Download as docx, pdf, or txt
Download as docx, pdf, or txt
You are on page 1of 1

Intrinsic Perms Bad

Destroys our ground if the aff gets intrinsic permutations well never be able to win counterplan competition because they can always perm out of our net benefit by adding new parts to the plan. Without counterplans the neg is stuck defending a morally repugnant status quo and always loses. If they get intrinsicness arguments, so do we that means we can add parts on to our advocacy of the status quo if we want to. If we can do that, the affirmative has no harms or solvency, because there are tons of other things that could be done in the status quo to solve for their case. They effectively granted us infinite conditional counterplans that we dont need a text for. Thanks, they lose. That puts the aff in a double bind either they lose because their permutation is horribly abusive or they lose because their case has no advantage now that we can make intrinsicness arguments to all their harms. Either way you vote neg.

You might also like