Professional Documents
Culture Documents
That The Universe Could Have Formed Spontaneously From Nothing
That The Universe Could Have Formed Spontaneously From Nothing
That The Universe Could Have Formed Spontaneously From Nothing
A Mathematical Proof That The Universe Could Have Formed Spontaneously From Nothing The Physics arXiv Blog Me
ThatTheUniverse
CouldHave
Formed
Spontaneously
FromNothing
Cosmologistsassumethatnatural
quantumfluctuationsallowedthe
BigBangtohappen
spontaneously.Nowtheyhavea
mathematicalproof
Oneofthegreattheoriesofmoderncosmologyisthattheuniverse
beganinaBigBang.Thisisnotjustanideabutascientifictheory
backedupbynumerouslinesofevidence.
Forastart,thereisthecosmicmicrowavebackground,whichisa
kindofechoofthebigbangthenthereistheongoingexpansionof
thecosmos,whichwhenimaginedbackwards,hintsataBigBang
data:text/html;charset=utf-8,%3Csection%20class%3D%22%20section--bottomCenter%20section-image--coverFade%20is-ima
1/5
2/1/2015
A Mathematical Proof That The Universe Could Have Formed Spontaneously From Nothing The Physics arXiv Blog Me
typeoriginandtheabundanceoftheprimordialelements,suchas
helium4,helium3,deuteriumandsoon,canallbecalculated
usingthetheory.
Butthatstillleavesahugepuzzle.WhatcausedtheBigBangitself?
Formanyyears,cosmologistshavereliedontheideathatthe
universeformedspontaneously,thattheBigBangwastheresultof
quantumfluctuationsinwhichtheUniversecameintoexistence
fromnothing.
Thatsplausible,givenwhatweknowaboutquantummechanics.
Butphysicistsreallyneedmoreamathematicalprooftogivethe
ideaflesh.
TodaytheygettheirwishthankstotheworkofDongshanHeand
buddiesattheWuhanInstituteofPhysicsandMathematicsin
China.Theseguyshavecomeupwiththefirstrigorousproofthat
theBigBangcouldindeedhaveoccurredspontaneouslybecauseof
quantumfluctuations.
data:text/html;charset=utf-8,%3Csection%20class%3D%22%20section--bottomCenter%20section-image--coverFade%20is-ima
2/5
2/1/2015
A Mathematical Proof That The Universe Could Have Formed Spontaneously From Nothing The Physics arXiv Blog Me
Thenewproofisbasedonaspecialsetofsolutionstoa
mathematicalentityknownastheWheelerDeWittequation.Inthe
firsthalfofthe20thcentury,cosmologistsstruggledtocombinethe
twopillarsofmodernphysicsquantummechanicsandgeneral
relativityinawaythatreasonablydescribedtheuniverse.Asfar
astheycouldtell,thesetheorieswereentirelyatoddswitheach
other.
Thebreakthroughcameinthe1960swhenthephysicistsJohn
WheelerandBryceDeWittcombinedthesepreviouslyincompatible
ideasinamathematicalframeworknowknownastheWheeler
DeWittequation.ThenewworkofDongshanandcoexploressome
newsolutionstothisequation.
AttheheartoftheirthinkingisHeisenbergsuncertaintyprinciple.
Thisallowsasmallemptyspacetocomeintoexistence
probabilisticallyduetofluctuationsinwhatphysicistscallthe
metastablefalsevacuum.
Whenthishappens,therearetwopossibilities.Ifthisbubbleof
spacedoesnotexpandrapidly,itdisappearsagainalmostinstantly.
Butifthebubblecanexpandtoalargeenoughsize,thenauniverse
iscreatedinawaythatisirreversible.
Thequestionis:doestheWheelerDeWittequationallowthis?We
provethatonceasmalltruevacuumbubbleiscreated,ithasthe
chancetoexpandexponentially,sayDongshanandco.
Theirapproachistoconsiderasphericalbubblethatisentirely
describedbyitsradius.Theythenderivetheequationthatdescribes
data:text/html;charset=utf-8,%3Csection%20class%3D%22%20section--bottomCenter%20section-image--coverFade%20is-ima
3/5
2/1/2015
A Mathematical Proof That The Universe Could Have Formed Spontaneously From Nothing The Physics arXiv Blog Me
therateatwhichthisradiuscanexpand.Theythenconsiderthree
scenariosforthegeometryofthebubblewhetherclosed,openor
flat.
Ineachofthesecases,theyfindasolutioninwhichthebubblecan
expandexponentiallyandtherebyreachasizeinwhichauniverse
canformaBigBang.
Thatsaresultthatcosmologistsshouldbeabletobuildon.Italso
hasaninterestingcorollary.
Oneimportantfactorintodaysmodelsoftheuniverseiscalledthe
cosmologicalconstant.Thisisatermthatdescribestheenergy
densityofthevacuumofspace.Itwasoriginallyintroducedby
Einsteininhis1917generaltheoryofrelativityandlaterabandoned
byhimafterHubblesdiscoverythattheuniversewasexpanding.
Untilthe1990s,mostcosmologistsassumedthatthecosmological
constantwaszero.Butmorerecently,cosmologistshavefound
evidencethatsomethingiscausingtheexpansionoftheuniverseto
accelerate,implyingthatthecosmologicalconstantcannotbezero.
Soanynewtheoryoftheuniversemustallowforanonzerovalue
ofthecosmologicalconstant.
WhatplaystheroleofthecosmologicalconstantinDongshanand
cosnewtheory?Interestingly,theseguyssayaquantityknownas
thequantumpotentialplaystheroleofcosmologicalconstantinthe
newsolutions.
Thispotentialcomesfromanideacalledpilotwavetheory
data:text/html;charset=utf-8,%3Csection%20class%3D%22%20section--bottomCenter%20section-image--coverFade%20is-ima
4/5
2/1/2015
A Mathematical Proof That The Universe Could Have Formed Spontaneously From Nothing The Physics arXiv Blog Me
developedinthemid20thcenturybythephysicistDavidBohm.
Thistheoryreproducesalloftheconventionalpredictionsof
quantummechanicsbutatthepriceofacceptinganadditionalterm
knownasthequantumpotential.
Thetheoryhastheeffectofmakingquantummechanicsentirely
deterministicsincethequantumpotentialcanbeusedtoworkout
thingsliketheactualpositionoftheparticle.
However,mainstreamphysicistshave
nevertakentoBohmsideabecause
itspredictionsareidenticaltothe
conventionalversionofthetheoryso
thereisnoexperimentalwayof
tellingthemapart.However,itforces
physiciststoacceptaprobabilistic
explanationforthenatureofreality,
somethingtheyaregenerallyhappytoaccept.
Thefactthatthequantumpotentialisanecessarypartofthisnew
mathematicalderivationoftheoriginoftheuniverseisfascinating.
PerhapsitstimetogiveBohmsideasanotherspinroundthe
block.
data:text/html;charset=utf-8,%3Csection%20class%3D%22%20section--bottomCenter%20section-image--coverFade%20is-ima
5/5