H}gg$$ }[Eg F F F [[[E$g$ [[

e
\ J

g [E $ FE i I [gBE i F FgEE$ i6l I I H -lrr rts t*rg$$ gi6$f [6g I$ E fgEE*uil[r F sFre ra seH r
i*FE+:1:FE
lr.
|d.

In Latin America in Comparative Perspective, Peter H. Smith, ed. (Westview, 1995), Chapter 6.

o H1

\ \

F D) FF
F.

8H 'Eg.
$ f
Flr Fr.

e 8
\t Fl

1 [E' t[3 lF1$ [ * [f,$$ IE;IE$ g $ [ f t f lr " u63 R F ' f:g; f i [ [ # f

\

[eeE $g agg [{i ffi rg;ig[e

Electronic copy available at: http://ssrn.com/abstract=1751834

" d d + lFllE; E8 i l e P i l H ds+g

Hrt-r , H f [ " fg : H{ r * H I E r ; g : e

FU 6 5 o tA B FF t=t
F. FF F. F L V F.

3 E 3 o o Ft \ H \ r) H. D) 9) r 6 1 5 Et b'

r) (') 9 . "

*-l[ gga;liitilggggligEig gEIliffill;igg; {**,*,'EFe['$ i $Ei EFIilfr ;5r [**[Es*sAfgs E$i{Fi* i gE[Eflgifliiigg if;li$-gigg+[[ [iFEE $i*
Electronic copy available at: http://ssrn.com/abstract=1751834

F*i*siu$*EE$ EiEFiiEg3[EI'ffi u iIF iii3iF* ggg c;+;*laaeii*{g}g$gg g6g;**q i *ii i gii;lgiEilggg'Eil;gl iigEii ig
(J) @

r-1

lt-

rl.1

\ o
H

ii3F$iEEE$giFl$ig EiiiiEr ;ia'legg;*s; ggg*; lig fif1$$ggF;;*a F$[iE$i iEi Eif[igfE3ig{$Fi[[ i+*eiis
-l

(n

l-l

z
F?1

r-

-l

o U)

iEEifliiF{ii[gFiiFiEi ; rri*gangs*l iFEiFFE{EFB $giEgF[Fig$$ [fEg lig'gg ir*rrFgFgti$ i' iffi *[s$FEreEr=i[

i i$iF F FEs iEs$ii*iiig$iiFi$ iEEiE$ ii fficsere rllil+iFile;igitggg$g 5 igE$$Ei-$igiiiii Fii3Fiiii l$iFfliiflf$E l

[Ei[$iiiiEii***'FrBl$

qJf 'ox
o (t ;'
^

X
v

o iD :'l
6 a ) Ft ! r i M VY

Ac x

F-l

- - l a t

II
l

- l
( / ) l

o _

r D - l x 5 l
r

T .r Y
a

n
V

c
)

- < ;
i -

hV'
l U

F =F ' i i
n -

tr; I
I

= o a- ' l
l

sEg l e d I 3 H 5 EE-l
rr1 n ts. I
I dr l

t
l

ix. n

-o
i * 0 i ; o ? o a q *o L Fr

-t
1

zG ' ;n. .
; +

i - . ' I d = l ;6 |
J
t

5'< | |
I
l

6
(

'

I *lrgrgr ***i fg*fgl rli :

fJ

'F lA

gIa*iil[essa, rgfigigEiggtg a$riiirE tIa gffiEiiEF6*?a F;5Fr$E $$ffSEEr$slI i[[EiElBEig i?E[EE rgE ?6iEIIFiEfilg t[f$E iEg E$giEFiE giB[Efs $gE $Egffixg[*?:* i sr*'*i-[l
-

fl $Ff r + [ri$6E Tfril $*$EB rfii ; e sl H i; E sn *$ E ; ge + e e ;I F;.[]F l g f3 i l F s s $ l + I f$E 1$fi $1ffil1ri3 tFg$Er filEEIFI frt iq;ri$r$EFrIF
o

*E f ;1355 rFa.#sfr [rHc +sFiE rI rH

r H f[g$* r+ifia$frr+Frrr[i r i pi*H e E n t s $H EgSi I a a$ , + +

l

8 S t A ; r 5 - t o - n H o
9 t
i

3'En6.a7. !t3 5 i I 8 6 ! a = i i . 0 a
tt

= y

s g : l g q

Z ! 5 .

3firD \
h

8 e
(n

a rrsg ifrI' n Ff [ +ge [ iE'Et

o U ) - P

-r*$ [*gu[{gE F * fiI : [ : $ *f i s r

s? f;17

r r 2a e 8 3 H R

a'X

*u

q n
< F-t

: <

)d

::

!
f

/\)

\J

x
t , !r

F
r VJ

iilHg$&
: , j - p aF d

;.H ETr til {[r

l E H fI

frf X3H sx i<s

T )
/n J

? '-H

i3 Pii:\

(n

rt
H /

.
!

(n

2
t

$6BtIrgeBg{

T ; E{

6* fii EH E g g ? q ?

o 3 ;+ p
! .

r
.

\,/s - l r i l z
A Ft-l F

ar

F:
I

g+lgtt F$6 $$ *F F [il$ e+ 1a

[ i [ [ bi l t r i ; E s * ;g l lt t l s [

Ei
$
o 3
;5' ^
i n

*3

:E

T H 5

';

TT

oa
a t H H

fF
i E
O
)

f;f;

sH :

3 ' z
H v v ' Y ^ L

cn

-J

o (n

F R

3q
Y

f;

3 ? U i
'F Ln

|5

[lgeiilFlgilg lgiilgiggiiffi lr g T1gSg;6;elirirrel i ;g Ei i+$*u*fiflgii$iFiis i

t-l

g;

r-

lrr1

o -

\ o Fi1

lFiiFiElEiEs;l?sE i3giiiifsiisflE }EElriiiEiE iiiBii[EiEiiiIgEE iilgi$$$ ililiHig tiii[ffi'eElislEil iiiiiiiii$E il

-l

z
trl

z
ln

z -U
r-l

+ r n

t <r* 5 P ( ' A r n - ' = ' - J

S'o

o(,
t t l l lU) tn I t J . +
H
t s F t

( n x
E N A A

E <
r r l l

( ^ x
E $ $ A

FI1 F l - F

:F**;

H il E'Et F

F I H+ Hi !-:'7r: YiE
s 30 P Ei; i lr) irtF5 ^ O = ' o - D A e Ei E * T EXH B3
\ a i ^ i i

ri

a $

t'r'l(
'
Y F . t N O

t (n

a -' \R

l l t t l l l-l r- ll' h l V F . 6 i^'H

)

2 5'8 L r f - ) . 1
O . ' . a -

!-

ir.

( ^ x ^ *: ^- '
F

:n
F ' W W / ^ i v

i.J

\u

i{
$

F e-ril
( r 7 @ (n ap. '= :9.H O . A o H '

r . X X

aqr
D ) . ) t s n

oq

s ) : : L

o
(h (h

V) (t (n

n x'

g ^ l
o n x'l X l n

F
('J

, ; X P

E5 +

F a o
^ A . V

E 8 e'El:?' : 1 c 0 ' O : l R

X ( ,

i-j E t q )
H -

Ft FI

I b ' H b ' 1 ,q l b ' q F

l - l * F l l

+ t l ! . r : + X

d F

/ H

o ! ) 5
F (t) Fl

+
t J

+
J Ft v

P T?i;
F r _

gq

I B I \J
O

R;ts XH F G a3 \5
U.l i F
i

H sB a l t
i-l ' g r+ | x \ ;-l t l I l l

5 ci6 5lF l ^ l 0 ) o t ) *
r'1 + >1 l-.j

(/)
FJ r-t

?.

x.(,
F T F ' 2f X' tr) t s . + +
H F . ! . ctvY / t s r D

v r i '-l !Y F . p G t ' 1 F . t / H i t H i s . ^

X' \
r)

(rl

o D)

+ l n P . / H

S -

i F 0
F l
H

+lJ

D ) D ) F D

u 3 + 6
q c
F 1 F L ^ ; F i A +

a ('.
@ D)

_l
ctY b J

rll

I J

tssq=

. (

n
s |

a
H <

'
( 1

t F

'tt

Fl F
H

E X

YO H. * -6 o lrsi

(r)

I
:]

-t

z (,
o
Ft

. Il b
-1

p.

L
Erl
H H

6 :s

E s

F > N3

Cf
-

o 6 '
H

r+

\ S R
G J i ; l

\
X

*d ig
, - O i"i
v ^ i H J

S \ *

3
O e

('J

*l
r*l

H l e + t l '.t + I

$j l>' a f
C

(, (' t* (t 6 ' 0 ' -q

6 n

s.
(a

r-t

lG.'

r-.i rl

t r 3 r :
;r. X 39)
^ i d

ni

v l R '
J

U)o

o
r+.4

I
o

l ' I

n
hl

: H

;
D

'

'

r :

+
!-

'

H
Fl

q ;

'
/n

\:i r-i' v
S
$ N A

=g oE i' P

5 o .3 x
n X
o- A) @
6

7 0 9 = Y
(e = 6H

t))

l-l

E Eq d e'
5

ll

P
e * f r F .

s K
m ' H H

; \ 6 ;o . ( 7^
-\
(n )J

; ' l y Fa-t -

i E fs ln + 3
Xd H
r H . i + l!. F ' . A + ) F * / vY

I'-d

P
('J

fti

fg$+Eo Eg$r f;

E
F
z
H '

g +
A
)
6 H

+ r,fi

qi o [ i

r = o R 5

ctF F$ o l fr l
+
.

a 6 ' E ' E t s gF

o.a

X H 5
) D
\

1e
o
+
J

'

d 6

!)

iiFFiii$#ffggffHFii$ Ffitsis g

ffiiffisiffsiffiii$rffi**$ ffgifffr i

Eii[**g;;[iig ; : iiilgEigiglg;giiIg

$if$ li* ff FgFEEii$f tggffi iiffH$ffifflFff g ggggg;gg'geei*i*F i g*i*fE*[F{ F$$*fr*r$*r ii'i$fi f, i

F i[ig gEE$$IgigE$EE [EgUi IEBEg$iiilE igEEFIiiiEiEEEE FgiiggEiEF

iiEfqEi[iEiigiFg ilBgfii{EiFi FgE E -srt'-*t--s-EEgFEit == E i[$tii[B g5H EFfiE igFilii$siiiFir[rFrg = g;tg;ggEiffirrgiiiirr E llgrIig;g [fif[*-,[i[[i'[ii*-*fiF**$ *-fF*$ :

t rE r s F I e iiastE {itEEg [[iEgt*EEiE [$ IgrE$ iE$sE ffi{lE[iEiFE iiiIFEF[iEEFtiS i[

r;a$isll;i*;;;riisill;rF g f FEiiiilliiisrglligggli; i i F$ glsrisigFigig;$aigg g isgi;igigg i

i$[iigig[[[FgEiiiEi[g EgE$gt[SEgE[*[gg r?E-*gflFl$r6f+E[[

ffffiffffimwwffT*ffiff r;iic$$ig$$$ ffiF #ffl$gsgegggi;ggg ffltiTiw*f

F (tl @

U o t-

= rn

E r$ IfiEE iiE F lfi EiE $rE;$ is sisui iE,i i$i [E{ f$[ I
\ o
F71

(, K

-l

z
-l

iiF iiii$Ei$i $ii$iiiiii iEgE[EiEFii i$igel$'$$gi iiI $3iEfltifi,i $iFfi lg$$$ t' ia+$a sis *iil[$s in et $i i iac fis*sr
z
ln

o
f-i

z
-

-.1

v)

(.rl

Fr

i$EgfiF$F$ i iFFi$$$iriii$Fii

* ;E **Etiii qgi gg lss *g tgit ts*Ilr $ *gsl ilggl l [*E $EiF$ gs $[ig lI*]i l*i [*i rEgg rrlsg ig i
o\
N

s
n

n $ E [iis $r s i

$$.;gb$i

gfg ug* *$ruffififlE lrr[$t*s $ltg$ sg$;$r

*$ig Y$ [$$es{g i $sflE$$ 6$FF frf IiHg[ l$F gi$"$ iEtEF;;rgf $itrinl ifil$$i
L^J

lF

E*[i$

$fE