

Sinh vin l i tng u tin nh gi cht lng ging dy v hc tp. H tri qua cc phng php lnh hi khc nhau. H c kin v cc trang thit b. D nhin, kin ca sinh vin cn c i chiu cng vi kin ca cc nhm i tng khc. Tuy nhin, nh trng cn thc hin ly kin sinh vin v s dng chng thc hin cc ci tin. Cu hi Thit k chng trinh ao tao sao? Th trng lao ng nh hng nh th no n vic thit k chng trnh o to? Vic i mi chng trnh o to c thc hin nh th no? Ai a ra nhng sng kin? Da trn nhng c s no? Ai chu trch nhim thc hin chng trnh? Vic thit k chng trnh c da trn vic so snh vi cc c s o to khc hay khng? Khoa/n v tham gia nhng mng li quc t no? C chng trnh trao i no vi nc ngoi khng? Chng trnh o to c c nc khc tha nhn khng? Ai chu trch nhim thit k chng trnh? S ng gp ca cn b, ging vin v sinh vin trong vic thit k chng trnh ra

M t ngn gn v cc hot ng m bo cht lng ca Khoa/n v. Khoa/n v c mt h thng t chc thc hin m bo cht lng hay khng? Nu c, hy m t h thng ny v phn tch cch hot ng ca h thng . Khoa/n v c cc Ban v Hi ng no tham gia m bo cht lng bn trong? Khoa/n v c Ban xy dng chng trnh o to (curriculum committee) khng? Vai tr ca ban ny l g?
24

Khoa c Ban ph trch thi c (examination committee) khng? Vai tr ca ban ny l g? Ban ny hot ng ra sao? Ban ph trch thi c thc hin nhng cng vic g? Chc nng v trch nhim ca cc nh qun l v cc ban chc nng c c mi ngi hiu r hay khng? Vic phn chia trch nhim c gp kh khn g khng?

nh gi hc phn v nh gi chng trnh o to: Chng trnh o to c nh gi ra sao? mc hc phn? mc ton b chng trnh o to? Vic nh gi c c thc hin mt cch c h thng hay khng? Sinh vin tham gia vo vic nh gi qu trnh o to nh th no? Kt qu nh gi c cng b ra sao v cng b cho ai? Kt qu nh gi c s dng ra sao? Tnh minh bch ca kt qu c m bo bng cch no?

anh gia bi sinh vin/ Ly kin sinh vin Nh trng c thc hin ly kin sinh vin mt cch c t chc khng? Ai qun l cng tc nh gi bi sinh vin/ly kin sinh vin? Kt qu nh gi c s dng lm g? C kt qu no c dng gp phn ci tin cht lng khng? Sinh vin cung cp cho hi ng nh gi iu g lin quan n qu trnh m bo cht lng bn trong?

Tiu chun 12. Hot ng pht trin i ng can b Cc tiu ch (02) 1. Nhu cu pht trin i ng c ghi nhn mt cch h thng, trong mi tng quan n nguyn vng c nhn, chng trnh o to v yu cu ca n v.(2.7) 2. i ng ging vin v nhn vin phc v c tham gia cc chng trnh pht trin i ng theo cc nhu cu thit thc. (2.8) Gii thch Nh trng cn m bo rng vic tuyn dng ging vin v cc nguyn tc tuyn dng l phng tin nhm m bo rng tt c cc ging vin mi tuyn t nht phi c nhng nng lc cn thit ti thiu. Nh trng cn to iu kin cho i ng ging dy pht trin v m rng kh nng ngh nghip v khuyn khch h nng cao k nng. Nh trng cung cp cho
25

ging vin c hi ci tin k nng t mt trnh c th chp nhn c v c cc bin php thuyn chuyn ging vin sang cc nhim v khc nu h ging dy khng hiu qu. Cu hoi Ai la ngi chiu trach nhim v cac hoat ng phat trin i ngu can b (ca ging vin va can b h tr)? K hoach va quy trinh phat trin va ao tao la nh th nao? Nhu cu ao tao c nhn bit bng cach nao? K hoach phat trin va ao tao co phan anh tm nhin va s mang cua trng va khoa hay khng? Trng co h thng nao phat trin cac kha nng ky thut va chin lc cho can b h tr? S lng gi va ia im ao tao cho can b giang day va can b h tr trong 1 nm? Phn trm ngn sach chi cho hoat ng phat trin i ngu can b?

Ngun minh chng: K hoach va chinh sach phat trin, ren luyn, ao tao can b Ni ao tao, thi gian ao tao Hoc bng K hoach phat trin ngh nghip va lun chuyn can b

Tiu chun 13. Ly kin phn hi ca cc bn lin quan Cc tiu ch (01) Cc trng i hc c khuyn khch xy dng c ch thng xuyn t nh gi chng trnh hc v hc phn, vi s tham gia ca tt c mi i tng c lin quan (lnh o nh trng, nh tuyn dng, sinh vin, cu sinh vin, v.v.). Gii thch Chng ta cn xc nh cht lng l s t c cc mc tiu v mc ch. Khi xy dng cc mc tiu, chng ta phi quan tm n yu cu ca tt c cc i tng c lin quan. iu ny ngha l chng ta phi t hi cc i tng ca chng ta c hi lng khng. t c iu ny, chng ta cn xy dng mt h thng phn hi hiu qu. Cu hi o Nh trng c mt h thng gim st hot ng hiu qu khng? Chng hn: Ghi nhn phan hi t th trng lao ng
26

o o o

Ghi nhn phan hoi t can b Ghi nhn phan hi t sinh vin Ghi nhn phan hi t cu sinh vin

Lin lac vi sinh vin tt nghip: Khoa co gi lin lac vi sinh vin tt nghip sau khi ra trng khng? Khoa co hi sinh vin tt nghip/ hi cu sinh vin khng? Sinh vin tt nghip nghi gi v chng trinh ao tao? Thng tin phan hi cua sinh vin tt nghip (y kin v chng trinh ao tao, thng tin v s phat trin cua thi trng lao ng) co c s dung iu chinh chng trinh khng?

Ngun minh chng: H thng ghi nhn y kin va khao sat (thng xuyn hoc ngu nhin) Ti l phan hi khao sat Vic s dung y kin phan hi vao vic cai tin.

Tiu chun 14. u ra Cht lng cua sinh vin tt nghip la phai at c kt qua hoc tp mong i va ap ng nhu cu cua cac bn lin quan. Cac hoat ng nghin cu c thc hin bi can b giang day va sinh vin phai ap ng yu cu cua cac bn lin quan. Gii thch Khi nh gi cht lng chng ta khng ch quan tm n cht lng qu trnh m cn quan tm n cht lng u ra. Trc ht, chng ta cn xem xt cc sinh vin tt nghip. H c t c cc tiu chun mong mun khng? Nhng kt qu t c c tng ng vi kt qu d kin khng? Sinh vin tt nghip c t c nhng kin thc, k nng v thi mong mun khng? Do cht lng u ra phi c nh gi da trn c cu ca qu trnh, v vy chng ta phi xt tnh hiu qu ca qu trnh o to ca chng ta, trong cn xem xt n t l tt nghip v t l b hc, thi gian hc trung bnh nhn bng tt nghip (thi gian tt nghip), v kh nng c vic lm ca sinh vin tt nghip. Nghin cu cung la mt u ra quan trong khac cua qua trinh ao tao. Cp cua cac hoat ng nghin cu c thc hin bi giang vin va sinh vin, ngun quy cho hoat ng nghin cu va cac xut ban phm phai ap ng yu cu cua cac i tng co lin quan. Cu hi
27

Kt qu t c ca chng trnh o to (sinh vin tt nghip) Cht lng ca sinh vin tt nghip ni chung c p ng yu cu ca Khoa/n v khng? Kt qu t c c trng vi kt qu d kin khng? Sinh vin tt nghip c d tm c vic lm khng? Nhng cng vic c ph hp vi trnh ca sinh vin tt nghip hay khng? Trong nhng nm va qua, th trng lao ng c kin g v sinh vin tt nghip ca Khoa/n v khng? Nhng trin vng tng lai l g?

T l tt nghip v b hc Hy cung cp thng tin v t l tt nghip v b hc ca sinh vin trong cc kha gn y theo Bng 5. Bng 5: T l tt nghip v b hc ca sinh vin (nu t 8 n 10 kha gn y nht) Nm hc Tng s SV trong kha* T l tt nghip vn bng th nht sau thi gian 3 nm 4 nm ** >4 nm T l b hc sau thi gian 1 nm 2 nm ** 3 nm >3 nm

* Tnh theo s lng sinh vin tuyn mi trong Bng 1 ** T l ny l t l tnh gp Cu hi o o Khoa co h thng phu hp theo doi: Theo doi tin trinh hoc tp cua sinh vin. Theo doi t l u va rt/ bo hoc.

Khoa/n v c kin g v t l tt nghip hin nay? Nu t l ny cha thc s tt, th nhng bin php g ang c thc hin nng t l tt nghip? Trong 5 nm va qua t l tt nghip c bin ng g khng? T l b hc l bao nhiu? C th gii thch l do sinh vin b hc vi t l nh hin nay khng? Khoa/n v c nm bt c thng tin sinh vin b hc thng i u khng?
28

Thi gian tt nghip bnh qun (sinh vin tt nghip) Hy nu thi gian bnh qun m mt sinh vin cn tt nghip chng trnh o to ca Khoa/n v. Nu cn, hy phn loi sinh vin ra thnh nhng nhm i tng khc nhau. Khoa/n v nh gi ra sao v thi gian tt nghip bnh qun ca sinh vin? Cc bin php no ang c thc hin khuyn khch sinh vin hon tt kha hc v rt ngn thi gian tt nghip? Nhng bin php ny c hiu qu n u?

Sinh vin tt nghip c vic lm T l phn trm sinh vin tt nghip c vic lm trong vng su thng sau khi tt nghip trong 5 nm gn y? C bao nhiu sinh vin tt nghip c th tm c vic lm trong vng mt nm? T l sinh vin tt nghip vn cha c vic lm trong 2 nm sau khi tt nghip?

Nghin cu Nhng loai hoat ng nghin cu nao c thc hin bi can b giang day va sinh vin? Nhng hoat ng nay co phu hp vi s mang va tm nhin cua trng va khoa? Ngun quy cho nghin cu cp nao va c s dung nh th nao? S lng cua cac bai nghin cu? Cac bai nghin cu c phat hanh ia phng, quc gia hay quc t?

Ngun minh chng Khao sat sinh vin tt nghip va tinh trang vic lam S liu tinh trang vic lam Mc lng Phan hi cua nha s dung lao ng Cac bao cao bao chi

Tiu chun 15. S hi lng ca cc bn lin quan Cac bn lin quan hai long v chng trinh ao tao va cht lng cua sinh vin tt nghip. Gii thch Sau khi phn tch u vo, qu trnh o to v u ra, chng ta phi phn tch mc hi lng ca tt c cc i tng c lin quan. Nhng i tng ny ngh g v hot ng ca nh trng? Lm th no chng ta bit c iu ? Cho nn, cn phai co mt h thng thu thp v o lng mc hai long cua cac bn lin quan. Thng tin thu thp c cn phai
29

c phn tich va s dung cho vic cai tin chng trinh ao tao, cai tin h thng thc hin cht lng va am bao cht lng. Cu hi kin sinh vin: Khoa/n v c bit r sinh vin ngh g v cc hc phn v chng trnh hc khng? V phng php ging dy? Thi c? Nhng than phin ca sinh vin c x l ra sao?

kin cu sinh vin: Nhng y kin va phan hi cua cu sinh vin v nhng nng lc ho at c la gi? Nhng than phin hoc nhng phn hi tch cc ca sinh vin c c s dng iu chnh chng trnh hay khng?

kin ca th trng lao ng Thi trng lao ng co anh gia cao nhng sinh vin tt nghip cua trng hay khng? Sinh vin tt nghip c b than phin g khng? Sinh vin tt nghip c nhng th mnh no c cc nh tuyn dng ghi nhn?

Ngun minh chng: Quy trinh va cng cu o lng s hai long cua cac bn lin quan. Xu hng hai long cua cac bn lin quan. Khao sat sinh vin tt nghip, cu sinh vin, nha s dung lao ng.

30

BNG I CHIU CC NI DUNG NH GI CTT VI CC TIU CHUN/TIU CH AUN (checklist)

CC NI DUNG NH GI Tiu chun 1. Kt qua hoc tp mong i Chng trnh c kt qu hc tp mong i c trnh by r rng [3] Chng trnh y mnh vic hc cch hc v hc tp sut i [1] Kt qu hc tp mong i bao gm c kin thc v k nng i cng ln kin thc v k nng chuyn ngnh [2] Kt qu hc tp mong i phn nh r yu cu ca cc bn lin quan. [3] kin chung Tiu chun 2. Chng trnh chi tit Trng i hc c s dng chng trnh chi tit [1] Chng trnh chi tit nu r kt qu hc tp mong i va cach thc at c kt qua hoc tp mong i. [1,2,3] Chng trnh chi tit cung cp nhiu thng tin, c ph bin va co sn cho cc bn lin quan. kin chung Tiu chun 3. Ni dung va cu truc chng trnh Ni dung chng trnh c s cn i tt gia kin thc, k nng i cng v chuyn ngnh [1] Ni dung chng trnh phn nh tm nhn v s mang ca trng S gp phn t c kt qu hc tp mong i cua tng hoc phn c th hin ro [3] Cu trc chng trnh o to c thit k sao cho ni dung cc hc phn c s kt hp v cng c ln nhau. [4] Chng trinh th hin chiu rng va chiu su [5] Chng trnh th hin r hc phn c bn, hc phn c s ngnh, hc phn chuyn ngnh v tiu lun hoc lun vn tt nghip [6] Ni dung chng trinh c cp nht [1] kin chung Tiu chun 4. Chin lc ging dy va hc tp Khoa co chin lc giang day va hoc tp ro rang [5] Chin lc ging dy va hc tp gip sinh vin hiu c v vn dng c kin thc [2,6] Chin lc ging dy va hc tp hng v sinh vin v kch thch vic hc c cht lng [3,4] Chng trnh ging dy kch thch sinh vin hc tp ch ng v h tr cho vic hc cch hc [1] kin chung Tiu chun 5. nh gi sinh vin 31 1 2 3 4 5 6 7

nh gi sinh vin bao gm kim tra u vo, kim tra qu trnh hoc tp ca sinh vin v kim tra cui kho. [1] nh gi da trn cc tiu ch [2] nh gi sinh vin s dng nhiu phng php [3,5] nh gi phn nh kt qu hc tp mong i va ni dung chng trnh [3] Cc tiu ch nh gi chnh xc v c ph bin rng ri [3,6] Vic sp xp nh gi bao ph mc tiu chng trnh ging dy [4] Tiu chun c p dng trong nh gi phai ro rang va phu hp [7,8,9,10] kin chung Tiu chun 6. Cht lng i ng cn b giang day Giang vin phai co kha nng ap ng nhim vu cua ho [1] Ging vin c s lng v kh nng thc hin chng trnh ging dy [2] Tuyn dng v thng tin da trn cng lao hc thut [3] Vai tr v mi quan h gia cc cn b c xc nh r v c hiu r [4] Cc nhim v c xc nh ph hp vi bng cp, kinh nghim v k nng [5] Khi lng cng vic v c ch khen thng c thit k nhm h tr cho cht lng dy v hc. [6] Trch nhim ca cn b c quy nh hp ly [7] C d liu cho vic thm nh, t vn v b tr li [8] Thi vic, ngh hu v phc li x hi c lp k hoch v thc hin tt [9] C h thng nh gi, khen thng hp ly [10] kin chung Tiu chun 7. Cht lng cn b h tr Can b th vin co u s lng va nng lc Can b phong thi nghim co u s lng va nng lc Can b phong may tinh co u s lng va nng lc Can b h tr (cng tac) sinh vin co u s lng va nng lc kin chung Tiu chun 8. Cht lng sinh vin Chinh sach cho sinh vin u vao ro rang Quy trinh thu nhn sinh vin hp l Khi lng hc tp tht s khp vi khi lng c tnh ton kin chung Tiu chun 9. H tr va t vn sinh vin H thng ghi nhn qua trinh hoc tp ca sinh vin thch hp [1] 32

Sinh vin nhn c s t vn hoc tp, h tr va phn hi y v vic hoc cua ho [1] Hoat ng c vn cho sinh vin la thoa ang [1] Mi trng tm l, vt cht v x hi cho sinh vin l tho ng [2] kin chung Tiu chun 10. Trang thit b v c s h tng Thit b ging dy (hi trng, phng hc) thch hp [1] Ti nguyn th vin y v cp nht [3,4] Thit b phng th nghim y v cp nht [1,2] My vi tnh y v c cp nht, nng cp. [1,5,6] Tiu chun v an ton v v sinh mi trng t yu cu ca a phng v tt c cc mt [7] kin chung Tiu chun 11. m bo cht lng qua trinh giang day va hoc tp Chng trnh o to c thit k da trn s tng hp ca tt c cc cn b c lin quan. [1] Sinh vin c tham gia vo vic thit k chng trnh [1] Th trng lao ng c nh hng n vic thit kt chng trnh [1] Chng trnh ging dy c nh gi thng xuyn [2] Cc hc phn v chng trnh o to nhn c s nh gi c h thng ca sinh vin [3] Phn hi ca sinh vin c s dng cho vic ci tin chng trnh o to [3] am bao cht lng va lin tuc cai tin hoat ng giang day va hoc tp, phng phap anh gia va hoat ng anh gia. [3] kin chung Tiu chun 12. Hoat ng phat trin i ngu can b C k hoach r rng v nhu cu ao tao va pht trin cn b, i vi ca can b h tr va can b giang day [1] Hot ng pht trin cn b tng xng vi nhu cu [2] kin chung Tiu chun 13. Ly y kin phan hi cua cac bn lin quan Th trng lao ng (nh tuyn dng) c phn hi cho nh trng. Cu sinh vin c phn hi cho nh trng. Can b c phn hi cho nh trng. kin chung Tiu chun 14. u ra T l thi u l tho ng va ti l rt la chp nhn c Thi gian tt nghip trung binh la thoa ang Tinh hinh co vic lam cua sinh vin tt nghip la thoa ang 33

Cp cua cac hoat ng nghin cu cua can b giang day va sinh vin la thoa ang kin chung Tiu chun 15. S hi lng ca cc bn lin quan Phan hi t cac bn lin quan la thoa ang Y kin chung Nhn inh chung

NI DUNG CUA BAO CAO T ANH GIA

Phn 1. Gii thiu Muc luc Tom tt qua trinh thc hin, gii thiu s lc bao cao t anh gia, thng tin c ban cua Chng trinh ao tao. C cu t chc hoat ng t anh gia (S ) Gii thiu ngn gon v trng, khoa. B mn

Phn 2. M ta cac tiu chun AUN M ta trng, khoa, BM at c yu cu cac tiu chun AUN nh th nao (tham khao checklist khi vit) Phn 3. Phn tich im manh va im yu Tom tt im manh Tom tt im yu Checklist K hoach cai tin

Phn 4. Phu luc Danh sach cac t chuyn mn Minh chng, vn ban

34