Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Aneta Serafimova I Jehona Spahiu - Nova Vlast-Druga Vera Saopstenja 45 (2013) 1-Libre
Aneta Serafimova I Jehona Spahiu - Nova Vlast-Druga Vera Saopstenja 45 (2013) 1-Libre
ZAVOD
ZA
ZA[TITU
SPOMENIKA
KULTURE
BEOGRAD
INSTITUT POUR
LA PROTECTION
DES MONUMENTS
HISTORIQUES DE
LA RPUBLIQUE
DE SERBIE
BELGRADE
COMMUNICATIONS
XLV2013
Comit de rdaction
Viktorija Popovska-Korobar
Evangelija Hadjitryphonos
Sreten Petkovi}
Milka ^anak-Medi}
Miroslav Timotijevi}
Marko Popovi}
Svetlana Peji}
Olivera Kandi}
Gordana Simi}
Dragan Vojvodi}
Mirjana eki
Pour lditeur
Mirjana Andri}
Chef
Gordana Simi}
Secrtaire
Ivana Prodanovi}-Rankovi}
YU ISSN 0354-4346
UDK 7 + 902 / 904
SAOP[TEWA
XLV2013
Redakcioni odbor
Viktorija Popovska-Korobar
Evangelija Haxitrifonos
Sreten Petkovi}
Milka ^anak-Medi}
Miroslav Timotijevi}
Marko Popovi}
Svetlana Peji}
Olivera Kandi}
Gordana Simi}
Dragan Vojvodi}
Mirjana \eki}
Odgovorni urednik
Mirjana Andri}
Urednik
Gordana Simi}
Sekretar
Ivana Prodanovi}-Rankovi}
BEOGRAD 2013.
. . . . . . . . . . . .
26
27
47
. . . . . .
Olivera Kandi}
.........
................
49
54
, ( 4)
Dimitrije Madas
55
65
-,
,
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
67
Nata{a Miladinovi}-Radmilovi},
Aleksa Janovi}, Zoran Rako~evi}
82
Ivanka Gergova
..........
..............................
83
92
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
93
Marin Brmboli}
Branislav Cvetkovi
Ta
.
I . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 133
Tatjana Starodubcev
a,
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 147
In Search of the Folk poet: Azdiya,Velvet in Medieval Serbia . . . . 163
Tatjana Vuleta
,
Aneta Serafimova, ehona pahiu
Miroslava Kosti
111
131
. . . . . 165
New Rule Another Faith . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 177
IV
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
179
Miroslav Timotijevi}
Vesna Biki
SADR@AJ
a, , :
1.
203
225
, , .
. . . . . . . . . . .
227
246
/Contributions
. a
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
251
261
, :
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
263
Bojan S. Turanjanin
Nenad Lajbenperger
277
-
-
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
279
287
289
, . . . . . . . . . . . .
291
.
, . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
294
1
The Relationship between Byzantium and Arabs
(May 1963) Dumbarton Oaks
Papers 18 (1964). ,
,
,
: G. C. Miles, Byzantium and the
Arabs: Relations in Crete and the Aegean Area,
DOP 18 (1964), 132 (
); O. Grabar, Islamic
Art and Byzantium, , 6788 (
);
G. Meyendorff, Byzantine View of Islam, ,
113132 (
).
2 . . , -
XVI
XVII ,
1 (1965), 119139 (
); . ,
, : XVI XVII
, 1995, 239253.
:
: (1) - (2) -. ,
,
XVI . ,
, -
.
j ,
, /, ,
, .
-
, .
: , ,
, , , , , ,
, ,
,
Dumbarton Oaks
,
.1 ,
, .2
,
1. : a)
,
,
, 1501; b)
, 1536/37; c)
, ,
XVI ; d)
, , 1627
1. St. Merkourios: a) paracclesion
of St. Nicholas, Presentation of the
Holy Virgin in the Temple, Kuevite,
1501; b) Monastery of Toplica,
1536/37; c) St. Nicholas, Zrze, c.
1550; d) St. John the Theologian,
Slepe, 1627
166
3
IV
,
2010,
, . A.
Serafimova, J. Spahiu, Contribution to Studying
Islamic Influences on the Post-Byzantine Painting
in Ottoman Macedonia, 4th International
Congress on Islamic Civilisation in the Balkans.
Abstracts, Skopje 2010, 62. , ,
(IBAC),
2011. ,
,
,
: D. Georgiev,
Ottoman Charshi: The Mutual Economic and
Socio-Cultural Space of the Balkan Town; I.
Velev, The Byzantine Culture and the Emergence
of the Global Civilization on the Balkans; .
Sotnichenko, Islam and Christianity in the
Ottoman Balkans: the Experience of Intercultural
Dialogue; A. Serafimova, Ottoman Social and
Historical Reflections on the Post-Byzantine
Painting in Macedonia, . International Balkan
Annual Conference (IBAC) on Co-existence of the
Cultures in Balkans. Abstracts, Skopje 2011, 5,
23, 84, 129.
: V.
Popovska-Korobar, D. Gorgiev, Icons from the
Museum of Macedonia with Ottoman Prayer
Inscriptions, The Historical Review LX (2011),
247269.
4 XIX
-
,
XIX
.
,
() .
5
/
,
.
XIV XVII
, . A. Lymberopoulou, Audiences and
markets for Cretan icons, : K. W. Woods, C. M.
Richardson, Viewing Renaissance Art, London
2007, 171208, 202203,
.
6 . , . , 125, . 4;
,
, 249.
7
. . ,
,
, 1995, 624, . 452; Ch.
Walter, The Warrior Saints in Byzantine Art and
Tradition, Aldershot 2003, 104; . ,
.3
,
XIX ,4 ,
(1) , (2)
(3) e .
() , ,
,
.
/
.5
1.
-
,
. ,
XV XVI .6
,
, .
. , ,
,
.7 ,
,
(1348)8
( 1385).9
, , /
XIII XIV ,
XV
.10 , ,
250. .11
(. 1),
XV
.12 ,
, ,
.
, , ,
167
,
. 12/2007 (2007), 9193.
,
, Abu al-Saifain
( ), . J. Kamil, Christianity
in the land of the Pharaohs: The Coptic
Orthodox Church, Routledge 2002, 258259,
fig. 10.4.
8 , . , . 5.
9 . , .
, 1953, . 154.
10 XIII
XIV . Persian Art: An Illustrated Souvenir
of the exhibition of Persian Art at Burlington
House, London 1931, 3251; E. Blochet,
Catalogue des Manuscrits Persans de la
Bibliothque Nationale, Paris 1934, passim; D.
T. Rice, Islamska umetnost, Beograd 1968, sl.
116, 118, 120, 219, 227; M. G. Lukens, The
Fifteenth-Century Miniatures, The Metropolitan
Museum of Art Bulletin 25/9 (1967), 317338.
11 . . ,
, 1977, 717 (: ,
); , ,
2001, 775776 (: ).
12 . ,
XV , 1980, . 33 (),
. 69 (), . 79 (), 118
(). XVI XVII
,
:
( ) 1501 (
,
: . , 2008, .
35), ( ),
(. -,
,
4, 1981, 426427, . 12), (.
-,
. ,
2003, . III)
(. ,
, 2001, 30).
13 . ,
,
10 (1976), 203266; , ,
, 224229; , 93; . ,
,
XXXII (1993), 167205; .
, . ,
IXXVIII , 1996, 107135.
14 . -, . ,
4144.
15 . . . , .
,
192021 (1996), 197,
200201.
, 1515. .13 ,
.
(1617)14
(1634),15
, ,
a
b
c
2. : a) ,
, 184852; b) , , 1864; c)
, 1881
2. St. George of Ioannina: a) St. George the Victorious, Rajica, 184852;
b) St. Elijah, Selce, 1864; c) Holy Virgin Immaculate of Kievo, 1881
3. , ,
, XIX
3. The Life of St. George of Ioannina, St. Athanasius, Bogomila, second
half of 19th century
168
16 .
. ,
(15571614), 1965, 8788, 110,
170, 185, 195 . 8 ( ), 26
(), 88 (); . : ,
,
181184.
17
,
,
,
1844. , . .
, XV XIX
, .
XXIV 1 ( 1993), 4648; ,
.
, .
XXXI/1 ( 2000), 101124; . : .
,
,
, 1990, 8889.
,
(
1839),
. . , .
, ,
2001, 485491, .
18 . , , , 552553; , 38.
19 . , .
, 116120.
20 .
30- XIX
II (. B. Masters, G.
goston, Encyclopedia of the Ottoman Empire, New York
2009, 55, 430),
,
. ,
, . . ,
, 18
( ), 1998, 2527.
21 ,
,
,
, . , 38 (), 93
().
22
. . .
, , VI
III (1887), 311317,
364 , . . (M.
M. Garidis, Etudes sur le Jugement dernier post-byzantin
du XVe l fin du XIXe sicles, Thessaloniki 1985)
Cahier balkaniques (6, ed.
T. Velmans, Paris 1984),
.
23
. . ,
( )
XVI ,
2223/199596 (1997), 5052; .
,
, .
,
.16
,
XIX .
(1838),
(.
2).17 ,
,
, , (), ,
.18
. , ,
(. 3).19 /,
,20 , ,
,
.21
2.
-
.
( 1595),
(1624/25)
(1630/31),
,22 ,
(. 4).23
,
.24
, .
, , .25
: /
/, .26
- ,
27 .28 ,
/ ,
169
, 2829/2002
03 (2004), 175176; ,
, 2005,
183184, 286.
24 . . , ,
, 1993,
131132, 140 (= Das Jngstes Gericht,
Recklinghausen 1963).
/
: , ,
175176, . 7375,
.
25 .
, -
:
, . 4/9 (2011), 203212.
26
, e,
,
, . E. J. Brills First Encyclopedia of Islam,
19131936, ed. M. Th. Housma, Vol. IV, Leiden
1993, 701.
27 ,
, . Garidis,
nav. delo, 9195, pl. 9497.
,
, , ,
, . A. Dumitrescu, La
faade ouest de Saint-Georges de Vorone en
Roumanie, CahBalk 6 (1984), 123125.
28
( XV ),
,
, .
Garidis, nav. delo, 100101; . , .
, :
, 2010/1
(2010), 3134.
4. :
a)
, ,
1595;
b) ,
1624/25;
c)
, 1630/31
4. Last Judgment:
a) Holy Virgin
Peribleptos, Ohrid,
c 1595;
b) Monastery of Zrze,
1624/25;
c) Monastery of
Kuevite, 1630/31
170
29
, , .
, , . , 3234,
.
30
,
()
,
,
,
,
,
: . ,
17
( ),
1995, 200201, . 125.
. ,
- ,
208209, . 43.
31
(1743).
: iyDEI,
(
. ).
Th. Papazotos, The Church of
Ayios Yermanos at the village of Ayios Yermanos,
: D. Evyenidou, I. Kanonidis, Th. Papazotos,
The Monuments of Prespa, Athens 1991, 3539.
32
(1847)
(. . , . ,
1997, 10);
(1880) . . -,
. ,
, . VIII,
. IX (1978), . 12, . 4.
33 . . ,
XV XVI , XXIII
(1975), 7589.
34 .
,
,
1517 ( ). . :
, . , 8189.
35 . (
, 81, 184185)
1466.
,
.
36 . ,
, 1516.
. . ,
XVI ,
, 1989, 109113.
37 . . , , 1933, 67.
, , , ,
,
.29
.
, .30
XVIII31 XIX .32
-
. XVI
.33
,
, .34
, XV ,35
,
XVI ,36
,
.
, .37
,
,
,
, XVII .38
XVI ,
.
/ - ,
, .
.39
-
,
,
-
.40
(1628), .41
, ,
,
XV XVI .42
,
XVIII ,43
,
171
5. , ,
, 1745
5a. The Life of St. George (icon), Holy
Virgin Immaculate of Kievo, 1745
5. , ,
, 1754
5b. The Life of St. Marina (icon), Gallery
of Icons, Ohrid, c. 1754
38 . . ,
XVII ,
1997, 3942 ( ).
39 -
. ,
- , 207211.
40
, . .
, , 1986, 8990, .
29, . 45; ,
, 247; . . ,
, Topics in PostByzantine Painting. In Memory of Manolis
Chatzidakis, Athens 2002, 4042, . 4, 7.
41 . . ,
. . ,
89/198182 (1983), 122,
. 31, . 10.
42 D. Nicolle, Ch. Hook, The Janissaries,
London 1995, 2022; S. Turnubull, The Ottoman
Empire 13261699, Routledge 2003, 18;
Masters, goston, nav. delo, 296297.
43 : .
, .
, 3 (1998), 3339.
. : . -,
18 , 2005, 87.
172
44 . ,
IXXVIII ,
1983, 218219, . 71; . ,
(),
1999, 9697.
45 . ,
,
, 1990, 108.
46 . . . ,
,
2627/20002001 (2001), 32, . 8.
47
.
.
-,
18 , 77.
48 . http://
valkyrja.shawwebspace.ca/asset/view/20675/
intro_to_ottoman_turkish_clothing_web_
version_july_2009.pdf; .
E.J. Brills First Encyclopaedia of Islam 1913
1936, Vol. VIII, (Tif - Zrkhna), Brill 1987,
885893.
49 -,
18 , 101, . 1; . ,
: ,
,
, CD-ROM, 2006, .
140141; . ,
, 1995, . 92, 9597, 101
102, 106107.
50 . . . ,
,
8 (1972),
131136; : . ,
, .
, 2008, 34.
51 . A. Rahman Zaky, Introduction to
the Study of Islamic Arms and Armours, Gladius
II (1961), 18, 21, fig. 2c, 3c (
: http://gladius.revistas.csic.es/
index.php/gladius/article/view/211/213); . :
D. Alexander, Swords and Sabers during the
Early Islamic Period, Gladius XXI (2001),
193220 (http://gladius.revistas.csic.es/index.
php/gladius/article/viewFile/86/86).
52
. -,
XV
,
XLIV
(2007), 560, . . ),
(,
,
109), ( )
( ).
53
(. -,
XV , 560),
.44
, , , ,
, , (. 5).
, 1745,
,45
.46
: ,
, , ,
(. 5).
,
, .47
, , , , , () () ,48
XVIII XIX .49 ,
,
, .
/ .
, ,
/.
(1376/77),50 (. 6).
(``), XV XVI .51
(.
6),52 (. 6).53
,
,
( 1460)54
,
(1534/35, . 6).55
,
.56
,
,
- .57
173
( ) (. .
,
, . 78 (2010),
348, . 13).
54 . . ,
, 1971, 56, . 10.
55 . ,
, Balcanoslavica 3031 (2002), 125.
56
(. ,
, Balcanoslavica
3739/20072010 (2010), . 3, 5, 6)
( )
( ).
57 Rahman Zaky, nav. delo, 2429, fig.
610; M. G. Parani, Reconstructing the Reality
of Images: Byzantine Material Culture and
Religious Iconography (11th15th Centuries),
LeidenBoston 2003, 124.
58 A. Petersen, Dictionary of Islamic
Architecture, Routledge 1999, 2425; J. Bony,
French Gothic Architecture of the 12th & 13th
Centuries, University of California Press 1983,
17; J. Warren, Creswells Use of the Theory of
Dating by the Acuteness of the Pointed Arches in
Early Muslim Architecture, Muqarnas: An
Annual on Islamic Art and Architecture, Vol.
VIII, ed. O. Grabar (1991), 5965.
59 . ,
, -
II, 1956,
14; . . ,
,
2223/19951996 (1997), . 1.
60 . -,
,
, 2009, 86, . 24.
61 . , , 71.
62 . . ni, St. Nicholas, village of
Strezovce, nr. Kumanovo, in: A. Serafimova, V.
Popovska-Korobar, . . ni, J. Trikovska,
Macedonian Cultural Heritage. Christian
Monuments, Skopje 2009, 7881, fig. 3.
63 . ,
, . 69,
.
64 . -,
, 2004, 69, .
34, 249, . 56, 267, . 74, 286, . 107; .
, XVIII
, 16/1989
(1993), 129133, . 6, 8; ,
,
,
25 ,
2006, 269270.
6. /: a) , 1376/77; b)
, 1534/35; c) , 1536/37; d)
, 1591
6. Saber: a) Markos Monastery, 1377/77; b) Monastery of Toplica,
1534/35; c) Monastery of Toplica, 1536/37; d) Monastery of Kuevite,
1591
3.
, , .
,
, .58
.
(1542/43, . 7),59
( XVI
),60 (1591, . 7)61
(1606),62 ,
.63
/ (. 7).64 -
174
a
7a)
(), ,
1542/43; b) (),
, 1591;
c) , , 161722
65 . . , . , ,
,
1994, 15, . 10, 11, 12, 14.
66 . . ,
XVIXVIII ,
1966, 56.
67
: . ,
,
15 (1971), 111
128; L. Stankova, L. Nenkovska, The Manuscript
Heritage of Ioan Kratovski, European Journal of
Science and Theology 5/1 (2009), 1324 (=
h t t p : / / w w w. e j s t . t u i a s i . r o / F i l e s / 1 7 / 1 3 24Stankova&Nenkovska.pdf).
68 . D. Sajdi, Decline, its Discontents
and Ottoman Cultural History: By Way of
Introduction, in: Ottoman Tulips, Ottoman
Coffee: Leisure and Lifestyle in the Eighteenth
Century, London New York 2007, 34; C.
Eritman, Ottmns Looking West? The Origins
of the Tulip Age and its Development in Modern
Turkey, London New York 2008, 40.
69 . S. Shaw, History of the Ottoman
Empire and Modern Turkey, Vol. 1, Cambridge
University Press 1976, 234238.
70 . N. J. Johnson, Paradisiacal
Imagery in Early Islmic Art, Toronto 1998,
1819, 4749; , . , 121.
71 -, . , .
XXIII, XXXIVXXXV; . 50, 6466.
72 M. B. Yazr, Medeniyet leminde Yazi
ve Islm Medeniyetinde Kalem Gzeli, Ankara
1989, res. 244, 261, 263, 292, 296; A. Gacek,
Arabic Manuscripts: A Vademecum for Readers,
LeidenBoston 2009, Tab. 6, 35ac, 52ac.
c
7a) Dormition (icon), Monastery of Toplica, 1542/43;
b) Dormiton (fresco), 1591; c) Sanctuary Doors,
Monastery of ure, 161722
.65
XV ,
,
- .
,
(. 8).
, , , , .
, ,
,66 , , , , .67
XVIII
,
Lle Devri. , ,68 , ,
.69
,
- ,
.70
,
(. 9).
,71
.72
, -
175
8. , : )
, 1673/74;
) , 1806;
) , 1829;
) ,
, 1840
8. Vases: a) Monastery of Slepe, Prilep,
1673/74; bc) St. Nahum of Ohrid,
1806; de) St. John of Bigor Monastery,
c. 1829; f) St. George the Victorious,
Rajica, 1840
a
9. : a)
( ),
, 1565; bd ,
1621/22
9. Floral ornaments: a) St. Nicholas
(St. Athanasius), ievo, 1565; bd)
Monastery of ure, 1621/22
c
176
73
X ,
. Miles, nav.
delo, 332 ( ).
- .
: P. Soucek, Byzantium and the Islamic East,
The Glory of Byzantium: Art and Culture of the
Middle Byzantine Era, A. D. 8431261 (ed. H.
C. Evans, W. D. Wixom), New York 1997,
402433.
74
O. Jones, The
Grammar of Ornament, London 1910, 5676.
75
, ,
. . -,
,
1965, 5972; , . , 1929,
4356; Z. Janc, Islamski elementi u minijaturama
Karanskog jevanelja, Godinjak Balkanolokog
instituta Naunog drutva NR Bosne i
Hercegovine II (1961), 159170.
76 . . ,
XII XVII , 2010 (
), 145146 ( ,
), 160161 ( ,
), 228229 ( ),
. LXXIII (. 203204).
77 . , , 207211.
78 , . , 119120;
,
, 246.
XV . H. abanovi,
Islamska kultura u jugoslovenskim zemljama do
XVIII stoljea, Historija naroda Jugoslavije II,
Zagreb 1959, 602610.
X ,73
.74 , , ,
, . -,75
, .
(1673/74).76
, , , , : (1) -, , (2) - , .
,
.
( ,
, , .)
- / .77 ,
,
( ),
;
.
/, (= ), (= ) (= ),
,
. , ,
,
, ,
XIX .
,
XV .78
-,
,
. . ,
-
177
Aneta Serafimova,
ehona pahiu
XVI
, . ,
(15201566),
,79 , (XVII XVIII)
.80
() -
(, , .) -
. - ,
, ,
XIV .81
,
,
, XVIII XIX .
, , ,
.
178
Aneta Serafimova,
ehona pahiu