Sdrnumorder5883 9425

Summary of Decisions Requested in Numerical Submission Order 5883 - 9425
Sub#/
Point Name Address for service Theme Topic Subtopic Summary
5883-1
AMP Capital Property Portfolio
Limited et al david.haines@hainesplanning.co.nz Zoning South
Rezone the Manukau Supa Centa, Manukau from General Business to Metropolitan Centre
[specific sites identified in the map in the submission refer page 10/48].
5883-2
Limited et al david.haines@hainesplanning.co.nz Precincts - South New Precincts All other New Precincts
Add a new sub precinct for the Manukau Supa Centa, which enables greater flexibility for
office, retail and commercial services [specific sites identified in the map in the submission
refer page 10/48].
5883-3
Limited et al david.haines@hainesplanning.co.nz Precincts - South New Precincts All other New Precincts
Add a new sub precinct over the Manukau Supa Centa [specific sites identified in the map in
the submission refer page 10/48] in the event that 70 - 100 Plunket Avenue remains Heavy
Industry zone at [to restrict activities that may be affected by air discharges], as stated in the
submission [refer page 12/48][refer also to point number 4].
5883-4
Limited et al david.haines@hainesplanning.co.nz Zoning South
Rezone the land at 70 - 100 Plunket Avenue, Manukau from Heavy Industry to Light Industry
[refer also to point number 3].
5883-5
Limited et al david.haines@hainesplanning.co.nz General Chapter A Introduction A3 Strategic Framework
Amend the Unitary Plan to enable differing resource consent application types for the same
development to be staged and processed separately, as stated in the submission [refer page
12/48].
5883-6
Limited et al david.haines@hainesplanning.co.nz General
Non-statutory information on
GIS viewer Clarify the provisions that relate to the Indicative Coastline non-statutory layer.
5883-7
Limited et al david.haines@hainesplanning.co.nz Definitions Existing Clarify the definition that relies on the Flood Hazards non-statutory layer.
5883-8
GIS viewer
Clarify the provisions that relate to the Macro invertebrate Community Index non-statutory
layer.
5883-9
GIS viewer Clarify the provisions that relate to the Soil Types non-statutory layer.
5883-10
GIS viewer Clarify the provisions that relate to the Flood Hazards non-statutory layer.
5883-11
GIS viewer Clarify the provisions that relate to the Mori Land non-statutory layer.
5883-12
GIS viewer Clarify the provisions that relate to the Treaty Settlement Alert non-statutory layer.
5883-13
GIS viewer Clarify the provisions that relate to the Hauraki Gulf Marine Park non-statutory layer.
5883-14
Limited et al david.haines@hainesplanning.co.nz
Business (excluding City
Centre) Business
D3 Business Zones / D3.1
General objectives and policies
Undertake further economic and retail analysis to determine the amount of land to meet
commercial needs, including retail, and rezone to meet the anticipated demand.
5883-15
Limited et al david.haines@hainesplanning.co.nz RPS Urban growth
B2.1 Providing for growth in a
quality compact urban form
Amend Objective 2 and Objective 4 by combining them, as stated in the submission [refer
page 14/48].
5883-16
B2.2 A quality built
environment
Amend the objectives and policies to focus on managing adverse effects, as stated in the
submission [refer page 14/48].
5883-17
B2.3 Dev. capacity & supply of
land for urban development Retain Objective 1 which is about development capacity and land supply.
5883-18
land for urban development
Undertake further economic and retail analysis to determine what land is sufficient in giving
effect to Objective 1 and rezone appropriately.
5883-19
Amend Policy 1 as follows: 'Maintain sufficient unconstrained residential and business land
within the RUB to accommodate an average of seven 10 years of urban zoned land supply at
any one time.'
5883-20
Limited et al david.haines@hainesplanning.co.nz RPS
Economic / Business /
Infrastructure / Energy /
Transport
B3.1 Commercial and
industrial growth
Amend Policy 2 as follows: 'Encourage the growth of commercial activities that serve the
function, role and amenity of the city centre, and metropolitan and town centres (including new
centres) and the General Business zone.'
5883-21
Limited et al david.haines@hainesplanning.co.nz RPS
Transport
B3.1 Commercial and
industrial growth
Amend Policy 4 as follows: 'Require development within identified growth corridors to primarily
be of a character and form that supports or serves compact mixed use environments.'
5883-22
Limited et al david.haines@hainesplanning.co.nz Natural Hazards and Flooding Flooding
C5.13 Background, objectives
and policies Amend Objective 1 to allow new development in areas at risk of flooding.
5883-23
and policies Amend Policy 2 to allow new development in areas at risk of flooding.
5883-24
5883-25
Limited et al david.haines@hainesplanning.co.nz Water
Water quality and integrated
management - objectives &
policies
Policies 9-16 Stormwater
management
Amend Policy 10(c) to reconsider the thresholds for triggering stormwater consent
applications.
5883-26
Limited et al david.haines@hainesplanning.co.nz Water
policies
Policies 1-5 Water quality &
ecosystem guidelines App.5.6 Amend the stormwater management rules to have realistic and achievable measures.
Summary of Decisions Requested
Proposed Auckland Unitary Plan
1/1145
Sub#/
5883-27
Limited et al david.haines@hainesplanning.co.nz Sustainable Development C7.7/H6.4 Sustainable design
Amend Objective 1 as follows: 'Buildings are designed to minimise adverse environmental
effects, encourage maximise efficiency and provide healthy and comfortable indoor
environments.
5883-28
Amend Policy 1 as follows: 'Encourage Require medium and large-scale office and industrial
buildings to be designed to meet sustainable building standards.'
5883-29
Amend Policy 2 as follows: 'Encourage Require medium to large-scale residential
development to be designed to meet sustainable building standards.'
5883-30
Limited et al david.haines@hainesplanning.co.nz Sustainable Development C7.7/H6.4 Sustainable design Delete this blanket requirement for sustainable building standards.
5883-31
Centre) Business
Amend Objective 3 as adding a further clause as follows: '(d) recognises existing
infrastructure and investment'.
5883-32
Centre) Business
Amend the objectives and policies to recognise the functional and operational needs of
buildings and focus on managing adverse effects, as stated in the submission [refer page
18/48].
5883-33
Centre) Business
General objectives and policies Delete Policy 4 which is about equal physical access.
5883-34
Centre) Business
General objectives and policies Delete Policy 6 which is about adaptable buildings.
5883-35
Centre) Business
Amend Policy 7 as follows: 'Require parking to be located, and designed, or landscaped in
such a manner as to avoid adverse impact on pedestrian amenity and the streetscape.'
5883-36
Centre) Business
General objectives and policies Delete Policy 11.
5883-37
Centre)
D3.8 General Business zone
desc, obs & pols
Amend the Description, third paragraph, by adding the following: '...to an active street edge,
while recognising the functional requirements of the activities.'
5883-38
Centre)
desc, obs & pols
Amend Policy 5, as follows: 'Enable light industrial activities to locate within the zone but
avoid discourage activities which have objectionable odour, dust or noise emissions that
cannot be remedied or mitigated.'
5883-39
Centre)
desc, obs & pols
Amend Policy 6 as follows: 'Manage compatibility issues of activities within and between
developments through site layout and design measures and imposition of conditions of
consent.'
5883-40
Centre)
desc, obs & pols
Amend Policy 7 as follows: 'Require a good standard of design given the location of the zone
close to centres and along growth corridors, while recognising the functional and practical
requirements of the development.'
5883-41
Limited et al david.haines@hainesplanning.co.nz Transport Auckland -wide
H1.2.3 Development controls
H1.2.6 Special information
requirements Delete Rule 3.1(1) Traffic Generation, total 'Retail' threshold of 500m
2
.
5883-42
requirements
Amend Rule 3.1(1), so that it does not apply in the General Business zone, as stated in the
submission [refer page 22/48].
5883-43
Limited et al david.haines@hainesplanning.co.nz General Chapter G General provisions
G2.1 Determining activity
status
Amend Rule 2(a)(i) as follows: '...The activity status and rules within a precinct takes
precedence over the same activity status and rules within a zone or an Auckland-wide
provision, whether more restrictive or enabling.'
5883-44
status
Amend Rule 2(a)(ii) as follows: '...If an overlay rule applies to the same matter then the most
least restrictive activity status will apply.'
5883-45
Limited et al david.haines@hainesplanning.co.nz General Chapter G General provisions G2.4 Notification
Delete all sections throughout the Unitary Plan that relate to notification and replace with a
single notification section.
5883-46
Limited et al david.haines@hainesplanning.co.nz General Chapter G General provisions G2.4 Notification Delete all notification provisions that set a more stringent requirement than the RMA.
5883-47
G2.7.1 General information
requirements & G2.7.2 Design
statements
Clarify within the assessment criteria for each zone how the details of the design statement
will be incorporated in the assessment of resource consent applications.
5883-48
statements
Recognise circumstances where the proposed design response leads future character of a
street or neighbourhood.
5883-49
statements
Amend the rules to exempt land use consent applications that are in accordance with an
approved structure plan, framework plan or concept plan.
5883-50
Limited et al david.haines@hainesplanning.co.nz RPS Mana Whenua B5 Strategic
Amend the provisions to streamline and formalise the engagement process including updating
the Unitary Plan maps with specific and recognised Iwi groups' interests.
2/1145
Sub#/
5883-51
Limited et al david.haines@hainesplanning.co.nz RPS Mana Whenua
B5.1 Recognition of Te Tiriti o
Waitangi partnership &
participation Amend the provisions to link the maps with each Iwi group's representative.
5883-52
Limited et al david.haines@hainesplanning.co.nz Mana Whenua General provisions
G2.7.4 Cultural impact
assessment
Amend the provisions to exempt resource consent applicants from confirming the need for a
cultural impact assessment within Treaty Settlement areas.
5883-53
requirements Retain Rule 3.2(1) Parking [refer also to point number 54].
5883-54
requirements Amend Rule 3.2(1) Parking, to increase maximums as a result of further evidence.
5883-55
Limited et al david.haines@hainesplanning.co.nz Precincts - South New Precincts All other New Precincts Add specific parking provisions for the Manukau Supa Centa precinct.
5883-56
requirements
Amend Rule 3.2(1) Table 4, by adding a new activity 'Large format retail' with a rate of 1 per
45m
2
GFA.
5883-57
requirements
Amend Rule 3.2(2), Table 5 to require retail activities greater than 3000m
2
to provide cycle
parking rate of 1 per 1000m
2
for visitors and 1 per 800m
2
for staff (secure).
5883-58
requirements
Delete Vehicle Access Restrictions Rule 3.4.1(2)(b), as follows: 'an activity is established on a
site '.
5883-59
requirements
Amend Vehicle Access Restrictions Rule 3.4.1(2)(c) as follows: 'there is a change of activity
and alternative legal access to a road is available'.
5883-60
Limited et al david.haines@hainesplanning.co.nz Earthworks H4.2.1.1 Activity table - Zones
Amend 1.1 Zones Activity Table, second table, to provide for earthworks up to 5,000m
2
and
5,000m
3
as a permitted activity in the Residential and Business zones.
5883-61
Limited et al david.haines@hainesplanning.co.nz Earthworks
H4.2.1.2 Activity table -
Overlays
Amend 1.2 Overlays Activity Table, to describe the column abbreviations in Part 4 as well as
above the activity table and repeat the heading rows across page breaks.
5883-62
GIS viewer Amend the overland flow path information on the planning maps.
5883-63
Limited et al david.haines@hainesplanning.co.nz Natural Hazards and Flooding Flooding H4.12 Rules
Amend the activity table under the sub heading Activities in flood plains, by changing the
activity status of 'New vulnerable activities and all associated buildings, including conversion
and/or change of use of an existing building to accommodate a vulnerable activity' from non
complying to restricted discretionary.
5883-64
Limited et al david.haines@hainesplanning.co.nz Natural Hazards and Flooding Flooding H4.12 Rules
Amend the activity table under the sub heading Activities in overland flow paths, by changing
the activity status of 'Any buildings or structures, including retaining walls but excluding
permitted fences) located within or over an overland flow path' from discretionary to restricted
discretionary.
5883-65
Limited et al david.haines@hainesplanning.co.nz Water Stormwater
H4.14.2 Stormwater
management -flow rules
Amend the activity table by deleting the following activity: 'Impervious areas (other than for a
public road) of less than or equal to 25m
2
in a SMAF 1 or 2 = permitted '.
5883-66
H4.14.2 Stormwater
Amend the activity table activity class as follows: 'New Impervious areas (other than for a
public road) greater than 25m
2
in a SMAF 1 or 2 (other than for a public road) that meet
hydrology mitigation requirements' and change the activity status from controlled to permitted.
5883-67
H4.14.2 Stormwater
Amend the activity table activity class as follows: 'Impervious areas in a SMAF 1 or 2 unable
to comply with the permitted and controlled activity controls'.
5883-68
H4.14.2 Stormwater
Amend the activity table, activity class as follows: 'The development of new impervious areas
less than 25m
2
where the total impervious area on the site comprises less than or equal to
10% of the total site area The development of new impervious areas where the design of the
stormwater system meets hydrology mitigation requirements' with the activity status remaining
unchanged as permitted.
5883-69
H4.14.2 Stormwater
Delete from the activity table, the activity class, as follows 'The development of new
impervious areas less than 25m2 where the total impervious area on the site comprises less
than or equal to 10% of the total site area ' which has an activity status of controlled.
5883-70
H4.14.2 Stormwater
Amend the activity table, activity class as follows: 'The development of new impervious areas
that do not meet the permitted or controlled activity controls' and changed the activity status
from discretionary to restricted discretionary.
5883-71
H4.14.3 Stormwater - quality
rules
Amend the activity table as follows, for the activity 'Uncovered parking (including that which is
accessory to the main use of the site) including entry/exit, which are greater than 1000m
2
in
area and which are not located in the Industrial or Trade Activity area, where stormwater
quality management requirements are met' by changing the activity status from controlled to
permitted.
3/1145
Sub#/
5883-72
rules
Amend the activity table as follows, for the activity: 'The installation of high contaminant
yielding roofing, spouting, cladding material or architectural features, exceeding permitted
activity area controls and where stormwater quality management requirements are met' by
changing the activity status from controlled to permitted.
5883-73
rules
Amend the activity table as follows, for the activity: 'The installation of high contaminant
yielding roofing spouting, cladding material or architectural features that does not meet the
permitted and controlled activity controls' by changing the activity status from discretionary to
restricted discretionary.
5883-74
Limited et al david.haines@hainesplanning.co.nz Sustainable Development C7.7/H6.4 Sustainable design Delete the rules.
5883-75
Centre) Business
I3.1 Activity table 1 for
Centres, Mixed Use, Gen. Bus.
& Bus. Park zones Retain the activity status of permitted for 'Food and beverage' in the General Business zone.
5883-76
Centre) Business
& Bus. Park zones Retain the activity status of permitted for 'Commercial services' in the General Business zone.
5883-77
Centre) Business
& Bus. Park zones
Retain the activity status of permitted for 'Internal alterations to buildings' in the General
Business zone.
5883-78
Centre) Business
& Bus. Park zones
Amend the activity table, activity class as follows: 'Alterations to building facades that are less
than: 1 50 per cent of its total surface area, or 50015 m whichever is the greater lesser ' and
retain the permitted activity status in the General Business zone.
5883-79
Centre) Business
& Bus. Park zones
Amend the activity table, activity class as follows: 'Additions to buildings that are less than: 1
50 per cent of the existing GFA of the building, or 2 500m whichever is the lesser greater'
and retain the activity status of permitted.
5883-80
Centre) Business
& Bus. Park zones
Amend the activity table to change the activity status of 'New buildings' from restricted
discretionary to permitted.
5883-81
Centre) Business
I3.1 Activity table 2 for Light
and Heavy Industry zones
Amend the activity table to ensure there is no conflict between activity classifications and
definitions.
5883-82
Centre) Business I3.2 Notification Delete Rule 2(1) Notification.
5883-83
Centre) Business
I3.4 Dev. controls Centres,
Mixed Use, Gen. Bus. & Bus.
Park zones Delete Rule 4.1(1) Development control infringements.
5883-84
Centre) Business
Park zones
Amend Rule 4.2 Building height, Table 1 by deleting the second column and using height in
metres only.
5883-85
Centre) Business
Park zones Retain Rule 4.2 Building height for the Manukau Supa Centa being 16.5m.
5883-86
Centre) Business
Park zones Amend Rule 4.2 Building height for the Manukau Supa Centa to be increased.
5883-87
Centre) Business
Park zones
Amend Rule 4.6(b) Buildings Fronting the street so it does not apply in the General Business
zone.
5883-88
Centre) Business
Park zones Amend Rule 4.7 Buildings Entrances so it does not apply in the General Business zone.
5883-89
Centre) Business
Park zones Delete Rule 4.8 Minimum floor to floor/ceiling height.
5883-90
Centre) Business
I3.6 - I3.9 Assessment & I3.10
Special information
requirements Delete Rule 3.10 Special Information requirements.
5883-91
Centre) Business
Park zones Amend Rule 4.9(c) Glazing so it does not apply in the General Business zone.
5883-92
Centre) Business
Park zones Delete Rule 4.12 Ground floor at street frontage level.
4/1145
Sub#/
5883-93
Centre) Business
Park zones
Amend Rule 4.17(2) Landscaping, as follows: 'Landscaping must be provided along the
frontage of sites not occupied by buildings or access points as allowed by clause 4.6 above,
for a depth of 3 2m, for sites in:...'
5883-94
Centre) Business
Park zones
Amend Rule 4.18(1) as follows: 'Maximum impervious area in the General Business and
Business Park zone: 80 95 per cent.'
5883-95
Centre) Business
Park zones
Business Park zone: 80 per cent.'
5883-96
Centre) Business
Special information
requirements
Delete the Assessment criteria 8.1(1) and 8.1(2) and relocate to the non-mandatory and non-
statutory Auckland Design Manual [refer also point number 97].
5883-97
Centre) Business
Special information
requirements
Amend the Assessment criteria 8.1(1) and 8.1(2) so the outcome sought is clear and they can
be used to assist in the identification and assessment of adverse effects [refer also point
number 96].
5883-98
Limited et al david.haines@hainesplanning.co.nz Definitions Existing Retain the definition of 'Large format retail'.
5884-1 Victoria J Park parksathome@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central Retain Single House zone for 14 Disraeli Street, Mt Eden.
5884-2 Victoria J Park parksathome@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central
Rezone from Mixed Housing Suburban to Single House for Disraeli St, Mt Eden and endorse
existing Single House on Disraeli Street, Mt Eden.
5884-3 Victoria J Park parksathome@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central Retain Single House zone for Woodside Road, Mt Eden.
5884-4 Victoria J Park parksathome@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central Rezone Poronui Street, Mt Eden from Mixed Housing Suburban to Single House.
Rezone the large block bordered by Mt Eden Road in the east, from Valley Road in the north
to Kingsview Road in the South, and Tarata Street and Henley Road in the west, Mt Eden,
from Mixed Housing Suburban to Single House.
Rezone a large block from Mt Eden Road in the west, to Rautangi Road in the north, to
Aberfoyle Street in the south, Mt Eden, from Mixed Housing Suburban to Single House.
Rezone Mt Eden Road, Mt Eden, from Mixed Use Zone to a zone which avoids dominating
adjoining residential properties.
5884-8 Victoria J Park parksathome@xtra.co.nz Built Environment (Overlays)
Overlay J4.2 Additional Zone
Height Control
Amend Additional Height Controls - Mount Eden from 12.5m/3 storey, down to 10m/2 storey
maximum.
5884-9 Victoria J Park parksathome@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central Delete Mixed Use Zone [Eden Valley].
5884-10 Victoria J Park parksathome@xtra.co.nz Built Environment (Overlays)
Height Control
Reduce Additional Height Controls - Eden Valley from 16.5m/4 storey down to 10m/2 storey
maximum.
Rezone both sides of Mt Eden Road, Mt Eden (between Kingsview Road and Woodside
Road) from Mixed Housing Urban to Mixed Housing Suburban [refer also to point 20].
Retain Single House zone for the large block of properties south of Eden Park
from Walters Road in the north to Parrish Road and St Albans Avenue, Mt Eden in the south,
and from Sandringham Road in the west to Dominion Road in the east.
5884-13 Victoria J Park parksathome@xtra.co.nz Historic Heritage (Overlay)
Overlay E2/J2 Historic
Heritage
Appendices 9.1 9.2 and 9.3
Significant Historic Heritage
Places Retain the overlay for Burnley Terrace and King Edward St, Mt Eden.
5884-14 Victoria J Park parksathome@xtra.co.nz Precincts Ak-Wide and Coastal Stadiums and Showgrounds K1.10 Precinct Rules Retain Sub-precinct Eden Park rules.
5884-15 Victoria J Park parksathome@xtra.co.nz General
Temporary Activities (C7.5 and
H6.5) Exclude Eden Park sub-precinct from the application of these rules.
5884-16 Victoria J Park parksathome@xtra.co.nz General Chapter G General provisions G2.4 Notification Amend Restricted Discretionary activities to use normal RMA notification tests.
5884-17 Victoria J Park parksathome@xtra.co.nz Residential zones Residential
Development Controls: Single
House zone, Large Lot
Residential zone and Rural
and Coastal Settlement zone Retain the maximum building height limit in the Single House zone of 8m / two storeys.
5884-18 Victoria J Park parksathome@xtra.co.nz
Pre - 1944 Building demolition
control
Overlay E3.2/J3.6 Pre -1944
Building demolition control J.3.6 Rules and mapping Retain Pre-1944 Building Demolition Control overlay.
5884-19 Victoria J Park parksathome@xtra.co.nz Residential zones Residential Land use controls Delete unlimited density in Mixed Housing Urban where a site is greater than 1200m
2
.
5884-20 Victoria J Park parksathome@xtra.co.nz Residential zones Residential Land use controls
Delete 200m
2
density in Mixed Housing Suburban where a site is greater than 1200m
2
and
retain minimum site density as 300m
2
.
5884-21 Victoria J Park parksathome@xtra.co.nz
Centre) Business I3.3 Land use controls
Amend the activity status of activities within 30m of a residential zone to change from
restricted discretionary to discretionary.
5884-22 Victoria J Park parksathome@xtra.co.nz Special Character
Special character Isthmus A, B
& C J3.3.1-7 Rules
Amend Activity Table to change the activity status of demolition to change from restricted
discretionary to discretionary.
5884-23 Victoria J Park parksathome@xtra.co.nz Special Character
& C J3.3.1-7 Rules Delete relocation from assessment criteria in the Special Character Isthmus A area.
5/1145
Sub#/
Amend the application of Mixed Housing Suburban or Mixed Use zones within Balmoral Rd,
west to Sandringham, North Kingsland, and East to Mt Eden Rd, and North to New North
Road, Mt Eden and stage intensification after adequacy of infrastructure and demand is
determined.
5885-1 Michael G Abbott mikeab@piletech.co.nz Zoning South Rezone 74 Douglas Rd, Waiuku and surrounding general land area from Rural Coastal
5885-2 Michael G Abbott mikeab@piletech.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - Rural zones
H5.2.3.3 Rural zones / App.
12.1 Receiver site exclusion
area
Amend the PAUP to open up the potential for further subdivision on this section of the
peninsula [on Douglas Road, Waiuku]
5885-3 Michael G Abbott mikeab@piletech.co.nz
Outstanding Natural
Landscapes (ONL) and
Outstanding and High Natural
Character (ONC and HNC)
Rules
J6.2.3 Development controls
J6.2.4 Assessment
Amend the plan to remove restrictions on permitted building size and allow buildings larger
than 50m
2

5886-1 R Purchas rosepurchas@xtra.co.nz
control
Building demolition control J.3.6 Rules and mapping
Review the existing zoning (and the related rules) applied across areas of urban Auckland
that were subdivided and developed before 1944 and provide a more refined methods of
enabling new development so that it delivers intensification in these areas while reinforcing
our sense of place.
5886-2 R Purchas rosepurchas@xtra.co.nz
control
Amend the 1944 demolition control has been applied and remove it from sites where all
buildings on the site post date 1944.
5886-3 R Purchas rosepurchas@xtra.co.nz Residential zones Residential Land use controls
Amend rules so that in the Mixed Housing Suburban and Mixed Housing Urban zones there is
no limit on the number of dwellings that can be located in an existing building on the site (as at
notification of the PAUP) as long as the size of the the new dwellings meet the net internal
floor areas limit 40m
2
.
5886-4 R Purchas rosepurchas@xtra.co.nz Residential zones Residential
Development Controls:
General
Amend the rules to require any new development to be the subject of a
restricted discretionary activity resource consent and require the proposed new development
to show how it considers a. the form and scale of the character buildings in the immediate
areas and b. how it addresses adjacent buildings located on the site or adjacent sites and c.
how it addresses the street.
5886-5 R Purchas rosepurchas@xtra.co.nz Residential zones Residential Activity Table
Amend the permitted activity status of care centre activities, supported residential care and
boarding houses unless land use controls are introduced.
5886-6 R Purchas rosepurchas@xtra.co.nz Residential zones Residential Activity Table Amend the activity status to provide for new buildings as a Restricted Discretionary activity.
Amend the land use controls for the hours of operation and location of outside play areas for
care centre activities and location of parking for supported residential care and boarding
house activities if they are retained as permitted activities.
Amend rule 3.1 Maximum density, Table 1 to include a reference to 3.1.4 in relation to Mixed
Housing Suburban and Mixed Housing Urban zones.
Amend rule 3.1(7) Maximum density, to provide certainty on what the most restrictive density
is.
Amend rule 3.1(9) Maximum density to reads: Clause 1 does not apply where an existing
dwelling (prior to notification of the PAUP) is converted into two dwellings as a permitted
[activity].
5886-11 R Purchas rosepurchas@xtra.co.nz Residential zones Residential Notification
Amend Notification to include side and rear yard infringements in the Single House, Mixed
Housing Suburban and Mixed Housing Urban zones.
General
Amend Development Control infringements to include a cross reference to rule 2.3 in Chapter
G, General provisions, about the infringement of development controls.
Development Controls: Mixed
Housing Suburban zone and
Mixed Housing Urban zone Retain 8m height in the Mixed Housing Suburban zone.
Mixed Housing Urban zone Retain definition of 'height' in the Mixed Housing Suburban zone.
Mixed Housing Urban zone
Delete the use of a 2.5m vertical measurments plus 45 degree recession plane for side
boundaries and the use of the alternative height in relation to boundary rule in the Mixed
Housing Suburban zone.
Mixed Housing Urban zone Delete the 1m side and rear yard requirements in the Mixed Housing Sububran zone.
General
Retain the waiver of height in relation to boundary and yard rules where there is a common
wall, but only if the common wall is defined.
General Retain the maximum impervious area rule of 60 per cent.
6/1145
Sub#/
Clarify the conflict between surveillance and privacy in the outlook space rules of the Mixed
Housing Suburban zone as described in the submission [page 6/7].
General
Amend rules so that separation requirements in all zones apply between buildings on adjacent
sites.
General
Amend outdoor living space rules to clarify that a deck is as appropriate as a balcony and
should provide for changes to existing dwellings where the outdoor space may not be directly
accessible from the principal living room.
General
Amend the rule 'Dwellings fronting the street' so that it achieves its purpose of
increasing surveillance, as described in the submission [refer to page 6/7].
General Amend rule 'Maximum building length' to increase the separation from the boundary.
General
Amend the rules for fences for all zones as follows: a. the maximum height of a fence or wall
on the road frontage boundary of the site, shall not exceed 1.6 metres in height if solid.
General
Retain the Garage rules for the purpose of reducing the dominance of garages, but note that
these rules will not avoid parked cars overhanging the footpath.
General
Clarify whether the 'Water and wastewater' rules apply to any structure requiring a building
consent.
Mixed Housing Urban zone Amend 7.2(2) Storage, to show that it applies to all dwellings.
I1.10-11 Assessment & I1.12
Special info. req.
Assess the design of new building relative to the neighbourhood and any dwelling on the site
and in particular the following matters can be considered: a. the form and scale of the
character buildings in the immediate areas and b. how it addresses adjacent buildings located
on the site or adjacent sites and c. how it address the street.
5887-1
Bruce Graham and Elizabeth B
Peat bpeat@clear.net.nz RPS
Historic heritage, special
character and natural heritage B4.3 Natural heritage
Require dialogue between [Auckland] Council and Landowners in order that areas designated
SEA and ONL be agreed between Council and Individual affected lanowners
5887-2
Peat bpeat@clear.net.nz RPS
Retain rural site subdivision rights as compensation for designating private land zoned rural
production as SEA or ONL
5887-3
Peat bpeat@clear.net.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - Rural zones
area
Amend the rules to permit subdivision with an average of 1.8Ha, minimum 1 hectare for the
Broomfields Peninsula, Whitford
5888-1 Justina Frost
79 Francis Street, Hauraki, Auckland
0622 Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula K5.11 Precinct rules
Delete the rules that allow four storey housing with minimum floor area of 40m
2
within the
Devonport Precinct
5889-1
Kelmarna Property Holdings
Limited michael@campbellbrown.co.nz Zoning Central Retain Local Centre zone for 1 Kelmarna Avenue, Herne Bay
5889-2
Limited michael@campbellbrown.co.nz
Centre) Business
Park zones
Retain Local Centre Zone development controls (subject to changes sought in this
submission)
5889-3
Limited michael@campbellbrown.co.nz Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
Retain proposed parking minimums, including restricted discretionary activity controls
modification to provide additional parking above the maximum levels
5889-4
Centre) Business
Park zones
Amend Minimum floor to floor/ceiling height rule from 4m to 3.5m [submission refers to rule
4.3.3.4.1.7 from the Draft Auckland Unitary Plan]
5889-5
Centre) Business
Park zones
Amend Residential at ground floor to enable activities on the ground floor in cases of corner
sites with secondary local roads [submission refers to rule 4.3.3.4.1.9 from the Draft Auckland
Unitary Plan]
5889-6
Centre)
D3.5 Local Centre zone desc,
obs & pols
Amend Policy [3.2.3.5.2 from the Draft Auckland Unitary Plan refers to enabling residential
use above street level] to acknowledge situations where a site has more than one frontage
5890-1
Broadwood Property Holdings
Limited colin@hardacreplanning.co.nz
Vegetation Management and
SEAs
Appendix 5.1 - Schedule of
Significant Ecological Areas -
Land Delete SEA from 7 and 11 Verbena Rd, Birkdale
5890-2
Limited colin@hardacreplanning.co.nz Mana Whenua
Overlay E5.2/J5.2 Sites &
Places of value to Mana
Whenua
Appendix 4.2 Sites and Places
of value to Mana Whenua Remove the overlay from 8 and 10 Crisp Rd, Clarks Beach
5890-3
Limited colin@hardacreplanning.co.nz RPS Mana Whenua B5 Strategic
Decline or amend the Mana Whenua provisions to remove any special rights, powers, co-
governance or authority given to any section of the community that has not been
democratically elected
5891-1 Mark English mark.english@harcourts.co.nz Zoning North and Islands
Rezone Northcross bush land, Browns Bay from residential zone (if the proposed Ministry of
Education sale proceeds)
7/1145
Sub#/
5891-2 Mark English mark.english@harcourts.co.nz
SEAs
Land Add Northcross Bush, Browns Bay to schedule of Special Ecological Areas
5892-1 Milford Marsh Trustee Limited les.harvey@xtra.co.nz Mana Whenua
Overlay E5.1/J5.1 Sites and
Places of Significance to Mana
Whenua
Appendix 4.1 Sites and places
of significance to mana
whenua
Limit those sites of significance to Mana Whenua to be included in the PAUP to those already
recorded within existing Council Heritage Schedules of the existing operative district plans,
except via a publicly notified private plan change and an application to the New Zealand
Historic Places Trust.
5892-2 Milford Marsh Trustee Limited les.harvey@xtra.co.nz RPS Mana Whenua B5 Strategic
Require Council to conduct a referendum of its ratepayers to determine: a) the status of the
Independent Mori Statutory Board ("IMSB"); b) that any rights provided to the IMSB or Mana
Whenua be subject to full democratic process; and c) that the IMSB be self-funded and
not receive any further grants from the Auckland ratepayers due to an abuse of the PAUP
process.
5892-3 Milford Marsh Trustee Limited les.harvey@xtra.co.nz General Chapter A Introduction A1 Background
Delete last 2 paragraphs and replace with "Unitary Plan is to be limited to fulfilling
its requirements only as required under the Treaty of Waitangi settlements and the
Resource Management Act."
5892-4 Milford Marsh Trustee Limited les.harvey@xtra.co.nz General Chapter A Introduction A2 Statutory Framework
Delete last paragraph and replace with " Auckland Council are required to notify Mana
Whenua of any application for Resource Consent on any Scheduled Site of Significance or
Value (as determined by the NZ Historic Places trust), as an affected party".
5892-5 Milford Marsh Trustee Limited les.harvey@xtra.co.nz RPS
character and natural heritage B4.1 Historic heritage
Add the following text "as approved by an application to the NZHPT and as fully Publically
Notified as part of a Private Plan Change for inclusion of any site as Specified Site Schedule
in accordance with the historic Places Act 1993."
5892-6 Milford Marsh Trustee Limited les.harvey@xtra.co.nz RPS Mana Whenua
B5.4 Protection of Mana
Whenua culture and heritage /
Fig. 1
Delete section and replace with the following: "Any site which Mana Whenua consider a site
of Significance or Value shall be subject to an application to the NZHPT and as fully Publically
Notified as part of a Private Plan Change for inclusion of any site as Specified Site
on the Council register by that Iwi. Any site which is currently contained within an Operative
District Plan Schedule shall be included within the Unitary Plan Schedule and Overlays."
5892-7 Milford Marsh Trustee Limited les.harvey@xtra.co.nz RPS Urban growth
environment Delete section.
5892-8 Milford Marsh Trustee Limited les.harvey@xtra.co.nz General Chapter G General provisions
statements Amend rule G2.7.1.4(k) to apply only to sites currently recorded by Operative Plans.
5892-9 Milford Marsh Trustee Limited les.harvey@xtra.co.nz General Chapter G General provisions
statements
Amend rule G2.7.1.4(k) as follows: 'location of any known sites or areas of significance to
Mana Whenua that are on Council records, ... or that are made known to the applicant during
any consultation process that may have been undertaken '.
5892-10 Milford Marsh Trustee Limited les.harvey@xtra.co.nz Mana Whenua General provisions
G2.5(2)(3) and (4) Accidental
discovery protocol
Delete Accidental Discovery Protocols clauses 5.2, 5.3 and 5.4 and rely upon clause 5.1 for
all historical, heritage or cultural sites of Significance or Value and subject to
the proposed change to Issue B5 - Protection of Mana Whenua and Heritage.
Whenua
E5.1 Overlay description,
objectives and policies Delete overlay.
Whenua
E5.2 Description, objectives
and policies Delete overlay.
5892-13 Milford Marsh Trustee Limited les.harvey@xtra.co.nz Mana Whenua Auckland wide - Mori Land
H2.1.1 Activity table, H2.1.2
Notification & H2.1.3 Dev.
controls
Delete rule 2.1.2(1) which limits the need for notification or affected party consent
for discretionary activities.
Auckland wide - Treaty
settlement land
H2.2 Treaty Settlement Land
rules/App. 4.3 legislation
Delete [notification] rule 2.2.2.1 which limits the need for notification or affected party consent
for discretionary activities.
Whenua
whenua
Delete Appendix 4.1 and replace with the following: 'Any site which Mana Whenua consider a
site of Significance or Value shall be subject to an application to the NZHPT and as fully
Publically Notified as part of a Private Plan Change for inclusion of any site as Specified Site
District Plan Schedule shall be included within the Unitary Plan Schedule and Overlays.'
Whenua
of value to Mana Whenua
Delete Appendix 4.2 and replace with the following: "Any site which Mana Whenua consider a
site of Significance or Value shall be subject to an application to the NZHPT and as fully
District Plan Schedule shall be included within the Unitary Plan Schedule and Overlays."
8/1145
Sub#/
5892-17 Milford Marsh Trustee Limited les.harvey@xtra.co.nz Definitions Existing
Delete 2nd and 3rd paragraphs of the definition of "Mana Whenua Cultural Heritage" and add
the following: "Any site which Mana Whenua consider a site of Significance or Value shall be
subject to an application to the NZHPT and as fully Publically Notified as part of a Private
Plan Change for inclusion of any site as Specified Site on the Council register by that Iwi. Any
site which is currently contained within an Operative District Plan Schedule shall be
included within the Unitary Plan Schedule and Overlays."
5892-18 Milford Marsh Trustee Limited les.harvey@xtra.co.nz Definitions Existing
Delete definition of "Mori Cultural Landscapes" and replace with the following:
"Any site which Mana Whenua consider a site of Significance or Value shall be subject to an
application to the NZHPT and as fully Publically Notified as part of a Private Plan Change for
inclusion of any site as Specified Site on the Council register by that Iwi. Any site which is
currently contained within an Operative District Plan Schedule shall be included within the
Unitary Plan Schedule and Overlays."
Whenua
objectives and policies
Limit those sites of value to Mana Whenua to be included in the PAUP to those already
recorded within existing Council Heritage Schedules of the existing operative district plans,
except via a publicly notified private plan change and an application to the New Zealand
Historic Places Trust.
5893-1 IAG New Zealand Limited bryce.davies@iag.co.nz Definitions New Add RMA definition of 'natural hazard' as specified on Page 11/11 of the submission.
5893-2 IAG New Zealand Limited bryce.davies@iag.co.nz Definitions Existing
Amend definition of 'land which may be subject to natural hazards' to 'land which may be
subject to vulnerable to natural hazards and insert additional criteria'.
5893-3 IAG New Zealand Limited bryce.davies@iag.co.nz Definitions Existing
Amend definition of 'Vulnerable activities' to read: 'Activities where there is permanent
occupation of buildings and concentrations of people who are likely to have difficulty coping
with physical threats from natural hazards, including flooding, and/or limited resilience to the
adverse effects of flooding ' natural hazards' to property and their contents'.
5893-4 IAG New Zealand Limited bryce.davies@iag.co.nz RPS Natural resources B6.7 Natural hazards Retain 6.7 Natural Hazards.
5893-5 IAG New Zealand Limited bryce.davies@iag.co.nz Natural Hazards and Flooding Flooding
and policies Retain the general approach taken to flooding.
and policies
Amend the flooding provisions to move toward a more holistic view of likelihood and impact as
opposed to using the 1-in100 year average return interval.
5893-7 IAG New Zealand Limited bryce.davies@iag.co.nz Historic Heritage (Overlay)
C3 Historic heritage -
Background, objectives and
policies
Amend historic heritage place provisions to ensure the protection of of historic heritage places
is balanced with the need to ensure such buildings will not create an increased risk to the
public should a natural hazard event occur.
Heritage
J2.1 Activity table 1 -
Significant historic heritage
places
Retain the restricted discretionary activity status for 'temporary dismantling of buildings for
seismic strengthening'.
5893-9 IAG New Zealand Limited bryce.davies@iag.co.nz RPS Natural resources B6.7 Natural hazards Retain the approach of the PAUP being activity focused as opposed to hazard focused.
5893-10 IAG New Zealand Limited bryce.davies@iag.co.nz Natural Hazards and Flooding Natural Hazards
and policies
Amend the third paragraph of the Background by replacing the first sentence to acknowledge
instead that land use planning for low-frequency high-magnitude events like tsunamis and
earthquakes is appropriate.
and policies
Amend the plan to connect each natural hazard present in the region is clearly linked to a
policy on how the risk will be addressed through land use planning.
5893-12 IAG New Zealand Limited bryce.davies@iag.co.nz RPS Natural resources B6.7 Natural hazards
Clarify why flooding has been separated out while other natural hazards are proposed to be
managed together.
and policies Amend the flooding provisions as the use of a single annual return period is undesirable.
Amend the PAUP to ensure that all hazards are considered individually and in combination as
natural hazard risks are concurrent.
Amend the PAUP to improve the focus on information gathering robust information on natural
hazards and their risks. Robust standards must be put in place to support this.
Amend the Objectives and Policies to provide for the avoidance of natural hazards and focus
on reducing exposure to natural hazards first and foremost and where this is not possible or
appropriate mitigation measures should be put in place.
H4.11.2 Controls /H4.11.3
Assessment
Add additional assessment criteria to enable decision makers and developers appropriately
understand and assess the risks of locating an activity in a hazard area.
G2.7.5 Information
requirements
Add additional information requirements to enable decision makers and developers
appropriately understand and assess the risks of locating an activity in a hazard area.
Amend the PAUP to provide for a more proactive approach to to risk management in relation
to vulnerable activities in areas that maybe at risk of natural hazards.
Heritage
Overlay E2 description,
Amend overlay to provide that buildings in areas vulnerable to natural hazards are not
covered by the blanket historic heritage provisions and to allow for the possibility of demolition
of historic heritage places where the retention of these places create a risk to public safety.
9/1145
Sub#/
Amend PAUP to specifically identify land vulnerable to natural hazards by way of an overlay
so the public can easily identify land in the region which is vulnerable to natural hazards and
give additional recognition to the risks of developing in such areas.
5894-1 Pamela Watson pammy@clear.net.nz Zoning Central
Rezone the area around Lynfield, including The Avenue, the triangle of White Swan Road,
and Griffin Park Road to stop 4-6 storey dwellings
5894-2 Pamela Watson pammy@clear.net.nz RPS Urban growth
Reject the approach to intensification; creating low quality subdivisions, infill housing and multi
storey apartment living
5894-3 Pamela Watson pammy@clear.net.nz General Chapter A Introduction
A4.1 Structure of the Unitary
Plan Reject the Unitary Plan in its current format
5895-1 Rod Mead rodem45@gmail.com General Chapter A Introduction
Plan
Amend the PAUP to clarify Council's intentions and present those intentions in plain language
prior to notification.
5896-1 Mr and Mrs Marx
infocentre.thompson_marx@yahoo.c
om General Miscellaneous Consultation and engagement Reject PAUP due to lack of consultation.
om RPS Mana Whenua B5 Strategic Reject provisions that require resource consent due to Mana Whenua cultural heritage.
om Mana Whenua General provisions
assessment Reject provisions that require consultation with Mana Whenua [G2.7.4]
5897-1
Mangere Mountain Education
Trust, Mountain View School et
al andrew@blakeyscott.co.nz
Volcanic Viewshafts and height
sensitive areas rules
Appendix 3.3 - Volcanic view
shafts survey coordinates
Retain the volcanic viewshaft height sensitive provisions which restrict building heights in
those areas where views of Mangere Mountain exist.
5897-2
al andrew@blakeyscott.co.nz
sensitive areas rules J6.3 Rules
Amend the Activity table to clarify the non-complying activity status of "buildings and
structures except in a height sensitive area".
5897-3
al andrew@blakeyscott.co.nz Zoning South
Amend the zonings applied to land beneath the areas of the viewshaft protection for Mangere
Mountain to reflect the limitations of the viewshafts. Refer to pg. 7/8 of the submission for
details.
5898-1 A M Culav et al peterr@catobolam.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - Urban zones H5.2 3.1 Residential zones
Amend the 600m
2
subdivison standard in the Single House zone to 450m
2
, either generally in
that zone or for the land at 247-261 Hepburn Road, Glendene, Lot 1 DP 200715, Lot 1 DP
8298 and Pt Lot 8 DP 1931.
5898-2 A M Culav et al peterr@catobolam.co.nz Residential zones Residential Land use controls Amend the dwelling density for 247-261 Hepburn Road, Glendene to 350m
2
.
5898-3 A M Culav et al peterr@catobolam.co.nz
SEAs
Land
Remove SEA T 4913 from 247-261 Hepburn Road, Glendene, Lot 1 DP 200715, Lot 1 DP
8298 and Pt Lot 8 DP 1931.
5898-4 A M Culav et al peterr@catobolam.co.nz
Coastal zones and activities in
the CMA
Appendix 6 - Coastal excluding
sch. 6.2 ONC/HNC
6.1 Schedule SEA
marine/Overlay 8.1 SEAs
Marine 1 and 2
Remove SEA M2 54 from 247-261 Hepburn Road, Glendene, Lot 1 DP 200715, Lot 1 DP
8298 and Pt Lot 8 DP 1931.
5898-5 A M Culav et al peterr@catobolam.co.nz Infrastructure
Overlay E1.4 /J1.4 Electricity
Transmission Corridor J1.4 Rules and mapping
Delete the Transmission Corridor provisions in their entirety, or in relation to 247-261
Hepburn Road, Glendene, Lot 1 DP 200715, Lot 1 DP 8298 and Pt Lot 8 DP 1931.
5898-6 A M Culav et al peterr@catobolam.co.nz Air Quality
Overlay E7.12 Air Quality -
Sensitive Activity Restriction
Delete the Heavy Industry Air Quality - Glendene Sensitive Activity Restriction overlay from
residential land within a 500m buffer, or in relation to 247-261 Hepburn Road, Glendene, Lot
1 DP 200715, Lot 1 DP 8298 and Pt Lot 8 DP 1931.
5898-7 A M Culav et al peterr@catobolam.co.nz Residential zones Housing affordability
and policies
Amend affordable housing provisions to allow for an incentive approach with flexibility for
innovative density and development design options.
5899-1
Auckland Planning Team:
Beca Limited graeme.roberts@beca.com General Eplan
Retain the features of the e-plan, including; nesting tables, the ability to hover over words to
get a definition, the 'I' information button, the links to the legacy plans.
5899-2
Beca Limited graeme.roberts@beca.com General Editorial and Part 6
Amend by adding cross references to the Plan stating the objectives and policies that each
rule seeks to achieve/respond to
5899-3
Beca Limited graeme.roberts@beca.com Definitions Existing
Amend the definition of building either by clarifying it or using an already established definition
from an Act or legacy plan.
5899-4
Beca Limited graeme.roberts@beca.com Definitions Existing Amend the definitions of both "greenfield" and "brownfield" areas and development
5899-5
Beca Limited graeme.roberts@beca.com Definitions Existing Clarify the definition of impervious surfaces
5899-6
Beca Limited graeme.roberts@beca.com General Cross plan matters Amend the plan by carrying out a thorough review of workability for all rules
5899-7
Beca Limited graeme.roberts@beca.com General Chapter A Introduction
A4.3 Legal Effect/A4.4
Identifying RPS, RP, RCP and
DP provisions
Amend the plan by clarifying which rules are Section 9-11 matters and which are Section 12-
15 matters - and amend the plan by correcting the explanations in Chapter G
5899-8
Beca Limited graeme.roberts@beca.com General Chapter G General provisions
G1.1-10 Administration (G1.3
refer to Designations theme)
Amend G1.4 Applying for a resource consent so that it is clear how the assessment criteria
are to be applied. Consider identifying (in all assessment criteria throughout the Plan) those
assessment criteria that have priority so that this explanation is carried through into the Plan
provisions
5899-9
Beca Limited graeme.roberts@beca.com Earthworks
and policies
Amend by clarifying what is trying to be achieved by the earthworks rules, for example: the
"per lot" provisions do not work for projects that cross multiple lots (especially trenching).
10/1145
Sub#/
5899-10
Beca Limited graeme.roberts@beca.com General Chapter A Introduction
DP provisions
Amend the Plan by clarifying which earthworks rules are "regional" rules and which are
"district" rules
5899-11
Beca Limited graeme.roberts@beca.com General Cross plan matters
Amend the plan to incorporate greater use of permitted activity status with accompanying
standards to manage actual and potential effects (the earthworks and associated vegetation
clearance rules are a particularly relevant opportunity to do this)
5899-12
Amend the Plan to remove "Prohibited" activities unless there is strong factual backing and
appropriate justification in a Section 32 report
5899-13
Beca Limited graeme.roberts@beca.com Mana Whenua General provisions
assessment
Amend the Plan by clarifying the process (i.e. for iwi, landowners and applicants) required for
engaging and undertaking investigations and assessment, and managing the time
frames involved within the statutory time frames set in the RMA
5899-14
Beca Limited graeme.roberts@beca.com Mana Whenua General provisions
assessment
Amend the plan by removing the third party approval processes for Iwi (with respect to Mana
Whenua sites and places of value)
5899-15
Beca Limited graeme.roberts@beca.com
the CMA General Coastal Marine Zone
D5.1 Zone description,
Amend the Plan by moving the overlay requirements in the Coastal General Zone Activity
Table to sit within the Overlay section of the Plan
5899-16
Beca Limited graeme.roberts@beca.com
control
Building demolition control
and policies
Amend the Plan by removing the 1944 Overlay until such time as the appropriate assessment
has been undertaken by Auckland Council to determine and confirm which specific sites and /
or areas of the region should be protected under the overlay
5899-17
Amend the plan as required to correctly cross-reference to and be consistent with National
Environmental Standards
5899-18
Beca Limited graeme.roberts@beca.com Transport Auckland -wide Mapping
Amend the Plan by clarifying how each road is classified (eg include corresponding maps or
overlays)
5900-1 Russell J Malone maloner@orcon.net.nz Precincts - North Bayswater K5.6 Precinct rules Require public notification for any residential development.
5900-2 Russell J Malone maloner@orcon.net.nz Precincts - North Bayswater
F5.6 Precinct description,
objectives and policies Require greater provision for community and recreational marine activities
5901-1 Sam Noon hinoon@clear.net.nz Zoning Central Retain single housing zone on Valley Road
5901-2 Sam Noon hinoon@clear.net.nz General
H6.5)
Exclude Stadiums and Showgrounds sub-precinct Eden Park from the application of these
rules.
5901-3 Sam Noon hinoon@clear.net.nz Zoning South Rezone Lovegrove Cres, Otara, from Light Industry to Mixed Use
5901-4 Sam Noon hinoon@clear.net.nz General Miscellaneous Other
Reject the private plan change initiated by Progressive Enterprises seeking to change zoning
to business 2 [on Valley Road]
5902-1
Ponsonby Baptist Social
Issues Group tonymac@ihug.co.nz RPS Urban growth
Extend the Mixed Housing Urban zone to a much higher percentage of the city than the
proposed 10% of city land currently allocated for this purpose.
5903-1 Gillian Magerkorth magerkorth@xtra.co.nz RPS Urban growth
B2.6 Public open space and
recreation facilities
Provide for open space and recreation in areas where intensification will occur, in particular, in
the Lynfield area bordered by White Swan Road, Hillsborough Road, Cape Horn Road,
Gilletta.
5903-2 Gillian Magerkorth magerkorth@xtra.co.nz RPS Urban growth
Provide for better public transport in areas where intensification will occur, in particular, in the
Lynfield area bordered by White Swan Road, Hillsborough Road, Cape Horn Road, Mount
Roskill.
5904-1 Barry Gibbon bandfgibbon@gmail.com RPS Urban growth
Amend the PAUP by incorporating the Waiuku Coastal Development Plan without any
changes.
5904-2 Barry Gibbon bandfgibbon@gmail.com
the CMA Mangroves
Appendix 6.6 Significant
wading bird areas
Retain the SEA-M for significant wading birds 32A Waiuku [refer to Appendix 6.6 Significant
wading bird areas].
the CMA
Disturbance of the foreshore
and seabed include associated
discharges of contaminants I6.1.4 Activity table
Amend the rules to delete the 1996 date for mangroves and enable any photographic
evidence about pre-mangrove infestation to be used as the basis for mangrove removal in
consultation with the local boards.
5904-4 Barry Gibbon bandfgibbon@gmail.com General Miscellaneous Other Amend the consent process for mangrove removal so that it is simple and consistent.
the CMA
Dredging include associated
discharge of contaminants I6.1.3 Activity table
Amend sediment removal provisions so sediment can be removed back to the areas previous
state, irrespective of the date, based on photographic [aerial photo] evidence.
5904-6 Barry Gibbon bandfgibbon@gmail.com General Miscellaneous Other Amend the consent process for sediment removal so that it is simple and consistent.
5904-7 Barry Gibbon bandfgibbon@gmail.com General Miscellaneous Other Amend the consent process for pacific oyster removal so that it is simple and consistent.
the CMA
Use, activities, development
and occupation I6.1.9 Activity table Amend the rules to make pacific oyster removal a permitted activity.
5904-9 Barry Gibbon bandfgibbon@gmail.com General Miscellaneous Other
Amend the rules for pacific oyster removal so decisions on issuing consents is given to the
Manukau Harbour Forum.
5904-10 Barry Gibbon bandfgibbon@gmail.com General Miscellaneous Other Amend the rules for mangrove removal in consultation with the Manukau Harbour Forum.
5904-11 Barry Gibbon bandfgibbon@gmail.com General Miscellaneous Other Amend the rules for sediment removal in consultation with the Manukau Harbour Forum.
5904-12 Barry Gibbon bandfgibbon@gmail.com RPS Coastal B7 Strategic
Amend the PAUP to recognise that the Manukau Harbour has been neglected and abused
in comparison to the Waitamata Harbour and that the plan must actively promote harbour
recovery with money spent on facilities, harbour transport options and tourist to
harbour and harbour surrounds must be encouraged.
5904-13 Barry Gibbon bandfgibbon@gmail.com General Miscellaneous Other
Amend the PAUP to give the Manukau Harbour Forum the power and resources to implement
change and bring the whole harbour back to good condition.
11/1145
Sub#/
Amend to the PAUP to ensure there are resources to maintain and install a) harbour
navigation aids b) wharfs and jettys c) capability for water passenger services. See page 3/5
of the submission for detail.
5904-15 Barry Gibbon bandfgibbon@gmail.com Water
policies
management
Amend the PAUP to ensure that run off provisions apply to both rural and urban run off. See
page 3/5 of the submission for detail.
5905-1 Mike and Margie Dutton mdutton2010@gmail.com Precincts - West Birdwood
Amend Birdwood Precinct Plan Subdivison controls and assessment criteria 3. Assessment -
Subdivision to provide for further subdivision of properties where geotechnical assessment
can demonstrate safe building sites, associated access and stormwater mitigation in
accordance with the Countryside and Foothills Stormwater Management Code of Practice
5906-1 Bob Demler bartlett@shortlandchambers.co.nz Zoning South
Rezone the area around Pukekohe that has been zoned for for urban activities and uses
especially the Future Urban zone (as shown on the Urban Grid Plan 61 and the Rural Grid
Plans 17 and 21) to either the operative zone or another appropriate rural zone.
5907-1 Mike Sparke mike.sparke@newcomb.co.nz Zoning West Reduce intensification within the Te Atatu Peninsula
5907-2 Mike Sparke mike.sparke@newcomb.co.nz General Miscellaneous Consultation and engagement Reject the speed of notification
5907-3 Mike Sparke mike.sparke@newcomb.co.nz RPS Mana Whenua B5 Strategic Reject the unelected control this plan gives to Mana Whenua
5908-1 Anthony McBride anthonypmcbride@gmail.com General Whole Plan
Decline the PAUP due to size of the plan, length of submission period
and inconsistency with the Local Government Act 2002.
5909-1 Lauren Hawken lauren@urbanplanning.co.nz Precincts - Central Saint Heliers K2.19.Precinct Rules Amend 3.3(1) Maximum Height controls to 8.5 m.
5909-2 Lauren Hawken lauren@urbanplanning.co.nz Precincts - Central Saint Heliers K2.19.Precinct Rules Amend Activity Table to make development that exceeds 8.5 m a Non Complying activity.
5910-1 Gary Westbury garyjwestbury@xtra.co.nz RPS Mana Whenua B5 Strategic
Delete "all references, controls and privileges that relate to Iwi or any other group that is
racially biased".
5911-1 Tim Baker chriskits@gmail.com Zoning North and Islands
Rezone Lot 2 DP 202561 at 0.201 Ha (141 Goat Island Road, Leigh) from Public Open Space
Sport and Active Recreation
5911-2 Tim Baker chriskits@gmail.com Zoning North and Islands
Rezone Lot 1 DP 202561 at 55.3635 Ha (109-123 Goat Island Road, Leigh) from Rural
Coastal to allow for additional housing lot developments
5911-3 Tim Baker chriskits@gmail.com Zoning North and Islands Use site specific zoning to provide for additional housing lot developments within the valley
5911-4 Tim Baker chriskits@gmail.com Special Character
Overlay - Business and
residential
Overlay E3.1 Bus. & Res.
special character areas
Add a special character area to protect and enhance the valley including some significant
ecological areas around Goat Island Road, Leigh. Refer to page 5/6 of the submission for
details.
5912-1 Mark and Karen Donnelly mark.donnelly@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central
Retain Single House zone between Balmoral Rd, Sandringham Rd, Mt Eden Road, Mt Eden
and New North Rd/Mt Eden Rd north, Mt Eden.
5912-2 Mark and Karen Donnelly mark.donnelly@xtra.co.nz Precincts Ak-Wide and Coastal Stadiums and Showgrounds K1.10 Precinct Rules Retain Sub-Precinct Eden Park provisions
5912-3 Mark and Karen Donnelly mark.donnelly@xtra.co.nz Public Open Space Zones
Special Purpose Zone Major
Recreation Facilities
I18.2-3 Land use &
Development controls Amend the Traffic Table 1 Threshold anticipated Crowd capacity for Eden Park to 5,000
5912-4 Mark and Karen Donnelly mark.donnelly@xtra.co.nz Residential zones Residential
D1.1 General objectives and
policies
Amend Auckland-wide objectives and policies with another Objective/Policy covering
protection and enhancement of residential amenity.
5912-5 Mark and Karen Donnelly mark.donnelly@xtra.co.nz Precincts Ak-Wide and Coastal Stadiums and Showgrounds K1.10 Precinct Rules Amend Temporary Activity to exclude Eden Park sub-precinct
5912-6 Mark and Karen Donnelly mark.donnelly@xtra.co.nz General Chapter G General provisions G2.4 Notification
Amend 2.4 Notification to ensure Restricted Discretionary activities use normal RMA
notification tests
5912-7 Mark and Karen Donnelly mark.donnelly@xtra.co.nz Residential zones Residential Land use controls
Amend rule 3.1 Maximum density, in the Mixed Housing Suburban zone for a site greater than
1200m
2
the minimu site size should be increased from 200m
2
to 400m
2
.
5912-8 Mark and Karen Donnelly mark.donnelly@xtra.co.nz Residential zones Residential Land use controls Delete unlimited density rule in Mixed Housing Urban zone for a site greater than 1200m
2
5912-9 Mark and Karen Donnelly mark.donnelly@xtra.co.nz
Centre) Business I3.3 Land use controls Amend Activities within 30m of a residential zone to change status to Discretionary
5912-10 Mark and Karen Donnelly mark.donnelly@xtra.co.nz Special Character
& C J3.3.1-7 Rules
Amend Activity table to change status for demolition from Restricted Discretionary to
Discretionary
5912-11 Mark and Karen Donnelly mark.donnelly@xtra.co.nz Special Character
& C J3.3.1-7 Rules Decline relocation and reuse of building as being part of assessment criteria
Rezone area Sangringham Rd, Sandringham from Rossmay Terrace south (both sides) to
Gribblehirst Rd from Mixed Housing Urban to Mixed Housing Suburban
5912-13 Mark and Karen Donnelly mark.donnelly@xtra.co.nz Built Environment (Overlays)
Height Control
Amend proposed Additional Height control for Eden Valley Local Centre to reduce from 12.5m
/ 3 storey to a maximum 10m / 2 storey
5912-14 Mark and Karen Donnelly mark.donnelly@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central Rezone Mixed Use, south from Prospect Terrace, East and West side to Brixton Rd, Mt Eden
5912-15 Mark and Karen Donnelly mark.donnelly@xtra.co.nz
Centre) Business
Park zones
Amend Mixed Use zone for Sandringham Road south from Prospect Terrace, East and West
side to Brixton Rd, Mt Eden by applying an Additional Height Control to maximum 10m / 2
storey
Rezone proposed Mixed Housing Urban and Mixed Use within the areas Balmoral Rd, west to
Sandringham, North to Kingsland, east to Mt Eden Road, Mt Eden, and north to New North
Road, instead applying a staged mechanism
12/1145
Sub#/
5913-1 Anurag Rasela anuragrasela@yahoo.com Zoning South
Rezone 87 Kolmar Road, Papatoetoe [from Mixed Housing Suburban] to either Terrace
Housing and Apartment Buildings or Mixed Housing Urban.
5913-2 Anurag Rasela anuragrasela@yahoo.com Zoning South
Rezone 57 Senator Drive, Manurewa [from Mixed Housing Suburban] to either
Mixed Housing Urban or Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings.
5914-1 Alaa Jaralla aj__007@hotmail.com General Chapter A Introduction A3 Strategic Framework Retain 3.5 Responding to climate change.
5914-2 Alaa Jaralla aj__007@hotmail.com Sustainable Development C7.7/H6.4 Sustainable design Retain objectives and policies that recognise and provide for solar energy.
5914-3 Alaa Jaralla aj__007@hotmail.com Rural Zones General I13.1 Activity table Add new activity for 'solar energy' in Rural zones with a permitted activity status.
5915-1 Aquaculture New Zealand rebecca@aquaculture.org.nz RPS Issues
B1.6 Sustainably managing
our coastal environment
Amend to recognise that some commercial activities such as shellfish aquaculture can help
improve coastal water quality.
5915-2 Aquaculture New Zealand rebecca@aquaculture.org.nz RPS
character and natural heritage
B4.3.1 Natural character of the
coastal environment
Amend Policy 5 to exempt existing uses and/or where an existing use right applies, so that it
does not apply to existing aquaculture activities located in overlay holes. Refer to submission
for details.
coastal environment Retain Policy 8 (b).
coastal environment Delete Policy 10.
B4.3.2 Landscape and natural
features
Amend Policy 4 so that aquaculture is treated as part of the working rural coastal landscape,
similar to rural production activities.
features
Amend Policy 8 so that it does not apply to existing uses and/or where an existing use right
applies.
character and natural heritage B4.3.4 Biodiversity Delete Policy 6.
character and natural heritage B4.3.4 Biodiversity Retain Policy 10.
character and natural heritage B4.3.4 Biodiversity
Delete Policy 14 (d) which seeks that activities be avoided where they will have more that a
minor adverse effect on the values identified for an SEA-Marine area.
Delete Policy 14 (i) which seeks to avoid activities which will result in a greater risk of access
and establishment of pest species.
Amend Policy 15 to allow the determination of what effects (including cumulative effects)
should be avoided, remedied or mitigated to be determined on a case by case basis. Refer to
submission for wording.
5915-12 Aquaculture New Zealand rebecca@aquaculture.org.nz RPS Coastal
B7.1 Subdivision, use &
development - coastal
environment Retain Chapter 7.1 in its entirety.
5915-13 Aquaculture New Zealand rebecca@aquaculture.org.nz
Land fill, clean fill and
managed fill
Land fill, clean fill, and
managed fill C5.5/G2.7.7/H4.4
Amend sections 5.5, 5.8, 5.9, 5.11 and any further appropriate sections in Chapter C5 to
provide consistent recognition of the need to consider the downstream effects of activities on
water quality in the CMA, similar to Objective 1 (C 5.5): 'Cleanfills, managed fills and landfills
are located, designed and operating... in a way that does not adversely affect the
environment, including water and the CMA.'
5915-14 Aquaculture New Zealand rebecca@aquaculture.org.nz Water Wastewater
C5.16 On site wastewater
objectives & policies
Amend Objective 2 and policies 1 (b) and 2 (a) to provide sufficient protection for aquaculture,
by requiring that adverse effects on the life-supporting capacity of ecosystems, public health
and the quality of water utilised for recreation, commercial activities, or food gathering are
avoided. Refer to submission for wording.
the CMA Discharges
D5.1.10 - D5.1.12 Background,
objectives and policies Retain Chapter 5.1.10 in its entirety.
the CMA Discharges
objectives and policies Retain Chapter 5.1.11 in its entirety.
the CMA
and occupation
D5.1.13 Background,
objectives and policies Retain the policy not to include coastal occupation charges at this time.
5915-18 Aquaculture New Zealand rebecca@aquaculture.org.nz General Miscellaneous Consultation and engagement
Seeks substantial consultation with the aquaculture industry if coastal occupation charges are
considered at a later date.
the CMA
Aquaculture include associated
discharge of contaminants
D5.1.14 Background,
Amend the Background to state that aquaculture in Auckland is to be enabled and to clarify
that aquaculture (particularly established aquaculture) is provided for in areas of high
environmental value, and will be located in areas where other types of development are
discouraged. Refer to submission for details.
the CMA
D5.1.14 Background,
Delete the reference to 'where appropriate' in Objective 1: "The cultural, social and economic
benefits of aquaculture are recognised, and aquaculture is developed in appropriate locations
that avoid, or where appropriate minimise, conflicts with other uses and values of the CMA.'
the CMA
D5.1.14 Background,
Amend Objective 2 to recognise the need to provide for established aquaculture: 'Established
aquaculture is provided for and is not compromised by other uses or activities that degrade
water quality.'
13/1145
Sub#/
the CMA
D5.1.14 Background,
objectives and policies Retain Objective 3.
the CMA
D5.1.14 Background,
objectives and policies Retain Policy 1.
the CMA
D5.1.14 Background,
objectives and policies Delete Policy 2.
the CMA
D5.1.14 Background,
the CMA
D5.1.14 Background,
Amend Policy 4 so that it is not overly restrictive in managing the effects of aquaculture
activities on overlay areas: 'Require that aquaculture activities be located and/or designed to
minimise to the extent practicable avoid adverse effects on the significant values of...'.Refer to
submission for details.
the CMA
D5.1.14 Background,
Amend Policy 5 so that it is not overly restrictive in managing the effects of aquaculture
activities on other uses and values: 'Require that aquaculture activities be located
and/or designed to minimise to the extent practicable avoid adverse effects on the significant
values of.... f. highly used areas for public access, particularly to highly used areas '. Refer to
the CMA
D5.1.14 Background,
the CMA
D5.1.14 Background,
Amend Policy 7 to recognise that resource consents for aquaculture need to be obtained
before land based facilities due to the uncertainty of whether consent will be granted. Refer to
the CMA
D5.1.14 Background,
the CMA
D5.1.14 Background,
Amend Policy 9 to remove the no cumulative effects threshold: 'Consider aquaculture to be
more appropriate when located in areas where it consolidates existing aquaculture activities of
like-species and like-farming methods, and where this will not result in adverse cumulative
effects. provided that potential opportunities to maintain biosecurity are not compromised'.
the CMA
D5.1.14 Background,
the CMA
D5.1.14 Background,
Add a new policy: 'To enable the continued operation and appropriate extension of
established aquaculture.'
the CMA
Amend to make the re-consenting of an existing marine farm a controlled activity (rather than
a restricted discretionary activity) in the General Coastal Marine zone. Refer to table 1.8 pg
22/30 of submission.
the CMA
Amend to make the re-consenting, extension or repositioning of an existing marine farm within
an overlay a [restricted] discretionary activity. Refer to table 1.8 pg 22/30 of submission.
the CMA
Amend to make new aquaculture a discretionary activity in overlay areas, rather than a
prohibited activity in SEA-M1, ONC and ONF-Type A1 and A areas, and a non-complying
activity in SEA-M2, HNC and ONL areas. Refer to table 1.8 pg 22/30 of submission.
the CMA
Add a notification section directing that applications to re-consent established aquaculture
activities will be considered on a non-notified basis. Refer to submission for details.
I6.4 - I6.6 Assessment and
Special information
requirements
Add as matters of control for the re-consenting of existing aquaculture activities; a. location
and extent; b. effects on coastal processes, ecological values, water quality and natural
character; c. effects on public access, navigation and safety; d. effects on existing uses and
activities; e. consent duration and monitoring.
Special information
requirements
Add assessment criteria for the re-consenting of an existing marine farm. Refer to submission
for details.
14/1145
Sub#/
Special information
requirements
Amend the matters of discretion so they are specific to aquaculture activities (not in addition
to the matters listed): a. location and extent; b. effects on coastal processes, ecological
values, water quality and natural character; c. effects on public access, navigation and safety;
d. effects on existing uses and activities; e. where applicable the effects on Mana Whenua
overlays; f. consent duration and monitoring. Refer to submission for details.
Special information
requirements
Amend the assessment criteria to be specific to aquaculture activities (not in addition to
general assessment criteria). Refer to submission for details.
5915-42 Aquaculture New Zealand rebecca@aquaculture.org.nz Mana Whenua General provisions
assessment
Add a section stating that a Cultural Impact Assessment will not be required for applications to
renew or extend an existing marine farm unless the application is to extend into a Mana
Whenua overlay.
Outstanding Natural
Rules
Outstanding Natural
Landscapes
Amend the overlay description to state that existing marine farm(s) within the overlays form
part of the existing environment to which the overlay applies.
Outstanding Natural
Rules
Appendix 6.2 Sch. of
Character - Coastal
Amend the overlay description to state that existing marine farm(s) within the overlays form
part of the existing environment to which the overlay applies.
5915-45 Aquaculture New Zealand rebecca@aquaculture.org.nz RPS Coastal B7 Strategic
Amend the holes providing for existing marine farms in overlays to allow for a moderate
extension of each farm without it encroaching into an overlay area and to ensure that all
established aquaculture activities have been provided for. Refer to submission for details.
5915-46 Aquaculture New Zealand rebecca@aquaculture.org.nz RPS Issues
Recognise the future potential growth of aquaculture as key to the viability of a dynamic,
responsive industry delivering increasing regional, social and economic benefits to Auckland.
5916-1
Elise H Burridge and Simon L
Jennings ehburridge@xtra.co.nz
control
Building demolition control J.3.6 Rules and mapping Delete pre-1944 demolition control at Eastern Beach and Bucklands Beach.
5917-1 Amanda Parkes amanda.parkes@gmail.com Mana Whenua
Whenua
and policies
Delete the Sites and Places of Significance and Value to Mana Whenua, undertake proper
consultation, redraft the provisions and remap the genuine sites showing accurate location.
5917-2 Amanda Parkes amanda.parkes@gmail.com RPS Urban growth
land for urban development Retain the exclusion of provisions relating to windfall gains on rezoned land.
5918-1 Lambert Hoogeveen lamberth@clear.net.nz Precincts Ak-Wide and Coastal Stadiums and Showgrounds
F1.10 Precinct Description,
Objectives and Policies Retain the rules for Stadiums and Showgrounds - Sub-precinct - Eden Park.
5918-2 Lambert Hoogeveen lamberth@clear.net.nz Precincts Ak-Wide and Coastal Stadiums and Showgrounds K1.10 Precinct Rules
Amend Sub-precinct - Eden Park so that all the existing consent restrictions are included with
no additional activities or change in activity status or notification.
5918-3 Lambert Hoogeveen lamberth@clear.net.nz Precincts Ak-Wide and Coastal Stadiums and Showgrounds K1.10 Precinct Rules
Amend Temporary Activity rules to exempt the Stadiums and Showgrounds Sub-Precinct -
Eden Park.
5918-4 Lambert Hoogeveen lamberth@clear.net.nz General Chapter G General provisions G2.4 Notification
Amend notification so that the default for restricted discretionary activities is not non-
notification.
5919-1 Stuart Callender stuart@wynyardwood.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - Rural zones
area
Amend subdivision rules to enable owners of land that is subject to an SEA to subdivide
through title creation (not just transferable rights), in the same manner as under the Auckland
District Plan (Rodney Section).
5920-1 Vivre Lokes vivrel@gmail.com RPS
Transport B3.3 Transport Amend to encourage better mixed transport options.
5920-2 Vivre Lokes vivrel@gmail.com RPS Issues
B1.3 Protecting historic
heritage, spec.character & nat.
heritage Encourage preservation of historical buildings
5920-3 Vivre Lokes vivrel@gmail.com General Miscellaneous Other Require a warrant of fitness for rental properties
5920-4 Vivre Lokes vivrel@gmail.com RPS Urban growth
quality compact urban form Require proper infrastructure for higher density living
5920-5 Vivre Lokes vivrel@gmail.com General Miscellaneous
Operational/
Projects/Acquisition Retain the City Rail Link
5921-1 Bruce and Donn Tomlinson brucemichtam@gmail.com
Outstanding Natural Features
(ONF) Rules
Appendix 3.1 - Schedule for
the Outstanding Natural
Features Overlay
Delete Outstanding Natural Feature ID 48, Hoteo hogback bluffs and unconformity from Lots
1,2 and 3 DP430859 Oldfield Road, Hoteo North.
5921-2 Bruce and Donn Tomlinson brucemichtam@gmail.com Subdivision Auckland-wide - Rural zones
area
Amend rural subdivision controls to include provisions in the Operative Auckland Council
District Plan (Rodney Section) 2011. Which provide for the creation of new sites by protecting
significant natural areas.
15/1145
Sub#/
5922-1 Matthew Buckeridge matt@windowslive.com Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula K5.11 Precinct rules
Amend the rules to reduce the level of intensification in sub-precinct B (including all sub-
precincts).
5922-2 Matthew Buckeridge matt@windowslive.com General Miscellaneous Consultation and engagement
Require more community consultation and mechanisms to ensure the provision of necessary
infrastructure in Devonport.
5923-1 Jann Hurley jann@hurleyarchitect.co.nz Zoning South Rezone the bulk of Pukekohe township from Mixed Housing Suburban to Single house zone.
5923-2 Jann Hurley jann@hurleyarchitect.co.nz RPS Urban growth
quality compact urban form Require improved public transport prior to intensification in Pukekohe.
5923-3 Jann Hurley jann@hurleyarchitect.co.nz Zoning South
Limit intensification to the area within walking distance of the Pukekohe town centre
and the railway station.
environment
Require adherence to the Urban Design Guidelines as the basis for future growth planning
across Auckland.
Require improvements to stormwater and sewerage systems prior to intensification in
Pukekohe.
5923-6 Jann Hurley jann@hurleyarchitect.co.nz RPS Urban growth B2.7 Social infrastructure
Require planning for new schools, particulary secondary
and intermediate schools, prior to future development in Pukekohe.
5923-7 Jann Hurley jann@hurleyarchitect.co.nz
Centre) Business
Provide for additional commercial land in Pukekohe to meet the needs of additional residential
development.
Provide clear boundaries for the Light Industrial zone around residential development in
Pukekohe.
5923-9 Jann Hurley jann@hurleyarchitect.co.nz Zoning South Rezone the land around the Pukekohe racecourse to commercial or light industrial use.
Delete provisions that allow for urban sprawl along State highway 22 from Pukekohe toward
Drury.
5923-11 Jann Hurley jann@hurleyarchitect.co.nz Precincts - South Pukekohe Hill
Require the further intensification of Pukekohe Hill to consider the strong community
attachments to the hill and retain its high visual amenity.
5923-12 Jann Hurley jann@hurleyarchitect.co.nz RPS Rural B8 Strategic
Ensure consideration of effects of loss of cropping and agricultural
land associated with residential development, and potential effects arising from adjacency of
residential land to cropping land.
5923-13 Jann Hurley jann@hurleyarchitect.co.nz Zoning South Provide for residential development on low-value agricultural land to the east of Pukekohe.
Require sub-regional strategic approach to growth of Pukekohe and surrounding Franklin
area, including use of a structure plan to guide staging with
relevant infrastructure developments.
5923-15 Jann Hurley jann@hurleyarchitect.co.nz Zoning Central
Rezone areas within walking distance of the Auckland CBD (e.g. Ponsonby, Grey Lynn,
Kingsland) to Mixed Housing Suburban.
5924-1 Harvey Norman david.haines@hainesplanning.co.nz General Chapter A Introduction A3 Strategic Framework
4/25].
5924-2 Harvey Norman david.haines@hainesplanning.co.nz General
5924-3 Harvey Norman david.haines@hainesplanning.co.nz Definitions Existing Clarify the 'Floodplain' definition that relies on the Flood Hazards non-statutory layer.
GIS viewer
layer.
5924-10 Harvey Norman david.haines@hainesplanning.co.nz RPS Urban growth
environment
submission. [p 5/25]
effect to the policy and rezone appropriately.
any one time.'
16/1145
Sub#/
5924-14 Harvey Norman david.haines@hainesplanning.co.nz RPS
Transport
B3.1 Commercial and
industrial growth
5924-15 Harvey Norman david.haines@hainesplanning.co.nz RPS
Transport
B3.1 Commercial and
industrial growth
5924-16 Harvey Norman david.haines@hainesplanning.co.nz Natural Hazards and Flooding Flooding
and policies
Amend the Background to clarify the the non-statutory Flood Hazards layer containing
overlays for Flood Sensitive Area, Flood Prone Area, Flood Plains, as stated in the
submission refer page 7/25.
GIS viewer
Review the accuracy of the overland flow path information and make it available in the Unitary
Plan maps.
5924-21 Harvey Norman david.haines@hainesplanning.co.nz
Centre) Business
Amend Objective 3 as adding a further clause as follows: 'Business activity is distributed in
locations, including out-of-centre locations, and is of a scale and form that:...(d) recognises
existing infrastructure and investment'.
Centre) Business
8/25].
Centre) Business
General objectives and policies Delete Policy 4 about equal physical access.
Centre) Business
General objectives and policies Delete Policy 6 about building adaptability.
Centre) Business
such a manner as to avoid adverse impact on pedestrian amenity and the streetscape.'.
Centre) Business
General objectives and policies Delete Policy 11 about wind glare and shading effects.
Centre)
desc, obs & pols
Amend the Description to recognise some additional retail activities, especially food based, as
permitted activities in the zone, as stated in the submission [refer page 11/25].
Centre)
desc, obs & pols
Amend the Description, third paragraph, as follows: '..expected to contribute to an active
street edge, while recognising the functional requirements of the activities.'
Centre)
desc, obs & pols
Amend Objective 2 as follows: 'Additional employment opportunities exist in a limited number
of areas which are located along identified growth corridors or close to City Centre,
Metropolitan and Town Centre zones, while ensuring activities within the zone do not detract
from the vitality and viability of these centres .'
Centre)
desc, obs & pols Delete Policy 4 about the location of small scale retail activities.
Centre)
desc, obs & pols
Amend Policy 5 as follows: 'Enable light industrial activities to locate within the zone but avoid
discourage activities which have objectionable odour, dust or noise emissions that cannot be
remedied or mitigated.'
Centre)
desc, obs & pols
Amend Policy 6, as follows: 'Manage compatibility issues of activities within and between
consent.'
Centre)
desc, obs & pols
5924-34 Harvey Norman david.haines@hainesplanning.co.nz General Chapter G General provisions G2.4 Notification
5924-35 Harvey Norman david.haines@hainesplanning.co.nz General Chapter G General provisions G2.4 Notification Delete all notification provisions that set a more stringent requirement than the RMA.
5924-36 Harvey Norman david.haines@hainesplanning.co.nz General Chapter G General provisions
statements
statements
17/1145
Sub#/
statements
5924-39 Harvey Norman david.haines@hainesplanning.co.nz Transport Auckland -wide
requirements Delete Rule 3.1(1) Traffic Generation, Table 1, total 'Retail' threshold of 500m2.
requirements
Amend Rule 3.1(1), so that it does not apply in the General Business and Mixed Use zone, as
stated in the submission [refer page 15/25].
requirements
45m2 GFA.
requirements
Amend Rule 3.2(2), Table 5 to require retail activities greater than 3000m2 to provide cycle
parking rate of 1 per 1000m2 for visitors and 1 per 800m2 for staff (secure).
5924-43 Harvey Norman david.haines@hainesplanning.co.nz Earthworks H4.2.1.1 Activity table - Zones
Amend the 'rp/dp' [second] activity table, under the sub heading General earthworks not
expressly either permitted or requiring resource consent above in this table, to provide for
earthworks in business and residential zones up to 5000m2 and 5000m3 as permitted.
5924-44 Harvey Norman david.haines@hainesplanning.co.nz Natural Hazards and Flooding Flooding H4.12 Rules
5924-45 Harvey Norman david.haines@hainesplanning.co.nz Natural Hazards and Flooding Flooding H4.12 Rules
Amend the activity table under the sub heading Activities within overland flow paths, by
changing the activity status of 'Any buildings or structures, including retaining walls but
excluding permitted fences) located within or over an overland flow path' from discretionary to
Centre) Business
& Bus. Park zones Retain the activity status of 'Food and Beverage' in the General Business zone as permitted.
Centre) Business
& Bus. Park zones Retain the activity status of 'Commercial services' in the General Business zone as permitted.
Centre) Business
& Bus. Park zones
Retain the activity status of 'Internal alterations to buildings' in the General Business zone as
permitted.
Centre) Business
& Bus. Park zones
Retain the activity status of 'Retail up to 200m2' in the General Business zone as
discretionary.
Centre) Business
& Bus. Park zones
discretionary.
Centre) Business
& Bus. Park zones
Retain the activity status of 'Offices up to 500m2 GFA per site' in the General Business zone
as permitted.
Centre) Business
& Bus. Park zones
Amend the activity status of 'Offices greater than 500m2 GFA per site' in the General
Business zone from discretionary to restricted discretionary.
Centre) Business
& Bus. Park zones
Amend the activity status of 'Retail greater than 450m2' in the General Business zone from
restricted discretionary to permitted.
Centre) Business
Special information
requirements
Delete the 6.1(2) Matters of discretion and 6.2(2) Assessment Criteria so far as they relate to
the General Business zone.
Centre) Business
& Bus. Park zones
Amend activity class as follows: 'Alterations to building facades that are less than: 1 50 per
cent of its total surface area, or 50015 m whichever is the greater lesser - permitted.'
Centre) Business
& Bus. Park zones
Amend the activity class as follows: 'Additions to buildings that are less than: 1 50per cent of
the existing GFA of the building, or 2 500m whichever is the lesser greater - permitted.'
Centre) Business
& Bus. Park zones
discretionary to permitted in centres, Mixed Use, General Business, Business Park zones.
18/1145
Sub#/
Centre) Business
Park zones
metres only.
Centre) Business
Park zones Retain Rule 4.2 Building height for the General Business zone being 16.5m.
Centre) Business
Park zones Amend Rule 4.2 Building height so that height in the General Business zone is increased.
Centre) Business
Park zones
zone. Refer to submission for proposed changes on 21/25.
Centre) Business
Park zones Amend Rule 4.7 Buildings Entrances so it does not apply in the General Business zone.
Centre) Business
Centre) Business
Special information
requirements
Delete Rule 10 Special Information requirements, about the requirement for design
statements.
Centre) Business
Park zones
Amend Rule 4.9(c) Glazing so it does not apply in the General Business zone. Refer to
submission for proposed changes on p 23/25.
Centre) Business
Park zones
Delete Rule 4.12 Ground floor at street frontage level, about the location of building
entrances.
Centre) Business
Park zones
Centre) Business
Park zones
Centre) Business
Park zones
Add new Rule 4.18(3) as follows: 'Maximum impervious area in the Business Park zone: 80
per cent.'
Centre) Business
Special information
requirements
Centre) Business
Special information
requirements
number 71].
5924-73 Harvey Norman david.haines@hainesplanning.co.nz Definitions Existing Retain definition of 'Large format retail'.
5924-74 Harvey Norman david.haines@hainesplanning.co.nz Zoning North and Islands
Retain General Business zoning at 24 Croftfield Lane, Wairau Park. [Refer to p 3/25 of
submission for map]
5925-1 Karaka North Village Limited rwallace@wallacegroup.co.nz Zoning South
Rezone the land zoned Mixed Housing Suburban within the Karaka North precinct to Mixed
Housing Urban as shown in Map 1, Appendix 3 on page 19/21 of the submission.
5925-2 Karaka North Village Limited rwallace@wallacegroup.co.nz RPS Changes to the RUB South
Rezone Lots 6, 7, 8 and 13 DP158573 within the Karaka North Village from Rural Coastal to
Single House as shown in Map 1, Appendix 3 on page 19/21 of the submission.
5925-3 Karaka North Village Limited rwallace@wallacegroup.co.nz Precincts - South Karaka 2
Extend the extent of the Karaka North Village precinct [inferred the Karaka 2 precinct] to
include Lots 1-8 and 14-18 DP15872 as shown on Map 2, Appendix 3 on page 20/21 of the
submission.
Separate the precinct into 3 sub-precincts as shown on Map 2, Appendix 3 on page 20/21 of
the submission.
Amend the precinct plan [in K6.9.9] to show the boundary changes requested in this
submission and to remove the 'riparian enhancement, stormwater management, protection
and maintenance covenants' as shown on Map 3, Appendix 3 on page 21/21 of this
submission.
5925-6 Karaka North Village Limited rwallace@wallacegroup.co.nz Mana Whenua
Whenua
Remove the overlay from the land owned by KNVL at the Karaka North Village which is
bounded by the Whangamaire Stream to the west, Linwood Road to the south and Dyke
Road, Karaka to the east. [Specific sites not identified]
19/1145
Sub#/
5925-7 Karaka North Village Limited rwallace@wallacegroup.co.nz General
GIS viewer
Remove the Flood Prone Area (1per cent AEP) and Flood Plain (1 per cent AEP) from
the land owned by KNVL at the Karaka North Village which is bounded by the Whangamaire
Stream to the west, Linwood Road to the south and Dyke Road, Karaka to the east. [Specific
sites not identified]
5925-8 Karaka North Village Limited rwallace@wallacegroup.co.nz Natural Hazards and Flooding Flooding H4.12 Rules
Delete the Flood Prone Area (1 per cent AEP) and Flood Plain (1 per cent AEP) rules from
the land owned by KNVL at the Karaka North Village which is bounded by the Whangamaire
Stream to the west, Linwood Road to the south and Dyke Road, Karaka to the east. [Specific
sites not identified]
5925-9 Karaka North Village Limited rwallace@wallacegroup.co.nz Precincts - South Karaka 2 Amend the precinct name from Karaka 2 to Karaka North Village.
Amend the Description to reflect zone and name changes requested in this submission and to
strengthen the focus of a rural village. Refer to page 9/21 of the submission for details.
Amend Objective 1 [in F6.9] to strengthen the desired outcome of achieving a rural village
settlement and to recognise the importance of areas of open space. Refer to page 9/21 of the
Add a new objective [to F6.9] to achieve a rural village settlement that is different from
conventional urban settlement and reflects a traditional New Zealand rural settlement. Refer
to page 9/21 of the submission for details.
Amend Objective 2 [in F6.9] to strengthen the rural village character through landscape
planting. Refer to page 10/21 of the submission for details.
Amend Objective 3 [in F6.9] to specify that it relates to servicing the Karaka North Village
rather than a general reference to community. Refer to page 10/21 of the submission for
details.
Amend Objective 4 [in F6.9] to qualify that development should only enhance the public realm
where possible. Refer to page 10/21 of the submission for details.
Add a new objective [to F6.9] to enable the use of Framework Plans to develop the precinct.
Refer to page 10/21 of the submission for details.
Amend Policy 1 [in F6.9] to ensure residential development contributes to the rural village
character. Refer to page 10/21 of the submission for details.
Amend Policy 2 [in F6.9] to provide for the use of a framework plan. Refer to page 11/21 of
the submission for details.
Amend Policy 3 [in F6.9] to improve the readability of the policy and to clarify that it relates to
tributary streams and associated riparian areas. Refer to page 11/21 of the submission for
details.
Add a new policy [to F6.9] to achieve a rural village settlement that is different from
conventional urban settlement and to give effect to the new objective requested in this
submission. Refer to pages 9 and 11/21 of the submission for details..
Amend Policy 4 [in F6.9] to give effect to amendments requested in this submission that seek
a greater focus on delivering a rural village. Refer to pages 9-11/21 of the submission for
details.
Amend Policy 5 [in F6.9] to improve readability and to promote rather than require active
building frontages orientated to Linwood and Dyke Roads. Refer to page 11/21 of the
Add a new policy [to F6.9] to provide for a mix of activities and open space areas that can be
used for events and market related activities Refer to page 12/21 of the submission for
details.
Amend Policy 6 [in F6.9] to encourage the use of a village square as a focal point within each
sub-precinct rather than the requirement to provide a village square. Refer to page 12/21 of
Amend Policy 7 [in F6.9] to focus on delivering a rural village character that is different from
conventional urban settlement and reflects a traditional New Zealand rural settlement. Refer
Amend Policy 9 [in F6.9] to avoid on-site wastewater disposal rather than to avoid large sites
and self services individual sites. Refer to page 12/21 of the submission for details.
Amend Policy 11 [in F6.9] to 'Avoid multiple small scale wastewater treatment and disposal
systems within each sub-precinct.'
Amend Policy 12 [in F6.9] to 'encourage' rather than 'require' integrated stormwater
management using sensitive design techniques. Refer to page 13/21 of the submission for
details.
Amend Policy 13 [in F6.9] to only require the development of the road network to have regard
to the specified roading typologies rather than to be in accordance with them. Refer to page
13/21 of the submission for details.
20/1145
Sub#/
Add a new policy [to F6.9] to encourage the use of framework plans prior to subdivision within
sub-precincts A and B. Refer to page 13/21 of the submission for details and the map on page
20/21 of the submission for sub-precinct boundaries.
Add a new policy [to F6.9] to encourage consultation with landowners within and between sub-
precincts when preparing a framework plan. Refer to page 13/21 of the submission for details.
Amend K6.9.1 Activity Table as follows: 'Subdivision not proposing a connection to a
centralised wastewater system for the Karaka 2 precinct .
Add a new rule to K6.9.1 Activity Table to provide for 'Any subdivision complying with the
subdivision controls of this precinct and an approved framework plan' is a controlled activity in
sub-precincts A and B and not applicable in sub-precinct C. Refer to page 14/21 of the
submission and the map on page 20/21 of the submission to show the sub-precinct
boundaries as requested in this submission.
Add a new rule to K6.9.1 Activity Table to provide for A framework plan, amendments to an
approved framework plan or a replacement framework plan complying with clause 3A.
'Framework Plans' as a Restricted Discretionary Activity in sub-precincts A and B and not
applicable in sub-precinct C. Refer to pages 14, 18 and the map on page 20/21 to show the
sub-precinct boundaries as requested in this submission.
Add a new rule to K6.9.1 Activity Table to provide for A framework plan, amendments to an
approved framework plan or a replacement framework plan not complying with clause 3A.
'Framework Plans' as a Discretionary Activity in sub-precincts A and B and not applicable in
sub-precinct C. Refer to pages 15 and 18/21 of the submission for details.
Amend Rule K6.9 3.1 'Maximum density' to change '1 dwelling per 300m
2
' to the Mixed
Housing Urban, rather than Mixed Housing Suburban zone and to change 1 dwelling per
800m
2
to 1 dwelling per 600m
2
in the Single House zone. Refer to page 15/21 of the
Amend Rule K6.9.4.2 'New community, commercial and residential buildings' (1) to provide for
a centralised wastewater system in each of the 3 sub-precincts proposed in this submission
rather than 1 centralised system for the whole precinct. Refer to page 15/21 and to the map
on page 20/21 of the submission for the sub-precinct boundaries.
Amend Rule K6.9.5.1 'Minimum site size' (1)(a) and (b) to change the minimum net site areas
from 300m
2
for the Mixed Housing Suburban to 300m
2
for the Mixed Housing Urban zone and
from 800m
2
to 600m
2
for the Single House zone. Refer to page 15/21 of the submission for
details.
Amend Rule K6.9.6.2 'Wastewater Servicing' clause (1) to provide for one wastewater
treatment and disposal treatment per sub-precinct rather than 1 for the whole precinct and
clause (2) to change the name of the precinct as requested in this submission. Refer to page
16/21 of the submission and the map on page 20/21 for the sub-precinct boundaries.
Add new matters of control and assessment criteria for controlled activities in relation to
consistency with an approved framework plan, the rural village character and the provision of
efficient and effective infrastructure. Refer to page 16/21 of the submission for details.
Add new matters of discretion and assessment criteria for framework plans as a restricted
discretionary activity including the requirement where possible for consultation with all
landowners in and within sub-precincts, consistency with a precinct plan and the precinct
objectives and polices and to provide a rural village character reminiscent of historic rural New
Zealand settlements and a landscape design that fits with the surrounding landscape. Refer to
page 17/21 of the submission for details.
Add a new rule '3A. Framework Plans' to rule 8 'Special information requirements' to include
requirements relating to the area it should apply to, consent for earthworks, the design and
location of public open spaces and roads, stormwater management devices, vehicular
accessways, and development control infringements. Refer to page 18/21 of the submission
for details.
5926-1
John Martens and Anna
Meiklejohn martensj@orcon.net.nz Special Character
Overlay Special character -
General
J3.5.7 Maps, App. 10.2 Spec.
character statement - General Amend the overlay at 51 Peary Road to be character supporting, not character defining
5927-1
Kensington Park Holdings
Limited cwong@bentley.co.nz Zoning North and Islands
Rezone Kensington Park, Orewa [near the northern end of Centreway Road, Orewa, as
shown in map in submission on p 12/36] from Mixed Housing Urban and Single House to
Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings.
5927-2
Rezone Lot 7 DP 395329 [being a small area of public open space within Kensington Park,
Orewa, between Kensington Drive and Parkside Drive, as shown in map in submission on p
13/36] from Public Open Space - Sport and Active Recreation to Public Open Space -
Informal Recreation.
21/1145
Sub#/
5927-3
Rezone various areas of Mixed Housing Urban Land within Kensington Park, Orewa, [near
the northern end of Centreway Road, Orewa] to Public Open Space - Informal Recreation.
Refer to map showing these areas, in submission on p 13/36.
5927-4
Limited cwong@bentley.co.nz Water
C5.14/H4.13Lakes, rivers
streams & wetland
management area overlays
H4.13.1 Introduction & Activity
table
Delete the Indicative Stream overlay from the Kensington Park site, Orewa, [near the northern
end of Centreway Road, Orewa] and move the alignment of the overlay to the centreline of
Nukumea Stream.
5927-5
Limited cwong@bentley.co.nz
SEAs
Land
Delete the SEA overlay T6652b identified in Lot 10 DP 460629 [being part of Kensington Park
site, Orewa, near the northern end of Centreway Road, Orewa].
5927-6
Limited cwong@bentley.co.nz Precincts - North Orewa 1
Delete the Masterplan (Precinct Plan 1) in its entirety and remove all consequential
references to it.
5927-7
Amend Orewa 1 Precinct Plan 2 as follows; so that it is called 'Orewa 1 Precinct Plan 1: Sub-
precincts'; so that the sub-precincts are reduced from 6 to 3; to reflect the land identified to be
public open space; and to provide for community facilities within the communal activity area
south of the existing Frank MacKereth Reserve. Refer to Schedule 2A on page 35/36 of
submission.
5927-8
Add new precinct plan titled 'Orewa 1 Precinct 2: Height Controls' and adopt the height
controls proposed in the precinct plan, which are between 9m and five storeys. See Schedule
2B on page 36/36 of submission and explanation on p16/36.
5927-9
Delete reference to 'Mixed Housing Urban and Single House ' and replace with 'Terrace
Housing and Apartment Buildings' throughout the precinct description, objectives and
policies.
5927-10
Amend Precinct description to reflect that future development of Kensington Park can be
managed by 3 sub-precincts rather than 6; and to remove reference to associated building
platforms and the Orewa Design Guidelines. Refer to submission for proposed changes. [p
17/36]
5927-11
Delete Objective 1.d. as follows; '1.d restrict the total number of dwellings to match the level
of infrastructure provided for the precinct '.
5927-12
Delete Objective 1.e. as follows; '1.e an integrated landscape theme that complements the
adjacent bush on Alice Eaves Scenic Reserve '.
5927-13
Amend Policy 1.a. as follows; 1. Require that the layout and development of the precinct is
consistent with the Orewa 1 Precinct Plan, including: a. a concentration of higher density
apartment housing in flatter areas on land with a more level gradient (predominantly sub-
precincts D, F and part of E B and C).
5927-14
Amend Policy 3 as follows; '3. Require that development achieves a cohesive architectural
style and character that is consistent with the Orewa Design Guidelines complementary to the
appreciable established characteristics of the existing built form within Kensington Park,
including...'.
5927-15
Delete Policy 1.d. as follows; '1.d. housing types, buildings platforms and building heights in
the building envelopes identified on the Orewa 1 Precinct Plan '.
5927-16
Delete Policy 4 as follows; '4. Design development and landscaping that is consistent with the
Orewa Design Guidelines and Orewa 1 Precinct Plan. '.
5927-17
Delete Policy 2 as follows; '2 . Apply a dwelling cap to ensure that development does not
exceed infrastructure capacity and maintains the spacious character of the precinct. '.
5927-18
Amend the Introduction to include the following; ' '5.30 Orewa 1 Kensington Park is a high
amenity residential community whose aesthetics and character have been foreshadowed by
development constructed to date. Higher density and height of built form has historically been
provided for and approved within this Precinct. The following provisions recognise the form
and pattern of development, and facilitate the completion of the development of the Precinct
in a consistent manner. '.
5927-19
Delete reference to 'Mixed Housing Urban and Single House ' and replace with 'Terrace
Housing and Apartment Buildings or Public Open Space _ Informal Recreation zone'
throughout the precinct rules.
5927-20
Amend heading row 2 of 1. Activity Table as follows; 'Sub-precincts A - E ; Sub-precinct F B;
Communal activity area in Sub-Precinct C '.
5927-21
Amend 1. Activity Table, first row under 'Development', as follows; 'New buildings complying
with Precinct Plan 1: Orewa 1 precinct '.
5927-22
Amend 1. Activity Table, third row under 'Development', to delete the entire row 'New
buildings not complying with Precinct Plan 1: Orewa 1 precinct ' and the associated activity
statuses.
5927-23
Amend 1. Activity Table, second row under 'Development', to delete the entire row 'Additions
and alterations complying with Precinct Plan 1: Orewa 1 precinct ' and the associated activity
statuses.
22/1145
Sub#/
5927-24
Amend 1. Activity Table, fourth row under 'Development', to delete the entire row 'Additions
and alterations not complying with Precinct Plan 1: Orewa 1 precinct ' and the associated
activity statuses.
5927-25
Delete land use control 2.1 Development cap, which limits the total number of dwellings in the
precinct.
5927-26
Delete development control 3.1 Development to be in accordance with Master Plan. [see
submission point 6 on p 15/36.
5927-27
Amend development control 3.2 Building height to delete existing rule and replace the text so
that; buildings do not exceed the maximum height shown in the proposed Orewa 1 Precinct
Plan 2: Height Control [see submission point 8 on p 16/36]; the method of determining height
and storeys are provided; and to confirm that buildings exceeding the nominated heights will
be a discretionary activity. Refer to submission for proposed changes. [p 23/36]
5927-28
Amend 3.3.1(2) Fences as follows; '2. No fences or walls must be located within a front yard
that is 1.8m of the front boundary or less in depth '.
5927-29
Amend 3.3.3(3) Garages as follows; '3. The total area of all attached or detached garage
doors or the open facade of a carport fronting the street must not occupy more than 35 per
cent of the active building frontage in any one precinct area along a single frontage '.
5927-30
Amend 3.4 Building coverage to delete Table 1 that provides maximum building coverage in
each sub-precinct, and replace it with the following; 'Maximum building coverage: 40 per
cent. '.
5927-31
Amend 3.4 Building coverage to add the following; 'Note: Building coverage is calculated over
the whole precinct and includes roads, as well as land zoned Public Open Space Informal
Recreation and Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings '.
5927-32
Amend 3.5 Height in relation to boundary to add new (2) that applies the height in relation to
boundary control from the operative district plan; and to make it clear that this applies instead
of development control 9.4 and 9.5 in the Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings zone.
Refer to submission for proposed changes [p 24/36]
5927-33
Amend 3.6 Impervious areas to delete (1) that provides maximum impervious areas in each
sub-precinct, and replace it with; 'Maximum impervious area: 60 per cent. '
5927-34
Amend 3.6 Impervious areas to add the following; ' Note: Impervious Area is calculated over
the whole precinct and includes roads, as well as land zoned Public Open Space Informal
Recreation and Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings ' .
5927-35
Amend the title of 3.7.1 as follows; 'Building block (within the residential area subject to the
9m height overlay shown on Precinct Plan 2: Orewa 1 precinct)'.
5927-36
Amend the title of 3.7.2 as follows; 'Building block (within the mixed use area southern
boundary Orewa 1 sub-precinct B shown on Precinct Plan 1: Orewa 1 precinct)'.
5927-37
Amend title of 3.7.3 as follows; 'Building block (within the remainder of the zone Orewa 1
precinct)' .
5927-38
Amend 3.7 Building block by adding the following text; 'Note: These provisions apply instead
of Development Control 9.13 Maximum building length in the Terrace Housing and Apartment
Buildings zone' .
5927-39
Delete 3.8 Visual amenity corridors, rule (3) as follows; 'Any activity that does not comply with
this rule is a noncomplying activity. '.
5927-40
Limited cwong@bentley.co.nz Precincts - North Orewa 1 Delete 3.9 'Street frontage (mixed use area)' in its entirety
5927-41
Amend 5.1(1) matter of discretion as follows; 'the nature and extent of built form
accommodating commercial activities and retail'.
5927-42
Amend 5.1(2) assessment criteria by adding the following criterion; ' The extent to which
commercial or retail activity in the ground floor of buildings provides for an active frontage
including such components as glazing; verandahs; and pedestrian amenities'.
5927-43
Limited cwong@bentley.co.nz Precincts - North Orewa 1 Delete subdivision control 4.1 Site size in its entirety.
5927-44
Limited cwong@bentley.co.nz Precincts - North Orewa 1 Delete subdivision control 4.3 Landscape plan in its entirety.
5927-45
Amend 5.1(1) matters of discretion as follows; 'For activities/development new buildings that
are a restricted discretionary activity in the Orewa 1 precinct, the following matters specified
for the relevant restricted discretionary activities in the relevant underlying Mixed Housing
Urban or Single House zone Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings zone: '.
5927-46
Amend 5.1(1) Matters of discretion by deleting the following; ' 1. the location, height and siting
and type of buildings constructed '.
5927-47
Amend 5.1(1) Matters of discretion by deleting the following; '3. impermeable surfaces and
stormwater '.
23/1145
Sub#/
5927-48
Limited cwong@bentley.co.nz Precincts - North Orewa 1 Amend 5.1(1) Matters of discretion by deleting the following; ' 6. servicing '.
5927-49
Amend 5.1(2) assessment criteria as follows; 'For activities/development new buildings that
are a restricted discretionary activity in the Orewa 1 precinct, the following assessment criteria
apply in addition to the criteria specified for the relevant restricted discretionary activities in
the relevant underlying Mixed Housing Urban or Single House zone Terrace Housing and
Apartment Buildings zone. '.
5927-50
Delete 5.1(2) assessment criteria (1) as follows; '1. The location, height and siting of buildings
should be consistent with Precinct Plan 1: Orewa 1 precinct and should not contrast with the
established pattern of development in the precinct. Consideration will be also be given to the
need to modulate or separate buildings into smaller groups and transitioning the form and
placement of buildings. '.
5927-51
Delete 5.1(2) assessment criteria (2) as follows; '2. Buildings should be contained within the
building platforms identified in Precinct Plan 1: Orewa 1 precinct. '.
5927-52
Delete 5.1(2) assessment criteria (3) as follows; '3. Buildings should be set back from precinct
boundaries in accordance with the setbacks shown on the Orewa 1 Precinct Plan'.
5927-53
Amend 5.1(2) assessment criteria (4) as follows; '4. The design and built form of buildings and
structures should be complementary with existing built form achieve the outcomes envisaged
in the Orewa Design Guidelines with particular consideration given to:... '.
5927-54
Delete 5.1(2) assessment criteria (6) as follows; '6. The overall landscape design and planting
of vegetation should include distinctive planting themes and integrate street tree planting with
reserves, the visual amenity corridors and stormwater areas. Compliance with any landscape
plan approved in accordance with clause 6 below should be achieved. '.
5927-55
Amend 5.1(2) assessment criteria (7) as follows; '7. The design of the extent to which the
location of buildings is consistent with the location of roads, reserves and visual amenity
corridors should be consistent within Precinct Plan 1: Orewa 1 precinct and Precinct Plan 2:
Orewa 1 precinct . Any deviations should be minor '.
5927-56
Delete 5.1(2) assessment criteria (8) as follows; '8. Any commercial and retail activities should
be of a small-scale and serve the needs of the immediate local community. These activities
should not detract from the economic viability of the Orewa town centre. '.
5927-57
Delete 5.1(2) assessment criteria (9) as follows; '9. Any additional dwellings or development
should not exceed the infrastructure capacity for water and wastewater.'.
5927-58
Delete 5.1(2) assessment criteria (11) as follows; ' 11. All applications for land use and
development should use best practice stormwater mitigation measure to minimise the adverse
effects on the Nukumuea stream catchment '.
5927-59
Delete 5.2(1) Matters of discretion for Subdivision control infringements, about subdivisions
not complying with site size. See submission for proposed changes. [p 30/36]
5927-60
Delete 5.2(3) Matters of discretion for Subdivision control infringements, about subdivisions
not complying with landscape plan. See submission for proposed changes. [p 30/36]
5927-61
Delete 5.2 Subdivision control infringements, criterion (1) that provides assessment criteria
about subdivisions not complying with site size. See submission for proposed changes. [p
30/36]
5927-62
Delete 5.2 Subdivision control infringements, criterion (3) that provides assessment criteria
about subdivisions not complying with landscape plan. See submission for proposed
changes. [p 30/36]
5927-63
Limited cwong@bentley.co.nz Precincts - North Orewa 1 Delete 6. Special information requirements in its entirety.
5927-64
Limited cwong@bentley.co.nz Mana Whenua General provisions
assessment
Delete 2.7.4(3) as follows; 'A cultural impact assessment will be required for a structure plan'.

5927-65
Limited cwong@bentley.co.nz Mana Whenua General provisions
assessment
Amend 2.7.4(4) so that the requirement for resource consents requiring cultural impact
assessments is limited to places specifically identified in the PAUP as being of iwi
significance. See submission for proposed changes. [p 32/36]
5927-66
Limited cwong@bentley.co.nz Residential zones Housing affordability
and policies Delete section in its entirety.
5927-67
Limited cwong@bentley.co.nz Residential zones Housing affordability H6.6 Rules Delete section in its entirety.
5927-68
Limited cwong@bentley.co.nz Sustainable Development C7.7/H6.4 Sustainable design
Amend Policy 3 to remove the prescriptive design elements in the policy. Refer to submission
for proposed changes. [p 33/36]
5927-69
Limited cwong@bentley.co.nz Sustainable Development C7.7/H6.4 Sustainable design Delete section in its entirety.
24/1145
Sub#/
5927-70
Limited cwong@bentley.co.nz Definitions Existing
Amend definition of 'Stormwater network' as follows; 'A system of stormwater pipes, open
channels, devices and associated ancillary structures operated by a public agency such as
the council or a network utility operator and used for the purpose of conveying, diverting,
storing, treating, or discharging stormwater. '.
5927-71
Limited cwong@bentley.co.nz Precincts - North Orewa 1 Delete the Orewa Design Guidelines appendix.
5928-1 Rod and Jane Twizell rod.t@orcon.net.nz RPS Urban growth
quality compact urban form Delete provisions that provide for intensification and keep existing density levels.
5929-1
Eden Park Neighbours'
Association Incorporated mark.donnelly@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central
Retain Single House zone between Balmoral Rd, Sandringham Rd, Mt Eden Road, Mt Eden
and New North Rd/Mt Eden Rd north, Mt Eden.
5929-2
Association Incorporated mark.donnelly@xtra.co.nz Precincts Ak-Wide and Coastal Stadiums and Showgrounds K1.10 Precinct Rules Retain Sub-Precinct Eden Park provisions
5929-3
Association Incorporated mark.donnelly@xtra.co.nz Public Open Space Zones
I18.2-3 Land use &
Development controls Amend the Traffic Table 1 Threshold anticipated Crowd capacity for Eden Park to 5,000
5929-4
Association Incorporated mark.donnelly@xtra.co.nz Residential zones Residential
policies
Amend Auckland-wide objectives and policies with other Objective/Policy covering protection
and enhancement of residential amenity.
5929-5
Association Incorporated mark.donnelly@xtra.co.nz General
H6.5) Exclude Eden Park sub-precinct from the application of these rules.
5929-6
Association Incorporated mark.donnelly@xtra.co.nz General Chapter G General provisions G2.4 Notification
Amend 2.4 Notification to ensure Restricted Discretionary activities use normal RMA
notification tests
5929-7
Association Incorporated mark.donnelly@xtra.co.nz Residential zones Residential Land use controls
Amend maximum density in Mixed Housing Suburban for a >1200m
2
site to increase
minimum site size from from 200m
2
to 400m
2
5929-8
Association Incorporated mark.donnelly@xtra.co.nz Residential zones Residential Land use controls Delete unlimited density rule in Mixed Housing Urban zone for a site greater than 1200m2.
5929-9
Association Incorporated mark.donnelly@xtra.co.nz
Centre) Business I3.3 Land use controls Amend 'Activities within 30m of a residential zone' to change status to Discretionary
5929-10
Association Incorporated mark.donnelly@xtra.co.nz Special Character
& C J3.3.1-7 Rules
Amend Activity table to change status for 'demolition' from Restricted Discretionary to
Discretionary
5929-11
Association Incorporated mark.donnelly@xtra.co.nz Special Character
& C J3.3.1-7 Rules Delete relocation and reuse of building as being part of assessment criteria
5929-12
Rezone area Sangringham Rd, Sandringham from Rossmay Terrace south (both sides) to
Gribblehirst Rd from Mixed Housing Urban to Mixed Housing Suburban
5929-13
Association Incorporated mark.donnelly@xtra.co.nz Built Environment (Overlays)
Height Control
Amend proposed Additional Height control for Eden Valley Local Centre to reduce from 12.5 /
3 storey to maximum 10m / 2 storey.
5929-14
Association Incorporated mark.donnelly@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central Rezone Mixed Use, south from Prospect Terrace, East and West side to Brixton Rd, Mt Eden.
5929-15
Association Incorporated mark.donnelly@xtra.co.nz Built Environment (Overlays)
Height Control
Amend Mixed Use zone for Sandringham Road south from Prospect Terrace, East and West
side to Brixton Rd, Mt Eden by applying an Additional Height Control to maximum 10m / 2
storey.
5929-16
Rezone proposed Mixed Housing Urban and Mixed Use within the areas Balmoral Rd, west to
Sandringham, North to Kingsland, east to Mt Eden Road, Mt Eden, and north to New North
Road, instead applying a staged mechanism after adequacy of infrastructure and demand is
determined.
5930-1 Robert G Kaye
44 Awa Street, Otahuhu, Auckland
1062 General Whole Plan No specific relief sought.
5931-1 Lynne Waterfield lynne.waterfield@actrix.co.nz Precincts Ak-Wide and Coastal Integrated Development
Require compulsory, publicly notified Framework plans for Integrated Developments e.g.
large residential developments by Housing New Zealand or other parties.
5931-2 Lynne Waterfield lynne.waterfield@actrix.co.nz Residential zones Residential
Special info. req.
Require Design statements (including Context Assessments) for developments of 4-15+
dwellings in Mixed Housing zones.
5931-3 Lynne Waterfield lynne.waterfield@actrix.co.nz
SEAs
H4.3 - H4.3.1.1 Intro./Activity
table - Vegetation
management in all zones and
roads
Provide for protection of native trees over 3m in height from alteration or removal within 20m
of MHWS as a restricted discretionary activity.
SEAs
table - Vegetation
roads
Provide for protection of areas of contiguous vegetation greater than 25m
2
within 20m of
MHWS as a restricted discretionary activity.
SEAs
table - Vegetation
roads
Retain the protection of vegetation from removal or alteration within 10m of urban streams as
a restricted discretionary activity.
Social infrastructure (Special
Purpose) D8.9/I23 School
D8.9 Background, objectives &
policies Retain the Special Purpose - School zone.
25/1145
Sub#/
Purpose) D8.10 & I24 Tertiary Education Retain the Special Purpose - Tertiary Education zone.
5931-8 Lynne Waterfield lynne.waterfield@actrix.co.nz Zoning Central Retain Special Purpose - Tertiary Education zone at 1 Carrington Road, Mt Albert (Unitec).
5931-9 Lynne Waterfield lynne.waterfield@actrix.co.nz Zoning Central Rezone Waterview from Mixed housing Urban to Mixed Housing Suburban zone.
5931-10 Lynne Waterfield lynne.waterfield@actrix.co.nz Precincts - Central New Precincts Northern Waterview
Add new Integrated development precinct for the area comprising Daventry Street and
Herdman Street inner loop and Waterbank Crescent corner area allowing integrated
development up to 3 storeys.
5932-1 Mistdale Enterprises Limited rose@mhg.co.nz Designations Auckland Transport
1599 Road Widening -
Cheshire Street Remove from 11-13 and 19-33 Falcon Street and 2 Akaroa Street, Parnell.
1580 Road Widening - York
Street Remove from 2-4, 6-8 and 12-24 York Street, 46 Parnell Road and 8-10 Bath Street, Parnell.
1597 Road Widening - Parnell
Road Remove from 73-141, 157-171, 187-207 Parnell Road, Parnell.
1600 Road Widening - Falcon
Street Remove from 167-177 and 209-215 Parnell Road, Parnell.
1598 Road Widening - Garfield
Street
Remove from 1, 9, 13-27 Garfield Street, 100 Parnell Road and 96 Saint Georges Bay Road,
Parnell.
Farnham Street Remove from 1-11 Farnham Street and 106 Saint Georges Bay Road, Parnell.
5932-7 Mistdale Enterprises Limited rose@mhg.co.nz
control
Building demolition control J.3.6 Rules and mapping Re-evaluate the location of the overlay.
5932-8 Mistdale Enterprises Limited rose@mhg.co.nz Built Environment (Overlays)
Height Control
Add the overlay to the sites zoned Mixed Use in Parnell to enable a maximum height between
20.5m and 32.5m.
5932-9 Mistdale Enterprises Limited rose@mhg.co.nz
control
Remove the overlay from Ruskin Avenue in the south, The Strand in the north, Balfour Street
in the east and Bradford Street in the west.
5932-10 Mistdale Enterprises Limited rose@mhg.co.nz General Cross plan matters Delete the storey control component from the building height rule for all zones.
5932-11 Mistdale Enterprises Limited rose@mhg.co.nz General Chapter G General provisions
Delete the third paragraph under the heading 'Assessment criteria' in rule I.1.4 'Applying for
resource consent' [inferred rule G.1.4] and / or clarify that the matters for discretion and
assessment criteria listed in the PAUP for Controlled and Restricted Discretionary Activities
are the sole matter for assessment of these type of consent.
5932-12 Mistdale Enterprises Limited rose@mhg.co.nz Mana Whenua General provisions
assessment Delete the requirements for a cultural impact assessment.
5932-13 Mistdale Enterprises Limited rose@mhg.co.nz General Chapter G General provisions
statements Delete the requirements for separate design statements.
5932-14 Mistdale Enterprises Limited rose@mhg.co.nz RPS Urban growth
environment
Amend references to the Auckland Design Manual to include confirmation that this is a non-
statutory guideline.
5932-15 Mistdale Enterprises Limited rose@mhg.co.nz Sustainable Development C7.7/H6.4 Sustainable design Delete the sustainable development provisions.
5932-16 Mistdale Enterprises Limited rose@mhg.co.nz Residential zones Housing affordability H6.6 Rules Delete the affordable housing provisions.
5933-1 Susan and Clyde Glasson glas@xtra.co.nz RPS Climate change
Retain the PAUP response to climate change by reducing emissions and endorse renewable
electricity generation.
5933-2 Susan and Clyde Glasson glas@xtra.co.nz Infrastructure
H1.1 Network Utilities and
Energy
H1.1 Activity table 1.1 -
Network utilities & electricity
generating facilities Retain the Restricted Discretionary activity status in Rural Zones for wind farming.
5933-3 Susan and Clyde Glasson glas@xtra.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - Rural zones
area
Amend to provide for smaller one to two hectare blocks where there are two or more titles on
one farm by title amalgamation.
5933-4 Susan and Clyde Glasson glas@xtra.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - Rural zones
area Amend and clarify transferable titles [for rural subdisivion].
5933-5 Susan and Clyde Glasson glas@xtra.co.nz Zoning North and Islands
Amend to improve the provision of retirement options for senior citizens in the Helensville
area.
5933-6 Susan and Clyde Glasson glas@xtra.co.nz Zoning North and Islands Provide affordable housing and work opportunities with light industry [in the Helensville area].
5933-7 Susan and Clyde Glasson glas@xtra.co.nz Mana Whenua
Whenua
and policies
Amend the adoption of Mana Whenua sites as identified in the PAUP and withdraw until the
authenticity of each site can be established.
5934-1
Penney Properties Matakana
Limited r.oflaherty@buckton.co.nz Zoning North and Islands
Rezone 66 Matakana Valley Road, Matakana, so that the zone boundary (between Single
House and Light Industry) reflects the legal boundary between Lots 1 and 2 DP 463664.
5935-1 Carl Weaver carl@workwise.co.nz RPS Mana Whenua B5 Strategic Decline the PAUP in order to address concerns regarding Mana Whenua provisions.
5936-1 Fuller Family Trust davefullernz@gmail.com Future Urban I5 Rules
Amend the Land use controls and Development controls for the Future Urban Zone to be
those in the Large Lot zone, where applicable - See Submission page 2/3
5936-2 Fuller Family Trust davefullernz@gmail.com Future Urban I5 Rules
Amend the Assessment criteria for the Future Urban Zone to be those in the Large Lot zone,
where applicable - See Submission page 2/3
26/1145
Sub#/
5936-3 Fuller Family Trust davefullernz@gmail.com Future Urban
D4 Zone description,
Amend the policies so that Future Urban Zones are able to be progressed to residential zones
or change to large; single house zones or mixed housing suburban if the location
is appropriate and background work is carried out to support this location and key
infrastructure components are in place.
5937-1 William Mockridge billmock@gmail.com General Chapter A Introduction
Plan
Decline the PAUP due to vagueness, length, complexity and flawed and undemocratic
content.
5937-2 William Mockridge billmock@gmail.com Definitions
Interpretation, Nesting,
Abbreviation and Acronyms Delete undefined Mori terms. No specific relief sought.
5937-3 William Mockridge billmock@gmail.com RPS Mana Whenua B5 Strategic Delete cultural and spiritual values. No specific relief sought.
5937-4 William Mockridge billmock@gmail.com Definitions Existing Delete use of term "Mana Whenua" and replace with Tangata Whenua.
5937-5 William Mockridge billmock@gmail.com RPS Issues
B1.1 Enabling quality urban
growth Amend the PAUP to reflect the actual Auckland population. No specific relief sought.
B1.4 Addressing issues of
significance to Mana Whenua
Delete the words "build stable and equal partnerships" from the 3rd paragraph
under "Decision-making, environmental governance, partnerships and participation".
Delete the words 'co-management" from the 3rd bullet point under "Auckland Plan strategic
direction and priorities".
5937-8 William Mockridge billmock@gmail.com RPS Mana Whenua
participation Delete Policy 3 regarding partnership arrangements with Mana Whenua.
participation Delete Policy 4 regarding transfer of powers.
Fig. 1 Delete Policy 14 regarding protection of Mana Whenua culture and heritage.
5937-11 William Mockridge billmock@gmail.com Mana Whenua
Whenua
objectives and policies Delete overlay and re-evaluate to ascertain which sites are of 'high value'.
Whenua
and policies Delete overlay and re-evaluate to ascertain which sites are of 'high value'.
Whenua
whenua Delete Appendix 4.1.
5937-14 William Mockridge billmock@gmail.com Mana Whenua General provisions
discovery protocol Delete Accidental Discovery Protocols.
5937-15 William Mockridge billmock@gmail.com Mana Whenua General provisions
assessment Delete requirements for Cultural Impact Assessments.
5937-16 William Mockridge billmock@gmail.com
Genetically modified
organisms
C5.17/H4.19 Genetically
modified organisms
Amend Policies 1-7 to substitute the term "Genetic Engineering / GE" for "Genetically
Modified Organisms".
5938-1 Mathew B Avery mat.avery@geovert.com General Whole Plan Decline the plan.
5938-2 Mathew B Avery mat.avery@geovert.com RPS Urban growth
Amend to provide for high density housing in areas where family sizes are 1-2 people
and retain some affordable suburban areas which have backyards suitable for children to play
in.
5938-3 Mathew B Avery mat.avery@geovert.com Zoning West
Rezone West Auckland so that residential density levels are similar to the levels in the March
Draft. For Te Atatu Peninsula the majority should be zoned Mixed Housing Suburban with a
small area each of Mixed Housing Urban and Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings.
Refer to pages 6 and 9/9 of the submission for details.
Reassess and redistribute housing intensification across Auckland in a fair and sensible
manner to give effect to the RPS policies that prioritises high density housing near;
Metropolitan and Town Centres, public transport routes, areas of high amenity and with
adequate infrastructure. For example the Central suburbs. Refer to pages 6-7/9 of the
Amend to provide for high density housing in areas with the highest land value, for example
the Central suburbs.
5938-6 Mathew B Avery mat.avery@geovert.com Special Character
residential
Delete the blanket application of the historic character overlay [infer Special Character],
especially in the central city suburbs.
Include coastal properties in areas of intensification, especially areas that are
near transport routes (including ferries) and metropolitan and town centres.
Remove high density housing from areas that do not have walkable access to high quality
outdoor amenity or green space, especially around the rail line in the inner west suburbs of
Avondale, New Lynn, Glen Eden and Henderson.
27/1145
Sub#/
Amend to provide additional facilities in areas of intensification e.g. shops, schools and parks
etc, including provision for more professional work opportunities in the Henderson
metropolitan area.
5939-1
William D and Barbara J
Saunders terraforcenz@xtra.co.nz Zoning North and Islands
Rezone the area surrounding Perry Road, Warkworth from Rural Production to Countryside
Living.
5940-1 Athol McQuilkan deanne@mhg.co.nz Zoning Central Rezone 77 Parnell Road, Parnell from Single House to Town Centre - Parnell.
5940-2 Athol McQuilkan deanne@mhg.co.nz Zoning Central
Rezone the remainder of the block, bound by Heather Street to the south and west, Cracroft
Street to the north and Parnell Road to the south, Parnell, to Mixed Use.
5940-3 Athol McQuilkan deanne@mhg.co.nz Definitions Existing
Amend the definition of height to include "the vertical distance between the highest part of the
building and the average level of the ground at the external foundations of the buildings".
5940-4 Athol McQuilkan deanne@mhg.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - Urban zones H5.2 3.1 Residential zones
Amend the development control for subdivision in Residential zones to replace 'net site area'
with 'gross site area'.
5940-5 Athol McQuilkan deanne@mhg.co.nz General Cross plan matters
Amend the maximum height controls, referring only to maximum heights in metres to
determine height in all zones and removing reference to storeys.
5940-6 Athol McQuilkan deanne@mhg.co.nz Definitions New
Add the following definition for 'gross site area' to the plan: "Gross site area: Means the total
area of a site including any entrance strip" including the diagram on p 5/7 of submission.
5940-7 Athol McQuilkan deanne@mhg.co.nz Designations Auckland Transport
Street Remove the road widening designation along York Street, Parnell.
Farnham Street Remove the road widening designation along Farnham Street, Parnell.
Road Remove the road widening designation along Parnell Road, Parnell.
Street Remove the road widening designation along Garfield Street, Parnell.
Cheshire Street Remove the road widening designation along Cheshire Street, Parnell.
5940-12 Athol McQuilkan deanne@mhg.co.nz General Chapter G General provisions
statements Delete the requirement to provide a design statement.
5940-13 Athol McQuilkan deanne@mhg.co.nz Mana Whenua General provisions
assessment
Amend the provisions to refine the circumstances under which a Cultural Impact Assessment
and engagement with Iwi may be required.
5940-14 Athol McQuilkan deanne@mhg.co.nz Sustainable Development C7.7/H6.4 Sustainable design
Delete the requirement to achieve a 4 Green Star rating or certification under the Living
Building Challenge.
5940-15 Athol McQuilkan deanne@mhg.co.nz Residential zones Housing affordability H6.6 Rules
Delete the requirement to provide affordable housing where more than 15 dwellings or 15
vacant sites are developed within the RUB.
5940-16 Athol McQuilkan deanne@mhg.co.nz
Centre) Business
Special information
requirements
Delete the requirement to provide a wind report for buildings higher than 20m where a canopy
is provided over public space.
5941-1 Ann G Hikaka gerhikaka@xtra.co.nz Mana Whenua General provisions
assessment
Delete the requirement for a resource consent applicant to provide a cultural impact
assessment and place the responsibility on Council to supply and prepare one if required.
5941-2 Ann G Hikaka gerhikaka@xtra.co.nz Zoning South
Rezone the sites on Linwood Road, including 1010 Linwood Road, Papakura from Mixed
Rural to the current rural zoning [inferred the Rural zone in the Operative Franklin District
Plan] and prevent any further rezoning of this area until the effects of the Kingseat
development on the existing community are known.
5942-1 David and Barry G Pinker burnette@opc.net.nz
Centre) Business
& Bus. Park zones
Retain permitted activity status for Community Facilities in the Metropolitan Centre, Town
Centre, Local Centre, Mixed Use and General Business zones,
and discretionary activity status elsewhere.
5942-2 David and Barry G Pinker burnette@opc.net.nz Future Urban I5 Rules Provide for Community Facilities in the Future Urban zone as a discretionary activity.
5942-3 David and Barry G Pinker burnette@opc.net.nz
Purpose) Cemetery zone
Provide for new small to medium scale cemeteries as a discretionary activity (rather than via a
plan change); in particular in rural zones.
5942-4 David and Barry G Pinker burnette@opc.net.nz Definitions Existing Retain definition of Community Facilities.
5942-5 David and Barry G Pinker burnette@opc.net.nz Definitions Existing Retain definition of Cemeteries.
5942-6 David and Barry G Pinker burnette@opc.net.nz RPS Changes to the RUB North and Waiheke Island Retain the land at 2 and 14 Mason Heights, Warkworth, within the RUB.
5942-7 David and Barry G Pinker burnette@opc.net.nz RPS Changes to the RUB North and Waiheke Island
Rezone the land at 2 and 14 Mason Heights, Warkworth, from Future Urban to Single house
zone.
5942-8 David and Barry G Pinker burnette@opc.net.nz Water Stormwater
H4.14.2 Stormwater
management -flow rules Delete or substantially amend the rule trigger for the SMAF overlay as it applies to Warkworth.
5943-1 Mei-Lin Hansen meilin.hansen@gmail.com Precincts - City Centre Arts, Civic & Entertainment Include the St James Theatre complex in the precinct description, objectives and polices.
28/1145
Sub#/
5944-1 Desmond and Glenise Nelson nelona@xtra.co.nz Precincts - South Runciman
Replace Countryside Living rule 3.4(1)(d)(iii) with the following 'All specified building areas
must be located within 155m radius from the cluster's centre (distance may be extended if
topography requires); or 'All specified building areas must be located within 200m radius from
the clusters's centre; or amend rule 3.4(1)(g) to read 'Subdivision that does not comply with 2
or more clauses 1(a)-1(d) above is a non-complying activity'.
5945-1 Yonas Yoseph yonasyoseph@gmail.com Precincts - North Rodney Landscape Delete average density control for cluster housing subdivisions in Sub-precinct F.
5945-2 Yonas Yoseph yonasyoseph@gmail.com Precincts - North Rodney Landscape
Reduce average density controls for cluster housing subdivisions and add Restricted
Discretionary criteria in Sub-precinct F.
5945-3 Yonas Yoseph yonasyoseph@gmail.com Precincts - North Rodney Landscape Add bonuses for enhancement of the landscape in Sub-precinct F.
5946-1 Gaynor R Salie salies@vodafone.co.nz RPS Mana Whenua B5 Strategic Address concerns regarding Iwi involvement in private land. No specific relief sought.
5946-2 Gaynor R Salie salies@vodafone.co.nz General Chapter G General provisions G2.4 Notification
Address concerns regarding notification of new buildings or renovations. No specific relief
sought.
5946-3 Gaynor R Salie salies@vodafone.co.nz General Cross plan matters Address concerns regarding building heights of 6-8m. No specific relief sought.
5946-4 Gaynor R Salie salies@vodafone.co.nz General Chapter A Introduction
Plan
Address concerns that the Plan is overly complex as it applies to 65 Ti Rakau Drive,
Panmure. No specific relief sought.
5946-5 Gaynor R Salie salies@vodafone.co.nz General Chapter A Introduction
Plan
Address concerns that the Maps section of the Plan is too complex and full of jargon. No
specific relief sought.
5946-6 Gaynor R Salie salies@vodafone.co.nz RPS
character and natural heritage B4.3 Natural heritage Retain those parts of the PAUP that protect natural features. No specific relief sought.
5946-7 Gaynor R Salie salies@vodafone.co.nz RPS Urban growth
Address concerns regarding future development in Panmure, in particular building heights,
infrastructure and facilities for increased population. No specific relief sought.
5946-8 Gaynor R Salie salies@vodafone.co.nz General Miscellaneous
Operational/
Projects/Acquisition
Address safety concerns regarding increased population in Panmure, including interaction
between neighbours. No specific relief sought.
5946-9 Gaynor R Salie salies@vodafone.co.nz RPS Urban growth
environment
Address concerns regarding urban design outcomes for intensive residential developments.
No specific relief sought.
5946-10 Gaynor R Salie salies@vodafone.co.nz RPS Urban growth B2.7 Social infrastructure
Address concerns regarding provision of additional schools in areas undergoing intensive
residential development. No specific relief sought.
Operational/
Clarify whether will provide a walkway in Panmure similar to that in Stonefields, St Johns, and
Glendowie. No specific relief sought.
Operational/
Clarify whether Council will provide a walkway along Glendowie and the foot of the St Heliers
cliffs. No specific relief sought.
5947-1
AML Limited and Allied
Concrete Limited lucy.delatour@wynnwilliams.co.nz Zoning West Retain Avondale Site (54 Patiki Road, Avondale) as Heavy Industry zone.
5947-2
Concrete Limited lucy.delatour@wynnwilliams.co.nz Zoning South Retain Tamaki Site (45 Cryers Road, East Tamaki) as Heavy Industry zone.
5947-3
Concrete Limited lucy.delatour@wynnwilliams.co.nz Zoning Central
Rezone Penrose Site (20 Leon Leicester Avenue, Penrose) and surrounding area as Heavy
Industry - see Submission page 14/15 for map at Attachment 1.
5947-4
Concrete Limited lucy.delatour@wynnwilliams.co.nz Zoning South Rezone Manukau Site (204 Wiri Station Road) as Heavy Industry.
5947-5
Concrete Limited lucy.delatour@wynnwilliams.co.nz Zoning North and Islands
Rezone Silverdale site (part of 63 Foundry Road, Silverdale) see Submission page 15/15
for map at Attachment 2.
5947-6
Concrete Limited lucy.delatour@wynnwilliams.co.nz RPS
Transport
B3.1 Commercial and
industrial growth Amend section to sufficiently recognise existing industry.
5947-7
Concrete Limited lucy.delatour@wynnwilliams.co.nz RPS Natural resources B6.1 Air
Add an additional policy to avoid reverse sensitivity effects by requiring subdivision, use and
development to not occur in a location or form that constrains the use, operation,
maintenance and upgrading of existing industrial activities.
5947-8
Concrete Limited lucy.delatour@wynnwilliams.co.nz Air Quality
and policies
Amend policy to provide further recognition of existing industry that discharges to air [refer
also to points 3 and 5].
5947-9
and policies
Amend Policy 18(e): Demonstrate that the chosen method and amount of discharge does not
have a reasonably practicable alternative that causes less adverse effects.
5947-10
and policies
Retain Policy 21(b) or remove the offsetting policy and refer to the National Environmental
Standard for Air Quality mandatory offset requirements.
5947-11
and policies
Amend the Air Quality standards as necessary to ensure that the standards are not more
stringent than the National Environmental Standard for Air Quality.
5947-12
Concrete Limited lucy.delatour@wynnwilliams.co.nz
Centre)
D3.10 Light Industrial zone
desc, obs & pols
Amend objectives and policies to recognise existing Heavy Industry located within Light
Industry zones.
5947-13
Centre)
D3.11 Heavy Industrial zone
desc, obs & pols Retain zone description and objectives and policies wording.
5947-14
Amend policies so that activities sensitive to air discharges cannot locate within 500m of the
boundary of a Heavy Industry zoned area unless the effects of those emissions can be
avoided, remedied or mitigated by the sensitive activity.
29/1145
Sub#/
5947-15
Amend policies so that the Air Quality - Sensitive Activity Restriction applies to all residential
zones and business zones that allow residential activity occurring within 500m of a Heavy
Industry zoned area.
5947-16
Concrete Limited lucy.delatour@wynnwilliams.co.nz General Chapter G General provisions G2.2 Activities not provided for
Amend Rule 1 as follows: Any activity that is not specifically listed in the Unitary Plan as a
permitted, controlled, restricted discretionary, discretionary or prohibited activity is a non-
complying discretionary activity.
5947-17
Concrete Limited lucy.delatour@wynnwilliams.co.nz General Noise and vibration H6.2 Rules
Retain Rule 10 and Table 6 in the current form in relation to the Heavy Industry zone
[submission lists as Chapter G, Rule 6.2.10].
5947-18
Concrete Limited lucy.delatour@wynnwilliams.co.nz Air Quality H4.1 Auckland wide rules
H4.1.2 Notification and H4.1.3
General controls
Delete the "Light Industry Zone" from the "air quality high amenity" area column in activity
table 1.1 and insert into the "air quality reduced amenity area".
5947-19
Concrete Limited lucy.delatour@wynnwilliams.co.nz Air Quality H4.1 Auckland wide rules Dust generating processes
Amend Rule 3.1.4 to replace reference to an independent chartered professional engineer
with an independent air quality expert. Clarify the rule so that for bag house filter systems no
actual measurements or data is required as part of the independent certification of the system
design.
5947-20
Hazardous substances &
Industrial or Trade Activities
(ITA)
Industrial and Trade activities
(ITA) H4.8.4 Table of ITAs
Add Table 4 for existing consents for high risk ITAs, include list of existing consents as
provided in the Submission pages 12-13/15.
5948-1
Buckton Consulting Surveyors
Limited surveyors@buckton.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - Urban zones H5.2 3.1 Residential zones Delete rule 3 Rear sites.
5948-2
Limited surveyors@buckton.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - Rural zones
area Delete rule 2.3.3(4)(b)(iii) transferable rural site subdivision rule.
5948-3
area
Complete Table 7, to identify what other areas in rural and coastal villages and rural zones
are receiver sites.
5948-4
area
Amend rule 2.3.3(5) to read: A management plan must include the maintenance of planting to
ensure all invasive plant parts are eradicated controlled.
5948-5
area
Amend rule 2.3.3(5) Table 8, to clarify if the SEA has to be on one site or can overlay one or
more sites in the same ownership.
5948-6
area
Amend rule 2.3.3(2) protection and enhancement of ecological features, to apply only to rural-
residential sites as it the case in the Auckland Council District Plan (Rodney Section).
5948-7
Limited surveyors@buckton.co.nz General Eplan Request that planning maps can be printed at scales up to 1:25,000.
5948-8
Limited surveyors@buckton.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - general
C.6 Background, objectives
and policies Amend policy 6 to provide for overhead power supply.
5948-9
and policies Amend policy 7 by deleting the word "public".
5948-10
and policies Amend policy 22 by requiring analysis for subdivisions of 10 or more sites.
5948-11
Limited surveyors@buckton.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - Urban zones
H5.1 Activity Table All zones
except Rural Amend Table 3 'Future Urban zone' activities from prohibited to non-complying.
5948-12
H5.1 Activity Table 5 Rural
zones only Amend Table 5 'Rural zone' activities from prohibited to non-complying.
5948-13
area
Amend subdivision rules to provide for niche agricultural activities on a greater variety of
scales than is economically feasible on large 20ha sites.
5948-14
except Rural
Add to Table 3 subdivision of sites with areas of 4ha or greater as an restricted discretionary
activity.
5948-15
except Rural
Include 4ha rule from the Auckland Council District Plan (Rodney Section), for Future
Urban subdivision.
5948-16
H5.2.1 & H5.2.2 Development
controls
Amend clause 2.1.4(a)(iii) to read: underground water and electricity supply in urban zones
and overhead electricity in rural zones.
5948-17
controls
Amend Rule 2.1(4) to provide for alternative electricity supplies such as solar, wind, micro
hydro in rural zones.
5948-18
controls
Amend Rule 2.1(4) to provide for alternative telecommunication methods such as cellular and
satellite.
5948-19
controls
Amend rule 2.1(6)(a) to delete the requirement to create esplanade reserves or strips on sites
greater than 4ha, unless Council can prove it has the funds available to compensate the
landowner for value of land lost and survey fees (as per RMA).
5948-20
controls Amend rule 2.1(6)(a) to include rivers or streams (non-tidal) with a width of 3m or greater.
30/1145
Sub#/
5948-21
controls
Amend rule 2.1(6)(c) so any reduction in width is assessed as a restricted discretionary
activity.
5948-22
controls Amend rule 2.1(6)(d) from discretionary to restricted discretionary.
5948-23
area Delete clause 2.3.3(1)(c)(i).
5948-24
area Delete clause 2.3.3(1)(c)(iv).
5948-25
area
Add to rule 2.3.3(2)(a): 'boundary relocations and sites greater than 150ha after 'boundary
adjustments'.
5948-26
area
Add to rule 2.3.3(2)(c): 'except boundary adjustments, boundary relocations', and sites with
areas greater than 150ha.
5948-27
area Amend rule 2.3.3(5) to include numbering.
5948-28
area Amend rule 2.3.3(5) to reduce the buffer around wetlands to be protected from 20m to 10m.
5948-29
area Clarify on whether 'boundary relocation' provisions have been included [refers to rule (7)].
5948-30
zones only
Add subdivision of sites over 150ha to the activity table, and reduce 150ha to 120ha as per
the Auckland Council District Plan (Rodney Section).
5948-31
controls Delete rule 2.2.1(5) requirement to provide details on staging.
5948-32
area
Clarify conflict between rule 2.3.3(1)(c) requiring a building area of at least 5000m2 and rule
2.3.3(8)(d)(ii) requiring a building area of no less than 2000m2. Amend to 2000m2.
5948-33
area Clarify clause 2.3.3(4)(b)(i) 'redefined as single site' as terminology is vague.
5948-34
area
Clarify clause 2.3.3(4)(b)(ii) 'rescinded' as terminology is vague and ambiguous. Titles can
be amalgamated by use of various legal mechanisms, e.g s220 of the RMA.
5948-35
area Amend clause 2.3.3(4)(b)(iii) by deleting the first bullet point.
5948-36
area
Clarify clause 2.3.3(4)(b)(iii) bullet point 2, as this would preclude any subdivision for
reserves, network utilities and public open space.
5948-37
area
Clarify clause 2.3.3(4)(b)(iii) bullet point 3, as this would preclude further amalgamation with
an adjoining site for transferable rural site subdivision, and is in direct conflict with the note
under Table 5 which allows for more than two sites to be created.
5948-38
area
Clarify clause 2.3.3(4)(b)(iii) bullet point 4, as removal should only be required when the land
is subject to a subdivision consent, not when a plan change is made operative.
5948-39
Limited surveyors@buckton.co.nz Rural Zones General I13.2 Land use controls Amend rule 2.6(1) by deleting clauses (a),(b) and (d).
5948-40
Limited surveyors@buckton.co.nz Definitions Existing
Amend 'ground level' to read: ...since 31 January 1975 or where no reliable determination of
ground level is available on sites created after 31 January 1975.
5948-41
Limited surveyors@buckton.co.nz Definitions Existing
Amend 'height' diagram text to read: The ground plane is made up of the levels existing at the
time of subdivision The ground plane is the same as the 'Ground Level' which is defined in
Part 4.
5949-1 Bill and Barbara Ellis wjbellis@clear.net.nz General Miscellaneous
Operational/
Provide more mobility carparks, all parks to be wider. Restricted parking areas only to apply
during daytime hours. Bus lanes to be marked green with indication for allowed distance to
intersection turn. Endorse the rail loop. Buses on the north shore must link coastal areas
without having to transfer buses. More Council help with volunteers at Council owned heritage
property
5950-1 Roger C Curl curley@xtra.co.nz RPS Mana Whenua B5 Strategic Delete Mana Whenua provisions in their entirety.
5951-1 Vera Schulze veraschulze@gmail.com General Miscellaneous Other Support the submission made by the Rangihoua Houseboats group.
31/1145
Sub#/
5951-2 Vera Schulze veraschulze@gmail.com
the CMA Mooring zone I8.1 Activity table
Amend the activity status for the occupation of the 7 houseboats at Rangihoua, Waiheke from
Restricted Discretionary to Permitted.
the CMA Mooring zone I8.2 Assessment
Retain the assessment criteria and matters of discretion for houseboats generally in Auckland
but not in relation to the Rangihoua House boats, Waiheke.
Amend the assessment criteria and matters of discretion in relation to the Rangihoua
houseboats, Waiheke to recognise that the seabed is not the only appropriate fixture point,
that structural integrity of houseboats is different from houses or other boats, that the
houseboats may need to increase in size in order to meet other assessment criteria and that
an expiration date for consent for the houseboats is inappropriate. Refer to pages 5-7/7
of the submission for details.
5952-1 Dominic McCarthy dominic.mccarthy.dm@gmail.com
SEAs
Land
Delete or reduce (such that it only applies where appropriate assessment has
been undertaken) the extent of SEA overlay (ID 2037) at 192 Colwill Road, Massey.
5953-1 E J Worley worleys@slingshot.co.nz General Miscellaneous Other
Support the submission of Vickey Bethell on behalf of the Bethell family, 280 Bethells Road,
Bethells Beach.
5953-2 E J Worley worleys@slingshot.co.nz Precincts - West
Waitakere Ranges Heritage
Area K7.9.5 Rules (sub-precinct E)
Support the inclusion of a LPMA [Large Property Management Area] for the Wainamu,
Bethells and Te Henga Area, and support the implementation of a LMPA for the Roberts
property.
Support submission by the Roberts Family of Roberts Farm 205 and 2051 Bethells Road,
Bethells Beach.
Support submission by the Wheeler family at Wainamu Farm (EJ Wheeler Trust) 224 Bethells
Road, Bethells Beach.
Support the submission of the Hooker Family of Te Henga (MR and NO Hooker Family Trust),
288 Bethells Road, Bethells Beach.
5954-1 Steve and Tanja Dumper dumper@snap.net.nz Trees
Overlay E6.1/J6.4 Notable
Trees
Notable Trees
Amend Schedule of Notable Trees with an approximately 100m stand of Oak trees between
126 Ponga Road and 215 Ponga Road, Opaheke, see Submission Page 8/16 for map and
Submission for further detail
5955-1
Brian and Maureen Eardley-
Wilmot philip@campbellbrown.co.nz
SEAs
Land
Reduce the extent of the overlay at 15 Fern Glen Road South, Saint Heliers. Refer to the
maps in Appendices B and C on pages 8-9/10 if the submission.
5956-1 Zhao Ruizhi david.macpherson@xtra.co.nz Zoning North and Islands
Rezone 15 Living Stream Road, Albany from Single House to either Mixed Housing or
5957-1 540 Great South Road Limited deanne@mhg.co.nz Definitions Existing
Amend the definition of height to include "the vertical distance between the highest part of the
building and the average level of the ground at the external foundations of the buildings"
5957-2 540 Great South Road Limited deanne@mhg.co.nz General Cross plan matters
Remove the maximum storey control, instead making maximum heights the sole development
control to determine height in all zones
5957-3 540 Great South Road Limited deanne@mhg.co.nz General Cross plan matters Remove the floor to floor/ceiling height minimums in all zones
5957-4 540 Great South Road Limited deanne@mhg.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - Urban zones H5.2 3.1 Residential zones
Amend the development control for subdivision in Residential zones to replace 'net site area'
with 'gross site area'
5957-5 540 Great South Road Limited deanne@mhg.co.nz Definitions New
Add the following definition for 'gross site area' to the plan: "Gross site area: Means the total
area of a site including any entrance strip" including the diagram on p 5/7 of submission
5957-6 540 Great South Road Limited deanne@mhg.co.nz Designations Auckland Transport
1677 Road Widening - Great
South Road Delete the Designation for Road Widening (ID 1677)
5957-7 540 Great South Road Limited deanne@mhg.co.nz General Chapter G General provisions
statements Delete the requirement to provide a design statement
5957-8 540 Great South Road Limited deanne@mhg.co.nz Mana Whenua General provisions
assessment
Refine the circumstances under which a Cultural Impact Assessment and engagement with
Iwi may be required
5957-9 540 Great South Road Limited deanne@mhg.co.nz Sustainable Development C7.7/H6.4 Sustainable design
Building Challenge
5957-10 540 Great South Road Limited deanne@mhg.co.nz Residential zones Housing affordability H6.6 Rules
vacant sites are developed within the RUB
5957-11 540 Great South Road Limited deanne@mhg.co.nz
Centre) Business
Special information
requirements
Delete the requirement to provide a wind report for buildings higher than 20m where
a canopy is provided over public space
5958-1 Gary G Guo tahiti.guo@gmail.com
SEAs
Land
Remove the SEA overlay at 17 McCahon Place, Titirangi or amend reflecting the work done in
the subdivision process to identifty the areas of the subdivision to be protected
5959-1 Singh Family Trust dhirendra_singh@xtra.co.nz
control
Building demolition control J.3.6 Rules and mapping Delete the Pre-1944 demolition control from the property at 38 Harlston Road, Mt Albert.
32/1145
Sub#/
5960-1 Michael Howard howardjm@xtra.co.nz Mana Whenua
Whenua
and policies Delete provisions for sites of significance to Mana Whenua.
5961-1 Julie Stirling stirlinggreen@hotmail.com Residential zones Residential
and Coastal Settlement zone Retain rule 6.10 Fences, in the Single House zone.
5962-1 Harry K Williams kwilliams@free.net.nz RPS Mana Whenua B5 Strategic
Amend PAUP to remove specific rights, obligations, objectives, policies and rules in favour
Mana Whenua. Remove the ability of Mana Whenua to register sites of significance and value
beyond those included in previous district plans, instead granting this to the New Zealand
Historic Places Trust [Heritage New Zealand]. See submission for details
5962-2 Harry K Williams kwilliams@free.net.nz General Miscellaneous Other
Request a referendum regarding the Independent Mori Statutory Board (see Submission
Page 4/6)
5963-1
Ravensdown Fertiliser
Cooperative Limited chris@rmaexpert.co.nz RPS Issues
our natural resources Retain Issue.
5963-2
Cooperative Limited chris@rmaexpert.co.nz RPS Natural resources B6.1 Air
Amend Introduction first paragraph second sentence to read: 'Rural air pollution is normally
more localised and comes from outdoor fires, use of agricultural agrichemicals and odour
from agricultural activities.'
5963-3
Cooperative Limited chris@rmaexpert.co.nz RPS Natural resources B6.1 Air Amend Objective 4(d) to read: 'd. application of agrichemicals'.
5963-4
Cooperative Limited chris@rmaexpert.co.nz
Rural Discharges,
Agrichemicals, VTAs &
Biosolids
C5.11/H4.10 Rural Production
Discharges
Amend the second paragraph of the background to read: 'The application of fertiliser to land is
a critical component of a productive farming unit. However, the runoff of fertiliser into rivers
and streams is a major can contributor to nutrient enrichment in Auckland's rural streams and
coastal water if best management practices are not adopted (including compliance with the
Code of Practice for Fertiliser Use). This in turn can affects the biological values of the water
and can encourage the growth of unwanted aquatic vegetation. Nutrient discharge from a
number of rural activities over Fertiliser contamination of the south Auckland volcanic aquifers
is also a matter of concern.'
5963-5
Rural Discharges,
Biosolids
Discharges Retain Policy 3.
5963-6
Cooperative Limited chris@rmaexpert.co.nz Water Aquifers/Groundwater
Amend the Overlay Description to read: 'These aquifers are shallow and unconfined and
therefore susceptible to pollution from a range of surface sources, such as excess fertiliser
application not applied using best practice methods (such as complying with the Code of
Practice for Fertiliser Use) or discharges of contaminants such as stormwater or sewage...'
5963-7
Rural Discharges,
Biosolids
Discharges Retain the permitted activity status for the 'use and discharge of fertiliser'.
5963-8
Rural Discharges,
Biosolids
Discharges Retain the permitted controls for 'use and discharge of fertiliser to land'.
5963-9
Rural Discharges,
Biosolids
Discharges
Amend the plan to clarify whether the general controls apply in 2.1.1 general in addition to the
specific controls in 2.1.3 'use and discharge of fertiliser to land'.
5963-10
our rural environment Retain Issue.
5963-11
Cooperative Limited chris@rmaexpert.co.nz RPS Natural resources
B6.3 Freshwater and
Geothermal Water Retain Objective 1.
5963-12
B6.3 Freshwater and
Geothermal Water Retain Objective 2.
5963-13
B6.3 Freshwater and
Geothermal Water Retain Policy 3(e)(i).
5963-14
B6.3 Freshwater and
Geothermal Water Retain Policy 3(e)(ii).
5963-15
Rural Discharges,
Biosolids
Discharges Retain Objective 1.
5963-16
Rural Discharges,
Biosolids
5963-17
Rural Discharges,
Biosolids
33/1145
Sub#/
5963-18
Rural Discharges,
Biosolids
5963-19
Rural Discharges,
Biosolids
5963-20
Rural Discharges,
Biosolids
5963-21
Cooperative Limited chris@rmaexpert.co.nz Water
policies
C5.15.1 Background &
Objectives Retain Objective 1.
5963-22
policies
5963-23
policies
ecosystem guidelines App.5.6 Retain Policy 1.
5963-24
policies
5963-25
policies
5963-26
Cooperative Limited chris@rmaexpert.co.nz Rural Zones General
D6.1 Introduction General
objectives & policies Retain Objective 3 for Rural Industries services and non -residential activities.
5963-27
Cooperative Limited chris@rmaexpert.co.nz Rural Zones General
objectives & policies Retain Policy 3 for Rural Industries services and non-residential activities.
5963-28
Cooperative Limited chris@rmaexpert.co.nz Rural Zones
D6.2 Rural Production zone
desc, obs & pols
Retain Objective 2 but amend PAUP to clarify if this objective is implemented through regional
or district rules or both.
5963-29
Cooperative Limited chris@rmaexpert.co.nz Rural Zones
desc, obs & pols
Retain Policy 4 but amend PAUP to clarify if this objective is implemented through regional or
district rules or both.
5963-30
Rural Discharges,
Biosolids
Discharges Retain rules for Rural Production Discharges.
5963-31
growth Retain Issue.
5963-32
our rural environment Retain the Issue.
5963-33
Cooperative Limited chris@rmaexpert.co.nz RPS Natural resources B6.2 Minerals Retain Section 6.2 Minerals.
5963-34
Cooperative Limited chris@rmaexpert.co.nz RPS Rural B8.1 Rural activities Retain Objective 1.
5963-35
5963-36
Cooperative Limited chris@rmaexpert.co.nz RPS Rural B8.1 Rural activities Retain Policy 8.
5963-37
5963-38
Cooperative Limited chris@rmaexpert.co.nz RPS Rural
B8.2 Land with high productive
potential Retain Objective 2.
5963-39
Cooperative Limited chris@rmaexpert.co.nz RPS Rural
potential Retain Policy 5.
5963-40
our natural resources
Amend Air Quality Issue to read: 'Clean air is fundamental to our health, well-being and
environment. Auckland, compared to many cities in the world, has good air quality. However,
air quality sometimes fails to meet acceptable levels or comply with the Resource
Management (National Environmental Standards for Air Quality) 2004 the government's
national environmental standards for air quality or Auckland Ambient Air Quality standards
(AAAQS) .'
5963-41
Cooperative Limited chris@rmaexpert.co.nz RPS Natural resources B6.1 Air Retain the Introduction.
34/1145
Sub#/
5963-42
Cooperative Limited chris@rmaexpert.co.nz RPS Natural resources B6.1 Air
Amend Objective 2 to read: 'The Auckland Ambient Air Quality Standards Acceptable air
quality is achieved throughout Auckland including meeting the and Resource Management
(National Environmental Standards for Air Quality) Regulations 2004 are met and the Ministry
for the Environment's Ambient Air Quality Guidelines, and in particular priority is given to
meeting the annual average standards for fine particles (PM10 and PM2.5) and hourly and 24-
hourly standards for nitrogen dioxide.'
5963-43
Cooperative Limited chris@rmaexpert.co.nz RPS General
B12 Environmental Results
Anticipated/Table 1/New ERAs
Amend Table 5 'Natural resources', the second Environmental results anticipated to read: 'Air
discharges and the use and development of land are managed to Improved air quality,
enhance amenity values and a reduction in reverse sensitivity complaints in Aucklands urban
areas and to maintain air quality at existing levels in rural and coastal marine areas.'
5963-44
Amend Table 5 'Natural resources', the second Natural Resource Objective to read:
'Acceptable air quality is achieved throughout Auckland including meeting the and Resource
Management (National Environmental Standards for Air Quality) Regulations 2004 and the
Ministry for the Environment's Ambient Air Quality Guidelines are met, and in particular priority
is given to meeting the annual average standards for fine particles (PM10 and PM2.5) and
hourly and 24-hourly standards for nitrogen dioxide.'
5963-45
Replace the second Environmental Results Anticipated in Table 5 'Natural resources' with:
'Air quality consistent with protecting human health and amenity is achieved throughout the
Auckland Region.'
5963-46
Cooperative Limited chris@rmaexpert.co.nz Air Quality
and policies
Amend the last two sentences of the Background to read: 'There are also industrial processes
that cannot avoid discharging contaminants into the air and their operation needs to be
recognised and supported. Therefore, Tt heir effects of these activities can need to be
managed through methods such as the use of suitable using suitable control technology, on-
site management techniques and by where practicable locating such industries in appropriate
areas.'
5963-47
and policies Retain Objective 1.
5963-48
and policies
Amend Policy 1 to read: 'Protect human health by ensuring air discharges do not cause
adverse effects to human health and that cumulative effects are minimised. requiring that air
discharges do not cause air quality to exceed the AAAQS in Table 1 for the specified
contaminants, and manage the discharge of other contaminants so that the adverse effects
on human health, including cumulative adverse effects, are minimised. '
5963-49
and policies Delete Policy 18.
5963-50
and policies
Amend Table 1: Auckland Ambient Air Quality Standards for S0
2
from 20 micro grams per
meter cubed to 120 micro grams per meter cubed.
5963-51
Cooperative Limited chris@rmaexpert.co.nz Air Quality H4.1 Auckland wide rules
General controls
Add new restricted discretionary activity 'Any activity failing to meet the Auckland Ambient Air
Quality Standards (AAAQS).'
5963-52
Cooperative Limited chris@rmaexpert.co.nz Air Quality H4.1 Auckland wide rules
General controls
Add new restricted discretionary matters of discretion for [the new activity] 'Any activity failing
to meet the Auckland Ambient Air Quality Standards (AAAQS)' as specified on page 23/24 of
the submission.
5963-53
Cooperative Limited chris@rmaexpert.co.nz Air Quality H4.1 Auckland wide rules H4.1.4 and H4.15 Assessment
Amend matter of discretion (8)(a) Combustion activities to read: 'The Auckland ambient air
quality standards'.
5963-54
Cooperative Limited chris@rmaexpert.co.nz Air Quality H4.1 Auckland wide rules H4.1.4 and H4.15 Assessment Retain 5.2 Assessment Criteria.
5963-55
Cooperative Limited chris@rmaexpert.co.nz Definitions Existing
Delete the definition of 'Fertiliser' and replace with the definition used in the Agricultural and
Veterinary Medicines (Exemptions and Prohibited Substances) Regulations 2011. The
specific definition wording is on page 24/24 of the submission.
5963-56
Rural Discharges,
Biosolids
Discharges
Amend control 2.1.1(3) to read: 'The application rate of nitrogen from any combination of dairy
effluent; nitrogenous fertiliser and other nitrogen discharges from the other rural production
activities must not...d) exceed 150kgN/ha/year and 30kgsN/ha/3 1 days onto....e) exceed
200kgN/ha/year and 50kgN/ha/3 1 days into...
5963-57
Rural Discharges,
Biosolids
Discharges
Add a new restricted discretionary activity to the Activity Table for 'any activity that can not
comply with the permitted activity controls'. Limit councils discretion to the matter that can not
be met.
5964-1 Peter Onneweer piet88@yahoo.com
control
Amend the activity status for the demolition or removal of heritage buildings to Non-
complying.
5964-2 Peter Onneweer piet88@yahoo.com
control
Amend the notification provisions to require the public notification for the demolition or
removal of heritage buildings.
5964-3 Peter Onneweer piet88@yahoo.com Zoning Central Rezone the existing residential areas in Grafton to Single House.
5964-4 Peter Onneweer piet88@yahoo.com Zoning Central
Rezone Park Road, Grafton from Local Centre to Neighbourhood Centre with a maximum
height of 9m for any new buildings.
5965-1 Grace and Rose Dickson dicksonyachting@gmail.com Zoning North and Islands Rezone Barrys Point Road, Takapuna from Light Industry to Mixed Use.
35/1145
Sub#/
5966-1 Second Avenue Limited rose@mhg.co.nz
control
Building demolition control J.3.6 Rules and mapping Remove the Pre 1944 Building Demolition Control from 12 Central Road, Kingsland
5966-2 Second Avenue Limited rose@mhg.co.nz General Cross plan matters
Amend the maximum storey control, instead referring only to maximum heights in metres to
determine height in all zones, removing reference to storeys.
5966-3 Second Avenue Limited rose@mhg.co.nz Definitions Existing
Amend the definition of 'Height' to include "the vertical distance between the highest part of
the building and the average level of the ground at the external foundations of the buildings"
as defined in the Operative Isthmus District Plan.
5966-4 Second Avenue Limited rose@mhg.co.nz General Chapter G General provisions
Delete the third paragraph under Assessment Criteria of G1.4 or clarify that the matters for
discretion and assessment criteria listed in the PAUP for Controlled and Restricted
Discretionary Activities are the sole matter of assessment for these types of consent
5966-5 Second Avenue Limited rose@mhg.co.nz Mana Whenua General provisions
assessment Remove the requirements for Cultural Impact Assessment from the PAUP
5966-6 Second Avenue Limited rose@mhg.co.nz RPS Urban growth
environment
Delete the requirement to provide a design statement and references to the Auckland Design
Manual include confirmation that this is a non-statutory guideline
5966-7 Second Avenue Limited rose@mhg.co.nz Sustainable Development C7.7/H6.4 Sustainable design
Decline the requirement to incorporate sustainable development in the prescriptive format set
out in Rule H6.4.2, including buildings with a GFA of 5000m
2
or greater and where 80 per cent
or more of the GFA is to be used as an office are proposed
5966-8 Second Avenue Limited rose@mhg.co.nz Residential zones Housing affordability H6.6 Rules
vacant sites are developed within the RUB
5967-1 Mutual Investments Trust deanne@mhg.co.nz
control
Building demolition control J.3.6 Rules and mapping Delete the Pre-1944 demolition control overlay at 46-48 Balmoral Road, Balmoral.
5967-2 Mutual Investments Trust deanne@mhg.co.nz Trees
Trees
Notable Trees
Delete the 'Notable tree' scheduling of the pohutukawa at 46-48 Balmoral Road, Balmoral (ID
895) and remove the natural heritage overlay.
5967-3 Mutual Investments Trust deanne@mhg.co.nz General Cross plan matters Delete floor to floor / ceiling height minimums in all zones.
5967-4 Mutual Investments Trust deanne@mhg.co.nz Definitions Existing
Delete the term 'gross site area' in the subdivision development control and replace with the
term 'gross site area', as defined and illustrated in the Auckland Council District Plan (Rodney
Section). Refer to details at page 5/7 of the submission (paragraph 4.2(c)).
5967-5 Mutual Investments Trust deanne@mhg.co.nz Definitions Existing
Amend the definition of 'Height' to include the wording "the vertical distance between the
highest part of the building and the average level of the ground at the external foundations of
the buildings", as set out in the Auckland Council District Plan (Isthmus Section).
5967-6 Mutual Investments Trust deanne@mhg.co.nz General Cross plan matters
Delete the maximum storey control in order that maximum height is the sole development
control that controls height.
5967-7 Mutual Investments Trust deanne@mhg.co.nz
Centre) Business
Special information
requirements
Delete the requirement for provision of a wind report for buildings higher than 20m where a
canopy is provided over public spaces or where the site is a rear site.
5967-8 Mutual Investments Trust deanne@mhg.co.nz General Chapter G General provisions
statements Delete the requirement to provide a Design Statement.
5967-9 Mutual Investments Trust deanne@mhg.co.nz Mana Whenua General provisions
assessment
Refine the circumstances in which a Cultural Impact Assessment or engagement with Iwi are
required.
5967-10 Mutual Investments Trust deanne@mhg.co.nz Sustainable Development C7.7/H6.4 Sustainable design
Building Challenge.
5967-11 Mutual Investments Trust deanne@mhg.co.nz Residential zones Housing affordability H6.6 Rules
Delete the requirement to provide 10% affordable housing for development of greater than 15
sites / dwellings inside the RUB.
5968-1 Masfen Holdings Limited markb@mhg.co.nz Zoning North and Islands Rezone 3 Akorange Drive, Northcote from General Business to Mixed Use.
5968-2 Masfen Holdings Limited markb@mhg.co.nz Built Environment (Overlays)
Height Control
Amend the height controls at 3 Akoranga Drive Northcote, by adding an additional height
overlay or precinct plan that specifies maximum height of 16.5m, 24.5m and 32.5m for
different parts of the site and a 6m setback for building mass above 4 storeys. Refer to
submission for details Page 9-10/21.
5968-3 Masfen Holdings Limited markb@mhg.co.nz
Centre) Business
Park zones
Delete minimum finished floor to floor height of 3.6 in rule 4.8(3) for non-residential uses
above ground level for all business zones.
5968-4 Masfen Holdings Limited markb@mhg.co.nz Mana Whenua General provisions
assessment Delete Cultural Impact Assessment provisions.
5968-5 Masfen Holdings Limited markb@mhg.co.nz General Chapter G General provisions
Amend 1.4 'Applying for resource consent' by deleting the third paragraph under Assessment
Criteria or clarify that the matters of discretion and assessment criteria for Controlled and
Restricted Discretionary Activities are the sole matters of assessment of these types of
consents.
5968-6 Masfen Holdings Limited markb@mhg.co.nz General Chapter G General provisions
statements Delete the requirements for separate design statements.
5968-7 Masfen Holdings Limited markb@mhg.co.nz General Cross plan matters Delete the storey component from the building height rules for all zones.
5968-8 Masfen Holdings Limited markb@mhg.co.nz Sustainable Development C7.7/H6.4 Sustainable design Delete 6.4 in its entirety, including rules.
36/1145
Sub#/
5968-9 Masfen Holdings Limited markb@mhg.co.nz Residential zones Housing affordability
and policies Delete the affordable housing provisions in their entirety, including rules.
Centre) Business
& Bus. Park zones
Amend to provide for Retail Activities of any GFA [gross floor area] as a permitted activity at
the following properties: 3 Akoranga Drive, Northcote, 199B Lincoln Road, Henderson, 69 St
Georges Bay Road, 79 St Georges Bay Road, Parnell.
5968-11 Masfen Holdings Limited markb@mhg.co.nz Zoning West
Rezone the land fronting Lincoln Road from 199 Lincoln Road to 237 Lincoln Road and 185 -
187 Universal Drive, Henderson, to Mixed Use or, General Business.
Centre) Business
Park zones Delete rule 4.8 'Minimum floor to floor height'.
Centre) Business I3.2 Notification Delete rule 2 'Notification'.
Centre) Business
I3.5 Development controls
Light and Heavy Industry
zones
Amend to provide for offices as a Permitted activity along the Lincoln Road frontage [infer 199-
237 Lincoln Road].
Centre) Business
zones
Amend rule 5.3 'Impervious Area Threshold' to provide that sites already lawfully exceeding
the 80% impermeable surface rule shall have existing use rights if they are being
redeveloped.
5968-16 Masfen Holdings Limited markb@mhg.co.nz Special Character
& C
character statements - Res.
Isthmus
Delete the Special Character Residential Isthmus A, B and C overlay from 21 and 23 Judges
Bay road and 17 and 23 Bridgewater Road, Parnell.
control
Delete the Pre-1944 Building Demolition Control overlay from 25 and 17 Bridgewater Road,
Parnell.
5968-18 Masfen Holdings Limited markb@mhg.co.nz Mana Whenua
Whenua
Delete the Sites and Places of Value to Mana Whenua overlay from 21 and 23 Judges Bay
Road and 23 Bridgewater Road, Parnell.
5968-19 Masfen Holdings Limited markb@mhg.co.nz Zoning Central
Retain Local Centre zone on Eastridge Shopping Centre, 209 Kepa Road (Lot 1 DP 167 500)
and 215 Kepa Road (Lot 2 DP 167 500), Mission Bay.
5968-20 Masfen Holdings Limited markb@mhg.co.nz Precincts - Central New Precincts Other New Precincts
Add a concept plan that outlines areas for different building heights and possible connections
at Eastridge Shopping Centre, 209 Kepa Road (Lot 1 DP 167 500) and 215 Kepa Road (Lot 2
DP 167 500), Mission Bay. Refer to submission, page 12/100.
Centre) Business
Park zones
Amend height rules for Eastridge Shopping Centre, 209 Kepa Road (Lot 1 DP 167 500) and
215 Kepa Road (Lot 2 DP 167 500), Mission Bay to specify a maximum height of 20.5m and
32.5m to apply to different parts of the site; and a setback of 6m for building mass above
16.5. Refer to submission page 12-13/100.
Centre)
Overlay E4.5 Identified Growth
Corridor
Delete restrictions on retailing/offices for Eastridge Shopping Centre, 209 Kepa Road (Lot 1
DP 167 500) and 215 Kepa Road (Lot 2 DP 167 500), Mission Bay.
SEAs
Land
Remove the SEA overlay from Eastridge Shopping Centre 215 Kepa Road (Lot 2 DP 167
500), Mission Bay.
5968-24 Masfen Holdings Limited markb@mhg.co.nz Mana Whenua
Whenua
whenua
Delete the sites and places of value to Mana Whenua overlay from Eastridge Shopping
Centre 215 Kepa Road (Lot 2 DP 167 500), Mission Bay.
5968-25 Masfen Holdings Limited markb@mhg.co.nz Zoning Central Retain the Mixed Use zone at 69 - 79 St Georges Bay Road (Lot 1 and 2 DP 80621), Parnell.
Centre) Business
Park zones
Amend the maximum height for 69 - 79 St Georges Bay Road (Lot 1 and 2 DP 80621),
Parnell to 165m, 24.5m and 32.5m for different parts of the site, and a 6m setback for building
mass above 16.5m, where height is to be taken above the RL [Reduced Level] of the nearest
boundary point. Refer to submission for details, page 20-30/100.
5968-27 Masfen Holdings Limited markb@mhg.co.nz Zoning Central Retain Metropolitan Centre zone on 61 - 73 Davis Crescent, Newmarket.
Centre) Business
Park zones Amend the maximum height for the Newmarket Metropolitan Centre zone to 72.5m.
Overlay Special character
Business
Character Statements - Bus.
Delete the character defining notation [special character overlay] from 61 - 73 Davis
Crescent, Newmarket.
Business
Delete the special character - business [Newmarket] overlay from 61 - 73 Davis Crescent,
Newmarket.
5968-31 Masfen Holdings Limited markb@mhg.co.nz Precincts - Central Newmarket 1 K2.11 Precinct Rules Delete the Floor Area ratio from 61 - 73 Davis Crescent, Newmarket.
5968-32 Masfen Holdings Limited markb@mhg.co.nz Precincts - Central Newmarket 1 K2.11 Precinct Rules
Amend precinct control 2.11 'Newmarket' to [delete the Floor Area Ratio and retain a
maximum height of 72.5] at 61-73 Davis Crescent, Newmarket. Refer to pages 31-50/100 of
submission.
Rezone 9-15 Davis Crescent and the surrounding properties on Carlton Gore Road, Short
Street and Alma Street, Newmarket to Metropolitan Centre zone. Refer to page 55/100 of
submission.
37/1145
Sub#/
Centre) Business
Park zones Amend the height limit on 9-15 Davis Crescent, Newmarket to 56.5m.
Business
Remove the Historic Character [Special Character] overlay from 9 - 15 Davis Crescent,
Newmarket.
Retain Business Metropolitan Centre zone on 42-56 Davis Crescent and 77 and 77a
Broadway, Newmarket.
Business
Delete the special character business overlay from 42-56 Davis Crescent and 77 and 77a
Broadway, Newmarket
5968-38 Masfen Holdings Limited markb@mhg.co.nz Precincts - Central Newmarket 1 K2.11 Precinct Rules Delete the floor area ratio from 42-56 Davis Crescent and 77 and 77a Broadway, Newmarket.
5968-39 Masfen Holdings Limited markb@mhg.co.nz Precincts - Central Newmarket 1 K2.11 Precinct Rules Delete the floor area ratio rules.
Centre) Business
& Bus. Park zones
Amend activity status for 'new buildings' and 'additions and alterations to buildings not
otherwise provided for' to be a Controlled activity, with assessment criteria to be confined to
the list contained and described within clause 3.6.2.5.
Add a Restricted Discretionary activity rule for 'Intrusions into volcanic cone site lines', which
specifies the information to be provided including a visual impact assessment. Refer to
submission page 97-98/100.
5968-42 Masfen Holdings Limited markb@mhg.co.nz Transport Auckland -wide
requirements Retain the Parking City Fringe Area overlay provisions in the Newmarket area.
Centre) Business
[Amend the rules to] retain the same business activities that are permitted, controlled or
restricted discretionary under the Operative District Plan at 199 Lincoln Road to 237 Lincoln
Road, Henderson. See page 5/7 of submission.
5969-1 Kristeen Scott ray4kris@slingshot.co.nz Zoning Central
Rezone Herdman Street, Daventry Street and Waterbank Street, Waterview from Mixed
Housing Urban to Mixed Housing Suburban to provide for a maximum building height of 2
storeys.
5970-1 Graham J Thomas
38 D'oyly Drive, Stanmore Bay,
Whangaparaoa, Auckland 0932 Residential zones Residential
General Amend rules to be more flexible without the need to notify.
5970-2 Graham J Thomas
38 D'oyly Drive, Stanmore Bay,
Whangaparaoa, Auckland 0932 Mana Whenua General provisions
assessment
No specific decision requested, express concerns about Cultural Impact Assessments and
associated cost.
5971-1 Denise A Tuely denise.tuely@husqvarnagroup.com Mineral extraction
Overlay E1.7/J1.7 Quarry
Transport Route Delete the Quarry Transport Route overlay from Alfriston Road, Alfriston.
5972-1 Damodara R Thangella damodarareddyt@yahoo.com Zoning Central
Rezone land at 180 White Swan Road, Mt Roskill, from Mixed Housing Suburban to Mixed
use or Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings zone.
5972-2 Damodara R Thangella damodarareddyt@yahoo.com
control
Building demolition control J.3.6 Rules and mapping Delete pre-144 demolition control overaly from land at 180 White Swan Road, Mt Roskill.
5973-1 Allan K Tapp
5 Ardlui Avenue, Manly,
Whangaparaoa, Auckland 0930 Mana Whenua
Whenua
objectives and policies Delete sites of value to Mana Whenua.
5974-1 Matthew Searle matthewjsearle@gmail.com Future Urban
Split Future Urban zone into two sub-zones, short-term and long-term, one showing areas
suitable for development in the next 10 years, and another beyond that with specific controls,
especially for long-term
5974-2 Matthew Searle matthewjsearle@gmail.com Residential zones Residential
General
Delete front yard setback rules or amend to reduce the required setback, particularly in zones
where intensification is anticipated.
5974-3 Matthew Searle matthewjsearle@gmail.com Residential zones Residential Land use controls
Delete density limits for four or more dwellings in the Mixed Housing Suburban zone, and
density limits should not apply to the Mixed Housing Urban zone
5974-4 Matthew Searle matthewjsearle@gmail.com Transport Auckland -wide
requirements Remove parking minimums from Mixed Housing Urban and Mixed Housing Suburban
requirements Remove parking minimums for Tavern activities
5974-6 Matthew Searle matthewjsearle@gmail.com Built Environment (Overlays)
Height Control
Amend to increase height limits for some areas zoned for Mixed Use, e.g. Morningside,
Newton, close to high quality public transport infrastructure
5974-7 Matthew Searle matthewjsearle@gmail.com Zoning Central
Rezone all areas between Morningside train station, and St Lukes Shopping Centre,
Morningside from Light Industrial, to Mixed Use
Rezone the area bounded by May Road to the west, Mt Albert Road, Mt Albert, to the north,
SH20 to the south and Mt Roskill Grammar to the East, to Terrace Housing and Apartment
Buildings
5974-9 Matthew Searle matthewjsearle@gmail.com Built Environment (Overlays)
Height Control
Amend to increase height control to the sides of Great North Road between Ponsonby Road,
Ponsonby and Surrey Crescent, Grey Lynn, to enable a higher height limit.
Rezone areas within a 800m walk of Meadowbank train station to either Terraced Housing
and Apartment Buildings or Mixed Housing Urban
38/1145
Sub#/
Rezone areas already zoned Mixed Housing Suburban within the area bounded by New North
Road in the west, the city fringe in the north, SH20 in the south and Great South Road in the
east to Mixed Housing Urban
Rezone Light Industry along both sides of Great South Road, between Greenlane East/West,
Greenlane, and Main Highway, Ellerslie to Mixed Use
5974-13 Matthew Searle matthewjsearle@gmail.com Residential zones Residential Land use controls Retain rule 3.3 The conversion of an existing dwelling into two dwellings.
5974-14 Matthew Searle matthewjsearle@gmail.com
Centre) Business
& Bus. Park zones Retain restrictions on retail and office activity outside centre zones
requirements Retain not having parking minimums in the various zones listed in Table 3
5974-16 Matthew Searle matthewjsearle@gmail.com RPS Urban growth
Retain the zoning of areas close to rapid transit or high frequent public transport to zones that
enable intensification - particularly Mixed Use, Terraced Housing and Apartment Buildings or
a Centre zone
5975-1 Kathleen Simpkins maungatani4@hotmail.com Residential zones Residential
Delete the rules that enable 3-5 storey buildings [in the Mixed Housing Urban and Mixed
Housing Suburban zones] in Devonport.
5975-2 Kathleen Simpkins maungatani4@hotmail.com RPS Urban growth
quality compact urban form Require roading improvements to Lake Road and Esmonde Road [prior to intensification].
5975-3 Kathleen Simpkins maungatani4@hotmail.com RPS Urban growth B2.7 Social infrastructure
Provide for additional and extended schools in the Devonport area and surrounding suburbs
[prior to intensification].
5975-4 Kathleen Simpkins maungatani4@hotmail.com
Centre) Business
& Bus. Park zones
Provide for additional supermarket in the Devonport area and surrounding suburbs [prior
to intensification].
5975-5 Kathleen Simpkins maungatani4@hotmail.com RPS Urban growth
Provide for additional open space in the Devonport area and surrounding suburbs [prior to
intensification].
5976-1 Mike Wood diana@opc.net.nz RPS Changes to the RUB North and Waiheke Island
Rezone 63 Riverland Road and adjacent land (as per map on page 4/14 of submission),
Riverhead from Rural Production to Future Urban and include within the RUB.
5976-2 Mike Wood diana@opc.net.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - Urban zones
except Rural
Amend to provide for subdivision to a minimum site size of 4000m
2
, where a plan is provided
showing that the subdivision does not compromise the ability to use the land for urban
purposes in the future.
5977-1 Jan I Trupinic janivantrupinic@gmail.com Precincts - North New Precincts All other New Precincts
Add a special area or 'precinct' to the southern-most end of Birkenhead Ave. Enforce special
controls only in this area for driveway design and restrict the amount of space for driveways
for each new house built here. Provide separated cycle lanes. Make special provisions for car
ports and parking areas for residents that are close to the road. Add design controls over new
apartments or terraced house developments so they are compatible with older houses. Give
land owners incentives to develop their land with apartments
5978-1 Barry P Thwaites lynne.barry@xtra.co.nz Built Environment (Overlays)
Height Control Reduce heights in Orewa to a range from 8.5m (2 storeys) to 16.5m (4 storeys).
5979-1
The Auckland District Council
of Social Services a.maynard@xtra.co.nz RPS Urban growth
Retain the concept of a compact city and intensification focused around public transport and
centres.
5979-2
Increase the percentage of the Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings zone from 5% to
7%, the Mixed Housing Urban zone from 10% to 20% across urban Auckland especially
around town centres and transport nodes and reduce the percentage of the Mixed Housing
Suburban zone from 40% to 28%.
5979-3
B2.4 Neighbourhoods that
retain affordable housing Support the Housing Action Plan and increase its active pursuit and resourcing.
5979-4
of Social Services a.maynard@xtra.co.nz Residential zones Housing affordability H6.6 Rules
Amend the minimum affordable housing provisions to 15% within 3 years for all significant
new housing developments and encourage and incentivise a minimum of 20% where
practical.
5979-5
of Social Services a.maynard@xtra.co.nz General Miscellaneous
Operational/
Develop intensified affordable housing on Council own land especially in existing pensioner
housing complexes.
5979-6
of Social Services a.maynard@xtra.co.nz General Miscellaneous Special housing areas Support affordable Special Housing Areas.
5979-7
of Social Services a.maynard@xtra.co.nz Historic Heritage (Overlay)
Heritage J2.2 Development controls
Strengthen the protection of heritage to ensure it can not be demolished or significantly
modified without being publicly notified.
5979-8
of Social Services a.maynard@xtra.co.nz Special Character
residential
Strengthen the protection of character and architecturally significant buildings and
structures to ensure they can not be demolished or significantly modified without
being publicly notified.
5979-9
of Social Services a.maynard@xtra.co.nz
control
Retain the requirement for a resource consent for the demolition or substantial modification of
pre-1944 places [infer retain the activity status].
39/1145
Sub#/
5979-10
of Social Services a.maynard@xtra.co.nz Historic Heritage (Overlay)
Heritage
Places Retain all scheduled sites.
5979-11
of Social Services a.maynard@xtra.co.nz Special Character
residential
special character areas Retain the sites within the overlay.
5979-12
Operational/
Increase the resources and priority to identify and protect heritage and special character
areas.
5979-13
of Social Services a.maynard@xtra.co.nz General Chapter G General provisions G2.4 Notification
Amend the notification provisions to require notification to immediate neighbours for a
resource consent to exceed any zone requirements especially an increase in intensification,
height or change of use.
5979-14
Centre) Business
Park zones Retain the permitted heights for each category of town centres.
5979-15
Operational/
Projects/Acquisition Provide or require more integrated, reliable, frequent and affordable public transport.
5979-16
of Social Services a.maynard@xtra.co.nz Residential zones Residential Land use controls Retain the provisions that provide for 'granny flat' type units attached to existing dwellings.
5979-17
of Social Services a.maynard@xtra.co.nz Residential zones Residential
General Retain the provisions for universal access.
5979-18
of Social Services a.maynard@xtra.co.nz General C7.4/H6.3 Signs Delete the provisions for signs and billboards and manage these through bylaws.
5979-19
of Social Services a.maynard@xtra.co.nz Infrastructure
Transmission Corridor J1.4 Rules and mapping Retain the provisions that encourage the undergrounding of high voltage transmission lines.
5979-20
of Social Services a.maynard@xtra.co.nz Infrastructure
Transmission Corridor J1.4 Rules and mapping Retain the provisions that do not excessively restrict land use near transmission lines.
5979-21
organisms
modified organisms Retain subject to deletion of the rule that excludes veterinary vaccines.
5980-1
Hauraki Gulf Investment
Limited fiona@campbellbrown.co.nz Zoning Central Rezone land at 817 Mt Eden Road from Single House to Neighbourhood Centre zone.
5981-1 Paula Maddren
83 Laurence Street, Manly,
Whangaparaoa, Auckland 0930 RPS Mana Whenua B5 Strategic
Delete rights and authority given to any section of the community that have not been
democratically elected.
5981-2 Paula Maddren
83 Laurence Street, Manly,
Whangaparaoa, Auckland 0930 Mana Whenua
Whenua
objectives and policies Delete reference and requirements of the 200m circles.
5982-1
Robert and Dianne Wynn-
Parke et al richard@forminteriordesign.co.nz Residential zones Residential
General
Amend minimum apartment sizes: Studio = 45m
2
; 1 bedroom = 60m
2
, 2 bedroom = 75m
2
; 3
bedroom = 110m
2
; minimum deck size = 10m
2
; minimum stud height = 2.7m; minimum street
height to first level 4.5m
5982-2
Parke et al richard@forminteriordesign.co.nz Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
Amend car parking ratio to be 1-3 car parks per apartment (depending on apartment size) as
a condition of any development
5982-3
Parke et al richard@forminteriordesign.co.nz Built Environment (Overlays)
Height Control
Amend heights in the area bounded by Ian McKinnon Drive, Alex Evans, Symonds Street &
Newton Road, Newton, from 32.5m down to 15m
5982-4
Height Control
Amend heights in the area bounded by Symonds St, Khyber Pass, Grafton, and the Motorway
to 20m
5982-5
Height Control
Amend heights in the area bounded by Khyber Pass Road, The Railway Line, New North
Road, Newton, to 32.5m
5982-6
Height Control
Amend heights in the area bounded by New North Road, Ian McKinnon Drive, Newton Road
and Symonds St, Eden Terrace, to 32.5m
5983-1 Simon Priddy
18 Creamer Avenue, Belmont,
Auckland 0622 Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Mapping
Delete sub-precinct D from around Plymouth Crescent, Portsmouth Street and Roberts
Avenue, Bayswater.
5983-2 Simon Priddy
18 Creamer Avenue, Belmont,
Auckland 0622 Zoning North and Islands
Retain the Mixed Housing Suburban zone for the area included in sub-precinct D of
the Devonport Peninsula precinct (Plymouth Crescent, Portsmouth Street and Roberts
Avenue, Bayswater).
5984-1 Barnett Family Trust
130 Shaw Road, Oratia, Auckland
0604 Precincts - West
Area K7.9.1 Rules (sub-precinct A)
Amend '"enhancement area" provisions affecting land at and around 136 Shaw Road, Oratia,
such that it only applies to lots that have not yet been subdivided.
5985-1 GM Welsford Family Trust maxd@andrewstewart.co.nz Zoning North and Islands Rezone 8 Stevensens Crescent, Albany Heights from Large Lot to Mixed Housing Suburban.
5986-1 Jane Admore admore.power@xtra.co.nz Residential zones Residential
policies Rezone more areas to Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings
5986-2 Jane Admore admore.power@xtra.co.nz Transport Auckland -wide
requirements Amend car parking rules to reduce mandarory provisions
40/1145
Sub#/
5986-3 Jane Admore admore.power@xtra.co.nz Transport Auckland -wide
requirements Retain mandatory cycle parking in large commercial and public premises
5987-1 Tim Vallings linda.grammer@gmail.com RPS Natural resources
B6.6 Genetically Modified
Organisms Retain and strengthen if necessary all provisions.
5988-1 Eruiti Limited
32 Rushden Terrace, Red Beach,
Apply a zoning to 5 Mill Road, Helensville that provides the ability to apply for consent for a
retirement village.
5989-1 Kelvin Hill hillbillees@clear.net.nz General Chapter A Introduction A3 Strategic Framework Retain structure of PAUP that replaces all previous Auckland plans.
5989-2 Kelvin Hill hillbillees@clear.net.nz Special Character
residential
Require Council to undertake a historic heritage and special character assessment of the area
around Western Springs / Morningside. Refer to details in submission at page 10/11.
5989-3 Kelvin Hill hillbillees@clear.net.nz Special Character
residential
Prohibit demolition of pre-1944 houses until a historic heritage and special character
assessment of the area around Western Springs / Morningside has been undertaken, and
protection extended to newly identified historic heritage and special character areas. Refer to
details in submission at page 10/11.
5989-4 Kelvin Hill hillbillees@clear.net.nz
control
Amend the PAUP to provide for demolition of any historic or special character houses [in the
area around Western Springs / Morningside] as a discretionary activity, rather than restricted
discretionary. Refer to details in submission at page 11/11.
5989-5 Kelvin Hill hillbillees@clear.net.nz Zoning Central
Rezone land in the Western Springs / Morningside area from Terrace Housing and Apartment
Building to Mixed Housing Suburban zone.
Rezone the shops along New North Road, Kingsland, and the corner of Western Springs
Road, Kingsland, from Local Centre to Neighbourhood Centre zone.
5989-7 Kelvin Hill hillbillees@clear.net.nz General Chapter G General provisions G2.4 Notification
Amend notification rule to include the following, or words to like effect: "Ensure residents are
involved when effects on the surrounding neighbourhood would more than minor".
5989-8 Kelvin Hill hillbillees@clear.net.nz General Chapter G General provisions G2.4 Notification
Amend notification rule to require public notification for restricted discretionary activities.
Refer to details in submission at page 11/11.
5989-9 Kelvin Hill hillbillees@clear.net.nz Water Aquifers/Groundwater
Include the Western Springs and Morningside area, in particular Western Springs Road,
Mountain View Road, Springfield Road, Bannerman Road, Finch Street, within the Natural
Resources overlay due to presence of natural springs in the area.
Reduce housing density to a minimum in those parts of the Western Springs / Morningside
area affected by land stability.
5989-11 Kelvin Hill hillbillees@clear.net.nz Residential zones Residential
policies
Reduce housing density to a minimum in those parts of the Western Springs / Morningside
area affected by flooding.
5990-1 Troy Hoogeveen troynh@hotmail.com
control
Delete the pre-1944 demolition control overlay from the property at 68-74 Larchwood Avenue,
Westmere.
5991-1
Grey Lynn Urban
Environments
PO Box 52058, Kingsland, Auckland
1352 Residential zones Residential Land use controls
Amend rule 3.1(1) Maximum density Table 1, 'Single House Zone' to read: One dwelling per
site or two where the requirements of clause 3.3 below are met.
5991-2
Grey Lynn Urban
Environments
Amend rule 3.1(2)(b) Maximum density, to read: each proposed dwelling is setback at least
4m and no more than 5m from the frontage of the site or, the average setback of the adjoining
existing dwellings, whichever is the lesser.
5991-3
Grey Lynn Urban
Environments
Amend rule 3.1(3)(b) Maximum density, to read: each proposed dwelling is setback at least
2.5m and no more than 5m from the frontage of the site or, the average setback of the
adjoining existing dwellings, whichever is the lesser.
5991-4
Grey Lynn Urban
Environments
Amend rule 3.3(2)(b) Maximum density, to read: have a common wall with the primary
dwelling of no less than 3m in length or share a ceiling and/or floor with the primary dwelling
or, have a net internal area of no more than 80m2.
5991-5
Grey Lynn Urban
Environments
1352 Residential zones Residential Land use controls Delete rule 3.3(3) The conversion of and existing dwelling into two dwellings.
5991-6
Grey Lynn Urban
Environments
1352 Residential zones Residential
and Coastal Settlement zone
Amend rule 6.3(1)(a) Height in relation to boundary, to read: Building must not project beyond
the applicable recession plane shown in figures 3 and 4 (J.3.3 Special Character 4.3)
measured from any point above 2.5m above the ground level of any boundary of the site other
than a boundary adjoining a road or Open Space zone.
5991-7
Grey Lynn Urban
Environments
Amend rule 6.3(1)(b) Height in relation to boundary, to read: Where buildings adjoin the road,
they must not project beyond a building envelope contained by the 55-degree recession plane
from points 2.5m above any boundary adjacent to the road as shown in figures 3 and 4 (J.3.3
Special Character 4.3).
5991-8
Grey Lynn Urban
Environments
Amend rule 6.9(1)(b) Outdoor living space, to read: excludes any area with a dimension less
than 3m.
5991-9
Grey Lynn Urban
Environments
and Coastal Settlement zone Amend rule 6.10(1) Fences, to read: must not exceed a height of 1.2m
41/1145
Sub#/
5991-10
Grey Lynn Urban
Environments
Amend rule 6.11(1) Garages, to read: A garage building facing the street must be no greater
than 40 per cent of the width of the front facade.
5991-11
Grey Lynn Urban
Environments
and Coastal Settlement zone Delete rule 6.11(2) Garages.
5991-12
Grey Lynn Urban
Environments
and Coastal Settlement zone Delete rule 6.12 Universal access.
5991-13
Grey Lynn Urban
Environments
Amend rule 7.3(1)(a) Height in relation to boundary, to read: Buildings must not project
beyond the applicable recession plane shown in figures 3 and 4 (J.3.3 Special Character 4.3)
measured from any point 2.5m above the ground level of any boundary of the site other than a
boundary adjoining a road or Open Space zone.
5991-14
Grey Lynn Urban
Environments
Amend rule 7.5 Yards, Table 5 ['Front' row, inferred from submission] to read: No minimum,
as rule 3.1(2)(b).
5991-15
Grey Lynn Urban
Environments
Add to rule 7.11 Seperation between buildings within a site: manage privacy and access to
direct sunlight.
5991-16
Grey Lynn Urban
Environments
Mixed Housing Urban zone Add to rule 7.11(4) Seperation between buildings within a site: with a minimum of 10m.
5991-17
Grey Lynn Urban
Environments
Add to rule 7.11(10) Separation between buildings: The largest area of glazing for the
principal living room must not be oriented toward 45 degrees either side of south.
5991-18
Grey Lynn Urban
Environments
than 3m.
5991-19
Grey Lynn Urban
Environments
Amend rule 7.16(1) Garages, to read: A garage building facing a street must be no greater
5991-20
Grey Lynn Urban
Environments
Add to rule 7.18(1) Minimum dimension of principal living rooms and principal bedrooms, the
following: and be no less than 12m2.
5991-21
Grey Lynn Urban
Environments
Add to rule 7.18(3)Minimum dimension of principal living rooms and principal bedrooms, the
following: The finished floor to ceiling height of habitable rooms must be at least 2.55m.
5991-22
Grey Lynn Urban
Environments
Amend rule 8.6 Yards, Table 6 ['Front' row, inferred from submission] to read: No minimum,
as rule 3.1(2)(b).
5991-23
Grey Lynn Urban
Environments
Add to rule 8.11 Seperation between buildings the following: manage privacy and access to
direct sunlight.
5991-24
Grey Lynn Urban
Environments
Mixed Housing Urban zone Add to rule 8.11(4) Separation between buildings: with a minimum of 10m.
5991-25
Grey Lynn Urban
Environments
Add to rule 8.11(10) Seperation between buildings, the following: The largest area of glazing
for the principal living room must not be oriented toward 45 degrees either side of south.
5991-26
Grey Lynn Urban
Environments
than 3m.
5991-27
Grey Lynn Urban
Environments
Amend rule 8.16(1) Garages to read: A garage building facing a street must be no greater
5991-28
Grey Lynn Urban
Environments
Add to rule 8.19(1) Minimum dimension of principal living rooms and principal bedrooms, as
follows: and be no less than 12m2.
5991-29
Grey Lynn Urban
Environments
Add to rule 8.19(3) Minimum dimension of principal living rooms and principal bedrooms, as
follows: The finished floor to ceiling height of habitable rooms must be at least 2.55m.
42/1145
Sub#/
5991-30
Grey Lynn Urban
Environments
1352 Special Character
General J3.5.1 - J3.5.6 Rules
Add to Development Control 3.3(1) ['Garages / carports']: A garage building facing a street
must be no greater than 40 per cent of the width of the front faade.
5991-31
Grey Lynn Urban
Environments
General J3.5.1 - J3.5.6 Rules Delete assessment criteria 5.2(2)(a)(vi).
5991-32
Grey Lynn Urban
Environments
1352 Zoning Central
Rezone the Eastern side of Richmond Road, Grey Lynn between Hakanoa and Sackville
Streets from Single House to Mixed Use.
5991-33
Grey Lynn Urban
Environments
& C
Isthmus
Add Special Character overlay to the Eastern side of Richmond Road, Grey Lynn between
Hakanoa and Sackville Streets.
5991-34
Grey Lynn Urban
Environments
1352 Zoning Central
Rezone the Northern side of Crummer Road, Grey Lynn between Coleridge Street and Great
North Road from Single House to Mixed Use.
5991-35
Grey Lynn Urban
Environments
& C
Isthmus
Add Special Character overlay to the Northern side of Crummer Road, Grey Lynn between
Coleridge Street and Great North Road.
5991-36
Grey Lynn Urban
Environments
1352 Zoning Central
Rezone the Northern side of Great North Road, between Surrey Crescent and Bullock Track
from Single House to Mixed Housing Suburban.
5992-1
Northern Region Equestrian
Trust viv@nzhorseriders.info Subdivision Auckland-wide - general
controls
Amend to require subdivision to include a 5m minimum greenway / bridlepath along the
boundaries of the area.
5992-2
Trust viv@nzhorseriders.info Rural Zones
D6.6 Countryside Living zone
desc, obs & pols
Add to Objective 1: 'Rural living may include the keeping of livestock or companion animals,
niche production, and sustainable living will be encouraged'.
5992-3
desc, obs & pols
Amend Policy 1(f) to require that land use and subdivision development does not obstruct the
use of rural berms as bridlepaths. Refer to page 5/41 of the submission for details.
5992-4
desc, obs & pols
Add a new policy that states 'Countryside Living Zones will not be used for pyrotechnics
manufacture, distribution or testing'.
5992-5
desc, obs & pols
Add a new policy that states 'Countryside Living land use and subdivision development should
support a sustainable future'.
5992-6
Trust viv@nzhorseriders.info Precincts Ak-Wide and Coastal Greenfield urban
Add a new objective and policy [in F1.2] that requires land to be vested for greenways /
bridlepaths [inferred].
5992-7
Trust viv@nzhorseriders.info Precincts Ak-Wide and Coastal Greenfield urban
Add a new objective and policy [in F1.2] to protect access for non-motorised transport
(walking, cycling and horse riding) across the development to and from existing recreation and
rural landscapes.
5992-8
Trust viv@nzhorseriders.info
(ITA)
Add a rule to make the manufacturing, training or testing of explosives and
pyrotechnics not permitted in any rural zone unless there is a minimum 200m buffer zone from
neighbouring properties.
5992-9
Trust viv@nzhorseriders.info
(ITA)
Add a rule to restrict the testing, training and display of pyrotechnics to land that is specifically
set aside for defence force training or activities or to areas that have specific consents
regarding noise disturbance to neighbours, livestock and companion animals.
5992-10
Trust viv@nzhorseriders.info Definitions Existing
Amend the definition of 'equestrian centre' to accurately reflect the various activities within the
equine sector, to exclude not-for-profit organisations and sports and recreation clubs rather
than just pony clubs, and to clarify the difference between equestrian centres and organised
sport and recreation. Refer to pages 9-10/41 of the submission for details.
5992-11
Trust viv@nzhorseriders.info Definitions Existing Amend the definition of 'organised sport and recreation' to delete 'recreation'.
5992-12
Amend the definition of 'sport and recreation structures' to delete the duplication of 'horse
jumps', and add 'Equestrian Arenas, and competitive all weather surfaces' and 'stables, pens
or stalls'.
5992-13
Amend the definition of 'showgrounds' to include 'livestock shows, competitions and events
including equestrian'.
5992-14
Trust viv@nzhorseriders.info Rural Zones General I13.1 Activity table
Amend to separate riding schools from commercial sporthorse and racehorse training centres
and to permit riding schools in all rural zones except the Rural Conservation zone.
5992-15
Amend to permit equestrian centres (sport horse or race horse training centres, and / or
sporting events facilities) in the Rural Production zone.
5992-16
Amend to permit equestrian centres (sport horse or race horse training centres, and / or
sporting events facilities) in the Mixed Rural zone.
5992-17
Amend to make equestrian centres (sport horse or race horse training centres, and / or
sporting events facilities) a Discretionary Activity in the Countryside Living zone.
5992-18
Amend to make equestrian centres (sport horse or race horse training centres, and / or
sporting events facilities) a Discretionary Activity in the Rural Coastal zone.
5992-19
Trust viv@nzhorseriders.info Precincts General Content Precincts General Content
Amend or add the local road design guides to include recreation trails and the Clevedon
precinct standards (including the amendments requested in this submission) for local roads in
all rural and rural boundary precincts including the Greenfield Urban precincts. Refer to
pages 14 and 19/41 of the submission for details.
43/1145
Sub#/
5992-20
Trust viv@nzhorseriders.info Precincts - North Huapai North
Amend the design guidelines in Appendix 5.3 to be consistent with the approach used in the
Clevedon precinct plan [inferred the non-statutory design guidelines in Part 6, Attachment 2.1
Clevedon precinct], especially in relation to recreation trails, bridlepaths and the recognition of
the value of the equine sector to the area.
5992-21
Amend the precinct plan to acknowledge the equestrian value to the area including Matua
Road, Oraha Road and the surrounding roads. Refer to page 15 and the map on page 16/41
5992-22
Amend the checklist for recreation in the design guidelines in Appendix 5.3 to include
bridleways or horse riding on shared paths.
5992-23
Amend to make Oraha Road and Matua Road 'local greenway roads' which make up part of
the proposed Coast to Coast recreation trails, unless offroad greenways are created as part a
result of subdivision. Refer to pages 15 and 21-41/41 of the submission for details.
5992-24
Amend to ensure subdivision within the precinct or between the precinct and Riverhead
Forest provides for bridlepaths / greenways / off road access from Matua Road to Oraha
Road and or Old North Road as public open space as part of development concessions.
5992-25
Clarify the public open space design guidelines [inferred in Appendix 5.3] to create links,
paths and trails to meet the Open Spaces strategy.
5992-26
Delete any precinct rules, (including Huapai North precinct), that require trees to be planted in
the road berm or in a coordinated manner or specifies the type of tree as part of a subdivision.
5992-27
Amend to ensure any precinct rules relating to the type and location of trees in road berms
also apply to light and utility poles. Refer to page 17/41 of the submission for details.
5992-28
Trust viv@nzhorseriders.info Precincts - North Long Bay
Amend to provide for non-vehicular travel between Long Bay Regional Park / Piripiri Reserve
and Vaughans Road including a multi-use greenway as part of the proposed Coast-to-Coast
bridleway / greenway. Refer to page 18/41 of the submission for details.
5992-29
Trust viv@nzhorseriders.info Precincts - North Riverhead 2
Amend to provide for tourism associated activities such as visitor accommodation, information
services and tourism retail.
5992-30
Trust viv@nzhorseriders.info Precincts - North Riverhead 4
Amend to provide for tourism associated activities such as accommodation, tourism services
and cafes.
5992-31
Trust viv@nzhorseriders.info Precincts - South Clevedon
Amend the design guidelines [Part 6, Attachment 2.1 Clevedon precinct] to delete the
requirement for bridlepaths to be separated from walking and cycling paths and instead base
the separation on expected usage levels. Refer to page 19/41 of the submission for details.
5993-1 Harsha Ravichandran harshavardhan1989@gmail.com Residential zones Residential
General
Remove or reduce front yard setback requirements in zones where intensification is
anticipated
5993-2 Harsha Ravichandran harshavardhan1989@gmail.com Residential zones Residential Land use controls
Remove density limits for development of four or more dwellings in the Mixed Housing
Suburban zone
5993-3 Harsha Ravichandran harshavardhan1989@gmail.com Residential zones Residential Land use controls Remove density limits from the Mixed Housing Urban zone
5993-4 Harsha Ravichandran harshavardhan1989@gmail.com Transport Auckland -wide
requirements Remove parking minimums from Mixed Housing Urban and Mixed Housing Suburban zones
5993-5 Harsha Ravichandran harshavardhan1989@gmail.com
Centre) Business
Park zones
Amend height limits for Mixed Use to reflect their locations close to high quality public
transport infrastructure
5993-6 Harsha Ravichandran harshavardhan1989@gmail.com Zoning Central
Rezone the central isthmus to Mixed Housing Urban or to Terrace Housing and Apartment
Building zone
5994-1 Ilse Schots ilse.schots@xtra.co.nz General Miscellaneous Other No specific relief sought.
5995-1 Alcohol Healthwatch amy@ahw.org.nz
Centre) Business
& Bus. Park zones Amend the activity status of alcohol to Discretionary.
5995-2 Alcohol Healthwatch amy@ahw.org.nz
Centre) Business
Ensure that the PAUP works in unison with the Local Alcohol Policy and any other alcohol-
related harm reduction work to maximise the controls that they have available to contribute to
the reduction of alcohol related harm.
5995-3 Alcohol Healthwatch amy@ahw.org.nz General Chapter G General provisions G2.4 Notification
Amend to require public notification for all resource consent applications for liquor based
entertainment and food and beverage which could be done through the Council website
similar to the system in Australia.
5995-4 Alcohol Healthwatch amy@ahw.org.nz RPS Urban growth
environment
Amend to maximise the opportunities in the PAUP to reduce alcohol-related harm indirectly
through measures such as controlling signage and visual amenity, lighting, use of public
space, temporary activities and Crime Prevention Through Environmental Design (CPTED).
5996-1 Clayton Mckenzie clayton.rachel@xtra.co.nz
SEAs
Land Delete the SEA affecting the land at 29 Umbria Lane, Whitford.
44/1145
Sub#/
5996-2 Clayton Mckenzie clayton.rachel@xtra.co.nz Built Environment (Overlays)
Overlay E4.3/J4.3 Ridgeline
Protection Delete the Ridgeline Protection overlay affecting the land at 29 Umbria Lane, Whitford.
5996-3 Clayton Mckenzie clayton.rachel@xtra.co.nz Precincts - South Whitford
Retain the operative 'Scenic Amenity' and associated rules under the Auckland Council
District Plan (Manukau Section) insofar as they relate to the property at 29 Umbria Lane,
Whitford.
5996-4 Clayton Mckenzie clayton.rachel@xtra.co.nz General Miscellaneous
Operational/
Projects/Acquisition Provide for alternative dispute resolution meetings prior to the formal hearing process.
5997-1 T Knight
PO Box 51445, Pakuranga, Auckland
2010 RPS Changes to the RUB South
Amend the PAUP with regard to the Rural Urban Boundary, Sunnyhills and Howick Ward. [No
specific relief provided]
5998-1 Blind Foundation hsonier@blindfoundation.org.nz General Miscellaneous Other
Support the submission made by Bledisloe Estate Trust in relation to the Foundation precinct
in Parnell and the submission by Don McKenzie in relation to making policies inclusive and
people centric.
5998-2 Blind Foundation hsonier@blindfoundation.org.nz General Cross plan matters
Include accessibility as a requirement for all activities and use specific accessibility standards
and guidelines as compliance and audit tools. Refer to pages 5 and 7/8 of the submission for
details.
5998-3 Blind Foundation hsonier@blindfoundation.org.nz Public Open Space Zones Public Open Space
I2.2-3 & I2.5 Land use & Dev.
controls & Spec. info. req.
Amend to require shared and public open spaces to be designed in an accessible way for
people who are blind or have low vision and to be developed in consultation with the disability
community and experts in universal design such as the Blind Foundation. Refer to pages 6-
5998-4 Blind Foundation hsonier@blindfoundation.org.nz RPS Urban growth
environment
Amend Policy 6 to strengthen the requirement for equal access. Refer to page 6/8 of the
submission for detials.
5998-5 Blind Foundation hsonier@blindfoundation.org.nz
Centre) Business
Amend Policy 4 to remove the word 'physical' to ensure that people who are blind or have low
vision are encompassed by the policy.
5998-6 Blind Foundation hsonier@blindfoundation.org.nz Infrastructure
C1.1 Infrastructure
background, objectives and
policies
Amend Policy 12 [inferred 1.1 'Infrastructure'] to add 'avoid impeding or causing a hazard for
people with vision impairments'. Refer to page 7/8 of the submission for retails.
5998-7 Blind Foundation hsonier@blindfoundation.org.nz Residential zones Residential
policies
Amend Policy 4 [inferred 1.1 'General objectives and policies for the residential zones'] to
require a percentage of medium and large residential developments to include a range of
housing, including affordable housing, that provides equal access and use for people of all
ages and abilities. Refer to page 7/8 of the submission for details.
5998-8 Blind Foundation hsonier@blindfoundation.org.nz General Miscellaneous Consultation and engagement
Continue ongoing engagement and consultation with the disability community and agencies of
interest throughout the implementation of the Unitary Plan.
5999-1 Kevin Bligh kmbligh@gmail.com General
GIS viewer Delete the Flood Prone area overlay.
GIS viewer Delete the Flood Plain overlay
GIS viewer Delete the Flood Prone overlay from properties along Cricket Avenue, Mt Eden.
GIS viewer Delete the Flood Plain overlay from properties along Cricket Avenue, Mt Eden.
5999-5 Kevin Bligh kmbligh@gmail.com RPS Natural resources B6.7 Natural hazards Amend whole section based on submission [no specific relief stated] pages 3/9 and 4/9.
5999-6 Kevin Bligh kmbligh@gmail.com Natural Hazards and Flooding Flooding
and policies
Amend all Objectives and Policies [in particular Policy 3] to recognise and provide for
development of sites to occur as permitted activities within flood areas subject to not
increasing the number of dwellings on the site.
5999-7 Kevin Bligh kmbligh@gmail.com Natural Hazards and Flooding Flooding H4.12 Rules Delete flooding rules.
5999-8 Kevin Bligh kmbligh@gmail.com Natural Hazards and Flooding Flooding H4.12 Rules
Amend flooding rules to provide for residential development within Flood Prone and Flood
Plains and sensitive areas as permitted activities providing the number of dwellings on the site
is not increased.
5999-9 Kevin Bligh kmbligh@gmail.com Precincts Ak-Wide and Coastal Stadiums and Showgrounds Mapping
Retain Policy Area B in Sub-Precinct A Eden Park particularly where it adjoins Cricket
Avenue, Mt Eden.
5999-10 Kevin Bligh kmbligh@gmail.com Precincts Ak-Wide and Coastal Stadiums and Showgrounds
Objectives and Policies Retain Objective 4.
5999-11 Kevin Bligh kmbligh@gmail.com Precincts Ak-Wide and Coastal Stadiums and Showgrounds
Objectives and Policies Amend Policy 4 by removing the word 'some'.
5999-12 Kevin Bligh kmbligh@gmail.com Public Open Space Zones
I18.2-3 Land use &
Development controls Retain land use control 2.2 'Licensed premises'.
5999-13 Kevin Bligh kmbligh@gmail.com Residential zones Residential
Amend rule 6.4 Yards, to be consistent with the Stadiums and showgrounds Sub-precinct
Eden Park along Cricket Avenue, Mt Eden.
5999-14 Kevin Bligh kmbligh@gmail.com Precincts Ak-Wide and Coastal Stadiums and Showgrounds K1.10 Precinct Rules Retain rule 10.1.3.2(1) the height in relation to boundary control in Sub-precinct - Eden Park.
45/1145
Sub#/
5999-15 Kevin Bligh kmbligh@gmail.com Special Character
& C J3.3.1-7 Rules Add new permitted activity for 'additions and external alterations to the rear of dwellings'.
5999-16 Kevin Bligh kmbligh@gmail.com Special Character
& C J3.3.1-7 Rules
Amend provisions to enable garages and carports to be provided for alongside or in the front
yard.
6000-1 Margaret L Wade
375 Hamilton Road, RD2,
Warkworth, Auckland 0982 RPS Changes to the RUB North and Waiheke Island
No specific relief sought, but opposes Warkworth being identified as a satellite city,
infrastructure will not cope with up to 40,000 people.
6001-1 Larry T Davison
3 Quedley Court, Eastern Beach,
Auckland 2012 Zoning South
Retain current zoning (rather than Sport and Active Recreation) for 67R The Esplanade,
Eastern Beach [Inferred from submission].
6002-1
PW and JI Alderdice and
Emma and Michael Langhorne emma.verberne@gjgardner.co.nz Mineral extraction
Buffer Area
Amend extent of the Brookby Quarry as per Environment Court Decision provided in
Submission, with particular regard to 266 Ara-Kotinga Road, Whitford; so the quarry buffer
zone extents 250-350m from the quarry face (not past the McLaughlan Farm boundary).
6003-1
Grove Hardware Limited and
Grove Enterprises Limited and
Stone Store Properties Limited office@grove.co.nz Infrastructure
Transmission Corridor J1.4 Rules and mapping
Remove the entire overlay, including for 1, 17-19, 21-23 Princes Street, 2-4, 3, 5-7, 9-15
Wharangi Street, Onehunga.
6003-2
Grove Hardware Limited and
Grove Enterprises Limited and
Stone Store Properties Limited office@grove.co.nz Zoning North and Islands
Rezone the Wairau Valley precinct, including 15 Poland Road from Light Industry to General
Business.
6004-1 Tony Chen
Auckland 2012 Zoning South Retain current zoning for 67R The Esplanade, Eastern Beach.
6005-1 Sue Davison
Auckland 2012 Zoning South Retain current zoning for 67R The Esplanade, Eastern Beach [Inferred from submission].
6006-1
Pukekohe Citizens and
Ratepayers Association
1/50 West Street, Pukekohe,
Auckland 2120 Definitions Existing Clarify what is considered as 'significant infrastructure'.
6006-2
Auckland 2120 Infrastructure
C1.1 Infrastructure
policies
Clarify how utility providers and private property owners will be able to deliver infrastructure
despite reverse sensitivity effects.
6006-3
Auckland 2120 RPS Urban growth
Amend so no future urban land north of Pukekohe is developed prior to the completion of
infrastructure projects. Refer to pages 5-6/12 of the submission for details.
6006-4
Auckland 2120 Residential zones Housing affordability
and policies Delete the provisions that provide for retained affordable housing / inclusionary zoning.
6006-5
Retain the zoning within the inner ring of commercial Pukekohe (defined by Wsley Street,
Massey Avenue, Stadium Drive and Tobin Street.
6006-6
Auckland 2120 Subdivision Auckland-wide - general
and policies
Amend so subdivision of brownfield sites has due regard for the reverse sensitivity effects on
adjacent property owners.
6006-7
Amend the policy approach of using aggregated intensification targets with a broad objective
to enable urban development in keeping with the design and profile of existing communities.
6006-8
Auckland 2120 Rural Zones General I13.1 Activity table
Amend to ensure that potential temporary reverse sensitivity issues do not restrict the range
of permitted rural activities.
6006-9
Auckland 2120 RPS
Amend heritage values of buildings and locations to be based on evidence
and differentiate between historic heritage places and buildings that are older and / or
obsolete.
6006-10
Auckland 2120 Historic Heritage (Overlay)
Heritage J2.3 & J2.4 Assessment
Amend provisions to ensure that the cost of maintenance and repair is taken into
consideration and is not disproportionate to the cost of a new building of similar size and
scale. Refer to page 8/12 of the submission for details.
6006-11
Auckland 2120 RPS
Add financial and regulatory incentives e.g. heritage grants, funding
and transferable development rights to property owners who are required to comply with
seismic strengthening requirements.
6006-12
Auckland 2120
control
and policies
Delete the blanket precautionary approach and replace with provisions that place the onus on
Council to identify historic heritage locations.
6006-13
Auckland 2120 RPS Changes to the RUB South
Add more Business Park, Light Industry and Heavy industry zoned land in Pukekohe and the
surrounding area.
6006-14
Auckland 2120 RPS Rural B8 Strategic
Add the provisions relating to the rural countryside living zone in Franklin Rural Plan Change
14 [inferred]. Refer to pages 10-11/12 of the submission.
6006-15
Auckland 2120 Mana Whenua General provisions
assessment
Delete the requirement to consult with iwi and make Council or another impartial body
responsible for preparing a cultural impact assessment.
6006-16
Auckland 2120 Mana Whenua
Whenua
and policies
Amend the Sites of Significance and Value by identifying grades of significance and vary the
level of protection according to the grade given.
6006-17
Auckland 2120 Rural Zones General I13.1 Activity table Retain the exclusion of rules that would require a resource consent for crop rotation.
46/1145
Sub#/
6007-1 Carol-Anne Hickey
6 Fairbanks Place, Glendene,
Auckland 0602 Zoning West
Reject Terrace Housing and Apartment building zoning at Great North
Road and Manhattan Heights, Glendene.
6008-1 Fred Revell fred.revell@asb.co.nz
SEAs
Land
Add part of 254 Rimmer Road, Helensville to the schedule. Refer to the map on page 4/4 of
the submission for the extent.
6009-1 Max Adams Images Limited maxadams@xtra.co.nz Rural Zones
D6.3 Mixed Rural zone desc,
obs & pols Delete the Mixed Rural zone and rely on the Rural Production zone.
6009-2 Max Adams Images Limited maxadams@xtra.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - Rural zones
area Delete the receiver site exclusion area for transferable rural site subdivision.
area
Amend to allow for dwellings on prime land as part of transferable rural site subdivision, for an
area of 4000-5000m
2
providing it is a lesser area of prime land than being gained from the
donor list. Refer to submission for details [vol 3 page 3/3].
area
Delete Table 7 that limits the location of a receiver site to the Countryside Living zone as part
of transferable rural site subdivision.
area
Amend the minimum area of an SEA to be protected from 5ha to 1ha as set out in Table 8 as
part of transferable rural site subdivision.
area
Amend the minimum rural site area in the Mixed Rural and Rural Production zones from
150ha to 20ha in Rule (9)(a).
6010-1 Wen-Ching Hu
6011-1
Eastern Beach Action Network
Incorporated s.mcgill@hyper.net.nz Zoning South
Rezone area identified, refer to submission [page 4/4, vol 2, map 2 (Relates to boundary
between Macleans College and park] at 2 Macleans Road, Eastern Beach from Special
Purpose School, to Public Open Space.
6011-2
Eastern Beach Action Network
Incorporated s.mcgill@hyper.net.nz Zoning South
Retain current zoning at 67R The Esplanade, Eastern Beach. Opposes Sports and Active
Recreation zoning.
6012-1 Mark Hodson markandrand@gmail.com Zoning North and Islands
Rezone 41, 41a, 41b, and 41c Glencoe Rd, Browns Bay, from Mixed Housing Urban to
Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings
6012-2 Mark Hodson markandrand@gmail.com Zoning North and Islands
Rezone 17-27 Bayview Rd, Browns Bay from Mixed Housing Suburban to Terrace Housing
and Apartment Buildings or, as a second preference, Mixed Housing Urban
6013-1 John Hugo hugonz@vodafone.co.nz Zoning South
No specific decision stated, expresses concern about rate payers funding sports fields for
Macleans College, Eastern Beach. Also opposes Sport and Active Recreation zone at 67R
The Esplanade, Eastern Beach.
6014-1 Heletranz Limited markb@mhg.co.nz Precincts - North New Precincts All other New Precincts
Add a precinct to the Heletranz facility (2 Jack Hinton Drive, Albany) to provide for 'Helicopter
facilities (including the landing and taking off of helicopters and associated fuelling and
service facilities)' as a permitted activity. Provide for increased activity or new buildings as
restricted discretionary activities in this precinct.
6015-1 Peter A Jenkins apne.jenkins@xtra.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - Rural zones
area
Amend to allow for subdivision down to 0.5ha for both sides of Ponga Road between 1583
and 600, including 916 Ponga Road, Opaheke.
6016-1
The Riverbank Enhancement
Group pam@opc.net.nz Zoning North and Islands
Retain the Public Open Space - Informal Recreation zoning of 5-7A Baxter Street, Warkworth
and Allotment 412 PSH of Mahurangi SO30371.
6016-2
Group pam@opc.net.nz RPS Urban growth
recreation facilities Retain the objectives and policies.
6016-3
Group pam@opc.net.nz Public Open Space Zones
D2.2 Informal Recreation zone
desc, obs & pols Retain the objectives and policies.
6016-4
Group pam@opc.net.nz Public Open Space Zones Public Open Space
controls & Spec. info. req. Retain development control 3.3 'Application of controls'.
6017-1 Equestrian 4 Everyone e4eincommunities@gmail.com Precincts - North Weiti Add new permitted activity 'equestrian' in sub precinct C.
6017-2 Equestrian 4 Everyone e4eincommunities@gmail.com Precincts - North Weiti
Amend land use controls for education facilities in 2.6(2) adding 'equine [education] ' as an
activity.
6018-1 Olga Holt olne@clear.net.nz Zoning South Retain current zoning for 67R The Esplanade, Eastern Beach [Inferred from submission].
6019-1 Neal Holt olne@clear.net.nz Zoning South Retain current zoning for 67R The Esplanade, Eastern Beach [Inferred from submission].
6020-1 Peter R Thorpe lynnthorpe@hotmail.com Precincts - North Bayswater
objectives and policies Remove residential activities from sub precinct B.
6020-2 Peter R Thorpe lynnthorpe@hotmail.com Precincts - North Bayswater K5.6 Precinct rules Amend rule 2 'Notification' to to require any future residential development to be fully notified.
6020-3 Peter R Thorpe lynnthorpe@hotmail.com Precincts - North Bayswater K5.6 Precinct rules
Amend activity status for dwellings with or without a framework plan from discretionary to non-
complying.
6021-1 Karen Hitchcock thehitchcocks@yahoo.co.nz RPS Mana Whenua B5 Strategic
Delete all provisions that provide for shared governance and require compliance with the
principles of the Treaty of Waitangi.
47/1145
Sub#/
6021-2 Karen Hitchcock thehitchcocks@yahoo.co.nz General Miscellaneous Consultation and engagement
Request that Council hold a referendum asking whether the general population of Auckland
agree that the governance of our physical and natural resources be shared in partnership with
Mana Whenua.
6021-3 Karen Hitchcock thehitchcocks@yahoo.co.nz RPS Mana Whenua
Fig. 1
Amend the Mana Whenua provisions relating to the protection of Mana Whenua culture and
heritage (including sections B.5.4 Protection of Mana Whenua culture and C.5.2 Sites and
Places of Value to Mana Whenua) to provide certainty for land owners, a fair balance
between cultural heritage and private property rights and the opportunity for mediation. Refer
to the submission for details [page 3/3].
6021-4 Karen Hitchcock thehitchcocks@yahoo.co.nz Mana Whenua
Whenua
Amend provisions so scheduled sites are ratified and graded into categories of significance
that have varying degrees of protection.
6021-5 Karen Hitchcock thehitchcocks@yahoo.co.nz Mana Whenua
Whenua
and policies
Amend provisions so scheduled sites are ratified and graded into categories of significance
that have varying degrees of protection.
6021-6 Karen Hitchcock thehitchcocks@yahoo.co.nz Mana Whenua General provisions
assessment
Amend Rule 2.7.4(5) so Council is responsible for preparing a cultural impact assessment
rather than iwi authorities.
6021-7 Karen Hitchcock thehitchcocks@yahoo.co.nz RPS Mana Whenua B5 Strategic Amend the Mana Whenua provisions to 'make sense, be clear and easy to follow'.
6022-1
Kiwi Vision Consultants
Limited jessica@kiwivision.co.nz Mana Whenua General provisions
assessment
Amend the cultural impact assessment requirements to be less onerous, in particular the
'main iwi organisation' should decide how many [iwi] organisations should be contacted.
6022-2
Limited jessica@kiwivision.co.nz
control
Reduce the extent of the overlay to only include areas that contain large tracts of pre-1944
buildings that were identified in legacy District Plans (i.e. include Herne Bay, St Marys Bay,
Ponsonby and Freemans Bay but exclude areas such as Orakei).
6022-3
control
Amend the rules such that construction of modern buildings is provided for, if the costs of
preservation and upgrade of a pre-1944 house to Building Code standards are unreasonable.
6022-4
Limited jessica@kiwivision.co.nz RPS
character and natural heritage B4.2 Special character
Amend to provide a process for Council to purchase a property at market value and undertake
preservation at the Council's own cost, where the property owner disputes the value of
retaining a pre-1944 building.
6022-5
control
Delete the overlay from houses established from 1941 to 1944, where the state of the housing
stock is questionable.
6022-6
SEAs
Land
Amend the extent of SEAs to align with areas of vegetation protected under the legacy
Council maps e.g. the the Significant Natural Areas of the Rodney Section of the District Plan
(remove from sites not already on legacy Council maps).
6022-7
Limited jessica@kiwivision.co.nz Definitions Existing Delete the definition of 'Site' [replaced with a new definition 'Delineated Area].
6022-8
Limited jessica@kiwivision.co.nz Definitions New
Add a definition for 'Delineated Area', as defined in the North Shore District Plan 2002 (which
better addresses properties that are cross-leased). Refer to the full submission for suggested
wording [page 7/22].
6022-9
Limited jessica@kiwivision.co.nz Definitions Existing
Delete the definition of 'Net Site Area' and replace with the definition provided in the North
Shore District Plan 2002 (which allows for shared access and decreases the need for multiple
vehicle crossings). Refer to the full submission for suggested wording [page 9/22].
6022-10
Limited jessica@kiwivision.co.nz General Chapter G General provisions
Retain the combined resource consent application process (where land use and subdivision
applications for a site are processed as one application). [Under rule G1.4 'Applying for a
resource consent'.]
6022-11
Limited jessica@kiwivision.co.nz RPS Changes to the RUB North and Waiheke Island
Amend the Rural Urban Boundary, to include all lots that are identified as Countryside Living
in the operative District Plan - Rodney Section.
6022-12
Limited jessica@kiwivision.co.nz Zoning North and Islands
Rezone small lots [in the former Rodney District] that are adjacent to Countryside Living
zones, from General Rural [operative District Plan - Rodney Section] to Countryside Living.
6022-13
Rezone the area west of the Northern Motorway from Riverhead township to Pine Valley
Road, Dairy Flat, from General Rural [Mixed Rural and Rural Production] to Countryside
Living. Refer to full submission for maps showing the changes requested [pages 21-22/22].
6022-14
Limited jessica@kiwivision.co.nz RPS Urban growth
quality compact urban form Retain the approach of intensification within the existing urban environment.
6022-15
Limited jessica@kiwivision.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - Urban zones H5.2 3.1 Residential zones
Amend the minimum net site area in the Single House zone from 600m2 to 500m2 in Table 1
'Minimum net site area'.
6022-16
Limited jessica@kiwivision.co.nz Residential zones Residential
policies
Replace the Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings zone with two distinct zones, Town-
house zone (up to three stories) and Apartment zone (four to six stories) in location close to
Town Centres (up to 8 storeys).
6022-17
Retain the location of the Terrace Housing and Apartment Building zone along arterial roads
(e.g. East Coast Road).
48/1145
Sub#/
6022-18
policies
Reject the location of the Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings zone next to the Single
House zone.
6022-19
policies
Amend the approach to residential zoning to provide Mixed Housing [Urban and Suburban]
zones as a buffer between the Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings zone and the Single
House zone.
6022-20
Reject further intensification of the Devonport Peninsula (in particular the high density zones
in the Belmont area).
6022-21
Provide for an increase in density in locations that are geographically open and enable
efficient traffic dispersion (not in peninsulas) [relating to Civil Defence emergency evacuation].

6022-22
Retain the Mixed Housing Suburban and Mixed Housing Urban zones in Belmont, North
Shore [retain the absence of Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings zone].
6022-23
Limited jessica@kiwivision.co.nz General Miscellaneous
Operational/
Projects/Acquisition Provide more efficient public transport (to decrease existing congestion).
6022-24
policies
Amend to provide for medium density [developments] only within a 500m distance from
transport hubs and public transport linkages.
6022-25
Rezone the area west of Lake Road, Takapuna (between Esmonde Road and Onepoto Road)
to Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings [from a variety of residential zones]. Refer to the
full submission for a map of the changes requested [page 19/22].
6022-26
Rezone properties on either side of Burns Avenue, Takapuna (between Bracken Avenue and
Tennyson Avenue) from Single House to Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings.
6022-27
Limited jessica@kiwivision.co.nz Zoning North and Islands Retain the Mixed Housing Suburban zone along the eastern side of Lake Road, Takapuna.
6022-28
Rezone the length of Shakespeare Road, Milford to Mixed Housing [Urban/Suburban not
specified].
6022-29
Rezone the property [2D Northcote Road, Takapuna] at the Lake Pupuke end of Northcote
Road to Single House [from Mixed Housing Suburban]. Refer to the full submission for a map
of the changes requested [page 20/22].
6022-30
Limited jessica@kiwivision.co.nz Special Character
Residential North Shore J3.4.1-7 Rules
Amend the development controls for the Devonport Historic Character Overlay [inferred this is
the Special Character - Residential North Shore overlay] to adopt the same controls used for
the areas of Herne Bay, Ponsonby and St Marys Bay Historic Characters [inferred this is the
Special Character - Residential Isthmus A overlay].
6022-31
Add further non-statutory/non-regulatory methods in relation to containing the predicted future
population growth within the Rural Urban Boundary. Refer to the full submission for further
detail [pages 13-18].
6022-32
Undertake a three-pronged approach to promoting higher density living (Council working in
conjunction with central government and the private sector).
6022-33
quality compact urban form Identify a different set of planning rules for infill development and greenfield development.
6022-34
Limited jessica@kiwivision.co.nz General Miscellaneous Other
Require banks and other financial institutions to make investing in and buying higher density
development more affordable [as a method to encourage high density development].
6022-35
Limited jessica@kiwivision.co.nz General Miscellaneous Development contributions
Offer smaller development contributions in exchange for more affordable housing and/or a
mix of housing typologies [as a method to encourage high density development].
6022-36
Limited jessica@kiwivision.co.nz General Miscellaneous Other
Consider ways to encourage residents to achieve home ownership in lieu of foreign investors
simply in search of a revenue stream (Central government and local government).
6023-1 Chang Yaojen
No specific decision sought regarding 67R The Esplanade, Eastern Beach and the effects of
car parking and noise. Opposes Sport and Active Recreation zoning.
6024-1 SD Patel Family Trust deanne@mhg.co.nz General Cross plan matters
Amend Table 1 by removing references to the building height in storeys in the Mixed Use
zone.
6024-2 SD Patel Family Trust deanne@mhg.co.nz Definitions Existing
Amend definition of "Height" to include "the vertical distance between the highest part of the
building and the average level of the ground at the external foundations of the buildings".
6024-3 SD Patel Family Trust deanne@mhg.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - Urban zones H5.2 3.1 Residential zones Amend rules by replacing references to "net site area" with "gross site area".
6024-4 SD Patel Family Trust deanne@mhg.co.nz Definitions New
Add a definition for "Gross site area" with diagram as currently worded in Part 3 of the
Auckland Council District Plan (Rodney Section). See page 4/6 of submission for details.
6024-5 SD Patel Family Trust deanne@mhg.co.nz
Centre) Business
Special information
requirements Delete 10.2' Wind report'.
6024-6 SD Patel Family Trust deanne@mhg.co.nz General Chapter G General provisions
statements Delete requirements to provide a design statement.
49/1145
Sub#/
6024-7 SD Patel Family Trust deanne@mhg.co.nz Mana Whenua General provisions
assessment Delete requirement to provide Cultural Impact Assessments.
6024-8 SD Patel Family Trust deanne@mhg.co.nz General Cross plan matters
Delete references in PAUP that Council may consider provisions beyond those specifically
listed as assessment criteria.
6024-9 SD Patel Family Trust deanne@mhg.co.nz Sustainable Development C7.7/H6.4 Sustainable design
Delete requirement for new buildings with a GFA of 5000m
2
or greater and where 60% of the
GFA is to used for industrial activities, or 80% is to be used as an office, to be designed and
constructed to achieve a minimum 4-star level from the NZ or Australian Green Building
Council.
6024-10 SD Patel Family Trust deanne@mhg.co.nz Residential zones Housing affordability H6.6 Rules
Delete requirement to provide at least 10% affordable housing where more than 15 dwellings
or 15 vacant sites are developed within the RUB.
6025-1 Terry Roberts
41 The Esplanade, Eastern Beach,
6026-1 Lorraine G Neil
56 The Esplanade, Eastern Beach,
6027-1
Kerry D and Wilhelmus G M
Ruiterman
137 McPike Road, Pollok, RD 4,
Waiuku, Auckland 2684 Mana Whenua
Whenua
objectives and policies Delete the overlay [inferred].
6027-2
Ruiterman
Waiuku, Auckland 2684 Mana Whenua
Whenua
Delete the overlay including the scheduled sites (IDs 14475, 14476, 14477, 14478) from 137
McPike Road, Pollock [inferred].
6027-3
Ruiterman
Waiuku, Auckland 2684 Water
streams & wetland
table
Add the activity of the removal of noxious weeds e.g. gorse, flannel weed and other weeds
that choke creeks and stop the flow of water as a farming activity [inferred].
6027-4
Ruiterman
Waiuku, Auckland 2684
Rural Discharges,
Biosolids
C5.10/H4.9 Agrichemicals and
Vertebrate Toxic Agents
Add the activity spraying of weeds with herbicide as a permitted activity on farms [inferred,
H4.9.1 Activity Table].
6027-5
Ruiterman
Waiuku, Auckland 2684 Public Open Space Zones Public Open Space I2.1 Activity table
Delete the provisions that allow buildings and structures to be erected in parks and reserves
without public notification.
6028-1 David Longville
62A The Esplanade, Eastern Beach,
6029-1 Manukau ECE Taskforce
susan.warren@cometauckland.org.n
z Definitions Existing
Amend the definition of 'care centres' to remove 'early learning services' and add it as a new
sub-category of 'education facilities', or add a new definition for 'early learning services'.
Amend the definition of 'Early childhood learning services' to remove the wording 'Those
activities associated with early childhood care must be licensed under the Education (Early
Childhood Services) Regulations 2008. ', or include the word 'certified' after the word
'licensed'.
z Public Open Space Zones Public Open Space I2.1 Activity table
Amend Activity Table to provide for 'New early learning services' as a Restricted Discretionary
activity within the [Public Open Space] Community zone.
z Public Open Space Zones Public Open Space I2.1 Activity table
Amend activity table to provide for 'Early childhood learning services over 100m
2
within an
existing building' as a Restricted Discretionary activity within the [Public Open Space]
Community zone.
z Residential zones Residential Activity Table Amend Activity Table as follows 'Care centres up to 200 250m2 GFA per site.'
z Residential zones Residential
policies
Amend to provide quality, affordable early learning services are available within a 750 metre
walk of all homes in low socio economic areas.
z Residential zones Residential Activity Table
Amend Activity Table to provide for new builds up to 250 square meters for early childhood
learning centres in all residential areas as a Permitted activity.
z
Centre) Business
& Bus. Park zones Retain Permitted activity status for care centres in business zones.
z Residential zones Residential Land use controls
Amend the controls for early learning centres in residential zones to be the same as the
controls applicable in business zones.
z Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
Amend 3.1 'Number of Parking and Loading Spaces' to have a maximum of one carpark per
three FTEs, plus two guest/parent spaces for care centres.
requirements
Amend parking space provisions to shift the onus of proof from early childhood education
services to the council, who would have to show there was a need to do anything more than
the standard requirement.
z Air Quality
Sensitive Activity Restriction Amend the air quality overlay so it does not apply to early learning services.
z Air Quality
Overlay E7.10/J7.1 Air quality
transport separation
Amend Activity Table as follows 'Care centres with up to three ten children (in addition to
children already under care of the provided) under the age of six'.
50/1145
Sub#/
z General Miscellaneous Development contributions
Add a requirement for subdivision development contribution to set aside land for early
learning in all developments of more than a certain size.
z General Miscellaneous
Operational/
Establish a single contact person for all early childhood education consents and create a
diagrammatic guide to help early childhood education centres through the process.
z General Cross plan matters
Amend all activity tables throughout the PAUP to refer to 'early childhood learning centres'.
See pave 5/10 of submission.
z
Centre) Business
and Heavy Industry zones Retain the restriction on Early learning services. See page 8/10 of submission.
6030-1
Y Zhang and H L
Developments Albany Limited peterr@catobolam.co.nz Zoning North and Islands
Rezone 55 Schnapper Rock Road and 52 Kyle Road, Schnapper Rock from Large Lot to
Single House. Refer to the map in Appendix A of the submission, page 17/19.
6030-2
Y Zhang and H L
Developments Albany Limited peterr@catobolam.co.nz
SEAs
Land
Delete SEA_T_835413, Land as it applies to 55 Schnapper Rock Road, Schnapper Rock.
Refer to the map in Appendix B of the submission, page 19/19.
6031-1 A S Giarn giarn@orcon.net.nz Zoning South Retain current zoning for 67R The Esplanade, Eastern Beach [Inferred from submission].
6032-1 Betty Thorpe
3002/142 Shakespeare Road,
Takapuna, Auckland 0622 Precincts - North Bayswater
Amend the description of sub-precinct B to remove reference to provision for residential
development (third paragraph, second bullet point of the 'Precinct description').
6032-2 Betty Thorpe
Takapuna, Auckland 0622 Precincts - North Bayswater K5.6 Precinct rules
Retain public notification of resource consent applications for framework plans, dwellings,
food and beverage and licensed premises, under 2. Notification.
6032-3 Betty Thorpe
Takapuna, Auckland 0622 Precincts - North Bayswater K5.6 Precinct rules
Amend the activity status of dwellings (with or without a framework plan) from discretionary to
non-complying [sub-precinct B], in Activity table 1.2 'Use and Activities'.
6032-4 Betty Thorpe
Takapuna, Auckland 0622 Precincts - North Bayswater
objectives and policies Reject provision for residential development at Bayswater Marina.
6033-1 Susan C Short susanshort@xtra.co.nz RPS Mana Whenua B5 Strategic
Delete all provisions that promote shared governance including but not limited to, sections
B.1.4 Addressing issues of significance to Mana Whenua and B.5.1 Recognition of Te Tiriti o
Waitangi partnerships and participation, policy 5 in section C.5.15.1 Water quality and
integrated management and policy 11 in section C.5.15.2 Water quality, allocation and use.
6033-2 Susan C Short susanshort@xtra.co.nz Mana Whenua
Whenua
and policies
Amend the overlay provisions to provide certainty of meaning and the protection of affected
property owners.
6033-3 Susan C Short susanshort@xtra.co.nz Mana Whenua General provisions
assessment Delete the requirement for a cultural impact assessment and the need to consult with iwi.
6033-4 Susan C Short susanshort@xtra.co.nz General Chapter A Introduction A2 Statutory Framework
Delete the word 'legal' when referring to the Treaty of Waitangi as a legal document in section
2.2 Treaty of Waitangi.
6034-1 Rana Partridge ranapartridge@hotmail.com Residential zones Residential
Amend height to a maximum of two storeys for the Mixed Housing Urban zone at Herman,
Daventry Streets and Waterbank Crescent, Waterview.
6034-2 Rana Partridge ranapartridge@hotmail.com Zoning Central
Rezone Herdman, Daventry Streets and Waterbank Crescent from Mixed Housing Urban to
Mixed Housing Suburban.
6035-1 Ross Davison ross.davison@xtra.co.nz General
GIS viewer Delete the Flood Plain and Flood Prone Area overlays from 100 Bryant Road, Karaka.
6036-1 Barry Wade oliveoil@ihug.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - Rural zones
area Amend table 10 'Whitford' to read: Average Not < 4ha 1ha
6037-1 Connie F L and John W Kum cojay@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central
No specific decision sought, opposes Terrace Housing and Apartment Building zone in
Epsom and Royal Oak. Concerns over Historic Heritage, Special Character and traffic
congestion.
6038-1 Amanda Weaver ajweaver@workwise.co.nz Mana Whenua General provisions
assessment
Amend provisions to require consultation with one iwi per piece of land (not multiple iwi), and
only where there are tangible reasons for consultation.
6038-2 Amanda Weaver ajweaver@workwise.co.nz Mana Whenua
Whenua
objectives and policies Delete the section on Sites of Significance to Mori.
6038-3 Amanda Weaver ajweaver@workwise.co.nz Mana Whenua
Whenua
Delete the 'sites of significance' [inferred this relates to 'Sites and places of value to Mana
Whenua' overlay], while an independent review is undertaken to determine whether these are
worthy of protection.
6038-4 Amanda Weaver ajweaver@workwise.co.nz RPS Mana Whenua B5 Strategic
Recognise that full disclosure should be provided to affected property owners [relating to Sites
and places of value to Mana Whenua], with information available on LIM reports.
6039-1 Margaret Murray
18 Sunnyhill Crescent, Pakuranga,
Rezone 67R The Esplanade, Eastern Beach from Active Recreation [Public Open Space -
Sport and Active Recreation] to Passive Recreation [Public Open Space - Informal
Recreation].
6040-1 Lloyd Renwick
2 Wades Road, Whitford, Auckland
2571 Subdivision Auckland-wide - Rural zones
51/1145
Sub#/
6041-1
Muriwai Community
Association admin@muriwaicommunity.org Subdivision Auckland-wide - Rural zones
area
Amend minimum site area rule of 4000m
2
to take account of existing wastewater issues in
Muriwai Village.
6041-2
Muriwai Community
Association admin@muriwaicommunity.org General Miscellaneous
Operational/
Create an alternative entrance to Muriwai Regional Park that is not through Muriwai Village.
Consider the northern section '5 mile'.
6041-3
Muriwai Community
Association admin@muriwaicommunity.org General Miscellaneous Special housing areas Require SHA developments comply with the provisions and aims of the PAUP.
6041-4
Muriwai Community
Association admin@muriwaicommunity.org RPS Rural
potential Preserve and protect the green surrounds of Muriwai to protect productive farmland.
6041-5
Muriwai Community
Association admin@muriwaicommunity.org Zoning North and Islands Rezone areas around Muriwai from Rural Production to Rural zone.
6041-6
Muriwai Community
Association admin@muriwaicommunity.org Subdivision Auckland-wide - Rural zones
area Provide more parkland when subdividing the surrounding Rural zone of Muriwai.
6041-7
Muriwai Community
Association admin@muriwaicommunity.org RPS
character and natural heritage B4.3 Natural heritage Give high priority to recognising the natural environment.
6042-1 Cooper and Associates martin.b.cooper@gmail.com RPS Issues
growth Review the projected population increase to make sure it is realistic.
6042-2 Cooper and Associates martin.b.cooper@gmail.com RPS Urban growth
Recognise the commercial realities of producing new housing and provide for up-zoning of
land for at least 200% more land than is deemed required to meet population growth.
6042-3 Cooper and Associates martin.b.cooper@gmail.com Residential zones Residential Land use controls
Amend rule 3.1 Maximum density, to provide for increased density in the Mixed Housing
Suburban zone (150m
2
/100m
2
net site areas rather than 200m
2
). Refer to the full submission
for suggested wording [page 8/25].
Amend rule 3.1 'Maximum density', to provide for increased density in the Mixed Housing
Urban zone (100m
2
net site areas rather than 200m
2
). Refer to the full submission for
suggested wording [page 8/25].
Add a clause to rule 3.1 ' Maximum density' to identify where an increased density (100m
2
net
site area, where four or more dwellings are proposed) in the Mixed Housing Suburban zone
can apply. Refer to the full submission for suggested wording [page 8/25].
Add a clause to rule 3.1 'Maximum density' to identify where an increased density (100m
2
net
site area, where four or more dwellings are proposed) in the Mixed Housing Urban zone can
apply. Refer to the full submission for suggested wording [page 9/25].
6042-7 Cooper and Associates martin.b.cooper@gmail.com Residential zones Residential
Retain development controls (for the Mixed Housing Suburban zone) which provide for
increased density within existing suburbs.
Amend development control 7.2 'Building height' (in the Mixed Housing Suburban zone), to
read: '1. Buildings must not exceed 8m in height except where the density is increased to
1:100 then the height may be increased to 10m.'
Amend development control 7.5 'Yards' (in the Mixed Housing Suburban zone), to reduce the
minimum depth for front yards from 4m to 3m (in a master planned community with quality
landscaping).
Amend development control 7.5 'Yards' (in the Mixed Housing Suburban zone), to delete the
riparian yard requirements (which require a minimum yard depth of 10m from the edge of all
other permanent and intermittent streams).
Mixed Housing Urban zone Retain development control 7.8 'Building coverage' (in the Mixed Housing Suburban zone).
Amend development control 7.9(3) 'Landscaping' (in the Mixed Housing Suburban zone), to
clarify the extent to which tree planting is required and to recommend retention of existing
trees. Refer to the full submission for suggested wording [page 12/25].
Amend development control 7.12(1) 'Outdoor living space' (in the Mixed Housing Suburban
zone), relating to dwellings at ground level, to include use of a 'common area' as outdoor
living space. Refer to the full submission for suggested wording [page 11/25].
Amend development control 7.12(2) 'Outdoor living space' (in the Mixed Housing Suburban
zone), relating to where the principle living room is at ground level, to reduce the amount of
delineated outdoor living space required, where there is access to a common area. Refer to
the full submission for suggested wording [page 11/25].
Amend development control 7.15 'Fences' (in the Mixed Housing Suburban zone), to allow
fence heights greater than 1.2m where required to screen a principle living space or adjoining
outdoor space. Refer to the full submission for suggested wording [page 11/25].
52/1145
Sub#/
Amend development control 7.16(3) 'Garages' (in the Mixed Housing Suburban zone), to
read: 'The garage door must be set back at least 5m from the sites frontage except where the
garage door is perpendicular to the street.'
Mixed Housing Urban zone Delete development control 7.22 'Universal access' (in the Mixed Housing Suburban zone).
Retain development controls (for the Mixed Housing Urban zone) which provide for increased
density within existing suburbs.
policies Increase the extent of the Mixed Housing Urban zone.
Retain the 10m height limit in development control 8.2 'Building height' (in the Mixed Housing
Urban zone).
Amend development control 8.5 'Yards' (in the Mixed Housing Urban zone), to delete the
riparian yard requirements (which require a minimum yard depth of 10m from the edge of all
other permanent and intermittent streams).
Mixed Housing Urban zone Retain development control 8.8 'Building coverage' (in the Mixed Housing Urban zone).
Amend development control 8.9(3) 'Landscaping' (in the Mixed Housing Urban zone), to
clarify the extent to which tree planting is required and to recommend retention of existing
trees. Refer to the full submission for suggested wording [page 18/25].
Amend development control 8.12(1) 'Outdoor living space' (in the Mixed Housing Urban
zone), relating to dwellings at ground level, to include use of a 'common area' as outdoor
living space. Refer to the full submission for suggested wording [page 19/25].
Amend development control 8.12(2) 'Outdoor living space' (in the Mixed Housing Urban
zone), relating to where the principle living room is at ground level, to reduce the amount of
delineated outdoor living space required, where there is access to a common area. Refer to
the full submission for suggested wording [page 19/25].
Amend development control 8.15 'Fences' (in the Mixed Housing Urban zone), to allow fence
heights greater than 1.2m where required to screen a principle living space or adjoining
outdoor space. Refer to the full submission for suggested wording [page 20/25].
Amend development control 8.16(3) 'Garages' (in the Mixed Housing Urban zone), to read:
'The garage door must be set back at least 5m from the sites frontage except where the
garage door is perpendicular to the street.'
Mixed Housing Urban zone Delete development control 8.22 'Universal access' (in the Mixed Housing Urban zone).
policies Increase the extent of the Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings zone.
Amend 9. 'Development Controls - Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings zone', to
provide separate rules for buildings over four stories (i.e. apartments).
Amend development control 9.2 'Building height' (in the Terrace Housing and Apartment
Buildings zone), to review [increase] heights in certain areas and provide for construction of
cost effective apartment buildings.
Amend development control 9.2 'Maximum impervious area' (in the Terrace Housing and
Apartment Buildings zone), to read: '1. Maximum impervious area: 60 100 per cent.'
Amend development control 9.8 'Building coverage' (in the Terrace Housing and Apartment
Buildings zone), to read: '1. Maximum building coverage: 40 100 per cent.'
6042-34 Cooper and Associates martin.b.cooper@gmail.com
Centre) Business
Park zones
Review development control 4.2 'Building height' in relation to certain areas (e.g. Newmarket)
and provide the ability to more intensely develop these areas.
Centre) Business
Park zones
Amend development control 4.2 'Building height' to increase the hight limit to 30 stories (or
unlimited) in Metropolitan Centres (from 18 stories).
Centre) Business
Park zones
Amend development control 4.2 'Building height' to increase the hight limit to 8-12 stories in
Local Centres (from 4 stories).
53/1145
Sub#/
Centre) Business
Park zones
Amend development control 4.2 'Building height' to increase the hight limit to 8-12 stories in
Neighbourhood Centres (from 3 stories).
6042-38 Cooper and Associates martin.b.cooper@gmail.com Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
Retain the removal of minimum parking requirements in development control 3.2 'Number of
parking and loading spaces', for Centres, the Mixed Use zone, Mixed Housing [Suburban and
Urban] and the Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings zone.
6042-39 Cooper and Associates martin.b.cooper@gmail.com Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
Delete the minimum parking requirements in development control 3.2 'Number of parking and
loading spaces', for all residential zones.
6043-1 Peter W Smith peter.smith@smithpartners.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - Rural zones
zones only
Amend the activity status of subdivision not provided for in rural zones from Prohibited to Non-
complying.
6043-2 Peter W Smith peter.smith@smithpartners.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - Rural zones
area
Amend to provide for rural subdivision for the protection of native bush and significant
wetlands or for significant enhancement planting or significant land rehabilitation in the
Rodney area as a Discretionary activity.
6043-3 Peter W Smith peter.smith@smithpartners.co.nz Rural Zones General I13.1 Activity table
Amend to provide for 'minor household units' as provided for in the Operative Rodney District
Plan as a Restricted Discretionary activity.
6043-4 Peter W Smith peter.smith@smithpartners.co.nz Rural Zones General I13.2 Land use controls
Amend to provide for a second dwelling on a site less than 40ha as a Restricted Discretionary
activity with assessment criteria relating to consistent visual appearance and impression of
density. Refer to submission for details [vol. 2, page 3/3].
6044-1 Deb Bennett debbennett@xtra.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - Rural zones
area Amend table 10 'Whitford' to read: Average Not < 4ha 0.8ha
6045-1 Elizabeth M Waters liz@waihekegulfnews.co.nz General Miscellaneous Southern Hauraki Gulf Islands
Amend to create a new zone that specifically registers Waiheke's rural buffer green belts and
high amenity Western Landscapes within the PAUP.
6045-2 Elizabeth M Waters liz@waihekegulfnews.co.nz RPS Changes to the RUB North and Waiheke Island Amend Waiheke's RUB on the GIS maps to reflect Waiheke's rural green belts.
Amend development controls in Waiheke Island landscape protection zones to strengthen
protection against inappropriate development.
6045-4 Elizabeth M Waters liz@waihekegulfnews.co.nz RPS
coastal environment
Amend Chapter E.3 by adding a section, with associated overlays, which should be used as a
conserving influence over outstanding landscapes such as Waiheke's Western Headlands
and the isthmus and island harbour margins to provide specific clarity and transparent overall
protection.
Amend to include regenerated and remnant coastal bush over 3m (as they apply to
Waiheke's landscape protection zones).
6045-6 Elizabeth M Waters liz@waihekegulfnews.co.nz
the CMA
Depositing and disposal of
material include associated
D5.1.2 Background, objectives
and policies Retain part 2.
the CMA
and policies Retain 'Background, objectives and policies'.
the CMA
discharges of contaminants
and policies Retain part 4.
the CMA
and occupation
D5.1.13 Background,
Amend PAUP by adding further protections to ensure that no land or coastal marine area is
alienated for permanent private occupancy without explicit approval from the affected
communities.
the CMA D5.5/I10 Ferry Terminal zone Retain the Ferry Terminal zone (CMA only) as it applies to Matiatia.
6045-11 Elizabeth M Waters liz@waihekegulfnews.co.nz Rural Zones General
objectives & policies Retain Rural zones.
6045-12 Elizabeth M Waters liz@waihekegulfnews.co.nz Rural Zones
D6.4 Rural Coastal zone desc,
obs & pols Retain, as it applies to further subdivision on the CMA.
6046-1 Heather Renwick
2 Wades Road, Whitford, Auckland
6047-1 Alec K Smith lesleysmith@actrix.co.nz Mana Whenua
Whenua
No specific decision sought, opposes six Sites and Places of Value to Mana Whenua located
on 540 North Road, Clendon.
6048-1 Michael Jones mike@pharmapac.co.nz Mana Whenua General provisions
assessment Delete G2.7.4.
6049-1 Calland Properties Limited martin@greengroup.co.nz RPS Urban growth
Retain Objectives 2 and 3 that recognise the need for urban growth within Auckland's
metropolitan area and in areas adjacent to centres, public transport routes and facilities.
6049-2 Calland Properties Limited martin@greengroup.co.nz RPS Urban growth
Retain Policy 2 that recognises the need for urban growth within Auckland's metropolitan area
and in areas adjacent to centres, public transport routes and facilities.
54/1145
Sub#/
6049-3 Calland Properties Limited martin@greengroup.co.nz Zoning Central
Rezone 223 Kohimarama Road and 7 John Rymer Place, Kohimarama from Special Purpose
School to Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings.
6049-4 Calland Properties Limited martin@greengroup.co.nz Precincts - Central New Precincts Other New Precincts
Add a new precinct to 223 Kohimarama Road and 7 Rymer Place, Kohimarama to provide for
maximum building height, boundary controls, coverage, access. building coverage and
setbacks that would enable a retirement village or residential development. Refer to the
submission for detail [page 8/8].
6049-5 Calland Properties Limited martin@greengroup.co.nz Residential zones
D1.7 Terrace Housing and
Apartment zone desc, obs &
pols
Retain the objectives, polices and rules for the Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings
zone subject to the inclusion of new objectives that recognise that, intensive development
within the zone will be enabled to the greatest possible extent despite the effects it will have
on the surrounding residential neighbourhood and adjacent traffic networks which may result
in changes to the existing neighbourhood character [refer to page 8/8 of submission for
details].
6050-1 Coral Wong c.wong@pioneer-nz.co.nz Zoning West Delete the Mori Purpose zone from Harbourview Reserve, Te Atatu.
6050-2 Coral Wong c.wong@pioneer-nz.co.nz Mana Whenua Mori purpose zone
D8.5 Desc, obs & pols I19.1-4
Activity table Land use & dev.
controls
Amend controls for Marae developments to be inline with Waitakere City Council
controls, particularly on ecology (Environment Court Decision W 041/2007).
6050-3 Coral Wong c.wong@pioneer-nz.co.nz Public Open Space Zones
desc, obs & pols Prohibit any development of any kind in Harbourview Reserve, Te Atatu.
6051-1 Glenn C Foster glenn@beancounterplus.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - Rural zones
6051-2 Glenn C Foster glenn@beancounterplus.co.nz RPS Mana Whenua B5 Strategic
Delete provisions requiring consultation with local iwi regarding current or future land use
[inferred from submission].
6052-1 Jim Donald
111 MacLeans Road, Bucklands
Beach, Auckland 2014 RPS Mana Whenua B5 Strategic
[Delete] extraordinary and over emphasis on Mana Whenua, Iwi and Tangata Whenua. All
Aucklanders [should be] treated equally.
6052-2 Jim Donald
111 MacLeans Road, Bucklands
Beach, Auckland 2014 RPS Urban growth
quality compact urban form [Enable] intensification [so as] to meet the cost of services.
6053-1 Mark Bennett markac@xtra.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - Rural zones
area Amend table 10 'Whitford' to read: Average Not < 4ha 0.8ha
6054-1 Simone Rasmussen svr668@yahoo.com Residential zones Residential
General Amend height restrictions to 1 level, with particular regard to 28 Riverview Road, Panmure.
6055-1
Auckland Netball Centre
Incorporated
diannelasenby@aucklandnetball.co.n
z Public Open Space Zones Public Open Space D2 Introduction
Rezone the area of Ngahue Reserve, Mount Wellington that is used by the Auckland Netball
Centre from Public Open Space Sport and Active Recreation to a new zone specifically for the
Auckland Netball Centre. The new zone should give effect to the Concept Plan E14-08A1 in
appendix 1 of the submission that sets out activities and development controls and include
provision for all outdoor netball courts to be covered with waterproof structures up to 12m in
height. Refer to the submission for details [pages 2-15/21].
6055-2
Incorporated
z Public Open Space Zones Public Open Space
Retain the rules for the Sport and Active Recreation zone that are consistent with and delete
the rules that are inconsistent with the existing Concept plan E14-08 A1 in Appendix 1 of the
submission [pages 2-15/21].
6055-3
Incorporated
Add rules for the Sport and Active Recreation zone that provide for netball courts to be
covered with waterproof structures up to 12m in height subject to the development controls
set out in the consent order/concept plan E14-08 A1. Refer to appendix 1 in the submission
[pages 2-15/21].
6055-4
Incorporated
z Public Open Space Zones Public Open Space D2 Introduction
Retain the approach of providing for 5 separate public open space zones to facilitate the
management of activities including the separation of the Community and Civic zones.
6055-5
Incorporated
z Public Open Space Zones
D2.3 Sport & Active
Recreation zone desc, obs &
pols
Retain the objective of creating a network of quality public open spaces that meet the
community's needs [objective 1].
6055-6
Incorporated
D2.3 Sport & Active
pols
Retain the policy to maximise the use of buildings and facilities (such as through multi-
functional use and adaptable designs) to increase the capacity of the public open space, and
avoid permanent single purpose buildings with restricted use [policy 5].
6055-7
Incorporated
D2.5 Community zone desc,
obs & pols
Retain the policy to provide public open spaces in town centres and urban areas to support
community activities, informal recreation and social interaction, and to enable events to take
place [policy 1].
6055-8
Incorporated
D8.4 Descriptions, objectives
and policies Retain the zone.
6055-9
Incorporated
z
policies Retain the zone.
6055-10
Incorporated
z
policies Retain objective 2 which allows for local communities to use school facilities.
55/1145
Sub#/
6055-11
Incorporated
z General C7.2/H6.1 Lighting
Delete the clauses 6.1 [Lighting] (1)-(4) which set out the illuminance levels but retain clause
6.1 [Lighting] (5) which relates to glare.
6055-12
Incorporated
Amend Rule 3.11 'Lighting' to include standards that; deal with spillage and glare rather than
lighting levels; the minimum lux for artificial lighting varies depending on different needs and
time restrictions are changed from 10pm to 6am - 11pm. Refer to the submission for details
pages 18-19/21.
6055-13
Incorporated
z General Noise and vibration H6.2 Rules
Amend Rule 1.3 'Recreational noise' so that the levels are 60dB (LAeq) 6am-11pm Monday to
Sunday and public holidays and 55dB at all other times rather than the varied times and limits
they are currently. Refer to the submission for details pages 19-20/21.
6055-14
Incorporated
z Earthworks H4.2.1.1 Activity table - Zones
Add the activity 'earthworks for the construction of sports fields' and amend the thresholds at
which activities are permitted so that maintenance activities such as the replacement of
an existing sand carpet is permitted [inferred].
6055-15
Incorporated
Amend Rule 3.9 'Maximum site coverage' so that the thresholds vary to reflect the character
of the spaces currently used e.g. netball and tennis.
6055-16
Incorporated
Amend Rule 3.10 'Maximum impervious area' to vary the thresholds depending on the activity
e.g. netball and tennis centres are likely to have approximately a 90-100% impervious area of
the public open space.
6055-17
Incorporated
requirements
Clarify the appropriate measure [e.g. parking spaces per person versus parking spaces per
hectare] to be applied to community sport organisations that manage / own facilities on public
open spaces and lower the thresholds to reflect the increase in use of public transport. Refer
to the submission for details page 21/21.
6056-1 Jenny Foster info@howickvillage.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - Rural zones
6057-1 Adrian Burr martin@greengroup.co.nz Zoning Central Retain the Single House zone for 12 and 18 Cremorne Street, Herne Bay.
6057-2 Adrian Burr martin@greengroup.co.nz Zoning Central
Retain the zone description, objectives and policies that pertain to 12 and 18 Cremorne
Street, Herne Bay.
6057-3 Adrian Burr martin@greengroup.co.nz Zoning Central
Retain the Single House zone development controls that pertain to 12 and 18 Cremorne
Street, Herne Bay.
6057-4 Adrian Burr martin@greengroup.co.nz General Cross plan matters
Retain the various overlay rules that pertain to 12 and 18 Cremorne Street, Herne Bay
[relevant overlays not identified].
6057-5 Adrian Burr martin@greengroup.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - Urban zones H5.2 3.1 Residential zones
Retain the Single House zone subdivision standards that pertain to 12 and 18 Cremorne
Street, Herne Bay.
6058-1 John M Anglem jmanglem@orcon.net.nz Residential zones Residential
Amend Single House development control 6.3(2) 'Height in relation to boundary' for sites
abutting Mixed Housing Suburban and Mixed Housing Urban, to make the height to boundary
controls on common boundaries the same.
and Coastal Settlement zone Delete Single House development control 6.4 'Yards', with particular regard to side yards.
Clarify Single House development control 6.9(2) 'Outdoor living space', especially in relation
to 6.9(3) [and the interpretation of 'rooms at ground level'].
and Coastal Settlement zone Delete Singe House development control 6.10 'Fences'.
and Coastal Settlement zone Delete Single House development control '6.11 Garages'.
and Coastal Settlement zone Delete Single House development control 6.12 'Universal access'.
Amend Mixed Housing Suburban development control 7.3(2) 'Height in relation to boundary'
for sites abutting the same or different zones, to apply the same height to boundary controls
on common boundaries.
Mixed Housing Urban zone Delete Mixed Housing Suburban development control 7.4 'Alternate height to boundary'.
56/1145
Sub#/
Mixed Housing Urban zone Delete Mixed Housing Suburban development control 7.5 'Yards'.
Mixed Housing Urban zone Delete Mixed Housing Suburban development control 7.10(1) 'Outlook space'.
Clarify Mixed Housing Suburban development control 7.12.2 'Outdoor living space', especially
in relation to 7.12(3) and [the interpretation of 'rooms at ground level'].
Mixed Housing Urban zone Delete Mixed Housing Suburban development control 7.13 'Dwellings fronting the street'.
Mixed Housing Urban zone Delete Mixed Housing Suburban development control 7.14 'Fences'.
Mixed Housing Urban zone Delete Mixed Housing Suburban development control 7.16 'Garages'.
6059-1 Patrick Kouwenhoven patkouwenhoven@hotmail.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - Rural zones
6060-1 Mark J Morgan mjmmedia@clear.net.nz RPS Mana Whenua
Fig. 1 Delete cultural sites.
6060-2 Mark J Morgan mjmmedia@clear.net.nz Historic Heritage (Overlay)
policies Delete heritage sites.
6061-1 Judith Groenewegen greenways@xtra.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - Rural zones
6062-1 Carol Kouwenhoven carolkouwenhoven@hotmail.com Subdivision Auckland-wide - Rural zones
6063-1 Duncan Clement
7 Hubert Henderson Place,
Remuera, Auckland 1050 Zoning Central
Reduce development [potential] in Hubert Henderson Place, or rezone it and Norden Place
and Richard Farrell Avenue from Mixed Housing Suburban zone to Single House.
Remuera, Auckland 1050 Residential zones Residential Land use controls
Delele 'density' controls [rule 3.1 Maximum density] for 1 dwelling per 300m
2
and 1 per
200m
2
in the Mixed Housing Suburban zone of Hubert Henderson Place and other narrow
streets with limited parking, or modify so as to not apply to certain streets - eg less than 7m
wide.
Remuera, Auckland 1050 Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
Amend parking standards to require 1.5 car parking spaces per bedroom in new
developments.
Remuera, Auckland 1050 Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
Amend 3 Development Controls to add a requirement that cars must be parked on hard
standing and not on grass and/or gardens.
Remuera, Auckland 1050 General Miscellaneous Bylaws and Licensing [Add] regulations preventing the obstruction of footpaths / driveways by vehicles.
Remuera, Auckland 1050 Residential zones Residential Land use controls
Amend rule 3.3(4) The conversion of an existing dwelling into two dwellings, to require parking
when converting one dwelling into two.
Remuera, Auckland 1050 Residential zones Residential
Mixed Housing Urban zone Delete rule 7.4 - Alternative height in relation to boundary.
Amend rule 7.3 'Height in relation to boundary' to include reference to north / south aspects to
ensure light is not unacceptably restricted by new development.
Amend rule 7.3 'Height in relation to boundary' to ensure that the topography and aspect of
the street are considered - not just height at the boundary point.
6064-1 Christine A De Boer christine.deboer@courierpost.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - Rural zones
area
Amend table 10 'Whitford' to read: Average Not < 4ha 1ha, or less, with two choices, 4000m2
and 6000m2
6065-1 Ka Tai Ko kesterko@gmail.com Zoning Central
Rezone 852A, 854, 856 and 856 Mount Eden Road, Mount Eden to Neighborhood Centre or
57/1145
Sub#/
6065-2 Ka Tai Ko kesterko@gmail.com
control
Delete the pre 1944 demolition control overlay from 852A, 854, 856 and 856 Mount Eden
Road, Mount Eden.
6066-1 Warner De Boer
51 Wades Road, RD1, Howick,
Auckland 2571 Subdivision Auckland-wide - Rural zones
area
Amend table 10 'Whitford' to read: Average Not < 4ha 1ha, or less, with two choices, 4000m2
and 6000m2
6067-1 Dennis Dominikovich rosedendom@gmail.com Zoning South
Rezone Awhitu to facilitate developing the area for retirees with small cluster business zones
and homestays, retirement villages etc.
6067-2 Dennis Dominikovich rosedendom@gmail.com General Miscellaneous
Operational/
Projects/Acquisition Reopen the Onehunga to Awhitu ferry service.
6068-1 R Utting c.utting@hotmail.com Subdivision Auckland-wide - Rural zones
6069-1 Roderick A Bray cmbbray@gmail.com RPS Mana Whenua B5 Strategic Delete specific rights, obligations, objectives, policies and rules in favour of Mana Whenua.
6069-2 Roderick A Bray cmbbray@gmail.com Mana Whenua
Whenua
Delete Mana Whenua's ability to impose, at will or subjectively, designation of Sites of
Significance or Value and [add] requirement that should Mana Whenua identify a site they be
required to apply to Council via Private Plan Change for approval of the site.
Whenua
Amend the PAUP so the NZ Historic Places Trust is the approving authority for the placing of
any site on the register as a Site of Significance or Value.
Whenua
Amend PAUP so that Sites of Significance or Value to Mana Whenua in the plan are limited
to those already recorded within existing Council Heritage Schedules of the various [former
council] Operative Plans.
6069-5 Roderick A Bray cmbbray@gmail.com General Miscellaneous Consultation and engagement
Conduct a referendum to determine the status of the Independent Mori Statutory Board; that
any rights provided to the Independent Mori Statutory Board or Mana Whenua be subject to
full democratic process; the Independent Mori Statutory Board be self funded and not
receive any further grants from Auckland Ratepayers.
6069-6 Roderick A Bray cmbbray@gmail.com General Chapter A Introduction A1 Background
Delete last two paragraphs of section 1.2 and replace with 'Unitary Plan is limited to fulfilling
its requirements only as required under the Treaty of Waitangi settlements and the Resource
Mangement Act'.
6069-7 Roderick A Bray cmbbray@gmail.com General Chapter A Introduction A2 Statutory Framework
Delete last paragraph of section 2.2 and replace with 'Auckland Council are required to notify
Mana Whenua of any application for Resource Consent on any Scheduled Site of
Significance or Value (as determined by NZ Historic Places Trust), as an affected party'.
6069-8 Roderick A Bray cmbbray@gmail.com RPS
Add to Policy 2(c) Mana Whenua '....as approved by application to the NZHPT and as fully
Schedule in accordance with the Historic Places Act 1993.'
6069-9 Roderick A Bray cmbbray@gmail.com RPS Mana Whenua
Fig. 1
Delete section and replace with 'Any site which Mana Whenua consider a site of Significance
or Value shall be subject to an application to the NZHPT and as fully Publically Notified as
part of a Private Plan Change for inclusion of any site as Specified Site on the Council
register by that Iwi. Any site which is currently contained within an Operative District Plan
Schedule shall be included within the Unitary Plan Schedule and Overlays.'
6069-10 Roderick A Bray cmbbray@gmail.com RPS Urban growth
6069-11 Roderick A Bray cmbbray@gmail.com General Miscellaneous Other
Amend G.2.7.4(k) to only refer to those sites currently included within the existing Operative
Plans.
6069-12 Roderick A Bray cmbbray@gmail.com RPS Mana Whenua B5 Introduction
Delete G3.2, clauses 5.2, 5.3 and 5.4 [query should be "B3" clauses 5.2, 5.3 and 5.4 - Issues
of significance to Mana Whenua] and rely upon 5.1 [as amended by submission point 9].
Whenua J5.1 Rules Delete rule 5.1.
6069-14 Roderick A Bray cmbbray@gmail.com Mana Whenua Auckland wide - Mori Land
controls Delete rule 2.1.2(1) Notification.
Whenua
whenua
Delete and replace with 'Any site which Mana Whenua consider a site of Significance or
Value shall be subject to an application to the NZHPT and as fully Publically Notified as part
of a Private Plan Change for inclusion of any site as Specified Site on the Council register by
that Iwi. Any site which is currently contained within an Operative District Plan Schedule shall
be included within the Unitary Plan Schedule and Overlays.'
58/1145
Sub#/
6069-16 Roderick A Bray cmbbray@gmail.com Definitions Existing
Delete 2nd and 3rd paragraphs of Mana Whenua Cultural Heritage definition and replace with
''Any site which Mana Whenua consider a site of Significance or Value shall be subject to an
application to the NZHPT and as fully Publically Notified as part of a Private Plan Change for
inclusion of any site as Specified Site on the Council register by that Iwi. Any site which is
currently contained within an Operative District Plan Schedule shall be included within the
Unitary Plan Schedule and Overlays.'
6069-17 Roderick A Bray cmbbray@gmail.com Definitions Existing
Delete definition of Mori Cultural Landscapes and replace with 'Any site which Mana
Whenua consider a site of Significance or Value shall be subject to an application to the
NZHPT and as fully Publically Notified as part of a Private Plan Change for inclusion of any
site as Specified Site on the Council register by that Iwi. Any site which is currently contained
within an Operative District Plan Schedule shall be included within the Unitary Plan Schedule
and Overlays.'
Whenua J5.2 Rules Delete rule 5.2.
settlement land
rules/App. 4.3 legislation Delete rule 2(1) Notification.
Whenua
Delete and replace with ''Any site which Mana Whenua consider a site of Significance or
Value shall be subject to an application to the NZHPT and as fully Publically Notified as part
of a Private Plan Change for inclusion of any site as Specified Site on the Council register by
6069-21 Roderick A Bray cmbbray@gmail.com Mana Whenua General provisions
assessment
Delete from G2.7.4(k) the text "or that are made known to the applicant during any
consultation process which may have been undertaken ."
6070-1 Tim Robinson tim12robinson@googlemail.com RPS Urban growth
Retain approach of planning for the future that moves our city forward to meet challenges,
rather than looking back to past solutions and expectations.
quality compact urban form Retain intent to create a compact, quality urban form.
Retain overall approach to distributing growth across the city based on strategic urban design
considerations, with balanced focus on intensification and necessary greenfield growth. This
approach will address issues of affordability, choice and capacity.
environment Retain the need to promote quality intensification.
environment
Retain the emphasis on design quality and the use of new tools, both regulatory and non-
statutory.
6070-6 Tim Robinson tim12robinson@googlemail.com General Eplan Retain the use of new electronic formats to communicate the plan.
6070-7 Tim Robinson tim12robinson@googlemail.com General Editorial and Part 6 Retain the intent to simplify provisions, for example the reduction in number of zones.
6070-8 Tim Robinson tim12robinson@googlemail.com General Editorial and Part 6 Retain the intent to simplify regulation in the interests of more effective plan operation.
6070-9 Tim Robinson tim12robinson@googlemail.com Residential zones Housing affordability
and policies Retain the intent to tackle issues of housing affordability.
6070-10 Tim Robinson tim12robinson@googlemail.com Zoning West Retain Mixed Housing zone at 3 Levy Road, Glen Eden.
6070-11 Tim Robinson tim12robinson@googlemail.com Zoning West Retain zoning across the Waitakere Local Board area.
6070-12 Tim Robinson tim12robinson@googlemail.com General Chapter A Introduction A3 Strategic Framework Seeks that policies and rules be better aligned.
Seeks that the extent and scale of up-zoning should both be increased, particularly in the
central isthmus area.
6070-14 Tim Robinson tim12robinson@googlemail.com Residential zones Residential
Special info. req.
Remove thresholds and specific exclusions from quality-based requirements, such as the
threshold for 5 or more units for application of key assessment criteria and rules in some
residential zones should be removed.
6070-15 Tim Robinson tim12robinson@googlemail.com Transport Auckland -wide
requirements Remove parking requirements.
Mixed Housing Urban zone Amend the maximum building height/storey in the Mixed Housing Suburban zone to 3 storeys.
6070-17 Tim Robinson tim12robinson@googlemail.com General Editorial and Part 6 Amend numbering approach, and ensure the numbering system works on the e-plan.
quality compact urban form Increase the extent of the Mixed Housing Urban zone, particularly in the central isthmus area.
6070-19 Tim Robinson tim12robinson@googlemail.com Residential zones Residential Land use controls Amend density controls to align with the objectives of the zone.
Mixed Housing Urban zone Reduce the separation between buildings in the Mixed Housing Urban zone.
General
Amend approach to controlling dwelling quality, avoid favouring low density development.
Control of dwelling characteristics should not be selective on the basis of zones.
59/1145
Sub#/
Amend Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings controls to specifically accommodate
terraced housing forms.
General Add maximum dimensions as well as proportions to frontage controls for [garaging].
Increase height controls in the Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings zone to make
development economically feasible.
General
Amend private outdoor space controls in the Mixed Housing Urban, Mixed Housing Suburban
and Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings zone to recognise the varying needs typically
associated with homes of different sizes.
6070-26 Tim Robinson tim12robinson@googlemail.com Transport Auckland -wide
requirements Remove all minimum parking requirements from residential zones.
Amend [building] coverage controls to enable terraced housing in the Terrace Housing and
Apartment Buildings zone.
Amend [building] coverage controls to enable smaller homes in the Mixed Housing Suburban
zone.
6070-29 Tim Robinson tim12robinson@googlemail.com Residential zones Residential Land use controls
Add rules to allow development of small dwellings on small sites, particularly by removing
density controls based on minimum lot size and replacing with an approach to density which is
based on design quality and amenity outcomes.
6070-30 Tim Robinson tim12robinson@googlemail.com Subdivision Auckland-wide - Urban zones H5.2 3.1 Residential zones
Amend provisions to ensure existing rear lot development is not prevented in cases where a
new roads can be included as part of development.
6070-31 Tim Robinson tim12robinson@googlemail.com Subdivision Auckland-wide - Urban zones H5.2 3.1 Residential zones Add rules which enable "zero lot line development" within the Mixed Housing Suburban zone.
Amend rules to allow buildings to be built up to the boundary line, where permission of that
neighbour is granted within the Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings zone.
General
Amend servicing and waste controls to allow greater flexibility, while retaining
the requirement to address the issue.
6070-34 Tim Robinson tim12robinson@googlemail.com Sustainable Development C7.7/H6.4 Sustainable design Remove threshold on homestar provisions.
Amend rules to enable smaller terraced housing developments, with individually owned lots
based on the assumption of common wall construction.
and Coastal Settlement zone Apply minimum room size and storage rules to the Single House zone.
General
Apply basic solar orientation requirements (private outdoor space and primary living spaces in
relation to the North) to all residential developments in the Single House, Mixed Housing
Suburban and Mixed Housing Urban zones.
Apply quality controls to private outdoor open space in the Single House, Large Lot and
Rural/Coastal zones.
General
Add controls to address location and relationship of public or common spaces in relation to
bedrooms in multi-unit schemes.
Terrace Housing and
Apartment Buildings zone
Add street frontage controls to the Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings zone, adopting a
similar approach to the Mixed Housing Urban and Mixed Housing Suburban zone controls.
General
Apply controls over parking location in relation to street interfaces to all residential schemes,
including development of less than 5 units.
6070-42 Tim Robinson tim12robinson@googlemail.com Definitions New Add definition of 'rear lane'.
6070-43 Tim Robinson tim12robinson@googlemail.com Subdivision Auckland-wide - Urban zones H5.2 3.1 Residential zones Amend to clarify measurement of the interface between the lot and the lane.
6070-44 Tim Robinson tim12robinson@googlemail.com Subdivision Auckland-wide - Urban zones H5.2 3.1 Residential zones
Amend to clarify provisions regarding accessways in the subdivision section with regard
auckland-wide parking rules (some contradiction).
General
Add mix requirements, relating to limiting high proportion of large dwellings in a single
development.
Amend private outdoor space requirements, to make them consistent across any building
level in the Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings zone.
60/1145
Sub#/
Resolve integration of rules for setbacks and outlook in the Terrace Housing and Apartment
Buildings zone, to ensure that side yards are not a wasteful allocation of space.
6070-48 Tim Robinson tim12robinson@googlemail.com Subdivision Auckland-wide - Urban zones H5.2 3.1 Residential zones Amend the rules to align with anticipated typologies, in particular terraced housing forms.
6070-49 Tim Robinson tim12robinson@googlemail.com Definitions Existing
Amend 'rear site' definition, to ensure it does not deny a range of good design outcomes to
be achieved that are not defined by their relationship to a publicly owned street.
General Remove thresholds from key design and quality rules [page 6/11 of submission].
Increase height control in the Mixed Housing Suburban zone to permit and encourage three
storeys [page 6/11 of submission].
6070-52 Tim Robinson tim12robinson@googlemail.com General Chapter G General provisions
statements Remove threshold relating to design statements [page 8/11 of submission].
6070-53 Tim Robinson tim12robinson@googlemail.com General Chapter G General provisions
statements Remove threshold relating to design quality requirements [page 8/11 of submission].
6071-1 Lynda E Todd ltodd@xtra.co.nz Special Character
residential
Add Maranui Avenue, Wainoni Avenue, Walker Road, Neville Street, Muripara Avenue,
Target Street, Point Chevalier to the special character overlay. Supports provisions to protect
character.
6071-2 Lynda E Todd ltodd@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central Retain single house zone along Maranui Avenue, Point Chevalier.
6071-3 Lynda E Todd ltodd@xtra.co.nz RPS Urban growth
Amend to reduce levels of intensification to a level that will not overstretch the local schools,
shopping facilities and prevent traffic volumes increasing.
6071-4 Lynda E Todd ltodd@xtra.co.nz Special Character
residential
special character areas Retain character overlay.
6071-5 Lynda E Todd ltodd@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central Retain Single House zone on Wainoni Avenue, Point Chevalier.
6072-1 Jana Durdevic durdevic@orcon.net.nz Zoning North and Islands
Rezone Bayview, Jutland Roads, Hauraki from Mixed Housing Urban to Mixed Housing
Suburban.
6073-1
Cato Bolam Consultants
Limited mylesg@catobolam.co.nz
SEAs
and policies
Amend to clarify or add explanation to Policy 1(a) 'provide cumulatively for at least 10 per cent
of the natural extent of each ecosystem type'.
6073-2
Limited mylesg@catobolam.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - Rural zones
area
Retain transferable title provisions for South Rodney, Wellsford, Kaukapakapa and
Helensville to obtain a 1ha average site size. Clarify if South Rodney area includes
Riverhead, Coatesville, Dairy Flat and the Stillwater and Okura areas.
6073-3
area
Retain ability to create new sites in the Rural Production and Mixed Rural zones
through transferable rural title subdivision.
6073-4
area
Amend to allow 1 new site on a property under 10ha, 2 [new sites] on a property over 20ha, 3
[new sites] on a property over 40ha and 4 [new sites] on a property over 100ha.
6073-5
area Amend minimum site size of 0.4ha in the Rural Production and Mixed Rural zones.
6073-6
area Amend to prohibit cats on all new rural lots.
6073-7
area
Add 150m separation distance between any new dwelling and any natural area being
protected.
6073-8
area Amend to permit only one dwelling per new site.
6073-9
area
Amend to allow the movement of sites resulting from natural area protection from
Rural Production to Rural Production, or from Rural Production to Mixed Rural.
6073-10
Limited mylesg@catobolam.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - general
controls Delete requirement to vest an esplanade reserve on properties of over 4ha.
6073-11
Limited mylesg@catobolam.co.nz Earthworks H4.2.1.1 Activity table - Zones Retain ability to conduct earthworks up to 1,000m3 as a permitted activity in a Rural zone.
6073-12
Limited mylesg@catobolam.co.nz Earthworks H4.2.1.1 Activity table - Zones Retain ability to conduct earthworks up to 200m3 within the Countryside Living zone.
6073-13
Limited mylesg@catobolam.co.nz Earthworks H4.2.1.1 Activity table - Zones
Retain ability to conduct earthworks in a flood plain as a permitted activity, subject to outlined
controls.
61/1145
Sub#/
6073-14
area Amend Rule 2.3.3(1)(c)(i) to reduce the specified building area from 5,000m2 to 1,000m2.
6073-15
area Amend Rule 2.3.3(1)(c)(ii) to reduce the area clear of yards from 2,000m2 to 1,000m2.
6073-16
area Amend Rule 2.3.3(2)(c) about valuable natural features to use consistent wording.
6073-17
area
Delete Rule 2.3.3(3)(b)(i) to remove the requirement for a bush or wetland area to be
identified as a SEA in order to allow protection to gain a transferable title right. Retain the
need for individual assessment of the quality of a SEA.
6073-18
area
Amend Rule 2.3.3(4)(a)(iii) to remove the requirement for a donor site to be a minimum of
1ha.
6073-19
area
Clarify Rule 2.3.3(4)(a)(iv) to give better explanation of the intent on whether the 40ha include
only land involved in the application, or adjoining surrounding land not involved.
6073-20
area
Amend Rule 2.3.3(4)(c)(iii) to specify that the dwelling must be located outside the identified
areas.
6073-21
area Amend Rule 2.3.3(4)(c)(iv) to reduce the minimum site size to 1ha or less.
6073-22
area
Amend Rule 2.3.3(4)(c)(viii) to only apply when there is a known possibility of the new title
being on elite land.
6073-23
area
Amend Rule 2.3.3(4)(c)(x) to include a scale that provides for more new titles as a parent title
gets larger, two new titles at 40ha, three new titles at 100ha with one more for each 100ha of
the parent site size.
6073-24
area
Delete Rule 2.3.3(5)(a)(i) to remove the requirement for a bush or wetland area to be
identified as a SEA in order to allow protection to gain a transferable title right. Retain the
need for individual assessment of the quality of a SEA.
6073-25
area
Amend Rule 2.3.3(5)(a)(ii) to allow for the contemporaneous creation of covenants and the
new titles.
6073-26
area
Amend Rule 2.3.3(5)(a)(ii) to provide guidelines as to when planting or
other enhancement work is expected when applying to covenant an SEA.
6073-27
area
Amend Rule 2.3.3(5)(a)(ii) to retain the ability for the use of bonds to allow for the early
release of the s224(c) for applications that involve planting.
6073-28
area
Amend Table 8 to provide additional explanation to the final comment, and confirm that
consents issued under legacy plans can have titles sold as transferable titles.
6073-29
area
Amend Table 8 to retain the current scale of title yield as it relates to bush or wetlands area,
as currently outlined in the operative Rodney District Plan.
6073-30
area
Amend Table 8 to require establishment of native plants within it at 2m centres. Retain a 10m
buffer zone.
6073-31
area
Retain in Table 8 a 2ha bush area as a minimum size for the creation of a transferable title
right.
6073-32
area
Clarify Rule 2.3.3(5)(a)(viii) that an application for bush protection protects only bush, and that
a wetland protection application only involves the protection of wetland.
6073-33
area Amend Rule 2.3.3(5)(a)(ix) to restrict protection to the identified natural area.
6073-34
area
Amend Rule 2.3.3(5)(a)(x) to allow for the contemporaneous creation of covenants and the
issue of titles.
62/1145
Sub#/
6073-35
area
Amend Rule 2.3.3(6)(a)(iv) to have a requirement of the initial implementation of an animal
pest management plan.
6073-36
area Amend Rule 2.3.3(7)(a) to remove the reference to a 10 per cent area
6073-37
area
Amend Rule 2.3.3(8)(c)(iii) Table 10 to retain the ability to use transferable titles in the
Kumeu/Huapai area.
6073-38
area
Amend Table 10 to retain a 2ha average site size in the Okura area, unless provisions do
allow the smaller 1ha site size.
6073-39
area
Amend Rule 2.3.3(8)(d)(ii) to retain a 1000m2 building area in regard to
geotechnical requirements.
6073-40
area
Amend Rule 2.3.3(9)(b) about subdivision of less than 150ha to remove the prohibited activity
status.
6073-41
Limited mylesg@catobolam.co.nz RPS Rural B8.3 Rural subdivision
Add new objectives and policies or amend existing to provide for the ability to create new titles
in the Rural Production and Mixed Rural zones.
6073-42
area
Amend Rule 2(a)(i) - (iv) to remove the requirement for a plan identifying the features outlined
[clause 2(a)(i) - (iv)], or confirm there will be no requirement for the natural features identified
to be included as protected areas.
6073-43
Limited mylesg@catobolam.co.nz Zoning North and Islands Rezone to remove the Rural Coastal zone from the Kaipara Harbour and South Head area.
6073-44
area Amend Rule 2.3.3(7)(a) to change activity status from prohibited to a discretionary activity.
6074-1 Warren Avery wavery@clear.net.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - Rural zones
area Amend Table 10 by reducing minimum net site area required at Okura from 4ha to 2ha.
6075-1 Wayne Walker wayne@waynewalker.co.nz Zoning North and Islands Rezone 29-33 Brixton Road, Manly to Single House.
6075-2 Wayne Walker wayne@waynewalker.co.nz Residential zones Residential
General
Amend waste minimisation provisions for apartment and high rise zones to require
appropriate design for high-rise and apartment buildings. A customised waste plan could
include the provision of waste and recycling chutes for taller buildings.
6076-1 David Phillimore phillimorefamily@gmail.com General Noise and vibration H6.2 Rules
Amend noise levels for all activities as follows, 'Monday to Saturday 7am - 10pm and Sunday
9am-6pm as 50dB Laeq; and all other times as 40dB Laeq'.
6076-2 David Phillimore phillimorefamily@gmail.com General Noise and vibration H6.2 Rules
Amend rule 1.3 Recreational Noise as follows; 'Monday to Saturday 7am - 10pm and Sunday
6076-3 David Phillimore phillimorefamily@gmail.com Air Quality
and policies
Amend PAUP to include rules restricting odours from businesses such as restaurants, cafes
and produce stores.
6076-4 David Phillimore phillimorefamily@gmail.com
sensitive areas rules J6.3 Rules Retain Non-Complying activity status and public notification provisions.
Amend activity status for activities which breach the floor of the volcanic view
shafts or the 8m height sensitive area limit restrictions inside or outside the view shafts to be a
Prohibited activity.
6076-6 David Phillimore phillimorefamily@gmail.com Zoning Central
Rezone Poronui Street, Oaklands Street, Stokes Road, Eglinton Avenue and Rautangi Road,
Mt Eden, from Mixed Housing Urban and Terrace Houses and Apartment Buildings to a zone
that limits building height to 8m.
Centre) Business
Park zones Amend the height rules for Mt Eden to '8 m and maximum two storeys'.
6076-8 David Phillimore phillimorefamily@gmail.com Public Open Space Zones Public Open Space
Amend notification provisions to require public notification for all public open space activities,
including Permitted and Restricted Discretionary activities, with particular regard to Mt Eden
Reserve, Nicholson Park, Windmill Road Park, Melville Park, Pollard Park, Potters Park and
Three Kings Reserve.
6076-9 David Phillimore phillimorefamily@gmail.com Public Open Space Zones Public Open Space
Amend provisions to limit the scale, intensity, frequency and hours of operation of community
use of school land, buildings and infrastructure so that it is complementary and secondary to
the educational purposes of the site. Provide for allowable use between 8am and 10pm Mon -
Sat, and 9am to 6pm on Sunday.
6076-10 David Phillimore phillimorefamily@gmail.com Zoning Central
Rezone Poronui Street, Oaklands Road, Stokes Road, Eglinton Avenue, Rautangi Road,
Essex Road, Ngauruhoe Street, Grange Road, Ashton Road and Tarata Street, Mt Eden, to
Single House.
63/1145
Sub#/
6076-11 David Phillimore phillimorefamily@gmail.com Special Character
& C
Isthmus
Add the Special Character overlay to Poronui Street, Eglinton Avenue, Stokes Road,
Oaklands Road, Rautangi Road, Valley Road, Ashton Road, Tarata Street, Grange Road,
Ngauruhoe Street and Essex Road, Mt Eden.
& C J3.3.1-7 Rules
Amend provisions to be more explicit in regards to the character and design of the Special
Character streets in terms of street parking layout, traffic calming measures, berms, footpaths,
street trees, lighting poles, service reticulation poles and signage so all are in character with
existing residential properties.
& C J3.3.1-7 Rules
Amend provisions to be more explicit in regard to requiring the design and character of new
building work in Special Character Isthmus B2 areas; and to be more explicit in regards to
design in allowing new building work generally and especially the design of new building work
in front of existing houses in the Special Character Isthmus B2 areas.
6076-14 David Phillimore phillimorefamily@gmail.com Residential zones Residential
policies Retain the Mixed House Suburban and Mixed House Urban zones.
6077-1 Massey University justine.bray@opus.co.nz
Purpose) D8.10 & I24 Tertiary Education Provide a section 32 analysis on the final Tertiary Education provisions.
6077-2 Massey University justine.bray@opus.co.nz RPS Issues
B1.2 Enabling economic
wellbeing
Revise the section to recognise the importance of tertiary education for its role to the
economic well-being of Auckland.
6077-3 Massey University justine.bray@opus.co.nz RPS Urban growth
quality compact urban form Retain section.
6077-4 Massey University justine.bray@opus.co.nz RPS Urban growth
environment Retain section.
6077-5 Massey University justine.bray@opus.co.nz RPS Urban growth B2.7 Social infrastructure
Revise the section to recognise the importance of tertiary education for its role to the
6077-6 Massey University justine.bray@opus.co.nz RPS
Transport
B3.2 Significant infrastructure
and energy
Revise the section to recognise the importance of tertiary education, as a piece of significant
infrastructure, to the economic well-being of Auckland.
6077-7 Massey University justine.bray@opus.co.nz RPS
Transport
B3.1 Commercial and
industrial growth
Add a new policy to recognise and provide for the importance of tertiary education to the
Purpose) D8.10 & I24 Tertiary Education Delete the Special Purpose: Tertiary Education zone provisions.
6077-9 Massey University justine.bray@opus.co.nz Precincts Ak-Wide and Coastal New Precincts All other New Precincts
Replace the Special Purpose: Tertiary Education zone with a tertiary education precinct/sub
precinct(s). Refer to the submission for details on Massey University Albany Campus sub-
precinct [pg 28-32/32].
6077-10 Massey University justine.bray@opus.co.nz Zoning North and Islands
Rezone Massey University Albany Campus, Albany from Special Purpose: Tertiary Education
to Mixed Use.
6077-11 Massey University justine.bray@opus.co.nz General Chapter A Introduction
A4.2 Area based planning
tools Delete the reference to 'concept plans'.
6077-12 Massey University justine.bray@opus.co.nz General Chapter A Introduction
tools
Clarify the content, process and use of 'concept plans', referenced in specific rules in the
PAUP.
Purpose) D8.10 & I24 Tertiary Education Delete I24.2 [Land use controls].
Purpose) D8.10 & I24 Tertiary Education
Delete I24.3 [Development controls] and replace with appropriate controls [tertiary education
precinct] reflective of the specific location and context of each tertiary institute covered by the
zone.
6077-15 Massey University justine.bray@opus.co.nz General Chapter G General provisions G2.2 Activities not provided for Delete rule.
6077-16 Massey University justine.bray@opus.co.nz General Chapter G General provisions G2.2 Activities not provided for Amend rule, so that activities are classified as Discretionary activity.
6077-17 Massey University justine.bray@opus.co.nz General Chapter G General provisions G2.4 Notification Retain rule 2.4.
6077-18 Massey University justine.bray@opus.co.nz Mana Whenua General provisions
assessment Remove rule G2.7.4(4) [Cultural Impact Assessment].
6077-19 Massey University justine.bray@opus.co.nz Natural Hazards and Flooding Natural Hazards
G2.7.5 Information
requirements Delete rule G2.7.5 [General information for resource consents - Natural hazards].
6077-20 Massey University justine.bray@opus.co.nz Natural Hazards and Flooding Natural Hazards
Assessment
Include natural hazard assessment requirements (currently included in rule G2.7.5) within
section.
6077-21 Massey University justine.bray@opus.co.nz Historic Heritage (Overlay)
Heritage
G2.7.8 Spec. info. req. & G2.5-
1 Accidental discovery
protocols Delete G2.7.8 [Historic heritage].
SEAs
Land Remove SEA-T_8340 from the Massey University Albany campus, Albany.
64/1145
Sub#/
SEAs
Land
Refine the SEA-T_8340 boundaries to reflect Massey University's existing use rights with
respect to development at its Albany campus.
6077-24 Massey University justine.bray@opus.co.nz Transport Auckland -wide
H1.2.1 Activity table H1.2.2
Notification
Amend the activity status for 'off-site parking' from discretionary to restricted discretionary
activity in Activity Table 1.
requirements
Retain the parking ratios based on Full Time Equivalent Employees and Students (EFTS) for
tertiary education facilities in development control 3.2, Tables 3, 4 and 5.
requirements Retain parking ratios in development control 3.2, Table 3, as parking maximums.
requirements
Amend development control 3.2, Table 4, so that parking ratios for tertiary education facilities
are set as parking maximums.
requirements
Amend development control 3.2, Table 5, so that cycle parking ratios are based on site-
specific considerations such as topography, local catchment, cycling infrastructure etc.
requirements
Amend development control 3.2, Table 6, so that end-of-trip facilities at tertiary education
sites address the provision of facilities as a whole.
6077-30 Massey University justine.bray@opus.co.nz Earthworks H4.2.1.1 Activity table - Zones
Revise H4.2 to provide clarity and certainty as to what specific activity maybe applicable for
an application.
Amend the activity table by increasing general earthwork thresholds to align with thresholds
for road/network utility services.
6077-32 Massey University justine.bray@opus.co.nz Earthworks
Overlays
6077-33 Massey University justine.bray@opus.co.nz Earthworks H4.2.1.3 Activity table - ONFs
Amend the activity table by generally increasing the thresholds which trigger the need for
resource consent.
Overlays
resource consent.
6077-36 Massey University justine.bray@opus.co.nz Earthworks H4.2.1.3 Activity table - ONFs
resource consent.
Overlays Delete the activity table.
6077-38 Massey University justine.bray@opus.co.nz Water Stormwater
Overlay E7.5 Stormwater
Management Area - flow
Remove the Stormwater management Area-Flow 2 from Massey University's Albany campus,
Albany.
H4.14.2 Stormwater
management -flow rules Delete H4.14.2 [Stormwater management-flow].
rules Delete H4.14.3 [Stormwater management-quality].
H4.14.2 Stormwater
Reclassify H4.14.2 [Stormwater management-flow] as rules in accordance with s15 of the
RMA.
rules
Reclassify H4.14.3 [Stormwater management-quality] as rules in accordance with s15 of the
RMA.
H4.14.1 Stormwater discharge
rules
Amend the activity table by aligning impervious surface thresholds between roads and other
general impervious surfaces (e.g buildings).
rules
Review the activity status within the activity table for impervious surface thresholds which
trigger the requirement for resource consent.
rules Amend the rules to take into consideration any reduction in impervious surfaces.
6077-46 Massey University justine.bray@opus.co.nz General
H6.5) Retain rules.
6077-47 Massey University justine.bray@opus.co.nz Definitions Existing
Amend the definition of 'student accommodation' to read 'Living accommodation, primarily
used or designed to be used by registered students or guests of a tertiary education facility
and which is served by one or more communal living areas, including kitchens. The
building(s) in which the student accommodation is located is composed of no more than one
site or stratum estate in freehold or leasehold, in one certificate of title .'
6077-48 Massey University justine.bray@opus.co.nz Definitions Existing Retain the definition of 'Tertiary education facilities.'
6077-49 Massey University justine.bray@opus.co.nz Public Open Space Zones Public Open Space I2.1 Activity table Delete 'informal recreation' as a specific activity.
6077-50 Massey University justine.bray@opus.co.nz Definitions Existing Delete the definition of 'informal recreation'.
6077-51 Massey University justine.bray@opus.co.nz Definitions Existing Amend the definition of 'Infrastructure' to include 'tertiary education'.
65/1145
Sub#/
6078-1 Daniel Thomas windsurfing_dan@hotmail.com Precincts - North Bayswater
objectives and policies Delete all provisions relating to residential activities and development in sub-precinct B.
6078-2 Daniel Thomas windsurfing_dan@hotmail.com Precincts - North Bayswater K5.6 Precinct rules
Amend rule 2 'Notification' to require that any future residential development in the precinct be
fully notified.
6078-3 Daniel Thomas windsurfing_dan@hotmail.com Precincts - North Bayswater K5.6 Precinct rules
Amend activity status for dwellings with or without a framework plan from Discretionary to Non-
Complying.
6079-1 Catherine Towns catherine.e.towns@gmail.com Precincts - North Bayswater K5.6 Precinct rules
Retain community recreation, public transport, open space, marine boating activities and
parking. Delete residential development and zoning.
6080-1 Momcilo Durdevic airnbrush@gmail.com Zoning North and Islands
Rezone Bayview, Jutland, Lake and Northboro roads block, Hauraki from Mixed Housing
Urban to Mixed Housing Suburban.
6081-1 Marian Kohler mariankohler03@gmail.com General Miscellaneous Other Support Herne Bay Residents Association Incorporated submission.
6082-1 Marilyn McPherson mjmac@xtra.co.nz Special Character
residential
Apply a Special Character Overlay to Hill Park, Manurewa to protect the original pattern of
subdivision and vegetation.
6082-2 Marilyn McPherson mjmac@xtra.co.nz Built Environment (Overlays)
Overlay E4.6 Local public
views / Appendix 3.5 Local
Public Views
Apply new development controls to areas adjoining Hill Park to protect views of Hill Park from
outside of it (ie retain views of the hill).
6082-3 Marilyn McPherson mjmac@xtra.co.nz Residential zones Residential
policies
Apply a transition zone around the Hill Park, Manurewa footprint , being Great South Road,
Alfriston Road, Orams Road and the Southern Motorway.
6082-4 Marilyn McPherson mjmac@xtra.co.nz Special Character
residential
Undertake a character study of Hill Park, Manurewa, and use the results to formulate new
development controls, including yard setbacks, fencing and front faade requirements.
6082-5 Marilyn McPherson mjmac@xtra.co.nz Historic Heritage (Overlay)
Heritage
Places
Identify significant properties that might be suitable for scheduling and protection in Hill Park
Manurewa.
6082-6 Marilyn McPherson mjmac@xtra.co.nz Zoning South
Rezone Mixed Housing areas which abut property zoned Single House in Hill Park,
Manurewa.
6082-7 Marilyn McPherson mjmac@xtra.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - Urban zones H5.2 3.1 Residential zones
Require subdivision of any lot under 750m
2
to be a non-complying activity in Hill Park,
Manurewa.
6082-8 Marilyn McPherson mjmac@xtra.co.nz
Centre) Business
Park zones Reduce the maximum height in the Manurawa Town Centre from 8 storeys to 4 storeys.
6082-9 Marilyn McPherson mjmac@xtra.co.nz Trees
Trees J6.4 Rules
Amend rules to make it easier to get trees and groves of trees notified (in context of
reinforcing the importance of Hill Park, Manurewa as a biodiversity corridor).
SEAs
Land Designate all of Hill Park, Manurewa as a SEA.
Trees
Notable Trees Continue to schedule individual trees and groves of trees.
SEAs
and policies Clarify what the difference is between a SEA and a property with notified vegetation.
Trees J6.4 Rules
Require a new native tree to be planted on the same site where a significant tree has been
removed.
6082-14 Marilyn McPherson mjmac@xtra.co.nz General
GIS viewer Further define overland flow paths/floodplains, and added this information to GIS.
6082-15 Marilyn McPherson mjmac@xtra.co.nz RPS
character and natural heritage B4.3.3 Trees and vegetation Re-introduce tree protection rules based on species and height /girth of trees.
6083-1 Gavin F Logan gavinlgn@gmail.com Residential zones Residential Land use controls Amend density of Mixed Housing Suburban zone to 1 dwelling per 300m2
6083-2 Gavin F Logan gavinlgn@gmail.com Residential zones Residential Land use controls Amend density of Mixed Housing Urban zone to 1 dwelling per 250m2
6083-3 Gavin F Logan gavinlgn@gmail.com Zoning Central Rezone 15 Harbutt Avenue, Mt Albert to Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings.
6083-4 Gavin F Logan gavinlgn@gmail.com Zoning West Rezone 36 Methuen Road, Avondale to Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings.
6084-1 Contact Energy Limited
rosemary.dixon@contactenergy.co.n
z Zoning South
Rezone the Otahuhu Power Station site (located adjacent to State Highway 1 and the Tamaki
River, Otara) from Light Industry to Heavy Industry. Refer to the full submission for a map of
the site in Attachment A [page 34/36].
z
Purpose) New Zones
Add a new zone 'Power Station' to be applied to the Otahuhu Power Station site. Refer to
Attachment B of the full submission [page 35-36/36] for details regarding the description,
objectives, policies, rules and development controls for this zone. Refer to the full submission
for a map of the site in Attachment A [page 34/36].
z Precincts - South New Precincts All other New Precincts
Add a new precinct to be applied to the Otahuhu Power Station site. Refer to Attachment B of
the full submission [page 35-36/36] for details regarding the description, objectives, policies,
rules and development controls for this precinct. Refer to the full submission for a map of the
site in Attachment A [page 34/36].
z RPS
Retain the absence of any natural heritage overlays at the Otahuhu Power Station site
(located adjacent to State Highway 1 and the Tamaki River, Otara). Refer to the full
submission for a map of the site in Attachment A [page 34/36].
66/1145
Sub#/
z Built Environment (Overlays)
Height Control
Retain the absence of an 'Additional Zone Height Control' overlay at the Otahuhu Power
Station site (located adjacent to State Highway 1 and the Tamaki River, Otara). Refer to the
full submission for a map of the site in Attachment A [page 34/36].
z Historic Heritage (Overlay)
Heritage
Places
Retain the absence of 'Historic Heritage' overlays at the Otahuhu Power Station site (located
adjacent to State Highway 1 and the Tamaki River, Otara). Refer to the full submission for a
map of the site in Attachment A [page 34/36].
z RPS Changes to the RUB South
Retain the absence of an 'Rural Urban Boundary' overlay at the Otahuhu Power Station site
(located adjacent to State Highway 1 and the Tamaki River, Otara). Refer to the full
submission for a map of the site in Attachment A [page 34/36].
z RPS Issues
growth Retain 1.1 Enabling quality urban growth [subject to changes requested].
z RPS Issues
growth
Amend the Unitary Plan issue (relating to ways to manage growth) to add a bullet point:
'allows for the development of new infrastructure'.
z RPS Issues
growth
Amend the 'Explanation' to read: 'physical resources, including accessing these resources
when they are constrained.'
z RPS Issues
growth
Amend the first two paragraphs under the heading 'Social Well-being' to recognise the need
for access to resilient significant infrastructure and to include the ability to access natural and
physical resources as a factor that influences social well-being. Refer to the full submission
for suggested wording changes [pages 11-12/36].
z RPS Issues
growth
Amend 'Supply of land in appropriate location' to divide into a separate section for 'significant
infrastructure', to better align with the two distinct targets for existing urban areas and
significant infrastructure. Refer to the full submission for suggested wording changes [page
12/36].
z RPS Issues
wellbeing Retain the section on 'Energy' [subject to amendments].
z RPS Issues
wellbeing
Amend the first paragraph under the heading 'Energy', to include reference to local thermal
electricity generation. Refer to the full submission for suggested wording changes [pages
13/36].
z RPS Issues
B1.8 Responding to climate
change
Amend paragraph 4 under the heading 'Mitigation', to recognise the role local thermal
generation plays in supporting the region's use of renewable electricity. Refer to the full
submission for suggested wording changes [page 15/36].
z RPS
Transport
B3.1 Commercial and
industrial growth
Retain 3.1, in particular objective 3 and policy 10 (relating to industrial growth in appropriate
locations), and policy 11 (relating to efficient use of industrial land and avoiding incompatible
activities).
z RPS
Transport
and energy Add a new objective: '8. The interdependent nature of significant infrastructure is recognised'.
z RPS
Transport
and energy
Add a new policy: '7. Recognise the value of the investment in existing significant
infrastructure'.
z RPS Natural resources B6.1 Air
Amend the fourth paragraph under the heading 'Introduction' to recognise that emissions
management can include an integrated approach (where different sources are jointly
managed). Refer to the full submission for suggested wording changes [pages 16-17/36].
Amend policy 2(b) to read: 'establishing caps for the total control, by way of consent
conditions, discharges of fine particles... '
z RPS Natural resources B6.1 Air Delete policy 2(c)(i): 'the activity will not exceed the cap established under (b) above'
Amend policy 5(a) to read: 'allow for reduced air quality amenity in industrial areas and the
coastal marine area when adjoining a heavy industry zone.'
z Infrastructure
C1.1 Infrastructure
policies Retain 1.1 'Infrastructure' [subject to amendments].
z Infrastructure
C1.1 Infrastructure
policies Add a new objective 2: 'The value of investment in infrastructure is recognised'.
z Infrastructure
C1.1 Infrastructure
policies
Amend policy 1 (relating to the benefits of infrastructure) to include a new clause (h): 'enabling
the continued operation of other interdependent infrastructure'.
z Infrastructure
C1.1 Infrastructure
policies
Amend policy 7 (relating to undergrounding of infrastructure in urban areas) to read: '...urban
areas (except in Industrial zones) unless there are significant technical and/or economic
reasons not to do so.'
z Air Quality
and policies Retain 5.1 'Air quality' [subject to amendments].
67/1145
Sub#/
z Air Quality
and policies
Amend policy 4 (relating to air quality amenity) to include a reference to 'remedying or
mitigating', consistent with the RMA. Refer to the full submission for suggested wording
changes [page 22/36].
z Air Quality
and policies
Amend policy 6 to include reference to whatever zoning is applied to the Otahuhu Power
Station site [currently Light Industry zone, though the submitter is seeking this be changed to
Heavy Industry].
z Air Quality
and policies
Amend policy 6 (relating to air quality amenity) to recognise that visual emissions of water
vapour within the Heavy Industry zone may be appropriate. Refer to the full submission for
suggested wording changes [page 22/36].
z Air Quality
and policies
Amend policy 12 (managing air quality from individual discharge sources) to include a
reference to 'remedying or mitigating', consistent with the RMA. Refer to the full submission
for suggested wording changes [page 22/36]
z Air Quality
and policies
Amend policy 13 (managing air quality from individual discharge sources) to include a
reference to 'remedying or mitigating', consistent with the RMA. Refer to the full submission
for suggested wording changes [page 22/36]
z Air Quality
and policies
Delete policy 15(b) (managing air quality from individual discharge sources): 'demonstrate for
activities that require discretionary air discharge consent that any adverse effects on aircraft
stability and/or safety are avoided '.
z Air Quality
and policies
Amend policy 15(b) (managing air quality from individual discharge sources), to achieve a
reasonable balance between the rights of the emitter and the user of airspace [in relation to
aircraft stability]. Refer to the full submission for suggested wording [page 23/36]
z Air Quality
and policies
Retain policy 17: 'Assess the effects of air discharges from a premise or site, including all
activities that require discharge consents, together to generally grant a single air discharge
consent per premise or site.'
z Air Quality
and policies
Delete policy 18(a): 'Require applications for activities requiring resource consent for air
discharges to: (a) have combined concentrations arising from the air discharge activity and
background levels below the AAAQS in Table 1 (b)... '
z Air Quality
and policies
Amend Table 1 'Auckland Ambient Air Quality Standards (AAAQS)' to explain that table 1
applies within a defined airshed and refer to plans showing the extent of each airshed.
z Air Quality
and policies
Delete policy 21(g), which requires an offset in relation to levels of discharge of PM
10
for
activities that require an air discharge permit.
z Air Quality
and policies
Amend the objectives and policies (particularly policies 17-21) to specify that any resource
consent application for discharges to air should be assessed within the context of the relevant
airshed and identify the contribution to the levels of contaminants in the air within that airshed.

z Natural Hazards and Flooding Natural Hazards
and policies
Amend policy 16 (which relates to new infrastructure in the 1 per cent AEP coastal inundation
plus 2m sea level rise area), to recognise that significant infrastructure (in particular electricity
generation) often needs to be located in or near the coastal environment. Refer to the full
submission for suggested wording [page 24/36].
z Water
C5.15.2 Water quantity,
allocation & use - obs & pols
Objectives
Amend the first paragraph under the heading 'Background' to address the allocation of water
and prioritisation of water uses, particularly in times of constraint. Refer to the full submission
for suggested wording [pages 24-25/36].
z
Centre)
desc, obs & pols Retain 3.11 'Heavy Industry zone' [subject to amendments].
z
Centre)
desc, obs & pols
Amend the first sentence of the 'Zone description', to read: 'This zone provides for industrial
activities (which, in the case of this zone, includes electricity generation facilities) that may
produce... '
z
Centre)
desc, obs & pols
Amend policy 6 (relating to control of building location, height and bulk) to be consistent with
the RMA, which anticipates that 'adverse effects' on the environment will be 'avoided,
remedied or mitigated'. Refer to the full submission for suggested wording [page 26/36].
z Mana Whenua General provisions
assessment
Retain 2.7.4(1), which requires a cultural impact assessment for applications requiring
resource consent under the 'Sites and Places of Significance to Mana Whenua' overlay and
the 'Sites and Places of Value to Mana Whenua' overlay. [G2.7.4 Cultural impact
assessment].
assessment
Delete 2.7.4(2),(3) and (4), relating to when a cultural impact assessment will be
required. [G2.7.4 Cultural impact assessment].
assessment
Delete (5) under the heading 'Information requirements' (a cultural impact assessment should
be prepared by an iwi or person or entity nominated by the iwi). [G2.7.4 Cultural impact
assessment].
assessment
Amend (10) under 'Information requirements' (relating to requests for additional information)
to read: 'Where Mana Whenua values may be adversely affected within an overlay relating to
Sites and Places of Value or Significance to Mana Whenua and a cultural impact
assessment... ' [G2.7.4 Cultural impact assessment].
68/1145
Sub#/
z Infrastructure
Energy
H1.1.1 Introduction to activity
tables
Retain the approach where network utilities and energy related activities are dealt with in a
single 'Auckland-wide' section (H1.1).
z Infrastructure
Energy
generating facilities
Retain the permitted activity status of various activities, particularly 'The operation, repair and
maintenance of network utilities and electricity generation facilities in existence [as at the date
of public notification of the Unitary Plan]'.
z Infrastructure
Energy
Retain discretionary activity status for 'Other electricity generating facilities' in Industrial
zones.
z Infrastructure
Energy
Amend the activity description 'Other electricity generating facilities' (under Electricity
generation), to read: 'Other electricity generating facilities including all associated and
ancillary land use activities'.
z Infrastructure
Energy H1.1.3 Development controls
Retain the permitted activity development controls in 3.1.2 'Operation, repair, maintenance
and development of network utilities and electricity generation facilities in zones', particularly
the exclusions in relation to the building area and height of structures in Industrial zones.
z
(ITA) Hazardous substances H4.6.1 Activity table
Amend to increase the threshold for the storage and use of hazardous substances as a
permitted activity in the Heavy Industry zone (provide a higher threshold than in the Light
Industry zone).
z
(ITA)
(ITA) H4.8.1 Activity table Delete 4.8 'Industrial and trade activities (ITA)' in its entirety.
Amend 'Community-scale energy generation' to read: 'Community-scale energy electricity
generation'.
z Definitions Existing Amend 'Industrial activities' to add "Includes electricity generation facilities".
z Definitions
Abbreviation and Acronyms
Amend the nesting table for 'Industry' to include 'Electricity generation facilities' (in the second
column).
Amend 'Industrial zones' to replace 'Includes:' with 'Means:' and include any Special Purpose
zone relating to the Otahuhu Power Station site. Refer to the full submission for suggested
Amend 'Minor infrastructure upgrading' to be consistent with the terminology that applies to
the infrastructure and network utility provisions of the PAUP and to include the installation,
improvement, repair or replacement of electricity generating activities. Refer to the full
submission for suggested wording [page 32-33/36].
6085-1 Bobbie McKay bobbiemckay@gmail.com
control
and policies Retain overlay, ensure pre-1944 housing is protected.
6085-2 Bobbie McKay bobbiemckay@gmail.com Zoning Central Rezone Point Chevalier from Mixed Housing to Single House.
6085-3 Bobbie McKay bobbiemckay@gmail.com RPS Urban growth
environment Enhance controls on architectural quality.
6085-4 Bobbie McKay bobbiemckay@gmail.com RPS Urban growth
quality compact urban form Seeks co-operation with transport and education authorities to plan for intensification.
6086-1 NBL Capstone Limited steve@taxshop.co.nz Precincts - North New Precincts Wairau Valley
Add new precinct for Wairau Valley incorporating provisions from the North Shore City
Council Strategic Plan for Wairau Valley.
6087-1
Fonterra Co-operative Group
Limited ablomfield@bentley.co.nz RPS Issues
wellbeing Retain.
6087-2
Limited ablomfield@bentley.co.nz RPS
Transport
B3.1 Commercial and
industrial growth Retain 3.1.
6087-3
Limited ablomfield@bentley.co.nz RPS
Transport B3.3 Transport Retain section.
6087-4
our natural resources Retain.
6087-5
our coastal environment Retain.
6087-6
our rural environment Retain.
6087-7
Limited ablomfield@bentley.co.nz Air Quality
and policies Amend Objective 4 to replace 'avoid' with 'manage'.
6087-8
and policies Amend Policy 6 to replace 'Heavy Industrial' with 'industrial.
6087-9
and policies Retain objectives and policies.
69/1145
Sub#/
6087-10
Limited ablomfield@bentley.co.nz
(ITA)
(ITA)
6087-11
(ITA) Hazardous substances
6087-12
Limited ablomfield@bentley.co.nz General Noise and vibration
6087-13
Centre)
desc, obs & pols Amend Objective 4 to replace 'avoids' with 'manages'.
6087-14
Centre)
desc, obs & pols Amend Policy 5 to replace 'maintain' with 'have regard to'.
6087-15
Limited ablomfield@bentley.co.nz Air Quality H4.1 Auckland wide rules Waste processes
Retain Permitted activity status for 'Treatment of wastewater that was generated on site
excluding municipal wastewater'.
6087-16
Limited ablomfield@bentley.co.nz Natural Hazards and Flooding Flooding H4.12 Rules
Amend activity status for 'Less vulnerable activities including all associated buildings' from
Discretionary to Restricted Discretionary.
6087-17
Amend activity in activity table to read 'Storage of material in any zone, including the storage
of hazardous substances where the amount of hazardous substances would be permitted by
the hazardous rules apply to the residential zones. '
6087-18
Delete the activity 'Storage of hazardous substances in any zone where the amount would not
be permitted by the hazardous substances rules applying to the residential zones.'
6087-19
(ITA)
(ITA) H4.8.1 Activity table
Amend activity table to read 'Existing or new high risk ITA sites where industrial or trade
activity areas have appropriate stormwater treatment ' and 'Use of land and associated
discharge for an existing [on the date of notification of this Unitary Plan] or new high-risk ITA
where the activity meets permitted activity controls and industrial or trade activity areas have
appropriate stormwater treatment ' from Restricted Discretionary activities, to Controlled
activities. Consequentially insert assessment criteria consistent with those from the Operative
Plan.
6087-20
Rural Discharges,
Biosolids
Discharges
Amend activity table to read 'Discharge of treated dairy effluent to water' as a Discretionary
activity.
6087-21
Rural Discharges,
Biosolids
Discharges
Retain Permitted activity status for 'The emergency discharge of milk onto or into land but not
directly into water'.
6087-22
Rural Discharges,
Biosolids
Discharges
Add the following text to 2.1.1.3 and 2.1.2.5 'Note: The discharge and application rates for
nitrogen are exclusive of animal urine not captured from a confined area.'
6087-23
Rural Discharges,
Biosolids
Discharges
Amend 2.1.2.1 to read' All new feedpads and permanent standoff pads must be sealed and
the permeability of the sealing layer must not exceed 1x10
-9
m/2. The permeability must be
certified by a chartered professional engineer holding a current practicing certificate and
provided to the council on request.
6087-24
Rural Discharges,
Biosolids
Discharges
Amend 2.1.2.2 to read' Effluent storage systems must be used and must comply with the
following: a. the volume of all systems constructed or modified after the notification date of the
Unitary Plan will be determined using the Dairy Effluent Storage Calculator for the Auckland
Region 2012 b. all new and modified effluent storage systems must be sealed and the
permeability of the sealing layer must not exceed 1x10-9m/s. The permeability must be
certified by a chartered professional engineer holding a current practicing certificate c.
confirmation of the storage system volume and certification of the permeability of the sealing
layer must be submitted to the council within 30 days of completion of the system. Note:
'Modified' means an increase in storage system capacity and excludes changes to a systems
supporting infrastructure including pumps, screens, stone traps, aerators, and inlet or outlet
pipes. Effluent storage system can include ponds and tanks and associated sump storage.
However, sump storage is not adequate to be considered an effluent storage system in the
Unitary Plan.
6087-25
Rural Discharges,
Biosolids
Discharges Delete 2.1.2.5.
6087-26
Rural Discharges,
Biosolids
Discharges
Amend to add the following note to 2.1.1 'Note: A nutrient budget, using the OVERSEER
model, should be utilised in respect of 3(a), (b) and (c).
6087-27
Limited ablomfield@bentley.co.nz Zoning Central Rezone 113 and 113A Carbine Road, Mt Wellington from Light Industry to Heavy Industry.
70/1145
Sub#/
6088-1 Healthy Life Media Limited dave.smith@hlmedia.co.nz Zoning North and Islands
Rezone Barrys Point Road, Des Swann Drive and Fred Thomas Drive, Takapuna from Light
Industry to a zone that is the same as Business 9 in the Operative North Shore District Plan.
6089-1 Allied Fastings Limited phil@alliedfastenings.co.nz Zoning North and Islands Rezone Wairau Valley from Light Industry to General Business.
6090-1 Megan L Grimshaw-Jones grimshawjonesmegan@gmail.com Subdivision Auckland-wide - Urban zones H5.2 3.1 Residential zones
Retain current (operative Auckland Council District Plan: North Shore section) subdivision
density controls for Montgomery Avenue, Belmont.
6091-1 Lionel A Don lionel.don@vodafone.co.nz General Chapter A Introduction A1 Background Retain Mayors foreword.
6091-2 Lionel A Don lionel.don@vodafone.co.nz Zoning North and Islands Rezone area identified on map in Wellsford [refer submission page 3/5] Future Urban.
6091-3 Lionel A Don lionel.don@vodafone.co.nz Zoning North and Islands Rezone area identified on map in Wellsford [refer submission page 3/5] Countryside Living.
6091-4 Lionel A Don lionel.don@vodafone.co.nz Zoning North and Islands Rezone area identified on map in Wellsford [refer submission page 3/5] Large Lot.
6091-5 Lionel A Don lionel.don@vodafone.co.nz Zoning North and Islands Rezone area identified on map in Wellsford [refer submission page 4/5] Local Centre.
6091-6 Lionel A Don lionel.don@vodafone.co.nz Zoning North and Islands Rezone area identified on map in Te Hana [refer submission page 5/5] Industrial.
6091-7 Lionel A Don lionel.don@vodafone.co.nz Zoning North and Islands Rezone area identified on map in Te Hana [refer submission page 5/5] Rural Settlement.
6091-8 Lionel A Don lionel.don@vodafone.co.nz Zoning North and Islands Rezone area identified on map in Te Hana [refer submission page 5/5] Local Centre.
6092-1
Waikato-Tainui Te
Kauhanganui Incorporated john.carter@boffamiskell.co.nz RPS Mana Whenua
participation
Seeks integration and 'a direct link' with the PAUP to the management plans and strategies of
Waikato-Tainui being: 'Waikato-Tainui Te Kauganui Incorporated - Waikato-Tainui
Environmental Plan' and 'Whakatupuranga Waikato-Tainui 2050' [documents not included, no
specific relief sought].
6092-2
Waikato-Tainui Te
B5.3 Mori economic, social
and cultural development
Carry through into the PAUP the long term vision for Mana Whenua and Mataawaha
described in the Auckland Plan. [Refer pages 7-8/22 for details].
6092-3
Waikato-Tainui Te
Kauhanganui Incorporated john.carter@boffamiskell.co.nz General Miscellaneous Other
Adopt the relief of sought in the submission by Ngti Tamaoho, Te kitai, Ngai ki Tai Tamaki,
Nga Te Ata, Te Kawerau--Maki and Te Ahiwaru.
6092-4
Waikato-Tainui Te
Kauhanganui Incorporated john.carter@boffamiskell.co.nz General Chapter A Introduction A1 Background
Retain the identification of iwi authorities, particulary Waikato-Tainui, in paragraph 4 [1.2
'Mana Whenua'].
6092-5
Waikato-Tainui Te
Amend introductory section to reference the unique status of Mataawaka within the region [1.2
'Mana Whenua'].
6092-6
Waikato-Tainui Te
Kauhanganui Incorporated john.carter@boffamiskell.co.nz General Chapter A Introduction A1 Background Retain text in 1.2 'Mana Whenua' which refers to the Treaty Settlement process.
6092-7
Waikato-Tainui Te
Kauhanganui Incorporated john.carter@boffamiskell.co.nz RPS Issues
Retain issue statement and explanatory text which recognises that development of Treaty
Settlement Land needs to be enabled.
6092-8
Waikato-Tainui Te
Retain explanatory text which acknowledges that coastal land may have been returned via a
Treaty settlement.
6092-9
Waikato-Tainui Te
our rural environment
Retain issue statement that acknowledges that the rural environment is of value to Mana
Whenua and rural land owned by Mana Whenua is important locations for Papakinga, marae
and related activities, and the land may have been returned via a Treaty Settlement.
6092-10
Waikato-Tainui Te
participation Retain objectives and policies, particularly Objective 4 and Policies 5, 7, 8 and 9.
6092-11
Waikato-Tainui Te
Kauhanganui Incorporated john.carter@boffamiskell.co.nz Mana Whenua
settlement land
6092-12
Waikato-Tainui Te
settlement land
rules/App. 4.3 legislation Retain rules.
6092-13
Waikato-Tainui Te
Kauhanganui Incorporated john.carter@boffamiskell.co.nz General Chapter A Introduction A2 Statutory Framework
Amend A2.2 'Statutory Framework' to include specific reference to the Treaty settlement
process.
6092-14
Waikato-Tainui Te
Amend to explain better how [right of first refusal] land and 'statutory acknowledgement' areas
will be provided for.
6092-15
Waikato-Tainui Te
growth
Amend issue statement to acknowlege that Treaty settlement land for commercial and cultural
redress is located in urban areas, as well as rural and coastal areas.
6092-16
Waikato-Tainui Te
participation
Amend to recognise and provide for 'RFR' [right of first refusal] land and
statutory acknowledgement areas.
6092-17
Waikato-Tainui Te
Kauhanganui Incorporated john.carter@boffamiskell.co.nz General
GIS viewer
Amend PAUP to correctly identify land returned as commercial redress, currently identified as
cultural redress land.
6092-18
Waikato-Tainui Te
Kauhanganui Incorporated john.carter@boffamiskell.co.nz Zoning South
Rezone land in rural areas returned under the 1995 Raupatu settlement as commercial
redress to Mori Purpose zone.
6092-19
Waikato-Tainui Te
GIS viewer
Amend plan to identify that Waikato Tainui have a 'right of first refusal' over crown land within
the 1995 Raupatu Settlement area.
6092-20
Waikato-Tainui Te
settlement land
Retain inclusion of Treaty Settlement legislation in Appendix 4.3. Add Waikato Tainui
settlement legislation including the Waikato Claims Settlement Act 1995 and the Waikato-
Tainui Raupatu Clams (Waikao River) Settlements Act 2010.
6092-21
Waikato-Tainui Te
Kauhanganui Incorporated john.carter@boffamiskell.co.nz Mana Whenua General provisions
assessment
Retain the information requirement to address hap or iwi planning documents in the
preparation of a cultural impact assessment.
71/1145
Sub#/
6092-22
Waikato-Tainui Te
Retain the way in which kaitiakianga has been provided for in the PAUP. Amend issue
statement and explanation to include specific reference to the kaitiaki role of Mana Whenua.
6092-23
Waikato-Tainui Te
Kauhanganui Incorporated john.carter@boffamiskell.co.nz Mana Whenua General provisions
assessment
Amend to require resource consents with respect to sites of significance within the tribal
takiwa to be assessed against the Waikato Tainui Environmental Plan 2013.
6092-24
Waikato-Tainui Te
Retain recognition in section 1.6 [Our Economy] of the role that Mana Whenua will contribute
to Auckland's economic growth.
6092-25
Waikato-Tainui Te
Amend section 1.2 [Mana Whenua] to provide better recognition of the role Mana Whenua in
contributing to economic development (both for iwi and Auckland).
6092-26
Waikato-Tainui Te
wellbeing
Amend section to provide better recognition of the role Mana Whenua contributing to
economic development (both for iwi and Auckland).
6092-27
Waikato-Tainui Te
Kauhanganui Incorporated john.carter@boffamiskell.co.nz Mana Whenua Mori purpose zone
controls Retain provisions in the PAUP but seek to enable the use and development of Mori land.
6092-28
Waikato-Tainui Te
Kauhanganui Incorporated john.carter@boffamiskell.co.nz Definitions Existing
Amend glossary term 'Papakinga' so that it is not limited exclusively to Mana Whenua with
whakapapa connections to the land where the Papakinga will be established.
6092-29
Waikato-Tainui Te
significance to Mana Whenua Retain recognition the way in which Papakinga have been provided for.
6092-30
Waikato-Tainui Te
Kauhanganui Incorporated john.carter@boffamiskell.co.nz Mana Whenua Mori purpose zone
controls Retain recognition the way in which Papakinga have been identified in the zone description.
6092-31
Waikato-Tainui Te
Retain Policy 2 which recognises that Papakinga supports Mori economic, social and
cultural development.
6092-32
Waikato-Tainui Te
Kauhanganui Incorporated john.carter@boffamiskell.co.nz RPS Urban growth
B2.5 Rural and coastal towns
and villages
Retain policies which recognise the need to provide for Papakinga in the expansion of
existing rural and coastal towns and settlements.
6092-33
Waikato-Tainui Te
settlement land
and policies Retain policies which 'provide for a range of activities.'
6092-34
Waikato-Tainui Te
Kauhanganui Incorporated john.carter@boffamiskell.co.nz Mana Whenua Auckland wide - Mori Land
and policies Retain policies which 'provide for a range of activities.'
6092-35
Waikato-Tainui Te
Kauhanganui Incorporated john.carter@boffamiskell.co.nz Definitions Existing Amend the determination of Integrated Mori development' so it includes informal recreation.
6092-36
Waikato-Tainui Te
Kauhanganui Incorporated john.carter@boffamiskell.co.nz Mana Whenua Auckland wide - Mori Land
controls
Amend the activity status of 'informal recreation' from a Discretionary activity to a Restricted
Discretionary activity.
6092-37
Waikato-Tainui Te
settlement land
Amend to provide for 'informal recreation' as a restricted discretionary activity rather than as a
discretionary activity.
6092-38
Waikato-Tainui Te
Kauhanganui Incorporated john.carter@boffamiskell.co.nz General Cross plan matters
Amend so that Papakinga is recognised explicitly and provided for as a region-wide activity
rather than relying on rules in various zones.
6092-39
Waikato-Tainui Te
Kauhanganui Incorporated john.carter@boffamiskell.co.nz Definitions Existing
Amend definition of 'marae complex': 'Facilities used for the provision of a focal point
for environmental, social, cultural, and economic activity for Mori and the wider community.'
6092-40
Waikato-Tainui Te
Kauhanganui Incorporated john.carter@boffamiskell.co.nz General Cross plan matters Retain the inclusion of references to the Waikato River.
6092-41
Waikato-Tainui Te
Amend to improve recognition of Mana Whenua relationships with natural resources, in
particular, specific natural resources which have been given recognition through Treaty
settlement legislation, like the Waikato River.
6092-42
Waikato-Tainui Te
Kauhanganui Incorporated john.carter@boffamiskell.co.nz RPS Natural resources
B6.3 Freshwater and
Geothermal Water
Amend to improve recognition of Mana Whenua relationships with natural resources, in
particular, specific natural resources which have been given recognition through Treaty
settlement legislation, like the Waikato River.
6092-43
Waikato-Tainui Te
Kauhanganui Incorporated john.carter@boffamiskell.co.nz Water Aquifers/Groundwater
Amend Objective 2 as follows: '...the Waikato-Tainui Claims (Waikato River) Settlement Act
2010 is recognised in the management of aquifers in the lower catchment of the Waikato
River in Auckland.'
6092-44
Waikato-Tainui Te
Kauhanganui Incorporated john.carter@boffamiskell.co.nz Water
streams & wetland
Overlay E7.3 High-use Stream
Management Area
Amend Objective 2 as follows: '...the Waikato-Tainui Raupatu Claims (Waikato River)
Settlement Act 2010 is recognised in the management of steams in the lower catchment of
the Waikato River in Auckland.'
6092-45
Waikato-Tainui Te
GIS viewer Identify Puketutu Island as Mori land.
6092-46
Waikato-Tainui Te
Kauhanganui Incorporated john.carter@boffamiskell.co.nz Zoning South Rezone land at 45-49 Cronin Road, Pukekohe from Rural Production to Mori Purpose.
6093-1 Vanessa P King vanessa_palmiro@hotmail.com Special Character
& C
Isthmus
Add Moa, Huia, Kiwi, Walmer, Riro, Target, Montrose, Alberta, Miller, Smale and Formby
Roads, Point Chevalier to the overlay.
6093-2 Vanessa P King vanessa_palmiro@hotmail.com Zoning Central Reduce the density of Point Chevalier.
72/1145
Sub#/
6093-3 Vanessa P King vanessa_palmiro@hotmail.com RPS Urban growth
Improve schools, roading, town centre and shopping infrastructure prior to intensification of
Point Chevalier.
6093-4 Vanessa P King vanessa_palmiro@hotmail.com Zoning Central
Rezone Huia, Kiwi, Tui, Moa, Walmer, and Riro Roads, Point Chevalier from Terrace Housing
and Apartment Building zone to a more suitable zone.
6093-5 Vanessa P King vanessa_palmiro@hotmail.com Zoning Central Rezone Point Chevalier from Mixed Housing to Single House.
6093-6 Vanessa P King vanessa_palmiro@hotmail.com Zoning Central
Amend extent of Mixed Housing zone in Point Chevalier to not extend further than 500m from
the Town Centre.
6093-7 Vanessa P King vanessa_palmiro@hotmail.com RPS Urban growth
quality compact urban form Expand city boundaries in conjunction with limited intensification.
6094-1 Ngi Tai ki Tmaki Tribal Trust
dave.beamish@ngaitai-ki-
tamaki.co.nz General Miscellaneous Consultation and engagement Support the use of pre-hearing mediation.
tamaki.co.nz RPS General
B13 RPS - Monitoring and
review procedures
Ensure appropriate provision is made with relevant council policies, strategies and budgets for
the implementation, monitoring and evaluation of the PAUP.
tamaki.co.nz General Cross plan matters
Ensure there is integration both vertically and horizontally in the PAUP in relation to the
provisions for Mori. Recognise that assessment criteria and matters for control must exist to
support restricted discretionary and controlled activities.
Add provisions to address adverse effects from adjoining activities can impact on sites and
places with cultural and customary value, Mori and Treaty Settlement land and the Mori
Purpose zones.
tamaki.co.nz RPS Urban growth
Ensure Mana Whenua Iwi are involved with processes which determine the extent and
location of the RUB.
tamaki.co.nz General
GIS viewer
Add non-statutory maps which recognise ancestral rohe of iwi. Develop these maps with
Mana Whenua input.
tamaki.co.nz General Chapter A Introduction A1 Background Retain section 1.2, Mana Whenua.
tamaki.co.nz General Chapter A Introduction A2 Statutory Framework
Amend section 2.2 to recognise the Treaty settlement process which informs the significance
and relationship between Mana Whenua and the natural and physical resources.
tamaki.co.nz General Chapter A Introduction A3 Strategic Framework
Amend the 'Mori Responsiveness Framework' to identify how it is integrated and given effect
to throughout the PAUP.
tamaki.co.nz RPS Issues
B1 Introduction - Issues of
Regional significance
Replace RPS issues which are written as 'outcome statements' to clearly identify the
resource management issue.
growth
Amend to read: 'This means we must manage our growth in a way that: ... Enhances
maintains Mori communities, culture and values.'
wellbeing
Amend the issue statement to recognise the positive value Mori economic development
contributes to Auckland's prosperity.
heritage
Amend issue statement to recognise that 'enabling Mana Whenua participation and decision-
making' is a general concern for the RPS, not just for indigenous biodiversity.
Delete the [heading] 'Explanation' to make it clear that the issue encompasses the
'explanation section' as well.
Amend the section heading to: 'Recognition of the Treaty and enabling the outcomes of
Treaty settlements.'
Add specific reference in the issue statement and explanation to the kaitiaki role of Mana
Whenua.
Amend the Explanation [last sentence of fifth paragraph] to: 'In some cases, rural land has
been returned through Treaty settlement as cultural or commercial redress to be used to re-
establish an economic base and platform for future development'.
Amend the Explanation [last sentence of sixth paragraph] to: 'In some cases, rural land has
establish an economic base and platform for future development'.
change Retain as a regionally significant issue.
tamaki.co.nz RPS Mana Whenua
participation Retain section.
participation
Amend Policy 9 to: 'Enable Mana Whenua to access, manage and develop use cultural
redress lands and interests for cultural activities .'
review procedures
Identify joint management agreements and the transfer of powers as key monitoring
indicators.
B5.2 Mana Whenua values
Mtauranga & tikanga Retain section.
73/1145
Sub#/
Mtauranga & tikanga Add specific objectives, polices and methods enabling customary use and cultural activities.
and cultural development Retain section.
and cultural development Add policies and methods identifying how Objective 2 will be achieved.
Add provisions in the natural resource, natural heritage and historic heritage overlays to
provide for the occupation development and use of Mori land and Treaty settlement land, as
permitted, controlled and restricted discretionary activities. Activities with significant adverse
effects to be assessed as discretionary activities using the Integrated Mori development tool.
Fig. 1 Retain section, including Objective 3 and Policies 5-6 and 12.
tamaki.co.nz RPS Natural resources
B6.3 Freshwater and
Geothermal Water Retain Section, including Policy 8 'use of geothermal water for tikanga purposes.'
tamaki.co.nz RPS Coastal
environment
Add a new objective which enables the subdivision, use and development of Mori land and
Treaty settlement land in the coastal environment.
environment
Retain reference to Mana Whenua provisions and providing for cultural and traditional use in
Policy 1 and 4.
B7.2 Public access & open
space - coastal environment Add specific objectives, policies and methods enabling customary use and cultural activities.
B7.3 Areas of degraded water
quality
Retain Objective 3 and Policy 2(c), and include planning maps or other mechanisms to
identify key areas to support the objective and policy.
B7.4 Managing the Hauraki
Gulf Retain Policies 10-12.
Retain the environmental results anticipated. Add additional environmental results anticipated
to cover the range of matters addressed in the plan that impact on Mori.
review procedures
Amend to state how and what will be monitored or state that a monitoring strategy will be
developed within a specified time frame. Clearly identify monitoring indicators for the Mori
provisions and these to be developed with the input of Mana Whenua.
tamaki.co.nz Mana Whenua Auckland wide - Mori Land
and policies
Retain provisions subject to relief sought in this submission and clarify that the map layer will
be updated as new Mori land sites are identified.
and policies
Amend definition of 'Mori Land' to refer to 'Parts 12 and 13 of Te Ture Whenua Mori Act
1993' and delete the reference to section 12 and 13.
and policies
Amend Policies 3 and 7 to: require an Integrated Mori Development Plan for discretionary
activities only; and include provision for controlled rules with consideration of natural heritage
as a matter of control.
and policies
Add a new objective and policy which: Provides for the development of Mori land while
considering the effects on natural resources [including SEAs]; Includes provision for a range
of associated activities with consideration of natural resource values as a matter of control;
Include provision for discretionary activities on Mori land within natural resource overlays
through Integrated Mori Development Plans. Make amendments to the rule framework to
give effect to this approach in the rules section.
and policies
Amend Policy 6: Enable Consider alternative approaches to site access and infrastructure
provisions in rural or coastal areas where the occupation, use and development of Mori land
is constrained by access or the availability of infrastructure.
and policies
Amend Objective 3: 'Mana Whenua can access, manage and develop use land acquired as
cultural redress to support cultural activities .'
and policies
activities only; and to include provision for controlled rules with consideration of natural
heritage values as part of the matters of control. Make amendments to the rule framework to
give effect to this approach.
tamaki.co.nz General Cross plan matters Retain provisions in Sections 3-7 where they are specifically related to Mori.
tamaki.co.nz Public Open Space Zones Public Open Space D2 Introduction
Retain policies which support and re-establish the relationship of Mana Whenua to their
ancestral lands, water, sites, waahi tapu and other taonga.
tamaki.co.nz Mana Whenua Mori purpose zone
controls Retain provisions and include new sites, particularly where supported by Mori.
tamaki.co.nz Historic Heritage (Overlay)
Heritage
Add policies which recognise Mana Whenua values when assessing developments
associated with scheduled places.
74/1145
Sub#/
tamaki.co.nz Mana Whenua
Whenua
objectives and policies Retain the objectives and policies.
Whenua
and policies Retain the Objectives and Policies.
tamaki.co.nz Precincts - Central New Precincts Other New Precincts
Add new Mana Whenua Management areas for marae and Papakinga areas and areas of
customary importance throughout the region where supported by Mana Whenua [inferred as
new precinct rather than extension of existing precinct].
tamaki.co.nz Precincts Ak-Wide and Coastal Regional Parks
Objectives and Policies
Add a new objective and policy supporting use of regional parks for Mori customary use
and/or cultural activities.
tamaki.co.nz Precincts Ak-Wide and Coastal New Precincts All other New Precincts
Add precinct provisions for all areas identified within the Mori Purpose zone, particularly
where supported by Mori.
tamaki.co.nz Definitions Existing
Amend definition of 'Mana Whenua' so that it appears in either Mori terms or definitions, not
both. See page 20/20 of submission.
tamaki.co.nz Mana Whenua General provisions
discovery protocol
Retain requirements for accidental discovery protocols subject to the relief sought in the
submission.
discovery protocol
Amend Rule 2.5(2)(i) to; "Work at the site ... NZ Historic Places Trust. In doing this, council
must provide for the impacts of the activity on Mana Whenua values, and any recommended
measures from Mana Whenua proposed to avoid any adverse effects on sites and places of
significance to Mana Whenua.'
discovery protocol
Amend Rule 2.5(4) to clarify when a resource consent will be required as a discretionary
activity.
tamaki.co.nz General Chapter G General provisions
statements
Amend Rule 2.7.2.1.3(e) to: 'places of cultural importance, including churches, marae, and
sites and places of significance and value to Mana Whenua.'
assessment
Retain Rule 2.7.4.1 'Cultural impact assessment' requirements for sites and places of
significance and value to Mana Whenua.
tamaki.co.nz General Miscellaneous Other Add new sites and places as supported by Mana Whenua.
assessment
Retain Rule 2.7.4.4 subject to any outcomes of a collaborative approach between Mana
Whenua, council and key stakeholders to refine the process.
assessment
Add clarification that only Mana Whenua can determine if a Cultural Impact Assessment is
required or not.
and policies Retain section.
controls Amend the preamble to refer to the definition of Mori Land.
controls Add a range of permitted and controlled commercial activities.
controls Delete the permitted rule threshold that restricts development to a maximum of 10 dwellings.
controls
Delete Development Control 3.1(b) and (c) 'Building height' and clarify activity status when the
permitted status is not met. Amend to a restricted discretionary activity if presently
discretionary.
H2.1.4-5 Assessment & H2.1.6
Spec. info. req.
Amend section to correct errors where the text refers to Treaty settlement land instead of
Mori Land, including Rule 2.1.5: 'Rural industries on Mori Land, activities associated with a
marae complex on Mori Treaty settlement Land ...'
controls
Amend section to correct errors where the text refers to Mori Land instead of Treaty
settlement land.
Spec. info. req.
Amend assessment criteria 5.2(1)(f) to recognise that there may be no alternative sites and/or
locations for development on Mori and Treaty settlement land.
settlement land
settlement land
rules/App. 4.3 legislation Add a range of commercial activities as permitted and controlled activities.
settlement land
rules/App. 4.3 legislation Delete the permitted rule threshold that restricts development to a maximum of 10 dwellings.
settlement land
Amend the Activity Table to include a new rule framework for cultural and customary activities
on Treaty Settlement land.
75/1145
Sub#/
settlement land
discretionary.
settlement land
Amend 2.2.5: 'Rural industries on Treaty Settlement Mori Land, activities associated with a
marae complex on Mori Treaty Settlement Land ... and marae complex on Treaty Settlement
Mori Land greater than 700m2 GFA.'
Spec. info. req.
locations for development on Mori and Treaty Settlement Land.
tamaki.co.nz
SEAs
Vegetation management in
overlays (except SEAs)
Retain provisions for customary use in Activity Table 1.2 'Vegetation management in
overlays', subject to the relief sought in the submission.
tamaki.co.nz
SEAs
H4.3.2-4 Controls and
Assessment Retain Control 2.5 'Vegetation alteration or removal for customary use'.
tamaki.co.nz Water Wastewater H4.15 Onsite wastewater rules Retain Control 2.1.1(2) but clarify what is meant by 'must not be disturbed'.
tamaki.co.nz
organisms
modified organisms Retain section 4.19.
tamaki.co.nz Sustainable Development C7.7/H6.4 Sustainable design
Delete objectives, policies, methods and rules stating sustainable development will be
regulated through rating scheme controls and replace with a education and advocacy
programme that encourages the use of Homestar/Greenstar or similar rating system.
tamaki.co.nz Rural Zones General I13.2 Land use controls
Clarify that Rule 2.6 'Dwellings' does not apply to Mori land and Treaty settlement land in
coastal areas.
Whenua J5.1 Rules Retain provisions.
tamaki.co.nz
(ONF) Rules J6.1 Rules
Amend provisions to provide for development of Mori land and Treaty settlement land as
permitted activities.
tamaki.co.nz Precincts General Content Precincts General Content
Delete land use controls in relevant precincts which stipulates that: 'The applicant must
belong to the same hap as the trustees of the associated marae.' [List of relevant precincts
not provided].
tamaki.co.nz Precincts General Content Precincts General Content
Clarify intent of precinct rules which restrict dwellings on Mori Land: 'must be no more than 1
dwelling and not exceeding 10 dwellings at a density not exceeding 1 dwelling per 1ha ...'
Remove the 10 dwelling maximum for rural zones.
tamaki.co.nz General Chapter G General provisions
status
Clarify the rule relationship where Mori land is located within a precinct by stating the more
permissive threshold controls apply.
tamaki.co.nz Definitions New
Expand the Mori terms to include definitions for all Mori terms used in the PAUP, including
pou haki
tamaki.co.nz Definitions Existing
Amend definition of 'customary use' to apply to stones, soil, water, marine or freshwater life
and for uses to include building waka or whare and associated cultivation, farming or
aquaculture activities. Refer to submission, page 20/20.
6095-1 Ngaati Whanaunga
nkennedy@ngaatiwhanaunga.maori.
nz RPS General
review procedures
Ensure appropriate provision is made within relevant council policies, strategies and budgets
for the implementation, monitoring and evaluation of the PAUP.
nz General Editorial and Part 6
Ensure there is integration both horizontally and vertically in the PAUP in relation to the
provisions for Mori.
nz General Cross plan matters
Amend PAUP to include provisions that recognise adverse effects from activities on adjoining
sites can impact on cultural and customary uses, specifically the use and development of
Mori and treaty settlement land, Mori Purpose zones and sites and places with customary
values.
nz RPS Mana Whenua
Fig. 1
Add new policy requiring consideration be given to the difficulty of assessing
Mori cultural effects, and in particular cumulative effects, and guidance material be
developed for this purpose.
nz RPS Urban growth
quality compact urban form Ensure Mori are involved in processes which impact on the extent and location of the RUB.
nz General
GIS viewer
Amend the PAUP to include 'ancestral rohe' maps as non-statutory layer, and that these maps
are developed in conjunction with Mana Whenua.
nz RPS Mana Whenua
Mtauranga & tikanga
Add a new method identifying that ancestral rohe maps will be developed (in conjunction with
Mana Whenua) as a non-statutory map layer.
nz General Eplan
Amend PAUP to provide a consistent plan navigation tool such as an advance schematic
explaining the inter linkages across sections/chapter.
nz General Editorial and Part 6 Review the numbering system and amend to improve its usability.
76/1145
Sub#/
nz General Chapter A Introduction A1 Background Retain section 1.2 'Mana Whenua' and include a profile of mataawaka in Tmaki Makaurau.
nz RPS Mana Whenua
participation
Amend PAUP to reference the mechanisms for dealing with inter-iwi issues, for example by
recourse to the Mori Land Court.
nz RPS Mana Whenua
participation
Amend PAUP to state that the council will use the Mori Land Court for complex Mori issues
in the course of consent hearings.
nz General Chapter A Introduction A2 Statutory Framework
Amend section 2.2 'Treaty of Waitangi/Te Tiriti O Waitangi' to outline the need to consider
natural and physical resources which are part of the Treaty settlement process as an element
contributing to the significance of Mana Whenua with these resources.
nz General Chapter A Introduction A2 Statutory Framework
Amend PAUP to provide recognition that cultural and commercial activities are not
mutually exclusive. The zoning of land should reflect that iwi have commercial
aspirations associated with cultural redress lands.
nz Definitions Existing Amend definition of 'Treaty settlement land' to include Right of First Refusal land.
nz General Chapter A Introduction A3 Strategic Framework
Amend section 3.2 'Mori Responsiveness Framework' to identify how the framework is
integrated and given effect to through the PAUP.
nz General Chapter A Introduction
tools
Amend section 4.2 'Area based planning tools' so the Integrated Plan for Mori Development
identifies Crown Right of First Refusal lands currently identified in negotiations for future Mori
development.
nz RPS Issues
Amend the RPS issues to clearly identify the resource management issues so they do not
read as statements.
nz RPS Issues
growth
Amend issue statement to: "This means we must manage our growth in a way that:
....enhances maintains Mori communities, culture and values."
nz RPS Issues
wellbeing
Amend issue statement to recognise the positive value Mori economic development
contributes towards Auckland's prosperity.
nz RPS Issues
heritage
Add 'enabling Mana Whenua participation and decision-making' as a general concern for the
RPS issue as opposed to just indigenous biodiversity.
nz RPS Issues
Delete the word "Explanation " to make it clear that the issue encompasses the following
section as well.
nz RPS Issues
Amend the section heading to: "Recognition of the Treaty and enabling the outcomes of
Treaty settlements."
nz RPS Issues
Whenua.
nz RPS Issues
Amend the Explanation, last sentence of fifth paragraph, to: 'In some cases coastal land has
been returned through Treaty settlement as cultural or commercial redressto be used to re-
establish an economic base and platform for future development."
nz RPS Issues
Amend the Explanation, last sentence of sixth paragraph, to: "In some cases, rural land has
establish an economic base and platform for future development".
nz RPS Issues
nz RPS
Add new policy: "Council will support efforts by Mana Whenua to be registered as heritage
authorities in pursuit of using heritage orders or similar mechanisms for culturally significant
places."
nz RPS Mana Whenua
participation
Amend Policy 4 to: "Promote the transfer of powers and/or establishment of joint
management..."
nz RPS Mana Whenua
participation
Amend Policy 9 to: "Enable Mana Whenua to access, manage and develop use cultural
redress lands and interests for cultural activities ."
nz RPS General
review procedures
indicators.
nz RPS Mana Whenua
participation
Add a new objective, amend Policy 6 and add a new policy (refer to submission pg 10 and 13-
14/37 for specific wording) to address the environmental offsetting or compensation where
more than minor adverse cultural impacts arise. Add new rules to support this change (see
page 27/37 of the submission for suggested wording).
nz RPS Mana Whenua
nz RPS Mana Whenua
77/1145
Sub#/
nz RPS Mana Whenua
Add provisions in the natural resource, natural heritage and historic heritage overlays to give
effect to Policy 5 of section 5.3 'Mori economic, social and cultural development.' This would
provide for the occupation development and use of Mori land and Treaty settlement land,
refer to page 15/37 of the submission for details of activity statuses.
nz RPS Mana Whenua
Fig. 1 Retain Objective 3 and Policies 5-6 and 12.
nz RPS Mana Whenua
Fig. 1 Clarify the intent of Policies 10 and 13.
nz RPS Natural resources
B6.3 Freshwater and
Geothermal Water Retain Policy 5.
nz RPS Natural resources
B6.3 Freshwater and
nz RPS Coastal
environment
nz RPS Coastal
environment
Policy 1 and 4.
nz RPS Coastal
nz RPS Coastal
quality
nz RPS Coastal
nz RPS General
B11 RPS - Cross boundary
issues
Add to section 11 'Cross Boundary Issues' a new issue: "iwi rohe". Under "processes for
dealing with cross boundary issues" add "support for and engagement with regional iwi
forum."
nz RPS General
to cover the range of matters addressed in the plan that impact on Mori (including
mataawaka).
nz RPS General
Amend objectives to include Mori views, in particular incorporating mauri into water quality
related objectives and AERs.
nz RPS General
review procedures
Amend to state how and what will be monitored. Clearly identify monitoring indicators for the
Mori provisions and Mori culture (in addition to western scientific ones) and these to be
developed with the input of Mori.
nz Mana Whenua Auckland wide - Mori Land
and policies
and policies
Amend definition of 'Mori Land' to refer to Parts 12 and 13 of Te Ture Whenua Mori Act
1993 and delete the reference to section 12 and 13.
and policies
values as part of the matters of control. Make amendments to the rule framework to give
effect to this approach.
and policies
considering the effects on natural resources [including SEA's]; Includes provision for a range
and policies
nz Mana Whenua
settlement land
and policies
Amend Objective 3: "Mana Whenua can access, manage and develop use land acquired as
cultural redress to support cultural activities ."
nz Mana Whenua
settlement land
and policies
nz General Cross plan matters Retain provisions in Sections 3-7 where they are specifically related to Mori.
78/1145
Sub#/
nz Public Open Space Zones Public Open Space D2 Introduction
nz
the CMA
D5.1.14 Background,
Add a new objective to ensure that the process for creating and allocating space is clear and
transparent, especially where there are multiple and competing applications. Add a new policy
to ensure that no further allocations are granted until the process is clearly defined.
nz
the CMA
D5.1.14 Background,
Add a new objective and policy to ensure that Mana Whenua (including Ng ti Whanaunga) are
notified, consulted and part of the decision making process in respect to the creation and
allocation of aquaculture space and that environmental impacts to cultural values
(both tangible and intangible) are avoided, remedied or mitigated.
nz
the CMA
D5.1.14 Background,
Add a new policy to ensure that the allocation of new space attracts an obligation to contribute
to the costs of Mana Whenua (including Ng ti Whanaunga) in its ongoing kaitiaki role and
responsibilities, and that Mana Whenua (including Ng ti Whanaunga) are empowered
to participate in aquaculture opportunities.
nz
the CMA
D5.1.14 Background,
Add a new objective and policy that recognises Mori customary and Treaty rights to the
coastal marine area and that these be properly considered in the allocation of aquaculture
space and its ongoing management.
nz Mana Whenua Mori purpose zone
controls Retain provisions and include new sites, particularly where supported by Mori.
nz Historic Heritage (Overlay)
Heritage
nz
control
and policies Add objectives and policies which enable development of Treaty settlement land.
nz Mana Whenua
Whenua
Retain the objectives and policies, and add a new policy: "Council will
develop protocols and systems in partnership with Mana Whenua for the scheduling of iwi
sites information and its proper ongoing management".
nz Mana Whenua
Whenua
nz Precincts - Central New Precincts Other New Precincts
nz Precincts Ak-Wide and Coastal Regional Parks
nz Precincts Ak-Wide and Coastal New Precincts All other New Precincts
Add additional precincts over all areas identified within the Mori Purpose zone, particularly
nz Mana Whenua General provisions
discovery protocol
submission (page 25-26/37).
discovery protocol
Amend Rule 2.5(2)(i) to; "Work at the site ..... NZ Historic Places Trust. In doing this, council
significance to Mana Whenua."
discovery protocol
activity.
nz General Chapter G General provisions
statements
Amend Rule 2.7.2.1.3(e) to: "places of cultural importance, including churches, marae, and
sites and places of significance and value to Mana Whenua."
assessment
Retain Rule 2.7.4.1 'cultural impact assessment' requirements for sites and places of
significance and value to Mana Whenua. Include any new sites/places as supported by Mana
Whenua.
assessment
Whenua, council and key stakeholders to refine the process. Add clarification that the
discretion to determine if a CIA is required is to be made by Mana Whenau.
controls Amend the preamble to refer to the definition of Mori Land.
controls
Add a range of permitted and controlled commercial activities and remove the limitation on
Papakinga development by removing the restriction of up to 10 dwellings.
controls
discretionary.
79/1145
Sub#/
Spec. info. req.
Amend section to correct errors where the text refers to Treaty settlement and instead of
Mori Land, including Rule 2.1.5: "Rural industries on Mori Land, activities associated with a
marae complex on Mori Treaty settlement Land ..."
nz Mana Whenua
settlement land
Amend section to correct errors where the text refers to Mori land instead of Treaty
settlement land, including Rule 2.2.5 "Rural industries on Treaty Settlement Mori land ..."
Spec. info. req.
locations for the development.
nz Mana Whenua
settlement land
Add a range of permitted and controlled commercial activities and remove the limitation on
Papakinga development by removing the restriction of up to 10 dwellings.
nz Mana Whenua
settlement land
on Treaty Settlement Land.
nz Mana Whenua
settlement land
discretionary.
nz Mana Whenua
settlement land
Amend assessment criteria 2.2.5(2)(1)(f) to recognise that there may be no alternative sites
and/or locations for the development.
nz
SEAs
Retain provisions for customary use in Activity Table 1.2 subject to the relief sought in the
submission.
nz
SEAs
Assessment
Retain Control 2.5 'Vegetation alteration or removal for customary use' and identify activities
not complying to be restricted discretionary activities and include new assessment criteria to
this effect.
nz Water Wastewater H4.15 Onsite wastewater rules Retain Control 2.1.1(2) but clarify what is meant by "must not be disturbed".
nz
organisms
modified organisms Retain section 4.19.
nz Sustainable Development C7.7/H6.4 Sustainable design
nz Rural Zones General I13.2 Land use controls
coastal areas.
nz Mana Whenua
nz Mana Whenua
nz Mana Whenua
Whenua
Enable Mana Whenua to include site information and other cultural landscape knowledge
within overlays without the need for private plan changes.
nz
nz
Outstanding Natural
Rules
J6.2.1 Activity table & J6.1.2
Notification
nz Trees
Trees J6.4 Rules
nz
nz Precincts General Content Precincts General Content
not provided].
6095-
100 Ngaati Whanaunga
nz Precincts General Content Precincts General Content
6095-
nz General Chapter G General provisions
status
6095-
nz Definitions New Expand the Mori terms to include definitions for all Mori terms used in the PAUP.
6095-
nz Definitions Existing
Amend definition of 'customary use' to provide a wider view. Refer to submission, page
36/37.
80/1145
Sub#/
6095-
nz Definitions Existing
Amend definition of 'Mana Whenua' so that appears in either Mori terms or definitions, not
both.
6095-
nz Definitions New
Add a new definition for 'tikanga', including specific recognition that tribal
and local variations exist.
6095-
nz Mana Whenua
Whenua
Enable Mana Whenua to include site information and other cultural landscape knowledge
within overlays without the need for private plan changes.
6096-1 Bunnings Limited
bronwyn.carruthers@russellmcveagh
.com General Cross plan matters Retain the Part 2 regional and district objectives and policies as currently worded.
.com General Chapter G General provisions
Amend 1.4, the third paragraph under 'Making a resource consent application', as follows;
' Where the proposal involves several activities with different types of consent classification
that are inextricably linked, the council will generally bundle all activities these will be bundled
together and assessed as a single activity in accordance with the most onerous activity
classification, except that apply the most restrictive activity status there will be no bundling of
consent classifications or assessments as between regional* and district plans, whether
operative or proposed. [note: * regional plan includes regional coastal plan] '.
Amend 1.4, the second paragraph under 'Consultation', as follows; ' Applicants are
encouraged to consult with the following parties prior to lodging a resource consent
application: 1. Mana Whenua where the proposal involves an activity that is on land identified
as Sites and Places of Significance to Mana Whenua or Sites and Places of Value to Mana
Whenua, adjacent to or likely to impact on Mana Whenua values . '. '.
Amend 1.4 under 'Assessment criteria', to amend the first paragraph and delete the third
paragraph, as follows; 'The Unitary Plan must specifiesy the matters over which the council
will reserve its control and restrict its discretion when assessing resource consent applications
for controlled and restricted discretionary activities respectively. The Unitary Plan contains
assessment criteria to assist in the assessment that aid the interpretation of the matters of
control/discretion....However, the assessment criteria are not an exhaustive list and the
council may consider any relevant policy or criteria within the Unitary Plan if it is within the
scope of the matter of control/discretion for the particular activity.
.com General Chapter G General provisions G2.2 Activities not provided for
Amend Rule 1 as follows; 'Any activity that is not specifically listed in the Unitary Plan as a
permitted, controlled, restricted discretionary, discretionary, non-complying or prohibited
activity is a non-complying activity discretionary activity. '.
.com Mana Whenua General provisions
assessment
Delete 2.7.4(4) about what types of resource consent applications will require a cultural
impact assessment.
.com General C7.4/H6.3 Signs
Amend Background, second paragraph as follows; 'The Unitary Plan provisions for signs
provide for a range of signs to advertise businesses, products, services or activities or provide
direction or information. However, these provisions must maintain pedestrian and traffic safety
and mitigate the adverse effects signs may have on the visual amenity of buildings and urban,
rural and coastal locations. Most site-related signs and directional signage will be regulated by
a bylaw. '.
.com General C7.4/H6.3 Signs Delete Policy 5 as follows; 5. Develop bylaws for site related signs and for directional signs. '.
.com Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
Amend 3.2 'Table 3: Parking rates for sites within the City Centre Fringe overlay and the
Metropolitan, Town, Local Centres, Mixed Use and Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings
zones' to add new activity below 'Retail', as follows; 'Trade suppliers - 1 per 20m2 GFA '.
Refer to submission for proposed changes. [p 9/32]
Amend activity status of 'Billboards on a side or rear building facade' from discretionary to
restricted discretionary in the Mixed Use zone.
Amend activity status of 'Billboards on a street facing building facade' from non-complying to
restricted discretionary in the Mixed Use zone.
Amend activity status of 'Billboards on a street facing building facade' from discretionary to
restricted discretionary in the General Business zone.
Amend activity status of 'All free standing billboards' from non-complying to discretionary in
the Metropolitan Centre zone.
Amend activity status of 'Billboards on a side or rear building facade' from discretionary to
restricted discretionary in the Metropolitan Centre zone.
Amend activity status of 'Billboards on a street facing building facade' from non-complying to
restricted discretionary in the Metropolitan Centre zone.
.com
Centre) Business
& Bus. Park zones
Amend the activity status of 'Trade suppliers' in the Mixed Use zone from discretionary to
81/1145
Sub#/
.com
Centre) Business
& Bus. Park zones Amend the activity of 'New buildings' to 'New buildings not otherwise provided for' .
.com
Centre) Business
& Bus. Park zones
Add new activity to activity table as follows; ' New buildings associated with integrated retail
developments, supermarkets, department stores, large format retail and trade suppliers'.
.com
Centre) Business
Amend the activity status for 'Offices not otherwise provided for' in the Heavy Industry zone
from non-complying to discretionary.
.com
Centre) Business
Amend the activity status for 'Offices not otherwise provided for' in the Light Industry zone
from non-complying to discretionary.
.com
Centre) Business
Retain the activity status for 'Trade suppliers' in the Light Industry zone as restricted
discretionary.
.com
Centre) Business
& Bus. Park zones
Add restricted discretionary activity status for the new activity; ' New buildings associated with
integrated retail developments, supermarkets, department stores, large format retail and trade
suppliers' [see submission point 18] in the Metropolitan Centre zone. [ p 11/32]
.com
Centre) Business
Add new activity as follows; 'Distribution centres'. [refer also to submission point 82 on p
29/32]
.com
Centre) Business
Add permitted activity status for the new activity 'Distribution centres' [see submission point
23] in the Heavy Industry zone. [p 12/32]
.com
Centre) Business
Add permitted activity status for the new activity 'Distribution centres' [see submission point
23] in the Light Industry zone. [p 12/32]
.com
Centre) Business
Park zones
Delete 4.6(4) about new buildings adjoining the street for 50 per cent of the site in some
areas. Refer to submission for proposed changes. [p 13/32]
.com
Centre) Business
Park zones
Amend 4.6(4) about new buildings adjoining the street for 50 per cent of the site in some
areas, so that trade suppliers are not subject to this rule. [see also submission point 26]
.com
Centre) Business
Park zones
Amend 4.7(1) Building entrances as follows; 1. At least part of the main pedestrian entrance
to a building subject to a Key Retail or General Commercial frontage overlay must be on or
within 3m of the site frontage. This control does not apply in the Business Park zone'.
.com
Centre) Business
Park zones
Amend 4.8(2) Minimum floor to floor/ceiling height so that a minimum ground floor height of
4m is only required in the Local Centre and Neighbourhood Centre zones. Refer to
submission for proposed changes. [p 14/32]
.com
Centre) Business
Park zones
Amend 4.8(2) Minimum floor to floor/ceiling height so that a minimum ground floor height of
4m is not required for buildings containing 'Trade suppliers'. [see also submission point 29] [p
14/32]
.com
Centre) Business
Park zones
Amend 4.7(1) Building entrances so that buildings containing 'Trade suppliers' do not have to
locate the main pedestrian entrance on or within 3m of the site frontage. [see also submission
point 28] [p 13/32]
.com
Centre) Business
Park zones
Amend 4.9(2) Glazing so the rule applies only in the Local Centre and Neighbourhood Centre
zones. Refer to submission for proposed changes. [p 15/32]
.com
Centre) Business
Park zones
Amend 4.9(2) Glazing so that buildings containing 'Trade suppliers' are not subject to the rule.
[see also submission point 32] [p 15/32]
.com
Centre) Business
Park zones
Delete 4.12(1) Ground floor at street frontage level as follows; '1.Entrances to the ground floor
of a building must be at grade with the adjoining street. '.
.com
Centre) Business
zones
Amend 5.3 Maximum impervious area so that the maximum impervious area in a
development changes from 80% to 100%. Refer to submission for proposed changes. [p
16/32]
.com
Centre) Business
Special information
requirements
Amend 6.2(1)(a)(i) restricted discretionary activity assessment criteria for 'Intensity and scale'
as follows; i. The intensity and scale of the land use activity, in particular, the number of
people involved and traffic generated by the activity, should be compatible with the planned
future form and character of the surrounding area. '.
.com
Centre) Business
Special information
requirements
Amend 6.2(3) restricted discretionary assessment criteria as follows; Garden centres, and
motor vehicle sales in the Light Industry and General Business zones and trade suppliers in
the Light Industry and General Business zones '.
.com
Centre) Business
Special information
requirements
Amend 6.2(3)(a)(i) restricted discretionary assessment criteria for 'Intensity and scale' as
follows; 'i. Refer to the assessment criteria in 1(a) above. The intensity and scale of the land
use activity, in particular, the number of people involved and traffic generated by the activity,
should be compatible with the surrounding area. '.
82/1145
Sub#/
.com
Centre) Business
Special information
requirements
Amend 6.2(3)(c) restricted discretionary assessment criteria for 'Design of parking, access
and servicing' to remove the inference that car parking should be underground; and other
matters related to the design and location of carparking contained in the submission. Refer to
.com
Centre) Business
Special information
requirements
Add new 7.2(2)(c) development control infringement assessment criteria as follows; 'c. Effects
on buildings which contain integrated shopping centres, supermarkets, department stores,
large format retail, or trade suppliers i. Buildings will be assessed in terms of the above having
regard to the operational and functional requirements of those retail activities. '.
.com
Centre) Business
Special information
requirements
Amend 8.1 Assessment criteria so that activities such as trade suppliers, supermarkets,
integrated retail developments, large format retail and department stores are not subject to the
assessment criteria in 6.2(5) as well as the criteria in 8.1. Refer to submission for proposed
changes. [p 18/32]
.com
Centre) Business
Special information
requirements
Amend 8.1 Assessment criteria, first bullet point, as follows '- New buildings for integrated
retail developments, supermarkets, department stores, trade suppliers, and large format retail
in the Centres, Mixed Use and General Business zones; . '. [p 18/32]
.com
Centre) Business
Special information
requirements Amend 8.1(1) Assessment criteria as follows; 'Building design and external appearance ' .
.com
Centre) Business
Special information
requirements
Amend 8.1(1)(a) Assessment criteria as follows; ' a.The preferred option for development is
building up to the street boundary with no parking to the street. ' .
.com
Centre) Business
Special information
requirements
Amend 8.1(1)(b) Assessment criteria as follows; ' b.Buildings should address public open
space, principal parking areas and in particular the street, by bringing visual activity, and
pedestrian amenity and activity to these edges where appropriate. One or more of the
following t Techniques to help achieve this may includeshould be used in order of importance,
having regard to the context of the site : ' .
.com
Centre) Business
Special information
requirements
Delete 8.1(1)(c) Assessment criteria as follows; c.Frontages should be integrated with the
prevailing rhythm and scale of existing or intended future frontages along streets, whichever is
appropriate. The stepping of building mass should be used on street frontages where
adjoining buildings are of a smaller scale. '.
.com
Centre) Business
Special information
requirements
Amend 8.1(1)(d) Assessment criteria as follows; 'd.Where alterations and additions are
proposed to buildings that are set back from the road with parking in front, or those buildings
are proposed to be demolished and rebuilt, the continuation of this form of site layout is
acceptable. '.
.com
Centre) Business
Special information
requirements
Add new 8.1(1)(e) Assessment criteria as follows; 'e. Buildings which contain integrated
shopping centres, supermarkets, department stores, large format retail, or trade suppliers will
be assessed in terms of the above having regard to the operational and functional
requirements of those retail activities. '.
.com
Centre) Business
Special information
requirements
Delete 8.1(2)(e) Design of parking, access and servicing, as follows; ' e. High quality
pedestrian connections through a site should be provided to main building entrances and the
street and through the site where the site has two or more street frontages.'.
.com
Centre) Business
Special information
requirements
Amend 8.1(2)(g)(i) and (ii), as follows; Design of parking, access and servicing, as follows;
'ii. have landscaping, including tree planting, of a scale and amount that visually breaks up
the parking area. As a guide, one tree should be planted every sixth parking bay iii. of a
depth that minimises building setback from the street. '.
.com
Centre) Business
Special information
requirements
Amend 8.1(2)(h), as follows; 'h. Where practicable, delivery vehicles separate vehicle access
should be provided for customers and for goods and service trucks and vehicles.should enter
the site by way of a rear lane or access way which leads directly to loading and storage areas.
'.
.com
Centre) Business
Special information
requirements
Amend 8.1(2)(i), as follows; 'i. Where a site adjoins or contains on its rear or side boundary a
service lane or access way (whether private or public ownership) that serves a significant
pedestrian role, that service lane or access way should be considered as a street for the
purpose of assessment criteria and in regard to the appropriate level of pedestrian amenity
the provision of pedestrian amenity should be appropriately addressed. '.
.com
SEAs
Land Delete the SEA overlay.
.com Zoning North and Islands Retain the General Business zoning at 18 Hibiscus Coast Highway, Silverdale.
.com
SEAs
Land Remove the SEA overlay as it applies to the site at 18 Hibiscus Coast Highway, Silverdale.
83/1145
Sub#/
.com Zoning North and Islands Retain the Light Industry zoning at 1-3 Foundry Road, Silverdale.
.com Zoning North and Islands Retain the Light Industry zoning at 17 Porana Rd, Wairau Valley.
.com Zoning North and Islands Retain the Light Industry zoning at 250 Archers Rd, Wairau Valley.
.com Zoning North and Islands Retain the Light Industry zoning at 15 Home Place, Rosedale.
.com Zoning West
Rezone the site at 559-567 Don Buck Road, Massey, from Light Industry to General Business
or Mixed Use.
.com Zoning West Retain the Mixed Use zoning at 21 Fred Taylor Drive, Massey.
.com Precincts - West Westgate
Retain the Westgate sub-precinct C provisions as they relate to 21 Fred Taylor Drive,
Massey.
.com Zoning West Retain the Light Industry zoning at 1/251 Lincoln Road, Henderson.
.com Zoning West Retain the Light Industry zoning at 221/211 Lincoln Road, Henderson.
.com Precincts - West Lincoln
Remove the Lincoln sub-precinct A from land adjacent to Lincoln Rd, at 221/211 Lincoln
Road, Henderson. Refer to map attached to submission at p30/32.
.com Zoning West
Amend the maps to change the area shown in Annexure 2 to submission [adjacent to 3144
Great North Road, New Lynn, and 10 Titirangi Rd, as at p 31/32] from Road to Metropolitan
Centre zone.
.com Zoning West
Retain the Metropolitan Centre zoning at 3144 Great North Road, New Lynn and 10 Titirangi
Road, New Lynn.
.com Designations Auckland Transport 1453 Road Widening - Titirangi
Remove Designation 1453 (for road widening) from the site at 3144 Great North Road, New
Lynn and 10 Titirangi Road, New Lynn.
.com
SEAs
Land
Remove the SEA overlay as it applies to 3144 Great North Road, New Lynn and 10 Titirangi
Road, New Lynn.
.com Zoning Central Retain the Mixed Use zoning at 272, 300, 302 Great North Road, Grey Lynn.
.com Zoning Central Retain the Light Industry zoning at 2 Carr Rd, Mt Roskill.
.com Zoning Central
Rezone the site at 459 Ellerslie Panmure Highway, Mt Wellington, so that part of the site
change from Mixed Use to General Business, and the remainder of the site remains Mixed
Use. Refer to map in submission at p 32/32.
.com Designations Auckland Transport 1633 New Road - Tainui Road
Remove Designation 1633: New Road - Tainui Road from the site at 459 Ellerslie Panmure
Highway, Mt Wellington.
.com Zoning Central Retain the Light Industry zoning at 78 Carbine Road, Mt Wellington.
.com Zoning South Retain the Light Industry zoning at 320 Ti Rakau Drive, Botany.
.com Zoning South
Rezone 94 Cryers Road, East Tamaki and the surrounding sites fronting Cryers Road from 90
Cryers Road through to Trugood Drive, from Heavy Industry to Light Industry.
.com Zoning South
Rezone the Mixed Housing Suburban zoned portion of the site at 173, 177 and 179 Great
South Road, Takanini, to Light Industry.
.com Zoning South Retain the General Business zoning at 55 Lambie Drive, Manukau.
.com Zoning South Retain the Mixed Use zoning at 105 Manukau Road, Pukekohe.
.com Designations Minister of Education 5049 Pukekohe High School
Remove Designation 5049, Educational purposes - secondary school years 7-13 (Pukekohe
High School), as it applies to the site at 105 Manukau Road, Pukekohe.
.com Definitions Existing
Amend definition of 'Building suppliers' as follows; 'A business primarily engaged in selling
materials for use in the construction, modification, cladding, fixed decoration or outfitting of
buildings. Includes:... - lighting '.
Amend the definition of 'Industrial activities' as follows; 'The manufacturing, assembly,
packaging, wholesaling or storage of products or the processing of raw materials or the
operation of distribution centres and other accessory activities. '. [refer also to submission
point 23 on p 12/32]
Amend the definition of retail as follows; 'Selling goods to the general public. Excludes: -
Trade suppliers. '.
84/1145
Sub#/
Amend definition of Trade suppliers as follows; 'A business engaged in sales to businesses
and institutional customers and may also include sales to the general public, and wholly
consists of suppliers of goods in one or more of the following categories:... - home furnishing,
including cleaning and storage suppliers... - lifestyle including leisure, BBQ / outdoor furniture
suppliers.
.com
Centre) Business
& Bus. Park zones
suppliers' [see submission point 18] in the Town Centre zone. [ p 11/32]
.com
Centre) Business
& Bus. Park zones
suppliers' [see submission point 18] in the Local Centre zone. [ p 11/32]
.com
Centre) Business
& Bus. Park zones
suppliers' [see submission point 18] in the Neighbourhood Centre zone. [ p 11/32]
.com
Centre) Business
& Bus. Park zones
suppliers' [see submission point 18] in the Mixed Use zone. [ p 11/32]
.com
Centre) Business
& Bus. Park zones
suppliers' [see submission point 18] in the General Business zone. [ p 11/32]
.com
Centre) Business
& Bus. Park zones
suppliers' [see submission point 18] in the Business Park zone. [ p 11/32]
.com Definitions Existing Delete 'trees' from the definition of 'vegetation alteration or removal' . [p 21/32]
6097-1
Coal Association of New
Zealand and Straterra bernie@straterra.co.nz RPS Issues
wellbeing Retain the Background.
6097-2
Zealand and Straterra bernie@straterra.co.nz RPS
Transport
B3.1 Commercial and
industrial growth Retain the Objectives and Policies.
6097-3
Zealand and Straterra bernie@straterra.co.nz RPS Issues
Amend 'Air Quality' to read 'However, air quality sometimes fails to meet acceptable levels or
comply with the Resource Management (National Environmental Standards for Air Quality)
2004. the government's national environmental standards for air quality or Auckland Ambient
Air Quality standards (AAAQS). Emissions to air can result in elevated levels of particulate
matter, nitrogen dioxide and other pollutants which are linked to negative health effects.'
6097-4
Zealand and Straterra bernie@straterra.co.nz RPS Natural resources B6.1 Air Retain the Introduction.
6097-5
Zealand and Straterra bernie@straterra.co.nz RPS Natural resources B6.1 Air
Amend Objective 2 to read: 'The Auckland Ambient Air Quality Standards Acceptable air
quality is achieved throughout Auckland including meeting the and Resource Management
National Environmental Standards are met , and the Ministry for the Environment's Ambient
Air Quality Guidelines, in particular priority is given to meeting the annual average standards
for fine particles (PM10 and PM2.5) and hourly and 24-hourly standards for nitrogen dioxide.'
6097-6
Zealand and Straterra bernie@straterra.co.nz RPS General
Amend Table 5 'Natural resources', the second 'Natural resource objective' to read:
'Acceptable air quality is achieved throughout Auckland including meeting the Resource
Management The Auckland Ambient Air Quality Standard s and (National Environmental
Standards for Air Quality) 2004 and the Ministry for the Environment's Ambient Air Quality
Guidelines are met, and in particular priority is given to meeting the annual average standards
6097-7
Amend Table 5 'Natural resources', the first 'Environmental result anticipated' to read: 'Air
discharges and the use and development of land are managed to i Improved air quality,
enhance amenity values and a reductione in reverse sensitivity complaints in Aucklands
urban areas...'
6097-8
Amend Table 5 'Natural resources', the second 'Environmental result anticipated' to read: 'Air
quality consistent with protecting human health and amenity is achieved throughout the
Auckland Region. The Auckland Ambient Air Quality Standards and National Environmental
Standards are met, and in particular priority is given to meeting the annual average standards
85/1145
Sub#/
6097-9
Zealand and Straterra bernie@straterra.co.nz Air Quality
and policies
Amend the last sentence of the Background to read: 'Therefore, Their effects of these
activities can need to be managed through methods such as using suitabl e the use of
suitable control technology, on-site management techniques andby where practicable
locating such industries in appropriate areas.'
6097-10
6097-11
and policies
Amend Policy 1 to read: 'Protect human health by ensuring air discharges do not cause
adverse effects to human health and that cumulative effects are minimised by requiring that
air discharges do not cause air quality to exceed the AAAQS in Table 1 for the specified
contaminants, and manage the discharge of other contaminants so that the adverse effects
on human health, including cumulative adverse effects, are minimised.'
6097-12
6097-13
and policies
Amend Table 1: Auckland Ambient Air Quality Standards to change the 24 hour (averaging
time) of Sulphur dioxide (S0
2
) from 20 mirco grams per metre cubed to 120 micro grams per
metre cubed.
6097-14
Zealand and Straterra bernie@straterra.co.nz Air Quality H4.1 Auckland wide rules
General controls
Add a new Restricted Discretionary Activity: 'Any activity failing to meet the Auckland Ambient
Air Quality Standards (AAAQS)'.
6097-15
Zealand and Straterra bernie@straterra.co.nz Air Quality H4.1 Auckland wide rules
General controls
Add new matters of discretion for 'any activity not complying with the Auckland Ambient Air
Quality Standards (AAAQS)' as detailed in the submission on page 56/58.
6097-16
Zealand and Straterra bernie@straterra.co.nz Air Quality H4.1 Auckland wide rules H4.1.4 and H4.15 Assessment
Replace the 'matter of discretion' for the assessment of combustion activities in 5.1(8)(b) to
read as follows: 'The Auckland ambient air quality standards.'
6097-17
Zealand and Straterra bernie@straterra.co.nz Air Quality H4.1 Auckland wide rules H4.1.4 and H4.15 Assessment Retain assessment criteria 5.2(1).
6097-18
Zealand and Straterra bernie@straterra.co.nz RPS Natural resources B6.1 Air
Amend plan to include adequate section 32 analysis in respect to the proposed Auckland
Ambient Air Quality Standards.
6098-1 Metlifecare Limited cmcgarr@bentley.co.nz General Miscellaneous Other Adopt the reflief sort by the Retirement Villages Association
6098-2 Metlifecare Limited cmcgarr@bentley.co.nz RPS Issues
growth
Amend issue as follows: Our growing and aging population increases demand for housing,
employment, business, infrastructure, and services. This means we must manage our growth
in a way that: - enhances quality of life and wellbeing for individuals of all ages and
communities - optimises the efficient use and development of our existing urban area
growth
Amend paragraph 3 as detailed on page 13/85 of the submission. Amendments put an
emphasis on the ageing population.
growth
Add and amend to the provisions under the 'social well-being' heading as detailed on pages
13 and 14/85 of the submission. Additions and amendments put an emphasis on retirement
accommodation as a housing choice
6098-5 Metlifecare Limited cmcgarr@bentley.co.nz RPS Urban growth
quality compact urban form Retain Objectives 1 - 4 and Policies 1 and 3
quality compact urban form Amend Policy 2 as follows: (e) which provide housing and care choices for older people.
Amend the 'explanation and reasons' as detailed in page 15/85 of the submission.
Amendments put an emphasis on retirement accommodation.
6098-8 Metlifecare Limited cmcgarr@bentley.co.nz Residential zones Housing affordability H6.6 Rules Amend to exclude retirement villages and supported residential care from these provisions
6098-9 Metlifecare Limited cmcgarr@bentley.co.nz Sustainable Development C7.7/H6.4 Sustainable design Amend Policies 1 and 2 by replacing the word 'Require' with 'Encourage'
6098-10 Metlifecare Limited cmcgarr@bentley.co.nz Sustainable Development C7.7/H6.4 Sustainable design
Amend Policy 3 as detailed on page 21/85 of the submission. Amendments remove the
detailed sustainable design measures listed in the policy
6098-11 Metlifecare Limited cmcgarr@bentley.co.nz Sustainable Development C7.7/H6.4 Sustainable design Delete sustainable development rules
6098-12 Metlifecare Limited cmcgarr@bentley.co.nz General Chapter G General provisions
statements Delete G2.7.2
6098-13 Metlifecare Limited cmcgarr@bentley.co.nz Precincts Ak-Wide and Coastal New Precincts Retirement Village
Delete the Special Purpose Retirement Village zone and replace it with a Retirement Village
precinct. Generally transpose the provisions in the Special Purpose Retirement Village zone
into the Retirement Village precinct
6098-14 Metlifecare Limited cmcgarr@bentley.co.nz Residential zones Retirement Village zone
D8.7 Description, objectives
and policies
Amend the zone description as detailed on page 29/85 of the submission. Amendments
prepare the description to move from a zone to a precinct and expand the focus of the
Retirement Village zone to include accessory activities such as medical services, supported
residential care and care centres
and policies
Amend Objectives 1 and 2 as follows: (1) Retirement villages, supported residential care and
care centre facilities make efficient use of... (2) Retirement villages, supported residential care
and care centre facilities provide for a range of...
and policies Amend Policies 1 and 3 by replacing the words 'retirement villages' with 'facilities'
86/1145
Sub#/
and policies
Amend Policy 5 as follows: Graduate building heights so higher buildings are located away
from the zone precinct boundary when the sites adjoins open space or a residential zone to
avoid significant over-shadowing and visual dominance, (except adjoining Terrace Housing
and Apartment Buildings zone where building height may be at a greater scale at the zone
interface
6098-18 Metlifecare Limited cmcgarr@bentley.co.nz Residential zones Retirement Village zone I21 Rules
Amend Activity Table to add 'supported residential care' and 'care centres' as permitted
activities.
6098-19 Metlifecare Limited cmcgarr@bentley.co.nz Residential zones Retirement Village zone I21 Rules Delete Rule 2.1 'Density'.
Amend the introduction to the development controls as follows: Retirement villages
Development will be subject to the following controls...
6098-21 Metlifecare Limited cmcgarr@bentley.co.nz Residential zones Retirement Village zone I21 Rules Retain Rule 3.2 'Building height'.
6098-22 Metlifecare Limited cmcgarr@bentley.co.nz Residential zones Retirement Village zone I21 Rules Retain Rule 3.3 'Height in relation to boundary'.
6098-23 Metlifecare Limited cmcgarr@bentley.co.nz Residential zones Retirement Village zone I21 Rules Amend the maximum impervious area in Rule 3.4 from 60% 70%
Amend the building coverage control in Rule 3.5 from 40% to 50%. Amend the purpose of the
rule as follows: Purpose: to manage the density of buildings on the siteconsistent with the
residential character of the zone
6098-25 Metlifecare Limited cmcgarr@bentley.co.nz Residential zones Retirement Village zone I21 Rules Delete Rule 3.6 'Landscaping'.
6098-26 Metlifecare Limited cmcgarr@bentley.co.nz Residential zones Retirement Village zone I21 Rules Delete the front, side and rear yard controls in Rule 3.7.
Delete Rule 3.8 'Outlook' and Rule 3.9 'Outdoor living space' and replace with a combined
outlook and outdoor living space control on page 33/85 of the submission. The combined
control only requires a development to meet either the outlook or outdoor living space
requirements.
6098-28 Metlifecare Limited cmcgarr@bentley.co.nz Residential zones Retirement Village zone I21 Rules Delete Rule 3.10 'Communal open space'.
6098-29 Metlifecare Limited cmcgarr@bentley.co.nz Residential zones Retirement Village zone I21 Rules Delete Rule 3.11 'Daylight to dwellings'.
6098-30 Metlifecare Limited cmcgarr@bentley.co.nz Residential zones Retirement Village zone I21 Rules Delete Rule 3.12 'Minimum dwelling size'.
6098-31 Metlifecare Limited cmcgarr@bentley.co.nz Residential zones Retirement Village zone I21 Rules Delete Rule 3.13 'Minimum dimension of principal living rooms and principal bedrooms'.
6098-32 Metlifecare Limited cmcgarr@bentley.co.nz Residential zones Retirement Village zone I21 Rules Delete Rule 3.14 'Minimum floor to ceiling height'.
6098-33 Metlifecare Limited cmcgarr@bentley.co.nz Residential zones Retirement Village zone I21 Rules Delete Rule 3.15 'Servicing and waste'.
Delete the restricted discretionary activities matters of discretion 4.1(1)(c) [design of
communal open space] and 4.1(1)(d) [design and layout of dwellings].
Amend the restricted discretionary activities assessment criteria as detailed on page 35/85 of
the submission. Amendments delete assessment criteria that address detailed design aspects
relating to privacy, communal open space, dwellings, and outdoor living space.
Delete development control infringement matters of discretion (1)(b) [height, height to
boundary, building coverage and side and rear yards], (3) [outlook], (4) [landscaping], (5)
[front yards], (6) [minimum dwelling size, daylight to dwellings, minimum floor to ceiling height,
waste storage, minimum dimension of principal living rooms and principal bedrooms, and
outdoor living space] [under 5. 'Assessment - Development control infringements'].
Amend the development control infringement assessment criteria as detailed on page 39/85
of the submission. Amendments delete assessment criteria that address outlook, front yards,
fences, garages, dwellings fronting the street, minimum dwelling size, daylight to dwellings,
minimum floor to ceiling height, storage, waste storage, dimension of principal living rooms
and principal bedrooms, and outdoor living space.
6098-38 Metlifecare Limited cmcgarr@bentley.co.nz Residential zones Retirement Village zone I21 Rules Delete the design statement requirement.
6098-39 Metlifecare Limited cmcgarr@bentley.co.nz Residential zones Residential Activity Table
Amend the activity status of retirement villages in the Single House, Mixed Housing
Suburban, Mixed Housing Urban and Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings zones from
Discretionary to Restricted Discretionary.
6098-40 Metlifecare Limited cmcgarr@bentley.co.nz Residential zones Residential Activity Table
Amend the activity status for 'supported residential care' activities greater than 200m
2
in the
Single House, Mixed Housing Suburban, Mixed Housing Urban and Terrace Housing and
Apartment Buildings zone from Discretionary to Restricted Discretionary
6098-41 Metlifecare Limited cmcgarr@bentley.co.nz
Centre) Business
& Bus. Park zones
Amend the activity status for retirement villages in the Metropolitan Centre, Town Centre,
Local Centre, Neighbourhood Centre, Mixed Use, General Business and Business Park
zones from Discretionary to Permitted
6098-42 Metlifecare Limited cmcgarr@bentley.co.nz Zoning South
Rezone 49 Aberfeldy Ave, Highland Park from Special Purpose Retirement Village to Terrace
Housing and Apartment Buildings
6098-43 Metlifecare Limited cmcgarr@bentley.co.nz Precincts Ak-Wide and Coastal New Precincts Retirement Village Overlay 49 Aberfeldy Ave, Highland Park with a Retirement Village precinct
Rezone 14 Edgewater Drive, Pakuranga from Special Purpose Retirement Village to Terrace
6098-45 Metlifecare Limited cmcgarr@bentley.co.nz Precincts Ak-Wide and Coastal New Precincts Retirement Village Overlay 14 Edgewater Drive, Pakuranga with a Retirement Village precinct
87/1145
Sub#/
6098-46 Metlifecare Limited cmcgarr@bentley.co.nz Zoning West
Rezone 38-44 Golf Road, Titirangi from Special Purpose Retirement Village to Mixed Housing
Urban
6098-47 Metlifecare Limited cmcgarr@bentley.co.nz Precincts Ak-Wide and Coastal New Precincts Retirement Village Overlay 38-44 Golf Road, Titirangi with a Retirement Village precinct
control
Building demolition control J.3.6 Rules and mapping Remove the pre-1944 building demolition control overlay from 38-44 Golf Road, Titirangi
Rezone 48-72 Avonleigh Road, Titirangi from Special Purpose Retirement Village to Mixed
Housing Urban
6098-50 Metlifecare Limited cmcgarr@bentley.co.nz Precincts Ak-Wide and Coastal New Precincts Retirement Village Overlay 48-72 Avonleigh Road, Titirangi with a Retirement Village precinct
6098-51 Metlifecare Limited cmcgarr@bentley.co.nz Precincts - West
Area Mapping Remove sub-precinct C from 48-72 Avonleigh Road, Titirangi
Rezone 135 Connell Street, Blockhouse Bay from Special Purpose Retirement Village to
Mixed Housing Urban
6098-53 Metlifecare Limited cmcgarr@bentley.co.nz Precincts Ak-Wide and Coastal New Precincts Retirement Village Overlay 135 Connell Street, Blockhouse Bay with a Retirement Village precinct
6098-54 Metlifecare Limited cmcgarr@bentley.co.nz Zoning Central
Rezone 7 St Vincent Ave, Remuera from Special Purpose Retirement Village to Terrace
6098-55 Metlifecare Limited cmcgarr@bentley.co.nz Precincts Ak-Wide and Coastal New Precincts Retirement Village Overlay 7 St Vincent Ave, Remuera with a Retirement Village precinct
control
Building demolition control J.3.6 Rules and mapping Remove the pre-1944 Building Demolition control overlay from 7 St Vincent Ave, Remuera
6098-57 Metlifecare Limited cmcgarr@bentley.co.nz Zoning North and Islands
Rezone 142 Shakespeare Rd, Takapuna from Special Purpose Retirement Village to Mixed
Use
Overlay 142 Shakespeare Rd, Takapuna with a Retirement Village precinct. Add a precinct
plan to the Retirement Village precinct as detailed on page 66/85 of the submission
Rezone 30 Matarangi Rd, Dannemora from Special Purpose Retirement Village to Terrace
6098-60 Metlifecare Limited cmcgarr@bentley.co.nz Precincts Ak-Wide and Coastal New Precincts Retirement Village Overlay 30 Matarangi Rd, Dannemora with a Retirement Village precinct
6098-61 Metlifecare Limited cmcgarr@bentley.co.nz RPS Changes to the RUB North and Waiheke Island
Rezone 91-101 Red Beach Rd, Red Beach from Special Purpose Retirement Village, Future
Urban and Mixed Housing Urban to Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings
6098-62 Metlifecare Limited cmcgarr@bentley.co.nz Precincts Ak-Wide and Coastal New Precincts Retirement Village Overlay 91-101 Red Beach Rd, Red Beach with a Retirement Village precinct
Rezone 1 Longford Park Drive, Takanini from Special Purpose Retirement Village to Terrace
6098-64 Metlifecare Limited cmcgarr@bentley.co.nz Precincts Ak-Wide and Coastal New Precincts Retirement Village Overlay 1 Longford Park Drive, Takanini with a Retirement Village precinct
6098-65 Metlifecare Limited cmcgarr@bentley.co.nz Zoning Central
Rezone 1381 Dominion Road Extension, Mt Roskill from Special Purpose Retirement Village
to Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings
6098-66 Metlifecare Limited cmcgarr@bentley.co.nz Precincts Ak-Wide and Coastal New Precincts Retirement Village Overlay 1381 Dominion Road Extension, Mt Roskill with a Retirement Village precinct
6098-67 Metlifecare Limited cmcgarr@bentley.co.nz Historic Heritage (Overlay)
Heritage
Places
Remove historic heritage place ID 2589 and historic heritage extent of place ID 2589 from
1381 Dominion Road Extension, Mt Roskill
Rezone 15 Sel Peacock Drive, Henderson from Special Purpose Retirement Village to
Metropolitan Centre
6098-69 Metlifecare Limited cmcgarr@bentley.co.nz Precincts Ak-Wide and Coastal New Precincts Retirement Village Overlay 15 Sel Peacock Drive, Henderson with a Retirement Village precinct
Centre)
Overlay Building Frontage
Maps only
Remove the general commercial frontage overlay from 15 Sel Peacock Drive, Henderson as
detailed in map on page 77/85 of the submission
Rezone 123 Stanley Road, Glenfield from Special Purpose Retirement Village to Mixed
Housing Urban
Overlay 123 Stanley Road, Glenfield with a Retirement Village precinct. Add a precinct plan to
the Retirement Village precinct as detailed on page 81/85 of the submission
6098-73 Metlifecare Limited cmcgarr@bentley.co.nz Historic Heritage (Overlay)
Heritage
Places
Delete historic heritage place ID 860 and historic heritage extent of place ID 860 from 123
Stanley Road, Glenfield
Rezone 125 and 147 Unsworth Drive, Unsworth Heights from Special Purpose Retirement
Village to Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings
Overlay 125 and 147 Unsworth Drive, Unsworth Heights with a Retirement Village precinct.
Add a precinct plan to the Retirement Village precinct as detailed on page 85/85 of the
submission
88/1145
Sub#/
6099-1 Ockham Holdings Limited mark@ockham.co.nz Residential zones Residential
policies
Replace all residential zone provisions and zoning maps to achieve the outcomes set out in
the submission.
6099-2 Ockham Holdings Limited mark@ockham.co.nz General Cross plan matters Delete the 'construct' of density from all sections of the plan.
policies
Merge the Mixed Housing Urban and Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings zones to
create a new Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings zone.
6099-4 Ockham Holdings Limited mark@ockham.co.nz Zoning Central
Rezone all land in the Mixed Housing Suburban zone to Mixed Housing Urban (MHU) zone
and apply the new MHU zone to all residential sites with access off all main arterial and
connecting road such as New North Road, Sandringham Road, Dominion Road, Mt Eden
Road, Manukau Road, Great South Road, Pt Chevalier Road, Great North Road etc; and
reduce the extent of the Single House zone accordingly. Refer to Figure 1 showing arterials
and collectors where the MHU should be applied on page 26/92 of the submission.
policies Reduce the size of the Single House zone.
6099-6 Ockham Holdings Limited mark@ockham.co.nz Zoning Central
Extend the Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings (THAB) zone to cover all residential
sites located with five minutes walking distance of all main arterials and connecting roads
such as New North Road, Sandringham Road, Dominion Road, Mt Eden Road, Manukau
Road, Great South Road, Pt Chevalier Road, Great North Road etc; and reduce the extend of
the Mixed Housing Suburban and Single House zones accordingly. Refer to Figure 1 showing
example of where the THAB zone should be applied on page 26/92 of the submission.
policies
Rezone all land within 10 minutes walking distance of train stations and transport nodes
(except for Business zoned land) to Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings zone.
6099-8 Ockham Holdings Limited mark@ockham.co.nz
control
Review and amend the extent of the pre-1944 demolition control over all residential zones to
identify only buildings that are worthy of specific protection.
6099-9 Ockham Holdings Limited mark@ockham.co.nz
control
Amend the assessment criteria to provide a clear direction that any building must have
outstanding heritage characteristics for it to be retained, when considering any proposal for
higher density development.
6099-10 Ockham Holdings Limited mark@ockham.co.nz Residential zones Residential Land use controls Delete all density controls.
6099-11 Ockham Holdings Limited mark@ockham.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - Urban zones H5.2 3.1 Residential zones
Amend rule 1 [site size] to apply a minimum gross site area of 400m2 in the Single House
zone, except that a minimum size size should not apply where there are two dwellings existing
or created within a single building.
General
Delete all development controls in all residential zones other than those relating to yards,
height, height to boundary and landscaped area.
Amend rule 4 [Building height in the Single House zone] and rule 6 [Building height in the
Large Lot zone] to increase the height from 8m to 9m.
Amend rule 4 [Height in relation to boundary in the Single House zone] to increase the
building height at side and rear boundaries from 2.5m to 3m.
Add a new rule in the Large Lot zone to apply a Height in Relation to Boundary control,
including a building height at side and rear boundaries of 3m.
Amend rule 6 [Landscaping in the Single House zone] to apply a minimum landscaped area of
50%.
and Coastal Settlement zone Add a new rule in the Large Lot zone to apply a minimum landscaped area of 50%.
Amend rule 8 [Building height] in the Mixed Housing Urban zone to increase the height from
10m to 12m.
Amend rule 4 [Height in relation to boundary] in the Mixed Housing Urban zone to apply a
building height at side and rear boundaries of 3m.
Amend rule 8 [Landscaping] in the Mixed Housing Urban zone to apply a minimum
landscaped area of 50%.
89/1145
Sub#/
Amend rule 9 [Building height] in the Terraced Housing and Apartment Buildings zone to
apply a building height of 14m.
Terrace Housing and
Amend rule 9 to apply a Height in relation to boundary control containing performance criteria
based around site specific access to daylight.
Amend rule 9 [Landscaping] in the Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings zone apply a
minimum landscaped area of 45%.
General
Amend all development control infringements to Restricted Discretionary activities,
irrespective of how many or which infringements occur.
6099-25 Ockham Holdings Limited mark@ockham.co.nz RPS Urban growth
environment
Delete all reference to the Auckland Design Manual in the objectives, policies and
assessment criteria.
6099-26 Ockham Holdings Limited mark@ockham.co.nz Residential zones Residential Activity Table
Amend rule 1 Activity Table to make any building in the Mixed Housing Suburban, Mixed
Urban and Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings zones a Restricted Discretionary activity
even where any of the densities in this rule are not met.
6099-27 Ockham Holdings Limited mark@ockham.co.nz Residential zones Residential Notification Delete rule 2 [Notification]
6099-28 Ockham Holdings Limited mark@ockham.co.nz Residential zones Residential Land use controls Delete all density controls in rule 3.1 [Maximum density]
6099-29 Ockham Holdings Limited mark@ockham.co.nz Residential zones Residential Land use controls
Amend Table 1 in rule 3.1 [Maximum density] to change Rural and Coastal Settlement zone
from 'One dwelling per 4000m2 net site area' to 'One dwelling per 2000m2 gross site area'; to
change Single House zone from 'One dwelling per site" to "One dwelling per 400m2 gross site
area'; to delete all reference to the Mixed Housing Suburban zone: to change Mixed Housing
Urban zone from various densities to "No density limits"; and to include Terrace Housing and
Apartment Buildings zone in the Table with a notation "No density limits". [This submission
point should be read together with submissions points 3 to 6 on page 25/92 seeking to change
the residential zones, including merging the two mixed housing zones].
6099-30 Ockham Holdings Limited mark@ockham.co.nz Residential zones Residential Land use controls Amendment rule 3.1 [Maximum density] to delete rules 3.1.2 to 3.1.8
6099-31 Ockham Holdings Limited mark@ockham.co.nz Residential zones Residential Land use controls
Amend Table 1 to rule 3.1 Maximum density (or elsewhere as consequentially required) to
make any development that exceeds the density limits a Discretionary activity.
6099-32 Ockham Holdings Limited mark@ockham.co.nz Residential zones Residential Activity Table
Amend the Activity Table in rule 1 to change the activity status [for dwellings?] to Permitted in
the Single House zone and Restricted discretionary in the Mixed Housing Urban and Terrace
Housing and Apartment Buildings zone [which should be read together with previous
submissions points 3 to 6 [on page 25/92] seeking to change the residential zones, including
merging the two mixed housing zones].
Amend rule 1 (Development control infringements) in the Mixed Housing Suburban zone to
assess all development control infringements as a Restricted discretionary activity.
Amend the purpose and rule 2 [Building height] in the Mixed Housing Suburban zone to
accommodate up to three storey housing and to increase the maximum building height from
8m to 12m.
Amend rule 3 [Height in relation to boundary] in the Mixed Housing Suburban zone to
increase the height at boundary from 2.5m to 3m
Mixed Housing Urban zone Retain rule 4 [Alternative height in relation to boundary] in the Mixed Housing Suburban zone.
Mixed Housing Urban zone Retain rule 5 [Yards] in the Mixed Housing Suburban zone.
Mixed Housing Urban zone Retain rule 6 [Common walls] in the Mixed Housing Suburban zone.
Mixed Housing Urban zone Retain rule 7 [Maximum impervious surface] in the Mixed Housing Suburban zone.
Mixed Housing Urban zone Delete rule 8 [Maximum building coverage] in the Mixed housing Suburban zone.
Amend rule 9.1 [Landscaping] in the Mixed Housing Suburban zone to increase the minimum
landscaped area for densities or up to 400m2 from 40% to 50%; and to increase the minimum
landscaped area from 30% to 45% for densities greater than 400m2.
90/1145
Sub#/
Mixed Housing Urban zone Delete rule 10 [Outlook space] in the Mixed Housing Suburban zone.
Delete rule 11 [Separation between buildings within a site] in the Mixed Housing Suburban
zone.
Mixed Housing Urban zone Delete rule 12 [Outdoor living space] in the Mixed Housing Suburban zone.
Mixed Housing Urban zone Delete rule 13 [Dwellings fronting the street] in the Mixed Housing Suburban zone.
Mixed Housing Urban zone Delete rule 14 [Maximum building length] in the Mixed Housing Suburban zone.
Amend rule 15 [Fences] in the Mixed Housing Suburban zone to read: "Fences in a front yard
must not exceed 2m 1.2m in height provided they are 50% transparent when over 1m in
height.
Mixed Housing Urban zone Delete rule 16 [Garages] in the Mixed Housing Suburban zone.
Amend rule 17 (1)(a) [Minimum dwelling size] in the Mixed Housing Suburban zone to reduce
the minimum floor area for studio dwellings from 40m2 to 30m2.
Delete rule 18 [Minimum dimension of principal living rooms and principal bedrooms] in the
Mixed Housing Suburban zone.
Replace rules 19 (1) and (2) [Servicing and Waste] in the Mixed Housing Suburban zone with
a new rule that reads: " All developments must provide a waste management plan to the
satisfaction of the Council".
Mixed Housing Urban zone Retain rule 20 [Water and waste water] in the Mixed Housing Suburban zone.
Mixed Housing Urban zone Retain rule 21 [Storage] in the Mixed Housing Suburban zone.
Amend rule 22 (1) [Universal access] in the Mixed Housing Suburban zone to reduce the
percentage of dwellings that must comply with the Universal Access requirements from 20%
to 10%. .
Amend rule 1 [Development control infringements] in the Mixed Housing Urban zone to
assess all development control infringements as a Restricted discretionary activity.
Amend rule 2 [Building height] in the Mixed Housing Urban zone to read: " Buildings must not
exceed 10m 12m or three storeys in height except that 50% of a building's roof, measured
vertically from the junction between wall and roof, may exceed this height by 1m, where the
entire roof slopes 15 degree or more".
Mixed Housing Urban zone Retain rule 3 [Height in relation to boundary] in the Mixed Housing Urban zone.
Mixed Housing Urban zone Retain rule 4 [Alternative height in relation to boundary] in the Mixed Housing Urban zone.
Mixed Housing Urban zone Retain rule 5 [Common walls] in the Mixed Housing Urban zone.
Mixed Housing Urban zone Retain rule 6 [Yards] in the Mixed Housing Urban zone.
Mixed Housing Urban zone Delete rule 7 [Maximum impervious area] in the Mixed Housing Urban zone.
Mixed Housing Urban zone Delete rule 8 [Building coverage] in the Mixed Housing Urban zone.
91/1145
Sub#/
Amend rules 9 (1) and (2) [Landscaping] in the Mixed Housing Urban zone to increase the
landscaped area to 45%.
Mixed Housing Urban zone Delete rule 10 [Outlook space] in the Mixed Housing Urban zone.
Mixed Housing Urban zone Delete rule 11 [Separation between buildings within a site] in the Mixed Housing Urban zone.
Mixed Housing Urban zone Delete rule 12 [Outdoor living space] in the Mixed Housing Urban zone.
Mixed Housing Urban zone Delete rule 13 [Dwellings fronting the street] in the Mixed Housing Urban zone.
Mixed Housing Urban zone Delete rule 14 [Maximum building length] in the Mixed Housing Urban zone.
Amend rule 15 [Fences] in the Mixed Housing Urban zone to read: "Fences in a front yard
must not exceed 2m 1.2m in height provided they are 50% transparent when over 1m in
height.
Mixed Housing Urban zone Delete rule 16 [Garages] in the Mixed Housing Urban zone.
Amend rule 17 (1)(a) [Minimum dwelling size] in the Mixed Housing Urban zone to reduce the
minimum floor area for studio dwellings from 40m2 to 30m2.
Mixed Housing Urban zone Delete rule 18 [Daylight to dwellings] in the Mixed Housing Urban zone.
Mixed Housing Urban zone.
Replace rules 19 (1) and (2) [Servicing and Waste] in the Mixed Housing Urban zone with a
new rule that reads: " All developments must provide a waste management plan to the
satisfaction of the Council".
Mixed Housing Urban zone Retain rule 21 [Water and waste water] in the Mixed Housing Urban zone.
Mixed Housing Urban zone Retain rule 22 [Storage] in the Mixed Housing Urban zone.
Mixed Housing Urban zone Delete rule 23 [Dwelling mix] in the Mixed Housing Urban zone.
Amend rule 24 (1) [Universal access] in the Mixed Housing Urban zone to reduce the
percentage of dwellings that must comply with the Universal Access requirements from 20%
to 10%.
Amend rule 1 (Development control infringements) in the Terrace Housing and Apartment
Buildings zone to assess all development control infringements as a Restricted discretionary
activity.
Mixed Housing Urban zone Retain rule 2 [Building height] in the Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings zone.
Mixed Housing Urban zone Retain rule 3 [Yards] in the Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings zone.
Amend rule 4 [Building setbacks within the Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings zone] to
apply a 3m setback from side and rear boundaries iirrespective of the number of storeys or
height of the building.
Terrace Housing and
Retain rule 5 [Building setbacks adjoining lower density zones] in the Terrace Housing and
92/1145
Sub#/
Delete rule 6 [Minimum frontage and site width] in the Terrace Housing and Apartment
Buildings zone.
Delete rule 7 [Maximum impervious area] in the Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings
zone.
Mixed Housing Urban zone Delete rule 8 [Building coverage] in the Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings zone.
Amend rule 9 [Landscaping] in the Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings zone to
increased the landscaped area from 40 to 45%.
Mixed Housing Urban zone Delete rule 10 [Outlook space] in the Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings zone.
Delete rule 11 [Separation between buildings within a site] in the Terrace Housing and
Mixed Housing Urban zone Delete rule 12 [Outdoor living space] in the Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings zone.
Delete rule 13 [Maximum building length] in the Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings
zone.
Amend rule 14 [Fences] in the Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings zone to read:
"Fences in a front yard must not exceed 2m 1.2m in height provided they are 50% transparent
when over 1m in height.
Terrace Housing and
Apartment Buildings zone Delete rule 9.15 'Garages'.
Delete rule 16 (1) (a) [Minimum dwelling size] in the Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings
zone
Mixed Housing Urban zone Delete rule 17 [Daylight to dwellings] in the Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings zone
Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings zone.
Replace rule 19 (1) and (2) [Servicing and Waste] in the Terrace Housing and Apartment
Buildings zone with a new rule that reads: " All developments must provide a waste
management plan to the satisfaction of the Council".
Mixed Housing Urban zone Retain rule 20 [Storage] in the Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings zone.
Mixed Housing Urban zone Delete rule 21 [Dwelling mix] in the Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings zone.
6099-
100 Ockham Holdings Limited mark@ockham.co.nz Residential zones Residential
Amend rule 22 (20 [Minimum floor to floor/ceiling height] in the Terrace Housing and
Apartment Buildings zone to: and of "Purpose: buildings are adaptable to a wide variety of
uses over time and provided with adequate daylight access. 1. The ground floor of a new
building must have a minimum finished floor to floor height of 4m for a minimum depth of 10m
where it adjoins an arterial road. 2. In all other instances, the finished floor to finished ceiling
height of habitable rooms must be at least 2.70m."
6099-
Amend rule 23 (1) [Universal access] in the Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings zone to
reduce the percentage of dwellings that must comply with the Universal Access requirements
from 20% to 10%.
6099-
Special info. req.
Amend rule 10.1 (3) 'Restricted discretionary activities - Matters of discretion' so the matters
apply to all dwellings in the Mixed Housing Suburban, Mixed Housing Urban and Terrace
Housing and Apartment Buildings zone, not just four or more dwellings.
6099-
Special info. req.
Amend rule 10.2 'Restricted discretionary activities - Assessment criteria' to delete reference
to the Auckland Design Manual.
6099-
Special info. req.
Amend rule 10.2 'Restricted discretionary activities - Assessment criteria' to reduce the
number of criteria so they are more concise and easier to administer.
93/1145
Sub#/
6099-
Special info. req.
Amend or delete matters for discretion and assessment criteria in rule 11 [Assessment -
Development control infringements] to reflect all relief sought in relation to the residential
zones.
6099-
Special info. req. Delete rule 12 'Special information requirements'
6099-
policies
Delete or replace all objectives and policies in the residential zones to reflect the proposed
merger of zones and amendments or deletion of the residential development controls in
residential zones [generally as set out in the high level relief sought on pages 25.92 to 27.92].

6099-
108 Ockham Holdings Limited mark@ockham.co.nz
Centre)
D3.7 Mixed Use zone desc,
obs & pols
Delete or replace all objectives and policies in the Mixed Use zone to reflect the proposed
merger of zones and amendments or deletion of the residential development controls in
residential zones [generally as set out in the high level relief sought on pages 25.92 to 27.92].

6099-
109 Ockham Holdings Limited mark@ockham.co.nz RPS Urban growth
environment
Delete reference to the Auckland Design Manual in all objectives, policies and assessment
criteria throughout the PAUP.
6099-
policies
Amend all zone descriptions to reflect the proposed merger of zones and amendments or
deletion of the residential development controls in residential zones [generally as set out in
the high level relief sought on pages 25.92 to 27.92].
6099-
Centre) Business
& Bus. Park zones Amend Activity Table to make all offices in the Mixed Use zone a Permitted activity.
6099-
Centre) Business I3.2 Notification Amend Notification provisions - no specific relief stated.
6099-
Centre) Business I3.3 Land use controls Retain 3.1 [Activities within 30m of a residential zone]
6099-
Centre) Business
Park zones
Amend 4.1 [Development control infringements] to make assessment of all development
control infringements a Restricted discretionary activity.
6099-
Centre) Business
Park zones
Amend Table 1 rule 4.2 [Building height] to increase building heights in the Mixed Use zone
from 16.5m (4 storeys) to 24.5m (6 storeys)
6099-
Centre) Business
Park zones Retain rule 4.3 [Height in relation to boundary]
6099-
Centre) Business
Park zones
Amend rule 4.4 [Building setback at upper floors} to increase building height from 16.5m and
four storeys to 24.5m and six storeys; and to reduce the minimum setback from 6m to 0m.
6099-
Centre) Business
Park zones Delete rule 4.5 [maximum tower dimensions and tower separation]
6099-
Centre) Business
Park zones Delete rule 4.6 [Buildings fronting the street]
6099-
Centre) Business
Park zones Delete rule 4.7 [Building entrances]
6099-
Centre) Business
Park zones
Amend rule 4.8 (4) [Minimum floor to floor/ceiling height] to increase minimum ceiling heights
for apartments from 2.55m to 2.7m.
6099-
Centre) Business
Park zones Retain rule 4.9 [Glazing]
6099-
Centre) Business
Park zones Delete rule 4.10 [roller doors]
6099-
Centre) Business
Park zones Delete rule 4.11 [Residential at ground floor]
6099-
Centre) Business
Park zones Delete rule 4.12 [Ground floor at street frontage level]
6099-
Centre) Business
Park zones
Amend rule 4.15 [Yards] so that any building 'tower' must be 3m from the boundary; and to
allow basement and semi based carparking to extend into this yard.
94/1145
Sub#/
6099-
Centre) Business
Special information
requirements
Amend rule 6 [Assessment - Restricted discretionary activities] to be less prescriptive and
more pithy to make the plan more user friendly.
6099-
Centre) Business
Special information
requirements
Amend rule 7 [Assessment - Development control infringements] to be less prescriptive and
more pithy to make the plan more user friendly.
6099-
129 Ockham Holdings Limited mark@ockham.co.nz Natural Hazards and Flooding Flooding H4.12 Rules
Amend Activity table to make new vulnerable activities and associated buildings, including
conversion and/or change of use of an existing building to accommodate a vulnerable activity
a Restricted discretionary activity.
6099-
130 Ockham Holdings Limited mark@ockham.co.nz Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
Amend Table 2 rule 3.2 [Number of parking and loading spaces - Parking rates for City centre
zone] to increase the threshold dwelling size for triggering maximum parking rates from 75m2
to 90m2; to reduce the number of spaces from 0.7 to 0.5 space for dwellings less than 90m2
and from 1.4 to 1.0 space for dwellings greater than 90m2 parking requirements for dwellings;
to increase the threshold floor limits from 1/200m2GFA to 1:250m2 GFA.
6099-
requirements
Amend Table 4 rule 3.2 [Number of parking and loading spaces - Parking rates for all other
areas] to delete reference to the number of bedrooms in relation to dwelling in the Mixed
Housing Suburban zone, Mixed Housing Urban zone and All other areas; and to the change
the parking rates to 1 per dwelling for the Mixed Housing Suburban zone; minimum 1 per
dwelling and maximum 2 per dwelling in the Mixed Housing Urban zone and 1 per dwelling for
All other areas.
6099-
requirements
Amend Table 3 rule 3.2 [Number of parking and loading spaces - Parking rates for sites within
the City Centre Fringe overlay and the Metropolitan, Town, Local Centres, Mixed Use and
Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings zone] to delete reference to the number of
bedrooms in relation to dwelings and apply 1 space per dwelling for all dwellings (not just
studio or one bedroom apartments).
6099-
requirements
Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings zone] to change the parking rate for Offices from 1
per 60m2 to per 100m2 GFA within the City Centre Fringe overlay and from 1 per 30m2 to 1
per 50m2 GFA elsewhere.
6099-
requirements
Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings zone] to change the parking requirements for Retail
by (i) reducing the rate from 1 per 10m2 to 1 per 40m2 GFA for Food and Beverage including
(rather than excluding) Taverns) and (ii) reducing the rate from 1 per 20m2 to 1 per 50m2
GFA for Food and Beverage excluding (rather than including) Taverns.
6099-
135 Ockham Holdings Limited mark@ockham.co.nz General Eplan
Change the online system of planning maps to allow access to full sheet map retrieval and
printing at scale (ie in the same format as they have been produced in hard copy form) .
6100-1
Auckland Regional Public
Health Service jdudley@adhb.govt.nz RPS Issues New Issues
Add new issue - Provide greater consideration of the wider health issues encompassed in
land use planning (e.g car usage and obesity), which are in line with the health related
impacts expressed in the principles of the RMA included in Council policy decision making.
6100-2
Health Service jdudley@adhb.govt.nz RPS Issues New Issues
Advance the the health related strategic aims of the Auckland Plan through the PAUP
including (i) Mori health; (ii) Child injury; (iii) Southern initiative targets - Health and Safety,
Housing; (iv) Physical activity; (v) Environmental goals; (vi) Greenhouse emissions and
human induced climate change; (vii) Increased provision of housing; (viii) Housing
affordability; (ix) Water network; (x) Transport; (xi) Urban design and transport. Refer to
Appendix 7 of the submission for details [pg 125-128/134].
6100-3
Health Service jdudley@adhb.govt.nz RPS Urban growth B2.7 Social infrastructure
Add a specific section on 'Health and Wellbeing' within the overall objectives. Include
reference to: (i) fundamental human 'right to health', as well as a standard of living that
ensures the social determinants of health as expressed in the United Nations Declaration of
Human Rights (UNDHR); (ii) standard of living that ensures the social determinants of health
are encompassed within equal rights expressed within Tiriti o Waitangi; (iii) improve poverty,
minority stress and other social determinants of health; (iv) an overview of communicable
diseases (such as those relating to poverty and climate change); (v) an overview of non-
communicable diseases (such as those relating to urban design, tobacco and alcohol use);
(vi) an overview of Environmental disease - including housing, recreational water access,
hazardous substances; (vii) a specific section on Mori health (viii) holistic frameworks as
used by Mana Whenua be integrated into health impact assessments. Refer to page 25-26,
95/1145
Sub#/
6100-4
Add a ninth objective to RPS to read 'Enabling improved health, wellbeing and safety for all
Aucklanders'.
6100-5
Introduce a system of formalised engagement with the health sector, including Auckland
Regional Public Health Service (ARPHS) and the Ministry of Health on issues of discretion in
areas that effect public health outcomes and to ensure expert guidance on public health
related decision making.
6100-6
Health Service jdudley@adhb.govt.nz RPS General B10 RPS - Methods, Table 1
Auckland Council should join the World Health Organisation (WHO) Alliance for Healthy
Cities.
6100-7
Develop a 'Healthy Cities Action Plan' in close collaboration with Auckland Regional Public
Health Service (ARPHS) and the district health boards in the Auckland region.
6100-8
Develop a Health Impact Assessment (HIA) tool in close collaboration with Auckland Regional
Public Health Service (ARPHS) to assess impacts to health of activities within the PAUP.
6100-9
Health Service jdudley@adhb.govt.nz General Cross plan matters
Review areas in the PAUP where the Council has power to exercise discretion to ensure that
the assessment criteria does not undermine health outcomes.
6100-10
Ensure that reference to national standards and guidelines (e.g disposal of bio solids, coastal
water quality, protection of human sources of drinking water) are routinely referenced and
referred to, even if the Council is proposing a higher standard on some issues due to local
environmental challenges.
6100-11
Health Service jdudley@adhb.govt.nz Definitions New
Add new definition of 'drinking water sources' with reference to the Health Act 1956 as
amended by the Health (Drinking Water) Amendment Act 2007.
6100-12
Health Service jdudley@adhb.govt.nz RPS Natural resources B6.7 Natural hazards
Ensure increased reference to the New Zealand Coastal Policy Statement (NZCPS),
particularly policy 24, with regards to natural hazards to ensure greater consistency.
6100-13
Health Service jdudley@adhb.govt.nz General Editorial and Part 6
Ensure Mori terminology is used consistently throughout the PAUP, to clarify the plan is
referring to Mana Whenua's role, rather than the interests of taurahere Mori or Mataawaka.
6100-14
Health Service jdudley@adhb.govt.nz RPS Mana Whenua
Mtauranga & tikanga Retain section B5.2.
6100-15
Add reference to the Te Whare Tapa Wha and Te Pae Mahutonga frameworks and provide
encouragement to using these models in decision making.
6100-16
Health Service jdudley@adhb.govt.nz Transport Auckland -wide C1.2 Objectives Retain increased emphasis on increasing public transport and walking and cycling.
6100-17
Health Service jdudley@adhb.govt.nz Transport Auckland -wide C1.2 Objectives
Provide a rationale for car parking requirements that balances the environmental impacts,
impacts on human health and the positive impacts of car usage with its policies relating to car
usage.
6100-18
Health Service jdudley@adhb.govt.nz RPS Urban growth
Add 'A phase approach to reducing vehicle dependency' to the objectives, policies and
regulatory methods in the RPS.
6100-19
Health Service jdudley@adhb.govt.nz RPS Natural resources B6.1 Air
6100-20
Health Service jdudley@adhb.govt.nz RPS Coastal B7 Introduction
6100-21
Health Service jdudley@adhb.govt.nz RPS Climate change
6100-22
regulatory methods to the requested ninth objective 'Enabling improved health, wellbeing and
safety for all Aucklanders' in the RPS.
6100-23
Health Service jdudley@adhb.govt.nz RPS
Transport B3.3 Transport Retain the objectives.
6100-24
Standardise 'transportation network' policies and rules e,g public transport, walking and
cycling across urban areas.
6100-25
Recognise that the focus of walking and cycling connections should be at the locality, sub-
district and district levels, as well as at the 'regional and inter-regional level'
6100-26
Transport B3.3 Transport Retain the RPS aims around encouraging pedestrian movement.
6100-27
Reconsider how pedestrians may more easily and safely cross busy highways and access
facilities such as schools, junctions and crossing points for pedestrian on matters of safety,
convenience and the needs of the mobility impaired e.g kerb ramping.
6100-28
Transport B3.3 Transport
Acknowledge that 'transport networks' are key lifelines for communities and are vital for
response and recovery after major hazard events such as earthquakes, as key elements of
the transport network could be viewed as vulnerable or sensitive activities.
96/1145
Sub#/
6100-29
Health Service jdudley@adhb.govt.nz Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
Increase the provision for bicycle parking [3.2,Table 5] and reduce provision for car parking
[3.2,Table 3] in workplaces and other facilities as a means of promoting active transportation.
6100-30
requirements
Increase the provision of 'end of trip' facilities [3.2(3)] such as showering spaces, to
encourage the use of active transport options.
6100-31
requirements Amend the unisex shower provision [3.2(3),Table 6] to provide separate showering facilities.
6100-32
requirements
Delete the use of 'minimum parking requirements' for car parking (with the exception of
disabled and emergency parking etc).
6100-33
requirements
Remove the Gross floor area assessment tool for car parking [3.2], and shift to transportation
planning assessment tools that facilitate Council's high level strategic aims to increase active
and public transport usage, and to create an overall reduction in car dependence.
6100-34
Health Service jdudley@adhb.govt.nz Designations Auckland Council
611 Greenmount Refuse
Disposal Delete the section '2.4 Acceptance of cash in lieu of car parking spaces.'
6100-35
Delete provisions within the PAUP that represent a conflict of interest between Council's role
and the reduction of vehicle dependency in the Auckland region. [Refer to page 11/134 of the
submission.]
6100-36
Transport B3.3 Transport Prioritise cycling and walking, rather than private passenger transport on roads.
6100-37
Health Service jdudley@adhb.govt.nz General Miscellaneous
Operational/
Separate cycle traffic from vehicle transportation paths to protect cyclists from injury and to
encourage cycling.
6100-38
Operational/
Projects/Acquisition Provide dedicated off road cycleways for only bicycles as forms of access to schools.
6100-39
Health Service jdudley@adhb.govt.nz Transport Auckland -wide C1.2 Objectives Incorporate provisions to provide a greater portion of dedicated off road cycle ways.
6100-40
Add a new definition 'Transport network': 'Transportation systems that provide for the
movement of people, goods and service (around and in and out of the region), and includes
the following: (i) road networks from state highways to local roads; (ii) rail networks; (iii)
provision for pedestrians and cyclists; (iv) public transport'.
6100-41
Transport B3.3 Transport Clarify subsets of the transport network in the text of the PAUP e.g freight network.
6100-42
Health Service jdudley@adhb.govt.nz Public Open Space Zones Public Open Space I2.1 Activity table
Include 'community gardens' as a permitted activity in public open space zones with
conditions being met, including not being located on an archaeological or cultural heritage
site, contaminated land or areas adversely affected by industry or transport routes.
6100-43
Operational/
Extend Council plantings in established recreational areas to provide fruit and nut trees to
residents with priority around school areas and educational facilities, near community facilities
and in high deprivation areas (including priority given to Southern Initiative Areas).
6100-44
Health Service jdudley@adhb.govt.nz Public Open Space Zones
desc, obs & pols
Add a new policy to support the establishment of community gardens in public open space
areas (with particular priority given to Southern Initiative areas and other high deprivation and
educational areas).
6100-45
Health Service jdudley@adhb.govt.nz Definitions Existing
Add community gardens as a 'sensitive/vulnerable activity' to discourage them from locating in
areas subject to air and noise quality related issues.
6100-46
Health Service jdudley@adhb.govt.nz Contaminated Land H4.5.1 Activity table
Ensure that establishing community gardens on reserve, residential or other land is a 'change
of use' for the purpose of National Environmental Standard (NES) for soil.
6100-47
Health Service jdudley@adhb.govt.nz
Centre) Business
Increase the number of fresh food markets/grocery stores/supermarkets close to residential
areas (prioritising in high deprivation areas and Southern Initiative Areas) by removing
provisions that restrict access to a variety of supermarkets. (e.g Albany 1 precinct objectives
and policies 'The Albany 1 precinct provides for: One supermarklet of up to 3000m2 GFA', as
well as other similar provisions in the PAUP).
6100-48
Centre)
desc, obs & pols
Reconsider reverse sensitivity matters as a basis for restricting access to supermarkets in the
Heavy Industry zone.
6100-49
Centre) Business
Park zones
Restrict fast food outlets close to schools, parks and low socio-economic areas by (i) setting
minimum distances between schools and fast food outlets; (ii) limiting density of fast food
outlets in any neighbourhood or restrict their proximity to one another; (iii) applying restrictions
to location/hours of operation; with prioritising the above in high deprivation and educational
areas and Southern Initiative Areas.
97/1145
Sub#/
6100-50
Amend rules to control location of new fast food outlets close to schools, parks and low socio-
economic areas through minimum distances, limiting density and restrictions on hours of
operation and location.
6100-51
Auckland Design Manual
(Content)
Include the provision of parenting facilities and in particular best practice design of breast
feeding facilities in the Auckland Design Manual.
6100-52
Centre) Business
Special information
requirements
Provide for breast feeding facilities in new workplaces throughout the PAUP and in particular
be included in assessment criteria.
6100-53
Health Service jdudley@adhb.govt.nz General Miscellaneous Other Include provisions in the PAUP, to facilitate the Auckland Plan smoke free targets.
6100-54
Health Service jdudley@adhb.govt.nz General Miscellaneous Other
Include tobacco reduction targets within the proposed specific health objectives section of the
RPS.
6100-55
Include tobacco reduction [targets - inferred] within a HIA and consenting process to assess
the likely impact of new council policies in order to reduce tobacco use through all areas of
council activity.
6100-56
Include smoking related urban design and reverse sensitivity features to reduce effects of
passive smoking on other vulnerable activities (e.g smoking on balconies in apartments that
wafts into balconies of other residents or in children play areas).
6100-57
Health Service jdudley@adhb.govt.nz General Miscellaneous Consultation and engagement
Ensure on going engagement between the Council and District Health Boards into new ways
to use design features to reduce smoking.
6100-58
Health Service jdudley@adhb.govt.nz RPS Urban growth B2.7 Social infrastructure Retain provisions within the PAUP that reduce alcohol related harms in the community.
6100-59
Health Service jdudley@adhb.govt.nz General Miscellaneous Bylaws and Licensing
Remove any referral to 'no-complaint covenants' within the PAUP, that limits an individual's
ability to lodge submissions to liquor licence applications or renewals to matters subject to the
Sale and supply of Alcohol Act (e.g Albany Centre precinct). Refer to page 57/134 of the
6100-60
Retain control 3.1 [activities within 30m of a residential zone] that makes taverns in Business
zones within 30m of a residential zone being classified as a restricted discretionary activity.
6100-61
Include zoning restrictions to curb alcohol related harms on other types of facilities that sell
alcohol (e.g restrict off-licence facilities, such as bottle stores around tertiary education
centres).
6100-62
Differentiate between off licence premises that have socially beneficial uses (e.g
supermarkets that provide food, and provide an after hours alternative to fast food and
takeaway options), and premises that exist primarily for the sale of alcohol (e.g bottle stores).
Consideration of supermarkets which do not sell alcohol or for limited hours, should also be
noted.
6100-63
Ensure that the PAUP enables and enhances the Local Alcohol Policy (LAP) to achieve a
reduction in alcohol related harm.
6100-64
Centre) Business
General objectives and policies Include restrictions on clusters of alcohol retailing premises.
6100-65
Health Service jdudley@adhb.govt.nz General Miscellaneous Bylaws and Licensing Restrict the sale of psychoactive substances by zoning [inferred].
6100-66
Health Service jdudley@adhb.govt.nz Residential zones Housing affordability
and policies
Retain the aims to improve housing quality and affordability, especially for the vulnerable, high
deprivation and Southern Initiative Areas and Mori and Pacific people.
6100-67
Health Service jdudley@adhb.govt.nz Residential zones Residential
policies
Include provision for culturally appropriate housing for Mori and Pacific people in residential
developments.
6100-68
Health Service jdudley@adhb.govt.nz Sustainable Development C7.7/H6.4 Sustainable design
Retain the use of mandatory Homestar guidelines and other design and quality requirements
that influence human health.
6100-69
Ensure a minimum air temperature of 18 degrees for adults and 21 degrees celsius for
children, the immune-compromised and the elderly for the implementation of the Homestar
insulation requirements.
6100-70
Ensure the implementation of Homestar insulation requirements follow compliance standards
and be independently audited to avoid leaks and and to ensure healthy housing requirements.
6100-71
Health Service jdudley@adhb.govt.nz Sustainable Development C7.7/H6.4 Sustainable design Require the mandatory Homestar guidelines be used for all new housing.
6100-72
Ensure all that new buildings be subject to design in all areas that influence health, wellness
and safety, in order to ensure good design standards.
6100-73
Health Service jdudley@adhb.govt.nz Definitions Existing Retain the definition of 'Retained affordable housing'.
98/1145
Sub#/
6100-74
Amend the definition of 'Retained affordable housing' by resetting the median income
threshold level relevant to all ethnic groups (for the ethnic group with the lowest median
income threshold), in order to provide equitable access to retained affordable housing.
6100-75
Health Service jdudley@adhb.govt.nz Residential zones Housing affordability H6.6 Rules
Extend the provision of retained affordable housing by reducing the requirement for affordable
housing to be provided for only 15 or more dwellings (i.e applies to developments with less
than 15 dwellings or vacant sites) [Rule1.1(1)]
6100-76
policies
Provide more affordable housing by increasing zoning requirements for well designed, mixed
use and higher density housing.
6100-77
Health Service jdudley@adhb.govt.nz Residential zones Residential Land use controls
Review the residential development threshold of 5 or more dwellings, so as not to act as a
perverse incentive to reduce the numbers of possible dwellings being created (due to lower
requirements for smaller developments).
6100-78
requirements
Remove excessive minimum parking requirements (e.g where adequate disabled and
emergency access is available and where adequate transportation or active transport
networks are available) to remove financial barriers to small scale housing developments.
6100-79
environment
Add mandatory design guidelines for housing and other design related aspects of the
Auckland Design Manual that affects health and safety outcomes.
6100-80
(Content) Provide an opportunity to comment on the content of the Auckland Design Manual.
6100-81
Health Service jdudley@adhb.govt.nz Water
Policies 4-9 - Take and use of
water
Review the issue of grey water reuse which should not be encouraged in the Auckland Design
Manual.
6100-82
water
Provide alternative water conservation measures, such as water reducing appliances and
metering options to address water demand related issues.
6100-83
Include a definition of 'grey water' as follows: 'Greywater is wastewater from handbasins,
showers, baths, spa baths, washing machines, laundry tubs, kitchen sinks and dishwashers.
It does not include water from toilets which is called 'blackwater'.
6100-84
Health Service jdudley@adhb.govt.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - Urban zones H5.2 3.1 Residential zones
Ensure mandatory design provisions for safe driveway designs to prevent children being run
over.
6100-85
General
Include mandatory provisions that prevent child driveway run overs, such as fenced off play
areas for children in high density housing developments.
6100-86
Centre) Business
Provide for the clustering of health services i.e general practice, radiology, laboratory and
allied health services wherever possible.
6100-87
Centre) Business
Park zones
Ensure that comprehensive development controls be more broadly applied to ensure well
located healthcare facilities and related social infrastructure.
6100-88
Retain provisions which seek to enhance the accessibility of social infrastructure to be
'sympathetic to the character, both existing and future, of the area and community in which it
is related'.
6100-89
Amend the definition of 'vulnerable activities' to ensure all relevant social infrastructure is
included.
6100-90
Amend the definition of 'sensitive activities' to ensure all relevant social infrastructure is
included.
6100-91
environment
Incorporate urban design requirements for developments that support both health facility
provision and access to those facilities by private and public transport. Refer to page 14/134
6100-92
Target access to social infrastructure for Mori, Pacific and Asian groups. Refer to page
6100-93
Centre) Business
Ensure urban design and zoning provisions enable health services and primary healthcare
facilities to be located within the communities they serve. Refer to page 14/134 of the
6100-94
Purpose)
D8.3/I17 Healthcare facility
zone
Retain objectives and policies and rules relating to secondary and tertiary healthcare facilities,
to enable and support District Health Board efforts to provide outstanding facilities and
services.
6100-95
Reassess the status of building regulations in healthcare zones on the basis of the sensitive
nature of the submitter's activities. Refer to page 15/134 of the submission for details.
6100-96
Health Service jdudley@adhb.govt.nz General Miscellaneous Consultation and engagement
Ensure ongoing collaboration between District Health Boards and Council to ensure the best
possible planning outcomes for tertiary healthcare facilities.
6100-97
Health Service jdudley@adhb.govt.nz Residential zones Residential Activity Table
Amend 'supported residential care services' GFA from 200m
2
to 350m
2
GFA as a permitted
activity [I1.1 Activity table].
6100-98
Amend the activity table classification for 'supported residential care' from a Discretionary and
a Non-complying activity to a Restricted Discretionary activity.
6100-99
Provide a infrastructure capacity overlay, or alternative means of communicating when land
will be adequately serviced for growth.
99/1145
Sub#/
6100-
100
land for urban development Ensure that there is a system to adequately communicate infrastructure constraints.
6100-
101
Require infrastructure capacity to be considered for any new development (not just
subdivisions or developments of five or more dwellings).
6100-
102
Provide more zoning for well designed (smart growth) mixed use and higher density forms of
'brownfields' residential developments over 'greenfields' developments, in peripheral
locations.
6100-
103
Provide for well designed 'brownfields' developments' that are close to amenities and
transport centres.
6100-
104
Increase incentives for 'smart growth' and brownfields' forms of residential development over
single site renewal through council led initiatives such as: (i) Expedited consent processes for
brownfield developments; (ii) Additional height or density controls (where these do not impact
on public health); (iii) Rate credits or grants (e.g reduced rates for well designed/sustainable
developments); (iv) Fee reductions or waivers.
6100-
105
App. 1.1-2 Structure Plan req.
& Metropolitan Urban Area
2010 Retain Appendix 1 Structure plan requirements and Metropolitan Urban Area 2010.
6100-
106
2010
Amend the 'Structure planning' section of Appendix 1 to list and ensure all infrastructure
providers are engaged, such as Ministry of Education, District Health Board etc.
6100-
107
2010
Clarify how urban structure encourages the provision of local social, economic and cultural
facilities.
6100-
108
2010
Clarify what 'level' of centre is established in newly urbanised areas so that there is an
appropriate distribution of metropolitan, town and neighbourhood centres to meet the new
community's needs.
6100-
109
2010
Amend the 'Transport networks' section, so that the street pattern is designed to ensure that
all dwellings and employment locations are within the 500m walk Public Transport Plan target
for access to the public transport network.
6100-
110
2010
Clarify that the structure plan is expected to consider the 'location, scale and capacity...' of
any necessary or desirable infrastructure, in the infrastructure section of Appendix 1.
6100-
111
2010
Involve the appropriate District Health Board planning and funding locality team in the
structure plan process.
6100-
112
2010
Include a summary document setting out the social infrastructure required,a Health Impact
Assessment (HIA) and a high level summary of the discussions that have taken place with
District Health Board planning and funding locality teams, in structure plan requirements.
6100-
113
Clarify the use of the term 'brownfields', so that it is not confused with the term used for
contaminated land.
6100-
114
Health Service jdudley@adhb.govt.nz Infrastructure
C1.1 Infrastructure
policies
Require supporting documents highlighting the potential contamination of greenfield sites for
any new developments, for structure plans.
6100-
115
C1.1 Infrastructure
policies
Introduce dwelling mix rules that limit the proportion of small and large properties in larger
developments.
6100-
116
Ensure the development of 'green space' be allocated a more central position in spatial
planning policy.
6100-
117
recreation facilities Retain and enhance vegetation cover in open spaces.
6100-
118
Ensure adequate access to open space and in particular green open space for Mixed Housing
and Terrace Housing and Apartment Building zones.
6100-
119
recreation facilities Ensure accessible open space to the elderly and disabled.
6100-
120
Provide a mixture of private and communal/public open space to meet the different needs of
the community.
6100-
121
environment
Acknowledge and remediate any health risks associated with intensification within the PAUP.
6100-
122
Health Service jdudley@adhb.govt.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - general
and policies Retain the requirement for assessing the quantity, quality and location of public open space.
100/1145
Sub#/
6100-
123
Provide a clear method for identifying indicative public open space that includes all relevant
public health concerns such as: (i) a range of open space types; (ii) equitable access for all
people, both genders, ethnicities and be free; (iii) vulnerable status of open space (natural
hazards, air quality, traffic and industry); (iv) role of open space as evacuation sites; (v) open
space on contaminated land should be managed and remediated to safe levels.
6100-
124
recreation facilities Include a formula to calculate open space requirements over time.
6100-
125
Health Service jdudley@adhb.govt.nz Contaminated Land
H4.5.2 Controls/H4.5.3 &
H4.5.4 Assessment
Require a management plan (meeting the Ministry for the Environment Contaminated Land
Guideline no.1 reporting requirements) for all new public open space on contaminated land.
6100-
126
Health Service jdudley@adhb.govt.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - general
and policies Clarify the expectations for vesting public open space.
6100-
127
requirements
Provide opportunities to convert some areas previously used for car parking to green space
and open space areas, as part of an overall policy of a phased reduction in car parking.
6100-
128
Provide measures that promote equal access to open recreational space for both men and
women.
6100-
129
Adopt the use of safety considerations (crime prevention through environmental design-
CPTED) within recreational areas, and extend to areas such as the Southern Initiative area.
6100-
130
Ensure equitable access to recreational areas for all people (gender, culture, age, disability
status) through urban design features features and that these considerations be required as
part of the assessment of future open space and recreational areas under the PAUP.
6100-
131
Include assessment criteria for all new developments to ensure that disabled access is
provided, in order to provide universal disabled access, throughout the PAUP.
6100-
132
and policies Clarify how 'other potentially contaminated land' will be identified.
6100-
133
H4.5.4 Assessment
Update the council's register of contaminated land, encourage identification of potentially
contaminated land and make available information on contaminated land.
6100-
134
Health Service jdudley@adhb.govt.nz General
H6.5) Retain the objectives and policies.
6100-
135
Health Service jdudley@adhb.govt.nz General
H6.5) Amend Policy 1(c), so that human waste be added underneath 'Mitigating adverse effects'.
6100-
136
Health Service jdudley@adhb.govt.nz RPS Natural resources B6.1 Air Retain the RPS on air quality (B6.1).
6100-
137
Health Service jdudley@adhb.govt.nz Air Quality
and policies Retain the objectives and policies.
6100-
138
transport separation Retain the objectives and policies.
6100-
139
Industry Transition Retain the objectives and policies.
6100-
140
Sensitive Activity Restriction Retain the objectives and policies.
6100-
141
Health Service jdudley@adhb.govt.nz Air Quality H4.1 Auckland wide rules
General controls
Include 'cooling towers' that do not meet the definition of such systems in the Building Act
2004 in the activity table (H4.1.1.1).
6100-
142
Health Service jdudley@adhb.govt.nz Air Quality H4.1 Auckland wide rules H4.1.4 and H4.15 Assessment
Include air quality criteria that draws on AS/NZ Standard 3666 to addres the potential adverse
effects of discharges into the air (i.e biological/microbial contaminants such as Legionella
bacteria from industrial and manufacturing sites that have a cooling tower/air scrubber which
do not meet the definition of a building under the Building Act 2004).
6100-
143
Ensure that air quality assessment criteria is consistent with Assessment - Restricted
discretionary activities, requiring resource consent for air discharges to demonstrate that any
risk to people and property has been avoided or mitigated.
6100-
144
Amend assessment criteria 5.2(3), so that guidelines for meeting this criteria should draw on
the AS/NZS 3666 which provide guidance on and means for which contaminants can be
avoided via regular testing of such systems, and the development of a control strategy so that
in the event that Legionalla is detected, that the system shall be immediately initiated i.e
disinfection through shock dosing.
6100-
145
General controls
Recognise the potential risk of bio-aerosols of containing human pathogenic bacteria such as
Legionella, from activities.
6100-
146
and policies
Add a policy as per Environment Waikato around the manufacture of compost-related
products, including scientifically-defensible minimum separation distances, critical control
points and active monitoring of the end product for Legionella contamination.
101/1145
Sub#/
6100-
147
Health Service jdudley@adhb.govt.nz Air Quality H4.1 Auckland wide rules Waste processes
Incorporate similar separation distance requirements (as per Environment Waikato
provisions) as they relate to compost making processes.
6100-
148
Health Service jdudley@adhb.govt.nz RPS Natural resources
B6.4 Land- hazardous
substances
Ensure consistent Hazardous Substances and New Organisms (HSNO) policy by reducing
the overlap between territorial functions, HSNO functions and Regional council requirements.
6100-
149
Ensure greater control around the location of hazardous substances with respect to
environmental, human health and water quality risk.
6100-
150
H4.6 - 2 Controls/ 3
Assessment Incorporate Ministry for Environment Hazardous Facilities Screening Procedure.
6100-
151
Define the Hazardous Facilities Screening Procedure with reference to the Health Act 1956 as
amended by the Health (Drinking Water) Amendment Act 2007.
6100-
152
Assessment
Review the proposed threshold method of ensuring that the cumulative effects from a range of
types of hazardous materials are appropriately addressed, particularly with regard to fire and
explosion risk and the risk to human health from spillage, so that it adequately protects the
public and the natural environment from risk.
6100-
153
Assessment
Require separation distances from vulnerable activities and waterways in the permitted
activity standards.
6100-
154
Amend the definition of 'hazardous substances' to include regularly used household items and
building materials such as: (i) Pool treatment chemicals; (ii) Lead based paint, lead sinkers;
(iii) Mercury containing items such as light bulbs, thermometers.
6100-
155
Provide free drop off locations for disposal of hazardous substances (especially household
hazardous substances), particularly in Southern Initiative areas.
6100-
156
Amend the definition of 'Cleanfill material' to match current international best practice and the
image of the world's 'most liveable city'.
6100-
157
Amend the definition of 'Managed fill material' to match current international best practice and
the image of the world's 'most liveable city'.
6100-
158
Amend the definition of 'Landfills' to match current international best practice and the image of
the world's 'most liveable city'.
6100-
159
managed fill
Amend the standards for cleanfill and clarify the standards, such as using the references to
'acceptable' and 'unacceptable wastes' as indicated in section 4 of the Ministry for
Environment guide. [H4.4 Auckland-wide rules]
6100-
160
managed fill
Amend the rules for the management of landfills to better ensure that public health priorities
are met. [H4.4 Auckland-wide rules]
6100-
161
managed fill
Add consistent standards for closed landfills to provide increased assurance that public health
priorities are met.
6100-
162
Rural Discharges,
Biosolids C5.8/H4.7 Biosolids Retain the objective of reusing biosolids as this will reduce landfill requirements [under C5.8].
6100-
163
Rural Discharges,
Biosolids C5.8/H4.7 Biosolids
Amend Objective 1 [under C5.8], to match the higher standard required in policy 1(b) (i.e
'...not pose a threat to public health...')
6100-
164
Rural Discharges,
Ensure monitoring of biosolids to ensure that it is not harmful to human health prior to being
applied onto or into land.
6100-
165
Rural Discharges,
Amend objectives and policies [under C5.8], with respect to monitoring to better protect
human health and reflect national standards and guidelines.
6100-
166
Rural Discharges,
Provide an independent review of the current evidence on health effects from molecular sized
waste particles in biosolids.
6100-
167
Ensure the PAUP provisions is consistent with the climate change mitigation measures
identified in the Auckland Plan.
6100-
168
Add strong policies around the main activities associated with Greenhouse Gas emissions
(including synthetic green house gas emissions) in order to reduce the emissions profile in the
Auckland region.
6100-
169
Health Service jdudley@adhb.govt.nz RPS Climate change Encourage the use of active transport (walking and cycling) as well as public transport.
6100-
170
Reduce overall car independence through policies on the management of parking provisions
and increasing zoning for mixed use and smart growth strategies for better urban design.
102/1145
Sub#/
6100-
171
Reduce agricultural emissions (e.g by aiming to reduce nitrogen related emissions through
changes in agricultural land use activities).
6100-
172
Reduce methane emissions through effective disposal of green waste (e.g through organic
waste disposal and 'zero waste' options).
6100-
173
Health Service jdudley@adhb.govt.nz RPS Climate change Localise food production (e.g through community gardens and fruit tree plantings).
6100-
174
Provide for carbon sequestration activities (e.g converting car parking to green space and
open space).
6100-
175
Health Service jdudley@adhb.govt.nz RPS Climate change Incentivise renewable energy production (e.g incentives for solar panels on housing).
6100-
176
Provide strong requirements and incentives for more efficient and sustainable building
standards.
6100-
177
Add specific projected climate health related effects. Refer to Appendix 4 to the submission
for details on page 115-117/134.
6100-
178
Ensure that a time factor and climate change factor be added to the assessment process (e.g
housing developments on low lying coastal land, where projected sea level rise over the life of
the development has the potential to increase the risk of damage from a future adverse
weather event when that event is combined with other factors such as a high spring tide and
storm surge caused by low barometeric pressure).
6100-
179
Add a new policy to ensure risk to 'vulnerable activities' is appropriately managed by avoiding
location of new vulnerable activities within areas at risk of natural hazards.
6100-
180
Add a new policy of managed retreat from areas subject to flooding risks and that new
developments not be built in these locations.
6100-
181
Health Service jdudley@adhb.govt.nz RPS Issues
change
Clarify the requirement to consider climate change effects to consider (e.g projected increase
in temperature, rainfall and sea level rise).
6100-
182
Add a policy of managed retreat from areas subject to flooding and inundation risks and that
new developments not be built in these locations.
6100-
183
Provide better consistency with New Zealand Coastal Policy Statement (NZCPS) policy 25-27
and RPS.
6100-
184
Align the requirements for flooding and natural hazards, including consistent use of defined
terms (including 'vulnerable activities' or 'sensitive activities'), policies and assessment
criteria.
6100-
185
Health Service jdudley@adhb.govt.nz Natural Hazards and Flooding Natural Hazards H4.11.1 Activity table
Amend the activity status for locating 'vulnerable activities' on land subject to natural hazards
to discretionary or non-complying activity.
6100-
186
Health Service jdudley@adhb.govt.nz Natural Hazards and Flooding Natural Hazards
Assessment
Amend the assessment criteria relate to address both the vulnerability of the activity and the
risk of the hazard.
6100-
187
Assessment
Add clear guidance as to how a 'suitably qualified engineer' should determine whether land is
subject to coastal erosion and inundation, or land stability, over a 100 year timeframe.
6100-
188
G2.7.5 Information
requirements Include requirements for assessments of other relevant hazards (e.g bushfire, liquefaction).
6100-
189
and policies
Ensure a consistent approach is taken to requiring resource consent and assessment of risk
for storage of hazardous substances (above domestic quantities) in all areas subject to
natural hazards.
6100-
190
and policies
Add an up to date register of natural and other hazards to help ensure consistency in decision
making.
6100-
191
and policies
Add data sets and information relating to infrastructure vulnerabilities via standard regional
forums, to encourage information sharing and collaboration for resilience and emergency
planning.
6100-
192
Ensure better consistency between natural hazards and the New Zealand Coastal Policy
Statement (NZCPS), particularly policy 24.
6100-
193
and policies
Ensure better consistency between natural hazards and the New Zealand Coastal Policy
Statement (NZCPS), particularly policy 24.
6100-
194
Redefine 'land which maybe subject to natural hazards' to include all natural hazards, not just
those relating to land instability or the coastal cliffs.
6100-
195
and policies Add more specific requirements on sea level rise considerations,
6100-
196
and policies
Amend the Council natural hazard register to ensure it is comprehensive, research based and
up to date.
6100-
197
and policies Amend to identify potential hazard areas with regard to the 100 year time frame.
6100-
198
'Future proof' the PAUP by including how factors which drive the development of various
overlays (such as use of the average rain index) will change over time (such as through
climate change and sea level rise).
103/1145
Sub#/
6100-
199
Health Service jdudley@adhb.govt.nz RPS Issues
change
Recognise 'urban heat island' effects and that appropriate adaption and mitigation measures
be provided such as (i) increased mandatory insulation; (ii) ventilation and cooling
requirements for dwellings and work places; (iii) inclusion of urban design considerations; (iv)
Increased green space; (v) encouraging the use of light colours and reflective materials for
roofs and pavings to maximise reflectivity; (vi) Adopt the practice of biophilic design; (vii)
Encourage green roof initiatives in urban areas.
6100-
200
Amend 'flood vulnerable infrastructure' within the flood plain, so that it is consistent with the
RPS.
6100-
201
Health Service jdudley@adhb.govt.nz RPS Natural resources B6.7 Natural hazards Retain the risk assessment infrastructure policy in the RPS.
6100-
202
Amend Policy 9 to include: 'a. Undertake a risk assessment based on a 0.2 per cent AEP (i.e
1 in 500 year event) natural hazard event, or an Auckland volcanic field eruption regardless of
return period'
6100-
203
Add access to a safe drinking water supply as well as metropolitan wastewater treatment
plants within the definition of 'lifeline utility'.
6100-
204
Health Service jdudley@adhb.govt.nz Definitions New Add a definition of 'lifeline utility.'
6100-
205
Energy
tables
Amend the infrastructure rules to be consistent with the resilient infrastructure aims within the
RPS.
6100-
206
Health Service jdudley@adhb.govt.nz Natural Hazards and Flooding Flooding H4.12 Rules Amend the flooding rules to be consistent with the resilient infrastructure aims within the RPS.
6100-
207
and policies Retain the approach of retaining natural defence systems for vulnerable areas.
6100-
208
Ensure that activities undertaken to 'replenish' or repair natural defence systems are a
permitted activity.
6100-
209
Ensure that significant infrastructure is provided, or upgraded, in coordination with the
structure and sequencing of growth and development, for example to provide reticulated
drinking water and wastewater before allowing urban development.
6100-
210
Transport
and energy
Add an infrastructure capacity overlay, or an alternative means of communicating when land
will be adequately serviced for growth.
6100-
211
Transport
and energy Add a system where infrastructure constraints are adequately communicated.
6100-
212
Require infrastructure capacity to be considered for any development (not just subdivisions or
developments of five or more dwellings).
6100-
213
Energy
generating facilities Review the appropriateness of treating wastewater networks as permitted activities.
6100-
214
policies
management Add policies regarding the use of tools such as monitoring of freshwater quality.
6100-
215
policies
Objectives
Add an objective to 'avoid where practical, and otherwise reduce, bacterial contamination
waterways', particularly where contact recreation is likely to occur.
6100-
216
policies
ecosystem guidelines App.5.6
Add additional standards into the freshwater policies to specifically address public
health/contact recreation indicators (i.e bacterial contamination and propensity to algal
blooms)
6100-
217
policies
Objectives
Seek to achieve 'Very Good' Suitability for Regional Grade (SFRG) for all fresh waters where
contact recreation is likely to occur.
6100-
218
policies
Objectives
Recognise water quality is improved by the progressive reduction of wastewater-contaminated
discharges, and by investment in infrastructure.
6100-
219
Mtauranga & tikanga
Add clear standards to provide a benchmark against which to assess any additional
contamination (including agricultural run-off), and to ensure that coastal waters outside urban
areas remain unpolluted to allow safe collection of kai moana.
6100-
220
the CMA Mangroves
and policies Add reference to the health related ecosystem services provided by mangroves.
6100-
221
the CMA
Add provisions to temper mangrove removal because of their value in filtration of hazardous
chemical run-off, particularly near motorways, and coastal areas.
104/1145
Sub#/
6100-
222
Health Service jdudley@adhb.govt.nz Definitions New Add a new definition 'ecosystem services'.
6100-
223
the CMA Mangroves
and policies
Acknowledge biosecurity, ecosystem services, health and water quality be treated from a
more holistic perspective, as is endorsed by manawhenua.
6100-
224
Health Service jdudley@adhb.govt.nz Residential zones
D1.3 Rural and coastal
settlement zone desc, obs &
pols
Protect future sites for wastewater plants and reticulated systems in its consideration of un-
serviced villages.
6100-
225
Health Service jdudley@adhb.govt.nz Water Wastewater
Add a compulsory onsite treatment and disposal inspection and certification programme for
areas where the cumulative effects of discharges from these systems are having an impact on
the receiving environment e.g water quality.
6100-
226
water
Amend provisions for domestic and municipal water supply and drinking water requirements
to ensure living beings are given priority e.g drinking water supplies.
6100-
227
B6.3 Freshwater and
Geothermal Water Add a future-focussed approach to protecting water sources and using water sustainably.
6100-
228
Taking, using, damming and
diversion of water and drilling
H4.17.1 Introduction & activity
table
Amend the activity status for prioritising drinking water supply [Inferred-permitted activity
status].
6100-
229
water
Amend the priority for drinking water supply by declining resource consents for water sources
that are close to being over-allocated.
6100-
230
water
Amend the water allocation limits to ensure they are based on the most recent technical
information, and having regard to potential changes in water availability over the lifetime of a
consent-due to climate change and changes in land use.
6100-
231
B6.3 Freshwater and
Geothermal Water
Amend the discharge provisions to protect water sources that meet, or are close to drinking
water quality standards.
6100-
232
B6.3 Freshwater and
Geothermal Water
Acknowledge activities have consequences for water supply quality including regard to their
potential effects on drinking water quality, so that drinking water quality is not compromised.
6100-
233
water
Add assessment of the potential change in water quality over the lifetime of the consent being
sought, for all resource consent applications to take water.
6100-
234
the CMA Discharges I6.1.7 Activity tables Review the permitted activity status of untreated sewage discharges from vessels.
6100-
235
the CMA Discharges I6.1.7 Activity tables
Review the permitted activity status of discharge of contaminants to the coastal marine
environment.
6100-
236
Health Service jdudley@adhb.govt.nz RPS General
review procedures Provide an effective monitoring and enforcement mechanism for coastal water quality.
6100-
237
Provide policies for coastal water quality relating to public health objectives, ecological, and
cultural considerations.
6100-
238
Add recreational water quality standards as an objective for beaches with high recreational
value (e.g Safeswim targets).
6100-
239
Add provisions to sufficiently provide protection against all current and future disease threats
such as vector-borne diseases (e.g dengue fever, Ross River virus).
6100-
240
Acknowledge longer term public health risks. Refer to Appendix 4 on page 115-117/134 of
the submission for climate change related threats associated with biosecurity.
6100-
241
Add provisions that enable activities to respond to a biosecurity threat or risk, so that they
allow an appropriate response to threats to human health to be made.
6100-
242
Cremation and incineration
processes
Reconsider the appropriate matters of discretion for open pyres as a restricted discretionary
activity.
6100-
243
Ensure urban design and zoning provisions [ in the Activity table] enable health services and
primary healthcare facilities to be located within the communities they serve. [Refer to page
14/134 of the submission for details].
6100-
244
and policies
Add a policy of managed retreat from areas subject to inundation risks and that new
developments not be built in these locations. Refer to page 95/134 of the submission for
details.
6100-
245
and policies
Add a policy to "avoid vulnerable activities within areas at risk of natural hazards". Refer to
6100-
246
Reconsider how development location decisions align with the 'reduction' phase of emergency
preparedness (refer Civil Defence Act 2002) of Auckland Civil Defence and Emergency
Management Group (CDEMG) plan 2011-16. Refer to page 96/134 of the submission for
details.
6100-
247
Amend the natural hazard rules to be consistent with the resilient infrastructure aims within
the RPS. Refer to page 101/134 of the submission for details.
6100-
248
Retain the approach of retaining natural defence systems for vulnerable areas. Refer to page
6100-
249
Health Service jdudley@adhb.govt.nz Natural Hazards and Flooding Flooding H4.12 Rules
Ensure that activities undertaken to 'replenish' or repair natural defence systems be a
permitted activity. Refer to page 102/134 of the submission for details.
105/1145
Sub#/
6101-1 Susan Song joseph.zou@envivo.co.nz Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
Retain the development controls relating to maximum parking ratios as they pertain to 2
Northcote Road and 64 Taharoto Road, Takapuna [inferred]. Refer to page 5/16 of the
6101-2 Susan Song joseph.zou@envivo.co.nz
Centre)
obs & pols
Retain the zone description in relation to location and the flexibility of building heights as
it pertains to 2 Northcote Road and 64 Taharoto Road, Takapuna [inferred]. Refer to pages 5-
6101-3 Susan Song joseph.zou@envivo.co.nz Zoning North and Islands Retain the Mixed Use zone for 2 Northcote Road and 64 Taharoto Road, Takapuna.
6102-1 Catherine Cullington sprotgirl10@hotmail.com
Centre) Business
& Bus. Park zones
Add the 'retailing of psychoactive substances within 100m of kindergartens, early childcare
centres, schools, places or worship, medical facilities or other community facilities and 50m
from a bus stop / railway station' as a Discretionary activity for the Centres, Mixed Use,
General Business and Business Park zones.
6103-1
Retirement Villages
Association john@retirementvillages.org.nz RPS Issues
growth
Amend 'Unitary Plan issue' to read '...quality of life and wellbeing for individuals of all ages
and communities...' (refer to page 15/101 of submission for details).
6103-2
Retirement Villages
growth
Amend 'Our sense of place' to reflect the range of accommodation and care options required
for an ageing population (refer to page 15/101 of submission for details).
6103-3
Retirement Villages
growth
Amend 'Social Well-being' to reflect the range of accommodation and care options required
6103-4
Retirement Villages
Association john@retirementvillages.org.nz RPS Urban growth
Add new objective to read '5. To recognise and provide for the various accommodation and
care needs of the elderly'.
6103-5
Retirement Villages
Amend Policy 2 to read '2. Enable higher residential densities and the efficient use of land in
neighbourhoods: a. within and around centres and within moderate walking distances from the
city, metropolitan, town and local centres b. in areas close to the frequent public transport
routes and facilities c. in close proximity to existing or proposed large open spaces,
community facilities, education and healthcare facilities d. adequately serviced by existing
physical infrastructure or where infrastructure can be efficiently upgraded e. to provide for the
accommodation and care needs of the elderly.
6103-6
Retirement Villages
Amend 'Explanation and reasons' to reflect the range of accommodation and care options
required for an ageing population (refer to page 20/101 of submission for details).
6103-7
Retirement Villages
environment
Amend Policy 8 to read '8. Enable the development of a range of built forms within
neighbourhoods to support maximum choice and recognise different demographic needs
and lifestyles'.
6103-8
Retirement Villages
environment
Amend Policy 11 to read '11. Require large scale developme nt, and e Encourage all other
development, to minimise its environmental impact through best practice sustainable design
which incorporates energy efficiency, renewable energy generation, waste minimisation and
water sensitive design.'
6103-9
Retirement Villages
Association john@retirementvillages.org.nz Water
streams & wetland
table Amend activity table so that works in intermittent streams are a permitted activity.
6103-10
Retirement Villages
streams & wetland
C5.14 Background &
Objectives
Amend objectives and policies to reflect a change to works in intermittent streams being a
permitted activity.
6103-11
Retirement Villages
streams & wetland
C5.14 Background &
Objectives
Identify intermittent streams of importance and provide specific rules for these streams
through a plan change.
6103-12
Retirement Villages
Association john@retirementvillages.org.nz Definitions Existing
Amend the definition of 'River or stream' to account for permanent streams only and remove
the reference to 'intermittently flowing body of fresh water'.
6103-13
Retirement Villages
Association john@retirementvillages.org.nz Water Stormwater
H4.14.2 Stormwater
management -flow rules Delete the introduction to '2. Stormwater Management - Flow'.
6103-14
Retirement Villages
H4.14.2 Stormwater
Amend Activity Table 2.1 so that 'Impervious areas (other than for a public road) of less than
or equal to 25m2 1000m2 in a SMAF 1 or 2' are a permitted activity.
6103-15
Retirement Villages
rules
Amend rule 3.2.2.1 (Controlled activities) to include the term 'uncovered parking' (refer to
page 27/101 of submission for details).
6103-16
Retirement Villages
H4.14.2 Stormwater
Add activity to Activity Table 2.1 (Within or discharging to a Stormwater Management Area -
Flow (SMAF) 1 or 2) making impervious areas where the discharge point of the nearest
stormwater network is to the tidal environment a permitted activity.
6103-17
Retirement Villages
H4.14.2 Stormwater
Flow (SMAF) 1 or 2) making impervious areas located on allotments contained within
subdivisions where the stormwater reticulation discharges to Wetlands, ponds or other
appropriately designed devices a permitted activity.
6103-18
Retirement Villages
Remove the Stormwater Management Area (Flow) overlay where the catchment discharges
directly to the tidal environment.
6103-19
Retirement Villages
Remove the Stormwater Management Area (Flow) overlay where diversion and discharge
consents exist for developments at the date of notification of the PAUP.
106/1145
Sub#/
6103-20
Retirement Villages
Association john@retirementvillages.org.nz Residential zones Residential
policies
Amend introduction to Residential zones to provide for retirement villages in all residential
zones (refer to page 30/101 of submission for details).
6103-21
Retirement Villages
policies
Amend Objective 2 to read 'A diverse range of housing provides choice for households
people and communities to meet their varied needs and lifestyles.
6103-22
Retirement Villages
policies
Add policy that reads '3. Recognise that the population of Auckland is aging and that
accommodation and care for the elderly is a critical need across all residential zones.'
6103-23
Retirement Villages
policies
Amend Policy 6 to read 'Enable retirement villages and non-residential activities that provide
benefits to local communities and which will have minimal acceptable adverse effects on the
amenityies values of the residential area.'
6103-24
Retirement Villages
Association john@retirementvillages.org.nz Residential zones
D1.2 Large Lot zone desc, obs
& pols
Amend zone description to read '...Retirement villages are contemplated at a greater height
and density than would otherwise apply in the zone. Such facilities can be designed to
integrate with the surrounding neighbourhoods, and will provide for the on-going social
wellbeing of aged residents living in these areas.'
6103-25
Retirement Villages
& pols
Add objective that reads '4. Retirement villages make efficient use of land to provide a range
of accommodation options and accessory services for older people and those requiring
care/assisted living.'
6103-26
Retirement Villages
& pols
Add policy that reads '3. Enable the development of retirement villages at a greater height and
density than would otherwise apply in the zone while ensuring any adverse effects on
infrastructure and neighbouring sites are managed.'
6103-27
Retirement Villages
pols
6103-28
Retirement Villages
pols
Amend Objective 3 to read '3. Development is of a density that is appropriate for the the
physical and environmental attributes of the site and any infrastructure constraints'.
6103-29
Retirement Villages
pols
Add a new objective that reads '4. Retirement villages make efficient use of land to provide a
range of accommodation options and accessory services for older people and those requiring
6103-30
Retirement Villages
pols
Add a new policy that reads '5. Enable the development of retirement villages at a greater
height and density than would otherwise apply in the zone while ensuring any adverse effects
on infrastructure and neighbouring sites are managed.'
6103-31
Retirement Villages
D1.4 Single House zone desc,
obs & pols
6103-32
Retirement Villages
obs & pols
Amend Objective 1 to read '1. Development is generally of a height, bulk and form that
maintains and positively responds to the site and the neighbourhoods low density suburban
residential character.'
6103-33
Retirement Villages
obs & pols
6103-34
Retirement Villages
obs & pols
Amend Policy 1 to read 'Manage the height, bulk, form and appearance of development and
require sufficient setbacks, landscaped areas and open space to maintain the generally low
density suburban residential character of one to two storey, detached dwellings within a
generally spacious setting.'
6103-35
Retirement Villages
obs & pols
6103-36
Retirement Villages
D1.5 Mixed Housing Suburban
zone desc, obs & pols
Amend zone description '...Retirement villages are contemplated at a greater height and
density than would otherwise apply in the zone. Such facilities can be designed to integrate
with the surrounding neighbourhoods, and will provide for the on-going social wellbeing of
aged residents living in these areas.'
6103-37
Retirement Villages
Amend Objective 2 to read '2. Development is generally of a height, bulk, form and
appearance that positively responds to the site and the neighbourhood's planned suburban
residential character, engaging with and addressing the street.'
6103-38
Retirement Villages
6103-39
Retirement Villages
density than would otherwise apply in the zone whole ensuring any adverse effects on
107/1145
Sub#/
6103-40
Retirement Villages
D1.6 Mixed Housing Urban
6103-41
Retirement Villages
6103-42
Retirement Villages
height and density than would otherwise apply in the zone while ensuring and adverse effects
6103-43
Retirement Villages
pols
6103-44
Retirement Villages
pols
Add a new objective that reads '6. Retirement villages make efficient use of land to provide
a range of accommodation options and accessory services for older people and those
requiring care/assisted living.'
6103-45
Retirement Villages
pols
6103-46
Retirement Villages
Association john@retirementvillages.org.nz Residential zones Residential Activity Table Amend activity table to read 'Retirement Villages - landuse'.
6103-47
Retirement Villages
Association john@retirementvillages.org.nz Residential zones Residential Activity Table
Amend the 'Retirement Villages - landuse' activity status from Non-complying to Permitted in
the Large Lot zone.
6103-48
Retirement Villages
the Rural and Coastal Settlement zone.
6103-49
Retirement Villages
Amend the 'Retirement Villages - landuse' activity status from Discretionary to Permitted in
the Single House zone.
6103-50
Retirement Villages
the Mixed Housing Suburban zone.
6103-51
Retirement Villages
the Mixed Housing Urban zone.
6103-52
Retirement Villages
Amend the 'Retirement Villages - landuse' activity from Discretionary to Permitted in the
6103-53
Retirement Villages
Association john@retirementvillages.org.nz Residential zones Residential Activity Table Amend activity to read 'Retirement Villages - development and operations'.
6103-54
Retirement Villages
Amend the 'Retirement Villages - development and operations' activity status from Non-
complying to Restricted Discretionary in the Large Lot zone.
6103-55
Retirement Villages
complying to Restricted Discretionary in the Rural and Coastal Settlement zone.
6103-56
Retirement Villages
Amend the 'Retirement Villages - development and operations' activity status from
Discretionary to Restricted Discretionary in the Single House zone.
6103-57
Retirement Villages
Discretionary to Restricted Discretionary in the Mixed Housing Suburban zone.
6103-58
Retirement Villages
Discretionary to Restricted Discretionary in the Mixed Housing Urban zone.
6103-59
Retirement Villages
Discretionary to Restricted Discretionary in the Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings
zone.
6103-60
Retirement Villages
Association john@retirementvillages.org.nz Residential zones Residential Activity Table Add new activity 'Retirement Villages - additions, alterations and demolition'.
6103-61
Retirement Villages
Add 'Retirement Villages - additions, alterations and demolition' as a Permitted activity in the
Large Lot zone.
6103-62
Retirement Villages
Rural and Coastal Settlement zone.
6103-63
Retirement Villages
Single House zone.
6103-64
Retirement Villages
6103-65
Retirement Villages
6103-66
Retirement Villages
108/1145
Sub#/
6103-67
Retirement Villages
Amend activity to read 'Supported residential care and Boarding houses up to 200m2 GFA
per site'.
6103-68
Retirement Villages
Amend activity to read 'Supported residential care and Boarding houses not provided for
above'.
6103-69
Retirement Villages
Add clause under the activity table for Retirement Villages - development and operation and
Retirement Villages - additions, alterations and demolition that reads '* These activities are
permitted where the comply with the building height, yards, height in relation to boundary, and
maximum impervious area rules for the relevant zone where the activity takes place.'
6103-70
Retirement Villages
General
Add new section '10. Development Controls - Retirement Villages' with accompanying text
that reads 'This Section contains all relevant development controls and other relevant rules
that applv to Retirement Villages located in any residential zone, Metropolitan and Town
Centre Zone, General Business zone, Business Park zone and Countryside Living zone.'
6103-71
Retirement Villages
General
Add new rule under proposed section '10. Development Controls - Retirement Villages' - '10.1
Carparking and access' with accompanying text that reads 'Any development controls for the
zone in which the activity is located.'
6103-72
Retirement Villages
General
Height in relation to boundary' with accompanying text that reads 'Any relevant height in
relation to boundary for the zone in which the activity is located.'
6103-73
Retirement Villages
General
Yards' with accompanying text that reads 'Any relevant yard controls for the zone in which the
activity is located.'
6103-74
Retirement Villages
General
Traffic generation' with accompanying text that reads 'Any relevant traffic generation controls
for the zone in which the activity is located.'
6103-75
Retirement Villages
General
Noise' with accompanying text that reads 'Any relevant noise controls for the zone in which
the activity is located.'
6103-76
Retirement Villages
General
Height' with accompanying text that reads 'Any relevant height controls for the zone in which
6103-77
Retirement Villages
General
Other relevant rules' with accompanying text that reads 'a) Auckland Wide rules in Chapter H.
excluding sections 6.4 and 6.6 b) The Overlay Rules in Chapter J c) The development
controls In any precinct plan in Chapter K apply where they are more permissive or
enabling d) The development controls contained In Sections 4 - 9, or any other part of the
Plan, do not apply unless those controls are more permissive or enabling.'
6103-78
Retirement Villages
General
Development control and other relevant rule infringements' with accompanying text that reads
'A Retirement Village activity including any addition. alteration or demolition that infringes a
development control or other relevant rule in this section is a restricted discretionary activity.'
6103-79
Retirement Villages
Special info. req. Amend to read '110 . Assessment - Restricted discretionary activities'.
6103-80
Retirement Villages
Special info. req. Amend to read '110 .1 Matters of discretion'.
6103-81
Retirement Villages
Special info. req.
Amend matters of discretion to read 'The council will restrict its discretion to the matters below
for the activities listed as restricted discretionary in the zone activity table or where otherwise
specified as restricted discretionary.'
6103-82
Retirement Villages
Special info. req.
Add new matters of discretion relating to retirement villages (refer to pages 84 and 85/101 of
submission for details).
6103-83
Retirement Villages
Association john@retirementvillages.org.nz
control
Apply only to those buildings which have proven heritage value, or else delete the overlay in
its entirety.
6103-84
Retirement Villages
Association john@retirementvillages.org.nz Mana Whenua
Whenua
Refine the extent of the sites and places of significance to accurately reflect the feature or
area of significance or else delete the overlay in its entirety.
6103-85
Retirement Villages
Whenua
whenua
Remove overlay from sites and places of significance that no longer exist as a result of
previously earthworked land.
6103-86
Retirement Villages
Whenua
whenua
Remove overlay from sites and places of significance that have existing resource consents for
land use disturbance (and/or Historic Places Act authorities) providing for ground disturbance.
109/1145
Sub#/
6103-87
Retirement Villages
Whenua
whenua
Remove overlay from sites and places of significance that have neighbouring properties
where the archaeological site in question is located off the site that is influenced by the
hatching.
6103-88
Retirement Villages
Whenua
Amend the diameter of the circle identifying Sites and Places of Value to Mana Whenua to
50m.
6103-89
Retirement Villages
Association john@retirementvillages.org.nz Mana Whenua General provisions
assessment Amend so that a Cultural Impact Assessment is a discretion, not a requirement.
6103-90
Retirement Villages
Association john@retirementvillages.org.nz Mana Whenua General provisions
6103-91
Retirement Villages
Association john@retirementvillages.org.nz Historic Heritage (Overlay)
Heritage
Places
Refine the extent of the overlay to accurately reflect the extent of place or else delete the
overlay in its entirety.
6103-92
Retirement Villages
Amend the definition of 'Retirement villages' to read 'A comprehensive residential
development used to provide accommodation for aged people, including: a retirement village
as defined in s.6 of the Retirement Villages Act 2003; recreation, leisure, welfare and medical
facilities (inclusive of hospital care and supported residential care) and other non-residential
activities accessory to the retirement village.
6103-93
Retirement Villages
Amend the definition of 'Supported residential care' to read 'Facilities used to provide
accommodation and full time care for aged or disabled people. The facility must be certified
under the Health and Disability Services (Safety) Act 2001 and comply with the Health and
Disability Sector Standards 2001. Includes: a rest home defined in s.58(4) of the Health and
Disability Services (Safety) Act 2001 accessory nursing and medical care. Excludes:
hospitals; retirement villages .'
6104-1 Bernard A Parker parkerb@xtra.co.nz Trees
Trees J6.4 Rules
Amend so an application for the removal of trees or groups of trees that are on the notable
tree schedule 'a non discretionary activity' [inferred to make the removal of trees more
difficult].
6104-2 Bernard A Parker parkerb@xtra.co.nz Trees
Trees J6.4 Rules
Amend so any application for the removal of trees or groups of trees that are on the Notable
Tree schedule is publicly notified.
6105-1 Johns Creek Holdings Limited brian@metroplanning.co.nz Zoning North and Islands
Rezone Lots 3 and 4 DP 336198 on Jack Hawken Lane, Silverdale from General Business to
Mixed Housing Urban. Refer to the maps on pages 4-5/5 of the submission for exact sites.
6105-2 Johns Creek Holdings Limited brian@metroplanning.co.nz Precincts - North Silverdale North
Remove Lots 3 and 4 DP 336198 on Jack Hawken Lane, Silverdale from the precinct. Refer
to the maps on pages 4-5/5 of the submission for exact sites.
6105-3 Johns Creek Holdings Limited brian@metroplanning.co.nz Transport
Overlay E1.5/J1.5 High land
transport noise J1.5 Rules and mapping
Remove Lots 3 and 4 DP 336198 on Jack Hawken Lane, Silverdale from the overlay. Refer to
the maps on pages 4-5/5 of the submission for exact sites.
6105-4 Johns Creek Holdings Limited brian@metroplanning.co.nz
SEAs
Land
Reduce the extent of the overlay from Lots 3 and 4 DP 336198 on Jack Hawken Lane,
Silverdale. Refer to the map on page 4/5 of the submission for the extent of the overlay.
6106-1 Ryman Healthcare Limited luke.hinchey@chapmantripp.com RPS Issues
growth
Amend 'Unitary Plan issue' to read '...quality of life and wellbeing for individuals of all
ages and communities...' (refer to page 15/101 of submission for details).
growth
Amend 'Our sense of place' to reflect the range of accommodation and care options required
growth
Amend 'Social Well-being' to reflect the range of accommodation and care options required
6106-4 Ryman Healthcare Limited luke.hinchey@chapmantripp.com RPS Urban growth
Add new objective to read '5. To recognise and provide for the various accommodation and
care needs of the elderly'.
Amend Policy 2 to read '2. Enable higher residential densities and the efficient use of land in
neighbourhoods: a. within and around centres and within moderate walking distances from the
city, metropolitan, town and local centres b. in areas close to the frequent public transport
routes and facilities c. in close proximity to existing or proposed large open spaces,
community facilities, education and healthcare facilities d. adequately serviced by existing
physical infrastructure or where infrastructure can be efficiently upgraded e. to provide for the
accommodation and care needs of the elderly.
required for an ageing population (refer to page 20/101 of submission for details).
environment
Amend Policy 8 to read '8. Enable the development of a range of built forms within
neighbourhoods to support maximum choice and recognise different demographic needs and
lifestyles'.
environment
Amend Policy 11 to read '11. Require large scale developme nt, and e Encourage all other
which incorporates energy efficiency, renewable energy generation, waste minimisation and
water sensitive design.'
110/1145
Sub#/
6106-9 Ryman Healthcare Limited luke.hinchey@chapmantripp.com Water
streams & wetland
table Amend activity table so that works in intermittent streams are a permitted activity.
streams & wetland
C5.14 Background &
Objectives
Amend objectives and policies to reflect a change to works in intermittent streams being a
permitted activity.
streams & wetland
C5.14 Background &
Objectives
Identify intermittent streams of importance and provide specific rules for these streams
6106-12 Ryman Healthcare Limited luke.hinchey@chapmantripp.com Definitions Existing
Amend the definition of 'River or stream' to account for permanent streams only and remove
the reference to 'intermittently flowing body of fresh water'.
6106-13 Ryman Healthcare Limited luke.hinchey@chapmantripp.com Water Stormwater
H4.14.2 Stormwater
management -flow rules Delete the introduction to '2. Stormwater Management - Flow'.
H4.14.2 Stormwater
Amend Activity Table 2.1 so that 'Impervious areas (other than for a public road) of less than
or equal to 25m2 1000m2 in a SMAF 1 or 2' are a permitted activity.
rules
Amend rule 3.2.2.1 (Controlled activities) to include the term 'uncovered parking' (refer to
page 27/101 of submission for details).
H4.14.2 Stormwater
Flow (SMAF) 1 or 2) making impervious areas where the discharge point of the nearest
stormwater network is to the tidal environment a permitted activity.
H4.14.2 Stormwater
Flow (SMAF) 1 or 2) making impervious areas located on allotments contained within
subdivisions where the stormwater reticulation discharges to Wetlands, ponds or other
appropriately designed devices a permitted activity.
Remove the Stormwater Management Area (Flow) overlay where the catchment discharges
directly to the tidal environment.
Remove the Stormwater Management Area (Flow) overlay where diversion and discharge
consents exist for developments at the date of notification of the PAUP.
6106-20 Ryman Healthcare Limited luke.hinchey@chapmantripp.com Residential zones Residential
policies
Amend introduction to Residential zones to provide for retirement villages in all residential
zones (refer to page 30/101 of submission for details).
policies
Amend Objective 2 of the general objectives and policies for the residential zones to read 'A
diverse range of housing provides choice for households people and communities to meet
their varied needs and lifestyles.
policies
Add policy that reads '3. Recognise that the population of Auckland is aging and that
accommodation and care for the elderly is a critical needs across al residential zones.'
policies
Amend Policy 6 to read 'Enable retirement villages and non-residential activities that provide
benefits to local communities and which will have minimal acceptable adverse effects on the
amenityies values of the residential area.'
6106-24 Ryman Healthcare Limited luke.hinchey@chapmantripp.com Residential zones
& pols
& pols
& pols
pols
pols
Amend Objective 3 to read '3. Development is of a density that is appropriate for the the
physical and environmental attributes of the site and any infrastructure constraints'.
pols
pols
111/1145
Sub#/
obs & pols
obs & pols
Amend Objective 1 to read '1. Development is generally of a height, bulk and form that
maintains and positively responds to the site and the neighbourhoods low density suburban
residential character.'
obs & pols
obs & pols
require sufficient setbacks, landscaped areas and open space to maintain the generally low
density suburban residential character of one to two storey, detached dwellings within a
generally spacious setting.'
obs & pols
Amend zone description '...Retirement villages are contemplated at a greater height and
density than would otherwise apply in the zone. Such facilities can be designed to integrate
with the surrounding neighbourhoods, and will provide for the on-going social wellbeing of
aged residents living in these areas.'
Amend Objective 2 of the Mixed Housing Suburban zone to read '2. Development is
generally of a height, bulk, form and appearance that positively responds to the site and the
neighbourhood's planned suburban residential character, engaging with and addressing the
street.'
density than would otherwise apply in the zone whole ensuring any adverse effects on
density than would otherwise apply in the zone while ensuring and adverse effects on
pols
pols
Add objective that reads '6. Retirement villages make efficient use of land to provide
a range of accommodation options and accessory services for older people and those
requiring care/assisted living.'
pols
Add policy that reads '12. Enable the development of retirement villages at a greater height
and density than would otherwise apply in the zone while ensuring any adverse effects on
6106-46 Ryman Healthcare Limited luke.hinchey@chapmantripp.com Residential zones Residential Activity Table Amend activity to read 'Retirement Villages - landuse'.
6106-47 Ryman Healthcare Limited luke.hinchey@chapmantripp.com Residential zones Residential Activity Table
the Large Lot zone.
the Single House zone.
Amend the 'Retirement Villages - landuse' activity from Discretionary to Permitted in the
the Mixed Housing Urban zone.
the Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings zone.
112/1145
Sub#/
6106-53 Ryman Healthcare Limited luke.hinchey@chapmantripp.com Residential zones Residential Activity Table Amend activity to read 'Retirement Villages - development and operations'.
complying to Restricted Discretionary in the Large Lot zone.
complying to Restricted Discretionary in the Rural and Coastal Settlement zone.
Discretionary to Restricted Discretionary in the Single House zone.
Discretionary to Restricted Discretionary in the Mixed Housing Suburban zone.
Discretionary to Restricted Discretionary in the Mixed Housing Urban zone.
Discretionary to Restricted Discretionary in the Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings
zone.
6106-60 Ryman Healthcare Limited luke.hinchey@chapmantripp.com Residential zones Residential Activity Table Add new activity 'Retirement Villages - additions, alterations and demolition'.
Large Lot zone.
Rural and Coastal Settlement zone.
Single House zone.
Amend activity to read 'Supported residential care and Boarding houses up to 200m2 GFA
per site'.
Amend activity to read 'Supported residential care and Boarding houses not provided for
above'.
Add clause under the activity table for Retirement Villages - Development and operation and
Retirement Villages - Alteration, additions and demolition, that reads 'These activities are
permitted where the comply with the building height, yards, height in relation to boundary, and
maximum impervious area rules for the relevant zone where the activity takes place.'
General
Add new section '10. Development Controls - Retirement Villages' with accompanying text
that reads 'This Section contains all relevant development controls and other relevant rules
that applv to Retirement Villages located in any residential zone, Metropolitan and Town
Centre Zone, General Business zone, Business Park zone and Countryside Living zone.'
General
Carparking and access' with accompanying text that reads 'Any development controls for the
zone in which the activity is located.'
General
Height in relation to boundary' with accompanying text that reads 'Any relevant height in
relation to boundary for the zone in which the activity is located.'
General
Yards' with accompanying text that reads 'Any relevant yard controls for the zone in which the
activity is located.'
General
Traffic generation' with accompanying text that reads 'Any relevant traffic generation controls
for the zone in which the activity is located.'
General
Noise' with accompanying text that reads 'Any relevant noise controls for the zone in which
General
Height' with accompanying text that reads 'Any relevant height controls for the zone in which
113/1145
Sub#/
General
Other relevant rules' with accompanying text that reads 'a) Auckland Wide rules in Chapter H.
excluding sections 6.4 and 6.6 b) The Overlay Rules in Chapter J c) The development
controls In any precinct plan in Chapter K apply where they are more permissive or
enabling d) The development controls contained In Sections 4 - 9, or any other part of the
Plan, do not apply unless those controls are more permissive or enabling.'
General
Development control and other relevant rule infringements' with accompanying text that reads
'A Retirement Village activity including any addition. alteration or demolition that infringes a
development control or other relevant rule in this section is a restricted discretionary activity.'
Special info. req. Amend to read '110 . Assessment - Restricted discretionary activities'.
Special info. req. Amend to read '110 .1 Matters of discretion'.
Special info. req.
Amend matters of discretion to read 'The council will restrict its discretion to the matters below
for the activities listed as restricted discretionary in the zone activity table or where otherwise
specified as restricted discretionary.'
Special info. req.
Add new matters of discretion relating to retirement villages (refer to pages 84 and 85/101 of
6106-83 Ryman Healthcare Limited luke.hinchey@chapmantripp.com
control
Apply only to those buildings which have proven heritage value, or else delete the overlay in
its entirety.
6106-84 Ryman Healthcare Limited luke.hinchey@chapmantripp.com Mana Whenua
Whenua
whenua
Whenua
whenua
Remove overlay from sites and places of significance that no longer exist as a result of
previously earthworked land.
Whenua
whenua
Whenua
whenua
Remove overlay from sites and places of significance that have neighbouring properties
where the archaeological site in question is located off the site that is influenced by the
hatching.
Whenua
Amend the diameter of the circle identifying Sites and Places of Value to Mana Whenua to
50m.
6106-89 Ryman Healthcare Limited luke.hinchey@chapmantripp.com Mana Whenua General provisions
6106-90 Ryman Healthcare Limited luke.hinchey@chapmantripp.com Mana Whenua General provisions
6106-91 Ryman Healthcare Limited luke.hinchey@chapmantripp.com Historic Heritage (Overlay)
Heritage
Places
Refine the extent of the overlay to accurately reflect the extent of place or else delete the
overlay in its entirety.
Amend the definition of 'Retirement villages' to read 'A comprehensive residential
as defined in s.6 of the Retirement Villages Act 2003; recreation, leisure, welfare and medical
facilities (inclusive of hospital care and supported residential care) and other non-residential
activities accessory to the retirement village.
Amend the definition of 'Supported residential care' to read 'Facilities used to provide
accommodation and full time care for aged or disabled people. The facility must be certified
under the Health and Disability Services (Safety) Act 2001 and comply with the Health and
Disability Sector Standards 2001. Includes: a rest home defined in s.58(4) of the Health and
Disability Services (Safety) Act 2001 accessory nursing and medical care. Excludes:
hospitals; retirement villages .'
obs & pols
Amend Objective 2 to read '2. Development is generally of a height, bulk, form and
appearance that positively responds to the site and the neighbourhood's planned suburban
residential character, engaging with and addressing the street.'
Whenua
114/1145
Sub#/
Whenua
6107-1 Jennifer Neel jenny@hiko.co.nz Mana Whenua General provisions
assessment Delete the requirement to obtain a cultural impact assessment [inferred].
6107-2 Jennifer Neel jenny@hiko.co.nz General Miscellaneous Consultation and engagement
Council to hold a referendum asking 'whether the general population of Auckland agree that
the governance of our physical and natural resources be shared in partnership with Mana
Whenua'.
6108-1 Auckland Transport
peter.clark@aucklandtransport.govt.
nz Designations Auckland Transport
R1405 Public off-street parking
- 8 Percy Street Delete R1405 from the PAUP.
1452 Road Widening - Te
Atatu South Road Amend the lapse date from fifteen to five years (in the full text table and Condition 1).
nz Designations Auckland Transport 1453 Road Widening - Titirangi
Amend the maps to be consistent with the description in the operative District Plan (Waitakere
Section) as follows: northern side: from Great North Road to Lot 1 DP 41916, southern side:
from Great North Road to Lot 1 DP 68428, 5m from existing road boundary.
R1559 Car Park - Graham
Street
Amend the extent of the designation to exclude private properties, by applying a three
dimensional envelope to ensure that only the public parking space is designated.
nz Designations Auckland Transport R1803 Road - Mahia Road Delete R1803 from the PAUP.
nz General Chapter A Introduction A3 Strategic Framework Retain the overall direction set by the PAUP for delivering the Auckland Plan.
6109-1
Ministry for Culture and
Heritage edward.siddle@mch.govt.nz Mana Whenua General provisions
discovery protocol
Replace protocols for the discovery of Kiwi Tangata [human
remains], archaeological features or deposits, and taonga with the suggested protocols on
pages 3-5/5 of submission. Prepare protocols in consultation with the Ministry for Culture and
Heritage.
6110-1 Mahi Maioro Professionals k.morgan@auckland.ac.nz RPS Mana Whenua B5 Strategic
Strengthen empowerment of Mana Whenua in decision making and resource management
further.
6110-2 Mahi Maioro Professionals k.morgan@auckland.ac.nz Mana Whenua General provisions
assessment
Add processes for cultural impact analysis that are holistic and acknowledged by
Manawhenua.
6110-3 Mahi Maioro Professionals k.morgan@auckland.ac.nz RPS Mana Whenua
participation
Retain acknowledgement of Mana Whenua their ancestrally derived interests in the wise
management of resources and their responsibilities as kaitiaki embodies in the ethic of
kaitiakitanga.
6110-4 Mahi Maioro Professionals k.morgan@auckland.ac.nz RPS Mana Whenua B5 Strategic Retain acknowledgement of the different perspectives held by Mana Whenua.
6110-5 Mahi Maioro Professionals k.morgan@auckland.ac.nz RPS Mana Whenua B5 Strategic
Incorporate reference to "Mauri", providing recognition of important metaphysical
considerations not otherwise included in the conventional impact assessment and monitoring.
6111-1 Community Waitakere simon@communitywaitakere.org.nz
SEAs
Land Add Henderson Creek Project Twin Streams area.
6112-1 Kevin Twiggins kevintwiggins@yahoo.com General Chapter G General provisions
Unify the Land Resource and Building Consent requirements throughout the greater Auckland
area with special recognition of unique areas
6112-2 Kevin Twiggins kevintwiggins@yahoo.com RPS Urban growth
Provide for some higher density residential development, in appropriate areas, to
accommodate growth
6112-3 Kevin Twiggins kevintwiggins@yahoo.com Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula
Correct the total area for the Devonport Peninsula Precinct - stated as 24.9 ha, however the
correct area is 29.5 ha based on a sum of all the individual sub-precinct areas
6112-4 Kevin Twiggins kevintwiggins@yahoo.com Zoning North and Islands
Rezone all land within the Devonport Precinct from Mixed Housing Suburban to Single House
except sub-precinct E
Require any future development of the former Navy housing sites to include a traffic impact
study and be based on capacity of existing infrastructure including roads and sewers
6112-6 Kevin Twiggins kevintwiggins@yahoo.com Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula K5.11 Precinct rules
Amend the rules in the Devonport Peninsula Precinct to align with the Unitary Plan rules and
objectives outlined in the Submission page 4/5
Delete the Precinct and require any zone changes to involve analysis of the issues and input
from the neighbourhood and community
6113-1
Community Housing Aotearoa
and Te Matapihi and The
Auckland Community Housing
Providers' Network director@communityhousing.org.nz RPS Issues
growth
Retain PAUP vision to house all Aucklanders in secure, health homes they can
afford...improving housing affordability and supply of affordable housing.
6113-2
growth
Retain Issue 1.1 Enabling quality urban growth, as shown in the submission [refer to page
5/18].
115/1145
Sub#/
6113-3
growth
Retain the identification that housing affordability can influence peoples quality of life and
social well-being and that affordable housing is a basic human need.
6113-4
growth
Retain the underlying premise of the PAUP being the Auckland Plan's Strategic Direction 11
which seeks to house all Aucklanders in secure, healthy homes they can afford.
6113-5
growth Retain recognition that Aucklands housing affordability as an issue of regional significance.
6113-6
Providers' Network director@communityhousing.org.nz General Miscellaneous Special housing areas Retain the Auckland Housing Accord as an interim measure to address housing affordability.
6113-7
Providers' Network director@communityhousing.org.nz RPS Urban growth
retain affordable housing
Retain the on-going pursuit of a wide range of housing options that provide affordable, stable
and suitable housing for all Aucklanders.
6113-8
Providers' Network director@communityhousing.org.nz General Miscellaneous Special housing areas
Add a mechanism to monitor the outcomes of Special Housing Areas over the next three
years to provide appropriate case studies and guidance on best practice to be used in the
Auckland Design Manual.
6113-9
environment
Amend the PAUP to make explicit rather than implicit references to place-making
a community development approaches which embodies the concept of well-planned and
sustainable communities.
6113-10
Providers' Network director@communityhousing.org.nz General Chapter A Introduction
tools
Retain 4.2 Area Based Planning Tools including that the mandatory structure plans ensure
that affordable housing provision can be planned from the outset and that Framework plans
are useful for brownfield development which may not require a plan change.
6113-11
Providers' Network director@communityhousing.org.nz General Chapter G General provisions
G2.6 Framework plans &
G2.7.3 Framework plans
Add more detailed criteria and a requirement for mandatory rather than voluntary Framework
Plans to ensure a broad pattern for greenfield and brownfield sites is achieved and that there
is consistent adoption of 10% affordable housing within each development.
6113-12
Providers' Network director@communityhousing.org.nz General Chapter A Introduction
tools
Clarify whether structure plans are required when land is rezoned from one urban use to
another.
6113-13
quality compact urban form Retain 2.1 Providing for quality growth in a compact form.
6113-14
Recognise concern over the emphasis on where intensification is to occur rather than
specifically dealing with housing affordability.
6113-15
Recognise the emphasis on affordable housing in areas close to the RUB, in satellite towns
and rural and coastal town is contradicting the PAUPs strategic objective for social well-being.
Affordable housing should be well connected and located close to significant employment
nodes within the urban area.
6113-16
Providers' Network director@communityhousing.org.nz RPS Urban growth B2.7 Social infrastructure
Clarify how infrastructure, particularly community infrastructure, will be adequately provided
for in new developments in light on proposed law changes which will rein in development
levies
6113-17
Retain 2.3 Development capacity and supply of land for urban development with reference
made to Policy 5.
6113-18
Providers' Network director@communityhousing.org.nz Definitions New Add a new definition for 'A well-planned, quality community'.
116/1145
Sub#/
6113-19
Providers' Network director@communityhousing.org.nz Definitions New Add a new definition for 'Placemaking and other tools for engaging communities'.
6113-20
retain affordable housing Retain 2.4 Neighbourhoods that retain affordable housing.
6113-21
Retain provisions which seek well-planned mixed tenure communities that will meet the needs
of current and future low to moderate income households.
6113-22
Retain the objectives and policies that seek to improve the affordability of dwellings for
households on low to moderate incomes.
6113-23
Retain a focus on the intermediate housing market to complement the government provision
of social housing.
6113-24
retain affordable housing Retain the high level approach that supports inclusionary zoning requirements.
6113-25
Recognise that affordable housing provisions may not be supported in other parts of PAUP. In
particular the density provision may exclude housing types that affordable housing
organisations seek to deliver.
6113-26
Providers' Network director@communityhousing.org.nz Residential zones Housing affordability
and policies
Retain 7.8 Affordable housing including objectives and policies which seek the provision of
retained affordable housing.
6113-27
and policies Retain provisions for retaining affordable housing established through a resource consent.
6113-28
and policies
Retain an approach which retains affordable housing through a separate body such as a
community housing provider.
6113-29
Providers' Network director@communityhousing.org.nz Residential zones Residential
General Add universal design provisions for all new housing, including all affordable housing.
6113-30
Providers' Network director@communityhousing.org.nz Sustainable Development C7.7/H6.4 Sustainable design Add Homestar [inferred] provisions for all new housing including affordable housing.
6113-31
and policies
Amend Policy 2 to remove the word 'similar' and include specific criteria to ensure affordable
housing has consistent minimum space standards and finishes.
6113-32
G2.7.3 Framework plans Recognise the need to retain affordable housing within the Framework Plan provisions.
6113-33
and policies Add a cross reference to the affordable housing definition and criteria across the plan.
6113-34
Recognise that the the voluntary nature of framework plans may be used by developers as a
way to circumvent the need for retained affordable housing.
117/1145
Sub#/
6113-35
Add the location, size and the number of retained affordable housing units in each
development within the framework plan requirements.
6113-36
Providers' Network director@communityhousing.org.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - general
controls
Recognise the location and numbers of retained affordable housing within the development
controls.
6113-37
controls
Retain the linkage of subdivision back to the overarching plan because it changes the activity
status to discretionary where it is not consistent with a previously approved plan.
6113-38
controls Add a specific reference to retained affordable housing.
6113-39
controls
Add the location, size and the number of retained affordable housing units in each
development within the Framework, Structure, Precinct and Concept plans.
6113-40
controls Add a cross reference to the affordable housing definition and criteria.
6113-41
Providers' Network director@communityhousing.org.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - general H5.3 - 4 Assessment
Add retained affordable housing to the assessment criteria tables (Table 13 and Table 14)
and ensure sufficient and consistent referencing to retained affordable housing.
6113-42
G2.7.1 Gen. info. req. H5.5
Spec. info. req. Add references to retained affordable housing into rule 5.5 Special Information Requirements.
6113-43
Providers' Network director@communityhousing.org.nz Sustainable Development C7.7/H6.4 Sustainable design Retain rule 6.4. and amend to apply to all affordable housing.
6113-44
Providers' Network director@communityhousing.org.nz Residential zones Housing affordability H6.6 Rules Retain rule 6.6 Affordable housing.
6113-45
and policies
Recognise opportunities where there is a benefit to the development for doing more
affordable or social housing.
6113-46
Providers' Network director@communityhousing.org.nz Residential zones Housing affordability H6.6 Rules
Clarify in Rule 1.1 [Number of retained affordable dwellings] the specific areas that are
required to provide retained affordable housing in the proportions specified.
6113-47
Amend rule 1.1 [Number of retained affordable dwellings] to read: 10 % of total dwellings
within a development (as identified within a structure of framework plan) are to be retained as
affordable housing. Their location and size should be identified within the plan.
6113-48
Add to rule 1.1 [Number of retained affordable dwellings] a threshold which states that if a
development includes a significant proportion of affordable housing then it is not required to
meet the retain affordable housing requirement.
6113-49
and policies Retain the philosophy of providing mixed tenure communities wherever possible.
6113-50
and policies
Recognise concerns that including a proviso that development that are solely
providing social housing will not have to meet the retained affordable housing rules will result
in one tenure communities.
118/1145
Sub#/
6113-51
Amend rule 2.1 [Matters of discretion] to specify a proportion of retained affordable housing
within a development rather than specifying a number.
6113-52
Amend rule 1.2 [Location of retained affordable housing] to recognise the need for market
value properties, retained affordable housing and social housing to be identified and
dispersed throughout a development.
6113-53
and policies
Recognise emphasis should be on providing well-planned development that meets identified
need through a range of retained affordable housing types and sizes. This could involve the
introduction of a threshold for 'net internal floor area'.
6113-54
Add reference to the design of affordable housing. To ensure there is no difference in the
external design of an affordable house and a market rate house. Specific reference should be
made to external materials and finishes.
6113-55
Amend rule 1.3 [Securing retained affordable housing] to specifically identify a legally
enforceable retention mechanism.
6113-56
Retain rule 1.4 [Eligibility for retained affordable housing] and introduce ongoing consultation
to refine and adjust the criteria.
6113-57
Amend section 2.1 Matters for Discretion and 2.2 Assessment Criteria to include retention and
eligibility if infringements are to be assessed as a restricted discretionary activity.
6113-58
Clarify the position on the provision of retained affordable housing off-site and amend
assessment criteria to include the size, type, mix and design of retain affordable housing.
6113-59
Add the ability to exercise discretion in the provision of land rather than houses may be used
to meet the retain affordable housing requirements.
6113-60
Clarify whether a development could provide retained affordable housing without the need for
a resource consent and therefore circumvent the special information requirement for an
affordable housing assessment.
6113-61
Amend rule 6.3 to apply the special information requirements to 'all development and
subdivisions of 15 or more dwellings/vacant sites' and the information requirements might be
best located in the relevant residential, business and subdivision sections.
6113-62
Providers' Network director@communityhousing.org.nz Residential zones Residential
General Retain rules 6.12, 7.22, 8.24 and 9.23, Universal Access.
6113-63
Providers' Network director@communityhousing.org.nz General Miscellaneous
(Content)
Add case studies and best practice guidelines of Universal Acces/Design within the Auckland
Design Manual.
6113-64
Providers' Network director@communityhousing.org.nz Definitions Existing
Clarify within the definition of Retained Affordable Housing, how the 80-120 per cent band is
to be determined.
6113-65
Amend the definition of Retained Affordable Housing to review the lower banding at 80 per
cent according to the needs of specific communities in Auckland. Lower the band to 60-80 per
cent or 40-60 per cent for areas where local demand requires greater affordability.
6113-66
Amend the definition of Retained Affordable Housing to target more frequent transport and
reflect the PAUP definition of 'Rapid and Frequent Service Network'.
119/1145
Sub#/
6113-67
Recognise that point 4 in the definition of Retained Affordable Housing could potentially result
in small apartments offered at an affordable price that may exceed market rate prices.
6113-68
Amend rule 6.6 Affordable Housing, to address concern with the definition of Retained
Affordable Housing as shown in the submission [refer to page 16/18] to enable a spread of
residential units at different price points.
6113-69
Remove point 2 of the definition of Retained Affordable Housing and put into a development
control.
6113-70
2010
Retain in Appendix 1.1 the consideration of retained affordable housing into the planning
process for greenfield land in the Future Urban Zone and in brownfield locations where
structure plans are used.
6114-1 Tane Pratt tane_kiwi@yahoo.com Zoning North and Islands Rezone 39 Verbena Road, Birkdale from Single House to Mixed Housing Suburban.
6114-2 Tane Pratt tane_kiwi@yahoo.com
SEAs
Land Retain SEA at 39 Verbena Road, Birkdale.
6115-1 Vaitaua Mauala vmauala@hotmail.com RPS Urban growth
quality compact urban form Retain 70 per cent of growth within city limits.
6115-2 Vaitaua Mauala vmauala@hotmail.com Future Urban
objectives and policies Amend the provisions staging [the release] of the Future Urban zone.
6115-3 Vaitaua Mauala vmauala@hotmail.com Sustainable Development C7.7/H6.4 Sustainable design Amend Homestar rating provisions to apply to all new houses.
6115-4 Vaitaua Mauala vmauala@hotmail.com Sustainable Development C7.7/H6.4 Sustainable design Amend Greenstar provisions to apply to all new commercial buildings.
environment
Amend provisions to ensure all developments are subject to a design review, with strong
6115-6 Vaitaua Mauala vmauala@hotmail.com Residential zones Residential Land use controls Retain rule 3.3 The conversion of a dwelling into two dwellings.
quality compact urban form Expand the area of Mixed Housing Urban zoned land, especially near the city centre.
Seeks further upzoning around transport nodes, such as City Rail Link stations, rail stations
and high frequency bus routes.
6115-9 Vaitaua Mauala vmauala@hotmail.com Transport Auckland -wide
requirements Remove minimum parking requirements from all areas.
6116-1 Barry Coates barrycoatesnz@yahoo.com RPS Urban growth
Seeks further upzoning around transport nodes, such as rail stations and high frequency bus
routes.
quality compact urban form Retain 70 per cent of growth within city limits.
6116-3 Barry Coates barrycoatesnz@yahoo.com Future Urban
objectives and policies Amend the provisions staging [the release] of the Future Urban zone.
6116-4 Barry Coates barrycoatesnz@yahoo.com Sustainable Development C7.7/H6.4 Sustainable design Amend Homestar rating provisions to apply to all new houses.
6116-5 Barry Coates barrycoatesnz@yahoo.com Sustainable Development C7.7/H6.4 Sustainable design Amend Greenstar provisions to apply to all new commercial buildings.
environment
Amend provisions to ensure all developments are subject to a design review, with strong
6116-7 Barry Coates barrycoatesnz@yahoo.com Residential zones Residential Land use controls Retain conversion of a dwelling into two dwellings provisions.
quality compact urban form Expand the area of Mixed Housing Urban zoned land, especially near the city centre.
6116-9 Barry Coates barrycoatesnz@yahoo.com Transport Auckland -wide
requirements Remove minimum parking requirements from all areas.
6117-1
Vallejo Trust and Sonoma 81
Trust skiing_phil@hotmail.com RPS Mana Whenua B5 Strategic
Remove the specific rights, obligations, objectives, policies and rules included throughout the
PAUP in favour of Mana Whenua
6117-2
Trust skiing_phil@hotmail.com Mana Whenua
Whenua
and policies Remove Mana Whenua's ability to provide control over sites of Significance or Value
6117-3
Trust skiing_phil@hotmail.com RPS Mana Whenua
Fig. 1
Recognise the NZ Historic Places Trust as the approving authority with regard to Sites of
Significance or Value.
6117-4
Whenua
and policies
Amend the Sites of Significance or Value to those already recorded within existing Council
Heritage Schedules
120/1145
Sub#/
6117-5
Trust skiing_phil@hotmail.com RPS Mana Whenua B5 Strategic
Request that the Council conduct a referendum of its ratepayers to determine a) the status of
the Independent Mori Statutory Board (IMSB) b) that any rights provided to the IMSB or
Mana Whenua be subject to full democratic process, c) that the IMSB be self funded and not
receive any further grants from Auckland Ratepayers due to an abuse of the PAUP process.
6117-6
Trust skiing_phil@hotmail.com General Chapter A Introduction A1 Background
Delete the last two paragraphs of 1.2 (Mana Whenua) and replace with 'Unitary Plan is to be
limited to fulfilling its requirements only as required under the Treaty of Waitangi settlements
and the Resource Management Act.'
6117-7
Trust skiing_phil@hotmail.com General Chapter A Introduction A2 Statutory Framework
Delete the last paragraph of 2.2 (Treaty of Waitangi) and replace with 'Auckland Council are
required to notify Mana Whenua of any application for Resource Consent on any scheduled
Site of Significance or Value (as determined by NZ Historic Places Trust), as an affected
party.'
6117-8
Trust skiing_phil@hotmail.com RPS
Add the following to Policy 4.1.2(c) [identification and protection - Mana Whenua] 'as
approved by application to the NZHPT and as fully Publicly Notified as part of a Private Plan
Change for inclusion of any site as Specified Site Schedule in accordance with the Historic
Places Act 1993.'
6117-9
Trust skiing_phil@hotmail.com RPS Issues
Delete 5 Addressing issues of significance to Mana Whenua - Nga take matua a nga Ahika-
roa mai i tawhiti in entirety and add 'Any site which Mana Whenua consider a site of
Significance or Value shall be subject to an application to the NZHPT and as fully Publically
Notified as part of a Private Plan Change for inclusion of any site as Specified Site on the
Council register by that Iwi. Any site which is currently contained with an Operative District
Plan Schedule shall be included within the Unitary Plan Schedule and Overlays.'
6117-10
Trust skiing_phil@hotmail.com RPS Urban growth
6117-11
Trust skiing_phil@hotmail.com General Chapter G General provisions
statements Delete 2.7.1.4(k) ensure only sites currently included in existing Operative Plans are included
6117-12
Trust skiing_phil@hotmail.com General Chapter G General provisions
statements
Amend 2.7.1.4(k) as follows 'location of any known sites or areas of significance to Mana
Whenua that are on council records, in the Unitary Plan or on the NZHPT records, or that are
made known to the applicant during any consultation process which may have been
undertaken
6117-13
Trust skiing_phil@hotmail.com General Miscellaneous Other Delete clauses 5.2, 5.3, and 5.4 from G. 3.2 [reference unknown]
6117-14
Whenua J5.1 Rules Delete 5.1 [Sites and Places of Significance to Mana Whenua] entirely
6117-15
Whenua J5.2 Rules Delete 5.2 'Sites and Places of Value to Mana Whenua'.
6117-16
Trust skiing_phil@hotmail.com Mana Whenua Auckland wide - Mori Land
controls Delete 2.1.2.1 [Notification] entirely.
6117-17
settlement land
rules/App. 4.3 legislation Delete 2.2.2.1 [Notification] entirely.
6117-18
Whenua
whenua
Value shall be subject to an application to the NZHPT and as fully Publicly Notified as part of
a Private Plan Change for inclusion of any site as Specified Site on the Council register by
that Iwi. Any site which is currently contained with an Operative District Plan Schedule shall
be included within the Unitary Plan Schedule and Overlays.'.
6117-19
Whenua
6117-20
Trust skiing_phil@hotmail.com Definitions Existing
Delete the 2nd and 3rd paragraphs from the definition of 'Mana Whenua Cultural Heritage'
and replace with 'Any site which Mana Whenua consider a site of Significance or Value shall
be subject to an application to the NZHPT and as fully Publicly Notified as part of a Private
site which is currently contained with an Operative District Plan Schedule shall be included
within the Unitary Plan Schedule and Overlays.'
121/1145
Sub#/
6117-21
Trust skiing_phil@hotmail.com Definitions Existing
NZHPT and as fully Publicly Notified as part of a Private Plan Change for inclusion of any site
as Specified Site on the Council register by that Iwi. Any site which is currently contained with
an Operative District Plan Schedule shall be included within the Unitary Plan Schedule and
Overlays.'
6118-1 Landsford Properties Limited pc@businessrealty.co.nz Zoning West Rezone Lansford Crescent, Avondale from Light Industry to Mixed Use.
6119-1 Robert H Taylor creativep@xtra.co.nz RPS Mana Whenua B5 Strategic Reject the requirement for Mori to be consulted.
6119-2 Robert H Taylor creativep@xtra.co.nz Residential zones Residential
General
Delete the height limit of 1.2m in rule 7.15 Fences. [Relief sought is unclear, a replacement
height is not provided].
6119-3 Robert H Taylor creativep@xtra.co.nz Zoning North and Islands Rezone 248 Red Hills Road, Taupaki, from Mixed Rural to Countryside Living.
6120-1
Auckland Gliding Club
Incorporated david-zero@vodafone.co.nz Zoning South
Seeks same zoning as adjacent property. Submitter is a Gliding club and requires a rural
zoning to carry out operations without reserve sensitivity effects, however recognises the
need for development and therefore if zoning changes on adjacent sites, the same zone
should be applied to 264 Appleby Road, Drury.
6121-1 Dingzhi J Huang p.comer@harrisongrierson.com General Cross plan matters
Amend Objectives and Policies contained in Part 2 C, in particular 1.1 Infrastructure, 1.2
Transport, 5 Natural Resources, 5.2 Earthworks, 5.12 Natural Hazards, 5.13 Flooding, 5.15
Water, 6 Subdivision, and 7 General, to be simplified and made less prescriptive in nature to
reflect the higher level role of policies and allow increased flexibility is design responses and
future proofing.
6121-2 Dingzhi J Huang p.comer@harrisongrierson.com Future Urban
Simplify Objectives and Policies to make them less prescriptive in nature to reflect the higher
level role of policies and allow increased flexibility is design responses and future proofing.
6121-3 Dingzhi J Huang p.comer@harrisongrierson.com Zoning North and Islands
Rezone Silverdale to the west of the northern motorway from Future Urban to appropriate
Single House, Mixed Housing and Terraced and Apartment Housing zones.
6121-4 Dingzhi J Huang p.comer@harrisongrierson.com Subdivision Auckland-wide - Rural zones
area
Delete the Built Environment: Additional Subdivisions Controls - South Rodney Countryside
Living 2ha Overlay from the land to the west of the Northern Motorway at Silverdale.
6121-5 Dingzhi J Huang p.comer@harrisongrierson.com Zoning North and Islands
Rezone Postman Road, Dairy Flat (Lot 2 DP 338426) from Futrue Urban to an appropriate
Residential zone
6121-6 Dingzhi J Huang p.comer@harrisongrierson.com Subdivision Auckland-wide - Rural zones
area
Delete the Built Environment: Additional Subdivisions Controls - South Rodney Countryside
Living 2ha Overlay from the land at Lot 2 DP 338426, Postman Road, Dairy Flat
6121-7 Dingzhi J Huang p.comer@harrisongrierson.com Subdivision Auckland-wide - Urban zones
except Rural
Amend Activity Table 3 so that subdivision not otherwise provided for in the Future Urban
zone is at worst, a Discretionary Activity
except Rural
Amend Activity Table 3 so that the rules associated with the Built Environment: Additional
Subdivisions Controls - South Rodney Countryside Living 2ha Overlay do not apply to the
land at Lot 2 DP 338426, Postman Road, Dairy Flat
except Rural
Amend Activity table 5.1 to provide for a wider range of urban activities to establish in the
Future Urban zone, including residential, commercial and other activities appropriate within an
urban area.
6121-10 Dingzhi J Huang p.comer@harrisongrierson.com Residential zones Housing affordability H6.6 Rules Delete the affordable housing provisions
6122-1 James Taylor taylorjs@slingshot.co.nz Mana Whenua General provisions
assessment
Delete the requirement to obtain a Cultural Impact Assessment for carrying out work on 'Sites
and places of Value to Mana Whenua' [G2.7.4 'Cultural Impact assessment'].
6123-1 Brian and Sheryll Titford
205 Upper Waiwera Road, RD1,
Silverdale, Auckland 0994 RPS Changes to the RUB North and Waiheke Island Retain RUB along the ridgeline of Upper Orewa Road, Wainui
Silverdale, Auckland 0994 RPS Changes to the RUB North and Waiheke Island Amend the RUB to follow the motorway corridor at Upper Orewa Road, Wainui.
Silverdale, Auckland 0994 Rural Zones
desc, obs & pols Retain Rural Production zone.
Silverdale, Auckland 0994 Rural Zones General I13.3 Development controls
Amend to clarify how waste disposal and composting areas are managed on smaller sites,
such as lifestyle blocks.
Silverdale, Auckland 0994
SEAs
H4.3 Significant Ecological
Areas - Land rules (all) Amend forestry SEA provision (5m from a SEA) to apply to future developments, not existing.
Silverdale, Auckland 0994 RPS
character and natural heritage B4.3.4 Biodiversity Amend to provisions to provide compensation for maintenance of SEA's.
Silverdale, Auckland 0994 General Miscellaneous Other Acknowledge Upper Wairewa as a distinct area, not Waitoki or Puhoi.
6124-1 Linda I Fox linda.fox@carsonfox.co.nz RPS Mana Whenua B5 Strategic
PAUP in favour of Mana Whenua.
6124-2 Linda I Fox linda.fox@carsonfox.co.nz Mana Whenua
Whenua
122/1145
Sub#/
6124-3 Linda I Fox linda.fox@carsonfox.co.nz RPS Mana Whenua B5 Strategic
Recognise the NZ Historic Places Trust as the approving authority with regard to Sites of
Whenua
and policies
Heritage Schedules
6124-5 Linda I Fox linda.fox@carsonfox.co.nz General Miscellaneous Consultation and engagement
6124-6 Linda I Fox linda.fox@carsonfox.co.nz General Chapter A Introduction A1 Background
Delete the last two paragraphs of 1.2 (Mana Whenua) and replace with 'Unitary Plan is to be
6124-7 Linda I Fox linda.fox@carsonfox.co.nz General Chapter A Introduction A2 Statutory Framework
party.'
6124-8 Linda I Fox linda.fox@carsonfox.co.nz RPS
Places Act 1993
6124-9 Linda I Fox linda.fox@carsonfox.co.nz RPS Issues
6124-10 Linda I Fox linda.fox@carsonfox.co.nz RPS Urban growth
environment Delete B.2.2
6124-11 Linda I Fox linda.fox@carsonfox.co.nz Mana Whenua General provisions
assessment Delete 2.7.1.4(k) ensure only sites currently included in existing Operative Plans are included
6124-12 Linda I Fox linda.fox@carsonfox.co.nz General Chapter G General provisions
statements
undertaken
6124-13 Linda I Fox linda.fox@carsonfox.co.nz General Miscellaneous Other Delete clauses 5.2, 5.3, and 5.4 from G. 3.2 [reference unknown]
Whenua J5.2 Rules Delete 5.2 'Sites and Places of Value to Mana Whenua' entirely.
6124-16 Linda I Fox linda.fox@carsonfox.co.nz Mana Whenua Auckland wide - Mori Land
settlement land
Whenua
whenua
Whenua
6124-20 Linda I Fox linda.fox@carsonfox.co.nz Definitions Existing
123/1145
Sub#/
6124-21 Linda I Fox linda.fox@carsonfox.co.nz Definitions Existing
Overlays.'
6125-1 Global Outlook Limited maxd@andrewstewart.co.nz Historic Heritage (Overlay)
Heritage
Places Delete the Historic Heritage overlay from 13 Albert Street, City Centre.
Heritage
Places Delete the Historic Heritage overlay from 9 Wolfe Street, City Centre.
Heritage
places
Amend to make the demolition of 13 Albert Street, City Centre a Restricted Discretionary
activity.
Heritage
places Amend to make the demolition of 9 Wolfe Street, City Centre a Controlled activity.
6126-1 Susan and Donald McDonald vmcdonald@gmail.com Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
Amend to include the use of the road classifications contained in the Auckland Council District
Plan (Isthmus Section), through identification on the PAUP maps (identify Selwyn Road,
Epsom as a 'local road') and reference to an Auckland Transport document. [As alternate
relief to including the classifications directly in the PAUP. The name of a specific Auckland
Transport document is not provided.]
requirements
Amend to include the use of the road classifications contained in the Auckland Council District
Plan (Isthmus Section), Strategic, regional arterial, secondary, collector and local roads and
service lanes. Identify all of the classifications on the planning maps and in particular, identify
Selwyn Road, Epsom as a 'local road'.
requirements
Include provisions [an overlay] to restrict heavy vehicles from using routes through residential
areas and include this as a notation on Selwyn Road, Epsom.
6127-1 Kent Baigent peter@trippandrews.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - Rural zones
zones only
Amend Table 5 so that subdivision for public open space, reserves, network utilities or road
realignment is a Controlled activity not Discretionary.
zones only
Amend Table 5 so that subdivision provided for in the rural subdivision rules is Restricted
Discretionary not Discretionary.
zones only Amend Table 5 so that other subdivision is Non Complying not Prohibited.
area
Amend rule 1 'Specified Building Area' to replace (a) with 'Council "may" impose a specific
building area which must be clearly identified on a scheme plan of subdivision.' to replace
(c)(i) with 'the specified buildings area must be at least 2000m2 and be clear of all yards and
1% AEP floodplain.', remove (c) (ii), retain (c) (iii), amend (c) (iv) to refer to dwellings only, and
amend (d) to replace Non-complying activity with Discretionary activity for subdivisions which
do not comply with this control.
area
Amend rule 2 'Protection and enhancement of ecological values' to reorder the points, ensure
that features are identified on a scheme plan not a subdivision plan, remove riparian strip
margins, identify features worthy of protection, define terms such as 'valuable natural feature',
be more clear and precise about land owners responsibilities particularly around Mana
Whenua issues and make subdivision that does not comply with this rule a Discretionary
rather than Non-Complying activity. (see pages 5-8/23 of Vol 1 of the submission for details)
area
Amend rule 3 'Transferable rural site subdivision: explanation of terms and process' to remove
or rewrite Table 5 to use the correct terminology around titles and consider consented sites.
area
Amend rule 4 'Transferable rural site subdivision: Controls for transferable rural site
subdivision through amalgamation of donor sites' to remove the blanket exclusion for road
severances, provide for the 4000m2-1 hectare lots created under the Auckland District Plan
Franklin section, remove the need for donor sites to be recorded on the Council Valuation
Roll, remove the need for an encumbrance, correct inconsistency within Table 6, delete
references to RSEA, reduce minimum net site area from 2 hectares to 4000m2 and balance
lots form 4 hectares to 1 hectare, remove requirement that receiver sites not cover elite or
prime soils and correct terminology regarding Land Transfer Plans, (see pages 8-13/23 of Vol
1 of the submission for details)
124/1145
Sub#/
area
Amend rule 5 'Transferable rural site subdivision: Controls for transferable rural site
subdivision through legal protection of an SEA' to clarify the riparian buffer around wetlands,
what a 'threatened ecosystem' is, that the protection should be of the feature not the site and
remove the limitation on SEA transferable titles to Countryside Living zone and villages only,
(see page 14/23 of Vol 1 of the submission for details)
area
Amend rule 7 'Boundary adjustments and boundary relocations' to recognize the need to
adjust rural lot boundaries, (see pages 15-16/23 of Vol 1 of the submission for details).
area
Amend rule 8 'Subdivision in the Countryside Living zone' to remove all averaging criteria and
remove the specified building areas in the Countryside Living zone (see page 17/23 of Vol 1
of the submission for details)
area
Amend rule 9 'Minimum site area in the Mixed Rural and Rural Production Zones' to provide
for an alternative subdivision method in the Mixed Use zone, remove the 150 hectare
minimum site area requirement and replace the Prohibited activity status with Non-complying
(see page 18/23 of Vol 1 of the submission for details)
area Delete Appendix 12.1, Receiver Site Exclusion Area.
6127-13 Kent Baigent peter@trippandrews.co.nz Rural Zones General I13.2 Land use controls
Add new rule for subdivision of existing large scale and/or economically viable intensive rural
activity using text from Plan Change 14 to the Auckland District Plan Franklin section (see
page 19/23 of Vol 1 of the submission for details).
6127-14 Kent Baigent peter@trippandrews.co.nz Definitions Existing
Combine the definitions of Boundary Adjustment and Boundary Relocation (see pages 19-
20/23 of Vol 1 of the submission for details)
6127-15 Kent Baigent peter@trippandrews.co.nz Definitions Existing
Amend the definition of Site to replace the words 'survey plan' with 'scheme plan' and delete 1
(b).
6127-16 Kent Baigent peter@trippandrews.co.nz Rural Zones General I13.2 Land use controls
Amend rule 2.6 'Dwellings' to remove the Valuation Roll requirement, change the net site area
from 2 hectares to 1 hectare and introduce a road severance point (see page 21/23 of Vol 1 of
the submission for details).
6127-17 Kent Baigent peter@trippandrews.co.nz RPS Issues
significance to Mana Whenua Delete provisions
6127-18 Kent Baigent peter@trippandrews.co.nz RPS Mana Whenua B5 Strategic Delete provisions
6127-20 Kent Baigent peter@trippandrews.co.nz RPS Mana Whenua
and cultural development Delete provisions
6127-21 Kent Baigent peter@trippandrews.co.nz RPS Mana Whenua
Fig. 1 Delete provisions
6127-23 Kent Baigent peter@trippandrews.co.nz Mana Whenua
Whenua
objectives and policies Delete Overlay.
6127-24 Kent Baigent peter@trippandrews.co.nz Mana Whenua
Whenua
and policies Delete Overlay.
6127-25 Kent Baigent peter@trippandrews.co.nz Mana Whenua General provisions
assessment Delete rule 2.7.4
area
Delete development control 5.2.3.3 paragraph (2). Refer to Rural zones development
controls.
6128-1 Orewa Subdivision Limited chris.walsh@woods.co.nz Zoning North and Islands
Retain Single House for 126 and 138 Grand Drive, Orewa (Lot 2 DP 365535 and Pt Lot 9 DP
65871).
6128-2 Orewa Subdivision Limited chris.walsh@woods.co.nz Residential zones Residential
Amend rule 6.7 Building coverage to change the maximum coverage from 35 per cent to 40
per cent.
6128-3 Orewa Subdivision Limited chris.walsh@woods.co.nz Natural Hazards and Flooding Flooding
and policies
Clarify the relationship between the Flood Hazard non-statutory layer and the resource
consent process.
6128-4 Orewa Subdivision Limited chris.walsh@woods.co.nz General
GIS viewer
Amend the Flood Hazard non-statutory overlay to reflect the Rodney District Council Flood
extent 100 year ARI event map on page 11/11 of the submission.
6129-1 1Law4All Incorporated office@1law4all.co.nz RPS Mana Whenua B5 Strategic
Delete proposals to create Partnerships, Joint Management, Co-Governance and the
imposition of mandatory CIA's.
6129-2 1Law4All Incorporated office@1law4all.co.nz RPS Mana Whenua B5 Strategic Delete the use of the term Mana Whenua throughout the plan.
6129-3 1Law4All Incorporated office@1law4all.co.nz General Miscellaneous Consultation and engagement
Provide more time for consultation as there was a lack of disclosure about the intent or
contents of the PAUP prior to notification.
125/1145
Sub#/
6129-4 1Law4All Incorporated office@1law4all.co.nz RPS Mana Whenua B5 Strategic Withdraw the PAUP, remove separated structures and protect the interests of all equally.
6129-5 1Law4All Incorporated office@1law4all.co.nz RPS Issues
significance to Mana Whenua Delete B1.4
6129-6 1Law4All Incorporated office@1law4all.co.nz RPS Mana Whenua
participation Delete B5 Introduction.
6129-7 1Law4All Incorporated office@1law4all.co.nz RPS Mana Whenua B5 Strategic Delete B5
participation Delete B5.1
Fig. 1 Delete B5.4 Explanations and reasons
Fig. 1 Delete B5.4
6129-11 1Law4All Incorporated office@1law4all.co.nz Water
policies
Objectives Delete Objective 5.
6129-12 1Law4All Incorporated office@1law4all.co.nz Mana Whenua
Whenua
objectives and policies Delete Objectives and Policies.
6129-13 1Law4All Incorporated office@1law4all.co.nz Mana Whenua General provisions
assessment Delete G2.7.4 Cultural Impact Assessment.
assessment Delete G2.7.4.
discovery protocol Delete Information requirement section 5.
6129-16 1Law4All Incorporated office@1law4all.co.nz RPS Mana Whenua B5 Strategic
Delete all provisions calling for partnership arrangements, co-management, joint management
agreements and the transfer of power to Mana Whenua.
6129-17 1Law4All Incorporated office@1law4all.co.nz General Miscellaneous Consultation and engagement Provide a referendum on shared governance proposals.
6129-18 1Law4All Incorporated office@1law4all.co.nz RPS Mana Whenua B5 Strategic Delete all references to Mana Whenua.
participation
Delete the text "Te Tiriti o Waitangi / the Treaty of Waitangi is a foundation legal document for
New Zealand" anywhere it is stated in the plan.
6129-20 1Law4All Incorporated office@1law4all.co.nz RPS Mana Whenua B5 Strategic Delete references calling for governance based on Treaty of Waitangi recognition.
policies
Objectives Delete Objective 5 [and 6].
Policies 10-11 - National policy
statement on freshwater
management Delete Policy 11
Whenua
objectives and policies Amend section 5.1. See submission for details, page 12/16.
Whenua
and policies Amend section 5.2. See submission for details, page 12/16.
6129-25 1Law4All Incorporated office@1law4all.co.nz
SEAs
Land Delete Appendix 5.1
6129-26 1Law4All Incorporated office@1law4all.co.nz
SEAs
Areas - Land rules (all) Delete all references to SEA's.
6129-27 1Law4All Incorporated office@1law4all.co.nz General Whole Plan Withdraw all of PAUP.
6129-28 1Law4All Incorporated office@1law4all.co.nz General Miscellaneous Consultation and engagement
Carry out three years of public meetings and direct communication to publicise and debate the
impacts on Aucklanders of the plan followed by a referendum.
Whenua
and policies Delete section 5.2.
6129-30 1Law4All Incorporated office@1law4all.co.nz General Chapter A Introduction A3 Strategic Framework Delete parts of PAUP operative under Section 86(3) of the RMA.
6129-31 1Law4All Incorporated office@1law4all.co.nz General Chapter A Introduction A2 Statutory Framework Delete section 2.2.
126/1145
Sub#/
Fig. 1
Delete policies relating to the recognition of Mana Whenua being specialists in determining
values and areas, features or sites of significance, which may also be significant to whanau,
hap and iwi. [Submission refers to policies from Draft UP, the closest policies in the PAUP
are B5.4 8 and 9]
6130-1 Catherine Hill catherine.hill@buddlefindlay.com General Whole Plan Support the PAUP [having one cohesive plan).
6130-2 Catherine Hill catherine.hill@buddlefindlay.com RPS Urban growth
environment Retain the intention to protect heritage and impose design guidelines for new developments.
6130-3 Catherine Hill catherine.hill@buddlefindlay.com Residential zones
pols
Retain the objective relating to protecting the privacy and sunlight of neighbouring properties
within the residential areas.
6130-4 Catherine Hill catherine.hill@buddlefindlay.com Residential zones
pols
Retain the objective related to graded boundaries at the interface with Single House
dwellings.
Retain the approach of having a [rural] urban boundary but reject the 'current compass circle
approach' [to intensification].
environment Retain the approach of having appropriate design-based intensification.
6130-7 Catherine Hill catherine.hill@buddlefindlay.com General Chapter A Introduction
tools
Prepare local precinct plans (with local community input) which provide for intensification and
incorporate these sequentially into the PAUP, in a staged manner, as required by population
growth and demand.
6130-8 Catherine Hill catherine.hill@buddlefindlay.com Zoning Central Retain the Single House zoning in Western Springs/Morningside.
6130-9 Catherine Hill catherine.hill@buddlefindlay.com
control
Building demolition control J.3.6 Rules and mapping Retain the 'Pre-1944 Building Demolition Control' overlay for Western Springs/Morningside.
6130-10 Catherine Hill catherine.hill@buddlefindlay.com RPS
character and natural heritage B4.1 Historic heritage Retain the introduction.
6130-11 Catherine Hill catherine.hill@buddlefindlay.com Historic Heritage (Overlay)
Heritage
places
Amend the activity status in all Activity Tables [specific activities not provided] to discretionary
(to protect any historic houses in the Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings zone).
control
Amend the activity status [specific activities not provided] from restricted discretionary to
discretionary (to protect any special character houses in the Terrace Housing and Apartment
Buildings zone).
control
Delete provision for demolition of pre-1944 houses until a full historic heritage and special
character assessment has been undertaken in Western Springs/Morningside, and the
respective overlays have been extended to protect newly identified historic heritage and
special character areas.
6130-14 Catherine Hill catherine.hill@buddlefindlay.com Residential zones Residential
Add a height in relation to boundary control to the Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings
zone.
Amend the setback limits by widening the distances in the Terrace Housing and Apartment
Buildings zone where the zone adjoins 1-2 storey dwellings.
policies
Amend the location of residential zones (in relation to ridgelines), such that Single House or
Mixed Housing Suburban is located at the highest point/ridgeline followed by Mixed Housing
Urban and Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings at the lowest point.
6130-17 Catherine Hill catherine.hill@buddlefindlay.com Residential zones Residential Notification
Delete the non-notification rule for high density developments in the Terrace Housing and
6130-18 Catherine Hill catherine.hill@buddlefindlay.com Zoning Central
Rezone areas that are zoned Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings in Western
Springs/Morningside to Mixed Housing Suburban.
Rezone the shops along New North Road and the corner of Western Springs Road
[Kingsland], from Local Centre to Neighbourhood Centre.
6130-20 Catherine Hill catherine.hill@buddlefindlay.com General Chapter G General provisions G2.4 Notification
Add to the rule: 'Ensure residents are involved when effects on the surrounding
neighbourhood would be more than minor'.
6130-21 Catherine Hill catherine.hill@buddlefindlay.com General Chapter G General provisions G2.4 Notification
Amend such that restricted discretionary activities will be considered with public or limited
notification and the need to obtain written approval from affected parties.
6130-22 Catherine Hill catherine.hill@buddlefindlay.com Water Aquifers/Groundwater
Add the area of Western Springs/Morningside (in particular Western Springs Road, Mountain
View Road, Springfield Road, Bannerman Road and Finch Street) to a Natural Resources
overlay [Aquifer].
Recognise that housing density should be kept to a minimum in areas affected by land
stability and flooding issues (in Western Springs/Morningside).
6131-1 Dene Thomas denethomas@gmail.com RPS Mana Whenua B5 Strategic Delete the Mana Whenua provisions [inferred].
6132-1 Friends of Sherwood ecobee@xtra.co.nz
SEAs
Land Add all areas shown in the North Shore City Ecological Survey as SEA's
127/1145
Sub#/
SEAs
Land Add the Northcross Urban Forest in its entirity and surorunding vegetation as an SEA
SEAs
Land Add the Cliff Face of Brown's Bay as an SEA [see submission for further details]
SEAs
Land
Add the remnant bush left to protect the stand of rare swamp maire at Helvetia Drive, North
Shore as an SEA
SEAs
Land
Add SEA's within the North Shore as shown in the Figure 6a of the North Shore Ecological
Survey 2005 [on page 4/18 Vol 2 in the submission]
6132-6 Friends of Sherwood ecobee@xtra.co.nz Trees
Trees
Notable Trees
Add the following trees to the schedule 'Kowhai, kauri, kanuka and puriri at 186 Stapleford
Crescent, North Shore
Trees
Notable Trees
Add the following trees to the schedule 'nikau, kohehlohe, puriri, karaka at 15 Woodlands
Crescent, North Shore
Trees
Notable Trees
Add appropriate trees to the schedule on sites neighbouring 15 Woodlands Crescent, Browns
Bay
Trees
Notable Trees
Add the following trees to the schedule 'pohutakawa all through Browns Bay -Glen Road, Bute
Road, Countdown car park, New World car park, Glencoe Road.'
6132-10 Friends of Sherwood ecobee@xtra.co.nz RPS Issues
Add Integrated Organic Management Systems to be adopted across many activities to avoid
degrading the environment and releasing toxic substances into the air, water and land.
organisms
modified organisms Keep Auckland GE free
Rural Discharges,
Biosolids
Vertebrate Toxic Agents Ban the use of toxic chemicals for vegetation control
6132-13 Friends of Sherwood ecobee@xtra.co.nz General Miscellaneous Other Stop adding highly toxic hydrofluosilicic acid to the water supply
6133-1 Anna Hawken
229 Eskdale Road, Birkenhead,
Auckland 0626 Precincts - City Centre Arts, Civic & Entertainment
Amend Precinct to specifically refer to purchasing, restoring and encouraging the use of the
St James theatre as part of the Arts district.
6134-1 Craig Wallace a.mccarthy@harrisongrierson.com Zoning South Rezone 65 Whangapouri Road and Lot 2 DP 464886 from Mixed Rural to Countryside Living.
6134-2 Craig Wallace a.mccarthy@harrisongrierson.com Subdivision Auckland-wide - general
and policies
Amend to provide more scope for the subdivision, use and development of land in rural
zones, particularly the Mixed Rural zone.
6134-3 Craig Wallace a.mccarthy@harrisongrierson.com Subdivision Auckland-wide - Rural zones
zones only
Amend activity status for "boundary adjustments and boundary relocations" from Discretionary
to Controlled for boundary adjustments up to 10% and Restricted Discretionary for boundary
adjustments over 10%; remove the term "boundary relocation".
zones only
Amend activity status for "transferable rural site subdivision" from Discretionary to
Restricted Discretionary.
zones only
Amend activity status for "Any other subdivision not provided for in this table or in the rural
zones subdivision rules" from Prohibited to Non-complying.
zones only
Amend to provide greater scope for subdivision in the Mixed Rural zone through enabling
environmental lot subdivision within a site as a Restricted Discretionary Activity.
zones only
Amend to provide greater scope for subdivision in the Mixed Rural zone through enabling a
subdivision to accommodate a Permitted Activity, or [a consented] Restricted Discretionary
Activity.
area
Amend to reduce the minimum lot size for Mixed Rural sites to facilitate the creation of lots
that are suitable for a mix of rural activities as envisaged in the zone.
area
Delete references that state the non-compliance with a 'control' in this section is a Non-
complying Activity.
area Delete rule 1 - Specified building area.
zones only
Amend activity status for "subdivision in the Countryside Living zone" from Discretionary to
6135-1
National Road Carriers
Incorporated grant.turner@natroad.co.nz General Miscellaneous Consultation and engagement
Consolidate all Unitary Plan and bylaws transport related provisions into a single document
and make available for review as part of the Commission's 3 year process. Refer to page 5/10
6135-2
Incorporated grant.turner@natroad.co.nz
Centre) Business
Amend the provisions for the business zones to provide for the efficient and safe performance
of the freight sector services in a more intensified environment.
128/1145
Sub#/
6135-3
Incorporated grant.turner@natroad.co.nz RPS General
issues
Amend to include enabling policies and streamlined rules to encourage a more inter-regional
collaborative effort to provide an integrated transport system. Refer to pages 6-7/10 of the
6135-4
Incorporated grant.turner@natroad.co.nz Transport Auckland -wide C1.2 Policies
Provide appropriate specifications and enabling rules to encourage the meaningful use of high
productivity motor vehicles (HPMVs).
6135-5
Incorporated grant.turner@natroad.co.nz Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
Add reasonable and practical urban design provisions that will enable the delivery of freight to
every future property in Auckland, including access to shopping malls, and appropriately sized
and located parking spaces and turning circles.
6135-6
Incorporated grant.turner@natroad.co.nz Transport
D7 and I14.1-5 Strategic
Transport Corridor Zone
Add provisions for existing or potential strategic transport corridors e.g. entire route designed
to take heavy vehicles, sufficient safe truck stops and efficient and safe access to-from the
corridor to adjacent properties are provided, separation of freight vehicle traffic and other
traffic.
6135-7
Incorporated grant.turner@natroad.co.nz RPS
Add provisions that will maintain the freight routes to the Port of Auckland
and Auckland Airport as Auckland grows.
6135-8
Incorporated grant.turner@natroad.co.nz RPS
Amend the freight-friendly policy statements with detailed and specific supportive measures,
including but not limited to the use of arterial roads, priority to freight vehicles, the efficient and
safe design of transport infrastructure and the balance between place-making, movement and
access. [Refer to page 9/10 of the submission for details.]
6135-9
Incorporated grant.turner@natroad.co.nz Transport Auckland -wide C1.2 Policies
Amend the parking policy and rules to provide for freight delivery vehicles, including access to
suitable loading zone parks.
6135-10
Incorporated grant.turner@natroad.co.nz Transport Auckland -wide C1.2 Policies Amend the parking policy by adding innovative, educative and penalty methods.
6136-1 Catherine Stormont c.stormont@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central
Rezone land in Parnell, particularly in Garfield Street so that not all the operative Auckland
District Plan (Isthmus section) Residential 7b zoned land is zoned Terraced Housing and
Apartments and all Residential 1 zone is zoned Single House.
6136-2 Catherine Stormont c.stormont@xtra.co.nz Residential zones Residential
Terrace Housing and
Amend the design controls for Terraced Housing and Apartment Buildings where it is adjacent
to Single House so that the scale, materials and details are respectful to the character of the
area and context of the environment without inhibiting architectural creativity.
6136-3 Catherine Stormont c.stormont@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central Amend zoning in Parnell to retain sense of community
General
Amend visual privacy provisions to address issues of outdoor living spaces being overlooked
from above.
General
Amend provisions so that tall buildings do not create shadows over adjoining lower level
character houses.
General Provide a transition between tall buildings and lower single houses.
6136-7 Catherine Stormont c.stormont@xtra.co.nz
control
Building demolition control J.3.6 Rules and mapping Revise the pre 1944 Overlay. Needs to be more considered.
6136-8 Catherine Stormont c.stormont@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central Rezone 3-13 Garfield Street, Parnell to Terraced Housing and Apartment Building.
Terrace Housing and
Amend the maximum building height in the Terraced Housing and Apartment Buildings zone
where it abuts the Single House zones to create an appropriate transition of buildings
heights.
6136-10 Catherine Stormont c.stormont@xtra.co.nz Residential zones Residential Activity Table Allow secondary accommodation in residential areas to provide more intensity.
6136-11 Catherine Stormont c.stormont@xtra.co.nz General Noise and vibration H6.2 Rules Strengthen noise control in areas with higher density housing.
6136-12 Catherine Stormont c.stormont@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central
Reduce the proposed higher density around Garfield Street, Parnell until traffic congestion is
addressed. More off street parking is required.
6136-13 Catherine Stormont c.stormont@xtra.co.nz RPS Urban growth
Ensure that public transport demand has been addressed in areas where higher density is
proposed.
6136-14 Catherine Stormont c.stormont@xtra.co.nz General Eplan
Amend the maps, they are hard to read, in particular it is hard to see what is in conflict with
the museum height zone restriction.
6136-15 Catherine Stormont c.stormont@xtra.co.nz RPS Urban growth B2.7 Social infrastructure Seeks integration between intensification and ability of schools to handle additional demand.
6137-1 Garry Pike gap62@xtra.co.nz Mana Whenua
Whenua
objectives and policies Delete the overlay.
6138-1 Beacon Pathway Incorporated glendal@beaconpathway.co.nz RPS Urban growth
environment
Recognise that Auckland housing and neighbourhoods are underperforming in terms of
quality, sustainability and affordability as described in the submission [refer to page 5/19].
environment
Acknowledge that the required changes to improve Auckland's housing and neighbourhoods
cannot be achieved by business as usual or by Auckland Council alone. Council must show
leadership, innovation and collaboration.
environment Retain statutory design requirements.
129/1145
Sub#/
environment
Amend and strengthen requirements relating to sustainable and high performing urban
design. An example from Portland, Oregon is used [refer to page 6/19]
6138-5 Beacon Pathway Incorporated glendal@beaconpathway.co.nz RPS Rural B8.1 Rural activities
Amend and strengthen rural provisions to address sustainability and resilience issues, such
as food security.
Amend provisions to require any proposed development of satellite towns to be designed to
include a vibrant local hub with amenity, social and economic activities.
6138-7 Beacon Pathway Incorporated glendal@beaconpathway.co.nz Sustainable Development C7.7/H6.4 Sustainable design
Acknowledge that existing housing is cold, damp and unhealthy and that is critical that they
are brought up to an appropraite standard. It is critical that new homes are built to high
performing standards.
6138-8 Beacon Pathway Incorporated glendal@beaconpathway.co.nz Sustainable Development C7.7/H6.4 Sustainable design Recognise that retrofitting insulation can improve the performance of existing homes.
Recognise that energy generation, stormwater management and wastewater disposal at a
individual property or neighbourhood level.
6138-10 Beacon Pathway Incorporated glendal@beaconpathway.co.nz Residential zones Residential Land use controls
Amend land use and development controls to encourage and enable secondary suites and
secondary dwellings. Examples given in the submission [refer to page 7/19]
6138-11 Beacon Pathway Incorporated glendal@beaconpathway.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - general
and policies
Amend the plan to ensure neighbourhoods are effectively linked to the wider settlement by
public transport and interconnected locally through the provision of public open space.
6138-12 Beacon Pathway Incorporated glendal@beaconpathway.co.nz Residential zones Residential
policies Acknowledge the need to demolish sub-standard homes.
Retain the provisions that increase the performance of new homes including requirements to
meet Homestar or the Living Building Challenge.
Amend the sustainable development controls to apply to all new residential developments,
including those with four or less dwellings.
Amend the sustainable design provisions to be applied in a manner which is easy to adopt
without unreasonable costs for the development community. An example from Christchurch
City Council is given [refer to page 7/19].
General
Amend the PAUP to ensure that all new buildings are designed to be accessible to people of
all ages and physical abilities. An example from Christchurch City Council is given [refer to
page 8/19].
quality compact urban form Retain the compact urban form.
quality compact urban form Amend zoning to increase densities along key transport corridors as well as in town centres.
2010
Add Beacon Pathways Neighbourhood Sustainability Framework and Assessment Kit to
neighbourhood planning excercises. Particular reference is made to the Special Housing
Areas.
6138-20 Beacon Pathway Incorporated glendal@beaconpathway.co.nz RPS Changes to the RUB General
Retain the RUB in its current location. It should not expand beyond the location specified in
the PAUP.
Amend objectives and policies to ensure uptake of brownfield redevelopment, not just
greenfield.
Amend rules [inferred] to enable secondary dwellings in the form of 'invisible' density which
does not compromise the character and amenity values of existing neighbourhoods.
Acknowledge the importance of brownfield redevelopment. Examples given of overseas
brownfield redevelopment [refer to pages 9-11/19].
Retain rule 3.3 The conversion of a dwelling into two dwellings. Examples are given of similar
approaches overseas [refer to page 9/19]
Amend the land use controls to enable a small secondary unit seperate from the main
dwelling on sites larger than 600m2.
Amend the development controls to enable the redevelopment of existing buildings for mixed
use purposes that also provide for additional residential units.
6138-27 Beacon Pathway Incorporated glendal@beaconpathway.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - Urban zones H5.2 3.1 Residential zones
Amend the subdivision controls to enable subdivision of large sites to provide additional
dwellings within smaller footprints. An example from Victoria is given [refer to page 11/19].
policies
Recognise that further investigation is needed into statutory and non-statutory methods to
achieving invisible density. Further descriptions and examples of invisible density are shown
in the submission [refer to pages 9-11/19].
policies Retain the simplification of 99 residential zones down to 6 residential zones.
6138-30 Beacon Pathway Incorporated glendal@beaconpathway.co.nz Residential zones
pols
Recognise opportunities to expand the Terrace Housing and Apartment Building zone,
particularly along transport corridors and other areas of high amenity which are close to good
public transport, walking and cycling options.
policies
Recognise that a key aspect of achieving successful higher density development [inferred] is
achieving a mixture of scales of built form.
130/1145
Sub#/
6138-32 Beacon Pathway Incorporated glendal@beaconpathway.co.nz General Miscellaneous Consultation and engagement
Recognise that Council and communities need to work together to ensure the design and
function of local places meet the needs of local communities.
policies
Recognise that the planning for neighbourhoods needs to take a bottom-up, community-led
approach.
6138-34 Beacon Pathway Incorporated glendal@beaconpathway.co.nz RPS Urban growth B2.7 Social infrastructure
Amend the regional policy statement to include objectives and policies which relate to social
well-being.
6138-35 Beacon Pathway Incorporated glendal@beaconpathway.co.nz RPS Urban growth B2.7 Social infrastructure Retain section 2.7.
6138-36 Beacon Pathway Incorporated glendal@beaconpathway.co.nz RPS Urban growth B2.7 Social infrastructure
Amend to provide more detail. Examples are given in relation to the provision of social
infrastructure through the RUB process [refer to page 13/19].
policies Retain objective 3.
6138-38 Beacon Pathway Incorporated glendal@beaconpathway.co.nz Residential zones Housing affordability H6.6 Rules Retain the actions which address housing affordability, including retained affordable housing.
6138-39 Beacon Pathway Incorporated glendal@beaconpathway.co.nz Residential zones Housing affordability
and policies
Recognise that housing affordability can be increase through the provision of more efficient
homes which are well located for public transport and other services.
and policies
Recognise that housing affordability must be addressed within Neighbourhoods, not just
regionally.
Amend section 2.1 to strengthen position on housing affordability, this includes adding an
objective which specifically seeks to increase the supply of affordable housing for people on
moderate and low incomes, as shown in the submission [refer to page 14/19]
Add provisions which support/enable value capture through a betterment levy and/or a
targeted rate.
and policies
Recognise successfull models from Pacific rim cities in the USA which have developed
funding mechanisms to address housing affordability.
environment
Retain policy 5 with amendments that recognise that choice needs to be more clearly defined
to include maximum choice within neighbourhoods, not just at a regional scale.
6138-45 Beacon Pathway Incorporated glendal@beaconpathway.co.nz Infrastructure
C1.1 Infrastructure
policies
Recognise the need to enable and encourage demand management, resilience and creating
an enabling environment for innovative solutions for all infrastructure.
6138-46 Beacon Pathway Incorporated glendal@beaconpathway.co.nz RPS Climate change Retain section B.9.
6138-47 Beacon Pathway Incorporated glendal@beaconpathway.co.nz RPS Climate change
Amend policy 1(d) to explicity identify that this refers to both residential and non-residential
buildings.
Amend to give a stronger emphasis on sustainability issues, including socal, economic and
environmental aspects.
6138-49 Beacon Pathway Incorporated glendal@beaconpathway.co.nz Sustainable Development C7.7/H6.4 Sustainable design Amend provisions to support the capture and reuse of rainwater.
Delete unneccessarily restrictive guidelines and rules relating to water use and water tanks.
The example of Clevedon village is given [refer to page 15/19]
6138-51 Beacon Pathway Incorporated glendal@beaconpathway.co.nz RPS Natural resources
B6.3 Freshwater and
Geothermal Water
Amend provisions to create an enabling environment allowing people to have a
supplementary water supply and include aggressive promotion of demand management and
good neighbourhood design.
Add mechanisms to ensure that a greater level of sustainability is integrated within all new
and existing developments, at a house and neighbourhood level. This could be achieved by
requiring a percentage of any new development to offset their carbon footprint through
renewable energy provision on site.
Recognise that sustainable design is also about enabling community involvement. Council
should continue to work with key neighbourhood and Local Boards in further developing the
PAUP.
6138-54 Beacon Pathway Incorporated glendal@beaconpathway.co.nz Mana Whenua Mori purpose zone
controls
Retain activities which enable the development of Papakinga and recognise the work that
Ngti Whtua o Kaipara is undertaking to improve the quality of housing for their iwi and
hapu.
controls Add a enabling process and holistic approach for developing Papakinga. [D8.5]
controls
Retain the Mori Purpose zone in its supporting economic development to ensure thriving and
self-sustaining Mori communities. [D8.5]
controls Amend provisions to better enable the provisions of communal facilities and activities. [D8.5]
131/1145
Sub#/
controls Amend provisions to enable and encourage sustainable design.[D8.5]
controls
Amend provisions to allow densities to meet the need of Whnau within sustainable design
principles. [D8.5]
6139-1 Ernest Tidalgo etidalgo@gmail.com Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula K5.11 Precinct rules
Amend building height to a maximum of 2 storeys, opposes precinct plan for Devonport
Peninsula.
Amend the rules to increase the amount of green space required around buildings and
houses.
6139-3 Ernest Tidalgo etidalgo@gmail.com Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula K5.11 Precinct rules Amend the rules to require existing trees remain.
Amend the rules to require notification of adjacent property owners for new buildings which
impede light, view or wind.
6139-5 Ernest Tidalgo etidalgo@gmail.com RPS Urban growth
quality compact urban form Amend the rules to reduce the population density limit for residential areas.
6140-1 Murray Finch murray.finch@gmail.com Special Character
residential
Add a new character overlay to protect the current character of the built environment, flora
and fauna of the Hill Park area in Manurewa.
6141-1 Kerin Tran stylish.ten@gmail.com
SEAs
Land
Amend the boundary of the SEA adjacent to 47, 49, 51 and 53 Harbour View Road, Te Atatu
Peninsula [refer to pages 3/5 and 5/5 of the submissions for maps]
6142-1 Susan Keaney susan_k@orcon.net.nz RPS Urban growth
Amend objectives and policies to provide that intensification is not to take place in areas that
do not have the infrastructure in place to support intensification.
6142-2 Susan Keaney susan_k@orcon.net.nz RPS Urban growth
Amend objectives and policies to provide that the risks of focusing intensification on the
Auckland isthmus with respect to volcanic hazard are to be evaluated.
6142-3 Susan Keaney susan_k@orcon.net.nz
Centre) Business
Park zones Amend height limit for the New Lynn Metropolitan Centre from 18 storeys to 6-8 storeys.
6142-4 Susan Keaney susan_k@orcon.net.nz Residential zones Residential
Mixed Housing Urban zone Retain the 2 storey height limit in the Mixed Housing Suburban zone.
6142-5 Susan Keaney susan_k@orcon.net.nz Residential zones Residential Notification
Amend notification provisions to provide for greater opportunity for public and limited
notification of proposals that do not comply with development controls in the Mixed Housing
Suburban and Mixed Housing Urban zones.
sensitive areas rules J6.3 Rules Retain the rules about volcanic view shafts.
sensitive areas rules J6.3 Rules Retain the rules about height sensitive areas.
Amend planning maps containing volcanic cones so that the area from the cone to the
nearest natural low point is zoned Single House in residential areas or and equivalent of 2
storey height limit in business areas.
6142-9 Susan Keaney susan_k@orcon.net.nz Zoning West
Retain zoning of Titirangi Road, Golf Road, South Lynn Road and Lemnos Place block. [refer
map, page 7/7 of submission].
6143-1 Rebecca Thompson skypetobecks@hotmail.co.nz RPS Natural resources
Organisms Retain GE (genetically engineered) provisions.
6143-2 Rebecca Thompson skypetobecks@hotmail.co.nz RPS Natural resources
Organisms Retain Genetically Modified Organism section.
6143-3 Rebecca Thompson skypetobecks@hotmail.co.nz
organisms
modified organisms Retain Chapter C 5.17.
6143-4 Rebecca Thompson skypetobecks@hotmail.co.nz Definitions Existing Retain definition for Genetically Modified Organisms (GMOs).
6143-5 Rebecca Thompson skypetobecks@hotmail.co.nz Definitions Existing Retain definition for GMO field trials.
6143-6 Rebecca Thompson skypetobecks@hotmail.co.nz Definitions Existing Retain definition for GMO release.
6144-1 Karen Byrne karen.byrne@xtra.co.nz Precincts - North Bayswater K5.6 Precinct rules
Amend precinct by implementing rules from the Special Purpose 7 zone of the operative
North Shore City Council District Plan for Bayswater Marina, upheld by the Environment
Court.
6144-2 Karen Byrne karen.byrne@xtra.co.nz Precincts - North Bayswater K5.6 Precinct rules Delete 'residential development' in sub-precinct B from the Activity Table.
6144-3 Karen Byrne karen.byrne@xtra.co.nz Precincts - North Bayswater K5.6 Precinct rules
Amend Activity Table for 'dwellings' with or without a framework plan to change the activity
status to non-complying not discretionary.
6144-4 Karen Byrne karen.byrne@xtra.co.nz Precincts - North Bayswater K5.6 Precinct rules Delete residential development, due to infrastructure.
6144-5 Karen Byrne karen.byrne@xtra.co.nz General Miscellaneous Special housing areas Delete creation of a Special Housing Area at Bayswater Marina.
6144-6 Karen Byrne karen.byrne@xtra.co.nz General Chapter G General provisions G2.4 Notification Retain notification provisions, and notification of framework plans.
6144-7 Karen Byrne karen.byrne@xtra.co.nz Precincts - North Bayswater K5.6 Precinct rules Amend rules to protect the unique bio-diversity of Bayswater.
6144-8 Karen Byrne karen.byrne@xtra.co.nz Precincts - North Bayswater K5.6 Precinct rules Amend rules to retain Public Open Space and Marine related activities for Bayswater Marina.
132/1145
Sub#/
6144-9 Karen Byrne karen.byrne@xtra.co.nz RPS Urban growth
Amend the provisions to upgrade necessary infrastructure prior to allowing development in the
Devonport Peninsula precinct.
6144-10 Karen Byrne karen.byrne@xtra.co.nz Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula K5.11 Precinct rules Delete proposal to alter David Street, Bayswater from a No Exit road to a through road.
6144-11 Karen Byrne karen.byrne@xtra.co.nz Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula K5.11 Precinct rules Amend the rules to delete medium-high density housing from all sub-precincts.
6144-12 Karen Byrne karen.byrne@xtra.co.nz Zoning North and Islands
Rezone Devonport Peninsula precincts from Mixed Housing to a more suitable zone due to
infrastructure.
6144-13 Karen Byrne karen.byrne@xtra.co.nz General Miscellaneous Special housing areas Delete creation of a Special Housing Area within the Devonport Peninsula precinct areas.
6144-14 Karen Byrne karen.byrne@xtra.co.nz General Miscellaneous Consultation and engagement Seeks extensive consultation and public notification of development plans.
6144-15 Karen Byrne karen.byrne@xtra.co.nz Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula K5.11 Precinct rules Add maximum building length provisions.
6144-16 Karen Byrne karen.byrne@xtra.co.nz Precincts - North Bayswater K5.6 Precinct rules Add comprehensive design rules and controls for developments.
6145-1 Sandesh Heinicke sandesh.heinicke@gmail.com RPS
character and natural heritage B4.3.3 Trees and vegetation Seeks greening of the city, include perma cultural knowledge and food forests.
6145-2 Sandesh Heinicke sandesh.heinicke@gmail.com General Miscellaneous
Operational/
Projects/Acquisition Close roads to traffic.
Operational/
Projects/Acquisition Provide safe and segregated cycle paths.
6145-4 Sandesh Heinicke sandesh.heinicke@gmail.com Sustainable Development C7.7/H6.4 Sustainable design Seeks good standard of housing, through good insulation and green building design.
Operational/
Projects/Acquisition Seeks no more spraying of berms.
Operational/
Projects/Acquisition Seeks no more fluoride in the water supply.
6146-1 Helen Somerville hels80@gmail.com Precincts - North Bayswater K5.6 Precinct rules
Reduce the amount of dwellings provided, and limit these to free standing dwellings. No
terraced housing.
6146-2 Helen Somerville hels80@gmail.com Precincts - North Bayswater K5.6 Precinct rules Amend density to no more than 1 per 600m2
6147-1 Ngti Paoa Iwi Trust Board admin@ngatipaoaiwi.co.nz General Miscellaneous Other
Support the submission of all other Mana Whenua in Auckland, Te Matapihi he Tirohanga mo
te iwi Trust and Community HousingAoteroa.
6147-2 Ngti Paoa Iwi Trust Board admin@ngatipaoaiwi.co.nz RPS Mana Whenua
participation
Retain the PAUP in so far as it provides a generic framework for Ngti Paoa to develop, foster
and advance cultural, economic, environmental and social aspirations.
6147-3 Ngti Paoa Iwi Trust Board admin@ngatipaoaiwi.co.nz General Miscellaneous
Operational/
6147-4 Ngti Paoa Iwi Trust Board admin@ngatipaoaiwi.co.nz General Chapter A Introduction
Plan
Ensure provisions are integrated both horizontally and vertically in relation to provisions for
Mori.
6147-5 Ngti Paoa Iwi Trust Board admin@ngatipaoaiwi.co.nz General Cross plan matters
Add provisions to address adverse effects arising from sites adjoining sites and place with
customary uses and values, including land identified as Mori and Treaty Settlement Land
and Mori Purpose zones.
6147-6 Ngti Paoa Iwi Trust Board admin@ngatipaoaiwi.co.nz RPS Changes to the RUB General
Ensure Mori [Te Kawerau--Maki] are involved in processes which impact on the extent and
location of the Rural Urban Boundary [no specific relief sought].
6147-7 Ngti Paoa Iwi Trust Board admin@ngatipaoaiwi.co.nz General
GIS viewer
Include 'ancestral rohe' maps as a non-statutory map layer, which are to be developed in
conjunction with Mana Whenua.
Mtauranga & tikanga
Include a new method identifying that 'ancestral rohe' maps will be developed as a non-
statutory map layer, which are to be developed in conjunction with Mana Whenua.
6147-9 Ngti Paoa Iwi Trust Board admin@ngatipaoaiwi.co.nz General Editorial and Part 6
Review the PAUP numbering system and amend to improve its usability and user
friendliness.
6147-10 Ngti Paoa Iwi Trust Board admin@ngatipaoaiwi.co.nz General Chapter A Introduction A1 Background Retain section 1.2, Mana Whenua.
6147-11 Ngti Paoa Iwi Trust Board admin@ngatipaoaiwi.co.nz General Chapter A Introduction A2 Statutory Framework
Recognise [section 2.2] the Treaty settlement process which informs the significance and
relationship between Mana Whenua and the natural and physical resources.
6147-12 Ngti Paoa Iwi Trust Board admin@ngatipaoaiwi.co.nz General Chapter A Introduction A3 Strategic Framework
Identify within section 3.2 Mori Responsiveness Framework how the framework is integrated
and given effect to through the PAUP.
6147-13 Ngti Paoa Iwi Trust Board admin@ngatipaoaiwi.co.nz RPS Issues
Amend the issues to ensure the resource management issue is clearly identified, rather than
being worded as an 'outcome statement'.
growth
Amend 1.1 to read: 'This means that we must management our growth in a way that:...
enhances Mori communities culture and values'. Refer to Vol. 1 page 88/77 of the
submission.
wellbeing
Amend the issue statement to include reference to recognise 'the positive value Mori
economic development contributes to Auckland's prosperity'.
heritage
Amend issue statement to recognise that 'enabling Mana Whenua participation and decision-
making' is a general concern for the RPS, not just for indigenous biodiversity.
Delete the [heading - Explanation] to make it clear that the issue encompasses the
'explanation section' as well.
Amend the header to read as follows: Recognition of the Treaty and enabling the outcomes
of Treaty settlements
133/1145
Sub#/
Include specific reference to the kaitiaki role of Mana Whenua in both the issue statement and
explanation.
Amend section 1.6 as follows: 'In some cases, coastal land has been returned through Treaty
Settlement as cultural or commercial redress to be used to re-establish an economic base and
platform for future development.' and make reference to the effect that outstanding harbour
Treaty claims in Auckland are also used to re-establish an economic base and platform for
future Iwi development.
Amend section 1.7 as follows: 'In some cases, rural land has been returned through Treaty
Settlement as cultural or commercial redress to be used to re-establish an economic base and
platform for future development.'
change Retain issue.
participation
Retain section 5.1 ' Recognition of Te Tiriti o Waitangi partnerships and participation' subject
to amendments contained in this submission.
participation
Amend Policy 9: 'Enable Mana Whenua to access, manage and develop use cultural redress
lands and interests for cultural activities' .
6147-25 Ngti Paoa Iwi Trust Board admin@ngatipaoaiwi.co.nz RPS General
review procedures
Amend section 13 'Monitoring and Review Procedures' to identify joint management
agreements and the transfer of powers as key monitoring indicators.
Mtauranga & tikanga
Retain section 5.2 'Recognising Mana Whenua values through integrating mtauranga and
tikanga in the sustainable management of Auckland's natural and physical resources', subject
to the amendments sought in this submission.
Mtauranga & tikanga
Add specific objectives, policies and methods to enable customary use and and cultural
activities.
and cultural development Amend to identify policies and methods demonstrating how Objective 2 will be achieved.
6147-29 Ngti Paoa Iwi Trust Board admin@ngatipaoaiwi.co.nz General Cross plan matters
Fig. 1
Retain section 5.4 'protection of Mana Whenua culture and heritage' subject to the
amendments sought in this submission.
Fig. 1 Retain Objective 3 and Policies 5, 6 and 12, and their references to cultural landscapes.
6147-33 Ngti Paoa Iwi Trust Board admin@ngatipaoaiwi.co.nz RPS Natural resources
B6.3 Freshwater and
Geothermal Water Retain Policy 5 'freshwater health and Policy 8 'geothermal health'.
6147-34 Ngti Paoa Iwi Trust Board admin@ngatipaoaiwi.co.nz RPS Coastal
environment
Add a new Objective to enable the subdivision, use and development of Mori land and
Treaty settlement land in the coastal environment, to give effect to B.5.3 [Mori economic,
social and cultural development].
environment Retain Policies 1 and 4.
space - coastal environment
Add new objectives, policies and methods to enable customary use and cultural activities' as
identified in B.5.2. [Recognising Mana Whenua values through integrating mtauranga and
tikanga in the sustainable management of Auckland's natural and physical environment].
quality
identify key areas to support the objectives and policies.
Gulf Retain Policies 10 - 12 'Managing the Hauraki Gulf / Te Moana Nui o Toi / Tikapa Moana.'
Add 'additional environmental results anticipated' to cover the range of matters addressed in
the plan that impact on Mori.
review procedures
Amend to state how and what will be monitored. Clearly identify these in the PAUP and
develop them with the input of Mori.
6147-41 Ngti Paoa Iwi Trust Board admin@ngatipaoaiwi.co.nz Mana Whenua Auckland wide - Mori Land
and policies Retain section 2.1 Mori Land.
134/1145
Sub#/
and policies
Clarify that the non-statutory Mori land map layer will be updated as new Mori land sites are
identified.
6147-43 Ngti Paoa Iwi Trust Board admin@ngatipaoaiwi.co.nz Definitions Existing
Amend the 'Mori land' definition to refer to 'Parts 12 and 13 of Te Ture Whenua Mori Act
1993', and delete the reference to section 12 and 13.
and policies
and policies
considering the effects on natural resources, including SEA's; Includes provision for a range
and policies
6147-47 Ngti Paoa Iwi Trust Board admin@ngatipaoaiwi.co.nz Mana Whenua
settlement land
and policies
Amend Objective 3: Mana Whenua can access, manage and develop use land acquired as
cultural redress to support cultural activities .
settlement land
and policies
Amend Policies 4 and 7 to require an Integrated Mori Development Plan for discretionary
heritage values as part of the matters of control.
settlement land
and policies Retain provisions in Sections 3-7 where they specifically relate to Mori.
6147-50 Ngti Paoa Iwi Trust Board admin@ngatipaoaiwi.co.nz RPS Urban growth
6147-51 Ngti Paoa Iwi Trust Board admin@ngatipaoaiwi.co.nz
the CMA
D5.1.14 Background,
Add an objective so that the process for creating an allocating will be clear and transparent,
especially where there are multiple and competing applications.
the CMA
D5.1.14 Background,
objectives and policies Add a policy that no further allocations will be granted until the process is clearly defined.
the CMA
D5.1.14 Background,
Add an objective and policy so ensure that Mana Whenua, including Ngti Paoa, will be
notified, engaged, consulted and part of the decision making process in respect of the
creation and allocation of aquaculture space; and that environmental impacts to cultural
values, both tangible and intangible, shall be avoided, remedied or mitigated.
the CMA
D5.1.14 Background,
Add a policy to ensure that the allocation of new space will attract an obligation to contribute
to the costs of Mana Whenua, including Ngti Paoa, and its ongoing kaitiaki role and
responsibilities, and that Mana Whenua, including Ngti Paoa, shall be empowered to
participate in aquaculture opportunities.
6147-55 Ngti Paoa Iwi Trust Board admin@ngatipaoaiwi.co.nz Mana Whenua Mori purpose zone
controls Retain Mori Purpose zone.
controls Add new sites to the Mori Purpose zone [no specific sites identified].
6147-57 Ngti Paoa Iwi Trust Board admin@ngatipaoaiwi.co.nz Historic Heritage (Overlay)
policies
control
Whenua
objectives and policies Retain objectives and policies subject to the relief sought in this submission.
Whenua
whenua
Include areas identified in the submission within the schedule [See submission points 131 to
328 for specific sites].
Whenua
6147-62 Ngti Paoa Iwi Trust Board admin@ngatipaoaiwi.co.nz Precincts - Central New Precincts Other New Precincts
customary importance throughout the region [inferred as new precinct rather than extension of
existing precinct].
135/1145
Sub#/
6147-63 Ngti Paoa Iwi Trust Board admin@ngatipaoaiwi.co.nz Precincts Ak-Wide and Coastal Regional Parks
6147-64 Ngti Paoa Iwi Trust Board admin@ngatipaoaiwi.co.nz Precincts Ak-Wide and Coastal New Precincts All other New Precincts Add additional precincts over sites identified as the Mori Purpose zone.
6147-65 Ngti Paoa Iwi Trust Board admin@ngatipaoaiwi.co.nz General Chapter G General provisions G2.4 Notification Add a rule to provide for notification in relation to any application that involves cultural issues.
6147-66 Ngti Paoa Iwi Trust Board admin@ngatipaoaiwi.co.nz Mana Whenua General provisions
assessment Retain rules subject to the relief sought in this submission.
discovery protocol
Amend rule 2.5(2)(i) 'Accidental discovery protocols' to read: Work at the site must not
recommence until approval has been granted by the council in consultation with Mana
Whenua and the New Zealand Historic Places Trust. In doing this, council must provide for
the impacts of the activity on Mana Whenua values, and any recommended measures from
Mana Whenua proposed to avoid any adverse effects on sites and places of significance to
Mana Whenua.
discovery protocol
Clarify when a discretionary consent is required under Rule 2.5.4 'Accidental discovery
protocols'.
assessment
Amend rule G2.7.1(3)(e) 'General information requirements': 'places of cultural importance,
including churches, marae, and sites and places of significance and value to Mana Whenua.'
assessment
Retain Rule 2.7.4(1) 'Cultural impact assessment' requirements for sites and places of
Whenua
of value to Mana Whenua Add any new sites/places, as supported by Mana Whenua [no specific sites given].
assessment
Retain 2.7.4(2) Cultural impact assessment subject to any outcomes of a collaborative
approach between Mana Whenua, council and key stakeholders to refine this process.
assessment
Clarify that discretion is held by Mana Whenua to determine if a cultural impact assessment is
required or not in Rule 2.7.4 Cultural impact assessment.
assessment
Amend Rule 2.7.4 'Cultural Impact Assessment' to require Iwi Management Plans objectives,
policies and methods to be reflected in the Cultural Impact Assessment.
assessment
Amend Rule 2.7.4(4) Cultural impact assessment to reflect that a Cultural Impact Assessment
will need to be carried out if required by Mana Whenua.
assessment
Amend Rule 2.7.4(4) Cultural impact assessment to list ways in which Mana Whenua may be
engaged and consulted.
controls Amend Preamble to Activity Table to refer to the definition of 'Mori Land.'
controls Amend rules relating to Mori Land to provided for the economic empowerment of Iwi.
Spec. info. req.
Delete rule 3.1(b) and (c) 'Building height' and clarify activity status when the permitted status
is not met. Amend to a restricted discretionary activity if presently discretionary.
Spec. info. req.
Mori Land. See submission for specific amendments Vol. 1 page 29/77 of the submission.
Spec. info. req.
Amend assessment for restricted discretionary activities criteria 1(f) to recognise that there
may be no alternative sites and/or locations for development on Mori or Treaty settlement
land.
settlement land
rules/App. 4.3 legislation Retain Treaty Settlement Land section, subject to the relief sought in this submission.
settlement land
Amend the Activity Table to permit the development of Treaty Settlement Land, including
cultural redress sites, for commercial [as a controlled activity], industrial and residential
purposes.
settlement land
Delete from the Activity Table the restriction on the number of dwellings [10] and any
references to an underlying zone.
settlement land
Enable Masterplans or Comprehensive Development Plans as a Restricted Discretionary
activity on a per site basis, with the ability to undertake intensive development at a character,
intensity and scale similar to adjacent sites with equivalent commercial, industrial or
residential zoning.
settlement land
rules/App. 4.3 legislation Add a new rule framework for cultural and customary activities on Treaty Settlement Land.
136/1145
Sub#/
settlement land
Delete rule 3.1(b) and (c) 'Building height' and clarify activity status when the permitted status
is not met. Amend to a restricted discretionary activity if presently discretionary.
settlement land
Amend section to correct errors where the text refers to Mori Land instead of Treaty
Settlement Land. See submission for specific amendments Vol. 1 page 33/77 of the
submission.
Spec. info. req.
Amend assessment for restricted discretionary activities criteria 1(f) to recognise that there
may be no alternative sites and/or locations for development on Mori or Treaty settlement
Land.
SEAs
Assessment
Retain section, particularly customary use in the Activity Table and Rule 2.5 Vegetation
alteration or removal for customary use.
SEAs
Assessment
Clarify what the activity status is of activities not complying with rule 2.5. If not a restricted
discretionary activity status, amend to this and add assessment criteria to support this.
6147-93 Ngti Paoa Iwi Trust Board admin@ngatipaoaiwi.co.nz Water Wastewater H4.15 Onsite wastewater rules
Clarify what is meant by 'must not disturb' [any historic heritage or any site or place of
significance to Mana Whenua] in clause 2.1.1(2).
organisms
modified organisms Retain section.
6147-95 Ngti Paoa Iwi Trust Board admin@ngatipaoaiwi.co.nz Sustainable Development C7.7/H6.4 Sustainable design
Delete objectives, policies, methods and rules stating that 'sustainable development' will be
regulate through rating scheme controls and replace with a non-regulatory method to
implement an education and advocacy programme, and encourage use of
Homestar/Greenstar or similar rating systems.
the CMA
Add a new Restricted Discretionary activity as follows: new aquaculture activities pursuant to
space allocate under the Mori Commercial Aquaculture Claims Settlement Act 2004.
Special information
requirements
Add a requirement that aquaculture management plans include provision for assessing,
addressing and managing cultural issues.
6147-98 Ngti Paoa Iwi Trust Board admin@ngatipaoaiwi.co.nz Rural Zones General I13.2 Land use controls
Clarify that rule 2.6 'Dwellings' does not apply to Mori and Treaty Settlement Land in coastal
areas.
controls
Amend the zone to permit the development of Treaty Settlement land, including cultural
redress sites, for commercial, industrial and residential purposes.
6147-
100 Ngti Paoa Iwi Trust Board admin@ngatipaoaiwi.co.nz Mana Whenua Mori purpose zone
controls Delete the current restriction on the number of dwellings [10].
6147-
101 Ngti Paoa Iwi Trust Board admin@ngatipaoaiwi.co.nz Mana Whenua Mori purpose zone
controls
Amend to enable Masterplans or Comprehensive Development Plans as a Restricted
Discretionary activity on a per site basis, with the ability to undertake intensive development at
a character intensity and scale similar to adjacent sites with equivalent commercial, industrial
or residential zoning.
6147-
102 Ngti Paoa Iwi Trust Board admin@ngatipaoaiwi.co.nz Mana Whenua
Whenua J5.1 Rules Retain section.
6147-
Whenua J5.2 Rules Retain section.
6147-
Whenua
and policies
Amend any rules that jeopardise the provisions of a buffer around sites and places of
significance to Mana Whenua.
6147-
105 Ngti Paoa Iwi Trust Board admin@ngatipaoaiwi.co.nz RPS
Amend all natural heritage overlays [ONFs, ONLs, HNCs and ONCs, Volcanic Viewshafts and
Height Sensitive Areas and Notable Trees] to provide for development of Mori Land and
Treaty Settlement Land as permitted activities.
6147-
106 Ngti Paoa Iwi Trust Board admin@ngatipaoaiwi.co.nz Precincts General Content Precincts General Content
not provided].
6147-
107 Ngti Paoa Iwi Trust Board admin@ngatipaoaiwi.co.nz Precincts General Content Precincts General Content
6147-
108 Ngti Paoa Iwi Trust Board admin@ngatipaoaiwi.co.nz General Chapter G General provisions
status
Clarify the rule relationship between Mori Land and precinct controls by stating that the more
permissive controls apply in the precinct.
6147-
109 Ngti Paoa Iwi Trust Board admin@ngatipaoaiwi.co.nz Definitions Existing
Amend list of Mori terms so it includes all the Mori terms used in the PAUP [list of missing
terms not provided].
6147-
Amend the definition of 'Customary use' by expanding it to include the use of stones, soils,
water, marine or freshwater life, for a range of uses including cultivation, farming or
aquaculture activities. Refer to submission for specific amendments, Vol. 1 page 39/77.
137/1145
Sub#/
6147-
both.
6147-
112 Ngti Paoa Iwi Trust Board admin@ngatipaoaiwi.co.nz Zoning North and Islands Retain Single House zone at 115 Kowhai Road, Upper Orewa.
6147-
113 Ngti Paoa Iwi Trust Board admin@ngatipaoaiwi.co.nz Zoning Central Rezone 3 Garfield St, Parnell from Single House to a zone which allows for apartments.
6147-
114 Ngti Paoa Iwi Trust Board admin@ngatipaoaiwi.co.nz Built Environment (Overlays)
Height Control
Provide for an additional height overlay at 71 Grafton Road, Grafton [zoned as Light Industry]
to amend the height limit from 20m to 7 storeys.
6147-
115 Ngti Paoa Iwi Trust Board admin@ngatipaoaiwi.co.nz
control
Building demolition control J.3.6 Rules and mapping Delete overlay from 71 Grafton Road, Grafton.
6147-
116 Ngti Paoa Iwi Trust Board admin@ngatipaoaiwi.co.nz Zoning Central Retain Mixed Housing Suburban at 115 Waipuna Road, Panmure.
6147-
117 Ngti Paoa Iwi Trust Board admin@ngatipaoaiwi.co.nz Zoning Central Retain Mixed Housing Suburban at 117 Waipuna Road, Panmure.
6147-
118 Ngti Paoa Iwi Trust Board admin@ngatipaoaiwi.co.nz Zoning North and Islands
Rezone 253 Hibiscus Coast Highway, Red Beach from Mixed Housing Suburban to provide
for terrace housing and/or hotel/motel development.
6147-
119 Ngti Paoa Iwi Trust Board admin@ngatipaoaiwi.co.nz Zoning Central Retain Mixed Housing Suburban zone at 54 Lillington Road, Remuera.
6147-
120 Ngti Paoa Iwi Trust Board admin@ngatipaoaiwi.co.nz Zoning North and Islands
Retain Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings zone at 36, 38, 39, 40, 41, 43, 45, 47, 49,
51 and 53 Tennyson Ave, Takapuna.
6147-
121 Ngti Paoa Iwi Trust Board admin@ngatipaoaiwi.co.nz Zoning North and Islands Delete the General Coastal Marine zone from 43 Tennyson Ave, Takapuna.
6147-
122 Ngti Paoa Iwi Trust Board admin@ngatipaoaiwi.co.nz Residential zones Residential
Amend the Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings zone at 36, 38, 39, 40, 41, 43, 45, 47,
49, 51 and 53 Tennyson Ave, Takapuna, to allow maximum ten storey development, with 60%
building coverage.
6147-
123 Ngti Paoa Iwi Trust Board admin@ngatipaoaiwi.co.nz
control
Delete the overlay from 36, 38, 39, 40, 41, 43, 45, 47, 49, 51 and 53 Tennyson Ave,
Takapuna.
6147-
124 Ngti Paoa Iwi Trust Board admin@ngatipaoaiwi.co.nz RPS Mana Whenua
Mtauranga & tikanga
Include the Interim Ngti Paoa Regional Policy Statement within the PAUP as a means of
representing the interests and aspirations of Ngti Paoa. See submission for further details
[Vol. 1 page 44 to 77. Note - pages 51 to 77 have been referenced in an early submission
point, #60, in relation to new sites of significance to Mana Whenua].
6147-
participation
Add a new objective as follows: 5. Where a proposal affects land or water resources and
results in more than minor adverse cultural impacts that cannot be avoided (whether tangible
or intangible) then these impacts to Mana Whenua must be addressed using mitigation
methods that include cultural offsetting or compensatory principles [Vol. 2 page 7/9 of the
submission].
6147-
participation
Amend Policy 6 to read as follows: Take into account, where Mana Whenua propose an
activity on Treaty settlement land, the benefits for the wider community and environment
provided by any property specific protection mechanism, such as a covenant or other form of
legislative protection, when considering the effects of the proposal.Protection may be
provided either for the site which is the subject of the proposal or from alternative sites that
have been, or will be, subject to a protective mechanism.
6147-
participation
Add a new policy as follows: Where a proposal affects land or resources and results in more
than minor adverse cultural impacts that cannot be avoided (whether tangible or intangible),
then these impacts to Mana Whenua must be addressed as part of the Cultural Impact
Assessment mitigation methods that include cultural offsetting or compensatory principles.
6147-
128 Ngti Paoa Iwi Trust Board admin@ngatipaoaiwi.co.nz Mana Whenua General provisions
assessment
Add a new rule to provide that where a proposal affects land or resources and results in more
than minor adverse cultural impacts that cannot be avoided (whether tangible or intangible),
these impacts to Mana Whenua must be addressed as part of a Cultural Impact Assessment.
See submission for specific amendments [Vol. 2 page 8/9 of the submission].
6147-
Amend the definition of 'Treaty Settlement Land' to includes properties over which claimant
groups have been awared Right of First Refusal and which are identified in a Schedule to the
PAUP and to exclude those which have not been identified in a Schedule. See submission for
specific amendments [Vol. 2 page 8/9 of the submission].
6147-
130 Ngti Paoa Iwi Trust Board admin@ngatipaoaiwi.co.nz Mana Whenua Auckland wide - Mori Land
controls
Delete the land use control which allows no more than 10 dwellings for Papakinga
development. Refer to page 28/77 of submission.
6147-
Whenua
whenua
Add Kawau Island Scenic Reserve to the schedule. Refer to submission for further details,
Vol. 1, page 53/77.
138/1145
Sub#/
6147-
Whenua
whenua
Add Smeltinghouse Bay Scenic Reserve to the schedule. Refer to submission for further
details, Vol. 1, page 53/77.
6147-
Whenua
whenua
Add Stony Hill Recreation Reserve to the schedule. Refer to submission for further details,
Vol. 1, page 53/77.
6147-
Whenua
whenua
Add Mahurangi Scenic Reserve to the schedule. Refer to submission for further details, Vol.
1, page 53/77.
6147-
Whenua
whenua
Add Motuora Island Recreation Reserve to the schedule. Refer to submission for further
6147-
Whenua
whenua
Add Tiritiri Matangi Island Papakura P tauranga waka area to the schedule. Refer to
submission for further details, Vol. 1, page 53/77.
6147-
Whenua
whenua
Add Matakana School to the schedule. Refer to submission for further details, Vol. 1, page
53/77.
6147-
Whenua
whenua
Add Kawau Island Site to the schedule. Refer to submission for further details, Vol. 1, page
53/77.
6147-
Whenua
whenua
Add Baddeleys Beach Road, Million Bay to the schedule. Refer to submission for further
6147-
Whenua
whenua
Add Sunnybrook Scenic Reserve to the schedule. Refer to submission for further details, Vol.
1, page 53/77.
6147-
Whenua
whenua
Add Ti Point Marginal Strip to the schedule. Refer to submission for further details, Vol. 1,
page 54/77.
6147-
Whenua
whenua
Add Baddeleys Conservation Area to the schedule. Refer to submission for further details,
Vol. 1, page 54/77.
6147-
Whenua
whenua
Add Puhinui Scenic Reserve to the schedule. Refer to submission for further details, Vol. 1,
page 54/77.
6147-
Whenua
whenua
Add Waihunga Moirs Hill Scenic Reserve to the schedule. Refer to submission for further
6147-
Whenua
whenua
Add Nukumea Scenic Reserve to the schedule. Refer to submission for further details, Vol. 1,
page 54/77.
6147-
Whenua
whenua
Add Lucas Creek Scenic Reserve to the schedule. Refer to submission for further details, Vol.
1, page 54/77.
6147-
Whenua
whenua
Add Orewa College to the schedule. Refer to submission for further details, Vol. 1, page
54/77.
6147-
Whenua
whenua
Add Leigh Road, Silverdale to the schedule. Refer to submission for further details, Vol. 1,
page 54/77.
6147-
Whenua
whenua
Add 105 Kowhai Road [either Mairangi Bay or Upper Orewa] to the schedule. Refer to
6147-
Whenua
whenua
Add 115 Kowhai Road [either Mairangi Bay or Upper Orewa] to the schedule. Refer to
6147-
Whenua
whenua
Add Whangaparoa Peninsula Naval Degaussing Site to the schedule. Refer to submission for
further details, Vol. 1, page 55/77.
6147-
Whenua
whenua Add Maungauika to the schedule. Refer to submission for further details, Vol. 1, page 55/77.
139/1145
Sub#/
6147-
Whenua
whenua
Add Te Haupa Island to the schedule. Refer to submission for further details, Vol. 1, page
55/77.
6147-
Whenua
whenua
Add Awataha - St Peters to the schedule. Refer to submission for further details, Vol. 1, page
55/77.
6147-
Whenua
whenua
Add 97 Gladstone Road, Parnell to the schedule. Refer to submission for further details, Vol.
1, page 56/77.
6147-
Whenua
whenua
Add North Shore Site to the schedule. Refer to submission for further details, Vol. 1, page
56/77.
6147-
Whenua
whenua
Add Crown owned land at Mechanics Bay Reserve to the schedule. Refer to submission for
6147-
Whenua
whenua
Add Crown land from Gladstone Park, Parnell to the schedule. Refer to submission for further
6147-
Whenua
whenua
Add Kohimarama area to the schedule. Refer to submission for further details, Vol. 1, page
56/77.
6147-
Whenua
whenua
Add New Zealand Transport Authority land at Mechanics Bay to the schedule. Refer to
6147-
Whenua
whenua
Add 136 Dominion Road, Mt Eden to the schedule. Refer to submission for further details,
Vol. 1, page 56/77.
6147-
Whenua
whenua
Add the former Takapuna Police station to the schedule. Refer to submission for further
6147-
Whenua
whenua
Add 71 Grafton Road, Grafton to the schedule. Refer to submission for further details, Vol. 1,
page 56/77.
6147-
Whenua
whenua
Add Boston Road Probation Service Centre [Mt Eden] to the schedule. Refer to submission
for further details, Vol. 1, page 56/77.
6147-
Whenua
whenua
Add Panmure Probation Service Centre to the schedule. Refer to submission for further
6147-
Whenua
whenua
Add 3 Garfield St [Parnell] to the schedule. Refer to submission for further details, Vol. 1,
page 56/77.
6147-
Whenua
whenua Add Musick Point to the schedule. Refer to submission for further details, Vol. 1, page 56/77.
6147-
Whenua
whenua
Add Manukau Harbour to the schedule. Refer to submission for further details, Vol. 1, page
56/77.
6147-
Whenua
whenua
Add Taurere/Taylors Hill to the schedule. Refer to submission for further details, Vol. 1, page
57/77.
6147-
Whenua
whenua
Add Te Pane o Horoiwi to the schedule. Refer to submission for further details, Vol. 1, page
57/77.
6147-
Whenua
whenua Add Mokoia to the schedule. Refer to submission for further details, Vol. 1, page 57/77.
6147-
Whenua
whenua Add Mauinaina to the schedule. Refer to submission for further details, Vol. 1, page 57/77.
6147-
Whenua
whenua
Add Te Waipuna a Rangiatea to the schedule. Refer to submission for further details, Vol. 1,
page 57/77.
140/1145
Sub#/
6147-
Whenua
whenua
Add Tamaki (Fairburn) Block area to the schedule. Refer to submission for further details, Vol.
1, page 57/77.
6147-
Whenua
whenua
Add Mutukaroa (Hamlins Hill) to the schedule. Refer to submission for further details, Vol. 1,
page 57/77.
6147-
Whenua
whenua Add Maungakiekie to the schedule. Refer to submission for further details, Vol. 1, page 57/77.
6147-
Whenua
whenua Add Maungarei to the schedule. Refer to submission for further details, Vol. 1, page 58/77.
6147-
Whenua
whenua Add Maungawhau to the schedule. Refer to submission for further details, Vol. 1, page 58/77.
6147-
Whenua
whenua Add Mt Albert to the schedule. Refer to submission for further details, Vol. 1, page 58/77.
6147-
Whenua
whenua Add Mt Roskill to the schedule. Refer to submission for further details, Vol. 1, page 58/77.
6147-
Whenua
whenua Add Ohinerau to the schedule. Refer to submission for further details, Vol. 1, page 58/77.
6147-
Whenua
whenua Add Ohuiarangi to the schedule. Refer to submission for further details, Vol. 1, page 58/77.
6147-
Whenua
whenua Add Otahuhu to the schedule. Refer to submission for further details, Vol. 1, page 58/77.
6147-
Whenua
whenua
Add Tmaki Makaurau Waters to the schedule. Refer to submission for further details, Vol. 1,
page 58/77.
6147-
Whenua
whenua
Add Motukaraka Island to the schedule. Refer to submission for further details, Vol. 1, page
58/77.
6147-
Whenua
whenua Add Matukutururu to the schedule. Refer to submission for further details, Vol. 1, page 58/77.
6147-
Whenua
whenua Add Rarotonga to the schedule. Refer to submission for further details, Vol. 1, page 59/77.
6147-
Whenua
whenua Add Takarunga to the schedule. Refer to submission for further details, Vol. 1, page 59/77.
6147-
Whenua
whenua
Add Te Tatua a Riukiuta to the schedule. Refer to submission for further details, Vol. 1, page
59/77.
6147-
Whenua
whenua Add Kawarahi to the schedule. Refer to submission for further details, Vol. 1, page 59/77.
6147-
Whenua
whenua
Add Kohimarama, Stone Cottage, to the schedule. Refer to submission for further details, Vol.
1, page 59/77.
6147-
Whenua
whenua
Add Awataha Marae to the schedule. Refer to submission for further details, Vol. 1, page
59/77.
6147-
Whenua
whenua
Add Alamein and Lake Housing Block, New Zealand Defence Force, to the schedule. Refer to
6147-
Whenua
whenua
Add Correlle Housing Block, New Zealand Defence Force, to the schedule. Refer to
141/1145
Sub#/
6147-
Whenua
whenua
Add Potter/Greenslade Housing Block, New Zealand Defence Force, to the schedule. Refer to
6147-
Whenua
whenua
Add Tennyson Housing Block, New Zealand Defence Force, to the schedule. Refer to
6147-
Whenua
whenua
Add Whangapararoa Training Centre, New Zealand Defence Force, to the schedule. Refer to
6147-
Whenua
whenua
Add Navy Museum Site at Torpedo Bay, New Zealand Defence Force, to the schedule. Refer
to submission for further details, Vol. 1, page 60/77.
6147-
Whenua
whenua
Add 45 Calliope Road, Devonport, New Zealand Defence Force, to the schedule. Refer to
6147-
Whenua
whenua
6147-
Whenua
whenua
6147-
Whenua
whenua
Add Ruapotaka Marae to the schedule. Refer to submission for further details, Vol. 1, page
60/77.
6147-
Whenua
whenua
Add Tapapakanga River (Riverbed) to the schedule. Refer to submission for further details,
Vol. 1, page 60/77.
6147-
Whenua
whenua Add Hunua to the schedule. Refer to submission for further details, Vol. 1, page 60/77.
6147-
Whenua
whenua Add Karaka Bay to the schedule. Refer to submission for further details, Vol. 1, page 60/77.
6147-
Whenua
whenua
Add Panmure Lagoon to the schedule. Refer to submission for further details, Vol. 1, page
60/77.
6147-
Whenua
whenua Add East Wairoa to the schedule. Refer to submission for further details, Vol. 1, page 60/77.
6147-
Whenua
whenua Add Pawhetau to the schedule. Refer to submission for further details, Vol. 1, page 60/77.
6147-
Whenua
whenua Add Waitawa to the schedule. Refer to submission for further details, Vol. 1, page 61/77.
6147-
Whenua
whenua Add Tawhitokino to the schedule. Refer to submission for further details, Vol. 1, page 61/77.
6147-
Whenua
whenua Add Koherurahi to the schedule. Refer to submission for further details, Vol. 1, page 61/77.
6147-
Whenua
whenua Add Te Kawakawa to the schedule. Refer to submission for further details, Vol. 1, page 61/77.
6147-
Whenua
whenua Add Orere North to the schedule. Refer to submission for further details, Vol. 1, page 61/77.
6147-
Whenua
whenua Add Orere Taupo to the schedule. Refer to submission for further details, Vol. 1, page 61/77.
6147-
Whenua
whenua Add Owairaka to the schedule. Refer to submission for further details, Vol. 1, page 61/77.
142/1145
Sub#/
6147-
Whenua
whenua Add Waiatarua to the schedule. Refer to submission for further details, Vol. 1, page 61/77.
6147-
Whenua
whenua Add Tahunatorea to the schedule. Refer to submission for further details, Vol. 1, page 61/77.
6147-
Whenua
whenua
Add Te Pupu o Kawau to the schedule. Refer to submission for further details, Vol. 1, page
62/77.
6147-
Whenua
whenua Add Albert Park to the schedule. Refer to submission for further details, Vol. 1, page 62/77.
6147-
Whenua
whenua Add Myers Park to the schedule. Refer to submission for further details, Vol. 1, page 62/77.
6147-
Whenua
whenua Add Te To to the schedule. Refer to submission for further details, Vol. 1, page 62/77.
6147-
Whenua
whenua
Add Te Wai o Paneiraira to the schedule. Refer to submission for further details, Vol. 1, page
62/77.
6147-
Whenua
whenua
Add Te Ana o Kahumauroa to the schedule. Refer to submission for further details, Vol. 1,
page 62/77.
6147-
Whenua
whenua Add Te Maketu to the schedule. Refer to submission for further details, Vol. 1, page 62/77.
6147-
Whenua
whenua Add Karaka Taupo to the schedule. Refer to submission for further details, Vol. 1, page 62/77.
6147-
Whenua
whenua Add Mtaitai to the schedule. Refer to submission for further details, Vol. 1, page 62/77.
6147-
Whenua
whenua Add Omaru to the schedule. Refer to submission for further details, Vol. 1, page 62/77.
6147-
Whenua
whenua Add Te Hiwa Ra to the schedule. Refer to submission for further details, Vol. 1, page 62/77.
6147-
Whenua
whenua
Add Tamaki Estuary to the schedule. Refer to submission for further details, Vol. 1, page
62/77.
6147-
Whenua
whenua Add Rotopiro to the schedule. Refer to submission for further details, Vol. 1, page 62/77.
6147-
Whenua
whenua
Add Urungahauhau to the schedule. Refer to submission for further details, Vol. 1, page
62/77.
6147-
Whenua
whenua Add Kiripaka to the schedule. Refer to submission for further details, Vol. 1, page 62/77.
6147-
Whenua
whenua Add Rangipakihi to the schedule. Refer to submission for further details, Vol. 1, page 63/77.
6147-
Whenua
whenua
Add Maramarua Crown Forest Licensed Land to the schedule. Refer to submission for further
6147-
Whenua
whenua Add Kohukohunui to the schedule. Refer to submission for further details, Vol. 1, page 63/77.
6147-
Whenua
whenua Add Wharekawa to the schedule. Refer to submission for further details, Vol. 1, page 63/77.
143/1145
Sub#/
6147-
Whenua
whenua
Add Mangoparerua P on Motuihe Island to the schedule. Refer to submission for further
6147-
Whenua
whenua
Add Motutapu Island tauranga waka area to the schedule. Refer to submission for further
6147-
Whenua
whenua
Add Tikapa Moana to the schedule. Refer to submission for further details, Vol. 1, page
64/77.
6147-
Whenua
whenua
Add 21-23 Waikare Road, Waiheke Island, to the schedule. Refer to submission for further
6147-
Whenua
whenua
Add 18 Jellicoe Parade, Waiheke Island, to the schedule. Refer to submission for further
6147-
Whenua
whenua Add Aotea Island to the schedule. Refer to submission for further details, Vol. 1, page 64/77.
6147-
Whenua
whenua
Add Rangitoto Island, multiple sites including tihi, to the schedule. Refer to submission for
6147-
Whenua
whenua
Add Waitemata Harbour to the schedule. Refer to submission for further details, Vol. 1, page
64/77.
6147-
Whenua
whenua
Add Motutapu Island to the schedule. Refer to submission for further details, Vol. 1, page
64/77.
6147-
Whenua
whenua
Add Motuihe Island to the schedule. Refer to submission for further details, Vol. 1, page
64/77.
6147-
Whenua
whenua
Add Te Ururoa o Paoa to the schedule. Refer to submission for further details, Vol. 1, page
65/77.
6147-
Whenua
whenua
Add Horuhoru Road (Gannet Rock) to the schedule. Refer to submission for further details,
Vol. 1, page 65/77.
6147-
Whenua
whenua
Add Tarahiki Island (Shag Rock) to the schedule. Refer to submission for further details, Vol.
1, page 65/77.
6147-
Whenua
whenua
Add Papakohatu Island (Crusoe Island) to the schedule. Refer to submission for further
6147-
Whenua
whenua
Add Parish of Waiheke land to the schedule. Refer to submission for further details, Vol. 1,
page 65/77.
6147-
Whenua
whenua Add Ratoroa to the schedule. Refer to submission for further details, Vol. 1, page 65/77.
6147-
Whenua
whenua Add Ponui to the schedule. Refer to submission for further details, Vol. 1, page 65/77.
6147-
Whenua
whenua Add Pakihi to the schedule. Refer to submission for further details, Vol. 1, page 65/77.
6147-
Whenua
whenua
Add Rakino/Motuhurakina to the schedule. Refer to submission for further details, Vol. 1,
page 65/77.
6147-
Whenua
whenua
Add Motuhoropapa to the schedule. Refer to submission for further details, Vol. 1, page
65/77.
6147-
Whenua
whenua Add Otata to the schedule. Refer to submission for further details, Vol. 1, page 65/77.
144/1145
Sub#/
6147-
Whenua
whenua Add Te Mata to the schedule. Refer to submission for further details, Vol. 1, page 65/77.
6147-
Whenua
whenua
Add Motuketekete Island to the schedule. Refer to submission for further details, Vol. 1, page
65/77.
6147-
Whenua
whenua
Add Te Putiki o Kahumatamoemoe to the schedule. Refer to submission for further details,
Vol. 1, page 65/77.
6147-
Whenua
whenua
Add Matietie Bay Historic Reserve to the schedule. Refer to submission for further details,
Vol. 1, page 66/77.
6147-
Whenua
whenua
Add Hangarua Bay to the schedule. Refer to submission for further details, Vol. 1, page
66/77.
6147-
Whenua
whenua Add Hoporata to the schedule. Refer to submission for further details, Vol. 1, page 66/77.
6147-
Whenua
whenua Add Piritaha to the schedule. Refer to submission for further details, Vol. 1, page 66/77.
6147-
Whenua
whenua Add Tawaipareiwa to the schedule. Refer to submission for further details, Vol. 1, page 66/77.
6147-
Whenua
whenua Add Piritahi Marae to the schedule. Refer to submission for further details, Vol. 1, page 66/77.
6147-
Whenua
whenua Add Te Huruhi to the schedule. Refer to submission for further details, Vol. 1, page 66/77.
6147-
Whenua
whenua Add Ostend to the schedule. Refer to submission for further details, Vol. 1, page 66/77.
6147-
Whenua
whenua Add Whakanewha to the schedule. Refer to submission for further details, Vol. 1, page 66/77.
6147-
Whenua
whenua Add Rangihoua to the schedule. Refer to submission for further details, Vol. 1, page 66/77.
6147-
Whenua
whenua Add Opotopoto to the schedule. Refer to submission for further details, Vol. 1, page 66/77.
6147-
Whenua
whenua Add Te Matuku to the schedule. Refer to submission for further details, Vol. 1, page 66/77.
6147-
Whenua
whenua
Add Kaiaua/Whakatiwai to the schedule. Refer to submission for further details, Vol. 1, page
67/77.
6147-
Whenua
whenua
Add Thames Foreshore and Seabed to the schedule. Refer to submission for further details,
Vol. 1, page 67/77.
6147-
Whenua
whenua Add Wairoa River to the schedule. Refer to submission for further details, Vol. 1, page 67/77.
6147-
Whenua
whenua Add Poupipi to the schedule. Refer to submission for further details, Vol. 1, page 67/77.
6147-
Whenua
whenua Add Waikaka to the schedule. Refer to submission for further details, Vol. 1, page 67/77.
6147-
Whenua
whenua Add Te Aute to the schedule. Refer to submission for further details, Vol. 1, page 67/77.
145/1145
Sub#/
6147-
Whenua
whenua
Add Te Raho o Mahia to the schedule. Refer to submission for further details, Vol. 1, page
67/77.
6147-
Whenua
whenua Add Weiti to the schedule. Refer to submission for further details, Vol. 1, page 67/77.
6147-
Whenua
whenua
Add Motuora Island to the schedule. Refer to submission for further details, Vol. 1, page
67/77.
6147-
Whenua
whenua Add Rocky Islets to the schedule. Refer to submission for further details, Vol. 1, page 67/77.
6147-
Whenua
whenua
Add Taurangamaro Island to the schedule. Refer to submission for further details, Vol. 1,
page 67/77.
6147-
Whenua
whenua
Add Whi tapu sites from the Ngti Paoa Resource Management Plan. Refer to submission
for further details and map, Vol. 1, page 68/77 [Note - map is too small to be able to clearly
see sites].
6147-
Whenua
whenua
Add Wai Kokota and Te To, area of Fanshawe St between Halsey St and Beaumont St, to the
schedule. Refer to submission for further details, Vol. 1, pages 69 and 70/77.
6147-
Whenua
whenua
Add Wai Ariki, beginning at Victoria St volcanic vent, Auckland Central, to the schedule. Refer
to submission for further details, Vol. 1, page 69 and 70/77.
6147-
Whenua
whenua
Retain ID 002 'Te Tokaroa - Te Arapekapeka a Ruarangi' in the schedule. Refer to
6147-
Whenua
whenua
Retain ID 003 'Te Rangimatarau' in the schedule. Refer to submission for further details, Vol.
1, page 71/77.
6147-
Whenua
whenua
Retain ID 005 'Onemaru' in the schedule. Refer to submission for further details, Vol. 1, page
71/77.
6147-
Whenua
whenua
Retain ID 006 'Te Koraenga Oka' in the schedule. Refer to submission for further details, Vol.
1, page 71/77.
6147-
Whenua
whenua
Retain ID 007 'Takarehaea' in the schedule. Refer to submission for further details, Vol. 1,
page 71/77.
6147-
Whenua
whenua
Retain ID 010 'Anzac Ave, Te Toanga Roa' in the schedule. Refer to submission for further
6147-
Whenua
whenua
Retain ID 011 'Te To' in the schedule. Refer to submission for further details, Vol. 1, page
71/77.
6147-
Whenua
whenua
Retain ID 013 'Te Paneiriiri' in the schedule. Refer to submission for further details, Vol. 1,
page 71/77.
6147-
Whenua
whenua
Retain ID 014 'Te Hika a Rama' in the schedule. Refer to submission for further details, Vol.
1, page 71/77.
6147-
Whenua
whenua
Retain ID 016 'Pa above Te Waihorotiu' in the schedule. Refer to submission for further
6147-
Whenua
whenua
Retain ID 017 'Te Whatu' in the schedule. Refer to submission for further details, Vol. 1, page
71/77.
6147-
Whenua
whenua
Retain ID 020 'Te Koranga' in the schedule. Refer to submission for further details, Vol. 1,
page 71/77.
6147-
Whenua
whenua
Retain ID 021 'Te Reuroa me Waipapa' in the schedule. Refer to submission for further
146/1145
Sub#/
6147-
Whenua
whenua
Retain ID 022 'Urupa Pakuranga' in the schedule. Refer to submission for further details, Vol.
1, page 71/77.
6147-
Whenua
whenua
Retain ID 023 'Urupa East Tamaki' in the schedule. Refer to submission for further details,
Vol. 1, page 71/77.
6147-
Whenua
whenua
Retain ID 024 'Urupa East Tamaki' in the schedule. Refer to submission for further details,
Vol. 1, page 71/77.
6147-
Whenua
whenua
Retain ID 025 'Te Pane o Horoiwi' in the schedule. Refer to submission for further details, Vol.
1, page 71/77.
6147-
Whenua
whenua
Retain ID 038 'Urupa Kawakawa Bay' in the schedule. Refer to submission for further details,
Vol. 1, page 71/77.
6147-
Whenua
whenua
Vol. 1, page 71/77.
6147-
Whenua
whenua
Vol. 1, page 71/77.
6147-
Whenua
whenua
Vol. 1, page 71/77.
6147-
Whenua
whenua
Retain ID 043 'Urupa Orere-Matengarahi' in the schedule. Refer to submission for further
6147-
Whenua
whenua
Retain ID 045 'Oue Pa' in the schedule. Refer to submission for further details, Vol. 1, page
71/77.
6147-
Whenua
whenua
Add Otakawhe Bay Recreation Reserve, Hunterville Road, Waiheke Island, to the schedule.
Refer to submission for further details, Vol. 1, page 72/77.
6147-
Whenua
whenua
Add Mawhitipana Recreation Reserve, Rocky Bay, Waiheke Island, to the schedule. Refer to
6147-
Whenua
whenua
Add Rata Street Reserve, Blackpool, Waiheke Island, to the schedule. Refer to submission
6147-
Whenua
whenua
Add Waiheke Farm, to the schedule. Refer to submission for further details, Vol. 1, page
72/77.
6147-
Whenua
whenua
Add Pakatoa Island, to the schedule. Refer to submission for further details, Vol. 1, page
72/77.
6147-
Whenua
whenua
Add Motukaha Island, to the schedule. Refer to submission for further details, Vol. 1, page
72/77.
6147-
Whenua
whenua
Add Whitford Point Recreation Reserve, Te Iwirahirahi, Kawakawa Bay, to the schedule.
6147-
Whenua
whenua
Add Waitawa Regional Park to the schedule. Refer to submission for further details, Vol. 1,
page 72/77.
6147-
Whenua
whenua
Add Point England Recreation Reserve, Point England to the schedule. Refer to submission
6147-
Whenua
whenua
Add Ngahue Recreation Reserve to the schedule. Refer to submission for further details, Vol.
1, page 72/77.
6147-
Whenua
whenua
Add Te Morehu Scenic Reserve, Kawakawa Bay, to the schedule. Refer to submission for
147/1145
Sub#/
6147-
Whenua
whenua
Add Kaiaua School to the schedule. Refer to submission for further details, Vol. 1, page
72/77.
6147-
Whenua
whenua
Add Miranda Taramaire Wildlife Management Reserve, Miranda to the schedule. Refer to
6147-
Whenua
whenua
Add Vining Scenic Reserve to the schedule. Refer to submission for further details, Vol. 1,
page 72/77.
6147-
Whenua
whenua
Add Mangatawhiri Forest Conservation Area, Mangatawhiri to the schedule. Refer to
6147-
Whenua
whenua
Add 141 Beach Road, Castor Bay to the schedule. Refer to submission for further details, Vol.
1, page 72/77.
6147-
Whenua
whenua
Add 253 Hibiscus Coast Highway, Orewa to the schedule. Refer to submission for further
6147-
Whenua
whenua
Add 10 Homestead Drive, Mt Wellington to the schedule. Refer to submission for further
6147-
Whenua
whenua
Add Fort Takapuna Recreation Reserve, Takapuna to the schedule. Refer to submission for
6147-
329 Ngti Paoa Iwi Trust Board admin@ngatipaoaiwi.co.nz RPS Mana Whenua B5 Strategic
Retain the development of co-governance and co-management arrangements as a way of
fulfilling kaitiaki responsibilities. Refer to submission for further details, Vol. 1, page 76/77.
6147-
Retain initiatives that management wai as a complete body of water, and as an open system.
6147-
Involve Ngti Paoa actively in the design and development of plans and decision-making
tools. Refer to submission for further details, Vol. 1, page 76/77.
6147-
Retain activities that encourage the use of traditional Ngti Paoa names for places as a way
to identify and reconnect. Refer to submission for further details, Vol. 1, page 76/77.
6147-
Encourage Council to consider opportunities that regional parks can contribute to the
aspirations of Nagti Paoa, including co-governance and co-management of parks, facilitate
ongoing access to traditional resources and activities, practical opportunities of Ngti Paoa
rangers to support physical connection to the whenua and council's responsibilities to Ngti
Paoa interests, and set aside space in spaces for cultural and commercial cultural
activities. Refer to submission for further details, Vol. 1, page 76/77.
6147-
Consider purchasing, or jointly purchasing with Ngti Paoa, lands that Ngti Paoa wish to
repatriate such as Mokoia P and Kohimarama. Refer to submission for further details, Vol. 1,
page 77/77.
6147-
Involve Ngti Paoa in council processes and decisions relating to the disposal of council land
so as to facilitate the return of lands that Ngti Paoa have an interest in back to Ngti Paoa
ownership. Refer to submission for further details, Vol. 1, page 77/77.
6147-
Undertake due diligence of all Council owned properties to identify the associated Mori
interests, including future interests that relate to those lands, to form the basis for the way in
which those lands are managed. Refer to submission for further details, Vol. 1, page 77/77.
6148-1 Shona Day johnday@zip.co.nz RPS Mana Whenua B5 Strategic Delete Iwi provisions.
6149-1 Ross and Pamela Hood diana@opc.net.nz Zoning North and Islands
Rezone land on Tauhoa Road, Kaipara Flats (Pt Allotment 100 PSH of Tauhoa, Pt Allotment
102 PSH of Tauhoa, Lot 1 DP 185663, Lot 2 DP 185663, Lot 9 DP 156611 and Lot 12 DP
156611) from Rural Production to Countryside Living
6150-1 NCI Packaging (NZ) Limited Helen.Webb@urs.com Zoning Central
Rezone 80 Mount Wellington Highway from Light Industry to a combination of General
Business and Mixed Use.
6150-2 NCI Packaging (NZ) Limited Helen.Webb@urs.com Contaminated Land
H4.5.4 Assessment Delete rule 21.4 or amend it to clarify its purpose is not onerous or unnecessary.
6150-3 NCI Packaging (NZ) Limited Helen.Webb@urs.com
(ITA)
(ITA) H4.8.1 Activity table Amend to make [the activity table] consistent with regional Air, Land and Water Plan.
(ITA)
(ITA)
H4.8.2 Controls/ H4.8.3
Assessment Amend [Controls] to be consistent with regional Air, Land and Water Plan.
148/1145
Sub#/
(ITA)
(ITA)
H4.8.2 Controls/ H4.8.3
Assessment
Amend [Matters of discretion and Assessment criteria] to be consistent with regional Air, Land
and Water Plan.
(ITA)
(ITA) H4.8.4 Table of ITAs Amend to make consistent with Regional Air, Land and Water Plan.
6150-7 NCI Packaging (NZ) Limited Helen.Webb@urs.com General Chapter G General provisions G2.2 Activities not provided for
Change the activity status of activities which are not specifically listed in PAUP from non-
complying to discretionary.
6150-8 NCI Packaging (NZ) Limited Helen.Webb@urs.com General Chapter G General provisions G2.4 Notification Retain non-notification provisions of rule 4.1
6150-9 NCI Packaging (NZ) Limited Helen.Webb@urs.com Zoning Central ADDITIONAL POINT - SEE QA SHEET...
6150-10 NCI Packaging (NZ) Limited Helen.Webb@urs.com Zoning Central Rezone 80 Mount Wellington Highway from Light Industry to General Business.
6150-11 NCI Packaging (NZ) Limited Helen.Webb@urs.com Zoning Central Rezone 80 Mount Wellington Highway from Light Industry to Mixed Use.
6151-1 R and D J Duthie jo.mcdonald@kipt.co.nz Zoning North and Islands Retain growth in the Birkenhead Town Centre.
6151-2 R and D J Duthie jo.mcdonald@kipt.co.nz Zoning North and Islands Retain Single House zoning of 163 Hinemoa Street, Birkenhead and Birkenhead Point.
6151-3 R and D J Duthie jo.mcdonald@kipt.co.nz Residential zones Residential Land use controls Retain density of 1:500m2 in the Single House zone.
6151-4 R and D J Duthie jo.mcdonald@kipt.co.nz
SEAs
Areas - Land rules (all)
Amend Activity Table allowing the 1:500m2 density (Single House zone) to be taken as an
average across the gross site area where a SEA overlay is applied.
6151-5 R and D J Duthie jo.mcdonald@kipt.co.nz
SEAs
Land
Amend extent of the SEA at 163 Hinemoa Street, Birkenhead. [refer map on page 3/3 of
submission].
6152-1 Dilworth Body Corporate anderson_eden@hotmail.com City Centre Zone I4 Rules/Appendix 7.1- 7.3 Retain the view protection for Dilworth Terrace
6152-2 Dilworth Body Corporate anderson_eden@hotmail.com
Centre) Business
Special information
requirements
Amend rule 5.5 'Building Heights' to read '(1) Buildings must not exceed 20m in height except
for land located on Lot 1 DP 315246 which is also subject to the View Protection Plane for
Dilworth Terrace under Rule I.4.4.4.6
6153-1 Ngati Te Ahiwaru nzwahine@hotmail.com General Chapter A Introduction A3 Strategic Framework
Clarify the use of the Mori Responsive Framework for individual Te Ahiwaru and Mana
Whenua.
6153-2 Ngati Te Ahiwaru nzwahine@hotmail.com RPS Mana Whenua
Mtauranga & tikanga
Develop a co-management model with Te Ahiwaru and Mana Whenua in the management of
natural resources.
6153-3 Ngati Te Ahiwaru nzwahine@hotmail.com Mana Whenua General provisions
assessment
Amend PAUP so that the cultural impact assessment provisions are not used when
maintenance is required for 'needed' services in emergency situations eg
stormwater/wastewater.
6153-4 Ngati Te Ahiwaru nzwahine@hotmail.com Definitions Existing Amend definition of 'Integrated Mori Development' to include reference to customary use.
assessment
Amend PAUP to ensure that sensitive information on a cultural impact assessment is
protected.
6153-6 Ngati Te Ahiwaru nzwahine@hotmail.com General Cross plan matters Amend PAUP to integrate iwi management plans into regional plans.
6153-7 Ngati Te Ahiwaru nzwahine@hotmail.com RPS Mana Whenua B5 Strategic Amend PAUP to incorporate Mori values,Tikanga and Kaitiakitanga.
6153-8 Ngati Te Ahiwaru nzwahine@hotmail.com RPS
character and natural heritage B4.3.4 Biodiversity Amend PAUP to recognise and protect indigenous biodiversity.
6153-9 Ngati Te Ahiwaru nzwahine@hotmail.com RPS Coastal B7 Strategic
Amend PAUP to protect and restore the three harbours with priority given to Manukau
Harbour.
6153-10 Ngati Te Ahiwaru nzwahine@hotmail.com RPS Mana Whenua B5 Strategic
Amend PAUP to recognise Mtauranga Mori as being of value and as a specialist
component by the council with the management of natural resources.
6153-11 Ngati Te Ahiwaru nzwahine@hotmail.com General Miscellaneous Consultation and engagement
Ensure there is early engagement with Te Ahiwaru and Mana Whenua on natural resource
management.
6153-12 Ngati Te Ahiwaru nzwahine@hotmail.com General Cross plan matters
Amend PAUP to provide stronger wording by removing "consideration of Mori Values' and
replace with "must apply Mori values when dealing with natural resource".
6153-13 Ngati Te Ahiwaru nzwahine@hotmail.com RPS Natural resources
B6.3 Freshwater and
Geothermal Water Amend freshwater management policy to in-coorporate mori values
6153-14 Ngati Te Ahiwaru nzwahine@hotmail.com Mana Whenua
Whenua
Amend PAUP to ensure that there is protection of sites of significance from development
inclusive of sports and recreational themed activities.
6153-15 Ngati Te Ahiwaru nzwahine@hotmail.com Water Wastewater
H4.16 Wastewater network
management rules
Amend PAUP to include consideration of mori cultural heritage and landscape in all
discharge of wastewater applications.
6153-16 Ngati Te Ahiwaru nzwahine@hotmail.com General Cross plan matters
Amend PAUP so where there is a modified site, continued development is not impeded
through overlays.
6153-17 Ngati Te Ahiwaru nzwahine@hotmail.com Mana Whenua
Whenua
Amend PAUP to recognise Te Ahiwaru and Mana Whenua knowledge as experts on the
history when identifying sites of significance.
discovery protocol
Amend PAUP to ensure that where Kiwi are found on or about development site
the accidental discovery protocols are followed.
6153-19 Ngati Te Ahiwaru nzwahine@hotmail.com RPS Mana Whenua
and cultural development Amend PAUP to give more flexibility for the development of Papakinga for Mori housing.
6153-20 Ngati Te Ahiwaru nzwahine@hotmail.com General Chapter G General provisions
refer to Designations theme) Reduce council costs for large scale Papakinga development.
149/1145
Sub#/
6153-21 Ngati Te Ahiwaru nzwahine@hotmail.com Mana Whenua Auckland wide - Mori Land
controls Amend to provide and allow for a wider range of activities on Mori Land.
controls
Amend activity table to include buildings associated with cultural and rural commercial
services on Mori Land.
controls Amend provisions to increase threshold to 10 homes for Papakinga development.
6153-24 Ngati Te Ahiwaru nzwahine@hotmail.com General Miscellaneous Other Adopt the relief sought by Te Ahiwaru and Makaurau Marae Mori Trust Inc.
6153-25 Ngati Te Ahiwaru nzwahine@hotmail.com General Miscellaneous Other Increase allowance for Pou Haki
assessment
Amend PAUP to recognise Mana Whenua values through integrating Mtauranga and
Tikanga in the management of natural and physical environment which directs applicants to
provide a cultural impact assessment where Mana Whenua values may be affected.
assessment
Amend provisions to ensure that when determining when a cultural impact assessment may
be required is determined by Mana Whenua.
6153-28 Ngati Te Ahiwaru nzwahine@hotmail.com General Miscellaneous Other Use mediation where conflict may occur over cultural impact assessments.
6153-29 Ngati Te Ahiwaru nzwahine@hotmail.com Water Wastewater H4.15 Onsite wastewater rules
Amend PAUP to include consideration of mori cultural heritage and landscape in all
discharge of wastewater applications.
6154-1 Priscilla Steel priscilla.steel@mac.com Mana Whenua General provisions
assessment
Amend provisions that require a resource consent and associated fee for Iwi to give approval
for works
6155-1 Andrew Mackenzie and Family andrew@seaforth.co.nz General Chapter A Introduction A3 Strategic Framework Retain section 3.3.
6155-2 Andrew Mackenzie and Family andrew@seaforth.co.nz RPS
Transport B3.3 Transport Retain Objectives 1-4.
6155-3 Andrew Mackenzie and Family andrew@seaforth.co.nz RPS Coastal
environment Retain Objective 1.
environment Retain Policy 2(c).
environment Retain Policy 6.
6155-6 Andrew Mackenzie and Family andrew@seaforth.co.nz RPS Rural B8.3 Rural subdivision Delete Objective 2
6155-7 Andrew Mackenzie and Family andrew@seaforth.co.nz RPS Rural B8.3 Rural subdivision
Amend Objective 2 with text that reads "Further fragmentation of productive rural land by
sporadic and scatted subdivision for urban and rural lifestyle purposes is prevented."
6155-8 Andrew Mackenzie and Family andrew@seaforth.co.nz RPS Rural B8.3 Rural subdivision
Amend Policy 5 with text that reads "Provide new rural lifestyle subdivision in Countryside
Living zones and Rural Coastal Bush Block zones."
6155-9 Andrew Mackenzie and Family andrew@seaforth.co.nz Infrastructure
C1.1 Infrastructure
policies Retain Objective 1.
6155-10 Andrew Mackenzie and Family andrew@seaforth.co.nz Infrastructure
C1.1 Infrastructure
policies Retain Policy 9.
6155-11 Andrew Mackenzie and Family andrew@seaforth.co.nz
SEAs
SEAs
and policies Retain Policy 2.
SEAs
and policies Retain Objective 1, particularly the "provision for reasonable use and development".
SEAs
6155-15 Andrew Mackenzie and Family andrew@seaforth.co.nz Rural Zones General
Add a new zone called "Rural Coastal Bush Block", to provide for coastal properties that are
non-productive and are primarily covered in native vegetation. Provides for new zone
description, objectives, policies and subdivision rules and activity table. See submission for
details; pages 8-14/25.
6155-16 Andrew Mackenzie and Family andrew@seaforth.co.nz General Editorial and Part 6
Remove at I13.4.2.1(a)(ii) the fullstop and replace with a space between 'environment' and
'the'
6155-17 Andrew Mackenzie and Family andrew@seaforth.co.nz Rural Zones
obs & pols Correct mapping errors. See submission for details, page 14/25.
150/1145
Sub#/
6156-1 Hilary Carlile hcarlile@hilary.co.nz Mana Whenua
Whenua J5.2 Rules
Amend the provisions so that there is no need to obtain resource consent for works within
50m of possible archaeological
6156-2 Hilary Carlile hcarlile@hilary.co.nz RPS Mana Whenua B5 Strategic An Independent Review Authority should be appointed by the Government.
6156-3 Hilary Carlile hcarlile@hilary.co.nz RPS Mana Whenua B5 Strategic
The definition of 'significant' should be clarified to cover only areas that are nationally unique
and worthy of special protection by a council (see page 2/3 of the submission for details)
6157-1 Christine E Madsen heritage@ps.gen.nz Historic Heritage (Overlay)
Heritage
Places Protect the architectural character of King Street, Pukekohe.
6157-2 Christine E Madsen heritage@ps.gen.nz
control
Building demolition control J.3.6 Rules and mapping Undertake further investigation to identify dwellings worthy of protection.
6157-3 Christine E Madsen heritage@ps.gen.nz RPS
character and natural heritage B4.2 Special character Provide owners of 1944 dwellings, rates relief and maintenance costs.
6157-4 Christine E Madsen heritage@ps.gen.nz Zoning South Retain Mixed Housing zone on Edinburgh Street, Pukekohe.
6157-5 Christine E Madsen heritage@ps.gen.nz General Miscellaneous
Operational/
Plant more street trees of a suitable variety, and retain existing trees in the Pukekohe Town
Centre.
6157-6 Christine E Madsen heritage@ps.gen.nz RPS Urban growth
quality compact urban form Provide for higher density development around the Central Business District.
6158-1
Coca Cola Amatil (New
Zealand) Limited
michael.hornikel@arrowinternational.
co.nz Precincts - Central New Precincts Other New Precincts
Amend the PAUP to include the use of a Concept Plan for the Coca Cola site at 1 'The Oasis'
Carbine Road, Mt Wellington and to include the existing concept plan provisions that
are contained in the legacy Auckland City Council Isthmus District Plan in G14-17 [See
submission pages 7/29 to 13/29 for details].
6158-2
Coca Cola Amatil (New
Zealand) Limited
michael.hornikel@arrowinternational.
co.nz Precincts - Central New Precincts Other New Precincts
Add a new Precinct for Coca-Cola Amatil New Zealand at 1 'The Oasis' Carbine Road, Mt
Wellington which reflects the existing concept plan provisions in the Isthmus District Plan in
G14-17 [See submission pages 17-13/29 for details].
6159-1 Top Harbour Limited peterr@catobolam.co.nz RPS Urban growth
Retain the provisions relating to enabling quality urban growth (specifically objectives 2.1 and
policies 2.1)
6159-2 Top Harbour Limited peterr@catobolam.co.nz Precincts - North Gulf Harbour
Amend the precinct description to better describe the sub-precincts and to focus on the
comprehensively planned development of a high quality urban environment as the purpose of
the precinct. Refer to the full submission for suggested wording [page 5/15].
Delete objective 1: 'Development is limited to avoid excess pressures on the capacity of the
road and wastewater infrastructure serving the precinct '.
Delete [General] policy 1: 'Limit the total amount of development within the precinct through a
development cap '.
6159-5 Top Harbour Limited peterr@catobolam.co.nz Precincts - North Gulf Harbour Delete [General] policy 4: 'Discourage the conversion of existing dwellings into two dwellings'.
Amend policy 12(a) to remove the expectation that sub-precinct B should have an
architectural theme that is compatible with and complimentary to existing development in sub-
precinct A and around the northern waterway. Refer to the full submission for suggested
Amend policy 15 (relating to sub-precinct C) to reflect that one household unit per 150m
2
is
allowed throughout the sub-precinct.
Delete [sub-precinct C] policy 16: 'Require buildings adjacent to waterways to be designed to
facilitate access to, and safe and secure berthage for, recreational boats '.
Add a new policy: 'Recognise that parts of the Gulf Harbour Marina are privately owned and
will be subject to a degree of private management'.
Amend the boundary between sub-precincts B and C to align with The Anchorage. Refer to
the full submission for a map of the change requested [page 11/15].
6159-11 Top Harbour Limited peterr@catobolam.co.nz Mana Whenua
Whenua
of value to Mana Whenua Delete the overlay [ID 1694], within Gulf Harbour sub-precincts B and C.
6159-12 Top Harbour Limited peterr@catobolam.co.nz Natural Hazards and Flooding Natural Hazards Coastal inundation - maps only
Delete the 'Natural hazards - Coastal Inundation' overlay from Gulf Harbour sub-precincts B
and C.
Delete 'The conversion of a dwelling into a maximum of two dwellings' from rule 1. Activity
table.
Delete the activity 'A framework plan,...not complying with clause 3.3 below' [third row] from
rule 1. Activity table.
Amend the activity status of subdivision, development or buildings that comply with an
approved framework plan (sub-precincts A-D), from discretionary to controlled, in 1. 'Activity
table' [row 4].
Amend the activity status of subdivision, development or buildings that do not comply with an
approved framework plan (sub-precincts A-D), from non-complying to discretionary, in 1.
'Activity table' [row 5].
151/1145
Sub#/
Delete rule 2(1) Notification, relating to public notification of development that does not
comply with the development cap land use control.
Amend rule 2(2) Notification, to read: "... limited notification may be undertaken, including
notice being given to any owner of land within the comprehensive development area sub-
precinct(s) who has not provided their written approval.'
6159-19 Top Harbour Limited peterr@catobolam.co.nz Precincts - North Gulf Harbour Delete land use control 3.1 'Development cap'.
6159-20 Top Harbour Limited peterr@catobolam.co.nz Precincts - North Gulf Harbour Delete land use control 3.3 'Framework plans'.
Amend development control 4.2 'Sub-precinct B - height' (which provides for buildings up to 5
storey in height), to add 'provided that one building only may be erected to a height of 25m'.
6159-22 Top Harbour Limited peterr@catobolam.co.nz Precincts - North Gulf Harbour Delete subdivision control 5.1 'Framework plans'.
Amend precinct plan 1 'Comprehensive development areas' to change the boundaries of
areas 1, 2 and 3 and to create a new area (13). Refer to the full submission for details [page
7/15] and a maps of the changes [figure 4 page 12/15].
6159-24 Top Harbour Limited peterr@catobolam.co.nz General Editorial and Part 6
Amend precinct plan 1 'Gulf Harbour comprehensive development areas' (K5.13 Gulf
Harbour) to remove the apostrophe in 'area' s' (used twice in the precinct plan).
6159-25 Top Harbour Limited peterr@catobolam.co.nz General Chapter G General provisions
G2.3 Rule infringements for
permitted controlled &
restricted discretionary
activities
Retain rule 2.3 ' Rule infringements for permitted, controlled and restricted discretionary
activities'.
environment
Retain the provisions relating to enabling quality urban growth (specifically Objective 2 and
Policy 2).
land for urban development Retain the provisions relating to enabling quality urban growth (specifically objective 2.3.
6159-28 Top Harbour Limited peterr@catobolam.co.nz Zoning North and Islands
Rezone Gulf Harbour sub-precincts B and C, to align the zone boundary between Mixed Use
and Mixed Housing Suburban with The Anchorage [increasing the extent of the Mixed Use
zone and reducing the extent of the Mixed Housing Suburban zone].
6160-1 Christopher J Cambourn conicalco@xtra.co.nz RPS Mana Whenua B5 Strategic No specific decision sought, opposes Mana Whenua provisions.
6161-1 Trevor N Larsen tlarsen@hotmail.co.nz Zoning North and Islands Rezone 221 Amreins Road, Taupaki from Mixed Rural to Countryside Living.
6161-2 Trevor N Larsen tlarsen@hotmail.co.nz Zoning North and Islands
Rezone the area in Taupaki as shown on Attachment D of the submission on page 11/11 from
Mixed Rural to Countryside Living.
6162-1
Kennedy Park WWII
Installations Preservation Trust wingett25@gmail.com Historic Heritage (Overlay)
Heritage
Places Include 139 Beach Road, Castor Bay as a Category A Historic Place
6162-2
Kennedy Park WWII
Installations Preservation Trust wingett25@gmail.com Zoning North and Islands Rezone 141 Beach Rd, Castor Bay to Open Space
6162-3
Kennedy Park WWII
Installations Preservation Trust wingett25@gmail.com Zoning North and Islands Rezone 139 and 141 Beach Road, Castor Bay to avoid intensive development.
6162-4
Kennedy Park WWII
Installations Preservation Trust wingett25@gmail.com Historic Heritage (Overlay)
Heritage
Places
Add 63 World War II Pillboxes around the Auckland region to Appendix 9.1 [Schedule of
Historic Heritage Places]
6163-1 Brendan and Shelagh Meehan meehanfamily@clear.net.nz Precincts - North Smales 2
Amend Objectives and Policies that relate to sub-precinct B to allow for development on the
Smale's land to a scale that will maintain and enhance the amenity of the Single House zone
and its frontage to Lake View Road and Rangitira Avenue, Takapuna. This can be achieved
by way of boundary setbacks and building height controls.
Amend rule 4.2.1(a) to read: '1(a) only detached dwellings no greater than 8m in height and
no closer than 10m to the western edge of the 30m lakeside yard. For the avoidance of doubt
this has the effect of an extended lakeside yard of 40m.'
Amend rule 5.2.1 Building Height, Table 2, to state: Within 10m 20m of land
zoned residential (Single House or Mixed Housing Suburban zones), with a maximum of two
storeys.
Amend rule 5.2.1 Building Height, Table 2, to read: 'At a setback of no less than 10m from
within the Lakeside Yard, 'and the Maximum storeys is '2'
Amend the minimum distance specified in Rule 5.2.3, Table 3, to read: Northcote Road: 5m;
Sub-precinct boundary with land zoned Residential - 5m; Lakeside Yard: 40m
Amend Rule 2 Notification to read: 'The council will require public notification as part of any
resource consent applications for framework plans (including amendments or replacement
framework plans). Reference should also be made to notification being likely to be required to
adjoining land owners (not just any land owner within the sub-precinct), especially those to the
south of the site on Rangitira Ave.
152/1145
Sub#/
6163-7 Brendan and Shelagh Meehan meehanfamily@clear.net.nz General Chapter G General provisions
Delete reference to offer 'incentives' to the land owner for the preparation of framework plans,
especially when such incentives involve a potential decrease in inter-site amenity with
neighbouring residents and non-notification of framework plan preparation.
Amend rule 6.3 to include 'inter site amenity with neighbouring residential land' as a specific
assessment criterion for the consideration of framework plans.
6164-1 Carson Duan carson.duan@konicaminolta.co.nz Zoning West
Rezone 45 Boundary Road, 87 and 89 Dundale Avenue, Blockhouse Bay from Single House
to Mixed Housing.
6165-1 Mangawhau Properties Limited lisa.phillimore@gmail.com General Noise and vibration H6.2 Rules
Amend noise levels for all activities as follows, 'Monday to Saturday 7am - 10pm and Sunday
6165-2 Mangawhau Properties Limited lisa.phillimore@gmail.com General Noise and vibration H6.2 Rules
Amend rule 1.3 Recreational noise as follows: 'Monday to Saturday 7am - 10pm and Sunday
6165-3 Mangawhau Properties Limited lisa.phillimore@gmail.com Air Quality H4.1 Auckland wide rules
Food, animal or plant matter
processes
Amend PAUP to include rules restricting odours from businesses such as restaurants, cafes
and produce stores.
6165-4 Mangawhau Properties Limited lisa.phillimore@gmail.com
sensitive areas rules J6.3 Rules Retain Non-Complying activity status and public notification provisions.
Amend activity status for activities which breach the floor of the volcanic view
shafts or the 8m height sensitive area limit restrictions inside or outside the view shafts to be a
Prohibited activity.
6165-6 Mangawhau Properties Limited lisa.phillimore@gmail.com Zoning Central
Rezone Poronui Street, Oaklands Street, Stokes Road, Eglinton Avenue and Rautangi Road,
Mt Eden from Mixed Housing Urban and Terrace Houses and Apartment Buildings to a zone
that limits height to 8m.
Centre) Business
Park zones Amend the height rules for Mt Eden to: '8 m and maximum two storeys'.
6165-8 Mangawhau Properties Limited lisa.phillimore@gmail.com Public Open Space Zones Public Open Space
Amend notification provisions to require public notification for all public open space activities,
including Permitted and Restricted Discretionary activities, with particular regard to Mt Eden
Reserve, Nicholson Park, Windmill Road Park, Melville Park, Pollard Park, Potters Park and
Three Kings Reserve.
6165-9 Mangawhau Properties Limited lisa.phillimore@gmail.com Public Open Space Zones Public Open Space
Amend provisions to limit the scale, intensity, frequency and hours of operation of community
use of school land, buildings and infrastructure so that it is complementary and secondary to
the educational purposes of the site. Provide for allowable use between 8am and 10pm Mon -
Sat, and 9am to 6pm on Sunday.
6166-1 Phillip Brown philbrown27@gmail.com Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula K5.11 Precinct rules
Delete the proposed development of sub-precinct C and the proposed access ways to Lake
Road, Devonport.
6166-2 Phillip Brown philbrown27@gmail.com RPS Urban growth
quality compact urban form Upgrade Lake Road, Devonport prior to proposed intensification.
6166-3 Phillip Brown philbrown27@gmail.com Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula K5.11 Precinct rules Delete proposal to turn David Street, Bayswater into a through road.
6166-4 Phillip Brown philbrown27@gmail.com Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula K5.11 Precinct rules Amend rules to include developer contributions to pay for upgrades to Lake Road, Devonport.
Upgrade wastewater and stormwater infrastructure prior to proposed intensification of
Devonport. Cost to be covered by developer.
6166-6 Phillip Brown philbrown27@gmail.com Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula K5.11 Precinct rules Add rules on the T3 volcanic view shaft to sub-precinct C provisions
quality compact urban form Upgrade kindergarten, learning centres and schools prior to intensification of Devonport.
6167-1 Paul M Stockman kingstocky@gmail.com RPS Mana Whenua B5 Strategic Oppose Mana Whenua provisions.
6168-1 Sarah Vile snv@ihug.co.nz Zoning Central
No specific decision sought, opposed to zoning of 1 Kelmarna Avenue, Herne Bay as a Local
centre. Due to height, development controls and scale of buildings permitted which would
change the nature of the neighbourhood.
6169-1 Campbell Family Trust
brandon.watts@meredithconnell.co.n
z Rural Zones General I13.1 Activity table
Amend the rules for the Rural Coastal zone to provide for the establishment of one dwelling
per site as a permitted activity
6169-2 Campbell Family Trust
brandon.watts@meredithconnell.co.n
z Zoning West
Revise the rules for 517 Oaia Road, Motutara so that they reflect the existing provisions under
Rule 14.8.2 of the Operative Rodney District Plan
6170-1 Alan S Calvert calverts@gmail.com Subdivision Auckland-wide - general H5.3 - 4 Assessment
Amend Table 13 'Matters of Discretion - subdivision for up to 4' to give council discretion to
allow subdivision in special circumstances such as family amalgamation, for up to 4 titles.
6171-1 Ian and Barbara Dutton barbaradutton@xtra.co.nz Zoning North and Islands
Delete the Future Urban zone at 174 Access Road, Kumeu and the Kumeu/Huapai Triangle
area.
6171-2 Ian and Barbara Dutton barbaradutton@xtra.co.nz Zoning North and Islands Rezone the Kumeu Showgrounds from Rural Production to Public Open Space.
6171-3 Ian and Barbara Dutton barbaradutton@xtra.co.nz
SEAs
table - Vegetation
roads Retain the tree buffer located at Lot 1 DP 79682 [116 Access Road, Kumeu].
6171-4 Ian and Barbara Dutton barbaradutton@xtra.co.nz General Miscellaneous Other
Remove covenants on land surrounding the Kumeu particle board factory [116 Access
Road, Kumeu].
153/1145
Sub#/
6171-5 Ian and Barbara Dutton barbaradutton@xtra.co.nz
managed fill
Amend the PAUP to cease all cleanfill activity in the Kumeu Huapai area until there are
environmental controls in place.
6171-6 Ian and Barbara Dutton barbaradutton@xtra.co.nz General Miscellaneous Other
Oppose the Attwood/Neil Cleanfill application for resource consent in the Kumeu Huapai
area.
6171-7 Ian and Barbara Dutton barbaradutton@xtra.co.nz RPS Urban growth
Amend the PAUP to ensure essential infrastructure is provided in the Kumeu, Huapai area
including safe access to State Highway 16, land to extend Huapai school, footpaths and cycle
lanes and an upgrade of public amenities.
6171-8 Ian and Barbara Dutton barbaradutton@xtra.co.nz RPS Natural resources
B6.3 Freshwater and
Geothermal Water
Establish a regular water testing regime on the Kumeu River to ensure there are no sources
of pollution entering the river.
6171-9 Ian and Barbara Dutton barbaradutton@xtra.co.nz General Noise and vibration
and policies
Amend the noise controls so that there are noise controls for industry located within the
Countryside living and Future Urban zones.
6171-10 Ian and Barbara Dutton barbaradutton@xtra.co.nz General Miscellaneous Rates
Ensure a reasonable percentage of the rates in the Kumeu, Huapai and Riverhead are spent
in the local area.
6171-11 Ian and Barbara Dutton barbaradutton@xtra.co.nz General Miscellaneous Other Object to a windfall tax.
6172-1 Eva Tamura evasamtam@xtra.co.nz Zoning West
Rezone the identified area in Glen Eden to Mixed Housing Urban [refer map identifying area
1, page 4/4 of submission].
Rezone the identified area in Glen Eden from Single House to Mixed Housing Urban. [refer
map identifying area 2, page 4/4 of submission].
Retain Mixed Housing Urban zone in an area of Glen Eden. [refer map identifying area 2,
page 4/4 of submission].
Rezone the identified area in Glen Eden to Mixed Housing Suburban [refer map identifying
area 3, page 4/4 of submission].
Rezone the identified area in Glen Eden from Mixed Housing Suburban to Mixed Housing
Urban. [refer map identifying area 4, page 4/4 of submission].
Retain Mixed Housing Urban zone in an area of Glen Eden. [refer map identifying area 4,
Rezone area in Glen Eden from Mixed Housing Urban to Single House. [refer map identifying
area 5, page 4/4 of submission].
Retain Single House zone in an area of Glen Eden. [refer map identifying area 5, page 4/4 of
submission].
Rezone area in Glen Eden to Mixed Housing Suburban [refer map identifying area 6, page 4/4
of submission].
Rezone area in Glen Eden from Mixed Housing Suburban to Single House. [refer map
identifying area 7, page 4/4 of submission].
Retain Single House zone in an area of Glen Eden. [refer map identifying area 6, page 4/4 of
submission].
Retain Mixed Housing Suburban zone in an area of Glen Eden. [refer map identifying area 8,
6172-13 Eva Tamura evasamtam@xtra.co.nz Built Environment (Overlays)
Protection
Retain ridgeline protection overlay in area identified on map. [refer map identifying area 8,
6173-1
Hatfields Property Holdings
Limited
169A Beach Road, Castor Bay,
Auckland 0620 RPS Changes to the RUB North and Waiheke Island Rezone 47 Otanerua Road, Hatfields Beach from Rural Production to Single House.
6173-2
Limited
Auckland 0620 RPS Changes to the RUB North and Waiheke Island
Amend the location of the RUB so that 47 Otanerua Road, Hatfields Beach is included within
the RUB.
6173-3
Limited
Rezone 47 Otanerua Road and 115 Hillcrest Road, Hatfields Beach from Rural Production to
Countryside Living.
6174-1 William W Rayner brayner@xtra.co.nz Precincts - North Bayswater
objectives and policies Delete all provisions for residential or non-marine related commercial development.
6174-2 William W Rayner brayner@xtra.co.nz Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula K5.11 Precinct rules
Amend the height limit in sub-precinct E from 4 storeys to the level of adjacent residential
zoning [2 storeys].
6174-3 William W Rayner brayner@xtra.co.nz Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula K5.11 Precinct rules Amend the 4 storey height limit in sub-precinct F [to reduce it].
6174-4 William W Rayner brayner@xtra.co.nz Zoning North and Islands
Rezone Devonport Peninsula sub-precinct F [7-37 Ngataringa Rd, Devonport] from Mixed
Housing Suburban to Single House.
6174-5 William W Rayner brayner@xtra.co.nz RPS
Add text to read: The council will develop a rates relief programme to assist and encourage
commercial property owners to carry out earthquake strengthening of historic listed buildings
character and natural heritage B4.2 Special character Add text to title: "Special Heritage Character Areas".
Amend introduction to read 'Special heritage character areas have collective and historic
importance... predominance or groups of pre-1940 buildings...
Clarify only one of the policies outlined in 2 a-c need to be satisfied in order to
identify whether an area meets the criteria.
6174-9 William W Rayner brayner@xtra.co.nz RPS Urban growth
environment
Amend the PAUP to make the Auckland Design Manual a statutory document and
enforceable.
154/1145
Sub#/
6174-10 William W Rayner brayner@xtra.co.nz Historic Heritage (Overlay)
Heritage
Places Add the Devonport commercial centre in Victoria Road as an Historic Heritage Area.
Rezone the eastern side of Wynyard Street, Devonport, from Town Centre zone to Light
Industry zone.
6174-12 William W Rayner brayner@xtra.co.nz Special Character
Amend the overlay rules to better reflect the objectives and policies, so as to retain the special
characteristics of the old Devonport area.
residential
Amend Objectives 10 and 11 and [corresponding] policies to protect the existing residential
character and reflect the strong heritage value of Devonport.
residential
Add new point 12 under sub-heading North Shore: "The survival of the form and pattern of
subdivision, buildings and streetscape in Auckland's early-established residential
neighbourhoods as identified in the special character statement, is ensured."
residential E3.1 Policies Amend policy 6 to read "Identify and manage protect individual buildings..."
residential E3.1 Policies
Add policy under heading All Special Character Overlays - "Control demolition and removal of
houses and control alterations and new building work to retain and enhance coherent
streetscapes and the visual record of earlier settlements."
residential
special character areas Replace the word "manage" throughout with the word "protect".
residential
Add text after point 10: "that development is controlled to ensure retention, maintenance and
enhancement of the heritage character amenity."
Amend policy 18 as follows: Manage development [and change to] Protect retain and
enhance the places, features, qualities and attributes that contribute to the context and
streetscape of the area.
6174-20 William W Rayner brayner@xtra.co.nz
shafts survey coordinates Retain the volcanic viewshafts and height sensitive overlays that apply to Devonport.
Heritage
Incorporate plan change 33, 'Business Built Heritage Area Overlay North Shore', to the
operative North Shore district plan into the PAUP.
Heritage
Places
Add to the schedule the 86 new items from plan change 38 to the operative North Shore
district plan
Residential North Shore
character statement - Res.
North Shore Add the area within sub-precinct E to the Special Character overlay area for Devonport.
6174-24 William W Rayner brayner@xtra.co.nz Precincts - North Devonport Naval Base Amend to include policies from Part 2, Chapter B 4.2 Special Character.
6174-25 William W Rayner brayner@xtra.co.nz Precincts - North HMNZ Dockyard
Amend to comply with Chapter J, 3.4, 6 Assessment [Special character Residential North
Shore]
Heritage
Amend the historic heritage places classification standards to make all Category A* historic
heritage places in North Shore Category A.
Amend policy 56 as follows: 'Require the design of new buildings and alterations to existing
buildings to respond to the character of the area'.
residential E3.1 Policies Amend policy 57 as follows: 'Ensure the retention of special features'.
6174-29 William W Rayner brayner@xtra.co.nz Built Environment (Overlays)
Overlay E4.1/J4.1 Auckland
War Memorial Museum
Viewshaft Retain the Auckland War Memorial Museum viewshaft.
6174-30 William W Rayner brayner@xtra.co.nz Built Environment (Overlays)
Public Views Retain the local public views overlay.
6174-31 William W Rayner brayner@xtra.co.nz Mana Whenua
Whenua
objectives and policies Retain the Mana Whenua provisions.
character and natural heritage B4.3 Natural heritage Retain the natural heritage provisions.
character and natural heritage B4.3.3 Trees and vegetation Retain the notable tree provisions.
Heritage
protocols
Retain heritage impact assessment provisions, particularly provisions on the use of heritage
policy documents. [Rule 2.7.8]
6174-35 William W Rayner brayner@xtra.co.nz General Chapter G General provisions
statements
Retain requirement for heritage impact and cultural impact assessments. Retain rule 26
[specialist reports], particularly arborist, landscape assessments, and heritage/ archaeological
value assessments. [G2.7.1]
155/1145
Sub#/
6174-36 William W Rayner brayner@xtra.co.nz General Chapter G General provisions
statements Retain context analysis provisions
Heritage
protocols
Amend rule 2.7.8(1)(a) to read: the proposal involves substantial alteration, addition or total
demolition of any feature(s) within a scheduled historic heritage place, excluding any features
within scheduled historic heritage places identified in the exclusions column in the schedule of
historic heritage places.
Heritage
J2.5 Special information
requirements
Retain requirement for conservation plans for significant work or alterations for all A and A*
places, subject to the threshold test and the requirement for council approval of conservation
policy documents. [Rule 2.5]
6174-39 William W Rayner brayner@xtra.co.nz General Chapter G General provisions G2.4 Notification
Amend notification provisions so that all resource consent applications will be considered for
possible notification.
6174-40 William W Rayner brayner@xtra.co.nz Residential zones Residential
Amend the Single House zone development controls to require discretionary activity consent
for buildings that infringe height, height in relation to boundary, yards, maximum impervious
area, building coverage or landscaping.
Heritage
Review all Category A* buildings using the assessment criteria with a view to upgrading all A*
buildings to A.
Amend notification rules to require that non-complying and discretionary activities to be
notified.
Heritage
places
Amend the activity status for seismic strengthening from restricted discretionary to
discretionary.
Require all applications for consent on historic heritage places and feature are considered for
notification.
Provide rules for permitted works to site surrounds, interiors, plant and free standing on-
permanent structures similar to those contained in Section 10 of the operative Central area
district plan.
Heritage
requirements
Retain requirement for detailing the methodology for dismantling, removal, relocation and
reassembly of the building or structure or its parts for temporary dismantling for seismic
strengthening.
Amend the North Shore Special Character overlay to add Section J 3.5 and the explanatory
material in the North Shore District Plan Appendices 16, H, I, and N. [submission refers to
attachment that has not been attached].
Residential North Shore J3.4.1-7 Rules Retain height in relation to boundary control [rule 4.2].
Amend the front yard control [rule 4.3] to read: The same as the two adjoining dwellings or the
average setback of the two adjoining dwellings, where they are different or 3m. Whichever is
the greater or more restrictive measurement will be the minimum required setback.
Residential North Shore J3.4.1-7 Rules Amend the garages setback control [rule 4.3] from 1.5m to 3m.
Residential North Shore J3.4.1-7 Rules Retain the building coverage control [rule 4.4]
Residential North Shore J3.4.1-7 Rules Amend the fence control [rule 4.5] by adding Appendix 16N from the North Shore District Plan
6174-53 William W Rayner brayner@xtra.co.nz General Eplan
Amend difference between e-plan and printed version where the index refers to Chapter 'J3.5
Pre-1944 Building Demolition Control' and the printed version refers to 'J3.5 Special
Character Residential'
control
[Retain the pre-1944 demolition control]. [Identify post 1944 character areas and include these
in the PAUP]. [Strengthen the language to include the words "preserve and protect"]. [Amend
the activity status of development modifications, new buildings and structures from restricted
discretionary to discretionary].
features Retain outstanding natural feature provisions
features Retain outstanding natural landscape and outstanding and high natural character provisions
Heritage
Places
Amend Appendix 9.1 to include all interiors except where they have been modified as to have
little or no heritage value.
Retain the concept of historic heritage place including its surround and its identification on the
planning maps
156/1145
Sub#/
Heritage
Places
Identify in Appendix 9 all applicable heritage overlays to include notable trees, geological
features, and significant ecological features [on each property] and create a version which is
searchable by street address.
North Shore Retain Birkenhead Point, Devonport and Northcote Point special character statements
Provide for the reduction/ waiver of consent application costs, the granting of underlying
zoning, development control infringements and funding/ grants for historic heritage places
[page 9/20 of submission]
6174-62 William W Rayner brayner@xtra.co.nz Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula K5.11 Precinct rules [Amend the height rules] to not allow four storey development in sub-precinct E.
residential
Amend the provisions so that Devonport and all North Shore special character business areas
are subject to plan change 33
Rezone the land within[ Devonport Peninsula] sub-precinct F at Wakakura Crescent to Single
House [page 12/20 of the submission]
6174-65 William W Rayner brayner@xtra.co.nz Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula K5.11 Precinct rules
Amend the height rule to [reduce the maximum] from four storeys to two storeys in sub-
precinct F [page 12/20 of the submission]
6174-66 William W Rayner brayner@xtra.co.nz Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Mapping
Delete [sub-precinct F] at Ngataringa Bay and Wakakura Crescent [page 13/20 of the
submission]
features Retain Objectives 1-7 and Policies 1-17 [page 7/20 of the submission.
Rezone Victoria Road, Devonport from Town Centre to historic heritage place [page 8/20 of
the submission]
6174-69 William W Rayner brayner@xtra.co.nz Zoning North and Islands Retain the Single House zoning in Devonport
control
and policies Retain objectives
6174-71 William W Rayner brayner@xtra.co.nz Trees
Trees J6.4 Rules Retain rules
6175-1 Colyer Mair Assets Limited l.marr@harrisongrierson.com Zoning Central Rezone 34-36 Galway Street, Onehunga to Light Industry.
6175-2 Colyer Mair Assets Limited l.marr@harrisongrierson.com Air Quality
Sensitive Activity Restriction Add the Sensitive Activity Restriction Overlay over 34-36 Galway Street, Onehunga.
6175-3 Colyer Mair Assets Limited l.marr@harrisongrierson.com Built Environment (Overlays)
Height Control Remove the Additional Height Control Overlay from 34-36 Galway Street, Onehunga.
6175-4 Colyer Mair Assets Limited l.marr@harrisongrierson.com Zoning Central Rezone 71-105 Onehunga Mall, Onehunga (odd numbers only) to Light Industry.
6175-5 Colyer Mair Assets Limited l.marr@harrisongrierson.com Air Quality
Add the Sensitive Activity Restriction Overlay over 71-105 Onehunga Mall, Onehunga (odd
numbers only).
6175-6 Colyer Mair Assets Limited l.marr@harrisongrierson.com Built Environment (Overlays)
Height Control
Remove the Additional Height Control Overlay from 71-105 Onehunga Mall, Onehunga (odd
numbers only).
6176-1 Shanna Coetzee shanna.coetzee@gmail.com Subdivision Auckland-wide - Urban zones H5.2 3.1 Residential zones
Retain the [addition subdivision control overlay] which has a minimum site area for subdivision
of 750m2 for Hill Park, Manurewa.
6176-2 Shanna Coetzee shanna.coetzee@gmail.com Special Character
residential
Add special character overlay, similar to Isthmus B2 overlay to protect 1960s period housing
in Hill Park, Manurewa.
6176-3 Shanna Coetzee shanna.coetzee@gmail.com Trees
Trees
Notable Trees Extend tree protection in Hill Park, Manurewa.
6177-1 Peter J Douglas-Bell douglasbell@vodafone.co.nz Special Character
General
character statement - General Retain the Special Character overlay applying to Balmoral streets
6177-2 Peter J Douglas-Bell douglasbell@vodafone.co.nz Zoning Central Retain the Single Housing zone applying to Balmoral streets
6177-3 Peter J Douglas-Bell douglasbell@vodafone.co.nz Residential zones Residential
Retain Rule 6.2, Building Height, applying a two storey 8m height limit in the Single House
zone, with particular reference to Balmoral
6177-4 Peter J Douglas-Bell douglasbell@vodafone.co.nz
control
Apply the pre-1944 Building Demolition control to Special Character Areas, particularly in
Balmoral, as interim protection until the PAUP is formally operative
6177-5 Peter J Douglas-Bell douglasbell@vodafone.co.nz Special Character
General
character statement - General Extend the overlay to include all of Kensington Ave, Balmoral, including 59 Kensington Ave
6178-1 Christopher M Ball cball@xtra.co.nz Residential zones Residential
General [Amend provisions to require] larger developments to set aside space for tree planting
6178-2 Christopher M Ball cball@xtra.co.nz
SEAs
table - Vegetation
roads
Add a Coastal zone 50-100m [from mean high water springs] where trees cannot be removed
without consent and pruning is only allowed under strict guidelines
157/1145
Sub#/
6178-3 Christopher M Ball cball@xtra.co.nz Transport Auckland -wide
requirements [Amend] parking provisions [to require more] for new apartments
6179-1 James Investments Trust daniel@sfhconsultants.co.nz Precincts - North Albany 2 Amend K5.3.1 Activity Table to allow for 'offices' up to 500m
2
as a Permitted Activity.
6179-2 James Investments Trust daniel@sfhconsultants.co.nz Precincts - North Albany 2
Amend K5.3.1 Activity Table so 'offices' exceeding 500m
2
are Restricted Discretionary
Activities.
6179-3 James Investments Trust daniel@sfhconsultants.co.nz Precincts - North Albany 2 Amend K5.3.1 Activity Table to provide for 'retail' less than 200m
2
Amend K5.3.1 Activity Table to provide for 'retail' exceeding 200m
2
as a Restricted
Discretionary Activity.
Amend K5.3.1 Activity Table to provide for 'commercial activities' less than 200m
2
as a
Permitted Activity.
Amend K5.3.1 Activity Table to provide for 'commercial activities' that exceed 200m
2
as a
Restricted Discretionary Activity.
6179-7 James Investments Trust daniel@sfhconsultants.co.nz Zoning North and Islands
Rezone Unit 1A, Unit 2A and Unit 6, 78/80, Paul Matthews Road, Rosedale, and land in the
vicinity, from Light Industry to General Busines.
6179-8 James Investments Trust daniel@sfhconsultants.co.nz Precincts - West New Precincts
Add a new precinct to Unit 1A, Unit 2A and Unit 6, 78/80, Paul Matthews Road, Rosedale, to
provide less restrictive objectives and policies and change the activity status of offices
exceeding 500m
2
per site from a Discretionary to a Restricted Discretionary Activity and
generally reflect the existing Rosedale area.
6180-1
The Trustees of the Roseangle
Trust ckirman@ellisgould.co.nz
control
Building demolition control J.3.6 Rules and mapping Retain the exclusion of 36 Pukeora Avenue, Remuera from the overlay.
6181-1 Sladjana Stojanovic stoja59@gmail.com Zoning North and Islands Rezone Bayview Road, Hauraki, Mixed Housing Suburban.
6182-1
Soil and Health Association of
NZ marion.thomson@live.com
organisms
modified organisms Retain wording relating to GMOs.
6183-1 Stephen Havill stephen@sfhconsultants.co.nz RPS Mana Whenua B5 Strategic
Amend the iwi consultation provisions to ensure structure around the fee schedule, time
frame, a co-ordinated iwi response, single cultural impact assessments if required and clarity
around the sites of significance and importance.
6183-2 Stephen Havill stephen@sfhconsultants.co.nz Zoning North and Islands
Rezone areas such as Barrys Point Road, Wairau Valley and North Harbour to reflect their
mixed use and general business direction [as opposed to being zoned Light Industrial].
6183-3 Stephen Havill stephen@sfhconsultants.co.nz RPS Urban growth
Amend the PAUP to ensure that parks and open space, community amenities including
walkways, cycleways, libraries, community gardens and institutional provision such as schools
are provided to enable intensification.
6183-4 Stephen Havill stephen@sfhconsultants.co.nz
SEAs
table - Vegetation
roads Delete proposed rule 4.3 relating to vegetation management.
SEAs
Delete all rules that relate to felling, trimming, damaging or removal of trees within SEA areas
(or which exist elsewhere in the PAUP).
SEAs
table - Vegetation
roads
Amend all rules relating to felling, trimming, damaging or removal of trees to align with the
2009 and 2013 tree laws and the October 2013 consent order and assurances given to the
Environment Court.
SEAs
table - Vegetation
roads
Delete, with immediate effect, all rules that were revoked, with effect from 1 January 2012, by
Section 152 of the Resource Management (Simplifying and Streamlining) Amendment Act
2009.
6184-1 Peter Bosch and Jane Masters pbosch@xtra.co.nz Zoning South Retain Single House zone for 94 Monument Road, Clendon.
6184-2 Peter Bosch and Jane Masters pbosch@xtra.co.nz Precincts - South Clevedon Retain Clevedon sub-precinct 1B over 94 Monument Road, Clendon.
6184-3 Peter Bosch and Jane Masters pbosch@xtra.co.nz Precincts - South Clevedon Retain Clevedon precinct subject to amendments set out in the submission.
6184-4 Peter Bosch and Jane Masters pbosch@xtra.co.nz Precincts - South Clevedon
Add clause to Activity Table to enable subdivision where 1-2 new lots are created in sub-
precincts 1A and 1B as a restricted discretionary activity.
Amend activity status to discretionary for: Subdivision in sub-precincts 1A, 1B and 2 and 3
that does not comply with an approved framework plan, or prior to the approval of a
framework plan.
Amend Activity Table so that subdivision and development in sub-precinct 3 is timed to
coincide with the completion of the public reticulated sewerage system (or other such
suitable timing when certainty regarding public connections to the system for sub-precincts 1,
2 and 4 is achieved).
158/1145
Sub#/
6184-7 Peter Bosch and Jane Masters pbosch@xtra.co.nz Precincts - South Clevedon Retain densities set out in Table 1.
6184-8 Peter Bosch and Jane Masters pbosch@xtra.co.nz Precincts - South Clevedon Delete Rule 4.2(4)(a).
6184-9 Peter Bosch and Jane Masters pbosch@xtra.co.nz Precincts - South Clevedon Amend Rule 4.2(4)(c) to refer to sub-precinct 1A.
6184-10 Peter Bosch and Jane Masters pbosch@xtra.co.nz Precincts - South Clevedon Amend Rule 4.5 'Wastewater' to include sub-precinct 2.
Amend Rules 4.5(1) and 4.5(2) to exclude new activities on existing vacant sites where
domestic type wastewater can be discharged to in accordance with Chapter H, 4.15 On-site
Wastewater rules from non-complying status.
6184-12 Peter Bosch and Jane Masters pbosch@xtra.co.nz General Miscellaneous Other Amend terminology in the Design Guidelines to be consistent with the PAUP.
6185-1 Roger and Diana Brookes
46 Evelyn Road, Cockle Bay,
Auckland 2014 RPS Mana Whenua B5 Strategic Delete Mana Whenua provisions
quality compact urban form Amend to take an area by area approach to development
quality compact urban form [Provide for] the development of un-serviced villages in the countryside to cater for growth
Auckland 2014 Residential zones Residential
General Amend rear yard controls to provide for backyards
Terrace Housing and
Require a playing area for children and green space to be provided for each multi-storey
development
Amend the minimum doorway width in the Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings zone
[rule 9.23(1)(a)] from 810mm to 900mm
Heritage
Places
Amend to provide for greater protection of heritage areas, particularly in the Howick and
Cockle Bay area
Auckland 2014
control
Building demolition control J.3.6 Rules and mapping Extend the pre-1944 building demolition control in Howick
Rezone the areas of Howick that have been changed from Single House in the draft Unitary
Plan back to Single House. Refer to map on page 16/28 in the submission
Mixed Housing Urban zone Amend [rule 7.5 Yards] from 1m to 4m rear yard and 2m side yard.
Auckland 2014 General Chapter G General provisions G2.4 Notification
Amend to require consent from affected parties for controlled and discretionary activities,
particularly height in relation to boundary controls in the Mixed Housing Suburban zone
General
Amend [height in relation to boundary control] to not permit buildings up to or on the
boundary.
Auckland 2014 Residential zones Residential Land use controls Amend [density controls] to limit the number of dwellings permitted on multi unit sites
Auckland 2014 Subdivision Auckland-wide - Urban zones H5.2 3.1 Residential zones
Amend Table 1 to require minimum lot sizes to be met [with no provision to reduce] the stated
size
Auckland 2014 Residential zones Residential Land use controls
Amend the [one dwelling per 200m
2
density provision] in the Mixed Housing Suburban zone
[to lower the density]
Auckland 2014 Subdivision Auckland-wide - Urban zones H5.2 3.1 Residential zones Amend the minimum site size in the Mixed Housing Urban zone from 300m
2
to 280m
2
Amend the minimum dwelling size [rule 9.16] in the Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings
zone from 40m
2
and 45m
2
to 60m
2
and 75m
2
, for small apartments and one bedroom
apartments
Auckland 2014 Public Open Space Zones Public Open Space I2.1 Activity table
Delete provisions for new buildings on public open space, particularly commercial buildings
such as cafes
Auckland 2014
SEAs
Land
No specific decision stated in respect of concerns with the identification of SEA's, particularly
in relation to local reserves in Howick [page 13/28 of the submission]
No specific decision stated in respect of the Mixed Housing Suburban and Mixed Housing
Urban rules relating to garage setbacks, houses face the street and 1.2m limit for fence height
[page 15/28 of the submission]
6186-1 Birch Family Trust daniel@sfhconsultants.co.nz Precincts - North Albany 2 Amend K5.3.1 Activity Table to allow for 'offices' up to 500m
2
6186-2 Birch Family Trust daniel@sfhconsultants.co.nz Precincts - North Albany 2
Amend K5.3.1 Activity Table so 'offices' exceeding 500m
2
are Restricted Discretionary
Activities.
159/1145
Sub#/
6186-3 Birch Family Trust daniel@sfhconsultants.co.nz Precincts - North Albany 2 Amend K5.3.1 Activity Table to provide for 'retail' less than 200m
2
Amend K5.3.1 Activity Table to provide for 'retail' exceeding 200m
2
as a Restricted
Amend K5.3.1 Activity Table to provide for 'commercial activities' less than 200m
2
as a
Permitted Activity.
Amend K5.3.1 Activity Table to provide for 'commercial activities' that exceed 200m
2
as a
Restricted Discretionary Activity.
6187-1 Community of Beth Shalom krisdupreez@gmail.com Zoning Central
Rezone 79 Margot Street, Epsom and neighbours from Single House to Mixed Housing Urban
or Suburban
6188-1 Takapuna Croquet Club g.vaughan@mac.com Precincts - North Takapuna 2
Amend the Precinct description [in F5.48], to include that the purpose of the precinct is to
'protect and enhance the many unique and highly values features in the precinct'.
Amend the precinct provisions to ensure they achieve the purpose of 'protecting and
enhancing the many unique and highly valued features in the precinct'.
Amend the Activity Table [K5.48.1] to add a new Discretionary Activity as follows: 'Areas B
and C: Buildings on sites that contain a shape of 40m (parallel to the road) by 35m (deep)' on
sites immediately north and east of Auburn Reserve as defined on Precinct Plan 1, areas and
frontages.
Amend the Activity Table [K5.48.1] to add a new Discretionary Activity as follows: 'Areas B
and C: Buildings that incorporate a public laneway in accordance with the relevant controls of
this precinct on sites immediately north and east of Auburn Reserve as defined on Precinct
Plan 1, areas and frontages'.
Amend the Activity Table [K5.48.1] to add a new Discretionary Activity as follows: 'Area D:
Buildings on sites immediately north and east of Auburn Reserve as defined on Precinct Plan
1, areas and frontages.'
Amend the Activity Table [K5.48.1] to add a new Discretionary Activity as follows: 'Anzac
Street: New development on sites fronting the appropriate part of the north side of Anzac
Street only of up to 20.5 metres in height and where vehicle access is only from Lomond
Street, Auburn Street or Pupuke Road'.
Amend K5.48.2(1) Notification to read: 'Buildings up to and including four storeys in height
except where they and other activities adjoin, or are likely to have an adverse environmental
effect on, Auburn Reserve. The need for public or limited notification remains for buildings
over four stories in height proposed in this locality.'
6188-8 Takapuna Croquet Club g.vaughan@mac.com Precincts - North Takapuna 2 Amend development control K5.48.3(1) and add the word 'generally' after 'zone apply'.
Amend development control K5.48.3(2) as follows: 'Activities which adjoin or impact on
Auburn Reserve and Buildings that do not comply with these development controls are a
discretionary activity unless otherwise specified.'
Amend the development controls for K5.48.3.1 'Height' and K5.48.3.2 'Frontage height and
street alignment' to ensure they do not have an adverse effect on Auburn Reserve in
Takapuna.
Amend the precinct provisions to ensure that it is acknowledged that in some cases the
building height rules may not always be achievable, in particular around Auburn Reserve in
Takapuna.
Amend development control K5.48.3.6 'Bonus provisions', to ensure that any
adverse environmental effects on Auburn Reserve, Takapuna are avoided/mitigated.
6188-13 Takapuna Croquet Club g.vaughan@mac.com Precincts - North Takapuna 2 Retain development control K5.48.3.7(5)(b) 'Vehicle access, parking and garages'.
Amend development control K5.48.3.7(5)(b) to clarify that the 'setback' is measured from any
reserve boundary and 'frontage' includes any building walls.
Amend assessment criteria 4.2(2)(y) as follows: 'Parking spaces should not be vented (by
either mechanical or natural means) into the adjacent street or adjoining reserve frontage.'
[under K5.48.4]
6188-16 Takapuna Croquet Club g.vaughan@mac.com Precincts - North Takapuna 2 Retain assessment criteria 4.2(1)(m) [under K5.48.4].
Amend assessment criteria 4.2(2)(m)(iii) to ensure that roof top terraces and lift plants or other
items do not add to the overall height of any buildings that adjoin the north and east boundary
of Auburn Reserve, Takapuna or in inappropriate areas on the north side of Anzac Street,
Takapuna [under K5.48.4].
Amend assessment criteria 4.2(2)(z) to add the words 'adjoining reserve' after the word
'streets' [under K5.48.4].
Retain assessment criteria 4.2(2)(ae) in that it includes the wording 'amenity along public
streets and reserves' [under K5.48.4].
Amend the precinct to ensure that the provisions avoid adverse effects from inappropriate
shading of Auburn Reserve, Takapuna.
Retain assessment criteria 4.2(4)(a) in that it includes the wording 'adjoining recreational
areas' [under K5.48.4].
160/1145
Sub#/
Amend assessment criteria 4.2(4)(c) as follows: 'Car parking should be designed with access
from rear laneways or minor streets where this is available and is of sufficient width and
capacity and would not have an adverse environmental effect on Auburn Reserve,
Takapuna' [under K5.48.4].
Amend the precinct provisions to ensure that no laneways or minor streets are constructed on
Auburn Reserve, Takapuna.
Amend assessment criteria 4.2(4)(j) to include the words 'including Auburn Reserve' after the
words 'the street' [under K5.48.4].
Amend assessment criteria 4.2(4)(l) to include the words 'and Auburn Reserve' after the
words 'public place' [under K5.48.4].
Amend assessment criteria 4.2(4)(m) to include the words 'and adjoining Auburn Reserve'
after the words 'street level' and the words 'and Auburn Reserve' after the words 'the street'
[under K5.48.4].
Amend assessment criteria 4.2(4)(p) to include the words 'Auburn Reserve' after the words
'adjacent developments' [under K5.48.4].
Amend assessment criteria 4.2(4)(g) to ensure that adverse wind effects are also avoided or
appropriately mitigated on the sports turf grass at Auburn Reserve, Takapuna [under
K5.48.4].
Amend the special information requirements in K5.48.5.1 to add the words 'and Auburn
Reserve' after the words 'other buildings'.
6188-30 Takapuna Croquet Club g.vaughan@mac.com Precincts - North Takapuna 2 Amend Precinct Plan 2 [in K5.48.6], to remove the building recession plane (d) to (d).
6188-31 Takapuna Croquet Club g.vaughan@mac.com Zoning North and Islands
Retain the Public Open Space - Active Sport and Recreation zone at Auburn Reserve,
Takapuna.
6188-32 Takapuna Croquet Club g.vaughan@mac.com Residential zones
pols
Amend the Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings zone to ensure 'other' objectives are
also achieved.
Add new policy [to F5.48] as per Policy 1.1(1) of the general residential zone to ensure that
developments should contribute positively, rather than adversely affect to public open spaces
such as Auburn Reserve and the Takapuna Croquet Club sports turf croquet lawns.
Amend the provisions in the PAUP to recognise that the sport and croquet lawns at Auburn
Reserve, Takapuna is a 'highly valued feature' [as described in the Mayor's Forward] and
should be protected and enhanced.
Amend the PAUP to do more to 'promote the sustainable management of natural and physical
resources' in particular the potential degradation / loss of the croquet lawns at Auburn
Reserve in Takapuna has not been adequately addressed.
Amend the precinct to ensure that in addition to encouraging good design and development
that the precautionary principle should be used when assessing activities on land immediately
north and east of Auburn Reserve and particularly land on the south side of Anzac Street and
the west side of Auburn Street, Takapuna [Refer to page 3/21 of the submission].
6189-1
New Zealand Disability
Support Network clareteague@nzdsn.org.nz Residential zones Residential Activity Table Amend the activity table to delete the activity 'Supported residential care'.
6190-1 Watercare Services Limited igotelli@water.co.nz Designations Watercare Services Ltd
9343 Warkworth Wastewater
Treatment Plant
Retain the inclusion of all Watercare Services Limited designations in the PAUP [subject to
minor alterations].
9300 Sunset Road Reservoir
and Pump Station Structures
Amend the description (designation schedule), to read: 'Water supply purposes - pump
station, reservoir, pump station and associated structures'.
9301 Schapper Rock Road
Pump Station and Future
Reservoirs
Amend the description (designation text), to read: 'Water supply purposes - reservoirs, water
pump station, future reservoirs and associated structures'.
Reservoirs
Amend the location (designation text), to read: '53 Schnapper Rock Road, Schnapper Rock
Albany '.
Reservoirs
Amend the designation name (designation text), to read: 'Schnapper Rock Road Pump
Station and Future Reservoirs'.
9302 Pupuke Road Reservoir
and Pump Station Amend location (designation text), to read: '106 Pupuke Road, Northcote Hillcrest'.
9303 Killarney Street Pump
Station Amend the purpose (designation schedule), to read: 'Water supply P purposes'.
9303 Killarney Street Pump
Station
Amend the location (designation text), to read: '39 Killarney Street and part of the adjoining
road reserve, Takapuna'.
6190-9 Watercare Services Limited igotelli@water.co.nz Designations Watercare Services Ltd 9304 Waipa Street Reservoirs
Amend purpose (designation schedule), to read: 'Water S supply purposes - reservoirs and
associated structures'.
161/1145
Sub#/
9305 Upper Harbour Drive
Reservoir Retain designation as notified.
6190-11 Watercare Services Limited igotelli@water.co.nz Designations Watercare Services Ltd 9306 Pinehill Reservoir Amend location (designation schedule) to read: '192A Browns Bay Road, Murrays Bay'.
6190-12 Watercare Services Limited igotelli@water.co.nz Designations Watercare Services Ltd 9306 Pinehill Reservoir Amend location (designation text) to read: '192A Browns Bay Road, Murrays Bay'.
6190-13 Watercare Services Limited igotelli@water.co.nz Designations Watercare Services Ltd 9307 Mairangi Bay Reservoir Retain designation as notified.
9308 Forrest Hill Reservoir and
Pump Station
Amend description [purpose] (designation schedule), to read: 'Water supply purposes -
reservoirs and associated structures'.
9309 Corinthian Drive
Reservoirs Retain designation as notified.
9310 Rosedale Wastewater
Treatment Plant Odour Buffer
Area
Amend description [purpose] (designation schedule) to read: 'Wastewater purposes - waster
water treatment plant odour buffer area.'
Area
Amend location (designation text), to read : 'Rosedale Park, and reserves, roads and
motorway in the vicinity of the Ww astewater Tt reatment Plant'.
Area
Amend description [purpose] (designation text) to read: 'Wastewater purposes - wastewater
treatment plant odour buffer area'.
Treatment Plant
Amend description [purpose] (designation schedule), to read: 'Wastewater purposes -
wasterwater treatment plant and underground route of outfall to Mairangi Bay'.
Treatment Plant
Amend description [location] (designation schedule), to read: 'Rosedale Road and Upper
Harbour Highway, Albany, then via various properties and roads to Mairangi Bay'.
9312 Easter Parade Pump
Station
Amend purpose (designation schedule), to read: 'Water supply Wastewater purposes - pump
station and associated structures'.
9313 Colwill Road Pump
Station
9314 Phillip Avenue Pump
Station
Amend purpose (designation schedule), to read: 'Water suppl y Wastewater purposes - pump
9315 McEntee Road
Reservoirs
9316 Massey West Reservoir
(Massey High School) Retain designation as notified.
9317 Swanson Reservoirs
(Scenic Drive North)
9318 Titirangi Reservoir
(Scenic Drive) Retain designation as notified.
6190-28 Watercare Services Limited igotelli@water.co.nz Designations Watercare Services Ltd 9319 Bush Road Reservoirs
6190-29 Watercare Services Limited igotelli@water.co.nz Designations Watercare Services Ltd 9320 Huia Road Reservoir Retain designation as notified.
9321 Waitakere Ranges
Catchment Headworks Areas Amend conditions to update all legacy plan references.
Catchment Headworks
Services Land
Amend description [purpose] (designation text) to read: 'Water supply purposes - headworks
services land'.
Catchment Headworks
Services Land Amend conditions to update all legacy plan references.
9323 Waitakere Water
Treatment Plant Amend conditions to update all legacy plan references.
9324 Huia and Nihotupu Water
Treatment Plants Amend conditions to update all legacy plan references.
9325 Sunnyvale Reservoir
(Waikumete Cemetery) Amend location (designation schedule), to read: '88 Sunhill Road, Glen Eden Sunnyvale'.
(Waikumete Cemetery) Amend location (designation text), to read: '88 Sunhill Road, Glen Eden Sunnyvale'.
(Waikumete Cemetery) Amend conditions to update all legacy plan references.
(Konini Road) Amend conditions to update all legacy plan references.
(Konini Road)
Delete condition 3 and explanatory text, relating to heritage effects [on features that are in a
different location and are not relevant to the site].
9327 The Concourse Storage
Tanks Amend conditions to update all legacy plan references.
162/1145
Sub#/
9328 Te Atatu South Pump
Station (Flanshaw Road)
Station (Flanshaw Road) Amend location (designation schedule), to read: '143 Flanshaw Road, Te Atatu South'.
Station (Flanshaw Road) Amend conditions to update all legacy plan references.
Station (Flanshaw Road)
Delete condition 3 and explanatory text, relating to heritage effects [on features that are in a
different location and are not relevant to the site].
9329 Titirangi Pump Station
(Pleasant Road) Amend conditions to update all legacy plan references.
9330 Te Atatu Peninsula Pump
Station (Kelvin Crescent)
Station (Kelvin Crescent) Amend conditions to update all legacy plan references.
Station (Te Atatu Road)
Amend purpose (designation schedule), to read: 'Water supply purposes - water treatment
plant Wastewater purposes - pump station and associated structures'.
Station (Te Atatu Road) Amend conditions to update all legacy plan references.
(Wood Bay Beach Reserve)
Amend purpose (designation schedule), to read: 'Water supply purposes - water treatment
plant Wastewater purposes - pump station and associated structures'.
(Wood Bay Beach Reserve) Amend conditions to update all legacy plan references.
9333 Laingholm Pump Station
(Laingholm Drive)
9334 Fred Taylor Drive Pump
Station
Station
Amend description [purpose] (designation text) to read: 'Wastewater Purposes pump station
and associated structures Construction and operation of a wastewater pump station pump
station and associated structures to service the new town centre of Massey North. The
proposed wastewater pumping station includes: an underground storage tank, wet well with
submersible pumps, control building, mechanical and electrical installation, siteworks, planting
and permanent access road .'
Station Delete all conditions [construction conditions].
Station
Delete designation attachments, Drawing No 131837.100R2 'Massey North Pumping Station
Control Building' and Drawing No 131837.021 'Proposed Design for Massey North Pumping
Station'.
9335 Wellsford Water
Treatement Plant Amend name (designation text), to read: '9335 Wellsford Water Treate ment Plan'.
6190-58 Watercare Services Limited igotelli@water.co.nz Designations Watercare Services Ltd 9336 Wellsford Reservoirs
9337 Wellsford Wastewater
Treatment Plant
Amend location (designation schedule), to read: 'Between State Highway 1 and Rustybrook
Road (Lot 3 DP 64870), Wellford'.
9338 Omaha Reservoirs
(Omaha Drive)
9339 Matakana Wastewater
Treatment Plant Retain designation as notified.
9340 Omaha Wastewater
9341 Warkworth Reservoir
(View Road) Retain designation as notified.
9342 Warkworth Water
9343 Warkworth Wastewater
9344 Snells Reservoir (James
Street)
Amend location (designation schedule), to read: '2 James Street, Snells Beach, and adjoining
properties (Lots 1 and 2 DP 205704).
9345 Warkworth Reservoir
(Tudor Collins Drive) Retain designation as notified.
163/1145
Sub#/
9346 Snells Water Treatment
Plant
Amend description [purpose] (designation schedule) to read: 'Wastewater Water supply
purposes - waste water treatment plant'.
9347 Snells Beach
Wastewater Treatment Plant Amend conditions to update all legacy plan references.
9348 Waiwera Wastewater
Treatment Plant
Amend location (designation schedule), to read: 'Weranui Road, iIn the vicinity of 135
Weranui Road, Waiwera'.
6190-71 Watercare Services Limited igotelli@water.co.nz Designations Watercare Services Ltd 9349 Waiwera Reservoirs
9350 Orewa Reservoir (West
Hoe Road) Retain designation as notified.
6190-73 Watercare Services Limited igotelli@water.co.nz General Eplan
Amend the E-plan maps, to correct where properties on West Hoe Heights, Orewa are
identified in the property summary results as being located on West Hoe Road (e.g. 138 West
Hoe Heights, Orewa).
9351 Orewa Wastewater
9352 Silverdale Reservoir
(Wainui Road) Amend location (designation schedule), to read: '105 Wainui Road, Silverdale'.
9353 Red Beach Reservoirs
(Whangaparaoa Road)
Amend description (designation schedule), to read: 'Water supply purposes - reservoirs and
associated structures'.
(Whangaparaoa Road)
Amend location (designation schedule), to read: '231 Whangaparaoa Road, Whangaparaoa
Red Beach'.
(Whangaparaoa Road)
Amend location (designation text), to read: '231 Whangaparaoa Road, Whangaparaoa Red
Beach'.
9354 Arkles Bay Reservoirs
(Wade River Road)
9355 Tindalls Bay Reservoirs
(Whangaparaoa Road)
(Whangaparaoa Road)
Amend location (designation schedule), to read: '1170 Whangaparaoa Road, Tindalls Bay
Beach'.
(Whangaparaoa Road) Amend location (designation text), to read: '1170 Whangaparaoa Road, Tindalls Bay Beach'.
9356 Helensville Wastewater
9357 Helensville Dams
(Mangakura Dams 1-5) Retain designation as notified.
9358 Helensville Reservoir
(Wishart Road)
Amend location (designation text), to read: 'Wishart Road (between 156-166), (Sec 62 BLK
XIV Kaipara Survey District SO 47866 (0.2966HA), Helensville'
9358 Helensville Reservoir
(Wishart Road)
Amend location (designation schedule), to read: 'Wishart Road (Sec 62 BLK XIV Kaipara
Surevey District SO 47866 (0.2966HA), Helensville'
9359 Huapai Wastewater
9360 Muriwai Water Treatment
Plant
Amend location (designation schedule), to read: '156 148-162 Motutara Road, Muriwai
Beach'.
9360 Muriwai Water Treatment
Plant Amend location (designation text), to read: '156 148-162 Motutara Road, Muriwai Beach'.
9361 Dwelling Exclusion Area -
Wellsford Wastewater
9362 Army Bay Wastewater
Snells Beach Wastewater
Waiwera Wastewater
Treatment Plant
Amend location (designation text), to read: 'Land surrounding the wastewater treatment
ponds, Weranui Road (including 135 Weranui Road and 12, 45, 83 and 105 Jarvis Road),
Waiwera'.
Orewa Wastewater Treatment
Plant Retain designation as notified.
9366 Orewa Reservoir (West
Hoe Heights) Retain designation as notified.
9367 Glenvar Reservoir
(Lonely Track Road)
Amend description [purpose] (designation schedule), to read: ' Water supply purposes - pump
station and associated S structures (including power supply and telementry) '
164/1145
Sub#/
(Lonely Track Road)
Amend description [purpose] (designation text), to read: ' Water supply purposes - pump
station and associated structures (including power supply and telementry) '.
(Lonely Track Road) Delete all conditions [construction conditions].
(Lonely Track Road) Delete attachment, Plan Number 2001111-03 - Site Plan.
6190-
100 Watercare Services Limited igotelli@water.co.nz Designations Watercare Services Ltd
9368 Redvale Pump Station
(East Coast Road)
Amend location (designation schedule), to read: 'East Coast Road (road reserve) south -
vicinity of Bawden Road, Redvale.'
6190-
9369 Wade Heads Reservoir
(Scott Road) Delete all conditions [construction conditions].
6190-
9370 Orewa Pump Station and
Associated Network (Millwater
Parkway) Retain designation as notified.
6190-
9371 Massey Pump Station
(Triangle Road)
Amend E-plan maps and location (designation text and schedule), to reduce the designation
extent (to only apply to Section 1 SO 466232) once construction works are completed in late
2014.
6190-
9400 Westmere Park Pump
Station
Amend location (designation schedule and text) to be consistent. [Specific wording not
provided.]
6190-
9401 Herne Bay (Cox's Bay
Reserve) Pump Station Retain designation as notified.
6190-
9402 Farnham Street Pump
Station
provided.]
6190-
107 Watercare Services Limited igotelli@water.co.nz Designations Watercare Services Ltd 9403 St Heliers Water Tower Retain designation as notified.
6190-
9404 Harbour View Road
Pump Station Retain designation as notified.
6190-
9405 Wainui Avenue Pump
Station
provided.]
6190-
9406 Oliver Street Pump
Station
provided.]
6190-
9407 Wright Road Pump
Station
provided.]
6190-
112 Watercare Services Limited igotelli@water.co.nz Designations Watercare Services Ltd 9408 Ponsonby Reservoirs Retain designation as notified.
6190-
9409 Khyber Reservoir
Complex and Pump Station
6190-
9409 Khyber Reservoir
Complex and Pump Station
Clarify whether the designation extends to the north-eastern boundary in the same alignment
as Auckland Transport designation 1596 'Council carpark'.
6190-
9410 Auckland Domain
Reservoir
6190-
9412 Shore Road Pump
Station
provided]
6190-
117 Watercare Services Limited igotelli@water.co.nz Designations Watercare Services Ltd 9413 Orakei Pump Station Retain designation as notified.
6190-
9414 Kohimarama Pump
Station
provided]
6190-
119 Watercare Services Limited igotelli@water.co.nz Designations Watercare Services Ltd 9415 Glendowie Pump Station
provided]
6190-
9416 Rosebank Siphon
Chamber Retain designation as notified.
6190-
9417 Mt Eden Domain
Reservoirs
provided]
6190-
9418 Mt Hobson Domain High
Reservoirs
provided]
6190-
123 Watercare Services Limited igotelli@water.co.nz Designations Watercare Services Ltd 9419 St Johns Reservoir Retain designation as notified.
6190-
124 Watercare Services Limited igotelli@water.co.nz Designations Watercare Services Ltd 9420 Mt Albert Reservoir Retain designation as notified.
6190-
125 Watercare Services Limited igotelli@water.co.nz Designations Watercare Services Ltd 9421 Mt Albert Pump Station Retain designation as notified.
6190-
9422 Edendale Branch
Overflow Apron
Amend purpose (designation schedule), to read: 'Wastewater purposes - Overflow Apron
Structure'.
6190-
Overflow Apron
Amend purpose (designation text), to read: 'Wastewater purposes - Overflow Apron
Structure'.
165/1145
Sub#/
6190-
Overflow Apron
Amend suburb in location (designation schedule and text) to be consistent. [Specific wording
not provided]
6190-
9423 Mt Hobson Domain Low
6190-
9424 Point England (Maybury
Reserve) Pump Station
Amend location (designation schedule), to read: '40 Maybury Street (Maybury Reserve), Point
England'.
6190-
9424 Point England (Maybury
provided]
6190-
9425 Point England (Riverside
Avenue) Pump Station
Amend location (designation text), to read: 192A Riverside Avenue (Riverside Reserve), Point
England'.
6190-
9427 Three Kings Low
Reservoir
provided]
6190-
9427 Three Kings Low
Reservoir
Amend heading under 'Attachments', to read: 'Designation Plan - 9427 Three Kings Reserve
Low Reso ervoir'.
6190-
9429 Onehunga High
Reservoir
provided.]
6190-
9430 Campbell Road
Reservoirs and Pump Station
provided.]
6190-
137 Watercare Services Limited igotelli@water.co.nz Designations Watercare Services Ltd 9431 Cornwall Park Reservoir
provided.]
6190-
9432 Onehunga Low
Reservoirs and Pump Station
provided.]
6190-
9433 Panmure Basin Pump
Station
provided.]
6190-
9434 Mt Wellington Domain
High Reservoir
provided.]
6190-
9435 Mt Wellington Domain
Low Reservoir
provided.]
6190-
9436 Avondale (Miranda
provided.]
6190-
143 Watercare Services Limited igotelli@water.co.nz Designations Watercare Services Ltd 9437 Mt Roskill Reservoir
provided.]
6190-
9438 Mt Wellington (Bowden
Road) Pump Station
provided.]
6190-
145 Watercare Services Limited igotelli@water.co.nz Designations Watercare Services Ltd 9439 Lynfield Pump Station Retain designation as notified.
6190-
9440 Hillsborough Pump
Station Amend location (designation schedule), to read: '39 Frederick Street, Hillsborough'.
6190-
Station Amend location (designation text), to read: '39 Frederick Street, HI illsborough'.
6190-
Station Amend E-plan maps.
6190-
9441 Onehunga (Alfred Street)
6190-
9442 Onehunga Water
Treatment Plant
Amend location (designation text), to read: '2 Spring Street, and Rowe Street road reserve
(adjacent to 2 Spring Street) Onehunga.
6190-
9443 Onehunga (Pearce
Street) Water Supply Well
Amend purpose (designation schedule), to read: 'Water Ss upply purposes - supply well,
pump station and associated structures'.
6190-
9443 Onehunga (Pearce
Street) Water Supply Well
Amend E-plan maps to improve usability, in particular to more easily identify designation
boundaries.
6190-
9444 Onehunga (Upper
Municipal Place) Water Supply
Well
Amend purpose (designation schedule), to read: 'Water S supply purposes - supply well,
6190-
9445 Onehunga (Lower
Municipal Place) Water Supply
Well
Amend purpose (designation schedule), to read: 'Water S supply purposes - supply well,
6190-
9446 Bycroft Reserve Water
Protection Reserve Amend conditions to update all legacy plan references.
6190-
156 Watercare Services Limited igotelli@water.co.nz Designations Watercare Services Ltd 9447 Hunua No. 4 Watermain
provided.]
6190-
9448 Onehunga (Miami
Parade) Pump Station Retain designation as notified.
166/1145
Sub#/
6190-
9449 Te Papapa (Mt Smart)
6190-
9450 Eastern Interceptor
Siphon Chamber Retain designation as notified.
6190-
9451 Mt Wellington (Bell
Avenue) Pump Station Retain designation as notified.
6190-
9452 Challenge Siphon
Chamber (Salesyards Road) Retain designation as notified.
6190-
9453 Otahuhu (Saleyards
Road) Pump Station Retain designation as notified.
6190-
9454 Otahuhu (Luke Street)
6190-
9455 Otahuhu (Portage Road)
6190-
9456 Cracroft Street Water
Supply Chamber Retain designation as notified.
6190-
9457 Constitution Hill Pump
Station
Amend purpose (designation text), to delete the two sentences from 'Existing pump station ...
works. '
6190-
9458 Fanshawe Street Pump
Station
Amend location (designation text), to read: 'Hardinge Street (r Road reserve (between 120
Hardinge Street and 136-142 Fanshawe Street), Auckland Central'.
6190-
168 Watercare Services Limited igotelli@water.co.nz Designations Watercare Services Ltd 9500 Cosseys Dam Retain designation as notified.
6190-
9501 Headworks Service
Lands (Cosseys)
headworks service lands'.
6190-
9501 Headworks Service
Lands (Cosseys)
Amend description [purpose] (designation text), to read: 'Water supply purposes - headworks
service lands'.
6190-
9502 Mangere Wastewater
Treatment Plant
Amend 'Attachments' to replace incorrect figure Figure 5.7 - Area Included in the Foreshore
and Coastal Restoration Plan.
6190-
9503 Odour Buffer Area -
Mangere Wastewater
Treatment Plant
Amend description [purpose] (designation schedule), to read: 'Wastewater purpose - Area 1A -
wastewater treatment purposes; Area 1B and 2 - odour buffer area and application of bio-
solids from wastewater treatment plant'.
6190-
9503 Odour Buffer Area -
Mangere Wastewater
Treatment Plant
Amend description [purpose] (designation text), to read: 'Wastewater purpose - Area 1A -
wastewater treatment purposes; Area 1B and 2 - odour buffer area and application of bio-
solids from wastewater treatment plant'.
6190-
174 Watercare Services Limited igotelli@water.co.nz Designations Watercare Services Ltd 9504 Mangere Pipeline Amend location (designation text [schedule]), to read: '4W Wilta Witla Court, Mangere'
6190-
175 Watercare Services Limited igotelli@water.co.nz Designations Watercare Services Ltd 9505 Flat Bush Pump Station Retain designation as notified.
6190-
9506 Redoubt North
Reservoirs Retain designation as notified.
6190-
177 Watercare Services Limited igotelli@water.co.nz Designations Watercare Services Ltd 9507 Redoubt Road Reservoir
Amend location (designation schedule), to read: '477A Redoubt Road (Pt Lot 1 DP 24865 and
SO 60815), Manukau Central'.
6190-
178 Watercare Services Limited igotelli@water.co.nz Designations Watercare Services Ltd 9507 Redoubt Road Reservoir
Amend location (designation text), to read: '477A Redoubt Road (Pt Lot 1 DP 24865 and SO
60815), Manukau Central'.
6190-
9508 Mill Road Reservoir
Complex Retain designation as notified.
6190-
180 Watercare Services Limited igotelli@water.co.nz Designations Watercare Services Ltd 9509 Mill Road Reservoir Retain designation as notified.
6190-
181 Watercare Services Limited igotelli@water.co.nz Designations Watercare Services Ltd 9510 Ardmore Pump Station
Amend description [purpose] (designation text), to read: 'Water supply purposes - pump
station, reservoir, pump station and associated structures'.
6190-
9511 Wastewater purposes
and Ambury Regional Park Retain designation as notified.
6190-
183 Watercare Services Limited igotelli@water.co.nz Designations Watercare Services Ltd 9512 East Tamaki Reservoir Retain designation as notified.
6190-
9513 Ardmore Water
Treatment Plant
Amend E-plan maps, as designation 9513 is identified in the property summary results for 264
Creightons Road, Clevedon [though the mapped designation extent does not include this
property].
6190-
9513 Ardmore Water
Treatment Plant
Ardmore W water T treatment P plant'.
6190-
9514 McLaughlins Pump
Station Retain designation as notified.
6190-
9515 Papatoetoe Pump
167/1145
Sub#/
6190-
188 Watercare Services Limited igotelli@water.co.nz Designations Watercare Services Ltd 9516 Howick Pump Station Retain designation as notified.
6190-
9517 Middlemore Pump
6190-
190 Watercare Services Limited igotelli@water.co.nz Designations Watercare Services Ltd 9518 Manurewa Pump Station Retain designation as notified.
6190-
9519 Manurewa West Pump
Station
Amend location (designation schedule), to read: '283R Maha ia Road (pt Lot 1 DP 25887 and
SO 46795), Manurewa.
6190-
9519 Manurewa West Pump
Station
Amend location (designation text), to read: '283R Maha ia Road (pt Lot 1 DP 25887 and SO
46795), Manurewa.
6190-
9520 Pakuranga South Pump
6190-
9521 Bucklands Beach Pump
Station
Amend location (designation schedule) to read: '2A Vivian Wilson Drive and part of 150
Bucklands Beach Road, Bucklands Beach Eastern Beach'.
6190-
9521 Bucklands Beach Pump
Station
Amend location (designation text) to read: '2A Vivian Wilson Drive and part of 150 Bucklands
Beach Road, Bucklands Beach Eastern Beach'.
6190-
9522 East Tamaki Pump
6190-
197 Watercare Services Limited igotelli@water.co.nz Designations Watercare Services Ltd 9523 Mangere Pump Station Retain designation as notified.
6190-
198 Watercare Services Limited igotelli@water.co.nz Designations Watercare Services Ltd 9524 Otara Pump Station Retain designation as notified.
6190-
9525 Pakuranga North Pump
Station
Amend description [purpose] (designation schedule), to read: 'Wastewater purposes - pump S
6190-
9526 Pakuranga (Millen
Avenue) Pump Station Amend location (designation schedule), to read: 13 and 15R Millen Avenue Pakuranga'.
6190-
9527 Mangere Bridge Pump
6190-
9528 Greenmount Branch
Sewer Retain designation as notified.
6190-
9529 Southwestern Interceptor
Line Retain designation as notified.
6190-
204 Watercare Services Limited igotelli@water.co.nz Designations Watercare Services Ltd 9530 Botany Pump Station Retain designation as notified.
6190-
9531 Weymouth North Pump
Station Amend location (designation schedule), to read: 54R Pitt Avenue, Weymouth, Clendon Park'.
6190-
9531 Weymouth North Pump
Station Amend location (designation text), to read: 54R Pitt Avenue, Weymouth, Clendon Park'.
6190-
207 Watercare Services Limited igotelli@water.co.nz Designations Watercare Services Ltd 9532 Weymouth Pump Station Retain designation as notified.
6190-
208 Watercare Services Limited igotelli@water.co.nz Designations Watercare Services Ltd 9533 Manurewa Pump Station Retain designation as notified.
6190-
9534 Mangere (Hinau Street)
Pump Station
Amend location (designation schedule), to read: '2A and 4 Hinau Street Road, and 6R
Walmsley Road (Tarata Creek Reserve), Mangere.
6190-
9534 Mangere (Hinau Street)
Pump Station
Amend location (designation text), to read: '2A and 4 Hinau Street Road, and 6R Walmsley
Road (Tarata Creek Reserve), Mangere.
6190-
211 Watercare Services Limited igotelli@water.co.nz Designations Watercare Services Ltd 9535 Maraetai Pump Station Retain designation as notified.
6190-
212 Watercare Services Limited igotelli@water.co.nz Designations Watercare Services Ltd 9536 Manurewa Reservoir Amend location (designation schedule), to read: 37 Walpole Avenue, Manurewa Hill Park'.
6190-
9537 Beachlands Wastewater
Treatement Plant
Amend location (designation schedule), to read: '100 Okaroro Road Drive, Maretai
Beachlands'.
6190-
Treatement Plant Amend location (designation text), to read: '100 Okaroro Road Drive, Maretai Beachlands'.
6190-
Treatement Plant
Amend description [purpose](designation schedule) to read: 'Wastewater purposes -
Beachlands W wastewater T treatment P plant'.
6190-
Treatement Plant
Amend description [purpose](designation text) to read: 'Wastewater purposes - Beachlands W
wastewater T treatment P plant'.
6190-
9538 Tamaki South East
Branch Sewer Delete conditions 1, 2, 3, 5 and 6 (relating to construction).
168/1145
Sub#/
6190-
9539 Kawakawa Bay
Wastewater Treatment Plant
Amend description [purpose](designation schedule) to read: 'Wastewater purposes -
Kawakawa Bay W wastewater T treatment P plant'.
6190-
9539 Kawakawa Bay
Amend description [purpose](designation text) to read: 'Wastewater purposes - Kawakawa
Bay W wastewater T treatment P plant'.
6190-
220 Watercare Services Limited igotelli@water.co.nz Designations Watercare Services Ltd 9540 Hunua No. 4 Watermain
Amend location (designation text), to read: 'Williams Road (Lot 1 DP 73307 and Lot 1 DP
154681), Glenbrook 396B Redoubt Road to Mangere Bridge, Hugh Watt Drive, Mangere'.
6190-
221 Watercare Services Limited igotelli@water.co.nz Designations Watercare Services Ltd 9541 Cosseys Dam Retain designation as notified.
6190-
222 Watercare Services Limited igotelli@water.co.nz Designations Watercare Services Ltd 9542 Wairoa Dam Retain designation as notified.
6190-
9543 Wairoa Headworks
Service Land Retain designation as notified.
6190-
9544 Waiuku Wastewater
Treatment Plant
Amend location (designation schedule), to read: 'Near Williams Road (lot 1 DP 73307 and Lot
1 DP 154681), Glenbrook'.
6190-
Treatment Plant
Amend description [purpose] (designation schedule) to read: 'Wastewater purposes - Waiuku
Wastewater Treatment Plant wastewater treatment plant'.
6190-
Treatment Plant
Amend description [purpose] (designation text) to read: 'Wastewater purposes - Waiuku
6190-
9545 Clarks Beach
Amend description [purpose] (designation schedule) to read: 'Wastewater purposes - Clarks
Beach Wastewater Treatment Plant wastewater treatment plant'.
6190-
9545 Clarks Beach
Amend description [purpose] (designation text) to read: 'Wastewater purposes - Clarks Beach
6190-
9546 Bombay Wastewater
Treatment Plant
Amend location (designation schedule), to read: 'Barber Road (Lot 10 DP 134365 BLK IX
OPAHEKE SD-LOCAL PURPOSE RESERVE), Bombay Township'.
6190-
Treatment Plant
Amend location (designation text), to read: 'Barber Road (Lot 10 DP 134365 BLK IX
OPAHEKE SD-LOCAL PURPOSE RESERVE), Bombay Township'.
6190-
Treatment Plant
Amend description [purpose] (designation schedule) to read: 'Wastewater purposes - Bombay
6190-
Treatment Plant
Amend description [purpose] (designation text) to read: 'Wastewater purposes - Bombay
6190-
9547 Kingseat Wastewater
Treatment Plant Amend location (designation schedule), to read: '16A Buchanan Road, Kingseat Papkura'.
6190-
Treatment Plant Amend location (designation text), to read: '16A Buchanan Road, Kingseat Papkura'.
6190-
Treatment Plant
Amend description [purpose] (designation schedule) to read: 'Wastewater purposes -
Kingseat Wastewater Treatment Plant wastewater treatment plant'.
6190-
Treatment Plant
Amend description [purpose] (designation text) to read: 'Wastewater purposes - Kingseat
6190-
9548 Pukekohe (Totara
Avenue) Reservoir
Amend location (designation schedule), to read: 'end of Totara Avenue (Roosesville Park),
Pukekohe'.
6190-
Avenue) Reservoir
Amend location (designation text), to read: 'end of Totara Avenue (Roosesville Park),
Pukekohe'.
6190-
Avenue) Reservoir
Amend description [purpose] (designation schedule) to read: 'Wastewater purposes -
Kingseat Wastewater Treatment Plant wastewater treatment plant'.
6190-
Avenue) Reservoir
Amend description [purpose] (designation text) to read: 'Wastewater purposes - Kingseat
6190-
9549 Pukekohe (Kitchener
Road) Reservoirs Retain designation as notified.
6190-
9550 Pukekohe (Anzac Road)
Reservoir
Pukekohe Water Reservoir reservoirs and associated structures'
6190-
243 Watercare Services Limited igotelli@water.co.nz Designations Watercare Services Ltd 9551 Pukekohe Hill Reservoir Retain designation as notified.
6190-
244 Watercare Services Limited igotelli@water.co.nz Designations Watercare Services Ltd 9552 Clarks Beach Reservoir
reservoir, pump station and associated structures'.
6190-
245 Watercare Services Limited igotelli@water.co.nz Designations Watercare Services Ltd 9552 Clarks Beach Reservoir
Clarify that the legal description for the designation text and the E-plan Maps property
summary is consistent.
6190-
246 Watercare Services Limited igotelli@water.co.nz Designations Watercare Services Ltd 9553 Waiau Beach Reservoir
Amend location (designation schedule), to read: 'Road Reserve and part Part of 129 Wharf
Road (l Lot 2 DP 458020), Waiau Beach'.
6190-
247 Watercare Services Limited igotelli@water.co.nz Designations Watercare Services Ltd 9553 Waiau Beach Reservoir
Amend location (designation text), to read: 'Road Reserve and part Part of 129 Wharf Road (l
Lot 2 DP 458020), Waiau Beach'.
6190-
9554 Glenbrook Beach
6190-
(Whangaparaoa Road) Retain designation as notified.
169/1145
Sub#/
6190-
250 Watercare Services Limited igotelli@water.co.nz Designations Watercare Services Ltd 9556 Buckland Reservoir Retain designation as notified.
6190-
251 Watercare Services Limited igotelli@water.co.nz Designations Watercare Services Ltd 9557 Bombay Reservoirs
Amend location (designation schedule), to read: 'Corner Paparata Road and Barber Road
(road reserve), and part of Sec 1 SO 66791, Bombay Road reserve on corner of Paparata
and Barber Roads, Bombay and part of Sec 1 SO 66791 BLK IX OPAHEKE SD'.
6190-
252 Watercare Services Limited igotelli@water.co.nz Designations Watercare Services Ltd 9557 Bombay Reservoirs
Amend location (designation text), to read: 'Corner Paparata Road and Barber Road (road
reserve), and part of Sec 1 SO 66791, Bombay Road reserve on corner of Paparata and
Barber Roads, Bombay and part of Sec 1 SO 66791 BLK IX OPAHEKE SD'.
6190-
253 Watercare Services Limited igotelli@water.co.nz Designations Watercare Services Ltd 9558 Waiuku Reservoir
Amend location (designation schedule), to read: '83A Victoria Avenue (Lot 2 DP 134302),
Waiuku'.
6190-
254 Watercare Services Limited igotelli@water.co.nz Designations Watercare Services Ltd 9558 Waiuku Reservoir Amend location (designation text), to read: '83A Victoria Avenue (Lot 2 DP 134302), Waiuku'.
6190-
255 Watercare Services Limited igotelli@water.co.nz Designations Watercare Services Ltd 9559 Hydraulic Balancing Tank
Amend location (designation schedule), to read: 'Corner of Rutherford Road and Runciman
Road (part Lot 1 DP 201876), Pukekohe East'.
6190-
256 Watercare Services Limited igotelli@water.co.nz Designations Watercare Services Ltd 9560 Hays Creek Dam Retain designation as notified.
6190-
9561 Papakura Reservoir and
6190-
9562 Papakura Water
6190-
9563 Creightons Road Water
Supply Purposes Retain designation as notified.
6190-
9564 Hays Creek Water
Supply Purposes Retain designation as notified.
6190-
261 Watercare Services Limited igotelli@water.co.nz Designations Watercare Services Ltd 9565 Hingaia Pump Station Retain designation as notified.
6190-
262 Watercare Services Limited igotelli@water.co.nz Designations Watercare Services Ltd 9566 Drury Pump Station Retain designation as notified.
6190-
9567 Puketutu Island
Rehabilitation
Amend description [purpose] (designation schedule), to read: 'Wastewater purposes -
Puketutu Island Rehabilitation - including but not limited to application of biosolids to land,
landform rehabilitation and associated activities.'
6190-
Reservoirs
Amend the location (designation schedule), to read: '53 Schnapper Rock Road, Schnapper
Rock Albany '.
6190-
9333 Laingholm Pump Station
(Laingholm Drive) Amend conditions to update all legacy plan references.
6190-
9428 One Tree Hill Domain
Reservoir
provided.]
6190-
9442 Onehunga Water
Treatment Plant
Amend location (designation schedule), to read: '2 Spring Street, and Rowe Street road
reserve (adjacent to 2 Spring Street) Onehunga'.
6190-
9458 Fanshawe Street Pump
Station
Amend location (designation schedule), to read: 'Hardinge Street (r Road reserve (between
120 Hardinge Street and 136-142 Fanshawe Street), Auckland Central'.
6190-
9513 Ardmore Water
Treatment Plant
Amend description [purpose] (designation text), to read: 'Water supply purposes - Ardmore W
water T treatment P plant'.
6190-
9302 Pupuke Road Reservoir
and Pump Station Amend location (designation schedule), to read: '106 Pupuke Road, Northcote Hillcrest'.
6191-1 Sarah Forsyth clevedon@ihug.co.nz Precincts - South Clevedon Extend the Clevedon Village Sub Precinct 2 further south along Papakura-Clevedon Road.
6191-2 Sarah Forsyth clevedon@ihug.co.nz Zoning South Rezone 36, 38, 40 and 42 Papakura-Clevedon Road as Neighbourhood Centre
6192-1 Sonya J Forbes
72A Beresford Street, Bayswater,
Auckland 0622 Zoning North and Islands Retain the zoning proposed from Takapuna to Devonport.
Auckland 0622 Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula
Amend the PAUP to ensure that quality design is achieved in practice by ensuring that design
rules apply in the majority of cases and in particular to large sites and intensively built
developments.
Auckland 0622 General Miscellaneous
Operational/
Amend the precinct provisions by carrying out a comprehensive traffic study in order to
determine the level of intensification that can occur given the existing infrastructure and what
future levels and locations could be considered if additional infrastructure was put in place,
Amend the precinct provisions to ensure any development is created in harmony with the
character and quality of the surrounding area as outlined in the submission on page 4/4.
Amend the precinct to include more rules around the amenities (e.g. parking and playgrounds)
that should be preserved or created within the precincts.
Delete the Devonport Peninsula sub-precinct F and ensure that the Single House zone
applies to this area including a height limit of two stories.
170/1145
Sub#/
Auckland 0622 Precincts - North Bayswater
objectives and policies Delete the Precinct [refer to pg 3/4 of the submission for details].
Auckland 0622 Precincts - North Takapuna 1 Delete the Precinct [refer to pg 3/4 of the submission for details].
Auckland 0622 Precincts - North Takapuna 2 Delete the Precinct [refer to pg 3/4 of the submission for details].
Auckland 0622 Precincts - North HMNZ Dockyard Delete the Precinct [refer to pg 3/4 of the submission for details].
Auckland 0622 Precincts - North Devonport Naval Base Delete the Precinct [refer to pg 3/4 of the submission for details].
objectives and policies Delete the Precinct [refer to pg 3/4 of the submission for details].
6193-1 Goodman Property Trust gerardt@barker.co.nz Zoning Central Rezone 594-614 Great South Rd, Ellerslie from Light Industry to Business Park.
6193-2 Goodman Property Trust gerardt@barker.co.nz Precincts - Central Central Park
Amend the activity table [in K2.4.1] as follows: 'New buildings or additions and alterations not
provided for as a permitted activities' - Restricted Discretionary Restricted Controlled
Amend the activity table [in K2.4.1] as follows: 'External additions and alterations to buildings
that are non-structural, do not increase the development area by more than 2.5 percent and
do not increase the height of the building'
Amend Rule K2.4.3.1 as follows: 'The development controls that follow replace those set out
in section I3.4 of the Plan. Any activity that does not comply with one or more development
controls below is a restricted discretionary activity.'
6193-5 Goodman Property Trust gerardt@barker.co.nz Precincts - Central Central Park Delete Rule K2.4.3.1 'External alterations and additions to buildings'.
Amend Rule K2.4.3.16 'Carparking', to provide wording that better reflects Figure 5: 'Car
parking ratios'. Refer pages 9/103 and 19/103 of submission for details.
6193-7 Goodman Property Trust gerardt@barker.co.nz General Chapter G General provisions
refer to Designations theme) Amend the PAUP to promote a more streamlined regulatory environment.
6193-8 Goodman Property Trust gerardt@barker.co.nz Transport Auckland -wide
requirements Delete Rule 3.1 Traffic generation. Refer page 33/103 of submission for details.
requirements
Amend Rule 3.1 Traffic generation if it is to be retained so that the traffic generation threshold
is set at a level that only applies to activities of an intensity that could not be reasonably
anticipated in the zone. Refer page 33/103 of submission for details.
requirements
Amend Rule 3.2 Number of parking and loading spaces, Table 4 to provide a maximum
parking ratio of one space per 25m
2
for office activity.
requirements
Retain Rule 3.2 Number of parking and loading spaces, Table 4 insofar as it relates to parking
ratios for industrial activities.
requirements
Amend Rule 3.4(2) 'Width and number of vehicle crossings to link the number of permitted
crossings to site size/road frontage.
6193-13 Goodman Property Trust gerardt@barker.co.nz Earthworks H4.2.1.1 Activity table - Zones Amend the Activity table to increase the thresholds for when resource consent is required.
6193-14 Goodman Property Trust gerardt@barker.co.nz Earthworks H4.2.1.1 Activity table - Zones
Delete the discretionary activity status for earthworks and change all earthworks to permitted
or restricted discretionary activities.
6193-15 Goodman Property Trust gerardt@barker.co.nz Contaminated Land H4.5.1 Activity table
Amend the activity status of contaminated land activities that are discretionary activites to
restricted discretionary provided that a preliminary site investigation is provided.
6193-16 Goodman Property Trust gerardt@barker.co.nz General
GIS viewer
Undertake further modelling and/or site investigations to better refine the sites affected by
flooding and where sites are affected by the rules, property owners should be notified.
6193-17 Goodman Property Trust gerardt@barker.co.nz Natural Hazards and Flooding Flooding H4.12 Rules
Amend the activity status to change activities from discretionary and non-complying to
permitted and restricted discretionary.
6193-18 Goodman Property Trust gerardt@barker.co.nz Water Stormwater H4.14 Introduction
Amend the activity status to change activities from discretionary to permitted and restricted
discretionary.
6193-19 Goodman Property Trust gerardt@barker.co.nz Sustainable Development C7.7/H6.4 Sustainable design Delete the sustainable development provisions.
6193-20 Goodman Property Trust gerardt@barker.co.nz Mana Whenua
Whenua
and policies
Amend the provisions 5.2 to better identify sites and places of value and to establish a better
framework around the need for consultation and preparation of cultural impact assessments.
6193-21 Goodman Property Trust gerardt@barker.co.nz
Centre)
D3.9 Business Park zone
desc, obs & pols
Add a new objective as follows: 4. Recognise that Business Parks form part of the overall
centres hierarchy and provide for businesses to locate in such environments, particularly
where they are not well suited to locating within centres.
Centre)
desc, obs & pols
Amend Policy 2 as follows: Enable the establishment of Require the location of a proposed
new business parks where to they: a. be are within a practical walking distance of the rapid
and frequent service network b. do not adversely affect the vitality and viability of the City
Centre, Metropolitan and Town Centre zones.
171/1145
Sub#/
Centre)
desc, obs & pols
Amend Policy 4(d) as follows: Require a plan change for a new business park to: ... d.
demonstrate that the business park will not adversely affect can mitigate adverse any effects
on the safe and efficient operation of the transport network
6193-24 Goodman Property Trust gerardt@barker.co.nz Zoning South Rezone 70-100 Plunket Ave, Manukau from Heavy Industry to Light Industry.
Whenua
Amend the Historic Heritage layers of Maps 41 and 48 so that the extent of the Sites and
Places of Value to Mana Whenua relates to the area of land only to the north of Highbrook
Drive, East Tamaki.
6193-26 Goodman Property Trust gerardt@barker.co.nz Precincts - South Waiouru Amend Activity table, to add a new activity 'Convenience retail' as a permitted activity.
6193-27 Goodman Property Trust gerardt@barker.co.nz Precincts - South Waiouru Amend Activity table, to add a new activity 'Showroom retail' as a permitted activity.
6193-28 Goodman Property Trust gerardt@barker.co.nz Precincts - South Waiouru
Amend Rule 2(1) 'Land use controls - Offices' as follows: Within sub-precincts A and B,
Offices offices must be accessory to an industrial activity on the site.
Amend Rule 2(2) 'Development controls - Sub-precinct C' as follows: 1.The development
controls are those listed in the Business Park zone, except that buildings located within the
hatched area shown on Figure 2: Sub-precinct C 45m Height Area are permitted up to a
height of 45m.
Add a new Figure 2: Sub-precinct C 45m Height Area. Refer to pages 53/103, 54/103 and
100/103 of submission for details.
Amend Objective 1 as follows: A high-quality business centre on the Waiouru Peninsula is
provided which becomes a significant employment node and for which enables a mix of
activities appropriate to each sub-precinct area, including light industry activities and
accessory offices, with supporting retail and food and beverage outlets.
Amend Policy 1 as follows: 1. Enable offices and supporting retail (including showroom retail)
and food and beverage outlets in the central area of the precinct.
Add a new Policy as follows: 4. Provide for additional height with parts of sub-precinct C to
strengthen the commercial centre and assist in placemaking.
6193-34 Goodman Property Trust gerardt@barker.co.nz General Cross plan matters
Amend the PAUP to only impose a level of regulation that is sufficient to achieve appropriate
environmental outcomes.
Amend the PAUP to set the activity status of activities at a level that is commensurate with
the level of discretion that Council needs to exercise over applications. Refer to Page 31/103
of submission for details.
Amend the PAUP to retain a permitted activity status wherever possible. Refer to page 31/103
of submission for details.
Amend the PAUP to make the default activity status controlled or restricted
discretionary. Refer to page 31/103 of submission for details.
Amend the PAUP to only apply a discretionary activity status in those cases where the full
range of matters cannot be reasonably envisaged or identified. Refer to page 31/103 of
6193-39 Goodman Property Trust gerardt@barker.co.nz General Chapter G General provisions G2.2 Activities not provided for
Amend the PAUP so that where an activity is not provided for, the default status is
discretionary.
Amend the PAUP to make greater use of permitted activity standards or permits to avoid the
need for resource consents. Refer to page 31/103 of submission for details.
Amend the PAUP to strike a better balance between the imposition of rules and the
application of assessment criteria. Where a particular aspect of an activity is covered by a
development control and a proposal complies with that control, the assessment criteria should
not require a re-examination of that matter. Where an activity requires consent and also has
an extensive range of assessment criteria, it might be appropriate to delete some of the
development controls. Refer to page 32/103 of submission for details.
Amend the PAUP to make assessment criteria specific to the activity and not be so broad as
to encompass matters that do not reasonably fall within the scope of the matter being
considered. Refer to page 32/103 of submission for details.
Amend the PAUP to retain flexibility so that resource consent applications are only required to
be assessed against criteria that are relevant to the application. Refer to page 32/103 of
6193-44 Goodman Property Trust gerardt@barker.co.nz General Chapter G General provisions
statements
Amend the PAUP to ensure that when a resource consent is required, the information
requirements are carefully balanced to ensure that the plans and the level of expert reporting
is commensurate with the scale and complexity of the proposed development. Refer to page
32/103 of submission for details.
requirements
Amend Rule 3.4(2) 'Width and number of vehicle crossings to allow for wider crossings as a
permitted activity in industrial zones. Refer page 41/103 of submission for details.
6193-46 Goodman Property Trust gerardt@barker.co.nz Earthworks H4.2.1.1 Activity table - Zones
Amend the Activity table to provide for smaller areas/volumes of earthworks as a permitted
activity (subject to complying with performance standards). Refer to page 41/103 of
172/1145
Sub#/
6193-47 Goodman Property Trust gerardt@barker.co.nz General
GIS viewer
Clarify the sites affected by flooding and where sites are affected by the rules, property
owners should be notified. Refer to page 41/103 of submission for details.
Whenua
Amend the provisions in 5.1 to better identify sites and places of significance and to establish
a better framework around the need for consultation and preparation of cultural impact
assessments. Refer to page 42/103 of submission for details.
6194-1 Alistair Ray al.stingray@gmail.com RPS Urban growth
Retain objectives and policies that relate to a quality compact city. Amend rules to give effect
to these objectives and policies
6194-2 Alistair Ray al.stingray@gmail.com General Eplan Add density references to maps
quality compact urban form Focus density in market attractive areas
6194-4 Alistair Ray al.stingray@gmail.com General Chapter G General provisions
statements Amend to require design statements for all applications
environment Link the Auckland Design Manual in the PAUP to provide examples and guidance
6194-6 Alistair Ray al.stingray@gmail.com General Chapter G General provisions
statements
Retain the requirement for a site context and specific design response statement for large
projects
6194-7 Alistair Ray al.stingray@gmail.com Residential zones Residential
policies Amend to place more emphasis on quality design
6194-8 Alistair Ray al.stingray@gmail.com
Centre) Business
General objectives and policies Amend to place more emphasis on quality design
6194-9 Alistair Ray al.stingray@gmail.com City Centre Zone
D3.2 City Centre zone Desc,
obs & pols Add specific objectives to strengthen and support the centres as the focus for development
Centre) Business
General objectives and policies Add specific objectives to strengthen and support the centres as the focus for development
Centre) Business
Rezone all Business Park to Mixed use. Rezone some General Business and Terrace
Housing and Apartment Buildings to Mixed Use [locations not specified]
6194-12 Alistair Ray al.stingray@gmail.com Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
Retain the removal of parking minimums in the Centre zones, Mixed Use zone and Terrace
Housing and Apartment Buildings zone
6194-13 Alistair Ray al.stingray@gmail.com Sustainable Development C7.7/H6.4 Sustainable design Amend so all dwellings are required to meet the Homestar rating
6194-14 Alistair Ray al.stingray@gmail.com Sustainable Development C7.7/H6.4 Sustainable design
Amend to significantly reduce the threshold for commercial development to trigger the
Greenstar rating requirement [threshold not specified]
6194-15 Alistair Ray al.stingray@gmail.com Residential zones Housing affordability H6.6 Rules Retain the requirement to provide a percentage of affordable homes
Increase amount of Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings and Mixed use zones within the
RUB
6194-17 Alistair Ray al.stingray@gmail.com General C7.2/H6.1 Lighting Delete restrictions on floodlights used by sport clubs on Sunday evenings
6195-1 Heather L Green
PO Box 28450, Remuera, Auckland
1541 RPS Mana Whenua B5 Strategic
1541 Mana Whenua
Whenua
1541 RPS Mana Whenua
Fig. 1
Recognize the NZ Historic Places Trust as the approving authority with regard to Sites of
1541 Mana Whenua
Whenua
and policies
Heritage Schedules
1541 General Chapter A Introduction A1 Background
Delete the last two paragraphs of 1.2 'Mana Whenua' and replace with 'Unitary Plan is to be
1541 General Chapter A Introduction A2 Statutory Framework
party.
173/1145
Sub#/
1541 RPS
Places Act 1993.
1541 RPS Issues
1541 RPS Urban growth
1541 General Chapter G General provisions
1541 General Chapter G General provisions
statements
undertaken
1541 General Miscellaneous Other Delete clauses 5.2, 5.3, and 5.4 from G. 3.2 [reference unknown]
1541 Mana Whenua
1541 Mana Whenua
1541 Mana Whenua Auckland wide - Mori Land
1541 Mana Whenua
settlement land
1541 Mana Whenua
Whenua
whenua
1541 Mana Whenua
Whenua
1541 Definitions Existing
1541 Definitions Existing
Overlays.'
6196-1 Iain C and Michelle M Gallie mgallie@xtra.co.nz Zoning North and Islands Rezone 23 Clemow's Lane Albany from Mixed Housing Suburban to Single House.
6197-1 Robert W Bell rbell780@gmail.com General Chapter A Introduction A1 Background
Delete the last two paragraphs from 1.2 'Mana Whenua', relating to direct involvement of
Mana Whenua in the resource management process, and replace with 'Unitary plan is to be
and the Resource Management Act'.
174/1145
Sub#/
6197-2 Robert W Bell rbell780@gmail.com General Chapter A Introduction A2 Statutory Framework
Delete the last paragraph from A2.2 'Treaty of Waitangi/ Te Tiriti o Waitangi' which relates to
providing opportunities for Mana Whenua to be involved in decision making and replace with
'Auckland Council are required to notify Mana Whenua of any application for Resource
Consent on any Scheduled Site of Significance or value (as determined by NZ Historic Places
Trust), as an affected party'.
6197-3 Robert W Bell rbell780@gmail.com RPS
Amend policy 2(c) (under 'Identification and protection', which relates to identifying a place as
having historic heritage value if it has value to Mana Whenua), to add 'as approved by
application to the NZHPT and as fully Publically [sic] Notified as part of a Private Plan Change
for inclusion of any site as Specified Site Schedule in accordance with the Historic Places Act
1993'.
6197-4 Robert W Bell rbell780@gmail.com RPS Mana Whenua B5 Strategic
Delete all of the provisions and add a paragraph to provide that any site which Mana Whenua
consider a Site of Significance or Value will be subject to an application to NZHPT and a Plan
Change process in order to be included in the PAUP, unless already in an operative District
Plan schedule. Refer to the full submission for suggested wording [page 4/6].
6197-5 Robert W Bell rbell780@gmail.com RPS Urban growth
environment Delete Chapter B2.2 (in Part 2). [Relief unclear as Chapter B is not in Part 2].
6197-6 Robert W Bell rbell780@gmail.com General Chapter G General provisions
statements
Amend 2.7.1.4(k) 'Existing site plan' to only reference sites which are currently included within
existing operative plans (in relation to providing drawings which show known sites or areas of
significance to Mana Whenua).
6197-7 Robert W Bell rbell780@gmail.com General Chapter G General provisions
statements
Amend 2.7.1.4(k) 'Existing site plan' to delete: 'or that are made known to the applicant during
any consultation process which may have been undertaken' (in relation to providing drawings
which show known sites or areas of significance to Mana Whenua).
6197-8 Robert W Bell rbell780@gmail.com Mana Whenua General provisions
discovery protocol
Delete G3.2 clauses 5.2, 5.3 and 5.4 in their entirety. [Inferred this relates to 2.5 'Accidental
discovery protocols', clauses (2)-(4) under 'Mana Whenua cultural heritage'.]
6197-9 Robert W Bell rbell780@gmail.com Mana Whenua
Whenua J5.1 Rules Delete 5.1 'Sites and Places of Significance to Mana Whenua'.
Whenua J5.2 Rules Delete 5.2 'Sites and Places of Value to Mana Whenua'.
6197-11 Robert W Bell rbell780@gmail.com Mana Whenua Auckland wide - Mori Land
controls Delete 2.1.2.1 'Notification'.
settlement land
rules/App. 4.3 legislation Delete Notification Rules.
Whenua
whenua
Delete Appendix 4.1 and replace with 'Any site which Mana Whenua consider a site of
[sic] Notified as part of a Private Plan Change for inclusion of any site as a Specified Site on
the Council register by that Iwi. Any site which is currently contained within an Operative
District Schedule shall be included within the Unitary Plan Schedule and Overlays'.
Whenua
Delete Appendix 4.2 and replace with 'Any site which Mana Whenua consider a site of
6197-15 Robert W Bell rbell780@gmail.com Definitions Existing
Amend the definition of 'Mana Whenua cultural heritage' by deleting the second and third
paragraph and replacing them with: 'Any site which Mana Whenua consider a site of
6197-16 Robert W Bell rbell780@gmail.com Definitions Existing
Delete the definition of 'Mori cultural landscapes' and replace with: 'Any site which Mana
NZHPT and as fully Publically [sic] Notified as part of a Private Plan Change for inclusion of
any site as a Specified Site on the Council register by that Iwi. Any site which is currently
contained within an Operative District Schedule shall be included within the Unitary Plan
Schedule and Overlays'.
6198-1 James Hughes jamorito@gmail.com RPS Urban growth
Limit urban sprawl by keeping more than 70% of growth within city limits and staging the
Future Urban zone
175/1145
Sub#/
Prioritise intensification around key transport nodes, such as train stations, ferry terminals and
others
Apply a consistent approach to zoning and do not down zone areas unless there is a justified
and published rationale
6198-4 James Hughes jamorito@gmail.com Zoning West Rezone Te Atatu Peninsula from Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings
6198-5 James Hughes jamorito@gmail.com General Miscellaneous
Operational/
Request for a western bus way and a dedicated interchange constructed in conjunction with
any intensification of Te Atatu Peninsula
6198-6 James Hughes jamorito@gmail.com General Miscellaneous Other
Provide clarity around implications of Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings zoning on
property values
6198-7 James Hughes jamorito@gmail.com Sustainable Development C7.7/H6.4 Sustainable design
Apply the Homestar and Greenstar rating systems to all new houses and commercial
buildings [respectively]
environment Ensure developments are subject to design review and strong assessment criteria
6198-9 James Hughes jamorito@gmail.com Residential zones Residential
General Remove rules which make development uneconomic
6198-10 James Hughes jamorito@gmail.com Residential zones Residential Land use controls
[Retain rule 3.3 The conversion of a dwelling into two dwellings that] enable existing houses to
be split into two flats.
quality compact urban form Expand the area of Mixed Housing Urban zoned land, especially near the City Centre
6198-12 James Hughes jamorito@gmail.com Zoning Central
Up-zone areas near railway stations and high frequency bus routes, particularly Newton,
Morningside, Greenlane and Ellerslie
6198-13 James Hughes jamorito@gmail.com Transport Auckland -wide
requirements Delete minimum parking requirements from all areas, particularly residential areas
6199-1 WEL Networks Limited kirsty.lanham@wel.co.nz Infrastructure
C1.1 Infrastructure
policies Retain Objectives 1, 2,3,4 and
C1.1 Infrastructure
policies
Amend Policy 1(e) to identify the positive effects network utilities can have on the
imrpovement of the environment. See submission page 6/15 for suggested amendment
C1.1 Infrastructure
policies
Amend Policy 2 to refer to read "Prevent reverse sensitivity effects from inappropriate
subdivision, use and development which may compromise the operation and capacity of
existing planned significant infrastructure".
C1.1 Infrastructure
policies Retain Policy 3
C1.1 Infrastructure
policies Retain Policy 10
6199-6 WEL Networks Limited kirsty.lanham@wel.co.nz Trees
Overlay C4.1/H3.1 Trees in
streets and public open space C4.1 Objectives and Policies
Amend Objective 3 to read "The efficient construction, operation, maintenance and upgrading
of network utilities in streets is undertaken in a manner that minimises the effect on trees or
groups of trees."
6199-7 WEL Networks Limited kirsty.lanham@wel.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - general
and policies Retain Objective 3
and policies
Add a new policy as follows: "Enable subdivision for network utilities, while avoiding,
remedying or mitigating adverse effects".
Energy
Amend the Activity Table to ensure each activity has a reference number and add a clause
that states any activity not otherwise provided for within the Activity Table defaults to a
Restricted Discretionary activity. See submission page 8/15 for suggested amendment
Energy
Retain the rules in Activity Table 1.1 listed under 'General' and 'Electricity transmission and
distribution'.
Energy H1.1.3 Development controls Delete Rule 3.1.2
streets and public open space H3.1 Rules Retain the Activity Table
6199-13 WEL Networks Limited kirsty.lanham@wel.co.nz Earthworks H4.2.2 Controls Retain the rules [controls inferred]
6199-14 WEL Networks Limited kirsty.lanham@wel.co.nz
SEAs
Assessment Retain the rules listed under Network Utilities [controls inferred]
6199-15 WEL Networks Limited kirsty.lanham@wel.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - Urban zones
except Rural Retain the rules for subdivision for a network utility listed in the activity tables
176/1145
Sub#/
controls
Amend 2.1(1)(a), (3)(a) and (4)(a) to exclude network utility subdivisions. See page 12/15 of
the submission for suggested amendment
6199-17 WEL Networks Limited kirsty.lanham@wel.co.nz Definitions Existing Retain the definition of 'building'
6199-18 WEL Networks Limited kirsty.lanham@wel.co.nz Definitions Existing Retain the definition of 'infrastructure'
6199-19 WEL Networks Limited kirsty.lanham@wel.co.nz Definitions Existing
Amend the definition of 'minor infrastructure upgrading'. See page 13-14/15 of the submission
for the suggested amendment
6199-20 WEL Networks Limited kirsty.lanham@wel.co.nz Definitions Existing Retain the definition of 'minor utility structure'
6199-21 WEL Networks Limited kirsty.lanham@wel.co.nz Definitions Existing Retain the definition of 'network utilities'
6199-22 WEL Networks Limited kirsty.lanham@wel.co.nz Definitions Existing Retain the definition of 'resverse sensitivity'
6199-23 WEL Networks Limited kirsty.lanham@wel.co.nz Definitions Existing
Amend the definition of 'significant infrastrcuture' to specifcally include network utility. See
page 15/15 of submission for suggested amendment
Amend Policy 1 to read "Balance the efficient construction, operation, maintenance and
upgrading of infrastructure and network utilities with the protection of trees and groups of trees
in streets."
Energy
Amend the rule listed under General to read "Network utilities and electricity generation
facilities in existence (as of the date of public notification of the Unitary Plan) or which has
been permitted or granted resource consent".
Energy
Add a new Discretionary activity [inferred] under general to read "Network utilities and
electricity facilities, and ancillary activities, not otherwise provided for."
Energy H1.1.3 Development controls Amend rule 3.1.1. See submission pages 9 and 10/15 for suggested amendment
6200-1 John and Gillian Wood parfitt.associates@xtra.co.nz Zoning North and Islands Rezone 55 and 60 Waimauku Station Road, Waimauku from Single House to Mixed Use.
6200-2 John and Gillian Wood parfitt.associates@xtra.co.nz Zoning North and Islands
Rezone any non residential use site on on the west side of Waimauku Station Road,
Waimauku from Single House zone to Mixed Use zone.
6201-1 Richard D Coles
objectives and policies Delete the Devonport Precinct.
6201-2 Richard D Coles
Delete the Devonport Peninsula sub-precinct F and ensure that the Single House zone
applies to this area.
6202-1 Xenia Marcroft xmarcroft@gmail.com Zoning Central Reject the level of intensification proposed for Point Chevalier.
6203-1 Ministry for Primary Industries michael.nielsen@mpi.govt.nz
the CMA
Retain new aquaculture space within the General Coastal Marine zone as a Discretionary
activity.
the CMA
Amemd to provide for re-consenting of an existing marine farm to be a controlled activity
within all zones and overlays.
the CMA
D5.1.14 Background,
Add new policy recognising the need for certainty for existing lawfully established aquaculture
activities.
the CMA
Add new rule providing for the change of species and equipment, and research trials, on
existing marine farms as a controlled activity.
the CMA
D5.1.14 Background,
Add a new policy acknowledging the need to provide flexibility for marine farmers to innovate
and undertake research trials on existing marine farms.
SEAs
SEAs
table - Vegetation
roads
Add Permitted activity status for the harvesting of indigenous timber in accordance with the
Forest Act 1949 when undertaken outside Significant Ecological Areas.
Outstanding Natural
Rules
Notification
Amend Forestry over 2 ha to be a Permitted activity within ONL overlay, where it is an
appropriate land use to prevent erosion, maintain water quality and increase biodiversity.
6203-9 Ministry for Primary Industries michael.nielsen@mpi.govt.nz Definitions Existing
Amend definition of 'forestry' to exclude the planting of indigenous forest species for timber
production.
6203-10 Ministry for Primary Industries michael.nielsen@mpi.govt.nz Definitions Existing
Amend the definition of 'conservation planting' to include the planting of indigenous forest
species for timber production.
177/1145
Sub#/
Amend activity table to remove items 1 and 2 from the following activity: Discharge of hull bio-
fouling organisms from below the load line resulting from: 1. in-water cleaning of a vessel
which has arrived from overseas with light to very heavy macro-fouling (level of fouling scale 2
to 5), or 2. passive release from a vessel which has arrived from overseas with light to very
heavy macro-fouling (level of fouling scale 2 to 5)
Amend activity table, point 3 under 'Discharge of hull bio-fouling organisms from below the
load line resulting from...' to come in line with the Anti-fouling and in-water clearing guidelines
endorsed by the Australian and New Zealand governments.
Amend activity table, point 4 under the activity 'Discharge of hull bio-fouling organisms from
below the load line resulting from: ...' to align with the outcomes of the Domestic Marine
Pathways Management Project.
6204-1 Brendan Catchpole brendan.catchpole@nz.pwc.com Zoning North and Islands Retain the Mixed Rural zoning along Pine Valley Road, Dairy Flat.
6205-1
Penelope Shelbourne and
Timothy Smyth pshelbourne@xtra.co.nz RPS
character and natural heritage B4.3.4 Biodiversity Retain Objectives 1 and 2
6205-2
Timothy Smyth pshelbourne@xtra.co.nz RPS
Amend Policies 12 and 13 to place additional emphasis on controlling the threats posed by
domestic pets in subdivisions over 15 sites adjacent to an SEA
6205-3
Timothy Smyth pshelbourne@xtra.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - general
and policies
Amend objectives and policies to make reference to the need to: manage adverse effects
relating to natural heritage; protect indigeneous flora and fauna through pest management;
and provide incentives and controls to protect SEAs
6205-4
Timothy Smyth pshelbourne@xtra.co.nz Rural Zones General I13.1 Activity table
Amend activity status' of equestrian centres in the Countryside Living zone from discretionary
to restricted discretionary.
6205-5
Timothy Smyth pshelbourne@xtra.co.nz Definitions Existing
Amend the definition of 'visitor accommodation' by deleting the exclusion of 'letting of
dwellings including for holiday purposes'
6205-6
Timothy Smyth pshelbourne@xtra.co.nz Precincts - North Matakana 1
Amend activity status' in sub-precinct A to reflect sub-precinct B, particularly in relation to
visitor accommodation, boarding houses and integrated dwellings. Amend the activity status
of 'erection, addition to or alteration of buildings and accessory buildings for any permitted
activity' in sub-precinct A from not applicable to a restricted discretionary activity [in K5.25.1
Activity table].
6205-7
Timothy Smyth pshelbourne@xtra.co.nz
SEAs
Land Retain SEA along Matakana River
6205-8
Timothy Smyth pshelbourne@xtra.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - general
controls
Amend so subdivision near an SEA includes the following conditions: (1)
Conserving indigenous habitats through e.g. weed pest control and revegetation. (2)
Protecting native fauna e.g. by placing limits on ownership of cats, dogs and other known
predators and predator free fencing.
6205-9
Timothy Smyth pshelbourne@xtra.co.nz Rural Zones General I13.2 Land use controls Add controls to avoid conflict between adjacent residential and Countryside Living zones
6205-10
Timothy Smyth pshelbourne@xtra.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - Rural zones
area
Amend minimum site size at 234 Matakana Valley Rd, Matakana from 2ha to a minimum site
size of 5000m
2
and an average site size of 1ha
6205-11
Timothy Smyth pshelbourne@xtra.co.nz
Outstanding Natural
Rules
Outstanding Natural
Landscapes
Delete outstanding natural landscape overlay from the hills to the north east of Matakana
River
6205-12
Timothy Smyth pshelbourne@xtra.co.nz Zoning North and Islands Rezone 254 Matakana Valley Rd, Matakana from Rural Production to Mixed Rural
6205-13
Timothy Smyth pshelbourne@xtra.co.nz Precincts - North Matakana 1
Retain the permitted activity status for 'Visitor accommodation' in sub-precinct A [in K5.25.1
Activity table].
6205-14
Timothy Smyth pshelbourne@xtra.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - Rural zones
area
Remove additional subdivision control overlay 'Matakana-Warkworth', including at 234
Matakana Valley Road
6205-15
Amend activity status of onsite primary produce manufacturing in the Countryside Living zone
from discretionary to restricted discretionary.
6205-16
Amend the activity status of artisan industries in the Countryside Living zone from
6206-1 Babich Wines Limited philip@campbellbrown.co.nz Zoning West Retain the Single House zoning at 9, 15, and 15c Babich Road.
6206-2 Babich Wines Limited philip@campbellbrown.co.nz Precincts - West Babich Retain the 'Babich sub-precinct C' over 9, 15, and 15c Babich Road.
6207-1 Paul Willoughby mufflerman24@hotmail.com Zoning North and Islands Rezone 24 Barrys Point Road, Takapuna from Mixed Use to Light Industrial.
6208-1 Furu Ding a.tsang@harrisongrierson.com Zoning South
Retain the Terraced Housing and Apartment Building zoning along the front of 39 Flat Bush
School Road, Flat Bush and rezone the rest of the site to Mixed Housing Urban
6208-2 Furu Ding a.tsang@harrisongrierson.com Precincts - South Flat Bush
Retain the Flat Bush Sub-precinct A development controls with the exception of the height in
relation to boundary rule.
178/1145
Sub#/
Amend the height in relation to boundary rule within Flat Bush Sub Precinct A to read 'i)For
all lots no height in relation to boundary control shall apply to the street boundary; ii) In the
case of front lots (not being a corner lot or adjacent to a corner lot) a building in relation to
boundary of 5m and 45 degrees shall apply on side boundaries adjoining other front lots, up to
a maximum distance of 18m from the front boundary.'
Replace the maximum allowable density control for sites located in the Moderate Aircraft
Noise Area with new land use controls requiring acoustic insulation
6208-5 Furu Ding a.tsang@harrisongrierson.com Precincts - South Flat Bush Retain 4.3 Subdivisions Standards Applying to Land with Areas 6 and 9
Identify and include the light green colour shaded areas shown on the Flat Bush Precinct Plan
2: Sub Precinct Areas in the key of the Plan, and with appropriate provisions to clarify the
intention of this area.
6209-1 Jeannette L Miller jennymiller@xtra.co.nz Designations Auckland Transport
Street
Remove designation 1598 from 13 Garfield Street, Parnell. Instead of widening Garfield
Street, Parnell convert Farnham street to a one way street.
6209-2 Jeannette L Miller jennymiller@xtra.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - Urban zones H5.2 3.1 Residential zones Retain existing subdivision potential on 26 Harrybrook Rd, Green Bay
6210-1 TransportBlog lowrie.matt@gmail.com RPS Urban growth
Clarify that higher density housing typologies will be provided in places where people want to
live.
Retain a focus on intensification in areas with good access to high frequency public transport
(especially public transport that is of 'rapid transit' quality).
Recognise that transport and land-use planning must be better integrated than has occurred
in the past.
land for urban development Recognise that greenfield development should be carefully controlled and properly priced.
6210-5 TransportBlog lowrie.matt@gmail.com Future Urban
Amend by splitting the Future Urban zone into two sub-zones, 'Short term' (areas suitable for
development in the next ten years) and 'Long term', with controls that reflect this sequencing.
6210-6 TransportBlog lowrie.matt@gmail.com Residential zones Residential
General
Amend the 'Yards' rule to remove or reduce the front yard setback requirements, particularly
in zones where intensification is anticipated.
6210-7 TransportBlog lowrie.matt@gmail.com Residential zones Residential Land use controls
Delete [rule 3.1 'Maximum density'] to remove density limits for development of four or more
dwellings in the Mixed Housing Suburban zone .
6210-8 TransportBlog lowrie.matt@gmail.com Residential zones Residential Land use controls
Delete all density limits applying to the Mixed Housing Urban zone [Land use control 3.1
'Maximum density'].
6210-9 TransportBlog lowrie.matt@gmail.com Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
Retain the removal of minimum parking requirements from Centres and the Terrace Housing
and Apartment Buildings zone. [Control 3.2 'Number of parking and loading spaces'].
6210-10 TransportBlog lowrie.matt@gmail.com
Centre) Business
Park zones
Recognise that some areas zoned Mixed Use should have a significantly higher height limits
to reflect their location close to high quality public transport infrastructure (e.g. Morningside
and Newton).
6210-11 TransportBlog lowrie.matt@gmail.com Zoning Central
Rezone all areas zoned Light Industrial between Morningside train station and St Lukes
Shopping Centre to Mixed Use.
Rezone the area bounded by May Road (west), Mt Albert Road (north) and Mt Roskill
Grammar (east), Mt Roskill to Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings.
6210-13 TransportBlog lowrie.matt@gmail.com Built Environment (Overlays)
Height Control
Add an 'Additional Zone Height Control' overlay to both sides of Great North Road between
Ponsonby Road and Surrey Crescent, Grey Lynn, to allow a higher height limit.
Rezone areas within a 800m walk of Meadowbank train station to Terrace Housing and
Apartment Buildings or Mixed Housing Urban (or a combination).
Rezone areas zoned Mixed Housing Suburban in the area bounded by New North Road
(west), the city fringe (north), State Highway 20 (south) and Great South Road (east), to Mixed
Housing Urban.
Rezone both sides of Great South Road between Greenlane East/West and Main Highway
from Light Industrial to Mixed Use.
6210-17 TransportBlog lowrie.matt@gmail.com Residential zones Residential Land use controls Retain rule 3.3 'The conversion of a dwelling into two dwellings'.
Centre) Business
& Bus. Park zones Retain the strong restrictions placed on retail and office activity outside of Centres zones.
Centre) Business
and Heavy Industry zones Retain the strong restrictions placed on retail and office activity outside of Centres zones.
6210-20 TransportBlog lowrie.matt@gmail.com Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
Retain the lack of minimum parking requirements for various zones in Table 3 'Parking rates
for sites within the City Centre Fringe overlay and the Metropolitan, Town, Local Centres,
Mixed Use and Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings zones'. [Control 3.2 'Number of
parking and loading spaces'].
Retain the location of zones that allow intensification, close to rapid transit or high frequency
public transport (particularly Mixed Use, Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings or Centre
zones).
6211-1 John A Staines johnstaines@xtra.co.nz RPS Mana Whenua B5 Strategic Reject the requirement to consult with iwi during the consent process.
179/1145
Sub#/
6212-1 Property Council New Zealand connal@propertynz.co.nz RPS Urban growth
quality compact urban form Retain policies
6212-2 Property Council New Zealand connal@propertynz.co.nz General Cross plan matters
Review all rules and requirements in the PAUP to ensure they achieve the RPS objectives
and policies 2.1 and 2.3
land for urban development Retain policies
6212-4 Property Council New Zealand connal@propertynz.co.nz General Cross plan matters Review all rules and requirements to ensure they achieve the RPS targets for urban growth.
Retain Policy 1 so long as non mandatory incentives approach is adopted; Amend Policy 2 to
read: "Require new large scale residential development within the RUB and encourage all
other developments to provide a proportion of dwellings that are affordable for the
intermediate housing market."
6212-6 Property Council New Zealand connal@propertynz.co.nz RPS
Transport
B3.1 Commercial and
industrial growth Retain objectives
Transport
B3.1 Commercial and
industrial growth
Ensure sufficient industrial land has been provided to achieve Policy 9 [Supply of industrial
land]
character and natural heritage B4.2 Special character Delete objectives and policies
6212-9 Property Council New Zealand connal@propertynz.co.nz RPS Climate change Delete objectives and policies
6212-10 Property Council New Zealand connal@propertynz.co.nz Water
streams & wetland
table Amend activity table to make works in intermittent streams a permitted activity.
6212-11 Property Council New Zealand connal@propertynz.co.nz Water
streams & wetland
C5.14 Background &
Objectives
Amend objectives and policies to make it clear that works will be allowed in intermittent
streams.
Ensure that public transport is provided to an adequate extent to facilitate access to those
areas where there are requirements for parking maximums.
6212-13 Property Council New Zealand connal@propertynz.co.nz Transport Auckland -wide
requirements Amend rules to provide for more flexible parking in the City Centre.
Ensure (i) there are cycle paths or sufficient accessibility for cyclists to areas where the
provision of cycle facilities are required; and (ii) that areas where cyclist facilities are required
should locate close to intensive residential areas.
6212-15 Property Council New Zealand connal@propertynz.co.nz Transport Auckland -wide C1.2 Objectives Retain objectives and policies
6212-16 Property Council New Zealand connal@propertynz.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - general
and policies
Retain approach of generally assessing urban subdivision as a restricted discretionary
activity'.
and policies Retain approach which provides for the use of incentives for Significant Ecological Areas.
and policies
Apply transferable development rights to landowners affected by Significant Ecological Areas
in urban areas as well as rural areas.
6212-19 Property Council New Zealand connal@propertynz.co.nz Sustainable Development C7.7/H6.4 Sustainable design Delete policies and replace with the provision of incentives to incentivise green ratings.
6212-20 Property Council New Zealand connal@propertynz.co.nz Residential zones Housing affordability
and policies
Delete housing affordability provisions and replace with a non-mandatory incentives based
approach.
6212-21 Property Council New Zealand connal@propertynz.co.nz
policies Allocate a generic zone for schools and apply an Education overlay across that zone.
6212-22 Property Council New Zealand connal@propertynz.co.nz Residential zones Residential
policies
Amend the Introduction in Residential zones to reinstate the residential zones under the 2013
Draft Unitary Plan, in particular to retain one Mixed Housing zone rather than splitting the
zone into the Mixed Housing Suburban and Mixed Housing Urban zones.
policies Delete policy 4 [Universal Access]
6212-24 Property Council New Zealand connal@propertynz.co.nz Residential zones
Amend Policy 7(c), so that infrastructure constraints are dealt with without the need to go
Amend Policy 7(c), so that infrastructure constraints are dealt with without the need to go
pols Amend Policy 3 to allow 5+ storeys rather than four to six storeys.
180/1145
Sub#/
Centre) Business
General objectives and policies Delete policy 4 [Universal access]
Centre) Business
Retain policy 12 [which includes circumstances where greater building heights should be
enabled within centres and the Mixed Use zone].
Centre) Business
Amend policy 13 to provide that building heights should only be reduced where the standard
height would have significant adverse effects on historic character, landscape features,
amenity etc. which are scheduled or identified in the PAUP. In addition, heights should only
be lowered after taking into account the factors listed in Policy 12 [which provides
circumstances where building heights may be increased].
Centre) Business
Amend policy 7 [Location and design of parking] to ensure the provision is flexible and
practical and acknowledges market and development realities.
6212-31 Property Council New Zealand connal@propertynz.co.nz City Centre Zone
obs & pols
Retain policies 13 and 14 [which provide incentives to encourage and provide for the retention
and conservation of the historic heritage and special character in the City Centre].
6212-32 Property Council New Zealand connal@propertynz.co.nz General Cross plan matters
Amend all zone policies so the provision of incentives to retain and conserve Auckland's
historic heritage and special character are broader than just transferable development rights.
obs & pols
Add a new subclause to policy 14 [Historic heritage and special character] that requires
consideration the financial viability of businesses, particularly small businesses.
obs & pols
Amend policy 22 [Public Realm] after undertaking a fine grain analysis of sight lines along
streets and public open spaces from and within the City Centre to balance those that should
be protected against the practical realities of development of development in each location.
obs & pols Retain objectives and policies.
Centre)
D3.3 Metropolitan Centre zone
desc, obs & pols
Amend policy 5 so that preference is given to retail and office, but flexibility afforded (for
example in back streets, lanes or peripheral areas) to allow residential development at ground
floor level where it would not detract from the overlay vision for the zone.
Centre)
D3.4 Town Centre zone desc,
obs & pols
Amend policy 2 (b) so that preference is given to retail and office, but flexibility afforded (for
Centre)
obs & pols
Centre)
D3.6 Neighbourhood Centre
Centre) Business
Park zones
Amend the Purpose and rule 4.11.1 [Residential at ground floor] so that preference is given
to retail and office, but flexibility afforded (for example in back streets, lanes or peripheral
areas) to allow residential development at ground floor level where it would not detract from
the overlay vision for the zone.
Centre)
desc, obs & pols
Amend policy 7 [key retail and commercial frontages] to provide greater flexibility to respond
to individual circumstances.
Centre)
obs & pols
to individual circumstances. Retain policy 6 that encourages supermarkets and department
stores.
Centre)
obs & pols
Amend policy 5 [design of buildings] to provide greater flexibility to respond to individual
circumstances.
Centre)
obs & pols
to individual circumstances.
Centre)
desc, obs & pols Retain policy 9 that encourages supermarkets and department stores.
Centre)
obs & pols
Retain policy 3 which enables intensification of commercial, residential and community
activities.
Centre)
obs & pols
Retain objective 3 which encourages a mix of compatible residential and non residential
activities. Retain policy 3 which enables the development of intensive residential activities.
Centre)
obs & pols
Ensure that unplanned centres do not develop which would undermine the centres based
compact urban form and impact the efficiency of the transport network.
Centre)
obs & pols Retain the Zone description
181/1145
Sub#/
Centre)
desc, obs & pols Retain the Zone description
Centre)
desc, obs & pols
Use precinct overlays to identify areas which support surrounding industries to provide for an
appropriate balance of activities.
6212-52 Property Council New Zealand connal@propertynz.co.nz Future Urban
objectives and policies Retain intention of this zone and taking a structured approach to development.
6212-53 Property Council New Zealand connal@propertynz.co.nz Historic Heritage (Overlay)
Heritage
Ensure that heritage restrictions are only placed buildings and areas the community truly
values and are balanced against Auckland's intensification and development needs.
Heritage
Ensure that special character restrictions are only placed buildings and areas the community
truly values and are balanced against Auckland's intensification and development needs.
Heritage
Retain policy 4 [Use, maintenance and repair of scheduled historic heritage places] which
provides incentives to assist in the cost of maintaining scheduled historic heritage places.
control
and policies Delete these provisions.
control
Building demolition control J.3.6 Rules and mapping Delete rules
Centre)
Overlay E4.4/J4.5 City Centre
Fringe Office Retain overlay
Centre)
Fringe Office
Add policy to actively provide excellent public transport to support intensive office and
commercial activities in this area.
6212-60 Property Council New Zealand connal@propertynz.co.nz General Chapter G General provisions G2.2 Activities not provided for Delete rule and apply RMA provisions.
6212-61 Property Council New Zealand connal@propertynz.co.nz General Chapter G General provisions
statements Delete Rule G 2.7.2
6212-62 Property Council New Zealand connal@propertynz.co.nz Mana Whenua General provisions
assessment Replace Rule G 2.7.4 with clearer, more appropriate, efficient and legally robust processes.
requirements
Amend Table 2, Rule 3.2 [Parking rates for City Centre zone - all other activities] to allow a
''market based approach", or if maximums have to be implemented, one space per 1002m
GFA
requirements
Amend Table 3 [Parking rates for sites within the City Centre fringe overlay area] to allow
apply more more flexible rules.
6212-65 Property Council New Zealand connal@propertynz.co.nz Earthworks H4.2.2 Controls
Amend to develop more targeted [higher] thresholds which enable permitted activity status for
activities without triggering a resource consent.
6212-66 Property Council New Zealand connal@propertynz.co.nz Water Stormwater H4.14 Introduction
Amend rule 4.14 to develop more targeted [higher] thresholds which enable permitted activity
status for activities without triggering a resource consent.
6212-67 Property Council New Zealand connal@propertynz.co.nz General
GIS viewer
Undertake detailed flood modelling before implementing rules and requirements in respect of
non statutory flood hazard overlays.
6212-68 Property Council New Zealand connal@propertynz.co.nz RPS Mana Whenua B5 Strategic
Clarify and replace various Mana Whenua provisions throughout the plan to achieve more
appropriate, efficient and legally robust processes, schedules and overlays.
6212-69 Property Council New Zealand connal@propertynz.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - Urban zones
except Rural
Amend Table 3 [Future Urban zone - Any subdivision not listed in table 3] to change activity
status from Prohibited to Discretionary.
6212-70 Property Council New Zealand connal@propertynz.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - Rural zones
zones only
Amend Table 5 [Rural zones - Any other subdivision not provided for in this table or in the
rural zones subdivision rules] to change activity status from Prohibited to Discretionary.
6212-71 Property Council New Zealand connal@propertynz.co.nz Sustainable Development C7.7/H6.4 Sustainable design Delete rules and replace the provision of incentives to incentivise green ratings.
6212-72 Property Council New Zealand connal@propertynz.co.nz Residential zones Housing affordability H6.6 Rules Delete rules and replace with non mandatory incentive based approach.
6212-73 Property Council New Zealand connal@propertynz.co.nz Residential zones Residential Land use controls
Delete rule 3.1 Maximum density, with specific reference to the maximum density
requirements in the Mixed Housing Suburban and Mixed Housing Urban zones.
6212-74 Property Council New Zealand connal@propertynz.co.nz Residential zones Residential Land use controls
Retain Rule 3.1(6) Maximum density, which includes the no density limit for the Mixed housing
Urban zone, but reduce the minimum net site area from 1200m2 to 900-1000m2.
General
Amend the maximum impervious surface rules to increase the maximum impervious area to
70 per cent in the Single House zone, Mixed Housing Suburban zone, Mixed Housing Urban
zone and Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings zone.
Amend [rule 6.7 Building coverage] to increase the maximum building coverage from 35 per
cent to 40 per cent.
182/1145
Sub#/
General
Amend the building coverage rules to increase the maximum building coverage to 50 per
cent in the Mixed Housing Suburban zone, Mixed Housing Urban zone and Terrace Housing
and Apartment Buildings zone.
General
Amend the landscaping rules to reduce landscaping requirements to 30 per cent in the Single
House zone, Mixed Housing Suburban zone, Mixed Housing Urban zone and Terrace
Housing and Apartment Buildings zone.
General
Delete outlook space rules in the Mixed Housing Suburban zone, Mixed Housing Urban zone
and Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings zone and provide for outlook space in the
ADM.
General
Simplify the rules on 'Separation between buildings within a site' in the Mixed Housing
Suburban zone, Mixed Housing Urban zone and Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings
zone.
General
Simplify the "Maximum building length" rule in the Mixed Housing Suburban zone, Mixed
Housing Urban zone and Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings zone.
General
Delete "Universal access" rules in the Single House zone, Mixed Housing Suburban zone,
Mixed Housing Urban zone and Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings zone.
Delete "Dwellings fronting the street" rules in the Mixed Housing Suburban zone and Mixed
Housing Urban zone.
General
Delete "Daylight to dwellings" rules in the Single House zone, Mixed Housing Suburban zone,
Mixed Housing Urban zone and Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings zone.
Centre) Business
Park zones
Amend rule 4.2 [Building height] to allow a maximum building height of at least 5+ storeys in
all the business zones.
6212-86 Property Council New Zealand connal@propertynz.co.nz Built Environment (Overlays)
Height Control Retain overlay.
Centre) Business
Park zones
Amend rule 4.5 Maximum tower dimension and two separation to increase the proposed
height of 28m at which the control commences; and to increase the maximum height from
50m to 75m.
Centre) Business
Park zones Delete rule 4.8 Minimum floor to ceiling height.
Centre) Business
Park zones Amend rule 4.9 Glazing to allow for individual site circumstances and a varied approach.
6212-90 Property Council New Zealand connal@propertynz.co.nz City Centre Zone I4 Rules/Appendix 7.1- 7.3 Retain rules 4.10 to 4.19 Bonus floor area controls
Centre) Business
General objectives and policies Apply bonus provisions similar to those in the City Centre zone outside the City Centre zone.
Centre) Business
Park zones
Amend rule 4.11 [Residential at ground floor] to give preference to retail and office but allow
flexibility where it would not detract from the overall vision for the centre zones.
Centre) Business
Park zones
Recognise that rule 4.12 Ground floor at street frontage level is too prescriptive and that
future proofing all ground floor frontage for potential commercial uses increases costs and
may not achieve the desired outcomes.
6212-94 Property Council New Zealand connal@propertynz.co.nz City Centre Zone I4 Rules/Appendix 7.1- 7.3
Amend Rule 4.23 Maximum tower dimension, setback from the street and tower separation to
increase the 50m dimension to 75m.
6212-95 Property Council New Zealand connal@propertynz.co.nz City Centre Zone I4 Rules/Appendix 7.1- 7.3 Delete rule 4.41[Universal access for residential buildings].
Heritage
places
Amend the activity table to change modification to heritage buildings from a discretionary to a
restricted discretionary activity.
Amend rule 2.1 Maintenance and repair to take a more balanced approach by including
consideration of economic implications.
Heritage
places
Delete activity under Development - earthquake strengthening: "Temporary dismantling for
seismic strengthening to meet the requirements of the council's plans prepared under the
Building Act "
features
Amend rules to be more flexible and only protect volcanic viewshafts of real value after
undertaking a fine grain analysis of the effects on achieving intensification targets of volcanic
viewshafts.
183/1145
Sub#/
6212-
100 Property Council New Zealand connal@propertynz.co.nz
Centre) Business
Recognise that the abandonment of floor area ratio controls in favour of urban design controls
will increase the need for urban design assessments and Council needs to manage this
process to ensure sufficient certainty, flexibility and efficiency and ensure that it avoids
unnecessary delays and costs.
6212-
101 Property Council New Zealand connal@propertynz.co.nz General Chapter A Introduction
Plan
Review the number and extent of overlays by withdrawing some of them and reducing the size
of others to align with the vision for a compact, dense city. Refer to further details and
attached maps on pages 86/90, 87/90, 88/90, 89/90 and 90/90.
6212-
102 Property Council New Zealand connal@propertynz.co.nz RPS
Remove blanket provisions (such as the Pre-1944 demolition rule) and rules where the
triggers are so low that they are, in practical effect, blanket provisions (such as SEAs).
6212-
character and natural heritage B4.3.3 Trees and vegetation
Limit the extent of protection contained in blanket provisions in 6.1 [Notable trees] so they do
not impose a burden on the owner to establish why they should not be protected.
6212-
104 Property Council New Zealand connal@propertynz.co.nz Special Character
Limit the extent of protection contained in blanket provisions in E3.1 [Business and residential
special character areas] so they do not impose a burden on the owner to establish why they
should not be protected.
6212-
105 Property Council New Zealand connal@propertynz.co.nz General Whole Plan
Retain the use of a single plan for the Auckland Region with a more consistent set of rules
than existed under the legacy plans.
6212-
106 Property Council New Zealand connal@propertynz.co.nz RPS Urban growth
Recognise that the PAUP will not achieve the compact city model and levels of intensification
proposed in the Auckland Plan.
6212-
land for urban development Review the PAUP to achieve greater upzoning of land to increase residential capacity.
6212-
Transport
B3.1 Commercial and
industrial growth
Recognise that the PAUP will not achieve the supply of business and industrial zoned land
required to accommodate future population and economic growth.
6212-
109 Property Council New Zealand connal@propertynz.co.nz Sustainable Development C7.7/H6.4 Sustainable design
Recognise that the sustainable design objectives, policies and provisions in the PAUP are not
legally robust and will lead to additional delays and costs for the development industry.
6212-
Includes greater recognition of the importance of infrastructure in Regional Policy Statement
and the role is plays in accommodating the timely and efficient growth of urban areas.
6212-
111 Property Council New Zealand connal@propertynz.co.nz Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
Recognise that the PAUP cannot rely on currently levels of public transport to justify the
onerous restrictions on car parking. Ensure that adequate provision is made for the provision
of cycle paths so the requirement to provide facilities is not redundant.
6212-
Notification
Amend activity table to make parking buildings and short-term parking a restricted
discretionary activity in the City centre.
6212-
requirements Delete reference to the non statutory Auckland Transport Code of Practice.
6212-
114 Property Council New Zealand connal@propertynz.co.nz General Cross plan matters
Apply a 'deemed to comply' approach to [endorsing] a development proposal where Council
satisfied that it will not affect neighbouring properties and the urban design criteria have been
met. Where they are not met, the development would revert to a normal resource consent
process.
6212-
environment
Retain the ADM as a non statutory document but ensure that this does not become a check
list for assessing compliance the same as a statutory document.
6212-
116 Property Council New Zealand connal@propertynz.co.nz General Chapter G General provisions G2.4 Notification Retain non notification provisions
6212-
117 Property Council New Zealand connal@propertynz.co.nz General Chapter G General provisions G2.4 Notification Make more activities a restricted discretionary activity to minimise notification requirements.
6212-
118 Property Council New Zealand connal@propertynz.co.nz General Chapter G General provisions
statements
Ensure that information requirements are carefully balanced to ensure that plans and level of
expert reporting is commensurate with the scale and complexity of the proposed
development.
6212-
119 Property Council New Zealand connal@propertynz.co.nz General Chapter G General provisions
Review the use of Framework Plans to ensure they are kept simple and commercially viable
for development as outlined in on page 29/90 of the submission.
6212-
120 Property Council New Zealand connal@propertynz.co.nz General Cross plan matters
Reject all rules that do not provide for sufficient upzoning and unnecessarily stifle
development.
6212-
121 Property Council New Zealand connal@propertynz.co.nz General Miscellaneous Special housing areas
Make greater use of the Special Housing Areas process to for all major projects to streamline
the approval process and ensure infrastructure is provided in an integrated manner.
6213-1
A C and O Downs and Wilson
McKay Trustee Company
Limited andrea@thelinkagency.co.nz Special Character
& C
Isthmus
Remove the Special Character Overlay as it relates to 66 Tohunga Crescent, Parnell
(Residential Isthmus B2)
6213-2
A C and O Downs and Wilson
McKay Trustee Company
Limited andrea@thelinkagency.co.nz Special Character
& C
Isthmus
Remove the additional demolition control on map J3.3.8 as it relates to 66 Tohunga Crescent,
Parnell.
6214-1 Suzanne V and Alan Norcott anorcott@xtra.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - Urban zones H5.2 3.1 Residential zones
Amend the minimum site size in the [Single House zone in Howick] from 600m
2
to 700m
2
.
Proposals which breach this minimum site size should be non-complying
184/1145
Sub#/
6214-2 Suzanne V and Alan Norcott anorcott@xtra.co.nz Residential zones Residential Land use controls
Enable minor household units where they blend in with the main dwelling and do not infringe
the 35% building coverage control
6214-3 Suzanne V and Alan Norcott anorcott@xtra.co.nz Zoning South
Retain Single House zoning in Northpark, Meadowlands, Somerville, Golflands, Dannemora,
Whitford Rd from Chapel Road to Smoerville Rd and all of Somerville Rd, Somerville
Rezone Bucklands Beach, Half Moon Bay, Farm Cove and Sunny Hills to Single House with a
minimum site size of 500m
2
generally and 400m
2
for townhouses
Rezone Hutchinson Rd, Penruddocke Rd and around Highland Park shopping centre from
Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings to [Mixed Housing Urban]
Rezone the eastern side of Pakuranga Rd around Williams Ave, Pakuranga from Terrace
Housing and Apartment Buildings to [Mixed Housing Urban]. Rezone the large Terrace
Housing and Apartment Building zoning on the [western side] of Pakuranga Rd to Terrace
Housing and Apartment Buildings and [Mixed Housing Urban]
6214-7 Suzanne V and Alan Norcott anorcott@xtra.co.nz
Centre) Business
Park zones
Amend the height in the Botany Town Centre from 18 storeys to 6 storeys along Ti Rakau
Drive and Ti Irirangi Drive and 3 storeys where the Botany Town Centre backs onto Adare
Place
Centre) Business
Park zones Retain 6 storey height limit on [451] Ti Rakau Drive, Pakuranga [the Hub]
Centre) Business
Park zones
Amend height limit of 500 Ti Rakau Drive [Town Centre zone], Pakuranga from 6 storeys to 3
or 4 storeys
Centre) Business
Park zones Amend height limit in Highland Park [Town Centre] to 3 or 4 storeys
Centre) Business
Park zones Amend height limit of 481/9 Pakuranga Rd, Pakuranga to 6 storeys
Centre) Business
Park zones Amend height limit of Pakuranga Plaza from 12 storeys to 6 or 8 storeys
Centre) Business
Park zones
Increase minimum dwelling sizes for apartments in City/ Metropolitan areas and do not allow
studio apartments
6214-14 Suzanne V and Alan Norcott anorcott@xtra.co.nz Residential zones Residential Notification
Amend so proposals that breach the density, height, height in relation to boundary, yard and
subdivision rules are non-complying activities and neighbouring properties are [notified]
Centre) Business
Park zones Retain apartment height limits in Browns Bay
6214-16 Suzanne V and Alan Norcott anorcott@xtra.co.nz Residential zones Residential
policies
Plan green space in areas of Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings and [Mixed Housing
Urban] zoning
General
Provide for garden sheds up to 1m from property boundaries. Encourage the rear of garages
to be designed as garden sheds.
6214-18 Suzanne V and Alan Norcott anorcott@xtra.co.nz Residential zones Residential Land use controls
Amend the additional residential units rules [inferred rule 3.3 The conversion of a dwellings
into two dwellings] to address size and design, and to consider the impacts on neighbours.
6214-19 Suzanne V and Alan Norcott anorcott@xtra.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - Urban zones H5.2 3.1 Residential zones
Amend minimum site size in the [Mixed Housing Suburban] zone to not allow subdivision of
sites under 800m
2
, and to require for sites over 1200m
2
, a minimum site size of 350m
2
with up
to 20% of sites able to be 300m
2
Amend [rules 8.6 and 7.5 Yards] to have 4.5m front yard control in the Mixed Housing Urban
and Mixed Housing Suburban zones.
6214-21 Suzanne V and Alan Norcott anorcott@xtra.co.nz Transport Auckland -wide
requirements Require visitor parking in the Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings zone
Rezone Macleans Park from Public Open Space Sport and Active Recreation to Informal
Recreation
6214-23 Suzanne V and Alan Norcott anorcott@xtra.co.nz Precincts - South Beachlands 1
[Amend the rules] so that there is no further development in Beachlands until mains water has
been provided and a road is constructed between Beachlands and Pine Harbour
6214-24 Suzanne V and Alan Norcott anorcott@xtra.co.nz Precincts - South Beachlands 1 Amend minimum site sizes in Beachlands to 700m
2
organisms
modified organisms Amend provisions to not allow GMO foods in Auckland
185/1145
Sub#/
6214-26 Suzanne V and Alan Norcott anorcott@xtra.co.nz RPS Mana Whenua B5 Strategic Delete the Mana Whenua provisions
Rezone Otara, Hunters Plaza, Takanini, Papatoetoe and other areas close to motorways,
hospitals, MIT and Manukau University Campus to increase the amount of intensive housing
and apartments
6215-1 The Neil Group k.kurzeja@harrisongrierson.com General Chapter G General provisions
activities Retain rule 2.3 (2) which states that rule infringements are a restricted discretionary activity.
6215-2 The Neil Group k.kurzeja@harrisongrierson.com General Chapter G General provisions G2.4 Notification Retain rule 2.4 Notification.
6215-3 The Neil Group k.kurzeja@harrisongrierson.com Mana Whenua General provisions
discovery protocol Remove the accidental discovery protocols.
G2.7.3 Framework plans Retain the Framework Plan rules and activity status.
6215-5 The Neil Group k.kurzeja@harrisongrierson.com Historic Heritage (Overlay)
Heritage
protocols
Remove the requirement [Rule 2.7.8] for a Heritage Impact Assessment for any discretionary
activity, non-complying activity or subdivision resource on land affecting water adjacent to a
scheduled historic heritage place.
assessment
Remove the requirement for a Cultural Impact Assessment for any restricted discretionary,
discretionary or non-complying activites on land affecting water adjacent to a scheduled
historic heritage place, where it is archaelogy of Mori origin.
assessment
Remove the requirement for all applications requiring a Resource consent on land containing
sites and places of significance/value to Mana Whenua, to provide a Cultural Impact
Assessment.
6215-8 The Neil Group k.kurzeja@harrisongrierson.com Transport
G2.7.9 Integrated transport
assessment
Delete Table 2, which contains the uses and thresholds for an integrated transport
assessment.
6215-9 The Neil Group k.kurzeja@harrisongrierson.com Transport
assessment
Delete 2.7.9.1 (3) Information requirements for resource consent applications: Integrated
transport assessment.
statements Amend the Design Statement requirement threshold for subdivision from 1 lot to 5 lots.
statements
Remove the Design Statement requirement, including the opportunities and constraints
diagram for specified activities in the Industrial zone.
6215-12 The Neil Group k.kurzeja@harrisongrierson.com Earthworks H4.2.1.1 Activity table - Zones
Retain the rule which states general earthworks greater than 2500m2/2500m3 is a restricted
6215-13 The Neil Group k.kurzeja@harrisongrierson.com Earthworks H4.2.2 Controls Retain rule 2.1.1 General controls.
6215-14 The Neil Group k.kurzeja@harrisongrierson.com Earthworks
Overlays
Delete any additional rules that may elevate the consideration earthworks within overlay areas
to an activity status higher than restricted discretionary activity.
6215-15 The Neil Group k.kurzeja@harrisongrierson.com Residential zones Housing affordability
and policies Delete the Retained Affordable Housing provisions.
6215-16 The Neil Group k.kurzeja@harrisongrierson.com Sustainable Development C7.7/H6.4 Sustainable design Delete the Sustainable Design provisions.
6215-17 The Neil Group k.kurzeja@harrisongrierson.com Water Stormwater
H4.14.2 Stormwater
Amend rule 2.1 Stormwater Management - Flow, so that additional resource consents are only
required where the development results in an infringements of the impervious area controls of
the underlying zone.
rules
Retain the rule for new and redevelopment of existing, high use public roads operated by road
controlling authorities within an impervious area greater tan 5000m2, where stormwater
quality management requirements are met.
rules
Amend the requirement that new public roads operated by road controlling authority having
new impervious areas less than or equal to 5000m2, including ancillary impervious areas that
are part of a public road, not meeting controls is a Restricted Discretionary Activity.
6215-20 The Neil Group k.kurzeja@harrisongrierson.com Residential zones Residential Land use controls
Retain the approach to density in the Mixed Housing Urban zone and the Terrace Housing
and Apartment Building zone.
6215-21 The Neil Group k.kurzeja@harrisongrierson.com Residential zones Residential
policies
Retain the General Residential objectives and policies, in particular Objective 1 - 3 and
Policies 1 - 3.
Retain the development controls in the Mixed Housing Suburban and Mixed Housing Urban
zones, with the exception of rules 7.5, 7.22, 8.18, 8.23 and 8.24.
Mixed Housing Urban zone Amend Table 5, Rule 7.5 Yards, so that the Front Yard is 3m not 4m.
Mixed Housing Urban zone Delete rules 7.22 and 8.24 Universal Access.
186/1145
Sub#/
Terrace Housing and
Amend rule 9.23 Universal Access, so that it is only applicable to apartment developments
and that the maximum slope control changes from 1:20 to 1:12.
Amend rule 8.19 [inferred] Minimum dimension of prinicpal living rooms and principle
bedrooms, to remove the requirement for a 3m minimum floor space
Terrace Housing and
Amend rule 9.22 Minimum floor to floor/ceiling height, to remove the minimum floor to floor
height of 4m.
Terrace Housing and
Amend 9.22(2) from 2.55m to 2.4m or that the 2.55m requirement only applies to the principal
living room.
General Delete the rules controlling dwelling mix.
Amend rule 9.8 Building coverage, to increase the maximum building coverage from 40 per
cent to 60 per cent.
Terrace Housing and
Apartment Buildings zone Amend rule 9.9 Landscaping, to reduce the requirement from 30 per cent to 20 per cent.
Terrace Housing and
Amend rule 9.7 Maximum impervious area, to reduce the requirement from 60 per cent to 20
per cent.
Amend the Building Separation rules in the Terrace Housing and Apartment Building zone to
allow for more realistic outcomes, as shown in the submission [refer to page 8/32]
6215-34 The Neil Group k.kurzeja@harrisongrierson.com Zoning Central Retain the Mixed Use zone on property at 8 Nugent Street, Grafton.
6215-35 The Neil Group k.kurzeja@harrisongrierson.com Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
Delete the maximum on-site parking space requirement in the City Centre Fringe Parking
Overlay Area for office use listed in Table 3 and 4 of Rule 3.2.(1)(b)(i).
6215-36 The Neil Group k.kurzeja@harrisongrierson.com Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
Delete the maximum on-site parking space requirement in the City Centre Fringe Parking
Overlay Area for residential use and retain the minimum requirement for one car park space
per dwelling.
6215-37 The Neil Group k.kurzeja@harrisongrierson.com
Centre) Business
Park zones
Amend rule 4.8(3) Minimum floor to floor/ceiling height, to specify an alternative floor to floor
height of 3m rather than 3.6m.
Centre) Business
Park zones
Amend the rear and side yard control in Centres, Mixed Use and General Business zones
from 3m to 2m.
Centre) Business
Park zones
Delete the 5m planted landscape side and rear yard where a development adjoins a public
open space, in the Light Industry zone.
Centre) Business
& Bus. Park zones Amend the activity status for new buildings from Restricted Discretionary to Controlled.
Centre) Business
Amend the activity status for offices not otherwise provided for in the Activity Table, from Non-
complying to Discretionary.
Centre) Business
& Bus. Park zones
Amend Activity Table, as shown in the submission [refer to page 23/32 of the submission], to
provide for retail thresholds of per unit not per site.
6215-43 The Neil Group k.kurzeja@harrisongrierson.com Definitions New
Add a new definition of Retail Unit to read: an individual, self contained entity engaging in
retail activities.
6215-44 The Neil Group k.kurzeja@harrisongrierson.com Subdivision Auckland-wide - general
and policies Retain the objectives and policies with the exception of Policies 15, 16 and 22.
and policies
Amend Policy 15 to read: Prioritise shared Ensure future vehicle access is planned for to
avoid: the proliferation of vehicle crossings that could affect adverse effects on the safety of
the road and footpath; limitations on the opportunity to plant street trees, and; or provide
inefficiencies in the provision of on street car parking
and policies
Amend Policy 16 to read: Require shared vehicle access to serve no more than eight rear
sites and to be of a width, length and form that...
and policies
Amend Policy 22 to read: Require subdivision applications with 5 or more sites to analyse the
context of the application area and neighbourhood through a design statement, to
demonstrate how the subdivision positively responds to its context, thereby enabling a high
quality responsive design.
187/1145
Sub#/
6215-48 The Neil Group k.kurzeja@harrisongrierson.com Subdivision Auckland-wide - Urban zones
except Rural
Add new Restricted Discretionary activity to Activity Table 1, which reads: Subdivision in
accordance with an approved Structure Plan, Concept Plan or Framework Plan
except Rural
Retain the activity status of subdivision of residential and business zoned land in Activity
Table 2.
except Rural
Amend the following activity in Activity Table 3: Any subdivision not listed in table 3
Prohibited Any other subdivision not listed in Table 1 and 3 Discretionary
except Rural
Retain the following activity in Activity Table 6: Any other zone not listed in activity tables 1 to
5 is a Discretionary Activity
6215-52 The Neil Group k.kurzeja@harrisongrierson.com Subdivision Auckland-wide - Urban zones H5.2 3.1 Residential zones
Retain the minimum site areas in rule 1 Table 1, with the exception of the 600m2 for the
Single House Zone.
Amend the minimum net site area for Single House Zone from 600m2 to 400m2. And amend
the minimum average net site area from 600m2 to 500m2.
Replace Rule 1(b) with the following: As an alternative to compliance with clause (a) above,
for a subdivision of a parent site of 1ha or more and where 15 or more vacant sites are
proposed in the Single House zone, the average net site area shall fall within the average lot
size range of 400m2 - 600m2 with a minimum average of 500m2.
6215-55 The Neil Group k.kurzeja@harrisongrierson.com Definitions Existing
Amend the definition of Rear Site to read: A site with frontage of less than 10m 8m to a legal
road, except that: A site served by a joint owned access lot or right of way easement service
lane for its vehicle access while providing for pedestrian access directly from a road is not a
rear site and Where preceding or concurrent land use consent has been obtained for a
residential dwelling that fronts and is directly accessed from a road on a site of less than 8m
wide a the frontage, this is not a rear site.
Amend rule 3 (a) to increase the percentage of rear sites allowed from 5 per cent to 20 per
cent.
Amend rule 4 (a) to read: A single jointly owned access lot or right of way easement must not
serve more than eight ten proposed vacant rear sites.
Amend Rule 4(b) Table 2 to read: Change the title from Access to rear lots to Access way
design. Change the heading for the fourth column from 6-8 to 6 or more. Change the
minimum legal width from 6.5m to 6.0m. Change the minimum formed width from 5.5m to
4.5m. Change the maximum length in the final column from 50m to 60m.
6215-59 The Neil Group k.kurzeja@harrisongrierson.com Subdivision Auckland-wide - Urban zones H5.2 3.1 Residential zones Amend Rule 6 (a) Table 3 heading in Column 1 to read:minimum average net site areas.
6215-60 The Neil Group k.kurzeja@harrisongrierson.com Subdivision Auckland-wide - general H5.3 - 4 Assessment
Amend assessment criteria 6 in Table 14 to read: Connection and integration with the
surrounding neighbourhood and other sites should be provided through roads which provide
for pedestrian and cycle use .
Amend assessment criteria 8 in Table 14 to read: Roads should be aligned north/south to
establish blocks and site layouts that are oriented east/west to enable proposed sites and
future buildings and associated private open space to derive maximum possible benefit from
solar gain. The shape factor for each site should demonstrate a future dwelling and private
open space can achieve maximum solar gain.
6215-62 The Neil Group k.kurzeja@harrisongrierson.com Subdivision Auckland-wide - general H5.3 - 4 Assessment Delete assessment criteria 10 in Table 14.
Amend assessment criteria 12 in Table 14 to read: Blocks should be of a scale, length and
shape to achieve a connected road layout with a choice of routes that prioritise for walking
and cycling.
Amend assessment criteria 18 in Table 14 to read: As many Proposed sites as possible
should front onto, and be accessed directly from, a legal road with a single road frontage
(except corner sites) . Rear sites should be avoided unless it can be demonstrated that there
are topographical, parent site shape or other constraints that prevent the creation of front
sites.
Amend assessment criteria 20 in Table 14 to read: Subdivision should provide a mix of site
sizes, where practicable. Smaller sites should be located closer to public open space, public
transport nodes, community facilities and commercial centres.
Amend assessment criteria 21 in Table 14 to read: Proposed sites should be designed, where
practicable, to be accessed from the southernmost point of the road boundary where the
roads are oriented north-south.
Amend assessment criteria 25 in table 14, to delete paragraphs 2 and 3 and to amend
paragraph 1 to read: Proposed sites should be designed and located to prioritise maximum
solar gain. Proposed site location, shape and orientation should enable future buildings
(including the windows to habitable rooms) and private open space achieves maximum solar
gain.
6215-68 The Neil Group k.kurzeja@harrisongrierson.com Subdivision Auckland-wide - general H5.3 - 4 Assessment Delete assessment criteria 27 in Table 14.
188/1145
Sub#/
Amend assessment criteria 31 in Table 14 to read: Driveways serving over eight ten sites or
over 50m 60m in length should be avoided, unless it can be demonstrated that a shared
driveway can provide safe and convenient access and can be reasonably managed and
maintained through private ownership. Any driveway serving over eight sites should have a
legal width of 6.5m 6.0m and formed width of 5.5m 4.5m.
Amend assessment criteria 35 in Table 14, to read: Cul-de-sacs should be avoided. They
should only be used where connected road patterns are not possible because of natural
features or where a connecting road network will result in a significant loss of developable
land. Where cul-de-sacs are provided, they should be short in length, straight and include
pedestrian and cycle links to surrounding roads.
Amend assessment criteria 38 in Table 14, to read: Any earthworks associated with a
subdivision stage should. And delete clauses (c) and (d)
6215-72 The Neil Group k.kurzeja@harrisongrierson.com Subdivision Auckland-wide - general H5.3 - 4 Assessment Delete assessment criteria 50(f) in Table 14.
6215-73 The Neil Group k.kurzeja@harrisongrierson.com Precincts - North Hobsonville Corridor Amend the mapping to correctly reference the Hobsonville Corridor sub-precincts.
6215-74 The Neil Group k.kurzeja@harrisongrierson.com Precincts - North Hobsonville Corridor
Amend Precinct Plan 1 to re-zone land as shown in the submission [refer to page 26 -27/36]
from Light Industrial to General Business. Add a signalised notation on Precinct Plan 1 at the
junction of Hobsonville Road and Hendrika Court.
6215-75 The Neil Group k.kurzeja@harrisongrierson.com Precincts - North Hobsonville Corridor Delete Objective 7.
6215-76 The Neil Group k.kurzeja@harrisongrierson.com Precincts - North Hobsonville Corridor Delete Objective 8.
Amend Objective 12 to read: In sub-precincts B and C Hobsonville Road is the focal point of
pedestrian activity, with active frontages and high quality urban design.
Amend Policy 5 to read:Enable high intensity development in sub-precincts B and C,
particularly adjoining Hobsonville Road, to provide for high densities of employment and
residential activity adjacent to the transport network.
6215-79 The Neil Group k.kurzeja@harrisongrierson.com Precincts - North Hobsonville Corridor Delete Policy 7.
Amend Policy 15 to read: In sub-precincts B and C, eE ncourage higher employment densities
along public transport corridors by requiring development fronting Hobsonville Road to be
at least two storeys.
Delete Policy 28 or, if not deleted, amend to read: Identify land within the Transit New Zealand
New Zealand Transport Agency Designation TSNZ4 6741 for appropriate development,
subject to the designation prevailing in all cases while it remains in place.
Amend Activity Table 1, as shown in the submission [refer to page 28/32] to delete
Accomodation and Commerce activities, to add Supermarket activities as a Non-complying
activity and to amend New buildings and external alterations and additions to buildings from a
Restricted Discretionary Activity to a Permitted Activity.
Add a new clause to rule 2 Notification, which reads: All other Restricted Discretionary
activities will be subject to the normal tests for notification.
Amend rule 4.1 and 4.2 to read: 1. Except as specified, the development controls of the
underlying zone in the Light Industry zone apply to sub-precinct A, the Mixed Use zone
applies sub-precinct B and the Local Centre zone applies to sub-precinct C. 2. Development
that does not comply with the development controls is a restricted discretionary activity.
6215-85 The Neil Group k.kurzeja@harrisongrierson.com Precincts - North Hobsonville Corridor Amend rule 4.3.1 Buildings fronting Hobsonville Road, to remove reference to sub-precinct A.
Amend rule 4.4.1 Building frontage height on Hobsonville Road, to remove reference to sub-
precinct A.
Amend first paragraph in section 6.1 Matters of discretion, to read: The council will restrict its
discretion to the matters below for the activities listed as restricted discretionary in the precinct
activity table, in addition to the matters of discretion for the activity in the underlying zone.
Amend the 3rd row of Table 1 in section 6.1 to read: Buildings, and alterations and additions
to buildings in sub-precinct A not meeting the development controls for the underlying zone.
And to remove reference to 'Building interface with public realm'.
Amend assessment criteria 2(g) to read: In sub-precincts B and C, D design car parking and
loading spaces should be either:
Amend assessment criteria 2(h) to read: Any proposed development, buildings and
subdivision in sub-precinct A that adjoin to or are visible from Hobsonville Road or the
Hobsonville primary school should achieve a high standard of visual amenity through such
methods as design articulation of building facades, limiting building height and bulk, building
set backs, the design of the landscape interface area, landscape treatment of front yards,
fencing on the Hobsonville primary school boundary, and screening of storage areas.
189/1145
Sub#/
Amend assessment criteria 2(j) to read: Any proposed development, buildings and subdivision
in sub-precinct A that adjoin to, or are visible from the northern and western boundary of the
Hobsonville primary school, achieves the mitigation of noise and visual effects on the school
through the implementation of a landscape interface plan. The frontage control (refer precinct
plan 4) should be adhered to where buildings are of a design or function that does not require
an active interface with the street, and where a setback is required to maintain a satisfactory
standard of visual amenity for any outlook from residential development directly opposite the
site on Hobsonville Road.
6215-92 The Neil Group k.kurzeja@harrisongrierson.com Precincts - North Hobsonville Corridor Amend assessment criteria 4(a) to remove reference to the New Zealand Transport Agency.
6215-93 The Neil Group k.kurzeja@harrisongrierson.com Precincts - North Hobsonville Corridor Amend assessment criteria 4(e) to remove reference to the New Zealand Transport Authority.
Amend assessment criteria 4(I) to read: In sub-precincts B and C, T the design of roads and
slip lanes should utilise land efficiently and encourages walkability by using minimal
dimensions for carriageways creating safe entry and exit points on the slip lanes and
integrating service lines beneath footpaths or parking bays. In sub-precinct A, the design of
roads should take into consideration the anticipated types of road users and ensure the
design does not compromise the safe and efficient of operation of the road network.
Amend assessment criteria 4(n) to read: When preparing framework plans for sub-precincts B
and C, P provision should be made for public transport facilities, including a public transport
interchange, taxi stops and bus stops.
Amend assessment criteria 4(q) to read: In sub-precincts B and C, C car parking should be
designed according to a perimeter block layout where parking is provided behind buildings,
except for kerbside parking, and with the main activity frontage for buildings oriented towards
public streets rather than parking area.
Amend assessment criteria 4(t) to read: In sub-precincts B and C, P parking areas should be
located behind buildings, screened with landscaping (not visible from street) or be located in
semi or full basements.
Amend assessment criteria 4(v) to read: When preparing framework plans for sub-precincts B
and C, W worker or student parking for non-residential activities should be provided for within
a five minute walking distance of land uses, rather than necessarily adjoining each non-
residential activity.
Amend assessment criteria 5(d) to read: Provision for storm water management and land use
must meet the requirements of the appropriate integrated catchment management plan
Waiarohia . Development must not cause a noncompliance with the condition of consent for
network discharge consent for Auckland Regional Council Permit 25692.
6215-
100 The Neil Group k.kurzeja@harrisongrierson.com Precincts - North Hobsonville Corridor Delete assessment criteria 5(f).
6215-
101 The Neil Group k.kurzeja@harrisongrierson.com General Chapter G General provisions
activities
Retain rule 2.3 (3): Rule infringements for permitted, controlled and restricted discretionary
activities.
6215-
102 The Neil Group k.kurzeja@harrisongrierson.com Residential zones Residential
policies
Retain the widespread use of the Mixed Housing Suburban and Mixed Housing Urban zones
and that this opens up opportunities for increasing housing typology choice.
6216-1 Alexander Shaw alex@masterspec.co.nz Residential zones Residential
Mixed Housing Urban zone Amend rule 8.13 [Dwellings fronting the street] to delete the percentage of glazing required.
Terrace Housing and
Apartment Buildings zone Delete rule 9.16 [Garages].
Mixed Housing Urban zone Amend rule 8.18 [Daylight to dwellings] to decrease the percentage of glazing.
6217-1 John and Hanneke Restall fjrestall@xtra.co.nz Zoning North and Islands Rezone 173 Shakespeare Road, Milford from Mixed Housing Urban to Mixed Use.
6218-1 The Avondale Jockey Club philip@campbellbrown.co.nz Zoning West
Retain the zoning over the Avondale Racecourse subject to the minor amendment identified
in Attachements C and D of the submission - pages 12 and 13/13
6218-2 The Avondale Jockey Club philip@campbellbrown.co.nz Definitions Existing Retain the definition of 'Major recreation facility'
6218-3 The Avondale Jockey Club philip@campbellbrown.co.nz Public Open Space Zones
Recreation Facilities I18.1 Activity table
Amend the Activity Table to include a wider range of activities as permitted activities. See
submission page 7/13 for details.
6218-4 The Avondale Jockey Club philip@campbellbrown.co.nz Precincts Ak-Wide and Coastal Racing K1.6 Precinct Rules
Amend the Activity Table to clarify that it does not restrict or limit the application of the Major
recreation facility zone activity table
6218-5 The Avondale Jockey Club philip@campbellbrown.co.nz Precincts Ak-Wide and Coastal Racing K1.6 Precinct Rules
Amend the development controls to clarify the areas to which the height and building
coverage controls apply
190/1145
Sub#/
6218-6 The Avondale Jockey Club philip@campbellbrown.co.nz Precincts - West Avondale 1
Amend K7.1.1 Activity Table, so that the mixed use activity table applies in all respects, with
the exception that reatil activites over 450 m2 gross floor area remain as non-complying
activities
6218-7 The Avondale Jockey Club philip@campbellbrown.co.nz Precincts - West Avondale 1 Amend K7.1.1 Activity Table by deleting the infrastructure rule
Amend K7.1.1 Activity Table so that it provides for the activities that are contained within the
Racing Precinct (Avondale Racecourse Sub-Precinct) activity table, at the same categories as
contained in that table
Remove the wedge-shaped piece of land between Elm Street and Racecourse Parade from
the Avondale 1 precinct plan including deletion of the indicative road link between Elm Street
and Racecourse Parade
6218-10 The Avondale Jockey Club philip@campbellbrown.co.nz Zoning West
Extend the Mixed Use zone at the end of Racecourse Parade to the extent shown on
Attachment D of the submission - page 13/13
Delete the indicative road shown on the Avondale 1 Precinct concept plan between Elm
Street and Ash Street [K7.1.6]
6219-1 Mary-Ann Robertson maryannrobertson@xtra.co.nz Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula K5.11 Precinct rules
Delete the street connection between David Street and Plymouth Crescent and retain the
existing pedestrian walkway. [Precinct plan 3: Devonport Peninsula sub-precinct C].
Reject provision for three and four storey building heights (retain two storey limit) [Sub-
precinct C].
6219-3 Mary-Ann Robertson maryannrobertson@xtra.co.nz Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula K5.11 Precinct rules Reject the lack of restrictions on the density control of housing in the area [Sub-precinct C].
6219-4 Mary-Ann Robertson maryannrobertson@xtra.co.nz Zoning North and Islands
Rezone Mixed Housing Suburban areas to Single House [in Devonport Peninsula sub-
precinct C, in the vicinity of Plymouth Crescent, Bayswater].
6219-5 Mary-Ann Robertson maryannrobertson@xtra.co.nz Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula
Amend the objectives and policies to adopt the Single House zone objectives and
policies, relating to the limitation to two storey development.
6219-6 Mary-Ann Robertson maryannrobertson@xtra.co.nz Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula K5.11 Precinct rules Amend to provide full public notification and consultation for any framework plan.
Amend development control 4.6 'Building length', so that building length rules apply in the sub-
precincts.
6219-8 Mary-Ann Robertson maryannrobertson@xtra.co.nz Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula
Complete improvements to infrastructure (including roading, sewerage, schooling, and
stormwater), prior to further development [in the Devonport Peninsula precinct].
6219-9 Mary-Ann Robertson maryannrobertson@xtra.co.nz General Miscellaneous Special housing areas Reject the identification of any Special Housing Area in the Devonport Peninsula precinct.
6220-1 Bridget G Fallwell bridget@fallwell.co.nz Zoning North and Islands Rezone the Wairau Valley from Light Industry to General Business.
6220-2 Bridget G Fallwell bridget@fallwell.co.nz Zoning North and Islands Rezone the 109 Wairau Road, Wairau Valley from Light Industry to General Business.
6220-3 Bridget G Fallwell bridget@fallwell.co.nz Zoning North and Islands Rezone 2A Gibbons Road, Takapuna, from Single House to Mixed Housing Suburban.
6221-1 Christine MacKenzie christine@eos.co.nz Zoning Central
Rezone Prospect Terrace, Mt Eden, particularly 33 Prospect Terrace from Mixed Housing
Suburban to Single House
Rezone Ashton Rd, Bellevue Rd, Valley Rd, Locklock Ave, Ngauruhoe St and St Albans Ave,
Mt Eden from Mixed Housing Suburban to Single House
6221-3 Christine MacKenzie christine@eos.co.nz Public Open Space Zones
I18.2-3 Land use &
Development controls
Retain the inclusion of the existing Eden Park concept plan and consent conditions in the
rules
6221-4 Christine MacKenzie christine@eos.co.nz Precincts Ak-Wide and Coastal Stadiums and Showgrounds
Retain the inclusion of the existing Eden Park concept plan and consent conditions in the
rules for the sub-precinct Eden Park
6221-5 Christine MacKenzie christine@eos.co.nz General
H6.5) Exclude rules from applying to the Eden Park sub-precinct.
6221-6 Christine MacKenzie christine@eos.co.nz General Chapter G General provisions G2.4 Notification
Amend so restricted discretionary activities are subject to the normal notification tests under
the RMA
6221-7 Christine MacKenzie christine@eos.co.nz Residential zones Residential Land use controls
Delete clause 3.1(5) Maximum density to remove the 200m
2
density control in the Mixed
Housing Suburban zone where the site is greater than 1200m
2
Delete clause 3.1(6) Maximum density, to remove the the unlimited density control in the
Mixed Housing Urban zone where the site is greater than 1200m
2

Amend rule 3.1 [Maximum density] so that the activity status of activities within 30m of a
residential zone is Discretionary rather than Restricted Discretionary.
6221-10 Christine MacKenzie christine@eos.co.nz Special Character
& C J3.3.1-7 Rules Amend the activity status of demolition from restricted discretionary to discretionary
6221-11 Christine MacKenzie christine@eos.co.nz Special Character
& C J3.3.1-7 Rules Delete consideration of building relocation from the assessment criteria
Rezone Sandringham Rd from Rossmay Terrace south to Gribblehirst Rd, Sandringham from
Mixed Housing Urban to Mixed Housing Suburban
6221-13 Christine MacKenzie christine@eos.co.nz Built Environment (Overlays)
Height Control
Amend the additional height control overlay over the Eden Valley Local Centre from 12.5 to
10m/ two storeys
6221-14 Christine MacKenzie christine@eos.co.nz Built Environment (Overlays)
Height Control
Add an additional height overlay to the Mixed use zone at Prospect terrace, east and west to
Brixton Road to reduce the height from 16.5m to 10m / two storeys.
191/1145
Sub#/
Rezone the area of Balmoral Rd, west to Sandringham Rd, north to Kingsland, east to Mt
Eden Rd, and north to New North Rd from Mixed Housing Urban and Mixed Use [submission
does not specify alternative zone].
6221-16 Christine MacKenzie christine@eos.co.nz Residential zones Residential
policies
Amend provisions for intensification in the Mixed Housing Urban zone to require a staging
mechanism to be applied which only applies new zoning after an independent verification of
infrastructure provision is carried out and a shortage of land can be proven.
6222-1
EA and JP Nicholls and
Belmont Land Owners and
Makan Lala and Sons Limited markball@xnet.co.nz RPS Urban growth
quality compact urban form General support for the Rural Urban Boundary and Future Urban Zoning
6222-2
Makan Lala and Sons Limited markball@xnet.co.nz Zoning South
Retain zoning which protects the elite soils around the eastern side of Pukekohe Hill,
Pukekohe towards Buckland
6222-3
Makan Lala and Sons Limited markball@xnet.co.nz RPS Changes to the RUB General
Revise the provisions for the Rural Urban Boundary regarding reverse sensitivity, noise and
odour
6222-4
Makan Lala and Sons Limited markball@xnet.co.nz RPS Urban growth
Add new and improved transport corridors serving the growth within the Rural Urban
Boundary around Pukekohe, eg the Pukekohe Eastern Arterial (PEA)
6222-5
Makan Lala and Sons Limited markball@xnet.co.nz Residential zones
& pols Retain the Large Lot provisions
6222-6
Makan Lala and Sons Limited markball@xnet.co.nz Zoning South
Rezone the new Belmont urban area to extend west, including land west of Adams Road
South, Pukekohe in a line down along Domain Road, Pukekohe. [refer to page 2/2 of the
submission for further details]
6222-7
Makan Lala and Sons Limited markball@xnet.co.nz General Noise and vibration H6.2 Rules
Amend provisions for noise as the Auckland wide noise standard for a rural environment will
curtail rural production.
6222-8
Makan Lala and Sons Limited markball@xnet.co.nz Rural Zones General I13.3 Development controls Retain the lack of provisions on the size and siting of greenhouses
6223-1 Iggy Fernandes iggy.fernandes@asb.co.nz Zoning Central
Reject the Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings zone in the Knight Avenue, Mount Albert
area.
6224-1 Mark E Fallwell mark@fallwell.co.nz Zoning North and Islands Rezone 109 Wairau Valley Road, Wairau Valley from Light Industrial to General Business.
6224-2 Mark E Fallwell mark@fallwell.co.nz Zoning North and Islands Rezone the Wairau Valley area from Light Industrial to General Business.
6224-3 Mark E Fallwell mark@fallwell.co.nz Zoning North and Islands Rezone 2A Gibbons Road, Takapuna from Single House to Mixed Housing Suburban.
6225-1 Bayswater Marina Limited craigshearer@xtra.co.nz RPS Issues
Amend first paragraph under the sub heading 'Subdivision, use and development' and add an
additional paragraph as detailed in submission (page 2).
6225-2 Bayswater Marina Limited craigshearer@xtra.co.nz RPS Issues
change
Add after second sentence under sub heading 'Adaptation': ".... existing locations. The
practicality and cost of measures for infrastructure to adapt to climate change also need to be
balanced against the risks involved."
6225-3 Bayswater Marina Limited craigshearer@xtra.co.nz RPS Urban growth
quality compact urban form Amend Objective 3 to: "....routes and public transport facilities...".
6225-4 Bayswater Marina Limited craigshearer@xtra.co.nz RPS Urban growth
quality compact urban form Amend Policy 2(b) to: "...routes and public transport facilities."
6225-5 Bayswater Marina Limited craigshearer@xtra.co.nz RPS Coastal B7 Introduction
Amend Introduction, sub heading 'Values of the coastal environment', by adding to the end of
the second paragraph: "....or marine industry. For these reasons, public access may also be
restricted in certain circumstances through the grant of occupation consents." Amend third
paragraph to: "...marine activities, marinas, recreational activities.." Amend fourth paragraph
to: "Land-based activities can have a significant effect..."
6225-6 Bayswater Marina Limited craigshearer@xtra.co.nz RPS Coastal
environment Amend Objective 5 to: "...coastal hazards is minimised to a reasonable and practical level."
environment Delete Policy 1.
environment Amend Policy 2(a) to: "concentrating and intensifying subdivision, use and ..."
environment Amend Policy 4 by adding "or" at the end of clauses a and b.
192/1145
Sub#/
environment
Amend Policy 5 to: "...on-going use, and operation and growth of infrastructure ....including
port and ferry transport activities...."
environment
Add a new policy: "Where appropriate, land adjacent to ferry terminals is used for intensive
urban development."
environment
Add five new policies to provide for integrated management of land and water (see
submission, page 6, for detailed wording).
environment
Amend Explanation and reasons, second bullet point, to: "...for example marine, port and
marina activities and renewable energy generation..."
Amend Objective 3 to: "Public access is restricted where necessary to ensure meet health or
safety requirements, the efficient and safe operation of activities, for security or to protect..."
Amend Policy 3(b) to: "......recreational use where this ensures the most efficient use of
space...".
space - coastal environment Retain Policy 5(g).
6225-17 Bayswater Marina Limited craigshearer@xtra.co.nz RPS Climate change
Amend Policy 1(b) to: "requiring encouraging 5 or more dwellings and office and industrial
new buildings over 5000m
2
to achieve best practice sustainable design.".
6225-18 Bayswater Marina Limited craigshearer@xtra.co.nz Natural Hazards and Flooding Natural Hazards
and policies Delete Objective 3.
and policies
Amend Objective 5 to: "The process adverse effects of permanent coastal.....are managed,
where reasonably practicable, to minimise risk...".
and policies
Amend Policy 1()c to: "at an elevation less than 3m 2m above MHWS if the activity is within
20m 15m of MHWS.".
and policies
Amend Policy 14 to; "a. new dwellings and habitable rooms... b. substantial additions....... c.
located in....above the mean high water spring the mapped 1 percent AEP coastal storm tide
event plus...".
and policies Amend Policy 16 to: "Allow for the construction of new infrastructure, and marinas, in the ..."
6225-23 Bayswater Marina Limited craigshearer@xtra.co.nz
the CMA
Drainage, reclamation and
declamation
and policies
Add new objective: "Where appropriate, provide for drainage, reclamation and
declamation which provide for enhanced public access and/or for social and economic
opportunities."
the CMA
declamation
and policies
Amend Objective 2 to: "The natural character, ecological values and natural coastal
processes of the CMA are not adversely affected by inappropriate reclamation, drainage or
declamation is avoided."
the CMA
declamation
and policies
Amend Objective 3 to: "The significant adverse effects of reclamation, drainage or
declamation on pP ublic access, amenity and Mana Whenua values are avoided, remedied or
mitigated to an appropriate level not adversely affected by inappropriate reclamation,
drainage or declamation. "
the CMA
declamation
and policies
Amend Policy 1(b) to: "...and electricity generation, where they comply with other relevant
policies ".
the CMA
declamation
and policies
Amend Policy 2 to: "provide for....enable the maintenance, repair ....seawalls, for
infrastructure, for enhanced public access and for extension of existing marinas."
the CMA
declamation
and policies
Amend Policy 6 to: "Require an esplanade reserve or strip, or a conservation covenant to be
included..."
the CMA
declamation
and policies
Amend Policy 9 to: "Provide for the declamation of reclaimed land.....a. ....b. ....c.
....infrastructure, or d. provide for other economic opportunities especially where
declamation may minimise or offset the need for reclamation or coastal structures."
the CMA
and policies Amend Objective 1 to: "....or mitigated to a reasonable and practical level."
the CMA
and policies Amend Objective 2 to: "Adequate water depth is maintained provided, particularly..."
the CMA
and policies
Amend Objective 3 to: "The safe and efficient operation of significant infrastructure, other
infrastructure and marinas is enabled..."
the CMA
and policies
Amend Objective 5 to: "New use and development outside the Minor Port, Defence, Ferry
Terminal and Marina zones and City Centre Waterfront Precincts that requires ...."
the CMA
the CMA
and policies Amend Policy 2 to: ".....significant infrastructure, infrastructure and marinas, and minimise..."
193/1145
Sub#/
the CMA
and policies Amend Policy 3 to: Provide for dredging that is necessary to maintain facilitate navigation...."
the CMA
and policies Amend Policy 4 to: "Require dredging....at a reasonable and practical time..."
the CMA
and policies
Amend Policy 8 to: "Require proposals for dredging outside the Minor Port, Defence, Ferry
Terminal and Marina Zones and City Centre Waterfront Precincts to demonstrate that: a.
there are no practicable alternative methods, locations or designs for the activity which would
avoid....."
the CMA Discharges
Add an explanatory note at the end of Table 1 as follows: "These guidelines do not apply to
dredging activities carried out in the CMA."
the CMA Discharges
Delete section 5.1.12 Discharges from bio-fouling and vessel maintenance and all
corresponding rules.
the CMA
and occupation
D5.1.13 Background,
Amend Policy 9 to: "Consider use and development to providinge for extensions
to existing marinas, including through extending an existing Marina zone..... b. where
there...ferry services, and the addition extension of a marina consolidates this function."
the CMA
CMA Structures, occupation
and use
D5.1.15 Background,
objectives and policies Amend Policy 5(c) to: "...new structure or structures elsewhere."
the CMA
and use
D5.1.15 Background,
objectives and policies Amend Policy 8(a) to: "be the minimum size reasonably necessary..."
the CMA
D5.1.17 Underwater noise
from dredging, mineral
exploration & extraction
Delete section 5.1.17 Underwater noise from dredging, mineral exploration and extraction in
its entirety.
the CMA Marina zone
Amend Objective 1 to:"Marina and supporting activities are located .... used by for marina-
related activity the marina."
the CMA Marina zone
Amend Objective 2 to: "Marina facilities are used, developed, used, maintained, refurbished,
reconstructed or extended and .....coastal environment to a reasonable and practical level,
while recognising the benefits obtained from marinas."
the CMA Marina zone
Amend Objective 4 to: "Activities that have a functional requirement for a coastal location are
prioritised provided for in Marina Zones."
the CMA Marina zone
Amend Objective 5 to: "Access to the waterfront for berth holders and the public is preserved
maintained or enhanced."
the CMA Marina zone
Amend Policy 1 to: "Provide for use, development, extension, repair, maintenance,
refurbishment, and reconstruction in existing marinas that avoids, remedies or mitigates to
an appropriate level adverse effects on the coastal environment, including adjacent land
zoned for residential or open space purposes."
the CMA Marina zone
Amend Policy 3 to: "Provide for existing and new ferry terminal facilities and operations at Half
Moon Bay, Bayswater, Pine Harbour, Gulf Harbour and Hobsonville West Harbour Marinas."
the CMA Marina zone
Amend Policy 5 to: "Encourage additional berthage to be created within at existing a M
marinas zone where this is ...."
the CMA Marina zone
Amend Policy 7 to: "Minimise, as far as practicable, the size of a Any wave attenuation
devices constructed to protect associated with a marina development shall be of an adequate
size needed to provide appropriate protection."
the CMA Marina zone
Amend Policy 8 to: "Require any marina development to be of a scale, design
and materials and located so that it avoids, remedies or mitigates to an appropriate level
adverse effects.... a. the natural existing character of the coastal environment (i) the need for
capital works and maintenance dredging within the marina and any approach/entrance
channel options for disposal, measures to address any contaminants in dredged material, and
effects of dredging on water quality ."
the CMA Marina zone
Amend Policy 9 to: "Provide for public access to be restricted where it is necessary for public
health, safety, security or operational reasons."
the CMA Marina zone
Amend Policy 10 to: "Require mitigation.....for other recreational users such as windsurfers,
kayakers and kite boarders ."
the CMA Marina zone
Delete Policy 11 or introduce rules into the Marina zone allowing for precinct plans to be
introduced or modified through the resource consent process.
the CMA Marina zone
Delete Policy 11 or replace it with a policy and supporting rules which allow for framework
plans to be approved through the resource consent process in the Marina zone (including the
ability for framework plans to be approved and to replace existing precinct plans in part or in
full).
the CMA Marina zone
Amend Policy 12 to: "Allow activities that .....of a precinct plan only where it can be
demonstrated that: a. .... b. no reclamation is required to enable the activity development c.
adequate provision... d. the foreseeable future demand for space..."
194/1145
Sub#/
6225-59 Bayswater Marina Limited craigshearer@xtra.co.nz Precincts - North Bayswater
Delete the last sentence in Precinct description: "Bayswater Marina was the subject of
an Environment Court decision (No. A 018/2009) in early 2009 ."
Amend Objective 1 to: "Bayswater Marina precinct is a community and marina-oriented place
with a focus on a mix of activities including residential, recreation, public open space and
access, public transport, boating and maritime facilities."
Amend Policy 1 to: "Ensure Require a 15 metre esplanade strip is sufficient open space be
provided for made available around the coastal edge at the time of the development of any
framework plan to maintain and enhance public access and enjoyment and to enable views
out over the coastal marine area."
Amend Policy 3 to : "Require, at the time of the development of a framework plan, that areas
of public open space on the main reclamation area (sub-precinct B), and are provided for in
sub-precinct A, B, or E, additional public open space on other land within the precinct are
provided for, to enable opportunities for recreation associated within the coastal marine area."
Amend Policy 6 to: "At the time of development, R require public traffic routes within the
precinct to allow easy access to parking facilities."
Amend Policy 7 to: "At the time of development, R require existing facilities for boating, such
as public boat ramps and parking space associated with the marina and boat ramp to be
retained, or alternatives provided."
objectives and policies Delete Policy 12(a): " generate significant traffic or additional parking needs .....
6225-68 Bayswater Marina Limited craigshearer@xtra.co.nz General Chapter G General provisions
G2.7.3 Framework plans Retain the framework plan provisions.
6225-69 Bayswater Marina Limited craigshearer@xtra.co.nz General Chapter G General provisions
statements Delete 2.7.1.2.
6225-70 Bayswater Marina Limited craigshearer@xtra.co.nz Mana Whenua General provisions
assessment Delete 2.7.4(4), (5) and (6).
6225-71 Bayswater Marina Limited craigshearer@xtra.co.nz Historic Heritage (Overlay)
Heritage
protocols Delete 2.7.8(3) and (4).
6225-72 Bayswater Marina Limited craigshearer@xtra.co.nz Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
Retain Development Control 3.2 'Number of parking and loading spaces' with regard to the
proposed parking rates for land adjacent to a public boat launching ramp and marinas.
6225-73 Bayswater Marina Limited craigshearer@xtra.co.nz Natural Hazards and Flooding Natural Hazards H4.11.1 Activity table
Subject to submission points on natural hazard objectives and policies on page 8/40 and 9/40
of the submission, retain the Restricted Discretionary activity status for new buildings,
structures and infrastructure on land which may be subject to natural hazards.
6225-74 Bayswater Marina Limited craigshearer@xtra.co.nz Natural Hazards and Flooding Natural Hazards H4.11.1 Activity table
Amend Activity Table as follows: "Development - coastal inundation and sea level rise: New
dwellings and h Habitable rooms floors of non- dwellings on land identified as being subject to
coastal inundation and sea level rise."
Assessment
Amend subclause (1) to: "Finished floor levels for new dwellings and habitable rooms in
dwellings within coastal inundation areas must be at least 500mm above the mean high water
spring event mapped 1 per cent AEP storm tide inundation plus 1 metre projected seal level
rise... [2.1 Permitted activities]
Assessment
Delete 2.2 (1)(a) and (b) regarding the projection of coastal erosion or inundation over a 100
year timeframe.
6225-77 Bayswater Marina Limited craigshearer@xtra.co.nz Sustainable Development C7.7/H6.4 Sustainable design Delete Rules 1 (a) and (b) regarding green building homestar requirements for new dwellings.
I6.2 Land use and water use
controls Delete underwater noise controls 2.1(2) (a) and (b).
the CMA Marina zone
I7.1 Activity tables and I7.2
Notification
Amend the general statement before the Activity Table to: " ..... Public Open Space - Sport
and Active Informal Recreation zone ..... "
the CMA Marina zone
Notification
Amend Activity Table 1.2, activity status for Food and Beverage and Marine Industry other
than marine and port activities to Permitted on land and delete associated Rule 5.1.2.
the CMA Marina zone
Notification
Amend Activity Table 1.3, activity status for observation areas, viewing platforms, boardwalks
and boat launching facilities from Restricted Discretionary to Controlled activity on land.
Change activity status for maritime passenger facilities from Restricted Discretionary to
Permitted activity in both the CMA and the land.
the CMA Marina zone
Notification
Amend the heading of activity table 1.1 to: "Works in the CMA (s. 12(1) RMA) and all
associated discharges (s.15 RMA)."
195/1145
Sub#/
the CMA Marina zone
Notification
Amend Activity Table 1.3 to add a new activity: "Marina Berths" as a Permitted activity in the
CMA and N/A in the land.
the CMA Marina zone
I7.3 Land and water use
controls/I7.3 development
controls Delete 3.1(2) 'Marine Retail' control.
the CMA Marina zone
I7.4/17.5 Assessment, I7.6
Special information
requirements
Delete 5.2(4)(d) Assessment Criteria. Amend subclause (e) to: "Measures should be taken to
maintain or enhance public access to the CMA." Amend subclause (g) to: "The activity should
avoid, remedy or mitigate to an appropriate level adverse effects...."
6225-86 Bayswater Marina Limited craigshearer@xtra.co.nz Precincts - North Bayswater K5.6 Precinct rules
Amend Activity Table 1.2 to add a new activity "Visitor accommodation complying with an
approved framework plan" as a Restricted Discretionary activity in sub-precinct B. Amend
"offices associated with with marina activities " to "offices". Change activity status of "A
framework plan, amendments to an approved framework plan or a replacement framework
plan complying with ...."from Discretionary to Restricted Discretionary. Amend "Activities listed
in this table not otherwise provided for in the sub-precinct " to: "Activities not otherwise
provided for".
Amend Activity Table 1.3 from "Buildings and structures listed in this table not otherwise
provided for in the sub-precinct " to "Buildings and structures not otherwise provided for".
Amend to add a new activity "Marina berths in sub-precinct G" as a Permitted activity.
Amend Land Use control 3.1 'Offices' to: "Offices must be accessory to marine and port
activities or activities included in an approved framework plan."
6225-89 Bayswater Marina Limited craigshearer@xtra.co.nz Precincts - North Bayswater K5.6 Precinct rules Delete (a) Framework plans from 2. Notification provisions.
the CMA
sch. 6.2 ONC/HNC
6.1 Schedule SEA
Marine 1 and 2
Amend the location of the overlay by re-drawing the southern boundary in Shoal Bay so the
SEA is at least 200m in a perpendicular direction from the Bayswater Marina breakwater.
6225-91 Bayswater Marina Limited craigshearer@xtra.co.nz Zoning North and Islands
Amend the Marina zone and Bayswater Marina Precinct boundary at Bayswater Marina so
that the Marina zone and precinct extends 200m seaward, perpendicular to the breakwater.
6225-92 Bayswater Marina Limited craigshearer@xtra.co.nz Definitions Existing Amend definition of 'Public Transport Facilities' to include "ferry terminals".
6225-93 Bayswater Marina Limited craigshearer@xtra.co.nz Definitions New
Insert a new definition: "Marina Berths - Structures used to berth a vessel. Includes: pontoons,
piers, gangways, piles and other accessory fixtures."
6225-94 Bayswater Marina Limited craigshearer@xtra.co.nz Precincts - West Westpark Marina Amend the name from 'Westpark Marina' to "Hobsonville Marina".
the CMA
declamation
and policies
Amend Background by adding a new paragraph after the second paragraph regarding
declamation of land in the CMA to enable social and economic opportunities. And delete last
paragraph. See page 31/35 of submission for suggested wording.
the CMA Marina zone
objectives and policies Amend the name of the marina to: "6. Westpark, West Harbour Hobsonville".
the CMA Marina zone
controls
Amend Development Controls 4.1 'Building Height' subclause (2) 9m 18m and subclause (3)
12m 18m.
the CMA Marina zone
controls Delete Development Control 4.2 'Yards'.
the CMA Marina zone
controls
Amend Development Control 4.3 'Building Coverage' to: "...must not exceed 15 50 per
cent...."
6225-
100 Bayswater Marina Limited craigshearer@xtra.co.nz
the CMA Marina zone
controls Delete Development Control 4.4 'Height in relation to Boundary'.
6225-
the CMA Marina zone
Special information
requirements
Amend Assessment Criteria 1(a)(ix) to: "the need for capital works.....channel, options for
disposal, measures to address any contaminants in dredged material, and effects of dredging
on water quality ."
6225-
the CMA Marina zone
Special information
requirements Delete 6.1 Design Statement provisions.
6225-
103 Bayswater Marina Limited craigshearer@xtra.co.nz Precincts - West Westpark Marina
Retain Activity Tables 1.1 'Works in the CMA (s. 12(1) RMA)' and 1.2 'Use and Activities (s9
and 12 (3) RMA) and associated occupation of the common marine and coastal area (s.
12(2))', [under K7.11.1].
6225-
Amend Development Control K7.11.3.1 'Building Height' for sub-precincts A, B and C to
increase the height to 18m.
6225-
Amend Development Control K7.11.3.3 'Maximum building coverage' for sub-precinct B from
35 to 60 percent.
6225-
Amend Development Control K7.11.3.4 'Landscape treatment' to impose a blanket 7.5%
across all sub-precincts.
196/1145
Sub#/
6226-1 Rebecca A Skidmore skidmore@xtra.co.nz
SEAs
Land Delete the SEA from the residential properties which front Lone Kauri Road, Karekare
SEAs
Land Delete the SEA from the property at 75 Lone Kauri Road, Karekare
SEAs
Amend 1.2 to provide for the removal of vegetation within as SEA to accommodate dwellings
and associated infrastructure (up to the coverage enabled by the zone/precinct) as a
controlled activity.
6226-4 Rebecca A Skidmore skidmore@xtra.co.nz Built Environment (Overlays)
Protection
Delete the Ridgeline Protection Overlay that applies to the residential properties on the lower
portion of Lone Kauri Road, Karekare
Protection Delete the ridgeline protection overlay from the property at 75 Lone Kauri Road, Karekare
Protection
Amend the Ridgeline Protection Overlay rule 1.1 to allow new buildings to locate within a
ridgeline as a Controlled Activity.
Protection
Amend the Ridgeline Protection Overlay rule 1.1 to include criteria which limit council's
discretion to the assessment of potential adverse effects on the visual integrity of the
ridgeline.
6226-8 Rebecca A Skidmore skidmore@xtra.co.nz Precincts - West
Area K7.9.2 Rules (sub-precinct B)
Amend rule (2)(1)(2) to read as : Two dwellings on site must comply with the following: a. the
GFA of one of the dwellings must not exceed 65m
2
excluding any garaging for motor vehicles
b. the site must have a net site area of 1500m
2
1,200m
2
c. the additional dwelling must be
incorporated within, or share a common wall no longer than 3m with the dwelling on the site.
6227-1 Deryk Paauwe deryk.paauwe@gmail.com Precincts - West
Amend subdivision controls to reduce the amount of land required for subdivision to 2ha.
[Inferred that this related to 4.1 controlled activities, (1)(d) - minimum site area of 4ha.]
6228-1 Jennifer Andrew Law jenny.paddymcginty@gmail.com
sensitive areas rules J6.3 Rules Amend so buildings which breach volcanic viewshafts are prohibited activities
6228-2 Jennifer Andrew Law jenny.paddymcginty@gmail.com Zoning Central
Rezone some of the Mixed Housing Urban area around the Glen Innes and Panmure town
centres to Mixed Housing Suburban
6229-1 John E Abbott johnabbott@clear.net.nz
Outstanding Natural
Rules
J6.2.4 Assessment
Amend the Outstanding Natural Landscape rules as they are too restrictive to allow effective
farming, particularly the 50m2 building area restriction.
6229-2 John E Abbott johnabbott@clear.net.nz Zoning South
Rezone 74 Douglas Road Pollok, and neighbouring property to the north, from Rural Coastal
to a zone not associated with the coastal area.
6229-3 John E Abbott johnabbott@clear.net.nz Mana Whenua General provisions
assessment
Amend the requirements for Iwi input to any environmental assessment of historic heritage to
ensure cost is not bourne by landowners.
6229-4 John E Abbott johnabbott@clear.net.nz Zoning Central Retain the increased density around the St Heliers centre.
6229-5 John E Abbott johnabbott@clear.net.nz Zoning Central
Rezone the area in Mt Wellington bounded by Sylvia Park Road, Penrose Road, the railway
line and Hamlins Hill from Light Industry to Heavy Industry.
Rezone the land in Penrose bounded by Maurice Road, Station Road, the railway line and
Church St from Light Industry to Heavy Industry.
Rezone the land in Penrose bounded by Station Road, Fairfax Avenue, Walls Road and Great
South Road from Light Industry to Heavy Industry.
Amend zoning of 51 Codrington Crescent, Mission Bay and surrounding land to be less dense
and to avoid intermittent developments of larger structures.
6230-1 The Department of Corrections kirsten.hauschild@boffamiskell.co.nz RPS
Transport
and energy
Amend the structure and provisions of the Regional Policy Statement to better recognise and
provide for social infrastructure and significant social infrastructure within Auckland within the
overall context of infrastructure.
6230-2 The Department of Corrections kirsten.hauschild@boffamiskell.co.nz RPS
Transport
and energy
Clarify which types of infrastructure are significant, including capturing regionally and
nationally significant infrastructure as significant infrastructure, which should in turn include
Justice and Correction facilities.
6230-3 The Department of Corrections kirsten.hauschild@boffamiskell.co.nz RPS Urban growth B2.7 Social infrastructure Clarify that social infrastructure has significant elements.
6230-4 The Department of Corrections kirsten.hauschild@boffamiskell.co.nz RPS Issues
growth
Acknowledge the role of social infrastructure (particularly regionally or nationally significant
social infrastructure) within the RPS issue statements.
6230-5 The Department of Corrections kirsten.hauschild@boffamiskell.co.nz RPS Urban growth B2.7 Social infrastructure
Include an enabling policy to use, operate, maintain and upgrade significant social
infrastructure facilities and establish new such facilities, while acknowledging that such
facilities may give rise to adverse effects on the environment (which may not be acceptable
less significant infrastructure).
Include a policy that implements Strategic Direction 12 of the Auckland Plan, which
recognises the importance, and promotes the provision of social and community
infrastructure.
197/1145
Sub#/
6230-7 The Department of Corrections kirsten.hauschild@boffamiskell.co.nz RPS Urban growth B2.7 Social infrastructure Expressly provide for regionally or nationally significant social infrastructure facilities.
Include a policy that seeks to protect regionally or nationally significant social infrastructure
from reverse sensitivity effects.
6230-9 The Department of Corrections kirsten.hauschild@boffamiskell.co.nz RPS Urban growth
Amend the PAUP to acknowledge that in certain circumstances it might be appropriate for
large scale regionally or nationally significant social infrastructure facilities to locate outside
the Rural Urban Boundary.
Retain the recognition of Community Corrections facilities, including those providing probation
and rehabilitation services as part of social infrastructure in the introductory text to Clause
B.2.7, but amend to include reference to community corrections facilities, including those
providing probation and rehabilitation services. Refer to paragraph 4.18(a) of submission.
Retain the acknowledgement of the range of providers of social infrastructure, including
central government as the provider of Corrections services, but amend to refer to corrections
services instead of prisons . Refer to paragraph 4.18(b) of submission.
Retain the recognition that social infrastructure is an important asset to society, including for
its role in providing facilities to support the justice system.
6230-13 The Department of Corrections kirsten.hauschild@boffamiskell.co.nz General Chapter A Introduction
DP provisions
Clarify which rules are regional rules, which are regional coastal rules, and which are district
rules.
6230-14 The Department of Corrections kirsten.hauschild@boffamiskell.co.nz
Centre)
desc, obs & pols
Amend the objectives and policies to recognise that existing office activities are appropriate
within the Light Industry zone.
Centre) Business
Amend the activity table to provide for office use existing at the date of notification of the
Unitary Plan as a permitted activity.
Centre) Business
Amend the activity table to provide for offices (not otherwise enabled as a permitted activity)
as a restricted discretionary activity, including consequential amendments to the matters of
discretion and assessment criteria for the Light Industry zone. Matters to be addressed should
include reverse sensitivity effects on industrial activities, scale of the proposed office
operation, and whether its operational characteristics are appropriate for the zone and
surrounding environment.
Centre) Business I3.2 Notification
Amend the notification rule to provide that applications for offices as a restricted discretionary
activity are not required to be notified.
6230-18 The Department of Corrections kirsten.hauschild@boffamiskell.co.nz Historic Heritage (Overlay)
Heritage
places
Retain the provisions that specifically provide for earthquake strengthening works to be
undertaken to the primary features of Category A scheduled historic heritage places,
specifically the provision for these works as a discretionary activity.
Amend the assessment criteria to clarify how many criteria need to be met to constitute
meeting the threshold of works constituting total or substantial demolition.
Refine the wording of the criteria so that it is consistently clear where the threshold lies within
each criterion (specifically criteria 3 7).
Delete criterion 2 which relates to the relative proportion of the portion of the historic place
affected (when considering total or substantial demolition), or combine with criterion 1 which
relates to the same matter (amount, size and proportion of works).
Amend the second part of criterion 3, (which provides that demolition or destruction of
elements of exceptional significance of a Category A place is a prohibited activity, except for
the purposes of temporary dismantling for seismic strengthening) so that it reads as a criterion
rather than a rule.
Amend Criterion 8 so that it clearly reads as a criterion to determine whether the works are
total or substantial demolition (rather than partial demolition or destruction).
Delete Criterion 9 (regarding temporary dismantling for seismic strengthening) to avoid
duplication of other criteria, or amend to read as an informative note.
Include the criteria within the definition of total or substantial demolition. In the alternative, or
in addition to that relief, enable demolition works in accordance with a council approved
conservation plan to be carried out as a permitted activity or with minimal regulation.
Delete the Volcanic Viewshaft overlay as it affects the site at 17-25 Boston Road, Mt Eden, or
such other relief to recognise the designated status of the site and the current prison
buildings.
6230-27 The Department of Corrections kirsten.hauschild@boffamiskell.co.nz Definitions Existing
Amend the definition of office as follows: Means activities conducted within a building (...) and
includes: where visits by members of the public are ancillary to the main use (...) Non-
custodial premises used by Corrections staff for the administration and delivery of community-
based activities, including, inter alia, probation centres and bases for community work
activities.
6230-28 The Department of Corrections kirsten.hauschild@boffamiskell.co.nz Definitions Existing Amend the definition of community facilities to more explicitly provide for museums.
198/1145
Sub#/
6230-29 The Department of Corrections kirsten.hauschild@boffamiskell.co.nz Designations Minister of Corrections 3903 Mt Eden Prison Amend the designation purpose for designation ID 3903 from Mt Eden Prison to prison.
6230-30 The Department of Corrections kirsten.hauschild@boffamiskell.co.nz Designations Minister of Corrections 3900 Auckland Prison Amend condition 1.d of designation ID 3900 to replace the unit dBH with dBA.
6230-31 The Department of Corrections kirsten.hauschild@boffamiskell.co.nz Designations Minister of Corrections General
Retain the way in which the Department's designations are depicted on the planning maps
and referred to in the designation schedule, and [retain] the conditions for each designation
that are included in the PAUP.
6230-32 The Department of Corrections kirsten.hauschild@boffamiskell.co.nz Designations Minister of Corrections General
Amend designations of the Minister of Corrections as necessary to reflect any changes that
have occurred post-lodgement of the rollover notices.
6230-33 The Department of Corrections kirsten.hauschild@boffamiskell.co.nz Zoning Central Rezone land at 1 Lauder Road, Mt Eden from Light Industry to Mixed Use zone.
6230-34 The Department of Corrections kirsten.hauschild@boffamiskell.co.nz Zoning South
Rezone land at 20 Beatty Avenue, Manurewa from Strategic Transport Corridor to Light
Industry Zone.
6230-35 The Department of Corrections kirsten.hauschild@boffamiskell.co.nz Zoning North and Islands
Rezone land at 540 Paremoremo Road, Paremoremo from Countryside Living to Single
House zone, or in the alternative, amend the subdivision rules to enable subdivision around
existing buildings and development within the Countryside Living zone as a permitted
activity. As a further alternative, rezone the land to Rural and Coastal Settlement zone with a
consequential amendment to the related minimum lot size rules to establish a minimum lot
size of 500m
2
.
Heritage
Places
Amend the extent of Scheduled Historic Heritage Place 2489 (48-52 Wyndham Street,
Auckland Central) so that it does not apply to the parcel of land at 63 Albert Street, Auckland
Central.
the CMA
sch. 6.2 ONC/HNC
6.1 Schedule SEA
Marine 1 and 2
Amend the extent of marine-based Significant Ecological Areas so that they do not extend to
the landward side of Mean High Water Springs.
6230-38 The Department of Corrections kirsten.hauschild@boffamiskell.co.nz Precincts - South Manukau
Amend the extent of the Manukau Precinct so that it reflects the intent of the rule contained
within the precinct, specifically that it does not affect the Departments sites at 30 Manukau
Station Road and 9 Barrowcliffe Place.
6231-1 Angela M Moon angela.moon@clear.net.nz Zoning Central Rezone Pt Chevalier to reduce the density.
6232-1 Ralph Hill ralph.hill@xtra.co.nz RPS Mana Whenua B5 Strategic
6232-2 Ralph Hill ralph.hill@xtra.co.nz Mana Whenua
Whenua
6232-3 Ralph Hill ralph.hill@xtra.co.nz RPS Mana Whenua
Fig. 1
Recognize the NZ Historic Places Trust as the approving authority with regard to Sites of
Whenua
and policies
Heritage Schedules
6232-5 Ralph Hill ralph.hill@xtra.co.nz RPS Mana Whenua B5 Strategic
6232-6 Ralph Hill ralph.hill@xtra.co.nz General Chapter A Introduction A1 Background
Delete the last two paragraphs of 1.2 'Mana Whenua' and replace with 'Unitary Plan is to be
6232-7 Ralph Hill ralph.hill@xtra.co.nz General Chapter A Introduction A2 Statutory Framework
Site of Significance or Value (as determined by NZ Historic Places Trust), as an affected party
6232-8 Ralph Hill ralph.hill@xtra.co.nz RPS
Places Act 1993.'
6232-9 Ralph Hill ralph.hill@xtra.co.nz RPS Issues
199/1145
Sub#/
6232-10 Ralph Hill ralph.hill@xtra.co.nz RPS Urban growth
6232-11 Ralph Hill ralph.hill@xtra.co.nz General Chapter G General provisions
6232-12 Ralph Hill ralph.hill@xtra.co.nz General Chapter G General provisions
statements
undertaken
6232-13 Ralph Hill ralph.hill@xtra.co.nz General Miscellaneous Other Delete clauses 5.2, 5.3, and 5.4 from G. 3.2 [reference unknown]
6232-16 Ralph Hill ralph.hill@xtra.co.nz Mana Whenua Auckland wide - Mori Land
settlement land
Whenua
whenua
Whenua
6232-20 Ralph Hill ralph.hill@xtra.co.nz Definitions Existing
6232-21 Ralph Hill ralph.hill@xtra.co.nz Definitions Existing
Overlays.'
6233-1 G and N Edwards colin@hardacreplanning.co.nz
SEAs
Land Remove the SEA from 49 Belfast Street, Hillsborough.
6234-1 Landowners of Kewa Road deanne@mhg.co.nz Definitions Existing
Amend the definition of 'height' to include average ground level as a means to calculate
height.
6234-2 Landowners of Kewa Road deanne@mhg.co.nz Residential zones Residential
General Remove the maximum storey control in all residential [inferred] zones
6234-3 Landowners of Kewa Road deanne@mhg.co.nz Residential zones Residential
General Remove the floor to floor / ceiling height minimums from all residential [inferred] zones
6234-4 Landowners of Kewa Road deanne@mhg.co.nz Definitions New Add a new definition for 'gross site area'
6234-5 Landowners of Kewa Road deanne@mhg.co.nz Zoning North and Islands
Rezone 5, 9, 15, 21, 25, 10, and 6 Kewa Road and 177 Lonely Track Road from Large Lot to
Single House
6234-6 Landowners of Kewa Road deanne@mhg.co.nz General Chapter G General provisions
statements Delete the requirement to provide a design statement with resource consent applications
6234-7 Landowners of Kewa Road deanne@mhg.co.nz Mana Whenua General provisions
assessment
Iwi is required so that applications which would not normally involve Iwi concerns are excluded
6234-8 Landowners of Kewa Road deanne@mhg.co.nz Sustainable Development C7.7/H6.4 Sustainable design
Building Challenge
6234-9 Landowners of Kewa Road deanne@mhg.co.nz Residential zones Housing affordability H6.6 Rules Delete the requirement to provide affordable housing
200/1145
Sub#/
6234-10 Landowners of Kewa Road deanne@mhg.co.nz
Centre) Business
Special information
requirements
Delete the requirement to provide a wind report for buildings higher than 20 m where a canopy
is provided over public spaces
6235-1 Hui Feng Holdings Limited r.fraser-smith@harrisongrierson.com RPS Changes to the RUB South Rezone 110A Jack Lachlan Drive, Beachlands from Countryside Living to Single House zone
6235-2 Hui Feng Holdings Limited r.fraser-smith@harrisongrierson.com Precincts - South Whitford
Remove the Whitford precinct from 110A Jack Lachlan Drive, Beachlands and apply either
the Beachlands 1 precinct or the Greenfield Urban precinct
6235-3 Hui Feng Holdings Limited r.fraser-smith@harrisongrierson.com Precincts - South Whitford Delete rule 4.1 [subdivision density]
Delete the text of rule 4.2 [sites] and replace it with the following: Subdivision density shall not
exceed what would have been allowed based on the parent allotment title date as at 8 July
2005
Delete rule 4.1 table 3 [subdivision density] and replace with the following: Subdivision density
in both Whitford A and B sub-precincts shall not exceed more than one site per 3.5ha gross
across the entire site
6235-6 Hui Feng Holdings Limited r.fraser-smith@harrisongrierson.com Mana Whenua
Whenua
Amend the sites and places of value to Mana Whenua overlay as it applies to 110A Jack
Lachlan Drive, Beachlands [ID 3463 and ID 1846] to more accurately identify the specific
locations
6236-1
Orewa West Investments
Limited craigshearer@xtra.co.nz Special Character
residential
special character areas Retain Objectives 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6 and 10
6236-2
Limited craigshearer@xtra.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - general
6236-3
Limited craigshearer@xtra.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - general
and policies
Amend Policy 7 as follows: "Require all sites capable of containing a building, in areas where
service connections are available to a public reticulated network are able to be provided, to
individually connect to the..."
6236-4
Limited craigshearer@xtra.co.nz Rural Zones
desc, obs & pols
Amend Policy 1(c) as follows: "c. locating accessways, services, utilities and building
platforms where these can be provided whilst minimising without the need for significant
earthworks, retaining, benching or site contouring".
6236-5
desc, obs & pols
Amend Policy 1(e) as follows: "....to be actioned to offset the adverse effects of the
development process, including vegetation removal, earthworks, retaining, benching or site
contouring at the time of the development proceeding through the implementation of the
development , including on an ongoing basis".
6236-6
desc, obs & pols Retain Policy 7.
6236-7
Limited craigshearer@xtra.co.nz Precincts - North Orewa Countryside Amend Objective 2 as follows: "....to provide a transition buffer between...."
6236-8
Limited craigshearer@xtra.co.nz Precincts - North Orewa Countryside Amend Objective 3 as follows: "...for farming, and recreational or conservation activities"
6236-9
Limited craigshearer@xtra.co.nz Precincts - North Orewa Countryside
Amend Objective 4 as follows: "...vegetation, unstable land and riparian margins are protected
from development"
6236-10
Limited craigshearer@xtra.co.nz Precincts - North Orewa Countryside Add the following objective: "5. Unstable areas are stabilised prior to development occurring".
6236-11
Amend Policy 1 as follows: "...of up to 86 300 sites on which a dwelling can be built
the precinct"
6236-12
Amend Policy 2 as follows: "....subdivision based on clustering of dwellings to which maintains
large areas of open space for conservation dry stock grazing and recreational activities".
6236-13
Amend Policy 4 as follows: "Avoid remedy or mitigate the effects of development of buildings
on prominent ridges or knolls"
6236-14
Limited craigshearer@xtra.co.nz Precincts - North Orewa Countryside Amend Policy 6 as follows: "Locate cluster development in a configuration..."
6236-15
Amend Policy 7 as follows: "...encourage the use of communal areas for conservation farming
and recreational use"
6236-16
Add the following policy: "Ensure any earthworks, site contouring, retaining or benching
undertaken minimise the effects upon native vegetation, streams and wetlands, with
environmental enhancement undertaken to off-set any adverse effects".
6236-17
Limited craigshearer@xtra.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - Rural zones
zones only
Amend the activity status from Discretionary to Controlled for the following
activity: "Subdivision provided for in the rural subdivision rules: - transferable rural site
subdivision - boundary adjustments and boundary relocation - subdivision in the Countryside
Living zone"
6236-18
zones only
Amend the activity status from Prohibited to Discretionary for the following activity: "Any other
subdivision not provided for in this table or in the rural zones subdivision rules"
201/1145
Sub#/
6236-19
area Retain the Rural zone rules.
6236-20
Limited craigshearer@xtra.co.nz Precincts - North Orewa Countryside Add the activity "Dwellings" as a permitted activity to the activity table.
6236-21
Amend clause 2 'Land use controls' as follows: "1. The land use controls in the Rural zones
Countryside Living zone apply unless otherwise specified below"
6236-22
Amend clause 3 'Development controls' as follows: "1. The development controls in the Rural
zones Countryside Living zone apply unless otherwise specified below"
6236-23
Limited craigshearer@xtra.co.nz Precincts - North Orewa Countryside Retain the yard rules.
6236-24
Add the following to clause 3.3 'Building coverage': "3. Every site must have a specified
building area of at least 400m2 and must contain a stable, flood free platform for buildings"
6236-25
Amend clause 4(2) 'Subdivision controls' as follows: "2. Any subdivision that does not comply
with the controls is non-complying discretionary activity unless specified below."
6236-26
Amend Rule 4.1(1) Precinct Plan as follows: "1. Any subdivision must not be carried out in
generally in accordance with Precinct Plan 1".
6236-27
Amend Rule 4.2(1) 'Maximum number of sites' as follows: "...a. on which a dwelling may be
erected must not exceed 300 86 within the precinct".
6236-28
Limited craigshearer@xtra.co.nz Precincts - North Orewa Countryside Amend Rule 4.4(a) 'Site area and shape' as follows: "a.be larger than 1,600m 1,000m2"
6236-29
Amend 5.1 'Matters of discretion' as follows: "5.1 Matters for Control of discretion 2.
Subdivision a. Rural Character ..."
6236-30
Amend 5.2(2)(a) Assessment criteria as follows: "2. Subdivision a. Rural character i. The
particular subdivision should occur without creating adverse effects on the rural
character anticipated within Orewa Countryside precinct".
6236-31
Amend 5.2(2)(c)(i) Assessment Criteria as follows: "i. The subdivision should provide each
cluster of lots with a ...."
6236-32
Amend 5.2(2)(c)(ii) 'Assessment criteria' as follows: "ii. The subdivision should reinforce
neighbourhood identity by developing clustering lots in conjunction..."
6236-33
Add clause to 5.2(2) Assessment criteria as follows: "v. The development should aim to
enhance the natural environmental values of streams in the precinct".
6236-34
Amend 5.2(2)(v) 'Assessment criteria' as follows: " Sites should be clustered to encourage
The efficient provision of utilities to groups of site should be encouraged, rather than to
sporadic or isolated sites".
6236-35
Limited craigshearer@xtra.co.nz Precincts - North Orewa Countryside Delete Matters of discretion.
6236-36
Remove the Precinct Plan 1 and replace it with one which is more relevant to the proposed
provisions.
6237-1 Christiane Pracht christianepracht@yahoo.com
control
Amend the activity status of demolition or removal of heritage buildings (pre-1944) to be a non-
complying activity subject to public notification.
6237-2 Christiane Pracht christianepracht@yahoo.com RPS Urban growth
Distinguish between areas that should be redeveloped and areas that should retain their
existing character
6237-3 Christiane Pracht christianepracht@yahoo.com Zoning Central Rezone residential areas in Grafton to Single House zone
6237-4 Christiane Pracht christianepracht@yahoo.com Zoning Central Rezone Park Road, Grafton, from Local Centre to Neighbourhood Centre.
6238-1 Christopher Paul christopher@chill.co.nz Mana Whenua General provisions
assessment Amend the provisions relating to third party input to cultural impact assessments
6239-1 Brett Mihaljevich brettsandy79@gmail.com Zoning Central
Rezone the land north of Tui Street, Point Chevalier from Mixed Housing Urban to Single
House.
6239-2 Brett Mihaljevich brettsandy79@gmail.com Zoning Central
Rezone the land north of Great South Road from Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings
and Mixed Housing Urban to Mixed Housing Residential.
6239-3 Brett Mihaljevich brettsandy79@gmail.com Residential zones Residential Notification
Amend the PAUP to ensure developments or five of more dwellings are notified to enable
community input into the process.
6239-4 Brett Mihaljevich brettsandy79@gmail.com RPS Urban growth
environment
Amend the PAUP so the Urban Design Guidelines carry more weight and are part of the
statutory process [not just guidelines].
6239-5 Brett Mihaljevich brettsandy79@gmail.com
control
and policies Retain the Pre-1994 heritage protection.
6239-6 Brett Mihaljevich brettsandy79@gmail.com
control
and policies
Amend the Pre-1944 heritage protection provisions to ensure public notification can occur if
there is any change to these properties.
6240-1 CIT Holdings Limited gerardt@barker.co.nz Zoning Central Rezone 14-30 Waimarie Street, St Heliers, from Single House to Mixed Housing Suburban.
202/1145
Sub#/
6240-2 CIT Holdings Limited gerardt@barker.co.nz
(ONF) Rules
Features Overlay
Delete ONF ID 194 (St Heliers Explosion Crater) from 14-22 and 28-30 Waimarie Street, St
Heliers.
(ONF) Rules
Features Overlay
Amend the location ONF ID 194 (St Heliers Explosion Crater) northwards (accurately define
the extent of the ONF).
Amend the activity status of 'buildings and structures' from discretionary to restricted
discretionary in Table 1 'Activity table Outstanding natural features overlay - Land use and
development'.
Amend the activity status of 'Fences - except post and wire' from discretionary to restricted
discretionary in Table 1 'Activity table Outstanding natural features overlay - Land use and
development'.
6240-6 CIT Holdings Limited gerardt@barker.co.nz Earthworks H4.2.1.3 Activity table - ONFs
Amend the activity status of 'earthworks exceeding 10m
3
' from discretionary to restricted
discretionary.
6240-7 CIT Holdings Limited gerardt@barker.co.nz Earthworks H4.2.3 Assessment
Amend 3.2 'Assessment criteria' for restricted discretionary activities, to clarify that discretion
is restricted to those matters relevant to the effects on the ONF (for earthworks less than
10m
3
)
6241-1 Hobsonville Marine Limited craigshearer@xtra.co.nz General Editorial and Part 6 Amend the name of Westpark Marina to "Hobsonville Marina" throughout the PAUP.
6241-2 Hobsonville Marine Limited craigshearer@xtra.co.nz
the CMA
declamation
and policies
Amend Background by adding a new paragraph after the second paragraph regarding
declamation of land in the CMA to enable social and economic opportunities and deleting the
last paragraph. See page 31/35 of submission for exact wording.
the CMA Marina zone
objectives and policies Amend the name of the marina to: "6. Westpark, West Harbour Hobsonville".
the CMA Marina zone
controls
Amend Development Controls 4.1 'Building Height' subclause (2) 9m 18m and subclause (3)
12m 18m.
the CMA Marina zone
controls Delete Development Control 4.2 'Yards'.
the CMA Marina zone
controls
Amend Development Control 4.3 'Building Coverage' to: "...must not exceed 15 50 per
cent...."
the CMA Marina zone
controls Delete Development Control 4.4 'Height in relation to Boundary'.
the CMA Marina zone
Special information
requirements
Amend Assessment Criteria 1(a)(ix) to: "the need for capital works.....channel, options for
on water quality ."
the CMA Marina zone
Special information
requirements Delete 6.1 Design Statement provisions.
6241-10 Hobsonville Marine Limited craigshearer@xtra.co.nz Precincts - West Westpark Marina
Retain Activity Tables 1.1 'Works in the CMA (s. 12(1) RMA)' and 1.2 'Use and Activities (s9
and 12 (3) RMA) and associated occupation of the common marine and coastal area (s.
12(2))' [under K7.11.1].
Amend Development Control K7.11.3.1 'Building Height' for sub-precincts A, B and C to
increase the height to 18m.
Amend Development Control K7.11.3.3 'Maximum building coverage' for sub-precinct B from
35 to 60 percent.
Amend Development Control K7.11.3.4 'Landscape treatment' to impose a blanket 7.5%
across all sub-precincts.
6241-14 Hobsonville Marine Limited craigshearer@xtra.co.nz Definitions New
Insert a new definition: "Marina Berths - Structures used to berth a vessel. Includes: pontoons,
piers, gangways, piles and other accessory fixtures."
6242-1 Huimin Liu huiminliu999@gmail.com Zoning North and Islands
Rezone the land within the Takapuna 2 Precinct from [Terrace housing
and Apartment Buildings] to a zone that has a minimum site size of 350m
2
.
6242-2 Huimin Liu huiminliu999@gmail.com Precincts - North Takapuna 2 Amend the minimum site size to 350m2.
6242-3 Huimin Liu huiminliu999@gmail.com Precincts - North Takapuna 2 Amend the height limit to 8m and two storeys [rule K5.48.3.1 'Height'].
6242-4 Huimin Liu huiminliu999@gmail.com Mana Whenua
Whenua
Amend the provisions from applying within 50 metres of the overlay to applying only within the
overlay as mapped.
6243-1 Carol-Anne Armitage ca@aaajobs.co.nz RPS Urban growth
land for urban development Amend the PAUP by not providing for infill housing unless there is sufficient infrastructure.
6243-2 Carol-Anne Armitage ca@aaajobs.co.nz General Miscellaneous
Operational/
Add a new rail link to the airport from Mangere Bridge with a railway station and park-and-ride-
area.
203/1145
Sub#/
6243-3 Carol-Anne Armitage ca@aaajobs.co.nz General Miscellaneous Other
Retain the existing parking provisions [not having to pay for parking] in Mangere Bridge
Village.
6243-4 Carol-Anne Armitage ca@aaajobs.co.nz
Centre) Business
Park zones Amend the PAUP to reduce the four story height limit at Mangere Bridge.
6243-5 Carol-Anne Armitage ca@aaajobs.co.nz
the CMA Mangroves
and policies
Amend the PAUP so that mangroves can be totally removed in order to return the foreshore
to what it was 50 years ago, and that a management plan for this is put in place.
6243-6 Carol-Anne Armitage ca@aaajobs.co.nz General Miscellaneous
Operational/
Add the ferry and water taxi services on the Manukau Harbour to be included in the Transport
Plan.
6243-7 Carol-Anne Armitage ca@aaajobs.co.nz Designations
Auckland International Airport
Ltd
1102 Obstacle Limitation,
Runway Protection and
Ground Light Restriction
Add a rule in the PAUP to ensure planes fly to a certain point [away from residential areas]
before making their turns in order to reduce noise pollution.
6244-1 Ruth Coombes ruth.calliope@gmail.com Special Character
residential
Amend Sub Precinct E on Vauxhall Road, Narrow Neck so that it is included in the Special
Character Overlay.
6244-2 Ruth Coombes ruth.calliope@gmail.com Residential zones Residential
policies Reduce the proposed density in Devonport until Lake Road traffic issues are addressed.
6244-3 Ruth Coombes ruth.calliope@gmail.com General Miscellaneous
Operational/
Facilitate competition for public transport providers of ferry crossings to encourage better
services
6244-4 Ruth Coombes ruth.calliope@gmail.com RPS Urban growth
quality compact urban form Improve infrastructure in Devonport prior to allowing increased population.
6244-5 Ruth Coombes ruth.calliope@gmail.com Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula K5.11 Precinct rules
Amend Sub Precinct F to retain the pleasant suburban neighbourhood with houses no higher
than one or two storeys as in the Single House zone.
6244-6 Ruth Coombes ruth.calliope@gmail.com RPS Urban growth
Revise the increase in density in Devonport to fit the constraints in infrastructure, heritage,
history, scale and quality of life of residents.
6245-1 Vicki and Phillip Lowe lowe1@xtra.co.nz General Chapter G General provisions G2.4 Notification
Amend to provide a notified planning process for suburban development, with full right of
objection and appeal for the public.
6245-2 Vicki and Phillip Lowe lowe1@xtra.co.nz RPS Changes to the RUB South
Rezone 178 Point View Drive, East Tamaki Heights, from Mixed Housing Suburban [to
Countryside Living].
6245-3 Vicki and Phillip Lowe lowe1@xtra.co.nz Rural Zones
desc, obs & pols
Clarify that the intent of the Countryside Living zone is for the zone to be a genuine large lot
rural residential zone (not a land bank for conversion into intensive suburban living).
6245-4 Vicki and Phillip Lowe lowe1@xtra.co.nz Built Environment (Overlays)
Height Control
Add an 'Additional zone height control' overlay to the Botany metropolitan centre, to reduce
the height limit from 18 storeys to 4-6 storeys.
6245-5 Vicki and Phillip Lowe lowe1@xtra.co.nz
Centre) Business
Park zones
Amend provisions relating to the height of buildings [in the Botany metropolitan centre], such
that buildings do not dominate the landscape or block views of the Waitakere ranges, city and
volcanic cones when viewed from surrounding ridge-lines.
6245-6 Vicki and Phillip Lowe lowe1@xtra.co.nz General Miscellaneous Consultation and engagement Allow full right of appeal over substantive matters arising from a decision on the PAUP.
6245-7 Vicki and Phillip Lowe lowe1@xtra.co.nz RPS Urban growth
quality compact urban form Reject further intensification of suburban areas.
6245-8 Vicki and Phillip Lowe lowe1@xtra.co.nz RPS Urban growth
environment
Recognise the importance of urban design and provide development rules that, while allowing
residential intensification, also enhance the residential character of existing suburbs (rather
than destroying it).
6246-1 Heart of the City alex@hotcity.co.nz Precincts - City Centre Port K3.7 Precinct Rules / Mapping
Retain the non-complying status for 'Reclamation or drainage not otherwise provided for' in
the Activity Table.
Amend the Precinct Plans to (a) reflect the new port precinct boundary as shown on page
7/24 of the submission (b) that this boundary is described using GPS coordinates and (c) that
it is confirmed that the proposed northern boundary is in the same location as PMA 1A in the
Regional Coastal Plan.
6246-3 Heart of the City alex@hotcity.co.nz Precincts - City Centre Port
Objectives & Policies
Amend the precinct to include Marsden Wharf as a sub-precinct with its own rules as set out
on page 8/24 of the submission.
Amend the Precinct description [particularly the second sentence of the second paragraph] to
reflect Waterfront Auckland's control over this area, including TEAL Park, but noting the
Department of Conservations walkway (400m) to the north of the Waterfront Auckland land.
Amend the precinct to create a Teal Park sub-precinct including Solent Street, the area east
of Solent Street, the 'Sunderland mound' and the DOC walkway.
Amend Precinct Plan 2 to alter the shaded area to clarify there are no buildings on TEAL Park
and the 'Sunderland mound'.
Amend Precinct Plan 1 to add additional shading for the proposed TEAL Park sub-precinct
[as outlined in the submission] with possibly reducing the maximum heights and revising
shading for the green area being the existing reclaimed areas.
Amend the precinct to ensure there are development guidelines to ensure intensification is
carried out with the appropriate planning controls.
204/1145
Sub#/
Amend the last paragraph of the description by replacing it with paragraph 765 and 767 of the
Auckland Plan as shown on page 10/24 of the submission.
6246-10 Heart of the City alex@hotcity.co.nz Historic Heritage (Overlay)
policies
Amend Objective 1 to read: 'Significant historic heritage places assets (being places,
buildings and for the purpose of clarity brigdes and other structures) that are not scheduled in
the Unitary Plan are protected from the adverse effects of use and development.'
policies Amend Policies 3 and 4 by replacing the word 'place' with 'asset'.
6246-12 Heart of the City alex@hotcity.co.nz Definitions New
Add a new definition of [heritage] 'place' to mean 'places, buildings and for the purpose of
clarity bridges and other structures'.
policies
Add a new policy as follows: 'Prioritise further systematic assessment of places, buildings and
for the purposes of clarity bridges and other structures, with a view of getting those places and
assets most under pressure from development appropriately scheduled.'
policies
Amend Policy 13 as follows: 'Encourage the retention and conservation of the city centres
historic heritage and special character through development adaptive re-use
heritage incentives and by protection through scheduling, giving greatest priority to the most
valuable assets most under threat.'
policies
Amend Objective 1 as follows: 'A scheduled historic heritage place or asset is protected and
conserved while enabling appropriate development or redevelopment, use and adaptive re-
use, maintenance and repair.'
Heritage
Places Add Queens Wharf as a scheduled Category A significant historic heritage place.
Heritage
Places Retain the schedule of significant heritage places.
Heritage
Places
Amend the PAUP so that scheduling of heritage is set at a level commensurate with the
information available from Council and other publicly accessible sources.
Heritage
Places
Amend the PAUP so that the registrations by the NZ Historic Places Trust under the Historic
Places Act 1993 be incorporated into the PAUP heritage schedule, and that the NZ Historic
Places Trust registration identifies a place as a Category 1, for it to be a Category A on the
PAUP schedule.
6246-20 Heart of the City alex@hotcity.co.nz Mana Whenua
Whenua
and policies Retain the Mana Whenua provisions.
6246-21 Heart of the City alex@hotcity.co.nz Mana Whenua
Whenua
and policies
Add new Mana Whenua sites and other sites that have possible but as yet not completely
assessed historic, cultural and archaeological value are recorded in a non-statutory alert layer
which would raise a flag and inform any proposed site developments rather than being
scheduled.
6246-22 Heart of the City alex@hotcity.co.nz Air Quality
and policies
Amend Objective 6 as follows: 'Landuse, transport and transport services are is managed to
avoid or mitigate the adverse effects of motor vehicle emissions on people, especially in
respect of childrens health .'
and policies Amend Policy 4(a) to add the words 'and invisible' after the word 'invisible'.
and policies Amend Policy 4(b) to add the word 'transport' after the words 'effects from'.
and policies
Amend Policy 9 by adding the words 'or plans for high-generating activity,' after the words
'high-traffic generating activity'.
and policies Amend Policy 9 by deleting sub clause (c).
and policies
Amend Policy 9(d) by adding the words 'or public transport in low emission environments'
after the words 'walking or cycling'.
and policies
Amend Policy 10 by adding the words 'separation being achieved by moving the activities,
moving the vehicle emission sources, or moving both' after the word 'sources'
6246-29 Heart of the City alex@hotcity.co.nz General Noise and vibration
and policies
Amend Objective 4 as follows: 'The strategic importance of transportation routes and
significant infrastructure is recognised and protected from the potential reverse sensitivity
effects of activities sensitive to noise the effects of transport-related noise and vibration on
activities is managed.'
and policies
Amend Policy 10 as follows: 'Avoid or minimise adverse effects from motor vehicle emissions
on activities sensitive to air discharges by using a range of measures including but not limited
to separating these activities from significant motor vehicle emission sources and lowering
overall emissions.'
205/1145
Sub#/
and policies
Add a new policy 'When an air measurement level (approaches) or exceeds an AAAQS
standard, Auckland Transport will be required to..' or similar in order to provide direction in the
PAUP as to the response required by Auckland Transport when the Auckland Ambient Air
Quality Standards are exceeded.
6246-32 Heart of the City alex@hotcity.co.nz RPS Urban growth
environment
Add a new PAUP topic called 'Landuse and Placemaking' with a series of objectives and
policies set out in the submission pages 16-17/24.
6246-33 Heart of the City alex@hotcity.co.nz Transport Auckland -wide C1.2 Policies
Amend Policy 2 by adding a sub-clause (e) as follows: 'there will be no new provision of on-
street parking schemes in these areas'.
6246-34 Heart of the City alex@hotcity.co.nz City Centre Zone
obs & pols
Amend the second paragraph of the introduction by adding the words 'event space and' after
the words 'reverse sensitivity effects on identified'.
obs & pols
Amend Objective 1 as follows: The city centre is a globall y an internationally significant
centre for business.
obs & pols
Amend Objective 2 as follows: 'The city centre is an attractive place to live, work and visit with
a 24-hour vibrant and vital business, entertainment and retail areas.'
obs & pols
Amend Objective 3 as follows: 'Development in the city centre is managed to accommodate
growth and the greatest intensity of development in Auckland and New Zealand while
respecting its valley and ridgeline form and waterfront setting and important viewshafts .'
obs & pols Delete Objective 5.
obs & pols
Add a new Objective as follows: 'The city centre is accessible by a range of transport modes,
with an increasing percentage of residents and workers choosing walking cycling and public
transport.'
obs & pols
Amend Policy 8 as follows: 'Support the development of public transport, pedestrian and cycle
networks and the ability to change transport modeswhile at the same time recognising the
need to emphasise placemaking and sense of place in key areas.
obs & pols
Amend Policy 11 as follows: 'Limit activities within the waterfront precincts that would have
reverse sensitivity effects on established and future marine and port activities, notwithstanding
that there are existing city attributes that may take priority over port activities.'
obs & pols
Amend Policy 13 as follows: 'Encourage the retention and conservation of the city centres
historic heritage and special character through development adaptive re-uses
heritage incentives and by protection through scheduling, giving the greatest priority to the
most valuable assets most under threat.'
obs & pols
Amend Policy 14 by adding a new sub-paragraph (e) as follows: 'while for clarity noting that a
new development may be more appropriate for an area then retaining a pre-1944 building with
modest character attributes.'
obs & pols Amend Policy 20 by adding the words 'interest and variation' after 'character'.
6246-45 Heart of the City alex@hotcity.co.nz Built Environment (Overlays)
Public Views
Amend the overlay description to add the words 'and will continue to be' after the words 'have
been'.
Public Views Add new sightlines to the Appendix.
Public Views Amend existing sight lines.
6246-48 Heart of the City alex@hotcity.co.nz Precincts - City Centre Arts, Civic & Entertainment
Amend the description [in F3.1] as follows: 'The Arts, Civic and Entertainment precinct is
located at the head of the Queen Street Valley. Aucklands major arts and entertainment
venues are situated in or near the precinct, including the Aotea Centre, Civic Theatre, Town
Hall, Q Theatre, Art Gallery, the to-be-restored St James and Central Public Library. The
precinct also has a number of private galleries, cafs, restaurants, cinemas, hotels and bars,
and the city centre's largest department store. Aotea Square is the focus for gatherings,
processions and celebrations.'
Amend to clarify why there are no precinct plans for this precinct, and the overlap between the
text in the precinct and the Queen Street Valley maps.
Add an additional policy [in F3.1] as follows: 'Encourage performing arts, private gallery and
other precinct-related tenancies into the precinct'.
6246-51 Heart of the City alex@hotcity.co.nz Precincts - City Centre Central Wharves
Amend K3.2.6, Precinct Plan 1 'Building heights', to set a non-building zone on the north end
of Queens Wharf as shown in the submission page 20/24.
6246-52 Heart of the City alex@hotcity.co.nz Precincts - City Centre Central Wharves
Amend K3.2.6, Precinct Plan 2 'Viewshafts', to add new view shafts from the northern ends of
Princes and Queens Wharf as show in the submission on page 20/24.
206/1145
Sub#/
6246-53 Heart of the City alex@hotcity.co.nz Precincts - City Centre Queen Street Valley
Amend the objectives and policies in F3.10 to include a range of other matters listed in the
submission on page 21/24.
6246-54 Heart of the City alex@hotcity.co.nz Precincts - City Centre Wynyard
Amend the precinct description by adding the word 'fishing' after 'marine' and deleting the
words 'and industry'.
Add a new policy as follows: 'Limit and/or manage activities on the Wynyard headland which
would have reverse sensitivity effects on future use of the Wynyard Headland Park as a major
event space'.
6246-56 Heart of the City alex@hotcity.co.nz Precincts - City Centre Westhaven
Obejctives & Policies Amend the precinct by including the Skypath as outlined in the submission on page 22/24.
6246-57 Heart of the City alex@hotcity.co.nz Precincts - City Centre Wynyard K3.14 Precinct Rules
Amend the rules by removing apartments from at least area A [submitters defined Area A] and
replacing them with more open space. More apartments could be built in area B [submitters
defined Area B]. [See page 22/24 of the submission].
Amend the provisions for the Wynyard Quarter Headland by carrying out a review by Council
and Waterfront Auckland as set out in the submission on page 23-24/24.
6247-1
Samson Corporation Limited
and Sterling Nominees Limited office@brownandcompany.co.nz Zoning Central Rezone 1 and 3 Grosvenor Street, Grey Lynn from Single House to Mixed Use
6247-2
and Sterling Nominees Limited office@brownandcompany.co.nz
control
Building demolition control J.3.6 Rules and mapping Remove the overlay from 293-295 Great North Road, Grey Lynn.
6247-3
control
Building demolition control J.3.6 Rules and mapping Remove the overlay from 8A Cleveland Road, Parnell
6247-4
Centre)
Maps only Extend the overlay so that it applies to 273 Ponsonby Road
6247-5
and Sterling Nominees Limited office@brownandcompany.co.nz Historic Heritage (Overlay)
Heritage
Places
Remove the overlay from 182 Jervois Road or if it remains within the overlay identify the site
as a non-contributing building
6247-6
and Sterling Nominees Limited office@brownandcompany.co.nz Zoning Central
Rezone 390-428 Great North Road, Grey Lynn from Terrace Housing and Apartment
Building to Mixed Use
6247-7
and Sterling Nominees Limited office@brownandcompany.co.nz Built Environment (Overlays)
Height Control
Amend the maximum permitted height at 70 -72 Princes Street, Onehunga to 24.5 metres with
a maximum of 8 floors
6247-8
Heritage
Places Remove the Historic Heritage overlay from 252 Church Street, Onehunga
6247-9
and Sterling Nominees Limited office@brownandcompany.co.nz Trees
Trees J6.4 Rules
Remove the overlay from 7 Alfred Street, Onehunga as there are no Phoenix Palms located
here
6247-10
and Sterling Nominees Limited office@brownandcompany.co.nz Mana Whenua
Whenua
of value to Mana Whenua Remove the overlay from 342 Church Street, Penrose
6247-11
control
Building demolition control J.3.6 Rules and mapping Remove the overlay from 519 Great South Road, Otahuhu
6247-12
Rezone 80 and 80A Franklin Road, Freeman's Bay From Single House to Mixed Housing
Urban zone
6247-13
and Sterling Nominees Limited office@brownandcompany.co.nz Definitions Existing Amend the definition of 'height' so that air conditioning units are excluded
6247-14
Centre) Business
Park zones Delete Rule 4.15
6247-15
Centre) Business
zones
Amend Rule 5.2 so that the height in relation to boundary control for Industrial zones requires
that buildings must not project beyond a 45 degree recession plane measured from a point 2
m vertically above ground level along the residential or public open space boundaries.
6247-16
and Sterling Nominees Limited office@brownandcompany.co.nz Infrastructure
Transmission Corridor J1.4 Rules and mapping Reduce the width of the buffer corridors of the overlay
207/1145
Sub#/
6247-17
and Sterling Nominees Limited office@brownandcompany.co.nz Earthworks
Overlays
Amend the Historic Heritage overlay so that there are no greater restrictions on earthworks
than the zone earthwork rules; and if earthworks are not permitted they only require a
restricted discretionary status
6247-18
Centre) Business
& Bus. Park zones Amend the Local Centre zone so that offices over 500 m2 GFA per site are permitted
6247-19
and Sterling Nominees Limited office@brownandcompany.co.nz RPS
Add incentive based rules for undertaking earthquake strengthening where they will contribute
to retaining heritage values. See page 21/22 of volume three of the submission for detail
6247-20
and Sterling Nominees Limited office@brownandcompany.co.nz Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
Amend the access rules so that restricted discretionary consent be required for construction
of vehicle crossings to provide vehicle access across any part of a site boundary which is
subject to a Key retail Frontage Overlay
6247-21
Rezone 20 and 22 Victoria Avenue, Remuera from Single House to Terrace Housing and
Apartment Buildings
6247-22
and Sterling Nominees Limited office@brownandcompany.co.nz Special Character
& C
Isthmus Remove the Residential Isthmus B overlay from 20 and 22 Victoria Avenue, Remuera
6247-23
and Sterling Nominees Limited office@brownandcompany.co.nz Zoning Central Rezone 57 Patterson Avenue, Mission Bay from Single House to Mixed Housing Urban
6247-24
control
Building demolition control J.3.6 Rules and mapping Remove the overlay from 461-463 Manukau Road, Epsom
6247-25
Height Control
Amend the maximum permitted height to 20.5 metres with a maximum of seven storeys for
the block contained by Hill Street, Princes Street, Wharangi Street, and Neilson Street,
Onehunga.
6247-26
Rezone 70 and 72 Princes Street, Onehunga from Terrace Housing and Apartment
Building to Mixed Use
6247-27
and Sterling Nominees Limited office@brownandcompany.co.nz Transport
Remove the overlay controls that apply to 70 and 72 Princes Street in relation to the Terraced
Housing and Apartment Buildings [inferred]
6247-28
Rezone 1-9 Park Road, 11 - 23 Park Road, 27-31 Park Road, 33-39 Park Road, 55 - 71 Park
Road, 123 and 125 Grefton Road, Grafton from Local Centre to either Town Centre or Mixed
Use
6247-29
control
Building demolition control J.3.6 Rules and mapping Remove the overlay from 41 - 43 Boston Road, Grafton
6247-30
Height Control
Amend the maximum permitted height of the centre of the block contained by New North
Road, Inwood Street, and Western Springs Road, Morningside to 24.5 metres with a
maximum of 8 storeys.
6247-31
control
Building demolition control J.3.6 Rules and mapping Remove the overlay from 72 Dominion Road, Mt Eden
6247-32
control
Building demolition control J.3.6 Rules and mapping Remove the overlay from 109 Dominion Road, Mt Eden
6247-33
and Sterling Nominees Limited office@brownandcompany.co.nz Designations Auckland Transport
1592 Road Widening - New
North Road Amend designation 1592 to include building line restriction distances
6247-34
and Sterling Nominees Limited office@brownandcompany.co.nz Designations G1.3 Designations
Amend designation 1685 to include the existing operative designation diagram as an
attachment
6247-35
1616 Road Widening - Mt
Eden Road Amend designation 1616 to include existing building line restriction distances
6247-36
1698 Service Lane - Captain
Springs Road Amend designation 1598 to include existing building line restriction distances
6247-37
1697 Road Widening - Captain
Springs Road Amend designation 1597 to include existing building line restriction distances
208/1145
Sub#/
6247-38
1587 Road Widening - Newton
Road Amend designation 1587 to include existing building line restriction distances
6247-39
1697 Road Widening - Captain
Springs Road Amend designations 1697 and 1703 to include existing building line restriction distances
6247-40
and Sterling Nominees Limited office@brownandcompany.co.nz Designations G1.3 Designations Amend all relevant designations so that they have a lapse date of no more than five years
6247-41
1592 Road Widening - New
North Road
Amend designation 1592 to correct an apparent error which states that the designation lapses
in 152 years
6247-42
and Sterling Nominees Limited office@brownandcompany.co.nz Trees
Trees
Notable Trees
Remove the 8 Chinese Poplar trees at 1B Ponsonby Road from the Schedule and remove the
overlay from this property
6247-43
Heritage
Places Remove 102 Onehunga Mall from the overlay
6247-44
Heritage
Amend the description and Policies 12 - 13 of the Historic Heritage Overlay so that they only
apply to properties that contain buildings and structures with identified heritage values
6247-45
Rezone Boston Road, between Khyber Pass and Nugent Street, Grafton from Light Industry
to Mixed Use
6247-46
Height Control
Amend the maximum permitted height of Boston Road, between Khyber Pass and Nugent
Street, Grafton from 20 metres to 24.5 metres
6247-47
and Sterling Nominees Limited office@brownandcompany.co.nz City Centre Zone I4 Rules/Appendix 7.1- 7.3
Amend Rule 4.9 (floor area ratio) as it applies 2 and 8 Canada Street, 4 Galatos Street, 4
Gundry Street, and 2 Abbey Street, Newton to allow for a Basic Floor Area Ratio of 4:1 and
Maximum Total Floor Area Ratio 6:1
6247-48
character and natural heritage B4.2 Special character Delete Objectives 3 and 4
6247-49
control
and policies Delete Objectives and Policies
6247-50
control
Building demolition control J.3.6 Rules and mapping Delete Rules
6247-51
control
Building demolition control J.3.6 Rules and mapping Remove the overlay from 7 Hereford Street, Ponsonby
6247-52
Transport
B3.1 Commercial and
industrial growth Retain Objectives 1 to 3 and Policies 1 to 11
6247-53
Retain the Mixed Use zoning of the land within the blocks contained by Dominion Road,
Horopito Street, and View Road; and the land within Dominion Road, Charles Street, and
George Street
6247-54
Height Control
Amend the maximum permitted height to 24.5 metres and 8 storeys of the land within the
blocks contained by Dominion Road, Horopito Street, and View Road; and the land within
Dominion Road, Charles Street, and George Street, Mt Eden
6247-55
Rezone 727-731 and 767-771 Dominion Road from Neighbourhood Centre and Single House
to mixed use.
6247-56
Heritage
Places Remove 727-731 and 767-771 Dominion Road from Appendix 9.1.
6247-57
Heritage
Places
Remove 727-731 and 767-771 Dominion Road from the Devon Estate Subdivision Historic
Heritage area.
6247-58
Heritage
Places Remove the Historic Heritage Extent of Place from 727-731 and 767-771 Dominion Road.
209/1145
Sub#/
6247-59
control
Building demolition control J.3.6 Rules and mapping Remove the overlay from 515 Sandringham Road, Sandringham.
6247-60
Height Control
Amend the maximum permitted height of the Mixed Use zone area as it applies to 27 - 31
Gillies Avenue, Epsom, to 24.5 metres and 8 storeys
6247-61
Business
Character Statements - Bus. Remove 27 Gillies Avenue from the overlay
6247-62
Business
Character Statements - Bus. Remove 110 - 116 Carlton Gore Road from the overlay
6247-63
Business
Character Statements - Bus. Remove 419 Khyber Pass Road from the overlay
6247-64
control
Building demolition control J.3.6 Rules and mapping Remove 234 - 238 Khyber Pass Road, Grafton from the overlay
6247-65
control
Building demolition control J.3.6 Rules and mapping Remove 30 Rawene Avenue, Westmere from the overlay
6247-66
control
Building demolition control J.3.6 Rules and mapping Remove the overlay from 3/202 Remuera Road, Remuera
6247-67
Rezone 20 and 22 Victoria Avenue, Remuera from Single House to Terraced Housing and
Apartment Building
6247-68
& C
Isthmus
Remove the Special Character - Residential Isthmus B overlay from 20 and 22 Victoria
Avenue, Remuera
6247-69
Rezone 2 Arthur Street and 2 Franklin Road, Freeman's Bay from Single House to Town
Centre
6247-70
Business
Add 2 Arthur Street and 2 Franklin Road, Freeman's Bay in the Special Character - Business
Ponsonby overlay
6247-71
Retain the Town Centre zoning of 1-11, 19, 29 - 45 Great North Road; 1-7, 7a, 1a Maidstone
Street; 2-6 Ponsonby Road
6247-72
Height Control
Amend the maximum permitted height of '1-19, 29 - 45 Great North Road; 1-7, 7a, 1a
Maidstone Street; 2-6 Ponsonby Road, Ponsonby,' and adjacent properties in that block to
24.5 metres in the central part of the block
6247-73
Height Control
Retain the 12.5 metre height limit on the block of 1-19, 29 - 45 Great North Road; 1-7, 7a, 1a
Maidstone Street; 2-6 Ponsonby Road, Ponsonby on the frontages
6247-74
Retain the Town Centre zoning of 57-65 MacKelvie Street; 108-112, 114-116, 118-126 and
128-128A Ponsonby Road, Ponsonby
6247-75
Height Control
Amend the permitted height of the centre of the block of 57-65 MacKelvie Street; 108-112,
114-116, 118-126 and 128-128A Ponsonby Road, Ponsonby to 24.5 metres
6247-76
Height Control
Retain the 12.5 metre height limit of Ponsonby Road, MacKelvie Street, and Pollen Street
frontages of 57-65 MacKelvie Street; 108-112, 114-116, 118-126 and 128-128A Ponsonby
Road, Ponsonby
6247-77
control
Building demolition control J.3.6 Rules and mapping Remove the overlay from 57 MacKelvie Street, Ponsonby
6247-78
Heritage
Places
Amend the extent of the overlay of 118 Ponsonby Road as depicted on the Historic Heritage
overlay to correctly reflect the location of the historic heritage place
6247-79
Rezone 7 Hereford Street and 1B Ponsonby Road from Town Centre to City Centre; or
alternatively allow a height of 35 metres as an overlay control
210/1145
Sub#/
6247-80
control
Building demolition control J.3.6 Rules and mapping Remove the overlay from 5 O'Rorke Street, Onehunga
6247-81
control
Building demolition control J.3.6 Rules and mapping Remove the overlay from 88 and 90 Onehunga Mall, Onehunga
6247-82
control
Building demolition control J.3.6 Rules and mapping Remove the overlay from 398-428 Great North Road, Grey Lynn
6247-83
Height Control
Add an overlay control to 390-428 Great North Road, Grey Lynn to allow and additional height
of 20 metres
6247-84
6247-85
and Sterling Nominees Limited office@brownandcompany.co.nz Water Aquifers/Groundwater
6248-1 Colleen McGregor Limited craigshearer@xtra.co.nz Precincts - West
Area K7.9.3 Rules (sub-precinct C) Include 298 Titirangi Road, Titirangi within Policy Area 1.
6248-2 Colleen McGregor Limited craigshearer@xtra.co.nz Precincts - West
Area K7.9.3 Rules (sub-precinct C) Amend Precinct Plan 16 to include 298 Titirangi Road, Titirangi.
6249-1 Brett Hopwood brett@pharmapac.co.nz Mana Whenua General provisions
assessment Amend the need to seek Iwi approval for work on Sites of Significance to Mori
6250-1 George R Webb gr.webb@xtra.co.nz General Miscellaneous Rates Reject increases to rate to cover Auckland Council's spending.
6251-1 David H Norman
1/31 Athens Road, Onehunga,
Auckland 1061
Centre) Business
Park zones
Amend the PAUP to include guidelines to support intensification such as in Ponsonby where
the only allowable intensification is to lift the building and add a floor underneath ensuring the
addition is in the style of the heritage nature of the area.
6252-1 Jamie Shaw jamiepshaw@yahoo.co.nz Zoning North and Islands
Rezone 87 Amreins Road Taupaki and the surrounding Taupaki area from Mixed Rural to
Countryside Living
6253-1 Birch Surveyors Limited kevin@bslnz.com RPS Changes to the RUB General
Rezone Future Urban areas and rural areas rezoned residential to appropriate zones which
take account of infrastructure constraints
6253-2 Birch Surveyors Limited kevin@bslnz.com Subdivision Auckland-wide - Rural zones
area
Enable transferable entitlements into the Countryside Living zone, particularly in the
Runciman area
6253-3 Birch Surveyors Limited kevin@bslnz.com Subdivision Auckland-wide - Rural zones
area Increase the maximum entitlement of conservation lots to more than 2
6254-1 Anthony Johnson walshaero@gmail.com RPS Urban growth
Revise the zoning and precincts on Devonport Peninsula so that traffic infrastructure issues
are resolved before intensification is allowed.
6254-2 Anthony Johnson walshaero@gmail.com General Miscellaneous
Operational/
Amend the provisions relating to Scheduled Item 831 (brickworks/jetty) to rehabilitate the site
and provide interpretation panels along the walkways
6254-3 Anthony Johnson walshaero@gmail.com Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Mapping
Remove the Devonport Peninsula Overlay from Wakakura Crescent, Devonport and rezone
as Single Housing
6254-4 Anthony Johnson walshaero@gmail.com Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula K5.11 Precinct rules
Amend the provisions of the Devonport Peninsula Overlay to avoid rules that allow Terraced
Housing and Apartment building type development.
6254-5 Anthony Johnson walshaero@gmail.com Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula K5.11 Precinct rules
Amend the Devonport Peninsula Sub Precinct F Overlay to reduce building height and
density.
6255-1 Nicola Pretty nicola.s.pretty@gmail.com Mana Whenua
Whenua
Remove the Mana Whenua overlay from 1537 Clevedon Kawakawa Bay Road, Kawakawa
Bay.
6256-1 Lee Joffe leejoffe1@gmail.com
Centre) Business
Park zones
Amend development control 4.15 (Yards) by inserting the following words 'Other than in
instances where on-site residential activity adjoins an adjacent Residential zone,...etc...side
and rear yards must be planted...'
6256-2 Lee Joffe leejoffe1@gmail.com Zoning Central Retain the Mixed Use zone at 343 Manukau Road, Epsom
6257-1 Rockgas Limited
z RPS Issues
wellbeing
Amend the first paragraph of Energy to recognise the significance of ensuring a reliable
supply of LPG. See Submission page 12/29 for suggested wording
z RPS
Transport
and energy
Delete the term "significant" from the title, introductory text, objectives, policies, methods and
explanatory text
z RPS Natural resources
substances Retain the Introduction
211/1145
Sub#/
z RPS Natural resources
substances
Amend Objective 1 to read "The adverse effects and risks associated with the storage, use,
disposal and transport of hazardous substances are managed to acceptable levels, having
regard to the sensitivity of the receiving environment and recognising the social and economic
benefits that such activities provide."
z Infrastructure
C1.1 Infrastructure
policies
Amend Objective 5 to delete the term 'significant' to ensure that infrastructure is protected
from reverse sensitivity effects.
z Infrastructure
C1.1 Infrastructure
policies
Amend Policy 2 to delete the term 'significant' to ensure infrastructure is protected from
reverse sensitivity effects.
z
Centre) Business
Add new policy as follows " recognise and support the continued operation and establishment
of service stations and associated activities as part of the range of activities within centres"
z
z
and policies Retain Policies 1 and 2
z
(ITA)
(ITA)
z
(ITA)
(ITA)
and policies Retain Policies 1 to 3
z
Centre)
desc, obs & pols
Amend the second paragraph of the Zone description to recognise service stations as an
acceptable form of retailing within the light industry zone.
z
Centre)
desc, obs & pols Retain Policy 3
z
Amend the Activity Table to allow the "use or storage of radioactive materials as an exempt
activity in the Radiation Regulations 1982" as a permitted activity in the Light and Heavy
Industry zones.
z
Assessment
Amend chapter H4.6.2.1 (permitted activities) to read "Facilities providing for the storage of
petroleum fuel for retail sale through a service station shall comply with: a. Environmental
Guidelines for water discharges from petroleum industry sites in NZ 1998;"
z
Assessment
Add a new clause to read "2. the requirements of H4.6.2.1.1.1 do not apply to LPG facilities."
or "2. the requirements of H4.6.2.1.1.1 will be satisfied through the provision of a valid
Location test Certificate pursuant to the HSNO Act and Regulations, or certification that the
facility will meet the requirements of AS/NZS 1596 The storage and handling of LPG, AS/NZS
60079.10.1 Explosive gas atmospheres, and AS/NZS 5601.1"
z
Assessment
Amend H4.6.2.1.2 to read "....having regard to the appropriateness of such activities within
the zone."
z
Assessment Retain provision (1) (matters of discretion)
z
Assessment
Amend 3(2)(1)(a)(i) to read "minimises adverse effects on the environment, human health
and amenity values, particularly on sensitive activities"
z
(ITA)
Amend Table 3 to extend the lodgement date for resource consents to "months after 30
September 2013". See submission page 21/29 for suggested amendment.
z
Centre) Business
Retain the permitted activity status for service stations within the Light and Heavy Industry
zones
Amend the definitions of 'industrial activities' and 'repair and maintenance services'. See
submission page 22/29 for suggested amendment
z Definitions Existing Retain the definition of 'infrastructure'
Amend the definition of 'service station' to reflect the range of activities associated with LPG
retailing. See submission page 23/29 for suggested amendment
z Zoning North and Islands Rezone 2 Waimauku Station Road from Local Centre to Light Industry
z Zoning North and Islands Rezone 731 Beach Road, Browns Bay from Mixed Use to Light Industry
212/1145
Sub#/
z Zoning Central
Rezone 340 Sandringham Road, Sandringham from Mixed Use and Terraced Housing and
Apartment Building to Light Industry
z Zoning South Rezone 153 East Tamaki Road, Otara from Neighbourhood Centre to Light Industry
z Zoning South Rezone 112 Weymouth Road, Manurewa from Mixed Housing to Light Industry
z Zoning South Rezone 755 Linwood Road, Karaka from Neighbourhood Centre to Light Industry
z Zoning South Rezone 286 Puhinui Road, Papatoetoe from Neighbourhood Centre to Light Industry
z Zoning North and Islands Rezone 33 James Street, Glenfield from Neighbourhood Centre to Light Industry
z Zoning West
Rezone 17 Henderson Valley Road, Henderson from Terraced Housing and Apartment
Buildings to Light Industry
z Zoning Central Rezone 629 Mount Wellington Highway, Mt Wellington from Local Centre to Light Industry
z Zoning South
Rezone 101 Walmsley Road, Mangere from Terraced Housing and Apartment Buildings to
Light Industry
z Infrastructure
C1.1 Infrastructure
policies Retain policies 1 to 4
z Infrastructure
C1.1 Infrastructure
policies Retain policies 1, 3, 4, 5, and 6
z
Centre) Business
Amend the Activity Table to allow the "storage of petrol associated with retail sale of fuel in
underground storage as part of a service station - not more than 100 000 l" as a permitted
activity in the Light and Heavy Industry zones.
z
Centre) Business
Amend the Activity Table to allow the "storage of diesel associated with retail sale of fuel in
underground storage as part of a service station - not more than 100 000 l" as a permitted
activity in the Light and Heavy Industry zones.
z
Centre) Business
Amend the Activity Table to allow the "storage of LPG in tanks or cylinders associated with
retail sale of fuel in underground storage as part of a service station - not more than 6t" as a
permitted activity in the Light and Heavy Industry zones.
z
Centre) Business
Amend the Activity Table to allow the "storage of LPG within vehicles as part of tanker parking
- not more than 200t" as a discretionary activity in the Light Industry zone and as a permitted
activity in the Heavy Industry zone.
z
Centre) Business
Amend the Activity Table to allow the "Use or storage of radioactive materials, LPG, diesels
and petroleum not meeting the relevant controls" as a restricted discretionary activity in the
Light and Heavy Industry zones.
6258-1 Martin J Jones
98 Marsden Avenue, Mount Eden,
Auckland 1024 Zoning Central Retain Local Centre zoning in Balmoral.
Auckland 1024 Zoning Central Retain Terraced Housing and Apartment Building zone in Balmoral.
Auckland 1024 Zoning Central Retain Special Character Area protection and Single House zone in Balmoral.
Auckland 1024
control
Require legal effect of Pre-1944 Building Demolition Control as it applies on Special
Character Areas.
6259-1 Bupa Care Services greg@wasleyknell.co.nz Residential zones Residential
policies
Add a new policy that specifically recognises the increasing number of aged persons in the
community and the need to make specific provision for the particular requirements of this
sector.
policies
Add a new policy recognising retirement villages including supported residential care is a
means of delivering specialised housing care needs to the elderly carried out enabling
detailed design and operational assessments as to their suitability within a community.
policies
Amend Policy 1 by adding a new policy to enable development of land for retirement villages
and care homes where the interface with other land does not compromise the environmental
outcomes sought by the policy framework.
policies
Add objectives recognising that retirement villages provide for the care and accommodation of
the elderly and is done without compromising the amenity of the relevant zone.
policies
Add policies enabling retirement village development and require the design
to integrate within the amenity of the neighbourhood, at the interface with adjoining land, and
without compromising the environmental outcomes sought for the relevant zone.
213/1145
Sub#/
6259-6 Bupa Care Services greg@wasleyknell.co.nz
Centre) Business
Amend policies making specific provision for retirement villages and supported residential
care.
Centre) Business
Add a new policy that recognises forms of residential care can complement the range of
business activity provided for.
6259-8 Bupa Care Services greg@wasleyknell.co.nz Residential zones Residential Activity Table
Amend the Activity Table so that Retirement villages are Restricted Discretionary Activities in
the Mixed Housing Suburban, Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings zones. Add specific
Restricted Discretionary assessment criteria for retirement villages.
6259-9 Bupa Care Services greg@wasleyknell.co.nz Residential zones Residential Activity Table
Retain the Discretionary Activity status in the Activity Table for Retirement villages in the
Large Lot and Single House zones.
Centre) Business
& Bus. Park zones
Amend the Activity Table to make the activity status for retirement villages a Restricted
Discretionary activity in the Metro Centre, Town Centre, Local Centre Neighbourhood Centre
and Mixed Use zones. Add specific Restricted Discretionary assessment criteria for retirement
villages.
Centre) Business
& Bus. Park zones
Retain the Discretionary Activity status in the Activity Table for Retirement villages in the
General Business and Business Park zones.
Centre) Business
& Bus. Park zones
Retain the Permitted Activity status in the Activity Table for 'Supported residential care' in
the in the Metro Centre, Town Centre, Local Centre, Neighbourhood Centre and Mixed Use
zones.
6259-13 Bupa Care Services greg@wasleyknell.co.nz Residential zones Retirement Village zone
and policies
Delete the Retirement Village zones to enable new retirement villages to be applied across all
zones. Retain the Retirement Village zone only on existing villages to provide for further
works.
6259-14 Bupa Care Services greg@wasleyknell.co.nz Definitions Existing
Amend the definition of 'Retirement villages' to include provisions for supported and full time
care of the aged.
6260-1 John Boyle jboyle@bmlaw.co.nz Special Character
& C J3.3.1-7 Rules
Amend rule 4.2 'Height in relation to boundary' for Isthmus A zone from a 45 degree recession
plane measured 3m above ground level to a 45 degree recession plane measured 6m above
ground level.
& C J3.3.1-7 Rules
Consider height in relation to boundary calculations for the Isthmus A zone in the context of
the streetscape and neighbouring properties as built and as built historically without specifying
a specific restriction in rule 4.2 'Height in relation to boundary'.
& C J3.3.1-7 Rules
Amend Table 3 of rule 4.5 'Building coverage, landscaped area and paved surfaces' to allow
site coverage at a minimum of 55% for all lots in the Isthmus A zone.
& C J3.3.1-7 Rules
Calculate site coverage for all lots within the Isthmus A zone according to historical average
site coverage for the street or the previous dwelling on the site (if any).
& C J3.3.1-7 Rules Delete rules 4.7(1), the requirement for only a picket fence up to 1.2m high.
& C J3.3.1-7 Rules
Amend rule 5.2 'Assessment - restricted discretionary activities', clauses (1)(b) and (7)(a) to
indicate that site context analysis required within the Isthmus A zone be prepared by an
independent expert at the council's cost .
6260-7 John Boyle jboyle@bmlaw.co.nz RPS
Charge no fees or costs in respect of an application or hearing for proposals that preserve pre
1940's buildings in the Isthmus A zone.
6261-1
Akarana Golf Club
Incorporated gm@akaranagolf.co.nz Zoning Central
Rezone 1388 Dominion Rd, Mt Roskill from Public Open Space to a new privately owned
Open Space zone.
6261-2
Akarana Golf Club
Incorporated gm@akaranagolf.co.nz Zoning Central
Rezone that part of 1388 Dominion Rd, Mt Roskill which is zoned Residential 6A in the
operative Isthmus district plan from Public Open Space to Terrace Housing and Apartment
Buildings
6261-3
Akarana Golf Club
Incorporated gm@akaranagolf.co.nz Residential zones Residential
Amend clause 7.3(2)(e) which excludes the height in relation to boundary control from
applying to site boundaries adjoining sites over 2000m
2
so it does not apply to properties
adjoining 1388 Dominion Rd, Mt Roskill.
6261-4
Akarana Golf Club
Amend clause 7.4(4) so that the provision which excludes the alternative height in relation to
boundary control from applying to site boundaries adjoining sites over 2000m
2
so it does not
apply to properties adjoining 1388 Dominion Rd, Mt Roskill.
6261-5
Akarana Golf Club
Amend rule 7.5 Yards, to change the rear yard control from 1m to 6m for properties adjoining
1388 Dominion Road, Mt Roskill.
6261-6
Akarana Golf Club
Terrace Housing and
Amend clause 9.5(1) Building set backs adjoining lower density zones, which excludes the
building setbacks adjoining lower density zones control from applying to site boundaries
adjoining sites over 2000m
2
, so it does not apply to properties adjoining 1388 Dominion Rd,
Mt Roskill
6261-7
Akarana Golf Club
Incorporated gm@akaranagolf.co.nz Precincts - Central New Precincts Other New Precincts
Add a rule requiring a discretionary consent for all activities within 30m of 1388 Dominion Rd,
Mt Roskill (Akarana Golf Club)
214/1145
Sub#/
6262-1
CCS Disability Action -
Northern Region
susan.sherrard@ccsdisabilityaction.o
rg.nz General Chapter A Introduction A3 Strategic Framework Retain 3.4 'Quality compact Auckland'
6262-2
Northern Region
rg.nz RPS Issues
Amend Table 1 to read 'A fair, safe and healthy Auckland, inclusive of all citizens, An
Auckland of prosperity and opportunity for all, A well connected and accessible 'barrier-free'
Auckland for all, A culturally rich, inclusive and creative Auckland in which all citizens can
participate directly, and with dignity, An Auckland whose facilities, services and amenities
intended for public use and enjoyment are available able for people of all ages and abilities,
unless such provisions can be shown to be unreasonable.
6262-3
Northern Region
rg.nz RPS Issues
growth
Ensure that a range of housing, including affordable housing, to accommodate a diverse
population with diverse needs is provided.
6262-4
Northern Region
rg.nz RPS Issues
growth Ensure quality open spaces are accessible to people of all ages and abilities
6262-5
Northern Region
rg.nz RPS Issues
growth
Ensure that community and social infrastructure is truly accessible and integrated, including
the public transport system.
6262-6
Northern Region
rg.nz RPS Urban growth
environment Retain Objective 1 (b)
6262-7
Northern Region
environment Retain objective 1 (c)
6262-8
Northern Region
environment Retain Policy 2
6262-9
Northern Region
environment
Amend Policy 4 of to add 'Require and progressively implement Policy 4 within the time limits
of the 30 year Plan'
6262-10
Northern Region
environment
Amend Policy 5 to read 'Design development with a level of amenity that enables long term
options for all to live and work'.
6262-11
Northern Region
environment
Amend Policy 6 to add 'Require and progressively implement Policy 6 within the time limits of
the 30 year Plan'
6262-12
Northern Region
6262-13
Northern Region
retain affordable housing Retain Objective 1
6262-14
Northern Region
retain affordable housing Retain Policy 1
6262-15
Northern Region
6262-16
Northern Region
recreation facilities Retain Objective 1
6262-17
Northern Region
recreation facilities Retain Policy 5
6262-18
Northern Region
recreation facilities Retain Policy 8 (d)
6262-19
Northern Region
rg.nz RPS Urban growth B2.7 Social infrastructure Retain Objective 2
6262-20
Northern Region
rg.nz RPS Urban growth B2.7 Social infrastructure
Amend Policy 1 to read 'Make social infrastructure accessible to users of all ages and abilities
unless shown to be unreasonable, by providing for:'
6262-21
Northern Region
rg.nz Transport Auckland -wide C1.2 Objectives Retain Objective 4
6262-22
Northern Region
rg.nz Transport Auckland -wide C1.2 Policies Retain Policy 11
6262-23
Northern Region
rg.nz Infrastructure
C1.1 Infrastructure
policies Retain Policy 1 (a), 1 (b) and 1 (g)
6262-24
Northern Region
rg.nz Infrastructure
C1.1 Infrastructure
policies Retain Policy 12 (e)
6262-25
Northern Region
6262-26
Northern Region
6262-27
Northern Region
rg.nz Transport Auckland -wide C1.2 Policies
Amend policy 2 (Traffic Generation) to read 'Limit the supply of on-site parking in the following
locations to support the planning growth and intensification provided for in the Unitary Plan,
recognize the existing and future accessibility of these locations to the rapid and frequent
service network, support walking and cycling and retain reasonable provisions for authorised
mobility parking permit holders:...'
215/1145
Sub#/
6262-28
Northern Region
rg.nz General C7.2/H6.1 Lighting Retain Objective 2
6262-29
Northern Region
rg.nz General C7.2/H6.1 Lighting Retain Policy 2
6262-30
Northern Region
rg.nz General Noise and vibration
and policies Retain Policy 1
6262-31
Northern Region
rg.nz General Noise and vibration
and policies Retain Policy 2
6262-32
Northern Region
rg.nz General C7.4/H6.3 Signs
Amend Policy 4 to read 'Apply traffic and pedestrian traffic safety standards particularly to the
wording, contrast, lighting and location of signs and variable image signs.'
6262-33
Northern Region
rg.nz Residential zones Housing affordability
and policies Retain 7.8
6262-34
Northern Region
rg.nz Residential zones Residential
policies Retain Objective 2
6262-35
Northern Region
policies
Amend Policy 4 to read 'Require a percentage of medium to large scale residential
development to provide equal physical access and use for people of all ages and abilities.'
6262-36
Northern Region
rg.nz Residential zones
Amend Policy 9 to read: Require dwellings to be designed to prioritise pedestrian access,
safety and movement.
6262-37
Northern Region
pols Retain Objective 1
6262-38
Northern Region
pols Retain Objective 3
6262-39
Northern Region
pols
Retain Policy 8 provided that access to multi-level living for all ages and abilities is facilitated
and reasonable accommodations made.
6262-40
Northern Region
rg.nz Public Open Space Zones
desc, obs & pols
Amend Policy 8 to read 'Require the location and design of parking areas, toilets and main
carriage ways to: A. Be convenient for users of the public open space....'
6262-41
Northern Region
D2.3 Sport & Active
pols
Amend Policy 3 to read 'Require the location, scale and design of new buildings and
structures and additions to complement the character of the public open space, retain a level
of spaciousness, enable opportunities for informal surveillance, and maintain a reasonable
level of amenity for all users of the public open space.'
6262-42
Northern Region
D2.4 Civic Spaces zone desc,
obs & pols
Amend Objective 1 to read 'Quality urban public open spaces are available for residents,
visitors and workers of all ages and abilities, to enjoy informal recreation, social interaction
and civic and community events.'
6262-43
Northern Region
obs & pols
Amend Objective 1 to read 'Public open spaces provide for existing and future community
buildings and activities that include people of all ages and abilities.'
6262-44
Northern Region
rg.nz
Centre) Business
General objectives and policies Retain Policy 3.
6262-45
Northern Region
rg.nz
Centre) Business
Amend Policy 4. To read 'Require a percentage of residential development, and require within
the 30 year lifetime of the Plan, all other development to provide equal access and use for
people of all ages and abilities.'
6262-46
Northern Region
rg.nz
Centre)
obs & pols
Amend Policy 4 to read 'Require development to achieve a high standard of universal access
design, unless shown to be unreasonable accommodation.'
6262-47
Northern Region
rg.nz
Centre)
obs & pols
design, unless shown to be an unreasonable accommodation.'
6262-48
Northern Region
rg.nz
Centre)
D3.6 Neighbourhood Centre
6262-49
Northern Region
rg.nz
Centre)
obs & pols
6262-50
Northern Region
rg.nz
Purpose)
zone
Amend Policy 3 to read 'Enable detailed site specific planning to reflect how major hospital
and healthcare facility sites will be used and developed, noting the requirements of many non-
ambulatory visitor-patients, and their need for proximity parking and-or pick-up and drop-off
areas.'
6262-51
Northern Region
and policies
Amend Objective 2 to read '...A. Provide for the social, economic and cultural well-being of all
people and communities.'
6262-52
Northern Region
and policies Amend Policy 7 (c) to read 'Are of a good standard of accessible design and appearance.'
6262-53
Northern Region
rg.nz Residential zones Retirement Village zone
and policies
Amend Objective 3 to read 'Developments are well designed with full accessibility for
residents in mind, and provide high-quality on-site amenity.'
216/1145
Sub#/
6262-54
Northern Region
rg.nz
policies
Amend Objective 1 to read 'The educational needs of schools' students are met and the well-
being of students, staff and visitors is provided for including accessibility requirements.'
6262-55
Northern Region
rg.nz
Purpose) D8.10 & I24 Tertiary Education
Amend Objective 1 to read 'Tertiary education facilities meet the education needs of their
students, facilitate research and development, and provide for the well-being of staff, students
and visitors, including the reasonable provision of accessibility requirements.'
6262-56
Northern Region
rg.nz Residential zones Housing affordability H6.6 Rules Retain Development Control 1.1 'Number of retained affordable housing dwellings'.
6262-57
Northern Region
General
Amend Development Control 6.12 'Universal Access' to read 'Medium to large-scale
residential development provides equal access and use for people of all ages and abilities,
having reasonable regard to locomotor sensory or perceptual impairment.'
6262-58
Northern Region
6262-59
Northern Region
6262-60
Northern Region
Terrace Housing and
6262-61
Northern Region
Special info. req.
Amend assessment criteria 10.2.3 (f) (iii) 'design of parking and access' to read 'The design of
pedestrian routes between dwelling entries, carpark areas, private and communal open
spaces and the street should provide equal access for people of all ages and abilities and
provide a high level of pedestrian safety and convenience.'
6262-62
Northern Region
Special info. req.
Amend assessment criteria 10.2.3 (f) (ix) 'design of parking and access' to ensure that ramps
enable wheelchair access
6262-63
Northern Region
Special info. req.
Amend assessment criteria 10.2.3 (f) (x) 'design of parking and access' to read 'Common
areas within buildings should provide equal physical access for people of all ages and
abilities.'
6262-64
Northern Region
Special info. req. Retain 11.1.8 'Universal access'
6262-65
Northern Region
Special info. req.
Add the following to clause 11.2.6 'Universal Access' A. Provided that, such decisions are
taken in consultation with practitioners experienced in Universal Access Design and reflect
the technologies and best practice of the day. B. That, compromise mitigations or offsets are
deemed, by practitioners experienced in Universal Access Design, to be reasonable, workable
and state of the art.'
6262-66
Northern Region
rg.nz Public Open Space Zones Public Open Space I2.4 Assessment
Amend I.2.4.2 (Development design, external appearance and landscaping) last bullet point to
read 'Developments, including building and structures for public use are designed to provide
equal access for people of all ages and abilities.'
6262-67
Northern Region
rg.nz
Centre) Business
Park zones Retain Development Control 4.6 'Buildings fronting the street'.
6262-68
Northern Region
rg.nz
Centre) Business
Park zones Retain Development Control 4.7 'Building entrances'.
6262-69
Northern Region
rg.nz
Centre) Business
Park zones Retain Development Control 4.12 'Ground floor at street frontage level'.
6262-70
Northern Region
rg.nz
Centre) Business
Park zones
Retain Development Control 4.20.1 (a) and (b) 'Dwellings, visitor accommodation and
boarding houses'.
6262-71
Northern Region
rg.nz
Centre) Business
Special information
requirements
Amend Assessment Criteria 6.2.1.c to read: ...iv 'Pedestrian access between parking areas,
building entrance lobbies and the street should provide equal access for people of all ages
and abilities, and provide a high level of pedestrian safety.' Retain v. Amend viii to avoid
contradiction with standard NZS4121.
6262-72
Northern Region
rg.nz City Centre Zone I4 Rules/Appendix 7.1- 7.3 Retain Development Control 4.41 'Universal access for residential buildings'.
6262-73
Northern Region
rg.nz City Centre Zone I4 Rules/Appendix 7.1- 7.3
Amend Assessment Criteria 6.2.1(c)(vii) 'Design of parking, access and servicing' as there is
a possible contradiction with standard NZS4121
6262-74
Northern Region
Amend Assessment Criteria 6.2.1(d)(iv) 'Design and layout of dwellings, visitor
accommodation and boarding houses' to read 'Common areas within buildings containing
dwellings, visitor accommodation and boarding houses should provide equal access for
people of all ages and abilities, in particular by providing doorways, corridors and circulation
spaces of sufficient dimensions and minimising stairs where possible. '
217/1145
Sub#/
6262-75
Northern Region
Amend 7.1(5)(a) 'Assessment -Development control infringements' - 'Universal access' to
read 'Effects on accessibility without compromising reasonable accommodations.'
6262-76
Northern Region
Add the following to 7.2.5 (a) 'Universal access': 'Provided that: A.The test of "reasonable
accommodation" of the needs of people of all ages and abilities is applied; and B:
Compromise mitigations or offsets are deemed, by practitioners experienced in universal
access design to be reasonable, workable and state of the art, and take into account the
technologies of the day.'
6262-77
Northern Region
rg.nz City Centre Zone I4 Rules/Appendix 7.1- 7.3 Retain Matter of Discretion 8.1(b) 'Universal Access'.
6262-78
Northern Region
rg.nz City Centre Zone I4 Rules/Appendix 7.1- 7.3 Retain Assessment Criteria 8.2.1 (a) (Public Open Space) and (b) (Universal Access)
6263-1 Robyn Floyd robyn.floyd@gmail.com RPS
Amend the existing special character overlay to encompass the extensive areas of well
preserved villa and bungalow streetscape that are not already included within the existing
special character areas.
6263-2 Robyn Floyd robyn.floyd@gmail.com Historic Heritage (Overlay)
Heritage
J2.1 Activity table 3 - Historic
heritage areas
Amend the PAUP to strengthen the provisions that relate to activities that affect historic
heritage areas to improve their level of protection.
6263-3 Robyn Floyd robyn.floyd@gmail.com Special Character
residential
Amend PAUP to include a rule to protect all buildings and structures older than 90 years i.e.
1924 and prior.
& C J3.3.1-7 Rules
Add controls or assessment criteria to reference the need for the protection of natural
character and special character areas for developments in historic heritage and special
character areas.
& C J3.3.1-7 Rules Amend the provisions to add development controls in order to protect visual amenity.
6263-6 Robyn Floyd robyn.floyd@gmail.com RPS
Add provisions to require development in existing urban areas to have regard to the
surroundings including the existing character and visual appearance of the surrounding area.
6263-7 Robyn Floyd robyn.floyd@gmail.com
control
Building demolition control J.3.6 Rules and mapping Amend the overlay to exempt old state houses and bungalows.
control
Amend rules so any demolition or removal of any buildings or accessory buildings (especially
those over 90 years) become a discretionary activity if written approval from affected parties
are not received and can therefore be publicly notified.
control
Retain the overlay for Grey Lynn, Ponsonby, Herne Bay, Westmere, St Marys Bay, Mt Eden,
Epsom, Remuera, Parnell and any other historic suburbs.
control
Building demolition control J.3.6 Rules and mapping Amend the overlay to ensure it applies on all main roads as well as back streets.
control
Amend the Pre-1944 Demolition Control provisions so that they have immediate legal effect,
pending the urgent assessment of Grey Lynn, to be carried out while the plan is developed.
6263-12 Robyn Floyd robyn.floyd@gmail.com Residential zones Residential
Amend the building height and height in relation to boundary rules in Mixed Housing
Suburban zone to revert back to the existing provisions [in the operative district plans].
6263-13 Robyn Floyd robyn.floyd@gmail.com Residential zones Residential Notification
Amend development control infringements rule so the default is a discretionary if written
approval from affected parties is not obtained.
6263-14 Robyn Floyd robyn.floyd@gmail.com Trees
Trees J6.4 Rules
Add protection in the PAUP for all well established and healthy trees of 20 years or older and
any trees that contribute to the heritage scape of neighborhoods the plane trees along Grey
Lynn etc...
6263-15 Robyn Floyd robyn.floyd@gmail.com General Miscellaneous Other
Provide for dog access and off leash dog exercise areas in all regional parks excluding those
areas with native birds nesting or similar.
6263-16 Robyn Floyd robyn.floyd@gmail.com Transport Auckland -wide C1.2 Objectives Amend the PAUP to improve walkability within developed urban areas.
6264-1 Christina Robertson cjr.robertson@gmail.com RPS
Transport B3.3 Transport Retain Policy 10(a) but ensure active transport modes should be favoured
6264-2 Christina Robertson cjr.robertson@gmail.com RPS Climate change Retain provisions
6264-3 Christina Robertson cjr.robertson@gmail.com Transport Auckland -wide
requirements Amend rules so that parking minimums are relaxed.
6264-4 Christina Robertson cjr.robertson@gmail.com Transport Auckland -wide
requirements Remove parking minimums for taverns specifically
6264-5 Christina Robertson cjr.robertson@gmail.com Residential zones Residential
policies
Amend density in the Mixed Housing zones to allow more intensification. Density limits should
be removed in Mixed Housing Urban zone and significantly relaxed in the Mixed Housing
Suburban zone.
6264-6 Christina Robertson cjr.robertson@gmail.com RPS Urban growth
Upzone areas close to rail lines or high frequency bus routes, particularly around the City Rail
Link.
218/1145
Sub#/
6264-7 Christina Robertson cjr.robertson@gmail.com Residential zones Residential
General
Remove or reduce setbacks for front yards and on small sections have the open space
concentrated in the back yard.
6264-8 Christina Robertson cjr.robertson@gmail.com Sustainable Development C7.7/H6.4 Sustainable design
Amend the Homestar provisions so that all new housing is required to comply with the
Homestar rating.
6264-9 Christina Robertson cjr.robertson@gmail.com General Chapter A Introduction A3 Strategic Framework All development should be subject to a design review with strong assessment criteria
6264-10 Christina Robertson cjr.robertson@gmail.com RPS Urban growth
quality compact urban form Increase the height within the Mixed Use zone close to quality public transport.
6264-11 Christina Robertson cjr.robertson@gmail.com Sustainable Development C7.7/H6.4 Sustainable design All new commercial buildings should be required to comply with the Greenstar rating
6264-12 Christina Robertson cjr.robertson@gmail.com
Centre) Business
& Bus. Park zones Retain restrictions on the location of retail and commercial activity outside of centres.
6264-13 Christina Robertson cjr.robertson@gmail.com Zoning Central Rezone the area between Morningside Drive and St Luke's Mall as Mixed Use.
6265-1 Michael Heuberger mick@deafzone.ch General Miscellaneous Consultation and engagement Ensure all public communication associated with the PAUP is also available in sign language.
6265-2 Michael Heuberger mick@deafzone.ch General Miscellaneous Other
Ensure there is suitable Deaf school in Auckland, following the model of the Kelston Deaf
Education School.
6265-3 Michael Heuberger mick@deafzone.ch RPS Urban growth
environment
Amend the PAUP to ensure that the city and public services can be used by all
people including deaf people without the need for adaption or specialised design.
6265-4 Michael Heuberger mick@deafzone.ch RPS
Transport B3.3 Transport Amend the PAUP to build more cycle lanes.
6265-5 Michael Heuberger mick@deafzone.ch Residential zones Residential
policies Amend the PAUP to not allow fast food chains in or near residential areas.
6266-1 New Kiwis Limited markb@mhg.co.nz Precincts - North Greenhithe
Remove sub-precinct A from 368 and 374 Upper Harbour Drive, Greenhithe and replace with
sub-precinct B
6266-2 New Kiwis Limited markb@mhg.co.nz Mana Whenua General provisions
assessment Delete cultural impact assessment requirements
6266-3 New Kiwis Limited markb@mhg.co.nz General Chapter G General provisions
Delete the third paragraph under the heading 'assessment criteria' in G1.4 so controlled and
restricted discretionary activities are solely assessed against the matters of discretion and
assessment criteria listed for those activities
6266-4 New Kiwis Limited markb@mhg.co.nz Precincts - North Greenhithe Retain the sub-precinct B provisions, and in particular, the density controls in Table 1.
6267-1 Michael J Fisher michael@cprwfisher.co.nz Residential zones Residential
Amend rule 6.4 'Yards,' Table 4, to reinstate clause 7.8.1.7 of the Operative Auckland Isthmus
District Plan which does not require setbacks to side and rear yards.
Amend rule 6.3 'Height in relation to boundary' to reinstate the 3m plus 45 degrees height in
relation to boundary control as contained in the Operative Auckland Isthmus District Plan
Amend rule 6.4 'Yards,' Table 4, as it relates to the front yard control to reinstate the existing
Residential 1 control of average setbacks contained in clause 7.8.1.7 of the Operative
Auckland Isthmus District Plan.
6268-1
Breakwater No.3 Trustee
Company Limited as Trustee
for the Breakwater Trust rose@mhg.co.nz Residential zones Residential
General Delete the third paragraph under the heading 'assessment criteria'
6268-2
for the Breakwater Trust rose@mhg.co.nz Mana Whenua General provisions
assessment Remove the Cultural Impact Assessment requirements
6268-3
for the Breakwater Trust rose@mhg.co.nz RPS Urban growth
environment
Remove the requirements for separate Design Statements be removed and references to the
Auckland Design Manual and include confirmation that this is a non-statutory guideline
6268-4
for the Breakwater Trust rose@mhg.co.nz Sustainable Development C7.7/H6.4 Sustainable design Remove the sustainable development provisions
6268-5
for the Breakwater Trust rose@mhg.co.nz RPS Urban growth
retain affordable housing Remove the affordable housing provisions
6268-6
for the Breakwater Trust rose@mhg.co.nz
shafts survey coordinates Delete the Mount Eden volcanic viewshaft provisions
6268-7
for the Breakwater Trust rose@mhg.co.nz Residential zones Residential
General
Remove the storey component from the building height rule for all [residential, inferred zones]
zones
219/1145
Sub#/
6268-8
for the Breakwater Trust rose@mhg.co.nz Built Environment (Overlays)
Height Control
Amend the additonal zone height control overlay in Newmarket to extend from Crowhurst
street in the East to Mountain Road in the West
6269-1 Giltrap Group Holdings Limited devonr@barker.co.nz
Centre) Business
& Bus. Park zones
Amend the activity status of 'Motor vehicle sales' in the Mixed Use zone, from discretionary to
Centre) Business
Amend the activity status of 'Motor vehicle sales' in the Light Industry zone, from restricted
Centre) Business
and Heavy Industry zones Add 'Repair and maintenance services' as a permitted activity in the Light Industry zone.
Centre)
Fringe Office Retain overlay at Great North Road, Grey Lynn.
Centre)
Fringe Office Retain the permitted activity status for offices.
6270-1
Paparimu School Board of
Trustees admin@paparimu.school.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - Urban zones H5.2 3.1 Residential zones Retain 2,500m2 minimum site size, Rural and Coastal Settlement zone. .
6271-1 Kaipatiki Project Incorporated manager@kaipatiki.org.nz Public Open Space Zones Public Open Space I2.1 Activity table
Amend the activity status of community centres to a discretionary activity in the [Public Open
Space] Conservation zone.
Amend the activity status of halls to a discretionary activity in the [Public Open Space]
Conservation zone.
Amend the activity status of cafes to a discretionary activity in the [Public Open Space]
Conservation zone.
6271-4 Kaipatiki Project Incorporated manager@kaipatiki.org.nz Zoning North and Islands Rezone the main grass area at Eskdale Reserve to Public Open Space - Informal Recreation.
6272-1 Allan J West westvale@xtra.co.nz General Whole Plan No specific relief sought [Reject the PAUP].
6273-1 Matthew J Webster webster@snap.net.nz Zoning North and Islands Rezone Stonedge Estate located on Rosedale Road, North Shore, as Single House.
6273-2 Matthew J Webster webster@snap.net.nz RPS Rural B8.3 Rural subdivision Reject keeping rural areas unsubdivided and undeveloped.
6274-1 Malcolm Fraser
1 Maryland Street, Point Chevalier,
Auckland 1022 Zoning Central Amend the PAUP to reduce the densities proposed for Point Chevalier.
6275-1 Russell Don russell.don@vodafone.co.nz RPS Changes to the RUB North and Waiheke Island Extend the Rural Urban Boundary tp Wellsford and Te Hana.
6275-2 Russell Don russell.don@vodafone.co.nz Zoning North and Islands
Rezone land in Te Hana from Rural Production zone to Rural Settlement, Local Centre and
Industrial zones as shown on the map on page 3/5 of the submission.
6275-3 Russell Don russell.don@vodafone.co.nz RPS Changes to the RUB North and Waiheke Island
Major rezoning of land around Wellsford as shown on the maps on pages 4/5 and 5/5 of the
submission, including the Future Urban, Large Lot, Countryside Living, Single House zone.
6276-1
Gilligan Rowe and Associates
LP jr@gra.co.nz General Whole Plan Decline the PAUP
6277-1 The Land Vault karyn@subdivision.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - general
and policies
Add the relevant objectives and policies relating to and supporting the Franklin District
Council Plan Change 14: Rural Plan change included in the Auckland Unitary Plan.
6277-2 The Land Vault karyn@subdivision.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - Rural zones
area
Add Version 7a of the Franklin District Council Plan Change 14: Rural Plan Change
provisions to the PAUP.
6278-1 CD Vernon Trust craig@subdivision.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - Rural zones
area
Add Version 7a of the Franklin District Council Plan Change 14: Rural Plan Change
provisions to the PAUP.
6279-1 Simon Head simon.head@vodafone.co.nz Residential zones Residential
policies
Amend the PAUP so that within 2km of major suburban nodes the minimum site size is
reduced to 200m
2
and in all other areas is reduced to 350m
2
.
6279-2 Simon Head simon.head@vodafone.co.nz Residential zones Residential
General
Amend the building height rules so that in all residential areas the maximum building height is
between 12m and 15m.
6279-3 Simon Head simon.head@vodafone.co.nz Residential zones Residential Land use controls Amend the density rule at 115A Halsey Drive, Lynfield to 1 unit per 400m
2
gross site area.
6280-1 Penelope Bright waterpressure@gmail.com RPS Issues
growth Reject population growth projections.
6281-1 1 Wellington Limited john@subdivision.co.nz Zoning South
Rezone 1 Wellington Street, Pukehohe from Mixed Housing Suburban to General Business
or Mixed Use Business.
6282-1 Patrick Fontein patrick@studiod4.co.nz RPS Urban growth
Recognise that the up-zoning has been nowhere near bold enough and thus the
intensification targets of Unitary Plan will be impossible to acheive.
Recognise that the assumption of the Auckland Plan and the PAUP that 400,000 households
are needed. If they cannot be accommodated through intensification then any shortfall of the
400,000 will have to be accommodated through greenfield development.
220/1145
Sub#/
Acknowledge the factors effecting intensification and the redevelopment likelihood of a site
includes: improvement value verses capital value, parcel size, the number of existing
dwellings on a site, the increase of value when re-developed. If a site is to be re-developed
related to the maximum extra dwellings able to be developed, the likely capacity utilisation of
owners who chose to redevelop and the development chance of properties. These constraints
mean only 20 - 50 per cent of intensification potential will actually be developed.
Recognise the limitations of theoretical dwelling capacity numbers which take no or minimal
account of development market reality and often does not up-zone enough.
Recognise that the analysis of development capacity, as shown in the submission [refer to
page 6/14], identifies a short fall of 130,000 dwellings.
6282-6 Patrick Fontein patrick@studiod4.co.nz
Centre) Business
Recognise that the intensification targets for the city fringe were ambitious with insufficient up-
zoning.
Centre)
desc, obs & pols
Acknowledge that metropolitan centres have had their building height and development
potential reduced.
Acknowledge, with regards to intensification in and around local and town centres, there is a
lack of understanding of development economics and up-zoning in the wrong areas with
greater building height in market attractive areas.
6282-9 Patrick Fontein patrick@studiod4.co.nz Residential zones
pols
Recognise that there will be major intensification and substantial change in the Terrace
Housing and Apartment Building zone, however the current zoning has missed opportunities
and redevelopment potential has been further reduced.
6282-10 Patrick Fontein patrick@studiod4.co.nz Residential zones Residential Land use controls
Recognise that the density restrictions in the Mixed Housing Suburban zone will have a huge
impact on numbers and restrict opportunities for developers to provide affordable housing.
Recognise the need to tidy up errors and omissions to achieve a greater level of quality
intensification, identify areas of missed opportunity and have a mind set of looking for
intensification opportunity.
6282-12 Patrick Fontein patrick@studiod4.co.nz Historic Heritage (Overlay)
Heritage
Places Amend heritage classification to allow redevelopment if not proper heritage.
Centre) Business
Recognise the need to up zone the city fringe especially around the City Rail Loop stations
and introduce more Mixed Use and greater height within 3-5km of the CBD.
Centre) Business
Park zones
Amend metro and town centres to increase height, example of 30 storeys in Takapuna is
cited. Review town centre development economics to increase height to 8-12 levels and
identify ridge-line development opportunities.
quality compact urban form Amend zoning around transport nodes or corridors to increase intensification.
6282-16 Patrick Fontein patrick@studiod4.co.nz Residential zones
obs & pols
Amend zoning of high amenity Single House sites close to public transport to medium density
and ensure intensification with strong urban design which will raise land values.
Acknowledge that intensification of a s further 200-300,000 extra residences within the current
MUL within the next 30-50 years is possible but this requires far greater intensification up
zoning.
6283-1 Chain Hill Farm Limited jeff@brownandcompany.co.nz RPS Urban growth
quality compact urban form Retain Objectives and Policies.
environment Retain Objectives and Policies.
land for urban development Retain Objectives and Policies.
6283-4 Chain Hill Farm Limited jeff@brownandcompany.co.nz RPS Changes to the RUB North and Waiheke Island
Amend by moving the RUB north to include the land bounded by the Hibiscus Coast Highway
on the east, the Waiwera River on the north State Highway 1 on the west and the existing
RUB on the south and rezone the balance of the area Countryside Living. [Refer to pg 1-2/9
of the submission for details].
Shift the RUB north to include part of the subject land (the area of land bounded by the
Hibiscus Coast Highway on its eastern side, the Waiwera River in its northern side, the State
Highway 1 motorway on the western side and the existing RUB on its southern side) and
apply the Future Urban zone.
Shift the RUB north to include part of the subject land (the area of land bounded by the
Hibiscus Coast Highway on its eastern side, the Waiwera River in its northern side, the State
Highway 1 motorway on the western side and the existing RUB on its southern side) and
apply different zonings as outlined in the submission on page 2/9.
221/1145
Sub#/
6283-7 Chain Hill Farm Limited jeff@brownandcompany.co.nz RPS Rural B8.3 Rural subdivision
Amend the objectives and policies to provide for subdivision that enables and incentives the
protection and enhancement of areas of high natural value including riparian
areas, indigenous vegetation and wetlands.
6283-8 Chain Hill Farm Limited jeff@brownandcompany.co.nz Rural Zones General
Amend the objectives and policies to enable subdivision that achieves the protection and
enhancement of nature conservation values.
6283-9 Chain Hill Farm Limited jeff@brownandcompany.co.nz Rural Zones
desc, obs & pols
obs & pols
6283-11 Chain Hill Farm Limited jeff@brownandcompany.co.nz RPS Rural B8.3 Rural subdivision
Amend the objectives and policies to enable and encourage subdivision that achieves the
permanent protection and enhancement of substantial areas of high
quality indigenous vegetation of wetlands while enabling the ability to create a limited number
of rural lifestyle sites on the same property as the area to be protected.
6283-12 Chain Hill Farm Limited jeff@brownandcompany.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - general
and policies
Amend the objectives and policies to enable and encourage subdivision that achieves the
permanent protection and enhancement of substantial areas of high quality indigenous
vegetation of wetlands while enabling the ability to create a limited number of rural lifestyle
sites on the same property as the area to be protected.
Amend Rural character and amenity Objective 1 as follows: 'The character and amenity
values of rural areas is recognised and ,maintained and enhanced while accommodating the
localised character of different parts of these areas.'
Amend Rural character and amenity Policy 1(a) as follows 'be of a nature, scale, intensity and
location that retains and enhances the natural values and rural character of the zone.'
Add a new policy in rural character and amenity as follows: 'Enable rural lifestyle subdivision
which promotes protection and enhancement of existing areas of native vegetation, wetland
areas and riparian margins, areas of outstanding or high natural character, significant
ecological areas and areas of outstanding natural landscapes or features within the rural and
coastal environment and ensures that such subdivision: (a) benefits the natural resources
within the rural and coastal environment (b) is achievable and provides clear environmental
enhancement targets that are related to the subdivision process and (c) provides a robust
framework to ensure long term benefits are retained following the completion of the
subdivision.'
desc, obs & pols
Add a new objective as follows: 'Where appropriate, protect and enhance the existing areas of
native vegetation wetland areas and riparian margins, area of outstanding or high natural
character, significant ecological areas and areas of outstanding natural landscape or
features'.
desc, obs & pols
Add new policy as follows: 'Provide for the protection and enhancement of natural
conservation values.'
obs & pols
Amend Objective 4 as follows: 'Avoid, remedy or mitigate the adverse effects of F further rural
lifestyle subdivision is prevented across the zone.
obs & pols Delete Policy 7.
obs & pols
Add new policy as follows: 'To promote environmental enhancement of existing areas of
native vegetation, wetland areas and riparian margins, areas outstanding or high natural
character, significant ecological areas and areas of outstanding natural landscapes or
features within the coastal environment'.
obs & pols
Add a new policy as follows: 'To utilise the subdivision process to promote environmental
enhancements within the Rural Coastal zone'.
obs & pols
Add a new policy as follows: 'To ensure that subdivision for environment enhancement:
(a) benefits the natural resources within the coastal environment (b) is achievable and
provides clear environmental enhancement targets that are related to the subdivision process
and (c) provides a robust framework to ensure long term benefits are retained following the
completion of subdivision.'
6283-23 Chain Hill Farm Limited jeff@brownandcompany.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - Rural zones
zones only
Amend the Activity Table so that 'other rural subdivision' is a Discretionary Activity as
opposed to a Prohibited Activity.
6283-24 Chain Hill Farm Limited jeff@brownandcompany.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - Rural zones
zones only
Add a new Discretionary Activity for subdivision for the protection and enhancement of nature
conservation values and add a suite of development standards and assessment matters to
provide for this as outlined in the submission page 8/9.
6284-1 Margaret Field plandemonium@xtra.co.nz
(ONF) Rules
Features Overlay
Amend the ONF overlay boundary for 27 - 33/35A Lake View Road, Takapuna, to reflect the
Northshore City Council Hearing Committee decision (2004) and the Environment Court
Decision (ENV A0325/04) with regard to lakeside yards. See page 2 and 3/5 of the
submission for details of boundary location.
6285-1 Lorne P B Weir lc.weir@xtra.co.nz General Miscellaneous Other Adopt the relief sought by Herne Bay Residents Association Incorporated.
6286-1 Pete H Johnstone daved@dredgingnz.co.nz Mana Whenua General provisions
222/1145
Sub#/
6287-1 Tony Lowe t.lowe@xtra.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - Urban zones H5.2 3.1 Residential zones
Amend rules to ensure that development can be carried out at 269 Te Atatu Road, Te Atatu
as a Discretionary Activity if it does not meet the relevant rules.
6287-2 Tony Lowe t.lowe@xtra.co.nz Designations Auckland Transport
Street Remove from 13 Garfield Street, Parnell.
Amend rules so 14 Cleveland Road, Parnell can be subdivided to a minimum site size of
200m
2
.
Amend rules so that if there is an infringement of the development controls then the activity is
assessed as a Discretionary activity rather than a Non-complying activity.
6288-1 Kaumosi Opie seankaum@gmail.com Mana Whenua
Whenua
objectives and policies Delete the requirement for a cultural impact assessment.
6288-2 Kaumosi Opie seankaum@gmail.com Mana Whenua General provisions
assessment Delete the requirement for a cultural impact assessment.
6288-3 Kaumosi Opie seankaum@gmail.com Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula K5.11 Precinct rules Amend the precinct to revert back to the current heights for the area.
6288-4 Kaumosi Opie seankaum@gmail.com Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula
objectives and policies Delete the sub-precinct C and apply a Single house zoning with a height limit of two stories.
6288-5 Kaumosi Opie seankaum@gmail.com Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula K5.11 Precinct rules Amend the precinct to ensure full public notification of any potential development.
6288-6 Kaumosi Opie seankaum@gmail.com Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula K5.11 Precinct rules
Amend the rules to ensure a building length rule applies to development in all of the sub-
precincts.
6288-7 Kaumosi Opie seankaum@gmail.com General Miscellaneous Special housing areas Delete the special housing areas from the precinct.
6289-1 B S, S B and C E Liggett liggett@vodafone.co.nz Zoning South Retain Mixed Housing Urban on 136 Ti Rakau Drive, Pakuranga.
6289-2 B S, S B and C E Liggett liggett@vodafone.co.nz Residential zones Residential
Amend [rule 8.2 Building height] to provide for 2 storey development up to 8 m in height and
3 storey development up to 10m in height on all greenfield sites as a permitted activity.
6289-3 B S, S B and C E Liggett liggett@vodafone.co.nz Residential zones Residential
Amend [rule 8.2 Building height] to provide for brownfield sites less than 1200m2
development up to three storeys and 10m in height complying with Residential Land Use
Control 3.1(6) Maximum density, as a Restricted Discretionary activity.
6289-4 B S, S B and C E Liggett liggett@vodafone.co.nz Residential zones Residential Land use controls
Retain the density provisions of the Mixed Housing Urban zone, with particular regard to 136
Ti Rakau Drive, Pakuranga.
6289-5 B S, S B and C E Liggett liggett@vodafone.co.nz Transport
transport noise
and policies
Delete the High Land Transport Route Noise overlay, with particular regard to 136 Ti Rakau
Drive, Pakuranga.
6289-6 B S, S B and C E Liggett liggett@vodafone.co.nz Air Quality
Delete the Air Quality Transport Corridor Separation overlay, with particular regard to 136 Ti
Rakau Drive, Pakuranga.
6289-7 B S, S B and C E Liggett liggett@vodafone.co.nz Transport
transport noise
and policies
Amend to require the road operation to undertake mitigation of the effects generated from the
roading environment onto surrounding land uses.
6289-8 B S, S B and C E Liggett liggett@vodafone.co.nz Air Quality
Amend the overlay provisions to require the road operation to undertake mitigation of the
effects generated from the roading environment onto surrounding land uses.
6289-9 B S, S B and C E Liggett liggett@vodafone.co.nz Designations Transpower New Zealand Ltd
8507 Pakuranga to Penrose
Underground Transmission
Cables
Amend mapped extent of ID 8507 to be consistent with Plan Change 136 of the operative
Manukau District Plan, such that the designation is contained with a corridor no greater than
2.5m in width from the kerb line of the centre median strip along Ti Rakau Drive.
6289-10 B S, S B and C E Liggett liggett@vodafone.co.nz Residential zones Residential Land use controls
Amend rules to provide for minor household units up to 65m2 in floor area and one storey /
5m in height as a permitted activity in all residential zones on sites over 600m2 in gross site
area..
6289-11 B S, S B and C E Liggett liggett@vodafone.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - Urban zones H5.2 3.1 Residential zones
Retain subdivision provisions enabling subdivision around existing and approved
development.
6290-1 Valley Farms craig@subdivision.co.nz Zoning South
Rezone 35 Grace James Road, Pukekohe from Mixed Rural and Countryside Living to
Countryside Living.
6290-2 Valley Farms craig@subdivision.co.nz Zoning South
Rezone the property on William Andrew Drive, Pukekohe (refer figure 1 on page 2/3 of
submission for location) from Countryside Living to Residential Large Lot.
6291-1 RG and WR Thomas et al richard.thomas@tcec.co.nz
SEAs
Land
Reduce the extent of the SEA located adjacent to 47, 49 and 51 Harbour View Road, Te
Atatu, to shift the boundary to the south side of the Harbour View park pathway. Refer to full
submission for a map of the change requested [page 3/5].
6292-1 G and P K Singh john@subdivision.co.nz Precincts - South Pukekohe Hill Retain Pukekohe Hill sub-precinct.
6293-1 Scrub Consultants Limited rodney@scrub.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - Rural zones
area
Support the rules for the protection of wetlands for transferable rural site subdivision in that
they must be an existing SEA.
area
Amend transferable rural site subdivision provisions to allow the restoration of degraded
wetlands located outside of SEAs to be eligible providing they have rigorous and clear
qualitative requirements as set on on page 4/12 of the submission.
area
Amend the transferable rural site subdivision provisions to allow subdivision in exchange for
significant enhancement planting with additional requirements as set on on page 5/12 of the
submission.
223/1145
Sub#/
6293-4 Scrub Consultants Limited rodney@scrub.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - general
and policies
Amend the second paragraph of the rural subdivision background as follows: 'However, in
rural zones owners of existing significant ecological areas are given additional opportunities
for subdivision through transferable rights.'
6293-5 Scrub Consultants Limited rodney@scrub.co.nz Definitions Existing Add a definition of 'elite or prime land.'
area
Amend control 2.3.3(2)(a) 'protection and enhancement of ecological values' in rural zones as
follows: 'All subdivision plans, excluding boundary adjustments , must show any of the
following features that exist on, or on the boundary of, the land being subdivided: i. any areas
of indigenous vegetation all areas within the significant ecological area overlay ii. all wetlands
without SEA classification but which comply with the definition of wetland as provided in part 4
definitions [and add definition as per submission] iii. all rivers, lakes and streams [again add
definition for these terms].
area
Amend control 2.3.3(2)(d) 'protection and enhancement of ecological values' in rural zones as
follows: 'The council may will require the landowner to protect natural features by'
area
Amend Table 5 'Transferable rule site subdivision process' to clarify that in the right hand
column in 'Step 1 Identify' '(b)It is not necessary to identify this site before starting the
covenanting process' does not mean applicants can sit on subdivision credits until the
right receiver site comes up.
area
Amend control 2.3.3(4) 'Transferable rural site subdivision: Controls for transferable rural site
subdivision through amalgamation of donor sites' to clarify that should an amalgamation
transferable rural site subdivision be carried out then this precludes the ability to to enact
another transferable rural site subdivision based on the protection of an SEA.
area
Amend 'Table 7: Transfer of sites provided for under these rules through legal protection of
indigenous vegetation or wetland' to clarify what '(2) Land in the following identified rural and
coastal villages: (to be identified).' What the 'to be identified' areas are.
area
Amend to clarify what bullet points two and three after Table 7 mean i.e. 'All applications must
include a management plan that...' and 'All applications must include a management plan that
includes the following matters, which must be implemented prior to the council issuing a s.
224(c) certificate...'Clarify the distinction.
area
Remove sub bullet point two which deals with 'maintenance of plantings' after the sub heading
'All applications must include a management plan that includes the following matters, which
must be implemented prior to the council issuing a s. 224(c) certificate...' after Table 7.
area
Amend to clarify what bullet points two and three after Table 7 mean i.e. will council be
requiring bonding for early release of titles under the rural site subdivision rules.
area
Amend the numbering under 'Table 7: Transfer of sites provided for under these rules through
legal protection of indigenous vegetation or wetland' as some have bullet points and other
quote numerals that do not exist. For example bullet point four has a (ii) under it and there is
no (i).
area
Add a definition of 'contiguous' with respect to indigenous vegetation for 'transferable rural site
subdivision'.
area
Amend bullet point four after Table 7 sub bullet point four to clarify the ecological
/scientific reasoning why a wetland must have a 20m buffer as opposed to 10m.
area
Amend bullet point four after Table 7 sub bullet point five to clarify the ecological /scientific
reasoning why indigenous vegetation must be at least 5ha as opposed to 2ha.
area
Amend 'Table 8: Maximum number of new sites for transfer' to amend the maximum yield of 2
to something higher in order to make it economically viable and encourage the protection of
much larger areas of SEA.
area
Amend rural subdivision control for transferable site subdivision 2.3.3(6)(a)(iv) so it relates to
'an animal and plant pest management' plan being required.
6293-20 Scrub Consultants Limited rodney@scrub.co.nz Definitions New Add a new definition of 'wetland'.
6293-21 Scrub Consultants Limited rodney@scrub.co.nz Definitions Existing Amend the definition of 'riparian margin'.
6293-22 Scrub Consultants Limited rodney@scrub.co.nz Definitions Existing Amend the definition of 'river'.
6293-23 Scrub Consultants Limited rodney@scrub.co.nz Definitions New Add a new definition of 'SEA'.
6293-24 Scrub Consultants Limited rodney@scrub.co.nz Definitions Existing Amend the definition of 'stream'.
6293-25 Scrub Consultants Limited rodney@scrub.co.nz Definitions New Add a new definition of 'watercourse'.
6294-1
Westlake Boys High School
Rowings Society Incorporated lazouchfamily@xtra.co.nz Precincts Ak-Wide and Coastal Rowing and Paddling
Amend the PAUP to include a Rowing and Paddling Precinct in the Upper Waitemata
Harbour, within Lucas Creek and from the Greenhithe Bridge to Riverhead, to the precinct.
224/1145
Sub#/
6295-1 David J Murphy mx3@xtra.co.nz Public Open Space Zones Public Open Space
Amend to require tighter controls over Reserve Land similar to those existing in the current
North Shore District Plan.
6296-1 Mark Robinson mark.d.robinson@outlook.com Residential zones Residential
policies
Amend the PAUP to have a range of housing types within each suburb, rather than variation
across suburbs.
6296-2 Mark Robinson mark.d.robinson@outlook.com RPS Urban growth
Recognise that 'growing up' is preferable to 'growing out' as it is a more cost effective in terms
of infrastructure to increase the number of residents in inner suburbs and younger generations
enjoy living in central areas and town centres.
6296-3 Mark Robinson mark.d.robinson@outlook.com Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
Delete minimum parking requirements for all zones, most especially in the Mixed Housing
Urban zone, Mixed Housing Suburban zone and for tavern activities.
6296-4 Mark Robinson mark.d.robinson@outlook.com Zoning Central
Rezone areas from the corner of Lake Road and Hurstmere Road to Takapuna Grammar
(particularly areas close to arterial roads) in Takapuna, from Mixed Housing Suburban to
Mixed Housing Urban.
6296-5 Mark Robinson mark.d.robinson@outlook.com Zoning North and Islands
Rezone areas bounded by the Northern motorway, Shakespeare Road, the coast and
Sunnynook / Kowhai Roads (particularly areas close to arterial roads) in Forrest Hill and
Castor Bay from Mixed Housing Suburban to Mixed Housing Urban.
6296-6 Mark Robinson mark.d.robinson@outlook.com Zoning North and Islands
Rezone the area bounded by the North Western motorway, South Western motorway and
Great South Road (particularly areas close to train lines and arterial roads), from Mixed
Housing Suburban to Mixed Housing Urban.
6297-1 The Ngti Tamaoho Trust dennis@tamaoho.maori.nz General Whole Plan Retain the strategic direction of PAUP.
6297-2 The Ngti Tamaoho Trust dennis@tamaoho.maori.nz General Miscellaneous Other Adopt the relief sought by the Independent Mori Statutory Board.
6297-3 The Ngti Tamaoho Trust dennis@tamaoho.maori.nz Water
policies
Objectives
Amend methods and rules to strengthen objectives regarding water quality discharge and
receiving environments within the Region.
6297-4 The Ngti Tamaoho Trust dennis@tamaoho.maori.nz Mana Whenua
Whenua
whenua
Add the following from the Appendix of submission page 7/7, Hays Stream (Waipokapu),
Hingaia Stream, Ihumatao, Kaikaka, Karaka Stream, Mangapu (Symonds Stream),
Mangatangi Marae, Mangatawhiri Forest, Mangere Mountain (Te-Pane-Mata-Oho),
Matukutureia, Mauku Stream, Maungaroa, Motu Mako (Shark Island), Mt Hobson-Ohinerau,
Mt Smart-Rarotonga, Mt St John-Te Kopuke, Ngakoroa Stream, Oira Creek, Opaheke,
Otuataua, Papahinu, Paparata, Paparimu, Paraheka, Patumahoe, Pehiakura, Puhitahi,
Puhitahi Creek, Pukekiwiriki, Pukekohe, Rakino Island, Remuera, Slippery Creek (Otuwairoa),
Taihiki Riiver, Tamaoho (Mt William), Te Aparangi, Te Aungaaunga, Te Awanui o Taikehu, Te
Hihi Creek, Te Ia Roa, Te Maketu, Te Maketu Falls, Te Tokaroa (Meola) Reef, Titi, Tuhimata,
Waihoehoe Stream, Waitete Pa, Waraha Stream, Whakaupoko (Bald Hill), Whangamaire
Stream, Whatapaka, Whatapaka Creek.
6297-5 The Ngti Tamaoho Trust dennis@tamaoho.maori.nz Natural Hazards and Flooding Flooding H4.12 Rules Identify an alternate overland flow path, where the current one is to be filled or piped.
6297-6 The Ngti Tamaoho Trust dennis@tamaoho.maori.nz RPS Urban growth
2010
Require all developments to provide a catchment management plan prepared in conjunction
with Mana Whenua and with regard to iwi management plans, prior to a structure plan being
accepted by Council.
streams & wetland
table
Retain intermittent streams as a restricted discretionary activity and if filled or piped that an
alternative overland flow route be supplied.
6297-8 The Ngti Tamaoho Trust dennis@tamaoho.maori.nz Mana Whenua General provisions
assessment
Amend Rule G.2.7.4.4 to require consultation with Mana Whenua if the proposed activity
discharges to water or the CMA.
6297-9 The Ngti Tamaoho Trust dennis@tamaoho.maori.nz Water Stormwater
rules Add mana whenua values to the criteria for discharges.
6297-10 The Ngti Tamaoho Trust dennis@tamaoho.maori.nz Water Stormwater
rules Amend private discharges to be referenced in this section.
6297-11 The Ngti Tamaoho Trust dennis@tamaoho.maori.nz Earthworks H4.2.2 Controls
Amend controls, that should flocculants be used, that organic flocculants such as "halo clear"
be used.
6297-12 The Ngti Tamaoho Trust dennis@tamaoho.maori.nz
Rural Discharges,
Biosolids
Add rules for setbacks from all waterways for all cropping and farming activities such as
setback to be grassed if not riparian planted.
6297-13 The Ngti Tamaoho Trust dennis@tamaoho.maori.nz Mana Whenua
settlement land
policies
Objectives
Add Mana Whenua values to policies, methods and rules regarding any potential impacts on
water quality.
assessment
Retain rule 2(7)(4), but recognise the need to further referral through collaboration with Mana
Whenua, council and key stakeholders.
assessment Add stormwater and wastewater activities to rule.
225/1145
Sub#/
6297-17 The Ngti Tamaoho Trust dennis@tamaoho.maori.nz RPS Changes to the RUB South
Delete Karaka and Karaka West as potential areas for inclusion in the southern RUB for the
next 10 years or whenever the PAUP is next reviewed to allow for roading and wastewater
impacts to be assessed.
6297-18 The Ngti Tamaoho Trust dennis@tamaoho.maori.nz RPS Changes to the RUB South
Retain a 5km wide greenbelt in the Bycroft Road area separating the Pukekohe-Paerata node
from the Drury (Oira and Burt Road) option areas. Prohibit subdivision and encourage and
support rural uses and investment.
land for urban development Establish a developed sequence and indicative programme for the southern RUB areas.
6297-20 The Ngti Tamaoho Trust dennis@tamaoho.maori.nz RPS Changes to the RUB South Delete extention into or further inclusion of land surrounding Kingseat.
organisms
modified organisms Retain provisions.
organisms
modified organisms
Prioritise policy that represents strong cultural concerns of Mori in Auckland and Northland
regarding GMO's.
the CMA Discharges
Amend method rules to strengthen objectives regarding water quality discharge and reciving
environments within the Region.
6297-24 The Ngti Tamaoho Trust dennis@tamaoho.maori.nz Earthworks H4.2.2 Controls Strengthen the erosion and sediment controls to beyond TP80. [Technical Publication 90].
Amend RUB so that none of the southern RUB options are available until all suitable land
within or adjacent to the existing Metropolitan Urban Limit has been taken up.
streams & wetland
C5.14 Background &
Objectives Retain protection of puna, streams and harbour.
6297-27 The Ngti Tamaoho Trust dennis@tamaoho.maori.nz RPS Mana Whenua
Fig. 1 Retain protection of cultural sites of significance including urupa.
6298-1
Brian Lewis and Pauline
O'Flaherty bripaul@ihug.co.nz Historic Heritage (Overlay)
Heritage
Places
Amend Appendix 9.3, Map 21 'Historic Heritage Area: Suttie's Estate' to identify 14 Jackson
Street, Onehunga as a site with non-contributing buildings (rather than a site with contributing
buildings).
6298-2
Brian Lewis and Pauline
O'Flaherty bripaul@ihug.co.nz Historic Heritage (Overlay)
Heritage
Places
Undertake individual assessment of buildings within Suttie's Estate Historic Heritage Area
[Appendix 9.3 Historic Heritage Place maps, Map 21], to identify which buildings contribute to
the heritage values of the area.
6299-1 34 Franklin Limited john@subdivision.co.nz Zoning South Retain the Mixed Use Business zoning for 34 Franklin Road, Pukehohe
6299-2 34 Franklin Limited john@subdivision.co.nz Transport
transport noise J1.5 Rules and mapping Retain the Overlay for 34 Franklin Road, Pukekohe.
6299-3 34 Franklin Limited john@subdivision.co.nz
Centre)
Maps only Remove the General Frontage Overlay from 34 Franklin Road, Pukekohe.
6300-1 Jan Pilkington jdcpilk@xtra.co.nz
Centre) Business
& Bus. Park zones
Remove commercial sexual [services] as a permitted activity in the Neighbourhood Centre
zone.
6301-1 Sarah Woodfield swoodfield@ihug.co.nz Transport Auckland -wide
requirements Retain Rule 3.2 Number of parking and loading spaces.
6301-2 Sarah Woodfield swoodfield@ihug.co.nz Transport Auckland -wide
requirements Amend provisions [Rule 3.2] to require bicycle parking for all new buildings.
6301-3 Sarah Woodfield swoodfield@ihug.co.nz RPS Urban growth
Retain the concept of intensification with a focus on walking, biking and public transport rather
than private vehicle use.
6302-1 John W Williams john_williams1@xtra.co.nz Mana Whenua
Whenua
Delete the 'Sites and places of value to Mana Whenua' overlay [ID 2545], from Torkar Road
and Crisp Road, Clarks Beach.
6303-1 Thomas Riddell thomasriddell@gmail.com Mana Whenua General provisions
assessment Delete the requirement to obtain a cultural impact assessment from iwi from the PAUP.
6304-1 Alex Rae john@subdivision.co.nz Precincts - South Franklin
Amend the activity status column for subdivision within Sub-precinct A from Restricted
Discretionary Activity to Controlled Activity [in K6.7.1 Activity table].
6304-2 Alex Rae john@subdivision.co.nz Precincts - South Franklin
Amend the activity status column for subdivision within Sub-precinct A from Non-Complying
activity to Discretionary activity [in K6.7.1 Activity table]..
6305-1 Brenda C Spiller brenda.spiller@xtra.co.nz General Cross plan matters
Remove reference to the words 'principles' or the phrase 'Treaty principles because that have
not been defined in the interpretation section of any NZ Statute and do not have legal
standing.
6306-1
Pukekohe East Church
Preservation Society SusanneStoneNZ@gmail.com RPS
character and natural heritage B4.1 Historic heritage Put more resources into protecting our heritage buildings, trees and features.
6307-1 D J and T K Bennett karyn@subdivision.co.nz RPS Changes to the RUB South Rezone 130 Heights Road, Pukekohe from Rural Production to Future Urban.
6308-1 David B Seymour ruggaseymour@hotmail.com General Whole Plan Decline the PAUP.
226/1145
Sub#/
6309-1 Bill Cunnington billmms@xtra.co.nz Precincts - North Bayswater
objectives and policies Reject residential development.
objectives and policies Amend to provide for existing businesses and boat storage.
objectives and policies Amend to require consultation with local residents regarding changes to the precinct.
6310-1 Rajinder Dass raj-macfarland@xtra.co.nz Mana Whenua General provisions
assessment
Delete the requirement for a cultural impact assessment for work within sites of cultural and
heritage value to Mori [rule 2.7.4 'Cultural impact assessment'].
6311-1 Gerald Shand karyn@subdivision.co.nz Mana Whenua
Whenua
Delete the overlay from 105 to 123 Torkar Road, Clarkes Beach as shown in Figure 1 (refer
page 2/2 of submission).
6312-1 George and Rosemary Holden g.holden@xtra.co.nz Mana Whenua General provisions
assessment Review the potential effects on 43 Farley Road, Pukekohe.
6313-1 Lisa McEwan lisa.mcewan@aut.ac.nz
SEAs
Areas - Land rules (all) Amend the SEA provisions to enable a minor dwelling at 75 Piha Road, Piha.
6314-1 Catherine Hennessy cate.hennessy@gmail.com Zoning Central
Rezone the block comprising Spring Street, Grey Street, Galway Street and Arthur Street,
Onehunga from Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings zone to Mixed Housing Suburban
Zone.
6314-2 Catherine Hennessy cate.hennessy@gmail.com General Miscellaneous Consultation and engagement
Consult with all residents in areas zoned Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings on an
individual basis to give those people who are directly affected the opportunity to object to this
zoning.
6314-3 Catherine Hennessy cate.hennessy@gmail.com RPS Urban growth
environment
Give more consideration to the Auckland Design Manual than to the PAUP as it prioritises the
design/plans of landscape architects, historic and natural heritage and above all people.
6315-0 Withdrawn Withdrawn
6316-1 Sarah Taylor sarah.taylor@clear.net.nz RPS Mana Whenua B5 Strategic Delete all proposals for shared governance within the Proposed Auckland Unitary Plan.
6316-2 Sarah Taylor sarah.taylor@clear.net.nz Mana Whenua
Whenua
Amend sections 5.1 and 5.2 to ensure that the provisions respect the property rights of
citizens, protect citizens from the arbitrary use of power and make council responsible for all
cultural impact assessments [Rules 5.1 and 5.2 relate to air quality and earthworks not Mana
Whenua which the relief sought relates to].
6316-3 Sarah Taylor sarah.taylor@clear.net.nz Mana Whenua
Whenua
objectives and policies Amend the listed sites of cultural significance to be graded into categories of significance.
6316-4 Sarah Taylor sarah.taylor@clear.net.nz Mana Whenua General provisions
assessment Delete Rule 2.7.4(5) 'Information requirement'.
6317-1 The Surveying Company karyn@subdivision.co.nz Mana Whenua General provisions
assessment Amend clause 2.7.4 to not require a cultural report in situations.
6317-2 The Surveying Company karyn@subdivision.co.nz Earthworks H4.2.1.1 Activity table - Zones Retain the threshold limits outlined in the Activity Table.
6317-3 The Surveying Company karyn@subdivision.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - Rural zones
zones only
Amend Table 5 as follows: 'Any other subdivision not provided for in this table or in the rural
subdivision rules' Prohibited to Non Complying
6317-4 The Surveying Company karyn@subdivision.co.nz Precincts - South Franklin
Include Version 7a of Plan Change 14 of the Auckland Council District Plan - Operative
Franklin Section 2000 in the Proposed Auckland Unitary Plan.
area
Amend Rule 1(a) as follows: "A specified building area must be clearly identified on the
receiver site and balance sites under 1 hectare in size on a scheme plan of subdivision on
which a building is anticipated".
area Delete Rule 1(c).
area
Amend Rule 1(d) as follows: "Subdivision that does not comply with this control is a
discretionary activity".
area
Amend Rule 4 as follows: "4. Transferable rural site subdivision: Controls
for transferable rural site subdivision through amalgamation or surrender"
area
Add the following to clause 2.3.3(4)(a)(i) immediately after the bullet point list: "and in the case
of the donor lots referred to in 3.a.iv above, may also include lots within Countryside Living,
Large Lot and Rural and Coastal Settlement Zones".
area
Amend Rule 4(a)(iv) as follows: "iv. The amalgamation of for every two donor sites being
amalgamated , or the surrender of a single donor site, once amalgamated or surrendered,
shall not result in more than one dwelling per 40 ha in the Rural Production zone or one
dwelling per site in any other applicable zone for the receiver site".
area
Amend Rule 4(c)(i) as follows: "i. be subdivided into no more than one receiver site for every
two donor sites amalgamated, or every single donor site surrendered. A donor site must not
be the same site as the receiver site".
227/1145
Sub#/
area
Amend Rule 4(c)(ii) by adding the following text immediately after the bullet point list: "and in
the case of the donor sites referred to in 3.a.iv above, may also include lots within the
Countryside Living, Large Lot and Rural and Coastal Settlement Zones".
area
Amend Rule 4(c)(iv) as follows: "Have a minimum net site area of: "- 2500m
2
and a maximum
area of 10,000m
2
if located in an identified receiver area other than the Country Site Living
zone, or"
area
Delete Rule 4(c)(iv) and (v) and replace with the following: "iv. have a minimum net site area
which complies with the applicable zone or precinct plan rule(s)".
area Amend Rule 4(c)(viii) to consider versatility of land and matching like for like soils.
area
Amend Rule 4(c)(ix) as follows: "....amalgamation or surrender of donor sites has been
deposited".
area
Add Franklin Plan Change 14: 7a provisions relating to Rule 22B.12.4.1(c) Rural subdivision
lot sizes (includes table). See submission for further details - page 7 and 8/9 of the
submission.
area
Add a new line to Table 6 to broaden the incentives for the transfer of sites. See submission
for specific amendments [page 8/9 of the submission].
area Retain Rule 5.
area
Delete Rules 1. and 2. from Table 7 and replace with: "Country Site Living Zone Mixed Rural
Zone Rural Production Zone Large Lot Zone Rural and Coastal Settlement Zone".
area
Adopt Franklin District Council Plan Change 14: 7a provision relating to Rural subdivision lot
sizes and insert the table from rule 22B.11.1A into Table 8.
area
Add a new line to Table 9 as follows: "Boundary adjustments or relocations for donor sites
under the transferrable rural site subdivision rules Controlled"
area Delete Rule 9.
6317-24 The Surveying Company karyn@subdivision.co.nz Residential zones Residential Activity Table
Amend the Activity Table and relevant provision to remove restrictions on the primary dwelling
existing on the date of the notification of the Unitary Plan.
6317-25 The Surveying Company karyn@subdivision.co.nz
Centre) Business
& Bus. Park zones
Retain the restricted discretionary assessment of development of new buildings across all
business zones.
6317-26 The Surveying Company karyn@subdivision.co.nz Precincts - South Pukekohe Hill Retain the Pukehohe Hill Sub-precinct.
6317-27 The Surveying Company karyn@subdivision.co.nz Precincts - South Runciman
Amend rule 3.3.(5)(a) to read: "a. separated by at least 85100 m from the edge of another
specified building area or an existing dwelling".
6318-1
Museum of New Zealand Te
Papa Tongarewa PO Box 467, Wellington 6140 Zoning South
Rezone the south western part of Hayman Park, Manukau from Open Space Informal
Recreation to Open Space Community [see page 7/8 of submission for specific location].
6318-2
Papa Tongarewa PO Box 467, Wellington 6140 Precincts - South New Precincts All other New Precincts
Apply a new precinct to the south western part of Hayman Park to accommodate the National
Centre for collections, learning and exhibitions [museum] on Hayman Park, Manukau which
provides for activities associated with the National Centre at Hayman Park [see page 5/8 of
submission for specific activities that should be included], and that the follow new
development controls are included which require a: - maximum building height of 18m -
maximum site coverage of 70% - maximum impervious surface of 27,000m2.
6318-3
Papa Tongarewa PO Box 467, Wellington 6140 Definitions New
Include a new definition for Arts and Cultural Centres and that it makes provision for a
national centre for collections, learning and exhibitions on Hayman Park, Manukau.
6319-1
Ministry of Business
Innovation and Employment paul.honeybone@mbie.govt.nz RPS Urban growth
Align policies and rules with strategic objectives to provide sufficient capacity for growth
including through appropriate density provisions and zoning.
6319-2
Align policies and rules with strategic objectives to provide sufficient capacity for growth
including freeing development from complicated policies and rules.
6319-3
Innovation and Employment paul.honeybone@mbie.govt.nz General Cross plan matters
Recognise, the broad brush approach of the overlays, the inconsistency in zoning between
market interest and density allocations and the misalignment between density allowances and
specific development controls that constrain density, all work against the overall regulatory
efficiency of the PAUP in achieving its strategic objectives.
228/1145
Sub#/
6319-4
Amend the zoning, overlays and development controls and other rules such that they do not
constrain provision of sufficient residential development to meet Aucklands long term (30
year) growth projections and proactively enable efficient growth in areas of high market
demand.
6319-5
Innovation and Employment paul.honeybone@mbie.govt.nz Residential zones Housing affordability
and policies Delete the Retained Affordable Housing provisions.
6319-6
Innovation and Employment paul.honeybone@mbie.govt.nz Sustainable Development C7.7/H6.4 Sustainable design Delete the Sustainable Development - Homestar provisions.
6319-7
Enable more residential development through green field expansion and by enabling greater
density in existing neighbourhoods.
6319-8
Amend zoning provisions to correct the misalignment between areas of high demand and the
areas where growth is provided for.
6319-9
Review the approach to consenting medium density development to remove rules, overlays
and controls which will stifle innovation and good design.
6319-10
Clarify why many zoning decisions across the city have been made. Inefficient use of market
attractive land and protecting the micro amenity of neighbourhoods in the short term will
seriously compromise the macro-utility of the city as a whole.
6319-11
Innovation and Employment paul.honeybone@mbie.govt.nz Residential zones Residential
policies
Amend the zoning, overlays and density rules to re-establish and ensure alignment with the
strategic objectives of the Auckland Plan and the Regional Policy Statement to provide
sufficient development capacity.
6319-12
Innovation and Employment paul.honeybone@mbie.govt.nz Residential zones Housing affordability
and policies
Recognise that there is no such thing as a house which is affordable for all time and
maintaining what is in effect a price ceiling will undermine the efficient use of the land.
6319-13
Innovation and Employment paul.honeybone@mbie.govt.nz Residential zones Housing affordability H6.6 Rules
Amend the affordable housing provisions, if they are to be retained, by removing the
requirement for external design comparability, allowing affordable housing outside the
development site, rely on quality/size price differences to control future use, removing any
legal mechanism to control future use and price and incentivise volume and diversity of new
construction.
6319-14
Innovation and Employment paul.honeybone@mbie.govt.nz Sustainable Development C7.7/H6.4 Sustainable design
Amend the sustainable development provisions, if they are to be retained, so that they
incentivise voluntary compliance with Homestar 6.
6319-15
Innovation and Employment paul.honeybone@mbie.govt.nz General Chapter G General provisions G2.4 Notification
No specific decision requested in relation to the shift away from non-notification of the March
Draft Auckland Unitary Plan and the greater uncertainty and increased cost for
developers. Refer to submission, page 22/23.
6319-16
Innovation and Employment paul.honeybone@mbie.govt.nz General Cross plan matters
Amend provisions to remove constrains and additional requirements of overlays, such as the
pre-1944 Demolition Control and the Sites and Places of value to Mana Whenua which will
impact significantly on potential development costs and development capacity.
6320-1 Jeremy Richards jeremjr@fastmail.fm
the CMA Mangroves
and policies Amend to change the mangrove removal date from 1996 to 1956 for the Kaipatiki area.
6320-2 Jeremy Richards jeremjr@fastmail.fm Public Open Space Zones Public Open Space I2.1 Activity table
Reject activity statuses in the Conservation Zone except those listed in volume 2 page 2 of
submission.
Reject activity statuses in the Information Recreation zone except those listed in volume 2
page 2 of submission.
6320-4 Jeremy Richards jeremjr@fastmail.fm Public Open Space Zones Public Open Space I2.1 Activity table Amend Activity Table for Conservation Land to prohibit built structures.
Amend Activity Table for Informal Recreation Areas to prohibit housing communities and
commercial facilities.
Amend Activity Table for Sport and Recreational Facilities to prohibit development of retail
and community facilities.
6321-1 Grant B Matheson grant_sonia@clear.net.nz
SEAs
Land Delete the SEA of [infer 67 Matheson Road, Papakura].
6321-2 Grant B Matheson grant_sonia@clear.net.nz Water
streams & wetland
table Delete the natural stream management area of [67 Matheson Road, Papakura].
6321-3 Grant B Matheson grant_sonia@clear.net.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - Rural zones
area Amend the minimum size of Rural Lot Subdivision from 2500m
2
to 4000m
2
.
area Delete the Rural Subdivision Lot sizes for larger properties of 4 hectare - 20 hectare lots.
6321-5 Grant B Matheson grant_sonia@clear.net.nz Zoning South Retain growth area around Paparimu School.
area Retain smaller lot rural subdivision around Paparimu School.
6321-7 Grant B Matheson grant_sonia@clear.net.nz General Miscellaneous
Operational/
Retain Council purchasing of areas that are important at market value rates. Or refund all
rates paid on this area for the period of ownership.
229/1145
Sub#/
6322-1 Edward Scott eadarscott@gmail.com General Whole Plan Decline the PAUP.
6323-1 Kana Holdings (1963) Limited dan@madsen-lawrie.co.nz Precincts - South Pukekohe Hill Remove Pukekohe Hill sub-precinct A from 204, 220 and 222 Kitchener Road, Pukekohe.
6323-2 Kana Holdings (1963) Limited dan@madsen-lawrie.co.nz Zoning South Rezone 204, 220 and 222 Kitchener Road, Pukekohe to Single House.
6324-1 Angelique Cathcart
27 Tapu Road, Kumeu, Auckland
0810 Subdivision Auckland-wide - Urban zones H5.2 3.1 Residential zones Delete provision for section sizes smaller than 750m2 in the Kumeu / Huapai area.
Allow no increase in housing in the Kumeu / Huapai area until issues relating to roading, such
as extra traffic have been addressed.
0810 General Miscellaneous Consultation and engagement
Requests full consultation at the time of planning / development to minimize stress in relation
to what will be built next door to the submitter's property (27 Tapu Road, Huapai) and loss of
investment.
0810 RPS Changes to the RUB West Retain the semi rural feeling of the Kumeu / Huapai area.
6325-1
Madsen Lawrie Consultants
Limited dan@madsen-lawrie.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - Rural zones
area
Add the Franklin District Council's Plan Change 14 into the PAUP as outlined in the
submission, refer to pages 3 to 5/19 of the submission.
6325-2
Limited dan@madsen-lawrie.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - Urban zones
except Rural
Amend the activity status for subdivision in Table 3 for the Future Urban zone from Prohibited
to Restricted Discretionary.
6325-3
zones only Provide for subdivisions as Discretionary in Table 5 for the Rural zone.
6325-4
Limited dan@madsen-lawrie.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - general
controls
Delete rule 6(a) Esplanade reserves (Council obtaining land without payment of
compensation).
6325-5
controls
Delete rule 2(b) which states that subdivision for network utilities to comply with the relevant
Auckland wide and zone rules.
6325-6
controls Delete Rule 2.1(a) and (b).
6325-7
controls Delete Rule 3.1(b).
6325-8
controls Delete 'land modification' from Rule 3.2(c)
6325-9
controls Delete rule 3.4(b).
6325-10
Limited dan@madsen-lawrie.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - Urban zones H5.2 3.1 Residential zones Delete 'public lines' from rule 2(c).
6325-11
Limited dan@madsen-lawrie.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - Urban zones H5.2 3.1 Residential zones Delete rule 3(a).
6325-12
Limited dan@madsen-lawrie.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - Urban zones H5.2 3.1 Residential zones Delete rule 4(a).
6325-13
Limited dan@madsen-lawrie.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - Urban zones H5.2 3.1 Residential zones Delete the 50m maximum length to access rear sites from Table 2: Access to rear sites.
6325-14
Limited dan@madsen-lawrie.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - Urban zones H5.2 3.1 Residential zones
Add Buckland, Clarks Beach, Glenbrook Beach, Patumahoe and Waiau P Beach in Table 3:
Additional subdivision controls.
6325-15
Limited dan@madsen-lawrie.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - Urban zones H5.2.3.2 Business zones Delete 'and public lines' from Rule 2.3.2(3)(vi).
6325-16
area Delete Rule 2.3.3(1)(c)(i).
6325-17
area Delete Rule 2.3.3(2)(a)(iv).
6325-18
Limited dan@madsen-lawrie.co.nz Definitions Existing
Amend the definition of 'suitably qualified'. [Note: a definition of 'suitably qualified' and
experienced person exists].
6325-19
area Delete Rule 2.3.3(2)(b).
6325-20
area Delete Rule 2.3.3(2)(d)(i).
6325-21
area Delete Rule 2.3.3(2)(d)(iv).
6325-22
area Delete Rule 2.3.3(2)(d)(v).
230/1145
Sub#/
6325-23
area Delete Rule 2.3.3(3)(b)(i), second bullet point.
6325-24
zones only Delete Countryside Living zone from Table 5, Step 1(b).
6325-25
area Delete the words 'road severance or designation' from Rule 2.3.3(4)(a)(ii).
6325-26
area Delete rule 2.3.3 Rural zones(4)(b)(i).
6325-27
area Delete "receiving site exclusion area as identified on the Appendix 12.1" Rule 2.3.3(4)(c)(iii).
6325-28
area Delete rule 2.3.3(4)(c)(iv).
6325-29
area Delete rule 2.3.3(4)(b)(viii).
6325-30
area Delete rule 2.3.3(4)(b)(ix).
6325-31
area
Amend rule 2.3.3(4)(b)(x) to identify the fact that two receiver sites can be placed on any one
title.
6325-32
area Delete the sites not to used as receiver sites from Table 7 of Rule 2.3.3(4)(b)(i).
6325-33
area Delete the second bullet point from [rule 2.3.3(5)(a)(ii)].
6325-34
area Amend the minimum area of 5ha to 5000m2 from Column A, Table 8 of Rule 2.3.3.
6325-35
area Amend the conservation title requirement from 8ha to 5ha from Column A, Table 8.
6325-36
area
Reduce the 20m buffer zone for wetlands to 3-5m from Column A, Table 8 of rule 2.3.3 Rural
zones.
6325-37
area
Delete the reference to the note from Column C, Table 8 and replace with a statement that
further lots can be obtained for every 5ha of conservation areas.
6325-38
area Delete Rule 2.3.3 (7) [table 9, first line]
6325-39
area Add the Franklin area with a minimum of 1ha in Table 10 of Rule 2.3.3.
6325-40
area Delete Rule 2.3.3(7)(d)(ii), bullet point 5.
6325-41
area Delete Rule 2.3.3(9)(a).
6325-42
area Delete item 12(d) from Table 12 of Rule 3.2 Assessment - Controlled activities.
6325-43
Limited dan@madsen-lawrie.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - general H5.3 - 4 Assessment Delete item 4 from Table 14 of rule 4. Assessment - Restricted Discretionary Activity.
6325-44
Limited dan@madsen-lawrie.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - general H5.3 - 4 Assessment Delete item 8 from Table 14 of Rule 4. Assessment - Restricted Discretionary Activity.
231/1145
Sub#/
6325-45
Limited dan@madsen-lawrie.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - general H5.3 - 4 Assessment Delete item [35 from table 14] of Rule 4. Assessment - Restricted Discretionary Activity].
6325-46
area Add Franklin District Plan's Plan Change 14 into the PAUP.
6326-1
Med Service Investment
Limited
sophie.benfell-
brinsden@colliers.com
Purpose)
zone
Insert the 'Ryman St Heliers retirement village and 188 Health Centre concept plan' as
contained in the operative Auckland Council District Plan - Isthmus section - C15-00.
6326-2
Limited
sophie.benfell-
Purpose)
zone
Amend restricted discretionary rule for 'new buildings located within 10m of a street or public
open space' to state that the development controls in the 'Concept Plan - Ryman St Heliers
retirement village and 188 Health Centre' take precedence.
6326-3
Limited
sophie.benfell-
Purpose)
zone
Amend the restricted discretionary rule for 'new buildings greater than 500m
2
' to not apply to
188 St Heliers Bay Rd, St Heliers.
6326-4
Limited
sophie.benfell-
Purpose)
zone
Amend the restricted discretionary rule for 'external alternations and additions to buildings
which are located within 10m of a street or public open space' to not apply to 188 St Heliers
Bay Rd, St Heliers, and to state the development controls in the 'Concept Plan - Ryman St
Heliers retirement village and 188 Health Centre' take precedence.
6326-5
Limited
sophie.benfell-
Purpose)
zone
Amend the Activity Table by adding the list of activities, detailed on page 10/14 in the
submission, as permitted activities. List of activities are healthcare related and include the
provision for up to 30% of gross floor area to be non-healthcare support services as a
permitted activity.
6326-6
Limited
sophie.benfell-
Purpose)
zone
Add the following to the Activity Table as a Restricted Discretionary activity: Any activity not
identified in the concept plan or precinct plan as a permitted activity
6326-7
Limited
sophie.benfell-
Purpose)
zone Retain the Restricted Discretionary matters of discretion [rule 3.3.1]
6326-8
Limited
sophie.benfell-
Purpose)
zone
Amend text to make specific reference to the 'Concept Plan - Ryman St Heliers retirement
village and 188 Health Centre'.
6327-1 Sarah Higgins sarahhiggins@hotmail.co.nz RPS
Recognise that more thought needs to be given to providing adequate infrastructure [to
support growth].
6328-1 M and B Chhagan dan@madsen-lawrie.co.nz Zoning South Rezone 1 Grace James Road, Pukehohe from Large Lot Residential to Single House.
6329-1 Carter Family Trust
1/63A McIntryre Road, Mangere
Bridge, Auckland 2022 Zoning Central Rezone 9 Ayr Street, Parnell from Single House zone to Mixed Housing Suburban zone.
6330-1 No Confidence Party tyau.chan@gmail.com General Whole Plan Decline the PAUP
6330-2 No Confidence Party tyau.chan@gmail.com General Miscellaneous
Operational/
No specific decision stated in relation to resource consent processes. Refer to submission
pages 4-11/11.
6331-1 Donovan Bisset don@bisset.co.nz Precincts - North Bayswater
Reject the classification of sub-precinct B as 'for the development of ferry terminal facilities
and for associated parking' and allow for continued use of this area by Takapuna Grammar
School Rowing Club.
6331-2 Donovan Bisset don@bisset.co.nz Precincts - North Bayswater
Provide an alternative area and building facility in proximity to the water for use of Takapuna
Grammar Rowing Club [at Bayswater Marina as alternative relief should Sub-precinct E not be
amended to enable continued use by the club].
6331-3 Donovan Bisset don@bisset.co.nz General Miscellaneous
Operational/
Projects/Acquisition Provide an additional launch ramp and/or pontoon at Bayswater Marina.
6332-1 Tui Glen Nurseries dan@madsen-lawrie.co.nz Zoning South Rezone 190 Jutland Road, Pukekohe from Future Urban to Mixed Housing Suburban.
6333-1
Village Farms Limited and
Salperton Downs Limited vaughan@vsplanning.co.nz RPS Changes to the RUB South
Amend the Rural Urban Boundary to include Karaka North and Karaka West. Refer to full
submission for a map [page 8/8]
6333-2
Salperton Downs Limited vaughan@vsplanning.co.nz Rural Zones
obs & pols Reduce the extent of the Rural Coastal zone.
6333-3
Salperton Downs Limited vaughan@vsplanning.co.nz Rural Zones General I13.1 Activity table Amend the provisions to allow for more development opportunities in the Rural Coastal zone.
6333-4
Salperton Downs Limited vaughan@vsplanning.co.nz Residential zones Housing affordability H6.6 Rules Delete the provisions requiring affordable housing to be included in residential development.
6333-5
Salperton Downs Limited vaughan@vsplanning.co.nz RPS Urban growth
Retain the approach to urban growth of intensification of existing areas and release of new
greeenfield areas.
6334-1 Korora Trust james@cpc-nz.com
SEAs
Land Remove the SEA from 41 Beach Road, Castor Bay.
6335-1 Pioneer Shore City Pte Limited jarrod.reilly@colliers.com RPS Urban growth
quality compact urban form Retain the PAUP's integrated, smart intensification approach to growth.
6335-2 Pioneer Shore City Pte Limited jarrod.reilly@colliers.com Precincts - North Takapuna 1
Amend wording in order to clarify that the development controls within the Takapuna 1
Precinct supercede those controls in the underlying Metrolitan Centre- Takapuna zone.
6335-3 Pioneer Shore City Pte Limited jarrod.reilly@colliers.com Precincts - North Takapuna 1 Amend the height limits in the Takapuna 1 Precinct, Sub-Precinct E to 72.5m (18 storeys).
232/1145
Sub#/
6335-4 Pioneer Shore City Pte Limited jarrod.reilly@colliers.com
Centre)
Maps only Delete the Key Retail Frontage overlay from 52-56 Anzac Street, Takapuna.
Centre) Business
Park zones
Amend Rule 4.9(1) by significantly reducing the requirement for glazing for 75% of the
frontage widths and heights at 52-56 Anzac Street, Takapuna.
Centre) Business
& Bus. Park zones
Amend Activity Table by including 'commercial carparking building' as a Permitted activity in
the Metropolitan Centre zone, which may be subject to permitted activity assessment criteria.
6335-7 Pioneer Shore City Pte Limited jarrod.reilly@colliers.com Air Quality
Amend Activity Table to change the status of care centres from Restricted Discretionary to
Permitted, subject to meeting relevant assessment criteria.
Centre) Business
& Bus. Park zones
Amend Activity Table to change the activity status of demolition of buildings within the
Metropolitan Centre zone from Restricted Discretionary to Permitted, provided it meets the
assessment criteria currently outlined for demolition as a Restricted Discretionary activity.
6335-9 Pioneer Shore City Pte Limited jarrod.reilly@colliers.com Sustainable Development C7.7/H6.4 Sustainable design
Delete Rule 6.4(2)(1) and make the sustainable development criteria a non-statutory
guideline.
6335-10 Pioneer Shore City Pte Limited jarrod.reilly@colliers.com Residential zones Housing affordability H6.6 Rules
Delete requirement (1) to provide affordable housing into new development, containing more
than 15 dwellings within the RUB and replace with 'wider Restricted Discretionary activity
matters of discretion and assessment criteria which are less restrictive'.
Centre) Business
Special information
requirements Delete the requirement within Rule 10(1) to provide a design statement.
6335-12 Pioneer Shore City Pte Limited jarrod.reilly@colliers.com Precincts - North Smales 2
Delete the 75% glazing control for width and height as part of the design criteria that is
considered for any redevelopment within the Takapuna 1 Precinct.
6336-1
Howick Pakuranga Cricket
Club Incorporated office@hpcc.org.nz Public Open Space Zones
obs & pols Retain Objective 1.
6336-2
6336-3
obs & pols
Amend Policy 5 to provide for accommodation buildings if certain criteria, including
spaciousness and reasonable level of amenity, can be met [refer to Page 5/6 for details].
6337-1 Shyamal Ram shyamal.ram@hotmail.com Subdivision Auckland-wide - general
controls
Amend controls to provide exclusions for large existing rear sites so that they are less
constrained in terms of the number of sites that can be created.
6337-2 Shyamal Ram shyamal.ram@hotmail.com Residential zones Residential Land use controls
Amend Rule 3.1(7) 'Maximum Density' to provide exclusions for large existing sites so that
they are less constrained in terms of the number of sites that can be created.
6337-3 Shyamal Ram shyamal.ram@hotmail.com Residential zones Residential
Amend [4.3 'Yards'] to provide for exclusions for large existing sites so that they are less
constrained of the number of sites that can be created.
6338-1 Paul Mitchell PM.exports@xtra.co.nz Precincts - West
Amend Map 4 [and Rule 4(4)(2), Sub precinct A- Waitakere Foothills] to allow flexibility in
terms of the enhancement areas shown on 174, 196 and 198 Parker Road, Oratia.
6339-1 Caroline Phillips phillips@orcon.net.nz RPS
Undertake a full, professional audit of both the scheduled and non-scheduled archaeological
and historic heritage sites as outlined on page 5/8 of the submission [audit to include sites
and places of value to Mana Whenua, historic heritage place, historic heritage extent of place
and pre-1944 demolition control].
6339-2 Caroline Phillips phillips@orcon.net.nz Historic Heritage (Overlay)
Heritage
Places
Map the extent of the [archaeological site or heritage place] sites wherever possible and
include the full extent of the site or place in the GIS layers, not a central point.
6339-3 Caroline Phillips phillips@orcon.net.nz Mana Whenua
Whenua J5.1 Rules
Ensure that precautionary buffers for archaeological and heritage sites are 30m unless there
is a particular reason to have a lesser or greater one.
6339-4 Caroline Phillips phillips@orcon.net.nz Mana Whenua
Whenua
and policies
Delete the 'Sites and Places of Value to Mana Whenua' overlay and its associated rules from
the PAUP and replace it with a non-statutory alert layer based on the Council's CHI and GIS,
as detailed on page 5/8 of the submission.
Ensure that archaeological sites and all provisions relating to them are distinct from the Mana
Whenua overlay and its rules, as outlined on page 6/8 of the submission.
character and natural heritage B4.1 Historic heritage Ensure that archaeological provisions in the PAUP align with the Historic Places Act.
Ensure that the archaeological provisions in the PAUP supplement protection in relation to
post 1900 heritage places.
Heritage
Additional management
controls for archaeological
sites or features
Remove restrictions imposed by the PAUP on the archaeological field assessment techniques
that can be employed by archaeological consultants and instead ensure that such techniques
continue to be governed under the Historic Places Act and the NZ Historic Places Trust
guidelines. Refer to page 7/8 of the submission.
233/1145
Sub#/
Remove the requirements for resource consent and supervision by Mana Whenua for
standard archaeological assessment, as outlined on page 7/8 of the submission.
Amend the historic heritage provisions to ensure that all archaeological sites i.e. pre-1900 of
Mori and non-Mori origin and historic heritage sites i.e. pre-1944 are treated identically by
requiring archaeological assessments to be undertaken for historic heritage places dated up
to 1944, as outlined on page 8/8 of the submission.
6340-1 N Wallabh and Sons dan@madsen-lawrie.co.nz Zoning South Rezone 178 Portsmouth Road, Bombay from Rural Production to Countryside Living.
6341-1 Mark S Hall thehall@clear.net.nz Mana Whenua General provisions
assessment
Amend the G27.4 to limit the tests associated with cultural impact assessment (particularly
with residential development).
6341-2 Mark S Hall thehall@clear.net.nz Definitions Existing
Amend the definition of 'earthworks' in terms of residential development, particularly for minor
works.
6342-1 T and K Whitton dan@madsen-lawrie.co.nz Zoning South
Rezone 36 Jellicoe Road, Pukekohe from Large Lot Residential to a more intensive
residential zone.
6343-1 Philippa Martin philippamartin@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central Retain the PAUP zoning for 25 Maranui Avenue, Pt Chevalier, including number 25.
6344-1 David J Marks david.marks@cornerstone.co.nz Zoning Central
Rezone Herdman Street, Daventry Street and Waterbank Crescent, Waterview to Suburban
zoning [Mixed Housing Suburban] with a two storey maximum height limit like the rest of
Waterview.
6345-1 Paul Sousa
18 Oranga Avenue, Onehunga,
Auckland 1061
control
and policies Delete pre-1944 provisions.
6345-2 Paul Sousa
18 Oranga Avenue, Onehunga,
Auckland 1061 Residential zones Residential Land use controls
Amend [rule 3.1 Maximum density] to remove frontage width requirements for 300m
2
density
in Mixed Housing Suburban zone.
6346-1 Mohan Parsot dan@madsen-lawrie.co.nz Zoning South Rezone 253 Kitchener Road, Pukehohe from Pukekohe Hill Sub-Precinct A to Single House.
6346-2 Mohan Parsot dan@madsen-lawrie.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - Urban zones H5.2 3.1 Residential zones
Amend Rule 3 Rear sites, to read: "3. Rear Sites a. On a site greater than 1ha only 30 percent
of the total number of lots proposed may be rear sites. Except where there is not enough
space for a public road then rear sites can be 100 percent with no limit on length or number".
6347-1 Murdoch Dryden murdoch@drydens.co.nz Zoning Central
Amend the mooring zone boundary for Panmure South A and B on the Tamaki River. See
page 3/3 of submission for map.
6348-1 Sean Opie seankaum@gmail.com Mana Whenua General provisions
assessment Remove cultural impact assessments.
6348-2 Sean Opie seankaum@gmail.com Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula K5.11 Precinct rules Amend height restrictions from 14.5 or 4 storeys to 8m or 2 storeys.
6348-3 Sean Opie seankaum@gmail.com Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula K5.11 Precinct rules Combine Mixed Housing Suburban and Single House, with a 2 storey limit.
6348-4 Sean Opie seankaum@gmail.com Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula K5.11 Precinct rules Adopt a building length rule for developments in the sub-districts.
6348-5 Sean Opie seankaum@gmail.com Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula K5.11 Precinct rules
Adopt a rule requiring the completion of infrastructure before development can proceed within
the precinct.
6348-6 Sean Opie seankaum@gmail.com Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula K5.11 Precinct rules Remove provision for special housing areas within the precinct.
6348-7 Sean Opie seankaum@gmail.com Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula K5.11 Precinct rules Amend the rules to require full public notification for any developments.
6349-1 Galatea Trustee Limited catheriner@barker.co.nz Residential zones Residential
policies
Retain the provisions in the PAUP that seek to strike a balance between allowing additions
and alterations to housing in Herne Bay and maintaining the special character of its housing.
6349-2 Galatea Trustee Limited catheriner@barker.co.nz Special Character
& C J3.3.1-7 Rules
Retain a maximum height of between 8m and 10m as a Restricted Discretionary activity in the
Isthmus B2 overlay.
& C J3.3.1-7 Rules
Amend Development Control 3.2.4 (4) to read as follows: 'It is a restricted discretionary
activity to infringe this rule. An application to infringe this rule will not be subject to public
notification. However, the normal tests for limited notifcation under section 95B of the RMA
will apply'.
& C J3.3.1-7 Rules
Amend Assessment criteria 5.2(4)- Restricted discretionary activities by adding the following:
'Whether the Unitary Plan's bulk and location controls prevent the achievement of an
architectural form or scale which might otherwise be appropriate to the locality, or whether
some relaxation of such controls will enable development of an appropriate form and
character such as enabling pitched rooflines while achieving a quality living environment'.
& C J3.3.1-7 Rules
Amend Assessment- Development Control Infringements by adding an additional Matter of
Discretion to read: '3. Building Height The relevant matters of discretion in clause J3.3.5.1 for
the Special Character Residential [Isthmus] A, B and C overlay apply'.
& C J3.3.1-7 Rules
Amend Assessment- Development control infringements by adding an additional Matter of
discretion to read: '4. Height in relation to boundary Effects of additional building scale on
neighbouring sites (sunlight access, dominance, visual amenity).
& C J3.3.1-7 Rules
Amend Assessment- Development control infringements by adding a further Assessment
criteria to read: '3. Building Height a. The relevant assessment criteria in clause J3.3.5.2 for
external additions and alterations, or for new buildings, in the Special Character Residential
[Isthmus] A, B and C apply.'
234/1145
Sub#/
& C J3.3.1-7 Rules
Amend Assessment- Development control infringements by adding a further Assessment
criteria to read: '4. Height in relation to boundary a. Infringing of the control should not result in
the building unreasonably dominating or shading the outdoor living space or windows to
habitable rooms of adjoining dwellings. b. The building should be designed to minimise
dominance, over-shadowing, or reduced access to sunlight of the adjoining dwellings and
their outdoor living spaces. Methods to achieve this include providing variations in building
heights, building setbacks, or breaks in building massing'.
6350-1
Linda M and Stewart D Sloane
and Lee A Cochrane dan@madsen-lawrie.co.nz Precincts - South Pukekohe Hill Remove Pukekohe Hill Sub-Precinct B from 63 Anzac Road, Pukekohe.
6350-2
and Lee A Cochrane dan@madsen-lawrie.co.nz Zoning South Rezone 63 Anzac Road, Pukekohe to Single House.
6350-3
and Lee A Cochrane dan@madsen-lawrie.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - Urban zones H5.2 3.1 Residential zones
Amend Rule 3 Rear sites to read: "3. Rear Sites a. On a site greater than 1ha only 30 percent
of the total number of lots proposed may be rear sites. Except where there is not enough
space for a public road then rear sites can be 100 percent with no limit on length or number".
6351-1 Malcolm Woolmore juderon@gmail.com Precincts - West Birdwood
Amend the Birdwood Precinct Plan to provide for two additional lots (total of five lots) at 93
Sunnyvale Road, Massey.
Amend rule K7.4.2 'Subdivision controls' to provide for further subdivision of properties where
geotechnical assessment can demonstrate the establishment of safe building sites and
associated access and stormwater mitigation in accordance with the Countryside and
Foothills Stormwater Management Code of Practice.
Amend the assessment criteria for subdivision in K7.4.3 'Assessment - Subdivision' [relief not
specified].
6352-1 Rhys Williams rhyswilliams.nz@gmail.com Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
Retain the approach whereby the zones in which minimum parking requirements apply are
reduced.
6352-2 Rhys Williams rhyswilliams.nz@gmail.com Zoning Central
Rezone the Grey Lynn area, in particular along Great North Road and Richmond Road, to
provide more of the Terrace Housing and Apartment Building zone.
Rezone properties along the Balmoral, New North, Sandringham, Dominion, Mt Eden and Mt
Albert Road corridors to provide for more intensification.
6352-4 Rhys Williams rhyswilliams.nz@gmail.com Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
Amend provisions so that there are no minimum parking standards for the Mixed Housing
Urban or Mixed Housing Suburban zones.
Amend zonings so that designated intensification areas are closer aligned to land values, with
particular reference to central areas.
6353-1
The A W McGough Family
Trust elan@xtra.co.nz Precincts - South Pukekohe Hill
Remove the legacy ranklin Council Open Landscape Value overlays from the area bounded
by Anzac Road, Jellicoe Road, Calcutta Road and north to Flynn Road which were inherited
from the Pukehohe North Hill Structure Plan.
6353-2
Trust elan@xtra.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - general
and policies
Allow subdivision of existing titles in accordance with the normal provisions of the Unitary Plan
and remove any requirements for approved framework plans.
6353-3
Trust elan@xtra.co.nz Zoning South
Rezone the area of land bounded by Anzac Road, Jellicoe Road, Calcutta Road and north to
Flynn Road to Single house with an average lot size of 1000m
2
.
6354-1
North Harbour Business
Association janine.brinsdon@nhba.org.nz Zoning North and Islands
Rezone the land located within the North Harbour Business Improvement District, refer to map
page 12/12, identified as Light Industry to General Business.
6354-2
Association janine.brinsdon@nhba.org.nz Precincts - North Albany 2
Delete the Albany 2 Precinct, which provides for additional office activity above the permitted
standard of the Light Industry.
6354-3
Association janine.brinsdon@nhba.org.nz Zoning North and Islands
Rezone the areas which contain commercial/residential activities including Arrenway Drive,
Saturn Place, William Pickering Drive, Lovell Court, Airborne Road, Rosedale [infer, from
Light Industry] to Mixed Use.
6354-4
Association janine.brinsdon@nhba.org.nz
Centre) Business
& Bus. Park zones
Amend the Activity Table, to change the activity status of Community facilities [from permitted]
to discretionary in the General Business zone.
6354-5
Centre) Business
& Bus. Park zones
Amend the Activity Table, to change the activity status of Education facilities (up to secondary
school) [from permitted] to discretionary in the General Business zone.
6354-6
Centre) Business
& Bus. Park zones
Amend the Activity Table, to change the activity status of Entertainment facilities [from
permitted] to discretionary in the General Business zone.
6354-7
Association janine.brinsdon@nhba.org.nz Definitions Existing
Amend the definition of 'Education facilities' to include tertiary education and training
organisations.
6354-8
Centre)
desc, obs & pols
Amend the Unitary Plan to recognise a preference to cluster like business operations to make
the best use of roading access and parking facilities within the zone.
6354-9
Association janine.brinsdon@nhba.org.nz RPS Issues
growth
Retain the PAUP's 30 year - medium term view, or extend further and combine with other key
regional planning documents, refer submission page 8/12.
235/1145
Sub#/
6354-10
Association janine.brinsdon@nhba.org.nz General Chapter A Introduction
Plan
Retain the consolidation and simplification of land zonings and activity controls, refer
submission page 8/12.
6354-11
Centre) Business
Retain the areas of General Business, Light and Heavy Industry zones and recognise the
need to reserve future development areas and brownfields for this type of activity, refer
6354-12
Association janine.brinsdon@nhba.org.nz RPS Urban growth
Retain the provisions that seek to intensify urban activity and focus development, protecting
the rural and coastal environment, refer submission page 9/12.
6354-13
Association janine.brinsdon@nhba.org.nz Air Quality
and policies
Retain provisions about [infer, manage,] air quality sensitive land uses, refer submission page
9/12.
6354-14
Association janine.brinsdon@nhba.org.nz Sustainable Development C7.7/H6.4 Sustainable design
Retain provisions about Green Star building ratings, appropriate to building type and scale,
refer submission page 9/12.
6354-15
Centre) Business
Park zones
Retain building height controls, [infer, Rule 4.2 Building height, being 16.5 metres and 4
storeys] in the General Business zone, refer submission page 9/12.
6354-16
Centre) Business
zones
Retain building height controls, [infer, Rule 5.1 Building height, being 20 metres] in the Light
Industry zone, refer submission page 9/12.
6354-17
Centre) Business
zones
Retain building height controls, [infer, Rule 5.1 Building height, being 20 metres] in the Heavy
6354-18
Association janine.brinsdon@nhba.org.nz Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
Retain minimum car parking provisions, [infer, Rule 3.2 Number of parking and loading space,
various standards related to particular activities] in the General Business zone, refer
6354-19
requirements
various standards related to particular activities] in the Light Industry zone, refer submission
page 9/12.
6354-20
requirements
various standards related to particular activities] in the Heavy Industry zone, refer submission
page 9/12.
6354-21
Association janine.brinsdon@nhba.org.nz Mana Whenua General provisions
assessment Clarify how the provisions related to Mana Whenua will operate, refer submission page 9/12.
6354-22
Association janine.brinsdon@nhba.org.nz General Miscellaneous Consultation and engagement
Provide ongoing policy and executive support to business improvement districts, refer
6354-23
Association janine.brinsdon@nhba.org.nz General Noise and vibration
and policies
Retain provisions which protect continuous 5+ days a week business operations in the
General Business zone, refer submission page 9/12.
6354-24
and policies
Retain provisions which protect continuous 5+ days a week business operations in the Light
6354-25
and policies
Retain provisions which protect continuous 5+ days a week business operations in the Heavy
6354-26
Association janine.brinsdon@nhba.org.nz RPS
Recognise the need to focus on more efficient private and public transport access to both
commercial and private users, [refer submission page 9/12].
6354-27
Association janine.brinsdon@nhba.org.nz Airport Airport Zone
Retain the potential for a regional commercial airport at Whenuapai, refer submission page
10/12.
6354-28
Centre) Business
Encourage building designs that create multi-level commercial operations, refer submission
page 10/12.
6354-29
Association janine.brinsdon@nhba.org.nz Sustainable Development C7.7/H6.4 Sustainable design
Amend the provisions to allow the use of the NABERS building energy efficiency rating tool or
national equivalent in addition to the Green Star building design ratings of 4, for new buildings
over 5000m2 refer submission page 10/12.
6354-30
Association janine.brinsdon@nhba.org.nz General Miscellaneous Other
Encourage economic development through local investment in business infrastructure,
creating ongoing demand for local employment and minimising the need to commute, refer
6354-31
Association janine.brinsdon@nhba.org.nz General Miscellaneous
Operational/
Encourage [infer, greater] clarity across Auckland's transport planning and navigation, refer
6354-32
Operational/
Provide additional infrastructure and capacity improvements including [infer, the use of]
private/public partnerships [infer, to pay] for - roading and public transport facilities, refer
6354-33
Operational/
Encourage the further development and integration of the Northern busway, extending it to the
west to State Highway 18/16, to and from western Auckland and the Central Business District,
refer submission page 10/12.
6354-34
Operational/
Encourage integrated transport solutions, and the implementation of combined pedestrian/
cycleway space adjacent to roadways, refer submission page 10/12.
236/1145
Sub#/
6355-1 Rolf Masfen Trust michael@campbellbrown.co.nz
Centre) Business
& Bus. Park zones Allow retail activities up to 600m
2
per tenancy in the Mixed Use zone as a permitted activity.
Centre) Business
Park zones
Increase the maximum height for 16 York Street, Parnell, and the surrounding Mixed Use
zoned properties to 24.5m.
Centre) Business
Park zones Delete Rule 4.8 'Minimum floor to floor/ceiling height'.
6355-4 Rolf Masfen Trust michael@campbellbrown.co.nz Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
Amend Rule 3.2 'Number of parking and loading spaces' to provide 'flexibility to provide
additional onsite parking if the demand arises'.
6355-5 Rolf Masfen Trust michael@campbellbrown.co.nz Sustainable Development C7.7/H6.4 Sustainable design Delete Rule 2.2 'Offices'.
control
Building demolition control J.3.6 Rules and mapping Remove overlay from 16 York Street, Parnell.
6355-7 Rolf Masfen Trust michael@campbellbrown.co.nz Designations Auckland Transport
Street Delete this designation.
6355-8 Rolf Masfen Trust michael@campbellbrown.co.nz Zoning Central Retain the Mixed Use zoning for 22 George [Terrace] and 23 Church Street, Onehunga.
(ONF) Rules
Features Overlay
Delete ID 42, 'Helena Rubinstein and Ratcliffe lava caves', from 22 George [Terrace] and 23
Church Street, Onehunga.
Centre) Business
& Bus. Park zones Delete the gross floor area restriction for offices in the Mixed Use zone.
6355-11 Rolf Masfen Trust michael@campbellbrown.co.nz Built Environment (Overlays)
Height Control
Add the Additional Zone Height Control overlay to 22 George [Terrace] and 23 Church Street,
Onehunga and the surrounding Mixed Use area to increase the maximum building heights in
this area to 24.5m.
6355-12 Rolf Masfen Trust michael@campbellbrown.co.nz Natural Hazards and Flooding Natural Hazards Coastal inundation - maps only Delete the Coastal Inundation overlay and associated provisions.
6356-1 Body Corporate 197887 david.haines@hainesplanning.co.nz General Chapter A Introduction A3 Strategic Framework
4/31].
6356-2 Body Corporate 197887 david.haines@hainesplanning.co.nz General
6356-3 Body Corporate 197887 david.haines@hainesplanning.co.nz Definitions Existing Clarify the 'Floodplain' definition that relies on the Flood Hazards non-statutory layer.
GIS viewer
layer.
6356-10 Body Corporate 197887 david.haines@hainesplanning.co.nz RPS Urban growth
Amend Objective 2 and Objective 4 by combining them, as stated in the submission [refer
page 6/31].
environment
submission.
effect to the policy and rezone appropriately.
any one time.'
6356-15 Body Corporate 197887 david.haines@hainesplanning.co.nz RPS
Transport
B3.1 Commercial and
industrial growth
6356-16 Body Corporate 197887 david.haines@hainesplanning.co.nz RPS
Transport
B3.1 Commercial and
industrial growth
237/1145
Sub#/
6356-17 Body Corporate 197887 david.haines@hainesplanning.co.nz Natural Hazards and Flooding Flooding
and policies
Amend the Background to clarify the the non-statutory Flood Hazards layer containing
overlays for Flood Sensitive Area, Flood Prone Area, Flood Plains, as stated in the
submission refer page 7/31
GIS viewer
Review the accuracy of the overland flow path information and make it available in the Unitary
Plan maps.
6356-22 Body Corporate 197887 david.haines@hainesplanning.co.nz Water
policies
management
Amend Policy 10(c) to reconsider the thresholds for triggering stormwater consent
applications.
6356-23 Body Corporate 197887 david.haines@hainesplanning.co.nz Water
policies
Objectives Amend the stormwater management rules to have realistic and achievable measures.
6356-24 Body Corporate 197887 david.haines@hainesplanning.co.nz Sustainable Development C7.7/H6.4 Sustainable design
Amend Objective 1 as follows: 'Buildings are designed to minimise adverse environmental
environments.
6356-25 Body Corporate 197887 david.haines@hainesplanning.co.nz Sustainable Development C7.7/H6.4 Sustainable design
Amend Policy 2 as follows: 'Encourage Require medium to large-scale residential
development to be designed to meet sustainable building standards.'
6356-26 Body Corporate 197887 david.haines@hainesplanning.co.nz Sustainable Development C7.7/H6.4 Sustainable design Delete the blanket requirement about requiring sustainable building standards.
6356-27 Body Corporate 197887 david.haines@hainesplanning.co.nz
Centre) Business
Amend Objective 3 as adding a further clause as follows: 'Business activity is distributed in
locations, including out-of-centre locations, and is of a scale and form that:...(d) recognises
existing infrastructure and investment'.
Centre) Business
10/31].
Centre) Business
General objectives and policies Delete Policy 4 about equal physical access.
Centre) Business
General objectives and policies Delete Policy 6 about building adaptability.
Centre) Business
such a manner as to avoid adverse impact on pedestrian amenity and the streetscape.'
Centre) Business
General objectives and policies Delete Policy 11 about wind glare and shading effects.
Centre)
obs & pols
Retain the Description, third paragraph, as follows: 'The zone does not specifically require a
mix of uses on individual sites or within areas,...'
Centre)
obs & pols
Amend the Description, fifth paragraph, as follows: 'New development within the zone
requires resource consent in order to ensure that it is designed to a high standard which
enhances the quality of streets within the area and public open spaces.'
Centre)
obs & pols
Amend Policy 4, as follows: 'Encourage Require development to achieve a high standard of
design.'
Centre)
desc, obs & pols
Amend the Description to recognise some additional retail activities, especially food based, as
permitted activities in the zone, as stated in the submission [refer page 13/31].
Centre)
desc, obs & pols
Amend the Description, third paragraph, as follows: '..expected to contribute to an active
street edge, while recognising the functional requirements of the activities.'
Centre)
desc, obs & pols
Amend Objective 2 as follows: 'Additional employment opportunities exist in a limited number
of areas which are located along identified growth corridors or close to City Centre,
Metropolitan and Town Centre zones, while ensuring activities within the zone do not detract
from the vitality and viability of these centres .'
Centre)
desc, obs & pols Delete Policy 4 about the location of small scale retail activities.
Centre)
desc, obs & pols
Amend Policy 5 as follows: 'Enable light industrial activities to locate within the zone
but avoid discourage activities which have objectionable odour, dust or noise emissions that
cannot be remedied or mitigated.'
Centre)
desc, obs & pols
Amend Policy 6, as follows: 'Manage compatibility issues of activities within and between
consent.'
238/1145
Sub#/
Centre)
desc, obs & pols
6356-43 Body Corporate 197887 david.haines@hainesplanning.co.nz General Chapter G General provisions G2.4 Notification
6356-44 Body Corporate 197887 david.haines@hainesplanning.co.nz General Chapter G General provisions G2.4 Notification Delete all notification provisions that set a more stringent requirement than the RMA.
6356-45 Body Corporate 197887 david.haines@hainesplanning.co.nz General Chapter G General provisions
statements
statements
statements
6356-48 Body Corporate 197887 david.haines@hainesplanning.co.nz Transport Auckland -wide
requirements Delete Rule 3.1(1) Traffic Generation, Table 1, total 'Retail' threshold of 500m
2
.
requirements
Amend Rule 3.1(1), so that it does not apply in the General Business and Mixed Use zone, as
stated in the submission [refer page 17/31].
requirements
Retain Rule 3.2(1) Parking, Table 3, about the number of parking and loading spaces [refer
also to point number 51].
requirements
Amend Rule 3.2(1) Parking, Table 3 about the number of parking and loading spaces, to
increase maximums as a result of further evidence [refer also to point number 50].
requirements
45m
2
GFA.
requirements
Amend Rule 3.2(2), Table 5 to require retail activities greater than 3000m
2
to provide cycle
parking rate of 1 per 1000m
2
for visitors and 1 per 800m
2
for staff (secure).
6356-54 Body Corporate 197887 david.haines@hainesplanning.co.nz Sustainable Development C7.7/H6.4 Sustainable design Delete the rules that require sustainable development.
6356-55 Body Corporate 197887 david.haines@hainesplanning.co.nz Earthworks H4.2.1.1 Activity table - Zones
Amend the 'rp/dp' [second] activity table, under the sub heading General earthworks not
expressly either permitted or requiring resource consent above in this table, to provide for
earthworks in business and residential zones up to 5000m
2
and 5000m
3
as permitted.
6356-56 Body Corporate 197887 david.haines@hainesplanning.co.nz Earthworks
Overlays
Amend 1.2 Overlays Activity Table, to describe the column abbreviations in Part 4 as well as
above the activity table and repeat the [heading rows across page breaks].
6356-57 Body Corporate 197887 david.haines@hainesplanning.co.nz Natural Hazards and Flooding Flooding H4.12 Rules
6356-58 Body Corporate 197887 david.haines@hainesplanning.co.nz Natural Hazards and Flooding Flooding H4.12 Rules
Amend the activity table under the sub heading Activities within overland flow paths, by
changing the activity status of 'Any buildings or structures, including retaining walls but
excluding permitted fences) located within or over an overland flow path' from discretionary to
Centre) Business
& Bus. Park zones Retain the activity status of 'Food and Beverage' in the General Business zone as permitted.
Centre) Business
& Bus. Park zones Retain the activity status of 'Commercial services' in the General Business zone as permitted.
Centre) Business
& Bus. Park zones
Retain the activity status of 'Internal alterations to buildings' in the General Business zone as
permitted.
Centre) Business
& Bus. Park zones
Retain the activity status of 'Retail up to 200m
2
' in the General Business zone as
discretionary.
Centre) Business
& Bus. Park zones
discretionary.
239/1145
Sub#/
Centre) Business
& Bus. Park zones
Retain the activity status of 'Offices up to 500m2 GFA per site' in the General Business zone
as permitted.
Centre) Business
& Bus. Park zones
Amend the activity status of 'Offices greater than 500m2 GFA per site' in the General
Business zone from discretionary to restricted discretionary.
Centre) Business
& Bus. Park zones
Amend the activity status of 'Retail greater than 450m2' in the General Business zone from
restricted discretionary to permitted.
Centre) Business
Special information
requirements
Delete the 6.1(2) Matters of discretion and 6.2(2) Assessment Criteria so far as they relate to
the General Business zone.
Centre) Business
& Bus. Park zones
Amend activity class as follows: 'Alterations to building facades that are less than: 1 50 per
cent of its total surface area, or 50015m whichever is the greater lesser - permitted.'
Centre) Business
& Bus. Park zones
Amend the activity class as follows: 'Additions to buildings that are less than: 1 50per cent of
the existing GFA of the building, or 2 500m whichever is the lesser greater - permitted.'
Centre) Business
& Bus. Park zones
discretionary to permitted in centres, Mixed Use, General Business, Business Park zones.
Centre) Business
& Bus. Park zones Retain the activity status of 'Commercial services' in the Mixed Use zone as permitted.
Centre) Business
& Bus. Park zones Retain the activity status of 'Drive Through facilities' in the Mixed Use zone as permitted.
Centre) Business
& Bus. Park zones Retain the activity status of 'entertainment facilities' in the Mixed Use zone as permitted.
Centre) Business
& Bus. Park zones Retain the activity status of 'Food and Beverage facilities' in the Mixed Use zone as permitted.
Centre) Business
& Bus. Park zones Retain the activity status of 'Retail up to 200m
2
per site' in the Mixed Use zone as permitted.
Centre) Business
& Bus. Park zones Retain the activity status of 'education facilities' in the Mixed Use zone as permitted.
Centre) Business
& Bus. Park zones Retain the activity status of 'care centres' in the Mixed Use zone as permitted.
Centre) Business
& Bus. Park zones Retain the activity status of 'health care facilities' in the Mixed Use zone as permitted.
Centre) Business
& Bus. Park zones Retain the activity status of 'warehousing and storage' in the Mixed Use zone as permitted.
Centre) Business
& Bus. Park zones
Retain the activity status of 'internal alterations to buildings' in the Mixed Use zone as
permitted.
Centre) Business
& Bus. Park zones
Amend the activity table to change the activity status of 'Retail up to 450m
2
per site' from
Centre) Business
Amend the activity table to ensure there is no conflict between activity classifications and
definitions.
Centre) Business
Park zones Delete Rule 4.1(1) Development control infringements.
Centre) Business
Park zones
metres only.
240/1145
Sub#/
Centre) Business
Park zones Retain Rule 4.2 Building height for the Mixed Use zone being 16.5m.
Centre) Business
Park zones Retain Rule 4.2 Building height for the General Business zone being 16.5m.
Centre) Business
Park zones [Amend] Rule 4.2 Building height for the Mixed Use zone to be increased.
Centre) Business
Park zones [Amend] Rule 4.2 Building height for the General Business zone to be increased.
Centre) Business
Park zones
zone.
Centre) Business
Park zones Amend Rule 4.7 Building Entrances so it does not apply in the General Business zone.
Centre) Business
Centre) Business
Park zones Amend Rule 4.9(c) Glazing so it does not apply in the General Business zone.
Centre) Business
Special information
requirements
Delete Rule 10 Special Information requirements, about the requirement of design
statements.
Centre) Business
Park zones Delete Rule 4.12 Ground floor at street frontage level about the location of building entrances.
Centre) Business
Park zones
Centre) Business
Park zones
Centre) Business
Park zones
Business Park zone: 80 per cent.'
Centre) Business
Special information
requirements
6356-
100 Body Corporate 197887 david.haines@hainesplanning.co.nz
Centre) Business
Special information
requirements
number 99].
6356-
101 Body Corporate 197887 david.haines@hainesplanning.co.nz Definitions Existing Retain the definition of 'Large format retail'.
6356-
102 Body Corporate 197887 david.haines@hainesplanning.co.nz Zoning Central
Rezone the [submitter's] site [20 - 54 Mount Wellington Highway, Mt Wellington] from General
Business to Mixed Use.
6357-1 Sally Moran
49 Girven Road, Arataki, Tauranga
3116 RPS Mana Whenua B5 Strategic Delete all those parts of the plan relating to powers given to iwi authorities.
6358-1 Grant McInman mcinman@orcon.net.nz Zoning North and Islands
Rezone the Hauraki area including Jutland Road, Stone Street and Bayview Road from Mixed
Housing Urban to Mixed Housing Suburban.
6359-1 Barbel Clearkin barbelclearkin@yahoo.com.au Mana Whenua
Whenua
Remove any Mori sites [Mana Whenua Overlay] including shell middens from 337c Clarks
Beach Road, Waiau Pa.
6360-1 Minister of Conservation cstaite@doc.govt.nz Definitions New
Add a definition of Biodiversity offsetting which is consistent with the NZ Biodiversity
Offsetting Programme and guidance and with the Business and Biodiversity Offsets
programme [page 3/75 in vol. 3].
6360-2 Minister of Conservation cstaite@doc.govt.nz RPS
Add policies which are consistent with the NZ Biodiversity Offsetting Programme and
guidance and with the Business and Biodiversity Offsets Programme [page 3/75 in vol. 3] and
seeks to achieve no net loss and preferably a net gain.
Add cross references with policies throughout the PAUP where biodiversity offsetting is
addressed, for example, 1B4.3.4, B6 2;C1.1; C5.12; C5.14).
241/1145
Sub#/
6360-4 Minister of Conservation cstaite@doc.govt.nz General Chapter A Introduction
DP provisions
Incorporate best practice cross referencing to assist in the identification of Regional Coastal
Plan provisions and how those provisions relate to other relevant parts of the plan.
6360-5 Minister of Conservation cstaite@doc.govt.nz General Chapter A Introduction A1 Background
Add an introductory statement and explanation outlining the Hauraki Marine Spatial Planning
process including timeframes, how the processes would inform the PAUP and how the
methods included in the plan covering marine spatial planning will be achieved [1.5 Our rural
and coastal environment].
6360-6 Minister of Conservation cstaite@doc.govt.nz RPS Coastal
Gulf
Outline marine spatial planning and Hauraki Marine Spatial planning process methods in
more detail, including timeframes and how Council plans to achieve the method specified.
6360-7 Minister of Conservation cstaite@doc.govt.nz
Use consistent terminology when referring to marine spatial planning or Hauraki marine
spatial planning.
DP provisions
Identify clearly all parts of the Regional Coastal Plan within the PAUP, including controls,
assessment criteria, information requirements, definitions, environmental results anticipated,
appendices and all other applicable provisions.
DP provisions
Identify the Regional Policy Statement as being entirely applicable to the Regional Coastal
Plan.
DP provisions
Clarify and explain the interrelationship and dual use between the Regional Policy Statement
objectives and policies and the Regional Coastal Plan, District Plan and Regional Plan.
6360-11 Minister of Conservation cstaite@doc.govt.nz RPS Issues
heritage Retain inclusion of indigenous biodiversity as a regional issue.
6360-12 Minister of Conservation cstaite@doc.govt.nz RPS Urban growth
land for urban development Retain policy 3(a).
land for urban development Retain policy 4(c)(iv).
and villages Retain policy 1(d)(g)(k).
recreation facilities Retain objective 2.
Amend objective 4 as follows: 4. Public access to and along Aucklands coastal marine area,
including the coastline, foreshore, beaches, and lakes and rivers and special natural areas is
maintained and enhanced.
recreation facilities Retain policy 7.
Amend policy 14 as follows: 14. Enable public access to, and along, the margins of lakes,
rivers and streams and the coastal marine area, unless restricting access is necessary to: ...
Transport
and energy
Amend policy 8(d) as follows: d.whether there are any reasonably practicable alternative
locations, routes or designs, which would avoid or reduce any adverse effects
Transport
and energy
Delete policy 8(f)(vi) as follows: vi.the extent to which the adverse effects can be avoided,
remedied or mitigated and make the following a standalone assessment criteria: x. the ability
of the significant infrastructure to avoid adverse effects, and where there adverse effects
cannot be practicably avoided, then the ability to appropriately remedy or mitigate adverse
effects, including through the use of biodiversity offsets.
Transport B3.3 Transport Retain Objective 3.
Add a policy setting out how transport infrastructure will address adverse ecological effects in
a manner consistent with Policy 8 in section B3.2.
Cross reference this section with B3.2 Policy 8 to ensure that transport infrastructure is
managed consistently with other strategic infrastructure.
character and natural heritage B4.3 Natural heritage Retain introduction.
coastal environment Retain Introduction.
coastal environment
Add new objective 1 as follows: The natural character of Auckland's coastal environment is
preserved and protected from inappropriate subdivision, use and development.
242/1145
Sub#/
coastal environment
Amend objective 2 as follows: The natural character of areas with high or outstanding natural
character value is preserved, and subdivision use and development is managed to maintain
their high levels of naturalness. The contribution of high and outstanding natural character
areas to preserving the natural character of the Auckland region is recognised and provided
for, and the adverse effects of activities on outstanding areas are avoided.
coastal environment
Amend objective 3 by rewording objective 1 as follows: Subdivision, use and development in
the coastal environment is designed and located to avoid significant adverse effects on
natural character in all other areas, and to ensure that retain the particular elements, patterns,
process or features that significantly contribute to these areas are retained the natural
character of an area .
coastal environment Retain and renumber objective 3 and objective 4.
coastal environment
Amend policy 1 to address areas not identified as higher or outstanding and other minor
amendments. See submission for amendments [page 16/75].
coastal environment Retain policy 2.
coastal environment
Amend policy 3 as follows: Areas of outstanding and high natural character are identified
using criteria attributes in Policy 13(2) of the NZCPS.
coastal environment
Amend policy 4 as follows: 4.Protect the physical, and visual integrity and the natural, and
wilderness values of ONC/HNC areas of the coastal environment by: ... d.avoiding the effects
of activities that individually or cumulatively detract physically or visually from the natural
character values of the area
coastal environment Delete policy 5.
coastal environment
Retain intent but amend policies 6 and 7 by combining as follows: 6.Provide for the use of
transferable development rights to avoid latent potential for inappropriate development in
areas identified as having outstanding natural character value. provided that 7.Exclude ONC
areas are excluded from being recipient areas for transferable development rights.
coastal environment
Amend policy 8 as follows: 8.Avoid subdivision, use and development in areas identified as
having ONC value, other than: a.works associated with maintaining or enhancing natural
character values b.existing uses and/or where an existing use right applies c.small-scale
buildings.
coastal environment Retain policy 10 and include point as an additional criterion within policy 11.
coastal environment
Amend 4.3.1 Methods - Regulatory as follows: Regulatory Unitary Plan: - Auckland Regional
Policy Statement objectives and policies - Auckland-wide vegetation management objectives,
policies and rules - Mapping of outstanding and high natural character areas in the coastal
environment excluding some marine areas. Within 1 year of this Plan becoming operative
complete the mapping of the natural character values for the remaining marine areas and
notify a plan change to update the PAUP Schedule 6.2 and the associated maps- Overlays
for mapped areas objectives, policies and rules applying to zones on land and in the CMA.
coastal environment Retain 4.3.1 Methods - Non-Regulatory.
coastal environment
Amend explanation and reasons to outline a process of natural character identification
assessment. See submission for amendments [page 24/75].
features Retain objective 1.
features Retain policy 1.
243/1145
Sub#/
character and natural heritage B4.3.3 Trees and vegetation Retain objective 2.
character and natural heritage B4.3.3 Trees and vegetation Add cross reference to B4.3.4 in policy 1(a)(iii).
character and natural heritage B4.3.3 Trees and vegetation Add cross reference to B4.3.4 in policy 3.
character and natural heritage B4.3.4 Biodiversity Retain objective 1.
character and natural heritage B4.3.4 Biodiversity Amend policy 1 to be consistent with recognised best practice.
Amend policy 6 to delete the reference to 'significant' parts of SEA areas. See submission for
amendments [page 27/75].
character and natural heritage B4.3.4 Biodiversity Retain policy 7.
Amend policy 8 as follows: 8.Adverse effects on indigenous biodiversity to be avoided,
remedied, mitigated or offset in accordance with Policies 6 and 7 may include, but are not
limited to: ... f.loss or degradation of originally rare ecosystems including wetlands, dune
systems, lava forests, coastal forests... h.significant loss of ecosystem services
... k.significant loss of, or damage to, ecological mosaics, sequences, processes, or integrity
character and natural heritage B4.3.4 Biodiversity Cross reference policy 13 with policies 6 and 8.
Amend policy heading as follows: Protecting significant indigenous biodiversity in marine
areas the coastal environment
Amend policy 14 by splitting it into two policies, addressing respectively the requirements of
NZCPS 2010 Policy 11(1) and (b) in order to give effect to the NZCPS 2010 in relation to
indigenous biodiversity in the coastal environment.
character and natural heritage B4.3.4 Biodiversity Retain 14(c) as a significant matter for the region.
character and natural heritage B4.3.4 Biodiversity Retain policies 15(a) and (c).
6360-78 Minister of Conservation cstaite@doc.govt.nz RPS Natural resources B6.2 Minerals Retain policy 3.
244/1145
Sub#/
6360-79 Minister of Conservation cstaite@doc.govt.nz RPS Natural resources B6.2 Minerals
Amend policy 4 as follows: ... c. the scale of significant physical and visual adverse effects on
ONCs, ONLs or SEAs and the extent to which these can be avoided, remedied or mitigated ...
6360-80 Minister of Conservation cstaite@doc.govt.nz RPS Natural resources
B6.3 Freshwater and
Geothermal Water Retain introduction.
B6.3 Freshwater and
Geothermal Water Retain objective 1.
B6.3 Freshwater and
B6.3 Freshwater and
B6.3 Freshwater and
B6.3 Freshwater and
Geothermal Water Retain policy 3.
B6.3 Freshwater and
Geothermal Water
Amend policy 6 as follows: 6. Manage the quantity of water taken from freshwater systems by:
a. avoiding further over allocation of water and reducing any allocation
6360-87 Minister of Conservation cstaite@doc.govt.nz RPS Natural resources B6.7 Natural hazards Amend introduction to list coastal erosion as a natural hazard.
6360-88 Minister of Conservation cstaite@doc.govt.nz Definitions Existing Amend definition of risk [natural hazard risk, see NZCPS 2010 and AS/NZS IS0].
6360-89 Minister of Conservation cstaite@doc.govt.nz RPS Natural resources B6.7 Natural hazards
Amend introduction as follows: Existing land use ... the degree to which natural hazardsand
natural hazard risks are avoided, mitigated or accepted during development. Predicted
Projected changes in climate could have an effect on the environmental processes that cause
natural hazard events.
Amend objective 1 as follows: Reduce the risk of social, environmental and economic harm to
the Auckland region to people, property and infrastructure from natural hazards while
minimising any adverse effects on the environment .
Amend policy 3 as follows: 3. Assess the hazard risks from subdivision, use and of
development locating in areas subject to natural hazards based on the : a. the type and
severity of the hazard events that may potentially occur there b. the vulnerability and
resilience of the subdivision, use and effects of other activities from development to damage
from hazard events c. the risks of harm to people, other property, and the
environment vulnerability of the activity to adverse effects, including safety, resilience to
damage and effects on the environment and human health across a range of timeframes
appropriate to the hazard risk, including at least a 100 year timeframe for flooding and coastal
hazard risks.
Amend policy 4(a) as follows: a. the effects of natural hazards are either uncertain, unknown
or may be little understood, but potentially significant adverse, including the possibility of low
frequency, high magnitude events
environment Retain objective 1.
environment
Amend objective 5 as follows: The risk of subdivision, use and development in the coastal
environment being adversely affected by coastal hazards is minimised not increased.
environment Cross reference to the objectives and policies of B6.3 and B6.7 in policy 1.
environment Retain policy 4.
6360-
100 Minister of Conservation cstaite@doc.govt.nz RPS Coastal
space - coastal environment Retain objective 1.
6360-
space - coastal environment Retain objective 2.
245/1145
Sub#/
6360-
Amend objective 3 as follows: Public access is restricted only where necessary to ensure
health or safety, the efficient and safe operation of activities, or to protect the value of areas
that are sensitive to disturbance.
6360-
space - coastal environment Retain policy 1.
6360-
6360-
6360-
6360-
quality Retain section.
6360-
quality Cross reference provisions relating to exclusion of stock from the RMA to this section.
6360-
Gulf Retain section.
6360-
110 Minister of Conservation cstaite@doc.govt.nz RPS Rural B8.1 Rural activities Retain policy 8.
6360-
111 Minister of Conservation cstaite@doc.govt.nz RPS Rural B8.1 Rural activities Retain policy 9.
6360-
112 Minister of Conservation cstaite@doc.govt.nz Infrastructure
C1.1 Infrastructure
policies
Add a policy that gives clear direction that infrastructure will avoid, remedy or mitigate or
offset adverse effects on SEAs in a manner consistent with the RPS direction.
6360-
113 Minister of Conservation cstaite@doc.govt.nz Infrastructure
C1.1 Infrastructure
policies Cross reference to B3.2.8 and B3.3.3.
6360-
114 Minister of Conservation cstaite@doc.govt.nz Air Quality
and policies Retain policy 14(i).
6360-
115 Minister of Conservation cstaite@doc.govt.nz Earthworks
and policies
Amend Policy 1 to have a consistent policy direction regarding avoidance and minimising
adverse effects on SEAs.
6360-
116 Minister of Conservation cstaite@doc.govt.nz Earthworks
and policies Add cross references between policies.
6360-
117 Minister of Conservation cstaite@doc.govt.nz
SEAs
and policies Retain objective 1.
6360-
SEAs
and policies Retain policy 1.
6360-
SEAs
6360-
SEAs
6360-
SEAs
6360-
SEAs
6360-
SEAs
6360-
SEAs
6360-
125 Minister of Conservation cstaite@doc.govt.nz Natural Hazards and Flooding Natural Hazards
and policies
Amend 'Background' as follows: Auckland is affected by a wide range of natural hazards
including those that occur frequently such as flooding and erosion (coastal and freshwater)
and ...
6360-
and policies Retain objective 1, particularly the phrase 'risks to people, property and the environment'.
6360-
and policies
Amend objective 1 as follows: Development on land subject to natural hazards only occurs
where the long term risks to people, property and the environment are well managed.
6360-
and policies
Amend objective 2 as follows: Natural features and buffers are used in preference to hard
engineering solutions where management of natural hazards is requiredin the short or long
term.
6360-
and policies
Amend objective 3 as follows: Subdivision, use and development does not exacerbate the
long term risks to people, property and the environment from natural hazards or its
their effects, taking into account the effects of climate change.
246/1145
Sub#/
6360-
and policies Delete objective 5.
6360-
and policies
Amend policy 1(c) as follows: c. at an elevation less than 3m above MHWS if the activity is
within 20m of the line of MHWS
6360-
and policies
Amend policy 8 as follows: Require coastal protection works involving the placement of any
material, objects or structures in or on any area located above MHWS to be designed and
located to avoid, remedy or mitigate adverse environmental effects including:
6360-
and policies
Amend policy 2 as follows: Manage For subdivision and development proposals on land that
may be subject to natural hazards by requireing an engineering assessment to confirm
whether the land is or will be subject to erosion, inundation or instability over the next 100
years.
6360-
and policies
Amend policy 3, in particular b, c and e to implement the New Zealand Coastal Policy
Statement, particularly policy 25(a).
6360-
and policies
Amend policy 4(i) as follows: i. the ability to use non structural solutions, such as planting or
the retention of natural landform buffers to avoid, remedy or mitigate the hazard, rather than
hard engineering solutions
6360-
and policies Amend policy 5 as follows: Consider allowing hard engineering coastal protection works...
6360-
and policies
Amend policy 6 as follows: Avoid hard engineering solutions in ONCs, HNCs and SEAs.
Where it is appropriate for hard engineering solutions to be allowed located in coastal areas...
6360-
and policies
Amend policy 7 as follows: Avoid the modification, alteration or removal of sand dunes and
vegetation on sand dunes for development within an area subject to coastal hazards where
that would compromise their function as natural defences or where unless erosion and
adverse effects on wider coastal processes such as sediment budgets have not been are
avoided or mitigated .
6360-
and policies Add cross reference from policy 8 to foreshore protection policies in D5.1.15.
6360-
and policies Amend policy 8 to include 'the line of' MHWS.
6360-
and policies
Amend policy 9 as follows: Require proposals for subdivision and development to subdivide
and develop in natural hazard areas to give effect to coastal and riparian yards for the
relevant zone, precinct or overlay. Where there is conflict between the yards and any land
identified as being subject to natural hazards, the greater distance shall prevail.
6360-
and policies
Amend policy 14 as follows: Require the finished floor levels of: a. new dwellings and
habitable rooms of non-dwellings, and ... c.located in coastal inundation areas to be above the
mapped 1 per cent AEP coastal storm tide event level plus 1m projected (as an allowance
for sea level rise)
6360-
and policies
Amend policy 15 as follows: Avoid subdivision and development in greenfield areas on land
affected by coastal inundation, taking account of projected potential for a sea level rise by 2m
over 100 years.
6360-
144 Minister of Conservation cstaite@doc.govt.nz Water
streams & wetland
C5.14 Background &
Objectives Retain objectives.
6360-
streams & wetland
C5.14 Background &
Objectives
Amend background to include reference to the indigenous biodiversity values and ecosystems
services of rivers, lakes, streams and wetlands in Auckland, and cross reference with policies
on indigenous biodiversity.
6360-
streams & wetland
C5.14 All Policies except 11 -
Stock Access Retain policy 1.
6360-
streams & wetland
6360-
streams & wetland
C5.14 Background &
Objectives
Amend introduction as follows: ... An offset is an action to address any adverse effects of a
development or activity on the environment that cannot be avoided, remedied or mitigated by
the proposal itself, or by conditions on the consent. Therefore offsetting can be used to
protect and conserve environmental values. ... In some circumstances, biodiversity offsetting
will be required where on-site remediation or mitigation is not possible, practicable or
desirable . Offsets will only be considered after avoidance, remediation and mitigation options
have been pursued.
6360-
149 Minister of Conservation cstaite@doc.govt.nz Definitions New
Incorporate biodiversity offset concepts from H 5.14 policy 3 into new definition of biodiversity
offset.
247/1145
Sub#/
6360-
streams & wetland
Stock Access
Reword policies 6 and 7 to ensure avoidance of effects in SEAs and rivers, lakes, streams
and wetlands with significant ecological values. Where effects cannot be avoided, they should
be remedied, mitigated and offset according to national biodiversity offset principles.
6360-
streams & wetland
Stock access policy 11, activity
table and controls H4.13.2.7 Amend policy 11 to include requirements for fencing and riparian setbacks.
6360-
streams & wetland
6360-
streams & wetland
6360-
streams & wetland
Stock Access
Amend policy 8 to ensure inappropriate plant species are not planted, and that planting of
locally sourced native plants appropriate to a site is supported.
6360-
policies
ecosystem guidelines App.5.6 Retain MCI as an indicator or limit of ecological health.
6360-
policies
Objectives
Amend to include reference to the ecosystem values of waterways and the importance of
waterways as habitat for aquatic life, and to improving the ecosystem health of freshwater
systems in urban and rural areas.
6360-
policies
Objectives Retain objective 3.
6360-
Objectives Retain policy 4.
6360-
6360-
6360-
Objectives
Amend policy 17 as follows: f.people and communities. g. known fish spawning sites h.
significant ecological areas and habitats.
6360-
162 Minister of Conservation cstaite@doc.govt.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - general
and policies
Amend objective 6 as follows: Subdivision manages adverse effects The adverse effects of
subdivision are managed in accordance with the objectives and policies relating to landscape
amenity, natural resources, natural hazards or historic heritage.
6360-
and policies
Amend policy 3 as follows: Require subdivisions to be in accord with the natural hazard
objectives and policies in this plan avoid or mitigate natural hazards and provide safe and
stable building platforms and vehicle access.
6360-
6360-
6360-
6360-
6360-
6360-
6360-
and policies Retain policy 38(a) and (d).
6360-
and policies Amend policy 38(e) and (f) by clarifying the limited circumstances.
6360-
the CMA C7.6 Vehicles on beaches Retain section.
6360-
173 Minister of Conservation cstaite@doc.govt.nz Rural Zones
D6. 5 Rural Conservation zone
desc, obs & pols Retain objective 1.
6360-
6360-
248/1145
Sub#/
6360-
6360-
Centre)
desc, obs & pols
Add policy to ensure subdivision, use and development within the heavy industry zone within
or adjacent to significant ecological areas is required to manage adverse effects on its value.
6360-
the CMA General Coastal Marine Zone Introduction
Amend introduction by adding a bullet point to the purpose of the zone as follows: - Avoiding
increasing the risk of social, environmental and economic harm from coastal hazards.
6360-
the CMA
declamation
6360-
the CMA
declamation
6360-
the CMA
declamation
6360-
the CMA
declamation
and policies Amend policy 1 specifically to implement policy 10(1)(b) NZCPS 2010.
6360-
the CMA
declamation
6360-
the CMA
declamation
6360-
the CMA
declamation
6360-
the CMA
declamation
6360-
the CMA
declamation
6360-
SEAs
table - Vegetation
roads
Amend activity table by adding as a permitted activity the following: The maintenance and
replacement of existing tracks and structures on Public Conservation Land to a same or
similar scale as that existing, provided the works are consistent with a conservation
management strategy, a conservation management plan, or a management plan prepared
under the Conservation Act 1987 or any other Act specified in Schedule 1 of that Act.
6360-
Rural Discharges,
Biosolids
Retain the permitted activity status for non-domestic uses, with the default to restricted
discretionary activity excluding urban aerial discharge [in H4.9.1 Activity Table].
6360-
Rural Discharges,
Biosolids
Amend H4.9.2.1 to allow herbicides as a permitted activity approved by the EPA to be
discharged directly to water, provided controls required by the EPA are complied with.
6360-
Rural Discharges,
Biosolids
Amend H4.9.2.1(6) to exclude the control of environmental weeds in non-production areas
from this requirement.
6360-
Rural Discharges,
Biosolids
Replace H4.9.2.2 references to trademarked systems, for example, GROWSAFE and
AIRCARE with 'recognised training program for agrichemicals'.
6360-
Rural Discharges,
Biosolids
Vertebrate Toxic Agents Amend H4.9.2.2 by replacing references to 'accreditation' with 'certification'.
6360-
Rural Discharges,
Biosolids
Amend H4.9.2.2 by clarifying that non-domestic agrichecmical use of agrichemicals that do
not require 'approved handler' certification are not unduly constrained by these controls
resulting in less pest control.
6360-
Rural Discharges,
Biosolids
Amend H4.9.2.2(3)(c) requirement for GROWSAFE certification with the following: c.any
person applying agrichemicals who is not an agrichemical contractor must hold either: i.a
Growsafe Introductory Certificate suitably qualified and trained for the agrichemical/s; or
ii.be under the direct supervision of a person holding either a Growsafe applied certificate
suitably qualified or trained for the agrichemical/s or holds or a registered chemical
applicator's certificate.
6360-
Rural Discharges,
Biosolids
Amend titles of controls for H4.9.2.2 and H4.9.2.3 to relate to non-dispersive and dispersive
respectively.
6360-
Rural Discharges,
Biosolids
Vertebrate Toxic Agents Amend H4.9.2.4 by deleting controls 2 and 3 as they are already required by the HSNO Act.
6360-
Rural Discharges,
Biosolids
Amend H4.9.2.5 by inserting a new control requiring that the application of vertebrate toxic
agents must comply with all HSNO requirements. Upon doing so, remove matters that are
HSNO requirements from the controls. See submission for detail [page 63/75].
249/1145
Sub#/
6360-
Rural Discharges,
Biosolids
Amend H4.9.2.5(1) as follows: 1. Best management practice must be followed to prevent the
discharge of vertebrate toxic agents: a. beyond the boundary of the property operational
area b. within 10m of the bed of a river, lake, or a wetland of more than 1ha.
6360-
Rural Discharges,
Biosolids
Amend H4.9.2.2(3) and H4.9.2.5(4) to refer to an Agricultural Compounds and Veterinary
Medicines controlled substance licence and an agricultural chemical rating for the Civil
Aviation Authority.
6360-
Rural Discharges,
Biosolids
Amend H4.9.2.5 to note that the use of GPS technology is a legal requirement under HSNO
for 1080 aerial application, and positive airflow application, and positive airflow indicators on
boundaries are not current best practice.
6360-
202 Minister of Conservation cstaite@doc.govt.nz Natural Hazards and Flooding Natural Hazards H4.11.1 Activity table Retain activity table.
6360-
Assessment
Amend 3 'Assessment - Restricted Discretionary activities' to clarify status of non-conforming
activities as at least discretionary.
6360-
the CMA
sch. 6.2 ONC/HNC
6.1 Schedule SEA
Marine 1 and 2 Retain activity status for activities in the SEA-M1 overlay [all coastal activity tables].
6360-
Outstanding Natural
Rules
Character - Coastal Retain activity status for activities in the ONC overlay [all coastal activity tables].
6360-
Amend activity table 1.7 activity status for 'Discharge of hull bio-fouling organisms from below
the load line resulting from (1) and (4): ...' to non-complying.
6360-
controls
Amend 2.15 by including clear standards and guidance for biofouling which is consistent with
the IMO - UN international maritime organisation guidelines on best practice for 1. commercial
shipping and 2. recreation craft [see included link to website].
6360-
environment
Add to Methods for the CMA as follows: a method is added to facilitate communication and
the adoption of best practice for biofouling by international vessels visiting New Zealand and a
collaborative relationship between MPI and Council.
6360-
the CMA
Retain activity table 1.8 activity statuses as they recognise and provide for SEAs and areas of
ONC, ONF and ONL.
6360-
the CMA
and use I6.1.10 Activity table Retain activity table 1.10 activity statuses for foreshore protection works.
6360-
Special information
requirements
Amend 4.1.1 Assessment - Controlled activities matters of control for mangrove removal as
follows: a.construction or works methods of removal, timing and hours of operation b.location,
and extent, design and materials
6360-
Special information
requirements
Amend 4.2.6(a)(ii) Assessment - Controlled activities assessment of criteria for mangrove
removal as follows: ii.of active potential coastal erosion where mangroves provide a buffer
against coastal processes causing erosion
6360-
Special information
requirements
Retain '5 Assessment Restricted discretionary activities and development control
infringements' matters of discretion.
6360-
Special information
requirements
Renumber 5 'Assessment Restricted discretionary activities and development control
infringements' matters of discretion.
6360-
Special information
requirements
Retain 5.1 and 6.1 'Restricted discretionary activities and development control infringements'
matters of discretion in relation to aquaculture. [Reference to 6.1 may be to 6.2, Special
Information Requirements for aquaculture.]
6360-
controls
Retain 2. land and water use controls unless otherwise stated in this submission [Minster of
Conservation submission].
6360-
the CMA
discharges of contaminants I6.1.4 Activity table Retain 2.9 and activity table 1.4 in relation to stock access to the coastal marine area.
6360-
controls Retain 2.11 mangrove removal.
6360-
controls
Amend 2.11(2) by adding a standard identical to 2.11(1)(f) - removal must not damage or
disturb areas of salt marsh or seagrass.
6360-
the CMA General Coastal Marine Zone I6.3 Development controls Retain 3.1(2) and (3).
6360-
Special information
requirements
Retain 4 Assessment - Controlled activities unless otherwise stated in this submission
[Minister of Conservation].
250/1145
Sub#/
6360-
Special information
requirements Retain 4.2(2) Assessment - Controlled activities - Activities in a SEA-Marine overlay.
6360-
Special information
requirements
Retain 4.2(3) Assessment - Controlled activities - Activities in an Outstanding Natural
Features overlay.
6360-
Special information
requirements
Amend 4.2(4) Assessment - Controlled activities - Activities in an Outstanding Natural
Landscapes (ONL) and Outstanding and High Natural Character (ONC and HNC) overlay by
defining which activities these assessment criteria apply to, and ensure that adverse effects
will be avoided on natural character in areas of the coastal environment with outstanding
natural character.
6360-
Special information
requirements
Retain 5.2(2) Assessment - Restricted discretionary activities and development control
infringements - Activities in a SEA-Marine overlay.
6360-
Special information
requirements
Retain 5.2(8) Assessment - Restricted discretionary activities and development control
infringements - Occupation.
6360-
SEAs
Land Retain appendix 5.1.
6360-
the CMA
sch. 6.2 ONC/HNC
6.1 Schedule SEA
Marine 1 and 2 Retain appendix 6.1.
6360-
Outstanding Natural
Rules
Character - Coastal Retain appendix 6.2.
6361-1 Susan Taylor owen.susan@xtra.co.nz Zoning North and Islands
Rezone the Mixed Housing Suburban and Single House zones in the vicinity of Maxwellton
Drive Mairangi Bay to a zone that better suits the slop of the land and does not cause
shadowing effects on surrounding houses.
6362-1 A G Quertier
50 Southern Cross Road,
Kohimarama, Auckland 1071 RPS Mana Whenua B5 Strategic Delete provisions giving iwi customary rights.
6363-1 Nick King and Jan Burbury burnette@opc.net.nz Rural Zones General I13.1 Activity table
Retain in their current form the following permitted activities within the Rural Coastal zone and
their related definitions: 'Farming', 'Greenhouses', 'Intensive farming', 'Intensive poultry
farming', 'Free-range poultry farming', 'Forestry', 'On-site primary produce manufacturing',
'Dwellings', 'Home occupations', 'Care centres', 'Information facilities', 'Artworks', and 'Artisan
industries'.
Retain in their current form the provisions for the Rural Coastal zone that enable 'visitor
accommodation' as a discretionary activity.
Add a new permitted activity to I13.1 'Rural zones' 'Activity table' enabling 'farmstay' and/or
'homestay' for up to 10 paying guests at any one time within an existing building.
6363-4 Nick King and Jan Burbury burnette@opc.net.nz Rural Zones General I13.2 Land use controls
Amend rule I13.2.6 'Dwellings' to provide for 'Minor household units' or for a second
household unit to be established on sites greater than 2ha in the rural zones.
6363-5 Nick King and Jan Burbury burnette@opc.net.nz
Outstanding Natural
Rules
Outstanding Natural
Landscapes
Amend the extent of the Outstanding Natural Landscape over 332 Ridge Road, Scotts
Landing to ensure that it is only applied to those land or sea areas that represent the best of
the best, as detailed on pages 4/13 and 5/13 of the submission.
6363-6 Nick King and Jan Burbury burnette@opc.net.nz Mana Whenua General provisions
assessment
Delete the requirement in rule G2.7.4 'Cultural impact assessment', clause (4)(o) for a cultural
impact assessment to be undertaken for any land disturbance or vegetation clearance in an
Outstanding Natural Landscape.
6363-7 Nick King and Jan Burbury burnette@opc.net.nz
SEAs
Land
Amend the SEA overlay over 332 Ridge Road, Scotts Landing to correspond to those parts of
the property that are already covenanted and contain significant vegetation, as shown on the
map on page 7/13 of the submission.
6363-8 Nick King and Jan Burbury burnette@opc.net.nz Mana Whenua General provisions
assessment
SEA.
Retain in their current for the provisions for the Rural Coastal zone that enable 'camping
grounds' as a restricted discretionary activity.
6364-1 Sarah Gambitsis slgambitsis@gmail.com Residential zones Residential
Amend to reduce the Terrace Housing and Apartment Building permitted building height
around Royal Oak and Onehunga Town Centres to 4 storeys.
251/1145
Sub#/
6364-2 Sarah Gambitsis slgambitsis@gmail.com Zoning Central
Reduce the extent of the areas zoned Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings around
Royal Oak and Onehunga to half of the proposed area.
6364-3 Sarah Gambitsis slgambitsis@gmail.com General Miscellaneous
Operational/
Projects/Acquisition Amend to require speed deterrents on Normals Hill Road.
6365-1 Amanda J E Lees alees@orcon.net.nz RPS Urban growth
quality compact urban form Retain the compact city model.
6365-2 Amanda J E Lees alees@orcon.net.nz Residential zones Residential
policies Adopt provisions to ensure housing and apartments are designed to a high standard.
6365-3 Amanda J E Lees alees@orcon.net.nz RPS
Adopt controls that ensure native trees and buses, fresh water in streams, clean water in
harbours, and clean beaches are valued and maintained.
6365-4 Amanda J E Lees alees@orcon.net.nz
SEAs
table - Vegetation
roads Amend existing coastal tree protection buffer from 20m to 100m.
6365-5 Amanda J E Lees alees@orcon.net.nz Sustainable Development C7.7/H6.4 Sustainable design
Adopt provisions encouraging transport options, building designs, and energy sources that
reduce the carbon footprint.
6365-6 Amanda J E Lees alees@orcon.net.nz Sustainable Development C7.7/H6.4 Sustainable design
Adopt provisions encouraging alternative energy systems (solar, wind) for residential, public,
and commercial buildings.
the CMA
sch. 6.2 ONC/HNC
6.1 Schedule SEA
Marine 1 and 2 Adopt provisions protecting Shoal Bay's value as a wild-life habitat.
6365-8 Amanda J E Lees alees@orcon.net.nz RPS Changes to the RUB North and Waiheke Island Retain the RUB on the Vaughans Rd ridge, Okura.
SEAs
Land Adopt Northcross Bush as a SEA.
6365-10 Amanda J E Lees alees@orcon.net.nz RPS Urban growth
Rezone areas within walking distance of railway stations, bus stations and other high quality
public transport routes to allow residential or mixed use intensification.
6365-11 Amanda J E Lees alees@orcon.net.nz Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
Delete parking minimum requirements from Mixed Housing Urban and reduce them in Mixed
Housing Suburban.
6365-12 Amanda J E Lees alees@orcon.net.nz Residential zones Housing affordability H6.6 Rules Adopt a rule requiring 20% of all new housing in brownfield areas to be affordable housing.
6366-1 Nigel Dean jenidean@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central
Rezone the north side of Jervois Road, Ponsonby from Local Centre zone to a residential
zone.
Rezone the north side of Sarsfield Street, between Sentinel Road and Curran Street,
Ponsonby from Mixed Housing Urban to Mixed Housing Suburban.
Rezone the west side of Shelly Beach Road, between Tweed Street and Emmett Street,
Ponsonby from Mixed Housing Urban to Single House.
Rezone Stack Street, Argyle Street (south side), Wallace Street (north, east west sides) ,
Jervois Road (north and south sides) between Clifton Road and Salisbury Street Herne Bay,
Jervois Road (south side) on Buller Street, Curran Street (west and east side), Emmett Street,
Tweed Street and Shelly Beach Road (east side), Herne Bay from Mixed Housing Suburban
to Single House.
6366-5 Nigel Dean jenidean@xtra.co.nz Residential zones
Amend the zone description by deleting the second paragraph and including the following
additional wording to the first paragraph "one or two storey detached and attached housing in
a variety of types and sizes to provide housing choice. It is not envisaged that there will be
widespread replacement of existing housing stock in this zone".
Amend objective 2 as follows: Development is of a height, bulk, form and appearance that
positively responds to the site and the neighbourhood's existing character, and in the case of
Greenfields development planned suburban residential character, engaging with and
addressing the street.
Amend Objective 3 as follows: Development provides high-quality on-site amenity for
residents and a chieves a reasonable standard of amenity for adjoining sites.
Amend policy 2 as follows: "....to maintain a suburban residential character of generally two
storeys."
6366-9 Nigel Dean jenidean@xtra.co.nz Residential zones Residential
Amend Rule 7.1.15 'Fences' to require fences in a front yard not to exceed 1.2m 1.8m in
height.
6366-10 Nigel Dean jenidean@xtra.co.nz Residential zones Residential
Mixed Housing Urban zone Delete Rule 7.4 'Alternative height in relation to boundary'.
252/1145
Sub#/
6366-11 Nigel Dean jenidean@xtra.co.nz Residential zones Residential Land use controls
Amend Rule 3.1 'Maximum density controls' in the Mixed Housing Suburban zone Table 1 as
follows: "One dwelling per 200m2 300m2 net site area where the requirements of clause
3.1.5 below are met".
6366-12 Nigel Dean jenidean@xtra.co.nz General Chapter G General provisions
activities
Amend notification provisions to read as 'Buildings that do not comply with any of the
development controls in the zone will be subject to the normal tests for notification under the
relevant sections of the RMA:', and delete clauses a-j inclusive.
6366-13 Nigel Dean jenidean@xtra.co.nz Residential zones Residential Notification
Amend 7.1, 'Development control infringements' of the Mixed Housing Suburban zone to
recognise that the decision on notification not be reflective on the number of infringements,
but rather the impact and add matters to be taken into account and assessment criteria.
Refer to the submission for details 25/35.
Amend 8.1, 'Development control infringements' in the Mixed Housing Suburban zone to
Amend 9.1, 'Development control infringements' in the Mixed Housing Suburban zone to
6366-16 Nigel Dean jenidean@xtra.co.nz General Chapter G General provisions
activities
Amend 2.3 to include matters of discretion that relate to building design and how it fits into the
neighbourhood and, particularly how it [affects] adjoining properties. Refer to submission for
details [page 27/36]
6366-17 Nigel Dean jenidean@xtra.co.nz RPS Urban growth
Require a detailed infrastructure study of areas for intensification prior to applying them e.g.
Terrace Housing and Apartment Building zones in older suburbs within the RUB e.g. Herne
Bay and St Mary's Bay.
6366-18 Nigel Dean jenidean@xtra.co.nz Transport Auckland -wide Mapping
Introduce a road hierarchy with detailed definitions of the various road categories similar to
those in legacy plans.
6366-19 Nigel Dean jenidean@xtra.co.nz Infrastructure
C1.1 Infrastructure
policies
Amend the infrastructure policies and objectives to clearly specify that any planning for and
management of infrastructure in areas within the RUB, take into consideration protecting
neighbourhood amenity in areas such as Herne Bay and St Mary's Bay.
6366-20 Nigel Dean jenidean@xtra.co.nz RPS Issues
growth
Amend the section relating to 'Supply of land in appropriate locations' to include additional text
relating to providing for additional urban growth along the north south corridor linking Albany
to Silverdale and Orewa, and recognising that development of satellite towns such as
Warkworth and Helensville is desirable. Refer to page 33/36 of submission for specific
wording.
6366-21 Nigel Dean jenidean@xtra.co.nz Mana Whenua General provisions
assessment Delete the provisions which require iwi consent before resource consent can be applied for.
6367-1 Designpoint Architecture chris@designpoint.co.nz Mana Whenua General provisions
assessment Remove Cultural Impact Assessments.
6368-1
Avondale Community
Gardeners
avondalecommunitygardener@gmail.
com General Miscellaneous Other Require libraries to include a Heritage Office for public interface with historians.
6368-2
Avondale Community
Gardeners
com General Miscellaneous Other Provide funding for Whau Environment Fund and and Whau Heritage and Cultural Fund.
6368-3
Avondale Community
Gardeners
com General Miscellaneous Other
Create an eighth democratically elected position on all local boards, for Mana
Whenua representative.
6368-4
Avondale Community
Gardeners
com RPS
character and natural heritage B4.3 Natural heritage Amend to protect heritage plantings (pre 1930) and tree buffer zones.
6368-5
Avondale Community
Gardeners
com General Miscellaneous Other Provide funding and education to recognise and protect the Whau horticultural heritage.
6368-6
Avondale Community
Gardeners
com RPS
features Retain protection of views to the Waitakere Ranges.
6368-7
Avondale Community
Gardeners
com
Centre)
obs & pols
Recommend a more sensitive, multicultural approach to the social and economic design of
Avondale town centre transformation.
6368-8
Avondale Community
Gardeners
com General Miscellaneous Other Promote alternative education schools.
6368-9
Avondale Community
Gardeners
com General Miscellaneous Other Promote Parallel Programmes.
6368-10
Avondale Community
Gardeners
com RPS
Protect all existing communities of trees and mangroves, with respect to Whau Local Board
area.
6368-11
Avondale Community
Gardeners
com General Miscellaneous Other Promote Street Upgrages funding.
6368-12
Avondale Community
Gardeners
com RPS Urban growth
recreation facilities Provide more playground reserves in Avondale.
253/1145
Sub#/
6368-13
Avondale Community
Gardeners
com Residential zones Residential
policies Provide for traditional quarter acre living in suburban areas.
6368-14
Avondale Community
Gardeners
com Trees
streets and public open space H3.1 Rules Require traffic laneways to be lined with vegetation.
6368-15
Avondale Community
Gardeners
com General Miscellaneous Other
Require Rosebank Business Precinct to incorporate values outlined in page 3/13 of the
submission.
6368-16
Avondale Community
Gardeners
com General Miscellaneous Other Phase out traffic emissions.
6368-17
Avondale Community
Gardeners
com RPS Climate change Develop climate change targets.
6368-18
Avondale Community
Gardeners
com RPS Natural resources
substances Phase out chemical spraying.
6368-19
Avondale Community
Gardeners
com General Miscellaneous Other Audit waste reduction.
6368-20
Avondale Community
Gardeners
com General Miscellaneous Other Auckland council to adopt living wage.
6368-21
Avondale Community
Gardeners
com RPS
Add new heritage category for fruit tress as well as heritage buildings connected to its original
garden landscape area.
6368-22
Avondale Community
Gardeners
com Historic Heritage (Overlay)
Heritage
Places Add homestead at 121 Avondale Road to the schedule of heritage places.
6369-1 Jean Opie opieclan@ihug.co.nz Mana Whenua General provisions
assessment Remove cultural impact assessments.
6369-2 Jean Opie opieclan@ihug.co.nz Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula K5.11 Precinct rules Amend height restrictions from 14.5m or 4 storeys to 8m or 2 storeys.
6369-3 Jean Opie opieclan@ihug.co.nz Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula K5.11 Precinct rules Combine Mixed Housing Suburban and Single House, with a 2 storey limit.
6369-4 Jean Opie opieclan@ihug.co.nz Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula K5.11 Precinct rules Adopt a building length rule for developments in the sub-districts.
6369-5 Jean Opie opieclan@ihug.co.nz Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula K5.11 Precinct rules
Adopt a rule requiring the completion of infrastructure before development can proceed within
the precinct.
6369-6 Jean Opie opieclan@ihug.co.nz Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula K5.11 Precinct rules Remove provision for special housing areas within the precinct.
6369-7 Jean Opie opieclan@ihug.co.nz Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula K5.11 Precinct rules Amend the rules to require full public notification for any developments.
6370-1 The Character Coalition sallyhughes1@me.com Historic Heritage (Overlay)
Heritage
Places
Amend the schedule to include any significant heritage places that have been identified in a
Plan Change to a legacy plan.
Heritage
Places
Amend the schedule to include any other places and areas that merit
scheduling including (but not limited to) parts of the CBD, Auckland University, Onehunga and
Waiuku.
6370-3 The Character Coalition sallyhughes1@me.com RPS
Amend the provisions throughout the PAUP to require activities affecting archaeological sites
to take into account the statutory responsibilities of the New Zealand Historic Places Trust
(NZHPT) to administer provisions under the Historic Places Act 1993.
Heritage
Places
Amend the schedule so all archaeological sites have been identified based on an assessment
of archaeological significance.
Heritage J2.2 Development controls Add rules to provide for the active management of scheduled archaeological sites.
6370-6 The Character Coalition sallyhughes1@me.com General Cross plan matters
Delete the rules [throughout the PAUP] that require a resource consent for 'invasive'
archaeological investigations.
Heritage
protocols
Delete the provisions [Rule 2.5(1)] relating to the accidental discovery of previously
unidentified archaeological sites.
6370-8 The Character Coalition sallyhughes1@me.com Mana Whenua
Whenua
objectives and policies Amend the schedule to ensure scheduled sites are accurately identified.
6370-9 The Character Coalition sallyhughes1@me.com Mana Whenua
Whenua
whenua Amend the schedule to include registered Whi tapu and Whi tapu areas.
6370-10 The Character Coalition sallyhughes1@me.com General Chapter G General provisions G2.4 Notification
Amend the notification rules for Controlled or Restricted Discretionary Activities that may
affect heritage items to provide for the opportunity for the New Zealand Historic Places Trust
(NZHPT) to be involved.
Heritage
requirements
Retain the requirement for a heritage impact assessment [Rule 5 'Special information
requirements'] for a proposal that could adversely affect scheduled historic heritage and
include (as appropriate) a proposal for ongoing management and archaeological provisions
that align with New Zealand Historic Places Trust (NZHPT) provisions under the Historic
Places Act 1993.
254/1145
Sub#/
6370-12 The Character Coalition sallyhughes1@me.com Mana Whenua General provisions
assessment
Amend the provisions relating to a cultural impact assessment so effects on archaeology are
addressed through a heritage impact assessment rather than a cultural impact assessment.
6370-13 The Character Coalition sallyhughes1@me.com General C7.4/H6.3 Signs
Retain the provisions relating to billboards and information signs in the vicinity of scheduled
heritage items subject to clarification. [Clarification not specified]
6370-14 The Character Coalition sallyhughes1@me.com Subdivision Auckland-wide - general
and policies
Amend the provisions to take into account possible future effects of subdivision on heritage
and opportunities for ongoing protection and enhancement.
6370-15 The Character Coalition sallyhughes1@me.com Designations G1.3 Designations
Amend the conditions of any infrastructure designation to ensure the protection of scheduled
heritage within the designated area.
6370-16 The Character Coalition sallyhughes1@me.com General Miscellaneous Other
Amend the Section 32 Reports on the Historic Heritage and Pre-1944 Demolition Control
overlays to address how heritage is to be protected and include a cost-benefit analysis that
includes economic benefits of heritage protection.
Heritage
objectives and policies Amend the provisions to recognise the significant economic benefits of retaining heritage.
6370-18 The Character Coalition sallyhughes1@me.com General Chapter G General provisions G2.4 Notification
Amend the notification provisions to require public notification of activities that may have an
adverse effect on heritage places and special character areas.
Add a rule requiring public notification for any activity in Activity Tables 1 or 3 requiring a
resource consent and the placement of a [notification] sign on these sites.
6370-20 The Character Coalition sallyhughes1@me.com Special Character
Business J3.1.1-5 Rules
Add a rule requiring public notification for any activity in the Activity Table requiring a resource
consent and the placement of a [notification] sign on these sites.
Overlay J3.2.1 Special
character Helensville
& C J3.3.1-7 Rules
6370-25 The Character Coalition sallyhughes1@me.com
control
6370-26 The Character Coalition sallyhughes1@me.com RPS Issues
heritage
Amend the Issue [under the heading 'Historic heritage'] to recognise that historic heritage can
also include; areas; wahi Tpuna; volcanoes; and volcanic landforms. Refer to pages 11-
Retain Policy 2 that states that a historic heritage place must have one or more historic
heritage values.
Heritage
Places Retain the schedule (Appendix 9.1).
Heritage
Places
Amend the schedule to; add any item identified and / or registered by the Historic Places
Trust (NZHPT); include all NZHPT registration numbers and types; and translate the NZHPT
Category 1 to Category A.
6370-30 The Character Coalition sallyhughes1@me.com General Miscellaneous
Operational/
Projects/Acquisition List any historic heritage nominations publicly on-line.
Streamline future Council heritage assessments by involving the New Zealand Historic Places
Trust (NZHPT) and Local Boards.
Facilitate the ongoing identification of heritage and historic character by; extending public
consultation; making legacy Council assessments available on-line; and by using a
methodology of thematic studies.
6370-33 The Character Coalition sallyhughes1@me.com RPS Urban growth
Amend the provisions to identify areas without heritage and landscape values and prioritise
intensification in these areas.
Adopt a consistent methodology / criteria for assessing areas for heritage values across the
region [inferred].
character and natural heritage B4.1 Historic heritage Prioritise areas to be investigated for heritage values.
Amend the provisions to require the assessment [for historic heritage] of areas to determine
the suitability for intensification, including town centres, and precincts before intensification
takes place.
6370-37 The Character Coalition sallyhughes1@me.com General Miscellaneous
Operational/
Projects/Acquisition Provide sufficient funding for heritage identification and assessment.
Amend the provisions to enable intensification in areas where there will not be adverse effects
on areas of regional heritage significance.
6370-39 The Character Coalition sallyhughes1@me.com General Miscellaneous Consultation and engagement
Include community groups and Local Boards to develop local area plans to implement any re-
zoning within the Unitary Plan.
255/1145
Sub#/
Amend the provisions to prioritise the development of existing brownfield sites over the
development of greenfield sites.
land for urban development Amend the provisions to require a review of intensification in 10 year intervals.
character and natural heritage B4.1 Historic heritage Amend the provisions to prioritise the inclusion of a heritage strategy within the PAUP.
character and natural heritage B4.1 Historic heritage Add incentives to protect historic heritage. Refer to pages 20-21 of the submission for details.
6370-44 The Character Coalition sallyhughes1@me.com Definitions New Add the definition for 'heritage maintenance' that was in the March Draft of the Unitary Plan.
Heritage J2.2 Development controls Add rules that require water proofing and maintaining the structural integrity of buildings.
6370-46 The Character Coalition sallyhughes1@me.com Definitions New Add a definition for 'historic character'.
6370-47 The Character Coalition sallyhughes1@me.com Definitions New
Add a definition for 'character-defining' which could include 'Buildings selected as 'character
defining' are seen as making a significant contribution to the 'sense of place' of each
individual village'. Refer to pages 21-22/62 of the submission for details.
6370-48 The Character Coalition sallyhughes1@me.com Definitions New
Add a definition for 'character-supporting' which could include ''Character supporting building''
play a lesser yet very recognisable contribution to that 'sense of place'. Refer to pages 21-
control
and policies
Amend the Description so the overlay is applied to all areas in Auckland. Refer to pages 26-
control
Amend the notification rule to require public notification for all resource consents to demolish
pre-1944 buildings.
residential
Add provisions to identify and protect post 1944 houses such as Hill Park in Manurewa and
areas on the North Shore that contain intact post war suburban houses and streets.
character and natural heritage B4.1 Historic heritage Retain the objectives that relate to scheduled historic heritage places.
Retain the policies, including the evaluative criteria / assessment criteria that determines the
heritage values of a place [inferred].
Retain the regulatory and non-regulatory methods that relate to scheduled historic heritage
places.
Heritage
objectives and policies Delete Category A* and reclassify all A* buildings as either Category A or B.
Heritage
places
Retain the Discretionary Activity status for 'development modifications', 'new buildings and
structures'.
Heritage
places Amend the Activity Table to change 'seismic strengthening' to a Discretionary Activity.
Add rules for permitted works to site surrounds, interiors, plant and free standing non-
permanent structures similar to those contained in the Auckland Council Operative Central
Area Plan.
Retain the rules that require a plan detailing the methodology for dismantling, removal,
relocation and reassembly of the building or structure or its parts for temporarily dismantling
for seismic strengthening.
Heritage
requirements
Retain Rule (1) 'Heritage policy documents' subject to the amendment of clause (a) to include
substantial alterations and additions as a trigger to determine if a proposal is considered
significant work.
Heritage
requirements
Retain the requirement for conservation plans to be provided for significant works or alteration
for all Category A or A* places subject to the thresholds.
Heritage
requirements
Retain the requirement for conservation policy documents to be approved by Council and
reviewed by a suitably qualified person.
Retain Policy 1 that seeks to identify and protect Auckland's historic heritage places through a
holistic and interdisciplinary approach.
Retain Policy 6(vii) which recognises the importance of interiors as fundamental to the historic
heritage values of the place.
Heritage
Places
Amend the schedule (Appendix 9.1) to include all interiors except where they have been so
modified as to have little or no heritage value.
character and natural heritage B4.1 Historic heritage Retain the concept of a historic place to include the surrounds.
Heritage
Places
Amend the schedule [inferred] to include the spatial dimension and / or a generic text
description to define the place, similar to the Operative Auckland Council Central Area Plan.
256/1145
Sub#/
Heritage
Places
Amend the schedule (Appendix 9.1) to identify 'all applicable heritage overlays
to include notable trees, geological features, and significant ecological features'.
6370-69 The Character Coalition sallyhughes1@me.com General Eplan Amend the schedule (Appendix 9.1) so it can be viewed by alphabetical street order.
Heritage
Places Retain the advice note on the role of the New Zealand Historic Places Trust in Appendix 9.1.
residential
Retain all the Business and Residential (Helensville, Isthmus A, B and C, North Shore and
General) Special Character Areas.
Business
Character Statements - Bus. Retain the identification of values in the Area Statement of Significance.
character Helensville Retain the identification of values in the Area Statement of Significance.
& C
Isthmus Retain the identification of values in the Area Statement of Significance.
North Shore Retain the identification of values in the Area Statement of Significance.
General
character statement - General Retain the identification of values in the Area Statement of Significance.
residential
Add Karangahape Road, Auckland Central as in the legacy plan [Operative Auckland Council
District Plan - Central Area Section] as a Special Character Business Area and include the
updated (statutory) design guidelines.
residential
Add Saint Heliers as in the legacy plan [Operative Auckland Council District Plan - Central
Area Section] as a Special Character Business zone [inferred Special Character Business
overlay].
Heritage
Places
Add the Devonport shops to the schedule as a Historic Heritage Area. [Also refer to
submission point 80 of this submission.]
residential
Add the Devonport shops as a Special Character Business zone [inferred Special Character
Business overlay]. [Also refer to submission point 79 of this submission.]
& C
Isthmus
Add the maps identifying Isthmus A areas in Clause (8) as referenced in the Introduction to
3.3, rather than relying on their identification in the planning maps.
residential
Add the explanatory material (relating to Special Character Areas) from former legacy plans
where it has been omitted such as the North Shore City Residential 3 provisions.
residential
Add the Special Character Area design guidelines [inferred from legacy plans] as statutory
documents.
Heritage
Retain Policy 4 that identifies incentives for the use, maintenance and repair of scheduled
historic heritage places.
environment Amend the provisions to make the Auckland Design Manual a statutory document.
6370-86 The Character Coalition sallyhughes1@me.com Residential zones Residential
policies
Delete all objectives, policies and rules and rewrite provisions based on local area studies,
including to determine the appropriate locations for higher density residential developments.
Refer to pages 31-34/61 of the submission for details.
growth
Amend the text under the heading 'Our sense of place' to state that residential intensification
needs to be balanced with retaining the residential character of the majority of suburbs. Refer
to pages 35-36/61 of the submission for details.
growth
Amend the text under the heading 'Supply of land in appropriate locations' to include the
development potential of greenfield areas around the urban fringe including the North South
corridor linking Albany to Silverdale and Orewa, and satellite towns such as Warkworth and
Helensville. Refer to pages 36-37/61 of the submission for details.
Amend the Introduction to state that business growth will be focussed in centres and along
frequent transport routes, and the majority of residential intensification will be in close
proximity to larger business centres, along major transport routes and constrained by the need
to preserve residential character. Refer to page 39/61 of the submission for details.
Add a new objective as follows; Identify a major north south corridor linking Albany to
Silverdale and Orewa.
257/1145
Sub#/
Amend Objective [2] as follows; Urban growth is primarily focused balanced between growth
within the metropolitan area 2010 and greenfields development on the periphery and along
defined growth corridors.
Amend Objective [3] so residential intensification is subject to the retention of the existing
residential character. Refer to page 39/61 of the submission for details.
Amend Objective [4] as follows; The focus for urban growth outside of the metropolitan area
2010, is greenfield land within the RUB that is contiguous with the urban area, investigation of
the potential North South urban corridor and the satellite towns of Pukekohe, Helinsville and
Warkworth.
Amend Policy 1 as follows; Concentrate urban activities within, the metropolitan area 2010,
the RUB, the potential North South urban corridor, the satellite towns, rural and coastal towns
and serviced villages.
Amend Policy 2 so areas in close proximity to larger business centres and along major routes
are identified as suitable for residential intensification while other residential intensification is
subject to the preservation of residential character. Refer to page 40/61 of the submission for
details.
Amend the regulatory methods as follows; The Unitary Plan will be changed to define the
RUB around the north south growth corridor, rural and coastal towns and serviced villages
and other areas the council has deemed necessary.
Amend the Explanation and Reasons to include the opportunities to develop along proposed
corridors and the need to protect residential character from inappropriate development. Refer
environment
Amend the Introduction in 2.1 'Providing for growth in a quality compact urban form' [inferred
2.2 'A quality built environment'] to state the different approaches required for development
and residential intensification in greenfield, brownfield and existing urban areas and the need
for robust design guidelines especially limiting the bulk and scale of development. Refer to
pages 41-42/61 of the submission for details.
environment
Amend Objective 1 to split into two objectives to better recognise the importance of design
guidelines and development rules to guide the form of development envisaged for a zone.
6370-
100 The Character Coalition sallyhughes1@me.com RPS Urban growth
environment
Amend Policy 2 to state the importance of developments being designed to respond
positively to its neighbours, street scape and the existing character. Refer to page 42/61 of
6370-
environment
Amend Policy 8 to state the need to retain the existing residential character of areas not
zoned Mixed Housing Urban or Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings. Refer to page
6370-
environment
Add a policy that states the need to restrict residential development so it fits with the existing
residential character of the area.
6370-
Amend the regulatory methods to include that the Unitary Plan will extend the RUB to include
'areas identified as suitable for urban development along the north south growth corridor'.
6370-
104 The Character Coalition sallyhughes1@me.com Residential zones Residential
policies
Amend the Introduction to include the use of 'dispensation provisions' as an incentive for a
'good design outcome'. Refer to pages 45-46/61 of the submission for details.
6370-
105 The Character Coalition sallyhughes1@me.com Residential zones
Amend the Description to state that development will be one or two storeys rather than
generally two and that 'It is not envisaged that there will be widespread replacement of
existing housing stock in this zone.' Refer to page 47/61 of the submission for details.
6370-
Amend Objective 2 as follows; Development is of a height, bulk, form and appearance that
positively responds to the site and the neighbourhood's existing and in the case of
greenfields development planned suburban residential character, engaging with the street.
6370-
Amend Objective 3 as follows; Development provides high-quality on-site amenity for
residents and achieves a reasonable standard of amenity for adjoining sites.
6370-
Amend Policy 2 to state that the height of the zone is one or two storeys in existing residential
areas. Refer to page 47/61 of the submission for details.
6370-
Amend Policy 3 to 'avoid dominance effects' rather than 'excessive dominance effects'. Refer
6370-
Add a clause to Police 6 to require development to be compatible with the existing residential
character and streetscape of the area. Refer to page 48/61 of the submission for details.
6370-
Amend Policy 7 to achieve a balance between the efficient use of the site, high quality on-site
amenity and protecting the amenity of adjoining properties. Refer to page 48/61 of the
258/1145
Sub#/
6370-
112 The Character Coalition sallyhughes1@me.com General Chapter G General provisions
activities
Amend Rules 3 and 4 to include the potential effect of non-compliance on adjoining
properties, the streetscape and residential character and the design of the development as
matters of discretion and assessment criteria for Restricted Discretionary activities. Refer to
pages 49-50/61 of the submission for details.
6370-
113 The Character Coalition sallyhughes1@me.com General Chapter G General provisions G2.4 Notification
Delete Rules 2.4 'Notification' (1) and (2) and replace with one rule that follows; Except as
otherwise specified in the Unitary Plan, all activities will be assessed against the notification
provisions in the RMA.
6370-
Special info. req.
Amend Rule 10.1 'Matters of discretion' (3) to include the effects of design, scale, bulk and
location of buildings on adjoining properties, the streetscape and residential character and the
effects of overshadowing, dominance, and loss of privacy at the interface between the
Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings zone and the Single House, Mixed Housing Urban
and Mixed Housing Suburban zones on adjoining properties and the streetscape. Refer to
6370-
115 The Character Coalition sallyhughes1@me.com Residential zones Residential Notification
Amend Rule 2 'Notification' to require buildings that do not comply with any development
controls for the zone to be subject to the normal tests for notification under the RMA. [Refer to
page 53/61 of the submission for details].
6370-
Amend Rule 7.1 'Development control infringements' (Mixed Housing Suburban zone) to
make any development control infringement a Restricted Discretionary Activity and include
the design, likely impact on adjoining properties and residential character of the area and the
visual effect on the existing streetscape as additional assessment criteria. [Refer to pages
53/54/61 of the submission for details].
6370-
Amend Rule 8.1 'Development control infringements' (Mixed Housing Urban zone) to make
any development control infringement a Restricted Discretionary Activity and include the
design, likely impact on adjoining properties and residential character of the area and the
visual effect on the existing streetscape as additional assessment criteria. [Refer to pages
53/54/61 of the submission for details].
6370-
Amend Rule 9.1 'Development control infringements' (Terrace Housing and
Apartment Building zone) to make any development control infringement a Restricted
Discretionary Activity and include the design, likely impact on adjoining properties and
residential character of the area and the visual effect on the existing streetscape as additional
assessment criteria. [Refer to pages 53/54/61 of the submission for details].
6370-
119 The Character Coalition sallyhughes1@me.com Residential zones Residential Activity Table
Amend the Activity Table to make three or more dwellings on a site a Restricted Discretionary
Activity in the Mixed Housing Suburban zone.
6370-
120 The Character Coalition sallyhughes1@me.com Residential zones Residential Activity Table
Amend the Activity Table to make three or more dwellings on a site a Restricted Discretionary
Activity in the Mixed Housing Urban zone.
6370-
121 The Character Coalition sallyhughes1@me.com Residential zones Residential Land use controls
Amend Table 1 in Rule 3.1 'Maximum density' to change from one dwelling per 200m
2
to
300m
2
net site area for the Mixed Housing Suburban zone. [Refer to page 56/61 of the
submission for details].
6370-
Delete Rule 7.4 'Alternative height in relation to boundary' for the Mixed Housing Suburban
zone.
6370-
Amend Table 5 in Rule 7.5 'Yards' to change the minimum rear yard depth from 1m to 4m, for
the Mixed Housing Suburban zone. [Refer to pages 57-58/61 of the submission for details].
6370-
Delete Rule 7.8 'Building coverage' and replace with a maximum building coverage of 35%
within the Mixed Housing Suburban zone. [Refer to pages 58-59/61 of the submission for
details].
6370-
Amend Rule 7.9 'Landscaping' (2) to increase the minimum landscaped area from 30% to
35% for the Mixed Housing Suburban zone. [Refer to page 59/61 of the submission
for details].
6370-
Amend Rule 7.15 'Fences' to increase the maximum fence height within a front yard from
1.2m to 1.8m for the Mixed Housing Suburban zone. [Refer to page 60/61 of the submission
for details].
6370-
Terrace Housing and
Amend Rule 9.5 'Building setbacks adjoining lower density zones' for the Terrace Housing
and Apartment Buildings zone to also apply the rule to sites adjoining the Mixed Housing
Suburban and Mixed Housing Urban zones. [Refer to page 61/61 of the submission for
details].
6370-
128 The Character Coalition sallyhughes1@me.com Residential zones Residential Notification
Delete Rule 2 [specific rule not specified] and replace with a rule that requires varied side and
rear setbacks for sites in the centres, Mixed Use, General Business and Business Park zones
that adjoin the Single House, Mixed Housing Suburban and Mixed Housing Urban and some
public open space zones. [Refer to page 61/61 of the submission for details].
6370-
129 The Character Coalition sallyhughes1@me.com Precincts General Content Precincts General Content
Retain the precincts that seek to retain 'historic character' as a major objective. Refer to page
8/61 of the submission for details. [No specific precincts identified.]
259/1145
Sub#/
6371-1 Peter Rothwell rothwellsurvey@xtra.co.nz Precincts - North Bayswater K5.6 Precinct rules Delete residential activities from precinct description.
6371-2 Peter Rothwell rothwellsurvey@xtra.co.nz Precincts - North Bayswater K5.6 Precinct rules Amend rules to make dwellings a prohibited activity.
6372-1 Owen Taylor owen@owentaylor.co.nz Zoning North and Islands
Rezone the properties around the Sunnynook Town Centre zone from Mixed Housing Urban
to Terrace Housing and Apartment Building.
6373-1
Drury and Ramarama
Protection Society
Incorporated robert.enright@dlapf.com RPS Changes to the RUB South
Amend the Rural Urban Boundary within the area of land previously subject to the Drury
South Private Plan Change to reverse the expansion on the RUB in this location.
6373-2
Drury and Ramarama
Protection Society
Rezone the area of land previously subject to the Drury South Private Plan Change from the
Future Urban zone to Rural Production or Mixed Rural zone.
6373-3
Drury and Ramarama
Protection Society
Undertake a robust stormwater assessment and modeling in a catchment management plan
for the area of land previously subject to the Drury South Private Plan Change before there is
any change in zoning from the previous rural zoning.
6374-1
Oratia District Ratepayers' and
Residents' Association
Incorporated penny@sparksinteractive.co.nz Precincts - West
Area
Retain the statement in the part F7.9 'Waitakere Ranges Heritage Area', which acknowledges
that this heritage area includes numerous different landscapes, local communities and
patterns of use and requests that this contributes to Council decisions affecting Oratia.
6374-2
Area
Retain the statement in part F7.9 'Waitakere Ranges Heritage Area', which recognises the
unique character of certain settlements, villages and property areas within the precinct
boundary and requests that this contributes to Council decisions affecting Oratia.
6374-3
Area
Add new statement to the objectives or the policies relating to the areas depicted in Precinct
Plan 1 Oratia Special Subdivision Area and Precinct Plan 2 Oratia Policy Area, to read:
Require all activities to: - protect, restore or enhance Oratia's heritage features, or; - provide
for the social and economic well-being of the Oratia community, or; - manage subdivision and
development so the Oratia's rural character and heritage features are retained, or; - provide
for future uses of rural land that will retain Oratia's rural character, or - be active in otherwise
implementing the LAP; and require that fulfilment of one or more of these objectives does not
contravene any other.
6374-4
Area
Amend Precinct Plan 11 'Oratia Village' to include Oratia District School within the boundaries
of the precinct plan.
6374-5
Area
Retain the statement in part F7.9, which states that "there is a clear is a divide between urban
Auckland and rural Oratia which is viewed as a 'gateway' or edge".
6374-6
Incorporated penny@sparksinteractive.co.nz RPS Changes to the RUB West Maintain the RUB where it borders Oratia as shown on the RUB overlay.
6374-7
Incorporated penny@sparksinteractive.co.nz General Miscellaneous Special housing areas
Prevent early termination of the Auckland Housing Accord and after its expiry ensure no
Special Housing Areas or their equivalent are established outside the current limits of the
RUB.
6374-8
Area
Add the text set out in paragraph 6 on page 5/6 of the submission into the PAUP, where
appropriate, to reflect a signage policy for the whole Oratia district (Oratia Special Subdivision
Area, Oratia Policy Area and Oratia Village) requiring all signage to be subservient to and
respectful to the landscapes and heritage of the area.
6374-9
Amend rule 2.1.6 'Signs' to include specify controls for lighting, maintenance, and additional
controls for real estate sigsn, as set out in paragraph 7 on page 6/6 of the submission.
6374-10
Amend clause 2.1.1 'Non residential activities' to say that "the restaurant must
not include drive through facilities, or chain restaurants or franchises" as set out in paragraph
8 on page 6/6 of the submission.
6374-11
Incorporated penny@sparksinteractive.co.nz Mana Whenua General provisions
assessment Review the cultural iwi requirements for SEA's [with a view to making them less onerous].
6375-1 Rachel Coppage rokecoppage@orcon.net.nz General Miscellaneous
Operational/
Establish rest homes for elderly deaf people (and other ailments) with staff proficient in New
Zealand Sign Language.
Operational/
Projects/Acquisition Adopt captions to ensure "Movie in parks" are accessible to deaf people.
Operational/
Produce information about environmental responsibility that is available in New Zealand Sign
Language.
Operational/
Projects/Acquisition Establish drop-in centres all around Auckland for deaf people.
6375-5 Rachel Coppage rokecoppage@orcon.net.nz General
Artworks - Background,
objectives and policies Adopt provisions to enable deaf arts to flourish in Auckland.
6376-1 Elizabeth Fontinha beth.fontinha@gmail.com Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula K5.11 Precinct rules [Delete Devonport Peninsula Precinct from the PAUP].
260/1145
Sub#/
6377-1
The Karangahape Road
Business Association business@kroad.com Precincts - City Centre New Precincts Add a new K Road Precinct, refer submission page 2/2 vol. 1.
6377-2
Business Association business@kroad.com Historic Heritage (Overlay)
Heritage
Places
Add a new Conservation Area, for the length of 'K Road' [Karangahape Road] refer
submission page 2/2 vol. 2.
6377-3
Business Association business@kroad.com Precincts - City Centre New Precincts
Acknowledge in the Unitary Plan, issues with traffic management, rail, pedestrian, cycle,
street connections and public space in the K Road area, refer submission page 131/137 vol.
3.
6378-1 Megan and Aaron Kirby megan@iconimages.co.nz Zoning Central
Rezone 15 Richard Farrell Avenue, Remuera from Mixed Housing suburban to Mixed Housing
Urban.
6378-2 Megan and Aaron Kirby megan@iconimages.co.nz Residential zones Residential
General
Amend building height rule to Increase height limit for 15 Richard Farrell Avenue to at least
9.5m.
6378-3 Megan and Aaron Kirby megan@iconimages.co.nz Residential zones Residential
General
Amend building height limit for Single Housing zone and Mixed Housing Suburban zone to
9.5m.
6379-1 Tom Ang tomang@orcon.net.nz RPS Urban growth
quality compact urban form Retain section.
6379-2 Tom Ang tomang@orcon.net.nz Historic Heritage (Overlay)
Heritage
objectives and policies Retain protection of heritage.
environment Retain design guideline requirements on new builds.
6379-4 Tom Ang tomang@orcon.net.nz Zoning Central
Rezone the area of Grey Lynn with Mixed Housing, and Terrace Housing and Apartment
Buildings to a more sympathetic zone which would not result in the loss of the suburb's
heritage buildings.
6379-5 Tom Ang tomang@orcon.net.nz Residential zones Residential
policies Retain objective protecting the privacy and sunlight of neighbouring properties.
6379-6 Tom Ang tomang@orcon.net.nz General Miscellaneous Consultation and engagement Relax the time-frame for the preparation of the Draft Auckland Unitary Plan.
6379-7 Tom Ang tomang@orcon.net.nz General Chapter A Introduction
tools
Adopt a staged approach and prepare a series of local precinct plans providing for
intensification, involving local community input.
6379-8 Tom Ang tomang@orcon.net.nz Designations G1.3 Designations Adopt designations for schools within the Special Purpose zoning.
6379-9 Tom Ang tomang@orcon.net.nz Zoning Central Retain Single House zone in Grey Lynn.
Heritage
Places Retain the Historic Heritage overlay in the Grey Lynn area.
Heritage
Places
Retain and extend the historic character overlay in Grey Lynn , pending a historic character
assessment and field survey.
6379-12 Tom Ang tomang@orcon.net.nz
control
Amend pre-1944 rules so that any demolition or removal of pre-1944 buildings across
Auckland is publicly notified.
6379-13 Tom Ang tomang@orcon.net.nz Zoning Central
Rezone the area along the Great North Road ridge from Mixed Housing to Terrace Housing
and Apartment Buildings where the parcel abuts land zoned Single House.
6379-14 Tom Ang tomang@orcon.net.nz Zoning Central Rezone sites zoned Mixed Use in Grey Lynn [zoning not suggested].
Recognise that infrastructure provision within the Draft Auckland Unitary Plan is inadequate
and are not consistent with planned population growth.
SEAs
Land
Adopt provisions encouraging covenanting and increasing any areas of native bush in Grey
Lynn.
Centre) Business
Park zones Retain a height limit of 12.5m for West Lynn and Grey Lynn.
6379-18 Tom Ang tomang@orcon.net.nz Zoning Central Rezone West Lynn from Local Centre to Neighbourhood Centre.
6379-19 Tom Ang tomang@orcon.net.nz General Chapter G General provisions G2.4 Notification Amend provisions to provide more public notification.
6379-20 Tom Ang tomang@orcon.net.nz Trees
Trees
Notable Trees
Add the avenues of London Plan trees along Browning Street, Selbourne Street, Castle
Street, and Hakanoa Street, Grey Lynn to the schedule of notable trees.
6379-21 Tom Ang tomang@orcon.net.nz General Miscellaneous Other
Adopt the matter raised by the Grey Lynn Residents Association surrounding the anomalous
plots of land and roads through Grey Lynn Park.
6379-22 Tom Ang tomang@orcon.net.nz RPS
Add a policy to 'preserve if possible' trees and vegetation, or replace more trees than are
taken out.
Add a rule that fines developers for the trees they eliminate from any site, and requiring them
to replace with more trees than they took out.
Amend the procedure for scheduling trees to lower the requirements and be less prescriptive
about what is a notable tree.
Amend the rules to give special protection to Pohutukawa trees and to encourage their use
over foreign species.
261/1145
Sub#/
Amend the Notable Tree listing procedure into a Tree Listing procedure that make it easier to
list trees.
character and natural heritage B4.3.3 Trees and vegetation Adopt a policy that actively encourages more planting of trees.
6379-28 Tom Ang tomang@orcon.net.nz Sustainable Development C7.7/H6.4 Sustainable design
Adopt provisions requiring that all development go through a process of assessment for the
requirement of green roofs and green walls.
6379-29 Tom Ang tomang@orcon.net.nz Sustainable Development C7.7/H6.4 Sustainable design
Amend rules to require all developments to, at a minimum, plan for water harvesting and
recycling.
6379-30 Tom Ang tomang@orcon.net.nz General Miscellaneous
Operational/
Projects/Acquisition Adopt a policy stopping the fluoridation of water.
Operational/
Projects/Acquisition Adopt vehicle emissions testing.
Operational/
Projects/Acquisition Adopt schemes encouraging the ownership and use of electric or hybrid cars.
6379-33 Tom Ang tomang@orcon.net.nz RPS Natural resources B6.1 Air
Amend the plan to emphasise managing vehicle emissions over fire emissions in regards to
Air quality.
organisms
modified organisms Adopt a rule banning the growing of GMOs.
organisms
modified organisms Retain the precautionary principal in relation to allowing GMO plantings in Auckland.
Operational/
Adopt clear guidelines for the handling of GMOs coming through Ports of Auckland and
Auckland Airport.
character and natural heritage B4.3.4 Biodiversity Adopt a rule limiting cat ownership to one per household.
6380-1 Gilbert Brakey biolandscape@xtra.co.nz
SEAs
Land
Amend the SEA over land at 50-60 Taumata Road, Sandringham as shown on the plan on
page 3/3 of the submission.
6381-1 Neil Wolfgram peter@trippandrews.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - Rural zones
zones only
Change activity status for 'Subdivision for public open spaces, reserves, network utilities or
road alignment' from a discretionary to a controlled activity.
zones only
Add a criterion after 'subdivision in the Countryside Living Zones' to read: 'subdivision in the
Mixed Rural and Rural Production zones' and change activity status for 'Subdivision provided
for in the rural subdivision rules...' from a discretionary to a restricted discretionary activity.
zones only
Amend activity status for 'Any other subdivision not provided for...' from a prohibited to a non-
complying activity.
area
Amend rule (1)(a) to read: 'Council may impose a specified building area which must be
clearly identified on a scheme plan of subdivision.' [Refer to submission for details].
area
Amend and combine rule (1)(c)(i) and (1)(c)(ii) to decrease the specified building area
requirement from 5000m2 to 2000m2 for dwellings and must not be located in yards or 1%
AEP floodplain. Amend, so rule (1)(c)(i) refers to 'dwellings only, not accessory buildings', and
renumber. [Refer to submission for details].
area
Amend rule (1)(c)(iv) (Specified Building Area) to read: '...be identified as the only place within
a site where dwellings can be located.'
area
Amend rule (1)(d) so a subdivision that doesn't comply with the minimum area for the
Specified Building Area rules is considered a discretionary activity rather than a non-
complying activity.
area
Amend rule (2), 'Protection and enhancement of ecological values', by reordering as follows:
(2)(c), (2)(a), (2)(b), (2)(d), (2)(e). Refer to submission for details.
area
Delete rule (2)(a)(iv) [that requires a subdivision plan to show a minimum 10m-wide riparian
strip].
area
Amend rule (2)(b) to read: 'The applicant must provide an assessment of the features
identified in (2)(a) above that are worthy of protection. The assessment must be undertaken
by a suitably qualified person and include a management plan for pests and weeds and
recommendations for ongoing protection.'
area
Add new assessment criteria to assess the significance of a 'valuable natural feature' in Rule
(2)(c). [May require a new or amended definition].
area
Amend rule (2)(d) to clarify criteria for assessing and protecting natural features. [Criteria not
provided in submission].
262/1145
Sub#/
area
Amend rule 2(d)(ii) to read: 'Management of the features should be in accordance with the
recommendations of the assessment report'.
area
Delete rule 2(d)(iv) [that may require land owners to provide access to sites and places of
significance to Mana Whenua].
area
Amend rule (2)(d)(v) to split provisions for cultural harvest and legal protection of a natural
feature into 2 rules by deleting cultural harvest from this rule and adding a further rule. [Refer
to submission for details].
area
Amend rule (2)(e) so a subdivision which doesn't comply with this rule [protection and
enhancement of ecological values] is assessed as a discretionary rather than a non-
complying activity. [Refer to submission for details].
area
Amend Table 5 in rule (3)(b)(i) - description of the Transferable Rural Site Subdivision
process. [An amended description was not provided with the submission]. In 'Step 1', change
the word 'abut' to 'adjoin'.
area
Amend rule (4)(a)(ii) so road severances that have an existing right to erect a dwelling or
building can be considered as a donor site. [Refer to submission for details].
area
Amend rule (4)(a)(iii) to remove the requirement for donor sites to be larger than 1ha (as part
of a Transferable Rural Site Subdivision), and base minimum site area on permitted building
rights (development rights). [Refer to submission for details].
area
Amend rule (4)(a)(v) to remove the requirement for donor sites [as part of Transferable Rural
Site Subdivision] to ...'be recorded separately on the Council valuation roll and exist when the
application is made...', and amend the second bullet point to state: 'shown on an approved
scheme plan of subdivision which would, if given effect to, create certificates of title that could
be sites in accordance with that consent and then used under these rules (consented site).'
[Refer to submission for details].
area
Amend rule (4)(b)(iii) by removing restrictions on new sites [as part of Transferable Rural Site
Subdivision] that prevent further subdivision or further transferable rural site subdivision
potential. [Refer to submission for details].
area
Amend rule (4)(c)(ii) so it is consistent with Table 6 [infer the request is to list the Rural
Conservation zone as a possible location for receiver sites as part of Transferable Rural Site
Subdivision. Refer to submission for details].
area
Amend rule (4)(c)(iii) to delete reference to 'Receiver Site Exclusion Area' and 'Appendix 12.1'
[Transferable Rural Site Subdivision], or at least restrict the receiver site rule to comparing the
Land Use Capability of soils within it with the donor site. [Refer to submission for details].
area
Amend rule (4)(c)(iv) to change the minimum area of a receiver site [as part of Transferable
Rural Site Subdivision] (other than in the Countryside Living zone) from 2ha to 4000m2.
[Refer submission for details].
area
Amend rule (4)(c)(v) to change the minimum balance area of receiver site [as part of
Transferable Rural Site Subdivision] from 2ha to 1ha.
area
Amend rule (4)(c)(viii) so a receiver site (as part of transferable rural site subdivision) that is
not in the Countryside Living zone can contain a percentage of prime or elite land to allow for
a building platform on relatively flat land. [Refer to submission for details].
area
Amend rule (4)(c)(ix) to reflect [Franklin] Plan Change 14 rule for rescinding titles (in relation
to Transferable Rural Site Subdivision). [Refer to submission for details].
area
Delete rule (4)(x) that limits the number of receiver sites to 1 (as part of Transferable Rural
Site Subdivision) for sites in the Rural Production zone, and allow more than 1 site to be
created.
area
Delete (4)(c)(ii) in favour of Table 6. [Transferable Rural Site Subdivision. This has also been
addressed by a previous submission point. Refer to submission for details].
area
Amend rule (5)(a) [Transferable Rural Site Subdivision] to include a reference to Table 10
when the receiver site is in the Countryside Living zone.
area
Amend rule (5)(a)(iii) [Transferable Rural Site Subdivision] to include criteria to clarify how
'threatened ecosystems' will be interpreted. Refer to submission for details.
area
Amend rule (5)(a)(iii) [Transferable Rural Site Subdivision] after Table 7 by laying it out
differently, and renumbering. [Refer to submission for details].
263/1145
Sub#/
area
Amend (5)(a)(ix), [Transferable Rural Site Subdivision] first bullet point, to read: 'permanent
protection of the site identified SEA feature.'
area
Amend rule (5)(a)(x) [Transferable Rural Site Subdivision] by adding new receiver areas for
transferable rural site subdivision, not limited to Countryside Living zones and unidentified
villages [no new receiver areas suggested].
area
Amend rule (7)(a) and (b) 'Boundary adjustments and boundary relocations' to delete Table 9
and to allow a range of new controls and activity statuses. Refer to submission for details.
area
Amend rule (8)(a) 'Subdivision in the Countryside Living zone' to remove all averaging criteria
in all cases. Refer to submission for details.
area
Amend rule (8)(d) 'Specified building area' to remove the requirement for specified building
areas in the Countryside Living zone. Refer to submission for details.
area
Amend rule (9)(a) to reduce the minimum net site area for rural subdivision in the Mixed Rural
and Rural Production zones from 150ha to 40ha. Refer submission for details.
area
Amend rule (9)(b) to change the acitivity status of any subdivision that doesn't comply with the
minimum net site area of 150ha from a prohibited activity to a non-complying activity.
area
Amend the boundaries of the Receiver Site Exclusion Area (Appendix 12.1) to exclude North
Franklin. Refer to page 18/23 of the submission for details.
area
Add a new rule which provides for subdivision around an existing large-scale and/or
economically viable intensive rural activity, such as the rule contained in [Franklin District
Council Plan Change 14 version (7A)] that relates to 'subdivision around an intensive use.'
6381-42 Neil Wolfgram peter@trippandrews.co.nz Definitions Existing
Combine the definitions of 'Boundary Adjustment' and 'Boundary Relocation', to achieve a
similar effect as the notified rule. [Refer to submission for details]. Add the following to the
definition: 'For the benefit of doubt, a property under this rule means an allotment or
contiguous allotments owned by a common registered proprietor'.
6381-43 Neil Wolfgram peter@trippandrews.co.nz Definitions Existing
Amend the definition of 'site', clause (1)(b), to state: 'contained in a single lot on an approved
scheme plan of a subdivision (consented site) for which a separate certificate of title could be
issued without further consent from council', and delete the line below clause 1b, i.e.: being in
any case the smaller area of clauses 1a or 1b above. Refer to submission for details.
6381-44 Neil Wolfgram peter@trippandrews.co.nz Rural Zones General I13.2 Land use controls
Delete rules (1) and (2) for 'Dwellings', and amend to read: (1) Any site where a new dwelling
is erected must comply with the following: (a) it must not be a closed road; (b) it must not be a
road severance unless a land use consent has been granted to erect a dwelling; (c) if the
council or its predecessor did not grant consent to its creation, its net site area must not be
less than 1.00ha; (d) it must have a title issued under the Land Transfer Act 1952 or one of its
predecessor statutes; (2) Any dwelling that does not comply with rule (1) above is a
6382-1 Waiheke Well Drilling waihekewd@gmail.com RPS Mana Whenua B5 Strategic Reject iwi consultation provisions.
6383-1 Jon Baxter jon@perceptual-engineering.com Precincts - West
Area K7.9.2 Rules (sub-precinct B) Amend to provide for multiple dwellings on one site.
6383-2 Jon Baxter jon@perceptual-engineering.com Precincts - West
Amend Matters of discretion to include limiting the impact of additional dwellings on the
ecology of a site.
6383-3 Jon Baxter jon@perceptual-engineering.com
SEAs
table - Vegetation
roads Amend to enable clearance of vegetation for a walking track as a permitted activity.
6384-1
Auckland CBD Residents'
Advisory Group Incorporated tcoffey@slingshot.co.nz General C7.2/H6.1 Lighting Retain.
6384-2
Auckland CBD Residents'
Advisory Group Incorporated tcoffey@slingshot.co.nz Air Quality
and policies
Amend rule 2.1 'Noise' to reduce permitted maximum noise levels by 6db between 10:00pm -
7:00am.
6385-1 Janette M Elliott janelliott@paradise.net.nz RPS
Amend the PAUP to introduce additional protection for Significant Ecological Areas and
Natural Heritage Overlays,
6385-2 Janette M Elliott janelliott@paradise.net.nz General Miscellaneous Other Support submission made by the Forest and Bird Motu Manawa Restoration Group.
6386-1
Te kitai Waiohua Waka Taua
Trust nickr@barker.co.nz RPS Issues
growth Retain Councils vision of Auckland as the most liveable city.
6386-2
Trust nickr@barker.co.nz General Chapter A Introduction A3 Strategic Framework
Recognise it is important the provisions provide an appropriate framework to enable Councils
vision and strategic objectives to be realised whilst providing appropriate protection for, and
enhancement of, our natural and physical resources.
264/1145
Sub#/
6386-3
Trust nickr@barker.co.nz RPS Mana Whenua
participation
Recognise it is important to provide the ability for Mori to engage meaningfully in resource
management processes.
6386-4
Trust nickr@barker.co.nz RPS Urban growth
quality compact urban form Retain the compact city approach through intensification.
6386-5
participation
Retain recognition of Te Tiriti o Waitangi partnerships and participation in resource
management and decision making, subject to amendments sought by the submitter.
6386-6
Trust nickr@barker.co.nz Mana Whenua
settlement land
and policies
Retain the overarching Mana Whenua objectives and policies which support the use and
development of Treaty Settlement Land for the benefit of whanau, hap and iwi.
6386-7
Trust nickr@barker.co.nz RPS
Retain the overarching vegetation management objectives and policies which support the
protection and enhancement of Aucklands native vegetation cover. Refer to page 19/27 of
submission for more detail
6386-8
Retain the overarching biodiversity objectives and policies which support the protection and
enhancement of Aucklands native vegetation cover. Refer to page 19/27 of submission for
more detail
6386-9
features
Retain the overarching objectives and policies framework for outstanding landscapes and
features in the region and the application of these notations to maunga and other landscape
features of importance and amend to extend the ONF overlay over the entire maunga feature.
Refer to page and 9/27 and 23-24/27 of submission for details.
6386-10
coastal environment
Retain the overarching objectives and policies framework for natural character areas in the
region and the application of these notations to maunga and other landscape features of
importance.
6386-11
Trust nickr@barker.co.nz RPS Natural resources
B6.3 Freshwater and
Geothermal Water
Retain the overarching lakes, rivers, streams and wetlands objectives and policies which
support the protection and enhancement of Aucklands waterways.
6386-12
Trust nickr@barker.co.nz Sustainable Development C7.7/H6.4 Sustainable design
Retain the overarching sustainable design objectives and policies which encourage
sustainable building outcomes.
6386-13
Whenua
Retain the identification and protection of mana whenua sites and places of significance,
subject to amendments sought by the submitter.
6386-14
Whenua
and policies
Retain the identification and protection of Mana Whenua sites and places of value, subject to
amendments sought by the submitter.
6386-15
Trust nickr@barker.co.nz Mana Whenua General provisions
assessment
Retain the requirement for cultural impact assessments for key projects and planning
activities, subject to amendments sought by this submission.
6386-16
Trust nickr@barker.co.nz Precincts - South Mngere Puhinui
Retain the application and extent of the Mangere Puhinui Precinct and supporting planning
framework.
6386-17
Trust nickr@barker.co.nz RPS Changes to the RUB South
Retain the location of the Rural Urban Boundary in respect of Puhinui and Mangere and the
zoning of this land as Rural Production.
6386-18
Trust nickr@barker.co.nz Zoning South Retain the Mori Purpose zoning as it applies to the Pukaki Marae and Urupa landholdings.
6386-19
participation
Amend so that Iwi are appropriately resourced to participate in resource management
processes and decision making.
6386-20
features
Amend to provide volcanic maunga and other sites of significance (for example Otuataua
Stonefields) with greater protection from the adverse effects of land use (for example water
infrastructure and roads). Protection should extend beyond public land boundaries.
6386-21
Fig. 1
Add cultural landscapes including to maunga and cultural viewshafts by working with Te
Akaitai Waiohua. Refer to page 5/27, 13-14/27, 23/27 of submission for further details.
6386-22
Add additional heritage trees identified by Te kitai Waiohua to the relevant schedules for
protection.
6386-23
Whenua
Amend provisions relating to sites and places of significance to Mana Whenua to improve the
framework around consultation and preparation of Cultural Impact Assessments. Council
should prepare a comprehensive study with Mana Whenua to accurately identify all sites
before the hearing. Refer to page 5/27 of submission for more detail.
6386-24
Whenua
and policies
Amend provisions relating to sites and places of value and to Mana Whenua to improve the
framework around consultation and preparation of Cultural Impact Assessments. Council
should prepare comprehensive study with Mana Whenua to accurately identify all sites before
the hearing. Refer to page 5/27 of submission for more detail.
265/1145
Sub#/
6386-25
assessment
Amend provisions relating to sites and places of value and significance to mana whenua to
improve the framework around consultation and preparation of Cultural Impact Assessments.
Council should prepare a comprehensive study with mana whenua to accurately identify all
sites before the hearing. Refer to page 5 of submission for more detail
6386-26
Retain the overarching biodiversity objectives, however, a 'no net loss' in biodiversity should
be championed in all areas including subsequent amendments to the zone rules. Refer to
page 19/27of submission for details.
6386-27
B6.3 Freshwater and
Geothermal Water
Amend to provide adequate protection, enhancement and restoration opportunities to
waterways such as water quality across the region particularly from stormwater and waste
water discharges.
6386-28
Trust nickr@barker.co.nz Water
streams & wetland
table
Amend the activity status of structures and modification of lower order urban and rural
streams as it is contrary to the overarching objectives and policies.
6386-29
Trust nickr@barker.co.nz RPS Coastal
environment
Amend to provide coastal areas and harbours with greater protection from future reclamation
and infrastructure/ airport / port activities.
6386-30
Trust nickr@barker.co.nz Airport Airport Zone
Delete the planning framework that applies to the Auckland International Airport including the
Airport Zone until amendments are made to address cultural values, the extent of the zone
and concerns raised by Te kitai Waiohua. Refer to page 5/27 and 20/27 of submission for
more details.
6386-31
Trust nickr@barker.co.nz Precincts - South Auckland Airport
Auckland Airport Precinct until amendments are made to address cultural values, the extent of
the precinct and concerns raised by Te kitai Waiohua. Refer to page 5/27 and 20/27 of
submission for more details.
6386-32
Trust nickr@barker.co.nz Designations
Ltd
1100 Auckland International
Airport
AIAL Designation. Inadequate consultation has been undertaken with Te kitai Waiohua.
Refer to page 21/27 of submission for further details of suggested amendments.
6386-33
Trust nickr@barker.co.nz RPS Mana Whenua B5 Strategic Retain Clause 5 Addressing Issues of Significance to mana whenua.
6386-34
participation
Amend the 5 Addressing Issues of Significance to Mana Whenua references to co-
management and transfer of powers to ensure that meaningful effect is given particularly
through methods. Full transfer of powers to be encouraged for: Pukaki Marae, Pukaki Urupa.
Co-management to be encouraged for: Matukutureia, Matukutururu, Pukaki Crater, Crater
Hill, Otuataua Stonefields, PukeKiwiriki, Puhinui Reserve, Mangere Lagoon, Kohuora Park,
Tapuwae, Mataaoho (aka Sturges Park, Mt Robertson or Robertson Hill).
6386-35
Mtauranga & tikanga
Amend (5.2) to clearly acknowledge that a key issue for mana whenua involvement in
resource management and decision making is lack of, funding, support services for iwi and
clear processes to facilitate engagement within the policies and how this will be facilitated.
6386-36
participation
Amend the PAUP to provide clear guidance for both council and applicants on when and how
mana whenua are involved in planning processes and adopt a robust process for engagement
and of mana whenua in resource management processes. Refer to page 7 and8/27 of
6386-37
participation
Amend Clause 5 to explicitly acknowledge mana whenua resourcing within the policies and
how this will be facilitated.
6386-38
Trust nickr@barker.co.nz RPS Mana Whenua B5 Strategic Retain generally the strategic objectives and policies.
6386-39
participation
Retain Addressing Issues of Significance to Mana Whenua objectives and policies which
provide for the future use and development of Treaty Settlement land.
6386-40
Retain Addressing Issues of Significance to Mana Whenua objectives and policies which
provide for the future use and development of Treaty Settlement land.
6386-41
Trust nickr@barker.co.nz Zoning South Retain Mori Purposes zone as it applies to the land at Pukaki Marae & urupa.
6386-42
Trust nickr@barker.co.nz Mana Whenua Mori purpose zone
controls Retain objectives and policies.
6386-43
controls Retain rules.
266/1145
Sub#/
6386-44
controls Amend the Activity Table so that urupa are permitted.
6386-45
controls
Amend Height to Boundary development control so that a 3m vertical height is applied to
Figure 1 (not 2.5m).
6386-46
controls Amend Building Height development control relating to pou haki so these are less restrictive.
6386-47
Trust nickr@barker.co.nz Precincts Ak-Wide and Coastal Mana Whenua Management
Retain the Mana Whenua Management precinct provisions particularly the maps (Precinct
Overlay), objectives & policies and rules.
6386-48
Whenua
and policies
Retain the sites and places of value to mana whenua approach and opportunity for mana
whenua involvement.
6386-49
Whenua
Retain the sites and places of significance to Mana Whenua approach and opportunity for
Mana Whenua involvement including policy 7.
6386-50
Whenua
and policies
Add a policy to incentivise projects which enhance sites and places of value to Mana
Whenua.
6386-51
Trust nickr@barker.co.nz Historic Heritage (Overlay)
Heritage
objectives and policies Retain historic heritage objectives.
6386-52
Whenua J5.2 Rules
Amend Rule 5.1 relating to [activities within 50m of a site or place of value to Mana Whenua].
This is integral if the sites are incorrectly identified on the maps.
6386-53
Whenua J5.1 Rules
Amend Rule (5.2) relating to [activities within 50m of a site or place of significance to Mana
Whenua]. This is integral if the sites are incorrectly identified on the maps.
6386-54
Whenua J5.1 Rules Retain rules which restrict earthworks on sites and places of significance to Mana Whenua.
6386-55
Whenua J5.2 Rules Retain rules which restrict earthworks on sites and places of value to Mana Whenua.
6386-56
Whenua
Amend rules to ensure that works which enhance and restore Mana Whenua sites items are
permissive.
6386-57
Whenua J5.1 Rules
Amend rules to ensure that works which enhance and restore Mana Whenua sites items are
permissive.
6386-58
Whenua J5.1 Rules
Amend rules to ensure that minor earthworks for footpaths, fencing, driveways, tracks,
carparking areas and sportfields are restricted discretionary activity status.
6386-59
Whenua J5.2 Rules
Amend rules to ensure that minor earthworks for footpaths, fencing, driveways, tracks,
carparking areas and sportfields are restricted discretionary activity status.
6386-60
Heritage
heritage areas
Retain rules for historic heritage generally, and amend Rule 2 historic heritage to ensure that
works which enhance and restore historic heritage items are permissive.
6386-61
Whenua
whenua Add the full extent of sites and places of significance to Mana Whenua on the planning maps.
6386-62
Heritage
Amend objectives and policies so that greater emphasis on the enhancement of heritage is
championed, to provide incentives where enhancement is proposed and so that mana
whenua values are incorporated into provisions.
6386-63
Heritage
objectives and policies Amend so that mana whenau values are incorporated into the provisions.
6386-64
Heritage
Places
Amend the schedules/maps so that historic heritage sites that are of mana whenua
significance are shifted to the mana whenua schedules and maps and ensure that historic
heritage place extents include the full extent of a scheduled site. It is noted that some of these
sites have significance to mana whenua.
6386-65
Heritage
Places
Add Matukurua maunga (Matukutururu and Matukutureia), Wiri to the maps and heritage
register
267/1145
Sub#/
6386-66
Whenua
whenua
Add Matukurua maunga (Matukutururu and Matukutureia), Wiri to the maps and sites of
significance to Mana Whenua.
6386-67
Whenua
Add Matukurua maunga (Matukutururu and Matukutureia), Wiri to the maps mana whenua
register
6386-68
Heritage
Places Add Pukaki Crater, Puhinui to the maps and heritage register
6386-69
Whenua
whenua Add Pukaki Crater, Puhinui to the maps and sites of significance to Mana Whenua.
6386-70
Whenua
of value to Mana Whenua Add Pukaki Crater, Puhinui to the maps mana whenua register.
6386-71
Heritage
Places Add Crater Hill, Puhinui to the maps and heritage register
6386-72
Whenua
whenua Add Crater Hill, Puhinui to the maps and sites of significance to Mana Whenua.
6386-73
Whenua
of value to Mana Whenua Add Crater Hill, Puhinui to the maps mana whenua register.
6386-74
Heritage
Places
Add sites that are identified as part of the Puhinui Master planning exercise (undertaken by
Council) to the maps and heritage register
6386-75
Whenua
whenua
Council) to the maps and sites of significance to Mana Whenua .
6386-76
Whenua
Council) to the maps and mana whenua register.
6386-77
Heritage
Places
Add sites and maunga that are a part of Nga Mana Whenua o Tmaki Makaurau Collective
Redress settlement including Mangere Mountain to the maps and heritage register
6386-78
Whenua
whenua
Redress settlement including Mangere Mountain to the maps and sites of significance to
Mana Whenua.
6386-79
Whenua
Redress settlement including Mangere Mountain to the maps mana whenua register.
6386-80
Heritage
Places Add Otuataua Stonefields, Ihumataoto the maps and heritage register.
6386-81
Whenua
whenua Add Otuataua Stonefields, Ihumatao to the maps and sites of significance to Mana Whenua.
6386-82
Whenua
of value to Mana Whenua Add Otuataua Stonefields, Ihumataoto to the maps mana whenua register.
6386-83
Heritage
Places Add Mangere Lagoon, Mangere to the maps and heritage register.
6386-84
Whenua
whenua Add Mangere Lagoon, Mangere to the maps and sites of significance to Mana Whenua.
6386-85
Whenua
of value to Mana Whenua Add Mangere Lagoon, Mangere to the maps and mana whenua register.
6386-86
Heritage
Places Add Pukekiwiriki, Red Hill to the maps and heritage register.
268/1145
Sub#/
6386-87
Whenua
whenua Add Pukekiwiriki, Red Hill to the maps and sites of significance to Mana Whenua.
6386-88
Whenua
of value to Mana Whenua Add Pukekiwiriki, Red Hill to the maps and mana whenua register.
6386-89
Heritage
Places Add Kohuora, Papatoetoe to the maps and heritage register.
6386-90
Whenua
whenua Add Kohuora, Papatoetoe to the maps and sites of significance to Mana Whenua.
6386-91
Whenua
of value to Mana Whenua Add Kohuora, Papatoetoe to the maps and mana whenua register.
6386-92
Heritage
Places
Add Tapuwae o Mataaoho (aka Sturges Park, Mt Robertson or Robertson Hill), Otahuhu to
the maps and heritage register.
6386-93
Whenua
whenua
the maps and sites of significance to Mana Whenua.
6386-94
Whenua
the maps and mana whenua register.
6386-95
Heritage
Places Add Papahinau, Mangere to the maps and heritage register.
6386-96
Whenua
whenua Add Papahinau, Mangere to the maps and sites of significance to Mana Whenua.
6386-97
Whenua
of value to Mana Whenua Add Papahinau, Mangere to the maps and mana whenua register.
6386-98
Heritage
Places Add Te Ihu a Mataaoho, Ihumatao to the maps and heritage register.
6386-99
Whenua
whenua Add Te Ihu a Mataaoho, Ihumatao to the maps and sites of significance to Mana Whenua.
6386-
100
Whenua
of value to Mana Whenua Add Te Ihu a Mataaoho, Ihumatao to the maps and mana whenua register.
6386-
101
Heritage
Places Add Maungataketake [Ellets Mountain], Ihumatao to the maps and heritage register.
6386-
102
Whenua
whenua
Add Maungataketake [Ellets Mountain], Ihumatao to the maps and sites of significance to
mana whenua.
6386-
103
Whenua
of value to Mana Whenua Add Maungataketake [Ellets Mountain], Ihumatao to the maps and mana whenua register.
6386-
104
Heritage
Places Add Waitomokia [Mt Gabriel], Ihumataoto the maps and heritage register.
6386-
105
Whenua
whenua
Add Waitomokia [Mt Gabriel], Ihumatao to the maps and sites of significance to Mana
Whenua.
6386-
106
Whenua
of value to Mana Whenua Add Waitomokia [Mt Gabriel], Ihumataoto to the maps and mana whenua register.
6386-
107
Heritage
Places Add Te Apunga o Tainui [McLennans Hill], Otahuhu the maps and heritage register.
269/1145
Sub#/
6386-
108
Whenua
whenua
Add Te Apunga o Tainui [McLennans Hill], Otahuhu to the maps and sites of significance to
mana whenua.
6386-
109
Whenua
of value to Mana Whenua Add Te Apunga o Tainui [McLennans Hill], Otahuhu to the maps and mana whenua register.
6386-
110
Heritage
Places Add Pukekawa, Auckland Domain to the maps and heritage register.
6386-
111
Whenua
whenua Add Pukekawa, Auckland Domain to the maps and sites of significance to mana whenua.
6386-
112
Whenua
of value to Mana Whenua Add Pukekawa, Auckland Domain to the maps and mana whenua register.
6386-
113
Heritage
Places
Add Te Hopua a Rangi [Geddes Basin, Gloucester Park], Onehunga to the maps and heritage
register.
6386-
114
Whenua
whenua
Add Te Hopua a Rangi [Geddes Basin, Gloucester Park], Onehunga the maps and sites of
significance to mana whenua.
6386-
115
Whenua
Add Te Hopua a Rangi [Geddes Basin, Gloucester Park], Onehunga to the maps and mana
whenua register.
6386-
116
Heritage
Places Add Mutukaroa [Hamlins Hill], Mt Wellington to the maps and heritage register.
6386-
117
Whenua
whenua
Add Mutukaroa [Hamlins Hill], Mt Wellington to the maps and sites of significance to mana
whenua.
6386-
118
Whenua
of value to Mana Whenua Add Mutukaroa [Hamlins Hill], Mt Wellington to the maps and mana whenua register.
6386-
119
Heritage
Places Add Pukewairiki, Highbrook to the maps and heritage register.
6386-
120
Whenua
whenua Add Pukewairiki, Highbrook to the maps and sites of significance to mana whenua.
6386-
121
Whenua
of value to Mana Whenua Add Pukewairiki, Highbrook to the maps and mana whenua register.
6386-
122
Heritage
Places Add Te Taurere [Tayor Hill], Glen Innes to the maps and heritage register.
6386-
123
Whenua
whenua
Add Te Taurere [Tayor Hill], Glen Innes to the maps and sites of significance to mana
whenua.
6386-
124
Whenua
of value to Mana Whenua Add Te Taurere [Tayor Hill], Glen Innes to the maps and mana whenua register.
6386-
125
Heritage
Places Add Puketutu Island, Mangere to the maps and heritage register.
6386-
126
Whenua
whenua Add Puketutu Island, Mangere to the maps and sites of significance to mana whenua.
6386-
127
Whenua
of value to Mana Whenua Add Puketutu Island, Mangere to the maps and mana whenua register.
6386-
128
Heritage
Places Add Wiroa Island, Mangere to the maps and heritage register.
270/1145
Sub#/
6386-
129
Whenua
whenua Add Wiroa Island, Mangere to the maps and sites of significance to mana whenua.
6386-
130
Whenua
of value to Mana Whenua Add Wiroa Island, Mangere to the maps mana whenua register.
6386-
131
Heritage
Places Add Shark Island, Te Karaka to the maps and heritage register.
6386-
132
Whenua
whenua Add Shark Island, Te Karaka to the maps and sites of significance to mana whenua.
6386-
133
Whenua
of value to Mana Whenua Add Shark Island, Te Karaka to the maps and mana whenua register.
6386-
134
Heritage
Places Add Pukekaroa Pa, Auckland Domain to the maps and heritage register.
6386-
135
Whenua
whenua Add Pukekaroa Pa, Auckland Domain to the maps and sites of significance to mana whenua.
6386-
136
Whenua
of value to Mana Whenua Add Pukekaroa Pa, Auckland Domain the maps and mana whenua register.
6386-
137
Heritage
Places Add Pukeiti Pa, Ihumatao to the maps and heritage register.
6386-
138
Whenua
whenua Add Pukeiti Pa, Ihumatao to the maps and sites of significance to mana whenua.
6386-
139
Whenua
of value to Mana Whenua Add Pukeiti Pa, Ihumatao the maps and mana whenua register.
6386-
140
Heritage
Places Add Waituarua Pa, Mangere to the maps and heritage register.
6386-
141
Whenua
whenua Add Waituarua Pa, Mangere to the maps and sites of significance to mana whenua.
6386-
142
Whenua
of value to Mana Whenua Add Waituarua Pa, Mangere the maps and mana whenua register.
6386-
143
Heritage
Places Add Moerangi Pa, Ihumatao to the maps and heritage register.
6386-
144
Whenua
whenua Add Moerangi Pa, Ihumatao to the maps and sites of significance to mana whenua.
6386-
145
Whenua
of value to Mana Whenua Add Moerangi Pa, Ihumatao the maps and mana whenua register.
6386-
146
Heritage
Places Add Te Maketu Pa, Papakura to the maps and heritage register.
6386-
147
Whenua
whenua Add Te Maketu Pa, Papakura to the maps and sites of significance to mana whenua.
6386-
148
Whenua
of value to Mana Whenua Add Te Maketu Pa, Papakura the maps and mana whenua register.
6386-
149
Heritage
Places Add Te Aparangi Pa, Red Hill to the maps and heritage register.
271/1145
Sub#/
6386-
150
Whenua
whenua Add Te Aparangi Pa, Red Hill to the maps and sites of significance to mana whenua.
6386-
151
Whenua
of value to Mana Whenua Add Te Aparangi Pa, Red Hill the maps and mana whenua register.
6386-
152
Whenua
Retain the approach to require cultural impact assessments for works either on or in proximity
to sites and places of significance and value to Mana Whenua at Clause 5 but ensure that
there is the ability for Mana Whenua to waive this requirement where consultation has agreed
this to be the case.
6386-
153
Whenua J5.1 Rules
to sites and places of significance and value to Mana Whenua at Clause 5 but ensure that
6386-
154
Whenua
and policies
to sites and places of significance and value to Mana Whenua at Clause E.5 but ensure that
6386-
155
Whenua J5.2 Rules
to sites and places of significance and value to Mana Whenua at Clause J5 but ensure that
6386-
156
assessment Retain the provisions at G.2.7.4 Cultural Impact Assessment.
6386-
157
Trust nickr@barker.co.nz RPS Urban growth
2010
Retain Clause 4(a)(iv) relating to cultural landscape and cultural impact assessment
requirements.
6386-
158
features
Amend existing sections such as ONF/ONL to incorporate provisions that recognise and deal
with the protection and enhancement and to consider the impacts of use and development on
cultural landscapes. Refer to page 13-14/27
6386-
159
Fig. 1
Amend to provide reference to cultural landscapes in various chapters, objectives, policies,
rules and assessment criteria where required.
6386-
160
character and natural heritage B4.3 Natural heritage Retain all objectives and policies.
6386-
161
Trust nickr@barker.co.nz
Outstanding Natural
Rules
Character - Coastal
Amend the maps so that the character overlays apply to the full extent of a natural feature or
landscape.
6386-
162
(ONF) Rules
Features Overlay
Amend the maps so that the ONF overlays apply to the full extent of a natural feature or
landscape.
6386-
163
Outstanding Natural
Rules
Outstanding Natural
Landscapes
Amend the maps so that the ONL overlays apply to the full extent of a natural feature or
landscape.
6386-
164
Trust nickr@barker.co.nz Infrastructure
C1.1 Infrastructure
policies
Add new objectives and policies which discourage infrastructure from locating in waterways,
significant landscapes, coastal areas, public open spaces and the like and avoiding significant
effects on these features and zones.
6386-
165
Energy
Amend rule framework so that this section is significantly amended to afford a more restrictive
planning regime to infrastructure, particularly in open space zones and maunga.
6386-
166
Energy H1.1 Activity table 1.2 - Roads
planning regime to infrastructure, particularly in open space zones and maunga to address the
concerns in this submission.
6386-
167
Trust nickr@barker.co.nz Transport Auckland -wide
Notification
planning regime to infrastructure, particularly in open space zones and maunga to address the
concerns in this submission.
6386-
168
Trust nickr@barker.co.nz RPS Coastal B7 Strategic
Amend the objectives and policies for all Coastal zones and relevant Precincts to avoid
further reclamation of harbours and coast, except where such works provide a positive
environmental gain or improve public accessibility. The latter should be appropriately
managed.
272/1145
Sub#/
6386-
169
environment
Amend the objectives and policies and rules to discourage infrastructure from locating on the
coast and harbours.
6386-
170
Trust nickr@barker.co.nz RPS Coastal B7 Strategic
Amend the objectives and policies to recognise the cultural importance of the coast to mana
whenua.
6386-
171
Trust nickr@barker.co.nz RPS Coastal B7 Strategic Retain provisions that prevent further reclamation for the Ports and Infrastructure activities.
6386-
172
the CMA
declamation I6.1.1 Activity table
Amend the provisions in the coastal zones so that reclamation is a non-complying activity
(prohibited in some instances) in all coastal areas (including Port areas) and other sections of
the PAUP may promote similar activity statuses (i.e. precincts) and consequential
amendments are sought where required to achieve the intent of this submission point.
6386-
173
controls Amend the rules at I.6 to facilitate projects that result in a positive environmental gain.
6386-
174
C1.1 Infrastructure
policies
Amend the relevant rules in Part 3G, H, I, J, K so that infrastructure is not afforded permitted
activity status where proposed in waterways or the coast.
6386-
175
streams & wetland
table
Amend generally to provide greater protection to all streams, lakes and wetlands in the region,
not just waterways that are classified as high value.
6386-
176
B6.3 Freshwater and
Geothermal Water
Amend to ensure that all objectives, policies and methods relevant to water quality and
waterways incorporate mtauranga Mori values into the assessment, management,
monitoring and restoration of marine and fresh water resources
6386-
177
streams & wetland
C5.14 Background &
Objectives
Retain objectives which require the protection of, and avoidance of adverse effects, on
streams, wetlands and lakes.
6386-
178
streams & wetland
Stock Access
Retain policies which require the protection of, and avoidance of adverse effects, on streams,
wetlands and lakes.
6386-
179
streams & wetland
table and controls H4.13.2.7
Retain policies which require the protection of, and avoidance of adverse effects, on streams,
wetlands and lakes.
6386-
180
streams & wetland
C5.14 Background &
Objectives
Amend objectives to ensure that protection and enhancement of all streams, lakes and
wetlands in the region is a key objective and include supporting policies.
6386-
181
streams & wetland
C5.14 Background &
Objectives
Amend policies to ensure that protection and enhancement of all streams, lakes and wetlands
in the region is a key objective and include supporting policies.
6386-
182
streams & wetland
Amend objectives to ensure that protection and enhancement of all streams, lakes and
wetlands in the region is a key objective and include supporting policies.
6386-
183
streams & wetland
Stock Access
Amend policies to ensure that the enhancement and restoration is a key objective and policy
and that this outcome is given priority over other outcomes.
6386-
184
streams & wetland
Stock Access
Amend objectives to ensure that the enhancement and restoration is a key objective and
policy and that this outcome is given priority over other outcomes.
6386-
185
streams & wetland
Amend policies to ensure that the enhancement and restoration is a key objective and policy
and that this outcome is given priority over other outcomes.
6386-
186
policies
Objectives
Amend objectives to: enhance water quality, the mauri of waterways and coastal areas,
restore degraded streams, encourage green engineering, avoid structures, modifications of
waterways and ongoing discharges and give effect to these [in policies 1-23]. Refer to page
16 of submission for more detail.
6386-
187
Objectives
16/27 of submission for more detail.
6386-
188
streams & wetland
C5.14 Background &
Objectives
273/1145
Sub#/
6386-
189
quality
waterways and ongoing discharges and give effect to these in the policies. Refer to page
6386-
190
streams & wetland
C5.14 Background &
Objectives
Amend the objectives of Part 2 to identify that all freshwater environments provide ecological
functions, contaminant removal and habitat and give effect to this in policies [1-11] Refer to
page 16/27 of submission for more detail.
6386-
191
streams & wetland
Stock Access Retain Policy 4, 5, 6, 9 & 10 as they relate to mana whenua values and mauri.
6386-
192
streams & wetland
Stock Access Retain Policy 3 relating to no net loss and like for like mitigation.
6386-
193
streams & wetland
Stock Access Amend to include an objective or policy which encourages day- lighting of streams.
6386-
194
streams & wetland
Overlay E7.4 Natural Stream
Management Area
Amend the criteria for Natural Stream Management Area so that a greater number of streams
are afforded the highest level of stream protection.
6386-
195
streams & wetland
table
Amend the approach to streams, lakes and wetland rules. Modification of all streams should
be afforded restricted discretionary activity status as a minimum, and preferably a higher order
activity status such as discretionary activity or non-complying consent; and amend the
activities status for land reclamation to a non-complying activity.
6386-
196
streams & wetland
C5.14 Background &
Objectives
Amend to facilitate a permissive planning regime for works that enhance waterways such as
day-lighting streams.
6386-
197
streams & wetland
H4.13.2 - 3 Controls excld.
stock access/Assessment
Amend so no net loss and like for like mitigation is adequately addressed either in the
standards or assessment matters / criteria.
6386-
198
streams & wetland
Stock Access
Amend so no net loss and like for like mitigation is adequately addressed either in the
standards or assessment matters / criteria.
6386-
199
streams & wetland
table Amend to provide for day-lighting of streams as a permitted activity.
6386-
200
streams & wetland
table
Amend the provisions to include a comprehensive set of criteria for works and activities in
waterways regardless of their activity status.
6386-
201
Trust nickr@barker.co.nz Water Stormwater H4.14 Introduction
Amend the provisions so that green engineering methods are afforded a more favourable
activity status over traditional engineering solutions.
6386-
202
streams & wetland
Management Area Amend Maps to include Oruarangi Creek
6386-
203
streams & wetland
Management Area Amend Maps to include Puhinui Creek.
6386-
204
streams & wetland
Management Area Amend Maps to include Paremoremo Creek.
6386-
205
streams & wetland
Management Area Amend Maps to include Otaimako Creek.
6386-
206
streams & wetland
Management Area Amend Maps to include Mangere o Waokauri Creek.
6386-
207
streams & wetland
Management Area Amend Maps to include Pukaki Creek.
6386-
208
streams & wetland
Management Area Amend Maps to include Te Wai o Taikehu (Tamaki River) and tributary arms.
6386-
209
B6.3 Freshwater and
Geothermal Water
Amend approach to stormwater, water and wastewater to provide a higher level of
remediation and mitigation, ideally infrastructure providers should aim to achieve net positive
gains for new infrastructure or discharges.
274/1145
Sub#/
6386-
210
environment
Amend and strengthen objectives and policies to discourage infrastructure development in
waterways and coastal areas throughout the region.
6386-
211
B6.3 Freshwater and
Geothermal Water
Amend and strengthen objectives and policies to discourage infrastructure development in
waterways and coastal areas throughout the region
6386-
212
Trust nickr@barker.co.nz Water Wastewater
management rules
Amend the discharge provisions so that a more restrictive rule regime is established with non-
complying activity consents required for discharges.
6386-
213
Trust nickr@barker.co.nz Water Wastewater
management rules
Retain the criteria which requires mana whenua values to be considered with respect to any
discharges.
6386-
214
Trust nickr@barker.co.nz Water Stormwater
rules Amend so that the mauri of water is a criterion for assessment.
6386-
215
Trust nickr@barker.co.nz Trees
Amend the objectives and policies to require native planting in streets and open spaces; and
to allow exotic planting in the case of fruit trees and community edible gardens.
6386-
216
Trust nickr@barker.co.nz Trees
streets and public open space H3.1 Rules
Amend provisions so that exotic vegetation is a restricted discretionary activity with
assessment criteria requiring an application to consider whether a suitable native plant can be
substituted; and to provide for fruit trees and edible gardens as a permitted activity in streets
and public open space.
6386-
217
Amend so indigenous planting is required over exotic planting to support biodiversity
outcomes
6386-
218
SEAs
and policies Amend so no net loss of biodiversity is required.
6386-
219
Retain SEA approach in principle, amend to include clear objectives and policy framework for
terrestrial SEAs [refer to pages 19-20/27 of submission for more detail]; and request that
Council undertake a full and thorough assessment of SEAs in the region prior to the hearing
to ensure that the application of SEAs is appropriate.
6386-
220
Amend to incentivise good practice for example works that enhance or restore SEAs or the
appreciation and education of SEAs should be afforded permitted activity status.
6386-
221
organisms
modified organisms Delete GM activities and experiments in the Auckland Region.
6386-
222
Trust nickr@barker.co.nz Precincts - South Mngere Gateway
Amend the Mangere Gateway precinct provisions at F.6.15 and K.6.15 so that full
consideration is given to cultural values and landscapes, and sites of significance / Whi tapu
areas. ]
6386-
223
Trust nickr@barker.co.nz Zoning South
Retain the Rural Production zone in the Puhinui area on land either side of Puhunui Road,
east of the Southwestern Motorway and east of the airport.
6386-
224
Trust nickr@barker.co.nz Zoning South Retain the Public Open Space Conservation zone at Pukaki Crater and Crater Hill.
6386-
225
(ONF) Rules
Features Overlay Retain the ONF overlay of Pukaki Crater and Carter Hill.
6386-
226
Trust nickr@barker.co.nz Zoning South Rezone Puketutu Island to Public Open Space Conservation zone and Mori Purposes zone.
6386-
227
(ONF) Rules
Features Overlay Retain the ONF overlay of Puketutu Island and extend to cover the entire island.
6386-
228
Trust nickr@barker.co.nz Zoning South Retain the Public Open Space Conservation zoning of Otuataua Stonefields, Mangere.
6386-
229
Trust nickr@barker.co.nz RPS Changes to the RUB South Delete Future Urban zoning around Otuataua Stonefields, Mangere.
6386-
230
(ONF) Rules
Features Overlay
Retain ONF overlay at Otuataua Stonefields, Mangere and extend this overlay over the entire
feature.
6386-
231
Fig. 1 Add a cultural landscape overlay to Otuataua Stonefields, Mangere
6386-
232
Trust nickr@barker.co.nz Zoning Auckland-wide
Retain Public Open Space zoning of the maunga[Mountain, mount or peak. Also refers to
volcanic cones] of the city
6386-
233
Whenua
Add a site and place of significance overlay to the entire maunga extent irrespective of title
boundaries.
275/1145
Sub#/
6386-
234
participation
Amend part 2 objectives and policies to ensure that the significant importance of maunga in
the objectives and policies framework is elevated and strengthened in all relevant chapters
and retain objectives and policies that have been drafted to recognise the importance of
maunga and their relationship with mana whenua in the various chapters of Part 2.
6386-
235
C1.1 Infrastructure
policies Amend objectives and policies so infrastructure on maunga is avoided.
6386-
236
Trust nickr@barker.co.nz Public Open Space Zones Public Open Space D2 Introduction Amend objectives and policies of open space zones so infrastructure on maunga is avoided
6386-
237
Trust nickr@barker.co.nz Public Open Space Zones Public Open Space D2 Introduction
Amend the objectives and policies of the open space zones and zones which relate to
regional parks to provide for the customary use / and or cultural activities to be undertaken on
this land.
6386-
238
Trust nickr@barker.co.nz Public Open Space Zones Public Open Space I2.1 Activity table
Amend I.2.1 Public Open Space zones so that grazing of animals and fencing is provided for
as a Restricted Discretionary activity.
6386-
239
Remove any link to precinct plan, or adopted reserve management plan, conservation
management strategy or conservation management plan in terms of any activity status rule or
development control and insert activities into the Activity Table.
6386-
240
Remove the Permitted Activity status for structures/buildings on maunga and require
meaningful consultation with tangata whenua.
6386-
241
Trust nickr@barker.co.nz Public Open Space Zones Public Open Space I2.1 Activity table Remove the Permitted Activity status for underground network utilities on maunga.
6386-
242
Trust nickr@barker.co.nz Precincts - South New Precincts All other New Precincts
Add findings of the structure planning exercise at Puhinui; incorporate in the final
development of the PAUP in consultation with the hapu.
6386-
243
Trust nickr@barker.co.nz General Miscellaneous Other
Adopt the relief sought by the Independent Mori Statutory Board submission. Particularly the
integration of regional and district provisions, Mori involvement, use of Treaty Settlement
land , providing for customary use in all zones and cultural heritage provisions. Provide for
such instances in the objectives policies and methods.
6387-1 McManus Family Trust iain@civitas.co.nz Zoning Central
Retain Single House zoning for properties along Hamilton Road, south of Sarsfield Street,
Herne Bay.
6387-2 McManus Family Trust iain@civitas.co.nz Special Character
& C J3.3.1-7 Rules Remove rule 4.3 'Height in relation to boundary for sites identified within figure 2'.
6387-3 McManus Family Trust iain@civitas.co.nz Special Character
& C J3.3.1-7 Rules
Remove rule 4.4 'Exceptions/qualifications to height in relation to boundary for Isthmus A and
Isthmus C1' and replace with: The exceptions to the height in relation to boundary control for
the Single House zone contained in Part 3, Chapter I, Rule 1.6.3 apply to the Special
Character - Residential Isthmus A and C1 overlays.
6388-1 Darby Partners Limited peter.hall@boffamiskell.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - Rural zones
zones only
Amend to provide for rural subdivision as a Restricted Discretionary activity in the Rural
Coastal Zone.
6388-2 Darby Partners Limited peter.hall@boffamiskell.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - general
and policies Amend to enable rural subdivision.
6388-3 Darby Partners Limited peter.hall@boffamiskell.co.nz Rural Zones General
objectives & policies Amend to enable rural subdivision.
6388-4 Darby Partners Limited peter.hall@boffamiskell.co.nz Public Open Space Zones Public Open Space I2.1 Activity table
Amend to provide for 'mineral extraction' in Public Open Space zones as a Discretionary
activity.
6388-5 Darby Partners Limited peter.hall@boffamiskell.co.nz
the CMA
Retain the Discretionary activity status for CMCA [common marine and coastal area] mineral
extraction in the General Coastal Marine zone.
the CMA
Amend to provide for CMCA [common marine and coastal area] mineral extraction in SEA
M2, HNC and ONL as a Discretionary activity.
the CMA
Amend to provide for CMCA [common marine and coastal area] mineral extraction in ONF
type C as a Discretionary activity.
6388-8 Darby Partners Limited peter.hall@boffamiskell.co.nz Rural Zones General I13.1 Activity table Retain the Permitted activity status for dwellings within the Rural Coastal zone.
6388-9 Darby Partners Limited peter.hall@boffamiskell.co.nz Rural Zones General I13.1 Activity table
Amend to provide for mineral extraction within the Rural Coastal zone as
a Discretionary activity.
6388-10 Darby Partners Limited peter.hall@boffamiskell.co.nz Rural Zones General I13.1 Activity table Retain Permitted activity status for dwellings in the Rural Coastal Zone.
6388-11 Darby Partners Limited peter.hall@boffamiskell.co.nz Rural Zones General I13.2 Land use controls Delete Land Use Control 2.6.1 'dwellings' clause (b) and (d).
6388-12 Darby Partners Limited peter.hall@boffamiskell.co.nz Rural Zones General I13.2 Land use controls
Amend 2.6.1(c) to replace 'a title issued under the Land Transfer Act 1952' to 'an allotment as
defined in the Resource Management Act 1991'.
276/1145
Sub#/
6388-13 Darby Partners Limited peter.hall@boffamiskell.co.nz Rural Zones General I13.2 Land use controls
Amend so that any dwelling that does not comply with rule 2.6(2) 'dwellings' is a Restricted
6388-14 Darby Partners Limited peter.hall@boffamiskell.co.nz Rural Zones General I13.3 Development controls Retain 3.5 'size of buildings', insofar as it does not apply to residential buildings.
6389-1 Sarah K George sarahgeorge33@me.com Special Character
residential
special character areas Retain provisions that protect character areas.
6389-2 Sarah K George sarahgeorge33@me.com Special Character
residential
Add Special Character overlay to Moa Road, Huia Road, Kiwi Road, Walmer Road, Riro
Street, Target Street, Montrose Street, Alberta Street, Miller Street, Smale Street and Formby
Avenue, Point Chevalier.
6389-3 Sarah K George sarahgeorge33@me.com Zoning Central
Rezone sites in Point Chevalier from Mixed Housing Urban and Mixed Housing Suburban to
Single House if they were identified as Single House in the March Draft of the Unitary Plan.
Amend the extent of Mixed Housing Urban so that it does not extend past 500m of
the Point Chevalier town centre.
Amend the extent of Mixed Housing Suburban so that it does not extend past 500m of
the Point Chevalier town centre.
6389-6 Sarah K George sarahgeorge33@me.com RPS Urban growth
quality compact urban form Reject concept of intensification and RUB.
Rezone the Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings at Huia Street, Kiwi Street, Tui Street,
Moa Street, Walmer Street and Riro Street to a more appropriate zone [preferred zone not
specified].
6390-1 Richard Court rc.7@hotmail.co.uk Zoning North and Islands
Rezone 18, 20 and 22 Willow Avenue, Birkenhead from Mixed Housing Urban to Single
House.
6391-1
Dairy Flat West Landowners
Group peterr@catobolam.co.nz Zoning North and Islands
Rezone the land bounded by Dairy Flat Highway, Kaihikitea Flat Road, Selman Road and
Wilks Road West from Mixed Rural to Countryside Living.
6392-1 A and O Pepers odette.pepers@glaister.co.nz Zoning West
Rezone the area between Great North Road and Manhattan Heights from Terrace Housing
and Apartment Buildings to Mixed Housing Suburban or Mixed Housing Urban. Refer to plan
on page 8/16 of submission.
6392-2 A and O Pepers odette.pepers@glaister.co.nz Residential zones Residential
Add more regulatory control over the design and amenity of developments in the Terrace
Housing and Apartment Building zone.
Add rules requiring development in Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings zone to be in
keeping with the surrounding, existing development and not in a scale and form that
differentiates from the well established neighbourhoods.
Amend rule 9.12 'Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings - Outdoor Living Space' to require
more outdoor living space for families.
6392-5 A and O Pepers odette.pepers@glaister.co.nz Built Environment (Overlays)
Height Control
Add an 'Additional Height Overlay' limiting height to 2 storeys to the area between Great North
Rd and Manhattan Heights, Glendene. Refer to plan on page 8/16 of the submission.
6393-1 P Coetzee
PO Box 38383, Howick, Auckland
2145 Residential zones Residential Land use controls Delete [rule 3.2 Home occupations] home occupation provisions.
6393-2 P Coetzee
2145 Subdivision Auckland-wide - Urban zones H5.2 3.1 Residential zones
Retain provisions which make the creation of a lot under 750m2 in the Hill Park, Manurewa
area a Non Complying activity.
6393-3 P Coetzee
& C
Isthmus Extend the Special Character Overlay Isthmus B2 to include Hill Park, Manurewa.
6394-1
Westhaven Investments
Limited lovett.j@woosh.co.nz Precincts - City Centre Wynyard K3.14 Precinct Rules
Amend precinct rules for maximum building height from 5m to 7m for the area marked on Map
1, page 3/5 of the submission.
6394-2
Add new activities 'travellers accommodation' and 'car parking buildings' as Restricted
Discretionary activities in Precinct area 3 (refer to Map 3 in submission, page 5/5).
6394-3
Amend precinct rules for maximum height to 21.5m for the area marked on Map 2, page 3/5
of submission.
6395-1 G Catley plandemonium@xtra.co.nz Historic Heritage (Overlay)
Heritage
Places
Delete Catley House (ID 1087) at 46 Quebec Road as a Historic Heritage Place and Historic
Heritage Extent of Place.
6396-1
Auckland Indian Association
Incorporated tit.law@xtra.co.nz
Centre) Business
Park zones Allow multiple level development at 145 & 155 New North Road [increase the height limit].
6397-1
Mount Wellington Licensing
Trust l.boyle@auckland.ac.nz Zoning Central
Retain the Mixed Use zone for the Waipuna Hotel and Conference Centre at 58 Waipuna
Road, Mt Wellington.
6397-2
Trust l.boyle@auckland.ac.nz Zoning Central Retain the Town Centre zone for Panmure Historic Hotel at 163 Queens Road, Panmure.
6397-3
Trust l.boyle@auckland.ac.nz Zoning Central
Rezone St Patrick's Catholic Cemetery on Church Crescent, Panmure to a Special Purpose
or Public Open Space zone.
277/1145
Sub#/
6398-1 Steven Hill sha.design@xtra.co.nz RPS
character and natural heritage B4.3.4 Biodiversity Delete SEAs from the PAUP.
6398-2 Steven Hill sha.design@xtra.co.nz
SEAs
Amend activity table to provide for clearing up to 10m3 within the SEA overlay for the
purposes other than building a dwelling. ['NA' is interpreted as Not Allowed instead of Not
Applicable]
6398-3 Steven Hill sha.design@xtra.co.nz Mana Whenua General provisions
assessment
Amend to exclude single family dwellings from the requirement for a Cultural Impact
Assessment.
6398-4 Steven Hill sha.design@xtra.co.nz Precincts - West
Area K7.9.4 Rules (sub-precinct D)
Amend height controls to revert to the operative [Waitakere District Plan] Height in Relation to
Boundary rules, and operative definitions of 'height' and 'elevation height'.
6399-1 Brian Fairchild secretary@nzsda.org.nz General C7.4/H6.3 Signs
Delete rule (1) [inferred] to remove restricted discretionary activity status for signs (except
billboards) associated with a comprehensive development and address matter with a bylaw.
6400-1 Alex Loudon alex.loudon@siemens.com General Miscellaneous
Operational/
Projects/Acquisition Provide for cycling infrastructure
6401-1 Hemant Kalyanji hamistheman@gmail.com Zoning South Rezone 7a Earlsworth Road, Mangere East from Single House to Mixed Housing.
6402-1 Elizabeth S Chamley tibby@actrix.co.nz
SEAs
Land Delete the SEA overlay from 238 Anawhata Road, Anawhata.
6402-2 Elizabeth S Chamley tibby@actrix.co.nz Precincts - West
Area K7.9.2 Rules (sub-precinct B) Amend Rule 2.1.2 'Dwellings' to enable multiple dwellings at 238 Anawhata Road, Anawhata.
Amend the Activity table to provide for multiple dwellings at 238 Anawhata Road, Anawhata,
as a Restricted Discretionary activity.
Amend the matters for discretion to only address limiting the impact small dwelling locations
would have on ecology, by keeping away from areas of particular importance.
Amend subdivision controls to allow new lots to be created with road access for multiple
dwellings at 238 Anawhata Road, Anawhata.
6402-6 Elizabeth S Chamley tibby@actrix.co.nz
SEAs
table - Vegetation
roads
Amend Activity table to allow vegetation removal for the purpose of the creation of walking
tracks as a Permitted activity.
Area
Retain the approach taken for land in the Waitakere Ranges and Bush Living precinct,
whereby established rural and residential activities are able to continue but with a
conservative approach to new land uses, subdivision and development in order to protect
natural values.
6403-1 Clifford P Mason cliff.mason@hotmail.com RPS Urban growth
Add to the discussion of population to establish a maximum carrying capacity under the
present infrastructure constraints cognisant of the existence of past and current damage to
the natural environment of the region. Plan for constrained growth to a future limit in accord
with the planned rate of development of new infrastructure capability and with the limits of
amenity and character as identified and preferred by the city's residents.
6404-1 Gay L Bevan gaybevan@gmail.com Historic Heritage (Overlay)
Heritage
Places
Remove the Historic Heritage listing from the entirety of Lot 1 DP 199409, 14 Whitford-
Maraetai Road. If the listing is not removed, the alternative is to amend the Historic Heritage
Extent of Place so that it excludes the Shed; and the area on Lot 1 DP 199409 between the
Former Garage and the Shed.
6404-2 Gay L Bevan gaybevan@gmail.com Precincts - South Whitford Village
Amend Objective 1 as follows: 'Subdivision and development within the Whitford Village is
designed and implemented in a comprehensive, efficient and integrated manner that protects
its historic heritage, creates a distinct village centre which facilitates social interactions,
avoiding ad hoc development.
Amend the activity status of 'Warehousing and Storage' in the Neighbourhood Centre zone
from non-complying to permitted for the site at 14 Whitford-Maraetai Road (1.3 Business 1
'Centres and Mixed Use zones and the General Business and Business Park zones' Activity
Table). If the preferred amendment is not successful, two alternatives are proposed involving
amendements to the precinct rules - refer to pages 4-5 of the submission.
Amend the activity status of ligh manufacturing and servicing on the site at 14 Whitford-
Maraetai Road. If the preferred amendment is not successful, two alternatives are proposed
involving amendements to the precinct rules - refer to pages 5-6 of the submission.
Delete Objective 7. [Whitford Village has a sustainable reticulated water
supply, wastewater treatment, disposal system and stormwater infrastructure].
Amend Policy 9 as follows: Restrict new development in Whitford Village occurring ahead of
connections being available to reticulated wastewater treatment and disposal system
constructed to any applicable industry-standard and provided by developers of land within
Whitford Village, unless the developer can demonstrate there is sufficient provision for roof
water collection to meet the servicing demands expected by activities on the site.
278/1145
Sub#/
6405-1 Pukekohe Swimming Club kjjhmcrew@gmail.com General Miscellaneous
Operational/
Projects/Acquisition Provide funded regional recreational facilities in Franklin.
6406-1 Tim Roberts tim@robertsfamily.co.nz Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
Delete parking minimums from the Mixed Housing Urban and Mixed Housing Suburban
zones.
6406-2 Tim Roberts tim@robertsfamily.co.nz Zoning Central
Rezone the area around Meadowbank Train Station to either the Terrace Housing and
Apartment Buildings and/or the Mixed Housing Urban zone.
6406-3 Tim Roberts tim@robertsfamily.co.nz Zoning Central
Rezone Great South Road, between Greenlane East/West and Main Highway, from the Light
Industrial zone to the Mixed Use zone.
6407-1 Ellerslie Cricket Club manager@ellersliecricket.co.nz Public Open Space Zones
D2.3 Sport & Active
pols Retain Objective 2.
6408-1 William Bott bollybitt@gmail.com RPS Mana Whenua B5 Strategic [Remove Mana Whenua provisions.]
6408-2 William Bott bollybitt@gmail.com General Whole Plan Reject PAUP in its entirety.
6409-1 Paul Walker alton10@xtra.co.nz Residential zones Residential
Mixed Housing Urban zone Retain rule 7.3 'Height in relation to boundary'.
6409-2 Paul Walker alton10@xtra.co.nz Residential zones Residential
Mixed Housing Urban zone Remove rule 7.4.3 'Alternative height in relation to boundary'.
6410-1 John E Sexton josexton@xtra.co.nz General Miscellaneous Other Adopt the relief sought in the submission by Federated Farmers of NZ.
6410-2 John E Sexton josexton@xtra.co.nz Rural Zones
desc, obs & pols
Retain 'proposed Rural Conservation Zones as in the draft plan' [unclear which version
referring to].
6410-3 John E Sexton josexton@xtra.co.nz Rural Zones General I13.1 Activity table
Retain permitted activity status for farming in the 'Rural Conservation Zone as proposed in the
draft plan' [unclear which version referring to].
6410-4 John E Sexton josexton@xtra.co.nz Rural Zones General I13.1 Activity table Retain permitted activity status for forestry in Rural Coastal zone.
6410-5 John E Sexton josexton@xtra.co.nz Rural Zones General I13.2 Land use controls Retain the rural rule that allows 1 dwelling on titles less than 40ha.
6410-6 John E Sexton josexton@xtra.co.nz Rural Zones General I13.2 Land use controls Retain the rural rule that allows 2 dwellings on titles greater than 40ha.
6410-7 John E Sexton josexton@xtra.co.nz Rural Zones General I13.2 Land use controls Retain the rural rule that allows 3 dwellings on titles greater than 100ha.
6410-8 John E Sexton josexton@xtra.co.nz Water
streams & wetland
table and controls H4.13.2.7 Retain stock exclusion from waterways policy.
6410-9 John E Sexton josexton@xtra.co.nz Infrastructure
Transmission Corridor J1.4 Rules and mapping Retain 'Transpower Transmission Corridor' rules [Electricity Transmission Corridor].
6410-10 John E Sexton josexton@xtra.co.nz Earthworks H4.2.1.1 Activity table - Zones Retain permitted activity status for new tracks greater than 50m long [inferred for rural zones].
6410-11 John E Sexton josexton@xtra.co.nz Rural Zones General I13.3 Development controls Retain exclusion of rules relating to impermeable surfaces in rural zones.
6410-12 John E Sexton josexton@xtra.co.nz RPS Urban growth
Retain exclusion of provisions relating to windfall gains on rezoned land that were included in
the March Draft Unitary Plan.
6410-13 John E Sexton josexton@xtra.co.nz
Rural Discharges,
Biosolids
Discharges
Retain rule 2.1.3 Use and discharge of fertilizer to land, subject to amendment of rule
(1)(b)(c)(d) to 20m [unclear which version of Unitary Plan referring to].
Rural Discharges,
Biosolids
Discharges
Retain rule 2.1.2 relating to dairy effluent discharges, subject to amendment of the rule 'that
says effluent cannot be sprayed closer then 100 metres from a boundary and 250 metres from
a neighbouring dwelling'. Amend this to be 20m from a boundary and 50m from a
neighbouring dwelling [unclear which rules or version of the Unitary Plan this refers to].
6410-15 John E Sexton josexton@xtra.co.nz RPS
Retain provisions for SEAs subject to amendment that would require landowners 'to apply to
have SES's recognized and their protection incentivised by not paying rates on the area under
SEA protection'.
Outstanding Natural
Rules
Notification
Delete provision that would require a resource consent when planting forestry in ONL area
[amend activity status to permitted].
6410-17 John E Sexton josexton@xtra.co.nz Definitions Existing Amend definition of farming to include farm forestry.
6410-18 John E Sexton josexton@xtra.co.nz RPS Natural resources
Organisms Delete all provisions relating to GMOs.
6410-19 John E Sexton josexton@xtra.co.nz Zoning South
Rezone sites affected by decision of [Franklin] Plan Change 14 so that extent of Rural Coastal
zone is the same as decided in Plan Change 14.
6410-20 John E Sexton josexton@xtra.co.nz Rural Zones General I13.1 Activity table
Amend farming rules in Rural Coastal zone so that they are the same as in the other rural
zones.
6410-21 John E Sexton josexton@xtra.co.nz General Chapter G General provisions
Revise the resource consent processes and practices including time
frames especially when additional information is required.
279/1145
Sub#/
6410-22 John E Sexton josexton@xtra.co.nz Mana Whenua
Whenua
and policies
Delete the Sites and Places of Significance and Value to Mana Whenua overlays in their
current form until consultation has taken place and modified provisions have been prepared.
6411-1 Rolf and Peter Masfen michael@campbellbrown.co.nz Special Character
& C
Isthmus Delete the overlay from sites 102 and 102A St Stephens Avenue and 12 Rota Place. Parnell.
6412-1 Nina Thomas nlevien@hotmail.com Precincts - North Bayswater
objectives and policies Remove all references to residential activities and/or development.
6412-2 Nina Thomas nlevien@hotmail.com Precincts - North Bayswater K5.6 Precinct rules
Amend rule clause 2 'Notification' to require full public notification of resource consents for
any future residential development within the Bayswater Marina precinct.
6412-3 Nina Thomas nlevien@hotmail.com Precincts - North Bayswater K5.6 Precinct rules
Amend clause 1 'Activity table' to change the activity status of 'dwellings' in the Bayswater
Marina precinct from discretionary to non-complying.
6412-4 Nina Thomas nlevien@hotmail.com RPS Urban growth
Allow no further intensification within the Bayswater/Devonport peninsula until such a time as
existing infrastructure problems (including but not limited to traffic congestion on Lake Road)
have been addressed.
6413-1 Envivo Limited james.hook@envivo.co.nz Zoning South
Rezone 180 Chapel Road, Flat Bush to a zoning with provisions that 'are no more restrictive,
and that provide greater flexibility than those under the operative Flat Bush Residential 1,
Precinct- Barry Curtis Park zoning'.
6413-2 Envivo Limited james.hook@envivo.co.nz Precincts - South Flat Bush
Amend Activity table to provide for a broader range of activities at 180 Chapel Road, Flat
Bush.
Amend to increase the permitted building height at 180 Chapel Road, Flat Bush, by at least
50% above the controls applicable within the operative Flat Bush Residential 1, Precinct-
Barry Curtis Park zone.
Amend to increase the permitted development bulk at 180 Chapel Road, Flat Bush, by at
least 50% above the controls applicable within the operative Flat Bush Residential 1, Precinct-
6413-5 Envivo Limited james.hook@envivo.co.nz Zoning South
Rezone 170 Chapel Road, Flat Bush to a zoning with provisions that 'are no more restrictive,
and that provide greater flexibility than those under the operative Flat Bush Residential 1,
Precinct- Barry Curtis Park zoning'.
Amend Activity table to provide for a broader range of activities at 170 Chapel Road, Flat
Bush.
Amend to increase the permitted building height at 170 Chapel Road, Flat Bush, by at least
50% above the controls applicable within the operative Flat Bush Residential 1, Precinct-
Amend to increase the permitted development bulk at 170 Chapel Road, Flat Bush, by at
least 50% above the controls applicable within the operative Flat Bush Residential 1, Precinct-
6414-1 Auckland Trotting Club michael@campbellbrown.co.nz Precincts - South New Precincts All other New Precincts
Include a new Pukekohe Racing Precinct to create a harness racing facility which generally
relies upon the Alexandra Park Precinct objectives with a new objective specifically for
Pokekohe. A key component of the precinct is to ensure the objectives and policies provide
for the establishment of a mixed use development should harness racing not materialise [see
page 5-7/7 Volume 1 for specific rules to be included in the proposed precinct].
6414-2 Auckland Trotting Club michael@campbellbrown.co.nz Precincts - Central Alexandra Park Amend the precinct plan map [refer to page 8/17 Volume 2 of submission].
6414-3 Auckland Trotting Club michael@campbellbrown.co.nz
control
Building demolition control J.3.6 Rules and mapping Remove the Historic Heritage Overlay from Alexandra Park.
6414-4 Auckland Trotting Club michael@campbellbrown.co.nz Historic Heritage (Overlay)
Heritage
Places Remove ID 1686 Brick wall, iron gates and ticket booths (Alexandra Park).
6414-5 Auckland Trotting Club michael@campbellbrown.co.nz Precincts - Central Alexandra Park
Amend precinct description to provide for the establishment of a Mixed Use development
should harness racing not materialise [refer to page page 9/17 volume 2 of submission for
specific amendments].
Amend Policy 1 as follows: "Enable Alexandra Park to continue to be used for horse racing
and related activities for as long as the Auckland Trotting Club wishes to undertake such
activities ".
6414-7 Auckland Trotting Club michael@campbellbrown.co.nz Precincts - Central Alexandra Park Amend Policy 4 to include reference to Alexander Park.
Amend Policy 8 as follows "Encourage variation in building heights that create a sense of
visual interest within the precinct while protecting acknowledging while protecting informal
views to Cornwall Park".
Amend Policy 15 as follows "Encourage the development of framework plans to establish a
spatial pattern of development to integrate mixed use activities with the racing activities, or if
it occurs, ? guide the transition away from racing and to address integration of the sub-
precincts".
280/1145
Sub#/
Delete Activity Table 1 replace with a new activity table which provides for activities such as
framework plans, racing activities, buildings and structures and a wide range of business and
commerce activities etc [refer to page 12/17 - 14/17 of the submission for suggested activity
table].
Delete and replace with new development controls that relate to compliance with development
controls in the Mixed Use zone and Local Centre Zone, non-compliance, and insert new
development controls that relate to height, height in relation to boundary, maximum
impervious area, building cover and landscaping, yards, building setbacks, view shaft,
building length, noise, traffic and precinct plan [refer to page 14/17 - 16/17 of the submission
for specific rules proposed].
6414-12 Auckland Trotting Club michael@campbellbrown.co.nz Zoning Central
Rezone a portion of Alexander Park, Green Lane from Major Recreation Facility zone to
Mixed Use [refer to diagram 1 on page 7/17 of the submission for specific area to be
rezoned].
6415-1
New Zealand Council for
Infrastructure Development leonie.armstrong@nzcid.org.nz General Miscellaneous Other Adopt the relief sought by the Auckland Utilities Operator Group (AUOG) in their submission.
6415-2
Infrastructure Development leonie.armstrong@nzcid.org.nz RPS Issues New Issues Identify infrastructure as an issue of regional significance.
6415-3
Infrastructure Development leonie.armstrong@nzcid.org.nz RPS
Transport
and energy
Add a separate section within Chapter B of the RPS discussing infrastructure, most notably:
transport, water, energy and telecommunications.
6415-4
Transport
and energy
Add a new consolidated section for infrastructure within Chapter B of the RPS which
recognises infrastructure networks are critical to the function and performance of the region.
6415-5
Transport
and energy
recognises that existing infrastructure networks must be protected from new development and
inconsistent activities, including reverse sensitivity impacts.
6415-6
Transport
and energy
recognises that infrastructure operators must have access to assets to ensure their safe,
reliable and ongoing operation.
6415-7
Transport
and energy
recognises that infrastructure operations and their effects should where possible be mitigated,
but that many such effects are unavoidable and provision must be made to ensure the
ongoing operation of infrastructure.
6415-8
Transport
and energy
recognises that future infrastructure delivery is a necessary consequence of growth and that
the location of such infrastructure, including potential corridors and sites, must be identified
and protected.
6415-9
Infrastructure Development leonie.armstrong@nzcid.org.nz Infrastructure
C1.1 Infrastructure
policies
Seeks a greater emphasis in the PAUP around the unique qualities of network infrastructure
in order to avoid levying large costs upon the provision of essential services.
6415-10
Energy
Amend the PAUP so that network infrastructure is not solely subject to a place based [zoning]
approach.
6415-11
C1.1 Infrastructure
policies
Recognise that the network nature of infrastructure as currently planned will levy additional
costs on network operators, who must at all times conform to a large and variable number of
requirements along different parts of their networks.
6415-12
Infrastructure Development leonie.armstrong@nzcid.org.nz RPS Urban growth
Council to work closely with network providers to ensure services can be provided effectively
and efficiently.
6415-13
Add an activity clause that acknowledges heritage, Mana Whenua, natural landscapes and
other important factors; however this clause should also seek to remove as many exceptions
to standard network service access, operation and delivery as reasonable.
6415-14
Prioritise the efficiency of infrastructure delivery to avoid transferring costs onto residents and
businesses.
6415-15
Ensure that the Council engages with each network service provider to develop an agreed set
of rules and requirements for delivering respective critical services across the region.
6415-16
Infrastructure Development leonie.armstrong@nzcid.org.nz Designations G1.3 Designations Retain the designations outlined in the PAUP.
6415-17
Ensure that future corridors for major network infrastructure, such as state highways, rail lines,
electricity and gas transmission corridors and trunk water assets are planned for and
protected.
6415-18
land for urban development Re-estimate the costs of growth under a compact city approach.
6415-19
Prioritise growth in Auckland by taking into consideration existing network service capacity
over other factors.
281/1145
Sub#/
6415-20
Ensure that early and detailed engagement with network providers occurs when making
decisions about where to prioritise growth in Auckland.
6415-21
Council collaborates with network service providers to identify areas where services are
currently inadequate for new growth, but which may be enhanced in the near term at minimal
cost.
6415-22
Identify areas where network infrastructure lacks capacity and where additional capacity is not
feasible in the short term, when establishing new growth areas.
6415-23
Better phase growth so that areas with services are permitted or encouraged to grow sooner
and areas with inadequate services are deferred until those services are provided.
6415-24
Incentivise or disincentivise development as a way to manage growth eg.
waivering development contributions in areas with service capacity, or higher contributions
demanded in areas necessitating services sooner.
6415-25
Revise the prioritisation of [infrastructure] projects to meet growth and amend the PAUP so
growth is reallocated to reflect infrastructure capacity.
6415-26
land for urban development Place greater focus on land use-transport alignment and investment.
6415-27
Retain intensification approach of aligning strategic infrastructure investment with land use
planning; for example the location of intensification around rail stations and other public
transport corridors.
6415-28
Increase the level of city shaping transport investment and ensure that it is more
effectively integrated with land use.
6415-29
Locate new growth in areas which are accessible to public transport and avoid new growth
increases with poor access.
6415-30
land for urban development Place a much greater emphasis on maximising intensification opportunities.
6415-31
Seeks improvements in land use allocation across the region in order to support new
investment.
6415-32
land for urban development Amend the policies so they align with transport infrastructure investment.
6415-33
Infrastructure Development leonie.armstrong@nzcid.org.nz General Miscellaneous
Operational/
Review of Council's funding capability to deliver the investment required to support a compact
city.
6415-34
Infrastructure Development leonie.armstrong@nzcid.org.nz General Miscellaneous Consultation and engagement
Better engagement by the Council with both central government and the Auckland public to
engender support for the compact city vision and the steps required to make it happen.
6416-1 Jennifer Jack jjac054@aucklanduni.ac.nz Mana Whenua General provisions
assessment Delete rule 2.7.4 Cultural impact assessment that requires a cultural impact assessment.
6416-2 Jennifer Jack jjac054@aucklanduni.ac.nz Mana Whenua General provisions
assessment
Amend rule 2.7.4 Cultural impact assessment, so that if a cultural impact assessment is
required this should be at no extra cost to the applicant.
6416-3 Jennifer Jack jjac054@aucklanduni.ac.nz Residential zones Residential
General Amend the 'Fences' so that the entire height of the fence to be 1.8m and 'all non transparent'.
6417-1 Judith Frost PO Box 50, Bombay, Auckland 2343 Subdivision Auckland-wide - Urban zones H5.2 3.1 Residential zones Retain Built Environment - Additional Subdivision Control overlay.
6417-2 Judith Frost PO Box 50, Bombay, Auckland 2343 Zoning South
Rezone properties between 108 and 152 Great South Road, and between 12 and 16 Kelvyn
Grove, and between 6 and 10 Hill Road, Manurewa from Mixed Housing Urban and Terrace
Housing and Apartment Buildings to Mixed Use Suburban. [Infer submitter may be referring to
Mixed Housing Suburban]
6417-3 Judith Frost PO Box 50, Bombay, Auckland 2343
Centre) Business
Park zones
Amend height limit in Manurewa Town Center from 24.5m to 16 storeys [meters] or a four
storey equivalent.
6417-4 Judith Frost PO Box 50, Bombay, Auckland 2343 Special Character
residential
Add a special character overlay to Hill Park, with similar objectives and policies to Isthmus
B2.
6417-5 Judith Frost PO Box 50, Bombay, Auckland 2343
SEAs
Land Add a natural heritage [SEA] overlay to Hill Park.
6417-6 Judith Frost PO Box 50, Bombay, Auckland 2343 General Miscellaneous Other Recognise Hill park as an eco-corridor.
6417-7 Judith Frost PO Box 50, Bombay, Auckland 2343 Zoning South
Rezone the properties that immediately adjoin Hill Park's Single House zone from Mixed Use
Urban [Mixed Housing Urban] and Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings to Mixed House
Suburban.
6418-1 Rosanna Gravatt grasinis_cafe@xtra.co.nz General Cross plan matters
No specific decision stated. Concerned with rural subdivision, future urban, Special Housing
Areas, transport infrastructure, truck access to industrial areas and tips, tighter controls
on housing subdivision, school capacities.
6418-2 Rosanna Gravatt grasinis_cafe@xtra.co.nz Special Character
residential
Keep the special character of housing areas in Kumeu and different areas of Auckland and
intact through forward planning and community feedback.
282/1145
Sub#/
6419-1 Abhishek Reddy mail@abhishek.geek.nz RPS Urban growth
Retain the Plan's approach to growth, favouring a broad transport modal shift and developing
the urban fabric with limited growth outside the urban area.
6419-2 Abhishek Reddy mail@abhishek.geek.nz Transport Auckland -wide C1.2 Background Retain the policy of maximum, rather than minimum, parking standards.
6419-3 Abhishek Reddy mail@abhishek.geek.nz Transport Auckland -wide
requirements Amend provisions by applying maximum parking standards to the Mixed Housing Urban zone.
requirements
Amend by lowering the maximum parking ceiling of 1:200m2 GFA for 'general activities' in the
city centre.
requirements
Delete the minimum parking standards for the Mixed Housing Suburban zone upwards [Mixed
Housing Urban zone].
requirements Delete the minimum parking standards for Taverns.
requirements
Retain provisions for bicycles, including bicycle parking minimums and the reference to
Auckland Transport's Code of Practice.
6419-8 Abhishek Reddy mail@abhishek.geek.nz
Centre) Business
Special information
requirements Retain Rule 8.1 relating to Assessment criteria for large format retail.
6419-9 Abhishek Reddy mail@abhishek.geek.nz Sustainable Development C7.7/H6.4 Sustainable design Amend Rule 2.1.1(a) to require Homestar 6 for all new residential development.
environment
Amend the PAUP to 'include the ADM in regulatory decision-making, assessment or review,
outside the RMA framework', making it loosely binding, neither totally mandatory or totally
advisory.
6419-11 Abhishek Reddy mail@abhishek.geek.nz Residential zones Residential
Terrace Housing and
Apartment Buildings zone Retain Rule 16, minimum floor areas for apartments.
Delete requirements for balconies for dwellings in the Mixed Housing Urban and higher
zones.
General
Amend rules by relaxing the height in relation to boundary requirements for all residential
zones.
Mixed Housing Urban zone Amend the Mixed Housing Urban zone provisions to be more ambitious.
Amend the Single House zone provisions so that they are more ambitious by encouraging
subdivision/infill/hidden density.
control
and policies Retain the overlay.
6419-17 Abhishek Reddy mail@abhishek.geek.nz RPS
features
Amend provisions by giving less priority to the protection of volcanic viewshafts, particularly
when those views are from a distance.
shafts survey coordinates Amend provisions so that city fringe development [is not restricted by] view shafts.
6419-19 Abhishek Reddy mail@abhishek.geek.nz Historic Heritage (Overlay)
Heritage
Amend built heritage provisions so that they do not freeze 'a neighbourhood's facades or
height limits' but rather 'acknowledge that certain local patterns of change or activity are
themselves heritage'..
6419-20 Abhishek Reddy mail@abhishek.geek.nz Zoning Central Retain areas of Mixed Use zone in Newton/Grafton.
6419-21 Abhishek Reddy mail@abhishek.geek.nz Zoning Central Retain the Town Centre zone in Newton.
6419-22 Abhishek Reddy mail@abhishek.geek.nz Zoning Central
Rezone around the future Newton rail station to provide more of the Mixed Use and Terrace
Housing and Apartment Buildings zones.
Rezone much of Grafton West, around Seafield View Road and Park Road, to provide more
of the Mixed Use and Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings zones.
Rezone tracts of Grey Lynn to provide more of the Mixed Use and Terrace Housing and
Apartment Buildings zones.
Rezone to provide for 'much greater intensification' around Morningside, Ellerslie, Greenlane,
Meadowbank and Orakei rail stations.
Rezone to provide for more intensification around Mt Roskill, including from Stoddard Road to
Dominion Road.
6419-27 Abhishek Reddy mail@abhishek.geek.nz Zoning Central Rezone to provide for more intensification around Mt Albert.
6419-28 Abhishek Reddy mail@abhishek.geek.nz Residential zones Housing affordability
and policies Retain the 'retained affordability housing approach'.
283/1145
Sub#/
Amend the approach to growth by applying a 80:20 ratio to growth within, and outside of, the
urban area.
requirements Amend by halving the maximum parking rates for dwellings in the city centre.
6419-31 Abhishek Reddy mail@abhishek.geek.nz Zoning Central Retain the Local Centre zone in Grafton [refer to page 6/6].
Rezone [parts of the] area between Grey Lynn and Grafton to remove the 'excessive Single
House zoning' [refer to page 6/6].
Mixed Housing Urban zone Delete requirements for setbacks for dwellings in the Mixed Housing Urban and higher zones.
6420-1 Mr Rahul rft_rms@xtra.co.nz Residential zones Residential
policies
Do not downzone sites within flood plain areas to Single House. Undertake flood risk
assessment to determine degree of risk.
6421-1 Tania F Mace tmace@ihug.co.nz Historic Heritage (Overlay)
Heritage
Places Retain historic heritage overlay in Grey Lynn.
6421-2 Tania F Mace tmace@ihug.co.nz Special Character
& C
Isthmus
Extend the special character overlay in Grey Lynn to encompass areas of villas and bungalow
streetscapes that have not already been identified, but warrant special character zone
protection.
6421-3 Tania F Mace tmace@ihug.co.nz Residential zones Residential
policies
Reject Terrace Housing and Apartment Building and Mixed Housing zones in areas with villas
and bungalows.
6421-4 Tania F Mace tmace@ihug.co.nz Zoning Central Retain Single House zoning in Grey Lynn.
6421-5 Tania F Mace tmace@ihug.co.nz Zoning Central
Retain the Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings zoning of the Great North Road ridge
west of Bond Street, Grey Lynn.
policies
Retain the division of Mixed Housing into Mixed Housing Urban and Mixed Housing
Suburban.
Mixed Housing Urban zone Delete the Mixed Housing Suburban height in relation to boundary rule.
6421-8 Tania F Mace tmace@ihug.co.nz Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
Amend the minimum requirement for on site parking in all residential zones to 1 carpark per
household unit.
6421-9 Tania F Mace tmace@ihug.co.nz Special Character
& C
Isthmus Retain Special Character overlay in Grey Lynn.
6421-10 Tania F Mace tmace@ihug.co.nz
control
Building demolition control J.3.6 Rules and mapping Retain the pre 1944 demolition control overlay.
6422-1 Rachelle Tapara rachellet@xtra.co.nz Mana Whenua
Whenua
Remove the Sites and Places of Value to Mana Whenua overlay from Torkar Road, Clarks
Beach.
6423-1 SkyCabs International Limited Hugh@skycabs.co.nz RPS Urban growth
No specific decision requested [but issues raised about intensification, whether compact
development is appropriate and whether rail will make Auckland a more liveable city]. Refer
to pages 3/9 and 4/9 of the submission.
6423-2 SkyCabs International Limited Hugh@skycabs.co.nz RPS Mana Whenua
Mtauranga & tikanga
Amend the Mana Whenua provisions so that Council is the decision maker on historic points
of interest in the PAUP rather than Mori.
6423-3 SkyCabs International Limited Hugh@skycabs.co.nz Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
[Amend the parking provisions to ensure that a more consistent approach is taken to
determining parking requirements, particularly in business centres].
6423-4 SkyCabs International Limited Hugh@skycabs.co.nz Residential zones Residential
policies Include provision for a greater number of housing types.
6423-5 SkyCabs International Limited Hugh@skycabs.co.nz Residential zones Residential
General
[Amend the height controls to remove reference to the number of storeys in addition to height
limits in metres]. Refer to page 6/9 of the submission.
6423-6 SkyCabs International Limited Hugh@skycabs.co.nz RPS Urban growth
Amend the PAUP to remove conflicts between housing affordability and and sustainable
'green' building requirements.
6423-7 SkyCabs International Limited Hugh@skycabs.co.nz Trees
Trees
Notable Trees
Ensure that trees nearing the end of their lifespan are not scheduled as 'notable trees' in the
PAUP.
6423-8 SkyCabs International Limited Hugh@skycabs.co.nz Air Quality
and policies
Ensure that suitable activities occur along major roads where air quality is an issue i.e. offices
rather than residential activities and eateries.
6423-9 SkyCabs International Limited Hugh@skycabs.co.nz General Miscellaneous
Operational/
Remove blocks that cause congestion by building more off ramps to motorways and green
lighting the off ramps in peak times for 90% of the time during peak hours.
6423-10 SkyCabs International Limited Hugh@skycabs.co.nz General Miscellaneous
Operational/
Projects/Acquisition Investigate public transport alternatives such as the SkyCabs elevated monorail system.
284/1145
Sub#/
6424-1 Toby G Mandeno toby.mandeno@gmail.com Subdivision Auckland-wide - Rural zones
area
Amend the subdivision rules to allow for the subdivision of land in rural zones which cannot be
used for productive means (i.e. do not prohibit subdivision).
6424-2 Toby G Mandeno toby.mandeno@gmail.com Rural Zones General I13.1 Activity table
Amend the development controls to allow for flexibility in land uses for areas within proximity
to urban Auckland which faces development pressure.
6425-1 Howell Davies
242 School Road, RD1, Waimauku,
Auckland 0881
SEAs
Land
Reject SEA rules, with particular regard to 242 School Road, Waimauku and properties on
School Road that have a SEA overlay.
6425-2 Howell Davies
242 School Road, RD1, Waimauku,
Auckland 0881 RPS
character and natural heritage B4.3.3 Trees and vegetation Reject tree protection rules. [Specific relief not provided]
6426-1 Rachel Lees-Green r.lees-green@outlook.com RPS Urban growth
quality compact urban form Retain the compact city model by keeping 70 percent of growth within city limits.
6426-2 Rachel Lees-Green r.lees-green@outlook.com Residential zones Residential
policies
Rezone more areas to Mixed Housing Urban and Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings,
particularly in the Isthmus, North Shore and areas close to high quality public transport hubs.
General
Adopt requirements for all developments to be subject to design review with strong
assessment criteria, particularly regarding quality living space, functional communal spaces
for developments of 4 or more dwellings and relax height to boundary and set back controls.
6426-4 Rachel Lees-Green r.lees-green@outlook.com Residential zones Residential Land use controls
Retain rule [inferred 3.3 The conversion of a dwelling into two dwellings] allowing each house
to split into 2.
6426-5 Rachel Lees-Green r.lees-green@outlook.com Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
Remove parking minimums in Mixed Housing Urban zone and reduce them in Mixed Housing
Suburban zone.
6426-6 Rachel Lees-Green r.lees-green@outlook.com Sustainable Development C7.7/H6.4 Sustainable design Require Homestar rating of all new houses.
6426-7 Rachel Lees-Green r.lees-green@outlook.com RPS
Adopt controls that ensure native trees and buses, fresh water in streams, clean water in
harbours, and clean beaches are valued and maintained.
6426-8 Rachel Lees-Green r.lees-green@outlook.com Sustainable Development C7.7/H6.4 Sustainable design
Adopt provisions encouraging transport options, building designs, and energy sources that
reduce the carbon footprint.
Adopt provisions encouraging alternative energy systems (solar, wind) for residential, public,
and commercial buildings.
Adopt provisions encouraging green roofs and permeable paving as alternatives to reduce run
off on sites with high building coverage.
6426-11 Rachel Lees-Green r.lees-green@outlook.com
the CMA
sch. 6.2 ONC/HNC
6.1 Schedule SEA
Marine 1 and 2 Adopt provisions protecting Shoal Bay's value as a wild-life habitat.
SEAs
table - Vegetation
roads Amend existing coastal tree protection buffer from 20m to 100m.
6426-13 Rachel Lees-Green r.lees-green@outlook.com RPS Changes to the RUB North and Waiheke Island Retain the RUB on the Vaughans Rd ridge, Okura.
6426-14 Rachel Lees-Green r.lees-green@outlook.com RPS
character and natural heritage B4.3.4 Biodiversity Adopt provisions to protect ecological corridors, including the Northwest Wildlink.
6426-15 Rachel Lees-Green r.lees-green@outlook.com Residential zones Housing affordability H6.6 Rules Adopt a rule requiring 20% of all new housing in brown-field areas to be affordable housing.
6426-16 Rachel Lees-Green r.lees-green@outlook.com Future Urban
Amend the Future Urban Zone into two zones. One suitable for development in the next 10
years, and another for development beyond that.
General
Amend front yard setback by removing or reducing them, particularly in zones for
intensification.
6426-18 Rachel Lees-Green r.lees-green@outlook.com Residential zones Residential Land use controls
Delete density limits for development of three or more dwellings in the Mixed Housing
Suburban zone.
6426-19 Rachel Lees-Green r.lees-green@outlook.com Residential zones Residential Land use controls Delete density limits in the Mixed Housing Urban zone.
requirements Delete minimum parking requirements for tavern activities.
6426-21 Rachel Lees-Green r.lees-green@outlook.com Residential zones Residential Land use controls Retain rule 3.3 'Conversion of a dwelling into two dwellings'.
Centre) Business
& Bus. Park zones Retain strong restrictions on retail and office activities outside of centres.
requirements
Retain table 3: Parking rates for sites within the City Centre Fringe overlay and the
Metropolitan, Town, Local Centres, Mixed Use, and Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings
zones.
285/1145
Sub#/
6426-24 Rachel Lees-Green r.lees-green@outlook.com RPS Urban growth
Retain zoning of areas close to rapid transit or high frequency public transport to zones that
enable intensification - Mixed Use, Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings or centre zones.
6426-25 Rachel Lees-Green r.lees-green@outlook.com Sustainable Development C7.7/H6.4 Sustainable design Require Greenstar rating of all new commercial buildings.
6427-1 Aitutaki Trust david@whitburngroup.co.nz Zoning West
Rezone 71 West Harbour Drive, West Harbour from Mixed Housing Suburban to Mixed
Housing Urban.
6427-2 Aitutaki Trust david@whitburngroup.co.nz Residential zones Residential
and Coastal Settlement zone Amend the maximum building height to be 9.5m in the Single House zone.
6427-3 Aitutaki Trust david@whitburngroup.co.nz Residential zones Residential
Mixed Housing Urban zone Amend the maximum building height to be 9.5m in the Mixed Housing Suburban.
6428-1 Double L Ranch Limited len@stonemasons.co.nz Built Environment (Overlays)
Protection
Amend the Ridgeline Protection overlay on, and in the vicinity of, 1 Sandstone Road,
Whitford, so that it aligns with the 'Scenic Amenity' overlay in the operative 'Whitford Rural A'
zone and follows a logical line/contour.
6428-2 Double L Ranch Limited len@stonemasons.co.nz Built Environment (Overlays)
Protection
Amend provisions to clarify the purpose of the Ridgeline Protection overlay to Whitford and to
provide clear rules for this overlay.
6429-1 The Sustainability Society caleb@morphum.com Sustainable Development C7.7/H6.4 Sustainable design
Retain elements of the PAUP that provide environmental protection and drive sustainable
development.
6429-2 The Sustainability Society caleb@morphum.com Water
policies
management
Strengthen and integrate requirements for water sensitive urban design throughout all parts
of the PAUP, particularly during structure planning and subdivision.
policies
management
Add a schedule of components for water sensitive urban design to be included at various
stages of planning. The schedule of components refer to - the protection of natural assets;
modifications to landforms and areas of earthworks and compaction; protection of floodplains
and overland flowpaths; avoidance of run-off; water treatment methods; discharge into
sensitive environments; road design
6429-4 The Sustainability Society caleb@morphum.com Water Stormwater
H4.14.2 Stormwater
Protect urban and sensitive stream environments and in particular, improve mitigation from
road and parking area run-off. Apply Stormwater Management Area Flow (SMAF) controls to
roads. Apply minimum requirements that are fit for purpose to non SMAF areas.
6429-5 The Sustainability Society caleb@morphum.com Sustainable Development C7.7/H6.4 Sustainable design
Incorporate Blue Star rating for water management for new buildings to complement the
Green Star rating which is primarily energy focussed.
streams & wetland
table
Prohibit piping and treat this as reclamation. Provide for culverting as a controlled activity
where necessary for accessways.
6430-1 Matthew Hall matt@morphum.com
SEAs
Land Delete SEA from 10 Hollywood Avenue, Titirangi [inferred].
6430-2 Matthew Hall matt@morphum.com RPS
Amend provisions so that new SEAs cannot be applied to private property less than 2000m
2
[inferred].
6431-1 Kirk A Serpes kirk.serpes@gmail.com Transport Auckland -wide
requirements Delete minimum parking requirements, especially from the Mixed Housing zones.
6431-2 Kirk A Serpes kirk.serpes@gmail.com RPS Urban growth
land for urban development Provide for more housing along Public Transport corridors, especially the rail network.
6431-3 Kirk A Serpes kirk.serpes@gmail.com Zoning Central Rezone Light Industrial Land in Morningside, Takapuna, Greenlane to Ellerslie to Mixed Use.
6431-4 Kirk A Serpes kirk.serpes@gmail.com
Centre) Business
Park zones
Amend maximum height controls in the Mixed Use zone to 8 stories with overlays to lower and
raise this where appropriate.
Centre) Business
Park zones Amend maximum height control for local centres to 4 storeys.
Centre) Business
Park zones Amend maximum height control for most Town Centres to be 8 storeys.
6431-7 Kirk A Serpes kirk.serpes@gmail.com Sustainable Development C7.7/H6.4 Sustainable design Retain Greenstar and Homestar provisions.
6431-8 Kirk A Serpes kirk.serpes@gmail.com Residential zones Residential
General
Amend rules in Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings and Mixed Housing zones to
ensure more land is intensified.
6431-9 Kirk A Serpes kirk.serpes@gmail.com RPS Urban growth
Amend the Future Urban zone to ensure growth is adequately staged by splitting it into two
zones, one being the 'Short Term Future Urban Zone' which should contain 7 years capacity.
286/1145
Sub#/
6431-10 Kirk A Serpes kirk.serpes@gmail.com Zoning Central
Rezone the Tropicana Farm near Lynfield to a mixed zoning that allows for new developments
up to 3 storeys.
6432-1 Rebecca Fuller rebecca.j.fuller@gmail.com Zoning West
Rezone Maple Street, Avondale so both sides of the street are zoned the same to achieve the
best urban outcome - either Mixed Housing Suburban or Single Housing.
6433-1
Mangere Bridge Progressive
Business Association
Incorporated info@mangerebridgevillage.co.nz Zoning South
Rezone the land north along the eastern side of Coronation Road between Rimu Road and
Kiwi Esplanade, Mangere Bridge from Mixed Housing Urban to Mixed Use [refer to page
10/26 for area to be rezoned].
6433-2
Rezone the Mixed Use zone on Crawford Ave, Mangere Bridge to a zone that allows for a
railway station and parking ride facility.
6433-3
Rezone the the land east of Coronation Road along the south side of Rimu Road, and along
the north side of Miro Road, Mangere Bridge from Mixed Housing Urban to Mixed Use.
6433-4
Rezone the land between Hastie Ave and Taylor Road, Mangere Bridge from Mixed Use to a
residential zone [refer to page 10/26 of submission for specific area to be rezoned].
6433-5
Incorporated info@mangerebridgevillage.co.nz General Miscellaneous
Operational/
Extend the pedestrian bridge which forms part of the coastal walk and cycle way, on Sate
Highway 20 across the harbour [refer to page 11/26 of submission]
6433-6
Incorporated info@mangerebridgevillage.co.nz Residential zones Residential
General
Amend the height rules in the Local Centre zone to require a maximum height limit of three
stories on the eastern side of Coronation Road, Mangere Bridge, and two storey on the
western side
6433-7
Incorporated info@mangerebridgevillage.co.nz Residential zones Residential
Include new provisions in the Mixed Use zone that protect business owners
from interruption of their core business
6433-8
Incorporated info@mangerebridgevillage.co.nz
Centre)
Maps only
Insert a new Key Retail Frontage Overlay for the Mangere Bridge business Improvement
District Area, to promote this area as a key retail street and focal point of pedestrian activity
[refer to page 13/26 of submission for proposed overlay area].
6433-9
Operational/
Add provisions to provide for a rail link to the airport via Onehunga and along the western side
of State Highway 20 and linking with the high density residential area and local shopping
centre.
6433-10
Operational/
Projects/Acquisition Provide for a railway station at Mangere Bridge at Crawford Ave,
6433-11
Incorporated info@mangerebridgevillage.co.nz Precincts - South Mngere Bridge
Extend the Mangere Bridge Precinct to include Mangere Bridge Village shopping area and Te
Puea Marae.
6433-12
Operational/
Projects/Acquisition Develop the Onehunga Port area into a ferry facility.
6433-13
the CMA
Remove the benchmark date for the removal of mangroves in the Manukau Harbour and
allow for the removal of all mangroves.
6433-14
the CMA
Amend the benchmark date to 1964 for the removal of mangroves, and require removal to be
done in stages from the most recent to the oldest with monitoring.
6434-1 Landview Farms Limited graeme@lcc-planning.co.nz Precincts - South Runciman
Retain the Runciman Precinct Plan and Bush Park Concept Plan as the principal techniques
for managing change, subdivision and development of the area contained with the Bush Park
Concept Plan area and/or for the Landview Farms Property [at 463 Runciman Road, Dury as
per the map on page 10/10 of the submission].
6434-2 Landview Farms Limited graeme@lcc-planning.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - general
and policies
Retain the text in the second bullet under the subheading 'Rural subdivision', which states
"where countryside living zones is appropriate in rural areas it has been provided for by
zoning the land Countryside Living with controls that recognise landscape qualities and
infrastructure limitations."
Amend the Introduction to ensure the second bullet point in the introduction to the rural
subdivision provisions in [C6] are reflected in the identification of environmental benefits and
characteristics sought by the Countryside Living zone at Bush Park, which states: "Land
subdivided efficiently to reflect intended outcomes of the zone"
6434-4 Landview Farms Limited graeme@lcc-planning.co.nz Precincts - South Runciman Amend the objectives section to reflect Objective 1 of the rural subdivision provisions [in C6].
287/1145
Sub#/
and policies Retain Policy 27(b).
Amend the policies section to give effect to Policy 34 of the subdivision provisions [C6] by
recognising that the Development Areas shown in the Bush Park Concept Plan are the
primary means of achieving this policy's implementation.
Amend the Activity Table so subdivision is a controlled activity if the density standards and
building site controls are met.
Amend the precinct description to ensure it reflects the countryside living zone general zone
description in and is not embellished with additional purposes [such as environmental
enhancements].
6434-13 Landview Farms Limited graeme@lcc-planning.co.nz Rural Zones
desc, obs & pols
Retain Objectives 1-6 with amendments to ensure low density living in a rural context is
provided for whilst maintaining and enhancing the range of qualities that form the character of
the precinct, sub-precinct or in the case of Bush Park, the Bush Park Concept Plan.
Amend Objectives 1-6 by incorporating the range of environmental qualities into the concept
plans and remove reference to ecological or riparian planting.
Amend Objectives 1-6 to ensure that in the bush park the primary considerations are that
buildings are located in identified areas and open space is retained.
Amend the precinct rules to ensure the primary focus is on Policy 7 [of the Countryside living
zone provisions [in D6.6]].
desc, obs & pols
Amend Policy 1(g) to encourage built form to fit in with the topography, taking advantage of
sites that avoid unnecessary earthworks and to avoid artificially contrived clustering, or
remove the term clustering altogether, in preference for identifying location of buildings within
development areas.
desc, obs & pols
Amend the Countryside Living zone provisions to ensure that they are areas that are
dedicated for lifestyle housing and ad hoc scattering of housing does not compromise
productive potential of highly versatile land or lead to uneconomic extension of roads and
services.
Amend policy 30 to ensure that the Landview Farms land within the Bush Park concept area
[463 Runciman Road, Drury] is identified as a receiver area for transferable development
rights.
Amend policy 30 to remove reference to clustering or that within the Bush Park Area within
Precinct A or B the clustering method for managing development will be by way of a concept
plan identifying areas where buildings are to be located.
Amend reference on the planning maps for the precinct so they align with the sub-precinct text
i.e. Precinct A and B notations in the rules. Alternatively remove the sub-precinct which
incorporates Bush Park and replace it with the Bush Park Concept Area.
Replace Precinct Plans 4 with map 110A in the Environment Court Consent Order as outlined
in page 2/10 of the submission.
Amend precinct plan 5 to be named the 'Bush Park Concept Plan Development Area' and add
the areas confirmed by the Environment Court Consent Order on page 2/10 of the
submission.
6434-24 Landview Farms Limited graeme@lcc-planning.co.nz Precincts - South Runciman Delete Objective 4.
Delete Policy 2(d) as far as it applies to the Bush Park Concept Area which has provided for
clustering.
Amend precinct to ensure that the primary means for achieving Policies 1, 2(a)-(c) are the
Bush Park Concept Plan.
6434-27 Landview Farms Limited graeme@lcc-planning.co.nz Precincts - South Runciman Delete Policy 2(j).
6434-28 Landview Farms Limited graeme@lcc-planning.co.nz Precincts - South Runciman Add a policy to provide a receiver environment for transferable rural site subdivision rights.
Amend Policy 6 to provide enhancement of ecological values by way of riparian planting to
provide shade for identified streams where there is not shade within the Bush Park area.
Amend the Bush Park Concept Plan to ensure that subdivision is a controlled activity with
matters of control [as per the Environment Court Consent Order Topic 64 ENV-2008-304-
00182].
Amend the precinct to remove reference to clustering and all rules relating to clustering [as
per the Environment Court Consent Order Topic 64 ENV-2008-304-00182].
288/1145
Sub#/
Amend the precinct to remove requirements for setbacks from Tuhimata and Runciman
Roads [as per the Environment Court Consent Order Topic 64 ENV-2008-304-00182].
Amend precinct rules so the maximum density is no greater than 1 lot per 2.0ha of gross site
area [as per the Environment Court Consent Order Topic 64 ENV-2008-304-00182].
Amend the precinct to provide for density to be reduced to 1 lot per 1.5ha gross floor area to
accommodate transferable lots [as per the Environment Court Consent Order Topic 64 ENV-
2008-304-00182].
Amend the precinct by deleting the requirement for separation distances between clusters or
specified building areas [as per the Environment Court Consent Order Topic 64 ENV-2008-
304-00182].
Amend the precinct to delete reference to 'significant' environmental benefits [as per
the Environment Court Consent Order Topic 64 ENV-2008-304-00182].
Amend [rule 3.2(5)] and associated table to provide for a 10m wide riparian corridor on
streams identified in map 110A, only where planting is already in place. No riparian planting is
required where there is existing vegetation or mature planting is in place adjacent to identified
streams or located in the near vicinity and providing shade.
6434-38 Landview Farms Limited graeme@lcc-planning.co.nz Precincts - South Runciman Amend the precinct rules to provide for receiving transferable development rights.
Amend the Precinct Plan 4 Riparian Corridors with the one included in the Environment Court
Consent Order as outlined on page 2/10 of the submission as so far as it applies to the Bush
Park Concept Plan area.
Amend Precinct Plan 5 Bush Park Concept Plan Development Areas to retain the existing
development areas and include additional development areas contained on Map 110E.
Amend the Precinct Plans, Sub-Precinct Plans and Bush Park Concept Plans Area to provide
greater clarity and better scale to determine detail relative to the topography and property
boundaries. In particular each of the Precinct Plans relevant to the Bush Park component of
the sub precinct in a separate series of maps to provide better clarity and precision.
6435-1 Glenda MacDonald
glenda.macdonald@lawsociety.org.n
z Zoning Central
Rezone the Housing NZ land at 16 Spring St, Freemans Bay from Terrace Housing and
Apartment Buildings to Mixed Housing Suburban
General
Include additional development controls to ensure an appropriate transition for sites zoned
with a higher density than Single House Residential which are adjacent or across the street
from a Single House Residential zone subject to the Special Character overlay. Include a
requirement that applications to build over 8m in height are notified to all surrounding
properties subject to the Special Character overlay
requirements
Include additional carparking requirements to ensure an appropriate transition for sites zoned
from a Single House Residential zone subject to the Special Character overlay.
Special info. req.
Include additional assessment criteria to ensure an appropriate transition for sites zoned with
a higher density than Single House Residential which are adjacent or across the street from a
Single House Residential zone subject to the Special Character overlay. The additional
criteria should require that sympathy and recognition be given to the streetscape character,
height, scale and form of dwelling subject to a Special Character overlay in the surrounding
neighbourhood. (Refer to submission for examples of assessment criteria).
General
Ensure any new building on the Housing NZ land at 16 Spring St, Freemans Bay is subject to
appropriate development controls to address the concerns raised in the submission about
infrastructure, adverse effects on the amenity of surrounding housing and street, traffic and
parking demand, wind effects and glare.
requirements
appropriate carparking requirements to address the concerns raised in the submission about
parking demand.
requirements
Impose minimum carparking requirements on sites zoned with a higher density than Single
House Residential which are subject to the City Fringe Parking overlay
6436-1 Vintage Polo Limited ross.george@directcapital.co.nz Zoning South
Rezone to provide 'greater residential expansion around the [Clevedon] village', using the
foothills to 'provide a logical and definable boundary for residential zoning around the village'.
6437-1 Jane Matthews
4 Alexander Street, Kingsland,
Auckland 1021 Special Character
residential
Remove the individual ranking of residential properties as Character Defining and Character
Supporting in any residential special character areas. Refers to policy 2.
6438-1 Jacinta Robertson jacinta@allproof.co.nz Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula K5.11 Precinct rules Amend [rule 4.3 'Building height'] to reduce the height limits for the precinct].
6438-2 Jacinta Robertson jacinta@allproof.co.nz Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula
objectives and policies Recognise roads and schools cannot support the lack of infrastructure in the precinct.
289/1145
Sub#/
6439-1
Grey lynn 2030 Transition
Community Trust colindasluis7@gmail.com General Chapter A Introduction A1 Background Support the vision of the Auckland Plan.
6439-2
Community Trust colindasluis7@gmail.com Historic Heritage (Overlay)
Provide stronger protection for heritage and character buildings and structures by requiring
a publicly notified consent to demolish or significantly modify.
6439-3
Community Trust colindasluis7@gmail.com
control
and policies Retain pre-1944 demolition control provisions.
6439-4
Heritage
objectives and policies Retain historic heritage provisons.
6439-5
Community Trust colindasluis7@gmail.com RPS
character and natural heritage B4.2 Special character Retain Special Character Area provisions.
6439-6
Heritage
Places
Request a finer grain master plan and streetscape assessment for Grey Lynn and Westmere
to allow the community to be involved with identifying sites that could be rezoned following
appropriate heritage assessment.
6439-7
character and natural heritage B4.2 Special character Amend character overlays to be better informed. [Specific relief not provided]
6439-8
Community Trust colindasluis7@gmail.com Zoning Central
Rezone Grey Lynn from Mixed Housing to Single Housing, pending
urgent heritage assessment.
6439-9
Retain Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings on the Great North Road ridge west of Bond
Street.
6439-10
Rezone Grey Lynn to Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings and Mixed Housing pending
community involvement in identifying areas and heritage assessment.
6439-11
Community Trust colindasluis7@gmail.com Residential zones Residential
policies
Retain division of Mixed Housing zone into Mixed Housing Urban and Mixed
Housing Suburban.
6439-12
Retain Mixed Housing Suburban and Mixed Housing Urban setback, garaging and fencing
rules.
6439-13
Community Trust colindasluis7@gmail.com Transport Auckland -wide
requirements Retain parking provisions which remove need for parking minimums.
6439-14
requirements Retain cycle parking rules.
6439-15
Community Trust colindasluis7@gmail.com Residential zones Residential Land use controls
Retain the provision [rule 3.3 The conversion of a dwelling into two dwellings] which allows the
conversion of a dwelling into two dwellings in all residential zones.
6439-16
character and natural heritage B4.3.3 Trees and vegetation Retain provisions to identify further trees for scheduling.
6439-17
Community Trust colindasluis7@gmail.com RPS Urban growth
retain affordable housing Retain affordable Housing Action Plan.
6439-18
Community Trust colindasluis7@gmail.com General Miscellaneous
Operational/
Projects/Acquisition Request council better resource the Housing Action Plan.
6439-19
General Retain provisions for universal access.
6439-20
organisms
modified organisms Retain GMO provisions.
6439-21
organisms
modified organisms Amend GMO provisions to include veterinary vaccines.
6439-22
requirements
Reject minimum parking requirements in the Mixed Housing and Single Housing zone, with
particular regard to Grey Lynn.
6439-23
Centre) Business
& Bus. Park zones
Amend big box development from Discretionary to Non-complying [inferred] in the Mixed Use
zone.
6439-24
Community Trust colindasluis7@gmail.com Residential zones Residential Notification
Remove the provisions which require three development controls to be contravened before
triggering notification.
6440-1 Tara Iti Holdings Limited peter.hall@boffamiskell.co.nz General Miscellaneous Other
Adopt the matters raised in the submission of Te Arai Coastal Lands Trust Limited, and the
submission of Te Arai South Forest Joint Venture/Ngti Manuhiri Settlement Trust.
6440-2 Tara Iti Holdings Limited peter.hall@boffamiskell.co.nz Mana Whenua
settlement land
and policies Retain the objectives for 'Treaty Settlement Land'.
settlement land
and policies
Amend the policies for 'Treaty Settlement Land' to specify that the provision for appropriate
development also applies to settlement land that is subject to a precinct/in addition to the
development potential provided by the precinct.
6440-4 Tara Iti Holdings Limited peter.hall@boffamiskell.co.nz Rural Zones
obs & pols
Amend the extent of the Pakriri Coastal Area map in figure 1, 6.4.1 'Pakiri Coastal Area' to
clarify that it only applies to land south of Te Arai Point as described in 6.4.1 'Pakiri Coastal
Area - Background'.
290/1145
Sub#/
6440-5 Tara Iti Holdings Limited peter.hall@boffamiskell.co.nz Precincts - North Te Arai North
Amend the precinct description to focus on [providing for cultural and commercial redress
while achieving better environmental outcomes].
Amend the precinct objectives and policies of the precinct to allow for appropriate
development to occur. Refer to the wording provided in paragraph 6.6, page 13/19 vol.1 of the
submission.
6440-7 Tara Iti Holdings Limited peter.hall@boffamiskell.co.nz General Chapter G General provisions G2.4 Notification
Retain 'Notification' rules providing for Controlled and Restricted Discretionary activities to be
considered without public or limited notification or written approval.
settlement land
Amend rules to clarify that provision for activities in Treaty Settlement Land also applies to
precincts on Treaty Settlement Land in addition to activities otherwise provided for in the
precinct.
settlement land
Amend H2.2.1 'Activity Table' to provide for more than 10 dwellings on Treaty Settlement
Land in Rural Zone (including Rural zone land with a precinct) as a permitted activity; and
Integrated Mori Development Paln as a restricted discretionary activity.
Amend rules to provide for landuse, subdivision and conservation regime earthworks as a
Permitted activity in all zones and overlays; and for earthworks associated with forestry and
conservation as a Permitted activity in all zones and overlays.
6440-11 Tara Iti Holdings Limited peter.hall@boffamiskell.co.nz
SEAs
Amend rule 'Activity Table' to provide for conservation planting as a permitted activity in all
overlays including the ONF.
SEAs
table - Vegetation
roads Retain provision for existing forestry activities within all overlays as Permitted activity.
6440-13 Tara Iti Holdings Limited peter.hall@boffamiskell.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - Rural zones
zones only
Amend rule 5.1 'Subdivision - Activity Table' to include subdivision in Rural zones otherwise
not in the Activity Table as a Restricted Discretionary activity.
6440-14 Tara Iti Holdings Limited peter.hall@boffamiskell.co.nz Public Open Space Zones Public Open Space I2.1 Activity table
Amend ' Activity Table' to provide for existing forestry as a Permitted activity and mineral
extraction and associated structures as Restricted Discretionary.
6440-15 Tara Iti Holdings Limited peter.hall@boffamiskell.co.nz Rural Zones General I13.1 Activity table
Retain provision for forestry, and conservation planting as Permitted in the Rural Coastal
zone, and the Rural Production Zone in rule 13.1 'Rural zones - Activity table'.
Amend rule 6.1 to provide for existing forestry, and conservation planting as a Permitted
activity; buildings and structures for recreational or public access purposes as a Restricted
Outstanding Natural
Rules
Notification
Amend rule 6.2 to provide for existing forestry as a Permitted Activity; for buildings and
structures with a GFA no greater than 50m
2
within the HNC and ONL overlays as a Permitted
activity.
Amend rules in 5.49 to provide for appropriate subdivision, development, recreation and
ecological/conservation management. Refer to the wording in paragraph 6.33, page 16/19 vol
1. of the submission.
Amend rule 2.1 to clarify that the limit to 'no more than 30 persons' for visitor accommodation
applies to each 'site' rather than the Precinct as a whole. Retain outdoor recreation and motor
sports as a Permitted activity.
6440-20 Tara Iti Holdings Limited peter.hall@boffamiskell.co.nz Precincts - North Te Arai North Delete from rule 2.4 the control limiting Outdoor Recreation ancillary building to 100m
2
.
6440-21 Tara Iti Holdings Limited peter.hall@boffamiskell.co.nz Precincts - North Te Arai North Delete from rule 3 references to minimum and maximum lot sizes.
Amend rule 3.1 to state that any subdivision that does not meet the subdivision controls are a
6440-23 Tara Iti Holdings Limited peter.hall@boffamiskell.co.nz Precincts - North Te Arai North Delete the information requirement from rules 3.3 and 3.6 as it repeats rule 3.1.
Delete from rule 3.2 'Subdivision from the Creation of Additional Public Reserve Land' and
replace with the provisions of Plan Change 166 [Rodney District Plan].
Remove from rule 3.4 (1) 'Subdivision for Significant Enhancement planting' requirements to
comply with the native re-vegetation standards at Appendix 11.5.9.3, and the requirement to
demonstrate a valuable ecological benefit. Amend to allow Significant Enhancement Planting
entitlements to apply to each existing and subsequently created lot.
Amend assessment criteria at rule 4.1 to reflect those of Plan Change 166 [Rodney District
Plan].
6440-27 Tara Iti Holdings Limited peter.hall@boffamiskell.co.nz Definitions Existing
Amend the definition of Treaty Settlement Land to read: Properties vested at any time with
claimant groups by the Crown as a result of Treaty Settlement legislation and final deeds of
settlement. Includes: ... or Deed of Recognition but not owned by claimant groups at any time.
6440-28 Tara Iti Holdings Limited peter.hall@boffamiskell.co.nz Precincts - North Te Arai North Retain the Te Arai North precinct as shown on Planning Map Rural Grid 1.
6440-29 Tara Iti Holdings Limited peter.hall@boffamiskell.co.nz Precincts - North Te Arai South
Amend precinct description in 5.50 'Te Arai South' to focus on [providing for cultural and
commercial redress while achieving better environmental outcomes].
291/1145
Sub#/
Amend the precinct objectives and policies in 5.50 'Te Arai South Precinct' to the wording in
paragraph 6.5, page 12 vol 2. of the submission.
the CMA
Amend rule 6.1.4 to provide for CMCA mineral extraction and associated structures as a
Restricted Discretionary activity om SEA-M2, HNC, ONL and ONF type C. Retain provision
for CMCA mineral extraction and associated structures as a Restricted Discretionary activity
in the General Coastal Marine zone.
6440-32 Tara Iti Holdings Limited peter.hall@boffamiskell.co.nz Rural Zones General I13.1 Activity table
Retain provision for conservation planting as a Permitted activity in the Rural Coastal zone
and the Rural Production Zone; for mineral extraction as a Restricted Discretionary activity in
the Rural Production zone in rule 13.1 'Rural Zones activity table'. Amend to provide for
mineral extraction as a Restricted Discretionary activity in the Rural Coastal zone.
Amend rules in 5.50 'Te Arai South Precinct' to the wording in paragraph 6.40, page 17 vol 2.
of the submission.
Retain the provision for outdoor recreation and motor sports as a Permitted activity; for
subdivision for the protection of natural areas, additional reserve land, and dwellings on Mori
land as a Restricted Discretionary activity in rule 5.50.1.
Amend 5.50.2.1 to clarify that the limit to 'no more than 30 persons' for visitor accommodation
applies to each 'site' rather than the Precinct as a whole.
6440-36 Tara Iti Holdings Limited peter.hall@boffamiskell.co.nz Precincts - North Te Arai South Remove from rule 5.50.2.4 the control limiting Outdoor Recreation ancillary building to 100m
2
.
6440-37 Tara Iti Holdings Limited peter.hall@boffamiskell.co.nz Precincts - North Te Arai South Remove references to minimum and maximum lot sizes from rule 5.50.3.
Amend rule 5.50.3.1 to state that any subdivision that does not meet the subdivision controls
are a Discretionary activity.
6440-39 Tara Iti Holdings Limited peter.hall@boffamiskell.co.nz Precincts - North Te Arai South Remove the information requirements from 5.50.3.3 and 5.50.3.6 as it repeats 5.50.3.1.
Remove rule 5.50.3.2 'Subdivision for the creation of additional public reserve land' and
replace with the provisions of Plan Change 166 [Rodney District Plan].
Remove from rule 5.50.3.4 'Subdivision for Significant Enhancement planting' the control
requiring compliance with the native re-vegetation standards at Appendix 11.5.9.3 and the
requirement to demonstrate a valuable ecological benefit. Amend to allow Significant
Ecological Planting entitlements to apply to each existing and subsequently created lot.
Amend the assessment criteria at 5.50.4.1 to reflect those in Plan Change 166 [Rodney
District Plan].
Retain the Te Arai South precinct as shown on Planning Map Rural Grid 1, but amend the
extent of the precinct to include land held in the following: Lots 1, 2 and 3 DP 351213.
Amend the landward edge of SEA-T-5548a, ONF149, ONL22 and HNC48 and all other
natural resource overlays, in accordance with the methodology used to determine the
landward edge of these natural features as presented to recent Environment Court
proceedings.
settlement land
Amend 2.2 'Notification' so that Discretionary activities on Treaty Settlement Land will be
considered without public or limited notification or the need to obtain the written approval from
affected parties.
SEAs
table - Vegetation
roads Retain conservation planting Permitted activity.
SEAs
overlays (except SEAs) Retain conservation planting as a Permitted activity within SEAs, HNC and ONLs.
6440-48 Tara Iti Holdings Limited peter.hall@boffamiskell.co.nz Public Open Space Zones Public Open Space I2.1 Activity table Retain conservation planting as a Permitted activity.
Amend rules to provide for landuse, subdivision and conservation regime earthworks as a
Permitted activity in all zones and overlays; and for earthworks associated with forestry and
conservation as a Permitted activity in all zones and overlays.
6441-1 777 Investments Limited michael@campbellbrown.co.nz City Centre Zone I4 Rules/Appendix 7.1- 7.3
Amend Map 3 to increase the height of 151 Beach Road, Auckland Central, and the other
sites in this block to 50m.
Delete Rule 4.9 Basic Floor Area Ratio, as shown on Map 9 'Site Intensity', for 151 Beach
Road, Auckland Central and all other sites within the same block.
Delete Rule 4.20 Total Floor Area Ratio, as shown on Map 9 'Site Intensity', for 151 Beach
Road, Auckland Central and all other sites within the same block.
Amend Rule 4.9 Basic Floor Area Ratio, as shown on Map 9 'Site Intensity', to 8:1 (Floor Area
Ratio) for 151 Beach Road, Auckland Central and all other sites within the same block.
Amend Rule 4.20 Maximum Total Floor Area Ratio, as shown on Map 9 'Site Intensity', to 13:1
(Floor Area Ratio) for 151 Beach Road, Auckland Central and all other sites within the same
block.
6441-6 777 Investments Limited michael@campbellbrown.co.nz City Centre Zone I4 Rules/Appendix 7.1- 7.3 Delete Rule 4.29 'Minimum floor to floor/ceiling height'.
292/1145
Sub#/
6441-7 777 Investments Limited michael@campbellbrown.co.nz Sustainable Development C7.7/H6.4 Sustainable design Delete Rule 2.2 'Offices'.
Delete Rule 4.9 Basic Floor Area Ratio, as shown on Map 9 'Site Intensity', for 309, 321-325
and 327 Karangahape Road, Auckland Central.
Delete Rule 4.20 Maximum Total Floor Area Ratio, as shown on Map 9 'Site Intensity', for
309, 321-325 and 327 Karangahape Road, Auckland Central.
Amend Rule 4.9 Basic Floor Area Ratio, as shown on Map 9 'Site Intensity', to 8:1 (Floor Area
Ratio) for 309, 321-325 and 327 Karangahape Road, Auckland Central.
Amend Rule 4.20 Maximum Total Floor Area Ratio, as shown on Map 9 'Site Intensity', to
10:1(Floor Area Ratio) for 309, 321-325 and 327 Karangahape Road, Auckland Central.
Increase the general height of 309, 321-325 and 327 Karangahape Road [and surrounding
sites] to 45 metres.
6441-13 777 Investments Limited michael@campbellbrown.co.nz
Re-instate the operative Mt Eden view protection controls as they apply to 309, 321-325 and
327 Karangahape Road, Auckland Central, with a height of 27.5m and with any infringement
to this rule being a restricted discretionary activity.
Delete Rule 4.9 Basic Floor Area Ratio, as shown on Map 9 'Site Intensity', for 12 and 16
Wyndham Street, Auckland Central.
Delete Rule 4.20 Maximum Total Floor Area Ratio, as shown on Map 9 'Site Intensity', for 12
and 16 Wyndham Street, Auckland Central.
Amend Rule 4.9 Basic Floor Area Ratio, as shown on Map 9 'Site Intensity', to 12:1 (Floor
Area Ratio) for 12 and 16 Wyndham Street, Auckland Central.
Amend Rule 4.20 Maximum Total Floor Area Ratio, as shown on Map 9 'Site Intensity', to 16:1
(Floor Area Ratio) for 12 and 16 Wyndham Street, Auckland Central.
Amend [Rule 4.10 Bonus floor area ratio] by enabling accommodation bonuses at a ratio of
4:1 within Bonus Area 1a, if the current Floor Area Ratios and Maximum Total Floor Area
Ratios are retained.
6441-19 777 Investments Limited michael@campbellbrown.co.nz Designations Auckland Transport
1563 Road Widening - Durham
Lane Delete designation.
6442-1 Myles Opie mylesopie@gmail.com Mana Whenua General provisions
assessment Reject Cultural Impact Assessment requirement for sites of significance and sites of value.
6442-2 Myles Opie mylesopie@gmail.com Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula K5.11 Precinct rules
Amend maximum height controls from three storeys in Area 2 and three to four storeys in
Area 3, to 8 m or 2 storeys.
6442-3 Myles Opie mylesopie@gmail.com Zoning North and Islands
Rezone Devonport Peninsula Precinct area from Mixed Housing Suburban to Single House
with a 2 storey limit.
6442-4 Myles Opie mylesopie@gmail.com Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula K5.11 Precinct rules Amend to require public notification and consultation of any framework plan.
6442-5 Myles Opie mylesopie@gmail.com Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula K5.11 Precinct rules Amend to apply building length rules to any development in sub precincts.
6442-6 Myles Opie mylesopie@gmail.com Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula K5.11 Precinct rules
Amend to prevent development in Devonport Peninsula Precinct prior to upgrading of roading,
sewerage, schooling and stormwater infrastructure.
6442-7 Myles Opie mylesopie@gmail.com General Miscellaneous Special housing areas Reject Special Housing Area on the Devonport Peninsula.
6443-1 Redwood Properties Limited hjrobson@xtra.co.nz Special Character
residential
special character areas Retain 298 Great South Road, Otahuhu in the Special Character Area.
6444-1 Civic Trust Auckland cta@civictrustauckland.org.nz General Chapter A Introduction A1 Background
Amend 7 'Our heritage' to recognise the importance of lava caves, volcanic explosion craters,
objects that have been removed from their original context and other heritage elements, and
to recognise Auckland Council's role in protecting Auckland's heritage including, items kept in
public facilities (e.g. public libraries, museums etc.). Refer to submission for details [page
2/49].
6444-2 Civic Trust Auckland cta@civictrustauckland.org.nz General Chapter A Introduction A2 Statutory Framework
Amend section 2 Treaty of Waitangi / Te Tiriti o Waitangi to emphasise that the Crown and
Mori are equal Treaty partners. Refer to submission for details [page 3/49].
6444-3 Civic Trust Auckland cta@civictrustauckland.org.nz General Chapter A Introduction A3 Strategic Framework
Amend section 4 Quality compact Auckland to emphasise development of
Auckland occurred 'pre contact' and urban expansion 'from 1841'. Refer to submission for
detail [page 3/49].
Amend section 4 Quality compact Auckland to describe how Auckland's heritage will be
protected from the pressures of intensification by assessing areas prior to any planning for
intensification, identifying areas without heritage, character and landscape values so
intensification is provided for there first, staging intensification, implementing intensification
through precinct plans prepared with property owners and community interest groups and
reviewing intensification at 10 year intervals. Refer to the submission for details [pages 5-
6/49].
Amend section 4 Quality compact Auckland to provide for Universal Design principles be
incorporated into new builds and modifications of existing residential buildings.
6444-6 Civic Trust Auckland cta@civictrustauckland.org.nz RPS Issues
heritage
Amend text under heading Historic heritage to include areas, wahi Tpuna, volcanoes and
volcanic landforms. Refer to submission for details [page 7/49].
293/1145
Sub#/
6444-7 Civic Trust Auckland cta@civictrustauckland.org.nz RPS Issues
heritage Replace all use of the term 'special character' with 'historic character'.
6444-8 Civic Trust Auckland cta@civictrustauckland.org.nz RPS Urban growth
Amend text under the heading Methods - Non regulatory to include 'Council to avail itself of
information about underlying values before development approval is granted' or at least notify
the New Zealand Historic Places Trust.
6444-9 Civic Trust Auckland cta@civictrustauckland.org.nz RPS
Retain provisions that relate to public transport, including cycle networks where cyclists are
separated from vehicular traffic and policy 4(a) but only in relation to rail rather than roading.
Amend Objective 3 to ensure that the transport system manages potential adverse effects on
the built environment and not just the natural environment. Refer to submission for detail
[page 9/49].
Add 'Consultation with local groups with a demonstrable interest in heritage matters'
underneath the heading Non-Regulatory - Monitoring and information gathering.
Retain policy 2 that identifies the historic heritage values that a place must have 1 or more of
in order to be considered a Historic Heritage Place.
Amend policy 5 that describes the 3 categories of historic heritage places so that the
threshold for Category A places be 'considerable significance' rather than 'exceptional overall
significance' and that the threshold for Category B places be 'significance' rather than
'considerable overall significance'.
Amend policy 6 so that adverse effects be avoided rather than significant adverse effects.
Refer to submission for details [page 11/49].
6444-15 Civic Trust Auckland cta@civictrustauckland.org.nz Historic Heritage (Overlay)
Add rules to give effect to policies 6 and 7 (in section B.4.1 Historic heritage) that would
require an owner of a historic heritage place to provide on-going protective care to prevent
deterioration and retain the historic heritage values including waterproofing and retaining
structural integrity. Monitoring and penalties for non-compliance,
including temporary moratoriums seeking consent for development for wilful demolition should
also be included.
character and natural heritage B4.1 Historic heritage Add a policy that incentivises the removal or replacement of inappropriate additions.
Heritage
Retain policy 4 subject to amendment to expand the range of incentives to include Special
character and historic heritage areas, rates relief, earthquake assistance, heritage floor
bonuses consent fee waivers and other incentives listed in submission. Reference and
electronically link to all incentives as documents outside the Unitary Plan including
the 'Incentives for Historic Heritage Toolkit' document. Refer to submission for details [pages
13-14/49].
features
Amend objective 3 so that the restoration and enhancement of natural features and
landscapes are 'provided for' rather than 'promoted'. Refer to submission for details [page
16/49].
Add a rule-based incentive for heritage protection for those affected by the rules in J.2
[Historic Heritage overlay] to 'apply for heritage enhancement credits / bonuses that can form
a tradable right to offset the cost of restoration and long-term protection'.
Add a rule-based incentive for heritage protection for those affected by the rules in J.3
[Special Character overlay] to 'apply for heritage enhancement credits / bonuses that can form
a tradable right to offset the cost of restoration and long-term protection'.
Add the New Zealand Historic Places Trust (NZHPT) Register to the Non-regulatory methods
underneath the heading Advocacy, education and information.
Replace all use of the term 'special character' with 'historic character' in section B.4 Protecting
our historic heritage, special character and natural heritage.
Retain the non-regulatory methods subject to amendment to expand the range of incentives to
include Special character and historic heritage areas, rates relief, earthquake assistance,
heritage floor bonuses consent fee waivers and other incentives listed in
submission. Reference and electronically link to all incentives as documents outside the
Unitary Plan including the 'Incentives for Historic Heritage Toolkit' document.Refer to
submission for details [pages 13-14/49].
Retain the non-regulatory methods subject to amendment to expand the range of incentives to
include Special character and historic heritage areas, rates relief, earthquake assistance,
heritage floor bonuses consent fee waivers and other incentives listed in
submission. Reference and electronically link to all incentives as documents outside the
Unitary Plan including the 'Incentives for Historic Heritage Toolkit' document. Refer to
submission for details [pages 13-14/49].
294/1145
Sub#/
6444-25 Civic Trust Auckland cta@civictrustauckland.org.nz City Centre Zone
obs & pols
Retain policies 13 and 14 subject to amendments to expand the range of incentives to include
Special character and historic heritage areas, rates relief, earthquake assistance, heritage
floor bonuses consent fee waivers and other incentives listed in the submission. Reference
and electronically link to all incentives as documents outside the Unitary Plan including
13-14/49].
6444-26 Civic Trust Auckland cta@civictrustauckland.org.nz Mana Whenua
Whenua
Retain policy 7 subject to amendment to expand the range of incentives to include Special
character and historic heritage areas, rates relief, earthquake assistance, heritage floor
bonuses consent fee waivers and other incentives listed in submission. Reference and
electronically link to all incentives as documents outside the Unitary Plan including
13-14/49].
Amend the list of attributes to include 'A collection of different but compatible styles reflecting
the area's historical evolution over time'.
Amend policy 2 to include 'A collection of different but compatible styles reflecting the area's
historical evolution over time'.
6444-29 Civic Trust Auckland cta@civictrustauckland.org.nz
Add the viewshafts of volcanic cones and other landscape features / areas that are currently
in the legacy plans.
features
Review all viewshafts and and consider new viewshafts for inclusion, including viewshafts to
the sea and heritage buildings.
Provide for buildings which have encroached onto volcanic cones to be removed at some time
in the future.
Require a minimum of limited notification for any new buildings or structures (including towers
and telecommunication structures) that would be within the volcanic viewshafts.
sensitive areas rules J6.3 Rules Prohibit any activities that may impinge on viewshafts.
6444-34 Civic Trust Auckland cta@civictrustauckland.org.nz General Eplan
Provide visual aids to help show viewshafts including the use of photos and a visual tool for
incorporation into the e-Plan.
6444-35 Civic Trust Auckland cta@civictrustauckland.org.nz RPS General B10 RPS - Methods, Table 1
Amend table 1 by moving the Auckland Design Manual from the 'Advocacy and education'
section to the 'Non-statutory plans, strategies and statutory plans under other legislation'
section and provide an electronic link to the Auckland Design Manual.
6444-36 Civic Trust Auckland cta@civictrustauckland.org.nz RPS Urban growth
environment Provide for the Auckland Design Manual to become a statutory document.
6444-37 Civic Trust Auckland cta@civictrustauckland.org.nz General Chapter A Introduction
Plan
Move the section (C4.1) on trees to another section that contains other Natural heritage
components or some other appropriate section.
6444-38 Civic Trust Auckland cta@civictrustauckland.org.nz General Chapter A Introduction
Plan
Move the section on trees (H3.1) to another section that contains other Natural heritage
components or some other appropriate section.
organisms
modified organisms Retain the provisions especially the prohibition of the release of GMOs into the environment.
control
and policies
Retain the Pre-1944 Demolition Control overlay but extend to cover the whole of the Auckland
region, including the City Centre.
6444-41 Civic Trust Auckland cta@civictrustauckland.org.nz Special Character
residential
Identify post-1944 areas of historic character [infer Special Character] for protection and
include these in the Unitary Plan.
6444-42 Civic Trust Auckland cta@civictrustauckland.org.nz General Chapter G General provisions
status
Clarify which overlay takes precedence over another when there is more than one overlay in a
particular area.
6444-43 Civic Trust Auckland cta@civictrustauckland.org.nz General Eplan
Amend the maps to differentiate clearly between all categories e.g.
between Outstanding Natural Character and High Natural Character, and the legends on
maps should show the different overlays at the same time as the map that is being viewed.
6444-44 Civic Trust Auckland cta@civictrustauckland.org.nz Residential zones Residential
policies
Remove all 'orange zonings (intensification) [infer Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings]
where there is also a heritage overlay and / or volcanic viewshaft'.
Heritage
Amend policy 12 so that non-contributing features are considered as distinct from detracting
features. Refer to submission for details [page 20/49].
control
and policies
Amend the overlay description to explain why the date of 1944 was chosen and that
'character' may become 'historic heritage' over time. Refer to submission for details [pages 24-
25/49].
control
Amend notification provisions to require notification for all resource consents for demolition of
pre-1944 buildings. This notification could be limited to a narrower geographical area
surrounding the property but wider than just adjoining or adjacent properties. Refer to
submission for details [page 25/49].
295/1145
Sub#/
6444-48 Civic Trust Auckland cta@civictrustauckland.org.nz Precincts Ak-Wide and Coastal New Precincts All other New Precincts
Add new Auckland-wide precincts for the volcanic landforms to provide protection, manage
the interface with suburban development and acknowledge the intention for the Auckland
volcanic field to become a UNESCO world heritage site. Refer to submission for details
[pages 25-26/49].
statements
Amend the text under the heading Opportunities and constraints analysis in rule 2.7.1 to use
'shall' instead of 'should' to strengthen certainty of requirement.
statements
Amend rule 2.7.1 to require a heritage assessment to be included with every resource
consent application for the total or substantial demolition or removal of a building within the
Pre-1944 Demolition Control or Historic Heritage Area overlays, and that a heritage
assessment carried out by the applicant's expert to be reviewed independently within Council.
6444-51 Civic Trust Auckland cta@civictrustauckland.org.nz General Miscellaneous Bylaws and Licensing
Add a provision that all existing and future parks be designated smokefree as soon as is
practicable and well before 2025.
6444-52 Civic Trust Auckland cta@civictrustauckland.org.nz Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
Amend table 6 Required end-of-trip facilities in rule 3.2 Number of parking and loading
spaces, so that the provision of showers is not a requirement for places with fewer than 40
people.
requirements
Amend 'Required end-of-trip facilities' in rule 3.2 Number of parking and loading spaces so
that cycle parking, where practicable and reasonable, should be under cover.
requirements
Amend rule 3.2 Number of parking and loading spaces, to provide for dispensation from
parking requirements in order to avoid the destruction of heritage buildings.
requirements
Amend rule 3.2 Number of parking and loading spaces, to delete all minimum parking
requirement except for those providing parking for people with disabilities.
6444-56 Civic Trust Auckland cta@civictrustauckland.org.nz General Miscellaneous
Operational/
Projects/Acquisition Make parking cheaper at the edges of urban centres, compared to parking in the city centre.
6444-57 Civic Trust Auckland cta@civictrustauckland.org.nz Transport Auckland -wide C1.2 Policies Provide a comprehensive parking management plan across the entire region.
6444-58 Civic Trust Auckland cta@civictrustauckland.org.nz General C7.4/H6.3 Signs
Retain rule 3.2 Assessment criteria (1)(a)(v) (restricted discretionary activities) subject to
possible exceptions to allow Council discretion to provide for signs or billboards that are close
to or on a scheduled historic heritage place if they are compatible with the historical
precedent.
residential
Amend the descriptions of the characteristics of special character areas to be more robust
[infer Appendix 10 Special Character statements].
residential
Add new Special Character areas based around centres. Refer to submission for details
[pages 30-31/49].
residential
special character areas Reinstate business character areas from legacy plans.
residential
special character areas Retain the business and residential Special Character areas.
Heritage
Places
Retain the 12 new Historic Heritage areas and the roll over of the former conservation areas.
Refer to the submission for details [page 29-30/49].
6444-64 Civic Trust Auckland cta@civictrustauckland.org.nz General Chapter G General provisions G2.4 Notification
Amend the notification provisions for residential zones, business zones, City Centre zone,
precincts, Special Character Residential Isthmus and those that use the phrase 'the normal
tests for notification' to require Council to give public notification of certain categories of
resource consent applications which are significant and potentially in the public interest,
including activities relating to Historic Heritage, Special Character and the Pre-1944
Demolition Control. Refer to submission for details [page 32/49].
Include other significant and / or relevant organisations with a publicly recognised local or
regional interest as an affected party if the NZHPT [New Zealand Historic Places Trust] is
notified as an affected party and always notify NZHPT for controlled and restricted
discretionary activities affecting heritage items.
6444-66 Civic Trust Auckland cta@civictrustauckland.org.nz General Miscellaneous
Operational/
Amend the notification process through measures such as affixing a notice of notification to
the site the application relates to, determining the extent of affected persons on a locality or
physical distance, planning staff consulting more broadly and including more information on
the Council website.
Require any resource consent application for 'buildings higher than three storeys next to
mixed use or single lot dwellings be subject to limited notification.
Require the notification of resource consent applications to adjacent and adjoining
landowners be mandatory.
Require 'volunteer groups working on volcanic cones, reserves, riparian or coastal areas to be
notified of all resource consents in their respective areas, as affected parties'.
296/1145
Sub#/
General
Amend the minimum dwelling size rule for studio and 1 bedroom dwellings to increase to size
to 50m
2
in the Mixed Housing Urban, Mixed Housing Suburban and Terrace Housing
and Apartment Buildings zones. Refer to submission for detail [pages 33-34/49].
6444-71 Civic Trust Auckland cta@civictrustauckland.org.nz City Centre Zone I4 Rules/Appendix 7.1- 7.3
Increase the minimum dwelling size for studio and 1 bedroom dwellings to 50m
2
for the City
Centre zone. Refer to submission for detail [pages 33-34/49].
6444-72 Civic Trust Auckland cta@civictrustauckland.org.nz Residential zones Residential Land use controls
Amend table 1 in rule 3.1 Maximum density to increase the net site area from 200m
2
to 300m
2
within the Mixed Housing Suburban zone. Refer to submission for detail [page 34/49].
Amend rule 7.5, Table 5 Yards, to increase the minimum depth of the rear yard from 1m to
4m.
General
Amend the development controls for the Mixed Housing Suburban, Mixed Housing Urban and
Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings zones to require acoustic barriers (e.g. double door
entry baffling and double glazing) for dwelling in urban centres.
6444-75 Civic Trust Auckland cta@civictrustauckland.org.nz Public Open Space Zones Public Open Space I2.1 Activity table
Amend activity table 1 to delete the provisions that permits buildings and structures to be built
on parks and reserves.
6444-76 Civic Trust Auckland cta@civictrustauckland.org.nz Public Open Space Zones Public Open Space I2.1 Activity table
Require public notification of resource consent applications to place buildings and structures
on parks and reserves.
Heritage
objectives and policies Delete Category A* and recategorise anything with this category to Category A.
Retain rule 4.3 Assessment criteria for total or substantial demolition or partial demolition or
destruction
Delete clause 4.2 Assessment criteria [1](f) for restricted discretionary activities to remove the
cost of restoration from consideration. Refer to the submission for detail [page 37/49].
Amend rule 4.2 Assessment criteria (2) for restricted discretionary activities to reorder the
clauses and change the word faade to fabric. Refer to submission for detail [page 38/49].
Delete clause 4.2 Assessment criteria (1)(g) for restricted discretionary activities to remove
the cost of rehabilitation from consideration. Refer to submission for detail [page 38/49].
& C J3.3.1-7 Rules
Delete clause 5.2 Assessment criteria [2](f) for restricted discretionary activities to remove the
cost of rehabilitation from consideration. Refer to submission for detail [page 39/49].
Amend Assessment criteria clause 6.2(4)(a) for restricted discretionary activities to change
historic form to historic fabric. Refer to submission for detail [page 39/49].
Delete clause 5.2 Assessment criteria [2][c](ii) for restricted discretionary activities to remove
the cost of rehabilitation from consideration. Refer to submission for detail [pages 39-40/49].
6444-85 Civic Trust Auckland cta@civictrustauckland.org.nz Precincts - City Centre Port K3.7 Precinct Rules / Mapping
Retain the non-complying activity status for 'reclamation or drainage not otherwise provided
for'.
6444-86 Civic Trust Auckland cta@civictrustauckland.org.nz Definitions New
Add a new definition for 'character defining' in relation to Special Character and provide an
electronic link to the definition. Refer to submission for detail [page 41/49].
Add a new definition for 'character supporting' in relation to Special Character and provide an
electronic link to the definition. Refer to submission for detail [page 41/49].
Add a new definition for 'Historic character' (currently proposed as "special character") and
provide an electronic link to the definition.
Add a new definition for 'Historic heritage' and provide an electronic link to the definition.
Refer to the submission for detail [page 41/49].
6444-90 Civic Trust Auckland cta@civictrustauckland.org.nz Definitions New Add a new definition for 'Rural character' and provide an electronic link to the definition.
Add a new definition for 'the various types of precincts' and provide an electronic link to the
definition. [specific relief sought unclear]
6444-92 Civic Trust Auckland cta@civictrustauckland.org.nz Trees
Trees
Notable Trees Review the threshold for scheduling a notable tree.
Amend the process for nominating a notable tree to provide ongoing information to anyone
who nominates a tree, including if the tree met the criteria for scheduling and when a resource
consent application is lodged that affects the tree. Refer to the submission for details [page
41/49].
SEAs
Land Check the overlay on the ground before implementation.
the CMA
sch. 6.2 ONC/HNC
6.1 Schedule SEA
Marine 1 and 2 Check the overlay on the ground before implementation.
297/1145
Sub#/
Heritage
Places Retain the Heritage values in Appendix 9.1.
residential
Add the North Shore City Council Residential 3 section 16 rules and appendices, including the
guides for the extent of demolition, into the special character statement.
6444-98 Civic Trust Auckland cta@civictrustauckland.org.nz Zoning Central
Rezone Spring Street, Freemans Bay from Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings to
mixed housing [specific preferred zone not stated].
6444-99 Civic Trust Auckland cta@civictrustauckland.org.nz Zoning Central
Rezone College Hill, Freemans Bay [infer the sites that back onto Dublin Street, Freemans
Bay], from Mixed Use to res 1 [infer Single House zone or Residential 1 zone in the Operative
Auckland Council District Plan - Isthmus section].
6444-
100 Civic Trust Auckland cta@civictrustauckland.org.nz Special Character
residential
Include Ponsonby Road, Ponsonby from Franklin Road to Pember Reeves Street in the
character overlay [infer Special Character overlay].
6444-
101 Civic Trust Auckland cta@civictrustauckland.org.nz Zoning Central
Rezone Gladstone Road from Parnell to Taurarua Terrace from Terrace Housing and
Apartment Buildings to Single House.
6444-
102 Civic Trust Auckland cta@civictrustauckland.org.nz Zoning Central
Retain Mixed Housing Urban, Mixed Housing suburban and Single House zoning in Mount
Eden, Three Kings and Balmoral as shown on the Urban Grid 32 map.
6444-
103 Civic Trust Auckland cta@civictrustauckland.org.nz Zoning Central Rezone Ashton Road, Mount Eden to Single House.
6444-
104 Civic Trust Auckland cta@civictrustauckland.org.nz Historic Heritage (Overlay)
Heritage
Places
Rezone Empire Road, Epsom as a historic heritage area [infer add to the schedule of
Significant Historic Heritage Places].
6444-
105 Civic Trust Auckland cta@civictrustauckland.org.nz
Retain the overlay for Royal Oak, Greenwoods Corner and Onehunga as shown on the Urban
Grid 40 map [inferred].
6444-
106 Civic Trust Auckland cta@civictrustauckland.org.nz Definitions Existing
Amend the definition of 'streetscape' to remove trees. Refer to the submission for details
[page 47/49].
6444-
107 Civic Trust Auckland cta@civictrustauckland.org.nz RPS Issues
heritage
Council to keep and make available online a list of all historic heritage nominations, including
all information provided with the nomination. Refer to submission for details [page 44/49].
6444-
Heritage
Places
Include all current NZHPT (New Zealand Historic Places Trust) registrations including all
places, areas and interiors identified on the NZHPT Register in the schedule of Significant
Historic Heritage Places. Categorise the NZHPT Category 1 as Category A and include the
NZHPT registration number and type. Refer to the submission for details [page 44/49].
6444-
Heritage
Places
Review Appendix 9.1 to determine if there is new information available that may result in a
change to the schedule, including the reclassification of an item from Category B to Category
A. Refer to submission for details [page 43/49].
6444-
Heritage
Places
Assess 55-57 Customs Street East (Showgirls), Central City for heritage values and either
add to the schedule or give some other lesser level of recognition.
6444-
Heritage
Places
Assess 95-105 Customs Street East (Sofrana), Central City for heritage values and either add
to the schedule or give some other lesser level of recognition.
6444-
Heritage
Places
Assess 63 Fort Street (Claymore House), Central City for heritage values and either add to
the schedule or give some other lesser level of recognition.
6444-
Heritage
Places
Assess 21 Emily Place (offices), Central City for heritage values and either add to the
schedule or give some other lesser level of recognition.
6444-
Heritage
Places
Assess 68-70 Khyber Pass (Saint David's Church), Grafton for heritage values and either add
to the schedule or give some other lesser level of recognition.
6444-
Heritage
Places
Add any items to the schedule that have failed to meet the previous legacy council thresholds
for scheduling. Refer to page 43/49 of the submission for details.
6444-
Heritage
Places Add 45 Airedale Street, Central City (Telephone Exchange) to the schedule.
6444-
Heritage
Places
Add 35 Albert Street, Central City (Commercial Building (Angus Steak House 1996)) to the
schedule.
6444-
Heritage
Places
Add the Wilson and Horton Building, 46-60 Albert Street and the corner of Wyndham Street,
Central City to the schedule.
298/1145
Sub#/
6444-
Heritage
Places Add 66 Albert Street, Central City (Wilson & Horton Building) to the schedule.
6444-
Heritage
Places
Add 122-126 Anzac Ave, Central City (Station Hotel (Harbourview Station Hotel 1996)) to the
schedule.
6444-
Heritage
Places Add 123 Beaumont Street, Central City (Mount Smart Marine) to the schedule.
6444-
Heritage
Places Add 136 Beaumont Street, Central City (Orams Marine) to the schedule.
6444-
Heritage
Places Add 5 City Road, Central City (Littlejohns / Barts Restaurants 1996) to the schedule.
6444-
Heritage
Places Add 47 Customs Street East, Central City (Achilles House) to the schedule.
6444-
Heritage
Places Add 26-32 Eden Crescent, Central City (Dominion Printer) to the schedule.
6444-
Heritage
Places
Add the three storey commercial building, 8 Elliot Street and Darby Street Corner, Central City
to the schedule.
6444-
Heritage
Places Add 35 Graham Street, Central City (BJ Ball Building, including the mural) to the schedule.
6444-
Heritage
Places Add 1 Grey Ave, Central City (Auckland City Council Administration Building) to the schedule.
6444-
Heritage
Places Add 115-139 Grey Avenue, Central City (Grey Avenue Flats) to the schedule.
6444-
Heritage
Places
Add 2 High Street, Central City (The Commercial Hotel (De Bretts Hotel 1996)) to the
schedule.
6444-
Heritage
Places
Add 27 High Street, Central City (Andrews and Clarke Building (Plaza Centre Ltd 1996)) to
the schedule.
6444-
Heritage
Places Add 35 High Street, Central City (Keans Building (Rakinos 1998)) to the schedule.
6444-
Heritage
Places
Add 2 Hobson Street, Central City (Maxwells Building (Dunningham House 1996)) to the
schedule.
6444-
Heritage
Places Add 30-32 Hobson Street, Central City (Liston House including sculpture) to the schedule.
6444-
Heritage
Places
Add 64-66 Hobson Street, Central City (Auckland Glass Company Building (Doyles 1996)) to
the schedule.
6444-
Heritage
Places
Add 246 Hobson Street, Central City (Shops and associate stables (Offices 1998)) to the
schedule.
6444-
Heritage
Places Add the Jean Batten State Building - faade, Jean Batten Place, Central City to the schedule.
6444-
Heritage
Places
Add the Newton Post Office (including Guy Ngan bronze sculpture - in storage), corner of
Karangahape Road and East Street, Newton to the schedule.
6444-
Heritage
Places
Add 18 Kitchener Street, Central City (Stables / motor garage (Black Crow Caf 1996)) to the
schedule.
299/1145
Sub#/
6444-
Heritage
Places Add 22 Kitchener Street, Central City (Commercial Building (Sister 1996)) to the schedule.
6444-
Heritage
Places
Add 24 Kitchener Street, Central City (Kapia Corn Broom Company Building (Standard Issue -
Retail 1996)) to the schedule.
6444-
Heritage
Places Add 5 Nicholas Street, Central City (Cottage) to the schedule.
6444-
Heritage
Places Add 7 Nicholas Street, Central City (Cottage) to the schedule.
6444-
Heritage
Places
Add 10 OConnell Street, Central City (Royal Exchange Assurance (Soul Haircutting 1996)) to
the schedule.
6444-
Heritage
Places Add 8 Pitt Street, Newton (Shops / residential) to the schedule.
6444-
Heritage
Places Add 8a Pitt Street, Newton (Methodist Church (Art Barn 1998)) to the schedule.
6444-
Heritage
Places Add 59 Pitt Street, Newton (Commercial Building (Davis Furnishings 1996)) to the schedule.
6444-
Heritage
Places Add 61 Pitt Street, Newton (Beggs Building) to the schedule.
6444-
Heritage
Places Add 70-76 Pitt Street, Newton (Commercial / residential building - faade) to the schedule.
6444-
Heritage
Places Add 20 Poynton Terrace, Central City (Espano Flats) to the schedule.
6444-
Heritage
Places Add the Custodians House, University of Auckland, Princes St, Central City to the schedule.
6444-
Heritage
Places Add 2 Queen Street, Central City (Endeans Building) to the schedule.
6444-
Heritage
Places Add 48-50 Queen Street, Central City (Imperial Building) to the schedule.
6444-
Heritage
Places Add 54-56 Queen Street, Central City (Everybodys Building) to the schedule.
6444-
Heritage
Places Add 58-60 Queen Street, Central City (Windsor House) to the schedule.
6444-
Heritage
Places Add 112 Queen Street, Central City (Beggs Building (Strevens 1996)) to the schedule.
6444-
Heritage
Places
Add 131-143 Queen Street, Central City (Milne & Choyce Department Store Building (Centre
Court 1996)) to the schedule.
6444-
Heritage
Places Add 166 Queen Street, Central City (Warwick Building) to the schedule.
6444-
Heritage
Places
Add 170-174 Queen Street, Central City (Commercial Building (Canterbury Arcade 1996)) to
the schedule.
6444-
Heritage
Places
Add 214-220 Queen Street, Central City (AMP Society Building (including bronze screen and
sculpture by David Barker)) to the schedule.
300/1145
Sub#/
6444-
Heritage
Places Add 224 Queen Street, Central City (Hallensteins Building) to the schedule.
6444-
Heritage
Places
Add the Smith & Caughey Department Store, Queen Street half of Queen to Elliott Streets,
253-261 Queen Street / Elliott Street, Central City to the schedule.
6444-
Heritage
Places
Add the Civic Tavern (Queen & Wellesley St associated retail use 1996), 263-267 Queen
Street, Central City to the schedule.
6444-
Heritage
Places
Add 317 Queen Street, Central City (Commercial Building (Pilgrims Lunch Bar / Manifesto
1998)) to the schedule.
6444-
Heritage
Places
Add 371 Queen Street, Central City (Theosophical Society Building (The Club 1996)) to the
schedule.
6444-
Heritage
Places
Add the Barristers Chambers (associated retail use 1996), 23 Shortland Street and the corner
of OConnell Street, Central City to the schedule.
6444-
Heritage
Places Add 93 Shortland Street, Central City (Shortland Flats) to the schedule.
6444-
Heritage
Places
Add 9 Symonds Street, Central City (House (Asian Languages Building 1996)) to the
schedule.
6444-
Heritage
Places Add 1 Union Street, Central City (Higher Thought Temple) to the schedule.
6444-
Heritage
Places Add the Caretakers Residence Victoria Park, Victoria Street, Central City to the schedule.
6444-
Heritage
Places Add 150 Victoria Street, Central City (Rainger House) to the schedule.
6444-
Heritage
Places
Add the Chemist Shop Building (The Dispensary Bar 1998), corner of Victoria Street West
and Hobson Street, Central City to the schedule.
6444-
Heritage
Places Add 10 Vulcan Lane, Central City (Leon Brook Models Building) to the schedule.
6444-
Heritage
Places
Add 24 Wellesley Street, West, Central City (Bledisloe State Building (Bledisloe House 1999))
to the schedule.
6444-
Heritage
Places
Add the McGregor Wright Building, 86-90 Wellesley Street West, corner Nelson Street,
Central City to the schedule.
6444-
Heritage
Places
Add 26 Wynham Street, Central City (Former Gas Co Building (Dick Smith Electronics 1998))
to the schedule.
6444-
Heritage
Places
Add 33 Wyndham Street, Central City (Former AA Building (Peoples Centre 1998)) to the
schedule.
6444-
Heritage
Places Add 8 Kings Road, Panmure (Loombs Hotel) to the schedule.
6445-1 Nigel and Gloria Hosken nigel@hosken.co.nz Precincts - West New Precincts
Add a new precinct for Te Atatu Peninsula and replace generic provisions with specific
objectives, policies, rules and plans more directly related to the needs and aspirations of
these communities.
6445-2 Nigel and Gloria Hosken nigel@hosken.co.nz Precincts - West New Precincts
Add a new precinct for Te Atatu South and replace generic provisions with specific objectives,
policies, rules and plans more directly related to the needs and aspirations of these
communities.
6445-3 Nigel and Gloria Hosken nigel@hosken.co.nz General Chapter A Introduction
DP provisions
Amend provisions so that the zones are only operative after new precinct plans have been
completed for Te Atatu Peninsula and Te Atatu South.
6445-4 Nigel and Gloria Hosken nigel@hosken.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - Urban zones H5.2 3.1 Residential zones Delete Rule 3(a) [Rear sites].
301/1145
Sub#/
6445-5 Nigel and Gloria Hosken nigel@hosken.co.nz Residential zones Residential
Amend Rule 6.2 'Building Height' to allow for maximum building height of 9m in the Single
House zone.
Amend Rule 7.2 'Building Height' to allow for maximum building height of 9m in the Mixed
Amend rule 6.10 'Fences', to define, for corner sites, the yard which has the garage and front
door as the 'front yard' for the purpose of restricting the height and location of any fence in the
Single House zone.
Amend rule 7.15 'Fences' to define, for corner sites, the yard which has the garage and front
and Coastal Settlement zone Delete rule 6.12 'Universal Access'.
Mixed Housing Urban zone Delete rule 7.22 'Universal Access'.
Mixed Housing Urban zone Delete rule 8.24 'Universal Access'.
Terrace Housing and
Apartment Buildings zone Delete rule 9.23 'Universal Access'.
and Coastal Settlement zone Delete rule 6.11(1) Garages, relating to garage widths in the Single House zone.
Mixed Housing Urban zone Delete rule 7.16(1) Garages, relating to garage widths in the Mixed Housing Suburban zone.
Delete rule 7.16(3) Garages, relating to garage setbacks in the Mixed Housing Suburban
zone.
Mixed Housing Urban zone Delete rule 7.10 'Outlook Space' in the Mixed Housing Suburban zone.
Delete rule 7.11 'Separation between buildings within a site' in the Mixed Housing Suburban
zone.
Mixed Housing Urban zone Delete rule 7.13 ' Dwellings fronting the street' in the Mixed Housing Suburban zone.
Mixed Housing Urban zone Delete rule 8.13 ' Dwellings fronting the street' in the Mixed Housing Urban zone.
Mixed Housing Urban zone Delete rule 7.14 ' Maximum building length' in the Mixed Housing Suburban zone.
Mixed Housing Urban zone Delete rule 7.18, relating to minimum room sizes in the Mixed Housing Suburban zone.
Mixed Housing Urban zone Delete rule 7.20 'Water and wastewater' in the Mixed Housing Suburban zone.
302/1145
Sub#/
Mixed Housing Urban zone Delete rule 8.20 'Water and wastewater' in the Mixed Housing Urban zone.
Mixed Housing Urban zone Delete rule 7.21 'Storage' in the Mixed Housing Suburban zone.
Mixed Housing Urban zone Delete rule 8.22 'Storage' in the Mixed Housing Urban zone.
Mixed Housing Urban zone Delete rule 9.20 'Storage' in the Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings zone.
Amend rule 8.2 'Building Height' to increase the maximum height in the Mixed Housing Urban
zone to 12m and 3 storeys.
Amend rule 8.3 [Height in relation to boundary] so that the height in relation to boundary
control in the Mixed Housing Urban zone only applies to any boundary where the adjacent
property is a lower density zone, with only the building setbacks applying at other boundaries.
Amend rule 8.4 [Alternative height in relation to boundary] so that the height in relation to
boundary control in the Mixed Housing Urban zone only applies to any boundary where the
adjacent property is a lower density zone, with only the building setbacks applying at other
boundaries.
Amend rule 9.2 'Building Height' by increasing the maximum height in the Terrace Housing
and Apartment Buildings zone to 12m and 3 storeys.
Amend Rule 9.2 [Building height] by increasing the permitted height of the basement above
ground to 1.5m where basement car parking is provided in the Terrace Housing and
Terrace Housing and
Amend Rule 9.4 Building setbacks, so that the building setback rule in the Terrace Housing
and Apartment Buildings zone only applies on any residential boundary where the adjacent
residential zone is of a lesser density.
6445-35 Nigel and Gloria Hosken nigel@hosken.co.nz Public Open Space Zones Public Open Space I2.1 Activity table
Amend provisions so that any building in a Public Open Space zone has an activity status that
is not less than restricted discretionary.
6445-36 Nigel and Gloria Hosken nigel@hosken.co.nz Public Open Space Zones Public Open Space I2.1 Activity table
Amend provisions so that any stormwater management device associated with, or installed to
mitigate the effects of, building activity in a Public Open Space zone has the same activity
status as the building activity itself.
6445-37 Nigel and Gloria Hosken nigel@hosken.co.nz Mana Whenua General provisions
discovery protocol Delete Rule G2.5 'Accidental Discovery Protocols'.
6445-38 Nigel and Gloria Hosken nigel@hosken.co.nz Mana Whenua General provisions
assessment Delete Rule G2.7.4(4) relating to cultural impact assessments.
Special info. req. Delete Rule I1.12.1, relating to the requirement for a Design statement.
6445-40 Nigel and Gloria Hosken nigel@hosken.co.nz
Centre) Business
Special information
requirements Delete Rule 10.1, relating to the requirement for a Design statement.
6445-41 Nigel and Gloria Hosken nigel@hosken.co.nz General Chapter G General provisions
statements Delete all rules relating to Design statements.
6445-42 Nigel and Gloria Hosken nigel@hosken.co.nz Residential zones Housing affordability H6.6 Rules Delete 6.6 'Affordable Housing' and related provisions.
6445-43 Nigel and Gloria Hosken nigel@hosken.co.nz Sustainable Development C7.7/H6.4 Sustainable design Delete Rule 6.4.1 'Dwellings'.
6445-44 Nigel and Gloria Hosken nigel@hosken.co.nz Sustainable Development C7.7/H6.4 Sustainable design Delete Rule 6.4.2 'Offices'.
6445-45 Nigel and Gloria Hosken nigel@hosken.co.nz Sustainable Development C7.7/H6.4 Sustainable design Delete Rule 6.4.3 'Industrial activities'.
6446-1 Karen J Guthrie guthrie.family@xtra.co.nz Mineral extraction
Buffer Area
Amend the Brookby Quarry buffer area to extend from the working face of the quarry (as per
the decision from the Environment Court) rather than from the boundary fence.
6447-1 R C Blakey
7C Atkin Avenue, Mission Bay,
Whenua
Amend the Sites and Places to Value to Mana Whenua overlay so that the extent is reduced
to only include the area needed to protect the historic heritage resource in question.
6447-2 R C Blakey
7C Atkin Avenue, Mission Bay,
assessment Delete rule 2.7.4 Cultural impact assessment that requires a cultural impact assessment.
6448-1 Beverley Gott beverleyfrancesg@gmail.com
organisms
modified organisms Retain GMO provisions.
organisms
modified organisms Amend Section 2 heading to read 'Land Use and CMA and controls'.
303/1145
Sub#/
organisms
modified organisms Amend activity status of GE [genetically engineered] vaccines to a Prohibited activity.
organisms
modified organisms Request cosistent regulatory approach to GMOs across Auckland and Northland.
6449-1
Madill and Smeed Limited /
Halls Transport roadhouse@clear.net.nz Zoning South
Retain the 'Light Industry Zone for the properties 1 Rawson Way (Lot 8 DP 125972), 58
Spartan Road (Lot 1 DP 43974) and 81 Spartan Road (Lot 2 DP 48958), Takanini.
6449-2
Halls Transport roadhouse@clear.net.nz Definitions Existing Add 'freight depots' to the definition of industrial activities, otherwise retain definition.
6449-3
Halls Transport roadhouse@clear.net.nz Precincts - South New Precincts All other New Precincts
Prepare a structure plan for the wider Takanini industrial area and incorporate provisions for
transportation and connectivity with the wider road network.
6449-4
Halls Transport roadhouse@clear.net.nz Designations
New Zealand Railways
Corporation
6302 North Island Main Trunk
Railway Line Retain Designation 6302 and the delineation of that designation.
6449-5
Halls Transport roadhouse@clear.net.nz Zoning South
Rezone as a Light Industry zone the portion of the railway reserve currently used in
conjunction with the Submitters' freight depot at 1 Spartan Road and 15 Spartan Road,
Takanini. Refer to submission - Figure 3, pg 4/13.
6449-6
Halls Transport roadhouse@clear.net.nz
Centre) Business
zones
Increase the proposed 20m maximum building height (Rule 5.1) to the height limit that
currently applies under the Operative Plan.
6449-7
Centre) Business
zones Retain the 3m front yard setback (Rule 5.4 - Table 7) for the Light Industry zone.
6449-8
Centre) Business
zones
Amend the front yard to 0 metres for the western boundary of the properties 1 Spartan Road
and 15 Spartan Road (referred to as Locality B in the Submission) where the land adjoins the
Takanini off-ramp.The requirement for landscaping Rule 5.4.(1) along this boundary should be
waived. Refer to submission Figure 3, page 4/13.
6449-9
Centre) Business
zones
Amend the landscaping provision (Rule 5.4.1) to require trees capable of reaching a height
limit of 5m, spaced at 5m intervals to be provided along the full length of the front yard only
where sites adjoin a residential zone or a reserve.
6449-10
Halls Transport roadhouse@clear.net.nz Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
Retain the option to calculate the on-site parking requirement based on 0.7 spaces / FTE
employee (Rule 3.2 Parking and Loading, Table 4).
6449-11
Halls Transport roadhouse@clear.net.nz Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
Amend the means of calculating on-site parking based on GFA to 1 space / 100m
2
as per the
Operative Plan, as opposed to 1 space / 50m
2
(Rule 3.2 Parking and Loading, Table 4).
6449-12
Halls Transport roadhouse@clear.net.nz General Noise and vibration H6.2 Rules
Amend the ambient noise standards to apply site specific noise controls to Locality B (refer
submission page 4/13), that take into account the high ambient noise levels already present in
the Takanini Interchange so that the generic noise standards in Rule 6.2 Noise and vibration,
1.2 Table 11, do not apply.
6449-13
Centre) Business
Retain Industrial activities as a permitted activity for the properties 1 Rawson Way (Lot 8 DP
125972), 58 Spartan Road (Lot 1 DP 43974) and 81 Spartan Road (Lot 2 DP 48958).
6449-14
Halls Transport roadhouse@clear.net.nz Definitions New
Retain the 'Light Industry Zone definition of 'industrial activities' for the properties 1 Rawson
Way (Lot 8 DP 125972), 58 Spartan Road (Lot 1 DP 43974) and 81 Spartan Road (Lot 2 DP
48958).
6450-1 V G Harford
7B Atkin Avenue, Mission Bay,
Whenua
Amend the Sites and Places to Value to Mana Whenua overlay so that the extent is reduced
to only include the area needed to protect the historic heritage resource in question.
6450-2 V G Harford
7B Atkin Avenue, Mission Bay,
assessment
Delete rule 2.7.4 Cultural impact assessment that requires the need for a cultural impact
assessment.
6451-1 Jasmine Kovach ijkovach@orcon.net.nz Zoning Central
Rezone Church Street, Neilson Street, Station Road, O'Rourke Road, Maurice Road -
Onehunga, from Business and Heavy Industry to include Mixed Housing Urban and Terrace
Housing and Apartment Buildings.
6452-1 John Kinsella jbkinsella@hotmail.com RPS Mana Whenua B5 Strategic Delete Mana Whenua provisons
6453-1 Andrea Middup
27A Booralee Avenue, Botany
Downs, Auckland 2010 RPS Mana Whenua B5 Strategic Remove rules requiring consultation with Iwi regarding building/alterations.
6454-1 Angela da Silva angeladasilva@yahoo.com Zoning Central
Allow high rise, high density housing in central Auckland areas i.e. Ponsonby, Newmarket,
Kingsland, and Herne Bay as well as other centres.
6455-1 Ray and Stan Ulyate mark@thurlow.co.nz Zoning North and Islands
Rezone 23 and 26 Travis View Drive, Fairview Heights (Lot 1 and 24 DP 467558) from Single
House and Mixed Housing Suburban to Mixed Housing Urban.
6455-2 Ray and Stan Ulyate mark@thurlow.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - Urban zones H5.2 3.1 Residential zones Amend the minimum net site area for the Single House zone to be 500m
2
.
6456-1 Grant Hewison grant@granthewison.co.nz Infrastructure
Energy
Amend 'Electricity Generation' to include: 'The use of radioactive material for the purposes of
power generation ' prohibited in all zones.
304/1145
Sub#/
6456-2 Grant Hewison grant@granthewison.co.nz
Amend 1 Activity Table to include under the heading 'Activity': 'the manufacture, production,
use, storage and disposal of radioactive material in excess of 10 terbequerel (1x1013Bq)'
prohibited in all zones.
6457-1 Greg and Michelle Garnett burnette@opc.net.nz RPS Changes to the RUB North and Waiheke Island Retain 1794 State Highway 1, Warkworth, within the RUB.
6457-2 Greg and Michelle Garnett burnette@opc.net.nz Future Urban I5 Rules
Ensure that land use provisions within the Future Urban zone do not compromise the ability of
the land to continue to be used for lawfully established land use activities such as the golf
driving range and related activities at 1794 State Highway 1, Warkworth.
6457-3 Greg and Michelle Garnett burnette@opc.net.nz Future Urban
Ensure that the policy framework for structure planning and rezoning land from rural to urban
makes provision to recognise the continuing operation of lawfully established non urban
activities.
6457-4 Greg and Michelle Garnett burnette@opc.net.nz Rural Zones General I13.1 Activity table
Retain in their current form the following permitted activities within the Rural Coastal zone and
their related definitions: 'Farming', 'Greenhouses', 'Intensive farming', 'Intensive poultry
farming', 'Free-range poultry farming', 'Forestry', 'On-site primary produce manufacturing',
'Dwellings', 'Home occupations', 'Care centres', 'Information facilities', 'Artworks', and 'Artisan
industries'.
6457-5 Greg and Michelle Garnett burnette@opc.net.nz General Editorial and Part 6
Amend the terms 'site type' and 'feature code' in Appendix 3.1 Schedule of the Outstanding
Natural Features overlay, in the fourth column of the table, and in the introduction of Chapter
J 'Overlay rules', section 6.4 'Natural Heritage Outstanding Natural Features' to use a
consistent terminology.
6457-6 Greg and Michelle Garnett burnette@opc.net.nz General Cross plan matters
Amend the rules for activities, earthworks and vegetation management in ONF's to enable the
ongoing use of the property at 108 Okahukura Road, Tapora as a permitted activity.
6457-7 Greg and Michelle Garnett burnette@opc.net.nz Mana Whenua General provisions
assessment
ONF, and clause (1) for earthworks within 50m of a site or place of value to Mana Whenua.
6458-1 Colette M Holland-Kearins colettekearins@hotmail.com RPS Urban growth
quality compact urban form Reject intensification of housing.
6458-2 Colette M Holland-Kearins colettekearins@hotmail.com General Chapter G General provisions G2.4 Notification
Delete provisions that allow consent applications to infringe development controls to be
processed without notification to public or affected parties.
6459-1 Charles P T Hutchison paul.hutchison@parliament.govt.nz
SEAs
Areas - Land rules (all) Amend SEA rules to ensure complying farming activity is not affected by the overlay.
6459-2 Charles P T Hutchison paul.hutchison@parliament.govt.nz RPS
Amend SEA provisions to ensure the applicant does not incur any personal expense or cost
from the overlay.
6459-3 Charles P T Hutchison paul.hutchison@parliament.govt.nz RPS
Amend SEA provisions to ensure any loss of property rights or to land use is fully
compensated financially or by subdivision rights.
6459-4 Charles P T Hutchison paul.hutchison@parliament.govt.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - Rural zones
area
Amend subdivision rules to enable the creation of an extra title for blocks less than 5ha in
return for covenanted wetland or native plantings.
6460-1 Heritage Landscapes mandymc@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central Retain Single House zoning for 27 Cromwell Street, Mt Eden.
6460-2 Heritage Landscapes mandymc@xtra.co.nz Public Open Space Zones
and policies Retain provisions.
6460-3 Heritage Landscapes mandymc@xtra.co.nz Precincts Ak-Wide and Coastal Stadiums and Showgrounds
Objectives and Policies Retain Eden Park Sub-Precinct provisions.
6460-4 Heritage Landscapes mandymc@xtra.co.nz General
H6.5) Exclude rules from applying to the Eden Park Sub-precinct.
6460-5 Heritage Landscapes mandymc@xtra.co.nz General Chapter G General provisions G2.4 Notification
Amend to require all Restricted Discretionary activities to be subject to normal RMA
notification tests.
6460-6 Heritage Landscapes mandymc@xtra.co.nz Residential zones Residential Land use controls
Delete 200m
2
maximum density requirement on sites greater than 1200m
2
in the Mixed
6460-7 Heritage Landscapes mandymc@xtra.co.nz Residential zones Residential Land use controls
Delete unlimited density requirement on sites greater than 1200m
2
in the Mixed Housing
Urban zone.
6460-8 Heritage Landscapes mandymc@xtra.co.nz
Centre) Business
& Bus. Park zones
Amend activity status for taverns and drive thrus within 30m of residential zones from
Restricted Discretionary to Discretionary.
6460-9 Heritage Landscapes mandymc@xtra.co.nz Special Character
& C J3.3.1-7 Rules Amend activity status of demolition from Restricted Discretionary to Discretionary.
6460-10 Heritage Landscapes mandymc@xtra.co.nz Special Character
& C J3.3.1-7 Rules Remove 'relocation of removed building' as an assessment criteria.
6460-11 Heritage Landscapes mandymc@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central
Rezone Sandringham Road from Rossmay Terrace south (both sides) to Gribblehirst Road to
from Mixed Housing Urban to Mixed Housing Suburban, with max dwelling at 300m
2
.
6460-12 Heritage Landscapes mandymc@xtra.co.nz Built Environment (Overlays)
Height Control
Amend Eden Valley Local Centre additional height control from 12.5m per 3 storey to 10m per
2 storey.
305/1145
Sub#/
Reject Mixed Use zone south of Prospect Tce, and east and west of Brixton Road, Mt Eden.
[Alternative zoning not provided]
Reject Mixed Housing Urban and Mixed Use zones around Balmoral Road, west to
Sandringham Road, north to Kingspand, east to Mt Eden Road and north to New North Road
until there is a proven shortage of intensified zone land.
6460-15 Heritage Landscapes mandymc@xtra.co.nz Historic Heritage (Overlay)
Heritage
heritage areas
Amend historic heritage provisions to require removal of homes to be a Non Complying
activity and be subject to public notification.
control
Extend the pre 1944 demolition overlay to include the residential streets between Balmoral, Mt
Eden and Dominion Roads, including Burnley, Onslow, Sandringham and Cromwell Streets,
Valley View, Horoeaka and Dominion Roads.
6460-17 Heritage Landscapes mandymc@xtra.co.nz General Miscellaneous
Operational/
Reduce the number of public carparks available in areas serviced by public transport,
redevelop strategically located land currently allocated to car parking in the city into residential
apartments. Build more cycle lanes and shared walking and cycling trails. Increase investment
in trains and buses.
6460-18 Heritage Landscapes mandymc@xtra.co.nz Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
Amend to require new developments to incorporate transport plans that include a range of
transport options, including public transport.
6460-19 Heritage Landscapes mandymc@xtra.co.nz Transport Auckland -wide
requirements Amend to require new shopping malls to be serviced by public tranpsort.
Centre) Business
Amend to promote development of small decentralised shows that people can walk or cycle
to.
6460-21 Heritage Landscapes mandymc@xtra.co.nz RPS Urban growth
Amend to require new developments to have green space and local parks that can produce
local food.
6460-22 Heritage Landscapes mandymc@xtra.co.nz RPS
Amend to strengthen the protection for scheduled trees and increase the number of trees that
are protected, including regulatory and non regulatory methods.
6460-23 Heritage Landscapes mandymc@xtra.co.nz Historic Heritage (Overlay)
Heritage
Amend to include the role of trees in the heritage character overlays of all older residential
areas.
6460-24 Heritage Landscapes mandymc@xtra.co.nz Trees
Trees J6.4 Rules Amend to extend protection of trees to all zones.
6460-25 Heritage Landscapes mandymc@xtra.co.nz General Miscellaneous
Operational/
Projects/Acquisition Plant more trees in parks and reserves, streets and public spaces.
character and natural heritage B4.3.4 Biodiversity Amend to apply a no net loss approach for biodiversity across the region.
SEAs
and policies Add objectives and policies for SEAs.
SEAs
Assessment
Amend to require resource consents to include an assessment of environmental effects for
protected species.
Amend Objective 1 to be specific as to what it seeks to achieve in a manner that
is measurable.
character and natural heritage B4.3.3 Trees and vegetation Retain Objective 2.
character and natural heritage B4.3.3 Trees and vegetation Amend Objective 3 to include a requirement to maintain and enhance both cover and quality.
Amend Policy 1 to establish a second category recognising trees that fall slightly under the
threshold, but that will mature over time to become Notable examples, with such trees subject
to more lenient pruning conditions or other flexibility.
character and natural heritage B4.3.3 Trees and vegetation Amend Policy 2 to refer to protect as well as promote.
character and natural heritage B4.3.3 Trees and vegetation Amend Policy 3 to include individual tress and groups of trees.
Amend Policy 5 as follows 'Maintain or enhance the number and quality of recognise
the benefit public trees provide within roads and in reserves while acknowledging the multiple
uses of these spaces'.
Amend to include further general tree protection provisions for riparian margins, urban
bush gullies and coastal conservation areas.
streets and public open space C4.1 Objectives and Policies Retain Objective 2.
Amend Objective 3 as follows 'enable the efficient maintenance and upgrading of utilities in
streets provided there is not net loss while achieving a net gain in the extent and quality
values of trees or groups of trees'.
306/1145
Sub#/
SEAs
and policies Retain Background.
SEAs
and policies
Amend Objective 1 as follows 'The ecosystem services and indigenous biological
diversity values of vegetation in sensitive environments and areas of contiguous native
vegetation cover are recognised, and maintained and enhanced while providing
for reasonable use and development .
Trees E6.1 Objectives and policies
Amend as follows 'Notable trees and notable groups of trees are protected, maintained and
enhanced retained '.
Trees E6.1 Objectives and policies Amend Policy 3 to reduce flexibility for allowing impacts.
Amend to allow the removal of pest plants in public open space as a Permitted activity for all
parties.
Amend so the provisions do not provide for other than minor alteration of vegetation by
Network Utility Operators.
Recognise Permitted activities constitute a weak alternative to controlled activity status or
above.
SEAs
table - Vegetation
roads
Amend the setbacks for vegetation alteration or removal in the Rural Production zone from
10m to 20m.
SEAs
table - Vegetation
roads
Amend the coastal protection yard for restrictions on vegetation alteration or removal to be
extended to 100m in all zones.
SEAs
table - Vegetation
roads
Amend activity status of alteration or removal of vegetation by a network utility operator from
permitted to a more restrictive activity status.
SEAs
Add control for the maximum vegetation extent able to be altered or removed under
Controlled activity status, e.g., 300m
2
.
SEAs
overlays (except SEAs) Retain removal of Kauri deadwood provisions.
SEAs
Areas - Land rules (all) Retain control on tree trimming within 10m of existing buildings within a SEA.
6461-1
Education Holdings (2008)
Limited (In Receivership) peter.hall@boffamiskell.co.nz Zoning Central
Rezone 223 Kohimarama Road, Kohimarama, from the Special Purpose- School Zone to the
6461-2
Limited (In Receivership) peter.hall@boffamiskell.co.nz Zoning Central
Rezone 7 John Rhymer Place, Kohimarama, from the Special Purpose- School Zone to the
6461-3
Limited (In Receivership) peter.hall@boffamiskell.co.nz Residential zones Residential Land use controls
Retain rule 3.1 'Maximum Density' to ensure that there is no maximum density limit for the
6461-4
Limited (In Receivership) peter.hall@boffamiskell.co.nz Residential zones Retirement Village zone I21 Rules
Amend the Plan to incorporate the provisions of 'C14-05-Concept Plan-Kohimarama
Retirement Village' from the Operative District Plan (Isthmus Section) to enable the option of
developing 223 Kohimarama Road and 7 John Rhymer Place, Kohimarama for the purposes
of a retirement village.
6462-1 Tania Searle (Phillips) tania.rico@xtra.co.nz
control
Delete registration of 4 View Road, Warkworth as a historic place. [Pre 1944 Building
Demolition Control overlay]
6463-1 Yael Lord
yael.lord@thestonetreecorporation.c
om Subdivision Auckland-wide - Rural zones
area
Allow more than 1 dwelling per property over 10ha in the Rural Production zone but with no
subdivision of title allowed, to a maximum of 2 dwellings per title for properties under 40ha.
6463-2 Yael Lord
om Rural Zones General I13.2 Land use controls
Allow more than 2 but not more than 10 non-resident persons to work on a property under
'Rural Production' as a 'Home Occupation'.
6463-3 Yael Lord
om RPS Changes to the RUB North and Waiheke Island
Use a population growth rate for Warkworth that is in line with the local GDP rate figures to
ensure that Warkworth can economically support a population increase (estimates predict the
Warkworth area population to be 5,500-7,700 persons in 30 years time).
6464-1 Megan Hall megan@gemwine.co.nz RPS Mana Whenua B5 Strategic
Delete requirement for property and homeowners to get permission from up to 9 different iwi
groups to build a house, do minor additions or/and install pools.
6465-1 Karaka Farms Limited jo.young@boffamiskell.co.nz Zoning South
Rezone the parts of 55 Harkness Road, Karaka, that are zoned Rural Coastal zone to the
Mixed Rural zone.
307/1145
Sub#/
6465-2 Karaka Farms Limited jo.young@boffamiskell.co.nz
(ONF) Rules
Features Overlay Delete this overlay from 55 Harkness Road, Karaka.
6465-3 Karaka Farms Limited jo.young@boffamiskell.co.nz
Amend provisions so that existing farming activities, including the grazing of animals and post
and wire fences are permitted activities within the ONF overlay on 55 Harkness Road,
Karaka.
6465-4 Karaka Farms Limited jo.young@boffamiskell.co.nz Water
streams & wetland
Amend 'the rule relating to the fencing of streams and wetland to ensure that suitable financial
incentives are available to enable compliance with this rule'.
6466-1 Ron Le Sueur rlesueur@vodafone.co.nz Precincts - West
Amend the subdivision rule to enable the subdivision in the Henderson Valley Road, Pine Ave
and Forest Hill Road, Henderson [within the Waitakere Ranges Sub Precinct A].
6466-2 Ron Le Sueur rlesueur@vodafone.co.nz
SEAs
Land Remove the SEA overlay from 168 Candia Road, Henderson Valley.
6467-1 David G Thomas dgthomasnz@gmail.com Residential zones Residential
General Retain maximum 2 storey/8m building height for Dexter Avenue, Balmoral.
6467-2 David G Thomas dgthomasnz@gmail.com Special Character
residential
special character areas Add overlay to Dexter Avenue and surrounding streets in northern end of Balmoral.
6467-3 David G Thomas dgthomasnz@gmail.com Zoning Central
Rezone Dexter Avenue, Balmoral and surrounding streets [from Mixed Housing Suburban]
to Single House.
6467-4 David G Thomas dgthomasnz@gmail.com
control
Add Pre-1944 Demolition Control overlay to Special Character overlay areas as an interim
protection measure until the Unitary Plan is formally operative.
6468-1 David L Jamison jamico@clear.net.nz Rural Zones General I13.3 Development controls Increase building heights to 12m from 7m in the Rural Coastal zone.
6468-2 David L Jamison jamico@clear.net.nz Rural Zones General I13.3 Development controls Increase dwelling heights to 9m from 7m in the Rural Coastal zone.
6469-1 Yudhvir Singh dentalyogi@gmail.com Future Urban
objectives and policies Amend the Future Urban zone by splitting it into two zones to ensure growth is staged.
6469-2 Yudhvir Singh dentalyogi@gmail.com Transport Auckland -wide
requirements Remove all minimum parking requirements especially in the Mixed Housing zones.
6469-3 Yudhvir Singh dentalyogi@gmail.com RPS Urban growth
quality compact urban form Rezone additional land along public transport corridors especially the rail network.
6469-4 Yudhvir Singh dentalyogi@gmail.com Zoning Central
Rezone the Light Industrial land in Morningside, Takapuna, Greenlane to Ellerslie to Mixed
Use.
6469-5 Yudhvir Singh dentalyogi@gmail.com
Centre) Business
Park zones Require a maximum height limit of 8 storeys in the Mixed Used zone.
Centre) Business
Park zones Require a maximum height limit of 4 storeys in the Local Centre zone.
Centre) Business
Park zones Require a maximum height limit of 8 storeys in the Town Centre zone.
6469-8 Yudhvir Singh dentalyogi@gmail.com Sustainable Development C7.7/H6.4 Sustainable design Retain the Greenstar and Homestar provisions.
6469-9 Yudhvir Singh dentalyogi@gmail.com Residential zones Residential
policies 'Loosen' the rules in the Terrace Housing and Apartment Building to allow for intensification.
6469-10 Yudhvir Singh dentalyogi@gmail.com RPS Urban growth
quality compact urban form 'Loosen the rules in the Mixed Housing to allow for more intensification.
6469-11 Yudhvir Singh dentalyogi@gmail.com Built Environment (Overlays)
Height Control
Apply an overlay to the Mixed Use zone to allow the height limit to be raised or lowered where
appropriate.
6470-1 Cure Kids dennis.gottschalk@colliers.com
control
Remove the Pre 1944 Building Demolition Control overlay from 338 Remuera Road,
Remuera.
6471-1 Sam Miles
5/166 St Andrews Road, Epsom,
& C J3.3.1-7 Rules
Amend Activity Table to provide for the external alterations and additions as a permitted
activity for buildings constructed after 1940.
6472-1 Lesley Opie opieclan@ihug.co.nz Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula K5.11 Precinct rules
Amend the maximum height limit from three and four storeys to a maximum of two storeys on
Eversleigh Road and Hillary Crescent, Devonport .
6472-2 Lesley Opie opieclan@ihug.co.nz Zoning North and Islands
Rezone the Mixed Housing Suburban zone to Single House zone in the Devonport Peninsula
Precinct.
6472-3 Lesley Opie opieclan@ihug.co.nz Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula
Amend the objectives and policies to support a height limit of two storeys in the Single House
zone of the precinct.
Require any future framework plan for any development to be subject to full public notification
and consultation.
6472-5 Lesley Opie opieclan@ihug.co.nz Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula K5.11 Precinct rules Require building length rules to be applied.
Require no development to occur until there is infrastructure in place to support the
development.
308/1145
Sub#/
6472-7 Lesley Opie opieclan@ihug.co.nz General Miscellaneous Special housing areas
Remove the special housing areas on the Devonport Peninsula (including Hillary Crescent)
which allows for inappropriate high density housing.
6472-8 Lesley Opie opieclan@ihug.co.nz Mana Whenua General provisions
assessment
Delete the requirement to undertake a cultural impact assessment for sites of significance and
sites of value.
6473-1 Joanne Quigg qaroma@xtra.co.nz Zoning West
Rezone Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings sites in Te Atatu Peninsula if they were not
zoned this in the March Draft of the Unitary Plan to Mixed Housing Urban or Mixed Housing
Suburban, including 70 Yeovil Road, Te Atatu Peninsula.
6474-1 Terry Lord terrylord1911@gmail.com Rural Zones General I13.2 Land use controls
Amend provisions so that there can be more than one residence at 515 Old Woodcocks
Road, Warkworth [which is zoned Rural production].
6475-1 Springs Promotions Limited rose@mhg.co.nz Definitions Existing
Amend the definition of 'Motor sport activities' as follows: 'The racing (e.g. speedway, cars,
trucks, bikes and boats), entertainment (e.g. stunt shows) and exhibitions (e.g. Monster
Trucks shows) and associated ancillary activities (e.g. Food, beverage and mechanise
[merchandise] sales and public announcement systems).'
6475-2 Springs Promotions Limited rose@mhg.co.nz Precincts Ak-Wide and Coastal Stadiums and Showgrounds K1.10 Precinct Rules
Retain the hours and noise limits defined in rule 5.1.1(1) 'Standard Noise Limits' for Western
Springs Stadium.
Amend the proposed noise limits in Rule 5.1.1(2)91), Table 14, for Western Springs
Stadium, so that the level from any motorsport race, entertainment or exhibition shall not
exceed 88dB LAeq at the nearest house boundary.
Amend rule 5.1.1.2(a)(ii) for Western Springs Stadium. so that the Time Interval (T) be
measured for the duration of the event; and retain clauses (i), (iii) and (iv) of the rule.
Retain Western Springs Stadium rule 5.1.1 'Noise' clause (3)(a)(i), (ii), (iii) and (iv) and amend
(3)(a)(v) to allow the public address system to be used during racing and other motorsports
events from 7:00am to 11:00pm.
Amend Western Springs Stadium rule 5.1.1.2(a)(vii) to read: "The maximum duration of any
event including practice and warm-ups on the track shall not exceed five and a half hours in
duration and the average finish time shall be 10.30pm or less, with a curfew of 10.45pm."
Amend Western Springs Stadium rule 5.1.1.(2)(a)(viii) to allow for a maximum of five practice
sessions per season; to allow for a maximum of 25 race meetings per season; to allow for
race meeting to be held during the week and be run back-to-back.; and to allow for media
demonstrations to take place outside Scheduled meeting between 7.00am and 6.00pm. Refer
to submission, Volume 1, page 6/12.
Amend Western Springs Stadium rule 5.1.1.2(a)(ix) to allow speedway to race on Auckland
Anniversary Day and retain the clause 'there must be no race meetings on Christmas Eve,
Christmas Day or Waitangi Day'.
Delete Western Springs Stadium rule 5.1.1.2(a)(x) and state that in the event of
postponement or cancellation of any race event or practice session because of rain or force
majuere, the promoter can allocate a new meeting within 14 days, and; that a date allocated
by a promoter to continue a meeting which has been rained off or otherwise halted during a
meeting can have a rain date attached to it schedule, and; that a notice will be provided to
Council and the rescheduling information should be included in advertising notices, copies of
advertising notices be posted at the entrances to the stadium and sent to council.
Amend Western Springs Stadium Rule 5.1.1.2(a)(xi) to enable car park sweeping to take
place on Sundays and require the activity to comply with the daytime noise standards.
Amend Western Springs Stadium rule 5.1.1.2(a)(xii) to enable grading to be permitted outside
these hours where it complies with the daytime noise standards.
Amend Western Springs Stadium rule 5.1.1.2(a)(xii) [inferred rule 5.1.1.2(a)(xiii)] to recognise
the health and safety reporting and enforcement of rules from international Motorsport
associations as well as local associations.
Retain Western Springs Stadium rule 5.1.1 'Noise' clause (3)(a)(i), (ii), (iii) and (iv) and amend
(3)(a)v to allow the public address system to be used during racing and other motorsports
events from 7:00am to 11:00pm.
Add a new activity table in the Western Springs Stadium sub-precinct providing for the
following as permitted activities: 'Concerts', Major sports events and training', 'Stadium
building catering for up to approximately 60,000 people', 'Earthworks', 'Impervious area', 'Car
parking', 'Ancillary activities (i.e. the sale of food, beverages and mechanise) [merchandise]'.
Include the 'Western Springs Stadium Events Noise Contours' in the PAUP. Refer to map on
page 12/12 Volume 1 of the submission.
6475-16 Springs Promotions Limited rose@mhg.co.nz Mana Whenua General provisions
assessment Delete the requirements for a Cultural impact assessment in rule G2.7.4.
309/1145
Sub#/
6475-17 Springs Promotions Limited rose@mhg.co.nz General Chapter G General provisions
Delete the third paragraph under the heading 'Assessment Criteria' of 1.4 Applying for
Resource Consent and/or clarify that the matters for discretion and assessment criteria listed
in the PAUP for Controlled and Restricted Discretionary Activities are the sole matter for
assessment of these types of consent.
Amend rule 6.1.1 Noise' clause (2)(a), Table 17, regarding the permitted noise level for
motorsport races, entertainment or exhibition, to a maximum of 88dB LAeq(T) at the nearest
house boundary [to apply to the Mount Smart sub-precinct].
Amend rule 6.1.1.1, Table 17 to state that "there must be no race meeting on Christmas Eve
or Christmas Day." [to apply to the Mount Smart sub-precinct].
Amend Rule 6.1.1.1, Table 17 to extend the hours from 8.00am to 10.00pm to 8.00am to
11.00pm. No specific decision stated in relation to opposition to the restriction on the number
of events in any 12 month period [to apply to the Mount Smart sub-precinct].
Add statement to Rule 6.1.1 stating that international associations for Motorsports will be
recognised as well as local associations. [Refer to submission, volume 2, page 5/9 for further
details].
Add a new activity table in the Other Stadiums and Showground Sub-precinct [for Mount
Smart Stadium sub-precinct] providing for the following as permitted activities: 'Concerts',
Major sports events and training', 'Stadium building catering for up to approximately 60,000
people', 'Earthworks', 'Impervious area', 'Car parking', 'Ancillary activities (i.e. the sale of food,
beverages and [merchandise]'. Refer to submission for details, pages 5-6/9.
Include the 'Mount Smart Stadium Events Noise Contours' in the PAUP. Refer map on page
9/9 Volume 2 of the submission.
6476-1 Joe Singh singhj@ihug.co.nz Future Urban
Amend the Future Urban zone by splitting it into two to ensure growth is adequately staged.
The Short Term Future Urban Zone should contain 7 years capacity.
6476-2 Joe Singh singhj@ihug.co.nz Transport Auckland -wide
requirements Remove all minimum parking requirements, especially in the Mixed Housing Zones.
6476-3 Joe Singh singhj@ihug.co.nz RPS Urban growth
quality compact urban form Rezone more land alongside Public Transport corridors, especially the rail network.
6476-4 Joe Singh singhj@ihug.co.nz Zoning Central
Rezone Light Industrial land in Morningside, and Greenlane to Ellerslie as Mixed Use. The
Mixed Use zone should be 8 storeys as a general height with overlays to lower and raise this
where appropriate.
6476-5 Joe Singh singhj@ihug.co.nz
Centre) Business
Park zones Increase Local Centre heights to 4 storeys.
6476-6 Joe Singh singhj@ihug.co.nz
Centre) Business
Park zones Increase heights in most Town Centres to 8 stories.
6476-7 Joe Singh singhj@ihug.co.nz Transport Auckland -wide
requirements Remove all minimum parking requirements in all zones - let the market decide.
6476-8 Joe Singh singhj@ihug.co.nz Sustainable Development C7.7/H6.4 Sustainable design Retain Greenstar and Homestar provisions.
6476-9 Joe Singh singhj@ihug.co.nz Residential zones Residential
Amend rules in Terrace Housing and Apartment Building zone to ensure more land is
intensified.
6476-10 Joe Singh singhj@ihug.co.nz Residential zones Residential
Mixed Housing Urban zone Amend rules in the Mixed Housing zones to ensure more land is intensified.
6476-11 Joe Singh singhj@ihug.co.nz Zoning North and Islands
Rezone Light Industrial land in Takapuna as Mixed Use. The Mixed Use zone should be 8
storeys as a general height with overlays to lower and raise this where appropriate.
6477-1 Sally Wallis
2/37 Tarawera Terrace, Saint
Heliers, Auckland 1071 Precincts - Central Saint Heliers
A 11.2.1 : Appendix- St
Helliers Character Statement
Retain the St Heliers Character Statement and ensure that it protects the established seaside
village character of St Heliers.
6477-2 Sally Wallis
2/37 Tarawera Terrace, Saint
Heliers, Auckland 1071 Special Character
residential
Amend to incorporate the Tamaki Drive Master plan into the PAUP and ensure that the
seaward side of Tamaki Drive is car free i.e. only for pedestrians and cyclists.
6478-1
Unique Developers and
Trading Limited uniquedvpr@gmail.com RPS Urban growth
Rezone so that the 'metropolitan area be classified as Mixed Housing Urban and the outer
area as Mixed Housing Suburban but not the other way around'.
6478-2
Trading Limited uniquedvpr@gmail.com Subdivision Auckland-wide - Urban zones H5.2 3.1 Residential zones
Amend provisions so that 'the [Mixed housing Suburban] zoning should allow to create
independent lots without any restrictions' [refer to submission for details].
6478-3
Trading Limited uniquedvpr@gmail.com Residential zones Residential
General Amend the height in relation to boundary rules by relaxing the requirements.
6479-1
West Auckland Historical
Society vivienb@westaucklandhistory.org.nz Historic Heritage (Overlay)
Heritage
Places
Evaluate and add the Sunrise Vineyards sign in front of 289 Great North Road, Henderson to
the schedule.
310/1145
Sub#/
6480-1
David Bell and Jeneal
Rohrback rohrbelly@xtra.co.nz Trees
Trees
Notable Trees Remove the Spanish Oak tree at 19 Burgess Road Devonport.
6480-2
David Bell and Jeneal
Rohrback rohrbelly@xtra.co.nz Trees
Trees J6.4 Rules
Amend the activity table to allow for a new rule to provide for dead wood removal, pest plant
removal and tree alteration or removal as a restricted discretionary activity.
6481-1 David Oliphant brent@synman.co.nz
Centre) Business
Park zones
Amend rule I4.4 'Building setback at upper floors', Figure 11 notation to read '6m setback from
4 storeys and 16.5m unless a special height limit applies and then use that special height
limit'.
6482-1
Te Matapihi He Tirohanga mo
te Iwi Trust hekeretari@tematapihi.maori.nz RPS Issues
growth Retain 1.1 Enabling quality urban growth.
6482-2
te Iwi Trust hekeretari@tematapihi.maori.nz General Miscellaneous Other
Acknowledge the experience of those involved in Special Housing Areas and in housing
development over the next 3 years as part of the Auckland Housing Accord to inform the
Auckland Design Manual case studies and to promote guidance on best practice.
6482-3
te Iwi Trust hekeretari@tematapihi.maori.nz RPS Urban growth
environment
Amend referencing to Placemaking and community development approaches for future
Auckland residential developments to be explicit rather than implicit.
6482-4
te Iwi Trust hekeretari@tematapihi.maori.nz General Chapter A Introduction
tools Add mandatory structure plans to ensure that affordable housing provisions can be planned.
6482-5
tools Add framework plans for brownfields type developments that do not involve a plan change.
6482-6
tools
Add more detailed criteria and a requirement for mandatory rather than voluntary Framework
Plans.
6482-7
tools Amend criteria for framework plans to provide clear identification of affordable housing.
6482-8
tools
Amend section to clarify whether structure plans are required when land is rezoned from one
urban use to another.
6482-9
te Iwi Trust hekeretari@tematapihi.maori.nz RPS Issues
growth Retain 2.1 Providing for quality growth in a compact form.
6482-10
te Iwi Trust hekeretari@tematapihi.maori.nz Residential zones Housing affordability
and policies
Amend the PAUP that will set out how the provision of affordable housing across Auckland
will be achieved.
6482-11
land for urban development Retain 2.3 Development capacity and supply of land for urban development.
6482-12
land for urban development Retain Policy 5.
6482-13
te Iwi Trust hekeretari@tematapihi.maori.nz Definitions New Add definition of 'A well-planned, quality community' throughout the PAUP.
6482-14
te Iwi Trust hekeretari@tematapihi.maori.nz Definitions New
Add definition of 'Placemaking and other tools for engaging communities' throughout the
PAUP.
6482-15
retain affordable housing Retain 2.4 Neighbourhoods that retain affordable housing.
6482-16
Add provision of well-planned mixed tenure communities that will meet the needs of current
and future low to moderate income households.
6482-17
Retain 2.4 Objectives and Policies that seek to improve the affordability of dwellings for
households on low to moderate incomes.
6482-18
Retain 2.4 Objectives and Policies that focus on the intermediate housing market to
complement the gvernment provisions of social housing.
6482-19
Retain 2.4 Retain the establishment of a high level approach that supports inclusionary zoning
requirements.
6482-20
and policies Retain 7. General.
6482-21
and policies Retain 7. General, Objectives and Policies.
6482-22
and policies Retain 7. General, background.
6482-23
and policies
Amend 'similar' and recommend specific, strict criteria within the resource consent process to
ensure that affordable housing has consistent minimum space standards and finishes.
6482-24
te Iwi Trust hekeretari@tematapihi.maori.nz General Chapter G General provisions
Retain 2.6 and ensure that they are not used as a way of circumventing the need for Retained
Affordable Housing.
6482-25
te Iwi Trust hekeretari@tematapihi.maori.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - general
controls Retain 5.2 Development controls.
6482-26
controls
Amend to include location, size, and the number of Retained Affordable Housing units in each
development within Framework, Structure, Precinct and Concept Plans.
6482-27
te Iwi Trust hekeretari@tematapihi.maori.nz Definitions New Add definition of affordable housing and criteria across the plan.
311/1145
Sub#/
6482-28
te Iwi Trust hekeretari@tematapihi.maori.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - general H5.3 - 4 Assessment Clarification of the specific provision of 5.4.1, Table 13.
6482-29
te Iwi Trust hekeretari@tematapihi.maori.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - general H5.3 - 4 Assessment Clarification of the specific provision of 5.4.1, Table 14.
6482-30
te Iwi Trust hekeretari@tematapihi.maori.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - general H5.3 - 4 Assessment Clarification of the specific provision of 5.4.1, Subdivision for up to 4 proposed sites.
6482-31
te Iwi Trust hekeretari@tematapihi.maori.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - general H5.3 - 4 Assessment Clarification of the specific provision of 5.4.1, Subdivision for between 5 and 15 sites.
6482-32
te Iwi Trust hekeretari@tematapihi.maori.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - general H5.3 - 4 Assessment Clarification of the specific provision of 5.4.1, Subdivision for over 15 sites.
6482-33
te Iwi Trust hekeretari@tematapihi.maori.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - general H5.3 - 4 Assessment Add Retained Affordable Housing within tables 13 and 14.
6482-34
te Iwi Trust hekeretari@tematapihi.maori.nz Residential zones Housing affordability H6.6 Rules Add Retained Affordable Housing to 6.6. Affordable Housing.
6482-35
Spec. info. req. Clarify 5.5 Special information requirements.
6482-36
Spec. info. req. Add Retained Affordable Housing references to 5.5.
6482-37
te Iwi Trust hekeretari@tematapihi.maori.nz Sustainable Development C7.7/H6.4 Sustainable design Retain 6.4 Sustainable development.
6482-38
te Iwi Trust hekeretari@tematapihi.maori.nz Sustainable Development C7.7/H6.4 Sustainable design
Retain 6 star rating on all affordable housing, consistent with 1.1.1 Enabling urban growth
'Access to warm, dry and affordable housing'.
6482-39
te Iwi Trust hekeretari@tematapihi.maori.nz Residential zones Housing affordability H6.6 Rules Retain 6(6). Affordable Housing.
6482-40
te Iwi Trust hekeretari@tematapihi.maori.nz Residential zones Housing affordability H6.6 Rules Retain 6(6)(1)(1). Number of retained affordable housing dwellings.
6482-41
te Iwi Trust hekeretari@tematapihi.maori.nz Residential zones Housing affordability H6.6 Rules
Clarify 6(6)(1)(1). Number of retained affordable housing dwellings, as to how developments
that are part social housing and part market rate housing will be treated.
6482-42
Retain 6(6)(1)(1). Number of retained affordable housing dwellings, whether the social
housing component is deemed to satisfy the Retained Affordable Housing requirement or if
this applies only to the market rate.
6482-43
Retain provision of Retained Affordable Housing that protects the philosophy of providing
mixed tenure communities.
6482-44
Clarify proximity of 'cluster' of housing and recommend that provision gives due regard to a
percentage within a development.
6482-45
Add market value properties, retained affordable housing and social housing to be identified
within a structure, framework plan.
6482-46
te Iwi Trust hekeretari@tematapihi.maori.nz Residential zones Housing affordability H6.6 Rules Amend provision to specify a range of dwelling sizes to those elsewhere in the development.
6482-47
te Iwi Trust hekeretari@tematapihi.maori.nz Residential zones Housing affordability H6.6 Rules Add reference within the provision to clarify the design of Retained Affordable Housing.
6482-48
te Iwi Trust hekeretari@tematapihi.maori.nz Residential zones Housing affordability H6.6 Rules Clarify retention mechanisms in 6.6.1.3 Securing retained affordable housing.
6482-49
te Iwi Trust hekeretari@tematapihi.maori.nz Residential zones Housing affordability H6.6 Rules Retain 6.6.1.4 Eligibility for retained affordable housing.
6482-50
te Iwi Trust hekeretari@tematapihi.maori.nz Residential zones Housing affordability H6.6 Rules Retain 6.6.2.1 Matters of Discretion.
6482-51
te Iwi Trust hekeretari@tematapihi.maori.nz Residential zones Housing affordability H6.6 Rules Retain 6.6.2.2 Assessment Criteria.
6482-52
Add retention and eligibility to 2.1 Matters of discretion, if they are to be Restricted
6482-53
Add 6.6.3.1 Special Information Requirements - 'all development and subdivisions of 15 or
more dwellings/vacant sites.
6482-54
te Iwi Trust hekeretari@tematapihi.maori.nz Residential zones Residential
and Coastal Settlement zone Retain 1.6.12 Universal access.
6482-55
Mixed Housing Urban zone Retain 1.7.22 Universal access.
6482-56
Mixed Housing Urban zone Retain 1.8.24 Universal access.
312/1145
Sub#/
6482-57
Terrace Housing and
Apartment Buildings zone Retain 1.9.23 Universal access.
6482-58
te Iwi Trust hekeretari@tematapihi.maori.nz Definitions Existing Retain the definitions of 'Retained affordable housing'.
6482-59
te Iwi Trust hekeretari@tematapihi.maori.nz Definitions Existing
Amend the definition of 'Retained affordable housing' to provide an interpretation of the 80-
120% band, and criteria for encouraging housing.
6482-60
Amend Retained affordable housing to lower banding to 60-80% or 40-60%, where land can
be provided through inclusionary zone provisions.
6482-61
Amend 'Retained affordable housing' to reflect the PAUP definition of 'rapid and frequent
service network' to frequent minimum frequency every 15 minutes and all day, operating
between 7am and 7pm weekdays as a minimum.
6482-62
2010
Retain Structured Plan requirements for future urban zoned greenfield land and brownfield
land.
6482-63
2010
Retain retained affordable housing to the planning process for greenfield land through the
Future Urban Areas.
6482-64
and policies
Amend to emphasize where intensification is to occur rather than specifically dealing with
housing affordability.
6482-65
and villages
Amend to address concerns about section 2.1 emphasis on the location of affordable housing
in areas close to the edge of the RUB, satellite towns such as Warkworth and Pukekohe and
in the rural and coastal towns as potentially contradicting the PAUP strategic objective for
'social wellbeing'
6482-66
te Iwi Trust hekeretari@tematapihi.maori.nz Infrastructure
C1.1 Infrastructure
policies
Acknowledge how infrastructure will be adequately provided, for new developments. No relief
sought.
6482-67
and policies
Recognise the implementation of universal design standard as a benchmark for all new
housing including affordable housing.
6483-1 Ruatotora Limited
PO Box 460, Pukekohe, Auckland
2340 Precincts - South Runciman
Amend subdivision provisions to be a controlled activity in the Runciman Countryside Living
zone - Bush Park area (241 Runciman Road).
Amend Precinct Plan to be consistent with the Bush Park Concept Plan in part consented to
in ENV 2008-304-000182.
Amend or remove development controls for the Bush Park area to: remove the need to
cluster; remove separation distances between building platforms; substitute maximum density
to 1 lot per 1.5ha; delete reference to significant environmental benefits; remove set backs
from Runciman Road; remove or amend that part of Rule 22 C 5 to provide for a riparian
corridor as per Map 110; ensure precinct plan 4 aligns with the Bush Park consent orders;
allow additional development areas on MAP 110E on Precinct Plan 5 map; amend maps to be
topographically accurate.
2340 Precincts - South Runciman Provide another road connection between Pukekohe, State Highway 1 and Runciman Road.
6484-1 Paul McFarland paul.peter@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central
Rezone Herdman Street, Daventry Street and Waterbank Street, Waterview to a suburban
zoning with a 2 storey maximum height.
6485-1 Brent Murdoch brent@cmca.co.nz RPS Mana Whenua B5 Strategic
6485-2 Brent Murdoch brent@cmca.co.nz RPS Urban growth
quality compact urban form Reject further intensity in the housing in Auckland, and further greenfield development
6485-3 Brent Murdoch brent@cmca.co.nz General Miscellaneous Rates
End any extensions to council borrowing to fund capital works that are not capable of creating
enough financial return to meet their costs
6486-1 Michael Reed deanne@mhg.co.nz Definitions Existing
Delete the definition of 'Net site area' and replace it with the following definition for 'Gross site
area' (taken from the Rodney District Plan): 'Gross site area means the total area of a site
including any entrance strip'. Also include an accompanying diagram for this definition as
shown on page 4/8 of the submission.
6486-2 Michael Reed deanne@mhg.co.nz Residential zones Residential Land use controls Amend rule [3.1 Maximum density] to refer to 'Gross site area' rather than per 'site'.
6486-3 Michael Reed deanne@mhg.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - Urban zones H5.2 3.1 Residential zones Amend rule 1 Site sizes, to replace the references to 'net site area' with 'gross site area'.
6486-4 Michael Reed deanne@mhg.co.nz Definitions Existing
Amend the definition of 'height' to 'include the vertical distance between the highest part of the
building and the average level of the ground at the external foundations of the buildings'
(taken from the Auckland Isthmus District Plan).
6486-5 Michael Reed deanne@mhg.co.nz General Cross plan matters
Delete the maximum number of storeys control and use height [in metres] as the sole
development control for determining 'height'.
6486-6 Michael Reed deanne@mhg.co.nz Zoning Central Rezone 77 Parnell Road, Parnell from Single House to Town Centre - Parnell.
313/1145
Sub#/
6486-7 Michael Reed deanne@mhg.co.nz Zoning Central
Rezone the block defined by Heather Street, Cracroft Street and Parnell Road, Parnell [from
Single House] to Mixed Use.
6486-8 Michael Reed deanne@mhg.co.nz Designations Auckland Transport
Street
Remove the road widening designations along York Street, Parnell Road, Garfield Street,
Farnham Street and Cheshire Street, Parnell.
6486-9 Michael Reed deanne@mhg.co.nz
Centre) Business
Special information
requirements
Amend rule 10 'Special information requirements' to delete the requirement for a wind report
for buildings higher than 20m where a canopy is provided over public spaces or the site is a
rear site.
6486-10 Michael Reed deanne@mhg.co.nz General Chapter G General provisions
statements
Amend rule 2.7 'Information requirements for resource consent applications' to delete the
requirement for a design statement to be provided with resource consent applications for
specified activities.
6486-11 Michael Reed deanne@mhg.co.nz Mana Whenua General provisions
assessment
Amend rule 2.7.4 'Cultural impact assessments' to refine the circumstances under which a
Cultural impact assessment and engagement with iwi may be required.
6486-12 Michael Reed deanne@mhg.co.nz General Chapter G General provisions
Amend PAUP to remove the statement that the Council may consider provisions beyond
those specifically listed as assessment criteria [1.4 Applying for a resource consent].
6486-13 Michael Reed deanne@mhg.co.nz Sustainable Development C7.7/H6.4 Sustainable design
Building Challenge.
6486-14 Michael Reed deanne@mhg.co.nz Residential zones Housing affordability H6.6 Rules
Delete the requirement to provide at least 10 percent affordable housing where more than 15
dwellings or 15 vacant sites are developed within the RUB.
6487-1 Wayne Donnelly wayne.donnelly@macdow.co.nz Zoning North and Islands
Retain Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings for 6B and 8 Browns Bay Road and 30B
Beechwood Road, Rothesay Bay.
6487-2 Wayne Donnelly wayne.donnelly@macdow.co.nz Residential zones Residential Activity Table
Retain restricted discretionary activity status for 5 or more dwellings within the Terrace
Housing and Apartment Buildings zone.
6487-3 Wayne Donnelly wayne.donnelly@macdow.co.nz General Chapter G General provisions G2.4 Notification Retain the rule [2.4(1)] that provides for non-notification of restricted discretionary activities.
6487-4 Wayne Donnelly wayne.donnelly@macdow.co.nz Residential zones Residential
Retain rules applying to the Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings zone, subject to
amendment of rule [9.6(1)] for minimum frontage and site width control from 25m to 20m.
6488-1
Nga Mana Whenua o Tmaki
Makaurau paul.majurey@ahjmlaw.com General Miscellaneous Consultation and engagement Support the use of pre-hearing mediation.
6488-2
Makaurau paul.majurey@ahjmlaw.com RPS General
review procedures
6488-3
Makaurau paul.majurey@ahjmlaw.com General Cross plan matters
6488-4
values.
6488-5
Makaurau paul.majurey@ahjmlaw.com RPS Urban growth
6488-6
Makaurau paul.majurey@ahjmlaw.com General
GIS viewer
Amend the PAUP to include 'ancestral rohe' maps as non-statutory layer. Develop these
maps in conjunction with Mana Whenua.
6488-7
Makaurau paul.majurey@ahjmlaw.com RPS Mana Whenua
Mtauranga & tikanga
Include a new method identifying that ancestral rohe maps will be developed (in conjunction
with Mana Whenua) as a non-statutory map layer.
6488-8
Makaurau paul.majurey@ahjmlaw.com General Editorial and Part 6 Review the numbering system and amend to improve its usability.
6488-9
Mtauranga & tikanga Ensure that Iwi management plans are taken into account when developing the PAUP.
6488-10
Makaurau paul.majurey@ahjmlaw.com General Cross plan matters Add 'customary use' as a permitted activity in all zones.
6488-11
Makaurau paul.majurey@ahjmlaw.com General
GIS viewer
Amend the PAUP to include an alert layer to identify for example, sites identified in iwi
management plans, and associated objectives, policies and rules, for sites not currently
included in the overlays (refer to submission page 7/31 for possible sources of sites).
6488-12
Makaurau paul.majurey@ahjmlaw.com General Chapter A Introduction A1 Background Retain section 1.2 'Mana Whenua'.
6488-13
Makaurau paul.majurey@ahjmlaw.com General Chapter A Introduction A2 Statutory Framework
Amend section 2.2 'Treaty of Waitangi/Te Tiriti o Waitangi' to outline the need to consider
6488-14
Makaurau paul.majurey@ahjmlaw.com RPS Issues
Regional significance Amend the RPS issues to clearly identify the resource management issue.
6488-15
growth
6488-16
wellbeing
Amend issue statement to recognise the positive value Mana Whenua economic development
314/1145
Sub#/
6488-17
heritage
6488-18
section as well.
6488-19
6488-20
Whenua.
6488-21
6488-22
6488-23
6488-24
participation
6488-25
review procedures
indicators.
6488-26
6488-27
6488-28
6488-29
6488-30
6488-31
Makaurau paul.majurey@ahjmlaw.com RPS Natural resources
B6.3 Freshwater and
6488-32
Makaurau paul.majurey@ahjmlaw.com RPS Natural resources
B6.3 Freshwater and
6488-33
Makaurau paul.majurey@ahjmlaw.com RPS Coastal
environment
6488-34
environment
Policy 1 and 4.
6488-35
6488-36
quality
6488-37
6488-38
to cover the range of matters addressed in the plan that impact on Mori.
6488-39
review procedures
Mana Whenua provisions and these to be developed with the input of Mana Whenua.
6488-40
Makaurau paul.majurey@ahjmlaw.com Mana Whenua Auckland wide - Mori Land
and policies
6488-41
and policies
315/1145
Sub#/
6488-42
and policies
6488-43
and policies
6488-44
and policies
6488-45
Makaurau paul.majurey@ahjmlaw.com Mana Whenua
settlement land
and policies
6488-46
settlement land
and policies
Amend Policies 4 and 7 to: require an integrated Mori Development Plan for discretionary
6488-47
Makaurau paul.majurey@ahjmlaw.com General Cross plan matters Retain provisions in Sections 3-7 in Chapter C where they are specifically related to Mori.
6488-48
Makaurau paul.majurey@ahjmlaw.com Public Open Space Zones Public Open Space D2 Introduction
6488-49
Makaurau paul.majurey@ahjmlaw.com Mana Whenua Mori purpose zone
controls Retain provisions.
6488-50
Makaurau paul.majurey@ahjmlaw.com Historic Heritage (Overlay)
Heritage
6488-51
Makaurau paul.majurey@ahjmlaw.com
control
6488-52
Whenua
6488-53
Whenua
6488-54
Makaurau paul.majurey@ahjmlaw.com Precincts - Central New Precincts Other New Precincts
6488-55
Makaurau paul.majurey@ahjmlaw.com Precincts Ak-Wide and Coastal Regional Parks
6488-56
Makaurau paul.majurey@ahjmlaw.com Precincts Ak-Wide and Coastal New Precincts All other New Precincts
6488-57
Makaurau paul.majurey@ahjmlaw.com Mana Whenua General provisions
discovery protocol
submission (page 20/31).
6488-58
discovery protocol
6488-59
discovery protocol
activity.
6488-60
Makaurau paul.majurey@ahjmlaw.com General Chapter G General provisions
statements
6488-61
assessment
6488-62
assessment
Whenua, council and key stakeholders to refine the process. Clarify that the discretion to
determine if a CIA is required is to be made with direct Mana Whenua input.
6488-63
controls Amend the preamble for section 2.1 to refer to the definition of Mori land.
316/1145
Sub#/
6488-64
6488-65
controls
discretionary.
6488-66
Spec. info. req.
6488-67
settlement land
Settlement Land, including Rule 2.2.5 'Rural industries on Treaty Settlement Mori Land ...'
6488-68
Spec. info. req.
6488-69
settlement land
rules/App. 4.3 legislation Add a range of permitted and controlled commercial activities.
6488-70
settlement land
6488-71
settlement land
discretionary.
6488-72
settlement land
6488-73
SEAs
submission.
6488-74
SEAs
Assessment
this effect.
6488-75
Makaurau paul.majurey@ahjmlaw.com Water Wastewater H4.15 Onsite wastewater rules Retain Control 2.1.1(2) but clarify what is meant by "must not be disturbed".
6488-76
Makaurau paul.majurey@ahjmlaw.com Sustainable Development C7.7/H6.4 Sustainable design
6488-77
Makaurau paul.majurey@ahjmlaw.com Rural Zones General I13.2 Land use controls
coastal areas.
6488-78
6488-79
6488-80
6488-81
Outstanding Natural
Rules
Notification
6488-82
6488-83
Makaurau paul.majurey@ahjmlaw.com Trees
Trees J6.4 Rules
6488-84
Makaurau paul.majurey@ahjmlaw.com Precincts General Content Precincts General Content
not provided]..
6488-85
Makaurau paul.majurey@ahjmlaw.com Precincts General Content Precincts General Content
6488-86
Makaurau paul.majurey@ahjmlaw.com General Chapter G General provisions
status
6488-87
Makaurau paul.majurey@ahjmlaw.com Definitions New Expand the Mori terms to include definitions for all Mori terms used in the PAUP.
317/1145
Sub#/
6488-88
Makaurau paul.majurey@ahjmlaw.com Definitions Existing
29/31.
6488-89
Makaurau paul.majurey@ahjmlaw.com Definitions Existing
both.
6488-90
Fig. 1
Add objectives, policies and rules for areas of particular customary value that iwi seek
repatriation for, including specific provision for iwi to carry out customary and cultural
activities.
6488-91
Makaurau paul.majurey@ahjmlaw.com General Miscellaneous Other
Include any new sites/places of significance and value to Mana Whenua, as supported by
Mana Whenua.
6488-92
controls
Remove the limitation on Papakinga development by removing the restriction of up to 10
dwellings.
6488-93
settlement land
rules/App. 4.3 legislation Delete the restriction of up to 10 dwellings for Papakinga development.
6488-94
Makaurau paul.majurey@ahjmlaw.com Zoning South
Rezone Matukutururu (Wiri Mountain) to Mori Purpose zone (See Appendix A, page
31/31 and page 18/31 of the submission).
6488-95
Makaurau paul.majurey@ahjmlaw.com Precincts - South New Precincts All other New Precincts
Include into a new Mori Purpose precinct (See Appendix A, page 31/31 and page 18/31 of
the submission) Matukutururu (Wiri Mountain).
6488-96
Makaurau paul.majurey@ahjmlaw.com Zoning Central
Rezone Mangakiekie (One Tree Hill) to Mori Purpose zone (See Appendix A, page
6488-97
Add Mount Albert to a new Mori Purpose precinct. (See Appendix A, page 31/31 and page
18/31 of the submission).
6488-98
Rezone Maungarei (Mount Wellington) to Mori Purpose zone (See Appendix A, page
6488-99
the submission) Maungarei (Mount Wellington).
6488-
100
Makaurau paul.majurey@ahjmlaw.com Zoning North and Islands
Rezone Maungauika (North Head) to Mori Purpose zone (See Appendix A, page 31/31 and
page 18/31 of the submission).
6488-
101
Makaurau paul.majurey@ahjmlaw.com Precincts - North New Precincts All other New Precincts
Include in the Mori Purpose precinct (See Appendix A, page 31/31 and page 18/31 of the
submission) Maungauika (North Head).
6488-
102
Rezone Mount Albert to Mori Purpose zone (See Appendix A, page 31/31 and page 18/31 of
the submission).
6488-
103
Add Mount Albert to a new Mori Purpose precinct (See Appendix A, page 31/31 and page
6488-
104
Rezone Mount Roskill to Mori Purpose zone (See Appendix A, page 31/31 and page 18/31
of the submission).
6488-
105
Add Mount Roskill to a new Mori Purpose precinct (See Appendix A, page 31/31 and page
6488-
106
Rezone Mount St John to Mori Purpose zone (See Appendix A, page 31/31 and page 18/31
of the submission).
6488-
107
Add Mount St John to a new Mori Purpose precinct (See Appendix A, page 31/31 and page
18/31 of the submission) .
6488-
108
Rezone Ohinerau (Mount Hobson) to Mori Purpose zone (See Appendix A, page 31/31 and
6488-
109
Add Ohinerau (Mount Hobson) to a new Mori Purpose precinct (See Appendix A, page
6488-
110
Rezone Ohuiarangi (Pigeon Mountain) to Mori Purpose zone (See Appendix A, page
6488-
111
the submission) Ohuiarangi (Pigeon Mountain).
6488-
112
Rezone Otahuhu (Mount Richmond) to Mori Purpose zone (See Appendix A, page
6488-
113
the submission) Otahuhu (Mount Richmond).
6488-
114
Rezone Rarotonga (Mount Smart) to Mori Purpose zone (See Appendix A, page 31/31 and
6488-
115
the submission) Rarotonga (Mount Smart).
6488-
116
Makaurau paul.majurey@ahjmlaw.com Zoning North and Islands
Rezone Takarunga (Mount Victoria) to Mori Purpose zone (See Appendix A, page 31/31 and
6488-
117
Makaurau paul.majurey@ahjmlaw.com Precincts - North New Precincts All other New Precincts
submission) Takarunga (Mount Victoria).
6488-
118
Rezone Te Tatua a Riukiuta (Three Kings) to Mori Purpose zone (See Appendix A, page
318/1145
Sub#/
6488-
119
Add Te Tatua a Riukiuta (Three Kings) to a new Mori Purpose precinct (See Appendix A,
page 31/31 and page 18/31 of the submission)
6488-
120
Rezone Mangere Mountain to Mori Purpose zone (See Appendix A, page 31/31 and page
6488-
121
the submission) Mangere Mountain.
6488-
122
Makaurau paul.majurey@ahjmlaw.com General Miscellaneous Southern Hauraki Gulf Islands
Rezone Rangitoto (Including tihi and Islington Bay properties) to the Mori Purpose zone (See
Appendix A, page 31/31 and page 18/31 of the submission).
6488-
123
Makaurau paul.majurey@ahjmlaw.com General Miscellaneous Southern Hauraki Gulf Islands
Include Rangitoto (Including tihi and Islington Bay properties) in the new Mori Purpose
precincts. (See Appendix A, page 31/31 and page 18/31 of the submission).
6488-
124
Rezone Maungawhau (Mount Eden) to Mori Purpose zone (See Appendix A, page 31/31 and
6488-
125
Add Maungawhau (Mount Eden) to a new Mori Purpose precinct (See Appendix A, page
31/31 and page 18/31 of the submission)
6489-1 Margaret van der Coer margaret.coer@slingshot.co.nz Residential zones Residential
General Amend the height controls to prevent multi storey buildings in residential zones.
6490-1 Dean Evitt dean.evitt@fronde.com Trees
Trees
Notable Trees
Delete the notable tree overlay (1122) in its entirety from the property at 18 Seaview Avenue,
Northcote.
6490-2 Dean Evitt dean.evitt@fronde.com Trees
Trees
Notable Trees
Amend the notable tree overlay to align with the same spatial extent as the SEA overlay at the
rear of the property at 18 Seaview Avenue, Northcote adjacent to the Council reserve, and list
and describe all trees. (This is an alternative relief).
6491-1 Conrad Properties Limited deanne@mhg.co.nz City Centre Zone I4 Rules/Appendix 7.1- 7.3
Amend activity status for demolition in the City Centre zone to either a permitted or controlled
activity [refer to page 4/10].
6491-2 Conrad Properties Limited deanne@mhg.co.nz Precincts - City Centre Queen Street Valley
Amend provisions so that demolition in the Queen Street Valley Precinct is a permitted or
controlled activity, except where buildings have been specifically identified for protection
under the Plan [refer to page 5/10].
6491-3 Conrad Properties Limited deanne@mhg.co.nz General Chapter G General provisions
refer to Designations theme) Delete 1.4 'Applying for a resource consent', 'Assessment criteria, third paragraph.
Amend 1.4 'Applying for a resource consent', 'Assessment criteria' to clarify that the matters
for discretion and assessment criteria listed in the Plan for controlled and restricted
discretionary activities are the sole matter for assessment of these types of consent.
6491-5 Conrad Properties Limited deanne@mhg.co.nz Definitions Existing
Amend the definition of 'height' to include the use of average ground level as a means to
calculate height [refer to page 5/10 of the submission for suggested wording].
6491-6 Conrad Properties Limited deanne@mhg.co.nz General Cross plan matters Delete maximum storey controls in all zones.
6491-7 Conrad Properties Limited deanne@mhg.co.nz General Cross plan matters Delete floor to floor/ceiling height minimums for all zones.
6491-8 Conrad Properties Limited deanne@mhg.co.nz Definitions New Add a definition for 'gross site area' [refer to page 6/10 of the submission for details].
6491-9 Conrad Properties Limited deanne@mhg.co.nz RPS Urban growth
Rezone to 'provide for greater density of development across the Auckland Region as
envisaged under the Draft version of the Unitary Plan'.
6491-10 Conrad Properties Limited deanne@mhg.co.nz Residential zones Residential Land use controls
Amend controls, including the density provisions for the Mixed Housing Urban zone [refer to
page 7/10 of the submission] 'to provide for greater density of development across the
Auckland Region as envisaged under the Draft version of the Unitary Plan'.
6491-11 Conrad Properties Limited deanne@mhg.co.nz Mana Whenua General provisions
assessment Delete the requirements for Cultural Impact Assessments.
statements Delete the requirements for Design Statements.
environment Amend wording to confirm that the Auckland Design Manual is a non-statutory guideline.
6491-14 Conrad Properties Limited deanne@mhg.co.nz Sustainable Development C7.7/H6.4 Sustainable design Delete the sustainable development provisions.
retain affordable housing Delete the affordable housing provisions.
Add standards/matters of control for demolition in the City Centre zone as a permitted or
controlled activity [refer to page 5/10 for details].
Add standards/matters of control for demolition in the Queen Street Valley Precinct as a
permitted or controlled activity [refer to page 5/10 for details].
Amend the demolition provisions by undertaking an assessment to identify the buildings within
this precinct that qualify for scheduling, and for which council may exercise its discretion over
[refer to page 5/10].
6491-19 Conrad Properties Limited deanne@mhg.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - general
controls
Amend the residential subdivision provisions by replacing 'net site area' with 'gross site area'
6492-1 Suzanne G Collis sue.collis@xtra.co.nz General Chapter A Introduction A1 Background
Amend clause 1.2 'Mana whenua' by deleting the last two paragraphs and replacing them with
the following text: 'Unitary Plan is to be limited to fulfilling its requirements only as required
under the Treaty of Waitangi settlements and the Resource Management Act'.
319/1145
Sub#/
6492-2 Suzanne G Collis sue.collis@xtra.co.nz General Chapter A Introduction A2 Statutory Framework
Amend clause 2.2 'Treaty of Waitangi / Te Tiriti O Waitangi' by deleting the last paragraph
and replacing it with the following text: 'Auckland Council are required to notify Mana Whenua
of any application for Resource Consent on any Scheduled Site of Significance or value (as
determined by NZ Historic Places trust), as an affected party'.
6492-3 Suzanne G Collis sue.collis@xtra.co.nz RPS
Amend clause 4.1.2(c) 'Historic heritage - Mana Whenua by adding the following text: 'as
approved by application to the NZHPT and as fully publically notified as part of a private plan
change for inclusion of any site as Specified Site Schedule in accordance with the Historic
Places Act 1993'.
6492-4 Suzanne G Collis sue.collis@xtra.co.nz RPS Mana Whenua
Fig. 1
Delete clause 5 'Addressing issues of significance to Mana Whenua' in its entirety and
replace it with the following text: 'Any site which Mana Whenua consider a site of Significance
or Value shall be subject to an application to the NZHPT and as fully publicly notified as part
of a private plan change for inclusion for any site as Specified Site on the council register by
be included within the Unitary plan Schedule and Overlays'.
6492-5 Suzanne G Collis sue.collis@xtra.co.nz RPS Urban growth
environment Delete section in its entirety.
6492-6 Suzanne G Collis sue.collis@xtra.co.nz General Chapter G General provisions
statements
Amend clause 2.7.1(4)(k) 'General information requirements - existing site plan' by deleting
the following text: 'or that are made known to the applicant during any consultation process
which may have been undertaken '.
6492-7 Suzanne G Collis sue.collis@xtra.co.nz Mana Whenua
Whenua J5.1 Rules
Delete clauses G3.2.5.2, 5.3 and 5.4 in their entirety [these clauses do not exist] and rely
upon clause 5.1 for all historical, heritage or cultural sites of significance or value and subject
to the proposed change to clause B.5. Refer to page 5/6 of the submission.
Whenua J5.1 Rules
Delete clauses 5.1 'Sites and places of significance to Mana Whenua' and 5.2 'Sites and
Places of value to Mana Whenua' in their entirety.
6492-9 Suzanne G Collis sue.collis@xtra.co.nz Mana Whenua Auckland wide - Mori Land
controls
Delete clauses 2.1.2(1) 'Mori Land - Notification' and 2.2.2(1) 'Treaty settlement land -
Activity table' in their entirety.
Whenua
whenua
Delete appendices 4.1 'Schedule of sites and places of significance to Mana Whenua' and 4.2
'Schedule of sites and places of value to Mana Whenua' and replace them with the following
text: 'Any site which Mana Whenua consider a site of Significance or Value shall be subject to
an application to the NZHPT and as fully publicly notified as part of a private plan change for
inclusion for any site as Specified Site on the the Council register by that Iwi. Any site which
is currently contained within an Operative District Plan Schedule shall be included within the
Unitary Plan Schedule and Overlays'.
6492-11 Suzanne G Collis sue.collis@xtra.co.nz Definitions Existing
Amend the definition of 'Mana Whenua cultural heritage' by deleting the second and third
paragraphs and replacing them with the following text: 'Any site which Mana Whenua
consider a site of Significance or Value shall be subject to an application to the NZHPT and
as fully publicly notified as part of a private plan change for inclusion for any site as Specified
Site on the the Council register by that Iwi. Any site which is currently contained within an
Operative District Plan Schedule shall be included within the Unitary Plan Schedule and
Overlays'.
6492-12 Suzanne G Collis sue.collis@xtra.co.nz Definitions Existing
Delete the definition of 'Mori cultural landscapes' and replace it with the following text: 'Any
site or landscape which Mana Whenua consider a site of Significance or Value shall be
subject to an application to the NZHPT and as fully publicly notified as part of a private plan
change for inclusion for any site as Specified Site on the the Council register by that Iwi. Any
site which is currently contained within an Operative District Plan Schedule shall be included
within the Unitary Plan Schedule and Overlays'.
6493-1 Marutuahu Iwi paul.majurey@ahjmlaw.com General Miscellaneous Consultation and engagement Retain the use of pre-hearing mediation.
6493-2 Marutuahu Iwi paul.majurey@ahjmlaw.com RPS General
review procedures
6493-3 Marutuahu Iwi paul.majurey@ahjmlaw.com General Cross plan matters
values.
6493-5 Marutuahu Iwi paul.majurey@ahjmlaw.com RPS Urban growth
6493-6 Marutuahu Iwi paul.majurey@ahjmlaw.com RPS Coastal
quality
6493-7 Marutuahu Iwi paul.majurey@ahjmlaw.com RPS Mana Whenua
Mtauranga & tikanga
Include a new method identifying that ancestral rohe maps will be developed (in conjunction
with Mana Whenua) as a non-statutory map layer.
6493-8 Marutuahu Iwi paul.majurey@ahjmlaw.com General Editorial and Part 6 Review the numbering system and amend to improve its usability.
320/1145
Sub#/
Mtauranga & tikanga
Seek that iwi management plans be properly taken into account when developing the
PAUP. Add objectives, policies and rules for areas of particular customary value that iwi seek
activities.
6493-10 Marutuahu Iwi paul.majurey@ahjmlaw.com General Cross plan matters Seek customary use as a permitted activity in all zones.
6493-11 Marutuahu Iwi paul.majurey@ahjmlaw.com General Chapter A Introduction A1 Background Retain section 1.2 'Mana Whenua'.
6493-12 Marutuahu Iwi paul.majurey@ahjmlaw.com General Chapter A Introduction A2 Statutory Framework
6493-13 Marutuahu Iwi paul.majurey@ahjmlaw.com RPS Issues
growth
wellbeing
Amend issue statement to recognise the positive value Mana Whenua economic development
heritage
section as well.
Whenua.
participation
redress lands and interests for cultural activities . "
review procedures
indicators.
6493-30 Marutuahu Iwi paul.majurey@ahjmlaw.com RPS Natural resources
B6.3 Freshwater and
6493-31 Marutuahu Iwi paul.majurey@ahjmlaw.com RPS Natural resources
B6.3 Freshwater and
environment
environment
Policy 1 and 4.
321/1145
Sub#/
quality
mataawaka).
review procedures
Mana Whenua provisions and these to be developed with the input of Mana Whenua.
6493-39 Marutuahu Iwi paul.majurey@ahjmlaw.com Mana Whenua Auckland wide - Mori Land
and policies
and policies
and policies
and policies
and policies
6493-44 Marutuahu Iwi paul.majurey@ahjmlaw.com Mana Whenua
settlement land
and policies
settlement land
and policies
6493-46 Marutuahu Iwi paul.majurey@ahjmlaw.com General Cross plan matters Retain provisions in Sections 3-7 in Chapter C where they are specifically related to Mori.
6493-47 Marutuahu Iwi paul.majurey@ahjmlaw.com Public Open Space Zones Public Open Space D2 Introduction
6493-48 Marutuahu Iwi paul.majurey@ahjmlaw.com Mana Whenua Mori purpose zone
6493-49 Marutuahu Iwi paul.majurey@ahjmlaw.com Historic Heritage (Overlay)
Heritage
6493-50 Marutuahu Iwi paul.majurey@ahjmlaw.com
control
Whenua
Whenua
6493-53 Marutuahu Iwi paul.majurey@ahjmlaw.com Precincts - Central New Precincts Other New Precincts
6493-54 Marutuahu Iwi paul.majurey@ahjmlaw.com Precincts Ak-Wide and Coastal Regional Parks
6493-55 Marutuahu Iwi paul.majurey@ahjmlaw.com Precincts Ak-Wide and Coastal New Precincts All other New Precincts
6493-56 Marutuahu Iwi paul.majurey@ahjmlaw.com Mana Whenua General provisions
discovery protocol
submission (page 21/32).
assessment
discovery protocol
activity.
322/1145
Sub#/
6493-59 Marutuahu Iwi paul.majurey@ahjmlaw.com General Chapter G General provisions
statements
Amend Rule 2.7.2.13(e) to: "places of cultural importance, including churches, marae, and
assessment
assessment
determine a CIA is required is to be made with direct Mana Whenua input.
controls Amend the preamble in section 2.1 to refer to the definition of Mori Land.
controls
discretionary.
Spec. info. req.
settlement land
Settlement Land, including Rule 2.2.5 'Rural industries on Treaty Settlement Mori Land ...'
Spec. info. req.
settlement land
settlement land
settlement land
discretionary.
settlement land
SEAs
submission.
SEAs
Assessment
this effect.
6493-74 Marutuahu Iwi paul.majurey@ahjmlaw.com Water Wastewater H4.15 Onsite wastewater rules Retain Control 2.1.1(2) but clarify what is meant by "must not be disturbed".
6493-75 Marutuahu Iwi paul.majurey@ahjmlaw.com Sustainable Development C7.7/H6.4 Sustainable design
6493-76 Marutuahu Iwi paul.majurey@ahjmlaw.com Rural Zones General I13.2 Land use controls
coastal areas.
Outstanding Natural
Rules
Notification
6493-82 Marutuahu Iwi paul.majurey@ahjmlaw.com Trees
Trees J6.4 Rules
323/1145
Sub#/
6493-83 Marutuahu Iwi paul.majurey@ahjmlaw.com Precincts General Content Precincts General Content
not provided].
6493-84 Marutuahu Iwi paul.majurey@ahjmlaw.com Precincts General Content Precincts General Content
6493-85 Marutuahu Iwi paul.majurey@ahjmlaw.com General Chapter G General provisions
status
6493-86 Marutuahu Iwi paul.majurey@ahjmlaw.com Definitions New Expand the Mori terms to include definitions for all Mori terms used in the PAUP.
6493-87 Marutuahu Iwi paul.majurey@ahjmlaw.com Definitions Existing
30/32.
6493-88 Marutuahu Iwi paul.majurey@ahjmlaw.com Definitions Existing
both.
6493-89 Marutuahu Iwi paul.majurey@ahjmlaw.com General Miscellaneous Other
Include any new sites/places of significance and value to Mana Whenua, as supported by
Mana Whenua.
controls
Remove the limitation on Papakinga development by removing the restriction of up to 10
dwellings.
settlement land
rules/App. 4.3 legislation Delete the restriction of up to 10 dwellings for Papakinga development.
6493-92 Marutuahu Iwi paul.majurey@ahjmlaw.com Zoning North and Islands
Rezone Takarunga, Mount Victoria, to Mori Purpose Zone (See Appendix A, page 32/32 and
6493-93 Marutuahu Iwi paul.majurey@ahjmlaw.com Precincts - North New Precincts All other New Precincts
submission) Motuora motu.
Rezone Tiritiri Matanga motu to Mori Purpose zone (See Appendix A, page 32/32 and page
submission) Tiritiri Matanga motu.
6493-96 Marutuahu Iwi paul.majurey@ahjmlaw.com General Miscellaneous Southern Hauraki Gulf Islands
Rezone Motuihe motu to the Mori Purpose zone (See Appendix A, page 32/32 and page
6493-97 Marutuahu Iwi paul.majurey@ahjmlaw.com General Miscellaneous Southern Hauraki Gulf Islands
Include Motuihe motu in the new Mori Purpose precinct (See Appendix A, page 32/32 and
Rezone Schoolhouse Bay properties Kawau motu to Mori Purpose zone (See Appendix A,
page 32/32 and page 18/32 of the submission).
submission) Schoolhouse Bay properties Kawau motu.
6493-
100 Marutuahu Iwi paul.majurey@ahjmlaw.com Zoning North and Islands
Rezone Mahurangi Scenic reserve to Mori Purpose zone (See Appendix A, page 32/32 and
6493-
101 Marutuahu Iwi paul.majurey@ahjmlaw.com Precincts - North New Precincts All other New Precincts
submission) Mahurangi Scenic reserve.
6493-
102 Marutuahu Iwi paul.majurey@ahjmlaw.com Zoning Central
Rezone Blacketts Point Parnell (Gladstone Rd) to Mori Purpose zone (See Appendix A,
6493-
103 Marutuahu Iwi paul.majurey@ahjmlaw.com Precincts - Central New Precincts Other New Precincts
Add Blacketts Point Parnell (Gladstone Rd) to a new Mori Purpose precinct (See Appendix
A, page 32/32 and page 18/32 of the submission)
6493-
Rezone Maungarei maunga (Homestead Drive) to Mori Purpose zone (See Appendix A,
6493-
submission) Maungarei maunga (Homestead Drive).
6493-
Rezone Fort Takapuna to Mori Purpose zone (See Appendix A, page 32/32 and page 18/32
of the submission).
6493-
submission) Fort Takapuna.
6493-
Rezone Mechanics Bay (Stanley St/Beach Rd) to Mori Purpose zone (See Appendix A, page
6493-
Add Mechanics Bay (Stanley St/Beach Rd) to a new Mori Purpose precinct (See Appendix
A, page 32/32 and page 18/32 of the submission)
6493-
110 Marutuahu Iwi paul.majurey@ahjmlaw.com General Miscellaneous Southern Hauraki Gulf Islands
Rezone 21-23 Waikare Rd Waiheke Island to the Mori Purpose zone (See Appendix A, page
6493-
Include 21-23 Waikare Rd Waiheke Island in the new Mori Purpose precinct (See Appendix
A, page 32/32 and page 18/32 of the submission).
6493-
Rezone 18 Jellicoe Parade Waiheke Island to the Mori Purpose zone (See Appendix A,
6493-
Include 18 Jellicoe Parade, Waiheke Island in the new Mori Purpose precinct (See Appendix
324/1145
Sub#/
6493-
Rezone 19-23 Anzac St & 1-3 The Terrace Takapuna to Mori Purpose zone (See Appendix
6493-
submission), 19-23 Anzac St & 1-3 The Terrace Takapuna.
6493-
Rezone 35 Grafton Rd Grafton to Mori Purpose zone (See Appendix A, page 32/32 and
6493-
Add 35 Grafton Rd Grafton to a new Mori Purpose precinct (See Appendix A, page
6493-
Rezone Panmure Probation Centre to Mori Purpose zone (See Appendix A, page 32/32 and
6493-
Add the Panmure Probation Centre to a new Mori Purpose precinct (See Appendix A, page
6493-
Rezone Boston Road Probation Centre to Mori Purpose zone (See Appendix A, page
6493-
Add the Boston Road Probation Centre to a new Mori Purpose precinct (See Appendix A,
6493-
Rezone 45,47 Calliope Rd Devonport to Mori Purpose zone (See Appendix A, page
6493-
submission), 45,47 Calliope Rd Devonport.
6493-
Rezone Tamaki Leadership Centre property Whangaparoa to Mori Purpose zone (See
Appendix A, page 32/32 and page 18/32 of the submission).
6493-
submission), Tamaki Leadership Centre property Whangaparoa.
6493-
Rezone De-gaussing property Shakespear Regional Park Whangaparaoa to Mori Purpose
zone (See Appendix A, page 32/32 and page 18/32 of the submission).
6493-
submission), De-gaussing property Shakespear Regional Park Whangaparaoa.
6493-
Rezone Torpedo Bay Naval Museum to Mori Purpose zone (See Appendix A, page
6493-
submission), Torpedo Bay Naval Musuem.
6493-
Rezone New Zealand Defence Force Housing Blocks (94 lots) - Potter/Greenslade;
Tennyson; Corella; Alamein to Mori Purpose zone (See Appendix A, page 32/32 and page
6493-
Add the NZDF Housing Blocks (94 lots) - Potter/Greenslade; Tennyson; Corella;
Alamein.Include in the Mori Purpose precinct (See Appendix A, page 32/32 and page 18/32
of the submission).
6494-1 Jason Jones jsjones@kol.co.nz Historic Heritage (Overlay)
Heritage
Places
Re-evaluate and delete 10 Symonds Street, Onehunga (Sutties Estate Historic Heritage Area)
from schedule.
6494-2 Jason Jones jsjones@kol.co.nz Historic Heritage (Overlay)
Heritage
Places
Re-evaluate Sutties Estate Historic Heritage Area and base evaluation of houses on an
individual case by case evaluation.
6495-1 J R Farquhar david@davidwren.co.nz Residential zones Residential
Delete rule 6.11 Garages in the Single Housing Zones where the Isthmus A Special Character
Overlay applies.
6496-1 Charles R Goldie richard@peddlethorp.co.nz City Centre Zone I4 Rules/Appendix 7.1- 7.3
Amend Rule 4.1 'Activity table' to require the demolition of buildings to be considered as part
of a consent application to construct a new building not as a restricted discretionary activity.
6496-2 Charles R Goldie richard@peddlethorp.co.nz City Centre Zone I4 Rules/Appendix 7.1- 7.3 Amend Rule 4.2 Notification to delete general height controls.
6496-3 Charles R Goldie richard@peddlethorp.co.nz City Centre Zone I4 Rules/Appendix 7.1- 7.3 Amend Rule 4.2 Notification to delete maximum tower rules.
6496-4 Charles R Goldie richard@peddlethorp.co.nz City Centre Zone I4 Rules/Appendix 7.1- 7.3 Retain Rule 4.3.1 'Retail'.
Amend Rule 4.1 'General height controls' to introduce minimum building heights. Buildings
should be at least as high as the width of the road space, including footpath, measured from
the property boundary to the property boundary on the opposite side of the street facing the
principle building faade.
Amend Rule 4.2 'Admission of sunlight into public spaces' so that the times for the admission
of sunlight into the identified public open space is determined by the optimal time of day and
year rather than the blanket 12-2pm.
Amend Rule 4.3 'Aotea Square height control plane' Figure 5 so that it allows for the build up
of higher buildings to the south of Aotea Square.
325/1145
Sub#/
Amend Rule 4.4 'Harbour edge height control plane' by rewording the first bullet of the section
of 'Purpose' as follows: "manage the scale of buildings at the western end of Quay Street to -
provide a transition in building height from the core central business district to the waterfront
reinforce the Quay Street east west connection running from the corner of Gladstone Road
and Quay Street to the east and Jellicoe Street in Wynyard Quarter to the west by alignment
of tall building frontages. maximise views between the harbour and the city centre.." Amend
4.4.4(1) to increase the building height and delete Figure 1 and amend Figure 2 to include the
centre of the intersection with Hobson Street to the centre of the intersection of Fanshawe
Street and the frontage alignment extending along Quay Street and The Strand.
6496-9 Charles R Goldie richard@peddlethorp.co.nz City Centre Zone I4 Rules/Appendix 7.1- 7.3 Retain Rule 4.6 'Railway Station building and gardens view protection plane'.
Amend Rule 4.6 'Dilworth Terrace views protection plan' Figure 4 to allow for the construction
of higher buildings towards the eastern end of the proposed extension.
6496-11 Charles R Goldie richard@peddlethorp.co.nz City Centre Zone I4 Rules/Appendix 7.1- 7.3 Retain Rule 4.7 'Measuring building height'.
Amend Rule 4.8 'Rooftops' by retaining clauses (2),(4)(a),(4)(c); and delete (4)(b); and amend
clause (1) to "...architectural features chimneys, lift towers, machinery rooms and water
towers that exceed the height of all parts of a parapet surrounding the roof on which the
projections are located, must be enclosed in a maximum of 1 enclosure where the roof area
<1000m2. For roofs >1000m2 plan and equipment must be enclosed in no more than three
enclosures three structures and integrated within the overall roof design. ?.; Amend 4(3) For
the purpose of this rule, rooftop includes the roof of building podiums in addition to its ordinary
meaning, except that plant and equipment including lifts must be contained within the podium
form".
Amend Rule 4.9 'Basic Floor Area Ratio' to be increased by 25% in all areas, and delete
4.9(2).
6496-14 Charles R Goldie richard@peddlethorp.co.nz City Centre Zone I4 Rules/Appendix 7.1- 7.3 Retain Rule 4.10 'Bonus Floor Area Ratio'.
6496-15 Charles R Goldie richard@peddlethorp.co.nz City Centre Zone I4 Rules/Appendix 7.1- 7.3 Delete Rule 4.11 'Bonus Floor Area Ratio - light and outlook'.
Retain Rule 4.12 'Bonus floor area ratio - use of or transfer of historic heritage and special
character floor space bonus'.
Retain Rule 4.13 'Bonus floor area ratio - securing historic heritage and special character floor
space bonus'.
Retain Rule 4.15 'Bonus floor area ratio - bonus floor space calculation for scheduled heritage
buildings'.
Amend Rule 4.16 'Bonus floor area ratio - public open space, by retaining clauses (1), (2), (3),
(4) and (6) and delete 4.16(7) and amend 4.16(5) to include the words '..The public open
space must be located within 1.5m of the adjacent street at which the principle access to the
public open space is located'
6496-20 Charles R Goldie richard@peddlethorp.co.nz City Centre Zone I4 Rules/Appendix 7.1- 7.3 Delete Rule 4.17 'Bonus floor area ratio - through site links'.
6496-21 Charles R Goldie richard@peddlethorp.co.nz City Centre Zone I4 Rules/Appendix 7.1- 7.3 Delete Rule 4.18 'Bonus floor area ratio - through site links through identified blocks'.
6496-22 Charles R Goldie richard@peddlethorp.co.nz City Centre Zone I4 Rules/Appendix 7.1- 7.3 Retain Rule 4.19 'Bonus floor area ratio - work of art'.
Amend Rule 4.20(1) 'Bonus floor area ratio -maximum floor area ratio so that the maximum
floor area ratio on all sites is increased by 25%, and amend 4.20(2) to make any building that
exceeds the maximum floor area ratio a limited discretionary activity and delete 4.4.20(3).
6496-24 Charles R Goldie richard@peddlethorp.co.nz City Centre Zone I4 Rules/Appendix 7.1- 7.3 Retain Rule 4.22 'Streetscape improvement and landscaping'.
6496-25 Charles R Goldie richard@peddlethorp.co.nz City Centre Zone I4 Rules/Appendix 7.1- 7.3 Delete Rule 4.23 'Maximum tower dimension, setback from street and tower separation'.
Amend Rule 4.24 'Building frontage alignment and height' by: Clause (1) to require all building
frontages to align with the street frontage; clause(1)(a) to replace the existing text with "The
All buildings must adjoin the entire...spaces" ; clause(1)(b) and (c) to replace the existing text
with "The building must have a minimum frontage height equal to the distance between the
site frontage and the frontage of the site immediately opposite"; and retain clause(2).
Amend Rule 4.25 'Ground floor entrances at street frontage level' by: clause(1) to require the
ground floor to be no more than 1.5m above or below the level of the frontage, rather than
1.5m; delete clause (2); retain clause(3).
6496-28 Charles R Goldie richard@peddlethorp.co.nz City Centre Zone I4 Rules/Appendix 7.1- 7.3 Delete Rule 4.26 'Glazing'.
6496-29 Charles R Goldie richard@peddlethorp.co.nz City Centre Zone I4 Rules/Appendix 7.1- 7.3 Delete Rule 4.27 'Ground floor activities' clause(1) and (2) and retain clause(3).
Amend Rule 4.28 'Verandas' as follows: retain all clauses except clause (d) and amend as
follows; 'where glazed, be opaque or patterned glass Be glazed with clear or patterned
glass '.
Retain Rule 4.29 'Minimum floor to floor/ceiling height' clause (1) and delete clause (2) and (3)
and replace with the following words "the finished floor to floor height of new buildings must
be at least 3m".
6496-32 Charles R Goldie richard@peddlethorp.co.nz City Centre Zone I4 Rules/Appendix 7.1- 7.3 Retain Rule 4.30 'Wind'.
326/1145
Sub#/
6496-33 Charles R Goldie richard@peddlethorp.co.nz City Centre Zone I4 Rules/Appendix 7.1- 7.3 Retain Rule 4.31 'Glare'.
6496-34 Charles R Goldie richard@peddlethorp.co.nz City Centre Zone I4 Rules/Appendix 7.1- 7.3 Retain Rule 4.32 'Special amenity yard'.
6496-35 Charles R Goldie richard@peddlethorp.co.nz City Centre Zone I4 Rules/Appendix 7.1- 7.3 Retain Rule 4.33 'Street sightlines'.
6496-36 Charles R Goldie richard@peddlethorp.co.nz City Centre Zone I4 Rules/Appendix 7.1- 7.3 Retain Rule 4.33 'Outlook space'
6496-37 Charles R Goldie richard@peddlethorp.co.nz Definitions Existing
Amend the definition of 'net internal floor area' to read "the floor space between the finished
internal surfaces of walls between residential units or adjacent common or public space".
6496-38 Charles R Goldie richard@peddlethorp.co.nz City Centre Zone I4 Rules/Appendix 7.1- 7.3 Amend Rule 4.35 'Minimum dwelling size' by retaining clause (1)(a) and deleting clause (1)(b).
Amend Rule 4.36 'Minimum dimension of principle living rooms and principal bedrooms' as
follows: '....internal walls of the room. The minimum size of living rooms must be 20m
2
for a
1 bedroom dwelling, and increase in size by 5m
2
per bedroom in any particular dwelling' .
6496-40 Charles R Goldie richard@peddlethorp.co.nz City Centre Zone I4 Rules/Appendix 7.1- 7.3 Retain Rule 4.37 'Daylight to dwellings'.
6496-41 Charles R Goldie richard@peddlethorp.co.nz City Centre Zone I4 Rules/Appendix 7.1- 7.3 Retain Rule 4.38 'Service and waste'.
6496-42 Charles R Goldie richard@peddlethorp.co.nz City Centre Zone I4 Rules/Appendix 7.1- 7.3 Retain Rule 4.39 'Dwelling mix'.
Retain Rule 4.40 'Outdoor living spaces' and include two new rules providing for balconies
projecting over streets or public space and enclosed balconies [refer to page 9/10 for specific
text].
6496-44 Charles R Goldie richard@peddlethorp.co.nz City Centre Zone I4 Rules/Appendix 7.1- 7.3 Delete Rule 4.41 'Universal access for residential buildings'.
6496-45 Charles R Goldie richard@peddlethorp.co.nz City Centre Zone I4 Rules/Appendix 7.1- 7.3 Retain Rule 5 'Assessment -Controlled Activities'.
Amend Rule 6(5) and (6) Restricted Discretionary Activities 'Matters of discretion' to include
'proposals for redevelopment of any site proposed for demolition'.
6496-47 Charles R Goldie richard@peddlethorp.co.nz City Centre Zone I4 Rules/Appendix 7.1- 7.3 Retain Rule 7 'Assessment - development control infringements'.
Amend 8(2) 'Assessment - bonus floor area as follows: All pedestrian spaces and facilities
within the public open space must should be universally accessible.
6496-49 Charles R Goldie richard@peddlethorp.co.nz City Centre Zone I4 Rules/Appendix 7.1- 7.3 Retain Rule 9 'Special information requirements'.
Amend the PAUP so that development contributions are not payable to areas where the
'Bonus floor area ratios and Bonus floor' apply (Rules 4.4.9 - 4.4.20).
6496-51 Charles R Goldie richard@peddlethorp.co.nz City Centre Zone I4 Rules/Appendix 7.1- 7.3 Require buildings fronting a public street to have articulation of their faades.
Add a new permitted activity that requires facade projections of not more than 0.5m from the
site boundary on the the street and no less than 4.5m above the footpath (this does not
accommodate the floor space), and that no air space lease will be payable for such
projections to council or other parties and permission is not required from them.
6497-1 Luke Christensen luke.xensen@gmail.com Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
Delete all minimum parking requirements from the PAUP, especially in the Mixed Housing
zones.
6497-2 Luke Christensen luke.xensen@gmail.com RPS Urban growth
quality compact urban form Rezone more land alongside public transport corridors, especially the rail network.
6497-3 Luke Christensen luke.xensen@gmail.com Zoning Central
Rezone Light Industrial land in Morningside, Takapuna and Greenlane to Ellerslie to Mixed
Use.
6497-4 Luke Christensen luke.xensen@gmail.com
Centre) Business
Park zones
Amend the general height limit in the Mixed Use zone to 8 storeys and use overlays used to
lower and raise the height limit where appropriate.
Centre) Business
Park zones Retain the height limit for Local Centres as 4 storeys.
Centre) Business
Park zones Amend the height limit for most Town Centres to 8 storeys.
6497-7 Luke Christensen luke.xensen@gmail.com Residential zones Residential
policies
Amend the rules for the Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings zone and the Mixed
Housing zones to provide for greater intensification of land.
6497-8 Luke Christensen luke.xensen@gmail.com Future Urban
Amend the Future Urban zone provisions to split this zone into two to ensure growth is
adequately staged. The short term Future Urban zone should contain 7 years capacity as
anticipated in the RPS.
6497-9 Luke Christensen luke.xensen@gmail.com Sustainable Development C7.7/H6.4 Sustainable design Retain Greenstar and Homestar provisions.
6498-1 NZ Bus scott.thorne@nzbus.co.nz RPS
Transport B3.3 Transport Retain Policy 5.
327/1145
Sub#/
6498-6 NZ Bus scott.thorne@nzbus.co.nz Transport Auckland -wide C1.2 Policies Retain Policy 2.
6498-10 NZ Bus scott.thorne@nzbus.co.nz Precincts - City Centre Arts, Civic & Entertainment
Add an objective [in F3.1] relating to transport in this precinct to read: 'The transportation
demand of the precinct are provided for and travel demand planning and operations reflect
the importance of Wellesley Street to the public transport frequent network'.
6498-11 NZ Bus scott.thorne@nzbus.co.nz Precincts - City Centre Wynyard
Amend Policy 18 to read: 'Improve public connectivity between Wynyard precinct and the city
centre for pedestrians, cyclists and local public transport'.
6498-12 NZ Bus scott.thorne@nzbus.co.nz Precincts - City Centre Wynyard
Amend Policy 34 to read: 'Constrain and manage private vehicle travel in and out of Wynyard
precinct, particularly during peak travel periods'.
6499-1 William D J McGarry bill@platinumpm.co.nz Zoning Central
Rezone land at 130 St Georges Bay Road, Parnell (corner of St Georges Bay Road and the
Strand) from Light Industry to the equivalent of the Auckland Isthmus District Plan's Business
5 zone.
6500-1 Odyssey House gerardt@barker.co.nz Zoning West
Rezone 56 Bollard Avenue, New Windsor from Special Purpose School to Terrace Housing
and Apartment Buildings.
6500-2 Odyssey House gerardt@barker.co.nz Precincts - Central New Precincts Other New Precincts
Add new precinct to 56 Bollard Avenue, New Windsor that will provide for existing activities of
Odyssey House as an addiction treatment facility. Refer to full submission for details including
objectives, policies, rules and assessment criteria [pages 5-10/10].
6501-1 Richard Brown rj.brown@xtra.co.nz
control
Building demolition control J.3.6 Rules and mapping Remove 8 Church Street, Onehunga.
6502-1 Mt Hobson Group deanne@mhg.co.nz City Centre Zone I4 Rules/Appendix 7.1- 7.3
Amend provisions so that demolition in the City Centre zone is a permitted or controlled
activity [refer to page 4/10].
6502-2 Mt Hobson Group deanne@mhg.co.nz Precincts - City Centre Queen Street Valley
Amend provisions so that demolition in the Queen Street Valley Precinct is a permitted or
controlled activity, except where buildings have been specifically identified for protection
under the Plan [refer to page 5/10].
6502-3 Mt Hobson Group deanne@mhg.co.nz General Chapter G General provisions
refer to Designations theme) Delete 1.4 'Applying for a resource consent', 'Assessment criteria, third paragraph.
Amend 1.4 'Applying for a resource consent', 'Assessment criteria' to clarify that the matters
for discretion and assessment criteria listed in the Plan for controlled and restricted
discretionary activities are the sole matter for assessment of these types of consent.
6502-5 Mt Hobson Group deanne@mhg.co.nz Definitions Existing
Amend the definition of 'height' to include the use of average ground level as a means to
calculate height [refer to page 5/10 of the submission for suggested wording].
6502-6 Mt Hobson Group deanne@mhg.co.nz General Cross plan matters Delete maximum storey controls in all zones.
6502-7 Mt Hobson Group deanne@mhg.co.nz General Cross plan matters Delete floor to floor/ceiling height minimums for all zones.
6502-8 Mt Hobson Group deanne@mhg.co.nz Definitions New Add a definition for 'gross site area' [refer to page 6/10 of the submission for details].
6502-9 Mt Hobson Group deanne@mhg.co.nz RPS Urban growth
Rezone to 'provide for greater density of development across the Auckland Region as
envisaged under the Draft version of the Unitary Plan'.
6502-10 Mt Hobson Group deanne@mhg.co.nz Residential zones Residential Land use controls
Amend controls, including the density provisions for the Mixed Housing Urban zone [refer to
page 7/10 of the submission] 'to provide for greater density of development across the
Auckland Region as envisaged under the Draft version of the Unitary Plan'.
6502-11 Mt Hobson Group deanne@mhg.co.nz Mana Whenua General provisions
statements Delete the requirements for Design Statements.
environment Amend wording to confirm that the Auckland Design Manual is a non-statutory guideline.
6502-14 Mt Hobson Group deanne@mhg.co.nz Sustainable Development C7.7/H6.4 Sustainable design Delete the sustainable development provisions.
Add standards/matters of control for demolition in the City Centre zone as a permitted or
controlled activity [refer to page 5/10 for details].
328/1145
Sub#/
Add standards/matters of control for demolition in the Queen Street Valley Precinct as a
permitted or controlled activity [refer to page 5/10 for details].
Amend the demolition provisions by undertaking an assessment to identify the buildings within
this precinct that qualify for scheduling, and for which council may exercise its discretion over
6502-19 Mt Hobson Group deanne@mhg.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - general
controls
Amend the residential subdivision provisions by replacing 'net site area' with 'gross site area'
6503-1
Whangaparaoa Ratepayers
and Residents Association contact@wrrai.co.nz Precincts - North Gulf Harbour Marina
Retain the present zoning provisions for sub precinct A which has an underlying zoning of
Marina.
6503-2
and Residents Association contact@wrrai.co.nz Zoning North and Islands
Rezone Gulf Harbour Marina Sub Precinct B to cover only the Hammerhead its reduction in
size, and reflect the Development License and associated plan GHM2 and its current use.
6503-3
and Residents Association contact@wrrai.co.nz Precincts - North Gulf Harbour Limit the amount of housing to 2913 dwellings. (Rule 3.1)
6503-4
and Residents Association contact@wrrai.co.nz Precincts - North Rodney Landscape
Retain a minimum large lot size of 8,000m
2
for sites adjacent to Coalmine Bay (on the
northern side of Whangaparaoa Road from Tindalls Bay to the vicinity of Siesta Terrace).
Refer to Rodney Landscape.
6503-5
and Residents Association contact@wrrai.co.nz Precincts - North Gulf Harbour
Retain 8,000m
2
minimum lot size for land bordering the Weiti Estuary. (refer to Rodney
Landscape)
6503-6
Retain the Public Open Space - Sport and Active Recreation zoning for the Gulf Harbour Golf
Course.
6503-7
Rezone the 'Archers Block' at 497 Whangaparaoa Road in Auckland Council ownership from
Large Lot to Public Open Space.
6503-8
and Residents Association contact@wrrai.co.nz Precincts - North Weiti Reduce the maximum number of dwellings from 1200 to 450 dwellings for the Weiti Block.
6503-9
Rezone the entire area of Mixed Housing Suburban around Tower Hill, Palmgreen Court and
Onepu, Stanmore Bay/Manly vicinity to Single House zoning.
6503-10
and Residents Association contact@wrrai.co.nz Zoning North and Islands Retain zoning of the shops at Manly (on Rawhiti Road) as Neighbourhood Centre (3 storeys).
6503-11
and Residents Association contact@wrrai.co.nz Trees
Trees J6.4 Rules Request public notification for felling of trees that are protected by scheduling.
6503-12
and Residents Association contact@wrrai.co.nz
SEAs
Land
Add 'uniquneness or distinctiveness' to the criteria that establishes the Significant Ecological
Area (SEA) 2166 (Weiti River). This will recognise the 'cheniers' - a unique geological
formation.
6503-13
and Residents Association contact@wrrai.co.nz RPS
Add a new objective to divert utilities away from SEA's as their installation and maintenance
are incompatible with the SEA status. Where utilities remain [in SEA's], guidelines need to be
agreed with the operating company and appropriate reporting and enforcement provided for.
6503-14
Rezone the area immediately south of the Weiti River mouth to 'Public Open Space -
Conservation' to replace proposed Coastal Transition zone. The informal recreation the
Coastal Transition zone allows for is incompatible with the dotterel breeding area.
6503-15
and Residents Association contact@wrrai.co.nz Mana Whenua
Whenua
and policies
Amend 'Sites and Places of Value to Mana Whenua' to an 'alert layer' to provide an indication
of when a particular development proposal may require a cultural impact assessment.
6503-16
and Residents Association contact@wrrai.co.nz Infrastructure
Energy
Amend the cellphone tower provisions to require resource consent of at least limited
notification to property owners in the vicinity, with appropriate consideration of alternative
sites, design, location, and co-location of facilities.
6503-17
and Residents Association contact@wrrai.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - Urban zones H5.2 3.1 Residential zones
Amend the subdivision rules to increase the minimum residential site size from 600m
2
to
700m
2
for the Coastal Areas of Eastern Whangaparaoa Peninsula as described in Rule
8.15.2.4(e) and identified in Appendix 8A of the Operative District Plan. Add an additional
Subdivision Control overlay and amend Table 3 to achieve this. Extend these provisions to
the rest of the Eastern Peninsula.
6503-18
and Residents Association contact@wrrai.co.nz Natural Hazards and Flooding Flooding
and policies
Limit development and improve development controls in those areas with stormwater
catchments (Manly, Stanmore Bay, Red Beach, Orewa, Arkles Bay, Gulf Harbour) where
provisions for flooding do not adequately take account of the catchment of the low lying areas
identified as flood prone, nor the link between flood and inundation-prone areas and the
associated catchments that flood those areas.
6503-19
Rezone properties on the southern side of Wade River Road, Whangaparaoa from Mixed
Housing Suburban to Single House where the Significant Ecological Area extends over the
properties on this section of the road.
6503-20
and Residents Association contact@wrrai.co.nz Precincts - North Gulf Harbour Marina
Ensure visitor accommodation and any form of residential, apartment, hotel or other
residential zoning is excluded from Sub Precinct A which has an underlying zoning of Marina.
329/1145
Sub#/
6503-21
Rezone Gulf Harbour Marina Sub Precinct B as a public open space zone with an allowance
for the Ferry Terminal and associated parking, recreational parking and use.
6503-22
Rezone Gulf Harbour Marina Sub Precinct B for new subdivision to provide for substantial
esplanade and reserve areas for public access, parking and recreation around the entire
perimeter of the Hammerhead.
6503-23
Retain Large Lot zoning for all that land adjacent to Coalmine Bay, on the southern side of
Whangaparaoa Road and bounded by Gulf Harbour marina to the eastern end of Matakatia
Beach to the west.
6503-24
Retain the Public Open Space - Sport and Active Recreation zoning for the
Whangaparaoa Golf Course.
6503-25
and Residents Association contact@wrrai.co.nz Residential zones Residential Activity Table
Amend provisions for boarding houses (up to 200 square metres GFA) and larger boarding
houses (over 200 square metres GFA) to be a non-complying activity in the Mixed Housing
Suburban zone.
6503-26
and Residents Association contact@wrrai.co.nz Residential zones Residential Activity Table
Amend provisions for boarding houses (up to 200 square metres GFA) and larger boarding
houses (over 200 square metres GFA) to be a non-complying activity in the Mixed Housing
Urban zone.
6503-27
Rezone the area of Mixed Housing Urban around Palmgreen Court and Red Hibiscus,
Stanmore Bay to Mixed Housing Suburban.
6504-1
Wood Processors' Association
of New Zealand jeanette@wpa.org.nz General Miscellaneous Other
Amend the sustainable building provisions in accordance with the changes requested in the
submission by Carter Holt Harvey Limited.
6505-1 Peter Snell Youth Village lancehessell@tnp.co.nz Precincts - North New Precincts All other New Precincts
Add a new precinct, 'Peter Snell Youth Village', Whangaparoa, which incorporates the
provisions from Rodney Plan Change 130. This includes providing for existing uses and future
growth and development. See submission for further details [pages 6 to 45/45 of the
submission].
6506-1 Cornwall Trust whitburns@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central Rezone to Mixed Housing Urban 318 Kohimarama Road from Mixed Housing Surburban.
6506-2 Cornwall Trust whitburns@xtra.co.nz Residential zones Residential
General
Increase building height limit to 9.5m from 8m for 318 Kohimarama Road; and also in the
Mixed Housing Suburban zone and Single Housing zone.
6507-1 Pastoral Genomics Limited
shoshona.galbreath@duncancotterill.
com RPS Natural resources
Organisms Delete all objectives and policies relating to GMOs.
6507-2 Pastoral Genomics Limited
shoshona.galbreath@duncancotterill.
com
organisms
modified organisms Delete all objectives, policies and rules relating to GMOs.
6508-1 Nick Conn conn.graeme@gmail.com
the CMA Mangroves
and policies
Amend the objectives and policies to allow for mangrove management that provides for
mangrove protection and removal of mangroves that are clearly linked to creating recreational
access points only.
6508-2 Nick Conn conn.graeme@gmail.com
the CMA
Amend rules to allow for mangrove management that provides for mangrove protection and
removal of mangroves that are clearly linked to creating recreational access points only.
6509-1 Mangrove Protection Society basilann53@gmail.com RPS Coastal
space - coastal environment Retain 2(d) boardwalks
6509-2 Mangrove Protection Society basilann53@gmail.com
the CMA Mangroves
and policies
Amend background regarding mangrove distribution, drainage, biodiversity and an additional
paragraph detailing benefits from mangrove retention and encouragement (see submission
page 1/2)
the CMA Mangroves
and policies Retain Objective 1 and Objective 2
the CMA Mangroves
and policies Delete Objectives 3, 4, 5 and 6
the CMA Mangroves
and policies
Add new objective "Protecting mangrove expansion to enhance further erosion protection,
habitat expansion, and the positive effects on air and harbour productivity for the benefit of
present and future generations"
the CMA Mangroves
and policies
Add new objective "Any authorised mangrove removal is on a scale appropriate to the
importance of mangroves as areas of indigenous vegetation"
the CMA Mangroves
and policies
Amend Policy 1 to add "Protect colonisation where it can provide
significant erosion protection, habitat expansion, or positive effects on Green house gases or
compensatory production to harbours in a future of climate warming".
the CMA Mangroves
and policies
Amend Policy 3 to (a) "public access to and along the CMA at an appropriate scale" and
delete the remainder of the policy
controls
Delete and replace rule 2.11(1) with "Mangrove removal to provide for public access to and
along the CMA should be kept to a minimum and preferably by boardwalks"
the CMA
Amend Rule 2.11(2) with the addition of "civil emergencies" as a reason for controlled or
permitted clearing or damage
330/1145
Sub#/
the CMA
Amend definition for 'Mangrove seedling' to "having a single and unbranched stem of less
than 30cm"
6510-1 Simon W Peacock
12 Waterbank Crescent, Waterview,
Auckland 1026 Zoning Central
Rezone Herdman Street, Daventry Street and Waterbank Street, Waterview to be Suburban
zoning with a 2 storey maximum height.
6511-1 Nigel and Sascha Mortimer saschamortimer@gmail.com
Centre) Business
Park zones
Clarify why it is ok to breach development controls under Rule 4.1 [Development control
infringements].
6511-2 Nigel and Sascha Mortimer saschamortimer@gmail.com Definitions New Include a new definition for 'outlook'.
Clarify under Rule 2.2 [notification] how building height and height in relation to building
controls apply to one another.
Centre) Business
Park zones
Require that the key development controls e.g. height, height in relation to boundary and
yards to be mandatory.
6511-5 Nigel and Sascha Mortimer saschamortimer@gmail.com Built Environment (Overlays)
Height Control Apply a 12.5m hight limit to the Local Centre zone on Jervois Road, Herne Bay.
Centre) Business
Park zones
Include a new development control that must be complied with, requiring a 3m set back on the
south boundaries of the Local Centre zone, Herne Bay (excluding the street frontage on
Jervois Road).
Centre) Business
Park zones
Require the development controls to be mandatory (i.e. not one of the two controls that can be
breached) on the boundaries adjoining residential sites and the Local Centre zone, Herne
Bay.
6512-1 Michael P A Coote biancahartley@tnp.co.nz Zoning North and Islands Rezone 186 Matua Road, Huapai from Large Lot to Single House.
6512-2 Michael P A Coote biancahartley@tnp.co.nz Precincts - North Huapai North
Delete Sub-precinct C from the Northern section of 186 Matua Road, Huapai and extend Sub-
precinct B over the entire property. See submission for further details and map [Vol. 1 page
5/14 of the submission].
6512-3 Michael P A Coote biancahartley@tnp.co.nz RPS Mana Whenua B5 Strategic
Reject majority of provisions relating to Mori, including provisions which give different rights
to Mori, Mori private interests. See submission for further details [Vol. 2 pages 3 and 4/71].
6512-4 Michael P A Coote biancahartley@tnp.co.nz General Miscellaneous Consultation and engagement Extend the submission period for submissions relating to Mori provisions.
6512-5 Michael P A Coote biancahartley@tnp.co.nz Mana Whenua General provisions
assessment Delete provisions for Cultural Impact Assessments.
assessment
Suspend Cultural Impact Assessments from having immediate legal effect until a public
inquiry can be held to determine an appropriate way to permit Cultural Impact Assessments to
function within the PAUP.
assessment
Establish an independent permanent commission to oversee and adjudicate impartially Mori
and Mana Whenua claims under the PAUP to sites and places of value and significance to
Mana Whenua. See submission for further details [Vol. 2 page 7/71 of the submission].
6512-8 Michael P A Coote biancahartley@tnp.co.nz General Chapter A Introduction A1 Background
Delete 1.2 'Mana Whenua' and replace with text that is fair and just to all Aucklanders. See
submission for further details [Vol. 2 page 9 and 10/71 of the submission].
6512-9 Michael P A Coote biancahartley@tnp.co.nz RPS Mana Whenua B5 Strategic
Delete all provisions concerning Mori culture. See submission for further details [Vol. 2
pages 10 to 13 of the submission].
6513-1 Briar H Wilson briar@66.kiwi.nz Zoning Central
Rezone properties at 56, 58, 60, 62,68,74,76 and 80 Gillies Avenue, Epsom from the
proposed Terrace Housing and Apartment Building zone to a [lower density] residential zone .
6513-2 Briar H Wilson briar@66.kiwi.nz Trees
Trees
Notable Trees
Schedule mature trees on the properties at 56, 58, 60, 62,68,74,76 and 80 Gillies Avenue,
Epsom.
6514-1 Patiki Investments Limited david@fuzo.co.nz Zoning West Rezone 100 Kemp Road, Massey from Mixed Housing Suburban to Mixed Housing Urban.
6514-2 Patiki Investments Limited david@fuzo.co.nz Residential zones
obs & pols Allow for a height limit of 9.5m for the property at 100 Kemp Road, Massey.
obs & pols Allow for a maximum building height of 9.5m in the Single House zone.
zone desc, obs & pols Allow for a maximum building height of 9.5m in the Mixed Housing Suburban zone.
6515-1 Waikato Regional Council
amanda.banks@waikatoregion.govt.
nz RPS Issues
wellbeing
Recognise importance of inter-regional collaboration for integrated planning in the Upper
North Island
nz RPS Urban growth
environment
Retain quality development approach and objectives and policies that relate to the sustainable
use of resources
331/1145
Sub#/
nz RPS Urban growth
environment
Amend Policy 11 as follows: Require large scale all development, and encourage all other
which incorporates energy efficiency, solar orientation of buildings, renewable energy
generation, waste minimisation and water sensitive design.
nz RPS Urban growth
environment
Amend Objective 1(a) as follows: Recognises Auckland's sense of place and enriches
its biodiversity, natural character and landscape, character, heritage and legibility (identify).
nz RPS Urban growth
environment
Insert new policy: Require subdivision and development to effectively integrate existing
natural values and provide for their restoration and enhancement as part of the overall design.
nz RPS Urban growth
Insert detail regarding growth, timing and staging of land release within the RUB to ensure the
full effects of growth and development are considered, particularly in terms of cross border
issues
nz RPS Urban growth
Amend policy 6 as follows: Require provision or upgrading of significant infrastructure,
including consideration of cross boundary infrastructure, to be coordinated with the structure
and sequencing of growth and development.
nz RPS
character and natural heritage B4.3.4 Biodiversity Retain policies 1 to 13
nz RPS
Amend policy 6 as follows: Manage the effects of activities on significant indigenous
biodiversity by: a) Avoiding and minimising adverse effects on:...
nz Water
Objectives Retain objectives 3 and 4
nz Water
Policy 3 - Water allocation
guidelines, availabilities and
limits Retain policy 3
nz RPS Climate change
Amend policy 1(b) as follows: (b) requiring 5 or more all new dwellings and office and
industrial buildings over 5000m2 to achieve best practice sustainable design.
nz RPS Climate change
Amend policy 1(c) as follows: (c) encouraging requiring all development to incorporate energy
efficient design through solar orientation of the building, location of windows and inclusion of
appropriate insulation and thermal mass.
nz RPS General
issues
Support for the Upper North Island regions and cities working together on strategic matters as
described in the Upper North Island Strategic Agreement
nz RPS General
issues
Acknowledge growth strategies within the Upper North Island and the need to ensure
consistency between growth planning in the Upper North Island
nz RPS General
issues Recognise the need for ongoing alignment of transport planning across the upper North Island
nz RPS General
issues
Recognise the inter-relationships between Waikato Region's economy, particularly the
primary production sector, the Auckland economy and the benefits of co-ordinated economic
strategies between regions
nz RPS General
issues
Support the coordination of freight movement and related facilities across the Upper North
Island, including development of inland ports
nz RPS General
issues
Insert recognition of the importance of the Waikato Regon's mineral/ aggregate industry for
Auckland and the impact of this on transport and freight systems
nz RPS General
issues
Insert recognition of the role of the Waikato Region plays in providing locations and facilities
for tourism and recreation for Auckland, and the need to plan of increasing demand as
population grows
nz RPS General
issues
Insert recognition of the range of infrastructure in the Waikato Region and beyond, which
supprots Auckland, including road and rail infrastructure, electricity transmission
infrastructure, the Waikato River water treatment plant and pipeline, and the Natural Gas
Corporation pipeline
nz RPS General
issues
Insert recognition of the need for aligning key infrastructure policy between the Auckland and
Waikato regions and the possibility of shared infrastructure corridors
nz RPS General
issues
Insert recognition of the facilities in the Waikato Region which service Auckland and the need
for appropriate forward planning of other services in the region which may need to service
Auckland
nz RPS General
issues
Insert recognition of the need for consistent and collaborative planning for rural-residential
development across the Auckland and Waikato regional boundary
nz RPS General
issues
Insert recognition of the need for strategic discussions about urban business, industrial and
other land use development either side of the Auckland and Waikato regional boundary
nz RPS General
issues
Insert recognition of the need for natural hazard and civil emergeny management to be
aligned across regional boundaries
332/1145
Sub#/
nz RPS General
issues
Insert encouragement of consistent approaches to management of the Hauraki Gulf and
Manukau Harbour, in regards to navigation safety and aquaculture. This should include
recognition of the proposal for Auckland Council and Waikato Regional Council to developer
a joint marine strategy for Hauraki Gulf
nz RPS General
issues Insert recognition of the need to coordinate pest management across the regional boundary
nz RPS General
issues
Amend the second sentence of the transport linkages section as follows: This includes
recognising and facilitating the different transport linkages between Auckland, Northland and
Waikato and where relevant wider UNISA linkages to the Bay of Plenty.
nz RPS General
issues Reference the growth strategies of neighbouring regional and district councils
nz RPS General
issues
Amend first paragraph of introductory comments to include role of iwi and energy
infrastructure providers.
nz RPS General
issues
Insert the following additional clause 7 into the processes section under cross-boundary
issues: 7. Cross-boundary transport modelling and monitoring with key stakeholders to inform
future planning and decision-making to achieve integration between land use and transport.
Amend the 6th clause as follows: Cross boundary notification of structure planning
processes, significant resource consent applications and participation in joint hearing
processes.
nz RPS General
issues
Insert provision for the establishment of a technical working group between Auckland Council
and neighbouring Councils to develop a more detailed RUB staging process
nz RPS General
Insert environmental results anticipated which are aligned with the objectives and policies in
B9 of the Plan [Responding to climate change]
nz Infrastructure
C1.1 Infrastructure
policies
Amend policy 3(d) as follows: the benefits of infrastructure to the wider community,
Auckland, neighbouring local authorities and/or New Zealand.
nz Infrastructure
C1.1 Infrastructure
policies
Amend policy 5(e) as follows: the benefits provided by the infrastructure to the wider
community, and/or Auckland and/or neighbouring local authorities provided by the
infrastructure .
nz Infrastructure
C1.1 Infrastructure
policies
Amend policy 10(a) as follows: contributes to the operation of the inter-regional single
integrated multi-modal transport system.
nz Transport Auckland -wide C1.2 Objectives
Amend objective 1 as follows: Land use and all modes of transport are integrated in a manner
that enables the adverse effects of traffic generation on the transport network, both within
Auckland and inter-regionally, to be managed.
nz Sustainable Development C7.7/H6.4 Sustainable design
Insert provisions to incentivise the efficient use of construction materials and therefore
minimise the production of construction waste.
nz Sustainable Development C7.7/H6.4 Sustainable design Retain provisions regarding water minimisation
nz
the CMA Mangroves
and policies
Amend objective 4 and policy 4 to ensure that areas identified as having significant ecological
value are not captured by mangrove removal provisions
nz Rural Zones General
Add the following new objective into section 6.1.1 Rural Economy: The value of high class
soils for primary production is recognised and high class soils are protected from
inappropriate subdivision, use or development.
nz Rural Zones General
Delete policy 3 in section 6.1.1 Rural Economy and replace with the following: Avoid a decline
in the availability of elite and prime land for primary production due to inappropriate
subdivision, use and development.
nz
SEAs
Undertake analysis on the potential cumulative effects of enabling SEA clearance for a
building platform and driveway if there is no practical alternative. Depending on results of this
analysis either insert additional matters of control to ensure ecological mitigation and
enhancement or alternatively amend activity status from controlled to restricted discretionary
and insert assessment criteria to address mitigation opportunities through enhancement and
restoration of SEA onsite, enhancement of SEA off site, and to assess cumulative effects of
SEA clearance.
nz Natural Hazards and Flooding Natural Hazards
Assessment
Amend rule 2.1(1) as follows: Finished floor levels for new dwellings and habitable rooms
within coastal inundation areas must be at least 500mm above the mapped 1 per cent AEP
storm tide inundation plus at least 1 metre projected sea level rise but with the following
exceptions that is not required to meet this control:
nz Natural Hazards and Flooding Natural Hazards
Assessment
Amend rule 2.2(1) as follows: All consent applications for restricted discretionary activities
must include a report by a suitably qualified engineer that confirms that the land on which the
activity is located is not subject to the following: a. coastal erosion or inundation over a 100
year timeframe; or b. land instability c. liquefaction
333/1145
Sub#/
nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - Rural zones
area Retain rule 2.3.3(9) [150ha minimum lot size in the rural production zone]
nz
the CMA
Amend the activity status of Mangrove removal (other than seedlings) from an area that was
free of mangroves in 1996, not in a marine reserve and in SEA-M1 and 2 only in areas listed
in Appendix 6.5, from a permitted activity to at least a controlled activity.
nz RPS Urban growth
2010
Insert a new clause under rule (2) as follows: m. the relationship with neighbouring local
authority infrastructure where networks are linked.
nz RPS Urban growth
2010
Amend rule (4)(a)(iii) as follows: iii. integrated transport assessment including inter-regional
assessment where appropriate.
6516-1 Chong Family Trust chongs@xtra.co.nz Sustainable Development C7.7/H6.4 Sustainable design Retain all objectives relating to sustainable design.
6516-2 Chong Family Trust chongs@xtra.co.nz Sustainable Development C7.7/H6.4 Sustainable design Retain all policies relating to sustainable design.
6516-3 Chong Family Trust chongs@xtra.co.nz Sustainable Development C7.7/H6.4 Sustainable design Retain all rules relating to sustainable design.
6516-4 Chong Family Trust chongs@xtra.co.nz Sustainable Development C7.7/H6.4 Sustainable design
Add new rule that makes non-compliance with any sustainable design rule a non-complying
activity.
6516-5 Chong Family Trust chongs@xtra.co.nz Residential zones Residential
General
Add a new rule that allows for 40m
2
self-contained units within existing sites provided these
are not subdivided from the parent site and they meet the site coverage and other residential
development controls, as a controlled activity.
6516-6 Chong Family Trust chongs@xtra.co.nz RPS Urban growth
Add new provisions that will raise the quality of landscaping and design outcomes within
industrial areas [Light Industry zone], in particular requiring landscaping on front boundaries.
6516-7 Chong Family Trust chongs@xtra.co.nz
Centre) Business
zones
Add new provisions that will raise the quality of landscaping and design outcomes within
industrial areas [Heavy Industry zone], in particular requiring landscaping on front boundaries.
6516-8 Chong Family Trust chongs@xtra.co.nz Historic Heritage (Overlay)
Heritage
places
Amend activity status of additions and alterations to existing buildings [from a discretionary
activity] to a restricted discretionary activity.
Heritage
places
Add additions and alterations to accessory buildings to activity table as a restricted
Add 'character and design of development to be compatible with the character of existing
building on site' as new matters of discretion for additions and alterations to existing buildings
and all accessory buildings as restricted discretionary activities.
6516-11 Chong Family Trust chongs@xtra.co.nz Designations
Ltd
Airport
Amend Auckland International Airport designation to add conditions that will provide for the
protection of cultural heritage and include consultation with local iwi.
6516-12 Chong Family Trust chongs@xtra.co.nz Designations
Ltd
Airport
Amend Auckland International Airport designation to add conditions that will provide for high
quality sustainable design, landscaping and high quality environmental outcomes.
6517-1 Todd Sylvester biancahartley@tnp.co.nz Zoning North and Islands Rezone 12 Matheson Road, Wellsford from Large Lot to Single House.
6517-2 Todd Sylvester biancahartley@tnp.co.nz Precincts - North Rodney Landscape Delete Sub-precinct A from 12 Matheson Road, Wellsford.
6518-1 Ngti Maru paul.majurey@ahjmlaw.com RPS General
review procedures
6518-2 Ngti Maru paul.majurey@ahjmlaw.com General Cross plan matters
values.
6518-4 Ngti Maru paul.majurey@ahjmlaw.com RPS Urban growth
Ensure Mana Whenua are involved in processes which impact on the extent and location of
the RUB.
6518-5 Ngti Maru paul.majurey@ahjmlaw.com General
GIS viewer
6518-6 Ngti Maru paul.majurey@ahjmlaw.com RPS Mana Whenua
Mtauranga & tikanga
Add a new method identifying that ancestral rohe maps will be developed (in conjunction with
Mana Whenua) as a non-statutory map layer.
6518-7 Ngti Maru paul.majurey@ahjmlaw.com General Editorial and Part 6 Review the numbering system and amend to improve its usability.
Fig. 1
Ensure that Iwi Management Plans are properly taken into account in the development of the
PAUP, for example all sites referred to in these plans should be included in the PAUP
depending on the interests and significance of those sites.
Fig. 1
Add objectives, policies and rules for areas of particular customary value that iwi seek
activities.
6518-10 Ngti Maru paul.majurey@ahjmlaw.com General Cross plan matters Add customary use as a permitted activity in all zones.
334/1145
Sub#/
6518-11 Ngti Maru paul.majurey@ahjmlaw.com General
GIS viewer
Amend the PAUP to include an alert layer to identify for example, sites identified in iwi
management plans to ensure that all sites not currently included in the overlays are
addressed. Add objectives, policies and rules for this alert layer. Refer to page 6/32 of
submission.
6518-12 Ngti Maru paul.majurey@ahjmlaw.com General Chapter A Introduction A1 Background Retain section 1.2 'Mana Whenua'.
6518-13 Ngti Maru paul.majurey@ahjmlaw.com General Chapter A Introduction A2 Statutory Framework
6518-14 Ngti Maru paul.majurey@ahjmlaw.com RPS Issues
growth
wellbeing
Amend issue statement to recognise the positive value Mori economic development
heritage
section as well.
Add a specific reference in the issue statement and explanation to the kaitiaki role of Mana
Whenua.
participation
review procedures
indicators.
6518-31 Ngti Maru paul.majurey@ahjmlaw.com RPS Natural resources
B6.3 Freshwater and
6518-32 Ngti Maru paul.majurey@ahjmlaw.com RPS Natural resources
B6.3 Freshwater and
6518-33 Ngti Maru paul.majurey@ahjmlaw.com RPS Coastal
environment
environment
Policy 1 and 4.
335/1145
Sub#/
quality
mataawaka).
review procedures
Mori provisions and these to be developed with the input of Mori. Alternatively, include a
method stating that a PAUP monitoring strategy will be developed within a specified
timeframe.
6518-40 Ngti Maru paul.majurey@ahjmlaw.com Mana Whenua Auckland wide - Mori Land
and policies
and policies
Amend definition of 'Mori Land' to refer to 'Parts 12 and 13 of Te Ture Whenua Mori Act
1993' and delete the reference to section 12 and 13.
and policies
and policies
considering the effects on natural resources [including SEAs]; Includes provision for a range
and policies
6518-45 Ngti Maru paul.majurey@ahjmlaw.com Mana Whenua
settlement land
and policies
settlement land
and policies
6518-47 Ngti Maru paul.majurey@ahjmlaw.com General Cross plan matters Retain provisions in Sections 3-7 in Chapter C where they are specifically related to Mori.
6518-48 Ngti Maru paul.majurey@ahjmlaw.com Mana Whenua Mori purpose zone
controls
6518-49 Ngti Maru paul.majurey@ahjmlaw.com Mana Whenua Mori purpose zone
6518-50 Ngti Maru paul.majurey@ahjmlaw.com Historic Heritage (Overlay)
Heritage
6518-51 Ngti Maru paul.majurey@ahjmlaw.com
control
Whenua
Whenua
6518-54 Ngti Maru paul.majurey@ahjmlaw.com Precincts - Central New Precincts Other New Precincts
6518-55 Ngti Maru paul.majurey@ahjmlaw.com Precincts Ak-Wide and Coastal Regional Parks
6518-56 Ngti Maru paul.majurey@ahjmlaw.com Precincts Ak-Wide and Coastal New Precincts All other New Precincts
6518-57 Ngti Maru paul.majurey@ahjmlaw.com Mana Whenua General provisions
discovery protocol
discovery protocol
activity.
336/1145
Sub#/
6518-59 Ngti Maru paul.majurey@ahjmlaw.com General Chapter G General provisions
statements
assessment
Retain Rule 2.7.4.1 'Cultural impact assessment' requirements for sites and places of
assessment
determine if a CIA is required is to be made with direct Mana Whenua input.
controls Amend the Preamble in section 2.1 to refer to the definition of Mori Land.
controls
discretionary.
Spec. info. req.
settlement land
settlement land, including Rule 2.2.5 'Rural industries on Treaty Settlement Mori Land ...'
Spec. info. req.
settlement land
settlement land
settlement land
discretionary.
settlement land
Amend assessment criteria 2.2.5(1)(f) to recognise that there may be no alternative sites
SEAs
submission.
SEAs
Assessment
Identify in Control 2.5 'Vegetation alteration or removal for customary use' activities not
complying to be a restricted discretionary activity and include new assessment criteria to this
effect.
6518-74 Ngti Maru paul.majurey@ahjmlaw.com Water Wastewater H4.15 Onsite wastewater rules Retain Control 2.1.1(2) but clarify what is meant by "must not be disturbed".
6518-75 Ngti Maru paul.majurey@ahjmlaw.com Sustainable Development C7.7/H6.4 Sustainable design
6518-76 Ngti Maru paul.majurey@ahjmlaw.com Rural Zones General I13.2 Land use controls
coastal areas.
6518-80 Ngti Maru paul.majurey@ahjmlaw.com Precincts General Content Precincts General Content
not provided].
6518-81 Ngti Maru paul.majurey@ahjmlaw.com Precincts General Content Precincts General Content
6518-82 Ngti Maru paul.majurey@ahjmlaw.com General Chapter G General provisions
status
6518-83 Ngti Maru paul.majurey@ahjmlaw.com Definitions New Expand the Mori terms to include definitions for all Mori terms used in the PAUP.
337/1145
Sub#/
6518-84 Ngti Maru paul.majurey@ahjmlaw.com Definitions Existing
Amend definition of 'customary use' to include: stones, soil, water marine or freshwater life
and expand uses to include contemporary uses.
6518-85 Ngti Maru paul.majurey@ahjmlaw.com Definitions Existing
both.
Outstanding Natural
Rules
Notification
6518-87 Ngti Maru paul.majurey@ahjmlaw.com Trees
Trees J6.4 Rules
6518-89 Ngti Maru paul.majurey@ahjmlaw.com General Miscellaneous Other
Include any new sites and places of significance or value as supported by Mana Whenua.
Refer to page 22/32 of submission.
controls
Delete the permitted activity rule threshold restricting development to a maximum of 10
dwellings. Refer to page 22/32 of submission.
settlement land
Delete the permitted activity rule threshold restricting development to a maximum of 10
dwellings. Refer to page 24/32 of submission.
6518-92 Ngti Maru paul.majurey@ahjmlaw.com General Miscellaneous Southern Hauraki Gulf Islands
Rezone 'Waiheke Reserves' to Mori Purpose and identify new Mori purpose precincts.
Refer to submission pages 18 and 32/32.
6518-93 Ngti Maru paul.majurey@ahjmlaw.com General Miscellaneous Southern Hauraki Gulf Islands
Rezone Aotea [Great Barrier Island] Conservation properties to Mori Purpose and identify
new Mori purpose precincts. Refer to submission pages 18 and 32/32.
6519-1
Pine Valley Road Landowners
Association biancahartley@tnp.co.nz RPS Changes to the RUB North and Waiheke Island
Rezone 330 ha of land along Pine Valley Road, Silverdale from Mixed Rural to Future Urban.
See submission for further details and map of the area [page 4/19 of the submission].
6519-2
Pine Valley Road Landowners
Association biancahartley@tnp.co.nz RPS Changes to the RUB North and Waiheke Island
Amend RUB boundary to include 330 ha of land along Pine Valley Road, Silverdale. See
submission for further details and map of the area [page 4/19 of the submission].
6520-1 Elisabeth Laird elisabeth.laird@gmail.com RPS Urban growth
Limit urban sprawl by keeping over 70% of growth within city limits and staging Future Urban
zone.
environment
Add provisions that will require all development to be subject to a design review with strong
6520-3 Elisabeth Laird elisabeth.laird@gmail.com General Miscellaneous
(Content) Make Auckland Design Manual available as soon as possible.
6520-4 Elisabeth Laird elisabeth.laird@gmail.com Residential zones Residential
General Remove rules that make residential development uneconomic.
6520-5 Elisabeth Laird elisabeth.laird@gmail.com Residential zones Residential Land use controls
Amend rules [3.3 The conversion of an dwelling into two dwellings] to allow 'existing houses to
be split into 2 flats'.
quality compact urban form Increase extent of Mixed Housing Urban zone especially near the city centre.
Upzone residential and commercial land that is near public transit (railway stations and high
frequency bus routes), especially in Newton, Morningside, Greenlane and Ellerslie.
6520-8 Elisabeth Laird elisabeth.laird@gmail.com Sustainable Development C7.7/H6.4 Sustainable design Amend provisions to require all new houses to meet the Homestar rating.
6520-9 Elisabeth Laird elisabeth.laird@gmail.com Sustainable Development C7.7/H6.4 Sustainable design Amend provisions to require all new commercial buildings to meet the Greenstar rating.
environment
Expand Policies 1 and 2 to ensure developments provide 'activation at street level' and
'pedestrian friendly designs'.
environment
Amend Policy 3 to improve the safety of pedestrian access on footpaths and accessways.
Refer to full submission for details [page 4/8].
environment
Amend Policy 4 to reduce zones that specify the use of buildings and remove the distinction
between residential and business zones while allowing zones, overlays and precincts to be
based on building types. Refer to full submission for details [page 4/8].
environment
Amend Policy 5 to encourage mixed use and changing use of buildings and easy access to
amenities.
environment
Amend Policy 6 to strengthen requirement for good access for pedestrians and those with
disabilities [inferred].
environment
Retain Policy 7 that requires a high standard of design in areas of residential and business
intensification.
environment
Amend Policy 8 to remove constraints which hinder the range of built forms such as minimum
balcony sizes, minimum glazing, minimum setbacks, minimum parking standards and
restrictions on increased density. Refer to full submission for details [page 4/8].
338/1145
Sub#/
environment
Amend Policy 9 to strengthen requirement to provide and maintain pedestrian and bicycle
permeability and to remove use of parking minimums and footpath cuts for driveways
[inferred].
retain affordable housing Amend Policy 1 to allow construction of medium to high density housing on smaller sites.
Retain Policy 2 that requires or encourages a portion of residential developments to contain
affordable housing.
6520-20 Elisabeth Laird elisabeth.laird@gmail.com Transport Auckland -wide C1.2 Objectives
Retain provision that provides for pedestrian and bicycle access and facilities. [Specific
provision not identified]
6520-21 Elisabeth Laird elisabeth.laird@gmail.com Transport Auckland -wide C1.2 Objectives
Retain provision that requires 'parking buildings to have a minimal impact on the surrounding
area and be able to be converted to alternative uses in the future'. [Specific provision not
identified]
6520-22 Elisabeth Laird elisabeth.laird@gmail.com Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
Add provisions that limit the construction of additional parking buildings. Refer to full
submission for details [page 6/8].
6520-23 Elisabeth Laird elisabeth.laird@gmail.com Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
Delete any provisions that require parking minimums except when this is for the 'provision of
disabled parking/access if this cannot be accommodated in the existing on- or off-street
parking or accessways'.
Provide for greater intensification of Single House zone through measures such as reducing
minimum lot sizes, removing or reducing side and front setbacks, removing minimum off
street parking requirements and removing minimum glazing requirements. Refer to full
submission for detail [pages 6-7/8].
Mixed Housing Urban zone Amend [rule 7.2 Building height], to allow up to 3-4 storeys in Mixed Housing Suburban zone.
Mixed Housing Urban zone Amend rule 8.2 Building height, to allow up to 4 storeys in Mixed Housing Urban zone.
6520-27 Elisabeth Laird elisabeth.laird@gmail.com Subdivision Auckland-wide - general
and policies
Retain urban subdivision objectives and policies that require subdivisions to have safe,
convenient and accessible layouts with good connections that support the 'concepts of
liveable, walkable and connected neighbourhoods. [Specific objectives and policies not
identified]
6520-28 Elisabeth Laird elisabeth.laird@gmail.com Subdivision Auckland-wide - general
and policies
Amend provisions relating to small scale urban subdivision to prioritise interaction with the
street and front and rear outlook. Refer to full submission for details [page 7/8]. [Specific
provisions not specified]
6520-29 Elisabeth Laird elisabeth.laird@gmail.com
control
and policies Retain Pre-1944 Building Demolition Control overlay.
6520-30 Elisabeth Laird elisabeth.laird@gmail.com Historic Heritage (Overlay)
Heritage
Retain objective 1 that promotes appropriate use, maintenance repair of historic heritage
places.
Heritage
Strengthen objective 2 to require a sufficient level of maintenance of historic
heritage places to prevent future demolition due to neglect or deterioration.
Heritage
Amend provisions [inferred] to ensure heritage values include 'the structure of areas and
design-based elements' such as street design, lots sizes, density of buildings and quantity of
public spaces, not just historical importance. Ensure new developments within heritage areas
promote these aspects. Refer to full submission for details [pages 7-8/8]. [Specific provisions
not identified]
6520-33 Elisabeth Laird elisabeth.laird@gmail.com Special Character
residential
Amend provisions [inferred] to ensure special character values include 'the structure of areas
and design-based elements' such as street design, lots sizes, density of buildings and
quantity of public spaces, not just historical importance. Ensure new developments within
special character areas promote these aspects. Refer to full submission for details [pages 7-
8/8]. [Specific provisions not identified]
6521-1
GB and JM Morris Farms
Limited graeme@lcc-planning.co.nz Precincts - South Runciman
Retain the Runciman Precinct Plan and Bush Park Concept Plan as the principal techniques
for managing change, subdivision and development of the area contained with the Bush Park
Concept Plan area and/or for the Morris Farms property [9A Bush Road, Karaka].
6521-2
Limited graeme@lcc-planning.co.nz Precincts - South Runciman Retain the Bush Park Concept Plan at [9A Bush Road, Karaka].
6521-3
Limited graeme@lcc-planning.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - general
and policies Retain the text in the second bullet under the subheading 'Rural subdivision'.
6521-4
Amend the precinct to ensure the second bullet point in the introduction to the rural
subdivision provisions in [C6] are reflected in the identification of the
environmental benefits and characteristics of the countryside living zone for bush park.
6521-5
Limited graeme@lcc-planning.co.nz Precincts - South Runciman Retain Objective 1.
339/1145
Sub#/
6521-6
Amend the precinct to ensure the policies and rules are robust and simple and incorporate the
Bush Park Concept plan as the principal technique for determining where buildings may be
located and the open space to be retained.
6521-7
6521-8
6521-9
and policies Retain Policy 27(b).
6521-10
6521-11
Limited graeme@lcc-planning.co.nz Rural Zones
desc, obs & pols
Amend the countryside living zone provisions to ensure that there are areas that are
dedicated for lifestyle housing and ad hoc scattering of housing does not compromise
productive potential of highly versatile land or lead to uneconomic extension of roads and
services.
6521-12
Amend precinct to ensure that the Morris Farms Land [9A Bush Road, Karaka] is identified as
a receiver area for transferable development rights.
6521-13
6521-14
Amend the precinct to give effect to Policy 34 of the subdivision provisions [C6] by
recognising that the Development Areas shown in the Bush Park Concept Plan are the
primary means of this policy's implementation.
6521-15
Amend the Activity Table so subdivision is a controlled activity if the density standards and
building site controls are met.
6521-16
Amend precinct to ensure it reflects the Countryside Living zone general zone description and
it is not embellished with additional purposes.
6521-17
desc, obs & pols Retain Objectives 1-6.
6521-18
Amend precinct by incorporating the range of environmental qualities into the concept plans
and remove reference to ecological or riparian planting.
6521-19
Amend the precinct to ensure that in the bush park the primary considerations are that
buildings are located in identified areas and open space is retained.
6521-20
Amend the precinct to ensure the primary focus reflects Policy 7 of the Countryside Living
zone provisions [in D6.6].
6521-21
desc, obs & pols
Amend Policy 1(g) to encourage built form to fit in with the topography, taking advantage of
sites that avoid unnecessary earthworks and to avoid artificially contrived clustering, or
remove the term clustering altogether, in preference for identifying location of buildings within
development areas.
6521-22
Amend the precinct to remove reference to clustering or that within the Bush Park Area within
Precinct A or B the clustering method for managing development will be by way of a concept
plan identifying areas where buildings are to be located.
6521-23
Limited graeme@lcc-planning.co.nz Precincts - South Runciman Amend the precinct by providing for transferable development rights in the Bush Park area.
6521-24
Amend reference on the planning maps for the precinct so they align with the sub-precinct text
in the rules.
6521-25
Replace the precinct plans with those in the Environment Court Consent Order as outlined in
6521-26
Amend precinct plan 5 to be named the 'Bush Park Concept Plan Development Area' and add
the areas confirmed by the Environment Court Consent Order on page 2/10 of the
submission.
6521-27
Limited graeme@lcc-planning.co.nz Precincts - South Runciman Delete Objective 4.
6521-28
Delete Policy 2(d) as far as it applies to the Bush Park Concept Area which has provided for
clustering.
6521-29
Amend precinct to ensure that the primary means for achieving Policies 1, 2(a)-(c) are the
Bush Park Concept Plan.
6521-30
Limited graeme@lcc-planning.co.nz Precincts - South Runciman Delete Policy 2(j).
6521-31
Add a new policy to provide for Bush Park to as a receiver environment for transferable rural
site subdivision rights.
6521-32
Amend Policy 6 to provide enhancement of ecological values by way of riparian planting to
provide shade for identified streams where there is not shade within the Bush Park area.
6521-33
Amend the precinct rules with the Environment Court Consent Order as outlined on page 2/10
of the submission.
340/1145
Sub#/
6521-34
Amend the Bush Park Concept Plan to ensure that subdivision is a controlled activity with
matters of control.
6521-35
Limited graeme@lcc-planning.co.nz Precincts - South Runciman Amend the precinct to remove reference to clustering and all rules relating to clustering.
6521-36
Amend the precinct to remove requirements for setbacks from Tuhimata and Runciman
Roads.
6521-37
Amend precinct rules so the maximum density is no greater than 1 lot per 2.0ha of gross site
area.
6521-38
Amend the precinct so the density is reduced to 1 lot per 1.5ha gross floor area
to accommodate transferable lots.
6521-39
Amend the precinct by deleting the requirement for separation distances between clusters or
specified building areas.
6521-40
Limited graeme@lcc-planning.co.nz Precincts - South Runciman Amend the precinct to delete reference to 'significant' environmental benefits.
6521-41
Amend [rule 3.2(5)] and associated table to provide for a 10m wide riparian corridor on
streams identified in map 110A, only where planting is already in place. No riparian planting is
required where there is existing vegetation or mature planting is in place adjacent to identified
streams or located in the near vicinity and providing shade.
6521-42
Amend the Precinct Plan 4 Riparian Corridors with the one included in the Environment Court
Consent Order as outlined on page 2/10 of the submission as so far as it applies to the Bush
Park Concept Plan area.
6521-43
Amend Precinct Plan 5 Bush Park Concept Plan Development Areas to retain the existing
development areas and include additional development areas contained on Map 110E.
6521-44
Amend the Precinct Plans, Sub-Precinct Plans and Bush Park Concept Plans Area to provide
greater clarity and better scale to determine detail relative to the topography and property
boundaries. In particular each of the Precinct Plans relevant to the Bush Park component of
the sub precinct in a separate series of maps to provide better clarity and precision.
6522-1
Pohutukawa Property
Development Company
Limited biancahartley@tnp.co.nz Zoning North and Islands
Rezone 46 Gilbransen Road and 217 Matua Road, Huapai (Western and Southern areas)
from Large Lot to Single House. See submission for map of the area [page 4/15 of the
submission].
6522-2
Pohutukawa Property
Development Company
Limited biancahartley@tnp.co.nz Precincts - North Huapai North
Delete Sub-precinct C from 46 Gilbransen Road and 217 Matua Road, Huapai and replace
with Sub-precinct B.
6522-3
Pohutukawa Property
Development Company
Limited biancahartley@tnp.co.nz Precincts - North Huapai North
Amend Subdivision control 5.2 'Site size and shape factor' Table 6 to confirm and clarify that
site size variation up to 15% above or below the site size specified for the Single House zone
is a restricted discretionary activity within sub-precinct B or sub-precinct C. See submission
for specific amendment [page 9/15 of the submission].
6523-1
Federated Farmers of New
Zealand rgardner@fedfarm.org.nz General Miscellaneous Other
Delete section 32 evaluation for the PAUP and carry out further evaluation as provided for in
section 32AA of the RMA.
6523-2
Zealand rgardner@fedfarm.org.nz General Chapter A Introduction A1 Background Remove the Mayors Foreword.
6523-3
Zealand rgardner@fedfarm.org.nz General Chapter A Introduction A1 Background
Amend 1.6 'Our Economy', third sentence, second paragraph as follows: Fruit, vegetables,
livestock dairy products, meat, fibre and forestry supply our export market.
6523-4
Zealand rgardner@fedfarm.org.nz General Chapter A Introduction A2 Statutory Framework
Add to 2.2 Treaty of Waitangi / Te Tiriti o Waitangi, a statement that: In making decisions
under the RMA, decision makers are required to achieve an overall balance of all the matters
in Part 2 of the RMA, including those discussed above.
6523-5
Add to 2.2 Treaty of Waitangi / Te Tiriti o Waitangi, more detail of how ancestral lands, water,
sites, Whi tapu and other taonga should be identified, and detail of the particular resource
management activities over which Mana Whenua seek greater participation in decision-
making.
6523-6
Add to 2.2 Treaty of Waitangi / Te Tiriti o Waitangi, more detail of how the Treaty Principles
are relevant to the Unitary Plan, and in particular how the principle of redress is to be taken
into account in the Unitary Plan.
6523-7
Zealand rgardner@fedfarm.org.nz General Chapter A Introduction A3 Strategic Framework
Amend 3.3 Sustainable management, second and third paragraphs to reflect section 5 of the
RMA, in particular the purpose of promoting sustainable management of resources requires
an overall broad judgement of potentially conflicting considerations. Refer submission for
detail [pg. 11/89].
6523-8
Amend 3.3 Sustainable management, fifth paragraph as follows: ...been degraded and in
some cases seeks their restoration and enhancement.
6523-9
Amend 3.5 Responding to climate change, as follows: ...Over time climate change will may
affect biodiversity... Auckland's built form will may need to respond to different
environmental...
341/1145
Sub#/
6523-10
Amend 3.5 Responding to climate change, third paragraph a statement that: Forestry is a
method by which the effect of greenhouse gas emissions may be mitigated.
6523-11
Zealand rgardner@fedfarm.org.nz RPS Issues New Issues
Add an issue enabling growth in the rural areas of the region, along the lines described in
the Auckland Plan.
6523-12
Zealand rgardner@fedfarm.org.nz RPS Issues
wellbeing
Clarify under "Rural and coastal economy" that most of the freshwater, biodiversity and
cultural heritage is in rural areas because the majority of Auckland is rural by amending as
follows: By virtue of the fact that rural areas make up 80% of Auckland by land area, R rural
areas contain most of the regions freshwater resources, the largest remaining biodiversity in
the region and most places of cultural heritage values significant to Mana Whenua.
6523-13
Delete all the statements that follow the first sentence of the Issue statement and, if
appropriate, recast them as an objective in the appropriate part of the Plan.
6523-14
Clarify "Decision-making, environmental governance, partnerships and participation" the term
environmental governance in a way that maintains the democratic processes for decisions
in resource management matters, or remove the term from the Unitary Plan.
6523-15
Add to the first paragraph of "Mana Whenua relationship to Aucklands natural
environment", examples of ways in which Mana Whenua see the mauri of Aucklands
biodiversity and natural resources being maintained, enhanced or restored, given the current
uses to which the land is being put, or remove the statement from the Unitary Plan.
6523-16
our natural resources Remove the entire statement concerning GMOs.
6523-17
change
Amend Mitigation by adding: Forestry is a method by which the effect of greenhouse gas
emissions may be mitigated.
6523-18
Zealand rgardner@fedfarm.org.nz RPS
Transport
B3.1 Commercial and
industrial growth
Amend the second sentence of the Introduction to read: Commercial and industrial activities
and rurally based enterprises are key drivers providing employment and business
opportunities, and for meeting demands for economic and social wellbeing associated with
population growth.
6523-19
Transport
B3.1 Commercial and
industrial growth Add an Objective: "Rurally based growth is enabled."
6523-20
Transport
B3.1 Commercial and
industrial growth
Add a Policy: "Where appropriate, activities and enterprises based on rural resources are to
be enabled."
6523-21
Review sections 4.3.1 and 4.3.2 to remove the doubling-counting of components such as
landform.
6523-22
features
Add to the explanation and reasons a statement which makes it consistent with the
Introduction, that some ONLs are within working environments and that the Unitary Plan sets
out a management response enabling the productive use of these areas to continue and
change in a way that supports their landscape values.
6523-23
features
Amend the objectives and policies to enable the productive use of ONLs to continue and
change in a way that supports their landscape values.
6523-24
features
Amend Policy 10 to read: Require activities to avoid adverse effects on outstanding natural
features by avoiding, where practicable:
6523-25
B4.3.5 Waitakere Ranges
Heritage Area
Amend the objectives and policies to clarify that the use of land for productive purposes is
anticipated in the heritage area.
6523-26
Zealand rgardner@fedfarm.org.nz RPS Natural resources
Organisms
Remove all provisions related to Genetically Modified Organisms from the PAUP including the
discussion, objectives, policies methods and other references.
6523-27
Zealand rgardner@fedfarm.org.nz RPS Coastal B7 Introduction
Correct Figure 1 - Extent of the coastal environment, so that it shows that that the beach and
the reach of the tide can extend inland well beyond MHWS.
6523-28
Zealand rgardner@fedfarm.org.nz RPS Coastal
quality
Amend to better reflect the strategy for implementing the National Policy Statement
Freshwater Management in the region as described in 5.15.1 Water quality and integrated
management of the PAUP.
6523-29
Zealand rgardner@fedfarm.org.nz RPS Rural B8.1 Rural activities
Amend Policy 9 to read: Protect and manage the natural character of the coastal
environment, wetlands, lakes, rivers and their margins, ONLs and indigenous biodiversity in
rural areas, while avoiding Avoid increases in scattered rural lifestyle lots.
6523-30
Zealand rgardner@fedfarm.org.nz RPS Rural
potential
Amend Policy 5 as follows: Encourage land management practices that retain the
physical and chemical capability of high quality soils.
6523-31
Zealand rgardner@fedfarm.org.nz RPS Rural
potential
Amend policy 6 as follows: Support the allocation of water to areas of elite and prime land and
to the areas of non soil dependent horticulture rural production.
342/1145
Sub#/
6523-32
Zealand rgardner@fedfarm.org.nz RPS Rural B8.3 Rural subdivision
Provide for greater subdivision opportunities in rural areas to provide for: estate planning; the
viability of small rural communities; rural lifestyle living outside of countryside living areas
(while including no compliance covenants); the subdivision of uneconomic farm land;
environmental or bush block protection; 25ha fee simple subdivision in line with the Auckland
District Plan: Hauraki Gulf Islands Section. Refer submission for detail [pg.24-26/89].
6523-33
Zealand rgardner@fedfarm.org.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - general
and policies
Amend Policy 3(c) to enable subdivision for rural production purposes in line with the
Regional Policy Statement.
6523-34
Zealand rgardner@fedfarm.org.nz RPS Climate change
Add in the Introduction or Explanation and reasons: "Forestry is a method by which
greenhouse gas emissions may be mitigated, by acting as a carbon sink and offering carbon
sequestration opportunities."
6523-35
Zealand rgardner@fedfarm.org.nz General Miscellaneous Other Integrate the management of the Kaipara Harbour into a single body.
6523-36
Zealand rgardner@fedfarm.org.nz RPS General
Amend the objective and the Environment Results Anticipated in the last row Table 3 'Historic
heritage, special character and natural heritage', [The quality and diversity of landscapes are
maintained by: ... c. managing change within a landscape in an integrated way, including
retaining a rural character] so that they are able to be understood by lay persons.
6523-37
Zealand rgardner@fedfarm.org.nz General Chapter A Introduction
DP provisions
Amend the PAUP to clearly distinguish between the provisions that form part of the regional
plan and those that form part of the district plan.
6523-38
Zealand rgardner@fedfarm.org.nz Air Quality
6523-39
Zealand rgardner@fedfarm.org.nz Earthworks
and policies Retain the objectives and policies
6523-40
Zealand rgardner@fedfarm.org.nz
SEAs
and policies Retain the objectives and policies for vegetation management.
6523-41
Zealand rgardner@fedfarm.org.nz Mineral extraction
C5.4 Mineral extraction from
land - background, objectives
and policies
Amend Policy 4 to read: Where the extracted minerals are to be removed from the site, R
require a quarry management plan to be prepared to address operational matters associated
with mineral extraction, including management of adverse effects and actions to remedy,
mitigate or offset these effects.
6523-42
and policies
Retain the objectives and policies to the extent that they relate to farm quarries and extraction
operations, except Policy 4 where specific amendments are sought.
6523-43
managed fill
Add a new policy to read: avoiding the establishment of cleanfills, managed fills or landfills in
locations where the traffic effects generated will have a significant adverse effect on the
environment. [C5.5 Background, objectives and policies]
6523-44
Rural Discharges,
Add a paragraph to the Introduction [in C5.8]: There is a perception, particularly in overseas
markets, that counts against the use of biosolids as a fertiliser in agricultural or horticultural
production. There is also sufficient doubt about the wisdom of such reuse of sewage and
sewage solids that their use on or on land used for food production should not be
contemplated.
6523-45
Rural Discharges,
Biosolids C5.8/H4.7 Biosolids Retain the objective and policies [in C5.8].
6523-46
Rural Discharges,
Biosolids
Vertebrate Toxic Agents Retain the objectives and policies [under C5.10].
6523-47
Rural Discharges,
Biosolids
Discharges
Amend Policy 4, to read: Where practicable, Aavoid the discharge of contaminants generated
from rural production activities directly into water bodies and artificial watercourses.
6523-48
Rural Discharges,
Biosolids
Discharges
Amend Policy 5(g), to read: (Enable discharges to land that could run overland into water
where ) there is no offensive or objectionable odour or dust beyond the boundary of the
property where the contaminants are being discharged, where the adjacent property is used
for residential purposes.
6523-49
Rural Discharges,
Biosolids
Discharges
Retain the objectives and policies except for Policy 4 and 5(g) where specific amendments
are sought.
6523-50
Zealand rgardner@fedfarm.org.nz Natural Hazards and Flooding Flooding
and policies
Add to the Background: The Plan recognises that certain rural activities, such as pasture
development, fencing, etc, are appropriate in areas subject to natural hazards / flooding.
6523-51
Zealand rgardner@fedfarm.org.nz Water
streams & wetland
C5.14 Background &
Objectives
Amend the Background to read: ... Offsets will may only be considered after avoidance,
remediation and mitigation options have been pursued where this better promotes the
purpose of the RMA.
343/1145
Sub#/
6523-52
streams & wetland
C5.14 Background &
Objectives
Amend Objective 3 as follows: Adverse effects on lakes, rivers, streams or wetlands that
cannot be avoided, remedied or mitigated are may be offset in exceptional circumstances ,
where this will better promote the purpose of the RMA.
6523-53
streams & wetland
Stock Access
Amend Policy 2(b) [managing the effects of activities on lakes rivers and streams outside of
management areas] as follows: where appropriate, restoring and enhancing the lake, river,
stream or wetland, including by providing for the clearance of channels for flood prevention
purposes.
6523-54
policies
Amend Table 1, Macroinvertebrate Community Index (MCI) guidelines for Auckland rivers and
streams by setting the interim MCI guideline value to 80 across the region, increasing it by 1
each year.
6523-55
policies
ecosystem guidelines App.5.6 Delete Policy 3.
6523-56
Objectives Retain the objectives and policies.
6523-57
Zealand rgardner@fedfarm.org.nz Water Wastewater
objectives & policies Retain the objectives and policies.
6523-58
organisms
modified organisms Remove all references to GMOs.
6523-59
Zealand rgardner@fedfarm.org.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - Rural zones
area
Amend to provide for: estate planning; the viability of small rural communities; rural lifestyle
living outside of countryside living areas (while including no compliance covenants); the
subdivision of uneconomic farm land; environmental or bush block protection; 25ha fee simple
subdivision in line with the Auckland District Plan: Hauraki Gulf Islands Section. Refer
submission for detail [pg.24-26/89]
6523-60
and policies
Amend Objective 9 as follows: The demand for rural lifestyle subdivision is directed mainly to
Countryside Living zones
6523-61
and policies
Amend Policy 37 as follows: Require esplanade reserves on the subdivided land adjoining the
coast and other qualifying water-bodies only in locations where there is a demonstrable
demand for access to the coast.
6523-62
Zealand rgardner@fedfarm.org.nz Rural Zones General
Amend the name of the Rural Coastal Zone to Rural Coastal Production Zone and the name
of the Rural Production Zone to Rural Inland Production Zone to better reflect the objectives
of the zones.
6523-63
Zealand rgardner@fedfarm.org.nz Rural Zones General
objectives & policies Retain the objectives and policies.
6523-64
Zealand rgardner@fedfarm.org.nz Rural Zones
desc, obs & pols Retain the objectives and policies.
6523-65
obs & pols Retain the objectives and policies.
6523-66
Zealand rgardner@fedfarm.org.nz Zoning South
Amend the Rural Coastal zone in the former Franklin District to reflect the zone boundaries
agreed as part of the Franklin Plan Change 14 process.
6523-67
Zealand rgardner@fedfarm.org.nz Zoning North and Islands
Amend the Rural Coastal zone boundaries in the former Rodney District, using criteria that
are similar to those in the former Franklin District.
6523-68
obs & pols
Amend the proposed policies enabling the continuation of activities associated with on-going
primary production, while applying additional restrictions on activities associated with the
subdivision of primary production land for residential type development. This is reflected in
Policy 6.4.22(6) of Proposed Change 8 to the Auckland Regional Policy Statement (Auckland
Council Revised Position June 2012 Version).
6523-69
obs & pols
Amend to have regard to the matters in the Auckland Plan related to the continued viability of
rural communities. Refer submission for detail [pg. 41/89].
6523-70
obs & pols
Amend Objective 3 as follows: Buildings not associated with rural production activities do not
dominate and are unobtrusive with the high natural character, landscape, biological and
ecological values of the zone.
6523-71
obs & pols
Amend Objective 4 to take provide for subdivision opportunities for: estate planning; the
(while including no compliance covenants);and the subdivision of uneconomic farm land.
6523-72
obs & pols Retain Policy 2.
6523-73
obs & pols
Amend Policy 3 as follows: Provide for the continued operation of forestry, including
harvesting and replanting, in existing forest areas, but require evaluation of new forestry
proposals in Natural Character, ONL and SEAs identified on the overlay maps and in other
areas that are used for primary production purposes.
6523-74
desc, obs & pols
Amend Objective 3 and Policy 3 to provide for the expansion of established rural activities
and the establishment of new rural activities in the zone.
344/1145
Sub#/
6523-75
desc, obs & pols
Amend Policy 3 as follows: Prevent subdivision and development from compromising the safe
and efficient operation of existing rural activities or industry, including by ensuring there are
adequate buffer zones to prevent reverse sensitivity effects from arising.
6523-76
Zealand rgardner@fedfarm.org.nz Infrastructure
Transmission Corridor
and policies
Retain the provisions as a whole, except for paragraph two of the Description and and Policy
1(a) where specific amendments are sought.
6523-77
and policies
Amend the paragraph two of the Description to read: Under the National Policy Statement on
Electricity Transmission 2008, the council is required to consult with Transpower New Zealand
Limited to identify and provide a buffer corridor below and around high voltage transmission
lines and transmission towers/poles. The Council may provide for this buffer corridor in the
Unitary Plan. These lines and tower/poles are owned and operated by Transpower New
Zealand Limited and form part of the national electricity grid.
6523-78
and policies
Delete Policy 1(a) [Requirement for subdivision, land use and development to meet the New
Zealand Electrical Code of Practice for Electrical Safe Distances (NZECP 34: 2001)].
6523-79
Buffer Area
Insert a paragraph into the Description [under E1.6] , along the lines: Where practicable,
these buffer zones will be provided within the same site as that in which the quarry is situated.

6523-80
Zealand rgardner@fedfarm.org.nz General Chapter G General provisions
Amend Rule 1.4 [Applying for a resource consent] as follows: All resource consent application
under s. 88 (2) must be in the prescribed form and manner and include an assessment of
environmental effects in such detail as corresponds with the scale and significance of the
effects that the activity may have on the environment, in accordance with Schedule 4 of the
RMA.;
6523-81
Zealand rgardner@fedfarm.org.nz Mana Whenua General provisions
assessment Remove Section 2.7.4, Cultural impact assessment.
6523-82
Zealand rgardner@fedfarm.org.nz Mana Whenua General provisions
assessment
Undertake a proper preliminary plan preparation process to evaluate the appropriateness of
including provisions relating to matters that are of significance or value to Mana Whenua, and,
if found to be appropriate, promulgate them again by way of a plan variation or plan change.
6523-83
Zealand rgardner@fedfarm.org.nz Natural Hazards and Flooding Natural Hazards
G2.7.5 Information
requirements
Amend paragraph 1 as follows :An application for any activity must be accompanied by a
report by a suitably qualified engineer which:
6523-84
Energy
tables
Amend Paragraph 1 as follows:...These rules do not apply to airports, ports, lighthouses,
navigation aids and beacons, and networks confined within individual farms, which are
addressed in the relevant zone rules.
6523-85
Zealand rgardner@fedfarm.org.nz Air Quality
and policies
Amend Policy 1(a) as follows: Production or blending of fertilisers on an industrial scale,
including the granulation of single or mixed fertilizers;
6523-86
Zealand rgardner@fedfarm.org.nz Earthworks H4.2.1.1 Activity table - Zones
Retain the thresholds and limits, as they apply in the rural zones, for the Activity General
earthworks not expressly either permitted or requiring resource consent above in this table.
6523-87
Zealand rgardner@fedfarm.org.nz Earthworks
Overlays
Amend the Activity Works below the natural ground level to permit works that are normal
farming activities such as land drainage works in the overlay areas.
6523-88
SEAs
table - Vegetation
roads
Amend the rural rule that requires a resource consent for the removal of vegetation in patches
grater than 1ha in rural zones other than the rural conservation zone to increase the slope of
land that the rules applies from 15 to 20 degrees.
6523-89
Zealand rgardner@fedfarm.org.nz Definitions Existing
Amend the definition of vegetation alteration or removal as follows: Damaging, cutting,
destroying or removing any part of protected vegetation including roots. Includes: tree
alteration; tree removal. Excludes:the alteration or removal of vegetation planted as crop,
garden or pasture.; pest plant removal; In rural zones, the alteration or removal of any
vegetation that is less than 20 years old.
6523-90
SEAs
table - Vegetation
roads
Amend all the entries in the riparian section of the table as follows: Vegetation alteration or
removal of more than 25m2 of contiguous vegetation within
6523-91
SEAs
table - Vegetation
roads
Amend the riparian setback distance from all water bodies and Mean High Water Springs in
rural areas to be 10m.
6523-92
Amend the definition of emergency tree works as follows: The alteration or removal of any
tree or vegetation immediately necessary to avoid any actual and imminent threat to the
safety of persons or animals or damage to property or to maintain or restore utility services.
6523-93
character and natural heritage B4.3.4 Biodiversity Amend the maps to delete the areas that do not meet criteria for Significant Ecological Areas.
345/1145
Sub#/
6523-94
SEAs
table - Vegetation
roads
Amend the distances around buildings in rural areas that vegetation can be cleared or
trimmed by increasing them as following: Vegetation alteration or removal for routine
maintenance within 3m in urban zones and within 20m in rural zonesof existing dwelling;
Vegetation alteration or removal for routine; maintenance within 3m in urban zones and within
20m in rural zones of existing buildings greater than 100m2 GFA; Tree trimming within 10m in
urban zones and within 50m in rural zonesof existing buildings.
6523-95
Amend the definition of emergency tree works as follows: The alteration or removal of any
tree or vegetation immediately necessary to avoid any actual and imminent threat to the
safety of persons or animals or damage to property (including farmed animals) or to maintain
or restore utility services.
6523-96
SEAs
Add a matter for discretion as follows: "the applicants need for a practicable site for farming
purposes".
6523-97
Amend to provide for the on-farm storage of sufficient quantities of fuels, fertilisers and
agrichemicals as is appropriate for normal on- farm use as permitted activities.
6523-98
Rural Discharges,
Retain Permitted Activity Control H4.7.2.1(2) [The application must not be to land used for
food production or residential activities].
6523-99
Rural Discharges,
Biosolids
Amend Control H4.9.2.2.1(c) as follows: where specified, being suitably qualified or
accredited through any relevant quality assurance systems such as GROWSAFE and
AIRCARE.
6523-
100
Rural Discharges,
Biosolids
Discharges
Amend the activity status of discharging treated dairy effluent to water from Discretionary to
6523-
101
Rural Discharges,
Biosolids
Discharges
Amend Control 2.1.1(1) as follows: There must be no discharge or runoff to water bodies or
water in artificial watercourses.
6523-
102
Rural Discharges,
Biosolids
Discharges
Amend Control 2.1.1(3) as follows: The application rate of nitrogen from any combination of
dairy effluent, nitrogenous fertiliser and other nitrogen discharges from the other rural
production activities, but not including nitrogen from non-point source discharges such as
emissions of dung and urine from farm animals, must not:...
6523-
103
Rural Discharges,
Biosolids
Discharges
Amend Control 2.1.2(1) as follows: All new and modified feedpads and permanent standoff
pads must be sealed and the permeability of the sealing layer must not exceed 1x10-9m/s....

6523-
104
Rural Discharges,
Biosolids
Discharges
Amend Control 2.1.2(1) as follows: ...Other than when a liner is used, T the permeability must
be certified by a chartered professional engineer holding a current practicing certificate and
provided to the council on request.
6523-
105
Rural Discharges,
Biosolids
Discharges
Amend Control 2.1.3(3) as follows: The storage, use and disposal of fertiliser must be in
accordance with the New Zealand Fertiliser Manufacturers Research Associations Code of
Practice for Nutrient Management (2007).
6523-
106
Rural Discharges,
Biosolids
Discharges
Amend Control 2.1.4.(3) to remove offal holes and offal trenches and include a new control
specifically for offal holes and trenches by amending the provisions as follows: 3. Silage
storage facilities, offal holes and offal trenches must not be located within: a. 20m of a surface
water body, floodplain or CMA; 4. Offal holes and offal trenches must not be located within: a.
20m of a surface water body, floodplain or CMA.
6523-
107
Rural Discharges,
Biosolids
Discharges
Amend Control 2.1.4(4) as follows: All silage leachate must be collected and directed into an
effluent storage system or diluted and directly applied to land disposed of in manner that
meets permitted activity controls, including by directing it into an effluent storage system or
diluting it and applying it directly to land.
6523-
108
Rural Discharges,
Biosolids
Discharges
Amend the activity table to provide a permitted activity for accidental discharges as
follows: "Discharges that occur which are not in compliance with the provisions in the rural
production discharges activity table and the associated controls are permitted provided: a. the
adverse effects on the environment are no more than minor; b. the discharge event is
reported to the Council within 24 hours of it occurring; c. no other discharge that is not in
compliance with the provisions in the rural production discharges activity table and the
associated controls has taken place on the site at any time within the preceding 3 months."
6523-
109
Zealand rgardner@fedfarm.org.nz Natural Hazards and Flooding Natural Hazards H4.11.1 Activity table
Add a new permitted activity under "Development - general" as follows: "Buildings and other
structures accessory to farming on land which may be subject to natural hazards."
6523-
110
streams & wetland
table
Add a new permitted activity as follows: "Channel clearance more than 100m on rivers, where
the bed of the river is greater than 2m in width." subject to controls that: make the total
distance inclusive of clearance in the Coastal Marine Area and enables only half the width of
the bed to be disturbed within two months of the other side being disturbed at any one point.
Refer to submission for details [pg. 64/89].
346/1145
Sub#/
6523-
111
streams & wetland
table Retain the Permitted activity for Emergency Works.
6523-
112
Zealand rgardner@fedfarm.org.nz Definitions New
Add a definition of "emergency works" for the purpose of clarifying the use of the term in
activity table for lakes, rivers, streams and wetlands [H4.13] and elsewhere
6523-
113
Amend the definition of "Pest plant removal" as follows: "The alteration or removal of any tree
or vegetation listed as a plant pest Total Control Pest Plants, Containment Pest Plants,
Surveillance Pest Plants or Community Initiative Pest Plants within the Auckland Regional
Plant Pest Management Strategy, or as a plant pest within the Department of Conservation
Pest Plants List or the National Pest Plant Accord (excluding research organisms) under the
Biosecurity Act 1993."
6523-
114
streams & wetland
Amend Permitted activity control for "Livestock access" to specifically exclude the controls
from applying to sheep farming, ephemeral reaches of streams and to enable the grazing of
riparian margins for weed control purposes. Refer submissions for detail [pg. 67/89].
6523-
115
Zealand rgardner@fedfarm.org.nz Water Stormwater
rules
Amend the provision relating to impervious areas in rural areas as follows: New impervious
areas in a rural area, including rural zones, open space zones and special purpose zones
outside the RUB where the impervious area, excluding sealed and compacted metal roads, is
less than or equal to 5,000m
2
and which does not increase the total impervious area of the
site, excluding sealed and compacted metal roads, to more than 5,000m
2
.
6523-
116
Zealand rgardner@fedfarm.org.nz Water Wastewater H4.15 Onsite wastewater rules
Amend Permitted activity control 2.1.1(3) as follows: Other than in rural zones (except the
Countryside Living Zone), T the wastewater treatment system must be maintained by a
contracted service provider in accordance with ...
6523-
117
table
Amend the Permitted activities for surface water takes: to reduce the permitted take from
lakes from 20m
3
to 15m
3
and increase the permitted takes from rivers or springs; and lawfully
established on-stream dams from 5m
3
to 15m
3
.
6523-
118
table
Amend the activity status of all surface water takes that are not Permitted activities from
Discretionary or Restricted Discretionary to Controlled.
6523-
119
organisms
modified organisms Remove the entire section.
6523-
120
zones only
Provide for greater subdivision opportunities in rural areas to provide for: estate planning; the
(while including no compliance covenants); the subdivision of uneconomic farm land;
environmental or bush block protection; 25ha fee simple subdivision in line with the Auckland
District Plan: Hauraki Gulf Islands Section. Refer submission for detail [pg.24-26/89].
6523-
121
controls
Amend General Control 6 (a) requiring esplanade reserves as follows: Where there is a
demonstrated demand for access to the coast, and W where any subdivision, including the
creation of a site of 4ha or more, is proposed of land adjoining the MHWS
6523-
122
zones only
Amend the activity status of boundary relocations that comply with all the applicable controls
from Discretionary to Restricted Discretionary.
6523-
123
zones only
Amend the activity status of boundary ajustments that comply with all the applicable controls
from Discretionary to Restricted Discretionary.
6523-
124
area Delete Control 7(b)(1) [10% of original site area limit on boundary adjustments].
6523-
125
area
Delete Control 7(b)(2) [sites must be comprised of Certificates of Title that existed on the date
of notification of the PAUP].
6523-
126
area
Delete control 9(a) [150ha minimum site area for subdivision in the Mixed Rural and Rural
Production Zones].
6523-
127
Zealand rgardner@fedfarm.org.nz General Noise and vibration H6.2 Rules Retain Controls 1.1.5-7 [noise within rural zones].
6523-
128
the CMA
Amend the activity Reclamation or drainage: carried out as part of rehabilitation or remedial
works; or where it is required for the safe and efficient operation or construction of significant
infrastructure to permit reclamation or drainage for the maintenance and repair of existing
drainage systems in the General Coastal Marine Zone, and make it a Controlled activity in the
other coastal zones and overlays.
6523-
129
the CMA
Amend the Activity Table to provide for waterway clearance in the General Coastal Marine
and SEA-M2 zones a Permitted activity, and make it Restricted Discretionary in other coastal
zones.
347/1145
Sub#/
6523-
130
the CMA
Amend the activity status of "Livestock access in the CMA (other than for droving and horse
riding) seven years after the date of plan notification for the General Coastal Marine zone and
five years after plan notification for SEA-M2 and ONF-A1 and A)" from Prohibited to
6523-
131
Zealand rgardner@fedfarm.org.nz RPS Natural resources
B6.3 Freshwater and
Geothermal Water
Work pro-actively with affected landowners to jointly develop ways in which to prevent stock
access to the CMA, including by providing compensation in appropriate cases.
6523-
132
Zealand rgardner@fedfarm.org.nz Rural Zones General I13.1 Activity table
Amend the activity status of dwellings in the Pakiri, Whangateau to Waiwera, Kaipara South
Head and harbour to Muriwai to Te Hunga coastal areas from Restricted Discretionary to
Permitted.
6523-
133
Zealand rgardner@fedfarm.org.nz Rural Zones General I13.1 Activity table
Amend to permit visitor accommodation of up to 10 guests in the Rural Production, Mixed
Rural and Rural Coastal Zones and provide for other visitor accommodation to be no more
than a restricted discretionary activity in those zones.
6523-
134
Zealand rgardner@fedfarm.org.nz Rural Zones General I13.2 Land use controls
Amend the setback for intensive farming and effluent disposal systems from 250m to 50m
from any dwellings on other sites and from 100m to 20m from site boundaries.
6523-
135
Zealand rgardner@fedfarm.org.nz Rural Zones General I13.2 Land use controls
Amend to permit the same number of dwellings in the Pakiri, Whangateau to Waiwera,
Kaipara South Head and harbour to Muriwai to Te Hunga coastal areas as in the rest of the
Rural Coastal zone [permitting one dwelling per site, two dwellings on sites larger than 40ha,
three dwellings on sites larger than 100ha].
6523-
136
Zealand rgardner@fedfarm.org.nz Rural Zones General I13.3 Development controls
Delete the height restrictions on Other accessory buildings in the Rural Coastal, Mixed Rural
and Rural Production zones.
6523-
137
Transmission Corridor J1.4 Rules and mapping Retain the provisions.
6523-
138
Buffer Area
Add new assessment criteria as follows: "Whether the quarry operator has taken all
reasonable steps possible to provide a buffer zone within the same site as that in which the
quarry is situated." [J6.1.3]
6523-
139
Zealand rgardner@fedfarm.org.nz Historic Heritage (Overlay)
Heritage
sites or features
Add a new Permitted activity as follows: "Grazing of cattle and other farmed animals between
1 October and 31 March of any two consecutive years."
6523-
140
Zealand rgardner@fedfarm.org.nz Historic Heritage (Overlay)
Heritage
sites or features Add a new Permitted activity as follows: "Regrassing by direct drilling or no-tillage methods."
6523-
141
Zealand rgardner@fedfarm.org.nz Mana Whenua
Whenua J5.1 Rules Delete the entire section.
6523-
142
Zealand rgardner@fedfarm.org.nz Mana Whenua
Whenua J5.2 Rules Delete the entire section.
6523-
143
Add a new activity with the same activity status as "Grazing of sheep and goats" as follows:
"Grazing of cattle and other farmed animals between 1 October and 31 March of any two
consecutive years." [J6.1.1 Activity Table]
6523-
144
Add a new activity with the same activity status as "Fences - post and wire" as follows:
"Regrassing by direct drilling or no-tillage method". [J6.1.1 Activity Table]
6523-
145
Outstanding Natural
Rules
Notification
Permit production forestry over 2ha, or at least farm forestry, in HNC and ONL areas with a
sugested setback distance of 30m from lakes and wetlands.
6523-
146
Zealand rgardner@fedfarm.org.nz Definitions
Abbreviation and Acronyms Nest "forestry" and, or at least, "farm forestry", within the definition of "farming".
6523-
147
Amend the definition of "agrichemicals" by replacing the word standard" with the word
"definition".
6523-
148
Zealand rgardner@fedfarm.org.nz Definitions Existing Amend the definition of Airport to exclude "farm airstrips".
6523-
149
Amend the definition of animal feedlots as follows: ... Excludes: concentrated but temporary
wintering of stock as part of normal farming operations, including on feedpads and standoff
pads.
6523-
150
Amend the definition of "Application Area" as follows: The site or sites or part or parts thereof
that are the subject of a resource consent application.
6523-
151
Amend the definition of "artificial watercourse" to include canals that supply water to electricity
power generation plants, farm drainage canals, irrigation canals and water supply races.
348/1145
Sub#/
6523-
152
Amend the definition of "channel clearance" as follows: ... Excludes: Mangrove removal, other
than mangroves in channels.
6523-
153
Add a definition of "farm forestry" as follows: "Forestry on land which is also used for
horticulture or raising, caring, breeding and grazing of livestock.". Specifically exclude farm
forestry from the definition of "farming".
6523-
154
Zealand rgardner@fedfarm.org.nz Definitions Existing Amend the definition of "food production" to replace it with the term "crop production".
6523-
155
Amend the definition of "Land use capability classes" by amending the chart of increasing
limitations to use and decreasing versatility of use to better reflect the suitability of the land
for various land uses. Refer submission for detail [pg. 87/89].
6523-
156
Zealand rgardner@fedfarm.org.nz Definitions Existing Clarify the definition of "River or stream".
6523-
157
Amend the definition of "site" by including the following exception following the exception that
relates to the Unit Titles Act 1972: "Provided that in the case of land that is in a title of 40ha or
greater, no part of the land that is greater in distance than 300m from the locus of a proposed
activity that is involved in any resource consent application shall be considered part of the
site."
6523-
158
Add a definition of "rural activities" as follows: "Activities, including development, that by their
scale, intensity, visual character, trip generation and/or design and appearance of structures,
are of a rural character typically associated with rural areas."
6524-1 Allen Calendars Limited goulter@calendars.co.nz Zoning Central
Rezone the block of land from Hillsborough Road down to Herd Road and Carr Road from
Light Industry to a zone that reflects the current uses.
6525-1 Geoffrey W F Mason geoffreymason18@gmail.com RPS Urban growth
quality compact urban form Keep 70% of growth within city limits. Stage the Future Urban zone to achieve this
6525-2 Geoffrey W F Mason geoffreymason18@gmail.com Sustainable Development C7.7/H6.4 Sustainable design Apply Homestar rating to all new houses
6525-3 Geoffrey W F Mason geoffreymason18@gmail.com Sustainable Development C7.7/H6.4 Sustainable design Apply Greenstar rating to all new commercial buildings
environment
Ensure all new developments achieve good urban design by being subject to design review
with strong assessment criteria
6525-5 Geoffrey W F Mason geoffreymason18@gmail.com Residential zones Residential
General Ensure greater housing choice by removing rules which make development uneconomic
6525-6 Geoffrey W F Mason geoffreymason18@gmail.com Residential zones Residential Land use controls Allow existing houses to be split into two flats
6525-7 Geoffrey W F Mason geoffreymason18@gmail.com Residential zones Residential
policies
Expand the area of the Mixed Housing Urban zone, especially near the city centre, to ensure
greater housing choice
Focus higher density living and commerce on transport nodes, giving emphasis to the city
shaping nature of the City Rail Link
Upzone more land near railway stations and the high frequency bus routes, in particular in
Newton, Morningside, Greenlane and Ellerslie
6525-10 Geoffrey W F Mason geoffreymason18@gmail.com Transport Auckland -wide
requirements Remove minimum parking requirements from all areas, especially residential areas
6526-1 Grant Chester markbellingham@tnp.co.nz RPS Changes to the RUB West Rezone 119-121 Totara Road, Whenuapai from Future Urban to Single House.
6526-2 Grant Chester markbellingham@tnp.co.nz Future Urban I5 Rules
Amend zone rules, particularly for 119-121 Totara Road, to be equivalent to the Operative
Rodney Plan - Countryside Environment zone to provide for residential development.
6526-3 Grant Chester markbellingham@tnp.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - Urban zones
except Rural
Amend Activity Table 3 to provide for a range of activities similar to the Operative Rodney
Plan, including subdivision as a Discretionary activity within the Whenuapai Future Urban
zone.
6527-1 Nick Harvey nick.harvey@nzsponsorship.co.nz Precincts - North Bayswater
Amend objectives and policies to remove all provision for dwellings especially in sub-precinct
B.
6527-2 Nick Harvey nick.harvey@nzsponsorship.co.nz Precincts - North Bayswater K5.6 Precinct rules Amend rules to remove all provision for or reference to dwellings, especially in sub-precinct B.
6528-1 David and Jodi Evans markbellingham@tnp.co.nz RPS Changes to the RUB North and Waiheke Island
Amend the RUB to include properties south of Sandspit Road, particularly 198 Sandspit
Road, Warkworth, excluding the area covered by the Outstanding Natural Landscape and the
extent of the Queen Elizabeth 2 covenant on the upper Mahurangi River bush slope.
6528-2 David and Jodi Evans markbellingham@tnp.co.nz RPS Changes to the RUB North and Waiheke Island
Rezone properties south of Sandspit Road, particularly 198 Sandspit Road, Warkworth from
Mixed Rural to Future Urban, excluding the area covered by the Outstanding Natural
Landscape and the extent of the Queen Elizabeth 2 covenant on the upper Mahurangi River
bush slope.
6528-3 David and Jodi Evans markbellingham@tnp.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - Urban zones
except Rural
Amend rules to enable the subdivision of Future Urban zoned land to a minimum site size of
4ha.
6529-1 Nirvana Trust monica@nirvanafarm.co.nz RPS Changes to the RUB South
Amend RUB boundary to allow land locally known as Brookby Hills that is to the west of
Clevedon village along Twilight Road, including 85, 97, 105 and 123 Twilght Road, Clevedon
to be rezoned from Countryside Living and Mixed Rural to Single House.
349/1145
Sub#/
6530-1 Takatwo Trustee Limited biancahartley@tnp.co.nz Mana Whenua
Whenua
Refine the extent of the overlay at 88 Oak River Drive, Matakana [ID 3024 and ID 3025] to
apply only to confirmed areas of significance following a further assessment of the site.
6530-2 Takatwo Trustee Limited biancahartley@tnp.co.nz Mana Whenua
Whenua
Delete the overlay at 88 Oak River Drive, Matakana and use the matters of control and
assessment criteria of the Coastal Protection Yard overlay. See submission for further details
[pages 4 and 6/12 of the submission].
6530-3 Takatwo Trustee Limited biancahartley@tnp.co.nz Rural Zones General
Spec. info. requirements
Amend 6.2(2) Assessment - Development control infringements for Yards to include criteria
for Sites and Places of Value to Mana Whenua. See submission for specific amendments.
6531-1 Wynne Jones wynnedajones@hotmail.com Zoning Central
Allow for high density housing between Tamaki Drive and Benbow Steet, and areas close to
the St Heliers Bay shopping area.
6532-1 Sheryl LaTrobe dslatrobe@hotmail.com Mana Whenua
Whenua
and policies
Remove Mana Whenua provisions in relation to Clarks Beach [specific sites and provisions
not specified, inferred Sites and Places of Value and Significance to Mana Whenua overlay].
6532-2 Sheryl LaTrobe dslatrobe@hotmail.com General Miscellaneous Consultation and engagement
Provide more time and further opportunity for public consultation before Unitary Plan is
accepted.
6533-1
Fluoridation Information
Network Tricia@MyCafe.co.nz General Miscellaneous Other
Place an immediate moratorium on the fluoridation of Auckland's water supply until a study
has been completed to determine the effects.
6534-1 Zakara Investments Limited markbellingham@tnp.co.nz Precincts - North Kawau Island
Provide for appropriate development opportunities on Kawau Island. See submission for
further details [Vol. 2 page 4/48 of the submission].
Amend the provisions of the precinct, in particular sub-precinct B, to promote sustainable
management.
6534-3 Zakara Investments Limited markbellingham@tnp.co.nz RPS
Include rules that are consistent with the biodiversity conservation objectives of the RMA and
the PAUP, including for SEAs and subdivision of significant areas, particularly for Kawau
Island.
6534-4 Zakara Investments Limited markbellingham@tnp.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - Rural zones
area
Amend the rules for transferable rural sites to provide more options for recipient site zones
while avoiding transfer of sites to elite and prime land, outstanding and high landscape areas
and ecological areas.
Delete and replace sub-precinct B and amend the area it covers. See submission for further
details and specific amendments [Vol. 1 page 4/48 of the submission].
6534-6 Zakara Investments Limited markbellingham@tnp.co.nz
Outstanding Natural
Rules
Outstanding Natural
Landscapes
Reduce the area of the Outstanding Natural Landscape overlay on the southern parts of
Kawau Island. See submission for specific amendments and maps [Vol. 2 pages 41 to 43/48
of the submission].
area
Incentivise the transfer of titles out of Rural Conservation zone sites, SEAs, ONLs and ONFs
into a wider range of recipient zones, including Rural Production, Mixed Rural, Countryside
Living, Rural Conservation and Rural and Coastal Settlements, excluding elite and prime land
(Class 1-3) as well as SEAs, ONLs and ONFs.
area
Replace 'Table 8: Maximum number of new sites for transfer' with provisions provided in
submission to provide greater subdivision allowances. See submission for specific
amendments [pages 20 and 21/48 of the submission].
6534-9 Zakara Investments Limited markbellingham@tnp.co.nz RPS Issues
Regional significance Retain the Regional Policy Statement.
6534-10 Zakara Investments Limited markbellingham@tnp.co.nz Precincts - North Kawau Island Retain the objectives and policies.
Amend the Description to describe in more detail the vegetation cover of Kawau Island, the
limited opportunities for sustainable local development and to also delete the description of
where the sub-precincts apply on the island. See submission for specific amendments [Vol. 2
page 25/48 of the submission].
Add an objective as follows: Existing rural and residential activities continue, but further
development across the Precinct provides for additional dwellings and visitor and commercial
developments on appropriate sites.
Add an objective as follows: Buildings and structure are unobtrusive within the natural
landscape.
Add a new policy under the sub-heading 'Sub-precinct A' as follows: Provide for the transfer of
sites from Sub-Precinct B for the creation of additional sites in Sub-Precinct A.
Add and amend policies under sub-heading 'Sub-precinct B' to provide for additional
residential sites, uses and activities appropriate to the coastal location, subdivision which
considers landscape and ecological features and encourage conservation and other public
benefits and limit activities which require the formation of public roads. See submission for
specific amendments [Vol. 2 page 25/48 of the submission].
350/1145
Sub#/
Amend the Activity Table to provide for more activities and uses such as buildings and
accessory buildings, greenhouses, retail, restaurants, visitor accommodation and camping
grounds, generally as either Permitted or Restricted Discretionary. See submission for
specific amendments [Vol. 2 pages 26 to 29/48 of the submission].
Amend the Activity Table to provide for greater flexibility of subdivision, including providing for
transferable rural site subdivision and boundary adjustments and relocations. See submission
for specific amendments [Vol. 2 page 29/48 of the submission].
6534-18 Zakara Investments Limited markbellingham@tnp.co.nz Precincts - North Kawau Island Add a new activity table to provide for boat access to properties on Kawau Island.
Amend Land Use control 2.1.2 'Dwellings' to provide for two dwellings per site where the site
is greater than 40ha. See submission for specific amendments [Vol. 2 page 30/48 of the
submission].
Add matters of control and assessment criteria for boat access to properties on Kawau Island.
See submission for further details [Vol. 2 page 30/48 of the submission - note that this relates
to previous submission point regarding addition of a new activity table for the precinct which
provides for boat access].
6534-21 Zakara Investments Limited markbellingham@tnp.co.nz Precincts - North Kawau Island Delete Land Use control 2.2.1 'Dwellings'.
Amend the title of the Subdivision control sub-rule 4.1 to read as follows: 4.1 Sub-precincts A
& B subdivision of low intensity sites restricted discretionary.
Add a new control named '4.2 Sub-precincts A & B - Assessment criteria for Subdivision in
Kawau Island Precinct' which provides for transferable rural site subdivision, subdivision for
protection of natural areas, bush, SEAs and wetlands; and subdivision for the creation of
reserves. See submission for specific amendments [Note - submission refers to provisions as
'Assessment criteria' but they read more like controls. Vol. 2 page 31 to 39/48 of the
submission].
Include specific criteria or guidelines for identifying SEAs and provisions for changing
conditions of areas identified or not.
Provide for 'potential SEAs' where this is supported by qualified ecological advice, where the
ecological values of a non-SEA area have improved through natural process or intervention
and it meets the SEA criteria.
features Include specific criteria or guidelines for identifying ONLs, HNLS, ONCs and HNCs.
6535-1 Ian and Nicola Davie-Martin nicola13@me.com Mana Whenua
Whenua
objectives and policies Remove the iwi cultural significance.
6536-1 Sheridan Square Committee robyn.glynn@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central
Rezone the areas held in common between Sheridan Lane, Hepburn Street and Wellington
Street, Freemans Bay [from Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings] to a zone that
provides for private open space and recreation.
6537-1 Fion Tlong wlam@orcon.net.nz RPS Urban growth
retain affordable housing Delete affordable housing from new housing development areas.
6538-1 Charlotte L Allen charlotte.allen@gmail.com General Chapter A Introduction A3 Strategic Framework Retain 3.3 Sustainable management.
6538-2 Charlotte L Allen charlotte.allen@gmail.com RPS
6538-6 Charlotte L Allen charlotte.allen@gmail.com RPS Coastal
6538-9 Charlotte L Allen charlotte.allen@gmail.com RPS Rural B8.3 Rural subdivision
Amend Objective 2 to remove the word 'prevented' and to add the word 'productive' after
'further fragmentation of'.
351/1145
Sub#/
6538-10 Charlotte L Allen charlotte.allen@gmail.com RPS Rural B8.3 Rural subdivision
Amend Policy 5 to add the words ' and Rural Coastal Bush Block zones' at the end of the
policy.
6538-11 Charlotte L Allen charlotte.allen@gmail.com Infrastructure
C1.1 Infrastructure
6538-12 Charlotte L Allen charlotte.allen@gmail.com Infrastructure
C1.1 Infrastructure
6538-13 Charlotte L Allen charlotte.allen@gmail.com Earthworks
6538-14 Charlotte L Allen charlotte.allen@gmail.com Earthworks
6538-15 Charlotte L Allen charlotte.allen@gmail.com
SEAs
6538-16 Charlotte L Allen charlotte.allen@gmail.com
SEAs
6538-17 Charlotte L Allen charlotte.allen@gmail.com Rural Zones General
Add a new zone called Rural Coastal Bush Block [refer to pages 7-14/24 of the submission for
proposed objectives, policies, rules and other details]
6539-1 Isthmus Properties Limited michael@campbellbrown.co.nz Zoning West
Rezone 34 Portage Road and sites that have frontage onto Portage Road between Clark
Street and Great North Road, New Lynn [as identified on the map in the submission on page
6/7] from Light Industry to General Business.
6539-2 Isthmus Properties Limited michael@campbellbrown.co.nz
Centre) Business
Retain existing permitted activities as in the Auckland Council District Plan (Waitakere
Section) for 34 Portage Road and sites that have frontage onto Portage Road between Clark
6/7]
Centre) Business
Retain existing controlled activities as in the Auckland Council District Plan (Waitakere
Section) for 34 Portage Road and sites that have frontage onto Portage Road between Clark
6/7]
Centre) Business
Retain existing restricted discretionary activities as in the Auckland Council District Plan
(Waitakere Section) for 34 Portage Road and sites that have frontage onto Portage Road
between Clark Street and Great North Road, New Lynn [as identified on the map in the
submission on page 6/7]
6540-1 Brian and Val Davies david@davidwren.co.nz Zoning North and Islands
Rezone properties on Russell Road, Wainui, from Rural Production to Countryside Living.
Refer to the full submission for a map of the area [page 5/5].
6540-2 Brian and Val Davies david@davidwren.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - Rural zones
area
Add the 'South Rodney Additional Subdivision Control' overlay to properties on Russell Road,
Wainui. Refer to the full submission for a map of the area [page 5/5].
6541-1 Mark R Munro mmunro@xtra.co.nz General Miscellaneous
Operational/
Projects/Acquisition Assist development in Auckland to deal with the housing shortage.
6541-2 Mark R Munro mmunro@xtra.co.nz RPS Mana Whenua B5 Strategic Reject requirements to consult with Iwi groups.
6542-1 Christine M Caughey c.caughey@xtra.co.nz
SEAs
Land Remove the natural resources [SEA overlay] from 63B Portland Road, Remuera.
6542-2 Christine M Caughey c.caughey@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central
Retain the Single House zone at Seaview Road, Arney Road, Arney Crescent, Bassett Road,
Bell Road and the Portland/Aldred/Victoria Avenue Block in Remuera.
6542-3 Christine M Caughey c.caughey@xtra.co.nz Special Character
& C
Isthmus
Retain the overlay at Seaview Road, Arney Road, Arney Crescent, Bassett Road, Bell Road
and the Portland/Aldred/Victoria Avenue Block in Remuera.
6542-4 Christine M Caughey c.caughey@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central Rezone 72 Seaview Road, Remuera from Mixed Housing Suburban to Single House zone.
6542-5 Christine M Caughey c.caughey@xtra.co.nz Transport Auckland -wide Mapping
Retain the 'infrastructure plan' [Parking - City Centre Fringe Area] at Seaview Road, Arney
Road, Arney Crescent, Bassett Road, Bell Road and the Portland/Aldred/Victoria Avenue
Block in Remuera.
6543-1 Steven Robson kiwifoot@gmail.com Mana Whenua General provisions
assessment Reject Cultural Impact Assessments by Iwi, assessments should be done by the Council.
6544-1 William and Diana Atkinson atkipc@clear.net.nz RPS
Add new provisions to provide for a rates relief programme to assist commercial heritage
owners with earthquake strengthening.
6544-2 William and Diana Atkinson atkipc@clear.net.nz Special Character
North Shore Retain Special Character areas in Devonport.
6544-3 William and Diana Atkinson atkipc@clear.net.nz Special Character
residential
Amend name of overlay to be Special Character Heritage Area in relation to
Devonport [inferred].
352/1145
Sub#/
6544-4 William and Diana Atkinson atkipc@clear.net.nz RPS
character and natural heritage B4.3 Natural heritage Retain of 'protection of Devonport coastal environment, landscape and trees'.
6544-5 William and Diana Atkinson atkipc@clear.net.nz Residential zones
obs & pols Retain description of Single House zone in relation to Devonport.
6544-6 William and Diana Atkinson atkipc@clear.net.nz Historic Heritage (Overlay)
Heritage
Places Add Devonport's business centre in Victoria Road to the schedule as a Historic Heritage Area.
6544-7 William and Diana Atkinson atkipc@clear.net.nz Zoning North and Islands
Rezone sites in Devonport from Town Centre to a zone that recognises the areas historic
value and will discourage inappropriate and over-height development. [Preferred zone not
specified].
6544-8 William and Diana Atkinson atkipc@clear.net.nz Zoning North and Islands
Rezone east side of Wynyard Street, Devonport from Town Centre. [Preferred zone not
specified].
6544-9 William and Diana Atkinson atkipc@clear.net.nz Zoning North and Islands Retain eastern side of Wynyard Street, Devonport as Light Industry.
Heritage
Incorporate [North Shore City Council] Plan Change 33 that added protection of heritage
within business areas, into the PAUP.
Heritage
Places
Incorporate [North Shore City Council] Plan Change 38 (that reviewed the heritage schedule)
into the PAUP.
6544-12 William and Diana Atkinson atkipc@clear.net.nz
shafts survey coordinates Retain the Volcanic Viewshaft and Height Sensitive Areas overlay in relation to Devonport.
control
and policies Retain the Pre-1944 Demolition Control overlay objectives and policies.
control
Retain the rules of the Pre-1944 Demolition Control overlay subject to amendment of
notification rule to require notification of all restricted discretionary, discretionary and non-
complying applications including the demolition of all pre-1940 houses.
6544-15 William and Diana Atkinson atkipc@clear.net.nz Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula K5.11 Precinct rules
Delete rule that allows building heights up to 4 storeys at Fort Takapuna [sub-precinct E
Vauxhall Road].
6544-16 William and Diana Atkinson atkipc@clear.net.nz Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula K5.11 Precinct rules Delete rule that allows building heights up to 4 storeys for Wakakura Crescent, sub-precinct F
Heritage
objectives and policies Amend schedule to reclassify all North Shore Category A* items to Category A.
6544-18 William and Diana Atkinson atkipc@clear.net.nz Precincts - City Centre Port K3.7 Precinct Rules / Mapping Prevent further reclamation of Waitemata Harbour.
6545-1 Ian Humphrey
PO Box 331472, Takapuna,
Auckland 0740 Precincts - North Waimauku
Delete the Waimauku Precinct from addresses given in submission [Page 1 and 3 of 4] to
ensure future farming and associated operations can continue.
6545-2 Ian Humphrey
PO Box 331472, Takapuna,
Auckland 0740 Precincts - North New Precincts All other New Precincts
Create a new precinct for a 750ha land holding in Waimauku, addresses given in the
submission, to specifically deal with the entire farm in a comprehensive and environmentally
sensitive fashion [Page 1 and 3 of 4].
6546-1 Bill C Marcroft
PO Box 404157, Puhoi, Auckland
Reject all provisions calling for partnership arrangements, co-management, joint management
arrangements and the transfer of power to Man Whenua.
0951 General Miscellaneous Consultation and engagement
Hold a referendum to ask whether the general population of Auckland agree that the
governance of our physical and natural resources be shared in partnership with Mana
Whenua.
0951 Mana Whenua
Whenua
Amend the policies to provide a balance between the protection of cultural heritage and
private property rights, using clear and unambiguous language.
0951 Mana Whenua
Whenua
and policies
Amend the policies to provide a balance between the protection of cultural heritage and
private property rights, using clear and unambiguous language.
0951 Mana Whenua
Whenua
Amend to grade sites into categories of significance which are accorded varying degrees of
protections and obligation and clarify with all affected parties the consequences and
obligations required when a property is identified as the location of a 'Site of Significance'.
0951 Mana Whenua
Whenua
Amend to grade sites into categories of significance which are accorded varying degrees of
protections and obligation and clarify with all affected parties the consequences and
obligations required when a property is identified as the location of a 'Site of Value'.
0951 Mana Whenua General provisions
assessment Delete G2.7.4 'Cultural impact assessment'.
assessment
Delete 'Information requirements' (5), to remove the requirement to obtain cultural impact
assessments from iwi. Identify Council as being responsible for preparing any cultural impact
assessment deemed necessary (by the Council).
6547-1 Tracy Gimblett tgimblett@xtra.co.nz Zoning West
Rezone 10 Fairbanks Place, Glendene and surrounding area [from Terrace Housing and
Apartment Buildings] to Mixed Housing Urban.
6547-2 Tracy Gimblett tgimblett@xtra.co.nz General Miscellaneous Consultation and engagement Provide more time [before Unitary Plan is accepted].
353/1145
Sub#/
6548-1 National Asset Group philip@campbellbrown.co.nz Zoning West
Rezone 172A Don Buck Road, the immediately adjoining site to the south, Massey from
Single House to Mixed Housing Urban. See submission for plan [Page 8/9 of the
submission].
6549-1
Dion and Melanie and Alan
Mayes david@davidwren.co.nz Zoning North and Islands
Rezone properties on Russell Road, Wainui, from Rural Production to Countryside Living.
Refer to the full submission for a map of the area [page 5/5].
6549-2
Dion and Melanie and Alan
Mayes david@davidwren.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - Rural zones
area
Add the 'South Rodney Additional Subdivision Control' overlay to properties on Russell Road,
Wainui. Refer to the full submission for a map of the area [page 5/5].
6550-1
Friends of Takapuna Beach
Reserve
7C Alison Avenue, Takapuna,
Amend Activity Table to add the following; ' Subject to compliance with permitted activity
performance standards'.
6550-2
Friends of Takapuna Beach
Reserve
Amend Activity Table so that those activities that do not comply with permitted standards are
non-complying activities.
6551-1
Newmarket Community
Association jon.eriksen@orcon.net.nz Built Environment (Overlays)
Height Control
Amend rules to reduce maximum building heights in Newmarket to what is allowed in
[Auckland Isthmus] Plan change 196 (Newmarket Growth Area Structure Plan). [No specific
heights specified]
6551-2
Newmarket Community
Association jon.eriksen@orcon.net.nz Precincts - Central Newmarket 1
Amend provisions for Newmarket area to ensure there is a greater graduation between high
density / tall buildings and residential areas.
6551-3
Newmarket Community
Association jon.eriksen@orcon.net.nz General Miscellaneous Consultation and engagement Request consultation with the Newmarket community between May and September.
6551-4
Newmarket Community
Association jon.eriksen@orcon.net.nz General Chapter G General provisions G2.4 Notification
Amend notification provisions so that 'all non-complying applications should have to be
publicly notified via public notice in the NZ Herald and notice posted on the site that is
proposed to be developed'.
6551-5
Newmarket Community
Association jon.eriksen@orcon.net.nz General Noise and vibration H6.2 Rules
Amend the Metropolitan zone rules for managing noise in relation to the Newmarket area 'to
ensure that there is reasonable respect for resident's typical activities (e.g. sleeping)'.
6551-6
Newmarket Community
Association jon.eriksen@orcon.net.nz
Centre) Business
Park zones
Amend provisions in relation to the Newmarket area to ensure good air quality in particular for
apartment buildings that are next to the Newmarket railway station.
6551-7
Newmarket Community
Association jon.eriksen@orcon.net.nz General Miscellaneous
Operational/
Prioritise stormwater and sewage separation as part of intensification of development
especially to prevent overflow into Hobson Bay.
6551-8
Newmarket Community
the CMA Discharges
objectives and policies Prioritise 'filtering' of stormwater to minimise contamination of Hobson Bay.
6551-9
Newmarket Community
Association jon.eriksen@orcon.net.nz Zoning Central
Rezone large vacant section on the corner of Mortimer Pass and Gillies Avenue, Newmarket
[40 Gillies Avenue] from Single House to Metropolitan Centre.
6551-10
Newmarket Community
Association jon.eriksen@orcon.net.nz RPS
features
Amend provisions so that volcanic viewshafts and other viewshafts such as to the harbour
and other relevant features (e.g. Newmarket Viaduct, the Domain) are maintained in the
Newmarket area.
6551-11
Newmarket Community
Amend provisions so that any resource consent application to compromise a viewshaft should
be publicly notified.
6551-12
Newmarket Community
Centre) Business
Park zones
Delete the provisions for the Newmarket Metropolitan zone that requires buildings to be built
to the road frontage boundary and encourage the public use of road frontages [inferred].
6551-13
Newmarket Community
Centre) Business
Park zones
Amend maximum building height restrictions within the Newmarket Metropolitan zone to take
into account the size of the site, for example up to 4 storeys for smaller sites and higher limits
for larger sites.
6551-14
Newmarket Community
Centre) Business
Park zones
Amend provisions for the Newmarket Metropolitan zone to increase setback and podium
requirements for larger buildings.
6551-15
Newmarket Community
Centre) Business
Park zones
Amend provisions for the Newmarket Metropolitan area to require mandatory verandahs over
all footpaths.
6551-16
Newmarket Community
Association jon.eriksen@orcon.net.nz Residential zones Residential
General
Amend provisions for the Newmarket area to ensure any future student accommodation is of
good quality.
6551-17
Newmarket Community
General
Amend provisions to encourage single level dwellings within the Newmarket area that are
affordable and of good quality sustainable design.
6551-18
Newmarket Community
Association jon.eriksen@orcon.net.nz General Miscellaneous
Operational/
Provide for mitigation of increased pressure on transport infrastructure (bus, train, car, cyclist
and pedestrian) in the Newmarket area including; staging implementation, improving public
transport flows along Broadway, improving pedestrian links between bus and train services
and increasing footpath widths especially around bus stops. Refer to submission for details
[page 8/11].
6551-19
Newmarket Community
General
Amend set back, yard and minimum dwelling size provisions for multiple dwellings to ensure
that neighbouring sites are 'not unduly impacted if equivalent buildings are developed on
adjoining sites' within the Newmarket area.
354/1145
Sub#/
6551-20
Newmarket Community
General Amend provisions for multiple dwellings to encourage single level dwellings [inferred].
6551-21
Newmarket Community
Centre) Business
Park zones
Amend set back, yard and minimum dwelling size provisions within the Mixed Use zone to
ensure that neighbouring sites are 'not unduly impacted if equivalent buildings are developed
on adjoining sites' within the Newmarket area.
6551-22
Newmarket Community
Centre) Business
Park zones
Amend set back, yard and minimum dwelling size provisions within the Metropolitan Centre
zone to ensure that neighbouring sites are 'not unduly impacted if equivalent buildings are
developed on adjoining sites' within the Newmarket area.
6551-23
Newmarket Community
Association jon.eriksen@orcon.net.nz RPS Urban growth
Provide for more public open space and community facilities to deal with increased
intensification in the Newmarket area [inferred].
6551-24
Newmarket Community
Centre) Business
Park zones
Ensure that new buildings do not block the natural light access of existing residential
developments in the Mixed Use or Metropolitan Centres zones.
6551-25
Newmarket Community
Consider rezoning of the residential zoned sites on Remuera Road between Middleton Road
and Wooton Street to allow mixed use up to 4-6 storeys on larger sites. Refer to submission
for details [page 4/11].
6551-26
Newmarket Community
Consider rezoning the northern part of the Mixed Use area bounded by Morrow Street, Gillies
Avenue / Crowhurst Street and Khyber Pass to Metropolitan Centre with a 10 storey height
limit.
6552-1 NZ Landcare Trust trudy.rankin@landcare.org.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - Urban zones H5.2 3.1 Residential zones Retain the additional subdivision control overlay of 750m
2
in the Hill Park Area [Manurewa].
6552-2 NZ Landcare Trust trudy.rankin@landcare.org.nz Zoning South
Rezone the properties between 108 and 152 Great South Road, 12 and 16 Kelvyn Grove and
6 and 10 Hill Road, Hill Park [Manurewa] from Mixed Housing Urban to Mixed Use Suburban.

Rezone properties on the corner of Kelvyn Grove and Great South Road [Manurewa] from
Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings to Mixed Use Suburban.
6552-4 NZ Landcare Trust trudy.rankin@landcare.org.nz
Centre) Business
Park zones
Amend the maximum height limit in Manurewa Town Center from 24.5m to 16m or a
four story equivalent.
6552-5 NZ Landcare Trust trudy.rankin@landcare.org.nz Special Character
residential
Add a new special character overlay to the Hill Park area Manurewa [see pages 6, 10, 18, 20-
22/45 of the submission for details on the proposed special character overlay including
objectives, policies and rules].
6552-6 NZ Landcare Trust trudy.rankin@landcare.org.nz RPS
Add a new natural heritage overlay to the Hill Park Area [Manurewa] in order to protect the
native plants and bird species. See page 6 and 11/45 of the submission for details.
SEAs
Land
Amend the PAUP to recognise that the Hill Park Area [Manurewa] is part of an eco-corridor
and that these eco-corridor areas remain intact and are preserved and strengthened.
6552-8 NZ Landcare Trust trudy.rankin@landcare.org.nz Trees
Trees
Notable Trees
Add trees to the notable tree schedule in the Hill Park Area [Manurewa] by engaging a
suitable professional to ensure all notable trees whether in front or rear yards, private or public
property are protected.
SEAs
Land
Add new SEAs to cover the entire Hill Park [Manurewa] footprint area [refer to page 10/45 for
the Hill Park area boundaries].
6552-10 NZ Landcare Trust trudy.rankin@landcare.org.nz RPS
Add rules similar to the Urban Tree Protection overlay to the Hill Park [Manurewa] area to
protect the density of native trees, and not just those of ecological significance, to support bird
life and to contribute to the special characteristics of the Hill Park area.
6552-11 NZ Landcare Trust trudy.rankin@landcare.org.nz Trees
Trees
Notable Trees
Add multiple new notable trees or groups of trees to the Hill Park Area as outlined on the map
in the submission on page 16/45.
6552-12 NZ Landcare Trust trudy.rankin@landcare.org.nz Residential zones Residential
and Coastal Settlement zone Amend rule 6.4 Yards to change the front yard setback to 6m.
General
Add specific landscape and fencing rules that reflect the park like streetscape of the Hill Park
area [Manurewa].
6552-14 NZ Landcare Trust trudy.rankin@landcare.org.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - Urban zones H5.2 3.1 Residential zones
Retain [rule 6(b)] which makes subdivision that does not comply with the minimum net site
area of 750m2 in the Hill Park area [Manurewa] a Non-complying activity.
Rezone all properties in the Hill Park area [Manurewa] to Mixed Use Suburban if they adjoin a
Single House zone but include development controls that fit comfortably between the Single
House and Mixed Use Urban scales and densities.
Amend controls so that where the Single House zone in Hill Park [Manurewa] adjoins a zone
with a higher density (i.e. Mixed Housing Urban or Suburban or Terraced Housing and
Apartment Buildings zones) then a building in relation to boundary rule is used, similar to the
Auckland City District Plan - Isthmus, on the common boundary between the two zones. See
355/1145
Sub#/
6553-1 Ian Rawnsley
447 Mill Road, RD2, Papakura,
Auckland 2582 General C7.2/H6.1 Lighting Reject using a level of 10lux from 10pm to 7am.
6553-2 Ian Rawnsley
447 Mill Road, RD2, Papakura,
Auckland 2582 General C7.2/H6.1 Lighting Amend rural areas to have a lux of 1 rather than 10 during nightime hours.
6554-1 Penrhyn Trust 2ashtonfamily@gmail.com Zoning Central
Rezone the area including 47 Balmoral Road, 620 and 628 Mount Eden Road, Mount Eden,
from Mixed Housing Suburban to Single House. Refer to the full submission for a map of the
area [page 3/9].
6554-2 Penrhyn Trust 2ashtonfamily@gmail.com Residential zones Residential
policies
Retain and amend objective 1 (relating to attractive environments with quality development) to
include neighbouring properties in the list of items that development responds to and
enhances. Refer to the full submission for suggested wording [page 4/9].
policies
Retain and amend policy 1 to include 'neighbouring properties' in the list of items that
developments are required to contribute positively to. Refer to the full submission for
policies
Amend policy 2 to read: 'Recognise that the density of Aucklands residential areas will
increase, to varying degrees, over time and apply controls to avoid remedy or mitigate the
effects of that manage that change.'
6554-5 Penrhyn Trust 2ashtonfamily@gmail.com Residential zones
Amend objective 3 to read: 'Development provides high-quality on-site amenity for residents
and achieves a reasonable standard of amenity for adjoining sites, having particular regard to
the objectives and policies of adjacent zones and overlays.'
Amend policy 2, to read: 'Manage the height, bulk, form and appearance of development and
require sufficient setbacks and landscaped areas to maintain a suburban residential character
of generally two storeys.'
Retain policy 4: 'Enable attached housing on smaller sites where the development faces the
street and integrates well into the neighbourhood.'
Amend policy 5, relating to the design requirements for dwellings, to include a requirement for
dwellings to be designed to avoid, remedy or mitigate adverse effects on neighbouring
properties. Refer to the full submission for suggested wording [page 5/9].
Amend policy 7(a), relating to limiting the density and scale of development, to read:
'achieving a balance between making the most efficient use of the site and providing high-
quality on-site amenity, without generating unreasonable adverse effects on adjoining sites
and the surrounding area'
6554-10 Penrhyn Trust 2ashtonfamily@gmail.com Residential zones Residential Notification Delete rule 2 'Notification', such that the normal RMA notification tests apply.
6554-11 Penrhyn Trust 2ashtonfamily@gmail.com Residential zones Residential Land use controls
Retain rule 3.1(2) 'Maximum density', relating to when a density of one dwelling per 300m
2
applies in the Mixed Housing Suburban zone.
6554-12 Penrhyn Trust 2ashtonfamily@gmail.com Residential zones Residential Land use controls
Retain rule 3.1(7) 'Maximum density', which clarifies that the most restrictive density applies to
existing and proposed rear site in the Mixed Housing Urban and Mixed Housing Suburban
zones.
Amend rule 7.5 'Yards' (in the Mixed Housing Suburban zone), to include maintaining the
amenity of adjoining properties in the purpose. Refer to the full submission for suggested
wording [page 8/9].
Amend rule 7.9 'Landscaping' (in the Mixed Housing Suburban zone), to include neighbouring
amenity in the purpose. Refer to the full submission for suggested wording [page 8/9].
Mixed Housing Urban zone Retain the purpose of rule 7.10 'Outlook space' (in the Mixed Housing Suburban zone).
6555-1 Colin R Beckwith cbeckwith@xtra.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - Rural zones
area
Amend provisions 'to allow subdivision of land under 20ha zoned rural or mixed rural into 2ha
lifestyle blocks'.
6556-1 Alister Kitchen alister@leuschke.co.nz Zoning Central
Rezone each side of Great North Road between Bond St and Grey Lynn shops from Terrace
Housing and Apartment Buildings to Mixed Use.
6556-2 Alister Kitchen alister@leuschke.co.nz Zoning Central
Rezone area of existing Business 4 in Morningside, by the railway station, from Light
Industrial to Mixed Use.
6556-3 Alister Kitchen alister@leuschke.co.nz Zoning Central Rezone Newmarket to reflect development potential agreed through plan modification 196.
6556-4 Alister Kitchen alister@leuschke.co.nz Residential zones Housing affordability
and policies
Delete affordable housing section, particularly at 736 Great South Road, Manukau and 41-43
Gillies Ave, Epsom which are zoned Mixed Use.
6556-5 Alister Kitchen alister@leuschke.co.nz Residential zones Residential Land use controls
Amend rule 3.3 The conversion of a dwelling into two dwellings, by removing the 40m
2
minimum net site area to have no minimum size and delete clause (2)(c) as it precludes
sleepouts and lofts over garages.
6556-6 Alister Kitchen alister@leuschke.co.nz Residential zones Residential
Mixed Housing Urban zone Amend rule 7.5 'Yards' to remove the side yard requirement.
356/1145
Sub#/
Mixed Housing Urban zone Delete rule 7.17 Minimum dwelling size.
Mixed Housing Urban zone Delete rule 7.13 Dwellings fronting the street.
Amend rule 7.15 Fences to recognise that it is onerous to expect no high fences within front
yards as many properties rely on these for privacy to north facing gardens.
Delete rule 9.4 Building setbacks, within the Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings zone,
on side boundaries to the same zone.
Terrace Housing and
Apartment Buildings zone Delete rule 9.6 Minimum frontage and site width.
Terrace Housing and
Apartment Buildings zone Delete rule 9.17 Daylight to dwellings.
Terrace Housing and
Apartment Buildings zone Retain rule 9.22 Minimum floor to floor/ceiling height.
6556-14 Alister Kitchen alister@leuschke.co.nz
Centre) Business
Park zones Delete the storey component of rule 4.2 Building Height.
Centre) Business
Park zones Delete rule 4.7 Building entrances.
Centre) Business
Park zones
Reject height limit of 24.5m and 6 storeys at 736 Great South Road, Manukau Central. Allow
greater building heights than 24.5m [Mixed Use zone - 4.2 Building height].
Centre) Business
Park zones
Reject height limit of 16.5m and 4 storeys at 41-43 Gillies Ave, Epsom [Mixed Use zone - 4.2
Building Height].
6557-1 Paul Jones pjplanning123@gmail.com Residential zones Residential Land use controls
Reject rule 3.1 'Maximum density', minimum site area of 400m
2
, or 300m
2
, in the Mixed
Housing Sububan zone.
6558-1 Mediaworks Holdings Limited ckirman@ellisgould.co.nz Definitions New
Add a definition for 'Broadcasting facilities' [in conjunction with adding this as a permitted
activity in the Town Centre and Mixed Use zones].
6558-2 Mediaworks Holdings Limited ckirman@ellisgould.co.nz
Centre) Business
& Bus. Park zones
Add 'Broadcasting facilities' as a permitted activity in the Town Centre zone [in conjunction
with adding a definition of 'Broadcasting facilities' to the PAUP].
Centre) Business
& Bus. Park zones
Add 'Broadcasting facilities' as a permitted activity in the Mixed Use zone [in conjunction with
adding a definition of 'Broadcasting facilities' to the PAUP].
6558-4 Mediaworks Holdings Limited ckirman@ellisgould.co.nz Precincts - Central New Precincts Other New Precincts
Add a new precinct (to the area bounded by New North Road, Flower Street, Nikau Street and
Korari Street, and 2 Flowers Street, Eden Terrace) to provide for use and development of
these properties as a national broadcasting facility and to recognise the particular operational
characteristics of television, radio and interactive broadcasting facilities.
6558-5 Mediaworks Holdings Limited ckirman@ellisgould.co.nz Built Environment (Overlays)
Height Control
Retain the height limit of 16.5m in the Town Centre (Newton-Upper Symonds St) zone, in
particular the properties on the south side of New North Road between Korari Street and
Flower Street, Eden Terrace.
6558-6 Mediaworks Holdings Limited ckirman@ellisgould.co.nz Built Environment (Overlays)
Height Control
Retain the height limit of 20.5m in the Mixed Use zone, at 2 and 3 Flower Street, Eden
Terrace.
6558-7 Mediaworks Holdings Limited ckirman@ellisgould.co.nz Definitions Existing
Amend 'Buildings' to provide an exemption for structures such as satellites and aerials that
are required to operate broadcast facilities (and need to be located some distance above built
structures to allow broadcasts to be transmitted).
Delete the Volcanic Viewshafts overlays from the area bounded by New North Road, Flower
Street, Nikau Street and Korari Street, and 2 Flower Street Eden Terrace.
6558-9 Mediaworks Holdings Limited ckirman@ellisgould.co.nz Infrastructure
C1.1 Infrastructure
policies
Amend to provide for protection of MediaWorks transmission corridors, from its premises
(located at 2 Flower Street and the area bounded by New North Road, Flower Street, Nikau
Street and Korari Street, Eden Terrace) to the Waiatarua and Sky City Transmission
Stations.
control
Delete the Pre-1994 Building Demolition Control overlay from 2 and 3 Flower Street Eden
Terrace.
357/1145
Sub#/
6558-11 Mediaworks Holdings Limited ckirman@ellisgould.co.nz Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
Amend development control 3.2 'Number of Parking and loading spaces' to replace the
maximum parking rate of 1:60m
2
GFA (Offices within the City Centre Fringe Overlay), with a
minimum rate of 1:45m
2
GFA.
6558-12 Mediaworks Holdings Limited ckirman@ellisgould.co.nz Special Character
Business
Delete the 'Special Character - Business Upper Symonds Street' overlay from the properties
on the south side of New North Road, between Korari Street and Flower Street, Eden
Terrace.
Centre)
Maps only
Delete the 'Building Frontage - Key Retail Frontage' overlay from the properties on the south
side of New North Road, between Korari Street and Flower Street, Eden Terrace.
Centre)
obs & pols
Retain all provisions in the Town Centre zone (zone description, objectives policies and rules)
that recognise and provide for broadcasting activities and operational needs [specifically at 2
Flowers Street and the area bounded by New North Road, Flower Street, Nikau Street and
Korari Street, Eden Terrace].
Centre)
obs & pols
Retain all provisions in the Mixed Use zone (zone description, objectives policies and rules)
that recognise and provide for broadcasting activities and operational needs [specifically at 2
Flowers Street and the area bounded by New North Road, Flower Street, Nikau Street and
Korari Street, Eden Terrace].
6559-1 Ronald C Batty
Amend Activity Table to add the following; ' Subject to compliance with permitted activity
performance standards'.
6559-2 Ronald C Batty
Amend Activity Table so that those activities that do not comply with permitted standards are
non-complying activities.
6560-1
The Matakana Coast Trail
Trust graeme@wwsurveyors.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - Rural zones
area
Add new provisions to allow transferable rural site subdivision through the construction and
legal registration of a public trail / cycle-way.
6561-1 C Simon Oxner
470 Remuera Road, Remuera,
Heritage
Places
Add 4 Victoria Avenue, Remuera (Remuera Citizens Advice Bureau), to the heritage
schedule.
Auckland 1050 Zoning Central Delete the Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings zone at 464 Remuera Road, Remuera.
General
Amend rules to provide consistent set back limits across Auckland [Specific reference made
to rules applying to bed and breakfast activities in Northcote Point and Westemere. Relief
sought is unclear].
6562-1 Leanne M E Smith leannetaka@hotmail.com RPS Mana Whenua B5 Strategic
Delete the ability for Iwi to be involved in the RMA process and charge for resource consent
approval.
6563-1
Tamaki Estuary Protection
Society cpercy@pl.net RPS Coastal B7 Strategic Strengthen provisions to improve water quality in the Tamaki Estuary.
6563-2
Society cpercy@pl.net General Miscellaneous
Operational/
Emphasise the responsibility of Local Boards to reduce pollution in stormwater and waster
outflows, especially in the Tamaki Estuary.
6563-3
Society cpercy@pl.net
the CMA Discharges
Strengthen provisions to reduce pollution in storm-water and wastewater outflows, especially
in the Tamaki Estuary.
6563-4
Society cpercy@pl.net General Miscellaneous
Operational/
Projects/Acquisition Check erosion of the Tamaki estuary shoreline where possible.
6564-1 Tzarina L S Smith
6 Minnehaha Avenue, Takapuna,
Auckland 0622 RPS Mana Whenua B5 Strategic
approval.
6564-2 Tzarina L S Smith
Auckland 0622 RPS Mana Whenua B5 Strategic Keep the RMA consent process as it currently is.
6565-1 Barbara J Lynch
18B Michaels Avenue, Ellerslie,
Auckland 1051 RPS Issues
growth Reject the population projection of a further 1 million people by 2030.
6565-2 Barbara J Lynch
18B Michaels Avenue, Ellerslie,
Reject further intensification of Ellerslie (including flats up to three storeys and 'Terraced
Housing').
6566-1 Glenn W Archibald glenn@aatax.co.nz General Miscellaneous Special housing areas
Ensure that the Housing Accord provides for a balance between greenfield and brownfield
developments.
6566-2 Glenn W Archibald glenn@aatax.co.nz Zoning South
Reinstate the Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings zone in Papakura as it was in the
March draft of the Unitary Plan, including north of Papakura town centre along Great North
Road and the south side of Trentham Road to the railway line.
6566-3 Glenn W Archibald glenn@aatax.co.nz Zoning South Enable commercial activities in Te Hihi to increase and allow expansion around existing site.
6566-4 Glenn W Archibald glenn@aatax.co.nz Precincts - South Karaka 2
Provide for greater certainty for smaller urban land lots (800m
2
or less) around the Karaka
village.
6566-5 Glenn W Archibald glenn@aatax.co.nz Water
policies
Objectives
Provide for improved water quality, especially around Karaka village and the Manukau
Harbour through improvements to the wastewater, stormwater and water supply (by Council
and Watercare).
358/1145
Sub#/
6566-6 Glenn W Archibald glenn@aatax.co.nz Mana Whenua Auckland wide - Mori Land
controls
Amend to provide greater certainty for Mori 'to utilise their land holdings for the good of their
Whanau', especially in rural areas.
6566-7 Glenn W Archibald glenn@aatax.co.nz RPS
Provide for new regional and national transport links including; the Karaka-Weymouth link, a
Manukau Heads north-south link, a road transport network that circles the
Manukau Harbour and a Manukau Harbour bridge route.
6567-1 Michael K Smith michael.k.smith@xtra.co.nz RPS Mana Whenua B5 Strategic
approval.
6568-1 Murray J Porteous mporteous54@gmail.com Historic Heritage (Overlay)
Heritage
Places
Review and determine whether 13 Arthur Street, Onehunga should be classified as a site with
contributing buildings (Suttie's Estate Historic Heritage Area).
6569-1 Phillip Guthrie
17 Gavin Street, Ellerslie, Auckland
1060 General Miscellaneous
Operational/
Reject proposals to reinstate the pedestrian underpass beneath the Southern Motorway,
between 19 Gavin Street to McNab Street, Ellerslie.
6569-2 Phillip Guthrie
17 Gavin Street, Ellerslie, Auckland
1060 Zoning Central
Rezone Gavin Street and Eaglehurst Street, Ellerslie, from Mixed Housing Suburban to a
residential zone with a two storey height limit (reject four storey height limit) [While specific
reference has been made to Ellerslie Precincts 1 and 2, development control 3.1 'Height',
these streets are not located within a precinct].
6570-1 Lavinia E White
approval.
6571-1 Michael and Lisa Langdon cherie@laneassociates.co.nz Historic Heritage (Overlay)
Heritage
Places Delete the Category B listing on the site at 44 Cheltenham Road, Devonport.
6571-2 Michael and Lisa Langdon cherie@laneassociates.co.nz Special Character
North Shore Retain the Special Character overlay that applies to 44 Cheltenham Road, Devonport.
6571-3 Michael and Lisa Langdon cherie@laneassociates.co.nz Historic Heritage (Overlay)
Heritage
Places
Add the information available in the 2013 Conservation Plan to the listing information for 44
Cheltenham Road, Devonport. [if the historic heritage notation is not removed as requested in
submission point 1 on p 4/12]
6572-1 Glenn Ward
6/45 Rockfield Road, Ellerslie,
Auckland 1061 Precincts - Central Ellerslie 1
Amend development control K2.6.3.1 'Height', to reduce heights from four storeys to two
storeys.
6573-1
Devonport Business
Association cherie@laneassociates.co.nz
shafts survey coordinates Delete the Height Sensitive area overlay from the Devonport Town Centre.
6573-2
Devonport Business
Delete the Height Sensitive Area overlay from the Light Industry zone in Wynyard St,
Devonport.
6573-3
Devonport Business
Association cherie@laneassociates.co.nz Built Environment (Overlays)
Height Control Retain the height of 12.5m in the Devonport Town Centre, without further overlay reductions.
6573-4
Devonport Business
control
Amend Activity Table, line 1, as follows; ' Total or substantial demolition (more than 30 per
cent by volume) or removal of any building, excluding accessory buildings, constructed prior
to 1944 '.
6573-5
Devonport Business
Association cherie@laneassociates.co.nz Definitions Existing
Amend 'Total or substantial demolition' to include specific reference to the 'pre 1944
demolition building' control.
6573-6
Devonport Business
Amend 'Total or substantial demolition' so that where there is reference to 'demolition' for 'a
character-defining or character-supporting building or identified building in a special character
area', it also reads; 'To cause or instigate complete or irreversible material destruction,
damage or modification.'.
6573-7
Devonport Business
control
Amend 3.1 matters of discretion for restricted discretionary activities, clause (1)(c), to delete
the reference to 'substantial demolition'.
6573-8
Devonport Business
control
Amend 3.2 assessment criteria for restricted discretionary activities, clause (4), so that all
references to 'dwelling' are amended to 'building'.
6573-9
Devonport Business
control
Amend 3.2 assessment criteria for restricted discretionary activities, clause (2), to delete
references to the demolition of pre 1944 buildings being considered in respect of their 'quality
as part of a special character area'.
6573-10
Devonport Business
control
references to the contribution the building makes in terms of its 'coherent repetition of
buildings of similar style'.
6573-11
Devonport Business
Association cherie@laneassociates.co.nz Definitions Existing Delete 'partial demolition or destruction' in its entirety.
6573-12
Devonport Business
Centre)
Maps only Retain the application of the Key Retail Building Frontage in the Devonport Town Centre.
6573-13
Devonport Business
Association cherie@laneassociates.co.nz Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
Retain the 'no parking permitted' controls that apply to sites subject to a Key Retail Frontage
overlay in Devonport.
6573-14
Devonport Business
Association cherie@laneassociates.co.nz General Miscellaneous
Operational/
Projects/Acquisition Retain all kerbside parking in Devonport as unmetered so it is freely available to the public.
359/1145
Sub#/
6573-15
Devonport Business
Centre)
obs & pols Retain the objectives and policies that support future intensification.
6573-16
Devonport Business
Centre)
obs & pols
Retain the objectives and policies that support mixed use development with a residential
component.
6573-17
Devonport Business
Centre)
obs & pols Retain the objectives and policies that support buildings of four to eight storeys.
6573-18
Devonport Business
Association cherie@laneassociates.co.nz Zoning North and Islands Rezone 1-21 Wynyard St, Devonport, from Light Industry to Town Centre.
6573-19
Devonport Business
Association cherie@laneassociates.co.nz Built Environment (Overlays)
Height Control
Add a height limit of 12.5m to 1-21 Wynyard St, Devonport, in line with the rest of the
Devonport Town Centre. [see also submission point 18]
6573-20
Devonport Business
Association cherie@laneassociates.co.nz Zoning North and Islands Retain the Light Industry zoning at 27 Lake Road, Devonport.
6574-1 Louise Stoupe marbuthnot@bentley.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - Urban zones H5.2 3.1 Residential zones
Amend the minimum site size for subdivision [in 2.3.1(1)(b)(i) and Table 1] in the Single
House zone from 600m
2
to 500m
2
.
6574-2 Louise Stoupe marbuthnot@bentley.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - Urban zones H5.2 3.1 Residential zones
Amend site size [in 2.3.1(1)(b) and Table 1] to be 'gross' site area as opposed to 'net' site
area.
6575-1 John and Louise Sinclair cherie@laneassociates.co.nz Precincts - North Smales 2
Amend the objectives and policies with reference to Sub-precinct B to; acknowledge the
proximity of the precinct to the adjoining Single House zone and Mixed Housing Suburban
land which has frontage to Rangitira Ave; and to consider topography and the need to restrict
development in the precinct to maintain and enhance the residential amenity on these
adjacent sites.
Amend the objectives and policies so that the framework plan follows the allowable controls
which already provide for increased development opportunity.
Clarify the meaning of 4.2(1)(a) Controls on Dwellings: Sub-precinct B; '1. Any framework
plan (including any amendments to an approved framework plan and any replacement
framework plan) shall provide: a. only for single dwellings within 10m of the western edge of
the lakeside yard '.
Amend 4.2(1)(a) Controls on Dwellings: Sub-precinct B; '1. Any framework plan (including
any amendments to an approved framework plan and any replacement framework plan) shall
provide: a. only for single dwellings within 10m of the western edge of the lakeside yard only
detached dwellings of no greater than 8m in height at no closer than 10m to the western edge
of the 30m lakeside yard. For the avoidance of doubt this has the effect of an extended
lakeside yard at 40m'.
Amend 5.2.1 Building height, Table 1 under Location, as follows; ' Within 10m 20m of land
zoned residential (Single House or Mixed Housing Suburban zones)' and so the 'Maximum
Storeys' are '2'.
Amend 5.2.1 Building height, Table 1 under Location, as follows; ' Within 10m of At a setback
of no less than 10 from the Lakeside Yard' and so the 'Maximum Storeys' are '2'.
Amend 5.2.3 Yards so the Purpose also considers effects on Rangitira Avenue. Refer to
submission for proposed changes. [page 5/9]
Amend 5.2.3 Yards, Table 3, so that the yard from Northcote Road decreases from 7m to 5m.

Amend 5.2.3 Yards, Table 3, so that the yard from the 'Sub-precinct boundary with land zoned
Residential' increases from 3m to 5m.
6575-10 John and Louise Sinclair cherie@laneassociates.co.nz Precincts - North Smales 2 Amend 5.2.3 Yards, Table 3, so that the 'Lakeside Yard' increases from 30m to 40m.
Amend 2. Notification, clause (1), to delete the statement that framework plans will be
considered 'without the need for public notification'.
Amend 2. Notification, clause (1), so that all aspects of the framework plan and development
are subject to the normal RMA test for notification.
Amend 2. Notification, clause (1), to specifically state that notification to adjoining land owners
is likely to be required.
Delete the 'incentives' in the form of development controls that are offered for the preparation
of a framework plan.
Add a specific assessment criterion that considers inter-site amenity with neighbouring
residential land for the consideration of framework plans.
6575-16 John and Louise Sinclair cherie@laneassociates.co.nz Precincts - North Smales 2 Retain the concept of a framework plan. [page 6/9]
6576-1 Graham and Lynette Mourant cherie@laneassociates.co.nz Precincts - North Smales 2
adjacent sites.
360/1145
Sub#/
provide: a. only for single dwellings within 10m of the western edge of the lakeside yard only
Storeys' are '2'.
6576-8 Graham and Lynette Mourant cherie@laneassociates.co.nz Precincts - North Smales 2 Amend 5.2.3 Yards, Table 3, so that the yard from Northcote Road decreases from 7m to 5m.
6576-10 Graham and Lynette Mourant cherie@laneassociates.co.nz Precincts - North Smales 2 Amend 5.2.3 Yards, Table 3, so that the 'Lakeside Yard' increases from 30m to 40m.
6576-16 Graham and Lynette Mourant cherie@laneassociates.co.nz Precincts - North Smales 2 Retain the concept of a framework plan. [p 6/9]
6577-1 Tanagra Holdings Limited cherie@laneassociates.co.nz Precincts - North Smales 2
adjacent sites.
provide: a. only for single dwellings within 10m of the western edge of the lakeside yardonly
Storeys' are '2'.
submission for proposed changes. [p 5/9 vol 1]
6577-8 Tanagra Holdings Limited cherie@laneassociates.co.nz Precincts - North Smales 2 Amend 5.2.3 Yards, Table 3, so that the yard from Northcote Road decreases from 7m to 5m.
6577-10 Tanagra Holdings Limited cherie@laneassociates.co.nz Precincts - North Smales 2 Amend 5.2.3 Yards, Table 3, so that the 'Lakeside Yard' increases from 30m to 40m.
361/1145
Sub#/
6577-16 Tanagra Holdings Limited cherie@laneassociates.co.nz Precincts - North Smales 2 Retain the concept of a framework plan. [p 6/9 vol 1]
6577-17 Tanagra Holdings Limited cherie@laneassociates.co.nz Zoning North and Islands
Rezone 8-12 Rangitira Ave, Takapuna, from Mixed Housing Suburban to Mixed Housing
Urban.
6577-18 Tanagra Holdings Limited cherie@laneassociates.co.nz Residential zones Residential
General
Amend the building height rule to Increase the permitted building height at 8-12 Rangitira Ave,
Takapuna, to 14.5m. [refer also submission point 17 p 4/5 vol 2]
Amend the objectives and policies with reference to Sub-precinct A to; acknowledge the
proximity of the precinct to the adjoining Mixed Housing Suburban land, particularly 8-12
Rangitira Ave; and to consider topography and the need to restrict development in the
precinct to maintain and enhance the residential amenity on these adjacent sites.
Amend Policy 9 to move the location of the landmark building and to ensure it is a distance
from the residential zoned land on Rangitira Ave. See revised precinct plan on p 14/14 vol 3
of submission for requested area.
Move the location of the 'Area 1' block, as shown in the precinct plan, away from the boundary
with the residentially zoned land at 8 Rangitira Ave.
Clarify 5.1.1 Building Height, line 1 in Table 1, which reads; 'Within 20m of land zoned
residential (Single House or Mixed Housing Suburban zones) and within 20m of Rangitira
Avenue (This rule does not apply to the boundary between Sub-precincts A and B)'.
Amend 5.1.1 Building Height, line 1 in Table 1, so that it begins ' At a setback of no less than
20m from land zoned residential...'.
Clarify 5.1.1 Building Height, line 2 in Table 1, particularly the method by which building height
is measured in relation to 'A single building within Area 1'. Define clearly what RL 62m relates
to and what the resulting building height is and where.
Clarify 5.1.1 Building Height, line 3 in Table 1, particularly the method by which building height
is measured in relation to buildings 'Elsewhere in the sub-precinct'.
Clarify 5.1.1 Building Height, particularly the advice note after Table 1, that describes the
maximum height and maximum storeys as being 'measured in relation to the natural height of
the ground at the closest sub-precinct boundary'.
Amend 5.1.4 Side yards, rule (1) as follows; '1. 5m 10m where a boundary adjoins a
residential zone. '.
Amend 5.1.4 Side yards, rule (2) so that the minimum width of the side yard increases to 5m,
and the balance width increases to 5m. Refer to submission for proposed changes. [p 6/14 vol
3]
Amend 5.1.4 Side yards to make it clear that the yard setbacks apply to the 'Area 1' eastern
'boundary'.
Amend 5.1.4 Side yards to ensure that Area 1's 'step-in' from the site boundary to 8 Rangitira
Ave (as shown in the precinct plan) does not nullify the side yard requirement under this rule,
by removing the 'step-in' from the site boundary.
Amend 5.1.4 Side yards to ensure that Area 1's 'step-in' from the site boundary to 8 Rangitira
Ave (as shown in the precinct plan) does not nullify the side yard requirement under this rule,
by amending the wording of the rule to ensure that the setbacks apply regardless of whether
the Area 1 boundary adjoins or is close to the residential site boundary. [refer also to
submission point 30 on p 6/14 vol 3]
6577-32 Tanagra Holdings Limited cherie@laneassociates.co.nz Precincts - North Smales 2 Delete 5.1.6 Maximum tower dimensions in Area 1.
Amend 5.1.6 Maximum tower dimensions in Area 1 so that the large building structure it
provides for is more appropriate to the area. [see also submission points 32 and 34]
Amend 5.1.6 Maximum tower dimensions in Area 1 to delete the references to Clauses 4.5.3
and 4.5.4. [see also submission points 32 and 33]
6578-1 Jubilee Trust cherie@laneassociates.co.nz Zoning North and Islands
Rezone the properties along Barry's Point Road, Takapuna, from Light Industry to General
Business.
6578-2 Jubilee Trust cherie@laneassociates.co.nz Zoning North and Islands
Rezone the properties along Barry's Point Road, Takapuna, from Light Industry to a zone that
reflects, enhances and protects the existing pattern of activities and character of the area.
[see also submission point 1]
6579-1
Eden Roskill District Cricket
Club erdcc@xtra.co.nz Public Open Space Zones
D2.3 Sport & Active
362/1145
Sub#/
6579-2
Eden Roskill District Cricket
Club erdcc@xtra.co.nz Public Open Space Zones
D2.3 Sport & Active
6580-1 JRL and BJ Poor Trust cherie@laneassociates.co.nz Zoning Central Retain the Mixed Housing Urban zone at 43 Webber St, Pt Chevalier.
6580-2 JRL and BJ Poor Trust cherie@laneassociates.co.nz Residential zones Residential
Mixed Housing Urban zone Retain the development controls for the Mixed Housing Urban zone.
6581-1
Parnell Cricket Club
(Incorporated) parnellcc@xtra.co.nz Public Open Space Zones
D2.3 Sport & Active
6582-1 Wallace Flats Limited cherie@laneassociates.co.nz Special Character
Business
Character Statements - Bus. Retain the overlay as it applies to 270 Broadway, Newmarket.
6582-2 Wallace Flats Limited cherie@laneassociates.co.nz General
H6.5)
Prohibit the operation of temporary food stalls outside character defining buildings in
Newmarket.
Business
Character Statements - Bus. Delete the overlay from 1-3 Cowan St, Ponsonby.
Business
Character Statements - Bus. Delete the overlay from 2 Pompallier Terrace, Ponsonby.
6582-5 Wallace Flats Limited cherie@laneassociates.co.nz
Delete the Height Sensitive Area overlay from the Devonport Town Centre, and particularly 12
[see p 7/10 vol 4] and 14 [see p 10/13 vol 3] Clarence St.
shafts survey coordinates Delete the overlay from the Light Industry zone in Wynyard St, Devonport.
6582-7 Wallace Flats Limited cherie@laneassociates.co.nz Built Environment (Overlays)
Height Control Retain the height of 12.5m in the Devonport Town Centre, without further overlay reductions.
control
to 1944 '.
6582-9 Wallace Flats Limited cherie@laneassociates.co.nz Definitions Existing
6582-10 Wallace Flats Limited cherie@laneassociates.co.nz Definitions Existing
control
control
control
control
6582-15 Wallace Flats Limited cherie@laneassociates.co.nz Definitions Existing Delete 'partial demolition or destruction' in its entirety.
Centre)
Centre)
obs & pols
component.
Centre)
6582-19 Wallace Flats Limited cherie@laneassociates.co.nz Historic Heritage (Overlay)
Heritage
Places Retain the historic heritage place overlay (ID 1130) that applies to 12 Clarence St, Devonport.
6582-20 Wallace Flats Limited cherie@laneassociates.co.nz Historic Heritage (Overlay)
Heritage
Places
Retain the historic heritage extent of place overlay (ID 1130) that applies to 12 Clarence St,
Devonport.
control
Retain the position by which no pre-1944 building demolition overlay applies to 12 Clarence
St, Devonport.
6583-1
Cornwall Districts Cricket and
Sports Association cornwall@xtra.co.nz Public Open Space Zones
D2.3 Sport & Active
6584-1 The Brenda Trust cherie@laneassociates.co.nz
control
Building demolition control J.3.6 Rules and mapping Remove the overlay from the site at 978-980 New North Rd, Mt Albert.
363/1145
Sub#/
6585-1
Birkenhead Town Centre
Operational/
Projects/Acquisition Retain all kerbside parking in Birkenhead as unmetered so it is freely available to the public.
6585-2
Association cherie@laneassociates.co.nz Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
Enable applications for vehicular access to sites subject to a Key Retail Frontage overlay in
Birkenhead to be considered on merit.
6585-3
Operational/
Projects/Acquisition Identify and develop public car park areas in Birkenhead.
6585-4
Association cherie@laneassociates.co.nz General Editorial and Part 6 Amend all references in the PAUP from 'Highbury' Town Centre to 'Birkenhead Village'.
6585-5
control
to 1944 '.
6585-6
6585-7
6585-8
control
6585-9
control
6585-10
control
6585-11
control
6585-12
Association cherie@laneassociates.co.nz Definitions Existing Delete 'partial demolition or destruction' in its entirety.
6585-13
Centre)
6585-14
Centre)
obs & pols
component.
6585-15
Centre)
6586-1
Suburbs New Lynn Cricket
Club sgate123@world-net.co.nz Public Open Space Zones
D2.3 Sport & Active
6587-1 St David's in the Fields joanne.graves@gmail.com Historic Heritage (Overlay)
Heritage
Places
Amend the Historic Heritage Place - 2591, Fields (El Ray Country Club) and the Historic
Heritage Extent of Place - 2591, Fields (El Ray Country Club) [at 202 Hillsborough Road,
Hillsborough] to enable provisions to facilitate the construction of a covered walkway between
the Church to the Church House.
Heritage
Places
Amend the Historic Heritage Place - 2591, Fields (El Ray Country Club) so that an exclusion
includes the North East facade of the Church House in order to facilitate the building of a
covered walkway between the Church and Church House.
Heritage
Places
Amend the Historic Heritage Extent of Place - 2591, Fields (El Ray Country Club) [at 202
Hillsborough Road, Hillsborough] so that the North East boundary of the Heritage Place is
shifted south-westwards till it is adjacent to the Church house as shown on photo 4 on page
13/14 of the submission.
Heritage
places
Amend the Historic Heritage Extent of Place - 2591, Fields (El Ray Country Club) [at 202
Hillsborough Road, Hillsborough] to enable permanent signage [bigger than the permitted
0.5m
2
and preferably more than two signs]. Also enable temporary signage to promote special
services where signs may be attached 4-6 weeks prior to Christmas Day and Easter Sunday.
Heritage
Places
Hillsborough] to reflect the plan on page 14/14 of the submission.
Heritage
Places
Hillsborough] to remove any protection afforded to the two Phoenix Palm Trees. Protection of
the Norfolk Island Pine may remain.
6588-1 Carter Auckland Limited simon.ash@wintonpartners.co.nz
Centre)
desc, obs & pols Amend Policy 4 to add the word 'residential' after 'commercial'.
364/1145
Sub#/
Centre)
desc, obs & pols
Replace Policy 5 with the following: 'Ensure residential development is designed appropriately
with respect to its location and street frontage'.
Centre) Business
Park zones
Amend rule 1(1) 'Development control infringements' so that in the metropolitan centre zone
the development control infringements that trigger this rule are limited to: (a) Height (b) Height
in relation to boundary (c) Tower separation (d) Yards.
Centre) Business
Park zones
Amend development control 5. 'Maximum Tower Dimension and Tower Separation' by
deleting the rule relating to maximum tower dimension but retaining the tower separation rule.
Centre) Business
Park zones
Amend development control 6. 'Buildings fronting the street' in the metropolitan zone
by retaining the control as it applies to 'key retail frontage' and 'general commercial frontage'
but deleting the control as it applies to other frontages not subject to the key retail or general
commercial frontage overlay.
Centre) Business
Park zones
Amend development control 8. 'minimum floor to ceiling height' by reducing the
minimum finished floor-to-floor height on the ground floor of buildings subject to a key retain
frontage or commercial frontage from 4.5m to 4m (for a minimum depth of 10m).
Centre) Business
Park zones
Amend development control 8(2)(f) 'minimum floor to floor ceiling height' as follows: 'those
parts of Metropolitan and Town Centre zones that adjoin arterial roads and are not subject to
the Key Retail Frontage and General Commercial Frontage overlay.'
Centre) Business
Park zones
Amend development control 9(2)(c)(vii) 'Glazing' as follows: 'Those areas in the Metropolitan
Centre fronting arterial roads and Town Centre zones not subject to a Key Retail Frontage
overlay.'
Centre) Business
Park zones
Replace development control 11(1) Residential at ground floor with the following new wording:
'Dwellings in the metropolitan centre must not locate on the ground floor of a building
adjoining streets subject to a key retail frontage overlay or commercial frontage overlay or
arterial road classification'.
Centre) Business
Park zones
Amend control 20(1)(a)(vi) Dwellings, visitor accommodation and boarding houses - outdoor
living space by reducing the minimum width of the balcony to 1.8m (note the 8sqm minimum
size is retained).
Centre) Business
Special information
requirements
Amend 6.1 Matters of discretion and 6.2 Assessment criteria as detailed in the submission on
pages 7/58 to 12/58.
Centre) Business
Special information
requirements
Amend Assessment development control infringements in 7.1 and 7.2 as detailed in the
submission on pages 12/58 to 15/58.
6588-13 Carter Auckland Limited simon.ash@wintonpartners.co.nz General Chapter G General provisions
Amend the last sentence of the fourth paragraph of the Introduction to framework plans as
follows: ..and any applicable overlays, unless otherwise stated in the Precinct Plan'.
Amend the fifth paragraph of the Introduction to framework plans by adding the word
'generally' after 'must' in two instances.
Amend eighth paragraph of the Introduction to framework plans as follows: '...prior to the
approval of a framework plan, however in some cases, a more onerous activity status...'.
Amend rule 2.6.2(c) Activity status and notification to amend the activity status that an activity
defaults from non-complying to discretionary.
Amend the Assessment criteria for framework plans in (8) as set out in the submission on
page 17/58.
G2.7.3 Framework plans Delete Rule 2.7.3.1(h) of the information requirements for framework plans.
6588-19 Carter Auckland Limited simon.ash@wintonpartners.co.nz Earthworks
and policies
Amend Policy (2)(a) as follows: 'retain soil and sediment on the land, and to the extent
practicable not discharge it to water bodies...'
6588-20 Carter Auckland Limited simon.ash@wintonpartners.co.nz Earthworks
and policies
Amend Policy 2(b) 'carefully manage limit the amount of land being disturbed at any one
time...'
6588-21 Carter Auckland Limited simon.ash@wintonpartners.co.nz Earthworks H4.2.1.1 Activity table - Zones
Amend the Activity Table under the heading 'General earthworks not expressly either
permitted...' the third row as follows: 'From 501m2 up to 1000m2 2500m2 and from 251m3 up
to 1000m3 2500m2'. In addition amend the Activity Table so this amended activity is a
Permitted Activity in Residential zones [as opposed to a Restricted Discretionary Activity].
Amend the Activity Table for 'General earthworks not expressly either permitted or requiring
resource consent above' as follows: 'Greater than 2500m2 and 2500m2 1ha' and amend the
activity status from Discretionary to Restricted Discretionary in 'All other zones and roads'.
Amend the Activity Table under the heading 'General earthworks not expressly either
permitted...' the fourth row as follows: 'Exceeding 2501m2 or 2501m3 From 1001m2 up to
2500m2 and from 1001m3 up 2500m3'.
365/1145
Sub#/
6588-24 Carter Auckland Limited simon.ash@wintonpartners.co.nz Earthworks H4.2.3 Assessment
Amend 3.2 assessment criteria (1)(g) as follows: 'whether the extent or impacts of adverse
effects from the earthworks can be mitigated by limiting managing the design, duration,
season or staging of such works'
6588-25 Carter Auckland Limited simon.ash@wintonpartners.co.nz Earthworks H4.2.3 Assessment Delete the assessment criteria (1)(h).
6588-26 Carter Auckland Limited simon.ash@wintonpartners.co.nz Earthworks H4.2.3 Assessment
Amend assessment criteria (1)(h) as follows: 'the extent to which the area of the earthworksis
minimised and is consistent with the scale of development being undertaken.'
6588-27 Carter Auckland Limited simon.ash@wintonpartners.co.nz Water Stormwater
rules
Amend the Permitted activity in the Activity Table as follows: 'New impervious areas in an
urban area, including open space zones and special purpose zones within the RUB where the
impervious area meets the relevant development controls for the zones for impervious areas
is less than or equal to 1,000m2 and which does not increase the total impervious area of the
site to more than 1,000m2 '.
rules
Amend the Restricted Discretionary activity in the Activity Table as follows: 'New impervious
areas in an urban area, including open space zones and special purpose zones within the
RUB where the total site impervious area does not meet the relevant development controls in
the zone for impervious areas is increased to greater than 1,000m2 but less than or equal to
5,000m2'.
rules
Amend the activity for land subject to a structure or framework plan from a Controlled Activity
to be a Permitted Activity in the Activity Table and amend the rule wording as follows: 'New
impervious areas where the development has been subject to structure or framework planning
or subdivision consent that includes integrated land use and stormwater planning'
rules
Amend the permitted activity control 1.2.1(3)(a) 'Public roads operated by a road controlling
authourity' as follows: 'the new impervious area, including footpaths, cycleways and ancillliary
areas, must: (i) either be less than or equal to 5,000m
2
10,000m
2
, or (ii) be part of an
approved concept plan, framework plan, structure plan or subdivision consent.'
rules
Amend the permitted activity control 1.2.1(3)(b) as follows: 'at a minimum, stormwater
treatment must be applied to catchpits for concentrated flows, or by directing sheet flows
across vegetated areas where flows are not concentrated, or subject
to stormwater management processes before the stormwater enters a natural water body.
rules
Amend the permitted activity control 1.2.1(6)(a) as follows: 'New impervious areasless than or
equal to 1,000m2 meet the relevant development controls in the zone for impervious areas in
an urban area, including open space zones and special purpose zones within the RUB
(excluding public roads) (a) the total impervious area meets the relevant development controls
in the zone for impervious areas must be less than or equal to 1000m2 .
rules
Amend the following activity in the Activity Table from a Controlled Activity to a Permitted
Activity: 'The installation of high contaminant yielding roofing, spouting, cladding material or
architectural features, exceeding permitted activity area controls and where stormwater quality
management requirements are met'.
rules
Amend the following activity in the Activity Table from a Discretionary Activity to a Restricted
Discretionary Activity: 'The installation of high contaminant yielding roofing spouting, cladding
material or architectural features that does not meet the permitted and controlled activity
controls'.
rules
Amend the following activity in the Activity Table from a Controlled Activity to a Permitted
Activity: 'Impervious area greater than 5000m
2
where stormwater quality management
requirements are met'.
rules
Amend permitted control 3.2.1(2) as follows: 'New high contaminant-yielding roofing, spouting,
cladding or architectural features, either:... (iii)..., or ...(b) all potential high
contaminant yielding roofing, spouting, cladding or architectural features have been
sealed/treated to industry standards to prevent or minimise leeching or contaminants.'
rules
Amend permitted control 3.2.1(3) as follows: 'New, and redevelopment of existing, high use
public roads less than 5000m2 provided as a permitted activity ( a) The new/redeveloped
impervious area of the high use road must be less than or equal to 5000m2(a) (b) Stormwater
runoff from the new/redeveloped area, and any additional existing area discharging to the
same discharge point(s), must be managed by devices or a stormwater management system,
that are designed to meet the stormwater quality management requirements for the relevant
contaminants of concern in Tables 3 and 4.'
rules
Amend permitted control 3.2.1(4)(a) as follows: '(a) Stormwater runoff from the
new/redeveloped area must be directed to an existing stormwater quality management device
or stormwater management system, required by a current stormwater discharge consent...'
366/1145
Sub#/
6588-39 Carter Auckland Limited simon.ash@wintonpartners.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - general
and policies
Amend Policy 16 as follows: 'Require shared vehicle access to serve no more than eight rear
sites and to be of a width, length and form that...'
and policies
Amend Policy 21 by moving it from the heading 'All urban subdivision' to under the heading
'Urban subdivision of a parent site over 1ha with 15 or more proposed sites'.
and policies
Amend Policy 24(a) as follows: '(a) Where topography and parent site shape allows aligning
roads and sites for maximum sunlight access'.
and policies
Amend Policy 26(c) as follows: 'passive surveillance of public open spaces and ensure all
public open spaces are fronted with roads'.
controls
Amend control 1(1)(a) as follows: 'Where a framework, structure, concept and/or precinct plan
has been approved, all subsequent subdivision must be generally in accordance with...'
6588-44 Carter Auckland Limited simon.ash@wintonpartners.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - Urban zones H5.2.3.2 Business zones
Amend Table 4 'Standards for vacant site subdivision in the City Centre and Business zones'
minimum site size in the 'Mixed Use zone' from 200m
2
to 150m
2
.
Amend control (2)(a) 'Rear sites' as follows: 'Rear sites must not exceed 20 per cent of the
total number of proposed sites or such number of rear sites as defined in a concept plan or
precinct plan for the particular area.'
Amend control (4)(c) 'Parking areas' as follows: 'Discretion may be applied where specific
approval has been granted by resource consent for shared car parking with other
development within the same precinct area, or particular controls apply in a precinct,
framework plan, or concept plan.'
6588-47 Carter Auckland Limited simon.ash@wintonpartners.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - general H5.3 - 4 Assessment
Amend Table 14: 'Restricted discretionary activity assessment criteria' to modify the language
to be less mandatory and more like assessment criteria, and to amend some specific criteria
to allow more flexibility for different site sizes, the use of rear sites and access arrangements.
See the submission for detail on pages 27/58 to 35/58.
6588-48 Carter Auckland Limited simon.ash@wintonpartners.co.nz Definitions Existing
Amend the definition of 'Building coverage' to add an additional exclusion as follows: 'carparks
with a landscaping deck podium or structure above the carpark'.
6588-49 Carter Auckland Limited simon.ash@wintonpartners.co.nz Definitions Existing
Amend the definition of 'Rear site': 'A site with frontage of less than 8m 10m to a legal road,
except that a site served by a joint owned access lot or right or way easement service lane
for its vehicle access while providing for pedestrian access directly from a road is not a rear
site.'
6589-1 Jonathan Polglase lancehessell@tnp.co.nz Zoning South
Rezone Inchinnam Road and Gracechurch Road, Flat Bush from Large Lot Residential to
Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings as shown in Appendix 2 - Option A [page 20/26 of
submission].
6589-2 Jonathan Polglase lancehessell@tnp.co.nz Zoning South
Rezone Inchinnam Road and Gracechurch Road, Flat Bush from Large Lot Residential to
Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings as shown in Appendix 2 - Option B [page 20/26 of
submission].
6589-3 Jonathan Polglase lancehessell@tnp.co.nz Precincts - South Flat Bush
Amend sub-precinct on land from sub-precinct B to sub-precinct A as shown in Attachment 3
[page 22/26].
6589-4 Jonathan Polglase lancehessell@tnp.co.nz Precincts - South Flat Bush Amend precinct plans as shown in Attachments 4 and 5 [page 23 to 26/26 of submission].
6590-1 Thurlow Consulting Limited mark@thurlow.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - Urban zones
except Rural Amend the prohibited activity status in the Future Urban zone to non-complying
6590-2 Thurlow Consulting Limited mark@thurlow.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - Rural zones
zones only Amend the prohibited activity status to non-complying
6590-3 Thurlow Consulting Limited mark@thurlow.co.nz Definitions Existing
Amend the definitions of boundary adjustments and boundary relocations to clarify and
simplify differences between the two
6590-4 Thurlow Consulting Limited mark@thurlow.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - general
controls
Enable greater flexibility to accommodate a dwelling on a proposed site for subdivision of a
site within the 1 per cent AEP floodplain
6590-5 Thurlow Consulting Limited mark@thurlow.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - Urban zones H5.2 3.1 Residential zones
Amend rules 1 Site size, and 2 Site shape factor, as detailed on page 5/15 of the submission,
to clarify the outcomes sought by these rules.
Delete rule 3 [rear sites] and amend rule 4 [Access to rear sites] enable jointly owned access
lots or rights of way to serve 10 sites.
6590-7 Thurlow Consulting Limited mark@thurlow.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - Urban zones H5.2 3.1 Residential zones Clarify the dimensions in Table 2 [Access to rear sites]
area
Amend rule (8)(b)(iv) as follows: (iv) Subdivision that does not comply with this control is a
non-complying activity.
area
Add more flexibility in the application of controls on the identification of specified building
areas on subdivision plans to enable site specific characteristics to be taken into account
6590-10 Thurlow Consulting Limited mark@thurlow.co.nz Residential zones Residential Land use controls
Amend rule 3.1 Maximum density, for all residential zones to further clarify and explain the
aim of the provisions.
Amend [rule 1(a)] to reduce the minimum site size for subdivision in the Single House zone
from 600m2 to 500m2.
6590-12 Thurlow Consulting Limited mark@thurlow.co.nz Residential zones Residential Land use controls Amend rules to enable minor residential units in all residential zones.
6590-13 Thurlow Consulting Limited mark@thurlow.co.nz Rural Zones General I13.1 Activity table Amend to enable minor residential units in all rural zones
367/1145
Sub#/
6590-14 Thurlow Consulting Limited mark@thurlow.co.nz Residential zones Residential
General Delete the garage setback controls in rules 7.16(3), 8.16(3) and 9.15(3), Garages.
General
Amend rules 6.12, 7.22, 8.24 and 9.23 Universal access, to change the threshold from 20 per
cent of dwellings, to reflect the level of demand for dwellings with accessible facilities.
General
Amend rule 7.15, 8.15 and 9.14 Fences, to increase the maximum fence height from 1.2m to
1.8m.
Mixed Housing Urban zone Delete the glazing requirement from rule 7.13 and 8.10 [Dwellings fronting the street].
Amend rule 7.21(2) Storage, to read: 'The required storage space for each dwelling must
include a single covered storage space within internal dimensions...'
General
Delete the minimum dimensions of principal living rooms and principal bedrooms control in
rule 7.18, 8.19 and 9.18 [Minimum dimensions of principal living rooms and principal
bedrooms].
Mixed Housing Urban zone Delete rule 7.21 Storage.
Amend rule 8.18 Daylight to dwellings, to provide flexibility to enable good design to be
achieved by means not anticipated by the control.
Terrace Housing and
Apartment Buildings zone Retain rule 9.6 Minimum frontage and side width.
Terrace Housing and
Amend rule 9.7 Maximum impervious area, rule 9.8 Building coverage and rule 9.9
Landscaping, to facilitate intensive development.
6590-24 Thurlow Consulting Limited mark@thurlow.co.nz General Eplan
Amend the planning maps so adjoining zones are identified with more strongly contrasting
colours
6590-25 Thurlow Consulting Limited mark@thurlow.co.nz Zoning North and Islands
Rezone 23 and 26 Travis View Drive, Fairview Heights from Single House and Single House
and Mixed Housing Suburban [respectively] to Mixed Housing Urban
6590-26 Thurlow Consulting Limited mark@thurlow.co.nz Zoning North and Islands
Rezone 39 and 56 Fairview Ave, Fairview Heights from Mixed Housing Suburban and Mixed
Housing Urban [respectively] to Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings
6590-27 Thurlow Consulting Limited mark@thurlow.co.nz General Miscellaneous
Operational/
Projects/Acquisition Train and support council officers with appropriate resources to implement the Unitary Plan
6590-28 Thurlow Consulting Limited mark@thurlow.co.nz General Chapter G General provisions
activities
Amend so where a clear localised non-compliance with a rule is accompanied with an affected
party consent, a resource consent is not required
6590-29 Thurlow Consulting Limited mark@thurlow.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - general
and policies
Add the conversion of cross-lease titles into fee simple titles with a streamlined resource
consent process. Discourage new cross-lease titles
6591-1 Ross Clark biancahartley@tnp.co.nz RPS Changes to the RUB North and Waiheke Island
Rezone the low-lying sections of 522 Wainui Road, Upper Orewa as described in the
submission [described in Vol 1. Page 4/17, shown in Attachment 2 on pages 9 to 10/17 of
submission] as Future Urban up to approximately the 40m contour with the balance of the site
zoned as either Countryside Living or Rural Production.
6591-2 Ross Clark biancahartley@tnp.co.nz Zoning North and Islands Rezone 50 Tavern Road, Silverdale from Light Industry to Heavy Industry.
6592-1 Colin Chester shanehartley@tnp.co.nz Zoning North and Islands
Rezone 165 Wainui Road, Silverdale from General Buisness and Single House [split zoning]
to Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings.
6592-2 Colin Chester shanehartley@tnp.co.nz Built Environment (Overlays)
Height Control
Add an Additional Zone Height control overlay to 165 Wainui Road, Silverdale permitting a
height of 16m or 20m if a minimum of 35% of the required parking is within the envelope of
the building.
6593-1 Laryssa Spackman
17A Gavin Street, Ellerslie, Auckland
1060 Zoning Central
residential zone with a two storey height limit (reject four storey height limit). [While specific
6594-1 David Clelland courtney.david@xtra.co.nz Residential zones Residential
Mixed Housing Urban zone Amend rule 7.5 Yards, to reduce the front yard requirement from 4m to 2m.
6595-1 Poplar Trust shanehartley@tnp.co.nz Zoning North and Islands
Rezone part of 1 Poplar Lane, Stanmore Bay [page 4/14 of submission] from Large Lot
Residential to either Mixed Use, Mixed Housing Urban or Terrace Housing and Apartment
Buildings to enable high density residential apartment development, i.e. at least one
household unit per 200m
2
[Error - Submission describes site as 1 Poplar Road in the text but
shows 1 Poplar Lane as the site for the rezone].
368/1145
Sub#/
6595-2 Poplar Trust shanehartley@tnp.co.nz Zoning North and Islands
Rezone part of 1 Poplar Lane, Stanmore Bay [page 4/14 of submission] from Large Lot
Residential to Light Industry [Error - Submission describes site as 1 Poplar Road in the text
but shows 1 Poplar Lane as the site for the rezone].
6596-1 Thomas G Parsons parsonst@ihug.co.nz Designations Auckland Transport 1402 Road - Weiti Crossing
Delete the Penlink designation unless substantive progress towards its development is made
this year
6596-2 Thomas G Parsons parsonst@ihug.co.nz Zoning North and Islands Retain the Marina zoning of the Gulf Harbour Marina
6596-3 Thomas G Parsons parsonst@ihug.co.nz Precincts - North Gulf Harbour Marina
Amend the activity status of visitor accommodation and residential development, including
apartments and hotels to non-complying
Amend the extent of sub-precinct B to only cover the 'Hammerhead' [no site address
provided]
6596-5 Thomas G Parsons parsonst@ihug.co.nz Zoning North and Islands
Rezone the 'Hammerhead' in the Gulf Harbour Marina [no site address provided] to reflect the
development license and associated plan GHM2 and its current use
Rezone the Ferry terminal and associated parking at Gulf Harbour Marina [no site address
provided] from Marina to Public Open Space
Require esplanade and reserve areas from subdivision around the 'Hammerhead' in the Gulf
Harbour Marina [no site address provided]
6596-8 Thomas G Parsons parsonst@ihug.co.nz Precincts - North Gulf Harbour Retain the development cap of 2913 dwellings [rule K5.13.3.1]
6596-9 Thomas G Parsons parsonst@ihug.co.nz Precincts - North Rodney Landscape
Retain the 8000m minimum lot size over Coalmine Bay and land on the Whangaparaoa
Peninsula bordering the Weiti Estuary
6596-10 Thomas G Parsons parsonst@ihug.co.nz Zoning North and Islands Retain the Large Lot zoning over Coalmine Bay, Whangaparaoa
Retain the Public Open Space - Sport and Active Recreation zoning of the Whangaparaoa
golf course on Whangaparaoa Road, Whangaparoa [no site address provided]
Rezone 'Archers Block' on Whangaparaoa Peninsula [no site address provided] from Large
Lot to Public Open Space [zone not specified]
6596-13 Thomas G Parsons parsonst@ihug.co.nz Residential zones Residential Activity Table
Amend the activity status of 'Boarding house' activities in the Single House, Mixed Housing
Suburban and Mixed Housing Urban zones from Permitted and Discretionary to Non-
complying.
6596-14 Thomas G Parsons parsonst@ihug.co.nz Precincts - North Weiti Amend from providing for 1200 dwellings to 450 dwellings
Rezone the area of Mixed Housing Suburban around Tower Hill and Onepu area
[Whangaparaoa] to Single House
6597-1
Martin Wechselblatt and
Katherine Smits
23 Poronui Street, Mount Eden,
recreation facilities Reduce extent of intensification to ensure preservation of public open spaces.
6597-2
Katherine Smits
Amend activity status of "New buildings and external additions to existing buildings" and "A
single worker's accommodation dwelling" in the Conservation zone from
permitted to discretionary activity.
6597-3
Katherine Smits
Require discretionary activity status for "Farming or grazing as part of
a management programme for the public open space" in the Conservation zone with constant
oversight by Council.
6597-4
Katherine Smits
Auckland 1024 Public Open Space Zones Public Open Space I2.1 Activity table Amend activity types as set out in attachment to submission [no attachment provided].
6597-5
Katherine Smits
Auckland 1024
Amend Activity Table as follows: "Buildings and structures on a residential zoned site that
shares a boundary adjoining a volcanic feature up to 9m and no higher than the average
height above sea level of the boundary common with the volcanic feature."
6597-6
Katherine Smits
Auckland 1024
Amend Activity Table as follows: "Buildings and structures up to 8m high in a height sensitive
area except residential sites with a boundary adjoining a volcanic feature."
6597-7
Katherine Smits
Auckland 1024
Amend Activity Table as follows: "Buildings and structures not except in a height sensitive
area."
6597-8
Katherine Smits
Auckland 1024
Amend activity status for "Buildings and structures except in a height sensitive area" from non-
complying to prohibited.
6597-9
Katherine Smits
Auckland 1024
Amend Activity Table as follows: "Buildings and structures over 8m high in a height sensitive
6597-10
Katherine Smits
Auckland 1024
Amend activity status for "Buildings and structures over 8m high in a height sensitive area
except residential sites with a boundary adjoining a volcanic feature" from non-complying to
prohibited.
6597-11
Katherine Smits
Auckland 1024
Amend Activity Table as follows: "Buildings and structures on sites residential zone that
shares a boundary adjoining a volcanic feature higher than the average height above sea
level of the boundary common with the volcanic feature."
6597-12
Katherine Smits
Auckland 1024
Amend activity status for "Buildings and structures on residential zone that shares a boundary
adjoining a volcanic feature higher than the average height above sea level of the boundary
common with the volcanic feature" from non-complying to prohibited.
6597-13
Katherine Smits
Auckland 1024
sensitive areas rules J6.3 Rules Delete Figure 1 - Illustration of the approach to height sensitive areas.
6598-1 Mark Beckerleg mark.beckerleg@aut.ac.nz Residential zones Residential Land use controls
Add new rules to allow a minimum of two buildings per site on properties that adjoin reserves
and public open space, provided a minimum site area (e.g. 200m
2
) is provided.
369/1145
Sub#/
6599-1 Edward Hornsby shanehartley@tnp.co.nz Zoning North and Islands
Rezone Pt Lot 28 DP 1943, Arkles Strand, Arkles Bay from Public Open Space Conservation
to Single House. [Refer to page 4/11 of submission].
6600-1 David Josland
3/20 Hayden Street, Freemans Bay,
Terrace Housing and
Apartment Buildings zone Amend rule 9.10 'Outlook space' to refer to 'bedrooms' rather than 'principal bedroom'.
Mixed Housing Urban zone Delete rule 7.11 Separation between buildings within a site.
Amend rule 8.11(1) Separation between buildings within a site, to ensure it applies to
dwellings within the same building facing each other.
Terrace Housing and
Amend rule 9.11(1) Separation between buildings within a site, to ensure it applies to
dwellings within the same building facing each other.
General
Retain rules relating to 'outlook and 'separation between buildings within a site' and
amalgamate into one rule.
Terrace Housing and
Amend rule 9.22(2) 'Minimum floor to floor/ceiling height' to change the finished floor to
finished ceiling height requirement from 2.55m to 2.7m.
Add a new rule to the Mixed Housing Urban zone which requires a minimum width for
common corridors within multi-unit housing/apartment buildings. [Refer to the full submission
for suggested minimum dimensions, page 3-4/4]
Add a new rule to the Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings zone, which requires a
minimum width for common corridors within multi unit housing/apartment buildings. [Refer to
the full submission for suggested minimum dimensions page 3-4/4].
Add a new rule to the Mixed Housing Urban zone, which specifies that the maximum number
of residential units permitted from a single common circulation corridor is nine.
Add a new rule to the Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings zone, which specifies that the
maximum number of residential units permitted from a common circulation corridor is nine.
6601-1 No.1 The Strand Limited jarrod.reilly@colliers.com
control
Building demolition control J.3.6 Rules and mapping Delete overlay from 1-11 Shipwright Lane, Parnell.
6601-2 No.1 The Strand Limited jarrod.reilly@colliers.com Zoning Central Rezone 1-11 Shipwright Lane, Parnell from Light Industry to Mixed Use.
6602-1 Aberdeen Adventures Limited owen@greengroup.co.nz RPS Changes to the RUB West
Rezone land at Duke Street, Riverhead (Lot 1 DP 154985) from Rural Production to Future
Urban zone, or to Countryside Living zone with associated amendments to allow for a
minimum net site area of 1ha.
6603-1 Patricks Bay Development biancahartley@tnp.co.nz Zoning North and Islands
Rezone 114 Matua Road, Huapai from Large Lot to Single House by extending the Single
House zone already on the site to meet the Rural Urban Boundary in the North.
6603-2 Patricks Bay Development biancahartley@tnp.co.nz Precincts - North Huapai North
Amend the precinct maps by deleting sub-precinct C from 114 Matua Road, Huapai and
replacing it with sub-precinct B.
6603-3 Patricks Bay Development biancahartley@tnp.co.nz Precincts - North Huapai North
Amend Table 6 in rule K5.18.5.2 'Site size and shape factor' to make clear that the variance
of site sizes up to 15% as a Restricted Discretionary activity applies to both sub-precinct B
and sub-precinct C. See submission for further details [page 8/18 of submission].
6604-1 Anna Sharp a.sharp@orcon.net.nz Trees
Amend to provide a process whereby Council can be called upon to assess whether a tree is
creating a negative impact (on a neighbouring property) and require the owner of the trees to
rectify the situation. Refer to the full submission for further detail including criteria for
determining whether there is a negative impact {page 3/4].
6605-1 Sandee Investments Limited deanne@mhg.co.nz Zoning North and Islands
Rezone 5 Matariki Street, Omaha from Neighbourhood Centre to Neighbourhood Centre and
Single House as per map on page 5/9 of the submission
6605-2 Sandee Investments Limited deanne@mhg.co.nz Precincts - North Omaha South
Amend sub-precinct E so it excludes the part of 5 Matariki Street, Omaha shown on the map
on page 5/9 of the submission as being zoned Single House
6605-3 Sandee Investments Limited deanne@mhg.co.nz Precincts - North Omaha South Amend to enable dwellings to be located on the ground floor in sub-precinct E
6605-4 Sandee Investments Limited deanne@mhg.co.nz Precincts - North Omaha South
Amend the activity status of dwellings located on the ground floor of a building adjoining
public open space and streets in sub-precinct E to a restricted discretionary activity
6605-5 Sandee Investments Limited deanne@mhg.co.nz Historic Heritage (Overlay)
Heritage
Places Remove all historic heritage overlays which apply to 5 Matariki Street, Omaha
6605-6 Sandee Investments Limited deanne@mhg.co.nz Definitions Existing
Amend the definition of 'height' to include the vertical distance between the highest part of the
building and the average level of the ground at the external foundations of the buildings.
6605-7 Sandee Investments Limited deanne@mhg.co.nz General Cross plan matters Delete the maximum storey component from height controls
6605-8 Sandee Investments Limited deanne@mhg.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - Urban zones H5.2 3.1 Residential zones
Amend the residential zone subdivision controls to refer to 'gross site area' instead of 'net site
area'
370/1145
Sub#/
6605-9 Sandee Investments Limited deanne@mhg.co.nz Definitions New
Add the following definition for 'gross site area': Means the total area of a site including any
entrance strip. Add the diagram on page 7/9 of the submission to the definition
6605-10 Sandee Investments Limited deanne@mhg.co.nz General Chapter G General provisions
statements Delete the design statement requirements
6605-11 Sandee Investments Limited deanne@mhg.co.nz Mana Whenua General provisions
assessment
Amend the circumstances where cultural impact assessments and iwi engagement are
required
6605-12 Sandee Investments Limited deanne@mhg.co.nz Sustainable Development C7.7/H6.4 Sustainable design
Delete requirements for a 4 Greenstar rating or certification under the Living Building
Challenge
6605-13 Sandee Investments Limited deanne@mhg.co.nz Residential zones Housing affordability
and policies Delete affordable housing provisions
6605-14 Sandee Investments Limited deanne@mhg.co.nz
Centre) Business
Special information
requirements
Delete wind report requirement for buildings higher than 20m where a canopy is provided over
public space
6606-1 Christopher G Mitchell chrism@ardent.co.nz RPS Mana Whenua B5 Strategic Decline Mana Whenua provisions.
6607-1 Simon Latif simon.latif.nz@gmail.com
Centre) Business
Park zones Delete the minimum floor to ceiling height control [rule 4.8] in the [Town Centre zone]
6607-2 Simon Latif simon.latif.nz@gmail.com Built Environment (Overlays)
Height Control
Amend the height limit in the Town Centre zone in Orewa from between 16.5m and 24.5m to 3
storeys
6608-1 Paul Wigglesworth shanehartley@tnp.co.nz RPS Changes to the RUB North and Waiheke Island Rezone 36 Sidwell Road, Upper Orewa from Future Urban to Mixed Housing Urban.
6609-1 Julie Guthrie j.guthrie@xtra.co.nz Designations Transpower New Zealand Ltd 8501 Penrose Substation Increase the extent of designation 8501, to include 40-60 Wilkinson Road, Ellerslie.
6609-2 Julie Guthrie j.guthrie@xtra.co.nz General Miscellaneous
Operational/
Reject proposals to reinstate the pedestrian underpass beneath the Southern Motorway,
between 19 Gavin Street to McNab Street, Ellerslie.
6609-3 Julie Guthrie j.guthrie@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central
residential zone with a two storey height limit (reject four storey height limit) [While specific
6610-1 Allan H and Madge A Kirk akirk@vodafone.co.nz Public Open Space Zones Public Open Space
Amend development control 3.4 Table 1 'Building height' to provide for a maximum building
height of 10m in the Sport and recreation zone, rather than 15m.
6610-2 Allan H and Madge A Kirk akirk@vodafone.co.nz Public Open Space Zones Public Open Space
Amend development control 3.5 to provide for a height in relation to boundary control of 2.5m
+ 45 degrees in the Sport and Recreation zone.
6610-3 Allan H and Madge A Kirk akirk@vodafone.co.nz
area."
prohibited.
6610-12 Allan H and Madge A Kirk akirk@vodafone.co.nz Public Open Space Zones Public Open Space I2.1 Activity table
Extensively amend Activity Table to provide a more restrictive activity status regime across
multiple activities in all public open space zones. Refer to details in submission at page 10/32
of volume 1.
Amend J6.1.1 Activity Table, to provide a more restrictive activity status regime across
multiple activities on land within the ONF overlay. Refer to details in submission at page
13/32 of volume 1.
6610-14 Allan H and Madge A Kirk akirk@vodafone.co.nz Residential zones Residential
Delete rule 7.4 Alternative height in relation to boundary, and provide for a height in relation to
boundary control of 2.5m + 45 degrees.
371/1145
Sub#/
Delete rule 8.4 Alternative height in relation to boundary and provide for a height in relation to
boundary control of 2.5m + 45 degrees.
Terrace Housing and
Delete rule 9.5 Building setback, and provide for a height in relation to boundary control of
2.5m + 45 degrees for sites adjoining lower density zones.
6610-17 Allan H and Madge A Kirk akirk@vodafone.co.nz Zoning Central Rezone Poronui Street, Mt Eden, from Mixed Housing Suburban to Single House zone.
6610-18 Allan H and Madge A Kirk akirk@vodafone.co.nz Special Character
& C
Isthmus
Amend the Special character Isthmus B2 overlay one block north from Disraeli Street, Mt
Eden, and properties on include Poronui Street, Mt Eden.
6610-19 Allan H and Madge A Kirk akirk@vodafone.co.nz Residential zones Residential Notification
Amend Rule 1.2 - Notification, to require notification for all development control infringements
in all residential zones.
Amend rule 7.1 Development control infringments, to require notification and a design
assessment for any development control infringements.
Amend rule 8.1 Development control infringements, to require notification and a design
Amend rule 9.1 Development control infringments, to require notification and a design
6610-23 Allan H and Madge A Kirk akirk@vodafone.co.nz RPS Urban growth
recreation facilities Increase supply of public open space to meet demands of increased population.
6610-24 Allan H and Madge A Kirk akirk@vodafone.co.nz Zoning Central Rezone Winstone Quarry, Three Kings, as public open space.
6611-1 Ross P George ross@nzfibreglass.co.nz Zoning Central Rezone 22, 24 and 26 Lunn Ave, Mt Wellington from Mixed Housing Urban to Mixed Use.
6612-1 Stonedowle Trust stonedowle@xtra.co.nz Historic Heritage (Overlay)
Heritage
Places Delete those parts of the PAUP relating to the Sutties Estate Historic Heritage Area.
Heritage
Places
Amend the title of Appendix 9 to read 'Schedule of Significant Historic Heritage Places and
Areas'.
Heritage
Places
Amend Appendix 9.2.18 'Suttie's Estate historic heritage area' to reflect the heritage values
that have been correctly identified in the Heritage Assessment, and that are valued by the
community. Refer to the full submission for suggested wording [pages 6-7/8].
Heritage
Places
Amend Appendix 9.2.18 'Suttie's Estate historic heritage area' to correct typographical and
grammatical errors in the two paragraphs below the heading 'Other features present'. Refer to
the full submission for suggested wording [pages 6-7/8].
Heritage
Places
Delete the last paragraph of Appendix 9.2.18 'Suttie's Estate historic heritage area', which
references the Historic Heritage Survey of Onehunga 2013. Refer to the full submission for
Heritage
heritage areas
Amend the activity table to provide for 'Total, substantial or partial demolition or destruction of
a building, feature or landscape feature identified within a Category B historic heritage area'
as a restricted discretionary activity for contributing sites (rather than discretionary). [Amend
activity description and status].
Heritage
heritage areas
Amend the activity table to provide for subdivision (within contributing sites) as a restricted
discretionary activity (where the proposed lot size greater than or equal to 450m
2
) and as a
discretionary activity (where the proposed lot size is less than 450m
2
).
Amend control 2.1 'Maintenance and repair', so that it only applies to individually scheduled
buildings, or buildings within Significant Historic Heritage Areas or Category A Historic
Heritage Areas (and not buildings merely identified as contributing).
Add a new clause to 2.1 'Maintenance and repair', to enable maintenance and repair of
buildings that are not individually scheduled, without being unduly onerous. Refer to the full
submission for suggested wording [page 7/8].
Add a new clause to 4. 'Assessment - Restricted discretionary activities' to clarify that the
matters of discretions and assessment criteria for buildings of sites not otherwise individually
listed should only be assessed in relation to the identified heritage values listed in Appendix
9. Refer to the full submission for suggested wording [page 8/8].
Heritage
requirements
Add a new clause to clarify that special information requirements (and the entire provision),
does not apply to any contributing or non-contributing buildings or sites within Historic
Heritage Areas, unless individually listed in the PAUP.
6613-1 Jane A M Sims gordonandjane@gmail.com Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula K5.11 Precinct rules Amend the height limit in all sub-precincts to 8m and 2 storeys
6614-1 Deborah L Lawton debbie@montlaurvillagehouse.com Precincts - North Devonport Naval Base
Reduce maximum building heights from 4 storeys to a height that is congruous with existing
architecture in the area.
6614-2 Deborah L Lawton debbie@montlaurvillagehouse.com Precincts - North Devonport Naval Base Provide for the protection of trees.
6614-3 Deborah L Lawton debbie@montlaurvillagehouse.com Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula K5.11 Precinct rules
Reduce maximum building heights from 4 storeys to a height that is congruous with existing
architecture in the area.
6614-4 Deborah L Lawton debbie@montlaurvillagehouse.com Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula K5.11 Precinct rules Provide for the protection of trees.
372/1145
Sub#/
6615-1 David S Arvidson arvidsonz@gmail.com
Outstanding Natural
Rules
Outstanding Natural
Landscapes
Reject ONL overlay based on mapping inaccuracies and lack of community input, specifically
at Lot 1, 195215, Dunning Road, Whangapiro.
6615-2 David S Arvidson arvidsonz@gmail.com Water Aquifers/Groundwater
Reject Aquifers overlay based on mapping inaccuracies and lack of community input,
specifically at Lot 1, 195215, Dunning Road, Whangapiro.
6615-3 David S Arvidson arvidsonz@gmail.com
SEAs
Land
Reject SEA overlay based on mapping inaccuracies and lack of community input, specifically
at Lot 1, 195215, Dunning Road, Whangapiro.
6615-4 David S Arvidson arvidsonz@gmail.com Water
streams & wetland
Management Area
Reject High Use Stream Management Areas overlay based on mapping inaccuracies and lack
of community input, specifically at Lot 1, 195215, Dunning Road, Whangapiro.
6615-5 David S Arvidson arvidsonz@gmail.com Water
streams & wetland
Overlay E7.6 Natural Lake
Management Area
Reject Natural Stream Management overlay based on mapping inaccuracies and lack of
community input, specifically at Lot 1, 195215, Dunning Road, Whangapiro.
6615-6 David S Arvidson arvidsonz@gmail.com RPS Urban growth
quality compact urban form Reject greenfield development in South Auckland.
6615-7 David S Arvidson arvidsonz@gmail.com General Cross plan matters
Reject rezoning of private or company land holdings, Council should only rezone land it or a
community trust owns.
6616-1
Frederic and Anne-Catherine
Boles
Auckland 1024 Zoning Central Rezone Poronui Street, Mt Eden, from Mixed Housing Suburban to Single House zone.
6616-2
Boles
& C
Isthmus
6616-3
Boles
& C
Isthmus
6616-4
Boles
& C
Isthmus
6616-5
Boles
& C
Isthmus
area."
6616-6
Boles
& C
Isthmus
6616-7
Boles
& C
Isthmus
6616-8
Boles
& C
Isthmus
prohibited.
6616-9
Boles
& C
Isthmus
6616-10
Boles
& C
Isthmus
6616-11
Boles
Auckland 1024
6617-1 Evelyn Norton john.norton@lochores.co.nz Zoning North and Islands Rezone all of Neptune Ave, Beach Haven, to Mixed Housing Suburban.
6617-2 Evelyn Norton john.norton@lochores.co.nz RPS Urban growth
land for urban development Require transport solutions when intensifying areas.
6618-1 Pine Grove Farms l.clarke@harrisongrierson.com Subdivision Auckland-wide - general
and policies
Amend the objectives and policies to be less prescriptive and provide more flexibility and
higher level policy direction
6618-2 Pine Grove Farms l.clarke@harrisongrierson.com Rural Zones
desc, obs & pols
Amend the objectives and policies to be less prescriptive and provide more flexibility and
higher level policy direction
6618-3 Pine Grove Farms l.clarke@harrisongrierson.com Precincts - South Clevedon Amend the objectives and policies to be less prescriptive and allow for more flexibility
6618-4 Pine Grove Farms l.clarke@harrisongrierson.com Mana Whenua General provisions
assessment Delete the cultural impact assessment requirements
6618-5 Pine Grove Farms l.clarke@harrisongrierson.com Natural Hazards and Flooding Flooding H4.12 Rules
Amend activity table to enable avoiding, remedying and mitigating potential flood hazards as a
restricted discretionary activity
373/1145
Sub#/
6618-6 Pine Grove Farms l.clarke@harrisongrierson.com Precincts - South Clevedon
Amend activity table to provide further scope for existing rural activities and associated land
uses to continue in the Single House and Countryside Living zones prior to development
6618-7 Pine Grove Farms l.clarke@harrisongrierson.com Precincts - South Clevedon Delete framework plan provisions [rule 3.3]
6618-8 Pine Grove Farms l.clarke@harrisongrierson.com Precincts - South Clevedon Amend sub-precinct 3 to include the entire extent of 190 Papakura-Clevedon Road, Clevedon
6618-9 Pine Grove Farms l.clarke@harrisongrierson.com Zoning South Retain the Countryside Living zoning of 195 Monument Road, Clevedon
6618-10 Pine Grove Farms l.clarke@harrisongrierson.com Zoning South
Retain Single House and Countryside Living zoning for the extent of 190 Papakura-Clevedon
Road, Clevedon zoned as Single House and Countryside Living
6618-11 Pine Grove Farms l.clarke@harrisongrierson.com Zoning South
Rezone the portion of 190 Papakura-Clevedon Road, Clevedon zoned Mixed Rural to
Countryside Living
6618-12 Pine Grove Farms l.clarke@harrisongrierson.com General
GIS viewer Delete the flood hazards: flood plain (1 percent AEP) overlay
6619-1 Evans Family Trust l.clarke@harrisongrierson.com RPS Changes to the RUB South
Rezone 311 Porchester Rd and 54 Berwyn Ave, Takanini from Future Urban to Mixed
Housing Suburban
6619-2 Evans Family Trust l.clarke@harrisongrierson.com Mana Whenua General provisions
6619-3 Evans Family Trust l.clarke@harrisongrierson.com General
GIS viewer
Delete the flood hazards: flood plain (1 percent AEP) overlay from 311 Porchester Rd and 54
Berwyn Ave, Takanini
6619-4 Evans Family Trust l.clarke@harrisongrierson.com Water Stormwater
Management Area - flow Delete the SMAF 1 overlay from 311 Porchester Rd and 54 Berwyn Ave, Takanini
6619-5 Evans Family Trust l.clarke@harrisongrierson.com Subdivision Auckland-wide - general
and policies
Amend the objectives and policies associated with general subdivision and rural subdivision
by simplifying and moving prescriptive material to assessment criteria
6619-6 Evans Family Trust l.clarke@harrisongrierson.com Rural Zones General
objectives & policies Retain the 'rural economy' objectives and policies
6619-7 Evans Family Trust l.clarke@harrisongrierson.com Rural Zones
obs & pols
Retain the objectives and policies which seek to provide for a range of rural based activities to
be undertaken on landholdings of varying size
6619-8 Evans Family Trust l.clarke@harrisongrierson.com Natural Hazards and Flooding Flooding H4.12 Rules
Amend activity table to enable avoiding, remedying and mitigating potential flood hazards as a
[restricted discretionary activity]
6619-9 Evans Family Trust l.clarke@harrisongrierson.com Subdivision Auckland-wide - Rural zones
zones only Amend the activity status of prohibited activities to non-complying
6619-10 Evans Family Trust l.clarke@harrisongrierson.com Zoning South
Retain the Mixed Rural zoning of 267 Brookby Rd, Brookby and 140 Clevedon-Takanini
Road, Clevedon
6619-11 Evans Family Trust l.clarke@harrisongrierson.com General
GIS viewer
Delete the flood hazards: flood plain (1 percent AEP) overlay from 267 Brookby Rd, Brookby
and 140 Clevedon-Takanini Rd, Clevedon
6620-1 Terra Nova Planning shanehartley@tnp.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - general
and policies
Amend to provide for hamlet subdivision and development rules in Rural zones as currently
provided in the Auckland District Plan: Rodney Section so long as the rules are generically
applicable to qualifying sites and not dependent on prior identification by the Council.
6620-2 Terra Nova Planning shanehartley@tnp.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - Urban zones
except Rural
Amend Table 3: Future Urban zone in 1. Activity table to provide for subdivision to a minimum
site area of 4ha. See submission for further details [page 4/11 of submission].
6620-3 Terra Nova Planning shanehartley@tnp.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - Rural zones
area Delete the amalgamation of sites provisions in Table 7.
area
Amend Table 9 Boundary Adjustments and boundary relocation to reinstate the provisions of
the Operative Auckland District Plan: Rodney section.
area
Amend Transferable Rural Site Subdivision to incentivise transfer of titles out of Rural
Conservation zone sites, SEAs (and potential SEAs), ONLs and ONFs into a wider range of
recipient zones including Rural Production, Mixed Rural, Countryside Living, Rural
Conservation, and Rural and Coastal Settlements (but excluding areas with Elite and Prime
land - Class 1-3, SEAs, ONLs and ONFs in these zones).
area
Replace Table 8: Maximum number of new sites for transfer in rule 2.3.3 Rural zones with the
table outlined in submission [page 8 to 9/11 of submission] to provide greater flexibility in site
sizes and numbers in transferable rural site subdivisions.
area
Add a new Transferable Rural Subdivision category that would provide for additional sites for
every 30ha of land, where a 35 year programme of significant ecological enhancement will
occur. See submission for specific amendments [page 10 to 11/11 of submission. Note:
Kawau Island precinct rule number is referenced here but unclear why].
area
Include in the PAUP the Native Revegetation Planting standards as subdivision controls from
the Rodney District Plan. See submission for specific references to controls in the Rodney
District Plan [page 11/11 of submission].
6621-1
Norman Disney and Young
Limited r.finley@ndy.com General Noise and vibration H6.2 Rules
Amend rule 1.1(3) Noise arising from activities within zones, from 75dBA to 70dBA to be
consistent with rule (1).
374/1145
Sub#/
6621-2
Limited r.finley@ndy.com General Noise and vibration H6.2 Rules Delete rule 1.1(4) 'Noise arising from activities within zones'.
6621-3
Amend rule 1.1(6)(a) 'Noise arising from activities within zones' by applying a percentage of
time outside to eliminate contentiousness.
6621-4
Amend rule 1.1(7)(b) 'Noise arising from activities within zones' by increasing permitted
frequency of firing.
6621-5
Limited r.finley@ndy.com General Noise and vibration H6.2 Rules Amend rule 1.1(7)(c) 'Noise arising from activities within zones' by correcting formatting error.
6621-6
Amend rule 1.1(9)(a) 'Noise arising from activities within zones' to reference only emergency
generators to justify a slight increase in noise.
6621-7
Limited r.finley@ndy.com General Noise and vibration H6.2 Rules Amend rule 1.1(9)(a) 'Noise arising from activities within zones' from 75dBA to 70dBA.
6621-8
Delete maximum noise level (LAFmax) from rule 1.1(10)(a) 'Noise arising from activities within
zones' as it is not specified.
6621-9
Amend rule 1.1(11) 'Noise arising from activities within zones' to apply 63 and 135Hz limits for
Centres and Mixed Use zones at night time and music noise instead of between 7am and
10pm.
6621-10
Limited r.finley@ndy.com General Noise and vibration H6.2 Rules Delete rule 1.1(11)(a) 'Noise arising from activities within zones'.
6621-11
Amend rule 1.1(11)(b) 'Noise arising from activities within zones' to avoid being applied
between tenants within one ownership title.
6621-12
Amend rule 1.1(11)(b) 'Noise arising from activities within zones' from 45dB LAeq(15 min) in
other habitable spaces or classrooms to 63 and 125Hz within internal sleeping spaces L95 +
8dB at 63 and 125Hz.
6621-13
Amend rule 1.1(12) 'Noise arising from activities within zones' to apply 35dB LAeq(15min)
from only 10pm to 7am instead of at all times.
6621-14
Amend rule 1.1(14)(b)(i) 'Noise arising from activities within zones' to require at least 10 air
changes per hour instead of 6 or as required by the Ministry of Education if applicable.
6621-15
Amend rule 1.2(1) 'Noise arising from activities between zones' from 75dBA for the Coastal
zone interface to 70dBA.
6621-16
Amend rule 1.2(3) 'Noise arising from activities between zones' by applying 60dB Leq(15 min)
at 63 Hz and 55dB Leq(15 min) at 125 Hz to music noise only.
6621-17
Amend rule 1.4(7)(c)(i) 'Construction noise' as follows: [third bullet point] the type of work
planned and the noise and vibration likely to be generated.
6621-18
Limited r.finley@ndy.com General Noise and vibration H6.2 Rules Amend rule 1.5(2) 'Vibration' to reference AS 2670 or ISO 2631.
6621-19
Amend Table 15 in rule 1.5(2) 'Vibration' to expand list to include other sensitive uses that
warrant this level of protection. For example, rooms with microscope operations, cameras for
broadcast, medical purposes etc.
6621-20
Amend rule 1.8(1) General to include "...and overall dBA targets" to ensure the special
audible characteristics correction is applied to the overall dBA value as NZS 6802:2008
intends.
6621-21
Amend 2(2)(a)(iv) 'Assessment - Development control infringements' assessment criteria to
read "...existing background noise and vibration levels..."
6621-22
Amend 2(2)(3)(a) 'Assessment - Development control infringements' assessment criteria to
read "...should not create unreasonable potential for reverse sensitivity issues if approved".
6621-23
Limited r.finley@ndy.com General
H6.5)
Amend rule 2.1 'Noise events outside the City Centre zone' by substantially reducing the limits
and separating duration and frequency.
6621-24
Amend rule 2.5(1)(d)(v) 'Temporary military training' to use a simpler criteria to set an Lmax
target that can be quickly converted to contours and minimum distances.
6621-25
Limited r.finley@ndy.com
the CMA
D5.1.17 Underwater noise
from dredging, mineral
exploration & extraction
Delete 200dB at 1m in rule I6 2.1(a) 'Noise' and undertake consultation with experts to set a
sensible limit.
6621-26
Limited r.finley@ndy.com Transport
D7 and I14.1-5 Strategic
Transport Corridor Zone
Amend rule 3.4 'Noise' attenuation walls or fences to avoid risk of applicants calling a normal
fence, limited to 1.8m, a noise fence that can be 3m.
6621-27
Limited r.finley@ndy.com Airport Airport Zone I15 Rules
Delete rule 3.1(2) 'Noise' as follows: For the purpose of determining compliance with clause 1
above, aircraft noise should be assessed ... modified for local conditions if necessary, and
records of actual aircraft operations. The noise level must be calculated as a 90-day rolling
average. '
6621-28
Limited r.finley@ndy.com Public Open Space Zones
I18.4-5 Assessment I8.6
Special information
requirements
Add a new bullet point to 4.2(1)(a)(iii) 'Assessment - Restricted discretionary activities'
assessment criteria to read "the existing background noise levels at the residential
properties".
375/1145
Sub#/
6621-29
Limited r.finley@ndy.com Public Open Space Zones
Special information
requirements
Add a new bullet point to 5.2(1)(a)(iii) 'Assessment - Development control infringements'
assessment criteria to read "the existing background noise levels at the residential properties"
[inferred this point as words missing from original submission - page 8/14].
6621-30
Limited r.finley@ndy.com Mineral extraction Quarry zone
I20 Rules/G2.7.6 Special
Information Requirements
Amend rule 2.1(1) 'Noise (mineral extraction activities)' to be consistent with other night time
limits. For example, 40/70dBA.
6621-31
Limited r.finley@ndy.com Airport
Overlay E1.2/J1.2 Aircraft
Noise
Amend Figure 1 in 1. Activity table to clarify one location showing Ldn 55 and 65 contours
rather than piecemeal.
6621-32
Noise
Review ventilation requirements in rule 3.1 'Acoustic insulation and ventilation for ASAN in the
ANB, ICB and OCB' to ensure they are practical, consistent and sensible.
6621-33
Noise
Review ventilation requirements in rule 4.1 'Acoustic insulation and ventilation' to ensure they
are practical, consistent and sensible.
6621-34
Noise
Amend rule 4.1 'Acoustic insulation and ventilation' to cross reference to the correct clauses
as 4.1.1 and 4.1.3 do not exist.
6621-35
Limited r.finley@ndy.com Infrastructure
Overlay E1.3 /J1.3 City Centre
Port Noise
Amend 1. 'Land use controls' and 2. 'Assessment - Land use control infringements' to
measure durations consistently, either 15 or 1 hour.
6621-36
Port Noise
Reject 35dBA and 40dBA LAeq(1 hour) limits for bedrooms and habitable rooms from rule 1.
Land use controls [J1.3, City Centre Port Noise overlay rules].
6621-37
Port Noise
Review ventilation requirements in in overlay to ensure they are practical, consistent and
sensible [inferred from submission as text is missing - page 8/14, relating to J1.3, City Centre
Port Noise overlay rules].
6621-38
Limited r.finley@ndy.com General Noise and vibration H6.2 Rules Amend rule 1.5(1) 'Vibration' to read "Construction and blasting activities"
6621-39
Require vibration producers to do more than comply with DIN4150 to ensure good amenity
outcomes such as requiring compliance with BS 5228 (1mm/s PPV) for adjacent occupied
spaces. Applicants must show when this best practicable option is not practical and that the
selected alternative represents the next least intensive option to protect adjacent users to the
maximum practical level.
6621-40
Port Noise
Undertake consultation with affected residents regarding the extension of contours over the
Auckland Isthmus as shown in Map 1 'Noise contours' [J1.3, City Centre Port Noise overlay
rules].
6621-41
Reject 35dBA and 40dBA LAeq(1 hour) limits for bedrooms and habitable rooms in Table 1 in
rule 2.1 Noise.
6621-42
Amend rule 2.1(2) 'Noise' to set out a consistent method of measuring train activity that
recognises some lines will be noisier or quieter than others.
6621-43
Amend rule 2.1(3) 'Noise' to clarify if both 1dB and 2dB would apply to a given
development/facade or whether they are mutually exclusive.
6621-44
Limited r.finley@ndy.com Mineral extraction
Transport Route
Reject 35dBA and 40dBA LAeq(1 hour) limits for bedrooms and habitable rooms in rule
J1.7.2.2 Ventilation [inferred from submission as text is missing - page 8/14].
6621-45
Buffer Area
Reject J1.6.3(3.1.2)(1)(c) 'Assessment - Restricted discretionary activities' assessment criteria
which specifies habitable spaces shall be no more than 40Ldn.
6621-46
Transport Route
Reject 35dBA and 40dBA LAeq(1 hour) limits for bedrooms and habitable rooms in Table 1 in
rule J1.7.2.1(2) Noise.
6621-47
Transport Route
Reject 35dBA and 40dBA LAeq(1 hour) limits for bedrooms and habitable rooms in rule 2.2(2)
Ventilation [inferred from submission as text is missing - page 9/14].
6621-48
Limited r.finley@ndy.com Precincts Ak-Wide and Coastal Motor Sports
Amend rule K1.5.2.1.3(1) 'Noise from motorsport activities' to show how this will be assessed
[inferred from submission - page 10/14].
6621-49
Limited r.finley@ndy.com Precincts Ak-Wide and Coastal Stadiums and Showgrounds K1.10 Precinct Rules
Amend 2.1(1)(b)(iii) 'Noise' to substantially revise limits either by limiting number of events,
overall noise levels or low frequency limits to protect residents from permitted amplified music
levels.
6621-50
Amend rule 3.1.3(4)(b) and (c) 'Specific activities' by requiring clause (b) to comply with
normal residential zone boundary noise limits and by deleting clause (c).
6621-51
Amend rule 1.1(2)(a) 'Noise' (North Shore Events Centre) to align with Environment Court
Decision No A 009/2006.
6621-52
Amend rule 1.1(2) 'Noise' (Western Springs Stadium) to align with the Report of Independent
Commissioner Hon Peter Salmond, 11 September, 2006.
6621-53
Amend rule 1.1(4) 'Noise' (Western Springs Stadium) to match consent conditions imposed
for the Big Day Out.
6621-54
Limited r.finley@ndy.com Precincts - Central Old Government House
Amend K2.15.4.2(1)(a) 'Assessment - Restricted discretionary activities' assessment criteria
to include limits on noise.
6621-55
Limited r.finley@ndy.com Precincts - Central rkei Point K2.18 Precinct Rules
Amend rule 4.7 'Noise' to reflect joint statement of Noise Experts ENV 2011 AKL 000077,
000078 and 0000131 and to apply daytime and night time external noise criteria (65dB Laeq,
15hr day criterion etc.).
6621-56
Undertake discussions with experts regarding the use of Maximum weighted velocity Vw,95 in
relation to vibrations from trains (rule 4.4 'Vibration').
376/1145
Sub#/
6621-57
Amend rule 4.8(1)(a) and (b) 'Noise emission' by reducing noise level from LAmax 75 dB to
70dBA Lmax.
6621-58
Limited r.finley@ndy.com General Noise and vibration H6.2 Rules Amend rule 2.1 'Noise' to only apply to music noise.
6621-59
Limited r.finley@ndy.com Precincts - City Centre Wynyard K3.14 Precinct Rules
Amend Table 1 in rule 4.4 'Noise' to clarify which noise limits apply to areas 1 and 2 and apply
70dBA Laeq (15min) to source location Noise Areas 1 and 2.
6621-60
Limited r.finley@ndy.com Precincts - North Dairy Flat
Reject rule K5.9.8. 'Special information requirements' having one criteria applying to
bedrooms and habitable spaces.
6621-61
Limited r.finley@ndy.com Precincts - North Hobsonville Corridor
Amend the phrase "...designed and/or managed to avoid or mitigate any potential for effects
arising from noise..." in 6.2(2)(i) 'Assessment - Restricted discretionary activities' assessment
criteria by setting noise limits [inferred this is the correct provision reference as submission
reference leads to incorrect provision - page 11/14].
6621-62
Limited r.finley@ndy.com Precincts - North Riverhead 2
Amend the phrase "... not diminished by effects such as a reduction in privacy..." in
K5.36.4.2(4)(d) 'Assessment - Restricted discretionary activities' assessment criteria by
setting noise limits.
6621-63
Limited r.finley@ndy.com Precincts - North Riverhead 4
Amend the phrase "... not diminished by effects such as a reduction in privacy..." in
K5.38.4.2(3)(d) 'Assessment - Restricted discretionary activities' assessment criteria by
setting noise limits.
6621-64
Limited r.finley@ndy.com Precincts - North Silverdale 2
Amend the phrase "The site should be screened so that the amenity values of nearby zones
are not diminished by effects..." in K5.43.5.2(6) 'Assessment - Controlled activities' by setting
noise limits.
6621-65
Limited r.finley@ndy.com Precincts - North
Rodney Thermal Energy
Generation
Use consistent vibration assessment and applicable standards in the PAUP, specifically in the
Rodney Thermal Energy Generation precinct rule K5.41.2.31 Vibration.
6621-66
Limited r.finley@ndy.com Precincts - North Takapuna 2
Amend rule K5.48.4.2(2)(z) 'Assessment - Restricted discretionary activities' to read "z. Plant
and equipment including mechanical ventilation should be located and designed to minimise
comply with applicable limits noise intrusion ..."
6621-67
Limited r.finley@ndy.com Precincts - North Waiwera Amend table 2 in rule 2.6 'Noise' as follows: 70 dBA Lmax.
6621-68
Limited r.finley@ndy.com Precincts - South Clevedon
Amend rule 6.2(3)(l) 'Assessment - Restricted discretionary activities' assessment criteria to
set noise limits.
6621-69
Limited r.finley@ndy.com Precincts - South Flat Bush
Amend rule 3.5(1)(a) 'Noise Insulation Requirement for an Attached Dwelling' to be less
onerous and reflect changes to NZBC clause G6.
6621-70
Limited r.finley@ndy.com Precincts - South Flat Bush
Delete horizontal assessment from rule 3.5(1)(d) 'Noise Insulation Requirement for an
Attached Dwelling'.
6621-71
Limited r.finley@ndy.com Precincts - South Mngere 1
Amend rule K6.12.2.5 'Noise' by lowering the maximum noise limit from 75 dBA Lafmax to
70dBA [inferred from submission as text is missing - page 11/14]
6621-72
Limited r.finley@ndy.com Precincts - South Mngere 1
Amend rule K6.12.4(3) 'Noise', (under 'Assessment - Development control infringements -
Assessment criteria), to set clear noise limits rather than use of best practicable measures
which may imply discretion to not meet nominated limits.
6621-73
Limited r.finley@ndy.com Precincts - South Waiuku
Amend rule 27.5(1)(d) 'Assessment - Controlled activities' assessment criteria to set noise
limits.
6621-74
Limited r.finley@ndy.com General Noise and vibration
and policies
Add rule in the policy section that activities should aim to comply with BS5228 (1mm/s PPV)
for adjacent occupied spaces. Where that is not practical, the applicant shall demonstrate that
this cannot be achieved and that the selected alternative represents the next least intensive
option to protect adjacent users to the maximum practical.
6621-75
transport noise
and policies
Review technical presentation to understand limitations of using World Health Organisation
guidelines [see submission for further details - page 14/14].
6621-76
transport noise
and policies Delete all references to the World Health Organisation, particularly in Policy 1.
6622-1 Fiona Sprott fiona.sprott@hotmail.com Definitions Existing
Amend the definition of 'landscaped area' as detailed on page 2/4 of the submission.
Amendments change the landscaped area definition to be consistent with the definition of
building coverage
6623-1 Objective Holdings Limited charles.shrimpton@practiv.com RPS Changes to the RUB North and Waiheke Island
Rezone parts of 983 Hibiscus Coast Highway, Waiwera, from Rural Coastal to Single House.
[In conjunction with the application of a Hatfields Beach Village Precinct. While unclear, the
submission also suggests some parts are to be Mixed Housing or Large Lot, refer to pages 7-
8/85]. Refer to the full submission for maps showing the proposed changes [pages 17-18/85].
6623-2 Objective Holdings Limited charles.shrimpton@practiv.com Precincts - North New Precincts All other New Precincts
Add a 'Hatfields Beach Village' Precinct to 983 Hibiscus Coast Highway, Waiwera. This
precinct is to be based on a concept plan and will provide around 150 household units with a
range of site sizes, 600m
2
, 1500m
2
and 1ha. Refer to the full submission for further details
[pages 5-13/85].
6623-3 Objective Holdings Limited charles.shrimpton@practiv.com RPS Urban growth
Amend objective 4 to provide for settlement that is not contiguous with the existing urban
area, by including 'generally' before the word 'contiguous'.
377/1145
Sub#/
6623-4 Objective Holdings Limited charles.shrimpton@practiv.com RPS Urban growth
Amend policy 1 to provide for settlement that is not contiguous with the existing urban area,
by including 'generally' before the word 'concentrate'.
6623-5 Objective Holdings Limited charles.shrimpton@practiv.com RPS Changes to the RUB North and Waiheke Island Extend the RUB to include 983 Hibiscus Coast Highway, Waiwera.
6624-1 Brent Jackson salientnz@gmail.com General Miscellaneous
Operational/
Projects/Acquisition Save the St James Theatre
6625-1 C McMullen owen@greengroup.co.nz Zoning Central
Rezone land at 21 Gabador Place, Mt Wellington (Lot 11 DP 114805), and other land shown
in Attachment 1 to the submission, from Minor Port to Light Industrial. Refer to details in
submission at page 4/4 of volume 1.
6625-2 C McMullen owen@greengroup.co.nz
the CMA D5.4/I9 Minor Port zone
Replace the activity "Industrial Activities accessory to marine and port activities" in the Activity
Table with the activity "Industrial Activities". Refer to details in submission at page 4/4 of
volume 1.
6626-1 Sayes In Trust Limited sayes@xtra.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - Rural zones
area
Amend transferable rural site subdivision rules to extend wetlands on donor site [possibly 49
Creightons Road, Clevedon/Papakura] to include riparian zone establishment and
management, including the establishment of native plantings.
6627-1 Donald G Scandrett don.scandrett@gmail.com Rural Zones General I13.1 Activity table
Amend the activity table to provide for alternative future land use opportunities in the Rural
Coastal zone, particularly in relation to 65 Scandrett Rd, Warkworth and the Snells Beach and
Algies Bay area
6628-1 Crispin Caldicott
2152 Kaipara Coast Highway, RD4,
Warkworth, Auckland 0984 General Editorial and Part 6 Amend the PAUP such that regulations make sense, are clear and easy to follow.
Warkworth, Auckland 0984 RPS Mana Whenua B5 Strategic
Amend the PAUP to remove any rules requiring compliance with the principles of the Treaty
of Waitangi.
Allow for mediation between the rights of the individual property owners and the protection of
sites of cultural heritage value, with the burden of proof falling on those who wish to restrict
the owners use of the property.
Warkworth, Auckland 0984 Mana Whenua
Whenua
Scheduled sites and places of significance to Mana Whenua should be graded into categories
of significance, to be accorded varying degrees of protection (instead of all sites and places
having the highest level of protection).
Whenua
Delete G2.7.4 'Cultural impact assessment' and require that the Council be responsible for
any cultural impact assessment deemed by the Council to be necessary.
Reject any passages calling for equal partnerships, joint management agreements, shared
governance and the transfer of power to iwi authorities.
Warkworth, Auckland 0984 General Miscellaneous Consultation and engagement
Hold a referendum asking whether the general population of Auckland agree that the
governance of our physical and natural resources be shared in partnership with Mana
Whenua.
Warkworth, Auckland 0984 General Miscellaneous Consultation and engagement Withdraw the PAUP for a minimum of six months to allow for a proper submission period.
Whenua
objectives and policies Delete the 3600 'Sites of Significance of Value to Mana Whenua'.
6629-1 Southern Heritage Limited markbellingham@tnp.co.nz RPS Changes to the RUB South
Rezone 45 Cossey Road and 76a Waihoehoe Road, Drury from Future Urban to an active
urban zone.
6630-1 Dean Forster owen@greengroup.co.nz RPS Changes to the RUB West
Retain land at Matua Road, Huapai (Lot 2 DP 592126) within the Future Urban zone. Refer
to details in submission at page 4/4 of volume 1.
6630-2 Dean Forster owen@greengroup.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - Urban zones
except Rural
Amend subdivision provisions of the Future Urban zone to allow for subdivision
and replicate the provisions of the General Rural zone under operative Auckland Council
District Plan (Rodney section).
6631-1 Stingray Bay Farms Limited liam.wpg@gmail.com Zoning North and Islands Retain Metropolitan Centre zone at 19-29 and 33-45 Hurstmere Road, Takapuna.
6631-2 Stingray Bay Farms Limited liam.wpg@gmail.com
Centre)
Maps only
Remove Key Retail Frontage at Hurstmere Road, particularly 19-29 and 33-45 Hurstmere
Road, Channel View Road and The Strand, Takapuna frontages.
6631-3 Stingray Bay Farms Limited liam.wpg@gmail.com General Chapter G General provisions
Reject rule 1.4 'Applying for a resource consent' which allows Council to consider provisions
beyond those specifically listed as assessment criteria. See specific relief at 5.3 [page 12/13
of the submission].
6631-4 Stingray Bay Farms Limited liam.wpg@gmail.com General Chapter G General provisions
statements
Reject 2.7.2 requirement to prepare Design statements as a separate section of an
Assessment of Effects and confirm that the Auckland Design Manual is a non-statutory
guideline.
6631-5 Stingray Bay Farms Limited liam.wpg@gmail.com Mana Whenua General provisions
assessment Reject 2.7.4 Cultural Impact Assessments.
6631-6 Stingray Bay Farms Limited liam.wpg@gmail.com Transport Auckland -wide C1.2 Background Support policy change from parking minimums to parking maximums in the Metropolitan zone.
6631-7 Stingray Bay Farms Limited liam.wpg@gmail.com Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
Reject rules 3.2(1) and (4) Number of parking and loading spaces and 3.4 Access which
result in a maximum of zero for parking, loading and access in the Key Retail Frontage
overlay.
378/1145
Sub#/
6631-8 Stingray Bay Farms Limited liam.wpg@gmail.com Sustainable Development C7.7/H6.4 Sustainable design
Reject requirement to incorporate Sustainable Development and prescriptive nature of rules
2.1 and 2.2.
6631-9 Stingray Bay Farms Limited liam.wpg@gmail.com Residential zones Housing affordability H6.6 Rules
Reject requirement to incorporate affordable housing within developments of 15 or more
dwellings.
Centre) Business
& Bus. Park zones
Amend demolition as a Restricted Discretionary activity within a Metropolitan zone to either
Permitted or Controlled with general standards/matters for controls as provided in submission
[page 10/13].
Reject notification requirement applying to any development control other than the
infringement of building height and height in relation to boundary controls.
6631-12 Stingray Bay Farms Limited liam.wpg@gmail.com General Cross plan matters Delete storey component from 4.2 'Building height'.
Centre) Business
Park zones
Reject rule 4.6 'Buildings fronting the street' requirement for new buildings to adjoin the entire
site frontage in the Key Retail Frontage overlay. Allow buildings to provide through site links.
Centre) Business
Park zones
Reject rule 4.7 Building entrances' requirement for buildings to locate the main pedestrian
entrance within 3m of the site frontage. Allow main pedestrian entrances to be located on side
frontages adjoining Public Open Spaces.
Centre) Business
Park zones
Reduce the minimum ground floor to floor height of 4.5m for new buildings subject to a Key
Retail Frontage and remove the minimum depth requirement in rule 4.8 'Minimum floor to
floor/ceiling heights'. Assess the minimum non-residential above-ground floor to ceiling height
at 4.5m for new buildings subject to a Key Retail Frontage.
Centre) Business
Park zones
Reject rule 4.9 'Glazing'. Reduce requirements for minimum clear glazing on ground floors in
the Key Retail Frontage overlay.
Centre) Business
Park zones Reject rule 4.11 'Residential at ground floor'.
6631-18 Stingray Bay Farms Limited liam.wpg@gmail.com Precincts - North Takapuna 1
Amend rule 1.1 'Building height' in 1 Sub-precinct A maximum height from 20.5m and
maximum 5 storeys to match the 1 Sub-precinct B of 24.5m and 6 storeys.
Amend rule 1.1 'Building height' in Sub-precinct C to be restricted by the underlying
Metropolitan zone height controls rather than have an unlimited maximum height.
Amend rule 1.2 'Frontage and building setback' maximum frontage height for Sub-precinct A
from 3 storeys to match the rule for Sub-precinct B which is 4 storeys.
Amend rule 1.2 'Frontage and Building setback' to reduce the maximum frontage height for
Sub-precinct A from 4 storeys in relation to the through-site lane in Rule 1.5 to match the
maximum frontage height controls for Sub-precinct B.
Reject any proposals to increase the 5:1 basis and 6.1 maximum floor area ratios for Sub-
precinct C in rule 1.4 Through site lane for Sub-precinct C.
Reject rule 1.5 'Through-site lane for site' in Sub-precinct A 2 storey height bonus. Reduce the
scale of bonus provisions.
Reject rule 1.5 'Through-site lane for site' in Sub-precinct A location of the through-site
pedestrian lane in Precinct Plan 2. Relocate the through site land south-east to provide better
linkage.
Notification
Add provision of a single vehicle access point per site within the Key Retail Frontage overlay
as a Restricted Discretionary Activity with applications assessed against criteria similar to
Rule 5.2(6) Construction or use of a vehicle crossing where a Vehicle Access Restriction
applies.
requirements
Reject minimum rates for cycle parking and end of trip facilities in 3.2(2) and (3) Number of
parking and loading spaces. Reduce these requirements.
requirements Retain existing legal uses for parking, access and loading.
6632-1 Sunnyheights Limited markbellingham@tnp.co.nz Precincts - North Orewa 3 Retain precinct.
6632-2 Sunnyheights Limited markbellingham@tnp.co.nz Zoning North and Islands
Rezone Lots 1-3 DP 1770969, Lots 1-3 DP 204866 and Lot 1 DP 204868, Corner West Hoe
Heights and Sunnyheights Roads, Orewa West [See submission for location - page 3/19 of
submission] from Single House to Mixed Housing Suburban.
6632-3 Sunnyheights Limited markbellingham@tnp.co.nz Precincts - North Orewa 3 Amend 6.2 Building height and 7.2 Building height from 8m to 9m.
6632-4 Sunnyheights Limited markbellingham@tnp.co.nz Precincts - North Orewa 3
Provide for a neighbourhood commercial area of a maximum of 2200m
2
(a maximum of
1100m
2
retail, and 200m
2
for any shop) within Development Area 4 fronting West Hoe Heights
Road. See Attachment C for specific rule amendments [this appendix has not been provided]
and Attachment B for commercial activity rule amendments [pages 13-19/19 of submission].
379/1145
Sub#/
6632-5 Sunnyheights Limited markbellingham@tnp.co.nz Zoning North and Islands
Rezone area of Orewa, corner West Hoe Heights and Sunnyside Roads, illustrated in Figure
1 [page 3/19 of submission] to either Local Centre or Neighbourhood Centre to provide for a
neighbourhood commercial area.
Amend maximum height for buildings to 15m or four storeys as a non-notified, Restricted
Discretionary activity within development areas shown on Precinct Plan 1 in Appendix C
[Appendix C has not been attached to submission].
Amend Non-complying rule for dwellings not meeting the household unit cap or development
outside the defined buildings platform to Discretionary in rule 2.4 Buildings and building
platforms or allow for the underlying zone rules to apply. See Attachment B for specific
amendments [pages 13-19/19 of submission].
Delete 20% cap on the total number of dwellings that may be transferred from one
development area to another from rule 2.1 Number of sites.
Amend Precinct Plan 1 to include the eastern part of the sites as shown in figure 2 [page 4/19
of submission].
6633-1 Adfence
5/319 Neilson Street, Onehunga,
Auckland 1061 General
H6.5)
Retain the provisions that enable temporary fencing to occur during construction as a
permitted activity.
6633-2 Adfence
Auckland 1061 Definitions Existing
Amend 'Temporary activity' to include fencing (in relation to building construction or
maintenance). Refer to the full submission for suggested wording [page 2/5].
6633-3 Adfence
Amend 'Building', to specifically exclude temporary 'fencing' for construction or maintenance
(in addition to scaffolding) and expand this exclusion to 'events'. Refer to the full submission
for suggested wording [page 2/5].
6633-4 Adfence
Auckland 1061 General Miscellaneous Bylaws and Licensing Notify the consolidated signs bylaw as soon as possible.
6633-5 Adfence
Auckland 1061 General C7.4/H6.3 Signs
Amend the section 32 report for 'Signs', to evaluate temporary advertisements and amend the
provisions accordingly.
6633-6 Adfence
H6.5)
Amend to provide for advertisements on temporary fencing as permitted activities (where no
larger than 2m by 6.5m and one is permitted every 4m of fence). Refer to the full submission
for a photograph example [page 4/5].
6633-7 Adfence
H6.5)
Amend to include advertisements associated with events as permitted activities, or define
signs of a certain size as permitted activities.
6634-1 Mick McLiver biancahartley@tnp.co.nz RPS Changes to the RUB North and Waiheke Island
Rezone parts of 327 Pine Valley Road, Pine Valley from Mixed Rural to Future Urban. See
submission for specific amendments [page 4/14 of submission].
6634-2 Mick McLiver biancahartley@tnp.co.nz RPS Changes to the RUB North and Waiheke Island
Amend Rural Urban Boundary to include land identified in Figure 3 in submission [page 6/14
of submission] at 327 Pine Valley Road, Pine Valley.
6635-1 Rob Aerts rob@alignworks.co.nz Residential zones Residential
Amend rule 7.14 Maximum building length, to enable buildings longer than 20m where the
length is exceeded at ground level only and no single elevation of the building is greater than
20m.
6635-2 Rob Aerts rob@alignworks.co.nz Zoning Central Retain the Mixed Housing Suburban zoning in Epsom, particularly 40 Buckley Rd
6636-1 Allan N Kirk allank960@gmail.com Zoning Central
Rezone 25 properties on land bounded by Mt Eden Road, Kingsway, Queensway and Three
Kings School, Three Kings, to Mixed Housing Suburban zone.
6637-1 Rochelle L Thomas rochelle57@hotmail.com RPS Changes to the RUB North and Waiheke Island
Amend the southern boundary of the RUB [in the vicinity of Dairy flat], so that it does not
extend further south than the North Shore Airfield/Aeropark Precinct (on the east side of Dairy
Flat Highway) or further south than Kahikatea Flat Road (on the west side of Dairy Flat
Highway).
6637-2 Rochelle L Thomas rochelle57@hotmail.com RPS Changes to the RUB North and Waiheke Island
Amend the RUB [in the vicinity of Dairy flat], so that if it extends further south than the North
Shore Airfield/Aeropark Precinct (on the east side of Dairy Flat Highway) and further south
than Kahikatea Flat Road (on the west side of Dairy Flat Highway), properties that form the
catchment area of Dairy Stream and its tributaries are not included within the RUB.
6637-3 Rochelle L Thomas rochelle57@hotmail.com
managed fill
Amend to provide remedial land-filling on properties, to maintain access ways and ensure
usable land not currently subject to flooding remains that way [Should the RUB in the vicinity
of Dairy Flat be retained as proposed].
6638-1 Arthur J Hore art.hur@xtra.co.nz
SEAs
Land
Amend SEA at 170 Kauri Road, Whenuapai to exclude vegetable garden and orchard and
only cover the area adjacent to the coastal strip at the rear of the property.
6639-1 Peter H Bennett peterb@pvl04.co.nz General Miscellaneous
Operational/
Install stormwater holding ponds for the Papakura stream in conjunction with residential
development in the area
6640-1 Wairau Park Syndicate biancahartley@tnp.co.nz Zoning North and Islands
Retain Mixed Use zone in Link Drive/Sunnynook Road, Wairau Valley on parts of area shown
in Figure 5 in submission [page 8/28 of submission].
6640-2 Wairau Park Syndicate biancahartley@tnp.co.nz Zoning North and Islands
Rezone area in Link Drive, Wairau Valley shown in Figure 3 [page 4/28 of submission] from
General Business to Mixed Use.
380/1145
Sub#/
6640-3 Wairau Park Syndicate biancahartley@tnp.co.nz Precincts - North New Precincts Wairau Valley
Add new precinct 'Wairau precinct' to Wairau Valley land as shown in Figure 3 in submission
[page 4/28 of submission] to provide for building heights of 40.5m (up to 10 storeys) as a
Restricted Discretionary activities or Discretionary if building height is infringed.
6641-1 Raelene Farrell
200 Riverside Avenue, Point
England, Auckland 1072 Zoning Central
Delete Mixed Housing [Urban] and Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings in Pt England,
particularly in the area of Erima Street and Riverside Ave
England, Auckland 1072 Residential zones Residential
General
Amend rules to require a resource consent in the Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings
and Mixed Housing [Urban] zone to assess shading and privacy issues.
England, Auckland 1072 General Miscellaneous
Operational/
Projects/Acquisition Amend the consent process to reduce cost and time taken
policies Ensure buildings are aesthetically pleasing
England, Auckland 1072
shafts survey coordinates Protect volcanic viewshafts in Pt England
England, Auckland 1072 Transport Auckland -wide
requirements Amend parking minimum and maximum controls so they are requirements not guidelines
England, Auckland 1072 RPS
Transport
and energy
Clarify how the development, operation and upgrading of infrastructure will be enforced on
developers
England, Auckland 1072 General Miscellaneous Other Provide for safer communities
England, Auckland 1072 General Miscellaneous Other Focus growth into other centres in New Zealand outside of Auckland
England, Auckland 1072 RPS Urban growth
quality compact urban form Add business parks to focus growth and population away from one focal point of the city
England, Auckland 1072 General Miscellaneous Other
Remove state housing from areas with good transport links and close proximity, such as Glen
Innes
6642-1 Neil Johnson and Joy Marriott
Auckland 1024 Zoning Central Rezone Poronui Street, Mt Eden, from Mixed Housing Suburban to Single House zone.
6642-2 Neil Johnson and Joy Marriott
& C
Isthmus
6643-1 Kerry R Titchener k.rex@xtra.co.nz Zoning North and Islands
Rezone the area between Westgate, Kumeu and Riverhead from Rural Production and Mixed
Rural to Countryside Living. Refer to the full submission for maps of the areas to be rezoned
[pages 5-6/13].
6643-2 Kerry R Titchener k.rex@xtra.co.nz Zoning North and Islands Rezone the Wairau Valley commercial area from Light Industrial to General Business.
6643-3 Kerry R Titchener k.rex@xtra.co.nz
Outstanding Natural
Rules
Outstanding Natural
Landscapes
Replace the entry for ID 83 with the Environment Court Order version for 'Waiheke Island. Te
Wharau Bay Coastal Ridge and Slopes'. Refer to the full submission for a copy of the
Environment Court version [page 13/13].
6643-4 Kerry R Titchener k.rex@xtra.co.nz Mana Whenua
Whenua
Delete the 200m diameter circles and replace with a small triangle or dot based on GPS
recorded reference points.
Whenua
and policies
Amend the policies such that the focus is on avoiding physical damage, alteration or
destruction of 'Site and Places of Value to Mana Whenua'.
Whenua J5.2 Rules
Amend the activity table such that restricted discretionary resource consent would be required
only if earthworks within 10m of a Site or Place of Value to Mana Whenua are likely to result
in damage, alteration or destruction (in the opinion of the territorial authority). Refer to the full
submission for suggested wording [Vol 2, page 3/10].
Whenua J5.2 Rules
Amend matters of discretion (1)[under J5.2.3], such that the focus is on the potential for
physical damage, alteration or destruction of 'Site or Place of Value to Mana Whenua'. Refer
to the full submission for suggested wording [Vol 2, page 4/10].
Whenua J5.2 Rules
Amend assessment criteria (1)(a)(i)-(vi)[under J5.2.3], such that a Cultural Impact
Assessment is only required in the event that the proposed earthworks will result in the focus
in physical damage, alteration or loss of the 'Site or Place of Value to Mana Whenua'.
6643-9 Kerry R Titchener k.rex@xtra.co.nz Mana Whenua General provisions
assessment
Amend G2.7.4 'Cultural impact assessment'(1)(a) and (b) such that a restricted discretionary
resource consent and Cultural Impact Assessment are only appropriate when the proposal is
likely to cause physical damage, alteration or destruction to 'Sites or Places of Value to Mana
Whenua'. Refer to the full submission for suggested wording [Vol 2, page 5/10].
381/1145
Sub#/
6644-1 Roger McGarry roger@fpp.co.nz Zoning South
Rezone Lot 6 12009 BLK XIV Titirangi S D, Orpheus Road, Orua Bay from Rural Coastal to
Rural and Coastal Settlement.
6644-2 Roger McGarry roger@fpp.co.nz Zoning South
Rezone all properties on the south side of the seaward end of Orpheus Road, Waiuku to
Rural and Coastal Settlement.
6645-1 Andrew J M Park andrew@rocketfuel.co.nz Zoning Central Retain the Single House zoning in Disraeli Street, Mt Eden, particularly 14 Disraeli Street
6645-2 Andrew J M Park andrew@rocketfuel.co.nz Zoning Central Rezone all Mixed Housing Suburban in Disraeli Street, Mt Eden to Single House
6645-3 Andrew J M Park andrew@rocketfuel.co.nz Zoning Central Retain Single House zoning in Woodside Road, Mt Eden
6645-4 Andrew J M Park andrew@rocketfuel.co.nz Zoning Central Rezone Poronui Street, Mt Eden from Mixed Housing Suburban to Single House
6645-5 Andrew J M Park andrew@rocketfuel.co.nz Zoning Central
Rezone area west of Mt Eden Rd from Valley Road in the north to Kingsview in the South,
and Tarata and Henley in the west to Mt Eden Road on the East (e.g. Ashton, Essex,
Ngauruhoe, Grange and Fairview), Mt Eden from Mixed Housing Suburban to Single House
Rezone area east of Mt Eden Rd from Rautangi Rd in the north to Aberfoyle in the south, and
Mt Eden in the West to St Andrews in the east (e.g. Stokes, Gary, Hasbury, Windmill and
Pencarrow) and Kohia Terrace, Mt Eden from Mixed Housing Suburban to Single House
6645-7 Andrew J M Park andrew@rocketfuel.co.nz Built Environment (Overlays)
Height Control
Amend the additional height control over Mt Eden Village and Eden Valley Centre from 12.5m
and 3 storeys to 10m and 2 storeys
Rezone both sides of Mt Eden Rd from Kings View Road and Woodside Rd, Mt Eden from
Mixed Housing Urban to Mixed Housing Suburban
Retain the Single House zoning south of Eden Park from Walters Road to Parrish and St
Albans Rd, and from Sandringham Rd to Dominion Road (e.g. Royal Terrace, Ward and
Paice Roads)
6645-10 Andrew J M Park andrew@rocketfuel.co.nz Historic Heritage (Overlay)
Heritage
Places Retain the historic heritage area over Burnley Terrace and King Edward Street, Mt Eden
6645-11 Andrew J M Park andrew@rocketfuel.co.nz Precincts Ak-Wide and Coastal Stadiums and Showgrounds K1.10 Precinct Rules
Retain the Eden Park concept plan and existing consent restrictions in the Major Recreational
Facilities zone and Eden Park sub-precinct
6645-12 Andrew J M Park andrew@rocketfuel.co.nz General
H6.5)
Exclude rules from applying to the Eden Park sub-precinct of the Stadiums and Showgrounds
precinct.
6645-13 Andrew J M Park andrew@rocketfuel.co.nz General Chapter G General provisions G2.4 Notification Amend so restricted discretionary activities are assessed by the normal RMA notification tests
6645-14 Andrew J M Park andrew@rocketfuel.co.nz Residential zones Residential
and Coastal Settlement zone Retain rule 6.2 Building height, with a 8m height limit for Disraeli Street, Mt Eden.
6645-15 Andrew J M Park andrew@rocketfuel.co.nz Residential zones Residential Land use controls
Amend rule 3.1(1) Maximum density, to remove the provision for unlimited density in the
6645-16 Andrew J M Park andrew@rocketfuel.co.nz Residential zones Residential Land use controls
Amend rule 3.1(1) Maximum density, to change the maximum density in the Mixed Housing
Suburban zone from one dwelling per 200m2 to one per 300m2.
6645-17 Andrew J M Park andrew@rocketfuel.co.nz
Amend the activity status of taverns and drive throughs within 30m of a residential [site] from
restricted discretionary to discretionary
6645-18 Andrew J M Park andrew@rocketfuel.co.nz Special Character
& C J3.3.1-7 Rules Amend the activity status of demolition from restricted discretionary to discretionary
6645-19 Andrew J M Park andrew@rocketfuel.co.nz Special Character
& C J3.3.1-7 Rules Delete assessment criteria relating to the relocation of removed buildings
6645-20 Andrew J M Park andrew@rocketfuel.co.nz RPS Urban growth
Add a mechanism to stage Mixed Housing Urban and Mixed Housing Suburban until an
independent verification of infrastructure capacity has been undertaken and a shortage of
land is shown, particularly in relation to the area from Balmoral Rd, west to Sandringham Rd,
north to Kingsland and East to Mt Eden Rd, and north to New North Road.
6646-1 Bobbie Carroll bobbiec@slingshot.co.nz Precincts - West
Reject site coverage reduction from 15% to 10% and amend to be 20% [Sub-precinct D 3.3
Building coverage is 15%].
6646-2 Bobbie Carroll bobbiec@slingshot.co.nz Built Environment (Overlays)
Protection
Allow property owners to choose building sites on a property, taking into account sensitive
ridgelines, not the Council (particularly relates to 9 Sylvan Glade and 54 Beach Valley Road,
Piha).
6646-3 Bobbie Carroll bobbiec@slingshot.co.nz
SEAs
Land
Delete SEA overlay from 9 Sylvan Glade and 54 Beach Valley Road, Piha and from all
properties within Piha Village.
6646-4 Bobbie Carroll bobbiec@slingshot.co.nz
SEAs
Areas - Land rules (all) Retain 20% per annum trimming of vegetation [from Waitakere District Plan].
6647-1 Robyn Hill robyn_hill@xtra.co.nz General Miscellaneous Other Adopt the relief sought by the Herne Bay Residents Association Incorporated
6648-1 Lesley A Munro kumquat@clear.net.nz Rural Zones General I13.2 Land use controls
Amend 2.6 Dwellings to allow secondary dwellings as Permitted in the Rural Production zone
on land less than 5ha, not 40ha.
382/1145
Sub#/
Amend 2.6 Dwellings to allow secondary dwellings in the Rural Production zone as a
Amend 2.6 Dwellings to allow secondary dwellings in the Rural Production zone if the majority
of a site cannot be used for rural production.
6648-4 Lesley A Munro kumquat@clear.net.nz RPS Mana Whenua B5 Strategic Delete all references to the Treaty of Waitangi in the PAUP.
6648-5 Lesley A Munro kumquat@clear.net.nz Mana Whenua
Whenua
whenua
Amend mapping of Sites and Places of Significance to Mana Whenua to apply only to the
property, not surrounding areas within the 50m buffer.
6648-6 Lesley A Munro kumquat@clear.net.nz Mana Whenua
Whenua
and policies
Amend Sites and Places of Value to Mana Whenua to be 'interest' sites only with no legal
standing or restrictive intent if a resource consent is sought.
6648-7 Lesley A Munro kumquat@clear.net.nz RPS Mana Whenua B5 Strategic Delete the cultural supremacy of Tangata Whenua values in policy making, restrictions etc.
6648-8 Lesley A Munro kumquat@clear.net.nz Mana Whenua General provisions
assessment
Amend 2.7.4 Cultural Impact Assessments so that the applicant does not need to deal directly
with Iwi and remove the ability to charge fees.
6649-1 Colleen Brown thebrowns@colbar.co.nz Built Environment (Overlays)
Public Views Create suitable development controls in adjoining areas to protect views of Hill Park.
6649-2 Colleen Brown thebrowns@colbar.co.nz RPS
Ensure that Hill Park is viewed in the wider context as part of a biodiversity corridor stretching
from Mill Road across the Auckland Isthmus.
6649-3 Colleen Brown thebrowns@colbar.co.nz General
GIS viewer Ensure that overland flow paths/flood plains are further defined and added to GIS.
character and natural heritage B4.3.3 Trees and vegetation Continue to schedule individual and groves of trees.
character and natural heritage B4.3.3 Trees and vegetation Re-introduce tree protection rules based on species and height/girth of trees.
Ensure that where significant trees are removed (based on sound/reasonable argument), new
native trees are planted as mitigation on the same site as the tree removed.
6649-7 Colleen Brown thebrowns@colbar.co.nz
SEAs
Land Designate all of Hill Park as a Significant Ecological Area.
6649-8 Colleen Brown thebrowns@colbar.co.nz Special Character
residential
special character areas Add a character overlay that protects the original pattern of subdivision in the Hill Park area.
6649-9 Colleen Brown thebrowns@colbar.co.nz Historic Heritage (Overlay)
Heritage
Places
Identify and investigate significant properties in the Hill Park area that might be suitable for
scheduling/protection from all eras including the mid-20
th
century.
6649-10 Colleen Brown thebrowns@colbar.co.nz Special Character
residential
Undertake a character study of the general fabric of Hill Park to inform character overlay
content, including specific development rules such as front yard setbacks, fencing and front
facade requirements.
6649-11 Colleen Brown thebrowns@colbar.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - Urban zones H5.2 3.1 Residential zones Make the creation of any lot under 750m
2
in the Hill Park area a non-complying activity.
6649-12 Colleen Brown thebrowns@colbar.co.nz Built Environment (Overlays)
Public Views
Create a transition zone around the Hill Park footprint which extends to Great South Road,
Alfriston Road, Orams Road and the Southern Motorway.
6649-13 Colleen Brown thebrowns@colbar.co.nz Trees
Trees
Notable Trees Identify protected trees in the Hill Park area.
6650-1
Summerset Group Holdings
Limited laura.swan@hainesplanning.co.nz Zoning Central Rezone 8 Harrison Road, Mt Wellington, from Light Industry to Mixed Use.
6650-2
Limited laura.swan@hainesplanning.co.nz
Centre) Business
& Bus. Park zones
Amend activity table to provide for retirement villages as a permitted activity in the Mixed Use
zone.
6650-3
Limited laura.swan@hainesplanning.co.nz Zoning Central Rezone 2-4, 6 and 10 Harrison Road, Mt Wellington, to Mixed Use.
6650-4
Limited laura.swan@hainesplanning.co.nz Zoning South
Rezone 67 Hingaia Road, Hingaia, from Single House to Terrace Housing and Apartment
Buildings zone.
6650-5
Limited laura.swan@hainesplanning.co.nz Residential zones Residential Activity Table
Amend the Activity Table to provide for retirement villages as a permitted activity in the
6650-6
Limited laura.swan@hainesplanning.co.nz Zoning North and Islands Rezone 31 Mansel Drive, Warkworth, from Retirement Village to Mixed Housing Suburban.
6650-7
Amend the Activity Table to provide for retirement villages as a permitted activity in the Mixed
6650-8
Limited laura.swan@hainesplanning.co.nz Zoning North and Islands
Rezone that part of 92-94 Woodcocks Road, Warkworth, currently General Business to Mixed
Housing Suburban.
6650-9
Limited laura.swan@hainesplanning.co.nz Precincts - North Warkworth 1
Remove that part of 92-94 Woodcocks Road currently zoned General Business from the
Warkworth Precinct Plan area.
383/1145
Sub#/
6650-10
Limited laura.swan@hainesplanning.co.nz RPS Changes to the RUB West Rezone 1-2 Squadron Drive, Hobsonville, from Future Urban to Mixed Housing Urban.
6650-11
Amend the Activity Table to provide for retirement villages as a permitted activity in the Mixed
Housing Urban zone.
6650-12
Limited laura.swan@hainesplanning.co.nz Historic Heritage (Overlay)
Heritage
Places Remove Schedule ID 00130 from 2 Squadron Drive, Hobsonville, from Appendix 9.1.
6650-13
Limited laura.swan@hainesplanning.co.nz Zoning South
Rezone 7 Flat Bush School Road, Manukau, from Retirement Village to Terrace Housing and
Apartment Buildings.
6650-14
Limited laura.swan@hainesplanning.co.nz Water
streams & wetland
table Delete the indicative stream notation from 7 Flat Bush School Road, Manukau.
6650-15
Limited laura.swan@hainesplanning.co.nz Designations Auckland Transport
1834 Road Widening - Flat
Bush School Road
Amend outline of Designation 1834 to exclude 7 Flat Bush School Road, Manukau, and its
frontage, because based on the description, the designation does not apply to the site.
6650-16
Limited laura.swan@hainesplanning.co.nz General Chapter A Introduction A1 Background
Retain text acknowledging the issues associated with demographic changes, particularly
relating to an aging population [1.3 Our growing population].
6650-17
Limited laura.swan@hainesplanning.co.nz General Chapter A Introduction A1 Background
Add specific provisions to Section 1.3 [our growing population] to enable the establishment of
rest homes, retirement villages and services that will meet community needs.
6650-18
Limited laura.swan@hainesplanning.co.nz General Chapter A Introduction A3 Strategic Framework
Amend Section 3.6 to recognise the structure and contents of the PAUP will deliver integrated
management outcomes by enabling various resource consent application types for the same
development to be staged and processed separately.
6650-19
Limited laura.swan@hainesplanning.co.nz General
GIS viewer
Delete the non-statutory layers (especially the flood layers, unless the legitimacy of rules
relying on them is confirmed).
6650-20
Limited laura.swan@hainesplanning.co.nz Definitions Existing
Amend 'Floodplain' definition [in the event that reliance on non-statutory layers is considered
inappropriate].
6650-21
SEAs
6650-22
SEAs
and policies
Amend Policy 1 to read 'Protect indigenous vegetation in sensitive environments including the
coast, riparian margins, wetlands and areas prone to natural hazards.'
6650-23
SEAs
and policies
Amend Policy 6 to read 'Minimise indigenous vegetation disturbance from activities, works,
access ways and building platforms by assessing alternative locations and methods for the
proposed works.'
6650-24
SEAs
and policies
Amend Policy 9 to read 'Averse effects from the subdivision or development of natural hazard
areas shall be avoided, remedied or mitigated.'
6650-25
Limited laura.swan@hainesplanning.co.nz Natural Hazards and Flooding Flooding
and policies
Amend Objective 1 to allow, where possible, reasonable occurrence of new development in
areas at risk of flooding depending on how the development is designed and how the flooding
risk is managed.
6650-26
and policies
Amend Policy 2 to allow, where possible, reasonable occurrence of new development in areas
at risk of flooding depending on how the development is designed and how the flooding risk is
managed and adopt a similar approach as that in policies 4, 7, 8 and 9.
6650-27
and policies
6650-28
Limited laura.swan@hainesplanning.co.nz Water Stormwater
H4.14.2 Stormwater
management -flow rules Amend thresholds for triggering stormwater consent applications.
6650-29
H4.14.2 Stormwater
Amend stormwater management rules, and in particular Stormwater Management Area Flow
rule, to have measures that are realistic and achievable.
6650-30
and policies
6650-31
Limited laura.swan@hainesplanning.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - general
and policies
Amend Policy 6 to read '...zoned for urban development c.on the basis that the costs of
providing or upgrading local infrastructure are met by the developer ...'
6650-32
6650-33
and policies
Provide guidance on when a longer lapse period may be granted, particularly for more
complex developments.
6650-34
and policies
Amend Policy 20 to read 'Require s Subdivisions design to contribute to or create a sense of
place through a design that: a.enables the creation of distinct neighbourhoods b.incorporates
and enhances significant landforms and natural features c.protects significant cultural
heritage, archaeological sites and other scheduled features.'
6650-35
and policies Amend language and intent of policies to provide guidance on the outcomes sought.
384/1145
Sub#/
6650-36
Limited laura.swan@hainesplanning.co.nz Sustainable Development C7.7/H6.4 Sustainable design
Amend Objective 1 to read 'Buildings are designed to minimise adverse environmental
environments'.
6650-37
Limited laura.swan@hainesplanning.co.nz Sustainable Development C7.7/H6.4 Sustainable design
Amend Policy 2 to read 'Encourage Require medium to large-scale residential development to
be designed to meet sustainable building standards.'
6650-38
Limited laura.swan@hainesplanning.co.nz Residential zones Housing affordability
and policies Amend policies to clarify that they do not apply to dwellings in retirement village facilities.
6650-39
Limited laura.swan@hainesplanning.co.nz Definitions Existing Amend the definition of 'Retained Affordable Housing' to exclude retirement villages.
6650-40
Limited laura.swan@hainesplanning.co.nz Residential zones Residential
policies
Amend introduction to residential zones to provide for retirement villages and care activities
(refer to pages 21 and 22/107 of submission for details).
6650-41
policies Delete Policy 8.
6650-42
policies
Add a new policy which provides for a longer lapse period (between 5 to 10 years) for large-
scale residential developments subject to assessment criteria.
6650-43
6650-44
policies
Amend Policy 3 to read 'Provide a range of residential zones that enable different housing
densities, a variety of housing opportunities and different housing types that meet the diverse
needs of the community and are appropriate for the existing and planned infrastructure,
natural environment and the existing and planned residential character of the area.'
6650-45
policies
Add a new policy that reads '9. Residents have access to retirement village and aged care
services within their community as their provision is enabled in the residential zones.'
6650-46
Limited laura.swan@hainesplanning.co.nz Residential zones
& pols
Amend Policy 1 as follows: 'Limit development on a site to a single dwelling and accessory
buildings and e Ensure that the activity site size will: a. be able to be provided
withaccommodate the infrastructure necessary to support the dwelling activity b. not detract
from any high quality landscapes or natural features c. not exacerbate any physical limitations
such as land instability.'
6650-47
& pols
Amend Policy 2 to read 'Require development to have sufficient setbacks and open space to
maintain the spacious landscape character of the area.'
6650-48
pols
Amend zone description to read '...These settlements rely on on-site disposal and treatment.
Due to factors including servicing, infrastructure and accessibility constraints and, in some
cases, their sensitive character, only limited or no growth is anticipated...'
6650-49
pols
Amend Policy 1 as follows: 'Enable subdivision and development that provides for a single
dwelling and accessory buildings and ensure that the site size will is: a. be able to
accommodate the infrastructure necessary to support the dwelling activity b. not detract from
any high-quality landscapes or natural features c. not exacerbate any physical limitations such
as land instability.'
6650-50
obs & pols Retain intent shown for multi-unit development in zone description.
6650-51
Amend rules in the Single House zone to provide for appropriate multi-unit developments,
including retirement villages.
6650-52
Limited laura.swan@hainesplanning.co.nz RPS Urban growth
quality compact urban form Reconsider the distribution and application of zoning in Auckland.
6650-53
obs & pols
require sufficient setbacks, landscaped areas and open space to maintain the low density
suburban residential character of one to two storey, detached dwellings within a generally
spacious setting .'
6650-54
obs & pols Delete Policy 4.
6650-55
zone desc, obs & pols Retain Objective 1.
6650-56
Amend Policy 1 to read 'Enable a variety of detached and attached housing types, including
retirement villages.' or 'Enable a variety of detached and attached housing
types, to accommodate all forms of residential activity.'
6650-57
Amend Policy 6 to read 'Require Encourage development to be designed, with a particular
emphasis on those parts of the dwelling visible from the street to: a.create visual interest
b.face the street and maximise passive surveillance of it c.minimise the dominance of garage
doors visible from the street .'
385/1145
Sub#/
6650-58
Amend Policy 7 to read 'Limit Manage the density and scale of development as is
necessary to take account any of one or more of the following factors: a.achieving a balance
between making the most efficient use of the site and providing high-quality on-site amenity...'
6650-59
zone desc, obs & pols Delete Policy 8.
6650-60
policies
Rezone [unspecified] residential land and the distribution of residential zones to better take
into account economic, social and natural features.
6650-61
pols
Amend zone description to read 'This zone allows urban residential living in the form of
terrace housing and apartments. The zone is primarily located around metropolitan, town and
local centres and the rapid and frequent service network. Proximity to open space and
topographical features of the site or area have also been considered are also important
considerations.'
6650-62
Centre) Business
Amend introduction to read 'The centres zones and Mixed Use zone are expected to
accommodate an increase in the density and diversity of residential activities housing ,
provided that it does not preclude opportunities for business development. A high standard of
amenity is required in the Mixed Use zone, given its mix of uses, including residential.'
6650-63
Centre) Business
& Bus. Park zones
Amend activity table to provide for retirement villages as a permitted activity in the centres
and Mixed Use zones.
6650-64
Centre) Business
General objectives and policies Retain Policy 2.
6650-65
Centre) Business
Delete Policy 6 [alternatively, the policy should not apply to specialist activities such as
retirement villages].
6650-66
Centre)
desc, obs & pols
Amend Policy 5 to read 'Require development that adjoins public open space or residential
zones to manage adverse effects of the activity in order to maintain the amenity values of
those places.'
6650-67
Centre) Business
General objectives and policies Delete Policy 11.
6650-68
Centre) Business
Amend zone description to read 'With the exception of retirement villages, R residential
activity is also not envisaged due to the presence of light industrial activities and the need to
preserve land for out-of-centre commercial opportunities.
6650-69
Centre) Business
& Bus. Park zones
Amend activity table to make retirement villages a discretionary activity in the General
Business zone.
6650-70
Centre)
desc, obs & pols
Amend zone description to read 'Due to the industrial nature of the activities, sensitive
activities such as residential, office or retail activities that are not related to the predominant
use on-site are not appropriate. An exception is made for trade suppliers, motor vehicle sales
and garden centres, and retirement villages which may locate in the zone subject to location
and traffic considerations.'
6650-71
Centre) Business
Amend activity table to make retirement villages a discretionary activity in the Light Industry
zone.
6650-72
Centre) Business
Amend activity statuses for activities in the Light Industry zone to align with the Business 4
zone of the Isthmus section of the Auckland City District Plan.
6650-73
Centre)
desc, obs & pols
Amend Policy 4 'Avoid: a.office activities, except where they are accessory to the primary
activity on-site b. residential activities other than for persons whose duties require them to live
on-site and retirement villages.'
6650-74
Limited laura.swan@hainesplanning.co.nz Future Urban
Amend Objective 1 to read 'Rural activities and the functioning of the rural community
continue until the land is rezoned to an urban zone or resource consent is granted.'
6650-75
objectives and policies Retain Objective 2.
6650-76
Amend Objective 3 to read 'Structure planning or resource consents determines future urban
development form and timing.'
6650-77
Amend Future Urban zone description to provide for some development in the zone by way of
resource consent.
6650-78
Amend Policy 3 to read '...c. create or require Council to extend infrastructure out of sequence
or that is not contiguous with the existing network infrastructure d. attract a high proportion of
users beyond the local community e. will give rise to reverse sensitivity issues when urban
development occurs.'
386/1145
Sub#/
6650-79
6650-80
6650-81
Limited laura.swan@hainesplanning.co.nz Rural Zones General
Amend Policy 2 under 'Rural Character and Amenity Values' to provide adequate
infrastructure for rural subdivisions and communities which enhance health and safety (refer
to pages 34 and 35/97 of submission for details).
6650-82
Limited laura.swan@hainesplanning.co.nz Rural Zones General
Amend objectives and policies to better reflect realities of the rural environment and the needs
of these communities.
6650-83
Limited laura.swan@hainesplanning.co.nz Residential zones Retirement Village zone
and policies
Amend objectives and policies as outlined on pages 36, 37 and 38/97 [if Retirement Village
zone is retained].
6650-84
Limited laura.swan@hainesplanning.co.nz General Chapter G General provisions
status
Amend rule 2.1 so that if an overlay rule applies to the same matter the least restrictive, not
the most restrictive activity status applies (refer to pages 38 and 39/97 of submission for
details).
6650-85
Limited laura.swan@hainesplanning.co.nz General Chapter G General provisions G2.4 Notification
Amend the PAUP to merge all notification sub-sections into a single notification section which
states that all Restricted Discretionary activities complying with specified development
controls must be non-notified an all Discretionary and Non-Complying activities are subject to
normal tests in the RMA.
6650-86
Limited laura.swan@hainesplanning.co.nz General Chapter G General provisions G2.4 Notification
Remove notification provisions in the Unitary Plan that set more stringent requirements than
the RMA.
6650-87
Amend description by removing references that require framework plans to comply with
underlying rules.
6650-88
G2.7.3 Framework plans Retain voluntary nature of framework plans.
6650-89
statements
Amend the assessment criteria of each zone to confirm how the details of a design statement
will be incorporated into the assessment of resource consent applications.
6650-90
statements
Amend to allow for circumstances where the proposed design response leads the future
character of a street or neighbourhood.
6650-91
statements
Amend 2.7.2(1) 'Context analysis' to exempt land use consent applications that are in
accordance with an approved structure plan, framework plan or concept plan.
6650-92
Limited laura.swan@hainesplanning.co.nz Mana Whenua General provisions
assessment
Amend PAUP to streamline and formalise engagement process and amend maps to show the
specific and recognised iwi groups' interests spatially.
6650-93
assessment
Amend the mana whenua overlays to provide representative contact details for each Iwi group
with the maps.
6650-94
assessment
Amend to provide an exemption from a cultural impact assessment requirement for resource
consent applicants within Treaty settlement areas.
6650-95
assessment
Add new provision to clarify the purpose and application of the non-statutory Treaty
Settlement alert layer.
6650-96
Limited laura.swan@hainesplanning.co.nz Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
Amend Rule 3.1 'Traffic Generation', Table 1, to provide for a Retirement Village threshold of
90 independent living apartments.
6650-97
requirements Retain Table 4.
6650-98
requirements
Amend Rule 3.2 'Number of Parking and Loading Spaces', Table 5, to require retirement
village activities to provide for a secure cycle storage rate of 1 per 10 staff and a visitor cycle
parking rate of 1 per 50 care beds.
6650-99
Limited laura.swan@hainesplanning.co.nz Earthworks H4.2.1.1 Activity table - Zones
Amend activity table to provide for earthworks up to 1000m2 and 1000m3 as a permitted
activity in the residential zones.
6650-
100
Limited laura.swan@hainesplanning.co.nz Earthworks H4.2.2 Controls
Amend controls to address noise and construction traffic and any other relevant matters to
ensure adverse effects are avoided, remedied and mitigated.
6650-
101
Limited laura.swan@hainesplanning.co.nz Earthworks H4.2.1.1 Activity table - Zones Amend to provide a uniform range of thresholds that are mutually exclusive.
6650-
102
Limited laura.swan@hainesplanning.co.nz Earthworks H4.2.1.1 Activity table - Zones
Amend Activity Table 2 to provide for earthworks up to 5000m2 and 5000m3 as a permitted
activity in the residential and business zones.
6650-
103
H4.14.2 Stormwater
Amend Activity Table to delete the controlled activity for impervious areas greater than 25m2
in the SMAF and provide for all new areas up to 1000m2 as a permitted activity (refer to
pages 46 and 47/97 of submission for details).
387/1145
Sub#/
6650-
104
H4.14.2 Stormwater
Amend Activity Table by changing the controlled activity fir impervious areas not connected to
a network to a permitted activity subject to permitted activity standards to meet hydrology
mitigation requirements (refer to pages 46 and 47/97 of submission for details).
6650-
105
rules
Amend Activity Table so all Controlled activities are amended to Permitted activities (refer to
pages 47 and 48/97 of submission for details).
6650-
106
Limited laura.swan@hainesplanning.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - Urban zones
except Rural
Amend Activity Table 3 for Future Urban zone to change the activity status for any subdivision
not listed from prohibited to non-complying.
6650-
107
Limited laura.swan@hainesplanning.co.nz General Noise and vibration H6.2 Rules
Amend the controls so those standards set out in Table 7 in Rule H6.2.2.1.1 apply when the
Light Industrial and Mixed Use or centres zones adjoin.
6650-
108
Amend the PAUP to ensure adequate noise provisions are in place to address noise concerns
between different zones.
6650-
109
Amend the PAUP to ensure adequate provisions are in place to regulate internal noise in the
habitable rooms of dwellings and apartments.
6650-
110
Limited laura.swan@hainesplanning.co.nz Sustainable Development C7.7/H6.4 Sustainable design Delete Section 6.4 Sustainable Development.
6650-
111
Limited laura.swan@hainesplanning.co.nz Residential zones Housing affordability H6.6 Rules Amend provisions to clarify they do not apply to retirement village activities.
6650-
112
Amend Activity Table to provide for retirement villages as a Permitted activity in the Large Lot,
Single House, Mixed Housing Suburban, Mixed Housing Urban and Terrace Housing and
Apartment Building zones.
6650-
113
Amend activity table to provide for retirement villages as a restricted discretionary activity in
6650-
114
Limited laura.swan@hainesplanning.co.nz Residential zones Residential Land use controls
Amend Rule 3.1 'Maximum density' to clarify that the rule does not apply to retirement village
activities. This could be achieved by adding a new clause that reads '10. Clause 1 above
does not apply to retirement village activities.'
6650-
115
General Delete rules 6.12, 7.22, 8.24 and 9.23 Universal design.
6650-
116
Centre) Business
Park zones Delete rule 4.1 'Development control infringements'.
6650-
117
Centre) Business
& Bus. Park zones
Amend activity table by providing for new buildings as a permitted activity in the business
zones.
6650-
118
Centre) Business
& Bus. Park zones
Amend activity table to provide for retirement villages as a permitted activity in the Metro
Centre, Town Centre and Mixed Use zones.
6650-
119
Centre) Business
& Bus. Park zones
Amend activity table to provide for retirement villages as a discretionary activity in the General
Business and Business Park zones.
6650-
120
Centre) Business
& Bus. Park zones
Amend provision in activity table to read 'Alterations to building facades that are less than:- 10
20 per cent of its total surface area, or- 15 50m whichever is the lesser greater'.
6650-
121
Centre) Business
& Bus. Park zones
Amend provision in activity table to read 'Alterations to buildings that are less than:- 10 20 per
cent of the exisitng GFA or 250m2 whichever is the lesser greater'.
6650-
122
Centre) Business
Amend activity table to provide for retirement villages as a discretionary activity in the Light
Industry zone.
6650-
123
Centre) Business I3.2 Notification Delete Rule 2 'Notification'.
6650-
124
Centre) Business
Park zones
Amend Table 1 under Rule 4.2 'Building height' by removing the column 'Maximum number of
storeys'.
6650-
125
Limited laura.swan@hainesplanning.co.nz General Cross plan matters Remove all rules relating to the maximum number of storeys.
6650-
126
Centre) Business
Park zones Amend Rule 4.2 'Building Height' to provide for greater height limits in some Mixed Use areas.
6650-
127
Centre) Business
Park zones Amend Rule 4.2 to provide for increased heights following a more detailed analysis of areas.
388/1145
Sub#/
6650-
128
Centre) Business
Park zones
Amend all figures in Table 2 under Rule 4.3 'Height in relation to boundary' to provide greater
flexibility when a new building to the south has a more sensitive zone. This could be achieved
by increasing the angle to 55 degrees and increasing the vertical height the measurement is
taken from to half of the height limit for the adjoining zoning. Retain the height in relation to
boundary measurement technique when a road is present.
6650-
129
Centre) Business
Park zones Delete Rule 4.4 'Building setback at upper floors'.
6650-
130
Centre) Business
Park zones Delete Rule 4.5 'Maximum tower dimension and tower separation'.
6650-
131
Centre) Business
Park zones Delete Rule 4.8 'Minimum floor to floor/ceiling height'.
6650-
132
Centre) Business
Park zones Delete Rule 4.12 'Ground floor at street frontage level'.
6650-
133
Centre) Business
Park zones Amend Table 4 to Rule 4.15 'Yards' to remove reference to intermittent streams.
6650-
134
Centre) Business
Park zones
Amend Table 4 under Rule 4.15 'Yards' to read 'Coastal Protection Yard: 25 20m, or as
otherwise specified in appendix 6.7'.
6650-
135
Centre) Business
Park zones
Amend Rule 4.20 'Dwellings, visitor accommodation and boarding houses' by adding the
following '4. Rule 3.4.20 does not apply to retirement village activities. Refer to specific
retirement village activity Rule XX in Chapter H: Auckland Wide Rules'.
6650-
136
Centre) Business
zones Retain Rule 5.1 'Building height'.
6650-
137
Centre) Business
zones
Amend Table 6 under Rule 5.2 'Height in relation to boundary' by adding further figures so
that the point above ground level at which the recession angle starts should be half the
maximum height for the adjoining zone, while the recession angle should also be greater
where the sensitive zone is to the north of the industrial zone.
6650-
138
Centre) Business
zones
Amend Rule 5.3 'Maximum impervious area' to read '1. Maximum impervious area: 80 95 per
cent.'
6650-
139
Centre) Business
zones
Amend Table 7 under Rule 5.4 'Yards' to only provide for extensive landscaping controls
where there is an interface with residential zones (refer to page 59/97 of submission for
details).
6650-
140
Centre) Business
zones
Amend Rule 5.4 Yards to read '...rubbish collection areas in an industrial zone that directly
face and are visible from a residential, rural or public open space zone adjoining a boundary
with, or on the opposite side of the road from an industrial zone...'.
6650-
141
Centre) Business
Special information
requirements Delete Rule 10 'Special Information Requirements'.
6650-
142
Limited laura.swan@hainesplanning.co.nz City Centre Zone I4 Rules/Appendix 7.1- 7.3 Retain the provision of retirement villages as a permitted activity.
6650-
143
Limited laura.swan@hainesplanning.co.nz City Centre Zone I4 Rules/Appendix 7.1- 7.3
Amend rules 4.25, 4.29, 4.34, 4.36. 4.37, 4.39, 4.40 and 4.41 to be less restrictive in relation
to design and to apply specific retirement village provisions.
6650-
144
Limited laura.swan@hainesplanning.co.nz Future Urban I5 Rules Amend Activity Table to include retirement villages as a discretionary activity.
6650-
145
Limited laura.swan@hainesplanning.co.nz Rural Zones General I13.1 Activity table
Amend activity table to provide for retirement villages as a permitted activity in the
Countryside Living zone.
6650-
146
Limited laura.swan@hainesplanning.co.nz Rural Zones General I13.1 Activity table
Amend activity table to provide for retirement villages as a discretionary activity in the Rural
Coastal, Mixed Rural and Rural Production zones.
6650-
147
Limited laura.swan@hainesplanning.co.nz Rural Zones General I13.2 Land use controls
Amend Rule 2.6 'Dwellings', Table 1, to read '...3. This rule does not apply to dwellings
associated with retirement villages...'
6650-
148
Limited laura.swan@hainesplanning.co.nz Rural Zones General I13.2 Land use controls
Amend Rule 2.11 'Restaurants and cafes' to read '...4. This rule does not apply to restaurants
and cafes associated with retirement villages...'
6650-
149
Limited laura.swan@hainesplanning.co.nz Rural Zones General I13.3 Development controls
Amend Table 3 under Rule 3.2 'Yards' to read '...20m from the edge of permanent and
intermittent streams...'
6650-
150
Limited laura.swan@hainesplanning.co.nz Rural Zones General I13.3 Development controls
Amend Table 3 under Rule 3.2 'Yards' to require a minimum setback of 0m from the coastal
protection yard.
389/1145
Sub#/
6650-
151
Limited laura.swan@hainesplanning.co.nz Rural Zones General I13.3 Development controls Delete Rule 3.4 'Landscaping in the Countryside Living zone only'.
6650-
152
and policies
Delete Retirement Village zone and replace with Auckland-wide provisions that apply to the
activity in a range of zones [set out in Annexures 2 and 3 of submission].
6650-
153
Limited laura.swan@hainesplanning.co.nz Residential zones Retirement Village zone I21 Rules
Amend Activity Table to refer to an 'approved' concept plan, rather than an 'incorporated'
concept plan.
6650-
154
Limited laura.swan@hainesplanning.co.nz Definitions New
Define 'Concept Plan' to mean that which is included in the Proposed Plan or approved
through resource consent.
6650-
155
Amend Activity Table to delete activities relating to 'Alterations, additions and demolition' and
'New buildings' and amend the activity status of 'Any development not complying with an
approved concept plan' to restricted discretionary (refer to pages 64 and 65/97 of submission
for details).
6650-
156
Heritage
places
Amend activity table to provide for subdivision as a discretionary activity in the Primary feature
Category A place, Primary feature Category A* place and Category B place and non-primary
features within the scheduled place extent of Category A and A* place.
6650-
157
Heritage
places
Amend Activity Table 1 by changing all the activity status' in the 'Features identified in
exclusions' column to permitted.
6650-
158
Limited laura.swan@hainesplanning.co.nz Precincts - South Flat Bush
Amend rule 1.2 'Density' to read '...2. Any application not meeting the density requirements of
clause 2.1.1 shall be a non-complying discretionary activity...'
6650-
159
Limited laura.swan@hainesplanning.co.nz Precincts - South Flat Bush Amend Rule 2.1 'Yards' to reduce rear yard setback to 1m in all areas of sub-precinct A.
6650-
160
Amend Rule 3.3 'Maximum building coverage' to increase maximum building coverage control
to 50% in Areas 1-6 or sub-precinct A.
6650-
161
Amend Rule 9 'Special information requirements' to read 'When a site contains a stream or
wetland, A a riparian planting plan shall be provided as part of any application for land
modification, development and or subdivision.'
6650-
162
Limited laura.swan@hainesplanning.co.nz Definitions Existing Amend definition of 'Artificial watercourse' to include man-made stormwater ponds.
6650-
163
Amend definition of 'Composting' to read 'The biological treatment or decomposition of
organic material under controlled conditions. For the purposes of the Unitary Plan, the
definition excludes composting undertaken for domestic purposes.'
6650-
164
Amend the definition of 'Dwelling' to include the clause 'For clarity, a dwelling includes a unit
within a retirement village that meets the description above.'
6650-
165
Amend definition of 'Hospital' to remove 'Supported residential care' and list it separately in all
activity tables.
6650-
166
Amend the definition of 'Impervious' to read '...gardens and other landscaped areas
...swimming pools.'
6650-
167
Amend the definition of 'Landscaped area' to allow for more flexibility in what constitutes an
area being landscaped (refer to pages 68 and 69/97 of submission for details).
6650-
168
Amend definition of 'Retained affordable housing' to include the following clause 'This
definition does not apply to dwellings in a retirement village.'
6650-
169
Amend the definition of 'Retirement village' as follows: 'A managed comprehensive residential
as defined in s.6 of the Retirement Villages Act 2003; recreation, leisure, welfare and
medical facilities (inclusive of hospital care) and other non-residential activities accessory to
the retirement village (if provided). A retirement village may include Supported Residential
Care Activities.'
6650-
170
Limited laura.swan@hainesplanning.co.nz Definitions Existing Retain the definition of 'Supported residential care'.
6650-
171
Heritage
Places
Retain the exclusion for the interior of the buildings in Schedule ID 00130 (Duke House and
Servants' Quarters).
6650-
172
Limited laura.swan@hainesplanning.co.nz Designations Auckland Transport
1834 Road Widening - Flat
Bush School Road Amend the lapse date of Designation 1834 to provide consistency.
6650-
173
Limited laura.swan@hainesplanning.co.nz RPS Issues
growth
Amend 'Unitary Plan issue' to reflect Auckland's aging population and the potential for
efficient development in greenfield areas (refer to page 74/97 of submission for details).
6650-
174
growth Amend 'Explanation' to read '...want to live, and work and retire..."
6650-
175
growth
Amend 'Our sense of place' to reflect the range of accommodation and care options needed
for an aging population (refer to page 75/97 of submission for details).
6650-
176
growth
Amend 'Social Well-being' to reflect Auckland's aging population, the need to provided
appropriate retirement accommodation, and the potential for efficient residential development
in greenfield areas (refer to pages 75 and 76/97 of submission for details).
390/1145
Sub#/
6650-
177
growth
Amend 'Supply of land in appropriate locations' to read '...communities can grow. Provision of
private infrastructure to support growth and the needs of communities may be appropriate in
some cases.'
6650-
178
Amend Objective 1 to read 'A quality compact urban form with most development within a
clear defensible limit (Rural Urban Boundary - RUB) to the urban expansion of the
metropolitan area, satellite towns, rural and coastal towns and serviced villages.'
6650-
179
Add a new objective to read '5. A diverse range of residential and business growth
opportunities will be facilitated throughout the city region to cater for demand in all geographic
areas and for all lifestyle needs.'
6650-
180
Amend Policy 2 to read '2...e. to provide for the accommodation and care needs of all
members of the community, including the elderly.'
6650-
181
Add policy that reads '4. Enable development outside of the RUB, when, the particular
circumstance, features of the site and proposed development will help achieve the objectives
and policies of the Auckland Unitary Plan and Directives of the Auckland Plan.'
6650-
182
needed for an aging population (refer to pages 79 and 80/97 of submission for details).
6650-
183
growth
Amend 'Introduction' to reflect the potential for flexibility in the design of streets, public spaces
and buildings to ensure they are appropriate for their intended use (refer to page 80/97 of
6650-
184
environment
Amend Policy 1 to read '1. Require development to be designed to integrate all relevant
elements of a place, buildings or space into a coherently designed solution.'
6650-
185
environment
Amend Policy 2 to read '2. Design development to respond positively to the site and its
context, while considering new opportunities and sites potential, as well asand the planned
future character of the place, and to reinforce the role of the public realm as the primary place
for public interaction .'
6650-
186
environment
Amend Policy 3 to read 'Require Encourage development to contribute to the safety of the
street and neighbourhood.'
6650-
187
6650-
188
environment
Amend Policy 8 to read 'Enable the development of a range of built forms within
neighbourhoods to support maximum choice and recognise different lifestyles and
demographics.'
6650-
189
environment
Amend Policy 9 to read 'Design streets and block patterns that maximise provide adequate
connectivity, provide for a range of travel options and have a high standard of amenity and
safety for pedestrians and cyclists to promote walking and cycling.
6650-
190
6650-
191
6650-
192
Amend Objective 4 to read 'The development of land zoned future urban within and
outside the RUB occurs in an orderly, timely and planned manner.'
6650-
193
Amend Policy 1 to read 'Maintain sufficient unconstrained residential and business zoned land
within the RUB to accommodate an average of seven 10 years land supply at any one time.'
6650-
194
Amend Policy 2 to read 'Enable the continued use of land zoned future urban within the RUB
for rural activities until resource consents are granted or urban zonings are applied through a
structure plan and plan change process, provided that rural subdivision, use and development
does not compromise the future urban use of the land or lead to land fragmentation.'
6650-
195
Amend Policy 3 to read '...e. close proximity to existing or planned significant infrastructure,
particularly where residential activities would cause reverse sensitive effects that cannot be
managed'
6650-
196
Amend Policy 4 to reflect the social and economic costs of not releasing the required
greenfield land (refer to page 83/97 of submission for details).
6650-
197
Add new policy to outline the potential circumstances in which greenfield land within the RUB
can be released for urban development without a plan change, particularly where a concept
plan is included with the resource consent (refer to page 84/97 of submission for details).
6650-
198
Amend Policy 2 to read 'Require Encourage new large-scale residential development within
the RUB and encourage all other development to provide a proportion of dwellings that are
affordable for the intermediate housing market.'
391/1145
Sub#/
6650-
199
Add new section titled '2.4A Neighbourhoods that provide housing choice', including an
introduction, objective, policies and explanation that provide for a range of residential
accommodation that are appropriate for the diversity and needs of Auckland's population
(refer to page 85/97 of submission for details).
6650-
200
and villages
Amend Objective 1 to read 'Growth in towns and villages enables residents to obtain the
services and housing choices they require while being is sustainable and efficient, capturing
and enhancing the local character and sense of place of the town or village and the
surrounding area.'
6650-
201
and villages
Amend Objective 2 to read 'Growth within un-serviced villages is primarily contained within
their urban zones existing at September 2013.'
6650-
202
and villages
Amend Objective 3 to read 'Growth in towns and serviced villages is primarily contained within
the RUB.'
6650-
203
and villages
Amend Policy 1 to read '...f. achieves high environmental performance and a high quality built
environment that provides and contributes to housing choice...j. is in accordance with
resource consent requirements or the structure plan guidelines in Appendix 1.1...'
6650-
204
and villages
Amend 'Explanation and reasons' to read '...towns and serviced villages. But Council
recognises that new towns and serviced villages may be a viable and sustainable growth
option where specific criteria can be met. It is expected...'
6650-
205
Limited laura.swan@hainesplanning.co.nz RPS Urban growth B2.7 Social infrastructure
Amend 'Introduction' to include reference to retirement villages and supported residential care
as social infrastructure providers and how retirement villages and supported residential care
privatise some aspects of healthcare and reduce the burden on the public health system
(refer to pages 88 and 89/97 of submission for details).
6650-
206
Amend Policy 1 to include reference to retirement villages and supported residential care as
examples of social infrastructure (refer to page 89/97 of submission for details).
6650-
207
Amend Policy 2 to read 'Provide Auckland with sufficient social infrastructure to meet the
needs of its growing and ageing population by:...'
6650-
208
Limited laura.swan@hainesplanning.co.nz RPS Urban growth B2.7 Social infrastructure Amend Policy 6 to read '...f. provide for the needs of people of all ages and cultures.'
6650-
209
Amend 'Explanation' to read '...This is particularly important for an aging, diverse and growing
city...'
6650-
210
Limited laura.swan@hainesplanning.co.nz RPS Rural B8.1 Rural activities
Add new objective that reads '4. Rural areas have access to the local services and amenities
they require.'
6650-
211
Limited laura.swan@hainesplanning.co.nz RPS Rural B8.1 Rural activities Amend Policy 2 to read '...c. predominantly serve residents in, or from, rural areas.'
6650-
212
Amend Policy 3 to provide for urban activities, including housing, in rural areas for retired local
residents (refer to page 91/97 of submission for details).
6650-
213
Amend 'Explanation' to read '...are not compromised now or in the future by urban activities,
urban g rowth, or inappropriate rural activities.'
6650-
214
and policies
Add new section to the Auckland-wide objectives and policies titled '8. Retirement Villages',
including a number of objectives and policies that provide for more enabling development of
retirement villages [if the Retirement Village zone is deleted] [refer to page 93/97 of
6650-
215
Add new section to the Auckland-wide rules titled '7. Retirement Villages', including the
following development controls: height in relation to boundary, height, Yards, maximum
impervious area, maximum building coverage and minimum landscaped permeable area [if
the Retirement Village zone is deleted] [refer to pages, 94 and 95/97 of submission for
details].
6650-
216
Add new activity table for retirement villages [under Auckland-wide rules] providing for new
buildings as a restricted discretionary activity [if the Retirement Village zone is deleted] [refer
to page 94/97 of submission for details].
6650-
217
Add matters of discretion for new buildings in a retirement village [if new buildings in
retirement villages are provided for at an Auckland-wide level] [refer to page 97/97 of
6650-
218
Limited laura.swan@hainesplanning.co.nz RPS Changes to the RUB South
Rezone 53, 59 and 65 Pararekau Road, Hingaia, from Future Urban to Terrace Housing and
6650-
219
Amend the Activity Table to provide for retirement villages as a permitted activity in the
6650-
220
and policies
Amend Objective 1 as follows: 'Retirement villages are located throughout the Auckland
Region to enable people to remain in their communities when they retire, retaining strength
and diversity in communities make efficient use of land and infrastructure within the RUB .'
6650-
221
and policies
Amend Objective 2 as follows: 'Retirement villages provide for a range of accommodation
options and accessory activities, including healthcare and recreation facilities to meet
the specific needs of the residents.'
392/1145
Sub#/
6650-
222
and policies
Amend Objective 3 as follows: 'Developments are designed to recognise and support the
unique operational needs of the activity well-designed and provide high-quality on-site
amenity .
6650-
223
and policies
Add a new objective as follows: 'Communities are enhanced by the economic and social
benefits that retirement villages create.'
6650-
224
6650-
225
6650-
226
Limited laura.swan@hainesplanning.co.nz General Cross plan matters
Amend all activity tables to ensure there is no inconsistency between the uses of Supported
Residential Care and Retirement Villages and Hospitals.
6650-
227
Centre) Business
& Bus. Park zones
Amend Activity Table by providing for retirement villages as a permitted activity in the centres
and Mixed Use zones.
6651-1 David P Walden david.walden@whybintbwa.co.nz General Miscellaneous Other Adopt the relief sought by the Herne Bay Residents Association Incorporated
6652-1 Werner Kloepfer
Houseboat O'Brien Road, Waiheke
Island, Auckland 1081
the CMA Mooring zone I8.1 Activity table Amend activity status of 'houseboats' from Restricted Discretionary to Permitted.
the CMA Mooring zone
Amend development controls for houseboats to include: 1. 7 houseboats in the Rangihoua
Mooring Area. 2. The uniform annual general charge shall be payed by every houseboat. 3.
There should be no houseboat rented out. 4. Yearly measurement of water quality.
the CMA Mooring zone I8.2 Assessment Delete matters of discretion for houseboats.
6653-1 Heather Ballantyne
michael.savage@parkchambers.co.n
z Precincts - South Runciman
Delete from Precinct Plan 2 the indicative route of trail sections highlighted in yellow on the
attached plan [page 3/5 of the submission].
Delete from Precinct Plan 3 the cultural heritage site highlighted in yellow on the attached plan
(and possibly relocating it into an adjoining property if Council has that information) [page 4/5
of the submission].
Delete from Precinct Plan 4 the sections of riparian corridors highlighted in yellow on the
attached plan [page 5/5 of the submission].
6654-1 GreensceneNZ Limited info@greenscenenz.com Trees
streets and public open space H3.1 Rules Amend Activity Table 1.1 to delete provision for tree trimming in roads.
6654-2 GreensceneNZ Limited info@greenscenenz.com Definitions Existing
Amend the definition of 'tree trimming' and standardise with reference to arboricultural
terminology.
6654-3 GreensceneNZ Limited info@greenscenenz.com RPS
character and natural heritage B4.3.3 Trees and vegetation Retain use of SEA's and other overlays to protect environmental features, including trees.
Specify individual allotments in order to protect trees on those allotments within the SEA
overlay.
features
Specify individual allotments in order to protect trees on those allotments under the ONF, and
ONL overlays.
Specify individual allotments in order to protect trees on those allotments under the Coastal
Natural Character overlay.
character and natural heritage B4.3.3 Trees and vegetation Retain the protection of historic and notable trees across Auckland.
Trees J6.4 Rules
Amend Activity Table to provide consistency of activity status between trimming of and
removal of deadwood from notable trees.
Trees J6.4 Rules
Amend Activity Table to apply more cautious approach to trimming of notable trees, in
particular in relation to maximum diameter for permitted trimming (50mm).
Trees J6.4 Rules
Amend rules to restrict permitted trimming of notable trees to that which is required for
maintenance of foliage up to a stated distance from to existing structures.
Trees
Notable Trees Amend Schedule to list notable trees in alphabetical order.
6655-1 BNZ kenny_clark@bnz.co.nz RPS
Transport
B3.1 Commercial and
industrial growth
Retain emphasis placed on growth through business-friendly planning that reduces risks,
costs and uncertainties
6655-2 BNZ kenny_clark@bnz.co.nz
Centre) Business
General objectives and policies Retain simplified Business zoning
6655-3 BNZ kenny_clark@bnz.co.nz RPS Mana Whenua
participation
Retain the general Te Tiriti o Waitangi approach and the recognition of the intended outcomes
of the Te Tiriti o Waitangi settlement process
Retain emphasis on developing Mana Whenua, strengthening Mori communities and
achieving outcomes for Mori
393/1145
Sub#/
participation
Retain co-management of resources, promotion of partnerships with Mana Whenua and
sustainable development of Mori outcomes
6655-6 BNZ kenny_clark@bnz.co.nz General Miscellaneous
Operational/
Projects/Acquisition Include permanent artistic Mori features and dual signage around Auckland
6655-7 BNZ kenny_clark@bnz.co.nz RPS Urban growth
environment
Retain emphasis on buildings which are efficient, minimise environmental impacts and create
healthy environments to live and work
6655-8 BNZ kenny_clark@bnz.co.nz RPS Issues
Recognise the importance of efficient use of resources, understanding and minimising our
impact and dependency on biodiversity and ecosystem services and addressing climate
change
6655-9 BNZ kenny_clark@bnz.co.nz Residential zones Housing affordability H6.6 Rules Reject the requirement for retained affordable housing [rule 1.1]
6655-10 BNZ kenny_clark@bnz.co.nz Residential zones Housing affordability H6.6 Rules
Delete the reference to a 5% price increase on dwellings near a bus, train or ferry services
with greater than one hour frequency during off-peak times
6655-11 BNZ kenny_clark@bnz.co.nz RPS Urban growth
environment
Amend emphasis on 'buildings of high quality design' to also consider the financial viability of
projects as a whole
Operational/
Projects/Acquisition Retain provision of consistent, reliable public transport to main business hubs
Operational/
Projects/Acquisition Implement plans for the improvement of cycle ways and lanes
6656-1 Mark Vickerman wendy@isleland.co.nz Mana Whenua
Whenua
whenua Delete the overlay from 402C Orapiu Rd, Waiheke Island
Whenua J5.1 Rules
Amend the activity table as follows: Earthworks on or within 50m of a site or place of value to
Mana Whenua. Amend assessment criteria in light of this change. Alternatively modify the
rule to trigger a resource consent only where earthworks fall within the known extent of an
archaeological site.
6656-3 Mark Vickerman wendy@isleland.co.nz Mana Whenua General provisions
assessment
Delete the mandatory requirement for a cultural impact assessment. Amend to allow the
assessment to be undertaken by a recognised specialist
Whenua
objectives and policies Delete the requirement in any objective, policy or rule for consultation with any party
Whenua J5.1 Rules
Amend to retain a level of discretion to Council over whether to incorporate the outcomes and
recommendations of any cultural impact assessment [under J5.1.3].
6657-1 Mike Elliott philip@campbellbrown.co.nz Zoning Central
Rezone those sites on the eastern side of Great South Road and Station Road, Penrose
between the Penrose Train Station and the intersection with the Ellerslie-Panmure Highway
from the Light Industry Zone to the Mixed Use Zone [refer to Attachment B, page 8/9 of the
submission].
6657-2 Mike Elliott philip@campbellbrown.co.nz Precincts - Central New Precincts Other New Precincts
Add an additional precinct which restricts residential activities on sites in this location [the
eastern side of Great South Road and Station Road, Penrose between the Penrose Train
Station and the intersection with the Ellerslie-Panmure Highway].
6658-1
Saint Stephens and Queen
Victoria Schools Trust Board c.covington@harrisongrierson.com Zoning Central Rezone 27 Glanville Tce, Parnell from Special Purpose - School to Mixed Use.
6658-2
Victoria Schools Trust Board c.covington@harrisongrierson.com Zoning Central
Rezone 27 Glanville Tce, Parnell from Special Purpose - School to an underlying zone of
either Mixed Use or Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings with a School Precinct if these
are reintroduced.
6658-3
Victoria Schools Trust Board c.covington@harrisongrierson.com
control
Building demolition control J.3.6 Rules and mapping Remove the overlay from 27 Glanville Tce, Parnell.
6658-4
Victoria Schools Trust Board c.covington@harrisongrierson.com Designations Auckland Transport
Beachlands Road
Amend the conditions as follows: ... 26. In accordance with Section 184(1)(c) of the Resource
Management Act 1991, the designation will lapse on the expiry of 30 9 years after the date on
which it is included in the District Plan unless:... Refer Vol 2 page 2/3 of submission for
details.
6658-5
Victoria Schools Trust Board c.covington@harrisongrierson.com Zoning South Retain the Special Purpose - School zone at 1832 Great South Rd, Bombay.
6659-1 Aaron D W Shinton shintondesign@gmail.com Residential zones Residential
and Coastal Settlement zone Amend rules to enable secondary dwellings in the Single House zone.
6660-1 David Waters marie.tomasia@gmail.com
Outstanding Natural
Rules
Character - Coastal
Extend outstanding natural coastline area from western point of Oneroa Bay to Park Point,
excluding Owhanake Bay and Matiaitia Bay, Waiheke Island.
394/1145
Sub#/
6660-2 David Waters marie.tomasia@gmail.com Zoning Coastal
Amend Coastal Management Area on Waiheke Island to recognise existing small craft
mooring areas, particularly Okahuiti tidal area and Rangihoua creek (houseboats).
6660-3 David Waters marie.tomasia@gmail.com
controls
Amend development control 2.15 to provide for discharges of untreated sewage from
pleasure craft as a permitted activity at least 1km from shore (retaining the 2km limit for
commercial vessels).
6661-1 Peter A Sergent peter@techsys.co.nz Precincts - North Kawau Island Retain precinct.
6661-2 Peter A Sergent peter@techsys.co.nz
SEAs
Land Retain having no SEAs on Kawau Island.
the CMA
and occupation
D5.1.13 Background,
Amend Background by adding the following to the last paragraph: and then only after
consultation with affected property owners. Properties which are dependent on structures in
the CMA for access, shall be exempt from any such charges.
6661-4 Peter A Sergent peter@techsys.co.nz Precincts - North Kawau Island
Amend Policy 5 as follows: Recognise the importance of sea access while managing the
number of wharves, jetties and other access structures by encouraging joint ownership,
and/or joint access where appropriate, ensuring that new access structures are established
only where there is a need, and by obtaining and requiring esplanade reserves, esplanade
strips and access strips.
6661-5 Peter A Sergent peter@techsys.co.nz Precincts - North Kawau Island
Amend 4.1(2)(a) Sub-precinct A subdivision of low intensity settlement sites restricted
discretionary activity as follows: Up to five sites may be created, all gaining frontage either
over a jointly owned access lot or right-of-way not less than six metres in width (or a
combination of both) or direct to the foreshore. Each site must have legal access to a jetty or
wharf. Sites are not required to have legal access to a road, notwithstanding any rules to the
contrary in the underlying zone and Auckland-wide rules.
the CMA
sch. 6.2 ONC/HNC
6.1 Schedule SEA
Marine 1 and 2
Delete Appendix 6.1 Kawau Island description or signal a structure to work with Kawau
Islanders through Kawau Island Advisory Committee to create a more accurate fact based
description.
Amend Activity 1.7 Discharges to outline that discharges, including 'Discharge of untreated
sewage from a vessel or offshore installation', must comply with nationwide regulations.
Outstanding Natural
Rules
Character - Coastal
Delete IDs 64, 65, 66, 67, 68 and 69 from Kawau Island or re-assess and re-write them to
reflect the reality of the situation with regards to unmodified forests.
Outstanding Natural
Rules
J6.2.4 Assessment
Amend 3.3 Yards [under J6.2.3 Development controls] as follows: c. 6m from mean high
water springs on Kawau Island.
6662-1 Gregory J Devine gregd@xtra.co.nz Special Character
& C
Isthmus
Extend the Special Character overlay in Epsom to include 547 Manukau Road, Epsom and
the area in general.
6662-2 Gregory J Devine gregd@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central
Extend the 'low lying zoning' [Single House zone] at the Manukau Road end of the block
(Empire Road, Manukau Road and Banff Ave) to Banff Ave, Epsom by deleting the Mixed
Use and Apartment zoning on that end of the block.
6662-3 Gregory J Devine gregd@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central
Delete the Mixed Use zone on Manukau Road, Epsom (from Golf Road to Greenwoods
corner).
6663-1
Saint Johns College Trust
Board c.covington@harrisongrierson.com Precincts Ak-Wide and Coastal New Precincts All other New Precincts
Apply a Tertiary Education precinct, in the same location as the Tertiary Education zone at
188-280 St Johns Road, St Johns as detailed on Attachment 2 in Vol 1 page 111/129 of the
submission.
6663-2
Board c.covington@harrisongrierson.com Zoning Central
Rezone 188-280 St Johns Road, St Johns from Tertiary Education to Mixed Housing Urban
and Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings as detailed on Attachment 2 in Vol 1 page
111/129 of the submission.
6663-3
Rezone 188-280 St Johns Road, St Johns from Single House to Mixed Housing Urban within
the western portion of the site, as detailed on Attchment 2 in Vol 1 page 111/129 of the
submission.
6663-4
Rezone 188-280 St Johns Road, St Johns from Single House to Terrace Housing and
Apartment Buildings within the eastern portion of the site, as detailed on Attachment 2 in Vol 1
6663-5
Board c.covington@harrisongrierson.com Zoning Central Retain Tertiary Education zone at 188-280 St Johns Road, St Johns.
6663-6
Board c.covington@harrisongrierson.com Special Character
& C
Isthmus Delete Isthmus B overlay from 188-280 St Johns Road, St Johns.
395/1145
Sub#/
6663-7
Board c.covington@harrisongrierson.com Historic Heritage (Overlay)
Heritage
Places
Remove the Historic Heritage extent of place [ID 1857] in Appendix 9.1 from 188-280 St
Johns Road, St Johns.
6663-8
Board c.covington@harrisongrierson.com Historic Heritage (Overlay)
Heritage
Places
Reduce the Historic Heritage extent of place [ID 1857] in Appendix 9.1, to match that of the
Operative Plan as detailed on Attachment 3 in Vol 1 page 112/129 of the submission.
6663-9
Rezone 350 St Heliers Bay Road, St Johns from Mixed Housing suburban to Neighbourhood
Centre.
6663-10
Board c.covington@harrisongrierson.com
control
Building demolition control J.3.6 Rules and mapping Remove the overlay from 55 and 57 Ripon Crescent, Meadowbank.
6663-11
Rezone 1/288, 2/288, 290, 1/292, 2/292, 1/296, 2/296, 3/296 St Johns Road, St Heliers from
Mixed Housing Suburban to Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings.
6663-12
Rezone 1/95, 2/95, 3/95, 4/95, 5/95, 97, 99A and 99B St Johns Road, Meadowbank from
Mixed Housing Suburban to Mixed Housing Urban.
6663-13
Board c.covington@harrisongrierson.com Zoning North and Islands Rezone 15 Home Place, Rosedale from Light Industrial to General Business.
6663-14
Board c.covington@harrisongrierson.com Zoning North and Islands
Rezone properties adjacent to Home Place and Holder Place, Rosedale shown as red in
Image 1 of Vol 2 page 2/4 from Light Industrial to General Business.
6663-15
Board c.covington@harrisongrierson.com Zoning Central Rezone 102 Lunn Avenue, Mt Wellington from Light Industrial to General Business.
6663-16
Rezone properties adjacent to Lunn Avenue, Mt Wellington, shown as red in Image 1 of Vol 3
page 2/4 from Light Industrial to General Business.
6664-1 John and Frances Sargent wendy@isleland.co.nz Mana Whenua
Whenua
whenua Delete the overlay from 35 and 41 Park Point Drive, Waiheke Island
Whenua J5.1 Rules
Amend the activity table as follows: Earthworks on or within 50m of a site or place of value to
Mana Whenua. Amend assessment criteria in light of this change. Alternatively modify the
rule to trigger a resource consent only where earthworks fall within the known extent of an
archaeological site.
6664-3 John and Frances Sargent wendy@isleland.co.nz Mana Whenua General provisions
assessment
Delete the mandatory requirement for a cultural impact assessment. Amend to allow the
assessment to be undertaken by a recognised specialist
Whenua
objectives and policies Delete the requirement in any objective, policy or rule for consultation with any party
Whenua J5.1 Rules
Amend to retain a level of discretion to Council over whether to incorporate the outcomes and
recommendations of any cultural impact assessment [under J5.1.3].
6665-1 Hololio Farm hololio@xtra.co.nz RPS
Amend to provide rates relief, free heritage consultation and resource consents for
landowners of heritage buildings
6665-2 Hololio Farm hololio@xtra.co.nz Historic Heritage (Overlay)
Heritage
places Amend to enable innovative uses of heritage sites to fund their preservation
6665-3 Hololio Farm hololio@xtra.co.nz Precincts - South Clevedon
Amend the Precinct to include properties on McNicol Road which are listed as historic
heritage places and extent of places, and the surrounding area
6665-4 Hololio Farm hololio@xtra.co.nz Precincts - South Clevedon Amend so the entire extent of 116 Monument Road, Clevedon is included within the Precinct
Amend to enable inclusion of land outside the Precinct to be included in a framework plan
where the majority of that property is within the Precinct
Amend the boundaries of sub-precincts 1B and 3 back toward Monument Road to take
account of landforms, natural features and property boundaries, particularly in relation to 116
Monument Road
6665-7 Hololio Farm hololio@xtra.co.nz Precincts - South Clevedon Reject the prohibited activity status for subdivision prior to 31 July 2017
6665-8 Hololio Farm hololio@xtra.co.nz Precincts - South Clevedon Amend the activity status of Retirement Villages to discretionary in sub-precincts 1A and 1B
Amend the activity status of farming after reticulated wastewater is provided but prior to
subdivision, in sub-precinct 2 to permitted
6665-10 Hololio Farm hololio@xtra.co.nz Rural Zones General I13.1 Activity table Amend to enable second dwellings in all Rural zones as a permitted activity
6666-1
Susanne Fisher and Hugh
McDonald Wendy@isleland.co.nz
the CMA Mooring zone I8.1 Activity table Retain the Discretionary activity status for new and existing swing moorings.
6666-2
Amend Policy 3 as follows 'Determine the appropriateness of new or existing moorings
outside a Mooring zone by also taking into account the following circumstances:' and add new
clauses as follows 'The period which a mooring has been established and any potential
adverse effects generated by the occupation of this time' and 'The ability of an existing
mooring to be available for public use'.
396/1145
Sub#/
6666-3
Add new assessment criteria as follows 'The period which a mooring has been established
and any potential adverse effects generated by the occupation over this time' and 'The ability
of an existing mooring to be available for public use'.
6667-1
Matthew N and Sharon
Henderson sxhenderson1@gmail.com
control
Building demolition control J.3.6 Rules and mapping Remove the overlay from 31 Lippiatt Road, Otahuhu.
6667-2
Matthew N and Sharon
Henderson sxhenderson1@gmail.com Residential zones Residential
Amend the development controls [Single House] to make them less restrictive and to allow for
site redevelopment in a manner consistent with Otahuhu's character.
6668-1 Seeby Woodhouse seeby@orcon.net.nz
SEAs
Land Delete SEA overlay from 35 Beach Road, Caster Bay
6669-1
Ostend and Okahuiti Residents
and Ratepayers Association
Incorporated bernard.rhodes@gmail.com Zoning Coastal
Add a Causeway Mooring zone at Waiheke that defines a navigation channel through the
centre of the inlet to the Boating Club launching ramp, with moorings each site. A port hand
beacon would mark the bend in the channel, provide a reference for delineating the Mooring
zones and be a useful navigation aid. The eastern zone would extend to 100m below Mean
High Water Springs in way of Wharf Road and the Ostend Domain Reserve, to keep the
boats at a respectful distance from the grassed reserve. See map on page 7/8 of submission.
6669-2
Incorporated bernard.rhodes@gmail.com General Miscellaneous Other
Council to provide rubbish disposal, re-cycling facilities and car parking in return for mooring
fees being levied at the Waiheke Causeway Mooring zone.
6669-3
Incorporated bernard.rhodes@gmail.com
Amend activity status of 'new and existing moorings' by separating it into two with 'existing
moorings' being a Permitted activity in the General Coastal Marine zone and Discretionary in
all other zones; and 'new moorings' being Discretionary in all zones.
6670-1 Denise and Allen Tonkin datonkin@gmail.com
Centre) Business
zones
Amend the height in relation to boundary control [rule 5.2] in the Light Industry zone to provide
greater protection of residential areas adjoining industrial zones
Centre) Business
zones
Amend the Yard development control [rule 5.4] in the Light Industry zone to provide greater
protection of residential areas adjoining industrial zones
Centre) Business
zones
Amend the Storage and Screening development control [rule 5.5] in the Light Industry zone to
provide greater protection of residential areas adjoining industrial zones
6670-4 Denise and Allen Tonkin datonkin@gmail.com Zoning Central
Rezone the area between the Light Industry and Mixed Housing Suburban zones between
Panama Road and George Bourke Drive to Public Open Space Conservation in order to
restore the 'green corridor'
Centre) Business
zones
Amend the setback [rule 5.4] from the Light Industry zone boundary to 10 metres between
Panama Road and George Bourke Drive, Mt Wellington, should the rezone requests to create
a 'green corridor' be denied
6670-6 Denise and Allen Tonkin datonkin@gmail.com Residential zones Residential
Mixed Housing Urban zone Amend rule 7.10 Outlook space, to provide a yard greater than 1m.
Centre) Business
zones
Amend the Maximum impervious area control [rule 5.3] in the Light Industry zoning on George
Bourke Drive, Mt Wellington which adjoins residential development on Panama Road, to
provide greater protection of this residential area
6670-8 Denise and Allen Tonkin datonkin@gmail.com Zoning Central
Rezone sites at the top end of Panama Road, Mt Wellington with stormwater issues, to Single
House
6671-1 Cara Carpenter larminspain@yahoo.co.nz Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula K5.11 Precinct rules
Amend 4.2 Landscaped area by including provisions to retain and enhance the density and
height of the existing bush on the lower north-eastern face of Birchfield Ave, Hauraki, Sub-
precinct B [See amendments on page 1/7].
6671-2 Cara Carpenter larminspain@yahoo.co.nz General Miscellaneous
Operational/
Projects/Acquisition Invest in 'greenways' in conjunction with the Devonport-Takapuna local board.
6672-1 Andrew Roberts andy@barworks.co.nz Historic Heritage (Overlay)
Heritage
Places Add the heritage housing in Pt Chevalier to the overlay
6672-2 Andrew Roberts andy@barworks.co.nz Zoning Central Rezone Mixed Housing [Urban and Suburban] in Pt Chevelier to Single House
6672-3 Andrew Roberts andy@barworks.co.nz Built Environment (Overlays)
Height Control
Delete buildings heights around Great North Road and Pt Chevalier Road, Pt Chevalier [Town
Centre]
6673-1 Bernard U Rhodes bernard.rhodes@gmail.com Water Wastewater
objectives & policies Reject Policy 2(d) with regard to Mana Whenua concerns.
6674-1 Simon M Jones sjones@deltacom.co.nz RPS Mana Whenua B5 Strategic Delete Mana Whenua provisions
397/1145
Sub#/
6675-1
Raewyn A and Lawrence R
Morrison morrisons.takatu@paradise.net.nz Definitions Existing
Amend the definition of 'rural commercial services'. See page 4/5 of the submission for
details. Define rural commercial services as wholly serving activities of a rural nature, and
exclude aerial based rural operations. Also amend the defintion to take into account appeal
decisions and approved consents in the Baddeleys Beach and Kaipara Flats areas.
6675-2
Raewyn A and Lawrence R
Morrison morrisons.takatu@paradise.net.nz Definitions Existing
Amend the definition of 'rural industries'. See page 5/5 of the submission for details. Define
rural commercial services as wholly serving activities of a rural nature, and exclude aerial
based rural operations. Also amend the defintion to take into account appeal decisions and
approved consents in the Baddeleys Beach and Kaipara Flats areas.
6676-1 John and Linda Lewis lindjo@xtra.co.nz RPS Mana Whenua B5 Strategic
6677-1 Milford Centre Limited cbarbour@nzrpg.co.nz RPS Urban growth
Retain the enabling quality urban growth provisions, particularly objectives 1-3 and policies 1-
3
6677-2 Milford Centre Limited cbarbour@nzrpg.co.nz RPS Urban growth
environment Retain Objective 1 and Policies 1-11
6677-3 Milford Centre Limited cbarbour@nzrpg.co.nz RPS
Transport
B3.1 Commercial and
industrial growth
Retain the enabling economic growth provisions, particularly objectives 1 and 2, and policies
1-3 and 5
6677-4 Milford Centre Limited cbarbour@nzrpg.co.nz Residential zones Housing affordability
and policies Delete the affordable housing provisions
6677-5 Milford Centre Limited cbarbour@nzrpg.co.nz
Centre) Business
General objectives and policies Retain objectives and policies, particularly objectives 1-3 and policies 1-5
Centre)
obs & pols Retain objectives and policies, particularly objectives 1-3 and policies 1-6
6677-7 Milford Centre Limited cbarbour@nzrpg.co.nz General Chapter G General provisions
activities Retain rule infringement provisions
Amend G1.4 to clarify that consent applications under regional and district rules will not be
bundled together
status
Amend to clarify that consent applications under regional and district rules will not be bundled
together
Delete the following under the assessment criteria heading in G1.4: However, the assessment
criteria are not an exhaustive list and the council may consider any relevant policy or criteria
within the Unitary Plan if it is within the scope of the matter of control/discretion for the
particular activity.
6677-11 Milford Centre Limited cbarbour@nzrpg.co.nz General Chapter G General provisions G2.2 Activities not provided for
Amend so activities not specifically listed in the Plan are discretionary activities not non-
complying
statements
Amend G2.7.1 and G2.7.2 to acknowledge the range of proposals and therefore the extent to
which it is necessary or relevant to include the comprehensive details required to accompany
applications
6677-13 Milford Centre Limited cbarbour@nzrpg.co.nz Natural Hazards and Flooding Natural Hazards
G2.7.5 Information
requirements
Amend to acknowledge the range of proposals and therefore the extent to which it is
necessary or relevant to include the comprehensive details required to accompany
applications
Amend rule 2.7.3 to acknowledge the range of proposals and therefore the extent to which it
is necessary or relevant to include the comprehensive details required to accompany
applications
6677-15 Milford Centre Limited cbarbour@nzrpg.co.nz Mana Whenua General provisions
assessment
applications
6677-16 Milford Centre Limited cbarbour@nzrpg.co.nz Historic Heritage (Overlay)
Heritage
protocols
Amend [Rule 2.7.8] to acknowledge the range of proposals and therefore the extent to which it
applications
6677-17 Milford Centre Limited cbarbour@nzrpg.co.nz Transport
assessment
applications
6677-18 Milford Centre Limited cbarbour@nzrpg.co.nz Transport Auckland -wide
requirements Delete parking maximums at Milford Centre
6677-19 Milford Centre Limited cbarbour@nzrpg.co.nz Natural Hazards and Flooding Natural Hazards H4.11.1 Activity table
Retain the permitted activity status for new dwellings and habitable floors of non-dwellings on
land identified as being subject to coastal inundation and sea level rises
Centre)
Maps only
Amend the mapping of the key retail frontage and general commercial frontage overlays in
Milford town centre as detailed on page 14/16 of submission
398/1145
Sub#/
6677-21 Milford Centre Limited cbarbour@nzrpg.co.nz Built Environment (Overlays)
Height Control
Amend the additional zone height control in Milford Town Centre to enable differing height
limits (between 32.5m and 48.5m) across the centre. Details on pages 4 and 15/16 of
submission
6677-22 Milford Centre Limited cbarbour@nzrpg.co.nz Zoning North and Islands
Rezone area around Milford Town Centre from Mixed Housing Urban to Terrace Housing and
Apartment Buildings. Refer to page 16/16 of submission for details.
Centre) Business
General objectives and policies Retain the Business zone rules
6678-1 Christiaan Ercolano
11 Wexford Road, Grey Lynn,
Rezone property at 11 Wexford Road, Grey Lynn, from Mixed Housing Suburban to Single
House zone.
6679-1
Thompson Park Holdings
Limited brent@synman.co.nz Zoning Central
Rezone 8 Thompson Park Road, Mt Wellington from Single House to a zone to reflect the
approved resource consent for 107 dwellings
6679-2
Thompson Park Holdings
Limited brent@synman.co.nz Precincts - Central New Precincts Other New Precincts
Add a concept plan for 8 Thompson Park Road, Mt Wellington from the Operative Isthmus
District Plan.
6680-1 Highbury Limited cbarbour@nzrpg.co.nz RPS Urban growth
Retain the enabling quality urban growth provisions, particularly objectives 1-3 and policies 1-
3
6680-2 Highbury Limited cbarbour@nzrpg.co.nz RPS Urban growth
environment Retain Objective 1 and Policies 1-11
6680-3 Highbury Limited cbarbour@nzrpg.co.nz RPS
Transport
B3.1 Commercial and
industrial growth
Retain the enabling economic growth provisions, particularly objectives 1 and 2, and policies
1-3 and 5
6680-4 Highbury Limited cbarbour@nzrpg.co.nz Residential zones Housing affordability
and policies Delete the affordable housing provisions
6680-5 Highbury Limited cbarbour@nzrpg.co.nz
Centre) Business
General objectives and policies Retain objectives and policies, particularly objectives 1-3 and policies 1-5
Centre)
obs & pols Retain objectives and policies, particularly objectives 1-3 and policies 1-6
6680-7 Highbury Limited cbarbour@nzrpg.co.nz General Chapter G General provisions
activities Retain rule infringement provisions
Amend G1.4 to clarify that consent applications under regional and district rules will not be
bundled together
status
Amend to clarify that consent applications under regional and district rules will not be bundled
together
Delete the following under the assessment criteria heading in G1.4: However, the assessment
particular activity.
6680-11 Highbury Limited cbarbour@nzrpg.co.nz General Chapter G General provisions G2.2 Activities not provided for
Amend so activities not specifically listed in the Plan are discretionary activities not non-
complying
statements
Amend G2.7.1 and G2.7.2 to acknowledge the range of proposals and therefore the extent to
which it is necessary or relevant to include the comprehensive details required to accompany
applications
6680-13 Highbury Limited cbarbour@nzrpg.co.nz Natural Hazards and Flooding Natural Hazards
G2.7.5 Information
requirements
applications
Amend rule 2.7.3 to acknowledge the range of proposals and therefore the extent to which it
applications
6680-15 Highbury Limited cbarbour@nzrpg.co.nz Mana Whenua General provisions
assessment
Amend to acknowledge the range and scale of proposals and therefore the range of
comprehensive details required to accompany applications
6680-16 Highbury Limited cbarbour@nzrpg.co.nz Historic Heritage (Overlay)
Heritage
protocols
Amend [Rule 2.7.8] to acknowledge the range of proposals and therefore the extent to which it
applications
6680-17 Highbury Limited cbarbour@nzrpg.co.nz Transport
assessment
applications
6680-18 Highbury Limited cbarbour@nzrpg.co.nz Transport Auckland -wide
requirements Delete parking maximums for the Highbury Mall site
Centre)
Maps only
Amend the mapping of the key retail frontage and general commercial frontage overlays in
Highbury [Birkenhead] town centre as detailed on page 12/13 of submission
399/1145
Sub#/
6680-20 Highbury Limited cbarbour@nzrpg.co.nz Built Environment (Overlays)
Height Control
Amend the additional zone height control to enable a unlimited height limit for the Highbury
Mall site, Birkenhead. Details on page 13 of submission
6680-21 Highbury Limited cbarbour@nzrpg.co.nz Air Quality
Delete the air quality [transport corridor separation] overlay or alternatively remove the air
quality [transport corridor separation] overlay from 50 Birkenhead Ave, Highbury
Centre) Business
General objectives and policies Retain the Business zone rules
6681-1 Mr and Mrs G W Tipling tipling@jgt.co.nz Zoning North and Islands
Rezone northwards to Quintal Road, Omaha (or similar area) from Rural Coastal to Mixed
Rural.
6681-2 Mr and Mrs G W Tipling tipling@jgt.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - Rural zones
area Allow subdivision of 1085 Leigh Road, Omaha, which is 12 ha [Mixed Rural zone].
6682-1
Jane Gifford Soc. Mahurangi
Action Mahurangi River
Restoration Trust Warkworth
Riverbank Enhancement secretary@mahurangi.org.nz RPS Coastal B7 Strategic
Amend PAUP to provide for the Mahurangi River Town Basins, Landings and Navigation Plan
[Note - specific provisions to amend are not provided, but generally relate to dredging around
Warkworth and the Mahurangi River, oyster farming shore depots and public access conflicts
between recreational boats and commercial boats].
6683-1 Karl and Kate Madsen kate@seedcd.co.nz RPS Changes to the RUB North and Waiheke Island
Rezone the south side of Bawden Road, Dairy Flat, particularly 180 Bawden Road from
Countryside Living to Future Urban. Alternatively create a buffer zone on the south side of
Bawden Road to allow a transition in density between Future Urban and Countryside Living
zones
6684-1
Wood and Partners
Consultants Limited stuart.penfold@woods.co.nz Mana Whenua
Whenua
Refine the mapping of the sites and places of value to Mana Whenua. Details on page 4/9 of
submission. Refinements include deleting sites that no longer exist, reducing the size of the
hatched area and regular updating of maps to account for any further investigations
6684-2
Wood and Partners
Consultants Limited stuart.penfold@woods.co.nz Water Stormwater
Delete the overlay in areas where the catchment discharges directly to the tidal environment
and areas where diversion and discharge consents exist
6684-3
Wood and Partners
Consultants Limited stuart.penfold@woods.co.nz General Miscellaneous Consultation and engagement
Engage with the relevant stakeholders regarding the stormwater management rules and TP
2013/035
6684-4
Wood and Partners
H4.14.2 Stormwater
Add the following to the activity table 2.1 as a permitted activity: Impervious areas where the
discharge point of the nearest stormwater network is to the tidal environment (within or
discharging to a SMAF 1 or 2)
6684-5
Wood and Partners
H4.14.2 Stormwater
Add the following to the activity table as a permitted activity: Impervious areas located on
allotments contained within subdivisions where the stormwater reticulation discharges to
wetlands, ponds or other appropriately designed devices
6684-6
Wood and Partners
H4.14.2 Stormwater
Amend wording of the rule regarding zone based impervious area thresholds as follows: All
zones with an Impervious Area Threshold where not otherwise controlled within SMAF 1 or 2
or combined sewer; or where connected to a stormwater network excluding the Hauraki Gulf
Islands).
6684-7
Wood and Partners
Consultants Limited stuart.penfold@woods.co.nz Water
streams & wetland
table Add third column to activity table to differentiate intermittent streams from permanent streams
6684-8
Wood and Partners
Consultants Limited stuart.penfold@woods.co.nz Definitions Existing
Amend the definition of river or stream to account for permanent streams only and remove
reference to 'intermittently flowing body of fresh water'
6684-9
Wood and Partners
Consultants Limited stuart.penfold@woods.co.nz General Chapter G General provisions
statements Amend rule G 2.7.1.26 [specialist report - fire].
6684-10
Wood and Partners
Consultants Limited stuart.penfold@woods.co.nz Mana Whenua General provisions
assessment
Undertake further work to refine where iwi groups have Mana Whenua. Amend the cultural
impact assessment requirements to include this further work. Alternatively delete the cultural
impact assessment requirements
6684-11
Wood and Partners
Consultants Limited stuart.penfold@woods.co.nz Mana Whenua General provisions
assessment
Delete rule 4 [Cultural impact assessments requirements where proposals impact on Mana
Whenua values]
6684-12
Wood and Partners
Consultants Limited stuart.penfold@woods.co.nz Natural Hazards and Flooding Natural Hazards
G2.7.5 Information
requirements
Amend rule 1 as follows: An application for any activity where the subject site is likely to be
subject to natural hazards must be accompanied by a report by a suitably qualified engineer
which:...
6684-13
Wood and Partners
Consultants Limited stuart.penfold@woods.co.nz Transport
assessment
Amend rule 1(1)(a)(iv) as follows: a resource consent application for land use or subdivision
not specifically provided for as a controlled, restricted discretionary or discretionary activity in
the zone applying to the site where the reasons for the Non-Complying activity status relate
primarily to transportation or traffic matters.
6685-1 Christopher J Rollins rollinschris@hotmail.com Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
Add provisions for Private Helipads/Helicopter landing areas in residential areas to be Non-
complying activities.
6686-1
Berechiah Developments
Limited chong@anchorltd.co.nz Zoning North and Islands
Rezone 276 Dairy Flat Highway, Dairy Flat from Mixed Housing Suburban to Mixed Housing
Urban or Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings
400/1145
Sub#/
6686-2
Berechiah Developments
Limited chong@anchorltd.co.nz
SEAs
Land Delete SEA overlay from 276 Dairy Flat Highway, Dairy Flat
6687-1
Westpac Mussels Distributors
Limited daniel.clay@minterellison.co.nz RPS Coastal B7 Strategic
Retain objectives and policies to the extent that they recognise the cultural, social and
economic benefits of aquaculture.
6687-2
Limited daniel.clay@minterellison.co.nz
the CMA
D5.1.14 Background,
Retain objectives and policies to the extent that they recognise the cultural, social and
economic benefits of aquaculture.
6687-3
Limited daniel.clay@minterellison.co.nz RPS Coastal
environment
Amend the objectives and policies to enable the development of aquaculture activities in
appropriate locations, including by ensuring that degraded water quality does not compromise
the future development of aquaculture activities in area where aquaculture is proposed or
viable. See submission for specific amendments [pages 15 to 16/16 of the submission].
6687-4
the CMA
D5.1.14 Background,
Amend the objectives and policies, particularly policies 1 and 2, to clarify and more
appropriately define and describe the circumstances where adopting a precautionary
approach and requiring staged development in respect of aquaculture activities should
apply. See submission for specific amendments [pages 15 to 16/16 of the submission].
6687-5
the CMA
D5.1.14 Background,
Amend the objectives and policies to acknowledge the low visual impact of aquaculture
activities for landward view shafts when the structures are located at a distance from the
shore. See submission for specific amendments [pages 15 to 16/16 of the submission].
6687-6
the CMA
Retain the Activity Table to the extent that it has removed the Prohibited Activity status for
aquaculture activities under the transitional Regional Coastal Plan and as was proposed
under variations to the partially operative Auckland Regional Plan: Coastal.
6687-7
the CMA
Amend the Activity Table to distinguish and provide for aquaculture activities involving
species that are currently farmed in the Auckland region as a Restricted Discretionary Activity
(as opposed to those species which are not currently farmed in Auckland which would be a
Discretionary Activity).
6687-8
the CMA
Amend the Activity Table to enable consented marine farms to change the aquaculture
methods used as a Controlled Activity, whether the species farmed remained the same and
the structures used are the same or similar.
6687-9
the CMA
Amend the activity status of 'Aquaculture activities (new)' from Non-Complying to
Discretionary in the High Natural Character and Outstanding Natural landscape overlay
areas.
6687-10
Special information
requirements
Delete assessment criterion 5.2(1)(g)(i) 'Assessment - Restricted discretionary activities and
development control infringements' which provides that 'consent duration should be limited to
the minimum duration necessary for the functional or operational needs of the activity' [in
relation to aquaculture].
6687-11
Special information
requirements
Delete assessment criterion 5.2(8)(a) 'Assessment - Restricted discretionary activities and
development control infringements' which seeks to limit or minimise the spatial and temporal
extent of structures and activities in the coastal marine area [in relation to aquaculture].
6687-12
Special information
requirements
Delete assessment criterion 5.2(17)(a) 'Assessment - Restricted discretionary activities and
development control infringements' which seeks that structures and buildings should not
adversely affect the natural character, landscape and visual amenity of an area [in relation to
aquaculture].
6687-13
Special information
requirements
Amend assessment criterion 5.2(17)(a) 'Assessment - Restricted discretionary activities and
development control infringements' to read as follows: structures and buildings should not
significantly adversely affect the natural character, landscape and visual amenity... [in relation
to aquaculture].
6687-14
Limited daniel.clay@minterellison.co.nz RPS
coastal environment
Amend objectives and policies to provide an appropriate balance between preservation or
protection of natural character and appropriate use and development of areas and resources
influenced by such environments and reflect in the PAUP that it is only "inappropriate" use
and development from which natural features are required to be protected. The provisions
should allow consideration of all aspects of environmental management, including avoiding,
remedying, mitigating, and minimising adverse effects in managing the effects. See
submission for specific amendments [pages 10 to 12/16 of the submission].
401/1145
Sub#/
6687-15
features
Amend objectives and policies to provide an appropriate balance between preservation or
protection of outstanding natural landscapes and appropriate use and development of areas
and resources influenced by such environments and reflect in the PAUP that it is only
"inappropriate" use and development from which natural features are required to be protected.
The provisions should allow consideration of all aspects of environmental management,
including avoiding, remedying, mitigating, and minimising adverse effects in managing the
effects. See submission for specific amendments [pages 13 to 14/16 of the submission].
6687-16
coastal environment
Amend objectives and policies to clearly identify which objectives and policies apply to
activities outside the identified natural character areas, particularly Policy 5. Where objectives
and policies expressly apply to activities outside the identified natural character area, they
should only apply to activities 'immediately adjoining' the identified area. See submission for
specific amendments [pages 10 to 12/16 of the submission].
6687-17
features
Amend objectives and policies to clearly identify which objectives and policies apply to
activities outside the identified landscape areas. Where objectives and policies expressly
apply to activities outside the identified natural character area, they should only apply to
activities 'immediately adjoining' the identified area. See submission for specific amendments
[pages 13 to 14/16 of the submission].
6687-18
coastal environment
Amend the objectives and policies which promote the enhancement of natural character to
take into account and reflect the varying levels of existing natural character and the limitations
on the private sector's ability to enhance natural character in the context of resource consent
applications for private proposals. See submission for specific amendments [pages 10 to
6687-19
Outstanding Natural
Rules
Character - Coastal
Delete or significantly reduce the extent of the overlay in relation to IDs 62 (Hunua Ranges)
and 63 (Orere Point).
6687-20
Outstanding Natural
Rules
Outstanding Natural
Landscapes
Delete or significantly reduce the extent of the overlay in relation to IDs 162 (Tapapakanga
Regional Park) and 163 (Matingarahi Point).
6687-21
features
Amend to clarify that parts of the overlay that extend into the coastal marine area are not
'outstanding natural landscapes' in their own right but are instead a buffer to provide an
additional level of recognition of the land-based landscape.
6687-22
coastal environment
Amend to clarify that parts of the overlay that extend into the coastal marine area are not 'high
natural character areas' in their own right but are instead a buffer to provide an additional level
of recognition of the land-based landscape.
6687-23
Limited daniel.clay@minterellison.co.nz Mana Whenua General provisions
assessment
Delete G2.7.4 Cultural Impact Assessment as part of a consent application or amend so that if
they are required, they should be only required where adverse effects on iwi interests are
more than minor.
6687-24
assessment
Amend to provide a clear process for establishing which iwi group or groups should be
involved in preparing any Cultural Impact Assessments for different parts of Auckland and
provide guidance on how Council decision-makers will 'balance' conflicting or cumulative
views where multiple Cultural Impact Assessments are anticipated.
6687-25
assessment
Delete rule 2.7.4(10) Cultural Impact Assessment which provides that where a Cultural Impact
Assessment is not provided, this will be considered when decisions under section 88. 92, 95A
and 95B of the RMA are made.
6688-1 WFH Properties Limited stuart.penfold@woods.co.nz Zoning North and Islands
Rezone 177 Millwater Parkway, Millwater to extend the Neighbourhood Centre zoning to the
northern boundary with Galbraith Greens
6688-2 WFH Properties Limited stuart.penfold@woods.co.nz Trees
Trees
Notable Trees Delete notable tree ID 2518 from 47 Ridgedale Road, Millwater
6688-3 WFH Properties Limited stuart.penfold@woods.co.nz Precincts - North Silverdale North
Amend the precinct rules to better reflect the rules in the operative district plan. Delete the
staging requirements [rule K5.44.5.6]
Delete the physical limitations area in precinct plan 1. Delete reference to buildings and works
in the physical limitations area from the activity table [K5.44.9 'Precinct plans' and K5.44.1
'Activity table'].
Amend rule K5.44.4.2(1)(c) [yards] as follows: '(c) 36 m from rear yard, or for rear sites, 3m
from one rear yard and 1m for any other rear yard.'
Amend rule K5.44.4.6.3(1) to reduce some requirements as detailed on page 5 of submission
[rear yards and open space rule].
402/1145
Sub#/
Amend rule K5.44.3.4(2) [activities in sub precinct B] as follows: '2. a. The number of
dwellings on a site must not exceed the limits specified belowfor all precinct development
areas except precinct development area 2:b. For precinct development area 2, Distribution of
densities shall be guided by urban design principles and the capacity of infrastructure to
accept higher overall density within the Precinct.'
Extend sub-precinct D to the northern boundary (with Galbraith Greens) of 177 Millwater
Parkway, Silverdale North
6689-1 Blind Citizens New Zealand mary@lansink.co.nz Residential zones Residential
General Require Lifemark certification for all homes across Auckland.
6689-2 Blind Citizens New Zealand mary@lansink.co.nz General Cross plan matters Require all multi dwelling, multi level buildings to have lifts.
6690-1 Erin Pedersen
20 Bernie Edwards Place, Botany
Downs, Auckland 2010 Mana Whenua
Whenua
and policies
Suspend the 3600 new sites of significance to Mana Whenua until a comprehensive and
independent review is undertaken to determine whether they are of national significance.
Downs, Auckland 2010 RPS Mana Whenua B5 Strategic
Establish a government appointed independent review authority to clarify that the definition of
"significant" should only cover areas that are nationally unique and worthy of special
protection by a council.
Downs, Auckland 2010 Mana Whenua
Whenua
and policies
Provide full disclosure to property owners where their site is covered by a site of significance
to Mana Whenua, and include this information on a Land Information Memorandum.
6691-1 Ivan W D Dunn ivan_dunn1519@hotmail.com Mana Whenua General provisions
6692-1 Ponsonby Cruising Club info@pcc.org.nz Zoning Central
Rezone any parts of the coastal marine area that have been zoned City Centre, specifically
where they extend beyond any current reclaimed land and into the coastal marine area in the
vicinity of the Viaduct Harbour, Wynyard Quarter and the Ferry Terminal area, to a zone that
recognises the coastal marine area.
6692-2 Ponsonby Cruising Club info@pcc.org.nz City Centre Zone
obs & pols
Reject the City Centre zone provisions applying to the area encompassed by Westhaven
Drive to the south, Beaumonth St and Hamer St to the east and the Westhaven Drive
breakwater to the north and incorporating Gurran St and its associated reserves.
6692-3 Ponsonby Cruising Club info@pcc.org.nz City Centre Zone
obs & pols Reject the City Centre zone provisions applying to any coastal marine areas.
6692-4 Ponsonby Cruising Club info@pcc.org.nz
the CMA Marina zone
objectives and policies Retain the zone.
Rezone the Westhaven area (the area encompassed by Westhaven Drive to the south,
Beaumonth St and Hamer St to the east and the Westhaven Drive breakwater to the north
and incorporating Curran St and its associated reserves) from City Centre to a new zone
specific to the Westhaven area. The new zone should provide for the character of
Westhaven, including public access to the coastal marine area, coastal and water related
recreational activities and supporting the goal of Westhaven being an important marine hub.
See submission for further details [page 2/7 of the submission].
Rezone the Westhaven area from City Centre to Marina or Public Open Space - Sport and
Active Recreation.
6693-1 Mana Taiapa
31B Woodside Place, Massey,
Rezone the land at Herdman Street, Daventry Street and Waterbank Crescent, Waterview,
from Mixed Housing Urban to Mixed Housing Suburban zone to achieve maximum height of 2
storeys.
6694-1 Hans de Leeuw hansdel@xtra.co.nz Residential zones Residential Activity Table
Amend activity table to require 'boarding house' activities to be a Non-complying activity in the
Single House and Mixed Suburban zones.
6694-2 Hans de Leeuw hansdel@xtra.co.nz Residential zones Residential
policies
Recognise that the Terraced Housing and Apartment Building and Town Centre zones are
more appropriate locations for boarding houses.
6695-1 Julia and Jennifer McGreal jen.mcgreal@clear.net.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - Rural zones
area
Retain current bush planting subdivision method when creating new sites [refers to the
operative Rodney District Plan].
6696-1 Jo Noonan jo.gazza@xtra.co.nz Special Character
residential
Add new special character area to protect St Heliers village rather than precinct. The special
character area would include provisions restricting development to a a small scale, limiting
maximum height to 9m, setting out detailed design guidelines, maintaining and enhancing
small businesses, encouraging adaption and reuse of buildings and limiting the number of
bars and restaurants.
6696-2 Jo Noonan jo.gazza@xtra.co.nz Residential zones Residential
General
Amend the rules so that the maximum residential building height on Goldie Street and
Lombard Street, St Heliers is 9m.
6696-3 Jo Noonan jo.gazza@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central
Retain the Mixed Housing House zone from Cliff Road to Clarendon Road and along the
Kohimarama waterfront area.
6696-4 Jo Noonan jo.gazza@xtra.co.nz Residential zones Residential
policies Retain the Mixed Housing Suburban and Mixed Housing Urban zones.
6696-5 Jo Noonan jo.gazza@xtra.co.nz Precincts - Central New Precincts Other New Precincts Add the Tamaki Drive Masterplan into the PAUP.
403/1145
Sub#/
6696-6 Jo Noonan jo.gazza@xtra.co.nz General Miscellaneous
Operational/
Projects/Acquisition Ensure Tamaki Drive continues to serve travel needs of local residents.
6696-7 Jo Noonan jo.gazza@xtra.co.nz Precincts - Central New Precincts Other New Precincts
Provide assessment criteria which assess the potential adverse effects on development along
Tamaki Drive on the harbour and Hauraki Gulf.
6697-1 Simon Swasbrook
England, Auckland 1072 Zoning Central
Delete Mixed Housing [Urban] and Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings in Pt England,
particularly in the area of Erima Street and Riverside Ave
General
Amend the rules to require a resource consent in the Terrace Housing and Apartment
Buildings and Mixed Housing [Urban] zone to assess shading and privacy issues.
England, Auckland 1072 General Chapter G General provisions
refer to Designations theme) Improve the consent process to reduce cost and time taken
policies Ensure buildings are aesthetically pleasing
England, Auckland 1072
shafts survey coordinates Protect volcanic viewshafts in Pt England
England, Auckland 1072 Transport Auckland -wide
requirements Amend parking minimum and maximum controls so they are requirements not guidelines
England, Auckland 1072 RPS
Transport
and energy
Clarify how the development, operation and upgrading of infrastructure will be enforced on
developers
England, Auckland 1072 General Miscellaneous Other Provide for safer communities
England, Auckland 1072 General Miscellaneous Other Focus growth into other centres in New Zealand outside of Auckland
England, Auckland 1072 RPS Urban growth
quality compact urban form Add business parks to focus growth and population away from one focal point of the city
England, Auckland 1072 General Miscellaneous Other
Remove state housing from areas with good transport links and close proximity, such as Glen
Innes
6698-1 Damon Brown
23 Riversdale Road, Avondale,
Rezone the land at Herdman Street, Daventry Street and Waterbank Crescent, Waterview,
from Mixed Housing Urban to Mixed Housing Suburban zone to achieve maximum height of 2
storeys.
6699-1
Yachting New Zealand
Incorporated jeremy@brabant.co.nz
the CMA Discharges
Amend Objective 1 to read as follows: The values of the CMA, and activities that rely on high
water quality, are protected from the adverse effects from the discharge of sewage from
vessels, while providing for the health and safety of vessels and their occupants.
6699-2
the CMA Discharges
Amend Policy 1 to read as follows: Avoid the discharge of sewage from vessels within areas
that have been identified as inappropriate due to the proximity to shore, marine farms, marine
reserves, or shallow water depth, while providing for the health and safety of vessels and their
occupants.
6699-3
controls
Amend Rule 2 [2.15 Discharges] to lessen the offshore distance required for sewage
discharges from the 2km to 500m, to specify that discharge is not permitted in Waitemata
Harbour, Mahurangi Harbour, Tamaki Estuary and Port Fitzroy unless during extreme weather
conditions, as specified, and to amend the criteria of what is considered an extreme weather
event. See submission for specific amendments [page 3/4 of the submission].
6700-1 Deutsch Family Trust deanne@mhg.co.nz Definitions Existing Amend the definition of height to include average ground level
6700-2 Deutsch Family Trust deanne@mhg.co.nz General Cross plan matters Delete the maximum storey control in all zones
6700-3 Deutsch Family Trust deanne@mhg.co.nz
Centre) Business
Park zones Delete the floor to floor/ ceiling height controls
6700-4 Deutsch Family Trust deanne@mhg.co.nz Definitions New
Add the following definition of 'gross site area': Means the total area of a site including any
entrance strip. Add the diagram on page 5/7 of the submission to the definition
6700-5 Deutsch Family Trust deanne@mhg.co.nz Historic Heritage (Overlay)
Heritage
Places Remove the historic heritage area overlay from 364-368 Onehunga Mall, Onehunga
6700-6 Deutsch Family Trust deanne@mhg.co.nz General Chapter G General provisions
statements Delete design statement requirements
6700-7 Deutsch Family Trust deanne@mhg.co.nz Mana Whenua General provisions
assessment
Amend the circumstances where cultural impact assessments and iwi engagement are
required
6700-8 Deutsch Family Trust deanne@mhg.co.nz Sustainable Development C7.7/H6.4 Sustainable design
Delete requirement to achieve a 4 Green Star rating or certification under the Living Building
Challenge
6700-9 Deutsch Family Trust deanne@mhg.co.nz Residential zones Housing affordability H6.6 Rules Delete the affordable housing requirements
404/1145
Sub#/
6700-10 Deutsch Family Trust deanne@mhg.co.nz
Centre) Business
Special information
requirements
is provided over public space
6701-1 Lucy Addision lucy@intuitivesystems.co.nz Residential zones Residential
policies Reject modern high rise dwellings in suburbs
6701-2 Lucy Addision lucy@intuitivesystems.co.nz Mana Whenua General provisions
6701-3 Lucy Addision lucy@intuitivesystems.co.nz General C7.2/H6.1 Lighting Delete floodlight controls for sports clubs adjoining residential areas [rule 1(2)]
6701-4 Lucy Addision lucy@intuitivesystems.co.nz Public Open Space Zones Public Open Space I2.1 Activity table Amend activity table to restrict buildings and structures in public open spaces
6701-5 Lucy Addision lucy@intuitivesystems.co.nz Historic Heritage (Overlay)
policies Retain historic heritage [specific relief not identified].
6701-6 Lucy Addision lucy@intuitivesystems.co.nz General Chapter G General provisions G2.4 Notification Require greater consultation with local communities around development
6701-7 Lucy Addision lucy@intuitivesystems.co.nz RPS Coastal
environment Reject high rise development near beaches
6702-1 Neil and Rachael Russ nruss@xtra.co.nz
Outstanding Natural
Rules
Outstanding Natural
Landscapes Remove the Outstanding Natural Landscape overlay from 31 Mount St John Ave, Epsom
6702-2 Neil and Rachael Russ nruss@xtra.co.nz Special Character
& C J3.3.1-7 Rules Delete the second part of the Isthmus C overlay height control [rule 4.1(1)(b)]
6703-1 Judy and Hsiu-Li C Hung diana@opc.net.nz Zoning North and Islands
Rezone 39 Fairview Ave, Albany from Single House and Mixed Housing Suburban to Terrace
6703-2 Judy and Hsiu-Li C Hung diana@opc.net.nz Residential zones Residential
General
Amend the PAUP to enable the development of 39 Fairview Avenue, Albany as sought
through resource consent LT-2135597.
6704-1
The Royal New Zealand Yacht
Squadron jgoddard@rnzys.org.nz Precincts - City Centre Westhaven K3.13 Precinct Rules Retain the defined area of the precinct as shown in the Precinct Plan.
6704-2
Squadron jgoddard@rnzys.org.nz Precincts - City Centre Westhaven
Obejctives & Policies
Amend the Description to clearly articulate the primary function of the precinct, recreational
boating, as well as other supporting activities such as parking areas and small scale marine
related retail, service industries and commercial services. See submission for specific
amendments [pages 2 and 3/5 of the submission].
6704-3
Amend Objective 1 to read as follows: A world-class marina for recreational boating and water
sport activities which are supported by a limited range of ancillary activities that contribute to
the amenity of the waterfront.
6704-4
Amend Objective 3 to read as follows: The efficient use and development of Westhaven
marina for recreational boating activities in a manner which avoids, remedies or mitigates
adverse effects on the coastal environment.
6704-5
Obejctives & Policies Delete Objective 4.
6704-6
Amend Policy 2 to read as follows: Enable limited use of the precinct for non-marina based
activities provided the current and future function and growth of the marina for recreational
boating activities and future development of the associated boating club premises is not
compromised.
6704-7
Delete and replace Policy 4 with the following: Allow for enhanced use of the precinct for
pedestrian and cycling to and along the waterfront where this does not compromise the safe
and efficient operation of the marina.
6704-8
Obejctives & Policies Delete Policy 5.
6704-9
Squadron jgoddard@rnzys.org.nz Precincts - City Centre Westhaven K3.13 Precinct Rules
Delete the first point of the preamble to the Activity Table and replace with: The following table
specifies the activity status of activities in the Westhaven precinct. Any activity not specifically
listed in this table is a non-complying activity in accordance with rule 2.2 of Section 2, Chapter
G.
6704-10
Amend the activity status of 'Offices, retail, commercial services and entertainment facilities
not specified as a permitted activity or non-complying activity' to Non-Complying in both the
CMA and on land.
6704-11
Amend the activity within the Activity Table to read as follows: Community facilities, education
facilities and healthcare services not specified as a permitted or discretionary activity,
hospitals and major recreation facilities. Amend the activity status to Non-complying for both
the CMA and on land.
6704-12
Amend the activity within the Activity Table to read as follows: Industrial activities not specified
as a permitted, restricted discretionary or discretionary activity. Amend the activity status to
Non-complying for both the CMA and on land.
405/1145
Sub#/
6704-13
Replace Rule 2.4(1) 'Parking' to read as follows: Parking for the marina activity must be
provided at a rate of 0.8 for every marina berth. Parking for other activities within the precinct
shall be in accordance with the requirements of Table 4, clause 3.2 of the Transport section of
Chapter H, District Wide Rules.
6705-1 John J Whittingham john.whittingham@gmail.com Residential zones Residential
policies Reject modern high rise dwellings in suburbs
6705-2 John J Whittingham john.whittingham@gmail.com Mana Whenua General provisions
6705-3 John J Whittingham john.whittingham@gmail.com General C7.2/H6.1 Lighting Delete floodlight controls for sports clubs adjoining residential areas [rule 1(2)]
6705-4 John J Whittingham john.whittingham@gmail.com Public Open Space Zones Public Open Space I2.1 Activity table Amend activity table to restrict buildings and structures in public open spaces
6705-5 John J Whittingham john.whittingham@gmail.com Historic Heritage (Overlay)
policies Retain historic heritage [specific relief not identified].
6705-6 John J Whittingham john.whittingham@gmail.com General Chapter G General provisions G2.4 Notification Require greater consultation with local communities around development
6705-7 John J Whittingham john.whittingham@gmail.com RPS Coastal
environment Reject high rise development near beaches
6706-1 John and Jacqueline Newick jnewick@gmail.com General Miscellaneous Other Adopt the relief sought by the Strategic Property Advocacy Network
6706-2 John and Jacqueline Newick jnewick@gmail.com Precincts - West
Area
objectives and policies Enable more economic development opportunities in the Waitakere Ranges Heritage Area
6706-3 John and Jacqueline Newick jnewick@gmail.com
SEAs
Land Remove SEA overlay from 70 O'Neills Rd, Swanson
6706-4 John and Jacqueline Newick jnewick@gmail.com Precincts - West
Enable subdivision of 70 O'Neills Rd, Swanson into 2 additional lots as a discretionary
activity. Enable subdivision beyond this as a non-complying activity
6706-5 John and Jacqueline Newick jnewick@gmail.com
control
and policies Delete the pre-1944 building demolition control overlay
6706-6 John and Jacqueline Newick jnewick@gmail.com General Miscellaneous Consultation and engagement
Withdraw PAUP and re-notify once further consultation has been undertaken in Waitakere
Ranges Heritage area
6707-1
Bong Joon Lee and Myung
Sook Choi bjlee61@hanmail.net Zoning North and Islands Retain Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings zone at 92 Anzac St, Takapuna.
6707-2
Sook Choi bjlee61@hanmail.net Precincts - North Takapuna 2 Retain precinct at 92 Anzac St, Takapuna.
6707-3
Sook Choi bjlee61@hanmail.net General Chapter G General provisions
Delete 1.4 'Applying for a resource consent' provisions which allow Council to consider
provisions beyond those specifically listed as assessment criteria. (Thirdparagraph under the
heading 'Assessment criteria').
6707-4
Sook Choi bjlee61@hanmail.net Mana Whenua General provisions
assessment Delete 2.7.4 'Cultural Impact Assessments'.
6707-5
Sook Choi bjlee61@hanmail.net
Centre) Business
Park zones Delete storey component of 4.2 'Building height'.
6707-6
Sook Choi bjlee61@hanmail.net General Chapter G General provisions
statements
Delete requirements for Design Statements to be separate sections within an Assessment of
Environmental Effects and reference to the Auckland Design Manual 5.1(e).
6707-7
Sook Choi bjlee61@hanmail.net Sustainable Development C7.7/H6.4 Sustainable design
Delete 2.1 'Dwellings' and 2.2 'Offices' requirements to incorporate sustainable development -
all zones 5.1(d).
6707-8
Sook Choi bjlee61@hanmail.net Residential zones Housing affordability H6.6 Rules
Delete 6.1 Development control requirements to incorporate affordable housing within a
development of 15 or more dwellings.
6708-1 Paul van Cingel paulvancingel@gmail.com RPS Changes to the RUB South
Remove the area from Ranfurly Road to the Papakura stream (bounded by Porchester Road
to the west and Mill Road to the east) from the RUB. Rezone this area from Future Urban to
Countryside Living or Mixed Rural. Restricted subdivision and development to self serviced
lots
6708-2 Paul van Cingel paulvancingel@gmail.com RPS Changes to the RUB South
Rezone the area between Ranfurly and Alfriston Road (bounded by Mill Road to the east and
Stratford Road roundabout) from Future Urban to Mixed Rural. Enable subdivision in this area
down to 3000m
2
to 5000m
2
for self serviced lots
6709-1
Kumeu-Huapai Residents and
Incorporated petesinton@townplanner.co.nz
control
Amend the rules to require resource consent for all works to buildings constructed prior to
1944 as a Restricted Discretionary Activity, requiring the processing planner to a) consult
with the Local Board; b) research, contact and consider descendants of the family responsible
for the original building design and construction; and c) consult with the
Local Community Association.
6709-2
Incorporated petesinton@townplanner.co.nz General Miscellaneous
Operational/
Record against the objectives and policies, and on the property file, the requirement for
consultation to occur prior to development of the property comprised in CT NA
5B1865 pursuant to the Memorandum of Understanding with Maddren Property Limited.
406/1145
Sub#/
6709-3
Incorporated petesinton@townplanner.co.nz Zoning North and Islands
Rezone the land owned by the Kumeu Agricultural and Horticultural Society on Waitakere
Road and Access Road, Kumeu, to Special Purpose - Major Recreational Facility.
6709-4
Rezone the land "known as DSIR land" on Waitakere Road, Kumeu, to "Public Open Space
and Active Recreation" zone. [Submission refers to attached plan but none attached.]
6709-5
Rezone the Kumeu Cemetery located at Farrand Road and Waitakere Road to Special
Purpose - Cemetery zone.
6709-6
Incorporated petesinton@townplanner.co.nz Precincts - North New Precincts All other New Precincts
Provide for a "Wine District" in the zoning maps and precinct area for the [Kumeu-Huapai]
District, with associated objectives and policies.
6709-7
managed fill
Impose regulations for cleanfill sites to be monitored by independent supervising engineers or
equivalent qualified [personnel].
6709-8
managed fill
Require large scale [cleanfill] sites to be given planning preference over small sites, and that
large sites are specifically zoned or designated and independently monitored by Council or an
appointee. [C5.5 Background, objectives and policies]
6709-9
managed fill
Require small scale cleanfill sites to obtain resource consent as a "limited
discretionary" activity to ensure neighbours' consent is obtained,to require independent
engineering analysis prior to approval, and to be subject to mandatory independent monitoring
of deposited material. [H4.4 Auckland-wide rules]
6709-10
Incorporated petesinton@townplanner.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - Rural zones
area
Provide for subdivision in the Rural Production and Mixed Rural zones to create Wetland and
Bush Blocks as a permitted activity where certain criteria are met. Refer to details in
submission at page 9/19 of volume 1.
6709-11
Incorporated petesinton@townplanner.co.nz RPS Changes to the RUB West
Rezone the two [unspecified] areas [shown on urban Grid 18] on Oraha Road, Old North
Road and Access Road, Kumeu, [from Countryside Living] to Large Lot Residential zone.
Refer to details in submission at page 11/19 of volume 1.
6709-12
Incorporated petesinton@townplanner.co.nz RPS Changes to the RUB West
Require Council to complete a structure plan for the Kumeu-Huapai area prior to confirming
the extent of the Future Urban zone as shown on Urban Grid Sheet 18, subject to stipulations
regarding public notification, specified matters of consideration and timing of development.
Refer to details in submission at page 18/19 of volume 1.
6710-1 The Tapora Trust graeme@wwsurveyors.co.nz Residential zones Residential Land use controls
Amend the density control [rule 3.1] in the Rural and Coastal Settlement zone to one dwelling
per 1500m2
6711-1 Michael Hart globalmh9@gmail.com RPS Mana Whenua B5 Strategic
Rejects those provisions requiring Mana Whenua involvement in the resource consent
process.
6712-1 Andrea Woodford awoodford@clear.net.nz RPS Changes to the RUB South
Remove the area from Ranfurly Road to the Papakura stream (bounded by Porchester Road
to the west and Mill Road to the east) from the RUB. Rezone this area from Future Urban to
Countryside Living or Mixed Rural. Restricted subdivision and development to self serviced
lots
6712-2 Andrea Woodford awoodford@clear.net.nz RPS Changes to the RUB South
Rezone the area between Ranfurly and Alfriston Road (bounded by Mill Road to the east and
Stratford Road roundabout) from Future Urban to Mixed Rural. Enable subdivision in this area
down to 3000m
2
to 5000m
2
for self serviced lots
6713-1 Lloyd Barton lloydbarton@clear.net.nz Definitions New
Include a definition of Minor Household Unit as a secondary residential unit not exceeding
65m
2
gross floor area, in addition to the main dwelling unit on the site.
6713-2 Lloyd Barton lloydbarton@clear.net.nz Rural Zones General I13.1 Activity table
Amend Activity Table 1 to include Minor Household Units [in the Rural Production zone] as a
permitted activity on sites exceeding 1 ha.
6713-3 Lloyd Barton lloydbarton@clear.net.nz Rural Zones General I13.1 Activity table
Amend Activity Table 1 to include Minor Household Units as a controlled activity on sites
below 1 ha in the Rural Production zone.
6713-4 Lloyd Barton lloydbarton@clear.net.nz Rural Zones General I13.3 Development controls
Amend Development controls to include the following development control for Minor
Household Units [in the Rural Production zone] - maximum separation from main dwelling
10m.
6713-5 Lloyd Barton lloydbarton@clear.net.nz Rural Zones General
Spec. info. requirements
Insert assessment criteria for Minor Household Units as a controlled activity on sites less than
1 ha in the Rural Production zone relating to: building siting, design and external appearance,
access, servicing, proximity to principal household unit, visual effects and landscape.
6714-1 Delegat's Wine Estate Limited petesinton@townplanner.co.nz Definitions New Add definition of "Winery".
6714-2 Delegat's Wine Estate Limited petesinton@townplanner.co.nz Rural Zones General I13.1 Activity table
Amend Activity Table to include "Winery" in the Mixed Rural and "Rural and Countryside"
Living zones.
6714-3 Delegat's Wine Estate Limited petesinton@townplanner.co.nz Zoning North and Islands Rezone the land at 172-230 Hepburn Road, Henderson, to Light Industrial zone.
407/1145
Sub#/
6715-1 Frank P Williams frankandamy@xtra.co.nz RPS Changes to the RUB South
Amend the RUB to extend out to the intersection of Mill Road and Ranfurly Road, Alfriston as
detailed in map in page 5/5 of the submission. Rezone this land to be included within the
RUB, particularly 116 Ranfurly Road, Alfriston from Countryside Living to Future Urban
6715-2 Frank P Williams frankandamy@xtra.co.nz RPS Urban growth
Undertake a Council led plan change to enable urban development for 116 Ranfurly Road,
Alfriston and surrounding area as soon as the PAUP is operative
6715-3 Frank P Williams frankandamy@xtra.co.nz RPS
Retain provisions that promote the integration of land use and transport, including
development along key transport corridors
6716-1 Price Properties Limited petesinton@townplanner.co.nz Definitions New Add a definition of "Apiaries and Beekeeping".
6716-2 Price Properties Limited petesinton@townplanner.co.nz Rural Zones General I13.1 Activity table
Amend Activity table to provide for Bee-keeping in the Mixed Rural and Rural Production
zones as a permitted activity, or as a restricted discretionary activity where the hives are
within 200m from a countryside Living zone or urban zone.
6716-3 Price Properties Limited petesinton@townplanner.co.nz Definitions New Add definition of "Wineries".
6717-1 Logan R Campbell
c/- Buckton Consulting Surveyors
Limited, Attn: R T O Flaherty, PO
Box 107, Warkworth, Auckland 0941 Zoning North and Islands
Rezone part of 485 Green Road, Matakana from Mixed Rural to Countryside Living. Refer to
map on page 4/4 for rezoning location.
6717-2 Logan R Campbell
Limited, Attn: R T O Flaherty, PO
Box 107, Warkworth, Auckland 0941 Subdivision Auckland-wide - Rural zones
area Reduce the minimum site size for the Countryside Living zone in Matakana from 2ha to 1ha
6718-1 Beauglen Farms Limited lane59@xtra.co.nz RPS Changes to the RUB South
Rezone Twilight Road, Clevedon between the village and the foothills of the Brookby Hills
from Countryside Living and Mixed Rural to Single House
6719-1 Edward L Noton cobalt4@xtra.co.nz Precincts - North Bayswater K5.6 Precinct rules Retain these rules
6719-2 Edward L Noton cobalt4@xtra.co.nz Zoning North and Islands Rezone 11 Riverland Rd, Kumeu from Rural Production to Countryside Living (1ha blocks)
6720-1 Stephen Morgan Family Trust grmorgan@xtra.co.nz
control
Building demolition control J.3.6 Rules and mapping Remove the pre 1944 building demolition control from 21 Cameron Road, Onehunga.
6721-1 Richard O'Flaherty r.oflaherty@buckton.co.nz Rural Zones General I13.3 Development controls Delete landscaping requirements [rule 3.4] in the Countryside Living zone
6722-1 Catherine M Noton cobalt5@xtra.co.nz Zoning North and Islands
Rezone land at 115 Riverhead Road, Kumeu, from Rural Production to Countryside Living
zone.
6722-2 Catherine M Noton cobalt5@xtra.co.nz Zoning North and Islands
Rezone land at 111 Riverhead Road, Kumeu, from Rural Production to Countryside Living
zone.
6723-1 S Houghton rickybobbynz@gmail.com RPS Mana Whenua B5 Strategic Reject concept of iwi co-governance.
6723-2 S Houghton rickybobbynz@gmail.com RPS Mana Whenua B5 Strategic
Retain status quo until all subject ratepayers are fully consulted [inferred to mean reject Sites
and Place of Value/Significance to Mana Whenua].
6724-1 Aqua Technics Pools Limited waimag08@yahoo.com Water Stormwater
H4.14.2 Stormwater
Amend to provide that natural flow areas do not require resource consent for additional 25m
2
impermeable cover.
6724-2 Aqua Technics Pools Limited waimag08@yahoo.com Definitions Existing Amend definition of impermeable cover to exclude swimming pools and permeable paving.
6725-1 Richard and Natalie O'Flaherty
Limited, PO Box 107, Warkworth,
area
Reduce the minimum site size for the Countryside Living zone in Matakana-Warkworth from
2ha to 1ha
area Add the Matakana-Warkworth Countryside Living zone to the receiver site areas
Auckland 0941 Rural Zones General I13.2 Land use controls Provide for minor household units in rural zones, including the Countryside Living zone
6726-1 Alan W Emmerson emmo66@xtra.co.nz RPS Urban growth
quality compact urban form Retain environmentally friendly compact city values.
6726-2 Alan W Emmerson emmo66@xtra.co.nz RPS Climate change Ensure the PAUP is aware of and acts on the threat of global warming.
6726-3 Alan W Emmerson emmo66@xtra.co.nz RPS
character and natural heritage B4.3.4 Biodiversity Provide strong protection for the North Shore's existing green spaces in perpetuity.
6726-4 Alan W Emmerson emmo66@xtra.co.nz
SEAs
Land Retain concept of Special Ecological Areas, particularly 145 Wright Road, Albany.
Request Council purchase the largest piece of bush remaining in Browns Bay, (Northcross
Reserve and adjacent bush area) and rezone it as an SEA.
6726-6 Alan W Emmerson emmo66@xtra.co.nz General Miscellaneous
Operational/
Projects/Acquisition Remove invasive pest plants and trees from all North Shore bush reserves.
SEAs
and policies
Retain the inclusion of the three lists of pest plants into the PAUP including the RPMS, NPPA
and DOC pest plant lists.
408/1145
Sub#/
Provide strong tree protection and require property development to be sensitive to trees and
build around significant native trees.
6726-9 Alan W Emmerson emmo66@xtra.co.nz General Miscellaneous Other Support the North-West Wildlink as an overarching concept.
6726-10 Alan W Emmerson emmo66@xtra.co.nz RPS Natural resources
B6.3 Freshwater and
Geothermal Water Protect waterways, the planting of stream banks and clean water.
Operational/
Projects/Acquisition Support the proposed inner city rail link.
Operational/
Projects/Acquisition Support a second Waitemata Harbour crossing.
SEAs
Land
Add an SEA to the largest piece of bush remaining in Browns Bay, (Northcross Reserve and
adjacent bush area).
6727-1 Janelle Gairdner davejanelle@xtra.co.nz Residential zones Residential
Amend rule 6.3 Height in relation to boundary, for contiguous areas of Single House zone
which are covered by the pre-1944 Building demolition control overlay, so that the control
results in built form outcomes that are sympathetic to the current building stock.
6728-1 Ivan A Curwood novan@clear.net.nz RPS Changes to the RUB North and Waiheke Island Rezone 3 Mahurangi East Rd, Sandspit from Rural Production to [Single House]
6729-1 Mona Townson
3 Point Street, RD2, Warkworth,
assessment Delete the requirement to consult with iwi as part of any consenting process
6730-1
Orua Bay and Wattle Bay
Residents and Ratepayers
Association roger@fpp.co.nz Mana Whenua
Whenua
whenua Delete Sites and Places of Significance to Mana Whenua from the Awhitu Peninsula.
6730-2
Orua Bay and Wattle Bay
Residents and Ratepayers
Association roger@fpp.co.nz Mana Whenua
Whenua
of value to Mana Whenua Delete Sites and Places of Value to Mana Whenua from the Awhitu Peninsula.
6731-1 Blair Headford blair.hht@xtra.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - general
and policies Delete all rural subdivision provisions
6731-2 Blair Headford blair.hht@xtra.co.nz Zoning North and Islands
Rezone the rural areas north of Auckland to reflect their production limitations compared with
rural land south of Auckland
6731-3 Blair Headford blair.hht@xtra.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - Rural zones
area
Enable bush and wetland protection, land rehabilitation and enhancement planting in
exchange for subdivision as in the operative Rodney district plan
area
Amend transferable site subdivision rules to apply to land only with an LUC class between 1
and 3. Revise these rules to be more enabling of subdivision
area
Delete the 10% threshold, only once and restrictions to ownership of properties in relation to
the boundary adjustment and boundary relocation rules
area Delete the prohibited activity status that applies to rural subdivision
6732-1
Joanna A Masfen and 777
Investments Limited and
Masfen Holdings Limited michael@campbellbrown.co.nz Built Environment (Overlays)
Height Control
Increase the maximum height from 12.5m to 20.5m for the Parnell Town Centre zone,
particularly 203-207, 209-215 and 235 Parnell Road, Parnell.
6732-2
Masfen Holdings Limited michael@campbellbrown.co.nz
Centre) Business
Park zones Delete rule 4.8 Minimum floor to floor/ceiling height.
6732-3
Masfen Holdings Limited michael@campbellbrown.co.nz Transport Auckland -wide
requirements Retain parking maximums in rule 3.2 'Parking'.
6732-4
Masfen Holdings Limited michael@campbellbrown.co.nz Sustainable Development C7.7/H6.4 Sustainable design Delete 2.2 Offices.
6732-5
Masfen Holdings Limited michael@campbellbrown.co.nz Designations Auckland Transport
Road Delete designation ID 1597.
6732-6
Masfen Holdings Limited michael@campbellbrown.co.nz Designations Auckland Transport
1600 Road Widening - Falcon
Street Delete designation ID 1600.
6733-1 Fiona McLeod fmcleodnz@yahoo.com.au RPS
character and natural heritage B4.1 Historic heritage Retain provisions for the protection of character buildings and houses in Auckland.
6733-2 Fiona McLeod fmcleodnz@yahoo.com.au Zoning Central Retain Single House in Kenyon Ave, Ewington Ave and Valley Road, Mt Eden.
6733-3 Fiona McLeod fmcleodnz@yahoo.com.au
control
Retain pre-1944 demolition control overlay for the houses on Kenyon Ave, Ewington Ave,
Valley Road and other surrounding streets in Mt Eden.
409/1145
Sub#/
6734-1 Horse Riding Warkworth horseriding@xtra.co.nz Rural Zones General I13.1 Activity table Amend the activity status' of farm stays and horse riding to be permitted activities
6734-2 Horse Riding Warkworth horseriding@xtra.co.nz Rural Zones General I13.2 Land use controls
Provide for minor household units up to 65m
2
and/or workers cottages as per the provision
under the operative Rodney district plan
6735-1 Hapai Te Hauora papa@hapai.co.nz RPS Mana Whenua
Fig. 1 Recognise 'cultural landscaping' and development that reflects mana whenua values.
6735-2 Hapai Te Hauora papa@hapai.co.nz General Miscellaneous Bylaws and Licensing
Recognise holistic health approaches alongside controls on access to harmful products
including alcohol, other drugs, unhealthy food and drink, tobacco and gambling.
Add smokefree targets and zoning restrictions to limit retail of psychoactive substances, and
zoning restrictions to curb 'alcohol related harms' including restrictions on off-license facilities.
6735-4 Hapai Te Hauora papa@hapai.co.nz RPS Urban growth
quality compact urban form Recognise opportunities for Whnau to access good quality, affordable housing.
Recognise approaches that prevent 'obesogenic' environments, encourage active forms of
transport such as cycling and walking and encourage healthier living such as through the
development of community gardens.
6735-6 Hapai Te Hauora papa@hapai.co.nz RPS Natural resources
B6.3 Freshwater and
Geothermal Water Recognise the revitalisation of the region's streams, planting of indigenous flora and fauna.
Recognise Whnau friendly areas as well as areas that encourage interaction between
cultures.
6735-8 Hapai Te Hauora papa@hapai.co.nz General C7.4/H6.3 Signs Recognise Mori signage and reclaiming of place names.
6735-9 Hapai Te Hauora papa@hapai.co.nz RPS Urban growth B2.7 Social infrastructure
Recognise the provision of safe spaces for tamariki and rangatahi which provide opportunities
to re-connect with the environment.
participation
Recognise whanau, hap and Mori community participation in all stages including the design
and development.
Mtauranga & tikanga
Amend to align with the spiritual needs of tangata whenua including a connection to the land
and acknowledgement of local mana whenua and Mori connection with the location.
6735-12 Hapai Te Hauora papa@hapai.co.nz Residential zones Residential
policies Prioritise access to gardening for high density housing.
Address the social impact of accessibility to harmful products. Monitor and restrict the
availability, quantity and accessibility to alcohol and other drugs, unhealthy food and drink,
gambling and tobacco.
policies
Add regulations to ensure the quality of housing particularly rental housing is maintained to a
quality standard.
policies
Ensure quality of housing in areas of high Mori populations of Papakura, Manurewa,
Clendon, Massey and Henderson.
6735-16 Hapai Te Hauora papa@hapai.co.nz General Miscellaneous Other Recognise wider health issues in landuse and planning in the RMA.
6735-17 Hapai Te Hauora papa@hapai.co.nz Mana Whenua
settlement land
and policies
Retain provisions which recognise and provide for the economic, cultural and social
development of Mori and Treaty Settlement Land.
6735-18 Hapai Te Hauora papa@hapai.co.nz Mana Whenua General provisions
assessment
Retain the provisions which recognise and provide for cultural values and heritage of Mana
Whenua including the framework for Cultural Impact Assessments.
Whenua
and policies
Retain the use of pre-hearing mediation sessions as a method for discussing and finding
agreed outcomes.
6735-20 Hapai Te Hauora papa@hapai.co.nz RPS Changes to the RUB General Retain the involvement of Mori in determining the extent and location of the RUB.
6735-21 Hapai Te Hauora papa@hapai.co.nz General Chapter A Introduction A1 Background Retain section 1.2 Mana Whenua and include a profile of mataawaka in Tmaki Makaurau.
6735-22 Hapai Te Hauora papa@hapai.co.nz General Chapter A Introduction A2 Statutory Framework Retain the Treaty of Waitangi section.
6735-23 Hapai Te Hauora papa@hapai.co.nz RPS Issues
wellbeing
Recognise the positive value Mori economic development contributes towards Auckland's
prosperity.
our natural resources Recognise the role of Mana Whenua as kaitiaki in the issue statement or explanation.
Acknowledge that a key redress outcome under the Treaty settlement process is to provide an
economic base for future development.
Mtauranga & tikanga
Recognise in provisions the statutory requirements under the RMA (including Part 2 and
section 62).
Mtauranga & tikanga
Add specific objectives, policies and methods enabling customary use and cultural activities.
Section 5.2 is generally supported.
Fig. 1 Retain provisions section 5.4.
Fig. 1
Retain provisions including reference to cultural landscapes in objectives 3 and policies 5-6
and 12.
410/1145
Sub#/
B6.3 Freshwater and
Geothermal Water Retain reference to freshwater health from a Mori perspective in Policy 5.
B6.3 Freshwater and
Geothermal Water
Retain reference to the use of geothermal water for tikanga purposes as a high priority in
Policy 8.
6735-32 Hapai Te Hauora papa@hapai.co.nz RPS Coastal
environment
environment
Retain the reference to Mana Whenua provisions and providing for cultural and traditional use
in Policies 1 and 4.
Gulf
Retain policies 10-12 which recognise the relationship between Mana Whenua and the
management of the area.
6735-36 Hapai Te Hauora papa@hapai.co.nz Public Open Space Zones Public Open Space D2 Introduction Retain policies in section 2.
6735-37 Hapai Te Hauora papa@hapai.co.nz Historic Heritage (Overlay)
Heritage
6735-38 Hapai Te Hauora papa@hapai.co.nz
control
and policies Add objectives and policies that enable development of Treaty settlement land.
Whenua
Retain objectives and policies. [section 5.1] in relation to the protection and enhancement of
sites and places of significance to Mana Whenua.
Whenua
and policies Retain objectives and policies in relation to sites and places of value to Mana Whenua.
6735-41 Hapai Te Hauora papa@hapai.co.nz Precincts - Central New Precincts Other New Precincts
Retain the approach and intent of the Mana Whenua Management area precinct and
precincts. Include new Mana Whenua Management Area for Mana Whenua marae and
Papakinga areas and areas of customary importance throughout the region where this is
supported by Mana Whenua [inferred as a new precinct, rather than extend current Mana
Whenua Management Area precinct].
6735-42 Hapai Te Hauora papa@hapai.co.nz Precincts Ak-Wide and Coastal Regional Parks
Include a new objective and policy supporting the use of regional parks for Mori customary
use and/or cultural activities.
discovery protocol Retain requirements for accidental discovery protocols.
assessment
Amend Rule 2.5.2 to ensure the impacts of the activity on Mana Whenua values and any
measures recommended by Mana Whenua are recognised and provided for.
assessment Retain the CIA requirement for sites and places of significance to Mana Whenua.
assessment Add any new sites/places as supported by Mana Whenua.
assessment
Retain provisions as notified subject to any outcomes of a collaborative approach between
Mana Whenua, council and key stakeholders to refine the process. Clarify that the discretion
to determine if a CIA is required is to be made by Mana Whenua.
6735-48 Hapai Te Hauora papa@hapai.co.nz Mana Whenua Auckland wide - Mori Land
controls
Amend the activity table to include a range of commercial activities as permitted and
controlled activities.
controls Remove the permitted rule threshold restricting development to a maximum of 10 dwellings.
controls Add a new rule framework for cultural and customary activities on Treaty settlement land.
6735-51 Hapai Te Hauora papa@hapai.co.nz
SEAs
Retain the provision for customary use in the Activity Table 1.2 'vegetation management in
overlays' and Rule 2.5 'vegetation alteration or removal for customary use'.
Whenua
objectives and policies Add any new sites/places as supported by Mana Whenua.
6736-1
Terence G and Beatrice F
Nuthall finu@xtra.co.nz
Outstanding Natural
Rules
Outstanding Natural
Landscapes Delete the outstanding natural landscape overlay from 97 Perry Road, Warkworth
411/1145
Sub#/
6736-2
Terence G and Beatrice F
Nuthall finu@xtra.co.nz Water
streams & wetland
Management Area Delete the high use stream management area overlay from 97 Perry Road, Warkworth
6737-1
Lou R Spencer and Christine L
Barton spencerbarton@xtra.co.nz Zoning North and Islands
Rezone land identified in submission, including 401 Taupaki Road, RD2 Kumeu, from Mixed
Rural to Countryside Living zone. Refer to details in Attachment D to submission on page
11/11 of volume 1.
6738-1 Alan Wiltshire liam.wpg@gmail.com Zoning North and Islands Retain 2/694 Hibiscus Coast Highway, Hatfield Beach as Rural Coastal.
6738-2 Alan Wiltshire liam.wpg@gmail.com Rural Zones General I13.1 Activity table
Retain Permitted activity status for the activity 'Dwellings except in the Pakiri, Whangateau to
Waiwera, Kaipara South Head and harbour to Muriwai-Te Henga Rural Coastal zone areas'.
6738-3 Alan Wiltshire liam.wpg@gmail.com Rural Zones General I13.1 Activity table Retain Permitted activity status for the activity 'Demolition of buildings'.
6738-4 Alan Wiltshire liam.wpg@gmail.com Rural Zones General I13.3 Development controls Retain rule '3.1 Height' of 7m in the Rural Coastal zone.
6738-5 Alan Wiltshire liam.wpg@gmail.com Rural Zones General I13.3 Development controls
Retain rule 3.2 'Yards' 6m side and rear yards and 50m coastal protection yards for the Rural
Coastal zone.
6738-6 Alan Wiltshire liam.wpg@gmail.com Rural Zones General I13.2 Land use controls Retain rule 2.6 'Dwellings' 1 dwelling per site where the site is less than or equal to 40ha.
6738-7 Alan Wiltshire liam.wpg@gmail.com Rural Zones General I13.2 Land use controls
Amend rule 2.6(b) 'Dwellings' to delete the net site area requirement and replace with 'gross
site area'.
6738-8 Alan Wiltshire liam.wpg@gmail.com Mana Whenua General provisions
assessment Reject 2.7.4 Cultural Impact Assessments.
6738-9 Alan Wiltshire liam.wpg@gmail.com General Chapter G General provisions
statements Delete all references to the Auckland Design Manual in Design Statements.
6738-10 Alan Wiltshire liam.wpg@gmail.com Rural Zones
obs & pols
Amend Figure 2 so that the Southern Boundary of the East Coast Area stops at the North
Bank of the Waiwera River.
Amend rule 2.6(1) 'Dwellings' requirement for 'Any site where a dwelling is erected must
comply with', which exceeds 2ha, to include share of common and private way areas.
Delete definition of 'Site' from Land use control 2.6 'Dwellings' and require compliance with
clause 1(a)-(d) or remove restriction to include land subdivided under the Unit Titles Act,
1972, the cross lease system or stratum subdivision as noted in the definition of 'Site'.
6738-13 Alan Wiltshire liam.wpg@gmail.com
Outstanding Natural
Rules
Outstanding Natural
Landscapes Remove ONL from 2/694 Hibiscus Coast Highway, Hatfield Beach.
6739-1 Fernando and Jill Sousa paulsousa@xtra.co.nz Zoning South Rezone 134 Runciman Road, Pukekohe from Mixed Rural to Countryside Living.
6739-2 Fernando and Jill Sousa paulsousa@xtra.co.nz Precincts - South Runciman Amend boundary of Runciman sub-precinct A to include 134 Runciman Road, Pukekohe.
6739-3 Fernando and Jill Sousa paulsousa@xtra.co.nz Rural Zones General I13.1 Activity table
Provide for minor residential units in all rural zones as a permitted activity subject to
development controls. Refer to page 8-9/11 of the submission for recommend controls.
6739-4 Fernando and Jill Sousa paulsousa@xtra.co.nz Rural Zones General I13.1 Activity table Amend activity status of 'Intensive Farming' in the Mixed Rural zone to Discretionary.
6739-5 Fernando and Jill Sousa paulsousa@xtra.co.nz Rural Zones General I13.1 Activity table Amend activity status of 'Intensive Poultry Farming' in the Mixed Rural zone to Discretionary.
Amend the activity and activity status of 'On-site primary produce manufacturing' in the Mixed
Rural zone by splitting it into two activities depending on whether the produce is produced on
site or the adjoining land, Permitted, or not, Discretionary. See submission for specific
Amend activity status of 'Quarries - Farm or Forestry' in the Mixed Rural zone to Restricted
Discretionary.
Amend the activity and activity status of 'Markets' in the Mixed Rural zone by splitting it into
two activities depending whether the development controls are met, Restricted Discretionary,
or not, Discretionary. See submission for specific wording [page 9/11].
6739-9 Fernando and Jill Sousa paulsousa@xtra.co.nz Rural Zones General I13.1 Activity table Amend activity status of 'Free Range Poultry Farming' in the Mixed Rural zone to Controlled.
6739-10 Fernando and Jill Sousa paulsousa@xtra.co.nz Rural Zones General I13.3 Development controls
Amend rule 3.3 'Buildings housing animals minimum separation distance' to provide greater
setbacks from site boundaries and neighbouring dwellings on a 'pro-rata' basis depending on
the size of the building.
6739-11 Fernando and Jill Sousa paulsousa@xtra.co.nz Rural Zones General I13.3 Development controls
Amend rule 3.5 'Size of buildings - intensive farming, intensive poultry farming, animal
breeding or boarding without dogs, produce stalls, on-site primary produce manufacturing' to
provide greater setbacks from site boundaries and neighbouring dwellings on a 'pro-rata'
basis depending on the size of the building.
6740-1
Ngti Rehua Ngtiwai ki Aotea
Trust Board ngati_rehua_chairperson@xtra.co.nz General Miscellaneous Other Adopt the relief sought from the Independent Mori Statutory Board submission.
6740-2
Ngti Rehua Ngtiwai ki Aotea
Trust Board ngati_rehua_chairperson@xtra.co.nz General Miscellaneous Other Amend so there is greater alignment to Iwi and Hap Management Plans.
412/1145
Sub#/
6741-1 John D Rosamond diggadoug26@gmail.com Zoning North and Islands
Rezone land identified in submission, including 81 Nixon Road, Tuapaki (RD2 Henderson),
from Mixed Rural to Countryside Living zone. Refer to details in Attachment D to submission
on page 11/12 of volume 1.
6742-1
Te Mahurehure Cultural Marae
Society Incorporated christine.p@vodafone.co.nz Zoning Central
Rezone 65 Premiere Avenue, Point Chevalier from Community Open Space to Mori
Purpose.
6743-1 Progressive Trust kerry.sanders@email.com Zoning North and Islands
Rezone land identified in submission, including 163 Taupaki Road, RD2 Kumeu, from Mixed
Rural to Countryside Living zone. Refer to details in Attachment D to submission on page
12/13 of volume 1.
6744-1 Biomarine Limited jim@biomarine.co.nz
the CMA
Amend the activity status of re-consenting marine farms to be a Controlled Activity, excluding
overlay areas.
the CMA
D5.1.14 Background,
Add a new objective and policy which specifically provide for the continued operation of
existing aquaculture facilities in the General Coastal Marine zone.
the CMA
D5.1.14 Background,
Amend the policies which direct aquaculture to avoid adverse effects on overlays to
acknowledge the existing aquaculture and the fact that it will not always be practicable or
appropriate for aquaculture to avoid its adverse effects.
the CMA
Amend to provide for applications to re-consent existing aquaculture activities to be
considered on a non-notified basis.
the CMA
D5.1.14 Background,
Amend to recognise within the overlay description in Appendix 3 or Appendix 6 that the
marine farm forms part of the existing environment in the vicinity of that overlay.
6744-6 Biomarine Limited jim@biomarine.co.nz General Miscellaneous Other
No specific relief sought - supports multiple points made within the Aquaculture New Zealand
submission in relation to points raised in submission, small extensions to existing marine
farms, establishing new marine farms and protecting existing marine farms from adverse
effects.
the CMA
Amend to provide for small extensions to existing marine farms as non-notified, Restricted
Discretionary Activities, regardless of the surrounding overlays.
the CMA
Amend to provide for the establishment of new marine farms within the General Coastal
Marine zone, including overlays, to be a Discretionary Activity.
the CMA
D5.1.14 Background,
Amend provisions to further expand on the importance of protecting existing marine farms
from adverse effects.
Outstanding Natural
Rules
Character - Coastal
Amend overlay following a review, in particular at Mahurangi Harbour, to provide justification
of the threshold and extent of the overlays [in relation to marine farms].
the CMA
sch. 6.2 ONC/HNC
6.1 Schedule SEA
Marine 1 and 2
Amend overlay following a review, in particular at Mahurangi Harbour, to provide justification
of the threshold and extent of the overlays [in relation to marine farms].
6744-12 Biomarine Limited jim@biomarine.co.nz Mana Whenua General provisions
assessment
Reject the requirement for a Cultural Impact Assessment when considering applications for
existing marine farms.
6744-13 Biomarine Limited jim@biomarine.co.nz General Miscellaneous
Operational/
Undertake dredging around Scotts Landing, Mahurangi, and Dawson Creek to enable the
area to be used for oyster farming and public access.
6745-1 Tania M Turner taniamt@orcon.net.nz Zoning North and Islands
Rezone precinct zones 1, 2 and 4 and reject those in other zones [No specific relief sought -
inferred to relate to Devonport Peninsula precinct which has sub-precincts A-F].
6745-2 Tania M Turner taniamt@orcon.net.nz Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula
objectives and policies Delete precinct.
6745-3 Tania M Turner taniamt@orcon.net.nz Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula K5.11 Precinct rules
Reduce building height to 8m unless there is a setback of at least 60m from all other property
or public open spaces.
6746-1 Johanna M Parker
270 Tawa Road, RD1, Kumeu,
Auckland 0891 General Miscellaneous Consultation and engagement
Reject intensification and increased development in Riverhead, Kumeu and Huapai due to
lack of consultation.
Require transport infrastructure to be upgraded to address additional transport issues arising
from intensification and increased development in the Huapai - Kumeu area
and surrounding areas.
Auckland 0891 General Chapter G General provisions G2.4 Notification Reject provisions that enable development to occur without public notification.
and villages
Retain and enhance the historical connections of the Huapai / Kumeu / Riverhead / Taupaki /
Waimauku districts in providing activities including vineyard trails, orchards,
horticultural speciality crops and animal husbandry to the greater Auckland population.
413/1145
Sub#/
Operational/
Preserve geotechnical reports identifying 10m topsoil in the area around Old North Road,
Riverhead.
Provide for a satellite city in the area of Frank Taylor Rd - Red Hills Road adjacent to
Westgate.
recreation facilities Provide for a satellite city in the area at the end of the [north] western motorway.
General Restrict development to 3 storeys in the areas including and surrounding Kumeu-Huapai.
6747-1 Andrew Mahon andrewmahon1234@hotmail.com General Miscellaneous Other
Educate Auckland's citizens about the value of architectural heritage, rail, compact cities,
infrastructure and the beneficial effects these things will have on the social and economic
wealth of the city.
6747-2 Andrew Mahon andrewmahon1234@hotmail.com General Miscellaneous Other
Build stronger links with economies such as China in order to source funding for Auckland
council and private sector projects.
6747-3 Andrew Mahon andrewmahon1234@hotmail.com RPS Urban growth
environment
Create a means to demolish unsightly buildings and replace them with spacious, well built,
architecturally appealing ones.
6747-4 Andrew Mahon andrewmahon1234@hotmail.com RPS
character and natural heritage B4.1 Historic heritage Take muscular action to protect and in many cases rebuild our old buildings.
6747-5 Andrew Mahon andrewmahon1234@hotmail.com Residential zones Residential
General
Amend rules to create bigger minimum spaces for apartments [minimum dwelling sizes -
inferred].
6747-6 Andrew Mahon andrewmahon1234@hotmail.com General Miscellaneous
Operational/
Projects/Acquisition Build a second harbour crossing, be that a bridge or a tunnel with rail.
Operational/
Projects/Acquisition Build a rail line to northern limits of the city, going through Albany.
6747-8 Andrew Mahon andrewmahon1234@hotmail.com RPS Issues
heritage Save the beautiful St James Theatre.
environment Require future developers to follow new strict high standards of architecture.
Define Auckland city's limits and ensure that housing development is prohibited past those
limits.
Operational/
Projects/Acquisition Make Queen Street car free and set up a tram line running the length of Queen Street.
Operational/
Source alternative funding (internationally even) for the City Rail Loop if this cannot be
obtained from the government.
6747-13 Andrew Mahon andrewmahon1234@hotmail.com RPS Issues
growth
Study world leading cities and their approaches to some of the urban planning issues being
experienced by Auckland.
6748-1 Kirsten B Rudolph kbrudolph@hotmail.com RPS Issues
growth
Amend strategic direction 11 [House all Aucklanders in secure, healthy homes they can
afford] so Council is not seen as the provider but the enabler.
6748-2 Kirsten B Rudolph kbrudolph@hotmail.com Infrastructure
C1.1 Infrastructure
policies
Amend section to clearly separate owned infrastructure, shared infrastructure and governed
infrastructure.
6748-3 Kirsten B Rudolph kbrudolph@hotmail.com General Miscellaneous Other
Identify areas in zones of high visibility that use certain high levels of underground
infrastructure to use paving stones instead of asphalt.
6748-4 Kirsten B Rudolph kbrudolph@hotmail.com General Miscellaneous Other Consolidate signposts and move to international standards and symbols.
6748-5 Kirsten B Rudolph kbrudolph@hotmail.com General Miscellaneous Other Place bus stops after pedestrian crossings.
6748-6 Kirsten B Rudolph kbrudolph@hotmail.com General Miscellaneous Bylaws and Licensing
Add bylaws to ensure that, in addition to cyclists, all similar road users are obliged to wear
helmets and obey road rules.
6748-7 Kirsten B Rudolph kbrudolph@hotmail.com Transport Auckland -wide C1.2 Policies Amend policy 11(b) to ensure access to transport between multi-site locations.
6748-8 Kirsten B Rudolph kbrudolph@hotmail.com Infrastructure
C1.1 Infrastructure
policies Amend policy 12(e) ' Road Network' as follows: iv. low cost maintenance.
6748-9 Kirsten B Rudolph kbrudolph@hotmail.com Transport Auckland -wide C1.2 Policies
Amend parking policy to socialise the concept that with higher density living, the current
assumed 'right' as an individual to park on the street outside their dwelling will cease.
6748-10 Kirsten B Rudolph kbrudolph@hotmail.com Trees
Add a policy to increase the regular, planned maintenance of street trees in order to maintain
shape, manage height and protect infrastructure and to reduce the need to replace trees.
Consider 5.11 Rural Production Discharges in relation urban compost as an alternative to
waste.
6748-12 Kirsten B Rudolph kbrudolph@hotmail.com General Miscellaneous
Operational/
Add future infrastructure in the 'infrastructure lists' including the Sky City Convention Centre
and the second harbour crossing.
6748-13 Kirsten B Rudolph kbrudolph@hotmail.com Residential zones Residential Land use controls
Amend density categories by creating an additional category and moving four or more
dwellings into this category. See submission for specific details [page 5/7].
Ensure those who reside in denser urban centres benefit from the cost saving associated with
better infrastructure utilisation.
414/1145
Sub#/
6748-15 Kirsten B Rudolph kbrudolph@hotmail.com General Miscellaneous
Operational/
Investigate lines where stormwater is separated from wastewater and evaluate treatment for
distribution.
Revisit future direction of existing library catalogues in the face of advance/new digital
technology.
Ensure that policies, prevention stratagies and monitoring are implemented that prevent the
establishment of international crime organisations.
Provide additional visible police in the before and after school timeframes to elevate safety
levels and encourage more parents to switch their child's transport mode from driving to
walking.
Use the learnings from the Kaipara sewerage project to generally apply to the Auckland Plan
to mitigate the risk of similar occurrences.
6748-20 Kirsten B Rudolph kbrudolph@hotmail.com General Editorial and Part 6 Amend the PAUP to use full references for each provision.
6748-21 Kirsten B Rudolph kbrudolph@hotmail.com General Eplan Consider the future ability to 'mark-up' the PDF version of the plan with comments for return.
6748-22 Kirsten B Rudolph kbrudolph@hotmail.com RPS Urban growth
environment Retain Auckland as one of the top 20 cities in the world [page 5/7 of the submission].
6748-23 Kirsten B Rudolph kbrudolph@hotmail.com Residential zones Residential
General
Clarify the purpose of the 6m building setbacks from the road boundary [The specific rule is
not clear from the submission].
Change traffic light algorithms to optimize flow, such as simultaneous pedestrian crossings
when traffic is impacted.
Enable a 'bypass' method to enable the flow of cycle traffic to continue in addition to the safe
movement of pedestrians from the link buss to ferries on Quay St.
Move to a fortnightly rubbish collection system in addition to continued charges via the rates
system rather than 'per lift' charges for waste disposal.
6749-1
The McAuley Trust
(Congregation of the Sisters of
Mercy New Zealand) matt@rms.co.nz Zoning Central
Rezone 3-11 New Street and 61 College Hill, (Lots 1-14 DRO BLUE 78 Pt Lots 14 17 Sec 8
Auckland) Freemans Bay from Special Purpose: School to Mixed Use.
6749-2
The McAuley Trust
Mercy New Zealand) matt@rms.co.nz Special Character
& C
Isthmus Delete the overlay from 3-11 New Street and 61 College Hill, Freemans Bay.
6749-3
The McAuley Trust
Mercy New Zealand) matt@rms.co.nz
Centre)
Overlay E4.5 Identified Growth
Corridor
Include as a Restricted Discretionary Activity (non-notified) within the Mixed Use Zone, an
'Urban Property Management Plan' which provides for a single resource consent for multiple
activities within a site or area where integrated development can be planned as a means to
take account of information contained within the various relevant PAUP overlays.
6749-4
The McAuley Trust
Mercy New Zealand) matt@rms.co.nz Historic Heritage (Overlay)
Heritage
Places
Amend the Extent of Place around St Marys Chapel (3-11 New Strret & 61 College Hill,
Freemans Bay) in the manner detailed in the submission. Refer to pg. 8-9/75 and 12-16/75 of
6749-5
The McAuley Trust
Heritage
Places
Amend the PAUP to refer to the 'Stella Maris building' ID 01764 (3-11 New Street & 61
College Hill, Feemans Bay) consistently throughout the Plan and remove any reference to the
'College Hall'.
6749-6
The McAuley Trust
policies
Retain provisions that provide for increased building bulk and land use flexibility at 3-11 New
Street and 61 College Hill, Freemans Bay.
6749-7
The McAuley Trust
Heritage
Places
Amend the Scheduling for ID 01764 to refer to "St Marys Chapel and the Stella Maris
building".
6749-8
The McAuley Trust
Mercy New Zealand) matt@rms.co.nz RPS Urban growth B2.7 Social infrastructure
Add an objective that clearly articulates the importance of education facilities and the need for
the expansion of present infrastructure facilities, nothwithstanding there may be unavoidable
minor impacts on adjoining land uses.
6749-9
The McAuley Trust
policies
Amend Objective 3 to read: 3. 'Potential adverse effects of schools, community facilities and
associated activities and their use on adjacent areas are mitigated to the extent that it is
practicable to do so having regard to the importance of the school to the wider community'.
6749-10
The McAuley Trust
policies
Amend Policy 6 to read: 6. 'Recognise the effcient utilisation of finite infrastructure and
manage the scale, intensity, frequency and hours of operation of community use of school
land, buildings and related infrastructure accordingly'.
6749-11
The McAuley Trust
Purpose) D8.9/I23 School I23.1 Activity table
Recognise the importance of Carmel College, at 108 Shakespeare Road, Milford, as local and
regional infrastructure in terms of rationalising resource use associated with the School zone
and overlays so that the implementation of school objectives takes priority over overlays.
6749-12
The McAuley Trust
(ONF) Rules
Features Overlay
Review and make accurate the delineation of the Outstanding Natural Feature as it relates to
Carmel College at 108 Shakespeare Road, Milford.
415/1145
Sub#/
6749-13
The McAuley Trust
SEAs
Land
Review and make accurate the delineation of the SEA as it relates to Carmel College at 108
Shakespeare Road, Milford.
6749-14
The McAuley Trust
Purpose)
zone
Amend Rule 2.2 to read: 2.2 The development controls in a concept plan or precinct plan
apply in place of the relevant control.
6749-15
The McAuley Trust
Mercy New Zealand) matt@rms.co.nz General Cross plan matters
Amend Restricted Discretionary Activity, the Matters of Discretion statement in Chapter H:
Auckland-wide rules to read: 'The Council will restrict its discretion to the relevant matters
below for activities listed as restricted discretionary in the activity table'.
6749-16
The McAuley Trust
Mercy New Zealand) matt@rms.co.nz Transport
transport noise J1.5 Rules and mapping Delete Rule 2.1 where it relates to classrooms in an educational facility.
6749-17
The McAuley Trust
policies
Retain provision for increased building and land use flexibility for Carmel College at 108
Shakespeare Road, Milford, through building bulk and location development controls.
6749-18
The McAuley Trust
policies
Retain increased building bulk, location and land use flexibility to enable schools to better
meet their education needs and to maximise efficient use of their sites.
6749-19
The McAuley Trust
policies
Enable Carmel College at 108 Shakespeare Road, Milford, to effciently utilise their site
without unduly and unnecessarily being constrained by adjoining residential land uses.
6749-20
The McAuley Trust
Purpose) D8.9/I23 School I23.1 Activity table
Provide for the use and development of schools to override the overlays controls as a
restricted discretionary activity within the School zone and introduce targetted assessment
criteria.
6749-21
The McAuley Trust
Introduce alternative provisions within the assessment criteria relating to overlays
(Outstanding Natural Features) to ensure Carmel College may fully (and appropriately)
develop recreational facilities for the long term benefit of the community.
6749-22
The McAuley Trust
Mercy New Zealand) matt@rms.co.nz Zoning Central Rezone 27 Fyvie Ave, Three Kings from Single House to Mixed Housing Suburban.
6749-23
The McAuley Trust
Mercy New Zealand) matt@rms.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - Urban zones H5.2 3.1 Residential zones Provide for the subdivision of 27 Fyvie Ave, Three Kings to provide an additional lot.
6749-24
The McAuley Trust
Mercy New Zealand) matt@rms.co.nz Zoning North and Islands
Rezone the land at 2 Ngapara Street, Red Beach (Lot 2 DP 51873) from Single House to
6749-25
The McAuley Trust
control
Building demolition control J.3.6 Rules and mapping Delete the Pre-1944 Demolition Control overlay from 2 Ngapara Street, Red Beach.
6749-26
The McAuley Trust
Mercy New Zealand) matt@rms.co.nz Residential zones Residential
General
Retain the bulk and location rules [no specific rules have been stated] which enable increased
development and land use flexibility for 2 Ngapara Street, Red Beach.
6749-27
The McAuley Trust
Rezone the land at 104 The Drive, Epsom (Lot 1 DP 77766) from Mixed Housing Suburban
to Special Purpose - Healthcare Facility.
6749-28
The McAuley Trust
control
Building demolition control J.3.6 Rules and mapping Delete the overlay from 104 The Drive, Epsom.
6749-29
The McAuley Trust
General
Retain the increased building and land use flexibility for 104 The Drive, Epsom, through
building bulk and location development controls.
6749-30
The McAuley Trust
Delete the volcanic viewshafts (E8, E11, E12 and E13) and height sensitive area provisions
for 3 and 11 Gilgit Road, Mt Eden.
6749-31
The McAuley Trust
Amend the provisions for 3 and 11 Gilgit Road, Mt Eden so that they are based on the height
of the existing Mercy Hospital that provides a backdrop to the relevant views.
6749-32
The McAuley Trust
Amend the Activity table to ensure any buildings exceeding the volcanic viewshafts are
assessed as a Restricted Discretionary activity and are subject to appropriate targetted
6749-33
The McAuley Trust
Delete the requirement for public notification of applications for buildings protruding through
the volcanic viewshaft.
416/1145
Sub#/
6749-34
The McAuley Trust
Mercy New Zealand) matt@rms.co.nz Special Character
& C
Isthmus Delete the overlay from 3 and 11 Gilgit Road, Mt Eden.
6749-35
The McAuley Trust
Retain the proposed Special Purpose - Healthcare Facility zoning for the Mercy hospital
[including 3 and 11 Gilgit Road, Mt Eden].
6749-36
The McAuley Trust
Rezone 12 and 12A Umere Crescent, Ellerslie (Lots 1 and 2 DP 156466) from Single House
and Mixed Housing Suburban to Special Purpose - Healthcare Facility.
6749-37
The McAuley Trust
Purpose)
zone
Amend the description and activity status to provide for residential development as a
permitted activity.
6749-38
The McAuley Trust
Purpose)
zone
Provide for residential development as a permitted activity as a site specific provision for 12
and 12A Umere Crescent, Ellerslie.
6749-39
The McAuley Trust
Mercy New Zealand) matt@rms.co.nz General Cross plan matters
Provide for an 'Urban Property Management Plan' as a Restricted Discretionary activity, to
facilitate and provide for integrated site development associated with different land uses.
6749-40
The McAuley Trust
General
development and land use flexibility for 12 and 12A Unmere Crescent, Ellerslie.
6749-41
The McAuley Trust
Purpose)
zone
Enable Mercy Parkland site at 12 and 12A Umere Crescent, Ellerslie to be able to effciently
utilise their site without unduly being constrained by adjoining residential land uses.
6749-42
The McAuley Trust
Mercy New Zealand) matt@rms.co.nz RPS Urban growth B2.7 Social infrastructure
Amend objectives and policies to recognise the necessity for more intensive land uses within
sites that provide social infrastructure such as care centres, rest homes and education
facilities.
6749-43
The McAuley Trust
SEAs
Introduce alternative provisions within the assessment criteria relating to overlays (SEA) to
ensure Carmel College may fully (and appropriately) develop recreational facilities for the long
term benefit of the community. Refer to pg. 33/75 of the submission for details.
6749-44
The McAuley Trust
Mercy New Zealand) matt@rms.co.nz Water
streams & wetland
Introduce alternative provisions within the assessment criteria relating to overlays (Lake
Management Area) to ensure Carmel College may fully (and appropriately) develop
recreational facilities for the long term benefit of the community. Refer to pg. 33/75 of the
6750-1 Isma Trust office@brownandcompany.co.nz Precincts - West
Amend (3)(1)(1) to increase building height from 6m to 8m. Refer to full submission for
details.
6750-2 Isma Trust office@brownandcompany.co.nz Precincts - West
Amend (3)(3)(3) Table 8 to increase building coverage from 15% of the net site area or
300m2, whichever is the lesser, to 20% or 300m2 whichever is the lesser.
6750-3 Isma Trust office@brownandcompany.co.nz
SEAs
Land Delete the SEA overlay from the property at 50 Beach Valley Road, Piha.
6751-1 Ron Ramdin ron@loveepsom.co.nz Zoning Central Retain the Single House zone for Valley Road, Mt Eden; particularly for 116 Valley Road.
6752-1
Cancer Society New Zealand
Auckland Division Incorporated bjenkinson@akcansoc.org.nz General Miscellaneous Other Include the "Smokefree" policy in the PAUP.
6752-2
Auckland Division Incorporated bjenkinson@akcansoc.org.nz RPS Urban growth
environment
Add a policy statement as follows: Encourage development that considers and enhances the
health and well-being of Aucklanders.
6752-3
Auckland Division Incorporated bjenkinson@akcansoc.org.nz RPS Urban growth
recreation facilities Add a policy statement as follows: Protect and promote public health.
6753-1 Est EJM Wheeler Trust adairw@xtra.co.nz Precincts - West
Retain Sub-Precinct E - particularly the statement: "The activities, controls and assessment
criteria in the underlying zones, Auckland-wide rules, and overlays apply in this sub-precinct
unless modified by the activity table, rules and assessment criteria below. " Refer to full
6753-2 Est EJM Wheeler Trust adairw@xtra.co.nz General Chapter G General provisions
status
Clarify rules (2)(1)(1), (2)(1)(2)(a)(i) and (2)(1)(2)(a)(ii) where there is a conflict between
activity status in other parts of the plan and the Sub-precinct E rules are less restrictive, then
the Sub-precinct E rules apply. Refer to submission for details.
Amend activity table: status for "farming" from "Not Applicable" to "Permitted" for Wainamu
sub-policy Area [note: N/A status applies when no change from underlying zone activity
status]
Amend activity table to include "grazing" as an activity for Wainamu sub-policy Area 1. [Note:
"grazing" is included in definition of "farming" which is a Permitted Activity in this zone and
precinct]
417/1145
Sub#/
Amend activity table: status for "home occupations" from "Not Applicable" to "Permitted" for
Wainamu sub-policy area [Note: N/A status applies when no change from underlying zone
activity status]
Area K7.9.5 Rules (sub-precinct E) Amend activity table to include "horse trekking" as an activity for Wainamu sub-policy Area 1.
6753-7 Est EJM Wheeler Trust adairw@xtra.co.nz Built Environment (Overlays)
Protection
Amend Ridgeline Protection overlay to reduce its extent as it applies to the property at 224
Bethells Road, Waitakere.
Amend rule (4)(3)(1) [assessment criteria] to read: "the extent to which the proposed
development will adversely affect sensitive ridgelines" [Note: there are no assessment criteria
for Ridgeline Protection under Rule (4)(3)(1) - infer that submitter has referred to a rule
contained elsewhere]
Amend rule (2)(1)(2) to include "filming" as a permitted activity in Large Property Management
Area sub-policy areas. [Note: filming activities are Permitted in the sub-precincts]
Area K7.9.6 Rules (sub-precinct F) Amend rule (1)(7)(1) to include "filming" as a permitted activity in Regional Park Precincts.
Area K7.9.5 Rules (sub-precinct E) Retain (2)(1)(3) - Road Network Activities as a Permitted Activity for Wainamu sub-policy area
Amend rule (2)(1)(3)(1) to read: "Road network activities must be limited to the maintenance
of existing roads, accesses and rights of way existing access roads to and within the
Wainamu sub-policy area.
Amend rule (3)(1) Subdivision in the Wainamu Policy Area from a Discretionary activity to a
Restricted Discretionary activity.
Amend rule (3)(1)(1) to read: (a) any sites created by the subdivision must coincide generally
coinciding with the location of proposed lot boundaries shown in Precinct Plan 18. Wainamu.
(b) the Streamside Enhancement Area shown in Precinct Plan 18. Wainamu. must be planted
or seeded with manuka and/or flax or planted with locally sourced native vegetation as per
planting plan prior to the issue of a 224(c) certificate for any subdivision. (c) the Wetland
Protection Area shown in Precinct Plan 18. Wainamu must is made permanently inaccessible
to stock by the erection of a stock barrier in the position shown in Precinct Plan 18.
Wainamu. See submission for details.
Amend rule (3)(1)(2) to read: (2) Subdivision meeting the following controls is a discretionary
activity. [infer that all subdivision to be Restricted Discretionary Activity as per point (14) and
that subsequent points will require re-numbering]. (a) the subdivision must create the same
number of sites shown in Precinct Plan 18. Wainamu (b) the Streamside Enhancement Area
shown in Precinct Plan 18. Wainamu. must be planted or seeded with manuka and/or flax or
planted with locally sourced native vegetation See submission for details.
Amend (2)(1)(4) Buildings (1) to read: "Buildings in the Wainamu Policy Area must have a
building coverage of no more than 15 per cent of the net site area or 800m
2
whichever is the
lesser, provided that no single building can exceed a coverage of 300m
2
. See submission for
details.
Area K7.9.5 Rules (sub-precinct E) Delete rule (2)(3)(2)(1)(d) - refer to full submission for details.
Amend rule (2)(3)(2)(1)(a)(b)(d) to make provisions for second dwellings less restrictive on
larger properties including the Wainamu properties
Amend rule (2)(1)(5)(2)(a) and (b) to include Farming Activities as Permitted and not limited to
grazing only on the Wainamu sub-policy area.
Area K7.9.5 Rules (sub-precinct E) Amend rule (2)(1)(5)(2)(a) and (b) to expand the area allowed for grazing [Precinct plan 18]
Amend rule (2)(1)(5)(2)(a) and (b) to expand the area shown as pasture on Precinct plan 18 to
include to reflect the use of manuka as shelter
Amend rule (2)(1)(5)(2)(a) and (b) to clarify the meanings of "farming" and "grazing" in the
context of the Wainamu sub-policy areas. Refer to full submission for details.
Amend (6)(1)(1) - 'Fences - post and wire' and 'Fences - except post and wire' to change
activity status from Restricted Discretionary and Discretionary [respectively] to Permitted.
Amend (1) Activity table to add two activities 'Fences - post and wire' and 'Fences - except
post and wire' as Permitted activities.
Amend (2)(1)(6), (2)(1)(7) and (2)(1)(8)to allow tree removal, tree alteration, scrub clearing
and vegetation alteration as part of track maintenance, farming and pasture management.
Amend (3)(a)(i)-(xii) and (3)(b)(i)-(iii) to remove assessment criteria which are additional to
those contained in the Rural Conservation underlying zone. See full submission for details.
418/1145
Sub#/
Area K7.9.5 Rules (sub-precinct E) Amend (5)(1) assessment criteria as per full submission.
Delete (3)(a)(i-xii) and (3)(b)(i-iii) and replace with wording consistent with the legacy
provisions. Refer to full submission for details.
Amend (4)(a)(i) to read: The subdivision design should avoid the need for clearance of native
vegetation, retain or link significant vegetation and fauna habitat areas, provide for
landscaping treatment and contain proposals to plant with native vegetation those areas of
the site outside of a SEA, avoid development on natural landscape elements and heritage
features , minimise soil erosion erosion, encourage on-site water retention, avoid
development on floodplans and use draiange methods that protect and enhance streams.
Area K7.9.5 Rules (sub-precinct E) Delete (4)(a)(i) and (ii)
Amend Precinct Plan 18 to add a note which reads: 'No Esplanade Reserve is required
adjacent to or within any proposed site exceeding 4 hectares in site area.'
6753-32 Est EJM Wheeler Trust adairw@xtra.co.nz
Outstanding Natural
Rules
Character - Coastal Remove the HNC overlay from 224 Bethells Road, Wainamu.
SEAs
Land Amend the extent of the SEA on sub-policy area 1. See submission for details.
Outstanding Natural
Rules
Character - Coastal Remove the HNC overlay from 224 Bethells Road, Wainamu.
6753-35 Est EJM Wheeler Trust adairw@xtra.co.nz Water
streams & wetland
Management Area Amend the Natural Stream Management Area at 224 Bethells Road.
Area Mapping
Amend Precinct Plan 18 to reflect the legacy Concept Plan for Large Property Management
Area 2. See full submission for details.
6753-37 Est EJM Wheeler Trust adairw@xtra.co.nz Built Environment (Overlays)
Protection
Amend the Ridgeline Protection overlay by reducing its extent for sub-policy area 1. See full
6754-1
Conservative Party of New
Zealand
regan.monahan@conservativeparty.
org.nz General Chapter A Introduction
Plan
The size of the Unitary Plan has made it inaccessible to many users. [No specific relief
sought].
6754-2
Zealand
Plan The layout of the plan could have been more user-friendly. [No specific relief sought]
6754-3
Zealand
org.nz General Miscellaneous Consultation and engagement
Elected representatives should have been better informed of the Plan in order to improve
communication to residents. [No specific relief sought]
6754-4
Zealand
tools
The plan is vague as it uses abstract, undefined concepts and constructs. [No specific relief
sought]
6754-5
Zealand
org.nz RPS Mana Whenua B5 Strategic
Amend plan so powers are not transferred away from elected representatives, unless they
mandate this.
6754-6
Zealand
org.nz General Chapter A Introduction A2 Statutory Framework
Amend section 2.2 to 'improve clarity and definition to these rather vague notions' 'that issues
relating to Mana Whenua are not exhaustive and should be treated holistically.'
6754-7
Zealand
org.nz RPS Mana Whenua B5 Strategic Remove provisions that has Mori playing a fundamental role in resource management.
6754-8
Zealand
Remove all sections relating to Mana Whenua and replaced only after 'a thorough
consultative process' including being put forward to the public in a 'binding referendum'.
6754-9
Zealand
Amend section 5 'to ensure that, whilst consideration in its simplest form is given to Mori
spirituality' and the relationship they have with 'ancestral land and various resources', that
'without exceptional reason' it will not be an 'impeding factor' in the 'consent process or the
management of resources'.
6754-10
Zealand
org.nz Mana Whenua
Whenua
and policies
Amend so only sites of value or significance are identified where they have 'robust and
verified evidence' which is available for all to access.
6754-11
Zealand
org.nz Mana Whenua General provisions
assessment
Remove cultural impact assessment requirement from sites which are yet to to be
'properly categorised and defined'.
6754-12
Zealand
org.nz Mana Whenua General provisions
assessment
Institute a 'robust and transparent regulatory system that has consistent requirements for both
sides of the consenting process [infer: council and iwi], including standardised time, cost and
mediation. Alternatively, council should 'reabsorb the responsibility for handling issues of
cultural impact' which would otherwise allow 'iwi to object to a consent'.
419/1145
Sub#/
6754-13
Zealand
tools
Stop progress of the Unitary Plan while work is done to ensure that 'all concepts are clearly
defined to a standard that all Aucklanders understand' and are 'content with'.
6755-1 Raywhite Takanini murray.smith@raywhite.co.nz Residential zones Residential Land use controls Amend rules to provide for minor household units in the Single House zone.
6756-1 Jimmy Chan jaicee88@gmail.com Zoning Central Retain Single House zone at McCullough Ave, Fyvie Ave and Smallfield Ave, Three Kings.
6756-2 Jimmy Chan jaicee88@gmail.com General Miscellaneous Other
Retain Housing New Zealand - Puektepapa Local Board initiative to an optimum
concentration of 25% HNZ and 75% private ownership and that Housing New Zealand stop
selling sites on the eastern side of Mt Eden Road.
Reduce Housing New Zealand intensity along McCullough Ave, Fyvie Ave and Smallfield Ave
to 50% HNZ and 50% private ownership.
6756-4 Jimmy Chan jaicee88@gmail.com General Miscellaneous Other Integrate 25% to 75% Housing New Zealand / Private ownership ratio with the PAUP.
6756-5 Jimmy Chan jaicee88@gmail.com General Miscellaneous
Operational/
Projects/Acquisition Separate combined sewer and stormwater drainage.
6756-6 Jimmy Chan jaicee88@gmail.com Special Character
& C
Isthmus Retain Special Character overlay controls along McCullough Ave, Three Kings.
6756-7 Jimmy Chan jaicee88@gmail.com Residential zones Residential
Amend the rules to require a resource consent for three or more dwellings in the Mixed
Housing Suburban zone [to address design issues].
6756-8 Jimmy Chan jaicee88@gmail.com General C7.2/H6.1 Lighting
Increase lighting (lux) levels along Henshaw Road, Smallfield Ave, Fyvie Ave and McCullough
Ave, Three Kings.
6756-9 Jimmy Chan jaicee88@gmail.com Historic Heritage (Overlay)
Heritage
Places Retain Historic Heritage controls for all churches.
Integrate the Sustainability Street initiative into the PAUP as well as existing Neighbourhood
Support and Civil Defence networks.
6756-11 Jimmy Chan jaicee88@gmail.com General Miscellaneous Other Undertake a risk assessment or the threat of oil leakage from the sunk RMS Niagara warship.
6756-12 Jimmy Chan jaicee88@gmail.com General
GIS viewer Clarify the risk to existing landowners from the Treaty Settlement Alert layer.
Adopt relief sought by the Mount Eden Planning Group Inc and other vested interests with
regards to coastal inundation and sea level rise by tsunami.
6756-14 Jimmy Chan jaicee88@gmail.com Precincts - Central New Precincts Three Kings
Support Puketapapa Local Board's consultation process with regards to the Three Kings
precinct.
Retain a design led approach, coordinated approach for redevelopment the existing quarry
and new linkages with adjacent land.
Ensure the notification of the PAUP zones involving any intensification should not process in
advance of the completion of the Three Kings precinct.
6756-17 Jimmy Chan jaicee88@gmail.com Precincts - Central New Precincts Three Kings Reject Fletcher Construction's application for a private plan change [Three Kings].
6756-18 Jimmy Chan jaicee88@gmail.com Sustainable Development C7.7/H6.4 Sustainable design
Amend Policy 1(b) to include "All new dwellings including significant alterations" and "all new
industrial and commercial building over 200m
2
gross floor area".
6756-19 Jimmy Chan jaicee88@gmail.com Sustainable Development C7.7/H6.4 Sustainable design
Require the NZ Green Building Council GreenStar and HomeStar standards as mandatory for
all new buildings, including significant alterations to existing buildings.
6756-20 Jimmy Chan jaicee88@gmail.com Sustainable Development C7.7/H6.4 Sustainable design Integrate NZ Green Building Council standards into NZ Building standards and the PAUP.
Adopt relief sought by Mount Eden Planning Group Inc with respect to zone objectives and
policies ("...no planning advantage if offered to autonomous buildings") [business].
6757-1
The Laingholm District
Citizen's Association (1998)
Incorporated changeco@clear.net.nz Precincts - West
Area K7.9.3 Rules (sub-precinct C)
Retain Large lot residential zoning for Laingholm [Note - precinct applies to Laingholm which
has not been recognised in submission]
6757-2
Amend rule (4)(5)(1) to add the following provisions (1) Sections up to 1500m
2
: Maximum
building coverage 150m
2
(2) Sections larger than 1500m
2
: Maximum building coverage: 10 %
or 400m
2
, whichever is the lesser (3) Large sections qualify for extra building coverage of 1%
of land area in excess of 4000m
2
. Extra building coverage only applies to buildings located
outside of SEAs. [Note - precinct applies for Laingholm which has not been recognised in
submission]
6757-3
Amend rule (4)(4)(1) to add the following provisions: (1) Sections up to 1500m2: Maximum
impervious area is: 150m
2
(2) Sections larger than 1500m
2
: Maximum impervious area: 10%
[Note - precinct applies for Laingholm which has not been recognised in submission]
6757-4
Amend rule (3)(3)(2) to clarify the provisions as they relate to people working on the site
rather than a total number engaged in the home occupation. See full submission for details.
[Note - precinct applies to Laingholm which has not been recognised in submission]
420/1145
Sub#/
6757-5
Amend rule (3)(3)(2)(2) to read: 'No more than two people who do not use the dwelling as
their principal place of residence may work on site in the home occupation.' [Note - precinct
applies to Laingholm which has not been recognised in submission]
6757-6
Amend rule (3)(3)(2)(3) to read: 'No more than four five people in total may work on site in the
home occupation.' [Note- precinct applies to Laingholm which has not been recognised by
submission.]
6757-7
Amend rule (3)(3)(2)(4) to read 'The sale of goods or services from the home occupation that
requires customers to come to the site and the delivery of goods to and from the site may not
occurr before 7am or after 7pm. The provisions of services from the home occupation that
requires customers to come to the site may not occur before 7am or after 9pm. See full
submission for details. [Note- precinct applies to Lainghom which has not been recognised in
submission]
6757-8
Amend rule (3)(3)(2)(6) to provide more flexibility for heavy vehicle movements. See full
submission]
6757-9
Amend rule (3)(3)(2)(7) to provide more flexibility for commercial vehicles. See full
submission]
6757-10
Delete rule (3)(3)(2)(9). See full submission for details. [Note- precinct applies to Lainghom
which has not been recognised in submission]
6757-11
Amend rule (3)(3)(2)(9) to provide more flexibility for this aspect of the activity. See full
submission]
6757-12
Amend rule (3)(3)(2)(10) to read: 'Where a primary element of the home occupation is selling
goods, with the exception of goods ordered and distributed electronically or by mail/courier,
goods sold from the home occupation must be produced on site.' See full submission for
details. [Note- precinct applies to Lainghom which has not been recognised in submission]
6757-13
Amend 1.1 Activity table to add a new category for smaller-scale Visitor Accommodation as a
Discretionary activity. See full submission for details. [Note - precinct applies to Laingholm
which has not been recognised in submission]
6757-14
Incorporated changeco@clear.net.nz Public Open Space Zones Public Open Space I2.1 Activity table
Reject Permitted Activity status for activities as listed in submission [Conservation zone]. See
full submission for details.
6757-15
Incorporated changeco@clear.net.nz Precincts Ak-Wide and Coastal Regional Parks K1.7 Precinct Rules Amend (1)(7)(1) to include activities as listed in submission. See full submission for details.
6757-16
Incorporated changeco@clear.net.nz General Miscellaneous Consultation and engagement
Amend provisions for the Regional Parks Precinct to include requirement for all new activities
in Regional Parks as listed in submission to be approved by relevant Local Board. See full
6757-17
Incorporated changeco@clear.net.nz
SEAs
overlays (except SEAs) Delete (2)(2)(1). Refer to full submission for details.
6757-18
SEAs
Assessment
Amend (2)(2)(2) to increase the permitted removal of live growth of tree from 10% to 20%.
See full submission for details.
6757-19
SEAs
Areas - Land rules (all) Retain 3m tree removal zone around dwellings trimming within 10m of an SEA.
6757-20
Incorporated changeco@clear.net.nz RPS
character and natural heritage B4.3.4 Biodiversity Amend to provide protection for urban biodiversity. See submission for details.
6757-21
character and natural heritage B4.3.4 Biodiversity Amend to provide more recognition of fauna biodiversity. See full submission for details
6757-22
Expand the criteria for Notable Trees to enable further specimens to be included. See full
6757-23
organisms
modified organisms Retain rule (4)(19). Refer to full submission for details.
421/1145
Sub#/
6757-24
organisms
modified organisms
Delete (4)(19) activity table, second row, to remove the permitted activity status for veterinary
vaccines.
6757-25
Incorporated changeco@clear.net.nz RPS Urban growth
Clarify growth predictions for Auckland based on 2013 Census data and revise plans for
intensification and development accordingly.
6757-26
Implement strategies in the PAUP which reduce greenhouse gas emissions and rely less on
fossil fuels.
6757-27
Incorporated changeco@clear.net.nz RPS Climate change Recognise and plan for climate change in the PAUP.
6757-28
objectives and policies Expand provisions for protection of coastal marine environment in the PAUP.
6757-29
the CMA Mangroves
and policies Amend to recognise the issue of sedimentation.
6757-30
the CMA
discharge of contaminants I6.1.8 Activity table Amend to add further controls which regulate the adverse effects of aquaculture
6758-1 Cecilia McNicholl ceciliamcnicholl@hotmail.com Mana Whenua General provisions
assessment Delete the requirement for a Cultural Impact Assessment.
6759-1
Auckland East City Elim
Church Trust matt@rms.co.nz Zoning South
Rezone 198 Mahia Road, Manurewa (Lot 1 DP 105238) from Mixed Housing Suburban
to Special Purpose - School.
6759-2
Church Trust matt@rms.co.nz Mana Whenua
Whenua
of value to Mana Whenua Delete the overlay from 198 Mahia Road, Manurewa (Lot 1 DP 105238).
6759-3
Whenua
Re-evaluate the areas on 198 Mahia Road, Manurewa (Lot 1 DP 105238) that are
delineated by the overlay and refine them in a more precise and accurate manner having
regard to the existing land uses.
6759-4
Whenua J5.2 Rules
Place emphasis on the accidential discovery protocol rather than a blanket resource consent
approval process.
6759-5
Church Trust matt@rms.co.nz
I23.2-3 Land use &
Retain provisions that provide for increased building and land use flexibility for school sites
through building bulk and location controls.
6759-6
policies
Provide for Auckland City Elim Church Trust to efficiently utilse their site at 198 Mahia Road,
Manurewa without unduly being constrained by adjoining residential land uses.
6759-7
Church Trust matt@rms.co.nz RPS Urban growth B2.7 Social infrastructure
Amend objectives and policies to recognise that there will be increasing use and demand on
school facilities, including school recreational facilities and that the Plan should proivide for
this.
6759-8
Rezone 94 Golflands Drive, Howick (lot 2, DP 168489) from Mixed Housing Suburban to
Special Purpose - School.
6759-9
Church Trust matt@rms.co.nz Residential zones Residential
General
development and land use flexibility for 94 Golfland Drive, Howick,
6759-10
Church Trust matt@rms.co.nz Definitions Existing
Amend the definition of Education Facilities to read: "Facilities used for education to
secondary level includes schools, accomodation, administrative, cultural and religious, health,
retail and communal facilities accessory to the above".
6759-11
Church Trust matt@rms.co.nz Zoning South Retain the Special Purpose - School zone for 159 Botany Road, Howick.
6759-12
Church Trust matt@rms.co.nz RPS Urban growth B2.7 Social infrastructure
Retain PAUP's recognition of the requirement for schools to be located within the residential
areas which they support and serve.
6759-13
I23.2-3 Land use &
Retain provisions for increased building bulk, location and land use flexibility to enable
schools to better meet their education needs and to maximise effcient use of their sites.
6759-14
Rezone 179 Botany Road and 286 Cascades Road, Howick (Lots 1 and 2 DP 20153) from
Mixed Housing Suburban to Special Purpose: School.
6759-15
policies
Amend Objective 3 to read: "Potential adverse effects of schools, community facilities and
associated activities and their use on adjacent areas are mitigated to the extent that is
practicable to do so having regard to the importance of the school to the wider community".
6760-1 Gweneth K Inger mareesillick@gmail.com Subdivision Auckland-wide - Rural zones
area Amend Table 6 to include the Rural and Coastal Settlement zone as a donor site zone.
422/1145
Sub#/
area
Amend Rule 4 so that Donor Sites are not restricted by area or other requirements separately
recorded on the Council Valuation Rolls. If a "site" exists and can be built on, it should qualify
as a donor site.
6760-3 Gweneth K Inger mareesillick@gmail.com Mana Whenua
Whenua J5.1 Rules
Amend requirements for cultural impact assessments to where identified sites of significance
to Mana Whenua are actually affected.
6760-4 Gweneth K Inger mareesillick@gmail.com Mana Whenua General provisions
assessment
Amend requirements for cultural impact assessments to where identified sites of value to
Mana Whenua are actually affected.
6760-5 Gweneth K Inger mareesillick@gmail.com Residential zones Residential Land use controls Amend Rule 3.1 to show a density of 1,500m
2
for the Rural and Coastal settlement zone.
area Amend Rule 3.1 to show a density of 1,500m
2
for the Rural and Coastal settlement zone.
6761-1 Kerekin Investments Limited kerekin@xtra.co.nz Residential zones Housing affordability H6.6 Rules
Amend Development Control 1.1 so the affordable housing requirement only applies to new
developments involving more than 100 dwellings.
6761-2 Kerekin Investments Limited kerekin@xtra.co.nz Residential zones Housing affordability H6.6 Rules
Amend provisions so that the affordable housing requirement applies to specific areas rather
than across all of Auckland. In particular it should exclude areas that the value of land has
gotten so high it is no longer viable.
6762-1 Lomalagi Te Henga Trust
PO Box 90223, Victoria Street West,
Auckland 1142 Zoning West
Rezone 156A Bethells Road, Bethells Beach from Rural Conservation to an unspecified
zone.
Auckland 1142
SEAs
Land Remove the overlay at 156A Bethells Road, Bethells Beach [ID 5539].
Auckland 1142 Built Environment (Overlays)
Protection Delete the overlay at 156A Bethells Road, Bethells Beach.
Auckland 1142 Earthworks H4.2.1.1 Activity table - Zones
Remove earthworks provisions in relation to 156A Bethells Road, Bethells Beach [Rural
Conservation].
Auckland 1142 Precincts - West
Delete impervious surface coverage provisions at 156A Bethells Road, Bethells Beach [Rural
Conservation].
Amend the building coverage provisions from 10% to 20%, particularly at 156A Bethells
Road, Bethells Beach [Rural Conservation].
Provide for small detached buildings up to 15m
2
, such as outbuildings and sleep outs, to be
permitted without consent, particularly at 156A Bethells Road, Bethells Beach [Rural
Conservation].
Delete restrictions on farm track formation and maintenance and provide for the right to create
and maintain farm access tracks for safe viable access, including emergency services in
relation to 156A Bethells Road, Bethells Beach [Rural Conservation].
Delete accessory dwelling provisions in relation to 156A Bethells Road, Bethells Beach [Rural
Conservation].
Auckland 1142
Outstanding Natural
Rules
J6.2.4 Assessment
Delete colour and reflectance value provisions in relation to 156A Bethells Road, Bethells
Beach.
Delete roadside stall provisions in relation to 156A Bethells Road, Bethells Beach [Rural
Conservation].
Delete home occupation provisions in relation to 156A Bethells Road, Bethells Beach [Rural
Conservation].
assessment Delete obligation to consult with Mana Whenua on all planning activities.
assessment
Reinstate previous nominal fee for Mana Whenua consultation on identified culturally
significant activities.
6763-1 Philip Le Gros legros.family@xtra.co.nz RPS Urban growth
Retain all existing open space and recreational areas and seek ways through development
proposals to add to existing spaces and also to create connectivity.
Ensure new developments are consistent with, and transition gently, from the existing urban
form.
environment
Require all new developments to be subject to design reviews where the form is significantly
different from that which currently exists in the area.
6763-4 Philip Le Gros legros.family@xtra.co.nz General Chapter G General provisions G2.4 Notification
Require normal planning and development processes to allow full community participation for
increased density developments.
6763-5 Philip Le Gros legros.family@xtra.co.nz Residential zones Residential
policies
Provide development of facilities to cater for an aging Devonport and Bayswater demographic
which will allow current residents to free up existing housing stock.
6764-1
Mangere Lawn Cemetery Trust
Board matt@rms.co.nz Zoning South
Rezone the land at the intersection of Kirkbride Road and McKenzie Road, Mangere (Allot 45
SO 5735 Suburb of Mangere) from Mixed Housing Suburban to Special Purpose - Cemetery.
423/1145
Sub#/
6764-2
Board matt@rms.co.nz
Centre) Business
and Heavy Industry zones Amend to provide for Cemeteries as a Permitted Activity within the Light Industry zone.
6764-3
Board matt@rms.co.nz Precincts - South Mngere Gateway
Amend K6.15.1 Activity table description and status to provide for Cemeteries as a Permitted
Activity within Sub-precinct A.
6764-4
Board matt@rms.co.nz Precincts - South Mngere Gateway
Amend K6.15.1 Activity table description and status to provide for Cemeteries as a Permitted
Activity within Sub-precinct A for 31, 51, 53 and 59 Kirkbride Road.
6764-5
Board matt@rms.co.nz Zoning South
Rezone 31, 51, 53 and 59 Kirkbride Road, Mangere from Light Industry to Special Purpose -
Cemetery.
6765-1 The Point Chevalier Hub pointchevwebsite@gmail.com RPS
character and natural heritage B4.2 Special character Retain PAUP provisions to protect character areas.
6765-2 The Point Chevalier Hub pointchevwebsite@gmail.com Special Character
residential
Add the following streets in Point Chevalier as Special Character areas - Moa Rd, Huia Rd,
Kiwi Rd, Walmer Rd, Riro St, Target St, Montrose St, Alberta St, Miller St, Smale St, and
Formby Ave.
6765-3 The Point Chevalier Hub pointchevwebsite@gmail.com Zoning Central Reduce the amount of growth that Point Chevalier receives under the PAUP.
6765-4 The Point Chevalier Hub pointchevwebsite@gmail.com Zoning Central
Delete the Terrace House and Apartment Buildings zone from Huia Rd, Kiwi Rd, Tui St, Moa
Rd, Walmer Rd, and Riro St.
6765-5 The Point Chevalier Hub pointchevwebsite@gmail.com Zoning Central
Rezone most of Point Chevalier from Mixed Housing Suburban or Mixed Housing Urban to
Single House.
6765-6 The Point Chevalier Hub pointchevwebsite@gmail.com RPS Urban growth
environment Retain the mandatory use of the Auckland Design Manual for high density developments.
6766-1 Hamish Firth deanne@mhg.co.nz Definitions Existing
Delete the definition of 'Net Site Area' and replace it with 'Gross site area' as is currently used
in the operative Rodney District Plan [See page 4/7 of the submission for specific
amendments and proposed diagram].
6766-2 Hamish Firth deanne@mhg.co.nz Residential zones Residential Land use controls
Amend rule 3.1, Table 1 'Maximum density', for Single House zone to read as follows: One
dwelling per site per 600m
2
of gross site area.
6766-3 Hamish Firth deanne@mhg.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - Urban zones H5.2 3.1 Residential zones Delete 'net site area' references and replace with 'gross site area'.
6766-4 Hamish Firth deanne@mhg.co.nz Definitions Existing
Amend the definition of 'Height' to include the vertical distance between the highest part of the
building and the average level of the ground at the external foundations of the buildings, as is
used in the Auckland Isthmus District Plan.
6766-5 Hamish Firth deanne@mhg.co.nz General Cross plan matters
Delete maximum storey controls and use maximum heights as the sole development control
used to determine height.
6766-6 Hamish Firth deanne@mhg.co.nz Special Character
& C J3.3.1-7 Rules Delete demolition controls applying to 32 Laurie Avenie, Parnell.
6766-7 Hamish Firth deanne@mhg.co.nz
Centre) Business
Special information
requirements
Delete the requirement for a wind report for buildings higher than 20m where a canopy is
provided over public spaces or the site is a rear site [13.10 Special Information requirements].
6766-8 Hamish Firth deanne@mhg.co.nz General Chapter G General provisions
Remove the ability to consider policies or criteria outside the listed assessment criteria for
Controlled and Restricted Discretionary activity applications [rule 1.4].
6766-9 Hamish Firth deanne@mhg.co.nz General Chapter G General provisions
6766-10 Hamish Firth deanne@mhg.co.nz Mana Whenua General provisions
assessment
Amend G2.7.4 to change the circumstances under which a Cultural Impact Assessment, and
engagement with Iwi, may be required.
6766-11 Hamish Firth deanne@mhg.co.nz Sustainable Development C7.7/H6.4 Sustainable design
Building Challenge.
6766-12 Hamish Firth deanne@mhg.co.nz Residential zones Housing affordability H6.6 Rules Delete the requirement to provide affordable housing.
6767-1 Daphne Feary matt@rms.co.nz Zoning North and Islands
Rezone 11 Spencer Terrace, Takapuna (Lot 19 DP 43848) from Single House to Mixed
Housing Suburban.
6767-2 Daphne Feary matt@rms.co.nz Residential zones
obs & pols
Amend the Single House zone by providing for an "Urban Property Management Plan" which
provides for increased dwelling density (relative to the baseline) as a restricted discretionary
activity, but only where a proposal addresses the entire site and provides for environmental
enhancement having regard to the site context, for example on large sites abutting the CMA
where integrated management can occur to benefit the wider area.
6767-3 Daphne Feary matt@rms.co.nz Residential zones
Amend the Mixed Housing Suburban zone by providing for an "Urban Property Management
Plan" which provides for increased dwelling density (relative to the baseline) as a restricted
discretionary activity, but only where a proposal addresses the entire site and provides for
environmental enhancement having regard to the site context, for example on large sites
abutting the CMA where integrated management can occur to benefit the wider area.
6768-1 Valera Koltsov valera@ishis.name Zoning West Retain Large Lot zone in Laingholm.
6768-2 Valera Koltsov valera@ishis.name Residential zones Residential
Amend Large Lot zone to have a limit of 150m
2
for permitted building coverage/impervious
surface.
424/1145
Sub#/
6768-3 Valera Koltsov valera@ishis.name Residential zones Residential
Amend rule 4.5 'Building coverage' to allow large sections to qualify for extra building
coverage of 1% land area in excess of 4000m2. Applicable only outside SEAs. See
submission for specific wording [page 3/5].
6768-4 Valera Koltsov valera@ishis.name Precincts - West
Area K7.9.3 Rules (sub-precinct C) Retain minimum section size average of 1 acre for future subdivisions in Laingholm.
6768-5 Valera Koltsov valera@ishis.name
SEAs
Assessment Ensure removal of pest plants on private and public land is not made difficult by rules.
6768-6 Valera Koltsov valera@ishis.name Residential zones Residential Land use controls
Amend rule 3.2 'Home occupations' to limit the number of people working on site who do not
live there to 2 people at any 1 time, allow 5 people in total to work on site, expand the time
limit to 9pm for services, permit 20 vehicle movements to and from the home occupation,
clearly state that prohibiting outsourcing is not intended and restrict selling of goods not
produced on the site when the sale of such goods is the primary activity. See submission for
specific details [page 4/5 of the submission].
organisms
modified organisms Retain GMO rules.
organisms
modified organisms Amend activity table to delete the activity 'Veterinary vaccines'.
6768-9 Valera Koltsov valera@ishis.name RPS
Provide more protection for trees as the notable tree nomination system criteria are set too
high.
SEAs
Retain permitted removal of trees within 3m from dwellings and pruning within 10m of
dwellings in an SEA.
SEAs
Areas - Land rules (all) Permit pruning of trees to to 20% per year. Remove branch diameter restriction.
character and natural heritage B4.3.4 Biodiversity Recognise and protect animals and aquatic creatures, not just plants.
coastal environment
Protect natural coastal areas that are of high importance to wildlife from development and
subdivision.
6768-14 Valera Koltsov valera@ishis.name General Miscellaneous Other
Allow Local Boards to have the oversight/right of approval for new buildings, demolitions,
public amenities etc that are being built in public parks. Such activities should not be classed
as permitted activities.
6768-15 Valera Koltsov valera@ishis.name RPS Urban growth
quality compact urban form Check population projections against 2013 census data.
6768-16 Valera Koltsov valera@ishis.name RPS Climate change
Retain the PAUP taking climate change and potential rising sea levels into consideration in
regards to where intensification is planned.
6769-1
Whangaripo Valley Estates
Limited chris@antics.co.nz
Outstanding Natural
Rules
Outstanding Natural
Landscapes Remove the ONL from Lots 1 and 2 DP 375759 1313 Whangaripo Valley Road Whangaripo
6769-2
Limited chris@antics.co.nz
SEAs
Land
Remove the SEA that covers 7 stream crossings and one farm track [as shown on the
attachment , pg 4/4 of submission] within Lots 1, 4, 5 and 6 DP 375759.
6769-3
Limited chris@antics.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - Rural zones
area
Replace all subdivision rules and controls that apply to land zone 'Rural Production' in the
Rodney Ward, and insert all subdivisions rules and controls contained in the Rodney District
Plan, that are applicable to the General Rural zone.
6770-1
Save our Saint Heliers
Incorporated and Saint
Heliers/Glendowie Residents'
Association Incorporated mag.king@xtra.co.nz Special Character
residential
Amend the planning provisions for Saint Heliers by way of a Special Character Business
overlay with appropriate objectives, policies and rules as detailed in the submission refer
pages 74 - 75/93 [refer page 4/93].
6770-2
Association Incorporated mag.king@xtra.co.nz Precincts - Central Saint Heliers K2.19.Precinct Rules
Amend the rules to encourage adaption and reuse of existing older buildings as as an
alternative to demolition.
6770-3
Association Incorporated mag.king@xtra.co.nz Precincts - Central Saint Heliers K2.19.Precinct Rules Amend the rules to require buildings to be maintained and avoid demolition by neglect.
6770-4
Amend the rules [infer, Rule 3.1 Frontage setback control and maximum height] to reduce the
height limit for buildings in St Heliers from 12.5m to 9 metres.
425/1145
Sub#/
6770-5
Amend [infer, 4.2 Assessment criteria - controlled activities] criteria to be articulated in
compulsory terms using, for instance, 'must' rather than 'should'.
6770-6
Amend [infer, 5.2 Assessment criteria - restricted discretionary activities] criteria to be
articulated in compulsory terms using, for instance, 'must' rather than 'should'.
6770-7
Amend the provisions to limit the bulk and scale of new buildings to be similar to older existing
character buildings.
6770-8
Association Incorporated mag.king@xtra.co.nz Precincts - Central Saint Heliers K2.19.Precinct Rules Amend the provisions to prevent building over amalgamated sites.
6770-9
Amend Rule 2. Notification, so that all applications to substantially alter, demolish and rebuild
are publicly notified.
6770-10
Amend Rule 2. Notification, clause 2(a) to remove the identified sites, or that their presence
be identified and explained in full.
6770-11
Association Incorporated mag.king@xtra.co.nz
control
Building demolition control J.3.6 Rules and mapping Retain the overlay, as it relates to the Saint Heliers Village.
6770-12
Association Incorporated mag.king@xtra.co.nz Precincts - Central Saint Heliers K2.19.Precinct Rules Amend the rules to include design controls.
6770-13
Association Incorporated mag.king@xtra.co.nz RPS Urban growth
environment
Amend the PAUP to recognise the Auckland Design Manual and give it the weight of a legal
requirement, following an opportunity for the community to give feedback.
6770-14
Amend the provisions to ensure all development maintains and enhances commercial
conditions at St Heliers local centre.
6770-15
Add provisions to control the mix of business activities, as St Heliers local centre, being a
local service centre.
6770-16
Association Incorporated mag.king@xtra.co.nz Precincts - Central Saint Heliers K2.19.Precinct Rules Add provisions which limit the number of bars, restaurants and cafes in the commercial zone.
6770-17
Association Incorporated mag.king@xtra.co.nz Special Character
residential
special character areas Amend the PAUP to recognise and incorporate the Tamaki Drive Masterplan.
6770-18
Association Incorporated mag.king@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central
Retain Mixed Housing Urban zone at the block bound by Goldie and Maheke Streets, St
Heliers.
6770-19
Association Incorporated mag.king@xtra.co.nz Residential zones Residential
Amend [infer, Rule 8.2 Building height], for the Mixed Housing Urban zone to reduce the
height in the block bound by Goldie and Maheke Streets, St Heliers from 11 metres to 9
metres.
6770-20
Retain Mixed Housing Urban zone at the block bound by Cliff Avenue and Cliff, Clarendon
and Vale Roads, St Heliers, refer map page 15/93.
426/1145
Sub#/
6770-21
Retain Mixed Housing Urban zone around St Heliers local centre, and at Kohimarama refer
submission page 12/93 and map page 17/93.
6770-22
Association Incorporated mag.king@xtra.co.nz Residential zones Residential
policies Retain the split between Mixed Housing Urban and Mixed Housing Suburban zones.
6770-23
Association Incorporated mag.king@xtra.co.nz RPS Issues
growth
Amend the provisions to to ensure that adequate infrastructure is in place to accommodate
growth, refer submission page 13/93.
6770-24
Association Incorporated mag.king@xtra.co.nz RPS
Transport
and energy
Amend the provisions to to ensure that adequate infrastructure is in place to ensure the
harbour is not polluted by increased building activity, refer submission page 13/93.
6771-1 Jason Gerrand
14 Akiraho Street, Mount Eden,
Auckland 1024
Centre) Business
Park zones
Reduce Mixed Use height of 20.5m on Akiraho St, Mt Eden, to take into consideration
character housing opposite.
6772-1 John Buchanan matt@rms.co.nz
control
Building demolition control J.3.6 Rules and mapping Delete the overlay from 7, 7a and 9 Audrey Road, Takapuna.
6772-2 John Buchanan matt@rms.co.nz Trees
Trees
Notable Trees
Remove the Notable Tree - ID 1034, Norfolk Island Pine at 9 Audrey Road, Takapuna from
the schedule.
6772-3 John Buchanan matt@rms.co.nz RPS
character and natural heritage B4.3.3 Trees and vegetation Require Notable Trees to not be assessed solely by the STEM assessment methodology.
6772-4 John Buchanan matt@rms.co.nz RPS
Require Notable Trees to be assessed by a system that includes special factors such as
heritage significance, scientific significance, ecosystem service, cultural significance and
intrinsic value in conjunction with tree-specific factors. This assessment should be weighed
against negative factors to ensure a well-rounded assessment of notable trees.
6772-5 John Buchanan matt@rms.co.nz Mana Whenua
Whenua J5.2 Rules Delete the 50m yard imposed on areas surrounding the overlay.
6772-6 John Buchanan matt@rms.co.nz Mana Whenua
Whenua J5.2 Rules
Amend Rule (1) so that earthworks within 50m of a site or place of value to Mana Whenua is
a permitted activity, with accidental discovery protocols to apply.
6772-7 John Buchanan matt@rms.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - Urban zones H5.2 3.1 Residential zones
Amend [rule 1(a)] to reduce the minimum site size for subdivision in the Single House zone
from 600m2 to 500m2.
6773-1 Sudhvir Singh sudhvir@gmail.com Transport Auckland -wide
requirements Delete all minimum parking requirements, especially in the Mixed Housing zones.
6773-2 Sudhvir Singh sudhvir@gmail.com RPS Urban growth
quality compact urban form Rezone land alongside public transport corridors, especially the rail network.
6773-3 Sudhvir Singh sudhvir@gmail.com Zoning Central
Rezone Morningside, Takapuna, Green and Ellerslie from Light Industry to Mixed Use, with
overlays to adjust this where appropriate.
6773-4 Sudhvir Singh sudhvir@gmail.com
Centre) Business
Park zones Amend the height limit in the Mixed Use zone to 8 storeys.
Centre) Business
Park zones Amend the height limit in Local Centre zone to 4 storeys.
Centre) Business
Park zones
Amend the height limit in most Town Centres to 8 storeys [no specifics given on which Town
Centres].
6773-7 Sudhvir Singh sudhvir@gmail.com Sustainable Development C7.7/H6.4 Sustainable design Retain Greenstar and Homestar provisions.
6773-8 Sudhvir Singh sudhvir@gmail.com Residential zones Residential
General
Amend rules in the Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings zone and the Mixed Housing
zones to ensure more land is intensified.
6773-9 Sudhvir Singh sudhvir@gmail.com Future Urban
Amend the Future Urban zone by splitting it into two zones to ensure growth is adequately
staged.
6773-10 Sudhvir Singh sudhvir@gmail.com General Miscellaneous Other
Adopt the relief sought by Generation Zero, Auckland Transport Blog and OraTaiao: The New
Zealand Climate and Health Council.
6774-1 Rita C Sallagher
126 Nixon Road, RD2, Henderson,
Rezone an area of Taupaki from Mixed Rural to Countryside Living (refer to the map in
Attachment D on page 11/11 in the submission).
6775-1 Nikau Retreat Limited david@osbornehay.co.nz Zoning North and Islands
Rezone 81 Thompson Road, Warkworth [and adjoining properties, as shown on page 7/8 of
submission] from Rural Production to Countryside Living.
427/1145
Sub#/
6775-2 Nikau Retreat Limited david@osbornehay.co.nz
Outstanding Natural
Rules
Outstanding Natural
Landscapes Delete the identification of an ONL applying to land [shown on page 8/8 of submission]
6776-1 Michael and Helen Guthrie matt@rms.co.nz Special Character
& C
Isthmus
Delete the Isthmus C3 overlay that applies to 553 and 559 Riddell Road, Glendowie (Lot 4-6
DP 82904 and Lot 3-6 DP 35581).
6776-2 Michael and Helen Guthrie matt@rms.co.nz General Cross plan matters
Provide for an "Urban Property Management Plan" that facilitates structured environmental
enhancement in association with increased development rights for the land as a Restricted
Discretionary activity, with targetted and specific assessment criteria.
6776-3 Michael and Helen Guthrie matt@rms.co.nz
SEAs
Land
Amend the SEA - 6114 Land, to accurately identify the vegetation that represents the values
identified in the schedule (with specific reference to 553 Riddell Road, Glendowie).
SEAs
and policies
Amend the PAUP to outline a more coherent strategy for development in association with the
proper management of riparian values of the area (553 and 559 Riddell Road, Glendowie.
Amend the PAUP to outline a more coherent strategy for development in association with the
proper management of coastal environment values of the area (553 and 559 Riddell Road,
Glendowie.
6777-1 Ann Hurley hurley@ihug.co.nz General Miscellaneous Consultation and engagement Undertake further consultation with the community in Kumeu on the RUB.
6777-2 Ann Hurley hurley@ihug.co.nz General Chapter G General provisions G2.4 Notification Strengthen the public notification provisions to protect resident's rights to be notified.
6777-3 Ann Hurley hurley@ihug.co.nz RPS Changes to the RUB West
Delete the Future Urban zone in the 'Triangle' area of Kumeu (bounded by Station Rd, Access
Rd, and State Highway 16) and finalise a new zoning in consultation with affected landowners.
6777-4 Ann Hurley hurley@ihug.co.nz General Miscellaneous Other
Delete provisions requiring no complaints subdivision covenants on properties in the 'Triangle'
area of Kumeu (bounded by Station Rd, Access Rd, and State Highway 16) and the south
side of Access Rd up to and including Farrand Rd.
6777-5 Ann Hurley hurley@ihug.co.nz Rural Zones General I13.1 Activity table
Prevent the proliferation of cleanfill sites in the rural area surrounding Kumeu, Huapai,
Taupaki, Waimauku and Riverhead.
6777-6 Ann Hurley hurley@ihug.co.nz General Noise and vibration H6.2 Rules
Lower the 65dB noise level for industrial areas in proximity to Countryside Living, Rural and
Future Urban zones.
6777-7 Ann Hurley hurley@ihug.co.nz Designations
New Zealand Transport
Agency
6768 State Highway 16 Road
Widening - Kumeu/Huapai Include a central median in any road widening planned through Kumeu.
6777-8 Ann Hurley hurley@ihug.co.nz General Miscellaneous
Operational/
Include a bypass for Kumeu that goes through greenfield or industrial areas rather than
residential areas.
6777-9 Ann Hurley hurley@ihug.co.nz RPS Changes to the RUB West
Amend the Future Urban zone so that the established buffer zone running from Access Rd to
Nobilo Rd (between the 116 Access Rd site and the Future Urban land) is retained.
6778-1 Kathleen Hills
167 Goatley Road, RD1, Warkworth,
Rezone all properties on Goatley Road, Warkworth, from Future Urban, Rural Production and
Mixed Rural to Industry.
6778-2 Kathleen Hills
167 Goatley Road, RD1, Warkworth,
Rezone all properties on Goatley Road, Warkworth so they can be subdivided down to 1
hectare lots.
6779-1 WaterSafe Auckland teresa.stanley@watersafe.org.nz General Chapter A Introduction A1 Background
Amend 1.5 'Our rural and coastal environment' as follows: ...They offer unique lifestyle and
tourism experiences, but along with these opportunities is an increased risk in drowning. The
rural and coastal environment...
6779-2 WaterSafe Auckland teresa.stanley@watersafe.org.nz Water
streams & wetland
C5.14 Background &
Objectives
Amend background to read as follows: The management of the beds of lakes, rivers, streams
and wetlands is important for the protection of natural ecological values, for the efficient
passage of flood flows, and for retaining high water quality and safe use of the aquatic
environment. ...The Council requires that the management of lakes, rivers, streams and
wetlands is undertaken with the view that water safety is intrinsic in all management aspects.
6779-3 WaterSafe Auckland teresa.stanley@watersafe.org.nz Public Open Space Zones
D2.3 Sport & Active
pols
Amend Policy 7 by adding a new clause (a) as follows: (a) manage aquatic public open
spaces with in best practice water safety protocols.
6780-1 J L Morrison Trust matt@rms.co.nz Historic Heritage (Overlay)
Heritage
Places Delete the overlay - ID 2627 Early Road Links, from 15A Matiere Road, Onehunga.
Heritage
Places
Reduce the delineated Extent of Place for ID 2627 Early Road Links Historic Heritage Area,
from non-contributing sites on Matiere Road, Onehunga by taking into consideration the
topography of the site, and other site characteristics that allow development and land use
which will not detract from the values of the contributing properties and historic heritage place.
Heritage
heritage areas
Amend to include a non-contributing rear sites column that does not control further
development on the sites.
428/1145
Sub#/
6780-4 J L Morrison Trust matt@rms.co.nz Zoning Central
Rezone 15A Matiere Road, Onehunga and surrounding non-contributing sites from Single
House to Mixed Housing Suburban.
Heritage J2.3 & J2.4 Assessment Amend the assessment criteria to facilitate further development on non-contributing rear sites.
6781-1 Craig W Booth craigrae@xtra.co.nz RPS Changes to the RUB West Rezone 44 Wintour Road, Waimauku from Mixed Rural to Single House.
6781-2 Craig W Booth craigrae@xtra.co.nz RPS Changes to the RUB West
Rezone the areas shown in the Waimauku Structure Plan as Future Residential (refer to the
map on page 6/9 in the submission) from Rural Production to Future Urban (excluding 44
Wintour Road, Waimauku).
6782-1 Heather Metcalfe hdmetcalfe@maxnet.co.nz RPS Mana Whenua B5 Strategic
Delete provisions that grant Iwi authorities the right to impose their values and beliefs on
others, and to intervene in the rights of others to manage and enjoy their properties.
Remove Mori language expressions that can be widely interpreted and lack clarity [examples
provided page 1/2 of submission]
Remove open-ended phrases which do not provide certainty [examples provided page 1/2 of
submission]
Remove objectives, policies and rules that favour Mori to an extent not envisaged by the Act
and in a manner that has the potential to disadvantage others.
6782-5 Heather Metcalfe hdmetcalfe@maxnet.co.nz RPS Mana Whenua B5 Strategic Remove rules requiring compliance with the principles of the Treaty of Waitangi.
6782-6 Heather Metcalfe hdmetcalfe@maxnet.co.nz Mana Whenua
Whenua
Amend so that scheduled places aregraded into categories that fairly reflect their significance
and with varying degrees of protection instead of having the single highest level of protection.
6782-7 Heather Metcalfe hdmetcalfe@maxnet.co.nz Mana Whenua
Whenua J5.1 Rules
Delete rules and replace with a simple rule requiring any person carrying out work to
immediately cease work and notify Council in the event that artefacts and other items are
discovered that might have some significance to Mori.
6782-8 Heather Metcalfe hdmetcalfe@maxnet.co.nz Mana Whenua General provisions
assessment
Amend rules to appoint the Council to be the agency responsible for preparing any Cultural
Impact Assessments deemed necessary by Council.
6782-9 Heather Metcalfe hdmetcalfe@maxnet.co.nz Mana Whenua General provisions
assessment
Amend rules that should consultation with Iwi be required under the RMA, the process be
clearly outlined, and firm costs time lines be provided for the consultation process, and that
these be strictly monitored by Council.
6783-1 Simone Schenirer simone@mondelloconsulting.com Residential zones Residential
Amend rule 7.1 'Development control infringements' so that infringing three or more
development controls is a Non-complying activity.
Amend rule 7.3(1) 'Height in relation to boundary' to 2m and 45 degrees for all boundaries, to
apply to all public open spaces, including roads, and to apply at the legal boundary of the site,
not the far side of an access way/lot walkway. See submission for further details [page 1/1 of
the submission].
Mixed Housing Urban zone Delete rule 7.4 'Alternative height in relation to boundary'.
Mixed Housing Urban zone Delete rule 7.6 'Common walls'.
Mixed Housing Urban zone Amend rule 7.8 'Building coverage' to 35% for all densities.
Amend rule 7.9 'Landscaping' to have a minimum landscaped area of 40% for all
developments.
Mixed Housing Urban zone Delete the 10% planting and size requirements from rule 7.9 'Landscaping'.
Mixed Housing Urban zone Amend rule 7.12 'Outdoor living space' to be 100m
2
per unit.
Mixed Housing Urban zone Amend rule 7.14 'Maximum building length' to apply to all boundaries, including the road.
6784-1
Perry Resources (2008)
Limited
graeme.mathieson@emslimited.co.n
z Earthworks
and policies
Amend Objective 1 to read: 'Earthworks are undertaken in a manner that protects the safety
of people and avoids, remedies or mitigates any adverse effects on the environment.'
6784-2
Limited
z
SEAs
and policies
Amend Policy 1 to read: 'Protect Maintain indigenous vegetation in sensitive environment
including the coast, riparian margins, wetlands and areas prone to natural hazards'.
6784-3
Limited
z
SEAs
and policies Amend Policy 2 by replacing the word ' protect' with 'maintain'.
429/1145
Sub#/
6784-4
Limited
z Mineral extraction
and policies
Amend Objective 1 to read: 'Mineral extraction from the land occurs in a way that meets the
industries and users needs while significant adverse effects to environmental and amenity
values are remedied or mitigated protected .
6784-5
Limited
and policies
Delete Policy 6 and replace with: 'Provide for industrial activities within or adjoining mineral
extraction sites where these rely on minerals as a principal raw material.'
6784-6
Limited
z General Noise and vibration
and policies
Amend Objective 4 to read: 'The strategic importance of transportation routes, and significant
infrastructure and regionally significant quarries is recognised and protected...'
6784-7
Limited
z General Noise and vibration
6784-8
Limited
z Mineral extraction Quarry zone
and policies
Amend Zone description to read: 'Mineral resources are important to Aucklands economy and
development. This zone provides for regionally significant mineral extraction sites to ensure
that mineral extraction activities can continue and are unrestricted by reverse sensitivity
effects incompatible activities but are undertaken in a manner that minimises remedies or
mitigates significant adverse environmental effects...'
6784-9
Limited
and policies
Amend Objective 2 to read: 'The significant adverse effects associated with mineral extraction
are minimised remedied or mitigated as far as practicable.'
6784-10
Limited
requirements
Amend Table 15 in the development controls 3.4.3 'width of access and queuing
requirements' to refer to an 8m maximum two-way vehicle crossing within Quarry zones.
6784-11
Limited
z Earthworks H4.2.1.1 Activity table - Zones
Amend Activity Table so that any earthworks greater than 2500m
2
or 2500m
3
is a controlled
activity in the Quarry zone and include relevant matters of control and assessment criteria.
6784-12
Limited
z Earthworks
Overlays
Amend Activity Table to include a new restricted discretionary activity for any earthworks
within an SEA also located within a Quarry zone.
6784-13
Limited
z
SEAs
Retain the restricted discretionary activity in the Activity Table for any vegetation alteration or
removal within an SEA located within a Quarry zone.
6784-14
Limited
z Water
streams & wetland
table
Retain the restricted discretionary activity for 'the diversion of a river or stream to a new
course and any disturbance and associated discharge associated with mineral extraction
within a Quarry zone'.
6784-15
Limited
z Water
streams & wetland
table
Add a new restricted discretionary activity for 'replacement of existing structures and
installation of new structures and the associated bed disturbance or depositing any
substance, diversion of water and incidental temporary damming of water associated with
mineral extraction in a Quarry zone'.
6784-16
Limited
z Water Stormwater
rules
Amend the activity status of 'the diversion and discharge of stormwater from impervious areas
not otherwise authourised by stormwater discharge and diversion rules' from discretionary to
6784-17
Limited
Information Requirements Amend the activity status of 'mineral extraction activities' from controlled to permitted.
6784-18
Limited
Retain all the activity statuses in the Activity Table with the exception of the proposed
amendment to the activity status of 'mineral extraction'.
6784-19
Limited
Amend land use control 2.2(2)(b) to read: 'All blasting is restricted to:...(b) an average of
two occasions per day over a calendar fortnight.'
6784-20
Limited
Add a new land use control requiring all new mineral extraction activities (not already provided
for my way of a resource consent or existing use rights) to be carried out in accordance with
an up to date Quarry Management Plan. For further detail regarding the proposed content of
a Quarry Management Plan see page 12/17 of the submission.
6784-21
Limited
Information Requirements Delete rule 4 Assessment - Controlled activities.
6784-22
Limited
Information Requirements Delete 5 Special information requirements.
6784-23
Limited
Buffer Area Add new discretionary activity 'papakaianga'. [J1.6.1 Activity table]
6784-24
Limited
Buffer Area Add new discretionary activity 'Equestrian Centre'. [J1.6.1 Activity table]
6784-25
Limited
Buffer Area Add new non complying activity 'retirement villages'. [J1.6.1 Activity table]
6784-26
Limited
Buffer Area Add new non complying activity 'boarding house'. [J1.6.1 Activity table]
6784-27
Limited
Buffer Area Add new non complying activity 'veterinary clinics'. [J1.6.1 Activity table]
6784-28
Limited
Buffer Area Add new discretionary activity 'animal breeding or boarding facilities'. [J1.6.1 Activity table]
430/1145
Sub#/
6784-29
Limited
Amend the definition of 'buildings' by making 'the stockpiling of materials associated with
quarries' as an exception.
6784-30
Limited
Amend the definition of 'industrial activities' to read: 'The manufacturing, assembly,
packaging, wholesaling or storage of products or the processing of raw materials and other
accessory activities (excluding mineral extraction activities).'
6784-31
Limited
Amend the definition of 'Industrial or trade activity' to read: 'Carrying out an industrial or trade
process as defined in the RMA but does not include a production land activity or a mineral
extraction activity.'
6784-32
Limited
z Zoning West
Rezone Te Henga Quarry at 99 Te Henga Road, Te Henga from Special Purpose zone to
Special Purpose Quarry zone.
6784-33
Limited
z Zoning West
Rezone all Special Purpose zones where they cover an area of regionally significant mineral
resources to Special Purpose Quarry zone.
6784-34
Limited
z General Eplan
Amend the map legend so it includes specific reference to Special Purpose Quarry zone [i.e.
all the special purpose zones are not shown as being the same].
6784-35
Limited
Buffer Area
Retain the quarry buffer area overlay around Te Henga Quarry at 99 Te Henga Road, Te
Henga.
6784-36
Limited
z Water
streams & wetland
Management Area
Delete the part of the natural stream management area which is located within the quarry
zone of the Te Henga Quarry at 99 Te Henga Quarry Road, Te Henga.
6784-37
Limited
z
SEAs
Land
Delete the part of the SEA which is located within the quarry zone of the Te Henga Quarry at
99 Te Henga Quarry Road, Te Henga.
6784-38
Limited
z Water
streams & wetland
table
Amend the indicative streams within the quarry zone of the Te Henga Quarry at 99 Te Henga
Quarry Road, Te Henga so that they are more accurately align with the path of the Waitapu
Stream as shown on the PAUP aerial maps.
6784-39
Limited
z Precincts - West
Area Mapping
Delete the part of the Waitakere Ranges Area sub-precinct B Overaly covering the Quarry
zone of the Te Henga Quarry at 99 Te Henga Road, Te Henga.
6785-1
Trust Management on behalf
of Saint Johns College Trust
Board et al c.covington@harrisongrierson.com RPS Issues
heritage
Amend Issue 1.3 as follows: Our distinctive historic and natural heritage is integral to our
identity. It is also important for economic, social, and cultural well-being. We need to support
and incentivise active stewardship to protect it for the future.
6785-2
Board et al c.covington@harrisongrierson.com RPS Issues
heritage
Amend Issue 1.3, Historic Heritage as follows: Our challenge... for future generations. It is
acknowledged that much of Auckland's historic heritage is in private ownership and
conservation of these places relies on the knowledge, commitment and active stewardship of
individuals and developers. To enable this there is a need for greater provision of incentives,
advice and assistance to support owners in the conservation and protection of heritage
places.
6785-3
Board et al c.covington@harrisongrierson.com RPS Urban growth
Amend 2.1 Introduction as follows: Urban growth needs to make the best use of existing
significant infrastructure, recognis ing balanced with protecting values such as historic
character and ecological areas, while considering constraints such as natural hazards.
6785-4
Board et al c.covington@harrisongrierson.com RPS Urban growth
Amend Policy 3 as follows: 3. Avoid Ensure urban development does not detract from within :
a. areas with significant...
6785-5
Board et al c.covington@harrisongrierson.com RPS
Amend Policy 2(b) as follows: 2. Identify a place as having historic heritage value if it has one
of more of the following values: b. social: The place has a strong or special association with,
or is held in high esteem by , a particular community, traditional or other cultural value.
6785-6
Add new policy 2(i) as follows: i. economic viability: The place is capable of economically
viable rehabilitation. Consideration will be given to the practicability and cost of any necessary
rehabilitation to achieve reasonable amenity for occupants and reasonable compliance with
any requirement of the Building Act.
6785-7
Amend Policy 3 as follows: 3. Evaluate historic heritage places for their overall...and include
the places in the Historic Heritage overlay if they are found to be of considerable overall
significance to the locality or greater geographic area and their retention, rehabilitation and
use is economically viable.
6785-8
Amend Policy 7 as follows: 7. Encourage and support the community and owners of
significant historic heritage places to protect, conserve, and maintian the place through
mechanisms such as: a. covenants b. applying for funding or heritage grants c. obtaining free
expert advice from Council on the conservation of historic heritage places d. transferable
development rights e. relaxation of development controls
6785-9
Add a reference to categories of SEA in a similar approach to that in the current Auckland City
(Isthmus Plan) with equivalent provisions for consideration of applications involving works in
an SEA.
431/1145
Sub#/
6785-10
Board et al c.covington@harrisongrierson.com Historic Heritage (Overlay)
Heritage
Retain the balanced approach to enabling development in circumstances where it ensures the
long term viability of a Heritage Place identified in policies 3 and 4.
6785-11
Board et al c.covington@harrisongrierson.com
SEAs
and policies Add clearer references to SEA's within the objectives.
6785-12
SEAs
and policies Add clearer references to SEA's within the policies.
6785-13
character and natural heritage B4.3.4 Biodiversity Identify categories of SEA's and set out development options based on the categories.
6785-14
Board et al c.covington@harrisongrierson.com Subdivision Auckland-wide - general
6785-15
6785-16
Board et al c.covington@harrisongrierson.com Sustainable Development C7.7/H6.4 Sustainable design Delete policy 1.
6785-17
Board et al c.covington@harrisongrierson.com Sustainable Development C7.7/H6.4 Sustainable design Delete policy 2.
6785-18
Board et al c.covington@harrisongrierson.com Residential zones Housing affordability
6785-19
Board et al c.covington@harrisongrierson.com General Cross plan matters
Include in the Activity tables for all zones the following: Activities not otherwise provided for
that involve the use of a scheduled historic heritage place - Discretionary.
6785-20
Heritage
heritage areas
Add the following: Activities not otherwise provided for that involve the use of a scheduled
historic heritage place - Discretionary.
6785-21
Add the following in the Assessment Criteria: In considering the application, the council will
have regard to the extent to which the proposed use will secure the scheduled historic
heritage places long-term viability, impact on the adjoining neighbourhood and retention of
heritage values.
6785-22
Add rules into the zone provisions throughout the PAUP which support the use, maintenance
and repair appropriate to scheduled historic heritage places.
6785-23
Add reference to flexibility for adaptive reuse of scheduled buildings in the assessment criteria
for development control infringements and parking shortfalls.
6785-24
Add into the assessment criteria for development control infringements, consideration of the
requirement land owners have to comply with the Building Act regarding earthquake
strengthening of scheduled buildings.
6785-25
character and natural heritage B4.2 Special character Delete the pre-1944 demolition control overlay and references to it throughout the PAUP.
6785-26
Board et al c.covington@harrisongrierson.com Mana Whenua General provisions
assessment
Amend Rule 7.4 Cultural Impact Assessments, to provide a more defined list of the situations
where a cultural impact assessment is required.
6785-27
Board et al c.covington@harrisongrierson.com Water Stormwater H4.14 Introduction
Amend Rule 4.14 Stormwater Management, so that it only applies where the developmenmt
(or addition of impervious area to an existing development) results in an infringement to the
impervious area controls of the underlying zones.
6785-28
controls
Amend Rule 3.1 Subdivision, to provide for subdivision of large sites and transferable
development to be offered where this will provide for the protection of Historic Heritage Places
and Significant Ecological Areas.
6785-29
Board et al c.covington@harrisongrierson.com Subdivision Auckland-wide - Urban zones
except Rural
Amend Rule 3.1 Subdivision, to provide for transferable development rights in the Urban Area
relating to SEA's and protection of Historic Heritage Places, particularly within business
zones.
6785-30
Board et al c.covington@harrisongrierson.com General Noise and vibration H6.2 Rules
Amend Rule 6.2 Noise, to include the following exception to the noise control in all zones: In
all zones, these levels may be exceeded by intermittent noise associated with church bells.
432/1145
Sub#/
6785-31
Board et al c.covington@harrisongrierson.com Sustainable Development C7.7/H6.4 Sustainable design Delete Rule 6.4.
6785-32
Board et al c.covington@harrisongrierson.com Residential zones Housing affordability H6.6 Rules Delete Rule 1.2 [Location of retained affordable housing] or comprehensively reconsider it.
6785-33
Board et al c.covington@harrisongrierson.com Residential zones Housing affordability H6.6 Rules Delete Rule 1.3 [Securing retained affordable housing] or comprehensively reconsider it.
6785-34
Board et al c.covington@harrisongrierson.com Residential zones Housing affordability H6.6 Rules Delete Rule 1.4 [Eligibility for retained affordable housing] or comprehensively reconsider it.
6785-35
Amend all Height in Relation to Boundary Rules that control height in relation to a boundary
with Public Open Space the following: "and sites containing Historic Heritage Places".
6785-36
Board et al c.covington@harrisongrierson.com Residential zones Residential
Terrace Housing and
Amend the Terraced Housing and Apartment Buildings zone where a heritage site is located
in that zone, by applying the same height in relation to boundary provisions as those for sites
adjacent to the Mixed Housing zone as follows: Where sites in the Terrace Housing and
Apartment Buildings zone adjoin a site identified as a Historic Heritage Place, buildings must
be set back at least 3m from side and rear boundaries for storeys one and two and 5m for
storeys three and four.
6785-37
Centre) Business
& Bus. Park zones
Amend the Activity table by for office activity greater than 500m
2
in a Local centre as a
6785-38
Centre) Business
Special information
requirements
Apply the same assessment criteria for Office activity greater than 500m
2
in the Local Centre
zone as for Retail activities over 450m
2
GFA.
6785-39
Centre) Business
Amend the Activity Table by increasing the threshold for office activity from 30% to 50% of all
buildings as a Restricted Discretionary activity.
6785-40
Centre) Business
Amend the Activity Table by increasing the threshold for retail activity from 10% to 30% of all
buildings as a Permitted activity.
6785-41
Centre) Business
Amend the Activity table by changing the activity stautus for offices not otherwise provided for
from Non-Complying to Discretionary.
6785-42
Board et al c.covington@harrisongrierson.com Definitions Existing
Amend the terminology used in the Historic Heritage rules from "Place", "Extent of Place", and
"Historic heritage Areas" to "Scheduled Buildings or Items", "Surrounds" and "Conservation
Areas".
6785-43
Heritage
heritage areas
Amend the Activity table to clearly identify the status of activities involving the Scheduled Item
(Place) and the surrounds (Heritage Extent).
6785-44
Heritage
heritage areas
Amend the Activity table to clarify that development outside the identified surrounds (Heritage
Extent) is a Permitted Activity.
6785-45
Heritage
heritage areas
Amend the Activity table to distinguish between buildings where surrounds (Heritage Extent)
are excluded i.e. Category B and provide for works as a Permitted Activity.
6785-46
Heritage
heritage areas
Amend the Activity table by deleting the requirement for Controlled Activity consent for parts
of the building or surrounds listed as an exclusion and list these as a Permitted Activity.
6785-47
Heritage
heritage areas
Amend the Activity Table to clarify that works to a scheduled building that currently exceeds
the maximum height of the underlying zone are not considered a height infringement i.e.
workls on a spire.
6785-48
Heritage
heritage areas
Amend the Activity Table by deleting the non-complying activity status for subdivision of land
containing a scheduled historic heritage place.
6785-49
Heritage
heritage areas
Amend the Activity Table by changing the status of works involving seismic strengthening to
RC [Permitted Activity] and include permitted activity criteria.
6785-50
Heritage
heritage areas
Amend the Activity Table by providing for activities not otherwise provided for in the
underlying zone as Restricted Discretionary where it allows the adaptive reuse of scheduled
buildings.
433/1145
Sub#/
6785-51
Delete 2.1(c) Historic Heritage - Development Controls, as follws: The maintenance and
repair of buildings identified as a primary feature in the schedule of historic heritage places
must: c. not involve the use of scaffolding affixed to the building or structure , or alternatively
provide permitted activity standards where affixing scaffolding would be permitted.
6785-52
control
Delete 3.6 Special Character Pre 1944 Demolition Control, or amend to address concerns
relating to the imbalanced approach to private property rights, encouragement of investment,
retention of land values, avoiding significant costs on the public, the practicality and cost of
any necessary rehabilitation or the inability to achieve reasonable amenity for occupants and
reasonable compliance with any requirement of the Building Act. Refer to pg. 9/9 of the
6786-1 William M Kinsella mikekinsella@xtra.co.nz RPS Mana Whenua B5 Strategic
governance or authority to any section of the community that has not been democratically
elected
6787-1
RSCJ Trust (Religious of the
Society of the Sacred Heart)
and Baradene College of the
Sacred Heart matt@rms.co.nz RPS Urban growth B2.7 Social infrastructure
Add an Objective that clearly articulates the importance of education facilities and the need for
the expansion of present infrastructure facilities notwithstanding there may be unavoidable
minor impacts on adjacent land uses.
6787-2
Sacred Heart matt@rms.co.nz
policies
Amend Objective 3 to read: "Potential adverse effects of schools, community facilities and
associated activities and their use in adjacent areas are mitigated to the extent that it is
practicable to do so having regard to the importance of the school to the wider community".
6787-3
policies
Amend Policy 6 to read: 6. "Recognise the efficient utilisation of finite infrastructure and
manage the scale, intensity, frequency and hours of operation of community use of school
land, buildings and related infrastructure accordingly".
6787-4
shafts survey coordinates Delete Volcanic Viewshaft H7.
6787-5
shafts survey coordinates Exclude Baradene College at 327 Victoria Ave, Remuera from Volcanic Viewshaft H7.
6787-6
Assess any new buildings infringing Volcanic Viewshaft H7 as a Restricted Discretionary
activity with targetted assessment criteria.
6787-7
Exclude Baradene College at 327 Victoria Ave, Remuera from any presumption of notification
associated with buildings exceeding the height of Volcanic Viewshaft H7.
6787-8
Sacred Heart matt@rms.co.nz Trees
Trees
Notable Trees
Delete reference to Kawaka Trees as a Notable Tree under ID Schedule 194, on the
Baradene College site at 327 Victoria Ave, Remuera.
6787-9
Sacred Heart matt@rms.co.nz Trees
Trees
Notable Trees
Define more precisely the location of the scheduled Morton Bay Chestnut on the
Baradene College site at 327 Victoria Ave, Remuera.
6787-10
Sacred Heart matt@rms.co.nz Historic Heritage (Overlay)
Heritage
Places
Restate Schedule ID 01897 as "Mitchelson House, Stables and Duchesne Building -
Baradene College".
6787-11
Sacred Heart matt@rms.co.nz Historic Heritage (Overlay)
Heritage
Places
Reduce the extent of the delineated Extent of Place for Schedule ID 01897, by taking into
consideration the topography and other site matters that allow development and land use
which will not detract from the values of the historic heritage features.
6787-12
I23.2-3 Land use &
Retain provisions that provide for increased building and land use flexibility for Baradene
College (327 Victoria Ave, Remuera) through building bulk and location controls.
434/1145
Sub#/
6787-13
Purpose) D8.9/I23 School I23.1 Activity table Include 'Recreation facilities and associated carparking" as a permitted activity.
6788-1 Mary R Botica mary.botica@thomsonreuters.com General Miscellaneous Other Adopt the relief sought in the submission by Herne Bay Residents Association Incorporated.
6789-1 Mervyn R File mvfile@slingshot.co.nz Designations
Agency
Widening - Kumeu/Huapai Retain designation.
6789-2 Mervyn R File mvfile@slingshot.co.nz General Miscellaneous
Operational/
Projects/Acquisition Retain Farrand Road, Kumeu as a no exit road.
6790-1 George - Evans leebarry@clear.net.nz RPS Changes to the RUB North and Waiheke Island Rezone 360 and 198 Sandspit Road, Warkworth from Mixed Rural to Future Urban.
6791-1 Alec Hawke daniel.clay@minterellison.co.nz Zoning South
Rezone land on Urquharts Peninsula (NA17C/1398 Lot 1 DP 58566) from Rural Coastal to
Mori Purpose.
6792-1 Vicki-Ann File mvfile@slingshot.co.nz Designations
Agency
Widening - Kumeu/Huapai Retain designation.
6792-2 Vicki-Ann File mvfile@slingshot.co.nz General Miscellaneous
Operational/
Projects/Acquisition Retain Farrand Rd, Kumeu as a no through road.
6793-1
General Trust Board Common
Fund c.covington@harrisongrierson.com Zoning South Rezone 32 Waikopua Road, Whitford from Countryside Living to Cemetry Purposes.
6793-2
Fund c.covington@harrisongrierson.com Rural Zones General I13.1 Activity table Provide for cemetery activities as a Discretionary activity within the Countryside Living zone.
6793-3
Fund c.covington@harrisongrierson.com Zoning Central
Rezone 39, 43 and 45 Church Crescent Panmure from Mixed Housing Suburban to Mixed
Housing Urban zone.
6793-4
Fund c.covington@harrisongrierson.com Zoning Central
Rezone the area identified in the submission [Church Crescent, Panmure] from Mixed
Housing Suburban to Mixed Housing Urban zone. Refer to pg 2-3/4 of the submission for
details.
6794-1 Ross Barritt ross.barritt@gmail.com Precincts - North New Precincts Wairau Valley
Add a new precinct to Wairau Valley which is consistent with the North Shore City Council
Strategic Plan for the area.
6794-2 Ross Barritt ross.barritt@gmail.com Zoning North and Islands Rezone Wairau Valley from Light Industry to General Business.
6795-1
Warkworth Area Business
Association rachel@zestcomms.co.nz Future Urban
Clarify the effects of extensive use of the Future Urban zone within the RUB, as the provisions
are too restrictive to enable reasonable use of land when urban zoning could be 30 years
away.
6795-2
Association rachel@zestcomms.co.nz RPS Changes to the RUB North and Waiheke Island
Rezone land to the west of Hudson Rd, Warkworth, from Future Urban. Refer to map on p
32/34.
6795-3
Rezone land to the west of Morrison Drive and the east of Mason Heights, Warkworth, from
Future Urban. Refer to map on p 31/34.
6795-4
Rezone land to the west of Mansel Drive and north of Woodcocks Road, Warkworth, from
Future Urban to General Business. Refer to map on p 30/34.
6795-5
Association rachel@zestcomms.co.nz Zoning North and Islands
Rezone land at Glenmore and Morrison Drive, Warkworth, from Heavy Industry to Light
Industry. [note - land is already zoned Light Industry]
6795-6
Association rachel@zestcomms.co.nz General Chapter A Introduction A3 Strategic Framework
Give statutory weight to the Area Plan when it is completed, in a similar way that Structure
plans are currently included in the Operative Auckland Council District Plan (Rodney
Section).
6795-7
Association rachel@zestcomms.co.nz General Miscellaneous
Operational/
Provide a single integrated solution to traffic on and off SH1 and the proposed Puhoi to
Wellsford Motorway by providing suitable local roads, including; addressing the Hill St
intersection bottleneck, implementing double lanes on the Shoesmith Bridge; building the
Western Collector Road including Mansel Drive Bridge; and investigating a Matakana and
Sandspit Link Road.
6795-8
Association rachel@zestcomms.co.nz Designations G1.3 Designations
Create a tar sealing programme and funding for the upgrade of all gravel roads in the North
Rodney region over the next 10 years.
6795-9
Association rachel@zestcomms.co.nz General Miscellaneous
Operational/
Designate land for a Park-and-ride at an appropriate location in Warkworth, adjacent to the
planned motorway extension or SH1.
6795-10
Association rachel@zestcomms.co.nz Historic Heritage (Overlay)
Heritage
Places Retain the overlay over buildings in Warkworth.
6795-11
Association rachel@zestcomms.co.nz
control
Building demolition control J.3.6 Rules and mapping Delete the control as it applies in Warkworth.
6795-12
Association rachel@zestcomms.co.nz Mana Whenua General provisions
assessment
Amend the overlay so that the requirements for a cultural impact assessment or extent of
consultation are determined by the planner assessing the application, with reference to well
written and robust assessment criteria.
6795-13
Association rachel@zestcomms.co.nz Natural Hazards and Flooding Natural Hazards Coastal inundation - maps only Delete the overlay affecting Warkworth township.
6795-14
Association rachel@zestcomms.co.nz General
GIS viewer Delete the flooding overlay affecting Warkworth township.
435/1145
Sub#/
6795-15
GIS viewer
Amend the overlay maps to accurately identify flood sensitive areas, flood plains, overland
flow paths or flood prone areas.
6795-16
GIS viewer Amend the overlay maps to accurately identify flood prone areas.
6795-17
Association rachel@zestcomms.co.nz Natural Hazards and Flooding Natural Hazards
and policies
Delete the provisions relating to coastal inundation unless it can be demonstrated by a
detailed S32 analysis that application of rules is necessary to manage a resource
management issue.
6795-18
Association rachel@zestcomms.co.nz Natural Hazards and Flooding Flooding
and policies
Delete the provisions relating to flood prone areas unless it can be demonstrated by a
detailed S32 analysis that application of rules is necessary to manage a resource
management issue
6795-19
Association rachel@zestcomms.co.nz Natural Hazards and Flooding Flooding H4.12 Rules
Delete the requirements for a resource consent where the building consent process will
manage the flooding hazard.
6795-20
Amend the activity status of development in flood prone areas from non-complying or
discretionary, to restricted discretionary.
6795-21
Add performance standards and a requirement for a flood hazard assessment to enable the
activity status of development in a flood prone area to be permitted.
6795-22
Association rachel@zestcomms.co.nz Natural Hazards and Flooding Flooding
and policies
Use flood prone information only to warn property owners of potential flood hazard, or for
more investigation to be done to ensure proper operation of stormwater systems, not to
control activities or development within these areas. [p 9/34]
6795-23
Association rachel@zestcomms.co.nz Water Stormwater H4.14 Introduction
Delete all rules and revert to those in the Regional Land, Air and Water Plan or the Operative
District Plan (Rodney Section).
6795-24
Association rachel@zestcomms.co.nz Definitions Existing Delete 'Land which may be subject to natural hazards'.
6795-25
Association rachel@zestcomms.co.nz Definitions Existing
Amend 'Land which may be subject to natural hazards' by deleting the 4th bullet point 'any
natural hazard area identified in a Council natural hazard register/database or GIS viewer'.
6795-26
Association rachel@zestcomms.co.nz Definitions Existing
Amend the definitions of rivers, streams and watercourses to those used in the Regional Plan
and/or the Operative District Plan(Rodney section).
6795-27
Association rachel@zestcomms.co.nz
Centre) Business
Park zones Retain the Key Retail frontage overlay provisions.
6795-28
Association rachel@zestcomms.co.nz Public Open Space Zones Public Open Space
Recognise that new development cannot provide on-site carparking in Warkworth, and
implement other processes or initiatives that that will provide sufficient car parking for the
anticipated growth in the area.
6795-29
H6.5)
Retain the activity allowing temporary activities in public places, for up to five consecutive
days, as a permitted activity.
6795-30
H6.5)
Amend the activity allowing temporary activities in public places, for up to five consecutive
days, so that the consenting trigger is where a temporary activity in a public place requires the
dominant use of the public space.
6796-1 Wisimca Company Limited deanne@mhg.co.nz Definitions Existing Amend definition of 'height' to include average ground level as a means to calculate height.
6796-2 Wisimca Company Limited deanne@mhg.co.nz General Cross plan matters Remove the maximum storey control in all zones.
6796-3 Wisimca Company Limited deanne@mhg.co.nz Trees
Trees
Notable Trees Remove Eucalyptus tree (No 53) from 167 Jervois Road, Herne Bay.
6796-4 Wisimca Company Limited deanne@mhg.co.nz General Chapter G General provisions
6796-5 Wisimca Company Limited deanne@mhg.co.nz Mana Whenua General provisions
assessment
Iwi may be required.
6796-6 Wisimca Company Limited deanne@mhg.co.nz Sustainable Development C7.7/H6.4 Sustainable design
Building Challenge.
6796-7 Wisimca Company Limited deanne@mhg.co.nz Sustainable Development C7.7/H6.4 Sustainable design Delete the requirement to provide affordable housing.
6796-8 Wisimca Company Limited deanne@mhg.co.nz
Centre) Business
Special information
requirements
is provided over public space.
6796-9 Wisimca Company Limited deanne@mhg.co.nz
Centre) Business
Park zones Remove the floor to floor/ceiling height minimums in all zones.
6797-1
Castor Bay/ Milford Cliffside
Owners Group stewartrundle@ihug.co.nz
SEAs
Land Remove all reference to SEA between Castor Bay and Milford.
6798-1 Fiona Murray drfi@hotmail.com Mana Whenua
Whenua
and policies Reject 'sites of significance'.
436/1145
Sub#/
6799-1
Te Atatu Peninsula Business
Association tcm@thedawn.net.nz Precincts - West New Precincts Add the provisions of the existing Te Atatu Town Centre concept plan to the PAUP.
6800-1 Brian Hughes jeni@hughesconstruction.co.nz RPS Mana Whenua B5 Strategic Delete section 5, particularly sections B5.2, B5.2, B5.4, E5.1 and E5.2.
6800-2 Brian Hughes jeni@hughesconstruction.co.nz Mana Whenua General provisions
assessment
Reject provisions where the PAUP requires individuals to require a consent, report or pay
fees to Mori 'Iwi' so that they can undertake construction activities of any kind of private
land.
6800-3 Brian Hughes jeni@hughesconstruction.co.nz RPS Urban growth
Retain rationalisation of rules and opening up areas for sensible controlled intensification on
residential properties.
6801-1 Joshua K Rumble josh.rumble@gmail.com Residential zones Residential Activity Table
Amend the activity status of boarding houses up to 200m2 gross floor area and larger
boarding houses over 200m2 gross floor area to Non-complying in the Single House and
Mixed Housing Suburban zones.
6802-1 Graeme Hammonds gehammonds@xtra.co.nz General Miscellaneous Consultation and engagement Make the PAUP shorter and less cumbersome for most individuals to read.
6802-2 Graeme Hammonds gehammonds@xtra.co.nz Definitions New Add a definition for what a community is.
6802-3 Graeme Hammonds gehammonds@xtra.co.nz General Miscellaneous Consultation and engagement
Include a process that empowers communities and enables them to make decisions
on their futures when it comes to planning.
6802-4 Graeme Hammonds gehammonds@xtra.co.nz General Miscellaneous Special housing areas
Seek that adjoining landowners are notified regarding development of the Special Housing
Area in Kumeu.
6802-5 Graeme Hammonds gehammonds@xtra.co.nz RPS Changes to the RUB West Rezone 100 Station Road, Kumeu from Future Urban to a mixed residential zone.
6802-6 Graeme Hammonds gehammonds@xtra.co.nz RPS Changes to the RUB West
Rezone the south west side of Station Road, Kumeu from Future Urban to a mixed residential
zone.
6802-7 Graeme Hammonds gehammonds@xtra.co.nz Future Urban
Amend the provisions of the Future Urban zone so that it is a staged zone that indicates the
timeframe of expected development on particular land.
6802-8 Graeme Hammonds gehammonds@xtra.co.nz General Miscellaneous Other Delete provisions that seek to tax property based on land value uplift from rezoning.
6802-9 Graeme Hammonds gehammonds@xtra.co.nz Future Urban I5 Rules
Amend the prohibited activity status for urban development in the Future Urban zone to non-
complying or discretionary.
6803-1 Laidlaw College Incorporated
Private Bag 93104, Henderson,
Auckland 0650 Precincts - West Lincoln Retain the concept of the Lincoln Sub Precinct A.
Auckland 0650 Precincts - West Lincoln
Amend the areas covered by Lincoln Sub Precinct A and Sub Precinct B to that shown on the
plan attached to the submission. [No plan attached].
Amend K7.5.1 Activity Table for the Lincoln Precinct A to provide for tertiary education
facilities as a Permitted Activity.
Amend K7.5.1 Activity Table for the Lincoln Precinct A to provide for the same ramngte of
activities and status as in the Light Industrial zone, in addition to the education and college
related activities.
Auckland 0650
Centre) Business
zones
Apply the same rules that currently apply to sites adjacent to Laidlaw College, Henderson, in
the Operative Plan.
6804-1 Brent Rees kiwirees@ihug.co.nz Mineral extraction
Transport Route Remove the transport corridor on Twilight Road, Brookby.
6804-2 Brent Rees kiwirees@ihug.co.nz RPS Rural B8.3 Rural subdivision Protect areas of Brookby through a greenbelt or alternative zoning.
6805-1
Property Investment
Partnership bdemler@xtra.co.nz Zoning North and Islands
Rezone land in the Wairau Rd area, Wairau Valley [indicated on page 5/6 of submission]
from Light Industry to General Business and Mixed Use.
6806-1 Mary Hammonds mjhammonds@hotmail.com RPS Urban growth
land for urban development Ensure that infrastructure is put in place prior to housing completion.
6806-2 Mary Hammonds mjhammonds@hotmail.com General Miscellaneous
Operational/
Projects/Acquisition Construct curbing on all roads within the urban area.
Operational/
Projects/Acquisition Add off road footpaths suitable for walking and riding.
Operational/
Projects/Acquisition Provide a dedicated horse trail.
6806-5 Mary Hammonds mjhammonds@hotmail.com General Miscellaneous Consultation and engagement
Include the existing community in the design and development process for Kumeu
to ensure that development reflects the history, needs and desires of the existing population.
6806-6 Mary Hammonds mjhammonds@hotmail.com RPS Urban growth
quality compact urban form Prevent ribbon development in the industrial and retail area of Kumeu.
6806-7 Mary Hammonds mjhammonds@hotmail.com General Miscellaneous Development contributions Ensure the contributions collected from development be spent within Kumeu.
6806-8 Mary Hammonds mjhammonds@hotmail.com Water
streams & wetland
C5.14 Background &
Objectives Remove existing pollution from the Kumeu River.
6806-9 Mary Hammonds mjhammonds@hotmail.com RPS Changes to the RUB West Rezone 100 Station Road, Kumeu from Future Urban to a live residential zone.
6807-1 Nicolas Reid nicolas.reid@gmail.com Residential zones Residential
Terrace Housing and
Delete rule 5.7(3) 'Outdoor living space' which requires a balcony or terrace that is directly
accessible from the principal living room. See page 2/3 of the submission.
437/1145
Sub#/
6808-1 David and Edwina Russell d.e.russell@xtra.co.nz Mana Whenua
Whenua
and policies
Reject changes to rules regarding Mori sites, particularly at 337B Clarks Beach Road, Waiau
Pa.
6809-1
Mount Eden Village Business
Association admin@mounteden.co.nz RPS
features Retain the volcanic viewshafts and prevent them being breached by buildings.
6809-2
Association admin@mounteden.co.nz
shafts survey coordinates Support the height sensitive area overlay across Mt Eden Local centre.
6809-3
Association admin@mounteden.co.nz Zoning Central
Ensure that the Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings zone does not apply around the
Valley Road Local centre.
6809-4
Association admin@mounteden.co.nz Zoning Central
Ensure that the Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings zone does not apply around the Mt
Eden Local centre.
6809-5
Association admin@mounteden.co.nz Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
Add a minimum car parking requirement for development of existing commercial sites within
and around the Mt Eden Local centre.
6809-6
Association admin@mounteden.co.nz Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
Add a minimum car parking requirement for significant alterations or redevelopment of
existing buildings located within the Mt Eden Local centre and the area zoned Mixed Use
around it.
6810-1 Ross Gillespie
74 Glen Brook Road, Omiha,
Amend criteria for public notification to be clear, appropriate and actioned, with less council
discretion before notification.
Auckland 1081 General Miscellaneous Southern Hauraki Gulf Islands
Create a single planning structure for the Hauraki Gulf Islands that enhances the
environmental protection of this area.
Auckland 1081
the CMA Marina zone
objectives and policies Remove the Marina Zone from the inner islands of the Hauraki Gulf Marine Park.
Auckland 1081 Public Open Space Zones Public Open Space
Improve protection of open space, reserves and road reserves through vigilant compliance /
control over encroachments.
policies
Amend Residential zones to accommodate diverse living environments, for example in the
HGI.
Auckland 1081 General Miscellaneous Bylaws and Licensing
Require houseboat owners (e.g. on Waiheke) to pay an Annual Uniform Charge - rubbish,
roads, library use and keep their rubbish off adjacent reserves.
Auckland 1081
the CMA Discharges
Include rules that prevent sewage discharge from vessels within the Hauraki Gulf Marine
Park.
Auckland 1081
the CMA
discharges of contaminants I6.1.4 Activity table Require mangrove removal to be notifified.
Auckland 1081
the CMA
D5.1.14 Background,
objectives and policies Adopt a precautionary approach to aquaculture.
Auckland 1081 RPS Coastal
environment Protect Matiatia Bay from a Marina Development.
Auckland 1081 Earthworks H4.2.2 Controls Amend earthwork controls to be less permissive.
Auckland 1081
SEAs
Assessment Amend tree removal controls to be less permissive.
Auckland 1081 General Chapter G General provisions G2.4 Notification Require less Council discretion before public notification, especially large scale developments
Auckland 1081 General Eplan Update the M.H.W Springs on GIS viewer.
Auckland 1081 General Miscellaneous Southern Hauraki Gulf Islands No more gated subdivision on Waiheke.
Auckland 1081
organisms
modified organisms Take a precautionary approach to GMOs
Auckland 1081
Outstanding Natural
Rules
Outstanding Natural
Landscapes Protect the rural character of the eastern end of Waiheke.
6811-1 Warren E Crook alexis@maxnet.co.nz Zoning Coastal Remove the mooring zone from Wharf Road on Waiheke Island.
6811-2 Warren E Crook alexis@maxnet.co.nz
Amend the mooring zone for houseboats to charge a rate commensurate with the value of the
foreshore location, occupation of the CMA and the same benefits as other ratepayers.
438/1145
Sub#/
Amend the mooring zones at Putaki Bay, Kennedy Bay and Anzac Bay, Waiheke to ensure
they include all existing moorings and there is adequate water at low tide for all moorings in
the zone. See page 2/9 of the submission for detail.
controls
Amend 2(2)(f) 'discharge of untreated sewage from a vessel' to clarify the term about extreme
weather as this is relative to the size of the vessel.
controls Amend 2(2)(b) 'discharge of untreated sewage from a vessel' to remove the 2km limit.
6812-1 Michael W Ward icearch@ihug.co.nz RPS Changes to the RUB West Rezone 50 Freshfields Road, Waimauku from Mixed Rural to Single House.
6812-2 Michael W Ward icearch@ihug.co.nz RPS Changes to the RUB West
map on page 6/10 in the submission) from Rural Production to Future Urban (excluding 50
Freshfields Road, Waimauku).
6813-1 Ian and Margaret Hutchinson home@hc.co.nz Natural Hazards and Flooding Natural Hazards Coastal inundation - maps only
Delete the overlay maps until the mapping has been done using a suitable methodology that
enables the maps to be accurately applied on a property by property basis, particularly at
Point Wells.
6813-2 Ian and Margaret Hutchinson home@hc.co.nz General
GIS viewer
Delete the flooding maps until the mapping has been done using a suitable methodology that
enables the maps to be accurately applied on a property by property basis, particularly at
Point Wells.
6813-3 Ian and Margaret Hutchinson home@hc.co.nz Natural Hazards and Flooding Flooding H4.12 Rules
Amend the Activity Table to remove all Discretionary and Non-complying activity statuses and
replace with no more than a Restricted Discretionary activity status for all activities and
introduce appropriate performance standards and/or a requirement for a flood hazard
assessment.
6813-4 Ian and Margaret Hutchinson home@hc.co.nz Natural Hazards and Flooding Flooding H4.12 Rules Delete 'flood prone areas' and only use the 1% AEP floodplain for controlling building levels.
6813-5 Ian and Margaret Hutchinson home@hc.co.nz Water Stormwater
rules
Permit ground soakage and/or dispersal of stormwater from buildings and hardstand areas
within the Point Wells settlement.
H4.14.2 Stormwater
Delete all stormwater management provisions, particularly in relation to the overlap in the
controls between stormwater management flow and discharge, and revert to the Regional
Plan: Air, Land and Water and/or the Rodney District Plan in relation to Point Wells.
rules
Amend the stormwater rules to be less onerous and restrictive, including amending the
Activity Table so that all activities are either Permitted, Controlled or Restricted Discretionary.
rules
Permit discharge of stormwater from residential dwellings and associated hard surfaces in
Point Wells. See submission for further details [pages 5 and 7/7 of the submission].
6813-9 Ian and Margaret Hutchinson home@hc.co.nz Definitions Existing Amend the definition of 'Height' to include water towers.
6813-10 Ian and Margaret Hutchinson home@hc.co.nz Definitions Existing
Delete the definition of 'Land which may be subject to natural hazards', particularly the
provisions for using any natural hazard register, database or GIS viewer.
6813-11 Ian and Margaret Hutchinson home@hc.co.nz Definitions Existing
Delete definitions relating to rivers, streams and watercourses and use the definitions for the
Regional Plan [Air, Land, Water Plan], such as permanent and intermittent/ephemeral
streams.
6813-12 Ian and Margaret Hutchinson home@hc.co.nz Natural Hazards and Flooding Natural Hazards
and policies Delete all provisions relating to coastal inundation areas.
6813-13 Ian and Margaret Hutchinson home@hc.co.nz Natural Hazards and Flooding Natural Hazards
Assessment
Delete requirements for resource consents relation to inundation where the building consent
process will achieve the appropriate outcome.
6813-14 Ian and Margaret Hutchinson home@hc.co.nz Natural Hazards and Flooding Flooding H4.12 Rules
Delete requirements for resource consents relation to flooding where the building consent
process will achieve the appropriate outcome.
6814-1 Peter D Louw delville.wood@orcon.net.nz Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula
Develop sub-precinct F to a level of intensification that is commensurate with the surrounding
area and the development which existed previously on the site
objectives and policies Ensure development has a high quality of design in sub-precinct F
objectives and policies Protect and guarantee access to the heritage sites within sub-precinct F
objectives and policies Preserve existing trees and coastal vegetation in sub-precinct F
objectives and policies Ensure public access to the waterfront through Mary Barrett Glade in sub-precinct F
objectives and policies Protect the bay from run off during development of sub-precinct F
objectives and policies Ensure pedestrian access to all foreshores within the precinct
Protect viewshafts to Rangitoto, North Head, Mt Victoria, One Tree Hill, Mt Eden and the CBD
from the public areas of Ngataringa Road
6814-9 Peter D Louw delville.wood@orcon.net.nz Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula K5.11 Precinct rules
Limit development to two stories and apply the density and height in relation to boundary
controls of surrounding zone, in sub-precinct F
6814-10 Peter D Louw delville.wood@orcon.net.nz Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Mapping Amend sub-precinct F to match the natural contours of the land
439/1145
Sub#/
Retain or increase the current height to boundary rules along the Ngataringa Road boundary
of sub-precinct F
6814-12 Peter D Louw delville.wood@orcon.net.nz Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula K5.11 Precinct rules Amend [building] coverage control to 40% in sub-precinct F
6814-13 Peter D Louw delville.wood@orcon.net.nz Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula K5.11 Precinct rules Retain density of one dwelling per 400m
2
in sub-precinct F
objectives and policies Restrict the amount of soil that can be removed when developing land in sub-precinct F
objectives and policies Restrict access to sub-precinct F to Wakakura Crescent, not Ngataringa Rd
Make Wakakura Crescent, Devonport a one way road to remove congestion around the Lake
Rd intersection
Request that development of former Navy housing sites, Devonport requires a traffic impact
study
objectives and policies Commission a study of infrastructure capacity in Devenport prior to development of precinct
6814-19 Peter D Louw delville.wood@orcon.net.nz General Miscellaneous Special housing areas Reject special housing areas on Devonport Peninsula
6814-20 Peter D Louw delville.wood@orcon.net.nz Residential zones Residential
General
Delete provision for developments which infringe less than three development controls to be
considered as Restricted Discretionary Activities and which do not need neighbours consent.
6814-21 Peter D Louw delville.wood@orcon.net.nz General Miscellaneous Other
Support the Auckland 2040 submission on notification of development that infringes less than
3 development controls
6814-22 Peter D Louw delville.wood@orcon.net.nz General Chapter A Introduction
tools Request that precincts only be applied following public consultation and due process
6815-1 Uptown Business Association rose@mhg.co.nz Zoning Central
Rezone the block bounded by Boston Road, Nugent St, Khyber Pass and Auburn St, Grafton,
so that it is all Mixed Use zone. [the southern portion of the block is currently Light Industry]
6815-2 Uptown Business Association rose@mhg.co.nz Zoning Central
Rezone the blocks bounded by Boston Road, Auburn St and Khyber Pass, Grafton, to Mixed
Use zone. [currently a mixture of Mixed Use, Light Industry and Strategic Transport zones]
6815-3 Uptown Business Association rose@mhg.co.nz Definitions Existing
Amend 'Height' so that the definition includes 'the vertical distance between the highest part of
the building and the average level of the ground at the external foundations of the buildings',
as defined in Part 13 of the Auckland Council District Plan (Isthmus Section).
6815-4 Uptown Business Association rose@mhg.co.nz Built Environment (Overlays)
Height Control
Amend the height of all sites zoned Mixed Use around the Newton/Upper Symonds St Town
Centre, to 32.5m, particularly the sites located between Symonds St and Ian McKinnon Drive.
6815-5 Uptown Business Association rose@mhg.co.nz
Centre)
Maps only
Retain the application of the Key Retail Frontage overlay in the Newton/Upper Symonds St
Town centre and on the sites fronting Symonds St.
6815-6 Uptown Business Association rose@mhg.co.nz Transport Auckland -wide
requirements Retain the parking and loading ratios for sites subject to the Key Retail Frontage overlay.
6815-7 Uptown Business Association rose@mhg.co.nz
Centre) Business
Special information
requirements
Delete the requirement for a wind report for buildings higher than 20m, where a canopy is
provided over public spaces or the site is a rear site.
6815-8 Uptown Business Association rose@mhg.co.nz General Chapter G General provisions
Delete the provision [infer in 1.4 Applying for resource consent] that enables processing
planners to consider policies or criteria outside of the listed assessment criteria.
6815-9 Uptown Business Association rose@mhg.co.nz General Chapter G General provisions
statements Delete the requirement to provide a design statement. [infer 10(2)]
6815-10 Uptown Business Association rose@mhg.co.nz Mana Whenua General provisions
assessment
Refine the circumstances under with a Cultural Impact Assessment and engagement with Iwi
may be required.
6815-11 Uptown Business Association rose@mhg.co.nz Sustainable Development C7.7/H6.4 Sustainable design
Building challenge.
6815-12 Uptown Business Association rose@mhg.co.nz Residential zones Housing affordability H6.6 Rules Delete the requirement to provide affordable housing.
6816-1 Allan and Margaretha Cooper am.cooper12@gmail.com General Miscellaneous Other Adopt the relief sought by Herne Bay Residents Association Incorporated.
6817-1 Waiheke Airfield Limited berin@isleland.co.nz General Miscellaneous Southern Hauraki Gulf Islands
Amend the Overlay Description to include reference to Waiheke and Great Barrier Islands [as
set out on page 3/6 of submission].
Amend Policy 2 to add reference to Claris and Okiwi designations [as set out on page 3/6 of
submission].
Amend the airfield approach path overlay mapping and associated building controls to protect
the Waiheke Island Aerodome [view Height Restrictions Map, page 6/6 of submission].
Include the airfield approach path mapping and associated controls and conditions for the
protection, management and operation of Auckland Council's Claris and Okiwi airfields in Part
7: Designations.
440/1145
Sub#/
6818-1 Martina Johnson
84 Tarrant Road, RD2, Helensville,
area Allow for subdivision of marginal land with SEAs.
6818-2 Martina Johnson
84 Tarrant Road, RD2, Helensville,
area Reduce the buffer zone from 10m to 3m.
6819-1 Steve Eyles steve@allianceprint.co.nz General Miscellaneous
Operational/
Projects/Acquisition Restore the St James Theatre
6820-1 Scott K Turner scott@business-iq.co.nz Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula K5.11 Precinct rules
Reject zoning of precinct zones 1, 2 and 4 and reject those in other zones [inferred to relate to
Devonport Peninsula precinct which has sub-precincts A-F].
6820-2 Scott K Turner scott@business-iq.co.nz Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula K5.11 Precinct rules Delete precinct.
6820-3 Scott K Turner scott@business-iq.co.nz Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula K5.11 Precinct rules
Amend height to 8m for all buildings unless there is a setback of at least 60m from all other
property or public open spaces.
6821-1 Gregory C Shaw gcsdev@hotmail.com Public Open Space Zones Public Open Space D2 Introduction
Require more Rural Conservation and Public Open space zones in the urban areas of
Rodney.
6822-1 521 Lake Road Limited c.covington@harrisongrierson.com Sustainable Development C7.7/H6.4 Sustainable design
Delete Policy 1 as follows; 'Require medium and large-scale office and industrial buildings to
be designed to meet sustainable building standards .'.
6822-2 521 Lake Road Limited c.covington@harrisongrierson.com Sustainable Development C7.7/H6.4 Sustainable design
Delete Policy 2 as follows; 'Require medium to large-scale residential development to be
designed to meet sustainable building standards. '.
6822-3 521 Lake Road Limited c.covington@harrisongrierson.com Sustainable Development C7.7/H6.4 Sustainable design Delete the sustainable development objectives, policies and rules.
6822-4 521 Lake Road Limited c.covington@harrisongrierson.com Residential zones Housing affordability
and policies
Delete Policy 2 about providing for affordable housing throughout the development.
[submission says 7.7 but infer 7.8]
6822-5 521 Lake Road Limited c.covington@harrisongrierson.com Residential zones Housing affordability H6.6 Rules Delete or comprehensively reconsider rule 1.2 Location of retained affordable housing.
6822-6 521 Lake Road Limited c.covington@harrisongrierson.com Residential zones Housing affordability H6.6 Rules Delete or comprehensively reconsider rule 1.3 Securing retained affordable housing.
6822-7 521 Lake Road Limited c.covington@harrisongrierson.com Residential zones Housing affordability H6.6 Rules Delete or comprehensively reconsider rule 1.4 Eligibility for retained affordable housing.
6822-8 521 Lake Road Limited c.covington@harrisongrierson.com Mana Whenua General provisions
assessment
Amend the rules and information requirement about Cultural Impact Assessments to provide a
more defined list of situations where a cultural impact assessment is required.
6822-9 521 Lake Road Limited c.covington@harrisongrierson.com
Centre) Business
Park zones
Delete the development controls relating to the Key Retail Frontages and prepare a
comprehensive set of specific assessment criteria.
6822-10 521 Lake Road Limited c.covington@harrisongrierson.com Subdivision Auckland-wide - Rural zones
area
Amend the threshold for the number of lots before a design statement is required, from 1 to
10 lots.
6823-1 Thelma A Phillips
140 Avondale Road, Avondale,
Auckland 1026 General Whole Plan Seek complete revision of PAUP.
Auckland 1026 General Chapter A Introduction
Plan Seek clarity of the PAUP as cannot understand it.
quality compact urban form Delete all infill building and high rise.
6824-1
New Zealand Residential
Investment Trust Limited c.covington@harrisongrierson.com Zoning Central Retain 63 Howard Hunter Ave, St Johns, as Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings zone.
6824-2
Investment Trust Limited c.covington@harrisongrierson.com Water Stormwater
H4.14.2 Stormwater
Amend the SMAF rules so they only apply where the development or addition of impervious
area to an existing development results in an infringement to the impervious area controls of
the underlying zones.
6824-3
Investment Trust Limited c.covington@harrisongrierson.com Zoning Central Retain 66 Merton Road, St Johns, as Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings zone.
6824-4
Investment Trust Limited c.covington@harrisongrierson.com Zoning Central
Rezone 298 St Johns Rd, St Johns, from Mixed Housing Suburban to Terrace Housing and
6824-5
Rezone sites along St Johns Road [near 298 St Johns Road, St Johns], from Mixed Housing
Suburban to Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings zone. Refer to map in submission on
p 8/16.
6824-6
Rezone 364 St Johns Road, St Johns, from Mixed Housing Suburban to Terrace Housing and
6824-7
Rezone sites along St Johns Road [near 364 St Johns Road, St Johns], from Mixed Housing
Suburban to Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings zone. Refer to map in submission on
p 13/16.
6824-8
Rezone 293 Kepa Rd, Mission Bay, from Mixed Housing Suburban to Neighbourhood Centre.

6825-1
The Outdoor Media
Association of New Zealand
(OMANZ) akirkbymcleod@bentley.co.nz General C7.4/H6.3 Signs Retain regulation of billboards within PAUP rather than using bylaw controls.
6825-2
The Outdoor Media
(OMANZ) akirkbymcleod@bentley.co.nz General C7.4/H6.3 Signs Retain recognised importance of signage and expected effects.
441/1145
Sub#/
6825-3
The Outdoor Media
(OMANZ) akirkbymcleod@bentley.co.nz General C7.4/H6.3 Signs
Continue to make no distinction between variable image billboards and billboards which
display static images.
6825-4
The Outdoor Media
(OMANZ) akirkbymcleod@bentley.co.nz General C7.4/H6.3 Signs Retain provisions for alterations to existing billboards.
6825-5
The Outdoor Media
Retain the incorporation of appropriate development control standards that generally reflect
the most recent developments in outdoor media technology.
6825-6
The Outdoor Media
Retain the provision of appropriate assessment criteria for restricted discretionary activities
which limit consideration to the relevant effects of amenity, traffic, safety and cumulative
effects.
6825-7
The Outdoor Media
(OMANZ) akirkbymcleod@bentley.co.nz Definitions Existing
Amend definition of sign as follows: A visual device which can be seen from a public place
(including the coastal marine area) or an adjoining property, to attract peoples attention by: ...
- advertising products, businesses, services, events or activities (including Billboard Signs). ...
6825-8
The Outdoor Media
(OMANZ) akirkbymcleod@bentley.co.nz Definitions Existing
Amend definition of Sign height as follows: The distance from the lowest point of the sign to
the highest point of the sign. In the case of a free standing billboard-sign, height means either:
it is - the distance from ground level immediately below any point of the billboard-sign to the
top of the billboard-sign immediately above that point; or - the distance between the highest
part of the billboard-sign and the average level of the ground on which the billboard-sign is
located.
6825-9
The Outdoor Media
(OMANZ) akirkbymcleod@bentley.co.nz General Editorial and Part 6
Amend annotation of provisions for both objectives and policies (Chapter 7.4 Signs) as
follows: [rcp/rp dp]
6825-10
The Outdoor Media
Amend Objective 1 as follows: The role of signs in the identification of places, buildings and
businesses and the advertising of goods and services is recognised and provided for.
6825-11
The Outdoor Media
Amend Objective 2 as follows: The adverse effects of signs on traffic and pedestrian safety
and the visual amenity of surrounding environments are avoided, remedied or mitigated.
6825-12
The Outdoor Media
(OMANZ) akirkbymcleod@bentley.co.nz General C7.4/H6.3 Signs Delete Policy 7.
6825-13
The Outdoor Media
Add a new Permitted activity rule as follows: Existing billboards that were lawfully established
as at [date of Unitary Plan notification], including their repair and maintenance, are a
permitted activity, provided they comply with the conditions of the authorisation under which
they were lawfully established,
6825-14
The Outdoor Media
Amend Activity Table Rule 1(b) as follows: The alteration or moving of an existing lawfully
established billboard on a site where the use of billboards in that zone is not provided for as a
permitted activity and where that change does not increase its size overall display area or its
non-compliance with the development controls below.
6825-15
The Outdoor Media
(OMANZ) akirkbymcleod@bentley.co.nz General C7.4/H6.3 Signs Delete Activity Table rule 1(d).
6825-16
The Outdoor Media
Amend Activity Table 1(1) to provide for billboard signs on street furniture in the road reserve
as a permitted activity.
6825-17
The Outdoor Media
Amend Development control [Free Standing Billboards] 2.1(r) as follows: The billboard must:
... not be displayed on any power pole, lighting pole, street furniture including but not limited
to: bollards, bus shelters, seats, rubbish bins, plant boxes, pylons and public signs or other
similar structures in a public place but excluding bus shelters and phone booths
6825-18
The Outdoor Media
Amend Development control 2.1(b) as follows: not be placed within 30m of a site within a
residential zone, a residential precinct or public open space zonefrom which it can be seen
6825-19
The Outdoor Media
Amend Development control 2.1(e)(iv) as follows: not exceed an illuminance of 5000 cds/m
between dawn and dusk and 250 500cds/m between dusk and dawn if it is lit by a internal
means (e.g. a digital display/LED billboard)
6825-20
The Outdoor Media
Amend Development control 2.1(i) as follows: not extend more than 200mm 400mm from the
face of any building or structure to which it is attached
6825-21
The Outdoor Media
Amend Development control 2.1(l) as follows: when placed on a wall, not exceed an area
equal to 25 per cent of the wall area or 36m, whichever is the lesser
442/1145
Sub#/
6825-22
The Outdoor Media
(OMANZ) akirkbymcleod@bentley.co.nz General C7.4/H6.3 Signs Delete Development control 2.2(b).
6825-23
The Outdoor Media
(OMANZ) akirkbymcleod@bentley.co.nz General C7.4/H6.3 Signs Delete Development control 2.2(c)(i).
6825-24
The Outdoor Media
(OMANZ) akirkbymcleod@bentley.co.nz General C7.4/H6.3 Signs Delete Development control 2.3(c).
6825-25
The Outdoor Media
Amend Assessment - Restricted discretionary activities 3(2)(1)(a)(i) as follows: The sign or
billboard sign should ... the council will consider: - the scale, style and simplicity of the sign or
billboard sign and the images likely to be used ... - the length of time that the billboard will be
in place for.
6825-26
The Outdoor Media
Add a new assessment criterion as follows: Where attached to a street frontage wall of a
building located on a corner site, the sign or billboard should be located on that frontage which
adjoins the road with the lesser traffic function where available.
6825-27
The Outdoor Media
Amend Assessment - Restricted discretionary activities 3(2)(1)(c)(iii) as follows: The sign or
billboard signs location, operation, lighting and design should not adversely affect traffic
safety, in particular it should not: ... - use the colours red, green, orange, white or yellow
where this is likely to form the background or foreground to or appear alongside a traffic
control device of similar colour when viewed by approaching motorists...
6825-28
The Outdoor Media
Amend 3rd column heading within all activity tables as follows: Billboards on a side or real
wall of an existing building.
6825-29
The Outdoor Media
Amend 4th column heading within all activity tables as follows: Billboards on a street frontage
wall on an existing building.
6825-30
The Outdoor Media
Amend the activity status of 'Billboards on a street facing building facade' from Non-complying
to Discretionary in the Mixed Rural and Rural Coastal zones.
6825-31
The Outdoor Media
to Discretionary in the Public Open Space - Conservation zone.
6825-32
The Outdoor Media
to Discretionary in Public Open Space - Civic and Community zone.
6825-33
The Outdoor Media
Amend the activity status of 'All free standing billboards' from Discretionary to Restricted
Discretionary in the Mixed Use zone.
6825-34
The Outdoor Media
Amend the activity status of 'Billboards on a side or rear building facade' from Discretionary to
Restricted Discretionary in the Mixed Use zone.
6825-35
The Outdoor Media
Amend the activity status of 'Billboards on a street facing building facade' from Discretionary
to Restricted Discretionary in the Mixed Use zone.
6825-36
The Outdoor Media
Discretionary in the General Business zone.
6825-37
The Outdoor Media
to Restricted Discretionary in the General Business zone.
6825-38
The Outdoor Media
Discretionary in the Town Centre zone.
6825-39
The Outdoor Media
to Restricted Discretionary in the Town Centre zone.
6825-40
The Outdoor Media
Amend the activity status of 'All free standing billboards' from Non-complying to Restricted
Discretionary in the Metropolitan Centre zone.
6825-41
The Outdoor Media
Restricted Discretionary in the Metropolitan Centre zone.
443/1145
Sub#/
6825-42
The Outdoor Media
to Restricted Discretionary in the Metropolitan Centre zone.
6825-43
The Outdoor Media
Amend the activity status of 'All free standing billboards' from Restricted Discretionary to
Permitted in the Light Industry zone.
6825-44
The Outdoor Media
Amend the activity status of 'Billboards on a street facing building facade' from Restricted
Discretionary to Permitted in the Light Industry zone.
6825-45
The Outdoor Media
Amend the activity status of 'All free standing billboards' from Restricted Discretionary to
Permitted in the Heavy Industry zone.
6825-46
The Outdoor Media
to Discretionary in the Historic Character - Business overlay.
6825-47
The Outdoor Media
Discretionary in the City Centre zone (except the residential precincts.
6825-48
The Outdoor Media
Restricted Discretionary in the City Centre zone (except the residential precincts.
6825-49
The Outdoor Media
to Restricted Discretionary in the City Centre zone (except the residential precincts.
6825-50
The Outdoor Media
Discretionary in the Strategic Transport Corridor zone.
6825-51
The Outdoor Media
Restricted Discretionary in the Strategic Transport Corridor zone.
6825-52
The Outdoor Media
to Restricted Discretionary in the Strategic Transport Corridor zone.
6825-53
The Outdoor Media
Discretionary in the Airport zone.
6825-54
The Outdoor Media
Restricted Discretionary in the Airport zone.
6825-55
The Outdoor Media
to Restricted Discretionary in the Airport zone.
6825-56
The Outdoor Media
Amend the activity status of 'All free standing billboards' from Non-complying to Discretionary
in the Healthcare Facility zone.
6825-57
The Outdoor Media
Amend the activity status of 'Billboards on a side or rear building facade' from Non-complying
to Discretionary in the Healthcare Facility zone.
6825-58
The Outdoor Media
to Discretionary in the Healthcare Facility zone.
6825-59
The Outdoor Media
Amend the activity status of 'All free standing billboards' from Non-complying to Discretionary
in the School zone.
6825-60
The Outdoor Media
Amend the activity status of 'Billboards on a side or rear building facade' from Non-complying
to Discretionary in the School zone.
6825-61
The Outdoor Media
to Discretionary in the School zone.
6825-62
The Outdoor Media
to Discretionary in the Ferry Terminal zone.
444/1145
Sub#/
6825-63
The Outdoor Media
to Discretionary in the Marina zone.
6825-64
The Outdoor Media
to Discretionary in the Minor Port zone.
6826-1 Mark O'Kane and Family phil.stickney@boffamiskell.co.nz RPS Urban growth
quality compact urban form Retain the vision of Auckland as the world's most liveable city.
6826-2 Mark O'Kane and Family phil.stickney@boffamiskell.co.nz Zoning South
Review the proposed zonings patterns surrounding existing centres, such as Papakura and
particularly 520-536 Papakura-Clevedon Road, to enable a greater proportion of Auckland's
required growth to occur in closer proximity to existing centres and areas with existing
infrastructure.
6826-3 Mark O'Kane and Family phil.stickney@boffamiskell.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - Rural zones
zones only
Delete the Prohibited activity status of 'Any other subdivision not provided for in this table or in
the rural zones subdivision rules' and include appropriate provisions to enable the subdivision
of large properties within the Mixed Rural zone.
6826-4 Mark O'Kane and Family phil.stickney@boffamiskell.co.nz Zoning South
Rezone the area surrounding Ardmore School, particularly 520-536 Papakura-Clevedon
Road, Papakura, from Mixed Rural to Rural and Coastal Settlement.
6826-5 Mark O'Kane and Family phil.stickney@boffamiskell.co.nz
SEAs
Land Delete the SEA, ID 409, at 520-536 Papakura-Clevedon Road, Papakura.
6827-1
Ken Davis Architects and
Herriot and Melhuish:
Architecture Limited ken@hma.net.nz
Increase the volcanic viewshaft and height sensitive area height control of 8m over Devonport
Town Centre to between 12-16m.
6828-1 Marie Dyhrberg fiona@campbellbrown.co.nz Zoning Central Rezone 4 Picton St, Freemans Bay from Single House to Town Centre.
6828-2 Marie Dyhrberg fiona@campbellbrown.co.nz Zoning Central Retain Mixed Use zone at 88, 90, 92, 94 and 96 Franklin Road, Freemans Bay.
6828-3 Marie Dyhrberg fiona@campbellbrown.co.nz
control
Building demolition control J.3.6 Rules and mapping Delete the overlay at 88, 90, 92, 94 and 96 Franklin Road, Freemans Bay.
6829-1 Lincoln Brooke arch.outline@gmail.com Residential zones Residential
Terrace Housing and
Amend Rule 9.6.(1) [Minimum site width - Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings zone]
from 25m to 18m.
6830-1 Soil and Rock Consultants chrisw@soilandrock.co.nz Definitions Existing
Amend the definition of 'Earthworks' to exclude geotechnical invesitigation works, including
drilling of hand augerholes and machine boreholes.
6831-1 Judy Barfoot jbarfooj@gmail.com RPS
character and natural heritage B4.3.4 Biodiversity Retain the protection of trees in the PAUP but reject the blanket approach of SEAs.
6832-1 John Jones johnjonesnz@hotmail.com Subdivision Auckland-wide - Urban zones H5.2 3.1 Residential zones Amend the minimum subdivision site sizes from 800m2 to 600m2 on Herald Island
6833-1
Wairahi Bay Station Company
Limited wairahi@gmail.com Zoning Coastal
Amend the Mooring zone in Wairahi Bay to include two morrings (GY008 and GY007) by
either extending the existing Mooring zone or creating a separate small Mooring zone around
them.
6834-1 Peter Reid and Daniel Thomas fiona@campbellbrown.co.nz Zoning West
Rezone 377 and 379 West Coast Road, Glen Eden from Light Industry to Mixed Housing
Suburban or Single House
6835-1 Gail Boyes gwboyes@xnet.co.nz
SEAs
Land Remove SEA on 29 Cotterell Street, Leigh [inferred]
6836-1 Robyn Simcock simcockr@landcareresearch.co.nz RPS Coastal
quality Insert policies and actions to improve the quality of our harbours and their waterways
6836-2 Robyn Simcock simcockr@landcareresearch.co.nz
SEAs
and policies
Insert policies and actions to maintain and enhance the vegetation in streets, parks, civic
places, streams and in backyards
6836-3 Robyn Simcock simcockr@landcareresearch.co.nz RPS Natural resources
B6.3 Freshwater and
Geothermal Water Integrate the management of stormwater across the plan and treat stormwater as a resource
6836-4 Robyn Simcock simcockr@landcareresearch.co.nz Trees
Increase requirements to retain stormwater onsite across all development and all
infrastructure, particularly roads and highly impervious areas such as centres and industrial
areas
B6.3 Freshwater and
Geothermal Water
Amend [Policy 10] to provide for a decrease in stormwater flows to combined sewers by 25%,
rather than an increase
B6.3 Freshwater and
Geothermal Water
Apply [Policy 10] to the Large Lot, Rural and Coastal Settlement, Single House and Mixed
Housing Suburban zones to achieve zero stormwater discharges
6836-7 Robyn Simcock simcockr@landcareresearch.co.nz RPS Urban growth
2010
Replace the words 'must have regard to water sensitive design' to 'must explicitly identify how
WSD has been addressed and implemented'.
6836-8 Robyn Simcock simcockr@landcareresearch.co.nz Sustainable Development C7.7/H6.4 Sustainable design
Add new assessment criteria to insert specific water sensitive design components that reduce
stormwater discharge volume and increased detention and utilisation, particularly with respect
to landscaping.
6836-9 Robyn Simcock simcockr@landcareresearch.co.nz RPS
character and natural heritage B4.3.3 Trees and vegetation Apply the tree protection overlay to the entire central city and Orakei ward
445/1145
Sub#/
SEAs
table - Vegetation
roads
Require resource consent and an arborist assessment for trimming of more than 20% of the
crown of a tree within the coastal zone, 20m of a cliff edge or a riparian area
SEAs
and policies
Protect native vegetation in the North West Wildlife link from clearance from additional
lighting, culverts and roads
6836-12 Robyn Simcock simcockr@landcareresearch.co.nz Water
policies
Objectives
Insert an objective to develop a green factor rating similar to that adopted by Seattle. Refer to
page 4/5 of the submission
SEAs
and policies
Ensure mitigation of tree and vegetation removal so there is at least no net loss of vegetation
cover, or a net gain
policies
Objectives
Insert objective for Auckland Transport to decrease underlying impervious area by 5% before
2025 through footpath and road narrowing during road renovation
policies
Objectives
Insert objective for Auckland Transport to decrease total impervious surface by 10% before
2025 by increasing tree canopy covering roads/ footpaths
SEAs
and policies
Insert the following objective for Auckland Transport: Tree removal must be offset by tree
planting, with new trees having a minimum root volume (depending on species and spacing)
and identified catchment to minimise stress and maximise stormwater removal.
policies
Objectives
Insert the following objective: Auckland Transport to reduce stormwater runoff by 20% by
2025
6836-18 Robyn Simcock simcockr@landcareresearch.co.nz Water Stormwater
Expand SMAF-1 and SMAF-2 to include catchments with many streams and connectivity to
the sea, especially those with confined estuaries
6836-19 Robyn Simcock simcockr@landcareresearch.co.nz Water Stormwater
Management Area - flow Extend SMAF-1 to include Hobson Bay and associated catchment
6838-1
Albany Investment and
Development Limited c.covington@harrisongrierson.com Precincts - North Greenhithe
Amend the precinct so that 364 and 404 Upper Harbour Drive, Greenhithe, is located in sub-
precinct B rather than sub-precinct A.
6838-2
Albany Investment and
Development Limited c.covington@harrisongrierson.com
SEAs
Land
Amend SEA number 8355A [applying to 404 Upper Harbour Drive, Greenhithe] to incorporate
the subdivision layout attached to the submission, on p 4/4.
6839-1
Campbells Bay Community
Association
campbellsbaycommunityassoc@gma
il.com RPS Urban growth
quality compact urban form Retain intent of the PAUP to make Auckland the world's most liveable city.
6839-2
Association
recreation facilities Retain preservation development of public open spaces.
6839-3
Association
il.com Zoning North and Islands Retain Single House zone around Campbells Bay coastal and conservation areas.
6839-4
Association
quality compact urban form Retain need for increasing both the quality and quantity of housing capacity.
6839-5
Association
il.com Residential zones Residential
policies
Retain split of the Mixed Housing zone into two - Mixed Housing Urban and Mixed Housing
Suburban.
6839-6
Association
il.com General Miscellaneous Other Adopt the relief sought by Auckland 2040.
6839-7
Association
Provide infrastructure before intensification, particularly in Campbells Bay, such as transport,
sewerage and stormwater infrastructure. See submission for further details [pages 4 and 5/7
of the submission].
6839-8
Association
il.com RPS
Retain concept of 'Rapid and frequent service network' but implement it in terms of the
'Congestion Free Network'.
6839-9
Association
il.com General Miscellaneous Other
Implement a trial of a minibus service within Campbells Bay to allow effective access to the
Rapid and frequent service network.
6839-10
Association
Implement a policy shift where some of the tax revenue accumulated for roads can be
assigned to public transport.
6839-11
Association
il.com General Miscellaneous
Operational/
Ensure ratepayers are informed of Watercare's proposals and costings to provide sewage
treatment and potable water for the projected increase in population across the entire
Auckland region.
6839-12
Association
il.com General Miscellaneous Other Do not charge for consent applications for rainwater storage tanks.
6839-13
Association
il.com Residential zones Residential
General
Require rainwater storage tanks as compulsory for larger scale developments and large
homes that have 50% of more site coverage.
6839-14
Association
Require a development of a plan that outlines both identifiable sites for new education
resources and the capacity cap in relation to quality vs. quantity education.
446/1145
Sub#/
6839-15
Association
Operational/
Projects/Acquisition Upgrade public toilet facilities in Campbells Bay.
6839-16
Association
Operational/
Improve small-scale local facilities in Campbells Bay before intensification e.g social and
cultural facilities.
6839-17
Association
Ensure the cost of upgrading infrastructure is fairly shared by developers, taxpayers, users
and existing residents.
6839-18
Association
Ensure negative impacts of the population intensification in the PAUP on Centennial Park,
Campbells Bay, are minimised.
6839-19
Association
Undertake environmental controls and appropriate amendment of the RMA to ensure
compatibility with the Unitary Plan in order to avoid loophole developments defeating the
intent of the PAUP.
6839-20
Association
il.com Public Open Space Zones Public Open Space D2 Introduction
Retain strong protection of Campbell's Bay existing green spaces in perpetuity to preserve the
catchment's rich ecology and recreational values.
6839-21
Association
il.com
SEAs
Land Retain SEA at the main bush area at Centennial Park, Campbell's Bay.
6839-22
Association
il.com
SEAs
Land
Retain SEA at the gum plantation at the top end of the north branch of the Campbells Bay
stream, Campbell's Bay.
6839-23
Association
il.com
SEAs
Land Retain SEA at Wilcox bush in the north branch of Campbells Bay stream, Campbell's Bay.
6839-24
Association
il.com
SEAs
Land Retain SEA at the pohutakawa lined edge of the cliffs north of Kennedy Park, Campbell's Bay.
6839-25
Association
il.com
SEAs
Land Retain SEA at Campbells Bay School community forest.
6839-26
Association
il.com
SEAs
Land Retain SEA at bush/tree areas in the properties adjacent to Centennial Park, Campbell's Bay.
6839-27
Association
il.com
SEAs
Land
Add an SEA to the entire remaining area of crown reserve currently leased to Pupuke Golf
Club and the associated grass areas which include significant bush blocks which are part of
the North-West Wildlink.
6839-28
Association
il.com
SEAs
Land
Add an SEA to the gum plantation and its significant native understorey on the golf course 8th
fairway which is currently being restored [inferred to refer to Pupuke Golf Course].
6839-29
Association
il.com
SEAs
Land
Add an SEA to the gum plantation and its native understorey at the corner of East Coast
Road and Forrest Hill Road, Campbells Bay currently being restored.
6839-30
Association
il.com
SEAs
Land Add an SEA to the top of Park Rise Bush, Campbells Bay.
6839-31
Association
il.com
SEAs
Land Add an SEA to All Hallows Church Bush, Campbells Bay.
6839-32
Association
il.com
SEAs
Land Add an SEA to entire Campbells bay catchment stream network.
6839-33
Association
il.com
SEAs
Land
Add an SEA to the coastal kohekohe and puriri forest at the north end of Campbells Bay
beach.
6839-34
Association
il.com
SEAs
Land
Add an SEA to the beach and its current coastal and clifftop margins to 100m back from high
water, Campbells Bay.
6839-35
Association
il.com
SEAs
Land Add an SEA to Huntly Reserve, Campbells Bay.
6839-36
Association
il.com
SEAs
Land Add an SEA to Campbells Bay school playing fields.
6839-37
Association
il.com
SEAs
Land Add an SEA to Greville Reserve adjacent to Campbells Bay.
447/1145
Sub#/
6839-38
Association
il.com
SEAs
Land Add an SEA to the green land at the East Coast Road end of Kowhai Road, Campbells Bay.
6839-39
Association
il.com
the CMA
sch. 6.2 ONC/HNC 6.7 Coastal protection yard
Increase the coastal margin of 20m to 100m in Campbells Bay, with strong protection of
mature trees in this strip.
6839-40
Association
il.com
SEAs
Assessment
Include reference in the PAUP to the RPMS, NPPA and DOC pest plant lists and give
authority for the removal of invasive pest plants and trees without resource consent.
6839-41
Association
il.com RPS
character and natural heritage B4.3.3 Trees and vegetation Retain strong tree protection including development being sensitive to trees.
6839-42
Association
il.com Zoning North and Islands
Retain Mixed Housing zone at 218-220 Beach Road, Campbells Bay [Mixed Housing
Suburban].
6839-43
Association
Rezone 220 Beach Road, Campbells Bay to Public Open Space - Conservation and ensure
appropriate negotiation between Council and the Methodist Church of New Zealand.
6839-44
Association
il.com Zoning North and Islands Retain Single House around Centennial Park, Campbells Bay.
6839-45
Association
il.com Zoning North and Islands Rezone 131 and 139 Beach Road, Campbells Bay as Public Open Space - Conservation.
6839-46
Association
il.com
SEAs
Land Add an SEA to 131 and 139 Beach Road, Campbells Bay.
6839-47
Association
il.com Historic Heritage (Overlay)
Heritage
Places
Retain the state house adjacent to Kennedys Park, Campbells Bay as a heritage building to
be developed internally for appropriate community use.
6839-48
Association
Operational/
Retain gradual acquistion of land along the cliff top between Huntly Ave and Kennedy Park,
Campbells Bay to develop a coastal walkway.
6839-49
Association
Extend the pockets of Public Open Space - Conservation along with coast, and not just the
Coastal Protection Yard, to establish a continuous zone through Campbells Bay.
6840-1 John Penney thepenneypeople@gmail.com Mana Whenua General provisions
assessment
Delete iwi assessment of resource consents and retain Council as only body to administer
resource consents
6841-1 El Callao Limited iain@civitas.co.nz Residential zones Residential Land use controls
Retain the maximum density requirements for the Mixed Housing Suburban and Mixed
Housing Urban zones in Rule 3.1 'Maximum density'.
6841-2 El Callao Limited iain@civitas.co.nz Residential zones Residential Land use controls
Retain the no density approach for the Terrace Housing and Apartments Building zone in
Rule 3.1 'Maximum density'.
6841-3 El Callao Limited iain@civitas.co.nz Residential zones Residential
Mixed Housing Urban zone Retain Rule 8.2 'Building height' for the Mixed Housing Urban zone.
6841-4 El Callao Limited iain@civitas.co.nz Residential zones Residential
Terrace Housing and
Apartment Buildings zone Retain Rule 9.2 'Building height' for the Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings zone.
6841-5 El Callao Limited iain@civitas.co.nz
control
Building demolition control J.3.6 Rules and mapping Delete the overlay, particularly at 861-863 New North Road, Mt Albert.
6841-6 El Callao Limited iain@civitas.co.nz Zoning West
Retain the Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings zone at 4 Rathgar Road and the
adjacent properties on the corner of Rathgar Road and Swanson Road, Henderson. See
submission for a map of the area [page 13/38 of the submission].
6841-7 El Callao Limited iain@civitas.co.nz Water Stormwater
Delete the overlay, particularly at 4 Rathergar Road, Henderson and 184 Great North Road,
Henderson.
6841-8 El Callao Limited iain@civitas.co.nz Water Stormwater
H4.14.2 Stormwater
Amend the overlay to make the provisions more economically efficient, including exempting
sites discharging to ground, are connected to the public stormwater network where a network
discharge consent is in place or already have a site-specific stormwater discharge. See
submission for further details [page 17/38 of the submission].
6841-9 El Callao Limited iain@civitas.co.nz Zoning Central Retain the Town Centre zoning at 861-863 New North Road, Mt Albert.
6841-10 El Callao Limited iain@civitas.co.nz Built Environment (Overlays)
Height Control
Retain the additional zone height control of 16.5m/4 storeys for the Town Centre zone in Mt
Albert, particularly 861-863 New North Road, Mt Albert.
6841-11 El Callao Limited iain@civitas.co.nz Zoning West
Retain the Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings zone the land adjoining Great North
Road, to the south of the Glendene Local centre, particularly 184 Great North Road,
Henderson.
6842-1 Terry Read tgr@mrl.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - Urban zones H5.2 3.1 Residential zones
Amend the Rural and Coastal Settlement zone minimum lot size in the Hunua Village,
particularly 23 Lockwood Rd and 38 White Road to 2500m
2
. Refer to map on page 3/3 of the
submission
6843-1
Fairview Property Investments
Limited c.covington@harrisongrierson.com
SEAs
Land
Amend the area of SEA 8065 [applying to 9 Richard Hill Close, Fairview Heights] so that it
reflects the covenant over the native bush on the site. See map on p 4/4 of submission.
448/1145
Sub#/
6843-2
Fairview Property Investments
Limited c.covington@harrisongrierson.com Zoning North and Islands
Rezone 9 Richard Hill Close, Fairview Heights, so that the entire site is zoned Single House.
Currently it is a split zoning of Single House and Large Lot.
6845-1 Child Poverty Action Group hannahanderson@hotmail.com Residential zones Housing affordability
and policies
Include greater reference to the [housing affordability] objectives of the Auckland Plan and
adopt tangible measures to review whether the Plan is meeting these objectives
6845-2 Child Poverty Action Group hannahanderson@hotmail.com RPS Urban growth
Demonstrate that the compact city model can provide affordable housing with only 15% of the
city zoned for intensification
6845-3 Child Poverty Action Group hannahanderson@hotmail.com Residential zones Residential
Amend the rules in the Single House and Mixed Housing Suburban zones to allow for greater
intensification in these zones
6845-4 Child Poverty Action Group hannahanderson@hotmail.com Residential zones Residential Land use controls
Decrease the density controls in the Mixed Housing Suburban zone [to allow greater
intensification]
6845-5 Child Poverty Action Group hannahanderson@hotmail.com RPS Urban growth
Significantly increase the amount of Mixed Housing Urban and Terrace Housing and
Apartment Buildings zoned land
6846-1 Samantha Palmer samantha.palmer@simedarby.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - Rural zones
area
Amend activity status for boundary adjustments that meet the rules from discretionary to
area
Amend the rules for rural boundary adjustments and boundary relocations to remove: the
distinction between adjustments and relocations; the 10% threshold; the requirement for the
sites to comprise of Certificates of Title existing on the date of notification of the PAUP; the
once only restrictions and the restrictions relating to the ownership of the properties
area
Amend the requirement in Rule 2.3.3(2) Protection and enhancement of ecological values, to
assess and protect natural features when undertaking a boundary relocation
6846-4 Samantha Palmer samantha.palmer@simedarby.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - general
and policies Delete all the objectives, policies and rules relating to rural subdivision
6846-5 Samantha Palmer samantha.palmer@simedarby.co.nz Zoning North and Islands
Rezone all rural areas north of Auckland to reflect their productivity limitations as compared
with the elite and prime land south of Auckland
area
Provide subdivision to create new lots in rural area where land does not contain land with LUC
(Land Unit Capability) Class of 1 to 3. This could include bush protection, wetland protection
and land rehabilitation and enhancement planting subdivision as per Operative Rodney
District Plan. Allow creation of lots on sites containing the protected feature
area
Amend so that Transferable Site subdivision only applies to land with a LUC (Land Unit
Capability) class of 1 to 3. Revise the rules to provide more subdivision opportunity
6846-8 Samantha Palmer samantha.palmer@simedarby.co.nz Rural Zones General I13.2 Land use controls
Amend Rule 2.6 Dwellings to provide for minor household units (gross floor areas of less than
65m2) as per the Operative Rodney District Plan, as a restricted discretionary activity
6846-9 Samantha Palmer samantha.palmer@simedarby.co.nz Rural Zones General I13.2 Land use controls
Amend Rule 2.6 Dwellings to provide for second dwellings on a rural site of less than 40ha as
a restricted discretionary activity. Include similar assessment criteria as used for Minor
Household Units in the Operative Rodney District Plan
6846-10 Samantha Palmer samantha.palmer@simedarby.co.nz Rural Zones General I13.2 Land use controls Retain provisions for dwellings in Rule 2.6 Dwellings
zones only
Amend so that Any other subdivision not provided for in this table or in the rural zones
subdivision controls is a non-complying activity rather than a prohibited activity
area
Amend Table 9 to remove the prohibited activity status for boundary adjustments that exceed
10% of the site area. Change activity status to restricted discretionary or discretionary
area
Amend Rural zone subdivision rules for rural areas north of Auckland to provide for
subdivision to protect native bush, significant wetlands, significant enhancement planning or
significant land rehabilitation as per the Operative Rodney District Plan, as a discretionary
activity. Allow creation of sites on the land containing the protected feature
6846-14 Samantha Palmer samantha.palmer@simedarby.co.nz RPS Mana Whenua B5 Strategic Delete Mana Whenua sites
6847-1 Airedale Property Trust c.covington@harrisongrierson.com Zoning Central
Rezone the site at 223-227 Mt Eden Road, Mt Eden, from Retirement Village and Mixed
Housing Suburban, to Mixed Housing Urban.
6847-2 Airedale Property Trust c.covington@harrisongrierson.com Zoning Central
Rezone 233-237 Mt Eden Rd, Mt Eden, from Mixed Housing Suburban to Mixed Housing
Urban.
6847-3 Airedale Property Trust c.covington@harrisongrierson.com Zoning Central Rezone 2-4 Puka St, Mt Eden, from Mixed Housing Suburban to Mixed Housing Urban.
6847-4 Airedale Property Trust c.covington@harrisongrierson.com
control
Delete the overlay from 223-227 and 233-237 Mt Eden Rd, Mt Eden, and 2-4 Puka St, Mt
Eden. See map in submission on p 2/7.
449/1145
Sub#/
6847-5 Airedale Property Trust c.covington@harrisongrierson.com Special Character
& C
Isthmus
Delete the overlay from 223-227 and 233-237 Mt Eden Rd, Mt Eden, and 2-4 Puka St, Mt
Eden. See map in submission on p 2/7.
6847-6 Airedale Property Trust c.covington@harrisongrierson.com Zoning Central Retain the Retirement Village zone over 55-63 Allendale Rd, Mt Albert.
6847-7 Airedale Property Trust c.covington@harrisongrierson.com
control
Building demolition control J.3.6 Rules and mapping Remove the overlay from 98 and 100 Beach Haven Rd, Beach Haven.
6848-1 Bridget Hackshaw bridget@inzonetravel.com Zoning Central
Rezone 27, 29, 31 and 33 Ruskin Road and 66 St Georges Bay Road, Parnell from Mixed
Use to Single House.
6848-2 Bridget Hackshaw bridget@inzonetravel.com
Centre) Business
Park zones
Amend the development controls, including height, height in relation to boundary, building set
back and landscaping requirements, of the Mixed Use zone for the sites 29-31 and 33 Ruskin
Road, Parnell to not have adverse effects on 2/62 St Georges Bay Road, Parnell or 66 St
Georges Bay Road, Parnell.
6849-1 Carla Sheldon carlajsheldon@gmail.com Zoning Central Reduce intensification in Point Chevalier.
6849-2 Carla Sheldon carlajsheldon@gmail.com Zoning Central Provide for intensification in Westmere, Grey Lynn and Ponsonby rather than Point Chevalier.
6850-1 Bridget and Stuart Velvin
PO Box 30, Waiheke Island,
Whenua
Remove the restrictions placed on 10 Shelly Beach Road, Waiheke from a midden in an
adjacent reserve.
Whenua
of value to Mana Whenua Identify heritage sites on Waiheke such as Rangihoua.
assessment Seek that the process include a method to gauge fees that iwi may charge.
6851-1 Times Trust deanne@mhg.co.nz Zoning South Retain Mixed Use zoning of 736 Great South Rd, Manukau
6851-2 Times Trust deanne@mhg.co.nz
Centre) Business
Park zones
Delete the requirement for a wind report for buildings higher than 20m where a canopy is
provided over public spaces or where the development is on a rear site [rule 4.19]
6851-3 Times Trust deanne@mhg.co.nz General Chapter G General provisions
activities
Reject provision for Council to consider provisions beyond those listed as assessment criteria
for controlled and restricted discretionary activities
6851-4 Times Trust deanne@mhg.co.nz Definitions Existing
Amend definition of height by including average ground level as a means of calculating
building height
6851-5 Times Trust deanne@mhg.co.nz General Cross plan matters Delete the maximum storey component of height limits in all zones
6851-6 Times Trust deanne@mhg.co.nz
Centre) Business
Park zones Delete [rule 4.8] minimum floor to floor/ceiling height control.
6851-7 Times Trust deanne@mhg.co.nz Built Environment (Overlays)
Height Control
Amend the additional zone height control on 736 Great South Rd, Manukau from 24.5m to
unlimited height
6851-8 Times Trust deanne@mhg.co.nz General Chapter G General provisions
statements Delete requirements for design statements
6851-9 Times Trust deanne@mhg.co.nz Mana Whenua General provisions
assessment Refine circumstances that a cultural impact assessment and engagement with iwi is required
6851-10 Times Trust deanne@mhg.co.nz Sustainable Development C7.7/H6.4 Sustainable design Delete requirement for Greenstar rating or certification under the Living Building Challenge
6851-11 Times Trust deanne@mhg.co.nz Residential zones Housing affordability H6.6 Rules
Delete the requirement to provide 10% of a development of 15 or more dwellings as
affordable housing
6852-1 Ellerslie Residents Association
PO Box 11474, Ellerslie, Auckland
1542 Built Environment (Overlays)
Height Control Retain Ellerslie Town Centre to a maximum height limit of 12.5m or three storeys
Provide sufficient information to the public and how growth has been allocated in and around
Ellerslie, or in other parts of Auckland. Request information on infrastructure capacity of
Ellerslie.
1542 General Miscellaneous Other
Recognise schools rolls in key Ellerslie Primary Schools have doubled in the last six years
and council needs to provide modelling of where the children of the new residents be
schooled
1542 RPS Issues
growth
Recognise that before growth is facilitated around Auckland, Council use the most recent and
accurate information before further errors are made
1542 General Miscellaneous Special housing areas
Seeks working in collaboration with the Government to accelerate further Special Housing
Areas for prioritised growth and affordable investment until Council can obtain all the technical
information essential to determine where the new population should go
1542 Zoning Central Retain the Special Purpose zoning for Ellerslie Racecourse
450/1145
Sub#/
1542 Zoning Central Retain the area identified as Single Housing in Ellerslie as Single Housing
1542
control
Building demolition control J.3.6 Rules and mapping Retain this overlay
1542 Zoning Central
Retain Open Space zone for all the open spaces in Ellerslie, in particular, Liston Park, the
Ellerslie Domain and St Michaels Reserve
Business
Character Statements - Bus. Retain the Special Character Statement - Business for Ellerslie in Appendix 10.1.3
& C
Isthmus
Add to the schedule the worker and railway housing in Findlay and Hewson Streets, Ellerslie.
Suggest a new Appendix 10.4.4 Isthmus D - Ellerslie Residential [refer to original submission
page 5/8 and 6/8 for suggested text]
Height Control Prohibits development in Ellerslie Town Centre above 12.5m
1542 Zoning Central
Rezone the areas around the Ellerslie Town Centre zone from Terrace Housing and
Apartments Buildings to Mixed Housing Suburban
1542 Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
Remove car parking maximums in the Ellerslie Town Centre and Terrace Housing and
Apartment Buildings zones
requirements Restore car parking minimums in Ellerslie Town Centre
1542 Zoning Central Rezone Tecoma Street from Terrace Housing and Apartment Building to Single House
Amend the development control threshold for increased development under the Mixed
Housing Urban zone from 1200m
2
to 1500m
2
.
Request a shift of growth around Ellerslie and ensure that higher density living be only
permitted in those areas where the impact of taller buildings is less obtrusive (i.e. in valleys
and along lower lying areas, rather than on ridges)
1542 Zoning Central
Rezone the area between Ladies Mile and Amy Street, Ellerslie from Terrace Housing and
1542 Zoning Central
Rezone the area between Ladies Mile and Amy Street, Ellerslie from Mixed Housing Urban to
Mixed Housing Suburban
1542 Zoning Central
Rezone the land between Cawley Street and the Ellerslie Panmure Highway, Ellerslie from
Light Industrial to Terrace Housing and Apartment Building
Height Control
Allow a maximum permitted height of 12 storeys for the land between Cawley Street and the
Ellerslie Panmure Highway, Ellerslie, gradually moving down to three storeys consistent with
the adjacent Terrace Housing and Apartment Zone
1542 Zoning Central
Rezone the area between Wilkinson Road and Ellerslie Panmure Highway to Terrace
Housing and Apartment Buildings - 4 Storey
1542 Zoning Central
Rezone Hudson Street and Main Highway, Ellerslie for more intensive development - i.e.
Mixed Housing Urban
1542 Zoning Central
Add an intermediate zoning between the Terrace Housing and Apartment Building zone on
the north side of Tecoma Street and the adjacent Single House zone to balance development
General
Add new provision in the Plan for new tree planting along berm and other public land areas to
offset the impact of new development on Ellerslie's green environment
6853-1 John Griffiths
8 Ostend Road, Ostend, Auckland
1081
Remove houseboats from the moorings zone at Okahuiti Creek (Shelly Beach Causeway and
Wharf Roads, Waiheke Island).
6854-1 Monica S Travaille travaille_ms@hotmail.com Mana Whenua General provisions
assessment
Require an Independent Review Authority, appointed by the government, to clarify the
definition of 'significant' [Cultural Impact Assessment].
6854-2 Monica S Travaille travaille_ms@hotmail.com Mana Whenua General provisions
assessment Provide relevant information on LIM reports [relates to Cultural Impact Assessments].
6855-1 Wynne and Carolyn Jones wynnedajones@hotmail.com Residential zones Residential Land use controls
Amend minimum site size to 500m
2
, particularly at 87 St Heliers Bay Road, St Heliers [Single
House zone].
6856-1 Christine E Waugh
1/54 Alverston Street, Waterview,
Rezone Herdman St and Daventry St, Waterview from a 3 storey urban zoning to a 2 storey
urban zoning.
6857-1 Diana R and Lesley Shand diana.shand@xtra.co.nz Precincts - North Kawau Island
Retain the precinct, particularly the objectives and policies which protect the Island's
biodiversity
6857-2 Diana R and Lesley Shand diana.shand@xtra.co.nz
SEAs
Land Apply the SEA overlay over all of Kawau Island
6857-3 Diana R and Lesley Shand diana.shand@xtra.co.nz Precincts - North Kawau Island Request practical options for landowners to have jetties, boat ramps and boat sheds
451/1145
Sub#/
6857-4 Diana R and Lesley Shand diana.shand@xtra.co.nz Built Environment (Overlays)
Protection Retain provisions which prevent ridge top development
6858-1 Ahmed A Shah shahmansoorali@gmail.com
Centre) Business
Amend the Light Industry zone, particularly at 171-173 Archers Road, Wairau Valley, to
provide for more 'mixed use' activities.
6858-2 Ahmed A Shah shahmansoorali@gmail.com Zoning North and Islands Rezone Wairau Valley from Light Industrial to General Business.
6859-1
Portland Ecological Valley
Group jackfam@xtra.co.nz Special Character
residential
special character areas Retain objective 6
6859-2
residential E3.1 Policies Retain policy 36
6859-3
& C J3.3.1-7 Rules Retain Rule 3.1 Density and the maximum building coverage Rule in 4.5
6859-4
Group jackfam@xtra.co.nz RPS
character and natural heritage B4.3.4 Biodiversity Retain SEA policies
6859-5
Group jackfam@xtra.co.nz
SEAs
Areas - Land rules (all) Retain SEA Rules.
6859-6
Group jackfam@xtra.co.nz
SEAs
Land Retain overlay applying to Portland Ecology Valley (SEA 6065)
6859-7
Group jackfam@xtra.co.nz Trees
Trees E6.1 Objectives and policies Retain policies.
6859-8
Group jackfam@xtra.co.nz Trees
Trees
Notable Trees Retain the inclusion of 13 notable trees in the Portland Road area.
6859-9
character and natural heritage B4.3.3 Trees and vegetation Reinstate the provisions that upplied under the Urban Tree Overlay [DAUP]
6859-10
Apply an urban tree overlay to the Portland Rd Valley, Remuera as was proposed in the Draft
Auckland Unitary Plan.
6860-1 R and A Family Trust webb@quaychambers.co.nz Zoning Central
Rezone the north side of Jervois Road, especially between Wallace Street and Hamilton
Road, from Local Centre to a residential zone that reflects the type of buildings and the low
key office uses in some of the buildings.
6860-2 R and A Family Trust webb@quaychambers.co.nz
control
Provide some assistance to property owners required to seek a Restricted Discretionary
Consent to alter or remove a building subject to a pre-1944 Building Demolition Control
Overlay.
6860-3 R and A Family Trust webb@quaychambers.co.nz
control
Building demolition control J.3.6 Rules and mapping Place a time limit on the period that the Demolition Control will be retained.
6860-4 R and A Family Trust webb@quaychambers.co.nz General Miscellaneous Other Adopt the relief sought in the submission by Herne Bay Residents Association.
6860-5 R and A Family Trust webb@quaychambers.co.nz Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
Insert a proper roading hierarchy, roading classification system and detailed 'functional
definitions'.
6860-6 R and A Family Trust webb@quaychambers.co.nz Transport Auckland -wide Mapping
Reclassify Curran Street from an Arterial Road (Regional or District), to a classification better
suited to its actual physical dimensions and functional capability.
Rezone the Mixed Housing Urban zone on the north-side of Sarsfield Street between Sentinel
Road and Curran Street and replace it with the Mixed Housing Suburban zone; but only do so
if the building rules have been amended to meet the Herne Bay Residents Association's
submission.
Rezone the Mixed Housing Urban zone on the west side of Shelly Beach Road, between
Tweed and Emmett Streets, and replace it with the Single House Zone.
Rezone the Mixed Housing Suburban zone from the following Streets: Stack Street (north and
south sides), Argyle Street (south side), Wallace Street (north, east west sides), Jervois Road
(north and south sides) between Clifton Road and Salisbury Street, Jervois Road (south side)
on Buller Street; and replace it with the Single House zone.
Rezone the Mixed Housing Suburban zone from the following Streets: Curran Street (west
and east sides), Emmett and Tweed Streets, Shelly Beach Road (east side); and replace it
with the Single House zone.
6861-1 K and N Lafferty
2145 General
GIS viewer
Review the application of the floodplain overlay for the area in Howick bounded by Ridge Rd,
Picton St, Cook St, and Union Rd as it affects the zoning of properties in this area.
6861-2 K and N Lafferty
quality compact urban form Retain the reduction of Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings zone in Howick.
6862-1 Rod Clarke rod_c@clear.net.nz Zoning North and Islands Rezone 130 and 132 Upper Orewa Road from Rural Production to Countryside Living Zone
6862-2 Rod Clarke rod_c@clear.net.nz RPS Changes to the RUB North and Waiheke Island Include 130 and 132 Upper Orewa Road so that it is inside the RUB
6862-3 Rod Clarke rod_c@clear.net.nz
SEAs
Land Revert SEA from 132 Upper Orewa Road, Silverdale
452/1145
Sub#/
6862-4 Rod Clarke rod_c@clear.net.nz RPS Changes to the RUB North and Waiheke Island
Amend the RUB perimeter by using the large bush areas surrounding the north of 130 Upper
Orewa Road, Silverdale, rather than solely the south side of Upper Oreawa Road
6863-1 Glenn Teal glenn@teal.org.nz Air Quality
transport separation Delete overlay.
6865-1 Peter Verschaffelt peter.verschaffelt@gmail.com General Whole Plan Rejects the fundamental premises underlying the plan
6865-2 Peter Verschaffelt peter.verschaffelt@gmail.com RPS Issues
growth Rejects the population projections that underlie the directions set by the plan.
6865-3 Peter Verschaffelt peter.verschaffelt@gmail.com RPS
Transport
and energy
Rejects the plan in that it fails to recognise the city's lack of infrastructure capacity, particularly
water and wastewater.
6865-4 Peter Verschaffelt peter.verschaffelt@gmail.com General Miscellaneous
Operational/
Projects/Acquisition Rejects the City Rail Link [suggests alternatives, page 7/17 of the submission]
6865-5 Peter Verschaffelt peter.verschaffelt@gmail.com RPS Urban growth
Reject 'new urbanism' approach. Accommodate growth by allowing growth in Waikato Valley
between Auckland and Hamilton.
6865-6 Peter Verschaffelt peter.verschaffelt@gmail.com Residential zones Residential Activity Table Allow the removal and relocation of houses.
6866-1 Kathryn and Jedediah Holland kat@avecplume.co.nz Zoning Central
Rezone all properties from Grey St to Arthur St, Onehunga from Terrace Housing and
Apartment Buildings and Mixed Housing Urban to Mixed Housing Suburban
6867-1
Sky Network Television
Limited patrick.mulligan@buddlefindlay.com Zoning North and Islands Rezone 1 John Glenn Avenue, Albany from Light Industry to General Business
6867-2
Limited patrick.mulligan@buddlefindlay.com Precincts - North New Precincts All other New Precincts
Provide a new precinct for 1 John Glenn Avenue, Albany and precinct rules for broadcasting,
media, television studios and offices and satellite dishes with application of controls and
assessment criteria specified in the General Business zone and Network Utilities rules. Refer
to listed precinct rules on page 6/29 of this submission
6867-3
Limited patrick.mulligan@buddlefindlay.com Zoning Central
Rezone 10 Panorama Road, Mount Wellington, 16 Leonard Road, Mount Wellington and 34
Leonard Road, Mount Wellington from Light Industry to Mixed Use.
6867-4
Limited patrick.mulligan@buddlefindlay.com Precincts - Central New Precincts Other New Precincts
Provide a new precinct for 10 Panorama Road, Mount Wellington, 16 Leonard Road, Mount
Wellington and 34 Leonard Road, Mount Wellington and precinct rules for broadcasting,
media, television studios and offices and satellite dishes with application of controls and
assessment criteria specified in the General Business zone and Network Utilities rules. Refer
to listed precinct rules on page 15/29 of this submission
6867-5
Limited patrick.mulligan@buddlefindlay.com Infrastructure
Energy
Amend the activity table in respect of telecommunication satellite dishes and
telecommunication activities. Refer to page 26/29 of this submission.
6867-6
Limited patrick.mulligan@buddlefindlay.com Definitions Existing
Amend a definition of network utilities and telecommunications and satellite dishes over 1
metre in diameter be removed from a definition of buildings.
6868-1 Bruce Stuart bruce@borderlaw.co.nz Residential zones Residential Activity Table Provide for minor dwellings in South Auckland.
6869-1
Stuart Stephen and Elizabeth
M Palmer remlaps@yahoo.com RPS Changes to the RUB South Delete the extension of the RUB in the south.
6869-2
M Palmer remlaps@yahoo.com RPS Urban growth
recreation facilities Provide more green space in the Drury area.
6869-3
M Palmer remlaps@yahoo.com Residential zones Residential
General
Reduce the height limit for Papakura to 2-3 storeys with a setback to the neighbour's
boundary.
6869-4
M Palmer remlaps@yahoo.com
Centre) Business
Park zones Reduce the height limit for town centres (e.g. Takapuna, Orewa).
6869-5
M Palmer remlaps@yahoo.com General Miscellaneous Other Seek that council reject the 52 storey hotel on Elliot Street.
6869-6
M Palmer remlaps@yahoo.com General Miscellaneous
Operational/
Projects/Acquisition Retain regional parks in present structure.
6870-1 David Hartley davehelensville@gmail.com Zoning Central
Rezone the area bounded by Great South Road, Main Highway Ellerslie and Kalmia Street,
Ellerslie from Light Industry to Mixed Use.
6871-1 Karl Schweder
PO Box 25073, St Heliers, Auckland
1740 Zoning Central
Retain current 'Residential 5' level of density of development permitted for Lot 3 DP 29538
(437 Riddell Road, Glendowie).
1740 Precincts - South Pukekohe Hill Amend average net site area to 2,000m
2
in Sub-precinct B.
1740 Zoning South
Rezone the land in Pukekohe Hill Sub-precinct B Bounded by Anzac Road, Jellicoe Road,
Calcutta Road, Blake Road and Kitchener Road, and in particular Lot 2 DP 87104 (149 Anzac
Rd) from Large Lot to Single House.
1740 Precincts - South Pukekohe Hill
Amend lot sizes to an average net site area of 1,000m
2
on the land in Pukekohe Hill Sub-
precinct B, bounded by Anzac Road, Jellicoe Road, Calcutta Road, Blake Road and Kitchener
Road, and in particular Lot 2 DP 87104 (149 Anzac Rd).
Remove the requirement for framework plans and all associated provisions from Sub-precinct
B.
453/1145
Sub#/
1740 Precincts - South Pukekohe Hill Amend the impervious area threshold area for Sub-precinct B to 20%
1740 Water Wastewater
management rules
Require land in Pukekohe Hill Sub-precinct B, bounded by Anzac Road, Jellicoe Road,
Rd) to be connected to the public wastewater system.
Seeks that land in Pukekohe Hill Sub-precinct B, bounded by Anzac Road, Jellicoe Road,
Rd) be connected to the public stormwater system.
Delete all references to 'open landscape' (and similar references) for the lower and middle
slopes of Pukekohe Hill (Sub-precincts A and B) particularly in Policy 4 and 5.
Delete references to 'graduating the intensity of development' from the bottom to the top of
Pukekohe HIll.
Amend references such as the 'retention of rural character,' the 'avoidance of urban character'
and other similar references to restrict them to Sub-precincts D and E as well as other rural
parts of Pukekohe Hill.
Amend references to the 'preservation of the rural open space character of Pukekohe Hill' to
restrict them to the Special Policy Area (now Sub-precincts D and E).
1740 Precincts - South Pukekohe Hill Recognise the special heritage and amenity values of the land in Sub-precincts D and E
1740 Precincts - South Pukekohe Hill Include provisions that prevent flooding originating from the area of Sub-precinct D
1740 Precincts - Central Saint Heliers K2.19.Precinct Rules
Require the built form of future development to be small scale reflecting the seaside village
character of St. Heliers.
1740 Precincts - Central Saint Heliers
Objectives & Policies Amend rules to ensure renovations and new buildings reflect the character of St Heliers.
1740 Precincts - Central Saint Heliers K2.19.Precinct Rules Amend height limit for St Heliers to be 9m.
Include detailed design guidelines for St Heliers as requirements for development, not just
considerations.
1740 Zoning Central
Rezone land at St Heliers from Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings to a less intensive
zoniing
1740 Zoning Central Rezone land in Saint Heliers from Mixed Housing Urban to Mixed Housing Suburban.
1740 Precincts - Central Saint Heliers K2.19.Precinct Rules Limit the number of bars and restaurants in St Heliers Bay.
1740 Zoning Central rezone land at Kohimarama from Mixed Housing Suburban to Mixed Housing Urban
6872-1 Murphys Development Limited marktollemache@ihug.co.nz RPS Urban growth
quality compact urban form Retain the intent to identify future urban land through the RUB and Future Urban zone
6872-2 Murphys Development Limited marktollemache@ihug.co.nz RPS Changes to the RUB South
Amend RUB to include additional land in Flat Bush catchment. Refer to map on page 5/9 of
the submission
6872-3 Murphys Development Limited marktollemache@ihug.co.nz Precincts - South Flat Bush
Retain all natural resource overlays that apply to 125 Murphys Road, Flat Bush, particularly
the SEA overlay
6872-4 Murphys Development Limited marktollemache@ihug.co.nz Built Environment (Overlays)
Protection Delete the ridgeline protection overlay as it applies to 12 Murphys Road, Flat Bush
Amend the Countryside Living zone in the precinct to provide for subdivision and land use
equivalent to the Flat Bush Countryside Transition zone in the operative Manukau District
Plan
6872-6 Murphys Development Limited marktollemache@ihug.co.nz RPS Urban growth
Insert a schedule for the release of Future Urban land for development. Give priority to Flat
Bush stage 3 in this schedule
6872-7 Murphys Development Limited marktollemache@ihug.co.nz RPS Changes to the RUB South
Rezone 125 Murphys Road, Flat Bush and surrounds as identified in map in submission from
Future Urban to Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings, Local Centre, Mixed Housing
Urban and Mixed Housing Suburban
6872-8 Murphys Development Limited marktollemache@ihug.co.nz Precincts - South New Precincts All other New Precincts
Insert a new Flat Bush precinct 3 [to cover Flat Bush stage 3],including specific objectives,
policies, rules and a structure plan or precinct plan.
Request for an alternative dispute resolution process prior to the hearings for the issues
raised in the submission around Flat Bush stage 3 development
6873-1
Whangaparaoa Community
Trust contact@wct.co.nz Designations G1.3 Designations
Remove road widening designation that runs across part of the property at 15 Main Street,
Whangaparaoa.(there is no road widening designation on the property).
6874-1 Flynn Bros Limited flynn.fam@xtra.co.nz Precincts - South Pukekohe Hill
Amend the provisions to allow for subdivision in sub-precinct B with an average net site area
of 1,000m
2
.
6874-2 Flynn Bros Limited flynn.fam@xtra.co.nz Zoning South Rezone sub-precinct B of the Pukekohe Hill precinct from Large Lot to Single House.
6874-3 Flynn Bros Limited flynn.fam@xtra.co.nz Precincts - South Pukekohe Hill
Amend the provisions to allow for subdivision in sub-precinct B with an average net site area
of 2,000m
2
.
454/1145
Sub#/
6874-4 Flynn Bros Limited flynn.fam@xtra.co.nz Precincts - South Pukekohe Hill Delete the requirement for framework plans for sub-precinct B.
6875-1 Maria A Schweder schweder@ihug.co.nz Zoning Central
Retain the current 'Residential 5' level of density of development permitted [Rule 3.1] for Lot 3
DP 29538 (437 Riddell Road, Glendowie)
6876-1
Whangaparaoa Community
Trust contact@wct.co.nz Designations G1.3 Designations Remove the road widening designation from 15 Main Street, Whangaparoa
6877-1 Vicky Hamill
42 Cory Road, Palm Beach, Waiheke
Island, Auckland 1081 RPS
character and natural heritage B4.3 Natural heritage Amend PAUP to provide special protection for Waiheke Island.
6877-2 Vicky Hamill
Heritage Area Amend PAUP to provide special protection of the Waitakere Ranges.
6877-3 Vicky Hamill
Island, Auckland 1081 Public Open Space Zones Public Open Space
controls & Spec. info. req. Amend PAUP to provide protection for Auckland's parks
6877-4 Vicky Hamill
character and natural heritage B4.3.3 Trees and vegetation Amend PAUP to provide protection for Auckland's forests.
6877-5 Vicky Hamill
Island, Auckland 1081 RPS Coastal B7 Strategic Amend PAUP to provide protection for Auckland's seas.
6877-6 Vicky Hamill
Island, Auckland 1081 RPS Urban growth
2010 Limit visual pollution in Auckland.
6877-7 Vicky Hamill
Island, Auckland 1081 General Noise and vibration
and policies Limit noise pollution in Auckland.
6878-1 Anna Copeland a.copeland@barfoot.co.nz Special Character
residential
special character areas Retain residential character of Mt Eden
6879-1 Crawford B Binnie
5 Clarks Beach Road, Clarks Beach,
Auckland 2122 RPS Mana Whenua B5 Strategic Delete Mana Whenua provisions.
6880-1 Ardeth Lobet ardeth@gosail.org Precincts - City Centre Queen Street Valley
Retain demolition or removal of pre-1940s buildings and require consent for demolition,
including "demolition by neglect." Exact serious penalties for those owners who defy the
policy.
6880-2 Ardeth Lobet ardeth@gosail.org Precincts - City Centre Westhaven
Amend the precinct to make primary provision for welfare and current use by mariners and
providing access to non-boating public should be secondary. Commercial facilities (i.e. marine
shops) should also be subordinate to the above users.
6881-1 Stephen R Verdellen-Knowles steve@sportzhub.com Mana Whenua
Whenua
of value to Mana Whenua Delete overlay from 135 McLeod Road, Waioneke.
6882-1 Searle Holdings Limited
2340 General Chapter A Introduction
tools Amend to clarify that the Patumahoe Structure Plan takes precedence over anything else.
6883-1 Christina J Euridge chrissie_euridge@yahoo.co.uk Zoning West
Rezone 105 and 107 Vodanovich Road, Te Atatu South from Single House to Mixed Housing
Urban.
6884-1
North Shore Takapuna Golf
Club owen.taylor@hainesplanning.co.nz General Eplan
Clarify the zoning notations on the base zone map in relation to the Property Summary of the
electronic version of the Plan. The Unitary Plan Base Zone map shows the site as having two
zones, being: Public Open Space - Sport and Active Recreation and Major Recreation Facility
6884-2
Club owen.taylor@hainesplanning.co.nz Public Open Space Zones Public Open Space I2.1 Activity table
Amend the Activity Table to provide for Care Centres as part of a sports complex with a floor
areas up to 200m
2
as a permitted activity
6884-3
Amend the Activity Table to provide for Restaurants and Cafes, excluding a drive-through
facility, accessory to a permitted activity and further than 30m from a residential zone, as a
permitted activity, provided it is part of a sporting complex
6884-4
Amend the Activity Table to provide for Restaurants and Cafes, excluding a drive-through
facility, accessory to a permitted activity and within 30m from a residential zone, as a
Restricted Discretionary activity, provided it is part of a sporting complex.
6885-1 Bridge City Properties Limited
2340 Precincts - South Runciman Delete the provisions for cluster development, riding trails and road setbacks.
6885-2 Bridge City Properties Limited
2340 Precincts - South Runciman Reduce the minimum average size to 8,000m
2
.
6886-1 Peter Blundell nicola.pretty@gmail.com Precincts - North Kawau Island Retain precinct.
6886-2 Peter Blundell nicola.pretty@gmail.com
SEAs
Land Retain approach of not identifying SEAs on Kawau Island.
the CMA
and occupation
D5.1.13 Background,
Amend the Background to add the following words "...and then only after consultation with
affected property owners." in relation to imposing a charge for occupation of the CMA.
6886-4 Peter Blundell nicola.pretty@gmail.com Precincts - North Kawau Island
Delete the last 12 words from the Objectives as there are no public lands inshore of any
properties on the island. See page 2/4 of the submission for further details. [Note - unclear
what provision this point applies to].
Amend Policy 5 by deleting the words highlighted in the submission [Note - no words have
been highlighted in the submission. Page 2/4 of the submission].
455/1145
Sub#/
6886-6 Peter Blundell nicola.pretty@gmail.com Precincts - North Kawau Island Retain requirement that each property on Kawau has direct access to the foreshore.
Amend Subdivision control 4.1 'Sub-precinct A subdivision of low intensity settlement sites
restricted discretionary activity' to not state there is no requirement for legal access to a road
as the goal of limiting the proliferation of road. See pages 2 and 3/4 of the submission for
further details.
the CMA
sch. 6.2 ONC/HNC
6.1 Schedule SEA
Marine 1 and 2
Delete or amend Appendix, in relation to Kawau Island, to correct incorrect information
(incorrect areas included) in conjunction with Kawau Islanders. See pages 3 and 4/4 of the
submission for further information.
Clarify that sewage discharges are permitted only if they are 500m off the coast. See
submission for further details [page 4/4 of the submission].
Outstanding Natural
Rules
Character - Coastal
Delete IDs 64 to 69, on Kawau Island or amend to reflect the current environment. See page
Outstanding Natural
Rules
J6.2.4 Assessment
Amend Development control 3.3 'Yards' to clarify that the front yard boundary on Kawau
Island is 6m from Mean High Water Springs.
6887-1 Peter Shepherd rj.ramsay@auckland.ac.nz
organisms
modified organisms Delete a prohibited activity status of both food and non-food related GMO releases.
6888-1
Brookfield Funds Management
Limited owen.taylor@hainesplanning.co.nz Zoning City Centre
Retain City Centre zoning at Lot 2 DP 141317 and Lot 1 DP 141371 (473-529 Karangahape
Road and 8 Hereford Street).
6888-2
Limited owen.taylor@hainesplanning.co.nz Precincts - City Centre Karangahape Road
Amend the precinct to exclude the Karangahape Road Plaza area and modify the delineation
of the precinct [as shown on the modified Karangahape Road Precinct Plan, page 8/19 of
submission]
6888-3
Limited owen.taylor@hainesplanning.co.nz Precincts - City Centre New Precincts
Include a new Precinct - Karangahape Road Plaza, at 473-529 Karangahape Road and 8
Hereford Street - to recognise the existing Concept Plan for Karangahape Road Plaza (C08-
27 Auckland Isthmus Section) and related development and its functioning of this area [view
page 9/19 of submission for objectives, policies and rules]
6888-4
Limited owen.taylor@hainesplanning.co.nz RPS Urban growth
retain affordable housing Delete policies that require provision of affordable housing
6888-5
Limited owen.taylor@hainesplanning.co.nz Residential zones Housing affordability
and policies Delete Policy 1 and 2
6888-6
Limited owen.taylor@hainesplanning.co.nz City Centre Zone
obs & pols Retain Objective 1-4
6888-7
Limited owen.taylor@hainesplanning.co.nz City Centre Zone
obs & pols Retain Policies 1-4, 8-9 and 19-20
6888-8
Limited owen.taylor@hainesplanning.co.nz General Chapter G General provisions G2.4 Notification
Remove all 'sub-sections' throughout the plan and replace with a single notification section.
All Restricted Discretionary Activities complying with specified development controls (or with
written approvals of immediate neighbours affected by a specific development control
infringement) must be non-notified. Discretionary and Non-complying activities are subject to
normal RMA notification tests and special circumstances unfettered in all cases.
6888-9
Limited owen.taylor@hainesplanning.co.nz General Chapter G General provisions G2.4 Notification
Remove notification provisions throughout the plan that set more stringent requirements than
the RMA
6888-10
Limited owen.taylor@hainesplanning.co.nz Residential zones Housing affordability H6.6 Rules Delete this section
6888-11
Limited owen.taylor@hainesplanning.co.nz
Centre) Business
Park zones Delete Rule 4.1(1)
6888-12
Limited owen.taylor@hainesplanning.co.nz City Centre Zone I4 Rules/Appendix 7.1- 7.3 Delete Rule 4.39 Dwelling mix.
6889-1 Berry Simons andrew@berrysimons.co.nz Trees
Trees
Notable Trees Remove the trees [ID 1328] from 8 Minnehaha Avenue, Takapuna.
6890-1 Stuart G Searle
2340 Zoning South Rezone the Runciman area from Countryside Living to a rural residential zone.
6891-1 Parallax Consultants Limited
PO Box 266, Warkworth, Auckland
0941 Zoning North and Islands
Rezone the rural areas north of Auckland to reflect the productivity limitations as compared to
the 'elite and prime' land south of Auckland.
area Provide for subdivision in rural areas if the site does not contain land with a LUC Class of 1-3.
456/1145
Sub#/
area
Allow lots to be created on sites containing bush protection, wetland protection, land
rehabilitation and enhancement planting subdivision as done in the Operative Rodney District
Plan .
area Revise Transferable Site Subdivision rules to only apply to land with a LUC Class of 1-3.
area
Remove the 10% threshold and 'once only' restrictions from boundary adjustments and
relocations
area
Remove the restrictions relating to ownership of properties from boundary adjustments and
relocations
area Remove the 'prohibited' activity status applied to rural subdivision.
area
Amend table 5 to that 'Any other subdivision not provided for in this table or in the rural zones
subdivision rules' are a non-complying activity, rather than a prohibited activity.
area
10% of the site area.
area
Amend rules to include provisions for subdividing sites in the areas north of Auckland for the
protection of native bush and significant wetlands or for significant enhancement planting or
significant land rehabilitation as provided for in the Operative Rodney District Plan as a
discretionary activity. This include allowing the creating of sites on the land containing the
protected feature.
area
Remove the prohibited activity status applying to rural boundary relocations and boundary
adjustments. Complying boundary adjustments should be Restricted Discretionary.
area Remove the distinction between boundary adjustments and boundary relocations
area
Remove the requirement for boundary adjustments and relocation that the sites must exist
and be comprised of Certificates of Title on the date of notification of the plan.
area
Remove the requirement to assess and protect natural features when undertaking a boundary
relocation subdivision.
0941 Rural Zones General I13.2 Land use controls
Retain Rule 2.6, in so far as it provides for additional dwellings. Delete restrictions in Rule
2.6(1) and (2)
Provide for Minor Household Units in all zones, as provided for in the Operative Rodney
District Plan as a restricted discretionary activity.
Amend rule to allow a second dwelling on a rural site less than 40ha as a restricted
discretionary activity, with assessment criteria similar to those for Minor Household Units in
the Operative Rodney District Plan (such as whether the two dwellings maintain a consistent
visual appearance on the site and whether the two dwellings will create the impression of
higher than usual residential density in an area_.
0941 Subdivision Auckland-wide - general
controls
Amend the wording of Rule 2.1(6)(a) to clarify that esplanade reserves are only required for
sites less than 4ha.
assessment Delete rules relating to Cultural Impact Assessments.
assessment
Require Iwi groups to more accurately identify areas of interest to them to avoid applicants
having to consult with so many parties.
0941 Mana Whenua
Whenua
objectives and policies Delete the 'Sites of Value to Mana Whenua'.
6892-1 Barbara Brandley musketelle@hotmail.com Zoning South
Decline the Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings zoning for the area bounded by Tamaki
Bay Drive, Williams Ave and Pakuranga Road
6892-2 Barbara Brandley musketelle@hotmail.com Residential zones Residential Land use controls
Delete the density control that allows Mixed Housing Suburban sites to reduce to 200m
2
for
sites 1200m
2
plus.
6892-3 Barbara Brandley musketelle@hotmail.com Zoning South
Rezone the area bounded by Riverlea Ave, Browns Ave and Tamaki Bay Drive on the north
(seaward) side of Browns Ave/Dowling Place from Mixed Housing Suburban to Single House.
457/1145
Sub#/
6892-4 Barbara Brandley musketelle@hotmail.com Residential zones Residential
Amend Rule 7.3 [Height In Relation To Boundary] so it does not apply to narrow walkways
which are encroached from both sides.
6893-1 Treasury Wine Estates nickr@barker.co.nz Rural Zones General
objectives & policies Retain general objectives and policies
6893-2 Treasury Wine Estates nickr@barker.co.nz Precincts - North New Precincts All other New Precincts
Provide new "Waimauku Winery Precinct" over the property at 311 Waikoukou Valley Road
and inclusion of specific description, objectives and policies for this proposed precinct, which
will form part of the north area precinct provisions. Refer to details on pages 9/60-11/60 of
this submission.
6893-3 Treasury Wine Estates nickr@barker.co.nz Definitions New
Add a new definition for winery to read "Winery means an activity in which any fruit or
vegetable juice is converted to a beverage with an alcoholic content and subsequently bottled
and packaged for sale".
6894-1 Karen Baverstock karenbaverstock@yahoo.co.nz Zoning West
Rezone Ahiriri Ave, Avondale from Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings to Single
House.
6894-2 Karen Baverstock karenbaverstock@yahoo.co.nz Built Environment (Overlays)
Height Control Delete overlay, permitting height up to 20.5m, from Ahiriri Ave, Avondale.
6894-3 Karen Baverstock karenbaverstock@yahoo.co.nz Precincts Ak-Wide and Coastal Racing K1.6 Precinct Rules
Amend the activity status of 'Motorsport racing' in the Avondale Racecourse Sub-precinct
from Permitted to Non-Complying.
6894-4 Karen Baverstock karenbaverstock@yahoo.co.nz Precincts Ak-Wide and Coastal Racing K1.6 Precinct Rules Retain Development controls.
6894-5 Karen Baverstock karenbaverstock@yahoo.co.nz Residential zones Residential Activity Table
Amend the activity status of 'The conversion of a dwelling into a maximum of two dwellings
complying with the land use controls in clause 3.3 below' from Discretionary to Permitted in
the Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings zone.
6894-6 Karen Baverstock karenbaverstock@yahoo.co.nz Precincts - West Avondale 2
Add 'For retail up to 450m2 GFA per site, the building interface with the public realm' as a
matter of discretion in K7.2.5.1 Assessment.
6894-7 Karen Baverstock karenbaverstock@yahoo.co.nz Precincts - West Avondale 2
Add 'built character' as a requirement of any design statement for 5-8 dwellings/units and 9-15
dwellings/units to K7.2.6. Special Information Requirements.
6895-1 Keith Squires kmljsquires@gmail.com Mana Whenua
Whenua
and policies
Reject the PAUP due to concerns over the Sites and Places of Value to Mana Whenua
provisions.
6896-1 David Pinker burnette@opc.net.nz RPS Changes to the RUB North and Waiheke Island Retain 48 Albert Rd, Warkworth inside the RUB
6896-2 David Pinker burnette@opc.net.nz Zoning North and Islands Rezone 48 Albert Rd, Warkworth from Large Lot to Single House
6896-3 David Pinker burnette@opc.net.nz Water Stormwater
H4.14.2 Stormwater
management -flow rules Delete or substantially amend the rule trigger for the SMAF-1 overlay
6897-1 Ivor Jones ic.jones@xtra.co.nz Water
table
Retain the taking of water and use of ground water, for stock and domestic purposes with
specific reference to 168 and 187 Jones Road, Matakana.
6897-2 Ivor Jones ic.jones@xtra.co.nz Precincts - North Omaha Flats Retain the Omaha Flats Precinct applying to 168 and 187 Jones Road, Matakana.
6898-1 Warren Snow warren@envision-nz.com RPS Issues
growth
Clarify the growth assumptions in PAUP and review wider impacts of the overall environment
and the regions that surround Auckland
6899-1 Fausett Family helvetia@xtra.co.nz Public Open Space Zones Public Open Space I2.1 Activity table
Prevent development of the Ray Fauselt Reserve, Princes Street West, Pukekohe, that goes
outside the parameters of a recreational and stormwater reserve.
6900-1 William C Williams williamcharles@gmail.com General Whole Plan Decline PAUP.
6901-1 Dennis Law and W Hong colin@hardacreplanning.co.nz
SEAs
Land Delete SEA [T 6065] overlay from 88 Victoria Ave, Remuera
6902-1
Corban Winery Estate
Heritage Preservation and
Development Trust robert@robertmakgill.com Precincts - West New Precincts
Provide a new heritage precinct over Corban Winery Estate at 426 Great North Road,
Henderson
6903-1 Spetses Property Trust Board c.covington@harrisongrierson.com Water Stormwater
Remove the overlay from 34 Athenic Avenue, 19 Rangitiki Crescent, 19 Athenic Avenue, 16
Orcades Place, 22 Caronia Crescent, 92 Halsey Drive, 37 Canberra Avenue, 1/156 and 2/156
Halsey Drive, 12 Orcades Place and 110A The Avenue, Lynfield.
H4.14.2 Stormwater
Amend the rules to only apply where the development (or addition of impervious area to an
existing development) results in an infringement to the impervious area controls of the
underlying zone.
H4.14.2 Stormwater
management -flow rules Clarify or revise the hydrology mitigation requirements
6904-1 Joshua Teal joshua@teal.org.nz Residential zones Residential
Terrace Housing and
Add new rules to provide for the sensitive and well designed intensification of sites which are
smaller than 1500m2 in central suburbs within the Terrace House and Apartment Zone
Buildings zone
6905-1 Judith M E Christie kukurei.crew@gmail.com
Amend 'Houseboats' to be a permitted activity in the mooring zone subject to the assessment
criteria in 2.2 being the permitted controls and an annual fee as contribution to local
amenities.
6905-2 Judith M E Christie kukurei.crew@gmail.com
the CMA Mooring zone I8.2 Assessment Retain Assessment criteria 2.2(2)(a) to (f).
458/1145
Sub#/
6906-1
Morris and James Matakana
Limited kieran@morrisandjames.co.nz RPS Changes to the RUB North and Waiheke Island Retain Warkworth RUB as is without extending further toward Matakana
6906-2
Limited kieran@morrisandjames.co.nz Sustainable Development C7.7/H6.4 Sustainable design
Request to use resources efficiently in relation to design, energy saving, waste reduction,
green space, the RUB and transport networks
6906-3
Limited kieran@morrisandjames.co.nz General Miscellaneous
Operational/
Projects/Acquisition Priovide more car parking in Matakana
6906-4
Limited kieran@morrisandjames.co.nz General Miscellaneous
Operational/
Projects/Acquisition Provide more public transport, cycleways and walkways in Matakana
6906-5
Limited kieran@morrisandjames.co.nz Precincts - North Matakana 3 Retain Matakana precinct plan
6906-6
Limited kieran@morrisandjames.co.nz Precincts - North Matakana 3
Insert the following new policy: Enable a sustainable traffic and transport approach in
Matakana village and surrounding areas.
6906-7
Amend the second sentence of the precinct description as follows: Morris and James Pottery
is located in this precinct, which consists of a large pottery, tile works factory, cafe and a large
clay pit.
6906-8
Amend Objective 1 as follows: To enable Morris and James Pottery to continue to operate as
a pottery and tile works factory, cafe and tourist attraction.
6906-9
Delete and replace Policy 2 with the following: The establishment of any new rural residential
or other activity in the vicinity of the precinct needs to be considered in relation to the effects
of the activities established and operating on the Morris and James site and the precinct area
such as dust from clay harvesting, traffic and noise.
6906-10
Add the following assessment criteria: The extent to which the location of any new activity in
proximity to the precinct creates the potential for reverse sensitivity effects to be generated.
6906-11
Amend wording of retail land use control [rule 2.2(1)] as follows: Retailing of arts and crafts
and architectural accessories made from clay, fibrous cements, glass, bronze or other
materials and a small range of locally produced artisan food items.
6906-12
Replace precinct plan 1 [showing future clay harvest zones] with the plan attached to
submission. Refer to page 9/9 of the submission.
6906-13
Amend the tourism tours land use control [rule 2.5(1)] as follows: Tourism tours of the factory,
on-site manufacturing activities and points of interest on or immediately adjoining the
property.
6906-14
Amend the temporary activities land use control [rule 2.6(2)] as follows: Temporary activities
must be limited to events for not more than 200 500 people on not more than six days in any
12 month period (January to December inclusive).
6906-15
Amend the clay extraction land use control [rule 2.4(1)] as follows: Clay extraction is for the on-
site manufacture of clay products and on a temporary basis (up to 2 years) the pottery at
Matakana precinct 3 may manufacture offsite with clay from the site.
6907-1 Stephen P Matatahi kukurei.crew@gmail.com
Amend 'Houseboats' to be a permitted activity in the mooring zone subject to the assessment
criteria in 2.2 being the permitted controls and an annual fee as contribution to local
amenities.
6908-1 Miranda Naturalists' Trust lawrie@ps.gen.nz
the CMA
sch. 6.2 ONC/HNC
6.1 Schedule SEA
Marine 1 and 2
Include the shell banks off Clarks Bay, Manukau Harbour as a Significant Ecological Area
(similar to Elletts Beach).
6908-2 Miranda Naturalists' Trust lawrie@ps.gen.nz
the CMA
and occupation I6.1.9 Activity table
Prohibit the use of the Elletts Beach and Clarks Bay shell banks for kite boarding launch
pads.
6908-3 Miranda Naturalists' Trust lawrie@ps.gen.nz RPS Coastal
Control public access and walkways to the foreshore to ensure a wide buffer margin around
wading bird roost sites.
6908-4 Miranda Naturalists' Trust lawrie@ps.gen.nz RPS Changes to the RUB South Delete the urban zone in Karaka West.
6909-1
LCLOUD Developments
Limited markb@mhg.co.nz Historic Heritage (Overlay)
Heritage
Places Remove 51-53 Albert Street from schedule
6909-2
LCLOUD Developments
Limited markb@mhg.co.nz General Chapter G General provisions
Delete the third paragraph under the heading 'assessment criteria' of I.1.4 applying for
resource consent
6909-3
LCLOUD Developments
Limited markb@mhg.co.nz Mana Whenua General provisions
assessment Remove the requirements for cultural impact assessment
6909-4
LCLOUD Developments
Limited markb@mhg.co.nz General Cross plan matters Remove the storey component from the building height rule for all zones
6909-5
LCLOUD Developments
statements Remove the requirement for separate Design Statements
6909-6
LCLOUD Developments
Limited markb@mhg.co.nz RPS Urban growth
environment Clarify the references to the Auckland Design Manual is a non-statutory guideline
459/1145
Sub#/
6909-7
LCLOUD Developments
Limited markb@mhg.co.nz Sustainable Development C7.7/H6.4 Sustainable design Remove Sustainable development rules
6909-8
LCLOUD Developments
Limited markb@mhg.co.nz Residential zones Housing affordability H6.6 Rules
Remove the requirement to incorporate affordable housing for those housing developments
which provide for 15 or more dwellings
6909-9
LCLOUD Developments
Clarification within G.1.4 of the PAUP that the matters for discretion and assessment criteria
listed in the PAUP for Controlled and Restricted Discretionary Activities are the sole matter for
assessment of these type of consent.
6910-1
Philip J and Janice M A
Harland harland-rusher@xtra.co.nz RPS Issues
growth
Retain 1.1 'Enabling quality urban growth', subject to greater flexibility to minimum subdivision
sizes and permitted activites in the Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings zone as they
apply to the northern side of Bracken Ave between Burns Ave and Lake Road, Takapuna [see
further points in submission for specific details].
6910-2
Harland harland-rusher@xtra.co.nz RPS Issues
growth
Retain 'Our Sense of Place' within 1.1 'Enabling quality urban growth', subject to greater
flexibility in the Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings zone for residential and residential
scale office developments.
6910-3
Harland harland-rusher@xtra.co.nz Residential zones
pols
Provide greater flexibility in the Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings zone for residential
and residential scale office developments.
6910-4
Harland harland-rusher@xtra.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - general
and policies
Amend Policy 18 to provide greater flexibility in subdivision minimums and the number of
dwellings permitted on each in the Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings zone. See Vol. 2
page 6/48 of the submission for further details regarding how this policy could be implemented
on maps.
6910-5
Harland harland-rusher@xtra.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - Urban zones H5.2 3.1 Residential zones
Amend rule 1 Site size, to enable subdivision in the Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings
zone to a minimum site size of 800m
2
as a Controlled activity.
6910-6
Harland harland-rusher@xtra.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - Urban zones H5.2 3.1 Residential zones
Amend the activity status of subdivision on sites between 800m
2
and 1199m
2
in the Terrace
Housing and Apartment Buildings zone from Non-complying to a Controlled activity with
controls limited to development design.
6910-7
Harland harland-rusher@xtra.co.nz Residential zones Residential Activity Table
Amend the activity status of '2 to 4 dwellings per site' in the Terrace Housing and Apartment
Buildings zone from Discretionary to Controlled for sites less than 1200m
2
, with control
reserved in relation to development design.
6910-8
Retain the Permitted Activity status of 1 dwelling per site in the Terrace Housing and
6910-9
Provide for residential scale offices on the northern side of Bracken Ave between Burns Ave
and Lake Road as a Controlled activity in accordance with the provisions in the North Shore
District Plan by scheduling these properties for residential scale offices.
6910-10
Amend the activity status of 'Alterations and additions to two or more dwellings on a site' from
Restricted Discretionary to Permitted in the Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings zone.
6910-11
Harland harland-rusher@xtra.co.nz Residential zones Residential
Special info. req.
Retain 10.1(3) 'Matters of discretion' for 'Four or more dwellings in the Mixed Housing
Suburban and Mixed Housing Urban zone, more than one dwelling in the Terrace Housing
and Apartment Buildings zone'.
6910-12
Harland harland-rusher@xtra.co.nz Residential zones Residential
Special info. req. Amend 10.2 'Assessment criteria' to allow for greater design flexibility.
6910-13
Harland harland-rusher@xtra.co.nz Zoning North and Islands Retain Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings zone at 23 Bracken Ave, Takapuna.
6910-14
Harland harland-rusher@xtra.co.nz
control
Building demolition control J.3.6 Rules and mapping Delete overlay at 23 Bracken Ave, Takapuna.
6910-15
Harland harland-rusher@xtra.co.nz Built Environment (Overlays)
Height Control Retain overlay permitting height to 20.5m/6 storeys at 23 Bracken Ave, Takapuna.
6910-16
Harland harland-rusher@xtra.co.nz Residential zones Residential Land use controls
Provide greater flexibility to minimum subdivision sizes and permitted activites in the Terrace
Housing and Apartment Buildings zone as they apply to the northern side of Bracken Ave
between Burns Ave and Lake Road, Takapuna [Vol. 2 page 5/48 of the submission].
6911-1 Alicia Warren alicia.warrennz@gmail.com RPS Urban growth
quality compact urban form Retain the compact city model
Retain the requirement for no more than 40 percent of new dwellings to be located outside of
the 2010 MUL
quality compact urban form Retain the RUB as an RPS tool.
Recognise the importance the proposed compact city strategy plays in protecting areas of
high natural and amenity value
Provide for staging of the intensification programme and to ensure that development of quality
infrastructure precedes intensification
460/1145
Sub#/
Recognise the potential for future volcanic events in the existing urban Auckland area by
seeking an urban form which duplicates resources in areas of the region that are outside the
volcanic field and able to be serviced from the rest of the country in the event of an eruption.
6911-7 Alicia Warren alicia.warrennz@gmail.com Residential zones Residential
policies
Include new zones that resolve the tension between accommodating growth and preserving
character in some areas.
Recognise the geography of Auckland when determining the location of intensification with
the goal of reducing travelling distance to the three Central Business Districts, Albany, the city
centre, and Manukau by intensifying around these areas and aligning infrastructure delivery.
quality compact urban form Ensure adequate urban open space is provided as intensification occurs.
6911-10 Alicia Warren alicia.warrennz@gmail.com RPS Rural B8 Strategic
Retain the provisions that protect land with high productive capability and protect areas with
high natural or amenity values.
6911-11 Alicia Warren alicia.warrennz@gmail.com RPS
coastal environment Retain ONLs and their mapping as an RPS tool.
features Retain the identified ONLs and amend them to reflect Plan Change 8 to the operative RPS
features Increase the level of protection afforded to ONLs
features
Insert an amenity landscapes overlay and provisions to maintain and enhance the values of
such areas
coastal environment Extend the ONC overlay to include all areas with outstanding natural character values
coastal environment Retain the provisions that protect the values of ONC areas
6911-17 Alicia Warren alicia.warrennz@gmail.com Rural Zones
obs & pols Extend the Rural Coastal Zone to include the entire coastal environment.
character and natural heritage B4.3.4 Biodiversity Add a new issue which acknowledges the threats to biodiversity and need for action
Add a new objective that seeks to achieve no net loss and preferably a net gain in biodiversity
across the Auckland region.
Amend the policies to require adherence to the mitigation hierarchy [avoid first, and remedies
or mitigate only if avoidance is not possible].
Amend the policies to provide clear direction on the implementation of biodiversity offsetting,
including the articulation of principles of offsetting
character and natural heritage B4.3.4 Biodiversity Provide additional non-regulatory methods for managing biodiversity.
character and natural heritage B4.3.4 Biodiversity Retain the SEA layer, subject to amendments
coastal environment Retain ONCs as an RPS tool.
character and natural heritage B4.3.4 Biodiversity Enable the SEA layer to be extended by a process other than a plan change.
Add regional objectives and policies relating to SEAs [in addition to the RPS level provisions
for biodiversity].
6911-27 Alicia Warren alicia.warrennz@gmail.com
SEAs
Areas - Land rules (all) Amend the rules to provide a greater level of protection for SEAs
SEAs
and policies
Amend the rules to provide a greater level of protection for trees and vegetation, particularly in
sensitive areas
character and natural heritage B4.3.3 Trees and vegetation Add an additional category of scheduled trees to enable more trees to be protected.
character and natural heritage B4.3.4 Biodiversity Place a greater focus on enhancement of biodiversity.
the CMA
sch. 6.2 ONC/HNC
6.1 Schedule SEA
Marine 1 and 2 Identify additional SEA Marine areas through a robust assessment process
6911-32 Alicia Warren alicia.warrennz@gmail.com Earthworks H4.2.2 Controls
Include additional controls to reduce sedimentation of the CMA, particularly non-point source
discharges in the rural area.
the CMA
D5.1.14 Background,
Strengthen provisions which manage aquaculture to ensure important values within the
coastal environment are protected whilst enabling aquaculture to occur in appropriate
locations.
461/1145
Sub#/
the CMA Mangroves
and policies
Amend mangrove removal provisions to ensure the ability to remove mangroves in areas
where they are expanding is based on a robust technical basis and is linked to management
of sediment-generating activities
6911-35 Alicia Warren alicia.warrennz@gmail.com Natural Hazards and Flooding Natural Hazards H4.11.1 Activity table Prohibit new development in areas subject to coastal hazards including sea level rise
6911-36 Alicia Warren alicia.warrennz@gmail.com RPS Coastal
environment
Ensure any residual adverse effects of coastal / marine activities are offset to achieve no net
loss, preferably net gain
6911-37 Alicia Warren alicia.warrennz@gmail.com RPS Issues
Retain the following issues: loss or degradation of waterbodies; degradation of water quality;
and demand for freshwater use.
6911-38 Alicia Warren alicia.warrennz@gmail.com RPS Natural resources
B6.3 Freshwater and
Geothermal Water
Amend the objectives to prevent further loss or degradation of waterbodies by; improving the
quality of freshwater; and maintaining flows and levels.
B6.3 Freshwater and
Geothermal Water
Retain the focus of freshwater management on stormwater runoff, wastewater overflows,
nutrients and sediment discharges.
B6.3 Freshwater and
Geothermal Water
Amend the objective of progressively reducing freshwater use, to ensure no increase in
freshwater use
B6.3 Freshwater and
Geothermal Water
Retain the overlays identifying high value freshwater bodies and freshwater bodies with
particular management issues
B6.3 Freshwater and
Geothermal Water Use additional factors to identify additional Natural Stream Management Areas
B6.3 Freshwater and
Geothermal Water Retain provisions which require avoidance of adverse effects in high value freshwater bodies
6911-44 Alicia Warren alicia.warrennz@gmail.com Water
policies
ecosystem guidelines App.5.6 Retain the use of the Macroinvertebrate Community Index for interim water quality limits
6911-45 Alicia Warren alicia.warrennz@gmail.com Water
policies
ecosystem guidelines App.5.6 Amend the Macroinvertebrate Community Index water quality limits in urban and rural areas
B6.3 Freshwater and
Geothermal Water
Strengthen provisions, particularly those affecting stormwater runoff, wastewater overflows,
nutrients and sediment discharges, to ensure the objectives will be achieved
change Retain climate change as a regionally significant issue.
6911-48 Alicia Warren alicia.warrennz@gmail.com RPS Climate change Retain the mitigate and adapt approach to managing this issue.
6911-49 Alicia Warren alicia.warrennz@gmail.com RPS Climate change Retain methods to reduce reliance on private motor vehicles.
6911-50 Alicia Warren alicia.warrennz@gmail.com RPS Climate change
Require all new development to implement best practice sustainable design, energy efficient
design, and water sensitive design and strengthen existing requirements.
6911-51 Alicia Warren alicia.warrennz@gmail.com RPS Climate change
Avoid hard engineering methods to reduce the risk from sea level rise, particularly for new
development.
6911-52 Alicia Warren alicia.warrennz@gmail.com RPS Climate change Include methods setting out how council will respond to climate change threats
6911-53 Alicia Warren alicia.warrennz@gmail.com Precincts - West
Area
objectives and policies Prohibit subdivision in the Waitakere Ranges.
6911-54 Alicia Warren alicia.warrennz@gmail.com Precincts - West
Include the Quarry Management Plan and rules for the Whitaker Quarry from the legacy plan
[Auckland District Plan, Waitakere Section].
6911-55 Alicia Warren alicia.warrennz@gmail.com Precincts - North Long Bay
Amend the plan for the Long Bay and Okura areas to reflect Environment Court Decisions
including Long Bay-Okura Great Park Society Inc v North Shore City Council (NZEnvC
A078/08, 16 July 2008)
Amend the PAUP to reflect the the 2013 census and ensure that rezoning for urban growth
outside 2010 MUL does not prematurely result in excessive provision for growth in that area,
particularly where that may mean a lesser proportion (than 60%) of actual growth occurs
within the 2010 MUL.
quality compact urban form Retain the urban growth provisions and the RUB as an RPS tool.
6911-58 Alicia Warren alicia.warrennz@gmail.com RPS General B10 RPS - Methods, Table 1
Add non-regulatory methods including the use of targeted rates to monitor and enforce
permitted activity controls, the establishment / continuation of an Environmental Response
Team or similar providing targeted engagement with sectors and the community on specific
environmental issues.
6911-59 Alicia Warren alicia.warrennz@gmail.com RPS General B10 RPS - Methods, Table 1 Include detail to describe how the methods in the RPS will be implemented.
6911-60 Alicia Warren alicia.warrennz@gmail.com RPS Issues New Issues
Include an Issue that addresses the loss and degradation of biodiversity and ecosystem
function.
growth
Refer to the adverse effects of peripheral urban growth on the coastal environment,
outstanding and amenity landscapes, outstanding natural features, ecological health,
biodiversity and the future provision of ecological linkages.
heritage Include a reference to the need to restore natural heritage within the region.
462/1145
Sub#/
heritage
Include a statement which makes it clear that cumulative effects of subdivision, use and
development on natural character, landscape and features need to be effectively managed.
heritage
Include explicit reference to the indigenous biodiversity challenge of halting the further loss of
important marine habitats and restoring those which have been lost.
heritage
Include specific reference to the need to manage the adverse effects of marine activities as
well as land use.
heritage
Include a statement on the importance of carefully managing landscapes which contribute to
amenity.
Clarify the three key issues 1.Loss or fragmentation of rivers, stream, wetlands and their
margins 2.Degradation of water quality, in particular due to stormwater and wastewater in
urban areas and nutrients and sediment in rural areas 3. Demand for freshwater, in particular
due to the growth of Auckland and constraints on supply due to climatic and land use factors,
and resulting ecological effects of water takes.
Clarify that there are areas of the coastal environment, including those identified as HNCs,
ONCs, ONFs, ONLs and SEAs where further development and further subdivision that may
result in development in those areas is not appropriate.
Expand the explanation to introduce a balanced recognition of all matters important to
sustainable management of the rural environment.
change Retain the identification of climate change as a regionally significant issue.
change Retain the identification of Challenges for Auckland.
change Retain the adoption of a mitigate and adapt approach to climate change.
change Amend to recognise increased droughts will increase importance of freshwater management.
change Provide further information about energy use for transport.
change Amend adaptation section to address challenges relating to freshwater and biodiversity.
Amend objectives 2 and 3 as follows: 2) Up to 70 per cent of total new dwellings by 2040
occurs is occurring within the metropolitan area 2010. 3) Up to No more than 40 per cent of
total new dwellings by 2040 occurs has occurred outside of the metropolitan area 2010.
Retain Policy 3(a) [ avoiding urban development within areas having identified significant...
values]
land for urban development Amend Policy 3(f) to refer to projected sea level rise over 100 years.
Identify how each area of Future Urban zoned land has been prioritised for urban
development, either by way of allocating a date for each area (first preference as relief) or by
including a priority order of introduction of development within each area.
Amend Policy 4 by adding a new sub clause (h) which reads: no Future Urban zoned land will
be rezoned for urban development unless it can be shown that urban development in
Auckland is proceeding at a rate that exceeds 60% of urban growth occurring within the 2010
MUL.
Clarify that no further Future Urban zoned land should be rezoned for urban purposes unless
there is confidence that the proportion of inside 2010 vs outside 2010 Metropolitan Urban
Limit will be no less than 60% inside and no more than 40% outside on a continuing basis.
Amend to provide for an emerging land release strategy and associated forward land and
infrastructure delivery programme that sets out priorities for the introduction of Future Urban
Zoned land.
and villages
Retain Policy 1(k) [avoiding expansion of rural and coastal villages into side, places and areas
with specific values...]
recreation facilities Retain Policy 6 [providing for the physical connection of public open space...]
Transport
and energy
Amend Objective 3 to refer to the need to avoid adverse effects on ONLs in the coastal
environment, areas with ONC, and threatened species and habitats referred to in Policy 11(a)
of the NZCPS and any other natural values.
463/1145
Sub#/
coastal environment
Amend the introduction by deleting the reference to areas of ONC and HNC as being
unmodified areas of the coastal environment.
coastal environment
Amend the introduction to include reference to landscapes which contribute to the amenity of
the region as being part of the regions natural heritage.
coastal environment Amend Objective 1 to include a reference to avoiding adverse effects on areas with ONC.
coastal environment Retain Objective 2 [preserve the natural character of coastal areas...]
coastal environment Retain Objective 3 [restoring or rehabilitating areas of degraded natural character...]
coastal environment Amend Policy 1 to include a reference to avoiding adverse effects on areas with ONC.
coastal environment
Retain Policy 2 [promoting practices and projects that will restore and rehabilitate natural
character values...].
coastal environment
Remove the reference to "minimise" from Policy 5(a) to avoid or minimise adverse physical
and visual effects on ONC/HNC areas.
coastal environment
Amend Policy 7 to also exclude HNC areas from being recipient areas for transferable
development rights.
coastal environment Retain Policy 8 [ avoiding subdivision use and development in ONC areas...].
coastal environment
Retain Policy 10 [require development to be undertaken outside HNC areas where there is an
alternative..]
features
Amend the introduction, second paragraph, to make it clear that new development should be
avoided in ONLs
features Amend Objective 1 to refer to avoiding adverse effects on ONLs and ONFs.
features
Remove the word cumulative from Policy 5(d) - avoid adverse cumulative effects on the
outstanding natural landscape.
6911-
100 Alicia Warren alicia.warrennz@gmail.com RPS
features Amend Policy 9 to clarify that adverse effects on ONLs should be avoided.
6911-
features
Amend Policy 16 and the accompanying explanation to provide effective means of protecting
ONLs including through stating that adverse effects are to be avoided and that new
subdivision, use and development is to be located outside ONLs.
6911-
Amend Objective 1 so that it specifies what it seeks to achieve in a manner that is
measurable. In particular that the objective is to maintain and enhance the quality and extent
of trees and vegetation.
6911-
Retain Objective 2 [the contribution of trees and vegetation to the maintenance of indigenous
biodiversity and provision of ecosystem services is enhanced].
6911-
Amend Objective 3 to include reference to vegetation. Further, the reference to retention
should be augmented with a requirement to maintain and enhance both cover and quality.
6911-
Amend to establish an additional form of Notable Tree recognition and provide appropriate
protection rules for this category of trees, recognising those trees that fall slightly under the
threshold, but that will mature over time to become strong Notable examples. Such examples
may be subject to more lenient pruning conditions or other flexibility.
6911-
character and natural heritage B4.3.3 Trees and vegetation Amend Policy 2 to refer to protect and include reference to vegetation.
6911-
character and natural heritage B4.3.3 Trees and vegetation Amend Policy 3 to include reference to trees and groups of trees
6911-
character and natural heritage B4.3.3 Trees and vegetation Amend Policy 4 to include reference to vegetation.
6911-
Amend Policy 5 as follows: Maintain or enhance the number and quality of Recognise the
benefit public trees and vegetation provided within roads and in reserves while acknowledging
the multiple uses of these spaces.
6911-
Include further tree protection provisions in identified areas, including the coast and other
sensitive areas. For example, areas identified in the draft Unitary Plan as coastal tree and
urban tree layers should be included by identifying the properties in a schedule.
6911-
character and natural heritage B4.3.4 Biodiversity Retain recognition of the importance of biodiversity and the threats to biodiversity in Auckland.
6911-
Amend the introduction to make express reference to that fact that much of the CMA has not
been comprehensively surveyed for the purpose of identifying SEA-Marine. For this reason a
strong precautionary approach needs to be taken when considering activities which may
impact on the CMA.
464/1145
Sub#/
6911-
Include additional SEA-Marine areas, and provide objectives, policies and rules having
undertaken a technically robust identification of areas of significant ecological importance
within the CMA.
6911-
Add a new category SEA- Marine overlay for the habitat of the Mauis dolphin. Include
appropriate objectives, policies and rules. Refer submission for detail [pg21,22 / 98].
6911-
Add a new category SEA-Marine overlay for the habitat of the Bryde's whale, including
appropriate objectives, policies and rules. Refer submission for detail [pg22/98].
6911-
Include snapper spawning areas in the SEA Marine overlays and include provisions to avoid
structures and activities likely to generate sediment or contaminants affecting the areas.
Refer submission for detail [pg22 / 98].
6911-
Include benthic habitats of significance to snapper and other fish species in the SEA-Marine
overlays and avoid activities which could adversely affect them. Refer submission for detail
[pg22/98].
6911-
Include rocky reef systems in the SEA-Marine overlays and protect them from sediment,
contaminants, aquaculture, structures and activities which may disturb the seabed. Refer
submission for details [pg22/98].
6911-
Include benthic habitat in the Ponui and Motuihe channels in the SEA-Marine overlay and
protect them from activities which might adversely impact on them. Refer submission for
details [pg22,23/98]
6911-
Include marine areas adjacent to conservation land in the SEA-Marine overlays and
provisions to protect them in order to provide a buffer for indigenous species in these areas to
enable an extension of conservation areas from the land into the sea.
6911-
Include significant shellfish beds in the SEA-Marine overlays and provisions to protect them
from sediment, contaminants, structures, aquaculture and other activities which may disturb
the seabed or water column.
6911-
Extend the SEA marine overlay to cover the entire extent of areas important to birds including
(but not limited to) those within the Kaipara and Manukau Harbours.
6911-
Provide for the identification of further SEAs within the CMA throughout the life of the Unitary
Plan through providing a set of criteria and providing for their application, including during the
resource consenting process.
6911-
Amend Objective 1 to refer to adverse effects on threatened or at risk species being avoided
while retaining consistency with section 6(c).
6911-
Amend Objective 2 as follows: Indigenous biodiversity is maintained, protected and enhanced
through restoration and legal protection, particularly where ecological values have been
degraded or where development is occurring.
6911-
Amend Objective 3 as follows: The natural heritage features of the Waitakere Ranges
heritage area and the Hauraki Gulf/Te Moana Nui o Toi/Tikapa Moana are protected and
restored.
6911-
Include specific policies and methods to implement the Hauraki Gulf Marine Park Act 2000
and Waitakere Ranges Heritage Area Act 2008.
6911-
Amend Policy 1 to include criteria relevant to the CMA and to ensure that they are adequate
to comply with policy 11 of the NZCPS and that they enable all ecologically significant areas
within the coastal marine area to be identified to enable their effective protection.
6911-
Amend Policy 1 to strengthen the criteria for identifying significant biodiversity. Refer
submission for details [pg24,25/98].
6911-
Retain in Policy 1 the use of criteria for identifying significant biodiversity and the approach
that one criterion needs to be triggered for a site to qualify as an SEA.
6911-
Amend Policy 1 to have due regard to significant habitats of indigenous fauna in criteria for
protection of areas on land and sea.
6911-
character and natural heritage B4.3.4 Biodiversity Retain all criteria in Policy 1 [criteria for identifying SEAs].
6911-
Amend Policy 1 to include the five categories set out in the proposed National Policy
Statement for Indigenous Biodiversity.
6911-
Amend Policy 1 to strengthen the criteria for identifying areas of significant biodiversity and
make them sufficiently clear to enable assessment and ensure that opportunities to recognise
ecological values are maximised.
6911-
Amend the relevant rules to reference the SEA criteria so they can apply in the course of
resource management processes (e.g. consenting) rather than solely be used in the one-off
event of SEA identification.
6911-
character and natural heritage B4.3.4 Biodiversity Enable the SEA assessment process to be undertaken and the layer added to at any time.
6911-
character and natural heritage B4.3.4 Biodiversity Retain the approach to the identification (including mapping) of SEAs.
465/1145
Sub#/
6911-
Amend Policy 2 to identify areas that enhance indigenous biodiversity values, or make a
significant contribution to providing ecosystem services, and include objectives, policies and
rules in order to protect the values of those areas.
6911-
139 Alicia Warren alicia.warrennz@gmail.com Definitions New Amend the definitions to include a definition of an SEA.
6911-
Amend Policy 6 to ensure that all more than minor adverse effects are avoided across all
SEAs.
6911-
Amend Policy 6(a)(iii) to also explicitly refer to other important marine habitats including (but
not limited to) horse mussel beds, sponge gardens and benthic biogenic structures
6911-
Amend Policy 7 to ensure the no net loss concept is applied to all indigenous biodiversity
(not just significant indigenous biodiversity) to enable the Council to achieve its function of
maintaining indigenous biodiversity.
6911-
Amend Policy 8 to clarify the intent of the policy and to make clear that the list cannot be
exhaustive.
6911-
Amend Policy 11(b) to use a more appropriate term such as features to ensure that the SEA
protection is not only vegetation-focussed.
6911-
Amend policy 11(b) to include numeric thresholds as follows or similar: minimising the loss of
native biodiversity by retaining all native vegetation within SEAs except where loss is
unavoidable to create a single building platform per site for a dwelling and associated
services, access and car parking to a maximum area of XXXm2. XXX = lesser of 100 m2 or
5% of the site (including house, driveway and water tank).
6911-
Amend Policy 11(c) to clarify intent. i.e. future needs = future demands to clear or damage
areas of significant indigenous biodiversity
6911-
character and natural heritage B4.3.4 Biodiversity Retain Policy 11(d)
6911-
Amend Policy 11 (e) as follows or similar: Enhancing maintaining existing water quality with a
net reduction no increase in the amount of sediment entering natural waterways, wetlands and
groundwater. Consequential amendments to methods and monitoring.
6911-
Amend Policy 12(b) as follows or similar: requiring legal protection of areas set aside for the
purposes of mitigating or offsetting adverse effects on indigenous biodiversity
6911-
Amend Policy 12 by including a new sub clause (c) as follows: requiring ecological restoration
and active ongoing management techniques in areas set aside for the purposes of mitigating
or offsetting adverse effects on indigenous biodiversity
6911-
Amend to include a new policy to guide implementation of biodiversity offsetting. The new
policy should provide guidance as to key principles applying to biodiversity offsetting:
equivalence, spatial proximity, additionality, timing, duration, compliance, and currencies and
ratios.
6911-
Amend Policy 13(a) to clarify intent of policy. E.g. provision of further opportunities for
threatened ecosystems = recreation /restoration / rehabilitation / protection of threatened
ecosystems
6911-
Correct Policy 13(g) as follows: use, where possible, of indigenous species sourced from
naturally growing plants in the vicinity of the re-vegetation site, and from places which match
the climactic and environmental conditions
6911-
character and natural heritage B4.3.4 Biodiversity Correct Policy 13(h) by replacing kaitiakitang with kaitiakitangi
6911-
character and natural heritage B4.3.4 Biodiversity Amend Policy 14(a) by deleting the words regular or sustained
6911-
character and natural heritage B4.3.4 Biodiversity Amend Policy 14(a) by deleting the word noticeably
6911-
character and natural heritage B4.3.4 Biodiversity Retain in Policy 14(a) the or in front of results in permanent abandonment of an area
6911-
Amend Policy 14(a) to include a suitable parentage reduction threshold for the level of
migratory bird activity.
6911-
Amend Policy 14 to include reference to the degradation or destruction of habitats of
importance to fisheries including fish spawning, pupping and nursery areas in the CMA
6911-
Amend Policy 14 to include reference to the degradation or destruction of habitats within the
CMA which support diverse marine communities
6911-
character and natural heritage B4.3.4 Biodiversity Amend Policy 14 to include reference to increased risk to threatened and at risk seabirds
6911-
Amend Policy 18 to include an additional subsection that requires disturbance of at risk or
threatened species and of benthic habitats in Marine SEAs by fishing activities, such as
trawling, dredging and set-netting to be avoided.
6911-
Amend Policies 14-21 so that the provisions within them also apply to any other areas which
have ecological values meriting identification as Marine SEAs.
466/1145
Sub#/
6911-
character and natural heritage B4.3.4 Biodiversity Amend Policy 14-21 as required to comply with Policy 11 of the NZCPS.
6911-
character and natural heritage B4.3.4 Biodiversity Retain the methods listed.
6911-
character and natural heritage B4.3.4 Biodiversity Amend to provide additional detail regarding the methods listed.
6911-
Amend methods to include further non-regulatory methods e.g. Council ensuring adequate
pest control in reserves, regional parks and stormwater network.
6911-
Amend the plan to include maps identifying important bird areas in accordance with Appendix
B of the submissions [pg 90,91/98] within the SEA overlay or another category of overlay.
6911-
Include a new objective and policy to apply to identified Important Bird Areas in accordance
with Appendix B of the submissions [pg 90,91/98]. Refer submission for details [pg29,30/98].
6911-
Include new rules and assessment criteria for activities in identified Important Bird Areas in
accordance with Appendix B of the submissions [pg 90,91/98]. Refer submission for details
[pg29,30/98].
6911-
character and natural heritage B4.3.4 Biodiversity Provide express recognition of Important Bird Areas and the threats facing them.
6911-
character and natural heritage B4.3.4 Biodiversity Include additional assessment criteria for activities in important bird habitats.
6911-
character and natural heritage B4.3.4 Biodiversity Include Important Bird Areas in marine and terrestrial SEA overlays.
6911-
character and natural heritage B4.3.4 Biodiversity Include rules applying to activities in the identified Important Bird Areas.
6911-
175 Alicia Warren alicia.warrennz@gmail.com RPS Natural resources
B6.3 Freshwater and
Geothermal Water
Amend the objectives so that they flow from three issues [freshwater systems, freshwater
quality, freshwater quantity] and they clearly identify the outcomes that are to be achieved in a
specific and measurable manner and they give effect to the National Policy Statement for
Freshwater Management 2011. Refer submission for detail [pg30,31/98].
6911-
B6.3 Freshwater and
Geothermal Water
Amend Policy 1 [Integrated management of land use and freshwater] by: amending (a) to
require that these matters are ensured before areas are identified for growth or intensification;
retaining (b); moving (c) to stormwater policy; deleting adequately from (d) and requiring
mitigation to achieve a net reduction in adverse effects compared to the current situation and
adding additional matters which relate to integrated management, including consideration of
coastal ecosystems when assessing freshwater plans and consent applications including
sedimentation effects.
6911-
B6.3 Freshwater and
Geothermal Water
Amend Policy 2 by retaining (a), retaining (b), amending (c) to direct at protecting and
enhancing natural character, retaining (b), amending (e) to add a requirement to achieve no
net loss of freshwater bodies (through enhancement or restoration) where permanent
diversion is necessary for public health and safety or significant infrastructure, moving (f) and
(g) to stormwater policy, amending (h) to existing riparian vegetation and to provide for
restoration of riparian vegetation, retaining (i).
6911-
B6.3 Freshwater and
Geothermal Water
Amend policy 3 by deleting where practicable and otherwise minimise and reduce, referring
to the setting of freshwater objectives and limits and avoiding over- allocation which is the
framework required by the National Policy Statement for Freshwater Management 2011,
address outstanding water bodies and wetlands and strongly provide for their protection
through avoidance of adverse effects retaining (e)(i) to (iii) and addressing stormwater,
wastewater, nutrients and sediment more specifically through individual policies.
6911-
B6.3 Freshwater and
Geothermal Water
Amend Policy 6 to link limits to the objective - to safeguard the life-supporting capacity and
ecosystem processes of freshwater and to address existing over-allocation through review of
consents and phase out.
6911-
B6.3 Freshwater and
Geothermal Water
Amend Policy 7 to be clear that groundwater takes must not exceed the recharge rate and
require a buffer to account for uncertainties.
6911-
B6.3 Freshwater and
6911-
B6.3 Freshwater and
Geothermal Water Add a new policy addressing how the allocable volume of freshwater will be allocated.
6911-
B6.3 Freshwater and
Geothermal Water
Add a new policy requiring efficient use of freshwater. New development should be required to
meet rigorous standards. Improvements to existing uses should be facilitated. Education is
required. Pricing and regulatory signals should be utilised.
467/1145
Sub#/
6911-
B6.3 Freshwater and
Geothermal Water
Amend Policy 9 to provide more stringent controls for sensitive areas, add additional matters
relevant to sediment runoff including land management practices and riparian vegetation
management and amend to provide for catchment wide sediment management approaches.
6911-
B6.3 Freshwater and
Geothermal Water
Amend policy 10 to provide that the objective is to progressively reduce the net effects of
stormwater compared to the current baseline and the achievement of freshwater limits/targets
and clarify by splitting the policy into (a) effects of future activities (b) existing effects.
6911-
B6.3 Freshwater and
Geothermal Water
Amend Policy 11 to provide that the objective is to progressively reduce the net effects of
wastewater compared to the current baseline and the achievement of freshwater
limits/targets.
6911-
B6.3 Freshwater and
Geothermal Water
Add a new policy directed at nutrient discharges indicating that the objective to be achieved is
to progressively reduce nutrient discharges compared to the current baseline to achieve
freshwater limits/targets and set out how this will be achieved for example through
requirements for farm management plans, effluent management, stock exclusion, bridges and
culverts, fertiliser application levels, wetland restoration, riparian planting, etc.
6911-
B6.3 Freshwater and
Geothermal Water
Add a new policy addressing freshwater recreational matters, including public access (from
Policy 2(g)) and social values (from Policy 2(c)).
6911-
B6.3 Freshwater and
Geothermal Water
Amend the methods [for freshwater and geothermal water to ensure they provide sufficient
detail and breadth for the achievement of the objectives.
6911-
B6.3 Freshwater and
Geothermal Water Add objectives policies and methods relating to wetlands and the beds of lakes and rivers.
6911-
191 Alicia Warren alicia.warrennz@gmail.com RPS Coastal B7 Introduction Amend the introduction to include a description of the CMA of the region outside harbours.
6911-
192 Alicia Warren alicia.warrennz@gmail.com RPS Coastal
environment
Amend Objective 1 so that it refers to subdivision, use and development in the coastal
environment being designed and located to ensure that the natural character of the coastal
environment is preserved and where practicable enhanced.
6911-
environment
Add an additional objective which refers to the design and location of subdivision, use and
development in the coastal environment reducing discharges into the CMA.
6911-
environment
Amend Policy 2(b) so that it also refers to the need to avoid degradation of areas with high
landscape values and areas with high natural character values.
6911-
environment
Include an additional policy which makes it clear that no further canal developments will be
permitted within the Auckland region.
6911-
environment
Include an additional policy that addresses new marina proposals. This should make it clear
that marinas will not be appropriate where a strong need for them is not established and will
not be permitted to locate in estuaries, in places subject to sedimentation, in areas with
significant natural or cultural values, or in places where any significant ongoing dredging will
be required.
6911-
quality
Include provisions in the regional and district plan sections to give effect to section 7.3 of the
RPS which addresses areas of degraded water quality.
6911-
quality
Include the degraded marine areas shown in Figure 2, page B130 [B7.3] as an overlay and
appropriate objectives, policies and rules provided (such as additional controls on sediment
generation and contaminated discharges from catchments draining into these areas) which
ensure that there is no further decline in these areas and that their quality improves over time.

6911-
Expand the areas identified as SEA Marine to include all known areas significant to the
ecological and biodiversity values of the Gulf and vulnerable to modification and provide an
effective mechanism to protect areas which could potentially be identified in the future through
a resource consenting process, such as a list of criteria, tailored to the Gulfs CMA, which
could be applied.
6911-
Gulf
Add an additional policy to make it clear that no further canal developments will be permitted
within the Hauraki Gulf Marine Park.
6911-
201 Alicia Warren alicia.warrennz@gmail.com RPS Rural B8.1 Rural activities
Amend Objective 3 as follows: No subdivision, urban activity or any other development occurs
in Aucklands rural areas that adversely affects the lands productive potential, biodiversity
values, landscape values, rural character or amenity values.
6911-
202 Alicia Warren alicia.warrennz@gmail.com RPS Rural B8.1 Rural activities
Reword Policy 3 [manage activities in rural areas] to improve it. Refer submission for detail
[pg36,37/98].
6911-
203 Alicia Warren alicia.warrennz@gmail.com RPS Climate change
Amend the introduction to include a description and explanation of the Natural Hazards
Coastal Inundation overlay and how it is linked to an effective response to climate change.
6911-
204 Alicia Warren alicia.warrennz@gmail.com RPS Climate change Retain Objective 1.
468/1145
Sub#/
6911-
205 Alicia Warren alicia.warrennz@gmail.com RPS Climate change Amend Objective 2 to add reference to additional mitigation types.
6911-
Amend Policy 1 by amending (b) to require all new dwellings and buildings to achieve the
standard, amending (c) to require all new dwellings and buildings to achieve the standard,
retaining (d), amending (f) to ensure all new neighbours achieve the standard, and retaining
(a), (e), (g), (h) and (i).
6911-
Amend Policy 2 by amending (a) to require new development to incorporate sustainable
design, amending (b) to provide clear direction as to how effects on indigenous biodiversity
will be reduced, amend (c) to ensure risk minimisation and avoidance of hard engineering
methods, amending (d) to specify that new development and infrastructure will not occur in
areas subject to sea level rise over the next 100 years.
6911-
Amend the regulatory methods [B9, Responding to Climate Change] to provide clear links to
the relevant objectives, policies and rules.
6911-
Provide additional non-regulatory methods [B9, Responding to Climate Change] to implement
the policies effectively.
6911-
Amend the explanation [B9, Responding to Climate Change] to ensure matters are addressed
equitably.
6911-
211 Alicia Warren alicia.warrennz@gmail.com RPS General
Amend the Environmental Results Anticipated to express an actual result by being specific,
numerical and time-bound to enable effective monitoring and evaluation.
6911-
212 Alicia Warren alicia.warrennz@gmail.com Infrastructure
C1.1 Infrastructure
policies
Amend Objective 1 to ensure new infrastructure is located in a manner that takes into account
climate change predictions for the next 100 years and risk to existing infrastructure from
climate change is minimised while avoiding hard engineering methods
6911-
213 Alicia Warren alicia.warrennz@gmail.com Trees
streets and public open space C4.1 Objectives and Policies Retain Objective 2.
6911-
Amend Objective 3 as follows or similar: Enable the efficient maintenance and upgrading of
utilities in streets provided there is not net loss while achieving a net gain in the extent and
quality values of trees or groups of trees.
6911-
215 Alicia Warren alicia.warrennz@gmail.com Earthworks
and policies
Add an objective which states that earthworks are to be undertaken in a manner which
ensures that there is no increase in sedimentation entering areas of degraded water quality as
identified in section 7.3 of the RPS.
6911-
and policies
Amend Objective 1 to provide a clear measurable objective which requires that all earthworks
are minimised and undertaken in accordance with best practice techniques to minimise
effects of earthworks on people and the environment.
6911-
and policies Amend Objective 3 to provide a clear direction as to the extent of minimisation sought.
6911-
and policies Delete remedy or mitigate from Policy 1 [Avoid, remedy or mitigate the adverse effects...].
6911-
and policies
Amend Policy 2 by adding a paragraph requiring earthworks to be avoided in sensitive
locations.
6911-
and policies
Amend Policy 5 by amending (a) to prevent significant short term effects, (b) to require
avoidance where Macroinvertebrate Community Index limits are not met, (c) to require
avoidance in sensitive locations and (d) to require other effects to be avoided, remedied or
mitigated.
6911-
221 Alicia Warren alicia.warrennz@gmail.com
SEAs
and policies Retain the description.
6911-
SEAs
and policies
Amend Objective 1 to state: The ecosystem services and indigenous biological diversity
values of vegetation in sensitive environments and areas of contiguous native vegetation
cover are recognised, and maintained and enhanced while providing for reasonable use and
development .
6911-
Rural Discharges,
Biosolids
Discharges
Amend Objective 1 to provide a clear measurable objective that seeks to ensure land/water
quality is maintained where it currently safeguards life supporting capacity and is improved
where it currently does not.
6911-
Rural Discharges,
Biosolids
Discharges
Amend Policy 1 to set out how good water quality will be maintained and poor water quality
will be improved. I.e. different management frameworks depending on current status.
6911-
Rural Discharges,
Biosolids
Discharges
Amend Policy 2 to prefer discharges to land over discharges to water and clearly set out
requirements for discharge systems to avoid (not minimise) overland flow and leaching.
6911-
Rural Discharges,
Biosolids
469/1145
Sub#/
6911-
Rural Discharges,
Biosolids
6911-
Rural Discharges,
Biosolids
Discharges
Amend Policy 5 to require that limits will not be exceeded and compliance with s70 [of the
Resource Management Act 1991].
6911-
229 Alicia Warren alicia.warrennz@gmail.com Natural Hazards and Flooding Natural Hazards
and policies
Amend Objective 2 so that it explicitly refers to discouraging the use of hard engineering
solutions.
6911-
and policies
Amend Policy 3 to insert an additional subsection which refers to the proposed activity not
creating any foreseeable need for coastal protection works over a 100 year time horizon.
6911-
and policies
Amend Policy 4 to include an additional subsection which refers to any adverse effects on
coastal flora or fauna, including restricting inland migration of biota in response to sea level
rise, or resulting in coastal squeeze where the intertidal area is reduced in extent.
6911-
and policies
Add an additional policy which indicates that any residual adverse effects of hard engineering
solutions which cannot be avoided, mitigated or remedied will be offset through restoration
and enhancement actions that achieve no net loss and preferably a net gain in terms of
impacts on natural heritage values of the coastal environment.
6911-
and policies
Amend the Objectives and Policies to refer to and effectively link into the Natural Hazards
Coastal Inundation Overlay.
6911-
234 Alicia Warren alicia.warrennz@gmail.com Water
streams & wetland
C5.14 Background &
Objectives
Amend Objective 1 to require the permanent loss of all lakes, rivers, streams and wetlands
and their margins to be avoided.
6911-
streams & wetland
C5.14 Background &
6911-
streams & wetland
C5.14 Background &
Objectives
Amend Objective 3 to require avoidance in areas with high values. In other locations, amend
to require offsets to achieve net environmental gain.
6911-
streams & wetland
C5.14 Background &
Objectives
Amend Objective 4 to provide that avoidance is required in areas with high values. In other
locations, avoidance is the first priority unless specified exceptions apply.
6911-
streams & wetland
C5.14 Background &
Objectives
Amend Objective 5 to specify the activities of concern, locations of significance and the extent
to which adverse effects must be minimised.
6911-
streams & wetland
C5.14 Background &
Objectives Amend Objective 6 to specify exceptions provided for in the policy and retain 'avoided'.
6911-
streams & wetland
Stock Access Retain Policy 1.
6911-
streams & wetland
6911-
streams & wetland
Stock Access Amend Policy 3 to ensure offsets only in respect of activities outside high value areas.
6911-
streams & wetland
Stock Access
Amend Policy 3 to retain offsetting principles and add further in accordance with Marie A.
Brown, Bruce D. Clarkson, R.T. Theo Stephens and Barry J. Barton (2014) Compensating for
ecological harm the state of play in New Zealand New Zealand Journal of Ecology 38 (1)
Pages: 139146.
6911-
streams & wetland
Stock Access Amend Policy 4 to make consistent with Policies 1 and 2.
6911-
streams & wetland
Stock Access
Amend Policy 6 as follows: Prevent unless . Exceptions do not apply in high value
areas. Add and before (e).
6911-
streams & wetland
Stock Access
Amend policy 7 as follows: Prevent unless Exceptions do not apply in high value
areas. Add and before (e).
6911-
streams & wetland
Stock Access Amend Policy 8 to prevent planting of any pest species.
470/1145
Sub#/
6911-
streams & wetland
Stock Access
Amend policy 10 to ensure reclamation or drainage is limited to situations specified in (b)(i)
where (a) and (c) are also satisfied. Delete (b)(ii).
6911-
streams & wetland
Amend Policy 11 to require stock exclusion from all water bodies and coastal water by [5/10
years following notification] and bridges and culverts for all stock crossings by [5 years
following notification].
6911-
streams & wetland
Stock Access
Amend Policy 12 to add how riparian margins will be protected and enhanced e.g. through
controls on vegetation removal, and requirements for riparian planting attached to water take
or discharge consents.
6911-
streams & wetland
6911-
policies
Objectives Retain the Background.
6911-
policies
6911-
policies
Objectives
Amend Objective 2 to require enhancement where the quality of water in the coastal
environment has deteriorated to the point where it has a significant adverse effect on
ecosystems.
6911-
policies
Objectives
Amend Objective 1 to require development to avoid further degradation and to achieve
enhancement.
6911-
policies
Objectives
Amend Objective 4 to require development to avoid further degradation and to achieve
enhancement.
6911-
policies
Amend Policy 1 to specify that Macroinvertebrate Community Index is used as an interim limit
for freshwater quality.
6911-
policies
Amend Policy 1 to delete where practicable. (b) Add timeframe of 1 July 2030. (c) Amend
to apply to all changes in land use.
6911-
policies
Amend Policy 1 by changing the Macroinvertebrate Community Index (MCI) limit for urban
areas to 90, changing the MCI limit for rural areas to 100 and retaining the MCI limit for native
and exotic forest.
6911-
policies
Amend the Appendix 5.6 map of Macroinvertebrate Community Index for landuse types if
necessary for accuracy.
6911-
policies
Amend Policy 3 to require enhancement where limits are not met. Where limits are met,
require enhancement where practicable.
6911-
policies
6911-
policies
Amend Policy 5 to require enhancement where limits are not met. Where limits are met
require enhancement where practicable.
6911-
policies
Policies 6-8 Integrated
management
Replace Policy 6 with a policy requiring management of use, development and subdivision to
avoid adverse effects on high value areas and to achieve limits in all areas.
6911-
policies
management Amend Policy 7(a) to emphasise planning or infrastructure in advance of development.
6911-
policies
management
Amend Policy 8 to set out what particular land use activities will be controlled, what sort of
controls will be utilised, and what those controls will seek to achieve in terms of
preventing/minimising adverse effects.
6911-
policies
management
Amend Policy 9 to: require other adverse effects to be avoided, remedied or mitigated;
making it apply to brownfield areas; amending (c) to indicate Council requirements; amending
(d) by deleting where practicable and requiring adoption of green infrastructure as a core
development approach.
471/1145
Sub#/
6911-
policies
management
Amend Policy 10 by: Transferring methods relevant to green and brownfields to Policy 9;
Restricting Policy 10 to addressing the unique challenges to intensification; Require an overall
reduction in adverse effects of stormwater runoff as intensification occurs compared to the
current baseline and include the methods that are relevant to intensification; Separating (f)
into a separate policy.
6911-
policies
management Retain Policy 11.
6911-
policies
management
Amend Policy 12 to require an overall reduction in contaminant concentration from new or
redeveloped activities.
6911-
policies
6911-
policies
management
Amend Policy 14: to apply to existing and new activities; to require overall reduction compared
to current; by deleting or minimise.
6911-
policies
management Retain policy 15.
6911-
policies
management
Amend Policy 16 to specify that stormwater hydrology should be mitigated to the extent that
will at a minimum offset the increase in impervious area.
6911-
policies
Policies 17,18 Groundwater
soakage
Amend policy 17 (c) to specify that the treatment must achieve a quality that will not result in
any reduction in the water quality of the underlying aquifer system.
6911-
policies
Policies 17,18 Groundwater
soakage
Amend Policy 18 to require that the quality of the discharge will not result in any reduction in
the water quality of the aquifer.
6911-
policies
Policies 19-22 Wastewater
network overflows and
discharges
Amend Policy 19 (d) to restrict to existing overflows while retaining the direction to avoid
increasing existing overflows or creating new overflows.
6911-
policies
discharges Retain policy 20.
6911-
policies
discharges
Amend Policy 21 to describe how the policy will be achieved i.e. adoption of best practicable
option, operations and maintenance plans, and response process.
6911-
policies
Objectives
Amend Objective 2 to provide for upgrading of wastewater and combined networks to address
design and capacity deficiencies in a staged timeframe.
6911-
policies Policy 23 Other discharges
Amend Policy 23 to provide for all other activities, specify that minimum performance
standards will reflect current best practice, and restrict (b) to situations where minimum
performance standards have not been developed due to prioritising development for the
discharges of most environmental concern.
6911-
policies
Objectives Add a new policy addressing sediment as set out in 1.B.6.3.9 [of the PAUP].
6911-
policies
Objectives Add a new policy addressing nutrients as set out in 1.B.6.3 [of the PAUP].
6911-
Objectives Retain the Background.
6911-
Objectives
Amend Objective 1 to maintain the flows and levels of waterbodies within limits which
safeguard the life-supporting capacity, ecosystems processes and indigenous species of
freshwater.
6911-
Objectives
Amend Objective 2 to efficiently manage current and future water needs within allocable
flows, including by progressively reducing the amount of freshwater used by Auckland per
capita so that there is no increase in freshwater use as a whole.
6911-
6911-
472/1145
Sub#/
6911-
allocation & use - obs & pols Policy 1 - Priority of water use
Amend Policy 1 by: replacing 'guidelines' with 'limits'; adding a requirement to take into
account the large commercial users who may utilise municipal water supply when prioritising
that use.
6911-
allocation & use - obs & pols Policy 2 - Efficient Use
Amend policy 2 to: require all municipal water supplies to provide a water management plan;
require water conservation and thermal efficiency methods in all new or redevelopment and
promote for existing development; add measures for efficient use of water.
6911-
Policy 3 - Water allocation
guidelines, availabilities and
limits Amend Policy 3 by replacing references to guidelines with limits.
6911-
water
Amend Policy 4 by amending: (b)(i) to refer to minimum flow limits; (c) to require proposals
that demonstrate how these measures will be implemented during water shortages and what
reductions can be achieved through these measures.
6911-
water
Amend Policy 5 by: amending (b) to require avoidance of adverse effects on surface water, or
alternatively count surface water depleting groundwater takes as a percentage surface water
takes; deleting (f).
6911-
water
Amend policy 6 to prevent take and use of water where significant adverse effects remain
following mitigation options.
6911-
water Retain Policy 7.
6911-
water
Amend Policy 8 to provide a timeframe for phasing out over-allocation in those catchments
which are already over-allocated.
6911-
water Amend Policy 9 to provide strong guarantees that natural flow variability will be maintained.
6911-
6911-
management Amend Policy 11 to provide for the identification of freshwater objectives.
6911-
management
Amend Policy 11 to provide timeframes for the stages of the process of 50% of catchments by
2020 and 100% of catchments by 2025, prioritising those known to have greater resource
management issues.
6911-
Policy 12 - Comprehensive
reviews of consents Retain Policy 12.
6911-
Policies 13-16 Damming of
surface water Retain Policy 13.
6911-
surface water
Amend Policy 14 by amending (a) to provide for consideration of new dams for municipal
water supply.
6911-
surface water
Amend Policy 15 by: amending (e) to add a requirement to avoid, remedy or mitigate other
adverse effects; requiring all adverse effects on high natural value areas (including SEAs) to
be avoided.
6911-
surface water Amend policy 16 to require additional monitoring to ensure flow variability is maintained.
6911-
allocation & use - obs & pols Policies 17-18 Diversions Amend policy 17 to add environmental effects to the paragraphs.
6911-
allocation & use - obs & pols Policies 17-18 Diversions Amend Policy 18 to add environmental effects to the paragraphs.
6911-
water Amend policy 19 to add avoiding adverse ecological effects, including effects on SEAs.
6911-
309 Alicia Warren alicia.warrennz@gmail.com Subdivision Auckland-wide - general
and policies
Add references in the explanation, objectives and policies to avoiding subdivision where it
may allow for development in HNCs, ONCs, ONFs, ONLs and SEAs
6911-
6911-
and policies Amend Policy 29 by including an additional subsection which refers to ONLs.
6911-
Add a new objective which indicates that any residual adverse effects which cannot be
avoided, mitigated or remedied will be offset through restoration and enhancement actions
that achieve no net loss and preferably a net gain in terms of impacts on natural heritage
values of the coastal environment.
6911-
Amend Policy 1 by including an additional subsection which refers to areas identified as
having ONC, an ONL or a SEA not being adversely affected.
6911-
Amend Policy 6 so that the word appropriate is replaced with the word necessary and is
followed by the words to protect public health or safety.
473/1145
Sub#/
6911-
Amend Policy 9 or include an additional policy that makes it clear that declamation of
unreclaimed land for residential/canal development will not be permitted.
6911-
Include an additional objective which states that material containing organisms of biosecurity
concern is not deposited within the CMA.
6911-
6911-
Amend Policy 4(a) so that it refers to areas with significant natural values including ONC, ONL
and SEAs.
6911-
the CMA
and policies
Add a provision which states that material containing organisms of biosecurity concern is not
deposited within the CMA.
6911-
the CMA
discharges of contaminants
and policies Amend Policy 2 so that it refers to areas with significant heritage values.
6911-
the CMA Mangroves
and policies
Add a provision in the background section making it clear that mangrove removal proposals
will only be considered when they are accompanied by a sediment management plan which
effectively addresses the transport of sediment into the CMA at the location where removal is
sought.
6911-
the CMA Mangroves
and policies
Add an objective to the effect that the removal of mangroves is only enabled where there is a
sediment management plan in place which effectively addresses the transport of sediment
into the CMA at the location where removal is sought.
6911-
the CMA Mangroves
and policies
Amend the policies so that they require a sediment management plan to be developed which
effectively addresses the transport of sediment into the CMA at the location where any
removal is sought.
6911-
the CMA Mangroves
and policies
Amend Policy 1(a) to remove the words identified as so that it refers to areas with significant
value.
6911-
the CMA Mangroves
6911-
the CMA Discharges
Amend the objectives and policies to give effect to Policy 7.3 of the RPS and Policy 21 of
NZCPS to ensure that areas where water quality is already degraded do not degrade further
and that their quality improves over time.
6911-
the CMA
and occupation
D5.1.13 Background,
objectives and policies Include a charging regime for occupation of the CMA.
6911-
the CMA
D5.1.14 Background,
Amend Objective 1 so that it refers to aquaculture being developed only in locations where
there are no conflicts with ecological, social and cultural values or with other uses.
6911-
the CMA
D5.1.14 Background,
Amend Policy 2 so that it includes a statement to the effect that a staged approach should not
be used where there is a risk of significant and/or irreversible effects and consent should be
declined in these circumstances.
6911-
the CMA
D5.1.14 Background,
Amend Policy 4 so that it refers to requiring aquaculture to be located outside of, and to be
located and designed to avoid adverse effects on the matters in the subsections of policy 4, to
be amended to include significant habitats, areas important to fisheries, shellfish and other
areas. Refer submission for details [pg.55/98].
6911-
the CMA
D5.1.14 Background,
Amend Policy 10 by deleting the word significant so that it refers to avoiding expansion of
aquaculture in the Mahurangi Harbour.
6911-
the CMA
D5.1.14 Background,
Include an additional policy which provides that aquaculture is not to be located in areas of the
CMA within 5 nautical miles of reserves, regional parks, sanctuaries or other conservation
land.
6911-
the CMA
D5.1.14 Background,
Include an additional objective which indicates that any residual adverse effects which cannot
be avoided, mitigated or remedied will be offset through restoration and enhancement actions
that achieve no net loss and preferably a net gain in terms of impacts on natural heritage
values of the coastal environment.
6911-
the CMA
and use
D5.1.15 Background,
Amend Policy 6 to remove the words identified as so that it refers to areas with significant
value.
6911-
the CMA
and use
D5.1.15 Background,
Amend Policy 13(a) so that it states that hard protection works are not be located below
MHWS or on public land unless there is a significant public or environmental benefit in doing
so.
6911-
the CMA
and use
D5.1.15 Background,
Amend Policy 14 to include an additional subclause to the effect that hard protection
structures are to be avoided when they may result in significant adverse effects on areas with
significant value.
474/1145
Sub#/
6911-
337 Alicia Warren alicia.warrennz@gmail.com Rural Zones General
Add an additional subclause to Policy 7 which refers to enabling forestry where it does not
result in the generation of additional sediment which may enter the CMA and where it will not
have an adverse effect on an ONL, ONC or HNC.
6911-
338 Alicia Warren alicia.warrennz@gmail.com Rural Zones
obs & pols
Amend Policy 3 so that it refers to: Providing for the continued operation of forestry; avoiding
forestry in areas identified as ONLs, SEAs and ONCs on overlay maps and ensuring new
forestry will not result in the sediment entering areas of degraded water quality. Refer
submission for detail [pg.57/98].
6911-
6911-
obs & pols
Amend Policy 1(b) to include specific reference to headlands as a particular
physical and natural feature.
6911-
obs & pols
Amend Policy 5(g) to include specific reference to landscape and natural character values
alongside biodiversity and ecological values.
6911-
6911-
obs & pols Amend Policy 9(b) so that it also refers to avoiding locating buildings on headlands.
6911-
6911-
obs & pols
Amend the second paragraph of the background section to refer to the ecological importance
of the five major estuaries within the East Coast Area including their importance as fish
nursery areas and their contribution to the overall productivity of the Hauraki Gulf.
6911-
obs & pols
Include an additional policy which refers to avoiding activities which could result in the
generation of sediment which may enter the Whangateau, Matakana, Mahurangi, Puhoi or
Waiwera estuaries.
6911-
obs & pols
Amend Policy 3 to also specifically refer to headlands as a place where dwellings and other
significant buildings should be avoided.
6911-
obs & pols Retain Objectives 1-4.
6911-
obs & pols Amend Policy 3 by removing the word prominent.
6911-
350 Alicia Warren alicia.warrennz@gmail.com General Chapter A Introduction
Plan
Add new objectives and policies for important natural heritage and natural resources overlays
including ONF, ONL, ONC, HNC and SEA.
6911-
quality
Add a new overlay showing areas of degraded water quality and include appropriate
objectives and policies which give effect to the relevant provisions of the RPS.
6911-
Amend Objective 1 as follows: Notable trees and notable groups of trees are protected,
maintained and enhanced retained.
6911-
Amend Policy 3 to strictly limit the flexibility for allowing impacts on notable trees and notable
groups of trees from inappropriate subdivision, use and development (such as by removal of
Policy 3b, 3d, 3e).
6911-
Trees E6.1 Objectives and policies Amend Policy 3 to include objectives and policies for second tier notable trees.
6911-
streams & wetland
Management Area Amend the description to refer to quantity of surface water bodies.
6911-
356 Alicia Warren alicia.warrennz@gmail.com Water Aquifers/Groundwater
Amend the Objective to "manage existing and future water take demands within aquifer
recharge rates."
6911-
streams & wetland
Management Area Amend Policy 1 to require the take and use of water to be within limits.
6911-
streams & wetland
Management Area Amend Policy 2 to specify prohibited activity status where takes would exceed limits.
6911-
Amend Objective 1 to provide an objective which requires the avoidance of the discharge of
contaminants which would degrade the quality of these sensitive aquifers.
6911-
Amend Policy 1 to avoid the discharge of contaminants which will degrade the quality of the
aquifers.
6911-
361 Alicia Warren alicia.warrennz@gmail.com Water Aquifers/Groundwater Amend Policy 2 by replacing discourage with avoid.
6911-
Amend Policy 3 to set out how the quality of the Onehunga aquifer will be maintained,
including how the risk of chemical spills will be minimised to be extremely low.
475/1145
Sub#/
6911-
streams & wetland
Management Area
Amend Objective 1 to manage existing and future water take demands within minimum flows
and allocation limits which safeguard the life- supporting capacity and amenity values of the
streams.
6911-
streams & wetland
Management Area
Amend Policy 2 to require resource consents for proposals to take or use water and require
applications to demonstrate matters (a) to (c) and the achievement of minimum flow and
allocation limits.
6911-
streams & wetland
Management Area
Amend Policy 2 to require resource consents for discharge proposals and applications to
demonstrate that they will not diminish the assimilative capacity of the stream / will achieve
the limits.
6911-
streams & wetland
Management Area Amend Objective 1 to require that in-stream values shall not deteriorate.
6911-
streams & wetland
Management Area
Amend Policy 1 to provide criteria for identification of Natural Stream Management Areas
based on high water quality / high ecological values.
6911-
streams & wetland
Management Area
Identify Natural Stream Management Areas based on additional criteria [high water quality
and high ecological values] and add additional areas to the Natural Stream Management
Areas overlay.
6911-
streams & wetland
Management Area
Amend Policy 2 to require freshwater limits to be set which maintain the high values of these
streams and management of takes / discharges within those limits.
6911-
streams & wetland
Management Area Retain Policy 3.
6911-
streams & wetland
Management Area
Amend Policy 4 to provide an exception for existing stock crossings to be replaced with a
bridge or culvert.
6911-
372 Alicia Warren alicia.warrennz@gmail.com Water Stormwater
Amend Objective 1 to provide for an overall reduction in the adverse effects of stormwater
runoff.
6911-
Clarify Policy 1 so that its role is identifying Stormwater Management Areas Flow 1 and 2 as
the Stormwater Management Areas Flow.
6911-
Amend Policy 2 to identify that mitigation must reduce adverse effects of stormwater runoff
from the site compared to the current baseline.
6911-
streams & wetland
Management Area
Amend Objective 1 to specify maintenance where water quality is currently high and
enhancement where water quality is not currently high.
6911-
streams & wetland
Management Area
Amend Objective 2 to specify maintenance where natural character and ecological values are
currently high and enhancement where natural character and ecological values are not
currently high.
6911-
streams & wetland
Management Area Retain Objective 3.
6911-
streams & wetland
Management Area Amend Policy 1 to require that diffuse discharges are within limits
6911-
streams & wetland
Management Area
Amend Policy 2 to provide that existing water allocation will be restricted to a level that avoids
adverse effects on Natural Lake Management Areas.
6911-
streams & wetland
6911-
streams & wetland
6911-
streams & wetland
6911-
streams & wetland
Management Area Amend Policy 6 to provide for the removal of existing invasive pest species.
6911-
streams & wetland
Overlay E7.7 Urban Lake
Management Area Retain Objective 1.
476/1145
Sub#/
6911-
streams & wetland
Management Area Amend Objective 2 to provide for a focus on enhancement.
6911-
streams & wetland
Management Area
Amend Objective 3 to specify what qualities of the margins of lakes are to be maintained or
enhanced.
6911-
streams & wetland
Management Area
Add a new objective addressing water quantity with respect to supply to the lakes being
predominantly groundwater.
6911-
streams & wetland
Management Area Retain Policy 1
6911-
streams & wetland
6911-
streams & wetland
Management Area
Amend Policy 3 to provide for how discharges are to be minimised and to what extent. Lake
Pupuke include controls on stormwater runoff, wastewater overflows, and fertiliser use.
Western Springs include control of the water fowl population.
6911-
streams & wetland
6911-
streams & wetland
Management Area
Amend Policy 5 to require new development and re-development to treat discharges and to
promote treatment of discharges from existing development.
6911-
streams & wetland
Management Area
Amend Policy 6 to require avoidance of disturbance from structure and vegetation clearance
for all purposes.
6911-
streams & wetland
Overlay E7.8 Water Supply
Management Areas Retain Objective 1.
6911-
streams & wetland
Management Areas
Amend Policy 1 to indicate which values will be preferred in the event of conflict. Where an
area is a Water Supply Management Area (WSMA) only municipal water supply values would
be preferred. Where an area is WSMA and e.g. Natural Stream Management Area both sets
of values should be protected.
6911-
streams & wetland
Management Areas Retain Policy 1.
6911-
streams & wetland
Management Areas
Amend Policy 2 to require no net loss of values of Natural Stream Management Areas and
Wetland Management Areas.
6911-
streams & wetland
Overlay E7.9 Management
Areas Wetland Appendix 5.3
Amend Objective 1 [of the Wetland Management Areas overlay] to emphasise reference to
spatial extent through a direction to avoid any decrease in spatial extent of Wetland
Management Areas (WMAs) while retaining the direction to maintain or enhance the natural
character and ecological values of WMAs.
6911-
streams & wetland
Amend Objective 2 [of the Wetland Management Areas overlay] to specify that natural
character and ecological values have priority in the event of conflict.
6911-
streams & wetland
Retain and amend Policy 1 [of the Wetland Management Areas overlay] by adding measures
providing for enhancement e.g. providing for enhancement planting and pest removal.
6911-
streams & wetland
Retain and amend Policy 2 [of the Wetland Management Areas overlay] to provide for minor
and temporary adverse effects.
6911-
streams & wetland
Amend policy 3 [of the Wetland Management Areas overlay] by: Retaining (a); amending (b)
to specify that these activities must avoid significant adverse effects; and amend (c) to delete
reference to new significant infrastructure and require activities relating to existing significant
infrastructure to be avoided unless the effects are minor and temporary.
6911-
403 Alicia Warren alicia.warrennz@gmail.com Precincts Ak-Wide and Coastal Waitemata Navigation Channel
Amend the 'Precinct description' in F1.11, to refer to maintenance dredging being a restricted
discretionary activity in the outer harbour and make consequential amendments to the rules.
6911-
404 Alicia Warren alicia.warrennz@gmail.com Precincts Ak-Wide and Coastal Waitemata Navigation Channel
Amend Policy 3 (in F1.11), to also refer to managing the potential adverse effects of sediment
dispersal on marine biota.
477/1145
Sub#/
6911-
Amend the plan to permit the removal of pest plants (those listed in Regional Pest
Management Strategy, National Pest Plant Accord and Department of Conservation weed
lists) from public open space be a permitted activity for all parties if it is for the purpose of
conservation.
6911-
Amend the plan to not provide for other than minor alteration of vegetation for Network Utility
Operators as a permitted activity and make all other trimming / alterations / removal a
6911-
407 Alicia Warren alicia.warrennz@gmail.com Earthworks H4.2.1.1 Activity table - Zones
Use controlled activity status, rather than permitted activity status [for all activities in all zones
and overlays where earthworks are a permitted activity].
6911-
and policies
Provide for integrated management of sedimentation in catchments which feed areas where
mangroves are expanding.
6911-
Overlays
Amend to make rules applying within SEAs more restrictive in order to protect the values of
those areas.
6911-
Overlays
Amend the rules, controls and criteria to avoid adverse effects on SEAs of earthworks in
areas adjacent to SEAs.
6911-
411 Alicia Warren alicia.warrennz@gmail.com Earthworks H4.2.3 Assessment
Amend the assessment criteria to provide for the application of the SEA criteria as
appropriate.
6911-
412 Alicia Warren alicia.warrennz@gmail.com Earthworks H4.2.2 Controls Identify high risk erosion areas and include specific controls for these areas.
6911-
413 Alicia Warren alicia.warrennz@gmail.com Earthworks H4.2.2 Controls Link sediment controls to water quality limits and areas of degraded water quality.
6911-
and policies Make controls in areas identified as high value / high risk more stringent.
6911-
Amend the general controls to use controlled activity status, rather than permitted activity
status.
6911-
416 Alicia Warren alicia.warrennz@gmail.com Earthworks H4.2.2 Controls
Amend the standards for cultivation to increase the required width of the required vegetated
riparian strip to 10m and 20m or as necessary to provide a high level of protection from
sediment run off.
6911-
Amend the controls for commercial forestry by increasing setbacks from sensitive areas (both
for commercial forestry earthworks and more generally).
6911-
Amend the controls for commercial forestry by providing for Wetland Management Areas in
setbacks for Earthworks for commercial forestry.
6911-
Amend the controls for commercial forestry by making tracking, roading and all other
earthworks required for forestry a restricted discretionary activity within catchments draining
into areas of degraded water quality to ensure that an adequate erosion and sediment control
plan is prepared and adhered to.
6911-
Amend matters of discretion 3.1, first paragraph to include: The sensitivity of the environment;
and Information and monitoring.
6911-
Amend matters of discretion 3.1, second paragraph 2 to include: Whether the activity will
result in increased discharges of sediment into areas of degraded water quality; Cumulative
impacts of sedimentation within the CMA; Potential impacts on threatened and at risk marine
species and significant habitats within the CMA.
6911-
Amend matters of discretion 3.1, third paragraph to include: Measures to ensure that there is
no increased discharge of sediment into areas of degraded water quality; Measures to avoid
cumulative impacts of sedimentation within the CMA; Measures to avoid adverse effects of
sedimentation on threatened and at risk marine species and significant habitats within the
CMA.
6911-
Amend the assessment criteria, second paragraph so that its provisions apply to earthworks
undertaken in a catchment which drains into a SEA Marine and amend subsection (c) so that
it also refers to cumulative effects of sediment within the CMA.
6911-
SEAs
table - Vegetation
roads
Amend activity table 1.1 [rural], first rule as follows: Vegetation alteration or removal, including
cumulative removal on a site over a 10-year period, of more than 250m2 of native vegetation
that: a. is contiguous vegetation or b. is outside the rural urban boundary c. is within the Rural
Conservation zone
6911-
SEAs
table - Vegetation
roads
Amend activity table 1.1 [rural], second rule to provide a higher activity status for removal of
native vegetation on land with an average slope exceeding 15 degrees.
6911-
SEAs
table - Vegetation
roads
Amend activity table 1.1 [riparian] to increase the setback in rural production and mixed rural
zones to 20m.
478/1145
Sub#/
6911-
SEAs
table - Vegetation
roads Amend activity table 1.1 [riparian] to include riparian controls for areas adjacent to SEAs.
6911-
SEAs
table - Vegetation
roads
Amend activity table 1.1 [riparian] to increase setbacks generally to ensure that setbacks
address all potential adverse effects on sensitive/high value areas.
6911-
SEAs
table - Vegetation
roads
Amend activity table 1.1 [coastal] to increase the coastal protection yard for restrictions on
vegetation alteration or removal to 100m in all zones and applies to the removal of any tree(s)
or vegetation (regardless of height or extent).
6911-
SEAs
table - Vegetation
roads
Amend activity table 1.1 [permitted and controlled activities] to require a restricted
discretionary resource consent for the work of network utility operators and require them to be
subject to regulatory best practice methods.
6911-
SEAs
table - Vegetation
roads
Amend activity table 1.1 [ network utilities] to provide discretionary activity status for minor
infrastructure upgrading.
6911-
SEAs
Assessment
Amend the assessment criteria to provide for the application of the SEA criteria as
appropriate.
6911-
SEAs
Assessment
Amend the assessment criteria to provide for the consideration of adverse erosion /
sedimentation effects.
6911-
SEAs
Amend activity table 1.2 to limit the amount of vegetation able to be altered or removed under
Controlled Activity Status (e.g. 300m2).
6911-
SEAs
Amend activity table 1.2 [network utilities] to make repair and maintenance a controlled
activity and minor upgrading a discretionary activity.
6911-
SEAs
Amend activity table 1.2 to limit the area of scale of vegetation alteration and removal for
existing farming and forestry activities (25m2 per annum or less) so that SEA values are not
lost or adversely affected as a result of activities that comply with the permitted activity rules.
6911-
Rural Discharges,
Biosolids
Discharges
Amend the activity table to make farming systems with a farm environment plan a controlled
activity in areas where limits are met.
6911-
Rural Discharges,
Biosolids
Discharges
Amend the activity table to make farming systems with a farm environment plan a restricted
discretionary activity in areas where limits are not met.
6911-
Rural Discharges,
Biosolids
Discharges
Amend the activity table to make farming systems without a farm environment plan a
6911-
Rural Discharges,
Biosolids
Discharges Amend the plan to specify requirements for farm environment plan matters to address.
6911-
441 Alicia Warren alicia.warrennz@gmail.com Natural Hazards and Flooding Natural Hazards H4.11.1 Activity table
Amend the activity table so that new dwellings and habitable floors of non- dwellings on land
subject to coastal inundation and sea level rise are a non- complying activity.
6911-
Assessment
Include a requirement for any authorised new dwellings and habitable rooms in coastal areas
that there is a legally binding requirement that no new hard protection works or additions to
existing hard protection works will be constructed to protect the property anytime in the future.
6911-
Assessment
Include as matters for discretion the impacts on natural character, sediment transport, healthy
functioning of dunes, discharge of sediment and contaminants, the healthy functioning of the
intertidal zone and marine biota and public access.
6911-
Assessment
Amend the assessment criteria [under H4.11.3] to include other adverse effects of developing
in coastal hazard zones including natural natural character, natural process, biodiversity
etc Refer submission for detail [pg. 72/98].
6911-
Assessment
Amend to require any residual adverse effects which cannot be avoided, mitigated or
remedied to be offset through restoration and enhancement actions that achieve no net loss
and preferably a net gain in terms of impacts on natural heritage values of the coastal
environment.
6911-
streams & wetland
table Retain the rules in the activity table related to planting.
479/1145
Sub#/
6911-
streams & wetland
table Retain in the activity table the rules related to depositing any substance.
6911-
streams & wetland
table Amend the activity table [disturbance] to prohibit channel clearance in high values areas.
6911-
streams & wetland
table
Amend the activity table [disturbance] to change the activity status of mangrove removal from
a permitted to a restricted discretionary activity.
6911-
streams & wetland
table
Amend the activity table [disturbance] to define emergency works in accordance with the
RMA.
6911-
streams & wetland
table
Amend the activity table [diversion of a river or stream to a new course] to make these
activities prohibited.
6911-
streams & wetland
table
Amend the activity table [existing structures] to make the activity status for replacement or
extension of existing structures to restricted discretionary.
6911-
streams & wetland
table
Amend the activity table [existing structures] to make the activity status for demolition or
removal of existing structures controlled.
6911-
streams & wetland
table
Amend the activity table [new structures] to lower (restricted discretionary) the activity status
for bridges / culverts for existing stock crossings for water quality improvement purposes.
6911-
streams & wetland
table
Amend the activity table [new structures] to change the activity status for Structures solely
under the bed including drilling and tunnelling and Weir in the overlay areas to controlled.
6911-
streams & wetland
table
Amend the activity table [new structures] to provide controls for Cables, ducts, lines or
pipelines on existing structures that ensure that there will be no associated bed disturbance
(except temporary) or deposition or amend to controlled activity.
6911-
streams & wetland
table
Amend the activity table [reclamation and drainage] to change the activity status of extension
of and existing or new reclamation or drainage to prohibited.
6911-
streams & wetland
Retain in the activity table [livestock access] the rules requiring livestock exclusion within 5
years excluding intermittent streams and within 10 years for the full extent.
6911-
459 Alicia Warren alicia.warrennz@gmail.com Definitions Existing
Amend the definition of intensively grazed production land to refer to the instantaneous
stocking rate.
6911-
streams & wetland
Amend the activity table [livestock access] to phase in additional livestock exclusion for all
production land over 15 year period.
6911-
461 Alicia Warren alicia.warrennz@gmail.com Water Stormwater H4.14 Introduction
Amend all rules and methods to ensure the objectives and policies sought in the submission
will be achieved. Refer submission for detail [pg. 74/98].
6911-
462 Alicia Warren alicia.warrennz@gmail.com Water Wastewater
management rules
Amend all rules and methods to ensure the objectives and policies sought in the submission
will be achieved. Refer submission for details [pg. 74/98]
6911-
management rules
Amend the activity table to change the activity status of wastewater overflows for new areas /
networks to prohibited.
6911-
management rules
Amend the activity table to change the activity status of all wastewater overflows to restricted
discretionary as a minimum.
6911-
table
Retain in the activity table [water take and use of surface water] the permitted activity status
for domestic and animal drinking water only.
6911-
table
Amend the activity table [water take and use of surface water] to make all uses other than
domestic and animal drinking water a controlled activity in under allocated catchments.
6911-
table
Amend the the activity table [water take and use of surface water] to make new takes in fully
allocated catchments a prohibited activity and renewal of takes a discretionary activity.
6911-
table
Amend the the activity table [water take and use of surface water] to make all new takes and
renewals of takes in high-use stream management areas a restricted discretionary activity as
a minimum.
6911-
table
Amend the the activity table [water take and use of surface water] to make activities which do
not provide for the measurement of takes a prohibited activity.
6911-
table
Amend the the activity table [diverting surface water] to make drainage of production land a
discretionary activity generally and prohibited in Wetland Management Areas. Amend
discharge activity statuses to align with the above.
480/1145
Sub#/
6911-
table
Amend the the activity table [diverting surface water] to make the activity status of diversion
not listed or not meeting the controls prohibited in Wetland Management Areas and
discretionary in other areas.
6911-
table
Retain in the activity table [water take and use of groundwater] the permitted activity for
domestic and animal drinking water uses only.
6911-
table
Amend the activity table [water take and use of groundwater] to make water takes for all uses
other than domestic and animal drinking a controlled activity status in under-allocated
groundwater systems.
6911-
table
Amend the activity table [water take and use of groundwater] to make new takes in fully
allocated groundwater systems prohibited and renewal of consents discretionary and apply
equivalent surface water restrictions where there are significant connections between ground
and surface water.
6911-
table
Amend the activity table [water take and use of groundwater] to prohibit activities which do not
provide for the measurement of takes.
6911-
table
Amend the activity table [water take and use of groundwater] to make the activity status for
land drainage to discretionary in all locations.
6911-
table
Amend the activity table [diversion of ground water] to make drainage generally a
discretionary activity and prohibited in Wetland Management Areas.
6911-
table
Amend the activity table [diversion of ground water] to prohibit diversion where there may be
an adverse effect on Wetland Management Areas.
6911-
table
Amend the activity table [damming water] to make off-stream dams discretionary and other
general dams non-complying.
6911-
table
Amend the activity table [damming water] to prohibit any dams in high value areas (e.g.
natural stream management areas, wetland management areas, etc).
6911-
H4.17.4 & H4.17.5
Assessment Amend the matters of discretion 5.1 to include freshwater limits.
6911-
H4.17.4 & H4.17.5
Assessment
Amend the assessment criteria 5.2 to provide for priorities for water allocation [5.2 (1)] through
differentiation of activity status or alternative allocation mechanism.
6911-
H4.17.4 & H4.17.5
Assessment
Amend the assessment criteria 5.2 to require efficient use methods, otherwise activity status
should be prohibited.
6911-
H4.17.4 & H4.17.5
Assessment Amend the assessment criteria 5.2 to add additional efficient use methods.
6911-
H4.17.4 & H4.17.5
Assessment Amend the assessment criteria 5.2 to ensure achievement of the policies.
6911-
Other discharge of
contaminants H4.18 Auckland
wide rules
Amend activity table to clearly indicate that the discharge must not enter into any water supply
catchment, Wetland, Natural Lake or Natural Stream Management Area or amend to
controlled activity status.
6911-
487 Alicia Warren alicia.warrennz@gmail.com Subdivision Auckland-wide - Urban zones
except Rural
Retain in activity table 4 the prohibition on subdivision not otherwise provided for in the Future
Urban Zone.
6911-
488 Alicia Warren alicia.warrennz@gmail.com Subdivision Auckland-wide - Rural zones
zones only
Retain in activity table 5 the prohibition on subdivision not otherwise provided for in the Rural
Zones.
6911-
zones only
Retain in table 5 the Amalgamation transferable rural site subdivision process to provide
flexibility without increasing the number of sites in rural areas.
6911-
zones only
Retain in table 5 the Protection of an SEA transferable rural site subdivision process subject
to rigorous requirements to ensure real and additional ecological benefits accrue.
6911-
area
Amend the controls for activities in particular zones, rural zones, 2.3.3 by deleting the
provision for receiver sites in the Rural Coastal Zone from table 6 .
6911-
Amend all the activity tables which are applicable to the General Coastal Marine zone in order
to give ONLs the same level of protection as ONCs (which could be achieved by moving the
ONL wording to the column which includes ONCs in each table).
6911-
the CMA
and occupation I6.1.9 Activity table
Amend the activity tables to make large vessels travelling through the Hauraki Gulf at speeds
of greater than 10 knots a non- complying activity.
6911-
Amend all activity tables to not include permitted or controlled activities for the General
Coastal Marine Zone which may adversely affect areas of high value. Refer submission for
details [pg. 78/89].
6911-
the CMA
Amend activity table 1.1 to make declamation for the purposes of a residential/canal
development a prohibited activity.
6911-
the CMA
Amend activity 1.2 to make depositing material not otherwise provided for a prohibited activity
within the Hauraki Gulf Marine Park.
6911-
the CMA
Amend activity table 1.2 so that disposal of waste or other matter in the CMA is a prohibited
activity within the Hauraki Gulf Marine Park.
481/1145
Sub#/
6911-
the CMA
Amend activity table 1.3 to remove the notation "ONL" from the column which also has SEA-
Marine 2 and HNC. The notation ONC should be inserted into the column with SEA-Marine 1.

6911-
the CMA
Amend activity table 1.3 so that capital works dredging is a prohibited activity in SEA-Marine
1, ONC, ONL, SEA-Marine 2, HNC, ONF areas.
6911-
the CMA
Amend activity table 1.3 to provide that dredging and trawling (including for the purposes of
fishing) is a discretionary activity within the General Coastal Marine Zone and is a prohibited
activity within the overlays.
6911-
the CMA
Amend activity table 1.4 so that minerals prospecting and minerals exploration is a
discretionary activity within the General Coastal Marine Zone.
6911-
the CMA
Amend activity table 1.4 so that all mangrove removal is at least a restricted discretionary
activity in the General Coastal Marine Zone.
6911-
the CMA
Amend activity table 1.8 so that aquaculture is prohibited in areas of the CMA within 5 nautical
miles of reserves, regional parks, sanctuaries or other conservation land.
6911-
the CMA
Amend activity table 1.8 so that ONLs have the same level as protection as ONC areas by
moving ONL one column to the left.
6911-
the CMA
and use I6.1.10 Activity table
Retain in activity table 1.10 the non-complying activity status of new marinas in the General
Coastal Marine Zone.
6911-
the CMA
Amend activity table 1.10 so that new marinas are a prohibited activity within all the overlay
areas.
6911-
the CMA
Amend activity table 1.10 to include a reference to set-nets and provide for them as a
discretionary activity within the General Coastal Marine Zone and as a prohibited activity
within the overlay areas.
6911-
the CMA
Amend activity table 1.10 to ensure ONLs have the same level as protection as ONC areas by
moving ONL one column to the left.
6911-
controls
Amend the land and water use controls to require a sediment management plan prior to
permitting mangrove removal. Refer submission for detail [pg. 79,80/89].
6911-
Special information
requirements
Amend the assessment criteria for controlled activities by amending paragraph 6(b) to replace
the word may with must so that proposals to remove mangroves are required to provide an
assessment of sediment inputs in the area and identification of catchment initiatives to reduce
sediment and nutrient inputs.
6911-
Special information
requirements
Amend the matters of discretion, 5.1, first paragraph, clause (c) to also include a reference to
effects on landscapes.
6911-
Special information
requirements
Amend the assessment criteria for restricted discretionary activities 5.2 paragraph 1(c) to also
include a reference to effects on landscapes.
6911-
Special information
requirements
Amend the assessment criteria for restricted discretionary activities 5.2 paragraph 2(b) to
provide that activities in SEA-Marine should avoid any adverse effect on the ecology and
wildlife of the area.
6911-
Special information
requirements
Amend the assessment criteria for restricted discretionary activities 5.2 paragraph 4 to include
an assessment as to whether adverse effects on ONL and ONC overlay areas are avoided.
6911-
Special information
requirements
Amend the assessment criteria for restricted discretionary activities 5.2 paragraph 12(b) to
replace the word may with must so that proposals to remove mangroves are required to
provide an assessment of sediment inputs in the area and identification of catchment
initiatives to reduce sediment and nutrient inputs.
6911-
Special information
requirements
Amend the plan to provide comprehensive assessment criteria for any aquaculture proposal
and which make it clear where aquaculture will not be appropriate. Refer submission for
details [pg. 80-82/98].
6911-
Special information
requirements
Amend the plan to require any aquaculture proposal to demonstrate that any residual adverse
effects which cannot be avoided, mitigated or remedied will be offset through restoration and
enhancement actions that achieve no net loss and preferably a net gain in terms of impacts
on natural heritage values of the coastal environment.
6911-
518 Alicia Warren alicia.warrennz@gmail.com Rural Zones General I13.1 Activity table
Amend the activity table so that farming is a controlled activity where a farm environmental
plan is prepared, and a restricted discretionary activity in catchments which are freshwater
quality over-allocated.
482/1145
Sub#/
6911-
Amend the activity table so that new forestry is a discretionary activity in the Rural Coastal
and Rural Conservation zones.
6911-
Amend the activity table so that mineral exploration is restricted discretionary in the Mixed
Rural and Rural Production zones and Discretionary in Rural Conservation and Rural Coastal
and Non-Complying in Countryside Living.
6911-
521 Alicia Warren alicia.warrennz@gmail.com Rural Zones General I13.2 Land use controls
Amend the land use controls to include additional controls to effectively manage the impacts
of farming on the marine environment, particularly through controlling the generation of
sediment. For example through requirements for riparian areas to be maintained adjacent to
waterways and the CMA.
6911-
To amend the controls on forestry to controls to effectively manage the impacts of forest on
the CMA, particularly through controlling the generation of sediment. For example through
requirements for harvesting management plans at the time of planting, maintenance of larger
riparian areas and other methods.
6911-
Amend the land use controls on forestry [2.3] by including and additional paragraph which
states that any forestry activity must not result in the generation of sediment that may enter
the CMA within an area of degraded water quality.
6911-
Outstanding Natural
Rules
Notification
Amend the activity table to provide the ONL areas with a similar level of protection as areas of
ONC.
6911-
Outstanding Natural
Rules
Notification Amend activity status for minor infrastructure upgrading to restricted discretionary.
6911-
Outstanding Natural
Rules
Notification
Amend the activity table to incorporate provisions applying to amenity landscapes to ensure
that they are carefully managed to retain amenity values.
6911-
Outstanding Natural
Rules
J6.2.4 Assessment
Amend the matters of discretion [in J6.2.4] to include as a matter of discretion impacts on
natural character and ecological values.
6911-
Outstanding Natural
Rules
J6.2.4 Assessment
Amend the first paragraph of the assessment criteria [in J6.2.4] to also state that the proposal
needs to ensure that there are no adverse effects on areas of ONL and ONC as shown on the
overlay.
6911-
Amend the activity table to the effect that activities which penetrate any volcanic viewshaft,
and are currently shown as non-complying, should be prohibited activities.
6911-
Amend the SEA layer to reflect ecological values including habitat edges, quality gradients,
areas where existing activites are located, areas missed, remaining habitat within the
Northwest Wild link, areas providing ecological links to SEAs. Refer submission for details
[pg. 84-86/98]
6911-
SEAs
Amend the rules for existing activities to provide for a less onerous activity status for existing
activities compared to new activities, rather than excluding them from the SEA overlay.
6911-
Amend the SEA criteria to ensure that areas that provide ecological linkages and buffers also
qualify as SEAs and provide for the protection of these areas.
6911-
Amend the SEA Marine overlay to include areas where existing activities are located if the
values exist in these areas.
6911-
Amend the rules for existing activities to provide for a less onerous activity status for existing
activities compared to new activities, rather than excluding them from the SEA Marine
overlay.
6911-
the CMA
sch. 6.2 ONC/HNC
6.1 Schedule SEA
Marine 1 and 2
Extend the SEA Marine 1 overlay to include all marine reserves including the Long Bay-Okura
Marine Reserve.
6911-
the CMA
sch. 6.2 ONC/HNC
6.1 Schedule SEA
Marine 1 and 2 Amend the SEA Marine 1 overlay to include the seagrass bed off Snells beach.
483/1145
Sub#/
6911-
the CMA
sch. 6.2 ONC/HNC
6.1 Schedule SEA
Marine 1 and 2 Amend the SEA Marine ovelay to include all the CMA from Goat Island to Ti Point.
6911-
the CMA
sch. 6.2 ONC/HNC
6.1 Schedule SEA
Marine 1 and 2
Amend the SEA Marine 2 overlay to include a SEA Marine 2 overlay over the areas in the
Kaipara harbour where there are significant areas of mangroves including those shown in
Appendix C [pg. 93,94/98].
6911-
the CMA
sch. 6.2 ONC/HNC
6.1 Schedule SEA
Marine 1 and 2
Extend the area of SEA-Marine so that it encompasses the CMA adjacent to important islands
in the Hauraki Gulf out to 5 nautical miles including Tiritiri Matangi, Rangitoto, Motutapu,
Motuihe, Browns, Rakino, Ponui, Rotoroa, and Pakatoa Islands
6911-
quality Amend the plan to include an overlay showing areas of degraded water quality.
6911-
streams & wetland
Amend the maps located Appendix 5.3 to identify the spatial extent of the Wetland
Management Areas and include them in the Maps section of the PAUP.
6911-
Recognise the information basis in Appendix A of the submission [pg. 1-29/29 of vol.3] which
identifies the important habitats of seabirds in the Auckland Region by: 1.Including maps of
Important Bird Areas (IBAs) in the PAUP (as set out in Appendix B) [pg. 90,91/98] within the
SEA overlay or another category of overlay sufficient to protect their values; 2. Including
appropriate provisions to recognise and protect IBAs.
6911-
and policies
Amend the coastal inundation maps to ensure they apply climate change predictions for the
next 100 years.
6911-
544 Alicia Warren alicia.warrennz@gmail.com General Miscellaneous Southern Hauraki Gulf Islands Include a coastal inundation overlay for the islands in the Hauraki Gulf.
6911-
features
Amend the maps to include an overlay showing areas of amenity landscapes, which
include the regionally significant landscapes as identified in the Auckland regional policy
statement when it became operative in 1999.
6911-
obs & pols
Extend the Rural Coastal zone where necessary to include the entire coastal environment
outside urban areas on all Maps including areas: on the Kaipara Harbour, in the vicinity of
Parkhurst, on the coast between Kawakawa Bay and Tawhitokina Bay, the coast south of
Maringatahi. Refer submission for detail [pg. 89/98].
6911-
the CMA
sch. 6.2 ONC/HNC
6.1 Schedule SEA
Marine 1 and 2
Amend the schedule so that it provides a technically robust and full description of the values
within the CMA that each SEA-Marine is seeking to protect.
6911-
the CMA
sch. 6.2 ONC/HNC
6.1 Schedule SEA
Marine 1 and 2
Amend the schedule to provide a description for any additional areas which are included as a
result of the Environmental Defence Society's submission on the maps.
6911-
the CMA
sch. 6.2 ONC/HNC
6.1 Schedule SEA
Marine 1 and 2
Amend the schedule to provide a clear linkage between the identification and description of
specific SEAs in the appendix and their location, including precise boundaries on the planning
maps.
6913-1 Albert A McNabb cush.alan@slingshot.co.nz RPS Mana Whenua B5 Strategic Retain acknowledgement in the PAUP of the importance of protecting cultural heritage.
6913-2 Albert A McNabb cush.alan@slingshot.co.nz RPS Mana Whenua B5 Strategic
Delete any provisions that refer to Mana Whenua values, cultural and spiritual values of Mana
Whenua, integration of mtauranga and tikanga, and the principles of the Treaty of Waitangi.
6913-3 Albert A McNabb cush.alan@slingshot.co.nz RPS Mana Whenua
Fig. 1
Place the burden of proof on Mana Whenua sites on those who wish to restrict the owner's
use of the property.
6913-4 Albert A McNabb cush.alan@slingshot.co.nz Mana Whenua
Whenua
and policies Grade Mana Whenua sites into categories of significance.
6913-5 Albert A McNabb cush.alan@slingshot.co.nz Mana Whenua General provisions
assessment
Delete the Cultural Impact Assessment so that the Council is the only agency responsible for
preparing them.
6913-6 Albert A McNabb cush.alan@slingshot.co.nz RPS Mana Whenua B5 Strategic
Delete any parts of the PAUP calling for equal partnerships, joint mangement agreements and
the transfer of power to iwi authorities.
6913-7 Albert A McNabb cush.alan@slingshot.co.nz RPS Mana Whenua B5 Strategic Delete all PAUP provisions regarding shared governance.
6914-1 Timothy M Wood timwoodmachinery@paradise.net.nz RPS Changes to the RUB South
Rezone 1359 Great South Road, Ramarama, and the corner of Great South Road and
Ararimu Road, Ramarama from Mixed Rural to Countryside Living or Large Lot.
6915-1 Mortre Holdings Limited graeme@wwsurveyors.co.nz Zoning North and Islands Rezone 59 Arabella Lane, Snells Beach to Mixed Housing Suburban zone.
6916-1 Janet C Leonard jan.c.leonard@gmail.com Mana Whenua
Whenua
of value to Mana Whenua Delete Mana Whenua sites around Torkar Road and Crisp Road, Clarks Beach.
6917-1 Judith Hill
18 Millbrook Drive, Waiuku,
Auckland 2683
the CMA Mangroves
and policies Amend the 1996 date from which the removal of mangroves is enabled.
484/1145
Sub#/
6917-2 Judith Hill
18 Millbrook Drive, Waiuku,
Consult further with the Waiuku Museum Society regarding the Historic overlay and heritage
issues.
6918-1 Lilburn Street Limited burnette@opc.net.nz Historic Heritage (Overlay)
Heritage
objectives and policies Retain schedules of protected historic heritage buildings
6918-2 Lilburn Street Limited burnette@opc.net.nz Zoning North and Islands
Retain the Mixed Use zone for Warkworth and related provisions including the additional
height controls on 5 Lilburn Street, Warkworth
6918-3 Lilburn Street Limited burnette@opc.net.nz
control
Building demolition control J.3.6 Rules and mapping Delete
6918-4 Lilburn Street Limited burnette@opc.net.nz Water Stormwater
Management Area - flow Delete SMAF-1
6918-5 Lilburn Street Limited burnette@opc.net.nz Built Environment (Overlays)
Height Control Retain the additional height controls overlay in Warkworth
6919-1 John A Flower john.flower@xtra.co.nz Historic Heritage (Overlay)
Heritage
Places Remove 72 Arthur Street [Onehunga] from the schedule.
6920-1 RPH Orchards heather.hitchings@gmail.com Subdivision Auckland-wide - Rural zones
area Allow a 1ha block to be subdivided off 1387 Coatesville-Riverhead Highway, Kumeu.
6920-2 RPH Orchards heather.hitchings@gmail.com Subdivision Auckland-wide - Rural zones
area
Allow 1 ha sub-dividable blocks on all properties on the Coatesville-Riverhead Highway
between Kaipara-Portage Road and SH 16 on the eastern side of the Coatesville-Riverhead
Highway (the same side as the two new subdivisions).
6921-1 David H Craig
363 Hamilton Road, RD4, Waiuku,
Auckland 2684
Outstanding Natural
Rules
Notification Delete the rules requiring a resource consent for planting forestry over 2ha per title.
6921-2 David H Craig
363 Hamilton Road, RD4, Waiuku,
Auckland 2684 RPS
Introduce economic incentives for landowners on the Awhitu Peninsula to plant native trees
on uneconomic parts of their farms.
6922-1 Pine Harbour Holdings Limited david@osbornehay.co.nz
the CMA Marina zone
Retain Marina zone, particularly the implementation of a single zone over both the landward
and seaward components of a marina.
6922-2 Pine Harbour Holdings Limited david@osbornehay.co.nz General Chapter A Introduction
tools Retain site specific precincts in the PAUP, particuarly marina precincts.
6922-3 Pine Harbour Holdings Limited david@osbornehay.co.nz RPS Urban growth
Retain objectives and policies, particularly those integrating transport with growth and
focusing development along frequent transport routes.
Amend Objective 3 as follows: Land within and adjacent to centres, frequent public transport
routes and public transport facilities is the primary focus for residential intensification with a
lesser degree of intensification in surrounding neighbourhoods.
Amend Policy 2(b) as follows: b. in areas close to the frequent public transport routes and
public transport facilities
6922-6 Pine Harbour Holdings Limited david@osbornehay.co.nz RPS Coastal
environment Retain objectives and policies.
environment
Amend Objective 5 as follows: The risk of subdivision, use and development in the coastal
environment being adversely affected by coastal hazards is minimised to a reasonable and
practical level.
environment
Amend Policy 2(a) as follows: a. concentrating and intensifying subdivision, use and
development within areas already characterised by development and where natural character
values are already compromised
environment
Amend Policy 4 as follows: Maintain ... that: a. have a functional need to be located below
MHWS; or b. are for public benefit and/or that enable recreational access and use of the CMA
by the public, including infrastructure that cannot be reasonably or practicably be located
outside the CMA, including existing uses, or c. enable the cultural or traditional use of the
CMA by Mana Whenua.
environment
Amend Policy 5 as follows: Provide for activities that are necessary to allow for the on-going
use and operation of infrastructure and existing activities in the CMA, including port and ferry
transport activities, while avoiding significant adverse effects to the extent practicable, and
avoiding, remedying or mitigating other adverse effects.
environment
Add new policy as follows: 6. Where reasonable and practicable, land adjacent to ferry
terminals is used for intensive urban development.
485/1145
Sub#/
space - coastal environment Retain objectives and policies.
Amend Objective 3 as follows: Public access is restricted where necessary to ensure
meet health or safety and security requirements, the efficient and safe operation of activities,
or to protect the value of areas that are sensitive to disturbance.
Amend Policy 3(b) as follows: b. identifying and providing areas for particular recreational use
where this ensures the most efficient use of space, and supports the provision of land-based
facilities for those uses
space - coastal environment Retain Policy 5, particularly clause (g).
the CMA
declamation
the CMA
declamation
and policies
Add a new objective, to be numbered as 1, as follows: Where appropriate to provide for
drainage, reclamation and declamation which provide for enhanced public access and/or for
social and economic opportunities.
the CMA
declamation
and policies
Amend Policy 1(b) as follows: b. the reclamation or drainage is necessary to enable the
construction and/or efficient operation of infrastructure, including but not limited to, ports,
marinas, airports, roads, pipelines, electricity transmission, railways, ferry terminals, boat
launching ramps, slipways and electricity generation, where they comply with other relevant
policies
the CMA
declamation
and policies
Amend Policy 2 as follows: Provide for reclamation and works that are necessary to enable
the repair and upgrade of existing reclamations and seawalls, for infrastructure, for enhanced
public access and for extension of existing marinas.
the CMA
the CMA
and policies
Amend Objective 1 as follows: The adverse environmental effects on the CMA from dredging
are avoided, remedied, or mitigated to a reasonable and practical level.
the CMA
and policies
Amend Objective 3 as follows: The safe and efficient operation of significant infrastructure
and marinas is enabled, including through undertaking dredging where necessary.
the CMA
and policies
Amend Policy 1 as follows: Enable dredging within navigational channelsin the General
Coastal Marine zone and within the Minor Port, Defence, Ferry Terminal, Marina zones and
the City Centre waterfront precincts, to provide for their ongoing use.
the CMA
and policies
Amend Policy 2 as follows: Enable dredging to be undertaken to maintain the safe and
efficient operation of significant infrastructure and minimise the risk of flooding and erosion,
including dredging that is necessary for: ...
the CMA
and policies
Amend Policy 4 as follows: Where practicable, Require dredging in the GCM zone to be
undertaken at a time that will avoid, or minimise, adverse effects on marine mammals, bird
roosting, nesting and feeding, and recreational users of the CMA.
the CMA
and occupation
D5.1.13 Background,
objectives and policies Retain objectives and policies.
the CMA
and occupation
D5.1.13 Background,
Amend Policy 9 to read as follows: Consider use and development to providing e for a new
Marina zone or to extend an existing Marina zone to be generally appropriate in locations: ...
(b) where there is an existing water-based transport or recreation function, such as existing
ferry services, and the addition or extension of a marina consolidates this function
[submission lists sub-clause (c) but detail matches sub-clause (b)].
the CMA
and use
D5.1.15 Background,
the CMA
and use
D5.1.15 Background,
objectives and policies Amend Policy 5(c) as follows: reduce the need for a new structures elsewhere.
the CMA Marina zone
objectives and policies Retain objectives and policies..
the CMA Marina zone
Amend Objective 1 as follows: Marina and supporting activities are located within a Marina
zone, which encompasses the CMA and any adjoining land used for marina-related activity.
the CMA Marina zone
Amend Objective 2 to read as follows: Marina facilities are used , developed, used,
maintained, refurbished, reconstructed or extended, and berthage maximised while avoiding,
remedying or mitigating adverse effects on the coastal environment to an appriopriate level,
while recognising the benefits obtained from Marinas.
the CMA Marina zone
Amend Objective 4 as follows: Activities that have a functional requirement for a coastal
location are prioritised provided for in Marina zones.
the CMA Marina zone
Amend Objective 5 to read as follows: Access to the waterfront for berth holders and the
public is preserved or maintained and enhanced.
486/1145
Sub#/
the CMA Marina zone
Amend Policy 1 as follows: Provide for use, development, extension, repair, maintenance,
refurbishment, and reconstruction in existing marinas that avoids, remedies or mitigates to a
reasonable and practical level adverse effects on the coastal environment, including adjacent
land zoned for residential or open space purposes.
the CMA Marina zone
Amend Policy 3 as follows: Provide for existing and new ferry terminal facilities and operations
at Half Moon Bay, Bayswater, Pine Harbour, Gulf Harbour and West Harbour marinas.
the CMA Marina zone
Amend Policy 5 as follows: Encourage additional berthage to be created within a Marina
zones where this is practicable and will avoid, remedy or mitigate adverse effects on the
environment including: ...
the CMA Marina zone
Amend Policy 7 to read as follows: Design and provide for wave attenuation devices in a
manner which meets the required design objectives to allow for the safe and efficient
operation of the Marina.
the CMA Marina zone
Amend Policy 8 as follows: Require any marina development to be of a scale, design and
materials and located so that it remedies or mitigates to a reasonable and practical
level adverse effects on the coastal environment, particularly the following: a. the natural
existing character of the coastal environment ... i. the need for capital works and
maintenance dredging within the marina and any approach/entrance channel, options for
on water quality j. effects on other users of the CMA including existing moorings and public
boat ramps (except when being relocated or removed as part of the development) ...
the CMA Marina zone
Amend Policy 10 as follows: Require, where necessary, mitigation for any loss of public
access to, along and within the CMA, including providing facilities such as public boat ramps,
and alternative access for other recreational users such as windsurfers, kayakers and kite
boarders .
the CMA Marina zone
Retain Policy 11 so long as amendments are made to the General rules or Marina zone rules
allowing for precinct plans to be approved or modified through a resource consent process.
the CMA Marina zone
Delete and replace Policy 11 with a policy and supporting rules which allow framework plans
to be approved through the resource consent process in the Marina zone, including the ability
for framework plans to be approved and to replace existing precinct plans in part or in full.
6922-44 Pine Harbour Holdings Limited david@osbornehay.co.nz Precincts - South Pine Harbour Retain precinct.
6922-45 Pine Harbour Holdings Limited david@osbornehay.co.nz Precincts - South Pine Harbour
Amend description [in F6.21] as follows: ... The Pine Harbour precinct plan includes provision
for a road connection with Karaka Road in the event that the existing reserve located at the
Karaka Road and Sunkist Bay Road intersection is not developed Sunkist Road extension to
Pine Harbour is not progressed in a timely manner by Auckland Transport. ... The long-term
objective is to investigate the rehabilitation of the watercourse with riparian planting on either
side where practicable. The stormwater management area is to remain in private ownership
and is not required to be vested in the council.
Amend Description for Sub-precinct A [in F6.21]: Marina Area 1 - Industry as follows: Area 1
has a maximum building height of 18m 9m
Amend Description for Sub-precinct A [in F6.21]: Marina Area 2 - Commercial as follows: Area
2 covers the existing commercial buildings and the additional area which may be required for
future commercial buildings servicing the marina and marine-related uses, such as marine
retail and offices . Area 2 does not provide for marine industrial activities. Area 2 is located
adjacent to the current ferry berthing area.
Delete the first sentence under both Objectives and Policies [in F6.21] which refer to the
objectives or policies listed under the Marina, Mixed Housing Suburban and Terrace Housing
and Apartment Buildings zone.
6922-49 Pine Harbour Holdings Limited david@osbornehay.co.nz General Chapter G General provisions
Amend Rule 1.4 Applying for resource consent to read as follows ... Making a resource
consent application ...Where a proposal involves several activities with different types of
consent activity status these will be bundled together and assessed as a single activity in
accordance with the more onerous activity status except that (i) there will be no bundling of
consent activity status or assessments as between regional and district plans, whether
operative or proposed.
Add a new section on Precinct Plans, similar to Section 2.6 Framework Plans that provides for
precinct plans to be introduced through the resource consent rather than the plan change
process. See submission for further details [page 14/37 of submission - see also submission
points 42 and 43 of same submission].
487/1145
Sub#/
statements
Amend Rule 2.7.1.26 General information requirements to either delete or refine the
requirement for a specialist fire report.
6922-52 Pine Harbour Holdings Limited david@osbornehay.co.nz Mana Whenua General provisions
assessment
Delete and replace 2.7.4 Cultural impact assessment with provisions that provide more
certainty for landowners. See submission for specific details [page 15/37 of submission].
6922-53 Pine Harbour Holdings Limited david@osbornehay.co.nz General Noise and vibration
and policies
Amend section to clarify which rules apply to the Marina zone, particularly 1.4 Construction
noise.
6922-54 Pine Harbour Holdings Limited david@osbornehay.co.nz General Noise and vibration H6.2 Rules Apply the General Business zone rules to the Marina zone.
6922-55 Pine Harbour Holdings Limited david@osbornehay.co.nz Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
Amend development control 3.1(1)(iii) Traffic Generation as follows: this rule does not apply in
the City Centre, Metropolitan Centre, Town Centre, Marina or Terrace Housing and Apartment
Buildings zones and the Gulf Harbour and Pine Harbour precincts.
6922-56 Pine Harbour Holdings Limited david@osbornehay.co.nz Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
Retain Table 4 rate of 0.35 per berth for Marinas as provided development control 3.2
Number of parking and loading spaces.
6922-57 Pine Harbour Holdings Limited david@osbornehay.co.nz Natural Hazards and Flooding Natural Hazards H4.11.1 Activity table
Amend 1. Activity Table to clarify that within the Coastal Inundation overlay only have to be
considered under "Development - coastal inundation and sea level rise".
6922-58 Pine Harbour Holdings Limited david@osbornehay.co.nz Natural Hazards and Flooding Natural Hazards
Assessment Delete control 2.1(2) Permitted activities - development in coastal areas.
6922-59 Pine Harbour Holdings Limited david@osbornehay.co.nz Water Stormwater H4.14 Introduction
Amend Introduction under the header 'Stormwater diversion and discharge rules' as follows:
... To avoid doubt, stormwater from a private site directed to any part of the Auckland
Council a reticulated public stormwater network is considered part of the stormwater network
discharge provided it meets the requirements of any relevant stormwater network discharge
consent (where any such consent is held). ...
6922-60 Pine Harbour Holdings Limited david@osbornehay.co.nz General Miscellaneous Other Provide all Council stormwater network discharge consents on the Auckland Council website.
6922-61 Pine Harbour Holdings Limited david@osbornehay.co.nz Sustainable Development C7.7/H6.4 Sustainable design Delete Land use control 2.3 Industrial activities.
6922-62 Pine Harbour Holdings Limited david@osbornehay.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - Urban zones
except Rural
Add a specific activity for subdivision in precincts to create a lot for any controlled or restricted
discretionary activity as Controlled or Discretionary if the subdivision does not comply.
6922-63 Pine Harbour Holdings Limited david@osbornehay.co.nz Residential zones Residential
and Coastal Settlement zone Delete Rule 6.12 'Universal access'.
the CMA
Amend the activity status of 'Maintenance dredging' to Restricted Discretionary in the General
Coastal Marine zone and the SEA - M2 overlay.
Special information
requirements
Add the same matters of discretion and assessment criteria for Maintenance dredging as in
the Marina zone.
the CMA
Amend the activity status of 'Capital works dredging' to Restricted Discretionary in the
General Coastal Marine zone and the SEA - M2 overlay.
Special information
requirements
Add the same matters of discretion and assessment criteria for Capital works dredging as in
the Marina zone.
the CMA
Amend the activity status of 'Extension or alteration of existing lawful CMA structures or
buildings' from Discretionary to Restricted Discretionary in the General Coastal Marine zone
and the SEA - M2 overlay.
Special information
requirements
Add the same matters of discretion and assessment criteria for 'Extension or alteration of
existing lawful CMA structures or buildings' as in the Marina zone.
controls Delete Land and water use control 2.1 Noise.
controls
Amend Land and water use control 2.6(3) 'Dredging: River mouth dredging; dredging to
maintain or gain access to an existing lawful structure; and dredging to clear the exit of any
lawful stormwater outfall or pipe' to read as follows: The extent to which sediment mobilisation
and dispersal is minimised.
controls
Delete Land and water use control 2.7(1) 'CMA disturbance related to scientific or engineering
investigations and mineral prospecting, mineral exploration'.
the CMA Marina zone
Notification
Delete the Introduction statement referring to the General Coastal Marine zone and the Public
Open Space - Sport and Active Recreation.
the CMA Marina zone
Special information
requirements
Amend assessment criteria 5(2) to remove reference to relevant assessment criteria relating
to the Public Open Space - Sport and Active Recreation zone in the General Coastal Marine
zone.
488/1145
Sub#/
the CMA Marina zone
Notification
Add a new paragraph to the Introduction as follows: The rules or conditions within a precinct
(or a consented precinct) takes precedence over the same rules in the Marina zone or an
Auckland-wide provision, whether more restrictive or enabling.
the CMA Marina zone
Notification
Add a new paragraph to the Marina zone, particularly sections 1, 3 and 5, as follows: The
rules or conditions within a precinct (or a consented precinct) takes precedence over the
same rules in the Marina zone or an Auckland-wide provision, whether more restrictive or
enabling.
Amend the Framework Plan process to be used by those Marinas not covered by a specific
precinct while also adding new Matters of discretion and Assessment criteria for Marinas. See
submission for further details [pages 19 to 20/37 and pages 28 to 31/37 of submission].
the CMA Marina zone
Notification
Add a new activity to Activity Tables 1 and 2 to provide for the approval of a new precinct plan
or modification of an existing precinct plan as a Restricted Discretionary activity.
the CMA Marina zone
Notification Retain Activity Tables 1, 2 and 3.
the CMA Marina zone
Notification Amend the activity status of 'Food and Beverage' in Activity Table 2 to Permitted on land.
the CMA Marina zone
Notification
Amend the activity status of 'Marine industry other marine and port activities' in Activity Table
2 to Permitted on land.
the CMA Marina zone
Notification Delete 5(1)(2) Assessment criteria for 'Marine industry other marine and port activities'.
the CMA Marina zone
Notification
Amend the activity status of 'Observation areas, viewing platforms, boardwalks and boat
launching facilities' in Activity Table 3 to Controlled on land.
the CMA Marina zone
Notification
Amend the activity status of 'Maritime passenger facilities established after the date of plan
notification' in Activity Table 3 to Permitted in both the Coastal Marine Area and on land.
the CMA Marina zone
Special information
requirements
Delete 5(1)(2) Assessment criteria for 'Maritime passenger facilities established after the date
of plan notification'.
the CMA Marina zone
Notification Amend the activity status of all 'Offices' in Activity Table 2 to Permitted on land.
the CMA Marina zone
Notification
Add to Rule 2. Notification as follows: Resource consent applications for precinct plans (or
modifications to precinct plans) will be subject to the normal tests for notification under the
relevant sections of the RMA.
the CMA Marina zone
controls
Amend Land use control 3.1 Marine retail as follows: 1. The gross floor area of an individual
retail tenancy must not exceed 100m2 500m2. 2. The total cumulative gross floor area of
retail activities within the site must not exceed 300m2.
the CMA Marina zone
controls
Amend Development control 4.1 Building height as follows: ... 2. Buildings must not exceed
9m 18m in height above ground level when located on land. 3. Structures such as travel lifts
and boat stacking (not within buildings) must not exceed 12m 18m in height above ground
level when located on land. ...
the CMA Marina zone
controls Delete Development control 4.2 Yards.
the CMA Marina zone
controls
Amend Development control 4.3 Building coverage as follows: 1. The maximum permitted
building coverage or cumulative total area of buildings on land must not exceed 15 50 per
cent of the land area in the zone.
the CMA Marina zone
controls Delete Development control 4.4 Height in relation to boundary.
the CMA Marina zone
Special information
requirements
Amend 5.2(1)(a)(ix) Assessment criteria as follows: ix. the need for capital works and
on water quality
the CMA Marina zone
Special information
requirements Delete 5.2(4)(d) Assessment criteria.
the CMA Marina zone
Special information
requirements
Amend 5.2(4)(e) Assessment criteria as follows: Measures should be taken to maintain
or enhance public access to the CMA.
the CMA Marina zone
Special information
requirements
Amend 5.2(4)(g) Assessment criteria as follows: The activity should avoid, remedy or mitigate
to a reasonable and practical level adverse effects on the amenity of the locality arising from
use of the facility, including by controlling noise and hours of operation.
489/1145
Sub#/
the CMA Marina zone
Special information
requirements
Delete 6.1 Design Statement and replace with amendments as provided for in submission
[pages 30 and 31/37 of submission].
Amend the activity status of 'Food and beverage' in Sub-precinct A - Area 2 to Permitted in
K6.21.1 Activity table.
Amend the activity status of 'Marine retail' in Sub-precinct A - Area 1 to Permitted in K6.21.1
Activity table.
6922-
100 Pine Harbour Holdings Limited david@osbornehay.co.nz Precincts - South Pine Harbour
Add a new specific activity table for Sub-precinct B using the same activity status that is
provided for the Village Square zone in Rule 17.17.9.2 of the Manukau District Plan as well as
providing for 'Excavation works associated with the creation of new water space which will
become part of the coastal marine area' as a Controlled activity. See submission for further
details [page 24/27 of submission].
6922-
Add matters of discretion and assessment criteria for 'Excavation works associated with the
creation of new water space which will become part of the coastal marine area' as a
Controlled activity. See submission for further details [page 24/27 of submission].
6922-
Amend the activity status of 'Dwellings' in Sub-precinct C to Controlled in K6.21.1 Activity
Table.
6922-
Add the activity 'Bed and Breakfast Accommodation' to Sub-precinct C as a Permitted activity
in K6.21.1 Activity Table.
6922-
Add matters of control and assessment criteria for 'Bed and breakfast accommodation' as in
the current Pine Harbour Marina zone rules under 17.15.10.2 of the Manukau District Plan.
See submission for further details [page 24/37 of submission].
6922-
Amend the activity status of 'Dairies' in Sub-precinct C from Restricted Discretionary to
Controlled in K6.21.1 Activity Table.
6922-
Amend the activity status of 'Restaurants and Cafes' in Sub-precinct C from Restricted
Discretionary to Controlled in K6.21.1 Activity Table.
6922-
Amend the activity status of 'Food and beverage' in Sub-precinct C from Restricted
6922-
Amend the activity status of 'Offices' in Sub-precinct C from Restricted Discretionary to
Controlled in K6.21.1 Activity Table.
6922-
Amend the activity status of 'Community facilities' in Sub-precinct C from Restricted
6922-
Add matters of control and assessment criteria for Dairies, Restaurants and cafes, Food and
Beverage, Offices and Community facilities as in the current Pine Harbour Marina zone rules
under 17.15.10 of the Manukau District Plan. See submission for further details [page 25/37
of submission].
6922-
Delete and replace K6.21.2 Land use controls with Rule 2 with the development standards
table under Rule 17.15.9.3.2 of the Manukau District Plan. See submission for further details
[page 25/37 of submission].
6922-
Delete and replace Development controls K6.21.3.2 Height and K6.21.3.3 Building coverage
and impervious surface with Rule 3.2 and 3.3 and the development standards table under
Rule 17.15.9.3.2 of the Manukau District Plan. See submission for further details [page 25/37
of submission].
6922-
113 Pine Harbour Holdings Limited david@osbornehay.co.nz Precincts - South Pine Harbour Amend the height in Development control K6.21.3.2 Height for Area 1 to 18m.
6922-
114 Pine Harbour Holdings Limited david@osbornehay.co.nz Precincts - South Pine Harbour Add the 'building restriction line' from the Pine Harbour zone in the Manukau District Plan.
6922-
Amend Development control K6.21.3.4 Maritime passenger operations and facilities as
follows: 1. A ferry terminal terminus must be provided at all times.
6922-
116 Pine Harbour Holdings Limited david@osbornehay.co.nz Precincts - South Pine Harbour Delete Development control K6.21.3.6 Road Connection.
6922-
117 Pine Harbour Holdings Limited david@osbornehay.co.nz Zoning Coastal
Increase the extent of the Marina zone at Pine Harbour, Beachlands, as shown in Annexure C
[pages 34 to 37/37 of submission].
6922-
118 Pine Harbour Holdings Limited david@osbornehay.co.nz Zoning South
Rezone the reserves adjoining Pine Harbour from Public Open Space - Conservation to
Public Open Space - Informal Recreation.
6922-
119 Pine Harbour Holdings Limited david@osbornehay.co.nz
the CMA
sch. 6.2 ONC/HNC
6.1 Schedule SEA
Marine 1 and 2 Delete the SEA-M2-43a from any area zoned as a Marina [Turanga Creek Estuary].
6922-
120 Pine Harbour Holdings Limited david@osbornehay.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - Urban zones H5.2 3.1 Residential zones Delete the additional subdivision control overlay from 96 Karaka Road, Beachlands.
6922-
121 Pine Harbour Holdings Limited david@osbornehay.co.nz Natural Hazards and Flooding Natural Hazards Coastal inundation - maps only Delete or refine the coastal inundation overlay, particularly from Pine Harbour marina.
6922-
122 Pine Harbour Holdings Limited david@osbornehay.co.nz General
GIS viewer
Refine flood plain and flood prone area overlays to reflect the Council flood modelling for the
catchment [inferred to be the catchment for 96 Karaka Road, Beachlands].
490/1145
Sub#/
6922-
123 Pine Harbour Holdings Limited david@osbornehay.co.nz Mana Whenua
Whenua
Delete or refine the extent of the Mana Whenua overlay - ID 2821 to ensure its listing meets
the requirement of Part 2 and S31 and 32 of the RMA.
6922-
124 Pine Harbour Holdings Limited david@osbornehay.co.nz Historic Heritage (Overlay)
Heritage
Places
Refine the extent of place for ID 1290 at 20 and 23 Tui Brae, Beachlands. See submission for
further details [page 27/37 of submission].
6923-1 Keith Matheson
1696 Ararimu Road, RD3, Papakura,
Auckland 2583 Subdivision Auckland-wide - Urban zones H5.2 3.1 Residential zones Reduce the minimum site size in the Rural and Coastal Settlement zone to 2,500m
2
.
6923-2 Keith Matheson
1696 Ararimu Road, RD3, Papakura,
Auckland 2583
SEAs
Land Delete all SEAs from private freehold land.
6924-1 Forsyth Family Trust clevedon@ihug.co.nz Zoning South Rezone 1 West Road, Clevedon from Rural Production to Countryside Living Zone
6925-1 Allan A Shanahan allan@shanahanarchitects.co.nz Mana Whenua
Whenua
Delete Overlay and rewrite in a way that: respects property rights; provides a fair balance
between protection of cultural heritage and private property rights; uses clear and
unambiguous terminology; requires the council to be responsible for all Cultural Impact
Assessments with applicants dealing directly with the council and not with iwi.
Whenua
and policies
Delete Overlay and rewrite in a way that: respects property rights; provides a fair balance
between protection of cultural heritage and private property rights; uses clear and
unambiguous terminology; requires the council to be responsible for all Cultural Impact
Assessments with applicants dealing directly with the council and not with iwi.
Whenua
Grade the Sites of signficance to Mana Whenua into categories of significance, to be
accorded various degrees of protection and obligation.
Whenua
and policies
Grade the Sites of value to Mana Whenua into categories of significance, to be accorded
varying degrees of protection and obligation.
6925-5 Allan A Shanahan allan@shanahanarchitects.co.nz RPS Mana Whenua
Fig. 1
Explain to all affected parties the impact of, and the obligations required of the landowners,
when a place is designated a Site of Signficance or Value to Mana Whenua.
6925-6 Allan A Shanahan allan@shanahanarchitects.co.nz Mana Whenua General provisions
6925-7 Allan A Shanahan allan@shanahanarchitects.co.nz Mana Whenua General provisions
assessment
Remove the requirement to obtain Cultural Impact Assessment from iwi. Make the council the
agency responsible for preparing any Cultural Impact Assessment where the council deems it
necessary.
6925-8 Allan A Shanahan allan@shanahanarchitects.co.nz RPS Issues
Amend B1.4 by deleting the statement 'It is important to build stable and equal partnerships
which enable Mana Whenua to actively and meaningfully participate in the management of
natural resources'. This appears in the third paragraph under the heading 'Decision making,
environmental governance, partnerships and participation'.
6925-9 Allan A Shanahan allan@shanahanarchitects.co.nz RPS Issues
Amend B1.4 by deleting the bullet point 'Enable Mana Whenua to participate in co-
management of natural resources'. This statement appears under the heading 'Auckland
Plan strategic direction and priorities'.
6925-10 Allan A Shanahan allan@shanahanarchitects.co.nz RPS Mana Whenua
participation Amend B5.1 by deleting Policies 3 and 4.
6925-11 Allan A Shanahan allan@shanahanarchitects.co.nz RPS Mana Whenua B5 Strategic
Remove all provisions in the PAUP calling for partnership arrangements, shared governance,
co-management, joint management agreements and the transfer of power to Mana Whenua.
6925-12 Allan A Shanahan allan@shanahanarchitects.co.nz General Miscellaneous Consultation and engagement
Prior to entering any co-governance arrangements, hold a referendum on whether the
governance of physical and natural resources should be shared in partnership with Mana
Whenua.
6925-13 Allan A Shanahan allan@shanahanarchitects.co.nz Water
policies
Ensure that management decisions regarding freshwater resources, in Policy 5, lie solely with
democratically elected governing bodies, and not in partnership with Mana Whenua.
6925-14 Allan A Shanahan allan@shanahanarchitects.co.nz Water
water
Ensure that management decisions regarding freshwater resources, in Policy 11, lie solely
with democratically elected governing bodies, and not in partnership with Mana Whenua.
6926-1
Outdoor Boating Club of
Auckland Incorporated david@osbornehay.co.nz
the CMA Marina zone
6926-2
Auckland Incorporated david@osbornehay.co.nz RPS Coastal
6926-3
environment
practical level.
491/1145
Sub#/
6926-4
6926-5
environment
6926-6
environment
Amend Policy 4 as follows: Maintain ... that: a. have a functional need to be located below
MHWS; or b. are for public benefit and/or that enable recreational access and use of the CMA
by the public, including infrastructure that cannot be reasonably or practicably be located
outside the CMA, including existing uses, or c. enable the cultural or traditional use of the
CMA by Mana Whenua.
6926-7
environment
6926-8
6926-9
6926-10
And Policy 3(b) as follows: b. identifying and providing areas for particular recreational use
6926-11
6926-12
the CMA
declamation
6926-13
the CMA
declamation
and policies
6926-14
the CMA
declamation
and policies
policies
6926-15
the CMA
declamation
and policies
6926-16
the CMA
6926-17
the CMA
and policies
6926-18
the CMA
and policies
6926-19
the CMA
and policies
6926-20
the CMA
and policies
6926-21
the CMA
and policies
6926-22
the CMA
and occupation
D5.1.13 Background,
6926-23
the CMA
and occupation
D5.1.13 Background,
Amend Policy 9 as follows: Consider use and development to providing e for a new Marina
zone or to extend an existing Marina zone to be generally appropriate in locations: ...
6926-24
the CMA
and use
D5.1.15 Background,
6926-25
the CMA
and use
D5.1.15 Background,
6926-26
the CMA Marina zone
492/1145
Sub#/
6926-27
the CMA Marina zone
6926-28
the CMA Marina zone
Amend Objective 2 as follows: Marina facilities are use d, developed, used, maintained,
refurbished, reconstructed or extended, and berthage maximised while avoiding, remedying or
mitigating adverse effects on the coastal environment.
6926-29
the CMA Marina zone
6926-30
the CMA Marina zone
Amend Objective 5 as follows: Access to the waterfront for berth holders and the public
is preserved or maintained and enhanced.
6926-31
the CMA Marina zone
refurbishment, and reconstruction in existing marinas that avoids, remedies or mitigates to an
reasonable and practical level adverse effects on the coastal environment, including adjacent
land zoned for residential or open space purposes.
6926-32
the CMA Marina zone
6926-33
the CMA Marina zone
Amend Policy 8 to read as follows: Require any marina development to be of a scale, design
and materials and located so that it remedies or mitigates to a reasonable and practical
6926-34
the CMA Marina zone
boarders .
6926-35
the CMA Marina zone
6926-36
the CMA Marina zone
6926-37
Auckland Incorporated david@osbornehay.co.nz General Chapter G General provisions
Amend rule 1.4 Applying for resource consent to read as follows ... Making a resource
6926-38
Auckland Incorporated david@osbornehay.co.nz General Chapter A Introduction
Plan
Add a new section on Precinct Plans, similar to Section 2.6 Framework Plans. See
submission for further details [page 14/37 of submission - see also submission points 42 and
43 of same submission].
6926-39
statements
6926-40
Auckland Incorporated david@osbornehay.co.nz Mana Whenua General provisions
assessment
6926-41
Auckland Incorporated david@osbornehay.co.nz General Noise and vibration H6.2 Rules
noise.
6926-42
Auckland Incorporated david@osbornehay.co.nz General Noise and vibration H6.2 Rules Apply the General Business zone rules to the Marina zone.
6926-43
Auckland Incorporated david@osbornehay.co.nz Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
6926-44
Auckland Incorporated david@osbornehay.co.nz Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
Retain Table 4 proposed parking rates for land adjacent to a public boat launching ramps and
marinas in development control 3.2 Number of parking and loading spaces.
6926-45
Auckland Incorporated david@osbornehay.co.nz Natural Hazards and Flooding Natural Hazards H4.11.1 Activity table
Amend 1. Activity Table to clarify that works within the Coastal Inundation overlay only have
to be considered under "Development - coastal inundation and sea level rise".
493/1145
Sub#/
6926-46
Auckland Incorporated david@osbornehay.co.nz Natural Hazards and Flooding Natural Hazards
6926-47
Auckland Incorporated david@osbornehay.co.nz Water Stormwater H4.14 Introduction
6926-48
Auckland Incorporated david@osbornehay.co.nz General Miscellaneous Other Provide all Council stormwater network discharge consents on the Auckland Council website.
6926-49
Auckland Incorporated david@osbornehay.co.nz Sustainable Development C7.7/H6.4 Sustainable design Delete Land use control 2.3 Industrial activities.
6926-50
the CMA
6926-51
Special information
requirements
the Marina zone.
6926-52
6926-53
controls
Delete Land and water use control 2.6(3) Dredging: River mouth dredging; dredging to
lawful stormwater outfall or pipe.
6926-54
controls
Delete Land and water use control 2.7(1) CMA disturbance related to scientific or engineering
investigations and mineral prospecting, mineral exploration.
6926-55
the CMA Marina zone
Notification
6926-56
the CMA Marina zone
Special information
requirements
zone.
6926-57
the CMA Marina zone
Notification
6926-58
the CMA Marina zone
Notification
enabling.
6926-59
the CMA Marina zone
6926-60
the CMA Marina zone
Notification
6926-61
the CMA Marina zone
Special information
requirements Delete 5(1)(2) Assessment criteria for 'Marine industry other marine and port activities'.
6926-62
the CMA Marina zone
Notification
6926-63
the CMA Marina zone
6926-64
6926-65
the CMA Marina zone
Notification
6926-66
the CMA Marina zone
Notification
6926-67
the CMA Marina zone
controls
6926-68
the CMA Marina zone
controls
Amend Development control 4.1 Building height as follows: 1. Buildings must not exceed 5m
in height above mean sea level within the CMA except at the Outdoor Boating Club (Tamaki
Drive) where a 9m height control (measured from a level based on a 1 percent ARI storm tide
event) shall be applied for any marine recreational building.
494/1145
Sub#/
6926-69
Auckland Incorporated david@osbornehay.co.nz Precincts - Central New Precincts Other New Precincts
Add a precinct to the Outdoor Boating Club (Tamaki Drive) permitting a 9m height control for
marine recreational buildings. See submission for further details [page 16/23 of submission].
6926-70
the CMA Marina zone
controls
Provide for buildings exceeding the 5m height control by up to 4m as a Restricted
Discretionary activity and introduce specific matters of discretion and assessment criteria
focused on effect on coastal character, efficient use of the Marina zoned land and public
access.
6926-71
the CMA Marina zone
controls
Amend Development control 4.1 Building height as follows: ... 2. Buildings must not exceed
9m 18m in height above ground level when located on land 3.Structures such as travel lifts
and boat stacking (not within buildings) must not exceed 12m 18m in height above ground
level when located on land. ...
6926-72
the CMA Marina zone
6926-73
the CMA Marina zone
controls
6926-74
the CMA Marina zone
6926-75
the CMA Marina zone
Special information
requirements
on water quality
6926-76
the CMA Marina zone
Special information
6926-77
the CMA Marina zone
Special information
requirements
6926-78
the CMA Marina zone
Special information
requirements
Amend 5.2(4)(g) Assessment criteria as follows: The activity should avoid, remedy or
mitigate to a reasonable and practical level adverse effects on the amenity of the locality
arising from use of the facility, including by controlling noise and hours of operation.
6926-79
the CMA Marina zone
Special information
requirements
Delete 6.1 Design Statement and replace with amendments are provided in submission. See
submission for further details [pages 22 and 23/23 of submission].
6926-80
Auckland Incorporated david@osbornehay.co.nz Zoning Central
Rezone Lot 2 DP 135204 (adjoining land owned by Auckland Council - Lot 2 DP 135204) from
Public Open Space to Marina
6926-81
Auckland Incorporated david@osbornehay.co.nz Designations Auckland Transport
1620 Eastern Transport
Corridor Delete designation at 3-7 Tamaki Drive.
6927-1 Greg Nikoloff greg@farsight.co.nz Future Urban
Split Future Urban Zone into two sub-zones, one which relates to areas suitable for
development in the next 10 years and another suitable for development beyond that date.
The specific controls for the zoning, especially in "Future Urban (long term)", would reflect the
direction of some future urban zoning developing earlier and some later.
6927-2 Greg Nikoloff greg@farsight.co.nz Residential zones Residential
General
Remove or reduce front yard setback requirements particularly in zones where intensification
is anticipated
6927-3 Greg Nikoloff greg@farsight.co.nz Residential zones Residential Land use controls Remove density limits of four or more dwellings in the Mixed Housing Suburban zone
6927-4 Greg Nikoloff greg@farsight.co.nz Residential zones Residential Land use controls Remove the density limits to the Mixed Housing Urban Zone
6927-5 Greg Nikoloff greg@farsight.co.nz Transport Auckland -wide
requirements Remove parking minimums from Mixed Housing Urban and Mixed Housing Suburban zones
requirements Remove parking minimums for Tavern activities
6927-7 Greg Nikoloff greg@farsight.co.nz
Centre)
obs & pols
Recognise some areas zoned for Mixed use development should have a significantly higher
height limit to reflect their location close to high quality public transport infrastructure (e.g.
Morningside, Newton)
6927-8 Greg Nikoloff greg@farsight.co.nz Zoning Central
Rezone all areas between Morningside train station and St Lukes Shopping Centre, Mount
Albert from Light Industrial to Mixed Use
Rezone the area bounded by May Road to the west, Mt Albert Road to the north, SH20 to the
south and Mt Roskill Grammar to the east as Terraced Housing and Apartment Buildings
6927-10 Greg Nikoloff greg@farsight.co.nz Built Environment (Overlays)
Height Control
Add an "Additional height control" overlay to the sides of Great North Road between
Ponsonby Road and Surrey Crescent to enable a higher height limit.
495/1145
Sub#/
Rezone the areas within an 800m walk of Meadowbank train station to either Terraced
Housing and Apartment or Mixed Housing Urban (or a combination).
Rezone the areas zoned Mixed Housing Suburban within the area bounded by New North
Road in the west, the city fringe in the north, SH20 in the south and Great South Road in the
east from Mixed Housing Suburban to Mixed Housing Urban
Rezone both sides of Great South Road between Greenlane East/West and Main Highway
from Light Industrial to Mixed Use.
6927-14 Greg Nikoloff greg@farsight.co.nz Residential zones Residential Land use controls Retain Rule 3.3 'Conversion of a dwelling into two dwellings'.
6927-15 Greg Nikoloff greg@farsight.co.nz
Centre) Business
& Bus. Park zones Retain strong restrictions on retail and office activity outside centres zones
requirements Retain parking minimums in the various zones listed in Table 3 of Rule 3.2
6927-17 Greg Nikoloff greg@farsight.co.nz RPS Urban growth
Retain the areas zoned Mixed Use, Terrace Housing and Apartment or Centre zoned sites
which are close to rapid transit or high frequency public transport
6928-1
Gulf Harbour Investments
Limited david@osbornehay.co.nz
the CMA Marina zone
6928-2
Limited david@osbornehay.co.nz Precincts - North Gulf Harbour Marina Retain precinct.
6928-3
Limited david@osbornehay.co.nz RPS Urban growth
quality compact urban form Retain objectives and policies.
6928-4
6928-5
Amend Policy 2(b) as follows: b. in areas close to the frequent public transport routes
and public transport facilities
6928-6
Limited david@osbornehay.co.nz RPS Coastal
6928-7
environment
practical level.
6928-8
6928-9
environment
6928-10
environment
Amend Policy 4 as follows: Maintain the value of the coast as an open space area with free
public access by limiting use, occupation and development in the CMA to activities that: a.
have a functional need to be located below MHWS; or b. are for public benefit and/or that
enable recreational access and use of the CMA by the public, including infrastructure that
cannot be reasonably or practicably be located outside the CMA, including existing uses, or c.
enable the cultural or traditional use of the CMA by Mana Whenua.
6928-11
environment
6928-12
environment
Add new policy 7 as follows: Where appropriate, land adjacent to ferry terminals is used for
intensive urban development.
6928-13
6928-14
6928-15
Amend Policy 3(b) as follows: b. identifying and providing areas for particular recreational use
6928-16
496/1145
Sub#/
6928-17
the CMA
declamation
6928-18
the CMA
declamation
and policies
6928-19
the CMA
declamation
and policies
marinas, airports, roads, pipelines, electricity transmission, railways, ferry terminals, launching
ramps, slipways and electricity generation, where they comply with other relevant policies
6928-20
the CMA
declamation
and policies
6928-21
the CMA
6928-22
the CMA
and policies
6928-23
the CMA
and policies
6928-24
the CMA
and policies
6928-25
the CMA
and policies
6928-26
the CMA
and policies
6928-27
the CMA
and occupation
D5.1.13 Background,
6928-28
the CMA
and occupation
D5.1.13 Background,
Amend Policy 9 as follows: Consider use and development to providing e for a new Marina
zone or to extend an existing Marina zone to be generally appropriate in locations: ...
(c) where there is an existing water-based transport or recreation function, such as existing
ferry services, and the addition or extension of a marina consolidates this
function [submission refers to sub-clause (c) but details mataches sub-clause (b) of PAUP]
6928-29
the CMA
and use
D5.1.15 Background,
6928-30
the CMA
and use
D5.1.15 Background,
6928-31
the CMA Marina zone
6928-32
the CMA Marina zone
6928-33
the CMA Marina zone
Amend Objective 2 to read as follows: Marina facilities are used , developed, used,
maintained, refurbished, reconstructed or extended, and berthage maximised while avoiding,
remedying or mitigating adverse effects on the coastal environment to an appriopriate level,
while recognising the benefits obtained from Marinas.
6928-34
the CMA Marina zone
6928-35
the CMA Marina zone
6928-36
the CMA Marina zone
appropriate level adverse effects on the coastal environment, including adjacent land zoned
for residential or open space purposes.
6928-37
the CMA Marina zone
at Half Moon Bay, Bayswater, Pine Harbour, Gulf Harbour and West Harbour marinas.
6928-38
the CMA Marina zone
zones where this is practicable and will avoid, remedy or mitigate adverse effects on the
environment including: ...
497/1145
Sub#/
6928-39
the CMA Marina zone
6928-40
the CMA Marina zone
and materials and located so that it remedies or mitigates to an appropriate level adverse
effects on the coastal environment, particularly the following: a. the natural existing character
of the coastal environment ... i. the need for capital works and maintenance dredging within
the marina and any approach/entrance channel, options for disposal, measures to address
any contaminants in dredged material, and effects of dredging on water quality j. effects on
other users of the CMA including existing moorings and public boat ramps (except when being
relocated or removed as part of the development) ...
6928-41
the CMA Marina zone
Amend Policy 10 as follows: Require, if necessary, mitigation for any loss of public access to,
along and within the CMA, including providing facilities such as public boat ramps, and
alternative access for other recreational users such as windsurfers, kayakers and kite
boarders .
6928-42
the CMA Marina zone
6928-43
the CMA Marina zone
6928-44
Limited david@osbornehay.co.nz Precincts - North Gulf Harbour Marina Retain precinct.
6928-45
Limited david@osbornehay.co.nz Precincts - North Gulf Harbour Marina
Amend Policy 1 [in F5.14] as follows: 1. Require new development to be designed and located
in a manner that is; a. sensitive to the unique marine location Integrated with the existing and
expected future environment.
6928-46
Limited david@osbornehay.co.nz General Chapter G General provisions
6928-47
Limited david@osbornehay.co.nz General Chapter A Introduction
Plan
Introduction a new section on Precinct Plans, similar to Section 2.6 Framework Plans. See
6928-48
Limited david@osbornehay.co.nz General Chapter G General provisions
statements
6928-49
Limited david@osbornehay.co.nz Mana Whenua General provisions
assessment
6928-50
Limited david@osbornehay.co.nz General Noise and vibration H6.2 Rules
noise.
6928-51
Limited david@osbornehay.co.nz General Noise and vibration H6.2 Rules Apply the General Business zone rules to the Marina zone.
6928-52
Limited david@osbornehay.co.nz Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
6928-53
Limited david@osbornehay.co.nz Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
Retain Table 4 rate of parking for land adjacent to a public boat launching ramp and Marinas
as provided in development control 3.2 Number of parking and loading spaces.
6928-54
Limited david@osbornehay.co.nz Natural Hazards and Flooding Natural Hazards H4.11.1 Activity table
Amend 1. Activity Table to clarify that within the Coastal Inundation overlay only have to be
considered under "Development - coastal inundation and sea level rise".
6928-55
Limited david@osbornehay.co.nz Natural Hazards and Flooding Natural Hazards
6928-56
Limited david@osbornehay.co.nz Water Stormwater H4.14 Introduction
6928-57
Limited david@osbornehay.co.nz General Miscellaneous Other Provide all Council stormwater network discharge consents on the Auckland Council website.
498/1145
Sub#/
6928-58
Limited david@osbornehay.co.nz Sustainable Development C7.7/H6.4 Sustainable design Delete Land use control 2.3 Industrial activities.
6928-59
the CMA
6928-60
Special information
requirements
the Marina zone.
6928-61
6928-62
controls
Amend Land and water use control 2.6(3) 'Dredging: River mouth dredging; dredging to
lawful stormwater outfall or pipe' to read as follows: The extent to which sediment mobilisation
and dispersal is minimised.
6928-63
controls
Delete Land and water use control 2.7(1) 'CMA disturbance related to scientific or engineering
investigations and mineral prospecting, mineral exploration'.
6928-64
the CMA Marina zone
6928-65
the CMA Marina zone
Special information
requirements
zone.
6928-66
the CMA Marina zone
Notification
6928-67
the CMA Marina zone
controls
enabling.
6928-68
the CMA Marina zone
Notification Retain Activity Tables 1, 2 and 3.
6928-69
the CMA Marina zone
6928-70
the CMA Marina zone
Notification
6928-71
the CMA Marina zone
Special information
6928-72
the CMA Marina zone
Notification
6928-73
the CMA Marina zone
Notification
notification' in Activity Table 3 from Restricted Discretionary to Permitted in both the Coastal
Marine Area and on land.
6928-74
the CMA Marina zone
Special information
requirements
Delete 5(1)(2) Assessment criteria for 'Maritime passenger facilities established after the date
of plan notification'.
6928-75
the CMA Marina zone
6928-76
the CMA Marina zone
Special information
requirements
6928-77
the CMA Marina zone
Notification
6928-78
the CMA Marina zone
Notification
6928-79
the CMA Marina zone
controls
6928-80
the CMA Marina zone
Special information
requirements
Amend 5(1) and(2) Assessment - Restricted discretionary activities to exempt applications for
new precinct plans or modifications to existing precinct plans.
499/1145
Sub#/
6928-81
the CMA Marina zone
controls
Amend Development control 4.1 Building height as follows: ... 2. Buildings must not
exceed 9m 18m in height above ground level when located on land. 3. Structures such as
travel lifts and boat stacking (not within buildings) must not exceed 12m 18m in height above
ground level when located on land. ...
6928-82
the CMA Marina zone
6928-83
the CMA Marina zone
controls
6928-84
the CMA Marina zone
6928-85
the CMA Marina zone
Special information
requirements
on water quality
6928-86
the CMA Marina zone
Special information
6928-87
the CMA Marina zone
Special information
requirements
6928-88
the CMA Marina zone
Special information
requirements
6928-89
the CMA Marina zone
Special information
requirements
Delete 6.1 Design Statement and replace with amendments as provided in submission [pages
24 and 25/25 of submission].
6928-90
Amend the activity status of 'Food and Beverage' to Permitted on land in both sub-precincts in
Activity Table 1.2 [under K5.14].
6928-91
Amend the activity status of 'Non-marine retail' to Permitted on land in sub-precinct B in
Activity Table 1.2 [under K5.14].
6928-92
Amend the activity status of 'Offices not accessory to a marine and port activity' to Permitted
on land in sub-precinct B in Activity Table 1.2 [under K5.14].
6928-93
Amend the activity status of all offices permitted in both sub-precincts in Activity Table 1.2
[under K5.14].
6928-94
Amend the activity status of 'Manufacture of vessels and boating/marine equipment' to
Permitted on land in sub-precinct A in Activity Table 1.2 [under K5.14].
6928-95
Limited david@osbornehay.co.nz Precincts - North Gulf Harbour Marina Add new rule to permit a maximum building height of 18m in both sub-precincts [under K5.14].
6928-96
Add new rule to permit a maximum building coverage of 50% in both sub-precincts [under
K5.14].
6928-97
Limited david@osbornehay.co.nz Zoning Coastal Retain Marina zone at Gulf Harbour.
6928-98
Limited david@osbornehay.co.nz Natural Hazards and Flooding Natural Hazards Coastal inundation - maps only Delete of refine the Coastal Inundation overlay.
6928-99
Limited david@osbornehay.co.nz Precincts - North Gulf Harbour Marina Retain the extent of the precinct.
6930-1 Auckland Maritime Foundation david@osbornehay.co.nz
the CMA Marina zone
6930-2 Auckland Maritime Foundation david@osbornehay.co.nz RPS Urban growth
quality compact urban form Retain objectives and policies.
Amend Policy 2(b) as follows: b. in areas close to the frequent public transport routes and
public transport facilities.
6930-5 Auckland Maritime Foundation david@osbornehay.co.nz RPS Coastal
500/1145
Sub#/
environment
practical level.
environment
environment
Amend Policy 4 as follows: Maintain the value of the coast as an open space area with free
public access by limiting use, occupation and development in the CMA to activities that: a.
have a functional need to be located below MHWS; or b. are for public benefit and/or that
enable recreational access and use of the CMA by the public, including infrastructure that
cannot be reasonably or practicably be located outside the CMA, including existing uses, or c.
enable the cultural or traditional use of the CMA by Mana Whenua.
environment
transport activities, ....
environment
Add a new Policy 6 as follows: Where appropriate, land adjacent to ferry terminals is used for
intensive urban development.
And Policy 3(b) as follows: b. identifying and providing areas for particular recreational use
the CMA
declamation
the CMA
declamation
and policies
the CMA
declamation
and policies
policies
the CMA
declamation
and policies
the CMA
the CMA
and policies
the CMA
and policies
Amend Objective 3 as follows: The safe and efficient operation of significant
infrastructure and marinas is enabled, including through undertaking dredging where
necessary.
the CMA
and policies
the CMA
and policies
the CMA
and policies
the CMA
and occupation
D5.1.13 Background,
501/1145
Sub#/
the CMA
and occupation
D5.1.13 Background,
Amend Policy 9 to read as follows: Consider use and development to providinge for a new
Marina zone or to extend an existing Marina zone to be generally appropriate in locations: ...
c. where there is an existing water-based transport or recreation function, such as existing
ferry services, and the addition or extension of a marina consolidates this function
[submission refers to sub-clause (c) but details mataches sub-clause (b) of PAUP].
the CMA
and use
D5.1.15 Background,
the CMA
and use
D5.1.15 Background,
the CMA Marina zone
the CMA Marina zone
the CMA Marina zone
Amend Objective 2 as follows: Marina facilities are used, developed, used, maintained,
refurbished, reconstructed or extended, and berthage maximised while avoiding, remedying or
mitigating adverse effects on the coastal environment to an appropriate level, while
recognising the benefits obtained from Marinas.
the CMA Marina zone
the CMA Marina zone
the CMA Marina zone
appropriate level adverse effects on the coastal environment, including adjacent land zoned
for residential or open space purposes.
the CMA Marina zone
at ...
the CMA Marina zone
zones where this is ...
the CMA Marina zone
the CMA Marina zone
and materials and located so that it remedies or mitigates to a reasonable and practical
the CMA Marina zone
boarders .
the CMA Marina zone
the CMA Marina zone
6930-43 Auckland Maritime Foundation david@osbornehay.co.nz General Chapter G General provisions
6930-44 Auckland Maritime Foundation david@osbornehay.co.nz General Chapter A Introduction
Plan
Add a new section on Precinct Plans, similar to Section 2.6 Framework Plans. See
502/1145
Sub#/
statements
6930-46 Auckland Maritime Foundation david@osbornehay.co.nz Mana Whenua General provisions
assessment
6930-47 Auckland Maritime Foundation david@osbornehay.co.nz General Noise and vibration H6.2 Rules
noise.
6930-48 Auckland Maritime Foundation david@osbornehay.co.nz Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
6930-49 Auckland Maritime Foundation david@osbornehay.co.nz Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
Retain Table 4 proposed parking rates for land adjacent to a public boat launching ramps and
marinas in development control 3.2 Number of parking and loading spaces.
6930-50 Auckland Maritime Foundation david@osbornehay.co.nz Natural Hazards and Flooding Natural Hazards H4.11.1 Activity table
Amend 1. Activity Table to clarify that works within the Coastal Inundation overlay only have
to be considered under "Development - coastal inundation and sea level rise".
6930-51 Auckland Maritime Foundation david@osbornehay.co.nz Natural Hazards and Flooding Natural Hazards
6930-52 Auckland Maritime Foundation david@osbornehay.co.nz Water Stormwater H4.14 Introduction
6930-53 Auckland Maritime Foundation david@osbornehay.co.nz General Miscellaneous Other Provide all Council stormwater network discharge consents on the Auckland Council website.
6930-54 Auckland Maritime Foundation david@osbornehay.co.nz Sustainable Development C7.7/H6.4 Sustainable design Delete Land use control 2.3 Industrial activities.
6930-55 Auckland Maritime Foundation david@osbornehay.co.nz Zoning South
Retain Neighbourhood Centre zone at the commercial area adjacent to Half Moon Bay
[specific address not given].
Centre) Business
& Bus. Park zones
Amend the activity status of 'Marine retail' in the Neighbourhood Centre zone to reflect the
activity status of other types of retail in the same zone.
Centre) Business
& Bus. Park zones
Amend the activity of 'Offices greater than 500m GFA per site' to exempt Half Moon Bay as
follows: Offices greater than 500m GFA per site (except that this rule shall not apply to Lot 1
DP 74913 and Lot 2 DP 74912 (Half Moon Bay Marina)).
Centre) Business
& Bus. Park zones
Amend the activity status of 'Supermarkets greater than 4000m GFA per site' from Non-
complying to Discretionary in the Neighbourhood Centre zone.
Centre) Business
& Bus. Park zones
Amend the activity status of 'New buildings' from Restricted Discretionary to Permitted in the
Neighbourhood Centre zone.
the CMA
Special information
requirements
the Marina zone.
the CMA
Amend the activity status of 'Capital dredging' to Restricted Discretionary in the General
Special information
requirements
Add the same matters of discretion and assessment criteria for Capital dredging as in the
Marina zone.
controls
Delete and replace Land and water use control 3.6(3) as follows: The extent to which
sediment mobilisation and dispersal is minimised.
controls Delete Land and water use control 2.7(1).
the CMA Marina zone
Notification
the CMA Marina zone
Special information
requirements
zone.
the CMA Marina zone
Notification
503/1145
Sub#/
the CMA Marina zone
Special information
requirements
enabling.
the CMA Marina zone
Notification
the CMA Marina zone
the CMA Marina zone
Notification
the CMA Marina zone
Special information
the CMA Marina zone
Notification
the CMA Marina zone
Notification
notification' in Activity Table 3 from Restricted discretionary to Permitted in the CMA and on
land.
the CMA Marina zone
the CMA Marina zone
controls
the CMA Marina zone
Notification
the CMA Marina zone
Special information
requirements
Amend 5. Assessment - Restricted discretionary activities to exempt applications for new
precinct plans or modifications to existing precinct plans. See submission for further details
[page 20/29 and pages 23 to 29/29 of submission].
the CMA Marina zone
controls
Amend Development control '4.1 Building height' as follows: ... 2. Buildings must not
exceed 9m 18m in height above ground level when located on land 3.Structures such as
travel lifts and boat stacking (not within buildings) must not exceed 12m 18m in height above
ground level when located on land. ...
the CMA Marina zone
the CMA Marina zone
controls
cent of the land area in the zone except at Half Moon Bay Marine which is to be limited to 15
per cent until such time a Precinct Plan has been consented or resource obtained for any non-
compliance.
the CMA Marina zone
the CMA Marina zone
Special information
requirements
on water quality
the CMA Marina zone
Special information
the CMA Marina zone
Special information
requirements
the CMA Marina zone
Special information
requirements
the CMA Marina zone
Special information
requirements
Delete 6.1 Design Statement and replace with provisions as provided in submission [page 25
and 26/29 of submission].
504/1145
Sub#/
6930-91 Auckland Maritime Foundation david@osbornehay.co.nz Zoning South
Amend the extent of the Marina zone at Half Moon Bay marina as shown in submission [page
29/29 of submission].
6930-92 Auckland Maritime Foundation david@osbornehay.co.nz Natural Hazards and Flooding Natural Hazards Coastal inundation - maps only Remove or refine overlay.
6930-93 Auckland Maritime Foundation david@osbornehay.co.nz General Noise and vibration H6.2 Rules Apply the General Business zone rules to the Marina zone.
6931-1
Grant and Deborah Andrew
and GDMK Properties Limited d.andrew@hyper.net.nz RPS Urban growth
land for urban development Bring forward a Waiuku area plan.
6931-2
and GDMK Properties Limited d.andrew@hyper.net.nz RPS Changes to the RUB South Provide some Future Urban zoned land around Waiuku.
6931-3
and GDMK Properties Limited d.andrew@hyper.net.nz General Miscellaneous Special housing areas Provide for Special Housing Areas in Waiuku.
6931-4
and GDMK Properties Limited d.andrew@hyper.net.nz General Miscellaneous
Operational/
Projects/Acquisition Provide for public transport improvements in Waiuku.
6931-5
and GDMK Properties Limited d.andrew@hyper.net.nz
Centre) Business
Park zones
Amend to clarify what the maximum height is for non-habitable business structures in the
Local Centre zone in Waiuku.
6931-6
Centre)
obs & pols
Amend to clarify whether buildings with a mix of business and low rise residential dwellings
are allowed in the Local Centre zone in Waiuku.
6931-7
the CMA
Retain the provisions to clear mangroves and enhance the waterways of the Waiuku Harbour
entrance.
6931-8
and GDMK Properties Limited d.andrew@hyper.net.nz Historic Heritage (Overlay)
Heritage
Places Re-evaluate the heritage aspects of Waiuku.
6931-9
control
Amend the pre-1944 demolition control overlay provisions after Council has undertaken a
detailed inspection of each affected Waiuku dwelling.
6931-10
and GDMK Properties Limited d.andrew@hyper.net.nz General Miscellaneous Consultation and engagement
Acknowledge that consultation with individual landowners on the pre-1944 demolition control
overlay has been poor.
6931-11
and GDMK Properties Limited d.andrew@hyper.net.nz Historic Heritage (Overlay)
Heritage
Places Investigate heritage dwellings in the rural area surrounding Waiuku.
6931-12
control
Amend to clarify for the pre-1944 demolition control overlay whether the zoning changes,
whether resource consent will be required for alterations to the interior and exterior, what the
criteria are for assessing resource consent applications, and what infrastructure the council
has to process the resource consents.
6932-1 Carl Gravatt grasinis_cafe@xtra.co.nz General Miscellaneous Special housing areas
Recognise the SHA in Kumera/Huapai is proposing to change so much of the fabric of the
community, and the proposed SHA will over double the population of the area
6932-2 Carl Gravatt grasinis_cafe@xtra.co.nz General Miscellaneous Other
Acknowledge that vehicle congestion exists in the feeder roads already and there is not a
good transport system and the population has very little option but to use cars in
Kumeu/Huapai.
6932-3 Carl Gravatt grasinis_cafe@xtra.co.nz RPS Urban growth
and villages
Remove industrial/commercial trucking ventures such as tips/landfills on rural road in
Kumera/Hapai
6932-4 Carl Gravatt grasinis_cafe@xtra.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - Rural zones
area
Seeks tighter controls on the type of housing subdivisions allowed in Rodney (in particular
Kumeu/Huapai) to keep the special character in tact
6933-1 Frucor Beverages Limited
97 Plunket Avenue, Wiri, Auckland
2104 Zoning South Retain Heavy Industry zone for 93 and 97 Plunket Ave and 22 Orb Ave, Wiri.
Notification
Amend activity table to provide for greater flexibility in parking assessments to recognise
unique situations.
2104 Water Stormwater
rules
Delete rules until costs are adequately quantified and an alternative has been identified that
responds to the actual and potential environmental effects.
H4.14.2 Stormwater
rules
6934-1 Tom Fuyala tom@eosglo.com Zoning Central
Rezone 248 Jervois Road (otherwise known as 1 Kelmarna Ave), Ponsonby to apply a Local
Centre zoning, and the rear balance of the property should be subject to a much lesser
intensity with height restrictions.
6935-1 Tania Perkinson tania.perkinson@orcon.net.nz Residential zones Residential Activity Table
Provide 'professional commercial activities' on the northern stretch of Jervois Road between
Salisbury Street and Wallace Street, Ponsonby
6936-1 Wayne J Langley wayne.langley@vodafone.co.nz RPS Mana Whenua B5 Strategic Require a mandate to be sought from the public re equal partnership and co-management
505/1145
Sub#/
6937-1
Waimauku United Land
Owners Group francisbro@xtra.co.nz RPS Changes to the RUB West
Rezone the land at 42 and 44 Wintour Road, 50 Freshfields Road, and Lot 32 DP331139,
Waimauku (as shown in Annexure B on page 11/11 in the submission) from Mixed Rural to
Single House.
6937-2
Waimauku United Land
Owners Group francisbro@xtra.co.nz RPS Changes to the RUB West
map on page 7/11 in the submission) from Rural Production to Future Urban (excluding the
land at 42 and 44 Wintour Road, 50 Freshfields Road, and Lot 32 DP331139, Waimauku (as
shown in Annexure B on page 11/11 in the submission)).
6939-1 Mark Ziegler evilvr4@hotmail.com Transport
transport noise J1.5 Rules and mapping Delete overlay from 87A Hill Road, Manurewa.
transport noise J1.5 Rules and mapping Delete maximum internal noise rule.
Clarify how the maximum internal noise rule fits within the overall consent process ie a
requirement to be met before consent is granted or as part of final inspection.
transport noise J1.5 Rules and mapping Delete ventilation rules from 87A Hill Road, Manurewa.
Amend maximum internal noise and ventilation rules to apply only to new bedrooms and
habitable bedrooms ... not to altered bedrooms and habitable rooms.
6940-1 Jitendra Pal chriskits@gmail.com
Centre) Business
Park zones Amend the maximum height rule to be unlimited on 46 Wellington Street, Howick
6940-2 Jitendra Pal chriskits@gmail.com
Centre) Business
Park zones
Add a rule that still seeks to protect adjoining residential zone in terms of height in relation to
boundary protection
6941-1 A L Hong bobtoi@clear.net.nz Zoning Central
Rezone part of 6 Carlton Gore Road from Single House to Terrace Housing and
Apartment Building. Refer to map on page 3/3 of the submission.
6942-1 Tet V Lee tvernelee@gmail.com Transport Auckland -wide
requirements Remove parking minimums for Mixed Housing Urban and Mixed Housing Suburban
6942-2 Tet V Lee tvernelee@gmail.com Transport Auckland -wide
requirements Remove parking minimums for tavern activities
6942-3 Tet V Lee tvernelee@gmail.com Residential zones Residential Land use controls
Remove density limits for development of four or more dwellings in the Mixed Housing
Suburban zone
6942-4 Tet V Lee tvernelee@gmail.com Residential zones Residential Land use controls Add no density limits provision in Mixed Housing Urban zone.
6942-5 Tet V Lee tvernelee@gmail.com Residential zones Residential
General Remove or reduce front yard setback requirements
6942-6 Tet V Lee tvernelee@gmail.com RPS Urban growth
Recognise areas near high quality public transport (e.g. Newton), and these areas should
have much higher height limits to reflect this fact and the value of these location
6942-7 Tet V Lee tvernelee@gmail.com Future Urban
Amend the future urban zone so it is split into two or more zones to allow staged expansion
and keep 70% growth within current urban limits
Increase the possibility of intensification by 'upzoning' as many areas as possible to Mixed
Housing Suburban, Mixed Housing Urban, Terrace Housing and Apartments, Mixed us as
appropriate.
Rezone areas in proximity to ferry terminals to allow for intensification using mixed housing
suburban and mixed housing urban, where the sites are not constrained by heritage or other
restrictions
6942-10 Tet V Lee tvernelee@gmail.com Zoning Central
Rezone area bounded by SH20, Mt Roskill Grammar, Mt Albert Road and May Road to
Terrace Housing and Apartments Buildings
Rezone both sides of Great South Road between Greenlane and Main Highway from Light
Industrial to Mixed Use.
Rezone all areas within 800m walking distance to Meadowbank station as Mixed Housing
Urban or Terrace Housing and Apartments
Rezone the area bounded by Great South Road, City fringe, New North Road and SH20 from
Mixed Housing Suburban to Mixed Housing Urban
6942-14 Tet V Lee tvernelee@gmail.com Built Environment (Overlays)
Height Control
Increase the height limit to the properties along Great North Road between Ponsonby Road
and Surrey Crescent
Rezone the areas between Morningside Station and St Lukes Mall from Light Industrial to
Mixed Use
6943-1 Remuera Business Association laura@remuera.org.nz Built Environment (Overlays)
Height Control Reduce the height restriction along Remuera Road within the town centre to three storeys.
6943-2 Remuera Business Association laura@remuera.org.nz Transport Auckland -wide Mapping Delete Arterial Road notation from Remuera Road.
6944-1 Barry J Brown bbrown@colbar.co.nz General Whole Plan Decline the proposed plan
506/1145
Sub#/
6944-2 Barry J Brown bbrown@colbar.co.nz Zoning South Decline the intensification on Claude Road, Manurewa
6944-3 Barry J Brown bbrown@colbar.co.nz Historic Heritage (Overlay)
Heritage
Places Add historic houses along Claude Road
6944-4 Barry J Brown bbrown@colbar.co.nz
control
Building demolition control J.3.6 Rules and mapping Clarify why this was not notified. Refer to submission
6944-5 Barry J Brown bbrown@colbar.co.nz Trees
Trees
Notable Trees Amend notable trees schedule Refer to submission.
6944-6 Barry J Brown bbrown@colbar.co.nz
SEAs
Land Amend Significant Ecological Areas for Hillspark. Refer to submission.
6945-1 CBC Wastewater craig@cbcwastewater.co.nz Water Wastewater H4.15 Onsite wastewater rules
Amend provisions so that future versions of the technical publication TP58 can be given effect
to automatically without requiring a plan change.
Amend control 2.1(5) so that the requirement for fencing is only required when heavy vehicle
or stock access could actually be at risk.
Amend controls 2.1(2), 2.1(4), and 2.1(5) to say "septic tanks where used must..."
and instead of "aerobic treatment system," specify the level of treatment required (eg
BOD5<20, SS<30) or refer to a "secondary treatment system".
6946-1 Andrew Williamson andrewandleonie@gmail.com Special Character
General
6946-2 Andrew Williamson andrewandleonie@gmail.com Zoning Central Retain the Single Housing zone applying to Balmoral streets
6946-3 Andrew Williamson andrewandleonie@gmail.com Residential zones Residential
6946-4 Andrew Williamson andrewandleonie@gmail.com
control
6947-1 Andrew Brands Limited daniel@sfhconsultants.co.nz Zoning North and Islands Rezone 239 Archers Road, Wairau Valley from Light Industry to General Business.
6947-2 Andrew Brands Limited daniel@sfhconsultants.co.nz
Centre) Business
& Bus. Park zones
Amend table to change the activity status of offices greater than 500m
2
per site in the General
Business zone from Discretionary to Restricted Discretionary [see pages 3-7/8 for details].
6948-1 AgResearch Limited tony.conner@agresearch.co.nz
organisms
modified organisms Remove all GMO provisions from the proposed Auckland Unitary Plan
6949-1 Rhondda F Richardson ronnier@actrix.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - Urban zones H5.2 3.1 Residential zones
Amend rule 1 'Site size' Table 1 to reduce minimum site size in the Single House zone from
600m
2
to 500m
2
.
6949-2 Rhondda F Richardson ronnier@actrix.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - Urban zones H5.2 3.1 Residential zones Amend rule 2(c) 'Site Shape Factor' from 8m wide to 7.5m wide.
6949-3 Rhondda F Richardson ronnier@actrix.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - Urban zones
except Rural
Amend to include specific purpose statement, objectives, policies and assessment criteria
relevant to each area.
6949-4 Rhondda F Richardson ronnier@actrix.co.nz Residential zones Residential
policies
Add an objective which reads: 'Development provides high quality onsite amenity for residents
and respects the amenity of adjacent sites.'
6949-5 Rhondda F Richardson ronnier@actrix.co.nz Residential zones
& pols
Delete Objective 2 [infer] and replace with new Objective to read: 'Development provides high
quality onsite amenity for residents and respects the amenity of adjacent sites.'
pols
obs & pols
Add a new objective which reads: 'Development provides high quality onsite amenity for
residents and respects the amenity of adjacent sites.'
pols
policies
Delete Policy 2 and replace with new policy which requires dwellings to have solar access
[see submission page 4/11 for details].
policies Retain the Mixed Housing Urban and the Mixed Housing Suburban zones.
& pols
Delete Policy 1(a) which refers to supporting infrastructure and add a new policy which reads:
'Require minumum sites sizes for subdivision to demonstrate that waste water can be
contained within the boundaries of the site.'
507/1145
Sub#/
pols
Delete Policy [1(a)] which refers to accommodating infrastructure necessary to support the
dwelling and add a new policy which reads: 'Require minumum sites sizes for subdivision to
demonstrate that waste water can be contained within the boundaries of the site.'
Amend Rule 7.4 'Alternative height in relation to boundary' activity status from Restricted
Discretionary to Permitted [see submission page 5/11 for details].
Amend Rule 8.4 'Alternative height in relation to boundary' activity status from Restricted
Discretionary to Permitted [see submission page 5/11 for details].
Amend Rule 7.4.(4) 'Alternative height in relation to boundary' so that gable ends and dorma
windows are not exempted.
Amend Rule 8.4.(4) 'Alternative height in relation to boundary' so that gable ends and dorma
windows are not exempted.
Amend Rule 7.4.(5) 'Alternative height in relation to boundary' to change activity status for
infringing the control from a Discretionary Activity to a Restricted Discretionary Activity and
that written permission from adjacent property owners is required.
Amend Rule 8.4.(5) 'Alternative height in relation to boundary' to change activity status for
infringing the control from a Discretionary Activity to a Restricted Discretionary Activity and
that written permission from adjacent property owners is required.
Clarify whether Rules 7.4 [Alternative height in relation to boundary] and 8.4 [Alternative
height in relation to boundary] are development control infringements for the purpose of Rules
7.1 [Development control infringements] and 8.1 [Development control infringements] [refer to
submission page 5-6/11 for details].
Mixed Housing Urban zone Retain rule 7.5 [Yards] requiring 4m front yard setback in the Mixed Housing Suburban zone.
Retain Rule 8.6 [Yards] requiring 2.5m front yard setback in the Mixed Housing Urban zone
(inferred).
Amend the 'purpose' of Rule 7.5 'Yards' by adding a statement which requires daylight,
access and visual separation [refer to submission page 7/11 for details].
Amend the 'purpose' of rule 8.5 'Yards' [inferred 8.6 'Yards'] by adding a statement which
requires daylight, access and visual separation [refer to submission page 7/11 for details].
Amend Rule 7.5 'Yards' to provide exemptions to the 1m yard setback [refer to submission
page 7/11 for details].
Amend Rule 8.5 'Yards' [inferred 8.6 'Yards'] to provide exemptions to the 1m yard setback
[refer to submission page 7/11 for details].
Amend Rule 7.5 'Yards' to add a rule that any exemption to the 1m side yard requirements is
subject to a further requirement about solar accessibility [refer to submission page 7/11 for
details].
Amend Rule 8.5 'Yards' to add a rule that any exemption to the 1m side yard requirements is
subject to a further requirement about solar accessibility [refer to submission page 7/11 for
details].
6949-30 Rhondda F Richardson ronnier@actrix.co.nz Sustainable Development C7.7/H6.4 Sustainable design Amend rules to require all dwellings to achieve a 6 star energy rating.
Special info. req.
Add an assessment criteria with accompanying diagram which requires passive solar heating
in dwellings and outdoor living areas and appropriate orientation to achieve this [refer to
submission page 7/11 for details].
6949-32 Rhondda F Richardson ronnier@actrix.co.nz Definitions New
Add a definition 'Delineated outdoor living space' which identifies a specific area of outdoor
living.
Amend Rule 6.9 'Outdoor living space' - to add a new purpose which requires delineated
outdoor living spaces and their locations [refer to submission page 8/11 for details].
Amend Rule 7.[12] 'Outdoor living space' to add a new purpose which requires delineated
508/1145
Sub#/
Amend Rule 8.[12] 'Outdoor living space' to add a new purpose which requires delineated
Amend Rule 6.9 'Outdoor living space' to include a rule to prescribe the location and
orientation of the outdoor living area and its position in relation to walls [see submission page
8/11 for details]
Amend Rule 7.[12] 'Outdoor living space' to include a rule to prescribe the location and
8/11 for details]
Amend Rule 8.[12] 'Outdoor living space' to include a rule to prescribe the location and
8/11 for details]
Special info. req.
Amend to include Assessment Criteria for Restricted Discretionary Activities which specify
location and orientation of outdoor living areas and to what extent it makes use of solar
access [refer to submission pages 8-9/11 for details]
Retain Rule 6.9 'Outdoor Living Space' in particular those set out in the submission [see page
9/11 of the submission for details]
Retain Rule 7.12 'Outdoor Living Space' in particular those set out in the submission [see
Terrace Housing and
Amend Rule 6.9 'Outdoor living space' to increase the area of delineated outdoor living space
from 20m
2
to 25m
2
.
Amend Rule 7.12 'Outdoor living space' to increase the area of delineated outdoor living
space from 20m
2
to 25m
2
.
Amend Rule 8.12 'Outdoor living space' to increase the area of delineated outdoor living
space from 20m
2
to 25m
2
.
Amend Rule 6.9 'Outdoor living space' to adjust the dimensions of balconies as set out in
submission [refer to submission page 9/11 for details].
Terrace Housing and
Amend Rule 6.7 'Building coverage - Purpose' to read: 'Maintain the suburban residential
character of zone.'
Amend Rule 7.8 'Building coverage - Purpose' to read: 'Maintain the suburban residential
character of zone whilst making efficient use of the site.'
Amend Rule 8.8 'Building coverage - Purpose' to read: 'Maintain the urban residential
character of zone whilst making efficient use of the site.'
509/1145
Sub#/
and Coastal Settlement zone Amend Rule 6.7 'Building coverage' to increase building coverage from 35% to 40%.
Amend Rule 7.8 'Building coverage' to increase building coverage for sites up to 400m
2
from
40% to 50% and for sites over 400m
2
from 50% to 55%.
Amend Rule 8.8 'Building coverage' to increase building coverage for sites up to 300m
2
from
40% to 50% and for sites over 400m
2
from 50% to 60%.
6949-57 Rhondda F Richardson ronnier@actrix.co.nz General Chapter G General provisions G2.4 Notification Delete rule 2(4) Notification.
6949-58 Rhondda F Richardson ronnier@actrix.co.nz General Chapter G General provisions G2.4 Notification
Amend to include a list of restricted discretionary activities in the PAUP which should be
exempted from normal tests for notification.
6949-59 Rhondda F Richardson ronnier@actrix.co.nz Residential zones Residential Land use controls
Delete all density controls for the Mixed Housing zones [infer - Mixed housing suburban and
Mixed Housing Urban] [Refer to submission page 5/11]
6950-1 Elise Macdonald elise@syfir.com Zoning North and Islands Rezone the Whangateau Harbour Catchment area to Rural Coastal Zone
6950-2 Elise Macdonald elise@syfir.com Precincts - North Omaha Flats Remove Omaha Flats Mixed Activity precinct
6950-3 Elise Macdonald elise@syfir.com Zoning North and Islands
Recognise that the whole of Whangateau Harbour Catchment area was Rural Coastal Zone
including the Omaha Flats area, and there is no infrastructure to support this change which
will have an adverse effect on Whangateau Harbour with its sensitive environment
6951-1 Michele Colligan speightcolligan@gmail.com Special Character
General
6951-2 Michele Colligan speightcolligan@gmail.com Zoning Central Retain the Single Housing zone applying to Balmoral streets
6951-3 Michele Colligan speightcolligan@gmail.com Residential zones Residential
6951-4 Michele Colligan speightcolligan@gmail.com
control
6952-1 Shelley Lovett chriskits@gmail.com Historic Heritage (Overlay)
Heritage
heritage areas Reject the overlay rules for 357 Onehunga Mall, Onehunga.
6952-2 Shelley Lovett chriskits@gmail.com Historic Heritage (Overlay)
Heritage
Places
Re-classify the site/building at 357 Onehunga Mall, Onehunga as a "non-contributing
building".
6953-1 David Glen david@glengaul.co.nz Historic Heritage (Overlay)
Heritage
Places Remove 12A Matiere Road, Onehunga from the [2627] schedule
6954-1 Joseph G Naden joenaden@ihug.co.nz Mana Whenua
Whenua
of value to Mana Whenua Remove overlay from 1137 and 1139 Dominion Road [ID2116], Mount Roskill
6955-1 Rowan Lane lanesco@xtra.co.nz Special Character
General
6955-2 Rowan Lane lanesco@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central Retain the Single Housing zone applying to Balmoral streets
6955-3 Rowan Lane lanesco@xtra.co.nz Residential zones Residential
6955-4 Rowan Lane lanesco@xtra.co.nz
control
6956-1
The Horne Group and The
TAWA Group ghorne@xtra.co.nz
Centre)
obs & pols Delete the Mixed use zone
6956-2
TAWA Group ghorne@xtra.co.nz RPS Mana Whenua B5 Strategic Delete the Treaty of Waitangi and Iwi provisions
6956-3
TAWA Group ghorne@xtra.co.nz General Chapter A Introduction
Plan Amend the PAUP to provide more flexibility
6957-1 Simon Badger simon.badger@glaister.co.nz Historic Heritage (Overlay)
Heritage
Places Delete the overlay from 372 Onehunga Mall, Onehunga.
6958-1 Sami Family Trust roshnisami@gmail.com
control
Building demolition control J.3.6 Rules and mapping Delete overlay from 306a Onehunga Mall, Onehunga.
510/1145
Sub#/
6958-2 Sami Family Trust roshnisami@gmail.com Historic Heritage (Overlay)
Heritage
Places Delete overlay from the driveway of 306a Onehunga Mall, Onehunga.
6959-1 Melanie Dixon melanie.r.dixon@gmail.com RPS Urban growth
land for urban development Keep over 70% of growth within the city limits by staging the Future Urban zone.
6959-2 Melanie Dixon melanie.r.dixon@gmail.com Sustainable Development C7.7/H6.4 Sustainable design Apply the Homestar rating to all new houses and Greenstar for all new commercial buildings.
6959-3 Melanie Dixon melanie.r.dixon@gmail.com General Chapter G General provisions
statements Require all developments to be subject to design review using strong assessment criteria.
6959-4 Melanie Dixon melanie.r.dixon@gmail.com Residential zones Residential
General Remove rules which make development uneconomic to ensure greater housing choice.
6959-5 Melanie Dixon melanie.r.dixon@gmail.com Residential zones Residential Land use controls Allow existing houses to be split into 2 flats.
6959-6 Melanie Dixon melanie.r.dixon@gmail.com Residential zones
zone desc, obs & pols Expand the area of the Mixed Housing Urban zone, especially near the City Centre.
6959-7 Melanie Dixon melanie.r.dixon@gmail.com RPS Urban growth
Encourage higher density living (upzoning) and commerce around transport nodes and routes
and the City Rail Link, such as Newton, Morningside, Greenlane and Ellerslie.
6959-8 Melanie Dixon melanie.r.dixon@gmail.com Transport Auckland -wide
requirements Delete minimum paring requirements from all areas, especially residential areas.
6960-1 Peter C Burridge pcbleaw@xtra.co.nz RPS Mana Whenua B5 Strategic
Delete special rights for Mori in relation to private properties and public places across
Auckland.
6961-1 Gary C and Helen J Gotlieb gary@gotlieb.co.nz General Miscellaneous Other Adopt the relief sought by Herne Bay Residents Association Incorporated submission.
6962-1 Squire L Speedy squire@speedy.co.nz RPS Mana Whenua B5 Strategic Delete provisions which give Iwi rights over private property.
6962-2 Squire L Speedy squire@speedy.co.nz RPS Mana Whenua
Fig. 1 Protect only sites that are proven by reasonable means to be 'significant'.
6962-3 Squire L Speedy squire@speedy.co.nz RPS Mana Whenua
Fig. 1
Confine Mori heritage sites to public land only such as reserves, streets and other open
spaces.
6962-4 Squire L Speedy squire@speedy.co.nz General Miscellaneous
Operational/
Projects/Acquisition Erect plaques on significant historical, cultural and heritage public sites.
6963-1
Metalman New Zealand
Limited lucy.delatour@wynnwilliams.co.nz Zoning South Rezone 1-3 Rangi Road,Takanini from Light Industry to Heavy Industry.
6963-2
Limited lucy.delatour@wynnwilliams.co.nz
(ITA)
Include in Table 4 all existing resource consent held by Metalman for high risk ITAs, including
but not limited to resource consent LU 10727 and 40480.
6963-3
Limited lucy.delatour@wynnwilliams.co.nz
(ITA)
(ITA) H4.8.4 Table of ITAs Include Table 4 in the PAUP.
6964-1 Arama G and Heidi C Puriri ahpuriri@gmail.com Mana Whenua General provisions
assessment Delete the Cultural Impact Assessment rules.
6964-2 Arama G and Heidi C Puriri ahpuriri@gmail.com Mana Whenua
Whenua
and policies Require Iwi groups to accurately identify the areas of interest to them.
6964-3 Arama G and Heidi C Puriri ahpuriri@gmail.com Mana Whenua
Whenua
and policies Delete the Sites and Places of Value to Mana Whenua or identify each area accurately.
6964-4 Arama G and Heidi C Puriri ahpuriri@gmail.com Subdivision Auckland-wide - Rural zones
zones only
Amend Activity Table 5 so that 'Any other subdivision not provided for in this table or in the
rural zones subdivision rules' should be a non-complying activity rather than a prohibited
activity.
area
Amend rules in rural areas north of Auckland to provide discretionary activity for subdividing
sites for the protection of native bush and significant wetlands, significant enhancement
planting or land rehabilitation, as provided for in the Rodney District Plan.
area
Remove the following: prohibited activity status applying to rural boundary relocations and
adjustments; the 10% threshold; the distinction between boundary adjustments and
relocations; the requirement that sites comprised of Certificates of Title that existed on the
date of notification; the requirement to assess and protect natural features when undertaking
a boundary relocation subdivision. Amend Table 9 to remove prohibited activity status for
boundary adjustments that exceed 10% of the site area.
6964-7 Arama G and Heidi C Puriri ahpuriri@gmail.com Subdivision Auckland-wide - general
and policies Delete all the objectives, policies and rules of the Plan relating to rural subdivision.
511/1145
Sub#/
6964-8 Arama G and Heidi C Puriri ahpuriri@gmail.com Zoning North and Islands
Rezone rural areas north of Auckland to reflect their productivity limitations as compared to
'elite and prime' land south Auckland.
area
Amend the plan to allow for new lots through subdivision in rural areas if the land is not Land
Use Class 1-3. Allow for bush protection, wetland protection, land rehabilitation and
enhancement planting as provided for in operative Rodney District Plan and allow lot creation
on sites containing the protect feature.
area
Amend rural subdivision rules so that transferable site subdivision only applies to land with a
Land Use Class of 1-3 and amend the rules to provide a real opportunity to subdivide.
area
Remove 'only once' and property ownership restrictions on boundary adjustment and
relocation subdivisions.
area Remove prohibited activity status applying to rural subdivision.
6964-13 Arama G and Heidi C Puriri ahpuriri@gmail.com Rural Zones General I13.2 Land use controls Endorse the provisions for dwellings in rural zones.
6964-14 Arama G and Heidi C Puriri ahpuriri@gmail.com Rural Zones General I13.2 Land use controls
Amend the plan to include Minor Household Units in all zones as provided for in the Operative
Rodney District Plan as a restricted discretionary activity.
area
Amend the Rural zones to allow for a second dwelling on a rural site less than 40 ha as a
restricted discretionary activity. Assessment criteria could be similar to that for Minor
Household Units in the Operative Rodney District Plan.
6965-1 Sue Gray bandsgray@gmail.com RPS Mana Whenua B5 Strategic
Remove any special rights, equal partnerships, powers, co-governance or authority given to
any section of the community that has not been democratically elected.
6966-1 The J E Gilbert Trust neil@rms.co.nz Zoning Central Retain the Mixed Use zone at 75-755 Parnell Rise, Parnell and surrounding land.
6966-2 The J E Gilbert Trust neil@rms.co.nz
Centre)
Fringe Office Retain overlay at 75-77 Parnell Road, Parnell.
Centre) Business
Park zones
Amend height limit for the Mixed Use zone at 75-77 Parnell Road, Parnell from 16.5m to
24.5m.
6966-4 The J E Gilbert Trust neil@rms.co.nz Transport
transport noise J1.5 Rules and mapping Delete overlay at 75-77 Parnell Road, Parnell.
6966-5 The J E Gilbert Trust neil@rms.co.nz Air Quality
transport separation Delete overlay at 75-77 Parnell Road, Parnell.
control
Building demolition control J.3.6 Rules and mapping Delete overlay at 75-77 Parnell Road, Parnell.
6967-1
Cambel Trust Limited
Partnership sallyh@barker.co.nz City Centre Zone
obs & pols Retain the objectives and policies.
6967-2
Partnership sallyh@barker.co.nz City Centre Zone I4 Rules/Appendix 7.1- 7.3
Retain the activity table, but amend the activity status of building demolition from restricted
discretionary to controlled.
6967-3
Retain the 30m building height for at 201 Victoria Street West, Auckland Central, map
attached, but amend the basic and maximum floor ratio (FAR) by increasing the basic FAR
4:1 and MTFAR to 6:1 at the site on Map 9 attached and amend the FAR bonuses.
6967-4
Partnership sallyh@barker.co.nz Transport Auckland -wide
Notification
Delete the notification rule, clause 2.1(a) for exceeding the maximum parking in Table 2 for
the CIty Centre zone.
6967-5
Partnership sallyh@barker.co.nz Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
Delete and replace Table 2 in Rule 3.2 with the parking ratios which apply to the Central Area
in the Operative District Plan.
6967-6
Partnership sallyh@barker.co.nz Sustainable Development C7.7/H6.4 Sustainable design Delete the sustainable development controls, including the relevant objectives and policies.
6967-7
Partnership sallyh@barker.co.nz Definitions Existing Replace definition term 'dwelling' to 'residential unit'.
6967-8
Delete the design statement requirements for development in the City Centre zone and the
design statement information requirements.
6968-1 Anne-Louise James
20 Hafton Road, RD4, Warkworth,
assessment Delete the Cultural Impact Assessment rules
Whenua
and policies Require Iwi groups to accurately identify the areas of interest to them
Whenua
and policies Delete the Sites and Places of Value to Mana Whenua or identify each area accurately
zones only
Amend Activity Table 5 so that 'Any other subdivision not provided for in this table or in the
rural zones subdivision rules' should be a non-complying activity rather than a prohibited
activity.
512/1145
Sub#/
area
Amend Rural Zone subdivision rules in rural areas north of Auckland to include provisions for
subdividing sites for the protection of native bush and significant wetlands, significant
enhancement planting or land rehabilitation, as provided for in the Operative Rodney District
Plan as a discretionary activity. Amend Table 9 to remove prohibited activity status for
boundary adjustments that exceed 10% of the site area
area
Remove the following: prohibited activity status applying to rural boundary relocations and
adjustments; the 10% threshold; the distinction between boundary adjustments and
relocations; the requirement that sites comprised of Certificates of Title that existed on the
date of notification; the requirement to assess and protect natural features when undertaking
a boundary relocation subdivision
area Reject all the objectives, policies and rules of the Plan relating to rural subdivision
Auckland 0984 RPS Rural
potential
Rezone rural areas north of Auckland to reflect their productivity limitations as compared to
'elite and prime' land in south Auckland
area
Amend the plan to allow for new lots through subdivision in rural areas if the land is not LUC
Class 1-3. Allow for bush protection, wetland protection, land rehabilitation and enhancement
planting as provided for in operative Rodney District Plan and allow lot creation on sites
containing the protect feature
area
Amend rural subdivision rules so that transferable site subdivision only applies to land with a
LUC Class of 1-3 and amend the rules to provide a real opportunity to subdivide
area
Remove 'only once' and property ownership restrictions on boundary adjustment and
relocation subdivisions
area Remove prohibited activity status applying to rural subdivision
Auckland 0984 Rural Zones General I13.2 Land use controls Endorse the provisions for dwellings in rural zones
Auckland 0984 Rural Zones General I13.2 Land use controls
Amend the plan to include Minor Household Units in all zones as provided for in the Operative
Rodney District Plan as a restricted discretionary activity
area
Amend the Rural zones to allow for a second dwelling on a rural site less than 40 ha as a
restricted discretionary activity. Assessment criteria could be similar to that for Minor
Household Units in the Operative Rodney District Plan
6969-1 Rental Space Limited neil@rms.co.nz Zoning Central Reject the Single House zone, and related provisions, at 5 and 9 The Rise, St Heliers.
6969-2 Rental Space Limited neil@rms.co.nz Special Character
& C
Isthmus Delete Residential Isthmus B Special character overlay from 5 and 9 The Rise, St Heliers.
6969-3 Rental Space Limited neil@rms.co.nz
(ONF) Rules
Features Overlay Delete overlay (St Heliers explosion crater) from 5 and 9 The Rise, St Heliers.
6969-4 Rental Space Limited neil@rms.co.nz
Amend the activity status of Development involving buildings and structures to non-notified
Restricted Discretionary. [J6.1.1 Activity Table]
6969-5 Rental Space Limited neil@rms.co.nz Zoning Central
Rezone 5 and 9 The Rise, St Heliers, from Single House to a zone that reflects the existing
characteristics and recognises the potential for further development, such as Mixed Housing
Suburban, and provides for a density of at least 5 residential units on the land with a building
height of 8 to 10m.
6970-1 Peter Hillary peter@peterhillary.com Subdivision Auckland-wide - Rural zones
area Amend plan to allow subdivision at 236 Anawhata Road.
6971-1 Pauline Denton thedreadedpauline@hotmail.com Zoning North and Islands
Rezone 4047m2 at Te Moau Ave, Parakai (Sec 49 SO 47119) owned by Helensville District
Health Trust, from Single House to Public Open Space Community.
6971-2 Pauline Denton thedreadedpauline@hotmail.com
Centre) Business
and Heavy Industry zones Recognise artistic endeavour as an industry in Helensville
6971-3 Pauline Denton thedreadedpauline@hotmail.com General Miscellaneous
Operational/
Projects/Acquisition Provide or support a permanent space in Helensville for the performance and visual arts
6972-1
The Fertiliser Association of
New Zealand tracy@fertiliser.org.nz General Miscellaneous Other Adopt the relief sought in the submissions by Ballance Agri-Nutrients Ltd and Ravensdown.
6972-2
New Zealand tracy@fertiliser.org.nz
Rural Discharges,
Biosolids
Recognise and enable the ongoing use of member companies existing and lawfully
established uses, and ensure that these are protected from reverse sensitivity effects [no
specific decision stated].
513/1145
Sub#/
6972-3
Assessment
Recognise the Hazardous Substances and New Organisms Act 1996 and the Fertilisers
Group Standards which together impose conditions for managing the risks associated with the
manufacture, importation and disposal of fertilisers [no specific decision stated].
6972-4
Rural Discharges,
Biosolids
Discharges
Seeks integration with a nationally consistent 'standards and guidelines' approach in relation
to managing contaminants [no specific decision stated].
6972-5
Rural Discharges,
Biosolids
Discharges
Fertiliser storage and use should be permitted where member companies currently operate,
including the rural zones and light industry zone [no specific decision stated].
6973-1
The Prospecting Trust and The
Mon Cherie Trust neil@rms.co.nz Zoning Central
Rezone 4 and 4a Coronation Road, Epsom from Single House to a zone that reflects the
existing characteristics and recognises the potential for further development on the eastern
portion of the land, such as Mixed Housing Suburban, and provides for a density of at least 3
residential units on a gross site area of 1200m
2
.
6973-2
The Prospecting Trust and The
Mon Cherie Trust neil@rms.co.nz Special Character
& C
Isthmus Delete the Residential Isthmus B overlay from 4 and 4a Coronation Road, Epsom.
6974-1 John Mee tolleyandmee@xtra.co.nz RPS Urban growth
quality compact urban form Intensification will affect my quality of life. [No specific decision stated]
6974-2 John Mee tolleyandmee@xtra.co.nz Special Character
residential
Highbury is a heritage area, intensification will not be in keeping with surrounding areas and
character. [No specific decision stated]
6975-1 Karaka Mate Limited neil@rms.co.nz Zoning Central Retain the Mixed Use zone at 33 Karaka St, Newton, and the surrounding land.
6975-2 Karaka Mate Limited neil@rms.co.nz
Centre)
Fringe Office Retain overlay at 33 Karaka St, Newton.
6975-3 Karaka Mate Limited neil@rms.co.nz Built Environment (Overlays)
Height Control Retain overlay which permits heights to 32.5m/8 storeys at 32 Karaka St, Newton.
6976-1 Dhirendra Singh dhirendra_singh@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central
Rezone all properties on both sides of Ennismore Rd, Mt Albert from Mixed Housing
Suburban to Single House.
6977-1 Marilyn F Aucutt
66 Koraha Road, Kumeu, Auckland
0892 RPS Changes to the RUB West
Rezone land along Burns Lane, Koraha Road and Oraha Roads, Kumeu, and currently zoned
Future Urban, to Large Lot development with no smaller than 1 acre lots
6978-1
Scarbro Construction Holdings
Limited and BC Scarborough
Family Trust markb@mhg.co.nz General Miscellaneous Other
Adopt the relief sought in the submission by Belmont Estates Limited and Infineon Properties
Limited who have also requested a Mixed Use zone on land bounded by Marua Road,
Ballarat Street and Stanhope Road, Mt Wellington. [No specific decision stated]
6978-2
Scarbro Construction Holdings
Limited and BC Scarborough
Family Trust markb@mhg.co.nz Zoning Central
Rezone the land identified as the Light Industrial on the southern side of Marua Road, Mt
Wellington between Ballarat Street and Stanhope Road to Mixed Use.
6979-1 Robyn Langwell jock13@vodafone.co.nz RPS Coastal B7 Strategic Provide for no further intrusion into the harbour by Ports of Auckland.
6979-2 Robyn Langwell jock13@vodafone.co.nz General Miscellaneous
Operational/
Projects/Acquisition Reject the expensive inner city rail extension.
6979-3 Robyn Langwell jock13@vodafone.co.nz Special Character
North Shore Retain Devonport as a Special Character Area.
6979-4 Robyn Langwell jock13@vodafone.co.nz RPS
character and natural heritage B4.2 Special character Amend wording to Special Character Heritage Area.
character and natural heritage B4.3 Natural heritage Retain protection of Devonport's coastal environment, landscape and trees.
6979-6 Robyn Langwell jock13@vodafone.co.nz Residential zones
obs & pols Retain the Single House zone description for Devonport.
6979-7 Robyn Langwell jock13@vodafone.co.nz Historic Heritage (Overlay)
Heritage
Places Amend to include Devonport's business centre in Victoria Rd as an Historic Heritage Area.
6979-8 Robyn Langwell jock13@vodafone.co.nz Zoning North and Islands Rezone Devonport from a Town Centre to a zone which recognises its' historic value.
6979-9 Robyn Langwell jock13@vodafone.co.nz Zoning North and Islands Rezone the eastern side of Wynyard St from Town Centre to Light Industry.
Heritage
Places Incorporate Plan Changes 33 and 38, regarding built heritage [Northshore District Plan].
6979-11 Robyn Langwell jock13@vodafone.co.nz
shafts survey coordinates Retain the Volcanic View Shaft and the Height Sensitive Overlay in the Devonport area.
control
and policies Retain the overlay.
character and natural heritage B4.2 Special character Identify post 1944 character areas and include in the Plan.
6979-14 Robyn Langwell jock13@vodafone.co.nz General Chapter G General provisions G2.4 Notification Make all restricted discretionary and non-complying activities to be subject to notification.
control
Building demolition control J.3.6 Rules and mapping Amend the rules to require notification for the demolition of all pre-1940 houses.
514/1145
Sub#/
6979-16 Robyn Langwell jock13@vodafone.co.nz Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula K5.11 Precinct rules Reject 4-storey development at Fort Takapuna and Wakakura Crescent, Devonport.
Heritage
objectives and policies Reclassify all North Shore Category A* building to an unspecified category.
6979-18 Robyn Langwell jock13@vodafone.co.nz General Miscellaneous
Operational/
Projects/Acquisition Ensure sufficient resources are available for civil defence emergency management.
6980-1
Auckland Kindergarten
Association catherine.richards@beca.com RPS Issues
growth Retain A.1.1 as notified [correct reference is B1.1].
6980-2
Association catherine.richards@beca.com RPS Urban growth
Amend paragraph 5 as follows: These public open spaces are complemented by a range of
recreation facilities and social infrastructure which are used for sports, recreation and leisure
and community activities, including: ... kindergartens ...
6980-3
Retain the policies as notified with the exception of the following amendment to Policy
1: Enable a wide range of public open spaces and recreation facilities to deliver a variety of
activities, experiences and functions for Aucklands residents and visitors to enjoy and
contribute to their social wellbeing.
6980-4
Association catherine.richards@beca.com RPS Urban growth B2.7 Social infrastructure
Amend the first paragraph of the Introduction as follows: Social infrastructure relates to ...
There are a range of social infrastructure providers: ... private providers early childhood
learning services; private schools, places of worship and hospitals.
6980-5
Association catherine.richards@beca.com RPS Urban growth B2.7 Social infrastructure Retain Objectives.
6980-6
Association catherine.richards@beca.com RPS Urban growth B2.7 Social infrastructure Retain Policies.
6980-7
Association catherine.richards@beca.com General Noise and vibration
and policies Retain provisions.
6980-8
Association catherine.richards@beca.com Residential zones Residential
policies
Amend the Introduction by adding the following text: There are many non-residential activities
such as schools, shops, care centres, medical facilities, community and recreational services
and home based employment with functions that support residential activity. Good access to
these activities, together with some diversity in residential areas can enhance the overall
amenity of residential neighbourhoods. Their location within or near residential
neighbourhoods can also reduce reliance on the use of private vehicles. This has positive
effects for energy use and air quality. These activities can be located in residential areas in a
way which maintains and enhances the amenities of the area.
6980-9
policies Retain Objectives and Policies (except Policy 6).
6980-10
policies
Amend Policy 6 as follows: Enable those non-residential activities that provide benefits to
local communities and which will have minimal the adverse effects on amenities of the
residential area can be avoided or mitigated.
6980-11
Association catherine.richards@beca.com Public Open Space Zones
desc, obs & pols
Amend to recognise that there are existing local small-scale social infrastructure activities in
the informal recreation zone and that this activity is appropriate and contributes to the
community's social and cultural wellbeing.
6980-12
desc, obs & pols
Amend to recognise that there are existing activities and social infrastructure e.g. care centres
located on sites in the informal recreation zone and that this activity is appropriate and
contributes to the community's social and cultural wellbeing.
6980-13
obs & pols Retain provisions.
6980-14
Association catherine.richards@beca.com
policies Retain Policies (with the exception of Policy 1).
6980-15
policies
Amend Policy 1 as follows: Enable a range of activities including education, recreation, early
childhood learning services, worship and residential accommodation, and appropriate
accessory activities.
6980-16
Association catherine.richards@beca.com Transport
transport noise
and policies
Amend Objective 2 as follows: New and altered activities sensitive to noise, such as places
where sleep or classrooms where teaching normally occurs, are protected from: ...
6980-17
transport noise
and policies
Amend Policy 1 as follows: Require new noise-sensitive land uses, and alterations to existing
noise-sensitive land uses to be designed and constructed so that occupants are not exposed
to levels of transport noise above World Health Organisation guidelines, particularly in
bedrooms and other noise-sensitive rooms.
6980-18
Association catherine.richards@beca.com Air Quality
transport separation Delete overlay.
6980-19
Amend Objective 1 as follows: Childcare facilities seeking to located near transport corridors
are managed to reduce the adverse effects of vehicle emissions on children.
6980-20
Amend Policy 2 as follows: Require new locations for childcare facilities within the overlay to
be assessed whether the building and site layout can bedesigned, constructed and operated
to avoid, remedy or mitigate adverse health effects from vehicle emissions on children
attending the facility.
515/1145
Sub#/
6980-21
transport separation Delete Policy 3.
6980-22
Association catherine.richards@beca.com General Chapter G General provisions G2.4 Notification Retain rules.
6980-23
Association catherine.richards@beca.com Transport Auckland -wide
requirements Retain Rule 3.2 'Number of parking and loading spaces'.
6980-24
Association catherine.richards@beca.com General Noise and vibration H6.2 Rules
Retain Rule 1.1(3) 'Noise arising from activities within zones - Residential zones - care
centres and educational facilities'.
6980-25
Retain Rule 1.1(4) 'Noise arising from activities within zones - Residential zones - care
centres and educational facilities'.
6980-26
Amend Rule 1.2 [Noise arising from activities between zones] to add the following new clause
(4): These levels do not apply to the noise from normal recreation activities occurring at a care
centre or educational facility between 8am - 6pm on Monday to Friday and 9am - 1pm on
Saturday.
6980-27
Amend Rule 1.3 [Recreation noise] to make it clear that these rules do not apply to care
centres or alternatively provide the following exemption: These levels do not apply to the
noise from normal recreational activities occurring at a care centre or educational facility site
in a residential zone between 8am-6pm on Monday to Friday and 9am-1pm on Saturday.
6980-28
Association catherine.richards@beca.com General Noise and vibration H6.2 Rules Retain Rules 2.1 [Matters of discretion] and 2.2 [Assessment criteria].
6980-29
Association catherine.richards@beca.com Residential zones Residential Activity Table Retain the Activity Table as notified (with the exception of care centres).
6980-30
Association catherine.richards@beca.com Residential zones Residential Activity Table
Amend the activity status of cares centres between 200m
2
and 400m
2
GFA per site from Non-
complying to Restricted Discretionary in the Large Lot and Rural and Coastal Settlement
zones.
6980-31
Association catherine.richards@beca.com Residential zones Residential Notification Retain Rule 2 'Notification'.
6980-32
Special info. req. Retain Rules 10.1 Matters of discretion and 10.2 Assessment criteria.
6980-33
Association catherine.richards@beca.com Public Open Space Zones Public Open Space I2.1 Activity table
Add a new activity to the activity table as follows: Early childhood learning services, not
provided for above: Permitted in the Community Zone; Restricted Discretionary in the Informal
Recreation, Civic Spaces, Sport and Active Recreation zones and Discretionary in the
Conservation zone.
6980-34
Centre) Business
& Bus. Park zones Retain the Activity table.
6980-35
Association catherine.richards@beca.com Future Urban I5 Rules Retain the Activity table.
6980-36
Purpose) D8.9/I23 School I23.1 Activity table Retain the Activity table.
6980-37
Amend paragraph 2 of Rule 2.1 Noise as follows: Any new activities sensitive to noise and
any new bedroom, sleeping area, habitable room or classroom within any new or altered
added to an existing activities sensitive to noise within the High Land Transport overlay must
be designed and/or insulated, or screened by suitable barriers on the property so that the
internal noise levels, measured in those rooms do not exceed: ...
6980-38
transport separation Delete the Activity table.
6980-39
Amend the Activity table as follows: Expansions to existing childcare centres - Permitted and
New Care centres with more than three children under the age of six - Restricted
Discretionary.
6980-40
Association catherine.richards@beca.com Definitions Existing Retain the definition of Care centres.
6980-41
Association catherine.richards@beca.com Definitions Existing Retain the definition of Early childhood learning services.
6980-42
Association catherine.richards@beca.com Definitions Existing Retain the definition of Educational facilities.
6980-43
Association catherine.richards@beca.com Definitions Existing Retain the definition of Activities sensitive to air discharges.
6980-44
Association catherine.richards@beca.com Definitions Existing Retain the definition of Activities sensitive to noise.
516/1145
Sub#/
6980-45
2010
Amend (3)(c)(ii) The structure plan content, second bullet point as follows: the provision of a
diversity of site sizes within neighbourhood blocks to maximise housing choice, accommodate
local small-scale social infrastructure and where appropriate a range of business activity, and
mixed use to enable employment and residential activity
6980-46
2010
Amend (3)(d)(iv) The structure plan content as follows: mix and distribution of land uses within
the structure plan area to provide opportunities for appropriate business activities and
employment, community and educational facilities, early childhood learning services, and
open space close to where people live.
6980-47
2010
Amend (3)(f)(iv) The structure plan content as follows: social and cultural infrastructure,
including educational facilities, early childhood learning services, libraries and marae, to cater
for the needs of the community and neighbourhoods and the timing of its availability.
6980-48
Association catherine.richards@beca.com Zoning Central
Rezone 14 Aberfoyle St, Epsom from Public Open Space - Informal Recreation to Public
Open Space - Community.
6980-49
Rezone 6a Dunkirk Tce, Owairaka from Public Open Space - Informal Recreation to Public
6980-50
Rezone 2 Wairua Rd, Remuera from Public Open Space - Informal Recreation to Public Open
Space - Community.
6980-51
Association catherine.richards@beca.com Zoning North and Islands
Rezone 50 Sunnynook Rd, Glenfield from Public Open Space - Informal Recreation to Public
6980-52
Association catherine.richards@beca.com Zoning West
Rezone 66a Divich Ave, Te Atatu South from Public Open Space - Informal Recreation to
Public Open Space - Community.
6980-53
Association catherine.richards@beca.com Zoning West
Rezone 12 Township Rd, Waitakere from Public Open Space - Informal Recreation to Public
6980-54
Association catherine.richards@beca.com Zoning South
Rezone 54R Pigeon Mountain Rd, Half Moon Bay from Public Open Space - Conservation to
Public Open Space - Community.
6981-1
The Tindall Foundation and
Stephen Matthews Architects
Limited stephen@smarchitects.co.nz
Centre) Business
Park zones
Add a 5m front yard control to properties fronting the road from 1 The Strand at the corner of
Lake Road, south to Esmonde Road / Rewiti Ave, both sides, until such time as a new
precinct is established.
6981-2
Limited stephen@smarchitects.co.nz Precincts - North New Precincts All other New Precincts
Add a new 'Southern Gateway to Takapuna' precinct, from 1 The Strand at the corner of Lake
Road, south to Esmonde Road / Rewiti Ave, both sides, which gives the same urban design
environmental attention and care as other precincts in Takapuna.
6981-3
Limited stephen@smarchitects.co.nz Zoning North and Islands
Review the zoning on Lake Road, from 1 the Strand, Takapuna to Esmonde Road with
respect to height. [No specific decision sought].
6981-4
Limited stephen@smarchitects.co.nz Built Environment (Overlays)
Height Control
Reduce the maximum height control to from 16m to 14m for sites adjoining Lake Road,
Takapuna, from 1 The Strand, to Esmonde Road.
6982-1 Chan Ken Meng chankenmeng1@gmail.com Subdivision Auckland-wide - general
and policies
Amend second paragraph in Background to: "Subdivision can
deliver....significant environmental effects. While it is important to consider development to
provide for future communities, the subdivision of land should not result
in environmental damage to the existing character of landforms and the amenity of the
underlying area. It is also necessary to provide for services,...etc."
6982-2 Chan Ken Meng chankenmeng1@gmail.com Subdivision Auckland-wide - general
and policies
Amend policy 3 to " building platforms and to provide for sufficient physical and legal access
vehicle access ."
6983-1
Farrand Road Land Owners
Group flicka@pl.net Designations
Agency
Widening - Kumeu/Huapai Endorse Designation 6768
6983-2
Group flicka@pl.net General Miscellaneous Consultation and engagement Acknowledge that there has been a lack of consultation within the Rodney District
6983-3
Group flicka@pl.net General Miscellaneous
Operational/
Projects/Acquisition Investigate access into and around Kumeu by road
6984-1 Roskill Properties Limited
PO Box 27078, Mount Roskill,
Rezone the land identified as Light Industry bounded by Carr Road, Hayr Road and State
Highway 20 to General Business.
6984-2 Roskill Properties Limited
PO Box 27078, Mount Roskill,
Auckland 1440
Centre) Business
& Bus. Park zones
Amend the activity status of 'retail activity accessory to a permitted activity, and retail up to
450m
2
per site' as permitted [infer General Business zone].
6985-1 Craig J Hughes flicka@pl.net Designations
Agency
Widening - Kumeu/Huapai Endorse Designation 6768
6985-2 Craig J Hughes flicka@pl.net General Miscellaneous Consultation and engagement Acknowledge that there has been a lack of consultation within the Rodney District
6985-3 Craig J Hughes flicka@pl.net General Miscellaneous
Operational/
Projects/Acquisition Investigate access into and around Kumeu by road
6986-1 Land Owners of Paremoremo cathy@condor.co.nz RPS Changes to the RUB North and Waiheke Island
Rezone the area of Paremoremo [from the Avenue west to the township of Paremoremo, see
submission page 10/12 for details] from Countryside Living to Large Lot Residential, to
provide for sites between 2000-4000m
2
, minimal building coverage of 20% and specific
landscape and vegetation controls.
517/1145
Sub#/
6987-1 Reinhard and Jillianne Hueber matt@rms.co.nz
control
Building demolition control J.3.6 Rules and mapping Delete overlay from 13 Audrey Road, Takapuna.
6987-2 Reinhard and Jillianne Hueber matt@rms.co.nz Mana Whenua
Whenua
of value to Mana Whenua Delete overlay from 13 Audrey Road, Takapuna.
6987-3 Reinhard and Jillianne Hueber matt@rms.co.nz Mana Whenua General provisions
assessment Delete 50m yard surrounding sites and places of values to Mana Whenua.
6987-4 Reinhard and Jillianne Hueber matt@rms.co.nz Mana Whenua
Whenua J5.2 Rules
Amend the activity status of 'Earthworks on or within 50m of a site or place of value to Mana
Whenua' to from Restricted Discretionary Permitted with accidental discovery protocols to
apply.
6987-5 Reinhard and Jillianne Hueber matt@rms.co.nz Residential zones Residential Land use controls Amend the minimum site of the Single House zone to 500m
2
.
6987-6 Reinhard and Jillianne Hueber matt@rms.co.nz General Chapter A Introduction
tools Reject the use of broad scale overlays, particularly the pre-1944 demolition control overlay.
6988-1 Wayne Lees wayne@wayneleesarchitect.co.nz Zoning North and Islands Retain the zoning of Devonport as a Town Centre.
6988-2 Wayne Lees wayne@wayneleesarchitect.co.nz Built Environment (Overlays)
Height Control Increase the building height for Devonport town centre from 16.5m.
6988-3 Wayne Lees wayne@wayneleesarchitect.co.nz Zoning North and Islands Retain the Neighbourhood Centre around 35 King Edward Parade, Devonport.
6988-4 Wayne Lees wayne@wayneleesarchitect.co.nz Zoning North and Islands Rezone Devonport from Single House to allow other forms of housing.
6989-1 Sharon C Fergusson
50A Ngataringa Road, Devonport,
Amend the Devonport Peninsula Precinct objectives to take account of the village like
community and special character that currently exists in Devonport - See Submission page
3/4 for detail.
Auckland 0624
SEAs
Land
Protect natives trees, and preserve Polly's Park and other bush area currently residing on the
land proposed for development in Sub-Precinct F - Wakakura Crescent.
Auckland 0624 Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula K5.11 Precinct rules
Retain public access to the foreshore through the development of Sub-Precinct F - Wakakura
Crescent.
Auckland 0624
the CMA
Require mangroves and sea bed area to remain undisturbed, and require public notification
for any resource consent in Sub-Precinct F - Wakakura Crescent.
Heritage
Places
Retain and protect the Duders Clay Works Heritage Site as part of the Sub-Precinct F -
Wakakura Crescent.
Amend the Devonport Peninsula Precinct to take into account increased traffic and increased
risk to the safety of its residents.
Require public notification for any resource consent regarding the proposed development
at Sub-Precinct F - Wakakura Crescent.
Auckland 0624 Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula K5.11 Precinct rules Limit building height to two storeys in the Sub-Precinct F - Wakakura Crescent area.
objectives and policies Require any development to be of a high standard.
Require development of Sub-Precinct F - Wakakura Crescent to include
recreational spaces and green areas.
Auckland 0624 Zoning North and Islands Retain the Single House zone in the Devonport Peninsula
6990-1 John P H McGrath mcgrath.iffley@scorch.co.nz Precincts - North New Precincts Wairau Valley
Seeks integration with the North Shore City Council Strategic Plan for Wairau Valley in
the absence of a current precinct plan.
6991-1 Issa Abdulahad issaabd@acs.com.sa Zoning North and Islands
Rezone 16 The Promenade, Takapuna from Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings to a
zone more appropriate to the character of the area.
6991-2 Issa Abdulahad issaabd@acs.com.sa Zoning North and Islands
Rezone the area around The Promenade, Takapuna from Terrace Housing and Apartment
Buildings to a zone more appropriate to the character of the area.
6992-1 Justin A Anselmi
objectives and policies Decline the objectives
6993-1 Suzanne Weld suzanne.weld@yahoo.co.nz RPS Urban growth
environment
Amend to require all developments in centres identified for growth to have strong
design/urban design concepts and relationship to public amenities.
6993-2 Suzanne Weld suzanne.weld@yahoo.co.nz Special Character
Amend Assessment criteria 4(2)(3)(d) so that it does not lead to excessive fencing or
screening of vehicle areas or restrict subdivision within the heritage character area.
6993-3 Suzanne Weld suzanne.weld@yahoo.co.nz Special Character
character Helensville Remove overlay from 2/54 Garfield Road, Helensville.
6993-4 Suzanne Weld suzanne.weld@yahoo.co.nz Precincts - Central Tmaki K2.22 Precinct Rules
Amend rule 3.1(c) [Framework plans] to require framework plans for sites with a minimum
area of 1000m
2
6993-5 Suzanne Weld suzanne.weld@yahoo.co.nz Precincts - Central Tmaki
Objectives & Policies Amend to clarify how drainage will be achieved without impact on existing waterways.
6993-6 Suzanne Weld suzanne.weld@yahoo.co.nz Precincts - Central Tmaki Mapping Clarify the location of Precinct A
518/1145
Sub#/
6993-7 Suzanne Weld suzanne.weld@yahoo.co.nz Precincts - Central Tmaki K2.22 Precinct Rules
Amend rule 3.1(c) [Framework plans] to require that framework plans are mandatory for sites
greater than 1000m
2
in the Precinct.
6993-8 Suzanne Weld suzanne.weld@yahoo.co.nz RPS Coastal
environment
Recognise that the estuary and harbour environment of the Tamaki Estuary require specific
protection from nearby development and earthworks [refer submission pages 10-11/11 for
details]
6994-1 Briar H O'Connor briar1@ihug.co.nz Residential zones Residential
General
Retain the two storey (8m) height limit applying to Balmoral streets [Single House and Mixed
Housing Suburban zones]
6994-2 Briar H O'Connor briar1@ihug.co.nz Special Character
General
character statement - General
Apply a Special Character Overlay to streets in the northern end of Balmoral (similar to streets
to the north in Mt Eden, and streets to the south in Balmoral)
6994-3 Briar H O'Connor briar1@ihug.co.nz Zoning Central
Rezone streets at the northern end of Balmoral from Mixed Housing Suburban, to Single
House
6994-4 Briar H O'Connor briar1@ihug.co.nz
control
6995-1 Anthony R Bollard
661 Manukau Road, Royal Oak,
Reconsider the Terrace Housing and Apartment Building zone, distribute more equitably
through the Isthmus, particularly from Royal Oak and Onehunga
Rezone properties adjoining the northern boundary of Royal Oak Primary School (ROPS),
between this boundary and Beckenham Avenue, including 669, 659, 659A and 657 Manukau
Road, and properties on the western boundary of ROPS on the Epworth Ave, Ambury Road
corner, and properties with a Haydn Avenue address, Royal Oak from Terrace Housing and
Apartment Building to Mixed Housing Urban
environment Amend the Auckland Design Manual to be a statutory and enforceable document
Auckland 1023
I23.2-3 Land use &
Delete Land Use control 1 - Use of Community Facilities and retain the rules in the Auckland
Isthmus Plan rules 10.8.1.10(a) to (e) inclusive
Auckland 1023
I23.2-3 Land use &
Development controls Delete controls 3.3 - 3.7 and retain existing Auckland Isthmus Plan rules 10.8.1
Auckland 1023
control
and policies
Delete the Pre-1944 Demolition Building Control or undertake immediate and ongoing,
comprehensive, street by street background studies to accurately assess historic heritage and
special character
Decide intensification through effective and comprehensive community consultation and
through staged local area plans
6996-1 Lizbeth Freebairn lizbethfreebairn@ihug.co.nz Residential zones Residential
General
6996-2 Lizbeth Freebairn lizbethfreebairn@ihug.co.nz Special Character
General
6996-3 Lizbeth Freebairn lizbethfreebairn@ihug.co.nz Zoning Central
House
6996-4 Lizbeth Freebairn lizbethfreebairn@ihug.co.nz
control
6997-1 Sally Monks tmonks@ihug.co.nz Air Quality
and policies
Clarify the rules around domestic indoor fires to define what is a nuisance and what are the
rules that govern smoke levels on neighbouring properties
6998-1 Christopher Good zeus.faber@xtra.co.nz Residential zones Residential
General
6998-2 Christopher Good zeus.faber@xtra.co.nz Special Character
General
6998-3 Christopher Good zeus.faber@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central
House
6998-4 Christopher Good zeus.faber@xtra.co.nz
control
6999-1
Regent Trustee Limited as
Trustee for the Regent Trust rose@mhg.co.nz City Centre Zone I4 Rules/Appendix 7.1- 7.3 Amend the activity status of demolition to a permitted or controlled activity.
6999-2
Trustee for the Regent Trust rose@mhg.co.nz General Chapter G General provisions
Delete third paragraph of assessment criteria. [Infer: Deleting 'However the assessment
particular activity' ].
6999-3
Trustee for the Regent Trust rose@mhg.co.nz General Chapter G General provisions
Clarify that the matters for discretion and assessment criteria listed in the PAUP for controlled
and restricted discretionary activities are the sole matters of assessment of these types of
consent. [rule 1.3]
6999-4
Trustee for the Regent Trust rose@mhg.co.nz Mana Whenua General provisions
519/1145
Sub#/
6999-5
Trustee for the Regent Trust rose@mhg.co.nz City Centre Zone I4 Rules/Appendix 7.1- 7.3 Delete requirements for separate design statements.
6999-6
Trustee for the Regent Trust rose@mhg.co.nz RPS Urban growth
environment
Add a clarification to references to the Auckland Design Manual that it is a non-statutory
guidline.
6999-7
Trustee for the Regent Trust rose@mhg.co.nz Sustainable Development C7.7/H6.4 Sustainable design Delete the sustainable development provisions.
6999-8
Trustee for the Regent Trust rose@mhg.co.nz Residential zones Housing affordability
and policies Delete the affordable housing provisions.
6999-9
Trustee for the Regent Trust rose@mhg.co.nz
shafts survey coordinates Delete the E10 Mount Eden Volcanic Viewshafts.
6999-10
Trustee for the Regent Trust rose@mhg.co.nz City Centre Zone I4 Rules/Appendix 7.1- 7.3
Replace the building in relation to boundary control with the Operative District Plan: Central
Area section control.
7000-1 Pravin Naran pravin@enfield.co.nz Precincts - North New Precincts Wairau Valley
Add a Precinct for Wairau Valley which is based on the Strategic Plan [North Shore section]
for Wairau Valley with modifications to transport and access.
7001-1 Emily and Andre Upston eupston@gmail.com Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula
Reject objectives; consider more input from the community, include infrastructure for
additional traffic on Lake Rd, Devonport
7001-2 Emily and Andre Upston eupston@gmail.com Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula K5.11 Precinct rules Amend rules regarding Precinct F to keep buildings to a standard height of two-storeys.
7001-3 Emily and Andre Upston eupston@gmail.com Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula
objectives and policies Protect Pohutukawa trees lining the proposed Devonport Peninsula land development
7002-1 Maike Wolbers maikeron@orcon.net.nz Residential zones Residential
General
7002-2 Maike Wolbers maikeron@orcon.net.nz Special Character
General
7002-3 Maike Wolbers maikeron@orcon.net.nz Zoning Central
House
7002-4 Maike Wolbers maikeron@orcon.net.nz
control
7003-1 Heather Goodey heather.goodey@gmail.com Precincts - North Bayswater
Delete reference to residential activities and development in sub-precinct B of the Bayswater
Marina precinct.
Acknowledge the marine related and open space activities remain the main focus of the
Bayswater Mairina precinct.
Delete residential development unless the effects on the local comunity are known [infer:
further investigation required].
7003-4 Heather Goodey heather.goodey@gmail.com Precincts - North Bayswater K5.6 Precinct rules
Amend rule to notify applications for the following activities; 'Framework plans, Dwellings,
Food and beverage, Licenced premises'.
7004-1 B and T Holdings Limited
PO Box 305272, Triton Plaza,
Rosedale, Auckland 0757 Zoning North and Islands
Rezone 11 Apollo Drive, Albany from Light Industry to a zone which provides for a wider
range of activities.
Rosedale, Auckland 0757 Zoning North and Islands
Rezone 49 Apollo Drive, Albany from Light Industry to a zone which provides for a wider
range of activities.
Rosedale, Auckland 0757 Precincts - North Albany 2 Amend K5.3.1 Activity table to be less restrictive for offices, retail and commercial activities.
Rosedale, Auckland 0757 Zoning North and Islands Rezone 33A William Pickering Drive, Albany from Light Industry to General Business.
Rosedale, Auckland 0757 Precincts - North New Precincts All other New Precincts Add a Precinct to 33A William Pickering Drive, Albany.
7005-1 Robert E Tait
22/16 Spring Street, Freemans Bay,
Rezone 16 Spring Street, Freemans Bay from Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings to
7005-2 Robert E Tait
22/16 Spring Street, Freemans Bay,
Auckland 1011 General Miscellaneous Special housing areas
Rezone 16 Spring Street, Freemans Bay from Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings to a
Special Housing Area.
7006-1 John N Duder john.duder@clear.net.nz Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula K5.11 Precinct rules
Amend precinct development to investigate and require corridors and a master traffic plan to
address traffic issues by extending Francis St southwards past Eversleigh Rd to link with
Bayswater Rd, and connect Francis St to Barrys Point with a short bridge
7006-2 John N Duder john.duder@clear.net.nz Precincts - City Centre Port
Objectives & Policies Prevent further reclamation of the Waitemata Harbour by Ports of Auckland
7006-3 John N Duder john.duder@clear.net.nz Precincts - City Centre Port
Require Ports of Auckland to initially complete Stage 2 of their investigations including full
investigation of optimum use of existing on shore areas and include possibility of extension
south of Quay St onto Railway land with traffic linkage benefits
7006-4 John N Duder john.duder@clear.net.nz Precincts - North Bayswater K5.6 Precinct rules Retain these rules
7007-1
Friends of the Earth (New
Zealand)
PO Box 5599, Wellesley Street,
Auckland 1141
Rural Discharges,
Amend the permitted application of biosolids in residential areas and food production land by
significantly tightening controls [inferred] to limit contaminations.
520/1145
Sub#/
7007-2
Friends of the Earth (New
Zealand)
Auckland 1141
Rural Discharges,
Biosolids C5.8/H4.7 Biosolids Amend to define precisely the 'use of biosolids in residential areas and food production'.
7008-1 Anthony P O'Connor toconnor@xtra.co.nz Zoning North and Islands
Rezone all the Single Housing zone to Mixed House - Suburban on the land east of College
Road and Deuxberry Ave and west of the State Highway, Northcote. Rezone all the Single
House zone to Mixed Housing - Suburban on land east of Howard Road and the Onepoto
Stream. Alternatively rezone all this land to a single residential zone.
7009-1 Rosemary H Lovell-Smith r.lovell-smith@auckland.ac.nz Precincts - City Centre Wynyard
Amend the PAUP to ensure that the northern finger of the Wynyard Precinct (the tank farm) is
not privatised.
7009-2 Rosemary H Lovell-Smith r.lovell-smith@auckland.ac.nz Precincts - City Centre Wynyard
Amend the Wynyard Precinct Plan to provide for a swimming pool complex at the tank farm
location.
7009-3 Rosemary H Lovell-Smith r.lovell-smith@auckland.ac.nz Residential zones
Amend the Mixed Housing Suburban zone to ensure a spacious, garden or green suburb
effect maintaining the amenity of these areas. This is of particular relevance to Point
Chevalier, Grey Lynn, Arch Hill and other inner city housing areas.
7009-4 Rosemary H Lovell-Smith r.lovell-smith@auckland.ac.nz
control
Retain pre-1944 housing protection in the Mixed Housing Urban and Mixed Housing
Suburban zones in Point Chevalier, Grey Lynn, Arch Hill and other inner city housing areas.
7009-5 Rosemary H Lovell-Smith r.lovell-smith@auckland.ac.nz RPS
Retain trees in the Mixed Housing Urban and Mixed Housing Suburban zones in Point
Chevalier, Grey Lynn, Arch Hill and other inner city housing areas.
7009-6 Rosemary H Lovell-Smith r.lovell-smith@auckland.ac.nz General Miscellaneous Other
Retain state housing in the Mixed Housing Urban and Mixed Housing Suburban zones in
Point Chevalier, Grey Lynn, Arch Hill and other inner city housing areas.
zone desc, obs & pols Retain Policy 6(c).
7009-9 Rosemary H Lovell-Smith r.lovell-smith@auckland.ac.nz Sustainable Development C7.7/H6.4 Sustainable design Amend the PAUP to provide for cycle only housing developments.
obs & pols
Amend the Single House zone to ensure a spacious, garden or green suburb effect
maintaining the amenity of these areas. This is of particular relevance to Point Chevalier,
Grey Lynn, Arch Hill and other inner city housing areas.
7010-1 W Hong colin@hardacreplanning.co.nz Trees
Trees
Notable Trees Remove the tree from the Schedule at 60 Empire Road, Epsom.
7011-1 Richard Buisson richard.buisson@dulhuntypower.com RPS Mana Whenua B5 Strategic Remove the iwi from decision making.
7012-1 R and P Drake colin@hardacreplanning.co.nz
SEAs
Land Remove the SEA from 47 Belfast Street, Hillsborough.
7013-1 Paul F Burge burges@orcon.net.nz Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula K5.11 Precinct rules Amend building height for Sub-Precinct F - Wakakura to restrict to two storey dwellings
7013-2 Paul F Burge burges@orcon.net.nz Zoning North and Islands Rezone Sub-Precinct F - Wakakura, Devonport, from Mixed Housing to Single House
7013-3 Paul F Burge burges@orcon.net.nz Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula
Acknowledge that development needs to harmonise with the character of the area, compatible
with infrastructure, respect the history of Duder's Brickworks, preserve Volcanic view shafts
and protect mature trees
7014-1 Churchill LDS karl@clds.co.nz RPS Urban growth
Rezone the residential zones without considering flood hazards across existing urban areas
throughout Auckland.
7014-2 Churchill LDS karl@clds.co.nz Water Stormwater
H4.14.2 Stormwater
management -flow rules Add wording to include a reference to 'ground soakage' in the activity table.
7014-3 Churchill LDS karl@clds.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - Urban zones H5.2 3.1 Residential zones
Amend the access controls to allow an unlimited number of rear lots to gain access off a
jointly owned lot or right of way.
7014-4 Churchill LDS karl@clds.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - Rural zones
area
Amend the Countryside Living zone labelled as Mangere-Puhinui-Whitford be split into
'Mangere-Puhinui' and 'Whitford'. The Whitford area should have a minimum lot size of 1ha
and average lot size of 2ha.
7014-5 Churchill LDS karl@clds.co.nz Precincts - South New Precincts All other New Precincts
Add a new precinct for the Mangemangeroa Valley in the 'Countryside area' which
incorporates the rules and assessment criteria in the Rural 4 zone of the Operative [Manukau]
District Plan.
7014-6 Churchill LDS karl@clds.co.nz Residential zones Residential Land use controls
Amend the the dwelling conversion Rule 3.3 by removing 'The primary dwelling must exist on
the date of notification of this Unitary Plan. '.
7014-7 Churchill LDS karl@clds.co.nz Precincts - North Hobsonville Corridor
Add Offices and Industrial Activities as a permitted activity to table 1 activity table of sub-
precinct A.
7014-8 Churchill LDS karl@clds.co.nz Precincts - North Hobsonville Corridor Correctly label the sub-precincts.
7014-9 Churchill LDS karl@clds.co.nz Definitions Existing
Amend the definition of 'overland flowpath' as follows: 'Low point in terrain, excluding
a permanent watercourse, where surface runoff will flow, with an
upstream contributing catchment exceeding 4,000m
2
and a flow of up to 200 liters per
second.'
521/1145
Sub#/
7015-1 Stephen M de Ment Trust monica@ditto.net.nz
SEAs
Land Remove the SEA at 258 Mahurangi West Road, Mahurangi West.
7016-1
Takapuna Grammar School
Rowing Club Incorporated chris@humearch.co.nz Precincts - North Bayswater
objectives and policies Retain sub-precinct D.
7016-2
Rowing Club Incorporated chris@humearch.co.nz Zoning North and Islands
Rezone Bayswater Marina zoned land at 2, 23-27 Sir Peter Blake Parade, Bayswater from
Public Open Space - Informal Recreation to Public Open Space - Sports and Active
Recreation.
7016-3
Rowing Club Incorporated chris@humearch.co.nz
the CMA Marina zone
objectives and policies Delete policy 12.
7016-4
7016-5
7016-6
objectives and policies Provide for other marine related activities in sub-precinct E.
7016-7
Amend the sub-precinct E area to allow for land required for a ferry terminal development
only.
7016-8
Rowing Club Incorporated chris@humearch.co.nz Precincts - North Bayswater Mapping Amend sub-precinct E to allow for a ferry terminal development and marine related activities.
7016-9
Rowing Club Incorporated chris@humearch.co.nz Precincts - North Bayswater K5.6 Precinct rules
Amend the activity status in activity table 1.2 for 'Dwellings complying with an approved
framework plan' in sub-precinct B from discretionary activity to non-complying activity and
retain non-complying activity status for all other sub-precincts.
7016-10
Amend the activity status in activity table 1.2 for 'Clubrooms associated with marine activities'
in sub-precinct E to permitted activity.
7016-11
Amend the activity status in activity table 1.2 for 'Organised sport and recreation' in all sub-
precincts to permitted activity.
7016-12
Amend the activity status in activity table 1.3 for 'Boat launching facilities' in sub-precincts B,
E and F to permitted activity.
7016-13
Amend the activity status in activity table 1.3 for 'New buildings for food and beverage and/or
licensed premises' in sub precinct E from non-complying activity to discretionary activity.
7016-14
Rowing Club Incorporated chris@humearch.co.nz Precincts - North Bayswater K5.6 Precinct rules Delete 'Park and Ride facilities' from activity table 1.3.
7016-15
Delete clause 1 (4)(1)(b) where a resource consent application for a framework plan, an
amendment or replacement of a framework plan, must only apply to land that the applicant is
the owner of.
7016-16
Rowing Club Incorporated chris@humearch.co.nz Precincts - North Bayswater K5.6 Precinct rules Delete development control 4 (1)(1) Building height.
7016-17
Amend development control 4 (1)(1) Building height to read 'Buildings must not exceed 12m
in height above ground level. in sub-precinct B'
7016-18
Rowing Club Incorporated chris@humearch.co.nz Precincts - North Bayswater K5.6 Precinct rules Delete development control 4 (1)(2) Building height.
7016-19
Rowing Club Incorporated chris@humearch.co.nz Precincts - North Bayswater K5.6 Precinct rules Delete development control 4 (3) Maximum site impervious area.
7016-20
Delete 5 (1)(3) Matters of control 'Park and facilities'. The submission notes that this probably
intended to be 'Park and Ride facilities'
7016-21
Amend 5 (2)(5)(e)(iii) - Assessment criteria to read '...should not conflict with the main marina
and other marine and recreation related uses and should be integrated with public transport.'
7016-22
Rowing Club Incorporated chris@humearch.co.nz Precincts - North Bayswater K5.6 Precinct rules Delete 5 (2)(6) - Assessment criteria for Park and Ride facilities.
7016-23
Delete the reference to 'residential' activities in clause 6 (1)(g) - Special information
requirements.
7016-24
Delete 6 (1)(i) - Special information requirements details of how the development will be
consistent with assessment criteria applying to four or more dwellings in the Mixed Housing
Urban zone.
7016-25
Rowing Club Incorporated chris@humearch.co.nz Designations Auckland Transport
R1430 Car Park - Sir Peter
Blake Parade
Delete designation [R1430] Park and Ride. The submission notes it is confused with R1424
as detailed in the designation schedule to the PAUP.
522/1145
Sub#/
7017-1 Leone Morrow
29 Vera Road, Te Atatu South,
Auckland 0610
organisms
modified organisms
Retain the provisions relating to the management of genetically modified organisms with an
amendment to the wording: Delete statement 'Veterinary vaccines are exempt for the need to
obtain resource consent or comply with the performance standards applicable to discretionary
activities. This is because the tend not to persist in the environment, appear to be low risk and
are difficult to monitor, making control by the District / Unitary Plan less appropriate.'
Delete 'Veterinary vaccines: Permitted Activity' from the activity table. Amend 'Medical or
veterinary' in the activity table.
7018-1 Margaret and Wayne Lees wlees@ihug.co.nz Zoning North and Islands
Rezone the portion of the site at 35-39 King Edward Parade, Devonport from Single House to
Neighbourhood Centre zone so the Neighbourhood Centre zone follows the title boundary as
per the diagram in the submission [page 6/12].
7019-1
Addams Trust Company
Limited colin@hardacreplanning.co.nz
SEAs
Land
Remove SEA from 19 Church Street, Swanson and Crows Road, Swanson [refer to
submission, pages 4-7 for details]
7019-2
Limited colin@hardacreplanning.co.nz RPS Changes to the RUB West
Rezone 19 Church Street, Swanson from Rural Conservation to Mixed Housing Urban. [See
submission pages 4-6/6 for details].
7019-3
Limited colin@hardacreplanning.co.nz RPS Changes to the RUB West
Amend the RUB boundary to include the property at 19 Church Street, Swanson. [Refer to
submission pages 4-6/6].
7020-1 Andrew Shelley amrag@ihug.co.nz Zoning North and Islands Rezone Devonport Peninsula from Mixed Housing Urban or Mixed Housing Suburban
7021-1
Abbey Trustee Limited as
trustee for the Abbey Trust rose@mhg.co.nz City Centre Zone I4 Rules/Appendix 7.1- 7.3 Re-classify demolition in the City Centre zone to a permitted or controlled Activity.
7021-2
trustee for the Abbey Trust rose@mhg.co.nz General Chapter G General provisions
Delete third paragraph, of section 1.4, under the heading "Assessment Criteria" and/or clarify
within G.1.4 that the matters for discretion and assessment criteria for controlled and
restricted discretionary activities are the sole matters for assessment for these types of
consent.
7021-3
trustee for the Abbey Trust rose@mhg.co.nz Mana Whenua General provisions
assessment Delete the requirement for cultural impact assessments.
7021-4
trustee for the Abbey Trust rose@mhg.co.nz General Chapter G General provisions
statements Delete requirements for design statements and references to the Auckland Design Manual.
7021-5
trustee for the Abbey Trust rose@mhg.co.nz Sustainable Development C7.7/H6.4 Sustainable design Delete the sustainable development provisions.
7021-6
trustee for the Abbey Trust rose@mhg.co.nz RPS Urban growth
7021-7
trustee for the Abbey Trust rose@mhg.co.nz
shafts survey coordinates Delete the E10 Mount Eden Volcanic viewshafts.
7022-1
Auckland Memorial Park
Limited lancehessell@tnp.co.nz RPS Changes to the RUB North and Waiheke Island
Rezone Lot 2 DP 186071, Allotment 248 SO33679, and Allotment 246 SO35027, being The
Auckland Memorial Park, East Coast Road, Silverdale from Future Urban zone to Special
Purpose Cemetery zone.
7022-2
Limited lancehessell@tnp.co.nz RPS Changes to the RUB North and Waiheke Island
Rezone the property at 15 Newman Road, Silverdale, Lot 7 DP 378065 from Light Industry
zone to Countryside Living zone.
7022-3
Limited lancehessell@tnp.co.nz Precincts - North Silverdale 1 Delete the Silverdale 1 Precinct.
7022-4
Limited lancehessell@tnp.co.nz Precincts - North New Precincts All other New Precincts
Apply a new precinct to the properties legally described as Lot 2 DP 186071, Allotment 248
SO33679, and Allotment 246 SO35027, being The Auckland Memorial Park, East Coast
Road, Silverdale. The purpose of the precinct is to continue the current enabling planning
rule framework provided for in SA 165. Refer to pages 5 - 9 of the submission.
7023-1 Gregory Cook gregory.cook@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central
Rezone 247 and 249 Ponsonby Road, Ponsonby, to be split Town Centre and Single House
similar to other properties between Ponsonby Road and Arthur Street, Ponsonby
7024-1 Warwick G Lee
7 Russell Street, Freemans Bay,
residential
Amend the sites in the Town Centre zone on the east side of Ponsonby Road between
Russell and Pember Reeves Streets to have a Special Character overlay with strong controls
to protect its existing architectural character.
Retain the Public Open Space zone at the intersection of Russell, Wood and Renall Streets,
Ponsonby
7025-1
Goatley Holdings Limited and
Stellan Trust markbellingham@tnp.co.nz RPS Changes to the RUB North and Waiheke Island
Rezone the sites at Warkworth legally described as Lots 1, 2 DP 88298, Pt Allot 95 Psh Of
Mahurangi SO 27C, Lot 3 DP 61693, and Lots 1, 2, 3 DP 155679 as shown on page 3 of the
submission from Future Urban zone to Light Industry zone or other business zones as
appropriate.
7025-2
Goatley Holdings Limited and
Stellan Trust markbellingham@tnp.co.nz General Miscellaneous
Operational/
Identify a proposed North-East Link Road alignment for Warkworth North on or about the
locations indicated on Figures 4 and 5 in the submission on page 5 and 6.
523/1145
Sub#/
7026-1
Silverdale West Landowners
Association Incorporated markbellingham@tnp.co.nz RPS Changes to the RUB North and Waiheke Island
Rezone a large number of sites located to the west of the northern motorway, bounded by
Dairy Flat Highway, Willks Road and the northern motorway in Silverdale from Future Urban
zone to Heavy and Light Industrial and Mixed Business as shown in Figure 2 on page 24 of
the submission.
7026-2
Silverdale West Landowners
Association Incorporated markbellingham@tnp.co.nz Precincts - North New Precincts All other New Precincts
Apply a precinct to a large number of sites located to the west of the northern motorway,
bounded by Wilks Road, Dairyflat Highway and the northern motorway in Silverdale as shown
in Figure 2 on page 5 of the submission. The purposed of the precinct is to enable industrial
and business development ans and associated activities. Zoning mark ups and precinct rules
are attached as Appendix C on page 68-73/91.
7027-1 William Somerville somcon@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central
7027-2 William Somerville somcon@xtra.co.nz Special Character
residential
Amend the sites in the Town Centre zone on the east side of Ponsonby Road between
Russell and Pember Reeves Streets to have a Special Character overlay with strong controls
to protect its existing architectural character.
7027-3 William Somerville somcon@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central
Retain the Public Open Space zone at the intersection of Russell, Wood and Renall Streets,
Ponsonby
7028-1 Charlotte Judge cjudge@orcon.net.nz Zoning North and Islands Rezone land within Devonport Peninsular sub-precinct C to Single House.
7028-2 Charlotte Judge cjudge@orcon.net.nz Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula K5.11 Precinct rules Amend maximum height to two storeys throughout the precinct.
7029-1
Edward Henderson Family
Trust markbellingham@tnp.co.nz RPS Changes to the RUB North and Waiheke Island
Extend the RUB to include those properties to the north and west of Hatfields Beach in the
Otanerua Stream catchment as shown on figure 2 [refer to pg 5/33] of the submission.
7029-2
Trust markbellingham@tnp.co.nz RPS Changes to the RUB North and Waiheke Island
Rezone the land 57 Otanerua Road, Hatfields Beach within the amended RUB to Future
Urban as shown on figure 2 [refer to pg 5/33] of the submission.
7029-3
Trust markbellingham@tnp.co.nz Zoning North and Islands
Rezone land to the north and west of Hatfields Beach and land east of the Northern Motorway
from Rural Production to Countryside Living as shown on Figure 2, pg 5/33 of the submission.
7030-1 Thomas R Piggin tom.piggin@xtra.co.nz RPS Mana Whenua B5 Strategic Delete the provisions entirely.
7031-1 PKMP Limited info@meihana.com RPS Changes to the RUB South
Rezone 724 - 726 North Road, Clevedon to provide for site specific canal housing and
recreational development.
7031-2 PKMP Limited info@meihana.com Precincts Ak-Wide and Coastal New Precincts All other New Precincts
Provide for a canal housing and recreational development at 724 - 726 North Road,
Clevedon, in accordance with an approved master plan or comprehensive development plan.
7032-1 Dirk Hudig
54 Marine Parade, Herne Bay,
General Amend fence controls to restrict height of rear and side yard fences to 1.8m
7032-2 Dirk Hudig
Auckland 1011 Residential zones
obs & pols Retain Objective 2
7032-3 Dirk Hudig
Amend notification rules so that any infringement of the zone rules development controls is
notified
7032-4 Dirk Hudig
Auckland 1011 Sustainable Development C7.7/H6.4 Sustainable design
Investigate the requirement of current and future photovoltaic installations and incorporate the
necessary development controls
7032-5 Dirk Hudig
General
Amend development controls so that any development or block/brick fencing must have a
minimum 50cm setback from any drain, and a minimum 1 metre setback from the exterior of
existing housing stock
7032-6 Dirk Hudig
General
Amend controls so that any new house build has sufficient setback from the boundary for
maintenance (unless no maintenance is necessary for the building product used)
7032-7 Dirk Hudig
Auckland 1011 General Miscellaneous Other Endorse the submissions of the HBRAI in full
7033-1 Stillwater Motorcamp Limited markbellingham@tnp.co.nz Zoning North and Islands Rezone 2 Duck Creek Road, Stillwater, from Single House to the Mixed Use zone.
7033-2 Stillwater Motorcamp Limited markbellingham@tnp.co.nz Precincts - North New Precincts All other New Precincts
Add a new Stillwater Maritime Precinct for the land and the surrounding 50m of Coastal
Marine Area at 2 Duck Creek Road. The new precinct will allow for the continued operation of
the existing motorcamp, while providing for progressive development of maritime and marine
servicing facilities [refer to Appendix B, pages 15-17/17 of the submission].
7033-3 Stillwater Motorcamp Limited markbellingham@tnp.co.nz
(ONF) Rules
Features Overlay
Remove the ONF - ID244, Weiti River shell spits, from the western-most spit at 2 Duck Creek
Road, Stillwater as shown on Figure 3, pg 8/17 of the submission.
7034-1 CLC Consulting Group Limited ying@clcgroup.co.nz Mana Whenua General provisions
assessment
Amend so that an applicant will only need to consult Mana Whenua if they are within a Mana
Whenua place of significance or value circle and the council determines the proposal to be
significant. Also amend so that the 50m around the circle does not require a cultural impact
assessment unless the council decides that it is a significant proposal.
assessment
Amend so that consultation is required for only up to 2 or 3 iwi groups within the vicinity of the
works. If iwi require a cultural impact assessment, then the council is to decide on which iwi
provides the cultural impact assessment.
assessment
Amend so that the Auckland Council planner assigned to the consent monitors the
consultation to ensure that it is fair.
524/1145
Sub#/
assessment Amend so that there is a fixed rate for cultural impact assessments and charge out fee.
7034-5 CLC Consulting Group Limited ying@clcgroup.co.nz
control
Building demolition control J.3.6 Rules and mapping Amend the overlay so that it only includes houses that were built before 1944.
7034-6 CLC Consulting Group Limited ying@clcgroup.co.nz Water Stormwater
H4.14.2 Stormwater
management -flow rules Increase the threshold at which consent is required form 25m
2
7034-7 CLC Consulting Group Limited ying@clcgroup.co.nz Residential zones Residential Land use controls Retain Rule 3.3 'Conversion of one dwelling into two dwellings'.
7034-8 CLC Consulting Group Limited ying@clcgroup.co.nz Residential zones Residential Land use controls
Amend to provide for detached minor household units in some zones. Ensure that they are of
a high quality design and fit in with the surrounding environment and with stricter rules being
imposed such as having to comply with the Auckland Design Manual.
Amend Rule 3.3 ['The conversion of a dwelling into two dwellings'] to delete 'The primary
dwelling must exist on the notification of this Unitary Plan' and replace with a clause that
allows the conversion of a dwelling into two dwellings on all brownfield sites.
Amend Rule 3.1 'Maximum density', so that the reduced density provides for front sites in the
Mixed Housing zones is also provided for rear sites, e.g. include a percentage of rear lots
permitted within a development.
Amend Rule 3.1 'Maximum density', to remove density limits for developments of four or more
dwellings in the Mixed Housing Suburban zone.
7034-12 CLC Consulting Group Limited ying@clcgroup.co.nz Transport Auckland -wide
requirements Retain not having parking minimums as listed in Table 3.
7035-1 Diane B Hudig
Amend notification rules so that any infringement of the zone rules development controls is
notified
necessary development controls
General
Amend controls so that any development or block/brick fencing must have a minimum 50cm
setback from any drain, and a minimum 1 metre setback from the exterior of existing housing
stock
General
Auckland 1011 General Miscellaneous Other Adopt the relief sought in the submission from the Herne Bay Residents Association Inc.
7036-1 Ivan R Davis ibsola@xtra.co.nz Zoning North and Islands Intensification south of Westward Road, Belmont is inappropriate.
7037-1
Outdoor Fabrics Products
Association of New Zealand lancehessell@tnp.co.nz Definitions Existing
Add shade structures to the list of exclusions under the definition of "Buildings"and specify
standards for these [refer to pages 4/7, 5/7 of the submission].
7038-1 Tonkin and Taylor Limited mruss@tonkin.co.nz RPS Issues
growth
Include additional references to natural hazards where these are relevant to issues of regional
significance, e.g. Enabling quality urban growth.
7038-2 Tonkin and Taylor Limited mruss@tonkin.co.nz RPS Natural resources B6.7 Natural hazards Retain Objectives 1 and 2 and Policies 1-4, 7 and 8.
7038-3 Tonkin and Taylor Limited mruss@tonkin.co.nz RPS Natural resources B6.7 Natural hazards Include strong and effective measures to implement Policies 7 and 8.
7038-4 Tonkin and Taylor Limited mruss@tonkin.co.nz RPS Urban growth
quality compact urban form Include additional references to natural hazards in the policies.
7038-5 Tonkin and Taylor Limited mruss@tonkin.co.nz RPS Rural B8 Strategic Include additional references to natural hazards in the policies
7038-6 Tonkin and Taylor Limited mruss@tonkin.co.nz Natural Hazards and Flooding Natural Hazards
and policies Retain the approach of using the best available information on natural hazards.
and policies
Develop and implement processes to ensure that the best information on natural hazards is
able to be readily identified and correctly used, within the PAUP and supporting the PAUP.
and policies Re-examine the definition of "land that may be subject to natural hazards" in policy 1.
and policies Retain the risk-based, adaptive management and avoidance approaches for natural hazards.
and policies
Delete the sentence that states: " The risk from some natural hazards, such as low frequency
...by emergency management groups such as Civil Defence". [Background]
and policies Review and strengthen the two objectives to better reflect the strong RPS objectives.
and policies
Amend policy 2 to provide for and require, as appropriate, comprehensive engineering
assessment of relevant natural hazards.
525/1145
Sub#/
7038-14 Tonkin and Taylor Limited mruss@tonkin.co.nz Definitions Existing Retain the definition of vulnerable activities.
and policies
Add policies to ensure competent engineering assessment and judgement is provided and
used to consider the matters in policy 4.
7038-18 Tonkin and Taylor Limited mruss@tonkin.co.nz Residential zones Residential
General
Amend the yard rules to include reference to natural hazards including Policy 9 in [C].5.12
'Natural Hazards'.
and policies
Amend policies 14 and 15 to ensure that these will achieve objective 5 and the relevant RPS
natural hazard objectives and policies.
7038-21 Tonkin and Taylor Limited mruss@tonkin.co.nz Natural Hazards and Flooding Natural Hazards H4.11.1 Activity table
Amend the rules to ensure that these will achieve objective 5 and the relevant RPS natural
hazard objectives and policies.
7038-22 Tonkin and Taylor Limited mruss@tonkin.co.nz Definitions New Include a definition of flood prone areas.
7038-23 Tonkin and Taylor Limited mruss@tonkin.co.nz Natural Hazards and Flooding Flooding
and policies Delete the reference to flood prone areas in objective 2.
7038-24 Tonkin and Taylor Limited mruss@tonkin.co.nz Natural Hazards and Flooding Flooding
7038-25 Tonkin and Taylor Limited mruss@tonkin.co.nz Residential zones Residential
policies
Include references to natural hazards in commentary, objectives and policies in all residential
zones (as currently included in the Large Lot and Rural and Coastal Settlement).
Assessment
Amend rule H4.11.2.2 to provide for and require, as appropriate, comprehensive engineering
assessment of relevant natural hazards (rule 4 in section 4.12 flooding provides an example).
Assessment
Retain rules 3.1 (matters of discretion) and H4.11.3.2 (assessment criteria), and ensure
implementation of these is supported by with competent engineering assessment.
7038-28 Tonkin and Taylor Limited mruss@tonkin.co.nz Natural Hazards and Flooding Flooding H4.12 Rules Retain the rules.
7039-1
Michael Kwok and Brianna
Parkinson brianna@briannaparkinson.co.nz Zoning Coastal Retain the Marina zone for Bayswater Marina.
7039-2
Parkinson brianna@briannaparkinson.co.nz Precincts - North Bayswater
7039-3
Parkinson brianna@briannaparkinson.co.nz Precincts - North Bayswater K5.6 Precinct rules Amend the activity table to provide for dwellings as a non-complying activity.
7039-4
Parkinson brianna@briannaparkinson.co.nz Precincts - North Bayswater K5.6 Precinct rules
Delete 'the provision for dwellings to comply with a framework plan or prior to the approval
with an approved framework plan' .
7039-5
Parkinson brianna@briannaparkinson.co.nz Precincts - North Bayswater K5.6 Precinct rules Delete the provision for framework plans from the activity table.
7039-6
Parkinson brianna@briannaparkinson.co.nz Precincts - North Bayswater K5.6 Precinct rules Delete the notification rule.
7039-7
Parkinson brianna@briannaparkinson.co.nz Precincts - North Bayswater K5.6 Precinct rules Delete the Special Information Requirements.
7039-8
Add a land use control to limit the total cumulative gross floor area of food and beverage and
licensed premises to 300m
2
GFA.
7039-9
Add a requirement for a landowner or the council to prepare a structure plan when seeking to
re-zone and develop the precinct for residential activities as part of a plan change.
7039-10
Parkinson brianna@briannaparkinson.co.nz Precincts - North Bayswater
Add objectives and policies to 'enable an appropriate intensity of residential activities, while
protecting the amenity values of the coastal environment and the neighbouring open space
and residential zoned land'.
7039-11
Add a land use control to limit the density of residential activities to 'an appropriate level in
order to implement policy 12 of both the Marina zone and the precinct.'
7039-12
Add development controls to enable 2 to 3 storey attached terraced housing, 10m maximum
height. Allow 50 per cent of the building to exceed the maximum height by 1m.
7039-13
Retain requirement for dwellings to comply with an approved framework plan to be assessed
as a discretionary activity, and assessed as a non-complying activity if prior to the approval or
not in accordance with an approved framework plan.
526/1145
Sub#/
7039-14
Amend the special information requirements to incorporate consideration of all the matters in
policy 12 of the Marina zone and Policy 12 of the precinct, including but not limited to location
and design of open space; provision for the Bayswater ferry and buses, including public
parking; provision for vehicle access to boat launching facilities and associated public parking;
an integrated transport assessment; a public facilities management plan; provision for a direct
pedestrian linkage to the ferry terminal from Sir Peter Blake Parade; provision for the
protection and enhancement of the coastal margin as esplanade reserve; and provision for
the enhancement of public access to and along the CMA and through the precinct.
7040-1 Phill Wallace biancahartley@tnp.co.nz RPS Changes to the RUB North and Waiheke Island
Rezone all of 17 and part of 19 Matheson Road, Wellsford, from the Rural Production zone to
the Single House zone [refer to figure 3 on pg 5/11 of the submission].
7041-1 Gareth and Helena Going garethgoing@gmail.com
SEAs
Land Delete the SEA overlay, with specific reference to 48 Christian Road, Swanson.
7041-2 Gareth and Helena Going garethgoing@gmail.com Mana Whenua
Whenua
and policies Delete the mana whenua overlay.
7041-3 Gareth and Helena Going garethgoing@gmail.com
control
Building demolition control J.3.6 Rules and mapping Delete the pre-1944 heritage overlay.
7041-4 Gareth and Helena Going garethgoing@gmail.com General Miscellaneous Other Supports the SPAN submission.
7041-5 Gareth and Helena Going garethgoing@gmail.com General Whole Plan
Withdraw the plan entirely. Renotify following further consultation about the Waitakere
Ranges area.
7041-6 Gareth and Helena Going garethgoing@gmail.com Precincts - West
Area
objectives and policies Amend to make subdivision a discretionary activity at one acre or 4000m
2

Area
objectives and policies Increase the building coverage threshold from 300m
2
to allow for a barn, garage and house.
Area
Amend the density control to provide more flexibility to construct more dwellings in appropriate
locations with the Waitakere Ranges.
7042-1 Graeme D McLeod
2/613 Manukau Road, Epsom,
7043-1 Michelle Tolley
15 Huka Road, Birkenhead,
quality compact urban form Opposes intensification in and around Town Centres [No specific relief sought]
7043-2 Michelle Tolley
15 Huka Road, Birkenhead,
Opposes intensification in and around the Highbury/Birkenhead town centre. [No Specific
relief sought].
7044-1 Treasurelands Limited biancahartley@tnp.co.nz Zoning North and Islands Retain the PAUP zonings for the land at 6 South Head Road, Parakai.
7044-2 Treasurelands Limited biancahartley@tnp.co.nz Precincts - North New Precincts All other New Precincts
Add a new Parakai Thermal Resort Precinct to the land at 6 South Head Road, Parakai. The
new precinct will allow the future development of the site, based on thermal resources
available, including a thermal resort, recreation activities and visitor accommodation [see
pages 6-9/16 of the submission].
7045-1 Jason P Robertson
6 Richbourne Street, Kingsland,
Amend notification rules so that any infringement of the zone rules - development controls is
notified
necessary development controls within the PAUP
General
stock
General
7046-1 Kate I Robertson
policies Retain Objective 2
Amend notification rules so that any infringement of the zone rules - development controls is
notified
necessary development controls within the PAUP
General
stock
527/1145
Sub#/
General
7047-1 Reta F Elliott
2169 Ponga Road, RD4, Papakura,
Reject all provisions calling for partnership arrangements, joint management, and co-
management and the transfer of power to Mana Whenua
7048-1
Protect Piha Heritage Society
Incorporated protectpihaheritage@xtra.co.nz Historic Heritage (Overlay)
Heritage
Places Add 'Piha Tramway' (sections not already scheduled), Piha to the schedule.
7048-2
Heritage
Places
Add 'Radar Station Radio House' (now cookhouse in the Piha Camping Ground), Piha to the
schedule.
7048-3
Heritage
Places
Add 'Radar Station/dormitory/crewhouse' former Hobsonviille Airbase, Hobsonville to the
schedule.
7048-4
Heritage
Places
Add the 'Radar Station Mess' (now situated at South Head Air weapons range), Kaipara to the
schedule.
7049-1 Walter F Titchener
PO Box 849, Whangaparaoa,
Whenua
and policies Remove the Sites and Places of Value to Mana Whenua Objectives and Policies.
Whenua
and policies Remove the Sites and Places of Value to Mana Whenua overlay.
assessment Remove all rules and objectives requiring a cultural impact assessment.
7050-1 John W Elliott
2169 Ponga Road, RD4, Papakura,
Reject all provisions calling for partnership arrangements, joint management, and co-
management and the transfer of power to Mana Whenua
7051-1
OraTaiao: The New Zealand
Climate and Health Council rg.jones@auckland.ac.nz RPS Urban growth
Retain approach of limiting sprawl and developing Auckland as a quality, compact city through
intensification focused on town centres and transport corridors.
7051-2
Maintain all development over the next 30 years within the current urban limits [the operative
MUL], or if growth beyond the current urban limit is deemed unavoidable, the Future Urban
Zone should be split into two sub-zones in order to limit sprawl. One sub-zone would would
include areas less suitable for development in the next 10 years, while the other would
comprise areas suitable for development beyond that date.
7051-3
Undertake 'smart' intensification supported by infrastructure, e.g. footpaths, cycle paths,
community shared spaces and local amenities. Ensure that amenities and mitigation of
hazards are provided prior to or concurrently with residential intensification.
7051-4
quality compact urban form Create mixed use zones rather than segregated residential, commercial and industrial areas.
7051-5
environment
Manage the downside of intensification, particularly those related to car use e.g. air pollution,
traffic danger, high noise levels.
7051-6
Provide for intensification adjacent to rapid transport nodes on designated corridors (rail or
busways).
7051-7
Climate and Health Council rg.jones@auckland.ac.nz RPS
Transport B3.3 Transport Provide for a significant expansion of the rapid transit network (rail).
7051-8
Climate and Health Council rg.jones@auckland.ac.nz
Centre) Business
Park zones
Increase the height limits in some areas zoned for Mixed Use development located close to
high quality public transport, e.g. Morningside and Newton.
7051-9
Climate and Health Council rg.jones@auckland.ac.nz Zoning Central
Rezone all areas between Morningside train station and St Lukes Shopping Centre from Light
Industry to to Mixed Use.
7051-10
Rezone the area bounded by May Road, Mt Albert Road, SH20 and Mt Roskill Grammar to
Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings Zone.
7051-11
Climate and Health Council rg.jones@auckland.ac.nz Built Environment (Overlays)
Height Control
Provide an additional zone height control overlay for additional height along the sides of Great
North Road, between Ponsonby Road and Surrey Crescent.
7051-12
Rezone the area within 800m walk of Meadowbank train station to Terrace Housing and
Apartment Buildings or Mixed Housing Urban.
7051-13
Rezone the area bounded by New North Road, the city fringe, SH20 and Great South Road,
from Mixed Housing Suburban to Mixed Housing Urban.
7051-14
Rezone along both sides of Great South Road between Greenlane East/West and the main
highway, from Light Industry to Mixed Use.
7051-15
Climate and Health Council rg.jones@auckland.ac.nz General Miscellaneous
Operational/
Projects/Acquisition Improve the quality of public spaces and amenities.
7051-16
Protect natural heritage and biodiversity within the city including by ensuring that increased
density does not impinge on current parks and green spaces.
528/1145
Sub#/
7051-17
Climate and Health Council rg.jones@auckland.ac.nz General Miscellaneous Development contributions Impose development contributions for use in the development of quality public spaces.
7051-18
Operational/
Projects/Acquisition Make streets more livable, especially in intensified areas.
7051-19
Operational/
Create new green space within the current urban area, if there is greenfields development
outside the current urban area.
7051-20
Climate and Health Council rg.jones@auckland.ac.nz Sustainable Development C7.7/H6.4 Sustainable design
Apply energy efficiency standards to all new buildings. In particular, apply the Homestar rating
to all new houses and the Greenstar to all new commercial buildings.
7051-21
Climate and Health Council rg.jones@auckland.ac.nz Sustainable Development C7.7/H6.4 Sustainable design
Apply a life cycle environmental analysis approach to all new construction. Apply measures to
ensure all construction is low-carbon, highly energy efficient, water efficient, low waste, and
low toxicity.
7051-22
Climate and Health Council rg.jones@auckland.ac.nz Natural Hazards and Flooding Flooding H4.12 Rules
Calculate the 1:100 year flood plain risk from the end of the lifespan of the infrastructure
rather than from now.
7051-23
Operational/
Projects/Acquisition Provide an integrated network of Copenhagen cycle lanes.
7051-24
Climate and Health Council rg.jones@auckland.ac.nz Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
Delete all minimum parking requirements. In particular delete the minimum parking
requirements for the Mixed Housing Urban and Mixed Housing Suburban zones and from
Tavern Activities.
7051-25
Climate and Health Council rg.jones@auckland.ac.nz Transport Auckland -wide
requirements Ensure that intensified areas have traffic calming measures.
7051-26
Climate and Health Council rg.jones@auckland.ac.nz Residential zones Residential
General Ensure that new residential buildings in intensified areas have high quality noise insulation.
7051-27
Climate and Health Council rg.jones@auckland.ac.nz General Miscellaneous Development contributions Require reserve contributions for use in the development of quality public spaces.
7052-1 Jenny J Rindermann
24A Herbert Road, Mount Eden,
General
General
House
Auckland 1024
control
7053-1 Matthew Oakes moakes@ihug.co.nz
SEAs
Land
Amend the extent of the SEA over 29 McKenzie Ave, Arkles Bay to properly include the
trees/vegetation that are significant. This needs to be done via a site visit not by aerial photo
7054-1 Ronald G Jacob
14 Herbert Road, Mount Eden,
General
General
House
Auckland 1024
control
7055-1 Sandra Stanley-Hunt david@davidwren.co.nz Zoning North and Islands
Rezone land at the eastern end of Russell Road, Wainui [refer to Appendix 1 page 5/5 of the
submission] from Rural Production to the Countryside Living zone.
7055-2 Sandra Stanley-Hunt david@davidwren.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - Rural zones
area
Extend the South Rodney subdivision rule requirements [refer to Table 10: Minimum and
average net site areas for subdivision in Countryside Living Zones, Part 5 Subdivision, 2.3.3
Rural Zone] to that land at the eastern end of Russell Road, Wainui [refer to Appendix 1 page
7055-3 Sandra Stanley-Hunt david@davidwren.co.nz Zoning North and Islands
Amend the PAUP to provide for countryside living in the area, particularly at the eastern end
of Russell Road, Wainui [refer to Appendix 1 page 5/5 in the submission].
7056-1 Alan and Beverley Wiltshire wiltshirepg@gmail.com General Chapter G General provisions
Delete: "However, the assessment criteria are not an exhaustive list and the council may
consider any relevant policy or criteria within the Unitary Plan if it is within the scope of the
matter of control/discretion for the particular activity." from G1.4.
7056-2 Alan and Beverley Wiltshire wiltshirepg@gmail.com RPS Urban growth
environment
Delete the requirement for separate design statements and amend to confirm that the
Auckland Design Manual is a non-statutory guideline.
7056-3 Alan and Beverley Wiltshire wiltshirepg@gmail.com Mana Whenua General provisions
assessment Delete the requirements for cultural impact assessments.
7056-4 Alan and Beverley Wiltshire wiltshirepg@gmail.com Residential zones Residential
General
Amend the side yard requirement from 1m to 2m for both the Single House and Mixed
Housing Suburban zones.
529/1145
Sub#/
7056-5 Alan and Beverley Wiltshire wiltshirepg@gmail.com Zoning North and Islands
Rezone the land on the north-east side of Holiday Road, Milford, from Mixed Housing
Suburban to Single House.
7056-6 Alan and Beverley Wiltshire wiltshirepg@gmail.com Zoning North and Islands Retain the Single House zone for 3a Holiday Road, Milford.
7057-1
Kylie Pridham and Carolyn
James kylie@blackandwhite.net.nz Special Character
General
7057-2
James kylie@blackandwhite.net.nz Zoning Central Retain the Single Housing zone applying to Balmoral streets
7057-3
James kylie@blackandwhite.net.nz Residential zones Residential
7057-4
James kylie@blackandwhite.net.nz
control
7058-1 Mary I Hullen maryhullen@gmail.com Residential zones Residential Activity Table
Amend Activity Table to allow building on a vacant/stage 2 cross-lease site as a permitted
activity
7058-2 Mary I Hullen maryhullen@gmail.com Subdivision Auckland-wide - Urban zones H5.2 3.1 Residential zones
Amend Activity Table to allow the conversion of cross lease titles to freehold titles as a
permitted or controlled activity
7059-1 Wendy Gray wendzgray@orcon.net.nz RPS Urban growth
Retain the vision of a "quality compact urban form with a clear limit to the urban expansion of
the urban area, satellite towns, rural and coastal towns and serviced villages" and the
intention to concentrate intensification around key transport hubs, the focus on encouraging
public transport use.
7059-2 Wendy Gray wendzgray@orcon.net.nz Sustainable Development C7.7/H6.4 Sustainable design Retain the proposals for encouraging energy efficiency in large buildings.
7059-3 Wendy Gray wendzgray@orcon.net.nz RPS Coastal B7 Strategic Retain the approach of the protection of coastal areas.
7059-4 Wendy Gray wendzgray@orcon.net.nz Historic Heritage (Overlay)
Heritage
objectives and policies Provide more heritage protection for buildings.
7059-5 Wendy Gray wendzgray@orcon.net.nz Residential zones Residential
General
Amend to better protect the privacy and sunlight access of neighbouring properties, and
graded boundaries to Single House in residential areas.
Amend the PAUP process to adopt a staged approach and prepare a series of local precinct
plans providing for intensification involving community input.
7059-7 Wendy Gray wendzgray@orcon.net.nz Designations G1.3 Designations Amend to give schools their own designation.
7059-8 Wendy Gray wendzgray@orcon.net.nz Zoning Central Retain the Single House zoning in Grey Lynn.
7059-9 Wendy Gray wendzgray@orcon.net.nz Historic Heritage (Overlay)
Heritage
Places Retain the Historic Heritage overlay in Grey Lynn.
7059-10 Wendy Gray wendzgray@orcon.net.nz Special Character
& C
Isthmus Retain the Historic Character Overlay in Grey Lynn.
7059-11 Wendy Gray wendzgray@orcon.net.nz Special Character
residential
Undertake a heritage character assessment of residential Grey Lynn not currently included in
the Historic Character Overlay, to allow the full extent of historic character to be protected and
identified.
7059-12 Wendy Gray wendzgray@orcon.net.nz
control
Amend to ensure that no demolition or removal of pre-1944 houses is allowed in Grey Lynn
until the full historic character assessment has been carried out and the Historic Character
Overlay has been amended.
control
Building demolition control J.3.6 Rules and mapping Amend to make demolition of pre-1944 buildings a publicly notified activity.
7059-14 Wendy Gray wendzgray@orcon.net.nz Zoning Central
Rezone all land zoned Mixed Housing Urban and Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings in
Grey Lynn to some other unspecified less intensive zone.
Rezone the land along Great North Road ridge from Mixed Use to Terraced Housing and
Apartments, where it abuts Single House [see land along Great North Road between
Grosenover Street and Scanlan Street].
Review areas zoned as Mixed Use in Grey Lynn [submission appears to seek less intensive
zoning].
Provide for infrastructure such as schools, public transport, walking and cycling connections,
sewerage and stormwater upgrades, recreation and sports facilities including swimming pools,
and parks and open spaces, in relation to intensification.
7059-18 Wendy Gray wendzgray@orcon.net.nz General Miscellaneous
Operational/
Provide for covenanting of and an increase of native bush areas, and along with good
environmental protection in Grey Lynn.
Centre) Business
Park zones
Clarify and reconsider the building heights for West Lynn shops. A height of 12.5m is
preferred to 14.5m.
7059-20 Wendy Gray wendzgray@orcon.net.nz Zoning Central Rezone the West Lynn shops from Local Centre to Neighbourhood Centre.
7059-21 Wendy Gray wendzgray@orcon.net.nz General Chapter G General provisions G2.4 Notification Amend to strengthen provisions for public notification.
530/1145
Sub#/
7059-22 Wendy Gray wendzgray@orcon.net.nz Residential zones Residential
policies
Amend to ensure that housing density is not increased in areas affected by land instability or
flooding in Grey Lynn.
7059-23 Wendy Gray wendzgray@orcon.net.nz Trees
Trees
Notable Trees
Assess the London Plan trees in Browning Street, Selbourne Street, Castle Street, Francis
Street, and Hakanoa Street, Grey Lynn, for inclusion in the schedule of notable trees.
Amend the anomalies in plots of land and roads through Grey Lynn Park. Inferred to refer to
the zoning of Grey Lynn Park.
7059-25 Wendy Gray wendzgray@orcon.net.nz RPS
Preserve trees, or if this is not possible, replace them with more trees than are taken out. Fine
developers for any trees they take out.
7059-26 Wendy Gray wendzgray@orcon.net.nz Trees
Trees
Notable Trees Amend to address the lack of notable trees in South Auckland.
Amend the notable tree listing procedure to make it less prescriptive and easier to list trees.
Allow people to list trees that are important to them.
character and natural heritage B4.3.3 Trees and vegetation Provide policies and practical tools to save trees and encourage more planting of trees.
7059-29 Wendy Gray wendzgray@orcon.net.nz Sustainable Development C7.7/H6.4 Sustainable design Amend so that all developments are assessed for a green roof and green wall requirement.
7059-30 Wendy Gray wendzgray@orcon.net.nz Sustainable Development C7.7/H6.4 Sustainable design Amend so that all developments are required to provide water harvesting and recycling.
7059-31 Wendy Gray wendzgray@orcon.net.nz General Miscellaneous Other Amend to prevent the fluoridation of water.
7059-32 Wendy Gray wendzgray@orcon.net.nz Air Quality H4.1 Auckland wide rules Mobile sources Amend to require emissions testing of vehicles.
7059-33 Wendy Gray wendzgray@orcon.net.nz General Miscellaneous
Operational/
Projects/Acquisition Provide for and encourage electric cars.
7059-34 Wendy Gray wendzgray@orcon.net.nz Air Quality
and policies Delete provisions regulating fireplace emissions and focus on vehicle emissions first.
organisms
modified organisms Amend to provide for better monitoring of GMO.
organisms
modified organisms
Amend to provide guidelines for handling of GMO coming in through the Port of Auckland and
Auckland Airport.
organisms
modified organisms Prohibit the growing of GMO.
character and natural heritage B4.3.4 Biodiversity Regulate cat ownership to protect birds, skinks and biodiveristy.
7060-1 Jeffrey Russell david@davidwren.co.nz Zoning North and Islands
Rezone land at the eastern end of Russell Road, Wainui [refer to Apendix 1 page 5/5 of the
7060-2 Jeffrey Russell david@davidwren.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - Rural zones
area
average net site areas for subdivision in Countryside Living Zones, Part 5. Subdivision, 2.3.3
7060-3 Jeffrey Russell david@davidwren.co.nz Zoning North and Islands
Amend the PAUP to provide for countryside living, particularly at the eastern end of Russell
Road, Wainui [refer to Appendix 1 page 5/5 of the submission].
7061-1 Kurt Marquart kurt@marquart.org Built Environment (Overlays)
Height Control Amend height limit in Browns Bay Town Centre zone from 6 storeys to 5 storeys
7061-2 Kurt Marquart kurt@marquart.org RPS Urban growth
environment Amend to apply building design regulations for buildings in prominent visual locations
7061-3 Kurt Marquart kurt@marquart.org RPS Urban growth
quality compact urban form Reject high rise buildings in favour of satellite towns and cities to house growing population
7061-4 Kurt Marquart kurt@marquart.org General Miscellaneous Bylaws and Licensing Introduce proactive enforcement and instant fines for infringement of bylaws
7061-5 Kurt Marquart kurt@marquart.org General Miscellaneous
Operational/
Projects/Acquisition Broadcast Council meetings on television
7061-6 Kurt Marquart kurt@marquart.org General Miscellaneous Other Record all votes in Council meetings and include these with the minutes
Operational/
Establish a auditing function for all community groups and societies that receive over $2000 in
funding from Council per annum
Operational/
Projects/Acquisition Provide facilities and money to the Marine Museum and associated marine heritage societies
Operational/
Emphasis roundabouts over traffic signals at intersections and look at land acquisition of such
intersections
7062-1 Rachael D McDouall rachaelmcdouall@hotmail.com Zoning Central
Rezone the land on the Northern side of St Leonards Road, Epsom, between Atanga
Crescent and St Andrews Road and adjacent properties, from Mixed Housing Suburban to
Single House.
7063-1 Fiona McDonald andela.mcdonald@xtra.co.nz Residential zones Residential
General
7063-2 Fiona McDonald andela.mcdonald@xtra.co.nz Special Character
General
531/1145
Sub#/
7063-3 Fiona McDonald andela.mcdonald@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central
House
7063-4 Fiona McDonald andela.mcdonald@xtra.co.nz
control
7064-1 John Humphries
2 Okoromai Views, Gulf Harbour,
Delete provisions calling for partnership arrangements, joint management and transfer of
power to Mana Whenua
7065-1 Rosalind A Smith rozignol@gmail.com Precincts - Central New Precincts Three Kings
Amend PAUP to create a Three Kings town centre precinct addressing the existing town
centre, the Fletchers Quarry site, Antiopodean land holdings, and land belonging to iwi trusts,
the Crown and Council, following development of a Precinct Plan based on consultation with
stakeholders and an 'Open Design Competition' endorsed by the New Zealand Institute of
Architects. Matters to be addressed include access ways, public open space, height controls,
viewshafts, and car parking. Refer to details in submission at page 4-8/19 and
appended submissions.
Provide for rehabilitation of the Three Kings Quarry site to create an integrated area with the
neighbouring town centre, including residential uses, additional public open space, multiple
accessible entrances, enhanced viewshafts, and maximised fill of the excavated area. Refer
to details in submission at page 5/19.
Amend the height controls for the car parking area adjacent to Countdown on Mt Albert Road,
Three Kings, [ to provide for a height of 16.5m reducing to 8m where adjacent to
residential properties]. Refer to submission at page 6/19.
Amend the rules (in particular height controls) for the Three Kings Town Centre (including
Antipodean, Council and Crown land) to enable intensification of the land adjoining a public
transport node. Refer to details in submission at page 6/19.
Require implementation of traffic, transportation, heritage and urban design considerations for
the Three Kings Town Centre (including Antipodean, Council and Crown land). Refer to
details in submission at page 6/19.
7066-1 Janemaree and Greg Hines david@davidwren.co.nz Zoning North and Islands
Rezone land at the eastern end of Russell Road, Wainui [refer to Apendix 1, page 5/5 of the
7066-2 Janemaree and Greg Hines david@davidwren.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - Rural zones
area
average net site areas for subdivision in Countryside Living Zones, Part 5. Subdivision, 2.3.3
7066-3 Janemaree and Greg Hines david@davidwren.co.nz Zoning North and Islands
Amend the PAUP to provide for countryside living around the eastern end of Russell Road,
Wainui [refer to Appendix 1, page 5/5 of the submission].
7067-1 Shieff Angland Lawyers richard.hatch@shieffangland.co.nz Zoning North and Islands Rezone Silverdale North Sub-Precinct D3 from Neighbourhood Centre to Local Centre.
7067-2 Shieff Angland Lawyers richard.hatch@shieffangland.co.nz Precincts - North Silverdale North
Amend Sub-Precinct D3 Activity table to make the following activities non-complying: garden
centres, marine retail, motor vehicle sales, supermarkets greater than 1500m
2
, trade
suppliers, industrial laboratories, light manufacturing and servicing and warehousing and
servicing [K5.44.1, Table 4].
7067-3 Shieff Angland Lawyers richard.hatch@shieffangland.co.nz Precincts - North Silverdale North
Delete food and beverage uses from the Sub-precinct D3 activity table, and rely upon the
Local Centre zoning [K5.44.1, Table 4].
7068-1 East Coast Farms Limited markbellingham@tnp.co.nz Zoning North and Islands
Retain the Town Centre zone for the southern part of 31 Curley Avenue, Silverdale; subject to
a realignment of Curley Avenue extension and a consequential change to the northern
boundary of the Town Centre zone.
7068-2 East Coast Farms Limited markbellingham@tnp.co.nz Future Urban
Overlay 4.4 Indicative Roads
and Open Space
Realign the extension of Curley Avenue through the site at 31 Curley Avenue, Silverdale in
the Built Environment Indicative Road Overlay to follow the road-line proposed by Auckland
Transport [refer to figure 3, pg 6/17 of the submission].
Rezone the northern boundary of the Town Centre zone at Silverdale to match with the new
alignment of Curley Avenue in order to continue the 70m band of the Town Centre zone on
the northern side of the road [refer to figure 3, pg 6/17 of the submission].
7068-4 East Coast Farms Limited markbellingham@tnp.co.nz Precincts - North Rodney Landscape
Delete the Large Lot Rodney Landscape Sub-precinct H on 31 Curley Avenue, Silverdale with
the Single House zone - Silverdale North Sub-precinct B.
Rezone the southern part of the Silverdale Scenic Reserve from Public Open Space
Conservation to the Town Centre zone [refer to figure 3, pg 6/17 of the submission].
7069-1 Nicole Lee nicole_physio@yahoo.com Residential zones Residential
General Delete front yard setbacks controls from all residential zones
7069-2 Nicole Lee nicole_physio@yahoo.com Residential zones Residential Land use controls
Delete density limits for four or more dwellings in the Mixed Housing Suburban zone [Rule
3.1(5)]
7069-3 Nicole Lee nicole_physio@yahoo.com Residential zones Residential Land use controls Delete density limits in the Mixed Housing Urban zone [Rule 3.1]
7069-4 Nicole Lee nicole_physio@yahoo.com Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
Delete parking minimum controls in the Mixed Housing Urban and Mixed Housing Suburban
zones [rule 3.2]
532/1145
Sub#/
7069-5 Nicole Lee nicole_physio@yahoo.com Residential zones Residential
Mixed Housing Urban zone Amend height limit in Mixed Housing Suburban zone from 2 stories to more than 2 stories.
7069-6 Nicole Lee nicole_physio@yahoo.com Residential zones Residential Land use controls Reinstate the density controls [in the residential zones] from the draft Unitary Plan
7069-7 Nicole Lee nicole_physio@yahoo.com RPS Urban growth
Reduce Single House and Mixed Housing Suburban zoning and increase zoning for increased
development and mixed development
7070-1 Christina A Jeffery opito@xnet.co.nz Residential zones Residential
General
7070-2 Christina A Jeffery opito@xnet.co.nz Special Character
General
7070-3 Christina A Jeffery opito@xnet.co.nz Zoning Central
House
7070-4 Christina A Jeffery opito@xnet.co.nz
control
7071-1 Whangaparaoa Golf Club moakes@ihug.co.nz Zoning North and Islands
Rezone 1337 Whangaparaoa Rd, Army Bay (Lot 1 DP455537) from Public Open Space -
Sport and Recreation to Single House
7072-1 Rebecca J Marshall beckym@slingshot.co.nz RPS Mana Whenua B5 Strategic Delete all provisions relating to co-governance; in particular sections 1.4, 5.1, 5.2 and 5.4.
7073-1 Tanya and Clinton Brown tanyaandclint@xtra.co.nz RPS Issues
Amend by deleting the statement 'It is important to build stable and equal partnerships which
enable Mana Whenua to actively and meaningfully participate in the management of natural
resources'. This appears in the third paragraph under the heading 'Decision making,
environmental governance, partnerships and participation'
7073-2 Tanya and Clinton Brown tanyaandclint@xtra.co.nz RPS Issues
Amend by deleting the bullet point 'Enable Mana Whenua to participate in co-management of
natural resources'. This statement appears under the heading 'Auckland Plan strategic
direction and priorities'
7073-3 Tanya and Clinton Brown tanyaandclint@xtra.co.nz RPS Mana Whenua B5 Strategic
co-management, joint management agreements and the transfer of power to Mana Whenua
7073-4 Tanya and Clinton Brown tanyaandclint@xtra.co.nz RPS Mana Whenua
participation Amend by deleting Policies 3 and 4
7073-5 Tanya and Clinton Brown tanyaandclint@xtra.co.nz RPS Mana Whenua
Fig. 1 Amend by deleting Policy 11
7073-6 Tanya and Clinton Brown tanyaandclint@xtra.co.nz Water
policies
Objectives
Ensure that management decisions regarding freshwater resources lie solely with
democratically elected governing bodies, and not in partnership with Mana Whenua
7073-7 Tanya and Clinton Brown tanyaandclint@xtra.co.nz Mana Whenua
Whenua
Delete and rewrite in a way that: respects property rights; provides a fair balance between
protection of cultural heritage and private property rights; uses clear and unambiguous
terminology; requires the council to be responsible for all Cultural Impact Assessments with
applicants dealing directly with the council and not with iwi
Whenua
and policies
Whenua
whenua
Grade the Sites of significance to Mana Whenua into categories of significance, to be
accorded various degrees of protection and obligation
Whenua
varying degrees of protection and obligation
7073-11 Tanya and Clinton Brown tanyaandclint@xtra.co.nz RPS Mana Whenua B5 Strategic
when a place is designated a Site of Significance or Value to Mana Whenua
7073-12 Tanya and Clinton Brown tanyaandclint@xtra.co.nz Mana Whenua General provisions
assessment Delete G2.7.4 Cultural Impact Assessment
7073-13 Tanya and Clinton Brown tanyaandclint@xtra.co.nz Mana Whenua General provisions
assessment
necessary. Provide the council with the discretion to determine whether iwi are adversely
affected, and whether further consultation should occur, in circumstances where further
development is proposed but previous iwi consultation has taken place.
Whenua
whenua
Limit the extent of the site of significance to correlate with the results of existing
archaeological assessments, where these have already been undertaken
533/1145
Sub#/
7074-1 Body Corporate 312977 jmorton@mortontee.co.nz Residential zones Residential
Terrace Housing and
Reject the permitted height and bulk on the Emerald Inn site located in the block bounded by
the Promenade, Allison Ave and Earnoch Ave, Takapuna [Terrace Housing and Apartment
Buildings zone]
7075-1 Colin F E Jeffery opito@xnet.co.nz Residential zones Residential
General
7075-2 Colin F E Jeffery opito@xnet.co.nz Special Character
General
7075-3 Colin F E Jeffery opito@xnet.co.nz Zoning Central
House
7075-4 Colin F E Jeffery opito@xnet.co.nz
control
7076-1 Gayatri Jaduram gayatri@jaduram.co.nz Special Character
& C
Isthmus
Apply Special Character overlay to Mont Le Grand Rd, Mount Eden and surrounding streets
including Brixton, Dunbar, Dexter, Rarawa, Manatu and Herbert Road.
7076-2 Gayatri Jaduram gayatri@jaduram.co.nz Zoning Central
Rezone Mont Le Grand Rd, Mount Eden and surrounding streets including Brixton, Dunbar,
Dexter, Rarawa, Manatu and Herbert Road from Mixed Housing Suburban to Single House
7076-3 Gayatri Jaduram gayatri@jaduram.co.nz
control
Apply pre-1944 building demolition control to all Special Character areas prior to the Unitary
Plan becoming operative
7076-4 Gayatri Jaduram gayatri@jaduram.co.nz Zoning Central Rezone 31 Mont Le Grand Rd, Mt Eden from Mixed Housing Suburban to Single House
7076-5 Gayatri Jaduram gayatri@jaduram.co.nz Precincts Ak-Wide and Coastal Stadiums and Showgrounds
Objectives and Policies Retain provisions which relate to the sub-precinct A area [Eden Park]
7076-6 Gayatri Jaduram gayatri@jaduram.co.nz General
H6.5)
Exclude rules from not applying to Stadiums and Showgrounds precinct, sub-precinct A [Eden
Park].
7076-7 Gayatri Jaduram gayatri@jaduram.co.nz General Chapter G General provisions G2.4 Notification Amend so restricted discretionary activities are subject to the RMA notification tests
7076-8 Gayatri Jaduram gayatri@jaduram.co.nz Residential zones Residential Land use controls
Reject the density control of one dwelling per 200m
2
where the site is larger than 1200m
2
in
the Mixed Housing Suburban zone [Rule 3.1(1)]
7076-9 Gayatri Jaduram gayatri@jaduram.co.nz Residential zones Residential Land use controls
Reject the unlimited density control for sites over 1200m
2
in the Mixed Housing Urban zone
[Rule 3.1(1)]
7076-10 Gayatri Jaduram gayatri@jaduram.co.nz
Amend activity status of Taverns within 30m of a residential zone from restricted discretionary
to discretionary
& C J3.3.1-7 Rules
Amend activity status of demolition in the Special Character Residential Isthmus A, B and C
from restricted discretionary to discretionary
& C J3.3.1-7 Rules Delete relocation of removed building from the [restricted discretionary] assessment criteria
Rezone Sandringham Road from Rossmay Terrace south to Gribblehirst Rd, Sandringham
from Mixed Housing Urban to Mixed Housing Suburban
7076-14 Gayatri Jaduram gayatri@jaduram.co.nz Built Environment (Overlays)
Height Control Amend the height limit for the Eden Valley Local Centre from 12.5m to 10m
7076-15 Gayatri Jaduram gayatri@jaduram.co.nz Built Environment (Overlays)
Height Control
Amend height limit of Mixed Use zone from Prospect Terrace to Brixton Road, Mt Eden from
16.5m to 10m
Reject Mixed Housing Urban and Mixed Use zoning within the area bounded by Balmoral Rd,
Sandringham Rd, Kingsland, Mt Eden Rd and New North Rd, or alternatively apply a staging
mechanism where zoning will not apply until adaquate infrastructure provision and shortage of
land is determined
7077-1 Gretchen J Eliott gretcheneliott@hotmail.com Zoning North and Islands Delete provisions for four-storey housing in the Devonport/Bayswater area.
7078-1 John S Francis
160 Fletcher Road, RD1, Waimauku,
Auckland 0881 Precincts - North Waimauku
Incorporate the Waimauku Structure Plan, as was developed by the Rodney District Council,
into the PAUP.
Auckland 0881 RPS Changes to the RUB West
Rezone the Waimauku land identified in Annexure B [refer to pages 5-10/10 of submission]
from Mixed Rural to Single House.
Auckland 0881 RPS Changes to the RUB West
Rezone the land shown in the Waimauku Structure Plan from Production Rural to Future
Residential [pages 5 to 9/10 of submission].
7079-1 Simon P Spiller p.spiller@xtra.co.nz RPS Mana Whenua B5 Strategic Delete any aspect of plan that confers a privilege on to a non-democratic body
7080-1 Penelope A Hammond pennyhammond@paradise.net.nz Residential zones Residential
General
7080-2 Penelope A Hammond pennyhammond@paradise.net.nz Special Character
7080-3 Penelope A Hammond pennyhammond@paradise.net.nz Zoning Central
House
7081-1
Thomas Richard and Company
Limited petesinton@townplanner.co.nz Zoning North and Islands Rezone 14-16 Brigham Creek Road, Whenuapai from Future Urban to Light Industrial.
534/1145
Sub#/
7082-1 Neil C Coombridge et al
25 Porritt Avenue, Chatswood,
Auckland 0626
SEAs
Land
Amend SEA over 25 Porritt Avenue, Birkenhead, to exclude areas inside pool fence lines with
a 2.5m fence maintenance strip outside and exclude areas to south east currently in lawn
(See Submission pages 5-10/10 for map and text detail)
7083-1 David I Heaney dh07@xtra.co.nz Built Environment (Overlays)
Height Control
Reduce the permitted height of buildings on the east side of Lake Road, Takapuna. [infer
Mixed Use zoned area between Blomfield Spa and Park Ave]
7084-1 Gayle H Wishart gaylewishart@yahoo.co.nz Residential zones Residential
General
7084-2 Gayle H Wishart gaylewishart@yahoo.co.nz Special Character
General
7084-3 Gayle H Wishart gaylewishart@yahoo.co.nz Zoning Central
House
7085-1 Roy and Nina Grant roy.g@xtra.co.nz Zoning North and Islands
Rezone the area of Mixed Use along Lake Rd, Takapuna [infer between Blomfield Spa and
Park Ave], to Mixed Use Urban. [infer Mixed Housing Urban].
7085-2 Roy and Nina Grant roy.g@xtra.co.nz Built Environment (Overlays)
Height Control
Reduce the 24.5m height limit along Lake Rd, Takapuna [infer between Blomfield Spa and
Park Ave].
7086-1
Clemows Orchard Society
Incorporated petesinton@townplanner.co.nz Public Open Space Zones
desc, obs & pols Create an esplanade reserve at 269 Rosedale Road, Albany.
7086-2
Rezone 269 Rosedale Road, Albany from School to Single House and Public Open Space -
Informal Recreation (to provide for an esplanade reserve).
7086-3
Rezone Clemows Orchard, Albany from Mixed Housing Suburban to Single House [refer to
submission map and listing of properties for details - pages 9/12 to 12/12].
7087-1 Femke Darke
140 Victoria Road, Devonport,
Reject the zoning of 4 storey apartment buildings on the vacant land at Wakakura Crescent,
Devonport
7088-1 Barbara Torrance
5A Lake Pupuke Drive, Takapuna,
Auckland 0622 Built Environment (Overlays)
Height Control
Reduce permitted height (6 storeys) on area around submitter's site at 5A Pupuke Drive,
Takapuna.
7089-1 Denise A Deakin andrew.denise@xtra.co.nz Residential zones Residential
General
7089-2 Denise A Deakin andrew.denise@xtra.co.nz Special Character
General
7089-3 Denise A Deakin andrew.denise@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central
House
7090-1 Carl and Joanne Price petesinton@townplanner.co.nz Zoning North and Islands Rezone 32 Broadwood Rise, Kumeu from Rural Production to Countryside Living.
7091-1 Wise Trust Board jaime.bright@harkness.co.nz Historic Heritage (Overlay)
Heritage
Places
Delete and replace the Green Hill Historic Heritage area with the Pre-1944 Building
Demolition Control overlay.
7091-2 Wise Trust Board jaime.bright@harkness.co.nz Residential zones Residential
Retain provisions that enable the provision of respite services on 119 Selwyn St, Onehunga
[Mixed Housing Urban zone]
7092-1
A C Gibbs and Liston Trustee
Services Limited (As Trustees
for the A C Molloy Family
Trust) b.gibbs@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central Rezone 34 May Rd, Mount Roskill, from Single House to Mixed Housing Suburban.
7092-2
Trust) b.gibbs@xtra.co.nz
control
Building demolition control J.3.6 Rules and mapping Remove the overlay from 34 May Rd, Mount Roskill.
7092-3
Trust) b.gibbs@xtra.co.nz Special Character
& C
Isthmus
Remove the overlay from 34 May Rd, Mount Roskill. [note - no special character overlay
seems to apply to the site]
7092-4
Trust) b.gibbs@xtra.co.nz RPS Natural resources B6.7 Natural hazards
Assess flooding matters at the resource consent stage rather than downzoning properties
based on flooding risk.
7093-1 Anna M Quirke anna.quirke@xtra.co.nz Residential zones Residential
General
7093-2 Anna M Quirke anna.quirke@xtra.co.nz Special Character
General
7093-3 Anna M Quirke anna.quirke@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central
House
535/1145
Sub#/
7094-1
Melanesian Mission Trust
Board c.covington@harrisongrierson.com Zoning Central Retain Local Centre zone - St Heliers.
7094-2
Board c.covington@harrisongrierson.com Precincts - Central Saint Heliers
Objectives & Policies Retain the objectives and policies.
7094-3
Board c.covington@harrisongrierson.com Precincts - Central Saint Heliers K2.19.Precinct Rules Retain activity table, development controls and assessment criteria.
7094-4
Board c.covington@harrisongrierson.com Precincts - Central Saint Heliers
A 11.2.1 : Appendix- St
Helliers Character Statement Retain the St Heliers Character Statement.
7094-5
Rezone 19 Pamela Place, and sites subject to a right of resumption (being 92, 94, 96, 98, 100
,102, 104, 106, 108, 110, 112, 114, 116, 118, 120, 122, 124 Allum Street and 280, 282 and
298 Kohimarama Road) from Single House to Mixed Housing Urban or Suburban
7094-6
& C
Isthmus
Remove Residential Isthmus B overlay from 19 Pamela Place, St Heliers, and sites subject to
a right of resumption (being 92, 94, 96, 98, 100 ,102, 104, 106, 108, 110, 112, 114, 116, 118,
120, 122, 124 Allum Street and 280, 282 and 298 Kohimarama Road, St Heliers)
7094-7
SEAs
Land
Remove SEA from 19 Pamela Place, St Heliers, and sites subject to a right of resumption
(being 92, 94, 96, 98, 100 ,102, 104, 106, 108, 110, 112, 114, 116, 118, 120, 122, 124 Allum
Street and 280, 282 and 298 Kohimarama Road, St Heliers)
7094-8
SEAs
Amend SEA rules for 19 Pamela Place, St Heliers, and sites subject to a right of resumption
(being 92, 94, 96, 98, 100 ,102, 104, 106, 108, 110, 112, 114, 116, 118, 120, 122, 124 Allum
Street and 280, 282 and 298 Kohimarama Road, St Heliers) to allow for subdivision and
additional building platform for each additional 600m2 of site area
7094-9
Board c.covington@harrisongrierson.com RPS
Provide for transferable development rights to compensate for the loss of development
potential brought by the SEA over 19 Pamela Place, St Heliers, and sites subject to a right of
resumption (being 92, 94, 96, 98, 100 ,102, 104, 106, 108, 110, 112, 114, 116, 118, 120, 122,
124 Allum Street and 280, 282 and 298 Kohimarama Road, St Heliers)
7094-10
Business
Remove Special Character Business - Eden Valley overlay from 114 and 116 Valley Road, Mt
Eden
7094-11
Board c.covington@harrisongrierson.com Zoning Central Rezone 114 and 116 Valley Road, Mt Eden from Single House to Local Centre
7094-12
Rezone 35-37, 39-41, 43, 59-63, 65-71 and 73-75 The Strand, Parnell, and sites marked in
red (See Submission Page 2/7 of Volume 3 for map image) from Light Industrial to Mixed Use
7094-13
Rezone 24 Melanesia Road, Kohimarama, and sites marked in blue (See Submission Page
7/7 of Volume 3) from Mixed Housing Suburban to Mixed Housing Urban
7095-1 P and K Edgeworth phil.edgeworth@gmail.com Natural Hazards and Flooding Flooding
and policies
Clarify the studies that have been carried out to establish the flood risk areas, particularly
around submitter's site at 83 Esperance Rd, Glendowie.
7095-2 P and K Edgeworth phil.edgeworth@gmail.com Natural Hazards and Flooding Flooding H4.12 Rules
Add minimum habitable floor levels as permitted activity standards, rather than requiring a
discretionary activity consent for development in flood risk areas.
7095-3 P and K Edgeworth phil.edgeworth@gmail.com General
GIS viewer Delete the the Flood Plain and Flood Prone overlays from 83 Esperance Road, Glendowie.
7096-1 Robert F Annandale
230 Annandale Road, RD2,
Henderson, Auckland 0782 Zoning North and Islands Rezone Kumeu from Rural Production to Mixed Rural or Countryside Living.
Henderson, Auckland 0782 Subdivision Auckland-wide - Rural zones
area
Apply Section 5 of the RMA, particularly economic well-being, to assess subdivision controls
for larger viable rural properties.
Henderson, Auckland 0782 Zoning North and Islands Rezone Southern Rodney to reflect its current fragmentation and allow alternative land uses.
area
Apply a subdivision restriction border much further from the RUB to where land use is mostly
economic farming [refers to Kumeu].
area
Apply Section 5 of the RMA to give greater weight to subdivision bush block provisions to use
more attractive incentives.
Henderson, Auckland 0782 RPS Rural B8 Strategic
Review Rodney Rural Policy statement, the District Objectives and the Zoning Rules to
accurately reflect existing and future land use particularly with regard to present and future
economic viability.
7097-1 David Dickinson d.dickinson@xtra.co.nz Residential zones Residential
General
7097-2 David Dickinson d.dickinson@xtra.co.nz Special Character
General
7097-3 David Dickinson d.dickinson@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central
House
536/1145
Sub#/
7098-1 David Madsen madsen@slingshot.co.nz RPS Urban growth
Increase intensification within 250m of Town Centres. Rezone sites further away than this as
Single House or Mixed Housing [not specified] zones.
7098-2 David Madsen madsen@slingshot.co.nz Zoning South
Rezone Pukekohe central area as identified in appendix to submission, particularly Edinburgh
St to Mixed Use and Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings. Amend height limit for this
Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings rezoning to 3 stories.
7098-3 David Madsen madsen@slingshot.co.nz Zoning South
Rezone housing within 500m of train stations, particularly in relation to Pukekohe to Terrace
Housing and Apartment Buildings. Refer to map attached to submission for rezoning around
Pukekohe train station.
7098-4 David Madsen madsen@slingshot.co.nz Transport Auckland -wide
requirements Delete car parking minimum controls from all zones
7098-5 David Madsen madsen@slingshot.co.nz
control
Amend the pre-1944 building demolition control to apply to buildings 100 years old. Delete the
blanket coverage of this control and undertaken an assessment on which buildings to be
given protection.
7098-6 David Madsen madsen@slingshot.co.nz Built Environment (Overlays)
Height Control Increase all town centre height limits to above what is proposed.
7098-7 David Madsen madsen@slingshot.co.nz Residential zones Residential
policies [Encourage] greater housing choices throughout city
7098-8 David Madsen madsen@slingshot.co.nz Sustainable Development C7.7/H6.4 Sustainable design Amend to require all developments to meet 6 star home-star rating
7098-9 David Madsen madsen@slingshot.co.nz Sustainable Development C7.7/H6.4 Sustainable design Amend to require all development to include solar hot water and solar PV systems
7098-10 David Madsen madsen@slingshot.co.nz Sustainable Development C7.7/H6.4 Sustainable design
Provide upgrades of solar systems for existing buildings, provide low interest funding, and
waive building consent costs for this type of development.
quality compact urban form Focus high density living and commerce on transport nodes, particularly the city rail link
environment
Make the urban design manual statutory and require all apartments and larger buildings to
undergo an urban design panel review process
7098-13 David Madsen madsen@slingshot.co.nz Residential zones Residential Land use controls
Delete density controls in the Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings and Mixed Use
zones.
7098-14 David Madsen madsen@slingshot.co.nz Residential zones Residential Land use controls Retain the conversion of one dwelling into two dwellings control [Rule 3.3]
7098-15 David Madsen madsen@slingshot.co.nz Residential zones Residential
General Delete or reduce front yard setback controls, particularly in intensive zones
7098-16 David Madsen madsen@slingshot.co.nz Residential zones Residential Land use controls
Delete density limit for four or more dwellings in the Mixed Housing Suburban zone [Rule
3.1(4)].
7098-17 David Madsen madsen@slingshot.co.nz RPS Changes to the RUB South
Provide greater level of detailed planning for the Pukekohe, Karaka and Drury areas [included
within the RUB]. Provide large areas within these greenfield areas for industry and
commercial development.
Upgrade transport infrastructure in the Pukekohe, Karaka and Drury greenfield areas prior to
development occurring.
7098-19 David Madsen madsen@slingshot.co.nz RPS Changes to the RUB South
Include the Karaka to Weymouth bridge in the plan as an alternative transport route, develop
all future transport projects to be multi-modal, and include pedestrian, bike and bus lanes over
the Weymouth to Karaka bridge, including potential for train tracks.
Develop Waiuku, Patumahoe, Glenbrook, Clarks Beach, Buckland, Bombay, Paerata, Karaka
and Ramarama before greenfield development between these areas occurs
Rezone towns to include more Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings before sprawl
occurs
Amend to ensure greenfield land is sufficiently planned prior to development and only release
when necessary. Delete provision to extend RUB
7099-1 Stuart S and Janet Diamond stujandiamond@gmail.com Mana Whenua
Whenua
and policies Delete E.5, Mana Whenua overlay.
7100-1 Chivalry Enterprises Limited david@davidwren.co.nz Zoning Central
Rezone the sites fronting the south side of College Hill, Freemans Bay, between Margaret St
and England St [as shown on map p 7/7], from Single House to Mixed Use.
7100-2 Chivalry Enterprises Limited david@davidwren.co.nz Special Character
& C
Isthmus
Retain the Isthmus A Special Character Area overlay over sites fronting the south side of
College Hill, Freemans Bay, between Margaret St and England St. [As shown on map p 7/7.
See also submission point 1.]
7100-3 Chivalry Enterprises Limited david@davidwren.co.nz Special Character
residential
Amend the Overlay description to make it clear that the Isthmus A overlay includes the Mixed
Use sites fronting the south side of College Hill, Freemans Bay, between Margaret St and
England St. [As shown on map p 7/7. See also submission point 1 and 2.] See submission
on p 5/7 for proposed changes.
7100-4 Chivalry Enterprises Limited david@davidwren.co.nz Residential zones Residential Activity Table
Add 'offices' as a Discretionary Activity in the Single House zone Activity Table, but only for
the sites fronting the south side of College Hill, Freemans Bay, between Margaret Street and
England Street. [As shown on the map on page 7/7 of the submission. See also submission
point 1.]
7101-1 Caroline Tibbits tibbits@xtra.co.nz General Miscellaneous Special housing areas Delete Huapai Triangle Special Housing Area.
537/1145
Sub#/
7101-2 Caroline Tibbits tibbits@xtra.co.nz RPS Changes to the RUB West Delete Future Urban zone in Kumeu to preserve the greenbelt.
7101-3 Caroline Tibbits tibbits@xtra.co.nz General Chapter A Introduction A3 Strategic Framework Acknowledge the 'Vision for Rodney' strategy published in July 2003 in the PAUP.
7102-1 Nigel C Tibbits tibbits@xtra.co.nz General Miscellaneous Special housing areas Delete Huapai Triangle Special Housing Area.
7102-2 Nigel C Tibbits tibbits@xtra.co.nz RPS Changes to the RUB West Delete Future Urban zone in Kumeu to preserve the greenbelt.
7102-3 Nigel C Tibbits tibbits@xtra.co.nz General Chapter A Introduction A3 Strategic Framework Acknowledge the 'Vision for Rodney' strategy published in July 2003 in the PAUP.
7103-1
3rd Fairway Development
Limited santabarbarahomes@xtra.co.nz Zoning North and Islands
Rezone 84 Laurel Oak Drive, Schnapper Rock, from Large Lot and Public Open Space -
Conservation, to Single House.
7103-2
Limited santabarbarahomes@xtra.co.nz Zoning North and Islands
Rezone 51 Appleby Rd, Albany, from Public Open Space - Sport and Active Recreation, to
Single House.
7103-3
Limited santabarbarahomes@xtra.co.nz Precincts - North Greenhithe Add 51 Appleby Rd, Albany, to Sub-precinct B.
7103-4
Limited santabarbarahomes@xtra.co.nz Precincts - North Greenhithe Add 84 Laurel Oak Drive, Schnapper Rock, to Sub-precinct B.
7103-5
Limited santabarbarahomes@xtra.co.nz Precincts - North Greenhithe
Amend the Precinct description to delete reference to the underlying Large Lot zone applying;
to delete reference to Sub-precinct A requiring lower densities than the Large Lot zone; and to
include reference to remedying and mitigating adverse effects. Refer to submission for
proposed changes [p 4/11]
7103-6
Amend the objectives to remove reference to the Large Lot zone; and to amend Objective 1
so that it manages rather than limits adverse effects. Refer to submission for proposed
changes [p 4/11]
7103-7
Amend the policies to remove reference to the Large Lot zone; and to amend policies 1, 3, 7
and 8 as shown in submission. [p 5/11]
7103-8
Limited santabarbarahomes@xtra.co.nz Precincts - North Greenhithe Retain the Activity Table as proposed.
7103-9
Limited santabarbarahomes@xtra.co.nz Precincts - North Greenhithe Delete Rule 2.1(1) about minimum site size in sub-precinct A.
7103-10
Delete Table 1 in 2.1(1) about minimum site size controls, and replace it with Table 9.1a of
rule 9.4.10.11.2 of the District Plan (North Shore section).
7103-11
Amend Rule 3(2) Assessment criteria so that the area is not required to retain rural character.
Refer to submission for proposed changes. [p 6/11]
7103-12
Limited santabarbarahomes@xtra.co.nz Earthworks H4.2.1.1 Activity table - Zones
Amend all earthworks activities associated with urban zoned land so that they are restricted
discretionary or discretionary activities when they exceed the permitted activity thresholds.
Delete all non-complying activity references.
7103-13
Limited santabarbarahomes@xtra.co.nz Earthworks
Overlays
Retain the specific rules for earthworks for network utilities and road networks where
associated with streams, riparian yards and SEAs.
7103-14
Limited santabarbarahomes@xtra.co.nz Earthworks H4.2.1.1 Activity table - Zones Retain the earthworks rules as proposed.
7103-15
Limited santabarbarahomes@xtra.co.nz
SEAs
table - Vegetation
roads Retain the activity table as proposed.
7103-16
Limited santabarbarahomes@xtra.co.nz
SEAs
overlays (except SEAs) Retain the activity table as proposed.
7103-17
Limited santabarbarahomes@xtra.co.nz Residential zones Residential
Amend Rule 4.3 'Yards' in the Large Lot zone, so that the controls are the same as those
applying to the Single House zone.
7103-18
Amend Rule 4.4 'Maximum impervious area' in the Large Lot zone, so that the controls are the
same as those applying to the Single House zone.
7103-19
Amend Rule 4.5 'Building coverage' in the Large Lot zone, so that the development are the
same as those applying to the Single House zone.
7103-20
Add new development controls to 4. Development controls for Large Lot zone, being the
height in relation to boundary, landscaping, outdoor living space, fences and garages
development controls that apply in the Single House zone.
7103-21
Limited santabarbarahomes@xtra.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - Urban zones H5.2 3.1 Residential zones Retain the provisions. [in H5 generally and subject to relief in submission]
7103-22
Limited santabarbarahomes@xtra.co.nz RPS Urban growth
retain affordable housing Delete provisions.
538/1145
Sub#/
7103-23
Limited santabarbarahomes@xtra.co.nz Residential zones Housing affordability
and policies Delete provisions.
7103-24
Limited santabarbarahomes@xtra.co.nz Residential zones Housing affordability H6.6 Rules Delete provisions.
7103-25
Limited santabarbarahomes@xtra.co.nz Sustainable Development C7.7/H6.4 Sustainable design Delete provisions.
7104-1 Gore Street Properties Limited deanne@mhg.co.nz City Centre Zone I4 Rules/Appendix 7.1- 7.3 Amend the definition of height to include average ground level as a means to calculate height.
7104-2 Gore Street Properties Limited deanne@mhg.co.nz General Cross plan matters Remove the maximum storey control in all zones and the floor to ceiling height minimums.
7104-3 Gore Street Properties Limited deanne@mhg.co.nz City Centre Zone I4 Rules/Appendix 7.1- 7.3
Amend to make demolition a permitted or controlled activity with general standards or matters
for control as detailed in the submission.
7104-4 Gore Street Properties Limited deanne@mhg.co.nz Precincts - City Centre Queen Street Valley
Amend to make demolition a permitted or controlled activity with general standards or matters
of control as detailed in the submission.
7104-5 Gore Street Properties Limited deanne@mhg.co.nz Historic Heritage (Overlay)
Heritage
Places
Amend to identify and schedule specific buildings within the Queen Street Valley Precinct for
protection, rather than applying a blanket protection.
7104-6 Gore Street Properties Limited deanne@mhg.co.nz City Centre Zone I4 Rules/Appendix 7.1- 7.3 Delete the requirement to provide a design statement.
7104-7 Gore Street Properties Limited deanne@mhg.co.nz Mana Whenua General provisions
assessment
Refine the circumstances under which a cultural impact assessment and engagement with iwi
may be required.
7104-8 Gore Street Properties Limited deanne@mhg.co.nz Sustainable Development C7.7/H6.4 Sustainable design
Building Challenge.
7104-9 Gore Street Properties Limited deanne@mhg.co.nz Residential zones Housing affordability H6.6 Rules Delete the requirements to provide for affordable housing.
7104-10 Gore Street Properties Limited deanne@mhg.co.nz City Centre Zone I4 Rules/Appendix 7.1- 7.3
Delete the requirements to provide a wind report for buildings higher than 20m where a
canopy is provided over public space.
7104-11 Gore Street Properties Limited deanne@mhg.co.nz General Cross plan matters
Amend to remove the provision that allows additional assessment criteria to be considered
beyond the specifically listed criteria.
7105-1
Pompallier Lawn Tennis Club
Incorporated manager.pompallier@vodafone.co.nz General Noise and vibration H6.2 Rules
Delete the rule [3.1 Recreational Noise] relating to restricting hours for floodlighting sporting
activities and engagement in organised outdoor recreational activities
7105-2
Pompallier Lawn Tennis Club
Incorporated manager.pompallier@vodafone.co.nz Public Open Space Zones Public Open Space
Retain the right to use floodlighting until 10.00pm, provided this is extended to established
venues in any zone
7106-1 John B Tomlinson
19A Stratford Avenue, Milford,
General
Amend height on the western side of Shakespeare Rd, Milford, between Stratford Ave and
Alma Rd, to reduce from three storeys to two.
7106-2 John B Tomlinson
19A Stratford Avenue, Milford,
Rezone the western side of Shakespeare Rd, Milford, between Stratford Ave and Alma Rd,
from Mixed Housing Urban to Mixed Housing Suburban.
7107-1 Bruce R Mawson mawsonbj@xtra.co.nz Residential zones Residential Land use controls
Amend Rule 3.1 'Maximum density', Table 1 for the Mixed Housing Suburban zone, so that
one house per 300m
2
is allowed in all cases. Refer to pages 2-3/3 of the submission
for details.
7108-1 Jeff Tobin
55 Nixon Road, Taupaki, Auckland
Rezone Taupaki from Mixed Rural and Rural Production to Countryside Living. Refer to
submission for details [pages 10/12 and 11/12].
7109-1
PACT Group (New Zealand)
Limited
c/- Russell McVeagh, PO Box 8,
Auckland 1140 Air Quality
and policies
Amend Policy 6 as follows: Manage reduced amenity in the Light Industry, Heavy Industry and
Quarry zones in the Unitary Plan and in the Commercial 6 zone, in the Hauraki Gulf Islands
section of the Auckland Council District Plan, to support the use and development of that
zone by...
7109-2
Limited
and policies
Delete Policy 21 or amend as follows: Give effect to the requirements of the National
Environmental Standard for Air Quality Regulation 17 and to comply with the AAAQS by
offsetting new discharges of PM
10
or PM
2.5
where required. particulate matter that require
consent and will discharge into the Auckland airshed. Offsets must: a.be required until the
Auckland airshed achieves five years without any breach of the AAAQS for PM10 or PM2.5
b.be for new activities or when emissions from existing consented activities increase c.be
calculated on an annual mass emission basis and be offset on a one-to-one annual mass
emission basis d.be done as close as practicable to where the effects of the discharge occur

7109-3
Limited
and policies
Delete the following from Table 1: Particles less than 2.5 microns (PM
2.5
) - 25 g/m
3
- 24 hour -
0
539/1145
Sub#/
7109-4
Limited
Auckland 1140 Earthworks
and policies
Amend Policy 2 as follows: Manage earthworks to: a. retain soil and sediment on the land,
and to minimise, as far as practical, the not discharge it of sediment to water bodies and
coastal water by use of best sediment and erosion control practices b. limit the amount of land
being disturbed at any one time, particularly where the soil type, typography and location is
likely to result in increased sediment runoff or discharge c. not create or exacerbate the risk
of natural hazards d. avoid, remedy or mitigate noise, vibration, odour and other amenity
effects, traffic and human health effects e. maintain...
7109-5
Limited
Auckland 1140
Centre)
desc, obs & pols
Amend the zone description as follows: This zone provides for light industrial activities that do
not are unlikely to generate objectionable odour, dust or noise emissions. This includes light
manufacturing, production, logistics, storage, transport and distribution activities...
7109-6
Limited
Auckland 1140
Centre)
desc, obs & pols
Amend Objective 1 as follows: Light i Industrial activities locate and function productively
within the zone.
7109-7
Limited
Auckland 1140
Centre)
desc, obs & pols
Amend Objective 4 as follows: Development avoids, remedies or mitigates adverse effects on
the amenity of adjacent public open spaces and residential zones.
7109-8
Limited
Auckland 1140
Centre)
desc, obs & pols Amend Policy 1 as follows: Enable a range of light industrial activities to locate in the zone.
7109-9
Limited
Auckland 1140
Centre)
desc, obs & pols
Amend Policy 2 as follows: Avoid Prevent activities that create reverse sensitivity effects and
constrain the the establishment and operation of light industrial activities.
7109-10
Limited
Auckland 1140
Centre)
desc, obs & pols
Amend Policy 4 as follows: Prevent Avoid : a.office activities, except where they are
accessory to the primary activity on-site b. residential activities other than for persons whose
duties require them to live on-site.
7109-11
Limited
Auckland 1140
Centre)
desc, obs & pols Retain objectives and policies
7109-12
Limited
Whenua
7109-13
Limited
Sensitive Activity Restriction Retain overlay.
7109-14
Limited
Sensitive Activity Restriction Amend the overlay so it applies to areas surrounding the Light Industry zone.
7109-15
Limited
Whenua
7109-16
Limited
Auckland 1140 Air Quality H4.1 Auckland wide rules
General controls
Amend the activity table by removing the Light Industry zone from the Air quality high amenity
area and inserting it into the Air quality reduced amenity area
7109-17
Limited
Amend so earthworks up to 1ha within Business zones is a permitted activity. Apply a
restricted discretionary activity status for earthworks that exceed 1ha and restrict matters of
discretion and assessment criteria to earthworks effects.
7109-18
Limited
Auckland 1140 Contaminated Land H4.5.1 Activity table
Retain the contaminated land provisions to the extent they accord with the [Air Land Water
Plan] rules
7109-19
Limited
Auckland 1140
Retain the managing hazardous substances provisions to the extent they accord with the [Air
Land Water Plan] rules
7109-20
Limited
Auckland 1140
(ITA)
(ITA) H4.8.1 Activity table
Retain the industrial and trade activities provisions to the extent they accord with the [Air Land
Water Plan] rules
7109-21
Limited
Auckland 1140 Water Stormwater
rules
Insert the following into the activity table as a restricted discretionary activity: Impervious
areas not otherwise provided for by the stormwater network, public road, ground soakage and
peat soil that do not meet the permitted activity controls
7109-22
Limited
rules
Amend the activity status of the diversion and discharge of stormwater from impervious areas
not otherwise authorised by stormwater discharge and diversion rules from discretionary to
7109-23
Limited
rules
Delete rule 1.2.1(1)(b) [Permitted Activities] as follows: b. the discharge must not result in, or
increase, flooding of other properties in events up to the 10 per cent AEP or the inundation of
buildings in events up to the 1 per cent AEP.
7109-24
Limited
rules
Amend assessment criteria 1.3(2)(2) as follows: 'New impervious areas where the
development has been subject to structure or framework planning that includes integrated
land use and stormwater planning a. Whether stormwater management is... b. The extent to
which the structure or framework plan and associated plan change or resource consent has
achieved integrated and effective stormwater management across the proposed development
area and in particular: i. adopts water sensitive design and green infrastructure; ii.
minimises...'
7109-25
Limited
Auckland 1140 Water Stormwater H4.14 Introduction
Amend the Introduction by deleting the paragraphs on stormwater management flow and
stormwater management quality rules
540/1145
Sub#/
7109-26
Limited
H4.14.2 Stormwater
management -flow rules Delete the stormwater management flow section and all cross references to this section
7109-27
Limited
rules Delete the stormwater management quality section and all cross references to this section
7109-28
Limited
Auckland 1140 Sustainable Development C7.7/H6.4 Sustainable design Delete the sustainable development rules
7109-29
Limited
Auckland 1140
Centre) Business
Amend activity table as follows: Offices that are accessory to an industrial activity on the site
and: a. the office GFA does not exceed 5030 per cent of all buildings on the site or b. the
office GFA does not exceed 500100 m
7109-30
Limited
Auckland 1140
Centre) Business
Insert the following into the activity table as a permitted activity in the Heavy and Light
Industry zones: Offices not accessory to an industrial activity on the site up to 500m
2
GFA
7109-31
Limited
Auckland 1140
Add Rule 2 (1)(c) as follows: 'The council will publicly notify resource consent applications for
the following activities: a. ... c. activities sensitive to noise of air discharges or dust located
within 50 metres of a Light Industry or Heavy Industry zones.
7109-32
Limited
Auckland 1140
Centre) Business
zones Delete the maximum impervious area control [rule 5.3]
7109-33
Limited
Auckland 1140
Centre) Business
zones Delete the front yard control [rule 5.4]
7109-34
Limited
Rezone 469 Rosebank Rd, Avondale from Light Industry to Heavy Industry or alternatively
rezone 469 Rosebank Rd and surrounding sites be rezoned to Heavy Industry to adjoin the
existing Heavy Industry zoning to the northwest of this location
7109-35
Limited
Rezone 589 Rosebank Rd, Avondale from Heavy Industry and Light Industry to solely Heavy
Industry. Alternatively rezone 589 Rosebank Rd and surrounding properties to Heavy Industry
to adjoin the heavy Industry zoning to the northwest of this location
7109-36
Limited
Retain the Heavy Industry zoning of 100 Harris Rd, East Tamaki. Alternatively rezone 100
Harris Rd and the surrounding sites bounded by Harris Rd, Neales Rd, Carpenter Rd and
Stonedon Dr, East Tamaki to Light Industry subject to the amendments to this zone requested
by the submitter
7109-37
Limited
Rezone 19 and 25 Maurice Rd, Penrose from Light Industry to Heavy Industry. Alternatively
rezone 19 and 25 Maurice Rd, and surrounding sites bounded by Mays Rd, Maurice Rd,
Church St and the railway line, Penrose to Heavy Industry
7109-38
Limited
Auckland 1140 Zoning North and Islands Retain Light Industry zoning of 1-3 Unity Drive, Albany
7109-39
Limited
Auckland 1140 Zoning North and Islands Retain the Light Industry zoning of 13-15 Rothwell Ave, Albany
7109-40
Limited
Auckland 1140 Zoning West Retain the Light Industry zoning of 19-25 Keeling Rd, Henderson
7109-41
Limited
Auckland 1140 Zoning West Retain the Light Industry zoning of Unit F1 29 Keeling Rd, Henderson
7109-42
Limited
Retain the Heavy Industry zoning of 43 Cryers Rd, 63 Neales Rd and 29 Carpenter Rd, East
Tamaki
7109-43
Limited
Whenua
of value to Mana Whenua Delete overlay as it applies to Cryers and Neales Rd, East Tamaki.
7109-44
Limited
Auckland 1140 Zoning Central Retain the Light Industry zoning of 8-10 Vestey Drive, Mount Wellington
7110-1 Eric M Livingstone
PO Box 104106, Lincoln North,
Rezone Taupaki from Mixed Rural and Rural Production to Countryside Living. Refer to
7111-1 Judy Lyon
15 Trafalgar Road, Milford, Auckland
General Amend the minimum size for dwellings from 40m2 to 50m2.
7111-2 Judy Lyon
15 Trafalgar Road, Milford, Auckland
Height Control Reduce the maximum height in Milford Town centre to 8 storeys.
7112-1
Graeme Malcolm and Suzanne
Craw
105 Nixon Road, RD2, Henderson,
Rezone Taupaki from Mixed Rural and Rural Production to Countryside Living Refer to
7113-1 Brendon Blue b.blue@auckland.ac.nz Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
Delete parking minimum controls for the Mixed Housing Urban and Mixed Housing Suburban
zones [Rule 3.2(table 4)], and for tavern activities [Rule 3.2(table 3)]
7113-2 Brendon Blue b.blue@auckland.ac.nz Residential zones Residential Land use controls
Delete the density limits for four or more dwellings in the Mixed Housing Suburban zone [Rule
3.1(5)]
7113-3 Brendon Blue b.blue@auckland.ac.nz Residential zones Residential
General Delete or reduce the front yard setback control [Rules 4.3, 5.4, 6.4, 7.5, 8.6 and 9.3]
541/1145
Sub#/
7113-4 Brendon Blue b.blue@auckland.ac.nz RPS Urban growth
environment
Improve quality design regulations, particularly in relation to visual amenity, street frontage
and energy efficiency
7114-1
Roger E and Barbara A
Stevens barbandrog@vodafone.co.nz Built Environment (Overlays)
Height Control Reduce height of proposed buildings in the area around Auburn St, Takapuna.
7114-2
Roger E and Barbara A
Stevens barbandrog@vodafone.co.nz Residential zones Residential
General Amend the minimum size for dwellings from 40m2 to 50m2.
7115-1 Mirjana Sumich sumich@xtra.co.nz Zoning West
Rezone the area between Waitaki Street, Manhatten Heights Fairbank Place and Milwaukee
Place, Glendene, from Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings to a less intensive zone.
7116-1 Pei-Ying Chen joe.planning@gmail.com RPS Changes to the RUB West Rezone 29 Red Hills Massey from Future Urban to Mixed Housing Suburban
7117-1 Dave Hurley hurley@ihug.co.nz General Miscellaneous Consultation and engagement Reject the lack of consultation undertaken for the PAUP in the Kumeu area.
7117-2 Dave Hurley hurley@ihug.co.nz RPS Changes to the RUB West Reject proposed large expansion of the Kumeu/Huapai area.
7117-3 Dave Hurley hurley@ihug.co.nz General Chapter G General provisions G2.4 Notification
Amend notification provisions in the PAUP to strengthen residents rights and ensure all major
consent applications are notified, particularly for landfills.
7117-4 Dave Hurley hurley@ihug.co.nz Zoning North and Islands
Rezone the Future Urban zone within the 'Triangle Area' bounded by Station Road, Access
Road and State Highway 16 to the final zoning [Inference - Huapai Triangle Special Housing
Area and for the zoning to be residential].
7117-5 Dave Hurley hurley@ihug.co.nz General Miscellaneous Other
Delete no complaints subdivision covenants in the 'Triangle Area', the south side of Access
Road and including Farrand Road, Huapai/Kumeu and 116 Access Road, Kumeu.
7117-6 Dave Hurley hurley@ihug.co.nz
managed fill
Reject the proliferation of cleanfill sites, both permitted and non-permitted, within the rural
area surrounding Kumeu, Huapai, Taupaki, Waimauku and Riverhead. [C5.5 Background,
objectives and policies]
7117-7 Dave Hurley hurley@ihug.co.nz General Noise and vibration H6.2 Rules
Amend noise levels in areas adjacent to industrial areas to less than 65dB and even lower at
night. [Rule 1.2 Noise arising from activities with zones]
7117-8 Dave Hurley hurley@ihug.co.nz Designations
Agency
6766 State Highway 16 -
Hobsonville to Wellsford
Amend designation 6766 through Kumeu to have a central median to allow traffic to turn right
to access existing commercial properties.
7117-9 Dave Hurley hurley@ihug.co.nz Zoning North and Islands
Rezone established buffer zone from Access Road to Nobilo Road, Kumeu between 116
Access Road and the future urban land from Future Urban to Buffer zone [Buffer zone relates
to legacy plan].
7118-1 Brookby Quarries Limited david@osbornehay.co.nz Zoning South
Amend the zoning around the Brookby Quarry, Kimptons Road, Brookby, so that the extent of
the Quarry zone is increased. For details see map on p 17/17 of submission.
7118-2 Brookby Quarries Limited david@osbornehay.co.nz Mineral extraction
Buffer Area
Amend the Quarry buffer area around the Brookby Quarry, Kimptons Road, Brookby, to
extend the buffer area, as shown on p 17/17 of submission.
Transport Route Retain the overlay as it applies to routes to the Brookby Quarry, Kimptons Rd, Brookby.
7118-4 Brookby Quarries Limited david@osbornehay.co.nz Water
streams & wetland
table
Delete the length of indicative stream within the site at Brookby Quarry, Kimptons Road,
Brookby, as it no longer exists.
7118-5 Brookby Quarries Limited david@osbornehay.co.nz
SEAs
Land
Remove the overlay as it applies to land to be zoned as Quarry, on the Brookby Quarry,
Kimptons Road, Brookby.
streams & wetland
Management Area
Delete the overlay as it applies to land to be zoned as Quarry, on the Brookby Quarry,
Kimptons Road, Brookby.
7118-7 Brookby Quarries Limited david@osbornehay.co.nz Definitions Existing
Amend 'Mineral extraction [activities]', final bullet point, as follows; '...accessory activities uses
'.
7118-8 Brookby Quarries Limited david@osbornehay.co.nz Definitions Existing
Delete and replace 'cleanfill material' so that the definition used is the same as that in the
Ministry for the Environment 'The Guide to Managing Cleanfills'. See submission on p 6/17 for
proposed text.
7118-9 Brookby Quarries Limited david@osbornehay.co.nz RPS Issues
wellbeing Retain the section on minerals.
7118-10 Brookby Quarries Limited david@osbornehay.co.nz RPS
features
Amend Policy 4 as follows; '4. Provide for appropriate rural production activities (including
mineral extraction) and related production structures as part of the working rural and coastal
landscape.'.
7118-11 Brookby Quarries Limited david@osbornehay.co.nz RPS
Amend Policy 9 about reasonable use and enjoyment of land, by adding new (f) as follows; ' f.
undertaking of mineral extraction activities within a Quarry zone. '.
7118-12 Brookby Quarries Limited david@osbornehay.co.nz RPS Natural resources B6.2 Minerals Retain the objectives and policies.
7118-13 Brookby Quarries Limited david@osbornehay.co.nz RPS Natural resources B6.2 Minerals
Add new policy as follows; 'Provide opportunities for industry using the products of mineral
extraction to locate on or near the site of mineral extraction activity. '.
and policies
Amend Background, paragraph 2, as follows; 'Mineral extraction operations or quarries in
Auckland can be divided into three typesthe first is large-scale operations serving the whole
of Auckland. Examples of these are the quarries in the Hunua Ranges and at Drury and
Brookby Quarry. '.
542/1145
Sub#/
and policies
Amend Objective 1 as follows; '1. Mineral extraction from the land occurs in a way that meets
industry and users' needs Auckland's requirements while environmental and amenity values
are protected adverse effects on the environment are avoided, remedied or mitigated to an
appropriate level which allows for the efficient extraction and delivery of the mineral resource.
'.
and policies
Amend Policy 2 as follows; '2. Significant adverse effects associated with mineral extraction
activities must be remedied or mitigated as far as technically and economically practicable.'
and policies
Amend Policy 5 as follows; '5. Locate buildings and structures associated with mineral
extraction activities appropriately, in relation to the site boundaries, and be of an appropriate
scale for a rural industry .'
and policies
Amend Policy 6 about avoiding quasi-industrial zones near quarries, to enable in these
locations some industrial activities that rely on minerals as a principal raw material. See
submission on p 8/17 for proposed changes.
managed fill
Amend Objective 1 as follows; '1. Cleanfills, managed fills and landfills are located, designed
and operated in accordance with best management practices in a way that does not adversely
affect the environment, including water and the CMA avoids, remedies or mitigates to an
appropriate level adverse effects on the environment.'.
managed fill
managed fill C5.5/G2.7.7/H4.4 Delete Objective 2 about cleanfills being compatible with neighbourhood amenity values.
managed fill
Amend Policy 1 about where cleanfills should be located, by adding 'where practicable' to
some of the the sub-clauses. See submission on p 9/17 for proposed changes.
7118-22 Brookby Quarries Limited david@osbornehay.co.nz General Noise and vibration
and policies
Amend Objective 1 as follows; '1.People are protected from unreasonable or unnecessary
levels of noise. '.
and policies
Amend the objectives and policies by removing the word 'unnecessary' where it appears in
these provisions.
and policies
Amend Objective 4 as follows; '4.The strategic importance of transportation routes (including
Quarry Transport Routes) and significant infrastructure is recognised and protected from the
potential reverse sensitivity effects of activities sensitive to noise.'.
and policies
Amend Objective 8 as follows; '8. The amenity of dwellings in rural areas is protected from
unreasonable or unnecessary noise, recognising that farming and other activities rural based
activities (including quarrying and transportation) may create high levels of noise. '.
and policies
Amend Policy 9 as follows '9. Manage the adverse effects of noise in the rural environment to
an practical and reasonable level, recognising that many activities (including transportation)
within a rural zone generate noise and a lower level of noise amenity could be expected
compared to a public open space or residential zone, while recognising the working nature of
this environment . '.
7118-27 Brookby Quarries Limited david@osbornehay.co.nz Mineral extraction Quarry zone
and policies
Delete and replace Objective 1 as follows; '1. The efficient extraction of regionally significant
mineral resources and accessory activities to support extraction can occur. The Quarry zone
shall provide for the efficient extraction, processing and transportation of regionally significant
minerals, and associated activities. '.
and policies
Delete and replace Objective 2 as follows; '2. The adverse effects associated with mineral
extraction are minimised. To provide for, and manage, the effects associated with the
extraction of minerals from land and their transportation to the market, to an appropriate
level. '.
and policies
Delete and replace Policy 2 as follows; '2. Enable compatible land uses within or next to the
zone, including mineral recycling activities. By providing for a limited range of industrial
activities within Quarry Zones where these rely on minerals as a principal raw material or
involve mineral recycling. '.
and policies
Amend Policy 5 as follows; '5. Manage noise and vibration to protect existing adjacent
activities sensitive to noise or vibration from unreasonable or unnecessary levels of noise and
vibration. '.
Buffer Area Retain the objectives and policies.
Transport Route Retain objectives and policies except for Policy 2.
Transport Route Delete Policy 2 about managing traffic to and from the quarry zone.
7118-34 Brookby Quarries Limited david@osbornehay.co.nz General Chapter G General provisions
Amend 1.4 Applying for a resource consent under 'Making a resource consent application',
paragraph 3, about bundling activities together and applying the most restrictive activity
status, so that regional and district plan consents are considered separately.
7118-35 Brookby Quarries Limited david@osbornehay.co.nz Infrastructure
Energy H1.1 Activity table 1.2 - Roads Amend Activity Table to add 'The transportation of people and goods' as a permitted activity.
7118-36 Brookby Quarries Limited david@osbornehay.co.nz Earthworks H4.2.1.1 Activity table - Zones Delete reference to earthworks in the Quarry zone from this chapter.
543/1145
Sub#/
SEAs
Land Remove SEA overlays from any areas of Quarry zone.
7118-38 Brookby Quarries Limited david@osbornehay.co.nz Earthworks H4.2.2 Controls
Delete 2.2.1(10) General controls for permitted activities, about locating earthworks at least
20m from historic heritage places or scheduled sites and places of significance to Mana
Whenua.
7118-39 Brookby Quarries Limited david@osbornehay.co.nz Earthworks H4.2.2 Controls
Delete 2.2.1(16) General controls for permitted activities, about preventing the spread of Kauri
Dieback disease by adopting vehicle and equipment hygiene techniques.
7118-40 Brookby Quarries Limited david@osbornehay.co.nz Earthworks H4.2.3 Assessment
Delete 3.1(1)(p) Matters of discretion for restricted discretionary activities, about landscape
treatment, screening and site layout and design.
SEAs
table - Vegetation
roads Clarify that the Rural area used in the activity table excludes Quarry zoned land.
SEAs
table - Vegetation
roads
Delete last line in Activity Table under 'Riparian', which reads 'Vegetation alteration or
removal within 10m of rural streams in the Rural Production and Mixed Rural zones' .
SEAs
table - Vegetation
roads
Amend Activity Table under Riparian, so that 'Vegetation alteration or removal within 10m of
rural streams in the Rural Production and Mixed Rural zones' only relates to the removal of
native vegetation which forms part of a contiguous area of native vegetation over 3000m2.
SEAs
Assessment
Delete 2.3 Controls for 'Vegetation alteration or removal for routine operation, maintenance
and repair of existing tracks, lawns, gardens, fences and other lawfully established activities',
which restricts areas of vegetation removal in a calendar year.
streams & wetland
table
Amend the Activity Table to add another row for 'Diversion of a river or stream to a new
course and any disturbance and associated sediment discharge' in the Quarry zone, with an
activity status of restricted discretionary in both columns.
streams & wetland
table
Amend the Activity Table to add another row for 'Extension of an existing reclamation or
drained area' in the Quarry zone, with an activity status of restricted discretionary in both
columns.
streams & wetland
table
Amend the Activity Table to add another row for 'New reclamation or drainage' in the Quarry
zone, with an activity status of restricted discretionary in both columns.
7118-48 Brookby Quarries Limited david@osbornehay.co.nz Sustainable Development C7.7/H6.4 Sustainable design Delete Rule 2.3 Industrial activities.
Information Requirements Retain Activity table.
Amend 2.2(1)(a) Vibration and blasting (mineral extraction activities) as follows; '1. The
measurement of blast noise (air blast) and ground vibration for blasting must be: a. measured
at a notional boundary from a dwelling that existed at 1 January 2001 September 2013. '.
Amend 2.2(1)(b) Vibration and blasting (mineral extraction activities) as follows; '2. All blasting
is restricted to: a. 9am-5pm, Monday to Saturday b. an average of two occasions over a
calendar fortnight per day. '.
Amend 2.2(4) Vibration and blasting (mineral extraction activities) as follows; '4. A siren must
be used prior to blasting to alert people in the vicinity. '.
Amend 4.2(1)(a)(i) Assessment criteria for controlled activities as follows; '1.Mineral extraction
activities a.Traffic and access i.The expected traffic generated by the activity should not
significantly adversely affect the safe and efficient functioning of the immediate surrounding
road network. '.
Buffer Area Retain the provisions, except for 2(1) Notification.
Buffer Area
Amend 2(1) Notification, to make it clear that the quarry owner and operator are affected
parties when development occurs in the buffer area. See submission p 14/17 for proposed
changes.
Transport Route Retain the provisions, except for 1(1) Notification.
Transport Route
Amend 1(1) Notification, to make it clear that the quarry owner and operator are affected
parties when development occurs in the overlay area. See submission p 15/17 for proposed
changes.
SEAs
table - Vegetation
roads
Amend Activity Table so that the removal of existing vegetation to allow for re-planting of
riparian strips is a permitted activity in all areas. [p 12/17]
544/1145
Sub#/
SEAs
7119-1 Maureen M Franklin-Pascoe josieshouse@gmail.com RPS Mana Whenua B5 Strategic Delete all mana whenua provisions that require consultation with iwi.
7120-1 Philip Holden phil.holden@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central
Rezone Point Chevalier from Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings and Mixed Housing
Urban to Single House.
7120-2 Philip Holden phil.holden@xtra.co.nz Historic Heritage (Overlay)
Heritage
Places
Apply objective 1 and policy 2 to Point Chevalier rather than the pre-1944 building demolition
control overlay to protect its historic and heritage value.
7120-3 Philip Holden phil.holden@xtra.co.nz Residential zones Residential
policies
Amend Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings and Mixed Housing Urban zones to not
locate next to lesser zones or adjacent to an existing underdeveloped site with a Single House
zoning. They should only take place adjacent to Neighbourhood Centres, Town Centres and
wide streets.
General
Require all development in Terraced Housing and Apartment Buildings and Mixed Housing
Urban zones to be notified and assessed by a skilled Council design panel.
General
Amend Rules 8.1 and 9.1 'Development control infringements' to be a Discretionary Activity if
one development control is infringed, not three.
General
Require all development planned for Point Chevalier to consider appropriate infrastructure
and the effects on residents and the environment.
7120-7 Philip Holden phil.holden@xtra.co.nz General Cross plan matters
Amend PAUP to consider the effects on the area/suburb instead of applying rules on a city-
wide basis.
7120-8 Philip Holden phil.holden@xtra.co.nz General Miscellaneous Consultation and engagement
Provide specific and easily understood information on the PAUP to every affected property
owner covering their specific property.
7120-9 Philip Holden phil.holden@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central
Delete Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings and Mixed House Urban zones from Point
Chevalier, in particular the block between Great North Road and Tui St, Point Chevalier
7121-1 Spinnaker Bay Limited david@osbornehay.co.nz Zoning South Retain underlying zoning of Kelly's Cove precinct, Beachlands, as Single House.
7121-2 Spinnaker Bay Limited david@osbornehay.co.nz Precincts - South Kelly's Cove Change the precinct name to 'Spinnaker Bay'.
7121-3 Spinnaker Bay Limited david@osbornehay.co.nz RPS Changes to the RUB South
Rezone area south of Maraetai School Rd and south and west of Carlton Crescent, Maraetai,
from Mixed Rural and Rural Coastal, to Future Urban zone. See map on p 13/13 of
7121-4 Spinnaker Bay Limited david@osbornehay.co.nz Zoning South
Rezone area south of Maraetai School Rd, Maraetai, (and in particular lots Part Te
Ruangaingai 2 Block, Lot 2 DP 211627 and Part Waihohonu) from Mixed Rural, to
Countryside Living. See map on p 13/13 of submission for details. [see also submission point
3]
7121-5 Spinnaker Bay Limited david@osbornehay.co.nz Mana Whenua
Whenua
Delete overlay ID 2952, which is located on sites along Weatherly Drive and Liberty Crescent,
Beachlands.
7121-6 Spinnaker Bay Limited david@osbornehay.co.nz Precincts - South Kelly's Cove
Delete and replace the Precinct Description to provide a more accurate description of what
has occurred to date and what is proposed for the remaining stages of development. Refer to
submission on p 6/13 for proposed changes.
Amend Objective 1 [in F6.10] as follows; '1. The Subdivision design protects and
addresses enhances the natural environment and responds to established development
patterns of the broader area and the coast . '.
Amend Policy 1 [in F6.10] as follows; '1. Protect and enhance the open gully system and
natural ecosystems which have been developed to date. '.
Amend Policy 2(c)-(d) [in F6.10] as follows; 2. Design and locate subdivision and
development using a road pattern which:...c. reflects the rectilinear road pattern of the existing
Beachlands Village with all connecting roads running north-south to obtain views of the
coastal reserve roading plan shown on the Precinct Plan d. adjoins coastal public open
spaces and is designed to utilise the amenity of coastal views as well as providing public
access to the existing reserves. '.
7121-10 Spinnaker Bay Limited david@osbornehay.co.nz Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
Amend 3.1(iii) Traffic Generation, as follows; 'iii.this rule does not apply in the City Centre,
Metropolitan Centre, Town Centre or Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings zones
Spinnaker Bay Precinct, Light and Heavy Industry and Marina Zones'.
7121-11 Spinnaker Bay Limited david@osbornehay.co.nz Earthworks H4.2.2 Controls
Whenua.
7121-12 Spinnaker Bay Limited david@osbornehay.co.nz Earthworks H4.2.2 Controls
7121-13 Spinnaker Bay Limited david@osbornehay.co.nz Earthworks H4.2.3 Assessment
545/1145
Sub#/
7121-14 Spinnaker Bay Limited david@osbornehay.co.nz Water Stormwater H4.14 Introduction
Amend Introduction, second paragraph under 'Stormwater diversion and discharge rules', as
follows; To avoid doubt, stormwater from a private site directed to any part of the Auckland
consent (where any such consent is held).
7121-15 Spinnaker Bay Limited david@osbornehay.co.nz Sustainable Development C7.7/H6.4 Sustainable design Delete Rule 2.1 Dwellings.
7121-16 Spinnaker Bay Limited david@osbornehay.co.nz Residential zones Residential
and Coastal Settlement zone Delete Rule 6.12 'Universal access' in the Single House zone.
7121-17 Spinnaker Bay Limited david@osbornehay.co.nz Precincts - South Kelly's Cove Retain the precinct subject to proposed changes elsewhere in the submission.
Amend subdivision control 4.2 Maximum density as follows; '4.2 Maximum density 1. The
minimum site size for subdivision is 700m2 400m2 net site area. 2. The number of dwellings
within the precinct must not exceed 420 480. '.
7121-19 Spinnaker Bay Limited david@osbornehay.co.nz Precincts - South Kelly's Cove Add new 4.5 Front Yard control so that the minimum front yard is 3m [under K6.10.4].
7121-20 Spinnaker Bay Limited david@osbornehay.co.nz Precincts - South Kelly's Cove Add new 4.6 Height to Boundary control so that there is no applicable control [under K6.10.4].
Add new 4.7 Building coverage control so that the Maximum Building coverage is 45% [under
K6.10.4].
Add new 4.8 Landscaping control as follows; ' Landscaping within individual lots in Stages 7
and 8 is to be in accordance with an approved Spinnaker Bay Design Guidelines' [under
K6.10.4].
Add new 4.9 Fences control, as follows; ' All front fences within individual lots in Stages 7 and
8 are to be in accordance with an approved Spinnaker Bay Design Guideline.' [under
K6.10.4].
7121-24 Spinnaker Bay Limited david@osbornehay.co.nz Precincts - South Kelly's Cove Add additional development controls based on the Stages 7 and 8 design process.
Delete and replace assessment criteria 5.2(1)(b)(iii) about the internal road pattern within the
precinct, so that it reads; ' iii The internal roading pattern shall generally be in accordance with
the Spinnaker Bay Precinct Plan (Figure 1). ' [under K6.10.5].
Delete the existing 'Precinct Plan 1 - Kelly's Cove precinct' in K6.10.6, and replace it with the
updated precinct plan shown on p 11/13 of submission.
7122-1 Nicola McGrath nicola-mcgrath@hotmail.com Special Character
& C
Isthmus Apply a Special Character Residential Isthmus B type overlay to include Hill Park, Manurewa
7123-1 Lennart Nout lennartnout@gmail.com Transport Auckland -wide
requirements Delete minimum parking requirements.
7123-2 Lennart Nout lennartnout@gmail.com Zoning Central Rezone for more Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings zone on the Isthmus.
7123-3 Lennart Nout lennartnout@gmail.com Zoning North and Islands Rezone for more Terrace Housing and Apartment Building zone around Takapuna.
7124-1
The Marion Ross Memorial
Trust Board david@osbornehay.co.nz RPS Issues
growth
Amend first paragraph under 'Unitary Plan issue' as follows; Our growing population increases
demand for housing, employment, business, infrastructure, community facilities and services.
This means we must manage our growth in a way that: enhances quality of life for
individuals and communities optimises the efficient use of our existing urban area
optimises the efficient use of existing and new infrastructure, particularly significant
infrastructure Optimises the efficient use of existing community facilities and provides for
new community facilities ...'.
7124-2
Trust Board david@osbornehay.co.nz RPS Issues
growth
Amend paragraph 4 under 'Social-Wellbeing' as follows; 'Social and community infrastructure
relates to public and private facilities and networks, which provide for Aucklanders quality of
life and socio-economic outcomes. Social and community infrastructure is an important asset
to society as it provides:.... Places to worship Places for cultural activities .'.
7124-3
Trust Board david@osbornehay.co.nz RPS Urban growth B2.7 Social infrastructure
Amend paragraph 2 under 'Introduction' as follows; Social infrastructure is an important asset
to society as it provides:... Places to worship Places for cultural activities. '.
7124-4
Amend Objective 1 as follows; '1. An high quality economically and socially
sustainable network of social infrastructure that meets Aucklanders needs both locally and
regionally. '.
7124-5
Amend Objective 2 as follows; '2. Social infrastructure is located where it is accessible by a
range of transport modes where practicable. '.
7124-6
Amend Policy 1(a) as follows; 1. Make social infrastructure accessible to users by providing
for: a. local small-scale social infrastructure so they are accessible and affordable to local
communities e.g. medical centres, places of worship, care centres, primary schools,
community halls and cultural facilities '.
546/1145
Sub#/
7124-7
Amend Policy 1(c) as follows; 1. Make social infrastructure accessible to users by providing
for: 'c. larger-scale land extensive social infrastructure e.g. hospitals, universities, large
community churches, marae and large cultural facilities and secondary schools in locations
where the existing and/or proposed roading network has sufficient capacity, and, where
practicable, in close proximity to the public transport network and the walking and cycling
networks. '.
7124-8
Amend Policy 2(d) as follows; 2. Provide Auckland with sufficient social infrastructure to meet
the needs of its growing population by: d. identifying new growth areas well in advance of
their development so that forward planning of the provision of social infrastructure can occur
via tools such as land acquisition, resource consents, structure planning and designations to
secure sites for future social infrastructure. '.
7124-9
Amend Policy 5 as follows; '5. Manage the transport effects of large scale social infrastructure
to an appropriate level and in an integrated manner. '.
7124-10
Delete Policy 6(b) as follows; '6. Require social infrastructure to:... b. be sympathetic to the
character, both existing and future, of the area and community in which it is located'.
7124-11
Amend Policy 6(c) as follows; '6. Require social infrastructure to:... c. Where appropriate and
economically viable incorporates the principles of sustainable building design '.
7124-12
Amend Policy 6(d) as follows; '6. Require social infrastructure to:... d. maintain or improve the
amenity of any adjoining streets and sites. '.
7124-13
Trust Board david@osbornehay.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - general
and policies
Add new rural subdivision policy as follows; 'To provide for subdivision of rural sites which is
required in order to provide for or to support additional open space and/or community,
educational or recreational facilities. '.
7124-14
Trust Board david@osbornehay.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - general
and policies
Amend Policy 36 about protection of SEAs and other areas, so that it reads less like a rule
and provides matters to be considered when protecting these areas. Refer to submission on p
6/14 for proposed changes.
7124-15
Trust Board david@osbornehay.co.nz Rural Zones General
Amend Objective 5 under '6.1.3 Rural industries, services and non-residential activities', as
follows; '5. Industries, services and non-residential activities of an urban type and scale
unrelated to rural production activities are directed away from rural zones unless they meet in
part the social and/or cultural requirements of the wider community. '.
7124-16
Trust Board david@osbornehay.co.nz Rural Zones General
Amend Policy 3(c) under '6.1.3 Rural industries, services and non-residential activities', as
follows; '3.Enable non-residential activities in rural areas where they have a clear and genuine
connection with the resources, amenities, characteristics and communities of the areas, with a
focus on:...c. outdoor education centres, outdoor recreation and pursuits, nature, rural and
wilderness experiences, and relaxation activities '.
7124-17
Trust Board david@osbornehay.co.nz Earthworks
Overlays
Amend Activity Table so that Earthworks in the SEA overlay in the Rural zone are a permitted
activity up to 500m
2
and 500m
3
.
7124-18
Trust Board david@osbornehay.co.nz Earthworks H4.2.2 Controls
7124-19
Trust Board david@osbornehay.co.nz Earthworks H4.2.3 Assessment
7124-20
Trust Board david@osbornehay.co.nz
SEAs
table - Vegetation
roads
Amend Activity Table under Rural, to delete the two rows and replace them with the following
text; 'Vegetation alteration or removal, including cumulative removal on a site over a 10-year
period, of more than 250m2 of native vegetation (with an average height of over 2m) that: a. is
contiguous vegetation b. is outside the rural urban boundary c. is within the Rural
Conservation zone '.
7124-21
SEAs
table - Vegetation
roads
Delete last line in Activity Table under 'Riparian', which reads 'Vegetation alteration or
removal within 10m of rural streams in the Rural Production and Mixed Rural zones' .
7124-22
SEAs
table - Vegetation
roads
Amend last line in Activity Table under 'Riparian', which reads 'Vegetation alteration or
removal within 10m of rural streams in the Rural Production and Mixed Rural zones', so that it
only relates to the removal of native vegetation which forms part of a contiguous area of
native vegetation over 3000m2. [see also submission point 21]
7124-23
SEAs
Amend Activity Table so that the alteration and/or removal of up to 50m2 of vegetation within
an SEA in the Rural Production, Mixed Rural and Rural Coastal zones, is a permitted activity.

7124-24
SEAs
Delete 2.3(1) 'Vegetation alteration or removal for routine operation, maintenance and repair
of existing tracks, lawns, gardens, fences and other lawfully established activities', about
vegetation removal in SEAs for routine activities up to a certain area.
7124-25
SEAs
Assessment
vegetation removal for routine activities up to a certain area.
547/1145
Sub#/
7124-26
Trust Board david@osbornehay.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - Rural zones
zones only
Amend final line of Activity Table, so that the activity status of 'Any other subdivision not
provided for in this table or in the rural zones subdivision rules' changes from a prohibited to a
7124-27
area Amend 2.3.3(1)(c)(i) so that the specified building area is reduced from 5000m2 to 1000m2.
7124-28
area
Delete 2.3.3(1)(d) about the minimum specified building area in rural zones being at least
2000m2 and clear of all yards and the 1% AEP floodplain.
7124-29
area
Amend 2.3.3(2)(C) [infer 2.3.3(2)] so that the heading 'Protection and enhancement of
ecological values' is replaced by 'Identification of Natural Features'.
7124-30
area
Amend 2.3.3(2)(D) [infer 2.3.3(2)(b)] to delete the final sentence of the rule, which states that
the assessment must be undertaken by a suitably qualified and experienced person. Refer to
submission on p 10/14 for details.
7124-31
Trust Board david@osbornehay.co.nz Rural Zones General I13.1 Activity table Retain the discretionary activity status for 'Education facilities' in the Mixed Rural zone.
7124-32
Trust Board david@osbornehay.co.nz Rural Zones General I13.1 Activity table Retain the discretionary activity status for 'Education facilities' in the Rural Coastal zone.
7124-33
Trust Board david@osbornehay.co.nz Definitions Existing
Amend Education Facilities as follows; 'Education facilities Facilities used for education to
secondary level. Includes: schools and outdoor education camps accommodation,
administrative, cultural, health, retail and communal facilities accessory to the above. '.
7124-34
Trust Board david@osbornehay.co.nz Zoning South
Rezone part of the site at 3 Maraetai Coast Rd, Clevedon, from Rural Coastal and Mixed
Rural to Single House. See map on p 14/14 for details.
7124-35
SEAs
Land Remove the SEA from the site at 3 Maraetai Coast Rd, Clevedon.
7124-36
SEAs
table - Vegetation
roads
7124-37
SEAs
7125-1 Barwant Bhikha barwant@gmail.com Zoning South
Rezone 31 and 31A Robertson Road, Favona, from Mixed Housing Suburban to Mixed
Housing Urban
7126-1 Nolene Berger
11 East Avenue, Whangaparaoa,
Auckland 0930
Rural Discharges,
Biosolids
Vertebrate Toxic Agents Amend Activity Table status from Permitted to Prohibited Use [H4.9.1 Activity Table].
Auckland 0930 RPS Natural resources
Organisms Adopt a GE/GMO-free status for Auckland Council
Auckland 0930 RPS
Adopt stronger protection for existing trees, and promote more planting of trees and other
vegetation to counter negative effects of growth
7127-1 Arhus Trust michelecwilson@gmail.com Subdivision Auckland-wide - Urban zones H5.2 3.1 Residential zones
Amend subdivision provisions to allow a minimum site size of 400m2 at 1/5 Kaumtua Place,
Te Atatu Peninsula [Mixed Housing Suburban] and neighbouring properties
7127-2 Arhus Trust michelecwilson@gmail.com Residential zones Residential
Amend to allow 1.8m height fences instead of 1.2m height fences. [Mixed Housing Suburban
Zone]
7128-1 LTD Architectural joseph@ltdarch.co.nz Mana Whenua General provisions
assessment
Amend Cultural Impact Assessment process to require it at the subdivision stage for
residential development, not at the resource consent stage
7128-2 LTD Architectural joseph@ltdarch.co.nz Mana Whenua General provisions
assessment
Amend the Cultural Impact Assessment provision so there is only one identified iwi group or
point of contact that needs to be approached
7129-1 Olivia Brown
8 David Avenue, Manurewa,
Rezone the area bordered by Orams Rd, Great South Rd to Halver and Arthur Rd, Hill Park,
Manurewa back to the motorway to Single Dwelling
7129-2 Olivia Brown
Auckland 2102
SEAs
Land Add Hill Park, Manurewa to the schedule of SEAs
7129-3 Olivia Brown
Heritage
Places Add a historic protection overlay to Hill Park, Manurewa to protect historic homes
7130-1 John Coady janandjohn@hotmail.com Zoning North and Islands
Rezone 240B East Coast Road, Forrest Hill [from Single House zone] to Mixed Housing
Suburban
548/1145
Sub#/
7130-2 John Coady janandjohn@hotmail.com Residential zones
Consider zoning residential sites adjacent to parkland to a Mixed Housing zone rather than a
Single House zone.
7130-3 John Coady janandjohn@hotmail.com Public Open Space Zones Public Open Space
Ensure that boundaries adjacent to parks are considered front boundaries in terms of design
criteria
7130-4 John Coady janandjohn@hotmail.com Residential zones Residential
General Limit the height of opaque fencing adjacent to parkland to 1.5m
7131-1 Hay Family Trust david@osbornehay.co.nz Zoning North and Islands Retain the Large Lot zone on 33 Albert Rd, Warkworth.
7131-2 Hay Family Trust david@osbornehay.co.nz
control
Building demolition control J.3.6 Rules and mapping Remove the overlay from Warkworth.
7131-3 Hay Family Trust david@osbornehay.co.nz RPS Changes to the RUB North and Waiheke Island Retain the zoning of those areas currently zoned as Future urban in Warkworth.
7131-4 Hay Family Trust david@osbornehay.co.nz RPS Changes to the RUB North and Waiheke Island Extend the Future Urban zone further along Woodcocks Rd, to Falls Rd, Warkworth.
7131-5 Hay Family Trust david@osbornehay.co.nz Zoning North and Islands
Rezone areas around Warkworth to Large Lot, and in particular, east of Pulham Rd / Hepburn
Creek Rd through to the Mahurangi River, and along Falls Rd between Hudson Rd and
Woodcocks Rd.
7131-6 Hay Family Trust david@osbornehay.co.nz Zoning North and Islands
Rezone area between Warkworth and Point Wells (including down Greens Rd to Rainbows
End), Omaha and Snells Beach, from Mixed Use Rural [infer Mixed Rural] to Countryside
Living.
7131-7 Hay Family Trust david@osbornehay.co.nz Water Stormwater
Management Area - flow Remove overlay from 33 Albert Rd, Warkworth, and surrounds.
7131-8 Hay Family Trust david@osbornehay.co.nz Earthworks H4.2.2 Controls
7131-9 Hay Family Trust david@osbornehay.co.nz Rural Zones General I13.1 Activity table
Amend Activity Table so that 'restaurants and cafes' changes from a non-complying activity to
discretionary in the Countryside Living zone.
Amend Activity Table so that 'Organised sport and recreation' is a discretionary activity in the
Countryside Living zone.
Amend Activity Table so that 'retail ancillary to an on-site activity' is a discretionary activity in
the Countryside Living zone.
Amend Activity Table so that 'On-site primary produce manufacturing' changes from a
discretionary activity to permitted.
7132-1 Heinz-J Panzner heinz-j.panzner@t-online.de Residential zones Residential
General
7132-2 Heinz-J Panzner heinz-j.panzner@t-online.de Special Character
General
7132-3 Heinz-J Panzner heinz-j.panzner@t-online.de Zoning Central
House
7133-1 Douglas C Pascoe josieshouse@gmail.com Mana Whenua
Whenua
and policies Delete sites of value to Mana Whenua.
7134-1 Grant Coupland grant.work@clear.net.nz Residential zones Residential
policies
Add two additional objectives and four policies regarding providing new open space in
residential zones proportional to density increases, providing neighbourhood parks,
pedestrian/cycle interconnection between parks and streets, and granting greater site
coverage to autonomous buildings (See Submission page 1/3 for details)
7134-2 Grant Coupland grant.work@clear.net.nz Public Open Space Zones
desc, obs & pols
Add two additional objectives and one additional policy regarding future needs of the city
including provision of public open space adjacent to residential, and other zones that they
provide amenity for, including landscaped links between informal recreation zones and these
zones (See submission page 2-3/3 for details)
7135-1
Potts Road Trust and Clifton
Holdings Trust and The Ayrlies
Gardens and Wetlands
Charitable Trust david@osbornehay.co.nz Zoning South
Retain the Countryside Living zone on land between Potts Rd and Clifton Rd, Whitford. See
p 4/19 of submission for site descriptions and p 18/19 for a map of the area.
7135-2
Charitable Trust david@osbornehay.co.nz Precincts - South New Precincts All other New Precincts
Add a new 'Ayrlies Parklands' precinct. The purpose of the precinct is to provide for and
maintain the amenity values of the gardens and wetlands at Ayrlies Gardens and Wetlands,
which is considered a garden of international significance. There are two sub-precincts that
distinguish between garden and wetland areas. Refer to the submission on p 19/19 for a
proposed precinct plan and p 11/19 to 17/19 for objectives, policies and rules.
7135-3
Charitable Trust david@osbornehay.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - Rural zones
area
Delete the Additional Subdivision control - Whitford Countryside Living 1ha' overlay from land
between Potts Rd and Clifton Rd, Whitford. See map on p 18/19 for area. [See also
submission point 2]
549/1145
Sub#/
7135-4
Charitable Trust david@osbornehay.co.nz Trees
Trees
Notable Trees
Amend the map location of tree ID 1485 on the site at 429 Clifton Rd, Whitford, so it is in the
correct location.
7135-5
Charitable Trust david@osbornehay.co.nz Mana Whenua
Whenua
Delete the four sites and places of value that are on land adjacent to Potts Rd and Clifton Rd,
Whitford, being ID numbers 2230, 2231, 2232 and 2740. [Refer to submission on p 18/19 for
the site area]
7135-6
Charitable Trust david@osbornehay.co.nz Mana Whenua
Whenua
Refine the four sites and places of value that are on land adjacent to Potts Rd and Clifton Rd,
Whitford, being ID numbers 2230, 2231, 2232 and 2740. [Refer to submission on p 18/19 for
the site area] [See also submission point 5]
7135-7
Charitable Trust david@osbornehay.co.nz Water
streams & wetland
table
Delete the two lengths of indicative streams that are on land adjacent to Potts Rd and Clifton
Rd, Whitford. [Refer to submission on p 18/19 for the site area]
7135-8
area
Retain the subdivision control of 1ha on land adjacent to Potts Rd and Clifton Rd,
Whitford. [Refer to submission on p 18/19 for the site area]
7135-9
area
Amend 'Table 10: Minimum and average net site areas for subdivision in Countryside Living
zones' so that the minimum site size in Whitford changes from 2ha to 1ha.
7135-10
Charitable Trust david@osbornehay.co.nz Natural Hazards and Flooding Natural Hazards Coastal inundation - maps only
Remove the overlay as it applies to land adjacent to Potts Rd and Clifton Rd, Whitford. [Refer
to submission on p 18/19 for the site area]
7135-11
Charitable Trust david@osbornehay.co.nz Natural Hazards and Flooding Natural Hazards Coastal inundation - maps only
Amend the overlay based on a 1m sea-level rise and area specific modelling, for land
adjacent to Potts Rd and Clifton Rd. [Refer to submission on p 18/19 for the site area]
7135-12
Charitable Trust david@osbornehay.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - general
and policies
Add new policy as follows; 'To provide for subdivision of rural sites which is required in order
to provide for or to support additional open space and/or community, educational or
recreational facilities '.
7135-13
Charitable Trust david@osbornehay.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - general
and policies
Amend Policy 36 about protection of SEAs and other areas, so that it reads less like a rule
and provides matters to be considered when protecting these areas. Refer to submission on p
7/19 for proposed changes.
7135-14
Charitable Trust david@osbornehay.co.nz Earthworks H4.2.1.1 Activity table - Zones
Amend the Activity Table to allow earthworks in the Rural zone [infer Countryside Living]as a
permitted activity up to 2500m2 and 2500m3.
7135-15
Charitable Trust david@osbornehay.co.nz Earthworks H4.2.2 Controls
Whenua.
7135-16
Charitable Trust david@osbornehay.co.nz Earthworks H4.2.2 Controls
7135-17
Charitable Trust david@osbornehay.co.nz Earthworks H4.2.3 Assessment
7135-18
Charitable Trust david@osbornehay.co.nz
SEAs
of existing tracks, lawns, gardens, fences and other lawfully established activities',
about vegetation removal in SEAs for routine activities up to a certain area.
7135-19
Charitable Trust david@osbornehay.co.nz
SEAs
Assessment
vegetation removal for routine activities up to a certain area.
550/1145
Sub#/
7135-20
Charitable Trust david@osbornehay.co.nz Rural Zones General I13.1 Activity table
Amend Activity Table so that 'restaurants and cafes' changes from a non-complying activity to
discretionary in the Countryside Living zone.
7135-21
Charitable Trust david@osbornehay.co.nz Rural Zones General I13.3 Development controls Delete 3.4 'Landscaping in the Countryside Living zone only'.
7135-22
zones only
Amend final line of Activity Table, so that the activity status of 'Any other subdivision not
provided for in this table or in the rural zones subdivision rules' changes from a prohibited to a
7135-23
area Amend 2.3.3(1)(c)(i) so that the specified building area is reduced from 5000m2 to 1000m2.
7135-24
area
Delete 2.3.3(1)(d) about the minimum specified building area in rural zones being at least
2000m2 and clear of all yards and the 1% AEP floodplain.
7135-25
area
Amend 2.3.3(2)(C) [infer 2.3.3(2)] so that the heading 'Protection and enhancement of
ecological values' is replaced by 'Identification of Natural Features'.
7135-26
area
Amend 2.3.3(2)(D) [infer 2.3.3(2)(b)] to delete the final sentence of the rule, which states that
the assessment must be undertaken by a suitably qualified and experienced person. Refer to
submission on p 10/19 for details.
7135-27
area
Amend 'Table 10: Minimum and average net site areas for subdivision in Countryside Living
zones' to delete the minimum average lot size of not greater than 4ha.
7136-1 Erica Hannam erica.hannam@ensynergy.co.nz Zoning North and Islands
Rezone land in Northcote from Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings to a less intensive
zoning. Specifically refers to parts of Lake Rd, Deuxberry Ave, Raleigh Rd, College Rd,
Exmouth Rd, Potter Ave, Greenslade Cres, Foster Ave and surrounding streets
Rezone Northcote Town Centre from Town Centre to a less intensive zoning with a lower
height limit
Rezone Highbury Town Centre (in Birkenhead) from Town Centre to a less intensive zoning
with lower height limit
7136-4 Erica Hannam erica.hannam@ensynergy.co.nz Residential zones Residential
Terrace Housing and
Reduce height and increase yard setback in Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings zone
on Lake and College Roads in Northcote, and other neighbourhood roads to avoid wind
tunnel, shadowing, canyon-like effect
7136-5 Erica Hannam erica.hannam@ensynergy.co.nz RPS Urban growth
Provide impact or feasibility studies, including social impact studies, on increased traffic
loads, flows and densification or provision of other vital services to cope with increased
densification (with specific reference to Northcote).
7136-6 Erica Hannam erica.hannam@ensynergy.co.nz General Noise and vibration H6.2 Rules Reduce noise levels for works on roads after hours
7136-7 Erica Hannam erica.hannam@ensynergy.co.nz Public Open Space Zones Public Open Space I2.1 Activity table
Remove provision for commercial activity and large structures in Conservation and Informal
Recreation zones
7136-8 Erica Hannam erica.hannam@ensynergy.co.nz Zoning North and Islands Retain Single House zone at Chatswood estate, Birkenhead
7136-9 Erica Hannam erica.hannam@ensynergy.co.nz Special Character
Include enhanced demolition controls in the Special Character North Shore overlay (similar to
those contained in the Special Character General overlay). Otherwise retain overlay
7137-1 Elaine Lougheed elainemorris56@gmail.com Residential zones Residential
General
7137-2 Elaine Lougheed elainemorris56@gmail.com Special Character
General
7137-3 Elaine Lougheed elainemorris56@gmail.com Zoning Central
House
7137-4 Elaine Lougheed elainemorris56@gmail.com
control
7138-1 Danneke Nicholas danneke.nicholas@tallpoppy.co.nz Special Character
residential
Protect mature trees in Hillpark, Manurewa or provide a character overlay to Hillpark [Inferred
from incomplete page in submission].
551/1145
Sub#/
7139-1 Cath Henry cathhenry@hsbc.com General Miscellaneous Other
Adopt the relief sought in the submission by Herne Bay Residents Association Incorporated
(HBRAI)
7140-1 Barry Robinson barry@safegroup.co.nz RPS Mana Whenua B5 Strategic Delete Mana Whenua provisions.
7141-1 Michele Copeland power.steering@xtra.co.nz Zoning City Centre Decline the planning map area that zones Westhaven and CMA as City Centre
7141-2 Michele Copeland power.steering@xtra.co.nz Precincts - City Centre Westhaven
Endorse the introduction of a new zone specific to Westhaven to recognise the Marina, Public
Open Space, Sports and Recreation
7141-3 Michele Copeland power.steering@xtra.co.nz Precincts - City Centre Westhaven
Obejctives & Policies Amend the Westhaven Precinct to recognise the historic nature of the area
7141-4 Michele Copeland power.steering@xtra.co.nz Precincts - City Centre Westhaven K3.13 Precinct Rules Amend 2.4 Parking Rule 1 to require a minimum of 0.8 car parks per moored boat
7141-5 Michele Copeland power.steering@xtra.co.nz Precincts - City Centre Westhaven K3.13 Precinct Rules
Amend Westhaven Precinct to provide for recreational activities including yacht clubs, race
start facilities, boat storage and sailing schools as permitted activities. Marine related
commercial activities including cafes and restaurants should be limited to no more than 25%
of gross floor area of buildings as controlled or discretionary activites. Non-marine related
industry, retail, visitor accommodation and residential should be non-complying activities.
7141-6 Michele Copeland power.steering@xtra.co.nz Precincts - City Centre Westhaven K3.13 Precinct Rules Amend 2.1 Retail Rule 3 from discretionary to non-complying
7141-7 Michele Copeland power.steering@xtra.co.nz Precincts - City Centre Westhaven K3.13 Precinct Rules Amend 2.2 Marine Retail Rule 2 from discretionary to non-complying
7142-1 Coatesville Rezoning Group john@deverevideo.co.nz Zoning North and Islands
Rezone properties east of the Coatesville-Riverhead Highway, from Mill Flat Road to
properties north of Sunnyside Road where it intersects the Coatesville-Riverhead Highway,
from Rural Production to Countryside Living. Refer to submission on p 4/4 for map of the
properties.
7143-1 Scott Gamble scott@gamble.gen.nz Transport Auckland -wide
requirements Remove parking minimums
7143-2 Scott Gamble scott@gamble.gen.nz Zoning Central Rezone transport nodes, corridors, Morningside, New Lynn, Newton to Mixed Housing Urban
7143-3 Scott Gamble scott@gamble.gen.nz RPS Urban growth
environment Enforce design rules and reviews
7143-4 Scott Gamble scott@gamble.gen.nz RPS Urban growth
quality compact urban form Develop on brownfield, not greenfield.
7143-5 Scott Gamble scott@gamble.gen.nz General Miscellaneous
Operational/
Projects/Acquisition Provide separated cycle lanes
7144-1 Daniel Lord zero_impact@hotmail.com Rural Zones General I13.2 Land use controls
Amend Rule 2.6, dwellings, to allow for more than 1 dwelling for a property over 10ha, or 2
dwellings maximum for a property under 40ha.
7144-2 Daniel Lord zero_impact@hotmail.com Rural Zones General I13.2 Land use controls
Amend Rule 2.7, home occupations, to allow for more than 2 but no more than 10 non-
resident persons to work on a property.
7144-3 Daniel Lord zero_impact@hotmail.com RPS Changes to the RUB North and Waiheke Island
Reduce the RUB at Warkworth to provide for growth equivalent to local GDP growth rate
figures (estimated to be 5,500 to 7,700 Warkworth area population in 30 years time).
7145-1 Karel M Lorier karellorier@gmail.com Zoning North and Islands
Rezone the Clemows Orchard subdivision, Albany from Mixed Housing Suburban to Single
House. (Refer plan attached to submission - includes Clemows Lane, Samuels Lane, Kristin
Lane, Floyds Lane, Denim Pl)
7145-2 Karel M Lorier karellorier@gmail.com Zoning North and Islands Rezone 269 Rosedale Rd, Albany from School to Single Housing
7146-1 Brett M Cunningham brettcunningham@xtra.co.nz RPS Mana Whenua B5 Strategic Reject transfer of powers to Mana Whenua based on race
7147-1 Laura Fayerman laura.fayerman@aucklandnz.com Zoning Central
Rezone the sites in Burrows Ave, Parnell from Mixed Housing Suburban to Mixed Housing
Urban
7147-2 Laura Fayerman laura.fayerman@aucklandnz.com Residential zones Residential Land use controls
Amend Rule 3.1 'Maximum density' to allow maximum density on sites with a 4.5m road
frontage including rear lots.
7147-3 Laura Fayerman laura.fayerman@aucklandnz.com Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
Delete rule 3.2 (Number of parking and loading spaces) from Burrows Avenue, Parnell and
apply the 'Parking Rates - other areas provisions
7148-1 Christopher P Watkins quangle@vodafone.co.nz Residential zones Residential
General
7148-2 Christopher P Watkins quangle@vodafone.co.nz Special Character
General
7148-3 Christopher P Watkins quangle@vodafone.co.nz Zoning Central
House
7148-4 Christopher P Watkins quangle@vodafone.co.nz
control
7149-1 Joan Berry petesinton@townplanner.co.nz Zoning North and Islands
7149-2 Joan Berry petesinton@townplanner.co.nz Zoning North and Islands Rezone 269 Rosedale Rd, Albany to Single House as an alternative to the School zone
552/1145
Sub#/
7150-1 Richard Bowes richardcbowes@gmail.com General Miscellaneous
Operational/
Projects/Acquisition Focus on core council services only (roads, footpaths, berms, parks, water, sewage).
7150-2 Richard Bowes richardcbowes@gmail.com General Cross plan matters Reduce the constraints on private property rights.
7150-3 Richard Bowes richardcbowes@gmail.com General Miscellaneous Rates Don't increase rates or debt.
7151-1 Ruben Hastings ariella-hastings@live.co.uk
SEAs
Land Delete SEA T_592 from property 418 Kemp Rd Waiuku
7151-2 Ruben Hastings ariella-hastings@live.co.uk
Outstanding Natural
Rules
Outstanding Natural
Landscapes Delete ONL overlay Area 55 from property 418 Kemp Rd Waiuku
7152-1 Peter C Berry petesinton@townplanner.co.nz Zoning North and Islands
7152-2 Peter C Berry petesinton@townplanner.co.nz Zoning North and Islands Rezone 269 Rosedale Rd, to Single House if the School zone is declined
7153-1 Jesvier Kaur jkjesvier@gmail.com Designations Auckland Transport
1643 Road Widening - Mt
Albert Road Amend the lapse date to preserve the heritage character of the Mt Albert Road
7154-1 Mahurangi Action Incorporated secretary@mahurangi.org.nz
Outstanding Natural
Rules
Outstanding Natural
Landscapes Retain the ONL protection for the prime areas of the Mahurangi Harbour.
Outstanding Natural
Rules
Outstanding Natural
Landscapes
Amend to adddress the concern that the ONL applies to areas distinct from the harbourscape,
and elsewhere, such that overuse of the overlay providing highest protection dilutes protection
for the most sensitive landscapes.
Outstanding Natural
Rules
Character - Coastal
Amend the ONC so that it applies to the seaward approaches and heads of the Mahurangi
Harbour, in place of the "high" overlay.
7154-4 Mahurangi Action Incorporated secretary@mahurangi.org.nz Zoning North and Islands Retain the Rural Coastal zoning of the bulk of the Mahurangi harbourscape.
SEAs
Land
Retain the SEA for the Mahurangi Harbour and the exclusion of mooring areas from the the
overlay.
7154-6 Mahurangi Action Incorporated secretary@mahurangi.org.nz RPS Coastal B7 Strategic
Amend any provisions that may create a hindrance to the proposed Mahurangi Coastal Trail,
particularly the proposed Puhoi River footbridge.
7154-7 Mahurangi Action Incorporated secretary@mahurangi.org.nz General Miscellaneous Other Supports the submission of Environmental Defence Society.
7154-8 Mahurangi Action Incorporated secretary@mahurangi.org.nz General Miscellaneous Other Supports the submission of Friends of Regional Parks.
7154-9 Mahurangi Action Incorporated secretary@mahurangi.org.nz Earthworks
and policies
Amend to better control sediment affecting the CMA, particularly non-point discharges, and
amend to create better linkage between the management of sediment generating activities
and the areas of degraded water quality (which includes most of the major estuaries in the
region) which are identified in the RPS.
the CMA
Amend the controls on aquaculture to ensure that important values within the coastal
environment are protected whilst enabling aquaculture to occur.
the CMA Mangroves
and policies
Link mangrove removal to sediment generating activities to avoid adverse effects of
mangrove removal.
7154-12 Mahurangi Action Incorporated secretary@mahurangi.org.nz Natural Hazards and Flooding Natural Hazards
and policies
Amend to provide for better management of development affected by natural hazards and sea
level rise in particular. Avoid new new development in hazard areas.
7154-13 Mahurangi Action Incorporated secretary@mahurangi.org.nz Precincts Ak-Wide and Coastal Regional Parks Mapping
Include the Te Muri Regional Park areas shown in designations 401 and 426 in the Regional
Park Precinct.
7154-14 Mahurangi Action Incorporated secretary@mahurangi.org.nz General Miscellaneous
Operational/
Encourage the development of open spaces and multi-use trails connecting conservation
areas to other open spaces using non-motorised transportation.
the CMA
discharge of contaminants I6.1.8 Activity table Retain discretionary activity status for oyster farming.
553/1145
Sub#/
7155-1 Kevin R Munro
2518 South Head Road, RD1,
Helensville, Auckland 0874 Subdivision Auckland-wide - Rural zones
area
Amend rules regarding Rural Coastal - Subdivision: need boundary adjustment not a few
large land owners.
Helensville, Auckland 0874 Rural Zones General I13.2 Land use controls Provide for minor dwellings for family on less than 10ha in Rural Coastal zone.
Helensville, Auckland 0874
SEAs
Land Ensure ecological areas are protect in the Rural Coastal zone.
Helensville, Auckland 0874 Rural Zones General I13.3 Development controls Prohibit houses on skyline in Rural Coastal zone.
SEAs
Amend rules for SEA to limit forestry to 100m from lakes, wet areas, provide 10 metre riparian
strips for any areas that will taking flowing water, hold water.
7156-1 Jonathan Elliot-Bateman eb@watchdog.net.nz
SEAs
Land
Amend list of SEAs to include wetland areas at 388 Upper Waiwera Road, as indicated on
map attached to Submission Page 3/3
7157-1 Stephan J Erasmus sjande@xtra.co.nz Zoning North and Islands
7157-2 Stephan J Erasmus sjande@xtra.co.nz Zoning North and Islands
Retain School zoning for 269 Rosedale Rd, Albany or rezone to Single House (rather than
Mixed Housing)
7158-1
A M Davis and R M
Bellingham m.bellingham@slingshot.co.nz
SEAs
Land Delete SEA off gardens, woodlots and orchards.
7158-2
A M Davis and R M
Bellingham m.bellingham@slingshot.co.nz Precincts - West
Amend Activity Table to control conservation forestry or exclude woodlots from the definition
of forestry.
7158-3
A M Davis and R M
Bellingham m.bellingham@slingshot.co.nz Definitions Existing
Exclude homestays from the definition of visitor accommodation and retain it in the definition
of home occupations.
7158-4
A M Davis and R M
Area K7.9.2 Rules (sub-precinct B) Amend Rule 2.1.2(2) to make dwellings not meeting the controls a controlled activity.
7158-5
A M Davis and R M
Area K7.9.2 Rules (sub-precinct B) Amend to make the assessment criteria in 2.5 more specific.
7158-6
A M Davis and R M
the CMA Mangroves
App. 6.5 Sch. SEA marine
where mangroves are a minor
component or absent
Amend marine SEAs in the Kaipara Harbour to include threatened species habitat in
mangroves and saltmarsh in the CMA along the Oruawharo River and between the Hoteo and
Kaukapakapa Rivers.
7158-7
A M Davis and R M
SEAs
Land Amend to include a SEA for Waikumete Park, Glen Eden.
7159-1 Kim Edginton g.edginton@xtra.co.nz Zoning North and Islands Rezone properties along Barry's Point Rd, Takapuna, from Light Industry to Mixed Use.
7160-1
Carolyn Dougal and Nigel
McLean nigecaro@xtra.co.nz Residential zones Residential
General
7160-2
McLean nigecaro@xtra.co.nz Special Character
General
7160-3
McLean nigecaro@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central
House
7160-4
McLean nigecaro@xtra.co.nz
control
7161-1 Chris Holt chris.holt@accentgroup.co.nz Zoning North and Islands Rezone 43 Hudson Rd Warkworth from Future Urban to Single House Zone
7162-1 Gordon Edginton g.edginton@xtra.co.nz Zoning North and Islands Rezone properties along Barry's Point Rd, Takapuna, from Light Industry to Mixed Use.
7163-1 Michelle L Buckler m.buckler@xtra.co.nz Zoning West Rezone 292 to 320 Lincoln Road, Henderson from Mixed Use to Mixed Housing Suburban
7164-1 Gordon and Kim Edginton g.edginton@xtra.co.nz Precincts - North Greenhithe
Amend the application of the sub-precincts so that 102 Kyle Rd and properties on the north-
western side of Kyle Rd change from sub-precinct A to sub-precinct B.
7165-1 Hector S Broome broomesnz@gmail.com Mana Whenua
Whenua
and policies
Existing provisions are sufficient to protect significant archaeological sites without the need to
obtain consent for works within 50m of possible sites
7166-1 Steven Yeh aucklandch@xtra.co.nz General Cross plan matters Decline the PAUP, with specific reference to 152 Onehunga Mall, Onehunga.
7167-1 STG Trustees Limited elrick@clear.net.nz Zoning Central
Rezone the south side of Remuera Rd, between St Vincent's Avenue and Ascot Avenue,
Remuera from Mixed Housing to Terraced Housing and Apartment Building
7168-1 Neven Sumich nsumich@xtra.co.nz General Whole Plan
Retain the PAUP to address the shortage of housing and build up the economy of the
community.
7169-1 Barbara J Tonson
8 Fir Street, Waterview, Auckland
General Reject high rise accommodation complexes in Waterview.
7170-1 Steve Kane steve.kane@whybintbwa.co.nz Residential zones Residential
General
554/1145
Sub#/
7170-2 Steve Kane steve.kane@whybintbwa.co.nz Special Character
General
7170-3 Steve Kane steve.kane@whybintbwa.co.nz Zoning Central
House
7170-4 Steve Kane steve.kane@whybintbwa.co.nz
control
7171-1 Susan L Parker parkerb@xtra.co.nz Trees
Trees J6.4 Rules
Amend to make applications to remove notable trees a non-discretionary activity and to be
publicly notified.
7172-1
Thomas G and Lenore J
Brebner gbrebner@neilgroup.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - Urban zones H5.2 3.1 Residential zones
Amend Table 3 reducing the minimum net site area to 500m
2
and the minimum average net
site area to 700m
2
for the Howick East area
7172-2
Thomas G and Lenore J
Brebner gbrebner@neilgroup.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - Urban zones H5.2 3.1 Residential zones
Amend rule 6(b) so that subdivision that does not comply with the net site area of 700m2 in
Table 3 is a discretionary activity rather than non-complying
7173-1
Otangaroa Te Kopuru No 7
Trust noelr7@xtra.co.nz Zoning North and Islands Rezone 7 Lewis Lane, Coatesville, from Rural Production to Countryside Living.
7174-1 Kieran J Rice kieran@morrisandjames.co.nz RPS Climate change
Delete all provisions relating to mitigation and adaption for man-made climate change and
extreme weather events.
7174-2 Kieran J Rice kieran@morrisandjames.co.nz Transport Auckland -wide C1.2 Policies
Amend to develop a policy for fair and reasonable parking to meet demands at all times in any
activities or developments in all areas excluding the city centre.
7174-3 Kieran J Rice kieran@morrisandjames.co.nz RPS Changes to the RUB North and Waiheke Island
Retain the RUB as proposed and do not extend further. In particular, the RUB around
Warkworth should not come too far towards Matakana. Retain a significant swath of rural
land between Warkworth and Matakana. Provide defensible boundaries to the expansion of
Warkworth.
7174-4 Kieran J Rice kieran@morrisandjames.co.nz Zoning North and Islands
Rezone all housing outside of precincts to Single House [relates to Warkworth and
Matakana].
7174-5 Kieran J Rice kieran@morrisandjames.co.nz RPS Urban growth
Provide for infrastructure and amenity development concurrently with subdivision and building
development at Warkworth.
7174-6 Kieran J Rice kieran@morrisandjames.co.nz RPS Urban growth
and villages Retain the local character of rural villages like Matakana.
7174-7 Kieran J Rice kieran@morrisandjames.co.nz RPS Rural
potential Retain productive rural land in close proximity to areas of growth.
7175-1 Cheng Jiang augustinelau168899@hotmail.com
SEAs
Allow building sites in areas of tree reserves at 32 Weranui Rd, Waiwera [inferred that this
refers to an SEA]. See submission for map outlining areas A to P which could be building
sites [page 3/3].
7175-2 Cheng Jiang augustinelau168899@hotmail.com Zoning North and Islands Rezone 32 Weranui Road, Waiwera to allow high density on the site in flatter areas.
7176-1 Roy and Michele Trebilco rmtrebilco@vodafone.co.nz Zoning Central Rezone 49 to 65 Te Kawa Rd, Greenlane from Single House to Mixed Housing Suburban
7177-1 Thomas W Wellington tom@livingherbs.co.nz Zoning North and Islands Rezone 12 Croft Lane, Riverhead, from Rural Production to Countryside Living.
7178-1 John Edwards kerryedwards@xtra.co.nz RPS Urban growth
quality compact urban form Reduce intensified housing and height of buildings
7179-1 Christopher J Bailey deidrebailey@radionetwork.co.nz Zoning North and Islands
Rezone the eastern side of the Coatesville-Riverhead Highway from Rural Production to
Countryside Living.
7179-2 Christopher J Bailey deidrebailey@radionetwork.co.nz RPS Issues
growth
Consider the different regions in Auckland so that each region's unique set of capabilities and
functionality is taken into account.
7180-1 LiJin Chen augustinelau168899@hotmail.com Zoning South Rezone 139 Kaipara Road, Papakura from rural to residential.
7181-1
Simon Mabin, Chantelle
Joseph and Bassett Trustees 3
Limited as Trustees of the
Mabin Family Trust deanne@mhg.co.nz General Cross plan matters Delete the maximum storey control in all zones and the floor/ceiling height height minimums.
7181-2
Mabin Family Trust deanne@mhg.co.nz Definitions New Include a term and definition for 'gross site area'
7181-3
Mabin Family Trust deanne@mhg.co.nz General Chapter G General provisions
7181-4
Mabin Family Trust deanne@mhg.co.nz Mana Whenua General provisions
assessment
Refine the circumstances under which a cultural impact assessment and engagement with iwi
may be required.
7181-5
Mabin Family Trust deanne@mhg.co.nz Sustainable Development C7.7/H6.4 Sustainable design
Building Challenge.
555/1145
Sub#/
7181-6
Mabin Family Trust deanne@mhg.co.nz Residential zones Housing affordability H6.6 Rules Delete the requirement to provide affordable housing.
7181-7
Mabin Family Trust deanne@mhg.co.nz
Centre) Business
Special information
requirements
is provided over a public space.
7181-8
Mabin Family Trust deanne@mhg.co.nz Definitions Existing Amend the definition of height to include average ground level as a means to calculate height.
7181-9
Mabin Family Trust deanne@mhg.co.nz General Cross plan matters
Amend to remove the provision that allows additional assessment criteria to be considered
beyond the specifically listed criteria.
7181-10
Mabin Family Trust deanne@mhg.co.nz Residential zones Residential Land use controls Amend the land use controls for density to refer to 'gross site area'.
7181-11
Mabin Family Trust deanne@mhg.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - Urban zones H5.2 3.1 Residential zones
Amend the subdivision controls for residential development to use 'gross site area' instead of
'net site area'.
7182-1 Jinzhu Lin augustinelau168899@hotmail.com Zoning South
Rezone 171 Murphys Road, Flat Bush (a reserve) to allow residential activities [referring to
Public Open Space - Sport and Active Recreation zoning on Southern part of site].
7182-2 Jinzhu Lin augustinelau168899@hotmail.com Zoning South
Retain the commercial and terrace housing zones at 171 Murphys Road, Flat [referring to
Neighbourhood Centre and Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings zone on site].
7183-1 Michelle and Kerry Conway michelleconway@ihug.co.nz Zoning North and Islands Rezone 73 Croft Lane, Coatesville, from Rural Production to Countryside Living.
7184-1 Paul F Donovan p.donovan@barfoot.co.nz Residential zones Residential
General
7184-2 Paul F Donovan p.donovan@barfoot.co.nz Special Character
General
7184-3 Paul F Donovan p.donovan@barfoot.co.nz Zoning Central
House
7184-4 Paul F Donovan p.donovan@barfoot.co.nz
control
7185-1 Bruce R and Shirley E Warren rwarren@xtra.co.nz RPS Urban growth
quality compact urban form Amend the PAUP having regard to the environmental and social impacts of zoning
7185-2 Bruce R and Shirley E Warren rwarren@xtra.co.nz General Miscellaneous Other
Investigate with government and other local bodies the opportunities to accommodate
population increases across a broader area, between Hamilton and Whangarei, minimising
the need to intensify Auckland housing
7185-3 Bruce R and Shirley E Warren rwarren@xtra.co.nz Zoning South
Rezone the Bucklands Beach peninsula from Mixed Housing Suburban to a special zone to
preserve existing provision relating to building site size, height and boundary set-backs
7185-4 Bruce R and Shirley E Warren rwarren@xtra.co.nz General Chapter G General provisions G2.4 Notification
Amend the PAUP so that applications which breech the provisions of the plan
are publicly notified and not only subject to Officer approval.
7185-5 Bruce R and Shirley E Warren rwarren@xtra.co.nz Mana Whenua
Whenua
Suspend the designation of sites of significance to Mori while an independent review is done
- they should be clarified to cover only areas that are nationally unique and worthy of special
protection by a council
7186-1 Shona Davies-Stone sdaviesstone@slingshot.co.nz Zoning North and Islands
Rezone land between the Coatesville-Riverhead Highway and the Riverhead forest from
Rural Production to Countryside Living. See map on p 3/3 of submission.
7187-1 Warren and Cate Haigh w-c-haigh@xtra.co.nz Zoning North and Islands Rezone 106 Mill Flat Rd, Riverhead, from Rural Production to Countryside Living.
7188-1 Trevor Haysom trevor@thefilm.co.nz General Miscellaneous Other
Adopt the relief sought in the submission by Herne Bay Residents Association Incorporated
(HBRAI)
7189-1 John G M de Vere john@deverevideo.co.nz RPS Issues
Amend by deleting the statement 'It is important to build stable and equal partnerships which
enable Mana Whenua to actively and meaningfully participate in the management of natural
resources'. This appears in the third paragraph under the heading 'Decision making,
7189-2 John G M de Vere john@deverevideo.co.nz RPS Issues
Amend by deleting the bullet point 'Enable Mana Whenua to participate in co-management of
natural resources'. This statement appears under the heading 'Auckland Plan strategic
direction and priorities'
556/1145
Sub#/
7189-3 John G M de Vere john@deverevideo.co.nz RPS Mana Whenua B5 Strategic
co-management, joint management agreements and the transfer of power to Mana Whenua
7189-4 John G M de Vere john@deverevideo.co.nz RPS Mana Whenua
participation Amend by deleting Policies 3 and 4
Whenua
7189-6 John G M de Vere john@deverevideo.co.nz Water
policies
Objectives
Ensure that management decisions regarding freshwater resources lie solely with
democratically elected governing bodies, and not in partnership with Mana Whenua
7189-7 John G M de Vere john@deverevideo.co.nz Mana Whenua
Whenua
Whenua
and policies
Whenua
whenua
accorded various degrees of protection and obligation
Whenua
varying degrees of protection and obligation
when a place is designated a Site of Significance or Value to Mana Whenua
7189-12 John G M de Vere john@deverevideo.co.nz Mana Whenua General provisions
7189-13 John G M de Vere john@deverevideo.co.nz Mana Whenua General provisions
assessment
necessary
7189-14 John G M de Vere john@deverevideo.co.nz Zoning North and Islands
Rezone the northern side of Coatsville-Riverhead Highway, including number 446, from Rural
to Countryside Living
7190-1 Ian R McIntyre mimac@ihug.co.nz Residential zones Residential
General
7190-2 Ian R McIntyre mimac@ihug.co.nz Special Character
General
7190-3 Ian R McIntyre mimac@ihug.co.nz Zoning Central
House
7190-4 Ian R McIntyre mimac@ihug.co.nz
control
7191-1 Holly Ryan hollyinvest@xtra.co.nz General Miscellaneous Other
Establish an alternative route through Kumeu/Huapai. See submission for further details
[page 5/5].
7191-2 Holly Ryan hollyinvest@xtra.co.nz General Miscellaneous Other
Upgrade Old North Road [West Auckland] where necessary to provide a feasible alternative
route for heavy traffic.
7191-3 Holly Ryan hollyinvest@xtra.co.nz General Miscellaneous
Operational/
Prioritise increasing the capacity of Helensville wastewater to facilitate both residential and
business/employment growth.
7191-4 Holly Ryan hollyinvest@xtra.co.nz General Miscellaneous
Operational/
Projects/Acquisition Fairly distribute sewage connections between residential and commercial development.
7191-5 Holly Ryan hollyinvest@xtra.co.nz RPS Urban growth
Undertake and apply a structure plan approach, building on the 1998 plan adopted by the
Rodney District Council, to develop Helensville South and Parakai western edge residential
expansion. Development to be coordinated and Council led.
7191-6 Holly Ryan hollyinvest@xtra.co.nz Residential zones Residential
policies Retain simplification of residential zoning categories from 99 to 6.
7191-7 Holly Ryan hollyinvest@xtra.co.nz Zoning North and Islands Retain Single House zone in the existing urban areas of Helensville and Parakai.
7191-8 Holly Ryan hollyinvest@xtra.co.nz Zoning North and Islands
Rezone Helensville South and Parakai Western edge to a combination of Large Lot and
Single House.
7191-9 Holly Ryan hollyinvest@xtra.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - Urban zones H5.2 3.1 Residential zones
Amend minimum site size to 4000m
2
in the Large Lot zone and 600m
2
in the Single House
zone in Helensville South and Parakai Western Edge .
Rezone Helensville South to large lot sizes with minimum sites between 1500 and 2000m
2
,
allowing for onsite sewage processing and disposal.
557/1145
Sub#/
7191-11 Holly Ryan hollyinvest@xtra.co.nz Special Character
character Helensville Retain the Special Character overlay for Helensville.
7191-12 Holly Ryan hollyinvest@xtra.co.nz Zoning North and Islands Retain Town Centre zone in Helensville.
Rezone Te Moau Ave, Parakai, Sec 49 SO 47119 from Residential to Public Open Space -
Community.
7191-14 Holly Ryan hollyinvest@xtra.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - Urban zones H5.2 3.1 Residential zones
Require less than 200m
2
of land per dwelling to faciltate affordable/community housing in
Auckland City.
7192-1 Leanne and Mark Chamberlin brookbyheights@xtra.co.nz Rural Zones General I13.1 Activity table
Amend the Activity Table for rural land in the Brookby area to prevent clean fill and other large
scale industrial activities
7192-2 Leanne and Mark Chamberlin brookbyheights@xtra.co.nz Mineral extraction
Transport Route
Remove the proposed industrial traffic route from Twilight Road, Brookby and surrounding
areas [Quarry Transport Route].
7193-1 Roy C Clements roy.clements@orcon.net.nz Historic Heritage (Overlay)
Heritage
Places [Schedule] the Loomb's Hotel at 8 Kings Road, Panmure
7194-1 Laura R Hamlet lrosehamlet@gmail.com Zoning North and Islands Rezone 27 Robinson Rd, Coatesville, from Rural Production to Countryside Living.
7195-1 Kirsten MacFarlane kirsten.macfarlane@gmail.com Zoning Central
Rezone Herdman Street, Daventry Street and Waterbank Crescent, Waterview from Mixed
Housing Urban to Mixed Housing Suburban with a 2 storey maximum height limit
7196-1 Jason Chandler liberty@xtra.co.nz Residential zones Residential
General
7196-2 Jason Chandler liberty@xtra.co.nz Special Character
General
7196-3 Jason Chandler liberty@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central
House
7196-4 Jason Chandler liberty@xtra.co.nz
control
7197-1 Marise Bowden w.m.bowden@xtra.co.nz Zoning North and Islands Rezone 16 Sunnyside Rd, Coatesville, from Rural Production to Countryside Living.
7198-1 Lynton Group Limited angela@deltaplanning.co.nz Zoning Central
Rezone 439 to 473 Parnell Road, Parnell from Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings to
Mixed Use.
7198-2 Lynton Group Limited angela@deltaplanning.co.nz Residential zones Residential Activity Table
Amend the Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings zone to provide for commercial
activities as a Discretionary activity.
7198-3 Lynton Group Limited angela@deltaplanning.co.nz
control
Building demolition control J.3.6 Rules and mapping Delete pre-1944 demolition control overlay from 463 Parnell Road, Parnell
7199-1 Lars Palmgren larspalmgren@gmail.com General Miscellaneous Consultation and engagement More consultation on the PAUP is required
7200-1 John A Taylor
13 Banks Road, Mount Wellington,
Operational/
Projects/Acquisition Request operation costs of trains, distance travelled and cost of overhead transmission lines.
7201-1 Jean M Hair
35 King Street, Waiuku, Auckland
2123
the CMA
Amend the mangrove removal rule to replace the 1996 reference point with specific dates for
different areas of the Manukau Harbour eg 1975 for Waiuku Estuary and much earlier in the
northeast part of the harbour
7201-2 Jean M Hair
35 King Street, Waiuku, Auckland
2123
the CMA
Amend the rules to make it easier for and to give assistance to those who want to remove
mangroves.
7202-1 Michael J Mcvicker m.mcvicker@paradise.net.nz RPS Mana Whenua B5 Strategic Reject Mana Wheuna provisions
7203-1 Carole M McIntosh carole.mcintosh@xtra.co.nz Residential zones Residential
General
7203-2 Carole M McIntosh carole.mcintosh@xtra.co.nz Special Character
General
7203-3 Carole M McIntosh carole.mcintosh@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central
House
7203-4 Carole M McIntosh carole.mcintosh@xtra.co.nz
control
7204-1 Guy King guyk@xtra.co.nz Special Character
Business
Character Statements - Bus. Retain the St Heliers Character statement.
7204-2 Guy King guyk@xtra.co.nz RPS Urban growth
quality compact urban form Ensure the built form of future development in St Heliers is small scale.
7204-3 Guy King guyk@xtra.co.nz Residential zones Residential
General Amend the height limit in St Heliers from 12.5m to 9m.
7204-4 Guy King guyk@xtra.co.nz Special Character
General
Require character statements to have detailed guidelines for development, not just
considerations, and have limited scope for discretion.
558/1145
Sub#/
7204-5 Guy King guyk@xtra.co.nz General Miscellaneous Other
Require development to maintain and enhance commercial conditions that foster and nurture
the survival of small retail and service businesses so that St Heliers role as a local service
centre continues.
7204-6 Guy King guyk@xtra.co.nz RPS
character and natural heritage B4.1 Historic heritage Encourage adapting and reusing existing buildings rather than demolition.
7204-7 Guy King guyk@xtra.co.nz
Centre) Business
& Bus. Park zones
Restrict the numbers of bars and restaurants in St Heliers through controls for commercial
centres.
7204-8 Guy King guyk@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central Retain residential zoning of Goldie St and Lombard St, St Heliers rather than commercial.
7204-9 Guy King guyk@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central Retain the Mixed Housing zone from Cliff Road to Claredon Road, St Heliers.
7204-10 Guy King guyk@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central
Rezone Kohimarama waterfront from Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings zone to
Mixed Housing.
7204-11 Guy King guyk@xtra.co.nz Residential zones Residential
policies Retain the separation of the Mixed Housing Suburban and Mixed Housing Urban zones.
7204-12 Guy King guyk@xtra.co.nz General Chapter A Introduction A3 Strategic Framework Incorporate the Tamaki Drive Master Plan into the PAUP.
7205-1 Emilia Kabazamalova e.kabzamalova@auckland.ac.nz Residential zones Residential
policies
Add policies which address the provision of additional public spaces such as new streets to
improve permeability and zone interface issues
7205-2 Emilia Kabazamalova e.kabzamalova@auckland.ac.nz
Centre) Business
Amend the Business zones as they are conceptually confusing being either geographically or
land use based entities and there are too many areas zoned with very simular land uses.
7205-3 Emilia Kabazamalova e.kabzamalova@auckland.ac.nz Residential zones
pols
Amend zoning so that Terrace Housing and Building is distanced from hazardous activities as
such Light Industrial.
Centre) Business
Park zones Amend the Mixed Use zone to require buildings to be adaptive to changing uses over time.
Centre) Business
Park zones Add density controls to the Centres and Mixed Use zones
Centre) Business
Park zones Amend the 'outlook space' to ensure adequate light and ventilation between tall buildings
Centre) Business
Park zones
Amend Rule 4.18 Maximum impervious area in the General Buisness and Business Park
zones, to apply to Centres and Mixed Use zones.
Centre) Business
Park zones
Amend the building height controls in 4.2, 4.8, 4.11 and 4.14 to specify number of storeys and
certain minimum heights per storey without an overall height limit.
Centre) Business
Park zones
Remove the 10m depth restriction in creating retail space on the ground floor if building height
is specified.
Centre) Business
Park zones
Amend the height in relation to boundary diagrams in rule 4.3 to make them a more realistic
scale and not misleading.
7205-11 Emilia Kabazamalova e.kabzamalova@auckland.ac.nz Definitions Existing Provide a workable definition of 'site' [refer to page 3/9 of submission for details]
Centre) Business
Park zones Provide better controls to manage the transition from one zone to another.
Centre) Business
Park zones Provide site coverage controls in the Centres and Mixed Use zones
7206-1
BVR and SKJ Trust
Partnership
7 Pickmere Lane, Kerikeri, Northland
Rezone 292 Ridge Rd, Mahurangi East [Scotts Landing], from Rural Coastal to Rural and
Coastal Settlement.
7206-2
BVR and SKJ Trust
Partnership
7 Pickmere Lane, Kerikeri, Northland
0230 Precincts - North Rodney Landscape Amend the precinct to include 292 Ridge Rd, Mahurangi East [Scotts Landing].
7207-1 Richard C Frechtling rfrechtling@gmail.com Residential zones Residential
General
7207-2 Richard C Frechtling rfrechtling@gmail.com Special Character
General
7207-3 Richard C Frechtling rfrechtling@gmail.com Zoning Central
House
7207-4 Richard C Frechtling rfrechtling@gmail.com
control
559/1145
Sub#/
7208-1 Shona Barton
24 Lansdowne Street, Bayswater,
Auckland 0622 Precincts - North Bayswater K5.6 Precinct rules Delete residential development from activities listed.
7208-2 Shona Barton
24 Lansdowne Street, Bayswater,
Auckland 0622 Precincts - North Bayswater K5.6 Precinct rules Require public notification of all activities.
7209-1 Ian R F Ross
310 Ridge Road, Mahurangi East,
Rezone 310 Ridge Rd, Mahurangi East [Scotts Landing], from Rural Coastal to Rural and
Coastal Settlement.
7209-2 Ian R F Ross
310 Ridge Road, Mahurangi East,
Auckland 0982 Precincts - North Rodney Landscape Amend the precinct to include 310 Ridge Rd, Mahurangi East [Scotts Landing].
7210-1 Kylana Trust tickle.pink@xtra.co.nz RPS Urban growth
Retain the direction for a quality compact Auckland, in particular providing for lower levels of
growth in neighbourhoods with recognised character, identity and heritage.
7210-2 Kylana Trust tickle.pink@xtra.co.nz General Chapter A Introduction
Plan
Retain the intention to simplify development controls through the use of zones, overlays and
precincts.
7210-3 Kylana Trust tickle.pink@xtra.co.nz General Chapter A Introduction
tools Retain the use of framework plans.
7210-4 Kylana Trust tickle.pink@xtra.co.nz RPS Urban growth
and villages Retain identification of villages as areas around which peripheral growth can occur.
7210-5 Kylana Trust tickle.pink@xtra.co.nz RPS Issues
Regional significance Retain the issues identified in the RPS.
7210-6 Kylana Trust tickle.pink@xtra.co.nz RPS
Heritage Area
Retain the protection of the Waitakere Ranges but make the amendments specified in the
submitter's other submission points, to provide more development capacity.
7210-7 Kylana Trust tickle.pink@xtra.co.nz RPS Mana Whenua
Fig. 1
Retain the PAUP objectives, policy and methods except where amendments are requested in
the submitter's other submission points.
Heritage Area
Remove any any PAUP regulation in the Waitakere Ranges which is more restrictive than the
operative district plan.
Heritage Area
Amend to provide for more dwelling platforms to be constructed in appropriate locations within
the Waitakere Ranges.
Heritage Area
Respond to an invitation to discuss legal mechanisms for protection of certain ecologically
valuable parts of properties.
7210-11 Kylana Trust tickle.pink@xtra.co.nz General Chapter G General provisions
status
Give careful consideration to how the precinct and overlay controls operate and amend them
so that restricted discretionary activities can be processed as such, without being elevated to
a higher activity status.
7210-12 Kylana Trust tickle.pink@xtra.co.nz Precincts - West
Area
Delete the provisions of 7.9 and draft new provisions following a thorough analysis of the
capacity of the Waitakere Ranges area, particularly rural areas, to provide more residential
and non-residential development. Alternatively, amend the provisions of of 7.9 to provide for
more development in a manner that follows a site specific assessment of each of the
properties with sub-precincts A - E.
Area Other provisions
Delete and draft new provisions following a thorough analysis of the capacity of the Waitakere
Ranges area, particularly rural areas, to provide more residential and non-residential
development. Alternatively, amend the provisions to provide for more development in a
manner that follows a site specific assessment of each of the properties with sub-precincts A -
E.
Area Other provisions
Delete the Large Lot, Rural and Coastal Settlement zones and precinct controls in respect of
the Waitakere Ranges and replace them with framework plans or similar tools which are
developed subject to a capacity study as to development potentiation and capacity in the
Ranges and distinct communities in the Ranges.
Area
objectives and policies Delete the 4ha minimum lot size for subdivisions.
Area
Amend the development controls (objectives, policies, rules and methods) so as to enable:
more subdivision, increased density, a framework plan for each community, and increased
building height, as detailed in page 17/22 of the submission.
Area
Amend the non-residential objectives and policies (Chapter F and K) to enable economic
activities to be treated as restricted discretionary activities with a wider range of assessment
criteria.
7210-18 Kylana Trust tickle.pink@xtra.co.nz
SEAs
Land
Delete the SEA from the Waitakere Ranges. Evaluate which parts of the Waitakere Ranges
are ecologically significant. Replace with a finer grain control in parts of the Waitakere
Ranges subject to ONF, ONL, ONC and HNC. Only protect outstanding parts of properties.
Investigate alternative approaches to vegetation used internationally.
7210-19 Kylana Trust tickle.pink@xtra.co.nz Mana Whenua
Whenua
and policies
Delete the Mana Whenua overlay. Replace with a system of a nominal charge for consents
for the council to notify relevant Mana Whenua.
7210-20 Kylana Trust tickle.pink@xtra.co.nz RPS Changes to the RUB West
Undertake a capacity study of the location of the RUB along the Waitakere Ranges to include
more land within the RUB. Investigate alternative development models such as cluster
housing.
560/1145
Sub#/
7210-21 Kylana Trust tickle.pink@xtra.co.nz General Whole Plan Delete the whole plan if the submitter's other requests are not adopted.
7210-22 Kylana Trust tickle.pink@xtra.co.nz General Miscellaneous Consultation and engagement
Undertake a site visit by council officers and a site specific response to be prepared for the
properties within the Waitakere Ranges that are in excess of 4ha.
7211-1 Linda Norton lyn.norts@xtra.co.nz Residential zones Residential
General
7211-2 Linda Norton lyn.norts@xtra.co.nz Special Character
General
7211-3 Linda Norton lyn.norts@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central
House
7211-4 Linda Norton lyn.norts@xtra.co.nz
control
7212-1 Robert S and Jillian M Rowdon rowdon@xtra.co.nz Zoning North and Islands
Rezone properties on the northern side of the Coatesville-Riverhead Highway from Rural
Production to Countryside Living.
7213-1 Lance A Hopwood lance.hopwood@pharmapac.co.nz Zoning North and Islands Rezone Wairau Valley from Light Industry to General Business.
7213-2 Lance A Hopwood lance.hopwood@pharmapac.co.nz Precincts - North New Precincts Wairau Valley
Apply Wairau Valley precinct [relates to other submissions requesting a new precinct for
Wairau Valley].
7214-1 Sandra Palmer sandrapalmer@vodafone.co.nz Precincts - West
Area K7.9.1 Rules (sub-precinct A) Amend the minimum subdivision size in the Waitakere foothills from 4ha to 1ha.
Amend the maximum building coverage from 300m2 to an increased area to allow building of
a large house, garage, and barn/equipment storage.
7214-3 Sandra Palmer sandrapalmer@vodafone.co.nz
managed fill
Amend the status of cleanfill sites in Countryside Living from non-complying to discretionary
or restricted discretionary. [H4.4 Auckland-wide rules]
Area K7.9.1 Rules (sub-precinct A) Increase the maximum size of minor dwellings from 65m
2
to 100m
2
.
Area K7.9.1 Rules (sub-precinct A) Amend so that sites over 2ha can apply for up to 3 dwellings.
Delete the rule that appeared in the March Draft Unitary Plan which had a 5m
3
threshold for
earthworks in the Waitakere Ranges Heritage Area [the submitter wishes to ensure that it has
not reappeared in the PAUP].
Delete the rule that appeared in the March Draft Unitary Plan which required consent for
fences in the Waitakere Ranges Heritage Area [the submitter wishes to ensure that it has not
reappeared in the PAUP].
7215-1 Grant A Campbell grant@classicgroup.co.nz Zoning North and Islands Rezone 83 Croft Lane, Coatesville, to enable owners to subdivide the land.
7216-1 Kiran and Michael Shanahan kiranalice@gmail.com Residential zones Residential
General
7216-2 Kiran and Michael Shanahan kiranalice@gmail.com Special Character
General
7216-3 Kiran and Michael Shanahan kiranalice@gmail.com Zoning Central
House
7216-4 Kiran and Michael Shanahan kiranalice@gmail.com
control
7217-1 Simon T Cox soo.si.cox@xtra.co.nz Zoning North and Islands
Rezone all land in Coatesville (and particularly 67 Sunnyside Rd, Coatesville) to Countryside
Living.
7218-1
Jesse Chalmers and Andrew
Duncan jesse@tonzu.co.nz Precincts - West Penihana North
Amend the Countryside Living zone at 24 Christian Road, Swanson to note that the subject
land is shown as 'Penihana South Land'
7218-2
Amend the minimum site are for 24 Christain Road, Swanson to 7000m2 provided that the
average site area is not less than 1 ha
7218-3
Add a notation to the land at 24 Christian Road, Swanson that all those sites within the
subject land with an area greater than 2ha can be subdivided into at least 2 lots.
7218-4
Duncan jesse@tonzu.co.nz Precincts - West Penihana North Rezone the site at 24 Christian Road, Swanson to Large Lot Residential
7219-1 Deidre A Broome deidre.broome@gmail.com Mana Whenua
Whenua
and policies
Existing provisions to protect archaeological sites are sufficient without the need to obtain
consent for works within 50m of possible sites
7220-1 Tony Busck
19 Brady Road, Otahuhu, Auckland
1062 Zoning South Rezone the right of way and part of 19 and 19A Brady Road, Otahuhu to residential
7221-1 Raymond J Nesbit nesbit@ihug.co.nz RPS Mana Whenua B5 Strategic Exclude iwi from any consultation
561/1145
Sub#/
7222-1 Alan J Bray aj.bray@xtra.co.nz Historic Heritage (Overlay)
Heritage
Places
Schedule the following buildings in Onehunga, Onehunga Woollen Mills in Neilson Street, the
Suburban Bus Building in the Te Papapa historic heritage area, the Stone House in
Waikakaraka Park, the former Te Papapa Rugby Club Hall in Captain Springs Road, Bray's
Building in Onehunga Mall, the Stone Store in Princes Street, Cardwell Street Houses in
[Caldwell Street], Church Street Houses in Church Street, all houses in Hornes Lane, the
shops on the corner of Onehunga Mall and Trafalgar Street, the Te Papapa School dental
clinic [no address supplied], the Old Mangere Bridge, and all houses in Spring Street.
7222-2 Alan J Bray aj.bray@xtra.co.nz General Miscellaneous Other Amend name of Bray's Landing to Bray's Wharf
7223-1 Gia N Phung gianghip@gmail.com Residential zones Residential Land use controls
Delete Rule 3.1(9) [maximum density] [and amend Rule 3.1(1)] to state a primary dwelling and
secondary dwellings is a Permitted Activity in the Single House zone.
7224-1 Peter W Schibli peter@truesight.co.nz Residential zones Residential Land use controls
Delete Rule 3.1(9) [maximum density] [and amend Rule 3.1(1)] to state a primary dwelling and
secondary dwellings is a Permitted Activity in the Single House zone.
7225-1 John Glenn Limited
gmckitterick@burtonconsultants.co.n
z
Centre) Business
Amend Activity table, Light Industry, to provide for the continued operation, and for minor
changes and additions to existing retail and food and beverage activities that have been
established in the Business 9 zone on the North Shore. See submission for specific wording
[Vol. 1 page 3/4].
z
Centre)
desc, obs & pols
Amend the description as follows: "...An exception is made for existing retail activities,
(including food and beverage premises) located in the former Business 9 zone of the North
Shore Section of the Operative District Plan and for trade suppliers, motor vehicle sales ...
z
Centre)
desc, obs & pols
Add clause to Policy 3 as follows: c. existing retail and food and beverage development,
including minor alteration and changes to existing premises located within the Business 9
zone of the North Shore Section of the Operative District Plan.
z Zoning North and Islands Rezone 327-329 Albany Highway, Albany from Light Industry to Neighbourhood Centre.
7226-1 Strand Properties Limited
z Trees
Trees
Notable Trees Delete notable tree, ID 1397, from 47 The Strand, Takapuna.
z Precincts - North Takapuna 1 Retain rule 1.1 Building height in sub-precinct D - 12.5m and 3 levels.
z Precincts - North Takapuna 1 Retain rule 1.2 Frontage and building setback not applying to sub-precinct D.
z Precincts - North Takapuna 1 Retain rule 1.3 Building coverage - 50% in sub-precinct D.
z Zoning North and Islands Retain Metropolitan Centre zone at 41, 43 and 45 The Strand, Takapuna.
7227-1 Daniel R Keane rex@pinesestate.co.nz Rural Zones General I13.2 Land use controls
Amend Rule 2.6 Dwellings to provide for minor household units (gross floor area of less than
7227-2 Daniel R Keane rex@pinesestate.co.nz Rural Zones General I13.2 Land use controls
a restricted discretionary activity. Include similar assessment criteria as used for minor
household units in the Operative Rodney District Plan
7227-3 Daniel R Keane rex@pinesestate.co.nz Rural Zones General I13.2 Land use controls Retain provisions for dwellings in Rule 2.6 Dwellings
7227-4 Daniel R Keane rex@pinesestate.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - general
and policies Delete all objectives, policies and rules relating to rural subdivision
7227-5 Daniel R Keane rex@pinesestate.co.nz Zoning North and Islands
with the 'elite and prime' land south of Auckland
7227-6 Daniel R Keane rex@pinesestate.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - Rural zones
area
Provide for subdivision to create new lots in rural areas where land does not contain land with
LUC Class of 1 to 3. This could include bush protection, wetland protection and land
rehabilitation and enhancement planting subdivision as per Operative Rodney District Plan.
Allow creation of lots on sites containing the protected feature
area
Capability) Class of 1 to 3. Revise the rules to provide more subdivision opportunity.
area
Amend the rules for rural boundary adjustments and boundary relocations to have fewer
restrictions. Specifically remove: the 10% threshold; the 'once only' restrictions; and the
restriction relating to the ownership of the properties
zones only Remove prohibited activity status applying to rural subdivision
area
zones only
Amend so that 'Any other subdivision not provided for in this table or in the rural zones
subdivision controls' is a non-complying activity rather than a prohibited activity
562/1145
Sub#/
area
subdivision to protect native bush, significant wetlands, significant enhancement planting or
7227-13 Daniel R Keane rex@pinesestate.co.nz Mana Whenua General provisions
assessment
Delete rules relating to Cultural Impact Assessments. Return to the practice of allowing iwi
who have identified the area as being of significance to them to review resource consent
applications and consult on applications they select. Require iwi groups to more accurately
identify areas of interest to them to avoid applicants having to consult with so many parties
7227-14 Daniel R Keane rex@pinesestate.co.nz Mana Whenua
Whenua
Delete Sites and Places of Value to Mana Whenua. If included, ensure each area is
accurately identified by iwi
7228-1
James Raymond Blackmore
Family Trust hazel-hewitt@internet.co.nz Zoning North and Islands Rezone 19-25 York Terrace, Riverhead from Local Centre to Single House.
7229-1 Diane D Maloney diane.maloney@xtra.co.nz Zoning South
Rezone Fencible Drive, Cook Street and Abercrombie Street, Howick from Terraced Housing
and Apartment Building to Mixed Housing Suburban
7229-2 Diane D Maloney diane.maloney@xtra.co.nz Zoning South
Rezone the South West of Howick Village from Mixed Housing Urban to Mixed Housing
Suburban
7230-1 Eleanor Webber
48 Webber Road, RD 1, Helensville,
assessment
Delete rules relating to Cultural Impact Assessments. Return to the practice of allowing iwi
who have identified the area as being of significance to them to review resource consent
applications and consult on applications they select. Require iwi groups to more accurately
identify areas of interest to them to avoid applicants having to consult with so many parties
Whenua
Delete Sites and Places of Value to Mana Whenua. If included, ensure each area is
accurately identified by iwi
zones only
Amend so that 'Any other subdivision not provided for in this table or in the rural zones
subdivision controls' is a non-complying activity rather than a prohibited activity
area
10% of the site area. Change activity status to restricted discretionary or discretionary
area
subdivision to protect native bush, significant wetlands, significant enhancement planting or
area
area
Amend the rules for rural boundary adjustments and boundary relocations to remove: the
distinction between adjustments and relocations; the 10% threshold; the requirement for the
sites to comprise of Certificates of Title existing on that date of notification of the PAUP; the
'once only' restrictions and the restriction relating to the ownership of the properties
area
Delete the requirement in Rule 2.3.3(2) Protection and enhancement of ecological values, to
assess and protect natural features when undertaking a boundary relocation
and policies Delete all objectives, policies and rules relating to rural subdivision
with the 'elite and prime' land south of Auckland
area
Provide for subdivision to create new lots in rural areas where land does not contain land with
LUC Class of 1 to 3. This could include bush protection, wetland protection and land
rehabilitation and enhancement planting subdivision as per Operative Rodney District Plan.
Allow creation of lots on sites containing the protected feature
area
Capability) Class of 1 to 3. Revise the rules to provide more subdivision opportunity.
zones only Remove prohibited activity status applying to rural subdivision
Auckland 0874 Rural Zones General I13.2 Land use controls Retain provisions for dwellings in Rule 2.6 Dwellings
Amend Rule 2.6 Dwellings to provide for minor household units (gross floor area of less than
563/1145
Sub#/
a restricted discretionary activity. Include similar assessment criteria as used for minor
household units in the Operative Rodney District Plan
7231-1 Louise Pickering loui.wils@gmail.com Special Character
residential
special character areas Retain the Special Character overlay provisions
7231-2 Louise Pickering loui.wils@gmail.com Zoning Central
Add the Special Character overlay to areas of Pt Chevalier including Moa, Huia, Kiwi,
Walmer, Riro, Target, Montrose, Alberta, Miller Smale and Formby Streets.
7231-3 Louise Pickering loui.wils@gmail.com Zoning Central Revise the density and population increase applied to Pt Chevalier
Remove the Terraced Housing and Apartment Buildings zoning from Huia, Kiwi, Tuia, Moa,
Walmer and Riro Streets, Pt Chevalier
7231-5 Louise Pickering loui.wils@gmail.com Zoning Central Rezone most of Pt Chevalier to Single House zone except the area around the Town Centre
Amend the zoning around Pt Chevalier Town Centre so that the Mixed Housing zones do not
extend past 500m from the Town Centre zone
7231-7 Louise Pickering loui.wils@gmail.com RPS Urban growth
quality compact urban form Allow the city to spread.
7232-1 Chris and Christine Johanson chris.johanson@me.com Residential zones Residential
General
7232-2 Chris and Christine Johanson chris.johanson@me.com Special Character
General
7232-3 Chris and Christine Johanson chris.johanson@me.com Zoning Central
House
7232-4 Chris and Christine Johanson chris.johanson@me.com
control
7233-1 Bayliss Farms k.bayliss@xtra.co.nz RPS Mana Whenua B5 Strategic Delete Mana Whenua overlay until proper consultation has taken place.
7233-2 Bayliss Farms k.bayliss@xtra.co.nz
Rural Discharges,
Biosolids
Discharges
Amend rule 2.1.3 Use and discharge of fertiliser to land to permit spreading of fertilisers within
20m of boundaries and waterways.
7233-3 Bayliss Farms k.bayliss@xtra.co.nz General Miscellaneous Other
No specific relief sought - support submission made by Federated Farmers relating to farm
drainage.
Rural Discharges,
Biosolids
Discharges
Delete provisions regulating silage discharges from silage stacks which are made without
water [rule 2.1.4].
Rural Discharges,
Biosolids
Discharges
Amend rule 2.1.2 Discharge of dairy farm effluent, to allow discharges 20m from a boundary
and 50m from dwellings.
7234-1
Lunn Avenue Properties
Limited markb@mhg.co.nz Zoning Central
Rezone Lunn Avenue Properties, Mt Wellington, (identified in Figures 1 and 2 in submission)
to a mixture of Local Centre, General Business and Light Industrial.
7234-2
Delete third paragraph, in section 1.4, under the heading "Assessment Criteria" and/or clarify
that the matters for discretion and assessment criteria for controlled and
restricted discretionary activities are the sole matters for assessment for these types of
consent.
7234-3
Limited markb@mhg.co.nz Mana Whenua General provisions
assessment Delete requirements for cultural impact assessments.
7234-4
Limited markb@mhg.co.nz General Cross plan matters Delete the storey component from the building height rule for all zones.
7234-5
statements
Delete the requirements for design statements and references to the Auckland Design
Manual.
7234-6
Limited markb@mhg.co.nz Sustainable Development C7.7/H6.4 Sustainable design Delete the sustainable development provisions.
7234-7
Limited markb@mhg.co.nz RPS Urban growth
7234-8
Limited markb@mhg.co.nz General Miscellaneous Other Request that alternative dispute resolution procedures are undertaken prior to the hearings.
7235-1 Chris Jarvis
46 Dexter Avenue, Mount Eden,
General
7235-2 Chris Jarvis
General
7235-3 Chris Jarvis
House
564/1145
Sub#/
7235-4 Chris Jarvis
Auckland 1024
control
7236-1 Aquita Holdings Limited hazel-hewitt@internet.co.nz Zoning North and Islands Rezone 19-25 York Terrace, Riverhead from Local Centre to Single House.
7237-1
Saint Marks Woman's Health
Limited gerardt@barker.co.nz Zoning Central
Retain Mixed Use zoning of 10-12 St Marks Road, 4-6 Robert Hall Avenue and 1 MacMurray
Road, Remuera [refer to map in page 11/24 of the submission]
7237-2
Limited gerardt@barker.co.nz
Centre) Business
& Bus. Park zones Retain the range of activities provided for in Mixed Use zones
7237-3
Limited gerardt@barker.co.nz Built Environment (Overlays)
Height Control Retain the controls around building coverage, GFA and setbacks in the Mixed Use zone
7237-4
Centre) Business
& Bus. Park zones
Retain the restricted discretionary activity status for new buildings in the Mixed Use zone but
deal with applications on a non-notified basis.
7237-5
Limited gerardt@barker.co.nz Transport
Remove the Motorway Interchange Controls Access Restriction from the MacMurray Road
frontage of 10 St Marks Road, Remuera
7237-6
Limited gerardt@barker.co.nz Sustainable Development C7.7/H6.4 Sustainable design Delete the sustainable development provisions
7237-7
Limited gerardt@barker.co.nz Residential zones Housing affordability H6.6 Rules Delete the affordable housing provisions
7237-8
Centre) Business
Park zones
Amend rule 4.2 (building height) applying to 4-6 Robert Hall Place and 1 MacMurray Road,
Remuera to provide for the additional height overlay of 24.5m (not withstanding volcanic
cones view protection controls)
7237-9
Limited gerardt@barker.co.nz Designations
Agency
6727 State Highway 1 -
Newmarket Viaduct Height
Restriction
Remove designation 6727 from 10-12 St Marks Road, 4-6 Robert Hall Place and 1
MacMurray Road, Remuera
7238-1 Steedman Farms Limited paisteed@farmside.co.nz Mana Whenua
Whenua
objectives and policies Delete all Sites and Places of Significance to Mana Whenua.
7238-2 Steedman Farms Limited paisteed@farmside.co.nz Definitions Existing Amend the definition of Farming to include 'farm forestry'.
7238-3 Steedman Farms Limited paisteed@farmside.co.nz
Outstanding Natural
Rules
Outstanding Natural
Landscapes
Amend the ONL at 170 Fuller Road, South Head to consider landscape, bush and lake
catchments.
Outstanding Natural
Rules
Notification
Amend 1. Activity table to permit all farm forestry within an ONL instead of being limited to
2ha.
7238-5 Steedman Farms Limited paisteed@farmside.co.nz Rural Zones General I13.2 Land use controls
Retain provisions allowing 1 dwelling on titles up to 40ha, 2 dwellings on 40ha to 100ha and 2
on 100ha plus in South Kaipara Heads [inferred to refer to 2.6 Dwellings Table 1].
Amend provisions to permit building on smaller sites in South Kaipara Heads as in other Rural
zones [inferred to refer to rule 2.6(1)(b)].
Amend spraying distances for dairy effluent discharges from 250m to 100m [inferred to refer
to rule 2.1(4)].
Rural Discharges,
Biosolids
Discharges
Amend rule 2.1.4 Silage storage and leachate disposal to read as follows: All leachate must
be collected and disposed of in a manner that meets permitted activity control. These may
include being directed into an effluent storage system or diluted and applied to land.
7238-9 Steedman Farms Limited paisteed@farmside.co.nz Rural Zones
obs & pols Reject any extension to Rural Coastal boundaries already recognised.
7238-10 Steedman Farms Limited paisteed@farmside.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - Rural zones
area
Delete provision to prohibit boundary adjustments and relocations that exceed 10% of the
original site area in Rural zones.
organisms
modified organisms Delete provisions on GMOs.
7238-12 Steedman Farms Limited paisteed@farmside.co.nz Rural Zones General I13.1 Activity table Retain farming as a permitted activity within the Rural Conservation zone.
7238-13 Steedman Farms Limited paisteed@farmside.co.nz Zoning North and Islands Retain Rural Coastal zone at 170 Fuller Road, South Head.
7239-1
Jonathan Cutler and Rachel
Beer jcutler@mrcagney.com Special Character
Amend activity table: The construction of a deck provided: - it is located at the rear.....does not
extend greater than 1.5m further towards the side boundary from the side of the building any
further than the rear corner of the building on either side. - the its floor level is no higher than
1m above..."
565/1145
Sub#/
7239-2
Beer jcutler@mrcagney.com Special Character
Add a new Permitted Activity to the activity table: "External alterations and additions to
buildings not visible from the road or any other public vantage points such as reserves,
beaches, the waterfront and other road beyond the site."
7239-3
Beer jcutler@mrcagney.com Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula
Retain the Mixed Housing Suburban, Mixed Housing Urban and Terraced Housing and
Apartment Buildings zones and sub-precincts for Devonport Peninsula but amend provisions
to prohibit the ability to develop until a master plan, funding plan and constructing the
necessary infrastructure is established and approved following public consultation, and
that development contributions to fund supportive infrastructure are finalised.
7240-1
Coatesville Resident and
Ratepayers Association hedleybr@xtra.co.nz Zoning North and Islands Rezone all land in Coatesville to from Rural Production to Countryside Living
7241-1 Bevan Domett bevan@domett.co.nz Residential zones Residential
General
7241-2 Bevan Domett bevan@domett.co.nz Special Character
General
7241-3 Bevan Domett bevan@domett.co.nz Zoning Central
House
7241-4 Bevan Domett bevan@domett.co.nz
control
7242-1 Apollo Drive 53 Limited
z Precincts - North Albany 2
Amend the precinct description, objectives and policies [in F5.3] to provide for offices as set
on page 3/4 of the submission.
z Precincts - North Albany 2
Amend K5.3.1 Activity Table to make offices up to 500m
2
a permitted activity and offices
between 500m
2
and 1000m
2
a restricted discretionary activity. Also amend to make existing
offices a restricted discretionary activity with details as set out on page 4/4 of the submission.
z Precincts - North Albany 2 Delete Rule K5.3.2.1 Offices.
7243-1 G and K Melville Family Trust hazel-hewitt@internet.co.nz Zoning North and Islands Rezone 19-25 York Terrace, Riverhead from Local Centre to Single House.
7244-1 Donald R Ensor mail@ensor.co.nz Zoning Central Rezone 111 Western Springs Rod to Mixed Housing Suburban.
7244-2 Donald R Ensor mail@ensor.co.nz RPS Urban growth
quality compact urban form Retain the "quality compact city" approach, but improve the implementation of this concept.
7245-1 Rashida Sahib-Aiyaz
27 Crossandra Drive, Mangere,
Auckland 2022 Designations
Ltd
Ground Light Restriction Remove Designation 1102 from 11a Finlayson Avenue, Manurewa
Auckland 2022 Water Aquifers/Groundwater Remove Aquifer overlay from 11a Finlayson Avenue, Manurewa.
Auckland 2022 Water
streams & wetland
Management Area Remove High Use Stream Management Area overlay from 11a Finlayson Avenue, Manurewa.
Ltd
Ground Light Restriction Remove Designation 1102 from 13A Kennington Drive, Clendon.
Auckland 2022 Water Aquifers/Groundwater Remove Aquifer overlay from 13A Kennington Drive, Clendon.
Ltd
Ground Light Restriction Remove Designation 1102 from 27 Crossandra Drive, Mangere.
Auckland 2022 Water Aquifers/Groundwater Remove Aquifer overlay from 27 Crossandra Drive, Mangere.
7246-1 S Freeth
6 Bancroft Crescent, Glendene,
Whenua
and policies Remove requirement for Iwi consent for sites of significance
7247-1 Truman Holdings Limited bianca@halaw.co.nz
Outstanding Natural
Rules
Outstanding Natural
Landscapes
Remove the ONL from 140-140B Aotea Road, Great Barrier Island and from the Awana
Settlement Area, Great Barrier Island.
7248-1 Claude V Sawyers
Helensville, Auckland 0874 General Noise and vibration H6.2 Rules
Amend to include rules that oblige pilots of parachuting aircraft and other aircraft to reduce the
effective engine noise of their aircraft in the rural area around Parakai Airfield to below 55dBa
at ground level during the week and 45dBa Sundays and public holidays. Also amend the
PAUP to provide residents with an effective means of lodging complaints about excessive
aircraft noise with the council.
7249-1 Scott and Claire Iszard scott.iszard@gmail.com Zoning West Retain the Large Lot zone at Laingholm
566/1145
Sub#/
7249-2 Scott and Claire Iszard scott.iszard@gmail.com Precincts - West
Area K7.9.3 Rules (sub-precinct C) Amend rule 4.3 [yards] to allow buildings to be constructed 3m from a boundary in Laingholm
7249-3 Scott and Claire Iszard scott.iszard@gmail.com Residential zones Residential
and Coastal Settlement zone Amend Rule 4.3 [yards] to accomodate the long, narrow, sloping sites in Laingholm.
Amend Rule 4.5 [building coverage] to allow maximum building coverage of 10% or 150m
2
whichever is the greater.
Amend Rule 4.4 [maximum impervious surfaces] so that all section are allowed 20% or 200m
2
whichever is the greater where all impervious surfaces have adequate stormwater run off
mitigation as approved by the Council or a suitably qualified and registered engineer.
7249-6 Scott and Claire Iszard scott.iszard@gmail.com RPS
Retain SEA in Laingholm where they were identified as Managed or Protected Natural
Environment in the Waitakere District Plan but remove SEA protection from areas previously
classed as General Natural Areas
7249-7 Scott and Claire Iszard scott.iszard@gmail.com Public Open Space Zones Public Open Space
Amend the permitted activities within the Public Open Space Conservation Zone [in particular
the Waitakere Ranges Regional Park] to remove the following activities: Artworks, Demolition
of Buildings, Internal additions and alterations to existing buildings, new buildings and external
alterations to existing buildings, offices and administration accessory to a permitted activity,
Public amenities and accessory buildings. Any application for the above works should be
tabled at a meeting of the relevant Local Board for discussion and not be undertaken without
prior approval from that Board.
7249-8 Scott and Claire Iszard scott.iszard@gmail.com
SEAs
Amend rules in 2.2 (Tree trimming within 10m of existing buildings in SEAs) to delete the
maximum branch diameter of 50mm and to amend bullet point 2 to increase the threshold
from 10% to 20%
SEAs
Areas - Land rules (all) Retain rule 1.1 regarding 3m tree removal zone around a dwelling
SEAs
Retain the concept of allowing restricted tree pruning within 10m of existing buildings in
SEA's
Area K7.9.3 Rules (sub-precinct C) Retain average section size of 4000m2 in the Large Lot zone
Scale [recognise] the varying section sizes in Laingholm (from suburban to lifestyle) and
adjust the development controls accordingly
Avoid implementing restrictive rules in Laingholm that negatively effect the weed removal by
the Sustainable Neighbourhoods community groups
Amend rule 2.1 [two dwellings per site] to allow buildings to be constructed 3m from a
boundary in Laingholm
7250-1 Farida Dean abduldean@xtra.co.nz Water
streams & wetland
Management Area
Remove High Use Stream Management Area from 18 De Havilland Drive, Goodwood
Heights.
7250-2 Farida Dean abduldean@xtra.co.nz Designations
Ltd
Ground Light Restriction Remove Designation 1102 from 18 De Havilland Drive, Goodwood Heights.
7251-1 Steven J Hill
15 Dunbar Road, Mount Eden,
General
General
House
Auckland 1024
control
7252-1 Glen and Megan Dobson dobbo.meegs@gmail.com Zoning North and Islands Rezone 19-25 York Terrace, Riverhead from Local Centre to Single House.
7253-1 Janine Paver jpaver@hotmail.com RPS Urban growth
quality compact urban form Retain the provisions
environment Retain Objective 1
567/1145
Sub#/
7253-5 Janine Paver jpaver@hotmail.com General Chapter G General provisions G2.4 Notification
Amend the notification provisions in the Unitary Plan to make more applications non notified
but also introduce a simpler, cheaper and less confrontational means of community
consultation, outside of the RMA framework.
2010
Each new Greenfield area should be assessed to determine its outcomes sought including
density targets, job targets etc before it is released for development
7253-7 Janine Paver jpaver@hotmail.com Residential zones Housing affordability H6.6 Rules
Strengthen affordable housing provisions by increasing the required thresholds and
percentage of all housing supplied.
7253-8 Janine Paver jpaver@hotmail.com Sustainable Development C7.7/H6.4 Sustainable design
Strengthen the Universal access provisions by applying in greenfield areas or areas where
detached housing is likely to occur.
7253-9 Janine Paver jpaver@hotmail.com Sustainable Development C7.7/H6.4 Sustainable design Retain the sustainable development provisions for Greenstar and Homestar ratings
7253-10 Janine Paver jpaver@hotmail.com Transport Auckland -wide
requirements Retain the minimum parking requirements for all zones
7253-11 Janine Paver jpaver@hotmail.com General Chapter G General provisions
statements
Retain the use of design statements, but apply consistently across the zones and correct
[unspecified] errors in information requirement text.
7253-12 Janine Paver jpaver@hotmail.com Residential zones Residential Land use controls
Amend the rules for Boarding Houses so that they provide the same level of amenity for
residents as residential zones
7253-13 Janine Paver jpaver@hotmail.com Residential zones Retirement Village zone I21 Rules
Amend the rules for Retirement Villages so that they provide the same level of amenity for
residents as residential zones
7253-14 Janine Paver jpaver@hotmail.com General Chapter A Introduction
Plan
Support the PAUP moving to a more discretionary system (more development proposals
require resource consent, allowing a discretionary design review) than a rules based planning
system.
7254-1
Stephen Krzystyniak and 4
Signatures gumby@ihug.co.nz General Noise and vibration H6.2 Rules
Amend to include rules that oblige pilots of parachuting aircraft and other aircraft to reduce the
effective engine noise of their aircraft in the rural area around Parakai Airfield to below 55dBa
at ground level during the week and 45dBa Sundays and public holidays. Also amend the
PAUP to provide residents with an effective means of lodging complaints about excessive
aircraft noise with the council.
7255-1 Flat Bush Consultant Limited charles_lilyinvestment@hotmail.com Zoning South
Rezone land at Bremner Road, Drury ( see map page 6/12 of the submission) as Local
Centre, Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings, Mixed Housing Suburban and Public Open
Space as per page 7/12 of the submission.
7255-2 Flat Bush Consultant Limited charles_lilyinvestment@hotmail.com RPS Urban growth
Add RPS objectives and policies that include specific approaches to sequencing and timing,
along with the criteria to prioritise development opportunities within the Future Urban Zone.
7255-3 Flat Bush Consultant Limited charles_lilyinvestment@hotmail.com Precincts - South New Precincts All other New Precincts
Create a new precinct at Bremner Road, Drury (as shown on page 6/12 of the
submission) With the insertion of specific objectives, policies, rules and other provisions
(details not included in submission), including the structure plan shown on pages 7-9/12 of the
submission.
7255-4 Flat Bush Consultant Limited charles_lilyinvestment@hotmail.com Precincts - South New Precincts All other New Precincts
Add requirements for a Integrated Catchment Management Plan, Network Discharge
Consents and an Integrated Transport Assessment prior to development in the 'Bremner
Road Precinct'.
7256-1 J Gibson, P Liw and F Lou
8 Tropicana Drive, Mount Roskill,
Auckland 1041 General Miscellaneous Other Request map of buildings being built on Tropicana Drive, Mt Roskill
7257-1 Roy Brooks et al
308 Fordyce Road, RD 1,
Helensville, Auckland 0874 General Noise and vibration H6.2 Rules
Include provisions within the PAUP that require parachuting aircraft, and noisy aircraft using
Parakai airfield, to reduce the effective engine noise of their aircraft in the rural area to below
55dBA at ground level during the week and 45dBA Sundays and public holidays.
7257-2 Roy Brooks et al
308 Fordyce Road, RD 1,
Helensville, Auckland 0874 General Miscellaneous
Operational/
Amend the PAUP to provide residents with an effective means of lodging complaints about
excessive aircraft noise with Council.
7258-1 John and Lyn Bell lynetteb.b@xtra.co.nz Zoning North and Islands
Retain the Terraced Housing and Apartment Building zone at 32 Beechwood Road, Browns
Bay
7258-2 John and Lyn Bell lynetteb.b@xtra.co.nz Residential zones Residential Activity Table
Retain the Restricted Discretionary activity status for 5 or more dwellings within the Terraced
Housing and Apartment Buildings zone
7258-3 John and Lyn Bell lynetteb.b@xtra.co.nz Residential zones Residential Notification Retain the non notification of Restricted Discretionary Activities.
7258-4 John and Lyn Bell lynetteb.b@xtra.co.nz Residential zones Residential
Terrace Housing and
Amend the Minimum Frontage and Site width Controls in the Terraced Housing and
Apartment Buildings zone to require a a minimum frontage of 20m as opposed to 25m.
7259-1 Evelyn A Bagnall
5 Lomond Street, Takapuna,
growth Reject height provisions in PAUP.
7260-1 Andrew D McKenzie
532 Inland Road, RD2, Helensville,
and policies Delete all objectives, policies and rules about subdivision in rural zones.
Rezone the rural areas north of Auckland to reflect their productivity limitations as compared
to the 'elite' and 'prime' land south of Auckland.
568/1145
Sub#/
area
Provide for more rural subdivision where the land is not LUC 1-3. Provide for Bush protection,
wetland protection, land rehabilitation and enhancement planting subdivision as provided for
in the operative Rodney District Plan as a discretionary activity. Amend to allow lots to be
created on the site containing the feature.
area
Amend so that transferable site subdivision is only available where the land is LUC 1-3. Also,
revise the rules so that there is a real opportunity to subdivide.
area
Reduce the restrictions on boundary adjustment and boundary relocation subdivisions. In
particular delete the: distinction between boundary adjustment and boundary relocation, 10%
threshold, prohibited activity status, once only, property ownership/title restrictions and the
requirement to assess and protect natural features.
zones only
Delete the prohibited activity status for rural subdivision and amend this so that subdivision
not provided for in the table is a non-complying activity.
Amend Rule 2.6 to provide for minor household units in rural areas. Alternatively provide for a
second dwelling on sites of less than 40ha as a restricted discretionary activity. Use
assessment criteria similar to the operative Rodney District Plan.
Auckland 0875 Rural Zones General I13.2 Land use controls Retain the provision for dwellings in Rule 2.6.
Auckland 0875 Water
streams & wetland
table and controls H4.13.2.7 Retain the livestock access controls.
Auckland 0875 Rural Zones General I13.2 Land use controls Retain Rule 2.3 Forestry controls.
Auckland 0875 Infrastructure
Transmission Corridor J1.4 Rules and mapping Retain the Electricity Transmission Corridor rules.
zones only Provide for complying boundary adjustments as a restricted discretionary activity [rural].
7261-1 Li Si Jun hua4y@hotmail.com Precincts - South Whitford
Remove eligibility limits on the age of land titles, so that large properties that may have
utilised subdivision entitlements from the existing Whitford subdivision rules (District Plan -
Manukau Section) can benefit from hamlet style countryside living.
7261-2 Li Si Jun hua4y@hotmail.com Subdivision Auckland-wide - Rural zones
area
[Amend] subdivision density within the Whitford Countryside Living zone to be one new lot per
1 hectares (for those eligible sites).
Provide for mandatory clustering or grouping of the [subdivided] lots (except lots containing
productive rural activities, native vegetation and balance lots - resulting in 80% of lots within
the cluster/s).
Amend the maximum size of the rural-residential lots to be 4000m2 and a minimum size of
1000m2, however at least 75% of the lots must have a size no greater than 3000m2.
Add rules to ensure specified building areas for rural residential sites are clustered outside a
road setback of 100m, outside of areas of existing native vegetation and the riparian margins
of streams/wetlands, and within a specific radius from the centre of the cluster/s to maintain
the grouping of the lots' specified buildings areas.
Add rule requiring a minimum number of lots be clustered together before a second or
subsequent cluster is established within the site.
Add rule requiring two or more clusters located on a site to be separated by native vegetation
or productive rural activities.
Add rule requiring clusters that are proposed or exist between two adjoining sites to be
separated from boundaries.
Add rules requiring that areas of steep slopes (above 21 degree and above 15 degree where
unstable), riparian margins and areas of native bush are protected, enhanced by native
plantings or otherwise restored.
Add rules that require balance lots and remaining larger lots to be either planted with native
vegetation or capable of use by productive rural activities.
Add requirement for a farm management plan to ensure that balance lots can be retained, to
the extent that is possible, in rural production activities.
7262-1 Edevine Wackrow edevine@bizworks.co.nz Residential zones Residential
General
7262-2 Edevine Wackrow edevine@bizworks.co.nz Special Character
General
7262-3 Edevine Wackrow edevine@bizworks.co.nz Zoning Central
House
7262-4 Edevine Wackrow edevine@bizworks.co.nz
control
569/1145
Sub#/
7263-1 Margaret Faed marjo@ihug.co.nz
the CMA
sch. 6.2 ONC/HNC 6.7 Coastal protection yard Retain the coastal protection zone [yard].
7263-2 Margaret Faed marjo@ihug.co.nz RPS
character and natural heritage B4.3.4 Biodiversity Retain the significant area of ecology.
Outstanding Natural
Rules
Outstanding Natural
Landscapes Add a new ONL at [Lot 4] DP 443418 as per page 4/6 of the submission.
the CMA Mangroves
Appendix 6.6 Significant
wading bird areas Retain Appendix 6.6 [refer to Significant wading bird areas].
7263-5 Margaret Faed marjo@ihug.co.nz General Miscellaneous Other
Amend plan so that Snells Beach and Kawau Bay marine monitoring is re-instated to ensure
safe water quality.
7263-6 Margaret Faed marjo@ihug.co.nz Zoning North and Islands Retain Light Industry zone at Snells Beach.
7263-7 Margaret Faed marjo@ihug.co.nz Zoning North and Islands Retain Local Centre - Snells Beach zone.
7263-8 Margaret Faed marjo@ihug.co.nz Zoning North and Islands Retain the zones for Snells Beach as per the legacy [Rodney] District Plan.
7263-9 Margaret Faed marjo@ihug.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - general
and policies
Amend the PAUP so that any subdivision in Snells Beach has open space as there is open
space between Algies Bay and Snells with the Highfield Reserve to the East and Countryside
living and farmland to the West.
7263-10 Margaret Faed marjo@ihug.co.nz Public Open Space Zones Public Open Space D2 Introduction
Ensure any development in in Snells Beach retains the green space and views to the west of
the Snells Beach Coastal Town, or Snells Beach Village.
7263-11 Margaret Faed marjo@ihug.co.nz Future Urban
Amend the provisions in the Future Urban zone adjacent to Sandspit Road, Warkworth to
ensure the number of property entrances is kept to a minimum or a green belt is formed.
7263-12 Margaret Faed marjo@ihug.co.nz Zoning North and Islands Oppose any residential development occurring in the Duck Creek Area in Snells Beach.
7263-13 Margaret Faed marjo@ihug.co.nz Zoning North and Islands Retain Single House zone at Snells Beach.
7263-14 Margaret Faed marjo@ihug.co.nz Zoning North and Islands Retain Large Lot zone at Snells Beach.
7263-15 Margaret Faed marjo@ihug.co.nz Zoning North and Islands Retain Countryside living zone at Snells Beach.
7263-16 Margaret Faed marjo@ihug.co.nz Zoning North and Islands Remove the Mixed Housing zone from Snells Beach.
7263-17 Margaret Faed marjo@ihug.co.nz Residential zones Residential Notification
Amend notification provision to ensure a three story building in the Mixed Housing zone is
notified.
7263-18 Margaret Faed marjo@ihug.co.nz Residential zones Residential
General Amend the minimum apartment size to 50m2.
Add a new view shaft as you come toward Snells Beach along Mahurangi East Road. This
should also ensure there is no alteration to the view across the top of the hill to Kawau Bay.
See map on Page 6/6 of the submission.
7263-20 Margaret Faed marjo@ihug.co.nz Zoning North and Islands
Retain all reserves and indicative reserves in the Snells Beach Area (including Te Whau
Esplanade Reserve, Highfield Reserve including the donkeys and playgrounds).
7263-21 Margaret Faed marjo@ihug.co.nz Public Open Space Zones Public Open Space D2 Introduction
Amend subdivision controls for Snells Beach to ensure they all have parks or reserves in their
design plans.
7263-22 Margaret Faed marjo@ihug.co.nz General Miscellaneous
Operational/
Amend Snells Beach Plans to include a combined cycleway/walkway that follows the banks of
the Mahurangi River from Snells Beach to Walkworth Town. See map on Page 5/6 of the
submission.
Operational/
Projects/Acquisition Retain the local bus service at Snells Beach.
Operational/
Retain the proposed link road at Snells Beach between State Highway 1 and Matakana
Road.
Operational/
Retain the link road between Grange Road, Snells Beach and Hamatana Road, Snells
Beach.
7263-26 Margaret Faed marjo@ihug.co.nz RPS Changes to the RUB South Retain the southern RUB.
7263-27 Margaret Faed marjo@ihug.co.nz Zoning North and Islands Retain the Light Industry zone at Hudson Road, Warkworth.
7263-28 Margaret Faed marjo@ihug.co.nz RPS
Transport
and energy Ensure infrastructure keeps up with future population growth.
Operational/
Projects/Acquisition Add a safe cycle route from Warkworth to the Mahurangi Peninsula.
Operational/
Projects/Acquisition Amend plan to add a large regional park to be set aside for future population growth.
7263-31 Margaret Faed marjo@ihug.co.nz RPS Urban growth B2.7 Social infrastructure
Add community centers to all new suburbs as well as within apartment living as part of the
urban design requirements.
7263-32 Margaret Faed marjo@ihug.co.nz Historic Heritage (Overlay)
Heritage
objectives and policies Retain overlay.
control
and policies Retain overlay.
570/1145
Sub#/
7263-34 Margaret Faed marjo@ihug.co.nz Trees
Trees
Notable Trees
Add urban tree protection to the area of Snells Beach as per the map on page 4/6 of the
submission.
7264-1 Donald F McKay donbron@xtra.co.nz Public Open Space Zones Public Open Space I2.1 Activity table
Add to 1. Activity table as follows: Subject to compliance with permitted activity performance
standards.
7264-2 Donald F McKay donbron@xtra.co.nz General Chapter G General provisions
status Require activities that do not comply with permitted standards to be Non-complying activities.
7265-1 John T Wynyard jtwynyard@maxnet.co.nz RPS Changes to the RUB North and Waiheke Island
Amend the RUB to include 317 Woodcocks Road, Warkworth, as shown on the maps in the
submission, pages 3-6/7. Rezone the area included to Future Urban.
7266-1 Footbridge Family Trust leigh@subdivision.co.nz Precincts - South New Precincts All other New Precincts
Create a new precinct at 59 Chamberlain Road, Bombay to allow for the continued operation
of the teaching and research facilities of Footbridge Lodge and its ancillary accommodation.
See pages 5-10/11 of the submission for provided description, objectives, policies and rules.
7267-1 Geoffrey J R Short geoffshort@xtra.co.nz Zoning North and Islands
Rezone Wairau Valley, particularly 91-95 Hillside Road, Wairau Valley, from Light Industry to
General Business and provide for residential activities as a co-zone with General Business for
large sites within the area.
7267-2 Geoffrey J R Short geoffshort@xtra.co.nz Zoning North and Islands
Rezone Barrys Point Road, Takapuna, particularly 17-19 Barrys Point Road, from Light
Industry to General Business and provide for high residential intensification.
7268-1 Nava Punpanich nukunik@hotmail.com Residential zones Residential
General
7268-2 Nava Punpanich nukunik@hotmail.com Special Character
General
7268-3 Nava Punpanich nukunik@hotmail.com Zoning Central
House
7268-4 Nava Punpanich nukunik@hotmail.com
control
7269-1 Allan A Dray allandprue@clear.net.nz RPS Mana Whenua B5 Strategic Delete all Mana Whenua provisions. Treat all people equally.
7269-2 Allan A Dray allandprue@clear.net.nz RPS Urban growth
land for urban development Provide infrastructure to service urban growth at Warkworth.
7270-1 Christine S Baines chrisandbill@xtra.co.nz General Miscellaneous Consultation and engagement
Request consultation is undertaken with the Trustees and tangata whenua of Pakiri G Block
[no address given], Pakiri
7271-1 Mingli Jiao susan314159@gmail.com Precincts - South Whitford Amend rule 4.2 (Sites) to remove the eligibility limits on the age of titles.
7271-2 Mingli Jiao susan314159@gmail.com Subdivision Auckland-wide - Rural zones
area
Amend the subdivision density of the Whitford Countryside Living zone to one lot per 1
hectare.
7271-3 Mingli Jiao susan314159@gmail.com Subdivision Auckland-wide - Rural zones
area
Introduce a new set of rules to allow the creation of Hamlets/Clusters in the Whitford
Countryside Living zone similar to the provisions in the Operative District Plan, Rodney
section and Franklin section. The size of the rural-residential lots would be 1000-4000m2 with
75% no greater than 3000m2. (refer to pages 4/6 of the submission for further details)
7271-4 Mingli Jiao susan314159@gmail.com General Miscellaneous Consultation and engagement Undertake Alternative Dispute Resolution procedures prior to hearings on the PAUP.
7272-1 Barton Trust paul24@xtra.co.nz Zoning North and Islands Rezone Barrys Point Road, Takapuna from Light Industrial to Mixed Use.
7273-1 Betty J Headford bheadford@xtra.co.nz RPS Mana Whenua B5 Strategic
Delete any hand over of power or joint agreement provisions for equal partnerships, joint
management and/or a transfer of power to Mana Whenua.
7274-1 Peter A Hull peter.hull@xtra.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - Rural zones
area
Reduce the minimum subdivision lot size to between 20ha and 2ha depending on the
proposed use of the land after subdivision.
7274-2 Peter A Hull peter.hull@xtra.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - Rural zones
area
Provide for a continuation of the operative Rodney district plan provisions for covenanting
and the granting of new titles.
7275-1 Robert J Taylor rob-thora.taylor@xtra.co.nz Residential zones Residential
General
7275-2 Robert J Taylor rob-thora.taylor@xtra.co.nz Special Character
General
7275-3 Robert J Taylor rob-thora.taylor@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central
House
7275-4 Robert J Taylor rob-thora.taylor@xtra.co.nz
control
7276-1 Joseph Erceg joseph_erceg@yahoo.co.nz Natural Hazards and Flooding Flooding
and policies
Rezone all residential land that is within flood areas from Single House to a more intensive
zoning and use methods other than zoning to manage the flood risk.
7276-2 Joseph Erceg joseph_erceg@yahoo.co.nz Zoning Central Rezone all of Wairere Ave, Mt Albert, from Single House to Mixed Housing Suburban.
7276-3 Joseph Erceg joseph_erceg@yahoo.co.nz Zoning West
Rezone the land along Edmonton Road, Henderson, as far as Matuhi Rise, from Mixed
Housing Urban to Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings.
571/1145
Sub#/
7276-4 Joseph Erceg joseph_erceg@yahoo.co.nz Zoning West
Rezone along Metcalfe Road, Ranui, to Swanson Road, from Mixed Housing Urban to
7276-5 Joseph Erceg joseph_erceg@yahoo.co.nz RPS Urban growth
quality compact urban form Provide for more intensification around railway stations.
7276-6 Joseph Erceg joseph_erceg@yahoo.co.nz Zoning West Retain a community hub around Te Atatu South.
7276-7 Joseph Erceg joseph_erceg@yahoo.co.nz RPS Urban growth
Retain the compact city model provided that there are excellent design criteria, planned
infrastructure improvements and world class public transport.
7277-1 Brenda M Higgins brenda@sulco.co.nz General Whole Plan Decline the Plan.
7278-1 M H Cox neil@subdivision.co.nz Zoning South
Rezone Lot 1 DP 28944 and surrounding properties at Harvey Road, Waiuku (as shown on
the map page 3/4 of the submission), from Mixed Rural to 'Single Lot - Residential'.
7278-2 M H Cox neil@subdivision.co.nz Precincts - South New Precincts All other New Precincts
Add new precinct for properties at Harvey Road, Waiuku (as shown on page 3/4 of the
submission) to allow for residential development of the property Lot 1 DP 28944 and
surrounding area, applying the Single House zone provisions.
7279-1 Balmoral Alliance p.oconnor@auckland.ac.nz Special Character
General
character statement - General Retain the Special Character overlay applying to Balmoral Streets.
7279-2 Balmoral Alliance p.oconnor@auckland.ac.nz Zoning Central Retain the Single Housing zone applying to Balmoral Streets
7279-3 Balmoral Alliance p.oconnor@auckland.ac.nz Residential zones Residential
Retain Rule 6.2 'Building Height' applying a two storey 8m height limit in the Single House
zone, with particular reference to Balmoral.
7279-4 Balmoral Alliance p.oconnor@auckland.ac.nz
control
Apply the Pre-1944 Building Demoltion control to Special Character Areas, particularly in
Balmoral, as interim protection until the PAUP is formally operative.
7280-1 Orewa Developments Limited a.stewart@harrisongrierson.com Zoning North and Islands Retain Single House zoning of 52 Sunnyheights Rd, Orewa
7280-2 Orewa Developments Limited a.stewart@harrisongrierson.com Precincts - North Orewa 2 Retain Orewa 2 precinct as it applies to 52 Sunnyheights Rd, Orewa
7280-3 Orewa Developments Limited a.stewart@harrisongrierson.com Precincts - North Orewa 2 Add the density controls in rule K5.31.3.1 into the subdivision controls in the precinct
7280-4 Orewa Developments Limited a.stewart@harrisongrierson.com Air Quality
Amend the Air Quality Transportation Corridor Separation overlay as it applies to 52
Sunnyheights Rd, Orewa from 150m to 100m
7280-5 Orewa Developments Limited a.stewart@harrisongrierson.com Mana Whenua General provisions
assessment Delete requirements for cultural impact assessments
7280-6 Orewa Developments Limited a.stewart@harrisongrierson.com Water Stormwater
H4.14.2 Stormwater
Amend so resource consent is only required where there is an infringement of the impervious
area control in the underlying zone
7281-1 Paul Barton paul24@xtra.co.nz Precincts - North Bayswater K5.6 Precinct rules Delete residential development from activities listed.
7281-2 Paul Barton paul24@xtra.co.nz Precincts - North Bayswater K5.6 Precinct rules Require public notification of all activities.
7281-3 Paul Barton paul24@xtra.co.nz Precincts - North Bayswater K5.6 Precinct rules
Amend dwellings with or without framework plans to be Non-complying activities instead of
Discretionary activities.
7281-4 Paul Barton paul24@xtra.co.nz
the CMA Marina zone
objectives and policies Delete Objective 12.
7282-1 Georgia Magee
4D Dunbar Road, Balmoral,
General
General
House
Auckland 1024
control
7283-1 Peishuang Dong susan314159@gmail.com Zoning South Retain the Countryside Living zone within the Turanga Catchment, Whitford
7283-2 Peishuang Dong susan314159@gmail.com Precincts - South Whitford Delete the cap of 925 Lots
7283-3 Peishuang Dong susan314159@gmail.com Precincts - South Whitford
Amend the Countryside Living provisions within the Whitford precinct area to allow clustered
or Hamlet developments and to avoid isolated and dispersed living.
Introduce a new sub-precinct C in the Turanga catchment (as identified in Figure 1 on page
4/7 of the submission)
Introduce a new rule that all subdivision in the proposed sub-precinct C be a Restricted
Introduce a rule that Restricted Discretionary subdivision in the proposed sub-precinct C be a
non-notified activity without the need for written approval or limited notification.
7283-7 Peishuang Dong susan314159@gmail.com Precincts - South Whitford Amend rule 4.2 (Sites) to remove the eligibility limits on the age of titles.
7283-8 Peishuang Dong susan314159@gmail.com Precincts - South Whitford Introduce subdivision density of one lot per 1 hectare within the proposed sub-precinct C.
Amend the objectives, policies and rules within the proposed Whitford sub-precinct C to allow
the creation of Hamlets/Clusters similar to the provisions in the Operative District Plan,
Rodney section and Franklin section. The size of the rural residential lots would be 1000-
4000m2 with 75% no greater than 3000m2. (refer to pages 5-6/7 of the submission for further
details).
572/1145
Sub#/
7283-10 Peishuang Dong susan314159@gmail.com General Miscellaneous Consultation and engagement Undertake Alternative Dispute Resolution procedures prior to hearings on the PAUP.
7284-1 John M Hill johnhillarchitect@xtra.co.nz Residential zones Residential
Terrace Housing and
Amend the building setback adjoining lower density zones control [Rule 9.5] in the Terrace
Housing and Apartment Buildings zone so that the 4th storey is setback 13m from the inter-
zone boundary rather than 9m.
7284-2 John M Hill johnhillarchitect@xtra.co.nz Special Character
& C J3.3.1-7 Rules
Amend height in relation to boundary control in the Special Character Isthmus A overlay to 3m
and a 45 degree recession plane
7285-1 Martin Waiguny mkjw1009@gmail.com Residential zones Residential
General
Amend the development controls [6.7] and [7.8] maximum building coverage for Single House
zone to 50% and Mixed Housing Suburban zone to 60%.
7285-2 Martin Waiguny mkjw1009@gmail.com Residential zones Residential
General Amend Rules [6.4 'Yards'] and [7.5 'Yards] to reduce the front yard depth to 3m.
7285-3 Martin Waiguny mkjw1009@gmail.com Zoning Central Rezone 22a and 30a Tawari St, Kingland, to Mixed Housing Urban.
7285-4 Martin Waiguny mkjw1009@gmail.com Built Environment (Overlays)
Height Control Reject the additional height restriction of 12.5m (3 Story) for Kingsland local centre.
7285-5 Martin Waiguny mkjw1009@gmail.com Zoning Central
Rezone, within the radius of 300 m around Kingsland station (1st to 4th Ave, around Eden
Park, Sandringham Rd, Walter Rd) from Single House to at least Mixed Housing Suburban
and Mixed Housing Urban.
7286-1 Ian D and Judith A Parton
144 Gowing Drive, Meadowbank,
Auckland 1072
SEAs
Land Delete SEA overlay from 144 Gowing Drive, Meadowbank
7287-1 Della M Senden della@seniorconcepts.co.nz Zoning Central
Rezone 1,3 and 5 Western Springs Rd and 2 and 10 School Rd, Kingsland from Terrace
Housing and Apartment Buildings to a [less intensive residential zone]
7287-2 Della M Senden della@seniorconcepts.co.nz
control
Retain the [pre-1944 building demolition control] on 1, 3 and 5 Western Springs Rd and 2, 8
and 10 School Rd, Kingsland.
7288-1 Roger Low rlow@ihug.co.nz
control
Building demolition control J.3.6 Rules and mapping Delete the Overlay until full assessment has been undertaken on individual properties.
7289-1 Murdoch Newell Limited
1542 Zoning South Rezone 344 Airfield Road, Ardmore from Mixed Rural to Light Industry.
7289-2 Murdoch Newell Limited
1542 Zoning South Rezone 864 Clevedon Road, Papakura from Mixed Rural to Countryside Living.
7290-1 Timothy J McGoldrick tmcgoldrick@barfoot.co.nz Residential zones Residential
General
7290-2 Timothy J McGoldrick tmcgoldrick@barfoot.co.nz Special Character
General
7290-3 Timothy J McGoldrick tmcgoldrick@barfoot.co.nz Zoning Central
House
7290-4 Timothy J McGoldrick tmcgoldrick@barfoot.co.nz
control
7291-1 John W Colebrook john@eos.co.nz Zoning Central Rezone 33 Prospect Terrace, Mt Eden, from Mixed Housing Suburban to Single House.
7291-2 John W Colebrook john@eos.co.nz Zoning Central
Rezone Ashton Rd (and all associated land through to Mt Eden Rd), Bellevue Rd, Valley Rd,
Lovelock Ave, Ngauruhoe St, St Albans Rd from Mixed Housing Suburban to Single House.
7291-3 John W Colebrook john@eos.co.nz Public Open Space Zones
Recreation Facilities I18.1 Activity table Retain the provisions for Eden Park.
7291-4 John W Colebrook john@eos.co.nz Precincts Ak-Wide and Coastal Stadiums and Showgrounds K1.10 Precinct Rules Retain the provisions for Eden Park sub-precinct.
7291-5 John W Colebrook john@eos.co.nz Precincts Ak-Wide and Coastal Stadiums and Showgrounds K1.10 Precinct Rules
Amend provisions to exclude Eden Park sub-precinct from the application of the Auckland-
wide (H 6.5) Temporary Activities rule.
7291-6 John W Colebrook john@eos.co.nz General Chapter G General provisions G2.4 Notification
Reject and amend provisions to ensure Restricted Discretionary Activities use normal RMA
notification tests.
7291-7 John W Colebrook john@eos.co.nz Residential zones Residential Land use controls
Delete or amend Rule 3.1 'Maximum Density': one dwelling per 200m
2
in the Mixed Housing
Suburban where the site is greater than 1200m
2
.
Delete or amend Rule 3.1 'Maximum Density': regarding the unlimited density in Mixed
Housing Urban zone where the site is greater than 1200m
2
.
7291-9 John W Colebrook john@eos.co.nz
Reject or amend Land Use Control 3.1 Activities within 30m of a residential zone to change
the activity status to Discretionary Activity for taverns and drive through facilities.
7291-10 John W Colebrook john@eos.co.nz Special Character
& C J3.3.1-7 Rules Reject or amend the activity status of demolition to Discretionary Activity.
7291-11 John W Colebrook john@eos.co.nz Special Character
& C J3.3.1-7 Rules Reject or amend Assessment 5.2.2h to remove relocation as part of the assessment.
Rezone Sandringham Rd from Rossmay Tce south (both sides) to Gribblehirst Rd from Mixed
Housing Urban to Mixed Housing Suburban.
573/1145
Sub#/
Amend Rule 3.1 ['Maximum density'] maximum dwelling at 300m
2
for the Mixed Housing
Suburban zone (also see submission, point 7).
7291-14 John W Colebrook john@eos.co.nz Built Environment (Overlays)
Height Control
Delete overlay provisions for Eden Valley local centre and amend to maximum of 10m/2
storey.
7291-15 John W Colebrook john@eos.co.nz Built Environment (Overlays)
Height Control
Delete Mixed Use zone on Dominion Rd south from Prospect Tce, east and west side to
Brixton Rd and amend to apply Additional Height Control overlay to max of 10m/2 storey.
Reject the increased intensification provisions in the Mixed Housing Urban and Mixed Use
zones within Balmoral Rd, west to Sandringham Rd, north to Kingsland, east to Mt Eden Rd,
and north to New North Rd. Amend by applying a staging mechanism based on an
independent verification of infrastructure capability and a proven shortage of land that is ready
to be developed.
7292-1 Robyn J Northey northeyr@xtra.co.nz RPS Urban growth
Retain compact city linked by public transport approach, particularly in relation to Onehunga
town centre area
7292-2 Robyn J Northey northeyr@xtra.co.nz Residential zones Residential
policies Increase percentage of Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings zone to 20% of urban area
7292-3 Robyn J Northey northeyr@xtra.co.nz RPS Urban growth
quality compact urban form Increase intensification and transport across and around the city
7293-1 The Cameron Road Group neil@subdivision.co.nz Zoning South
Rezone properties on Glenbrook-Waiuku Road and Cameron Road, Waiuku (as listed on
page 1/4 of the submission) from Mixed Rural and Rural Coastal to 'Single Lot -Residential'.
7293-2 The Cameron Road Group neil@subdivision.co.nz Precincts - South New Precincts All other New Precincts
Add new precinct for properties on Glenbrook-Waiuku Road and Cameron Road (as shown
on page 3/4 of the submission) to allow for residential development of the properties and
surrounding area.
7294-1
Young Ones Before and After
School Care
17 Atkinson Avenue, Papatoetoe,
Auckland 2025 Airport
Noise
Amend rules to enable child care facilities in Activities Sensitive to Aircraft Noise (ASAN)
areas
7295-1 Colin W Freland
3/40 Woodward Avenue, Mangere
Bridge, Auckland 2022 Historic Heritage (Overlay)
Heritage
Places [Retain the historic heritage scheduling] of 2 and 4 George Terrace, Onehunga
7296-1 Joy A and B M Urlich
23A Dunbar Road, Balmoral,
General
General
House
Auckland 1024
control
7297-1 Murray and Rachel Nelson juderon@gmail.com Precincts - West Birdwood
Amend Birdwood Precinct Plan to provide for two lots in addition to the three already provided
for at 10 Red Hills Rd, Massey.
7297-2 Murray and Rachel Nelson juderon@gmail.com Precincts - West Birdwood
Amend rules to enable further subdivision of properties: where geotechnical assessment can
demonstrate safe building sites and access, and stormwater mitigation is in accordance with
the Countryside and Foothills Stormwater Management Code.
7297-3 Murray and Rachel Nelson juderon@gmail.com Precincts - West Birdwood Amend 3. Assessment Criteria for Subdivision.
7298-1 Drury Community Committee lizpalmerdrury@yahoo.co.nz RPS Changes to the RUB South [Add] greenbelt between Drury and Pukekohe.
7298-2 Drury Community Committee lizpalmerdrury@yahoo.co.nz RPS Urban growth
land for urban development [Add provisions for] infrastructure, including transport.
7298-3 Drury Community Committee lizpalmerdrury@yahoo.co.nz
Centre) Business
Park zones Limit maximum height in Papakura to two to three stories.
7298-4 Drury Community Committee lizpalmerdrury@yahoo.co.nz
Centre) Business
Park zones Retain a suitable distance from the neighbours boundary and regard neighbour's privacy.
7298-5 Drury Community Committee lizpalmerdrury@yahoo.co.nz General Miscellaneous
Operational/
Projects/Acquisition Retain regional parks as a separate entity from Auckland Council Parks.
7299-1 E F Gojak
1/26C Quadrant Road, Onehunga,
Heritage
Places Delete 1/26C Quadrant Rd, Onehunga from the Early Road Links historic heritage area
7300-1 O Singh
PO Box 64462, Botany, Auckland
2163 Zoning South Rezone 178 Point View Drive, Botany from Mixed Housing Suburban to Countryside Living.
7300-2 O Singh
2163 RPS Changes to the RUB South
Retain the Metropolitan Area 2010 Boundary in respect of the site at 178 Point View Drive,
Botany.
7300-3 O Singh
Protection
Seeks preparation of a comprehensive landscape assessment report and an urban design
report to detail the full extent of the Ridgeline Protection Overlay as it applies to the area
along the Point View Drive ridgeline in Botany.
574/1145
Sub#/
7300-4 O Singh
Protection
Add objectives, policies and rules framework to ensure that prominent ridgelines (such as the
Point View Drive, Botany area) which geographically mark the edges of Auckland's urban
areas are protected and maintained.
7301-1 Brett Ogilvie bogilvie@xtra.co.nz RPS
Add new Policy: "Recognise that uncontrolled growth of public trees may represent a threat or
nuisance to the enjoyment of neighbouring privately-owned properties."
7301-2 Brett Ogilvie bogilvie@xtra.co.nz Trees
Add new Policy: "Manage existing trees in order to not threaten network utilities and privately
owned property and infrastructure, including drainage, foundations and paving."
7301-3 Brett Ogilvie bogilvie@xtra.co.nz Trees
Amend section 3.2. Assessment Criteria 1c to read "the likelihood of actual damage or
nuisance to people and property from the protected tree."
7302-1 Jennifer Hunter rhpositive@slingshot.co.nz Zoning North and Islands
Rezone parts of Dairy Flat including Jean Mackay Place, Blackbrige Road and Dairy Flat
Highway, as indicated in submission [page 2/7] to not allow subdivision through cut and fill
methods denser than currently present due to natural hazards and rural character.
7302-2 Jennifer Hunter rhpositive@slingshot.co.nz RPS Changes to the RUB North and Waiheke Island
Amend the boundary of the RUB at Jean Mackay Place, Dairy Flat, as indicated in submission
[page 6/7].
7303-1 Lawrence Tay lawrencetay@orcon.net.nz
control
Building demolition control J.3.6 Rules and mapping Delete the Overlay. Identify specific streets and character.
7304-1 Di Dixon didixon16@gmail.com RPS Mana Whenua B5 Strategic Delete all references to Mori and treat all people equally.
7304-2 Di Dixon didixon16@gmail.com General Miscellaneous
Operational/
Projects/Acquisition Work on a cost effective transport unit to the airport.
7304-3 Di Dixon didixon16@gmail.com RPS Urban growth
quality compact urban form Consider rural and satellite towns more when planning for central Auckland.
7304-4 Di Dixon didixon16@gmail.com General Miscellaneous Other
Make the paperwork for submissions accessible for all (too many formats and unattainable by
average computer user).
7304-5 Di Dixon didixon16@gmail.com Infrastructure
C1.1 Infrastructure
policies Amend provisions to ensure that roading takes into account the effect of noise on public.
7305-1 Kerrin Sime kjsime@gmail.com Zoning West
Rezone 203, 205 and 207 Halsey Drive, Lynfield, from Mixed Housing Suburban to Mixed
Housing Urban.
7306-1 Abdullah Mangera salimmangera@xtra.co.nz Historic Heritage (Overlay)
Heritage
Places Reassess heritage status of 298 Onehunga Mall, Onehunga.
7307-1 Isbey and Collier Families oakwhale@ihug.co.nz Residential zones
& pols Retain objectives and policies.
7307-2 Isbey and Collier Families oakwhale@ihug.co.nz Precincts - North Waimana Point
Retain precinct, specifically provisions regarding the requirement for a Comprehensive
Development Plan, landscape/vegetation led rules, esplanade reservation around the entire
point and across the point connecting Algies Bay and Scandrets/Goldsworthy beaches,
protection for archaeological features (Historic Heritage Plan), natural resource provisions
(Natural Resource Plan), notional roading proposals linking adjoining lands (Built Environment
Plan), acceptance of the need to work within reports done by Tonkin and Taylor and the public
waste water pipeline between Algies Bay and Martins Bay.
7307-3 Isbey and Collier Families oakwhale@ihug.co.nz Precincts - North Waimana Point Include original operative Concept Plan.
7307-4 Isbey and Collier Families oakwhale@ihug.co.nz Precincts - North Waimana Point Include any operative rules not included in the PAUP.
Replace 6.1 Matters of Discretion [under K5.51.6] with the clearer operative plan rule 2. See
submission for wording [page 3/4].
7307-6 Isbey and Collier Families oakwhale@ihug.co.nz Precincts - North Waimana Point Include provision for pedestrian linkage between the beaches.
Amend to show the east/west Council road on the "Built Environment Plan" and don't show
only part of it on the Precinct Plan.
Amend to show the existing wastewater pipeline across Waimana Point and adjoining land on
the "Infrastructure Plan".
7307-9 Isbey and Collier Families oakwhale@ihug.co.nz Precincts - North Waimana Point Amend to show a "Plan" which shows notional pedestrian linkage.
Consider implementation of notional roads on the "Infrastructure Plan" for Waimana Point to
ensure active zoning and infrastructure requirements match.
7308-1
Alfriston Residents Group -
Lifestyle Blocks gandm@xtra.co.nz RPS Changes to the RUB South
Amend the RUB to exclude the Takanini North area between Ranfurly Rd and Papakura
Stream, bounded by Porchester Rd on the west and Mill Rd on the east. Apply restrictions to
prohibit any further development apart from self-sustaining countryside / mixed rural blocks
until all appropriate infrastructure is in place
7308-2
Rezone the land between Ranfurly and Alfriston Rds (bounded by Mill Rd on the east and to
the Stratford Rd roundabout), Takanini North, from Future Urban to Mixed Rural
575/1145
Sub#/
7308-3
Lifestyle Blocks gandm@xtra.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - Rural zones
area
Limit lot size (eg to 3000-5000m2) for the area between Ranfurly and Alfriston Rds (bounded
by Mill Rd on the east and to the Stratford Rd roundabout), Takanini North. Ensure lot size is
compatible with surrounding Countryside Living and Mixed Rural zoning as described in
submission. Prohibit subdivision in this area other than self-sustaining countryside / rural
blocks. [This is in conjunction with rezoning to a rural zone as addressed elsewhere in the
submission]
7308-4
Rezone the land between Ranfurly Rd and Papakura Stream, bounded by Porchester Rd on
the west and Mill Rd on the east, Takanini North, from Future Urban to Mixed Rural. This is
until suitable infrastructure is in place for subdivision.
7308-5
Lifestyle Blocks gandm@xtra.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - Rural zones
zones only
Prohibit subdivision (except for self-sustaining countryside / rural blocks) in the Takanini North
area between Ranfurly Rd and Papakura Stream, bounded by Porchester Rd on the west and
Mill Rd on the east. [This is in conjunction with rezoning to a rural zone as addressed
elsewhere in the submission].
7309-1 Red Horizon Trust david@whitburngroup.co.nz Zoning West
Rezone 71 West Harbour Drive, West Harbour, from Mixed Housing Suburban to Mixed
Housing Urban.
7309-2 Red Horizon Trust david@whitburngroup.co.nz Residential zones Residential
General Limit building height at 71 West Harbour Drive, West Harbour, to at least 9.5m.
and Coastal Settlement zone Amend Rule 6.2 maximum building height to 9.5m.
Mixed Housing Urban zone Amend Rule 7.2 maximum building height to 9.5m.
7310-1 Grant McMillan d.grantmcmillan@yahoo.co.nz RPS Issues
growth
Amend 'Our Sense of Place' to include direction on the need to balance provision of
intensification with preserving existing residential character (see pages 3-4/75 of the
7310-2 Grant McMillan d.grantmcmillan@yahoo.co.nz RPS Issues
growth
Amend 'Supply of Land in Auckland' to include opportunities for growth around the north south
corridor linking Albany to Silverdale and Orewa (see pages 6-7/75 of the submission for
details)
7310-3 Grant McMillan d.grantmcmillan@yahoo.co.nz RPS Urban growth
Undertake further detailed infrastructure studies of areas proposed for intensification prior to
upzoning e.g. Terraced Housing and Apartment Buildings and Mixed Housing Urban zones,
especially in older existing suburbs within the RUB such as Herne Bay and St Marys Bay.
7310-4 Grant McMillan d.grantmcmillan@yahoo.co.nz Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
Insert a 'Roading Hierarchy' into the PAUP (see pages 9-11/75 of the submission for details)
with detailed definition of the various road categories similar to the Auckland Legacy Plan.
7310-5 Grant McMillan d.grantmcmillan@yahoo.co.nz Infrastructure
C1.1 Infrastructure
policies
Amend infrastructure objectives and policies to more clearly specify that planning for and
management of infrastructure within the RUB takes into consideration protection of
neighbourhood amenity in areas such as Herne Bay and St Mary's Bay (see page 11/75 of the
submission for details)
7310-6 Grant McMillan d.grantmcmillan@yahoo.co.nz Historic Heritage (Overlay)
Heritage
Places
Conduct a Heritage Study of Herne Bay within two years to identify buildings and groups of
buildings that warrant 'listing'.
7310-7 Grant McMillan d.grantmcmillan@yahoo.co.nz
control
Remove the Overlay from buildings that do not meet clearly detailed heritage status criteria,
following a detailed study of Herne Bay and St Mary's Bay.
control
and policies
Remove the fee required for consent on applications under the pre 1944 Overlay and provide
free independent professional advice from qualified experts for 2 years until detailed heritage
studies have been done.
Heritage
Places
Scehdule the group of buildings on the north side of Jervious Road, Ponsonby between
Lawrence Street and Sentinel Road.
7310-10 Grant McMillan d.grantmcmillan@yahoo.co.nz RPS
Include incentives for owners of scheduled places to care for and preserve their buildings, e.g.
rates relief, free consents and professional services and support for seismic strengthening.
7310-11 Grant McMillan d.grantmcmillan@yahoo.co.nz Zoning Central
Rezone the properties on Jervois Road from Wallace Street to Hamilton Road, Ponsonby and
Islington Street to Blake Street, Ponsonby from Business (Local Centre and Mixed Use) to a
zone which encourages retention of heritage.
Add a provision for the sites on Jervois Road from Wallace Street to Hamilton Road,
Ponsonby and Islington Street to Blake Street, Ponsonby to allow owners to lift their buildings
to create a second storey in keeping with the period of the building.
7310-13 Grant McMillan d.grantmcmillan@yahoo.co.nz Residential zones
Amend the zone description to remove the discussion on new housing types and state that it
is not envisaged that there will be widespread replacement of existing stock (see page 17/75
of the submission for details)
576/1145
Sub#/
Amend Objective 2 to say 'Development is of a height, bulk, form and appearance that
positively responds to the site and the neighbourhood's existing character, and in the case of
Greenfields development planned suburban residential character...' (see page 18/75 of the
submission for details)
Amend Objective 3 to say 'Development provides high-quality on-site amenity for residents
and achieves a reasonable standard of amenity for adjourning sites.
Amend Policy 2 to say 'Manage the height, bulk, form and appearance of development and
require sufficient setbacks and landscaped areas to maintain a suburban residential character
of generally one or two storeys in existing residential areas.
7310-17 Grant McMillan d.grantmcmillan@yahoo.co.nz General Chapter G General provisions
activities
Amend to add two new points to rule 3 as follows; c) The potential effect of the non-
compliance on adjourning properties, the streetscape and the residential character of the
area; d) The design of the development.
7310-18 Grant McMillan d.grantmcmillan@yahoo.co.nz General Chapter G General provisions
activities
Amend to add a new point to rule 4 as follows; iv) The effect of the development on
adjourning properties and the extent to which the design is compatible with the streetscape
and character of the area.
7310-19 Grant McMillan d.grantmcmillan@yahoo.co.nz General Chapter G General provisions G2.4 Notification
Amend to ensure all controlled and restricted discretionary applications will be assessed
against the tests in the RMA. Note also the change to the discretionary and non-complying
rule. (see page 23/75 of the submission for details).
7310-20 Grant McMillan d.grantmcmillan@yahoo.co.nz Residential zones Residential
Amend Rule 7.1 (Development control infringements) to ensure that any infringement of
development controls in the Mixed Housing Suburban zone is considered a Restricted
Discretionary Activity and the matters for discretion are expanded (see page 26/75 of the
Terrace Housing and
development controls in the Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings zone is considered a
Restricted Discretionary Activity and the matters for discretion are expanded (see page 26/75
of the submission for details).
Terrace Housing and
development controls in the Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings zone is considered a
Restricted Discretionary Activity and the matters for discretion are expanded (see page 26/75
of the submission for details).
7310-23 Grant McMillan d.grantmcmillan@yahoo.co.nz Residential zones Residential Land use controls
Amend Rule 3.1 (Maximum density) from 200m
2
to 300m
2
in the Mixed Housing zone (where
the requirements of Clause 3.1.5 are met) (see page 28/75 of the submission for details)
Mixed Housing Urban zone Delete Rule 7.4 (Alternative Height to Boundary) for the Mixed Housing Suburban zone.
Amend Rule 7.5 (Yards) rear yard distance in the Mixed Housing Suburban zone from 1m to
4m.
Amend Rule 7.8 (Building Coverage) to apply a 35% threshold for all sites in the Mixed
Housing Suburban zone (see page 34/75 of the submission for details).
Amend Rule 7.9 (2) (Landscaping) to increase landscaped area for the Mixed Housing
Suburban zone from 30% to 35% for higher density sites.
Amend Rule 7.15 (Fences) for the Mixed Housing Suburban zone from 1.2m to 1.8m in front
yards.
Terrace Housing and
Amend Rule 9.5 (Building setbacks adjoining lower density zones) for the Terrace Housing
and Apartment Buildings zone to include set backs adjoining Mixed Housing Suburban and
Mixed Housing Urban sites (see page 40/75 of the submission for details).
Centre) Business
Park zones
Introduce setbacks where sites adjoin for Single House, Mixed House Suburban and Mixed
House Urban zones (see page 40/75 of the submission for details).
7310-31 Grant McMillan d.grantmcmillan@yahoo.co.nz Transport Auckland -wide Mapping
Reclassify Curran Street from an Arterial Road to a classification better suited to its actual
physical dimensions and functional capacity.
Rezone Shelly Beach Road, Ponsonby (east side adjacent to Harbour Bridge off ramp and
opposite Tweed Street to just north of Westward Terrace, west side between Sarsfield and
Emmett Streets and between Tweed Street north to Jervois Road) from Terraced Housing
and Apartment Buildings to Mixed Housing Suburban (see pages 45-46/75 of the submission
for details).
577/1145
Sub#/
Rezone Jervois Road (north side Salisbury to Wallace Street, Seymour Street to Dedwood
Terrace, Hamilton Road to Curran Street) from Terraced Housing and Apartment Buildings to
Mixed Housing Suburban (see pages 45-46/75 of the submission for details).
Carry out area studies in Herne Bay to determine whether Mixed Housing Urban would be
appropriate in some areas along the Herne Bay Ridge (see page 47/75 of the submission for
details).
Rezone the north side of Jervois Road from Local Centre to a Residential or Mixed Use zone
until a Business Area Review has been carried out and a Herne Bay Business Development
Strategy has been prepared (see pages 48-49/75 of the submission for details).
Rezone Jervois Road, Ponsonby (south side Islington St to Blake St, and north side Shelly
Beach Road to Seymour Street) from Mixed Use to a new Business Zone that allows for more
specific low-key office type activities and has development controls designed to retain the
current building character. (see pages 51-52/75 of the submission for details)
Add a provision for the sites on Jervois Road, Ponsonby (north side Shelly Beach Road to
Seymour Street) to allow owners to lift their buildings to create a second storey in keeping with
the period of the building (see pages 51-53/75 of the submission for details).
Rezone Jervois Road, Ponsonby south side from Kelmana Ave to Islington Street from Local
Centre to Neighbourhood Centre.
7310-39 Grant McMillan d.grantmcmillan@yahoo.co.nz Precincts - Central New Precincts Other New Precincts Introduce a Herne Bay Precinct Plan (see page 55/75 of the submission for details)
7310-40 Grant McMillan d.grantmcmillan@yahoo.co.nz Transport Auckland -wide C1.2 Objectives Delete Objective 3
7310-41 Grant McMillan d.grantmcmillan@yahoo.co.nz Transport Auckland -wide C1.2 Policies Delete Policy 2 (parking)
requirements
Delete the provisions in Table 3 where there are no minimum car parking requirements for city
fringe overlay areas (including parts of Herne Bay), in Centres, Mixed Use and Terraced
House and Apartment Building zones.
requirements
Replace the parking rules for Herne Bay with the existing minimum level levels as specified in
Rule 12.8.1 of the Operative Auckland Council District Plan Isthmus Section.
Rezone Stack Street (north and south side), Argyle Street (south side), Wallace Street (north,
east and west sides), Jervois Road (north and south sides between Clifton Road and
Salisbury Street and south side on Buller Street), Curran Street (west and east sides), Emmett
Street, Tweed Street, and Shelly Beach Road (east side) Herne Bay from Mixed Housing
Suburban to Single House (see pages 59-62/75 of the submission for details).
Rezone Sarsfield Street, Herne Bay (north side between Sentinel Road and Curran Street)
from Mixed Housing Urban to Mixed Housing Suburban.
Rezone Shelly Beach Road, Herne Bay (west side between Tweed Street and Emmett
Streets) from Mixed Housing Urban to Single House.
7310-47 Grant McMillan d.grantmcmillan@yahoo.co.nz Residential zones Residential Land use controls
Delete 'No density limits apply where four or more dwellings are proposed and the
requirements of clause 3.1.6 below are met' from the table in Rule 3.1 (Maximum Density) and
the associated clause 3.1(6) (applies to the Mixed Housing Urban zone).
Amend 2.6 to include details of how the Waitemata Harbour 'Blue Space' can be harnessed
and enhanced to make up for lack of open space in Herne Bay (see page 71/75 of the
Include an Open Space Strategy in the PAUP which outlines how open space will be acquired
within existing suburbs being intensified (see page 71/75 of the submission for details).
Retain the Open Space -Sports and Active Recreation zoning of the West End Bowling Club
and Ponsonby Bowling Club.
Rezone the two schools in Herne Bay, including Ponsonby Primary School, to be Public Open
Space.
Revise the Mixed Housing Urban provisions so that new development respects
existing development in heritage suburbs e.g. Herne Bay (see page 72-73/75 of the
Terrace Housing and
Revise the Terrace Housing and Apartment Building provisions so that new development
respects existing development in heritage suburbs e.g. Herne Bay (see page 74-75/75 of the
7311-1 Hamuera Rapata
16 Dunbar Road, Balmoral, Auckland
General
General
578/1145
Sub#/
1024 Zoning Central
House
1024
control
7312-1 Kindercare Learning Centres tim@kindercare.co.nz Air Quality
transport separation Delete Rule 7.1 Air Quality - Transport Corridor Separation.
7312-2 Kindercare Learning Centres tim@kindercare.co.nz Air Quality
transport separation Delete the rule that restricts Childcare centres from locating on local roads.
7312-3 Kindercare Learning Centres tim@kindercare.co.nz Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
Amend the design of carparking rule to address the concerns raised in the submission about
the order of preference for locating carparking for childcare centres (ie underground, to the
rear, or physically separated from the site frontage). Refer to pg. 5/17 of the submission for
details.
7313-1
Okura Residents and
Ratepayers Association okura.residents@gmail.com Zoning North and Islands
Rezone Okura Village from Rural and Coastal Settlement to another zone that addresses the
concerns on page 3/3 of the submission.
7313-2
Okura Residents and
Ratepayers Association okura.residents@gmail.com Residential zones Residential Activity Table Provide for secondary dwellings at Okura Village, including on sites less that 1200m
2
.
7313-3
Okura Residents and
Ratepayers Association okura.residents@gmail.com Subdivision Auckland-wide - Rural zones
area
Amend the West Okura rules to provide for minimum site area of 5000m
2
with an average site
area of not less than 2ha.
7313-4
Okura Residents and
Ratepayers Association okura.residents@gmail.com Precincts - North New Precincts Okura
Create a new overlay to include the development controls for Okura that are contained in the
North Shore district plan, particularly section 9 and 18.
7313-5
Okura Residents and
Ratepayers Association okura.residents@gmail.com RPS Changes to the RUB North and Waiheke Island Retain the RUB at Okura so that it remains on the Vaughans Road ridgeline.
7313-6
Okura Residents and
Ratepayers Association okura.residents@gmail.com General Miscellaneous Special housing areas Do not undertake any Special Housing Areas on the land north of the RUB at Okura.
7314-1 Glen Houghton gandlhoughton@vodafone.net.nz Precincts - North Waimauku Connect Waimauku to the public wastewater system as soon as possible.
7314-2 Glen Houghton gandlhoughton@vodafone.net.nz Rural Zones General I13.2 Land use controls Delete Rule 2.9 (a) and (b).
7315-1
Waiwera Heights Country Club
Limited augustinelau168899@hotmail.com
SEAs
Land
Delete tree reserves on lot 1, 2, 7, 8 at Weranui Road, Waiwera as shown in submission to
accommodate a house site [page 3/7 - inferred as SEAs].
7315-2
Limited augustinelau168899@hotmail.com Zoning North and Islands
Rezone lots 2, 3 and 4 at Weranui Road, Waiwera as shown in submission [page 3/7] to be
high density commercial rather than lot 1.
7315-3
Limited augustinelau168899@hotmail.com Precincts - North Waiwera
Reject the reserve roading area at Weranui Road, Waiwera as shown in submission [page
3/7]
7315-4
Rezone lots 3 and 4 at 48 Weranui Road, Waiwera to be high density rather than lot 12 as
shown in submission [page 7/7].
7315-5
Rezone lots 5 and 6 at 48 Weranui Road, Waiwera as high density as shown in submission
[page 5/7].
7315-6
Limited augustinelau168899@hotmail.com
SEAs
Land Delete tree reserve from 48 Weranui Road, Waiwera [inferred as SEA].
7316-1
Nigel G Taylor and Hazel E
Denyer petesinton@townplanner.co.nz Zoning North and Islands
Rezone the land south of Access Road and Tawa Road, Kumeu (identified on the plan on
page 3/3 of the submissions) form Mixed Rural to Countryside Living or Large Lot Unserviced
(see pages 1-2/3 of the submission for details)
7316-2
Nigel G Taylor and Hazel E
Denyer petesinton@townplanner.co.nz RPS Changes to the RUB West
Rezone the area south of Access Road and Tawa Road, Kumeu from Mixed Rural to Large
Lot. (refer to plan on page 3/3 of the submission for details)
7317-1
Lifestyle Blocks
25 Everlea Place, Alfriston, Auckland
2105
SEAs
Land Add SEA at 146 Mill Road, Alfriston.
7318-1 Baoland Holdings Limited
c/- Woods, PO Box 6752, Wellesley
Street, Auckland 1141 RPS Changes to the RUB South
Rezone the land at 110A Jack Lachlan Drive, 712, 722, 732, 740, 746, 758 and 770 Whitford-
Maraetai Road, Beachlands mapped on page 33/35 of the submission as Single House zone
to Single House.
Maraetai Road, Beachlands mapped on page 33/35 of the submission as Terraced Housing
and Apartment Building zone to Terraced Housing and Apartment Buildings.
Maraetai Road, Beachlands mapped on page 33/35 of the submission as Neighbourhood
Centre zone to Neighbourhood Centre.
Street, Auckland 1141 Precincts - South Beachlands 1
Apply the Beachlands 2 Precinct over the land at 110A Jack Lachlan Drive, 712, 722, 732,
740, 746, 758 and 770 Whitford-Maraetai Road, Beachlands as shown on the map on page
33/35 of the submission as Proposed Beachlands Precinct 2 Area.
Introduce a new Beachlands Precinct 2 with similar Objectives, Policies and Rules to those in
Beachlands Precinct 1(see pages 5-7/35 of the submission for details)
579/1145
Sub#/
Amend the Beachlands Precinct 1 to review the objectives, policies and rules to acknowledge
the village/rural interface between 110 Jack Lachlan Drive and the rural zoned land to the
south set as out on pages 8-10/35 of the submission.
7319-1 Lawrence G Mann mannclan@ihug.co.nz Zoning North and Islands Rezone 582 Leigh Road, Whangateau from Rural Coastal to an unspecified zone.
7320-1 David Pinker d.p@vodafone.co.nz RPS Changes to the RUB North and Waiheke Island
Amend plan to action the Matakana bypass up to Claydon Rd and opening up a serviced
urban area around it.
7321-1 Christopher G Wrapson sally.chris@xtra.co.nz Residential zones Residential
General
7321-2 Christopher G Wrapson sally.chris@xtra.co.nz Special Character
General
7321-3 Christopher G Wrapson sally.chris@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central
House
7321-4 Christopher G Wrapson sally.chris@xtra.co.nz
control
7322-1 Anne Beeson abeeson@orcon.net.nz Zoning North and Islands Rezone 2 Crestview Place, Browns Bay from Single House to Mixed Housing Suburban.
7323-1 Bruce and Jane Skinner
c/- SFH Consultants, Attn: Daniel
Shaw, PO Box 31280, Milford,
Auckland 0741 Zoning North and Islands Retain Mixed Housing Urban at 213 Eskdale Road, Birkenhead.
7324-1 Roderick and Beverly Hedley
Helensville, Auckland 0874 General Chapter A Introduction A3 Strategic Framework Retain the climate change response provisions at 3.5.
Helensville, Auckland 0874 RPS
Transport
and energy
Retain objectives and policies supporting renewable energy, particularly wind farming at
Wilson Road, South Head.
Helensville, Auckland 0874 Infrastructure
Energy
generating facilities Retain the restricted discretionary activity status for wind farms on rural land.
SEAs
Land
Amend the SEA on the submitter's land on Wilson Road, South Head, as shown in the figure
attached to the submission.
7325-1 Domain Heritage Trust david@davidwren.co.nz Zoning Central
Rezone the portion of 1 Domain drive (as shown on page 6/6 of the submission) from Terrace
Housing and Apartment Buildings to Mixed Use.
7326-1 Leslie W Stewart lesstewart@actrix.co.nz Zoning North and Islands Rezone 654 Beach Road, Browns Bay, from Single House to Mixed Housing Urban.
7327-1 Lawrence and Wendy Blount lawrenceb@ihug.co.nz Zoning West Agree with Laingholm zoned as Large Lot.
7327-2 Lawrence and Wendy Blount lawrenceb@ihug.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - Urban zones H5.2 3.1 Residential zones Retain the subdivision controls that require an average section size to be at least 4000m
2
.
7327-3 Lawrence and Wendy Blount lawrenceb@ihug.co.nz Residential zones Residential
Amend Rule 4.5 'Building Coverage' (or an alternative way) to reflect the various sizes of
properties in Laingholm (refer to page 4/11 of the submission for exact wording of amended
rule).
7327-4 Lawrence and Wendy Blount lawrenceb@ihug.co.nz Residential zones Residential
Amend Rule 4.4'Maximum Impervious Area' (or an alternative way) to reflect different section
sizes in Laingholm (refer to page 4/11 of the submission for exact wording of amended rule).
7327-5 Lawrence and Wendy Blount lawrenceb@ihug.co.nz Residential zones Residential Land use controls Retain the provisions that allow home occupations.
7327-6 Lawrence and Wendy Blount lawrenceb@ihug.co.nz Residential zones Residential Land use controls
Amend Rule 3.2 'Home Occupations' clause (2) to "No more than......may work on site in the
home occupation." and (3) "No more than five four people in total may work on site in the
home occupation."
Amend Rule 3.2 'Home Occupations' clause (4) to "The sale of goods or services
from......7pm. The provision of services from the home occupation that requires customers to
come to the site may not occur before 7am or after 9pm."
Amend Rule 3.2 'Home Occupations' clause (6) so that it does not discriminate against
anyone whose home occupation may be as a heavy vehicle owner/driver that parks the
vehicle at home at the end of a working day and drives it out in the morning to carry out the
home occupation.
Amend Rule 3.2 'Home Occupations' clause (7) so that it is clearer regarding what is a
"commercial vehicle" and made more reasonable.
Delete Rule 3.2 'Home Occupations' clause (9) or amend it by limiting it to reasonable
restrictions.
Amend Rule 3.2 'Home Occupations' clause (10) to "Where a primary element of the home
occupation is selling goods, with the exception..."
7327-12 Lawrence and Wendy Blount lawrenceb@ihug.co.nz Residential zones Residential Activity Table
Amend Activity Table to create a new category for smaller visitor accommodation i.e. up to
60m
2
as a Discretionary Activity.
580/1145
Sub#/
7327-13 Lawrence and Wendy Blount lawrenceb@ihug.co.nz Public Open Space Zones Public Open Space I2.1 Activity table
Reject the following as Permitted Activities within the Conservation zone: artworks, demolition
of buildings, internal additions and alterations to existing buildings, new buildings and external
additions to existing buildings, offices and administration accessory to a permitted activity,
public amenities and accessory buildings.
7327-14 Lawrence and Wendy Blount lawrenceb@ihug.co.nz Public Open Space Zones Public Open Space I2.1 Activity table
Amend plan so the following activities require Local Board prior approval: artworks, demolition
of buildings, internal additions and alterations to existing buildings, new buildings and external
additions to existing buildings, offices and administration accessory to a permitted activity,
public amenities and accessory buildings.
7327-15 Lawrence and Wendy Blount lawrenceb@ihug.co.nz
SEAs
Avoid rules that restrict the ability of community groups that undertake voluntary weeding,
particularly in Laingholm.
SEAs
Areas - Land rules (all) Amend Control 2.2 Tree Trimming to distinguish between native trees and exotic trees.
SEAs
Areas - Land rules (all) Delete Control 2.2 Tree trimming clause (1) regarding branch diameter.
SEAs
Areas - Land rules (all) Amend Control 2.2 Tree Trimming clause (2) to be increased to 20%.
7327-19 Lawrence and Wendy Blount lawrenceb@ihug.co.nz RPS
character and natural heritage B4.3.4 Biodiversity Provide for the protection of urban biodiversity.
7327-20 Lawrence and Wendy Blount lawrenceb@ihug.co.nz RPS Issues
heritage Create a specific issue for biodiversity.
character and natural heritage B4.3.4 Biodiversity Provide more protection of fauna and enhancement of habitat.
organisms
modified organisms Retain the precautionary approach.
organisms
modified organisms Remove "veterinary vaccines" as a permitted activity.
7327-24 Lawrence and Wendy Blount lawrenceb@ihug.co.nz RPS Urban growth
Review and revise, where necessary, proposed intensification and development based on
2013 census data for growth projections.
Retain transport strategies that do not rely on fossil fuels and help to reduce the city's
greenhouse gas emissions.
7327-26 Lawrence and Wendy Blount lawrenceb@ihug.co.nz RPS Climate change
Amend plan to ensure that intensification does not take place in areas at risk from sea level
rise and prepare a strategy to recognise and mitigate the impacts of climate change during
next 30 years.
Provide more protection for the significant ecological values of the
coastal marine environment.
7327-28 Lawrence and Wendy Blount lawrenceb@ihug.co.nz RPS Coastal
quality Address the issue of sedimentation more.
coastal environment
Provide robust protection for highly valued areas in the coastal environment
where development is not permitted and these rules should not be waived.
Develop rules to ensure protection of the health of our coastal marine environment and
marine species from any adverse effects of aquaculture.
7328-1 T G Bridge
34 Tamatea Drive, Snells Beach,
Auckland 0920
the CMA
sch. 6.2 ONC/HNC
6.4 Schedule of coastal marine
area boundaries
Retain the Coastal Protection zone on undeveloped land. Delete it from residential land and
Snells Beach in particular.
7328-2 T G Bridge
Auckland 0920
SEAs
Land Retain the SEA on undeveloped land.
7328-3 T G Bridge
Operational/
Provide link roads: from State Highway 1 to Matakana Road, the Western Link Road -
McKinney Road, Mansel Drive through to Hudson Road, from Grange Road to Hamatana
Road, and a future road through to Hamilton Road.
7328-4 T G Bridge
Auckland 0920 RPS Changes to the RUB North and Waiheke Island Retain the southern RUB at Warkworth.
7328-5 T G Bridge
Provide more land and zoning for business and light commercial areas, at
Warkworth particularly in the vicinity of Hudson Road, Maunsel Road and along Woodcocks
Road to the High School.
7328-6 T G Bridge
Operational/
Projects/Acquisition Provide more infrastructure to service growth at Warkworth.
7328-7 T G Bridge
Rezone the land in the McKinney Road area, Warkworth, from Future Urban to an operative
urban zone.
7328-8 T G Bridge
Auckland 0920 Zoning North and Islands Rezone Snells Beach to match the zoning of the operative plan 2000.
7328-9 T G Bridge
policies Avoid additional development at Snells Beach.
581/1145
Sub#/
7328-10 T G Bridge
Auckland 0920 Subdivision Auckland-wide - Urban zones H5.2 3.1 Residential zones Ensure that new development at Snells Beach provides open space.
7328-11 T G Bridge
Auckland 0920 RPS Changes to the RUB North and Waiheke Island Retain green space and open views to the west of Snells Beach Coastal Town.
7328-12 T G Bridge
Rezone land adjoining Sandspit Road, Matakana from Future Urban to a zone that avoids
ribbon strip development.
7328-13 T G Bridge
Rezone the land north of Warkworth and from Future Urban to a zone that retains the existing
urban boundary.
7328-14 T G Bridge
Auckland 0920 Zoning North and Islands Zone to avoid residential development in Duck Creek and surrounding area at Warkworth.
7328-15 T G Bridge
Retain Single House, Large Lot and Countryside Living Zones around Snells Beach, but avoid
any zoning for higher densities.
7328-16 T G Bridge
Auckland 0920 Residential zones Residential Notification Ensure that applications for mixed housing of 3 storeys are publicly notified.
7328-17 T G Bridge
General Increase the minimum size for apartments to 50m
2
.
7329-1 Sarah Solaris sarah@thevaultnz.com RPS Mana Whenua B5 Strategic
Delay Mana Whenua provisions until more consultation and debate with the public on the
practical workings and the aims of the provisions.
7330-1 WSZ Company Limited
PO Box 99459, Newmarket,
Auckland 1149 Zoning North and Islands Rezone 73 Barrys Point Road, Takapuna from Light Industry to Mixed Use.
7331-1 Lawrence B Whistler matakanapalms@gmail.com RPS Issues
Delete the statement 'It is important to build stable and equal partnerships which enable Mana
Whenua to actively and meaningfully participate in the management of natural resources'.
This appears in the third paragraph under the heading 'Decision making, environmental
governance, partnerships and participation.'
7331-2 Lawrence B Whistler matakanapalms@gmail.com RPS Issues
Delete the bullet point 'Enable Mana Whenua to participate in co-management of natural
resources'. This statement appears under the heading 'Auckland Plan strategic direction and
priorities'
7331-3 Lawrence B Whistler matakanapalms@gmail.com RPS Mana Whenua B5 Strategic
Delete all provisions in the PAUP calling for partnership arrangements, shared
governance, co-management, joint management agreements and the transfer of power to
Mana Whenua.
7331-4 Lawrence B Whistler matakanapalms@gmail.com RPS Mana Whenua
participation Delete Policies 3 and 4.
Prior to entering any co-governance arrangements, hold a referendum on whether
the governance of physical and natural resources should be shared in partnership with Mana
Whenua.
7331-6 Lawrence B Whistler matakanapalms@gmail.com Water
policies
Objectives
Ensure that management decisions regarding freshwater resources lie solely
with democratically elected governing bodies, and not in partnership with Mana Whenua.
7331-7 Lawrence B Whistler matakanapalms@gmail.com Mana Whenua
Whenua
applicants dealing directly with the council and not with iwi.
Whenua
and policies
Whenua
accorded various degrees of protection and obligation.
Whenua
Amend the Sites of value to Mana Whenua by grading them into categories of significance, to
be accorded varying degrees of protection and obligation.
Explain to all affected parties the impact of, and the obligations required of the
landowners, when a place is designated a Site of Significance or Value to Mana Whenua.
7331-12 Lawrence B Whistler matakanapalms@gmail.com Mana Whenua General provisions
7331-13 Lawrence B Whistler matakanapalms@gmail.com Mana Whenua General provisions
assessment
necessary.
7332-1 Houghton Family Trust petesinton@townplanner.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - Rural zones
area
Amend the PAUP to provide the ability for sites to be created within the submitter's farm [at
Muriwai Downs] based on wetland and bush qualification of the Unitary Plan. Such sites
should be limited to 5,000m
2
to 10,000m
2
on land not suitable for farming and where there is
no call on the extension of Council services.
582/1145
Sub#/
7333-1 Colleen Crampton colleencrampton@xnet.co.nz Zoning North and Islands Retain the Mixed Use zone adjacent to Centreway Road and Florence Ave, Orewa.
7333-2 Colleen Crampton colleencrampton@xnet.co.nz Zoning North and Islands Retain the Rural Conservation zoning for the land south of Hillcrest Road, Orewa.
7333-3 Colleen Crampton colleencrampton@xnet.co.nz Rural Zones
desc, obs & pols
Retain the Objective 3 and the policies, particularly Policy 5 (in the context of retention of
Rural Conservation zoning of the land south of Hillcrest Road, Orewa).
7333-4 Colleen Crampton colleencrampton@xnet.co.nz
Outstanding Natural
Rules
Outstanding Natural
Landscapes Retain the ONL on the south side of Hillcrest Road, Orewa.
SEAs
Land Retain the SEA on the south side of Hillcrest Road, Orewa.
7333-6 Colleen Crampton colleencrampton@xnet.co.nz Trees
Trees
Notable Trees Retain the scheduled native trees between West Hoe Road and Hillcrest Road, Orewa.
7333-7 Colleen Crampton colleencrampton@xnet.co.nz Built Environment (Overlays)
Height Control
Retain the 24.5m, 16.5m, 12.5m and 8.5m additional height controls for the town centre in
Orewa.
7333-8 Colleen Crampton colleencrampton@xnet.co.nz Zoning North and Islands Retain the Single House zoning adjacent to Orewa Beach.
7333-9 Colleen Crampton colleencrampton@xnet.co.nz Zoning North and Islands Retain the Town Centre zone for Orewa west of Hibiscus Coast Highway.
7333-10 Colleen Crampton colleencrampton@xnet.co.nz RPS
features
Retain the objectives and policies (in the context of retaining the ONL on the south side of
Hillcrest Road, Orewa).
SEAs
Retain the rules (in the context of retaining the SEA on the south side of Hillcrest Road,
Orewa).
7334-1 Graham L Pettersen valhowell@xtra.co.nz Zoning North and Islands Rezone Bayswater Marina to what was in the existing district plan.
7335-1 Walton Ashforth Family Trust
49 Beach Road, Castor Bay,
Auckland 0620
SEAs
Land Remove the SEAs from area between Castor Bay beach and the Wairau Estuary.
7336-1 Stephen J McCarthy stephen@sjmlaw.co.nz Special Character
General
Add the Hillpark area including 38 Claude Road, Manurewa, from Halver Rd through Arthur
Rd north east and west through to the Southern Motorway, Orams Rd and Great South Rd as
a special character and historic heritage area (see attachment in submission).
7336-2 Stephen J McCarthy stephen@sjmlaw.co.nz Special Character
residential
Reclassify as a special character and historic heritage area: the Hillpark area including 38
Claude Road, Manurewa, from Halver Rd through Arthur Rd north east and west through
to the Southern Motorway, Orams Rd and Great South Rd (see attachment in submission).
7336-3 Stephen J McCarthy stephen@sjmlaw.co.nz Historic Heritage (Overlay)
Heritage
Places
Reclassify as a special character and historic heritage area: the Hillpark area including 38
Claude Road, Manurewa, from Halver Rd through Arthur Rd north east and west through
to the Southern Motorway, Orams Rd and Great South Rd (see attachment in submission).
7337-1 Kaipatiki Local Youth Board srya040@aucklanduni.ac.nz RPS Urban growth
quality compact urban form Supports housing intensification around metropolitan areas and town centres.
7337-2 Kaipatiki Local Youth Board srya040@aucklanduni.ac.nz Residential zones Residential
General
Amend the rules to require apartments to be within safe walking distances of secure
playgrounds for children.
7337-3 Kaipatiki Local Youth Board srya040@aucklanduni.ac.nz Residential zones Housing affordability H6.6 Rules
Define affordable housing being that housing costs should not exceed 30% of gross
household income, and ensure development of affordable housing is consistent with this
definition.
7337-4 Kaipatiki Local Youth Board srya040@aucklanduni.ac.nz General Miscellaneous
Operational/
Ensure that the public transport system is expanded and is affordable. Extend it to the
suburbs so that it connects residents in outer suburbs with the town centres as well as running
between town centres.
7337-5 Kaipatiki Local Youth Board srya040@aucklanduni.ac.nz Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
Provide for and don't limit parking in Metro and Town Centres until such time as the public
transport system meets the demands of all commuters.
7338-1 Mike Blackburn
251 Ponsonby Road, Freemans Bay,
General
Amend Height in Relation to Boundary rules to relate daylight requirements based on the
context of the site.
7339-1 Norman Wallace walnorm@hotmail.com RPS Mana Whenua B5 Strategic [Remove] the process of iwi approval [for resource consents].
7339-2 Norman Wallace walnorm@hotmail.com General Miscellaneous Consultation and engagement Retain public consultation for the use of public land.
7339-3 Norman Wallace walnorm@hotmail.com General Miscellaneous Consultation and engagement
Seeks public consultation for any consideration of selling off a reserve or changing its
classification as a reserve.
7340-1 John E Mortimer john@morts.co.nz Zoning North and Islands
Reject Terrace Housing and Apartment Building at block of land bordered by Hurstmere
Road, The Promenade, Earnoch Ave and Alison Ave, Takapuna.
7341-1
Arnot Investments Limited and
Steelpipe New Zealand Limited david@osbornehay.co.nz Zoning Central Retain the Heavy Industry zoning on 224 Neilson Street, Onehunga.
7341-2
Steelpipe New Zealand Limited david@osbornehay.co.nz
SEAs
Land Delete the SEA Overlay SEA_T_6229 from 224 Neilson Street, Onehunga.
583/1145
Sub#/
7341-3
Steelpipe New Zealand Limited david@osbornehay.co.nz Natural Hazards and Flooding Natural Hazards Coastal inundation - maps only
Delete or refine the coastal inundation overlay based on the 1m sea level rise (or similar for
this area) and area specific modelling from 224 Neilson Street, Onehunga.
7341-4
Steelpipe New Zealand Limited david@osbornehay.co.nz General Eplan Remove reference to Designation ID6305 from 224 Neilson Street, Onehunga.
7341-5
Centre)
desc, obs & pols Retain the objectives and policies of the Heavy Industry zone.
7341-6
Steelpipe New Zealand Limited david@osbornehay.co.nz Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
Retain Rule 3.2 Number of Parking and Loading Spaces Table 4 parking rates for industrial
activities and lock-up facilities.
7341-7
Steelpipe New Zealand Limited david@osbornehay.co.nz Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
Delete part of Rule 3.2 cycle parks for industrial activities and storage and lock-up facilities in
Table 5 Required Cycle Parking Rates.
7341-8
Steelpipe New Zealand Limited david@osbornehay.co.nz Water Stormwater H4.14 Introduction
Amend the text under 4.14 Stormwater Management as follows: 'To avoid doubt, stormwater
from a private site directed to any part of the Auckland Council a reticulated public stormwater
network is considered part of the strormwater network discharge provided it meets the
requirements of any relevant stormwater network discharge consent (where any such consent
is held).'
7341-9
Steelpipe New Zealand Limited david@osbornehay.co.nz Sustainable Development C7.7/H6.4 Sustainable design Delete Rule 2.3 Industrial Activities.
7341-10
Centre) Business
zones
Amend rule 5.3 Maximum Impervious Area as follows: '1 maximum impervious area: 80 90
per cent.'
7341-11
Centre) Business
zones
Amend rule 5.4 yards as follows: 'Riparian Yard - 10m from the edge of permanent a and
intermittent streams .'
7342-1 John Connor
31 Gazelle Avenue, Beach Haven,
Auckland 0626
control
Building demolition control J.3.6 Rules and mapping Delete the overlay from 31 Gazelle Ave, Beachhaven
7342-2 John Connor
Whenua
of value to Mana Whenua Delete the overlay from 31 Gazelle Avenue, Beachhaven.
7343-1 Abdul Hafeez
105 Parrs Cross Road, Glen Eden,
Auckland 0612 RPS Changes to the RUB West Include 105-107 Parrs Cross Road within the RUB.
7343-2 Abdul Hafeez
105 Parrs Cross Road, Glen Eden,
Auckland 0612 Zoning West [Rezone] 105-107 Parrs Cross Road for residential and small business development.
7344-1
The Church of Jesus Christ of
Latter-day Saints Trust Board david@osbornehay.co.nz RPS Issues
growth
Amend the issue to include reference to community faciities and include a new bullet point
about optimising the efficient use of existing community faciities and provide for new facilities.
[See page 4/17 of the submission for details].
7344-2
Latter-day Saints Trust Board david@osbornehay.co.nz RPS Issues
growth
Amend the text under Social Well-being to include new bullet points about places to worship
and places for cultural activities. [See page 4/17 of the submission for details].
7344-3
Latter-day Saints Trust Board david@osbornehay.co.nz RPS Urban growth B2.7 Social infrastructure
Amend the text under Social Infrastructure to include new bullet points about places to
worship and places for cultural activities. [See page 5/17 of the submission for details].
7344-4
Latter-day Saints Trust Board david@osbornehay.co.nz Transport Auckland -wide C1.2 Objectives
Amend Objective 3 by adding an additional clause as follows: 'The number, location and type
...(e) the efficient use of land d accessibility to community facilities for all sectors of the
community. '
7344-5
Latter-day Saints Trust Board david@osbornehay.co.nz Transport Auckland -wide C1.2 Policies
Add a new Parking policy as follows: ' Recognise that in some circumstances, community
facilities in all zones may require additional car parking to ensure the facility is practically
accessible to the community. '
7344-6
Latter-day Saints Trust Board david@osbornehay.co.nz Earthworks
and policies
Amend Objective 3 as follows: 'Sediment generation from earthworks is avoided, remedied or
mitigated to an appropriate level. minimised . '
7344-7
Latter-day Saints Trust Board david@osbornehay.co.nz Residential zones Residential
policies
Amend Objective 3 as follows: '3 Non-residential activities (including community facilities) that
locate in residential areas contribute to and support the amenity of the neighbourhood and
provide opportunities for social, economic and cultural well-being.'
7344-8
policies
Amend Policy 6 by deleting the existing text and replacing with the following text: ' Provide for
a range of non-residential activities to meet the needs of the community while ensuring they
will not significantly adversely affect the residential amenity of the area. '
584/1145
Sub#/
7344-9
Latter-day Saints Trust Board david@osbornehay.co.nz
Centre) Business
Amend Policy 6 as follows: ' Where appropriate require buildings to be adaptable to a range
of uses to allow activities to change over time.'
7344-10
Latter-day Saints Trust Board david@osbornehay.co.nz Future Urban
Add a new policy 7 as follows: ' To allow for the establishment of community facilities that are
planned to service the surrounding existing and/or future communities, in a manner which
does not adversely affect any adjoining rural activities or may significantly compromise the
structure planning process for the area. '
7344-11
Latter-day Saints Trust Board david@osbornehay.co.nz Rural Zones General
Amend Objective 5 as follows: 'Industries, services and non-residential activities of an urban
type and scale unrelated to rural production activities are directed away from rural zones
unless they meet in part the social and/or cultural requirements of the wider community.'
7344-12
Latter-day Saints Trust Board david@osbornehay.co.nz Rural Zones General
Amend Policy 4 as follows: ' Where appropriate, require buildings and other significant
structures to be in character with the surrounding rural area and, as far as practicable, to be of
a similar scale and form to buildings required for non-intensive rural production activities'.
7344-13
Latter-day Saints Trust Board david@osbornehay.co.nz Mana Whenua General provisions
assessment
Amend the entire chapter 2.7.4 Cultural Impact Assessment so that it: (a) Better defines when
a Cultural Impact Assessment may be required; (b) Allows for a CIA to be prepared either by
a representative of the mana whenua or a suitably qualified party; (c) Recongnises that only
one CIA is required even if there are multiple mana whenua for the area (and in such cases a
CIA by a third party rather than a specific mana whenua representative may be more
appropriate); (d) is not prescriptive of what is required in the CIA as this should be the joint
determination of the applicant and the party preparing the CIA.
7344-14
Latter-day Saints Trust Board david@osbornehay.co.nz Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
Amend Development Control 3.2 Table 3 to include a car parking rate for community facilities
(the same as Table 4).
7344-15
requirements
Amend Development Control 3.2 Table 4 car parking rate for entertainment facilities, club
rooms and community facilities by adding text as follows: ' 0.2 per person the facility is
designed to accommodate except that for places of worship that include both a Chapel and
Hall that are not occupied at the same time, the parking requirement for the larger of the two
may be used. '
7344-16
requirements Delete Development Control 3.3 Design of parking and loading spaces (1)(e) (i) and (ii).
7344-17
Latter-day Saints Trust Board david@osbornehay.co.nz Earthworks H4.2.2 Controls
Delete General controls 2.1.1(10) which state: The earthworks must be located at least 20m
from any scheduled historic heritage place or scheduled sites and places of significance to
Mana Whenua .
7344-18
Latter-day Saints Trust Board david@osbornehay.co.nz Earthworks H4.2.2 Controls
Delete General controls 2.1.1(16) which state: To prevent the spread of Kauri Dieback
disease, vehicle and equipment hygiene techniques must be adopted so that no soil from
earthworks within 30m of a New Zealand kauri tree is transported off site.
7344-19
Latter-day Saints Trust Board david@osbornehay.co.nz Earthworks H4.2.3 Assessment
Delete Matters of discretion 3.1(1)(p) landscape treatment, screening and site layout and
design.
7344-20
Latter-day Saints Trust Board david@osbornehay.co.nz Water Stormwater H4.14 Introduction
Amend the paragraph under Introduction to 4.14 Stormwater management as follows: 'To
avoid doubt, stormwater from a private site directed to any part of the Auckland Council a
reticulated public stormwter network is considered part of the stormwater network discharge
provided it meets the requirement of any relevant stormwater network discharge consent
(where any such consent is held). '
7344-21
Latter-day Saints Trust Board david@osbornehay.co.nz Water Stormwater
H4.14.2 Stormwater
management -flow rules Amend the permitted threshold for areas in a SMAF to 400m
2
.
7344-22
Latter-day Saints Trust Board david@osbornehay.co.nz Water Stormwater
Amend the extent of SMAF areas across Auckland so they only apply to those areas with
significant stormwater flow constraints / issues and where there is no practical or economic
alternative except on-site stormwater retention.
7344-23
Latter-day Saints Trust Board david@osbornehay.co.nz Residential zones Residential Activity Table Retain the Discretionary Activity status for community facilities.
7344-24
Special info. req.
Amend Rule 1.12 Table 9 to state that Design Statements are not required for Community
Facilities.
7344-25
Centre) Business
& Bus. Park zones
Amend activity status for community facilities to Permitted [from Discretionary] in
Neighbourhood Centre and Business Park zones.
585/1145
Sub#/
7344-26
Centre) Business
Amend activity status for community facilities to Permitted [from Discretionary] in Light
Industry zone.
7344-27
Centre) Business
Park zones
Amend Control 4.15 'yards' as follows: Side and rear yards ... within five years of planting.
This rule does not apply to community facilities.
7344-28
Latter-day Saints Trust Board david@osbornehay.co.nz Future Urban I5 Rules Amend Activity Table to provide for Community Facilities as Discretionary Activities.
7344-29
Latter-day Saints Trust Board david@osbornehay.co.nz Definitions Existing Amend the definition of 'Height' to include 'Church Spires' within the list of exclusions.
7344-30
Latter-day Saints Trust Board david@osbornehay.co.nz Definitions Existing
Amend the definition of 'Height' to include the following: 'Church spires not exceeding 20m in
height and located at least 3m off all boundaries'.
7344-31
Latter-day Saints Trust Board david@osbornehay.co.nz General
GIS viewer Remove the flood prone area from 5-7 Taharoto Road, Takapuna.
7344-32
Latter-day Saints Trust Board david@osbornehay.co.nz Precincts - City Centre Residential Remove the Residential Precinct from 2 Scotia Place, Auckland CBD.
7344-33
Latter-day Saints Trust Board david@osbornehay.co.nz Precincts - City Centre Residential Remove the Residential Precinct from 407-409 Queen Street, Auckland CBD.
7344-34
Latter-day Saints Trust Board david@osbornehay.co.nz RPS Changes to the RUB South
Rezone 1185 Alfriston Road, Alfriston, from Future Urban Zoning to Residential (possibly
Mixed Housing Suburban).
7344-35
Latter-day Saints Trust Board david@osbornehay.co.nz Zoning Central
Rezone the whole site at 15-19 Pilkington Road, Panmure, from split zoning of Town Centre -
Panmure and Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings to Town Centre - Panmure.
7344-36
Latter-day Saints Trust Board david@osbornehay.co.nz Precincts - Central Tmaki Mapping Remove 15-19 Pilkington Road, Panmure, from Tamaki Precinct.
7344-37
Latter-day Saints Trust Board david@osbornehay.co.nz Precincts - Central Tmaki K2.22 Precinct Rules
Amend the rules to exempt the redevelopment of existing community facility sites on 15-19
Pilkington Road, Panmure, from the Tamaki Precinct Rules.
7344-38
Centre)
Maps only Remove General Commerical Frontage Control from 15-19 Pilkington Road, Panmure.
7344-39
GIS viewer Amend the extent of the flood prone area on 75 Ferguson Road, Otara.
7344-40
Latter-day Saints Trust Board david@osbornehay.co.nz Zoning South Rezone 204 Hingaia Road, Papakura, to Single House.
7344-41
GIS viewer
Amend the extent of Flood Plain based on any recent modelling undertaken for 204 Hingaia
Road, Papakura.
7344-42
Latter-day Saints Trust Board david@osbornehay.co.nz Zoning South Rezone 123 Coronation Road, Mangere, to Light Industry or another Business Zone.
7344-43
shafts survey coordinates Remove Blanket Height Sensitive Area Overlay from 123 Coronation Road, Mangere.
7344-44
GIS viewer Remove or amend the flood plain area from 123 Coronation Road, Mangere.
7344-45
Latter-day Saints Trust Board david@osbornehay.co.nz General Eplan Remove Designation 6709 from the 19 Redoubt Road, Manukau.
7344-46
Latter-day Saints Trust Board david@osbornehay.co.nz General Eplan Amend the property summary for 19 Redoubt Road, Manukau, to remove Designation [6709].
586/1145
Sub#/
7344-47
Latter-day Saints Trust Board david@osbornehay.co.nz Precincts - Central Tmaki Mapping Remove 9 Taniwha Street, Glen Innes, from Tamaki Precinct.
7344-48
Latter-day Saints Trust Board david@osbornehay.co.nz Precincts - Central Tmaki K2.22 Precinct Rules
Amend the rules to exempt re-development of existing community facility sites from the
Tamaki Precinct Rules for 9 Taniwha Street, Glen Innes.
7344-49
Latter-day Saints Trust Board david@osbornehay.co.nz Zoning Central
Rezone whole site at 487 Blockhouse Bay Road, Blockhouse Bay, from split zoning of Mixed
Housing Suburban and Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings to Terrace Housing and
7344-50
control
Building demolition control J.3.6 Rules and mapping Remove Pre-1944 Demolition Control Overlay from 205 Captain Springs Road, Onehunga.
7344-51
Latter-day Saints Trust Board david@osbornehay.co.nz Special Character
& C
Isthmus Remove Special Character Overlay from 35 & 37 Calgary Street, Sandringham.
7344-52
Latter-day Saints Trust Board david@osbornehay.co.nz Trees
Trees
Notable Trees
Amend the scheduled tree notation to correct location at 1-5 Kiwitea Street, and 35-37
Calgary Street, Sandringham.
7344-53
GIS viewer Remove or refine flood prone overlay from 35-37 Calgary Street.
7344-54
GIS viewer Remove flood plain overlay from 11 Huron Street, Takapuna.
7344-55
GIS viewer Remove flood sensitive overlay from 11 Huron Street, Takapuna.
7344-56
GIS viewer Remove or refine flood prone overlay from 30 Ashlynne Avenue, Papatoetoe.
7344-57
GIS viewer Remove or refine flood plain overlay from 27 Bairds Road, Otara.
7344-58
GIS viewer Remove or refine flood plain overlay from 33 Dawson Road, Otara.
7344-59
Latter-day Saints Trust Board david@osbornehay.co.nz Trees
Trees
Notable Trees Remove Notable Tree - 1786 from 49 McKenzie Road, Mangere.
7344-60
GIS viewer Remove or refine flood plain overlay from 27-28 Fraser Road, Papatoetoe.
7344-61
GIS viewer Remove or refine flood plain overlay from 66 Yates Road, Mangere.
7344-62
Latter-day Saints Trust Board david@osbornehay.co.nz General Eplan
Remove reference to Designation 6500 on 66 Rua Road, Glen Eden, from planning maps and
property summary.
7344-63
GIS viewer Remove or refine flood plain overlay from 152 Universal Drive, Henderson.
7344-64
Latter-day Saints Trust Board david@osbornehay.co.nz General Eplan Remove reference to SMAF2 in the property summary of 152 Universal Drive, Henderson.
7344-65
Amend Objective 1 as follows: 'An high quality economically and socially sustainable network
of social infrastructure that meets Aucklanders' needs both locally and regionally.' [See page
7344-66
Amend Objective 2 as follows: 'Social infrastructure is located where it is accessible by a
range of transport modes where practicable.' [See page 5/17 of the submission].
587/1145
Sub#/
7344-67
Amend Policy 1 (a) and (c) as follows: '(a) local small-scale social infrastructure so they are
accessible and affordable to local communities e.g. medical centres, places of worship, care
centres, primary schools, community halls and cultural facilities; (c) larger-scale land
extensive social infrastructure e.g. hospitals, universities, large community churches, marae
and large cultural facilities and secondary schools in locations where the existing and/or
proposed roading network has sufficient capacity, and, where practicable, in close proximity to
the public transport network and the walking and cycling networks.' [See page 5/17 of
submission].
7344-68
Amend Policy 2(d) as follows: 'identifying new growth ... via tools such as land acquisition,
resource consents, structure planning and designations to secure sites for future social
infrastructure.' [See [age 5/17 of the submission].
7344-69
Amend Policy 5 as follows: 'Manage the transport effects of large scale social infrastructure to
an appropriate level and in an integrated manner.' [See page 5/17 of the submission].
7344-70
Amend Policy 6 by deleting 6(b) and amending 6(c) and 6(d) as follows: '(c) Where
appropriate and economically viable incorporate the principles of sustainable building design;
(d) maintain or improve the amenity of any adjoining streets and site.' [See page 6/17 of the
7344-71
Centre) Business
Special information
requirements
Amend Table 8 'Design statement requirements' in the 'Special information requirements' rule
to state that Design Statements are not required for Community Facilities. [See page 12/17 of
the submission].
7345-1
Yuen Seng Liew and Victoria
Oei
1/29 Gazelle Avenue, Beach Haven,
Auckland 0626
control
Building demolition control J.3.6 Rules and mapping Delete the overlay from 1/29 Gazelle Avenue, Beachhaven
7345-2
Yuen Seng Liew and Victoria
Oei
1/29 Gazelle Avenue, Beach Haven,
Whenua
of value to Mana Whenua Remove the overlay from 1/29 Gazelle Avenue, Beachhaven.
7346-1 M and A Perkinson david@osbornehay.co.nz Zoning North and Islands Rezone 181, 185 and 193A Gills Road, Albany, to Single House.
7346-2 M and A Perkinson david@osbornehay.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - Urban zones
except Rural
Remove the "Built Environment: Additional Subdivision Controls - Albany North 1500m
2
"
overlay over 193A Gills Road, Albany.
7346-3 M and A Perkinson david@osbornehay.co.nz
SEAs
Land
Remove the SEA from the area required for the Silver Moon Road extension (which goes
from the current end of Silver Moon Road to 193A Gills Road, Albany).
7346-4 M and A Perkinson david@osbornehay.co.nz Zoning North and Islands
Amend Planning Maps by showing the final approved road alignment for Silver Moon Road
extension (which is a refined version of the indicative road in Plan Change 32 to the Auckland
Council District Plan North Shore Section).
7347-1 Victor Bond victorebond@gmail.com RPS Urban growth
quality compact urban form Retain Objective 3.
quality compact urban form Retain Policy 2.
quality compact urban form Retain Policy 8.
land for urban development Retain Policy 3.
land for urban development Retain Policy 4(b).
retain affordable housing Retain Policy 1.
7347-7 Victor Bond victorebond@gmail.com Zoning North and Islands Retain the Mixed Housing Suburban zone surrounding 39 Gazelle Ave, Beachaven
7347-8 Victor Bond victorebond@gmail.com Subdivision Auckland-wide - general
and policies Retain this Chapter
7347-9 Victor Bond victorebond@gmail.com Residential zones
obs & pols Retain the objectives and policies
7347-10 Victor Bond victorebond@gmail.com Zoning North and Islands Retain the Mixed Housing Suburban zone for 39 Gazelle Avenue, Beachhaven
7347-11 Victor Bond victorebond@gmail.com Designations Minister of Defence
4311 Whenuapai Airfield
Approach and Departure Path
Protection Retain designation.
7347-12 Victor Bond victorebond@gmail.com Precincts - North Chelsea Retain the Chelsea precinct
7347-13 Victor Bond victorebond@gmail.com Residential zones Residential Activity Table Retain dwellings as a Permitted Activity in the Mixed Housing Suburban zone.
7347-14 Victor Bond victorebond@gmail.com Residential zones Residential Land use controls Retain the Maximum Density provisions for the Mixed Housing zone.
7347-15 Victor Bond victorebond@gmail.com Residential zones Residential
Mixed Housing Urban zone Retain the Development Controls for the Mixed Housing zone.
7347-16 Victor Bond victorebond@gmail.com
control
Building demolition control J.3.6 Rules and mapping Delete the overlay from 39 Gazelle Avenue, Beachhaven
588/1145
Sub#/
7347-17 Victor Bond victorebond@gmail.com Mana Whenua
Whenua
7348-1 Glyn E Williams glyn.w@clear.net.nz General Editorial and Part 6
Amend the PAUP to remove the terminology where the meaning is unclear and open to wide
interpretation. This must include the removal of any rules requiring compliance with the
principles of the Treaty of Waitangi.
7348-2 Glyn E Williams glyn.w@clear.net.nz RPS Mana Whenua B5 Strategic
Amend the PAUP to allow for mediation concerning the rights of individual property owners
and the protection of sites of cultural significance and heritage value, with the burden of proof
falling on those who wish to restrict the owner's use and enjoyment of the property.
7348-3 Glyn E Williams glyn.w@clear.net.nz Mana Whenua
Whenua
Amend the PAUP so the scheduled places of significance to Mana Whenua are graded into
categories that fairly reflect their significance and accordingly be granted varying degrees of
protection instead of having the single highest level of protection.
7348-4 Glyn E Williams glyn.w@clear.net.nz Mana Whenua General provisions
discovery protocol
Add a rule requiring any person carrying out work to be required to immediately cease work
and notify Council in the event that artefacts and other items are discovered that might have
some significance to Mori.
assessment
Amend the rules so the Council be the agency responsible for preparing any Cultural Impact
Assessment deemed necessary by Council.
assessment
Amend the rules so that should consultation with iwi be required under the RMA, the process
be clearly outlined, and firm costs time lines be provided for the consultation process, and that
these be strictly monitored by Council.
7348-7 Glyn E Williams glyn.w@clear.net.nz General Editorial and Part 6
Amend the PAUP to provide certainty and to ensure that the regulations make sense, and are
clear and easy to follow.
7349-1
Northcote Residents'
Association admin@nra.org.nz RPS Urban growth
Retain the overall thrust of the PAUP that Auckland needs to go up more than out, and that
means multi storey accomodation focussed at and in proximity to town centres such as
Northcote.
7349-2
environment
Retain the overall thrust of the PAUP that shows a general commitment to good quality
development which is positive.
7349-3
Association admin@nra.org.nz
control
Retain the heritage protection provided in the PAUP via continuation of the former North
Shore City Council Residential 3 zoning at Northcote Point and that via application of the pre-
1944 demolition control at the extended area adjoining Northcote Point north of Onewa Road.
7349-4
Add a provision that the outward spread [of development] be restricted to 1/3 of a km from the
commercial centre until this is 2/3 developed in intensified housing - then to be followed by the
next 1/3 km and so on [staged approach].
7349-5
Association admin@nra.org.nz Residential zones Residential
General
Amend rules to require design approval for 2 and 3 dwelling developments rather than 4 or
more dwellings.
7349-6
Association admin@nra.org.nz Residential zones Residential Notification
Delete the provision that allows developments which infringe less than 3 rules to be dealt with
as a Restricted Discretionary Activity which will not require the consent of neighbours.
7349-7
Centre) Business
Park zones
Amend the development controls on set backs so that the first set back in commercial areas
should be at the 3rd storey, not 4 and again after 6 storeys.
7349-8
Association admin@nra.org.nz General Miscellaneous
Operational/
Amend the PAUP to deliver 'liveability' by providing additional transport infrastructure capacity
of public and private modes of transport in Onewa and on Lake Road.
7349-9
Association admin@nra.org.nz General Miscellaneous
Operational/
Amend the PAUP to deliver 'liveability' by developing other infrastructure such as stormwater
management and sewage disposal to keep up with population growth in Northcote and
Birkenhead of the North Shore.
7349-10
Amend the PAUP to provide the supporting infrastructure where intensification is allowed,
rather than through political considerations.
7349-11
policies
Add an objective to retain existing levels of amenity for established residential
neighbourhoods, especially in relation to Northcote.
7349-12
Amend Policy 2(b) as follows: ' ... in areas close to the frequent public transport routes and
facilities where this can be expanded adequately to cater for population growth' .
7349-13
Amend Policy 2(d) as follows: 'adequately serviced by existing physical infrastructure or where
infrastructure can be up-graded efficiently '
7349-14
Amend Policy 2 by adding a paragraph as follows: ' while ensuring that the interface between
'terrace/apartment', 'mixed' and 'single housing' zones is managed sensitively and in a way
which does not impact negatively on the living environment, residential amenity or value of
smaller adjoining properties.'
589/1145
Sub#/
7349-15
environment
Amend the PAUP to provide that a sample of building developments be regularly assessed or
reviewed against the Objectives and Policies. If there is a shortfall, a combination of the
Design Manual and planning regulations should be adjusted to meet the expectations of the
Objectives and Policies to ensure the long term 'liveability' of Auckland.
7349-16
Association admin@nra.org.nz Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
Delete the part of Development Control 3.2 that sets a maximum limit of 2 car-parks per
residential property in the Mixed Housing Suburban and Single Housing zones.
7349-17
Centre) Business
Park zones
Amend Development Control 4.3 'height-to-boundary' to replace the 60 degrees from 8m with
45 degrees.
7349-18
Centre) Business
Park zones
Amend Development Control 4.15 'ground level set back from boundaries' from 3m to a
minimum of 5m.
7349-19
Association admin@nra.org.nz Residential zones Residential Activity Table
Amend the rules to require that all multiple dwelling sites should be Discretionary Activities for
2 and 3 dwellings.
7349-20
Amend the rules to require notification for 4 or more dwellings for nearby sites likely to be
affected by the development.
7349-21
General Amend the rules to require all [development] to be subject to the Design Manual.
7349-22
Mixed Housing Urban zone Retain Development Control 7.3 'building height in relation to boundaries' at 2.5m/45 degrees.
7349-23
Delete Rule 7.4 'Alternative height in relation to boundary' [in the Mixed Housing Suburban
zone].
7349-24
Amend Rule 7.5 'Yards' so that the side yard requirement is increased from 1 to 2m, and the
rear [yard] retained at 4m [in the Mixed Housing Suburban zone].
7349-25
Amend Rule 7.17 'Minimum dwelling sizes' so that the minimum dwelling size be 50m
2
for
studios and 60 for 1 bedroom apartments [in the Mixed Housing Suburban zone].
7349-26
Association admin@nra.org.nz Residential zones Residential Activity Table
Amend the rules to require all multiple dwelling sites to be Discretionary Activities [in the
Mixed Housing Urban zone].
7349-27
Amend the rules to require public notification of applications for 4 or more dwellings for nearby
sites likely to be affected by the development [in the Mixed Housing Urban zone].
7349-28
Amend Rule 8.3 'Height in relation to boundary' so the 'start height' for the 45 degree slope is
2.5m not 3m.
7349-29
Mixed Housing Urban zone Delete Rule 8.4 'Alternative height in relation to boundary' [in the Mixed Housing Urban zone].
7349-30
Amend Rule 8.6 'Yards' so the provision is increased to 3m at the front boundary, 2m for the
side boundary and 4m for the rear boundary [in the Mixed Housing Urban zone].
7349-31
Amend Rule 8.17 so the 'Minimum dwelling size' is 50m
2
for studios and 60m
2
for 1 bedroom
apartments [in the Mixed Housing Urban zone].
7349-32
Association admin@nra.org.nz Built Environment (Overlays)
Height Control
Delete the Additional Height Control of 17.5m/5 storeys in the areas flanking Northcote
Central.
7349-33
Terrace Housing and
Amend Rule 9.3 'Yards' so the yard rule on all sides of buildings is 3m [in the Terrace Housing
and Apartment Buildings zone].
7349-34
Terrace Housing and
Add a new control about height-to-boundary [in the Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings
zone] which requires that on boundaries with other residential zones, the standard 45 degree
'light-line' is required.
7349-35
Association admin@nra.org.nz Zoning North and Islands
Rezone the area around the Northcote Town Centre and the intersection of Onewa Road and
Woodside Avenue from the existing zone to a less intensive zone in accordance with the zone
maps attached in Appendix 3 pages 18-20/23 of the submission.
7349-36
SEAs
Land Amend the total size of an SEA so that it is limted to 40% of total property size.
7349-37
SEAs
Assessment Amend the controls so the minimum clearance from dwellings be increased from 3m to 5m.
590/1145
Sub#/
7349-38
SEAs
Assessment Add control about a minimum clearance from 'hard' outdoor installations such as patios.
7349-39
SEAs
Amend the controls to allow vegetation removal and reasonable pruning as a Permitted
Activity inside the first 10m.
7349-40
SEAs
Amend the controls to provide boundary fencing as a Permitted Activity within the SEA for
protection and demarcation.
7349-41
Association admin@nra.org.nz Mana Whenua
Whenua
and policies
Amend the provisions so that they only apply within 30 meters not 50m of a site or place of
value.
7349-42
Association admin@nra.org.nz Mana Whenua
Whenua J5.2 Rules
Amend the assessment criteria 1.a. to read: 'Whether the proposal could reasonably be seen
to have a negative impact on the relationship of Mana Whenua ...'
7349-43
Association admin@nra.org.nz Public Open Space Zones Public Open Space I2.1 Activity table
Amend the activity status of 'camping grounds' in the 'Conservation zone' and the 'Informal
Recreation zone' to Non Complying.
7349-44
Amend the activity status of 'A single workers' accommodation dwelling' in the 'Conservation
zone' to Non Complying; and that in the 'Informal Recreaion zone' and the 'Sport and Active
Recreation zone' to Restricted Discretionary.
7349-45
Amend the activity status of 'Visitor accommodation - huts and lodges only' in the
'Conservation zone' to Non Complying.
7349-46
Amend the activity status of 'Community centres and halls' in the 'Informal Recreation zone'
and the 'Sport and Active Recreation zone' to Restricted Discretionary.
7349-47
Amend the activity status of 'Arts and cultural centres' in the 'Sport and Active Recreation
zone' to Restricted Discretionary.
7349-48
Association admin@nra.org.nz Public Open Space Zones Public Open Space I2.1 Activity table Amend the activity status of 'Clubrooms' in the 'Conservation zone' to Non Complying.
7349-49
Amend the activity status of 'Libraries' in the 'Informal Recreation zone' and the 'Sport and
Active Recreation zone' to Non Complying.
7349-50
Amend the activity status of 'Offices and administration accessory to a permitted activity' in
the 'Conservation zone' to Non Complying.
7349-51
Amend the activity status of 'Organised sport and recreation' in the 'Informal Recreation
zone' to Non Complying.
7349-52
Association admin@nra.org.nz Public Open Space Zones Public Open Space I2.1 Activity table Amend the activity status of 'Markets' in the 'Informal Recreation zone' to Non Complying.
7349-53
Amend the activity status of 'Restaurants and cafes, excluding a drive-through facility,
accessory to a permitted activity and further than 50m from a residential zone' in the 'Informal
Recreation zone' and the 'Sport and Active Recreation zone' to Non Complying.
7349-54
Amend the activity status of 'Restaurants and cafes, excluding a drive-through facility,
accessory to a permitted activity and within 50m from a residential zone' in the 'Informal
7349-55
Amend the activity status of 'Retail not otherwise provided for' in the 'Informal Recreation
zone' and the 'Sport and Active Recreation zone' to Non Complying.
7349-56
Amend the activity status of 'Farming or grazing as part of a management programme for the
public open space' in the 'Conservation zone', the 'Informal Recreation zone' and the 'Sport
and Active Recreation zone' to Non Complying.
7349-57
Amend the activity status of 'New buildings and external additions to existing buildings' in the
'Conservation zone' and the 'Informal Recreation zone' to Non Complying and that in
the 'Sport and Active Recreation zone' to Discretionary.
7349-58
Amend the activity status of 'New buildings and external additions to existing buildings
exceeding the gross floor area threshold clause 3.8 below' in the 'Conservation zone' to
Restricted Discretionary and that in the 'Informal Recreation zone' to Non Complying.
7349-59
Amend the activity status of 'Maimais - erection, use, alteration, maintenance and demolition
associated with lawful gamebird hunting' in the 'Conservation zone' and the 'Informal
7349-60
Amend the activity status of 'Sport and recreation structures' in the 'Informal Recreation zone'
to Non-Complying.
7350-1 Quentin Smith
29 Killarney Street, Takapuna,
Rezone 25, 27 and 29 Killarney St, Takapuna from Mixed Housing Suburban to Terrace
7351-1 John and Daphne Mooney
Auckland 0626
control
7351-2 John and Daphne Mooney
Whenua
whenua Delete the overlay from 33 Gazelle Avenue, Beachhaven
7352-1 Robert M Ross bobross@paradise.net.nz General Miscellaneous Other
Adopt the relief sought in the submission by HBRAI [Herne Bay Residents Association
Incorporated].
591/1145
Sub#/
7353-1 Bruce H Ross bruceross@orcon.net.nz RPS Urban growth
Amend to contain clear, binding processes and rules that allow for intensification of residential
housing so that all building consents are fully open to public scrutiny.
Amend to contain clear, binding, processes and rules that allow for housing intensification that
does not depend upon, or privilege private car use and ownership.
environment
Amend provisions to contain clear binding processes and rules that provide criteria for good
design standards of all buildings on small subdivisions terrace houses and apartment blocks.
7353-4 Bruce H Ross bruceross@orcon.net.nz General Miscellaneous Special housing areas
Amend to ensure that all resource consents for special housing areas follow due processes in
particular the requirements of the Resource Management Act.
7353-5 Bruce H Ross bruceross@orcon.net.nz General Chapter G General provisions G2.4 Notification
Amend to require all applications for discretionary consents to build outside of the established
principles, policy statements, district objectives, district policies and rules of the Unitary Plan
to be publicly notifiable.
7353-6 Bruce H Ross bruceross@orcon.net.nz Residential zones Residential
General
Amend to require a traffic management plan as part of all resource consents for new
apartments and terrace homes with more than 2 units or dwellings, and for all residential
subdivisions in all housing zones.
7353-7 Bruce H Ross bruceross@orcon.net.nz Residential zones Residential
General
Add statutory design specifications and clear enforceable criteria regarding energy efficiency,
room sizes, green space and public access around apartment complexes that can only be
changed through a notifiable discretionary resource consent.
7353-8 Bruce H Ross bruceross@orcon.net.nz Precincts - North Bayswater K5.6 Precinct rules Amend to make residential housing a non complying activity.
7353-9 Bruce H Ross bruceross@orcon.net.nz General Miscellaneous Special housing areas
Amend to require resource consents for residential building on special housing areas and
designated precincts to follow due process and by publically notified.
7353-10 Bruce H Ross bruceross@orcon.net.nz General Miscellaneous Other
Adopt the relief sought in the submission by Environmental Defence Society's on urban forest,
biodiversity and coastal and marine provisions.
7354-1
Carl Johnson and Claire
Barker carlausnz@hotmail.com
control
7354-2
Carl Johnson and Claire
Barker carlausnz@hotmail.com Mana Whenua
Whenua
7355-1 Lynn Usmani lynn@theaunties.co.nz RPS Urban growth
environment Retain Objective 3
land for urban development Retain Objectives 1, 2, 3, 4.
land for urban development Retain Policy 3 and 4(b).
7355-7 Lynn Usmani lynn@theaunties.co.nz Zoning North and Islands Retain the Mixed Housing Suburban zone surrounding 37 Gazelle Avenue, Beachhaven
7355-8 Lynn Usmani lynn@theaunties.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - general
and policies Retain this chapter.
7355-9 Lynn Usmani lynn@theaunties.co.nz Residential zones
obs & pols Retain these objectives and policies.
7355-10 Lynn Usmani lynn@theaunties.co.nz Zoning North and Islands Retain the Mixed Housing Suburban zone at Gazelle Avenue, Beachaven.
7355-11 Lynn Usmani lynn@theaunties.co.nz Designations Minister of Defence
Protection Retain the Designation
7355-12 Lynn Usmani lynn@theaunties.co.nz Precincts - North Chelsea Retain the Precinct
7355-13 Lynn Usmani lynn@theaunties.co.nz Residential zones Residential Activity Table Retain dwellings as a Permitted Activity in the the Mixed Housing Suburban zone.
7355-14 Lynn Usmani lynn@theaunties.co.nz Residential zones Residential Land use controls Retain the Maximum Density control for the Mixed Housing Suburban zone.
7355-15 Lynn Usmani lynn@theaunties.co.nz Residential zones Residential
Mixed Housing Urban zone Retain the development controls for the Mixed Housing Suburban zone.
7355-16 Lynn Usmani lynn@theaunties.co.nz
control
7355-17 Lynn Usmani lynn@theaunties.co.nz Mana Whenua
Whenua
7356-1 Karepiro Holdings Limited
c/- Cabra Developments Limited, PO
Box 197, Orewa, Auckland 0931 Zoning North and Islands
Rezone the parts of 24 Arklow Lane and 76 Karepiro Drive, Stanmore Bay that are Mixed Use
to Mixed Housing Urban split zoning, see page 7/42 of submission].
592/1145
Sub#/
7357-1 Ho Yin Anthony Leung a_leung@outlook.com Residential zones Residential
General
Amend front yard setbacks to be removed or reduced, particularly in zones where
intensification is anticipated.
7357-2 Ho Yin Anthony Leung a_leung@outlook.com Residential zones Residential Land use controls
Amend density limits to be removed for development of four or more dwellings in the Mixed
7357-3 Ho Yin Anthony Leung a_leung@outlook.com Residential zones Residential Land use controls Delete density limits in the Mixed Housing Urban zone.
7357-4 Ho Yin Anthony Leung a_leung@outlook.com Transport Auckland -wide
requirements Remove parking minimums from Mixed Housing Urban and Mixed Housing Suburban.
7357-5 Ho Yin Anthony Leung a_leung@outlook.com
Centre) Business
Park zones Increase the maximum building height in the Mixed Use zone.
7357-6 Ho Yin Anthony Leung a_leung@outlook.com Zoning Central Rezone the Central Isthmus to Mixed Housing or Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings.
7358-1 Ian Barton ibtrees@wc.net.nz General Miscellaneous Special housing areas
Greater consideration should be given to the Wesley College Special Housing Area before
the project is signed off. The sewerage disposal proposals should be divulged and better uses
for the site considered.
7358-2 Ian Barton ibtrees@wc.net.nz Historic Heritage (Overlay)
Heritage
Places Protect heritage buildings on the Wesley College site [801 Paerata Road, Pukekohe].
7358-3 Ian Barton ibtrees@wc.net.nz RPS Changes to the RUB South
Investigate the possibility of having only 'Countryside Living' north of Paerata, intermixed with
a node, perhaps centered on Wesley College, dedicated to educational facilities and high
tech.
Opposed to small section development at Wesley College Special Housing Area, and
consider its use for mixed development, in part a tertiary education/ R & D type establishment;
with the remainder going to mixed housing.
If the chapel, original 1923 school buildings, hospital and water tower [on the Wesley College
site at 801 Paerata Road, Pukekohe] require earthquake strengthening then some of the
money obtained from the sale of the site for a special housing area should go toward this.
7358-6 Ian Barton ibtrees@wc.net.nz Historic Heritage (Overlay)
Heritage
Places Develop Pukekohe into a heritage town.
7358-7 Ian Barton ibtrees@wc.net.nz
SEAs
and policies
Add an Urban Forest Plan which outlines the value of trees to communities and clearly states
the requirements for protection and management, putting all urban forest issues in to one part
of the plan.
7358-8 Ian Barton ibtrees@wc.net.nz RPS
Determine a methodology to reasonably apportion the costs of any work on any vegetation,
structure, building or place deemed to be of heritage value between the owner and the
council.
7358-9 Ian Barton ibtrees@wc.net.nz RPS
character and natural heritage B4.1 Historic heritage Add a system of penalties to be applied to those who damage or remove any heritage item.
7359-1
Positive Planning Team -
Petition with 51 Signatures mark@glasshape.net.nz RPS Urban growth
land for urban development Retain growth plan for Auckland, particularly in Warkworth.
7359-2
Ensure infrastructure is in place in Warkworth to meet the current needs and increased
growth.
7359-3
Petition with 51 Signatures mark@glasshape.net.nz General Miscellaneous Other
Build a Western Collector Bypass in Warkworth and continue it towards Matakana and
Sandspit as described in submission [page 6/28] and indicate mark these as indicative paper
roads in the PAUP.
7359-4
Petition with 51 Signatures mark@glasshape.net.nz Zoning North and Islands
Rezone parts of Warkworth for industrial uses as the available land on Morrison Drive is too
sloped.
7359-5
Petition with 51 Signatures mark@glasshape.net.nz RPS Changes to the RUB North and Waiheke Island
Rezone land from Mahurangi College west along the river boundary to Woodcocks Bridge,
Warkworth as Light Industry.
7359-6
Petition with 51 Signatures mark@glasshape.net.nz Zoning North and Islands
Rezone land around the restirement village near Mahurangi College, Warkworth as a green
buffer.
7359-7
Petition with 51 Signatures mark@glasshape.net.nz Zoning North and Islands Rezone the Perrindale land, Warkworth to quality commercial/industrial.
7359-8
Rezone land along the new Western Collector Bypass behind Hudson Road, Warkworth from
Future Urban to industrial.
7359-9
Petition with 51 Signatures mark@glasshape.net.nz RPS Changes to the RUB North and Waiheke Island Rezone land on Hudson Road/State Highway 1 corner, Warkworth as bulk retail.
7359-10
Rezone land on Morrison Drive towards Valerie Close in Warkworth from Future Urban to
industrial.
7359-11
Petition with 51 Signatures mark@glasshape.net.nz Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
Develop a two tier parking rule system, one that suits the big city parking needs, one that is
smaller town friendly making provision for longer parking zones until the Council identifies and
provides more parking areas.
593/1145
Sub#/
7359-12
Petition with 51 Signatures mark@glasshape.net.nz RPS Changes to the RUB North and Waiheke Island Rezone land in Warkworth close to the Bypass motorway connections as residential.
7359-13
Petition with 51 Signatures mark@glasshape.net.nz
control
Delete blanket historic zonings over large areas in Warkworth and replace with identified/titles
that should have such restrictions.
7359-14
Petition with 51 Signatures mark@glasshape.net.nz General Miscellaneous
Operational/
Projects/Acquisition Permit the proposed bore water pump at Sanderson Road, Warkworth.
7359-15
land for urban development Upgrade the sewage system in Warkworth with capacity for future growth.
7359-16
Petition with 51 Signatures mark@glasshape.net.nz Zoning North and Islands Rezone land in Warkworth for a new cemetery.
7359-17
Petition with 51 Signatures mark@glasshape.net.nz General Miscellaneous Other Extend the McKinney Road, Warkworth cemetery on the south side.
7359-18
Petition with 51 Signatures mark@glasshape.net.nz Residential zones Residential Activity Table
Amend the activity status of Community Facilities, specifically places of worship, to be a
Permitted Activity rather than a Discretionary Activity.
7359-19
Petition with 51 Signatures mark@glasshape.net.nz Residential zones Residential
General Add criteria for places of worship within residential zones e.g. require road frontage.
7359-20
Petition with 51 Signatures mark@glasshape.net.nz General Miscellaneous Other Provide curbs and footpaths on roads in Warkworth.
7359-21
Petition with 51 Signatures mark@glasshape.net.nz General Miscellaneous Other Seal all roads within 3km of Warkworth.
7359-22
Petition with 51 Signatures mark@glasshape.net.nz Future Urban
and Open Space
Indicate future zone changes on PAUP maps to show where future green belts, parks and
leisure areas will be along the river in Warkworth.
7359-23
Petition with 51 Signatures mark@glasshape.net.nz Water Stormwater
H4.14.2 Stormwater
Amend 25m
2
requirement for impervious areas to be more realistic to not include areas such
as driveways.
7359-24
Petition with 51 Signatures mark@glasshape.net.nz RPS Mana Whenua B5 Strategic Reject Mana Whenua overlays to gain consents.
7360-1 P and P Plastics Limited bdemler@xtra.co.nz Zoning North and Islands
Rezone parts of the Wairau Valley from Light Industry to General Business and Mixed Use
zones (as indicated on the map attached as Appendix B on page 5/6 to the submission;
including but not restricted to Lot 5 DP 124669).
7361-1 Stephanie and Stephen Hay s.hay@slingshot.co.nz RPS Urban growth
quality compact urban form Retain Objective 3
quality compact urban form Retain Policy 2
land for urban development Retain objectives 1, 2, 3, 4.
land for urban development Retain Policy 3 and 4(b).
7361-7 Stephanie and Stephen Hay s.hay@slingshot.co.nz Zoning North and Islands
Retain Mixed Housing Suburban zoning for the wider neighbourhood surrounding 35 Gazelle
Avenue, Beachhaven.
7361-8 Stephanie and Stephen Hay s.hay@slingshot.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - general
and policies Retain this chapter
7361-9 Stephanie and Stephen Hay s.hay@slingshot.co.nz Residential zones
zone desc, obs & pols Retain the objectives and policies.
7361-10 Stephanie and Stephen Hay s.hay@slingshot.co.nz Zoning North and Islands Retain the Mixed Housing Suburban zoning for 35 Gazelle Ave, Beachhaven
7361-11 Stephanie and Stephen Hay s.hay@slingshot.co.nz Designations Minister of Defence
Protection Retain the designation
7361-12 Stephanie and Stephen Hay s.hay@slingshot.co.nz Precincts - North Chelsea Retain the precinct
7361-13 Stephanie and Stephen Hay s.hay@slingshot.co.nz Residential zones Residential Activity Table Retain dwellings as a Permitted Activity in the Mixed Housing Suburban zone.
7361-14 Stephanie and Stephen Hay s.hay@slingshot.co.nz Residential zones Residential Land use controls
Retain the Maximum Density controls for the Mixed Housing Suburban zone as it applies to
35 Gazelle Avenue, Beachhaven.
7361-15 Stephanie and Stephen Hay s.hay@slingshot.co.nz Residential zones Residential
Retain the Development Controls for the Mixed Housing Suburban zone as they apply to
Gazelle Avenue, Beachhaven.
7361-16 Stephanie and Stephen Hay s.hay@slingshot.co.nz
control
7361-17 Stephanie and Stephen Hay s.hay@slingshot.co.nz Mana Whenua
Whenua
594/1145
Sub#/
7362-1 Jannie Astle nannytini@gmail.com RPS Mana Whenua B5 Strategic Reject provisions.
7363-1 Carmen van Landeghem cvanlandeghem@hotmail.com RPS Urban growth
quality compact urban form Retain Objective 3
quality compact urban form Retain Policy 2
land for urban development Retain Objectives 1, 2, 3, 4, and Policy 3
land for urban development Retain Policy 4b
7363-7 Carmen van Landeghem cvanlandeghem@hotmail.com Zoning North and Islands Retain the Mixed Housing Suburban zone surrounding 18 Aplin Place, Birkdale.
7363-8 Carmen van Landeghem cvanlandeghem@hotmail.com Subdivision Auckland-wide - general
and policies Retain chapter
7363-9 Carmen van Landeghem cvanlandeghem@hotmail.com Zoning North and Islands Rezone 18 Aplin Place, Birkdale from Single House to Mixed housing Suburban.
7363-10 Carmen van Landeghem cvanlandeghem@hotmail.com Zoning North and Islands Rezone 18 Aplin Place, Birkdale from Single House to Mixed Housing Suburban
7363-11 Carmen van Landeghem cvanlandeghem@hotmail.com Designations Minister of Defence
Protection Retain the designation
7363-12 Carmen van Landeghem cvanlandeghem@hotmail.com Precincts - North Chelsea Retain the precinct
7363-13 Carmen van Landeghem cvanlandeghem@hotmail.com Residential zones Residential Activity Table Retain up to 3 dwellings as a Permitted Activity in the Mixed Housing Suburban zone.
7363-14 Carmen van Landeghem cvanlandeghem@hotmail.com Residential zones Residential Land use controls
Retain the Maximum Density controls for the Mixed Housing Suburban zone as it would apply
with the rezone of 18 Aplin Place, [Birkdale].
7363-15 Carmen van Landeghem cvanlandeghem@hotmail.com Residential zones Residential
Retain the Development Controls for the Mixed Housing Suburban zone as it would apply with
the rezone of 18 Aplin Place, [Birkdale].
7363-16 Carmen van Landeghem cvanlandeghem@hotmail.com Residential zones Residential Land use controls
Retain the rules that allow the conversion of a dwelling into two dwellings for the Single House
and Mixed Housing Suburban zones.
7364-1
John Farrell Nurseries Limited
and Brendon Farrell Limited dan@madsen-lawrie.co.nz Zoning South
Rezone Jellicoe, Middleton, Bayly, and Anzac roads, Pukekohe from Countryside Living and
Rural Production to Large Lot Residential.
7365-1 Collie Family Trust bdemler@xtra.co.nz Zoning North and Islands
Rezone parts of the Wairau Valley from Light Industry to General Business and Mixed Use
zones (as indicated on the map attached as Appendix B on page 5/6 to the submission;
including but not restricted to Lot 1 and 2 DP 87249 and Lot 17 DP 60369).
7366-1 Kirkwood Whanau
78B Whatapaka Road, RD1, Karaka,
Retain provisions which recognise and provide for the economic, cultural and social
development of Mori and treaty settlement land.
assessment
Retain provisions which recognise and provide for cultural values and heritage of Mana
Whenua, including the framework for Cultural Impact Assessment.
Auckland 2580 RPS Mana Whenua B5 Strategic Retain provisions which recognise and provide for customary use and cultural activities.
Retain the use of pre-hearing mediation sessions as a method for discussing and finding
agreed outcomes for key areas of concern.
Auckland 2580 General Miscellaneous Other
Ensure appropriate provision is made for the implementation, monitoring and evaluation of the
PAUP.
Auckland 2580 General Editorial and Part 6
Amend PAUP to integrate Mana Whenua provisions both vertically and horizontally e.g.
where an issue is addressed in the objective and policy framework, ensure this is reflected in
the relevant rule assessment criteria for Controlled and Restricted Discretionary activities.
Amend PAUP to recognise that adverse effects from activities on adjoining sites can impact
on cultural and customary uses, specifically the use and development of Mana Whenua and
Treaty Settlement land.
Ensure Mana Whenua are involved in processes which impact on the extent and location of
the RUB.
GIS viewer Include 'ancestral rohe' maps as a non-statutory layer.
Auckland 2580 RPS Mana Whenua
Mtauranga & tikanga Add a new method that will identify and develop ancestral rohe maps as a non-statutory layer.
Auckland 2580 General Editorial and Part 6 Review the numbering system of the PAUP.
Auckland 2580 General Cross plan matters Provide for customary use as Permitted in all zones.
595/1145
Sub#/
Fig. 1
Add objectives, policies and rule for an alert layer that ensures all other sites not currently
included in overlays are addressed.
Auckland 2580 General Chapter A Introduction A1 Background Retain section 1.2 Mana Whenua.
Auckland 2580 General Chapter A Introduction A2 Statutory Framework
Amend 2.2 Treaty of Waitangi / Te Tiriti o Waitangi to outline the need to consider natural and
physical resources which are part of the Treaty Settlement process as an element contributing
to the significance and relationship of Mana Whenua with these resources.
Auckland 2580 General Chapter A Introduction A2 Statutory Framework Retain 2.2 Treaty of Waitangi / Te Tiriti o Waitangi.
Regional significance Retain intent and strategic direction of the Regional Policy Statement.
Amend Regional Policy Statement to ensure the resource management issue is clearly
identified.
growth
Amend section as follows: '...This means we must manage our growth in a way that: ...
maintains enhances Mori communities, culture and values....'
wellbeing
Amend section to include reference to recognising the positive value Mana Whenua economic
development contributes towards Auckland's prosperity.
heritage
Amend section to include 'enabling Mana Whenua participation and decision making' as a
general concern for the Regional Policy Statement as opposed to just indigenous biodiversity.
significance to Mana Whenua Retain section.
significance to Mana Whenua Amend section by deleting the heading 'Explanation'.
Amend section as follows: ...Recognition of the Treaty and enabling the outcomes of Treaty
settlements....
Amend section to include specific reference to the kaitiaki role of Mana Whenua in the issue
statement and explanation.
Amend section as follows: '...In some cases, coastal land has been returned through Treaty
settlement as cultural or commercial redress to be used to re-establish an economic base and
platform for future development. ...'
Amend section as follows: '...In some cases, rural land has been returned through Treaty
settlement as cultural or commercial redress to be used to re-establish an economic base and
platform for future development. ...'
change Retain section.
participation Retain section.
participation
Amend Policy 9 as follows: 'Enable Mana Whenua to access, manage and develop use
cultural redress lands and interests for cultural activities .'
participation
Amend Methods to identify joint management agreements and the transfer of powers as key
monitoring indicators in Section 13 - Monitoring and Review Procedures.
Mtauranga & tikanga Retain section.
Mtauranga & tikanga
Amend section to include specific objectives, policies and methods enabling customary use
and cultural activities.
and cultural development Add policies and methods to clarify how Objective 2 will be achieved.
Auckland 2580
Outstanding Natural
Rules
Notification
Amend to provide for the occupation, development and use of Mori and Treaty settlement
land as Permitted, Controlled and Restricted Discretionary activities and use the integrated
Mori development tool to assess activities with significant adverse effects. See submission
for details [Vol. 1 - page 11/33]
settlement land
596/1145
Sub#/
Fig. 1 Retain section.
Fig. 1 Retain references to cultural landscapes in Objective 3, Policies 5 to 6 and Policy 12.
Fig. 1 Clarify the intent of Policy 10.
Fig. 1 Clarify the intent of Policy 13.
B6.3 Freshwater and
B6.3 Freshwater and
environment
quality Retain Objective 3.
quality Retain Policy 2(c).
quality
Include planning maps or other mechanisms to identify key areas to support Objective 3 and
Policy 2(c).
Gulf Retain Policy 10.
Auckland 2580 RPS General
Retain provisions with additional Environmental Results Anticipated to cover the range of
matters addressed in the Plan that impact Mana Whenua [Table 4 'Mana Whenua' ]
review procedures Amend to clearly identify key monitoring indicators in the PAUP.
review procedures
Include a method stating that a Unitary Plan monitoring strategy will be developed within a
specified timeframe with the input of Mana Whenua.
Auckland 2580 Mana Whenua Auckland wide - Mori Land
and policies Retain section 2.1 Mori land.
and policies Clarify that the Mori Land map layer will be updated as new Mori land sites are identified.
Amend the definition of 'Mori land' to refer to Parts 12 and 13 of the Te Ture Whenua Mori
Act 1993 rather than reference to sections 12 and 13.
and policies
Amend Policy 3 to require an integrated Mori development plan for Discretionary activities
and include provision for Controlled rules with consideration of natural heritage values as part
of the matters of control.
and policies
Amend Policy 7 to require an Integrated Mori Development Plan for Discretionary activities
and include provision for Controlled rules with consideration of natural heritage values as part
of the matters of control.
597/1145
Sub#/
and policies
Include a new objective and policy which provides for the development of Mori land while
considering the effects on natural resources as well as including provision for a range of
associated activities and provision for discretionary activities on Mori land within natural
resource overlays. See submission for further details [page 15/33 of submission].
and policies
Amend Policy 6 to read as follows: 'Consider Enable alternative approaches to site access
and infrastructure provisions in rural or coastal areas where the occupation, use
and development of Mori Mana Whenua land is constrained by access or the availability of
infrastructure.'
settlement land
settlement land
and policies
Amend Objective 3 as follows: 'Mana Whenua can access, manage and develop use land
acquired as cultural redress to support cultural activities .'
settlement land
and policies
only and include provision for Controlled rules with consideration of natural heritage values as
part of the matters of control.
settlement land
and policies
only and include provision for Controlled rules with consideration of natural heritage values as
part of the matters of control.
Auckland 2580 RPS Mana Whenua B5 Strategic Retain provisions in Chapter C, Sections 3-7 which relate to Mana Whenua.
Retain policies in Public Open Space zones which support and re-establish the relationship of
Mana Whenua to their ancestral lands, water, sites, waahi tapu and other taonga.
Auckland 2580 Mana Whenua Mori purpose zone
controls Retain provisions. [D8.5]
Heritage
Auckland 2580
control
and policies Add objectives and policies that enable the development of Treaty settlement land.
Whenua
objectives and policies Retain section.
Whenua
Auckland 2580 Precincts - Central New Precincts Other New Precincts
Add new areas for Mana Whenua marae and Papakinga areas and areas of customary
importance throughout the region where this is supported by Mana Whenua [inferred as new
precinct rather than extension of existing precinct].
Auckland 2580 Precincts Ak-Wide and Coastal Regional Parks
Add a new objective and policy supporting use of regional parks for Mana Whenua customary
use and/or cultural activities.
Auckland 2580 Precincts - Central rkei 1 Develop and include provisions for all areas identified within the Mori Purpose zone.
Auckland 2580 Precincts - Central rkei 2 Develop and include provisions for all areas identified within the Mori Purpose zone.
Auckland 2580 Precincts Ak-Wide and Coastal New Precincts All other New Precincts Add new precincts for Mana Whenua.
discovery protocol Retain requirements for accidental discovery protocols.
assessment
Amend rule 2.5(2)(i) as follows: 'Work at the site must not recommence until approval has
been granted by the council in consultation with Mana Whenua and the New Zealand Historic
Places Trust. In doing this, council must provide for the impacts of the activity on Mana
Whenua values, and any recommended measures from Mana Whenua proposed to avoid any
adverse effects on sites and places of significance to Mana Whenua.'
discovery protocol Amend rule 2.5(4) to clarify when resource consent will be required as a Discretionary activity.
Auckland 2580 General Chapter G General provisions
statements
Amend rule 2.7.2.1.3(e) Context analysis as follows: 'places of cultural importance, including
churches, marae, and sites and places of significance and value to Mana Whenua'
assessment
Retain the Cultural Impact Assessment requirement for sites and places of significance and
value to Mana Whenua.
Whenua
Add any new sites/places of significance and value to Mana Whenua as supported by Mana
Whenua.
598/1145
Sub#/
assessment
Amend to clarify that the discretion to determine if a Cultural Impact Assessment is required it
to be made with direct Mana Whenua input.
controls Amend Preamble to refer to the definition of Mori Land.
controls
Amend Activity table to provide for a range of commercial activities as Permitted and
Controlled activities.
controls Delete the Permitted threshold restricting development to a maximum of 10 dwellings.
controls Delete Development control 3.1(b) and (c) 'Building height'.
controls
Amend rule 3.1 'Building height' to clarify what the activity status is if the Permitted building
height rules are not met. If default is Discretionary, amend to Restricted Discretionary for
activities where the effects are not significant.
Spec. info. req.
Amend rule 5. Assessment - Restricted discretionary activities as follows: 'Rural industries on
Mori Land, activities associated with a marae complex on Mori Treaty settlement Land
greater than 250m2 GFA and marae complex on Mori land greater than 700m2 GFA.'
[Amend in Matters of Discretion and Assessment criteria].
and policies
Review section to ensure correct references to Mori Land and Treaty Settlement land. See
submission for specific details [Vol 1. page 23/33 of submission].
Spec. info. req.
Amend 5(2)(1)(f) Assessment - Restricted discretionary activities to recognise that there may
no alternative sites and/or locations for the development.
settlement land
rules/App. 4.3 legislation Retain section.
settlement land
Amend Activity table to provide for a range of commercial activities as Permitted and
Controlled activities.
settlement land
rules/App. 4.3 legislation Delete the Permitted threshold restricting development to a maximum of 10 dwellings.
settlement land
rules/App. 4.3 legislation Add a new rule framework for cultural and customary activities on Treaty Settlement Land.
settlement land
rules/App. 4.3 legislation Delete Development control H2.2.3.1(b) and (c) 'Building height.'
7366-
100 Kirkwood Whanau
settlement land
Amend rule H2.2.3.1 'Building height' to clarify what the activity status is if the Permitted
building height rules are not met. If default is Discretionary, amend to Restricted Discretionary
for activities where the effects are not significant.
7366-
101 Kirkwood Whanau
settlement land
Amend rule H2.2.5. 'Assessment - Restricted discretionary activities' as follows: 'Rural
industries on Treaty Settlement Mori Land, activities associated with a marae complex on
Treaty settlement Land greater than 250m2 GFA and marae complex on Treaty
Settlement Mori Land greater than 700m2 GFA.' [Amend in Matters of Discretion and
Assessment criteria].
7366-
102 Kirkwood Whanau
settlement land
and policies
Review section to ensure correct references to Mori Land and Treaty Settlement land. See
submission for specific details [Vol 1. page 25/33 of submission].
7366-
103 Kirkwood Whanau
settlement land
Amend H2.2.5(2)(1)(f) 'Assessment - Restricted discretionary activities' to recognise that there
may no alternative sites and/or locations for the development.
7366-
104 Kirkwood Whanau
Auckland 2580
SEAs
table - Vegetation
roads Retain section.
7366-
105 Kirkwood Whanau
Auckland 2580
SEAs
Assessment
Amend Control 2.5 Vegetation alteration or removal for customary use to specify activities not
complying to be Restricted Discretionary activities and include new assessment criteria to this
effect.
7366-
106 Kirkwood Whanau
Auckland 2580 Water Wastewater H4.15 Onsite wastewater rules Amend rule 2.1.1(2) General to clarify what is meant by 'must not be disturbed'.
7366-
107 Kirkwood Whanau
Delete section and replace with a non-regulatory method e.g. education and advocacy
programme and encourage use of Homestar/Greenstar or similar rating systems.
7366-
108 Kirkwood Whanau
Amend Landuse controls 2.6 Dwellings to not apply to Mori land and Treaty Settlement land
in coastal areas.
7366-
109 Kirkwood Whanau
Whenua
and policies Retain section 5 Mana Whenua.
599/1145
Sub#/
7366-
110 Kirkwood Whanau
Auckland 2580 General Cross plan matters
Amend section 6 Natural Heritage overlays to provide for development of Mori land and
Treaty settlement land as Permitted activities.
7366-
111 Kirkwood Whanau
Auckland 2580 Precincts General Content Precincts General Content
Delete the following from within all precincts in the PAUP that have a 'Dwellings on Mori
land' rule: 'The applicant must belong to the same hap as the trustees of the associated
marae'
7366-
112 Kirkwood Whanau
Amend in all precincts in the PAUP that have a 'Dwellings on Mori land' rule to clarify the
intent and delete the 10 dwellings maximum for Rural zones.
7366-
113 Kirkwood Whanau
Clarify within all precincts in the PAUP that have a 'Dwellings on Mori land' rule relationship
where Mori land is located within a precinct by stating the more permissive threshold controls
apply.
7366-
114 Kirkwood Whanau
Auckland 2580 Definitions New Add definitions of all Mori terms used in the PAUP.
7366-
115 Kirkwood Whanau
Amend the definition of 'Customary use' as follows: 'The extractive use of indigenous plants or
animals, stones, soil, water, marine or freshwater life by tangata whenua for traditional or
contemporary uses according to tikanga, including food gathering, carving, weaving, building
of waka or whare, and rongoa (traditional medicine), according to tikanga and includes
cultivation, farming or aquaculture activities associated with these uses.'
7366-
116 Kirkwood Whanau
Amend to have one definition of 'Mana Whenua' that reflects the role of Iwi authorities and the
RMA definition. [Currently there are two, one in the Definitions and one in the Mori terms
section].
7366-
117 Kirkwood Whanau
Amend the PAUP to be more enabling, especially for Mori with traditional or ancestral
pockets of land, including more certainty for Mori to establish on their land a range of
Papakinga housing estates, Papakinga housing, farm parks, precincts and health
orientated facilities as well as Urupa.
7366-
118 Kirkwood Whanau
Auckland 2580 Precincts - South New Precincts All other New Precincts
Add a new precinct which provides for new Papakinga dwellings as Permitted activities and
enables a number of low impact self-reticulated homes to be established on titles of three
acres each [specific address not given, assumed to be in Karaka].
7366-
119 Kirkwood Whanau
B6.3 Freshwater and
Geothermal Water
Reject any discharge into the Whatapaka Awa [river], including treated water, and all
waterways that feed into the Manukau Harbour.
7366-
120 Kirkwood Whanau
quality compact urban form Reject Auckland's dependence on greenfields to supply housing needs.
7366-
121 Kirkwood Whanau
Include new zones and sites to be included in the PAUP [specific zones and sites are not
detailed within the submission [Vol. 1 page 3/33].
7366-
122 Kirkwood Whanau
Adopt the relief sought in the submission by Ngti Tamaoho Trust and the Independent Mori
Statutory Board.
7367-1 Fullers Group Limited littlejohn@quaychambers.co.nz Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
Amend rules to require adequate parking for passengers be provided within a reasonable
walking distance from the point of departure.
7367-2 Fullers Group Limited littlejohn@quaychambers.co.nz
the CMA D5.5/I10 Ferry Terminal zone
7367-4 Fullers Group Limited littlejohn@quaychambers.co.nz City Centre Zone I4 Rules/Appendix 7.1- 7.3
Amend rules to require appropriately located and adequate sewage pump-out and temporary
storage facilities be provided to service maritime passenger operations.
the CMA D5.5/I10 Ferry Terminal zone
7367-7 Fullers Group Limited littlejohn@quaychambers.co.nz Precincts - City Centre Central Wharves
7368-1 Shirley E Lees bdemler@xtra.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - Rural zones
zones only
Amend the Prohibited activity status for 'subdivision not otherwise provided for' in a rural zone
to Discretionary or Non Complying.
7368-2 Shirley E Lees bdemler@xtra.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - Urban zones
except Rural
Amend the Prohibited activity status for 'subdivision not otherwise provided for' in a rural zone
to Discretionary or Non Complying for any subdivision that complies with the residential rules
and any relevant structure plan or similar.
7369-1 Gael Walker johngael@xtra.co.nz Zoning North and Islands
Rezone Matai Road, Stanmore Bay [address not provided] to require this to be used as a
private residence with off street parking.
7370-1 New Sun Developers Limited
Auckland 1141 Precincts - West Westgate K7.10 Rules and Mapping Retain the existing alignment of the Sub-precinct boundaries in Precinct Plan 1.
Auckland 1141 Precincts - West Westgate K7.10 Rules and Mapping Adopt a Community Facility Overlay Area of 5,000m
2
.
Auckland 1141 Precincts - West Westgate K7.10 Rules and Mapping
Relocate the location of the Community Facility Overlay to the area shown on the Indicative
Land Use Plan (page 22/45 of the submission).
600/1145
Sub#/
Introduce a rule in the Westgate Precinct to provide for alternative land uses within the
Community Facility Overlay.
Auckland 1141 Precincts - West Westgate K7.10 Rules and Mapping Amend Table 1 header to reference Sub-precinct D.
Amend Table 1 to remove activity thresholds which are not currently imposed under the
operative district plan rules [as listed on pages 6-7/45].
Amend Table 1 to retain the activity status for those activities which are currently permitted
under the operative district plan rules [listed on pages 6-7/45].
Auckland 1141 Precincts - West Westgate K7.10 Rules and Mapping Amend density requirements for Sub-precinct D to 40 apartments per ha (net).
Auckland 1141 Precincts - West Westgate K7.10 Rules and Mapping Retain the maximum height limits of 32.5m within the Mixed Use zone.
Increase the maximum height limit of the Terrace Housing and Apartment Building zone to
32.5m (equating to a maximum of 8 storeys).
Increase the maximum number of storeys within the Terrace Housing and Apartment Building
zone to 8 storeys with no minimum floor levels required.
Auckland 1141 Precincts - West Westgate K7.10 Rules and Mapping Delete Rule 4.2 'Building Setbacks at Upper Floors'.
Amend rules so that if a framework plan deviates from the Precinct Plan it is a Discretionary
Activity.
Add rule that where a retirement village is proposed the maximum impervious area is
increased from 60% to 70%. Retain the 60% maximum impervious threshold throughout the
remainder of the zone.
Auckland 1141 Precincts - West Westgate K7.10 Rules and Mapping Add rule that where a retirement village is proposed the maximum building coverage is 50%.
Amend Activity Table 1 of the Westgate Precinct rules to include retirement villages within
Sub-precinct D.
7371-1
Better Living Landscapes
Limited kpegrum@xtra.co.nz Zoning North and Islands
Rezone the land from Kaipara Flats through Warkworth out to Matakana as 'Mixed Rural
Production' in accordance with the Auckland Plan; except that where small lot sizes already
predominate, those parts should be zoned Mixed Rural, and there be a Countryside Living
zone to act as a buffer around the edge of the Future Urban zone.
7371-2
Limited kpegrum@xtra.co.nz RPS Rural B8.1 Rural activities Amend the objectives and policies to allow subdivision in the rural zones.
7371-3
Limited kpegrum@xtra.co.nz Rural Zones General
Amend Objective 1 under 6.1.2 Rural character and amenity values to substitute the phrase
'allowed to evolve' for 'maintained'.
7371-4
Limited kpegrum@xtra.co.nz Definitions Existing
Amend the definitions of 'elite land' and 'prime land' to reflect the definitions as they apply in
the Land Use Classification but without linking them to the LUC maps.
7371-5
Limited kpegrum@xtra.co.nz Rural Zones
obs & pols
Amend Policy 4(c) of the Mixed Rural zone to clearly identify that reverse sensitivities cannot
result in land use changes with respect to appropriate rural zone activities.
7371-6
Limited kpegrum@xtra.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - Rural zones
area
Amend rules to allow subdivision of rural land in the Rural Production and Mixed Rural zones
where the majority of the land being subdivided (i.e. the new site) is not highly productive, or a
large percentage of the land is being protected (by bringing forward Rodney District Council's
existing rules). A cap can be created that allows for amenity blocks in the Mixed Rural zone.
7371-7
area
Amend rules to reflect that for the Rural Production and Rural Coastal zoned areas, the best
limitation is based around protection of on-site bush or wetlands with a cap, and any excess to
be transferred by way of transferable rural site and possibly two separate thresholds set up.
7371-8
zones only
Delete any reference that makes any form of subdivision a Prohibited Activity in the Rural
zones.
7371-9
Amend Policy 3(a) under 6.1.3 Rural industries, services and non residential activities as
follows: '...and provide services not appropriate to meet or able to be met by similar facilities in
local rural towns and settlements'.
7371-10
objectives & policies Delete Policy 5(c) under 6.1.3.
7371-11
Amend Policy 7 to add the two additional conditions as follows: 'd. follows accepted best
practise to avoid soil erosion at all stages during the forestry life-cycle (and especially during
logging); e. ensure that all public roads used during logging operations remain at all times
safe for public use.'
7371-12
desc, obs & pols
Amend Policy 3 as follows: 'Enable the establishment of new and the expansion of existing
greenhouses that rely on soil (as opposed to hydroponic) cultivation in specific locations ...'
7371-13
obs & pols
Amend Objective 1 as follows: 'the existing pattern of landholdings, and non-residential
activities that support them, is used by a diverse range of rural production activities.'
601/1145
Sub#/
7371-14
Amend to exclude Policy 3(b) under 6.1.2. to exclude motorised sports or alternatively
motorised sports may be considered in a similar vein to boarding kennels with a policy
statement virtually identical to Section 6.1.3, Policy 1(c)(iii).
7371-15
Limited kpegrum@xtra.co.nz Rural Zones General I13.1 Activity table
Amend the Activity Table to provide for more Restricted Discretionary and Permitted Activities
instead of Discretionary Activities. [See page 11/38 of submission for details of process to
determine changes. No specific amendments are stated].
7371-16
Add minor dwellings as a Restricted Discretionary activity in both the Rural Production and
Mixed Rural zones.
7371-17
Rezone parts of the area between Kaipara Flats and Matakana zoned as Rural Production to
a mix of Countryside Living; and in areas where lot sizes more nearly approach an economic
size rezone as Mixed Rural.
7371-18
Limited kpegrum@xtra.co.nz RPS Urban growth
and villages
Amend the PAUP to allow rural settlements (of all sizes) to be zoned (both boundary and
minimum lot size) to provide for appropriate growth sufficient to facilitate active and
progressive rural community hubs.
7371-19
Limited kpegrum@xtra.co.nz RPS
Add mechanism to have additional land identified as an SEA with the criteria for SEA set in
place as the benchmark.
7371-20
Amend the extent of SEAs to include stream/river corridors and coastal edge in addition to the
bush wetland senario.
7371-21
area
Amend the PAUP to allow subdivision of 'hard' land which is not valuable as farm land, being
either swamp or steep hill country. [See page 14/38 of submission for details].
7371-22
Amend the Activity Table regarding Visitor Accommodation to differentiate between: small
scale low-impact accommodation (BnBs) which should be a Permitted Activity (or at a
minimum Restricted Discretionary); boutique accommodation which should be a Discretionary
Activity; and large scale accommodation which should be a Non-Complying Activity.
7371-23
Limited kpegrum@xtra.co.nz Rural Zones General I13.1 Activity table Remove the Prohibited Activity status from the Activity Table.
7371-24
Amend the Activity Table to include 'Minor Household Unit' as defined in the current Rodney
District Plan.
7371-25
Limited kpegrum@xtra.co.nz Rural Zones General I13.1 Activity table Amend the Activity Table to include 'sleepouts' as a Permitted Activity.
7371-26
Limited kpegrum@xtra.co.nz Rural Zones General I13.1 Activity table Amend the Activity Table to include 'homestay' as a Permitted Activity for up to 10 people.
7371-27
Limited kpegrum@xtra.co.nz Rural Zones General I13.1 Activity table Amend the Activity Table to include 'childcare' as a Permitted Activity for up to 10 people.
7371-28
Amend the Activity Table to include 'cleanfill disposal sites' as Non-Complying Activity for a
threshold over 10,000m
3
.
7371-29
Limited kpegrum@xtra.co.nz Definitions Existing Amend definition of 'Organised sport and recreation' by removing reference to motorsport.
7371-30
Limited kpegrum@xtra.co.nz Rural Zones General I13.1 Activity table Amend the Activity Table by adding 'motorsport' as a Restricted Discretionary Activity.
7371-31
Limited kpegrum@xtra.co.nz Rural Zones General I13.2 Land use controls Delete Land Use Controls 2.6(1)(a) to (1)(d) and (2) for Dwellings.
7371-32
Limited kpegrum@xtra.co.nz
SEAs
table - Vegetation
roads
Amend the Activity Table to insert the word 'Native' within the Riparian Section, to
amend widths of margins to be more reactive to stream widths rather than a zone lead
discretion, and to clarify what is a pest plant.
7371-33
Limited kpegrum@xtra.co.nz Earthworks
and policies
Amend substantively the General earthworks subsection by simplyfing the volumes for
landuse rules (using the operative Rodney District Plan), and reinstating a sediment control
zone for regional rules as per current Regional Plan controls, extending tracking to 500
meters, and creating a set of standards for both volumes and areas for less than the rule
threshold. [See page 18/38 of submission].
7371-34
Limited kpegrum@xtra.co.nz Earthworks H4.2.1.1 Activity table - Zones
Amend activity status of 'Tracks for farming' to reinstate Permitted Activity status but with
standards (and utilise sediment control zone rule and definition).
7371-35
Limited kpegrum@xtra.co.nz Earthworks
Overlays
Amend the Activity Table to remove all Restricted Discretionary Activities up to 1000m
2
and
1000m
3
and replace as Permitted Activities with standards (to be added), to provide a waiver
in all zones that have inaccurate flood maps if that can be demonstrated, and to provide a
waiver for all situations that have previously been assessed and have consent notices
attached to the title. [See page 18/38 of the submission].
602/1145
Sub#/
7371-36
Limited kpegrum@xtra.co.nz Water Stormwater
H4.14.2 Stormwater
Amend the Activity Table relating to SMAFs to remove thresholds and set standards to be
met, to recognise existing consent notices on titles for Hydro neutrality, to recognise existing
consent notices for building in flood plains, and to amend the entire rule and standards. [No
other specific amendments provided. See page 19/38 of submission].
7371-37
Limited kpegrum@xtra.co.nz Water
streams & wetland
Delete from permitted activity control 2.7(1)(a) the reference to the full extent of rivers and
streams.
7371-38
Rural Discharges,
Biosolids
Discharges Amend rule 2.1.3(2) to allow farming use as well as horticulture.
7371-39
Limited kpegrum@xtra.co.nz Mana Whenua General provisions
assessment
Amend the 'Cultural impact assessment' rules so that the process of allowing iwi to 'pick up'
resource consent applications should continue and require a site visit as a pre requisite prior
to preparing a full Cultural Impact Assessment. [See page 19/38 of submission].
7371-40
Limited kpegrum@xtra.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - Urban zones
except Rural
Amend Activity Table 3 - Future Urban zone, to delete Prohibited Activity status and replace
with Non-complying Activity status with criteria such as a comprehensive design, and other
criteria to allow the sustainable use of land without a plan change.
7371-41
zones only
Delete Activity Table 5 and replace with provisions that allow for limited subdivision in the
Mixed Rural, Rural Coastal and Rural Production zones. Limited subdivision can be based on
threshold of parent lot size, maximum development right, use of Transferable Title Rights
provisions, and a combination of those listed in conjuction with the protection of significant
natural features. [See page 20/38 of submission].
7371-42
area
Delete section 2.3.3 and replace with new provisions providing for increased subdivision
potential including using Transferable Title Rights, generally and include the same provisions
as the Operative Rodney District Plan and provide for Retirement Blocks. [See pages 20-
21/38 of submission].
7371-43
Limited kpegrum@xtra.co.nz Residential zones Residential Land use controls
Amend Rule 3.1 'Maximum density' Table 1 to amend Rural and Coastal Settlements to one
dwelling per 1200m
2
for un-serviced and 800m
2
for serviced.
7371-44
Limited kpegrum@xtra.co.nz Trees
Trees J6.4 Rules
Amend the overlay map to be consistent with the Policy, remove areas of farmland and
provide a clear basis of the notableness of the trees.
7371-45
Outstanding Natural
Rules
Outstanding Natural
Landscapes
Amend the Outstanding Natural Landscape overlay so that ONLs are confined to
only significant stands of bush and not wider areas of farm land. [See page 23/38 of
submission].
7371-46
Outstanding Natural
Rules
Character - Coastal
Amend the Coastal Natural Character overlay [infer Outstanding and High Natural Character
overlay] to limit these to just areas below the ridgelines that run down to the coastal edge and
exclude well settled areas. [See page 23/38 of submission].
7371-47
Limited kpegrum@xtra.co.nz Mana Whenua
Whenua
and policies
Amend the overlay to remove the pink circles and replace with the exact location of the site or
place, as shown on the Cultural Heritage Inventory, and amend rules so that the place must
not be destroyed or damaged.
7371-48
Limited kpegrum@xtra.co.nz Mana Whenua
Whenua
Remove items from the Cultural Heritage Inventory that have had consent to be damaged or
destroyed or no longer exist due to coastal erosion.
7371-49
Limited kpegrum@xtra.co.nz Historic Heritage (Overlay)
Heritage
Places
Amend PAUP to reinstate those 'Heritage Items' listed in legacy district plans, especially
Chapter 17 of the Operative Rodney District Plan. [See page 23/38 of submission].
7371-50
obs & pols
Delete all objectives, polices, maps and parts of any activity table relating to the East Coast
area.
7371-51
SEAs
Land Remove the SEA overlay as there are no supporting objectives and policies in part C5.3.
7371-52
SEAs
Land Amend the PAUP to provide the whole information set regarding SEA's with clear information.
7371-53
Amend the SEA layer to set standards for SEA's and ensure the assessment is
comprehensive. Each SEA should be provided with a category that qualifies it.
7371-54
SEAs
Land Amend the PAUP by correcting the mapping errors for SEA's.
603/1145
Sub#/
7371-55
Amend the PAUP so that vegetation in SEA's is managed with vegetation rules and a set of
clear criteria that stand alone [to] identify what values make for an SEA and that can then be
addressed if a landowner is seeking to protect a feature or conversely damage a feature.
7371-56
Limited kpegrum@xtra.co.nz Water
streams & wetland
table Delete or significantly amend the indicative streams map layer.
7371-57
Limited kpegrum@xtra.co.nz General
GIS viewer Delete the flood hazard maps until a total review of their accuracy has been undertaken.
7371-58
Limited kpegrum@xtra.co.nz Natural Hazards and Flooding Flooding H4.12 Rules
Amend the rules so properties that currently have consent notices relating to flooding, and
where subdivision has been granted and a flood analysis has been undertaken, will over-ride
the flood hazard maps.
7371-59
Limited kpegrum@xtra.co.nz Natural Hazards and Flooding Flooding H4.12 Rules
Delete all rules relating to overland flow paths and amend all overland flow path maps to
address all the 'as built' subdivision plans for completed subdivision.
7371-60
Limited kpegrum@xtra.co.nz Future Urban
and Open Space Remove the indicative road map layer and its rules.
7371-61
Rezone from Rural Production to Mixed Rural zone all the land between Woodcocks Road,
Old Woodcocks Road and Kaipara Flats Road and link with SH1 near Warkworth. The zone
should extend to the boundary of landowners on those roads and should also extend to the
sealed section of Tauhoa Road on the outer extent of Kaipara Flats Village.
7371-62
Limited kpegrum@xtra.co.nz RPS Changes to the RUB North and Waiheke Island
Rezone to the area from the unnamed access road on the immediately east of Mega 10
Warkworth to the east (and north side of Woodcocks Road) using the river boundary and the
boundary of Mahurangi College from existing zone to Mixed [Use] Business.
7371-63
Rezone the block of land between Hudson Road and the west side of Great North Road,
Warkworth, from Future Urban to Mixed Business .
7371-64
Rezone Christian Bay on Takatu Road from Rural Coastal to a new mixed settlement zone
(Special Zone). [See pages 28-29/38 of submission].
7371-65
Limited kpegrum@xtra.co.nz Precincts - North Matakana 1 Incorporate Plan Change 64 to the Rodney District Plan regardig Matakana.
7371-66
Rezone Omaha Flats to incorporate the Special 22 zone Omaha Flats in the Operative
Rodney District Plan into the PAUP.
7371-67
Rezone land to incorporate the plan change about Kaipara Flats airfield into the PAUP. [See
7371-68
Rezone the Future Urban zone in Warkworth by pulling back from the foothills of the Dome
Forest. A low density type of Countryside Living with landscape controls with an assessment
may be appropriate.
7371-69
Amend PAUP to provide infrastructure in Warkworth, which is identified for substantial
population growth but has poor level of infrastructure.
7371-70
Amend the Future Urban zone [inferred to be the provision of B 2.3 and Structure Plan
Guideline] to explicitly state that before any land is rezoned into any form of urban zone that
the expected levels of infrastructure be agreed across the city, plans are prepared that identify
the expected timing of growth in each part of the Future Urban zone, plans are prepared that
identify delivery of infrastructure and those plans are locked into Council financial planning.
[See page 30/38 of submission].
7371-71
Amend the rules of the Future Urban zone to include a requirement to identify sufficient space
for both commercial and industrial purposes to match the employment requirements of the
urban growth. Where such space is not proposed that suitable levels of public transport be
required to enable residents to move to and from work in the major commercial and industrial
areas of Albany and points south without needing to travel by private vehicle [in Warkworth].
7371-72
Rezone land to identify a buffer area maybe 2 to 4 km wide surrounding the RUB that is
zoned Countryside Living [in the area] immediately abutting the Warkworth RUB [identified as]
Rural Production zone.
7371-73
Amend PAUP to recognise that in relation to Warkworth unless all key infrastructure points
are funded and built with the proposed level of growth, then either the target population needs
to be increased to achieve a critical mass that facillitates all the infrastructure or the whole
idea of growing Warkworth needs to be shelved beyond a modest growth model.
7371-74
Limited kpegrum@xtra.co.nz General Miscellaneous
Operational/
Ascertain whether the proposed level of growth can support Warkworth being part of the city's
Rapid Transit Network.
7371-75
Amend definition of 'Rear Site' to split definition into a new and old based on the date of
operative status of the PAUP.
7371-76
Amend definition of 'Front Site' to split definition into a new and old based on the date of
operative status of the PAUP.
604/1145
Sub#/
7371-77
Amend definition of 'Front Yards' to split definition into new and old sites as per existing
definitions in Operative Rodney Plan.
7371-78
Amend the definitions of 'stream', 'intermittent streams' and 'ephemeral streams' so they are
less convoluted and more workable.
7371-79
Amend the definition of 'livestock' to read: 'Animals (both traditionally farmed in New Zealand
and other species not traditionally farmed in New Zealand) that are raised for food or other
products, or kept for use, especially farm animals. ...' (excluding zoo animals and ferrets).
7371-80
Amend definitions of 'prime land' and 'elite land' to relocate parts to the descriptors that make
up the constituent parts of these land types and not rely on the maps (indicative only).
7371-81
Limited kpegrum@xtra.co.nz Definitions New
Add a definition of 'marginal land' to also qualify those land-types suitable for rehabilitation
planting.
7371-82
Amend the definition of 'site' by replacing 1b with 'contained in a single lot on a digital title plan
certified pursuant to Section 223 of the Resource Management Act 1991 for which a separate
certificate of title could be issued without further consent of the Council.' and adding 'or' at the
beginning of 2 and 3. [See page 34/38 of submission for details].
7371-83
Amend the definition of 'boundary relocation' by removing the words 'within a property held in
the same ownership ' [from the second bullet point].
7372-1 G Marshall parfitt.associates@xtra.co.nz Zoning North and Islands Rezone 227 Lonely Track Road, Albany from Large Lot to Single House
7373-1 S Thomas parfitt.associates@xtra.co.nz Future Urban I5 Rules
Add a provision to the Future Urban zone rules requiring a structure plan to be prepared and
notified three years from the date of confirmation of the zoning. If this rule is not met the land
shall automatically be zoned Mixed Housing Suburban.
7373-2 S Thomas parfitt.associates@xtra.co.nz RPS Changes to the RUB North and Waiheke Island Rezone 51 Postman Road, Dairy Flat from Future Urban to Mixed Housing Suburban.
7374-1 Natalya Ujdur and Family owen@greengroup.co.nz RPS Changes to the RUB North and Waiheke Island
Rezone the land at Matua Road, Huapai as described in submission [page 6/83 of
submission] from Future Urban to Mixed Housing Urban and Terrace Housing and Apartment
Buildings or a suite or similar appropriate zones. A Masterplan has been attached to
submission [pages 8 to 83/83 of submission].
7374-2 Natalya Ujdur and Family owen@greengroup.co.nz General Miscellaneous Special housing areas
Include the land at Matua Road, Huapai as described in the submission as a Special Housing
Area [page 12/83 of the submission]. A Masterplan and infrastructure assessments for the site
have been attached to the submission, page 8 to 83/83].
7375-1 Epsom Preservation Society
Ltd
Airport
Expand the membership of the Aircraft Noise Community Consultative Group to ensure it
includes representatives of those suburbs now experiencing significant noise effects from the
new SMART flight paths.
Ltd
Airport
Expand the terms of reference for the Aircraft Noise Community Consultative Group so these
refer explicitly to addressing issues associated with aircraft noise being generated from the
new SMART flight paths.
Ltd
Airport
Require the Chairperson of the Aircraft Noise Community Consultative Group to be
sufficiently independent of the Airport, Airways, BARNZ [Board of Airline Representatives
New Zealand] and all the airlines using the new flight paths.
Ltd
Airport
Amend to restrict the hours during which the new SMART flight paths can be used, and
maximum number of flights that can use the new flight paths a day.
Ltd
Airport
Amend to require appropriate acoustic mitigation to be provided for houses which are
suffering significant and unreasonable noise effects as a result of the new SMART flight
paths.
Ltd
Airport
Amend the airport noise area maps so they appropriately reflect and accommodate the use of
the new SMART flight paths.
Ltd
Airport
Amend to require appropriate and onoing noise monitors to be installed, in order to properly
assess and address noise effects from the new SMART flight paths.
Ltd
Airport
Amend to require the Airports Noise Management Plan and Noise Minimisation Procedures
(Designation 1100) to adequately include, and address, noise effects from the new SMART
flight paths.
7376-1 Brett Illingworth
54 Woodcocks Road, Warkworth,
Auckland 0910 Earthworks H4.2.1.3 Activity table - ONFs
Amend the Activity Table and controls so that a consent is not required and a code of practice
is implemented.
Auckland 0910 Earthworks
Overlays Delete the proposed earthwork rules in relation to ONC's.
Auckland 0910
SEAs
Land Remove the SNA [inferred to be SEA] from the property at 70 Ward Road, Matakana.
Auckland 0910
Outstanding Natural
Rules
Character - Coastal Remove the ONC from the property at 70 Ward Road, Matakana.
605/1145
Sub#/
Auckland 0910
control
and policies Delete the Pre-1944 Building Demolition overlay.
7377-1 Grbavac and Ujdur Families owen@greengroup.co.nz RPS Changes to the RUB North and Waiheke Island
Rezone the land abutting State Highway 16, Huapai as described in the submission [page
6/101] from Future Urban to Mixed Housing Urban and Terrace Housing and Apartment
Buildings, or a suite or similar appropriate zones. A Masterplan has been attached to
submission [pages 7 to 101/101 of the submission].
7377-2 Grbavac and Ujdur Families owen@greengroup.co.nz General Miscellaneous Special housing areas
Include the land abutting State Highway 16, Huapai as described in the submission [page
6/101] as a Special Housing Area.
7378-1 A T Snowden igloo1@makodev.com
Outstanding Natural
Rules
Outstanding Natural
Landscapes
Remove ONL overlay from 1684 State Highway 1, RD3, Warkworth, or, waive all future
resource consent application fees relating to the ONL.
7378-2 A T Snowden igloo1@makodev.com
SEAs
Land Remove the SEA overlay from 1684 State Highway 1, RD3, Warkworth.
7378-3 A T Snowden igloo1@makodev.com RPS Changes to the RUB North and Waiheke Island Amend the RUB boundary to exclude 1684 State Highway 1, RD3, Warkworth.
7379-1 Corinne Henrikson corinnehenrikson@hotmail.com
Centre) Business
Park zones Amend height restrictions in New Lynn to be lower and restrict what can be built.
7380-1 Peter Elder elderconsulting@xtra.co.nz
SEAs
Land Remove SEA overlay from 43 Beach Road, Castor Bay.
7381-1 Andrew B George leebarry@clear.net.nz RPS Changes to the RUB North and Waiheke Island
Amend the RUB to include 360 Sandspit Road, Warkworth (lot 2 DP 155020) within the
proposed urban boundary for Warkworth. [See maps on pages 5-10/10 of submission].
7381-2 Andrew B George leebarry@clear.net.nz
Outstanding Natural
Rules
Character - Coastal
Retain the Coastal Natural Character Areas overlay applied to the property at 360 Sandspit
Road, Warkworth (lot 2 DP 155020).
Outstanding Natural
Rules
Outstanding Natural
Landscapes
Retain the Outstanding Natural Landscape overlay applied to the property at 360 Sandspit
SEAs
Land
Retain the SEA overlay applied to the property at 360 Sandspit Road, Warkworth (lot 2 DP
155020).
7382-1 Poplar Family Trust parfitt.associates@xtra.co.nz Future Urban I5 Rules
Add a provision to the Future Urban zone requiring a structure plan to be prepared and
7382-2 Poplar Family Trust parfitt.associates@xtra.co.nz RPS Changes to the RUB North and Waiheke Island Rezone 51 Postman Road, Dairy Flat from Future Urban to Mixed Housing Suburban.
7383-1 The Planning Room logan@theplanningroom.co.nz Zoning North and Islands
Rezone the frontage to a depth of 70m along Beach Haven Road from Light Industry to
7384-1 Catherine L George leebarry@clear.net.nz RPS Changes to the RUB North and Waiheke Island
Amend the RUB to include 360 Sandspit Road, Warkworth (lot 2 DP 155020) within the
proposed RUB at Warkworth. [See maps on pages 6-12/12 of submission].
7384-2 Catherine L George leebarry@clear.net.nz
Outstanding Natural
Rules
Character - Coastal
Retain the Coastal Natural Character Areas overlay applied to the property at 360 Sandspit
Outstanding Natural
Rules
Outstanding Natural
Landscapes
Retain the ONL overlay applied to the property at 360 Sandspit Road, Warkworth (lot 2 DP
155020).
SEAs
Land
Retain the SEA overlay applied to the property at 360 Sandspit Road, Warkworth (lot 2 DP
155020).
7385-1 Kamal Nagin das Jhaveri kamal_jhaveri@hotmail.com Zoning South
Rezone 75 and 77 Hillcrest Road, Papatoetoe from Mixed Housing Suburban to Mixed
Housing Urban or Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings.
7386-1
Judith Brown on behalf of the
other registered proprietors parfitt.associates@xtra.co.nz Zoning North and Islands
Retain the Future Urban zoning on Part allotment 47, and Allotments 269, and 268, 120
Cemetry Road, Wainui.
606/1145
Sub#/
7386-2
other registered proprietors parfitt.associates@xtra.co.nz RPS Changes to the RUB North and Waiheke Island Rezone Lot 2 DP 42008 at 120 Cemetry Road, Wainui from Rural to Future Urban.
7386-3
other registered proprietors parfitt.associates@xtra.co.nz Future Urban I5 Rules
Add a provision to the Future Urban zone rules requiring a structure plan to be prepared and
7387-1 Kim Walker kimwalstan@gmail.com
Centre) Business
Park zones Delete 4.1(1) provisions that allow two infringements of the rules as of right.
7387-2 Kim Walker kimwalstan@gmail.com
Centre) Business
Park zones Amend yard width from 3m to 10m.
7387-3 Kim Walker kimwalstan@gmail.com Zoning Central Rezone Jervois Road strip of shops from Local Centre to Neighborhood Centre.
7387-4 Kim Walker kimwalstan@gmail.com Precincts - Central New Precincts Other New Precincts
Amend provisions for 1 Kelmarna Avenue, Herne Bay to reflect the current concept plan and
Business 8 provisions.
7387-5 Kim Walker kimwalstan@gmail.com Zoning Central Rezone 3 and 5 Kelmarna Avenue to the operational district plan zone Res 1.
7388-1 Tim Holdgate tim@hsl.net.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - Rural zones
area
Amend the PAUP to alter the threshold for bush covenants [additional title based on
protecting bush] from 5 ha to 2 ha.
7389-1 Graham Parfitt parfitt.associates@xtra.co.nz Zoning North and Islands Rezone 13 Westbourne Road, Murrays Bay from Single House to Mixed Housing Suburban
7389-2 Graham Parfitt parfitt.associates@xtra.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - Rural zones
area
Amend the Rural Subdivision rules to add Objectives, Policies, Rules, and Assessment
criteria generally along the lines of those in the Operative Rodney District Plan for wetland
and bush block subdivision
7389-3 Graham Parfitt parfitt.associates@xtra.co.nz General Miscellaneous Consultation and engagement
Request the process to be slowed down. Recruit a panel of experts to to help report writers
and the hearings panel
7390-1 Graeme A Jamieson
239 Taupaki Road, RD 2,
Henderson, Auckland 0782 RPS Mana Whenua B5 Strategic Reject provisions.
7391-1
Little Shoal Bay Protection
Society Incorporated ameys@ihug.co.nz Public Open Space Zones Public Open Space I2.1 Activity table
Amend the Activity Table to make new buildings and external additions to existing buildings a
Non-complying activity in Public Open Space Zones 1, 2 and 3 (with the exception of the
activity already being permitted on Public Open Space in accordance with a precinct plan, or
reserve management plan, conservation management strategy, or conservation management
plan).
7391-2
Amend the Activity Table to make early childhood centres, restaurants, retail, offices,
markets, storage, and stacks of materials, Non-complying activities in Public Open Space
Zones 1, 2 and 3 (with the exception of any activity already being permitted on Public Open
Space in accordance with a precinct plan, or reserve management plan, conservation
management strategy, or conservation management plan).
7391-3
Amend the Activity Table to make Marae complex, places of assembly, parks depot, storage
and maintenance, and stacks of materials, Non-complying activities, except in the Civic
Spaces or Community zones (with the exception of any activity already being permitted on
Public Open Space in accordance with a precinct plan, or reserve management plan,
conservation management strategy, or conservation management plan).
7391-4
Allow organised sports and recreation, grandstands, recreation facilities, sports and recreation
structures, swimming pools / spas, and verandahs, as Permitted Activities in the Sport and
Active Recreation zone only (with the exception of any activity already being permitted on
Public Open Space in accordance with a precinct plan, or reserve management plan,
conservation management strategy, or conservation management plan).
7391-5
Restrict maimais involving the use of guns in all Public Open Space zones (with the
exception of the activity already being permitted on Public Open Space in accordance with a
precinct plan, or reserve management plan, conservation management strategy, or
conservation management plan).
7391-6
Amend the Activity Tables so that the following are Discretionary Activities in the Public Open
Space zones: any activity identified in a precinct plan or adopted reserve management plan,
but not in the location specified on those plans; visitor accommodation - huts and lodges only;
vehicle parking and associated vehicle access; art works; non-security floodlighting;
clubrooms.
7391-7
Remove 'Occupiable structures used as a dwelling' from the Public Open Space activity
table.
607/1145
Sub#/
7391-8
Amend the activity status of 'Any activity identified in a precinct plan or adopted reserve
management plan, but not in the location specified on that plan, conservation management
strategy or conservation management' from Restricted Discretionary to Discretionary in the
Conservation zone, Informal Recreation zone and the Sport and Active Recreation zone.
7391-9
Amend the activity status of 'Accessory buildings' from Permitted to a Non-Complying Activity
in Conservation zone, Informal Recreation zone and the Sport and Active Recreation zone.
7391-10
Amend the activity status of 'Camping grounds' from Discretionary to a Non-Complying
Activity in the Conservation zone and the Informal Recreation zone.
7391-11
Amend activity status of 'A single workers' accommodation dwelling dwelling' from Permitted
to a Non-Complying Activity in the Conservation zone, Informal Recreation zone and the
Sport and Active Recreation zone.
7391-12
Amend the activity status of 'Visitor accommodation - huts and lodges only' from Restricted
Discretionary to Non-Complying in the Informal Recreation zone.
7391-13
Amend the activity status for 'Visitors centre' from Discretionary to a Non-Complying activity in
the Informal Recreation zone.
7391-14
Amend the activity status for 'Community centres and halls' from Discretionary to a Non-
Complying activity in the Informal Recreation zone and the Sport and Active Recreation zone.
7391-15
Amend the activity status for 'Early childhood learning' from to a Non-Complying activity in the
Informal Recreation zone and the Sport and Active Recreation zone.
7391-16
Amend the activity status for 'Marae Complex' to Non-Complying in the Conservation zone,
Informal Recreation and the Sport and Active Recreation zone.
7391-17
Amend activity table for 'Artworks' from Permitted to Discretionary in the Conservation zone
and Informal Recreation zone.
7391-18
Amend the activity status for 'New buildings and external extensions to existing buildings' from
Permitted to Discretionary in the Conservation zone and the Sport and Active Recreation
zone.
7391-19
Amend the activity status of 'New buildings and external extensions to existing buildings from
Permitted to Non-Complying in the Informal Recreation zone.
7391-20
Amend activity status of 'New buildings and external additions to existing buildings exceeding
the gross floor area threshold in clause 3.8 below' from Restricted Discretionary to Non-
Complying in the Informal Recreation zone.
7391-21
Amend activity status of 'New buildings and external additions to existing buildings exceeding
the gross floor area threshold in clause 3.8' from Restricted Discretionary to Discretionary in
the Sport and Active Recreation zone.
7391-22
Amend the activity status of 'Nonsecurity floodlighting, fittings and supports and towers 18m
high or less' from Permitted to Discretionary in the Informal Recreation zone and Sport and
Active Recreation zone.
7391-23
Amend the activity status of 'Nonsecurity floodlighting, fittings and support towers more than
18m high' from Restricted Discretionary to Non-Complying in the Informal Recreation zone.
7391-24
Amend the activity status of 'Nonsecurity floodlighting, fittings and support towers more than
18m high' from Restricted Discretionary to Discretionary in the Sport and Active Recreation
zone.
7391-25
Amend the activity status of 'Gardens, including botanic' from Permitted to Discretionary in the
Informal Recreation zone.
7391-26
Amend the activity status of 'Maimai erection, use, alteration, maintenance, and demolition
associated with lawful gamebird hunting from Permitted to Non-complying in the Conservation
zone and the Informal Recreation zone.
7391-27
Amend the activity status of 'Sport and recreation structures' from Permitted to Discretionary
in the Sport and Active Recreation zone.
7392-1
New Zealand Green Building
Council office@nzgbc.org.nz RPS Urban growth
quality compact urban form Retain the principles of a quality compact city.
7392-2
Council office@nzgbc.org.nz RPS Climate change Retain the approach which addresses climate change through both mitigation and adaptation.
7392-3
Council office@nzgbc.org.nz RPS Issues
Retain the issues of regional significance. Recognise that sustainability of the built
environment is an inherent component of each of these issues.
7392-4
environment Retain the approach which seeks to promote quality buildings.
7392-5
environment Retain the goal of delivering buildings of a higher sustainability standard.
608/1145
Sub#/
7392-6
Council office@nzgbc.org.nz Sustainable Development C7.7/H6.4 Sustainable design
Acknowledge that the rule 6.4 [inferred] will reduce the environmental impact of new buildings
as well as improve the efficiency, health and comfort of new buildings.
7392-7
Council office@nzgbc.org.nz Sustainable Development C7.7/H6.4 Sustainable design Retain the conclusions of the Section 32 report for Sustainable Design.
7392-8
environment Retain objectives and Policy 11.
7392-9
Council office@nzgbc.org.nz Sustainable Development C7.7/H6.4 Sustainable design Retain Objective 1 and Policies 1 and 3.
7392-10
Amend rules 2.2(1)Offices, and 2.3(1) Industrial activities, as shown in the submission [refer
to pages 13/21 vol 1] to reference design rating rather than a design an built rating.
7392-11
Council office@nzgbc.org.nz General Miscellaneous Rates
Add a discounted rates policy for Green Star certified buildings, as shown in the submission
[refer to page 15-16/21 vol 1].
7392-12
Council office@nzgbc.org.nz General Chapter G General provisions
Add a discounted consenting fee structure for Green Star certified buildings, as shown in the
submission [refer to page 16/21 vol 1].
7392-13
Amend rule 2.2(1) Offices, to delete clause (c) and amend clause (a) to read:1 A new building
with a GFA of 5000m2 or greater where 80 per cent or more of the GFA is to be used as an
office, must be designed and constructed to achieve: a minimum 4 Green Star level certified
rating from the New Zealand Green Building Council Green Star Office Tool (2009), or
7392-14
Council office@nzgbc.org.nz Sustainable Development C7.7/H6.4 Sustainable design Add a new clause (d) to rule 2.2 Offices, which reads: Offices used for medical purposes
7392-15
Amend rule 2.3(1) industrial Activities to delete clause (c) and amend clause (a) to read:1 A
new building with a GFA of 5000m2 or greater where 60 per cent or more of the GFA is to be
used for industrial activities , must be designed and constructed to achieve: a minimum 4
Green Star level certified rating from the New Zealand Green Building Council Green Star
Industrial Tool (2009), or...
7392-16
Council office@nzgbc.org.nz General Editorial and Part 6
Amend Part 6 Non-Statutory Guidance, to include the following: Attachment 3 contains the
New Zealand Green Building Council Green Star Office Tool (2009) and Attachment 4
contains the New Zealand Green Building Council Green Star Industrial Tool (2009)
7392-17
Amend the location of the rules 2.2 Offices, and 2.3 Industrial activities, to avoid confusion in
relation to when the rules apply.
7392-18
Council office@nzgbc.org.nz Sustainable Development C7.7/H6.4 Sustainable design Clarify the interaction between particular zones and the Green Star requirements.
7392-19
Council office@nzgbc.org.nz General Miscellaneous Development contributions
Amend the development contribution policy to reflect reduced infrastructure demand of Green
Star buildings, as shown in the submission [refer to page 18-19/21 vol 1].
7392-20
Add bonuses for Green Star certified buildings, such as bonus floor area, as shown in the
submission [refer to page 19/21 vol 1]
7392-21
Council office@nzgbc.org.nz General Chapter G General provisions
Add 'fast track' consenting process for Green Star registered and certified buildings, as shown
in the submission [refer to page 19/21 vol 1].
7392-22
Recognise that the Homestar tool can assist in achieving the Strategic Priority 11 of the
Auckland Plan.
7392-23
Amend rule 2.1(1) Dwellings, to read: In new developments containing five or more dwellings,
each dwelling must be designed and constructed to achieve: a.a minimum 6 Homestar design
rating and a minimum 6 Homestar Certified Rating, certified by-star level from the New
Zealand Green Building Council Homestar Tool (2013), or b.certification under the Living
Building Challenge (2013).
7392-24
Council office@nzgbc.org.nz General Editorial and Part 6
Amend Part 6 Non-Statutory Guidance, to include the following: Attachment 3 contains the
New Zealand Green Building Council (Homestar Tool v2 2013)
7392-25
Recognise the importance of aligning consenting process with the practicalities and practices
of the development and building industry.
7392-26
Recognise that current wording of rule 2.1(1) Dwellings, does not require the development to
be certified. This potentially generates additional costs and processing time for Councils to
assess whether a development meets the requirements.
7392-27
Recognise the importance of developers/applicants to provide formal confirmation of the
intent to achieve 6 Homestar via registration of the project with NZGBC.
7392-28
Retain the reference to the Living Building Challenge in rule 2.1 Dwellings, but recognise that
certification under the Living Building Challenge may create Council compliance issues.
7392-29
Council office@nzgbc.org.nz Sustainable Development C7.7/H6.4 Sustainable design Retain the referencing to the New Zealand Green Building Council Homestar Tool (2013).
7392-30
Acknowledge there needs to be a framework established to allow public easy access to
electronic and hard copies of the Homestar tool.
609/1145
Sub#/
7393-1 Purewa Cemetery Trust Board c.covington@harrisongrierson.com Zoning Central
Rezone the southern portion of 4 Parson's Road, Meadowbank (the driveway portion from St
Johns Road up to Parsons Road) from Public Open Space - Community to Mixed Housing
Urban. See page 5/22 of the submission for map of area.
7394-1 The Kumeu Trust owen@greengroup.co.nz RPS Changes to the RUB West
Rezone the land (Corner Oraha Road and Burns Lane) in Kumeu, described in submission,
from Future Urban to a zone providing for subdivision and a suite of appropriate urban uses
[Attachment 1 - page 6/126].
7394-2 The Kumeu Trust owen@greengroup.co.nz RPS Changes to the RUB North and Waiheke Island
Rezone the land (Corner Oraha Road and Burns Lane) in Kumeu, described in submission,
from Future Urban to Mixed Housing Urban, Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings and
Neighbourhood Centre. See Attachment 2 of submission for specific details [pages 8 -
82/126].
7394-3 The Kumeu Trust owen@greengroup.co.nz RPS Changes to the RUB West
Retain the land (Corner Oraha Road and Burns Lane) in Kumeu, described in submission,
within the Kumeu - Huapai RUB [page 6/126].
7394-4 The Kumeu Trust owen@greengroup.co.nz General Miscellaneous Special housing areas
Include the land (Corner Oraha Road and Burns Lane) in Kumeu, described in submission, as
a Special Housing Area [page 8/126].
7395-1 G Fry parfitt.associates@xtra.co.nz
SEAs
Land Delete the overlay from 135 Upper Harbour Drive, Greenhithe.
7395-2 G Fry parfitt.associates@xtra.co.nz RPS
Pay full compensation for the restrictions imposed by the SEA at 135 Upper Harbour Drive,
Greenhithe.
SEAs
Land
Amend SEA so it only applies from the ridge line down to the coast at 135 Upper Harbour
Drive, Greenhithe.
Outstanding Natural
Rules
Character - Coastal Remove the overlay from 135 Upper Harbour Drive, Greenhithe.
7396-1 General Church Trust Board c.covington@harrisongrierson.com Zoning Central Rezone 12 Judge Street, Parnell, from Public Open Space - Conservation to Single House.
7396-2 General Church Trust Board c.covington@harrisongrierson.com Mana Whenua
Whenua J5.2 Rules
Amend to provide clarity of information requirements and process for dealing with sites
identified as being of value to Mana Whenua.
7396-3 General Church Trust Board c.covington@harrisongrierson.com Mana Whenua General provisions
assessment
Provide clear guidance on the process for determining when a cultural impact assessment is
required.
7397-1 Hayden T Mackenzie hayden.m@me.com RPS Rural B8.3 Rural subdivision Amend to remove the prohibited activity status of subdivision in the rural zone.
7397-2 Hayden T Mackenzie hayden.m@me.com Rural Zones General
Add a new rural zone called "Rural Coastal Bush Block" zone including new zone description,
objectives, polices, rules and development controls (on height and yards), as described in full
in the submission at pages 5-12. The new zone is based on the existing Rural Coastal Zone
but the primary purpose of the land is the protection of native ecosystems while allowing for
some subdivision as a discretionary activity.
7397-3 Hayden T Mackenzie hayden.m@me.com Zoning North and Islands
Rezone 674-692 Hibiscus Coast Road, Hatfields Beach (being Lots 1-5 DP 65095) from Rural
Coastal to Rural Coastal Bush Block [a new zone proposed by the submitter].
7397-4 Hayden T Mackenzie hayden.m@me.com Zoning North and Islands
Rezone 674-692 Hibiscus Coast Road, Hatfields Beach (being Lots 1-5 DP 65095) from Rural
Coastal to Countryside Living.
7397-5 Hayden T Mackenzie hayden.m@me.com Precincts - North New Precincts All other New Precincts
Create a new precinct and apply it to 674-692 Hibiscus Coast Road, Hatfields Beach (being
Lots 1-5 DP 65095). Submission states that rules can be provided on request.
7397-6 Hayden T Mackenzie hayden.m@me.com General Chapter A Introduction A3 Strategic Framework Retain Strategic Framework.
7397-7 Hayden T Mackenzie hayden.m@me.com RPS
Transport B3.3 Transport Retain Objective 1, Objective 2, Objective 3 and Objective 4.
7397-8 Hayden T Mackenzie hayden.m@me.com RPS Coastal
7397-11 Hayden T Mackenzie hayden.m@me.com RPS Rural B8.3 Rural subdivision Amend Objective 2 to replace the word "prevented". [No alternative relief is proposed.]
7397-12 Hayden T Mackenzie hayden.m@me.com RPS Rural B8.3 Rural subdivision
Amend Objective 2 so that it applies only to productive rural land as follows: "Further
fragmentation of productive rural land by sporadic and scattered subdivision for urban and
rural lifestyle purposes is prevented."
610/1145
Sub#/
7397-13 Hayden T Mackenzie hayden.m@me.com RPS Rural B8.3 Rural subdivision
Amend Policy 5 to provide for a new proposed zone, as follows: "Provide new rural lifestyle
subdivision in Countryside Living zones and Rural Coastal Bush zones."
7397-14 Hayden T Mackenzie hayden.m@me.com Infrastructure
C1.1 Infrastructure
7397-15 Hayden T Mackenzie hayden.m@me.com Infrastructure
C1.1 Infrastructure
7397-16 Hayden T Mackenzie hayden.m@me.com Earthworks
7397-17 Hayden T Mackenzie hayden.m@me.com Earthworks
7397-18 Hayden T Mackenzie hayden.m@me.com
SEAs
and policies Retain Objective 1, in particular the provision for reasonable use and development.
7397-19 Hayden T Mackenzie hayden.m@me.com
SEAs
Add new description, objectives and polices for proposed new zone 'Rural Coastal Bush
Block' based on the amendments to the existing rural coastal zone and countryside living
zone, descriptions, objectives and polices shown on page 5-7 of Submission 7397.
Amend the Activity Table to provide for subdivision in the proposed new "Rural Coastal Bush
Block zone" as a Discretionary activity.
7397-22 Hayden T Mackenzie hayden.m@me.com Subdivision Auckland-wide - Rural zones
zones only
Amend the Activity Table to delete Prohibited Activity status. [No alternative activity status is
proposed]
Add new activity table for proposed new zone 'Rural Coastal Bush Block' based on the
amendments to the existing rural coastal zone shown on page 8 of Submission 7397.
Amend Land use control 2.1(1) "General - all rural zones" to include reference to the
proposed new Rural Coastal Bush Block Lot zone.
Amend Land use control 2.4(1)(b) "Animal breeding or boarding except dogs" to include the
proposed new Rural Coastal Bush Block zone.
7397-26 Hayden T Mackenzie hayden.m@me.com General Editorial and Part 6 Amend Land use control 2.5(3) "Produce stalls" to remove an unnecessary "than".
Amend Land use control 2.5(3)(b) "Produce stalls" to include the proposed new Rural Coastal
Bush Block zone as well as the Countryside Living zone.
Amend Table 1 of Land use control 2.6 "Dwellings" to include reference to the proposed new
"Rural Coastal Bush Block" zone in column three, with the same controls as Countryside
Living Zone.
Amend land use control 2.11(3) "Restaurants and cafes" to include the proposed new Rural
Coastal Bush Block zone.
objectives & policies Add new column to Height table to provide for new zone Rural Coastal Bush Block.
objectives & policies Add new column to Yards table to provide for new zone, Rural Coastal Bush Block.
7397-32 Hayden T Mackenzie hayden.m@me.com General Editorial and Part 6 Amend 4.2.1(a)(ii) to improve sentence readability.
Amend Assessment criteria 4.2.2(a) for Restricted Discretionary activities, as follows: "Rural
character and amenity values, and in the Rural Coastal Bush Block zone; protection of native
bush environment"
Amend 6.1 Matters of Discretion for development control infringements 1(a), 2(a), 4(a) and
5(a) to include the text 'and in the Rural Coastal Bush Block zone; protection of native bush
environment.'
7397-35 Hayden T Mackenzie hayden.m@me.com General
GIS viewer
Amend GIS maps so that the map layers accurately align with underlying map layers or
property boundaries, particularly in relation to the submitter's property at 688 Hibiscus Coast
7398-1 The Salvation Army parfitt.associates@xtra.co.nz
control
Building demolition control J.3.6 Rules and mapping Delete the overlay from 32B Powell Street, Avondale
control
Building demolition control J.3.6 Rules and mapping Delete the overlay from 1A Sproston Avenue, Ellerslie
control
Building demolition control J.3.6 Rules and mapping Delete the overlay from 3 - 19 Ewington Ave, Mt Eden
control
Building demolition control J.3.6 Rules and mapping Delete the overlay from 10 -14 Clyde Street, Epsom
7398-5 The Salvation Army parfitt.associates@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central Rezone 1159 Dominion Road, Mount Roskill from Single House to Mixed Housing Suburban
611/1145
Sub#/
7398-6 The Salvation Army parfitt.associates@xtra.co.nz Definitions Existing
Amend the Definition of 'Community Facilities' to include 'A place of worship,' and the
definition to read: "A place of worship may include all or any of the following offices, meeting
rooms, welfare and advice services and humanitarian ad emergency services and supplies",
7398-7 The Salvation Army parfitt.associates@xtra.co.nz Zoning West Rezone 425 West Coast Road, Glen Eden from Single House to Mixed Housing Urban.
7398-8 The Salvation Army parfitt.associates@xtra.co.nz Zoning West Rezone 269 Glengarry Road, Glen Eden from Single House to Mixed Housing Suburban.
7398-9 The Salvation Army parfitt.associates@xtra.co.nz Special Character
& C
Isthmus Delete the overlay from 691 Mt Albert Road, Royal Oak.
7398-10 The Salvation Army parfitt.associates@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central Rezone 21 Celtic Crescent, Ellerslie from Single House to Mixed Housing Suburban.
7398-11 The Salvation Army parfitt.associates@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central Rezone 30B Lenore Road, Favona from Single House to Mixed Housing Suburban
7398-12 The Salvation Army parfitt.associates@xtra.co.nz Zoning West Rezone 6 Bently Drive, Henderson from SIngle House to Mixed Housing Suburban
7398-13 The Salvation Army parfitt.associates@xtra.co.nz Zoning North and Islands Rezone 24 Greenview Lane, Red Beach from Single House to Mixed Housing Suburban
control
Building demolition control J.3.6 Rules and mapping Delete the overlay from from 3A Highland Road, Mt Albert
7398-15 The Salvation Army parfitt.associates@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central Retain the Mixed Use zone at 691 Mt Albert Road, Mount Albert.
7398-16 The Salvation Army parfitt.associates@xtra.co.nz Transport Auckland -wide
requirements Remove the requirement to provide bicycle parking in the Business zone
7398-17 The Salvation Army parfitt.associates@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central Rezone 18 Allright Place from Light Industry to Mixed Use.
7398-18 The Salvation Army parfitt.associates@xtra.co.nz Zoning West
Rezone the rear third of 532 - 534 Don Buck Road, Massey from Future Urban and Mixed
Housing Urban to Mixed Housing Urban
7398-19 The Salvation Army parfitt.associates@xtra.co.nz Residential zones Residential Activity Table
Amend the Activity Table to provide for 'Family store for the Salvation Army as a Permitted
Activity at 532 - 534 Don Buck Road, Massey.
7398-20 The Salvation Army parfitt.associates@xtra.co.nz Mana Whenua
Whenua
of value to Mana Whenua Delete the overlay from 9 Willcott Street, Mt Albert
Amend the Activity Table to change the floor area for boarding houses as a Permitted Activity
from 200 m
2
to 300 m
2
, and the floor area for boarding houses as a Discretionary Activity
to 300 m2

Amend the Activity Table to include a statement that identifies 178 Chapel Road, Flat Bush as
a site for the Salvation Army including places of worship, cafe, family store, and community
health and welfare services and premises for these activities
Centre) Business
Amend the Activity Table to allow for The Salvation Army activities at 18 Allright Place, Mount
Welilngton [Refer to page 34/40, Volume 1 of the submission for this point].
7398-24 The Salvation Army parfitt.associates@xtra.co.nz Transport Auckland -wide
requirements Exempt places of worship from the requirement to provide bicycle parking.
7398-25 The Salvation Army parfitt.associates@xtra.co.nz Definitions New
Add a definition of 'Church' or 'Place of worship' to read: "A place of worship my include all or
any of [the] following offices, meeting rooms, welfare and advice services and humanitarian
and emergency services and supplies."
7399-1 Francis S Sharpe stephensharpe@clear.net.nz RPS Mana Whenua B5 Strategic
co-management, joint management agreements and the transfer of power to Mana Whenua.
7399-2 Francis S Sharpe stephensharpe@clear.net.nz General Miscellaneous Consultation and engagement
Whenua.
7399-3 Francis S Sharpe stephensharpe@clear.net.nz Water
policies
Amend Policy 5 to keep management decision regarding freshwater resources to lie solely
with the elected council and not in partnership with Mana Whenua.
7399-4 Francis S Sharpe stephensharpe@clear.net.nz Mana Whenua General provisions
assessment Remove the requirement to obtain cultural impact assessments from iwi.
assessment
Amend the plan to make Council the agency that is responsible for preparing a cultural impact
assessment that is deemed by Council to be necessary.
7399-7 Francis S Sharpe stephensharpe@clear.net.nz Mana Whenua
Whenua
Rewrite the policies in a way that: respects property rights; provides a fair balance between
Whenua
Grade these sites into categories of significance with varying degrees of protection and
obligation.
612/1145
Sub#/
Whenua
and policies
Grade the sites into categories of significance with varying degrees of protection and
obligation.
7399-10 Francis S Sharpe stephensharpe@clear.net.nz RPS Mana Whenua B5 Strategic
Require council to fully explain to all affected parties the impact of, and obligations required by
landowners, when a site of significance or value is designated.
7399-11 Francis S Sharpe stephensharpe@clear.net.nz Water
management
Amend Policy 11 to keep management decision regarding freshwater resources to lie solely
with the elected council and not in partnership with Mana Whenua.
Whenua
and policies
Rewrite the policies in a way that: respects property rights; provides a fair balance between
7399-13 Francis S Sharpe stephensharpe@clear.net.nz RPS Issues
Amend B1.4 by deleting the statement 'It is important to build stable and equal partnerships
which enable Mana Whenua to actively and meaningfully participate in the management of
natural resources '. This appears in the third paragraph under the heading 'Decision making,
7399-14 Francis S Sharpe stephensharpe@clear.net.nz RPS Mana Whenua
participation
Amend B1.4 by deleting the bullet point 'Enable Mana Whenua to participate in co-
management of natural resources'. This statement appears under the heading 'Auckland
Plan strategic direction and priorities'
7399-15 Francis S Sharpe stephensharpe@clear.net.nz RPS Mana Whenua
participation Amend B5.1 by deleting Policies 3 and 4.
7400-1 Ria Masae
20C Saxon Street, Waterview,
Rezone North Waterview - Herdman, Daventry, Waterbank Streets from Mixed Housing
Urban to Mixed Housing Suburban.
7401-1 Brian D Drummond junichiro2u@gmail.com
SEAs
and policies
Amend Objective 1 to insert "significant" before the words "areas of contiguous native
vegetation cover".
SEAs
and policies
Amend Policy 2 to insert "significant" before the words "areas of contiguous native vegetation
cover".
SEAs
Amend 1.2 activity table, SEA overlay, to insert "vegetation alteration or removal of less than
25m
2
of any exotic vegetation" as a permitted activity.
SEAs
Amend 1.2 activity table, SEA overlay, to insert "vegetation alteration or removal of more
than 25m
2
of any exotic vegetation" as a discretionary activity.
SEAs
Amend 1.2 activity table, SEA overlay, to insert "vegetation alteration or removal within a
SEA for building platforms and works for improvements ancillary to any dwelling on the site"
as a controlled activity.
SEAs
Insert in 3.1 a new subclause "3(3) Matters of control - Improvements" (refer to submission for
wording) regarding vegetation alteration or removal within a SEA for building platforms and
ancillary works.
SEAs
Insert in 3.1 a new subclause "3(4) Assessment criteria - Improvements" (refer to submission
for wording) regarding vegetation pruning, alteration or removal for building platforms and
ancillary works.
SEAs
Land Delete SEA_T_6065 [infer at 94 Victoria Ave, Remuera].
7401-9 Brian D Drummond junichiro2u@gmail.com RPS
Exclude exotic and pest trees from SEAs, and properly identify areas of native vegetation in
SEAs, and accurately reflect the area of significant native vegetation in SEAs, and incorporate
amendments set out in pages 3-6 of the submission.
Amend Plan to specify the nature and extent of the indigenous vegetation that it wishes to
protect by species and size.
character and natural heritage B4.3.4 Biodiversity Delete the broad brush blanket approach of large residential areas identified as SEAs.
character and natural heritage B4.3.4 Biodiversity Compensate landowners with SEAs identified on their property.
7401-13 Brian D Drummond junichiro2u@gmail.com General
GIS viewer Delete the macroinvertebrate community index layer.
SEAs
Land
Amend provisions for 94 Victoria Avenue, Remuera to: exclude exotic and pest trees from the
SEA, and properly identify areas of native vegetation in the SEA, and accurately reflect the
area of significant native vegetation in the SEA, and incorporate amendments set out in points
1-7 in the submission.
SEAs
Land
Insert a new provision setting out council requirements to purchase residential land, at 94
Victoria Ave Remuera, identified as a SEA (see page 20/40 of submission for wording).
Insert a new provision regarding council to reduce rates on residential land, at 94 Victoria Ave
Remuera, identified as a SEA (see page 21/40 of submission for wording).
613/1145
Sub#/
7401-17 Brian D Drummond junichiro2u@gmail.com General
GIS viewer Delete the macroinvertebrate community index layer from 94 Victoria Av, Remuera.
7401-18 Brian D Drummond junichiro2u@gmail.com General Miscellaneous Consultation and engagement
Extend the timeframe for public submissions to 31 August 2014 and extend all subsequent
milestones.
Insert a new provision regarding council to offer to purchase any residential land identified as
a SEA (see page 23/40 of submission for wording).
Insert a new provision regarding council to reduce rates on any residential land identified as a
SEA (see page 24/40 submission for wording).
7402-1 Audrey Ritchie awr7@clear.net.nz Historic Heritage (Overlay)
Heritage
Places Schedule the 'Manual training centre' at 82 - 84 Selwyn Street, Onehunga [inferred].
Heritage
Places Schedule 'Selwyn lodge' at 52 Selwyn Street, Onehunga [inferred]
Heritage
Places Schedule 'Fencible cottage' at 154 Arthur Street, Onehunga [inferred].
7403-1 Denise A Tonkin datonkin@gmail.com
Centre) Business
zones
Amend the Height in Relation to Boundary control [Rule 5.2] to provide greater protection of
residential areas adjoining Industrial zones
Centre) Business
zones
Amend the Maximum Impervious area control [Rule 5.3] to provide greater protection of
residential areas adjoining Industrial zones
Centre) Business
zones
Amend the Yard control [Rule 5.4] to provide greater protection of residential areas adjoining
Industrial zones.
Centre) Business
zones
Amend the Storage and Screening development control [Rule 5.5] to provide greater
protection of residential areas adjoining Industrial zones.
7403-5 Denise A Tonkin datonkin@gmail.com Zoning Central
Rezone the Maungakiekie - Tamaki area so that there is less mixed and high density
housing
7403-6 Denise A Tonkin datonkin@gmail.com Zoning Central
Panama Road and George Bourke Drive to Public Open Space Conservation in order to
restore the 'green corridor'
Centre) Business
zones
Amend the setback from the Light Industry zone boundary adjoining the residential zone to 10
metres between Panama Road and George Bourke Drive, Mount Wellington.
7403-8 Denise A Tonkin datonkin@gmail.com Residential zones Residential
Amend the Outlook Space development control [Rule 7.10] of the Mixed Housing Suburban
zone to provide a yard greater than 1 metre.
7404-1 Allen R Tonkin allen.tonkin@gmail.com
Centre) Business
zones
Amend the Height in Relation to Boundary control [Rule 5.2] to provide greater protection of
residential areas adjoining Industrial zones.
Centre) Business
zones
Amend the Maximum Impervious Area control [Rule 5.3] to provide greater protection of
residential areas adjoining Industrial zones.
Centre) Business
zones
Amend the Yard development control [Rule 5.4] to provide greater protection of residential
areas adjoining Industrial zones.
Centre) Business
zones
Amend the Storage and Screening development control [Rule 5.5] to provide greater
protection of residential areas adjoining Industrial zones.
7404-5 Allen R Tonkin allen.tonkin@gmail.com Zoning Central Rezone the Maungakiekie- Tamaki area so that there is less mixed and high density housing.
7404-6 Allen R Tonkin allen.tonkin@gmail.com Zoning Central
Panama Road and George Bourke Drive, Mount Wellington.
Centre) Business
zones
Amend the setback from the Light Industry zone boundary to 10 metres between Panama
Road and George Bourke Drive, Mount Wellington.
7404-8 Allen R Tonkin allen.tonkin@gmail.com Residential zones Residential
Amend the Outlook Space development control [Rule 7.10] of the Mixed Housing Suburban
zone to provide a yard greater than 1 metre.
614/1145
Sub#/
Centre) Business
zones
Reduce impervious threshold controls applying to Panama Road and George Burke Road,
Mount Wellington, to address current stormwater issues.
7405-1 Lillian A Epston bicycle2@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central Retain the Single House zone on Queens Ave, Balmoral.
7405-2 Lillian A Epston bicycle2@xtra.co.nz Residential zones Residential
Retain the Maximum permitted building height for the Single House zone as it applies to
Queens Avenue, Balmoral.
7405-3 Lillian A Epston bicycle2@xtra.co.nz Special Character
General
character statement - General Retain the overlay as it applies to Queens Avenue, Balmoral.
7405-4 Lillian A Epston bicycle2@xtra.co.nz
control
Building demolition control J.3.6 Rules and mapping Retain the overlay as it applies to Queens Avenue, Balmoral.
7406-1 Neil R Palmer neilpalm@gmail.com Zoning Central
Retain the Mixed Housing Suburban zone on Campbell Road, Te Kawa Road, and on August
Place, Greenlane.
7407-1 Wendy Hughes wendy.hughes@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central Retain the Single House zone at 3 Tongariro St, Mt Eden, and the surrounding street.
7407-2 Wendy Hughes wendy.hughes@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central
Retain the Single House zoning in all of the area within the Special Character overlay in the
immediate vicinity of Eden Park.
7407-3 Wendy Hughes wendy.hughes@xtra.co.nz Public Open Space Zones
I18.2-3 Land use &
Retain the Major Recreation Facility zone on Eden Park only if the existing Eden Park concept
plan and consent restrictions are fully incorporated into the zone and with no additional
activities, or change in activity status or notification.
7407-4 Wendy Hughes wendy.hughes@xtra.co.nz Precincts Ak-Wide and Coastal Stadiums and Showgrounds K1.10 Precinct Rules
Retain the Eden Park Sub-precinct on Eden Park only if the Existing Eden Park concept plan
and consent restrictions are fully incorporated into the Sub-precinct and with no additional
activities, or change in activity status or notification.
7407-5 Wendy Hughes wendy.hughes@xtra.co.nz General
H6.5)
Amend the Activity Table to exclude the temporary activity rule from applying to Stadiums and
showgrounds, particularly Eden Park sub-precinct.
7407-6 Wendy Hughes wendy.hughes@xtra.co.nz General Chapter G General provisions G2.4 Notification Amend to ensure that all Restricted Discretionary activities use normal RMA notification tests
7407-7 Wendy Hughes wendy.hughes@xtra.co.nz
Amend Rule 3.1 Activities within 30m of a residential zone, to change activity status from
Restricted Discretionary to Discretionary.
7407-8 Wendy Hughes wendy.hughes@xtra.co.nz Special Character
& C J3.3.1-7 Rules
Amend the Activity Table to make demolition a Discretionary activity, not Restricted
Discretionary.
7407-9 Wendy Hughes wendy.hughes@xtra.co.nz Special Character
& C J3.3.1-7 Rules Amend to remove the relocation of a removed building as part of the Assessment Criteria.
Rezone Sandringham Road from Rossmay Terrace south (both sides) to Gribblehirst Rd,
Sandringham, from Mixed Housing Urban to Mixed Housing Suburban.
7407-11 Wendy Hughes wendy.hughes@xtra.co.nz Built Environment (Overlays)
Height Control
Delete the Additional height control of 12.5m/3 storeys for the Eden Valley centre and replace
with a maximum permitted height of 10m/2storeys.
Rezone from the Mixed Housing Urban and Mixed Use zones to a less intensive zoning within
the area of Balmoral Road, West to Sandringham Road, North to Kingsland, East to Mt Eden
Road, and North to New North Road.
7408-1 Ray Talbot ray.talbot@xtra.co.nz Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula K5.11 Precinct rules
Delete the Precinct Plan 3 and replace with the proposed road layout provided in page 7/7 of
the submission
Add a requirement for a traffic impact study to be carried out for proposed developments. See
submission page 4/7 for full suggested wording
Add a requirement for a secondary access route to the Devonport Peninsula to be provided
before any housing intensification is permitted.
Add a requirement for a capacity assessment of water supply and drainage network before
and development commences. See page 5/7 of submission for full suggested provision
Add a Development Control to Sub-precinct C requiring a minimum of 7.5% of the
development area to be provided as Public Open Space.
Add a Development Control requiring development height will comply with the volcanic cone
corridor
Add a Development Control so that retail and commercial activities are not permitted within
Sub-precinct C
Amend the Building height in Sub-precinct C so that buildings do not exceed 8 metres in
height
7409-1 Keith Sharp keith.sharp@xtra.co.nz Residential zones Residential
General
Reduce the permitted residential height limits in the Panmure area to the levels of the
Operative Plan.
7409-2 Keith Sharp keith.sharp@xtra.co.nz Built Environment (Overlays)
Height Control
Remove the Additional Height overlay from residential areas in Panmure to the east of
Jellicoe Road
615/1145
Sub#/
7409-3 Keith Sharp keith.sharp@xtra.co.nz Built Environment (Overlays)
Height Control
Remove additional height control from the Panmure town centre to the east of Jellicoe Road,
and if necessary increase the permitted height to the west of the Panmure railway station.
7409-4 Keith Sharp keith.sharp@xtra.co.nz Residential zones Residential Land use controls
Rezone the Panmure area to reduce the Maximum Density limits to those in the current
Operative Plan (e.g from Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings to Mixed Housing Urban).
7409-5 Keith Sharp keith.sharp@xtra.co.nz General Chapter G General provisions G2.4 Notification Require full notification for all new developments (particularly high rise, high density plans).
7409-6 Keith Sharp keith.sharp@xtra.co.nz
shafts survey coordinates Retain the Volcanic View Shafts towards Mount Wellington in the Panmure area
7409-7 Keith Sharp keith.sharp@xtra.co.nz RPS Urban growth B2.7 Social infrastructure
Provide for the additional schools in the Panmure area to accommodate the projected
population growth.
7409-8 Keith Sharp keith.sharp@xtra.co.nz Historic Heritage (Overlay)
Heritage
Places Schedule Loombs Hotel at 8 Kings Road, Panmure
7409-9 Keith Sharp keith.sharp@xtra.co.nz
Centre)
obs & pols
Provide for a shopping mall-type development in the Panmure Town Centre area bounded by
Queens Road, Pilkington Road, Pleasant View Road and west of Jellicoe Road.
7409-10 Keith Sharp keith.sharp@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central
Rezone to the West of the Panmure Railway Station to recognise the development potential
for brownfield residential development.
7410-1 Cheryl Price prices59@vodafone.co.nz Precincts - North Bayswater
objectives and policies Remove the reference to providing for residential activities in Sub-precinct B
7411-1 Joshua Don joshuadon@vodafone.co.nz RPS Changes to the RUB North and Waiheke Island
Rezone Wellsford to allow for additional growth [as per maps provided on pages 3&5 of the
submission. The maps include additioanl Future Urban zoning].
7411-2 Joshua Don joshuadon@vodafone.co.nz RPS Changes to the RUB North and Waiheke Island
Rezone Te Hana to allow for additional growth [as per the maps provided on pages 4/5 of the
submission. The map includes additional industrial zoned].
7412-1 Gary Appleby karleen.gary@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central
Rezone 94 Alfred Street, Onehunga, from Single House from Single House to Mixed Housing
Urban.
7413-1 Kelly Brown
47 Herdman Street, Waterview,
Rezone area of Herdman/Daventry/Waterbank Streets to Mixed Housing Suburban zone to 2
storeys maximum like the rest of Waterview.
7414-1 Dave Henry
41A Parrs Cross Road, Henderson,
Rezone Herdman/Daventry/Waterbank Streets to Mixed Housing Suburban Zone to 2 storeys
maximum like the rest of Waterview.
7415-1 Denise Meihana dtaiapa1@gmail.com Zoning Central
Rezone Herdman/Daventry/Waterbank Streets, Waterview to Mixed Housing Suburban
zoning to 2 storeys maximum like the rest of Waterview.
7416-1 David and Marguerite Crickmer margueritec@vodafone.co.nz Precincts - West
Area
objectives and policies Rezone 176 Candia Road, Henderson Valley to rural residential.
7417-1 Milford Residents Association stephen@sfhconsultants.co.nz Built Environment (Overlays)
Height Control Retain the distinct height areas at Milford Town Centre as notified.
7417-2 Milford Residents Association stephen@sfhconsultants.co.nz Zoning North and Islands
Retain the spatial extent of residential zones adjoining Milford Town Centre and along
Shakespeare Road, refer submission page 6/80.
7417-3 Milford Residents Association stephen@sfhconsultants.co.nz Residential zones Residential
Mixed Housing Urban zone Amend the [infer, Rule 7.5] Yards, to provide a 4 metre rear yard.
Mixed Housing Urban zone Amend the [infer, Rule 8.6] Yards, to provide a 4 metre rear yard.
Mixed Housing Urban zone Amend [infer, Rule 7.8 Building] coverage, to reduce the proportion of coverage.
Mixed Housing Urban zone Amend [infer, Rule 8.8 Building] coverage, to reduce the proportion of coverage.
7417-7 Milford Residents Association stephen@sfhconsultants.co.nz Residential zones Residential Land use controls Amend [infer, Rule 3.1 Maximum] density, to be [infer, no more than] 1:300m2.
7417-8 Milford Residents Association stephen@sfhconsultants.co.nz Residential zones Residential Notification
Amend [infer, Rule 4(1) Notification] to require applications which infringe the development
controls to obtain the consent of affected parties, in the Mixed Housing Urban and Suburban
zones, refer submission page 9/80.
7417-9 Milford Residents Association stephen@sfhconsultants.co.nz General Chapter G General provisions
activities
Amend the Unitary Plan to allow the Council, in the case of restricted discretionary
activities, to consider the potential effects of development on neighbouring properties or the
character of an area or its design, refer submission page 9/80.
7417-10 Milford Residents Association stephen@sfhconsultants.co.nz General Chapter G General provisions G2.4 Notification
Amend clause (1) to allow controlled and restricted discretionary activities to be assessed
against the tests for public and limited notification or written approval from affected parties.
Amend the rules governing the interface between the Mixed Housing Suburban and Urban
zones and the Mixed Use and Terraced Housing/Apartment zones to protect these areas from
building dominance, overshadowing, loss of privacy, sunlight and other adverse effects.
616/1145
Sub#/
7417-12 Milford Residents Association stephen@sfhconsultants.co.nz RPS Urban growth
Amend the Unitary Plan so that new facilities, such as the proposed National Ocean
Watersports Centre, are placed on land newly acquired for that purpose, refer submission
page 11/80.
General Retain the heights of residential zones adjoining Milford town centre.
7417-14 Milford Residents Association stephen@sfhconsultants.co.nz Mana Whenua General provisions
assessment
Amend the cultural impact assessment provisions to ensure they are transparent, and remove
streamline the consultation process, refer submission page 12/80.
7417-15 Milford Residents Association stephen@sfhconsultants.co.nz Zoning North and Islands
Rezone the car park at [#139] Kitchener Road, Milford [infer, from Town Centre] to future
community open space.
7417-16 Milford Residents Association stephen@sfhconsultants.co.nz Public Open Space Zones Public Open Space D2 Introduction
Amend the Unitary Plan to ensure full public consultation is undertaken when new buildings
and structures are proposed to be constructed on parks and reserves, refer submission page
12/80.
7417-17 Milford Residents Association stephen@sfhconsultants.co.nz General Miscellaneous Consultation and engagement
Add a new Milford Centre Plan, to establish additional community amenities, open space and
activity areas, refer submission page 12/80.
7417-18 Milford Residents Association stephen@sfhconsultants.co.nz General Miscellaneous Development contributions
Ensure that development contributions are allocated to reflect local intensification and [infer,
local area planning, such as] the centre plan [refer point number 17].
7418-1 Sharleen F McClay smandjj@hotmail.com Zoning South Rezone 28A Miller Road, Mangere Bridge, from Single House to Mixed Housing Suburban.
7419-1 Venkataraman Narayanan nara@asia-oss.net Residential zones Residential
General
7419-2 Venkataraman Narayanan nara@asia-oss.net Special Character
General
7419-3 Venkataraman Narayanan nara@asia-oss.net Zoning Central
House
7419-4 Venkataraman Narayanan nara@asia-oss.net
control
7420-1 Angela Fuller amfuller@xtra.co.nz
organisms
modified organisms Retain the strong precautionary genetic engineering objective, policies and methods.
7421-1
Clevedon Business
Association hololio@xtra.co.nz RPS
Provide support to landowners to preserve, repair and maintain heritage buildings by rates
relief, free heritage consultations and free resource consent processes.
7421-2
Clevedon Business
Association hololio@xtra.co.nz RPS
character and natural heritage B4.1 Historic heritage Provide support for innovative uses of heritage sites.
7421-3
Clevedon Business
Association hololio@xtra.co.nz Mana Whenua General provisions
assessment Reject requirement to consult with Iwi on all heritage restoration projects.
7421-4
Clevedon Business
Association hololio@xtra.co.nz General Miscellaneous Other Provide support for landowners to make the best business use of their land.
7421-5
Clevedon Business
Association hololio@xtra.co.nz Precincts - South Clevedon Provide for visitor based businesses as Permitted activities in Clevedon.
7421-6
Clevedon Business
Association hololio@xtra.co.nz General Miscellaneous
Operational/
Ensure infrastructure such as wastewater, roading and public toilets are provided and
maintained in Clevedon.
7421-7
Clevedon Business
Association hololio@xtra.co.nz RPS Urban growth
land for urban development Reject capital gains tax for rezoned land.
7421-8
Clevedon Business
Association hololio@xtra.co.nz RPS Issues
Recognise the Wairoa River as a resource of regional significance that needs to be restored
to a navigable state.
7421-9
Clevedon Business
Association hololio@xtra.co.nz Precincts - South Clevedon
Retain the precinct objectives and policies to the extent that it incorporates Plan Change 32
provisions.
7421-10
Clevedon Business
Extend the boundary of the precinct to include the old Wairoa or Otau Mountain settlement on
McNichol Road, Clevedon.
7421-11
Clevedon Business
Extend the boundary of the precinct to include the Wairoa River catchment i.e. the ridgeline
above McNicol Road and Chrichtons Road, Clevedon.
7421-12
Clevedon Business
Association hololio@xtra.co.nz Precincts Ak-Wide and Coastal Regional Parks
Amend the precincts to separate the Regional Park from Public Open Space and other
designations.
7421-13
Clevedon Business
Association hololio@xtra.co.nz Designations G1.3 Designations Designate the Clevedon Equestrian Trails, where vested in Council.
7421-14
Clevedon Business
Association hololio@xtra.co.nz Rural Zones General I13.1 Activity table
Provide for minor household units or second dwellings on all rural blocks as Permitted
activities.
7421-15
Clevedon Business
Association hololio@xtra.co.nz General Miscellaneous Other Support the submission made by the Franklin Business Associations.
7422-1 Tyronne A Cooke
3/30 Colchester Avenue, Glendowie,
residential
Add new special character area to protect St Heliers village rather than a precinct. The
special character area would include provisions restricting development to a small scale,
limiting maximum height to 9m, setting out detailed design guidelines, maintaining and
enhancing small businesses, encouraging adaption and reuse of buildings and limiting the
number of bars and restaurants.
617/1145
Sub#/
Auckland 1071 Precincts - Central Saint Heliers K2.19.Precinct Rules
Restrict maximum residential building height in Goldie Street and Lombard Street, St Heliers
to 9m.
Retain the Mixed Housing zone from Cliff Road to Clarendon Road, St Heliers and along the
Retain the Mixed Housing Suburban and Mixed Housing Urban zones at St Heliers and its
environs.
residential
special character areas Add the Tamaki Drive Masterplan into the PAUP.
Operational/
Projects/Acquisition Ensure Tamaki Drive continues to serve the travel needs of local residents.
residential
Include assessment criteria which assess the potential adverse effects of development along
7423-1 Arzhela M Henton arzhelahenton@hotmail.com
organisms
7424-1 Claire Duncan duncan5@xtra.co.nz
organisms
7425-1 Sally D Challinor sallydchall@gmail.com Special Character
residential
7425-2 Sally D Challinor sallydchall@gmail.com Precincts - Central Saint Heliers K2.19.Precinct Rules
to 9m.
7425-3 Sally D Challinor sallydchall@gmail.com Zoning Central
7425-4 Sally D Challinor sallydchall@gmail.com Zoning Central
environs.
residential
7425-6 Sally D Challinor sallydchall@gmail.com General Miscellaneous
Operational/
residential
7426-1 Brian Alderson brian_alderson@hotmail.com
organisms
7427-1 Sarah Williams sarah@stillsabro.co.nz
organisms
7428-1 Paul Cummings pspc@hotmail.com Special Character
residential
7428-2 Paul Cummings pspc@hotmail.com Precincts - Central Saint Heliers K2.19.Precinct Rules
to 9m.
7428-3 Paul Cummings pspc@hotmail.com Zoning Central
7428-4 Paul Cummings pspc@hotmail.com Zoning Central
environs.
residential
7428-6 Paul Cummings pspc@hotmail.com General Miscellaneous
Operational/
residential
7429-1 Ingeborg Muller ingamu@slingshot.co.nz
organisms
7430-1 Glenis McIntyre
214A Saint Heliers Bay Road, Saint
residential
Heliers, Auckland 1071 Precincts - Central Saint Heliers K2.19.Precinct Rules
to 9m.
618/1145
Sub#/
Heliers, Auckland 1071 Zoning Central
environs.
residential
Heliers, Auckland 1071 General Miscellaneous
Operational/
residential
7431-1 Roy T Bain
63/184 Saint Heliers Bay Road, Saint
residential
7431-2 Roy T Bain
to 9m.
7431-3 Roy T Bain
7431-4 Roy T Bain
environs.
7431-5 Roy T Bain
residential
7431-6 Roy T Bain
Operational/
7431-7 Roy T Bain
residential
7432-1 Richard Thorn
360B Kohimarama Road, Saint
residential
to 9m.
environs.
residential
Operational/
residential
7433-1 Diana S Meiklejohn sallymeik67@gmail.com
organisms
7434-1 Lisa Benson benson_lisa@hotmail.com
organisms
7435-1 JoAnne C Bowden pj.bowden@xtra.co.nz Special Character
residential
7435-2 JoAnne C Bowden pj.bowden@xtra.co.nz Precincts - Central Saint Heliers K2.19.Precinct Rules
to 9m.
7435-3 JoAnne C Bowden pj.bowden@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central
7435-4 JoAnne C Bowden pj.bowden@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central
environs.
residential
7435-6 JoAnne C Bowden pj.bowden@xtra.co.nz General Miscellaneous
Operational/
619/1145
Sub#/
residential
7436-1 Nerena Morris doghouse@ihug.co.nz
organisms
7437-1 Richard T Wall rajah345@gmail.com Special Character
residential
7437-2 Richard T Wall rajah345@gmail.com Precincts - Central Saint Heliers K2.19.Precinct Rules
to 9m.
7437-3 Richard T Wall rajah345@gmail.com Zoning Central
7437-4 Richard T Wall rajah345@gmail.com Zoning Central
environs.
residential
7437-6 Richard T Wall rajah345@gmail.com General Miscellaneous
Operational/
residential
7438-1 Adam Lloyd-Jones revolutionatwork@gmail.com
organisms
7439-1 Valerie E Keppel
3/5 Brookfield Street, Saint Heliers,
residential
to 9m.
environs.
residential
Operational/
residential
7440-1 Stuart Devine stu@ppw.co.nz Special Character
residential
7440-2 Stuart Devine stu@ppw.co.nz Precincts - Central Saint Heliers K2.19.Precinct Rules
to 9m.
7440-3 Stuart Devine stu@ppw.co.nz Zoning Central
7440-4 Stuart Devine stu@ppw.co.nz Zoning Central
environs.
residential
7440-6 Stuart Devine stu@ppw.co.nz General Miscellaneous
Operational/
residential
7441-1 Russell Phillips
11 Weybridge Crescent, Glen Innes,
residential
to 9m.
620/1145
Sub#/
environs.
residential
Operational/
residential
7442-1 Susanne Spencer
3 Gifford Street, Saint Heliers,
residential
to 9m.
environs.
residential
Operational/
residential
7443-1 Michele Hough
5 Lombard Street, Saint Heliers,
residential
to 9m.
environs.
residential
Operational/
residential
7444-1 Helmut Letz helmut_letz@xtra.co.nz
organisms
7445-1 Caroline Fenton cfid@xtra.co.nz Special Character
residential
7445-2 Caroline Fenton cfid@xtra.co.nz Precincts - Central Saint Heliers K2.19.Precinct Rules
to 9m.
7445-3 Caroline Fenton cfid@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central
7445-4 Caroline Fenton cfid@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central
environs.
residential
7445-6 Caroline Fenton cfid@xtra.co.nz General Miscellaneous
Operational/
residential
621/1145
Sub#/
7446-1 Rowan M Carroll
40 Waimarie Street, Saint Heliers,
residential
to 9m.
environs.
residential
Operational/
residential
7447-1 Peter L J Williams
residential
to 9m.
environs.
residential
Operational/
residential
7448-1 Suzanne Loughlin suzanne.loughlin@gmail.com
organisms
7449-1 Shirin Brown shirinlives@gmail.com
organisms
modified organisms Retain the strong precautionary approach to GMOs
organisms
modified organisms Replace references to 'outdoor' with fresh water, sea water, crop and field
organisms
modified organisms
Establish a prohibited activity status, or at the least non-complying, for testing of GMOs in
fresh water, sea water, crop and field. Prohibit them in the Hauraki Gulf
7449-4 Shirin Brown shirinlives@gmail.com General Miscellaneous Southern Hauraki Gulf Islands
Decline any changes from previous plans which result in an increase in building height on
Waiheke
7449-5 Shirin Brown shirinlives@gmail.com Water
table Retain previous water extraction daily limits
Decline any measures that negatively impact on the level of storm water or contamination of
the Hauraki Gulf
7449-7 Shirin Brown shirinlives@gmail.com Water Wastewater H4.15 Onsite wastewater rules
Decline any measures which pave the way for reticulation [infer this relates to Waiheke].
Allow all sites to dispose of waste on site.
7449-8 Shirin Brown shirinlives@gmail.com Sustainable Development C7.7/H6.4 Sustainable design Allow all sites to collect water on site
7450-1 Elizabeth Cowie sandecowie@xtra.co.nz Special Character
residential
7450-2 Elizabeth Cowie sandecowie@xtra.co.nz Precincts - Central Saint Heliers K2.19.Precinct Rules
to 9m.
7450-3 Elizabeth Cowie sandecowie@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central
7450-4 Elizabeth Cowie sandecowie@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central
environs.
residential
622/1145
Sub#/
7450-6 Elizabeth Cowie sandecowie@xtra.co.nz General Miscellaneous
Operational/
residential
7451-1 Rilma R Pickman and R R Hall rjraye@rocketmail.com RPS Issues
our natural resources Retain statements about Genetically Modified Organisms
7451-2 Rilma R Pickman and R R Hall rjraye@rocketmail.com RPS Natural resources
Organisms Retain these provisions
7451-3 Rilma R Pickman and R R Hall rjraye@rocketmail.com
organisms
modified organisms Retain these objectives, policies and rules
7451-4 Rilma R Pickman and R R Hall rjraye@rocketmail.com Definitions Existing
Retain the definitions for Genetically Modified Organisms, GMO Field Trials, and GMO
Release
7452-1 Olea Sorensen
residential
to 9m.
1062 Zoning Central
1062 Zoning Central
environs.
residential
Operational/
residential
7453-1 Ian MacAndrew agrimac@xtra.co.nz Special Character
residential
7453-2 Ian MacAndrew agrimac@xtra.co.nz Precincts - Central Saint Heliers K2.19.Precinct Rules
to 9m.
7453-3 Ian MacAndrew agrimac@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central
7453-4 Ian MacAndrew agrimac@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central
environs.
residential
7453-6 Ian MacAndrew agrimac@xtra.co.nz General Miscellaneous
Operational/
residential
7454-1 Rosemary C Elliot corin.elliot@xtra.co.nz
organisms
7455-1 R E Craddock
residential
7455-2 R E Craddock
to 9m.
7455-3 R E Craddock
7455-4 R E Craddock
environs.
7455-5 R E Craddock
residential
7455-6 R E Craddock
Operational/
623/1145
Sub#/
7455-7 R E Craddock
residential
7456-1 Marilyn Worsley
195 Menlove Avenue, Liverpool,
United Kingdom Special Character
residential
United Kingdom Precincts - Central Saint Heliers K2.19.Precinct Rules
to 9m.
United Kingdom Zoning Central
United Kingdom Zoning Central
environs.
residential
United Kingdom General Miscellaneous
Operational/
residential
7457-1 John Cassidy john.corinne@xtra.co.nz Special Character
residential
7457-2 John Cassidy john.corinne@xtra.co.nz Precincts - Central Saint Heliers K2.19.Precinct Rules
to 9m.
7457-3 John Cassidy john.corinne@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central
7457-4 John Cassidy john.corinne@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central
environs.
residential
7457-6 John Cassidy john.corinne@xtra.co.nz General Miscellaneous
Operational/
residential
7458-1 Stephanie Lane drstef@actrix.co.nz
organisms
modified organisms Retain the GMO provisions
7458-2 Stephanie Lane drstef@actrix.co.nz
organisms
modified organisms Delete permitted activity status for veterinary vaccines in H4.19
7459-1 Michael J Roberts m_vroberts@xtra.co.nz Special Character
residential
7459-2 Michael J Roberts m_vroberts@xtra.co.nz Precincts - Central Saint Heliers K2.19.Precinct Rules
to 9m.
7459-3 Michael J Roberts m_vroberts@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central
7459-4 Michael J Roberts m_vroberts@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central
environs.
residential
7459-6 Michael J Roberts m_vroberts@xtra.co.nz General Miscellaneous
Operational/
residential
7460-1 Peter G Dormon pgdormon@xtra.co.nz Special Character
residential
7460-2 Peter G Dormon pgdormon@xtra.co.nz Precincts - Central Saint Heliers K2.19.Precinct Rules
to 9m.
624/1145
Sub#/
7460-3 Peter G Dormon pgdormon@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central
7460-4 Peter G Dormon pgdormon@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central
environs.
residential
7460-6 Peter G Dormon pgdormon@xtra.co.nz General Miscellaneous
Operational/
residential
7461-1 Robert J Freeman nameerf@xtra.co.nz Special Character
residential
7461-2 Robert J Freeman nameerf@xtra.co.nz Precincts - Central Saint Heliers K2.19.Precinct Rules
to 9m.
7461-3 Robert J Freeman nameerf@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central
7461-4 Robert J Freeman nameerf@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central
environs.
residential
7461-6 Robert J Freeman nameerf@xtra.co.nz General Miscellaneous
Operational/
residential
7462-1 Robyn G Cowan
33 Parkside Street, Saint Heliers,
residential
to 9m.
environs.
residential
Operational/
residential
7463-1 Rosalind and Anthony Vyle
47 Hanene Street, Saint Heliers,
residential
to 9m.
environs.
residential
Operational/
residential
625/1145
Sub#/
7464-1 Dian Hall dianhall@xtra.co.nz Special Character
residential
7464-2 Dian Hall dianhall@xtra.co.nz Precincts - Central Saint Heliers K2.19.Precinct Rules
to 9m.
7464-3 Dian Hall dianhall@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central
7464-4 Dian Hall dianhall@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central
environs.
residential
7464-6 Dian Hall dianhall@xtra.co.nz General Miscellaneous
Operational/
residential
7465-1 Susan Nementzik delancey@xtra.co.nz Special Character
residential
7465-2 Susan Nementzik delancey@xtra.co.nz Precincts - Central Saint Heliers K2.19.Precinct Rules
to 9m.
7465-3 Susan Nementzik delancey@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central
7465-4 Susan Nementzik delancey@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central
environs.
residential
7465-6 Susan Nementzik delancey@xtra.co.nz General Miscellaneous
Operational/
residential
7466-1 Dimitri Marcel djmmarcel@gmail.com Special Character
residential
7466-2 Dimitri Marcel djmmarcel@gmail.com Precincts - Central Saint Heliers K2.19.Precinct Rules
to 9m.
7466-3 Dimitri Marcel djmmarcel@gmail.com Zoning Central
7466-4 Dimitri Marcel djmmarcel@gmail.com Zoning Central
environs.
residential
7466-6 Dimitri Marcel djmmarcel@gmail.com General Miscellaneous
Operational/
residential
7467-1 Christine N Geyson
20A Grace Street, Orakei, Auckland
residential
to 9m.
1071 Zoning Central
1071 Zoning Central
environs.
residential
626/1145
Sub#/
Operational/
residential
7468-1 Francesco Garino teclis1988@hotmail.com
organisms
modified organisms Retain the GMO provisions
7468-2 Francesco Garino teclis1988@hotmail.com
organisms
modified organisms Delete permitted activity status for veterinary vaccines in H4.19
7469-1 Miles G Shepheard miles@ibs.org.nz Special Character
residential
7469-2 Miles G Shepheard miles@ibs.org.nz Precincts - Central Saint Heliers K2.19.Precinct Rules
to 9m.
7469-3 Miles G Shepheard miles@ibs.org.nz Zoning Central
7469-4 Miles G Shepheard miles@ibs.org.nz Zoning Central
environs.
residential
7469-6 Miles G Shepheard miles@ibs.org.nz General Miscellaneous
Operational/
residential
7470-1 Scott Waghorn scott@dentalcarewest.co.nz Special Character
residential
7470-2 Scott Waghorn scott@dentalcarewest.co.nz Precincts - Central Saint Heliers K2.19.Precinct Rules
to 9m.
7470-3 Scott Waghorn scott@dentalcarewest.co.nz Zoning Central
7470-4 Scott Waghorn scott@dentalcarewest.co.nz Zoning Central
environs.
residential
7470-6 Scott Waghorn scott@dentalcarewest.co.nz General Miscellaneous
Operational/
residential
7471-1 Brandon Nementzik delancey@xtra.co.nz Special Character
residential
7471-2 Brandon Nementzik delancey@xtra.co.nz Precincts - Central Saint Heliers K2.19.Precinct Rules
to 9m.
7471-3 Brandon Nementzik delancey@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central
7471-4 Brandon Nementzik delancey@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central
environs.
residential
7471-6 Brandon Nementzik delancey@xtra.co.nz General Miscellaneous
Operational/
residential
7472-1 Merle Abbot
10A Winhall Rise, Remuera,
residential
627/1145
Sub#/
7472-2 Merle Abbot
to 9m.
7472-3 Merle Abbot
7472-4 Merle Abbot
environs.
7472-5 Merle Abbot
residential
7472-6 Merle Abbot
Operational/
7472-7 Merle Abbot
residential
7473-1 Rewa Vowles
83 Kesteven Avenue, Glendowie,
residential
7473-2 Rewa Vowles
to 9m.
7473-3 Rewa Vowles
7473-4 Rewa Vowles
environs.
7473-5 Rewa Vowles
residential
7473-6 Rewa Vowles
Operational/
7473-7 Rewa Vowles
residential
7474-1 Patricia J Knight jacqui@madambutterfly.co.nz RPS Issues
7474-2 Patricia J Knight jacqui@madambutterfly.co.nz RPS Natural resources
7474-3 Patricia J Knight jacqui@madambutterfly.co.nz
organisms
modified organisms Retain these objectives, policies and rules
7474-4 Patricia J Knight jacqui@madambutterfly.co.nz Definitions Existing
Release
7475-1 Anna Nementzik delancey@xtra.co.nz Special Character
residential
7475-2 Anna Nementzik delancey@xtra.co.nz Precincts - Central Saint Heliers K2.19.Precinct Rules
to 9m.
7475-3 Anna Nementzik delancey@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central
7475-4 Anna Nementzik delancey@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central
environs.
residential
7475-6 Anna Nementzik delancey@xtra.co.nz General Miscellaneous
Operational/
residential
7476-1 Karen D Wesley karenwez@orcon.net.nz Special Character
residential
7476-2 Karen D Wesley karenwez@orcon.net.nz Precincts - Central Saint Heliers K2.19.Precinct Rules
to 9m.
7476-3 Karen D Wesley karenwez@orcon.net.nz Zoning Central
628/1145
Sub#/
7476-4 Karen D Wesley karenwez@orcon.net.nz Zoning Central
environs.
residential
7476-6 Karen D Wesley karenwez@orcon.net.nz General Miscellaneous
Operational/
residential
7477-1 Laura Nementzik lnementzik@gmail.com Special Character
residential
7477-2 Laura Nementzik lnementzik@gmail.com Precincts - Central Saint Heliers K2.19.Precinct Rules
to 9m.
7477-3 Laura Nementzik lnementzik@gmail.com Zoning Central
7477-4 Laura Nementzik lnementzik@gmail.com Zoning Central
environs.
residential
7477-6 Laura Nementzik lnementzik@gmail.com General Miscellaneous
Operational/
residential
7478-1 Berkley M Seward
35 Pembroke Crescent, Glendowie,
residential
special character area would include provisions restricting development to a a small scale,
to 9m.
policies
environs.
residential
residential
special character areas Ensure Tamaki Drive continues to serve travel needs of local residents.
residential
Include assessment criteria which assess the potential adverse effects on development along
7479-1 Ilene M Simpkins isimpkins@hotmail.com Special Character
residential
7479-2 Ilene M Simpkins isimpkins@hotmail.com Precincts - Central Saint Heliers K2.19.Precinct Rules
to 9m.
7479-3 Ilene M Simpkins isimpkins@hotmail.com Zoning Central
7479-4 Ilene M Simpkins isimpkins@hotmail.com Residential zones Residential
policies
environs.
residential
residential
residential
7480-1 Rodney D Mark
47 Speight Road, Saint Heliers,
residential
629/1145
Sub#/
to 9m.
environs.
residential
Operational/
residential
7481-1 Tamsoh Abbot
residential
7481-2 Tamsoh Abbot
to 9m.
7481-3 Tamsoh Abbot
7481-4 Tamsoh Abbot
environs.
7481-5 Tamsoh Abbot
residential
7481-6 Tamsoh Abbot
Operational/
7481-7 Tamsoh Abbot
residential
7482-1 Karen L Chretien karenchretienparis@gmail.com Special Character
residential
7482-2 Karen L Chretien karenchretienparis@gmail.com Precincts - Central Saint Heliers K2.19.Precinct Rules
to 9m.
7482-3 Karen L Chretien karenchretienparis@gmail.com Zoning Central
7482-4 Karen L Chretien karenchretienparis@gmail.com Zoning Central
environs.
residential
7482-6 Karen L Chretien karenchretienparis@gmail.com General Miscellaneous
Operational/
residential
7483-1
Tony Achtzelmer and
Theodora J Clarke tonyl8er@xtra.co.nz
organisms
7484-1 Kelley Videbeck k-videbeck@clear.net.nz Special Character
residential
7484-2 Kelley Videbeck k-videbeck@clear.net.nz Precincts - Central Saint Heliers K2.19.Precinct Rules
to 9m.
7484-3 Kelley Videbeck k-videbeck@clear.net.nz Zoning Central
7484-4 Kelley Videbeck k-videbeck@clear.net.nz Zoning Central
environs.
residential
7484-6 Kelley Videbeck k-videbeck@clear.net.nz General Miscellaneous
Operational/
630/1145
Sub#/
residential
7485-1 Janice Marcel djmmarcel@gmail.com Special Character
residential
7485-2 Janice Marcel djmmarcel@gmail.com Precincts - Central Saint Heliers K2.19.Precinct Rules
to 9m.
7485-3 Janice Marcel djmmarcel@gmail.com Zoning Central
7485-4 Janice Marcel djmmarcel@gmail.com Zoning Central
environs.
residential
7485-6 Janice Marcel djmmarcel@gmail.com General Miscellaneous
Operational/
residential
7486-1 Susan Fredericksen
19B Tuhimata Street, Saint Heliers,
residential
to 9m.
environs.
residential
Operational/
residential
Auckland 1071
Clarify whether the volcanic view shaft height limits take precedence over other Unitary Plan
height limits applying in St Heliers
Adopt intensification in Glen Innes with a focus on affordability for new home buyers. This is
to compensate for limiting height limits at St Heliers
7487-1 Norfolk Trustee Company rose@mhg.co.nz City Centre Zone I4 Rules/Appendix 7.1- 7.3
Amend Assessment Criteria for demolition to the following: A safe temporary hard or
landscaped edge; an edge treatment should be maintained; and a construction traffic
management plan shall be submitted to Council. See submission pg 7/11 for detail
7487-2 Norfolk Trustee Company rose@mhg.co.nz Precincts - City Centre Queen Street Valley
Amend the Activity Table to change demolition from Restricted Discretionary activity to either
Permitted or Controlled Activity. Additionally amend Assessment Criteria for demolition to the
following: A safe temporary hard of landscaped edge; an edge treatment should be
maintained; and a construction traffic management plan shall be submitted to Council. See
submission page 7-8/11 for detail.
Delete the 50m maximum height control and replace with the Aotea Square Height Control
Plan as under the Operative Auckland Council District Plan: Central Area Section
Amend Activity Table to change demolition from Restricted Discretionary activity to either
Permitted or Controlled Activity
7487-5 Norfolk Trustee Company rose@mhg.co.nz General Chapter G General provisions
Delete or clarify the third paragraph under Assessment Criteria of 1.4 Applying for a Resource
consent so that the matters for discretion and assessment criteria listed in the PAUP for
Controlled and Restricted Discretion Activities are the sole matter for assessment
7487-6 Norfolk Trustee Company rose@mhg.co.nz Mana Whenua General provisions
assessment Remove the requirements for Cultural Impact Assessments from the PAUP
7487-7 Norfolk Trustee Company rose@mhg.co.nz RPS Urban growth
environment
Remove the requirement for separate Design Statements and amend references to the
Auckland Design Manual to include confirmation that this is a non-statutory guideline
7487-8 Norfolk Trustee Company rose@mhg.co.nz Residential zones Housing affordability H6.6 Rules
Remove the requirement to incorporate affordable housing into developments of 15 or more
dwellings
631/1145
Sub#/
7487-9 Norfolk Trustee Company rose@mhg.co.nz Sustainable Development C7.7/H6.4 Sustainable design
Remove the requirement to incorporate sustainable development in the prescriptive format set
out in the plan. Remove the requirement to incorporate sustainable development where new
buildings with a GFA of 5000m2 or greater, and where 80 per cent or more of the GFA is to be
used as an office
7488-1 Michael Frogley michael@frogley.org Special Character
residential
7488-2 Michael Frogley michael@frogley.org Precincts - Central Saint Heliers K2.19.Precinct Rules
to 9m.
7488-3 Michael Frogley michael@frogley.org Zoning Central
7488-4 Michael Frogley michael@frogley.org Zoning Central
environs.
residential
7488-6 Michael Frogley michael@frogley.org General Miscellaneous
Operational/
residential
7489-1 Mr and Mrs C Courtney carolinecourtney@xtra.co.nz Special Character
residential
7489-2 Mr and Mrs C Courtney carolinecourtney@xtra.co.nz Precincts - Central Saint Heliers K2.19.Precinct Rules
to 9m.
7489-3 Mr and Mrs C Courtney carolinecourtney@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central
7489-4 Mr and Mrs C Courtney carolinecourtney@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central
environs.
residential
7489-6 Mr and Mrs C Courtney carolinecourtney@xtra.co.nz General Miscellaneous
Operational/
residential
7490-1 Tom Hunter tomhunter.nz@gmail.com Special Character
residential
7490-2 Tom Hunter tomhunter.nz@gmail.com Precincts - Central Saint Heliers K2.19.Precinct Rules
to 9m.
7490-3 Tom Hunter tomhunter.nz@gmail.com Zoning Central
7490-4 Tom Hunter tomhunter.nz@gmail.com Zoning Central
environs.
residential
7490-6 Tom Hunter tomhunter.nz@gmail.com General Miscellaneous
Operational/
residential
7491-1 Cranleigh warunak@cranleighmb.com RPS Urban growth
Rezone to provide for more density around areas where there is a high level of amenity, such
as parks and coastlines, not just around town centres and major transport corridors
quality compact urban form Rezone more areas to Terrace Housing and Apartment Building and Mixed Housing Urban
7491-3 Cranleigh warunak@cranleighmb.com
control
Remove the pre-1944 demolition controls from Terrace Housing and Apartment Building and
Mixed Housing Urban zones - the council should instead analyse these zones quickly to
determine if there are building worth of protection and use other mechanisms to protect them
632/1145
Sub#/
Allocate greater growth opportunities to parts of the City that are not restricted by character
areas
7491-5 Cranleigh warunak@cranleighmb.com Residential zones Residential Land use controls
Remove the frontage controls restricting increased density concessions in the Mixed Housing
Urban and Mixed Housing Suburban zones as these will impact on the ability to develop back
lots
7491-6 Cranleigh warunak@cranleighmb.com General Chapter G General provisions
Improve the Framework Plan process, including more targeted assessment criteria, and
greater flexibility to change over time
Investigate further the mechanisms for the support of assisted affordable housing through
community housing providers and mechanisms to ensure long-term workability instead of
passing this responsibility onto the development sector
quality compact urban form Ensure land supply is sufficient to provide market affordable housing
7491-9 Cranleigh warunak@cranleighmb.com Residential zones Residential Land use controls
Amend the density concessions within the Terrace Housing and Apartment Buildings and
Mixed Housing zones to reduce the 1,200m
2
trigger to between 900-1,000m
2
where quality
and urban design requirements are achieved.
7491-10 Cranleigh warunak@cranleighmb.com Residential zones Residential Land use controls Retain the provision for the conversion of a dwelling into two dwellings
7491-11 Cranleigh warunak@cranleighmb.com General Chapter G General provisions
status
Amend the PAUP to allow precincts to override overlay provisions if specified in the precinct
provisions
Retain the approach of a hierachy of centres, from city centre to neighbourhood centres, the
location specific height controls and broad variety of activities within the centres including
residential development
Centre) Business
Park zones
Identify key retail frontages and core business streets where retail/business activity at ground
level should be protected. Outside these streets provide a more flexible approach including
housing to ground level
Centre) Business
Park zones
Protect future ground floor uses for commercial uses through detailed controls in the Mixed
Use zone only on specifically identified streets. Elsewhere, provide for greater flexibility in the
Mixed Use zone
7491-15 Cranleigh warunak@cranleighmb.com General Cross plan matters
Amend the approach of the Plan which relies upon restrictive rules, further resource consent
requirements including low threshold triggers for matters such as earthworks, stormwater, and
sites of significance or value to Mana Whenua, and instead move towards a more outcome
focused performance regime (see submission for more information pg 18/18)
7492-1 Putiputi Organics dhkdhk@ihug.co.nz
organisms
modified organisms Retain GMO provisions
7492-2 Putiputi Organics dhkdhk@ihug.co.nz
organisms
modified organisms Prohibit all outdoor use of GMOs including full release, field trials and outdoor experiments
7493-1 Eleanor Robinson eleanor7363@xtra.co.nz Special Character
residential
7493-2 Eleanor Robinson eleanor7363@xtra.co.nz Precincts - Central Saint Heliers K2.19.Precinct Rules
to 9m.
7493-3 Eleanor Robinson eleanor7363@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central
7493-4 Eleanor Robinson eleanor7363@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central
environs.
residential
7493-6 Eleanor Robinson eleanor7363@xtra.co.nz General Miscellaneous
Operational/
residential
7494-1 Louise E M Forman lforman@cameronfleming.co.nz Special Character
residential
7494-2 Louise E M Forman lforman@cameronfleming.co.nz Precincts - Central Saint Heliers K2.19.Precinct Rules
to 9m.
7494-3 Louise E M Forman lforman@cameronfleming.co.nz Zoning Central
7494-4 Louise E M Forman lforman@cameronfleming.co.nz Zoning Central
environs.
633/1145
Sub#/
residential
7494-6 Louise E M Forman lforman@cameronfleming.co.nz General Miscellaneous
Operational/
residential
7495-1 Wayne Parker
10 Emerson Street, Saint Heliers,
residential
7495-2 Wayne Parker
to 9m.
7495-3 Wayne Parker
7495-4 Wayne Parker
environs.
7495-5 Wayne Parker
residential
7495-6 Wayne Parker
Operational/
7495-7 Wayne Parker
residential
7496-1 Gary and Joan Forman
593 Riddell Road, Glendowie,
residential
to 9m.
environs.
residential
Operational/
residential
7497-1 Kiri Lowe kirilowe@gmail.com
organisms
7497-2 Kiri Lowe kirilowe@gmail.com
organisms
modified organisms Delete the permitted activity status for animal vaccines in H4.19
7498-1 Mary Miller
c/- The Framer, 18 Polygon Road,
Saint Heliers, Auckland 1071 Special Character
residential
7498-2 Mary Miller
Saint Heliers, Auckland 1071 Precincts - Central Saint Heliers K2.19.Precinct Rules
to 9m.
7498-3 Mary Miller
Saint Heliers, Auckland 1071 Zoning Central
7498-4 Mary Miller
environs.
7498-5 Mary Miller
residential
7498-6 Mary Miller
Saint Heliers, Auckland 1071 General Miscellaneous
Operational/
7498-7 Mary Miller
residential
634/1145
Sub#/
7499-1 Dianne Mason
33 Sierra Street, Glendowie,
residential
7499-2 Dianne Mason
to 9m.
7499-3 Dianne Mason
7499-4 Dianne Mason
environs.
7499-5 Dianne Mason
residential
7499-6 Dianne Mason
Operational/
7499-7 Dianne Mason
residential
7500-1 Felicia A Renand
residential
to 9m.
environs.
residential
Operational/
residential
7501-1 Stephen Hayden steve.hayden@orcon.net.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - Rural zones
area
Allow further subdivision within the Mixed Rural zone including change from prohibited to
discretionary status
7501-2 Stephen Hayden steve.hayden@orcon.net.nz Future Urban
Delete the Future Urban zone and rezone to residential, or amend the zone to allow a greater
range of activities to occur
7501-3 Stephen Hayden steve.hayden@orcon.net.nz Rural Zones
obs & pols
Amend the Mixed Rural zone policies to more closely align with the Future Urban zone to
better provide for rural uses and for subdivision
7501-4 Stephen Hayden steve.hayden@orcon.net.nz RPS Rural B8.3 Rural subdivision
Amend to allow for larger rural land holdings to be subdivided to a size which becomes
economic and encourages rural industries to develop
7501-5 Stephen Hayden steve.hayden@orcon.net.nz RPS Changes to the RUB North and Waiheke Island
Rezone the land located between Richards Road and Blackbridge Road, Dairy Flat, from the
beginning of these roads to a north/south line drawn where the metalled road ends of
Blackbridge Road (approx. number 500 Blackbridge) from Mixed Rural to Future Urban
7501-6 Stephen Hayden steve.hayden@orcon.net.nz
SEAs
Simplify the rules which establish the protection of significant ecological areas to encourage
these areas to be developed and protected in larger numbers over a larger area
7502-1 Megan Coates mcoates@davis.co.nz Special Character
residential
7502-2 Megan Coates mcoates@davis.co.nz Precincts - Central Saint Heliers K2.19.Precinct Rules
to 9m.
7502-3 Megan Coates mcoates@davis.co.nz Zoning Central
7502-4 Megan Coates mcoates@davis.co.nz Zoning Central
environs.
residential
7502-6 Megan Coates mcoates@davis.co.nz General Miscellaneous
Operational/
635/1145
Sub#/
residential
7503-1 Pauline Ward alistair@wwauckland.co.nz Special Character
residential
7503-2 Pauline Ward alistair@wwauckland.co.nz Precincts - Central Saint Heliers K2.19.Precinct Rules
to 9m.
7503-3 Pauline Ward alistair@wwauckland.co.nz Zoning Central
7503-4 Pauline Ward alistair@wwauckland.co.nz Zoning Central
environs.
residential
7503-6 Pauline Ward alistair@wwauckland.co.nz General Miscellaneous
Operational/
residential
7504-1 Michael T McGuinness mmcguinness@davis.co.nz Special Character
residential
7504-2 Michael T McGuinness mmcguinness@davis.co.nz Precincts - Central Saint Heliers K2.19.Precinct Rules
to 9m.
7504-3 Michael T McGuinness mmcguinness@davis.co.nz Zoning Central
7504-4 Michael T McGuinness mmcguinness@davis.co.nz Zoning Central
environs.
residential
7504-6 Michael T McGuinness mmcguinness@davis.co.nz General Miscellaneous
Operational/
residential
7505-1
GE Free Northland in Food
and Environment murphymiller@slingshot.co.nz RPS Issues
our natural resources Retain statements about Genetically Modified Organism
7505-2
and Environment murphymiller@slingshot.co.nz RPS Natural resources
7505-3
and Environment murphymiller@slingshot.co.nz
organisms
modified organisms Retain the objectives and policies. Retain the rules with amendments.
7505-4
organisms
modified organisms
Amend H4.19 by deleting the reference to district plan in the second paragraph of the
introduction.
7505-5
organisms
modified organisms Amend the heading in H4.19.2 to read 'Land use and CMA'
7505-6
organisms
modified organisms Make GE vaccines a prohibited activity
7505-7
and Environment murphymiller@slingshot.co.nz Definitions Existing
Release
7506-1 Lorna Keam
3 Edison Place, Saint Heliers,
residential
7506-2 Lorna Keam
to 9m.
7506-3 Lorna Keam
7506-4 Lorna Keam
environs.
7506-5 Lorna Keam
residential
636/1145
Sub#/
7506-6 Lorna Keam
Operational/
7506-7 Lorna Keam
residential
7507-1 Lori-Ann de Zoete-Hall
31A Rielly Place, Mount Wellington,
residential
to 9m.
environs.
residential
Operational/
residential
7508-1 Elena Andreeva
residential
to 9m.
environs.
residential
Operational/
residential
7509-1 Marina Prozorova marinap@xtra.co.nz Special Character
residential
7509-2 Marina Prozorova marinap@xtra.co.nz Precincts - Central Saint Heliers K2.19.Precinct Rules
to 9m.
7509-3 Marina Prozorova marinap@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central
7509-4 Marina Prozorova marinap@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central
environs.
residential
7509-6 Marina Prozorova marinap@xtra.co.nz General Miscellaneous
Operational/
residential
7510-1 Frank Hoffmann hoffmann01@vodafone.co.nz
organisms
7511-1 Bronwen Simpson
19 Yattendon Road, Saint Heliers,
residential
to 9m.
637/1145
Sub#/
environs.
residential
Operational/
residential
7512-1 Averil Gordon agordonnz@gmail.com Special Character
residential
7512-2 Averil Gordon agordonnz@gmail.com Precincts - Central Saint Heliers K2.19.Precinct Rules
to 9m.
7512-3 Averil Gordon agordonnz@gmail.com Zoning Central
7512-4 Averil Gordon agordonnz@gmail.com Zoning Central
environs.
residential
7512-6 Averil Gordon agordonnz@gmail.com General Miscellaneous
Operational/
residential
7513-1
Future Proof Implementation
Committee ken@kentremaine.co.nz RPS General
issues
Amend as detailed in tracked changes on pages 26-31 of submission. Changes expand and
elaborate on cross-boundary issues between Auckland and adjoining local authorities
7513-2
Committee ken@kentremaine.co.nz General Chapter A Introduction A1 Background Add summary of the key strategic cross-boundary issues identified in B11
7513-3
issues
Add objectives, policies, methods and rules throughout the PAUP to incorporate cross-
boundary issues identified in B11
7513-4
Committee ken@kentremaine.co.nz General Miscellaneous
Operational/
Projects/Acquisition Collaborate and plan with Waikato Regional Council on strategic public transport corridors
7513-5
Committee ken@kentremaine.co.nz RPS Issues
wellbeing
Add the following under the heading of 'Inter-regional linkages': Auckland's linkages with
neighbouring regions are important in terms of enhancing economic outcomes for both
Auckland and the wider Upper North Island. Inter-regional collaboration on integrated planning
will help deliver key economic well-being outcomes.
7513-6
Committee ken@kentremaine.co.nz RPS Urban growth
Add the following as an additional non-regulatory method: Undertake joint modelling with the
Waikato Region in order to analyse the cross-boundary effects on inter-regional transport,
infrastructure (including water) and land use of both residential and industrial settlement
patterns envisaged under the Auckland Unitary Plan and throughout the Waikato region.
7513-7
review procedures
Add the following after the 6th paragraph of monitoring and review procedures: Auckland and
the Waikato will also jointly monitor the cross-boundary effects of land use, transport and
other infrastructure, particularly water, and resource use over time.
7513-8
quality compact urban form Retain the RUB
7513-9
2010
Amend rule (1)(g) as follows: (g) involve key stakeholders, infrastructure providers and
landowners in the development of the structure plan area, including collaborating with
neighbouring territorial local authorities and regional councils and other stakeholders if there
are potential cross-boundary issues. Add rule (2)(m) as follows: (m) where relevant any cross
boundary effects on neighbouring regions, including the need to achieve compatibility and
integration of land use and infrastructure with adjoining regions
7513-10
Collaborate with Waikato region to model and analysis urban growth capacity, staging, time
and infrastructure demands within Auckland, particularly in relation to impacts on the Waikato
region
7513-11
Committee ken@kentremaine.co.nz Mineral extraction
and policies Identify the location of mineral resources in both the text and maps
7513-12
Committee ken@kentremaine.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - Rural zones
area Retain 150ha minimum lot size in the rural production zone [rule 2.3.3(9)]
638/1145
Sub#/
7513-13
Committee ken@kentremaine.co.nz RPS Rural
potential
Add objectives and policies that align with the provisions that manage elite soils in the
proposed Waikato regional policy statement and plan change 14 to the Waikato district plan
(Franklin section)
7513-14
Add objectives, policies and rules to manage the effects of urban development in Auckland on
the Waikato region, including reverse sensitivity effects and loss of rural production
7513-15
Committee ken@kentremaine.co.nz Water
Objectives
Retain the priorisation of municipal water supplies and the objectives and policies in relation
to water quantity, allocation and use.
7513-16
Committee ken@kentremaine.co.nz General Chapter A Introduction A3 Strategic Framework
Amend A3.3 [sustainable management] to note sustainable development practices are central
to urban development as they are more efficient, use less resources and lower energy use.
7513-17
Committee ken@kentremaine.co.nz RPS Issues
Amend as detailed on page 25/31 of submission. To include discussion on the vision and
strategy for the Waikato river
7513-18
Committee ken@kentremaine.co.nz Precincts - South New Precincts All other New Precincts
Identify Waikato river catchment within Auckland Council's boundaries. Add objectives and
policies for this area in accordance with the Waikato-Tainui Raupatu Claims (Waikato river)
Settlement Act 2012. Establish process methods for developments within this catchment that
have cross-boundary effects.
7513-19
Committee ken@kentremaine.co.nz RPS
Add policy to address management of biodiversity across local authority boundaries and
public/private boundaries and effectively integrate biodiversity management under other
legislation
7513-20
Add objectives to address the continued functioning of ecosystems which do not meet the
criteria for significance, provision of ecosystem services and their maintenance and
ehancement
7513-21
character and natural heritage B4.3.4 Biodiversity Retain significant ecological area approach
7513-22
Amend policy 1(a) as follows - representativeness: The area is important for the indigenous
habitats and/or ecosystems it supports because they are ecologically representative of the
habitats (including mature and successional stages of the vegetation vegetated habitats) of
each ecological district in Auckland and provide cumulatively for at least 10 per cent of the
natural extent of each ecosystem type.
7513-23
Amend policy 7 to clarify where and how the impacts on biodiversity outside of significant
ecological areas will be managed
7513-24
Add mitigation measures for the loss of indigenous vegetation within SEA's, such as
restoration planting and active management measures (such as pest control)
7513-25
Committee ken@kentremaine.co.nz
the CMA
discharges of contaminants I6.1.4 Activity table Amend the activity status of mangrove removal from permitted to controlled
7513-26
Committee ken@kentremaine.co.nz RPS Natural resources B6.7 Natural hazards
Amend objective 1 to read as follows: Avoid risk to people. property and infrastructure by
identifying the areas at highest risk from natural hazards
7513-27
Retain the non-regulatory method of increasing public awareness of causes and effects of
natural hazard events
7513-28
Amend policy 2 to read as follows: Undertake hazard identification and risk assessment for
subdivision and the cumulative effects of subdivision, use and development using the best
available and up-to-date hazard information.
7513-29
Committee ken@kentremaine.co.nz Subdivision Auckland-wide - Rural zones
zones only
Add 'subdivision of land involving the transfer of development rights across the territorial
boundaries of the Auckland Council' to the activity table as a prohibited activity.
7514-1 Craig Love sootylove@actrix.co.nz
organisms
7514-2 Craig Love sootylove@actrix.co.nz
organisms
modified organisms Delete permitted activity status for animal vaccines in H4.19
7515-1 Joseph P Hall dianhall@xtra.co.nz Special Character
residential
7515-2 Joseph P Hall dianhall@xtra.co.nz Precincts - Central Saint Heliers K2.19.Precinct Rules
to 9m.
7515-3 Joseph P Hall dianhall@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central
7515-4 Joseph P Hall dianhall@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central
environs.
residential
639/1145
Sub#/
7515-6 Joseph P Hall dianhall@xtra.co.nz General Miscellaneous
Operational/
residential
7516-1 Douglas Anderson
residential
to 9m.
environs.
residential
Operational/
residential
7517-1 M Robinson
45 St Heliers Bay Road, Saint
residential
7517-2 M Robinson
to 9m.
7517-3 M Robinson
7517-4 M Robinson
environs.
7517-5 M Robinson
residential
7517-6 M Robinson
Operational/
7517-7 M Robinson
residential
7518-1 Audrey J Tatham
1/6 Tuhimata Street, Saint Heliers,
residential
to 9m.
environs.
residential
Operational/
residential
7519-1 Irena Beddington-Behrens irenabb123@gmail.com Special Character
residential
7519-2 Irena Beddington-Behrens irenabb123@gmail.com Precincts - Central Saint Heliers K2.19.Precinct Rules
to 9m.
7519-3 Irena Beddington-Behrens irenabb123@gmail.com Zoning Central
640/1145
Sub#/
7519-4 Irena Beddington-Behrens irenabb123@gmail.com Zoning Central
environs.
residential
7519-6 Irena Beddington-Behrens irenabb123@gmail.com General Miscellaneous
Operational/
residential
7520-1 Felicity Christian fchristian@xtra.co.nz
organisms
modified organisms Retain the strong precautionary genetic engineering objective, policies and methods
7521-1 Lynn Taylor
5/36 Polygon Road, Saint Heliers,
residential
7521-2 Lynn Taylor
to 9m.
7521-3 Lynn Taylor
7521-4 Lynn Taylor
environs.
7521-5 Lynn Taylor
residential
7521-6 Lynn Taylor
Operational/
7521-7 Lynn Taylor
residential
7522-1 Bruce Fyfe
21 Isherwood Place, Saint Johns,
residential
7522-2 Bruce Fyfe
to 9m.
7522-3 Bruce Fyfe
7522-4 Bruce Fyfe
environs.
7522-5 Bruce Fyfe
residential
7522-6 Bruce Fyfe
Operational/
7522-7 Bruce Fyfe
residential
7523-1 Christine Machanek cici.mach5@gmail.com
organisms
modified organisms Retain the strong precautionary genetic engineering objective, policies and methods
7524-1 J Devine coach@jennydevine.co.nz Special Character
residential
7524-2 J Devine coach@jennydevine.co.nz Precincts - Central Saint Heliers K2.19.Precinct Rules
to 9m.
7524-3 J Devine coach@jennydevine.co.nz Zoning Central
7524-4 J Devine coach@jennydevine.co.nz Zoning Central
environs.
residential
7524-6 J Devine coach@jennydevine.co.nz General Miscellaneous
Operational/
residential
641/1145
Sub#/
7525-1 Jenifer Ricketts lilicky@xtra.co.nz Special Character
residential
7525-2 Jenifer Ricketts lilicky@xtra.co.nz Precincts - Central Saint Heliers K2.19.Precinct Rules
to 9m.
7525-3 Jenifer Ricketts lilicky@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central
7525-4 Jenifer Ricketts lilicky@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central
environs.
residential
7525-6 Jenifer Ricketts lilicky@xtra.co.nz General Miscellaneous
Operational/
residential
7526-1 David Smith
2/263 West Tamaki Road, Glen
Innes, Auckland 1072 Special Character
residential
7526-2 David Smith
Innes, Auckland 1072 Precincts - Central Saint Heliers K2.19.Precinct Rules
to 9m.
7526-3 David Smith
Innes, Auckland 1072 Zoning Central
7526-4 David Smith
Innes, Auckland 1072 Zoning Central
environs.
7526-5 David Smith
residential
7526-6 David Smith
Innes, Auckland 1072 General Miscellaneous
Operational/
7526-7 David Smith
residential
7527-1 Rachel Burns rachelburns@xtra.co.nz
organisms
7528-1 R A Ricketts
43 Hoskins Avenue, Hillsborough,
residential
7528-2 R A Ricketts
to 9m.
7528-3 R A Ricketts
7528-4 R A Ricketts
environs.
7528-5 R A Ricketts
residential
7528-6 R A Ricketts
Operational/
7528-7 R A Ricketts
residential
7529-1 Deborah Lynch deborahjelynch@hotmail.com Special Character
residential
7529-2 Deborah Lynch deborahjelynch@hotmail.com Precincts - Central Saint Heliers K2.19.Precinct Rules
to 9m.
7529-3 Deborah Lynch deborahjelynch@hotmail.com Zoning Central
7529-4 Deborah Lynch deborahjelynch@hotmail.com Zoning Central
environs.
642/1145
Sub#/
residential
7529-6 Deborah Lynch deborahjelynch@hotmail.com General Miscellaneous
Operational/
residential
7530-1 John G Hargrave g.hargrave@barfoot.co.nz Special Character
residential
7530-2 John G Hargrave g.hargrave@barfoot.co.nz Precincts - Central Saint Heliers K2.19.Precinct Rules
to 9m.
7530-3 John G Hargrave g.hargrave@barfoot.co.nz Zoning Central
7530-4 John G Hargrave g.hargrave@barfoot.co.nz Zoning Central
environs.
residential
7530-6 John G Hargrave g.hargrave@barfoot.co.nz General Miscellaneous
Operational/
residential
7531-1 Marjorie McDonald onehappymarj@aol.com Special Character
residential
7531-2 Marjorie McDonald onehappymarj@aol.com Precincts - Central Saint Heliers K2.19.Precinct Rules
to 9m.
7531-3 Marjorie McDonald onehappymarj@aol.com Zoning Central
7531-4 Marjorie McDonald onehappymarj@aol.com Zoning Central
environs.
residential
7531-6 Marjorie McDonald onehappymarj@aol.com General Miscellaneous
Operational/
residential
7532-1 Jenny Boyd
113 Waipuna Road East, Mount
Wellington, Auckland 1060 Special Character
residential
7532-2 Jenny Boyd
Wellington, Auckland 1060 Precincts - Central Saint Heliers K2.19.Precinct Rules
to 9m.
7532-3 Jenny Boyd
Wellington, Auckland 1060 Zoning Central
7532-4 Jenny Boyd
environs.
7532-5 Jenny Boyd
residential
7532-6 Jenny Boyd
Wellington, Auckland 1060 General Miscellaneous
Operational/
7532-7 Jenny Boyd
residential
7533-1 Ed Johnson edwardjohnson088@gmail.com Special Character
residential
7533-2 Ed Johnson edwardjohnson088@gmail.com Precincts - Central Saint Heliers K2.19.Precinct Rules
to 9m.
643/1145
Sub#/
7533-3 Ed Johnson edwardjohnson088@gmail.com Zoning Central
7533-4 Ed Johnson edwardjohnson088@gmail.com Zoning Central
environs.
residential
7533-6 Ed Johnson edwardjohnson088@gmail.com General Miscellaneous
Operational/
residential
7534-1 Melanie Tuscia melanie@tuscia.co.nz RPS Issues
7534-2 Melanie Tuscia melanie@tuscia.co.nz RPS Natural resources
7534-3 Melanie Tuscia melanie@tuscia.co.nz
organisms
modified organisms Retain the objectives and policies
7534-4 Melanie Tuscia melanie@tuscia.co.nz
organisms
modified organisms Remove the exemption for veterinary vaccines from H4.19. Otherwise retain these rules.
7534-5 Melanie Tuscia melanie@tuscia.co.nz Definitions Existing
Releases
7535-1 Daniel Lund
residential
enhancing small businesses, encouraging adaption and reuse of buildings.
7535-2 Daniel Lund
to 9m.
7535-3 Daniel Lund
7535-4 Daniel Lund
environs.
7535-5 Daniel Lund
residential
7535-6 Daniel Lund
Operational/
7535-7 Daniel Lund
residential
7536-1 Amar A Padel
17 Auckland Road, Saint Heliers,
residential
7536-2 Amar A Padel
to 9m.
7536-3 Amar A Padel
7536-4 Amar A Padel
environs.
7536-5 Amar A Padel
residential
7536-6 Amar A Padel
Operational/
7536-7 Amar A Padel
residential
7537-1 Peter Nicholson peternicholson@xtra.co.nz Special Character
residential
7537-2 Peter Nicholson peternicholson@xtra.co.nz Precincts - Central Saint Heliers K2.19.Precinct Rules
to 9m.
7537-3 Peter Nicholson peternicholson@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central
7537-4 Peter Nicholson peternicholson@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central
environs.
644/1145
Sub#/
residential
7537-6 Peter Nicholson peternicholson@xtra.co.nz General Miscellaneous
Operational/
residential
7538-1 Amy Mayer
c/- Relax and Revive, Shop 11, Saint
Heliers Bay Road, Saint Heliers,
residential
7538-2 Amy Mayer
to 9m.
7538-3 Amy Mayer
7538-4 Amy Mayer
environs.
7538-5 Amy Mayer
residential
7538-6 Amy Mayer
Operational/
7538-7 Amy Mayer
residential
7539-1 Nadia Hopkins
42B Ferndale Road, Mount
residential
to 9m.
environs.
residential
Operational/
residential
7540-1 Mark Pitcaithly
20A McArthur Avenue, Saint Heliers,
residential
to 9m.
environs.
residential
Operational/
residential
645/1145
Sub#/
7541-1 Michelle Heatherley
Shop 11, Saint Heliers Bay Road,
residential
Saint Heliers, Auckland 1071 Precincts - Central Saint Heliers K2.19.Precinct Rules
to 9m.
environs.
residential
Saint Heliers, Auckland 1071 General Miscellaneous
Operational/
residential
7542-1 Lynda Pitcaithly
residential
to 9m.
environs.
residential
Operational/
residential
7543-1 Sarah Reeder sarah_reeder31@hotmail.com Special Character
residential
7543-2 Sarah Reeder sarah_reeder31@hotmail.com Precincts - Central Saint Heliers K2.19.Precinct Rules
to 9m.
7543-3 Sarah Reeder sarah_reeder31@hotmail.com Zoning Central
7543-4 Sarah Reeder sarah_reeder31@hotmail.com Zoning Central
environs.
residential
7543-6 Sarah Reeder sarah_reeder31@hotmail.com General Miscellaneous
Operational/
residential
7544-1 Tania Carmignani
6C/18 Cranbrook Mews, Glendowie,
residential
to 9m.
environs.
residential
646/1145
Sub#/
Operational/
residential
7545-1 Anne Mellor
17 Washington Avenue, Glendowie,
residential
7545-2 Anne Mellor
to 9m.
7545-3 Anne Mellor
7545-4 Anne Mellor
environs.
7545-5 Anne Mellor
residential
7545-6 Anne Mellor
Operational/
7545-7 Anne Mellor
residential
7546-1 Margaret G Neilson
43 Thatcher Street, Mission Bay,
residential
to 9m.
environs.
residential
Operational/
residential
7547-1 Steven P Bayliss
3A Waimarie Street, Saint Heliers,
residential
to 9m.
environs.
residential
Operational/
residential
7548-1 Walter Nathan
39 Inglewood Street, Wai o Taiki
Bay, Auckland 1702 Special Character
residential
Bay, Auckland 1702 Precincts - Central Saint Heliers K2.19.Precinct Rules
to 9m.
Bay, Auckland 1702 Zoning Central
647/1145
Sub#/
environs.
residential
Bay, Auckland 1702 General Miscellaneous
Operational/
residential
7549-1 Leo Boyd
residential
7549-2 Leo Boyd
to 9m.
7549-3 Leo Boyd
7549-4 Leo Boyd
environs.
7549-5 Leo Boyd
residential
7549-6 Leo Boyd
Operational/
7549-7 Leo Boyd
residential
7550-1 Judith R McIlroy
165 Saint Heliers Bay Road, Saint
residential
to 9m.
environs.
residential
Operational/
residential
7551-1 Diane Holland diane.holland@xtra.co.nz Special Character
residential
7551-2 Diane Holland diane.holland@xtra.co.nz Precincts - Central Saint Heliers K2.19.Precinct Rules
to 9m.
7551-3 Diane Holland diane.holland@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central
7551-4 Diane Holland diane.holland@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central
environs.
residential
7551-6 Diane Holland diane.holland@xtra.co.nz General Miscellaneous
Operational/
residential
7552-1 Lara Courtenay laracourtenay@gmail.com Special Character
residential
648/1145
Sub#/
7552-2 Lara Courtenay laracourtenay@gmail.com Precincts - Central Saint Heliers K2.19.Precinct Rules
to 9m.
7552-3 Lara Courtenay laracourtenay@gmail.com Zoning Central
7552-4 Lara Courtenay laracourtenay@gmail.com Zoning Central
environs.
residential
7552-6 Lara Courtenay laracourtenay@gmail.com General Miscellaneous
Operational/
residential
7553-1 Stephanie Hall llahihpets@myway.com Special Character
residential
7553-2 Stephanie Hall llahihpets@myway.com Precincts - Central Saint Heliers K2.19.Precinct Rules
to 9m.
7553-3 Stephanie Hall llahihpets@myway.com Zoning Central
7553-4 Stephanie Hall llahihpets@myway.com Zoning Central
environs.
residential
7553-6 Stephanie Hall llahihpets@myway.com General Miscellaneous
Operational/
residential
7554-1 Lesley Hankin
261 West Tamaki Road, Wai o Taiki
residential
Bay, Auckland 1072 Precincts - Central Saint Heliers K2.19.Precinct Rules
to 9m.
environs.
residential
Bay, Auckland 1072 General Miscellaneous
Operational/
residential
7555-1 Mary J Reardon
105 Saint Johns Road, Saint Johns,
residential
to 9m.
environs.
residential
Operational/
residential
649/1145
Sub#/
7556-1 Peter Garthwaite
43/207 Riddell Road, Glendowie,
residential
to 9m.
environs.
residential
Operational/
residential
7557-1 John Draper
5 Gwilliam Place, Freemans Bay,
7557-2 John Draper
General
7557-3 John Draper
Auckland 1011 Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
7557-4 John Draper
Special info. req.
7557-5 John Draper
General
7557-6 John Draper
requirements
parking demand.
7557-7 John Draper
requirements
7558-1 William A Horridge
18B Bay Road, Saint Heliers,
residential
to 9m.
environs.
residential
Operational/
residential
650/1145
Sub#/
7559-1 Patricia A Hall
68 Robley Crescent, Glendowie,
residential
to 9m.
environs.
residential
Operational/
residential
7560-1 Catherine Galich
12 Sheridan Lane, Freemans Bay,
General
requirements
Special info. req.
General
requirements
parking demand.
requirements
7561-1 Janet Burnes bob@robertburnes.co.nz Special Character
residential
7561-2 Janet Burnes bob@robertburnes.co.nz Precincts - Central Saint Heliers K2.19.Precinct Rules
to 9m.
7561-3 Janet Burnes bob@robertburnes.co.nz Zoning Central
Retain the Mixed Housing zone from Cliff Road to Clarendon Road and along the
7561-4 Janet Burnes bob@robertburnes.co.nz Zoning Central
environs.
residential
7561-6 Janet Burnes bob@robertburnes.co.nz General Miscellaneous
Operational/
residential
7561-8 Janet Burnes bob@robertburnes.co.nz Precincts - Central Saint Heliers K2.19.Precinct Rules Notify development within St Heliers Bay Village
651/1145
Sub#/
7562-1 Alex Alvarez
3A Glover Road, Saint Heliers,
residential
7562-2 Alex Alvarez
to 9m.
7562-3 Alex Alvarez
7562-4 Alex Alvarez
environs.
7562-5 Alex Alvarez
residential
7562-6 Alex Alvarez
Operational/
7562-7 Alex Alvarez
residential
7563-1 Abraham P Bergh
PO Box 25887, Saint Heliers,
residential
to 9m.
environs.
residential
Operational/
residential
7564-1 Julie Beagley
42 Sprott Road, Kohimarama,
residential
to 9m.
environs.
residential
Operational/
residential
7565-1 Richard and Serena Stevens richard@brandworld.co.nz Zoning Central
7565-2 Richard and Serena Stevens richard@brandworld.co.nz Residential zones Residential
General
7565-3 Richard and Serena Stevens richard@brandworld.co.nz Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
652/1145
Sub#/
Special info. req.
General
requirements
parking demand.
requirements
7566-1 Michael J Jakobi mike.jakobi@akl.buchan.co.nz Special Character
residential
7566-2 Michael J Jakobi mike.jakobi@akl.buchan.co.nz Precincts - Central Saint Heliers K2.19.Precinct Rules
to 9m.
7566-3 Michael J Jakobi mike.jakobi@akl.buchan.co.nz Zoning Central
7566-4 Michael J Jakobi mike.jakobi@akl.buchan.co.nz Zoning Central
environs.
residential
7566-6 Michael J Jakobi mike.jakobi@akl.buchan.co.nz General Miscellaneous
Operational/
residential
7567-1 Clare Dockery claredoc@slingshot.co.nz Zoning Central
7567-2 Clare Dockery claredoc@slingshot.co.nz Residential zones Residential
General
7567-3 Clare Dockery claredoc@slingshot.co.nz Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
Special info. req.
General
requirements
parking demand.
requirements
653/1145
Sub#/
7568-1 Pauline A Savage paula.savage@hotmail.com Zoning Central
7568-2 Pauline A Savage paula.savage@hotmail.com Residential zones Residential
General
7568-3 Pauline A Savage paula.savage@hotmail.com Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
Special info. req.
General
requirements
parking demand.
requirements
7569-1 Gayle Roach
13 Jillteresa Crescent, Bucklands
Beach, Auckland 2012 Special Character
residential
7569-2 Gayle Roach
Beach, Auckland 2012 Precincts - Central Saint Heliers K2.19.Precinct Rules
to 9m.
7569-3 Gayle Roach
Beach, Auckland 2012 Zoning Central
7569-4 Gayle Roach
Beach, Auckland 2012 Zoning Central
environs.
7569-5 Gayle Roach
residential
7569-6 Gayle Roach
Beach, Auckland 2012 General Miscellaneous
Operational/
7569-7 Gayle Roach
residential
7570-1 Lynn Gruenwald lynngruenwald@me.com Special Character
residential
7570-2 Lynn Gruenwald lynngruenwald@me.com Precincts - Central Saint Heliers K2.19.Precinct Rules
to 9m.
7570-3 Lynn Gruenwald lynngruenwald@me.com Zoning Central
7570-4 Lynn Gruenwald lynngruenwald@me.com Zoning Central
environs.
residential
7570-6 Lynn Gruenwald lynngruenwald@me.com General Miscellaneous
Operational/
residential
654/1145
Sub#/
7571-1 St Heliers Hardware
residential
to 9m.
environs.
residential
Operational/
residential
7572-1 Sue Smith susan.e.smith@virginmedia.com Special Character
residential
7572-2 Sue Smith susan.e.smith@virginmedia.com Precincts - Central Saint Heliers K2.19.Precinct Rules
to 9m.
7572-3 Sue Smith susan.e.smith@virginmedia.com Zoning Central
7572-4 Sue Smith susan.e.smith@virginmedia.com Zoning Central
environs.
residential
7572-6 Sue Smith susan.e.smith@virginmedia.com General Miscellaneous
Operational/
residential
7573-1 Gaylene Maynard gaylene.darrin@xtra.co.nz Special Character
residential
7573-2 Gaylene Maynard gaylene.darrin@xtra.co.nz Precincts - Central Saint Heliers K2.19.Precinct Rules
to 9m.
7573-3 Gaylene Maynard gaylene.darrin@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central
7573-4 Gaylene Maynard gaylene.darrin@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central
environs.
residential
7573-6 Gaylene Maynard gaylene.darrin@xtra.co.nz General Miscellaneous
Operational/
residential
7574-1 Peter R Millard
70 Maskell Street, Saint Heliers,
residential
to 9m.
environs.
residential
655/1145
Sub#/
Operational/
residential
7575-1 Maggy and Gary Hamilton maggyhamilton44@gmail.com Precincts - Central Saint Heliers
Objectives & Policies Retain provisions that protect and maintain the village character of St Heliers.
7576-1 Here R Coleman
c/- Warkworth Post Office, Auckland
Protection
Exempt property on Kawau Island within the Settlement Policy Area (DP 419092 Lots 1-3,
Lots 150-152, DP4961 Kawau Island) from Rule 4.3 Ridgeline protection.
Protection Delete the overlay from the Settlement Policy Area of Kawau Island.
0910
Outstanding Natural
Rules
J6.2.4 Assessment
Amend Rule 3.2 Height [under J6.2.3 Development controls], to increase the maximum
permitted height from 5m to 9m for Kawau Island.
0910
Outstanding Natural
Rules
J6.2.4 Assessment
Amend Table 1 Gross floor area [under J6.2.3.1 Development controls], so that the GFA for
HNC/ONL is increased to from 50m
2
to 100m
2
and the GFA for ONC is increased from 25m
2
to 75m
2
0910
Outstanding Natural
Rules
Outstanding Natural
Landscapes Delete the ONL overlay from North Cove and Vivian Bay, Kawau Island.
0910 Precincts - North Kawau Island
Amend Rule 2.1.10 Tree removal, to allow removal of Kanuka/Manuka for planting of other
higher value native species.
0910 Precincts - North Kawau Island Amend Rule 3.3 Yards, so that it does not apply to front and rear boundaries.
0910 Precincts - North Kawau Island Provide for boat yards as a discretionary activity at Kawau Island.
0910
Outstanding Natural
Rules
J6.2.4 Assessment
Amend Rule 3.3 Yards [under J6.2.3 Development controls], by deleting 200m
and substituting 20m from mean high water springs.
0910
Outstanding Natural
Rules
J6.2.4 Assessment
Delete assessment criterion 8, 2.4 Assessment criteria (restricted discretionary activities)[in
J6.2.4].
Amend rule 2(a) by deleting the sentences 'Each site must have legal access to a jetty or
contrary in the underlying zone and Auckland-wide rules.' from Rule 2(a), Subdivision
controls, Sub-precinct A.
Amend the precinct policy, to allow removal of Kanuka/Manuka for planting of other higher
value native species.
0910
Outstanding Natural
Rules
Outstanding Natural
Landscapes
Amend the ONL overlay where it applies to Kawau Island, so that the overlay is confined to all
ridgelines between Kawati Point and the top of North Cove.
0910
Outstanding Natural
Rules
Character - Coastal
Delete the HNC overlay from the Coastal Settlement zone at the top of North Cove, Kawau
Island.
0910 Precincts - North Kawau Island Retain Rule 7. Organised sport and recreation.
7577-1 Anne L Green annehall@itlaw.co.nz Special Character
residential
656/1145
Sub#/
7577-2 Anne L Green annehall@itlaw.co.nz Precincts - Central Saint Heliers K2.19.Precinct Rules
to 9m.
7577-3 Anne L Green annehall@itlaw.co.nz Zoning Central
7577-4 Anne L Green annehall@itlaw.co.nz Zoning Central
environs.
residential
7577-6 Anne L Green annehall@itlaw.co.nz General Miscellaneous
Operational/
residential
7578-1 Melva L Archer
residential
to 9m.
environs.
residential
Operational/
residential
7579-1 Christine Hargrave
41 Devore Street, Saint Heliers,
residential
to 9m.
environs.
residential
Operational/
residential
7580-1
Kawau Island Access
Organisation
0910
Outstanding Natural
Rules
Outstanding Natural
Landscapes
Amend the ONL overlay where it applies to Kawau Island, so that the overlay is confined to all
ridgelines between Kawati Point and the top of North Cove.
7580-2
Kawau Island Access
Organisation
0910
Outstanding Natural
Rules
Character - Coastal
Delete the HNC overlay from the Coastal Settlement zone at the top of North Cove, Kawau
Island.
7580-3
Kawau Island Access
Organisation
Amend rule 2.(a) by deleting the sentences 'Each site must have legal access to a jetty or
contrary in the underlying zone and Auckland-wide rules.' from Rule 2(a), Subdivision
controls, Sub-precinct A.
657/1145
Sub#/
7580-4
Kawau Island Access
Organisation
0910
Outstanding Natural
Rules
Outstanding Natural
Landscapes Delete the ONL overlay from North Cove and Vivian Bay, Kawau Island.
7580-5
Kawau Island Access
Organisation
Amend Rule 2.1.10 Tree removal, to allow removal of Kanuka/Manuka for planting of other
higher value native species.
7580-6
Kawau Island Access
Organisation
0910 Precincts - North Kawau Island Amend Rule 3.3 Yards, so that it does not apply to front and rear boundaries.
7580-7
Kawau Island Access
Organisation
0910 Precincts - North Kawau Island Provide for boat yards as a discretionary activity at Kawau Island.
7580-8
Kawau Island Access
Organisation
0910 Precincts - North Kawau Island Amend Rule 3.3 yards, by deleting 200m and substituting 20m from mean high water springs.
7580-9
Kawau Island Access
Organisation
0910
Outstanding Natural
Rules
J6.2.4 Assessment
Delete assessment criterion 8, 2.4 Assessment criteria (restricted discretionary activities)[in
J6.2.4].
7580-10
Kawau Island Access
Organisation
0910
Outstanding Natural
Rules
J6.2.4 Assessment
Amend Rule 3.2 Height [under J6.2.3 Development controls], to increase the maximum
permitted height from 5m to 9m for Kawau Island.
7580-11
Kawau Island Access
Organisation
Protection Delete the overlay from the Settlement Policy Area of Kawau Island.
7580-12
Kawau Island Access
Organisation
Amend the precinct policy, to allow removal of Kanuka/Manuka for planting of other higher
value native species.
7580-13
Kawau Island Access
Organisation
Protection
Exempt property on Kawau Island within the Settlement Policy Area (DP 419092 Lots 1-3,
Lots 150-152, DP4961 Kawau Island) from Rule 4.3 Ridgeline protection.
7580-14
Kawau Island Access
Organisation
0910 Precincts - North Kawau Island Retain Rule 7 'Tree removal'.
7580-15
Kawau Island Access
Organisation
0910
Outstanding Natural
Rules
J6.2.4 Assessment Increase the maximum GFA in Table 1 to 100m2 for ONL and 75m2 for ONC.
7581-1 John and Annette Jonassen
80 Kildare Avenue, Saint Heliers,
residential
to 9m.
environs.
residential
Operational/
residential
7582-1 Anthony Wijdeven nicky@brianroberts.co.nz RPS Changes to the RUB South Rezone 1213 Paerata Road, Pukekohe from rural to Future Urban.
7583-1 Alistair Brown asbrown@bluewin.ch Special Character
residential
7583-2 Alistair Brown asbrown@bluewin.ch Precincts - Central Saint Heliers K2.19.Precinct Rules
to 9m.
7583-3 Alistair Brown asbrown@bluewin.ch Zoning Central
658/1145
Sub#/
7583-4 Alistair Brown asbrown@bluewin.ch Zoning Central
environs.
residential
7583-6 Alistair Brown asbrown@bluewin.ch General Miscellaneous
Operational/
residential
7584-1 John R Cameron
3C Clarendon Road, Saint Heliers,
residential
to 9m.
environs.
residential
Operational/
residential
7585-1 Jitendrakumar D Patel
residential
to 9m.
environs.
residential
Operational/
residential
7586-1 Barry Wood barryjewel@hotmail.com Zoning South Rezone Howick residential heritage zone to the current heritage zone [Manukau District Plan].
7586-2 Barry Wood barryjewel@hotmail.com Zoning South Rezone to remove all zones for infill housing in Howick.
7586-3 Barry Wood barryjewel@hotmail.com Mana Whenua General provisions
assessment Delete all provisions that provide for iwi to have input in the building process.
7587-1 David Gow
residential
7587-2 David Gow
to 9m.
7587-3 David Gow
7587-4 David Gow
environs.
7587-5 David Gow
residential
7587-6 David Gow
Operational/
7587-7 David Gow
residential
659/1145
Sub#/
7588-1
Sarah Phear and Richard
Shakles sarahphear@rocketmail.com General Miscellaneous Other Adopt the request of the New Zealand Archaelogical Association submission.
7589-1 Sue Doogue susiedoogue@hotmail.com Special Character
residential
7589-2 Sue Doogue susiedoogue@hotmail.com Precincts - Central Saint Heliers K2.19.Precinct Rules
to 9m.
7589-3 Sue Doogue susiedoogue@hotmail.com Zoning Central
7589-4 Sue Doogue susiedoogue@hotmail.com Residential zones Residential
policies
environs.
residential
residential
residential
7590-1 Louise M Davie
13 The Parade, Saint Heliers,
residential
to 9m.
environs.
residential
Auckland 1071 General Miscellaneous Other Ensure Tamaki Drive continues to serve travel needs of local residents.
residential
Prevent buildings and structures from being built or placed on parks, with particular reference
to Vellenoweth Green, St Heliers
7591-1 Jesse and Rie Savage jessedavidsavage@gmail.com Zoning Central
7591-2 Jesse and Rie Savage jessedavidsavage@gmail.com Residential zones Residential
General
7591-3 Jesse and Rie Savage jessedavidsavage@gmail.com Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
Special info. req.
General
requirements
parking demand.
660/1145
Sub#/
requirements
7592-1 Edna Meech 6 The Oaks, Ellerslie, Auckland 1051 Special Character
residential
7592-2 Edna Meech 6 The Oaks, Ellerslie, Auckland 1051 Precincts - Central Saint Heliers K2.19.Precinct Rules
to 9m.
7592-3 Edna Meech 6 The Oaks, Ellerslie, Auckland 1051 Zoning Central
7592-4 Edna Meech 6 The Oaks, Ellerslie, Auckland 1051 Zoning Central
environs.
residential
7592-6 Edna Meech 6 The Oaks, Ellerslie, Auckland 1051 General Miscellaneous
Operational/
residential
7593-1 Mary Baldwin marypattuohey@gmail.com Special Character
residential
7593-2 Mary Baldwin marypattuohey@gmail.com Precincts - Central Saint Heliers K2.19.Precinct Rules
to 9m.
7593-3 Mary Baldwin marypattuohey@gmail.com Zoning Central
7593-4 Mary Baldwin marypattuohey@gmail.com Zoning Central
environs.
residential
7593-6 Mary Baldwin marypattuohey@gmail.com General Miscellaneous
Operational/
residential
7594-1 Ailsa M McLean mcleanailsa@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central
7594-2 Ailsa M McLean mcleanailsa@xtra.co.nz Residential zones Residential
General
7594-3 Ailsa M McLean mcleanailsa@xtra.co.nz Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
Special info. req.
General
requirements
parking demand.
661/1145
Sub#/
requirements
7595-1 Josephine Tong josephine.tong@fintax.co.nz RPS Changes to the RUB West Retain the Future Urban zone for Scott Point, Hobsonville.
7595-2 Josephine Tong josephine.tong@fintax.co.nz RPS Changes to the RUB West
Rezone Scott Point, Hobsonville from Future Urban to a combination of Mixed Housing Urban
and Mixed Housing Suburban as described in on page 3/5 of the submission.
7595-3 Josephine Tong josephine.tong@fintax.co.nz
SEAs
Land
Delete SEA from Scott Point, Hobsonville, until such time as they can be investigated and
implemented specifically on a property by property basis in consultation with the property
owner.
7595-4 Josephine Tong josephine.tong@fintax.co.nz Historic Heritage (Overlay)
Heritage
Places
Delete the Heritage items from Scott Point, Hobsonville, until such time as they can be
investigated and implemented specifically on a property by property basis in consultation with
the property owner.
7596-1 Catherine Saunders cathsaundersnz@gmail.com Zoning Central
7596-2 Catherine Saunders cathsaundersnz@gmail.com Residential zones Residential
General
7596-3 Catherine Saunders cathsaundersnz@gmail.com Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
Special info. req.
General
requirements
parking demand.
requirements
7597-1 Sharlene E Ryan seryan@vodafone.co.nz Special Character
residential
7597-2 Sharlene E Ryan seryan@vodafone.co.nz Precincts - Central Saint Heliers K2.19.Precinct Rules
to 9m.
7597-3 Sharlene E Ryan seryan@vodafone.co.nz Zoning Central
7597-4 Sharlene E Ryan seryan@vodafone.co.nz Zoning Central
environs.
residential
7597-6 Sharlene E Ryan seryan@vodafone.co.nz General Miscellaneous
Operational/
residential
7598-1 Mary J Simmons
residential
to 9m.
662/1145
Sub#/
environs.
residential
Operational/
residential
7599-1 Kathryn H Heaton-Brown kathyheatonbrown@gmail.com Special Character
residential
7599-2 Kathryn H Heaton-Brown kathyheatonbrown@gmail.com Precincts - Central Saint Heliers K2.19.Precinct Rules
to 9m.
7599-3 Kathryn H Heaton-Brown kathyheatonbrown@gmail.com Zoning Central
7599-4 Kathryn H Heaton-Brown kathyheatonbrown@gmail.com Zoning Central
environs.
residential
7599-6 Kathryn H Heaton-Brown kathyheatonbrown@gmail.com General Miscellaneous
Operational/
residential
7600-1 Mark T D'Audney tane23@gmail.com Special Character
residential
7600-2 Mark T D'Audney tane23@gmail.com Precincts - Central Saint Heliers K2.19.Precinct Rules
to 9m.
7600-3 Mark T D'Audney tane23@gmail.com Zoning Central
7600-4 Mark T D'Audney tane23@gmail.com Zoning Central
environs.
residential
7600-6 Mark T D'Audney tane23@gmail.com General Miscellaneous
Operational/
residential
7601-1 Gerard and Diane Zwier
146 Pine Valley Road, RD2,
Silverdale, Auckland 0992 Subdivision Auckland-wide - Rural zones
area Provide for subdivision down to a 1ha minimum in Weiti Valley, Silverdale.
Silverdale, Auckland 0992 Public Open Space Zones Public Open Space D2 Introduction
Provide for sports and recreation such as an extension to the Silverdale Rugby Club's playing
fields, cricket grounds, pony club, within Weiti Valley, Silverdale.
Silverdale, Auckland 0992 Zoning North and Islands Rezone Weiti Valley, Silverdale, from Mixed Rural to Countryside Living.
7602-1 Angela Saunders angelasaunders11@gmail.com Zoning Central
7602-2 Angela Saunders angelasaunders11@gmail.com Residential zones Residential
General
7602-3 Angela Saunders angelasaunders11@gmail.com Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
663/1145
Sub#/
Special info. req.
General
requirements
parking demand.
requirements
7603-1 Robert P Bogers bogers@xtra.co.nz Special Character
residential
7603-2 Robert P Bogers bogers@xtra.co.nz Precincts - Central Saint Heliers K2.19.Precinct Rules
to 9m.
7603-3 Robert P Bogers bogers@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central
7603-4 Robert P Bogers bogers@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central
environs.
residential
7603-6 Robert P Bogers bogers@xtra.co.nz General Miscellaneous
Operational/
residential
7603-8 Robert P Bogers bogers@xtra.co.nz Precincts - Central Saint Heliers K2.19.Precinct Rules
Limit height to two levels (ground plus first floor) along St Heliers Bay Rd, between Tamaki Dr
and Polygon Rd, St Heliers
7604-1 Anthony Simmons
residential
to 9m.
environs.
residential
Operational/
residential
7605-1 Mark Moll mmoll@adhb.govt.nz Special Character
residential
7605-2 Mark Moll mmoll@adhb.govt.nz Precincts - Central Saint Heliers K2.19.Precinct Rules
to 9m.
7605-3 Mark Moll mmoll@adhb.govt.nz Zoning Central
664/1145
Sub#/
7605-4 Mark Moll mmoll@adhb.govt.nz Zoning Central
environs.
residential
7605-6 Mark Moll mmoll@adhb.govt.nz General Miscellaneous
Operational/
residential
7606-1 Christine M Savory
residential
to 9m.
environs.
residential
Operational/
residential
7607-1 Simon E K Reeves rethink@xtra.co.nz Residential zones Residential
General
from a Single House Residential subject to the Special Character overlay. Include a
properties subject to the Special Character overlay.
7607-2 Simon E K Reeves rethink@xtra.co.nz Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
from a Single House Residential subject to the Special Character overlay.
Special info. req.
Single House Residential subject to the Special Character overlay. The additional criteria
should require that sympathy and recognition be given to the streetscape character, height,
scale and form of dwelling subject to a Special Character overlay in the surrounding
neighbourhood. (Refer to submission for examples of assessment criteria)
General
requirements
parking demand.
requirements
House Residential which are subject to the City Fringe Parking overlay.
7607-7 Simon E K Reeves rethink@xtra.co.nz Transport Auckland -wide C1.2 Objectives
Delete the objectives and policies (eg objective 3 and policy 2) which support the City Centre
Fringe overlay including the absence of minimum parking requirements for Freemans Bay.
requirements
Amend the PAUP to maintain the minimum parking requirements for Freemans Bay as per
Rule 12.8.1 of the Operative District Plan (Isthmus Section).
7607-9 Simon E K Reeves rethink@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central
Apartment Buildings to a less intensive zoning consistent with the Residential 6a zoning under
the Operative District Plan
7608-1 Keith G Savory c.k@savorygroup.co.nz Precincts - Central Saint Heliers K2.19.Precinct Rules
Encourage adaption and reuse of the existing older buildings as a viable alternative to
demolition.
7608-2 Keith G Savory c.k@savorygroup.co.nz Precincts - Central Saint Heliers K2.19.Precinct Rules Require maintenance of properties in order to avoid 'demolition by neglect'.
7608-3 Keith G Savory c.k@savorygroup.co.nz Precincts - Central Saint Heliers K2.19.Precinct Rules Reduce the maximum height in St Heliers local centre from 12.5m to 9m.
665/1145
Sub#/
7608-4 Keith G Savory c.k@savorygroup.co.nz Precincts - Central Saint Heliers K2.19.Precinct Rules Amend the assessment criteria to use compulsory terms such as 'must' rather than 'should'.
Limit the size and scale of new buildings to a small scale, similar to the older existing
character buildings.
7608-6 Keith G Savory c.k@savorygroup.co.nz Precincts - Central Saint Heliers K2.19.Precinct Rules Prevent block building over amalgamated titles.
7608-7 Keith G Savory c.k@savorygroup.co.nz Precincts - Central Saint Heliers K2.19.Precinct Rules Strengthen design controls for St Heliers, with little scope for discretion.
Maintain and enhance commercial conditions for all developments to foster the survival of
small retail and service businesses.
7608-9 Keith G Savory c.k@savorygroup.co.nz Precincts - Central Saint Heliers K2.19.Precinct Rules Limit the number of bars, restuarants and cafes allowable in the commercial zone.
7608-10 Keith G Savory c.k@savorygroup.co.nz Special Character
residential
special character areas Incorporate the Tamaki Drive Master Plan into the PAUP.
7608-11 Keith G Savory c.k@savorygroup.co.nz Zoning Central Amend the residential zoning of St Heliers and Kohimarama [no details provided].
7608-12 Keith G Savory c.k@savorygroup.co.nz Precincts - Central Saint Heliers
Objectives & Policies Retain Objective 1.
7609-1 Benjamin Lawlor
117 Long Drive, Saint Heliers,
residential
to 9m.
environs.
residential
Operational/
residential
7610-1 Doug and Christine Fenwick
29B Paparoa Road, Cockle Bay,
Rezone all parts of Pakuranga, Pakaranga Sunnyhills, Buckland Beach Farm Cove and Half
Moon Bay, from mixed housing [height in relation to boundary], to a less intensive zoning such
as Single House.
7611-1 Roger Seyb roger.seyb1@gmail.com Residential zones Residential
Amend Rule 8.3 ['Height in relation to boundary'] to read: 1A: Buildings must not exceed a
height of 3m measured vertically above ground level at side and rear boundaries. Thereafter,
buildings must be set back 1m for every additional metre in height (45 degrees). 1B Where
sites in the Mixed Housing Urban zone adjoin sites in the Mixed Housing Suburban zones,
buildings must not exceed a height of 2.5m measured vertically above ground level at side
and rear boundaries. Thereafter, buildings must be set back 1m for every additional metre in
height (45 degrees).
7611-2 Roger Seyb roger.seyb1@gmail.com Definitions New Define common wall: as a wall between two buildings (not just a wall on a boundary).
7611-3 Roger Seyb roger.seyb1@gmail.com
control
Building demolition control J.3.6 Rules and mapping Delete the pre-1944 Building Demolition Control overlay from 57 Vale Road, St Heliers.
control
Building demolition control J.3.6 Rules and mapping Amend 3.6.1 to exclude buildings, where the frontage was constructed after 1944.
control
Amend 3.6.1 to exclude buildings, where the pre 1944 floor area makes up less than 50% of
the current floor area.
7612-1 Michael Culpan
residential
to 9m.
environs.
residential
Operational/
666/1145
Sub#/
residential
7613-1 Dario Tommasi dariot@usa.net Special Character
residential
7613-2 Dario Tommasi dariot@usa.net Precincts - Central Saint Heliers K2.19.Precinct Rules
to 9m.
7613-3 Dario Tommasi dariot@usa.net Zoning Central
7613-4 Dario Tommasi dariot@usa.net Zoning Central
environs.
residential
7613-6 Dario Tommasi dariot@usa.net General Miscellaneous
Operational/
residential
7614-1 Wayne Brown biznewz@xtra.co.nz RPS Urban growth
quality compact urban form Retain intensification provisions.
7614-2 Wayne Brown biznewz@xtra.co.nz Definitions Existing Amend the definition of 'dwellings' to allow 2 kitchens per household.
7615-1 Aiman Grace aiman.grace@kiwirail.co.nz Special Character
residential
7615-2 Aiman Grace aiman.grace@kiwirail.co.nz Precincts - Central Saint Heliers K2.19.Precinct Rules
to 9m.
7615-3 Aiman Grace aiman.grace@kiwirail.co.nz Zoning Central
7615-4 Aiman Grace aiman.grace@kiwirail.co.nz Zoning Central
environs.
residential
7615-6 Aiman Grace aiman.grace@kiwirail.co.nz General Miscellaneous
Operational/
residential
7616-1 Cecilie J Rushton cec.rushton@gmail.com Special Character
residential
7616-2 Cecilie J Rushton cec.rushton@gmail.com Precincts - Central Saint Heliers K2.19.Precinct Rules
to 9m.
7616-3 Cecilie J Rushton cec.rushton@gmail.com Zoning Central
7616-4 Cecilie J Rushton cec.rushton@gmail.com Zoning Central
environs.
residential
7616-6 Cecilie J Rushton cec.rushton@gmail.com General Miscellaneous
Operational/
residential
7617-1 Emma Marchant emma.marchant@gmail.com Special Character
residential
7617-2 Emma Marchant emma.marchant@gmail.com Precincts - Central Saint Heliers K2.19.Precinct Rules
to 9m.
667/1145
Sub#/
7617-3 Emma Marchant emma.marchant@gmail.com Zoning Central
7617-4 Emma Marchant emma.marchant@gmail.com Zoning Central
environs.
residential
7617-6 Emma Marchant emma.marchant@gmail.com General Miscellaneous
Operational/
residential
7618-1 Alistair J Ward alistair@wwauckland.co.nz Special Character
residential
7618-2 Alistair J Ward alistair@wwauckland.co.nz Precincts - Central Saint Heliers K2.19.Precinct Rules
to 9m.
7618-3 Alistair J Ward alistair@wwauckland.co.nz Zoning Central
7618-4 Alistair J Ward alistair@wwauckland.co.nz Zoning Central
environs.
residential
7618-6 Alistair J Ward alistair@wwauckland.co.nz General Miscellaneous
Operational/
residential
7619-1 Loretta and David Verry ldverry@ihug.co.nz Zoning Central
Apartment Buildings to Mixed Housing Suburban.
7619-2 Loretta and David Verry ldverry@ihug.co.nz Residential zones Residential
General
7619-3 Loretta and David Verry ldverry@ihug.co.nz Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
Special info. req.
General
requirements
parking demand.
requirements
7619-8 Loretta and David Verry ldverry@ihug.co.nz Transport Auckland -wide C1.2 Objectives
requirements
7619-10 Loretta and David Verry ldverry@ihug.co.nz General Miscellaneous
Operational/
Provide 120 minute parking in Ryle St, Freemans Bay with exemption stickers for owners /
tenants
668/1145
Sub#/
7620-1 Sam Scott
residential
7620-2 Sam Scott
to 9m.
7620-3 Sam Scott
7620-4 Sam Scott
environs.
7620-5 Sam Scott
residential
7620-6 Sam Scott
Operational/
7620-7 Sam Scott
residential
7621-1 Loretta Verry ldverry@ihug.co.nz Zoning Central
7621-2 Loretta Verry ldverry@ihug.co.nz Residential zones Residential
General
7621-3 Loretta Verry ldverry@ihug.co.nz Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
Special info. req.
General
requirements
parking demand.
requirements
7621-8 Loretta Verry ldverry@ihug.co.nz Transport Auckland -wide C1.2 Objectives
requirements
7621-10 Loretta Verry ldverry@ihug.co.nz General Miscellaneous Other
Implement maximum parking requirement of 120 minutes during the Mon-Fri working day in
Gunson St, Freemans Bay, with exemptions for residents
7622-1 Mandy Tutton mandy.tutton@xtra.co.nz Special Character
residential
7622-2 Mandy Tutton mandy.tutton@xtra.co.nz Precincts - Central Saint Heliers K2.19.Precinct Rules
to 9m.
7622-3 Mandy Tutton mandy.tutton@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central
7622-4 Mandy Tutton mandy.tutton@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central
environs.
669/1145
Sub#/
residential
7622-6 Mandy Tutton mandy.tutton@xtra.co.nz General Miscellaneous
Operational/
residential
7623-1 Simon R Mountfort rhysmountfort@xtra.co.nz Special Character
residential
7623-2 Simon R Mountfort rhysmountfort@xtra.co.nz Precincts - Central Saint Heliers K2.19.Precinct Rules
to 9m.
7623-3 Simon R Mountfort rhysmountfort@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central
7623-4 Simon R Mountfort rhysmountfort@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central
environs.
residential
7623-6 Simon R Mountfort rhysmountfort@xtra.co.nz General Miscellaneous
Operational/
residential
7624-1 Beverley Holdsworth bevholdsworth@yahoo.com Zoning Central
7624-2 Beverley Holdsworth bevholdsworth@yahoo.com Residential zones Residential
General
7624-3 Beverley Holdsworth bevholdsworth@yahoo.com Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
Special info. req.
General
requirements
parking demand.
requirements
7625-1 Robert C Greer
9/23 Coates Avenue, Orakei,
residential
to 9m.
environs.
residential
670/1145
Sub#/
Operational/
residential
7626-1 Nigel and Chloe Lewis
78A Kildare Avenue, Glendowie,
residential
to 9m.
environs.
residential
Operational/
residential
7627-1 Peter Seco
residential
7627-2 Peter Seco
to 9m.
7627-3 Peter Seco
7627-4 Peter Seco
environs.
7627-5 Peter Seco
residential
7627-6 Peter Seco
Operational/
7627-7 Peter Seco
residential
7628-1 Carl Maitland
8 Wood Street, Freemans Bay,
General
requirements
Special info. req.
General
requirements
parking demand.
671/1145
Sub#/
requirements
Auckland 1011 Transport Auckland -wide C1.2 Objectives
requirements
7629-1 William Trigance
1A/18 Cranbrook Street, Glendowie,
residential
to 9m.
environs.
residential
Operational/
residential
7630-1 Anthony Scarborough
40 Glendowie Road, Glendowie,
residential
to 9m.
environs.
residential
Operational/
residential
7631-1 Colin J Tutton colin.tutton@nz.abb.com Special Character
residential
7631-2 Colin J Tutton colin.tutton@nz.abb.com Precincts - Central Saint Heliers K2.19.Precinct Rules
to 9m.
7631-3 Colin J Tutton colin.tutton@nz.abb.com Zoning Central
7631-4 Colin J Tutton colin.tutton@nz.abb.com Zoning Central
environs.
residential
7631-6 Colin J Tutton colin.tutton@nz.abb.com General Miscellaneous
Operational/
residential
672/1145
Sub#/
7632-1 Kisione Fonua
1/32 Speight Road, Kohimarama,
residential
to 9m.
environs.
residential
Operational/
residential
7633-1 Min Lee
7633-2 Min Lee
General
7633-3 Min Lee
requirements
7633-4 Min Lee
Special info. req.
7633-5 Min Lee
General
7633-6 Min Lee
requirements
parking demand.
7633-7 Min Lee
requirements
7633-8 Min Lee
7633-9 Min Lee
requirements
7634-1 David Hill and Sue Haywood sue.haywood@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central
7634-2 David Hill and Sue Haywood sue.haywood@xtra.co.nz Residential zones Residential
General
7634-3 David Hill and Sue Haywood sue.haywood@xtra.co.nz Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
673/1145
Sub#/
Special info. req.
General
requirements
parking demand.
requirements
7635-1 Mary L Scott mlscott@xtra.co.nz Special Character
residential
limiting maximum height to 9m or less, setting out detailed design guidelines, maintaining and
7635-2 Mary L Scott mlscott@xtra.co.nz Precincts - Central Saint Heliers K2.19.Precinct Rules
to 9m.
7635-3 Mary L Scott mlscott@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central
7635-4 Mary L Scott mlscott@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central
environs.
residential
7635-6 Mary L Scott mlscott@xtra.co.nz General Miscellaneous
Operational/
residential
7635-8 Mary L Scott mlscott@xtra.co.nz Precincts - Central Saint Heliers K2.19.Precinct Rules Limit building height in St Heliers Village to two stories
7635-9 Mary L Scott mlscott@xtra.co.nz General Miscellaneous
Operational/
Projects/Acquisition Remove traffic wardens from St Heliers Bay village
7636-1 Heather Hamilton
33A Coldham Crescent, Saint Johns,
residential
to 9m.
environs.
residential
Operational/
residential
7637-1 Phillip Barca
General
674/1145
Sub#/
requirements
Special info. req.
General
requirements
parking demand.
requirements
requirements
7638-1 Louise Dempsey louisemary@gmail.com Zoning Central
7638-2 Louise Dempsey louisemary@gmail.com Residential zones Residential
General
7638-3 Louise Dempsey louisemary@gmail.com Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
Special info. req.
General
requirements
parking demand.
requirements
7639-1 Miriam T Dunningham jmdunningham@xtra.co.nz Special Character
residential
7639-2 Miriam T Dunningham jmdunningham@xtra.co.nz Precincts - Central Saint Heliers K2.19.Precinct Rules
to 9m.
7639-3 Miriam T Dunningham jmdunningham@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central
675/1145
Sub#/
7639-4 Miriam T Dunningham jmdunningham@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central
environs.
residential
7639-6 Miriam T Dunningham jmdunningham@xtra.co.nz General Miscellaneous
Operational/
residential
7640-1 Hannah Drury onlyonered@gmail.com Zoning Central
7640-2 Hannah Drury onlyonered@gmail.com Residential zones Residential
General
7640-3 Hannah Drury onlyonered@gmail.com Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
Special info. req.
General
requirements
parking demand.
requirements
7640-8 Hannah Drury onlyonered@gmail.com Transport Auckland -wide C1.2 Objectives
requirements
7641-1 Allan Whatt
6B/18 Cranbrook Place, Glendowie,
residential
7641-2 Allan Whatt
to 9m.
7641-3 Allan Whatt
7641-4 Allan Whatt
environs.
7641-5 Allan Whatt
residential
7641-6 Allan Whatt
Operational/
7641-7 Allan Whatt
residential
7642-1 Marlen Smith marlensmith@live.com Zoning Central
676/1145
Sub#/
7642-2 Marlen Smith marlensmith@live.com Residential zones Residential
General
7642-3 Marlen Smith marlensmith@live.com Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
Special info. req.
General
requirements
parking demand.
requirements
7642-8 Marlen Smith marlensmith@live.com Transport Auckland -wide C1.2 Objectives
requirements
7643-1 Peggy Meikle
7643-2 Peggy Meikle
General
7643-3 Peggy Meikle
requirements
7643-4 Peggy Meikle
Special info. req.
7643-5 Peggy Meikle
General
7643-6 Peggy Meikle
requirements
parking demand.
7643-7 Peggy Meikle
requirements
7644-1 Nicola and Campbell Shearer
45 Paunui Street, Saint Heliers,
residential
677/1145
Sub#/
to 9m.
environs.
residential
Operational/
residential
7645-1 Paul Dennis
6D/18 Cranbrook Place, Glendowie,
residential
7645-2 Paul Dennis
to 9m.
7645-3 Paul Dennis
7645-4 Paul Dennis
environs.
7645-5 Paul Dennis
residential
7645-6 Paul Dennis
Operational/
7645-7 Paul Dennis
residential
7646-1 Emily Wong emilywong.nz@gmail.com Zoning Central
7646-2 Emily Wong emilywong.nz@gmail.com Residential zones Residential
General
7646-3 Emily Wong emilywong.nz@gmail.com Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
Special info. req.
General
requirements
parking demand.
requirements
7646-8 Emily Wong emilywong.nz@gmail.com Transport Auckland -wide C1.2 Objectives
requirements
678/1145
Sub#/
7647-1 Louise P Stericker louise.stericker@gmail.com Special Character
residential
7647-2 Louise P Stericker louise.stericker@gmail.com Precincts - Central Saint Heliers K2.19.Precinct Rules
to 9m.
7647-3 Louise P Stericker louise.stericker@gmail.com Zoning Central
7647-4 Louise P Stericker louise.stericker@gmail.com Zoning Central
environs.
residential
7647-6 Louise P Stericker louise.stericker@gmail.com General Miscellaneous
Operational/
residential
7648-1 Catherine M Gordon catherine.gordon@xtra.co.nz Special Character
residential
7648-2 Catherine M Gordon catherine.gordon@xtra.co.nz Precincts - Central Saint Heliers K2.19.Precinct Rules
to 9m.
7648-3 Catherine M Gordon catherine.gordon@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central
7648-4 Catherine M Gordon catherine.gordon@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central
environs.
residential
7648-6 Catherine M Gordon catherine.gordon@xtra.co.nz General Miscellaneous
Operational/
residential
7649-1 Paul Edwards pauledwards83@gmail.com Zoning North and Islands Rezone 46 Castleton Street, Birkdale, from Single House to Mixed Housing Suburban.
7650-1 Janice Hartshorne
residential
to 9m.
environs.
residential
Operational/
residential
7651-1 Heather C Hume heather@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central
7651-2 Heather C Hume heather@xtra.co.nz Residential zones Residential
General
7651-3 Heather C Hume heather@xtra.co.nz Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
679/1145
Sub#/
Special info. req.
General
requirements
parking demand.
requirements
7652-1 John Bolton
12 Pine Ridge Terrace, Hauraki,
Amend the policy to: respect property rights, fairly balance cultural heritage and property
rights, use clear terminology, and make the council responsible for cultural impact
assessments rather than requiring applicants to deal with individual iwi.
7652-2 John Bolton
Whenua
and policies
Grade the sites of significance or value into categories of significance, to be accorded varying
degrees of protection and obligation.
7652-3 John Bolton
Whenua
and policies
Explain to all affected parties, the impact of, and the obligations required of the landowners of
sites of significance or value.
7652-4 John Bolton
assessment Delete information requirement G.27.4(5).
7652-5 John Bolton
assessment Delete the requirement for cultural impact assessments.
7652-6 John Bolton
assessment Make the council responsible for preparing cultural impact assessments.
7653-1 Douglas K Stockwell doug@eaglen.co.nz Zoning Central
7653-2 Douglas K Stockwell doug@eaglen.co.nz Residential zones Residential
General
7653-3 Douglas K Stockwell doug@eaglen.co.nz Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
Special info. req.
General
requirements
parking demand.
requirements
7653-8 Douglas K Stockwell doug@eaglen.co.nz Transport Auckland -wide C1.2 Objectives
680/1145
Sub#/
requirements
7654-1 Alison Lindegger
2 Panapa Drive, Saint Johns,
residential
to 9m.
environs.
residential
Operational/
residential
7655-1 Bernadette Perkins bernie_perkins@hotmail.com Special Character
residential
7655-2 Bernadette Perkins bernie_perkins@hotmail.com Precincts - Central Saint Heliers K2.19.Precinct Rules
to 9m.
7655-3 Bernadette Perkins bernie_perkins@hotmail.com Zoning Central
7655-4 Bernadette Perkins bernie_perkins@hotmail.com Zoning Central
environs.
residential
7655-6 Bernadette Perkins bernie_perkins@hotmail.com General Miscellaneous
Operational/
residential
7656-1 Graham A Cheesman ptfnz@yahoo.co.nz
SEAs
Land Add an SEA at 146 Mill Road, Alfriston.
7657-1 Nicola Flint nikkibaileyflint@gmail.com Zoning Central
7657-2 Nicola Flint nikkibaileyflint@gmail.com Residential zones Residential
General
7657-3 Nicola Flint nikkibaileyflint@gmail.com Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
Special info. req.
General
681/1145
Sub#/
requirements
parking demand.
requirements
7658-1 Susan J McColl mccoll@xtra.co.nz Special Character
residential
7658-2 Susan J McColl mccoll@xtra.co.nz Precincts - Central Saint Heliers K2.19.Precinct Rules
to 9m.
7658-3 Susan J McColl mccoll@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central
7658-4 Susan J McColl mccoll@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central
environs.
residential
7658-6 Susan J McColl mccoll@xtra.co.nz General Miscellaneous
Operational/
residential
7659-1 Danny Selak dansgarden@xtra.co.nz RPS Changes to the RUB West Retain the Future Urban zone at Scott Point, Hobsonville.
7659-2 Danny Selak dansgarden@xtra.co.nz RPS Changes to the RUB West
Rezone Scott Point, Hobsonville, from Future Urban to Mixed Housing Urban and Mixed
Housing Suburban.
7659-3 Danny Selak dansgarden@xtra.co.nz
SEAs
Land
Delete SEA from Scott Point, Hobsonville, until such time as they can be investigated and
implemented specifically on a property by property basis in consultation with the property
owner.
7659-4 Danny Selak dansgarden@xtra.co.nz Historic Heritage (Overlay)
Heritage
Places
Delete the Heritage items from Scott Point, Hobsonville, until such time as they can be
investigated and implemented specifically on a property by property basis in consultation with
the property owner.
7660-1 Margaret P Hibbs
1/278 St Heliers Bay Road, Saint
residential
to 9m.
environs.
residential
Operational/
residential
7661-1 Steven H Brodie steven.brodie@xtra.co.nz Special Character
residential
7661-2 Steven H Brodie steven.brodie@xtra.co.nz Precincts - Central Saint Heliers K2.19.Precinct Rules
to 9m.
7661-3 Steven H Brodie steven.brodie@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central
7661-4 Steven H Brodie steven.brodie@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central
environs.
residential
682/1145
Sub#/
7661-6 Steven H Brodie steven.brodie@xtra.co.nz General Miscellaneous
Operational/
residential
7662-1 Carmel A Connolly
residential
to 9m.
environs.
residential
Operational/
residential
7663-1 Diane Nicholson di.nic@xtra.co.nz Special Character
residential
7663-2 Diane Nicholson di.nic@xtra.co.nz Precincts - Central Saint Heliers K2.19.Precinct Rules
to 9m.
7663-3 Diane Nicholson di.nic@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central
7663-4 Diane Nicholson di.nic@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central
environs.
residential
7663-6 Diane Nicholson di.nic@xtra.co.nz General Miscellaneous
Operational/
residential
7664-1 Ronald Bruell ron.bruell@xtra.co.nz Special Character
residential
7664-2 Ronald Bruell ron.bruell@xtra.co.nz Precincts - Central Saint Heliers K2.19.Precinct Rules
to 9m.
7664-3 Ronald Bruell ron.bruell@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central
7664-4 Ronald Bruell ron.bruell@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central
environs.
residential
7664-6 Ronald Bruell ron.bruell@xtra.co.nz General Miscellaneous
Operational/
residential
7665-1 Joanna Wickham jo@jowickham.co.nz Zoning Central
7665-2 Joanna Wickham jo@jowickham.co.nz Residential zones Residential
General
683/1145
Sub#/
7665-3 Joanna Wickham jo@jowickham.co.nz Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
Special info. req.
General
requirements
parking demand.
requirements
7666-1 Philip Mercieca philipmercieca@xtra.co.nz Special Character
residential
7666-2 Philip Mercieca philipmercieca@xtra.co.nz Precincts - Central Saint Heliers K2.19.Precinct Rules
to 9m.
7666-3 Philip Mercieca philipmercieca@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central
7666-4 Philip Mercieca philipmercieca@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central
environs.
residential
7666-6 Philip Mercieca philipmercieca@xtra.co.nz General Miscellaneous
Operational/
residential
7667-1 Morrison Family rosimorn@xtra.co.nz RPS Changes to the RUB North and Waiheke Island
Retain the Future Urban zone at 1773 State Highway 1, Warkworth, subject to land rate
values being based on rural land use rather than urban land use.
7667-2 Morrison Family rosimorn@xtra.co.nz RPS Urban growth
land for urban development Commence early work on the Warkworth Area Structure Plan.
7668-1
Keith J Taylor and Patricia A
Moseley-Taylor kjtaylor@xtra.co.nz Special Character
residential
7668-2
Moseley-Taylor kjtaylor@xtra.co.nz Precincts - Central Saint Heliers K2.19.Precinct Rules
to 9m.
7668-3
Moseley-Taylor kjtaylor@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central
7668-4
Moseley-Taylor kjtaylor@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central
environs.
7668-5
residential
7668-6
Moseley-Taylor kjtaylor@xtra.co.nz General Miscellaneous
Operational/
7668-7
residential
7669-1 Bryce C De Luca bryceone@orcon.net.nz Zoning Central
684/1145
Sub#/
7669-2 Bryce C De Luca bryceone@orcon.net.nz Residential zones Residential
General
7669-3 Bryce C De Luca bryceone@orcon.net.nz Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
Special info. req.
General
requirements
parking demand.
requirements
7670-1 Susan Barker slam16@xtra.co.nz Special Character
residential
7670-2 Susan Barker slam16@xtra.co.nz Precincts - Central Saint Heliers K2.19.Precinct Rules
to 9m.
7670-3 Susan Barker slam16@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central
7670-4 Susan Barker slam16@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central
environs.
residential
7670-6 Susan Barker slam16@xtra.co.nz General Miscellaneous
Operational/
residential
7671-1 Julia Woodhouse juliaw@slingshot.co.nz
SEAs
Areas - Land rules (all) Amend rule to provide for more than 3m of vegetation clearance around a building at Piha.
7671-2 Julia Woodhouse juliaw@slingshot.co.nz Residential zones Residential
General Amend the rule to provide for 20% building coverage at Piha.
General
Delete all controls that effect the location of buildings on a site at Piha, so that building
location is determined by the owner, not the council.
SEAs
Land Delete SEAs from all residential areas at Piha.
SEAs
Areas - Land rules (all) Retain the provision for 20% vegetation trimming per year.
7671-6 Julia Woodhouse juliaw@slingshot.co.nz General Eplan
Provide a means of viewing properties on a map with all restrictions and overlays in one place
for ease of understanding.
7671-7 Julia Woodhouse juliaw@slingshot.co.nz RPS Mana Whenua B5 Strategic Delete rules which require the approval of iwi.
7671-8 Julia Woodhouse juliaw@slingshot.co.nz Zoning Central
Rezone Wellpark Avenue, Grey Lynn, from Mixed Housing Suburban to a less intensive
residential zone.
General
Restrict the height of the apartment buildings at the top of Francis Street, Grey Lynn to 2
storeys.
685/1145
Sub#/
7672-1 D Mary Christiansen
82a Vale Road, Saint Heliers,
residential
to 9m.
environs.
residential
Operational/
residential
7673-1 Pat O'Brien
residential
7673-2 Pat O'Brien
to 9m.
7673-3 Pat O'Brien
7673-4 Pat O'Brien
environs.
7673-5 Pat O'Brien
residential
7673-6 Pat O'Brien
Operational/
7673-7 Pat O'Brien
residential
7674-1 Peter Harrison peterh129@gmail.com Zoning Central
7674-2 Peter Harrison peterh129@gmail.com Residential zones Residential
General
7674-3 Peter Harrison peterh129@gmail.com Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
Special info. req.
General
requirements
parking demand.
requirements
7674-8 Peter Harrison peterh129@gmail.com Transport Auckland -wide C1.2 Objectives
686/1145
Sub#/
requirements
7675-1
Christopher J and Anita M
Booth chrisbooth@orcon.net.nz Special Character
residential
7675-2
Booth chrisbooth@orcon.net.nz Precincts - Central Saint Heliers K2.19.Precinct Rules
to 9m.
7675-3
Booth chrisbooth@orcon.net.nz Zoning Central
7675-4
Booth chrisbooth@orcon.net.nz Zoning Central
environs.
7675-5
residential
7675-6
Booth chrisbooth@orcon.net.nz General Miscellaneous
Operational/
7675-7
residential
7676-1 Jill Blanks
Heliers, Auckland 1071 Precincts - Central Saint Heliers
Objectives & Policies Retain the unique seaside village character of St Heliers.
7676-2 Jill Blanks
Heliers, Auckland 1071 Precincts - Central Saint Heliers K2.19.Precinct Rules Limit the height of buildings in St Heliers to 9m.
7677-1 Elsa Kooge elsaooge@hotmail.com Zoning Central
7677-2 Elsa Kooge elsaooge@hotmail.com Residential zones Residential
General
7677-3 Elsa Kooge elsaooge@hotmail.com Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
Special info. req.
General
requirements
parking demand.
requirements
7677-8 Elsa Kooge elsaooge@hotmail.com Transport Auckland -wide C1.2 Objectives
requirements
7678-1 Mabel Chen mabelchen72@gmail.com Zoning North and Islands
Rezone 72 Glencoe Road, Browns Bay, from Mixed Housing Suburban to Mixed Housing
Urban.
7679-1 Michael and Judith Farquhar mike.jude_farquhar@wave.co.nz Special Character
residential
687/1145
Sub#/
7679-2 Michael and Judith Farquhar mike.jude_farquhar@wave.co.nz Precincts - Central Saint Heliers K2.19.Precinct Rules
to 9m.
7679-3 Michael and Judith Farquhar mike.jude_farquhar@wave.co.nz Zoning Central
7679-4 Michael and Judith Farquhar mike.jude_farquhar@wave.co.nz Zoning Central
environs.
residential
7679-6 Michael and Judith Farquhar mike.jude_farquhar@wave.co.nz General Miscellaneous
Operational/
residential
7680-1 Barry and Prue McNutt b.p.mcnutt@paradise.net.nz Special Character
residential
7680-2 Barry and Prue McNutt b.p.mcnutt@paradise.net.nz Precincts - Central Saint Heliers K2.19.Precinct Rules
to 9m.
7680-3 Barry and Prue McNutt b.p.mcnutt@paradise.net.nz Zoning Central
7680-4 Barry and Prue McNutt b.p.mcnutt@paradise.net.nz Zoning Central
environs.
residential
7680-6 Barry and Prue McNutt b.p.mcnutt@paradise.net.nz General Miscellaneous
Operational/
residential
7680-8 Barry and Prue McNutt b.p.mcnutt@paradise.net.nz Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
Require any new development at St Heliers to provide car parking in proportion to the visitors
it is likely to engender
7681-1 Gordon T Rodger gordon_rodger@xtra.co.nz Special Character
residential
7681-2 Gordon T Rodger gordon_rodger@xtra.co.nz Precincts - Central Saint Heliers K2.19.Precinct Rules
to 9m.
7681-3 Gordon T Rodger gordon_rodger@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central
7681-4 Gordon T Rodger gordon_rodger@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central
environs.
residential
7681-6 Gordon T Rodger gordon_rodger@xtra.co.nz General Miscellaneous
Operational/
residential
7682-1 Margaret Ward bogers@xtra.co.nz Special Character
residential
7682-2 Margaret Ward bogers@xtra.co.nz Precincts - Central Saint Heliers K2.19.Precinct Rules
to 9m.
7682-3 Margaret Ward bogers@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central
7682-4 Margaret Ward bogers@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central
environs.
residential
7682-6 Margaret Ward bogers@xtra.co.nz General Miscellaneous
Operational/
688/1145
Sub#/
residential
7683-1 Mitchelson Family Trust almitchelson@xtra.co.nz Special Character
residential
7683-2 Mitchelson Family Trust almitchelson@xtra.co.nz Precincts - Central Saint Heliers K2.19.Precinct Rules
to 9m.
7683-3 Mitchelson Family Trust almitchelson@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central
7683-4 Mitchelson Family Trust almitchelson@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central
environs.
residential
7683-6 Mitchelson Family Trust almitchelson@xtra.co.nz General Miscellaneous
Operational/
residential
7684-1 Carl Knox carl.knox@xtra.co.nz Special Character
residential
7684-2 Carl Knox carl.knox@xtra.co.nz Precincts - Central Saint Heliers K2.19.Precinct Rules
to 9m.
7684-3 Carl Knox carl.knox@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central
7684-4 Carl Knox carl.knox@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central
environs.
residential
7684-6 Carl Knox carl.knox@xtra.co.nz General Miscellaneous
Operational/
residential
7685-1 Amanda R West
2A Roxy Terrace, Glendowie,
residential
to 9m.
environs.
residential
Operational/
residential
7686-1 Jane A E Hunter janec_1@yahoo.com Special Character
residential
7686-2 Jane A E Hunter janec_1@yahoo.com Precincts - Central Saint Heliers K2.19.Precinct Rules
to 9m.
7686-3 Jane A E Hunter janec_1@yahoo.com Zoning Central
7686-4 Jane A E Hunter janec_1@yahoo.com Zoning Central
environs.
689/1145
Sub#/
7686-5 Jane A E Hunter janec_1@yahoo.com Special Character
residential
7686-6 Jane A E Hunter janec_1@yahoo.com General Miscellaneous
Operational/
7687-1 Kiri Harkess kiri.harkess@mcelroys.co.nz Zoning Central
7687-2 Kiri Harkess kiri.harkess@mcelroys.co.nz Residential zones Residential
General
7687-3 Kiri Harkess kiri.harkess@mcelroys.co.nz Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
Special info. req.
General
requirements
parking demand.
requirements
7688-1 Robyn Larsen larsen.family@xtra.co.nz Special Character
residential
7688-2 Robyn Larsen larsen.family@xtra.co.nz Precincts - Central Saint Heliers K2.19.Precinct Rules
to 9m.
7688-3 Robyn Larsen larsen.family@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central
7688-4 Robyn Larsen larsen.family@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central
environs.
residential
7688-6 Robyn Larsen larsen.family@xtra.co.nz General Miscellaneous
Operational/
residential
7688-8 Robyn Larsen larsen.family@xtra.co.nz General Chapter G General provisions G2.4 Notification Publicly notify all applications for consent outside of zone rules
7689-1 Russell R West
residential
to 9m.
environs.
residential
690/1145
Sub#/
Operational/
residential
7690-1 Gabrielle Ryan
146A Riddell Road, Glendowie,
residential
to 9m.
environs.
residential
Operational/
residential
Auckland 1071 Precincts - Central Saint Heliers K2.19.Precinct Rules Require roof lines of buildings to well designed without visible air conditioning and pipes
7691-1 Laurel G McCulloch
residential
to 9m.
environs.
residential
Operational/
residential
7692-1 John B Good
residential
7692-2 John B Good
to 9m.
7692-3 John B Good
7692-4 John B Good
environs.
7692-5 John B Good
residential
7692-6 John B Good
Operational/
7692-7 John B Good
residential
7693-1 Halie Doak halieclaire@yahoo.com Special Character
residential
7693-2 Halie Doak halieclaire@yahoo.com Precincts - Central Saint Heliers K2.19.Precinct Rules
to 9m.
691/1145
Sub#/
7693-3 Halie Doak halieclaire@yahoo.com Zoning Central
7693-4 Halie Doak halieclaire@yahoo.com Zoning Central
environs.
residential
7693-6 Halie Doak halieclaire@yahoo.com General Miscellaneous
Operational/
residential
7694-1 Lynette Roper roperlynette@hotmail.com Special Character
residential
7694-2 Lynette Roper roperlynette@hotmail.com Precincts - Central Saint Heliers K2.19.Precinct Rules
to 9m.
7694-3 Lynette Roper roperlynette@hotmail.com Zoning Central
7694-4 Lynette Roper roperlynette@hotmail.com Zoning Central
environs.
residential
7694-6 Lynette Roper roperlynette@hotmail.com General Miscellaneous
Operational/
residential
7695-1 Paul Ivamy
74 Victoria Street, Pukekohe,
residential
7695-2 Paul Ivamy
to 9m.
7695-3 Paul Ivamy
7695-4 Paul Ivamy
environs.
7695-5 Paul Ivamy
residential
7695-6 Paul Ivamy
Operational/
7695-7 Paul Ivamy
residential
7696-1 Emma Ivamy
residential
7696-2 Emma Ivamy
to 9m.
7696-3 Emma Ivamy
7696-4 Emma Ivamy
environs.
7696-5 Emma Ivamy
residential
7696-6 Emma Ivamy
Operational/
7696-7 Emma Ivamy
residential
7697-1 Trevor G Zohs trevor@legaleagle.co.nz Zoning Central
692/1145
Sub#/
7697-2 Trevor G Zohs trevor@legaleagle.co.nz Residential zones Residential
General
7697-3 Trevor G Zohs trevor@legaleagle.co.nz Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
Special info. req.
General
requirements
parking demand.
requirements
7697-8 Trevor G Zohs trevor@legaleagle.co.nz Transport Auckland -wide C1.2 Objectives
requirements
7698-1 Charlotte King
51C Hawera Road, Kohimarama,
residential
to 9m.
environs.
residential
Operational/
residential
7699-1 Warwick Mahon warwickmahon@orcon.net.nz Zoning Central
7699-2 Warwick Mahon warwickmahon@orcon.net.nz Residential zones Residential
General
7699-3 Warwick Mahon warwickmahon@orcon.net.nz Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
Special info. req.
693/1145
Sub#/
General
requirements
parking demand.
requirements
7699-8 Warwick Mahon warwickmahon@orcon.net.nz Transport Auckland -wide C1.2 Objectives
requirements
7700-1 Christine Young
residential
to 9m.
environs.
residential
Operational/
residential
7701-1 Robert King
residential
7701-2 Robert King
to 9m.
7701-3 Robert King
7701-4 Robert King
environs.
7701-5 Robert King
residential
7701-6 Robert King
Operational/
7701-7 Robert King
residential
7702-1 Xue Bai sales@childhood.co.nz Special Character
residential
7702-2 Xue Bai sales@childhood.co.nz Precincts - Central Saint Heliers K2.19.Precinct Rules
to 9m.
7702-3 Xue Bai sales@childhood.co.nz Zoning Central
7702-4 Xue Bai sales@childhood.co.nz Zoning Central
environs.
residential
694/1145
Sub#/
7702-6 Xue Bai sales@childhood.co.nz General Miscellaneous
Operational/
residential
7703-1 Alison Wheatley-Mahon
2 Elizabeth Street, Freemans Bay,
General
requirements
Special info. req.
General
requirements
parking demand.
requirements
7704-1 Larissa King
residential
7704-2 Larissa King
to 9m.
7704-3 Larissa King
7704-4 Larissa King
environs.
7704-5 Larissa King
residential
7704-6 Larissa King
Operational/
7704-7 Larissa King
residential
7705-1 Melanie Sullivan qua.e.la.designers@gmail.com Zoning Central
7705-2 Melanie Sullivan qua.e.la.designers@gmail.com Residential zones Residential
General
7705-3 Melanie Sullivan qua.e.la.designers@gmail.com Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
695/1145
Sub#/
Special info. req.
General
requirements
parking demand.
requirements
7705-8 Melanie Sullivan qua.e.la.designers@gmail.com Transport Auckland -wide C1.2 Objectives
requirements
7706-1 Saint Heliers Home Cookery
residential
to 9m.
environs.
residential
Operational/
residential
7707-1 Grant Stainton
residential
to 9m.
environs.
residential
Operational/
residential
7708-1 Nicola Edgar
residential
7708-2 Nicola Edgar
to 9m.
696/1145
Sub#/
7708-3 Nicola Edgar
7708-4 Nicola Edgar
environs.
7708-5 Nicola Edgar
residential
7708-6 Nicola Edgar
Operational/
7708-7 Nicola Edgar
residential
7709-1 Philippa Waara
8A Appleyard Crescent,
Meadowbank, Auckland 1072 Special Character
residential
Meadowbank, Auckland 1072 Precincts - Central Saint Heliers K2.19.Precinct Rules
to 9m.
Meadowbank, Auckland 1072 Zoning Central
Meadowbank, Auckland 1072 Zoning Central
environs.
residential
Meadowbank, Auckland 1072 General Miscellaneous
Operational/
residential
7710-1 Jarcee Investments Limited devinejw@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central
7710-2 Jarcee Investments Limited devinejw@xtra.co.nz Residential zones Residential
General
7710-3 Jarcee Investments Limited devinejw@xtra.co.nz Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
Special info. req.
General
requirements
parking demand.
requirements
7710-8 Jarcee Investments Limited devinejw@xtra.co.nz Transport Auckland -wide C1.2 Objectives
requirements
697/1145
Sub#/
7711-1 Nicola Aamir
466 Riddell Road, Saint Heliers,
residential
7711-2 Nicola Aamir
to 9m.
7711-3 Nicola Aamir
7711-4 Nicola Aamir
environs.
7711-5 Nicola Aamir
residential
7711-6 Nicola Aamir
Operational/
7711-7 Nicola Aamir
residential
7712-1 Sharon M Henashaw
residential
to 9m.
environs.
residential
Operational/
residential
7713-1 Melanie Curry-Irons melaniec_021@hotmail.com Zoning Central
7713-2 Melanie Curry-Irons melaniec_021@hotmail.com Residential zones Residential
General
7713-3 Melanie Curry-Irons melaniec_021@hotmail.com Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
Special info. req.
General
requirements
parking demand.
requirements
698/1145
Sub#/
7714-1 Janelle M and Colin T McCloy janelle.monica@xtra.co.nz Special Character
residential
7714-2 Janelle M and Colin T McCloy janelle.monica@xtra.co.nz Precincts - Central Saint Heliers K2.19.Precinct Rules
to 9m.
7714-3 Janelle M and Colin T McCloy janelle.monica@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central
7714-4 Janelle M and Colin T McCloy janelle.monica@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central
environs.
residential
7714-6 Janelle M and Colin T McCloy janelle.monica@xtra.co.nz General Miscellaneous
Operational/
residential
7715-1 Jeremy Nash jeremy@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central
7715-2 Jeremy Nash jeremy@xtra.co.nz Residential zones Residential
General
7715-3 Jeremy Nash jeremy@xtra.co.nz Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
Special info. req.
General
requirements
parking demand.
requirements
7715-8 Jeremy Nash jeremy@xtra.co.nz Transport Auckland -wide C1.2 Objectives
requirements
7716-1 Saint Heliers Bay Fruit Shop kamalduggal2003@yahoo.co.nz Special Character
residential
7716-2 Saint Heliers Bay Fruit Shop kamalduggal2003@yahoo.co.nz Precincts - Central Saint Heliers K2.19.Precinct Rules
to 9m.
7716-3 Saint Heliers Bay Fruit Shop kamalduggal2003@yahoo.co.nz Zoning Central
7716-4 Saint Heliers Bay Fruit Shop kamalduggal2003@yahoo.co.nz Zoning Central
environs.
residential
699/1145
Sub#/
7716-6 Saint Heliers Bay Fruit Shop kamalduggal2003@yahoo.co.nz General Miscellaneous
Operational/
residential
7717-1 Valerie B Leech
102 Hepburn Street, Freemans Bay,
General
requirements
Special info. req.
General
requirements
parking demand.
requirements
requirements
Amend Rule 3.2 Number of parking and loading spaces, to apply minimum carparking
requirements to Freemans Bay
7718-1 Margaret Voyce margaret.voyce@visionstream.co.nz Zoning Central
7718-2 Margaret Voyce margaret.voyce@visionstream.co.nz Residential zones Residential
General
7718-3 Margaret Voyce margaret.voyce@visionstream.co.nz Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
Special info. req.
General
requirements
parking demand.
requirements
700/1145
Sub#/
7718-8 Margaret Voyce margaret.voyce@visionstream.co.nz Transport Auckland -wide C1.2 Objectives
requirements
7719-1 Kate E Mill sheardkate@yahoo.com Special Character
residential
7719-2 Kate E Mill sheardkate@yahoo.com Precincts - Central Saint Heliers K2.19.Precinct Rules
to 9m.
7719-3 Kate E Mill sheardkate@yahoo.com Zoning Central
7719-4 Kate E Mill sheardkate@yahoo.com Zoning Central
environs.
residential
7719-6 Kate E Mill sheardkate@yahoo.com General Miscellaneous
Operational/
residential
7720-1 Jacqueline H Cameron
residential
to 9m.
environs.
residential
Operational/
residential
7721-1 Brian Pearcy
2 Fallingbrook Road, Toronto,
Canada ON M1N 2T4 Special Character
residential
7721-2 Brian Pearcy
Canada ON M1N 2T4 Precincts - Central Saint Heliers K2.19.Precinct Rules
to 9m.
7721-3 Brian Pearcy
Canada ON M1N 2T4 Zoning Central
7721-4 Brian Pearcy
Canada ON M1N 2T4 Zoning Central
environs.
7721-5 Brian Pearcy
residential
7721-6 Brian Pearcy
Canada ON M1N 2T4 General Miscellaneous
Operational/
7721-7 Brian Pearcy
residential
7722-1 Philip J Southworth gillietastic@hotmail.com Special Character
residential
7722-2 Philip J Southworth gillietastic@hotmail.com Precincts - Central Saint Heliers K2.19.Precinct Rules
to 9m.
701/1145
Sub#/
7722-3 Philip J Southworth gillietastic@hotmail.com Zoning Central
7722-4 Philip J Southworth gillietastic@hotmail.com Zoning Central
environs.
residential
7722-6 Philip J Southworth gillietastic@hotmail.com General Miscellaneous
Operational/
residential
7723-1 Philomena M McSweeney
412/28 College Hill, Freemans Bay,
General
requirements
Special info. req.
General
requirements
parking demand.
requirements
requirements
7724-1 Mariya Janashia
260 West Tamaki Road, Glen Innes,
residential
to 9m.
environs.
residential
Operational/
residential
7725-1 Kate Bedford monkeybizzniss@gmail.com Zoning Central
702/1145
Sub#/
7725-2 Kate Bedford monkeybizzniss@gmail.com Residential zones Residential
General
7725-3 Kate Bedford monkeybizzniss@gmail.com Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
Special info. req.
General
requirements
parking demand.
requirements
7726-1 Philippa G Stickland strugglestreet@xtra.co.nz Special Character
residential
7726-2 Philippa G Stickland strugglestreet@xtra.co.nz Precincts - Central Saint Heliers K2.19.Precinct Rules
to 9m.
7726-3 Philippa G Stickland strugglestreet@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central
7726-4 Philippa G Stickland strugglestreet@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central
environs.
residential
7726-6 Philippa G Stickland strugglestreet@xtra.co.nz General Miscellaneous
Operational/
residential
7727-1 Nigel W Stickland strugglestreet@xtra.co.nz Special Character
residential
7727-2 Nigel W Stickland strugglestreet@xtra.co.nz Precincts - Central Saint Heliers K2.19.Precinct Rules
to 9m.
7727-3 Nigel W Stickland strugglestreet@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central
7727-4 Nigel W Stickland strugglestreet@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central
environs.
residential
7727-6 Nigel W Stickland strugglestreet@xtra.co.nz General Miscellaneous
Operational/
residential
703/1145
Sub#/
7728-1 Elizabeth Darke lizziedarke@clear.net.nz Special Character
residential
7728-2 Elizabeth Darke lizziedarke@clear.net.nz Precincts - Central Saint Heliers K2.19.Precinct Rules
to 9m.
7728-3 Elizabeth Darke lizziedarke@clear.net.nz Zoning Central
7728-4 Elizabeth Darke lizziedarke@clear.net.nz Zoning Central
environs.
residential
7728-6 Elizabeth Darke lizziedarke@clear.net.nz General Miscellaneous
Operational/
residential
7729-1 Ken and Julene Dorman kdormancam@gmail.com Zoning Central
7729-2 Ken and Julene Dorman kdormancam@gmail.com Residential zones Residential
General
7729-3 Ken and Julene Dorman kdormancam@gmail.com Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
Special info. req.
General
requirements
parking demand.
requirements
7730-1 Hamish D Milne sailfast@xtra.co.nz Special Character
residential
7730-2 Hamish D Milne sailfast@xtra.co.nz Precincts - Central Saint Heliers K2.19.Precinct Rules
to 9m.
7730-3 Hamish D Milne sailfast@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central
7730-4 Hamish D Milne sailfast@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central
environs.
residential
7730-6 Hamish D Milne sailfast@xtra.co.nz General Miscellaneous
Operational/
residential
704/1145
Sub#/
7731-1 Gillian E Jones
28A Melanesia Road, Kohimarama,
residential
to 9m.
environs.
residential
Operational/
residential
7732-1 Sir/Madam Perera
PO Box 87496, Meadowbank,
residential
to 9m.
environs.
residential
Operational/
residential
7733-1 Paul Field paul@fieldrubber.co.nz Special Character
residential
7733-2 Paul Field paul@fieldrubber.co.nz Precincts - Central Saint Heliers K2.19.Precinct Rules
to 9m.
7733-3 Paul Field paul@fieldrubber.co.nz Zoning Central
7733-4 Paul Field paul@fieldrubber.co.nz Zoning Central
environs.
residential
7733-6 Paul Field paul@fieldrubber.co.nz General Miscellaneous
Operational/
residential
7734-1 Carolyn Field carolyn.field@xtra.co.nz Special Character
residential
7734-2 Carolyn Field carolyn.field@xtra.co.nz Precincts - Central Saint Heliers K2.19.Precinct Rules
to 9m.
7734-3 Carolyn Field carolyn.field@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central
7734-4 Carolyn Field carolyn.field@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central
environs.
residential
705/1145
Sub#/
7734-6 Carolyn Field carolyn.field@xtra.co.nz General Miscellaneous
Operational/
residential
7735-1 Maren A Kracke
3/9 Eltham Road, Kohimarama,
residential
to 9m.
environs.
residential
Operational/
residential
7736-1 Nicola S E Amani sailfast@xtra.co.nz Special Character
residential
7736-2 Nicola S E Amani sailfast@xtra.co.nz Precincts - Central Saint Heliers K2.19.Precinct Rules
to 9m.
7736-3 Nicola S E Amani sailfast@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central
7736-4 Nicola S E Amani sailfast@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central
environs.
residential
7736-6 Nicola S E Amani sailfast@xtra.co.nz General Miscellaneous
Operational/
residential
7737-1 M McDade
23 Taylors Road, Morningside,
residential
7737-2 M McDade
to 9m.
7737-3 M McDade
7737-4 M McDade
environs.
7737-5 M McDade
residential
7737-6 M McDade
Operational/
7737-7 M McDade
residential
7738-1 Claire J Milne sailfast@xtra.co.nz Special Character
residential
7738-2 Claire J Milne sailfast@xtra.co.nz Precincts - Central Saint Heliers K2.19.Precinct Rules
to 9m.
7738-3 Claire J Milne sailfast@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central
706/1145
Sub#/
7738-4 Claire J Milne sailfast@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central
environs.
residential
7738-6 Claire J Milne sailfast@xtra.co.nz General Miscellaneous
Operational/
residential
7739-1 Christine Matos christine.matos@xtra.co.nz Special Character
residential
7739-2 Christine Matos christine.matos@xtra.co.nz Precincts - Central Saint Heliers K2.19.Precinct Rules
to 9m.
7739-3 Christine Matos christine.matos@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central
7739-4 Christine Matos christine.matos@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central
environs.
residential
7739-6 Christine Matos christine.matos@xtra.co.nz General Miscellaneous
Operational/
residential
7740-1 Rachel Coates
residential
to 9m.
environs.
residential
Operational/
residential
7741-1 Susan G McKnight mcknight.family@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central
7741-2 Susan G McKnight mcknight.family@xtra.co.nz Residential zones Residential
General
7741-3 Susan G McKnight mcknight.family@xtra.co.nz Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
Special info. req.
General
707/1145
Sub#/
requirements
parking demand.
requirements
7742-1 Gudrun Fallows fallowsnz@xtra.co.nz Special Character
residential
7742-2 Gudrun Fallows fallowsnz@xtra.co.nz Precincts - Central Saint Heliers K2.19.Precinct Rules
to 9m.
7742-3 Gudrun Fallows fallowsnz@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central
7742-4 Gudrun Fallows fallowsnz@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central
environs.
residential
7742-6 Gudrun Fallows fallowsnz@xtra.co.nz General Miscellaneous
Operational/
residential
7743-1 Robert and Dylan Makgill robert@robertmakgill.com Zoning South
Rezone 1307 Wattle Bay Road, Orua Bay to a zone the same as the operative Franklin plan
zones.
7743-2 Robert and Dylan Makgill robert@robertmakgill.com Residential zones Residential Land use controls Retain the Franklin Operative Plan density allowance for 1307 Wattle Bay Road, Orua Bay.
7743-3 Robert and Dylan Makgill robert@robertmakgill.com
SEAs
Land Delete SEA over 1307 Wattle Bay Road, and over Orua Bay generally.
7743-4 Robert and Dylan Makgill robert@robertmakgill.com
the CMA
sch. 6.2 ONC/HNC
6.4 Schedule of coastal marine
area boundaries Delete the Coastal Protection Yard over 130I Wattle Bay Road, Orua.
7744-1 Save Our Saint Heliers
residential
to 9m.
environs.
residential
Operational/
residential
7745-1 Katherine Orange pkorange@gmail.com Special Character
residential
7745-2 Katherine Orange pkorange@gmail.com Precincts - Central Saint Heliers K2.19.Precinct Rules
to 9m.
7745-3 Katherine Orange pkorange@gmail.com Zoning Central
7745-4 Katherine Orange pkorange@gmail.com Zoning Central
environs.
residential
708/1145
Sub#/
7745-6 Katherine Orange pkorange@gmail.com General Miscellaneous
Operational/
residential
7746-1 Distinctive Linens
residential
to 9m.
environs.
residential
Operational/
residential
7747-1 Colin McKnight mcknight.family@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central
7747-2 Colin McKnight mcknight.family@xtra.co.nz Residential zones Residential
General
7747-3 Colin McKnight mcknight.family@xtra.co.nz Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
Special info. req.
General
requirements
parking demand.
requirements
7748-1 Meat Trenz
residential
7748-2 Meat Trenz
to 9m.
7748-3 Meat Trenz
7748-4 Meat Trenz
environs.
7748-5 Meat Trenz
residential
7748-6 Meat Trenz
Operational/
709/1145
Sub#/
7748-7 Meat Trenz
residential
7749-1 Laurence A Davie ldavie99@gmail.com Special Character
residential
7749-2 Laurence A Davie ldavie99@gmail.com Precincts - Central Saint Heliers K2.19.Precinct Rules
to 9m.
7749-3 Laurence A Davie ldavie99@gmail.com Zoning Central
7749-4 Laurence A Davie ldavie99@gmail.com Zoning Central
environs.
residential
7749-6 Laurence A Davie ldavie99@gmail.com General Miscellaneous
Operational/
residential
7749-8 Laurence A Davie ldavie99@gmail.com RPS Mana Whenua B5 Strategic Decline provisions which allow iwi to have overriding approval of building projects
7750-1 Nicole Anfang
20 Brilliant Street, Saint Heliers,
residential
to 9m.
environs.
residential
Operational/
residential
7751-1 Gae Black
residential
7751-2 Gae Black
to 9m.
7751-3 Gae Black
7751-4 Gae Black
environs.
7751-5 Gae Black
residential
7751-6 Gae Black
Operational/
7751-7 Gae Black
residential
7752-1 Tina Young
3B Clarendon Road, Saint Heliers,
residential
7752-2 Tina Young
to 9m.
7752-3 Tina Young
710/1145
Sub#/
7752-4 Tina Young
environs.
7752-5 Tina Young
residential
7752-6 Tina Young
Operational/
7752-7 Tina Young
residential
7753-1 Andrew Davie adar159@aucklanduni.ac.nz Special Character
residential
7753-2 Andrew Davie adar159@aucklanduni.ac.nz Precincts - Central Saint Heliers K2.19.Precinct Rules
to 9m.
7753-3 Andrew Davie adar159@aucklanduni.ac.nz Zoning Central
7753-4 Andrew Davie adar159@aucklanduni.ac.nz Zoning Central
environs.
residential
7753-6 Andrew Davie adar159@aucklanduni.ac.nz General Miscellaneous
Operational/
residential
7754-1 Adilson Ramalho adilson.ramalho@fonterra.com Zoning Central
7754-2 Adilson Ramalho adilson.ramalho@fonterra.com Residential zones Residential
General
7754-3 Adilson Ramalho adilson.ramalho@fonterra.com Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
Special info. req.
General
requirements
parking demand.
requirements
7755-1 Alistair Niven alistair.niven@vodafone.co.nz Zoning Central
7755-2 Alistair Niven alistair.niven@vodafone.co.nz Residential zones Residential
General
7755-3 Alistair Niven alistair.niven@vodafone.co.nz Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
711/1145
Sub#/
Special info. req.
General
requirements
parking demand.
requirements
7755-8 Alistair Niven alistair.niven@vodafone.co.nz Transport Auckland -wide C1.2 Objectives
requirements
7756-1 Neil W M Carter neil.carter@xtra.co.nz Special Character
residential
7756-2 Neil W M Carter neil.carter@xtra.co.nz Precincts - Central Saint Heliers K2.19.Precinct Rules
to 9m.
7756-3 Neil W M Carter neil.carter@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central
7756-4 Neil W M Carter neil.carter@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central
environs.
residential
7756-6 Neil W M Carter neil.carter@xtra.co.nz General Miscellaneous
Operational/
residential
7756-8 Neil W M Carter neil.carter@xtra.co.nz Precincts - Central Saint Heliers K2.19.Precinct Rules Include mandatory design controls for any commercial development
7757-1 Marion Circuilt marionlc@xtra.co.nz Special Character
residential
7757-2 Marion Circuilt marionlc@xtra.co.nz Precincts - Central Saint Heliers K2.19.Precinct Rules
to 9m.
7757-3 Marion Circuilt marionlc@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central
7757-4 Marion Circuilt marionlc@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central
environs.
residential
7757-6 Marion Circuilt marionlc@xtra.co.nz General Miscellaneous
Operational/
residential
7758-1 Bruce M Rankine bruce@b-r.co.nz Special Character
residential
712/1145
Sub#/
7758-2 Bruce M Rankine bruce@b-r.co.nz Precincts - Central Saint Heliers K2.19.Precinct Rules
to 9m.
7758-3 Bruce M Rankine bruce@b-r.co.nz Zoning Central
7758-4 Bruce M Rankine bruce@b-r.co.nz Zoning Central
environs.
residential
7758-6 Bruce M Rankine bruce@b-r.co.nz General Miscellaneous
Operational/
residential
7759-1 Don Brown dbrown@basfordbrands.co.nz Zoning Central
7759-2 Don Brown dbrown@basfordbrands.co.nz Residential zones Residential
General
7759-3 Don Brown dbrown@basfordbrands.co.nz Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
Special info. req.
General
requirements
parking demand.
requirements
7759-8 Don Brown dbrown@basfordbrands.co.nz Transport Auckland -wide C1.2 Objectives
requirements
7760-1 Christine Beckhaus
4 Fenton Circus, Orakei, Auckland
residential
to 9m.
1071 Zoning Central
1071 Zoning Central
environs.
residential
Operational/
residential
713/1145
Sub#/
7761-1 Amanda Iavarone
2D/38 Douglas Street, Ponsonby,
residential
to 9m.
environs.
residential
Operational/
residential
7762-1 Trevor R Lund trevorlund@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central
7762-2 Trevor R Lund trevorlund@xtra.co.nz Residential zones Residential
General
7762-3 Trevor R Lund trevorlund@xtra.co.nz Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
Special info. req.
General
requirements
parking demand.
requirements
7762-8 Trevor R Lund trevorlund@xtra.co.nz Transport Auckland -wide C1.2 Objectives
requirements
7763-1 Sandra Lee Royalhouse sandy@cleanslatepress.com Transport Auckland -wide C1.2 Objectives
Fringe overlay including the absence of minimum parking requirements for Freemans Bay
7763-2 Sandra Lee Royalhouse sandy@cleanslatepress.com Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
Rule 12.8.1 of the Operative District Plan (Isthmus Section)
7764-1 Pamela Degotardi
25 Burns Street, Forest Hills, New
York, United States of America,
Auckland Special Character
residential
Auckland Precincts - Central Saint Heliers K2.19.Precinct Rules
to 9m.
714/1145
Sub#/
Auckland Zoning Central
Auckland Zoning Central
environs.
residential
Auckland General Miscellaneous
Operational/
residential
7765-1 Eva Naera evaandsonny@gmail.com Zoning Central
7765-2 Eva Naera evaandsonny@gmail.com Residential zones Residential
General
7765-3 Eva Naera evaandsonny@gmail.com Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
Special info. req.
General
requirements
parking demand.
requirements
7765-8 Eva Naera evaandsonny@gmail.com Transport Auckland -wide C1.2 Objectives
requirements
7766-1 Kate Rutledge
residential
to 9m.
environs.
residential
Operational/
715/1145
Sub#/
residential
7767-1 Trevor Langford-Read trevor@auckland1011.com Transport Auckland -wide C1.2 Objectives
7767-2 Trevor Langford-Read trevor@auckland1011.com Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
7768-1 Papakura Netball Centre ops@papakuranetball.org.nz Public Open Space Zones Public Open Space D2 Introduction
Retain approach that separates Public Open Spaces into 5 zones, and in particular the
separation of Community and Civic zones.
7768-2 Papakura Netball Centre ops@papakuranetball.org.nz Public Open Space Zones
D2.3 Sport & Active
pols
Retain Objective [1] to create a network of quality public open spaces that meet the
community's needs.
D2.3 Sport & Active
pols
Retain Policy [5] to maximise the use of buildings and facilities (such as through multi-
avoid permanent single purpose buildings with restricted use.
obs & pols
Retain Policy [1] to provide public open spaces in town centres and urban areas to support
place.
and policies Retain Major Recreation Facility zone.
7768-6 Papakura Netball Centre ops@papakuranetball.org.nz
policies Retain Special Purpose School zone.
7768-7 Papakura Netball Centre ops@papakuranetball.org.nz
7768-8 Papakura Netball Centre ops@papakuranetball.org.nz General C7.2/H6.1 Lighting Delete controls 'Lighting' 6.1.2, 6.1.3, 6.1.4 and retain control 6.1.5 only.
7768-9 Papakura Netball Centre ops@papakuranetball.org.nz Public Open Space Zones Public Open Space
Amend control 3.11 'Lighting' to include standards that manage spillage and glare, in
accordance with Australian Standard AS 4282, rather than level of lighting or the timing of
their use. Seek minimum lux for artificial lighting dependent on the sporting code using the
grounds, based on Australian Standard AS 2560. The controls would apply between 6am to
11pm Monday to Sunday and public holidays.
7768-10 Papakura Netball Centre ops@papakuranetball.org.nz General Noise and vibration H6.2 Rules
Amend land use control 1.3(1) Recreational Noise (Table 12) to prescribe the specific 25
hours per week that the noise limits may be exceeded for each space, to align with the timing
of lighting controls as follows: 6.00am-11.00pm Monday to Sunday and Public Holidays -
60dB (LAeq) / 55dB at all other times, and delete reference to 15 minute periods.
7768-11 Papakura Netball Centre ops@papakuranetball.org.nz Earthworks H4.2.1.1 Activity table - Zones
Amend to include earthworks for the construction of sports fields, and to raise the threshold at
which earthworks within a Public Open Space zone (including the Sports and Active
Recreation zone) require resource consent.
Amend control 3.9(1) 'Maximum site coverage' to reconsider the thresholds for some
activities, such as netball and tennis, to reflect the character of the varying recreational and
sporting activities that take place in public open space zones and to anticipate future use.
Amend development control 3.10(1) 'Maximum impervious area' to reflect that certain sports
(e.g. netball and tennis) require impervious area amounting to 90-100% of the public open
space.
7768-14 Papakura Netball Centre ops@papakuranetball.org.nz Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
Clarify the appropriate parking measures to be applied to community sport organisations that
manage/own facilities on public open spaces.
7768-15 Papakura Netball Centre ops@papakuranetball.org.nz Transport Auckland -wide
requirements Reduce parking thresholds [for organised sports and recreation].
7768-16 Papakura Netball Centre ops@papakuranetball.org.nz Precincts Ak-Wide and Coastal Rowing and Paddling Apply the Rowing and Paddling Precinct to existing facilities that are not currently included.
7769-1 John Keir john@keirfilm.co.nz Zoning Central
7769-2 John Keir john@keirfilm.co.nz Residential zones Residential
General
7769-3 John Keir john@keirfilm.co.nz Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
716/1145
Sub#/
Special info. req.
General
requirements
parking demand.
requirements
7769-8 John Keir john@keirfilm.co.nz Transport Auckland -wide C1.2 Objectives
requirements
7770-1 Graeme Hargreaves
5/66 Waiatarua Road, Remuera,
residential
to 9m.
environs.
residential
Operational/
residential
7771-1 Margot Rieder margot.rieder@gmail.com Transport Auckland -wide C1.2 Objectives
7771-2 Margot Rieder margot.rieder@gmail.com Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
7772-1 Elizabeth M Bourke libbybourke@xtra.co.nz Special Character
residential
7772-2 Elizabeth M Bourke libbybourke@xtra.co.nz Precincts - Central Saint Heliers K2.19.Precinct Rules
to 9m.
7772-3 Elizabeth M Bourke libbybourke@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central
7772-4 Elizabeth M Bourke libbybourke@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central
environs.
residential
7772-6 Elizabeth M Bourke libbybourke@xtra.co.nz General Miscellaneous
Operational/
residential
717/1145
Sub#/
7773-1 Netball Manurewa netballmanurewa@xtra.co.nz Public Open Space Zones
D2.3 Sport & Active
pols
community's needs.
7773-2 Netball Manurewa netballmanurewa@xtra.co.nz Public Open Space Zones
D2.3 Sport & Active
pols
7773-3 Netball Manurewa netballmanurewa@xtra.co.nz General C7.2/H6.1 Lighting Delete controls 'Lighting' 6.1.2, 6.1.3, 6.1.4 and retain control 6.1.5 only.
7773-4 Netball Manurewa netballmanurewa@xtra.co.nz Public Open Space Zones Public Open Space
7773-5 Netball Manurewa netballmanurewa@xtra.co.nz General Noise and vibration H6.2 Rules
7773-6 Netball Manurewa netballmanurewa@xtra.co.nz Earthworks H4.2.1.1 Activity table - Zones
space.
7773-9 Netball Manurewa netballmanurewa@xtra.co.nz Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
7773-10 Netball Manurewa netballmanurewa@xtra.co.nz Transport Auckland -wide
Amend the land use controls in the Sports and Active Recreation zone to provide for covering
of existing outdoor courts as a permitted activity of up to 15m in height to provide for all-
weather play
7774-1 Georg Grabner
20 Ryle Street, Freemans Bay,
General
requirements
Special info. req.
General
requirements
parking demand.
requirements
718/1145
Sub#/
requirements
7775-1 Waiuku Tennis Club nigel.bradley@bluescopesteel.com General C7.2/H6.1 Lighting Delete controls 'Lighting' 6.1.2, 6.1.3, 6.1.4 and retain control 6.1.5 only.
7775-2 Waiuku Tennis Club nigel.bradley@bluescopesteel.com Public Open Space Zones Public Open Space
7775-3 Waiuku Tennis Club nigel.bradley@bluescopesteel.com General Noise and vibration H6.2 Rules
7775-4 Waiuku Tennis Club nigel.bradley@bluescopesteel.com Earthworks H4.2.1.1 Activity table - Zones
7775-5 Waiuku Tennis Club nigel.bradley@bluescopesteel.com Public Open Space Zones Public Open Space
space.
7776-1 David B Hingston
3/85 Kurahaupo Street, Orakei,
residential
to 9m.
environs.
residential
Operational/
residential
7777-1 Trevor G Coleman
88 Whitehaven Road, Glendowie,
residential
to 9m.
environs.
residential
Operational/
residential
7778-1 Marcus Crawshaw marcuscrawshaw@hotmail.com Transport Auckland -wide C1.2 Objectives
7778-2 Marcus Crawshaw marcuscrawshaw@hotmail.com Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
719/1145
Sub#/
7779-1 Annemieke Pritchard annemieke@fairyjobmother.co.nz Zoning Central
7779-2 Annemieke Pritchard annemieke@fairyjobmother.co.nz Residential zones Residential
General
7779-3 Annemieke Pritchard annemieke@fairyjobmother.co.nz Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
Special info. req.
General
requirements
parking demand.
requirements
7779-8 Annemieke Pritchard annemieke@fairyjobmother.co.nz Transport Auckland -wide C1.2 Objectives
requirements
7780-1 E A Edge
residential
7780-2 E A Edge
to 9m.
7780-3 E A Edge
7780-4 E A Edge
environs.
7780-5 E A Edge
residential
7780-6 E A Edge
Operational/
Ensure Tamaki Drive continues to serve travel needs of local residents. Develop and maintain
measures to ensure safe cycling and rapid transport into the city precincts.
7780-7 E A Edge
residential
7781-1 New Zealand Football andy.martin@nzfootball.co.nz Public Open Space Zones Public Open Space D2 Introduction
7781-2 New Zealand Football andy.martin@nzfootball.co.nz Public Open Space Zones
D2.3 Sport & Active
pols
community's needs.
D2.3 Sport & Active
pols
obs & pols
place.
720/1145
Sub#/
7781-6 New Zealand Football andy.martin@nzfootball.co.nz
7781-7 New Zealand Football andy.martin@nzfootball.co.nz
7781-8 New Zealand Football andy.martin@nzfootball.co.nz General C7.2/H6.1 Lighting Delete controls 'Lighting' 6.1.2, 6.1.3, 6.1.4 and retain control 6.1.5 only.
7781-9 New Zealand Football andy.martin@nzfootball.co.nz Public Open Space Zones Public Open Space
7781-10 New Zealand Football andy.martin@nzfootball.co.nz General Noise and vibration H6.2 Rules
7781-11 New Zealand Football andy.martin@nzfootball.co.nz Earthworks H4.2.1.1 Activity table - Zones
space.
7781-14 New Zealand Football andy.martin@nzfootball.co.nz Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
7781-15 New Zealand Football andy.martin@nzfootball.co.nz Transport Auckland -wide
requirements Reduce parking thresholds [for organised sports and recreation]
7782-1 Alison Vernon ali@limeblue.co.nz Zoning Central
7782-2 Alison Vernon ali@limeblue.co.nz Residential zones Residential
General
7782-3 Alison Vernon ali@limeblue.co.nz Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
Special info. req.
General
requirements
parking demand.
requirements
7783-1 Lynne Butler lynneb1@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central
721/1145
Sub#/
7783-2 Lynne Butler lynneb1@xtra.co.nz Residential zones Residential
General
7783-3 Lynne Butler lynneb1@xtra.co.nz Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
Special info. req.
General
requirements
parking demand.
requirements
7783-8 Lynne Butler lynneb1@xtra.co.nz Transport Auckland -wide C1.2 Objectives
requirements
7784-1 John W Spencer
residential
to 9m.
environs.
residential
Operational/
residential
Auckland 1071
control
Building demolition control J.3.6 Rules and mapping Retain pre-1994 provisions but with stronger notification requirements.
7785-1 Craig Hexter Juleshex@gmail.com Zoning Central
7785-2 Craig Hexter Juleshex@gmail.com Residential zones Residential
General
7785-3 Craig Hexter Juleshex@gmail.com Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
722/1145
Sub#/
Special info. req.
General
requirements
parking demand.
requirements
7785-8 Craig Hexter Juleshex@gmail.com Transport Auckland -wide C1.2 Objectives
requirements
7786-1 Peter and Sarah Withell seg@xtra.co.nz Transport Auckland -wide C1.2 Objectives
7786-2 Peter and Sarah Withell seg@xtra.co.nz Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
7787-1 Gina Wing ginawing@clear.net.nz Zoning Central
7787-2 Gina Wing ginawing@clear.net.nz Residential zones Residential
General
7787-3 Gina Wing ginawing@clear.net.nz Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
Special info. req.
General
requirements
parking demand.
requirements
7787-8 Gina Wing ginawing@clear.net.nz Transport Auckland -wide C1.2 Objectives
requirements
7788-1 Julianne Hexter juleshex@gmail.com Zoning Central
723/1145
Sub#/
7788-2 Julianne Hexter juleshex@gmail.com Residential zones Residential
General
7788-3 Julianne Hexter juleshex@gmail.com Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
Special info. req.
General
requirements
parking demand.
requirements
7788-8 Julianne Hexter juleshex@gmail.com Transport Auckland -wide C1.2 Objectives
requirements
7789-1 Jane Coleman
residential
7789-2 Jane Coleman
to 9m.
7789-3 Jane Coleman
7789-4 Jane Coleman
environs.
7789-5 Jane Coleman
residential
7789-6 Jane Coleman
Operational/
7789-7 Jane Coleman
residential
7790-1 Eden-Roskill Softball Club edenroskillsoftball@gmail.com Public Open Space Zones Public Open Space D2 Introduction
7790-2 Eden-Roskill Softball Club edenroskillsoftball@gmail.com Public Open Space Zones
D2.3 Sport & Active
pols
community's needs.
D2.3 Sport & Active
pols
obs & pols
place.
7790-6 Eden-Roskill Softball Club edenroskillsoftball@gmail.com
724/1145
Sub#/
7790-7 Eden-Roskill Softball Club edenroskillsoftball@gmail.com
7790-8 Eden-Roskill Softball Club edenroskillsoftball@gmail.com General C7.2/H6.1 Lighting Delete controls 'Lighting' 6.1.2, 6.1.3, 6.1.4 and retain control 6.1.5 only.
7790-9 Eden-Roskill Softball Club edenroskillsoftball@gmail.com Public Open Space Zones Public Open Space
7790-10 Eden-Roskill Softball Club edenroskillsoftball@gmail.com General Noise and vibration H6.2 Rules
7790-11 Eden-Roskill Softball Club edenroskillsoftball@gmail.com Earthworks H4.2.1.1 Activity table - Zones
space.
7790-14 Eden-Roskill Softball Club edenroskillsoftball@gmail.com Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
7790-15 Eden-Roskill Softball Club edenroskillsoftball@gmail.com Transport Auckland -wide
7790-16 Eden-Roskill Softball Club edenroskillsoftball@gmail.com Precincts Ak-Wide and Coastal Rowing and Paddling Apply the Rowing and Paddling Precinct to existing facilities that are not currently included.
7791-1 Abbie Reynolds abbie_reynolds@yahoo.co.uk Zoning Central
7791-2 Abbie Reynolds abbie_reynolds@yahoo.co.uk Residential zones Residential
General
7791-3 Abbie Reynolds abbie_reynolds@yahoo.co.uk Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
Special info. req.
General
requirements
parking demand.
requirements
7791-8 Abbie Reynolds abbie_reynolds@yahoo.co.uk Transport Auckland -wide C1.2 Objectives
requirements
725/1145
Sub#/
7792-1 Teresa M Cummack
50 Bay Road, Saint Heliers,
residential
to 9m.
environs.
residential
Operational/
residential
7793-1 Anna-Louise Wilson annawilson66@yahoo.com Zoning Central
7793-2 Anna-Louise Wilson annawilson66@yahoo.com Residential zones Residential
General
7793-3 Anna-Louise Wilson annawilson66@yahoo.com Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
Special info. req.
General
requirements
parking demand.
requirements
7793-8 Anna-Louise Wilson annawilson66@yahoo.com Transport Auckland -wide C1.2 Objectives
requirements
7794-1 Peter Bailey
25 Clarendon Road, Saint Heliers,
residential
7794-2 Peter Bailey
to 9m.
7794-3 Peter Bailey
7794-4 Peter Bailey
environs.
7794-5 Peter Bailey
residential
726/1145
Sub#/
7794-6 Peter Bailey
Operational/
7794-7 Peter Bailey
residential
7795-1
Papatoetoe Association
Football Club Incorporated pamela.luhrs@beca.com Public Open Space Zones Public Open Space D2 Introduction
7795-2
Football Club Incorporated pamela.luhrs@beca.com Public Open Space Zones
D2.3 Sport & Active
pols
community's needs.
7795-3
D2.3 Sport & Active
pols
7795-4
obs & pols
place.
7795-5
7795-6
Football Club Incorporated pamela.luhrs@beca.com
7795-7
Football Club Incorporated pamela.luhrs@beca.com
7795-8
Football Club Incorporated pamela.luhrs@beca.com General C7.2/H6.1 Lighting Delete controls 'Lighting' 6.1.2, 6.1.3, 6.1.4 and retain control 6.1.5 only.
7795-9
Football Club Incorporated pamela.luhrs@beca.com Public Open Space Zones Public Open Space
7795-10
Football Club Incorporated pamela.luhrs@beca.com General Noise and vibration H6.2 Rules
7795-11
Football Club Incorporated pamela.luhrs@beca.com Earthworks H4.2.1.1 Activity table - Zones
7795-12
7795-13
space.
7795-14
Football Club Incorporated pamela.luhrs@beca.com Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
7795-15
Football Club Incorporated pamela.luhrs@beca.com Transport Auckland -wide
7796-1 Patricia A Topley
6/2 Ryle Street, Freemans Bay,
General
requirements
727/1145
Sub#/
Special info. req.
General
requirements
parking demand.
requirements
requirements
7797-1 David Singh
50 Collingwood Street, Freemans
Bay, Auckland 1011 Transport Auckland -wide C1.2 Objectives
7797-2 David Singh
50 Collingwood Street, Freemans
Bay, Auckland 1011 Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
7798-1 Mary Egan maryegannz@gmail.com Zoning Central
7798-2 Mary Egan maryegannz@gmail.com Residential zones Residential
General
7798-3 Mary Egan maryegannz@gmail.com Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
Special info. req.
General
requirements
parking demand.
requirements
7798-8 Mary Egan maryegannz@gmail.com Transport Auckland -wide C1.2 Objectives
requirements
728/1145
Sub#/
7799-1 Caroline S Hanan-Jones shj@ihug.co.nz Special Character
residential
7799-2 Caroline S Hanan-Jones shj@ihug.co.nz Precincts - Central Saint Heliers K2.19.Precinct Rules
to 9m.
7799-3 Caroline S Hanan-Jones shj@ihug.co.nz Zoning Central
7799-4 Caroline S Hanan-Jones shj@ihug.co.nz Zoning Central
environs.
residential
7799-6 Caroline S Hanan-Jones shj@ihug.co.nz General Miscellaneous
Operational/
residential
7800-1 Robert N Silver silverrn69@gmail.com Zoning Central
7800-2 Robert N Silver silverrn69@gmail.com Residential zones Residential
General
7800-3 Robert N Silver silverrn69@gmail.com Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
Special info. req.
General
requirements
parking demand.
requirements
7800-8 Robert N Silver silverrn69@gmail.com Transport Auckland -wide C1.2 Objectives
requirements
7801-1 Cynthia M Beeby cbeeby@hotmail.co.nz Zoning Central
7801-2 Cynthia M Beeby cbeeby@hotmail.co.nz Residential zones Residential
General
7801-3 Cynthia M Beeby cbeeby@hotmail.co.nz Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
729/1145
Sub#/
Special info. req.
General
requirements
parking demand.
requirements
7801-8 Cynthia M Beeby cbeeby@hotmail.co.nz Transport Auckland -wide C1.2 Objectives
requirements
7802-1
Netball North Harbour
Incorporated lynette@netballnorthharbour.co.nz Public Open Space Zones Public Open Space D2 Introduction
7802-2
Incorporated lynette@netballnorthharbour.co.nz Public Open Space Zones
D2.3 Sport & Active
pols
community's needs.
7802-3
D2.3 Sport & Active
pols
7802-4
obs & pols
place.
7802-5
7802-6
Incorporated lynette@netballnorthharbour.co.nz
7802-7
Incorporated lynette@netballnorthharbour.co.nz
7802-8
Incorporated lynette@netballnorthharbour.co.nz General C7.2/H6.1 Lighting Delete controls 'Lighting' 6.1.2, 6.1.3, 6.1.4 and retain control 6.1.5 only.
7802-9
Incorporated lynette@netballnorthharbour.co.nz Public Open Space Zones Public Open Space
7802-10
Incorporated lynette@netballnorthharbour.co.nz General Noise and vibration H6.2 Rules
7802-11
Incorporated lynette@netballnorthharbour.co.nz Earthworks H4.2.1.1 Activity table - Zones
7802-12
7802-13
space.
730/1145
Sub#/
7802-14
Incorporated lynette@netballnorthharbour.co.nz Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
7802-15
Incorporated lynette@netballnorthharbour.co.nz Transport Auckland -wide
7802-16
Incorporated lynette@netballnorthharbour.co.nz Precincts Ak-Wide and Coastal Rowing and Paddling Apply the Rowing and Paddling Precinct to existing facilities that are not currently included.
7803-1 Margaret Boulton
General
requirements
Special info. req.
General
requirements
parking demand.
requirements
requirements
7804-1 Neil Dewar ndewar@stheliersdentalcentre.co.nz Precincts - Central Saint Heliers K2.19.Precinct Rules
Ensure development in St Heliers Centre maintains and enhances commercial conditions that
foster the survival of small retail and service businesses
7804-2 Neil Dewar ndewar@stheliersdentalcentre.co.nz Special Character
residential
7804-3 Neil Dewar ndewar@stheliersdentalcentre.co.nz General Miscellaneous
Operational/
7804-4 Neil Dewar ndewar@stheliersdentalcentre.co.nz Special Character
residential
7805-1 Corinne Laporte coco@cocolaporte.co.nz Zoning Central
7805-2 Corinne Laporte coco@cocolaporte.co.nz Residential zones Residential
General
7805-3 Corinne Laporte coco@cocolaporte.co.nz Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
731/1145
Sub#/
Special info. req.
General
requirements
parking demand.
requirements
7805-8 Corinne Laporte coco@cocolaporte.co.nz Transport Auckland -wide C1.2 Objectives
requirements
7806-1 Carol Palmer caroljpalmer24@gmail.com Zoning Central
7806-2 Carol Palmer caroljpalmer24@gmail.com Residential zones Residential
General
7806-3 Carol Palmer caroljpalmer24@gmail.com Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
Special info. req.
General
requirements
parking demand.
requirements
7806-8 Carol Palmer caroljpalmer24@gmail.com Transport Auckland -wide C1.2 Objectives
requirements
7807-1
North Shore United
Association Football Club
Incorporated tony@agllaw.co.nz Public Open Space Zones Public Open Space D2 Introduction
7807-2
North Shore United
Incorporated tony@agllaw.co.nz Public Open Space Zones
D2.3 Sport & Active
pols
community's needs.
732/1145
Sub#/
7807-3
North Shore United
D2.3 Sport & Active
pols
7807-4
North Shore United
obs & pols
place.
7807-5
North Shore United
7807-6
North Shore United
Incorporated tony@agllaw.co.nz
7807-7
North Shore United
Incorporated tony@agllaw.co.nz
7807-8
North Shore United
Incorporated tony@agllaw.co.nz General C7.2/H6.1 Lighting Delete controls 'Lighting' 6.1.2, 6.1.3, 6.1.4 and retain control 6.1.5 only.
7807-9
North Shore United
Incorporated tony@agllaw.co.nz Public Open Space Zones Public Open Space
7807-10
North Shore United
Incorporated tony@agllaw.co.nz General Noise and vibration H6.2 Rules
7807-11
North Shore United
Incorporated tony@agllaw.co.nz Earthworks H4.2.1.1 Activity table - Zones
7807-12
North Shore United
7807-13
North Shore United
space.
7807-14
North Shore United
Incorporated tony@agllaw.co.nz Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
7807-15
North Shore United
Incorporated tony@agllaw.co.nz Transport Auckland -wide
7808-1 Peter H Talbot peter.talbot@xtra.co.nz Zoning North and Islands
7809-1 Andrew Crowe andrewcrowe01@gmail.com Zoning Central
7809-2 Andrew Crowe andrewcrowe01@gmail.com Residential zones Residential
General
7809-3 Andrew Crowe andrewcrowe01@gmail.com Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
Special info. req.
733/1145
Sub#/
General
requirements
parking demand.
requirements
7809-8 Andrew Crowe andrewcrowe01@gmail.com Transport Auckland -wide C1.2 Objectives
requirements
7810-1 G B Herrick gbherrick@wnation.net.nz Zoning Central
7810-2 G B Herrick gbherrick@wnation.net.nz Residential zones Residential
General
7810-3 G B Herrick gbherrick@wnation.net.nz Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
Special info. req.
General
requirements
parking demand.
requirements
7810-8 G B Herrick gbherrick@wnation.net.nz Transport Auckland -wide C1.2 Objectives
requirements
7811-1 Desmond G Lowe no1bowler@xtra.co.nz Zoning North and Islands
7812-1 Wendy Cracroft wendycracroft80@hotmail.com Zoning Central
7812-2 Wendy Cracroft wendycracroft80@hotmail.com Residential zones Residential
General
7812-3 Wendy Cracroft wendycracroft80@hotmail.com Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
734/1145
Sub#/
Special info. req.
General
requirements
parking demand.
requirements
7812-8 Wendy Cracroft wendycracroft80@hotmail.com Transport Auckland -wide C1.2 Objectives
requirements
7813-1 Wayne A E Knight knightcentaurus@gmail.com Zoning Central
7813-2 Wayne A E Knight knightcentaurus@gmail.com Residential zones Residential
General
7813-3 Wayne A E Knight knightcentaurus@gmail.com Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
Special info. req.
General
requirements
parking demand.
requirements
7814-1 Remuera Golf Club office@remueragolfclub.com Public Open Space Zones Public Open Space D2 Introduction
7814-2 Remuera Golf Club office@remueragolfclub.com Public Open Space Zones
D2.3 Sport & Active
pols
community's needs.
D2.3 Sport & Active
pols
7814-5 Remuera Golf Club office@remueragolfclub.com General C7.2/H6.1 Lighting Delete controls 'Lighting' 6.1.2, 6.1.3, 6.1.4 and retain control 6.1.5 only.
735/1145
Sub#/
7814-6 Remuera Golf Club office@remueragolfclub.com Public Open Space Zones Public Open Space
7814-7 Remuera Golf Club office@remueragolfclub.com General Noise and vibration H6.2 Rules
60dB (LAeq) / 55dB at all other times, and delete reference to 15 minute periods
7814-8 Remuera Golf Club office@remueragolfclub.com General Noise and vibration H6.2 Rules
Amend the dB limits in land use control 1.3(1) Recreational Noise (Table 12) to ensure that
golf course maintenance equipment can be used without infringing the limits
7815-1 Luciana Olivera-Smith luciana.oliverasmith@gmail.com Zoning Central
7815-2 Luciana Olivera-Smith luciana.oliverasmith@gmail.com Residential zones Residential
General
7815-3 Luciana Olivera-Smith luciana.oliverasmith@gmail.com Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
Special info. req.
General
requirements
parking demand.
requirements
7815-8 Luciana Olivera-Smith luciana.oliverasmith@gmail.com Transport Auckland -wide C1.2 Objectives
requirements
7816-1 Heather K Ellis heatherkayellis13@gmail.com Zoning Central
7816-2 Heather K Ellis heatherkayellis13@gmail.com Residential zones Residential
General
7816-3 Heather K Ellis heatherkayellis13@gmail.com Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
Special info. req.
736/1145
Sub#/
General
requirements
parking demand.
requirements
7816-8 Heather K Ellis heatherkayellis13@gmail.com Transport Auckland -wide C1.2 Objectives
requirements
7817-1 Peter Kang pdhkang@gmail.com Zoning North and Islands
7818-1 Shane and Paula Walsh pwalsh@stmaryak.school.nz Zoning Central
7818-2 Shane and Paula Walsh pwalsh@stmaryak.school.nz Residential zones Residential
General
7818-3 Shane and Paula Walsh pwalsh@stmaryak.school.nz Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
Special info. req.
General
requirements
parking demand.
requirements
7818-8 Shane and Paula Walsh pwalsh@stmaryak.school.nz Transport Auckland -wide C1.2 Objectives
requirements
7819-1
Titirangi Tennis and Squash
Rackets Club wec@babbage.co.nz Public Open Space Zones Public Open Space D2 Introduction
7819-2
Rackets Club wec@babbage.co.nz Public Open Space Zones
D2.3 Sport & Active
pols
community's needs.
7819-3
D2.3 Sport & Active
pols
7819-4
obs & pols
place.
737/1145
Sub#/
7819-5
7819-6
Rackets Club wec@babbage.co.nz
7819-7
Rackets Club wec@babbage.co.nz
7819-8
Rackets Club wec@babbage.co.nz General C7.2/H6.1 Lighting Delete controls 'Lighting' 6.1.2, 6.1.3, 6.1.4 and retain control 6.1.5 only.
7819-9
Rackets Club wec@babbage.co.nz Public Open Space Zones Public Open Space
7819-10
Rackets Club wec@babbage.co.nz General Noise and vibration H6.2 Rules
7819-11
Rackets Club wec@babbage.co.nz Earthworks H4.2.1.1 Activity table - Zones
7819-12
7819-13
space.
7819-14
Rackets Club wec@babbage.co.nz Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
7819-15
Rackets Club wec@babbage.co.nz Transport Auckland -wide
7820-1 Mark Van Kaathoven mvkozaus@gmail.com Zoning Central
7820-2 Mark Van Kaathoven mvkozaus@gmail.com Residential zones Residential
General
7820-3 Mark Van Kaathoven mvkozaus@gmail.com Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
Special info. req.
General
requirements
parking demand.
requirements
7820-8 Mark Van Kaathoven mvkozaus@gmail.com Transport Auckland -wide C1.2 Objectives
738/1145
Sub#/
requirements
7821-1 Janet A Grabner-Clark jancl@ihug.co.nz Zoning Central
7821-2 Janet A Grabner-Clark jancl@ihug.co.nz Residential zones Residential
General
7821-3 Janet A Grabner-Clark jancl@ihug.co.nz Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
Special info. req.
General
requirements
parking demand.
requirements
7821-8 Janet A Grabner-Clark jancl@ihug.co.nz Transport Auckland -wide C1.2 Objectives
requirements
7822-1
Otahuhu United Association
Football Club (Incoporated) otahuhuafcsecretary@gmail.com Public Open Space Zones Public Open Space D2 Introduction
7822-2
Football Club (Incoporated) otahuhuafcsecretary@gmail.com Public Open Space Zones
D2.3 Sport & Active
pols
community's needs.
7822-3
D2.3 Sport & Active
pols
7822-4
obs & pols
place.
7822-5
7822-6
Football Club (Incoporated) otahuhuafcsecretary@gmail.com
7822-7
Football Club (Incoporated) otahuhuafcsecretary@gmail.com
7822-8
Football Club (Incoporated) otahuhuafcsecretary@gmail.com General C7.2/H6.1 Lighting Delete controls 'Lighting' 6.1.2, 6.1.3, 6.1.4 and retain control 6.1.5 only.
7822-9
Football Club (Incoporated) otahuhuafcsecretary@gmail.com Public Open Space Zones Public Open Space
739/1145
Sub#/
7822-10
Football Club (Incoporated) otahuhuafcsecretary@gmail.com General Noise and vibration H6.2 Rules
7822-11
Football Club (Incoporated) otahuhuafcsecretary@gmail.com Earthworks H4.2.1.1 Activity table - Zones
7822-12
7822-13
space.
7822-14
Football Club (Incoporated) otahuhuafcsecretary@gmail.com Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
7822-15
Football Club (Incoporated) otahuhuafcsecretary@gmail.com Transport Auckland -wide
7823-1 Larry Smith larrys@ecom.co.nz Zoning Central
7823-2 Larry Smith larrys@ecom.co.nz Residential zones Residential
General
7823-3 Larry Smith larrys@ecom.co.nz Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
Special info. req.
General
requirements
parking demand.
requirements
7823-8 Larry Smith larrys@ecom.co.nz Transport Auckland -wide C1.2 Objectives
requirements
7824-1 Gaynor E Steel gaynor.steel@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central
7824-2 Gaynor E Steel gaynor.steel@xtra.co.nz Residential zones Residential
General
7824-3 Gaynor E Steel gaynor.steel@xtra.co.nz Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
740/1145
Sub#/
Special info. req.
General
requirements
parking demand.
requirements
7824-8 Gaynor E Steel gaynor.steel@xtra.co.nz Transport Auckland -wide C1.2 Objectives
requirements
7825-1 Barry Burnand burnand@xtra.co.nz Zoning North and Islands
7826-1 Lindsay E Foster lindsay.foster@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central
7826-2 Lindsay E Foster lindsay.foster@xtra.co.nz Residential zones Residential
General
7826-3 Lindsay E Foster lindsay.foster@xtra.co.nz Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
Special info. req.
General
requirements
parking demand.
requirements
7826-8 Lindsay E Foster lindsay.foster@xtra.co.nz Transport Auckland -wide C1.2 Objectives
requirements
7827-1
Counties Manukau Touch
Association lance.watene@xtra.co.nz Public Open Space Zones Public Open Space D2 Introduction
7827-2
Association lance.watene@xtra.co.nz Public Open Space Zones
D2.3 Sport & Active
pols
community's needs.
741/1145
Sub#/
7827-3
D2.3 Sport & Active
pols
7827-4
obs & pols
place.
7827-5
7827-6
Association lance.watene@xtra.co.nz
7827-7
Association lance.watene@xtra.co.nz
7827-8
Association lance.watene@xtra.co.nz General C7.2/H6.1 Lighting Delete controls 'Lighting' 6.1.2, 6.1.3, 6.1.4 and retain control 6.1.5 only.
7827-9
Association lance.watene@xtra.co.nz Public Open Space Zones Public Open Space
7827-10
Association lance.watene@xtra.co.nz General Noise and vibration H6.2 Rules
7827-11
Association lance.watene@xtra.co.nz Earthworks H4.2.1.1 Activity table - Zones
7827-12
7827-13
space.
7827-14
Association lance.watene@xtra.co.nz Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
7827-15
Association lance.watene@xtra.co.nz Transport Auckland -wide
7827-16
Association lance.watene@xtra.co.nz Precincts Ak-Wide and Coastal Rowing and Paddling Apply the Rowing and Paddling Precinct to existing facilities that are not currently included.
7828-1 David Scholefield dsko@orcon.net.nz Zoning Central
7828-2 David Scholefield dsko@orcon.net.nz Residential zones Residential
General
7828-3 David Scholefield dsko@orcon.net.nz Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
Special info. req.
General
742/1145
Sub#/
requirements
parking demand.
requirements
7828-8 David Scholefield dsko@orcon.net.nz Transport Auckland -wide C1.2 Objectives
requirements
7829-1 Elvon Young elvonyoung@gmail.com Transport Auckland -wide C1.2 Objectives
7829-2 Elvon Young elvonyoung@gmail.com Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
7830-1 Jenny Granville jenny.j.granville@gmail.com Zoning Central
7830-2 Jenny Granville jenny.j.granville@gmail.com Residential zones Residential
General
7830-3 Jenny Granville jenny.j.granville@gmail.com Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
Special info. req.
General
requirements
parking demand.
requirements
7830-8 Jenny Granville jenny.j.granville@gmail.com Transport Auckland -wide C1.2 Objectives
requirements
7831-1 Iona and Toby Russell ionarussell@gmail.com Transport Auckland -wide C1.2 Objectives
7831-2 Iona and Toby Russell ionarussell@gmail.com Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
7832-1 Barbara S Cox b-cox@ihug.co.nz Zoning North and Islands
7833-1 Sandra Stockwell sandrastockwell33@gmail.com Zoning Central
743/1145
Sub#/
7833-2 Sandra Stockwell sandrastockwell33@gmail.com Residential zones Residential
General
7833-3 Sandra Stockwell sandrastockwell33@gmail.com Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
Special info. req.
General
requirements
parking demand.
requirements
7833-8 Sandra Stockwell sandrastockwell33@gmail.com Transport Auckland -wide C1.2 Objectives
requirements
7834-1 Carole Curtis carole@legaleagle.co.nz Zoning Central
7834-2 Carole Curtis carole@legaleagle.co.nz Residential zones Residential
General
7834-3 Carole Curtis carole@legaleagle.co.nz Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
Special info. req.
General
requirements
parking demand.
requirements
7834-8 Carole Curtis carole@legaleagle.co.nz Transport Auckland -wide C1.2 Objectives
requirements
744/1145
Sub#/
7835-1 Auckland Badminton john@auckbad.co.nz Public Open Space Zones Public Open Space D2 Introduction
7835-2 Auckland Badminton john@auckbad.co.nz Public Open Space Zones
D2.3 Sport & Active
pols
community's needs.
D2.3 Sport & Active
pols
obs & pols
place.
7835-6 Auckland Badminton john@auckbad.co.nz
7835-7 Auckland Badminton john@auckbad.co.nz
7835-8 Auckland Badminton john@auckbad.co.nz General C7.2/H6.1 Lighting Delete controls 'Lighting' 6.1.2, 6.1.3, 6.1.4 and retain control 6.1.5 only.
7835-9 Auckland Badminton john@auckbad.co.nz Public Open Space Zones Public Open Space
7835-10 Auckland Badminton john@auckbad.co.nz General Noise and vibration H6.2 Rules
7835-11 Auckland Badminton john@auckbad.co.nz Earthworks H4.2.1.1 Activity table - Zones
space.
7835-14 Auckland Badminton john@auckbad.co.nz Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
7835-15 Auckland Badminton john@auckbad.co.nz Transport Auckland -wide
7835-16 Auckland Badminton john@auckbad.co.nz Precincts Ak-Wide and Coastal Rowing and Paddling Apply the Rowing and Paddling Precinct to existing facilities that are not currently included.
7836-1 Doreen Arapai doreen.arapai@gmail.com Zoning Central
7836-2 Doreen Arapai doreen.arapai@gmail.com Residential zones Residential
General
7836-3 Doreen Arapai doreen.arapai@gmail.com Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
Special info. req.
745/1145
Sub#/
General
requirements
parking demand.
requirements
7836-8 Doreen Arapai doreen.arapai@gmail.com Transport Auckland -wide C1.2 Objectives
requirements
7837-1 Jack F G Hall jackfhall@gmail.com Zoning Central
7837-2 Jack F G Hall jackfhall@gmail.com Residential zones Residential
General
7837-3 Jack F G Hall jackfhall@gmail.com Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
Special info. req.
General
requirements
parking demand.
requirements
7837-8 Jack F G Hall jackfhall@gmail.com Transport Auckland -wide C1.2 Objectives
requirements
7838-1 Kenneth C Cox
c/- Northland Town Planners, Attn:
Pete Sinton, 188 Oraha Road, RD2,
Kumeu, Auckland 0892 Zoning North and Islands
7839-1 Amelia Wong amelia.w.wong@gmail.com Zoning Central
7839-2 Amelia Wong amelia.w.wong@gmail.com Residential zones Residential
General
7839-3 Amelia Wong amelia.w.wong@gmail.com Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
746/1145
Sub#/
Special info. req.
General
requirements
parking demand.
requirements
7839-8 Amelia Wong amelia.w.wong@gmail.com Transport Auckland -wide C1.2 Objectives
requirements
7840-1 Arnette M Arapai arnette.arapai@gmail.com Zoning Central
7840-2 Arnette M Arapai arnette.arapai@gmail.com Residential zones Residential
General
7840-3 Arnette M Arapai arnette.arapai@gmail.com Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
Special info. req.
General
requirements
parking demand.
requirements
7840-8 Arnette M Arapai arnette.arapai@gmail.com Transport Auckland -wide C1.2 Objectives
requirements
7841-1 Wen-Pei Chen wenpeichen@gmail.com Zoning Central
7841-2 Wen-Pei Chen wenpeichen@gmail.com Residential zones Residential
General
747/1145
Sub#/
7841-3 Wen-Pei Chen wenpeichen@gmail.com Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
Special info. req.
General
requirements
parking demand.
requirements
7841-8 Wen-Pei Chen wenpeichen@gmail.com Transport Auckland -wide C1.2 Objectives
requirements
7842-1 Erika Rodriguez erika01.genesis@gmail.com Transport Auckland -wide C1.2 Objectives
7842-2 Erika Rodriguez erika01.genesis@gmail.com Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
7843-1 Carl Presant carlpresant@gmail.com Transport Auckland -wide C1.2 Objectives
7843-2 Carl Presant carlpresant@gmail.com Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
7844-1 Andrew Cox b-cox@ihug.co.nz Zoning North and Islands
7845-1 Darren and Michelle Bound darrenb@xtra.co.nz Zoning North and Islands
7846-1 Leon Downey leondowney@gmail.com Transport Auckland -wide C1.2 Objectives
7846-2 Leon Downey leondowney@gmail.com Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
7847-1 Helen Vernon hmv@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central
7847-2 Helen Vernon hmv@xtra.co.nz Residential zones Residential
General
7847-3 Helen Vernon hmv@xtra.co.nz Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
748/1145
Sub#/
Special info. req.
General
requirements
parking demand.
requirements
7848-1 Eva Smaill selemr@gmail.com Transport Auckland -wide C1.2 Objectives
7848-2 Eva Smaill selemr@gmail.com Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
7849-1 Johannes Berweiler jberweiler@orcon.net.nz Zoning North and Islands
7850-1 Marsha L Chase marsha.chase.nz@gmail.com Zoning North and Islands
7851-1 Patrick O'Reilly
45A Anglesea Street, Freemans Bay,
7851-2 Patrick O'Reilly
45A Anglesea Street, Freemans Bay,
requirements
7852-1
New Zealand Rugby Union
Incorporated jason.chin@nzrugby.co.nz Public Open Space Zones Public Open Space D2 Introduction
7852-2
Incorporated jason.chin@nzrugby.co.nz Public Open Space Zones
D2.3 Sport & Active
pols
community's needs.
7852-3
D2.3 Sport & Active
pols
7852-4
obs & pols
place.
7852-5
7852-6
Incorporated jason.chin@nzrugby.co.nz
7852-7
Incorporated jason.chin@nzrugby.co.nz
7852-8
Incorporated jason.chin@nzrugby.co.nz General C7.2/H6.1 Lighting Delete controls 'Lighting' 6.1.2, 6.1.3, 6.1.4 and retain control 6.1.5 only.
7852-9
Incorporated jason.chin@nzrugby.co.nz Public Open Space Zones Public Open Space
749/1145
Sub#/
7852-10
Incorporated jason.chin@nzrugby.co.nz General Noise and vibration H6.2 Rules
7852-11
Incorporated jason.chin@nzrugby.co.nz Earthworks H4.2.1.1 Activity table - Zones
7852-12
7852-13
space.
7852-14
Incorporated jason.chin@nzrugby.co.nz Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
7852-15
Incorporated jason.chin@nzrugby.co.nz Precincts Ak-Wide and Coastal Rowing and Paddling Apply the Rowing and Paddling Precinct to existing facilities that are not currently included.
7852-16
Incorporated jason.chin@nzrugby.co.nz Precincts Ak-Wide and Coastal Stadiums and Showgrounds K1.10 Precinct Rules
Confirm whether the noise level measurement protocols for all stadiums and showgrounds
include spectator noise
7853-1 Garsing Wong akcentralmedical@gmail.com Zoning Central
7853-2 Garsing Wong akcentralmedical@gmail.com Residential zones Residential
General
7853-3 Garsing Wong akcentralmedical@gmail.com Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
Special info. req.
General
requirements
parking demand.
requirements
7853-8 Garsing Wong akcentralmedical@gmail.com Transport Auckland -wide C1.2 Objectives
requirements
7854-1 Benjamin Smaill ben.smaill@gmail.com Transport Auckland -wide C1.2 Objectives
7854-2 Benjamin Smaill ben.smaill@gmail.com Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
7855-1 James M Batley markb@xtra.co.nz Zoning North and Islands
750/1145
Sub#/
7856-1 Paul Rosenberg
40 Anglesea Street, Freemans Bay,
7856-2 Paul Rosenberg
40 Anglesea Street, Freemans Bay,
requirements
7857-1 Auckland Rugby Union andy.dalton@aucklandrugby.co.nz Public Open Space Zones Public Open Space D2 Introduction
7857-2 Auckland Rugby Union andy.dalton@aucklandrugby.co.nz Public Open Space Zones
D2.3 Sport & Active
pols
community's needs.
D2.3 Sport & Active
pols
obs & pols
place.
Retain the principle of including generic activity and development controls for the Major
Recreation Facility zone
Amend the activities permitted to make them more permissive and reduce the operational
limitations on venues like Eden Park holding sporting and entertainment events
Delete the thresholds for ancillary activities. Restrictions are more appropriately addressed in
the precinct and sub-precinct provisions
7857-8 Auckland Rugby Union andy.dalton@aucklandrugby.co.nz Precincts Ak-Wide and Coastal Stadiums and Showgrounds K1.10 Precinct Rules
Amend the activity status [in land use control 2.1 Noise] for infringement of the noise controls
in the Eden Park, North Harbour Stadium, North Shore Events Centre, Trusts Stadium, and
Western Springs sub-precincts from non-complying to restricted discretionary
I18.2-3 Land use &
Delete [land use control 2.2 Licensed premises] that limits the location of any licensed
premises to within the main structure of the Major Recreation Facility, and require its
operation to be associated with the primary function of the facility
I18.2-3 Land use &
Amend [land use control 2.3 Traffic] by increasing the threshold at which traffic management
measures are required for Eden Park from an anticipated crowd capacity of 10,000 to 24,000
I18.2-3 Land use &
Delete [from development control 3.5 Screening] the requirement that outdoor storage and
rubbish collection areas be screened by a solid wall or fence of at least 1.8m high. Allow
screening by vegetation.
Special information
requirements
Amend assessment criteria as required as a result of amendments sought in the submission
to activity and development controls.
Retain the inclusion of specific precinct and sub-precinct land use and development controls
for Eden Park.
Retain the inclusion of open space within the Eden Park sub-precinct supporting the
maintenance of a second rugby playing field on the No 2 ground
7857-15 Auckland Rugby Union andy.dalton@aucklandrugby.co.nz
7857-16 Auckland Rugby Union andy.dalton@aucklandrugby.co.nz
7857-17 Auckland Rugby Union andy.dalton@aucklandrugby.co.nz General C7.2/H6.1 Lighting Delete controls 'Lighting' 6.1.2, 6.1.3, 6.1.4 and retain control 6.1.5 only.
7857-18 Auckland Rugby Union andy.dalton@aucklandrugby.co.nz Public Open Space Zones Public Open Space
7857-19 Auckland Rugby Union andy.dalton@aucklandrugby.co.nz General Noise and vibration H6.2 Rules
of lighting controls as follows: 6.00-11.00pm Monday to Sunday and Public Holidays - 60dB
(LAeq) / 55dB at all other times, and delete reference to 15 minute periods
7857-20 Auckland Rugby Union andy.dalton@aucklandrugby.co.nz Earthworks H4.2.1.1 Activity table - Zones
751/1145
Sub#/
space.
7857-23 Auckland Rugby Union andy.dalton@aucklandrugby.co.nz Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
manage/own facilities on public open spaces
7857-24 Auckland Rugby Union andy.dalton@aucklandrugby.co.nz Transport Auckland -wide
7858-1 Kate Bell kateelizabethbell@gmail.com Transport Auckland -wide C1.2 Objectives
7858-2 Kate Bell kateelizabethbell@gmail.com Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
7859-1 Nichole Cameron
General
requirements
Special info. req.
General
requirements
parking demand.
requirements
requirements
7860-1 Ross and Debra Barnett rjdabarnett@xtra.co.nz Zoning North and Islands
7861-1 Hayder Kubba and Rula Alatia
7862-1 Sport New Zealand paula.ryan@sportnz.org.nz Public Open Space Zones Public Open Space D2 Introduction
7862-2 Sport New Zealand paula.ryan@sportnz.org.nz Public Open Space Zones
D2.3 Sport & Active
pols
community's needs.
D2.3 Sport & Active
pols
752/1145
Sub#/
obs & pols
place.
7862-6 Sport New Zealand paula.ryan@sportnz.org.nz
7862-7 Sport New Zealand paula.ryan@sportnz.org.nz
7862-8 Sport New Zealand paula.ryan@sportnz.org.nz General C7.2/H6.1 Lighting Delete controls 'Lighting' 6.1.2, 6.1.3, 6.1.4 and retain control 6.1.5 only.
7862-9 Sport New Zealand paula.ryan@sportnz.org.nz Public Open Space Zones Public Open Space
7862-10 Sport New Zealand paula.ryan@sportnz.org.nz General Noise and vibration H6.2 Rules
7862-11 Sport New Zealand paula.ryan@sportnz.org.nz Earthworks H4.2.1.1 Activity table - Zones
space.
7862-14 Sport New Zealand paula.ryan@sportnz.org.nz Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
7862-15 Sport New Zealand paula.ryan@sportnz.org.nz Transport Auckland -wide
7862-16 Sport New Zealand paula.ryan@sportnz.org.nz Precincts Ak-Wide and Coastal Rowing and Paddling Apply the Rowing and Paddling Precinct to existing facilities that are not currently included.
7863-1 Erica M Brash ericamb027@gmail.com Zoning North and Islands
7864-1 Ryan Sclanders ryansclanders@hotmail.com Zoning North and Islands
7865-1 Pukekohe Lawn Tennis Club t.roberts@orcon.net.nz General C7.2/H6.1 Lighting Delete controls 'Lighting' 6.1.2, 6.1.3, 6.1.4 and retain control 6.1.5 only.
7865-2 Pukekohe Lawn Tennis Club t.roberts@orcon.net.nz Public Open Space Zones Public Open Space
7866-1 Philip D and Linda J Kerr philipkerr@xtra.co.nz Zoning North and Islands
7867-1 Gary Wheeler ryga@xtra.co.nz Zoning North and Islands
7868-1 Cockle Bay Tennis Club admin@cocklebaytennis.co.nz Public Open Space Zones Public Open Space D2 Introduction
7868-2 Cockle Bay Tennis Club admin@cocklebaytennis.co.nz Public Open Space Zones
D2.3 Sport & Active
pols
community's needs.
D2.3 Sport & Active
pols
753/1145
Sub#/
obs & pols
place.
7868-6 Cockle Bay Tennis Club admin@cocklebaytennis.co.nz
7868-7 Cockle Bay Tennis Club admin@cocklebaytennis.co.nz
7868-8 Cockle Bay Tennis Club admin@cocklebaytennis.co.nz General C7.2/H6.1 Lighting Delete controls 'Lighting' 6.1.2, 6.1.3, 6.1.4 and retain control 6.1.5 only.
7868-9 Cockle Bay Tennis Club admin@cocklebaytennis.co.nz Public Open Space Zones Public Open Space
7868-10 Cockle Bay Tennis Club admin@cocklebaytennis.co.nz General Noise and vibration H6.2 Rules
7868-11 Cockle Bay Tennis Club admin@cocklebaytennis.co.nz Earthworks H4.2.1.1 Activity table - Zones
space.
7868-14 Cockle Bay Tennis Club admin@cocklebaytennis.co.nz Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
7868-15 Cockle Bay Tennis Club admin@cocklebaytennis.co.nz Transport Auckland -wide
7868-16 Cockle Bay Tennis Club admin@cocklebaytennis.co.nz Precincts Ak-Wide and Coastal Rowing and Paddling Apply the Rowing and Paddling Precinct to existing facilities that are not currently included.
7869-1 John and Janene Barnfield
7870-1 Rini Rosinah
7871-1
High School Old Boys Soccer
Club cabooth@clear.net.nz Public Open Space Zones Public Open Space D2 Introduction
7871-2
Club cabooth@clear.net.nz Public Open Space Zones
D2.3 Sport & Active
pols
community's needs.
7871-3
D2.3 Sport & Active
pols
7871-4
obs & pols
place.
7871-5
7871-6
Club cabooth@clear.net.nz
7871-7
Club cabooth@clear.net.nz
7871-8
Club cabooth@clear.net.nz General C7.2/H6.1 Lighting Delete controls 'Lighting' 6.1.2, 6.1.3, 6.1.4 and retain control 6.1.5 only.
754/1145
Sub#/
7871-9
Club cabooth@clear.net.nz Public Open Space Zones Public Open Space
7871-10
Club cabooth@clear.net.nz General Noise and vibration H6.2 Rules
7871-11
Club cabooth@clear.net.nz Earthworks H4.2.1.1 Activity table - Zones
7871-12
7871-13
space.
7871-14
Club cabooth@clear.net.nz Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
7871-15
Club cabooth@clear.net.nz Transport Auckland -wide
7872-1 W M Prentice bill@prentice.net.nz Zoning North and Islands
7873-1 Soesanto Widjaja
7874-1 Parnell Lawn Tennis Club pltc@xtra.co.nz Public Open Space Zones Public Open Space D2 Introduction
7874-2 Parnell Lawn Tennis Club pltc@xtra.co.nz Public Open Space Zones
D2.3 Sport & Active
pols
community's needs.
D2.3 Sport & Active
pols
obs & pols
place.
7874-6 Parnell Lawn Tennis Club pltc@xtra.co.nz
7874-7 Parnell Lawn Tennis Club pltc@xtra.co.nz
7874-8 Parnell Lawn Tennis Club pltc@xtra.co.nz General C7.2/H6.1 Lighting Delete controls 'Lighting' 6.1.2, 6.1.3, 6.1.4 and retain control 6.1.5 only.
7874-9 Parnell Lawn Tennis Club pltc@xtra.co.nz Public Open Space Zones Public Open Space
7874-10 Parnell Lawn Tennis Club pltc@xtra.co.nz General Noise and vibration H6.2 Rules
7874-11 Parnell Lawn Tennis Club pltc@xtra.co.nz Earthworks H4.2.1.1 Activity table - Zones
755/1145
Sub#/
space.
7874-14 Parnell Lawn Tennis Club pltc@xtra.co.nz Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
7874-15 Parnell Lawn Tennis Club pltc@xtra.co.nz Transport Auckland -wide
7875-1 Libing Zhang zlb0315@hotmail.com Zoning North and Islands
7876-1 Eden J Hall ednennz@icloud.com Zoning North and Islands
7877-1 Mark D and Jodie Nielsen thenielsens@orcon.net.nz Zoning North and Islands
7878-1 Elena O Pavlova
7879-1 Vladimir V Kozlov
7880-1 Joseph N Cundy
7881-1 Jan Blatch janisblatch@hotmail.com Zoning Central
7881-2 Jan Blatch janisblatch@hotmail.com Residential zones Residential
General
7881-3 Jan Blatch janisblatch@hotmail.com Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
Special info. req.
General
requirements
parking demand.
requirements
7881-8 Jan Blatch janisblatch@hotmail.com Transport Auckland -wide C1.2 Objectives
requirements
756/1145
Sub#/
7882-1 Shirley A Cundy
7883-1
Dennis Grant and Sheila A
Cunningham cunningham@clear.net.nz Zoning North and Islands
7884-1 Yue Hu haiyueivy@hotmail.com Zoning Central
7884-2 Yue Hu haiyueivy@hotmail.com Residential zones Residential
General
7884-3 Yue Hu haiyueivy@hotmail.com Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
Special info. req.
General
requirements
parking demand.
requirements
7884-8 Yue Hu haiyueivy@hotmail.com Transport Auckland -wide C1.2 Objectives
requirements
7885-1 Albert R Bedwell
7886-1 Maureen Power rmpower@clear.net.nz Zoning North and Islands
7887-1 Nick Hearn nick@nickhearn.com Zoning Central
7887-2 Nick Hearn nick@nickhearn.com Residential zones Residential
General
7887-3 Nick Hearn nick@nickhearn.com Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
Special info. req.
757/1145
Sub#/
General
requirements
parking demand.
requirements
7887-8 Nick Hearn nick@nickhearn.com Transport Auckland -wide C1.2 Objectives
requirements
7888-1 Mark and Sarah Johnson markjo606@gmail.com Zoning North and Islands
7889-1 Carleen A Blucher robertblucher@hotmail.com Zoning Central
7889-2 Carleen A Blucher robertblucher@hotmail.com Residential zones Residential
General
7889-3 Carleen A Blucher robertblucher@hotmail.com Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
Special info. req.
General
requirements
parking demand.
requirements
7889-8 Carleen A Blucher robertblucher@hotmail.com Transport Auckland -wide C1.2 Objectives
requirements
7890-1 Simone Jackson moni.jackson@hotmail.com Zoning North and Islands
7891-1 Alan and Samantha Marinus marinusnz@clear.net.nz Zoning North and Islands
7892-1 Grey Seagar grey@englandchambers.co.nz Zoning Central
758/1145
Sub#/
7892-2 Grey Seagar grey@englandchambers.co.nz Residential zones Residential
General
7892-3 Grey Seagar grey@englandchambers.co.nz Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
Special info. req.
General
requirements
parking demand.
requirements
7892-8 Grey Seagar grey@englandchambers.co.nz Transport Auckland -wide C1.2 Objectives
requirements
7893-1 Peter G Aspden
7894-1 Michael J Milham
7895-1 Julia Seagar julia@englandchambers.co.nz Zoning Central
7895-2 Julia Seagar julia@englandchambers.co.nz Residential zones Residential
General
7895-3 Julia Seagar julia@englandchambers.co.nz Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
Special info. req.
General
requirements
parking demand.
requirements
759/1145
Sub#/
7895-8 Julia Seagar julia@englandchambers.co.nz Transport Auckland -wide C1.2 Objectives
requirements
7896-1 Waka and Carol Donnelly
7897-1 Cynthia Simalai
General
requirements
Special info. req.
General
requirements
parking demand.
requirements
requirements
7898-1 Alan R and Barbara Sullivan alanbarb@orcon.net.nz Zoning North and Islands
7899-1 Penelope Saxton-Beer pennysaxbe@gmail.com Zoning Central
7899-2 Penelope Saxton-Beer pennysaxbe@gmail.com Residential zones Residential
General
7899-3 Penelope Saxton-Beer pennysaxbe@gmail.com Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
Special info. req.
760/1145
Sub#/
General
requirements
parking demand.
requirements
7899-8 Penelope Saxton-Beer pennysaxbe@gmail.com Transport Auckland -wide C1.2 Objectives
requirements
7900-1
Glennis Matthews and Robert
Otter
7901-1 Douglas Drury doug@velocitymadegood.co.nz Zoning Central
7901-2 Douglas Drury doug@velocitymadegood.co.nz Residential zones Residential
General
7901-3 Douglas Drury doug@velocitymadegood.co.nz Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
Special info. req.
General
requirements
parking demand.
requirements
7901-8 Douglas Drury doug@velocitymadegood.co.nz Transport Auckland -wide C1.2 Objectives
requirements
7902-1 D G Dillman dgdillz@gmail.com Zoning Central
7902-2 D G Dillman dgdillz@gmail.com Residential zones Residential
General
7902-3 D G Dillman dgdillz@gmail.com Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
761/1145
Sub#/
Special info. req.
General
requirements
parking demand.
requirements
7902-8 D G Dillman dgdillz@gmail.com Transport Auckland -wide C1.2 Objectives
requirements
7903-1
Murray R and Meriel C
Johansen mjohansen@paradise.net.nz Zoning North and Islands
7904-1 Karen Hatton karenhattor@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central
7904-2 Karen Hatton karenhattor@xtra.co.nz Residential zones Residential
General
7904-3 Karen Hatton karenhattor@xtra.co.nz Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
Special info. req.
General
requirements
parking demand.
requirements
7904-8 Karen Hatton karenhattor@xtra.co.nz Transport Auckland -wide C1.2 Objectives
requirements
7905-1 Matewiki Karehana matewikikarehana@hotmail.com Zoning Central
762/1145
Sub#/
7905-2 Matewiki Karehana matewikikarehana@hotmail.com Residential zones Residential
General
7905-3 Matewiki Karehana matewikikarehana@hotmail.com Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
Special info. req.
General
requirements
parking demand.
requirements
7905-8 Matewiki Karehana matewikikarehana@hotmail.com Transport Auckland -wide C1.2 Objectives
requirements
7906-1 Andrea Harker pufftrouble@hotmail.com Zoning North and Islands
7907-1 Mitchell L Shelford
18 Ireland Street, Freemans Bay,
Rezone the land at 16 Spring Street, Freemans Bay from Terraced Housing and Apartment
Building to a zone which transitions between Special Character Overlay sites and more
intensive development.
7907-2 Mitchell L Shelford
18 Ireland Street, Freemans Bay,
requirements
7908-1 Alison Hunter
General
requirements
Special info. req.
General
requirements
parking demand.
763/1145
Sub#/
requirements
requirements
7909-1 Linda Stent
7910-1 Evangelia Papoutsaki epapoutsaki@unitec.ac.nz Zoning Central
7910-2 Evangelia Papoutsaki epapoutsaki@unitec.ac.nz Residential zones Residential
General
7910-3 Evangelia Papoutsaki epapoutsaki@unitec.ac.nz Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
Special info. req.
General
requirements
parking demand.
requirements
7910-8 Evangelia Papoutsaki epapoutsaki@unitec.ac.nz Transport Auckland -wide C1.2 Objectives
requirements
7911-1 Graham Dickie grahamdickie05@gmail.com Zoning Central
7911-2 Graham Dickie grahamdickie05@gmail.com Residential zones Residential
General
7911-3 Graham Dickie grahamdickie05@gmail.com Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
Special info. req.
764/1145
Sub#/
General
requirements
parking demand.
requirements
7911-8 Graham Dickie grahamdickie05@gmail.com Transport Auckland -wide C1.2 Objectives
requirements
7912-1 Alexander Zubov azuboff@ihug.co.nz Zoning North and Islands
7913-1 Christopher Cardwell delaney.cardwell@vodafone.co.nz Zoning Central
7913-2 Christopher Cardwell delaney.cardwell@vodafone.co.nz Residential zones Residential
General
7913-3 Christopher Cardwell delaney.cardwell@vodafone.co.nz Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
Special info. req.
General
requirements
parking demand.
requirements
7914-1 Louise J McLean lou_j_mc@hotmail.com Zoning Central
7914-2 Louise J McLean lou_j_mc@hotmail.com Residential zones Residential
General
7914-3 Louise J McLean lou_j_mc@hotmail.com Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
Special info. req.
765/1145
Sub#/
General
requirements
parking demand.
requirements
7914-8 Louise J McLean lou_j_mc@hotmail.com Transport Auckland -wide C1.2 Objectives
7915-1 Rose Zubova rosez@ihug.co.nz Zoning North and Islands
7916-1 Powney Family Trust paul.powney@orcon.net.nz Zoning North and Islands
7917-1 John S Robertson john.robertson@slingshot.co.nz Zoning North and Islands
7918-1 Deborah Reed debsreed73@gmail.com Zoning North and Islands
7919-1 Annette Gault annette.gault@hp.com Zoning North and Islands
7920-1 Grant and Lynette Masters mastersl.g@ihug.co.nz Zoning North and Islands
7921-1 Steele Family Trust steele_family@xtra.co.nz Zoning North and Islands
7922-1 Barbara D Watson
7923-1 Janice D Albert albejan@gmail.com Zoning North and Islands
7924-1 Ronald Bol
7925-1 Kate S Rhee katesrhee@hotmail.com Zoning North and Islands
7926-1 Christine M Sherwood derickandchrissy@xtra.co.nz Zoning North and Islands
7927-1 Craig Sentch craig.sentch@gen-i.co.nz Zoning North and Islands
7928-1 David A and Beverly A Tripp tripps@xtra.co.nz Zoning North and Islands
7929-1
John C and Elizabeth A
O'Leary
Peter Sinton, 188 Oraha Road, RD2,
7930-1 James M Kelly
7931-1 Rachel Jamieson rachel_karl@xtra.co.nz Zoning North and Islands
766/1145
Sub#/
7932-1 Rachel Padfield rachel.padfield@me.com Zoning North and Islands
7933-1 Mark S and Nikola B Brent markandkola@vodafone.co.nz Special Character
General
7933-2 Mark S and Nikola B Brent markandkola@vodafone.co.nz Zoning Central Retain the Single Housing zone applying to Balmoral streets
7933-3 Mark S and Nikola B Brent markandkola@vodafone.co.nz Residential zones Residential
7933-4 Mark S and Nikola B Brent markandkola@vodafone.co.nz
control
7934-1 Brenda R Nicholson blenda2@xtra.co.nz Zoning North and Islands
7935-1 Leonard Nicholson blenda2@xtra.co.nz Zoning North and Islands
7936-1 Vanita and Sham Hurbuns hurbuns@gmail.com Zoning North and Islands
7937-1 Andrew and Donna Robbie
7938-1 Michael Lloyd barbaralloydtravel@gmail.com Zoning North and Islands
7939-1 Peter C Fong petercfong@hotmail.com Special Character
General
7939-2 Peter C Fong petercfong@hotmail.com Zoning Central Retain the Single Housing zone applying to Balmoral streets
7939-3 Peter C Fong petercfong@hotmail.com Residential zones Residential
7939-4 Peter C Fong petercfong@hotmail.com
control
7940-1 Barbara Lloyd barbaralloydtravel@gmail.com Zoning North and Islands
7941-1 Robert Gibbs robandsue.gibbs@xtra.co.nz Zoning North and Islands
7942-1 John G Charles
72 Peary Road, Mount Eden,
General
Auckland 1024 Zoning Central Retain the Single Housing zone applying to Balmoral streets
Auckland 1024
control
7943-1 Phillip V Hope-Ede normahopeede@xtra.co.nz Zoning North and Islands
7944-1 Daniel Metcalfe dmetcalfenz@gmail.com Special Character
General
7944-2 Daniel Metcalfe dmetcalfenz@gmail.com Zoning Central Retain the Single Housing zone applying to Balmoral streets
767/1145
Sub#/
7944-3 Daniel Metcalfe dmetcalfenz@gmail.com Residential zones Residential
7944-4 Daniel Metcalfe dmetcalfenz@gmail.com
control
7945-1 Norma Hope-Ede normahopeede@xtra.co.nz Zoning North and Islands
7946-1 Kate Davey kate.kiwi.davey@xtra.co.nz Zoning North and Islands
7947-1 Edwin J Fernie
7948-1 Caron P O'Grady c.ogrady@barfoot.co.nz Special Character
General
7948-2 Caron P O'Grady c.ogrady@barfoot.co.nz Zoning Central Retain the Single Housing zone applying to Balmoral streets
7948-3 Caron P O'Grady c.ogrady@barfoot.co.nz Residential zones Residential
7948-4 Caron P O'Grady c.ogrady@barfoot.co.nz
control
7949-1 James and Lynnette Campbell cam5859@gmail.com Zoning North and Islands
7950-1 Don Puton
84 Peary Road, Mount Albert,
General
7950-2 Don Puton
7950-3 Don Puton
7950-4 Don Puton
Auckland 1024
control
7951-1 Seungran Park linktravel@hotmail.com Special Character
General
7951-2 Seungran Park linktravel@hotmail.com Zoning Central Retain the Single Housing zone applying to Balmoral streets
7951-3 Seungran Park linktravel@hotmail.com Residential zones Residential
7951-4 Seungran Park linktravel@hotmail.com
control
7952-1 Sandra Hart houseofharts@xtra.co.nz Special Character
General
7952-2 Sandra Hart houseofharts@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central Retain the Single Housing zone applying to Balmoral streets
7952-3 Sandra Hart houseofharts@xtra.co.nz Residential zones Residential
7952-4 Sandra Hart houseofharts@xtra.co.nz
control
7953-1 Janet T Watt
General
7953-2 Janet T Watt
768/1145
Sub#/
7953-3 Janet T Watt
7953-4 Janet T Watt
Auckland 1024
control
7954-1 Murray D Watt
General
Auckland 1024
control
7955-1 Robert Berry robvalberry@xtra.co.nz Special Character
General
7955-2 Robert Berry robvalberry@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central Retain the Single Housing zone applying to Balmoral streets
7955-3 Robert Berry robvalberry@xtra.co.nz Residential zones Residential
7955-4 Robert Berry robvalberry@xtra.co.nz
control
7956-1 Lisa Chapman lisachapman@ihug.co.nz Residential zones Residential
General
7956-2 Lisa Chapman lisachapman@ihug.co.nz Special Character
General
7956-3 Lisa Chapman lisachapman@ihug.co.nz Zoning Central
House
7956-4 Lisa Chapman lisachapman@ihug.co.nz
control
7957-1 Lucille Peters tim.luce@xtra.co.nz Residential zones Residential
Retain Rule 6.2, applying a two storey 8m height limit in the Single House zone, with particular
reference to Balmoral
7957-2 Lucille Peters tim.luce@xtra.co.nz Special Character
General
Apply a Special Character Overlay to Manatu St and surrounding streets in the northern end
of Balmoral
7957-3 Lucille Peters tim.luce@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central
Rezone Manatu St and surrounding streets at the northern end of Balmoral, from Mixed
Housing Suburban to Single House
7957-4 Lucille Peters tim.luce@xtra.co.nz
control
7958-1 Nikki Flexman nikki.flexman@gmail.com Residential zones Residential
Retain Rule 6.2, applying a two storey 8m height limit in the Single House zone, with particular
reference to Balmoral
7958-2 Nikki Flexman nikki.flexman@gmail.com Special Character
General
Apply a Special Character Overlay to Tenderden Ave and surrounding streets in the northern
end of Balmoral
7958-3 Nikki Flexman nikki.flexman@gmail.com Zoning Central
Rezone Tenderden Ave and surrounding streets at the northern end of Balmoral, from Mixed
Housing Suburban to Single House
7958-4 Nikki Flexman nikki.flexman@gmail.com
control
7959-1 Tony Dillon tony.dillon@xtra.co.nz Special Character
General
7959-2 Tony Dillon tony.dillon@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central Retain the Single Housing zone applying to Balmoral streets
769/1145
Sub#/
7959-3 Tony Dillon tony.dillon@xtra.co.nz Residential zones Residential
7959-4 Tony Dillon tony.dillon@xtra.co.nz
control
7960-1 Julie M Colquhoun julie.wayne@xtra.co.nz Special Character
General
7960-2 Julie M Colquhoun julie.wayne@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central Retain the Single Housing zone applying to Balmoral streets
7960-3 Julie M Colquhoun julie.wayne@xtra.co.nz Residential zones Residential
7960-4 Julie M Colquhoun julie.wayne@xtra.co.nz
control
7961-1 Pamela J Bathgate pamjb@xtra.co.nz Special Character
General
7961-2 Pamela J Bathgate pamjb@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central Retain the Single Housing zone applying to Balmoral streets
7961-3 Pamela J Bathgate pamjb@xtra.co.nz Residential zones Residential
7961-4 Pamela J Bathgate pamjb@xtra.co.nz
control
7962-1 Amanda J Stewart amandaandgeoff@gmail.com Special Character
General
7962-2 Amanda J Stewart amandaandgeoff@gmail.com Zoning Central Retain the Single Housing zone applying to Balmoral streets
7962-3 Amanda J Stewart amandaandgeoff@gmail.com Residential zones Residential
7962-4 Amanda J Stewart amandaandgeoff@gmail.com
control
7963-1 Colin and Philippa MacDonald col.pip.macdonald@xtra.co.nz Special Character
General
7963-2 Colin and Philippa MacDonald col.pip.macdonald@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central Retain the Single Housing zone applying to Balmoral streets
7963-3 Colin and Philippa MacDonald col.pip.macdonald@xtra.co.nz Residential zones Residential
7963-4 Colin and Philippa MacDonald col.pip.macdonald@xtra.co.nz
control
7964-1 Mark Gander gandermark@gmail.com Special Character
General
7964-2 Mark Gander gandermark@gmail.com Zoning Central Retain the Single Housing zone applying to Balmoral streets
7964-3 Mark Gander gandermark@gmail.com Residential zones Residential
7964-4 Mark Gander gandermark@gmail.com
control
7965-1 Kerry and Glenis Claydon k.g.claydon@xtra.co.nz Special Character
General
7965-2 Kerry and Glenis Claydon k.g.claydon@xtra.co.nz Zoning Central Retain the Single Housing zone applying to Balmoral streets
7965-3 Kerry and Glenis Claydon k.g.claydon@xtra.co.nz Residential zones Residential
770/1145
Sub#/
7965-4 Kerry and Glenis Claydon k.g.claydon@xtra.co.nz
control
7966-1 Michael Taler mtaler@orcon.net.nz Special Character
General
7966-2 Michael Taler mtaler@orcon.net.nz Zoning Central Retain the Single Housing zone applying to Balmoral streets
7966-3 Michael Taler mtaler@orcon.net.nz Residential zones Residential
7966-4 Michael Taler mtaler@orcon.net.nz
control
7967-1 Hannah Stanley hannahstan@gmail.com Transport Auckland -wide C1.2 Objectives
7967-2 Hannah Stanley hannahstan@gmail.com Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
7968-1 Sara Bowie sarabeara@hotmail.com Transport Auckland -wide C1.2 Objectives
7968-2 Sara Bowie sarabeara@hotmail.com Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
7969-1 Squash Auckland Incorporated
generalmanager@squashauckland.o
rg.nz Public Open Space Zones Public Open Space D2 Introduction
D2.3 Sport & Active
pols
community's needs.
D2.3 Sport & Active
pols
obs & pols
place.
rg.nz
rg.nz
rg.nz General C7.2/H6.1 Lighting Delete controls 'Lighting' 6.1.2, 6.1.3, 6.1.4 and retain control 6.1.5 only.
rg.nz Public Open Space Zones Public Open Space
rg.nz General Noise and vibration H6.2 Rules
rg.nz Earthworks H4.2.1.1 Activity table - Zones
space.
771/1145
Sub#/
rg.nz Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
rg.nz Transport Auckland -wide
7970-1 Matthew D Nichols matt@nzsm.com Transport Auckland -wide C1.2 Objectives
7970-2 Matthew D Nichols matt@nzsm.com Transport Auckland -wide
requirements
7971-1 Auckland Bowls phil@aucklandbowls.co.nz Public Open Space Zones Public Open Space D2 Introduction
7971-2 Auckland Bowls phil@aucklandbowls.co.nz Public Open Space Zones
D2.3 Sport & Active
pols
community's needs.
D2.3 Sport & Active
pols
obs & pols
Retain Policy [1] to provide public ope

Sdrnumorder5883 9425

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

You might also like

Sdrnumorder5883 9425

Uploaded by

Document Information

Original Description:

Original Title

Copyright

Available Formats

Share this document

Share or Embed Document

Sharing Options

Did you find this document useful?

Is this content inappropriate?

Copyright:

Available Formats

Sdrnumorder5883 9425

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

Summary of Decisions Requested in Numerical Submission Order 5883 - 9425

You might also like