1 S GIO DC V O TO TNH QUNG NAM

TRNG THPT L QY N

SNG KIN KINH NGHIM

TI:

DY PHT M CHO HC SINH THPT

Ngi Thc hin: T :

Nguyn Th Xun Hy
Ngoi ng

Qung Nam, thng 4 nm 2011

2 I. T VN : Pht m chnh xc l iu bt buc i vi bt c ngi hc ngoi ng no bi nu ngi ni pht m chnh xc th ngi nghe mi hiu c. V tng t, nu ngi ni pht m chnh xc m ngi nghe khng nm c cc pht m th cng khng sao hiu c nhng g mnh nghe. Vi Ting Anh , pht m chnh xc cng ti quan trng v Ting Anh l ngn ng a m. Nu pht m sai mt t Ting Anh th s thnh t khc lm ngi nghe hiu sai hoc khng hiu c. V b sch gio khoa mi Ting Anh THPT rt ch trng vn ny: bn cnh thit k bi dy v GRAMMAR, READING, WRITING nh b sch gio khoa c , b sch gio khoa mi cn c cc phn SPEAKING, LISTENING v PRONUNCIATION nhm pht trin ton din cc k nng cho ngi hc. y chnh l mt trong nhng ci hay ca b sch gio khoa ln ny. V vy, ni dung kim tra hc sinh theo chng trnh mi ng nhin cng bao gm c phn pht m( PRONUNCIATION). Trn thc t, hu ht hc sinh rt i ph vi ni dung ny v cha nhn thc y v tm quan trng ca pht m cng vi hn ch khch quan v mi trng giao tip l hu nh khng c . V pha gio vin, y cng l ni dung dy mi m khi hc chng trnh ph thng (c) cha c tip cn. Khi hc i hc th cc gio vin tng lai cng khng c hc nhiu v chuyn su v pht m . V cc gio vin dy Anh Vn THPT hin ti cng khng c mt ti liu chun dy ng m nn phi t tm ti nghin cu phc v cho vic ging dy pht m ca mnh nn khng trnh khi nhng kh khn. L mt gio vin trc tip ging dy cho hc sinh b mn Anh Vn nn ti cng rt mong mun c chia s vi tt c cc thy c gio, ng nghip dy Anh vn v vic dy pht m cho hc sinh v cng rt tm huyt gip hc sinh ci thin kh nng pht m ca mnh. y cng l l do ti sao ti chn ti: GIP HC SINH THPT HC PHT M TT hay DY PHT M CHO HC SINH lm ti nghin cu ca mnh. II. C S L LUN: vic hc pht m Ting Anh c hiu qu, vic thng xuyn nghe v luyn pht m theo ging c chun ca ngi bn ng v gio vin trn lp l rt cn thit. Ngoi ra, ngi hc cn c trang b mt s kin thc c bn v cch pht m Ting Anh. Nhng cc quy tc pht m Ting Anh tht khng n gin. V Ting Anh cng khng phi l mt trong nhng ngn ng m ngi ta c th da vo cc m tit trong t quyt nh nh trng m. Nhiu tc gi Ting Anh cho rng trng m t ca ting Anh kh d on n mc tt nht l coi vic nh trng m nh mt c tnh ring ca tng t v khi hc mi t th ngi ta cng phi hc cch nh du 2

3 trng m ca t y. y l mt quan im xc ng v khng c g l cng iu. (Trch sch Hng dn n tp thi Tt Nghip THPT nm hc 2010-2011). Do , vic c kt v a ra c nhng quy tc pht m sc tch v d hiu l rt hu ch i vi hc sinh. III. C S THC TIN: i tng hc sinh ti trng THPT L Qu n ca chng ti a s l hc sinh nng thn. T nh khi bt u hc Ting Anh cc em cng t c b m hay anh ch em km cp v ng vin hc Anh vn bi trong gia nh cng hu nh khng c ai gii v mn ny . iu ny cng nh hng khng tt n nhn thc ca cc em v tm quan trng khng nhng v pht m m vi mn Ting Anh ni chung. Thm ch, phn ln cc em b hng kin thc hng c kin thc c bn v b mn Anh vn. Ln ln khi bc vo trng THPT cc em bt buc phi hc v pht m m c kim tra, nh gi v cho im hn hoi nn hong s! Cc em bt u i ph vi vic hc pht m. Nhng c s trn khin ti tp trung cho ti nghin cu v pht m Ting Anh. IV. NI DUNG NGHIN CU:

Khi bt u vo lp 10, cc em i ph vi vic hc pht m . Qua thc t cc lp ti ging dy th mt s cc em khi hc c qua loa, c sai ri khi lm bi th theo ngn ng ca hc sinh vi nhau l li ngha l cc em lm ngu nhin ch khng c hiu bit g. S khc cc em th lm bng s hiu bit ca mnh v s cu ng rt t. Kt qu th hin kim tra v pht m qua gi kim tra ming ti pht hand-outs cho hc sinh v kim tra vit 15 pht v mt tit vo cui thng 9 ti lp 11A2 nm hc 2010- 2011 nh sau: STT 1 2 3 4 5 6 Kim tra ming v pht m H v tn hc sinh Nguyn Hng Cng H Th Lnh Hunh Th Dim My L Nguyn Pht Quang Tn ng Th Kim Trc im 0 0 3 0 0 2

4 Trong bi kim tra 15 : gm 3 cu v pht m v tng im ca 3 cu pht m l 1,5 im (mi cu 0,5 im). im s ca 6 em trn nh sau: STT 1 2 3 4 5 6 Kim tra 15 v pht m H v tn hc sinh Nguyn Hng Cng H Th Lnh Hunh Th Dim My L Nguyn Pht Quang Tn ng Th Kim Trc im 0,5 0 0,5 0 0 0

kim tra 1 tit gm 6 cu v pht m v tng im ca 6 cu pht m l 1,5 im (mi cu 0,25 im). im s ca cng 6 em trn nh sau: STT 1 2 3 4 5 6 Kim tra 45 v pht m H v tn hc sinh Nguyn Hng Cng H Th Lnh Hunh Th Dim My L Nguyn Pht Quang Tn ng Th Kim Trc im 0,25 0 0,5 0 0 0,5

Vi kt qu v kim tra ng m rt thp nh trn, ti lun cho cc em bi tp kim tra v pht m dng trc nghim trong cc tit hc v pht m v lun yu cu hc sinh c tng t v gii thch cho cu tr li la chn ca mnh, sau sa v luyn chung bng cch cho c lp luyn c li vi cc t sai. Phn Post ca cc tit hc cn li v Reading, Speaking, Lisening, Writing ti cng lun cho bi tp v pht m cc em c nhiu c hi luyn tp v thc hnh. Bn cnh ti cng tm ti v dy cho cc em cc quy tc v pht m t nhng quy tc rt c bn m rt hu ch vi cc em m hu nh cc em khng h bit g v nhng quy tc ny cho n nhng quy tc phc tp gip cc em c th hon thnh cc bi tp trong chng trnh nhng sch gio khoa hay sch gio vin khng a ra mt chun mc hay quy tc no . Xin mo mui gii thiu nhng quy tc pht m ting Anh sau: A. Cu to m trong Ting Anh: 4

5 Nguyn m l yu t c bn trong vic cu to thnh cc t Ting Anh. Bt k mt m ting Anh no cng phi c s hin din ca nguyn m. T c cu to hon chnh khi c s phi hp gia nguyn m v ph m. Ting Anh c cu to bng cc hnh thc sau: (1) Mt nguyn m ng u mt m: a. nguyn m (vowel); eg: I [ai] (ti) a [ , ei] (mt) Oh! [] () b. nguyn m + ph m (consonant); eg: at [t, t] (, ti) it [it] (n- ch vt) c. nguyn m + ph m + ph m ; eg: ask [:sk] (hi, yu cu) and [nd, nd, n] (v) d. nguyn m + ph m + ph m + ph m; eg: eight [eit] (tm)

Mt nguyn m ng cui mt m ( mt hay nhiu ph m ng trc nguyn m) a. ph m + nguyn m; eg: do [du:] (lm) me [mi:] (ti) b. ph m + ph m + nguyn m; eg: slow [slu] (chm) stay [stei] ( li) c. ph m + ph m + ph m + nguyn m; eg: spray [sprei] (phun, xt) d. ph m + ph m + ph m + ph m + nguyn m; eg: schwa [w:] (m khng nhn) (3) Mt nguyn m ng gia mt m: a. ph m + nguyn m + ph m; eg: let [let] ( cho) sit [sit] (ngi) b. ph m + ph m + nguyn m + ph m; eg: swim [swim](bi) clip [klip] (ci kp) c. ph m + ph m + ph m + nguyn m + ph m; eg: spread [spred] (tri ra, m rng) d. ph m + nguyn m + ph m + ph m; eg: call [k:l] (gi) mill [mil] ( nh my) e. ph m + nguyn m + ph m + ph m + ph m; eg: height [hait] ( chiu cao (4) Hai nguyn m ng gia mt m: ph m + nguyn m + nguyn m + ph m; eg: head [hed] (ci u) coat [kut] (o khoc) Do , khi pht m mt t ca Ting Anh, ta phi nhn nh m chnh xc ca nguyn m, ri ta ghp vi ph m ng sau nguyn m, sau cng l ghp ph m ng sau nguyn m; eg: face [f ei s] (gng mt) 5

(2)

6
3 1 2

B. Pht m cc nguyn m: B1/ Nguyn m a: (1) a pht m [ei] khi c cu trc: a. a + ph m + m cm e* + e* : Trong bt k ch Ting Anh no, mu t e ng cui cng l m cm , ngha l chng ta khng pht m , tr trng hp e i km vi c, s hay g thnh ce, se hay ge th pht m thnh m gi (hissing sounds- ce pht m [s], se pht m [s] hoc [z]) , ge pht m [d]; eg: age [eid] (tui, thi i) race [reis] ( cuc ua) gate [geit] (cng) name [neim] (tn) pane [pein] ( ca knh) decade ['dekeid] ( thp nin) cake [keik] (bnh) b. a + ph m + ph m + m cm e*; eg: chance (c hi) (2) a pht m [e] trong cc ch: any ['eni] mt vi many ['meni] nhiu area ['eri] khu vc care [ke] cn thn bare [be] tr tri (3) apht m [e] khi c cu trc: a + ph m (+ph m); eg:back [bk] pan [pn ] (4) a pht m [a] khi c cu dng ar, ast, aff, ath, alm; eg: part [p:t] fast [f:st] staff [st:f] father ['f:] calm [k:m] (5) a pht m [:] khi c dng al, alk, wa, qua; eg: call [k:l] chalk [t:k] water ['w:t] quality ['kwliti] (6) a pht m [i] khi c dng age cui t; eg: village ['vilid] cottage ['ktid] orphanage [':fnid] B2/ Nguyn m e: (1) e pht m [i:] khi c cu trc: e + ph m + mu t e cm; eg: scene 6

7 intervene (2) e pht m [e] khi c cu trc: e + ph m (+ ph m); eg: ten pet debt send (3) e pht m [e] xy ra trc re; eg: there [e] where [we] (ngoi l: here [hi]) (3) e pht m [a] trong ch : sergeant B3/ Nguyn m i: (1) i pht m [i] xy ra trc 1 hoc 2 ph m theo cu trc: i + ph m (+ ph m) Eg: pin [pin] ship [ip] till [til] ability ['biliti] (2) i pht m [ai] xy ra t 1 vn hoc v tr cui 1 t theo cu trc: i + ph m + e cm Eg: strike [straik] file [fail] provide [pr'vaid] (3) i pht m [i: ] xy ra trong cc t mn t Php ng: machine [m'i:n] routine [ru:'ti:n] police [p'li:s] marine [m'ri:n] (4) i pht m [] xy ra xy ra trc r ( to thnh ir) Eg: bird [b:d] shirt [:t] circus ['s:ks] B4/ Nguyn m o: (1) o pht m [] khi c cu trc: o + ph m (+ ph m) Eg: fossil ['f sl] coffee ['kfi] (2) o pht m [u] khi c cu trc: o + ph m + e cm Eg: hope [hup] home [hum] close [klus] (3) o pht m [:] ch yu xy ra trc re (to thnh ore hoc or) 7

8 store [st:] before [bi'f:] (4)o pht m [:] xy ra trc r khi or ng sau w; eg: worm [w:m] worth [w:] (5) o pht m [u] trong cc ch: woman ['wumn] wolf [wulf] womanly ['wumnli] wolverine ['wulvri:n] (6)o pht m [u:] trong cc ch: move [mu:v] do [du:] to [tu:, tu, t] who [hu:] whose [hu:z] whom [hu:m] movie ['mu:vi] (7)o pht m [] khi sau o l m, n, v, the; eg: some [sm] son [sn] love [lv] mother ['m] B5/ Nguyn m u: put [put] full [ful] (2) u pht m [ju:] khi c cu trc:u+ph m + e cm; eg: tune [tju:n] tube [tju:b] cube [kju:b] + u cng pht m [ju:] nhng vn nhn ging; eg: human ['hju:mn] duty ['dju:ti] tuesday ['tju:zdi] C/ S phn vn trong Ting Anh (Syllable division): Mun t c c cc t Ting Anh mt cch d dng , chng ta cn nh phng php phn vn sau: (1) u tin ta m xem trong t c bao nhiu: - Nguyn m n: a, e, i, o, u, y - Nguyn m i: ai, ay au, aw ea 8 ie oa oi, oy (1) u pht m [u] khi u ng sau l, r, j; eg: Eg:

9 ee ei, ey eu, ew - Nguyn m ba: air, are ear ear+ ph m eer l c by nhiu vn. (2) Nu gia 2 nguyn m ch c 1 ph m , ta s ghp ph m vi nguyn m ng sau n; eg: pa/per ['peip] mo/ment ['moumnt] stu/dent ['stju:dnt] (3) Nu gia 2 nguyn m ch c 2 ph m, ta phn lm 2 phn ring bit : 1 ph m ghp vi nguyn m ng trc n, 1 ph m ghp vi nguyn m ng sau n; eg: an/ger ['g] pen/cil ['pensl] win/dow ['windou] sup/per ['sp] (4) Nu gia 2 nguyn m ch c 2 ph m, nu r l ph m th nht v ph m th 2 c th bt k ph m no ta cng chia thnh 2 phn ring bit: ph m r ghp vi nguyn m ng trc n, ph m cn li ghp vi nguyn m ng sau n v nguyn m c r s c nhn ging; eg: par/ty ['p:ti] bur/den ['b:dn] cor/ner ['k:n] (5) Nu gia 2 nguyn m ch c 1 ph m l r th r: thuc v nguyn m ng sau n, nhng nguyn m ng trc phi c thm m [] nu l vn nhn ging; eg: fu/ry ['fjuri] inqui/ry [in'kwairi] (6) Khi 2 nguyn m c chung 1 m, th khng th phn lm 2 phn ring bit; eg: read [ri:d] goal [goul] (7) Hai nguyn m i km vi nhau , c phn lm 2 phn ring bit khi pht m m chng ta thng gp l: e/ate ; eg: cre/te [kri:'eit] o/ic ; eg: hero/ic [hi'rouik] u/i ; eg: su/icide ['su:isaid] i/ence; eg:sci/ence ['sains] 9 oar our oor ower ou oo ow

10 i/o ; eg: vi/olence ['vailns] i/ate ; eg:associ/ate ['souiit] (8) Cui t c le, re, hoc er phi c 1 ph m i km vi n to thnh vn; eg: ar/ti/cle [':tikl] peo/ple ['pi:pl] mus/cle ['msl] (9) Nu gia 2 nguyn m c qu th qu s thuc v nguyn m ng sau n; eg: li/quid ['likwid] e/quality [i:'kwliti] (10) x l 1 mu t nhng pht thnh 2 ph m , theo nguyn tc phn vn n thuc v nguyn m ng trc n, nhng khi c th thnh 2 m [ks] hoc [gz]; eg: lu/xury ['lkri] an/xious ['ks] e/xotic [eg'ztik] (11) Nu sc khng pht thnh m [s] hoc [] th c xem l 2 ph m , ta phi phn lm 2 phn ring bit: 1 ph m ghp vo nguyn m ng trc n, 1 ph m ghp vo nguyn m ng sau n; eg: mis/count ['miskaunt] dis/covery [dis'kvri] (12) Ph m ng trc l, r c c chung khi n ng u 1 t; eg: blue [blu:] brain [brein] crook [kruk] (13) Khi c tip v ng -ing v trc n c chm m (cluster), ta ghp chm m vi _ing; eg: trou/bling ['trbls] cen/tring ['sentri] (14) Khi g i km vi i hoc e s pht m thnh [d]; eg: gi/ant ['daint] ge/ne/ral ['denrl] gen/tle ['dentl] gi/gan/tic [dai'gntik] D/ Mu t cm (silent letters): Trong Ting Anh c mt s ph m cm trong cc trng hp sau. Do , trong cch phin m ngi ta khng ghi vo phn phin m: (1) b l m cm khi c dng: -mb, -bt (khi b i km vi m v t); eg: comb [kum] dumb [dm] debt [det] doubt [daut] (2) c l m cm, xy ra trong t : muscle ['msl] (3) d l m cm khi ng gia 2 ph m khc; eg: handkercheif ['hktif] sandwich ['snwid] 10

11 (ngoi l: Wednesday ['wenzdi]) (4) e l m cm khi ng cui t; eg: bite [bait] ripe [raip] (5) g c pht m [n] khi g ng trc n c dng gn-, -gn; nhng pht m l [] khi c dng -ng; eg: sign [sain] champagne [m'pein] song [s] (6) gh l m cm khi gh c dng gh, -ght (gh ng cui t hoc i vi t) eg: high [hai] plough [plau] eight [eit] height [hait] (Ngoi l: cough [kf] laugh [l:f] rough [rf] enough [i'nf] tough [tf] chough [tf] trough [trf] ) (7) h l m cm trong cc t sau y: honest ['nist] honour ['n] hour ['au] heir [e] John ['dn] Oh [u] (8) k l m cm khi c dng kn- v ng u ca mt t (ch pht m m [n]) Eg: know [nu] knife [naif] knee [ni:] (9) l l m cm khi c dng -alf; eg: calf [k:f] -alv; eg: calves [k:f] -alm; eg: calm [k:m] -alk; eg: walk [w:k] -aulk; eg: caulk [k:k] -olk; eg: folk [fouk] -ould; eg: could [kud] -oln; eg: Lincoln ['likn] (10) n l m cm khi ng sau m v c dng mn cui t; eg: autumn [':tm] hymn [him] 11

12 (11) "p" l m cm khi ng du ch v dng ps-, pn- v pt-; eg: psalm [s:m] pneumatic [nju:'mtik] ptisan [ti'zn] (12) "s" l m cm khi ng sau 1 nguyn m v ng trc 1 ph m; eg: island ['ailnd] aisle [ail] +"s" cng l m cm trong nhng t sau: debris ['debri:] demesne [di'mein] (13) "t" l m cm khi c dng -sten, -stle, -ft; eg: listen ['lisn] castle ['k:sl] often ['fn] (14) "r" l m cm duy nht trong t : iron ['ain], cn cc trng hp khc r pht m [r] (15) w l m cm khi ng u 1 t v i km vi r to thnh wr; eg: write [rait] wrap [rp] + w cng l m cm trong cc t : sword [s:d] two [tu:] answer [':ns] + wh c l [h] khi wh ng trc o; eg: who [hu:] whose [hu:z] whole [houl] + wh c l [w] khi wh khng ng trc o; eg: when [wen] why [wai] where [we] what [wt]

V.

KT QU NGHIN CU:

Vi nhng p dng v nhng quy tc nh nu trn , kt qu ca cc em trn vo cui k I nm hc 2010- 2011 nh sau: 12

STT 1 2 3 4 5 6 STT 1 2 3 4 5 6 STT 1 2 3 4 5 6

13 Kim tra ming v pht m H v tn hc sinh Nguyn Hng Cng H Th Lnh Hunh Th Dim My L Nguyn Pht Quang Tn ng Th Kim Trc

im (im ti a: 10) 6 3 8 4 6 7

Kim tra 15 s 4 v pht m H v tn hc sinh im(im ti a :1,5) Nguyn Hng Cng 1 H Th Lnh 0 Hunh Th Dim My 1,5 L Nguyn Pht 0,5 Quang Tn 1 ng Th Kim Trc 1,5 Kim tra 45 s 3 v pht m H v tn hc sinh im(im ti a:1,5) Nguyn Hng Cng 1 H Th Lnh 0,5 Hunh Th Dim My 1,5 L Nguyn Pht 0,75 Quang Tn 1,25 ng Th Kim Trc 1,5

VI. KT LUN: Tm li, ci tin vic hc pht m ca hc sinh cn s kt hp c v phng php v ni dung dy. Nhng ci thin trong vic hc pht m mn Anh vn 13

14 ti lp 11 A2 nm hc 2010- 2011 khng ch th hin kt qu m cn th hin trong thi hc tp ca cc em. Trong gi hc cng nh gi luyn tp v ng m ti thy rt t nhng em t ra ngi m phn ng cc em u tp trung v c bit hn l mt s em cn t thi rt thch th. V kt qu s kh quan hn nu c thc hin ca gio vin xuyn sut v so snh, nh gi kt qu ngay t khi hc sinh bc vo lp 10 cho n ht nm 12. V chc chn theo thi gian, cc nghin cu v quy tc pht m Ting Anh s ngy cng hon thin hn s thun li hn cho gio vin trong vic tm ti nghin cu dy cho hc sinh m bo va gii thiu cho hc sinh bit cc quy tt va rt ra c nhng quy tt d hiu nht. VI. KIN NGH:

c tip cn b sch gio khoa mi rt hay v trc tip ging dy cc em hc sinh c 3 khi 10, 11 v 12 trong nhng nm qua, ti xin c 1 s kin ngh sau: - Bn cnh a phn ni dung chng trnh SGK rt hay th cn gim ti bt chng trnh, c bit l chng trnh Ting Anh lp 10 v c qu nhiu ni dung v iu chnh nhng ni dung cha hay c gp trong mi nm hc. - Sch gio vin nn a ra chun v pht m theo yu cu tng ng vi cc im ng php v pht m v nhng chun cn c th, chnh xc. Trn y l nhng sng kin kinh nghim rt nh b ca bn thn ti gip hc sinh ci thin kh nng pht m. Vn dy pht m hin l vn cha c mt chun mc v cc quy tc v pht m no khng nhiu v phc tp nn chc chn cn nhiu. Rt mong nhn c cc kin ng gp v ch gio.

TI LIU THAM KHO 1.Trnh Quang Vinh , Rp vn ting Anh- Phin m quc T. 14

15 2. Michael Swan, Practical English Usage 3. English Phonetics 4. Nguyn Kim Hin, Hng Dn n Tp Thi Tt Nghip Trung Hc Ph Thng nm hc 2010- 2011

MC LC: Ni dung 15 Trang

16 Tn ti I/ t vn II/ C s l lun III/ C s thc tin IV/ Ni dung nghin cu V/ Kt qu nghin cu l VI/ Kt lun VII/ Kin ngh VIII/ Ti liu tham kho IX/ Mc lc Phiu chm im-xp loi SKKN Phiu nh gi-xp loi SKKN 1 2 2 2-12 13 14 14 15 16

PHIU CHM IM, XP LOI SNG KIN KINH NGHIM Nm hc 2010- 2011 ----------------------------------16

17 (Dnh cho ngi tham gia nh gi xp loi SKKN) HI NG KHOA HC Trng THPT L Qu n - ti: DY PHT M CHO HC SINH - H v tn tc gi: Nguyn Th Xun Hy - n v: T Ngoi Ng - im c th: Phn 1. Tn ti t vn 2. C s l lun 3. C s thc tin 4. Ni dung nghin cu 5. Kt qu nghin cu 6. Kt lun 7. ngh 8.Ti liu tham kho 9.Mc lc 10.Phiu nh gi xp loi Th thc vn bn, chnh t Tng cng Nhn xt im ca ngi nh gi xp loi ti ti a 1 1 2 9 3 1 1 1 1 20 im t c

Cn c s im t c, ti trn c xp loi : Ngi nh gi xp loi ti:

(K, ghi r h tn)

CNG HA X HI CH NGHA VIT NAM c lp - T do - Hnh phc 17

18 PHIU NH GI, XP LOI SNG KIN KINH NGHIM Nm hc: 2010 - 2011 I. nh gi xp loi ca HKH Trng THPT L QU N 1. Tn ti: DY PHT M CHO HC SINH 2. H v tn tc gi: Nguyn Th Xun Hy 3. Chc v: Gio vin T: Ngoi Ng 4. Nhn xt ca Ch tch HKH v ti: a)u im ................................................................................................................ ................................................................................................................................... .. b)Hn ch: ................................................................................................................ ................................................................................................................................... .. 5. nh gi, xp loi: Sau khi thm nh, nh gi ti trn, HKH Trng THPT L Qu n thng nht xp loi : ..................... Th k HKH: (K, ghi r h tn) Ch tch HKH (K, ng du, ghi r h tn)

II. nh gi, xp loi ca HKH S GD&T Qung Nam Sau khi thm nh, nh gi ti trn, HKH S GD&T Qung Nam thng nht xp loi: ............... Nhng ngi thm nh: (K, ghi r h tn) ............................................................ ............................................................ ............................................................ Ch tch HKH (K, ng du, ghi r h tn)

18

19

19