Journal of Surgery Pakistan (JSP)

www.jsp.org.pk
PART A: Editorial Office Only
SECTION I
Reviewers Name:
E-Mail:
Manuscript Number:
Title:
Date Sent To Reviewer:
Date Expected From Reviewer:
PART B: Reviewer Only
SECTION II: Comments er Se!tion of "anus!rit
#eneral !omments on:
Importance of the subject, write up
style, spelling and grammar etc
A$stra!t % &ey 'or(s:
Structured as per guidelines, up to
250 words with 3-5 key words etc
Intro(u!tion:
ell introduced, importance of topic
highlighted, brief reference to
literature made, rationale pro!ided
etc
"et)o(ology:
Study desin and met!odoloy
described" statistical tests
incorporated etc
Results:
Data presented in clear
sentences supported by tables
and rap!s wit! statistical
analysis etc
*is!ussion:
#ey $indins discussed and
comparison made wit! already
reported literature etc%
"e!iewer#s $uide
SECTION II (Cont+)
Referen!es:
&ancouver style" between
'( -)( and latest etc
Ta$les an( ,igures:
Confli!t of interest
an( Et)i!al issues:
SECTION III - Please rate t)e follo'ing: (1 = Excellent) (2 = Good) (3 = Fair) (4 = poor)
SECTION IV - Recommandation: (Kindly Mar !it" #n $)
*ccept *s +s:
Re,uires Minor -orrections:
Re,uires Moderate Revision:
Re,uires Ma.or Revision:
Re.ect /n 0rounds /$ 12lease 3e Speci$ic%:
SECTION .: A((itional Comments
Please add any additional comments (Including comments/suggestions, if any):
/riinality:
-ontribution To T!e Field:
Tec!nical 4uality:
-larity /$ 2resentation :
Dept! /$ Researc!: