B

APPROVED A
Approved without exception
APPROVED WITH COMMENTS AC
Approved Subject to Incorporation of comments
RETURNED FOR CORRECTION RT
Insufficient Information/ Detail
Resubmit for Approval
REJECTED RJ
Complete redesign required
RECEIVED FOR INFORMATION I
Returned without comments
RECEIVED FOR INFORMATION IC
Returned with comments
any obligations covered under contract
Engineer:
Discipline:
Date:
Note: Approval or comments does not relieve the Contractor of
Pyry Energy
TWO(2) X 500MW
MONG DUONG 1 THERMAL POWER PLANT
David Langhorne
Senior Mec Engineer
28-Jun-13
Pyry Comment
Two(2) x 500MW Mong Duong 1 Thermal Power Plant Project

Dwg. / Doc. Title
Cross Over Piping
Drawing For BFP and
Booster Pump
Dwg. / Doc. No. MD1-0-V-121-23-00002
HDEC DT No. MD1-HDH-EVN-X-1219 Submitted Date 2012.11.20 Rev. A
Pyry TR No. 9A000323-002852 Received Date 2012.12.11
New HDEC DT No. MD1-HDH-EVN-X-3788 Re-Submitted Date 2013.06.13 Rev. B
Status Submitted for Information Returned with Comment

Page 1 / 1
No. Pyrys Comments Contractors Reply / Action
1 Please provide KKS identifying number for
equipment and instruments on the drawings.

Poyry Comment on Rev. B
Reflected but still not completed.

Reflected.
2 See comment on Document MD1-0-V-121-21-
00001 P&ID for BFP and Booster Pump
regarding location and type of valves and
instruments on the feed water pipe from the
Booster Pump to the BFP. Please check and
clarify accordingly.

Poyry Comment on Rev. B
Noted.

We will submit revised P&ID with correct order
of instruments, valves, and lines according to
the order on this drawing.
Poyry Comment on Rev. B
Please explain why the pipe route has changed
and a low point has been included in the design.
This has added 4 x 90 deg elbows and 1 x 45
deg elbow. This creates a disturbance in the
flow that could have an impact on the accuracy
of the flow meter.
The low point is also an obstruction to motor
access
The relief valve has been deleted.