Scribd Logo
Upload

Welcome to Scribd!

  • 14 views

    In Re Designation of Judge Manzano (Zaya Pono's Conflicted Copy 2012-10-06)

    Uploaded by

    Jackie Canlas
    1. The petitioner, Judge Rodolfo Manzano, was assigned to the Province of Ilocos Norte Committee on Justice by Executive Order. 2. The petitioner requested permission to accept the appointment and to not consider the membership a violation of his independence as a judge. 3. The Court denied the petition, finding that Committees on Justice perform administrative functions to improve local jail conditions and reduce congestion, not judicial functions. Membership would not violate the prohibition on assigning judges to non-judicial tasks.

    Copyright:

    © All Rights Reserved
    Download as DOC, PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
    Flag for inappropriate content

    You might also like

    In Re Designation of Judge Manzano (Zaya Pono's Conflicted Copy 2012-10-06)

    Uploaded by

    Jackie Canlas
    14 views1 page
    1. The petitioner, Judge Rodolfo Manzano, was assigned to the Province of Ilocos Norte Committee on Justice by Executive Order. 2. The petitioner requested permission to accept the appointment and to not consider the membership a violation of his independence as a judge. 3. The Court denied the petition, finding that Committees on Justice perform administrative functions to improve local jail conditions and reduce congestion, not judicial functions. Membership would not violate the prohibition on assigning judges to non-judicial tasks.

    Original Description:

    consti

    Copyright

    © © All Rights Reserved

    Available Formats

    DOC, PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd

    Did you find this document useful?

    Is this content inappropriate?

    Report this Document
    1. The petitioner, Judge Rodolfo Manzano, was assigned to the Province of Ilocos Norte Committee on Justice by Executive Order. 2. The petitioner requested permission to accept the appointment and to not consider the membership a violation of his independence as a judge. 3. The Court denied the petition, finding that Committees on Justice perform administrative functions to improve local jail conditions and reduce congestion, not judicial functions. Membership would not violate the prohibition on assigning judges to non-judicial tasks.

    Copyright:

    © All Rights Reserved
    Download as DOC, PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
    Flag for inappropriate content
    Download as doc, pdf, or txt
    14 views1 page

    In Re Designation of Judge Manzano (Zaya Pono's Conflicted Copy 2012-10-06)

    Uploaded by

    Jackie Canlas
    1. The petitioner, Judge Rodolfo Manzano, was assigned to the Province of Ilocos Norte Committee on Justice by Executive Order. 2. The petitioner requested permission to accept the appointment and to not consider the membership a violation of his independence as a judge. 3. The Court denied the petition, finding that Committees on Justice perform administrative functions to improve local jail conditions and reduce congestion, not judicial functions. Membership would not violate the prohibition on assigning judges to non-judicial tasks.

    Copyright:

    © All Rights Reserved
    Download as DOC, PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
    Flag for inappropriate content
    Download as doc, pdf, or txt
    of 1

    Pascua

    In Re Designation of Judge Manzano


    1
    Constitutional Law Judiciary Non-judicial Tasks
    A.M. No. 88-7-1861-RTC
    Octo!r "# 1$$8
    %on!nt!& %adilla
    %!tition!r& Jud'! Rodol(o ). Man*ano# +,!c. Jud'!# RTC# -an'ui# .locos Nort!# -r. 1$
    /ACT0&
    %!tition!r was assi'n!d to t1! .locos Nort! %ro2incial Co33itt!! on Justic!
    -y 4o2. Rodol(o C. /ari5as
    T1! Co33itt!! was cr!at!d y %r!s. +,!c. Ord!r 8"6 67!c. 18# 1$869 as a3!nd!d y +O :86
    6Jun! 1# 1$889
    T1! d!si'nation was accordin' to +O R/6-;<
    %!tition!r s!nt a l!tt!r dat!d July <# 1$88 to t1! court askin' (or t1r!! t1in's&
    1. %!r3ission to acc!=t a==oint3!nt
    8. To not s!! t1! 3!3!rs1i= in t1! co33itt!! as a 2iolation o( 0!c. 18# Art. >... or o( =ar.
    8# 0!c. 7# Art. .?6-9 nor o( t1! .nd!=!nd!nc! o( t1! Judiciary
    :. Consid!r t1! 3!3!rs1i= as =art o( (unctions o( an +,!c. Jud'!
    R)L.N4& Court d!ni!d 1is =!tition
    RAT.O&
    +O 8"6 @ Co33itt!!s on Justic! ar! cr!at!d to insur! t1! s=!!dy dis=osition o( cas!s#
    all!2iatin' jail con'!stion and i3=ro2in' local jail conditions
    Co33itt!!s on Justic! =!r(or3 ad3inistrati2! (unctions
    0!c. 18# Art. >...# A87 Constitution =ro1iits 3!3!rs o( t1! 0C (ro3 !in' d!si'nat!d to ot1!r
    o((ic!s =!r(or3in' Buasi-judicial or ad3inistrati2! (unctions
    4arcia 2. Macarai' 6/or3!r CJ +nriBu! M. /!rnando9
    .tAs ok (or RTC jud'!s to assist t1! Co33itt!!s as lon' as t1! assistanc! ! r!asonaly
    incid!ntal to t1! (ul(ill3!nt o( t1!ir duti!s
    4)TT.+R+C# JR. 7iss!nt&
    D1!r! to draw t1! lin! inso(ar as ad3inistrati2! (unctions ar! conc!rn!dE
    M!3!rs1i= in t1! co33itt!! do!s not in2ol2! any r!'ulation or control o2!r t1! conduct or
    a((airs o( indi2iduals. N!it1!r do!s it !,!rcis! any Buasi-l!'islati2! (unctions. .tAs =ur!ly ad2isory.
    FAssistanc!A in 3ajority o=inion is 2a'u!
    0tudyin' =rol!3s in2ol2in' t1! ad3inistration o( justic! and arri2in' at =ur!ly r!co33!ndatory
    solutions do!s not constitut! as an !ncroac13!nt o( t1! judiciary into !,!cuti2! or l!'islati2!
    (unctions or into 3att!rs not wit1in its conc!rn
    T1! co33itt!!s will ! !n!(itt!d y t1! 3!3!rs1i= o( jud'!s
    M+L+NC.O-G+RR+RA 7iss!nt&
    G!sitat!s to 'i2! a r!stricti2! and i3=ractical int!r=r!tation to 0!c. 18# Art >...
    Co33itt!! cannot ! lik!n!d to an ad3inistrati2! a'!ncy o( 'o2!rn3!nt. .t is a study 'rou= wit1
    r!co33!ndatory (ucntions.

    You might also like