Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Baked Bricks in Egypt of Exodus and Al Qur'an
Baked Bricks in Egypt of Exodus and Al Qur'an
A formula type contradiction of any staement '' C'' is:It is false that C
WHAT AL QUR'AN HATH SAID IS NOT CONTRADICTED BY ANY
ARCHEOLOGICAL EVIDENCE.
If it is accepted that archeological evidences contradict AL
QUR'AN , THEN THE WORD
CONTRADICTION must be in its proper sense.
If Qur'an reporteth:
<Pharoah said "A" > OR <Pharoah did say ''A''>, A PROPER
CONTRADICTION /NEGATION IS
<< PHAROAH DID NOT SAY ''A''>>.
In more strict form statements like
<Pharoah is one that/who said ''A''> or <Pharoah is one that/ who
did say ''A''> IS CONTRADICTED BY
<<Pharoah is one that/who did not say ''A''>> .This is the negation
in the second part. How ever a negation
in the first part is:- PHAROAH IS NOT THE ONE THAT/WHO
SAID/<DID SAY > ''A''.
A formula type negation / contradiction is:It is false that Pharoah is the one that/who said/<did say> A.
Such a negation may be considered as a compound statement:<<<< Pharoah is NOT the one that/who said/ <did say> '' A"
OR
there is no Heiroglyphic
or non hieroglyphic writing which contradictas Al Qur'an in any
proper sense.
Only it can be said that Egyptological research shews that
Egyptian did not use BAKED BRICKS
, and did use mud bricks inthe time of Exodus.
All the research stops at this point. AL QURAN CONTRADICTETH
NOT this research.
Qur'an only saith that Pharoah of Exodus ordered HA:MA:N to
make a Pillar or A Tower
Baked Bricks.
Qur,an never saith that pharoah's order were carried out. So their
is no contradiction at all
since building, no structure,no tower, no pillar etc was ever made
in the history of Egypt
at the time of Exodus or prior to it.
An interpellation does arrise that if Egyptians did not know how to
build a structure by baking
bricks , then how did Pharoah said so.
The answer may be given as follow:The Pregnant Mind of the imprecated Pharoah concieved the idea
to build a tower or a
pillar by baked bricks.
This can be responded as follow:
It is impossible of the mind of Pharoah to concieve the idea to
make a Tower or a Pillar
by baked Bricks.
To claim that It is Impossible and Incontingint that the mind of
Pharoah could concieve
a very NEW idea, unknown to other Egyptians is a claim which
cannot be proved.
It is impossible to prove the impossibility of conception of a New
Idea in general and
this idea mentioned above in particular by secular Egyptology.
Atmost Egyptology can say that Backed Bricks were never used in
ancient Egypt.
Quran saith not that baked brick were used so that a proper
contradiction occureth.
Qur'an only saith that it was a sugggestion, and if a very new or
strange idea was
concieved in the
Pharoah's mind , it has nothing to do with excavations and
Egyptology.
Even if it is assumed that Pharoah's mind was so barren that it
was impossible to concieve
a very new idea, and so Qur'an is incorrect, even then this alleged
impossibility in the mind of
Pharoah is not a problem of Egyptology, but of SUBJECTS LIKE
Deductive Logic
or Mathematical Logic or Psychology or Philosophy or Theology.
Such a contradiction cannot be found in any possible text found in
excavations.
This extenuates the alleged power of the objection ti its minimun.