Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Advantage of Hedging For Importers
Advantage of Hedging For Importers
C ATC H T H E F U T U R E
CURRENCY FUTURES
Currency Risk Exposure and Advantage of Hedging for Importers, Exporters, and SMEs
December 2008
The movement of the US dollar (USD) against other currencies is a major cause of concern for the financial markets all over the world. In the past six months, the Indian rupee (INR) has been very volatile against the US dollar, moving from Rs 45/USD to Rs 39/USD and again to Rs 50/USD. The strengthening of INR by 13 percent has taken away the Indian cost advantage for exporters but at the same time benefited the importers. On the other side, the depreciation of the rupee by 28 percent has affected the importers adversely while benefiting the exporters.
This insight analyses transaction exposure in detail to understand currency risk to importers, exporters, and SMEs.
USD/Mn 300000
200000
150000
100000
The appreciation of USD or depreciation of INR will result in loss to an importer and gain to an exporter. The importer will have to pay more for his purchases whereas the exporter will receive more in rupee terms for selling the same goods or services. On the other side, if INR appreciates or USD depreciates, the importer will gain and the exporter will lose. The importer will have to pay less for his imports whereas the exporter will receive less in rupee terms for the same goods or services.
Payoff 6 (Long Position) 4
Payoff
USD/INR 40 41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
-2
What is Hedging?
Hedging is taking a position in the futures market, a position that is opposite to the already existing position in the cash market. The objective of hedging is to minimize risk associated with unpredictable changes in the USD/INR rate. In this process, it should be observed that the objective is to lock in a particular USD/INR rate and not to be exposed to favourable as well as unfavourable exchange rate movement.
Futures Market Losses / Gains in Futures Market Risk Mitigation by locking in the USD/INR rate
A long futures hedge is appropriate when you know you will buy any foreign currency in the future and want to lock in the price. A short futures hedge is appropriate when you know you will sell any foreign currency in the future and want to lock in the price. The profit (loss) in the cash position is offset by equivalent loss (profit) in the futures position.
Importers :
The importer is affected by volatility in the foreign currency rate (USD/INR) in which the payment is to be made. If INR appreciates, he makes a profit by buying the goods / services at a lower price. But if INR depreciates, he incurs loss by buying the same goods / services by paying more in rupee terms. Hence, such volatility in currency rate exposes the importer to currency risk.
Impact of Volatility in USD on P&L A/c of an Importer Event On April 1, 2008, an importer enters into a contract to import Crude Oil worth $ 550,000 (of which 10% is his margin) and to make the paymenton August 1, 2008. The USD/INR rate on April 1, 2008, is 43.50 Movement in USD/INR USD/INR rate remains constant, i.e., USD/INR = 43.5 till August1, 2008 USD appreciates by August 1, 2008,i.e., USD/INR = 48.5 INR appreciates, by August 1, 2008,i.e., USD/INR = 39.5 Impact on P& L A/c Nil (margin Rs 21,75,000)
Margin decreases to 8.85% (Rs 19,25,000) Margin increases to 10.92% (Rs 23,75,000)
For example, say, on January 1, 2008, an Indian importer enters into a contract to import 1,000 barrels of oil with payment to be made in USD on June 25, 2008. The price of each barrel of oil has been fixed at USD 110/barrel at the prevailing exchange rate of 1 USD = INR 39.41. The cost of one barrel of oil in INR works out to be Rs 4,335.10 (110 x 39.41). The importer has a risk that the USD may strengthen over the next six months causing the oil to cost more in INR. On June 25, 2008, the INR actually depreciates and the exchange rate stands at 1 USD = INR 43.23. He has fixed his price in dollar terms, i.e., USD 110/barrel, however, to make payment in USD, he has to convert the INR into USD on the given date and the exchange rate stands at 1USD = INR 43.23. Therefore, to make payment for one dollar, he has to shell out Rs 43.23 as against Rs 39.41. Hence the same barrel of oil that was costing Rs 4,335.10 on January 1, 2008, will cost him Rs 4,755.30 on June 25, 2008, which means 1 barrel of oil ended up costing him Rs 420.20 more (Rs 4755.30 - Rs 4335.10 = Rs. 420.20). Hence 1,000 barrels of oil have become dearer by Rs 4,20,200.
USD/INR (January 1, 2008 to June 25, 2008)
Date of Payment USDINR @ 43.23
43
USDINR
42
39 Time
This means that when INR weakens, the importer makes a loss, and when INR strengthens, the importer makes a profit. As the importer cannot be sure of future exchange rate developments, he has an open position in the cash market, which can affect the value of the firm's operating cash flows, income, competitive position, and hence market share and stock price. Hedging strategy : Suppose the same Indian importer pre-empted that there is good probability that INR will weaken against USD given the current macro-economic fundamentals of increasing current account deficit and FII outflows and decides to hedge his exposure on an exchange platform using currency futures. Since he will have to buy USD in future, he is concerned about appreciation in USD, hence he will go long on currency futures, which means he purchases a USD/INR futures contract as a hedging strategy. This protects the importer because strengthening of USD would lead to profit in the long futures position, which would effectively ensure that his loss in the physical market would be mitigated. The mechanics of hedging using currency futures is explained below:
Time t1
Is short on USD 1,10,000 in the spot market Is long on (buys) 110 USD/INR futures contracts
Oil Importer
Sells USD/INR futures contracts to square off transaction Buys USD to meet import
Time t2
Spot Market USDINR 1-Jan-08 25-Jun-08
Market S pot Futures Entry Date 1-Jan-08
Date
39.41 43.23
Market Price 39.41(S ) 39.90(L)
The loss in the spot market is set off by profit in the futures market. By hedging, the importer has locked in the price, i.e., Selling price in spot market Rs 47,55,300 - profit from Futures market Rs 4,20,200 = Rs. 43,35,100
Result : Following a 9.7% rise in the spot price for USD, the US dollars are purchased at the new, higher spot price, but profits on the hedge foster an effective exchange rate equal to the original hedge price.
Exporters :
In anticipation to meet the demand and to fulfill the sales commitment, an exporter produces the finished goods/services to be exported to a foreign country (say, the US) at a later date and receive payment in foreign currency (USD). The exporter is affected by volatility in the foreign currency rate (USD/INR) in which he receives the payment. If INR appreciates, he incurs a loss due to selling goods/services at a lower price. But if INR depreciates, he makes a profit by selling the goods / services at a higher price. Hence the adverse movements in currency rates expose the exporter to currency risk.
Impact of Volatility in USD P&L A/c of an Exporter Event On March 1, 2008, an exporter enters a sale contract and expects a receivable of $ 4,20,000 (of which 5% is his margin) on June 1, 2008. The USD/INR rate on March 1, 2008,is 42.50. Movement in USD/INR USD/INR rate remains constant, i.e., USD/INR = 42.5 till June 1, 2008 USD appreciates by June 1, 2008, i.e., USD/INR = 48.5 INR appreciates by June 1, 2008, i.e., USD/INR = 39.5 Impact on P& L A/c Nil (profit is Rs 8,50,000)
Margin increases to 5.71% (Profit = Rs 9,70,000) Margin decreases to 4.65% (Profit = Rs 7,90,000)
For example, say, on March 1, 2008, an Indian copper exporter enters into a contract to export 1,000 MT of copper with payment to be received in the US dollar (USD) on June 25, 2008. The price of each MT of copper has been fixed at USD 7,200/MT at the prevailing exchange rate of 1 USD = INR 44.05. The price of one MT of copper in INR works out to be Rs 3,17,160 (7,200 x 44.05). The exporter has a risk that the INR may strengthen over the next three months causing the copper to give less revenue in INR. However, he decides not to hedge his position. On June 25, 2008, the INR actually appreciates against the USD and the exchange rate stands at 1 USD = INR 40.30. He has fixed his price in dollar terms, i.e., USD 7,200/MT; however, the dollar that he receives has to be converted into INR on the given date and the exchange rate stands at 1 USD = INR 40.30. Every dollar that he receives is worth Rs 40.30 as against the contract price of Rs 44.05. So the same MT of copper that initially would have fetched him Rs 3,17,160 will realize Rs 2,90,160, which means 1 MT of copper ended down fetching him Rs 27,000 less (Rs 3,17,160 Rs 2,90,160 = Rs 27,000). Hence 1,000 MT of copper have become cheaper by Rs 2,70,00,000.
USD/INR (Mar 1 - June 25, 2008) 45 Exposure inititaion date USDINR @ 44.05
44
US D IN R
43
42
USD depreciated by Rs. 3.75 (Currency Risk) Date of Payment USDINR @ 40.30
41
40 Time
This means that when INR strengthens, the exporter makes a loss and when INR weakens, the exporter makes a profit. As the exporter cannot be sure of future exchange rate developments, he has an entirely speculative open position in the cash market, which can affect the value of the firm's operating cash flows, income, competitive position, and hence market share and stock price. Hedging strategy : Suppose the same Indian copper exporter pre-empted that there is good probability that INR will strengthen against USD given the current macro-economic fundamentals of reducing fiscal deficit, stable current account deficit, and strong FII inflows and decided to hedge his exposure on an exchange platform using currency futures. Since he will have to sell USD in future, he is concerned about depreciation in USD, hence he will go short on currency futures, which means he sells a USD/INR futures contract as a hedging strategy. This protects the exporter against weakening of USD as it would lead to offsetting profit in the short futures position. The mechanics of hedging using currency futures is explained below:
Time t1
Is long on USD 72,00,000 in the Spot market Is short on (sells) 7,200 USD/INR futures contracts
Copper Exporter
Time t2
Buys back USD/INR futures contracts to square off transaction Sells USD in the spot market
Date
1-Mar-08 25-June-08
Market Spot Futures
The loss in the spot market is set off by profit in the futures market. By hedging, the exporter has locked in the price, i.e., Selling price in spot market Rs 29,01,60,000 + profit from Futures market Rs 2,70,00,000 = Rs. 31,71,60,000
Result : Following an 8.51% fall in the spot price for USD, the US dollars are sold at the new, lower spot price; but profits on the hedge foster an effective exchange rate equal to the original hedge price.
As a result of globalization and liberalization, coupled with the WTO regime, Indian SMEs have been passing through a transitional period. Due to the nature of their businesses, SMEs are generally involved in trades denominated in a currency pair, i.e., large volumes of imports/ exports. Hence SMEs are also exposed to exchange rate fluctuations as explained earlier. Importers, exporters, and SMEs can minimize their exposure in terms of exchange rate fluctuation by hedging using derivative instruments on a currency futures exchange. Since the regulators RBI and SEBI have given the green signal to start currency futures exchanges in India, they all have a platform open for them to mitigate their risk.
Disclaimer:
This is a market insight from FT Knowledge Management Company Limited (FTKMC). The content has been developed based on sources believed to be reliable but is not guaranteed by FTKMC as to its accuracy or completeness. The insight has been made available on the condition that errors or omissions shall not be made the basis for any claims, demands, or cause of action. Readers using the information contained herein are solely responsible for their action. FTKMC or its representative will not be liable for the reader's investment/business decision based on this insight.