Professional Documents
Culture Documents
أثر التغير في نمط الملكية على اداء المالي للمؤسسات
أثر التغير في نمط الملكية على اداء المالي للمؤسسات
spec CoB Gao Ce Wana gS Juss AF pal phen nal lg CS il AIL i ~/ Bap eall Lasalle lint I gig Yl Leads! sca Qa ally alll Ge Yay Gal ee AB gall Ail G85 Illy Se ell Lanne lps any Lhe 8 pabanll J cya Cals lta slat dasa GAS gf ga OAS: St Gand Ul Oe dl ols Yt Gilet e tae On GF AG) aia BED gb egal pny oY HU SS Cal gS Co gL DOS oF phaall leajall Se dane yh Spat oll gay Lee glall ¢ Ll) Ui jay daaayal foalall chil me Ss Lengel olall gall Gash Ge Winans GHA Sal Ca fab Clana dls —/5 Had) a eae gp a ySall Sey US oS aly ull Gaia Gyo Ha Cay Leal AI Onin yk Ge 88 5 SI An (Ghia Gold Cob gl) Gee jena dasa Ad cll gh pla Chall (DA Gye Dts Uginan AD guns aa i Giy Lan Ranga SB Ap cata 5 GR ata Jy AY pga pall gall La als le penal pad Re aaa 1 Gd Sy ec Jal Gy Uy tins SI) Ll Caagall Dad! Guy 35 SSA Hg Chae gall Gy anda Lacan gS gd Ayat il Lats Coe nell at ge CaS pga) Geta ch ib of og SW Gb kk, Ais Ligh le iss labs Meals Uglies ais 94 Ali GUE ie Logan SS Heth jase Sing LS (iguana 5g 3) Lay lal gall ued gall MLA "digas Ba COIS 1 Leads chisee CHalE) Agal pd LSI) Gm yey yee pei Me a laid ASI Hall 380 Qe al a LagSall 45 6 5 sal pies othe Lad ge Ay gat gl Ula To ag ad Gf al Ait Co padty uy SASSY Ny Shad aaa all Ly EA gd tll SLY Ga yuS EUs le Fagin 2 & gage ol gay oF equa Gaal sCtlam al Ca 5 pS Aad Leen 953 a ySall tall CORN S gal ol Leis Gully Cede dla Gall ¢ sl) gyi LN gb Ed y oka 19S on Seal OM SU gl UI Gyan et Gg Subll 65S) pal Amadall Slay of AaSall dean ay DE Gye pb Leeee gill Cals aL oe nal 98 Aaa Ale gl GLB peed Gall y ola Chl) at of gh Casal Saas lesa y asa pal al sh Zi ad G4 LI (ASL Bey 5th) ted pnaly NNSAYI Rass Jyeal gas DIS Ge dome Al ASL, “gag Chany aot Lanne ool sal oi goldinyt Leal sl jae ja danas Ge Youd tall dessa Abatsl gay @ FAaSall LUA Ha Ugazey cll AL 5 Lal) Citi Jal ye JS Ha Lilla | tsi oes AM ye dos pal HIS 1 tls Upeal) Gila ayay alla 0 eel aba GIS al ithe spgisas sf Gages peal aay gained GSy Ab ealLll '. Gliz Abdelkader, Op.Cit, P30. j. Abdeladin Leila, Les privatsations dentreprise publiques dans les pays du Maghreb, Les. Editions Intemationales, Paris, 1998, P.192 -44-Gynt deci) gai digacll Gls Aystal) dad pb stl) SY daa) eee CB eee gS) ye el pa Yl Ihe pels aby 51 pital) Al gual Gye WOUG) Luaege ols) avs SAaaLW clan gl apap Qiay geay Ayal ile le Ss ll p pend Le ALB pai ple Goldll Ubi ae Abbas 48 po eLttl Le Sall pli ya USA Pg ened oe a ks La Sa pit oF Say lghanlis Gao aS J pall Ao y yal ogi Mati 4S 2) Fay Jy Bd CDLaeall jee ayant Gal ay pl po Gull le ol Sey Upc awe 3 aga peal any AHL ol) hy hl cy SF Lead IE ga.) oJ US ol pl 84 Axe AST) Gla coll Dynal aglilly as tse et OSs Gol Wl Ge Cay iual Ciagall My yhll ole Leet Leyes Wginea sd i dad giall Hal YN Qe Sl Cala murat Cua oI ES Use Ughals soley al yal Veciheajall ight yy May sal ba ye ale y jae J gual SSE Je Ugnas ol Lab ged a Bagnall AS p20) aula DS ye Faw ala CH ysl sia Ua ye Mi ph oka ole gall ab LS Anna gill Aoaanjall ood dpa Veins hy Val All Cll Ul je ca Ug) dena jall Jpeal gus DE Gye Lene sill 4h Sg sally shes Lead ALIS, Aull 5 ply old CASA! al as gill og fall Las Hagel Yael garb Coy gi CD oly AY gh tal Lagall peal gay cael te daly ass ot Lsaaall gle Le sled Quill Uno US pte oh Lela Pict iy ll ode Gaye Ld ohn Gli leabinn I gual AIS yo aldill Ae (gi y CHSEENY LaSalle yas Lee cla Asal Gile gle gins gM Aaah ogi Waal! ogi ill Uifins US ¢ jh diy sh scAbLath ji Genel a tale) 9} Anata clans 826 ll gasSall & y ptall pei iy LY ogy epindy BS 8 Say IAS ject J pany UY ol a! a gy G4.H fae Udy choldingy Laat 45 53 Ane Clan y oe Leal pus DA ye Aecanen 9S Co Ha Gf BLY pany Aueald Fag SLAM Cauliy Fle gle Mil y cALAMI Keajall JID dite Abt Loose LasSall ei lass @ Samy ol Meagan Soll ay iy od pull 6 Sine Aeaagall Gy Last J og 8h dbl fade Mii Baaly Ban. 9S pine ph Caney Gill edecl Chuufall Ula 5 diy hl ol pasiud ullis dba yd lad Algy Y ob gl pla) Gall ¢ ghd DE Ge : ey Sal oe sl egal Lab sey Ul egalell etki Gye ila) OLY Gs dal Ga HIS) Ua 92 Abell donald golcin yh lal Ba) CI Soll Gare Gl Lal CLR on ped Abhi 5 5 Lt) (Ql) paca Frama sd JSS ally 548 dual yal -oakall E UAH 5 plall Se ah Y eh LLM lpuSle Ge SY Aa Sal of My hada PLLA, ALG P5355 He ll ole Gf IS ea dpa gf Lapa Qld Gg Aaa Loe ‘ '. Bouinin .O, Michalet Ca, Op.Cit, P.141. ~45-Goel eat ga Jyail Us ate baa gd cd ds dua fee aes hase ts qed Ay all ok Ol juny tOlaagal US Saley ADU JULY oly ss © sceatBYl leall quugi # scasllaall Ualall lal onl st igs sats Ey stall cya dari CH cd by Leal of LgsSle A gll olall pac @ el gee a ll (gb Ae dal gh gill IE (pk Anca gl gd ca lett Ni gals (ill Cll ally Al aed gh all cay a Dalal Seal ally J At Jed ob cH LEY ys Bold Ady Anuagall uals ic ch pS grind petinue Jyda utait Le bale LasSally Aamagall pine 9S GH (p25 of ll Claall diy yD ok AS eS cla aby 3 JY gd 4 Je Alpe Ll Dal aly gb LaSalle gr sl eltt gus DLA age ye Peal badly Sip all any ALS! Mi phil ola Glo Atliade GS Le SI grt gi deold dun upall (Sous Evaluation) (xd pill 41S hao Pata Lassa a) pg ne SS ¢ gay Cul Ayal Ade gat Gf Sed (Lal 4 58) A gall Galle aye GL gl Aig ll oh gagi Y @ fps lle iL be gas pala gta a gM) Zabel Cana all gal ALI By gy Bye any Ge pant Asal ge ly» 28 Jydall Gall phil ays Ayla Aglaall ald eb yyelk GIS, 45 tt YS! LY) Jal shed) ee pele Lene Sl apse) JS Ube MS ey ghd 1992p ssh gh Lay gl ld ey a ob ASU gla SG Cage Ge 1991 gated SAN e sal Saal Cll Go arn gl Ryd Dy Cans 9 Lislyy 9 balay Oe IS oh Ge Aad gle gaan gob Gall 3h JS GF ale Hay sll ode pis cpl Lett ya 4g. ll dbs LST pk Chad a gSall GY coli GUA ya Gl Cilaagall od Stall Gy gis CI Ned y cll gis AML a Cet Poe gd ib LE! Gl gad Slee £24 «coupon schéme» ji «voucher» | «coupons d'investissementy stud Ba Ga plat Cus op jay peany 3h lane Ga Cig I) aa Paid SLanll GM) gl cuthl gll 5 ee Ge 8 USL pl UpS4 LS nes yall aargall cob peal coll B20 dey Ughiyad any ASA cay Aisaall AME ab ya SII ode GS GF Say g Ugsle Jyuaall Late Cal ju og Uydall BOSE 5a US Bia Oe sng sain G9 J Utlagy gd LS A Aa Jans Sy LS 4 Nigles LUStH gla Sut 83. 83 Gn Qa gst pally ale. *. Bouinin .O, Michalet Ca, Op.Cit., P.146. silk gut yl ase gle Seal i a AY al Lande Geb Lah i! ip? “Conseil national d'aide technique(CNAT), Projet d'aide a la Privatisation des entreprises publiques, suivi et accompagnement, Compte rendu de la session, Alger, Premiére Session Du 28avril Au 05 Mai 2002, PP. 08-09. -46-gall suai) gai gail Ais Asta dead (gb ct) Phipen = ee "sgt Adland ola el yy Ge Ginell 5 ales ii gy amen y8ll gale gh yytanl 1S jules cab JULY AGA calalah . alld (gd Claill add OS cgi ASI ALY! A yall ygaad Waal 5 Geel saleby caw gad! ileal gis « ya JU] Jae Gaba gL He cea ICL 9 ADGA Dla oF ley cl peed eps Aad yy Gaal Cl pad) Gil gi pe gle abel Sy gal Nha Ghai @ rasta og} Ussaiy Glial «Montage financier al oS Al cbbae Ga et) Ago al dps gh gay Sty ca @ebt Equity Swap) du be 3 4 ASLAN Ng) (dlawSall yaa Lelia (Sy clginane ys Waa} hy lel cy patinne ol} Gala GSI! Ge o 5a gu Liga yess oa sects 9250 Bg) Sota Aa yall og Gate J cule cy petal ga DS Adal Sj yas iad © any Haga Syl gl le A yA gh Go a lie Alas Ragily Ugly gay p gil Agheall A gall 5 36 yall had (W Gy tall IS any Cyaasd chyna Pda sh ah yall Shae all geal» pend an ay ila Leal Leaky ela} Gant cael fie Cubs Gin Ga gue Zyatll Ayal of Lia day gall vba DDR Gs FMB) Lined) U yall i US all Gheaeball Seared y dep LSM) Gy yaad gd GLY Bika 5 9S AG Fl Bake} DDE Gyn gales J AY! Baas ool) aad (gil Leal (Giysil 3:40 Gla! Scull Aaa i ely Zan LG yell Geasias@ Oe Weialdind y Lema phall AylieiYT Cua BeliS Quad y yall LAL! Gils & copia saad yes les gil nl hy dap hg al Algal (Sj yall Saal Gadd y aah ela Sao Joa Lyall! Ui aie aybetlly Ua jut yo yea oka gle wibeadhe Say Le Aiyadll Al gall og 35 yall his Sasi) gill ccoalcinl Gy pctiaall) i Cubiciall 5 palsy, TB Lede cing al hy Gh glees GI LS (Aa lly Lila ig GP gD ne gl Solaad 3 basics apts Ulery Lee (ath alae cull endl) Gi Fat Hg Ua jas Aa A G8 A sah Cas Ga bly eR Ge 1S Y Ua gas col Alas Rasle pgds gin Yl Cysll Lady Cine Cus 1989 le oi peta! aiall gle ayilly O88 gn Na ST Leal Da nad soln gb nein A Ge a fy Caldas aly Schall gd 4 atl '. Gliz, Abdelkader, Op.Cit, P.26. 2. Bouinin .O, Michalet Ca, Op.Cit, P.141. >. Goumiri Lies, Conversions des dettes en capital debt equity swap dans le cadre du programme de privatisation en Algérie, in le jeune indépendant, 13/04/99, PP. 05-08. ‘, Bouinin .O, Michalet Ca, Op.Cit, P.141. 5. dem. -47-Gyuadl Ascii) gai galt tls Aystalt Jani A scl ISM Saal Se AM elael Vg — als We Qed 5 le yuen g Ylbec 528i) daaagall ay 3 drove sill Gye Ais ph ode uct Cory bite Lele SY Golly Ugase pte Ute gi Leaagall Ge A jtll ila sla Gt ag nN Wa Leaky 5g hago Quail AUS Gey pall Sybee Gf Capa AlLanll Gal) Ste tOntle Liewe gill 5 JY cluael sb Gy yuaall Sylke © : sdlall 4S yLta @ GAG Lael AS Lk Lay eos puall ye bys Fe gene Yad 5 Jay eluacl AS yutud Hanuall gle & ypu! al UY) Caylee Asia 215 y da Lee ga isl chasuagall Sac & yaray CLF hs od appar Lengel Ube uly gd ol jal Sita Gf LS sIginane yh gill ities He AL CIS CJ ll paSLAS} ale Go yall pgndty Le ghiy Ut pated) y Laaagall Sole ol paall of Cus plall pUbill Aa Aauagall Cals Leste Gilad ang yuSe Hie 5 aaa Ay yal oh Alaa gp aad Ald og} Mila! cpgitlla gd aeaben Gane (gill Gil EF iol) Ope pina pa Ayia Ash Land ile yaaa sins La Soll cay Lea lal Gunalle le lial Say CSep yt nd yi dn eng sSNA > Gy Seg US gil sal Sy Lead Cyslany sll IS ll ol yt le tes sal 2S p35 gall Cando fpgie 29h JS Annd tl by il Cn sSd fee: Meola cy ll Ye soled tla shally canal aay SUL © Byind Sig) 1 ce cote alah DE Ge ol pill Ha Gili Ge ell pee Aaa) Gaal LS Kaigall A Ge BST 10 Gio pele 40 Gila (Hullo lad ss y tls Fins) 10 gl (Aaatd Nes Nyald al abeall oda gle cpalalell clay c5.ae cadayy He Gf abt Yy lel gh 8 eB 1st! ce Lseefall ol yh Ci patil Galen pel | bs ol paally Leall Lassally coll o sal iy GAM Glare pied sf Aeuagally Uillaall UI jhe clyieliS ciate gf cll Alla suis AMG ye Ale Aeuagal apa) had) JSS Ady ght 054d cb Jay y DLaall gyled gle eanpe aul ead GES gle tia 6 sah Race ll gd Go sLalyl He gL Gf coll Gute judy cauull 4 SAY TU sad g Liha y Lally yy LS gall a asaally odd Le Hag cL Gundy J HS gf Langella o 5m Crslalal ells Cape rd BOE Bagh Ge pay duane All Gye g sill Lhe Lisl 5 el yrall (Sey Sayan aged sara Le sSall pit Coal 1g) Gy sagas JUGS) ~ /L jG Sy gall dh peal Ay lal AS gall Lal Ge iy Sale gly Ue anes ju lash ght (ha col all hy 508 Quill wy! gy pend col gb og sled lip olf Alaall 3 a) ob BY cluael 4S je Gf stirs). Ha gilt gill Coleus all Cualiy Pama ally ce s4ill $1 age Lis cll sa5y af Angell 45Le }, Betiahar Rabah, Documentation sur la privatisation, In revue algérienne de comptabilté et daudite, N:°02, SNC, Alger ,2Trimestre, 1994, P.34, i 11997 pL yen Gone Lanaly SAS AIS gh ME Aah oc 2 A He! PAIL Lig Yaa Qe eaten Span 50 -49..30 2 18 “Ol. ye 83 Gen gos be gin? -48-Gal) clea) gai Jail ls 46a Jaa yl 3H! dual a He Ts Ma AIS Leds Ay is yl oy Spend DDS ce alld Lesh cglany gil anal JS Rana pall JLab dasan ol yds Lal Fill cQsaalel yy Futall p45 9S of jl AutLall GI Saad Ab | yi allby daY dish Gad Gle Bb Sy eat pl ey AS le ES y WAM IMT Ge pall Agta og «14 gil (Employée Stock Ownership Plan) (ESOP) peo‘) o1 3 Ja publ GMb Cage pple cob Leal deals Ales gail Cara gal pl ant La (CM) chase pany ae cabal at gael 5 Cael gaan Qu pte: AS AN MU Meee ellis ceamay LS Ay pall Gila Jab Gal WY Ge gas! al le aa + HWSO she Aap cll a9 Gye (p4es al ol p2I ganedal) Gulalell Gyrinal Yiu f Nga Pah fatal pga Ge aly cll (CLM) cakes 5g) Gye Laay ll 4g clgule Jaasd il) ssa LYN 4 ARLE Oe clay! Jia Sh nals Lesnn'sall Slantl ol cys pital pt yt — /3 pale «Holding» dans 45 po 35S) lanl) eo gb cps pile Gy paall ps Md, phil Bile le 9S wa dash gal YN DDS Go edge 0 ee Sl eallgals ele Ne Legh as gall Mg cya IS gb ygh Sagi ahaa y Leaas pall aI) ol pth Aczalall 4S cll oka 3 asi anes Acaglll AS tll ogi Gf gle hace sill SI yaih l! ot Aiea Le caulitly coy tall oll ASL gg yi DRY He, Asay Ane si Lol ual pill Ciba sall (Leveraged Buy Outs) (LBO) vay i) Used! el til Asasally Alaall 5 ll gle AebinD ay cael 13a Gosh Goad lilly 5 Asin (5 yuu Lace gall sighs 8 ypS dna J elena Uja 5 Jay elaacl y Slanll Spell! gy 3! AS bbe Gabe Ge Arana yl) il y sland! Citllay gle Sslia J Her eee esr ee ear er or 2 Aaa 5 Gap all CLP 5 Que sills aqagd cll all Stas} 4 Leal eres 3 rae Sone pl Ga oxS ELLE te SLI s20ll quasi Gane : SCAMGUD Ae Sah pa yes Y Aaepall Saal! elles 5 DBs OS y EDs po Lely Slaallé dy ghll gad le dagall Lary 9 9 peas BSL) GM gad Le Nay ele Ge A day Ley Lata pa ahead Aina : inet Al] Label SLeciYl cya Syn Gf Cun tena gSlh Ala yal gules aul Cus .7 spelee Gealin Gal ates ye Ss pa pick Sled) je Aancal y dae lee df gay ab G gull 3 sls se Gd All Sil yaks Lad baal ak Gf gd ict Ute Ud cael SS 4 Joy Gli) MSS] Guay AB Lae ba yas SUEY 5 egal g Gr gail y @HYI Bb SiN LL LY pang AN GL WU lod gh EAI cay gk py? 1Tac0 1993 casa hd aad By pl Lapel 9s oh ual egal Spy yoh OptSt 1B Ole 0 53 ne gm re as gan? -49-Gout) sti} gai gail NLS Zsa bad pic Sah dani se Ee PSM gb glad Rigs Ugh Asana ll ah gl Cas gla gi Ha LN Sd Cais Ga tall gf LS DAN le Ly Gn yAF Oy pines cl Lael Ge LELSbe ital gal Lea Ghaapall Ge Raga LB ghd Al Age Gay chen (ye Lie pgiille sg! pelted AS y Sleall Gajb Gy 3 yttiuull Arana 98 Gali ye MAE AMS (6b UE) ggg eg) Lyn yd Gd sluc ge Leal) say gts yogi Maia 5g (gala by 2 28 edi Ghuagall oo Hi yb lbs alls Sagal) lps Gb Ail 44 yeall ull aj 3 aus A lasts 5 3 jfisus uilade Ue ya de gone © eclyill ya al FRY! ABU uate Sle dale yy al Gad 4 pe} Cilbty USI alge lal oda G3 Gf Gael egal Gel 9 Mebias Se il CLM qo) BUBB oN) 59 iS called 224) laa!) Ltt pal oar Go gyn Lema gy ay Le gf Goldll g Ubaill ll Joy JE Gull 0s Vala Qty aby clad ll Aclall 451d) Gad Y la gli) Yaladd ducal Ulead) duane yi Ry gia il 5 Laagal Dals y AS solely qe Atay Ma yo ane gAll Ge & sil A aL IBA cya gle Cased) Cy 7elguSle JE Gay ge Ypnero ss Asal! ull any init on tal op il Lipa gaall AUG a an ogth paul ell Laue dae gue gi Mel ak gl Lala) Laagall gue alba gh Lege Aa Sia y amagall gle Any pied og AI apie 4g gel ya 8S asic Uple Hl Gane Gob ge Geld! phil Ge gah JI yg siee sla by SUA ale Casag O Uelay pana Guns i} sags — Anan yes pha al ySl ctl cylelehad aly gall Gap Led Ui yp sie oy gh OR kal fg Maly fane aya gly Pe SY! Na Giga Gye Label Renal juny iS Ge ae hs Fy Aenea Ayla lal) GG jb ital 95 abel Ha 3 jue hath y bay yl ha CNY ssi a Y Saas la gd Lala Paty yh! He Ae gale cua ged atl atin Gols senall oll Gibel aday AD sall pg ula! Ha ley Xam all ci phe Gye ca col ASW! Ap ally gal N GUY! oy Ae Cad Le ann DAY puna gle All 4) Feed Lae gy DL UY! 849 ape Yikes Ga A gall J ja) Qe aaa pall Gad) git Gs Nala] de A gall plan AAMC Ae gl) yo Mi LN ol ith ody Lgl jhLaall Geass S.CUAWI Gilady Le jhe Gal Gall jpalld Aula lanrall op) faa Gis LS «AS jl Alay SEAL Ug) casey al gall Js dya.y Goa gunaill ayia Apa 5 ally SBN hy WISP SIAN Gueal le Upeaall by og Ja) ayuaill USte Ja Ge Weise al OF ppp age DUA Ge CS ola plaid y GURS oh pall dus '. Bettahar Rabah, Op.Cit, P. 36. 2 Gliz Abdelkader, Op.Cit,, P34. ». tbidem, P35. 4 Bettahar Rabah, La privatisation *.Bouinin .O, Michalet Ca, Op Ci °.Bettahar Rabah, Documentatio Opi, P36 P.149. a privatisation, Op.Cit, P.36, Te cn 83 i aoe ala cm las Gals 7Got sett} gad Jyaill Aalis Austad) baad (i yall ISM! dual —— fe Sleds lal! ASL y Roll 5 Yi dial yo} Gd Leake GS Lege 3 fall asad Sy GAD GUY 5. AS pA Gilsbec Ge Leal jilud ool Algal! enti Cua sblaall ants Y A yall La go SYN The cial galuany eI ge sill Gad) QU Glad 3 )DU Gace sed pls AD Gye os Gall could hae Aisa 5 hy Soli 5 5 teal Sty Gf cans Lemme gill Gye SSM Le gd Sheiall 5 sly 2 aah gina Uebe Bgm pall Gila gl a oat SI Uy vUgiane 96 al yl) Lal BN ES) SG lal 5 CUED ane Leugall oda Gl) aay Oi} ged cb ge Uta Nha GLetbhill , i oy ell ha Geb Say US Nasal y dala lee ogi a gia oda ia y “GAY! Apleidyh : Je — Arner hg Cem cal gil y Gepsleniiyl cubabetad aah y yal oye Wl LauY ates ay Cay LAY G52 Uaasaads (Sy Alle Allee plies Sates Usha} 8 iil yal gill dueger yea pusls Sey Bay tall loa) tal Aal6 easy jaa of pies Ha DAY dass Use 9 abatiS AL Ay eal Laas Y Sled GJ Cue 5 9 agi AS SA AS. Ye AA Ysa) QL GE ys yall yaa) pass ll UG gus Gay Dg g geal ily ple Be Spall jbl Goo ill 94s gia JAD le yaa ullis, Pad gd pale Lee 3 yghie Ia) y A Clee los seal ay LS agg SY) Ala YAMS ON ga sini Aas pall Loa JH Aa) GIy Geli Ga 5ST Aa yay AS 3 peal oS AS Sige Uf Ayal ga Safleiad Laka 2 520 gal Gad Upucl 4SLd dasa deeay “geal 5 fd DIS UG Util le Gaal le Ud any gill antl Gye 3ST J yell SMe cally ll aos ad ually BLY! agi Gan Lis el ya! a 1) ila oly Aaaall bar Ge Ale Ly juae gf SSVI agate Gants Y SLY agi Gio Arades ALIS esti bls ast salud! Gb palit age GAL sla Lu Bud de pd Ula i ta ly! dad gy Cam Lemna gl) Je La sall gh Gulab le oly pi Y jalaull pall oie Gio dace Ld aos pal Dla Ua juss gl all Ubeall le elisyl gb AUS A pal al Salle) Jlaall Ga Gall Qa 3 Jay TOY 4g Ulead Lgl pny ala LeU puol unatt (gd ALAS 2 pat A jal Saal yer yee BJoYT Gills Gls sJoYl agi gi Ll cya DU Aneel a9 5g sual Amen gS) Gala lily LI GY Say! agie y sai) ayie PLAY 5 LAL Reefer Ale Lema gS yg) pains ll NOY! y All 1 a Lae psy FAs ASU ae gs Uyeda SY CLAN ul Ged '. Gliz. Abdelkader, Op.Cit,, P.34, *, Bouinin .O, Michalet Ca, Op.Cit,, P.147. AD. spe 0383 Ge mye WSalally IAD CAS MSL fie Mle Hanns sgn ayaa 2 24 ~ Olan a 83 ee np CLAD uae las Git). 18 OL ge gan 83 Ge gaye ale gap -51-Ggath saat gad dyall Uys Asta al gf sil JS) Quail a a ccna oda Ale aya ghd A lh agS ogy gh nla ob Ge Raul tye oI glne ileal alld el yy (9s af als Naigget Kinga Saale sae! Sal ye Gurgbal plasind lily ay ye pub Aamege 2 SUS of Li je Wisi Lee gil step ASG dene sill by 3 ALadaN Clase hell Ag pode Ge CRS Y eel 5 829 agie of a BURY) puat S S SS ged 8 Joy ayia Laat UI oc yall ll saul iS YB eal sie dy ails Ayhaaal AALS sal giall CLV! fb Aad gual) LH ag Gh pithy AIM aL Zana gall leo etal LagSall Cpe qe AG Jal asic Gygh ye Lowagill of ud l Ailes} GIS sRaaeaSall uals sale Y AMLall 2) yl) Ge ay jal PD Ba Oke Gyo Si Cos 5 JY 4g pealll ade Giyk Ge Lereyill She clail Za pall BM Syngl 1: Pia ht gl 98 950M eed) GU YI NS, « alana Adaisell snd) OU Sela cles gl Sly jay! ade =/4 BoM oSgd qa Lea Luald Aeaage city Aatall Aeaagall la shioly Aga) cus 13s gow EG Leniey tel gill ubilell Gad chad J pyury gla cilia geal yan: Dita S52 cpl sagtiaall Aga) GH ye shilly Gut Gia Usat luli «Franchising» | juiq| Ua Naud CAGED) I ALoYL: poltll Colinal ge US GLGAYI se Gaataty ty Lola «Lay 5. Fil sie pla cUadll i Spell an. siy «5 LLY! Galie ile ole aii al) AM d gh LM Ge Ay hanall din SUYN canlen J gd Mis ph od¢l dagt I tad OS gtd Ge 8S dal ss cull pailly Gy Ayal gle TNL Le Gye iy Lee CH Lay WSgh cogiall yo g gill Via Leal gill CLAD jis) ppl 11S Gy patie sled ob Sly yene HY Adaslss (gi ase po stall 98s Lead oad A CLAN gale at GSI aalsd ACUI Auaagall ge gla Ge SY # Seal gall gabaleiall gal Guile $ Shady Aaa Din gle 3 pall aed cy etinns alla angy Y GSI Aaaeapall gus ans Hise SS Gila JSS gi Satay Litle athe daapall Glace alli a so sags cated be UEeYl agic Gantt y pak, be ede es ad yea Tk PAP POE RIPEN IS pe eh Ig Fad base Sle y phe yagi GUiAY) Nae Garis plall ¢ Lill ll «Operater Us—tiy «Build» ols 4543 ols LLY Na cod AnaLll & Silly (pala! a le cc Sall sf plall GUL 45 la}, vel dss I ated Ge GIS Aged an g spe pet aeall Lal aly ala sins ad ip AMIS 3 fd any Le gSall og 8 350 «Transfer al yo5 2 pile ale aes Guindy *. Bettahar Rabah:« Documentation sur la privatisation », Op.Cit, P.37. J AH LY BOT heya eo Rey Seley Ae ge as gle hae sane le. 632.40 2001/2000 «4p S91 gaa -52-gull deat gai J saill Ais Mtl Lead 44 sist) s¥) Sait —————S Aap pL gag cpa! is) Cilide Gb Vp Leena Sl Caltisd SSI Gye Ca gLul Nha any Aa Li Cle gy Lang gb Quy GU le ptdtiny Up JN) CI LAL Gas eee Ulaally «5 gacall 6h Sh col SW eC LASY colpall Glan tSia tae Satay € sl gh Calelall 9 igs YS ytd of aad Nha Gage aw Gay Gott le Littell § pyall Gyo jattinal Say Yl juan Gye ail YY a gSall 4s GAS aie. vide gle ke GULY! U yal elie} Guile a 4 7 il is — fas — pti" RNS 9 Came & spe Blas clay oly ppd LAS 52 aig Sa) ISS AL) Gall Bs elle 43 8 1g 5 pal Ge liS gle Melia) (6b palg aah agli Hin Cl juan Guay AagSall inge- ce ta playa! ye Latah Sab gi) pdteall Ge Syed pe Gn Oe Ll dill Evid tala Uni Uy Sing LBL Ag SN pURil paul! ~/5 Le $8 Gale Uhl Cian y glad He sill Ra} asl Aone gl) Gallul Ga tact gt oh Gey adie ge Quang Giagy pla g Uhl lauaipe Les p git Uatil y 5 Sell 4a gta Gl gall 9 Ap il ASL Ga Oe Gat I asl ga Gala ull 4 Sy 2a a iin 1 opal Uni clan y Guana ¢ pial) ISNT Ss GUY glad Ua 99 Qengy Cums galeeiYh (Ua) dele pity ANS Uald Qu jl Gye Alagle 3 fll Cyc y J asset) G99 Gatall EU UY oy Haag clin 9S glad! EU 559 UeLintsy Galil! Tigola J dala oltudl 45k. Fala Laas Cyany 4h a Salt pai of Say WE Lig yh CTs Uys Ay Arena gia sf deage ee Lao Dall Goals gla yeti) ADL eae Sie Gan yas QsLell JS cya JE » ely ojledl be dS ching YL Glad PUeK ce alsa gl al yall le Speaall gal deena yall Ge Leal al ga) Ging of CS ASOD Of Sp etn att EU oo JY y GLAD eG gf plall Lal G3 Gil Spied shal le fs pha Aalenny lS 5 Sad le gel Leta Malas gue Coal (nanny A gill ¢ 5 pall denen 6 gele col itis past ghd yd Ls OB the (gf rela avadiall dy fly alls y55 Yaga oh 9 SLs Gt Fe HN Gg phat Ugall Glin gall 6 y glial Ny Gu Coal placid 5 be disc A lag Malady CUI yh IB Gd Aol, ali aS ph Gig ual elBLY, ait Ald a ld he chad! ¢ Ubi Utialy Gola! EUaall Lau, 5 Golly alll Que Ubill Ga AS ll Gases y alilly plall Guethil gu 451 2 eisai gl celal) CULM peal fal gf Lela) CsleaSl) Quen dl Heal Gad sae SSA 4 lads gas gy ye 49 AT 50 0 2001 sre AO ne aay pl ge aly all yell oy 451520 oy a GL! -53-Gye ea) gai Jyaill Alls Asta bad 4 ll Saat) J gail 5 t Aaa Clas AI) aad Jpneity dob ead al dyghe bey Sac gy pte ate py Cs Die gay lal EU Gf yy pally pall Quota) Ow 45) 52 a gs pa (GB) Notas ola jig ge B8yal A yjudl anny glad jyeaall ge Lig Glas) aS Ny Sary Shit CLM pul gle Gall) y pl Gyetbill Gy 45 lta Gay Es DS Ge Sey sll Liban Gye coy cotta et sl cle this Ge sl Algo Cle g pe 7 JAM (ys Lest Call (gle Jyuenll 5 Auta cl Lauay PAUaMe CAS ys ol Ladatl Cua’ J/g Ray ML a subg gk Ati CS 5 lt Lala Gleagall agate Glad Gf BAAS Si ls MNS y Gull Saye yes AAS Hey yal they 5 Alaa gt At Leal egal Guall 65 Lua ode Ba gd pa Sal ileal SI tae oly al yall Gx pall Ugall ASL Ges pada le Gly IB AS 5 Ge Fhe Si elk gle lage 5 bagd gate ly Lene all Still Gala LS Fans Se Qe ala! thee ed pein LLYN Ge Lei Cana JAY al Gye GES Gy Clajall oda 3h cote kindy sync Gi ola 359 ged (Gaal J Gilad) Gala) Qu yd Ya home Reaaiall Alla’ Om Gel 9 ol cue oa ASA a gata 58 Sa LU ge Ly DE CH sail) GA 5 gl gh y Aeeaha eth hs Abbas US 5 I alall Claagall dugad © 1994 Lassa bo et YAS Ch ll 4 SV Aad gas Ol Sy eye tbh yds gle WLytll ys fualally plall Asileall AN ypeeal plall ¢ Ubi Latins Cony Golal 4 plall EUbill Gy agsall gle Yass ala) Glas yi 5 gb pales og ti Liga 9 Ace ot) cid gee eal lead Ly A 4g Bade spe bee Cad lal EULA ol) pall GUL Go pail Sac Gf SBS A Leola I AE Yy cg fa BS EN gall je Nad Oy pS Lagay ct S| gb ASSL Lal pall di yee NS clgace ed ab AI) i gall te wall (gle ye Gees lect a DU iy HN Rags le eal) Jil, Leis Jail! : ASU SRE Gog caedd ts) (9h Lasetall al geld 28g sil . Vedaaat Cony ll till dip hl ya SEY coh SLY ib Ald UHL hl) Ga e any Ge Hg AL egal) Me gD MaRS Cally Goel gue GLASY y ALLL Sule “esas Ge algal Ge ayaa Se era cg sles eae! M9 87s ua 6 SS bee os Oa yen ys ies? tna apa le AS jen AMS » ym ae oh gga AQ yaa ga gta gl gc ua? 22-01. a.2002/05/ 28 =18 la 209M) eal 63-65.y0 30 4 5 See ony sgn agen! -54-yu) suai gai Jgaill Ais Astalt dead Gb sitll JS3! ducal fa A Arce gl) ali yy (ye Le gSalt cilasi =/1 Cy fi nee BIL 5 ght sy 9Sy ab Arne gill Auber Gye Me pie g 5S Cilaal Ud de ySalls Hac 5ah5 Weloe 5S By ALjal evel DE Gye Bint Hay Label) Clea pall eld gos Ueioe GIS 1S) Lil bat Gan 8 leas Ge Ya) Aes Igeal Que ook Ge ul Gia se alll cyl Gb Ge Clu awe canes gill alin geal y SRS (ye Ald y Le sSall Cilaal Ge yall ce ALallys «lise pga yyy pall GY gh le Mala Lagall posh ISA fy Ugeganly Qala pip 9 ayn Ay pe CIS Lead CIS 3M ne gl) bt Chee yas WL dl aly Sp gd pled Nested ase ply Cue clgieane gs Byte Ge GS aed Laing Lee cot YF Uap Quad ANd AaSSN) Gb Ga Daly AS lan Laagall SIS sla AGS Ugegel Cp AS ey ob Aetna CAS pl Qi Uh i an a tale pt US Mgasy Say Y CGayeecall lta ly Sead (gILall AY Culd Halal Gla palld style Mintel Oth pally Aenaall Opt Gand LeySall (Say Ugly sale Feaaa'yall hil 6 ill ¢ Ui —/4 lia Capa Leen 9S) yuilld Ign yd bee gi Meal ais gall LL & 5 USS ey Ly Shit! Agia GLY coll! Gall oly ygSNS ala GLaaall gf Sask) Spine clio slot yo ulldy Ugale 415 ly Lia) Gok) Ug Lol) dealin agi slg Asta) Lthatl 3) pull 3 oh -/5 Cs ign Gps Sathana oye CIS 13] Le a8 ie liS Hp ya VIS 5 Mall GB gall ght os ghee hg Lie OSs ob 1 Leal egal OS Y pee plall ¢ ghll 4a yh had Aone Sl G gb Sa a Ss lay hed el al gd Gasel M Oy patina Ga guS ase aay Vy peal Quist Dec Ai st ga lad I cuba cy ptiaa Gall Ag eilld ALM JE Boh y Gallad ss! le fyi Seley! opllly Gulu GI Lae YU Saal ye GS acliia| y Aealee Cob yea JE) oF Lalall Claall Gye apna he Ala ALAN ELA cya ase The Gal jp Cibaagall oe 5 55 DI (ye Latins Clade cl} gail Senay A cial Una ol} Ha gS pgaal ASLe Uo ya Segall G6 9s Gell Gua ales he Sal Remwe gS U5 cathy plall cpl ll geal y con pel Adeay ali 4S le Reena gill Ales ci ges iepllll 6 io 0 Vein 5) HTS ene gS alee Mega ab Clr yenall Ge ayaa poly) Gu jut cL aes A ULE Oe ila Lee ll Gilad pie i Line BIS Sy cs sh GI} Uys regllagd il yall ola Gls] Say tyghlad Siciy Muclaial cilia —/i iY Ge wi I eal gab deal ge Gut sue 5545 Caney Alle Uli a jlea ] ala Ua of ye Saal ye assed) go pach Leola GCL Gl Label Cite y ya SL -55-Goad set) gai J sail Ufis Acta bas 8 ppl dg! dual Fn cc Leal hsp tthe Leal Gog old galls 4 adlal ily city tay) GyLY jai ‘hanes 9 Aelia! JSUte GIS Gl gaye chin ay syd Meee gill AS pa) GLijeall Ji Ypallias 5 Abell de gapall JS .2 Fite Sagal 4 petals petals ob 3850 9 pelsSo y ppalloon BLE! 5 Cle pan Cate ae tabla 4 suai ch gue -/o DAM oS Lee beastly abel le CULY alist tly 48) pall 6 jail) Gali] fala gh pall ¢Unill i ol yuc OIS pill le pill sy 2 ii yall pats ewe gill hee od Lage Ijuaic: pull JS) tue pull Ate 2 beads coll HB Uatiall oby gas SI pall Calan lol yk Ge pa peels Deas 5 ci pdtinall Asal ell slag) old gly Hay jal Aad adh CSA uals glad oll ayy Ul Raowe sill She clad ald due JS ol eh al Leal peal ges Ula ob Gil Lema ydll Lins jpal dali 3 Aland yy AG Alte hi Ling Ayeeall dbeally COLL St Cue gia) Jad I Agha! ADa ¢ jail allel diggs Cong) Gell ear y 8) aby Lee Seanad J al iY) jLatay ld den 9S Ciliseall pal JSty Goldl 2YI paw Galil Arena gill Agee Jy Y gSl 300) cas lilly 5 gay ol all Label dasa! of al ale agin Dhaadl Y y ABW oy 8545 555 ol spl oe Ay uk Nee ae gill ASM yada CAS IN pine ee ld yall cy yall Uist 5 SCL Ha gi cl yill 552) Uginllan Aad! BSN USS gil gala! yy pail Aubee selec 3 ysheie Ulle Goue agmy ge 6 Cfite Hyaytne y Gest 8 uly Jal Guan gi Magia gala Ca! gal yl eh ts Fe Baan Ae ila pd RAY ssi hss g gales hall ald Sts LowasSll Shee clail AS All age Cuans el IME tS pl Gyan y pall Gaile Ge Gil st Gay ill .7 9 5b ey GEG AS A Gy ey uy ne Gy fd PAs aks oy I mal og and Alin os 8 AS ph angi hd CAS ll Guay Chl DLN GE Cah sll 8 fehl Cy duds Lily Spel Aad Oe Siadll y gull y Ga jlidl lel yal GS a CYL Gn dla 9 eh ese Se ol gall EAE Cl ye apn ys any oF Lee tall Cale. Ge LS fall ble Gis Ayal 1159 “150.40 Ga 0 5 Se eng dae ey! ABT ya 385 Se ga SN ae Gaal 4.98 dad. -56-gull sect) gai Jail Alls Aystati baad of SY) Jaci a MM pyghall Al gh Sate] AMSG Gh AEG g Rw gS laa) 5 pS AlLal) ast. 0 ILS (ys AUS y lathell Gyo aS ojo cllyiad 5 yl thy pane «Jlaall Ghia gad call Anawo ysl 9 AAs eas Uta can g Una Slaaage GOS CHE Sf fall pia ETT sed Cas ye Bilge Keane sll Ais Glad ans Ally Gli. dlLeall gaa y cual dad ALY 5 Lolth call pall Hel je Qe pena gd al pall Clauagall fos ag ad a Riad wale Se] thay Lae ns pall UG gN Gye La gE Laisa yy pally geting Lele Leap Gosh lll Glad aay Ae diy pod An SD AS jal) cle BM INSP 4g Aeewa,gSll Alec i Sige inate Miles Ctliyene 2 $Cilical gall gle gud GUD apay prey Gaal 2H Cilb gall Lam lee ooh 36 y JS 5 O98 gle gH A Falla 4 oy Haene yl 5 Si) Gun itall Fa jal) plan 5 ye Carlin HLL: Target Uglal yo ose y Acne sll bLec Jala asd 4 wCiledual Guiles pac y 3 Recueil) Clad bay yh 20 gl EY Le jy Gla pall laf ciate Gd By cally Gana Y Aalell Shall gf ag oh Y Les Pegs creat 2 isco wala id cl a 9 yaad AG BLL pga ual Ws laf y Yulorel du jles dis gh le ce aL CAD 9 let! Cal dye Ga oS MH gat Wanna ld pepe Spl DU) Hy Ae game ag clbty Vl Oli Ugilaal Guindy Loreal She clei Glas! y Wie Yas ual HS she yl oe ab yaa, GEASS oo a tyid Vee pane ood 9S Cla giall cya Gis egg LS IS Gn I uel Yl Guslety) olS 2 geal CYL clad 2 AVIS elit ay pall Gye de gene cad pe CLAY Fas pee celal J sll ghia fl Gulu! saball ¢ LH] de 5 a) 1 ABI LAY! 5 lait gd y Lethal 5 Aubadll og) dp yall nN) tet Gllsy 5A Naas Bes papas LY ges of ca US aif) Degli Qe all OLA Pepe cybeletall 4 Leith} Ging AVL dgieal) Laue gall Saal Rath Cea) Ne hey pecan (CU) Gas Ja gi La glia gle 3 pul gan 2 Sy OL AL cpgatth $35 le Gasman gh pedis Ossian Le coill Cuil yall cere Chey) coe ad Y Guay Clagiall ode Spal gd Uily Gatty Gf Gay duece gill Ge sepa Ale gi Lat lenally HLabal gl Lal Sikeegll ode Gey bated cg sil Come ae Leet Ge Seeing BGs ole el cian y Uncle Coan gh $ See 184 “LID 0 936 Si ca i ne al Sie | Apel soilly Lae SD hse » ye gly ill Apheitly Seleg Yi Oly Lae gill Ye CNEL yt pte Gy. 2 Ol 0 2004 i 07/03 sts Haale Ca panvsecan halon 149 148 0 85 Ga ne att gh? -57-Gguall abe) gai J gail Ayfls Asta daa 4 ict) J) Saat _ ey Jeyt shall Aall G yull of ld «cea! Aalae AS ya 5 ype Ale Gye omy 3 SY ADU 3g all Gell EUbill ele ys Asleall ode Uuguil Guetta jleall y Halal Cle all GB jay Dd all cipal Qualia Sad GAS Gye oy Y Ugdlaal Sint y Levessll cat 4 Negi Sin 1 Aj) US A Sin Yh Label! Lea gall USL aN IIS haul Nba Gd gin CSheals lll Ging Cus Saal Gu y lea yas 5 9) a} y aye auses Gi SI Aya etbel 5 peal dale Gault y 4 Noy! allel Sl Ged efi ll LLY cde le Calblh-y i alg US sy Wig ela ally chill pry Gaye i Madly lt cand I bla ge cad Ga 6 Sal gS Cantal 5 Guay yall i aad dle GS ob pay Ga ill Se aed coll As gH) iL olla Sa gle Ge sal bye aah down gS Gls .7 foal (Sa YY pl [Gayl Jats Y ida Galil e Ubi) Sia) Gigs & FEMS yh bad gf IS 2 ye Fe yore Al yo Cand Ula Cilaasall ¢ shy Pe ce Gall Gok Ge ile Laehe JS Meola all Qe ace gil sis ane gS 5a. y0 fue usb Filia Myo 1 DU Appell Gad yas 8 fogllaly gaitll Ua yy 9 Schall Gok Ge Sjery shliall Ys lb Lee ¢ pun yj Leen sill cilaal ass 10 Soest gt oaay Soli lee GsSoy Leal Label cle y all Cyy MiSs Ges odd II fcilauasall Say Clad Wada ety nadia Gane JS Lge poy Aree gills dain Cilmefall tliat) anit ol yal 12 oY Ble yas p80 (Say Aa gall da yaks aS y Aaa y Lally! og laa lily JAM Aailiall ye Salta! Chags Leela! 2 gill ine i als digs INE Ly Legal jul Die Apsley 12001 «th ty a easly pill Sy yN 9 yl VI Aah shay ey ry) cal vighe ly Gand se. | Blue -58-Goal slat) gai J gsc Aulis sal bead 4d stat) gM) act ———— eee Atal) Stal Jualtt sats Asi pdt) za) consall Bal plies Sue Gh ALN 4g ysl Goh y Gal ary poled galacti! Ghidl gf Gl saleaBYl gail yale Glalaree atesyt g allel egy hall 4S) 2 ya US iad ale Bee le 3S f sup Lala cleale Jal! las Bac pt Gy Aylay ee allall fay alae Gus Vogt gl Raley CH shell Ge CULE Alay ge ASI 20) gl ad Les full Gye Ce Sa ft GS tll ge Hy Sb AILS ta hs Oe peed Cun of alia Gl ye olla GRY cali se JURY Sik ya aga je LS lad SB Ge peley Glas Ligalas danse y agp IS 3 ASI ll p gga ayant pi saat) Ha Gay call ty Guin he i Sap A EVI lysis Qo BLA oLgadh 93.¢ AS) pa gee 255 2) cuillaall Ps hat gale) eainall le Aus ye 5 ple J ppll Barly Cuad Gy slaill 3S on AS) Att fae Gf YY Ssall AlaLsall 5 4S fuel alloall faye gle Loslacy 1 bs doles “ SVN CA gill ob YY plainly as ol deci yy ghtll acl fiulS AaleaiY Shaul cot Leahy Saute wtb Cul ASI ptlle aby) Lagall gh Qf Luckal te, coal Lect Ud Legal Gest Sel hall Ge Usa gf Bsa 81) GLAS coast clad clits tel) «Michel Crozier sé cuss ts jee! an GI Spall shail ok cial 7 gel Coetal Caaes gk Lali] TES nena gb isla Lenaall aad Sulla Sl Sal Gg ASI cI Foxy SLi) Maly Lal ola (gd Leap) aan dang Solely cand tule ALAN y Cael 2 i sauaall 9 GLY jail dae Sl fue) Geist dal Ow Lens fad LS Ge Syke KIA GS LS sqglgll WS 5 goo shal gS Lyall ech na Atal all yall dea S 555 2S gtll oly Gaal gy LS AAS Ge g 98) Gel jie AS) 2) a gga JQ Ei + USE tl se Ge pad Call GDGALy as) Sy ASI 2) Cubed 5 928 Gis lh Sip sla pal apie plbey salccBYl Jalil Lebar Ge pany gglall JIS ll lie Syn.yy 3f Asad Aa Wa birdy Ga p65 AS yy gh) LS JOY fe guage Uesije Meggelan Lae gi kanal) y Qos 9 AS ful) aay Jaa gah 6 Ul ji sAetinall cles tall Go ASI J asl cll ghey 3sl sl) ash Ow Stil Ge tyke USL 2 cat Lg gala JalS yu LDL dg ys Gilad dbuny Lied UA yt I Ge 15) '. J.Claude Ruano-Borbalan, Partenariat clé de réussite américaine, Science humaines hors série, N:°20, Pars, Mars-Avril 1998, PP.66-70. 2. Michel Gervais, Stratégie de lentreprise, 4% Edition, Edition Economica, Pars, 1995, P.199, , Encyclopédie du management, Tome2, Edition Vuibert, Paris, P. 769. -59-gall alec) gi J gacll Aulls AysLall Jaad 8 ict SSI acail ae 4 ll baby at bY Glad aye Dude y Hale Alseey iss call Weiner an sy 7 "Gl LI wig) skis les Gudady Wl Aalyl Fee Gee Stl allel as Gilad de Rly 45 puted ADL all Ga ASI 23 2B EE LL HI geal 8 Zee Ge Gob JS Ghaalee y Gah gas aay aad gid 2208 gd Sil alt ala le pine Gbacegall Gur Gysheill JS Ga ISS Gs ASI 2 4 ecules) Silda J gall SAV gle ike WDLe day y Gla Glaaage 0 bl Gi gil Huold ADL! Lad gs A512 5 Lntail ak eps ga tle Case Ugly cApaball Lal) SDL Cal Usd 5 gl cb gla ileal on ee gail I a Sal os fall gle Sh sh ost ys Ow A AYN Gul le pai AS12116 AS ital AIEY afi of le «pacatll fl Aad Gad) Gal eV Gilat 5 aha 85 BAM cellh aga QL Gay canis) lead 2.500) jaattall Ge Cueaiy My Lanne a cihaal Gains gia IS ged Guns (Ql 4 th LL lg ype Oneal aud ell Shea pe 45 gape Gu bal ss ge aye ya Gilad .7 Lig: Ailsadl cotta le lines Lala gh Callas) G8 AS ial Glagall ia Mi gla Niqede GUS clea! Clap Done! ojb clan! cas gd Gly Gs 3 2 ph ASE] a ASI BIB BM Gayl ped] Gage lef Lac Ge aan pnt lg Gas AS) pl Ce Ging Chee og see aby I Gyall [SEIS HS Ska es Sis Gh ly aul Lasts (4 i Blas has geal Ga MY pans GS gl Lasley Vengo sna Asti SLeadl ol} Upbeat cpl ged Lil Hale S12 ein Las J) A AIL le: Gita ga Ltd) 4S of Sy old all gay PiDa Masia J Alyse gal wba Oy gf Sey US eC philly Can) Ayal a Load YAS) all Santelli Lal Gye pe th al og uals hel say) ll GL DE ga Lo Gail Gh sxe I Gui gh on Gabel gpl Ge G5 ASSAD GS Glo Layee GES Ansel 3) Sa go GS tall cep ll Gein cok JL Esl Glee Ge AS jit Gla Lia slte) GSe Y gall Aste Mi yk ghd Gls 145) 4 ual of) sjLtyl assy pred Heigl ag Gye oS AN dy (Sikes ney Ths yo Aba DLE Gl) yal ALAS Hate Gilad ele pelle Cpa aed Sal on UU) 4) aaa Cte gna FON 5a Ish cle AS fe Sal GLGSL BAY LEN ge LES plac y of il Sigg ey Let ga LM Ral AS ey all any yl SACD yn gal Lg ge jo Ma YE Spe gy Ml Sy 282 yl 09/08 widen Lana «ail pe Rn pl) AE oe M1 yD ASL Jay pnd AIS pd gaa 11 O10 goa 2004 gc. 2. Frangois Pradoux, Le partenariat client - founisseur dans Vindustrie, Le Cahier Du Collége Des Ingenicurs, Ne3, 1990, P.73, *. BGarette, P.Daussauge, Anticiper les conséquence des alliances stratégiques, Revue Francaise de gestion, "1 12.Juin-Aout 1997, P.106, RM hg Bind ANN ge DI gD gL ga UY eh say ASD SIS ae Gam on! «1S OL om 2002 ple 22/21 shal Raat ve A! -60-yal) steal gad Jyailt Alls 49a) aad ob tld ds) ail Ged Lag) tal he GSS Calladll y 45) palld AS sill gf Absa AAW Gacy 45,8 Aula gall segltll Jysall dacs LS olS 2 dale Cau Leas Gaby (sie B Garette, PDaussauge, Op Cit, P. 66, :suaah Cael) Op slat Dae G9 ob Sey (i) ile Ualll GOGAL SI tll a gga GS: Ale 5 I oa) ak Ay Ub 5 le GLAM Ne gag ASI gal goad call Gita YT DESL eH gall BU ool I Gall Luc fate dade el lal Gilay fl gaa GL ga 3S) EM Hag WS fake lad | yey Ha Md be gh iS J Lal cal y igh AS Ud CIS ol yas 5S) AS Lal poe Gh os Cue CY Gal J CMS Ga Lj BS hey SLAY! Oe Cased Id Hylan cal Gey Gy Gale SSA Go SSA ga 45129 Gf TY yl GS ells (gb Lapidus ef jhll ISI hin Cum Guns & 5 plier pli wad Upiluaia DSL) Nee deal 4g Weipa seal Sapte Cal hs Ud lea ASI pal dans fads sale) Sil a) LS hy shail oda Ge Gey Baal Lda i Canine Ay Wee i a Uy Sy pall oka ans dat 4 bi -| Ame SSH Ge Na GIBY! alge US Al jay Dik USL Gal Gl Aaa pal ASI yl UPUSLS Dp gh Saal 58! Splie) Gaja ae ASI CAST Di iad y Ls gle Ublin Aolaityl douagall of rel val) cautss 2 i —/2. ANS pai Hay UGGS Gl o Sal LUE Llda le dad Gf Cay Apleniyl Lao yl ste gg US GHEY ugk Gd pales gl Ct JS DY gy! 4d Fy shill ohn y AMY IS Ge Gyull Sia} Cle guns lta Gf cua role, Jy -, Qt LAY yy pay Gp NSal SSE Gd LY Shade Gy Gla ub g gle ake Sajal iad gb inte y 8p 5S ya aed geil galled aac Gd lal CYL Jocks gd Lol Male aed Ay aghill y Cand CALLE Ugde an Gy aly Slay! : Aap gS CA ght ga Uggla g AslenSY! Chagall hina gall Gag ASI aI Gt Ay Lah oS) Lids cilia) Lith sind g alsa CUI Ay ei -/4 Ab di bt Aan ad asS ol pay Lee Lalla gall Mig pa ASI pl OS gb PLS Lang) $65 520 Gay da by DLE SAI Aa AAI gg bl Ate aa ata le tly olga MIS ag fe pa gids ne! 08-01 = uo 2004 pi th 6 4a -61-Goal saci} ga J gail Aytls Zystal doa (9b ll JS Jaci Coll psi plans JA, Leal ul Ue) asl aay A815 GS Gi Qua om ch eclell 5 Ua gang ALE 0 AS) pl pl jad Gla aang galusifY Sa) a} LS Noy Mciall 9 ASI 520 Ugle a i AA gil Gigli Gla lan al AI 555 a Asleatiy! GDL rtustaatiyt elidel ~/1 fais te AA ol tied yo sual Gaba (AgU4l Fala) Saye GLudlin 5 59d ob gi seth A aly daa Clctall Ge slapllall pe CDE Bae yg sf dada Gsteil Gane Ullny Sl yall a sy Aaya lala AEE oh Len MT lls Gaggia y gure Sas seh junc gaglll Leal 3 DESY, ols LG ic il gM cy gles) asks) Capel! pea 2y gel g Jats -/2, ane lS all gal gle lod gd Lea silly 5S ig ye cle yeaa Jal ge ali i Haswell gi ila) JSLLal) Seat OS poe cpa) Glad nny hal CLs Sa fl) cas Ng gaa -/3 a ol Lees 9 Sy AS) aN aa gid a GD Cay Sane GI peal Gils SAS All gb Oe ashe Gj She gall Ghai gay 42959 y4 le Jyuaall gay aly sr S an ste al gh Sai ph Gy Vy Cpt yas shea = eal Cl teal le 5S sll ad an ay La Gey Ua sll el 3 daly g sila oe She aL Sl lS A pa of LoS cols ya Coli y ile. sie Ga clan Aste} Foal LAY Ah ISG ge Hylan Alay y itll G6liS y 260 8 ay Gena ARES 2h IS Cl ge pull Aig Alle GIS Gof Gla Clee Quan gh HC Sd pestis -/5 Gapll Ty sh J CU Hig UL gid gla aslo and US cSLdl ad aie 4 JLl vigs Hla Caen gh UE en ya any 0 9909 gill Al 2 Gi be a Ql eh RD Lym Cas Gye lS yp Label oh yl) On 653 9S Gl Gags 2 7 amend Cus Gay cy ol od lal AUIS Qa caaly @ gia J aaly Gy pba de LYS mahal Les gi egg Lib & 9 il a & SF yi Lag (LG ee pas CIS oA clone LADY Healy Dal 98 US Lauda Gao Se gua GL of gl DML gs te Jal Bondy SSI Haak gle as LS pS Cap ol 3 pe GIS LAS sil pe -/7 Sahl Chall Spay Spal gh @ Sal 799 jm ASL ye Gh (Sy Gall Oe Mpg Some All Leaasall an id LD yd a ob ASI jt GY! gan 3 wept Gy day iS) Meeead Call BS 53 9 Coys Le Sayan GDL G4 & 9) Cael ly ALA of ye YY) tl AS} Ga iez gil AISI Lhe «MLPorter» (ye Qala GML! «Robert Nee ails BD Aas Gad ally 30 Linge GSI § fins yt LIME CS a CY Gy AS) All Ge GUUS 5 AS tll ada gs Uy LY! Aa Saih Gi Saal jy Reich» OSU Ob lly auaiyy eagle Yan Mi yb gle ASI pH lana casbl ob Gus Vy eS pS Ad lal uel nl iS he gall 4s Gs ghaitly HDs 0 0585 Sm gee Sti gl. | *. B.Garette Et P.Daussauge, Op.Cit, P.62, -62-Sgt dail gai gail Alls Achat baal ob scl gil Geaill ————————— Se me Lae A512 vi ly cSt «Richard D'Avenin ish pai US Ne gal ch UGS) ins eS ytd sol Agi gb selad aby eg JS IS pot AS) pall of 5G Gol} WAS oY ga hay any aps Lay AS all lll) sind (od sed Y ASIA) Gl yy ped SAY Gb 5 lus ety Mail Sole gall Aasitial GLU Ay A) Ud Gb Os ey Vea! ASI Al gyal ESD) dae YY geal) Clasp Ueagts il) Hla Loy aay ass fad Shane of ILS ASI old Os DAW gle Gyshe le GUE gf GAS Geo pallan gan! Gd c puns oan YH pil Let Sina pa AS) yt) Qdga typi io pagans AILe gi Chau pall Ye cided Sliey Elia dais yet Up pall yo 451 pa) Lass ol Gs Nap AL igh angel Gully Lila 1d Gael ASI 2 ys Alay lies) CDS Hepltle Lede AS) yl) cpl Calas gall ya 585 o ga gl! ah Gitaa hy lad cgaleaty! GUL cals y Abts ol yall uae ood Alay! 4st ity! Ud ek Aaa gh Apabicctyh Coltbadll JVI pales) el yall y ell pt A yall Cosma cca geal ByaleniBY! 9 Apel Ay Al) le Aye OI yt ye alld Cle ay ogo gpl oll Sel} ay Cay celled cgaleecsy! pail Sy pry cztell cl gall salut! aUlaill 583 Sy p15 Andie NSD pin ae Rade Lang td 5 ete Ay by AS Cie oh Ugaadd ll Citta SH Rgid SAS lg go LARP 953 4p ol CH gl abe a DE hy AlN! Lgiteny pt EU Ciitbady GSI sah AUG SLES! Cf yas y equa) ULM Ge Galadlly Ubapeaid Lala 7AS1 pill Allan gai GUYS gh Leash y Lae GS Ggalaefl gaily Apacll Lane ob wd HW ail gall =) sa gt SLL S Ga Ayclinall Glob cle Cua obi! caked! SSLte lly avails gis galled Gl gat Jala 4 AN phy Lytle gine GH jas cg Jems dae gill galiaify! Gd Aaah MW had sleud Cosas! 1986 Liu sey Leols Ay fill. 40591 pla aye gill cig gna Ya ae Balin) y Ayame baal Ub) i geal gle ASI 20 Alias gpl Gf ulld wgaleeti¥! ial ud Aasels Fee Oe Aamagall gle oo yiy Lin gl yiSill aan 000) shill ta ob i aly Aalsa alls of 2 HB ll gua ge Sl La Hae cieg Ane castes sla y ysl Sey plan! s oe Cass} Le OSs LytleliS yy phy yas y sy Leila Gp yt Lacy) hea fell ESM Agata Shs gle hs ial cee LED Lailay Lege Unga Clay Hn y gt Qolall GaNSGl 4igall 28) yall bed og Lda Lago 15g) 8p ghaill LMA ode gle all gees a05 451 p20 ofS alla cc gall gall ae AS ag de ol SY Be peas 9 Gill plac Aeagall gm yy AIS Hay a endl Goes pp HR Glas 9 5 a aL YN Laaagall Gilad oy GST GIBYI Ne Gay cya rls Lad Ulloa! GS gill 5 Splat J poll go ners Fy alad Gaal sll gad all ody '. Richard D'veni, Hyper compétiton, Edition Vuibert, Paris, 1995, P. 357. 15 “Ol oe ge 85 See gore GI 0 al ov? -63-oul Seat gai Jal 4816 Uta oad ob pit si deat oN RNS policed 5 Hei Quo yy Gyull od bane clblis cla fl Gyull dijee @ SG) DDuGADL Ala fall 42,9 pul! PAMled JS 4 Leal ALLL Kaylee y dun tall Lp gl yiSil le peal © Rag JAD Rafal Cl Laiial i pSal y Sayap GULL Gb LALLY & ee Cin ila gam Da ia hs 5 any Aaa 0359) Spd aga,y lane le aed fell os sind fa Sa le gaan 5 Raatay CANS yall sla dya sl al ead Geng " Aye ALY! yy ghi sas’ Litas Lindtiall pal ya agi Ugtil JS plas) gl polio) Cihaufall adap Gd! ali Gy Hagel ye LgitSaly Spal ei) Cilaaupall yap SLaSYT y CrsLeill Alay ta Loe SI AI 4g Llyay CALAIS ode gal yey ety dl YD SS Gly YLTSAY Lenape Daly Aadlial 5 pal ia ap gh Si CH ISYT ps sap plas] CANS) Aad gy @Satll sf 3 phaull Ngai y Lhasa ehyy aghy HabaniBY Laaagal) syd gd lal ale go shi psa of ab tp gy Sey Lag pana Dale gp gh pS phil GyS) hay gn 16 Gl gall le gon Lee aaagel (La Uile JOE af A AMS 11s Lega 48155 cf Apbeaisyl Lenape gle Vigo. 1S SLANT GMS Goal tas fut ASI 2 Aachas oll ¢ gall Hiagoeall Zeid Ci pal -/6 Gels cup seal ple Bagnall Cl ill das yx | ghd ag yaad! At bal gf OF gen ANI Sa Gb ebgiSualiga hy Asap spur gpd Yuka Disle Cail CSIs valaally Depa a ial Ch I cae SH gl Sead ell cL fal Ypaary gpl Le anal a hae gb Dyha I jilay Aalicsty! Ghaugall Qe Lally Lidia) yess Gb saad HAS gle Rafal Qin cle Le Sy Of ALE yale JS gait og AVI Cla fall ag glaly ASI 2 Csa'galy Milede Gtata crysis! -/7 iM Rad Cay Wy alll gl agb YG! Gyo Wall Aap Slaagall Ga GES gid UagS eld Gad ASI 2 Ge Call Alyy Clana a Qual oly gly aly Hany at al AY ClaeLa B MLAYL a jal ep Leal digg GLY! Le asny pl gle Jat SHEE Clue pall oda yal Le; dyigall GletiSll yd shy 08 -O1 ga yan 89 eg ig i gts a! AS “Dlg ga 83 Ge en 1G! A aml Se - -64-Gyul seat) gai grill Als Asta bad 7b tlh JSS dail AS! pill & 9 pie Clad Gila dhe : elit! cullall Linge 558 gi al ally ay pth Gye Le rane 9 jas ged & ype UA bse ASI pt Gf clad dal Ge UL AS Ga GA algal pal Galas Gh Lady egy pill Ua clas Bybee sah 3) Sal Es =, Vang a J jatg 4S fuel Cle y yield clas jal gaps cold yd Lyall sid of ee Gy ts I GY a tie a ele) bea ga pl WF le 5 pchall GY Sela ny alll jbl cepted July @ OY AN plea YT J lial Sy chad Ce jay CL baal age Ae Ay yeiely (Abad gle gla G1 aay Ay Sue LDL y Cl yg decd le ho pall da ga of J shell ot Nag ye Gp petal Gy gl ISN) aaa Lg saad) Sad 6 BLY Gla! cael (gd a) eum wcll agdeey! Jy © ORY gol ntiyl util debi C1) silly Gt all I ie) galeaiy! | dial sweaty ge Gol 8 gL LL (ks deal ly 9 Qatny Sy ahaa! Lal Gerd apes ek shi gala! J jiu gif ull GY Mlayy ducal cl Udy, Dina cgay cei pn ply Aas y Asluct Chula iS ogi pues Alli y Ua jae A Udi} TL Sigs Ge pei ga 3 piled Bia die ble ee ale pda Gels Ce pDka dy yh) JUSS) ee lpn (ile| Alli aaa —/2, SSSY Ay yy pny Aegucte CApaledd be gee ool AS futidl CI SLY ging ASI pill ae pl yf aie aD Cals cel IS ye My gh Galt LA ads Lay oly LL Rta Ca ef Albina gues Le ghee oh ot gl ik Ge dsl gl BY cued Glad gle Jpenl pth aan 2 haga (ob Spall y spel gle ha Ssy Lady Gy ob gM ft AS fill Leaaally Gold pDle} alla Ly bide Led Gi Si og yy wall yo Gb Hgly toph gM! lb ua plasty Hen pS Claliay! goad Shan sh iS og] SLeriad a pg ee aptny Gulla gl C2 Fete ec eed ge al a gl 5 il elggle Jaan A500 ed Cay a ld CYL 15 5p lb gay pall Coe esa lb aA Ghd 530 Lu OB Gs basal) Gila Gyo oS pl) Gil esate aadiy AID as Gi gy pall go ila e152) Care Gay fil MS GLE duit Se Gn pl Nad ASG al OF aaa SAS! Be yy et pend Chbeall uady Wigs Glial Gd LY Gedy Lat SIS ae cy (Cane $59) MAAN LUD laa kag AS) gy ye ype AS) yl aa Chall Ga 8 Babyy Gl genall Gye sal day pall JS. OLS -65-Goll atl gai dyaill His Asta) haa 48 SY duct E Sil gall -, eye Ge aS 5 AS tl ey ya Cla ala Ayyy pao yealic AQLM jib yall JSG Aga Li gine GU) Metall lasso y alps Fag SI daalad lass ll ale gd aly! ALON as Gf ape Dna pally Gla gb Bay Ah A cgay Le cg Qual faa Male MAY Aad gl yall Sl Ua pall a gad ely gS Gillan paeal “Wee Aan nals ASI lg gpa Gl gay ab ld aclé SLs Li 6 par Gf ot . V Aglaall 40) coisa igo Cn Oe iad Lead IL «patsy LaLtall yale 3S yl) Aaah Sane! sal alae ce Seat pal Le ull Aelaall basal CY ASI Qi gad GISe Ugalde U8) Gl Guglial DY ese kei Chl Git iy Ayuny 5 ale dLee See gill Dal) UG} asad Up «Allan Ome 9S sal gle Ajay Leal gi Ay Anca) gy Hl ala I} alll yal als Ata A UH cal ASI 58 Gg i has le Bae Led il ll pal E 5 Cosme bb AS) 5A Clad ayy pny dale polio oo gall Luau lady eg cul haga se Lad gt Ella hell cal jin Agel Gi juin o Cj agee bye hn elic} JE Say as 8h Gl ys Gye Stig cs jin) Gakss Supa Clelie} eich Jal Giana I US CUM tad Sale} la mS) AUS 5 6G Lita ee eh ad lle SDS UG Gs Ua ty py pil ha tae Gl Jus A ites oe taal Cdl Agta cil judi) She hj el ol fall) Goons LA ASI gy phe Cas (DUM LLU Ags al ge togd Dud Ia jee eg Leia dasa last Ja qa sa 5th an Gay f gle Jpeaall A8iC) 0 Scop spetineall 5 paliall gil yall Quail Gold Aalcaid GYier @ -e CRY Gland LU Alaa ah Gy Sd ll leaae path Sty RS 4 asl Lia gall 5 Finns C4 KET SB cog AN ool Aya Gye GSS Cl jistGye sail] ga gail Als Zyl) aad oh yi sit Jani oe AS) pod) phe 45 sal) UY) oN) Gllall Aap Lal Gila y Ale Lines LalectBYhy Ald laa! sea y AS) yl) yi LES by cgi ball seal y (AS seatYl Ga JS Quy yf ae y old dicey Slama fig Gell Lawl JE LILY aaa Saag Jp wpa AT HapsLesSyl dyesll aa ging .2 SSL, Gstbegll gy pciineall Gat 3 Hadad yey Kiel GILLI gh 4 sAgdaall AMY! A gall y ay) yall yaght sale! .5 ala LIS yshs 6 fA peal) @ 1S CH pleall yigh 7 tae Gualia GS 8 fcileUbill ase Gur Aaseo OSI Meola 9 Reape le ahge cll gull Calg 6 yghsiall Coll pally Lp gh iS dy at 10 risks Ge Aap sl Susy oa yy gh Gh LElady Ayal Big ya este le gi AIS Hay SN sch Gis i = gst ye gab yeh see 9 pla yh db OS Gl gle Lalas Leaagall ASI ja sels Baggy Lash Tidy Laapall ole WAG GI US Ai gS GY gail Gey Ye Gbaslly fle ghy LS Gila site ¢ UL aaa ss 1 Sas yd gl dal | SAsp NSM 5 hail y Gy yadill (gd Sayagl Cilia eles By! GWG yh 2 3 4 S 5 Realise cd lila ull go GI 6 aT! HASH 8 Sy oath 7 4 8 9 WS yA Syatiy silo Lay jy ghd Aylad ye AS all ge atl BY as LGD Gl yal GS USS gaa Lauaall ys OB -O1 ism con oS Be ae p36 pan sgt sing sane! rode? -67-