Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Theory Megger
Theory Megger
By ?
AVO
ABSTRACT: What does the measurement tell me? Fundamentally, how "good"
the insulation is, and by extension, the overall condition of the piece
of electrical... Use of Megger devices
URL: www.avointl.com/products/insulation/xtra/faq/theory1.html
Last modified 6-Oct-98 - page size 36K - in English [ Translate ]
deterioration or damage. If the item has been functioning adequately since its last scheduled test, and
the readings are consistent, there is no cause for
alarm. On the other hand, a dramatic or marked decrease from a very high value, even though the present reading is still quite high, indicates that something is effecting the insulation negatively. If not
halted, continued decline and the eventual failure of
the equipment well ahead of normal life can be expected.
The availability of prior records, unfortunately, is
a luxury. Frequently, one must function without
them. In such cases, other, more general, sources
must be used as resources. Manufacturer's specifications, of course, would be a prime example, but they
are often difficult to obtain, and still require interpretation of change unless testing brand new equipment. For more general applicability, independent
standards agencies are excellent sources, and always
available in some manner or other. Familiar organizations like IEEE, UL, ANSI, IEC, and so on, issue
written standards for testing various categories of
equipment and materials. If you are testing motors,
you may consult IEEE; for wire and cable, IEEE or
IPCEA (Insulated Power Cable Engineers Association); for materials, ANSI; for electrical consumer
goods, UL. Many others exist in addition to the few
mentioned. Often, there are formulas available by
which you may calculate minimum acceptable resistance values for different types of insulation and
equipment.
A convenient and simple method of interpreting a
test is to employ an industry-accepted standard test
method that includes a built-in result determination.
Such widely-known methods as the PI (Polarization
Index) and Step Voltage tests can be evaluated independently of any external standard or previous data.
They work by taking advantage of the difference in
behaviors exhibited by healthy and deteriorated insulation during the time of the test. By comparing
readings at different times or stages of a single test
and reducing the comparison to a ratio or number,
the operator is provided with a ready reference upon
which to base a judgment about the insulation's condition.
At the very least, and in the absence of any other
recourse, the industry has gotten reasonable success
from using the so-called "One Megohm Rule",
which states than a minimum acceptable insulation
resistance value should be equivalent to one M* per
kV of rated operating voltage, not to be less than one
M* (that is to say, familiar 120 & 240 V equipment
should exhibit at least 1 M*). If the test item reads
less than this, it's time for maintenance and/or repair!
If higher, it will probably run, but unless there's a
history to predict a trend, the question remains as to
how long.
What is a PI (Polarization Index)?
This is a popular standard test procedure. It is recognized throughout the industry, and was not devised by Megger Instruments merely for the use of
our models. It is a specialized version of the more
general testing technique called the "dielectric absorption ratio". In this technique, insulation resistance readings are taken at two fixed times during
the progress of a single test, with the first reading
being divided into the second to yield a ratio. A Polarization Index is specifically a 1-minute reading
divided into a 10-minute reading. Other time intervals can be used for convenience, in which case the
test becomes a more generic dielectric absorption
ratio, but not a PI.
The PI test works because of the notable difference in ratios of leakage and charging currents between "good" and "bad" insulation. When in good
condition, insulation passes very little leakage current in comparison to the charging currents that are
pulled as a result of basic design. When insulation
deteriorates, however, this relationship inverts.
Leakage becomes large compared to charging, and
masks the charging effect. Deteriorated insulation
maintains a relatively constant current, much like a
circuit, as the applied test voltage pulls current
through the imperfections in the insulation. Charging
current is small by comparison, and so a reading
taken at 10 minutes is nearly the same as one taken
at 1 minute, and the ratio tends to approach "1".
Pristine insulation, on the other hand, will exhibit a
rising resistance throughout a test, as the charging
currents go to completion and the leakage remains
small. Such a PI, therefore, will be calculated from a
second reading that is much higher than the first, and
the ratio will be large.
The PI test has a number of advantages: it is independent of extraneous influences like temperature,
and is self-contained; it does not rely on actual values, and does not need any external reference; because it is standardized and universally recognized,
results can easily be compared, even if performed by
different persons at different times; the calculated
ratio provides a ready means of evaluation, independent of any reference sources; the test can be performed on large equipment relatively quickly and
easily.
Because it merely takes advantage of readings at
two different times within a single test, there is no
need to correct to a common temperature. The actual
values of the readings are of lesser significance,
since 50 Megohms into a hundred will yield the
same interpretation as five hundred into a thousand.
Large, complex equipment, like generators, can require prohibitive test times by other methods, because the large windings will have lots of capacitance and can charge for hours. Again, because it is
looking only for difference and does not rely on actual numbers, a PI can perform a reliable test in a
Our convenient and popular insulation-testing manual, "A Stitch In Time", contains a table. Remember
that it isn't just ambient temperature that must be
taken into account, but operating temperature as
well. A piece of equipment that has been up and
running prior to the performance of an insulation test
will yield a much lower reading than the same piece
of equipment had it been tested while idle. Operating
temperatures may be found with the specifications of
the test item, or may be measured at the time of test,
such as with an infrared heat-sensing gun. In the absence of any specifications or testing instruments, an
experienced judgment of a piece of equipment's running temperature can serve nearly as well. Humidity
cannot be quantized in its effects as can temperature,
because different types and conditions of insulation
will take up moisture to varying extents. But it may
prove worthwhile to record an estimate of relative
humidity at test time, because it may help to explain
deviations from the expected measurements.
Spot-reading tests may be all that are necessary
for small equipment, because such items can reach
their fully-charged condition shortly after initiation
of the test, and therefore exhibit little time-resistance
effect. A reading taken 30 seconds into the test may
be all that the test item will ever show. Standard test
procedures must still be observed, however, to prevent assumption from leading to error. Spot-Reading
tests are facilitated on Megger Models BM11D,
BM21, and BM25, by a digital clock right on the
display, which starts from zero upon initiation of the
test. The latter two models also have a control function permitting pre-setting of the time interval up to
90 minutes. The tester will automatically terminate
the test at the prescribed time and retain the data on
the display until shut down by the sleeper circuit.
The Spot-Reading test is generally the quickest
and easiest to utilize, and if properly performed, can
be a reliable and useful method.
What about the humidity?
Humidity has an effect upon insulation resistance,
but it cannot be quantified as neatly as can temperature effect. This is because different types of insulation will absorb moisture to varying degrees, as will
varying ages and conditions of the same type. So the
best that can be said is that humidity is a factor that
should not be overlooked when evaluating test results. Unlike temperature, humidity's effect is not a
constant gradient. So long as the temperature remains above the dew point, humidity will not appreciably effect insulation readings. However, at the
dew point, microscopic condensation can form in the
cracks and crevices in the insulation surface without
being noticeable to the touch, and this accumulation
will accommodate leakage current and bring down
readings. Aged and dirty insulation may aggravate
this effect because certain lints, acids, and salts are