BOP

The
Bottom
of the Pyramid




 . ,
( ...)
-

," " ,
' , ," " ,
," " ,
, ,
," ,


? 5 .................................... ................................ ................................ ................................ ................................ ................................ ................................
7 .................................................. ................................ ................................ ................................ ................................ ................................
8 ...................................... ................................ ................................ ................................ ................................ ................................ ................................
: 32............................... ................................ ................................ ................................ ................................
(38........................................................ ................................ ................................ )BOP
23..................................... ................................ ................................ ................................ ................................ ................................ ................................
27........................................... ................................ ................................ ................................ ................................
:3 23....................................... ................................ ................................ ................................ ................................ ................................
:3 23............................................. ................................
25..................................... ................................ ................................ ................................ ................................ ................................ ................................
28................................................. ................................ ................................ ................................ ................................
23....................................
55..................................................... ................................ ................................
53.................................................... ................................ ................................ ................................ Grand Challenges Israel-

 ,
,
, " " "B.O.P. -"Bottom of the Pyramid
,
.
.
.
, , ,
5 .
, ,
, , ( ,)ICT ,
. , ,
(" ).

.
.
, - , ,
, .
, .

,

"

 ?
7.3 , 3.3
( ) 3.2 - ( 3-2
) 2.7 1. " " " "
( .)Bottom of the Pyraid - BOP
. ,
.
,
2
.
Stuart L. Hart C.K. Prahalad - 3553
" " . ( )
.
(
) , . ,
.
. , ,
, 3. ,
. 2.7 ,
2 - . , ,-
4
Prahalad " ".
,
.
, .
.
;
.

1
2

()PPP
, BOP - 2,555 -
( 2,555 .)PPP ,PPP , 2.3 - 3.3 , 3.3 , 3.2
, .3555 -

A. Hammond, et al, The Next Four Billion: Market Size and Business Strategy at the Base of the Pyramid, World
Resource Institute and International Finance Corporation, Washington DC, 2007
C. Prahalad and Harvey Fruehauf, The Fortune at the Bottom of the Pyramid , Wharton School Publishing, Philadelphia,
2004.
5

 ?
.
3 , 35-
.
.
.

* ""

:
* Low Income Countries: $3,522
* Middle Income Countries: $33,235 - $ 3,522


5 5.
,
.
,
. , , ,

.
,
. ,
.
.
.
,
, , , ( ,)ICT
. , ,
(" ).
:
: ()Embrace Incubators

35 - , 85
2 - .
,
.
"( "Extreme Affordability )
, . ,
, 35 -.
, ,
. .

Alexandre de Carvalho, Jessica Graf, Olivier Kayser, and Christian Vousvouras, Access to Safe Water for the Base of
the Pyramid, Hystra, Paris, 2011
7


,
. ,
. :

. 3.3 -
, 355 3.3 -
.
3.2 - ,
, .
, 3.7 -
, 255 - . ,
75% - ,3525 3.7
.
,
. , ' , ,
7.5 , 5.33
.6
,
.

Alexandre de Carvalho et al. , Access to Safe Water for the Base of the Pyramid , Hystra, Paris, 2011
8

 ,8002

: WRI 20077 ,

)World Resources Institute( WRI -( IFC -
) , 3535 35 - 8.
2.32 .
2.8 - 323.5 .
()
8002 :

355 - .
: WRI 2007 ,

A. Hammond, et al, The Next Four Billion: Market Size and Business Strategy at the Base of the Pyramid , World
Resource Institute and International Finance Corporation, Washington DC, 2007

8 33 7 , 5 , 7 -
9


:
: , ,
.
,
.
,
.

, .
9
, , .
.
. , ,
385 ( -
) , .
.
- ()peri-urban
.


. .
3.2 - ,3535 ,
( ) . 255 -
. .
.
:
,
, 55 .
.
/ (
, ) , ( , ) , .

Alexandre de Carvalho, Jessica Graf, Olivier Kayser, and Christian Vousvouras, Access to Safe Water for the Base
of the Pyramid, Hystra, Paris, 2011.
11

10

, .
, ( )
.
( ) /
.

3 - . ,-
3.7 .
.
.
.
, 3.2 - ; ,
. ,
( ) . " "
.
,
( )
, , (,)double bottom line
.

,
222 - ,3557 2.32 .
,
11
377 - 3.5 .

10 ,3532 - 75% -
A. Hammond, et al, The Next Four Billion: Market Size and Business Strategy at the Base of the Pyramid , World
Resource Institute and International Finance Corporation, Washington DC, 2007.

11

11


43304 :

: WRI 2007 The Next 4 Billion ,

.
, 2.5 , 223- ,
353 - . 35.2 - 35.3
, 237 - . , 383%
12
.
-
:

( ) , .
, (.)LPG
3.7 ,
( ) .
, . , 35
.
, ( )LED
- .
A. Hammond, et al, The Next Four Billion: Market Size and Business Strategy at the Base of the Pyramid, World
Resource Institute and International Finance Corporation, Washington DC, 2007

12

12

 ,
, . () ,
( -) , ,
.
, .
,
, ( Feed
,in Tariffs ) , .
:

( Solar Electric Light Company )

3335 , . -
.
,
( .)microfinance 375 -
' , 35- . ,3335 , 335,555 -
.
,

. ,
, . ,
.

,3533 255 - ( 75 ) ,
25 2 - .
() , 3.3 .
32 - ,
55 - ( 55- ).

-,
- , .
, " " ()SelCo Labs
. ,
.
()

13

 , 335,555
85,555 - , ,
- . ,3553 - .
25 ,
7 ( 255 ).
2 - 35-
, 35 - . ,3335
35 .

Bottom Up 0 , .
.
.
, .
0 3332 - USAID . . ,
,
, ,
.
0 , .
, .
5 . ,
25% - 32.
( )Consumer Finance 0 ,
, .

. , ( Regional Rural
,)Banks '
, .

14


,
, .
( )Fossil Fuel
. ,
.
:

, - , ,
,solar on water ,
, .
-
. ,
,
. ,

.3535 ,
.
( )biofuels ,
.

( ,)computational genomics .
,
( ,) ( ).
( , ,enhanced digestibility -
') .
,
, .
, .

()ICT
, ,
. , .
, , , .

15

 2.8 , ,
.
. ,
. -
.

( ) 53 -
13
(.)WRI, 2007
,3557 , 38.2 -
, 2 . -
ICT ,
. , 255 ,
14
.

4204 :

355
: WRI 2007 ,

Jakobus Smit, Cooperation Issues in Developing the BOP Market , Utrecht: Utrecht University, 2009. The report
can be found at: http://www.academia.edu/360950/Cooperation_Issues_In_Developing_the_BOP_Market
Enock Yonazi, Tim Kelly,Naomi Halewood and Colin Blackman, The Transformational Use of Information and
Communication Technologies in Africa , Washington D.C: The World Bank and the African Development Bank,
2012

16

13
14

 -ICT -
ICT -
.
:
.3 / ) ( :
,
.

, .
.

.
.3 ICT - , , .
15
.2 ,ICT 0
"
. , (
M-Pesa) , .
, . ,
ICT .
. ,
ICT - ,
16
" ( "").

15

Alexandre de Carvalho, Lucie Klarsfeld, and Francois Lepicardm, Leveraging Information and Communication
Technology for the Base Of the Pyramid Innovative business models in education, health, and Financial Services ,

Paris: Hystra, 2012.

Enock Yonazi, Tim Kelly,Naomi Halewood and Colin Blackman, The Transformational Use of Information and
Communication Technologies in Africa , Washington D.C: The World Bank and the African Development Bank,
2012

17

16

 - M-PESA :
. M-Pesa
, 37 3533 .
M-Pesa ,
. 222 - , ,
,3533 - 7.8
.

M-Pesa :
.3 , ( ) , , ,
, '.
.3 M-Pesa - .
, 35 M-
.Pesa

35 -
- .
32.2% ,M-Pesa .
,
.
. , ,
, ,
. ,3553 ( )UK Department for International Development
35 . ,
,
.
M-PESA
M-Pesa 3557 - .Safaricom , M- ,
Pesa . 53,555 - 3557 - 35 - .3533
P2P , 255 -

( 32%" ) . 28% - ( 27%

) . M-Pesa - 355 - ,3533
23% - . 3533 255 - ,M-Pesa
325 3533 ( 23% -" ) M-Pesa .
.
M-Pesa , 78% -.

18

 M-PESA

- Safaricom 0
Vodafone . ,
35 . ,
,UK Department for International Development
.
M-Pesa ,3557 33%-
. ,
, , ,
. M-Pesa .
bottom up - M-Pesa
.
( )microfinance ,
, .

. ,
M-Pesa .
, "" .
.
.
M-Pesa
.
, " ".
,Safaricom-
- , .BOP-
Safaricom
. ,
0 Safaricom -
.M-Pesa Safaricom , - .

, .B2B
,
. ,
, .
, ,
.
19


. , ,
.
;
.
, .IP
, .
.

, , .
, ,
. ,
, .
.
.
: , ,
- , , , , .

, Voice over IP .
, .

' ,
. ,
, , , .

/

. ,
.

.
.

21


3.83 - ,3557
2.32 . ,
3.3 - , 3.5 .
()
8,2,4 :

5 -
: WRI 2007 ,

85% - .
.
.
( ) ,
-
.

:
, .
, , ' .
, , '.
, , .
( cash crops
) .
,
, .

21

 -
,
.
.
.
, , 85% - .
, .
,
.
( : )
.
- .
.
, .
(
, ) .
.
, 25% - . ,
,
. ,
. ,
, .
.
, , ,
.
, , ,
.

22

 :
?

. ,
( ,)BOP:
BOP - .
, ,
( lease to own ).
/ BOP . ,
. ,
. ,

.BOP
( .)MFI
MFI -.
" "
. , BOP - ,
. ,
.BOP BOP
. ( )
. ,
.
- BOP
. .
BOP .
BOP - ,
.
( , )
( , -) .
,
.

23

 , . ,
BOP - - . ,
.
BOP
. BOP
. .
, ,BOP
, , .
BOP
, .
.
. ,
BOP .
, .
( )track record ,BOP , . ,
.

" "Ruf and Tuf

' . 85 - '
, 25 25 ,' .
, Ruf and Tuf - " " ' ( ,,
) 2 - . ,
, .'
, ".

?
BOP .
, , , .
, - BOP .

24

 .BOP
,
:BOP
02 BOP
. :
.BOP -
BOP- .
, ,
(. .)EMBRACE
,
, .BOP ,

.
08
( ,)Cash Economy
BOP - - .
, BOP .
BOP .
, .
( )prepaid BOP
. ,
.BOP , 85% - .prepaid

BOP ,
. " " ( ) ,
BOP (
) . , , .
, .
.2 BOP -
. , BOP .
BOP
.

25

 :

.
,
.

.
( ).
- - - .
. ,
,
.
04 " " , ,

:
, , BOP .
, , .
.3
, ( , ) ( :
) .
.
, .
, ,
.BOP , ,
.

26


, .
.
, .
.BOP -
.
BOP .
,
.
, ,
.BOP -'
, .
:
3557 ( )Grameen Bank
.BOP -
, .

.
.
BOP - , UNDPs Growing
Inclusive Markets InitiativeWorld Resources Institute (WRI) Development Through -
( Enterprise project ).

27

 ()BOP
.
,BOP -
.
.BOP :

02
.BOP - -
, .BOP -
17
.BOP -
. ( )
.
.
.
.
. ,
. , BOP
. , -
, ,
.
. .
BOP ,
.
BOP -
. ,
, .
. ,
.
. , .

17

.
, ,
.BOP
28

 08

.
.
BOP :
. BOP
. , -
. ,
, .BOP
,
.
. BOP ,
. , ,
. ,
. ,
, .
. BOP
. , ,

. , ""

.
.
- . ,
.
,
.

03
.
, " -" -
.
" " .BOP

BOP -
18
.
18 , ,
. , ,
. " " "".
29

 ,
,
. ,
.BOP ,
. , ,
BOP . ,
, :
0 ,
,BOP ( )NGO .
-
,BOP
. , ( 19
) , .
0 "" , ,
,BOP
( , , ).
0 " "
.
, .
BOP
, .
0
,BOP .
BOP - .
0 .

.
.
.
0
, , ,
( "" ) .
, ( ),
.
0
( )ecosystem , ,
, , '.
19

. .
31



. , ,
. " "
20
( )Development Finance Gap " " (.)The Missing Middle

" "

Source NCDO

, ,
.BOP ,
,
( " ") .
.BOP - , , , .
.

20

, .BOP -

31

 BOP

()

()

()

()

( )DFI

( ,

) ,

()Private Equity

" "

'.

) ,

'.

()DFI- Development Finance Institutions

( )DFI
.BOP - , ,
.
. ,
, , ,
. ,
(
"" ).
( ) ,
"( World Bank International Finance Corporation
32

 ") (European Bank for Reconstruction and ,)IFC

"( )EBRD( Development ")"( )EIB( European Investment Bank ,
")"( )AfDB( African Development Bank , ") .

, , 22 - ( 3553
) . "
BOP . ,
. ,
21
.

( )DFI BOP -
" " -
.Inter- American Development Bank
, ,BOP
. , , , ,
BOP - 2 - 35 - (
35 - ) . 355,555 555,55 -
, , ,
. :
http://www.iadb.org/en/resources-for-businesses/financing -for-bop-businesses-in-latinamerica,5764.html

:
( Inter American Development Bank .)European Investment Bank - ,
. ,


.
African Development Bank - , Asian Development Bank- ,

. ,
, , .
21

Christian Kingombe, Isabella Massa and Dirk Willem te Velde, Comparing Development Finance Institutions ,
London: Overseas Development Institute
33

 , .BOP
" , ( ,")Impact Investing
.
( .)carbon finance
.
, BOP .
:

()Impact Investors
, .
( )Global Impact Investing Network
55 3535 355 -
.
, , .
.
BOP - ,
. , .
,
, . ,
, .
BOP . ,

355,555 3 - . , BOP -
, . ,
( )debt (( ) equity )
.
.
BOP . ,
BOP . ,
, ,
. , BOP
.

34

 ()Impact Investing
,
. ,

( )Impact First
( ,Vital Capital ).
, .
, ,
.

()Carbon Market
BOP .
BOP ( )
"
( )Clean Development Mechanism-CDM (.)Voluntary Carbon Markets

.
"( )CER( "Certified Emission Reduction ) -
"( )VER( "Emission Reduction Voluntary ):
( CDM - ") ( .)Carbon credit
22
( ) , .
,CDM -
. , ,
( ) .

,
. , CDM -
355,555 355,555 . ,
, .

.
,
.
CER .VER - ,
22

- .
:CDM -
http://unfccc.int/parties_and_observers/parties/non_annex_i/items/2833.php

35

 . , -
.
,
, .
, .
.
.

Clean Development Mechanism-CDM -

;
20,000
40,000

PIN;PDD -
28;
40,000 200,00

3-2
;
20,000 -
;


6

;
84 -6

;
20,000
80,000

2-
3;
20,000
80,000 8% +
CER -

36


2 -
.
, , , , ,,
, . .
, , : ,
.
.
,
.
, . ,
, , (
) , .
, .
,
,
.
.
,
.
.3
.3
.2

.2

.5

. .
.
. BOP -
.Pay Per Use -
. BOP - ,
. ,
( .
(Market Development). BOP -
, .
.
. ( ,
') .
37

 .2 . ,
. , "
" ( ) , BOP
.

,
.
, :

3-2 .
0 , , , .
.
.
.
, , .
, / .
.
. .
.
!

38

 :2
: :
" ,3533 ,WRI

African
Development
)Bank (ADF

AFD -


( ,)ADF
-
.ADF ADF-
78

Inter-American
Development
( )IDB( Bank

IDB - -
3353

.
IDB - 28

-
,IDB
,

European Bank
for
Reconstruction
and
Development
(( )EBRD

EBRD -





33 -

.
22 ,

EIB -

(
)

-
)

()

()Quasi equity



,

,



,
,
,
A-
non-( B
)sovereign

:

;

:
A/B,


,



;

( concessional
)financing



: 5
355 -
,

5 35 -;

:EBRD -

,

39

IDB -

MIF --

,

,

( ,)IRS
interest ,

Emergency
Liquidity
FacilityTrade -
Finance Fund

rate caps and

,collars

Inter-American
Investment
Corporation

Disbursement

;Loan Program

:

;

3
355 -
.

,
,
,
"
(,)income notes
.

/


Guarantee -

guarantees for
trade
facilitation

 ()
European
Investment
( )EIB( Bank

37

,

.
35%

,
2/2-


,

35
,
,senior
,
" ,-

World Bank

International
;
Bank for
Reconstruction
.
and
388
Development

(( )IBRD

World Bank

International
:
Development

Association

(( )IDA
83 -

;
)
375

( )
World bank
Multilateral
Investments
Guarantee
( Agency

,
377

()


business -

angels
matching
funds

,
-
TransEuropean
Transport
,Network

,



,

()

( Quasi
)equity

25

,
,

,

()concessional

IDA -
( ),
.

,

( hard
)lending

"

41

 ()
World Bank
International
Finance
Corporation
(( )IFC

;

;
382
IFC -

A -
IFC

; IFC -


( lender of

C
"
,

( record

Asian
Development
Bank: Public
and Private
)ADB( Sector

(
)

.-
ADB 27

,

LIBOR
,

;
( concessional
)loans

41

,
"

( multi-tranche
financing
)facility

(,)risk sharing

( Guaranteed
offshore
Liquidity
)Facility
Risk
Management
)swaps

 :8

Heinrich, M., 2010, Public-Private Development Partnerships An Overview of Current Work of DCED
Member Agencies, DCED Working Paper.

42

43

44



...!
, :
- ,
.
:

, ,
, - Road shows , .
-
,
.

, , .
-
- ,
.
-
- ,
, , .
.

, - - :
, , , - , , , -webinars ,
.

,
.
- .
.

23 , .
.
.

45


, .
, - 32 , ( , ,,
, ) , ,
, , .
&2000
,3555
, .
, .

-
, .
,
.
.

, .
- .

, ( )EU
53- . ,
.

,
. , ,
.B2B

, .

, .

, , ,
. .
-
;
; .

46

, : , , - ,
, Experts4u .
/
, () .
, .
, , ,
-.

, , -
, .

,
, .

, (75%-
) , .
.

,
. , .

, ,
, .

47



.

. ,
. ,
- .www.israeldev.org
, ,

.

48



"( Grand Challenges Israel") "
GRAND CHALLENGES
. , , ( 355) ,
, "" .
555,555" , (PROOF OF CONCEPT), 35%
. , .
, ,
: .
. , " ,
:
" : "
. "
, .
: " ,,
, BETA -
.
" ,
.
www.matimop.org.il :
www.grandchallenges.org.il :

49

 :
3535 - ,
- .
" :

.
. "
. . 855,555-
3535 382 . 353 25 - .
:

, - , - .
.

. -EBRD,
, " ,

.
:

- , ,
. ,
, .
55%- , , ,
. 3.5
. ,3533 .
335 55
. .
, 3,255,555 73,555,555" ,
28 . .
".
" , ,
.
www.economy.gov.il/icf :

51

Grand Challenges Israel-

51

BOP
The
Bottom
of the Pyramid