Comment Resolution sheet

Sr. No.

Dwg / Doc No

Rev

Comment From PEC (21-Sep-13) Page no 4 Specify condition check YES / NO (.006>1 NO)

CPE/DC/BX48/420-VE-4265

Page no 6 Spelling mistake Adequate, Hollow cylinder Page no. 9 No value (#REF)

CPE - 34108

"View from R" CS Plate details for lifting lug. "Detail of A" Fixing detail for Top channel and cover plate Page no 4 Specify condition check YES / NO (.006>1 NO)

CPE/DC/BX48/470-VE-4765

Page no 6 Spelling mistake Adequate, Hollow cylinder Page no. 9 No value (#REF)

4 5 6 7

CPE - 34113 CPE/DC/BX48/420-VE-4270 CPE - 34109 CPE/DC/BX48/470-VE-4770

5 2 5 2

"View from R" CS Plate details for lifting lug "Detail of A" Fixing detail for Top channel; and cover plate Page no 4 Specify condition check YES / NO (1.811>1 YES) "Section X-X" Dim. not matching with design calculation. Radial width shown in drawing is 150 whereas in calc. it is 200 Page no 4 Specify condition check YES / NO (1.811>1 YES)

Sr. No. 8 9 10 11 12

Dwg / Doc No CPE - 34114 CPE/DC/BX48/460-VE-4629 CPE - 34110 CPE/DC/BX46/470-RA4710/4720 CPE 40873

Rev 5 2 5 3 5

Comment From PEC (21-Sep-13) "Section X-X" Not matching with design calculation. Radial width shown in drawing is 150 whereas in calc. it is 200 Shell stiffening design check is not included. "Section X-X" Not matching with design calculation. Radial width shown in drawing is 140 whereas in calc. it is 200 Page no. 16 Check the Tags (Gusset & Baffle) "View from B" 80x60x12 thk stiffening shall be provided on opposite side also Agitator nozzle N10 detail shall be furnished

13

CPE 40874

"View from B" 80x60x12 thk stiffening shall be provided on opposite side also Agitator nozzle N10 detail shall be furnished

14

CPE 34127 CPE/DC/BX48/440-VE-447 CPE 34117 CPE/DC/BX48/530-VE-5370 CPE 34115 CPE/DC/BX48/550-VE-5570

2 2 5 2 4 2

No comments No comments "Section X-X" Dimensions are not matching with calc. Please check. Radial width shown in drawing is 150 whereas in calc. it is 200. Thickness also marked as 8 instead of 10. No comments "Section X-X" Dimensions are not matching with calc. Please check. Radial width shown in drawing is 150 whereas in calc. it is 200. Thickness also marked as 8 instead of 10. No comments

15

16

Sr. No.

Dwg / Doc No CPE 34116 CPE/DC/BX48/470-VE-4740

Rev 4 2 5 2 5

Comment From PEC (21-Sep-13) "Section X-X" Dimensions are not matching with calc. Please check. Radial width shown in drawing is 150 whereas in calc. it is 200. Thickness also marked as 8 instead of 10. No comments "Section X-X" Not matching with design calculation. Radial width shown in drawing is 140 whereas in calc. it is 200 No comments "Section X-X" Not matching with design calculation. Radial width shown in drawing is 140 whereas in calc. it is 200. Ht mentioned in calc as 150 whereas in dwg it is 110

17

18

CPE 34112 CPE/DC/BX48/460-VE-4635

19

CPE 34111

Comment Resolution sheet

Date :21-Sep-13

Resolution From CPE

Resolution From CPE

Resolution From CPE