Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Sample Annotated Bib by James Andersen Revised
Sample Annotated Bib by James Andersen Revised
James Andersen
Professor Allison Fernley
English 1010
November 18, 2014
Head in Sy, Fee! on "ro#nd
$ al%ays %an!ed !o be an as!rona#!& 'ell a figh!er (ilo!, and !hen an as!rona#!& 'ha! id doesn)!*
+igh!* ,hen, in fo#r!h grade, $ go! !he -oe bo!!le glasses& $n re!ros(e-!, !he glasses %eren)! !he ma.or
(roblem& ,ha!)s really no! %hy $ bro#gh! !ha! #(& ,he (oin! is $ s!#dy s(a-e and as!ronomy as of!en as $
-an& $!s immensi!y and mys!ery s!ill leave me feeling !ha! same sense of a%e !ha! $ fel! as !ha! id in
fo#r!h grade, %ho dream! of flying !he S(a-e Sh#!!le& For many of !hose in my genera!ion %ho love
s(a-e, !he end of !he sh#!!le (rogram is bi!!ers%ee!& $! (la-ed Sylab in orbi! and %as -ri!i-al !o !he
-ons!r#-!ion of !he $n!erna!ional S(a-e S!a!ion /$SS0& ,he H#bble res-#e res#s-i!a!ed a (rogram %hi-h is,
!o !his day, rendering as!ronomi-al da!a %hi-h is as irre(la-eable as i! is bea#!if#l& 1e! i! %as !ime for !he
(rogram, %hi-h %as no longer -os! effe-!ive or safe, !o finally re!ire& A re(la-emen! %as in !he %ors b#!
i! demanded more in man (o%er and f#nding !han b#dge!ary -on-erns %o#ld allo%& 2#! %e need !o be
able !o ge! !o s(a-e& ,his need %as (#n-!#a!ed by !he re-en! air b#rs! e3(losion of an as!eroid over
Siberia& $f %e %ere l#-y eno#gh !o -a!-h an inbo#nd as!eroid early eno#gh, !he 4S doesn)! -#rren!ly
have a (la!form %e -o#ld #se !o res(ond !o !he !hrea!& Af!er lis!ening !o many vie%(oin!s and (o!en!ial
sol#!ions, Presiden! 5bama de-ided !o (riva!i6e !he (ro-ess of sending as!rona#!s and goods !o ear!h
orbi!& 4l!ima!ely, !he ho(e is !ha! (riva!e firms -om(e!ing for NASA -on!ra-!s %ill (rod#-e a s(a-e !a3i
and (a-age delivery sys!em, allo%ing NASA !o fo-#s on s-ien!ifi- advan-emen!&
'hile $ feel !ha! !he (riva!i6a!ion of !he s(a-e (rogram is inevi!able and ne-essary, $ have
reserva!ions abo#! !he (riva!e se-!or being !he only sol#!ion& ,here is no %ay !o 7#an!ify !he -on!rib#!ion
%hi-h o#r s(e-ies) s(a-e (rogram has made !o o#r general 7#ali!y of life& Among !heir -o#n!less
Andersen 2
-on!rib#!ions are !he ligh!%eigh! ma!erials in o#r -ars, !he minia!#ri6a!ion of ele-!ri-al -ir-#i!s %hi-h
res#l!ed in mi-ro-om(#!ers, and !he basis for !he da!a -om(ression !e-hnology %hi-h maes !he in!erne!
(ossible& $f yo# remove !hese !hings o#r lives %o#ld be im(ossibly differen!& For ins!an-e, imagine a
medi-al -omm#ni!y %i!ho#! 8+$)s and E9")s& ,his e3(losion of !e-hnology and no%ledge is !ied !o a
governmen! r#n and s(onsored s(a-e (rogram& 9o#ld (riva!ely f#nded en!i!ies g#ard -er!ain !e-hnologi-al
advan-emen!s -loser, res#l!ing in res!ri-!ions on (o!en!ially gro#nd breaing s-ien!ifi- and !e-hnologi-al
brea!hro#ghs* Ano!her %orry is !ha!, %i!h b#dge!ary (ress#res !he %ay !hey are, s#--essf#l (riva!i6a!ion
may leave NASA and i!s (rograms #nderf#nded& $! %o#ld be easy for #s !o forge! or ignore !he
-on!rib#!ions %hi-h NASA has made and dismiss !heir b#dge! as an #n%arran!ed e3(ense& ,his begs !he
7#es!ion, is (riva!i6a!ion a good idea* Here are some vie%(oin!s:
A#!ry, "reg& ;Ho#s!on, 'e Have a 8are!: Priva!i6ing S(a-e <a#n-hes Pays 5ff 2ig&; Forbes& 2 5-!&
201=& 'eb& 2 Nov& 201=&
$n >Ho#s!on 'e Have a 8are!: Priva!i6ing S(a-e <a#n-hes (ays off 2ig,? "reg A#!ry arg#es
!ha! !he (riva!i6a!ion of s(a-e !ravel is a reso#nding s#--ess& He -on!ras!s !he re-en! governmen!
sh#!do%n %i!h !%o se(ara!e miles!ones %hi-h %ere a--om(lished by (riva!e -om(anies d#ring !he same
!imeframe& S(a-e @ s#--essf#lly la#n-hed an #nmanned !es! of i!s in!ended manned Fal-on A sys!em
%hile 5rbi!al S-ien-es s#--essf#lly do-ed !he 9ygn#s 9a(s#le %i!h !he $SS& A#!ry e3(lains !ha! bo!h of
!hese !es!s %ere made (ossible by !he 9ommer-ial 5rbi!al ,rans(or! Servi-e or 95,S, %hi-h is !he
offi-ial (rogram %hi-h has e3!ended !he no%ledge and s#((or! of NASA !o !he (riva!e se-!or %i!h !he
in!en! !o hel( !hem (rod#-e viable -ommer-ial s(a-e (rograms& He also no!es !ha! !o da!e !he en!ire -os!
of !he 95,S (rogram !o !a3(ayers has -ome !o less !han half !he -os! of a single sh#!!le fligh!, and !ha!
!he res#l!s are e3-e(!ional& ,he !%o remaining -om(anies have o(era!ional (la!forms #nder a federal
(rogram for -on!ra-!ing s#((ly missions !o !he $SS& ,hese (riva!e en!i!ies, %hi-h are -om(e!ing %i!h
governmen! (rograms from o!her na!ions s#-h as Ja(an and +#ssia, have (rod#-ed a signifi-an! n#mber
Andersen 3
of high silled highB(aying .obs& A#!ry -on-l#des !ha! 9ongress sho#ld (la-e a (riori!y on addi!ional
f#nding for !his (ro.e-!&
A#!ry demons!ra!es !he effe-!iveness of !he (lan !o (riva!i6e s(a-e !ravel #sing logos& His a((eal
is a bi! -heey as i! -on!ras!s ma.or miles!ones in !he (riva!i6a!ion ra-e agains! !he (e!!y infigh!ing %hi-h
-a#sed !he governmen! sh#!do%n& NASA %as li!erally #nable !o re(or! !hese s#--esses be-a#se !heir
%ebsi!e %as sh#! do%n& He sho%s !ha! for a fra-!ion of !he -os! of one sh#!!le mission 95,S has hel(ed
!o (rod#-e !%o viable -ommer-ial al!erna!ives !o governmen!al s(a-e delivery sys!ems& 2e-a#se of !his
logi-al a((eal, A#!ry earns his -on-l#sion !ha! -ongress sho#ld (la-e a (riori!y on reinfor-ing !his
(rogram !ha! has been so reso#ndingly s#--essf#l&
,his ar!i-le %ill assis! me in ill#s!ra!ing no! only !he -a(a-i!y !he (riva!e se-!or has !o advan-e
s(a-e fligh!, b#! also ho% effe-!ive a !ool 95,S is in advan-ing !he !e-hnology and red#-ing !he -os!&
,he im(a-! of !hese !%o !es!s is !remendo#s in advan-ing h#mani!y and in valida!ing 5bama)s de-ision !o
(riva!i6e& ,he ar!i-le is one of many %hi-h have s%ayed my o(inion !o%ards a more favorable vie%(oin!
on !he -a(a-i!y for (riva!e and governmen! in!eres!s !o -oo(era!e&
2arber, Eli6abe!h& ;'ill !he 4ni!ed Na!ions (ro!e-! #s from an as!eroid*; Christian Science Monitor& 2A
5-!& 201=& 'eb& 4 Nov& 201=&
$n >'ill !he 4ni!ed Na!ions Pro!e-! 4s from an As!eroid*? Eli6abe!h 2arber arg#es !ha! !he ne%
4N -ommi!!ee is o#r bes! be! for de!e-!ing and -oordina!ing a global res(onse !o (o!en!ially damaging
NearBEar!h 5b.e-!s /NE50& 2arber begins %i!h some of !he fa-!s& ,his fall an as!eroid labeled 201=
,C1=D (assed !he ear!h ro#ghly 4&2 million miles a%ay, and %ill be ba- in 20=2, %here i! may have a
one in E=,000 -han-e of s!riing !he ear!h& $f i! does hi!, i! %ill im(a-! %i!h !he for-e of a 2,D00 mega!on
bomb& 2arber (oin!s o#! !ha! %e have no -#rren! (lans in (la-e !o res(ond !o !hrea!ening NE5)s& ,he
s-ary !hing, she -on!in#es, is !ha! !here are so many of !hem& As!ronomers are -er!ain !ha! !he 10,=22
de!e-!ed NE5)s are a mere fra-!ion of !hose no! ye! seen& She #ses !he re-en! in.#ries -a#sed by air
Andersen 4
de!ona!ion of an #nde!e-!ed as!eroid in Siberia !o ill#s!ra!e ho% li!!le %e no% abo#! (o!en!ially damaging
or le!hal NE5)s& ,he sobering fa-! is !ha! !here is very li!!le %e -an do !o defle-! !hese ob.e-!s if %e do no!
de!e-! !hem early eno#gh&
2arber)s ar!i-le is (rimarily logos, an a((eal !o !he fa-!s regarding NE5)s and !he reali!y of !heir
(o!en!ial !o im(a-! !he Ear!h& She #ses fa-!s s#-h as NE5)s in e3is!en-e and re-en! even!s lie !he Siberia
im(a-! !o ill#s!ra!e !he !imeliness of !he iss#e& She effe-!ively ill#s!ra!es !he ne-essi!y of !he 4S
-ommi!!ee !o address NE5)s&
$ %ill #se !his ar!i-le !o assis! in -rea!ing airos and (a!hos for my (osi!ion syn!hesis& No!hing is
more !imely and emo!ional !han o#r s#rvival& ,he s(a-e (rogram of o#r s(e-ies is in!egral !o res(onding
!o s#-h !hrea!s as !hese& $ am s!ill no! -er!ain $ %an! !o in-l#de !he As!eroid airosF(a!hos -onne-!ionG
ho%ever, i! -o#ld (rovide s!rong versions of bo!h !hese rhe!ori-al a((eals, %i!h referen-es !o H#i3o!e
almos! %ri!ing !hemselves& As!eroids may no! be !he bogeyman, b#! !hey -o#ld irrevo-ably redefine o#r
life !omorro%& ,he 4N feels i! is salien! eno#gh !o addressG !herefore, i! is (robably !imely for me !o
address&
2enson, 8i-hael& ;E3(loring !he Plane!s Enri-hes 4s a! Home&; New York Times& 10 A#g& 2012& 'eb&
28 5-!& 201=&
8i-hael 2enson)s o(Bed >E3(loring !he Plane!s Enri-hes 4s a! Home? s#gges!s !ha! b#dge! -#!s
%ill have a nega!ive im(a-! on NASA)s (lane!ary e3(lora!ion (ro.e-!s %hi-h may #l!ima!ely r#in a gro#(
of irre(la-eable s-ien!ifi- innova!ors& He e3(lains !ha! !he !%en!y (er-en! b#dge! -#! !ha! NASA has no%
e3(erien-ed %ill (#! an end !o many of !he (ro.e-!s a! NASA %hi-h have develo(ed irre(la-eable
!e-hnology s#-h as mi-ro-om(#!ers and da!a -om(ression& 2enson goes on !o no!e !ha!, in many -ases,
!hese are divisions %i!h #ni7#e (ersonnel %hi-h !oo de-ades !o assemble& As a res#l!, !heir
re-ons!r#-!ion a! a f#!#re da!e may (rove nearly im(ossible& He -on!ras!s !his !e-hnologi-al innova!ion
%i!h !he NASA)s a-!#al e3(endi!#re, %hi-h amo#n!s !o >less !han one half of one (er-en! of !he federal
Andersen 5
b#dge!&? He -on-l#des !ha!, given !he life -hanging innova!ions !ha! NASA has (rod#-ed for !he %orld,
%e sho#ld no! i- !hose !ha! (rod#-ed !hese as!o#nding a--om(lishmen!s !o !he -#rb&
,he (rimary !one of !his (ie-e follo%s a logi-ally based em(a!he!i- (lea !o ee( NASA in (lay&
,he ar!i-le -overs .#s! a fe% of !he signifi-an! and irre(la-eable !e-hnologi-al advan-emen!s %hi-h
NASA has (rod#-ed& ,his is an effe-!ive arg#men! for governmen! -onsidera!ion !o%ards !heir -on!in#ed
e3is!en-e&
2enson)s vie%(oin! e-hoes my o%n -on-erns abo#! %ha! b#dge! (ress#res migh! do !o NASA&
,he s-ien!ifi- -on!rib#!ions of a (#bli-ly f#nded NASA have made irre(la-eable -on!rib#!ions !o o#r
so-ie!y and -o#ld -on!in#e !o do so& Iee(ing a signifi-an! (or!ion of resear-h and develo(men! in
NASA)s (#rvie% may (rove -ri!i-al !o !he (#bli- dissemina!ion of s-ien!ifi- dis-overies&
Fros!, +ober!& ;'hy is Priva!i6ed S(a-e ,ravel a 9hallenge*? Forbes& 10 5-!& 2012& 'eb& 28 5-!& 201=&
+ober! Fros!, an Engineer and $ns!r#-!or a! NASA, ans%ered !he 7#es!ion >'hy is Priva!i6ed
S(a-e ,ravel a 9hallenge*? in a Forbes ,e-h -ol#mn by -hroni-ling !he !e-hnologi-al and logis!i-al
iss#es %hi-h a s(a-e (rogram en-o#n!ers& He begins by ill#s!ra!ing !he -om(le3i!y of s(a-e vehi-les,
%hi-h -on!ain millions of (ar!s %hi-h si! on !ons of e3(losives, moving a! in-on-eivable s(eeds, !hro#gh
ra(idly -hanging (hysi-al si!#a!ions& Fros! sho%s !ha! m#-h of !he -hallenges addressed in one s(a-e
going (la!form %ill need !o be readdressed in ne% (la!forms& He f#r!her arg#es !ha! !his -om(le3i!y ge!s
even more in!ense %i!h !he addi!ion of manned s(a-e -raf!& Every!hing added redefines !he f#ndamen!al
needs of !he -raf!, affe-!ing every sys!em dee(ly& E3a-erba!ing !his, he -laims, is !he reali!y !ha! a
signifi-an! (or!ion of !he (revio#s genera!ion)s no%ledge is no! a((li-able !o !he -#rren! design
res!ri-!ions& ,he (riva!e se-!or is s!ar!ing from s-ra!-h in a n#mber of %ays& 5n !o( of all !his !he
f#ndamen!al (rin-i(le of s(a-e fligh! is !o an!i-i(a!e every!hing, be-a#se fail#re !o do !his -an -os!
billions, or even h#man lives&
Andersen 6
Fros! is logi-al and dire-! in ans%ering a readerJs 7#es!ion regarding !he -hallenges %hi-h !he
(riva!e se-!or fa-es as i! %ors !o%ards o(era!ional s(a-e (la!forms& ,his is .#s! logos, %hi-h is all i!
really needed !o be&
$ reali6e !ha! !his is no! an o(Bed& $! is a layman)s e3(lana!ion of !he -om(le3 na!#re of s(a-e shi(s
from a NASA engineer)s (ers(e-!ive %hi-h $ ho(e !o #se in e3(laining !he gravi!y of !he -hallenges
%hi-h !his endeavor (resen!s !o !he (riva!e se-!or&
"armong, +ober!& ;'e Sho#ld Priva!i6e S(a-e E3(lora!ion&; Central New York Business Journal& 18&28
/20040: 20& 'eb& 28 5-!& 201=&
$n >'e Sho#ld Priva!i6e S(a-e E3(lora!ion? +ober! "armong arg#es !ha! !he s#--ess of S(a-e @
(rogram has sho%n !ha! governmen! involvemen! in !he s(a-e (rogram is obsole!e& No!ing a governmen!
(anel %hi-h re-ommended in-reased (riva!e se-!or involvemen!, "armong ass %hy no one has !aen i! a
s!e( f#r!her and s#gges!ed !he -om(le!e (riva!i6a!ion of all s(a-e a-!ivi!ies& He (oin!s !o !he differen!
goals and s#bse7#en! varied res#l!s !ha! NASA has gone !hro#gh over !he years as varied (oli!i-al
(ress#re and f#nding iss#es have redefined !he agen-yJs -a(a-i!ies& "armong asser!s !ha! !hese res!ri-!ions
%o#ld be less severe in !he (riva!e se-!or& He -hroni-les ho% ineffi-ien-ies inheren! in s(a-e sh#!!les)
generi- na!#re (rod#-ed a generi- s(a-e -raf! %hi-h %as overly -om(li-a!ed, ineffi-ien! and #nsafe& He
a--#ses NASA of e3!ending !he sh#!!le (rogram s(e-ifi-ally be-a#se of b#rea#-ra!i- ins!i!#!ional iner!ia
and re!i-en-e !o fire long s!anding em(loyees& "armong ill#s!ra!es !he dilemma !he engineers of NASA
fa-e %here !hey have !o balan-e !he hard fa-!s of s(a-e fligh! %i!h an ever -hanging r#leBse! of (oli!i-al
-orre-!ness %hen he re-o#n!s !ha! !he 9ol#mbia Kisas!er -o#ld have been aver!ed if !hey only #sed Freon
based ins#la!ion ins!ead of !he environmen!ally friendly foam %hi-h -a#sed !he fa!al damage& 4l!ima!ely,
"armong arg#es !ha!, %i!ho#! !he se! of s(a-e (ro(er!y righ!s %hi-h (riva!i6a!ion %o#ld (rod#-e,
h#mani!ies effor!s in s(a-e are hobbled& He -on-l#des !ha!, even !ho#gh !hey have (aved !he %ay, i! is
!ime for !he (riva!e se-!or !o !ae over and r#n %i!h !he res#l!s&
Andersen 7
"armong is #sing effe-!ive logos !o s#((or! his o(inion abo#! !he fail#res of NASA& He maes a
s!rong -ase for !he ins!i!#!ional iner!ia %hi-h leads !o a NASA !ha! is behind !he !imes and loos lie i!
%an!s !o s!ay !ha! %ay& ,he fa-!s he (resen!s s#((or! his arg#men!& 4nfor!#na!ely $ find !he arg#men!
fairly one sided& $! (res#((oses m#-h abo#! !he (ress#res !ha! lead !o NASA)s mis!aes, of!en defa#l!ing
!o -as!ing !he -hara-!er of NASA in !he %ors! (ossible ligh!& ,his r#bs me !he %rong %ay, b#! (robably
be-a#se $ am (redis(osed !o liing NASA&
"armong is going !o be one of my (rimary >!hey say? vie%(oin!s& His arg#men! is (ers#asive b#!
omi!s a -o#(le of ey (oin!s regarding NASA)s effe-!iveness& $f yo# .#s! loo a! NASA)s fail#res !hen
!hey are a grim gro#( indeed, b#! in !ha! same ligh! %o#ldn)! %e all be* 8any of NASA)s shor!-omings
are d#e !o !he (oli!i-al na!#re of !heir oversigh!G o!hers are h#man na!#re rela!ed h#rdles any organi6a!ion
%o#ld have !o over-ome& $! is a mis!ae !o overloo NASA)s mon#men!al a--om(lishmen!s&
Ina((, Ale3& ;As!eroid $m(a-! %as !he -o#( de gra-e for dinosa#rs&; Forbes& 2 5-!& 201=: 2& 'eb& 4 Nov&
201=&
$n >As!eroid $m(a-! %as !he -o#( de gra-e for dinosa#rs? Ale3 Ina(( arg#es !ha! 7#es!ions
regarding !he -a#se of !he Kinosa#rs) demise have been laid !o res! by re-en! findings abo#! !he as!eroid
!ha! s!r#- Ear!h .#s! off !he 1#-a!an (enins#la& +e-en! s-ien!ifi- advan-es in !he a--#ra-y of da!ing
!e-hni7#es have (rod#-ed defini!ive da!a& ,he im(a-!, Ina(( e3(lains, %as !he (oin! of no re!#rn, a >final
s!ra%? from %hi-h !he s!ressed environmen! of !he ear!h -o#ld no! re-over& 'hile !here %ere o!her
fa-!ors, !he im(a-! %as sim#l!aneo#s %i!h !he e3!in-!ion& Ina(( also e3amines !he -on!rib#!ion of
signifi-an! -lima!e shif!s !ha! ha((ened in !he million year (eriod leading #( !o !he im(a-!& ,he s!ress of
!his shif!, -ombined %i!h !he im(a-!, (rod#-ed !he massive e3!in-!ion even! %hi-h -laimed !he las! of !he
dinosa#rs& Ina(( -on-l#des !ha!, %hile se(ara!ely !hese even!s may have been s#rvivable, -ombined !hey
%ere devas!a!ing&
Andersen 8
Ina(( (resen!s a very effe-!ive >-en!ral ro#!e? logos a((eal re-o#n!ing fa-!s s#rro#nding !he
1#-a!an as!eroid im(a-!& He is mos! effe-!ive in lining !he as!eroid im(a-! and !he e3!in-!ion even!& ,he
im(or!an-e of !he im(a-! of -lima!e -hange on !he even! is also em(hasi6ed& 2y effe-!ively -onne-!ing
!he -lima!e -hange and !he im(a-!, Ina(( has ill#s!ra!ed ho% !he im(a-! made i! im(ossible for !he Ear!h
!o -on!in#e s#s!aining !he Kinosa#rs) e-osys!em&
,he -on-e(!s in !his ar!i-le are (ar! of !he airos and (a!hos elemen!s of my arg#men!& ,he
!imeliness is bo!h !ha! %e are e3(erien-ing -lima!e -hange and !he (ro3imi!y of NE5)s& ,he (a!hos is !ha!
!he dinosa#r)s fa!e -o#ld be o#rs& $! sho%s !ha! an im(a-! does no! need !o -om(le!ely obli!era!e o#r
e-osys!em !o deal a dea!hblo% !o o#r ra-e or (lane!& 5#r ra-e has (la-ed !his (lane! in an ar!ifi-ially
s!ressed environmen!al s!a!e& An im(a-! -o#ld %ell be !he !i((ing (oin! for #s as i! %as for !he dinosa#rs&
$f $ end #( #sing !his resear-h, i! -o#ld be -o#(led %i!h !he 4N (ie-e by 2arber in order !o bring
addi!ional gravi!y !o !he reasons s(a-e e3(lora!ion ma!!ers righ! no%&
Smi!h, Josh& ;NASA)s Ne% 8ission: E3(loring !he Heavens on a 2#dge!&; National Journal& 21 Jan
2011: 1LB1L& 'eb& 2 Nov& 201=&
Josh Smi!h %ro!e an o(Bed for !he National Journal en!i!led, >NASA)s Ne% 8ission: E3(loring
!he Heavens on a 2#dge!,? %hi-h arg#es !ha! !here is (o!en!ial for a NASA %hi-h has been relieved of i!s
s(a-e going d#!ies !o fo-#s on develo(ing ne% !e-hnology& He begins his arg#men! by remembering !he
s(a-e ra-e of !he 1AE0)s %here (eo(le %ere en!hralled by !he (ossibili!ies of s(a-e !ravel and -on!ras!s
!his %i!h !he la-adaisi-al a!!i!#de !ha! m#-h of !he %orld has !o%ards a seemingly slo% develo(ing and
#nin!eres!ing s(a-e (rogram& ,his fall from fame has lef! NASA and i!s (ie in !he sy goals %hi-h la-
immedia!e real %orld benefi!, v#lnerable !o b#dge! -#!s& Adding !o !his is !he re!iremen! of !he sh#!!les,
!he only manned s(a-e vehi-le !ha! !he 4S has& Smi!h -laims !his v#lnerabili!y has made i! diffi-#l! !o
diver! addi!ional dis-re!ionary f#nds !o !he agen-y& 5bama has (ro(osed a -om(romise !o (riva!i6e s(a-e
!ravel, %hi-h %ill enable NASA !o -on!in#e resear-h and develo(men! of !e-hnology %hile relieving !hem
of !he e3-e(!ional overhead !ha! s#s!ained s(a-e fligh! (rograms (resen!& ,his %o#ld allo% NASA !o s!o(
Andersen 9
%orrying abo#! !he everyday de!ails of s(a-e fligh! and fo-#s on !e-hnology %hi-h migh! red#-e !he
over%helmingly e3(ensive -os! of breaing in!o orbi!, %hi-h averages o#! a! 10 grand (er (o#nd& Smi!h
-on-l#des !ha!, (rovided NASA s#rvives i!s de!ra-!or)s a!!em(!s !o limi! i!s b#dge!, !his may (rove !he
mos! effe-!ive %ay !o allo% NASA !o fo-#s on (#shing o#r bo#ndaries even f#r!her in!o s(a-e&
Smi!h)s eval#a!ion of NASA)s b#dge!ary -on-erns is (rimarily from !he logi-al (ers(e-!ive& He
begins, ho%ever, %i!h an a((eal !o (a!hos by reminis-ing ba- !o !he s(a-e ra-e and !he golden era of
NASA %hen i! %as almos! #niversally %ell regarded& ,his effe-!ively -on!ras!s %i!h !he ambivalen-e or
even hos!ili!y %hi-h NASA mee!s no%, as i! deals %i!h aging e7#i(men! and b#dge!s %hi-h seem !o never
be me!& He ba-s ea-h (oin! %i!h signifi-an! fa-!s, s#-h as a gra(h ill#s!ra!ing NASA)s b#dge!ary
roller-oas!er and !he e3(ensive -os! of a-hieving orbi!& His dis-#ssion of !he #n-er!ain!y in NASA)s f#!#re
%ell earns !he 7#es!ion (osed a! !he end of !he ar!i-le: is s(a-e %or!h !he money*
,his ar!i-le ill#s!ra!ed !he f#nding !#g of %ar NASA is (er(e!#ally end#ring& Addi!ionally, i! %ill
hel( !o shed ligh! on !he mer-#rial na!#re of !he -hanging (oli!i-al dire-!ives leveled a! NASA&
9onsidering !here are some (ro.e-!s %hi-h s(an m#l!i(le -hanges in na!ional (ros(eri!y and (oli!i-al
vie%(oin!s, !he !e-hni-al -hallenges NASA fa-es be-ome even more -om(li-a!ed& ,hese (ress#res
em(hasi6e !he !#g of %ar inheren! in main!aining a s(a-e going (la!form, ill#s!ra!ing ho% i! red#-ed
NASA)s -a(a-i!y !o e3(lore and resear-h& ,his is one of !he s!ronges! arg#men!s in -onvin-ing me !ha! !he
(riva!i6a!ion of s(a-e fligh! -an even!#ally (rod#-e be!!er resear-h for everyone&
,here are many voi-es s#rro#nding h#mani!yJs endeavor !o brea !he bonds of !he ear!h& Fe% of
!hem arg#e !ha! i! is a #seless s!r#ggle& 8any dis(#!e !he me!hod& ,hese arg#men!s have (ers#aded me
!ha! !asing (riva!e in!eres!s %i!h !he heavy lif!ing is !he bes! %ay !o le! NASA fo-#s on resear-h and
e3(lora!ion& ,his %ill (ave !he %ay for big brains !o s(end !heir effor!s on im(or!an! iss#es lie NE5)s
and (lane!ary e3(lora!ion& $! may be !he -ase !ha! Presiden! 5bama)s de-ision !o (riva!i6e !he s(a-e
delivery (la!forms is one of !he bes! !hings !o ha((en !o NASA, and h#mani!yJs, s(a-e in!eres!s in
de-ades&