Professional Documents
Culture Documents
مجلة ألباب
مجلة ألباب
مجلة ألباب
2014
:
:
:
All rights reserved
Mominoun Without Borders
- -
info@mominoun.com
+212537730450 :
+212537730408 :
.10569 :
www.mominoun.com
.
No Part of this magazine may be reproduced, stored in any retrieval system, or transmitted in any form or
by any means without prior permission in writting of (Mominoun Without Borders Association).
:
:
.
.
"" :
5
7
13
26
54
75
92
114
133
141
148
152
159
4
()1
"" ""
.
:
"" :
.
""
.
5
()1
.
"
"
.
"" " " .
""
. ""
""
!
6
()1
"":
""
" "
" "
"" .
"
"
- - /
" "
.
.
" " " " .
7
()1
.
.
- -
.
( )
"" "/".
.
- -
.
:
( )
.
( )
8
()1
.
""
() ()
.
.
.
.
""
""
.
9
()1
"" ""
"" .
.
.
.
.
- -
.
10
()1
11
()1
:
.
.
.
.
( )Euthyphron
.
"" - -
"" "" . :
:
:
:
:
*
12
()1
.
(Euthpron, in. uvres compltes de Platon, traduites par Emile Chambry).
( ) .
.
"" ( ) () ""
.
"" :
:
/ /
: ()
( )
.
:
:
: .
""
.
.
. .
.
13
()1
: .
"" " "
.
" "
.
" " .
.
.1
:
.
.
" "
.
.
. ( )
" " - - ...
. " "
.
"
" : .
1990 20
1 -
14
()1
.
.
.
( )
.
.
:
:
.
.
. .1
. 2
" " .
" "
1 1 2001 34
2 : 1 2000 63
15
()1
.
1
.
.
.
.
.
- " " -
"
" ""
" "
" " .2
""
. ""
"" .
"
3 : 68
1 75
16
()1
"
. -
-
.
: .
" "
. () -
-
.
" " - - .
" "
.
- " " - -
- "" -
" " .
" " .
:
17
()1
()
" "
"" . -
-
- .
""
:
.
"" - - ""
. ""
"" - "" -
.
..
""
""
.
..
""
"" " "
" "
.
.
18
()1
"" "" .
""
.
.
.
:
:
"" ""
.
.
.
""
. * .
19
()1
(
)
1
. " :
( )...
".
"
".2
" "
.
- ()-
.
-
-
"" ""
"" .
" "
" "
*
( .)
1990 40 41
1 -
2 1 2001 52
20
()1
.
" "
.
" " .
"" .
" "
. "
" " " " "
.
"" .
" "
" " ""
.
.
""
21
()1
.
.
... ..
. :
.
()
" "
( ).
- - :
.
() " "
.
.
22
()1
:
:
-
La morale du Coran (
.)1973 - - -
1 :
.2000
:
.
.1990
-
2001 1
23
)1(
"
" .
" "
.
.
.
) John Rawls (2002 -1921
. " " 1971
.
.
" " .
*
24
()1
.
.
" "
.
.
.
.
.
( )1993 :
.
.
.
.
.
25
()1
.
.
.
.
""
.
.
. :
":
" ( .)18
1996
.
. :
.
( .)39 1996
.
26
()1
.
.
" "
.
.
:
.
.
(.)30 1993
.
""
.
.
( .)44 1996
27
()1
( .)46
(
.)217
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
1
1 2001 49 52
28
()1
.
.
(.)50 1996
.
.
.
.
(.)51 1996
.
( .)52-51
.
.
.
( )
.
.
.
29
()1
.
. .
( .)51
.
. *
(
.)1986
.
(.)53 1996
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.1
.
.
.
.
.
.
1 2001 146 147
31
()1
.
.
.
(.)62-58 1996
.
( .)59
.
.
.
.
.
. ( )83
.
32
()1
( 1 )366 1995
.
.
.
( )
(1996
.)35-15
( .)54-48
( )58-54
( )86-81 (.)112-110
.
.
.
( .)54-53
.
.
.
(59-56 .)61
.
1- Lief Wenar
33
()1
( .)61
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.1
.
( .)43
1 2001 406
34
()1
:
.
.
.
( 1 1996.)147-146
( .)4
.
(.)37
.
. .
.
(.)41
.
.
1
*Modus Vivendi
35
()1
.
.
.
.
. .
.
.
( .1)171
. .
.
.
.
.
.
.
1 .
36
()1
" "
.
( .)159
.
) .(163-160
.
.
* . .
"
" ( .)226 " "
. ** .
. *** .
*Public Reason
37
()1
.
(.)52-51
. " "* (1995
.)231
.
.
" :
" ( .)19878
.
.
.
. .
.
.
( .)249 1989
.
.
*Method of Avoidance
38
()1
" " " "
.
.
.
.
" "
" " .
.
.
.
" "
" " .
.
.
.
" " " " .
39
()1
" "
. " "
.
.
" "
.
.
( .)150-145 1995
" " "
"
.
. " "
.
.
.
.
" " .
40
()1
.
.
" "
.
.
. " "
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
( .)55-54
.
41
()1
.
.
.
(.)11 1987
.
( .)13
.
. .
.
. .
.
.
. .
( .)137 1995
.
.
42
()1
.
( .)214
.
.
.
.
( ) .
( )
.
( .)769 1977
.
.
.
.
43
()1
.
(
.)797
.
.
( ) .
.
: .
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
44
()1
(
.)147-125
.
:
.1
.
.
2
.
( .)84 1996
( .)54-48
.
( )
.
( 29 .)31
1
2 Conception dependent desires
45
()1
.
1 ( 1985 .)231-230
Thomas Hobbes Jeremy Beantham
.David Gauthier
.
.
( .)53-52 1996
.
.
1- Public Conception
46
()1
(
.)112-110
( .)96-94
.
(.)62-52
.
.
.
.
.
.
(.)111 1996
*Political Constructivism
47
()1
.
.
.
(.)62-52
.
.
.
:
.
.
48
()1
.
.
.
.
.
(1996 )157
( ) .
.
.
.
.
.
.
49
()1
.
.
.
.1990
1.1
2.2 .2001
50
()1
.
.
.
( )Henry Sidgwick
" : "
.
.1
:
.
* -
51
()1
:
1
: .2
:
- : :3
" "
: :
1.1
2.2
3.3
4.4
5.5
6.6
7.7
8.8
9.9
1- John Rawls, Thorie de la justice, trad. Catherine Audard, Paris, seuil, 1997, p. 438
2- Charles Taylor, Le juste et le bien, in, Revue de mtaphysique et de morale, tome, 93, N 1, 1988
-3 ( . )universalisme /cosmopolitisme
.
.
: .:
- Jocelyne couture et Kai Nielsen, Introduction: Cosmopolitisme et particularisme, in, Philosophiques, vol.34,
N1, 2007, p. 315
52
()1
.
.
.
( )
.1
. "
".2
" :
".3
" : "
.
:
1.1
2.2
3.3
4.4
4
5.5 .
1- John Rawls, Thories de la justice, op-cit., p. 486- 490
2.-Ibid., p. 490
3-. Ibid., p. 438
4- John Rawls, Justice et dmocratie, trad. Catherine Audard, Paris, Seuil, 1993, p. 288.
53
()1
:
. .
.
.
.
( )
.
.
.
:
" .
54
()1
" .1
.
" : "
.
.2
: :
55
()1
. "
.
" .1
.2
:
.:
"
.
" .3
.
.
.
1- Michel Mtayer, La philosophie thique, enjeux et dbats actuels, Editions du renouveau pdagogique,
Canada, 1997 op-cite., p.227
-2 2012 89
3-Charles Taylor, Rapprocher les solitudes, Ecrits sur le fdralisme et le nationalisme au Canada, Saint-Foy,
PUL, 1992, p.139
56
()1
. .
( )la moralit .
.
.
.
.1
:
" ".
. "
" .2 :
.
.
.
3
." : " .
.
.
1-Charles Taylor, Multiculturalisme. Diffrence et dmocratie, Paris, Flammarion, 1994, p.46
2- Ibid., p.47
3-id
57
()1
.
.
: .1
.2
.
.
. " :
" .3
.
.
.
.
: .
"
" .4
" : ".5
-1 " :
" .
1997 3 309
2-. Ibid., p.49
3- Ibid., p.125
4- Ibid., p.44
5- Id
58
()1
.
.:
"
" .1
. .
.
.2
.
.
:
.3
. .
. " :
1-Charles Taylor, Le juste et le bien, op-cit., p.48
2- Justine Lacroix, Communautarisme versus libralisme, Quel modle dintgration politique? Editions de
luniversit de Bruxelles, Bruxelles, 2003, p.80- 81
3 1957 355
59
()1
.
" .1
:
.2
.
.
.3
. :
.
1-Charles Taylor, Rapprocher les solitudes: Ecrits sur le fdralisme et le nationalisme au Canada, Sainte-Foy,
PUL,1992, p. 139
2 84
3-Charles Taylor, Le juste et le bien, in, Revue de mtaphysique et de morale, tome, 93, N 1, 1988, p. 50
60
()1
( )bien commun
.
( )holiste ( )atomiste
.
.
.
:
)(tyrannie douce
.
.
.
. " "
.
. :
.1 .
.2
.
: .
61
()1
.3
.
.
.
.4
. :
.
.5
.
" " .1
.
.
.2
.6
.
.
.
1 1981 116
2-Charles Taylor, Les sources du moi, la formation de lidentit moderne, Qubec, Sainte-Foy, PUL, 1996, p.292
62
()1
" :
" .1
. "
".2
.
.
.3
.4
.
: :
." :
1 2005 13
2 15
3-Will Kymlicka, Les thories de la justice, une introduction, Edition la Dcouverte, Paris, 2003, p. 252
4-.Emmanuel Renault, Lexprience de linjustice, Reconnaissance et Clinique de linjustice, Edition la
Dcouvert, Paris, 2004, p. 163
63
()1
" .1 " :
.
.
)...(.
".2
.
.
.
" "
" :
" .3
. :
.
1-Axel Honneth, La lutte pour la reconnaissance, , traduit de lAllemand par Pierre Rusch, Paris, Les ditions
du CERF, 2002,p .207
2- Axel Honneth, Le conflit des traditions, in, Magazine littraire, N361, janvier 1998, p.47
3-Axel Honneth, Les pathologies de la libert, Une ractualisation de la philosophie du droit de Hegel, tra.
Franch Fischbach, Paris, Editions La Dcouverte, 2008, p.15
64
()1
.1
.
.
.
.
. .
.
.
2
.
:
.1 :
.
1- Axel Honneth, La lutte pour la reconnaissance, op-cite., p.162
2- Axel Honneth, La socit du mpris, , vers une nouvelle thorie critique, trad. Olivier Voirol, Pierre Rusch
/ 1et Alexandras Depeyrix, Paris, La Dcouvert, 2006, p. 21. 57
65
()1
.1
.
.
. :
.
.
. "
" .2
.
) (intrt transcendantal
) (intrt dmancipation
.
:
.3
1-Nancy Fraser, Quest-ce que la justice sociale? Reconnaissance et redistribution, tra. Estelle Ferrarese, Paris,
Editions la dcouverte, 2005
2- Axel Honneth, Justice et reconnaissance, in, Le Passant, N 38, 2002
3 189
66
()1
.2 :
:
.
.
.
:
.
""la vie bonne
.3 :
:
.
.
.1
( )
:
1 191
67
()1
.
:
.
1
.
.
.
.
.
.
1 1978
68
()1
.
.
" :
() ()
( )
( ) :
( )
()
".1
( )
.
" " 1
1
2013 50
69
()1
.) - ( 1.1
2.2
.2012
3.3
.1957
.1981 4.4
5.5
.2005
.1978 6.6
7.7
.2013 1
71
)1(
" "
" ".
.
:
" "( )August comte "
1".
* -
-1 1 1994 25
72
()1
. " "
.
.
" "
( )Emile Durkheim " "
.
""
"
... " 1
".
2".
"
-1 : 119/118/ 2001 59
2- EmileDurkheim,Les formes lmentaires de la vie religieuse. Le systme totmique en Australie, PUF, coll, 2008
73
()1
".
" "
( )Rodolf otto ""
. .2
"" ""
""
.""
" "
" " "" ) (Sigmund Freud
"
.
.
.
3
".
4
74
()1
1". "" ""
. ""
" "."
"."
2
.
3.
" " ( )Roger Caillois
( )sensibilit .
4. ""
.5
.
1 123
2 1 2011 .43-42
3 : 41
4. Roger Caillois, l'homme et le sacr, 3eme dition, France, Gallimard, 1991, pp 23 -30
5. Ibid, p48
75
()1
.1
"
.2
""
4
" .
" 5
.
" "
1 : 38
2 38
3 1 1996 23
4 27
5. Roger caillois, L'homme et le sacr, 3eme dition, France, Gallimard 1965 .P24
76
()1
1
"
" 2 ( 728 )
"
.
...
" 3
.
( 751)
"
1 : "
: " . :
http://www.altasamoh.net/Article.asp?Id=332 .
2 1 ( -) 37
3 1 .2004 308
77
()1
" .1
"
" " ".2
" ":
" "
"
. .
".3
" :
.
.
.
" .4
1 1 1428 32-31
2 31-30
3 1 1983 10-9
4 22
78
()1
" "
" "
" " 1
"
"
:
""
2
.
.
" "
" " "
1. Ren Girard, la violence et le sacr, 1er dition, Paris, ditions Bernard Grasset, 1972.pp 13 -14
2 ": ""
"" ".
1 2004 29
79
()1
" .1
" " " " " : :
" .2
.
" : " .
. " ""
" .4
"
"
.
.5
"
" ":
" .6
1 ... ... 10 1997 67
2 68
3 71
-4 75
-5 127-121
-6 1 1999 27
80
()1
.
"
"" .
".1
.
"
" "
" .2
"" ""
3
.
.
:
:
-1 6 1979 99
2 108-107
3 : 2 1994 104
81
()1
.
.
:
.
:
.
:
""
.
:
.
".
".1
82
()1
:
"
" 1 .
- :
" :
.
. .
" .2
.
" " "
. .
" .3 "
""
""
" .4
1 1 2009 66
2 3 1935 35
3 .www. Shahabd.com4 3-
4 4
83
()1
" " "
.
"
.
: .
".1
" "
1 1 .2005
232-231
84
()1
1
2
""
" " .
" "
1 : " " "" ""
. 2
1998 67
2
.
85
()1
""
" "
-
-
" "
1 .2
1 99
2 111
86
()1
:
1.1 1
( ).
2.2 1
.2004
3.3 2 .1994
4.4 1
1999
5.5 1
.1988
6.6 1
.2009
7.7 1
1428 .
8.8 1 .2011
9.9 ... ... 10
.1997
1010 1
.1996
1111 3 .1935
1212 1 .2004
1313 2 .1998
1414 4
.1998
1515 6 .1979
1616 1
.1994
1717 1
.1983
87
()1
1818 1
.2012
1919
1 .2005
:
Caillois (Roger), L'homme et le sacr 3eme dition, France, Gallimard
1965.
Durkheim (Emile),Les formes lmentaires de la vie religieuse. Le
systme totmique en Australie, PUF, coll. 2008.
Girard(Ren), la violence et le sacr, 1er dition, Paris, ditions Bernard
Grasset, 1972.
Otto(Rodolf), le sacr, Paris, Petite bibliothque, 1968.
1.
2.
3.
4.
:
: 119/118
/.2001
:
www. Shahabd.com
:
http://www.altasamoh.net/Article.asp?Id=332
88
()1
:
*
" "
( )1804-1724 " "
" "
,
.
.
:
( )...
.
... .
* -
89
()1
"
" 1 .
.
" " 2
.
.
:
: .
: .
: :
.
...
- 1 2000 69
" : "
-2 " " : . 2012 1
90
()1
.
.1
.
1 .
.
:
- :
.
.
.
.2
- 1 " " 2011 124
-2 " " :.
1 200227
91
()1
1 "
"2
:
.
.
.
3
...
.
.
.
. :
- 1 31
- 2 " " 1 200870
- 3 : . 2004 216 - 215
92
()1
.
.
.
- 2
" :
1
: "
2 ...
...
" "
3
4
5
.
- 1 " " 37
- 2 37
- 3 37
- 4 " " 39
- 5 " " 1993 119
93
()1
... .
1 " :
... ...
.
.
".2
. .
3 .
:
. .
- 3
.
- 1 " " 40
- 2 40
- 3 38
94
()1
.
. "
1
" . "
...
" .2
.3
4
- -
.5
.
" : " "
" .
" : ".6
- 1 " " 70
- 2 .71
- 3 " " : 13
- 4 " " 1
200975
- 5 76
- 6 76
95
()1
.
:
.1
.
.
.
.
.
:
.
.
.
.
.
- 1 " " 46-45
96
()1
- 4 :
.
.1 .
: .
.
- :
" :
" 2
. :
.
. " : ( )
. . :
:
".3
-1 56
-2 " " 83
-3 78-77
97
()1
"
" 1 .
.
.
" " "
"
.
.
.
- 1 " " 78
98
()1
- :
" :
" .1
.
.
. " :
" 2 " :
" 3 " :
4
"
- 1 " " 109-108
- 2 109
- 3 110
- 4 110
99
()1
.
" " 1
.
- :
" : " .
. .
.2
.
3
"
( : )".4
-1 " " 117-116
-2 " : " .
.13
. .
-3 " " 14
- 4 15
100
()1
.
.
" .
".1
" : " .
.
:
-1 " " " 1 2008 .81
" "2005 156
101
()1
.
1543 ( )
( )1543-1473
.
.
.
.
. (.)1650-1596
102
()1
" : "
.
" " )(1626-1561
" "
) (1677-1632 "
" ) (1704-1632
" "
)(1776- 1711
" "
1
.2
.3
": " "
" " " .
:
- 1 " " . 2008 1 .34
- 2 .39
- 3 .33
103
()1
1
.
": " 2
.
( )
,
" :
: .
.
". 3
.
DAlembert 1717- 1783
" "" " 4 voltaire
1694-1778 " :
- 1 " " 51
- 2 52
- 3 .208 :
(Enqute sur l entendement humain / traduction par Didier deleule. Livre de poche/Librairie gnrale
) franaise. 1999p289- 290.
- 4 . " " 2005 1 20
104
()1
" 1
.
( )
.2
:
3.
)" : M. Mendelssohn (1786 -1729
" 4 " " " "
5
.
.
6
() ()
- 1 . " " 20
-2 " " 34-33
-3 " " 2007 137
-4 . 21-20
-5 21
-6 " : " - 2001113
105
()1
.
.1
. :
" "
.
.
:
.
.
...
.
.
.
" : "
-1 " "( ) .2002 1
73
106
()1
.1
:
2
.
.
3
.
" ".
" " 4
.5
-1. " : " 113
- 2 117
- 3. " : " 170
-4 " "
" " .
" "Bloss ...
.
40-39 :
- 5 . " " 2006 154
107
()1
1
" "
2
3
.4
.5
6
.
.
7
.
.8
- 1 " " 15
- 2 18
- 3 19
- 4 25
- 5 . 125
- 6 " " 21
- 7 . 133
-8 129-128
108
()1
.
.
:
1.
: 2
3. .
.
" " " " .4
109
()1
1.1
.1988
2.2 " " : 1
.2012
3.3 " " 1
.2008
4.4 " " : .
1 .2002
5.5" " "
1 .2008
6.6 " " . 2011 1
7.7 . " "
.2006 1
8.8 . " : "
.1994
9.9 " " (
) 1 .2002
1010 " " .
2008 1.2008
1111 " " 1993
1212 " "
1.2009
1313 " "
.2005
1414 :
.2000
1515 .
.2004
110
()1
.
.
.
.
.
* -
111
()1
... .
.1
" "
:
1.1
2.2
3.3
....
"
" "......
: ""
"" " 2
"" ""
.
3
" "
(
)
/ : .
-1 199633
2 19828
- 3 33
112
()1
113
()1
"
" .1
" "
" " .
" :
19 20 ".2
3
" "
" "
. ""
"" .
- 1 68
- 2 68
- 3 70
114
()1
" " :
.
" "
-1 : ... : 1992 20-19
- 2 26
- 3 26
- 4 31
115
()1
" :
.
" "
"
" 1 " "
.
" "
19
.2
" "
( ) "
3
"
"
" : .
-1.2
.19
( /)
""
"" .
- 1 ... ,83
- 2 84-83
- 3 84
116
()1
-2.2
:
. . . "
.
3
"
""
:
.
.
"
- 1 ... 85
- 2 86
- 3 103
117
()1
".1
"
... .
" .2
.
":
".3
" : [ ]...
.
- 1 ... 108
- 2 104
- 3 104
118
()1
" .1
. :
2
.
".3
/ :
19
.
" " " "
: . "
" .4
" ""
.
""
5
"
"
- 1 ... 105
- 2 106
-3 107
- 4 110
- 5 111
119
()1
""".1
"
" . " :
:
2
"
"" " "
" " " "
" :
:
.
" .3
.
.
- 1 ... 111
- 2 113
- 3 114
120
()1
" . "".1
- -
2
""
.
" "" ..
3
"" "
" "
" " ""
....
"
:
4
. "
: " :
".5
1 : 77
2 78
-3 105
-4 107
-5 .124
121
()1
-1.3
.19
"" .
""
.. .1
.
" :
.
" " .
2
: "
" " " " .
" :
. .3
" "
.
-1 .78
- 2 .125
- 3 .127
122
()1
"
.
1
.
""
.
-2.3
.
. :
"
2
"
"
.
3
".
"
".4
" :
1 .123
-2 .80
-3 80
-4 .128
123
()1
1
"
" "
" " .
""
2
"
" " " ".
- -
" () " ()
3
.
.
.4
-1 .128
-2 .82
- 3 .93
- 4 .94-93
124
()1
".1
"
".2
.3
"
".4
"
".5
-
-
.6
.
" ""
- 1 .129
- 2 : 1 .44-43
- 3 .129
- 4 .131
- 5 .133
- 6 .134
125
()1
" .1 - -
.
"
" .2 ""
.
.3
" :
... *
".4
.
- 1 .134
- 2 .135
- 3 .136-135
* "... "
" . " " 30
( ) .1989
- 4 441
126
()1
-5
.
.
( ) ( ) .
/ /.
.
.
" /"
:
. .19
.
.
:
127
()1
.
.
. .
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
. .
.1
-1 1987 1
128
()1
:
:
.
.
.
.
.2
129
()1
.1996
.1982
...
.1992
.1989
" "" "
.
.1987
/
.1990
130
()1
131
()1
:
:
: .
: 2009
: .
" "
" :
"( .)16 " :
" ( )16
.
" "
.
" :
* - -
132
()1
" ( .)11
" " " " " "
( )
"" "" "" "
-.
( ) "
( ) .
( )...
"( .)26
" " ""
:
"
" ( )33 "( .)28
()
"
- " ( .)28
133
()1
" "
.
"
" ( .)45 " " " :
( )
"( )41 .
()1896 "
( .)1884
" () () :
() () " ( .)30
" ()
(
) " (.)70
" "
- "" :
" " ( .)53
"
.
( .)53
134
()1
":
" ( .)58
( )
" :
"( .)95
"
" ( .)95
"
.
)...(.
" ( .)105
( ) "
-
"( .)112 "
.
" ( .)120
135
()1
" "
-
" ( .)136
"
( ) () " ( .)114
( )
"
"( .)150 ( :
) ":
"( .)164
" : "
:
" ( .)167
.
"
" ( .)68
":
136
()1
" ".
"( .)188
: .
"
-
- .
"( .)194
"
( )...
" ( .)200
"
(
..)
" ( .)211
.
" .
" ( .)194
"
137
()1
"
" :
" ( .)242
"
" .
( )
" ( .)248
"
" ( .)233
"
" "
" ( .)279
311
( )
" "
.
138
()1
: :
:
:
:
: - 2013
: . *
* -
1 1994
139
()1
.
.
.
.
. 1979
.
.
.
.
.
.
"
140
()1
".
1998
"The roots of Muslim Rage
" :
.
"
".
. " :
".
"
.
"
.
.
.
.
141
()1
" "
" " .
.
.
. " .
".
"
".
. "
" .
. "
.
".
.
:
.
142
()1
.
.
( ) :
.
.
.
.
.
: "
".
.
.
143
()1
( "
")
"
. "
"
".
.
" " " "
""
"
"
.
.
.
:
(
)
144
()1
. "
".
(
) .
.
.
.
( / :
)
.
( :
)
" "
.
.
( ! :
)
.
)
.
145
()1
:
:
:
: -2009
: *
146
()1
" ".
"
:
".
" "
"
".
""
" "
. "
" .
. " ( )
".
147
()1
.
" .
.
"
".
149
()1
: La Voie
:
: 2011
: *
.
"" Edgar Morin
() " ."
" "
.
:
:
.
.
.
.
.
" "
150
()1
. :
. .
"" "" .
.
""
""
( 89 )
.
" "
( )2011 ""
.
.
"
""
" Cioran
300
!" "" "" . ""
.
151
()1
.
:
.
".
" :
" " " " "
" .
".
: "" .
!
: () 1941
.
".
() ()
. 5 ()
200 .
. " " "".
: ""
" " " ". .
.
" .
".
152
()1
"
" "" ""
.
" :
[ ] ".
"
.
.
"" .
.
.
" :
" Hlderlin "
.
".
"
. .
. .
153
()1
. .
.
. "" .
( ) .
""
".
. "" .
"
".
"
.
.
.
".
" " . .
" .
".
( .)...
.
"
154
()1
. .
. . .
. "
.
Joseph de Maistr Maurra
Tocqueville
Proudhon .Bakounine
"" .
.
.
-
" . .
".
" : :
.
. ( )
!
.
.
.
://".
"
155
()1
. ( )
.
.
".
(
..) "" .
.
156
()1
"":
" ".
.
.
""
.
157
()1
.
( : )
.
""
.
.
.
158
()1
.
:
.
""
:
1.1 .
2.2 .
3.3 .
4.4 : .
5.5 : .
6.6 .
7.7 .
8.8 .
9.9.
1010
159
()1
""
""
:
1.1 5000
( )Word
.
.
2.2
:
.
3.3
. .
4.4
albab@mominoun.com
5.5 ( )100 .
6.6 .
7.7
.
8.8
( )Scanner .
:
.
.
.
.
1500.
160
()1