Integrated Unit of Work: Stage 2 Science and Literacy
Written By: April Elliott Unit of work: Science, Stage 2: What comes next..?
Content area Outcome
ST2-10LW - describes that living things have life cycles, can be distinguished from non-living things and grouped, based on their observable features Summary of Content Relevant to Outcome
All living things have unique patterns of growth and development that they experience in their lifetimes from birth until death. Some animals, such as frogs and butterflies, experience changes so abrupt that they are described as going through stages of metamorphosis. Each species also has a unique way of reproducing that restarts the cycle of birth and death with subsequent generations. These natural processes are referred to broadly as life cycles and are a key feature for distinguishing between living and non-living things (Board of Studies, NSW, 2012). Everyday experiences, in conjunction with information extracted from factual texts, will aid students to recognise and describe sequential stages in a range of different animal life cycles, particularly the butterfly. These stages should be explored in linear form (focusing on the development of a specific member of the species) as well as secular form (focusing on the species in general and how the cycle is repeated). Students will describe physical attributes that pertain specifically to different stages of metamorphosis. Students will represent this information using a range of appropriate forms including diagrams, time lines, and selected written text forms (Board of Studies, NSW, 2012).
APRIL ELLIOTT S00119391 2
Rationale
This sequence of five lessons is intended as one of the final segments in an integrated unit that aims to support students (especially EAL/D learners) develop literacy in the context of the scientific field (de Courcy, Dooley, Jackson, Miller & Rushton, 2012). Previously, students were introduced to two focus texts including a narrative and a factual text. In this segment, students will again use The Dream Tree as a basic platform to make links between first hand knowledge of butterfly life cycles and the key, abstract terminology presented in Metamorphosis Changing bodies. To support students establish these connections, the teacher will immerse them in a text rich environment that fosters multiple opportunities for talking and listening tasks in which students will utilise this terminology to promote comprehension (Cairney, 2010). This strategy endorses principles of both Intellectual practices 3 and 4, and allows EAL/D learners to practice oral communication in more formal registers (Gibbons, 2009). In addition, this sequence will endorse principles of Intellectual Practice 2. Students will be scaffolded in their roles as transformers with tasks requiring them to apply and record content knowledge in various written forms (that ultimately allude to the design and production of an imaginative, descriptive recount inspired by the life cycles of butterflies) (Hill, 2012). Thus far, the instruction of specific language features within the unit has consisted of the content specific vocabulary, effective expansion of nominal groups, personal pronouns, reformation of verbs into the past tense and complex sentence building. Students will now revisit this terminology, along with feeling verbs, similes and sequencing to prepare them for their final written assessment (Board of Studies, NSW, 2012). The mode of delivery for each lesson will be shaped by stages of the Teaching and Learning Cycle including field building, joint construction and independent reading and writing. The inclusion of these strategies in the literacy program will deftly transition the control of the learning from the teacher to the students, establishing a strong set of explicit scaffolds for all students, including EAL/D learners (Hill, 2012). Ultimately, the activities in this unit have been built on a theoretical foundation that promotes high challenge and high support for all learners to establish Vygotskys Zone of Proximal Development (Berk, 2011).
Key for Abbreviated In Text References IP Intellectual Practice T & L Talking and Listening R & V Reading and Viewing W & R Writing and Representing APRIL ELLIOTT S00119391 3
Lesson Plan 1 Revisiting Key Technical Language AIMS To reinforce comprehension of key technical language associated with scientific concepts (namely the life cycle and metamorphosis of a butterfly). WHAT Technical Vocabulary: Metamorphosis, larva, caterpillar, nutrients, moult, chrysalis, pupa, butterfly. Skills: Articulation and definition (describing the meaning of contextualised technical terms using everyday language). HOW R & V: Teacher will display a word wall chart covered in the target technical vocabulary at the front of the room (a chart made collaboratively at the start of the unit with Metamorphosis Changing Bodies as the source). Teacher then defines the purpose of the looming Modelled Reading session; to find references to key terms in The Dream Tree and compare the different types of language used. The teacher then commences a Modelled Reading session, extracting phrases and words related to terms on the word wall. For example, the teacher extracts the phrase build a cocoon, identifies the scientific term chrysalis and rephrases (eg. form a chrysalis) (IP 3). T & L: Students would then engage in a reverse of this process by playing a modified version of Barrier Crossword (Gibbons, 2009). Partner A is provided with a technical vocabulary crossword with the down answers filled in. Partner B is provided with all the across answers. To fill their whole crossword, partners must work together by articulating meaning in hopes of the other matching the key technical language (eg. 4 down is a word used to describe when caterpillars shed their skin - moult) (IP 3). ASSESS The teacher will observe students oral interactions to informally assess accuracy of definitions, ability to link key terms with respective meanings (in this particular scientific context) and whether or not students utilise any scientific terms to help articulate the meaning of other scientific terms (eg. 5 across is a stage of metamorphosis). EAL/D SUPPORT As students actively recall, describe and use words in sentences their meaning is being reinforced in a way that makes clear links between content knowledge and how it is effectively expressed using more abstract, technical terms (IP 4) (Gibbons, 2009). Comprehension is also supported with the word wall as a visual reference. In addition, picture prompts could be provided to help students channel ideas during the articulation process (ESL Steps: ESL curriculum framework K-6, 2005).
APRIL ELLIOTT S00119391 4
Lesson Plan 2 - Expressing Emotion through Feeling Verbs AIMS To introduce feeling verbs as structures that express opinion or emotion in a piece of writing. Student reflections on imagined situations initiate thought about the severity of such physical changes and how it could affect everyday life. WHAT Feeling Verbs: Past tense (adding ed to base form). Focus on their function to communicate feelings and evaluative opinions. Skills: Application of feelings verbs to express theoretical emotions (imagined, past circumstances involving personal reflections). HOW R & V: Teacher engages students in a shared reading of the text The Dream Tree. On each page, they will work collaboratively to examine both the text and illustrations for clues about how the characters are feeling, particularly Patti. Teacher will create a word bank during the reading for past tense feeling verbs, modelling how to express other emotive phrases/clues as feeling verbs (eg. loved, contented, enjoyed). T & L: Students are divided into mixed ability groups, with each being allocated an imagined scenario. Utilising their knowledge of butterfly metamorphosis as inspiration, students engage in substantive conversations about how their imagined situation might of made them feel considering the affect it would have on day to day living (IP 4) (Appendix 2). Students will utilise feeling verbs in their dialogue, but will also record any other language they use to express emotions on a piece of butchers paper. Students then present these ideas to the class, justifying the feelings they had and adding any additional contributions from the class. Any new feeling verbs will be added to the class word bank to display on the wall. ASSESS Teacher will observe specific emotive language being utilised during group discussions as part of a formative assessment. In particular, teachers will assess the recorded brainstorms to identify whether the language recorded was emotive, whether a variety of feeling verbs were utilised and how strongly this language expressed emotion relevant to the assigned situations. EAL/D SUPPORT The personal nature of the talking and listening tasks allows students to make meaningful text to self-connections. Students can draw on familiar mediums such as imagination and emotion to help express abstract, high order thought (Cross, 2012).
APRIL ELLIOTT S00119391 5
Lesson Plan 3 Enhancing Descriptions using Figurative Language (Similes) AIMS To demonstrate how the incorporation of similes can enhance descriptions by creating poignant, visual imagery. This type of language development will aid students to effectively describe the physical attributes of a butterfly at different stages of metamorphosis. WHAT Similes: Focus on their function to intensify descriptions. Identify them as a form of figurative language. Skills: Developing appropriate and effective similes from a variety of stem adjectives. HOW R & V: Students review a poster of Patti the Caterpillar that they created earlier in the unit (which consisted of an image of Patti surrounded by adjectives describing her appearance and physical attributes). Teacher presents a new image, this time of Patti the Butterfly. Teacher allows time for students to study the image, and then continues to lead the class in a brainstorm of adjectives to describe Pattis new physical attributes. W &R: Teacher then picks one adjective and models how to create a simile starter around it (eg. Pattis wings are as delicate as.). Students are then prompted to jointly construct the end of the sentence, recording at least three examples on interchangeable cardboard strips (eg. as delicate as cobwebs etc.). Students then select a particular stage of metamorphosis as a source of inspiration to write their own similes. Teacher should encourage the use of quality comparisons by introducing evaluative prompt questions (eg. Is my object of comparison delicate? Is the way it is delicate similar to the way the wings are delicate? Cobwebs is more appropriate then glass because it tears, like wings). ASSESS Teacher will check that written similes are built upon appropriate adjectives. The teacher will then formally assess how effectively the objects or things being compared link to the stem adjectives in the context of the particular thing or phenomena they are describing. EAL/D SUPPORT Similes development will be scaffolded with visual supports including images of things/stages/processes being described as well as two separate word banks of field appropriate adjectives (de Courcy et al., 2012).
APRIL ELLIOTT S00119391 6
Lesson Plan 4 Time Connectives and Event Sequence AIMS To establish the sequence of physical changes/stages experienced by Patti in the text. Using their knowledge of typical butterfly life cycles, students will project this knowledge to stages Patti would of experienced before and after the events in the text. WHAT Time connectives: eg. In the beginning, Firstly, then, after that, a few days later, finally etc. Skills: Recognition of time connectives as an indicator of sequence. Application of time connectives to establish cohesive sequencing. HOW R & V: Teacher displays a number of sentences describing Pattis physical changes as she undergoes metamorphosis during the events of the story (Appendix 3). Utilising their knowledge of butterfly life cycles, student work collaboratively to rearrange the sentences into the correct sequence. Teacher will draw special attention to the clues evident in the language used, namely time connectives such as In the beginning. Teacher should discuss how, content aside, these time connectives indicate what order the information is intended to go in. R & V: Teacher will describe how the sequenced sentences provide information about Pattis personal timeline from caterpillar to butterfly. Teacher then asks students to imagine that Patti is a monarch butterfly. Utilising the focus text Metamorphosis Changing Bodies as a source, students will engage in a shared reading to identify stages of the life cycle that were not evident in the book (eg. egg, larva etc.) W & R: Students will then create their own complete timeline of Pattis physical changes before, during and after the events of the book (from birth to reproduction). Each stage will also include descriptions that will utilise time connectives to reinforce their position in the sequence (IP 2). ASSESS Teacher will check that timelines have each of the required components, including a title as well as labels, pictures and descriptions for each stage of Pattis metamorphosis. Descriptions should all start with a time connective that links it effectively into the sequence and should outline the major physical changes in sequential order (pertaining specifically to the monarch species). EAL/D SUPPORT To present a concrete scaffold, teacher will provide a timeline template for students requiring extra support. This template could include a blank time line, boxes for drawing, lines for description underneath boxes as well as a selection of time connectives to aid students organise their ideas (ESL Steps: ESL curriculum framework K-6, 2005).
APRIL ELLIOTT S00119391 7
Lesson Plan 5 Imaginative, Descriptive Recount (Diary of a Butterfly) AIMS To transform content knowledge of butterfly life cycles into a mixed genre framework with an enriched, imaginary context (that serves to both entertain and inform the audience). WHAT Mixed Genre Framework: Imaginative, Descriptive Recount in the form of a diary (including an orientation, sequence of events and personal reflection). Skills: Application of targeted language to produce a dynamic, creative text built on a factual foundation. HOW W & R: Teacher will present the source of inspiration for the written text, Pattis ultimate unanswered question; What does it feel like to be a butterfly? Teacher then describes the task. Students must construct a journal that describes metamorphosis from the perspective of a monarch butterfly, from birth to reproduction. The teacher will provide a simple model of an imaginative, descriptive recount on the Smart Board and annotate each paragraph and its components (Appendix 4). The teacher then models construction by producing their own orientation paragraph (or the first entry) with specific emphasis on who, what, when and where (eg. My life started off in a small egg on the branch of a gum tree. etc.) W & R: Using their content knowledge of the butterfly life cycles, the language developed over the past four lessons and their creativity, students will independently write their own imaginative, descriptive journals (IP 2). The text framework will be displayed on the Smart Board for students to reference (Appendix 5). ASSESS This task will be a formal, summative written assessment with a set of modified criteria aimed to assess the use of language features and content knowledge pertaining specifically to this mixed genre text type task (Appendix 6). EAL/D SUPPORT The timelines created in the previous lesson will serve as a scaffold for sequencing ideas. Word banks, posters and visual prompts displayed around the room will also help channel focus and provide support with technical vocabulary. Students could even have field specific word walls on their desks for the course of the unit (de Courcy et al., 2012).
APRIL ELLIOTT S00119391 8
References Berk, L. (2011). Infants, children and adolescents (7th ed.). Boston: Pearson Education. Board of Studies, NSW. (2012, December 11). NSW Syllabuses for the Australian Curriculum: Scope and Sequence of Punctuation and Grammar for K-6. Retrieved from http://syllabus.bos.nsw.edu.au/support-materials/additional-support-materials/ Board of Studies, NSW. (2012). Science and Technology sample unit: What came first? (Stage 2). Retrieved from http://syllabus.bos.nsw.edu.au/support- materials/sample-units/ Cairney, T. (2010). e:update 013 - Developing comprehension: Learning to make meaning. Metro, NSW: e:lit, Primary English Teaching Association. Cosgrove, S. (1985). The Dream Tree. Los Angeles: Price/Stern/Sloan Publishers Incorporated. Cross, R. (2012). Reclaiming the territory: Understanding the specialist knowledge of ESL education for literacy, curriculum and multilingual learners. In TESSOL in Context, 22 (1). 4 17.
de Courcy, M., Dooley, K., Jackson, R., Miller, J. & Rushton, K. (2012). PETAA Paper 183: Teaching EAL/D learners in Australian classrooms. Newtown, NSW: Primary English Teaching Association.
Derewianka, B. (2011). A New Grammar Companion for Teachers. Sydney: eLit (PETAA).
ESL Steps: ESL curriculum framework K-6. (2005). Australia: NSW Department of Education and Training. Hill, S. (2012). Developing Early Literacy: Assessment and Teaching (2nd Ed.). South Yarra: Eleanor Curtain Publishing. Gibbons, P. (2009). English learners, academic literacy and thinking. Portsmouth, N. H: Heinemann. Kalman, B. (2005). Metamorphosis: Changing Bodies. Melbourne: Crabtree Publishing Company. APRIL ELLIOTT S00119391 9
Appendix 1 (pp. 9 11): Aligning Content, Activities and Outcomes NSW English K-10 Syllabus: Stage 2 Outcomes Language and Grammar Content Learning Activities Objective A: Communicate through speaking, listening, reading, writing, viewing and representing EN2 - 1A: Communicates in a range of informal and formal contexts by adopting a range of roles in group, classroom, school and community contexts Students: Develop and apply contextual knowledge Understand that social interactions influence the way people engage with ideas and respond to others for example when exploring and clarifying the ideas of others, summarising their own views and reporting them to a larger group Understand and apply knowledge of language forms and features Interact effectively in groups or pairs, adopting a range of roles Use interaction skills, including active listening behaviours and communicate in a clear, coherent manner using a variety of everyday and learned vocabulary Use information to support and elaborate on a point of view Demonstrate understanding of ideas and issues in texts through role-play and simulations
Modified Barrier Crossword articulating word meanings orally in order to match descriptions to technical terms and language (Lesson 1).
Small Group Discussions Sharing and justification of emotional responses to imagined situations. Target language includes emotive language, particularly feeling verbs. Imagined scenarios are inspired by butterfly metamorphisis, which presents a unique approach for exploring content. Students summarise and record points of discussion to present to the class (Lesson 2). EN2 4A: uses an increasing range of skills, strategies and knowledge to fluently read, vie and comprehend a range of texts on increasingly challenging topics in different media and technologies. Students: Develop and apply contextual knowledge Draw on experiences, knowledge of the topic or context to work out the meaning of unknown words Understand and apply knowledge of language forms and features Understand how texts are made cohesive through the use of linking devices including time connectives Deconstruct text to scan for particular information/language Respond to, read and view texts
Modelled Reading (The Dream Tree) - Location and extraction of references to the process of metamorphosis. Comparison of language used in the narrative to corresponding technical terms (Lesson 1).
Shared Reading (The Dream Tree) Identification of text and picture elements that provide clues about how specific characters are feeling, particularly Patti. Demonstration of how to express other emotive phrases/clues and words as feeling verbs (Lesson 2).
APRIL ELLIOTT S00119391 10
Outcomes Language and Grammar Content Learning Activities Use comprehension strategies to expand content knowledge, integrating and linking ideas and analysing and evaluating texts Recognise how aspects of personal perspective influence responses to texts Justify interpretations of a text, including responses to information and ideas Describing Visual Text Elements - Work collaboratively to record a brainstorm of appropriate adjectives that describe the physical attributes and appearance of Patti the butterfly (from the Dream Tree). (Lesson 3).
Sequencing (The Dream Tree) Arranging information extracted from the text about Pattis physical changes (in order). Utilisation of time connectives to help establish sequence (Lesson 4).
Shared Reading (Metamorphosis Changing Bodies) Identification of the stages in a monarch butterflies life cycle. Identification of stages not explored in The Dream Tree (Lesson 4).
Objective B: Use language to shape and make meaning according to purpose, audience and context EN2 - 7B: Identifies and uses language forms and features in their own writing appropriate to a range of purposes, audiences and contexts Students: Develop and apply contextual knowledge Identify and analyse the purpose and audience of imaginative and informative texts Understand and apply knowledge of language forms and features Understand how a range of language features can shape readers' and viewers' understanding of subject matter Examine how emotive and figurative language can be varied to be more or less forceful Use images in imaginative, informative and persuasive texts to enhance meaning Respond to and compose texts Discuss how texts, including their own, are adjusted to appeal to different audiences, how texts develop the subject matter and how they serve a wide variety of purposes
Modelled/Shared Writing (Similes): Creation of simile starters using stem adjectives (modelled). Creation of whole similes by identifying appropriate objects/things of comparison (shared) (Lesson 3).
Independent Writing (Similes) Creation of appropriate and effective similes that describe physical attributes and/or changes experienced during different stages of a butterflys metamorphosis. Reflection on writing to assess effectiveness (Lesson 3).
Patti the Monarch Butterfly (Extrapolated Timeline) Creation of time line that describes Pattis entire lifecycle (as a monarch butterfly). Utilisation of information from both The Dream Tree and Metamorphosis Changing Bodies. Target language includes descriptive language and time connectives to establish sequence (Lesson 4).
Modelled Writing (Imaginative Descriptive Recount) Annotation of sample imaginative, descriptive recount to highlight the text framework. Construction of orientation paragraph or journal entry including information about who, what, where and when (Lesson 5). APRIL ELLIOTT S00119391 11
Outcomes Language and Grammar Content Learning Activities Independent Writing (Diary of a Butterfly) Composition of imaginative, descriptive recount from the perspective of a butterfly. Description of physical attributes and changes (similes and adjectives). Insight into the impact of physical change emotional and practically through personal reflection (feeling verbs). Sequencing that aligns with the monarch butterflys life cycle (time connectives) (Lesson 5).
APRIL ELLIOTT S00119391 12
Appendix 2: Metamorphosis Inspired Scenarios Imagine that you had been sleeping for a long time. When you awoke, your body felt different. You noticed that you had grown your own large set of wings! How might you have felt about this?
Imagine if you shed your skin every few weeks. How would this impact on your day-to-day life? What might you do with all the skin you shed? How might it make you feel?
Imagine human teenagers could only eat one type of food until they grew to adult hood. How might that make you feel? If you were allowed to pick which food, what would it be? Imagine you had ten brothers and sisters who were all the same age as you. How might you feel about it? What are some pros and cons? Imagine you had twelve legs and no hands. How might it make you feel? What sorts of things would be easier or harder? Imagine that you had been sealed in a sleeping bag for weeks, with no food, no water and no light. How might it have felt to be trapped in there? How might it of felt to finally come back out?
APRIL ELLIOTT S00119391 13
Appendix 3: Pattis Stages of Metamorphosis in The Dream Tree (Sequencing Activity)
Patti found the perfect twig, attached herself, wove a delicate white cocoon and fell into a deep sleep. One day, Patti the caterpillar was playing amoung the branches of the tree. A few weeks later, Patti emerged from her cocoon as a beautiful butterfly. Soon after, Patti felt that it was time to make her very own cocoon. APRIL ELLIOTT S00119391 14
Diary of a Butterfly Entry 1 Inside the Egg My journey to become a monarch butterfly began in an egg as small as a sesame seed. Mother butterfly laid all her eggs on the underside of a gum leaf where my brothers, sisters and I were protected from the sun and other hungry insects. I liked being in my egg, it always felt so warm and had just enough room for my little wormy body. Entry 2 - Hatching After a few days, I started to grow legs as delicate as silk. Suddenly, my egg started to make me feel restless and cramped! I knew it was time to hatch. Slowly, I stretched to press against the soft shell until a hole appeared. As soon as it was wide enough, I squeezed out into the open air for the first time. There was so much wonder around me, but I couldnt concentrate. I was so hungry! Entry 3 My First Real Meal After I emerged, I quickly went it search of my first meal. I didnt have to go far. My eggshell was full of nutrients so I decided to munch on that first. When I was finished I felt very energetic but I still wasnt full so I went in search for some luscious, green leaves. For a while, I spent most of my time eating and growing. Whenever I got too large for my skin I would moult. It was always strange looking at the skin I had shed. It was black, yellow and white striped like a tiger. I thought I must be a very ferocious looking caterpillar.
Imaginative Descriptive Recount Purpose: To entertain, describe and inform Framework First Entry must include:
- Orientation Tell who what, where, when and why (optional)
Language Features
Descriptive Language (Adjectives and Adverbs)
Figurative Language (Similes)
Past Tense
Emotive Language (Feeling Verbs)
Time Connectives
Sequenced Events
Simple, Compound and Complex Sentences
Personal Pronouns Subsequent Entries should include:
- Sequence of Events Stages of metamorphosis in chronological logical order.
- Description Description of physical changes/developments.
- Personal Reflection Emotions and opinions associated with physical changes/developments.
Final Entry should:
Conclusive/Evaluative Statement - Reflect on the series of events as a whole.
APRIL ELLIOTT S00119391 16
Appendix 6 Part 1: Stage 2 - Imaginative, Descriptive Recount Rubric (Diary of a Butterfly) Stage 2: Imaginative, Descriptive Recount Rubric (Diary of a Butterfly) Organisation Total Marks/Comment Orientation who, what, when, where No details present 0 One detail only 1 Two to three details 2 All details present 3
Sequencing No evident of logical sequencing
0 Evidence of sequencing related to monarch butterfly life cycle
1 All journal entries related to monarch butterfly life cycle in order
2 Journal entries include mention/description of each stage in monarch butterfly life cycle in order 3
Personal reflection No evidence of personal reflection or opinion
0 Evidence of personal reflection related to designated role
1 Two to three personal reflection statements that maintain designated role
2 Frequent personally reflective comments that effectively maintain designated role
3
Language Features Feeling Verbs Uses simple verbs only
1 At least one feeling verbs/attempt at emotive language
2 Two to three feeling verbs used.
3 Two to three feeling verbs used effectively with other examples of emotive language
4
Descriptive Language No use of adjectives or adverbs At least two simple adjectives or adverbs Two to four effective adjectives and adverbs 2 More then four effective adjectives and adverbs 3
Tense Incorrect use of tense
0 At least two correct uses of past tense 1 Mostly correct past tense sustained 2 Correct use of past tense throughout journal 3
Figurative Language No use of figurative language 0 An attempt to use figurative language made 1 At least one correctly structured simile 2 More then one effective simile used 3
Sentence Structure Fewer then five sentences
0 At least five simple sentences with at least one correctly punctuated 1 At least four simple sentences and one complex 2 At least two complex sentences used
3
Time Connectives No time connectives used
0 Correct use of one time connectives
1 Correct use of two to three time connectives
2 Correct use of time connectives sustained throughout 3