DHp'Ht4lio X tt.

'Fi!ium 'in 'c!iU1nIS • ICn fCCDJI&m pl;r(on:ilin cITe" vnigenimrn • & Spirimm S. non df(j. natum aut

. gel1ltUJIl. fcd prcccdeneem.Explicaee aurcm ra!ioncm filij natural.s j non de IiIi.JtlllJH: pet rnodurn origin is, fed de lilr3~iooe pc., modum Ijnaitari5~ qlliJ IiJi.uio orginis non pardI: finC'h~rdi utribui SpiritLli S.dl: lubtcrfllgium quzrcre ~rrori.& verhIS iUi cornrnunicare >'nolllfquc vocum ambiguiranbus Il!hfum Inaudirutn hngetc: nam Ecdc6a non (ohlin Spiriulitl S.neg;Jt dIe genisurn, &: n~tum a Deo,'1uo.d pernnet ad filiatjonem origin!). fcd .bfoluu! negac die Fjlium.M~ ~Jium Filiil pofTe 'dj~i in Trioiuif: qulm vnum , nee alium Patrcm. quam vnum.vr pmc in SymboJo J\tllJn1fi j.YnliJ erg(} Piltt'~I1f1ff tttl Piitru.1i;;tli F,IJIIi.'U/n ~t(4 FilfJ. -Sed in hrc (ententi:! pettll did. NOll vnus Filius, {cd dno filii, vel enam tr~$ (nam cQdemrnodo Pare! dicemr Filius ,.nor:t orjg'n~. led f~naiwc. & communica~ione diuin:!: l'IaWr:t:. qLTia Iiccr non ab alio fibi eommnnicetnr.vere ramen ilI,lIn habet elide idcntirlfc;qua FdillS,t.: Spidrns S. ) ergo rnaf1ifelTi: opponitur Symbolo qUil:cumqnc Hliario pta:ttrvnami plm timplkin:r qi';itUr «nus Fditu. non tres lilij:quociiqnc ergo modo p0r:tllltJ:Ir U'C'~1 VItI duo liliJ.conrr~lcilur hulc pmpoJi(jf;rni Add, {~Itcm in modo loq\lcndJ ,c:tfi in fm[n diucrtatur.

"9 • Sed ramen {i in rebmillis dog~~dds ira lib~ri !ice'at loqui , ~ U ql1~ commurn Imfu omnurm ;ttceprj, (unr. ~ IigJIific~tione l;olUmllni ~ncmur, alio fcnfll accipere. & nonas lingere acc"puIID", Rominl1m ,(ell rerum :dicn~; oi commlfflcbu!I dcnnidorlibllS,vi:t aHquid eel'li in Ecdefiot' ddinitionibllslhre p~)lefir , & fCii1pCr pateb'InE b.ererieis (lIbtcrfii~i:l ~ &: ocm!rari potef~nt ~rrot:s. & palHari (ub Iptcl~ d~Ilerlonim (COlllllon. Ecdcdia aurem qllmdo ;;h'l.lUd .lbC"httc'l cenjjjt. nOD potelt altelldn'~.\Ie acc:epriol}e~ nemln am • alit ad (cnrus pr('lpol'iEiontlm .qui pro Ii~ii'o CIJili(CIl1I'1- que 6ngi vd ac:commodui polIlint. r~d emnes ilbsacupriolles r~icir .. ICD non ~d!hjuir,boc ipfo fJUdd ron ~iqllam fllb mi~ termini5.&' noromibus abfolUfC dclinit , \!'.g. derujnin~t Eccleli~ DOIl efle in Cbritlo pCtfOIUID creatarn eOlltra Ndlorinms fialiquis diceree in Chri!1o elfe petf,;mam crcaram int1:lIigendo nemine pf:r[on:E: DOn inGtllidu;ln1 fubllantiam iDcommlmicabikm. l'E commurum:

.Artli:~ V If.

intdligiE'ur;'&:' dCfi!iir\lr,f~d !i.lbftanrianl vr rllileil~ tathi;UlI vo=! cap:tc~acdd~mifdl'r1~l1ol1rte d~rnllarCIll1:

. ilia propo~do vt de fe oppofira dc:J1nicioni f.-cd!;'r.~.HcctiO:o I1tJllO Cub.t:dugio veUti, occul rart, &: euaderc (eI'lSl! hoE· eticurn ; Similiter Ecdl:fi;l ddi~ flit ~uod cll'ent/a dioina (CIl deltas 1'10·1'1 gene·r;lt~n~ .. q~lc gcncr<lmr,fcd Deus in concrete fn G'.Diiria71'/ur~ dt jllm'l1lt T Tifllli1ft.Si a'utem ;lliqilis diccu:rqllod Ddtas gmtrat,&: gcneraulr (umcl1do gcnerui'on! no po rrigillC',& pro'c(Jiort~,f~"j pro cotnllnicJrilJr PC Cui,~llr rnanifdbri('l1c.;flir J~cbfl'a!ipnc,n il€)uicl pr¢l't~tt:li aJl'j'iltte-dllS dr~t,&!,!o magls dan~nclu51 Sic dkC're Spidi(l S.Filiil,&' g<llli,u Mh (ci:l!hdl.m origincml~d (CCllhdiHIl ilifiilit:atione nullo modO. 2dntim:ndum eJl;:dioqt1lt:l ~ FlIiu}c11,cr~tut Pater non otigine,Ccd Uignitate.quia candf h .ber qU.lm patcr,~iit :ilio !irnili tilll!"; Co:: amrllol, cruut t:ollfu{a in pcr(oD~'r!l~ ncrionrbus , &pto hbitq, ~ fcntl1 cuiulcumque in.oh'lltli. vocabula rl1liraf:nllkll1'.

Nee obllat 9!1od cortct;'dilTTu~ Chrlfhrm df6 4~ (rc;ltur5.non ~bjohm\nc cOfll1cniHl>Il; cum A[riallis,lcd cum addi~o,in qU;HIIL,m homo,&: )f'irimm S'I'(}IT'~ did il1~l,;niwm (unll:'fjdtl ing~Mrl pro (ol~ nc.:g,lrionc g<'niti,docct S Tllo.111.q. H,Ar: +."tI 1. Cur elgo fl!nili'crnofl1Poh;rjtJld Splril!!' S.f !lin~.

non ~bioluri:. nee f~~undilm prm~I[!Olle I)f'gllll"i

fed cum ~d<l ro , in qlrantii IJ.u.:rifiC'lw$ (Jcl(ar~! lh(p dI(: d, fpll£~ ratione ,quia die FiIlllm de f~,4

1;;1; communi 'IIi.! l(lqtl~nCli" (igmtiea~ pwcdIim)e,

t:.. origirla,c~l~m CLU!:1 di~it!!r d,; Fdio ';,!pptluo • &:

tic q!lo"um.jli<:fub~;H~ d~lt"min~[lon,m F1lihEt

de ::.pimu !i-.1c:cnnclum orlgrn~m hu~ mnuralf.« ptnpdam,linc m~t;iphoflc.Jln, ~ adopcill<lm.nulla nIP(iti iliei pOEdt UIOJ; V"ft> .ccfp:io fili~ticni.i r~9' r.\'H~lifii':3ii()ne f.1'1.1 per d;lIi01 fj,1tlld nullo modo diciE <lnalog1am ~d .. rrgrlU'm,nie' f~rioncm orfginit

rahs hIlario habtt ,1i:J foJt'HII cornmutJi",don~ fl::llura: cum lure ,f(:'~1 !=ornmllnicarioilc hzicdiufi!. Ei

fie nomine fill; talis. commllilicniQ non venirinrdligen d, i tlll:ril commulJ~ fenfU: intclligendi {jgnili~ caeum huills nominis Fllitu. At "'1;(0 dfc Cte;ililri inquantit hominem, iJlgeniulm inqa;trtlii p1il1:!.fii gerteriitlone,.non e:lrf;lhil nnmin:ulla :. proprio li~ gnilicart',Ced lignili'awm proplillm (Urn qilad~m, r(.'RriciJone:ltmbuir fubil:ao~ quz rdhit'hu ~EWn

~ VCI" !k prep.i:..

QV j£·STIO

XXVIII.

De Rtlatienilml d;uiniJ.

s Y M sc » LIT T E R ce.

PIt 0 C 1> 55 10. N (B V s ad rei,;niodes relJ:o ordi nc rranlir .'O.th!lnl. quia proceffioncs fe habenr Vt fundamenra reJOltionllm reatir:er di!l:ill"lnum lit

r(!iariones oppolitz;& incommunic;Ihiles (UDt (orm:r: pClfon31es. "

. Duo prz~pll~ capira cratbc D Thorn. in quzfiione. '

Pnmum an finr) &: qUid tim reladones .reaks in Deo.

Secundum quat finc.Pritnu.m ex:pcdit d!lobus prioribus anicuiis. Se.cundum, duohu! v][imis.

In primo articulo affiriIl3t effe in Deo'fe-ales rdationes.

~l:Itio ~fi ~ui.a realitcr Deus eft Pater & F f !iils: ergo tealirer bab~t relationes p~[einj'; ~atls)& fihatloms.Rur(us vbi fundamenta (Unt realiJ, rdl$tioneHefult::utesreales fUDI!lft I?e? d~h[utfllndamenca tcalia t nempe procc:ffl.ones jm,ta ea ildom t131IJf"m, "iJrdlncni

tiimnum;vr oftenfum eft Rrt.p,.cudmti; !:t.go&: rdationes f~aJC;s. .., ..

,. 1,,,n . .i S.TJmlJ.itll.p.llrt,D.Th. Tomu~ alIa, ' K 1 < Jri

f.

84 §}.1!l-Jl· XXf/ Ill. t» Re1ationibrtt diuini!

In z..:l.nie.affinnat quid ant H'hc rclatiollesrcaies, at qua t'calitare;& elfc gaudeant,

ncmpe ipfa realieare, &.e·{fc diuinx. c~e~ti:e. : .' , '.. . . ,...

Rario ca, quia relaciones reales licet 11m ad term,mum; "ere ramen " &:rtahter funt ill fubietl:o quod referunr)& denomina,nt. S7d rdatlOIl(;S, non.poffu~t. melft: Deo. vr acctdcnria inba:rcmia, &. (upcraddi!3) qUIa. ~(1: rricap.tx accldcll:1l1m dl,mna ~ubll:anna,curn non habeas potCI:l!ialirJtcm ad IUa recipicnda. .Ergo [Ll:1t Ip('"! DCl Cubfta,ntI3.

llur,.,. doccw::lationes pJurcs,dTedebcr.e III I?eo, &::non vnarn ta~tulTI: •

Ratio eft, quia relano realis (OIU~l dat~r itt ord~ne a,d ten~"I?Urn realizer ?d1:~n&umt quia eiu(dem ad fc no~. daturr~latlorcahs. ~c:rmim1S lite ddbntl:us non al~qUld crea ... tum exrrz Dcum, qlll:t In:!: relationes fone ad inera , &; ante omnem creaturarm e.rgo ad alrquid diuimun, non abfolurum.quia inabf?ll.ltis nulla dater diftin(;:io, fed Iumma

vnrtaS ~ ergo in relariuis. . ' : ' .

In art. 4.docct elfe quatuor relationes reales , non plures.nec pauaiores. Radoe!l:ql1ia fumdme procejficnes rC:1ics,& quzhbet haber duo exerema reahree dillina-." qux extrema non po(funt cffe nifi relariones : abfoluta enlm tanulof habent vrntarcm: .ergo qu:tlibct proceflio exigit duas relationes ; &: ficdtm lim du% proceffiones, erunr uuacuor rclariones. Non ramen nUi rrcs perfone, quia vna Hl:arum rc!;lrlonurn noll ell incommunicab.lis , (cilicct Cpiratio;!.G\;iua:comrnunicatur enim Patri, ~ Filio j &: fie non con(bruit perfonam [cor(um ab illis.Rdationcs ergo ql1acllorfum, Patcrnius, FJliatio. Spiroldoachll:l) SC Spil:!ltlo p:affiua ,fed perfone funt rres Pacet l & Filius) & Spiritus S, quia in Paw) & FIliI) cit Spiracio aa:iua.

~rt,4f,~ ~rtt&,r.v,:~~rf,~;;v,~~ DISP VT A TIO XUI.

De Rclationibus diuinis,

:A R TIC V L V S r.

1i..llomt:ldo 1fo1ltiIJ Jillina , & re/l:fiaI1E5 Jijl il1gllllntHd

i

v ,,£ in pr;ltfcllti Ie offl:rnnt difficul. tat!:S. 'Ilia: proptc:-r fui aJliniuu:m.&

,R fimiiiwdinem ordlne qUodOllIl 3. DQbiSdgit~nd3! funt.

_ P[il113 t1~ drc;l di"-inlticnc:m r~~

htiotltltU .lb ~lfcmia qualis fit • & quarcnus ad-

milt~!Id~ • 1u~ diBicl"I~$ Iket !:omltlunis liE pro (lltlnibilS attributi$ quomodo di R:ingulnrur ~h c{fCl1ti~.llc. iruer fe• 'pt~ulem Umcn difficult ... - ((Ill in JtbtiDnibus habet, ptopru maiofcm vim qua"'; i~ cis h-lbcI allirm~ijo , &. negtrio , qu~ eft prtn~lplllm diftina:joni~, quia ibi d.1rjmll'l~ appaleI dkmbm comlTlllnicari,non conlmunit3ra relal~on~ in I;C. & arne omncm inu:llctlus 0PCf;I,uoncm,

SeCUn.h difficulraJ elt • dare qu Dd ante imdlclt~m lion d~ltinguantut ab1:lf~tia , quomodo in (1I~. oo~lbus int:ludatnr.:tn c:ifeIlPa, indudaW( In CODCeptu rduionuQ1 • oS:: an [ei;uiolles lint J~ 'O!l,~ftu t(('~Il~iz,~n~on!Dc: Iuc (<:CUIl!U age:

mus m.Jfi·DI: pmnam Ilh;l. .

rtTf/1IIpr~ftlppofilt;m J~ jid~.& lI!tm"" tx phi/oftphill. .

,. Ow in Deo r~L.tione, re~c:s crna fide: tC:nc:n-o

dum .tft HdC: ell ptiIrnlm £(:11 rll~p"t1[llm. D~d '

c~ . L' __ 1 'A' In

... tlln1 rCultontJ t .. .q~ .. !~~In g a. t~blH abro~

~tli ~ cma pbiluCQphia pra:fuppOIiCQdu11l dt &: ... !iHC Thud.~ diCpcndio non vidGtYrpoll"e n:ga.. Q. oUll (~ndum. .

Primum connat ddinitiont Ecclcliz. deducl .. turquc eX SC[ipru[;!. Dc:6nirio Ecclc:lia: fumiru[ jl\ ptimise:c Contilio Tolesane II. if I t~'1ftffio1Zt.vbi. inucnirur r~prd5C nominari tcl.atiOl1d in SanCia Trinil3rc,<=um diehun In rl14t~it 'IItrJ p"fol1ll~lIm n~minibw p"u1'lfJ. FiUHm • FiJiHllld Pamm. Sf;'; rilUJ S .4a 'fJtrtJf'l"1 u/muY;fJrJii cum r~/lltiith1'(4 p"'''! [Mil. ditAl!tur.'V111J ilfrMTl rliftlfrli flY fobp;llltiAtl1&rt~ diw', lir inft. Quod ,ni,n Plm,. tfl, I1IJIJ "d fo.{d. "J, Fifi/jmtft,w If",d Fmw tftl'ml(lld.ft~J.llll P4'1'nr~J?: jimi/illr, &. SfffitlU S.n!)" 1f4 fo.fid Ifd !,,"ytt?(!T F,ftllm 1'&1 II/11ft r~f"illr. ~o 10.'0 rehnotlc$ llJ. diuinls proprio tclationis nomine c:~primuntur. C,t:tmr enam ~d hoc fexta SynodLU JiiplJll b.D ~piaola SophIanij III illo Concilla n:cept3'" ~ CQntiUllffi Laceranenfefub I DPocentiQ 111 • .i, ". FinJlirt1', & Flcrentlnum ftff.l S.d' I ,.I!t. in littl:1'iI '1IlIil1l1;". C:vtulim in his 10 cis non iu e:xprelfum haberue nomen rd.uionjhlic:u£ in pra:dic!l:o Coneilie Tolerane , quia in cpHlola 'Sophtonij djdnlt in SAllEE.; TrlmUft lIfo 'fIt1"1P Tl4tY'"4tn in 'J';b:uf,.b[,_ jl&I1,ii4.non veri! relationis menrio fir. Et in e.Fsrmill~ dicilut clli! hanc Sailcr:nn T riniratem fc:cilndum communem c:!Tcntiam 'i(ldiuidn~m, & (eeundum perfenales proprictarcs diCere ram , fcd relationi! nomen ibi lion c:xpdmimr. {I."d ncqut ill c. D;IJ1l11iUnlU fi'llllf1/i, ybl D,tt dic.atur quod hrn' Eilium gttlrYImdrl foam JilbJiilfltiam ti ddtTi" non tamcn. ;ldditur pr.rrer relarioncm • vr ~Iiqlli ell. illo tC::([1l ciranr, (cd male: ibi cnim non addi~urta1i1l Eani(:uh.ln Concilie FioreminQ,in limru l1nj~tli.4 aicit Eugcnius Papa.quod omnia qu~ Plitti$' funr. fpfe Pat~ vnigcni[Q fUI) .dc.dit .. · .pJZiI;I: dr!: P;l.trc:m~ fcd .n",n dicitut przter relarionem • Iieet die P<ttrem tc!ado littCed a. Poatifice non exprimitut nomine rclalionis. V erum quid~11l dl quod ill fiffiQntJ

. 11.IK.(t J!i'.fJeq~lt~mer nomine rebtionllm,& hy~ pollaCuin n;tllr· Cone ilium, red f~mm1fi ilIis Cd:' fionibus nihil dt:finilhl~ protulit ,Coneilium, fcd (alum diCputationc; do¢lrinal~!l babrnmr.clt: 'I.uibus couthca fllir delmicio • quz pond in Iit(eri, \'ci~nis ab Eugenio polit=lcll:,vbi nomine rel~lio~ nis non. "timr.Similiter in CQndlio Rhcmenfi rub E.ugl;pio Ut.cditum eft qlloddam fymbo4.lm :1 I)a:.

ribQ$ prouilll;ia,umJb~ ci. Epi£:opis, 9bi (Onrn propoIidQ~;S

D ijfulAiio xtt:

propo fi[ iond'S 'GilT:!el'fi ~icitUr.ititcr ;ilb ; N Ie 41~6 t}IIJJJ 01##1,,11 r",flut ttld/fD1fQ,/11H /"0J7neI4UJ dietlln. 'Hr .u/4r~ D:o,&tliiM.111111 ji'1l Dtm, vbi mCl1do reladrliium fir; Sed qtlilmvjm luhc:at hoc: fymbolum illhi> C Olltilij,&: !:In flleri t :1PPtol5~tum ~ Papa; di-

xim ~s pra,d.ttli1JtJ di[p'4.nrr. 6. '.

'3 'C:r:cerllm cammunem efT!: fenfiun E.cdefttt

quod 'rdatiOlll)S in Deo diriltur ad dillingucndas per(onas COI1I1::~t ex modo communi. 'losui:ndi S:.mctorum. Pauam. Augull;f. it 'T ri"it ,c. 8.& " .affirm'" fll~ !Ubjlifflti#T1T. & reltl,i(liifliJ prDrf6 1'1- ftr;r; in 2)tt1. & IJ.dt TrillJI,c.j. i2_1I11d tit VIl1iliellllr 'WI {tcU,'1d;',1i r"fifl4nr~f11,rt!atill; Ji.:'i;nae~iu9 .lib. ti, Trinit. :fla-bet iUam celebrem {ciiremriam. $lIbjlant;d prJId. ~1i,IId/iJ!J. ,.tifftill mlill;pJ;~41 TrJ~ '";'o4I:m,& tn« "141tl",,J~pe ttbtionc5 in Dee dati ·-aairmat. S. AnfdmllJ Ilb.dt1 .. <arJ'iat.r. J. de hoc mylledo la-quens infc=rtpro fntOnllalien'd contu ilium contra q'~em difpuflir. ~tlM 11110.; ertt in D~, nl .. ,i" • (/;' fie pLN1YS """ n'lil1t p"{imi. s. nern~tdns 'Pift.l5Io . .::ontraerror~$ Petri A blyl.u-di,l::Cpith re.pmt ,elatir:m.l!$iw in Dee c;lf~. O('fijqu~ M. fc:ntcntiullm in 1.J.Jj1.!O.& 17- & vniuetlj Dol!c:)"fCI Sc hob.aid. J!,l D. Tll011M" htl. ,".13. &.. d~ni q ue 'Qlilncl C~th(lli,i Dotlorc:;; In hisrdi\rfonibus :;ifkrc:;ndis,&: ponl!lldis vll~nHTljtet contleninm.

4 HiEC autc:m jll~'tEio c:r. ip(a S(;riptur~ d~ducftllrf

qU;i: c:Uidc~t~f rdoltiuis nomillibu~ cltpl,icU p~r~ fonannn dliliodioIlc:m, Vt IJ;;ms. & Fllfl, vr cum dicitu. 'JJ"pli~mu e~r in 11tm1me Patr". &- F'/i-J.& SpirillU S.M;)rth.1 S. T,,(,j (lI;rt qUI tefl,:,i!mtlm d.t,,,, ;'H'~ll!.P"ur,Y"bllm, ;iF Spirr;.",S. Lioln.vlr.&' multi:! aliis lod~ e:c qUlbLlS mylie-rillln Tnnlcarif cQlligimr. '" nemine Patris • a£ FdJj lignllican1t. llhs allt~U! nOmiDlbllJ :J1'lld nos '1'clationc~ ielplic~lltur. Patermim;& Fd'IlJ rdadue drcumur: ct'< eo in diuinil en.am jntlcni¢UUlt relauooes, {tU geIIU$ rdariullm,hquidem flomina6gnijk:ltlti~ rc:1.ltion1l:s pafonil alligrunttJ\.'. N 0[1 'POifUDt aueem iIlit nominibw: Jign,lic.m ,datlonC:5 ijcl.r,fcll [<ltio~ niS.tUIll quia pnanitas , & liiiatio apud n05 relstioncs ~C'a1Cf {UnI::ergo GDeoatmbllu[Ur pJ;"oprie. &noll mc:~pboricc. nee in 'o,dlne ~d creaturas quz funt e:tna fe, fed jn ordine ad pl:,fona!l~qnr dillUU~ funt • v tiqu(: fc;;!les rel;1dQllt:S.1ttr.blli 4=~ bentjtl1m qlliOl DellS rc:aliter ell Patc:r.& Filim non Bd:c,/3l I"lllm fceundum miQnc:m. '!lih dfet in l'c: (anuim vnum & idCIU PUe:. & filiu,. qUia nOn ,ealitc1'.fc:d P" imelled:E1m wccr«ur Patf;t', IX Filiu5; atqu~ adco !Jon realitet" dlilingutrC'nlllr Fi.. JitJ5,&' Parer in dl'c. & ratU)ac: pc=(~ooor. &:: 1lIi1led minih in ipfa. f<llionc diUmirniJ. lell perfectione abColuta • qllz diuidi non pou::11 : cfgO ent eadem pcrfona id quod dicifU( I'atct. &. Ftlius,'1u~ cft ~~(c:fi~ S~bdiiiUU. V nde- e'ilplimuur magiJ ba'(: r;.UI;),qma de lid.: ell perfolU.I dillingai rc;;!lifer ~ ergo fccundtim ;diqU3Ql realilatcm.q~ lid" t'rm.5c non in alia. Sed bz~ tulirasnOIl potcll eere ilh(oluta , qui. .. lie diuldm:tur di wna cfimri3l~ nee dfd" ead~m DumefO in per10nis fed diueru • quod ,c-fler pOllere plures Deo~=etgo eli rcaliu~ rd:niU2. Tum J.eni.qlle quia. in di\linls d.u1U" reali$ prOCc:ffio. &: origo,.utUf e-nim g~niru~& gene;;uls,cr!?U dafUt rafl:' fundamenlum rdanonurn , wr t:tum rer~ minlU dillioetus. quia dUur perfonz dillifu!l:a; i~. Ira. Dalm: Ergo darur quidqu;d ttquirirur ad talem rcUnoll;m. (cil.rca.le fWld~nt~fnumj&: £~r~ nUnlU.

S '. Secundum quod (uppoSllntlt c=:t ma:aphy6.ca. . &" lnobistnibtum db17ugicif. QI4.1'7.;m. 1- eft -hri 'leru tCbtio~ tul.e~ dinind:1$l ge;ntr'e :l.b~ £bluto tx meru:e S. Thom~jqw tzpct dQ~;t il:iario::

.41 ; 1. . :n.ftrc. ,.

:SJ

'i1C5 ~lTe :,iccidl;"mia in'b:.erel1'tia 'fiibie8'o ,& ira dr'fiincta. quod f~dilnt (Q'mpo/lrionem ~Ilm Cubic .. aoo Videaitir in '1.dijl. H .qU.l :.tft.J. in fine corpo •

.'ri!j vbi inquit, /17 re/ifti911lbH4 'r~AliIiJu ,,[ilia 41 eifo UUlljURU,& jHbj1i1lfiitr.'1u"« r~fn'tlP'j& liko aiefllltHr 'ifitJfo ~ & ftcliridJtfn 'fkoi:l. iflf1W , ilfmp~foiuj'Jtm flZffHht lIe';il~ntu Ad r,)bleflMl.,Er i17.~'t: ".,ar;.2., tit t~7:Rd/Uio,ifl(lI11r,jtcili1dkm ,14l1d 1ft MddmJ.fl. ~ft iT1h~ytI1J fllbi~Eio, ¢r bJh:iil tJ/i!,dCt:idOililit illip_fo:Ji.r. idem dO(;I;~ ;".£1111'''4 Gtmii.c.'I'f. tifta '1.I'''/j,O''t*~

, & Q{l.S.4e p~flfiii.t iI~t.r. '~z omnia ibi prClbauimUg,nUD ex ;n~[lItaHbu""ft1m ex 'Ebeologll:u. ('It. 'C'x hoc my/h:tio in qllo re'i;uio'lH" re'lle, IIltl~'niun;' rur, Ec ill hoc'dicJrtJU5 I'lonpoffi: fin-c Thcoro~iz difpendio l!egari relnricnes r(:ales pra:di'~imc:nt<1m t~,reu fi;cUrldt'irtl cae,&.' qua:;pilr~ n:I~[fOliC$ 'fine-, lIee polfe e.:plic:ati tationcm rdiciortis. (ohlrtl pet conceprum V11il.l'.c·xm:mi ablohm cum ·connora. ticne a ftcrim, vd cum exttinf.:.:.i dmommacionet vc aliqui 'puralJt r Nam ha:dm~gim.io(lickf .. lso) .poller in creati~nllgi > in'dininls a~tdm 1hIn[c:lia~ myllcrio Trinirari5,llon pareLtNam Ii rc!iI;fio;noll cit alil.!dqlJam duerum abColutorum affiarn,i:.Jt~ connlllatio> vr 2'qn21im efi: dilat ql1antiratc~ non (c: escedenres , Ot"flilitudc Qua: (jtWhatc;: con~ n'ienrcs , dol. mibi intra Deum duo eXtIC:iIJ.a rcalira diHinaajquorum l1!lifri:ttda. &; confWfif.a Ic:I~ tionem cOIla:kuar: ham...-d JIb. e~m:llIa ditlin& f!lnr rd;l.ion~.vd ilb(alurz cnritaEeJ. G abfoh.lt$. dillidiJ. & difl:inguis dfmu:un in coin 'quo ab(o·

. Inca dl Si timE ff'btiom::$ ~ li:"rg:o nen in cOnnonfione,&: c;oa.ffilhmEia dliorlJm '::OIJGrut {c:b.rio. ftd Ult¢" ipeam connontiollrn1 f'l~c:ti, tdatiODCJj 'lllia ipCa ~rrcm.t qll:e c'!nnotatc:; Ce- dcbtl1t.-:. &. coaJIk frere, non nH, per rarfoncm rdariuam (Ilorre .. liiet diiHllcb,lIon aurem per :iliqllid :Jbfohmlm. qlri& bee non cli nHi ~Il~tn i'i1, d~uil1if~ ~1~.£Ie in De-a danrur C!l;rftlIla tca-lm:t dllhntb J yu:ielicC'f pm()IlZ,&, d~ntuI "criam rdationel 'rc:l~. ifia cxm:m.t rum dilhnguufitlll' P" ratioc¢:5' ~h(olutu • qnia quod lIbfohuUID dl in Dee, dilHngui non pO[t:a~ qu ia.opponi non po~fhJ.iG:ingu lUltJ;n etgo p~ r~ Iationes ~ t:tgo POll pore-it tclatw in diuittil cordifierI;" in connot~njoflllr;3Qt aIliJl~i:-j~dllorumC!:uce5 morum • vel dellominaEiooc: t:x:tdflfcca illcCQiU7 qUia c.!Cm:m~ ipr3.int«qa~ dwen¥fel:onnotati'Oj. non runt "'trem .. dilHnCh,nili peti"C'utiollc5jan~ connoc;ltionem ergO' dlJortun ditUnc:blfo; & tic rebEio non poreft aat~ in compolirionc aut auf· firtrntia <;Iuonlm clmcmorum ab[oILlrOr!l~ , dim in dillinis line dilii nd:iol'lc .. b(ohuotum &hun u.Di:ar per dillinmonc:m ip(arum rd.uiollum. Rcfa.. liollt:$ crg'o aliquid iUllr prilm:r connomionem abfolurorum. if IicL1c in diuiniJgclnlf ril!luiuuni JnuenlrlJf dilUnctum i (onno!~rionc, & competitione abfolllromm. ii:. in ac,twri~ ralarWiJts prz.. Hicam~JltaleJ aliqllid (unt pr~fer plllri"um abrollJ-o torum f;OPIlOt:OIriOllml,.& przttt SI.'IlU$ abtDllIttlm, fc:n pfa:ter vnanl qucdqut: ~tol!ltum in ordinc: ad Cc:.Et boc: ipfurn vfgcH1r ex ThealogiJ:,qlria lloA aim fllndama)[o Cone-ilia. &: Partes ddilliunr in dillinis diui tdztiona. &dil1inglll OOIl f«1lI1dun\ abrolllt3,f~d przci~~ CC'cI.II](him reLuionC1. q~ia hi Scriptu!:15 figQi6.t~ntl.tr pd,onz hOmiPibUJ rd~ dull,fcil.pauu,& 6lij,&'" MID ipfilOl Qomcn ~ tiQnis in .sttiptLlla. noh aprimirilr: ergo Ii paie4 & filius apud '1101 npu ugruhGnr oUi nucma abfolnd ellm COlli1QtahOnt • feu iknominadone u-trin(ec3, eD2Ill in mmni$llon pon~rdarion[!;fj rca r-lntUm eXttdnaabfohlta '!I~ COJUl.LohGn(~

quoa cit pol)Clcd.,rum·l~~~ ID. ~b{Dhu.IS.. s-

, NCIl obJlil qaOd fonna_ ,ulll'UIj1. ""ifgnt II

. 1\ j ~~'t~.c.

§l.t!£jlio XXVIII.

conlicnire, Onlnia, qli:l: de ic\atiuis dicuntilrj Gn.~ itbl. cntitiltenb.tiua (uperaddlu. (olum pet pltlull lIbG,ll1torum' poGtioncm J &: eorum ~~nnota?o.' nCill,jicUt polito patte gCDcrante. & filio g~n~to.

'We rorrRalitCI,& propric di: ~ater,qLlia fort11~uer "g4!'I1Uit,dlc filius. ,'quia f"rmalltt:t prlJ~c~[ lib dl,? , & tamen Pard: qui gencrott,&: ge!1(:mlolp{a;&:.~"

!ius qUi genirus efi,aliqllid ab{olufum Funt : politiS

, . dllabus qJlantitarib(I~.ji:non e~cc:de:nuhus Jotm~ljt~r ::tqualcs fam, qUI). formalat('t ~na Don eft mrnor alutr~ : ergo formaliter {Ullt a:quales, Et ide~. ell de dllobu$ lilTlihbus , & de qmbuCcutnquc= 'alns .rdarh.li5' sup.crl1ue ergo ponunmr Hb: cndf;lttS tdatill;'t" fllpc!~ddita: ,Ii line ipGs eotum exercetur, quod nos per ipfas cXCrCef! pon imd 5: .

Refpon. quod lin~ clltltat.: rclatlua; rc[nltanre non dict:ntl1f de iIlis ~xm:mls omnia,qu:J: dicunfur pnfi!:I illa eI1tiralC relatiua i deeR- cnim (ahem. vuum pr~dianlll1'fornla\c'ccil.rtfpici~nti:CJ &. or.do • 'qliO comparalur vnum o;ucmum ad :dme!. Nam polito Pam: gencranrc.& .gent'fationc.&: Ji~ 'lia'geniro,lIlc dicicu~ Pater, &: ifte Jilins cau(aduc}. 'non rebtiuc;fund.lmcnralilcr,non fonnalitct ~ dicitllr enirn ille homo clluf:IIU filium,1l011 ram ell di .. (irur tdatiui:;& formalitct pner.foIlllalif.:l.fc cern. paulina. £t dUll: qUIDlii.:l.Ei:i ita eenuenienres, qUQd nulb.: ell minor altl~ra. (unt du~ qll3.llfit-ltcs ·:zqualcs qLianti~tilla ; nan rd:atiu~.fund2~tntalirer, non·fonnabtcr ~ & Vn:i, non fuptr:at ;h~m.ncc eft minatiHa ,cntita!ille; &: quoai:lqllantit:uem, non rcla.tiuc,&:per comp:l[arioncrn tealem:tonftat enim hOl:non.h~bercminu.s de quantitate, quim aliud.led non ordiDatur:ad a1iud , nee re (pici i illud ranqll3~ non minlls,& infcriut ilia. quou!que h.1- -be~t rcl;l:tiuatn emiut~rn, qua formalit~t erdfneeur ergll iIllld. Sed tceum'boe pc:ninct ad fundamenrum rebt~onj5, ·flon.:1d ipram ,fotm3litatCfl\ fcfpi-

, (icndi,in qua cOIl{jt\:ic rclariotfed hoc luber per entir.:1tem tdatiu:lm (upc:raddir.lm ad· connocarioneln •. & dillinGl:ionc:m cxtremofum .ab{olu[o~ rum,

JltlRlietJ~s diuin4fol. t'lftiDII{' Jijlin~ gllim:ur "b eJfmtlll-

7 De hoc pun~o egimu'f7'~td,t(mfj}Jjffi+lU't.~.

agendo de djftinaion~ ;lttrihutonun rum infer te, '11m lh tlL:ntia.Rd.niong tnim licCt non computenrur inter amibut1" quia 3ttfibura cemmunia {unr olOnthUi pl:f(anis,&: ad ;ili(olutam pClfe£!;ionem pettinclit.pc:nonut's ~ctO relarienes lion, tamen qUia diuinz (unt,& intra Oc:um rcpcn;e. eodcm diuino clf~ gludct~ debeDt fi~ut attnbuca, '" Jic: en~ idem cUm elf~ntia.. B~euiur dieo ell: omni~ hIl.s dilUn&ionibU5 quz inul:niri pol'funt (110$ ptO~ ,~ilr~ Author~ • qui al~uam ex illis tcnuer-im d;lri mrc:r :!.tttibun. inter cOenriam;& n:latiQn~s. Eft enim dirunClio mills. Gcut intM dU25 (t.$. Eft di~ '~D,aiQ.l.bc:ldalis JiaJr inter r~.&.tnodultl • int« : . cffiom:m. &; (ccknttm. Ell diftintiio forn13\is a~5.qu, nimirUQ"I :ante opus imclldl:u$ Vnum .... 011 anduilit ;diud.EIl: dilliilCUo rationis cum fun~DlCIl'O iD~.'IUZ "a~t diftinttio rationis r~l1OCiJ1~. E~blmiqll.c diIkmaic; t;1rignis Ii~ flln~lnmf(t IInc. quz didtw miQll,iHatiol;i-

llanoS. '. :: '~ ':

Prinum dill:intlio~ Etakm~. eRemi~m . " pnfolW.(cn rc1:uioncs p~rukGilbmus POrte:

t~nus.Vtm"m. S.Tb~bit.m-.I .. Ef~ip(tnn

, . d:: :r::r ~~mtt Ilidoc~'.~udt,erus. qUi- '

~,J ~"~ • .-l1li« I: mnun.~,mnbl1u. 41)./' '._ .t;JI!dit\:in{tiQJu:m ~.,yt~Suarcz

J":': --:. i

· lib. I ,de ej[ehfis: Dei «. (0 .• & V:rlqlJ.Mc dlJ}. f r6.M,.

Spccialitct tam en Gilbertus·l-oqucbatur de diJtitl~

· etiene: intCC" rdationcs,& dfc:nthlln ; ilWi. de ;!nti~ buds, {jc:ut Gu~lterus. ··In ilia camt"ntlHlinfHDuc:

I'tlarionu1il ab c::H~mia idem fenfillC!vichiillrc:uin Gualtcro,licet Va('luez mum l1. {cllli iftadit1jfi~Ho-

De liberare conerur dlJ}. Uti'. . c •. _ " . . • ~

· .Sccunwm difl:inaionemmoddem porukDu~ . undusin I.dfj1.".q.(.&d1lb.4.q.:t;· . . .

" 'Tertiam dill;inaione~ po[uit Sco>tlt.WLJijI. 1-.qulfp.,. ,.Sea hie 1ejlllt. & tbjl. S.fjll.+·/k ;I;lb.6.I:JH~. & aJiis.locis qUit prt«ed.tWllJ>difP.'t·Ilr1if;,ci4

a.uimus. . .. ,' '" r , ,"

Q_uMum dHl:inClion~ ponlt fJ. Thorn .. 10-quen, de attributi$ in l;dijl.2,~9u'.J'lin'3.,'Bi; 10- qucns de petConis;& ell"eilfia in hllr'f/u.4rf .. ".tk qll. ~9·lIrt.1..;rJ.1.& it! l,ilifl+l;dJ,u,ilrt'-I,.,d:z.: Edequulllur c:ommllnitt" T:homilla:., quos 1(I&tI titlltfl

addu)!:imlls.·· . ' ,,-.:

, ~intam ditlilltliont'ffi tenuerunt aliqlJi quos rtfen D.Thom,in J,difl;2..tlll.I.Al"t,1. c.2mque af~ tribuir Auicenl1a:. & Rabbi Moyfi. & eam vldCll.~ mr poftd [("cllti Gr~gofilU in l,dij1,S''1U.2..Arl. f. & 1. & A11[C'olu5 ibuiel/f41,ie'.t1.qllo1tC:nlis '{olihn t.;uiccdum dillln{tionem in mnbutis 'lU;E eonnoter dilictfoi.,!fctlU5 ig -ereseuds , ~1 pane vera. Dei nihil eiJ eottefponde3t ~ ni4 diucdira.rDo" milli5.

Contra primam Icntendam Gilberti afhlm en S in CondliQ Rb~m6 ulb Eligenio 111. &. ,bi damnm &1: propoIitiO G!lbc:rri.qu~ tali$ c~:Jt,quOd :Tl'"tJ p_~tfol1'" [Rift lr~ rill 6tmlJe, &- .. d ;nflimn <Ii Ji"inA fobPtlnri. in mtmmJ a.~l'tnUil.Si numere diffecunt 3 diuina (ubfiantia : ergo realuCI; sb JlJa djf., fefUdt,& cl;:uin{cc::t iIIi (unr. Vndc: ad tomprimE6 dum hune errerem , & cxpungc:ndam propolitio·nero Gilberti, primo cotnptl'fiturn ell (ymboluqa

ab Epi[cQPis prou.inci:mlm inreruenm S, Patti, Dcrn.:lrru; qUi In Concilio illo pr.tkns fuit.&: po;. tir;! fuk eJ( aduerfc hee prOpallrlQ ;quod N utk y~ IlIti~tt" ]iHt pTflprrl!fllrt4. 1111 "IInmf/~ pMlIl1t"llr > 'ItI~ foil um1If, (!J' n4n [Wi Delio. Elt quo dare confiabat rc1adoms,feu FeICOnas a diUID:L lubtbnti~ rtaliret nO!l'dllferre; fie enim nOn ciTc:nr DCU5,fc=d ahquid ditler(um i Dee, Sed tamen quia hoc iymbollllQ non ~ideUlt fuUfe ~ Concilio accept:Utltn. Vt e% 'OthoncFrilingeuJi doce~5eUCl"inus Binills ill TIll';'

Ad ;OIlJ.:CDheittll11J;futll' :J. COI1(;il;in ,..p. Cub Eugenio, Ill. co quod /ine 1nlCrurntU C;I¥din;tlium ab EpiCcopis fuc:rit 1:00 fj;crum,qui de hoc "alde 1:011- f;JutUi !unr llpud I?ontifict"m, tam~ vr ibi dicitut eire;!, vnaltl ell: propo»rionibus Gilberti fie Pond~ fell: acnniuiE. Nt ali']"" rllli, ill Tht(llogill(id eft nullum argumcnunn.anr ftntenti3~ vel opitIio) ilf~

rer ptrfo'/~71I>& tJfimiAm drtliJmt. nlut! Delli Ji"i~

1'14 ~JTt111jA dinTttfii" in Cit!" "bIRri"i tIlNtiI111;{td tti~ tI~jn"/;fli : id ell quod abftr;u'la pr:rdic3~t!"ntur de concrcds in'nominatiuo> vr quod Deuscll delcas (en diuina :ellcnti;). •. non vera {olt'tm in ablating. quod drnate dl: Dc!.u:.Q_uu:e non dl dubirandum quad. Gilbertus iUam kPtcntiam tc=nnm[ de dr • 'ili!lrui)n~ per(ofl3ulm ab dlenti3.licer poReA teo cantOlUmE • quidqtiid Va.(qul:7, hie ;lifp. J 2.f).rJi: Otmnf dttlffJ. velit ilium ab h:u: femcntia.,cxoncufe. Magis.cnimercdiidllm cllipl'is Allh. f-lSymbolo

a S,Bcmatdo. & Epili'opis confctlo:conna Gilbetrurn,& D. Thom.bie 111"/. 2..& D .Bonaumtlirz • Aleundro de Alts,& aliis anriquiotibu5. qui propinqui fU~lunt ttlllporibus Gilbcni, &. in ci(dem. locis CJuib!.ts illc. vi:tefunt. & documrnt; qrulm V:t(qun crcd:at Otboni. qui falllen non.Qmnia gea

lb. inillo Concilio. ;tUt ~ Gilbc:uo ajfeIta.Qblig*

. bai:uc

lJifpJlt4ii"o XltI. " ::ar'lic. IJ. '. ~-, ~i:' .

b:1.tur n:iirlitc:in'hihciria (U:I. Vnde Sitare!t Iib·4.d. aidr: Om;;i;' fll#1II1ifU' :bdbit P;;iir.~li.JtIl,jt,~r~:;;"7,"" Tril'1iratec.,.;jure inuehirnr ill i!los.~ui :xifl inHIJt 'tir f,tneYAll0l1ro11 1'14 II_on.figrliji&,1f/ [u!ijllfliiIi. diffi'.'

S. Thomam, & l!onlluent. h~c imroL1Jifle Gil- 'TtlJtilltn,l1{fjflf dtglfit.tHn,ftd m~liHitJ txi1f.fitl~. ~

berro. , '. . C.l1• bi'gtJfirull1,fS1.elfiuim. &1'rq~tffibih f/OJfltib4

,. Conllindnk aUrtm manifd!:emorhic, quia jhilll;4flmljignifitlfmiif,·,pdiii:ul/HI. ,,!il.iHH;tl'n~fl

vel p~rf""li: diuin:e [unr u:alitilres Creara: , vel in- h,.bimdi;m, &' tXijJtTiti4 m~ili. Ergo,pcrlOOii'mli-

crelra;:. Si c.ea~a:;noll ~r per[ena: Dci,fed{;tlb: dum fignilic.:lr. '&; r£nquam mOilusd,tl:insltitlnl

ab ipfo,&-ini:iditurin ha:rdim Arij, & M~c~dg... {ubltantia. c:J1cntik. Sitnillrtr S.Augt1ft:7,J" Tri..

"ijSi inercm:::ergo funt Deus. & aCluspurm tii- Tli/lltH.I. inquit. qUOdO'IJIlM:tis;lf~ .~tifri,fji Ji'i.

hi! porenrIali(,uIS habenres : ergo non dilHngllu'll~ 11I1',(jJ ,,!i'l(lid fxnprl! rtlitt/uofi;, 7'(l4ti~llt. 'Ex 'lttO

eur ab clltimC! • & c::lfc dillino,quia eire: diuimull condLldir quOd fnPanc :pt:ttcr 'p~tcrnk;ltemi:a:

Ct\1tJ iiI i'1finiEum.& "ehls punu.omoem radoncm aliquill, f~if. dfcnria. Et if! (.0:;. d,cit,qllod N M1 1ft

diuin.1in ill v"ic~ ; &: indiuilibiJi ,adone- condner. ideJA D~/l1flqfl,& Plltrim lifo: ergo patc::miras. k

nee pcr cornpofiriollem fibi aggrcglf: U Milt! in ,1dtJ$ [ccllndlilt] bc:!ium AllgldllllordWlt.p~i1:U¥

fila ratione at!:ln puri. & diuinl1: n~nl~ non irrue- Id~m.Ec idem docec fope,. I'f;l,f;b8~, :,' .

nic,ur omnc quodditlinum ell. fcd altquiJ;tb ill:!. R(:'(pon.lld principale arglimetl~Urn. 8c ad fc-' IS'

dillinguicur, dql~e adD!Cliire putdl,iam in ilIa (lia eundem (cpliram di: hh quz Ilrnl ~de'm ,vtlft"-

ntiol1l~ , infinira: perteet;oniJ, ,& purlmh non cft. rio. (~fj~ filpcr{lfJe 1 iiobis athml cllC',& {Qhltll'm

~quidem ali~lllid.iUi. d.c:efHn iIIo (00(9',11, &r~- arf.~.pr"ml. E, it;ntmv~lIic fc;ltI1:nd~~lIa prim ..

Iw.cc qu~ ~dllcmrc dh po~cft. E~go dlcclldum ell replica pro fe-menna ScmJ: eadem emm funlb ..

quod eff~lltia,& pc:r[o"~difHngnj nonpolI'ullt.li memo nirimr., VI" ",iam adUeHimIUP1'o(C'tJ. iO~

ip(z p~tfonOl: inw:;ac-:e (um. Vndc tandem ccnfir, Jifr'4'R~f,6. vbi hzc omnia foluc:dunt. Br~uit~

quia inter eIfClltj~m,& rd<llionem non 1:11 oppoli- djcinlll~. ad ilIam alhnnationcm • 8c Deg.Hioncrn

rio, IlcqllC rel,atiu::t. qui;i jjOmill~ dlcntia: flon cx~ fuffiec:re ,liaintiionclD ta£ionl~, V~ doe~t S. Thom.

pliealUr ;!Iiquid ,orr¢l~ciullm • fcd id fuhim quod i'ifY''1II',9,Jlrt.t.IfJ ~. &: iii •• dijl.J;r,''1H.14,rr.I':..4

ab[olunlm cit, nc-qlle prilnuu;J.. aue conrt:ltia vel 1.1l01l aurcm fcquiri dilHnttioncm ,,!!!(Iidem in tl:'",

ncgatiua.qllia hz' omnia limi!:ltiollc:m) & impcr- {cd fillndr in!e die fundlmemaIem. • '~ cmincn.:.

I fctlionem impol'unr : aliqll id enim dcclt vni tMcm Jilhnetiom:m, id ell, nm {antz ~imn~

I;fudd eli in :dio. l!l ~ COliua ~ ergo null:! C:lt di~' qll1J: :tqlliLlalcat pluriblU rt bus. qujhu, ¢omH:ni[lI:

llinClio • quia hz~ fumbcur in ali'lUi 'oppofi- diucr{z il~ ) &" oppolir~ (q_ndiuones. Jra fl\iUCil

uone. qnod qnando propofitlo n~gatilJil pon~llr,llOn ne-

! I) Eodem fundamcnro expungimr femcnri;l Dn- get prordl,;mun de rubktio fccnM,im omnem ra..

rmdi de dillintiicne mod.li illter effrntilm. '" rion~m,tti;lm rc~litcr;& identiee,{l:'d fohlmin ftn:.

perfon:u. QJ.!~ modus iIle fie modalircr difiinClw- fu forma!i • fjCllf c!'lm di,itur Pacct gCllcrat.diiruo-

Ii 1WU1"1 vel ell efelr~s • vel inCf&:aruJ. S i (fc~nlJ {tU cffmcia nOn gtnerat. rb ncgifiua. vam\:;lnIC

11011 porclt narutatn diuinam allie-ere. & modi6ca. in (enfu fOfll1ali.id ell.cll'emia. vi! deisu'ilf~teDl#

re : dlh mim m:lgn2 impcrfcetio modi6cari, 8{ figniliC-;UUf tali modo .. id eft.in ~bllr,,&; 8& 'I"il.

informni aliquo cteato. Si Eft incl'~:uus.cll ;jailS prupoficjoncj , .Ii :lb{oIIiIC pmfermrut' • (emp" m

puruJ! ergo {llmma c:ntitu: ergo non eft modLU 1tmll form~1i p,ocedollc. idro abfolinj.ncgandunl

qui eft infim4 emir:!s, "" minor 3ccidentc,(ed (ub· ell qu3d dfenria vel deiras ge'n~t • fianmg:anii;

Randa, qua; ellnobilior. Q!:od Ii (ubfrantl;t., vel in Concilla La[C:l'~n('nti c". J)1VRIf __ ; .It ffl~

dillinguemuQlirttabelfemiadlUina.&nonfllo- 'Trmir, Cx[crnm ncg.:itiu:J. in (cn(u identic:o.dt

d1Ii,Cl: tannim,& illddirur in errerem Gitbcni.vd falfa,vt fi dicarur. Nllll:l res QU3!: dl: cficmia gme.-

ell: omnino idem cum d('itJ~e c=ffeurialirer,& fo[~ rar. & in-concerto. Dew: oon genaar. fallZ fWlft,

mali.ter,& lie ~I!: falCa fentcntla Durandi, parom- quill tfii-Iltia diuina eft 'fe~ iUa 'ilia: gmef.t.Q_~

que dillar 1 Gilbmi fe-nfll. ad hOG non fcqnirinlt diftinllio rtalis in :lau Jnm-

.1 f 'Fulldamenta Gilberti (unt. qnil aJiqllid conuc- ilia c11rema, i~d ftlffidt mlinemialu, qr.um {t"d.~

nit p(:rfona:.quod non lIatllr~ • &: boc non per in· dem res {ir limnl clfmcia, & rcla~llnJl:' ~ c"x vujp( ..

tellet} um nOlt tum, (C'd in rc: d ieimus enim '111M qlll! g_enerinblolml, & rdatiui munus ge-.at. &

perfona ge-ncra~ .• non n3mf3,ptr!-O?;l f!lij cll i?ear~ quia cfien,ria Il~~ ~oJiirn ell Pmmir2s. qll;e ge~

l1ilf<i n~n drCntI2~a-go habrnt: dilhntbonc:m In reo t.at. (l'd ([lain nh:mo • qu~ ~c:ntt~[UJ', i4co diamc

Er ad ldem rtdudrur qnod proponj[ DurO!llous. qllod tJoU eft ad~quare p:1mni{a1,fd ~a;non dHo-

quill ex nuur .. rei,' &" anre ncgofi:nitmm1 inr~lJe4 h'lm p:arcmifa~,ncc eft :id~qJ1atc Jili'ltio.(cd vrmm..

am parer dl formaJitn' pat« per parcfniuftm, :It que limul. Ec ,,1m inn-rt Dut.;nduJ qUQd ell iii

~on pet ~~e'uiam.all;h non dillillggcreetlr forma- plw: c.llhni.:2,qulm Falemiw • difl:ingl1o • in phu

Ilttr ~,Flho,tl('c peT tlf~nciam r(~!r • &. ~PFoni- i~l:micc,& ,f!li:Jliret • Ilc!~o (eft t'I! 1m eadem. bmpfi_--

mt Fdlo.fed per parerrtlt2rcm;eflama 6qd,dcm eJl:affi~ n:~bta5' fonna1ltl:r ex modo figndlc~ndl' eriam in Filio. V nde effentia ell ill plus \f1l:1ID pa- tr:lnrcar. Et nob dico formalitcr. fQt~;lluatc {edi

tcrniraJ,qllj,,; p:uunit;lS ell elfenria. (cd elf s=mi:l dl IJillintb , '10: eft modulI fed fo.maincr ex modo

p;!t~nit:l$.&" a1iquid phu.(ciL6Jiario.ad quam nod figni6L"andi, quod in canan .e:t.lit;trc locum baNi

~xrc:nditur patcmiras. (~d iUi opponftur. & hoc tU- proprcrfl1a1l1 {ummarn emiw:~nWn. E~ ad con(~

rom in re: ergo aliquid iu re ell p;ttrrnirou quod qumri:un.quOd ,CUlJt eadem vni rctcio, {!ce. Ok"

non dTtntla.lf~m f1uzeumqllC funt C;ldem VIIi tC!,.- quOd defelhu illig, fyllogifmi nCn dl iii mlnori~

~io.fimr i~£Ul ~lirct ~tet fc:Ced rfCS ~C'~rDn:J;"fr.mt fcd iii maiod mali jntdk~a; & ~I<. ~Ctt ~oil~

ldl=nl te:lhCel JR ClfroU3, qma non d'illmguumUf t}1Iroti3m d£fe-tluQ(:!.m. Naill fn3!or mrell1gtndt

ab ilia per ft:ngo {untfdtm R~lirainfer fe.Con- til de- hisqilz {unr eade-m vni retno fube:ad~m:lp~

fcqueni ell b~eria~m ,: er~o ~li.'JiI:i pr;t~ifr.uum pd~:lrioru:,&: fOfmali~rc: .. non [ljb diu.rra, Ifc ~~M

f21ra.Non malor,ql~a eft pnuClP!llm lumlnc. nam;: ~() ~odo mint ndrm IllJ" (c quo flltfJ~f l,P J~I.

f:lh nomm; ergo mlllot; & fic dieendllm eft quOd trnlot& nbn alirer ; & iii; pm"l1~ aunc id~ID ln~

diftinglluntur l=lfrnria. 8( rdariones. Drniquc: fa.. ra (c C!I1Cnriali'~. nOD rcl.uiue ~ quia (olUm fune:

ciunt pnl DurandO' aliqtl~ authozlfaru ex Dam;1- tadcm vni [uno tlnen.iaJiru,nOD r(ladu~~ Yt f(uZi~

G;CIlQ.8c. Antult. N~m Dmu[c. UlM.Jidci c.,. fK lIus Ui.&~us Jifp1r.,td"'f~'.

:'~-~~~~ ,

,.' .. 88

d, ~"ft.. XX/? Ill.

.... if" Ad ~ea S. Dllt'l&~ni, Be Auglilt.. Re(pon.nuJ.. . lartlllt5 has Panes dlctcre pufooas eKe mo~os,&:

nOll [ublb.nriam ipLam diuinarn I exptcfsi- CIlII]) S. ·AugulklJb.,i.,u T~II!'.c.~: .diCit C~mdJci1tJf16 pe,.flu,/j PAU'fij •. no" all" awmlll '1''1IM .(lIbftdl1l1,!~ '((.'r.4. cUm e=tgo D:lma(ccn. gcm:rauoncro OtClt elfe !noduin,Don (Llbf!~n£ia: dilfct~ntiam.& quod inge:nitunI;& gCllitllTll n,on iilbfl:tuti:t .Wpc ~guifi·4l'illa. fed modi, '!oqUIPlnle his notlon:dlhus ex: patte modi 1igl1i1kandi. non ~x: ~arce rej figni~e~tz. prove ~ re cll:, & rC:.llndum: Hi qllo~'ide~tlc7' & entitariui: d1:. E.r h ce[ ex n1odo liglllficanoilis GgliUic!:nt modum (lIbfranti::t'.non figniflcantrngdUin (llpl;t..dditU1n ~ & dil1:inChJm, led idrndlic:atum> & diuinl,lIn,qui ip(a fublbntia cll,/icut ,111n flgni6.camus aliquam ... imnem in Dco, vt iultitii. lIIifecicordiam, &:c.nol1 rabllol.nti~m lignificarnus. {cd proptit:tatcm, & v1rtut~m, q~ tamen in rc,& idcnrke (ubll:antia,& ea'~nria ipCa cnlcd ex modo rtgni ficandi lignifiC3mr Vf aliquid cOllfc~mLlm ad cllcntiam.&: {upponens ilbm:ue rd~tio. & pern {~Ila li~lli6c3tl1r !n Deo,> no? v~ ptQprit:t:1.S f~u vlrrus,led ve rermmus ilxlJtcnuz ~ Id cnlm til Cub/ill:c/1t1a.E.r quia tennimlJ QPud nos haber ratir;mcm modi rclP~au rublbntiz. idcu-tranilaU,io DttJm, neUe habet tatiOl'lem termini. ita intdligitllr.& 6- gnilU:atur 1 nobis (ecundUm r~tionem modi~ licec rnodaUter non diffcrii.r.

14 Ad leeam primum Allgulr. IX 7.aeTrinit.c.r.

re(pond« O.Thom, in hlle 'l14.M,.2..lIrl1. vbi p~o argumento aft"eu alum locum, &. expli(u iUum, quod quando Augult. dicit, quOd omnis res quz: rdatiuc dieimr. ell: eriam aliquid elr:cepro ICiatiIJO. intelligitur iu:na diltributionem accommodam , id ell:. non eadem modo in Ic:bus crClris,& in Deo: !tam in rebus Gtea.tis inucnirur pra:Ecf rebtioncm aliquid abrolutum eanquam rclitionis fubic8:uln. quod eli: alia res a. relatione. In Deo allt~m inucnitur cri~rn .tliquidab(olIlNm, fed lion tanqaarn alia res i rdat(oIlc,qllia res iII.a.quar eil: DC:l1s. zquiualet ab(oluro , & rdatiuo 6mul. Eit :lUtem a1iquid cxapto relatino (ec:llndi\rn vinwlcm dillindionem,Be Cecundlim tonliderationern nollr;&in , non (<<und~m atlualel1l diruntlionc:m in reo Ad Ie~undum locum Augufr, rerponQet 5.Thom.,1i.8. k P611/flW 4rt.1.44 14. vbi locum illlli1l Autt, explic:at.quud quando Augu{l:. dicit non eo dlc PaD ~m quo Dea'!l' iotdUgit)lOp tOlnOIl quo:ad r~J.~ litttetn , Be cntuatem. li:d q~ad m odul1I tignl fi~ undi •. quia relado non fignilicoltut 'It id quo ali.quid eft in (t, fed y[ id quo ad aJiquid tft, deit3s :lllmn 6gnifiatm 'l't id. quo in (e cll. Be. quo COnIl:ituiwdn (e , quia tignfficatur 'It Cubtlantb jpCa qm Deus til. ltaqllC: CI p;utc: sci 6gni6cat~. eo 4J.1l0 dl Pata. ell Deus; fed CJ; modo {ignifinlJdi. non,qui:t P:uemicate lignilic;m~r '1t:td alr~tll fc lu~l • ddtaIe vt ad re.&. me modllS lignific;andi

itl\ ptQprlllS fublbpti2. -

l.,. CitC.1. diltinaionrpl ScQti,quam ip(e: voeat formalem • frta ~ natura te:i ;lDte pegoti>lrionern inttUtt\us.DUIandtu dtlU.Loc. JjJlin8.J ;,qu.l.llUm. d. rd«euslunc Scoti fentetltt;lm. dixit fc ilbm. fOl'l1MliUlmt d~th!= C1 n;U,lta rei non imdli. gert_nili i~ eo q_I,lOQ dit.wlt lion elfe idem fa(11\:l-

. ~iter,(ed ddr~ fO[m~ltet ~ natura (ci.irll;lucbnt illud quod qwdam dicUllt quOd nOd lUlu idem .quuc. ~ i-l C(uod alij diGunt. fCilquod diffe.. tUnt. ticur res, &_ modus .. ~~e :diqUi I'i:: inu:\h:". : ~nu1lt SCO~1Il ln ~ ~iili.nttione formaU. quafi 'lpfe vomt aliqn.un dillintlinmm CSE{¢IlIorum 1

P~'fci.k ~le ~pe.rar arionem rarioni!. ~.t ndi poIlU: ~ Q~ 'fidctut n.u~ lUi'll poJl¢.lIifiqb ~

De Re14tionJ6m diuin it.

JlinQio fi~ realis, iii ell a ~2i:te rei, vel fieue d ua: ref. "c:IIiCLIt te,.& modus I Be rune eodern modo illlpugnamt' Geut fcneenri; Gilbc:ni, & Durandi.vtpore. omnico tcpugnans li:npli~itatl ~iuinl!:, &: a£tul pure, 'lUll! funt fundamenta ell qufbus ornne genus c1inin!tioni$ snrecedenris opc:ratiolll:!rtl ii1-

rcUed:us rdedmLl'J,prt,ctd.tIJml1 Ji!p.J, •• f'I.6. 5i aU~ , tent SCOtL'I~ di!l:ill~'liollem omnem A pane rel, feu realem dcnegat Deo • vt d.:ncg;ue viiletut) Vt.i~j diximlls,& l1:adm :1lfCrL1I'IUs; &. ... keriu, non Cola dillilltlionc rationi~ eoneenrus fuir; (cd introducerc volUit dHtina:ionclfi qua~dam mediam inter djflind:ion~m realcm , & rltionh, 'It aliqui ei :lecnmulanr !:oIJuid.i c:t c:lus didis, Quia nee rcalem. nee modalem '1Qluit dfe iil:~m di!linCliunel1l.lJltc ~[i~m (olhu ~:ltionis~ Ced ante opmtionem inrellcd:uSiplallc l1lonClrum in Metapbylica. Be Thcolegi" imroduccret. N.lm omnis dillindio, JiCIIt.~ vnim.s feqllifUf cntimcm, (cd nulla ~ntir.u fingi pOtt;1l media inter eos r!:lk,&' ratielJu: ergo IJt;C diltintlio.

OJ!arc ego Ctmper ellOHlimaui Centemlam Sc:oti " nOli ram c:xpliclfi dcbcrc pc, dill:ina:iom:iU.ccu itpawioncm extremorum liue n:;llem fiue modaIcm,quRm per nOD inclnlioncm,fcu noll id.cllrili4 ' catloncm formaliJ (adonis vnius in formali utio-

nc :I!ttri~s. ~IJC ea quod. 'I'~Il.m non lit deconce:_

plU altCfluS • Ita quOd llcch dicl pollit quOd hoc cit hoc, v .g. (ilpicntia.ell: iuaici;l, vel eft ipfa dciras am:

e eomr~ .. W~len non p.orcn ?ici.quod. includitnr 1 p:lrtC tel rano fQ~mahl vnlU$ m ranene formali

a IrerillS , ira quM c~ eadem ratione fotm3li intlll'": datur ex n:uura fua in ~onccptll fotrn::lli. (eu ratio-

ne formolli alterills. Et lie 'realitel: idcntificmtut

ilb eiltcem:l.. Ceil. relaeie • & eB"tntia, fed non fub omni fotm:ditatc ideotincantur, neque vnum includir aIiud.& fub ilia formalitate. qU:lllon incIu. dunrur.dHnnguij(l1r,& cum C~ natura rei. & ratio~

ne (Ili non ilJclu~ntllr.dillingu~ur edam 2. par-

re rei, (ell ex nauna rei. Q..uod dl pone:re dillin ... lI:iuncm a parte rei. (ell ex natm;l. rcl.non fllnda.

lam in opparltion.!: :lliql!!, vr !lOS ponimus , fed iii

non indufionl: huius in alio ell: pane alicnius (11- tionis formalis. Cub qlla ilb indulio Room.licet

liat identirg (ub lilia. Ita oftcndi ex ip(o SCOtO,&:

ex Arrerjllo ",tUtti. ff7rJIJ J.i{P+"rt.~. Et lie Scad {c:ntentia .. 'l't dillillguit ur a. (entellria Durandi.", Gilbeni, magis penincE ad fpbdlit.1tem quandam~ quam ad vcram ~ill:inClioDem fubilicncbm. Nam ScotUS in UJ.uJi/I.2.''1If",§, Sed hicrtjl.-,. il1 1.[ tIt-

IIl1t. dininltioncmtc:;:.lc:m) l$c modalemindiufui, reiecir , idque euam fie jnEcllcltit Dllr.mduHefc~

ralS tiul fentcmiam 'fIbi {"PA, lie (alum pofui( di. f1indione~ iIlam formal em ex natllf3 rei.quam tandem ~ot:eE cae vil;tUalc:m J & polTe vocari ~~ tionis. Et fie SC:OEUS ) P'~Cs! fumptll5~non vidc:tuc diffi:rre a communi fcnt@:1D.ThlJm. Jid;c in Plc;uio loqucndi valde dilf'crat. 8{ pet difi.inai~

m:m ex natlU'3 rei I Ccu .ante opu.uionclll intdlc-.

ltus intcUl::r;ir foll'un ouo. Primum quod :iliqua.;

non arnoi form:ditne idem:Hicc:ntur. lic:~t in (c 'I'.\lln fmt in entitate. & teilitac:e. Sccundu!Up 'tuad duo cODtr;ldidona in re ilia vcti6ccntut an~

tC, oPCtilrioDc:m intclleau" vt quOll elf entia lie communicabilis,rc:lado non.Hze c:nim dllo viden-

tUt aliquam dillintliollem. reu allq!l3in non vni~ mcm aliqllO mQdo poneee. liquidcm Ii odiqIU e:E4

. Uern:l. fub :1liqua formaliu.tc non funt'l'DUIll. ac idem. fub ilhi formlilitue [dbnr diuctfa. [eu non vhu!;il,liech in l'e vnum tint : hoc ell «go form alit« diuerlificari. £t 11 de aliquo dicitur quod 0.011 C:Qnmlllni.canu; in 'e, ~ Cub alia. founal.iwc 'om-

IIlUD1I;;Eur

miJnicWlf' In'rc.iItl 0pp'oucio,[tu aAirmaria;& negano aJiquam. vide:nJ~ dillCrfic:ltem mdueeee,

'17 C,zt.n~~ d~rora h:l.c ~c~t~ diA:ifit;t'ione. Ceil non Idenultcanone: formal! d'lI:tltlus fat" (uphql!~ tllmo pr~ml:dili ..... tS.,.'.6'''ltd'J'& plu:iJ edam con(fa dlJl:mthonem modalem Durandl , & realem Gilbml jbidem videri polli.znt ~ nee enim aliud in pr:.: [emi addendum eeeurrie pte impugnandis [fils dHbntkionibus.Solllln aduerre • omnia qua: ibi eliaa fum de amiburis inter fe. Be cum clfmria j hie elf'e dicc:ndum de rdafion;bu!. (ro peffoni~ • quia Lee, perron:!: inEa (e dillingu.antur. quia oppo~ nuntur , unum in rei' pt!r(onaJ. & elfcntiam nulla daeur c'lppotitio, QUi4 nOD [0= h.tbem correlafiue. {cd Jicur rcbrio crcatatalirtr cit te:(pedus :ld :l1~ rerum • quod edam ell accidtM ili~niiu. & hoc quod ell: eae acddem. fCIl ;pfa rario Iff, lion opponitur rarioni Ad. (cd inuin{t:d imbibitur in illa: ira in dillinis idalio Ql1lZ rtfpicit :drcrum Vf rcrminum. non opponitur ipu r.tdon i Itt. qu:z ell (ublbnti.a dium.1. af_que: ipfamc:t re:llit~$ rc!:'tioni;. 5i ti:go Il1tt( elfcnriam. '" rehtiollem nulla ell oppoJiuo. (ed filmm;!' idtnci6cariD aauali.. & in (I;. idem cenl~ndum ell de dillinitione inrer lI.nrlbma. & e!Tenti"m.:tt· que infa telatiotics • IX: elfrntiam', Q.!li.l ergo culelJi diuina (lIblbntiot. abfollllUln genua comiaee, &: relatiaum , ;uqlll; vtrilJfque gent mIlRIIS. Be oflidum , ilia conliadidio. qU:2 fOtllJatllr di-

,cendQ quOd dTeQria ell communic.wiliJ j non pCffon:! ~ (olum tequirif, & rllffidr.ad iTIam diuerJ'it;1S mllnmJ, &: officii. Ron enrit;ltllrn , red eadem fimplidffim:t enaw ob (Ili cmiiu:ntiam habet vleem pllirium ferum; & hc habet capadt2tcm verinllandi ilbm 'Clnrraditi::ionem r durnr modo in fcnfn farnuli ~ l5& (ub ~ppellnionc: fur~ mali ponamur. non vere fi terminis idemi!)i, tigniliccruf. vtl:ue ullendimuHir.tf ,/lIC'''. Be de fe nunifelle pau{ • qUia 6. farmo conttadidoria in bh terminu t Res qua: dl diuina dfcntia. res qua: dl patCfl1IW. verincatur quod res 'qtl3;: ell: patcrni{.l$. commnniearur , licet p~emit.U non comIiJlmim:nr, & verilicatur quad res q\l% cit ef{enda non cDmmunicatur. !ide palCfOirag eommunlccmr, Er til; lignum ell:. quOd ilia contracJiClio,(eu affi~rio.~ negatio.li:jl.p~teInitas non wrnmunica~ur. elTclltia communic:aim ~ non perir diuerlimem feu difiindionan ex namra (I:j in ipus extrnnis de qUibu, didmr. (cil. in patl:fllita~ teo&: t:'ifcmia,fcd in officio.& Jllili1cte fc=u focmalitaribm. quz in eadem emirn:milJilD<l cnEiml; di- 4intlioncm non habent. fed plurium zquinafro. Dam, ~nia folfun in {onnali {mlil horumrerminow fIlM tir iJb afJirm~tio • & D~g~iio. non in fl;llrli idmticoJfll:llin rermini! facielmbu~ (m(um idcnricwn,Necobftat' quod commllnicari.& Dtln comnmnicari dicunt ilite~ {e difundionan. f~(em ncg,nilUID in rc:. quiaoppontlnruf COtltt~tlorie:crgo ilia duo conrrOldi.:lQrla commdniC-'1!" illi fa qu:z eli Ocu!.facier aliquam dillin4iollmi"falrem negariuam in [I: in ipro Dco quarc:nos dfmd~ • & quatenllsprnQll;l.Ncgamu!canltqutDnam;.yrne-. ga~~U! in Logi~:J ,.;,~.6,.J l,m fnf.~d opp~ jino til", furu:br dllhndionc:m m:gJnuam ulrcttipf.1 ClI:'treill.i oppofidonl! • (cit communicari • &: nOll commllmcari; hzc ellim in re POn (Urit idem; non iammin ipro fuhietlo cui cOrillrniunr.quia non eLl cll"ed:lls fornulis illil15 cOQtnditiionis wldere 1llhie4uIU diullum in entiure flU (lice! inter f~ ll~ ]a COnttadUlio diuifa c:xuem.1 dic.u) G infinirulri i'it.& eminens ad vtn1mqlic: munUS c:ommuniandi.~ nop communlcandl • fed !olum Ii liQljrlltUI11

J'II71';' ~.ThQ'pf.i~ A 'f"rt.D. Th. TCUlUS ahu.

Dif}tltatio X III . Artie. 1. " 8;

lir.'it di;:;imn, pr~;tJ;t(l'IjJ'bJijp.'4,iwti~.G. Ad fui:fd~ , ducendum aueem dHhntliancm ,a<tll in ipf:i (0 ante operation em iim:llcCl:us t non (ufficit;'lffirrn:l~ 'tio.& ilcg,ltiO in a[iquo lenCIi. j Be rormalitatc:; \pd appdbtione. fed affirmatio, &: ne~ado in ipla i:e~ eriam Jdemkcj Ik .. bjolutc fignilicara. quia alii{-" matio,& negaEio rub oiliqua formalil~te. ttU fn ~tr.:. 'quo {eneu t.1.nnirn, & non in ip(.1. re.etla!b in (I:D(Li idennco tignitkua, porr:l1vc;rilkui. maIicbE~ c:i~ dem vnitar'tei j & nullo modo diui(a;qulli FOEiuSi crnnino vna propter (!lam Iummarn cmjflen,tia:m~ qll:g '"dirt in~.a.", 'indl iJJ(azquilialet pluribu$, Eudd",qiiod Ii I\oc fLinad!IlcmtUm quo SCOtUS t t mou~clir; &; in quo ali'llii vim fa,iunt ;'id inrrodd:. CCnd,lJ1t dHtinttiOi1c:m atiualcmj aliquid prob.l.r, prob;tt (eilCi:nd,lIi'i GiI!icffi ab E~defi:i dtmnar;(cn~ Nc!: cniln ip(e ~liud fund~mcn~um "b:!buir,quain. qi,od de eadem re non po.ell id~m .dHrmui ; & negari, 'lLlod C'ciam cueru IOlj,ucndo 'de ~dt:m f'C em/urlue: .. & (eculldtlm fe:n~rn du" con,ra'd~d6-

ria de e;tdem re cmimiLle, & ! par'r't: rei nQn vcdfi~;tmtlr, ;tar Ii verHk5mr d~ eadem tc p~tlptcr iliutr(arn fOID1;'1limem, &: dltJcEf~m tonfidC:f~'idnero, qu:t:' de eadem tl! h;l.bcri porc:ft.licirrc~ ilfa

in (c vna fir. fmarl ex hoc fundamcnrQ- allrtdi Seoms dill:in8.iofif'iit ;lctllalcm n,naturoHti • 11~ quidcm lI:ante ind,ltin,hollc. &: vnit.nc fine "nil. oppolitione , & diuificmc in re.po~cll !:ldtin lim .. plidffima entit:ls propter luam eminenriam pail "Sitmationcrn, &. n~gatiOl'ltm d~ todtm fi:cundum diucr(;im formalimuu, vel tj}n6d,'t';ltiontn:l~ q~atcnUJ il~.1 eluirat It'qu~llollet phitibu;, ~ g~~ vicem pll,.1rium line dlu,It,.nc In f'hnil; & Ik iii {cnlu fonnali tll.pliczn!C'illa diuc:'d,l. nHlI"tJ:J. 'k non diuerfam cntitatcm 5, .fJiirnniQ • & IKpi6;

ad quam (ullicit ilia plur;alirou emincndahl > feU vinualis. quz nibil liliud eft qulm fUfld",meru: um quod c:tf in aJiquOi entitace.vt per inrt:lkthml po(-

lit urio diRillgucrc; & fi~ affixmate,&' ncg.:m: dt.tledaiflOo autcm iZallOlJis dillint1ioJqbz ada ~i.u..

dOlt anee opera!ionem inrdlctlu5,

FundamCta aurem hl1iuf Sc,uic.z diiUntli!)nH; omnia :JdtliiCla, &. lo!lualunt C'iIA/~ liU~ pr,"~JJII'",i agelldo de di!'iinetionc: ;lm,ibutomsn J;jf+

111'1.6. '

~od miner ad dHlmClioJ:u:m iafionis, qUilm I J

D. ThOIn. ponlc inter amibuEa,& clfrnriam,.6: lIittr c:ai:llfi-tm, & ptrfonu cam fnndnnenru in ris quz ~Jl dllHndio rationi!! tatloCl.tlat%. eain drill;' d.ifp.+ faU5 clplic3Uimut. & i)!ieodilnus qU;iinnlifi adeluo.

PtimllrP quOd noli dl fota diRipllio i~iii;!Dif fafi(llin~niil,qu~ ell lint' fll"damento in H~:,&: (6- h'lm (I: fCnet u rane modi ligni6caudi c~ndcm Rm.ucutnomin.lfynonymOl.vc vdli~.& hidurncn~ rllm non dit1inglluilE wn ali«i"~. hcquc ci:m:~' dil1t:tfa ~dllot in I:'cihceptJbU$~ Lltd (onccpruin d~

'Cad~ m fL" multip!ieant.. ,

S('CundlllD eft ciolfi dHHnfiionem nltionHc rido.. dll:!t.i,fltil fund.iu:a: in ipfO' obit:ll:o.& Ilolha ltmiprione inrd1igc:ndi.qllllrenlls hnt!. (tnmrnria DOO poteft ';l1j,o ,on'~t~ ~oll:~ lirnitarionil. atringi', 6(; 6e conCeptus diurdltut JUxra dlutrl2t fOi1U2U.

r:uu .. .fro ra.~.'one~ 6;plk~EaJ ion ~Ilfs c.Cliu:cpr.ibll~ Ikd In f(:, fmE vnum ~mJntnCJlIllta &:cmpttdC'ni Dimies ilI:u rationeS. q'll:t' a nobiS nQn nit; Cllm «time, Be connotadonc old ruionis £twa. & U;;. miraru aplicari pOiflln[T HZc dllo bt~ ibf pro:.. bar.or. (UUt d'AIII iliff., ",.pr«~JmIiIlofhi~&. odli. c:uhne~ in ~pofu:um foh:nz.ncc e~,a.li~l1id linda ampliol adela,m.

L

...!!c.

fl!!.41. XXI' III.

9° II/iii Jiflinlfj(J 'DirtulIl# .. ttmkrniJ ;p-

, .

lO Nihilomiwu$ it;l. plurium menresl'lIp~git mud

fllnd.lIner;tum Gilberti PorJUani,Du1'aJld.,tII: SeQ. t:i,qitod DOli pOtcll: de ~adi ~e omni!lo vria verj.lk~w

ri affirmatio.& ncg~d() ciulacnJ t'~'~ [~~ contradidie, yt quod clli:llria Ut ,om,nnn~cab'lts,& pat;rnita! jncollunLillic;lbiJi~.i pme1;el. &: {(:'~I1.dl.lm 'luod l Dc;C1.&lne3Ii~ viderJlr h?c: my~e~lU l~ (c~

vr (C=ll1per inultint in ponend.a ahqua ~I(bnchonc !lUU: opcr.1fiancm illfcUc:Ct~ • qu~m GI~bcrtlls • &:

GU;:Iht:fUS {ineambag,bi.l5 d.x.erum reale,&: ab ~C" c:ldiz delin/tiene opprelli fum; alii modafem • 1<:& Jlonrc;lli!. 'It Durandus.qui eadem feril darnnation~ rellcrtlr;alij ad euif~lldic:al(1I1i~m,~c, rl;2le, nee:

Jl\o,bkm.(c:d forma[i:"bl,ure po(ue£iit,vt S((l1115. 'lui in re ROD aliud qnlm nOn idcmitatE yohu£ poDele,&: de falto vinualc ditlmdioflem 3ppcU.uir. Vt YldinlllS. Alij taRde huill! rcmpori$ Amhotcs

. (IcgJnu::~ cti.1n1 form.1l~ dHlintliQtlcm in atttibutis \1ntC opc:r .. rioncm ill!I':U.:du5. Jilb:lomlllu$ .lliqua aliam Jil1indiol1cln ante opu'! intdkCitls dati In diuini$ a.urm.u-unt.Scd qu.,m ;tliam?Si ~c£ba aui· d~siphlribQS nominibuf OPUIC:l1r:'i. nobis dillJn4ioncm pl.'pcrefum:Ji tcm,ti:n5linlque aperiiu.f'lilnili vel SC[ju.:um.vl;'i PorrCt.I!l1cum ijlLlc:nic!. Voc;mt bane JIIHntbon.cm iniriatiu;lm. :Iptirlldmalc.fur.daliltllI.tlcm,rr;d communius 1rm-u.Uc.quo nomine nugis inuidiam dcclincllr.~m fCMauiS late defendie J£gidius a pr~(ont;ttioJ1c Itb. f. J~ /ftlltitrlJmtq.f·.",.6. §. 1. & ,. multotqlle pro dlan:f.:n. E.am obllii$ manibus quali de c.clo· !apraID fama venctadQne cxe:cpir E:.nci! diff.:,· c. J. 1If',", ~8. & Pij}.l1..c-.I.n"tfJ'4·&.J.[P·fo.C.1..a num, lJ. qllf.ld ,hane dHlfulliotl,m inul;lltum diuinl.lln :appcllct ad c:tpli~nJ,u infupcrabilc5 dini~ulratcs. qu~ in n'latui.l de T rinit2tC OeClllTUt1t. Et alii R!:ccndo,. res idlml Ccqlluntur. V ccanr bane diQindiQncnt inchQwua1n~& fUruUmcnu1em > quia t;ldix 1;'11. di~ tlind:ionil; ac!lu:alis • quz pet inrclledurn cQncipi'Uf_ Q._UUc: ntionl: viuualcm ctiun • appellant feu emlnennalem tca.lem ~ fcd ramen quoad milnus. ac officium. idem ptJ2lbM d')cclU arquc: diffintlioncm aaualem • quia r.3.tionc tiu:i pOll:1l dl'e vnUm vbi non!!1l a1iud. perindc: a' Ii utrc.Ill;' d1i:m; fedit~r diltina~. Et cOItobonntUr argu~ mente • quia non (olum in rc communir;.ttur cc. (ell~& Don P.ltCl;nir~ • rcd eri.am Dl;us vidc:t in fc fnam clfcnu~m communicari. & p.ucrnitatdn non cOl:lununi~.&: non difHnguir per r~tiorl(:m. plt~uir:uem ab e.lfe~tia. qui.J. non f~t~at. Deus !.tftma'!on~ f:moms ~ «go .lute dillmll::loncm utionis in c:.dem indilli6bili mtitate vctilkanlUf 'duo cannwtlorU;& Ik debet d3r1 aliq Ila dUl:inaio aJ1{e[:c:dells opcf;ltlOnltJD r:ationis in ipfa'miWe diuin;t • q\li;l eti:am viC!. in k: immr;di;J.te;; illas.

• CQntudi«(Irias fundar.

~ l C;Ue[Uw. ilb [Cflttlltia Ii nomine di4infHonis

vittuali$.&atw: optntionc:m intcllcdo$ non :illud i~cm'~CJ.q~ q~~ in.r~t~ria ~homilt~ nonus neh ~~ ~alQnlS mtdllgi Cotet ) &;: III

I: 0.. ~ uotnmc dUUn&iQl'lis Ulfet"cdenriS op~lone .m:'"d~au_s ~ nihil noui aam, Si "tic)' Ilid. alilld lI~dbgu~ilut nlhl! dicit, aUt in iltu I'cCidit ftntcntw.HalI!: ergo dllbndiollcm vift\t.l.la cgte.. &~ i~pugnat P .Alaru11Hi'.a.l.at T riml, difp.i. r·7.CI' lol'-lg$ brcuitet duo ditimlH.

,ntDUJn.:ipud andqlUm ftlltCntu,1b I). TbQ.mll!l &_ 'r~mi~.iIn"" & Scod inumirl ma.Ei(l~ ~dillina,ouit.Nam cUm (!tnru: ici 1\1.101\ di. 9'-~ ak, die"" qcdfari4 FC( Vtliinml.

De Relationiblfl' J,;,eil1i1;

ad i<1 qu~d a&."alitef -cfrtalc i pO.tta viL'tIl:f1is di': ftind:io d,ci. \'d te(peClIl'aCiuatis qU~ll\ fa "lillua . potd1- rccipfre~ at habere in (~. Y.:1 rclf'~ctll-actlla. lis quam pon~ft f.tl:ere-:renrentl:l. T~otolll:arum fa .. tctllr rirru;l.lcm diltinCl:ionem ill ,1nributis Dd ref.. pettit aflualis, ql.iiIC pbteft lieri ~r r~ti()ncltn IS( tic non crt. aliud quam ipCuro. {uodam_l;ntum. quod fe renee ell: plttHci • Vt cum diftill~jone t:onc'?i.1tur.Et licc fund:1rnentL\~ rcmaDCE II"!. k antc o{,crOlEjgllettl. intdlcd:u, omtuno vnum • .::It jndillilum fine aJiqua d,(lintliolle in adLl ; " fie Ii !:ontt~diCl:ori~ vcrilicantur de iHo, vrique 'Veri6c~ntu{ dc :lliquo quod all(e op~r::Jrjoncm intclb1us ~11: omnino vnum j 6: ioh'un b;lba ~I ur~lit!l{(:ln com patadonc ;.d I:ODCeptuS naftro. diftinguenrc5 , quod ell: pullam dutmt"boTlcm dar, ;mtc opl:£ation~m il1tcllcQu$ Old vuilil:anda illa coniradi«odil, fcd de eodem (ecllndilm di .. uell":lin fonl1a)jr~t,=m f.ltione dillinguibilem, &: ~llrf! r'per~tionern imdlcdu5 form;ilitC'f • &,:;,ttl.lalieer vnum,c;ontradiaoria veri&c;lri.Hl2c didt (enrcnria T homilhnlln de vittll.1li dminaione , 'lil:olil (ane yirtualis eft per o{(lin~m ad atll!aiem, qll;!; portll ill iplil. re !'1m ab imclletlu. 5i vero viuaa .. lem diftinctionem fumu bz;: nol4 fememi:l,IlOI'l p~r ordincm ad adualcm • qua: n;uop;:r fOllionmJ) ted III ordinc:ld;l.dU.1lc:m quamip(;.pol!it fac:erC ill ipfi5 rebus ami: ope::radonem intdlctll.l$ iiXidi& ill opiniom:s Scot,,'1d Our.tndi.aut Gilbi:!tti, n~

porcH rc ab illi~ cJ.pcdire:JV[~ didmils. •

Sr;clInd.tin ergQ quod addimw tft.iftam rcnten~ sa. tiam.c\un conerur Induccre per bane nouidiliindione virfl.l.tlE a1iquid>quod aDu;o.pcmi.oneiniclleaus opcrt'tur verificationl5 dupJlds contnditlQ;o tiz, cum (uffi~i'mi dillintliolJc. "" yuJr fug':fC f~ ttrtti~m SCOt!, Durandi, & Gilbl:fli d.;: dillinCl:io-

n~ ~auali g, pa~~ rei.&. ~li: al~a p.me :unpJiU5 vult dlc:t'te>E}uihn ditlla'lll;lnc: t;It!QUU cum fundamt-

to in rr.=.qJ.l.3: ell: vimulis dilliDtlio Thomill:atulU .. plane il\l!xplic:abile fe reddere, Be t;1dE aut nibilll~

n \'0'(:$ d!c;it~ aut in vnum ex: i11is au!;;mi" qn~ vult euitarc,rcdkef~. Narn ai!1l mquirimll5 ~ quicl

ell virtualis dillindio in Dec 3fltC opaariontJllo imc-lIcfi:uslDkllnt.non elfc aliud,qulni DculD f~ cUl1durn fc.& ante opcmionem inreUeaus zquj .. ualere pluribus • &; ditl:intUs. ita quod ilLl vir .. tuatis dilljnaio fit quodcbm perinde yal«l;'pluriii~

IX ip(Utll Dl;ii. plurium ac ddlinlCorii getcrc mil~ nus.Bcne.Hoc ipfumnon DI:gantThomifb:. }Je- .. que c:minl."ntia hz, djuma.quOd iimpticiffima cxi .. 1l~fi5 pitlribus)&: mlinitis pc(f.:il:iomblls ;tqlliLl~ leat ab ali~uo ntgari pOfelt. Sed ptCmimll$ vJrc-o rius;lo hal: c:mint'ntia rt'man~rnc ""i'3~~ indiui(i .. hilis ratio,fc:u ~ntiti!Sa!Uc:opcrilti"nenl in'cllcaus~ (uPe't quam cadnilla affiml.ltio. Be negltio ~ ;lIuli~. quid dl ad:u. diltinCl:LJma pure Jcijuper qilod, f~!.Oquam lilpcr Cllrrrnla 3Dft: QPUS inrcHetlu5 diflinch,cadit affimJ~tio.& m:g.uiglSi .i pure rei ~Jt l!liquid ad:u dillindlilD ran'luam c~rrcmaa.Iiqu1 dillindioDi! haberia 3nte opus intdlctlU$,fupit ~\la:. cad;1I ilia. afficmltio J & D!:g.u:iO• jam non ell: fob, dil1in4iQ vinualis, ftd alt~i$ antC opcralioJJcm. intellc.'lus.& il~ a4uali$ dillintlio vd.dc:bct £fro formali,~ficu, ell apud $toru,vd modaUJ~ Vt :lpud. Diltandwn, vel fe;lclis. vt ap"n GilbcnuhI, nec atilll modo.Q!!,Od G djclI.nr 1 pafte '.I:i nulla etl'e aal»o lcm d.illiuaioncm.nec aetll elle phua.fcc! virtlU"I lira plu~.& aau vnum : inllo fimper,quid .lir it .. Iud virftl.aliw: plura ) vhta hQ~ quod eft dre:: fiUl .. c1aftl~rulll diluoClioDis l"atioDif, Nibil coiln

irlllmi~l:IU' tn ilia plut2llrate y ~uali • quod ar1~ tc: Qpuati,Q;1Il hm:lleGlII$ ~X~ iltaoa CJ;l.titafgU

.~- """ ".,tJ!fPHlilliD 'nIL .\.' ,,-;A/iii-: f7.~V",':, ,( 91"

tnrita~ ~b Wilt* , milib,j1ifi1 :iliqllam dilli~;; doilin1u~,ibafi' ~jif.n_bii ct!mmun}cat( id. qID3l1 - Hi

dioneh1 in iClu ~ erga p~i:et id-' quod 'eft' 'Inilift' vrilca,& ('ad't!~~~ d,iuin~' (e'c-ub~ilm~ dil:lf'lfit

in reo' Sl funliamenrllm dHlfMllbnis [ationis~lJ.it.i conf1di:ra'tiiJij'e5';~i~jngi\ibil¢';1Iiideri! ad:u fecuij::.

l:oid'H!it in to-quod iIla eminentia Itquiua!er plli'~ dum nolh'o5con'c:~pmS'1i1\ re veru non \i.ttll,dillin::o

ribus " nilUl -amplius im.lc:nimr, qllad' illi:vOiie 4'oU-.lid ,olumfDIiw.j'n~MI'tidil~r .feu virlualikd'. ri

lflimMlil d;jliillfllditii Ggrtilketlir.' 5i ::nitl::m a p~~ quOd non comtminii:arF!'iiti" conllc!IHt ei ~b[ol'ut~

t'erei;'&; anre operkio,l!efn [~eUetllis ~dil ~hiU~ '&;'(~c::ufiduin totii¢J~~I1(Jdlaemic'l:C-dt: ill re ,Ctd

niwt ruG vnica. & irid}uilibiliS ratio i,liaaiJ~ 'faJ41i1fub-~u,:~fi"tfe' .'Videlicet Vf relad:U~ op~

ned ritirijliEur' ilia . vnitu "in ali~u2m: diftiuaiol n'intr! aliis enim:6 ;negaoo' lif' .profetilroi'.~il1;o nem :itlUa!el'l,,{l:d "'nl,mfldn~fiil fundaffiCnfo,ae quidcJl elfen,lia diu~]liliefOl'mll~ftctt6ne' id~w:

in radicc qllOllfqtlc vc.u:it c:Onet~US udanfj di~ tenOn cOmnfitnic2tar,fllllill'ri en: mU9'icfgd,vi;,

Hirig~lcn~ ;' ergo I~c tinte'riria" '~iDqlfjt, i~a<u ~et i~ 'quOd com~tin~~ur ab(oJUt~T~ ~nvlfr,o~J.

omneg dillicult.il.rcs hulus' biy'lh:rti, &' (ibm Vc;~ mum(,uutPt0vr te~_¢. "'an' men: ,wllMthG:.:>

rificationemailplki' torifritlidoUlt • nee mai,j'icm nem in t'~( ~ emincntf.un tS'"CYtiUts rd' 'lnl1fQ'd'ert;;

Iucem liffm~d'hoc'iOId,MdulfI, qli~ti\ ' 'dil\ina-iij- II! multas ilia; p,a;ci(1onC'g~ .. .ir, - .r:;, '",

~tluill;s' ,'&raiiotli. rlIricdnafiZ j 'quam p"nllnt ,., . ~- fl' , ,".

Thomillz; {i'lUidmt [ou difficulcu ;qu~ 'ntouit _ ..... ...;.:.-';;...0..-,....;.." ........ ......:-- ...... -;.;;;,:=~

Gilbertum;Onrandtim ,:&:kotum ad pOlJendUm A It j.f;,',',t",C_'_ ",,_"_i_V L ",-,. n ~'('kr,;'j'~l;". ,:

di/tinccioncm.ex nafUta~j ante :opecatirmem in.:. ,1 V:.:,~: '/ "it ; '_,'

tellcchu, ellquia In re lion polfQn£ dlla cond'adi" ' , ~n 1I.tlll_· 'i"';~/ft' 1_';;" de, &~&, _-n:t.~ : tll,'_ 't,.ir;;;;i~ ',i "

tloria verilian deb:dem re'omniilojndiuilibiJi.& "c, .. ' ilJt··_,

vna;& proprc:rQ cOnad . (ynE in"il!im'itate ylta ali-:- ffT e cQl1Im:fi~ , , "

quid di/f;inClionismdlll:Cl'ulftco,".njoncmilird~ " ,7 I;; ~~ • ,"

JeGhB~ vta1Jignarcntdt aliquaexErema :iaU :lnre 1" Nrciatldn'C! rt~h,duo induJuilflH:iiHl~i1plii:1 l'

ilJam op'mrion~;Cupc:r quit'c2Mcet ilb ;dlirlri:1- form.firate '3ut'0'biidcmionc ex-plicaltlur t &

tio,&' negalio;(c-d (glum quod ilb (enrentia ponit p-a oruincm ltd filbie-~um • qtlo'd· 'j:J;il;iftli' 111 fl;l~

mtc opc=r.il.ooncm ifitt'Uc¢lWl .:11 ratio omn~no \'0«. [iOfij~,eo qllod uladoii'" quor filfif a(tidentn , iiP-

&; ilia vinualitas dillihdionis non c:xuabir I tali bri:n~ I'llbitt'lb' ~tm6d-ldeafficfum:', ,V M~! bmncl

vnitatc. nee rc:duci[ ad dillintlioriem albJ ;lnt~ qUod tclatrooi tonllC:!i1t ex p;utddbie'lli~ Ilue(ul

opa:lriolJl:~ inu::~k8;D51~laih y irn~,iltitaF; C'rgo: jllbzrn.linc inq_uQ (ubtilhrj. VOt':Iillf 111 t~J.riohbi

catd~ p:ltUur dlfficuItate5 de vmlicauolit: cen- & fccund4.\ cDnuth:r:ittir.r"Ia:do:ttal'i5C Ftwdintm

u:uLllpri:ittlm fe(peelu vilius.&- dufdem. clmemr ad rcrminllm.1;k {ub'lul! .:onGdc:r:idone appeUatui

nOD pillrifi~'i :a.ilu. Dicere IlUCent quod iJlgd /I1J. Erin rtJafioi,-j~ul!tnlibll$ ,q'U2;i paue rei jJj.i.

vnum extremum in fe-,ell: virmalirct d1lo.non u:ru~ ~eniu~Ulr ~'tt!I.t~~fetil.nd~l~ vt~amquc f~fHl~J!f~ ,"

HOC"iion·eftaplicarc:C e llfumjlm mubipbciiln! Vfi- re rC.lill dl.&:rnhlafh'n dIm. no tolUib reb~fC!hri

ba ~"inquirimu:l cnim an ly 1!i'mulmt' JIi., pona" diuinz , qllll: reaUdimlil,' 6: {ubIbndales {lUll ' ~

in re dllo adu. an folt\m relmquiU 'InUrn lJa-u~: cti;iU:i ~rC:~{lI'.b quidem;P .511~lcz 1,b-.1.JtT7iri;.

"iuad ra!Rcn fei tatloncm parelleJft: mW6plur h1'tt,dOCtE di{pubti apII'd Thomifias;oin rebdolfl:i

noun liaau non rdinqiuc nili "dum. ~tlidohlbi diuin:t.linr fe~ltJ (ccundlim cOe .Ad, illqu:tilr~

1",1: vc:rificationidllarum cii~doria:mm.qu;t: no Al. DI)D tOb.im kcuft'dUm t-iIe "l"~qtUild' iiJ1dS l'Jl

iit ruG illVlW-'uncmo~OIJ in plutibus 1 pan:~ rei i- ea'c iubfi4ens. ~~ C.2ia.(inqu.i(}it1 h6~Ji, i''1.i8:

, ~afe llOs-ditlindiobcm virtualt:m ~ quz non: exiilimat kClIndumcOefia,ilt.\I rdaJibilt$! n6 tlf'e ell: aliud qolm dlilinfuo ~tioDis CUm fl.llidam~ aliqilid rale;& idE'auflbuitCliptcolb,"'J Ji} .4j~ w a parrc.1'eJ,adminimus , quz ell fentcotia Tho- Sed Caia-.no loql.lifllf de rc:lationibUi dilliM,liJI8

iDilW'um,rullindionem amem virriUkm IIlL'diant neq.ue de: rulJhUJ re!atio"iblH', 1«bMiltn ,.;I/'Jj

un« ddtiritlioneID ill:am rarionis, quz rarione Cui Y[ lale ,pid (t'lle ('-.,lab;! rillS Ibnr) fcd 9uilbtdil' {undamcnri vinltdis diciflU, U diruna-ioncrri' ell ex ratione Ad- • {ccuodnm le.Et'trten! Caier.«t '

:IItlualcm arne opus iluc:lleflm,fiue fonnalem!liue. Thomillarum in ba~ parte eIl:, quOd ,,('facio fd.I

realem • intdliglnllu .. nee Yldeo quid aplicn in lis fecundrun v'~umqu~ coneepwm ~'ftu fOlm~

his diflicultatiPiu DiG P"Ea vt'rb'}' litatem 171, & Ad ~ rc:alis Be vt(:1 e&-otten li8i1.(elf

" J Ad' funcbm~ntum inlinruuum oppontz {en~ illain fealjr.ucm htln e.p!icM in COJl(eptU JorJ, P"

tcotiz: dicimus Deum~&; ikaros "juDIJe; fUoi jnmi- ominem ad ,t&ml1lnllm ,lie« lhi iIt~'rtlint:ac -. 8t

tina Yi~~c: id ip(um quod 1 {'me rd dam in Deo~ h.1be2r:J'J;'~ in ordinc ~ r~r~lnum 101m» ~rJi~.

&: t:Q moG~ quo d;nur,non co modo'luo nos ciSd- ",uu:a.quld Iif.noD <Juid {if ,fie tdpc8tu rrruW:

p1mus.quilmpetfcCb t'cgnitionc: ducitllt. Vida aUtcm proprie pa-nnct adid qnbd ell, bon ad iii'

~Q- DcnsparetJlif:JtCIlJ vuc:Luiue Qppoli(;i fillo~ eorraq1toaelt. Vnde- prQv,dplic:x.Ad. fudmmet

(en (elaUonem ill~m fec::nudilln oooncm Aa.non erg:!: (mDinUlD,ilOII nplicll.r fe-alifatequain ~httf

comtnllDicaIifiiiO.dfcotLun ... ~O.& anributa • k licet ibi tasb babear.{~d J/liu$ Jr3Iit;ulscpp-o[monE.:

omnem perfed:ioot:'m ab(oldfam cQ!UiUilniCu:t; C,," ilia Eamtn oppo~fio per ,akhl • 8( vtta fQlbiam

lie vIla dillinctionc iDtt:'l' dknri:ull.. &. p~tcwiu-. eUKetllr. qu!:O rdalio. edam vr ad fCfininUIDi'

te'm,& rum dilbnruolJ~ inrcT pat~~em. It Ji- qui .. pa lwCqllod Ii[ ad rmninum rum <1miuk,n~c

lialioncm.Ncc c:t hoc: fonw,t di(lmtliollePl r:!tilJ- e,:l1it rnlir.!tcl!l;ntc t~r-rlL~t 3liquid quod tealita-.

nis inter clfcnri~m.& p.l[uniEaEc:m.q~ia mID tan- Ie ~auri non ~Ol1if.f.lC'C D. Thorn.- ilaic in- p~

git iIla plurihlls c:oncc:pt1bll$ • nere: adinlbr colum [Inti 41'1.l ,quOd '(clDm in przdicaIDtllto rdalj(t,o

qll;r in nobiS dillini!ta funr~(cd V't (ullt vnum in (e~ niJ inucnitur :1Hquid {t-cundum raliofJetD; vt

quia euam (a:undiim h3DC fcnrmnam quam im- SliIaICZ cir;tt pro fmt~(u Tbomill-.:u:n~lS~d ill1r1

flJgn1Jll1l$,dfifia.& patanifal in r~.& atiu Vllom lic (e b-abcn, '1.:rba. D. Tho. f~d folam dkir:S(11it7J

{unE. Vide. ergo DeLIS eJfc:nri;;aM (uaM ira cile infi- ift h~ ,k~ Ilk.min' " .. lii"ill i1JlIliIiJlmlir A/filM

ni(~& Cl1linent~m c:lJtiI;jteJn qund enrct[ op- [,ctJllallPl- 'tdrmPJI liIn1imJ i tT nlfJ [mindimJ

pourioocm,& refpc-anm (lib r-.molle relatiLli.& Vt l'Hn • 'I"~tl"WJ tllftings, in .liiI gfJIm'vs,~ &c.

patc:miras ell rdpf,;t'k11 fil~tiQni~ • & non c:xtrCt'c Vbilicct "idcaun S.Tho. Jr:Lufoncmcorura,Ponc-:

rc(pt:duiplin~ r:{J;:nrl:twt ab{ulut"e~ i IX. tic vld~t " aliis vncribos 11k k loq,lli de Fdiamciltd

Ifiln.;'S.T_.,g l.pilfl.D. Th. Tomusah". L ~ IC~.

·ro-_ .... ····..,_

, .

9 ~ 1i2!!.,,{tiP ~~rJIJ. ~"> rtl Re/tltl~q~.diuinil. .'

,datW,ms ,~fflrnefi' 1iPll;!)d~s~J?a;jlp~a~Jlin.ait 1, ~Pt:~to.il~ftll. fR~li Q~riu~,&ft .t'e;l~~~~~ nomine: p.ttt:~j!l.aroC/Jt,i , &, Coj~ffi~il;it:t/}~ hu '1~ ~c:c::nt~.;lku,t! f!l/#t1:1; I\O:~ ell: d; 'OJ;lC9ptlJr~l~rt.

Ji&iJl1/lII" 4Jl M,iq_~~j abl!:u~~"J, 1;.:~~i!lJl~ <JUil!' (:fi; lJI1'~vd ~ contra, n-e:cv.qJ~I1t~ do; .con~r~Il,1'1~1~0;

in pE:,qjcafJl¢QtQ. &. rol~m #ip(9, t;q ~ptll. rd~ 4.~',lt:l-docet p ·.v:oWJ~·~1t diff1..~! ~ '~'I1"~.cf·+qw:_~

tiQnis~oque:It$. qlla:_. (l.!iqq,~"d.R.J!1.W;!lilJ:l~ (CGUq! f~q~'~lIt.A4r,on Ir"a'f.,~e:l):~Jh.dift_.,1·F·lr~"&

, dU!ll,=[i; ·~I;.)ll~. ,&;.111 p,l'ZRl~mP.\t~JfaJjq?~nd~ If·~!t:lt':lU~ 6~"31J1l~..;J:~~~nll~,"G.IUJ\!fQ.c%aUoi'

noo,.fed cJr:napr!tqi~arl!~!1!J1[1tJ).,4(q;lIlldmn.ra~ Jl,hPIl,~t :~ntJ.lm l~IJlP~',~·,k t:?n'tpt~

~onl:mj!lH!,d fiOfl '9ntjngit' i!l: ,:,tl#s gene,ribus, ,~Il~ f9flI}ah relil~lopW~.(~d !~OJlC::s l'lqpetJ!=.d=.~

mi f01'IJ)Il!if con~ep,N" n~IJ.nifi in ~~ab przdlC::~~ ~P,~.~i."4~UZ., fr~ b;1~ feautda p:i~~; prz,!:~ V, a~ ..

mento in1Lenitut".:;· ~, . ,,£1;; ""'" ," ;;, Q!1C';ii1' :ilIIOH-!~a-!1f ~tli!l!liSU:ir~ lik.+4~ T "",1,0

" '.N~ Jc:(l,;Q~elre ad re,1l.ir~~I}J. j~li\ls. ~.eCpcd:l,lf '~i.Arrtlb~! difP.. ~~'~t"'i·:~Fn~. ~r1P.;J~jlFi4'

:.dJ,.1l1Illtiplicarc:: ipfmn //.I~}U, ~qP.od ;ll-llIJd fit I. ~ [@.1.!~ ahJ.P~Q .p~un!l',v~p parr.e~d,~~od CI{fe~

. top1mq.IlP .. ~,gcn~rale .o~~Jt;la.~ipDi>~,~1 ~Il d!u~ li1\f!r de cilllcer.tu.:,relatiqfIlUtl; Ib~. id~?" SU2J:~~~

ni> oll1l1i!r~tlOlla:,. qllille c;.I)l.p~~c:r ,~I1cnna. dlul,,: A_rrllb~.Gr.llna~I.C_al!~dcplis.DcUalmlnl!s,8? all'

na.,u[ omnes idenrifi.:;~n!U[ irt~IJCCPtil ~bl!JlutO:i guof gtllt, & (eq!l4~ Roui!' h1& 4ifi~!l;J~qHllfl. h

~Ii!ld velo fit tn iplius terpettll' • III eo quod Ad. ¢: ft9"flllj~~,: £05 "Ua~, &:itst .4.1pr:~n.1l_;; {Ii";.

&.jn.eo_iu,qllQ.difconLleoic~pponitu' vila tela- p,,;u •. i~;,.. '" ,; .. ," '. '.:': ~.-_; .,.

do alu:d.Hoc 11.0n, ~(t nccclllq t"n~ quit illud f n, 1" J~deo:ulji,~jc\ln~ tam !!Jf(ntiam ~ifc: de con':

q!!O t~qdj~1r r6JdpCuIn J1d~ell: traflfcendtll$ rea- CC~t!l relationum ~ qulro teladont:S Ae CpntilpCI1

hi~s • &: ~Jt ;;OIlCC:pcUS in quo conucnil!nc OJ1)ne5 cJ1cl1tj:l:. Pro, qua. (clUemia drat Suarez, ",#Ii /f4f'.

rclatl(Jhr'~'.i!:rg'Qnon ell- n~t'eiJ~qIfOd:multiplicc. 1!h1u~.Illo.dmli)s,.t;')l:lloJitote$·O:rliOl:n, £U!!Uda

tur in c~dt:nl relanone I CeJ vnuJl;) lir;qui~ ~Il~ fnr~ (:om.n}ul}i~ cll,1:ho!lliUanllih dQceturquc: Ii Caia.

m~dHpGHChtio,& iplum .A4'!ii,l;( per Itt CJ1{hti hi''1H.17.m.1..(;ir~1I ~;J &nnc:t qtl.2Jj",;,r;. i..da[,.

tU1IIqili" ~ittcntiz noll muldpl\camur in h:l.triO: ~.cir~~ 6 .• argrmJ'nfHm>Nau~ucte i_IJ."mtlrhl.18.

nlbusi"'~·f~~~iJ:e:u.t = ergo neq\~~ /it>lh:ec Inuhii- ~ftque, On1ilIUIJl aliorum qui lCnent n,on poRe vi~

pJi,entllt,p.li~;lt~S ,I quod,t~;i.llfl.magis. c~pliG.'lbi-: den i!1 DC9 c:fl'l:ndll~ .linc'pc:fConis, qUia pertinent

till: tlY~.,;,Uq~t}fi. ,. .1 v • [.";: c,,', . , . pct(onit ad f'if~,tui:un ~jDinitarii. Ferrar. farneR 1.

2. : jCI'lIlJ:CiSO (101l(.epuU. rcIMionis-,rttamqllc fot- (amt;A Gtrltil.('.,. 'poni' diftintlioncm intci' II lui-

malirateru IJ1.~ Ad,fe3Iill:r,indud.at.~ [ciaJio di.:" but.t. & rebrioll~ .. qupd ;ltttibuu. docc:t e-jfe de

uina, loco f II. quod ill nollris .rd,atiOt!ibU5.dl in;'! ~nCeptu,de'(ta~.i5. fi 1~«llldUtn fe t:Oncipiatur.qlilii

h~~hi\bC:llt el1iuliuinum1qbliftcn5 • & id&:nti~ p~!fcctioilem important) relmone$' amed\ non

lkatum ~.i.lm ip.fa .. elfend1"q!!i_~ c:aimtiz JiuiJ:'ia: fuot d~ f;Jlione dcirillls.li:tiam U fecundiun fe con.-

hue ipfo quod ~ll:JI~1I5 puru~. gibilporelll1llllltcr cipi:lILlr. quia pafe€liotttm in fllo cOJlc!:'pm lIOn

a4UCJ1jq~l;ln'lUaID. dillil1Ci:um He; ;z:dlac: cont£(J-i impoctant. .. ' '.

ucrfaa pta::fco5an,rel:!'fioilcs~folp", ftcundunr , lJri;J hlliust~mm r~folutione adumc;n.dWiJ,C&. -if

~pcop~!-un I n • 'l~i ell e6~rlJ$ c:atliill \'I filbli~. diL~rn c::llCnfiam duplil!her pone CODCipi.. V nD

AClltLfJ tunc. fcd Ct1amJceundumcortcCptlllil AJ~ modo cOllupcuquafi, u;n{c:endenralf,provtptz-

t}LI!J rcfpi~iunt tcnninum,lJon (oJIhn ttalin:ridc:n.. cite'dicit rarionern cmilim:ceati. '" ad;uJ ptU'i.qui

~ifi~tlu cum clIi:J;ltia, (t;'d ctum in fUl;> fonmli tr3I1r.::cnJ~nt.alil diciEur. nOD quia en comDJUllis

COI1'i:ptUs*, :i!, {~ti~n~. dfenw,Ji ingccdianlW'. '. Nii Deo, & creattllu.{cd {olum omnibus pafctl:iolli ..

tillation~ i~tinCo1ri realitet.& iJKtdilit« cUm C!f-. bllsdiuinis J ~. Qlnni rcidiuin~ bcUt- CP$ £"rc:Kum

(entia diuia~.co"lb:elt{lipi;i diCli5 Ulnrt,1Gil!m-", u.tllCcclldc,ntalite~ Ce babet ad ii:!bftmtiaDl.Ic'aeci-

tllln~&:Duf:mdliilJ. quia non diffingullUC\U' ~b iI". delis> & .lid omms pcrfl;tlionC1 ~qui. itt;

1i!~crg~ idtnti6tai1tu( cum ila. Vllde in ConcU. omhibll5 imbibituc·nqnJQJumnrlo coPs" vt tic;

~r.ull~tI. ~,t;.: D}lmna111141 didcu~ quod. 1'#10'.& fed rario ~tiJ cruri j G, .rano ~$ incteari iiltim~

~lifU. ct Spir;t~ S. fo711 ~itin. -t 6' 'IIf/1i fob.- itnbibitut in omni prrfetlionc J & atuiburoquod

p,ttltiA •. ,.Nl1l1c~o,:lr«iI\s pIo<:cdimus. & inquirimut diuillum eft. &: in.omni co quod. illtIa.DeIUil:dl:

~ l~G lcla,tiOtqu;Il; ~on dillinguitur i fed eft idem jiue fit Ilatma, uueannl111tllIn.liuc ptrf'0D:l. line

A:: Vmim cum ilia. lubflantia. dillina J ingredi:ltut op!:ratio~ Aliomodo Luminu diui~a ¢(feotill. pro

ctiam inc::onc:c:ptum forrtla1tm • LIe elfenti~c:m u- conccpnl fped6cI) , 6= p~oprio.proyt ugnificar ra.-

lls Cubjwui~ t &. mt(1lS ipfa (ubllantia diuilU irJ.o' tioncm .lluin:e Jlamr:c {ub eo t;;Qncepru, adinC:;I~

gredimu ~4'c:nlia1cm ~ k fOIlualc:m eonce-plUm. qua diftinguitur a conceptu.&" linea ;uUibutOlUiDj

ipfius t~lil~oni5: lie« hoe fe:~dum heili!» iute!. qU2 (c babcnt per modum propric:tatil ~ &: a con"

ligaUlf.qni.l ellimti,1 diuina re h4bet Vt quid ibUilt- eeptu ptt[OQarum. feu I"e1ationum I quz (¢ habtilt

fe:tum. ~ quafi COnlDlUn~ omnibu •• qu:£ in Dco vt tc:nnini (ublill:cnte~ ; & lie :l.mibllu;& penome

funt i (die: amibuds.fiuc rdatiollibus. GellI anbn:al ex Cua proprio tonc.ptu CupponUilt MUlUm in !i ..

~ de inq-infl:Co conteptu hOmiois,& WOlin {pe- nea • &; cQllcep[u n:ttUr:t. Et ba.n~ diftillClionem

cl~m. Ptimum vet"Qd.iOicilillS Ce h.-.be(,quod reo. ali; ~itct ponllnt.di~nre:1 quod aliud dl pc:tfomsj

¥D~C5 lin.t de CD!lcepm ip.Gns c:ffc:n.riz; CUDl po- & auributa ctre de c4'entia diuinif3,w/nl effc::ntiao

oUs 11blll pr.t(uP_PQpanr: (cctUldUrn tuum forma- liter :Jd eam pt"ffiner~ ~ aliud pafOJllU dre:. de con.

h:m COll~tllm.1iCw:: mrihu~.& proprieraresfuP'" CtplU diuinitatis. vciquc: de: cOllceptnptoptio.&

~OIlUnt. fut'fiaam.. &; ticut tctmiu'lS lilblill~ria: fpecifico ~ qUi eft conceptUS diuiniiatis ~t na~

~ppo!Ut . ~aU\Jficnt fpedes hQminis fuppo- tllR:. '

rut fmuumnu.lis. ,no .. tllollituii,llEC in clUJ £QI"~ .. Scc:undA clhdll~r'~lId!lm quOd aliter lranC-- - f.

1m pcm conccp(u~ I?af~' ccndc:nfalc: cfeOlrum imbibitur inume in onlnibll$

.. 3 ~op~~ tocdiul (Uot AUlhm:es. prz:Crniln ad quos uan(cclldlf. 3lif~ diuinul!) : w.inf'l:nd~n-

m ~l' m 3C p~ut:c.... talc: enim qeatllm ingrcditut c:on'tptus !onnalei

IIffi~dam yuun:qlle ~~g~t orr. (Cit n~c tlftnti;m fuo..u.m inmiorutn • non Vi pm:incmium :ad (lI~nt

, 1: .... l;Onc~ptu lorm~ t"" I:llmtiali (~Wi \t'm_ ~ .n,,; .D. ft'· . 'll

11~ bd i' , . '" tfc on. pc.(Ii~""oncmJ • .,.. t:oP ItIlOOPtm. 'Jill:! I I; COIII:e-.

~n: (J~ r:G~tdi ~ = m,one pttls. ~n(Ctndent.ali5 ~Il illl~logu$. ~ COml~1l1~S,

hJtun:l.k ~ . , . D '6w ,annbu_ nec: III iU~ f\a abJlra~ICll1e.&: ana.ioglaconfbtLlltllf

, lUU,quc 111 CQUEU"I&: "811m non [ICf an:dog~ , Utj ''i!nnc4intt "lJ~ ilps, ted infCloOO

. ri~J

ni1jn1f41iO,;.X Ill.

'J;'iora cODo=*iOl'lcm elfentialem biht:nr hdipfum.. Cammlm dinln;i. el1titis non ell ~erln(smdenral'is o;Id omlle; peric:i!ioilf!S diuirtas,tanquam quid analogum,&: ccmrnnne, Cc:dn enlius'olhnino fingu~ bri5,'&:; indiLltdu:.. (ell h:r:c. ,VJlde non ro~ft ad omaes !Uas pc[fceti(in~s tun(,e,nd~re,c:alqilc in (t imbibe',c'j niG quia, ad (Dam ctfendlllu'linglibrcm 'pcnincrr[ • & ei c;jfe'I'I'tililitet COIJI'u:niLlnt.alias t)oli apparer -ql1o«u;lIitt res i'ingubd. In ci! irnbrb"rnE uanCcenclenralirer. nill mum c:lf~mi~lifer. tel t'ti~ f~()pter :di9~in e1f~ntialc'rn connt;x'iOl'lem cu~ Wihu! perfctiionibu5. f!cm ref tran(ceDdcnuIJ$ vniuc:tfalis non imbibitut in inferioribus. til r. propre:t c'£icntimm cotmuionem • qu~tn rei iDferioiles h:lbcnt CU~ ilIo [nperiod.i~a q,~a~d.o ~anrcen. J.nr4l1: ell qlfJd (ingufale';n6n mlbibfmt 1ft his , in -quibl.ls rran[,endfr, nih ad muicem lit rc,lprm:;a "onncltio dl~rniali5 ~ qu:!.tcnu$ hOI; ullgulatt: pcrit cll (ua intrinreea. &; c:ili:nli2.li ratione omnes illas pcl!elHones. Et HoC ideo eft in Dee.quia cffcm:ia llU cft alius putw el fEw proprio.&: ctknti:iJi (00- "cpcu~vndc ex vi ralis conceptus nlill:.Jij haooporencialitau:lll. nee ad ali'llllim pafettionem, 8& ndttalit.;m:m-ell in paten. f ergo omncm 'pufe. aionc:m ex vi clfcndali5 conCepfU$ h3bn in ~a:LI~ J'iqliidcm DIlUa caret; &; (u: e(fenljlliir:cr (;'I;mne'iitUE cum omni eo qllod ubi potcft C'OlJllcnire ~ alioqUin fi elfcnti:difc:l' non eonne~e:rct!lt j 8.: ramen polfer iIli conucrilie • ex vi drclKiali, conceptus. ace:ra iIIo.& c((ec in pot~nffa ad ill nd • .sic ergo fi ~tluj pum conuenit ;;P;!iquod auribtlti1iJt • vel per{ona,fc:u tc::IOItio t & ex vi • & ratione ~'l," puri in {no clfentiali conceptu non connc:clirur elllu mh~ ?,gQ ex vi~e_nrialjs ~onceprlH. ell in ro.tent~;I'd iIli. &' caret .111$ • 6quidmt ex VI drc:ntl;uu cotll;l:pidS non habet <l:Clu i11.3.& tamell porell habere: V't

.Gbi identiliata,[cd non c::i: vi conneJ;ionl$. .

I; ,His fuppotici. duabll$ condlUiDoibus: tcfpon~ deo.

Prima ell ft diuinitas faa diuina e1fcntia [nm.i9 tilt in vi conctptuS' namrz.fenmdum qaod Iy 17 ... zP4 dicit (oiJce:ptum ipeci6cum ~ tIC propriulU condiftjndum 1 proprict;nibm. opm:tjonibu~.8c petfonali~eibw:,fic neque ;ttrnbuE:t,nc-que relariobes fUllede COhC'1'tn fOmWi natuc;l; diuin~ ncqllc e !:Onua[Q t'OQeepEUs 04:tIUZ eft; de fonn.ili concepN rclarlonum.Be :itttibutomm.

Sc:clloda condWio: Si dr~'tItia diuina fumatttt ill vi conceptus entU' increafi, vr 6" (ell aau~ puri. qui eft eOIlt'cptlls tranfccnd:nnlis ad omoe quod in ~~o cft. ~ ~acatllm elfe h"ba, lic IJ~~ lOhl.m diwlU eJlentl;! ell:: de: cOIJr;epni dfcnflab pufonwl!n; &. n:I:lI£ionum, atque aluibmomm. fed mam ;tttribut~& telationeJ lunt de carntiali r~iQnc t & cOlln,nione CU~ jp~ dentn dillin:lt aliter camen,& aJltctmam dlmna dl de COft"pill l'datioiiUI1i tmqlUM inErin(eCUm c"llltinuiuutn, fell ullquam endus.rebtiollCS allfdn (Ulude con«ptn • (CII de efi'c:nri3li nrmne dfcmiz di!limr. tanqll3m modi. (CII termini ipfiIU dI~ntj~ diuilJZ~ non Vt conllimciullm • nee quzlibcr rd.:uio ell ada:qu;lEe imrinfcca. & drcniiali~ ilitlil1;t' ellcmiz. fed inad3::qu2d;, tota autem colledio rcbdonutn

mqI13u~. '

Jt.' Pn ilhl dwi ~ondnliones com:ilialiIllt varia I loaD.Tbom~inbacpanc. quz vidmmrcontr.l7 ria, & apui[lu melll ci~ Ad quam pm~ranthm

prz ocu1is hahmdam til, diflinglli in DoChina D. Thain. elfe i1iqwd. feu pr~dic:m ciftmialir.ct de Dco ~ aut indlldi in·ems fabftanEia tll: pane modi 1ignitic.mdi. ,,!:lex pme rei fignffic:tl:::e. Ell: parte 1nQd~ fis~ n.on ~qur (\1m m De" ~ lk

;;iHfB. ,"it. ' . 9}

,funt ipfa tubfi:.;ifIria:Dci:, CtgnIAc:an't\lf pet 'inQdum :(ubll~ilria: .:.& clfcndz,Ced vtnJlfdus II,qr px'upric:~ I:as cti'cliti:lt. Ex. pam: ailremteilignifi<;a!:e 'quidqtlid, c:lt DCIlS,elfentiaIJu;r C'fi'Deus • &. fi ipu De!) conuenie aliqlJod :erzdil::;l.tl1m. v,g- 'qlh~d 'fit ParCf~ aUt Pi!ius ; quiJd Itt'j n!l:u5, aut (apiens.elfent~H~ci' ilti conilellir~&:de :corr~dicatlfr.suUlI'\ll: ba:~ l~ {trilla elC ip(o O. Thelin. '1".8-. de pDftflll1l an.l.iltl ,..vbHlTql!ir •. 'ldOd ReiJitil)11U diHmltli~JI jigrrjfifmr idtffWJ 1ft tiiutrtil tJJ.U;filt , 11l)n tllmln Fir tII/Jdifm t/~ [tl1fiYl'lfil1Jim per mUdH11J JifIKif/,mu.foJ. fl 'hllbt~ tild~ iiU;;il·2ud S .lnqu·it; qLr6d . ,u&JUdRIUr fo fHbJl411t11l dillitfiJ. m" tllmm jigmfi~1I1 pv mllt}#tit. {Hbftlil1l i£ j r!t ;4'6111111 Ji(ti1it'/lr. fittm3HM /Hbffil1i'IiaRi, 11114 Jiei P'!iilJkm" [lIbflllilt;lim PfTrl;,it lid lIIMHtn jig"iji(lIml,'£t idem docc:t' inhK.qf;;.dtlrt. ,

l..dd t- ",' . i&

Inl!U b,tnc «go jUHIi:tiontn'l.\ & "'1ft qlllllil 1) poni niu; in hiJ dllahm wndllGonibu, in[clligipo~

tell: mens S- Tbomz. Nam Jo'.!uenljID):!c re!;ttioiii .. bll!,& :mribmis • & elJ~mia ex pmel'd fl8nifl~

ne, & (<<undum quoll Cm~n(i3 rumirur pro. en~ii:ilt. dil.lina, qua Ii modo cranCclindemili. remper dotei td~rionC:i clfcnrialiu:. canucn!,¢: eifcnt • .t ) & 'a conu~no, faclir6que p~di".uiollc:m pede. N~m i~ft''1~''9·drt.(;.iltl1.illfitma,. quOd.SiG.r# ifiiif111- pl1jimt/1 per ft, Pllm ~fl1}tlU. ;14 &ij!II,Dllidlj 1'11'11'.& ~& ml)d() p" IfwdmJ,- Et hoc C(';lltgit D. Thorn.a. co quOd cd.m dieiult, J;.h:~ ~ vel etlm£i. Jiuina dl Plta ~ en pr:tdie:ujo pc~i~kndrafcmi non fJi:Ut inf~iQri$ de (llperiore, Vhf S,Do(loi prZ'djc>1tiQncm jJlam pee ideiJrj,afe'lD cUim eff'CinEi:ilcm dfc:docuit, (ell P" k. nOn aUtem eft pa fc

iii qu~no moda~nequl; lil {ectln~; [1:4 in prj~o. Non In qu.ano modo per [c I ql4i qd:UCW; modUJ

per (I; eft perreIra!! 0p~r.lrlon»,fJo f'tzdiution.U~ill iHis aurem prDpoGtionibus nulla GgnifiQtut opc:rado. Non per fe in {ccundo modo,qliiaifb p«(elt~s cLI; proprierati!:. quz com~r.uur ad rubie-. tlllm accl4cnu.lire, • feU Vt :1I;cicknJ~ lide PC('dU-

no ilIi conne:l::tJm,in Ub, :lutein propolitH:inc e~

tia diuina ell P;lEct,ly Pa1"~non ('ompaEal:unt eccidl"itf ad {ubieltu~~ nee vt at:rriburum. & pro,,:, 'priet:U,kd 1It pcnona: nCii ergO' dl wnnuio ~ 1ft perreira! in fecendo modot&: lie [alum debet d~

in primo,qdi c:Jt confielionis dlenEum. Vnde &:

D. Thorn., dicit quod ira eft pq (~) G,1It itla,Parri eli Deus, vbi 11 DtH.; n6n pIdC:::ltur vt fTop.i~ tas P,mis.(['d VI nahlta i 8c HC noB ell in fccuaao modo pet: fc ; tin: p~r~mita ell propria," narur2t

, fed (ub6ltenria. Vnde fi ptZ'dic~l1r pet f~ ntiom: idc:ndratis,oon in (<<un do modo n propr,~uJ~ red lit etTell ri.llifcc "lfIiU:n:I;n! in primo mudo f" fc

pfa:Qic.1fur. .

Deinde ,p[c: D.Th",m.["p'';QjJ.L7,.dt.1.4'J J. , tJOCC:'f quOd in ipfo p"flfiil1f1't lI,ti;rt' ~ffi rOmil'iCl;q 'fltTb_~& prilfripiH11J 'Vft'biJirllt f/1I.¢NlIlf!'U lid tiHI pvf~aitJ!ttmpm;"lm,f«UlfyrAdUlHm 91· VbiJo:.. quizut deconlin~mj;;p; Iii dft dinino. quartnos dr~ dUIinum imbibintt in o~ni.qi.lad diuinum elhfli milD modo quajl ttanf,c:nanlt'illi fc babe.r. It i1J hilt: tJtJ>It>'t.1. eli!:ir. quM 1U{~I;' nJllittT ,rijms ilj I1~1I hJm tJli t{tmi4 Jilli",,_ iJnn ttJrm~ aijlnu;. AliiJ aure:m loris quz poilel itt fllfllimt ttTl.fJTIJ#1I~1ij (ubiiei£mu$,doctt nOD indlldJ pwpiiet;ltd~

fro fe~fioJit$ m conc::tpro dfmrlz •. vel quia d modo lignific.mdi non lncJuduDtur,vc:l quia fumt-

fur conceptuS cdfrnil% pro WDeepm: proprio. '~ fOl:mali (pecifico c:tTtmiz ~ ~ eft t cocd~niuguirmque fonnaliret a I;OUI;,p-EU IIRIlbu(orum. 4'

nmrionulD. , ' ,

FalWU ,duD i1xwioll~ Sanfioruro Patmm~ i 6,

L f lid"

.'

!:2g;l,ft. XXP Ill.

liect ll'bn mii'l\\I ~dalicanturptG vila pa>re , qullJ\ pto ~lia:QJ!ia a,liql1a~do l~att~ attCn?l;lltcs a~ ne{hum modum, tmclbgendl,qUl prQpt.ctau:s,h:u aCtribut:1 q\la(l accidcntia.fcli acc::idcntia ad, Dei (ubflantiam iritdligil11us,&: rdatiDnes vc ad aliurl,noll ~n (e vt (ubfr.and.l.Itl cxpl!c~m[ts~ dic.ullt (ublb.llti~~ liter iRa nOn nominari, (ell. (LibfbntJaJI11l0n esph .. care.Narn, Vt rd.la admonuit Cyti!lus.lib.l J.,Thtn fa,.,i: N on fJmrlja '1U~ in Dlo {/In,' • &' M p~~ d'fHrIm,fobftll',fiam Ji!/tifi:df1~. ~lU}uJl,,? ejJlg.tfuf• '(1& 'IIo&f,tIl~dJqfJe diurl~j IU.'~t1!t'~ eJfo dICA'",1U I qll~· niafMmdo dct:iJ,rlflU;n. tlHnteifjg~tnl{J.5I1pttnlt' IJU .. rilll) ji(;t"r nih,l drcidm [ubj1anr;1I. 'Dti, q(J4niam ;'1 [tipf>f pdJeEfa eft: 1Io/lro arlttrlJ prl11'rio mgd~ intINiglT1ltl4,& 1~lJni1ttur: t~ hil 111" in n,bid {lm/lqHofP p"'tXtmpls, maiora, id<j1 ,jilfilfairtuliltln1(l. Yb.i pblle Cyritlus menrcm nobis SanttorLlm 3pcmirt llll.1m D,Thom.SchoIaIHeis renninis pollca deli~ ne~ujt ; Ieilic.ex malic nolho fignifil:oll1di,l'Ion vt (Liblbmbm , (eu e!lenda11llJci (:;~ ligllil19ri; ex p~rte aueem rei figl1i!ic~t::e en', ip[all1 f~bllantia~ Ddjn~c errcntia Iirer , &. intrin (c~c pollc alilltl ~l1c ~uarn Deus • nee i?CIU aHud qnim ipCt. Op.lim:l {lim verba netlunll ferm.BO.1II Colflmil. vbl 10- qlleM contra Gilbcfnlllll Rt.~JAnt. inquit.."071't.llit tlDI1 di41~fli&i • f~t1. h.mici, iJl~' mj(gniiuaJfl~m. '1u~ 1tIJlg#1I4 1ft D~JU,& item bQnita'ern. 'f"lllMnH4,{td f!l' foPiemiilm. qU4 j'apieltJj & iuj1iliAmI1144 lujliN tn, F'fimnD J.iuini'4t.nn • 'lIla DIu; tft, 'Dt1i1lJ n~" tJfo impjijfimU.i[pU'1II1r. Srd fl [J:III n~17 tp ,f/llia eft f £1: fn~, dbfo 1/t "jfomi41 Calholi~4 &d~J'ltttJfo 'Vide I;'" m fobftaIJ1i4m , vel (lliqultm "ml7il1o rem 'IliA 'Dtl4 jU'&'llll.l111t1 fit De;IJ.Scd Deus patl:fllitaic c:(l Paten ergo p;lteIl\it~5 Deus el]. Dteune ; Palc{rljras DellS ell\: rcalitcr. non cl1i,nti:llire{. Vrgeo con(l!~ quentiarn I1c:rnatdj : Si e!fentiaIiC(;'f Deus J1QJ'I ell, qUid cWt't1f;~ljtcr dllNJln cflentialirer aliquid di: llc illud aliqllid {j Deus non, ell: clli:o[ialiter • nibil c:nenti3lircr cft. V!ld~ undem Allgl.lIl:.l.b'7.J~ TritIIt.l;lfp.6. C~m di~irmu inqllit.pvfolUlrn PM.,.~,t1IJ7J Iiljll4 aicJf1jJt! 1]11"'" fM~ft"fIIlafll Pl/m,u.Sj non aliud didmu$,ergo c!lcmi~lite( [lIbfhnri~ ill:! d\:.

I I Similirer prQ alia pandcll.qllQd ipCc D~lu. (~u

trr~mia dil.lina elfe=n{hlitc~.U inltinf'c~ tit rd.1tio. (cu pt=r(ona, funt optililOl YCrbl S,Arhanalij .wilti,,lIfW1JTjS at"tg.d~SilbtU~. Yf1IlIrti'" plmilud •• (iT itlugrit,oU DfllillU t}l Pillef, &' E.jilfl : qu.:.1i dlC3[ ex plenitlldine ipGU5 Di:it2(h provt :at.l:u.s purus ell,& omnia imbibir qu~ Dei [unr.etfc Parrc:m, "" Filium , qU:1u:nus anlbonllIl vna forma ell.n ipre Athallafius illqtli(. E~ Cyrillut jfJ lib.l.. ThlftiHyj c. J.N fill f~I~j1.inqlJiI,ptrf,a" ,ifo DdlM.l1ij Filium haht.t. &' [THUHTi1 t:;: ft pr~fotAt. ~od fi colleCUI1~ Patcr,& Filius.&: SpirirqS S,~uinenE ad pIe. niludinem.& inE~gtil3tt!l1 Dc:itatis; crgo.& ad 1;[ftn.ri;u~ conceptqm, quia im~gIita$, !o:piellitudo tRcl'lw\\j diuinilati eft. ~od G ad pto=nitudinl!ll1

t~o=~~o~cQlle4iopttfonannn: ergo ~ qU:t"lict dl\tlliue ~ nam ctU:I;libl;C penom tantUIll pond~~t;q~turn lOU eDIlr:llio. V nde dint Concilium Toltt. 11. j~ 'l7IftjJ~lIt Jiki. Sinf,,,t.,itty 'P174if";(i"'~ pnJ~;& 'ft pk4.u D~ Sine qllalibc:t etg~ p~Oll~ Deus non el\. pltnus Deus:ergo Ii c;((tlll.llhfCf D cu~ til pttl\l1S , e(fcl1~liteJ P-ells ell: pctfolU. N ~c pote n: did quOd diui~ &:R~ntill. met~phyfi'~ lon~dtrata. int~l\;~it~ re(pc:aq p 1;((0- JUmm,vt [PC:CICS nfpetlu tndiuldllOnlm, indiuidIU ~\ltan non funt de: (Onteplll fpcl;iei:n:lln cons Ifa (:1\. quOd fpedc:s non babet pta pltnU:lldi~ Ile. ec int~rit;l,te tllZ cir~ indiuidU<1, dei~ m al!~~ ~ pro pkIlitJJdin~ • .:Ie: iQt~u, .. It dcita!:a iif..,s l'cnaDa$ i Vt dicit AElwUl.iu.s~

-,

,'J.Je BetAtioni/;tiJ diuiniJ ~

& plenitudo dc:itatis elt cjfmd~lis d-e:imi-; .

lJn tlretnA CQ{libt Partes (ub,nnminc fla{ura: i 8c u': non d~jtati5 vel clIcnti~ qllafi rranfcendenralirer {umpt:t' negare per(on:l$ [eurc!aciollc£ ad n~ruralIl

Dei peninen:, lic!l~ Dam~fcenl1~ Ijb.~,J, fiat c. G. Cha"lfkrijii~~inquit,hJ?ojl4e{,nl1n rtAlIIYA{tmt, Et Anfeltnus in MQfiologio Cllp.l.j.. Siquid. inquitjd, [lIrt1mAflallSl'" ~idllir re1>fliHt; iton tjl~ilU (ignifo .....

HUll. Q!lod incc\ligimdubforrnalit:lte, & expref .. linne couceptus lJ.:J.turz: id enim intenditur In I,. fi1.rlijiCiltU1!J ~ q ua eti~~ ration!! de aUri~utjs;dbtiC Danutanu$ lib.l.d~ Fd~ ('4.5j bjj~:~rnt!; ,uj1um,Ji-.

tIl/ia Mlt diKlru,mm tifltHrllm ~ti diri4.Pd 'lHZ i"x ..

ffl flilt"yarn follt. Vb; 11 '1I1'Bram dil:u, idem ell: .tc f(lrll1a,li~cr e~ pliCa!. Alioqui,n idcntid, &: realiret n~gm non paten quod .dauo , &: pcrCon.'\ lit n~

tura d.uina j de6nient.: Cencillo L(ir~ranenG in t: .. Damf141111u. quod quzlibet trium p~tfQnl1'um ell

lib res, viddkl;E (ubll:lI~ci~. clfcii~i2.,(eu natUt3. df-

uina,

Fllnd~mcntllm vtriu(que conr:luliGnis (umitut J i c)c diais, N~ln prima-: fundamCDtUm ell qui. fQrmali' toncl;ptus naeuce dillinguitlU' :\ formali conceptu :mribI1Ioruffi, &. lebtiolium.& pu:(op .. ponitllr natUU e:J: ipfa formali ratiolle, '" modo lignj6c~Il{li ad pctioJ'ulirlltu: ergo rc=pugn:1.( quod ptr(ona lic de: fi>rnull eonci:ptu n~rur;E , vc:l ~ contra, Conrc-quc::n{ia patet qllia efIc VOLUD de fQrn1~li co nee pEU alrcrius, nihil alilold ell. quam iiigt!:di ,( 50!: pcrtinetc ad iIIud quod formalc

ell: in conccptu proprio, Be (peci!icQ talis rei. II ..

lud aurern cil furmale III conceptu natura:'. vel CLliulcumque auribud. quod e;:ptimkurin rali concl'pnl t~nquam forma prDpria, [m fotmalis ra-

tio illius auriburi ",c:lllllur:c; quod enim commu ..

ne dl aliis armburis • vel natl1t;e; non ell: fQtmal==~

& proeriurn ulis con~cptlls.[cd cOlllrllunc,&pr«=fi'ppolltutn, fonna aurcm gil qaz: di!l:inglliq &

i,ico iIllld dicitut form31e , fell. formaliH!{ pertinc .. read concCptUIll (:Iliufque attdbuti, velm~ur~;in

quo dHl:inguitur sb ;llio amibllto. vel a. formali{a-

ee ipfiusn:lturJ:.aud formotli cOllcepru rebrioniS' ..

(~U pcdonz. IX hoc ell: quod formalitr:dn eo con. aptu uptimimq!i(ur com:eptu5 (.apic:ntill': form ..

litet d.llinguitUf a concepr:u hlll.iUZ t vcl mi(ed-' cordi:.:, &:e. Anteced. vlilro manifcll:e c:onll:::.r,qllia (:onccpIUs n3tur%;!!I? pc:rCOllit.(cl1 amibutofUm ira

{e h;lbenr,quot! natUrOl cOlllider~[llr Cub conct!pr" n3(IJtZ,Vt fundamenrum,& radiX ~rrIiburoIUm,&; opl;ndonum, & vt qUid P[~fllppolitum ad pu(o_ !lam. qt~i=l, intclHgirut VE aHquid,fermin;bile ptf pc=don~~tatl:m t~nqllam ptr rennmum: lirgo eXptic;lt cotl~['pUlm lub 3liqUl formali 'rationc di4 tlinClum a concertu per(ollz.& anribmorum.Et-

gQ p~rfonJ.. &. iclado non potdl ingrcdi nc'lu(: pc:rrincre ad fotm~lcm ~onceptum tali! IUmr.r. Rcpllgnat cnim Cub ea fonnalime ingn:di conct:ptum, Cub quo abillo dHl:inguitur. Uillinguitlll: ;!Utl~:m CCI;undum formalem con~c:ptum 3b iUo:

ergo (ub ill~ r:uionc llon!:1l: de conccproolH.

Fuodamemum £ecunda: (:oDthdionis }I;I~

du~u panes. .

Prima en quad dfcmia diuim fuh amplo, &: qU3" Eranrcel'ldcm~li co:gccptU l:ntimtis diuirue.

¢ [~nrialiti:r indudamf in rclationibu! r3nqllam 1 f imdn(tc:un.& cmit:lliuum pra:dicatum c'Irum.

Scc:undl.quod rebtiones ~ti:lm indudanrnreffClubliter. feu cOl'lllet:bnmr clf~nd31itt:r ipli e(..' remi~. Et prima paIS cOllilOlt • qUI~ felatione$ ill:&: elfcbtl.iliter runt emia inercat;l.: ergo't!fclldantl:r (!.lnr dI'rntia diuill;!,&: dcit:l$. Parer confequ. quill! cifrntia dUlbu.fcu Jilei~ill , eft: ip&. Utjg aa!1~ puri ..

, ~c:1l~

'1Ji.lp(Jtati~ X III (Attic. / j. , J

& elfe diLlini. reo tntis increari : ergo quod dl tf~ Onini! 'clli::diuinl1in. in'lI\ eil quat iden'riia,~1; di"o

fenrialitcr:r en, inereafU:I'i'I.cll: c:l1'tflli.tliter ea'C diui- uinum ·tll eKe diuinum.

nUII1:ergo DCI1 • .rea 1!I=it~i ip_&. Antece"l.~onl1at~ RdpotJdertt ramen op'pofili An'thotes' qui pti-

quj~ r~lado ills e_lferui;i.liter ell ~liquod ens ) ~ ,ef- roam panerl'd1U'ius ct'n dulionis nc:giint, q uod hc~i:

f~ntlah~er_ ell: cm non crearum : _~~go _ e~cJ'mahtera parte rei l1Iu:tliber rc:latio fit diEllna.&, quodlibet

elt Cn$ tncrearum. Vnd~ elt iirmll1ima rlla confe- ::awburum liretii:nti:dIEn Deus ','& non ma:mra.

quentia quam facit Pm.Suarc::t 'IIbiftlprlt lib.;,.J, 'umen IUb lUo Ih-m przciiiollis,. quo c'onfidcratni:

TrilJit. e'7' Parernirns c:1t Deus: crgo dfcmialit:t fecundilm (c,nc'c'Clldiuil1l1m,nc'que !=[c:itllfIJ,q1tla

Deus:(:rgo in rUQ dfc:ntiali 'Otic.-.ptU jnciud" Dei. neuenim ctplicar. {cd ranttlfn [L1.1m formalci'll ra-

tatem. Prim:! con:"cqur::l'ltia parcE, qUia id '111ad eft 'tiorlcJn expl"imit: Ikut flOlllO {j:'\lndL~1Ti Cc nee cit

DeUi.IlQll potdl: elfe Deus acddemOlli,c:r,!anquall'l o'Ilbu5;ncc dl non albu!,fcd :rba(~hi! ;:& m~gis:rd.

accidens 1 Ce di(lin,:}um,net tallquam pra:dic<l;fUm fern, homo, .... el animal (lib illc pr:tcilo COJ)C~P1ih

a [c dillillaum. 'lim non fie aliqliid per cOinpoti- nee ell: quid produaum,ncqlll: 'improdu,tum .. Ji.

rionem,& p~f modum ad:L1s, &. poeenti:!:, (",d per eel in re dI~lHiaHtcr 'l.lild cre~tum, & prorluch.UD

{umll'laltl idl;mimeln ath15 puri : ergo per conne- Ii! ; & SpiriCtu S. (ilb form::.li!are proc:cl'lionfHII:4

xlonem nc'clfui:zm > &. hrttrlilrabilem.& tarrquam que pf(]ce'dit ve crc:Ullra. nee 'vt DCIl~ in quam)

urnnino idem: corgQ tanquam clfentialltCr coune- modo p~[ fc,Heer 'in r~,& in .priml' mDdo per (I: fie

);Um. S::cl1nda vero con!cq:l.I.cti.2.m ellilunifdh. dlcntlalitf;r Dc(u. Eadem modo relariolIcs(ub if-

.quiil quod ell Clfentialite.r tale , in (uo e-l1emi,lli io CDnCeptl! non induihmc dfcllcJ;I!ici"r naruram.

COtit:~ptU ilIlld indud;t : ~tgQ li clfcnti~liu=r p .. rd. "c~r in tC dfc<ltialitcr fjjtu"ra dia-ina; (im:.& Deus.

ell DCLU, in Itlo elfcnti .. li conccptu Pater indlldi't 6nr. ,

Ociran:m. . C:il:!.'[llm b~i: rdponGo lfIa:tima indic.u;quarn.

J) lic hine [umirur {e!:anJ:r: p:!nii pro. baric ,qu,;!. in rc;lortum.& ill vc~ti!!incrn ~g.lfU' oppofita (ei1~

quidquld conutnit 0:0 realircr, & in Ic,e-Ifcnti;tli- ttlltia vi atgllillcmi opprcJ1ii.. Ettnim lkc:r fdf.i

u:t llil conLlel'li!, ira quOd iu:c ell: J~gi!HtJ~ confcg. rhIiQ(ophi.1 lit, qllod r~! aliqua fub .1ltqua plred-

Dcas cit lultusaur r .. pkns:l:l'g(J ellcntMitL"17 cfl: fa· fion~ 'o1:di~euu,ilJi:l prlj"dicaf.lnon drli~'jt,q~jam

pietls,& iuJtus,DC:d5 elt Pa[l:r:crgo efli;l'Id~Hte:r cit q_Uit: in i1!~ pt::tcinollc c~ plk;:m~uf .&:ld ill:lm pc£'

Pater, quia q_LiidquJo:! Deti~ eft el{~nu~liEcr, &. in- Ie conducum • ramen tri"m in DUm! pn,lo{ophia.

trinfece ell, & ellenejaiitct Illi conucnit , f1:'d Dee ell cenum 'i\'Dd quando Jfiquirimll~ :111 ;liqllod

c;:onUc=ni[ form,1lirer, &:.a P;Z([c tl:i dr~ intern.oX prOE'dic~nlin cllcutialitcf inc:!uibt!4",& pCfdne'af:!'4

iilium,l1on minus quam df.: inl1um am :1:tt"mnm .1liqllam rem.non proudimu$ tum pf:E,ifj(Jnc:;f~

ira ql10d h.-.:c elt veta !ectmdilm l:idem , Deus cll nnlpliE:.rcr ea qu~ jnuinfl;~e: (Urn r~Ji re CCilIlC:do

Parer, Dci1seit filius. didru-c cnim lQ;ln.J. DIHI fUM. C:l:.pIiCOImUH Y.g.~nifllal fub przeb,. & fo~~

ITllt flttb_. ergo Verbum. (ell Pater c:lfenrialittr Piali r~fione lnimllJis non cx.p[k~u:!tiQflCm C£)f"§

Dco conubUt. Minor ell de fide~& COIJ{cq1t.c:Jt in ptlri~ vel fubtbnti;r,aut creatUf:l: ,("'men U inqui-

a.m,.Maior probu gr. '~idqL1id Deo (onucnldn ramUHn till: nrialiu~l' incJudiltut {ubfJ:anua in mi.

fe." fonnalitcr inm:at11m.& d iUjl1tUJl cft:. & alhu Piali J iI:!. qucid dli=ntialittr pr~dicC:ltlt dc ~mmau.

ptuaf. 'In!:!', YE prob:luimllS • c!f!:llEia ,fcu c..1li: dilti- .&;: lilnilircr eliS crcamm~lJui~ porc:rit dubitarc qua4

Dum dl: cif,,"nti~le Patri.~ ,cllltiol1lbu:> • .x aernbn- ita;c fir dle:oti;llis priEdit.¥io. Anim:d ell {ubfia.ti~

tis i fcd emne dfi: dillinlliU •. !o: incrl!'atllm cll cJl(.-n- ti~>eft Ct"aEura,~1t 'otpusiqui;I~l:roe t't fit PJzdi-

tim ipli Dee, {(:u .:Jfc.:nclz dillil1~ in qu~~um eOJ t;atio cflm'[jalis> fufticit dicntialis. (rn inuin{eQ

diuinUIn,feu elfc dl'.Iinllm dl: : ergo p~~~roit.n at: ",OnneXfO e:mcmOrum. Ctim crgQ in ~c fC'lIllda

JcI~tioncs ,qu.t: C"lfent.~lw:=r lum Clltl4 diuina. & -colldutionc rron prot"cditmuJ rub lrzclfiQil~" ac

elf!; diuinum , c:tl;;nrialiter cenueni IIRt JiuiniE<1ti, appellationc: formOlH, conctptus ~ ( enim ptrrfn«

~uia omne df<: diuinum ell elre-ntAle c~Cnuz dt~ ad primJom '()1ldIlGon~lnfred flmplidtcr an (;n~1l'>

UillZ. ti.:ditain repr;edicetUf, at conneCt .. tllr dl"ema

Et con£icm. qui~ Deo etl"cnriaHra cOllUcnir dfc cum paCoDis, & parana: cum tlfrntla.. ita Vt ilt2:' llctlJm pururn: ergo etfcmiaJitcr cOllucnit qllid. przrlh:a!iort~ in re tint per (e in primo modo

qUId leb, pann eJ: rUG 'anc~ptu. c!fcmiaJi lub«j Dcu~ dl P;ICI~~ , Parer ell Oeu5 ~ "CUt fi inquit"~~

[~d c:.: ctT:ruWi (onlcptU aCtus purl conuenlt c:i illllS an C:OlpUS. & [ubn~ntia pnCice.nrur in tc era

ad nIhIl t;11~ in p,nemia,lcd omncm pWt"GCioncrn {(;hliaIIler 0: aninlali.& nunc "Ejam mqiiirflilUI ali

ubi conucnire. & omnc quod jn ipro ell ~ ergo C)! patemitas iit pntdk;)flIm cllb:ui:dc Ddutu) &.

vi fai cjf~ntiaU5 conceptUs cit quidquid dl:rcd ce. Ddra\ dfemille pta:dit:~turn pa(t'rniuri$,ir:l. Itt cf,..

{cnril diuin:r, • feu DCU5 atlu (It P:lft<tt &. F!lius,A: (I:lid~lircf tint COnnl!X3, quid Df'0U~t diue-rterc It:-

ad tiLlS perfcctionem pminct hoc rnyllcriii. quod {r6nuonem ~ rt;rdic~tlon~ fad.;lm d-c aU'iuo

(dUic Hinus in pet(oltis,&: non 'E1mm [antum per. (lib pra:cifioo[:a[,qU:l,tfl" arpdl;ltio~-r

10nam habear, nc:c {ohlm genus ahfQIQmm,fcd t=ti:lm relatiullm : ago elf~mialitcr eft ipf~ reInl". lie ipGe perlonz. S~ tamen c~m il1dud3t rrts per{onllS cQrrdatilie nppoGta5. !leer dfmrialiter ~(~ (t=nti~ fit pcr[Ofil > nOR ramen *qU:lte eft q~li~ ber perfoa~. quia. ira en hu p~t(on;& • quOd t:tiam ,ell alia 1 ticut en$licl't Itl!nfccndeQt.direr ind~cbt accidcnSt &: (ubA:anriam, non (ameD :uLrqllale;d.. tetUltl.fed. ad~qllare "ullmquC.

::16 Vnde pate. Awhom;qui primam panml hwu$ . c-OItcbzflOuU cQlI«dunt. vr SUllIe:!:. 6; alij, &: ne- 1'IlIt fccundam. incoDfeqaent« loqui • qqia pet euidenttm comequcntiam (kduJ:itlJ( • quOd!i per{Olla eJUntialitu ell D~JIc eJfe diuinl.lm. neec(. (:mG fcqttitUl' cBaariam muin;zm feu Dcir;tem ~lfclUi~itKr clf" pu(omm, lima cffellliatrc[ c11

SOIRII1Jliir Rt!!/ITTiffltil.

priin-6argwt. 2uthQrit~tiblJ5mm S5. PP. mm ii D,Thom. qui plant videJ1rur fmdk net:: rdado· nes,nec atrtibuu dre d~ tubfiantla clhlibitaris. nee

:ld rius clfcllri.nn pen-inerc .. Amhoritara ~ P .mi~ bus (unt ; Augult. itl 7.J~ Trinil.e.:.. & ".6: f!if" prJ·". i!jeit P.rrm lIIi, tift P':Tmz t 4fi, Dtttm. ,Mi.6 qu,J ~P,4d It Jj,;iUtT ~ PJdtr 1IIIll1M ltd FilitDJi ~i'~.EdimiliEet clO<CI Vcr~llmiloll eo em~ .. p1cJwam. quo Vabum ~ & uL:m en: de dli:Jltl2O. liem III f.J~TTiflil. e.6. do,~ l:t1aliOiltS thd de:

D~o, !lon {'tuudiim fubwi:lrn, nee ktvndutt1 .acddcns,{cd VE ad aliquid.: E.go d~ tOlKcptU rd~ fi~ nOn dl illbfbntia diuin~ I),c(}JIc de: o,,,crprti

&.thn~~

§lJt.4lio xxr Ill.

(\lbA:anti~ rc"!:!.tfones. Jtl3n Na;t.i~nz.Dratitme 4<i· loq',cns de pcr(onis~ N eqlll fubjlami<t1i9,illquit,fo,trfl"trt. 'vel'''"' (j"a r II'hjlamiatIJ pctTtl/4ntur. .Ath~nafins D'4logo ~,de,Trittif.c:ollt711 A7IDm,zHm,Jn-

,quit) q~",rA'i~'1tm norul '1uiJdlt71J tJfollli"/~. ergo 1l0!\ pettinet ad cl1~lItill.m D~j:llidorlls 7. EthJ'['oI~g.t:. r, Desm non tJJteJfontiahur'j qll~d It{A/IUt' Ita 'i1l4Tl1Cnmq"e perf~nalh tjl.D~IIla(c. },b.~.dt Jidt' C .. 6. ChJiraf1mjlu:,/"hJP~pa{{b$; n~n n",uu.[llnI. C:Y!II~ Ius Aic:)t'anddnu5 1.Thtfour$ c.~. doccr C!xtnnlecc fc habcre: ad eflenriam rclaticnem qua diltinguitur fl;£[onJ. Auli:hnus in M ullolog. C4f'. J 4· Si. 91lid it' {u"'tIIIt. natllr(l diet/Iff' relatilli, 11M eft ciIU jigl1ift( alum.

G~.IIlf.c:x D.Thom. qUi in 1.Ji(1. H.q.I.j:lrt. r.at/. ".c~prc($': dicit. quod De itlttlkflu p'Tfolt'- oporUt ~Jfolfli'lll"m Tiftiol1tm ,fo,L. reltiti'J':~,9111. no» tft de ;m&£I1J tffin1it.EI ;111.114 411ibalJ.. diP. ~ ~.q.vfJi(JI ~Tt .. t. docec, quod PrUpl'itl.u ad (Jfmtiilm ~ habtt Jijpaolfi, ad ftrJQ1l4tll allftm fo hllbtt ptr ti7~dflm flrmt.U!!omodo trga dl de COJlcc=ptU c=fI~nd~,& cU~nti~litcr pr;tdic3tLlrd~ ilIa,G di(p~rata [c h3bcn AdlulC vrgentius itt qu.g.dt PlJl",lill.m,,,.Jfd (I. dicit ham; prUkiltiorltm nOI1 tD~ P" [t: tj[ml1il rjl fA. terlliMI; crgo non elt de conc~·rn!. ~1I~mi~ forin~lilcr. lrem in h-« l,p''1.n.",t+Rd I. ilttlUit. IIII'M Cumm'mi" abfolHlt I11tllrdilfUur in "lltUd/1I pl'~pTill- 111m,fed 11011 ; ~oml,rfo.11I i;tlelkEfIi fllirn Flrfon~ Pfi~ trid inuPigitHr <[Jew,pJ. tto}1 cC12umi,ur. ~id eladU5 peruir D. Thorn. dicere contra fC(IlJl!.l~m partern 1101hz fecund;!! conclufionis j

R.efpon.:&d p.rimaln amhori(;item Augull.quod il.l:un e"p~E(~e lIbi obiicir D.Thom.lJll. g.dt' ((11m. ts« ",rl. J;j,,, 11r!/"rltI'lfD 1+ Eue-fpon dcr S. LJ. A J. 14· DICtllallffl 'lso-l V'I(.! din/If)' r!(JII to DeHa)qHo PAw ter• r~fllj' di1ltrfom moJllm JiI"i{j(II'iJi dSlli •. ;141M, 6' patrmi,:n U. 'III txpojitum tJl. E:{pofuerllrit anrcm fo1u;itJl1t ad -4. quod rd,ltiones dJi.lln~ lictr fig'lifi. cenr teI'luad ell dillill~ cirenria, non tamcn pel: modum c:-11..:-mi;r, q'li~ non pe-l: modum ill~;1I;ill:clItis/ttl per modum [I; hJbt:II[;S ad aliuQ.Qu3re cum dicit Augull:. alio dr~ Parrem, !Ilia Deum.inrelllg!tur d!: 'llio ex p~[[e modi fignifie-and;, non ex: p.tftC rei fign;6nt:t. Ex hac enim pmc: didt Aug. 7.lll Tt1lflt.C.&.q11od Cum di&Unsuprrjumm. Pllm~, :rro"",fi~ Jicimilj 'fIfRm !"bjllfI11ill-m PRtTM.Scnandll locum AliguCt. c=od~m modo intcrpmatUI S. Tb. I~~o citllt.Ail I J. & ill h", ,W.=I.l- . .d. r. Y((obiq!lt: cnim ilium libi obic:tiI,& (oluit. diccfldo quod rclatiua pon dicuntl1t de Dec (ublhnd;tlitr:t. (cn quo;d (ublhnri~mCll pmemoJi ugnilic:mdi,qui:l. pOll modo rublhnti~ (Jgniiicanrur, vt p~ fe.&: ad (t,fcd modo Id:ltiuo. YI ad :dtc=mro. Ex P;lrtt f.lmen ro tigllilj,;~t;t (ubllanria (unt· Eodtm [cnfu 2Cdpe quO(ks apud :tJiquos P P. audieri$ ~mibu[;J. Dd nun fignificardubftm.ti:nl1 , fd ali'luid circa r~blh,ntiml>vt:iplld Dama(l;.ljb. t.dt Jid~C'4.BJfiliulnid',l."Mtl'<II EJPIomium, Nazianzetlum DYIII. J8.& :H.lulHnlltIl'H G~mi/. &; alio~: illttlliguntuf r:nun non 6gnifiun: fubllamiam in modo G. ghi6.~dl>nbn ill ipfa re fignifie:~t:l'

I, Ad IDC\lm Nazi~n't. in 3.rl;umnuo alblum,dicimu~ ~Xtt3 t~'!' :M!dllri : SmlU5 cilim cill! ~n plaM mlS. quAd ft=~I(Jn'; fublbmiam non ((cemu Ilt, id~ cit • non diU1d.u'!l Cllblhnli=.m. Cl;!d Qrc~ iplim feurnuni:ur, ql1l:1lntc( fc: dd\inguUntur non ab ipf ... lubn~tia. ElIl"li.c.a\lit enil'l'l Thc:olog~5 \lilD illius , ~1TIm1S fu hthnn:r .qu;r tunc ttmporb (;omrouc=(_ . ttb~t\lr :lolignificartf hyponalim. &. lit muhiplie

ur~ in Dc:o.~n naturam,&: lie non diuidcrcrw. h.~~ ~inOC;tlione buiul nomini5 vdde tun!; ~ dl'flopt(l ~iZnQnuu ~l{lJi~~

D« R elalidnibtiJ diuinh.

los GmpliCes dc-cipichtiiJin,vc, plures flibflantias in. Dee concedcndo ', ipti diuerfas aaruras inferrenr, Vnae Nazbnz..r<:li:e dil!:k, fubftamiam non fccerni p'er p~r((}tjas,quianDJi1l:n natura: c~, nec illa p~r p~[!(jn:t5 diuidirut;. S~d hoc quid ad pra::fc!,tcm connouerfiam : Ad locum AihJn~fij didtllf gCrtC~ rarionem non dlt: :iliquid dlell[jal~. ~uia ell notlcnale s dillinguimu5 cuim norionali:l..ab dTi:r.tial.bus , lion qUIa dfl:lltiali .conncil:iot\e de dkllda non pr:tdicentur. (caquia conceptu rciarjuo ditUlltllr,& (unt propda perfonarum ,dim cjf~ntia. lia lint abfolula,& ccrnmunia, !:.adcm ell cxplicario lfidtlri.,fcil. DC,um non dIe d;'~ntialita, qucd rdadllc til:, quia relatiuum ell noriollaie ; non cf~ fcndale: ~ & fie tJHlinguit c:nemj~litet cdI'e conrra ncrionaliter dIe. non tamen negac dr"nd~lircE eonuei.irc notionalibus , feu rclaliuil jd qi10d elfe diu;ni ell. Ad Damakenum iam fopy;' du:inull quod hypolhCes non funr n;ltnr~ fub ceneepru 1):ll\Ir:l: proprio,& IpedJltQ I a.. (ccundt'im modum figmlic:l.1cdl t ql.htB:nm narura figllillcatiJr fuodo ccmmunicabili , laypoltafc5 modo iIH;:oIilmunka .. blli,noll umltJ nrg~t dI~ nat1.1t:lItl, fllmpta natura pro dlc:mia. lell ctle dllll IlO ,modo I;juafi tr~nfctnd~nr~J. h: hJb"l1do ~d omnia, qllzin Deo funt. lit lie (cnliu dt quod char ... aerUhc:!. in Oro> leu 1I~ ucn.Jia , non (un! natuI~,id ea, non fub concert\ll1~tllr::e ,I~dold hypc>{hlim Leu per(onam p~i~ nent. Ad Cynlhlm didtl1t relanonem e::urinrc~c fc hab ~I():ld drl1uiam. tum c=x p:&nc modi iigm.. heand; • quia nOili'C[ rnodum dli.:miz, fed extra ilium figmficamr; tum quo~d cenceprurn proprillm • & Ipt(;ili[tJnl efll;!lria: In rarieue naful~. cui cOllceptui fOrIJllliu:r. &. quoad lui r::xprcf~ lioncm t':t trln r ce c J c; habet l·c.Luio • I; r:tt in ratione con~tr[U! uan!cLf\d~llt3li5, & r:ntllatlS wcnat:l: inlrinlecc iIIam in Ie includat,

Ad Conf. c=x variis locis O. Thorn. Rcfp. in J.O primo loco • Ctll'Il dicit relarioncm dfe- de jntelle- . du pc:tfomr • nOI\ de inrellcdu cfl'eilti:c- .1oqui dc= relatione u p~ltc modi fignificandi, lion ex pa~-

te rei lignificat:e i EI iterum loqui de dl~mia pro concepru nallltz ptOpli() • !Ie Ipe{ilico, H natUIa

elt cotld,fl;infb eb ~ttllbud5 ,lion duollc,"ptU eCrcnti:t pro omni eire diuino, IX ati:u puta. Et hine '(lam "PF3rer qllod 'lUOlndo D.ThoID.'TI .zli-

"10 IX hil l~eu do~ct n:hrionem contraponi I!f[('ntin: ; 'luod plus (onar. '[113m ~illingui r:ul0ne

ab ilJa ~ nam :mnbm .. difiingl'umur , &. non conlr~ponumur: dicit mim Iy ~onl'lapuni cJfeoppofitum i & fie vidclur clier:tc quOd in qu~mum tOlHraponitLl{noll ~It de conceptu eius, Stdre(p. quod If WJtraPQtJi ell a: pane modi figililicandI oppOni. non ex parte rei fignific:I(;a:; & fie (0- lum fcquJttlr quOd c1 modo fignifil13Ddi. ff;ilicer (ublbnri.a , vr ad (e , rehuio vt !lOll :Ie:!. fe> fed :ld ;tHud contr3pommtur in I)' Ila fl. &. non ad fe ;l.b~ folute dici, & non abColut': • Iicc:t t:t pant: rei G~ gnilicalz non f;Ontrapon3mur, Vel (ccundo, rC!ati() non dt de ,collc:cpm dfentiz. tan!Jllam prn:dic;atLim 3da:qu:llum. &: conu~rlibile tum jpra~

&: Vt CC)!lfiitutiuum dfc:nri3lis talionis. Non la~ men lie-gat dIi: de (Onl;~ptU rl1cnri.r r2llq\l~m, quid inloa:quaturn iIIi ,liquidlm ~lfcnti; ita indudit in Cc ynlm rclationcm, quod nen exchllli, :!.lIarn = debet rnim h3b~rc c;;oudatiul1m. Nee: rr;- , pugnat in VIlD conccptu drcllti:lli dari vnulQ. pra=dicatul'Il m:agi. amplum de ft, Vt animal> alilld snillU5 amplum, iUique inad:tqu~IlItn • (ciUeer rationale • licet in hoc n(,ln tenear; txc:mphllll. quia. 2nimal • Vt dl in bOlIlinc: iingubciuluM i &. de:-: =min.UIlDl adz'luatW: Ia,ionali ;. \It llllttm .;i&~

. 1lnhit

DilPytlttio str;

fir3bit,Bl generic~ {llmimr.non ad:tquamf illi-.E(:' fentia ~utetn diuif\1 in [e fiogul~ri5 (:J(Hfen5 corn- 111110is dl:ttibll5 pa(oni5. Vode habet prittilegimn rei vnillCti"a[i1 abfirollll[,v .g,gcneri5;ira quod ,!fcn. rialitcrconncctanln:ull'l ptdonis , feu rclltionibus.nee ramen <:oJ1ueHibi!Jtcr.licut Ii daretur animal jhlh.1etum a. paree rei',vr p.,[uit Plato, ideneficarct llbi dift',:remiil.5 fr.:citi,~~ s nee tamen COIiuereibilncr , & ;lI:b:qn:uc cum qll~libee (;arUnl [c hjbew. Deniquerelarlo non ingreditllr Ctln~ep~ tum cf!i:nti~ ve rra:dkaturfl contlirucns , [cd Vt rCrmiUilI15;& ti~c:ffelltiaHter illi ecnuenlr raoqllam 11101.111>,& tcrminLu ehn.Sfc.ltut~mimdligiltlus S. ThoI1.lam,quiil ip[e !icr.Jlplicat in eodem loco, qui citaeur dijl. H. hoc I\odtm exernple de vnil~erl:di rdp~all infcrionltn,Ii<:<:t cum differ~nda dith,Er lie: ponie non clferdationem de inrdltdu dlcmia: quod nullo modo ab ip(:ldiff~n,qtl.,d eft non dIe de i n~dlc.!tu eius pet :iidxqU:ItiOl1~fIl. &: per mo;· dum pm:dicati ~onlhtmilli.non modifi,~riui, dim ;!liis Iocis fflpYd tel:U!S explicauCfit clfemilli!cr • & per (c rda!ionC5 rrrdk~ri d:: Deo.

;10 Ad fc~undl1m locum elf. IJ.S.it PQunt"',S, Tho" , dicit hanc propoliric:ll\I:ID non elle pcr fi: EiTmtiA tft parttrmlitJ. e~ patte modi fignih(.lndi ,non u: paree rei fillnificaror: rnrn elf.prcjs~ (onccdl! IfJ hit. If''1'S!J.lJrt.?II'': t.quud,.~mif/A~j/Ftr~.P'Itrr tjl iJ!ill ,tj1l<tM ifliI. DtHUj1 ffllfr. Non dt etiarn per fe , fnmtndo cfi'cnrialrt pro conrepru £ormali ctf(;mi~, [¢Il namra-:. vt Jin illguiJ:Ir l. conctptu formalLmriborofilnl.& pCtron~l\Im ,Cub hac pra:dtione ,& fOl'm~!it~.tc non cit pcr [e • qni:! non cenducie • aur pf:nillcr ad ilbm formahu~ rem • feu ptot'cilionem conccptLIs.licct jib rd conct:pt;'C pCI ii; conm:8:atur, & de: ilia dfentialircr pr:tdicctur. V ndc.D' Th.iff illo tod. Ig~t1 ~ticir qnod, nit: uillm tJfintillo pro(dk4u11' ptl' ft /, pAUTT111a1l; clm ramen relaric non h:lbeat ;lli~m ~Ui:nriam quam dillinam , & li~ eonllar quod p.U'ilic.1t ("mper D. Tho, has prop.,tidoncs ,D!;u5 eft Pater "" Paett' eft Deus, vel elI'IH;;! diuilla, quia vn:amqlle faciE per [I;: ) ;1J bA: q. ~9· vrramque non per [e • ill qll.8.Je patentla,quod ell: euidens Ugll\l!1\ lccmum fuil1i= D. Thom.tUb dilll:rflS cOJlJidcrarionibus , i" q.Bl.ex parrerci lignificat:t:. 111 q.8.dl po'mtill~ p~m; modi 6gnifkil.ruli) vel cda~fcClindtim pr:J;c:dionr=m, &: formahmem propnt conecptu~quod [aris indicaE ibi S.D.dum dicit PCI' fo pwimu; illi~ '}lIid at "liqllU 'jlml prolai.iI/III' d~ ~~ 1~(fmJkm popriilm MliotIan) hoc cll: Ulb formali:;nc propriis cQnc"p~u~.

%.1 ad teftlUm locum Refp. quod lbi n .. gat O.

Thorn.p[opriadl{:d~con,~pm commUnllim .10- quendo d~ cOllcepm Cub fo~m;iliwlO, &. pf<~dfionc cills quod cthorllTnllnr; • &; eill5 Ql10d c:ll propfium. non dC(:ollce'pm :l.hfolmc, IS.: (ecufidum rCJ!ir;I{l:'m,&: cUemiOlm, VI til in {c. Er POltCf hoc:, qui.lloqulrurdecomuni bus.& pl'opnj~ t~culldilm ordine intdltCi:U5 nofiri, qui vtlqul: lion pOl1i[ o~dill(:m,id dl:,pdIlS.& poHc:du~ in ifli.5 con.tpribtl5 nHi qllatenu~ vrmmqll(ldqul:' intdligiI lecundiim propriJm formalit:w.:m • &. pra:cilionc:,~cl;ipjendo nJtuumfnb c!)nc~rll Mt\U%, & :l.ttdbmuJIi fila ~oneep[u proprktatrs, & rdltionl'!m {tlb CDnecpm n:rminamtf,c:.:c.tic cnim e.l q!l~ (unt pdora lime de conc~ptu palh:riotum.& commnnlUln,qui:I 1:'(fentillitet ill<i pra:fuppollllnr fecundtim CUD! formales cOllcc-ptmJed nOll e conlletio poilc:riora no fupponum prio[J.;& fie non fum dl; I:onceprll illo~\lm, qua tti;).m l;ltione in ip(is p.:zdil::ltis abloluth poten id ti:pc=r1ri,qu,a yolUIHi!.S ell~mia!iter lilppoQirintellttlum,lcu Imellctliuam n~turam, non i

J04n.~ S. TJMlJ.in I .poll" .D. Th. Tomm ;UIO.

Arlie. If.

97

(:6nuC'rro,& <t'remim rup'ponii im'm'ui::ibilfcatcm. 1'1011 e conuer(o.1tlt)Ue aetendendo ad ardinen-o intdlctlm tlOfiri • & loqllcndo (uLJ hac fortnaliratc. 'quat~nus pani! ordinern in Hlisconcep[ib\lS,COm~ murua (tim de imdleau propriorum • non e conutrro.Etlie ident e11: dicere; quod inrelhgirur 111 c6~cptu p::rfona:: parri~ Deus.ac dicere qllod przintf'liigimr. {ell praiJilpponi!ur ad wnceptum Pa';'

, 'fris,liCllt anlnu.l ad conCcpWl11 hQtninis,Er hoc dedncirur ex illis verbis S.Tlm.in initit1 ,I lim /ol'lfiDI1i1 lid I.quod communia abfolmc dicta {tciin'dllh'i ordiiJi:nl inrdlcaul nulhi [11m pri(Jr~ quam pfopr(l. Si ergo {ccundrjm ordinem jnrd!Cali~ IIOnr! pr6- eedir ~rbln indufio in intellell.u propriorum, dl. fr:cundlllTI iIIulII onJin(m,& p~i'orita~cm,id eft,pri. !i,'ppofidllc indmluntuf, non e conu~r{o. Porcft etlrim dici qUQ(1 communrs illch:rdunmr,& (lmt de:

Ineclle {t II propriorLlm, non folum 'pra:111PF06tim.\, f(:'d Ciianl farm;i1itcr , q!jj;j abfo!m;j. &: (ommtinril (um cOllllirmim proprioru;&: fimilin~r rropri;; non runt de inrdlcdu commuO!um;fictit pcrlolla Patri~ non imdHgil1lr ill coaccptu DCjl~il. acla;::qun&, & cIHlllt:rtiblllccf cum ip{o, lim ranquam <:onflituduLl JU: um: D ei.bene ramen iti~d.:i'qu~r~> & ta n'lul modus Cdl tl:rmitlll~diuill;r d!cliti:t. 'It exph~;lrii eft.

SeclUldo arguimr ex Parre Suarc:tt"ti(ln~ qu± :t2'. ipli viderur cllidcns.Quiclqnld d1. de drt'fTti:1 Dei,

eft de: ell~mb fingu[arum t'cr(on~r\lmrHliCquc cumtlnicatnr, {~d Ir~'! tc!adone~ 110nl unr de dlCmiOi hfTgul~rul11 pcrfol11rum. qUirt pOriUS Voa pcr{ffllii (lppofiiwr.& nOtl communicarur alrui : C'rgo noli (lInt de'~ficnd;\ Dei.M.llor prob. tuTU qnia ~"glil:z pcrfon:t {lim 'It;rtlS D~\I~:~Jgo CJmdquld dl~JlCi;t!i-

U;r cOllucn!r,$.: rr:I:dic;lmr de D~(>.C:OIlii"mt pcrronif,mm qllia ihCancilio Ljrer;\Ilcnli I:.DamffIl1!lUJ,o

&. in H.,r~min"t didtut P~tMn ~otr.rnunfcatfe fl ...

110 toram clli:nriam,n(}n vcr& hoc quod cf] dle 1'.:. t,ren1:cl'go paterIltr:J.s non porcfi [,crtihne ad 'on" Hprum.& cQnfiitut10lletn dlcil!iz,q[lj~ (ftC f'a~~rnirate inm:nlmr,& communksrur {Ora dlcnrja.M i-

nor autem manif~ft;t elf, ~uiot vn~ per(ofla. &. vili rebdo non eft ali~ = trgo non dl de COfl'crm > &; cifembalrctii.a ,fiqnidcm ci OPPQnilUr.

Conf. 111 ilia priod or:giJ'hs q~IQ PJIt'i' i'rHdfigl~ mr confii[u~m. &. potc:ns SC:h~rare, & nor.dllm illrdligittlr Filim gmcfOlf lI~ • ihn:!Hgimr (Ora • & integra, & ptff,·d:I dluil'lir:ts. & f.in'en non emnes reluiones 7 & pd[OI1a:: ibi imeUigufitur; erg~ non omnt~ rel1[!Qn~~ fLlm dl: dr~ntl:t > IX l';(lflCCpru diuinirads, criaftl inad:rquate, Con{'q.efl (:(~ f::l. quiJ time n(Jtldlflli int(;ltigimr fdiu!,& imdligimr eIl~nti:l rime t &: pl'Ifdtc = rrga filiJiIO non imr::!t cUIlHnmitllmn, &. pfclllwdm,m imul dli:IHi:r. J\nu:,~d,v~r,j rrob. quia in illo pfarr inrcllIgitur in Pam: to!tillt. quod ro~C'ft C::amrl1li~ nicarc fjlil> ell vi g'fltt.i!ionis: corr. munic"r ~m ~m t()t~m eJltmfarn pl~nam.& pc=rfecbm:cl go Hll:l. eflend;} pro We. priori plene conftimq. &. t Hemiali!crinu:lI~gimt. Ilt'c~lml.n irmlligiwt tun' fi!tltio.

Conf.1. tIllia clIentia df: vpa f &. !imp!':! , ni::(: in riltione dl~ntiz; vlbm diiincUOII< m admitdrj rela60nes :llltl:'ID dHHnllion~m .dmiUllllr ,frmilit~r e"cnda ell abfOima > & ,onllitllirur ;rb{o!uro: crgorcbrion~~ non POl11.UlC r~niller" ad conltitilfiUlltn drCI!t~~ trgo I1cQUI; de elliS dl'i:nriali (.,nc:epnl dli;. Er in hoc f\mdatur ;'ifguWCtllUm quod communitc:r folet fieri 'lUll rOta dli:mu con rnu-" nKatut fllio,ec nOll eomrnunicamr parcmi!:l1 ; tl~ go p;ltcrnila1 non dl de ,0nceptll,60: dJcmi~1i "In'; fiit\niDnedftnltz.

Den'que qui.J>~ reb.lioncs {n~r deconc(pnl ejL;nu.= , non rofin ;'lIum pt;!!(c1nQcre, ab diCit

, M km

·,S !bJ..eftio XXViI/.

. {icllfc'onc¢pcus'homlnls non:pt;r(cll1dit A:raiionali. "'Jl1_ia ~[I: de t.:11~!lt~al! rado~1: hOlfiifl~s;aec~ll~c:ptLis 'C!lcml~.pril;:klljdlr a relarione '.&' c ~,onlL.t·. ~rg~ vnum non efr'de c~nt'Cp[u alrcf.Hls,al~?~ ~nl~l;t d~ -(ent in Deo Formaliecr rdcm • & non fo.t1ln Idcn'lice,1i vnosn elrce de fonnal!,&: ,41cmiali COllt"C'p11i slrcrius-

Rdp. :!'tgumc:ntum iI~ud quod Suare:t vidcrur euldcns , & plane (OpAllbclIll1. & P"ccacc rnnranilo 'Jlud;in4d .,J..'1Hid,qu.od S '. Thom,. vocac f'lllaciarn lIccid"nrislll dlullm, IgI[ur dlllmgllcnd., dt mMor,O.!;!idquld ell de ~J1cnda Dd,cll de dleniiA fillgulJfltll1 pCI-{onJ[llll1. dillinguo, qllldquid ell: de ci1~ntia Dei tanq\lam qltid ,(ell per l1Iodu;tl quidim:is.colICcdo.: hoc f!l1i.ll commune cit omnibu. perlouis ; qllic!"IUid ell 'de elTcrJda Dei (atl, qll~~ modus, tanqn~?l ad ~liquid qllnd ~n rnodus maJ.t:quJ.tus(qua:hbct emm [Cl.IIIO non ;)d;E~ -qll;\UOtJm elIl:mi~m,cltm debe'H ill ilia dJr(~ ,10.CUIn [uo i:orreiatlUO ) nego, Er {i,Ut eft fophdlt.cum arglltnentum quod formant ha:tctid: ~id. qUid enrir.nillcJCil realuer cll Dcus , alltdl~mja. Dei,.1l in q'I.Ilibctp~rCOllj. v,g.ill PJcfc:fc:-d ii!ia, tlo ell: rcaheer, (eu ~l1tiratillc! t:llcnd~ Del: ergo filiatlo cit Pater; in 'luO (()phi!lnar~ t.:uidcntCI' mutatur qmd,in aJifbqllla. & maier wg;ll1th i:l1: ab(olu!(~, au~ dl{tJngu~llda: <J.!!,dq Ild elltiraritlc dl: "ffcmia (.lillin~ pcr medurn qtlldl{.l!i~ j 1.'11 in Pmc • verum ell ; 'luidqnid ell: df.nlia diu ina rer modum rebtionis,[~l1 ~d aliquid, m=go.Pror{us idem pC,",,,tum iriuenies in argumcnrc Suarez, (ulilln murando illum rcrmmurn llltir;Jli,,;.& ~&I,ljur in ilium ICrn1inUIU ~ffi'Jri",I,,~r,& dicendo: ~ldql.lid ell: e!Ii=ntialltl:~ DC=[I~. feu de c(f(mti:i Del.cll:in qualibcre~r[DnJ.v,g in P;me.6Ii~tjo ell: t!l'~miilli(er Deus , leu at.: cllcmia Dd : ergo ell ill Palle,l'ofic aurem loco lllnis termini c!nrir~tille poni 1 y eJJ~'" i4huri & fie vtrUln'lllc! (ophi(lll.l (':0- ucm ped!:: claudicarc conlht, quia Deu$ q\lidqtlid ea,,; (lcJJtialitet ell : ficut cnim ipfc: Sllarc:~ t"OIlCCdit[uprlze'7' quod itt.. e(l bona con[i:qtl~l1Iia [1:1.ter cIt Delis: ergo c[I: ,Hemi3lircr 0(115: Iimilitl:C t:=rgoilb erit boo;!,. OCUli ell pJ:tc=r:ergo clicllIi.llitcr cll p;t[I!r:quidqllid cnirn Deus ell. ea~mi.1lirer cli:nullum enirn pI.t.:iica(um Dee conuenir accidenealirer • fed pcr indlbam.1X dli:nti~hffirnalll ,0nnCJtiDncm.tiqtlid~m ex vi (ui elf~nti;lIiJ.&: r<lt~ Illalis ccnceptus.qui dt aCw purus,babet Jibi annexum quidquJd fibi conu~llit:crgo Id~m ell: COIl\1(~f1ire D~o aliquid in re,& t"onuenirc elfcnriali!cr, q\li~ coonex:!!) diuin~ cum (uis pra:diC3ris cll fum- 11\.1;& lie c:lri:nril1H1irnl. Et hoc :!.rgumentu m lie Co\uit S.Tho. &. ill eifdem fcre tcrminis ptoponit S.tkfaul1/i,t ,U'/.l,l1;ti,iltnttJlr;. G.& 7'

,. 3 Dicc=s:lmplie;lt quod aliquid {it dr~nti~lit('r conn~um a\ic.lli,&: i.ngt~dia(Ur conc eptum dli=nliaiE ciu$ i &: tatncn fit d lIlacLrqlJamm, ticut fi modus vnioni.s ingrc:dirur confiittltionc:m hOll:lillis,t3.tlqui ~O~US>i01pliQ.I: 'luOd nOn fit iIIi aO:J:quatus.& iIl~ l.I'lIUfUt_ ~blcurnquc inuenimc homo: ergo hoc quod dlqmll$ de c:!f~ntiali ;'Id;t:q1l3to vel in3d~ :t~lmo eit: m~tum c;ornmCntllm :ul. duclend~m vim :u-gumelltJ.

. RC:lp. neg.lndo an~«c=dt:ns. quando ellr.ntiJ. :r.h~IU ob (UI ampl,tudmt=m,&: ~mlru:ntii,JlOn Vila {glum modo. {,d phmbus.pCtit {!:f1l'lhIJri, Etl.ic

hot non palfumus u::eltlplu ornllino ~1U d '

u ' . b .. ( I' .~ ~ fan~ Ill' .. cnur:. 10 ti~ tlH,eam > ... ~' 'pn1ur;nirtil\us (tmiJe • G. ... ~nl:l;;I.o. .pC:'IC~yt pOlulr ato, dli:llt ~ p~nt tei lllbfilltnti:munc cnim drellli:tli~er id"I\{I" .' fib" ~ . ' • n[;~t~llt

~'c!;d~"J~lliqlli~l;rn ~llcnrial~Ict:I:{fent \'ni.- . . . '.~Cl:.allque Inf~,q[iI. &. IIQd:c:qL!alht_

De Relalionl6l11 diuii1i4.

.{~ntcUm 'luo!ibcr Illfcriori.Jhii(tu.} (umptoiE'a:cn- ··tia·~lnci\1 diuina. habet vHnl(:rrn~Ili communls 'rem fpcthrperfdnJrii,licct iinguhlris ;& Iubfirlens foL'·ma Ii[; Vllck admitti~ ilbm rtrjClnctn ·t""Ollncxiolli"s ·elli:lllja1idnadreqilat~ • vel achrq(1;ice, vc diCnlm ell, qllOd in rebus crearis non dl: vid~rt. Ec hoc return nafcirur ex illo fundamcllto.quoo Deus 'quid~luid realireref] ,-effclmaHtc, ell : conflar au- . tell") quod ctlcmia diu[l'la u.'alirer. Be cnrimiue dl:

I)01[cr,& 1)On en ad~u~te Parer, id cit (alUm Pater,quu ceiam ell: Filius: ergo ell: iJ1daqu::.tc}:crgo criam el] cl1enlialite~ inac:l.rqu:il~il;quia b:!!c cit diuinitar.j~ vls , vt idem fa in ea el1l: .-c3liier rale , 6C c!li:ml~lit~r talc. id ~!1: ,.pcrfumm;.,1n cQllnexionem.

Ad (.Confirm. RC(p,q~loa in iIIo priori orig!. 2.4 nis intelligitur-:l nQbi~ (ora I:ll~nfjll dluinJ,li:d lion roralucr • qlliJ non c~plic:ltur pre ilia figno omn!: quod pc=rtinct ad cllcntilim dWinam,l:llam tallqu5 nlodificanIILOrn,& rcrmuuriuurn eius n.,d:rcJIlati:: (juia enim ilia priorhas non cdl ptil;1ril:l~ rCI,kd tn~ tclligeutla: ~ ~ rationis I Ibi tunc 1:11 dkllliol cum OmO! ~D quod pcttinct 3d II:,cri~rn n(]dOfl.1li[Cl,~ rdatiuc;I~J ql.b !l05 per 110flrJnl irlrdl!gcnti~ diuidil11U~ in '1110" Ibi !:11.collcipllnu> i&qm:i,1 dl~n-

cia: quantum ad ~b(oluta, & qUm[llrn ad in qllOil communieabile eft per gencralic>Ilem ,non quan- 111m ad rdaiilla. & modificarlua dlrntia: 1 quod

(:11 non tOl'a.litCt eil:primcrc: que ,:ad dlemi3m p ertjnent , ij~~t tora dlcllria uptimarur. E.t hc~h pta illo priori Pater intclligatur comprehc11dcre k~

&: rerum quod ~II: in Deo • non ramen hee con-

II illcit quod 1'10 itlo priori inrdligatur pc=mma lilij,yt proollfla, lic':t intdligatur oblc:aiuc 3. P;l~ ere: a!rJt}a, & cognit3, liquidcm ex cogilirionc

(ui • & creaturarum prccedir, Vt in{ dlfPBt. IfQfrcnd~rnus : ergo pri(15 illtdligitur f.ogllo(ci yt Qbicdum • qullin cxptimi, tit pco,edere VE gf:Di .. tum ,quia ClI: cognl[ionc Pauls grni:rOlmr.

Ad {et"ll1ld~~ Confirm. Rdp. ql1Qd dfcmia vna exulens non adminit dilfjntl;iQPC:nt in abro, luris , bene ramen in rcluiuis : Vl\dC quo3d ab[g.. ItIU non ,onfl:itnituuclati cnefub f ormalirate , 8c pr%cHionc abfoluti. Sed abfoluium ) VI ell ratio lion tinensin ratione ab(olud • red 1;0mptetlC:Jls eri~m genus relaelu urn ob t til cminennam • fie:: cti 50 I.D I elariuo ,onftilllit ur , qu ia pt"rtiQct ad illam dlcnti:lm, Vt ell: atlu5 pmus. & ;1I11bitIl50mncm perfcll;io(l~m,& f:!tionem dillinarn,cri~m drmdl~ lir~r ~omincrl; tdariollcm. q lIi3 !i rQlit~t t"QIlIi!lCf, eliam dlcmialitct,& ~b imrillicco. Et (Ii:: cfi~mia~ ~t didr pr;rdsh"on,tptum llalUrll: coudiftinguiwr 1 r~br1onc, lice pcr c~m t"onlhrLHlur in r<l.li CQIlj;cptU, {Iuia !d.nio pCn'IlCt ad munus. & roncrprllm p~rfon:r, nU;l natura: • Vt ~l1tem dicit 13tloncm qu.\Ji uani,cnd( Ilultm aall~ purl, &: Colis iIlCf~d,lic vrn.;m'luf! genus indndit. & ahfolutum, & . rd.u:iuum. rcJadonl..fque dlcndalitcr indmlit Vt' tmninos • «moditicatiu~ qua-dam clf~nti3;'.

Et tum. v,ge{ur commun.c nrgUn1l:nEUm ; qllod Z,f commUJUC:llllf rora dicnua , &. nOll pat~rniras; dilling~IO. commullicatur eJl~nlia Cub conc('}l1U abfoimo , & (lib pr;=cifa raliOll~ cflcnti:t • COJ'iccdo; (lib emlli modQ • &. IllduJiOIlC: talis dr~n-

ti:t! ,ntgO'. quia non (lib !llodo patc'tllit~ti5, iltni cOllm.unic::nUf lora cflcmia , h:d non totaliterj

id eft, non (ub omni mod" indu!o in r"li ell ntia pl·[liIlCnre 3d eius ec=tminatjom:(ll • & fubl'lh-n~ li<l.m. Et lie rdatio non cfl: de con,CJ'ru ~ Ilcl!ti;e \'t conRimcns rationem ab(olmalll, &. qU;ditarll1am. dt ramen de con~eptU cll~mi.:t VI Inodlnc.tiuum~

~ {crmillol.tillum ~iU5.

Ad

!.6Ad id q!iod 'Vldm3prop,,?~icllt'. _R.e(p. 'qIlOd fd quad eft drt::ilti.:l.lcj& intrinkCilin ~Iicili • poteJT ab eO pra::fcindc:tc, fi in:ido:equato.&' impl:rfcGto COIlc:eptU concipi<1tl1r. 'noll Ii pcrfcctCl , &. ad~lJ.luto~ ficur qui conclpir hominc91ub conceprll gC:Iletill proxim~.v.g~.:I.iljl~taH~,~& ditfcf~nuz vl[imz,,((i~ llc« ratlonah~ ,elf~tI~m hOIllUllS conclpl~. heet nOn explkctgradll~ fupcnorcs vt (CItrUS.) {ubfumiam , Bec. lit cam(:11 qui! Deger bOJ gradus d'fe homir;! ccrcnc!~les 1 Nee umen :ib ilIis P!~~ {cindie 'eifcmia bomrnis przciJione c1:clufiu~J <ju:di iIlos h~1l: indud.it. aut imponmtia ad eos ht • fed pr;t!cifiom.: non cxpreAiua , (CII fer 'non explicatiom:m '; qUia riCtE jbj inclndantlif • rl1l1i ramen ibi cxpIJeanrar. V e enimsduenfmes p""ttd. wr;u dij}"t + '"' .". duplex cllprot'"fju. aID ,per tllln jnelilliQn~m l '1u:ifido ali<:Juid Iia fegr .. gi'l' 1Ilt':lb :alio,qtu'id foJiim remlOC'E in,porcnrili:id iIIud: a\jot pl:f {etum non cxprclflOllcnl. qll:lndo Illiquid atl:u qllidc:mim:llldit ;lJiud, red non explicarillud •. quuadonc tt:mk:cndmcia przfcln.. dum ab infcriOfiblU j & actus rums; fw diuinll. etrenEid (uis atlribllti5 • & r:ltion.bus qua.J in-dLldir·; nllnqllam ab illis lie przfcinJlt. Cfuod reman car ill ~Ofi'ia,{c:d. pOEe~ 6, e):pJj(:~rt: v.tlum. quod non a1iud ; Ijc:a o~ma elf~mbhrC1' lnd\ldar ~ quia non plene t & r~alit-cr ~li(ottIlE toCUm quod perrine:!: ad cffc:nri:am. Cum v(t'u dfcitur quod fie omnia crant in DCD forrnalirc:r idem •. IX non {oh'mi identic':. llefpond. ql1'M amnia funt fo-rmalira idem. G Iy IJln~lIi&r tic idem quod elfenrialiter.fen in primo modo pet fe! non enim alitet' (unt idem. Sed non oniilia (unE formallEet' idem futlbiLlihte pr~dtioni5. tic ~ppdlifioni; • fieut nee in qu:uto rondo p!:f Ie,

-:,SeCliodo .atguir.~.P.V.1(q~ M~J'J~lIt: m.

7 ~Rp.". R.d.ana conc'IplUlt aduc:nl(c elfcnu:r : ergo non indudere ill.un fOfm::i11ter ~ lIlil$ Ij indllderer , quomodo ei adllcniEct. it pu:fcnim • qllia relanO' iu. ,oncipirur .uluel'lire dr~nri:e, quOd derttmin;zt COlm : id aUlem qolod dercrminarur. QOIl cominttUr in COIICcptU d~ctminantis ~ vel C contta. Net' oblhr aemplum de enre , quod de,cntllnarur prt mCld~ contr~h-=ntl;'$ • Be t:mJm in JIlis includitut. Cornu culm e.1l:, 'luia ens nen tigndicat .a1iquml rarionem l:ommUll::m. quz dtrcrmjlJ~tur per panicunrt$ • fed {olum nomen en commune fin p[2fcllU aUfcm df~ Ee3:liter, &. yeti: communi! ell perfonh.

Confirm. qUia li dfcnTht Induderetuf in conC::C:PIU rdztioDis, hzc c!lct vera, Parcrnitas dl c:(.. fenti~ • vl!!dc fcqueretur quOd parernitaEC Deus mreUigerC'tio & patcmira{c:- clfet f~picnJ ~ & timili~c:r filiation, (jill verba. quia dremj~ ell puer~ '!IEas. & dt:lltIiI eft fOlpicliJ • & intL'J1ig('n~. Non c~ceditUE al1l'cm a Tb,;ologi$. quod Oms I;fi (a~ PlcnS (~picnria gcnlra.

Conlirm.(ecnndo, qUill Ii rd3rio mdaderer rt~lItiam. Cl;qllC:,rtlur quod teJario non eonfliluir pt:rfonam. Confequens Il(ln admiuimus ~ ~go. Seqnd~ prohi1mt J quia p~rfona. noR eli ali lid quam c:U·mria detetroin'lta pefip~mfdariOn~nH Ii ergo rd;uio illdudit dfllrni:un • i:l(n rc:luio cit pet(gna : I:Igo nOR ell: id quo conllitllitur prttOlU; iiqnidem p«fona nun (tillllitllirqr pcdot!~ (an~ 'luam forma, fed dl (a conllinlE:I.

RelP. quod rdario inrdHgimr aducrurr elfc:n~ ti3: • non Vt allquid nrfinfe,urn, & foulitcr pfZdrum ;tb ipf:t • 1.U.:I6 elfcm:ia mant:=at in porcini;!. "nort h,lbear i!l Ii: aClu ip(aIU rebrionc;m j cU[t! elT'entia fir aau~ pllnn • Be :ul nihil in pot~'Iltla~

1 Vllll-ol S. ThtmJ.I(I l.pMt.D. Tb. T omu$: all"_

'didmi:ergoadaeMre .& acterfilinttte e"ir~iiaful non ftC:Qt diff.;rellfia de(ern'l'faatg~hlll id~llad comp aratllcr,'u'lqa;anl a!l'ui ad,p~t~i~tn, -(cd .'It .aJiqll id magis e:cpl(l;itllID .ld 'quod 'eft 'mil'III5 c ito ,ptic/nlm, &; '1'I'Iagi9 in. eon£L1(6 'ligrJiJiciitn'1'l., . :Ef .. {entia qUippc: 'diaiha {ub Inrc nomure ftgmficiUiI. faltllfi lignilica:t e'{fc:dillhlllnl i!'1 tOr:Il'uUlllpli'ilJo. dine • &; Vf in confuJo incladfr 'o'mnc'lu petfe<tliom~m J t:ltm 'vdo~ipliC'~'tIlh'el;iri'o.den:rmin:1:' rile, &; cxpJic:mtt ~d 'qilDd dl;t~rmimlt~m 'Cpland.1m pc:tfcAiontm :rut (;itloncm e:~plic_,{in 0'1:0', quz priOri 'ccmccpm el1i:'nri2' nun c~h,,~b~lftlr;. Ii.:=, ibi incilldc-li.itur '. 'ionv~r'O ,ddirur ~li'cJnM 'lllodin ,If entia v~1 fi~tiHOl a'au~'~ 'c'ifeflfiili, ~ ~cll:jonelloll incIl1ooCt~lr; lr.l'liJ.!fe 'def~~il1a~~ ,!til. & adti~nra'i rdadOlil~ ;'non hi p'crotddltlOll'cm vniu~ ad ;rli"d, 9,1:11.1 in Dco crtl Inlpoffibiffl 'om;;' ni!Compolido; cclam Ptf intcl1~·thrm nofimm., cum r~rugn-e, {mntn~ limpllcirari ;'" attui plltOj. & cO'llleqllC11tcttll impol1ibil'is ·DmIlis ~ddifi(jlnl a'ccnmUilltfQ viljll~ 3d ahtrd'j li:'d huone aa'UI rUti~ 'juidqujd lliuinum til. ~au indudir. fi~ ~rgo adu~n'lIf. {';( Qet~rroinririo r~bt,onh :Ie clI~n;,m pet nOUam expl,c~Honem du; qtlOO antd non ~xpri~ mebalur in "mceJ"u ilIilu rti ,hc:cr jnd'udebamtJ, non pcr addilionc:m ,illt compobnoDtm VflIU~ eumalio, ~dd vnn dicuur cns '1110 'ncimmccfi"c eemmune, e:ftdicc:'rC'. q.;od ~1l5 lion ell: ~nalogult!. {~Jpud ~uillocllm~c:uius C:OlllO"U\lrn U D.Tho.

o!h:IldimuSJ/t i.ug1£4 '1.f~,& 1.(. . , ",

Ad p~im~m Conf.Rcip.vcram eie fIl~m pr(lpo-- 1t Gritlllcm, ParCtniril5 dt df. nlia. f~d lion ((lot'c;;' dllncuuliz prOPQHritinCI P.lt~H.:!rt D,u; dHa;. pi6J.aur IiIi;),tIQn~. <tel velbo;quia u; 'modQ fl£fiifi.. candi,fit ihi fOfIDalit fignifkario. " appliurio pz.;. tCrnit::llU Cub proprio ,& (tltffialt t'''IKCPt~ nlad.o

uo • (lib quo, dminguifllf ab ab!OIufo. lit lob con .. C'cprurc:-hciao GOnfiitllir O~.".m rdlifum .fi:i:t p~ t«.'JtI~non (~p;c:ncrnJ1qui ell concepw~ p~lfet'tioni'r abLt;dll~. Vnde cUm tignificatur aliqllid illb for':' rn~itare , & przC:IJionc: proprif aJl1Ccl'tus,non po.. [cli concedi • quUd tub Ilia fonna!itiltc::. &. pi:tdGone: ttibllae dfcdum formalcm. qui patiDC[ ad :jltcram pr;fciGonl:m.I~1I f(lrmalil:lt~m. Et Iic« ef;;. (cntia dlUina in rc: fit roc tim MC.& idrneici iIf:l reo qllz ell pilcqnim.lit (api=ns • & ilJa w.qUIir eli ~ picntU. ht Patcr;t.'nnr:n qun in ilia dkmia ptop~

tel' [uam cmimmiam plure! niioncJ, & ~rfttl:iollc!I difiinguunrur ~ IX 6gniJic~DtUr nofho modo intdligrndi, ideo ex modo figni6eandi ;!liquetn tdlllitmm tub illiqu~ fon'na!it1Ei'. &. ptZcitioll~.nDn eontt:di!l!uJ ahquas propolirionC'f, li-

etr tinr circ-a C';U!d~m rem, qua: dltnrialircr ell omnll ilb,a: inErinCC't'i!. bb diur:r(llrn modum 6~ gnifiandl.Nch ~nim didmuJ quod per yolunr:a~

(em prccedi( filiuJ.led per jmell~tlum. & Spifilul S.prr '1011lnf.:ltrnl. & ramtn voiulnOl5. &: inrdk-

.!tu; in D~o Cune omnino vnum,&' id~m dl~miaIita. eerte nllnpotetincg.lfe-V.lfq qQodUciras fit

d~ concrpttl, illUinfcw .lk. elf1:ntia1i Dd • qUia pei DciEittlll dli:ntWittt f;ollll:ituiru:. & rllffi~ in doGrim fidti Dn1S genet:lt. ~ Dc:itai non g~e-bf; propt'« diu~lrum m~tlm iigni6cmdi fc:rinit.u:ttllm:ergo non mifllm quad II'ft patemiru fiE de elfmtiali COllCl pm diuiTiz dlenr=. &: 6- picntlz. &c. famen p~rernii:~tcnon tit f:tpfcn!J4 dfc:mia propter diuul\lm modum tignJ6undi • at diuClfam futm~lmlltm.& ps:Z'c.Gob..~, qii .. o:pU.

ann Yngm,&: aliud. .

Ad (ccundlm Conlinn. Rtfp.iIIud 2fgum~~ tum cffl: plane lopbdlicum ; 6: tnlbn lltUIifdli in

M £ cxcmrhi

'/ ,.

cxe~pJo ~Hato- 'de De? & Dc:itate. N~ Dcit_li[e 'CORftiuLi tLlt Deus tanqilam (Mlna;&: t.a!1lCll DeltaS ,jpf, -ell: l)c:.u~. eeiarn ilHoncEct(t: JUtn quidquid :in "Oco' e(1:, D eu s eft: I &. dic!;re qllod aiL'ltOiras non tit Delli, unpii ffimullHIt. "lr BI!Ula~dusfrtm. 80. JII CanticA dicit contra Gilbertutn. S.lmlli.~er tela" '-iicme ,p.nftirlliturperiona, & ip[OI relado ell:: pep. -fon~, & cit clli:nria, & ell Deus. nee ramen per-~

-luna conflit1.litur pcr(olla , fcd pcr(Qna!ira[:, &:'t':-~

.udanc liellt nee 0 Ct1~CQ!l (bntitllr D co i ted DC:l~ laIC Vt 'fO):l,lJil j li~ctcrjan1 ip[~ Dcicas Deus "', CU!ia ill diu/nis abH,a~lI prxdic,~ntur de ~oncrctis~ & i 'OOWI.. eo qllod Jih non ddfctam flI(j [e«:un~lillt lIlodum iigl'llti,andi ,IlOil ~~ parte rei, ~glJitic,at:!:.Si!: t"tgo ad argumcnrum InfottlJ:1 dlCllllU1 IIcg.1ndo fl!qnchrn, Ad probanonern ; Perfcna non eft aliud qulm !;Jfenria determlnara pCrr!:I.l~ iiOIlCln ,diftingllo , nihil aliud en quam cfl:i:ndil. (ub concepti! eommuni, &. qUl," tt;lIl(:cndc;ntali ¢a~l1d:t,I1~go; fub coneepeu dlcmtia:, Y"t c!1-mtUfa tcnninabilis pet Pd(ol,alit;lfC~ tehtiU:i$ , ttan(m. 4d con{c:qut:ntiam : ergo {j rcl.ulo Includit cc. r~ntia_l\l • iam tcl~,j~ edt perron 1 • dillioguo:(i reb~io includic cl1..:l1tlam rub tOnel;ptll nltura: eerIllil13hilis ~ pcrl()ll~bilirate • ctit parOlla.lcmccdo~ 6 includie IQh\m rub communi,&' tranfcmdcnuli concepru ~d5 in(:rC<I!i, qllod ell: C011l1nUllC onmi r~j dhli n~ ,I ~quitllr,quod fit pctfoM,nego; (~dCut1i~ cit quod lit p_c:rfollahtas,{tll form:!. (ernlin~,&c;a.. llitUCll~ pcrlonam • qU:I: qUid..:m idcnti'~.& reahfer p~fona ~Jl:. fcd ~J: modo lignilicandi, folWn ligllifi,~tut <,It Cornu. feu terminus petfon.z, non VI pcr!on;dp(lCunfiiruraIUcLlt Dc:ir:l.S" 6gni6c:1Iur ... c-forma ~Ol1l1irucns DCIlI1l • ex mode figoificandi, !ieet c:t pm!: rei Ji~llifiQ[:t Ocus III. Vndc wnl illfcuur. ~Iuod rdanL) erit pl~fona.!i indudit cltcntiarn • q eli.! pct!onl nen i,;~llilitllitllt pet{o- 113, dHHn guo • erit pcrl(m~ ii iudlldir cf(enti.!m eum r.di modo 1i3,1l!J1c2ndi,quod Iigru6- cetur per modum c;:ollflitLltl n cfii:nti:! ; vt,.namra, &. rcloilionc .... r rcnn:'o-.concedo j Ii GUill tali modQ figllific.mJi quoj tignilimuf per medum form~) (tU rermini confiiuu:ntis, & indud.t:ntis dl'entiam modo (:0 rnmuni, &, quw tr:lnCc;c;:ndemali ranu~m. Ijc;go; lie" enim ell clfcntia. per modum fonn~ p~'(OIl.nn cOI1J1-ituenri~. DO.n ptr modum l't't(onO' conllitur;t. Et qUia dh:nti~ diutua ommbu~ HI:is modis 1ignifi~.lri porca-; in i:oncrcto, 8.: in ab. fir all:o. Vt form:!. conllitucns • &. yt res conlHt\lta, ~Ili.i emnil. ill.;. DeliS "lilt ct'IID hma Dcum linl, lit quud Cl( illdulionc: cJl'ent;:t in rcL1Iiall£ quo.Dlildocunque. non [i:quilUt' quod lit pc::r(cl'l'.i; ni6 cti~m eJ: modo ligni6,andi. IigniJicnut vt conili(Iltul'rr,non lit fOrlllaconftituc:m. Si aurcm indur d..t ctre:mj~m. tic lignilicetur Vt fortn:!, non fcqui~ tur q_uM fir pe.rlon:l.fl;d pct(oDa!ius.

2., . BI_WS motnmr ctiam foluta quzd~m inconuc- - I1ICmla qtu= t~nqL1ml fcphifmm. oblici polfum: cO~!(~ noa.r~ (~Il[cntiam. N~ primo lr:qllitu! quod polfc£. liI.I~UO eRe de cODce.pU-l pa(c~nit;tti~. 6 ell: de tOnttptu t:lI"cnti3;-: n~m dralna efl: de con,epl,U patl" • 61iuio ~n de conctpm c"entia::; a~o bitauQ dl dt; tGilCtptu Patrit. SccundQ fc~ qlll[lIr q,u~J c:lfcmiJ. pOn;;( ~oncipi (OnCCpnl :da.. tlUO : c~nl~qUdls dl a.blufdull'l : ergo & noar;! (~~Cnti;i. Sequcl:!. prab. qUi;l ~lltn~iOl, ponti conelpl e.~ toncepn1 quo conllltuituf • &: c:tl de: eius d";-ntQ. ~e~ p~r II: tontlitll,iUlr (cb~onc : ergo potdb:c;mqpt ~oncqtU n:btlug. MlIm, pate:!: q\li.z CQb~~ptW. reb.w.IUJ ell mcontltl!lniQbilis • c:mc:c:t::tfQ d{(UDZ ell:: commUnicabil_is • &}~o tf-

.. ~ ~~~ gcm:ntUl',qulil, rthtl!~e nOll

rf~ habet. t ctdd 'qUifilt 'qu6d aliqllia. 'Gt -de"con. cept!l·clU-ntizin.p~tto::,quod non 'cit di: CQnc~~ >effendI!) in 61iCl. eon(equetn el1 .. bfurdurn: ergo. ,Millor pat~r. qula.atias non etlce cad~ ,.fl~tja 'In Patre -& ~ilil;' ._ flql1idem aliqllid l~abefet de cotl<:eptll cllcl'lCiah Ul. VBO, 'quod non 111 altere, .lit {co-q!oleb prob. qUla:patcrllitas ell: de concep'tU'dIim-'ti.c: non . .:I.da:q ~Iatc-~ pro Drin omfiibu~ perlonis.:!.Ii~ p.u~miUl ClJlllnlUflicarcIlKfilio; quOd etlufCfl-. cum, folum ergo ell de eencepru efi'entiz- izwl~ zquati: (Ul11ptlrj Ccll. prout in Patre: non ergo clt de conceptiullcntire,praut in Fmo: aliquid ergo ell: de eoneepru dfcntla: in Patte. qJ>od. non eft de cit!! com:epm pCOVt in Pilio. ~a[):o, Ccquittlr mud vulgare incanut:niens quOd Pater non "'Ill'municaret Filio tcram cU'mtiam. qUia non communlcarct rerum quod eli de comcptu c:Jfen~~ (i;jlicc:t eeladonem.

H:te '" ali,1 fil11i1i.i(apbi(mat.:t. ex: did-Ii [oIUUUlr • .3 0'.

Ad p.rhnu!11 didtur peecare illud (uphi(rna {iCUt & illud v ulgarc, Parer eft h~c cfiimi.1 dillin1:b:te cilcmia diuura elll:lliu~ : ergo l'ater eft filius; (:(in-.. fcqucmia non ... aler , aiam lequendo tcalitct ~ tit: idetid,quia muratur qllid in (Iliquid.quz4;!l falb.cia :!~iJclltil:i[.1 enim J1atct eft ba:e ctlcnria,(I.:: He clfcmia til Patc;f, quod no adliEqmm: eft Pater.(e;d etta FiliUS, vnde no fc:quiruc ex idt:nrific¥iODe Pa--. [tis cum cjl~[ia,quOd ldalti6c~tur cum ornoi Qlia. ,d;uionc: clrcnci~.ldem PCGI:.tn'i eft in eadem COIl[c'luemia , addieo 11 IJJtru~liitr • quia in diuinii pc:ri !ide [tf!laba qu od Parer lir Deus tcalircr. Be quod Gt e:1Ii=ntiaitrcr. vel eriam Deus lit Parer r(~ knd,3Iirer! quidquid c.oiiii D tU5 eft J ea~nri.:lli(ct dl.

. Ad [ccundl.lJil. diliingtl-itUf fequeJa: teqoinu:

qllod df!:ru:i;;I poffit ~llClpi conteptu tebuuo ,Cub pr~cif(),& expliciw (oncepru elfmriZ',& eX modo f1gnilica.ndi en(=m.iam~ ru:go;{oIb alia conCtptu aplk:ilut modum , "'" terminationem pedonalcm cf{cl1ti<t ~ tr a nkat: fed·hoc DOll crit {u~ conUPtll clIent ia: • nee Vt agoi lic.atut iJIo' nomino. drenriz~' E.t ad prohationem qijOO dfc:lltia pordl ~pi to conceptu qt:o confiimirur, diliinguo, fi ad.· qlla'~ cODdpi:ltur , &. t'J:plicctul',con«,doj G mac!:quaf(!,nego; nee enim in concepm in~bqllat(J. & pr:c:ci(o opcm:t u pHari omne quo confiituitqr iBlcl{~d omne (}uoconftiu~iludub iUa pr.t=ci!io--. ne , & c~li(:a.tjQnc. E1l.tnti~ ~ml:lD C'Xplicllr orone quod ell con!l:inuilluID dfenriz, [tlb rarione 'tuid; !Cd non omlle ~onnituriuum fub ratione lid aUqn/Ii,fell fub r;uione modi,quia ngn upli~( omne quod dl- modificati't1um t~lit dfeJltia:, &: hoc modifit~dllurn cri~m clfc:nti~liret eft Deus, (tU drtn~ tiadiuina, quia nOtl hah!;t =lliamelr~nli:lm, & ,ct: fc::miOi diuirut ob (u:r pcrfc:d:iollis i(limimioncffi, ttiam ralc::m modum ellc:mi~lircr indud,r.qui:l Oinne dIe dillinnm elremialitcr indudir; .fed non fub cmni CQIlI;CptU explicat tatum quod dTcmiaHu:t: indudit ; & lie: proVt a:plic:;.tur (ub conccprn cflcmi~ ,in quo- - p~fcindit ! U1odi6c:atiuis • non (,lIplica!ut conc~plu rdatiuo. &: inco~IDllnicabili. lieir relariu3m r:ltionc!D ibi includat,

Ad rmium Rc(pon, dilHngucndo ftqlldam: aliquid en. de CQIlc;epiU cOcmia!') provt in I'afrl:. quod non cll tie conc~plu dlenrix prt)vt in Fille, .:lilbngllo. qll~mum ~d modllicarion:m dt~nd;t:. rran(e.'It; quantum ad ~onfiilUtilla dlc:nrhT,n~so~ id di. qu~ntunllld lIliIJ,,;J. {cd non q 112ntUln "d IjljiJ.Er lie dim jnfcnur,quod cri[ ah"riu~ latinnif cHenoa in Parre,q\llm in fllio.dillinguQ • alrcrill5 (OlIionis quamum ad contlitutiull. cfleilfiz,& quantum a.clquid. neSQ i a1tcriU.UatIOws,quantum ad

modi

,!iJij"jiUf4tfo XIIl

lIJodi 6.::atiU'!Im 'j 'Be quanmm ad 1I1;qllid ,rrafifcat;- 6ppcli1i~ur eniin 'vila tc:lario alteri;1lc ftc quoad hoc elt al~eriunatjohi!, Vnde.non p~tel1 {equi.quod aliquld lit de ~om:eptu ~Il~nua: In II~:I p~rCOI1~. quod non fit in alia fimpli.::iter loquendo ~ fed io~ JillIl quoad modiricationem inadzquatam , ~ teo. latiuam.

Ad quarturn jam {!lpra rrJponf!lIn eil: qudd PlIter co mmun kat torarn dfcnriam Filio ,fed non toraluer, IX Cub ornni moddkat!l:mc • id dt. rcram quantum ad quid, fed non quantum ad aliquid.

A It TIC V LV SUI.

rfrtJm trrs rt/,,/irmn JiO~1Jf IYujtr .... ft&7iones, ~xijmlj,h. & ii/in jmiiilf iJtlTihlltMilIlIli!limlt?

J

C· EttUIll ell: quOd 6cur diltiniras mulriplicari non potdt in per(onis (~bllanrllli:, iu nee atnibuEa,qmt'omnino ~bColuta fimt ; &. non COI11- mUllircr przdic4fiUlt de rcbtiuo,a.: a!J{oJuto,mul~ fiplic;!dnQfi PQllilnt (ubI1.mriue.

ErmiG cit milfiifella. quia in ptrfcilioDibus :1bfolutis, nulla d,teur (lppolitio ~' nC"~ reiatiu.l,quia abfolu£if funt,n", ptiuariLl;l.;aut negarill;l)vd cootraria , quia i1IimifOlI~ (ont. nee ilia opp'o1itio per Deglrioncm ;lor pciu>lrionem fund,ui polll nifi in limir,uione,& imperfc~jone, ... t ai(p.pr«ed.lP't ... , ptmdc{.uum til:. \l..!!m: atttibuta ilb 1I(llllliagi; mu1tiplic~ti polTunt t &. dilHn$ui quam diuinitas ipCa. Y nde in 5ymbo'io Arhanauj dicimr ~ N IJIJ mil 4Ifmi,{td "'If"" gtmtUl, nan Irll #I'lVJlf~iMIt1. {ttl. 'fIflHllJrmlipmnJ. <!Cc. quod itudligitUf wb~~mti. u~; nam adidtiui;multiplicamur ad Co lam multip1icnioncm [uppo liwrum. vnde dicimlls eire: rres pafona5 diuin.s.illcfCJta$,COztClllas. co~qualtS; &: in t:.PitmitrT. d.ioIntlir oumipcteates ; confllblwlEiaJ~ &.:. 'quod dl Itlanifdlnm •• diellill~ ifta n1ultiplk~i. Sed d~ffi.:ulw (;11 de ahis ar:ttibutis (eupu:dic~ris, quz nen Clint omninoabCoiu[a. fcd etiam cemmunirer pr:rdil:.1ri {olent de- relatiuis, & abColuds. quia p~t moduJIl ttanf!:enuenraIem pt3:aia.ltrtlt. 'It nes (CS, rrc:-s enritsres tt"oI(eS, tIes vIJi{atc$ (eliltiuE. & IimiliO\. 11\ q\1ibn~ aliqua non exptimum dl:terminaum perf~,;liun~m. \It eres realirares, rres "niratcs {ebclIu:,alia pcrf~d:ioncm cxprimun~. 'l't tees borut ... res, eres Vt'ti[;lfI;S. tres cxifrcnti:t t rru inrinir.are,.&: Gmili~. EE id"., (Miculm dl: t quamam ex hit: mulcipli.:::ui poffintt ql!:t:(lon.

~ia tamen fere omnet in~ quzllioncs dc" pmdl:lIt ex .... fU priori dilli'IJIUtc;, (cj). an tendones fc:cundum filUm proprillm COIJcc:ptnm fQn~ lcm. & non (olum rarione: dr~'nti.1: diuiJU: cui identifil;amur, (~d in Clla pr;;cifiofiC.& in (lRliD~a dicant pcrfeclioncll1;idc:o hoc priIlS difcuriendl1IU eft. & dl:illde- difClltrc:ndum per :lrttibuu.ftou pt%dic.:lta.quz poifunud;!tiue mubipliQri. .

i((idlio1JU ditlin.t 'lJlomcaD dkJJnl perfi,1ivnt1fl.

loqumdo ergo ckrcb.rionioo1 diuinls. non rinone cJlemiz cui idcnEiUantur. fi=d r;uio!l~ Cui formau1.& p~d!i cOllCeptus.vt tdatio cit • &. vi: dillinth;h aliis gcncribll$.,& amibud5,dtlplc~ ell print:ipalis felltcmia.

Prima tell" (ciatiDncs feculidYm fuum fonna-

:arlie. ill. .' 101

:lem '~onci:ptll riJ ,.kpriEi:ir)itii:(~u 'quifcnu's '6lp1i~ ·t:a:nt form~litatcrn.,4.d. non dime :pe((eet:ionen't. feu 110n c"pljcarc ipCa)1l. Hec (~nCCllti:z .nttlbditdi: .pluribus Thomifli.¥, t~pr.eolo in {.d;jl·7· '1J1/J.:.it ;.mma pNtIiIlr7J conclujioflt1n.Cakr. 'h!c'.m.1.,Bannez ,bid,m,Ferrar.2.,timtr", qmt,J,&:,. &; aliis locir. EanacllI tenet SCOtU5)'1'1 ,dijh ''1~.r.",J '4.leqtii-, eur Molina i" htl; qli.z·g,ifTI.z.,d!IP.vll'TI14,.,Beltit:' mlnus!tb.uie Chl'.ftu.n.. lmo&' IJ.V~(qn~ h& 'Jifp.i1I.,,6.rr;llet quiddn 'relationcs in De'odicere pc:tftlHonem,lcd non :ptrfcl!iancs afaii'icb~ ctiam rel,ulun.(ed VflIC>i{1i, 'Q.!!i~ 'duplc:t ell 'bQJU~ ti5,ah~ra .Ilbfoluca;& nan e~ aliild quam peifctl8; lnrc:grrt;"~'~. qu~ V.liaqllzqile res hlb~~plrne]4 quod ad foam' ration em fotmaltri:i',& c;onlticuritJ-;nem pCE tinct j :Ilia el1: boniu~ reLire,fciI, v, aliquic1 en conuenrens aitcri.Pdor bonirss itiUcnimr in \e.:. bl ionibus 1i,u:lrenus percinent 3d ill t<igra_ffi.&:. perft!tam Dei cOfiftiEUtlQIJC:itI,q1iia fine ip'Jis inu:gcr, &: perfl;'Clu$ D,l;:ul non clfc:r. Sed hac bvnit.a.~ no* (uminir c% rcLltionihuj unquam ex ,p:mi&u'$. (ed per Iummarn idcnrif:lu:m , vndc non mul'ipU(:i(li~ ill (c1adonibu~. {c:d ell: "'Il~> Be cadem, BonifU liutern relate nun conucnit reliidolli},ul (e:llirer;qail nondil1:ingullntOr abcrfmtia. v.tIdcmm conue~ niu m iIIi. nifi fecundum cc[pc.'lum f3tioni~, qUill!, inQeni~\lr ciufdC:JD ~ Ie iffu,?, HilDe {enu:u: uam Va!que~ rc:pllt:lt pIohabilem P. AIncon mfFl. f ,difF, J.f.,. .",1111·9· J:'am'lJJC: leget Ruu. Ji{p~

30·foi1.:l.. . . .

Se,unda CcnECntia non (alum aSirmar rtbtio.;. l nes diuinas i!l1po~ace in 610 cO[lcepm petfea-ianem ~ Ii:d edam h~J p(;Jfc:d:ioPI:~ il1tdljplh;.:lri in quantum relatiuas • &. fie Cub cQPcepm tnagi;lf:x~ plicira tel~lioni&. & (ub irC;. formalicatC" Ad, vf Ad, impetrafe pecfe4iancm.Jt3 tenet V.Saacd;; Itb.;,J, Trl1J;',c.,.hNNi. ,,,,&, fllfiltmilnu.& peo ca ciear Gabrie!em, Heruzum, '" .. dio,. ~ ~ quuntur .::iliqtli Tbomillz. vc Cllbfa;':5,plITr.ifl.1,~ dljp • .". &. in cand~m indin:ar Ledcfina afJlifdli;::"

114 diHin4 'lJl+.ut.~. qui ~D addit non cae ad· minendnm qnOd ,diqua pereaio innniu. ctlani re-iafiua lit pon~n.;U. in p~p;~, qli2 non 6t in FiHo~

vel c eonrra , quia lic(t ilia pcrfectio in "fit inlinir.l • umc=n in quantum nplkat ipfulll Ad reb;. titmis. non elf.plitar roUloncm inliwti. Scquir~ esodem [f;ptentiam M.Gano~ 3t: Tor~ Gitau a M~ -Bano~z hi~ ,,",.7.. d¥b.J. .Ean.dc:m fcmcnEi~m vi: ptobabilcm defend!t P. Alarcon 'lIbi fuprJ fftlm.lo:. ~l~rc!que alios pro Col citat Rlliz flJ,.~~p,.~ft~.J .• licct ,pre fiH",,, n.16~~ fo.a'1.11.L~.I:~lml:'t. Jm~ proprie did multiplic.u'i in Dc-o n:.da paf;tlig..

M! limplicirtr limplicci. ,

R:niones qll\t i n Iuc panc diffi,ulwem Eiciunf. 4 pro prima (1:'111 mrb lime. In primiJ ell illud vulga-.

re argurnentum 1 pollcriori,qula li rdado, vt rc:~ lio,c:t1" p~rrel1iQ: etg() VE oppoGra, & dillinaub alia,pc:rfdtio dl ,quia ridnia, 'It rdatio oppofna

d1 flio concbdu(J ~ ergo iddn eft di(:trc quOd fii:

. p~,ftfho • vr (t;Ptio, :);c diceIc quod tit pcrfc:ltio; lit condariw. k yt diUiJ1CI", feu in '}Qlnmm dithnd.a.:lib :llia rc:latione, ~o polic&< h~ argurtlcntOlD: Sc:qllittll; CX hoJ:: quod aliqu:I pafcdfu lir U1 P:ltte~ qllZ Don lit in Fil.i&. c:ooftquc:ns etl f.ilium: ergo. S~quda frob. Eft aliqua rdario iii Parrc*qat btllJ ell in filio. ftd in quanEUtn dl in Parre .& non in Filio • feu VI diai~litlir 1 ilhQ dl perf.s. lho : ago aliqua pCIf~dio eft in p,uu; 'lUZ hall til U1 fiho. Et 1icur valet ifta tOP~'iuc:ndii :Rd~ rio provr in Paue. 6: VI difiilltt~ a filw • eft fub... filf:cmia t leu perli:malir~ ; ergO' mulriplkata rela: none; lIlulrJplkanu fub.G4cwia. CUr nOD valebi

M3 ~

§1.!t¢. XX? III.

ta4etn c6nfcquenrla foqlle'ndQ de petfr.&io~e • ~ ,tdlltio ilia. etiaui Vtoppouta, & incommtUl,~bJ'lis al(~ri pcrte:8:iOJl.eOl dicit. & ipfdn\ opram • &. multipliCIlI.'i. pctfcltio eR: 1· Vndi: non pote:,tl: flen inJ1:,uuia.-cie ipfa effcntb diuina. quia l'aternlta5 ell: 'd1ellti.a~etiam Vt.dillinguitlir 3 FJlio.&: ramen non til" atiq [u, eil"entiOJ. diutna. in ~artc: •. qua: ~on .Ii~, i,n Fflil!l. R.dicituttam~n ba=c mtl:~rla.qI11.il. e{lemla rdiliil1:! non ell rerminus e:tplicans rel:Jtionem, nee in elfC:R(ia oppontlnfUr rd~liones! fed idm~~canH tUr, vndc proVE 0ppoliiWt r,ltel;11ira"no~ diCIt c~ f~ntiaIIl,1iccf in re iluOl (upponat. At veto oppoliu {cnccllria.dicir quOd relatio , etiam 17[ opponitut .. Ireti~~ dHlinguirut ab ilia. &" (ub fotm.l!i ceneepiLI reb-tiuo t'lIpli~:1nte Oppoli!ionem/diCit pc&~ aian~m ; ergo 3hquJ pcffetho cei.:l[lIla eft In PaIrC,9.U~ non in Fil~o. Minor Y~tO arg,umenr~ f~a::i ptobarur,quf'a Ii aliqua pcrfelHo fdamu ell m ilia relatione. v~g.in patemi!atc,quz non in liHatione: ergo tdatio patrtlliratis non ell: infinita in linea; &: gM,crt: tctarionis.Patc[ cOii(c'lu.Non h~bet ernnem pcrfeClioncm iIIius gCllcris, fiquidcm aliqua pcrf~aio eft ill fd~[ion~ patri~. ~1i": non,cit i? fiJio: ergo non ell mfinlta. qLlla iIludelllnfinltUm q,uod eO,"t~nct omnem. perfe(tiOm;l1~ , nee aliq?~ 1:1 Ji!dlln illc gcnetc.1O quo elt. N ei: poreit dlel quod tcbtia P:ltris.crninmtcr. & virmahtec cenrlnet pcrfcltionem, qua: eft in i;'Clarione 61ij.1ic~t non lit formal iter (elatia Filii. Contra enim ell~ quia p,1[crnitas non ell: forma ernincllrior filiatione , Cd omnino :rquali! ei ; ergo non pcm:1l:: eminenter eontinerc ilIam, fed vel formalitc~ debet con rinere, v d. nullo modo.

• A priori Veto vrgcr i111 ntio:qui:l relario Iic~t in rubieao.in quo cit, fl.c perfeflio ipfiu .. 5 ~.ubh::ai, t~~ men refpcCl:u iernum nuUam pcrfelHonem P0l"llt. fcd foluln fiurn ei 0ppDllit;£L'tminus enim non I!Il :aliqllid perfcd:ibile a relatione, fiquidem pcrfeCtibile non opponlrur (u~ perfeCli()l1i,(ea eam (11('1- pil,re!atiO autem opponitu( tem.1I'1o I erg.o rc(peau eius perfc4ionem non cJ.r1iO:::lt; &. I1cprov£ .Ad pcrfeQionesn jioll dicit , tc=a provt I n.{cittefpea:~ (l.lbieCli •• ll.!!0d n. on. ell. lie accip!endum. qu~(i lprUfO Ad In fcperffrulm~ ntln dien.curn reuera .A4 in (ubicQoo (If,& inctu<uc /11 , (e::d quia llbm,paib!lioncm qtum dicit. rc:fpc:l!ln f\lbiefli dicit,m'm teCpea:u termini. Sed [ciarlo non di!lillw gultUub ilia rdarione e~ pm-e fui In, quia hoc habet rarione elfauiz. (cd rarione rui .AA • '1£ tangirtcrmimlm, non vt (llbfitlir in fe. vel Yf eft h'l fubicdo: ergo 6 ratione: ...4.i non r:xplic;lt pcrfeaionem,nequc pc:tfc:ltio rnu1tiplicalur.

Denique ad cixplicarimmn liuius t'Ilyfb:rij non (Ongruit be muh:iplicario rcl:ationum , red im.gi5 :ld ilbm condtic:it • quod pcrfeaio {ertlpcr maneat VIl2.,6cw: manti: pc:&tliQ ablOlura.& eJl'entia, li:d '111M (Dlilln in elfe: re(pedillQ muhiplicc:nl;Ut : ~~ . gofipDtell ~Ilari. quOd pufeltio non multipli«t1U",\i,~ vna,&; eadem omnibus cODueniar.multo tongmentios dl:.

J PtO [;::cund;.. :l.mem renr~Dtia tft iltgd 'fu1gare

argumenNIll •. ~ multiplkua enrif.1U~' reali,DecelT!:. ell mulupUa.n id <J.llOd ad taIem enrn.1l"mI t'9~'mr ; ad e~1 a\l(mJ (cquilUr honiw vd perfe!!ho. ergo ficut dannu IttS reales auicllrts teLld. tlz. 6~ dabui1Ei1f ttC1 FctfeailJllct n:llUiuZ". qui~ petfc(Ho ell p.:Iffio ~~. it "tfgttllt hoc .:ltllE_lius in tcl:\dunibus diuinis.qui.1 ~dadDpi:lIn Vt dlffinth; ~;Ji:l, (~nc:. in Deo inlimim rorma1itt~l ~o dl C3.f'2l alicuilU pttfeilionis~ nam '1uad eft :itu pmeafunis mnjm~ dong~l'IIr 1 Dt:(MIUi . ~·~;ctgo(itd;anoP[pvldillintb

De Relationitni diuillu;

ell; formalitet in Vet! ; op'Orte ~ quod ,provt ltc,tit c:apu: perf'et'tfimis : ergo dillinth:!: pcrfcClionit. quia provt ·td:i¢iD dHHlIda cft. Si ergo rtlario prov!: JifiiJ16ta.dl: capax ·petfediohi5: ergo de fado haber illam , quia quod ell: Capll!: perfr.dioni$, Be de facto nOll halJu.tarct ilia; & ftc erit res imperfdta.

Secundi;, hoc 'lIgetur,'luia my iterium Trill.ft;i.- 6. lfs perrincf ad m.agnam, & ltH{infccam pc:rfc:aio~ nem Dei. ita quod Ii caterer illo j carerer m~

gn& petfeaione. dm in hoc myih:rio e!cuetut DellS (uper omne quod :1 crcatLltis imit:ibiJe ell:

de Dco. Ergo non (olu.m id quod f~nim: r ad vnira,tc~ ~,d abfohJ[am,. fed c:liail1 que.Hi pert:iner ad c.1lllmt!llOnem pe,t(Jnamm ~ & rebtlOfll1m pcrfe~ d:ionC:1l1 impotta( in Dee : ergo id quod di.lijn.d:ioni9 eft in relationibus, feli rclationcs;vt diRin-

d:t, pcrte:fiioncs dicllnt in Deo.Er vrgctUr (CIt eonfir!I1:'Ltlll;:in'lpJins, quia Ii myllerium Tti_nit.ath

ell: perfea:io Dei : ergo paternit3s 'ft dillinguimr a filiationc ell pcrfc:dio in DCD, liquidt'm lincipfa.

Vt diftincb. Deus rrinui non elfet; ergo edam p:i~ tcrnitas 'It difl:inlh 1 fili~tilJne ell pe,;(c8:io fitrl~ plicitet fimplc~". P:UCt confcqu. quia intcgral.&: eonllituit perfeClum fimplidrer Glllplcx • fW:il.my ~ aerium Trinimis, qllia in Deo meliu$ eLl ipttlltl

my Il"I:ri 11m qulm non ip(um, &" melior dhdado patqrnirati$ , qnam nOn Ip(lI,quz ell delinitio perfc!a:iDni~ umplicitcr limplitis. .E.r in hoc "identUr .dida P~1jf!1m cenuenire • qUi dif;Unt Gne pen(lnis Ddratcnf'mancre imptrFcdam ; V nde dicit A,1mna/hl! mft~nt Cit"!". G1"tglllu SabtlliJ f RQ CDr/dill, P

iUJI1 jim , n~1i J;mimf.llm r;o"Jiwrtm r prDlq liiitWi ft lJlt1JCo;tIl'f'IU.liur '~r;'I;ifiA'Il1fm I'itlrr. Jttrim,",1PtJ tiff"' Fr;"fiHiIi/fi illilU {ubflilJlt;4.. E£ Nazianz. N en

tffit DtitMJi imp/,a. tJfo1i Ptift£llltlllltff1 '1-~

do trit, itt qUIZ lid ptrftIlionni? ./iqsrll 4fsJmvltJlT: dejlJtr.t,.rllljttm jifottElillJtl eM,., • 'fI_ 'f1II11'M~

tU h.t"~bit Ji fpi,jium nD11 hablA'. £t denique C,._ pllus_ 1. T~efllHTi c. I. N tI'J P«lft lifo ynftEl4 Dn.... till/lift Ffli_ httbtM,&frsfi"m,,: ftPifTUu.Et lie difp,prl.ctJ.nr .... probauimul fa:c:unditatcm, &: g~nc:ratiQIlt'm m diuinis ad pctfedionc:m pcni~ nt:tc-.9ama(c.edilm lib. I ,lit fkk e. t"i. dicitP.m'mt~

& Filium J,fl;ngfi! ptfftfliqntbHl p"[;mdibsu.Mo.l_ tipliQIiollcm ergo petfcClionum agno(clr. Edn t:piftob. Ag,:nbon,s P"'p.1e in 6. S.JOQJ.~oIf,Ui~ttt ,..di« eitur JiJUllitAttm P/Jiri;, & FU~ ,6" SpirilKl S"ifo

in triltlU perfoa;, f14bfijltntii4, Jiue iii tribHl pvftUiI

P"{t111U. '

VlrimQ: Tre$ relationel litnt Ires fublillcnti:r 7 relari ml:,leu paConalitafC:s : (ubli !lentia .1utem ell" tenninus fUDlhnti:t , &ad eil15 pc:rfcltLonem (peCl:at:crgo aiam in diuini~ (ubliltemia, qtl3: dl rthtio[anqnarn vlrimlls terminus incommuniC;lbi~

lis perfeliionem iinponat in quantum ;nCDl1lmllni~abili$ ell:crgo in ~uaHrllm _di.llin8:a ab alia ~ebtJ.onc~&: [ubfificntla 1 ergo dii1:md.am petfe~,o-, nem habet Yn:11"eiario ab alia.

Et 'olllir. quia 6 foliim in Deo tlrc:t vna [nbGRenna, Ik pcnonalius i ilb. tine dubio elfet pfrfe- 8:j(). vrpote tcddcns Il3tUf31n illam vtrim", c:am~ plc~m.& terminamn:ergo fi tres reb.tiones ver~ & proprie (unt [re5 (ubfillen1ia:. & penQmlit;l,rc$. c;.ur .1rnimmt r:uionem perfeltjoni! in qu.anmm diuerf:r1qll2m habcrcnt fi (Dllu!'lciTellt'ln3!

Contir.Ct'cuncio,nam in diuina nanna eire com.~ ltlunic:abiletn • maxinb petfc:Cl:io e!l,& propria ra~ lis natu(lr':etgo C'tjam per(onte diuill~ in qU;lflfn~ plure$ dic;rnt~rfeaionml. I"~tetl;on[cqu.quia iii quantllm plules, & d.iLHn8~ fum c~paccf iIIiuf puf;ltioriil inlil1itor,qU:i: ubi comnmni.;afUt. &::

. jlU

. ·Diflmldtio XlIi

ill; peIfelliotii idcbrilicantur,b,lbcrc:ltttem pcrfc(liollem infinit~m eique idcndfic~ri non modica ptrfct.l:io dl,fed maxima. Ergo pc:r(onz etiam vc pJuresf& q\l~libct ve diHillcl:.l ab .IIia m,lxima petfettlo fUIt; & fie pct(mulitas V erbl COmmuJlicata humanitati Chdlh edam ve diilinaa 11 Pmc (pa~ eernitas enim commlmh:~ra noll fuie) maximam illi pcrfca:ion~rtl cOlltulit,& per.looa: ip(;e etiam yt dil1incb;, & qualibet earurn lcorfilrtl ratione lUi maximo arnore. /!tl. venerarione (unt digoa: ciiln adorentur I atria : ergo fum maximc: perfillz.

8 fmer h;n {~mcntia; probabiliu9 lUdico (cclln~

dl'lm meneem S. Thom.fdatiollCs,ccbrn (eCII '1 dil m fc. &: in linea, & f(lnnalirare r~btioni~ p~rf.:{honem dicere, (cd nan cxplitarc iIIam po:r ordinern ad terminum , fcd pcr (JrdmC:ffi ~d fubicel:um. & fllndamcn£rJlII. Et confi:qnc:mci' non mufdplic=lti mas pClf.:.::liom;.' in rribus rcbionibus,(CiJ p~r:onis.q ui~ non Iilulripii,al ur fund .. m c nt111t1 • fcel eadem pcrfcc'liont: edam vrrclsriua cit gaudere,

PrIma pars conclefio Ilis defumirnr In prilTlis ell; D.ThomfHpr~ '111·:7·,m.1..lfd J. vbiinquit,quod In ip/li P"ftfJW1t d'nmi ~!l~ (lJflfirltttt1, &' "ItrbHm .nlllligibiliW' F~mJff1~' & priricI,t11l1 V abl,p'llt ,& '1~4&HtJlq~,. If~ ".1Id f/1"fttJ,~".,m ptrlmmr ; Sed Verbum,& prmclp1um V erhi lunr pCrCOll:L",& relariolies vc dillinC1:;£ ; ergo fi ccnnnenrur in pl:'rfcCtlone dluini dl::,ficm quz;:umquc .ld CIU§ perfcaionern pertinent. vuquc Verbum, & £,rindphlm V trbi ~d pcrfed:ioncrn pmin'llt. Et q~ ,de pot enli4,4rr.J.aa r. inqlllt. quod Dill;",' fJfo'll;a qHia CIJmprthmdi1lffmmiTrJ gtnemm perft(lj"nfJ,dih./ ptilhlba rei4iiol1tm il'l {a ,nulll;"', Ql!iC rario nihil valet,1i [I.:b[io non dicat pt:rf~·.'l;ionl!m. Item ilJY.q*. l~M",.~.dicit S.Tbom.quM P~Yfof11l fi1.lliJit4t ill q""J. p~ift:a1fif1ltlm e]l in /Dr4 tlltttrrd,foJi. fllbfiflml ;lIl1l11tf4r~ ratiDnali. "nat cilm omne illild qUl/d til ptrfi!li"ni4 De~ fit .tltTibHmdllln.tu I}Jlud eim 1ft'llilll nl'ltiflet ill fo flmtlem plrftEEIMim • t;lInllemen~ e}l. 'VI hl1& 11#111111 p~rfon~ de De(J Jit:alllr. / If ert .a urem .... i1l1l'l1tdiaru did! quod Perfona in diuinw jigmft"''Ts 'Ttiilfiul'lem ft~1f"dkrn qllllJ. jade difti"Elinl1tm. & fignifit;~t i/lam ~t [ubftPenm!J. IgltDHeiado vr fublifl:J:ns.& vr pet(onalis • q!lod vtique conuen!r rdacioni djuin~ f,cundlll11 le,& in Ilrlca,& formaliu· rc tciationis.ll,er nOll tub cs:crcitio :ild rtrminum. fed VI fllndata. dl in fuo fi.lndJmemo > p~rfc(qonem dicit> fiquidem nomen petfona:. vt didr S. Thom.efl: nomen perfc:frionis. id~bque am'lblfi~ tut Oeo Vt p_cdoo:t rdatiuaetl:,& td;lrione conllimta. V id eridus 1:1\: c:ti;t.m S.O .qu.,.dt pdttntilll4rr. J. vbi diJltl'lgllit in pcrfona n.iruram ~ & moJUIn q~o. Ci:ilHt natu~~.Et qUidc:m flJltUr:t eft dignHIirl1-l. ~cd.lnt~lIcallaln; modul .:Intern t:::tlilelldi, '1l1cm ImpDtt.lt pe~(ona. til dignHIi:mlJ';:. Ceil. v, fie perfe aillens. & Cum omnc '1llDd ~ digniilimum in q~nuis lit D~o .mribll~ndum • conrt'{u~n~ efl .... t nom~.pCtrOJ1;l: ;mtimurur Deo.lgimr D.Thom. ~ eO qnod modll$ fubli~l~ndi dic"ir perfccliooe-m-. amibuir ilhltn Dco; fcd tcbrio pfon difiinguf{ur nQl\:m modo inrdligendi l narlin dt form:llircr, modus file pe~ fe C:l:.illendi • & incommunicabiHs fublitl:cmi:r.quj;l ipli til qn~ form,lliulf contlimit PCdOfl;!ID in ution~ PC({o~ tubUlh::mis ilJrommllnicabiJitCf,& diilincb: ab aliiJ perfonf~ = e£go rdario imr;! Iineam reLuioni5 in DM perfc:dionem impotrat hoc ipCo qtlQd mod'iln p(!"[(onahralL~ impornt. DCniqu~ iii -t.(wtm~ Gmtfl.t:. H.&l7c.i !J.Jr IO.tii'guTntiml1l1 fat¢Ulf D.Thorn. quod reJatio in aeullfii habet elfe dcpendeo$ non lohlm 3. !ublbnda, I~d eri<lm ab aliis ;u;cidemihuJ, idf:-bquc: .imr.:J:ff'diillm\lm,& polhemc.lID,(ed in dill!mH~--:

Artie. tn. ,.·oj:·

btio non .\~ab ee .;.:(fe dcpenderis ,'heq\lc impede. chlm. Ex ~ldo cbHigii, 'lllbd E:~ tmptrpmllllt,'1". in rt/(lljonibiu ~ruitiJ ~Jfo viderur,l1lJ7I ji'lHifllr, ij~otl < pfrflm~ din;,;,/; jinl'iml'erjeffl., qtrrereLuionibU5 'oifiillguumnr,!fd {tqilitlJi' quOd perfonarlllfl 4Jfliriiirllln lIIillilf111 fir d;ftT~/ill. Si ergcle:x relarione etiam. vr drlhnglientc .plitronas non {ctIilinlt imperfedio in druinis . rci;!tib ergo perfectiouem dd)~'t imporrare in vi conccpttufui ,edam qU3(C=llIis re~

lario ddHn'h {eli diftilT"ucm ali, .

~6d vero ham::pcthccionelit non c,pliC::l't:pir ~ ordin(:m;ld ecrminurn, &lnb C'lIcrcirio .Ad,Yt Iy

.Ad rangi( mrnifium. (~d vr r~!igifUf , IX fia(dU1t

ex ftmd'iIllento,filmimr ex ipfoD, Thom.in 1 : diP· 16.qU.l,OjTf.:L.ad ;.& 4. vbl diCit, quod !!gamil" ,,&lal jPlli ~:r h~c 'ilIad "a IIlftrtittJ dlcitur , nun debe,,-

tu» '1ulid fit r(4 ql/~da'n t eft t(ll7WI ru alilJltll ft&Hlidil>n quod ""btt fil11ddTllmtltTlf,n f(1 ¥juua r<ftTt~ tiT~:t: hoc 'II/ferm; h"bu t11 'l1f1l!lfHt!J aillimfiqHMt fit hypofl4i~,1ItI jJ1bl"lIIt,a;& U{CQ fH,;t rmietn h.!f~ft4- j,mt dijlinWlJlflffl. Er darill$ in J.aa ;Jflfir!lld.ttIdfm dlf/.1.6 .qu. I. ,/Ii'l. t .SmTldHfR,.inqlli~, 'lu«J·r~I(lt judu;, pllCitlr far~}l cllnJid~rllri. r fllJ 1fIOdO.qHllti/flmlld itt

"d 9'lua dictlllY;o.'f qRO tllJtI habn '111!1ti PUf1l1t /i[,qltiJ. qtl<trllHU edam t:c hut tlun htlb(1l1 quad nihil fit: font tnim il/iqu) reJp,n MI,1'11 funt Illiquid !mmdi1trJ t&rw. quidam veto qui I"h,l, qlflJa in aliu gmeribm nan inHemll,r • .lllilHflQar1'1U(I"llIfR ad jJ. Jll ijlll1tfh &' fo 'lfWlb hili", ellilfom iii {ltbicUII N/fllf,r i1111 ' ,p. ,p!m{l'tClH4,jI ~talu.~t Jdemf~ml tf;ldidl'I.h..:r~ lJiI,. ~3.,m,l. Er UtlO bums m.uufclb dl, '1lllli IIru4

Ad , quo,l in fc reale ell. & jli f~ p~lfc:Wo ell re(peau !crmhli,non panic 11i6 rcfpjcitmi~m,& con:'

tea ip(uJti cH .~ ergo non cxplicar .prove uc,re3Jit;itcm,quz lit,fcd ~d quam rcalitatcm lir • nee refri:' cienria ponir (juid'illafn in fcrminG,nili ctTc telre:" dnm, nee hdrnino acdpi~ p~rfcttionem,(cJ (0- him corre(pondCiiti.2:m.& correlarionern.ncc eempar~rut 3d ipf"m VE pcrfctl::ibile ad petfeCiionem;

Lcd V~ purtlS. termimrs, In fe ergo re;llifatl;"l? ha~

re po[cl1:r3tioJ'lc ftlnd.-imcnti, qui~ 1!1 ip(o babet cll~.1ll atl::llahl:man. on'mii ltiU:m pcrfeaiodid-

rur ratione: alicuius em:, 'lei a,ltJ3litati~ ,& omni~ re.liita~ ;Iliquam c:tHkmiam refpicit,pcr f~rminum autcm non hab~t ,-tli:, lIeque Cl!:ltlctiam,feu actU:l~ lit~relIl, fcd r.mnim rermmarionem. ex ipf" ergo non h~be~ It<llimtcm, fcd ad ipfillll. Er ira fi:rnd1~ ·mentum ell: uufJ u3Iir;uis. terminus alllcm conditio, (cuid circa quod t:,,~rcc:wrrc~li;; "ppoJiriO'. q!lia line ro;tmioo fcaiiHcq:.icic:nri:l. & CJppoJJriQ non eller. V mit: D .Thom.dicir qfl.8.J, fu/tnll;ll ",rr.

J .ai i.quod JJ "Mqd tft fNfml1tJ rtl~l!l!riil,rCl~.fJPPI1I1"& 41jll1lgui,7f"lmr i~ a.ltJl/uitf!.lm#IIY. Q!llre !Jon n<:golr D. Thorn, nee VUUf C=ill~ dif;:iputUl Reg~re ro~dt quOd rdilIio , vr rd~li~, &. V~ Ci:en:cr ...1.1,& .... t !,tJJgit rCnlnllllffi, rc=alis lit, &. oppolirio. at'1ue dillmdio cillJ 6r rcalis. fcd <iidmus quod reali~ar~m hane, & dlf., &: adu~Iiriltem. & !;Qnf~~ qnclllcr perfedton~m h~btr ra:ione fundamtnd.

lL in iIlo ponk id quod dl. R~ fpdlu veto t~'Imilli ~xc:rCct banc- r('allt<ltl.:m 'lttam eJ: fundamc:nto mb~r, non pon;:ndo Cain jn ,1Io, fed o;;ontraponendo iUi.aut rdpkiendo. &. hw: dl non aplie-are e~m Pa'" ordincm ad tCfmhlum • qlUu in c:() p()ncndo~

aUt :zb eo b:lbcndo. .

~oad Imtnd,un Veto, p2ftcm comllJlionis. J ~ quod pcrfcaao qll~m dlci: Id:tio • & qllJ:m. c~ mnw.ntJlto haur.t. l)(. kClUldum quam n:fplcll; oppo(iruin cDtrdttriUl.lm. non Illulciph,ebu,!illui-

wr imrr~mi~ c::t S. Tborn. iTJ j.p''1H.Att .:.;.tld ;L vbi diLit~Suhr ~"dr". {Dim," '1"6 In Ptltu 1ft p~ur~)it4l'~

jn £,111} t{l.jilimib, ifilI"4dr';J digffiltU. '1".& VI P":~

~£ft. s: X vtn.

1/ plflfYnitM, in jU/JJ ~flfililtjq. YmuJieitHr,quilll _qllJdqHid dfgtlitaruhAbtt Pat~r,h."Jm FitINo. ~~&fl-

: '9#II!f;', .p.,/ufiitAum hilbel pater; erg" plt./mm4ltm - h"bel filj~:1t/flr~tu, ~/lim ~Liidin:l? aliqui4 : e4dl~ ~lIim tli ~Jfomia, &' tligflllM P.uru_,& Flt~., fo~." Ptltr~ eft (tcI'rtdiitn nladll1trR tM1ttl6_. In F~J,(j fl&Hn--

: d;ITIJ 1'dllr~(mem Itccipiell;id •• V ode fic. argllm~mll~!

- Q_ u:ccumqllC: perfeaio_ , cnam .. elaeiua, qua: ed II'). II:llL'e.pc:rtJllec ad djglllt~tem eius . nanr elfe Pauetu,fcu prim:ipium pcr(o~:lru~. dj~nir~s dus c~, & hoc ell: qUid rd;t[iL1UIl1,.lc~dl';:iC S:~bo~n, qllod c~~m ell digrti[a~ p~tC[l!Jtjm;& 6hmonLs: ergO' c,\d~tn pcrf(;tJ:io rclariua. Item in q11.S. de pgt~lftlll A~t.1.ad i ,. dicit S. Tborn.qn Cd NfIiI4 tI1Qio cOl1ce(/(tldl/l7J ep,qllbd .dil4d fit effi r#lt.tiMU in dluillu • & a/illd ~JJ~r1tjlt. R.trio ,illmil nsn ft1.7IifiCllt lifo. fod tjfo '1uiJ.,id41 qUid illiquid. ~p. r nd» Jilof rarioflet rei nM dm1ofljIra1tt dlipk.t: tJfo eill<l. Si ergo cft'e r~l,1tionii in Deo nullo modo eoncedendum eft quod fit allud .. b dIe effemia: , Iicet fir alia ro1tio relarionis, Be el1cnria:. I!A, omlli~ pcrfedio, & bonius fccull~ J'lm D. Thom. J.PM,1".f,,ut.1. (umiru[ ex ordi .. ne ad eHe, OpoHct qnudC~cL.lndum D.Thom,p~r~ fcelio, & elle relatiunis, ttiam Vt reheiuum , non

lIlultiplicetur. .. '

II DCllique vidcndus ell S.D •• " l.Jift'H'lfH~fl.l.

Ilrt.I."d ~.1/bi inquit. quod Si,ut ill FtJio tjllJfo tf fiflfiof,rfi ejfo pamtJit4tM, lJ "'4 in di1JiniJ rI~n tft i'iiji '1/,,11111 ej{t. Vbi manifdl:mn eft, quOd c:ondil1inr gucndo erre clfc:J1tia: ;Lb cae: patc:mit:ms , non po· reli ~cdpi elfc patcrnlraris > nHi pro efIC td:ltillo: di~it :Uluan S.U. quod !itUt eft in Filio em: ell::nti;e, iu t=1l: elfc patemi!ilti~a:rga il!udmft die relntiL1um quod ell: Patris , ell: fllij. 8( non falum eni: ab(o!u[um quod eft clrenti~. EttedJir r~tio[lt:1ll qui:l.dl ta(lulm vnum clle: ergo fr:mirj quod efle relnriuurn eft rannim vnum, &; noa lt1ulliplkatur, cri~1lI ve ddlinguirur ab elfc cl1'=nti~. (>c&C1:io aurem re-latina tcgulatut pcnc:s dle,feu ;laualitarem (cb.fiuilm • uCUt pcrfcdio ablQlura penes elle. & aCt\13!itatem ellcnua::"go fcntit D. Thorn. noli 111 ulriplicari pctf~dionem rdatinam in Oco ~ licet multipli'l:lurrcfpeaus,etrclario dillinguatut:nam pollqu.tm D.Tbom. dixit qUQdelfe pate:mir;1tiJ di ill filio.qui:L eft ~(ltum vnlim dfe.fubdit,qu6d P<f1fYlfi't$J habet ralil'/lt711 pafm1ftlltll , '1"~ ~ft ali" # r/Jfi~t~JfolftU.· '!hiM [eciimUtilJ [JUfJII rtUioMm F#tfl rtfPtUIIi ~Jfo in Film. & mm ill FiJiD,foil. Jijlil1g1Jm Patrtm ~ F,liD. Ecce quomodo offidum dil1inSllendi {c;cundum rationr:m tefpea:us • a.= reb.tioDis. f1tCfllr O. Thorn. clfe in re~onibU$ diLlinis. nOll diflinhtucndo,nc, multiplicando cae ipuus rebrionis. feu p.ncmiuti5 'It dillinguitut ab cITe c1l'enti:J:: ago pUi form. perfelCio rebtiua non rn1lltiplieiliitut,lic:et rcbr;o fecundum oppoGtionern IDlllrip\iccttu: re.uiter.

11 ~~onem bnius e1: iplis 'vifc:eribus nattlr:r: reIM10IIIs vidctllr rc:ddidill~ S.Tbom. cum :tit qlJ_S. Je po,.mriJl. 41't .1. 4Jl. 11, quOd citm relalill fit tU:d ... J~IlJ j)J m ... r.u~M"Jfo [1t1fTll eft i,,~Jfo; tn1tk tffi foRm ~QIj ~p.u: ;d~fi Mm. <l.!!z ratio fottius cUtrit In dllllflU.qUta Ii in crutQri$ c:1li= relariopi5 eft in~ clr~~in diuillis. en fubfillcrc t 'lode: elfe fiulI~ non en ... d31iud~fiq~idt-1ll in ft fublillit, &:td (e elf iI~ Iud e!'"c pr~ ... t IlIbfil1cPI : Ccd rot.uatio IULdtipli'~I'ldl ,e1auon~ fcu ~t(pc.!lU$.cl\:oppor.tio.& "Of~ It(pondc~ri~ ad {~um torrtl;ttiu~m ~ orgo Ii ip[um tilt! te4uonlS folun'l ~(l pet Ofdincm ad fubictlu. ,LUndt. ell :1C(idcm inb!:re!lS,vel pet ordinem :ld

tt t!l(Il~filletl$ > m;!nifc:fic dc:ducitllt' • quod uk c C;"¥l oppafitioliiJ i:d.atiu: multiplicni non :1 .. : U'b ii in Dco n nullo alio prin,ipk> 1'0-

s» Relation; /;m Jiuiny;

tell: mulriplicati aliquid~ qUa'm (:x oppofirioocre; briua.vbi ilia cetf.lt,cdbr multiplio;ario;ql1C1d non ell in I!reatis , in qllibus cum rd«do addd£. e{l~ accidentale lilp(:l ipfum (ubi ecru III ; (~U fllnd!lmcn~ rum , potell: 1tI11Jdpfi~ati relario ex diuerfo clle Hmi~ato quod haber qn;idibcE relaslo, etiam ex p ar-re lui fllndamenti ~ 60: ill o[dilieadfubier.l:Ulll,l10n n'lultiplicau oppoluione ccrrelatiua : rum eriam rclstiones dl(parolra:) sc 110n corr~la.thll: mlliripli_ cantur in aliqeo (ubicito,&noll per oppolitioil~m correlarlaam imer [e, quod in Deo non contingk. quia Ii rdationcs aliqu:r non opponunrur , hoc ipfo idf:'llcilicannlt.vt patcr in plrcmjt~tc,&: [piratione a(HIla. Si !!q:\:o ex parce fun~.mcnri) & cllC quod ex ilia relationes lub.:nt • non daeu( aliqua oppofitio in relauone diu!":!. cum fua fund.iml:n. tO,ex hn.' ~m~ m?lti~Hc~r! non pOrrUM , quia de_ eft mulrlplic,otJonu f'nnqplLJm, quod eft oppoflrio. Ergo ti to,a pl:rfcdio rcbtiollls,c:ri.1m 1/[ rcl.1~ tiU3 cxfundaLIJI!DtQ. & (u.bicCl:o dcfumitur.tepu_ gnat IDulriplicari in ratlone pctfcll:ionis. Ii~cr in fatioue rc!"peClus 0l'poJi~i ) l!oc dillingucnti' muldplicClitilf. c •

COl1llnn. qllb bene {b[ relariOllem in Dee di..; aingui, & opponi cum alia libi cortd:itiuain ra.. lione rcrpc:Clus oppollri, &; ramen in-ratione: cnti~ t.ttis tdldu,e, l!J; ali;lrum petfc:8:ionum edam rclati uarurn idcnrific~ri cum aliis relaricnibus • quibG non opponimr. V[ patct in fpiratiollc =llliLU, qU.1: opponimtf.ipiritui S.p[oc(!dcnri, non anrern I)p~ ponitut. rcd idt'ntificamr edam quoad rein reb_ tiuarn , & ciI~ relatiuum cum patcmit;tu: • & fili~tiopc:, (lui bus non oppOnitUf I e~go t1 jpr~ {el;tdo_ nes pcr[Ol1alcs non oppolllln[llt In perfcchopc tC_ l;l[iu;l prlllvt haulh, &: hllbibita 1 fundilmCnto. II) quo orpo!itiopcm non Iube~t; fed (ollIm pron oppah!J. rermmo , feu cerrelatiuo, non eft muum quod III ipfa pcrfccbollc P[OV[ relatiU4 idc:ntitt.. ccnrur. ~ VIlUIll lint. lic~ rciationes in officio di-fiillguendi. &: opponcndi cal;feutine nllt piares,

Dices: Etiam relado ell: rennino non habet rca- I i litlfCIll) &: ramen mnltiplieat ilLtm,lice( terminus

non pr~beat illam r Cut ergo nOB Ull1ltipli(:~bit perfc:d::ioncm .lichcx rermino non b;.b~~.

{cd ex fundam<:ntQ ~

Rc:Cpon. qnoo.licCt ex rmnino non habe.lt r~ btiorealit;lfcmq1to~delfc1/t ell D.Thom. ilf l."a ,Aw,ib,djjJ.1.6.,fopr" ... idimus, tamct1 circa ilium habet oppoficioncm rcalem , & confc:quentet dillin~ d.ioncm rc;dcm, qua; fonnaljtcr (c:qWtut eJ: 0ppo_ litione, Vt ex ip(o D. Thorn.lJlI.S.lie pDIetJtill ICY;. [. "d ~.Jllp,a edam re[Ulimu~. At ipfol pctfed:ia teladila ncque lubec rC3lim~1l1 cx ttrmino,neque op~ poUtiollcm. Non rcaliE;ltcm) quia hane ell: fIJnd;l~ mento (ottitur. qUi~;lb iIIo habet C1:ille.IJti3m ,& illud n:fpicit v[ pc[fc:aibile: fuurn,&" raditem a qua oritut,quod non habet in rermino. Non OppO,HfiOnem.quia petfelHo rdatil:mis non tonllcJ,lir. neque exercemt p~r ordinem ad terminum,(cd ad fl1nd~_ ltIentum • tadone cuius h:l:betur : terminus cnirn nOll complfamr 'It pcrfc:ttibilc vel p~rft:ailll1~ rc[pe£tu rel,uionis > fcd 'If aliquid mere conmpo- 1inim, &: cQftclatiuum quod rdpicit. non quod perfidt, qUil nihil in c~fmino ponir,ncc termil1\1s itl relarione. fed CQli'lm COI'IUapD(l\llltur. &. ie te~ ipiciunr, fllnd.l!l1enmm au~c:m pl:rficieut 3 tebt!o ... ne, qtli:l in eo ponitur • & ptdidt rdarion:m,quia. ah eo oritllr. Vbi ergo re1:ario non hab~[ c:Jfc:inh.ntlls (lIbir;tlo.a limit:ltum.atque dillinllum 1 fundal'l'ltnto.&: :!.li~~ ei non oppDoiElJr, non poteft ~~tipli~'c:' p~fecHoll~m quam mb;t eli: ilIQ in

. tealliillC

XII/.

tca.litlltc fll;l.l R.dation~1 :iUlcm .diuirue in fundamenee npn opponuntuc ; quia" fundamcntum elt aliquid ab(o!tltum _ i nee enim fundanmr fupet ali02 ri:lilltione. Abffilul;l anl~ in Deo nee or' p!lJ1umur ,n ec multiplican£uf ~ ergD nee p~rfca [Unes ex fundamcnto relaeioeibus. conuenienees.

14 . Qaod fi his adiufile,is doCirinam S. Thorn, [ft.P";' q. f. ,m. ,. tid ~. quod non ell inconueniens, quod alieui end fub aliqLla contldcratlonc,vd formalitate no» conuenias bonitllJ; fiech in re eonucni;lt. qub _bonit2S feqLlitllf ad ens.non quomede .. cumque, fed (ub ea radone qua erpli(:at dh:. &. aau.alitaE~m.qila potdl: :llIfcl:tc:. IX rnotll:rC veluntatem,ficut inaihcmafica fub ca ablhad:ionc boru(;lcem non c:tplinnf; quam [amen in re h~bcnt in ratione quanrir;ltis natur.l.!i,; videbi~ qUClmoao inu:Uigi pOllir qucid tetnio b:ibc:tls in (c perf~c1itlnq ~:t Cuo fl1nd:illieto.fi ramen ab eo non dillingnimr licut relatloncs diuinl:.non dillinlbm neqllc mul .. ejpliaram pcrfe(£ionem h:lbe~llt ex if'ro.E~ compar:itionc autem rcbtionis ad terminum Coreirllr quidem oppo{itionc:m~&: ditHlltlionS in rc(pidi.do.fi:d non in pctfeCliollc.& il.a:l.I~litafc.quia holn&: non ncrtc:r lilb formalirate ad taminurn .lic~t ill {c:.& in re perfr::Clkmem habcar ~ii:d void. nil mill. fipliu~am.quiacopuadanc 3d (u~ict:hlm illi habet.Ratio anrem P. Vafq.pfobiiris C1 co pcrfc:d:ionem rd~donum crre VlIJIli,qt.lja integrant.& confiiruum eandcm perfeCiione Dd,parll vrger. quia POll bene (.;quiruf e~ hoc;qllod (altern inada:qnati bonicaccm non mbC:3I1r. quia ips" inrtgtlrc: boniratcm;ptr(l.'t"lia,& bonitas cit t Iicll[ l:tiii amibula Dei c211aS indiui(ibilem Dei bunitolie in1t"sraJIt,& t.lmC vnli qlJ(ldqneia(ualinca,& fonnaJir,uc: pcr{Cd:UID eft. vi" ttiam centra ip{um Vafq.probabi. Ie etfc: (enri, Alarcon mfa. f .dij}.+e.J,.nllm.lo.

]I . Ex his babel int~lll:a:am propohfiollc:m S. Th,in

r •. I.hllilU q.ql1z lUUJtiS obWI1J3 vila eft. kil. quod {alUm in bif,qu~ fum ad aliquid.inllcnitur fi:cun· ~lfm ptopriam radoni,aliquid (ecundu,m r;lIion~~ it no [c:aliu:r>qllod in a1iis generihllS no eft inueDIJe.qeod d!lli~ult.ilt~ ~I;~je~ ~uod fi ~oq!.limr L? Tb. de: r~l.uion~ pr zdica(Jict:lb.tcu de IPC!) pr;l;dlc;ame:nto.c:onlbt fum dlc,qaiOl pr.rdicamcmil II!· hrioni5 non niG ex rcalibl1l retilionlbus contiar. nee in iUo· reladenes rarionis ~ti po!TlJnt. Si autf loqQInu: de relatione prOVE ahfttabit l.eali. /k t .... uonJs,quid mirum quod in c;!. pollit~l!cniri relario non Eealis!Sed bD' etiam in aliis: gc:ncribu~ in~eni[llnq!la!Jtit~s cnim v[ abllrablr alcali1 & imaginada,t{iam quantirarem rafiQDiJ: aruninit. & loCUs v£ abftnhit a \f~rQ.vd imagipuio.&:t:.

. Sed Re!p.D.Tb.llunquam dixif{"eqllod in pr~~ dJl;amc:ntQ.fc:luiol1i$ inuc:niruf rdatio udonis • vt aIi<iui no.n,attmdcnl~ tid vnb.1 S. ThUlll4n,di (cftrum.Cedfo!iim dicit q_uod m 1m 'J"<I fon, "i.flip

, ,/1I$a inrl,:ni/~l' <I/i'lflid t<ltilll1i1; &. lcnfus cll ~ quOd te:latio ex ilia pmc qua Cl:cn:al.lE' :td tcrlnillUnl • & • t~ngit mum,nci~~nit tCiliracem nlfc .c:xdQdir~ am. follit e;lm > 'It S. Thorn. fc dedarauit in 1M Ahj.. btil.dijl.~6.foPT; rrilUif, Eddeo ptO ~ plnl: pr~rise confiduata rebrio.& ROIl attcndcwlo ad fun~ ~mentum. non t~pllgtiilt d.m rdarionn rationis; & fie loquitur de ~<:bti'me non a~. :q. ua~e COlltiw deut.l. ~ fcmndum omnc: quod mc1udn tam C:I: pmc: (Ilbielli.& fiid.wEti.qulJi ~inl.liue pro"r en in pi:td'.91mmto,tiue £'IOYl ah,Guhit 1 tCaIi. &-~rlollis.kd oe relatione przdlc ~ ~ i~qnatc Collfidmu rub iUa p~:ecib fOf,,;iUtatC' qua =~. UIl"ad alta'um.Q.god non conringitin aliK gcnmbus. in q[Jibllf Ii a1iquiit raria~is .:&. im:Igim~ ri!lm inaenimr. non eft ex ipla conc~tu aut for- .

J~ .. n.;~S:rhim.if11i"rl.J).Th: Tomus~tu:

·~Mrlic.

111..

10$ malirate tdlis generis,qult da te locurtl.der entita,ri non rc.lli,li:d 'iuia nos aliquas i'J'"guiQllcs, & inc(aS Jidiones sd Inlbi' enriurn iealium dlingimuJ,fn:,,,,t rnontem illhcum,c:him;ram,lintam infinitam,& 6- wilia , tlQ~ quia ipfc monSjaut aurum, aut linea •. de (ti~ iI.li9UI:H;oncc:r·· ru realir~~em ~ ~l!;pl,c~nf. [I:d qUIa .lJaqua: nd:u [um ad In.ll~t Illorulll ~u:e.tealia {un! i~i1giDamllr, Relationtm V~tP ptt hOG pra::ci~c quod iIlJda-qu;ue taniidtreli1us,ld elt .pro c .. patte '~ium>qu~ ,onfid~rarur ~d u:uninum.ted~ acre: pOlUttliiU non reslem, EoUendo id 'luud eQ ex pattc fundamcilt., '1[1d,:: u;itil tius (t~htu deCu~ liJiEllr.

Ad fUnda!'nc:tir# oppo6r:. pro e~ paw: qua pro- ill bam notlr:iltl cenclufionem , 1i:i1iecr reladoncs di. cere pcrfelijonern , admircimliS. Pro ca verOp~t4

ee ql1~impugnimE. (ciliccr vel prohando q~od non du;ar i1bm • vd '1"od mll]riplictnmr ;. Re.pont!t;<> rur, .

Ad primum pro prima f¢ntentia Re(pon.qua4 rdillio V£ feiatio. 00:. VE oproti~.t. fuo c:onelacino pcrfc:Clio en ill (.: cmitatiul,vc:l (ubi"d"iut!,(ednoD ft:rtJ1lnJtiu~.hOl; el] hJb~t in Ii: p~rlell.ionem. &; tcrinet.li:d~" Cubir;{t(l, & fiHld.>memo defump~ r~m.nOI1 n (,rmino,nee ratione cumini;vncic (lon en nma'e quod m~l!ripllccr pl:rf~aion~m~ fC'd (0'", 111m t_ctminatitmem,"qIIia Ipiilm refp~a.1l tc:rlnini. OppdlitiDQrnl h;Jb~~,qlJ,t" oppolitio ~ealJ4 ell rdp~ all u:rmiol. &. r~ahh;rC:Url;eIIlJ trga. rcrmimlllll' fed non erienr CiUf ~ Ifc: ,I$l reali!~i C1 rermino , (",d CI fnndarncmo. Nee ell mitum qtJod in c~dcm ellrifatc: fcl:uiua multjpliccmll~ nlp(;'{tu!I. &. non pCEfctlicmu • cum tliam III n mutrirli'~u.~ c:,-;. ,e-nti.u .Ij,~t iprOf rel~'io. Ii, omnino idc::ndfi,;of~ CUItI drcnlia dillina. E~ lid iel quod oppOnitUi Contra il1l il1ll~nri~m (1:0 ncmplum didl!:!f nibil enineere; quia lica. Iy t.Df!lliA noD lir E.:cmima rdatlllU~ fDfm;'llirCf • c:ll filmeD tefaEio idqlli~i!r.k . ue lid, !)DP c:~pli~t"tur effi'nEia in oplltiw eDJl~t"p- . ru tcl1{ioni$ • pta::fupponiEU' '·ramen. & indudirnI' in ilia. Similiter pel fr:Clio.ctiam tcIa(lw,in,. cludnur in cDnCtp~n Iebtionis ~ fc-q non explic<llllf: in ordine ad Ec:rmjn~tioncm ~ quia folum eenUt;[Jit relationi ~ modo qno conu,-nk illi d~ & a(;li1.l1llfa~.q~a bonl.·!;t~~& paf~aio j~quiiur ~d ens ,tlon pron In pDteDfl;J • fed ptOVt fJI ~au • 1St. inelfc.Habcmus alm:m ngulam/Hra da~:I~ es D, Tbom.'l.S' dt pafttllilllt_fl. I. Ad u. qut1dqllia dIe [dilrioni, eft incllc • ncn h~b" dfe p~r (lUUnern;[d ;liiud , ftd pttoldlll~m ad fubi"aum feu fllnd:unc:muUl.Et ira. pcrfc:tHo ;. f~u e8"e ctlam rl>. latiuum non mulriplieaiur t qlli3 non opponimr6 nee compcrit relmoni {nb.. conCtpED ('xpfj~n(e oppoliliom:lU • &. t'Jt:cn:irium;lei tc:rJ1linllm. QM;lU! (odcm lDode IDqilcnduJlI ell dc rtlif,aion;- JtJa.,. au.a,oztqu:: dt= ... ff~ntia • quia a funeamcmo quod eft clkutia rum!,"! perfell/o. in 1I::latipne~ ~t ad ~fequ~num) de: fuhlilt.:nua~ 'Ill:!: lnulupl!car;ut pm1ril'IiQta rd:uiollt: ; dit;-o quOd ClIbfifiencia provt di!liflguituf :ili ~~i!lcmia. {olum dicit r~minllm n;\tU1Z pton inl:ommllnic:ahilem. inenmmllnicabilc autc:m djd~ oppohtio-nem; & lie: lilb irfo formali ,onctptu .d .. min. tiionis cQ_nrumi~ rUt fnbftltenria.. at(lu~ adeg non lniflliD" qllOd muliiplkc;mrin r3.riofll; • &. ~DIlCC=Pru (ubfll1ulfiz licat non in ipfo elf,. 'ell peued:ij,ne ~ ~ 11M c:nim ~bt=t fe: 'It reluio.P¢tfcCbo ;nntrn non di ... ~~ ijK:oD1mnniClbiliU[cm de f"net: I:ODIJ~it ldanOn4pfO'ft oppolit:l ~cm-diUiQD~ fN prc\!,1 {un_ in (UD fundamc11Io.& 1:1 hac pane blob" "niu'cm~

nOD mu1ripli(:alioncltl.· ..

Ad ot.unDnem. Rc{p.tbtt pto nobiJi'" prob;ltt 17

_ , ~ N ~M

· -.~ - .

~41. XXP//l.

quOd E'et:iet\'lc:; tehtioni$ inuenitur qUldcm, fed non mulu p Itcarut in tdblu pt=f(onit. C urn quo ramen n~e.q,~od telatiotctiam ill ipfo Ad)pcrt(:tl_io. aem hapctimbibiu.JII.fieut 6f. ["calituem,& ennratem , non ramen llIuitiplka.f p~r~caio~cm ,qnia fpfuln AJilltrinft:cc habet Imbibjrum Ilium fundamentu[l\ &' ([nun /1I.,5l qUidquid rarionc fund~lTicl).d fibi cornpcdr , I~d pra:re, fUnd:i!llcnnJlIl edam rangie r.:rrnill!1m vt con:~latiuum. ~t ql1j~qUid fibi ,ollllcmit pro p~m.& coa_fidcL:.Lt.IO~!: ragClIdi tcrt1Umlln,mllltlphcd~r. \Pt_ cit d~lhi1cho>J.: oppofiti(J cOI~d'ltIlJOrlimlqUl~qu~d aU[C pro parrc. & 'On Gdcut!onc fundamcnu libl conuenrr , nnn muitiplbtl.lr,q?-ia ind~oppofitiQru;(ll ~o habct;li,adn ipfo Ad. klnptr includarur , &. mnemsrur, liwt muenirur , & idemHicatur dCnti:1 , fed non multi p lic:nur.

Ad vitii'nllm didmlIsprobue nollram conelulionelR p,o ea pam: qua non multiplicamus pc:rfC9 tl:iones edam rclstiuas, & etiatn in lPCO Ad , qUia ~:rf~aio ~(lmpcrit iff. AJ,vr fl~nd.ato • & rari~nc fud.:lm!!mJ,llon vero eJ:phcamr In .pro Vt rermma-

[o)(eu in erdine ad (ernlinum. .'

:,8 J\d prirnulll pro demelltia, R.t:fp. quod !ll\lIri~ pljcat.1 C11ttr~t:: rnl.lltipli~ari debe! quod ad e~m Ji:qI.HtU! I dillinguo ,Ii lcqllillut fllb ~a formaliu. re , & c()nlidcr.uione qua muhipii(~[lif cnritas. conccdujli lub C:L qua non opponilUf ,n,i cli· filnguirll!,(cd identltic~mr, nego_ Perf;:o!lio ~utern (cqUitUI relationcrn \It fUnd"t:l,(ll • & ex pane fUlldmu:od, .... t aitlult' c.l.qlli:l ind.: habet dl(:,& ~Cl:UJ,li!arcln. ~ co nlcqllcter pC1'fcctioncm JCX P;Jfte autcm fund.lnlCmi n~qul; oppofirionem hJ.bcf, ncque d,llinCtionem.EI lidi relacio ad3·quat~ , &: t:t olnnl p.ute l1'Iultiplicarcwr.id eft ,um ~lI; p~ru:: fili cl)rrC'!atiui,ql1~m ell: parle (ui fund3.mcmi • t~m ~x parte oppl'lidonis, qulm funJ,\fionis. bene {eqlMctnr m~Jltiphca[i pcrfcdioltl;S ; fcd in diuiDis rdinio (01u111 inUilip1i!:;IlUt vbi obUiat oppofilio j ideo non amphu§ estenduur illa rnultiplitmQ. quim C:Xt~lIJltUr il1:1 oppo(i[io. &; lie quaOtlH1ICllmquc ;tIll prl:!dk~t;t idcntiliceneur • vd cllnLquanrur • aut imbibamur in fd~[ionc J fi :td jIb, pro (ub(unt fua: PUCillOiii , &. fomuli I;.nioni, non extcnditllr OppOfifio. non vllia in-Ferte, qnod c:nend:Lmr ;Jd ilLl muldpliClrio; & lie in ifiisrcilriol'ubl.ls dmlois facile! ~mc[]b peccanr falhci3 .. ccid~Jltis • arguendo ;b his qua.; Libi c;ornpct\lnI, in qu~n(l-lm dj1lintb.:, &: appo"!% {unt,ad e.1 q!l~ Ubi l;ompJ:funr.vd ah-(olllte.vei in qWI'IiU!ll non oppoJit~.Concedimus ergo (clatioDC$ dfe m:s rcs;ve) trCS c:ntifarc:s op' paulas u~liltiue-Jquia oppoucio rl!ollitc:r.& entitatillcl exc:tcc:tuud terminum,nllPnd:c;&: "cedi vt QP.lin. t[:~dtl • & -ad tcrminum ~a1is eft. Cztcriim qu~ndo (;om:cdimu! bas r6 effl1 bonasJ& Vd';t!;J 8; pC.lft:C4s, nOD ramrn dfc= hofiaS d.icimus pt:rfe~ tli?n_e.'1erita[~>allt boni[a[C mnlriplicara. Cc:-d caM. ,1lI.a. In bQnitatc.& vertf;1re non OppOIl Ulltut .Et fic : ~ttttb\lta CbDuenillnt tdarionibus • feu rtaii[ld.:t liS oppcfids. "donn oppo{itc • qui3 in bi~ nOD

tU~ c;Qu\:htto:(icl1[ ~iam e:tdcm cfi"cnria & fubIbDrt~~ di?inimc (ublbntiales • &. 4'\iuj~% Cllnr. CJUlil 1n.!l1hU:ltlri:a. & Dtlmc oppc>littoncm non n;~ccnt. V n~e ad Conf. feu inlbl1tiam bllius pri:12rgllmeml, R.E:(p. ll~Od [chilO p~OVt ddlincb.

o_rpt)(it;!. fl.lo o:orrdatl\io, d\. c;ap~:l; p~fe"'·o .•

r..... f1: di -d d I! -.<1 m"

J .... non c: cap.ll[ III en i ~JcfiiCfI~ . • •

c_ ". 6 ' -. ~> ,quia III

ca nOn QI. op~ouuo, 'lit 6ltari(J VI dilHnftll & or-

~o~ P~~~tll;~ ~lI~a~ diuini[~. non 'ramen ~ 6!: d.1l1dt~t dtl~nn~tcln>qUia !!On poteR ill

oppofitiq.Et c:um mfblur;rfO\"t ic.(i:U.vt

9Je R el4tioni~UI diuinil.

oppolha.eil: tapa:!: pe&Woni5icrbo eil capaldi':' flincb: pe,fe.d:ionisj ncgatllr confeq, qUia vt: elltt: capax dll1:ind:~ perfeCl:lOni5, deberee ,lie clpalCdiuidendi perfc-Ci;ionem,&; ad hoc nC:l:cfie-·cr;l,t facere. opP(JfitLOne in ratione perfcCl:ioniJ. Diciturerga pran difl:inch,capax perfc:aiDnis,quia retinet ,& indudir illam ) fiquide includie [ual11 tcalitatff. red non oppollit illam, neque in vi oppoutionis Warn explicat,[ed (olum iucludit,ficur indudit diuilli(1I4 rem ,& r:uiolle cntisim:reati.& (apicn_t & ~t~l'niraris.ncn ramen habet vim opponendjjlla;n~qu. in vi oppofitionis cot(elatiua: i!h. citplicar.lidr incJudac,[ca fohlm cltplicat [prom AJ.~c~lC:tn6 flail t~(po=au termini in rdpiti~ndo,&" ilihil ampliu!.

Ad 1.conccdiiUl\$ItJ 1 Jl:mum T rinitatis • :atqlll! 19 adco non lalum Yilimil elfcntitl!: ~ q,Ioad ;l.brolut~. jed ip(~5 erisrn pcrCOti.1S qUO;l.drc:i:tdlla pl!rfcGiig.

n~ lli.,rl!,(ed nou !\1ultiplkatam,ftd c~ndon,quz adomii~s rcrtin~t rclationes , omnc(quJ: pnfcdu rcddit;fcd 1'10;-( dillinguir l'ufelliones. quia in illis non fie oppo {irio,&' corrdatio qn3ttlllls pt'(feClio~ nes :i\f.E~ a~ i~{lanti:i qt~3: ~rg'tut • ditoquo~ p~tctlll[as • vr dll1mfta l 6haflOllc, el! ferfet.bo III Dco,dHlillgl.lo,pmeCliom: oppofira, &: dilHnCla 1 perfcfrionc !ili.niollis, nego t perfstliont non op .. poli[~.rtd id~nrlfi,at:l cum pufec!Uonc filiatioilis, ceneedc iSc petfeaio quam h.t bet filiatio.vt diffiL1" th ell pc{fcctio lirnpli'itl:t 6mplcx. fed non cit pctfeltio dillin£ta. Et fie 6liatio "r dillind:a in f;1" done 61£1tillnis adhuc Il!tillet , t,c itidudir pnfe~ d:ionem'hon dillin~li in rarionc perfecuonis;. qlit. nee oppofir.lm. Vnde Y~riarin iJliu! panicuiz ~i df/1intla,q~£ modo cadit rUpet 61~:u.ioriem difli?-::thm,moao CUpCI' perfc:tllonem dillint.hm. 'lana!: ~ppeUationem;ficut inltatur ilia con(l'quc:tlti.z. Pa. remiM ve d1llin(b l filiation!;: dl: Dc:us,(eu dl: m.. uina:crgo lubet dilbnm. ail.lini~:ltem a fili.uione; conlcquenria non vale~ • Be ramen anteccdells dt. ccrtu m , q ui.:t p'lrcmna! Yr dittinCh iI. filiation!: eft: ells filigulatc.& dereaninatum, non ens aelltum. ergo ~buinum .• tdem ergo de pctfedione didmus. Vlcb S S. Parrum ptob'lnt rdarionc5 lid pttfcttionem Dc:imis pcnint[e,(eclnon:ad 4ill:incbm.p_i .. dum ~U{C: D~mafc:eni.qllod P;I(I:r, I.'( Filius peril:<ltionibu§ pcrfon:dibus dillinguunrllf nOn fie inur:nhur in ilto loco citato 1 SUM'·:;!. fcd dicit quod In_pr~priu~'i.''MI pamnitat;r. & Pf;lJfilmil.& pot:tffil}nil P"fo;;~;trf;aiau(1n T id. rfl,lXifltndi ffl1'J1I7!J dg11l1ftitIJlIl.Vbi Damaii:tnu! {ccxpiicauir quid no~ mine pOtfct"l:ioois inrdligat • ('III,ct ~l;iJlclldi modil!q!lod vero ilh p~rfcttio rd3riil~ rnulripliccrnr. ne( 111 nUlTItto plurali rtomintrur,non dicit. Ad Jn~ CllJl1 eX cpiH.ola Ag.lthQnis dkirur no; edam f,mti erre diuimt<lIC!il ill nibu~ 'p~rlonis p.o:rtctlis,imo &. diuillis,(c:d non dillerfa, lk mu1tipHc:au perfctl:fo.. nt,ficut nt c n'lul~iphC:lta diuinir'IIt;:.

Ad ~ .Refp .dIc: ms fllbLitlmtiaste!atiuas in rot-" 2.0 ticileteonini jn,ommunicabilis, Crd'mills pc:rfetl:ioniscomm·.micabilh,l:riam retmiI2.quia parearo td~di1:1 commtlniellbilis eft, h'porc 06 0PPQ-

!ita io gcnerc pc&d:ionis. lit tic eri.un ues (Ilblillenti:;L: in qlIantii i!lI:ollimiU!ie3biles, & di!Hntlz imporrlnt paf~a;on~ .dillinguQ( 6, LIE de rduio>nlbm ditl:imtirnus) impl1rnlm petfo::tl:ion~ eti1i in,ommul1kabilem ill ratione pc&aloni~.nt'_gO •• 6~ mLIDicabilc:m in mont pe&a:ionis,licc{ !ub6,l.E;(ia,&: tdatio,qua:petfel!tionem inclpdit inl;amu~ Jlk~bili$ fit in raDonc tc.(pe-d IlS , & tcrzni!uElOllis~ fed !louin rarion~pcrfcc1iotlh,wmfea.t. .. _ -

Ad 1: Coni dicinms qllQd fi eWer rna t=\nllltn {lIhGJimth. ctretpmcGta.& modo t fl;:S fubljllentu;." Jtbtjgll~cti~ pl:~fc;~ (\JUt. Ltd no~ 4iW:fll

. ~ . Dif}lliittio X m.

diuer& ~~fteHone • fed eadem t eo qlio8 in ipfa fdcra!~nc ~ppalltiD DO~ ~tt. riCtlt Ii c{f;:t . voa (ilbfillcul1. efI~tl)CU5.& dlUlnll;C!) modo [res (ub~ bJl:c:ntiz fUiit diuin;l:')[cd eadem dluinit:m:,m:m dininc1a.&: IHulriplic.ata j quia nee oppollra ; idem ,u-go etitilep~rfcdiofieet~;tm g~neli, n:lalitli,quia

)11 Col non exercemr oppolHio. .

Ad 2. Conf Rc:fp.eodemmodo. qllod ~don~ in quantum dilhnCl:3!.funr pc:tfl.'dz~l!:dnQn perfediuned[llina:a,&: [untc;apJ.ccs iJ~ntific:lIionis cum c:ficmia.qliod vtiqu_t: ~a.Jtima peifc:tUo ell, fed flU per ddl:mti:arn pcrfetl:,oiicrn funt cjp~c.e$, red per eandi.Ec quzlibc:rpcrCoilil Vt dinint.b hsbee han~ m~iiim,li!n p'erfcctionem.& c:unfc:rrmam. (:d non ~nfcrt perfe'kionemdHmil~'bm 3. p~rfdlio~e l:~. IIIS;&' adorantut atquearn~niur perton:t' (ctudum Cju"dplures non mulripli(:~r,1 p~rfelU()IlC'J& bonl' tan:.e dam rdoldu~.~ comrnunu;ata,ftu communi (IIDnibUh

Exij1mlilJ n; 1i/lIltiplirsfnT in ralltimiFJJlj.

3: D £" fund.1m~mis 1;II9:j~ {adle p«Crlt formati i udiciu de aliqmbu5 p{~dit;;ltif, qLlZ allC Ir.ln((:end~~ ti:dunt~;llltilli~;znnc:x.l.,&: limili;z an mnbiplkcnlllf ad muhiplic.1lioi:u:mrc;aliumrtladonum in Dea.lit otC'Urr!r primo tlCilienli:l,~u~ lk~r inc:r tnnfccn: dClitol!tli non numcretur.cnmmcrearuns pr3:dicuu. comingelU fil,tamcnql.lia cmne enH~alc & qPJJ: illiui,& fi dlexrra c:n:!lag.habef iII~m • medrD de: illa agimu5,licut 4: tr.m(c.c:~dellt~Ii?9S quoad. hoc Functum ~n multlphcetut In dlUll>l~

Er (ti.rponimLI~ Vt I:cHum,in Dee d.ui exil1:cn- . ri~l11.blolu!5. vnam, quam male aliqlli cum (ubfi. jlc:nti.lc<mfulldtntes.,n,golunUJII darl in D&:o,ji.u~ J1c~am plqique dad vila (lIbfln~tiJm abf,.hu~, fcd !Ohlin rres rd~!iu.i~.5I:'d c.: (ubbltftia qmdquid fit ~n con,cd~ndol yel n.g:U1,d.l G~ ~tf",nrj.djtc:dn Dco, ~arnc:n de elti!l&:!ld .. null" modo ru:g;lII pot,:ft fineC:UOfe ,cum nominc clI:ili(:nuz intcllig;amus ~Ire CJ.uo aliqu,d ell CJ;tra mbll,& [!:ttTa puri pullibdime in .(tu;&: fide iUD<tv[ vhimu~ in ,arion;: altus c:nrimitJI,quia vlrrmum -luOli IDf!::ndi[ lIgells. crt dlt:, id ell, pontt!: rem adu in fe ell:Cr.H·.'Ui~S. vel Cl:[r:l nihd.[)l:us autc:mJccLllldum effendi fua abfoluum dl t:iU l f~,it~c!}~~J. (dp(q QECt omni pott:nrialit3 re, lSi. r;Jt ap-a lilhil;, & {ie exil1:qc in Dee non ell: pfOl:dic:ltum cOlmngem,{cd inrrin(ccii ~ cJf~nlia.k~crgo conu~nit dlemiz ICcundum .b(oluu. ration~m coolidentor.quz etl. e05 3; fe.& tt: (~tU nillens elfenti.:lHu:r~ ratione rUi.Et lied.·, citur iplilm dIe unqna nomen proprlu Dp £.XQd., 4'£// [10m 'Iii rlim;Ji...fjitfl,mijil"mrlfl~. fillS,.

It I Di6iculras ergo eil.an pr~,cr c:s:jlkni~m jllam abfolul:lIn.quJ, ~lfC:nli .. dUiil1:uR: I:'D~ 1 (e.q:uocll b~ rclatio,licul eft ~mir;lS rea lis ddiifld:a olb ah,uth,. nonc,m t.li.:lm di~inaaui~ti:trdadua,ka quild 6,ut funt tIes Cml(:lrc:s realcs,lEa Hnt [rcs c"iIf~d~ Idadll~:[n quo multi Authotc:s.qui t.Cneocel'iil& dina dTe allUJ.q\lam ~n$ aCEu, ~"tT;1 nibjJ.~c :Diu per J<ltiO!l::'ID di mDg,:,~ drmri~(n;lb c:xificlJeu~ fem:r t:rra!ll mDlriFli'.~l elill~aJ tc!;l1iua.A!ui:J. mulriplical1tnf t[~i I!:ntitatc:s [~31~$.&: aduale!.Ell: {toteEnia P.S~!('z J.i1111J1l ,.p.d1r. 'S.ftEl. 3. lid J. Jifp.J l.PEl.'.dtfN6.(ed.,.& /lb.~.d~ Trjni;.IJ. [. &./;b.f .tap.i.adlun~ti$ hl~ qllz .dr.J~.t til!p.; utu'iJfph.fiU.".dr: indiftmdione, dieD' .:1;.& niflelUj~. ~aJXI (en(~liJIII'plu[~s <c:t B.~,~otjo(jbus f~ quunmr.EtM.Mt:rl:m ;.p.'l.~· "·I.l.{;onccdic tn:s exillentias rl:!atiuJs "" <llio fulld;LlPl;'lltO) quia cxillimat non difiingui cxifitilu .. m it lublilt.:ml.1, & he. n:ul!iplica,is lilblillc-lUiis rd.<tiul$ .JIC~([~

}1Jil_'!.iI S. Thflm.;lJ J.!iUl.iJ. 7 tJ. 'T "!nUS a;,cr,

Arlie •. II/. '''1'

(e cr\ riliJlripliearl· ~liil:~lJtias. sed t~meA n1ed~ {uppDnimus (;~Hlcnti~f)1 non cflc idem qQod rubliftelui~m ,(etl diuc'rio:. dfdlus fQrmalt~ ~JbCIC; exillc:ntia enim ponit rem extra uuf ... ,; leu c:uc~ nibil.!ublifh:mja, [~tmiriilr.&' complet nruram, lit iit per fr:~~ non mallo, Be Ii lie Lublin~nrl~ comf'leu ., & Ctlppofitahs. f.!~it iliCOmtJ111nicabilt~ naeuram, Simili,er eXIlrc:m:ia inuenuur tam ill. luafbmia j qulm in accidenre ,rain in Ipblbnlij~ complerls, quam Illctlmpletls. (ublif1erniJ (o[itni til filb (bmw complftis, (~U p~r (e ~illtn'tlbus ~

(rgo non Cunt idem. " ,.

Cotlirati~m (c:iitcnria'tn t~n~nt commuDiccr lUi U.

Amhor!:s q\11 dHHngunl dl~nli.im a.b exilfeiiti:i,& per cXll1enri;lm (ol1m (efl(iunr n ill ere pmt; ; 1% quJdquid ell in tOmpohtO, t'fi:nn rcncnt i~ D~f) non rli!l:ingiii Ire. relOldil:iS extfienria5. [ed vl'li~ ca eatnd:!: diuiii~ el!ilteiltl;i omni;i diuiWi el!Hlef~. Et hoc fcquu ntur Thomilt::.:. qUI (~l1!iUfit exm&:nfjam dutingui ab eo, 'liillS &:11 ell:il1cnria; n=c mulriplkal'l ~xifre"iiam iultra quarnC!ilIiqUl:: end .. f.1Cllm di!linaionem.Hos Authore~ adduxi py~m;l. mn~ dl/p'i.,m 'l. §. 1;1 Ijla dIJJitHi",r,. it prztcrea ~:t Autho~iblls qlli f~llenr uifl~miam non di{Iinglli ab rndt;:uc aan~H J ~dhuc in dillinis ne~~il[ iux(iI ~r~s 'nti(~~, rc:laliuds debc:tc: mnlriplicad cxtlltntias rclal[u~s,f~rl fohim OdDe(C' vnum eire. Cl.t!od (c:npt V.l(q~Jt7. hit: d'jp. n.6.tJiP'~· &,.Rui7.djrp.lf.f(U+:;,~.'t Gran;t_~jpHM£J.j.dlrp f. fli/.J.qui ~ddu~un( plUtC5 c;t. Th6tnill;is.

• H:e:demnda fcnt('n~i~ dl: ph~e D. Thorn. qlli t. J m 'j.s.dt pgwma.p.,/.l .at/. hUlqlIH; In d'1iI~'" nM/.

I" mudo ~ {1 tiP, mji (jJroll;' • ftt:l# ntt: i1f(tOjgty,~

1I1ji l7lul/tUsu. ~t inf. Nul/II mJt) (t)hudtmiMnJ

~p '111M "Ii,.J jil '1' 'Tlll'ltiDn;J 'l1·di.'rJtJ ~ fiIIlilM tJltmi.t; r4ri"4fflt1n tIM figrrrpt4l1/p .ft"

tjfr quia, ~ I}I ,ttt;id iffiqli1lhjl. Vbi dH1iogulr

S. T hom.dc elTc qllllQ .:11 t'xillerc " &. de ctJ{:nti.a,.

ku qllidll~rc .qUit' ~Il ratio; feo qnid. 3& ~jIl!lcmii didt. non cil,= ~1~;Jm in rebdoluPtIS. qulm in dJcthl:fumit epi~ elf.: proVE dl!lingult!1f i quidirate

(~u (.'UcJ)!iaz, qu~ ... ft ratw,Etm 'I'f),ill F~ljnt~lI~

f ,ad 19.6; ~it ~ N,dllJ _dO&l1lfWillld1<1ftrjl ,q1<dd

J/1 dillf1ik fit rip -rJftI.m ~Jf~ ,t!Hn; tJf~ {t1i'Ftr Ad IffU1ti!l~" p"tlnta, • tfi p.-~I:'pll; in D,~ ; 'inUI if-

fo 1ft filII Ljfoniitl. Jl.dall"flt4 "11;071 'Ii';. JIjli"~ guunt JHPffljiI4i"dl~miJ .114" Addk(Ulif IIJ~ud tfl Jilfty tJJt 'Jfomi~. qHi~ nen i,,(ilfnt t(;mppjiliotm~ tllm rJlfhli,a ,'VI d,t/,.m .fl. Et(.ondudi.:D,1O"fif4l' erg" J~"md;'m efJ~ jfl],murpJ""41:,;'tt7fl {1~fp"jilllFilm ,jif:Ht it ,41~m /ir"l ~Jfefl,.je;n . rlbl "'tilltl.

N tllU'lIm lI.,rtm ,,; J,,,,,,u. 'l.!!o loco apntimma loquilUr O. T hO'l!'xdudcfl~4illintb; dlr; a n-Iari""" nibil!! difiingut:fidbli~ Itrppdira lndiUinis.« "nti inmim dl~ ,onc('de,~~. Et J.p. ". 17.01• ~. "il J.

.a'un propp(uitIel ;lrgll,m,cntl'ffi;.qU(lO ill Trinft<ltc qU.1nJllh fillt ~1n pc:dQnz • ell taiIicn 'l'nllm drc~ pr(lptct vnir~tl:m na,rl.it~. &c:JilOnd~. qWJd 'jN'" Ffrpll~ Jiui,;a rjl idUll ,'~m n~/lll ~ 1<1 perfimu dJH~ i1.iI,mm IjI".UIIJ ~JIt fufon~ p,.ttc7 tJfr '111111.711.;& fJdr.

Ius pup .. " fla4 b"bmr mfi 1!1l"fH ,fft. E Jfor IIIIU",. tripl~x fffi,p in fi4 t 1ft1 "liud tffi Ftt ji;,,~.& ,tltlllhjJi lI'/tlilTjt,$['d)i dJ.r~urili pct!c.nisahJ,lddfc ab dfc I}lIt!itz,IUnd c:ile; redcm •. lc $:'Jl~r rdatimlm : ergo 6.. ncg:upc:t(oI1IJ (Urlel!. ~(Ii: 'J,tlQd h.lx:rmt ~ fi eli· filngUC!fCrtlfCarudfc ab dr~ narur~ > Dcga.rciuri":,' plex cJI'~ IdatIUum.Nc, PO[l:1\ biclclp.qqai(qvod a1iqlll dll:Um}p.Tho.[umere 1, ~ff~P[9iubfiileJ~;;

&: ho, fuptiiltrc itlundir quod iu "'nu il1namrao e Comra cnim en • ':I.uia D. Tholl). didr • quad Jft' C pcrfonz oon Inbtm nin vm,ID cife, 6 .aUrcm (!JA < met« (fie frQ fllbhtluc, f;i.l!i ~ffc:c ilIa CldutilJ~

:N 1 q~

,<

}08

~4!. XX'V'IIl.

,..s' '

"llih ttes~perrOtl~ etli fi!1tvntlti:dnirnafub~aetltie. abfolufll;t:lmen IIcre (unr rlmesfhhfil1:~n.rl~'rI~!a'tiU3) ; ergo [umic elte pta exifl:cnlia,v~ ddhilg~j~ilr .a (ublitlcllri<1-. E:t p[:I:tCr~~ falfa dftt dia ,o~~htlo~ 'nalis,qulI1do dicit, quM cll~[ 'rripl~% elfe 10 p~rfotlis,1i in ciseHCr: aliud ctf: ft'r(ona:, ~ natura:.: faceree cllirribunc (cnrUIll • qUQd ~lfel [[Ipk~,fubflll-crolll periollis,ii dklaliud cITe p_ct'(ona:, I~ cft, fubllitcre perlon:!!; , 6(. namr~. fiqu~deln Utllllr cG. fc pro (Llblift~t'c : hoc autem 0YOIUnO fal(a~ .c.lt ,uode:lfcr triplcx (llb@creperfon'itrtlm.~ dllbn,gucrerut cae pl:rfona:, Be 112tUrre:llec emm vlb~ j;On(cqu~riam h.oc h~bedoque~do de ~lIb!il1~ntl:l. Cl)m modo lic rriplex Cuhfi!l:elit!:I. n:latlU3, erlarllU idem lit cae n:itllr.e, Bl ptr(on(C ;Cublii!erc snrera ab(clururn noll exhoc cfi~uripb:;quia elfe peefonI!' dillinguercmr ab dfe nature,

~4 Fundarnemum huius fumimr ex duplici ptillciw

pio• • ••

Pritmun ell: generale ej !pro cQnct:pru eXltlcntt:t

(wmdllTJ"l (c~cdi YC C0I111lni5 elt crear,e, 50: inereat.r .lk~r~ppliccrur m~iori vi uil1:c:nti:t diuiJlz:

SeCU!IJum el1lpcci31im ~x conctptu rdatiQ. nis vr orpomcur, /}t. dilHng~lut i (uo correlanuo, fub quo concepru Mil l'(Jflunt .mt!ltiplkarc cxi~ lt~mial11j qUia lI;!;c non opponitur> {cd incluJitl.lr 'Ill'datlone q",ll: oppolliwr. '

Prirnum principium cli:plic:J.tut fit: QE.ia exf(lelllia,lell die non cotlcqui!ur ad cncitllem rei fccundiim le,au! quomodocurnqne cOl!.iideraram. fcd in rebus crearis (cqUilllf ;ld I;"JTfitauln iuxra filum fieri I &. produci , In diuinis ~l1t..:m leqititur cndrnrcif'l • vr ell: 1 CI.',I\QI1 lit Itt ab alio ; qllu exifI:~ntja habet pro c!fd!:u formal! pmll;"(c rem e:tll;'.:l. callf~s • sc 'ex-uil nihil; & lic con(~qJtitllr ad entitatml non abfolutc, (~d (ub illa forlnaliutC'. qua eg!e:ditu( 1 t::lulis, (ciliCl:t fubipCo produd.vd fub ipfo imprl}dlld • &,Ifc: Hc. V nde ad poncn~ durn vnarn c:w;:illemiam • vel plures • non debe- mus 3[[cnde:rc: ad vnirarem vel pilltaliutem entitatUm f,e,cunaum Cc .fed provt otdinatuf' in vno fieri. & in Vno product ,lid pluribus > ~ in VIlO elie ~ fe. & incre:uo •• el in pluribus, Er hzc ell m,iQ quare in crc~rllriJ !:lfc exiftmtiz {itp(Qprium fUfpofiri., &; in, vne filppofiro foliun lit vrium eRe: IIt!a:pim doter D. Thonl. &' nos ollcnJimUS pr4t4. tQmll JiIP. "'" tiTI. 4. qUia in ctearuris id

_ q~od dired;: • & per {e produd[ut • ell: ipCum f up' pofimm .. Cell ip[utnrotllm : PUtes cnim non prnduc:untuc pet Ce, led c:omproduc:unruf. Vnde per fcipfllID (uppotiril.nt h.1bet cde ~ pane~ verA C:~ iIIo. 3ur in i\JQ pmlcip211f t[e: • &: c::ti!llllJr.ln Oett alltc;m eft ~ conuetfo. quia jd qi10d primo;&' per (e ~illit !ill ip(~ elrc:mi~. quzeft ipfum elfe. qUia ell en.s a f'e • ira quod e1fe tIl prrediCJ.Ulln e!1imria-· le in D~o • arquc adco prith con.uenit ipfi I:lfrnti:l! • qWJ: rali pr.rdic:il:1;J tonfiitllirur, quam ruppotit.'" • q \lod conditur;ttn ejfcmiam- fupponi!,& tcr";

1nltlal:. .

~: ' ~x quibns confil!i!1lr argamenmm ad nOn mul..;

p. 5 [1p~c:\li~\lm cii.il:ctlfj~ rebtiu~. quia ill" plum CJlfI::nU:oe telatlu~. a'lllm lit plurcs t vel funt I'lxi-' flcnu2 .~re.ulC .. vel iDtJ:c:t{~. CrC:.1t:e cITe non poC(ilnt. :l.h:n p«f~;r elfenI entit:ma crelt;t; ill qoonrll!lJ; pllUcs • & ltl quantum reiUilllt,1i creans I:xifienli:l.$ !ubH.Cjl.[~q~od II~ bil:r«icum t &: ttpugll:lt

i. ~co qllQd .ahqU!d llll[31pfum njllat pet uiftc:nuam CfQram. ·lll.a:e,Jt:t.autern e:tmenIi2« ml!ldpli~nlt.r:ergo erUnt tri:l elf!: inac:l{a tclatiua· ~ fie CfUnt mt incrc:ad f ubllanulle ( in hoc enirr: fc=n(1l l~l1itut ilia fcmCDtb .• c:thn P(1IlU ftes e1:inenrias ~ IlQn _l~tirri~~liftcnles) ~uod ell: \gmm illud

..

-~ ,

~ De Rclatirin;6Hi, ,t/iui"y;

'Syniboli 'Athana6p'V"dnit;'~ im.;~Ati·i:"1t 11!~:;,J,.: 'liuitji·.fod'f/;im tnm;ttH!' Vn~c'P; SU3rt;z;~ib:~.'" Tfitlir.fJfp.I):.f1iJl7J+ non audee 'conaedertnnli!uf.. -nis tria incrca(a. fed VlIIl1n, qllia cITe il'1crec3tutb. conucnirradone 'natU'~J lJl; filbflantilC , qUlt c;OIJ.. li l1:itin fp[o elIe it Ie, k ell'Cuumclle per cill:ndaln. Si ergo non ih:bcr clln!;edinlplclC elle ieere a rum~~ nee triplet eXt lbntii lncresta re Iatiua,qllia,j y rd". 'Iin.t non dimin.uit de ratione incn::!ti.EfrUIO. elt) qUil ex-ifrcnrfa hoc ip!o quod inc~cara eft, elbplU. cdc lie, &: ipfa el1cntia di'jill:i : e:rgo eft :przdic;1" tum dr~Jiti~!e Dei~& non relariunm.teu notionalii': 'ergo repugnar multiplic;lti e"ilh,rtdam inc~earam. provr relarilt~m,& multiplicari in ratione inCt~t:t ~:dftemi~ ~ nili rnulriplicetllr in rJ.tiOlll: ipfius elfe

~ {c. atque adco in raeione altus puri, .

Secundum principhnn cxplic:arur fic, quia vt 1~ S.Th(1itl.q.8.J~ pilWiktirt .!r .. d Il.. Elfo,fm ~xiP'n.~

iiIJ ,(Jlt.t CMffellil rei;(,iMi f11i.'iquiim ~ft ttMt;tt4, tit

ad t~"m;lIum ; fld en ad {t,vti .td [1I.(m£lulTi. Er in

hoc t:omingir nugna deceprie oppolil:!: fcntemi~~

~ pr~(und.lta$ mi.r~ I'adollis p.Th?m:qu~ rchdo~

illS c~tll~rItl3m diCIt non ell:!' ad ahqutd,'lrli qdod Ilccr did pOmE ~datiwi ctntimriui! • qUil Cliftenti~ rcialionis 1.'11,1'11>1\ ramen oppofitiu~ j CUhl' fltio .. n':111 brcuilTimc redelldir S. Thorn. Ci¥lIi IflDQ, di" cens ,q il,~el (11m. 'e/~iiD /it lJ(ciatlJl il1 cri41"ril.~J!~ f1l1l11l; efl j,ujfo), fJilJ.t 'Ii jil1JtIJ mm ,p lUI. ,difld ft h4bm. ~od eft dic:c:re c:xiftemiam conuCflirexchrioni per erdinem ad (ubicli;um. non per ttppoli~ rioneilt ~a terminum • quia exiftcnria cius ell in fubicao,~b\m htllccideu$ inh:l:re:iU. tcrmiuIU aU. rem non ell: Cubidlum relarlenis in quo' pl)nirur~; [e:d c;1\; idcui comr~poriitl1r. ~3re eliJli:nriallcit fitrel3tiQilis.& hlC ratione did poffir relatiU:i,ooli ramen t:llrehtil.l~ oppo[lra • ita quodlitCtconue~ niat ipG ·.Ad. rd:nionis(quod relic dl) non ramc:n conllituitin cO AJ,fed In, !;lee ip(a induic'Oppor,.... rienem Ad,quia non Ce lubtt c:rga fcrminum. fcd polirioneJ",qi1ia G: habet,crga Cubied:ii. Si argo cxiftcntill ret~rioni5 non oppttnirur. nee teDdic.ad: ttITtlinum,ied inherer Cubii:d:o , exiftc:ntinditio ..

ni' notl' t:lflgimr principia dilHl1tlionis. qu~ ell: oppolitiordarill:t. fed principiil vnirati$, qaz eft

fo ndamsnmm,& r ubied:nt\'l~ V nde cUm in dillinis rebrio honft~ inha#r:nivl:!ii~den$, f~dfliblifh:ns~

& ad Ce,:iIIulro migis'l;xil1:i:nii3 cins -non' e:tlrda~ thl1 per modum AJ, nee per rnodn:n (1ppolicio. ni5; & lie rion diftinguimr, nee mwtip!icaruf,qui;i non (1PPC?nitut cOfrdi1rill~; li~h :\ffic:iar. & cooftifUar rdntione:lri inipr3 emirare: (ubfifrl!lHi. Et fic cum c~'rc;a[ oppo/jiiun~,licct multiplicctur rcali= rdarhta. & in ratione.Ad; nOn mulriplierut at ... Itciuia, qi\:t ipfi Ail canne-nit Vt ilih%renti 'I'd

(ubiiA:end, quia iriwl'ip(mn' Jd.!lt reale.jmbihi-

tur Itt. . ,

O!!od:lmrliIlHonJir:m~ror. &: explicator, qui:! rcl~riones in Deo liilbcm fib. idc:ntific:atam ipf:un 'l.7 elf~llfja.m diuiMm ,qu::e 't:;A: ipliimmet 1I:1f~ puc[-:{(nti~tn : I;rgo CX t:lliid~ti6'ilrione libi iptrinfcc3. exillenta reddumur ~Ilc iDa 'pc:rfed:illima • & in~ creato quod eft :lUUS PUfUf/' Er laud elf!: quo per id~nti6cil.tionc:m . redtillntnrtd:lriQm:s aiftences.

& in{l: politte in ltEll non .mnlfiplicarur quamUiD.'; Clllnqm:rcbtio eorcelatiue, & appolirine multipli': ccmr,quia hoc dbnyfrenmn Trinit3ris. quod ef~c:ntia. ~lIa~tum~u'm9~e, int~nrc"C:l' ~ t!fentialirct

lri rthttombu! Imbibtta • !phs 'mult1phcaris non mwtiplicC{Df': erga vcr~. &. proprie. &: innillfec;! reddJlIlnn l;ei;Jriont's exitlem:e:s > &: in ~tm 'P,!ti~, criam per exilienri3m nOn mulriplicatiitIh

ftd VD:I.ID dlmtill~m.. & libi idclltiliratam. Kd

, . iu)4

, i.

,

'Wi}ptltd'lio. X lIt. ~riir:.' ill. .' lio9.

qLrid ergo nee.eire ea Cuper.2dcli tt~s exilleritia'~ '8. vitalitaiis pia:ber. vt in .cari1e "[entire" in oc~11\

in illis tribus fcalitOltibw , qmc per vnam- nOll vidr,te,&c.Sic :ib eadem dIe dillinjtatis • & dIen,

Iliuldp~i,aralii, (cd fibi, id.entiE~at3m, rupptillUIl~ 'tia dl: 1 fc, ik abrolUt~j &. rddtioncs,cl(.il1uriUti:i,~

(!.If clI:tA:cmes! Allt quem eff~chlln formoilem 'vr muleipJicat~,peE !;dmrill.i.njcation~mtamen ~4

fad~lr1tr~le$'exi!l:clld<l: in tcloItionibu5, qua: .exl- 'idctttincatiom:mdu[dem:c:lIe, .' :"

lIemcs [uppOlluntur in vi fiu: intim:J: cff~fitiz • '" Bt ~d vhiinandDftai:!tiam,quod Ii (Ullt ttes re'~

dre lib! idclUificari! E, wgerur hoc;,quia quandCJ ·litatl;"s,funttrfa.eiitanihil, & muJuphcanir ipfu#l

eft:: illud ell'enri:e ita. imbtblrur, Be idcmificamr re-' extra nihil."Concedimus. Ad con(l:liuetitilffi': E.[g4

laerenibus, quod rcddit illas exiltcmes, {cd t.lmen inultiplicatlU' exiJ1entia.n~go. Et ad ptoba'ionem'~

telationes ipCa: noo pojfun~ cam dinidere. &: mnl- 'quod ~Ilc tnr<t nihil. elt dfeCfm formali$ elC.ilirn~

tiplicare oppotitiom: [Uil, il1qlliro. exifleitti:e ili;t: tiil;, coneedo,(i:d mulriplicato hoc dfcCl:u formalr~

dhlifl:,&: multiplklrz; QI1:t' vlrra hoc c!r~ id~ntifi- f~iL t(l~ e~iril nihil' ititrl~Jpli,a'~tfOfm:l.di,ainguoi ~:itum rc(uhant. {unene c"jltemi;;;: eiu(d:m r3tiow Ii itiuhrphC<'itLJr dfeClm forma!Js acbquatui. mlil~

niJ'PQtjtaEi~,& at!Walir;uiJ. ~ciJ'ra I,:~iltmtja con'l- tiplic~tlIr forma. ,oncedo;{i '!lIlJriplie~rflr elfeau!I

munis;& dfentiillis.an nonl5i Iune eillCdem laua· iil:ld,uqu;!tI.lS tamumjnc:g:o •. E{feal.ltetn CX'(fa nibil

li£ilris, & puriratis. fLinr ipllln'imet eJl(: acltl~ purl in tribllS [cl.ulonibU!I e!hti'cOul formalh"inadlt:"

cifcntiale.& repugnabit eodem modo itillltfpli~u'i t.j11;ltU5 ipliLIS cll\: diuini,nolJ adiqui!.ttl~.N;tm (:If~

~tq ue ip(ulfi c:lf:: fe,undilm [c. Si non Iunr, ergo di uinum ,ompleel:hur-genilS fcladuum,& abfolu.,,:,

non flint f;xi!t(:[ltiz illttc;ltz. &. diuljj<l:.fc::J jnf~- tum, &, db c::odem dre iftrUttique. gefiil$ C"onftimi~

dotes. q_ltia aliqu-ld minus de 'adu:ilitate hab:nt. rur in aau pura. V nde fumendo f(ihlm·r~l:uiom:g'.

q.,:m. ipfulIl cll~ Dei. Vbi anrern ell minus Ieu di- {eu genus relariuum in Deo 'non babet omnr;nl

minueio.creaeum dl,non diuinlitn. EiI:"lflc:tula: au- etL"'ilrn:ldll!qltamliiiHlil~ fontlJl!,quz ell exiHen:-

tern crc.u;c cxub.red(b::nt ir. Deo , & .ib.cius pcr~ til dluiru. E.c fie Beet mlil£iplicdur clfcQus ille:

ronis. fonnalls , qUi ell e'tre: extra nihil in rcLdonibu~ ..

2.8 Vnde foluitur fUrI!hmenmm ccmrarium, queM 'lllJ[enus fun'tre! reales ~ndt~uc!. non ramen ~&

(ohlm innidmr mulnplie,ltiCJnJ cn[icamrn teahum n~Gelfc mulripiicari .fQtmam, quia illi df,au~ in-

.in Dc:o. qll~ fioe rnldflpliearlonc CJ.i(lemi3; fia[t:" ;ld~'I.u;td fum ~i'PcaQ ip6lls. liCllt etiam ab e-a!..

IUIn PO[c!1. c:um exifienti~ non fie aliud,quIun en- clem aQionc .prrllilnc plures eifcaQ~ ill:ulz-qlj~ti

dras in <lau,&:: fie c\lrn jim phlre~ cOllmes in ac1tt proc.;dere. Er tic non jllferllrt~ mu1tiplicarionc:1tl

ilia: relariones.emne plmes ~xilh:nn;e. Nee eft 111· fllrm~, fen e~ifl:c:nri<l:; (cd id~nri6enionc'm riue..

,elligibllc .ql1()d n;ultip!icc:nt.ur. rCllitaTii in.!atio. dem f(jcma:.l)um ilI/Hribus (ulit"tibus. 'lniua1iJ

ne ..:td,1k Ilia rCOltltaS. ve multlphc~ta. firmhll : cr- petf'cClionis.&:: innnii.:itis dl,Yt OJtin.cS ill.as reali~

go Vt multiplkau, eft exrra nilHl:ergo multipilea. !!:'Hompled:a£ur. .' ,

tIlt c]!;iil:c:ntia.Gcut lIl,tltip!k~ttlr Iy ~xmlnihll; c!:' \~Z diximtls de exHleMi~ • diundnm eli dt:

fl: a!.ltem cl:rra nibil. elfcthu formalis eft cd- dumioDcj qlliadllfOltio-cll'ipbmerexia,miaptovt'

ilenfi:Z!. flondilcontillUit:l, In quzcumque tamen (ente'llri~

Refpon.t~alitare$ mubipHeari, fed non aCtuali:.. non eft mnltiplfc<lnQa ztcmiU:I. cti.aID daco quii4

~l£es, quibus iIlz en'itarc~ aCl:ualc:$ dicuntur • qUQ mu1tiplicttur exi ltenti;t vd du.udo. quia ;t~emir~

vt aliquid fit team;5,(uffidr quod Ii, a.pa:t exirten- non dicit d!.ltationcm ~~mdm • f~ '(iJjformirarclil

di in aa:u per propriam vel.:lluullCblll, & id~ntifi:. dllratiotlis per modurn mrn(lJfZ immilt.i.b.il~,li~

L'2t:un atluaIitaUm: qllomodoelJlJlquf: -enira ali- aueem vllifon:nitas .eadem;Q. in omnibus< i,Ui:$ '4~

quid nffiat in atlu,lUt lit capax e:tlll;I.'ndi,hoe ip[!;) 'u[ionibus.quia COIdC:1II cit immllra:biljras.

non ell nibil , Cd resle em". quia nibil nC'1ue cft : ' . , , •. , .. ':;. < :

aau ens, neque capaciratc"fn haber c~iflendi. ne- Yt:rits Jimi Us, inji",iid4'~:fonl1jtM,

que e:.:iIl:ir r:zrione[ui • nee pa' aliqllid-~ulnaum . non. multtplhlltJtlW •.

iibi,fed omniD& t"q'llgnar exiihmtlZ'. ~od aurern . ..•

c:titfu.vd ptr[O't","pet"ptopd;unuillentiam. vi'll Oevuit:ltc &iI!O Ptimo..: No~ rnql,r?Ji~Bu~e.; 1.','

pl!t' ;uiiunCfam, &. idemilicatalD rc:aht;tS eft. Vode: 'titas in ttibUi p«Conis,ifa:v.r {im VCJltatCSJ 1lC:f.f-!.;w

poteft mulrlplic.ari re.aUlas. non rnuitipliG"'lQ cxi- males UI![; tranf.::endt:lIr~lt;·$.· De vcritarlil.rQlmali~

denna, dummodo emnes tealira[tl IJJb d12. cltifU- qu~ cli VCl"i~ .. i; in~ognl)[a:ndo.aUt iJ;J,dic'fllPo non.

ria lint.&: cum ilb. idenrinccntur, 'I'd ei (ilborJi- tit CCQttOllCriia,qula r31is.Y~ri.~:coaliRitliu n.ot~-

ncntar. Ec ntm intblur Qll0d cxiltenda cit: cnS ria/ell alit! ii1cdleGhlsinH:lljgcntC,.«m<wifdbIJ~

:lcm,concediml.U ; & milhiphC-.illfUr pltu"tS cmi,a- Ic,feu dic:cm·c. ACtin ~ultcm,inttlfig.~i ~an (4

tcs in ad-u.dillinguo ~ mulciplic;!nrura partCOp- ill omnibus p-"r(o"ni~'~lujaeatle'm n:lillt.l imdklti-

p,Qfidonis cDm::.bfjU2'~'~n~eao. ex p~nc atlQ;t)jfa- U.1.. idfrnque in!clldtw. &: il\t~Uige'c ~I f;Ollue-

tu. nego. red fie mulflplte:n: a1DcmntUE eadem nir, ficLu PatEr, &. FiI/U5 cod~m \"JlQfl: F [OPllellur

;ltt!.l,:ilit3U: C(lltIprcnt:l1dlmte'omne:s.&: ptre;lDCcIIl Spidtum S.Lot:llri(Hllltcii.~ dl4io .. Gfit ad cxu·,z •

.aClulllit:ltetD libi idcntilicatam.l5t. eommunieauIIl eft ff"llCbdo qua aliqtrid.{~l;ful.:rl;'lJm:.e.Et h;c:c;

omlles afficiolltUf. ncuE eadc:m diuinime OnloC$ fit indin~~ i uib'ls pl;'l"u)[li~ : IS(. tic. (Ji vJla "c,iq~

"li:te~ rdariones f IJnE 'diilinz, & jncre:ac~ jnt~in[ec~. in dic~do ad e:nra. LOQJriQ. aQtcln leu diQio ~

c:tiam in IpfD Ad. Nee ~il inc(Jnnc:nicm c.tdan for· intra folum dtvn:l;' 'qQi:.i. folwPatcl" loquitUl no.

ma aut tcnninll yel ~iftei!ti:i . afiic:j plmet pilITes tionali[ri prodii.cendo V ctbum,Aliz PeUt;J~z non

aut cliriran:s, quz in II'nUni ordhUIlIlU'. aut alHs iOi:Juuntur notiOn:llit~. fed inttlligii.r dfenti.alitl:r~

iaentific;lDtUr,ficur ea,lem fiJb1iriemil omncs par- Er fi.:: eadem clhcrit:ts 10 cognof"Ddo;- Ljc in di-

m compolit"i tennimmut • & tadl;tn fotm;rinfo.- emdo in lribu3 ptrfonis: ,_ ..

Illannlt plutts pattcsin homine.& c:adcm e1i1tc:n- . Dc v~ltatc wlDf,c:ndClltali ~ qu.t non ~Il iai:~I- J a

tia e~unr, V( latt proballimlls pratJ.tdml1 1iI{l' + lcdio adill3, f!:d intelligib.ilicas pafliija fell aim~ "1'1.4. Ef fie mturiplkad po~el1 eff~aQ! formJI;" . Vt coglll:lfC-ibHj!.tft maiQr diHicQ!w.Et .IlIulti (:1:0-

.inad;t;quiltU5.1k poirfialis.vn<t e.lillcnte;forma a.d:r:. fCllt mllhipli~i' hane v.l:'~i(amn in mbuJ pCt.rCJ~ .

qilala.qlJ~ Ornm')5 ilIas f'Ufcs.& inadzqtJimi dt~ n15,quia dl rranfccrldcD5, & fJQ!t fUJlt uc~ «11.1,,,-

ti:U5 compl~8"ifur, flcut eadem anim;t indiuilibibJ~ rcs rda:riuz ., ,it~ ~ lrC5 vCJilatcs uanfcendtnt .. ks;

&; {pkjtu~li~ tam mulros c:li':aI.lS in elfc animati.. & tic Poue: 'ltd! dillintluln l!Jppotinlln i fiiio.

, N ~ ~

§l:!4Jio XXTlIIl

eft 't~r~ i:ogno(cibile Vt dillina:llm~ ergo di!lind;iI. '1etiute a. Filio cognofcibilc elt. iillia Ver!I:iJ. tnn~ Il;Cndcns,cognoCclbi1ita' ell. Ita Vafqu.hfcdiJfur. b.l;~'7'& S lIare:q ,it Tril1it,e. Sl.quo$ requltUI:

Alarcon tract f .difp.f .c. ~> "tim, 5 '. It u~Ziu; all~em n~'gal elfe tres vcrilatcs IIi {"!;troms Qi[P. ~7·elfp, f· quia eltj(t;hTl.~t vetit.a!~m ~Oil ~ffe ttanf~ndenta: lem·l!.c fie non rnultlph~arl re-allter. V~[qu.mouc tur ~I!: eo quod putar v~&itate,:" qU2 cJ:t: paaio,cntis, eJfe dcuoluinaricllclll cnrm(ccam prouem~nrem c,c intdlcdu vere cogno[ct"[1[e ~ /jt.. h~c denomiRada Inllkiplic~tur inlnbu.s rdiitlOmbu5. Suarez qllii c:KiflillJa[ vcdtltCm non feq~i 'natllr:un ~uc {uppolitLlm • (cd quatnCllm~u e em.ltatcm,hoe /pro quad filb non c.!l,(edre;JlI$:Ii~ emm ell: veta. Slln! aurem eres [el~rloncs, UCs enneares ver~ , & lion atb. Bt de ipro Filio Dei dicitur I .Iean. vir. VI jil'lJlI4 in nur« FiJio ejlll,bi~ tft -utriU '])em, ergo dupllci ratione darur vetu:as in FJlw, (cil. ratione liliationis.&: ratione Dcirads. Addo quod in Deo flint quinque: notiones qlli?IU defign~nrur per(on~, & i[1norereiJn~, (eu fignl6c3ntUt dluerfimod~. vr docer S.Thonl.inft·1"·p·.crt. t.&" 3' Ergo fundane diuc:r(am (ogno(tibiHt:tten\. quia noriQ eo-

g!lo(cibilit~s ell,qua lIliquid ii1nOfl~{elt. .

3.C:!refutTI D. Thorn,;lbfgIUtcccnCcc, tluod veriras in tribw; petfonis en vna t~nuJm. nec verhss pcr~onaliter aicitu, il\ diu~n~', V( p~tc~1 i1l 1f1l. ~ .~~ vrrlt"m.,.3.a quod addllClt dluci Augall.S.dc- Tritlit.C.I. r rium perfoni.r"T/J ,p Tll1lf.1JtTU44,. ~od licee poffit exponi de vcriratc clTentiali, non rebdlla ; tamen cum ibi Augll!l. ofic:nd;lt quod nonca: plus veriraeis in VOa pe,[o[la vel duabus • quam in tribus. videtur etiam cemprehenderc relsriuas verilate!." · .. lfdJ.t.qlll~ alias illis 1"1011 numeratis , non polfer fcrrc judiC'ium Ile veriute perronmlnl,quomodo· non lit plus v~ritati5 in vna pa[l;ma, qll~m in tribU5.fi plllrcs vC:r1UttS in .tiblls (untquam in vn~. In pr~f.;uo autem artie. ab(ohm~ decee D. Thorn.quod verita5,6 prQpric acciplatut > III dfui'ilIS tlfcptialitet di~itur. kdfohlm i1Ic,~pboricc ,;iF" propriati {oler vtrita, I;i!io. qU:itm!1S cit hlfnm~ imitatio (ui principij. (ciI.Patril. Si ergo veriras propri?Cumpta-in'Deo dlC-mia.lircr dicitur. & non nolionllIirc:r ,. v£tU:as propric non multiplic;ltut. ctiaJn(i muldpli~tntur cmiutcs rcbtiu:t.

'it 1':!,[io..hiliu5 ell: , quia 'It l:ltc ttadidimus fopT.

J.Jfp. 1. ~x D. Thorn. "criras ttmkwdrntalH cit adzqWltio q_u~&'m> &; cOnlmCnfuf:ttio feu imitado Id tUm (IiO principio. quod eft in intel! taU, feu cum [uo -originali. Eot quia i n D~ non cll: conu.s deriuabills .ib im:dlettu. \tel illl'dlcCl:ione: Dei, (cd idem omnino cum iOIdligcH: diuino, eft ibi liIIDnl:l, lJ( vniC2 vailas, litut vnuln ineelligerc identi6cUIlID cum omni cntimc dillina. Sed reh.~ tlon~ diuinz qU.lIJUUlIlclltilq_ue muldplkentut nan hW~nt diua6.ro ~zqJUtionem.& eomcn(uration~ COin imdlcdu. diuino) qui ... vnico.& eo-. dem modo idaui6cnlilt illi : ergo ~dem vcrit:1- tan.quia eandcm :alkqnationem,,& commenCuration~1'n halxnt • rcil.p~r idemitatelil. It~m funda!Jle1HWil "«iUlls huills fine lit ad%qlUn~.cum in-· tellt=Clu. uuc fit taDI) ~nriuri$ non 6&, am aliquid diud • dt vnum ~ &. idem in ltib~ rcl.!.tioni~ bus:efgo.Jo: Yerir;u~adetn. Am~cd.probaru,)qui; iIIud dk f~ncWntntum ~eri!:u.i;. in quo "ait;! l».bc:t firmlfnem,& Crn.IWGtnl;'ib lpartc tei~irll fit ens r:ttUmt&' {hum. non li.ftum • & bene funda~ Ulm in c!knd~. At [arum fllDlbmentum. tota fitnntn.~ connell!O ... erit:nis, & n«l:ffi~ ciIu COIlq~t Itiarionibus C1 etfenti:l.j &: a iDlIQutahiliQ_ ~c,& -fcCli,bi1iuEc{1lIIIllI.¥i1lZ Vriqllr: .:ft.ipfnm

De Re!flIionMm diuinit.

cll"c: atlus pun ~ qua dire, & ind e-p eti-dt'tl'ter~ qultlibet ... Iio.& immutabi.le in er[cnd",.Ergo rota ratio vl3!iratiStr:mfcendcnbllis [umitur. "" fllnda• eue in. ejfen~(a ': ergo non eft mulriplicanda v.eriraJ Jtlagis,qullU C'a~nda ip(1, I ktr JUUltlplicctLltrc:!arlo re:1lis perfonarum. E. :;, I'~ilUBd} ~!E v~r~5>& nonliLbs coufiderarl debet.non [olum raelonerel~tion!s, ... t tnulriplic~l:i:,&: opp<Jfi!~ aleeri, ie~ [~. ttOI'H: IPULiS rC:lhsc-Il<:, quod habenr, & firmjtat~ in eLfenllo: in tantlllll 1=11Irt1 rcceditlu ab eire- fia-o~ in quantum haberur t;11~ i p:mc rei, &: in tantum ell: ens.resle Vt dillitlguitur ab enre rarionls , &. Iill;o. in q:uantum cIt cap:!x exifi-ctltiz • (ell cITe rC'.1.o lis. Per iprum ergo eIre 'luod babenr pc,fona:, fune non Ji~ ,fed ver~ pcr(on:c. (Olo & ::1'(;1 DPpOHl!!) relanenum in qU;ilitum ell c;I.iIlens. eli rcalis.&: vera,& non lilb : Sed efi"e.fcu ~xiaenria non rnul .. tiplicalur in rcl.uioilibus diuinis , Vt oJl:cn(iIID en .. edam fi dkatur c;;iJl;cnti.t rel:uilll: ergo neque VI:-r/las rcrfolJ~runl multiplic;lmr qU:Uei1l1J dkullsur Yene, & non fiCl:~, etiam in iprot rcalitatc rcl<l-' donum.

Denique v~ri~as pcr{on~rum vc:l Cllmitur pro j lo ~(}gnQ(e,bllit~tc len imclligibilitatc pallilll' qua in

Ie cogllo(ci polhuu, vel pro rcalimc qua dHIin,gUllnmr sb enre fiao, &.1 rcl:ltionibllS ratiQnj!~

vel pro cornmenfurarione , & ad~quadonc cum

fuo originali ~ & cum iudicio vero ,quod ell in in-. reUeau, •

Primum non muidplie3IUt in perronis loquen..; do de inli!ligihi!ita[c propria ftlndata in ipCa (nEi .. rate rei, non de exrranva.quafunt inrclligibJles ad modun, ~lreriu5 : h.1:~ cnim non dl- ptQprili vt'rira. rei , rcd alico~>mi unlen accornmod.l,ta • &. de h~ non IQq\IHn~r. Prcpns aueem intelligibilira.s .. feu vc:ritas mulriplicari non pon:fi.quia intdliglbiliw {I:quimr entirarcm rarione hnmatedaliuri$ quam lubet,qUia fie proportionata cll: intelletlui; im~ rcriaiita5 autem non mulripllcamr ill Iclatiombm .. fed tit vna.quia pc:ttillet ad friri~ualiratem > Be earemiam materi z,fc:u potc:ntialitati5 • quod conuenit 0 co ratione ;taUS purl, & es tali hnmat!:riali~ tate problLlit D.Tbom,DculU dreiotdligibatm~ & irucUigenret1'l fopa QIl41. 14·,.",·1. Et talis P"-. fdtio non multiplic:itur in Dee. ,

Sccunq1;11f1 ~ (cil. tcalitaS v t diftinguitu:r ab COlt 6Clo multiplictJ.tu~quid~m in diuiois :rclarionibllS~ eta rub eodes:n eife.&: 6unitate qllod ell: drc ad:u£ p-uri, &: ilPrnut~bilita$ c:iUi. Realitatc$:lut~n1non q['U!1Iur I1C[;I: (eeundLlffi quod velUm dillinguitlll i fid;o.nili per ordillcln ad c:Jfe qilO c:xill:um i par~ Ie rei, vel capaces runt e~ilhmdi: ergo non !l1u1~i~ plicato hoc eire, nec immutabilitatc eiIu t non multiplici'!tur llCJ:iras, &. firmiu5 Vt cxcludit fi&io~ ru:m,

T ertium.fcil.commr;n(urario,&' ada:quado CUI11 orlginali vd cum iudido, &. mCIl[ura intelJelhls~ non mlllripliC:lltUr in rdadonibus ) q~ja yc:IiraS iD. illis ell inc:reara,& prima: Dun cnim creara c;ffe ~ rcn. V crit;l.~ autem prim~& incrC:ltanoll ell: lIlc:n~ {arara per aliatn tegulam, r~d ell: ipfa oRlniu!D-te"; gula ; CtG~ quia DeuscfHuus intclle8:us.& fuulU intdligcre non hab~t l'criroucfU p!:r imitationem. &. ad~Ll:!rtom:m cum alio.(cd per [e eft ('urnma."" ptil1l3 vc:rir;!ll. Aut ergo vl;rita$.quz mulliplic;ltut in rdationlbu$.cll verius prima, & inctcata,aut fe,undOl.&: a-Cat:i Ceu mc:nCuraea.Crear3m poneu: in per(oois,nc:f.ls dl:. fncreaum, &. prirnaID,multipli .. c:art~poffibilc; m:cip(e Suare:zid conec:dit. fal negat iDa c«p. 8 .ltIIm. f .quia vtrir;u prima ell: fllptc.: rna,&: ~c dl: drentialis in Deo; vnde fQlum 'on~ I;CQ;run: lum.inqlJit ) ttcs VClflWCi ~um addi~o>i.d

. elk

lJifPR~aii(J XlIi.

ell r~luj n:r. Q!!:~ii vct~ tlTe rres'rclatiuat,diininll31: 1iliquid &clllptemucrirate. Si cniro Iune eres v edutc:ud,tiu_,vel (afif in,cc:nil:, &: fit lune rupee.m:t.& non c:nt vn;1 fol. Yc:,;t.iS prima;& {uprclli:t. V d fant (:rc;;ua:,& bOE nOn poc(;li cDgita.i. Dtb«

ergo ellc vna. ..

Ad fUlldime:iiboppol"ira p~tec e:x didcis. Ad id

13 '1llod didmr de c:ogno(cibiiimre perfonarllm • di. .::imlu. quod !:agilofcibilir2s propda. quam ex {e: fl1lid.In~,& qua potrUfif cogno(ciJn fc. clfe vnam, quia fUlld.uur in eadem irtlmaterialirate; qua: ell radi:!: intelligibiliraltJ,_. Vnde rcpu~nat vidcri in {c In.am pc:r(onam fine aha, aUt df!;:rlnam Gne perfeWi ,'ilii:! c:ognofctbilita omnium cl1 'Ina, Yc dixi~ mUi pr.c,a.t,mIlJYp.t f .$i vao loquamur non de cogno(cibmrare propria, qUlin (c (unt imdltgibilcs, (cd de alien;!., (!II. pCHonnolaliu:ls eOIll:tptn~, ilk non ell v~ririU propria p~t[on.irmn,fccll nobis formatat& de tali non loqnirtlllr. Ad id qood dicit Va(qll. quod ... .:rifa~ qU;I; ell pallio ends, c:ll (olum G¢llomin;uio tlCtrinfcca A iudicia intdkltus pro~ tl'c;nien~.laterc(ponfLlm ell Jkf!"'; d'.IF.].. &: oflen-

fum ell hoc cere: f:t1(u,m. .

1+ Ad mo~iila 5.u~n:~ Rdp~n. Ad illnd de- n:~lit<lee qua cnuras d1l::l£ur veu. id ell non fich,lam re{pon(u," ell: .quOd (unt qmdcm rres fcalir:iltcs VCZ;#,& non 6£tz.non surem tres ycritatts.qulafufl· d;ime:nEllm, &: 6£mir.&s£alls veriearis, V-I upr001i UI; .ficboni,(ciJ ilnd tari(.Jni~.lInum ell:,Cdl.ctli: [calc.~ =tluale pe:t qued u:ecdrtab enee Jit1o, illod non eft !:;lpn. ClI:iliemiz aatlali~, &. fimihtC'r ImmlIUbjlira5 eillS. &. bee elI: vnurn in rcladonibus dlUi~ nj$. Ad locum ilium' .Ioan.vlr. dldtu~ illum nullo modo po[fe aprari (cnrcnfiz 5u~re:2l. quia dim dici, y, jimrui71 ver« FdiuHU.hit tj1flttK1 V,lf,. ibi non dillinglldl)[U'; du~ verirarcs, alrcr2 fiii~tionis~ alten Dcitads; quia in nulla fententia venras dli:ntialli:.qu~ ell diuillit:1tis, &: 61iacioills,qu2 eft }klCQPdjs dillingutmrur, fic!!t inrer eni::ntJ.1ID di- _ uihalll'& pufonam nulla eft di1hnctlo teaJi~. Difficulra cfl an VqltaS Ftcmitar~. & 6lUrionis lint diLlinl!Cz. non v-mtu Dei, f~ Dc:irat~.& 6Ii:uitlnit. Ex iIIo allttm 10(:0. in quo dicimr eJfe verum Dedm , '" vemm filium. quomodo colligi pollit c:lfc difrindas vaitatt1 p.aret'nlt3tl;fl1. &. lihafionem • omnino non vid~o ~ fed dicimus olnnino Dcum e!fe \lawn Dcum,& Vcfum Patrem, & V~tum Filium eadem vcneart. 'luz omni~ iJIa. artl~ ple:duU,t. ficur t:od~m cite • &. dJuinira[~ exifi.unt.

'3 f Ad vhimum Rc:fpon.illunorioncs non poRu- 1ale: plurc, vcrit;lta; imc ntqllt rlur~~ tmk~res ~oflulanhqnianon omoc:s fUilt ()ppofi~~ > nellf {pltatio actiua. &: l'iI.t~JjilU funr duz nodonrt. non lamrn du:r erniuEcl.eci:lIn tcbriuz. quia. noli tunc (IppoflSz. Didmu5 exgo. qllOd norioi:ln func quzdam no[:r,ft:lt dcGgn~ticnc:i7 quibus petfonu aut ~ quz ad penODotS p:rtin~nt,digl1o(cilnl1!r. Et potTunt dari pllJrc~ rub eQd = df= , 6:: cnriuu:, ~ nrime; liM ~ ~ont1~ fum plua. aUTibura. abColma, qllibu~ elftnti;am variis (oneeptibus figni. fieamlU ~ lite (amm ilia plure$ Vrntuc5.allt phml dfe balxmled idem.

3 & J)ifO {eGUndO I Donita! in ,elarioni~ diuinu

non mubip1ica,l1I'~ elf:llD~ue. IkG condnuuditiieulrmm non habet n·foprJiditlli:ofi.L':ndinllll cairn in D .. o non poilhcbripJurcs pctfedioncst DCC plm c!fe.~lil uwiuc • CJUiOl in petfeaione:l & dfe non 0pPQnunrnr rdariCDCS. &miras all[aD conumit alitm {ecllndihp 'lUCId ptIfetium • & ra~ t\Qnr. pttfcdiflnist "clfc : ergo" non {unt phltcs pc(f~ai4nctjn~CJ.; r1ul;'tS bOllimt5.Ad h:ec. boni~

,

:Arlic~ ill. IIi

US'" Ii!Q!tip!ic;:Lfetltr in rda·rionfu.o:s,debc:ief muifiplicui 'It incn:ai:a,& (ultlnJa bollitaS:li;t1'll vl:c:rea:.. t;'l "Chi etl ad rem.Summa aurem,& inacafOl lioni" 'las implkat multiplitari, turn qUia ·eIt ('Iln~I'r;;a pC'r·~ fcdio ; IX DC cmnem perf~ioli~!'h inclu1ilr. vncie: ~icit oIGillm f!lIrum.& non (alum genu! telathuim. (~d '~riam abfolutultl in'c:iJ:ldir, hoc aurem I;epugn:it Inu[dpliL~rj : rum quia bonitas inCte;lta. , ~ ·diuma., etl: vkilliu~ finis,ergo li lnultipliCltur> erun, plufC:~ Ifltimi fine~.qaiapILlre$ b(ltlitll'~S incrcatz,h~~g;. rem rt:pl1gnar:etgo.

~:i,rc olll ?ia. tr~f,cnd~nr~lI~ qu~. t'~nli~jii.E; .3 1" Ctln ratione allCulUS perfe:aroms. mulclphc3rJ nOll poJlililt • 'Illia hoc ipfo quod pd'ccHo elt, diu/na;

& inCfl'::ltJ, &. fumma perf~Clio e:Q. Be (ub bac 1'<1&' tione fepngn at rn ulriplkari. Jix qUQ [equitur .reaJifatem; c:micarem, vfiicaternt aliqllid ir (~U rC:3j :&:

enr , mlllrjrlic~ri polk quia Me de (UQ ~on~epni.. pc:rfcd:ionem nor) dicum in fI.ro fortn;'lli con'eptlJ~

ted feS. ens, Be aliq uia {(lIi.un important comm.r.. nimm;p,m rarionem entis • provt dicit eOntCpnlM penincnrcm 3d quid, feu lid poJitluum d~tum 1 p~w: rei, quidquid iIJ,ud fit, IlLle pcrfCall~} fiu~ lI11petfeClum, pou:nrrlle vel aaua.lc. lidlic:u'J'lud

fir. c~pax: c:zi£ltn~.lln re, fiue per 1?"0priam,linc P~ slicnam e"dtenI13m: flam hoc Ipfo cfhcs pmv.c:: oppOni£tlf fiihilo,Ccu cDei fid". Ef {reb hoc eotlc;,:...

pm multiplicari rotell in Deo , fed cltiften:.pei idem dfe. V num aueem didr indiui!1onm1. (Ie pri fllU!tiplicationcm enriuti9 lTlulcipliarur; s.: heCJ, ... cimus £rcs perfona~. Be diccndocte;. ml'llciplie.:i-

mus vnit:ttem. V nde aidt D. Thorn·fupya IJII~f1.6~ jl"f.~.Ad 1. quod vnum non imporut rariottmt p~rfC'ai(jniJ. (cd jfi(h\li6Qni~ , &; fie per: hec: quod {nlllr[plicc~llr vnir~, u vi r.ths ccmeptw • noft mulrirlic~ttlr pufc:Gtio. fed fol!~lIn lollilur in diai-

lio. Mulriplic:ado ergo td .. tina cum tiE qmlfipJic;;.

rio realiuris,vi OPPOfiIZ,fub qua oppofitione nod, cx~li, .. tur perfc'~m.'. nee: qnfd,ela~~ 6~, ~c:.~ .. a. qUid fi •• non mulr,phcat pmettion~lidt dJn~

rea lira cern (ub ratione: .&d.

Dlee te-tlio. NOll ell lDuIriplicanda infitJltM J j edam rclarina in pr=rConis, Pro infclligcnri~ huiuJ condli{ioni~ adueneadum ci It quOd P. SuaEez lib~

J.de T'rmit.c.t. t. 1111111'7' Dnplict=iIJ in6nir.2f~rn wftin.guir. Alilm ftmplidter in gen«e ellti;:,;d~

pro priam in vnoquoq LIe gcnete • {iCUt· de quolib« :lttnbuttt fmmdiim proprilltn gmus didmus c::~ infinirum . in Lila gcncrc:, licut dicimm wpicmiaM

cHi: infinitaJtl in filtl genefc ,& iuJlitiam in (uo,"'c~· Ergo limitir« reJa£iunes in (g.o gtJJc:" i~nic~!rnl bab~bun[ • &. eQ modo mulnpbnblmr mnm,OUJ· quo p~rfcd:iQ~ q!!i~ infinira.J ad 'llI..1nritarcm pcni-.

ncr pr:ffl!'aj'mi';~ E, fie qui 'Of!t:lldoor rnultiplitul pe:rf.aionef fci.arillo1s. vrgcnrurmulciplkjofCinfiImar~ • qui.t pCJ;filliofies db mulclpliC;lut: 6nitle non Cdnt,ciun Hon lint Cftatz. age ummtz.in fud: proprio' gl:oet~ ; fitutemm dici~lI! Vaburn prQ-. cedm:: vrraroinum intdktlionis infinitli=, Spirio-. [11m S.amom in6nid. Sed poni[ inRantiam Suarc::t

de ipfa (!:r;itlmria,qwm muhiplicat intd::!rionihnft 'tuia vel Cum CtClrz.vc! in'tc:ll:r:.Primum non po"

tc:ll poni in D~Q. S~ttmdum ponlr pluki aiften-·, tiu in,rtataJ > quod cIt abfllrdum. Et rcfponderi quOd crC2Eum, & iDCn~tum conlll:nif '{lIppoli~ tationt= t1l1.tur%,"C:llt e:1k genaabile vd COlnlprW

Ie. V pde non rnll!tipliamr nUll inacatib;Hli!ili!h~

fcd (olum conuC1lit ratIont= mtufZ.

'. C2:tl.'tilin nofira conduJio ~Wm tt appon. 3' tis principiis fIJPt'4{bbilitis.qnfa ift.6nllas el1 qU2fititu ptifc tiionis! ergt) non muinpuclOlOl pnft:~ alone non 19uJdp]i'~lu, ii#iniw:: ['¥;. ::=

. . .

altel"limiis perfeC1:ioli~~ etillm wlatiUiS n~ multiplicJ.ri • quia in cis It on OppOIiUliIlU: r(::b.tJon~s. mulro miaus oppOlluntur in inlii1i{~rc. ~Od ~f:Ie] vnum qnodqueamibunun l~fi~jlUm ~t, !e:I(HitlUm elt Ied [amen notllJil1lrlphcarUrIll cis Inttnir:u Ced eadem iI1Jini~ ... re olnnia in (uo genere infinir; (unt. Idem ergo dicelllU5 dcrelati~lJibus~ quia edi opponamudn ip(o 1d.yr cond:ltluo,ra. men in illfhlitJtc (ua:: p~rfelbon,s lion 0ppol1untur:,rgo non rtluldpli'Jtt.lr: Be iea in hoc; In .qLlO non opponunmr, a:qtliparant~r ~clationcs attn ~u~ tis. Spcdali~cr aurern 'Irg:t ?lC .llud.m~g.num In""llucniCfls. quia fi rnlll[lp!JcatctUt In~nlt:a.s telaliua. non polf<!t vna p~t[ona babere omnern perkCliOJ1.el11 alt~duJ. nee fotrnaliter,ncc emineneen &: fie aliq ua petfcliio c/fct in v ns, qll;I! non c=jf~~, in alrcr:l., Non ell'ct formaliter,qllia cnlit.ls.rcb.do~ llis P2triS non ell: formalitcr rclatio Filii,fta illi opponitutj& :!.b eadifHngllitur: ergo in611ita5 Parris rclatiua non ell: fOflJlalitct inllnit;ls relatillOl. Filii; :allis c(lC[ ~cm.& vna formalitcff'ctfcd:io.:l.tque IlJcQ non mulriplic3remr. No~ dIet eminenrer in vna quod in alter .... quia contineutia clJiincnti;l[is c:a,qumdo vna fOEIJI,l dl enunenticr :l[rera, I!< excedie illarn , 6 aurem lit omnino Itquali~,rt(m po. cell: eminenrer cOntiner{',quia ponpotdt (tIle crniI1cntior ilia. Sed Ii vtr:l.quc; habet (\laIn irllinit.1tem rclatillarn 1~paratam ab alia. vtraqucinfirdtas tela. tiu:L :tqu;l.!i$ eft. & ciufdcnl OIunino perf~aionis ill6nie;E: in ratione rdariua: : ergo non pord!: emineuter com incre ; vt non bene co needit P .S,13re2; lIbi foprii &.11. fe,l vel nullo modo continl:t pededlontl'll altenusin6nirllffi. a qua dil1inguitllr, vel 'OO[I1\C[ form;).liter, quod rcpugnat. & pondera- 111m ell, cum fotm~lIrc:r 0PPOO;tOtUf. Ell: itlulri!,li~ C,I,tionc ergo in fimt~tls,f<!q uitur pcrfca:iolle vnius nOn clfc ill alia. A qU;! ccm(cqtlcnria non fc ClI:pCdiltn[,qlti perfcd:ionc; rc:lathU$ doeent multip1icari, V Ink tandem aliqni cOlll;cJllnt a1iquam pc:rfccrionem rc:lariuaJ\\ eire in vna rd~tionc. qU;t; non ell in alrera.Sed ex hoc rcqllitllr, ncUtr~fIl elfc

. infinit.lm in gt:naerda!iuo , qUia tunc aliqlla perfed:io cIt infin iu in a1iquo genere , qU~l1do nulla perfcaio llllus gcncris illl dcdi: fcd in h3C: td~tione P ... uis non eft omnis pErfc:flio genens relariui, quia a1iquaperfc«io fibi de.,ft. {cit. p~rfetuo. &: innniril5 rcbthu Filii: ergo ncotfa ell: inlinit:l in generc rdariuo. Nifi fort~ diclmr'V!l~rnqu'!.Inquc ctIe innniurn in (U;I fpede. v.g. fpedc filQtlonis. vel ponemitatiH;ltltllm) liI:et comlcoiant ingcnc:rc rdJriuo,licut (:Ipienti3 eft in!inita in [pecic lapienr liz.~on in fp:eic prudenci3!.Hd:t v tuque {kin g~n~c Illtclletlulo.Sed e:u:mpfum non qU.:Idrar.qula fir.pientia non tubet difiin\'l:tRl illnnitatcm :l pru~ delltia. (ed vtraquc: in gener~ intcUigibili infiniu e.II:, Be; fohimpct ranoncm dHlinguitur ilia inlinitas. A~in pertoni$ diuinis multiplicatio eft lealisj&: ftc pttfeaio in6nit.1,qu~ ell: in vna relatione. nOn erit ~IJ ~lia ; & lie quidquid fit ~n in [IU (pecie paltnUtat4 vel6liadonis Iemancam infinitz • in ge-nuc t:unen tclatiuo. in6nitz non c:tunt, ficur G .. pien.lQ.. & ptudemia (unt inlinitz in gcnere in~e1- ~eat~o.~Od ergo.V ttbum proced.tt vt terminus ln~lut,!11II game u\t~l1eaionis. Spirims S. Vt infinug$ In genetll arnoru • non diuidit eos in in6ni~ Qle.(ed in oppondonc rel:u:iu.a (oIUm.

, Dico quuto.Sanaim pcr[oml4,&:.u:btipanon ~ultip1iuc,?, ill pcr(onis d!uinb.,(cd SanClitas pcr~

~ tinct ad ;nmbuniR1 ctf'enllale,fic:nt bonita.; & tic I:Qnu.cnirmione.~· Aliqui nillini:lnt o:autti~ p~ fan4il<l.ta rclatiuu: nun qllia f11i~fi!;:luO

• ~.;d ip& principia. 0l'~di 'l\lZ Jt;~

\

De RclAJionitUJ diU/flU.

debent pet (:in.2itatCIll~. ptincipium aUv'm op~ r~odi Don {o!Utll ~Il: ptiucipiUln qllq , ied ctiam ptindpium (jlml, fdl.pet(ona, vcl luppofirtlm >.Be::

CUrti ill::! prindpfil muJtip!lcetltur in dillinis ,w,un {anaitarcs perlonalcs mulripllcabunrur. Tum quia. Ve~bum diuinum udone {UiJ: rclariu;lt pedtma: fanfrificauit hl1lflal1itatcm anJmpram !imti:irate per(onali, pr:J;u:r iIlam quam habuit form;;lcm ac. ~identalcrn ex gratia, Vt did Ioler ~'IUl'7.Ergo non folum peniner {ado Canti-iratis ad naturam I {i:11 etiarn sd pet(on;l;s. : '

Ca:ten'tm de hoc pertiner tra€brc ad pr:tdi .. lhllnlocum !.p, Nunc: breuiterclico, quod quid~ quid lir an dcrur fanaitas pcr(onali5, pf;.;tct :mrio; butalem • qua vo!unt.u'(Cl.l opcr~tio vide-tilt retlifielIi; ramen non inuenio perron:!.ic:s fcbdon~t oproni in fanctitatc,licut nee in perfeaione, &lti ellt aauali: penine! aurcm f.1nctius a:iam fa lit pl':trolldisad puritarcm,B( rctkitudinem openn,i!. & fie maxime C"quitur pcrfcdioncm. non oppofitionem reladOllls pcrforl:'lIi&.ln pctfcd:ioJlc al1tem. nan opponunrut rclariones ,Ikelt Illam indudanf. ergo neque in (Jna:il~tc opponuntllr,& 6" f:l.na:iE;lS 11011 muldpliciirurj lie. It c:onLlcl1ial per(onif t &; ill cis indud.ltUr,dfquC'rcddal pet(on~litern~tl:u. & r~nch~ : iicut ell~ conGituit cas cxillcntes. nee ramen multiplic:atur. qui;). ex parte fUfld;imellti (c tenet. ncn ex p~rte atdngenti;!; ad [cmninU[1l, &. correlarionis. CcrrillS tamcn vidctilr, qUQd [:lI1o'1i. !~ ~I!rc ~.l 3HnbLl~alis. quia in Dee dicit indefe-· cl:Jbll1t~tetn.&; pllmarcm lllrelleanalem; &. mor;i~ Icm.feu if! inrelledu, ,:0.. volLlnt3tc. R~tiQ autem imdlr;Cliui pcttilmOld narurarn dil:!inam fubc::o~ecpru namf:i:,& moralifas perrinc[ ad .mributa VO~ lunratis > Icil.ad virrures , vt Ihif!:rir.ordia. iu(litia,. &c. Ergo rc:c.1:i[udo tam ck. patte intl~Heau$ did. genris , qulm mor~litati. regular;.; in voluntatc ad. raricncm llafUr.:r: vel arrnburi prnini:t, &; hoc: ell de ~onceptu [.mdit.leis. Vndc gr3.tb qu~ in nobIS: f.cit animam f:lnchm lilpcrnaruraliIC["; tan'lU<ltn p:midp.ltio diuin~ (antbt:Ltis, ell:: patl'iclpatio,~ conlorrium diuina: natut:!;, hu:ra illud l.Peni I,Yt· per ht.& e_ffi,;.llnini dilljn" '~nrqyH~ nlft1ir1t.: (Tgo Can",,· dims in Dee ad naruram p:trrinct)&: attriouta.

Rationes V(!CO dnbirandi non fIl(JUeJ'It.

Ad prim:zm enim dieirur qll.od (aritlific:uioper"; tincr ad principi=l • qu~ r(!LliDC:l.ri debcnt,per mo-: dum .perfcd:iQnis. & meralitatis Corum,nDII pcc· modum dill:inti-ionLs. 8< oppofidonis: non cnim p~inc:t ad Can~it3tc:m dilling~u:~re pripcipia ope~ r~mua, :m~tc:btlOm:5 opponc:rc Inter rc. (cd omlli malieiz.& dcfe£tui, & impurir:ltimorali 0pponcrt. Ho~ :lutein r;/l: commUne pcrConi$ , hon parri~ eu Lue Ili;cui.quia hoc hahent Clt plcnitudinc ad:io.. nis, fen aC'tualirads voluntari~) & intellea:u~il. vnde redil;Udo omnis dimanat.'

Ad fcculldam dicitur • quod V erburn fan&j~ cauie humaniEatem ranone. pet[onili$ fanGlitatis. dillinguo J ita quod Iy pt7flm",li4 dic:iltmionem: formalcm limditacis; nego; ira: quOd dicar mo~ dum. (eu tt!rminnm talis (ancHt;trU.: concedo. Hie alltcm teraninus. feu mbdus indu.dit ipfam fand:itatcm idcnricc. dunque ffiQdlfii::at unquaM Cubfitlentiaj&: prim::ipium quod iIIitis. Vnde '(Jtn~ n1!lnic;;1t:l. humanirari {ub(iCtentia medhue (ommli~ nic:atur fanCtila3 ... t in UlIJ (ublillcpli:l modiEcar:l:· fie.tnin (cluemia D.Thom.c:ommullic:arut buma~· ~itari e:ntten.tia dinina v, mod!ij':sta pctfou:Uitoui

Va-bii nOn abfDll1r~. < •• c

f

,

Difputalio xtt: $1J6Jiflen'fiIlMflltillic':Uitlll' ih perfiYhit.

De !toe: amplins dicCTtlIl5 fo'l.J;ff'. N Ilnc:Cohl.m. dice fLlblhntiam rt.lmi pm rermlno complente.& peno!li1nte naeurarn t &. fie mueniuneur pll1t~$ (ublinenri;e :ttnibl1i perfonij j &, timpHci'u:r fotten plutes eire in Oeo Cubfi.tlcnti:l.!i, vr parer in: epi11:o!a So!,hrcl(1ij ,qlta: leth,& recep!:! ~11: in V [. Synodt1 ac1illflt 6. vbi {;:spilh nornlnanmr eres fubtiftc:nri3: in Dee. Cum ergo plut3litarem in fubfi!icmihteneamus. videndum dl quomodo id lIare pollit cum Vl'iiure ipfius uiJtc:mjil: per fe. Ef dic(l fLibJiJtentilm duo polle impOHjre. l'omo exiflentiam pede,v, oPFCinifllt cnli in alio.Ceu accidcnri inh:i:renti;&: patti Cub{bmJaIi non (ubli(t':~ 'i.SerandMumim, pro rerminc vIti mo incommunk;i!l)ill. vt cxprctR dccee S.Th.fit!. q.i,.II,~, ad of. '" nos di~emu$ [tq.dtjf.Dicit enim defe terminii

. i'i) pertinent-em ad (Ilppoilt~itt'lf(:u ~YPQna'ii,'n , '<;tun. {ubJil1:en~ dl: qu~!i Cub aho l!!ie-fiS f ~ (ie -di-ctu~ miourn vkimi (ub alils politi,&: quoci habet ratjo~ nern "lrirni.terminum imporm rc~ed:\i eoru,quz [liper iprum ponumur,vrnon ccmmunicenrur fII.·rcri rerrnino. Primo ergo modo 110n multip·Jjcatut fub!1!lemia in diuinis,qllfil non dlalilld-qnillfi d:i .. ficnria p~t (e,feu independens ab alio cui inh;l;'reat aut infir. Ec fie datm fublil1enda ab(olut:l in Deo, Vt"diccrnll5 difP.(l!q,Sccuodo vero modo lIOn da-CUr (uhf! rlcnda abCof Ul:!. • &: aarHur ftcs rcllltilllC'; qui:! inCD1"i1mUrlicabilifas tieCdUfio req1!lirit oppoti(ioncm cum vltcripri rermin·o i tiiblara enim oppolirionc , omnia fum vnurn • &. con(cqlfCnrl!t fecO'nlrtiunic~ilf,8.I: idemificant.Ergo (11b hoc ron-. cepru fubfiftc:nria '1I:Ia~iUl dc:bet 1fiulrip!/cui,qui;i debet oppon.tiollcm dicere; & fub o£,pouriont exercere f3tjcmem lenninj.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~*~~~~~*~

Q V .IE ST.I 0 XXIX~

De P (;jOnil diujni.t~

S Y M MAL ITT E P. ce.

~~ .. 't.::~11Il G 1 T S.Thom.poil: e"plicatas procelliones,. &" relariones , quz fundicut principia ponend;'erConasditlinLlas in Deo 7 dcipfis perionis. Ee primo dehls qua: perrinenr sd omnes petfonas in communi quatllor qlia:t\iolli. ~~~~t!. bus Iequennbus. Deinde de his qua: pereinene ad fingulas Ipeciahrer,

~~. Primum ergo quod occurrit de ip(i§ perfonls in comuni c:ftagerc de p~rfo~

nh fc:cundumfe,. &chi quoc6.tifr<!t,quiduefignilicet:uf hoc nomine: P~rfotJli,Er. 6crratld quatuor. Primo,dennitiOoem pc:r(onz in communi explica, Secnnda.quomodo comparerur ad (ubGllel1ti<l.tn '" dfcndam Be hypoftaGm. T crcio ;i quomodo inur;niatudn diuinis .. Qp.ano , an fignificc:t ibi r~!;uionem vel etfentiam.

Igirur in r.arciculo exphcar defimnonem perfonzaffignar:una Bocrio7 quod eft radonalis namra: indiuidua fpbfrantia: dicirur enim (ubfl:anria indiuidua,qu:ucnus fignificat ilngubre ingenere fubf1:3:ntia:. Dicirur aurem raeionalis naturz.qui~ non quodlibet mditriduum luhQantialt:,fed quod ell natura: inteUeUllalis (cu raeionshs f perfena vadtur.

In art. a, ad. melius explieandcmranonem pc:r[on{l!"j(:ompaut illam cum. aibus,quz:in {ubftalltiis fingularibus concurrent. Inuenitur enim in ahquo indimduo fubnamiafulJl~ pta pro quidirare, & euncef] idem quod effentia : deinde inuenlrcr fubfiftentia qu~ perriner ad rnodum exmendl, CdL quarcmus pet' (0 cxHh., Ee j. refuleae hYpOtl~fi5 feu fup~ pofirum , quo nomine figmlicamr res ilh,fcu indiuiduum,prouc[ubdtj fCllliibfiernicur accidt:ntibu5& przdicans fupcrioribus,[ca accidcntibus fubfrernitur reaheer vr fOJ"mis inha:rentibu5; & ficdi~i[ur res natura: , ((.'"u·hypuHafis, id eil rub aliis pofirurn, quonomine etiam [ub(bntia feler Ggnific.ari7vt fit ide quod Iub allislbns.PrzdicaEis aUte fupc. ricribus fuben: t non realit!=[ • (ed logice; & (cl;DnduhI inJ.cmiones ranoms ; & tic di~i~u, fuppofitum.quafi fiJppo6t1oriem faciens. Nunc aurern communi~cr pro eodem accipitur fuppofitum , hypofra!is t res natura:,(ubii(lens- complete • crt .. Pcrfona aurem dl ide m quod hy?oftafi s vel (ub1iftcns complerum In genere natur.,; inrellcdualis,

In an. ,. ofbcndit Deo conuenire fignificatum huius nominis perrona; quia conuenir ei eKe fubGQens eompletum & perfellum in natura dtUtna, qu::r ell: natura intcUeCtuahs. Hoc enim, quod cfr(ub6llere in inrelleltuali natura, nullam imperfcd:ionetn irnporrar, fed perfeCtioncm maximarn.id dl com,ret2m &: terminaram. Elfe aurern inaiuidu:un (ubttantiam non conuenir Dee rationcalicuius matcrire,fcd ratione io<.omunicabili(2ris,. vt dicit flltilitJ1U If,/. 4. Er licet conceptusformahs perfonz , VI: relacio cl1: ad :iliba ~ pc: rfe.:.. liioncmnon explicer , explrcat ramen pct'fed:HTimumin natura; Icil, cffe u;rmin.attlnJ itt natura intelIcfruali.& rerminus,feu modus pcrfcClionis in Deo en. Hie ramen abfl:rahit c D. Thom.ab co quod partlcularil:crconO::ituit perfonam in Dco " & (QUun vult fi~hifi ... carum huius. nominis pfyfo'IJA Deo connenire , quia conuc:uit pCt(ctli.ffi"p:la: na~u~z:> qual cft ituc:UcttuaIis.

ill,,{t. 01 ~.ThrffJJ.i~ ,.pArl.D.Th .Tomuuhu. I) ip.