Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Thesis Writing
Thesis Writing
Thesis Writing
MarkC.Griffin,DepartmentofAnthropology,SanFranciscoStateUniversity,San
Francisco,California941324155.http://online.sfsu.edu/~mgriffin
Thisguideisdesignedtogiveyouaproceduraloutlineforworkingonyourthesis.Everythesis
projectwillhavespecialconsiderationsthatarenotcoveredhere.Youshouldconsultwith
yourcommitteeearlyandfrequentlytoresolvehowtohandlethesespecialconsiderations.No
onedocumentcancoverallthebases.TherearetwootherexcellentdocumentsontheWeb
thatyoushouldalsoread:
How to Organize Your ThesisbyJohnW.Chinneck,CarletonUniversity
How to Write a Ph.D. ThesisbyJoeWolfe,UniversityofNewSouthWales
WhatistheThesis?
TheculminationoftheM.A.istheMaster'sThesis.Chinneck(How to Organize Your Thesis,
1999)assertsthat"Thedistinguishingmarkofgraduateresearchisanoriginalcontributiontoknowledge.The
thesisisaformaldocumentwhosesolepurposeistoprovethatyouhavemadeanoriginalcontributionto
knowledge.Failuretoprovethatyouhavemadesuchacontributiongenerallyleadstofailure."
TheM.A.thesisisthedemonstrationofyourabilitytoconductoriginalresearchandpresent
thewrittenresults.Itisnotaclassthatyousimplytakeandgetcreditfor.Norisitaglorified
termpaperthatyoucanwaittothe"eleventhhour"tofinish.Yourthesisisaresearchproject
thatyouhavespentconsiderabletimeinpreparatoryresearch(literaturereview),project
design(formulationofahypothesis),datacollection(fieldandorlaboratory),analysis
(statisticalexaminationofthedata),andfinallypresentationandsynthesis(examinationofthe
statisticalresultsinthecontextofyourhypothesisandliteraturereview).Eachofthese
individualpartswillconsumeconsiderabletimeandeffort.
Writing the Thesis pg. 1
HowLongWillitTake?
Chinneck(1999)answersthiswith:"Longerthanyouthink.Evenaftertheresearchitselfisalldone
modelsbuilt,calculationscompleteitiswisetoallowatleastonecompletetermforwritingthethesis.It'snot
thephysicalactoftypingthattakessolong,it'sthefactthatwritingthethesisrequiresthecompleteorganization
ofyourargumentsandresults.It'sduringthisformalizationofyourresultsintoawellorganizedthesisdocument
capableofwithstandingthescrutinyofexpertexaminersthatyoudiscoverweaknesses.It'sfixingthose
weaknessesthattakestime."
Ingeneralfrominitialresearchtofinaldraft,youshouldallowfrom12to18months.This
guidelinecomesfromyearsofexperience,sotakeitseriously.Thefollowingisabreakdownof
thephasesofanalysisandthetimeyouneedtoallotforeachone:
(1) LiteratureReview.Theliteraturereviewisinmanywaysthemostdifficultandtime
consumingpartofthethesisproject.Itisalsothemostimportant.Thereviewofthe
literatureprovidesthecontextforyourthesisproject.Youwillbebuildingonprevious
researchersworksoitisimportantthatyoubethoroughlyfamiliarwithit.Thereview
oftheliteratureprovidesyourhypothesis,yourmethodology,andyourcontextfor
analysisandinterpretation.Thereforeyoushouldspendconsiderabletimeonthispart
ofyourproject.Youshouldinitiallyallotatleastthreetosixmonthsforthispartof
yourresearch.Howeveryoushouldalsorealizethattheliteraturereviewwillcontinue
forthedurationoftheproject.
(2) DataCollection.Dependingonwhereyouwillbedoingyourdatacollectionand
whetheryouwillbedoingitfulltimeorparttime,thedatacollectionphaseofyour
projectwilltakebetweentwoandsixmonths.Itisveryimportantthatyoubuildin
enoughtimetogobackandredosomeofyourdatacollection.Mostresearchersfind
thattheirexpertisechangesoverthecourseofdatacollectionandyouwillneedtogo
backandrecheckthedatathatyouinitiallycollected.
(3) DataAnalysis.Donotunderestimatethetimeyouallothere.Learningastatistics
packagetakestime.Researchingtheappropriatestatisticsandlearninghowtouseand
Writing the Thesis pg. 2
applythemtoyourdatatakestime.Planonatleastthreemonthsforthisphaseofyour
analysis.
(4) PreparationoftheThesisDrafts.Youwillbewritingindrafts.Youshouldcounton
writingatleastthreetofourcompletedraftsbeforeyourthesisiscomplete.Asa
generalguideline,fromfirstdrafttofinaldraftyoushouldcountonatleastsixmonths.
Thismeansthatifyouplantograduateinthespringsemesteryoushouldhaveyourfirst
drafttoyourcommitteeatleastbyOctoberofthatacademicyear(e.g.,ifyouplanto
graduateinSpring2009,yourthesiscommitteeshouldhaveyourfirstdraftbyOctober
2008).
GettingStarted
Onceyouhavetalkedwithyourcommitteemembersandestablishedatopictheveryfirstthing
todoisstartlibraryresearch.Oneofyourgoalsfromtheoutsetshouldbetotrackdownand
readeveryreferencethatyoupossiblycan.Ideallyyoushouldstartthistaskinyourfirstyearin
theMAprogram.Youwillbeworkingonthisaspectofyourthesisrightuptothefinaldraft,so
getanearlystart.Thewaytostartthisprocessistofindseveralrecentarticlesorbooksthat
pertaintoyourstudy.Readthemthoroughlyandtakenotes.Thenturntotheirliterature
cited.Cullthroughandfindthereferencesthatarepertinenttoyourresearch.Getthose
references,readthem,takenotes,andminetheirreferences.Continuethisprocessuntilyou
haveamassedallofthereferencesthatyoucanfind.
Itisimportantthatyoustartthisprocessassoonaspossiblebecauseinterlibrary loancantake
alongtimeinthecaseofhardtofindbooksorarticles.
Youshouldfamiliarizeyourselfwiththejournalsthatareavailablethroughtheelectronic
resourcesatthelibrary.Thiswillmaketheresearchphaseofyourprojectmucheasier.
TheOutline
Afterseveralweeksofresearchingandreadingtheliteratureyouwillbereadytoconstruct
anoutline.Thisistheroadmapforyourthesis.Theoutlinewillprovidethechapterheadings
andsubheadingsforyourthesis.Constructtheoutlinewithtwogeneralguidelinesinmind.
First,mosttheseswillfollowthegeneralsectionsdescribedbelow.Secondly,addheadingsand
subheadingsbasedonwhatyou'vediscoveredinyourliteraturereview.Onceyouhavean
outline,giveittoyourcommitteeforcommentsandrevisions.
Younowhaveatangibleplacetobeginwriting.Foreachofyourheadingsandsubheadings,
writeaparagraphormore.Thisshouldbeveryinformalatthispoint.Writedownwhatyou
plantocoverandwhy.
Timetable
Makeatimetable(seeexampleatendofthisdocument)andplanwhenyouwillhaveeach
phaseofyourprojectfinished.Thiswillhelpyoutobudgetyourtime.Thisstructurewillhelp
yougetthingsdoneontime.Otherwise,thetemptationistosetadatewhenthefinaldraftis
dueandturninthedraftatthelastminute.Draftspreparedinthismanneraregenerally
horriblydisorganizedandhopelesslyincomplete.Handinginthiskindofdraftwillonlyirritate
yourcommitteeandseriouslyprolongtheeditorialprocess.Sodontdoit.Amuchbetter
Writing the Thesis pg. 4
strategyistoturnindraftsofthekeypartsofyourthesisforfeedback.Themostimportant
initialthingsthatyoushouldshowyourcommitteeare(1)adiscussionofyourhypothesis,(2)
anoutlineofchapterheadingsandsubheadings,and(3)apreliminaryliteraturereview.
DataCollection
Ifyourthesisinvolvesdatacollection(measurements,observations,orinterviews),youneed
tobuildinextratimeforthisverylaborintensiveactivity.Datacollectionistremendouslytime
consuming.Makesurethatyouallowenoughtime.Invariably,measurementshavetobe
redone,statisticsrecalculated,andinterviewsfollowedupon.Ageneralruleistoallowtwice
asmuchtimeasyouthinkyouneed.
MechanicsofWriting
Beforeyoubeginwritingyoushouldgetthetwoessentialwritingmanualslistedbelow.Get
themandreadthem.Keepthemwhereyouwriteforreference.
Turabian,KateL.1996.AManualforWritersofTermPapers,Theses,andDissertations,6
th
edition(ChicagoGuidestoWriting,Editing,andPublishing).UniversityofChicagoPress.
Strunk,WilliamJr.,E.B.White,CharlesOsgood,andRogerAngell.2000.TheElementsofStyle.
AllynandBacon.
BeginWriting
Probablythemostcommonmistakethatbeginningwritersmakeistryingtowritefrompage
one.Takingalookatthegeneralsectionsdescribedbelow,THELASTthingthatyoushould
writeistheabstract.Thisisthehardestpartofthethesisandislargelydependentonthework
beingdone.Saveittilllast.Ingeneral,theeasiestthingstowritearetheliteraturereview,
materials,andmethodssections.
Writing the Thesis pg. 5
PartsofaThesis
Abstract
Thisisthesynopsisofyourthesis.Itshouldstateyourhypothesis,yourmethods(howyou
wentabouttestingthehypothesis),abriefsummaryofyourfindings,andabriefconclusion.
ThisistheLASTthingthatyouwrite.Waituntileverythingelseiswrittenbeforeattemptingthe
abstract.
Introduction
Theintroductionshouldintroducethethesis.Thisisnotasummaryofthethesis.Itisnota
briefversionofeachchapter.Itisanintroductiontothetopic.Introducethesubject.In
generalterms,whatdoesyourstudyaddress?Whyisitimportant?Wheredoesisfitinthe
overallfield?Besuretoincludeintheintroductionaclearstatementofyourhypothesisand
howyouaregoingtoaddressit.Throughouttheintroductionyoushouldusecitationsfromthe
researchliteraturetosupportyourstudy.Thesecitationsshouldincludebutnotbelimitedto
researchpresentedintheLiteratureReview.Thefollowingaresuggestedtopicsthatare
usuallycoveredintheintroduction.
StatementoftheProblem.Youshouldsuccinctlystatetheproblemthatyourthesisis
goingtoaddress.Youshouldalsopresentrelevantinformationaboutwhythisisan
importantproblem.
BackgroundandNeed.Youshouldpresentrelevantliteraturethatsupportstheneedfor
yourproject.Researcharticles,books,educationalandgovernmentstatisticsarejusta
fewsourcesthatshouldbeusedhere.Thissectioncanincludebriefoverviewsofarticles
coveredintheliteraturereviewthatsupporttheneedforyourproject
Rationale.Youshouldcarefullypresentthemodelortheorythatunderliestheproject.
Therationaleshoulddefinethelargerproblembeinginvestigated,summarizewhatis
Writing the Thesis pg. 6
knownabouttheproblem,definethegap(s)intheknowledge,andstatewhatneedsto
bedonetoaddressthegap(s).
PurposeoftheProject.Basedontheabovebackgroundinformation,explainthepurpose
ofthestudy.Explainwhatyouhopethestudywillaccomplishandwhyyouchosetodo
thisparticularstudy.Thisshouldbesupportedwithcitationsandspecificinformation
relatedtothestudy.
ResearchQuestions/Hypotheses.Giventhebackgroundabove,youcarefullystatethe
hypothesis(ses)thatwillbetestedinyourthesis.
Methods.Briefly(asyouwillcoverthisindepthinalaterchapter)describethemethods
thatwereusedinyourstudy(i.e.,researchmethods,variables,instrumentation,
participants,pilot,analysisofdata).
Limitations.Beginthiswithasummaryofthedocumentthusfartoprovideabackground
foranylimitationstothisstudy.Beveryspecific,forexamplethepopulationtowhich
yourfindingswillbelimited.
LiteratureReview
Theliteraturereviewshoulddiscussalloftheresearchthathasbeendoneonthesubject.
Howyougroupthediscussionwilldependonyourproject,butbesuretocomeupwitha
logicalorganizationbeforeyoubeginwriting.Thisisthediscussionandanalysisofthelibrary
researchyou'vebeendoingforthepast12months.Howmanystudiesshouldbeincludedwill
dependonthetopic,butageneralbaselineis75to100references(althoughmanytopicswill
appropriatelyhavemanymorethanthis).
Thepurposeoftheliteraturereviewistoconciselydemonstrateyourlevelofunderstanding
oftheresearchrelatedtoyourproject.Youshouldnotdiscussalloftheliteratureindepth.
Ratheryoushouldgroupyourliteratureaccordingtosomegeneraltopicsandonlydiscuss
specificstudiesiftheyarelandmarkstudiesforyourareaofresearch(thereshouldbe610of
these).Eachofthesespecificdiscussionsshouldincludespecificinformationaboutthegroup
involvedintheresearchproject,data,andresultsreported.Oftenareviewofliteraturewill
includeseveraloftheseindepthreviewswithminireviewsofstudiesthatcametothesame
orsimilarconclusions.Theliteraturereviewshouldendwithadiscussionofhowtheliterature
relatestoyourstudy.
MaterialsandMethods
Thissectionshouldprovideanindepthdiscussionofyourmaterials(e.g.,ifthisisan
archaeologicalthesis,youshoulddiscussthehistory,etc.ofthepopulationsthatyouare
dealingwith).Themethodsportionofthissectionshouldcarefullyandmethodicallydiscuss
themethodsthatyouaregoingtouse,theprecedentforthese,andthereasonswhyyouare
usingthem.Ageneralguidelineisthatyoushoulddiscussyourmethodsinsufficientdetailthat
anotherresearchercouldtakeyourdataandduplicateyourresults.Oneoftheexpectationsof
performingoriginalresearchisthatsomeoneinthefuturewilldofurtherresearchonthistopic.
Sucharesearchershouldbeabletouseyourmethodologywithouthavingtoconsultanyother
source.Ifyouareusingstatisticalanalyses,explainthestatisticalmethods.Whatdothey
mean?Howaretheyused?Whyaretheymoreapplicableherethanothersimilarmethods?
Forsometheses,thematerialsandmethodsshouldbediscussedinseparatesections.
Itisveryimportantnottotryandcombinethischapterwiththenextone.Youneedto
carefullypresentyourresultsfirstwithnofurtherinterpretation.Onceyouhavepresentedthe
datayouarereadytomoveontothenextsection.
Discussion
Thischaptershouldbeginwithaconciserestatementofyourstudyspurposealongwithany
neededbackgroundinformation.Youshouldrestateeachofyourhypotheses.Nowthatyou
havepresentedtheresultsintheprevioussection,discusstheminthissection.What,
specifically,dotheresultsmean?Howcantheybeinterpreted?Cantheybeinterpretedin
multipleways?Whatdothefindingstellyouaboutyourhypothesis?Donotclaimmorefor
yourresultsthanthedatareallyshows.Avoidspeculation.
Conclusions
Thisshouldsummarizeyourresultsanddiscussion.Youshouldincludealistofthemost
importantfindingsofyourstudyindescendingorderofimportance.Youshouldalsoprovidea
statementaboutthepossibilityoffuturestudy.Whatneedstobedoneandwhatdoesthis
studycontribute?
LiteratureCited
Thisisalloftheliteraturethatyouhavecitedinthetext,tables,andfigures.Thisisnota
bibliography.Donotincludeworksthathavenotbeencitedinthebody.Keepcarefultrackof
Writing the Thesis pg. 9
thisasyouwrite.Whenyouuseasource,addittothissection.Beforeyoubegincompiling
thissection,findoutwhatstyleyouareexpectedtouse.Ingeneral,anthropologistsshoulduse
thestyleofthejournalCurrentAnthropology.Makeahardcopyofthestyleandtapeitabove
yourcomputer.Carefullyadheretoitoryouwill(deservedly)raisetheireofyourcommittee
(thisisapetpeeveofmostacademics).
Appendices
Ifyouhavematerialthatistoolongtoincludeinatable(rawdata,fieldnotes,etc.)ornot
appropriatetoaparticularsectionitshouldbeincludedasanappendix.
TablesandFigures
Tablesandfiguresshouldappearinthetextaftertheyarefirstmentioned.Appendingthem
attheendofthethesisisaveryawkwardarrangementandmakesthethesisdifficulttoread.
Materialpresentedintablesandfiguresshouldnotbeduplicatedinthetext.Thereare
examplesofthegeneralformatthatshouldbeusedfortablesandfiguresattheendofthis
document.
RawData
Yourrawdatashouldalwaysappearaspartofthethesis.Thisshouldappearasanappendix
attheendofyourthesis.Anotherresearchershouldbeabletoduplicateyourworkwithno
otherdocumentsattheirdisposal.
HealthyParanoia
JoeWolfe(HowtoWriteaPh.D.Thesis)makesthefollowingsuggestionsregardingmaintainingfiles
(computerandpaper)whilewritingyourthesis.Thisisgoodadvice.Followitandsaveyourself
troublelater.
"Itisencouragingandhelpfultostartafilingsystem.Openawordprocessorfileforeachchapter
andoneforthereferences.Youcanputnotesinthese,aswellastext.Whiledoingsomethingfor
Chaptern,youwillthink"OhImustreferbackto/discussthisinChapterm"andsoyouputa
notetodosointheChaptermfile.Oryoumaythinkofsomethinginterestingorrelevantfor
Writing the Thesis pg. 11
thatchapter.Whenyoucometoworkonthatchapter,themoresuchnotesyouhave
accumulated,theeasieritwillbetowrite.
Makeabackupofthesefilesanddosoeverydayatleast(dependingonthereliabilityofyour
computerandtheageofyourdiskdrive).Neverkeepthebackupdiskclosetothecomputerin
casethehypotheticalthiefwhofanciesyourcomputerissmartenoughtothinks/hecoulduse
somedisksaswell.Youshouldalsohavearotatingmasterbackup:usetwodisks,backupone
ofthemeveryweek,andkeepthemphysicallyseparatefromyourmaincomputer.Thatwayyou
alwayshavebackupsthatare1and2weeksold,andifafilebecomescorruptedyouwillhave
anolderversionofitavailable.Ifyouwanttobereallycareful,youcouldtransferyourbackups
toamachineatsomegeographicallyremotelocation(usingFTPoranemailattachment),
withoutofcoursetellingthesystemadministratorthatIsuggestedthis.(ForMacintoshfilesuse
BinhextoconvertthefilestoASCIIformandFTPinASCIImode.ForDos/Windowsfiles,transfer
usingbinarymode).Asimplewayofmakingaremotebackupistosenditasanemail
attachmenttoa(consenting)emailcorrespondent.Youcouldsendittoyourselfifyourserver
savesyourmail(insomeemailpackageslikeEudorathisisanoptionalsetting).Ineithercase,be
carefultodisposeofsupersededversionssothatyoudon'twastediskspace.
Youshouldalsohaveaphysicalfilingsystem:acollectionoffolderswithchapternumberson
them.Thiswillmakeyoufeelgoodaboutgettingstartedandalsohelpcleanupyourdesk.Your
fileswillcontainnotjusttheplotsofresultsandpagesofcalculations,butallsortsofoldnotes,
references,calibrationcurves,suppliers'addresses,specifications,speculations,lettersfrom
colleaguesetcwhichwillsuddenlystrikeyouasrelevanttoonechapterorother.Stickthemin
thatfolder.Thenputallthefoldersinaboxorafilingcabinet.Asyouwritebitsandpiecesof
text,stickthehardcopy,thefiguresetcinthesefoldersaswell.Touchthemandfeeltheir
thicknessfromtimetotimeah,thethesisistakingshape.
Ifanyofyourdataexistonlyonpaper,copythemandkeepthecopyinadifferentlocation.
Considermakingacopyofyourlabbook.Thishasanotherpurposebeyondsecurity:usuallythe
labbookstaysinthelab,butyoumaywantacopyforyourownfutureuse.Further,scientific
ethicsrequireyoutokeeplabbooksandoriginaldataforatleasttenyears,andacopyismore
likelytobefoundiftwocopiesexist.
Whileyouaregettingorganised,youshoulddealwithanyuniversitypaperwork.Examinershave
tobenominatedandtheyhavetoagreetoserve,variousformsarerequiredbyyourdepartment
Writing the Thesis pg. 12
andbytheuniversityadministration.Makesurethattheratelimitingstepisyourproductionof
thethesis,andnotsomeminorbureaucraticproblem."