K

18.11.2014 A

: 9

: 288

4 & 400

F 2 F

F K P

K
g .m

I ..C. G F M
C I EM. F, i F
K F A .

... H J
O

, . 18&
I .m
OJ
PJ PJ
;&
K H
J JP
P
I O
F
F GF,

K
HJ
cFF I
CJ

! e
P
O
J.
K H
J I
, I MJ
O

IF
K G
C M
.
, K
J 141
a
A .

, FM,
F
, M
G ,
C M
F
M
F P
OJ
GF.
K H

F
J.

I
M.
F.
H
J
OK A
J.
J

GJ 2012 &


F bJ.
G
P.
H
HK


F F,
A A
A F F
K, . 18 &
h K v
P . F F.
FJ
Nc F

F N L
A.
c FO
AI F.
F
Nc, c
O
G .
c
F
J ,
FO

i
M.

F

A.
L FJ OJ C

G CJ F H F F
M IF A. OJ U, . FJ
CK, CK, C, v, J, Q , AKI J
.
FL FI
K, . 18&
FJ
C
( 39) .
Av H. 6&
F H
T
K

.
P
h 3
Q M

A.
F K
hv H,
H
O O e
F
. Q
cF
F H, MT, ,
, M, w,
F, ,
O 11
.

w
J Q
J

. 11
3 L
h .
O F AH
MJ
O

:
FJ C
H,
K
F GM
.
K v
N

. FJ
A.
Q HJ
H
L .
P E

GF
P OJ
, HJ
I , P
5 MJ
F, F
A F
Av E

M .
7.11.2014
GF
P OJ
. P
F P
M ,
C
C P

KM
e iN
F GF.
F, K
P
cFF
PH,

F
K c
F

FI P
e IF
.
K
J c 142
AM ,
AM 5
MJO

, F

,
C

F
KA.
, H
H
P
F
M
M

M MA
GF.
K J
142
a A

cF

O
GJ, c
J F
K
J cK

A.

H
M
C
. cF

HK .
GF K
.
P H

M.
Q,
K b
.
I
cF,
cFF
I
b
C M
. ,
b
F
i
GF

K c H
M

Q .
HJ
H b
J
K
C M
,
NJ
F
A.
cFF
GJ
, K
J c
136 JL 120

F

9.12.2011

b
GP , I
O
OF,
P
F
A
, C M
15.12.2011
C

F H
b G
P.
I
G O
, O
P
,
J, K

,
c 136
JL 142 ;
C

H, 152
F
cF
27.2.2006 bO
H, ,

, P
F J,
c
(F) , 2006,
P
F F ,
cFF G
4& ...

x F AO
FL

, F
F

J.

FJ
Y,
F
.

F
O O


F F .
P
F cM.
P F ..
. FLF
KM.

FL F
K J
C. P
M.

AO

. C
F F

F F

AO
F
F J
A.
H
Nc O
P
. C
J
c .
F
CJ

K .
F
O c, N
c A G G
.

AO
E c
N c

FLF
F
P KM.

K 18.11.2014

E JL c
M, . 18&
M

E
F JL M
F
,
A a F
M.
M
E
F
JL
M F
G 1,243
F
G 4,250
5493
F .
E F
J
736.96 I.. .
J
c 32.50
. M F
16.11.2014
30.11.2014
P M 25
a F
L M 42

a
FMA. 1.12.2014
9.01.2015 45

P M 15

a F
L M 84
a F
M . F
4,250
M
M
A.
M 1,243
M
A. 5,493
M M

A.
F
,
, E
, , ,
i,
,
c, GF,
A A
.
K
,

F J A
v i
F.
, H, Q
.

I
,
, 18&

..IJ
J .

L

KM
.

.JI .
M F
( 85)

..
I.

C
.

..IJ

F
L

KM
. I
.m

KM
.
FO F
F
(J) J
. F
,

H,
C&C
C H,

H
M
FK
F L
F.

,
,

A

N a F
MF K,
PC, C,

,.18&
M
MFJ

F
, JC

F
.
G
M G

K
J MFJ
JC A
.
MFJ

F
.
20 F 50-
60

F
A.
GJ,
28 L
MF ,
JC O

F H
C. ,
K JC
F
F H .
F, L
.
h

KM
. M
h L e
H

M F
J M

FJ
F vF


F

vF. eF
e
J F
.
M G


FA.
GI
M A
J
P.
, O

,

.
M C

KM.

C

,
CQM w

H
A .
vFJ
CQ

M F
.
F, A
C .

PH.

Namathu Murasu Evening Tamil Daily

RNI No. PONTAM/2006/16752
Printed, Published and Owned by P.Rajeswari, and Printed
at Anitha Printers Unit-II. No.31, Journalist Colony,
N.Rangasamy nagar, Murungapakkam, Puducherry-605 004
and Published at No.31, Journalist Colony, N.Rangasamy
nagar, Murungapakkam, Puducherry-605 004.
Editor P.Rajeswari.

AP M
e F

F L

, . 18&



FCE (83).

F (75)
M 4
. v
F
F 3
M.
M
FCE
J

. FCE
M

C,
15 AO
M
C J

E
J KM.
GCJ
PC
H x, PC
H
, PC
C F,
P
, F,
, PC

FQ, P
WFL F F
H C,
K FMM I C FK M
E P
KI, M F A. ..., F,
P FK GA .
, HK (M
P) H,
C
HE
M HFGF,

AK F
M i F H. i
FH FCE
F
.
GJ
F F
FCE
J
HK. M 2
O
F
F F.
FCE

M
.

. ,
L
KF
JK
M KM.
F
h C
Q
C
M F
KM. JK
L JC
MFJ M
,



K C
hC KM.

M 7

G
.
G
F
O J,
'
.

CF C
C,.18& AP P
M , J
e F
CJ
C

.
I P,

AO
M
FK. P
M A
A
O F
M P M G
.
M
E
H,
J
e, e J
.
IF
A
P
MF
H, G
M

P M
e
Q G
F P
. C
H
I
P C,
AP M

e J
85 .e. 35
.e.
F
A.
11 14
M
AP J
A
.
K
F C
C
MH.
P C
P:

F ,
F GJ .

Y A
J

.
AP
M
H O

F .
,
AP

J G P
.
N O
.
, vd, O
, vd
.
O
M

. ,
K .

AP
M ,
GJ
,
A H J

.
C
A

MA.

.

CO P A.
A
G C ,
F
FJA.

O

IA.
C
F
v dR
e .
i
K A
. C
C F
KA.
H
C
PJA .
JI M.

U F
C .
F
. b c
A.
L
OF .
Q

e
C v .
QM ,

F
v.

C
. F
G
KMAF ,

U 2
M
: ,
i , ,
C , H
OF:
: Q
K, :
M
N ,
M QKI


A

U 2. I
K ,
M
J
F?
hC
F
JC ,

IP, Q
JC O F
. L
i .
C F
NOJ
K Q
OJ I A
A. O

,

A.
F
, Q
O F e

A.
Q O
O ,
N
C,

COL
HA
eF.
O
O Q
O OO K
F, M
E
C

F. C
C

GA.

M A .

L
C C
J

FF 9 C L

F F
9 C
L

H.

w GF
FJ
Q OJ H
FJ , Cc

GJ 9
C H
e. P
J bM
M F.

P
CQ i

( 40)
e h
.
J MKF
H
F O
.
F
,
C

.
J M
FF FA

P.

K
FF

.
F F
M.
C L
F F A
F.

K
F .
C
IP
K
. H

, Cc

.
H CQ
L


H
. H OM
F 4 E

JK K
M.
J
bM
M

F
A.

 K 18.11.2014

MM .51 M

FJ M
K AwF A
F, .18-&F
F
M M

K Aw
F A .
C
J M
..

F
Q A.

K Aw
F C:
4.2.1955&
24.12.2008
F
F A
A.
L

8 E 8.00
E 12 E
C A.
F
1,23,231
22 ,781 H
P
I AC A

.
F
C
A
N. J
e L e
F
J PO
50
F K
A I
J.
F 22 O
, 17 , 77

M A.
K O 450


. I

O
C
. M
O
F

N .
J F

F 661
.

.10000 O
7 , .5000 O 27
A
OA. F

F 47 C
MM
AC
A.
C.
GCJ
H
C
,
,

M
, P
,
A, eK,
I,
Mx, ,

,
A

. M
J P
P.

J
P
cFF F
K, . 18&
K G
cF
P
vL
H M K
F M,
v
A
. 5,
F .
F
K G
cF .
M P
F .
cF
P ..,

P M
, I - K
C H
A
Q A.
P
- M
A
A. MM
P,
FK, F
K FK

. P vL
Q F
cF I

.
J " Q
Q C
QF I
"
PH.
P vL

MM F
, P P.
P
vL
K C
K
A, cF
F
PH.

, . 18&
FL ,
A
v
L
J H FF
M
J
. F

O P
K
O M
A.

MM, O,
K , M

E,
A

,
A O P
K
, C
,
E
H

FO
W 32 O
O M
.51 FH
M A

A.
C:&
O
NL I
F
b F
A. H
G
FF J

F I
23,000
O
HFGF

.

HFGF
J
O
E C
A.

MG
FF W
J
M
J KC
MJ , J,
J

A.

,
L M P
F
A.
, A
O
O CE
M, i F
M, MJ
J M, O

HI H
MN E
.18&
F
HI
A
K

F
vv FJ
MN
E F.
E HI

KI
A.
F

MM F
M
K H
F v
Q K
H
N
HI J
ML K M
300-
.
GC J
KI
P,

F
A
.

C K
A.
P
F
F HC
H.
PP M
.

JC


KM.
GCJ
MM,
F , M
A C. K
H,

N,
ML
. GC

FK
.

M
M, F
O M
M

F
A.

FO W M

Q F b
F FOO J L MJ
O QI A.
.

F
WFL P

, . 18&
FM I HCF
M
O WF
G . Q
F M 10 A
O
.

K J
c 141.30
, .18--&
3
K J
c 141 J
. J
cH FO
142
F
.

J
F M
aK

.

K J
c 141.30
. c 1038

F A
,
J
FH F .
O

C .
, A

H,
C
,
F
.
C.
.H.,
I iF K
.
, C
vK, MT F
,.H., H,
.H., JF
..., M,
..., F
,
I iF
F
, FL
F A
,
F P
v.w,
PJ

.,
.

.
J 147
a F
MA.
I F GF
. 7477
I. a A
.
J
c 48
. c 950
, F 1860
.

J iF
Av A
O
M
A.
F
G P
A.
L
v Av

K
F
P
. M
Av
WF I
. F

.
F P
WFv F HK
x
P:&
75
F
C WF
A.

GC, H

, M,

O
H


M KM.
F
H
P
A. O
M
F


.


gF Q
I
E

.
GCJ
WFv GF
F HK
Y

.

TQ P .v.M
'L' HH

J
TQ
E

P PH
A

.v.M.
TQ
A.
.v.M
F TQ F
'L' F
Of M
J
JA
. TQ
P P
.v.M.
L HH
K
,

PH
P P M.
P, TI T
A
K HI
PH
A.
G
..
" J TQ
J F
C
A.
C TI T

A.

F. ,
v
P F, GF
.
J

aK A Q .
.
v,
, TI Q, "
. ,

, "

.
A.
F TI
A
i. , TQ
A
.

J

A H G
.
J ,"
PM C GI
A
.v.M.
TQ
A. C
PH P
KM TQ.

EF J I
Y . A J
&C FH F Qv C H
F

K 18.11.2014

Y 25&F :

J F hv
FK
F . Mv
K, . 18 &
K F
Qv G
M GO
P:
KJ ,
,
NP,
F
. C F
H
K A.
,
J
A P
.
N N
F
CJ
, H
J
J
,
O , K
, CP ,
FI G K,

NO
A.

A
I
K.


A.
O J
v.H. F
, v
F

.

A.

J

A.

O ..
A

J LF .
J
HEJ
J

FF .
J
HK v
A. v.H.
I, v
F, .v
,
x A

A
A.

J .
L M
F
G
AM
? Qv
C
M J.

iF K
J K
Y.

. G
GI .
.. Av
, C

M
A.
I
M
F
,
F .
,

...
1& C...
J ,
K

H ,
O dF
AHM, F

K ,
L
F; K
J c 120

9.12.2011
J
b P


Q ,
F,

K

, bF
e I O
F KM
; K
,

H

, I
, M
G G
, K

F N
,
, Central Industrial
Security Force-
F
F
;
cF bH ,
K
J c 142

, 2006 ,
c
(F)
F K F

;
J
c
152
, C c

E
, IF

;
GJ,
I K
M
, I

bQ
A. b


Av
GF
M?
, I
H, I e
H
H C
M
F b
GP F

H
.
K
J, cF
bH, c A

b
GJ
C
.
K
J c
142
F
7.5.2014
cF A
bH, K
J c
142
F
c, I
GO
GI 3
H
M
QJ
P
H.
, C M
H
3.6.2014 K
F J c
142 M

M

LFF
K, F
1.7.2014
. 17.7.2014
M
2 F
K J c
142
M F
.

J
WN.
HJ
M
H F
GF, F
M

. K
H
5 M
cF PM
, F
P GF
.
b

CJ
,
, F
M M,
I C H
M

b G
P GF.
I O
H
K H
F M
b GP M
FM
GFJ P
J
O
MA.
GF

PJ C
C P

KM ,
cFF M
P
M
P.
M

P
GF
K
P
O
F. ,
K H
P cF
F

Y P
K
OF
. cF
C 7.5.2014
A bH
F

Y

cF
M
M.
Y M
cF bH GF

K

M.

e, GH
A P
M
OJ ?
Y


. Y
F

A.
F
G T
.
KJ
KJ
.
F
MF

A.
Y
G O
A.
E
, FK
. KJ
C
A.

GFM
F H
,
K
M ..
Av ,
hv
L
.

Q
..Av
.

c G
..
Av.

C
.... I
F
, 75 iF

GO E
N
A
M. O
A
I A
. K ..
Av G
.
O
K
H
F i
A.
.. Av
H i
MF
A.

. .H.
A. .H.

A.

Al
A.
Q K
M.
F
.
I M


OJ.
MM
O
HJ J
.

25&
F
F
Qv C H
F A
.
P.
J
GA .
, h, W,
A
.

cFF
M
cF 7.5.2014
A bH F
223 PH
M F

E P
cFF

KM e
M

N

F- 1
.
(1)(1)This is an application filed by the State of
Kerala seeking clarifications
or guidance on para 223 of the
judgment dated 7.5.2014 of
the Constitution Bench of this
Honble Court in O.S.No.3 of
2006.
KM.


FA, I
H F

P
KM
.
cF
F M
P
cF MFO
18-& W MF 2 .
cF
7.5.2014
bH F,

Y
M
G
J GJ

M e
I M
PM O
HH
M

CI
GF
KM A.
M
P
K, P
P
GF Q
GF

.
K
J c 31.10.2014
F 2
EM 136
. 1.11.2014

J 2.4
C c
. 3.11.2014

K
c
FK P P
.
J
c, K
c
AP
J c
A. F
C
GF
K
JL O
c 142
c
P
OJ
cFF
N
M.
,
KJ

CM
I C e
PJ GF
.
K Fc H
J G


f cF
F GJ
GJ,
, K cK G
H J
cI F
F

22.8.2013-& FKJ
F ,
F I
C FJP

F
P
,
K

K

F F
F F
GF
F

F P

C
M

H 2.9.2013
LF
.
,

F
c

L CJ
K F M
..C.,
K, . 18&
L HF
F A

CJ K
A K
F .
K G
C
J
MM

K F
M
M
P A .
G C J

H A, N

GC

. K
G P C

F N

M GCJ
O
.
K
K P
GC

.. 41-& C .C,
v.M.M A K N
F ..v. H.P
... A . C v. (K MF G
), 4& .F,
E H.Ov, F
O, v.I .
6.9.2013
17.9.2013
. P,
F c
7.10.2013 H
F F, C
F
F MK
F P
N
K
F c
F C
I M
KM.
F c
, 18.11.2013 F
J F
I
KM.
f O b

F

F F
P K
9.10.2013 F
C
.
, ,

c
I
F
F Q
G


OJ
GF
K
F
F
12.8.2014
.
, K
F

M,
C F
CF
cI
F
F
,


M K
.

5.2.2007- O F

G F
K M
e
M

J
M.

GJ, c
K
M PJ,
K c
F

,
F
,
F
I C
Q

K. G
FO c
GF

cFF 22.11.1991-
O J O
PH.
, K F
G F
, W
G I
, F
C
F
F
. G
,
, cI
F P
KM c
F J
IF F

,
, N F
P

M
PM
F
,
H
HJ
J
C
GF,
, cI,
c F
c
J
J F

I


C P
, 12.11.2014
H

H.
, I

C F
F F C

c
,
O
C P
F
.
C
P
C

18.11.2014
cFF
I C
H
. F P,
c
J

C

K
.
, P
GF I
P
O J
KM
MA.
K Fc H
,

K H
,
I H
, I e
H ,
IO

IF
K G



C M
.
C M
O
NJ
C
,
K J
141.35 M
c .

M
M PM

F

A.
GJ,
I C e
F P
O J
I

GF
P,
P
I F
,
F

GM

,

PJ,
I
P KO

GF
A.

P.