[7n]

sgb}o

~e *Z\N*
ghZZ
zZ

gzZ

Why We Believe in God(s)

a0D7}
V-g { n<
{z6,
yQkZ
m
yZz6,
~* Zi W

11

+ Z e el
g :7

16

21
22

k3w

27

y~Zg s NZ :Z}
. : X 1

34

" Z g Z :>
z^ X 2

42

Zg :Kzg: Zizg ~g X 3

49

gVjzg :h
+ **
zh
+ X 4

52

g6,
+ **
h
: 9[  Wa X 5

60
70
78

99
106

**
za
KZZ}
.:XgzZ X 6
G
'
**
ntuWZ}
.:Y~g7zig W~g + X 7
)g fxgI:VN Z { c*
iz c*
z~?Z
# X8
wEZ ~d
]oK Z}
.6,
gg ZzZa ~f : Zzy ZZ} Z X 9
G
'
M F,

V :Y1: yJZ Zg +} X 10

110

142

}

,
k
z
cg Yr
KZ /
-d
H4E
CG
cg 5G
r
KZ /

p!
ax V Y"LZ~6,gy3F,
L


zZgzZ\N*
~ hZ~^[kZX Z Z **
g ZizZ
o
x q
-ZT c*
7tz1 (Zq
-Z Vzg ZizZax q
-Z
~ Z7W X Ya js { c*
i~}g !*
ZZ <

5_I],
bZ.
$e:G3G
Z eh Zxg X}4,
',

~hZ X C Z

W,
O
<
[tL
6f gzZ C;{g Z  D y s
# Z

zZ gzZ \N*
E
2 $
.G
yZ g I  D 3 {z X H z "I VE
E
2 $
.G
t X  DW',}{ n]zZ X DwEZVE
zV1 {lg\ ~aY 2011tX gy

W @*
wzZ[
The New Science of the Mind:

'' *Z e-e X 6
,
zZ
~
Evolutionary Psychology

];* ~g z!*
VF,F,
x gzZ Y (bL
~hZ X g Y h~ ]i DgzZ 0
+Z Z
+uz
6,
Vzq.
**
VY r
KZD Cts:

zZgzZ\N*
[t X  D Y L
VY6,g %a kZ  t
rg
sg9Zg W X , } LZQ (
| 7,Z
# gzZ7,
bhZ a^gg c&
+ + Z e el
gI],
Z eh Z ~ e Z8

H y ~ [ W,
1KZ

zZgzZ ~hZ 6L
X W~zk',
VK~<
, }g
Z{z X
A & p
pg 6,kZgzZ @*
- y
KZ wq
G$
4G
5E
gzZ YgzZ4 kZ yZ  B
bg gzZ NZ I G
_
r ~ eC
! ZgX X X 7~~
Mother Nature and Mothers and Others: The Evolutionary
Origins of Mutual Understanding

ax ]~ ~i 0*
Z ~L
]x{ c*
iZ Cc6,
b) [tX ]gz
E
5_I],
2y
G3G
Z eh Z BJ.G
X X X Y Y HwEZay
kZg Z
~
/cp ? @*
ZabyZZ6,
Z}
.h
+ **
-Zf
q
KZL

KZCgzp

zZgzZ\N*
~hZ];+C
yZgz6,
uZg Z.
**
-ZHZzty]:SZaf
q

fgzZ: !ZD6,Zzs k
,
yZX M
hg6,Z}
.1
V70
+
i
qtXw6~}g!*
g

5_^g7k
Dg
/
g Kg G3G
,
Z VyZ : @*
i Z0
+Z W,
Z6,
LZa+ Y\WLZX ggZ
/0
+
ig0
+ZIJ
-yZ
~eZ8d]X ~"7,
[:ZqZq
-Z

zZgzZ~hZXY
YH
Why Her? Why Him?'gzZ ;gE- i&g]c*
C
C
+I Hyw

Z
zZgzZ\N*
~hZ ?lZz+',
L
QgzZD Zzgx ZgzZ !*
g ~g 0*
X VYk
,
8,
igkZa
y~ Cg Y gzg0
+Z}g  4 (ZgzZX X X  D gz
( X ,k
,
~kZgzZ) [NgzZyWq
-Z ?VY Z}
.X
4

4F
5G~ ezzX n
EG
pg6,
VEz Yv{ c*
iZ 7
Chair, Advisory Board of the Secular Coalition for America, and
President, Defending Dissent Foundation

vI X~gzu" Dq6,wZgq
-Z L
[Z wZkZ [t X VY W,
Q 7C<

/Z y7
H

4
5
H5G
4h GZ Z X X X CZ

&h Z G
X $HI],
Z e G34G

f {zX^ Z
Z ] gzZ: c*
 q
-Z g0
+ZV~f
ZL
,Zq
-Z

zZgzZ \N*
~hZX  K J ea
yZz6,
~i*r
KZ
Hc*
3t~TDY6,
^
G
G$
X X X 1wJ ea ih
+]
.V 3E
_yZ <
gzZ J m

E
E
H
H
4
4
]
]
c&
+ ^ ~

G3 g G3 e N*


11

7
_+ Ze el
g_
s WYgzZ ~ L L[KZ f
exgZ Z yzgZege

4F
5_
.nI
y
KZ L L: Hz~7Wq
-Zg Z
KZ~( ZZ q Z Z ) E
G
G
H{LZZ s Z
/ZckZ X Y Z e zg6,g @*
kZgzZi W

yZy6 6 Z { c*
i }~ xV ;gN ~L L: *
@Y
X Y~96,

C5q
-Z];gzZ

g7kZ  ~ V Z ];g Z yZ \N*

Z e

yzg Z e GN [yZ~}g!*
ZIg ZX g"
$U*

g7I/5p
/Z yzg Z eX CY hz ?
Z6,Vb

q
-Z ~ V26,
ual
y Z e {zXgzB"_
.I {zp

c*
Y V;z !*
DZoyZ0
+{ LZgZZ gZ ZgzZ

V,Z (X n
pg~gYoKZ {z*
@Y`g0
+Zal
yZ0
+{Z
# )D

?VY Z}
.

12

{h
+Id

U if
$
/
g&
+ZyZgzZ q
W~g 0*

woyzg Z ep
/ZX g ( ]
C ~) Y woL L@z[

p~ wZL LkZyZ@*
c*
g!*
z [
Z L L{7Y

Qce7]~kZX wZ{zgzZ :7L

X Lg @*
ZZwZ~

kZ ? D VY {gz6, Z
+ I ~x gzZ v Z

& Y Y j4~~mkZ ` W VY L L

X  x4,
zg Z e L L7pyzgZ ep

 Y Y Hy V- ]q Zh
+]
.wZ yzg Z e
E
28EyZ bQ
.G
kZ \N*
? Dg e6, kZ ~ E
e Z6,!*
) g ZzZa ~f L L
<
a : uVc*

! (

 g ZzZa ~f ]**
Dg C;yZt 7Z pZ &
+
X qZa

]; e
\W
/Z L L: zg ,k
,
i [ kZ e
L L

X wV{gzZ q
-Z X B];<
\W  B

p VOX e**
**
q~gZl{ c*
iZa Z]
.Z !*
W1}g
~g t [
7 W !*
tZ
# [ZgzZX B~ Pgz h
+kZ

X g yv

zz C
!*
1t [ZX g ZzZa ~f t e

oL!*
W}g X g0
) !*
b)?, ZgzZ _{yv

X CYW s<
{g !*
z]!*
tX Z 7,
**
7
E"
g ZzZa ~fLL bZu5F
y-yZ];gZVc*
gzZq
-Z

13

b i Z ~g & UL L nq
-Z u {z X  g Z

E"
5F
X *
@Y HaZVkV6&6f Z

V6&6f Zz Y Z6,gg Zz Za ~f suq

- 4,
) Vz i Zz Wp!*
g: k
,
z kZmF,
{ c*
i

X @*
g ga Z ( y!*
i

gzi6,]**
Dg C;yZt e
I N*
@*

Zg ZakZ XZC;{g (Z L L: YY]**

DgY

DgzZ +
MgzZ]b!*
BV}uz 

~d
$
~ z j
Z}g Zt X } ~ Za kZ
X J e

y
KV6&6f { g Z F+Z ~ [ \N*

c*
}x **
Ic*
Wq
-ZC
~yZgzZ c*
VZ {Z
+^
,Y**
<
X
 @*
L L zZp~L L X L L Kzg : Zizg ~g L L:

:V5oW,
P, Z X nY1yJZ Zg v

g\ e gzZ Yc*
VZ~Z Lega!zq
-Z

-Z- [ZX @*
q
iZ \WgzZ @*
VZ6,
zZB; LZ {zX Y H

Z}
.gzZ @*
VZ6,
zZB;LZ {zX m13!*
i~fg ~g
BV
KZ}uz X @*
iZ ~ i Z0
+Z VQ~KZ=L LZ

{ ~g
zC
Z}
.p M
h h mzz A c*
]%Z ]
X Lgk0*
}g

X 4: z"i Z0
+Z ZzVZB; ~g VZ~

7: z"t :,_ Y~ Z { c*
iZ "7,\N*

?VY Z}
.

14

B+E
B;c*
qC
ZgqgzZq
-Z {zkZX: F

X Zp

L6,gap @*
y ga6,\W VY (Z

\W VY (Z [i ZzW { i Zzg \W

/Z ?@*
7y

Z{ i Zzg YkZ/ H{ i Zzg!t

9KZVp (
|
# g^ q
-Z VY (Z X
H
X ;g WZ] *
@Y,
-spN

]gzZzlqC
~V~fZ]
.Z}g
4E
& yv g Z Wx
/F
X Z zz yi Z x E
/
u { c*
i

: Z
) !*
?
Zuu~kv { c*
iykZ ]!*
kZ6,gCc*
g
,Zga c*
X { c*
i } ~uz 7 tq
-Z ~ VzpX

ZzykZ 6,
gCc*
g 4pVOX M
huh\W Z

LZ6,~p Zz Y h Z Z yzg Z ep ) X Y c*
CZ { i Z0
+Z

Z**
X X X @*
J (,Ww Z \N*
( X ]!*
6,g

{gzZq
-Z Vz
CC;yZgzZX X 8
L S(,
u~}g !*

X Q6,
X @*
Z

gwVX wVgzZq
-Z uZ zg Z e Zg ~}g !*
Vg

~g 0*
bZX *
@YJ
- V L
L
L L V~e
$Zzgzg6,

pgzZ \
<
!*
klL L\7X DB L L<
ZgZ
#  \!*
LL
X *
@Y al
g klLL

Dy {zgzZ H_SVzgzWp \N*

Z e

: CYwEZ b];F6,
~g Z g~
M F,
gzZ CyZ

15

X D}PVgg
M F,
gzZg Cy>

YJ e6,
VgzZV g Z',
LZ D(
p~yZ

]+Z X  Dgz VZ0

+{Z LZgzZ ',6,bZz

Vzg Z g kZ 7zJ
- Vzgjs

X M]
A

f] }}uz<
q
-Zq
-Z \N*

C~ kZD VZ N {zX i W T6,{)z xgI W

)\N*
~ hZX Zz gzZ Z Z[|Z yZX @*
W6,

tX CW~)((6,
],[zgTd
$ Zew6,g

X Yg c*
,
k
@*
gzZ YS7,
~![ W,
1

16

?VY Z}
.


G-4$
+R,
i
gz G3 Gg
CZX W~z6,gi !*
yCZ**
[t

$
d
3kZkZX ;gq
M F,
~~]g qq
-Zd
$
W
n

~6,
ggYVd
$
;]kZX
X c*
qz_ ~
/cp

X  7q 5a }Vc*
g { n ;V; y
KZ

~X @*
7,gZg Z BV6,=6,g
R,ug
;ghZz
KZz r 0_Z',
/
%Qgz s W;gE- w F
CYwZ q
-Z V Z g @*
gzZ Vzg ]g \ + C
t X V

k * :zzX H :zz Zz
R,& \z
/

gZ~ ZziZ H_s: V {gz V

"VzgezgzZ Z: Zgz& }p

X H Z Z

17

5q
-Z ]z ]c*
yZgz_~
/c p ~z!*

Tg r
KZ ~ {z kZ X c*
g * rY gzZ

~ yZgz kZ XKN Z@Z ~}g !*

<
mm{

X { c*
igzZ { c*
i ~X H{ .Z bggzZ V1g

]&gzZ6 yZ~TCY0*
7[uZz+Z t~

-Z Zzp
q
pg p qkZ T
HHy jy W, Z

XY[c*
;~gx
%i
-Z]yZ c*
q
VQ Z x t ~~ [LG

X VjJ
-~g t

~ b zZ y 
,@*
pW7~J
-<
L=

{xZZz]~v{zX ;g 6,
/e {Vz(,

LZ

=Q 4<
Z
/ZBgzZ Y0
+
igzZ *gzZV8

6,<
~ Lg H~p
/ZX V Y(
~ kkZ~ce

x(
|$
+X @*
7(
C!*
.~ p Z}p V
_
rg
Z
g Zlp g Z
/
zB V2z **
'Y o g Z Zgz Z

pC bV { z D c*
' Y op
/Z X @*

i Z0
+Z W,Z6,J
- ` W } L L wX C Zg Z0
+(
uI hZ

X C

>
[
+
z
h ~ yZgz
M F, e

6,g Zz [
+
z
X S7,( Future of Illusion) w zL L[

kZ @*
X @*
Za VY]I r
KZ HZ~D}g

X 7={7

?VY Z}
.

18

c p
) !*
Zz {6 ];gZ
G-Y
~ ^gZ:],
10*
8
-yZ^e~yZgz6,~
/
V,ZX H{ .ZxVzgZuugzZel
<
g

VzgzWpxyZX Vd
$
!*
kZ c*
1iz

X g ~ Z4a~6,

: Z% : V- ~
C ~
/c p._ ]Z@x

t X *
@Y H: 6,V{ k
H" ~ Tq
-Z ~ g

Vz%x
A &t X **
Z6, kZ
KZ p **
Z6, Z
X C~

@*
x@ZX *
@Yc*
0*
~VzVggzZVz%yDg p

negative ) +
Mzi!t: D ]**
kZ {gZ z p

X ( retaliation bargaining) + A ! ZgzZ ( inclusive fitness

}gzZ {}VzgzWp&Zp
8kZ1ykZ

6,VzgzWp%y kZ Zuz X q
-&Zp ~g \

qZ <
Va X km
yZz6, kZ
fgzZ r"t gzZ @*

G
G
$
45E
G
_ Zg Z {g Z F+Z a kZ g ZzZa f
KZ gzZ Y

gzZ Z
+ I   ( evolved cognitive adaptations)

kZX Y Y HwEZ6,gu~
<
/c p

apgzZ$V6&{g Z *
@Y0tg !Zq
-Z
X CY~:WVc*
/~g VX Y0;

VZcp~gzZ
)(
ZbkZ
zZ
E
E
4H
5"m,
.nI
G
+qgzZ +**
X g i%6,<
z~ E
6,~ }g !*

19

X ~z]}~Vz

m,
6,]q
-ZgzZ KZ~J
-bZzZY 2009

X n
pgVY6,
( V Z}
.c*
) Z}
.s
# zt~T g

m,
6,kZ bz ? Z',c&
+ yZgzZ + Z e el
g
Z~ ] q
-Z V
HH
7 6,[k- ZgzZ
Hc*
G ]g '

 Z kZ=zz pzg kZ~x }X

<
Hg !*
V
X ]gz[ g YgzZZzq
-Z~}g!*
b5

X :
L W~z [kZw

gVZ
/a ]c*
FgzZ c*
` z Y CZ6,k
,
~ 
zZ

X X Z
BVgzZ]
X
4
5

G{~gY *
*7m,
?{t V,ZBB

g~zb
k
,
tX *
@Y
W Z}
.L &
L YwEZ k
,
m

] }
. V, Z V x X s gz T6,
X e

kZ\W
/ZX b: ] x ~g Z

gzZfN0*
t\W ,s
zZ h~"7,
[

T e 7wZ~}g !*
kZ\W
/Z )X  Z
+ I r

( X p~[Z yZ=

X ,
z a"7,
X ,!ZjkZX 7,
[ ~g7

NZ6,Z}
.f}g yYt [ZX ,wjc*
~k
,
$
~ D}g 5X  D ; bZgzZ  Db

: *6,

Cy
KZ q X Y Zi WVDtX gZ

20

?VY Z}
.

VY N*
g H{z eM
hwZ ezAa
/<

Zh
+(
gzZ X xq
-Zax }K q
-Z ~ p9{z :

[t\WgzZq]I\W
/ZX q ~g ~
X 7,
ZX kZ VZ~V;LZ

k3w

21

k3w
b]S+ Z e el
gax LZgzZp [kZ

Z',c&
+ + Z e el
g= V,Z a kZB BX 

u"a}*
*xByZgzZ 'YZXc*

W;R,bz?

c&
+ zq
-Z g Zz q |
# z
[ kZX
) !*

ac&
+ \W ~h
+y

[t\W
/ZX YH3za
Xt]X c*

h Z bz ? Z',c&
+ + Z e el
g~ b

{yZgz[ kZ {zX Vg Z
/
]sz ygZ 0zgI],
Ze
$U*
g q
-gzZ
z
],
Vz 0i!ZZ[kZ V,ZX "

-V] c*
J
z ] LZ ~ H Z
)=gzZ

X Vj
YE4
VzzZZ R6e N*
gzZ5Gr
-
/;R,
}~c&
+
X "
$U*
g akZgzZ 1{ ^
,Y

?VY Z}
.

22

 
pa lzy
z l kZ :zz ^D }g

yZgz x kZ X c*
3 J
-y
W VwZZ uZ Z V,Z
X gwq
}g ggzZ+zD
+
: ZqZ yZ
(

 ~
Z wg Z L L[ V
$Zg ^',
Zg 8
-3 z

VR,
} Zi r
# yZ X} i Zzg ];gZ6,)g f
X Z
Wg.
e
$.6,
} 0i!AzZ[
Y
G-
H8
~ ^g-],
10*
xw0*
8
-f
$ E4h E
yZ^e

VM *
<
@Y1~V ZbyZx **
el
ggzZuu

X Z e zg6,
J e Zg Z

5.\ Z7 wP ' e-e y-',Hg i-ghZ w0*

~e Hg m,H
G
YE
"
4J& W+Z H
5E

hegzi
+Z 3,
eg kg d]zi
+g Z} Z EjG
e l e 0zg
E
E
" y-%0*
38Ei[Zg 4,
5F
-/~ hg H~G
r
 yzzZ ~ eg ; Zg

23

EJ
I G4]
yg~hg} z|i 
wz; E$(
z eg G4]e N*
l
gyY
 vx }uzgzZ z kc*
gi
+Z^
,Zz EgzZ wP?Zz w0*
!IyYI

V,Z  g x
/
u~ V Zy ]Z D
KZgzZ ];g Z

gzZVZ: g ZgzZgZgzZbzg
KZgzZVzk
,
KZ

B}~ VZ ]Z D
KZ Z', Z Z
gzZkcyYZ~X Za z~]})gfW

gzZ Hxl  x
/ ~ VMV @*
kCzg
X 7yxg}g [Z

~ s %Z~ ] {7~ [ kZgzZyZp

/Z

VMVg Z
/
]^ **
g q
LZ~ Qgz s W;gE- Q

X g ~~yZy]Z

c*
)gf}pggzZV2z
R,
}

gm{~yZX H ]}~}g!*
<
)gfc

c&
+ f
$
/
ggzZyGX (
D
/kz',
gzZ',
Zk
,
ZZyG6,
E&
kZ X ~ ]
~ *i3 Zz ~ G
5G
e #=

*Z }X 5
)(
Z bgZzZa ~f g <
g !*
)g f

x~
/
%kZQgzs W;gE- ~ HZ
=:zz Zz

V,Z X
) !*
Y J
-V {i q i *= xt X Vj

~
/cp~T A
$%[q
-Z Zz Y 6,~
/c

X (
y*q
-Z Z~}g!*

p k; k
,
H Z L L g Qgz wz ug (

gzZ
zZX HZ
J
-x ZZ\Yy*Z6,
~
/c

?VY Z}
.

24

~ }g!*
<
y*t Zz Y B y Z',g Zz Zizg

X (
~[kZ]X
H0q i p
{zz]

hZ 4,
C
N*
} X }pgzZ Z= iW

7 !*
~ V Z ~B X}g 8kg X VQ wZ6,q

w$
+"~X H Z
,ja[t= [q
-Z6,
~gF
X HU
$N*
{z[kZCy ~ug

Y
z kZ',
zZ .
L L@z
) ) }~ pz
YEJ
X V}YZ~Z
# D E5"Zg e wgzZn
pgzg [
YEJ"
}g <
 W~ + Yt ~g E5 Zg e yZ

X km
yZz6,
b~V~f
E
\
J
4
&
G
45G-. Zz ~ ~ e dZz
x Z
/
z6, ~ wos W *i EG

gZ
KZZzYb~[kZF0*
el
gI],
ZeZZ
KZ Z',


7w; Zz ZZ
KZ *ikZ \W
/ZX 1{^
,Y
X , Z~

x e L L[ Zg WcKZ !*
$w 6,

X U*
6,
Y
!
H
5

G
X Z
WWg 6,}
0i! }4,
',4h WgzZ h Z ZG-#
G
#
G GJ5 G
H_ Y
HJ5 G
5-#GZ 4h4G
& Z hZ 4h4G
5 E
5G
Z Qgz DZ bZ HiJ4G
Z kZ
G
#
G
G
#
H
J
4
5 GZ 45G
y7z Qgz Z k s W **
- HiJ4G
Z ;ugc*
E
H5_
5_ ;gE- y N*
gzZ ;gE- `g Y bZ e:G3G
`g YgzZ 5G4F
;
!
5 Jg
gzZ ]Z~ X [k
,
g ~6,q [ kZ ;gE- EG
X Vg Z
/
]yZaVzgt

25

"
J4E
5G
gzZ k e 5G
e + Z e el
g g g gzZ ZC
yc*
W
6X
E
.>F
~q]Z`
gzZ V1 IBV Zz + <
Vzk
,
KZ E
:


X n
pgx S~w}
) !*

 ]o Zy

aV ZbyZgzZ b[t

J
-\W]yZ~
/ZX gx 6,
x4,
ki <
f

~g Zf yZ~V @*
X , Z Zt]yZ V ;g[x~
X V@*
wJ

26

?VY Z}
.

Z}
. :

27

Z}
. :
y~ZgsNZ

f
: Sg 7 q gz

LL

e { c*
i
BB~p q {z X X X q
( yzg Z eg e) X B
bg
A &

CggZc*
x<
gZv,ZV

Z}
.
/Z@*
XKqzyZ!gzZf n]

~gqgz
u" q
-Z~g Zy
KZgzZKZ kZ z Zz
X y~yZZ6,
Z}
.:

zg fm,
ZgzZ J
-d
$fm,
Z V-^*

6,"
$|$
+V zy V V- V|V26,
MJ
-d
$

/
gqzg ~
/
%c*
Z}
.q
-Z i Z d
$xC

6,
yX @*
*][Zt mT g

?VY Z}
.

28

V'{ yZ gzZ V
KZC
<
 zz H ?VY

? zb
W

Zg ZgzZ ];yZgzVzz
/X  K]!*
t [Z

wZkZ [zZ kZ X Z 0*
',[zZ ~ bzgE( cognitive)
nmVY @*
Za YZ
+ Ir
KZ 5[Z g Z

yDg ;gzZ wJZ VY r }g gzZ  Z

+
X n
pg

g0
+Zr w@ZigzZ]c*
k^k0*
}g [ Z
g6,(KZ Z b
ZX Qe
$]!*
Z yZ XVzk
,

KZ VY M
h qgba[ZwZkZ[Z X 
CZ y
KZ{ ]c*
yZzz HgzZ @*
wJgzZ Za ]ZgI r
X *
@ YL
6,
g %gzZ @*
sptzg

]Zg+F,
Z {f
KZt OCgyzgZ ege

6,}i O CgX  g"

$U*
gZ@ZgzZ q

-Z ~

uZza g ggzZ qF,

x 0
+
i

KZt gzZ X .
V @*
-gzZ V Z}
. r X .
|
# gzZ g r

X 4,
Z@
6n
pgm q q
-Z
X NZ hz
/
g Z LZ

g gx kZp Z&& ZJgzZ

~g p
/Z

Q VzgZ g gzZ +Zz }g

~g X  OzgFz!*
! x
X  uB Z]
.Z !*
W LZ VpgzZ Vx{ ~g X 

X {Z
+Zi

Z}
. :

29

yzg Z eXB7j9vZbZ +F,

VziLL

WgzZ**
wj e ._]q+
Mzi._

yZ ~ X .
$Y Vzg Z0
+Y yZ4z]
. X
A &J (,
X @*
yZhV6&

GG3I
" zg 7x99yzg Z eC
~uzq
-Z

# Z 7,**
Z
g OZ J
-Y 1953aD]!*
kZX CvJ
-8E
g !*
bkZ X c*
g |
# } Z +Z ~ e u1Z
gzZ ?Zz E,G
GG3I
" zg Zx
X CbF,

E
4E
7
H45G
lW 5G ~ OCggzZ ` ZZugzZ ?Zz~ yzg Z e
E4E
LZ{ yZgz
z g ZX CW~z;@*
EJ45Gz& g Z eh
+]
.
yzg Z e ,Z !*
Xf
e wJ e ._ wj mLZ\W
Y"
Y"
5
F

G
G

+Y 5F5LJ%Z b
5X e ~ Vj LZ LZVzg Z0
}k
,
q
b
-Z X Sg7~g ( iguana) @ !g }gzZ~* {z

gzZ Z 7,**
o b)Z} hJ
-VzgZ0
+Y}k
,
}uz
b
C1j Z CZ }k
,
C
b
V X Hi VhLZ LZZ V,Z

]!*
F,
ZpX 1wJ e\WLZ V,Z~T ( ecosystem)x

X HvJ
-VYZ]:S5yZV,Zt
GG$
_4Z Zg y
KZ wg Z0
+YC

-Z ( adaptations) V 3E
q

s O Cg& i b) {7 s wj c*
o1%
E
28EyZ jm _C
.G
E
X @*
z yZgz i g Z
GG$
X D Wx ~|
# V 3E
_yZ ~
g
/
u OCgyzgZe6,
ZgC
J
- r VZ

?VY Z}
.

30

]gzxWa !g {0
+
i\WX  Zhz 6,\W LZ X 

g(Zi (Z q
-Z)g f g Z \W ]gz\Wg Z0
+YgX C7,
X J
-LZZqxWc\WT,

X C7iZ B yp|
# w \W

wX Ciz6,0X J
-
IZ}uzgzZ r xW

c CW Vz {z @*
B xWT~ 0
w
L LZzgg x kZ X kgZ Z XE3WdX  DiX rxW

X 

r X @*
t :Z ;@*
+]
h
.Z 6,fgzZ r y
KZ
E
" y-g gzZ];C
 {zf~p Z5F
-Z
egzg ;X q
b{0
+
i}uz ( mind is what brain does) @*
r

V i g Zs OCg& ` ZZH ]Wo1%Zr

GG$
# Zgz
/E
wV 3E
_yZX Haib)m~ G
G
$
4G
5E
f gZ ~gZ
/0
+
i~Vz
/Lg G
_Y
E
28EyZ {z Z jkZg0
.G
# yZ }~F,
|
E
+Z
X g Zf

W6,(

Cg )}6,W  \WLZ~ N
WW\WZ
#
GG$
kZ)g fV 3E
_~yr \WX C~ ZzgzZyQk
,
Zz

gzZ w{z}
.
wVg~ yZX @*
~ Z4ZgzZ @*
Jk
,

x ZuZg t{ (
Zb
Z Zz|
# Vzg )^

X 
G
G
$
45E
# X g(Z G
Z
_Y{bZ Z]
.Zz!*
W}g

Z}
. :

31

q C!*
.wCgzp/kZ \W  {n \W
_

]ZpgzZ Z
+ +
M kZ wr %) kZ gzZ ,
G
G$
V 3E
_ i{iZ0
+ZL LyZ]zZ ZX D} iZ0
+Z ~h
+~}g!*
\W {zX  Sg~ga F ~ yZgzZ 7
X swV~yZD<
,

 ,g i 0*
Z X J
-u .
**
r Bf

gzZ ab] m!WC

~X]W

X!*
g]WPsi!*
yZgz kZX @*
iXmq
-Z

W\WX,g6,VzqyZ ZgfX Dx bZ r }g

Zz ~ r \WwyZX z N*
gq
-Z xt X
X B
bgw#~L W6,
V}g

p 7 _p Z &
+
 <
VY ~gz't
GG$
V
/
g Z LZ  @*
0*
$ V 3E
e
_4Z {z
G
G
$

45 E
G
_t CwiogZ+
M
KZV V X DwEZa
6,g Z X I CW~zaib)CZfgzZ Ym
~gzWg!*
ggzZ }ogIC
V,Z jW,
Z6,V7 p

X ]Zg~
CYBpZ
+ IX Z
3a
GG$
6, ];z ~uz g ZzZa ~f V 3E
_yZ <
]!*
t

 6X @*
7

',
ikZW~z
,y~9[!*
G
G
G
$
G$
45E
g ZzZa ~f V 3E
_yZt  7G
_pZ &
+7,gzZ r

X gzZZ X

~}g !*
e
$gzZ : A] X X X <
Z x

32

?VY Z}
.

yZZ6,
{E
+Z c*
VklZ
+Ziq
-Z c*
-Z X X X YYZ
q
+

(
Z}
.Z
+Ziq
-Z c*
Z}
.(Zq
-Z~Z~yZX Dqz
~g  DZ ~ V70
+
i ~g  D   D
LZ X  Dg 6,qC
gzZ  DwJZgzZ  F
g N l{

kZX,t%ZgzZ ,]!*
6,Z}
.q
-Z s{

nZk0*
XDZ}
.~X,Z<
s

t @*

X  CY 0*
Vc*
- ~ <
Z Z
#  C

<
Z Z',
Z} (,V7~kZX DV76,g )

X,wEZZaV VKZakZ q
-Z Z}
.

@*
oz) # \!*
iZ gzZ Z}
.~g3+q
-Zt

] ]/kZZ
#
7
zZN ~g {z@*
X
(" kZgzZ,tt,V*!*
(
~{ ZgkZ,

Og6,]!*
kZgzZ ( }: c*
}wJN ~g {z e) NO]

@*
g 6,
V ~g s: Z}
.tX Za }',


Na}g 
rgV V
KZ}uz~}g !*
}g

]!*
kZA
$}]c*
gzc*
]Zp~g {z
/ZX D

kZX : 3 (Z C
e 4a}g n
pg 6,

~f}g
tX C{7 '
g : ~]!*
Z}
C
.%)
X Vg: a}g !*
kZ e Lg {6,
:

6,
g) Cg+Zq
-Z\WV \W
/Z~Z

L\Wp
/ZgzZ ZzgzZy!*
$gZ { c*
iu @

kZ\W H ga
a\WQpB7

Z}
. :

33

XaVPsh
+(
pXZ y
WBh
+(
?B

kZ
t n
pg 6,Z}
.q
-Z \Wzz HQ

kl6,kZ @*
;g~V~f}g  ? @*
{ c*
i

f Zg a yZZ6,Z}
.X 4yW g yZZ6,][Z t
Y
GG$
7Vzg ZD
V E
O Cg @*
wEZV 3E
_{g (Z { c*
i
E
4F
5G4]LZyZX k
.J2G
V
KZE
,
+g~
5
WWX **
.
q6,}i kZgzZ VB
te**
s: y;f Z
KZgzZ VYNC\W~], Zz
X ggzZ 
{kZV,Z D

kZ **
yZZ6,Z}
. V
KZ bNC \W

kZ**
k6,p]gz ^kZ b hg]56,kZ **
g e kZ **

gzZ **
akZ gzZ **
xgz]Z } {z g gzZ

I bY{g (Zt NC t \WX H qz *

*%

: VY Zg yZ e  C J
-u ) **
uF,
Z
+
X VT e**
q

X Y{E
+
V!*
~
C gZkZp

?VY Z}
.

34

z^
>
" Z g Z

kZ c*
',
Z', c*
g |5 **
b & Z t L L

( yzg Z eg e) X 4

[ZgzZ X X X  g `Z6,
zZ 7
}
/
n

t **
Z ~g X  @Za"
$U*
Z k0*
}g

# X B&5gkZ {zn
Z
pg NZ6,
Z}
.vgzZ zg

Vzg Y ZL Ly
KZwtsV H7tCZyzgZe
{ C " , ZpX Zzb 6, ggb g Z

"akZ bVzgZ0
+Yx }uzDC
t@Z
x Zz Y 0*
6,}i V  W~z ~ g Z
X Zi W ]

Ti\ HZ CY0*

~zf
$
/
6,
ii
Z

 z^
>

35

X #J
-

y!*
~Vs9ZXB
bgzgg3ga
KZ
~Zzt

X H qz^g ZmCZ y
KZ V({ztX YY

gzZ Zg X  g `
! X Z 7 Vzg g Z Zg

E
4)9F
2F
.G
 uZ]
.yZgzZ Zg X u+Z ~ e98.6V- E
ZFgzZ KY
KZZ]
.
ukZX Zg
/
w70 @*
50

X  Y a
(
~h ,Z !*
X h^6,V2Zg g Z

gzZ`q
-ZsX Ixznhy
KZx ~uzhgq
-Zg Z
X {Z
+ZiT\W

4G
5! c*
5G
a :%~y
W ( hominid) HE
g j
Z m

Zg e ~ * wg ZD
50 sd
$
`
! g Z X 
4G
4G
5!!*
5!
5E
5E
X 0*
$bsHE
X !*
WU/UhHE
Ardipithecus X _ !*
WF}g ]5 ~g [Z

E
4)9FgzZ}g Kc*
2F
.G
+F,
$
d
Z]
.
V- E
g
gzZ Sg~^Vzh +Zq
-ZtC
X q
-Z~Vzg Z g
X q]:Sbg Y

zz kZ X g ! i
Z Australopithecus
G
-#G
gzZ q
-Z X 5 \ G3 Z Ik',:e  L Lg]

Y 1948 gzZ Y 1938  ( d

$
y
KZ L L T) Paranthropus
4 (ZX ',
Z',
40r }g r kZX 5i
Z ! ~
akZ m7 V=p Zz~ZgzZ]1j tVa

X $


36

-Z d
q
W! ] *C
q
-Z ~ Y 2008~ i
Z

?VY Z}
.

q
-Z ~ 7,
t X c*
g ~ 7,
!*{ c*
i}

gzZ }g t 6,gX
H3g Australopithicus sediba x **
T

XZezgh
+'
6,
*ZzgZzY0*
yxgAustralopithicus

-w20n~i
J
Z q Z Zt{zZZ}g

X ;gsu": i q Z ZyZ~}g XgU/U

@*
qz N 20 eg kg \z
/}g
Homo

gzZ Homo erectus Homo habilis ~ \z

/kZ X

i
Z wk Homo erectus X  (
heidelbergensis

y!*
i k0*
kZ X Y J
- kz&
+Z gzZ us gzZ C
!*

X 7
A&

x(Z
Homo heidelbergensis V\g-  @*
YEE
J
5k4&} Z+Z ~ eDqX Re~wg hZ g
/
wi og Zyg Z

: ~ wg hZ gzZ !*
W Homo sapiens}g

{g ~ i
Z  Homo heidelbergensis {z X ;g o %Z

X W~z-Zy
KZh
+]
.6,
gK

X  Z6,w z +F,*Homo sapiens

6,g 8
-gX M r Zu V6& X @Z,Z

A syxg Vz
/ZV M
h YK wEZ a`g

r Z {naV kZX ]ggzZ + A Zz

k0*
yg Z +F,
*q ~g  ykZ
]!*
kZX ]gz

Zg7 V C;gzZ Y ~gyZ 

A & +Z q
-Z

 z^
>

37

X
A &y!*
iX X X IZ

E
4F
5G4]h
.J2G
E
+]
.b\WgzZ ~w
A &y!*
i

X qz]i
ZIwg ZD
60` W

Vz~g X [
gsq
-Z]%Z IgzZ Dp#x

hz   zZ {z
/ Lgq
-Z
X  j
Z
g0
+Z
X 1h *x g ZgzZ Whgq Z Z~uz~

t
(Z q
-Z
@wq
-ZgzZ wg ZD
70 yZgzZ ]!*

{gzJ
-k 600s~ !*
W~g 6, ]Zph
+~T c*
Wgz
E
4
7
H
45GE
z kZ kZX x 5Gh

+]
.]!*
t X

{z
/1 LgkZ q
-ZC
~ V
KZ [g Z ]6,}i zg
X $pu kZ zZ

Aus tralopithecus ? $gzZ VY ?VY bs

~yZ @*
C
.
V-7,
V
KZh
+]
.gzZ Homo erectus

y
KZh
+]
.X qz **
zg Vp6,(6,
zZ V\W

~ Australopithecus  w r X
H qz **
w O yZze
E
4F
5G4]Z
.J2G
H&~ E
k
# k
Hz ~?k
,
Z {z
aTk 500 @*
400
E
H
 {zt g0
+Z r X Vc*
{ c*
i6,x [ 5
" ~pt X
H
G
G
$
45E
* Y~g  G
_{ g Z {z CY 0*
~{V
X CIZ

}g
) !*
X] y{zy
W @*
ZatwZ[Z

Z
Z }uz q ~g m<!*
X p u{z ?
H| (,Z w r

KX ]gz!gV}uzq
-ZaVY

?VY Z}
.

38

X c*
6{z
/L LpVOX ~gzYa

z j Z
Zg0
+Z} #q
-Z\W
/Z

'Zj{z
/kZ|
# KZlp{z,~Vz
/

V Zz {z
/}uzgzZ g 0
+Z L L{z
/kZ\W LZ {z X
HH!Z

qzeJyxgVz
/VzXC
!*
LL
X Vg: VY bZa}uz q
-Z Z
Zg0
+Z{z
/I
7h
+(
?47t\W HX  0yg Zq
-Z bZ[Zp

X, (Z \W ykZ ~ X Cg~Vs9tVY

* KZ !*
W}g kZgzZ @*
g0
+Z}g 6{z
/LtL

X Q~g Z
/0
+
i~

gZ
/0
+
ig0
+ZVzP LgLg6,VzgZ g R

g @*
* t X CY 0*
` W  | e ~ ^kZ ]
KZ
ZgzZV-g Dzz ~ !*
W *Iw0*
sX 7
wj Y{zt X F6,VXLgLg( hunter gatherers) V Zz
` W p F~];KZX c*
W~zcy
KZh
+]
.T

X q /[Z tQpX D{

X
? mH<
kZ7\W

@*
wEZaLZ]56f Y0
+
i {%izg<

E
2${z( Adaptive Psychology)];V_tX
.G
V2xE

gzZ xAgzZ +
M yZ ]B V}uz
E
2$t X ~ ~ Za kZ D
.G
z AZ}g ~ d
$
xE
X V` Wzz4ZX m
yZz6,
~i
Z

 z^
>

39

E
2$C;yZ aIp 7_pZ&
.G
VE
+
p
/Z<
Z

~ g V * YV}uz  g ZzZa ~f
GG$
V 3E
_yZ<
VaX ~gzu"ay
KZ&&tX 

Xg ! Z takZ @*
sp
G$
7
/F
\W H : bzZigzZ q
-ZVzgzZa ~f: SG
5E
_yZ G
? gzZ KZ

)
/
',j
+ ^
,} (,q
-Z ? Ie

X Ch
+kZZ]zZgzZDI**
3nkZv

c*
X C 3%g rL e C 7 e
\W
/Z
m,
/ yZa kZ V n

pg w KZ \W YX *W
nkZ%%KZ[g rL\W ykZ ~ pVD

X Vf
e3**
3

*W<ec*
3%e
\W
/Z ? @*
7,
t
HkZ

X M
hW];<
\WQVB];

g0
+Z}g yZgz ZX Z~Vj u**
gzZh
+g Z Zg

X ~gzu"6,gKa}g  Za V Z+Z

~ i *,a
gzZ Vc*
!x lZ X C 7Vz:

X CVgzZ Z Zz=

pX [
7

z6, C Z! l
g Y Kg DZ Zz =
~ ZZ

X D Z V6 ,q ~ ZZ X =g f w%Z m,
ggzZ

wZ ZzZ
Z~ ikZXN*
zgzZ m,
gj~

X Y7,
**
h
+(
 Lg @*
r6,
u
zC
ykZtX 7

lV 3[c*
**
j]p Zu"tX _q
-Z

40

?VY Z}
.

lV 3yZ {zC ZyZ!*

W}gZ
# X CiX

Z { c*
i ykZ yZ6,VyZzz kZX D 7,~
X C7Za bkZg0
+ZX@*

3Z KZQ f
eqXZgpt gzZ V {z Z
# gzZ

@*
7 Z~ kZ Z g Z Zg ~ * TX D 3| (,
_kZgzZ 3Z { c*
i ]gzX 7c*
A 3 y Z

X ~~iwqgD)bZ
uZgp

~g Zl
Zz uZgp~ VCc*
F,
9 * ` Wp

[Z X  al 5 Zg 6 kZ d
$
KZa kZ

k0*
}g
CVg ~g  C=
~T e

1gzZ
Z Hg D Z]
.Z}gVgzZ uZgptVX CJ (,yizgzZ

X V5N*
gzZ Z ek0*
}g [Z6,
(V]}kgX V

 M
h HB}g gzZ#=
w1 Yt

Y ~:
M F,
J
-Z
# gzZ V ZyZg0
+Z }g

?VYXg F,
6,
V]gzZ
Z

r }gXu,
W(F,
)g0
+ZyZakZ

]gz Z]
.Z}gt,zBqhZ]cDqkZ m,
g

D3uZgp{h
+I KZ Z
# X  , kZ r }g X

DkC X  0Zx ]
/Z%o
Kz g0
+Zr 

r  Co ]
OZh
+q
-Z C7q
-Z {z 
{ 6 Z q
-Z ~ yZX C Za `g{ Vz 6 ~

} t s: X @*
6,
/Z% z {g!*
z L Lr  @*
B}0*
ze

 z^
>

41

XNZC
0Zo
K
tDbt DZ

Za uZgpt ~ ZZX _q
-Z kZt

Z
) !*
yEZYkZgzZ luZgpZ

X ~bZ
uZgp
G
G$
V 3E
_yZx)~g aVZgp i6

V Z !*
W}g ~ VZgph
+]
.pX ~ ~ ~g V2

iZ6, Zg7 ~g akZ gzZ =

{ c*
i}6,

X C Z
C!*
.h
_
+{ c*
i}6,
V]6gzZ

B]; e
\W
/Z 7]!*
&5ItakZ

g~g)
zDe
XB];<
\W
G
G
$_*uZgp6,
X 10;V 3E

-Z t &r Zg p 7g Z e
q

0u **
t [ZpX g ZzZa ~f t e
X _

XM
h Za b) kZ YC
!*
1t
/ZVY

X Z 7,
**
7oL!*
W}g

yZ ce I V- c*
X CW 6,<
{g!*
z c ~g t

GG$
X @*
0*
x Z
+ X6,
V 3E
_

? YZa}g{z CTH

?VY Z}
.

42

Kzg: Zizg ~g
G
E
5O.' Zg

y
KZz!*
]:SdZ F,
x  4=L L

( yzg Z eg e) X g U*
WZZZ ZkZg0
+Z

G$
4G
5E
~
w  G
_+Z F0~:r }g

0
+
i~* Ym<ZZ*tX }g(
ZaW

~gtpX ~uu ,z
/ZgzZ 7z6,
yZX C.

G
G
$

45 E
X 
CZ
+ I}g G
_tX [ZgzZ~gzZa

x Zz

X C7,
]gz}g

H~oq
-Z 6

~g %kZX _g !
~g x Zz

 Dg D Z
# vZ ~X 7eJ
- ;g Z g Z

kZ}g tXnwN ~g D qg Zg :

Kzg: Zizg ~g

43

XkZ{ `?X *
@YqzD W~*

y~ 1940 w1yY];C
~ ',
kZ

BgzW~yZ];k%Z+=zh
+'
kZ~X H

+Zz gzZ a ` kZ X e ]!*

6,a gzZ V
z Pgz 1}g t X @*
zz x Zz myxg
X **
Z6,
k',
Vzhz

V ]gz~
CZZzt IVZbzgE

**
( oxytocin) I Wm]sX@*
g6,
kZugz,
Mq
-Z

,{ c*
i^{W~}g !*
"
$gkZX C"
$gq
-Z

X7,

~
CDLZ
) !*
ZzDgegzZZ
#

x Zz  DY} (,Z
# X Q ~ NBgz

-gyzg kZmC sp
8
/ZX
8g(Z ^ zg

yxg+ZzgzZatX LggZ
',
(KZxZz@*
DY7,

X @*
oVgyxgVz(,
xZzZz0*

R
X @*
W,
O]}uz0
+
i Vz(,x Zz

6,
V~]qzzX $
VQ{Z
+kZV
7z

e~ Vz
/LggzZ
H@*
gZ ZgX 76,gzZ D

X ~~ggzZ
g~gZzV}uzgzZV

V i *wVlZ
.
**
-Z xZzg0
q
+Z!*
W}g
I
d
4)FgzZZzZ]c*
?gZV2 Q
z$
+ EG
C

s V|yZXA ~i
ZkZX H{E
+]gq
-Z

?VY Z}
.

44

X uh zz 3~g Zl{ c*
i } Z N*
z ]g{z

{z HkX N*

zt ~T c*
3g Y kZ6,g

ypVzhkZyZgzTg {0
+
iJ
-Vc*
VgpC
ikZ

~ ]q w V ]gt X g~ 1h
+{zgzZ ;g c

1gzZ ;g 0*
gzZ **
3Z i: X $
{g7{0
+
i%g Z

X ;g @*
kZVzg Y

V Zz! eV2zgzZV70
+
i KZizgC
x kZZz ` W

,zxZz|gX  /zg~]BVgzZ

LZ {z DhZzByZ0
+{ LZvs:X *
@Y 1t

y Z',ge X BV2z LZgzZ VZz!e LZ Vzg Y p0*

[{h
+I LZ^ ,Z hZz LZ b
z
X @*
kZ Dx kZX @*
B

9 t X  DhZz V Z}
.LZ vI C
gzZ

J e I @*
x ~ ]5 Ks: x Zz7
*gB, Zz ~$
+Z EZ q
-ZgzZ ZpZzB
X @*

g\ e gzZ Yc*
VZ~Z Lega!zq
-Z

-Z- [ZX @*
q
iZ \WgzZ @*
VZ6,
zZB; LZ {zX Y H

gzZ @*
VZ6,
zZuB; LZ {zX m1 3!*
i~fg ~g

V
KZ}uzX @*
iZ~i Z0
+Z VQ~KZ=L LZZ}
.
{ ~g
zC
Z}
.pM
hh mzzA c*
]%Z]B

X Lgk0*
}g

Kzg: Zizg ~g

45

kZ&9%yZ q
-ZX  Z~];i{C
bkZ

~<
|LZ {z c*
:
K |$
+!*
igzZ C!*
. K \!*
_

wJkZgzZ}g\ kZ \!*

q
-Z : Cl
Z kZ

kZ}q g~}g !*
Vh0
+
i Z}
.LZ {zX}

gzZ @*
]!*
\!*
!*
gzZy!*
$LZyZ }]!*
V-
}g !*
g\!*
LZ qV- ~}g !*
gkZ

X @*
y.6,
~

\WX C7Lzig W Zgq

-Zg0
+Z}g t |

y V6~uz 0
+
igzZ ] n~g FuVzg\ \WgzZ

\W%g Z}
. Lg\WZ
# ?+Zz \W ? X
\W ` W {0
+
i [Z {z
/ZXM
h
# V Z}
.+Zz

gzZ Vi D \W k0*
X By
KZ x q
-Z Z

6,
\W{z[Z YX 7
A &S%$
+Zg J

X VDg Z

gzZ s: {z Y Zg g !*
g !*
/Z Z}

. gzZ yZ! q
-Z

~ &
+
e vw }g @*
Z
DV Zz! e }g

gzZ @*
D]~g @*
X sp] @*
~g
X Yc*
, ;x ~g ~T 0
+
i ~zy
Z {z

p M
h7wN ~g +Zz}g X {z <
t

X 4+ Z}
.C
~g ?VzX YZ}
.

]
',
i {zt X @*
Z
+ZzL L][Z t <

XD V+ZtgzZ *
@YhZzy
KZBXC

?VY Z}
.

46

Z}
.D~Z
# % ZX M
h7{@xL~ 0
+
i {%izg

~g gzZ }~g7 ]Zp~g N ~g {z D qg

X Zz ;`
ZnyZV:VYJX e])
G
G
$_a
~ V 3E
]I b e
Vgg

XDZ
Zb
Z6,
gzZ(F,
][Zt <
Z` Wp
e
X CYg Z\G,
h
+
'
E!LIL Lg0
+Zy
KZzz
G
G
$_+Z ]Ib
~ Z]
.Z}gV2DZV 3E
G$
4G
5E
X a}g G
_t7tkZp ~
y\W ?*W c*
?
zg r%c*
~!DIH\W
? M{ c*
iZ

g\
gzZZz

X Cx ]gz Zz ZgzZ wJ<

X T eg6,
,EZgzZ Zz~p Z {

@*
Y 1831 {z Z
# X M
hN ~ 0
+
i yzg Z e g e ]!*
t

kZ N*
{ zZ
# X
rg6,{z
z kZ
H6,
^~dgLZY 1836
Y"

G
8
X
Xb}yYgwL }0
+
6,
{q 5F5],
Zb

{ c*
iX ' 7Y q Z Z 1g6,ykZ kZ yzg Z e
Y"
5F5 c*
}0
+
6, G
CyzgZ eZ
# X 7 Z}
.{z6,
gEZz
E
-
t
Hyzg Z e M7{E
+Xn
pgm **
FL L
X w$
+
BB
zzzspwj q Z Z

# g 0
|
+
igzZBV\ gKZ yzgZe~V
/Y 1837

g Z q Z Z
HH ZzbkZ ~ T( tree of life) c*

Kzg: Zizg ~g

47

g (
q
-Z {z &~gz LZ y
KZ L
L kZ X  Cg
/
X Vzg YZZ kZV&~X Hx&

Bg
/
z~ qZZ 1T 7Dg & kZ ZyzgZe
G-
~ !*
W L LJ 7,
! gW KkZ~Y 1838mXCzgVp

a {c*
i} kZg Y H7tkZ~T y*q
-Z6,VZ

XgzZ C4z]
.a w kZX D0*
$ D Za

X  Tg !*
z C
A &J(,
WgzZ Y $g0
+Z
X NkZ

kZ
z kZ X
H
z ~ g <
J
-yzg Z e p

~ VZ O

/q ]I
Y 1838 X _ ez z ZZ y

=~L LZZZX c*
{ W]LZZyzgZe
z

}g tV~p7{k
Hu;!*
gzZ: ZgZyZZ C=
X ~ (
yZ~Y 1839~g X ,Za Uu **
gq
-Zyxg

pX 1x 6,
b OCgLZJ
-
zkZyzg Z e

)(

Z kZ }Yyzg Z etzz ~zb

T ;g,)J
-wt
g Z Z yxg Vz J
-Y 1850 pX )g~ kZ

Z
/ DoBVgzZ ZZ {zX Y Y t
V
X
rg ~gYoKZyzgZegzZ DYg0
+ZZ
/agzZ ZZX *
@YJ
-

{oIyzg Z e D%kZ ]tB

$
ZekZZ
#

X
H
%

Dx6,m
)\WKZ Iwq
-Z % LZ ~ Y 1881

 ~L L:~Y 1839kZ~TJ 7,
ZZ yzg Z e

?VY Z}
.

48

Y: "
$U*
{z J
-Z
# **
: J
-
z kZ6,q ~ []c*

X Y7"
$U*
}: W,
O~}g!*
Vzq+Zf}gv

6,<
kZgzZ]yzgZeZakZ| ZZ

 'YV Y%~Z
# L LyzgZ enX C1p
pg:

X e aX WgzZ ag !*
FZ~

_+Zh
+(
t b
<
x Zz s:
Y4
Darwin: How [ KZ EjEwg X @
*
**
q Zg T

: q~to be a Christian and Believe in Evolution

+Zz}X zz k^q

-Z 6,Z}
.k0*
}L L

gzZ ~~X )h
+Z VzuF,
~
<
/ZgzZ|6

gzZ Y !*
z
hg6,Z}
.X  n
pg 6,Z}
.a

X Y?
~0
+
i ~

c*
s Z)Z}oNCm,
R
}g  7ip

 Y6,g Z]
.z ]!*
t X pZp
pg 6,<
yZ
G
G
$
45E
0z |
# ~
Cf}g [Z G
_
KZ~uzVY
 ~ (gyZ~}g !*
LZ  _

T @*

A &kZ f} g i W kZX }:-{z e

zQ]!*
kZX  ZVyZV~fyZ1

Vzq{h
+ **
M
h7N&D6,
kZs: CYW6,

D Za
A & "7,] Vzuz X  D

VhZz X bq
-Z X V :t }g {z e 
X D Y0
z
yZ

+ **
h
zh
+

49

+ **
h
zh
+
gVjz

ByYtZ
# {zx+F,
~y
KZL L

( yzg Z eg e) X **
0*
16,
VaKZ

z gzZf

akZ @*
7,**
x BVzuza KZ Va

z
A & 2 zG~}g !*
Vzuz V~f }g

%KZ  b~g }uz D Za at X

XM
h7NV~fyZp
/Z# ~g fX

fzt{z z c*
fzUq
-ZkZ

bzg J
-
z kZ X @*
73W~ VzgzZ  Dx Z Z

D 0*
(ZakZX Og: Z f J
-Z
#M
h7g
X  iZ r }g VY

?VY Z}
.

50

g bz

K) | Vzg !*
V\W ~ { Z r


uV gzZ ]Zp] C!*
.~ggzZ W ]:S
_
Dg6,]5~h
+T z{z r tX 

&t X ]ZgzZ ]ZpZ

A
+ Z yZ f V}uz
Z ZgzZf r X @*
ZaBkZ^C
CY 7-

BtgzZM
h ZfkZX @*
7~Vu
X }%i Z ZzzfDkCgzZ

D|
# Vzq %gzZ k^ V {zz Y r
T({zt X {)z ]wVVzuzgzZ {n CZ Zg 

w&

wq +Z  D{@x C
b )
Xce**
7

zf )} (,{zVY D W,
ZakZ ]I
yY"gzZg Z0
+Y~VLg bZX D Y~ z kZ
N D
w lptz1g Zp { 0*
X $
Y@
aX @*
7yZN D
wy
KZ ^pX *
@Y{g lx

p $

w} Zg Z LZ ,q {0
+
i Cg Ot ar
Xce**
7
wbV
KZVzqyY"
L8X C],
W;gE- ~"Z q
-Z Zz YK6,V

X c*
(
q
-Zj];

kZX *
@Y\E
a q
-Z 1q
-Z~

Y8 3[Z ;aHXi7wZF~}g!*
aV8
-

+ **
h
zh
+

51

B{zp Y78 3[Z ;a Ya? @*

c*
V KZ ;aH ?

g0
+Za }%q
-Z VLgyZX @*
c*
V KZ {z
XM
h7N {z&g6f +Zq
-Z

/ZL L: @*

Wt~^wZkZ Z~t
# IbZgt

1{8
- ?,kCH\W Yc*
yZgz\W
tkZH{C
b z zf Vp
/Z c*
3 ":
wj LZyZgzz~ 7q+Z6,
][Zt
XC7,
7]gz(F,
YaT!W c*
q
-ZtXH
~V!geX @*
UgzZq
-Z
CI~V
z 

VX @*
xX  D
z 


Zg Z}
. p FX  Dwd{ c*
i6,gY^W{z  D
X
z

Zzkzg ][Z t n Zg e
@*
b 6,wJt  @*
7, f, Z q
-ZZz kZ

I][Zt X CZgz {%c*

{0
+
i&&gzZ 0
+
i6f y
KZ
yZV}uz  D4Z ~ V~f}gZ
+
E
4& Vz Zg ZyZgzZ]
/F
g0
+ZkZgzZfX D { W6,E
X Lg Z

T ZZ {z 'z zfgzZx Zz

c*
gza+ Z
+ If}g 1XM
hyYj{z
X YY

?VY Z}
.

52

9[  Wa
g6,
+ **
h

*
*gZ]!*
kZpw]Z**
6LL
G3$kZ
6,
]Zz]z@*
yZgZ ~zb
G
X ~|&
6,
V\gzZVzg7ZkZ

( yzg Z eg e)

uZg Zz

tiuZzxwq fk0*
\W,n

X V e**
]
KZ x ~ ]gkZ X t \W{z
Vzuz C7,
]gz]!*
kZX C6,
!*
W}g]!*

X V:VYzZVz~g{z{Zp3Y]ZgzZ]

%){z 
A &t g0
+Z V
KZakZ

h sp CZ 9
M
L oyZgzZ  M
h t V

X D{C
bkZ: ZizgZ~X 

 9[  Wa

53

okZgzZ]!*

\W Z(Z LB\W H

Yw$
+w$
+z]Zg L\W H ?c*
W~~f\W[Z
c*
m,
? ~ (
\W H ? !~}g !*
Z0 ~ c*
Z

? g6f
Zpg Z~{ Z 9

A yZ q
-Z  CY 0*
t
A &
',
iq
-Z ~ V
KZ

h {q
M
-Zg0
+Z f LZB
z ~ k!*

6,t\WX cB\WX @*
Zi W{(gzZ
z 

\WX **
~/kZ\WpX T e**
]gm[ZgzZ
  D { i Z0
+Z ]!*
kZgzZ  Dg 6f kZ

{%izg LZ \WZ
# @*
;g
z kZ
t X 3 g H.

decoupled ) uZg Z z kZ X  D sz^~ V

X}oItgzZ *
@Y ( cognition

A &t X  M

hz ]qgzZ(
zuZg Z LZ

^ X Y Y ~ V VZgzZ fm
yZz6,

{z p e L
1 t }Y^ X Y ~Wyh Qe L
1
~Wyh QBkZgzZ 4K~Wyh QZi Z0
+Z|

X ;gzuZg Z LZ^X
8]:S

suspension ) VxL
L nkZ~VIgzZVZg e n

{z ;g6,+h Y\WX @*
wEZ Z ( of disbelief
{0
+
igzZ -Zg Z BtZ \Wz!*
kZX 7|
X
Huhg Zq
-Z c*
{ n
/
>
Zzg tgzZ

# X ~gza~/gzZ
Z
Z c*
gT t ~V!*

?VY Z}
.

54

gzZ  M
h^ wz  D Z hz6,]{%izg LZ

pg c*
n
z ]5BfZ LZ X  M

h Y6,VZ~ V

x tX f
e~/w 0 n kZ
zX 

X @*
6,
g: BVyZ
~ wqv X Cg6fBV)
!*
W| (,
WqX Tg D'!*
~! ZBVzm,
Zz%
*
* @*
Z s~ kZX CY sp~ ] Z}
.gzZ Y7
X *
@YWzZ h{],
Z ]BV

tV4,
k6f

g0
+Z f }g t X
A &6f 0Z ]q
-Z uZg Z z
E
2$fx(Zq
.G
,gtIkZX@*
BxE
-Z

e (Z]zZ ZgzZX {z @*

f
't}

+
MgzZ ]ZpZ
+ kZ "7,]Vzuzg0
+Z}g X 

X D 6,

CZgzZ
A & Cg+ Y~}g !*
/8F~}g !*
X V Y bhZ \WqG
VyZ Zg f
kZ \WX  g a H
z kZ {z M
h CB4g {\W

kZ X  n
pg a H~ }g !*
\W {z  M
h { i Z0
+Z ~ }g !*
gzZ ygzZ
zy Z]
.Z}g 6,
g
A&

X ~~tzgKZ ._kZQ

uZz {zX $
e
$ ZZ y
KZ
A &ti%z

Vzuz s: ~TDyz{BVzuz gY

g|7,f Zg}uzDgN t Dg|7,y;fZ

 9[  Wa

55

pX 4yW
tVY 7y { c*
i6,
]!*
kZX 
X 7 (Z~Z

XBZzW]ZgD\WgzZ~6,
gwV

Zuz }Yq
-ZC
~X c*
K
M F,
/q
-Z

kZX $
k
,
= Y\WpX hZzJ
-u"kZ

Wk
,
}\WV }Y ~gzZ **
W6,
z = \Wa
m
\W~}g !*
:KZ~ Y \WgzZX m
]

D Z\W V *
@Y V k
,
{ qz~ Z
# X V!*

 Y \WgzZ  lp
z )0*
~\WV }Y~X 

7]gz%1 q
-Z X V Yp\W~ M
hNgzZ

T M
h g r y
KZ q
-Z ~ T x N*
gq
-Zt X ~ 7,
y
KZ kZ X  } Zg ZgzZ ]C]~}g !*
Vzuzg0
+Z

kZX  M
h} "
) !*
kZgzZ M
hg r

/ZX lp ]!*
kZ {zX  M
hyyY
/y q
-Z

X lp{zD YyY @*
o lp

A &6f )gzZq

-ZtX e
$ ZgZL1
L q
-Z PMkZ

$ Zg Z
e

:bkZtX

X V~L L

X !?V~L L

X !?!?V~L L

%Zuz

%Z

X !?V~!?V~L
L %a

?VY Z}
.

56

:,bkZ[Z

X yZ=L L

X zI[kZ ?yZ=L L

I[kZ?yZ=!*
kZ ?V}Y~L L
X D

%Zuz

%Z

]!*
kZ"V }Y~ce **
]!*
kZ"L L

%a

X I[t"yZ=

-Z Zg f [ZX  $
q
~p._]q'!*
~gtC

T g]!*
W,Zq
-Z]gq
-ZX ,gwqgY

wZ]g w%pX g Z{z wkZ~}g !*

w T ;gN0
+
z{ ]gkZ~q
-Z}#X
kZgzZ ',
{z }Y{zVY g^B%kZ ~kZ

Xnt0
+
z{LZ @*
gZz{z YXg!$
+

Vg a H !t {zt gzZ ] Vzuz

X ~gzu"a]Y WnkZ
X V
rg~L L

X LeZ}
.V
rg~L L

X ,B+
MhZLeZ}
.V
rg~LL

B+
M hZ Le Z}
.g?V Le~L L

X ,

%Zuz

%Z
%a

n
pgVzggZ]!*
kZ ?VLe~L L %VZv0*
X ,B+
M hZ LeZ}
.

 9[  Wa

57

<
CZ f L Le
$ Zg Z Zg} e 0Zg yZ ];

e
$ Zg Z Zga q
-ZQ `b\W
/ZpX

kZ X Og \W H \WZ ~g6f \WgzZ

X @*
W~z <
Y  L L

\Wt Bt|<
Y\W
/Z

kZgzZNYm\W ,Z Zg ,v0*
\W
/ZX @*
7

kZ Z
LZvX Z e <
C L L \W b

X,(Z }uzDc_

$ Zg ZkZZa
e
A &%1~V\W

tq
-Zt kZgzZ , 6,l
a LgX M
hN
A &

Zt[ZX Y(
~kZ W~(,{zX BYZW

\WZgzZ Wt^ X Y `gz VVz\W{zBYZ

X }{g (
Z qz{g !*
zg~B;

{g!*
z {z Y\WtgzZ  YkZ\W }Y {z

X Le o

zgZ~gzZ\W
/ZX $

Cy!*
ic*
$ZgZt
e

[
L LKj  YVz s1
 YtgzZ Y
Q  Y~ m,
Z
/ZX H
&Q L Lb Z  Y}uz
X H E
e @*
Z Zg Z CZ **

g ~}g !*
Vzuz

mgzZ {ua X V Y: c*
V YVzuz
G$
4G
5E
X *
@Y 9 bzg L LV\WaZh
+(
 g (Z G
_

?VY Z}
.

58

T M
h~
.Z ] ~}g !*
yZ V\WVzuz

z c*

+ Y ]zZg0
+Z V VXC
!*
c*
\ LZ Z]
.Z }g

|0
+!*
a, Z \W
/ZX *
@Y+ Tt

X 3gNt\W }Y7\W

yWyZ];;gE- `{C
b
A &kZ

~@WV}uzg0
+Z}g  c*
C ,0Z] V,ZX H
UX 
A &"7,B4g {] C!*
.FN
_

X V: Y&M
h} i Z0
+Z {~}g!*
, Z

]!*
.
_

Zzg0
+Z ~gs: \!*
LZ c*
Z}
.

<
t X  ]!*
.& _gzZ q
_
-Zzz q
-Z kZ
X $
}~KV U
DgZ2Z6,
]*]0
+
iKZ6,
g~g)

B Vzuz  D .
gzZ %1 ~ Z
# X

~g Vqt]X D YDA
$%Vq]
] Zz W~Z X  ]:S0*
,
k
,

X DwEZ6,
g
Ca
D @*
',
bZB]g~/6,
gwV

]gt f
et X D~ V',
LZ 
D HB}g v~}g , @*
', (z B}g
]!*
t
/ZX  f
e wJ e ~ zg "bzg LZ gzZ
X ,u|zB}g ]gDqf
e

 9[  Wa

59

]Dq e  s J e ~ zg Z ] LZ yZ

X: VYx3,
u|

?Sm
yZz6,
VY
A &]!*
.
_
KZ QwZ
~r

?K}g7V_ykZ ?Kib)ykZ

{zB] ZwEZ
^g (
L
L ]!*
.
_

D HB] Z~LZ   NbzggzZ ]!*

.
_

-Z {z e **
g Z2Z6,] ]Dq~ ]q+4X

,gXiW,
( }]q
c*
V]
} 7,
G}u6
zDmY *C
Z
# H
zkZ
XNYK]bBV

^6,X D{@x Vh, Z: Zizg ];+

C

yZgzeZ
# X  s Z e W,
Z t6,]Dq]: Zg F

0=g f ` pZ &
+]]!*
.
_
ZC
t]!*
.
_
Yc*

V!*
yZpX CY

g]!*
.x yZ ? mH<
_
6,{)z V *%\!*
W |X D W~
wzz <

: D Y0]!*
.
_
+ tvtQX  D
CZf bZ

Z e V I X {)z ] q
gzZ +Zz
KZ

]!*
.
_
g0+Z!%~ X D Wt ],Z ]zZ

X
) !*
e
$]IkZ

?VY Z}
.

60

XgzZ
**
za
KZZ}
.

*
@Y H Zgz =6,kZ t kZ L L

( yzg Z eg e) X

6,qC
t e
$ ZZ
KZgzZ q
-Z Zz Y ~ h <

X |&
]:S
KZ

L6,ga p @*
y ga 6,\W VY (Z

\W VY (Z [i ZzW{ i Zzg\W

/Z ?@*
7y

HZ YkZ/ H{ i Zzg!t

spN 9KZVp (
|
# g^ q
-Z VY (Z ?

@*
VYwtV *gzZ ;g WZ] *
@ Y,
-
#C
 w ];E
LG
?W]n

q ~g Z
# g c*
gz kZ }g ]Zz W',n

XgzZ

61

X CBaustralopithecines
~ { I ~g g Y ~g DngzZ @*
Z6,Vg Z` Zg
z kZ
kZ }hng0
+Z}g J
-[Zgz kZXTg D r
X
] %{z 1T *
C
@Y c*
0*
yDgq
-Zg0
+Zy
KZ

@# y
*
KZpt ]zZ ZX g Z
Zzgg : q

A & Zg Z [ Vzi ZzW c*

V~h
+X

y
K}{z bkZVY B ~ Z]
.Z}g
Tga gzZg Z +
$Y }{z kZXV D 0*
$ kZ

\WtkZ/B8
-Nt\Wt4XV
X 8
-6,
zZ

!Wx
/
u{ c*
i]gz|
#

W gzZ ( x
/
u { c*
i ]gz) ~!
A &t

]gz|
# ZX CW~
w( k{ c*
i]gz)

X *
@Y ( hyperactive agency detection device)!Wx
/
u{ c*
i
A yZ s:tVY mZ ez CZ ~ zF,
]I!Wt

X  D y
KZ t X @*
Z
Z,jkZ ]i YZ

{ c*
ig @*
- c*
bzg$
+]Q mnkZ r Zg Z
#

V@ yZ a }g  zz V_
A &t X Lg 7

Cg $
i Z0
+Z W,
Z6,V70
+
i ~g Vit 't gzZ **
n


Y
Zpg +Z
/Z **
n
tCg ZX

X *
@Ysp~W~(,
**

ZpgX $
w$
+~g {z

62

k~ }g !*
^
KZgzZ ]:Sk { gZ ~g

?VY Z}
.

QQ y

KZ(C
n r Zg V6& Zg Z ~uz
X YN

( :{nZ@*
Z~szZgc*
,
k
(q)}6,
W(,
6,
+e
0

tXf
eN
W Z}
.L L~k
,
zV !*
Kv

@*
W7
z kZ1gzZ q
-Z X 6,tgzu[ kZ k
,
z

XV Zc*
V !*
}}zg VEVE)xZ
#

**
-* X ZtL Lc*

;g~VyW `W L L\W

y7 @*
',}0
+
Wk-iX Wxq
-ZgkZ
X C[Vzi Vj5Vc*
6,
VgzZ @*
y~g

][Z t wdgzZ uZg Z z  7 \W

8
-NtgzZ kB Z]
.Z LZ ?Za ]Zg
D{ W6,
qd Zx ? VJ
-Z
+ ][Zt

X D{ Wag e kZ t%) jg pgzZ

GG$
p
pg6,Z}
.q
-Z w]Y: V 3E
_yZ

v]!*
. 0
_
+
i {%izg KZgzZ qdkZ X  D Yg a
*
*B}g t p
pg t ~ T

{ kZgzZ Sg J
-u ~(,gzZ %)tpX Se
? Csp~Z}
.tX DT
$6,
gZz

N* gzZw+ZY Z 5Z
{d%X w+Z YZ 5Zt X  D6,
{

XgzZ

63

V * *
*BVzG~
C yZPgzZ*
*6,

X kZ (Minimally Counterintuitive Worlds)

,%q
-Z\Wp7,~kZX Bk
,
~n

{ bq
-ZgzZ H ` Z 5Z %6, @Z \WX 

izgC
BVw+Z YZ 5Z \W  DZ * Z Z \W
/Z X  6,
X 

GG$
k
,
**
BV 3E
_~uz
A &6, {

wJZ Q Z z N*
gq
-Z
/ZX

~gt X Qt Xf
ek
,

X @*
Vziq
-ZyxggzZN kZ V *

zf YN* tt63Zq
-Z r
KZ

# g Z (,~r !*
|
- 4,
q
y\WY \W
/ZX Cg c*
gzZ
Cwqw\WgzZ }#
%g\W} \W

6|
# g L LVakZ ?VYX,7i6,
kZ\W
X gVc*
igzs { c*
i

\W|
# g ~ VZg 0
+e}g7  Y \W
/Z @*

?VY Z}
.

64

X y Zz !g c*
{ c*
it X B6,kZ \W e
7N

P|
# gp
/Z X 6,A ',
Z',w!*
s |t VY ?VY

A &KgzZG

g i ZzW
KZ6,gwV []:S
KZ

~
/
% kZ X Lg |
# g |
# g z!*
kZ p **
3 g6,kZgzZ

,q~g {z~ kZgzZ Z9~ r !*

 Sg |
# gS

) !*

pZ 6 z Y } hQX  C~ |
# g  
-Z :g ~ \W g VEz Y yZ Zg f
q

X
C

sm
q
-Z CY0Q~y
WgzZ gg J\zg sm
]gzp

@7
-eZ e$ CV V~ ;T

X g~ (
} ZPzgzZ CY0z


A & V * yZ ~g

VX
CbZigzZwJgzZ ]I

J e ~
/
% <
Z x ,z @*
yW **
6,VE z Ya

gZ !*
 @*
6,]:SC;c*
C K ~
C

X Lg gzZV7

* {%izggzZ x ][Z t ~ V *

y
KZ]Z g c*
s: ZUt X Lg Z Z a

g = @*
w E Z a f b) ~ z ~
C

X DC
!*
G
GG34]!*
~- ~^*
~(,{ c*
i **
gt X D-6,
V/gzZVa~x Z` **
Z~y t{z 78
-6f

XgzZ

65

C^VWBZg @*
- `g ~-q
-ZZg {z C{

C h Z\0*
Z ZggzZ CX Vjzg$
+gzZ V-g FV
KZgzZ
GG3G
4]!*
YC
igzZ Va Zz ;n% q
-Z
6,g~
CX

p Z]
.z~hqq
-Z~kZX C{ Vzg Y Zzg

]g*%pc*
} *%~g Z.X ~ |a
V!*
x
X g#
s,q!*
6

Va~{z X 6,g K(C

Z}
. <
Z Z',
Z

Z}
.{zkZpX$
+c*
V(~ a a~ }Y {zX 3Zz

,q ~g {z6,T ,+Z q
-Z {z X
KZ qC
~}g !*

Y ` Z'
rgzZ" zg lF,
{z X  $
6,%  C

X by
KZx !*

X D YD6,
{d%

|X  D!]:S
KZ x { Z}
.<
Z

gzZ V ]:S

KZx X Z}
.gzZ y
KZ} B

kZ kZJ
-
zkZX Dmgz-ZBZ}
.

,:g6,]Z +Z, ZgzZ v: ~}g !*

kZ J
-Z
# @*
7

*
@Y Hg~}g !*
V Z}
.X ]gz` Zz "7,f

V Z}
.X  DgzZ DkC ! b V
KZ x {z

~
Ca<
C
gzZ  ]zG~
Ct ~}g !*
X Dx

kZQ 3ZzVa~g Z}
.
/Z ?_ VY v

[Z wZkZ ~ !*
? C kCVY ]gz ]!*

?VY Z}
.

66

<
x:Zz gzZX Y kZ Z
#
7
z kZ sZ}
.:

X D YW6,
"
$U*
g

?g}d
$
\WLZ H

R
p

} Vzuz W ~(,Q , \W LZ
/Z

m{ {z n
pg m} (,yZ
(x 6,X  M
h
\WLZkg Z MZgzZ Z LZ {z|gX g[NZ{

X Dg

-Z wW L L Zg egZ ~ Y 1947 Hg W'O%Z
q

-Z ~Zg e kZ X mZ e zg6,
q
R
p Zg et X F6,E

}g 0*
RZ T @*
F,
Vzi6,[Zy

1yY ~1

& {~LZx ZZ Zg X D Y
\WLZJ
-w&{zwZ e6,g LG
{z @*
{z Cg DW CZ
# X Lg VzuzgzZ
b~g7 6,kZgzZ ;g
t a> ~1gzZ yZ0
+{ LZ

X
rg

ZgzZ CgDWR
pkZ bt q Zg e

X @*
7,
**
o|

/ZX Za}oI
A &R
py
KZ

~qJ<
R
p Z NV~f LZ vI

X CZ Zg ZZ (,

pg6,
n
Z}
.q
-ZvI
/ZX VbC
pg{z e

VY 8
- ~ Vaga X \W LZ
z V1 {zQ 

XgzZ

67

7\W LZ {z
/Z }Y bhZzq
-Z V~f yZ ? D

{z M
h{zX ,7t
~ ugzZ V1 NX
X l{6,
^yZ yZpn
pg

KZ v ? yk ? D ZVY v I

D Y ug6,HcuX 7Z}
.D, ZV
H0
+
i

DVzm,
LZgzZ LZgzZD ~Vg VLZ

:o Z L L:g6,cVg q
-ZX  D{C
b ~g Zfa
6,

C~T{z ._b|)u~h t

gZg e%~( Rapture,]5}JZ6,

zZ }i |

I
/ZX ;gGVzgZg e}uzgZg et
z kZ !

n {zXtC
p V Z}
.]g @*
gzZV Z}
.<
Z}uz

X @*
0
+
i bV-C

X,0
+
i bV-C
{zn
pg Vzuz

X  ~ y Z ~0
+
zZ}
. f
e 7n
t gzZ  D Y ug6,Vo cu

: y6,]!*
kZ VI D Y ~ ]!*
kZ ~ * ! f

,Z c*
yCZ**
# zz X  Dg Z
Z
/0
+
i 1<
{z,O

pg6,<
n
Zz D o V, Z yZgz Zz

X C]~(,


t~"7,
M
+
6,%gzZ ~ gD e
$g1 kZ &t  bC
kZ

C
X DYt~"7,
c*
Vz ZgZ
KZ gwZe}gze

?VY Z}
.

68

a kZ `W L L 6,g wVX 7 kZ ]zZ Z 

 D v<
 X c*
7B ~pKZ~ lg!*
X : Zz Zz~V70
+
iyZ

x ~VD7{zV
8n
+
MgzZ(kZ

akZ}{z eCa7a \W
/ZX
3" Xa ? Da}0
+
6,X ~yZ VM

z kZ +Zz VX
/
g" KZ yZg Y @*
? Ca

?VY L L 7g !*
,zg ZD
^!&yZZ
# 0Q

~ a X  D b
C
Z]
.zL L{z
H~}g!*
V

o & Cq q
-Z
t X *
@Y ( promiscuous telelogy) ]c*

zg kZ * CY ~ T F,~
Cq
-Z

p%Vz(,
aX Q~K]c*
VkZX Y

* 6,gZa
g0
+ZX f
e Za g * {gzZ Z}
. l

X xX  Zzp
pg6,

qC
{z C]gzZX D7x{ c*
i} (,

K l~ p <
|g X ,l
X

] L L: `g V- p<
~6,gwV

Zgz ]Z
# 6,gm{Z
+ 0gzZ :
L

X Y
y
KZ

u Zz Vzg Y B Zz p
pg sw/ sw6,!*

~g ZV
KZ Vzg YD Ywt {zX **
#
}
.V
KZ

XgzZ

69

XB;Z (,
yZ~p
pgg Z
',
wj }igzZ H Z Zg Z

C ~g Z ~K O Cg
) !*
e
$

'takZ @*
qC
BVYX

@*
**
t]!*
kZa}g X Z bg Z 0
+
i *
@Y
G
G
E
28Eg Z
.G
~gz)X @*
zz ( mutations ) EG3$ ZgzZ g~ E

**
~K g Z"gzZ0
+Z0
+
igzZZp&
+
e6,
g
X 4yW{ c*
i *ZgIzz

gzZz ~ 0
<
+
i C]gzZa q
-Zg0
+Z}g

X @*
Zg7]gzkZ

?VY Z}
.

70

G
'
+
Y~g7zig W~g
*
*ntuWZ}
.
$ Z~ Vzg YZg X]:SYtL L
e

jZ!*
W}gZ 7gZ
( yzg Z eg e) X j OCgHq

x Z Z g

" ~ Y 1961 ]!*

5G
G
t X  Dx Z Z { c*
i ]gz g
Y
Y E
4H_
*$X Wt ~"gq
-Z *$ 5G5 ];C
q
-Z ;gE{c*
iz Yc*
sg
/Z HC
t~"kZ
XgDu(
s %kZ D

L LZg"q
-Z Z
Z
6,,
MZZsxP  3Zz**
"kZ \W
/Z
Y
X ]N }*$gzZ"Z\WXN
Xz z}g ]Z/$
+ z
)ggzZ x Z Z

G
'
Y~g7zig W~g +

71

[p<
]Z yZ X @*
J e V-zg }g +
$Y Vg

kZX zy z @*
- c*
Z}
.LZX z]\!*
V LZX @*
wEZ
X z quW

] Z

]zZ Z~ TL L: V- z Zuz p<

~
*
@Y Hq Z ]5 0
+
i
KZ 1 T *
@Y c*
0*
Z

t ZgzZ y
KZ%<
   v, Z X
X !*
]!*
tX Y~g

W z ~g t Z X  g Y (6,gZa

{z @*
: { i Z0
+Z 9gzZ !*
W}g
/ZX 7]gz<
av
XM
h{g: #
sL~Vz
/Y

,~[!*
,f X( mirror neurons) V sW

s]Z Dg]!*
kZ  @ZF,Z {z
X 7UZakZgzZtzgZ5

pX  Vi ZuZz  @*
b 6,Wt gz
KZ

s Z !$
+ z 3g ~g^ g0
+Z Vzg Y }uz

X D Y0*
]!*
.{)zax ZkZ
_

VqX *
@Y c*
g Z
~
. ]Z
KZ q ]:S{zt

q m{ ce **
Y 6,g{V Z { g ZgZ
X D~gzabzg

CX BB g Z } g Z V-zg Z
X q C{ c*
igzZX Z

72

?VY Z}
.

"
5G
& Hc*
g yZgzZxw0*
yZ];;gE- G

kZ Za Z **
gzZ s ZgzZ}',gzZiZ 9gzZ ~ V{
X @*

-ZgzZ km
q
6,
zZ~h N q
-Z
Hc*
3 q
-ZVyZ Z
#

s g cg CZ V mZ e^zg c*
@*
kZ c*
gzZ

Y {z kZ X 1 h- Zz % Z e ^zg gzZ 1

x w0*
X IZ g Z p q
-ZgzZ eg
tT @*
q{Z
+{ c*
i **
x ]zZ ZaV
KZ L L
C Z
zz q
-Z kZX _q
-Z "Y Z',c*
YZVzuz

X YZa ]ZgZ ~
C

nt6,
l
 ~wVaq
-Z~[!*
,v0*
\W

^k XZ 7
- m*`
 + wVt X

VyZgzZ V,ZX I],

Z eq
-]c*
Dg Z~

Za  IyZX Wt '!*

5T 6,
V
X Hp} (,
 Ig Z

{ ^
,Y VE6& V~ V-zg { \z
/+
E

"
5

5gz GX @*
EG
kZ Zz ~I s Z~ V HC

Zr ZrZ V KZ a / wz
Hc*
3N~-i
+z
X ~%i ZgEq
-Z

y!*
ig0
+Z
 b%Z
/Za ~g x Z}g

bZX Hy!*
ipKZgzZ 
A &I

wyZ X  H,gZ pKZgzZ x Zg0

+Z

G
'
Y~g7zig W~g +

73

gzZ g pZ]
.z }g ,g {z gzZ  f
e z z LZ Z

X M
ht
9gzZ%<
X Ci Z0
+Z W,
Z6,
g C!*
.
_

gT ~g)gzZ ~gg0
+ZTx ZC
q
-Z]Z ~g

-Zr  x ;
q
i ZL Lq
-Z {z kZX  
X *
@Yc*
0*
~{m{
E
H"
orbitofrontal ) Lg 5
gzZ x Z gzZ C!*
.}g
_

z{zt X Zz~ Vzr  D Y 0*

~ ( cortex
8{ ^

,Yx }g g0
+ZkZgzZwj Y6,gm{gzZwj 

X  D 3 g jg p C ~p~ wj Z
# X Lg

{g ) kZ t
/Z X  Dxl kZ ~p
/Z
X egC!*
.~g q
_
-ZtX Dg (Z

~ X g Z f g Z }g { r
B C ~igz s yZ

/ZX 
zLaZ **
gzZ yv
D 3 g jg p6,Vzg (
Z vx X  D 3 g

X D]gkZt
Dp @*

Y
]!*
*$ 6@*
rt Vg
p
/Z

Vg  D]!*
.Zg0
_
+Z}g H"
$U*

~gZ zg0
+Z\z
/LZT~A
$%]B

X D q yZgzZBYZVyZX MC

kZgzZTgo Z sXM
h|
# Vz
/Yg {

JZ
# YH:gZJ
-
zkZ6,
yZgzZu{zD]!*
E
2$ , Z q
.G
xE
-Z V X , : "
$U*
IZ kZ \W LZ {z

?VY Z}
.

74

X $
Yy
KVz
/Yg {
]1T H Z Zg Z

}gt X Z_UgzZq
-Z ]!*
.Zgp}g
_

Za kZ ~gZ **
Zz Za
}vg0
+ZZ]
.Z
~]YkZt ~gZ **
p**
X V-gFT

Y1x #
gzZWT
H0/_
.Zg!q
-Z ~gZ **
X c*
Wg

kZ X VC
!*
{z
/
 *
@Yc*
Z
Z,Z6,
gx:
KkZX

# C1
Z
zkZgzZ
H16,
VzqgzZVVI

X CY
)$
+
~yZc*
CY~igzs ] gZzYkl

LZ 1 X g T [{z ]Z Zg!*
}g

K]!*
kZX  D"
$U*
$O hg C!*
+
.g p
_

{h
+I KZ\WZ
# X ,.
g ZVh C1) a

VY Y Y7 Z
# X Ci Z0
+Z W,
Z6,\WgzZ @hZ\W{z 

"
$U*
$O ht p D kZ \W
+

N :mgg pkZ eXl

X ZZag0
+Z\W

VziZ gzZg ZgpbZg0

+Z}g

z VzL Lf}g X  D"

$U*
g Z b

t Xz r @*
B( cerebral cortex) LgwQ
X @*
oR Zg gzZ @*
C ];z g Z

gzZ *
@Y W
6,g C!*
.}g ]zZ zq
_
-Z r }g

]6,g <L L T M
h } g Z
x9, Z zz kZ
X VD

G
'
Y~g7zig W~g +

75

ZC
<
@*
~g)zZ (,
C!*
.}g a
_

et X y WV
H0
+
i ~g Z
] ~g] Z
/Z pX ( { c*

i B Bp I)

M
h
@ OeupKZ\W ,z 6,p Z!*
\W

*X ] Z d
$z , Z ~ <
Z}uz ( 7:21 ])

@Z)y
KZ`W  ~ 7,~ Vzg Z +Z I
{c*
i AZ ~
CKZgzZ,~zc]Z
I\WX 
XVZz~gZk0*
]Z{ c*
iZ\W,wEZ

(Z e
g {z& C{z ]Z{

X
Hc*
T C{z ]Z I X 7c*
a
-Z <
q
X CZ
];z k^a6,x Z
I

~v W3tc*
M,EZ& @*
Z

Wz{z
/
,Z
gm <
D CI v{zX YXW

6f D 1 <
X yW { c*
i } Q
X C7,
**
ay
**
Z

];~g Z g

E
2$6fn
.G
 ZBVE
',
i, Z g Z V
KZ

F,
6,
V
ZVzgZ ggzZh mByZ+TVzgZ g

LZ~L L: CWt ~]z Z6,q

-Z]!*
tX ~

X s V
Z~gzZy
/Zsy
/LZ~gzZZs
E
28EyZ}g ~g s: ]Z: ZgZ gt
.G
a E

e kZ g Z Zg X D Y0*
K
g0
+ZVzg Z g}g ~gz

76

?VY Z}
.

X V}g g0
+ZX F,
VyZ Z

zgX HwEZ]: Zg Z gyZ <

<
Z

ZX *
@Y J
- V L
L
L LVX wV{q
-Z kZ~

\!*
klL L\7 X DB L L<
ZgZ
#  \
!*
L L~g0*
b
X *
@Y al
g klL L<
pgzZ

M F,

gzZ CVzgzWp ` WwEZ ]!*

.: Zg Z g
_

V-)~g Z gyZgz kZX @*

Z Zg Z~
C~
) Z{z
/LZgzZ

} PVgg
M F,
gzZg Cy>X *
@Y Z hZ h

6,
VgzZV g Z',LZ D(
p~yZX D

+Z X  Dgz VZ0
+{ Z LZ gzZ ',6,bZz Y J e

kZ 7zJ
-Vzgjs]

X M]
A Vzg Z g
" Z Z
5G
!p~(,
]!*
kZ^g7gq
-Z Y 2010y {g VZ 6,HH

VY c*
O\!*
LZ I ]q
-Z {Z L L: CC

X ;gx wW` O%Z~t Z{z

W
6,~g Z g Z ~g Z g { <
~ RkZ

O\ !*
+s} ] !*
Z
.~ ZZs:X
_

u**
J
-u<
 @*
C
kZX 1 :

KZ { c*
i
V; y
KZ yCZ **
~M%Z

X Y

v 918 ~ y N*
4,
 ~ Zz kZ X Zzz <
yv V70
+
i

t **
X p8 909 ~X uh

G
'
Y~g7zig W~g +

77

X Hq
-Z **
4,
W\z
/

bV; 0*
-Z Z V70
q
+
i KZ V 909 yZ

?1

~$
+kZ D z6,, Z \W

{zgzZ: {zZ
# *
@Y| (,
zkZ z\W ?@*

{z

6,x **
Z}
.gzZ ~ _Z }gzZ !Z eg ZD
q
-ZC
4,
 X}

X
H *q
-Z~M%Z! Vzh
+%LZgzZ}g } hp

~(,Z<
X z ]}g }zQgzZ:

CZgzZ , Zj kZ\W LZ  H{z X @*

wEZ 
X ,y!*
J

-g Z g LZ
zWyp

uB} LZgzZ<
\W =

P \W~ ] g I ~

/Z ~ ]gkZ ? hZz J
-

P6,g Kgz Z gzZ { x Zg W) { DZ ] g +Z X VN

X C

?VY Z}
.

78

VNZ{c*
izc*
z~?Z
#
wEZ ~d )gfxgI

VzgzZ~iZ qZZmgzZV!*
iZLL
( yzgZ ege) X W~z~gq
-Z

E
2$6f, Z ] g I bZ
.G
~f VE
+ gzZ ]I

Xa}uz Z g ZzZa

z F,
yZ p
pgg Z
',Z
+ Zi W{(gzZ
z ] g

qJ]If ~ ZZ X Dx V

+ IYc*
Z
uzgDt
/ZX @*
k
,
+W,
5
Z H~p
pg6,yZgzZ

`g {Vz 6 r ,Z] gpX YHj J ee6,

g q
-sp~g ZpgzZC Za C!*
.h
_
+

~ ZZ D(Zq
-Z ]ZZzgzZ]

X @*
g!{ c*
i}Z b
Z

VN Z{c*
iz c*
z~?Z
# 79

**
wzN)g f] g~d

 rZ e W,
Z6,V ~ ZZ,Z Z ] g

~g T C oh
+'
e
$b!*
ZgzZ  Dg
X *
@Yg W,
Zziq
-Z V~g)gzZ
Z]
.Z 1}g  <
Zq
-Zs~ * p q
-Z

` W{ i Z0
+Z *kZX H~i
ZIwg ZD
,@*
k.` W

X YYc*
_] gV
KZzgz

Zh [Z   y i
Z
~ Vz
/yZ

~, F (Z q
-Z Zuz X D 0
+
ig DJ
-IY

}g !*
yZ X Lg~ y &
+Z ],
Zb
~ wX Ut X Z * J
-

gzZWhgi
Z
 ]!*
VyZt *
@Y ~

!*
W Y7Wy
s !*
gzZ kz&
+ZV;zQgzZy*zyg
/
[{k
,

b
i
Z ._ V_ CQ  }!*
Z 7W}X
XW~^q
-Z

g
CVX RX6,g0Z]<
ZbDVyZ

6g!
r }g VzqyZC
?VYX6,
.zgzZz
]
]!*
. ZzgzZ ~gZp OZ sp  D `g {}
_

g\W
/Z Hc*
g <
g! Z Z]
.Z }g X  D Za

~<
Z xZz Y 0*
~ *\Wi!*
<
ZZ kZ B

i
ZIwq
-Z  zZ {z
/
LgkZ bTX }

zg {c*
g{z
/kZ<
x bZLg~V Zy Wz
X D{ .Z]
.zgzZ

80

?VY Z}
.

~d ] g

/7Eg0
DF,
] !~ :W Vz 6 G
+ZE
r
2.gZ$R,
.G
X *
@Y H
zgEq

& @*
{ 6q
-Zg0
+Zg YC
Zzp
pgx !Z ~
/
%
E
$
g
.- ZR,
}Z & {%i+F,
* H
zgEt X  ( seritonin) W
t VgzZ @*
g0
+ZM+',WX *
@Y ( monoamines)

V] Zz g !*
g !*
~ yZX Lg &W6, ];z Zg0
+Zr
t ]!*
Z { c*
i 0 q}g pX  (
W
w

X @*
wzN"_
.~g Zp}g 9
L og YW

gzZYg ZlW~r }Yc*

w~=
/Z
gzZ 6Z m
m
cTe 6,gg0
+Z } zz ~ g Y}

Y c*
g M%Z=
/Z @', kZ X  $
Za ] g ZCZ

kCg z!*
{ c*
i\WLZ~gzZ Y| (,g ZlW~ r

X CZ~g ZlWq
-iz6,]c*
z Z5cTeX V

W~M+',\W  g| 7,[t {\WZ

# [Z
/7E
t VgQ^\W
/ZpX g^g g 6 &G
WDligz~g \WZ
# X CY6 0*
| (,
g Zl

X
*
@YZ~g Zl
E
2.gZ$R,
.G
zeH
zgEggzZq
-Z
kZtgzZ ( dopamine)}0*
J4G

5 E {z CY 0*
{ c*
i }0*
ze Vz{z r }g X
&Z
E
.2E.G
]gzZ muZgpt gzZ @*
B ( nuleus accumbens) E

g {g!*
z {g!*
zLL6,e
({zt X @*
Y W~
w VC

VN Z{c*
iz c*
z~?Z
# 81

g V]tX 7 { 6Vgs}0*
zepX C3

repetitive compulsive ) bzg Zz Y ZC

g !*
g!*
]wR,

@*
Z Zg Z~ V ZC
uzg" wdZ gzZ X ( behavior

} 6 q
-Z R X }0*
ze mgCzZ zgE X
4
~}g !*
kZ V,Z ~ X Hwb6,gzzV% *I H
5G
p ZVzq ~ r }g }0*
ze X 6,T[

X B
bg AgzZ #]:SVc*
Z Ciy
K
E
E
E
"3 Zg **
"3 Z H
3E
3E
.-gZ$R,
epinephrine ) yG
gzZ + G
zgE }Z ~y
W

adrenaline ) Abgi
+Zg **
gzZ Abgi
+Z q ( and norepinephrine

~ P w }g Abgi
+Z X *
@Y ( and noradrinaline

CgzZ Ci%z~g Cu" CZ

gzZ Cg a c*
u C Z
**
Z zz t X

LZ VZg V q
-Z CZzx Kne**
]zZ

X na
4hW
3G
] gI { 6 gzZqZ ( oxytocine)H
4hW~r V yZgzZaaX @*
3G
H
Z ZgZ ~
/
Zg~

4hWyZgz |zX C `g{~gZl~(,

3G
C `g{H
4hWX
3G
X CZi%6,
azkZ VGZz~uzVH
4hW
3G
yZgzgzZ C Za yZgzyH
X C`g {gZl{kZ
4hW
3G
]!*
. ~g^ gzZ z OZ ~ s 0 Z Vz H
_

rZ e W,
Z6,
]!*
.Yx }g 6,
_
ggzZ CsptX CZa

82

?VY Z}
.

4hW<
3G

y
KZ ~B; kZ YwEZ H
 X

X CYW]!*
.u **
_

gzZ0Z
g !
#
G
E
X Za<
 D  6ngzZq
-Z~r
E
E
E
.gz&
.E
niE
+ZX  yAZ zg0
+Z ~g *
@Y ( endorphins) E
gz&
+ZZ

ug y ligzt gzZ  Dg ~ ]g

hz D r A Z
/ZX DZa ~ga%gzZ
E
$ E
2G4hG
.F
.gz&
X  uH
g E
+Zg0
+Z kZ Y H
E
.E
~g zz m{ q
-Zt X *
@Y ; i3,
g L LZ ~g ZlE
gz&
+Z
X DZa ligz
E
E
.gz&
ligz ~g X ~gza ` Zy
Z E
+Za Z]
.Z}g

}0
+
g \WLZ c*
Vgg D{z e C
) !*
^a 6,gx
-ZgzZ @*
q
g a kZ r Zg Y ^a
/Z X Vg X

zz X @*
kZ ]gzZg (Z T @*
Z
{ g

!Z
u ~y
Wg LZ ( weekend warriors) Zz oVg 0*

X @*
kZ gy ZZX Tg D oYg
/

XTgp}~g Z]
.Z}g bZ
E
.E
~` Zy
Z}0*
zegzZDoVGZz YE
gz&
+Z
E
.-gZ$R,
p x mCZ q
-ZC
p
/ZX x ~i H
zgEtX 

D W~z{z bkZ X  ~ ` Zy
Z}uz q
-Zt

I q
-Z ~ yZ X Y Y HwEZ a m& 
X ] g

V,Z Qp n
pg 7D ~dzgE Z]
.Z}g p
/Z

VN Z{c*
iz c*
z~?Z
# 83

E
"3 Z }0*
3E
3 Zg **
yG
ze WalwdZ, Z b
E
"
4hWyE
.E
3E
3G
G
] g I ~ Vzx X  D ` Zy
Z E
gz&
+ZgzZ H
X$
7 yZqgzZ  JK0*
,
k

T religareH~
. religion~ m,
Z

~g V2X XZ ] g I +Z Z]
.Z}g X 0
+!*
L L

D Wd
$
}uz q
-Z v T 1~1 jq
-Z 6

X CLVZzYgzZ

{z
/Y Z]
.Z}g a!g {0
+
i~wj : Z0
+q
-Z

]i gzZ ]%Z CZ f ~ Vz
/X Za b)n6 XK
-ZpX Y7,~}z {z
q
/}g7 *
@Y H: i
/Z q Za
{z
/


/ZX 7~ g Z}g ` Z3,
gzZg _
OZ w q Y
kZ} @*
h{tV Zz6,
{ ZgSkZ @*
x s

X X {h
+ **
pX ,: Zzgg s yZg Z ggzZ
z

{z
/%ZxgzZ M
h Zw
kZX X @*
- c*
Z]
.Z {%
XM
hoh
+'

]Z W,
Z <
6,ZwX e
$2 zGkZ Dq

X Hx VyZgzZZg yZgzq
-Z~}g !*

Vzuz V,Z~ ]c*

Z@I~gZ 1
z D Zw

6,g~gZ 1 X , NZwJ{ c*
i VV6,
YE
E
-&Z V ZwwzNgzZ V ZwV ZwI
GBG
X
<
HH ( prime)
E
2$zVX NZwJ}6,V7z
.G
x xE
/z}uzzz
Y
E
-&Z IX @*
E
5! yZ][Z tL LXg
GE
.G
BG
6,YK
BxE

?VY Z}
.

84

][Zt: (
Z B{zVYJ{c*
iZwV
E
2$}uzX lp **
.G
~}g !*
6: g ZZ Dp~xE
c*
',
yZ
X (
qdI

X
Ci Z ~g)p
/Z k^ Z]
.ZgzZ V @*
- bkZ

] g I aZg Vh
+ **
yQx x Z kZ
Z]
.Z}g *
@Y c*
Vg !gzZh
+ **
/Z ~ ] gpX

[Z Z]
.Z {%t c*
W 6,V @*
- h
+ **
mb
F,
!*
p VJ
-~
C}oI :Zz ? n
pg

X {)zkZ Zg
kZgzZg

4{ c*
i]!*
kZ c*
g ZzZa f @*
-
z kZ b ` W
E
2$ Zg Zr  YYV-j
.G
Xg ZzZa ~f VE

g Z V1Zp~]
.zgzZxg

~[Zp
V @*
- Z]
.Z}g  k+

V70
+
i C!*
.~g tX g ZzZa f}g [Zp Y ` WX
_

yZ Y DtgzZ  M
h Z
] ~}g !*

X uv(
!*
gL L[Zp [
+
z
X: Yc*

.Z }g  Y J
-V p
];+
C g / Z]

 M
h C 7t ];+
7

C +4}ggzZ 7[
}g gzZ [Zp Z]
.Z }g pX  gzZ VY [Zp

X qg ![ZpB{z];zKtk0*

6SaV% VE**
- *~ [I~,v0*
J5F
"
Vz6yZvX[( Asclepius) 4G
#Z@*
-g

VN Z{c*
iz c*
z~?Z
# 85

[Zp)g fV gzZVzizg] ggzZ D Ya~

DwEZa !c*
{z] @ ~ [ZpX D

DWV1Zp~^*X D W~V1ZpyZ @*
-BgzZ
XB=g f Z

V y
KZ 1q
-Z,ggzZ NY Zg f ~ g Z
KZ

gZ g {%q
-Z~[ZpkZX Zc*
~V Zyi
ZIwg ZD

&Nh
&N ]!*
V1Zp k
)G
et pX k
)7G
kZC
X @*
W
gzZq=z *gzZ h
+(
X |%)q
-Z wj d
$z

g ~g ~ * kZ ~ V @*
- n c*
Z]
.Zg !
5gi]~}g!*
* Cg]!*
kZ Zgf[Z

X M
h

+ *
h
*t` C~}g!*
T)(
uZgZz~B

X Yg6,
V @*
-gzZ(~wJVzq

Z]
.Z *}g n7xL

)gfVV! CgV @*
- YXK b@*
-

~] g <
Z 9* [Z v WX @*
- v W
HH

q
-Z ~ Z]
.Z}g Zgf X ~ ^Vox6,gwV (

q: Z7{Zv WX ;g0*
16,
v Wg!*
 ,g
z }uzgzZ 0
+e `gV]>WVpZge {z kZ X

C
b C;g !}uz X ~g Z z [
kZ C
b Cgd
$
X(
Z b
ZgzZ F~V][Zt b

pgZgByZ {zV1Zph
p
+(
Bi WV @*
-

?VY Z}
.

86

/Z O rZ6,V1Zp ZX Zi WZpJ

-yZgzZ

T e **
Zg1yYB* V1Zp Z]
.Z}g bVE**
-

V[
RV,Z eakZX y uv(
L LKZpV,Z
1Ji~g
q]
.z)gfOwegzZgJ
-V

Z\W LZ V,Z bVz+&

+Z i
+g X
T5( sensory deprivation)ixz]2

X @*
kZ wZBC
gzZ }uz

~g y*
c B
) !*
kZ @*
W,
OkZs:} izg

J (,
gzzkZh
+(
X p
pg { izg~<
ZX Y

V,Z yZgz kZ Xg (Z~sq

-Z ] gt Z]
.Z}gEX W,
Z
$
g
2. ZR,
.G
Y (-!*
Z ~ \
ok {z
/gzZ J(,g Zli H
zgE

[Wf T)
A &l~g  k+

X J

yZgz ] g
[gZ
KZ]Zg~h
+ (

}%LZs: Z]
.Z}g kZXc*
ZzJ (,
Vz 6

X B~6,
V][Zt ~uz Z Z\!*
+ **
h

{z Y~}g!*
X6,
V
/
u+ZgZ gC

BBgzZ]!*
.h
_
+]w}W u:$
W,
O6

~g ~g vgzZ  C Zz { ] g X z
~g Zl
Zz} 6
/
uh
++Z X  Tg D !**
]Zg
X D Yqz**
`g {

.z( ZgzWgzZ )g 1xt6,

]
g Z]
.Z}g

VN Z{c*
iz c*
z~?Z
# 87

g
Zg Z',J
-Vh
+ **
] ggzZ  ~g
q

Vjzgg0
+ZkZgzZz* Yg {q
-Z] gtX $
Yq

{ T enthusiasm~ m,
ZwVq
-ZkZX C]o Z

w @*
-g0
+ZTL L T enthousiasmos **
xg bkZgzZ 6,
: ,i%z6,{z
/yZgz] g

X V

7
 C{z] gX$gzZ*Z Z~}g !*
{z
/

* Z]
.Z {%6,gm{ *h
+ **
6,q
-ZaV{ Ze\t :Y

X $
t

~ (

) Za}iZ%Z0
+
i6,
gx] gZZt

X CY Z Z6,
]gzZ
!*
gz { c*
C#e Zg]c*
C

i Zz Y Og [a iZ% 0
+
i~ Vzz {0
+
}C
`WiZz[a]gnkZX DZZgZZ

V  CY 0*
[Z ~ V ]!*
kZ X  D Y O ~

Vh$]zZ gzZ u **
ggzZ u +p Zz W6
"Ll X *
( g: qgYu" nq
-Z ) HF
@Yc*
Zzkzg0
+
i

X PMlzy

zl Cxg

~ *  bD z V FA a ` W

wEZxgaq
-~Vzi ZgVXLZVDZ

$
u +pgzZ u **
g ( initiation rituals) xg zgX  D

X D o*gB\ C `g {} 6 ,ZtgzZ

\gzZCg Z zZC{ WaVlVz%] g nkZ

?VY Z}
.

88

X CoZzB` Zzgzg

z [Zp L L
z g @*
i Z I( g'Z ) }!*
!*
W 7W

C~:W CQk0*
k WVi -Z
#  ( Dreamtime)

3g {7 VC
!*
] g m` WX C*gzZ

CD]g'Z YXgg Z
',
go\ @*
*
@Y

zg6,]ZgklD Y:Z
z[Zp~yZ6,gx gzZ
*
@Yc*
Zzsg Z ~uzgzZ -V Zz(
6gzZ *
@YH

V1@*
{zkZX C(
Vzg Y IgzZ g~xg yZX

(
**
O i E6,VgzZ **
Z~ :WVzgzZ V-r**
O
X D

E
2$ g] g
.G
xE

FX Cib) F
z ] g I Z]
.Z}g

y
KV Y&
+
eiVzgzZ]i Y} ZwVzg
T Y} Z h 3Z (Zq
-ZgzZ Ygz} Y

~g Dzz] g {zkZX D YKwJ}g(

Z: VgzZ C
XVD Yvg e g Y
V D 7]Yg I c*
ZI ~ <
Z ZZ yZ

: ;Z',
u4k0*
XV D+Z
+qgzZ%{u ~ yZX
` W{z%ZX sp~}y (
~ V}n

XVD7Vgx !* %)bV ZI

~( The Faith Instinct) I[KZi

+z

Cg ZZptgzZ C Za kZ
',
i CZ ] g

VN Z{c*
iz c*
z~?Z
# 89

]Zg ~g ~g Z
# X Y 3g F,
]Z CZ f]Z \

~ oq
-ZB kZ\W LZ  D !**
B
X DkCZJ

}g  @*
e
$bkZ eg kg ]c*
D
W
gzZ`U*

0*
,
k
~^tXD YB] gtKZD YVV Z]
.Z z
X g
/
]
.zgzZzg] g

w g ZD
k X Z w g ZD
{gG ` Wi W V ZZ

Zz gz Z ~g D ~ * ` Wp
/Z X X Z
) Zg i I

g ! Z <
Z { -Z  a !*
\ ( hunter-gatherer)
X
Hw$
+<
~B$
+OX YYH7uF,
Z

VY 1g (Z }W V <
X
H&
) Zgi y
KZ

g <
Z Z6,X {0
+
i ` We
$Zzgt X Za
) Zgi
J
.n$zZ& H qz **
og Zq
*
@Y c*
oBj~ e
$ X *
@Y ( Oestra ) ZH
xn]zZzz(
X  gzzZ k0*
X g Zq `

~ ^ Vzg Zq}uz gzZ7Z VzgZqyZ |X gZq

X 1g (Z

~g/q
-Z gJ
-][Z t k
,
Iwg ZD
0*
E
E
45BV( V ZI X ;g:
X , qz **
G

~gZf%
k0*
yZ 1J V (
gzZ V ZI

X ',
x \ s{zM
h}g Z tV @*
-g Zf **
{z

C Z: c*
z)6,gY] g
]
.zgzZzg

p X C c*
Y~zg nC
gzZ @*
H
N ZFx ~T

?VY Z}
.

90

6,
g~<
ZX qz~{ c*
ix d
$gzZVz

%ZX C Z
Z,j]Zz)Yzz kZVY ~ ~0*
i vV CY0*
~xsZwVq
-Z kZX g ~g Y]w}W


bq
-Zt X  D{>gzZ  r D} 9N Z yZgz

X g

!*
g (gzZst { y!*

Y~al
zg c*

& } 9gzZ
/G
X G
t
+gc
/J
- ; Y 1960 Q c*

Xg6,g Z( chant) ;
.yZgz] gH al

5_ ~ Val
,a
T { ^
,Y
uF
O%Z j
Z Zzg
X ~] ggzZg j
Z

 akZ6,
g~
C
] g~<
Z}uz

@Y c*
3sp kZ
} 9( Southern Baptists) *Z ! X *

V Y
/X gg {z:tZ}
.} @*
D7

~ Val
8 g- X $6,yZ vCY 7a kZ Zzg0
+Z

nC!*
.{ c*
_
i pXn Y zg W**
V t
X g7i !*
W**
V~VZ

X q
-Z

wgzZuO**
**
a Z]
.Z}g

}uztHX DY0*
]c*
Z~}g!*
iWu

E
2 $
.G
uQc*
?g6,
}WP w
CTg ZzZa ~f VE

+4b OyZ u w yzg Z e ? _g Up

X q
-Z~V V

}WgzZ w@*
u !*
Wy
KZV @*
]!*
6,kZ~L L

VN Z{c*
iz c*
z~?Z
# 91

zHyZ 3@*
uX HwEZaqz # U
X
rg
A & kCg Y  I[ ]!*
.+F,
_
!
Xm]!*
.F Zzg Zu yzg Z e
_

X *
@Y y sU gzZ q
-Z ] g I ZZ kZ
+A \
/E\zg **
] q
V({z G
Z6,Zg f g~ ua ]Zg Z
B\gzZg ZW

{h
+I\WX $
]5

~]
.z gzZ a **
? Y ygzZ 4 kZ iY ~g Z z
X : e{xg]q
-tgzZ76

LZ I qzhz A Z q
-Z \W

o Z

i"gzZ
Zpg @*
-tX @*
y
KkZ6,J
g
-8Eyzz ~h gw!*
Z Z gq
-Z qz C
E,G
g!*
X
T D O @*
C
 rg e 0*
CN*
6,V; LZ {z X  D

wYZ~ ZsVjZ LZg e 0*

{zQX *
@Y)g e 0*
s

~g ZnkZX C"gzZ @*
Z~ OZyZ kZX 
}<
 w [
+
z
hX  Cx gz sp]w
~g FtgzZ ( disorderobsessive-compulsive) ~gF~gZCZ

X 7]W{z k0*
yZp 1&
+
e*g yzg Z eX <

: Z 7g0
+Z r  Y [Z X M
h6,g}g7 Z {z
x ZuwdZ ~g Za " x
E
2$t X 
.G
Zz Za } c*
D" w EZ ~ ] g I xE
gz Z]
.Z}g p)i0
+
i,qVztX D"

?VY Z}
.

92

X V Z { c*
igzZt~*u**

wZgzZ W

 CwEZ ( V sW ) 4,
ZgE g%}g ] g I

5g Z0
+Y h
+(
Z 4,
ZgE g%yZX W~ [!*
,f -X
v Z
# X  CVZ {Z
+ kZ ] g I X b ~I,q

zz W 4,
ZgEg%X *
@YO**
Vg a**

/
g Z\W
E3G
4H
5_X ~ (Z
ZxZzY~wj)
,
eE

Z~ kZyz ]w}W%wEZV] ~g

g^5x xBVzuz c*
Vgo
/Z\WX @*

XCZa~}g!*
VLZ\W~wqgVzV
Za Zz 6, ,(
V]~g~kZ

Og Y (
V] ~g ~ ]w}W
/Z X CY
E
N q
-Z V Z b ;gE- e i WX @*
Z ~
Z',

t ~"X H{@x ` N ZgzZ! Z V Zg ~"

g yZg ! Z ZxX DgyZg 

\z
/X C 6,V Zz `
A &
Z',
E
E
E
E
.gz&
.gz&
YE
+Z YX *
@YZ~g ZlE
+ZyZgz
/
u
X CLV

/8F~}g !*
Zz u 6ez Zg f
 a VyZ s: G

gzZxZzt X Z Zaq
-Z ~g7 V;z

zz : i
]qJv yZgz kZX f .

iz0
+Z]gzZ}g egugzZDx N Z~

VN Z{c*
iz c*
z~?Z
# 93

XD

WgzZ wj gzZ V e
$h
+'
Vz 6 ,qt

X BZh
+'
ZzzW,
Z

hN ~ ~g3
M
M wj;

/b!*
] g

X @*
**
6,
5#T

z Y

kZh
+(
X  Ds
z ~ wN }uzq
-Zg

 @*
x@ZX | (,} g NgzZzzZ
E
E
4hW
.gz&
3G
E
+ZX @*
i W "_
.Zz Y T C `g {H

N3 wqgu **
+Zq
-Z]g\W
/ZX C oh
+'
kZ
X Yzgz **
Z r kZ : B;{zZ
#

kZ } B; bZ {z
/Z X {i sp{z X @*
wzNspzt
& LZ {z
{c*
igzZsp B;] LG
/ZX YJ
-usp
LZkZ ~ sp]gt ]!*
Z { c*
iX *
@Y
X CW{ c*
i~sp]iZX C
]B

ZbkZgzZDYW~yj
/Z%C!*
.r
_
Zuz
86,
g}g (
ZkZr X *
@Yi

X }~VZ1
J
gzZ  q Zz yz{ c*
i
~ Vzg Y HG3.'Z6,y
KZ

} h
+'
] xV~ V V}g

-Z ~h T{z w!*
q
g!*
 Zx gzZ q
-ZX  D

^(
[xq
-ZX  C"
$U*
[x { c*
i Dg{c*
i}uz

?VY Z}
.
94
E
$
g
2. ZR,
.G
Z~gZliH
zgEYgzZz6,
#gB;6,
B;

X  ZzJ(,
kZwZ{z
/
gzZ3q
-yzb*
!*
@Y
 c*
g 6 {z6,g~g) Z]
.Z}g ~ iq
-Z
F,
kZ X e
$g ZgzZ yz OZ
E
2$ Zg Z]56g !u"tX
.G
Xg **
Z VE
X @*
i W <
V-X ~
Z
+ ][Zt

/N*
gq
-Z

gzZD\WTv~}g!*
axq
-Z

QX ,t
qC!*
.KZxkZ[ZX ,g6,
_
]!*
.LZa
_
kZ

eVt \WZ
# X gTBgzi6,
zi !*
LZ

gzZ d
$
\W
/Z X Nq
-Z RgzZ V} 9J Q B

\WZ
# X , qz **
a **
VzgzZ ,b!*

/
kZ 

Z',g \W B [Z X B e {g!*
z B **

}g !*
LZ \W ? DkCH~}g !*

kZ \WX X
A&

?gkCH~

Qw
t ~ 9\W , i Z0
+Zz7,kZ LZ )

( X ;gN D

@*
^g7g ~pq
-ZC
V @*
Zzt V~ Z
#

~}g !*
V=pzgEg0
+Zr \W~ wKgyZX

s
tgzZX CZa zz
w}WgzZ

c*
~ V Zyi
Z \W
/Z,g Zg f X *
@Yg0
+Zg0
+Z VwP
! Vg]Zg~g ~gx t~V7W

VN Z{c*
iz c*
z~?Z
# 95

gzZ D !**
b Z V V ~ ^{uZg L\W
/Z

] g \W kCg0
+Z Vg KZ \WgzZ  D Z

X H{@x

~g ]!*
tgzZD: eiYqZ]q
-] g
X @*
wEZ<
& UgzZq
-Z +
M
KZ

~ zg

GG$
_m
yZz6,
) !*

V 3E
_m~r ]~ zg}g

B q
-Z ~ zggzZ C Z
i W kZ ZpX 

m zg D{ .Z q kZ <
X C Za Zz o
kX ,gj~
A Z *
@Y H{z ZyX @*

paVg~g Z.6,gm{Vg c*
4 gI
X NY0@{ c*
iVzgj Y~
A {zVY
CgzW

%X C
{ Z ~
A  CY ~ $JZ
(VzgzWp
Vz% 1k{ c*
i h
+(
{z VzgjG.O@XE

X C{ .ZZp

HwEZ6,e } (,qZ ~ zg ~ <

Z }uz

o Zz (
~ wqyZX B wV (g X *
@Y

V~ z z
|gX  C]!*
~ (
}{z

X *
@Yc*
4 al
gzZ CYob~ (
d
$q~al

gzZD B I }L L\WLZ 
V` W

gzZ ~VZ ~ (
gzZD Yk]~ (
6,
] g ZZ

X CY

96

1g OZ'
q
-ZyZgzGod of Letting Go q
-Z6,
~zK

?VY Z}
.

}af~ ]Zp~ iZ Cs Z

X C H~(,
yZk
,
q
-Z

z jg7~]~ zgx Zzg ~x[!*

  D^ C!*
.QgzZ F
_
~ zgh
+ ZpX
8
X%~y
W x Zz

~gtu: ZZz

t
kZXD7st
~
Cyxgs0Z
bzg mq
-Z
( Parental Investment) ~g tu: ZZz& @*

gzZ C;{ c*
i a - ]!*
kZmkZX *
@Y
X ~g tuC!*
.
_

V
KZ6,
gwVXC~gtu{c*
i6,
zZ{ ~qZZF,
{c*
i
0
+
i~6kZ3gkZaTCgg7Z]g~

$ciQ B
bg~{ a {zQX @*
~g { C

C[7{ c*
iZaV X SgC|zV',
agzZCg
/

X 40*
gzZx4P7kZ~Vz%6,
kZX

aX t
yW}i~~g tu6,ayxg]ggzZ%

f wN kZ ~ VzCc*
F,
[f Za
t p'gzZ @*
s } G,
7 a LL\!*
X C7,6,]g~g Z

X ~g Zf ]gF,
{ c*
i

C~gtu{c*
i
T-{zJ
-ubzgakZ

{ -t 6,gx X}\5B{z C[NZ ]!*

kZ {z

VN Z{c*
iz c*
z~?Z
# 97

A VT-{zX %{ ~yZy6X C

} CQLZZ @*
3,
6,
gx  C~g tu
~

aq gJ
-{ Byg Z}uz-KZa

X @*
7,
**
J

[NZ gzZ Z ~ Vg s ] ~ V
KZ

} N,Z {z zz T
) !*
Z
oa Vz%

VzN,Z X 6,6]g)g fX Tg D &
+
e

Vg} j: XzgzZ **
JhzZ ',J
-cuVgYZziZM~

6,pwLZ%~ Vl: Zg Zz 
c*
I X  (
{)z **
Zz

X  D :
K C c*
it V\WVgyZ0*

Vq *
@Y Z
o~(,{ c*
iVz%6,Vg]!*
kZ

*
@Y \a/~g ~\LZ6,
VgkZ

X @*
~ar ZX

&
+
egVzi~s 0ZVz V~VzYziq
-

$~ (
d
|Zzg Zg fX @*
U Z<
@*
{ c*
ia

X , h :y
KZ Z Z h Z}
.TL L:g6,

Z s Z Zz Y 6, **
zi ~k
,
Z ~ g ZD
z

3k
,
z Z
Z 6,-KZ y Z Z
# Vz V ggzZ Vz%

: k
,
z-KZg ZzX
HZ~]Z IyZ I
& Z
<
@*
a ] LG
# a kZ X #X *
@YW~yZy

? ]!*
kZ gzZ  D{ c*
i6,<
Z

98

?VY Z}
.

X Ky
KZp<
Z

c*
CtgzZ Hf Z b
Z ~
C] ggzZ}oJ
-V
E
2$ Zg Z V _ bt
.G
k0*
}g [ZpX  gZzZa ~f VE

 [Z  WX  @Z Zz q k
,
z r
X @*
WHg0
+Zr

 ZzyZZ} Z

99

ZzyZZ} Z

]oK Z}
.6,
gg ZzZa ~f
Vy
KZ Z
# @*
Z Hawqw
z kZ L L

( yzg Z eg e) X Z yyxg

wz" c*
gz$ t 4 (ZX 4 Z){gZzZa ~f
G
G$
V 3E
_yZ7,
gzZr6,
gwVX
ZkZ]!*
~Zpq

"7,~ r }g X agzZ  g ZzZa ~f

GG$
y!*
i
C{zV 3E
_~uz k0*
}g pX 7
G
G
$
45E
_x t X   a ]wV; gzZ a
kZ G
q ~g t X 57,gzZ r y

KZ Z
# NW~
wN Z
z

X XZ Dp Z

Vq~k
Z VYgZzZa~f y!*
i6,
gubZ

3.|!gzZ
X P w6,g~
Cw@*
gzZ *
@Y c*
~ }WV G

100

?VY Z}
.

gm{[{h
+I CZ
[
~k
,
+W,
5
Z gZzZa Dp

X VhZz, c*
BT(Z6,

V-zg ~ ZZgzZ}g Jg @*
T ]g!q
-Z <

6 gm{CY7
,
kZg ZzZa ~fZX Hcg
K~ wqX  DC
h
+'

kZ_ CDq~]gkZ

gzZ i~}g !*

/][Z t <
6,
zZ}g Zz Y
X Wt @Z0
}g L Li 
y gzZ!*
zgEug e
t ]!*
k
,
z gzZbgE X Zz yxgV z
X CW

 6, x **
g
* <
gzZ
IE&
g Z
x Z}
.L L Y 1980{zX  yZ ];;gE- Ej4G

*
@Yc*
~} #l{gzZq
-g @*
-ZVX g]!*
q

gxq
-Z6,
uyZgzZ CY ~
A &G
ggzZ yZ
( temporal lobe) { Y q yZ  *
@Y c*

Y
E
-&Z)g f
GE
BG
X @*

yZX DkC }
uz L L Z
Z(
~"

c*
][Z t L LkZ Z
Zt ._: DpgzZ CZ f

X @*
[x{ c*
iVz%/t~VgX D,I

:gzZ 7kZ CZ fuZzgzZ xg0

+Z}g  I 6,

g0
+Zr |gXYkZtVz(Z r

M YX ~kZ ~g]Z f ~g  {, Z F

 ZzyZZ} Z

101

CZ f cTe spX @*
wzNy!*
i Lg
zVc*
!*
r
z

Zq
-Z x Z}
.L Lc*
g Zl
/
~ypxW

X @*
g DW~^ }
uz L 
L @*
Wg~g}g kZ CZ f
YE
E
-&Z kZ"I )gf )
GBG
{ /s
,
wgC

g i ZzW Z}
G
.%1 s: )
,
wgCX 7/! Zz g0
+Z

gzZ ti ZzWg0
+Z LZX CZ Zg Z Z ~kZI

%[wgC
HH{@x ]!*
kZ V',FX  M
hi ZzW

X DI!%, ZgzZ @*
kZIh
+ Z
Zg D

Z 7,{gz %6,uvZ e g Y w Z
# w0*

(X  !% % !*
<
Z Z * et X
E$
T%[wgC{)z
z6,g gzZ hG2zgzA -Z s W

X i%6,
zyZ
<
E
38E
rVv',
E-ghZZe;gE-G
N*
M%Z

VpqZ]
.zZ
Z}uzgzZyZgzZ%VZgD

~T
qC!*
.+Z
_
 @*
{iZ0
+ZxyZX k
,
z~
E
H"
r m @*
kC }WB] L L \WLZ{z
[5

+Z {t r X @*
qd [ ?Zc N!*
gzZ qd { c*
i
tX ~CZg0
+Zwj LZD ]

XCqzV *!*
gzZ@*
VZgD C{
%i Z% V l6,
~ Vu uI ]z
LG
/Z

Y~ uzgF,
C2{kZr V~uzgzZ"7,
] Yo

X YY 3gi!*
t
yxg* zgzZ zg0
+Z )gzZp r

?VY Z}
.

102

\WLZ
7]C2* z{kZr Z
#

X kCz

E C ]~ nkZ tE
EE
4gG)9
4gG)9 G
"
CgzZ 6,gwVX {)z [z!%% 45v

# |
@*
Zz
Z kZ ( glossolalia)  s1 jg pZ
E
H"
wzNzzT Cqd~[ 5
6,
kZX
X @*
/myxgZ}
.gzZ]Z f KZT @*
k Z
% is W^k XZ DM%Z ~ Y 2009
-Z x Z LG
q
X >}uz 0*
gz Z Qk- ' T (
[

The Cognitive ) k Z Cc*

gEgzZ Zg Z }oIL Lx **
[kZ

~ kZgzZ ( and Neural Foundations of Religious Belief

<

X b
',
ig ZzZa ~f
E @Z
E
I

E
5
X
HHt)gf WgW *Z 5k V V~ kZ
gzZ |7,
]**
F~}g!*
<
t VyZ Vzg

/
%Z}
.L Lg0
+Zr p
/ZX ,s%Zc*
tZkZ{z
HyZ
YE-!
 zgz,
M Ir  Zx)gf 5BG
Hc*
0*
7
EZzgEp
X DwEZ~]!*
.gzZ+
_
Mbf

t ]**
.
} Z
Z I)gzZ I

M -Zt 7 Z Q X
,
Hc*
0*
7t
~g T
pi ZZ
+ I X  D wEZ ~ uZg Z Y B gz

+ IX@Zg ! kZX t :gzZ D Za 7

Z
E
E
2$tgzZDwEZxE
2$6fgzZ
.G
.G
yZxE
u Yx gzZ TY

 ZzyZZ} Z

103

X [YHfXD1wdZ V_

wEZ Wg W* Z pZ V,ZgzZ k DqgzZq

-Z

V(
~"Z
# Ht
z kZ I)gzZ I D

Vy Z r VI X g b)I)gzZ I t

Z b Z
Z 0 ] !*
kZgzZ |
#  Wqd { c*
ig0
+Z
X D7gzZ \WLZs

yZgEg%

Z Vzg ZX ~V
yZgEg%
g6,g
Vzg ( Macaque) ~ V; 90 gzZY 1980  Hc*

0*
~r
KZt ZxZz~Xg6,
-Z ~ V:c*
q
g +F,
Z bzgEh
+]
.c*
g 4,
ZgE yZX  DY

ZgzZ xZug YZ
#
# Dwd
zkZyZgEtX
Vzuz yZzgEt X 8 xZuzg YgzZ gY {z

ItOX Vgz~kZp{zD7,Z bzg

X Dwg
gZz

D VQzi !*
Vc*
Z CZ\WZ
# X D Zz wVq
-ZkZ

wB; NZ D YwdyZgE{zsN!*

r \W

NYwdyZgE B Dx t=\W
/ZX DwzN

Y/ e ~B; NZ }
/Z X
zi !*
Vc*
Z \Wp
/Z

B=\W
/ZXNYwd Zz wzgr N!*
}
XNYW~
w{r \W

X 7]gzkCga /t p\Wp

?VY Z}
.

104

,kCBZ f lF,
6,y!*
i \W B 5a N*
b\W
C
/Z

Qc*
X VgkaN*
{zp\WYW 0*
, Z~-\WgzZ
X B: )\W, Vg V)}uzZ
#

~ * {z X  B]!*
t Zz {P a V k#

pX8g: J
-V6,yh
+(
,7g z ZZ~}g !*
u

{P sV N3k
,
a wJ&
+
u{z
/Z
X D Y| (,
]**
kZ

w V *i Zz ~ ~ Y 2010

k
,
zu V-g { n i c*
z VY c*
{P w

7{g%K+W,
OgzZM
hkC~ !*
',
gzZ zg {z
X
yZgEg%X D ~g tZ @*
: <

/Z *
@Y Z

XM
h

}gtgzZDkCg Vzuz~VsX DgwkZ

]Z~|
# r }gX @*
gZkZ gzZ ~g^g0
+Z

|',
bkZ6,
g~g)c*
~ggzZ@*
wEZkZ<
X (

XnYc*
6fkZ

X  Q k
,
z
M Q}q a |

{z @*
x @Zp D Y ~ kZ {z B|
h Vr6,Z @*
kZ gZ Z Z
#

aLZjg !V6& Z ~
C~g k
,
tX
Hc*

X CwEZ
Y4
$Z@zg Z Zg
V,ZX |zg Zzg L LEjEge

 ZzyZZ} Z

105

I4F
& ~ Zz
g7~ $Z ~ s W EjG
W ~ Y 2004 KZ yDg kZ

yZ V| 3o pZ~THwEZ
Y
4

j
E
E
~ V,Z
HgzZ
Hc*
x ZZ # 6, X HnZ Z6,
~ m,
z*z~}g!*
kZX Z h
+'
Z
+ I 3

g0
+ZkZ V [
7 6,V
$ d
$z q
-Z t gzZ  _0`

tX7g0
+Z Zz Y7~m K(
o{z

X CYwEZa(~Val

YH_
Z ( Stigmata) N*
) 5 6,g KVI J
-u

b}[Q6,
ggZuZ6,
~VUgzZVzcV;V~kZX

{ c*
ip *
@Y z6,
gx ZX D Yni
yZtk+
yZp @*
kC jg ! Zk
,
}[Q r ~g

X H{@xb
A &g!kZ r X DYWni6,

ni\WLZp6,gZ)c*
Z~
q ]
.z V,Z et

X V

t @*
 gx 6,bgE h
+]
.g .

z kZ

t }g yq
-ZX DwJgzZ Za ]Ir n Y
Xk
,
/**

**
(Zk
,
+c*
$
X YWk
,
bzgE<

106

?VY Z}
.

G
'
+
Y1: yJZ Zg }
M F,

 {z : OZ { c*
i
O DL L

{z c*
Xt b D gzgzi  Y
( yzgZ ege) X n7iX

YE8
% iz .M%Z~ 1918
5 E@zg ZzyZ Cg ZgzZzg {LG
54G
Z',E

~ V
/Y 1925 k
B t X ~ qzk
B v% @*
L Ls g Z
&
4E4H
kZ pX *
@Y bZR,
:j& 6,lg gG5G
c*
g

W~} VZZ', zk
,
e q Vz X Z%7gZz!*

b`
t X c*
g:|N/Nb F6,!*
Z',QgzZ a
X q
-Z~Vj`
+F,
x g @*
O%Z

X
H
%y 0*
 Z*gkZZ',
H
E
4
&
4
~igz s y = gG5G kZ x ZZ6,:jyY

G
'
Y1: yJZ Zg +}

107

Wy
KZ ~ ~ !*
b L L~ Vj~g u1T
6,
Zk
,
+g Z Vzg YZg y
5
KZJ 7,tg

A ZrZZ',
p
/ZX
Hc*
c~t X ~ ~0*
X ~k
B g y
WZp

gzZ ;g **
-w:e y =X ~g YZ k
J
B ~(,p

*ZgzZ q
-Z ~ Y 1967 gg D b) J 7,g Z

X c*
Z f
eZgF,
MWO%Z

^]l} (,
{sJ 7,
gZJ
-[ZzY 1960

V Zzp
pg m zi !*
NZ I X J
-^g*4z ~ X `

ZgzZ b U ~ g Zt
Z
# pX Y c*
J 7,BBg Z ( intelligent design)

X
A b J
-"
$rZXt

~
) ) ,
U*
~ Z yY Q z
C|~ Y 2005
E
4~RkZX c*
H-LG
g]gzJ 7,
Z6,
gw g Z

wj c*
,
k
Zgzze x H
/ Zc6,<
 yZ ] q
-Z **
~ ( Kitzmiller v. Dover Area School District) R
7e

gzZb gzZ &kZ y~hb

X 7s %Z ~<

i !*
k
,
g **
~ ZiW(L Ll:j~pZkZ

 kZX yq e eVzyzzk
,
e ~

agzZbRgzzeX 7 ~bgzZ<

yxgbgzZ<
~LZ yY QpX Z"
$U*
~(,

108

?VY Z}
.

$E
X Ht Z0\G
yqgzZHf

7~bgzZ<
z!*
t{70
+Z

}9]i~ V(gzZ~ VZVj~M%Zx

X yxgbgzZ<
7~kZX gD

]gzZiWgzZ]y
KZiW]J
-V-Z
+ I

]gzZ Vz yZ bX g D}~}g!*
:

Z 7,
**
o]ZZ~kZp
/ZX c*
gj
Z
5
y
KZ * ` W C3 lZ s X @*
C\W @*
{0
+
i G3G
/
4] HE
E
4F
5G
.J2G
&LZzY$~y
X E
W gj
Zq
-ZZg
DuF,
J
<
-yzgZ e ~ x[!*
 6

kZ k0*
kZ]!*
Zt
` W 7U
DC!*
E
2$ {z X k0*
.G
{ z  D k
,
+ia]I  xE
5
}g
@*
\5 Zz+',YVyZZ
# X }
/
}

X @*
Z9W ZBZgzZ NZ0
+Zt }g

~ yZ ] g Z gzZ m I . 6

X Z',
t~bp qhZ NZ~<
L L

pg: g I C \WI . 6gzZ

p

@*
7 VZ <
X yW{ c*
i}6,
E
2$6f V_}g Z
.G
zg{6,A kZt Y c*
5 VE
#&

w7 k}g Z Z Zzh
e{^
,Y )Zg~Y 2010X ]gz

{ c*
i~ }g !*
<
Z *6, VI V-C
 Hx
X HgXa{ c*
i6,
]5yZV,ZtkZX ]

G
'
Y1: yJZ Zg +}

109

6,! } Z M
m O%Z Y 2010 y b X !*
yZ [Z p

qz v & ; y-yZ ]g -zZ

X t
~
CyxgbgzZ<
L LByZb Z (,

bX =gzZ {@x
CbZ
# 6,4 !*

C<

b Yv  6 X C3x tVY

e D Y0:
KZ sZ} Z ~g Fu**
KZ ; %

{zgzZ ;gx [Z r !yZz!*

kZX DNayZv

X D J 7,
gzZ H,q5[ZY (h
+]
.

b Zg Zm<!*
gzZb
Hc*
3~[kZ 6

y Dg
/
X @*
C
]IgzZ
r
KZ CC
E
2$C;<
.G
Y D Zzh
+'
~dzgEgzZ **
ZzgExE
B
zgE Zg Z <
~ wj~gu:jc*
yY X  g

M%Z\W Vg YJ7,
}ptZ
# XVg J7,
b

XNY~
Znt{zXM
h{iZ0
+ZgV|
6,

C
lkZXY~^g*46,
ggzZ
Zzy
s !*
Rt

 ZxXA ]h
+'
V:c*
gyZkZXce *
*xl

CC g @*
X @*
Jm
yZz6,ZgzZ @*
Z
+ I bf
KZ
X Y
A b

`a}ggzZ @*
Z
gz~*3g"q
-Z<

}Z
+kZtrX f
e]izz kZp @*

* Bt]!*
t
/ZgzZHV
KZZpX ]**
vgzZ
X $
0(4q
-Z

?VY Z}
.

110

F
54X
5G
g
Zz~**
zi~k
,
ZgzZgz T**
Itm G

Wt Y 2010#kg !*
k
,
tZ
# X 1{ g

Nk
,
kZ VX
HH
WZ}
.L LZ~Vq~ Z
X zg} 7F

"m,
E
4H
5E
.nI
G
$z ~a E
d
6,gzZ }p}6,~
/c p
&V
G
www.jandersonthomson.com /G
$

<
6,+
M
KZ  v',Zz y-]C
gt

X @*
_ q
-Zad
${z  Dx ax3,

/
"&
5E
~*i3q
-Z **
G3G
+L L~c Z ~ ey~Y 2006V,Z]!*
t

~ e B]C
6,gm{~X ,k
,
{F~ *i3kZ X
J
X V@*
lg \ m,
6,
Ej$N*
kZ
/

111

w Z[!*

z}g s:t g Z)g f[NZ CgyzgZ e L L

Vz7 Vzg Yt XwJ.

uZz z0
+
i }~]

C
gzZg Z0
+YC
[NZ CgXuZz q8
-g gc*
gzZ

ag!*
zg{%izgD gZXwJ.
uZz
Zm,
e L L]gzp
%
/ZpX M
hgZ
/0
+
i%x**
yzgZ e\WX 7~gz

i ]c*
yzgZe\W g Y a \W T e 'Yt \W
\
Xp
-Zs W~gL LG-. eg fyY+ Z e el
g X } 7,
**
_

( 19936,
;gE-`,)

"Richard Dawkins, forewordto John Maynard

Smith's The Theory of Evolution,Canto ed."
(Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1993)

E
.-J'**
E
ze ]W Zz iZPg Zyt

:~y*LZV,Z

"Adaptationism and Human Mating Psychology,

in the Handbook of Evolutionary Psychology,
ed. David M. Buss (Hoboken, NJ: John Wiley
& Sons, 2005)."

Bi r gzZ X @*
r  {z f L L

E"
[5F
y-

"Steven Pinker's How The Mind Works (New

York: Norton, 1997)."

**
- gzZ <
p
/Z :6,Vkl{ c*
i q
-Z c*
-Z
q

V Z}
.Zgt p *
@Y <
Z Zuz<
Z Z eg W gzZ

112

?VY Z}
.

X Db<
Z Zz

{
KZ<
  DVi][Z t z

Z ,]!*
4\WLZ
/ZX D Z
]o
H
E
"5G
4-E
_ Z\W Yq\W
/ZX @*
- Lg z

LZX _ 5 e V T e **
Zzx e**
\W
/ZgzZ 

yyl,
z8~}Y 1950ezz
L Lm

{z kZa kZ $
Y 7al
a~/Sh1 {z X 0
X $
N6,
Vzg Z- }vLZd
$I

][ZtyZxu
Z Z
V Z}
.Lgzp
/Z

( lobbyist)g (F,WZakZ C{<zZg

yZ {z 7t Z {zp _ VCz X Y Y

X Yx C
Z}
.s *
@Y c*
C Z X ,[|N

tX Faz J
- Z}
.{z VCzgzZ_ gJ
-V Z}
.
z X *
@Y X U x ZZ( polytheism) 46,M e ~(,t

IG
GG35" ) q
X ( hg
-ZsZ}
.pM
h

@*
qz kl !6,} z

7@Z gzZ ~i 0*
kZ vQ X  Y v&

g~}g !*
kZ\W
/ZX  D Y Re~ ^] Z@Ze
$zX 

]Z7Z}
.{z Cg zkZ]!*
t x,

@*
J
-uq
-Z]tq
-~kZ ~g 0*
X @*

Zpg

X @*
J
-!*
ZfZLZZ

W z X CY VJ
-\7 D eg ]!*
s !*
y

113

XNY [ kZ ] Z8&i Z  @*
~gz6,gx a

gzZq
-ZkZ )X CYzJ
-] Zzot%]L%Z
&~VzgzWp~<
/G
( X G

X  V
KZ <
 wV{]!*
kZ t e
$z

(e
$z\7g ] ZZ]!*
kZ~V',
Dq

s~uz ( Y 2008 ~gz

18 yZN*
} F)X c*
F,
!6, ];z

Vz
)
:}X *
@Yc*
`g {e
$z{],
ZVCz
H
&
54G
EG
z Z  3 g0
+Z V",k
,
XgzZ  z
t
~ #
zygzZ |zz V!*
yZ X c*
} g Z
z)L L

kZp g Z}
.q
-Z~TgzZ *
@Y<
: &Lg7!*
X *
@YHtzV Z}
.}uz~

&
4)G
EG
Z @z {Lt X 
Zz
/
: g ZzQ L L

xz[!*

]Z ]!*
.y!*
_
i g Z :
H1 ~ .
$m,
6,Z y:
( 1994y::ug c*
E)X HzbVzgzZ

"William Allman's Stone Age Present: How

Evolution Has Shaped Modern Life-From Sex,
Violence and Language to Emotions,Morals
and Communities (New York: Touchstone,
1994)."

g ZV
KZ ` Kgq
-Z :q
-Z ~ VE{h
+I ~

Vzg H L L Y7V KZkZX Wy"7,

~}g !*
` X Vi1gzZVzgXp q
-ZV;L LV ?

?VY Z}
.

114

?VgQL LY7
E
45
sW eg1 m GLL c*
[Z gzZ ea x q
-Z V

X mZ

g @*
X Z]
.Z}g : L L[ i
+z { ^
,Y g Z

E)
c*
i !*

y
KZ L L[ +Z|
:gzZ ( Y 2006 6,E :ug c*

H1( Y 20106,

Z
/
D:~ e dZz) X H
.( National Geographic Press, 2010X
"NicholasWade's Before the Dawn:
Recovering the Lost History of OurAncestors
(New York: Penguin Press, 2006) and Richard
Pottsand Christopher Sloan's What It Means to
Be Human (Washington, DC: Natio nal
Geographic Press, 2010)."

YE4
gzZ 5G
-
r
/R6 e N*
+ Ze el
g ~ ;gqiZZt =
\
iWy
KZ~*i2G-. ~ e dZzB\z
/q
-Zegzg;

!*
$V,Z~X @BF0*
el
gI],
Z e~}g!*

t\W e
/ZXnY&kZ @*
J 7,
YZ6,
gZ

X ^+F,
dZtX Bgz

i Z0
+Z6,e} (,
A &yzT q Yq
-Z

[!*
b!*
gzZ g Z :}uzgzZ N L L[ ~ eC
{g X *
@Y c*

E5E
":ka` )X7,
6,
;gE-egzg;sW6,
g~yZyLL
FG34G
(Belknap Press of Harvard University Press, 2009).( 2009
"Sarah Hrdy's book Mothers and Others: The
Evolution of Mutual Understanding.

115
(Cambridge, MA: Belknap Press of Harvard
University Press, 2009)."

{~6,
zZgzZVQy}uzq
-ZM
h~iq
-Z

h
M
Z',V gzZ VgzZ  M
h} ~p
pg~
9
E
4) FO y
2F
.G
z DC i Dg Z~E

KZ~ i kZ
/ZpX 
X D} )}9V~kZ

X VyNszyg0zgage
g<
~
E
E
(

-;X
5Z
[ EG
gzZ G',~g
/Z% z{g !*
z L
L y;f Z}g
GO58E
E
28E
.G
X **
1V 3 E~
CKZ :J
-uZgpgzZ
z: E
}L L
"Terry Burnham and Jay Phelan, Mean Genes:
From Sexto Money to Food: Taming Our
Primal Instincts (New York: Penguin Press,
2000)."

4G
&zg Z eh
5E
4 kZ @ZkZgzZ;@*
EJ4G
+]
. g Z \WLZ
E
_
IG
5
4 GZ ( Y 1996 Hg :ug c*
E)
G aZz Z : 7i
E
4G
&
:ug c*
E)Bg Z yW HiH
/Z gzZ ( Y 2009 6,;gE- ei W :ug c*
E)

X {k
,
+ Z e el
gx tX ( Y 20096,
~

"The Blind Watchmaker (New York: Norton,

1996), The Selfish Gene, 30th anniversary ed.
(New York: Oxford University Press, 2006),
and The Greatest Show on Earth (New York:
Free Press, 2009), all by Richard Dawkins."

wZjZ ~gF Zz zz } Z N*
z ]g?g Z

x[!*

116

?VY Z}
.

d
-I
4)F
1~
li Wy
KZ :4,
1Zs WxeizZ L[ EG
gzZZzZ

:
H

"Alan Walker and Pat Shipman's The Wisdom

of the Bones: In Search of Human Origins
(New York: Knopf, 1996 )"

ZZ
KZ~ wos W*i~ e dZz V*
c A yZ

X $
Y@E~w;
49
tJ
-+ZzagzZ J
- Z}
.V| gG)} yxg <
gzZ x Zz V2u u

X ( Y 2010W CZ f ) H_m
:,5[ yZ

"Attachment, Evolution, and the Psychology of

Religion (New York: Guilford Press, 2005)."

:B [ w1yY{ zkZ
"John Bowlby, Attachment (New York: Basic
Books, 1969)."

E&
y
KZ XWz6,];~Qgzs W;gE- Bg i4G
Z ~
X zg~f}gzZ 4z
YE5E
E&
IZ 5.G"L L yP^',
Zg sg +4 x w1 gzZBg i4G
Z

Hg (Z ^[~gzZ Z (
~ Z Y Y ~
Y 5E
5.G"
 D
A &~g {zgzZ ] :IZ E
E
X ( Y 1994 6,
;gE-ei W :ug c*
E)
"Becoming Attached: First Relationships and
How They Shape Our Capacity to Love (New
York: Oxford University Press, 1994)."

117

V', !Z}Y 1830yzg Z eg e } z|i 

O Cg yzg Z e Z
# : i {zt X y*
',
iq
-Z ~}g !*

X Hc*
g

t X HVY ( intelligent design) Z yzg Z e L L

X Z (
~ g^Zy*

"Why Darwin Rejected Intelligent Design," in

Intelligent Thought: Science versus the
Intelligent Design Movement, ed. John
Brockman New York: Vintage, 2006)."


q
-Z yZ0
+{ kZW,
Z Zz 6,yzg Z e wZ e

E
2whg
.G
: Hy E

KZgzZekZyzg Z eg e
X ( 2001ZBg :y) gZ

"Randal Keynes in Annie's Box: Charles

Darwin, His Daughter and Human Evolution
(London: Fourth Estate, 2001)."

4E
7 6,Vzz Z~
3G
X y Z',HE
Cyzg Z e
Y +G
5BEZz x **
:ug c*
E) E
kZ
"Voyaging (New York: Knopf, 1995) and The
Power of Place (Princeton, NJ: Princeton
University Press, 2003)."

xg X[!*

r }g t  ] t ~ }g !*
z f gzZ
G-4$
} (, q H {zL L y* y Z',G3 G z J e

b:HW L L[2y Z',

mt ? CZzG]

?VY Z}
.

118

X (
~ ]P~}g !*
w
"What Makes Big Ideas Sticky?" in Max
Brockman's edited volume What's Next:
Dispatches on the Future of Science (New
York: Vintage, 2009)."

][Zt L Ly*yZY]!*
: gzZx 8
-

92 k%Z}h
+`
y*t X
Hc*
~ ]; Zg Z ~

X Z(
~( Y 2006)

"The Cognitive Psychology of Belief in the

Supernatural," in American Scientist 92
(2006): 142-149"

}p a k%Z 4 yZ  YZ {z

bzg : ~
C: 7,gz[ yZ pX  D .
"7,
+
igzZ
X g (
~2011[tX ];0
"The Belief Instinct: The Psychology of Souls,
Destiny, and the Meaning of Life."

+ Ze el
g ~wZjZ {q
-Z }g!*
W,
Z C{ V
H
X 7,
~y* **
}
>
6,5Z L L~yh=ee Z[
"The little purple man" in Richard Dawkins'
The God Delusion (New York: Houghton
Mifflin, 2006), 349."

X Cs
# zbg ZzZa~f<
[t

Ukggz Zq
-Z ]
KZ {oI tgzZq
-Z

Q[!*

119

M|e-e Zzp
pg p ~bkZX g ZzZa p\z
/
gzZ
G4
5-G
X M
h| 7,
]}gzZ<
:wg H
4,
zgZ e[z
G
i
+z {z kZ X ( 2002 6, D s W ;gE- : D)
E 4E
4h$ZG-G
Xg Z
',
- ` WVYtgzZ J m
J
yZz6,
<
: H5EH
[
"David Sloan Wilson's Darwin's Cathedral:
Evolution, Religion and the Nature of Society
(Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 2002)
and Nicholas Wade's Faith Instinct: How
Religion Evolved and Why It Endures (New
York: Penguin Press, 2009)."

: 7
,
!el
gacgZzZa~fp\z
/
"The Adaptationist-Byproduct Debate on the
Evolution of Religion: Five Misunderstandings
of the Adaptationist Program," Journal of
Cognition and Culture 9:? The Cognitive
Psychology of Belief in the Supernatural," in
American Scientist 92 (2006): 315-332. "

:aU~g Z<

"Lyle Steadman and Craig Palmer's The
Supernatural and Natural Selection: The
Evolution of Religion (Boulder, CO: Paradigm
Publishers, 2008)"

: yjiZ~[kZZuZg Zza<

"Pascal Boyer's Religion Explained: The
Evolutionary Origin of Religious Belief (New
York: Basic Books, 2001)

120

?VY Z}
.

Robert Dunbar's explanation of religion's use

of intensionality is found in "We Believe,"
New Scientist 189 (2006): 30-33.
"The Cognitive Psychology of Belief in the
Supernatural," in American Scientist 92
(2006): 30-33."

6,g i
~ gzZ  Za I g Z
tt

*`
{z X Y Y V; + I  D Y 0I
J
gzZyZ];Z
Z {zX hZz^kXZ7
-mvE
F.*

X { Z',
u]c*
D
g Z^kXZ7
-

E
4)9FgzZ V +
2F
.G
V6&yzb!*
~ V- E
$Y ^k XZ
X n
pgm ]!*
ZzYK6,
K}uzq
-ZgzZ
yZ[yZgzZ}pF\z
/
kZgzZ+ I
"Why We Cooperate (Cambridge, MA: MIT
Press, 2009)"

: M~[ kZ + Iwh
eVy!*
i
"Origins o f Hu man Co mmu nication
(Cambridge, MA: MIT Press, 2010)"

` y W y
/q
-Z y Cg ZZ MOZ'

$ZgzZ xu,
.nG
;6,xzgFi
/F
W V,Z X yZ ];~ ;gE# n
Z
pgyDg ~i x { c*
i r Vz%._gyZX
X D{ c*
i]!*
.~g^~V Vg
_

xxu,WX  C && { c*
i ._ f ~ Vg

gzZ]Y!V,ZX C7^Z r %~gF

121

: [(q
-Za~gx
"The Essential Difference: Male and Female
Brains and the Truth about Autism (New
York: Basic Books, 2003)"

X C{ c*
i D Za ]!*
.~g^ Vz%
_

KZ aV Zz Za
z i Z I
H^
E
2$ C;g **
.G
xE
-Z r ]!*
q
.X ~gz 'TVzn
_
X *
@Yc*
0*
~[!*
-Z [
q
+
ZgzZ/zhgyw
"The Evolution of Psychodynamic
M e c h a n i s ms , " i n T h e A d a p t e d M i n d :
Evolutionary Psychology and the Generation
o f C u l tu r e, ed . Je ro me B ar k o w , Led a
Cosmides, and John Tooby (New York:
Oxford University Press, 1992)"

[!*

H8
^ E4h E
g ! W l wd { c*
i ]gzL L

:
H1[

"Wh y Wo uld An yon e Believe in Go d?

(Lanham, MD: AltaMira Press, 2004)"

Zg Z {wEZ<
~T [
',
iq
-Zt

E
2$
.G
bz[ ~g7 ~y
W[ kZ%ZX
HHy VE

HHs ZZ <

|6,g)~ T s Z
/Zcq
-Z Zz

( anthropomorphize) **

KZ V
s
KZ X
<
G-Y
q[~ ^g Z-

?VY Z}
.

122
"Faces in the Cloud:A New Theory of Religion
(New York: Oxford University Press, l993)"

V,ZX Wz6,];~ *gsW;gE- kZel

g

Zz vV~fZ]
.Zw7W}g~V~f
KZ
E
2 $
.G
yV * ~g XK y @ZgzZgVE

~ [ ],
1 0*
kZ X kZ bzgE Zg Z Z
+ I ]

X
HHy

"Religion Explained: The Evolutionary Origin

of Religious Belief (New York: Basic Books,
2001) and Scott Atran's In Gods We Trust:
The Evolutionary Landscape of Religion (New
York: Oxford University Press 2002)"

H
? c*
VY A8
-[
+Zgi
+g 5

b`gzZc*
Zz%1X]uZzz~kZ

X **
WC
!*
s9
#

"The Evolution of Psychodynamic

M e c h a n i s ms , " i n T h e A d a p t e d M i n d :
Evolutionary Psychology and the Generation
o f C u l tu r e, ed . Je ro me B ar k o w , Led a
Cosmides, and John Tooby (New York:
Oxford University Press, 1992)"

] 0*
z c*
]k+
x ]

X n
pg c*
j4{ c*
i6,

&a@ZC!*
/G
: G
kZ

"Memory and Mystery: The Cultural Selection

123
of Minimally Counterintuitive Narratives" by
Ara Norenzayan, Scott Atran, Jason Faulkner
and Mark Schaller in Cognitive Science 30
(2006): "The Cognitive Psychology of Belief
in the Supernatural," in American Scientist 92
(2006): 531-553."

gzZVEu[x  @*
3y*t

X n
pgw~
/
%~VEI
yZy
KZgzZ  Tg} a
0
+
i {%izg][Z t

X ]VC
!*
V=6,gx M
hib)~z~
C
X YY HvJ
-ZgzZ YY c*
ZC
YY 3g c*
WZ
'
X M~[ E)GR,
e N*
 {x q
-Z bzgE Zg Z <

"Minds and Gods: The Cognitive Foundations
of Religion (New York: Oxford University
Press, 2006)."

el
g ig-R,
^',
Zg~ q
-Z ~ ] l+F,
Z[
b ~ The Selfish Gene [ Zz (
~ Y 1976 + Z e
ci
+Z ~g c*
, [)lt X  Ds
# z g R
p
]c*
,
.zX YY ~
! o gzZ ( intuitive theists)+uZ]
Xc*
Zz} Zg'e
sg ( promiscuous teleology)
"Are Children Intuitive Theists? Reasoning
abo ut Purpose an d Design in Nature,"
Psychological Sciences 15 (2004): 295-301"

VagsJ H{g (
Z s WgZ sz yg0zg

X D Y0*
~

124

 D ~ Vg V LZ  D Zz vI

?VY Z}
.

DW ~ *, bkZ {z n
pg VzuzgzZ

:G~}g !*
q~^kZ ~` \W
/ZX *
@Yc*
0*
7
"Military A sso ciatio n o f A th eists an d
Freethinkers, www.militaryatheists.org."

"
J4E
5G
~e 5G
e kZ CW7 ~K g Z

:
HHq Z

"Human Nature and Belief," Darwin Festival,

Cambridge University, July 8, 2009"

X YW6,
\Wt

CMc*
g {%c*
g wEZ VzR,
V,Z

% OCgX W **
gqZ%X M
hi/G
WX Z%=%gzZ Z m,
e ]g[pg

X W~z~g ZDqq
-Z
A&

X g (ZwIk
,
Zz
WZ}
.L L

* bv Wkk
,
tZzW6,
x
~Y 2003
g!*

Xbqz**
d
$
kZVX )gf~ Z~
:._~ Zq
-Z ~6,
$d
V
$z **
snopes.com
X **
,
k
g *
*tL L
X *
@YWZ}
.Z

X @*
zgwgZD
&C
1t

X _ 3} 7~V70
+
iVk
,
t

X 7
-~W Z}
.\WX X X ,Zp\W

125

X,kCV=p~0
+
iKZg0
+Zg0
+Zyq
-Z G\W

X Og:zJ
-p~ ZkZp,: c*
,6,
kZ\W e

X NJ
-V]i Z Z
X
4
E
5k
4G
5"G
,
k
uZzt X k
,
G3E
,
tL L._V
$ d
$z kZ
X k
,
z gz
F iq
-ZgzZgzT **
7
X
4
5 L L h
"G
4G
5E
,
k
kZ 78
-g {z G3E
+'
~V
$d
$z
X 8
-gkZX X X gW~

" gzZX **
4G
5tE
zC

G3E
: 3g bZ q
-Z Lk
,
L Z}
.L Lx**
kZ

X iq
-Z~k',
Vzg ZD
: Lg @*
W

kZ
8WZ}
.k
,
z{8
-gw !*
q
-Z

X]gzgzZqZZ}
.g0
+Zy
KZ ]oZz]!*

[!*
NY -i
+zgzZx Stanley Milgram &
+
e6,,
MZ

X yc*
g yZ~X

X Vp! zZ~bzgE Zg ZgzZ];]Z

**
(+F,
Zq
-Zaq] h
+'
~}g!*
kZ

X , k
,
FyZgzZV
$d
$z Jonathan Haidt's ^

"Morality: A Comprehensive Review of Moral Psychology"

Handbook of Social Psychology

V,Z [!*
{zt

c{ Zz6,
]Z~g k
,
{u" q
-ZtX a
X }kzg

126

: 7
,
[^a"7,
{^
,YhvyZ

?VY Z}
.

"The New Synthesis in Moral Psychology,"

Science 316 (2007): 998-1002.

:t[ Zzh
e{wq
-Z]ZVzg Y
"Marc Bekoff and Jessica Pierce, Wild Justice:
The Moral Lives of Animals (Chicago:
University of Chicago Press, 2009)"

}g !*
VzgZgzZ]ZyZbgzZbg**
Z6,

~[Dqq
-Z KZ kx zq
-Z}gkZX Y7~
X c*
g
Z

"The Moral Landscape: How Science Can

Determine Human Values (New York:Free
Press, 2010)"

x ]Z
KZ bzgE gzZ yZ bb {z
" XB
5G
Paul Bloomx w0*
~ ;gE- G
bg w~
/
%aVE

&[yZX Hx
/G
: G
',
i6,
VLgVyZgzZ
"Descartes' Baby: How the Science of Child
Development Explains What Makes Us
Human (New York: Basic Books, 2004)"

YZ 5Z Z~V/J
-{ &V,Z~V1: ! Z

X 1{ ^
,Y moral inferential systemsV

: 7,
!yZa% Z eq
-Z6,
x x

"The Moral Life of Babies," New York Times

Magazine, May 5, 2010."

E3G4H
5_
~ Y 2010 )^',
Zg zgE q
-Z ;gE- eg E

127

y*Nq
-ZaZN*
ug c*
E
"This Is Your Brain on Metaphors"

g *Vzg Y k Zx Z}g  c*
C V,Z~ T

gaS
Qc*
D 3 **
3[Zy
c*
 **
3ZZvZ
# X F6,

zr }g 1^ (,{ q
-Z T !~}g !*

X Dx
/
u{

^e];yZ0
+{aCgzZ]Hw ~
/cp

: YYJ 7,
6,
y*{+Z

"Scott Atran's outstanding "Genesis of Suicide

Terrorism," Science 299 (2003): 1534-1539.
"The Cognitive Psychology of Belief in the
Supernatural," in American Scientist 92
(2006): 166-172."

&[iz
/G
G
Z] [ Barbara Ehrenreich

"Dancing in th e Streets: A H istory o f

Collective Joy (New York: Henry Holt, 2006)"

**
Zg eVzg Y u **
]Zgq
-Z g w yZ

F ~Vzg k0*
}gtNiz
Zwq
-Z~ yZX
z~T 7k
,
+Zpg a **
N Zv~Xk
,
z+Z

X Vg]!*
Z
Z
E
H$
58E~ yZ bzgE {h
.G
E
~ ;gE- E4h6,  E
+I q
-Z}

X D J 7,
];

: YY~y*kZyZsgWg q
-Z W
"Serotonin, Motor Activity and Depression-

?VY Z}
.

128
Related Disorders," American Scientist 82
(1994): 456-463."

gzZ ~dgE ( Stephen Stahl) w6y-a~gt

HH7 bkZ Z X  C7sg{6,Y g r

gzZ~~i W~dzgE Yk
,
z~g 

X YyY~}g !*
]c*
z Z KZ~

"Stahl's Essential Psychopharmacology:

Neuroscientific Basis and Practical
Applications, 3rd ed. (New York: Cambridge
University Press, 2008)"

YE
E

G
bzg
o**
bBG&ZI
Hc*
3t~Dqq
-Z

: J (,
Zw

"Ryan McKay, Charles Efferson, Harvey

Whitehouse, and Ernst Fehr, "Wrath of God:
Religious Primes and Punishment,"
Proceedings of the Royal Society B, November
24, 2010,
http://rspb.royalsocietypublishing.org/content/
early/2010/11/17/rspb.2010.2125.abstract?papetoc."

(,A ~i
Z   bZ r q
-Z Maurice Apprey

:tV,Z

 =7 al
}g ~**
voi
Z ! fL L

XD OgW

}gzZ = gzZ W k0*

}g [ZCZ gzZ >
Z ~(,{z

:HItW**

/
|
# gq
-ZgzZ
zVo)

129

?! D YKjZ @*
- 7t" g L

{zpgzZ ] wkZZ {g {i]

X M
h@*
-x
/
|
# gq
-Z

"Rodney Needham, "Percussion and

Transition," Man 2 (1967): 606-614. "The
Cognitive Psych olo gy of Belief in the
Supernatural," in American Scientist 92
(2006): 606-614.
Nicholas Wade, in The Faith Instinct: How
Religion Evolved and Why It Endures (New
York: Penguin Press, 2009)"

y &
+Z y : c 6,]:S<
Z &~

yZ {z kZ X <
Vz!*
g1Z 7WgzZ <
V Zz }k
,

b
X
HHB<
Z*i
Z.
<
Z

~ ^\z
/<
V 75 wkZyZ ~p
/Z

X VyNyZ Q~ _{g (Z

*=| 7, ZzgyZ~}g !*
<
ZF6,
.zgzZg
]

myxg
A & wEZ~dgE Z]
.Z}g gzZ <
Z
X c*
Ww

"Robin Dunbar's "We Believe," New Scientist

189 (2006): 30-33"

E
.E
yxg] g Zz 6,gK<
ZgzZ E
gz&
+Z
E
E
4hW E
.gz&
3G
}Z gzZ H
+Z Y W x q
-Z ~ X Hf m
E
.-gZ$R,
X 5i W<
Vz H
zgE

?VY Z}
.

130
"Daniel Dennett's review of Walter Burkett's
Creation of the Sacred: Tracks of Biology in
Early Religions titled "Appraising Grace:
What Evolutionary Good is God?" Sciences
(January-February 1997): 39-44"

uX M y { messenger strategy mere~

&[t~}g !*
/G
: G
_ Zz Oc*
g ZzZa ~f
"Pinker's How the Mind Works, Geoffrey
Miller's The Mating Mind: How Sexual
Choice Shaped the Evolution of Human
Nature (New York: Doubleday, 2000)"

:{ zkZ
"Daniel Levitin's This Is Your Brain On
Music: The Science of a Human Obsession
(New York: Dutton, 2006)"

yzgzZ synchronyChip Heath gzZ Scott Wiltermuth

yzV ~ X Zz (
]!*
N ~ }g!*

B}uzq
-ZZ C7,**
7ligz ~g a Za ]!*
.
_

&X C**
: /GG

w~W
"Synchrony and Cooperation," Psychological
Science 20 (2009): 1-5."

THz/q
-ZBV Zg \z
/
e0zg
E
E
.gz&
ggzZ CY| (,
gZlE
+Zx ~^\z
/
 Zx

X *
@YZ~
O

"Emma E. A. Cohen, Robin Ejsmond-Frey,

131
Nicola Knight, and R. I. M. Dunbar, "Rowers'
High: Behavioral Synchrony Is Correlated with
Elevated Pain Thresholds," Biology Letters,
2009,
http://rsbl.royalsocietypublishing.org/content/
6/1/106.full."

.;E *Z q
gu**
&Zp yE
-Z Qgz s W;gEG

B; yZ Z
# 7 B; yZ Z
# 1
z kZ r ~ wq
& yZB;yZZ
X ] LG
# gzZ bZq
-Z
"ames A. Coan, Hillary S. Schaefer, and
Richard J. Davidson,"Lending a Hand: Social
Regulation of the Neural Response to Treat,"
Psychological Science 17 (2006): 1032-1039. "
"The Cognitive Psychology of Belief in the
Supernatural," in American Scientist 92
(2006): 1032-1039."

"
4G
5E
5E
ug c*
E~PuH
y*{q
-ZY 2010~gz
22~ZN*
G
"Evidence that Little Touches Do Mean So
Much"

=X
HHyY Zz 6,W,
ZkZgzZ~ T

**
ZzgEX 5x Bd]]c*
C

E
H
k$
45 G
Te AZ Zz J(,g ZlW X Ht
Hx 6,
]Z W,
Z ~f

"Lust, Romance, Attachment: Do the Sexual

Sid e Eff ects o f Sero to n in - En h an cin g
Antidepressants Jeopardize Romantic Love,

?VY Z}
.

132
Marriage, and Fertility? " Evolu tio nary
Cognitive Neuroscience, ed. Steven Platek
(Cambridge, MA: MIT Press 2006)"

z Z',
g !*
y c*
4~ }g !*
VzgzWp &Zp

: YY~~ m,
z*

"Women Suicide Bombers, available on her

Web site, and are in her book, Army of Roses:
Inside the World of Palestinian Women
Suicide Bombers(Emmaus, PA:Rodale, 2003)"

D I }L L<
Zg I szxZ0zg
z}

zal

CgzZq
-Z}X *
@Yc*
akZsq

t *
@Y ~}g!*
w, ~ (
~oo X w

|C
X ]g~:WV
KZgzZ Z}
.aLZuZ
| 4 (Z X % X n } gZ :

f g ~g tu: ZZz X ~ Y } V- (

X Hyig-R,
^',
Zg]C

"Parental Investment and Sexual Selection," in

Sexual Selection and the Descent of Man,
1871-1971, ed. Bernard Campbell, 136-179
(Chicago, IL: Aldine, 1972)"

~}g !*
[
76,~ e ~z ~ e [Z Zg e 1
&a+ Y
/G
www.juliasweeney.com/letting_go_mini: G

:Z
+ I VY {zz!*
wZVg s<

&akZ ? CF,
/G
sz x Z0zg G
yZ  C
Z',s

133

:y*
"Why Women Are Bound to Religion: An
Evolutionary Perspective,"
http://richarddawkins.net/articles/3609."

I Zx _q
-Z **
zi ~k
,
Z ~ Y 2009

X YJa&
+
eZ
# DY|(,
zkZ]

"Yexin J. Li, Adam B. Cohen, Jason Weeden,

and Douglas T. Kenrick, "Mating Competitors
Increase Religious Beliefs," Journal of
Experimental Social Psychology 46 (2010):
428-431.
"The Cognitive Psychology of Belief in the
Supernatural," in American Scientist 92
(2006): 428-431."

2[!*
Z q
-Z yZ X  gzZ  c*
!*
zgE e q
-Z i 
y

: [{i Z0
+Zp

"Mindfield: How Brain Science Is Changing

Our World (Oxford: One World Publications,
2009)"

V,Z ~ T [!*
{q
-Z6,bzgE g Z Z I V,Z

wZjZ p x Z}
.L LgzZ Y { / Michael Persinger

X Hy

:
H1y*kZW~Bv',
E-ghZgzZ6,

134
"L. S. St-Pierre and Michael A. Persinger,
"Experimental Facilitation of the Sensed
Presence Is Predicted by Specific Patterns of
Applied Magnetic Fields Not by Suggestibility:
Re-analyses of 19 Experiments," International
Journal of Neuroscience 116 (2006):
1079-1096; Michael A.
Persinger, "Are Our Brains Structured to
Avoid Refutations of the Belief in God? An
Experimental Study," Religion 39 (2009):
34-42; Andrew Newberg and Mark Robert
Waldman, How God Changes Your Brain
(New York: Random House, 2009); Sharon
Begley,"Religion and the Brain," Newsweek,
May 7, 2001; Jack Hitt, "This Is Your Brain on
God," Wired 7, No.11 (November 1999); and
Constance Holden, "Tongues on the Mind,"
Science NOW, November 2, 2006.
Persinger, "Are Our Brains Structured to
Avoid Refutations of the Belief in God? An
Experimental Study," Religion 39 (2009):
34-42; Andrew Newberg and Mark Robert
Waldman, How God Changes Your Brain
(New York: Random House, 2009); Sharon
Begley, "Religion and the Brain," Newsweek,
May 7, 2001; Jack Hitt, "This Is Your Brain on
God," Wired 7, no. 11 (November 1999); and
Constance Holden, "Tongues on the Mind,"

?VY Z}
.

135
Science NOW, November 2, 2006."

L L D c*
6,Z e6,x !Zy*Y 2009 LZ
G$
7gj6,T
A &: G
5E
_+Zq
-Z g6,
Z}
.n
M
+
KZ ZzBq
-Z ~ VIzGx t X
HH

X m7&LkZq{Z
+a
6,
CkZ sq ~ 7,~ V VV, Z g @*

KZ
J
-O ZwZ yZ
HH Z n
pg76,Z}
.yZ {z
X
Hc*

1!I **
G
Z zgE gzZ ( neurocognitive processes) Zg Z zgE
Z Y Y H {u ( neuroanatomical pathways) V2Zg
X ce '
CV-zg
KZ u**
6,Z}
.gzZ YY HwzN
r V I)gzZ I x V yZgzZ Kapogiannis
Y -!
5BG
X E
EZ
"Dimitrios Kapogiannis, Aron K. Barbey,
Michael Su, Giovanna Zamboni, Frank
Krueger, and Jordan Grafman, "Cognitive and
Neural Foundations of Religious Belief,"
Proceedings of the National Academy of
Science 106 (2009): 4876-4881."

X wVdZ 6,
(b_t

OZ(
6,
Zsg^kXZDt
#

X ~V',
~y
W

tH @*
c*
WZ]!*
NZ O%ZY 2008
/ZV~

X$
(

136

The End of Faith, Letter to a

X k

?VY Z}
.

**
<
Z q
-ZZ The Moral LandscapegzZ Christian Nation
yZ bzgE q
-ZB B { z X Bz{ c*
i w #
Y -!
5BG
X (
~Y 2009yZ6,E
EZVI)gzZI

X 

"Sam Harris, Jonas T. Kaplan, Ashley Curiel,

Susan Y. Bookheimer, Marco Jacoboni, and
Mark S. Cohen, "The Neural Correlates of
Religious and Nonreligious Belief," PLoS One
4, no. 10: e7272."

E
5gzZ wj
/G
: G

_NgzZz~}g!*
]ZW,
ZIgzZ<
6,
M
+
KZ

X
HH7gh
+(
6,
XK(

E
H
3G45_ gzZZ Cc*
;gE-eE
V:pZ~Y 2005

+
&
e ]tSapolsky)*Z^',
ZgWz6,
YzgEgzZY
E
X @*
B;]1j gzZ /G Z'~]IB
~D
6,MZz!g~VC',gZ ]g@*

yZ @*
- n
pg yZ 6,]!*
kZgzZ  n
pg 6,Vjzg F6,C
b

Dg Z
/0
+
i8
-gq
-gzZ Zz!g~
Z X DZ~V70
+
i
Z~V70
+
igzZ ( misogynistic)g Zyiq
-Z6,
gx {zgzZ
X n
pg6,
Z}
. Zz

} (,
+
M
KZ Z}
.Zz!g~
Z t
) !*
] ;  z Z

&[yZX J
: /GG
-{

137
"Monkeyluv: And Other Essays on Our Lives
as Animals (New York: Scribner, 2005)"

_q
-Z Zz YK ~ GE s W;gE- ~ Y 2008

 @y
KZ}uz y
KZq
-Z {z6,gm{Vc*
g nF~ ZC

X Ci Z0
+Z W,
Z6,
QV

X {yva<
tU

G
'
X }g +gzZ ? ~ rz
Z <

?VY

{z { c*
i
bV-g F Zz J
-y
KZy
KZV{z
X I

"Corey L. Fincher and Randy Thornhill,

"Assortative Sociality, Limited Dispersal,
Infectious Disease and the Genesis of the
Glob al Pattern of Religion Diversity,"
Proceedings of the Royal Society B 275
(2008): 2587-2594.
"The Cognitive Psychology of Belief in the
Supernatural," in American Scientist 92
(2006): 2587-2594."

Joshua GreeneZp KZr }g ]!*

t

: y*kZ

"Fruit Flies of the Moral Mind," in What's

Next: Dispatches on the Future of Science, ed.
Max Brockman."

?VY Z}
.

138

[!*

G-4$
~ }g!*
bZR,
:j } b
A G3 GD77, yzgZ e g e
:]Z W,
@*
CZ f
"Trials of the Monkey: An Accidental Memoir
(New York: Picador, 2000) and the Dover
trial, 40 Days and 40 Nights (New York:
Harper Collins, 2007)"

4'gzZ ] C
4E
5G
lgzze HG-G
;gE- y Z',

:~] t~

? s <
g Z H

:wZ

 t gzZ  D W g Z~ b LZ yZbH

:wZ

X [ ~g7~6,
qkZgzZ &7(Z~ :[Z
? s Z}
.gzZ s <
g Z

+ Ze el
gVYf ]+
gZiF~V;Y :[Z
C
"
J4E
5G
X ~}g !*
g ZV2)@zc*
e 5G
e c*

b C
 ~gz 't ~ 6p

H"
$!*
bg Z  C
gzZX @*
7b
_-yZ
X{z7i

gzZ 0
+
iayZ ~(,
+ Z e el
g6,
gwV

i *"p
pg6,
WZaz~ q
-Z 'ZZ kZ
c*
V Y]!*

s b + Ze ~ c*
W~ }Y 7~

}g(kZwta}X J6,
qkZ~p7

139

}oW} ~ixq
-Z B ]x 6,

0Z]kZ~V*
@Yal
~Z
# tkZgzZ @*
Z h
+'

gkZ T gZ BgzZ V @*
Z Z]{a* 6,gzZ

]}tX H Za qgkZ
/
gZ}ggzZ c*

g~:gzZ;g7]!*
~iZ0
+Z ~pX ]LZ+ Ze

X Ze
$.ttw}gzZV;gw1yZb

? [ ~g76,
kZyxgbgzZ<
.
\W :wZ

V }Y t ~pV &t ] ~X X X V; Y :[Z

X :gzZb:]}

I q
-Z ZC si 'q
-}Vg @*
Ct ~

{zgzZ~X  ZZ
+ gzZ ]~}g !*
<
yZgzZ 
X Dx Z Zu"}uzq
-Z

g~g7 BZ
+ IZ}g g Z BVz

{zgzZ  7Z
+ I }g  Bt p }W

Xk
)7(~[ c*
[yZgzZ]CZ fgzZI:

Kitzmiller v. Dover Area School District 4

,
 ~ Z yY

Z
Z Zzp
pg6,
ZgzZy? L L:~l

tzG yZ X !*
 n
pg 6,2 zG~
Cq
-Z

g!*
g !*
Vz ~lkZX s Z}
.gzZ <
g Z

~g Z',Z @*
b hZ g Zt ~ ]

X @*
7h
+ F,
zZ}
.btgzZ 1t6,
e} (,

VYg6, Jerry Coyne6,t

yxg<
gzZb

?VY Z}
.

140

: M
"In religion faith is a virtue; in science it's a
vice," comes from "Science and Religion
Aren't Friends," a column in the October 11,
2010, edition of USA Today."

Zz X 0
+
i 0*
t ~~g ZyiO
6,
CnC

X Dge6,
IVgzZ ~0*
6,

?Y[ZpzZg e<
L* H

ZL LgzZ Zzp
pg 6, ~
6,
C|

yY]!*
t {zp DwEZ ]W7
-ZZh
+]
.

i t


g ~ VzR,
gzZ yb!*
 b zt Di Z0
+Z1
X g^] CCb

gzZ C& O Cg z b Z ZZh

+]
.

kZX Cy g @*
0*
g Z Vzg Y y
KZ ZZgzZ Vzg ~g

ZzY~q
-Z c*
b}i Z6,
wgZD
bZW~
X 7R *

:~7[kZTim Folger

"The Best American Science and Nature

Writing 2004 (New York: Houghton Mifflin,
2004)"

^ '

V5~ }g !*
<
g0
+Z \W [kZ
/Z

:Viz0
+Zsfzgq\W Bq
-

141
"www.richarddawkins.net Ayaan Hirsi Ali,
Infidel (2007) and Nomad (2010) Richard
Dawkins, The God Delusion (2006) Daniel
Dennett, Breaking the Spell (2006) Sam
Harris, The End of Faith (2004) Letter to a
Christian Nation (2006), and The Moral
Landscape (2010) Christopher Hitchens, God
Is Not Great (2007) and The Portable Atheist
(2007)"

?VY Z}
.

142

}

+ I   Z~
Z
C{zV~f}g sfzgq
pZ<
d
$
d
$
 ]gz
KZ ~
C{z

(kZ c*
e
$yZ0
+{<
X Cy

X 

X :Zz

X
8

B+E
gzZ a X  D W z!*
@Z
X :~ NZzi: F

gZZ
#
zkZ6,
gm{Dk
,
+i
5
X J 7,

Z6,
kZ ',
} h6,
#KZ

{z V W yZZ~
/ZgzZ g 6,<
LZ

X Y0 Z

X :{g (
Z

B A yZ q
-Zg0
+Z V~f LZ kZ X :uZg Zz
X Q~Y{

}

143

gZ
Z kZ e  Dx Z Z ]g
X :Z pZa{g
X,: c*
,

X *
@Y H76,g ]o z !*
WgzZ * gzZ q
-Z Z X [Zp

gzZ V@ yZ kZ X l wd { c*
i ]gz

GZ
D g Z kZX Q(F,
n
Z
KZ
+
-oBE
GG3.G

kZ Xtga gzZ  f
ega X Za

X CgZ{ Zg ( anthropomorphism)
E
28E
.G
XZbF,
6,
VzuzVzgZgLZ~E
}gX ];~gZg

K VgzZ Z
+ ]Zp] LZ kZ

~ZgWk~}g!*
]Vzuz~

X :e
$ Zg Z

X Q

XQ~ 6,
{L)
L gfykZ X :w+Z Z]
.z

~p
pg6, bzg L
L ZgzZf kZX :z gzZf
X Q

Q ~p
pg 6,][Z t kZ X :N*
{ c*
i +
M
KZ gzZ : | (,{ c*
i ]gzt

X@*
: *VZ ~
C

: ZatX DkCg Vzuz

<

X :yZgEsW

X g^gZa X {
G-E
8
X 5 E
gzZg ptX f
e Z}g yZX :xCCZ
yZ <
 D 
g C
!*
g}g tVY

<
s Yg ZZt gzZ Y !

144

X @*
2]Z

?VY Z}
.

X oo Z X :w+Z

kZ}g t( promiscuous teleology)

X  We
$ *~T g

X :]c*
o

$g Z! Z
\W~X NY" ~\W ( reciprocal altruism) X :e
X V Y"

@*
yJZ ]!*
kZgzZ @*
Z~ \
ok z
/ kZ

X :tzg Cxg

D Yg
/~ I ~uz c*
}v

X :~ zg

XhZz{ c*
iB{z
/y

Zz  D g z',]:S6f -ZgzZ 

X C~gza

g  CwEZ ]:SyZ ~dzgE ~gt

gzZ ~ OZp OZgzZ ~ spgzZ

X :zg

X CZ~yz

gzZ Z
+ ]Zp ] Vzuz kZ

X :ft

bT M
h wJ W Z VI

.
_
X :]!*

X Q~ "7,
L L Vz Zg Z

X  Y qDwJ Z
ZyZ0
+{

X vJ
-]I]Z0
+{ LZ