MATOTITU ITUREI HA-TORAH QUESTIONS BY RABBI CARL ASTOR 1. The Reubenites and the Gadites owned cattle in very great numbers!"#um! $%&1' Iturei Ha-Torah& (Mikneh rav( ) "lit! (ownershi* o+ the Rav(' ) they had ownershi* in (the Rav,( i!e!, Moses our Teacher! And they could not se*arate +rom him! There+ore, they stayed on the other side o+ the -ordan! "The seer of Lublin' a! .hat, according to this inter*retation, caused them to remain on the /ast ban0 o+ the -ordan1 b! Is this a danger today1 2. Moses re*lied to the Gadites and the Reubenites, (Are your brothers to go to war while you stay here1( "#um! $%&2' Iturei Ha-Torah: The sim*le meaning o+ this te3t is, (4o you thin0 that while 5your brothers go to war5 ) when enemies attac0 Israel ) 5while you stay here5 ) that you can sit in *eace and 6uiet in your dias*ora1( 7et this not enter your mind8 The battle +or de+ense o+ Israel is the battle +or the e3istence o+ the entire *eo*le o+ Israel! a! 9ow is this a**licable to today5s world1 b! 4oes this necessarily mean living in Israel1 ANSWERS Iturei Mattot/Massey - Astor % 1a! They could not brea0 their attachment to the *ast: in this case, Moses! This attachment held them bac0 +rom *rogress! 1b! .hether it is attachment to a great leader, a building, or a custom, there must be a willingness to move +orward! %a! .e cannot sit bac0 and say that Israel5s *roblems are not ours! Our +ate and destiny are closely lin0ed to that o+ Israel! %b! .e can hel* as much, and sometimes even more, +rom here, i+ we ta0e our roles seriously ) raising money, involving ourselves in *olitics, etc!