!"#
$&% '

()
*+
","#-
/.0
13254568792;:<>=06?6A@B
CEDGFIHKJKLNMOHQP =0R*SUTWVYX9ZW[OZ]\I^`_Qa9\5bIcedfZg[O^U\hSiTW\5ZN\I^Ujkce^idE[ORWbI\>cOj3SUTW\5dE[OVYR*lWVYXUbIceRQSUVYRmncemWX5op[OqY\I^irQVYRsutpo;v
df\wSiTnclWX5jxce^y\IqYqYVYZnSiVYbzZg[O^{SiV|[OqGlnV }3\I^U\`RSUV|[OqG\`~Qmg[KSUVYceRWX;ceR[dfcQlW\IqGZW^iceWqY\Id><>TW\Ice^i\wSUVYb`[Oq\IX{SiVYdE[KSU\IXcOjSiTW\
bIceRWlWV SUVYceRfRmnd*N\I^cOj]SiTn\5X{SiV }]RW\IXUX9dE[KSi^UV ,[O^i\>eV \IRjxce^t;odf\wSUTWclnXa5TWceXi\>WVYqYVYRn\[O^Ajkce^idVYXXUdfdf\wSi^UVYbe_
a5TWVYbT[O^i\yXiTWc`a5RSUc*N\XUTg[O^iZERQmWdf\I^iVYb`[OqYq A<>TW\IR_SUTW\p\wfbIVY\IRWbwEcOj?SUTW\pdf\wSUTWclnXhVYRESUTW\pbIcedfZWmS[KSUVYceR$cOj
NcOSiT$SiTW\;ZNcOSU\IRQSUV|[OqA[ORWlV SUX5e^[OlWVY\IRSyVYXhSU\IXUSU\`lceRmWRWX{Si^UmWbwSimn^i\IlSU^iV|[ORWemWq|[O^5df\IXiTW\IX`
Q # JOGFePp VYRWV SU\p\IqY\Idf\IRQSUX_glnVYXibIceRQSUVYRQmWcemWX;op[OqY\I^UrVYRdf\wSiTWcQlWX`_WbIceRWlWV SUVYceRWVYRWfcOjXUSUV }]RW\IXiX>dE[KSU^iV
CEFK?D MOHEMQLNF`FKYMeLWHe FePeee
Q9Qg>y]{ $w/A*x3I;GnQ]A]g`]K]3GuQ]x?A]]k?x{yQG
GA$W]QAK]33]x?kA]AixkN$?QK]xx]Q]?]nex]A]kgn
AK]AxQ Q Wz3/Nx3KGGex]K)AAGIne]kg,]]g]QK?kN*
`KgKN5KAN;ANKAQQKng3QIONA]K3x]#AkkQfQAGA
Q]AAKg?xAfAk3G]OGQz3QKNfNAWGxNx]px 33KK3I;KO]Gkx]NGA
Ak#]]xA,QAGAgQW]#fAx]/G]KQz]ANONxxQxx]k,x3KQikQ
3xIux3>5]x]x]x]*]AkONKG]KQQN `n]G9QKQQx
QKh N?xAKAQAGAAkKNk]NKAQ$3Q$Ax3I]nNOQQK
3$QKQQG]xQK`kAkNAkuQNx]A3AxQ fAQKKA G9k3
uANEA]xk3kk3AN&AQxxkGKx3Ak Q
nQKk33EKA3xh3#KQQi#GO?AAK]NKkA> WAQ]k3n$AK]Q*]K
x fAxOKAQ3QuQ]IONAxxIN]kGx;]]GKk ]AQK3;`x gn,N]GONxA3
?kNxkNxAKAQ?u`xA?Q;Eg*Q3QngQ G/N#GuKKzx3`ON#uAn
g]xkW]AAO]kx]A$wx]fAuOu]`N,z> /
*]KWn*3AkQ KA*]KAKQnk! W,?N]k?kAKAKAGAK]
AO]uQN]x3;]?kyAfKAGAp**Q]xAQ;NKzKA*]xkgfxA/5AfN9 WN
nN Ni $QNkIKAG W5fAuOxKAkAx`NNxz?QewQe{g
QN|U{I#zQAGk?G?
A g?fAuO x#]ANhEOI*`?KuQAGA
]/kxA]NA3GkxA]NON]xu/AK]kfKggNk]Ax]zQKK]`x gnQ
`n]GIOgK]Kx] NhKA$Nxkn
y Og /
KNi0

EgkQ g0KAG y
]AAKQxQxkxGKx#AK]AxQ ,kW? G gNN>WNxx]NQx35NAA3Gw`?KuzKAGAQ
Q]kx
/N 
e  QUe we{N 9g|i
ENk N08 I# 3?>
WzfxOkQkG$
KAG&3`n?N]A)NGQ ?> !Wi
" NKxnIKk$
#NxIN& %xQ]#KA ?AQKxNz]AAKW?x gKk3>
" ]]KANg]KAGAfk Kne 83`?GKNuW?k3 NAe
ONp3Gkx]?A$]z`kK gKkhhIK]ON]3`Ogn],33QK]]
]AO]Q]>]AAKWGk gKk3 N>KA]QKx]9]3K3GxQpAu*Q]]u`3 xN
Kkn&3G3GG5kxkAuAK]AxQ fK `?NK`3kGKk3>A/neONy]GKk3
?A/Qu]Nx?Q?AQKxNxk]A]KKxNxk3`?Ku KAGAQ
NNx?u/`Kk3k]xAQGAkukGAKK`x]/NfKA&]Ak NEKA`K]Ak
xkngx]NONKQOE],3O?>( ']$AA3G?QKx/?Qh*/Q]K
B :bIVY\`RSUV g) bE79cedfZWmnSUVYRWE1^Ucee^[Od_:bTWcQceqcOj+*[KSUTW\IdE[KSiVYbIX_4yRnV \`^UXiV S0cOj,*VYRWRW\IXicOSi[n_.-VYRWbI\IRQS0/y[OqYqu_
*VYRWRW\`[OZNceqYVYX_* e21e _3546798:;:;<2=?>94272@ACB>DAFE2G2Bg,<>TW\;ahce^ircOjASiTWVYX[OmnSUTWce^a>[OX5Zg[O^USUV|[OqYq $XimWZWZNce^{Si\Il
&SUTW\ [KSUVYceRg[Oq#:bIVY\`Rnb`\ cemWRWlW[KSiVYceR suo^[ORStH
* :IKJ;L &M51 JN v[ORWl&SUTW\4yRWV \I^iXUV S0cOjO
* VYRWRW\IXUcOS[
:mWZN\I^ibIcedfZWmSi\I^5=0RWXUSUV SimSi\e

1 g7>[OX{SiVYqYqYc
?AQKxNz`AN#AeKK],3Gkx]?A/Q3AeKk3N*A `xQ3
*Qx>]NQxEIONAxkxNx]NONQQO
A]K3Nkngx]NpKA/]$u3f3kxgEQfwx]A*/AKQEKA3QAK]
]K/xNx]N Qx3]GuK]Kk?A3 NxQKx {? fAuO Q]K]k]k
QAGA&]`uGQKx Au&NQn w!x] **AKQKAQ3QuQ]
NNx?uN*AeKK],3Gkx]?A/Q]QAGA/fK8`?KuAkxxA]
]K Q " /Nu`NK]G$?AuQ]5IKGNp/3Gkx]?A/Qk)KQKNp
`KNkxkngKk3NONKQfNp3O)QAGh#w`neKk3 A*GKKk/3GKNx]]
ONQ*]KkfAuO/KAE3NKx]y]* ]G3yw eKk3 AN#Q]K3NKx]
K] K3euQ]yQOnex]3 " N]k?`3K]]/Q3`N3AGOgK$N
3?]QK];]GA 5WIN
EI*n35*Qx?]hKA]QQAO]$NAKA,NKQuNG]
]O]Ak3OQA`KeKAK)ANKh 'yx]kx]#/Qxfk`3]xGxA
KQ NKGQ
> 
?
  
  GU  )

3 y5  " AKKkKA3AxNx]],
]AQONGuQ]x?A]pNxQK?kQAG/]AAxknKE,3kxgfkQxxkGKx#GGQ?AK]AxQ
fkxKxOAxE]ANKQ]Gkx]Q
 
UAkW
  x
]

$
%
#

UA 3
!"

fA&
 xf]AA)33&A] Nx&x(
'*)
" ]xkg Wi`fNu` nip*/xK?AxAAQW]uNk,
+ .- ]*fQ]KQfKK
]fGG>AK]AxQ ]f`G`NA3
+ -/ k
 
UA 
 
UA ?
 -10 +  x
!" ]$#%32
" E/`#]x,]AzN,KANA?xxx]W]uNk4
+&QN EkxkNn3KA #3gx]
fAuO)x]kxA]fA]3u]K`uQ]9kG&?Q
>Q6
587]AQON*KuNA3AxNx]N9  A)*N3Augx]x3GK]k8?
/KkAx?k #Nx]UG 3EN iG *??N)K`Aex]4 :]$
;Knex]k
]n]OQxQQ < N4 5 7 f0KQxQ3KNxA)?]`O#3GK]k ]xkgfxA)*N
]K/xNx]
=?> + :
> : > =?>
UA 3
0 @BA  0D C  %-E0 : 

>

> ?; + >GF = > ;

=> + ;
0-  @ A 0 D C
 

UA

fA D C uKA/3GINO)AAk3eK]$A]K NyKAQxQQH</ N/N$KA]g3

#Nx]f]*Qx5GA&]E]? Ax]>   +]I;  :*x$JLK$M fA
J ONP(Q$RTS f VU Q> WYX I<$ [Z < Q 5878\ 
M ON + Q R[S ] f` ) ^ U + U Q$WYX I <$ ) [Z < Q 5 7 \_2
U
EQ?G*QNAWGxNAA3eE`3kAx]  +#fk&Ax]  7  + 7 #x
AkQxQ33`
JbaKMGacdJ!KM fAQK
>
Jba ONP(Q$R S f  U Qf> e4g I < [Z < Q 5 7 \ 
M a ON + Q R[S ] f` ) ^ U + U Qe g I <$ ) VZ < Q 5878\ 


A1 \I^Ujkce^idE[ORWbI\pcOjtVYXUbIceRQSUVYRmncemWXpop[OqY\I^UrVYR *\ISUTWcQlWX5ceR
qYqYVYZSiVYbp1t X
N&kOgAkQxQ3]Q e4g I<$uKA`Q],3k?A3x]x$N#AQ]KQg3`
 ?xQ]E]x]&k4 <?AK`Kuex],K^
< ]  7 N]y3O&]yKA3]
A3OfN*+ 7 k3AKA
Q  x?N53]?KAufGK*KAGGxA NQAGA
3xGK]Ax`xAkNNN*A`K]ANOkGKAGAQynuNxk]Ax]A
G]KQ)3k?A3x]fkGQ]E`]nQ!)AkQxQ3]xGKk3  7  + 7 uGQAn?
k Ag3x]An&*]3AxNx])?&K #AxKkAKg$]]k < Q 5879N3
NxzI ;  :9 Qe g <$V K e g <$ )*W3

>
7  > : > = > 7 :
= > +  :
UAY]
 08D C 
0  @A 
 -E0 
>
F
> ; +
  >
=> + ;
=> ;
UA
 0D C
0-  @ A
 
>
>
fA 
7   N +
   NKEKA$Nxkn  eONO ?&
fAuONKA]]*3
QxANAWGxNx],KAO]Q]5AeKk3  N+Gn`x]k3 " 3A
g*An`GG*NKExGQN+#]3> KKkn,xKA> ``N#KAQ G> &]Ax] KAKK3n
AG3N;Aex]  7      7      N!g] -/ 7     fA/<N#"'NK
kQK NKxAnG]$3g]Qnp#
G>KAA
x]> KKgKx`]
3`u AK]QxO83$Og
e
ew,gpKg/u  7     N +     -/ ]
?]AeKk3  >K#Axnx?AuQ]QAGA3]`ggKk3uWENA
Q]kx Og
Q&%ggi{g3`I3GfAxON3 ]kx> GQA)3*]xkgE0>Q
< ]$"
AkKfNKknG]'A?A> QKxNG)(*  xfQ]QKggx]k
(*   (*   2

*$AkKNkOA?3kA*KAz?AQKxN+GG*;]GONxAzQAGA5#z]pxQK`n
x>G],Agf x WpyAAA,GG#*AKkKGGQ$]> EA]KNx]> >Q-
N)xQKx]G3`NK&&QxQQO < ])"8A*GQN? D C ] D C  KA]AI*]K
AAkA]K N53]Of3#KQugKk3
<N."'n`x]Qx] 'A]N?&Ax] ; Q J
*AAKAIA> ;3 ]&AW3QON]3 N ;\ 3G] ; 3)]&xx]A]'A?
F >0
F > >
;]  ;   D C 
;  D C N N ;\  $ / ;   ;  2
> >
>
'A3KA3AA])nG]n*xkGQA`Q  O  D C
N N P \ 1  'A]]
Ax]$1 Q M GKAIAN&KAW]K]]]GQA)kxx]x]
F > >
F >0

:A  :   0D C 
:  0D C N N :%\  / :   :  2
wNAx/Gx]G*`g KA/GQAkx])Np?AQKxNGGn]fKA/ > QAGA
3xGnxAu
N> Qn/$QK]Kgnhk*]A9 gg nN Ni QAGh 
7   x$A]
3QKWNx]] +    u,N*Q]uIKQ;Ek]A3]GKk ]K],`xNn#N`xk
]GONxA)?&`xA Q]I& NA3KAQ2i435 S7698 X;: AI?];QAGA
NK*ANzAONAx*];AO]uQ]?Q]AGOgKk3QNx*E]GKk3?ApNKAE`kAn
gKku33`Kk3NpK<2U=3>5 S?69b8 S: fAuO x/nuNxk3fAQA@ ]w
I ? NK uQ]BGG ]Q]x`N3`gNx]]AQAGx
Ku/]3OAk]nE]Ax]yOgK$N,Q]?]3QQ]]KANKQuNpN
]O]Ak3n;kA;AAxk3]A9 gg ] Ni KAGh#NxxgKk3  xGG3
N*NAWGxNx]3k?A3uNzAQ]KQ3Eg*Q3Qn9A&IONAxkxNx]NONQQ'Cx
GwGQQAQzN/`,OA`/uNK]*QA3A]/ N]#fAkxxA]p]K?QOx]3y

1 g7>[OX{SiVYqYqYc
]KAIp?A yuf?QKxKAG)N&])?AQKxN GGnfNKQ]uIKQ
N&Q]QKggx]3 Akx]KAIQAGh?KA 5 KAG

uf`> KNk$] C
!w&

EI* N]A NAG`G> EQAGhKA/?AQKuQN=G  7   uEA]Q]QKggx]3
xKQGQO$AAxkxAnN]K A3Gw`?KuN ENKNy]A NAG`G> KAG
G?NK#Ax NkIKQK Q Eg*Q3Qn9Auu]O]`K]AxkxNx]xK3KNAx
]A`3Gx NxI)NpKA3QK3];A?>A
I# KAG)KknEK A
x*AK]AxQ ?xxGxA/Q]IKQK fAxO&x*]>A]OGB2i43 e   ]*
EI*N
  3 EI#( 

 

 !#"$%&'(*)+-,.0/21 3*45(76798".7,;:<1 ,.0 (&8=> ?>@)A9%&-B 8#CED% -!(&82F*GH1.I7> IJ,K967F)+1  8A#"$BLMG7,K2EN

?
+
  
 7  
NAh` gN nN ]
 7PO Q
 7&SKX T<R UWV  W7
I
N F  7_\
N -/ 78\ Y7 R X  N7
y
N  7B\ F  >  0  N7 N +  \    0 +  Z7 R X  N7
N]AG`GQ N  7B\ D C 0  N7
N -/ 7B\
F >
EI#
N  7B\ F D C > 0  N7
N -/ 78\  7 R X  N7
EI#(
N  7 \ D C 0  7
N -/ 7 \  7&R [X  7

\5 yn{yU^ ] ;P 
^Qn` _,
?P3

Gg` a zx;*Qx?AgfgAAQ,QQKNx
 3Gkx]yNAAAk]KI]AA*>gKA*eKK]Q]AKk3/?A/Qp]AA`kAn
gKk3;$`KNANOAkkQ#KAGx#Nh3KG 2U=3 S pfA u;
k]wKAu,eKk3>]*fN]k?#KAneKK]3Gkx]?A/Q;]KAfKGQ`kAn
gKkhNU ]xgKAf gKk]GONxAg0KQp*kxkgx]NAE]GGkxuNKg]uNAx + y "
Gx]Q]KKxN;]AA3A ?fK8`?KuAxkxA]]K Q
AK?NKQxkn]$p3kNA 'AKxGKxOIiI?pxA #]kkI9]` >Q GYE]EKA3x& ]iH 'A3
A3G?QKx#KAGAQ]NQx]NAKAG]N]AG`GQ& !WN/ I#!N
" AQxQn GNG]W9] ^
 Ab x;,N cE
WGQ]KKxNONO]QKxgKk3]hA`KA x
k3AQNKkA %nGAufuf?uQ]>IKG]5KA`ON>Q]Gkx]?A/Q
u]AN]K]
>
\5{ > 
?{
8{ Gg
? 'A]*3O QxQQV < Q 5 7 *GANK? AGuNKQ#> N
< N?e d GuNKQz]KAEuNK]`;NxQ]K]kAnk^ <N*E`Q#  N N
< Q 5 7 \ " /GANK fgpA`QEN;kKQKk3fG3fN) fA/$N;NxhA/G3
xxGxAAf]ANKA] " f]K`*Kgp#KuN]AugKk3/u #3]KQ3AuNnWN
uQGKAQKGuIOf3kx]3`KN *Og>
< 5 7 >ih *"2

 d

A*W]#A*3kxgfk$KQugKk3/I*QQ+j ]Klk 0 k mzN/  A]Kon 0 n S  m

xJ a EAQGx`3Kk3]IONq!r]sq!rrS KgGQQ)]stN S *p9`O)p N

1A\I^Ujkce^idE[ORWbI\pcOjtVYXUbIceRQSUVYRmncemWXpop[OqY\I^UrVYR *\ISUTWcQlWX5ceR
qYqYVYZSiVYbp1t X
]fn]O (Q Jba*W3
q r ) k  k mS h n  n pS  m h ) q r<r k  k mS 2
A`ON;3Gkx]/Q 
$$N,A `kAn gKk
QNA3AGn
?




r qq S 
X



kW

fA rxAOgxsq!rrJq!rN q  q NK3Kk3 ]IONK>fAuONGQQ

]&n`k>O&Nf]E]k X Q JbS ahAAAxxkAnN3
0 P0 *uf]AG?
q n  n pS  m h   h q n  n pS  m 2
X
S
?]K]GONxAKA]A Axn;#Eg3AEQGx`E]9AQ]`K]K'q ] q
An`E]fGx]nK]AEp3kNA 'AKxGKxOhI?f]xA #3NxI >Q AYGX 3NS
]xxgfkA `K]ANOx?]K]&O]Q$xA #]kkx
  NN
<$ AQ]
e 9
e0i %W Og
Owg
q  q   *>/g 
X X
q  q   *>(
; !) Ag Qe g
S S
> h
>
>
n -/ n pS  q >3 S n  n pS  > 
  3
X
h
n  n pS   q 3 X n  n pS  2
  


*QKk3A 33?]A*n`O,KQxA3&p]xQ]AQ  'xAuOyI?N5xA #3Nk

kI]$x$k#NxkIfxxyQQx]5xAKg?kA?QOkx?I)N;KA/kxkN]K N
Q]K]y KAGA/E3h#*])kx]xKAgn`Akk]OGQ]GONx
NGAxukEGAKK`x]&k ]yKANONQQO*Np ?>
 "$#&% >Q GYEx) ]'  5Q
)( + *2 G, i{g0/ J,-*g$N. 9
e0U %g$  ( 
/ ,,0 K/]
e Og

ewg
?q g eq
2 ! AN

S
F =
h
n  n pS  m
q ^n /-  n pS  m
  S 
F
  7 S  q q ] AQ 
g  N q ]  9
N A0F 
AQ q  q
X
S X
S
g Nx  G  X  &
lc
n O " AGQQ 3k g >Q Q W ]f W f )KA]xGx] N
AK]AxQ)   L k N  !3#% ;EufS xNKgp /X  - *Kgu`
n  n pS  m  = m -/60-  =  - 
/

65

2143

87

;:=<?>

9 
6C



D*

 B

1
D

0

E*

GF

 B



H

IF

F

Q>N0ENNAkuQNx]N;*]O?7GO?NKxA#]kkI*]GONx

F =

F =65  #F
DJ SLK
X
S ?X J S 

n
F n S m
- p
/NM # D M  !O
  S7
M
M p
M
M
uEN)NKAkONK `kx]]K]p kAx3GKNx]M ]x]M 
n - F n pS  m h q n  n pS  m 

n  n pS  m h
fA



A@

n -/ n pS  m

65

1 g7>[OX{SiVYqYqYc
fA q  q f xKAp3kNA& Q]`K] 3g]z`xA]xkgfxAO]Q
xA#]kkIX9A`kX ]g,
> F
>
h
#

S
Z Q$W S I<$  MM # D MM p   q S 3  k k SX   k k SS  7 
M
M
fA]ION q  q *>M GQM QAf]k&]&AxAk ]5NA3k]AhA*3
S S F
n - F n pS  m = 5 /  M ##F M S   h q21 n  7n pS  m 
D Mp
M
F :=<D>   7 S
M
M
M
M

fA q21  q
q
>

q
q
W]A ]g3`KgKGQQGQQ]Ax
1X

S
X S
3AkQn*AAX K?NI
" NKfAgn]G/AKg]*KAE`x gKz]9AQ]AKk3?Az3;A`QG
GA fk!?QKx)AxxkAnN 3) w Ax] AYG**Ag3N ]N9 WN
nN Ni $QNkIKAGh>KA3Gkx]/QuN*]OGQ 2i435
5fAx
]AAKW?x gKk3]x?A]uNGQ3];AgfkNKAQAG8uS769b8 ASN: `AkK]Ax3
Ax]83KAQ/]AAKW?x gKk3Qw`A`nex]
A ] A p*&NNxAI]
5 ?Qyn`x]Qx] " AgKgNK ?W] Q]Gkx]?A/Q
g;xp]3KG 2i 3 S ]kxx]yKAf]?G]u#QWx]NAf`K]ANO/Q]x?A]
Akk 'yx]kx]>*Qxx]fk &?AQKxN;IKG],KA ]GKk3
?A/Q#]#$A3Gw`?KuEKAGAQGAx]
 A3fQK*$Ag N#KA]A
Gkx]?A/Q,x;]3KAQ2U=3 S y] EI#f]*]A NAAIG> pQAG32U=3
g
] I#( 
\5 > p 
 8 T
8I. T
? 8 

 y> y$3GK]k/AAxxkAnNp3 *#]
3z3kxgE 'xK`?]`3N#KA]GGkxuNKgNKuNAx + x# #]K -/ 7 pwGh
]]  7 Q Jbahh
xA> &x]Ogx]?]`O]KAx]KQK N, #gKk3UAY]]
GKk3]  7   G#W]
0

=
Z : Q MGa   +   - a 0 :  @BA  / a       a : 0    2
E3B +  .-/ 7 ;wQxAKAu,Q?nk3 k #gKk3UA eGN 3AGxA/g3Q,]k
QxQ3OQ#]AKNx
F =5 C
= ; 72
=

N
7

;
N
7

7 ; 73


   m -/ 7 0- ; 7
S?698 X
m 
AQ]Kn`]AkAQA3A3 k k 0 k k?uf3k3Q
F =5 C
k k  7k k S   7   73  n -/ 7 n pS  m
 ?
S7698 X  7N S 2
A*]xxgfkAKA;AgEyAfGGQNAf3Gkx]?A/QpN 0  0 fK
n`k>
 !  #" +%g
q X  7 n  7n pS  m h  7   73 h q S  7 n  7 n pS  m 

R F
FR
7
K
S
T
AQ q X  7  %$'&&q!r
q!r g q S  7  7 X S q 7 `S TR UJS q AQ !q r  q!r  q  q
X
S
X S X S
gK 9
e0iR %W Og
Owg
X Ag R ] S ( &N  R *   c

9 

2



 B



9 


A1 \I^Ujkce^idE[ORWbI\pcOjtVYXUbIceRQSUVYRmncemWXpop[OqY\I^UrVYR *\ISUTWcQlWX5ceR
qYqYVYZSiVYbp1t X
nE*OAkg*Q]A ]ION q X  7 N&]GONxA?`xAKAp]xNA
'AKxGKxOkA #NxI3
> AYGGfk / R  7 R S`T " W3
F
n  n pS  m h q 1 3 n -/ n pS  m = 5 C  S 7
S?698 X
F
F
fA q 1  q!r 7 SKT q!r n] q!r  q] feJ q!r  q *>Q`Q q X  7   & q!r 7 S`T q!r
AAAQX]R AS 3IONX q S  7 N8S &n]kx]GONxAg0R  N]AAxxX gx]RN S (
R
>3  3#]  
F C q
h
q
7
3
   7]
SX
S769b8 S S 7 n  7n pS  m  F
fA!
q  q   *>EN q  q   *>,E3Ax q S  7  q N S C q N S769b8 S
xAX & Axne?k*u,AS 3`KQEKgk
H7uzKAR Q]KnX`]Gk/IS K9An* gKkh
`ON>3Gkx]?A/Q 
373*uf]AG?
F C
F
0
h r q S  7

q
7
S
6
r
r
r

7
q
q
q
2

3
3
q RX  7 
S X S?69b8 S S 7
C S7 
/ S?6 8 S 2
X
R
\50 \5 & 
9
WU
? 8 

P > " Ag3`uGAI KAGh;Q]
`Agf&gfQA3 A]K k k 0 k kG3Gugn KAu?)ufGQA
F =5 C
=
5
k k  7 k k S  7  7   7  n -/ 7 n pS  m   7 N -/ 7 \
  7 S 2
 !  #" +%g

q X n  7 n pS  m h
F R
AQ!q S  & q r 3 S [ N
9e ROg
Owg
AX g ]R AQ ( g$

h q S n 7n
R  pS  m 

S
F
q S  q q C N & Og
Owg
q  q  q g
S
X S
*R   c X

Au>KQAKQO>f gI35GOWf]Of3h,IKAG`xQ;A*IONAxxkngx] ]K]
KQ-C /`#x]3QzKNA3ION+q fxOGQQ,3$N$KQ3AuNKIN
ENKANAWGx gx]]xh ]xF ]G]KQENu,A %#k AO]u3
n O kAKAk#NxkI]
S S X F S G3EN? ?
!AG*W]
S
= g7 7B\ h = N7
= en
N - 7?\ n pS   
 N -/
 S

 7   73



9 





2 B

0



E*

65



65



N?5Q )AY]G#3GK]k

= 7 7 \ h = 7 F q n 7 n m
 N -
 S
-/ pS 
5

 3



fA!q  q   *>uf`kx]Q]`K];AQ5

F = C
  7g S 

F C
= 7 2
`  q e n 
n
7
-  pS  m   q
 S

 7   7 `  q  e n /
-  l7 n pS  m









1 g7>[OX{SiVYqYqYc
AGuIKQQN5KA3ION q fkxh]xxg!?OA?3k C&ONHq
xg#*]x3GK]kAn`xAR X >  AGfK /  C  ew  q  ee
 q  n 7n 2
7
   7
q 1  pS  m




Cz





A@q X  X 3
J AfxO)uNA3  & q!r 3 S

y3R GK]kKAAF AQf]AhA*F AGQQF &]X*3kxR gE(
h
=5
7E 7
   7] ` qE n -/ 7 n pS  m F ` CA  7W S  ?$ AGfK  
h q n 7 n F q ` CA n 7 n
> 3 AY] A  
S
 pS  m 
S X  pS  m
S
h q S n 7ln
F S R  pS  m 
fA!
q  q
C q N q  q   *> q  q   *>NK3kx]3IONK
ER S AX ]A)S ]fKA/X neKK]53GkS x]?A/Q$NAIK9AnNKNp
I?uf]x]&?
F
F q!r

h
r # q C q 3lq r C S q 7 

H7?

 
X
S X

S
fA!
q  q  q  q!r  q!r ]3Kk3Q]`K]K
w 'k Xk3AS #X Ag S A/Q]AKk3?AENnGn)IK9AKf gKk3f
IKAG]$Ax]];A/n``xQ5 3k3Qxk/KQAKQKfAW]ugKk3)N
Q]AKk3Ak]AG3k?A3uF N;G]KQ3 kAxkAnN]F KK`x]*N
k3n/F ]E&xkNK  8 2k ] !  !!3$  3  B 2 !] !  ! !]  ]
 B 2 !3g  ! !]*  A?Q9KA]GKk3AxA&]z gKkW]nxx] 2U=3 S
xGQQGQx]yKA]x]x]>GQ3]GAgfkKgE3AENNx?u#ufNK>


6
degree = 1
degree = 2
degree = 3

5.5

log

10

()

4.5

3.5

2.5

1.5
1.1

0.9

0.7

0.5

0.3

log

Q
LI*2/9,K1

10

0.1

0.1

0.3

(h)

3 /2 B 00 !(&) 9,'#";%&  )A9%&-B1 8$1="2(&/-7e#"=%&A)+-8#% 8 9

AzA5]A  A 3>`AgEhN>A,Gx`KyGAQQG5`kx]#]ION
C p `ONyKA`ON?]GKk3?A/Q CA5]5A#]xxgfkA$]GKNKx,W?k3
` C  C p  k C  C p 
CA   2
2 CG
k C @ 2

4.75

5.5

4.25

()

5.25

10

log

log

10

()

A1 \I^Ujkce^idE[ORWbI\pcOjtVYXUbIceRQSUVYRmncemWXpop[OqY\I^UrVYR *\ISUTWcQlWX5ceR
qYqYVYZSiVYbp1t X
w 'xAYG#`g KAeKk3 CA3$xkNN #3]GOgKx]AAKW?x gKk3QE
AxNxkx]NKKAxKQ]kN)3EQ`0K)K AKKxNyW]k C p
B2 ]3]33
]*  N#C p
 2 !A 3#  G$`3N CA]KgEfxkAnNKk3 C]?n
kAAkI8N fQ C8]AAK33OAK#C p pgxk3 p C  C p   pQA3
KQ/kn;IKK]k33pxkAfKx]  ]N]AxAN X CA  2` C  C p e;Auz`gE
gE]A]KuQ]hN]kGxufNu` NK3A`K]AxkxNx]NONKQBC9

3.75

4.5

3.25

2.75

3.5

2.25
4.5

3.5

2.5

1.5

0.5

0.5

log ( )
10

1.5

2.5

3
5

log ( )
10

  W LI& /9,K1 3 /2 B   (*)  -, ";%&  )+-%&9B<C (*82F*G 3 F21 ,`3 ". ?1 B
9(&1LB ,K1 /`,. G<%*
1.I7IJ,K967F)+1  8A1 8$1 ".(*/9 e ";%&'821  3 -1700 ?I&1 ,K1 )+-M9, 

",> 85 n]9Uhy8
>UY

3y5 Oy!QAG]ykG
5\ y &

KGGQ #GOAN ??kkW3;]QQONxkngx]NAE!QAGAK]3

?&]K5N QW y]fKA/]xGx])]KA/Q]AKK`xAx W?k`?K]]n*#gKk3
nQKk3*]`xkxy#GO?AAK>5p]uN<GO ]b nN  WzAKQnK`]GKk N
9e{geQK3`xNn,3A`n]G`KN]Kk3]5( y]NKAkONKn`AnQ
xA)A 3QAK]]K/AugKk3])GuQ]x?A]NxQKxQAGhy #Nx] iG|Ne
UA e?kfN`gf N]AQONGAKK`x]]#AGwGQQAQ*AQK]A3
k k 0 k k|x3k3Q?
F =5 C
k k  7 k k S  7  7   7  n + = n pS  m
 Y]
n]  7 n pS   
fA#Af3]yAx]^
+  Qx]A9 M a ]/u;GQA? #Nx]G|fx/KQK pN
7 Aw]AQONig3#N?GuQ]x?A]#NxQKx?G ? #gKk3EiG|N;]
UA eg*#N?xQ +  ]N/]AAKWGk gKk3NGKA#3K3GxQy]GA*A]]xGx]  Ax
NAWGx gx]&xNpAO]eKxNhxQK`kQ]xx]&K33QQAKNNAWGk
gKk3]pA3K3GxQf]Q]AuQ]]?3QK]fKAx]AEKNnNz33QK]$]
`K]ANOAxQQfu`&]O]GxQ -/ 7A QQx]##GO?AAK>NON;pQKA3x]
GO ]b nNk n>3GK]k`KQ]?]3QQEn`#]*A]O]Ak3*]*NuN3uA
kf
+ ]]NAWGxNx] -/ ]xxgfkA xQ nIONAxu`An&]Ax]
I*QQ(
+ ] - 7
 

   N&g *2 G QU{N  7 Q Jba,$ AQ)3
e
& 9
e0U %g Og
Owg+ q  
q`     *>
; !) Ag
n +   -/ 7 n pS  m h q  = 5   7 S 2


!

1g7>[OX{SiVYqYqYc

nE *O-?k&
+ N -/ 7 k3A^
MGahA*Q]ON]3 :  +   -/ 7 Ax) #Nx]
U AY]eA>yN0k]OgKkA)?]`OA Kx]QK-]##3gx]iG|NN3AGxA
g]fNx9AkKA#3GK]k
>

65
=
n +   - 7 n pS  m  x  7     7  +   -/ 7
=65  `   + 

 -/ 7 N +   -/ 7 \g 0  7 

kQ
F
 :G  N P \ :?
 N :%\ 2
xA*NO?7AONKxA #3NxI3G#]Q

n +   -/ 7 n pS  m h
3

SV = 7 SV 2
=  n  + 

+


W
\
n
7
7


 S
 -/  N  -/ pS

 
65

65

'kNxk3g0KQENAk?xAAx?]K$xA#3NxI A 3A#3GK]k&AnIKk N

n +   -/ 7 n pS  m h q  =   N7 S 2

5

fA]ION q  3*A`KNGGQ]#AxfQ]AxKKAA?]I
A)3kxgfkKAk AgEKg KA`ONEQ]Gkx]?A/Q ]$KA`kAn
gKk]KA 5QAGuf3AGn)2U=3 S e
 !  #" +%g
q  X  n  7ln pS  m h 7  7   7 h q  S  R n  7 n pS  m 
R
F S
9 AQ q X  
 & q  N  N *  RX  \ c ( g Hq  S  R  q X C q S , 9  q   q X  q S g 9
e0i %W
Og

Owg
R  Ag ]B  g
 
nE *O '3 AGAKk3];AIONAxxkkA

#>NA]QQONGAKK`x]
NQA3 A]K

7 A #Nx] A|?G*W]
F =5 C
7 7
   7  n  7 n pS  m
  7 S 2
y3GK]kKAAAQf]AhA*AGQQ&]*3kxgE
F
F =5 C
h
7 7
   73 ?n -/ 7 n pS  m ?n P7  -/ 7 n pS  m
  7N S
h ?n 7 n F q = 5 7g F = 5 C 7N
?$5Q 
-/ pS  m
   S
  S


h q n 7 n F # q F AC q n 7 n

S X  pS  m
S S  pS  m 
h q  S  n 7n
S R  pS  m 

?$> 3 A Y] A 

3
A1 \I^Ujkce^idE[ORWbI\pcOjtVYXUbIceRQSUVYRmncemWXpop[OqY\I^UrVYR *\ISUTWcQlWX5ceR
qYqYVYZSiVYbp1t X
F
fA KA3Kk33`KN q  S  3KA3QAK]p]K$q  S   q
C q ]
3Kk33QAuQ]`K]!
q N R q W]3kxgfxAAQQR GX q  S q   *  y
X
S
X
Nq  q   *>e
yS g3KAkg*Q]A&*AK?QQn&3*]xkgE
F =5
h
n  n pS  m
q 3^n -/ 7 n pS  m
> AYfK / 
  S 7 
h q 3 ?n& 7 n F n 7  7 n F = 5
-/  pS  m
pS  m
  S7 
h q 3 ?n&P7 n F ` F q = 5
?$5Q A
pS  m
   S7 
h q 3 n 7n F = 5
pS  m
  S87 F 
S
fA`kx]3`KN q  N N  q  \3;A*W]
S
F =5 C
h

n  n pS  m
q N N  C \ 3En9P7 n pS  m
 7g S87 2
S
Axg#3A)3ION]xkgE*?xA q  X    & q  g N  X \
AeKK]3Gkx] ?A/Q 
H7ef]KR A`kK gKk

3R 7 ( N5
KAG&uf]AG?
F
h r q  S  3

\ 3 2
r

H7
#

q
C
q

3lq


R
S

N


q X 
C 7 S
X
S
R
w 'k
A A#EAgA$]GKk3 ?A/Q#NhEnGQ `kAn# gKk/3z 5
]$ Aex]N;k5 3OkxAAn`KfKAQ]AKk3?A/QkA&
Gk#]x]x]AQ]KF Q,    A kA/kxA]F #KQ3nx]# Kg#AF k3n
NfkxA,NK  8 2k3 !  !!]5  ]  B 2 ! 
 ! !*3>  ]  B 2 !3
!?+ ! !3
 ]K?p3Gkx] ?A/Q,W]xzkx],2i43 S 3xGGQKkN9E3k?A3x]
G]KQ]*AKGueK?]A]KuQ]>N]kGx
E]KgnAAAxk3AI KAGhGKA 5QAG)ufIONAx]E] C
!A0
EQ?
*/`g KgQ]KKxNyAAQ3A3GK]kAnx  xNK>Ew 'x
 *
AxN`ON>3Gkx]?A/Q CA]fAex])]C3x]NKKAxNx]?*
W3/NAWGxNx]N#AQ]KQ$    A/$QK]KgKA3k3N;3`?G]u
QW?x] ukAQQG3'KANAWGxNx]3k?A3uNEAQ]KQ3!A`kAn
gKk3xkkQ]AKk3A]BCNAAK33OA, !GnNAxAgf 5KAG
3xKfIONAx3GeKh0 ']BC  ]Gx] CA*QW3*xk3`ONx]*xxAfK
k3  ]N$u CG  2 X e 'kNxk33C @ ]QA3/QW3kx]`ONx]
xkA&fKk3]pgu R CG  2 CA*NK]?G]uQW?x]ON3 fK]
Q]KKxN>]NxG`uQ


3 y5  Au;u]K
\5 > & 
  
b


WU9P
g{
? 8 8
>UY

"
NpKAGAkxGfAKAGAENNx k? QK] AQxQE]xONAk 3ni
NA ]AG`GQ> KAGk !A G>3ey]&AGuK]Kk?A3ENUAKQxQQEKAG
N;E3`]5GO?*]&N$^ Ab k# Wi
kx]KA I QAGh]A NAG`GQ )KAG u]kWG&*QxGQA ]
*N?x`K]Akk KAQx n G3`KAgKQx]xx3O]f`K]AxkxNx] 3




1g7>[OX{SiVYqYqYc
4.5
degree = 1
degree = 2
degree = 3

4.1

3.7

log10 ( )

3.3

2.9

2.5

2.1

1.7

1.3

0.9

0.5
1.1

 W
LI&

0.9

0.7

0.5

0.3

0.1

0.1

0.3

log10 ( h )

/9,K1 3 /2 B  !(&) # 9,' "=%&
?>@)A9%&-B1 8$1 ".(*/9  #"=%&A)+-8#%82-


5.5

4.5

log

10

()

3.5

degree = 1
degree = 2
degree = 3

2.5
5

 l  N
LI*2/90,#1

log ( )

10

3 /2 B F0 !(&) 9,'#";F% ?>@)+-%&9B="  ,1.ILI,K967F)+1  8A#"B7`G ,K2 NN 
 

)A3gKk3k3exA3QK3]#KAKAGx k/3Q]`3N/
x3Kzx A$]OGQ,N53?]QK]*3#]x?A]uNu;N>]QAQ]KQ?AOz3 A#fK
#]AxxNK]AQxQQO$ Wpw]A*GQKk3OQk/A`KAKKuN]AuNzn`AnQ
*]x]QK]Auk*]]AO]Q9?QeKk3 A ;A EI#?N " QQxQ
Q/g c ]nE]`K]AkxxgKk3]$NA NGIAQ> /QAGhEQK],#)3`uG/I*
Q3`nQ EI*/i ]xP   ]fAxO&]KK3A`KNkxkngKk3QK `xkuN,Kg*N

5 NI KAGAK] EI*( i 3k   AfxO)ufkAx N>g]kAN
]x]nz3Gx N9KNnzN5Q]?]3QQfkA R A]K ]#ANuNip$NNx?u,Q]
S
]Ax 3n0
w y]Ak Ax],#AKQKA`ONEQ]Gkx]?A/QN$A`kKNK
]]A NAG`G> QAGhH EI*] EI*( )QAGhy]  #AQNA`n
`KeKAn A ?xNA NGIAQ> zKAGu#`K]AxE]*]x]x]]5GQ3
]KN#3# #3N])AA3k)3K]GxA/  x*x0fQGI3 " 3A

 
A1 \I^Ujkce^idE[ORWbI\pcOjtVYXUbIceRQSUVYRmncemWXpop[OqY\I^UrVYR *\ISUTWcQlWX5ceR
qYqYVYZSiVYbp1t X
$]?G]ufW?k3,]KA$eKK]Q]AKk3 /Q*x,N>]OG 2U pwy]Ax
AYGy#Ag uQ]kxnIKk N N
#yfxO]3GK]kAnkxAnNKQ]KKk3>
?GAeKK]>3Gkx])?A/Qf]yKA EI*NNA NGIAQ> ?>Ax
Np]OG 2i43 S N]3KG 2U=3
g#] EI#( 

 

/ 7B F7e(&) 9, ". ,'1?8.
-( -/2A#"$)A98#%&-8


 
F
F
F
? ]!g !A G !]
!] F !3


Ax]9 N F !3
AY ] F !3


F
NA ]AG`GQ
]Y ! !  A 3
3] F ! 


G !A3] F !  ]  ] F !



LI*2/-,K173

G ! ?! g]

F 3! ]|!!N F

A !3 N
A|? !g
] N
AYN 
G
]]

EI#

F
F

! 
!


!


!


F
F

]  F
G GWN] F

EI#(

;(*)+-,.0/21

!

? !]] F
G ]!g F
]x G? F
!! !]

! 

!
!

!


G N F
3N F

! 

!
!


?|3 !] F
F ]! ]Y
?
N F !

x N
A| 3]
] ]! ?g]

! 
!


!


! 

!]

] ] ]!

G   3]

!

F
F

G
.!
3
] !N N
 .N]
]| 3 N
A
3]

3
?  ]
]YGnN
] A
Ax] 3]

! 

!

!
!

!


F
F
F
F
F

! 

!

F ]!

F !

 
  
3-82F)+1 M' ";%&+ ,KBL-,s#";%&A/2 B 00 F*GH(&) #9,


 
F
F

!]

*]A NAAIG

IG ! !!AQ

I#

wA !3]g

I#(

!.Ng

!!

IG !Ag]W

!!

 ! ! GQ

! !

wA !! 3 N

! !

wA !! Q

! !

 N

!!

!!
!!

w' x A Gn#,Ak] CA93>KA  I#{kQ0OyN I#({x]OhQAGA5]ykxAnNn

#]AKNu])Ax]AAKWGk gKk3?kKA EI*uE `K]AkxxgKk3)N;*]A NAA

G> &KAGhEKAeKK]$Q]Gkx] /Q)`A3Au Nx!3AGn 3 C]?n

!>33k?A3uNuNfG]KQ]KgKQ]#N;KN8A 'A]xxA]NAAKWGk Nx]
NA ]AG`GQ> yQAGxAIONAx]gK?A3Gkx]?A/QpNA EI*KAG
A]Au3g ],CQ]]kxQn g3uNK]gNxAnEN C9 ]KgEfkxAnNKkfK
Kne C9G]fNK&g]kAnN z,Auf`]]nION)]GKNKxQW?x]NyA]OG

1 g7>[OX{SiVYqYqYc
2 CA*3 C @ 3kxx]NENyAI]yKAGAQ
6

6.5

5.5

6
5
5.5

log

10

()

log10 ( )

4.5

4.5

3.5

3.5
3
3
degree = 1
degree = 2
degree = 3

2.5

2
5

log ( )
10

degree = 1
degree = 2
degree = 3

2.5

2
5

log ( )

10

  LI& /9,K1 3J/2 B7F (&) 9,^1 8 15".(*/9 #" F% ^82M1 -F3  91 7'I&1 ,K1 )+-M9, "  , %&  $>
)+-%&9B<C  ;>
 N `3 ". ?17B  $>  `,. G%*

y 

?

?9P Gn{ Pn
_ $xkKgKk3]#Au*NQ*u*AQKk3
K]A,]K/AugKk3N]QQON3 KAGhg#Nx]#UAY]>NUA eyxN`O]
]K/xNx]N8)3`xkKK]`ugK xAO]uQ],GGAuN GG& `xA]
$GIne``$Kk3K&zK]]F`OF NxAi*zNO]Gx])H 'A]*KAxNuAuNxkKgKk3
*W])KA
3]ONkAuNA3N3]  AKg?xA NAONfW83
xkxA3QAK]zu]KNf QAGA/k`xA]xQ]AGOgx]N;ONQ*]K9
*AAxA/] N`O]z]Eu]KQ3#ENGQA]QQONAQAGhfAxk]QAxA
kAxQQOgx]GQK]kuf]AENAxQ{]Q;wAuENIKK3eEu]KQG*GQA
33x`{3;O]pK]GKk]pKA]AQOgKk3/NEIK9AKp gKkNKx]
] `uG3;3GxA]KA&Q]AGOgKk38N]O]Ak3OQpN G9QKQKx]#N G3
G]QOgK]OQ ]`KxQAx]?NAgxAkQn3N]AIe/AQKk3
K] AN`O]$u]K,?k/kkAQKONxyA/QOUAgON)Ax]OK]
kKf3`Qx3?#W3]u nGQ3Qx]AQfN&K`xANpGx`xAK]GKkAnQ
w3KAQ$W]A3 ONQ*]K9*W]`nKA ]kGNp3k?A3x]
]Q]E3f#W]xAkQn AAx]G]OGQ]A3]]Nf3`u 3KuNA3Ax]
kAxxQAK]3&?$AAxAQ/k i
y{ >K _,
?
AQg` a A]x]]xkN?` ]GONxA3 A3QAK]GuI
 3x],]K/AugKk3u/uNK]`]K$GIKQ fAuOx?]3k3#AN]AxNKQuN
AGE]xKANGGxkuNKW]uNk9+)]*#ki;]KQg3QnNKAn`AkxA`G` x*xGAK]
'A3An`K3`3uAKQONkxAO]u)kxkNKANGGxkuNKgNKx]Ax]
]x]]Ax ]KANuNi " If]xE]Ggf
xf> kxkgx]ukk]k
Q]N5ANux]*OA3xQ]>A?AQKxN!G  7   fxOGQQ#3Ax3
W]uNk 
A3QAkNAKAn`k9AKf gKk&Q])/A]AKAQE?Q]AGKk
GO?AQ]AxQQK] KA ]x]]pkxA]`G`-]?QGAk3Kk&KAGuQ]x?A]
]K/xNx]g,AQxQQ,xQ3Qi;AEO`#NA]Ox,$u]KxNAAKGnGAKE x

9
A1 \I^Ujkce^idE[ORWbI\pcOjtVYXUbIceRQSUVYRmncemWXpop[OqY\I^UrVYR *\ISUTWcQlWX5ceR
qYqYVYZSiVYbp1t X
GnKAGAH'xK`f#]AKNxKAFNKQGAnx] 3*#gKk3UG|N#NUA E
 7 F  7 
K kW
 7 q X  7 !
K 3
S
fA,A#NK uyAx?OGuN3]]N ]K5 NKhy,AxGO`KAKzNA#]x]]
gKkuE`xkuNKNENpGKAGA,E3?A`K]AkxxQxA xKQAKQK
? AkGO NK
qGkQ uk?3QxAk3G#N]GONxA)NGAxukEGAKK`x]
] + 3 #gKk3 x] kAAuGAKK`x] x & #3gx] Y)#&]GONx
]xxgfkAxkNfGIKQ3Ag]uNAx 0  7
/ q  S 3 X X  7   S 3 X  2
A`n3NA]O>fAuOx3A/*/W3/k]AAK$xkKgKk3
K]]n]Gg]3ON3]$KAAxGO`KeKAKgKAQxQ3xQ3Qi]?kAKA3QAk
AKGK]K x?NiAxNA]Ox`ONAx ]/QAQ3`x#3AxAK
K]KQ/kAx?O&QKxf]yKA3QxQQOfgW3Q NK]n3EQA
NAQxQ3O/x8KAQxIKQQki AAKGn/xkxx])GO?A3k
NA]O>hg#]Qn9AQK]y# Q]xAQA xGQ];GAKK`x]],  #gKk3gn]O
QxQ3n#A`k9AKf gKkN&A`3n&`xA Ax?O&]Kk3]p `K]ANO
KOAQ;3`3xAENO`,NKxQy`O3 kx]O3O$KOAQz3yQ]AKK`n]K
Kg
> 
 Gg n 

P >  fwKAu5eKk3##]]z`3K]]zQ3`W]GKk3
?A/QnGOgn,]y3?]QK]N&]AO]Q]p5AuQhG#]x]EKA?AQhAK]AxQ
GxfkA]3]QQ]3AA] Q]Gkx]/x8KAQ]?]QA] Nx>T     n3 K
  n)x]] xGxOA3Q ONA]]xGx]u`?NK
Ax]   *]x]Q?
   `  S `  S ? p 5 8 : 2
" `nIONn  K]x]&AxkAnN ?`)8w3KAQ]GONx]O
AKQxk33f3K`xAx]GKAIK]AkAQkx]uE`O&KgfKAKQugx]KxAN>]Kx
xK*] ! 3 X

?
8%  
h
?

?9P  $`xQNyA`x>AKg?xANAAQE]
>{ 1
]EA/`3K]]I$NA/`k9AKE gKkN3EGxneEx]kNONxk
>kA> x
QKNx]*x$3kQQx&AxA)?AOA]u]yKA?AQKxN4G +   
fx G GQQA/3 &NA?xxx]W]uNk6
+  zN kx3KQO]Kfk8kKx
GugKAk3?3K] NufK Ak3]O]kKAk3]O5KA gGx/A k
NpKA/`Qxyu !x)I#AkQ`x]]5G3]kKxxEA/]] 5 QAGh
QKfx]]]kQzkKQO]eOp]Ax/fkkK;xGugKfAQx]?]OQgAKAf3K`xAx
gGx/AxQ]E`x>u Gi 3;IpNA NGIAQ&] EI* KAGAQ
" n]AKKAIK]ON3Q3`]5KAIK9Anf NKx NyAKNONh?A/Q
NkK&A3GiQK QKx >Q kNKA`xi t g AGk`x] N
x?Nh]x?A]uNh`] {#]KAKgfKA3k?A3uN>AQ]KQ  x*KA]3&n]O
QxQ3e,] D KAEKNK]?A#]>QxQQO,x KuNA3Augx]6
5 7 ;AQ5?]AAQ
]A&3 D%D Fx











 







D%D

D &t Sg 2


Eg*Q3QnA*/`]x$]AENKAxx$ K]A3nIKk N])xAK3eKxQA]]

?A/QfxkQxg Au]hwNAx Ak*AgOgKk],IxNx]K

1 g7>[OX{SiVYqYqYc
NKfK)xAx/A `]ON33ENAWGxNx]*]pG]KQ    ?k
Ip I#!]NA NGIAQ> pW]f3];`xGKAx,KNx`A3Au/x3*]
Eg*Q3Qn] 5 KAKNxA3Axx3AKAQ3QuQ]h3A !69  B 2 G
G]{





 K

^K
]/K
!3
K
.! /
K







 K)

^K)
]/K)
!3
K)
.! /
K)



N
!3

.!

 
 
1 0 

3 !!
3 !!
3 !!
3 !!
3 !!

5

I#



3kn 
3kn
3kn]
3kn]
3kn

] g
GYN3
G 3.
G 3
G

] !
] !
] !
] !
] !

!!
! !

! !

! !

! !


]x
]Y
!
]Y
!3
]Y
!?
]Y
!3

]Y
!?
]YG
]Y]
]Y]]
]Y]

]|

] !
] !
] !
] !
] !

!!
! !

! !

! !

! !


]x!3
]x] !
]x]W
]x] 
]x]

]x]!
]x]n
]x]
]xn !
]xnA

!
!
!
!

K! 3 !3 Gx

K! 3 !3] G  3
3 !3
3 !3

G 
G 33












] !
] !
] !
] !
] !

I#(

] 3G
] ]
G ! !?
G !]
Gx]g

K! 3 !
K !
/K!

!!
! !

! !

! !

! !


] !

] !
] !]3
] !

] !

> > yn{yU^] wNAxGYG*`A NKxQ KA Q]KKxN#`xNn]A

K]k)x`neKk3  " `Ag /]OGENp/3Gkx]?A/Q]#k53fKA]OG
N;KA/QNxkngx])KQK ];A?]feKk3N;KA/k])KA/]x
A3uN*GQ35 " &W]]xxxGnA&A]A?QKx QAGA]38]
?AQKxNn`OQ 'A3f` Nxn``xQ5?ANxxgKk3KQKG]xgK3K?#]
Q]kxNx]KQK N,3KG
2i e9KAeKK]Q]AKk3?A/QA]AuNz]OG
2U 8X 
" Q]xAQ#A3Gkx]?Af]*Ax]N>KAIONAxkxNx]NONKQ-C
w 'k
Gx]#W] AxNKA&eKK],3Gkx] ?A/NKAIp yH EI*
N
I#( ?Q?3fkxA] #3GOguNAx]AAKW?x gKk3,3`KeKAn
KuNA3Ax] fK ]&kQK 'A]/x]3g]kAn]BC93Gkx]?A/QN
Ip y ] EI#NK3`?GKNuQ]kxAKN]pAun`x`3$QKQ
G)kAkE`K]AxkxNx]&QKuNyAKN]OGQn?U ]x2 R7 zAuf`A3]nIO
gfAQA)AKQ]AKk3Ak&uh5AI?fxkpON3xK/* x]
5KAGhyxQ]KxA)NK?]ne3$AkxAkuQNx]fkA yx
8G xn]K&Q?Q`x]NfKKA)Ip0 'A3KAA3G?QKx&KAGAQ

EI*fkx53GQ]K A
I#( kQ3Gkx])?A/Q$Np
EI*( x
k3AQNKkuNK]Eg*Q]W*/`;]QxxfkN9]AO]QNKA EI*
]]x]x]x]]G]KQ3

1A\I^Ujkce^idE[ORWbI\pcOjtVYXUbIceRQSUVYRmncemWXpop[OqY\I^UrVYR * \ISUTWcQlWX5ceR
qYqYVYZSiVYbp1t X

6.5

IP
LDG
NIPG = 1
NIPG = 3

5.5

log10 ( )

4.5

3.5

2.5

2
5

log ( )

10

6.5

IP
LDG
NIPG = 1
NIPG = 3

log10 ( )

5.5

4.5

3.5

2.5
5

log10 ( )

log10 ( )

6.5

IP
LDG
NIPG = 1
NIPG = 3

log

10

()

5.5

4.5

3.5

3
5

  Q 7)^I&1 ,.F8.  #"+F% +80I&2/-,K1 35/2 B 00  (*)  -,
?snv+1 8A1"2(&/-0   "'F% +8 M1 -F3  91 0 
I*17,K1 )+-M9, ?."  ,;3 F21 , ` I 9C
9(&1LB ,K1 /`)AB7B 3  ?1 BH/9(  0/    M ) ?1 I7I,K967F)+1 78 

1g7>[OX{SiVYqYqYc

 
  
8
) IM /  %&1 :< ,;#" %&=8I*2/90,#1 3P/2 B  (*)  -, ?

s ]v^1 8^1 "2(&/-0 H#"^%&=)+98K%?82 9 C D%&9
(&8  *G (* ". ,.) 1.I7IJ,K967F)+1  8A#"$BLMG7,K2 N 
KAG

QNxkngx]

]A9 gg ] N

2 / 4 35 ?S 6 8X?:
0
2 / 43 X
0
2 / 43 X

I
5

*]A NAAIG
I#
I#(

AQ]kxNx]
0
2 / 43 X
0
2 / 43


2 / 4 35 7S 698bS:
0
2 / 43 S
0
2 / 43 S
0
2 / 43 S
0
2 / 43 S
0
2 / 43

>0 \5  W
  ] 
 ]

" Q]NK]OGQOf];Q]?]3QQ]NK

/NuNpN)KA]O]GxQ " `n#A/N,`KeKAn)KuNA3Ax]EA
N 5g \     2P2 29fA/ A5g;x)GAw `xQA]NOKNKAKQQ)$NKA[5g ?8AX x$QKx]NzhOKgAK]NAz3N[35QgK]  g
GANKKAQKK]](
RS
*1 gAufGA)]
1 g  k3 x]X p  g 8 !X2 3+ g 2
Xp
" &3xGI*NAWGx gx]NfKA3K3GkAK` -/ 7A;u3GK]k ?
GxneNAkuQNx]N,KA]O]GxQ]QOgK]$A Q]AGK`3kAx]  7A]A
NAWGx gx]uGQKx]3 A]AQONpGuQ]x?A]E3AxNx]>9xAKA G0
xAKk38NfKA&]GGkxuNKgNKx]Axf
+  x8 #3gx]A wNAx G A0 G ] G G*
AKQ*A?AQKxN9]OGK#Np]?3QK]QE]>AK]*k&NKQuN  7GG3K3GxQ
-/ 7] ]O]Ak3 +  ?KneKk3Qx]3]3k?A3x]x,NyG]KQE ,$QK]EN#3
EI#])NA NGIAQ> ?>GA/KN]yKANuNy]AG]GKk ]
fA]x?A]uNupNQ]AQ]KQf]hpEg*Q3QnWA]*]GKk ]G];]x?A]uNu
N?G]KQ3yAuW?k3y3pNu`$Q3`K?NA ]A>G]/N9 W
W>] #]AxxNK]n`AnQ0 I#( xfA3AkA]GwKu$QAG)]OkxA]A
x NKNnEN,Q]?]3QQk]KA/NKQuNpN]O]GxQE*]]AAKW?x gKk3
N]O]GxQf]?3QK]3Gx Nxk]]k9KA?Q
>y H
_T
?Nf >P 
&P p U  GU  G 8

P
C9 " *Q]K3Gyf?AQKuQNIKG
N$A)Qne NEKAIONAxxkngx]NONQQ C838 #]kkI N$A]AAKW?x gKk3>
y`xAKA$3QK3/]5KAGu#/G %QAk5ANN xkkK]9pIG]kx]3]*
]`KxQAx]n`5G##3AuW3KKA`QfNyNONKQ*fAxO]x]n#Akk N
QKK]n$E3*]]AKNxN;KAQK3KQI#QKA]Gw`?KuN
5 QAGhA3#/Ax]N>KA`K]AxkxNx]NONKQC]*kxA] #3GKNu]
Ax/NAAKWGk Nx] " W3`nAKQIKen)n`E];
3N N  !
QxQ3OQfAuO NK`Agfx GYGw3AK G AH G N A A5*`Ag KNx)N
/QKK]Ex/NuNiKA/3K3GkH +  ]AxQQfu`/]O]GxQ -/ 7G9n`x]k3
EufxNKgnAfA C&xE NxU?KA 5x]K]AOgKKN)N)gNKuNK*N

1A\I^Ujkce^idE[ORWbI\pcOjtVYXUbIceRQSUVYRmncemWXpop[OqY\I^UrVYR * \ISUTWcQlWX5ceR
qYqYVYZSiVYbp1t X

 
  
,KB79,.8$#"/ 7:<9,0GL-/2E". ,F%  I& M-173
 
KAG
    
3 ! ! A ? A N 
I

3
3
3
3
3

y

!3
3!
!!

]A NAG`G

3 !3
3 WN
3 !]?
3Y !!
3 !
3

EI*
EI*(

A !
A ]
A G
A !
A !!
A 3 !3
A 
Ak 
A . N
A G!
Ak 3
AY
 !
A  3
A A

A

3 g!
3 !
3 !
3 
3 !.
A !?9
Ak3n
Ak3 !
Akg
Akn !3
Ak !
3YN]3
3 ?!
3

G
G !
G !
G ]?
G 
A x3
Ax 3A
A ! !
AY] .!
AY
!]
Ax 
G !
G G!
G

A

A 

Gn
N

3]
A 9
A ] !3
A  !
A g
A 
]

A 33
A

A 

!3
A !]
A N
A


]]
N!
]
!
|NN?
Y
!]
|]g.

.]
!]

G !3N 

N

KAG

 
  
,KB79,.8$#"/ 7:<9,0GL-/2E". ,  
    
!

3
G  A W

!  
!

! N3
! 9
! !

y

]A NAG`G

3kn]
3k9
3k 3 
! 

! ?n
! A

EI*
EI*(

A 
A

]N
A ?
A ]3
A 3
xW
]
Y]]A
YG]3
!?3
!
?
! 
!3
A Gn
A ]

EI*] 3 #AQKk]NA ]AG`GQ> ;KAGh;Eg*Q3QnN]#x]3fgNxA,N

C]k?KAEKAGA]xxGxAAI{AN,AgfkKA]nKyW3,KAKNf]QQAO ]3
" W]]x3NK + ] -/ 7 " &Q]uGQKAOgKk)NKAQKK]O
 
GQA)3*]xkgE


 

n
7ln m
 n- /- f6  /- +   n m 2

w'x A ?#3NKfAuOgxH'A3*AIQAG*]Ax3`uGn x]3EgNxA

N'C9]A5 N I#+#]`uGQK NxEgNxA&] *QxU w3QAK]U**


!

1g7>[OX{SiVYqYqYc

Unstructured mesh 1
1
0.75
0.5

0.25
0

-0.25
-0.5
-0.75
-1
-1

-0.5

0.5

Unstructured mesh 2
1
0.75
0.5

0.25
0

-0.25
-0.5
-0.75
-1
-1

-0.5

0.5

Unstructured mesh 3
1
0.75
0.5

0.25
0

-0.25
-0.5
-0.75
-1
-1

-0.5

0.5



 g
8 ,.( /-(&,K2B?)+-8#%&98#C<C

 1 B  e93 -)+-8 

1A\I^Ujkce^idE[ORWbI\pcOjtVYXUbIceRQSUVYRmncemWXpop[OqY\I^UrVYR * \ISUTWcQlWX5ceR
qYqYVYZSiVYbp1t X

 
 
,KB79,.8$#"/2 :<9,0GL-/2 ". ,

 
KAG
    
! .]
3 ]. G !3 A N
I

y

]A NAG`G
EI*
EI*(

! 
! !
!

3
]
!
!

3 3G
3k ]3
3 !?g !
! GW
! Ag
! ]

3
3
3
3 ].
3
A !3A3
A ! W
A ! .
Akn 
Ak9
Ak ]
3 ]n
3 
3

G G
G ]
G An
G

G ]
A x]

Ax]]
A !]
AYG
Ax]3
Ax ]
G
G
G
G ]

A

N
!
A ]
A G
A n
Y
!
x !3
x . !
!3]
!
!
!A !
!A .!
A 3
A

A

]`3EI*KQ3kH'A] C  ]  7 x]K]QQAOg]KA 5 N&]*A I#

KAGAQ 'A3
C#@ NK]AAKWGk gKk3EW]A KN3QQAK33 ?&xAuQ3`3
]AAKW?x gKk3 ]GONxAK] KA]O]GxQ/3KN]x]K %xQx&x
3AkQkxGQ]>NN9QO*]3QK3N&A]GGkxx] g]uNAx'P 7
U  EwAu;]N*AKQpAO`p?AuQ]A]]u]/]
5 y {
KAGAf3?AQ5kxxGuAK]AxQ) " 3k3A]KKxN5]NxG`uNA/W?k3
NhKA`ON9]GKk3?A/Q#]*KAGA*fK&KuEkxkN#]K ,x KQK
NNONKQO,]yKAKAGhAfAuO)]Q)Agf&`]5
'AK]]Af?AQKuQNhQGxQK*QN?KK3eA3kxgfxA ]x`x]$
 A3Gkx]AxAN,KAI ] y?u3`?GKNuQ]kx)N#A KN
]OG3*]KAIONNO&Q]x?A]]]
 A A3Gw`?KuQAGAN]Ax3OAxQ]]Ax]zOgnNf33QK]
]KANuN>?xAx]3QNkI  AAQkK]xA ]GKk3AxA
N$A)KAG8K] 43 S K843
],fQ  xK3`n3 &K
xQ]
Q]kGQ3K3G*AEQ]K NQfN9EKQOgKk3*QAG3,`3k?xA
xkAnNEGIKQ)
 QAGA$fKKu/AxKKKkngx]QU ]+ 5IpW3QQ]
NQ)] A`fk]Gw`?KuGuQQxgKk3 Eg*Q3Qnz3uNK]
gNxA]yKA`KNkxkkNONKQfNx9AQAGAfW]AKN]AO]Q]
 A 5  #3kKg;3`,G fKk;Af`]ON3,]fQAGApfk Q]]
`QxU;OIpyNA ]AG`GQ N
I#Ax/])AQgKk3 k3e/x
]QOgx])3AKf]NONxkxAxQQKNx]
 'A3;x]3QpgNxAzN!C9]A3`?GKNu*W?k3pNAEneKK]3Gkx]
QN]QQAO]NzNK?QKx/QAGAhI ] y u$AKN]w
xONA3N/Q]kxNx]!NONKQnE`xA
5 u&3GQk3
KAGhGIuf]K& %xQn
 A 5 QAGx]K`K]Ax/KNAI ?kQkK`K]AxkxNx]
]K]QyG?yA]pG3#/]]KA*]AAKWGk gKk33k?A3x]

1g7>[OX{SiVYqYqYc
10.5

18

50

NIPG = 1
NIPG = 3

9.5

NIPG = 1
NIPG = 3

8.5

NIPG = 1
NIPG = 3

45

16

40

14

7.5

35

6.5

5.5

4.5

ratio of errors

ratio of errors

ratio of errors

12

10

30

25

20

6
3.5

15
4

2.5

10

1.5

0.5
5

log10 ( )

0
5

log10 ( )

0
5

18

35

12

30

ratio of errors

40

14

ratio of errors

16

10

15

10

0
5

0
5

log10 ( )

0
5

log10 ( )

30

NIPG = 1
NIPG = 3

14

20

log10 ( )

log10 ( )

25

NIPG = 1
NIPG = 3

NIPG = 1
NIPG = 3

45

NIPG = 1
NIPG = 3

ratio of errors

NIPG = 1
NIPG = 3

NIPG = 1
NIPG = 3

8
25
12
7
20

ratio of errors

ratio of errors

ratio of errors

10

15

10
4

3
5

0
5

log10 ( )

1
5

log10 ( )

  W E1 #";%&+9,.,K ,.8 ". ,$%& I& M-173  ;> ?>

/2 3 (*)A!M?1.I7I,#96 )A1700  #";BLMG7,K2 

0
5

log10 ( )

7D
;/2 ,.,#-8I*7B 8'MH)A98#%
;17B

G]KQ]
Ek]A3A yKAGn3nhxK5`KNkz3hO5`K]AkxxgKk3NONKQ4C
NA]OAnH !AgKAf?u;]Kf]AOgK,KNEA]A?QKx*KAGAQ
xk3$KANA ]AG`GQ> *?>
 'A3uNK]gNxAnfN C99Nx>?W3`xkuN$]QQAO]&k)KA/NKQuN
N ]O]GxQO&
+  N -/ 7 Eg*Q]y&3K3Gk/
+ ]fA&I] 5
KAGAx]K]QQAOg/]KAAxfx]O]GxQ -/ 7]` ]kpgNxA
N C90 'A3fA]GwKu$QAGAExKA]`k3
 & >y ^
? ]
?

?9  A$]GA3,*]Au xk3f/]A zKNIp*QKNOG#GO
AAKN$;wuNKxpQKA3x/]fxk33A5GuKK`x]Q


1A\I^Ujkce^idE[ORWbI\pcOjtVYXUbIceRQSUVYRmncemWXpop[OqY\I^UrVYR * \ISUTWcQlWX5ceR
qYqYVYZSiVYbp1t X
9

50
NIPG = 1
NIPG = 3

140
NIPG = 1
NIPG = 3

45

NIPG = 1
NIPG = 3
120

40
7
100

ratio of errors

ratio of errors

ratio of errors

35
6

30

25

20

80

60

15

40

3
10
20

1
5

log10 ( )

0
5

log10 ( )

0
5

60

40

80

ratio of errors

ratio of errors

100

30

20

40

10

20

log10 ( )

log10 ( )

0
5

12

60

NIPG = 1
NIPG = 3

50

NIPG = 1
NIPG = 3

1
5

120

NIPG = 1
NIPG = 3

ratio of errors

log10 ( )

0
5

log ( )

10

18

70

NIPG = 1
NIPG = 3

NIPG = 1
NIPG = 3

NIPG = 1
NIPG = 3

16
60

10
14

50

ratio of errors

12

ratio of errors

ratio of errors

10

40

30

6
20
4

10
2

0
5

log10 ( )

0
5

log10 ( )

  N 1700?#" %&'-,.,# ,.8l". ,=%& G7,K17B79

/2 3 (*)A!M?1.I7I,#96 )A1700  #";BLMG7,K2 

 ;>

=
= 749:

0
5

log10 ( )

 >  E D
^/2 ,.,K98I* B78$M+)A98#%
^17B

2/9(*,K98; !93F3  I/  (&B71 ,
?:1 3 (&^I,K -3 -)A8_ -9[OR ceX{Si^i[ORW(l *[KSUTW\IdE[KSiVYb`[Oq?:QSimnlWVY\IX_
1 ^iVYRWbI\wSUceR_   _.N J e
 $t#W2y^iRWceqYl3_ 9^i\

IVu_]79cQbrQWmW^iR3_N[ORWlt#9*[O^iVYRWVu_?>@)+-%&9B 85"  ,93F3  I/^I,K  3 -)A8_]tVYXUbIceRI
SUVYRQmWcemWXop[OqY\I^irQVYR *\wSiTnclWX <5Tn\`ce^{_h79cedfZWmnSi[KSUVYceR[ORWl 2ZWZnqYVYb[KSUVYceRWXs79cbrQWmW^UR_9o# y
;[O^URWV|[Olg[OrQVYX_[ORWlE7 IQ:TQm_Q\IlWX v_6?\IbwSimn^i\ cOSi\IXVYRE79cedfZWmnSi[KSiVYceRg[Oq]:Qb`VY\IRWbI\y[ORWl RneVYRW\I\`^ I
VYRnW_]:ZW^UVYRWe\I^ -\I^iq|[OW_ \`n^img[O^{  ee _WZWZ
L;J
N Ne
 $t# 2^URWceqYl_  FM-,.0 ,I&-173 
+MH93 9)+-;)+-%&9B DlF% B F8./2 F(  (&8H93 9)+-8_1T3 t#
SUTW\IXiVYX`_N4yRnV \`^UXiV S0EcOj79TWVYb`[OecW_]79TWVYb`[OecW_g=06_ N J M Jn
1 
_  M-,.0 , I*91 3 
5FM=93 9)A9)+-%&9B'DF%?B F8./2 F(  (&8 93 9)+-8_Q:Q=0H2 *  mnd
2yRg[Oqu /s N J;Lv_ M51  MOe
 =
h[OW m Xi rK[n_;7 yh[OmWdE[ORWR3_5[ORWl  <;h@ln\`R3_ B 82/2 (& (&8 7N  -3 9)A9')+9F% -B"  ,
B   (&8 0  IJ,K -3 9)'8
 1 1 3
8 8_N7hcedfZnmnS9 *[KSiT3g2ZWZnqu !/sN J;J;Jvw_ N e 
N n
 =" h[OW m XU rO[#[ORWl * #]q [O$ dE[Oqu_ ; /2 9"  ,.)AF*G -3 -)+908 FF% FM;93 9)A9 )+-%&9B Dl%;I&-173 
e_
:Q=0H2 *  mWd2Rg[Oqu %s N J MO v_ L e L MO
 M o# 2# h[Ore\I^'_ & FME93 9)A9 )A9%&-B 8J"  , 93F3  IJ00/E -
( 1 78(&82F*G=7/ 79". ,.)AF*G-3 9)A98i2_ *[KSUT
79cedfZ( s N J M;M v_ 1  Jn
 L<;) h[O^{SiT[ORW
l /,t\IbIceRWVYRWrsk\IlWX v_ $F8./2 F(  (&8>E173 9,+* )A9%&-B 8 "  , / 7:<2/900 KB77)'1 M B
I,K -3 9)A8i_6?\IbISUmW^U\ cOSU\IXVYR#79cedfZWmnSi[KSUVYceRg[Oqg:bIVY\IRWbI\h[ORWlRneVYRW\I\`^UVYRWW_Kcequ5 Jn_:QZW^iVYRWe\I^ -\I^iq|[OW_
 N:]2edfceR_

1g7>[OX{SiVYqYqYc
1.6

5
NIPG = 1
NIPG = 3

NIPG = 1
NIPG = 3

NIPG = 1
NIPG = 3

21.5

4.5
1.5
18.5

4
1.4

1.3

1.2

15.5

ratio of errors

ratio of errors

ratio of errors

3.5

2.5

12.5

9.5

2
1.1

6.5
1.5

3.5

0.9
5

log10 ( )

0.5
5

1.5

log10 ( )

0.5
5

log10 ( )

5
NIPG = 1
NIPG = 3

NIPG = 1
NIPG = 3

NIPG = 1
NIPG = 3

14

4.5
1.4
12

1.2

1.1

10

ratio of errors

3.5

ratio of errors

ratio of errors

1.3

2.5

2
4
1.5

1
2

0.9
5

log ( )

0.5
5

10

log ( )

0
5

10

1.8

2.8
NIPG = 1
NIPG = 3

NIPG = 1
NIPG = 3

2.6

1.7

1.6

log10 ( )

6
NIPG = 1
NIPG = 3

5.5

2.4

2.2

4.5

1.4

1.3

ratio of errors

ratio of errors

ratio of errors

1.5
2

1.8

1.6

3.5

1.2
1.4
1.1

0.9
5

log ( )
10

2.5

1.2

1.5

0.8
5

log ( )

  E1 #"$%&'9,.,K ,.85". ,$%&$G7,K17B 0-

1 BH/ 73 (&)' MH1.I7I,K<6 )A1 0   "$B7`G7,K2  

10



 $>

1
5

log ( )

10

?>  E D
;/ 7,.,K-8I& B 8A )A98#%

N J;J;Jn
h[OXiXUV;[ORWl:N>\`W[`_ %& G%K ,KBL-, 17/2/-(&,K1 M B F8./2 F(  (&8AFM -3 9)A9+)A9%&-B ". ,!%&
(*)+-,.0/21 3^8. 3 (&00 s#"%& /2 )^IJ,K-8282 -3  $1 :<9, JM* 98H
9(&1700 8_  >79cedfZWmS1TnX` 
s N J;J M v_  & M   M Jn
 N 7 y h[OmWdE[ORWR_  7N K17B71.IJ0:<eB F8./2 F(  (&8 >E173 9,+* )A9%&-B "  , / 7)^I(&M1  173 4 (*0B B

1 )'0/-8_g1T3 t#nSUTW\IXiVYX`_W<>TW\,4yRWV \I^UXiV S0EcOjA<G\wW[OX[KS52mWX{SiVYR_N J;J M
 N;N7 y h[OmWdE[ORWR)[ORWl  <;y@lW\IR_
B7F8./2 F(  (*8 7NFM -3 9)A9 )A9%&-Be"  , /2 :2/-0 
B   (&8 0 ?I,#  3 9)'8_]79cedfZWmnS` *\wSiTWcQlWX52ZWZnqu9 *\IbT Rne^iWY_VYR$ZW^U\IXiX_XiZN\IbIV|[Oq3VYXUXimW\yceR:QZ]\Ib I
SU^[Oqu_:ZN\`bwSU^[Oq qY\Idf\IRQS`_e[ORWl 7N *\wSUTWclnXVYR#7 t#_K\IlWV SU\Il*#o# y;[O^iRWV|[OlW[OrVYX`;_ *2VYRWX{ahce^USUT
[ORnl7 9\I^iRg[O^UlWVu
 N $1A7>[OX{SiVYqYqYcW_ -/21 3EB 8./ 70(&7(*8 >E1 3 9,+* F )+-%&9B 8="  , /2 :2/-7KB   (&82 1 B 93F3  IJ00/IJ,K 
3 9)'8_g1T3 t#nSUTW\IXiVYX`_g4yRnV \`^UXiV S0cOj *VYRWRW\IXUcOS[n
_ *VYRnRW\`[OZ]ceqYVYX`_ * _  e Ne
 N $137h[OX{SiVYqYqYcW!_ 379cQbrnmW^iR_3=]1A\`^UmWeV|[n_3[ORWlt#3:biT cO+S
`[Om_  1'I,. ,.^-,.,K7,A1 173
82F8A#"'%&+3 -/21 3
B F8./2 F(  (&8>E1 3 -,+* F )A9%&-BE".7, -33  I/I,K -3 -)A8_n:=02 *  mWdK2yRg[Oqu 
Es  ee v_nRncW _
N & MO 
N MOe
 N 1  h79cQbrQWmW^iR[ORWl79tp[`a5XiceR3_ P )A .6 M98 0 8 #" %&e3 9/ 173=B7F8./2 F(  (*8 >E1 3 9,+* F@)+-%&9B
". , /2 : /9 #B   (&8 0   -
( 1 78' )A(*3 B )A982 8_G<G\IbT) 5\IZNce^USz<G\IbT3 >\IZ]ce^{S J;J5I  M _
<G\wn[OX=0RWX{SiV SUmnSU\;jxce^y79cedfZWmnSi[KSiVYceRW[OqG[ORWl2yZWZWqYVY\Il *[KSUTW\IdE[KSUVYb`X`_ N J;J;Jn
 N  g79cQbrQWmW^iR3_]o# ;[ORWXUbTg[KS`_N=W1A\I^imWeV|[n_W[ORWlt,N:bT cO+S
`[Om_ J(9I&-,#/ 7:<9,0GL-/2 #";F% 3 -/21 3 B 8./ 7
0(&7(*8 GL1 3 -,+* Fe)A9%&-B;". ,'-33  I/ I,K -3 -)A8  / 17,.9821  G ,.0B 8_N:=0H2 *  mWd2Rg[OquY_Sic

 J

1A\I^Ujkce^idE[ORWbI\pcOjtVYXUbIceRQSUVYRmncemWXpop[OqY\I^UrVYR * \ISUTWcQlWX5ceR
qYqYVYZSiVYbp1t X
1.6

5.5
degree = 1
degree = 2
degree = 3

degree = 1
degree = 2
degree = 3

1.5

4.5
1.4

ratio

ratio

1.3

3.5

1.2

2.5
1.1

2
1

1.5
0.9

1.2

1.4

1.6

1.8

2.2

2.4

2.6

2.8

1
5

log ( )

1.1

0.9

0.9

0.8

0.8

0.7

0.7

ratio

ratio

1.1

0.6

0.6

0.5

0.5

0.4

0.4

degree = 1
degree = 2
degree = 3

0.3

0.2
5

log ( )
10

10

log10 ( )

degree = 1
degree = 2
degree = 3

0.3

0.2
5

log10 ( )

  E1 
". ,'3 21 , C -

( 17B ,K1700/ 1 B /-( -/A1.I7I,K<6 )A1 0 8  J 17,.0*G="2,K ) M.I 3 ". F
/93 9/* Dl82+ ,#B7-, C  C ?> C  $>
<C  $> 

[OZnZ]\`[O^`

 N  N79cQbrnmW^iR_No# y;[O^URWV|[Olg[OrQVYX_N[ORnl7 IN:TQmsk\IlWX v_P$F8./2

F(  (&8 G7173 9+, *!)+-%&9B 8 %&

 ,
<C/2 )^IJ(*M1 7 17B 1.I7I3 /21 78i_n6?\IbwSUmW^i\ cOSU\IX9VYRE79cedfZWmnSi[KSiVYceRW[Oq:Qb`VY\IRWbI\y[ORWl RneVYRW\I\`^I
VYRnW_Wcequ.N;Ne_]:QZW^iVYRWe\I^+-\`^Uq|[OW_ \IW^Umg[O^U  ee
 N M  z79cQbrnmW^iR[ORWl87 ;:TQm_  %&3 9/21 3 B F8./2 F(  (&8@>E1 3 9,+* FFM-3 -)+9)+9F% -B "  ,
/ 7:<2/900  KB   (*827e8
829)Ai8 _N:=02 *  mndn2yRg[Oqu /sN J;J;Lvw_  1;1   1e
 N L  NtcemWeq|[OX`_  ^`N[ORWl<;]tmnZ]ceRS`_ .M-,.0 , I&-1 3 
I,#-/22B (*,#-8 ".7,'93F3  I/+1 BAI&1 ,K1   3 /e>E1 3 9,+* F
)A9%&-B 8 _N6?\IbwSimW^U\ cOSU\`X5VYR1TQXiVYbIX`_ncequ Ln_N:ZW^iVYRne\`^I-\`^Uq|[OW_(9\I^UqYVYR_.N J MO
 N J *OtymWWVYRW\I^_ LI*2/-,K173)A9%&-B 8^  ,.17*G 3 -8E17B' %&9, B77)A1 8 _  :Qb`Vu7hcedfZ3
$sN J;JNv_ 21  J
    <zG@lW\IR_=uc h[OWm XU rO[n_9[ORWl7 yh[OmWdE[ORWR_ B F8./2 F(  (&8 7NeMH93 9)+-=)+-%&9B "  ,
B   (&8 0  IJ,K -3 9)'8 _  ]79cedfZWmnS`W1TQX  
sN J;J;Lv_ 1 JN  N Jn
 N  5V V\I ^i\$[ORWl$* &TW\I\IqY\I^_ E17,.  2) I,K :2B -9,0G
982F)+1 M-8 "  , FM9,. ,AI*91 3 
<C /2  
8 ,K17F2B 1 B B 82/2 (& (&8 >E1 3 -+, * F)A9%&-B78$"  , -33  I/+I,K  3 -)A8 _><G\IbT>\`ZNce^{S J;J5I Jn_
<>={792H*_N J;J;Jn
  
>V V\` ^U\e_ * &TW\I\IqY\`^`_y[ORWl$-#>oVY^i[OmWq S_ 2) I,K :2B 9-,0G
-82F)+1 M98;"  , FM-,.0 , I*91 3 
<C
/ 78 ,K17F2B+1 BB 8./ 70(&7(*8$>E173 9+, * )A9%&-B78 ". ,E93F3  IJ00/lIJ,K -3 9)'8   1 ,. _O<G\IbT3 >\`ZNce^{S
J;J5I Jn_g<>={7h2 *_.N J;J;Jn
  y?: mWqYVu_7?:bTa>[O_[ORWl1/ycemWX{SiceR3_7N ?> & ".7,;I*1 ,.1735B7 ^-,#-173 
9(&1 0 8 DlF%   
MGL1 F:A/.%&17,K17/99,.F82/E"  ,.#) _NtVYXibIceRSiVYRQmWcemWXop[OqY\I^irQVYR(*\wSUTWclnX <>TW\Ice^U_]79cedfZWmnSi[KSiVYceR[ORWl
 1 

2yZWZWqYVYb`[KSUVYceRWX/s97hcQbrQWmW^UR_o# y;[O^iRWV|[Olg[OrQVYX_5[ORnl)7 Ih:QTm_5\IlWX` vw_>6?\IbwSUmW^i\ cOSi\IXEVYR

79cedfZWmS[KSUVYceRg[Oq:bIVY\IRWbI\,[ORWl
RWeVYRW\I\I^iVYRWW_Wcequ N;Ne_]:ZW^UVYRWe\I+^ -\I^iq|[OW_  ee _gZWZ N   e
* !

&TW\I\IqY\I^_  93F3  I0/ /2 3F3 -/21 0  FM-3 9)A9=)A9%&-BeDlF%e9,.7,;I*91 3 0-8_:=02 * 
mWd2Rg[Oqu s N J M Lv _ N 
N Ne