The document discusses a plan for the United States federal government to substantially increase its economic engagement toward Cuba, Mexico, or Venezuela. It notes that the plan text specifies investment by the USFG, not just investment generally. It argues that allowing the plan to be interpreted more broadly to include investment from other sources would mean the plan's solvency could not be researched fairly and would create an infinitely regressive debate with a moving target. Careful writing of the original plan is important to incentivize research and limit the scope of the round.
The document discusses a plan for the United States federal government to substantially increase its economic engagement toward Cuba, Mexico, or Venezuela. It notes that the plan text specifies investment by the USFG, not just investment generally. It argues that allowing the plan to be interpreted more broadly to include investment from other sources would mean the plan's solvency could not be researched fairly and would create an infinitely regressive debate with a moving target. Careful writing of the original plan is important to incentivize research and limit the scope of the round.
The document discusses a plan for the United States federal government to substantially increase its economic engagement toward Cuba, Mexico, or Venezuela. It notes that the plan text specifies investment by the USFG, not just investment generally. It argues that allowing the plan to be interpreted more broadly to include investment from other sources would mean the plan's solvency could not be researched fairly and would create an infinitely regressive debate with a moving target. Careful writing of the original plan is important to incentivize research and limit the scope of the round.
Interpretation: The United States federal government should substantially
increase its economic engagement toward Cuba, Mexico or Venezuela. Violation the plan means the USFG does not increase ITS investment toward Mexico. The plan text just says The United States federal government should substantially increase investment Its is possessive - Belonging to or associated with that means the plan can also not be from the US, but from other sources Oxford Dictionary 10 (Of, http://www.oxforddictionaries.com/definition/its?view=uk) Pronunciation:/ts/ possessive determiner belonging to or associated with a thing previously mentioned or easily identified:turn the camera on its side he chose the area for its atmosphere Voting Issue: 1 Grammar - it outweighs --- it determines meaning, making it a pre-requisite to predictable ground and limits and, without it, debate is impossible Allen 93 (Robert, Editor and Director The Chambers Dictionary, Does Grammar Matter?) Grammar matters , then, because it is the accepted way of using language, whatever ones exact interpretation of the term. Incorrect grammar hampers communication, which is the whole purpose of language. The grammar of standard English matters because it is a codification of the way using English that most people will find acceptable. 2 Limits they could literally get their funding source from anywhere (private sector, foreign nation FDI, subsidies from international institutions, charity from the public, etc). That makes research impossible and kills fairness. 3 the 1AC abuses this the solvency evidence is just about private investment. Plan solvency would mean they fiat private sector or international investment. 4 - infinitely regressive ignoring one word in the resolution justifies ignoring others this creates a slippery slope which always makes the AFF a moving target and makes being NEG impossible. 5 US investment is key to stable links dealing with US action like politics, tradeoff, spending, etc. These arguments help education. 6 Careful plan writing the plan is the center point of the debate. They had infinite prep to write the 1AC plan text. Careful plan writing incentivizes research on various terms and their implications with the resolution. 6 This is a voting issue, and is not a throwaway argument. Hold the AFF to a high threshold.