Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Sync.: The Future of Technology, Media & Telecoms
Sync.: The Future of Technology, Media & Telecoms
Issue 64
July 2013
Cyrus Mewawalla
cyrus@researchcm.com
+44 (0) 20 3393 3866
www.researchcm.com
Authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority
CM Research
22 Upper Grosvenor Street
London W1K 7PE
July 2013
(Vol. III)
Contents
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
PART I: HARDWARE
TechnologyHardware:ExecutiveSummary
Connecteddevices
ConsumerElectronics
10
ComponentMakers
12
PCs,Servers,StorageandNetworking
14
TelecomEquipment
16
Semiconductors
18
20
TechnologySoftware:ExecutiveSummary
21
ApplicationsSoftware
22
InfrastructureSoftwareandtheCloud
24
SecuritySoftware
26
VideoGameSoftware
28
ITServices
30
www.researchcm.com 2
(Vol. III)
July 2013
32
Internet&Media:ExecutiveSummary
33
Internet(ecommerce)
34
Internet(socialmedia)
36
Advertising
38
Film&Television
40
Publishing
42
44
TelecomServices:ExecutiveSummary
45
Cable&SatelliteOperators
46
TelecomOperators
48
51
54
55
www.researchcm.com 3
July 2013
(Vol. III)
Executive Summary
In this report, the third volume in our Global TMT Trend Forecast series, we identify the major disruptive technologies that we will see in
2014 and predict how they will impact the worlds largest technology, media and telecom (TMT) companies. Our objective is to offer
investors and industry executives a comprehensive trend forecast for the global TMT sector over the next 12 months.
To set the scene, the chart below shows the relative market performance of 17 TMT sectors since the beginning of 2008, benchmarked
against the S&P 500 index. Future performance will be largely impacted by the trends outlined in this report.
Over the last five years internet companies, software developers and data centres have been the most prominent outperformers
whilst consumer electronics companies, telecom equipment makers, publishers and telecom operators have underperformed.
Global TMT sector: Cumulative 5 year share price performance
200%
2008
150%
2009
2010
2011
2012
2013
100%
50%
0%
50%
100%
Hardware
Software
Telecoms
Source: Company data, FT, Bloomberg, S&P Capital IQ, CM Research. Bars show the cumulative sector performance from 1 January 2008 to the periods ending 31 December 2008, 2009, 2010, 2011, 2012 and 30 June 2013 of a selection of stocks that we believe are
bellwethers for each sector aggregated on an equal weighting basis. Note: Whilst the performance of every sector is shown over a 5 year period, the performance of social media is shown over a two year period as most social media companies were not listed 5 years ago.
www.researchcm.com 4
(Vol. III)
July 2013
July 2013
(Vol. III)
Part I: Hardware
www.researchcm.com 6
July 2013
(Vol. III)
www.researchcm.com 7
July 2013
(Vol. III)
Connected devices
Dominant theme: Wearable computing devices will be the next big thing to follow smartphones and tablets.
Outlook: China is set to dominate shipment numbers for smart connected devices for several years, heralding an era of cheap
phablets where Huawei, ZTE and Lenovo may edge out western rivals.
Theme
Whats happening?
Leaders
Laggards
Wearable
devices
Apple, Google
Alibaba, Amazon,
Baidu, Microsoft,
RIM, Sony, Nokia,
LG, Tencent
Apple copycats
Apple, Google,
Microsoft, Baidu, Alibaba,
Tencent, Huawei,
Facebook, Amazon
New mobile
ecosystem
entrants
Apple, Google
Cheap
smartphones
Apple, Microsoft,
Nokia, HTC, RIM, LG
Litigation
Apple, Google
Conflicts of
interest
Apple
Google, Microsoft
www.researchcm.com 8
July 2013
(Vol. III)
Outlook
Today the world has 2.8bn internet users. Of these, at least 1.5bn access the internet wirelessly. Thats up from 1.1bn a year ago. The next
billion users are all likely to use their smartphone as their primary means to access the internet. Mobile now makes up 16% of all internet
traffic. This internet traffic is monetised most effectively by those with the largest mobile ecosystems. So far Apple and Google dominate,
with a joint 92% market share of the mobile operating system market.
But with China set to remain the worlds biggest mobile internet market for the foreseeable future it is already home to 29% of the worlds
mobile internet subscribers two things will change. Cheaper smartphones will flood the market, benefitting local manufacturers such as
Huawei, ZTE and Xiaomi at the expense of dearer western rivals. And Google Androids hold on the low-end operating software market
may be side-lined by home-grown software from the likes of Huawei, Tencent, Baidu or Alibaba.
Connected devices: Cumulative 5 year share price performance
200%
150%
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012
2013
100%
50%
0%
50%
100%
www.researchcm.com 9
July 2013
(Vol. III)
Consumer Electronics
Dominant theme: Internet TV is likely to be the next big consumer product, but there is no clear winner for investors as yet.
Outlook: As with smartphones and tablets, consumer electronics hardware makers are seeing their profits sucked out by
software ecosystems. Asia is fighting back: Samsung may yet revive Bada and LG has bought HPs WebOS.
Theme
Whats happening?
Leaders
Laggards
Internet TV
Apple, Google,
Microsoft, Fanhattan,
Roku, Boxee
Slaves to the
ecosystem
Amazon, Alibaba,
Apple, Facebook,
Google, Microsoft,
Netflix
Samsung, LG,
Nintendo, Nokia,
Philips, Sony, Canon
Robotics
iRobot, Microsoft,
Apple, Google
On-shoring
Apple, Google
Screen
technology
Sony
Samsung, LG
www.researchcm.com 10
July 2013
(Vol. III)
Outlook
As the share performance chart below aptly illustrates, only two of the worlds leading consumer electronics companies are trading at
higher valuations than five and half years ago. They are Apple and Samsung. The consumer electronics sector has become polarised by
the internet. The big mobile internet ecosystems Apple, Google, Microsoft, Baidu and Tencent are sucking all the profits out of
hardware manufacturing, reducing hardware-only makers to low-margin producers of commodity products. The next big product cycle for
the industry is internet TV. Here too the lions share of the profits is destined to go to internet ecosystems rather than hardware makers.
Samsung, the most profitable hardware-only maker, owes its manufacturing prowess to a strategy of relentless hardware innovation. It is
likely to hold that lead with its new hardware innovations such as flexible screens or eye-scrolling technology. But without its own software
ecosystem it tried and failed with Bada it is doomed to fail ultimately. LG Electronics, conscious of this dilemma, purchased WebOS
from HP for use in its smart TV platform. If it makes the most of this opportunity LG could become the first Asian player to compete
successfully on a software level with Apple, Google and Microsoft, giving it a slim chance to claim a decent slug of the profits of the
internet TV market.
Consumer electronics: Cumulative 5 year share price performance
200%
150%
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012
2013
100%
50%
0%
50%
100%
www.researchcm.com 11
July 2013
(Vol. III)
Component Makers
Dominant theme: 3D printing could lead to the democratisation of manufacturing, changing how we design, manufacture and
repair virtually everything we use today from medical devices to aircraft parts to houses.
Outlook: Consumer electronics devices are increasingly controlled by two dominant operating systems: iOS and Android now
account for over 90% of smartphones and tablets shipped worldwide. Successful component makers will need to align their
businesses more and more to these software ecosystems.
Theme
Whats happening?
Leaders
Laggards
3D printing
3D Systems,
Stratasys
Flexible displays
Samsung
Apple, Google, LG
Display, Sony,
Universal Display
Apple supply
chain
TSMC, TPK, LG
Display
Robotics
Slaves to the
ecosystem
AAC Technologies,
Goertek
www.researchcm.com 12
July 2013
(Vol. III)
Outlook
Five years after the start of the financial crisis, two thirds of the component makers in our stock universe below are still trading at valuations
below those at 1 January 2008.
As profits in the consumer electronics industry shift from hardware makers to internet ecosystems, the profitability of component makers
will be linked more and more to how successfully they compete for coveted places in the supply chains of the leading operating software
developers such as Apple and Google rather than the leading hardware manufacturers such as Samsung. AAC Technologies which
makes miniature microphones used in the iPhone and iPad is a case in point.
Component makers: Cumulative 5 year share price performance
350%
300%
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012
2013
250%
200%
150%
100%
50%
0%
50%
100%
www.researchcm.com 13
July 2013
(Vol. III)
Dominant theme: SDNs will soon threaten the dominance of networking equipment leaders like Cisco and Juniper Networks.
Outlook: Microsofts disastrous Windows 8 launch has had an adverse impact on the hardware sector. Outlook remains bleak
for PC/ notebook makers and HDD storage; rosy for servers, tablets, SSD storage and niche networking products.
Theme
Whats happening?
Leaders
Laggards
Software defined
networks (SDNs)
VMware, Netflix,
Amazon, Google
Cisco, Juniper
Networks
Cloud
Samsung, Asustek,
ARM, Quanta,
Lenovo, Google
Intel, Microsoft
Death of
Windows 8
Apple, Google,
Samsung, Lenovo,
Asustek
Microsoft
Storage
technology
Seagate, Western
Digital
Open source
storage
Backblaze, RedHat
Micro servers
ARM
Intel
WAN
optimization
Brocade, Fusion-IO,
SGI, Riverbed
Technology
www.researchcm.com 14
July 2013
(Vol. III)
Outlook
In Q1 2013, PC shipments declined 14% year on year, much worse than expected, and largely down to the poor reception for Windows 8.
Lenovo fared better than any other PC maker. In the short term, Microsofts troubles may give hardware makers slightly more competitive
power as they play Microsoft off against Google Android Indeed Samsung and Asustek have already started, by releasing dual operating
system tablets. IHS expects hard drive (HDD) sales to fall 12% in 2013 to $32.7bn as solid-state drives (SSDs) march ahead. Last
quarters worldwide enterprise expenditure figures for the storage services sector generally have also been lacklustre.
Looking ahead, we see continued turmoil in the PCs, Servers, Networking and Storage sectors. Storage market leaders like EMC and
NetApp will see threats both from open source and a host of new entrants into the sector. But one problem that remains in the networking
and storage sectors is data latency. Niche players in networking technology who can make data flow faster stand to benefit. Three names
immediately spring to mind: Brocade, Riverbed Technology, and Fusion-IO.
PCs, Servers, Storage and Networking: Cumulative 5 year share price performance
150%
100%
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012
2013
50%
0%
50%
100%
www.researchcm.com 15
July 2013
(Vol. III)
Telecom Equipment
Dominant theme: As mobile technology moves to an all-IP environment, leading providers of fixed IP networking equipment
such as Cisco will move into the wireless equipment market thus far dominated by Ericsson.
Outlook: The near term outlook for telecom equipment will be dominated by an increasingly vicious US-China dispute over
state-sponsored cyber-attacks. Trade embargos and subsequent retaliation measures are likely to impact Huawei more than
Cisco and Ericsson.
Theme
Whats happening?
Leaders
Laggards
Mobile moves to
IP
Ericsson, Alcatel
Lucent, Nokia
Siemens
Trade wars
Alcatel Lucent,
Ericsson, Nokia
Siemens, Cisco
Huawei, ZTE
LTE/Wi-Fi
integration
Aruba Networks,
Cisco
Ericsson
M&A
Nokia, RIM
Alcatel Lucent
Patents wars
www.researchcm.com 16
July 2013
(Vol. III)
Outlook
Much of the telecom equipment sector, as the chart below illustrates, is still trading at pre-2008 valuation levels. Note that Huawei the
largest telecom equipment player in the world by revenues does not feature on our share performance chart below because it is privately
owned. As 4G (OFDM) technology proliferates, Huaweis lead is likely to increase for two reasons. First, the biggest problem with 4G
technology is call handover from CDMA (3G) and TDMA (GSM) technology. The best way to ensure seamless handover is to buy handsets
and network infrastructure from the same vendor. Huawei is the only vendor that currently provides an end to end product range. Second,
since 4G is an all-IP platform, Huawei, a low-cost manufacturer of fixed IP equipment, has yet another advantage. All this is bad news for
Cisco, Ericsson, Alcatel Lucent and Juniper Networks.
But politics may change the balance of power. The US has started a trade war, pointing its finger at Huawei and its alleged military
connections. Depending on how this war of words unfolds, western equipment players may be handed an advantage in western markets.
Telecom equipment: Cumulative 5 year share price performance
200%
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012
2013
150%
100%
50%
0%
50%
100%
www.researchcm.com 17
July 2013
(Vol. III)
Semiconductors
Dominant theme: Cheaper smartphones and tablets are entering the market, many made in China, switching demand for
chips from expensive US chipmakers like Qualcomm to cheaper Chinese ones, like MediaTek and Spreadtrum.
Outlook: Chinese wireless chipmakers are best positioned for the rush to mass market phablets.
Theme
Whats happening?
Leaders
Laggards
Cheaper
smartphones
MediaTek,
Spreadtrum
Qualcomm, Marvell,
Broadcom
Internet of things
Microchip Tech,
Freescale, Asia
Optical, Infineon,
Micronas, Omnivision
Apples supply
chain
Graphics chips
MediaTek, ARM
Samsung
Imagination Tech,
Nvidia, Qualcomm
www.researchcm.com 18
July 2013
(Vol. III)
Outlook
In 2013, Gartner estimates that 2.35bn IT devices will be shipped. Of these, 305m will be PCs and laptops, 201m will be tablets and 1.8bn
will be mobile phones. Within the mobile phone category, smartphone shipments are expected to reach 958m units this year, up from
722m last year. With connected devices being the most lucrative end market for chips, it is not unsurprising that the fortunes of many chip
companies are tied to the most profitable IT device maker, Apple. Chip companies in Apples supply chain like Cirrus Logic, Skyworks
Solutions, Omnivision, Avago and ARM saw their share prices rise with Apples until mid-September 2012, when Apples shares peaked.
Now, during the next phase of the smartphone cycle when smartphones go mass market, particularly in China it is the turn of Chinese
chip makers to rise. MediaTek and Spreadtrum are closely integrated with the supply chains of Huawei, Xiaomi and ZTE and are likely to
benefit as Chinese smartphone penetration grows from 15% to 50% (the steepest section of the typical S-shaped growth curve) over the
next three years.
Semiconductors: Cumulative 5 year share price performance
600%
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012
2013
500%
400%
300%
200%
100%
0%
100%
www.researchcm.com 19
July 2013
(Vol. III)
www.researchcm.com 20
July 2013
(Vol. III)
www.researchcm.com 21
July 2013
(Vol. III)
Applications Software
Dominant theme: Apple and Google pioneered the internet ecosystem. Now the race is on to build software ecosystems that
include ERP platforms, Big Data solutions, cloud services, cyber-security and search functionality.
Outlook: Large software groups, unable to innovate fast enough, will continue to acquire smaller application software houses.
Theme
Whats happening?
Leaders
Laggards
Software
ecosystems
Targets: small/
medium sized
application software
companies
Acquirers: IBM,
Oracle, SAP, Apple,
Google, Yahoo,
Microsoft, Baidu
Mobile-first,
app-centric
start-ups
Twitter, Jolla,
Amazon, Mozilla,
UCWeb, Opera
Apple, Facebook,
Google, Baidu,
Tencent
Cloud business
model
If monthly subscription fees replace larger, oneoff license fees, revenues will fall in the short
term. Whilst Adobe has succeeded here, other
houses may issue profit warnings.
Adobe, Salesforce,
NetSuite, Apple,
Google, Red Hat,
VMware, Citrix, EMC
Microsoft, SAP,
Oracle, IBM
Computer aided
design (CAD)
software
PTC, Autodesk,
Dassault Systemes
Big Data
Amazon, Baidu,
Google, Facebook,
Alibaba, IBM
SAP, Oracle
www.researchcm.com 22
July 2013
(Vol. III)
Outlook
Three industry trends are making life uncomfortable for many traditional software companies: the move to app platforms, the move to the
cloud and the move to the mobile internet. In addition to these new dimensions, there are a myriad of emerging technology cycles
including 3D printing, robotics, software defined networks, smart TVs, cloud computing and mobile payments that are all software based.
All of this is heralding a new golden age for applications software.
Large software groups, unable to innovate fast enough, are acquiring specialist software houses. The M&A timeline charts on pages 50
and 51 illustrate the scale of the upheaval taking place in the software industry: software companies account for just 11% of the market
capitalization of the global TMT sector, by our estimates, but made up 55% of M&A transactions, by value, in the TMT sector over the last
three years.
With the exception of IBM, SAP and Oracle, many of the application software companies listed below are likely to become takeover targets
as the sector consolidates further.
Applications software: Cumulative 5 year share price performance
300%
250%
200%
150%
100%
50%
0%
50%
100%
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012
2013
www.researchcm.com 23
July 2013
(Vol. III)
Dominant theme: As IT infrastructure moves into the cloud, virtualisation products act as the gateway. Niche players like
VMware and Citrix Systems now face fierce competition from the bigger software houses like Microsoft.
Outlook: Infrastructure software stocks are the most susceptible to a dramatic fall in value during an economic downturn.
Theme
Whats happening?
Leaders
Laggards
Virtualization
Microsoft
VMware, Citrix
Cloud ERP
NetSuite, WorkDay,
Salesforce
Open source
Amazon, Citrix,
VMware, Microsoft,
EMC, NetApp
Rackspace, Equinix,
HP, Dell
Software defined
networks
Google, VMware
Wi-Fi offloading
Mobile networks are increasingly offloading heavy data users onto Wi-Fi.
Aruba Networks
www.researchcm.com 24
July 2013
(Vol. III)
Outlook
In the short term, the big trends likely to impact investors in communications infrastructure stocks are the cloud and, particularly,
virtualisation. Microsoft, VMware and Citrix are fighting it out in the virtualization market. Meanwhile, Oracle, IBM and SAP are fighting
cloud-only ERP platforms like Salesforce, NetSuite and WorkDay by making cloud acquisitions of their own. The incumbents legacy
product base of expensive, difficult-to-implement, semi-redundant ERP systems turn customers away.
In the longer term, software defined networks (SDNs) could have a far more profound impact than the cloud. Just as internet protocol (IP)
standards made proprietary telecom equipment makers like Lucent and Nortel less relevant, so SDNs may turn todays leading IP
networking equipment makers like Cisco and Juniper Networks into commodity box makers, with all the power to control data flows
resting with software developers, using standards like the Open Flow protocol as the communication medium between these boxes. The
winners will be the communications infrastructure software companies who will be able to program the networking equipment boxes to
carry their traffic efficiently without having to invest in expensive hardware boxes.
Infrastructure software and cloud: Cumulative 5 year share price performance
800%
700%
600%
500%
400%
300%
200%
100%
0%
100%
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012
2013
www.researchcm.com 25
July 2013
(Vol. III)
Security Software
Dominant theme: Our interviews with executives in the insurance industry confirm that board level of awareness,
understanding and accountability for cyber-threats is low. As a result, corporations have long underinvested in cyber-security
assets.
Outlook: When a respected CEO gets fired for mishandling cyber-risk market sentiment will change: boards will be forced to
increase expenditure on cyber-security services, lifting earnings prospects for the cyber-security industry.
Theme
Whats happening?
Leaders
Laggards
Corporate
awareness
levels
Check Point,
Sourcefire,
Symantec, Qihoo,
Verint, Websense
Fortinet, ProofPoint,
Banks, stock
exchanges, telecom
operators, power
grids
Software
ecosystems
Targets: Fortinet,
ProofPoint, Palo Alto,
Sourcefire, Verint
Trade wars
Alcatel-Lucent, Cisco,
Ericsson, Intel
Huawei (unlisted),
ZTE
Credit fraud
Experian, Equifax
Regulation
www.researchcm.com 26
July 2013
(Vol. III)
Outlook
Recent technology trends have triggered new cyber-security risks for corporations: the bring-your-own-device (BYOD) trend coupled with
the fact that mobile workers travel all over the globe mean that corporate IT managers have to protect corporate data across more IT
platforms at a time when budgets are tight. The explosion in personal data online makes it easier for criminal gangs to steal identities and
fraudulently access bank accounts. The proliferation of third party apps has led to a dramatic rise in reported malware. In 2012, the number
of malicious web links grew by almost 600% worldwide, according to Websenses 2013 Threat Report.
As IT infrastructure and software move to the cloud, physical security gets replaced by cyber-security but a worldwide skills shortage
means that many IT managers are out of their depth when it comes to cyber security. In the longer term, the move to software defined
networks is the most worrying trend: as network hardware becomes a commodity, cyber-security risk which is currently contained in the
top four layers of the 7-layer OSI protocol stack (applications, presentation, session, transport) spreads to the bottom three layers
(network, data, physical) as well. Boards arent taking cyber-security seriously. The catalyst is just around the corner. When a respected
CEO gets fired for being asleep at the wheel during a cyber-attack, boards will be forced to spend more on cyber-security and market
sentiment will change in favour of the cyber-security sector.
Cyber-security software: Cumulative 5 year share price performance
700%
2008
600%
2009
2010
2011
2012
2013
500%
400%
300%
200%
100%
0%
100%
Ahnlab
CheckPoint
Software
F5Networks
FSecure
Gemalto
NiceSystems
Sourcefire
Symantec
TrendMicro
VerintSystems
Verisign
Websense
www.researchcm.com 27
July 2013
(Vol. III)
Dominant theme: Mobile and online games developers are losing competitive power to the big apps platforms like Apple and
the big social media platforms like Facebook and Tencent. Longer term, HTML5 technology may reverse that trend.
Outlook: The shift from console games to online and mobile games is happening faster than many expected. Mobile-first
games developers like Gameloft and Gamevil could benefit from being in the right space at the right time.
Theme
Whats happening?
Leaders
Laggards
The platform
effect
Amazon, Apple,
DeNA, Google, Gree,
Facebook, Tencent
Perfect World,
Zynga, Activision
Blizzard, EA,
Ubisoft, Zynga
HTML5
Gameloft, Gamevil,
Activision, EA,
Netease, Ubisoft,
NCsoft
Apple, Google,
Microsoft
Motion sensors
Microsoft,
Leap Motion
Nintendo
Smart TV
strategy
Freemium model
failing
Tencent
Changyou, Perfect
World, Giant
Interactive
www.researchcm.com 28
July 2013
(Vol. III)
Outlook
Sales of console games worldwide peaked at $32bn in 2008, according to PwC. By end 2012 they had fallen 15% to $27bn. PwC expect
console game sales to start rising again, but we believe they will continue to decline. The online gaming market was worth $19.5bn last
year, up 80% on 2008, and is expected to increase another 60% by 2016 China accounts for 37% of this market. The mobile games
market was worth $10bn last year, up 73% on 2008, and expected to increase another 44% by 2016 Korea, Japan and China account for
22%, 17% and 10% respectively of this market.
Whilst the online and mobile gaming sectors are growing, a sizeable chunk of the industrys profits are likely to gravitate towards the big
platforms Apple, Google, Facebook and Tencent. Meanwhile, as Microsoft, Sony and Nintendo see their customers move towards
cheaper gaming platforms, they are working hard to adapt their games consoles to become the digital hub for home entertainment, though
with limited success so far. For now, however, the mobile games developers like Gameloft and Gamevil seem to be in the sweet spot.
Gaming software: Cumulative 5 year share price performance
600%
500%
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012
2013
400%
300%
200%
100%
0%
100%
www.researchcm.com 29
July 2013
(Vol. III)
IT Services
Dominant theme: The IT services industrys business model is changing: the typical customer is now the Chief Marketing
Officer rather than the Chief Technology Officer; its key partnerships are shifting from ERP vendors to cloud services vendors;
most importantly, its future as a middleman in a world where cheap, cloud-based services can be bought directly is threatened.
Theme
Whats happening?
Leaders
Laggards
Big Data
Amazon, IBM,
Oracle, Google,
Facebook, SAP,
Microsoft
Accenture, Atos,
Capgemini, Infosys,
TCS, Tieto, WIPRO,
Apple, HP, Dell,
Digital Marketing
Acxiom, Marketo,
Constant Contact,
ValueClick,
Responsys
Cloud services
Amazon, EMC,
NetSuite, Red Hat,
Salesforce, Teradata
Accenture, Atos,
Capgemini, IBM, TCS
Tieto, Infosys, Wipro
Open source
databases
Red Hat
Software
ecosystems
Citrix, Fortinet,
NetApp, Progress
Software, Red Hat,
SGI, Informatica
www.researchcm.com 30
July 2013
(Vol. III)
Outlook
The IT services sector is in a digital transition phase that, in many ways, resembles the retail sector. It risks becoming irrelevant as internet
services companies cut out the middle man and offer IT services storage, data analytics, ERP systems directly via the cloud. Ironically,
Amazon who destroyed much of the retail sector is now taking direct aim at the IT services industry with its enterprise cloud offering.
Revenue models for IT services companies are changing. One-off fees for expensive, large-scale ERP systems implementations are being
replaced by monthly subscription fees for Infrastructure-as-a-service (IAAS). That could reduce revenues in the short term and raise
upfront costs (because IT services companies would have to invest in their own infrastructure). Oracles partnership with Salesforce,
announced last month, is an admission that Salesforces cloud-based strategy is the future.
On 12 March 2013, we issued a Sell note on the Indian IT services sector. Since then there have been profit warnings not only from
Infosys but right across the industry from IBM, SAP, Oracle, and Tieto. We may be witnessing the start of a painful industry restructuring.
IT Services: Cumulative 5 year share price performance
200%
150%
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012
2013
100%
50%
0%
50%
100%
www.researchcm.com 31
(Vol. III)
July 2013
www.researchcm.com 32
July 2013
(Vol. III)
www.researchcm.com 33
July 2013
(Vol. III)
Internet (e-commerce)
Dominant theme: Maps and mobile payments are the new battlegrounds in the war for supremacy of the mobile internet.
Outlook: A host of new mobile ecosystems are coming onto the market, threatening the dominance of Apple and Google.
Theme
Whats happening?
Leaders
Laggards
Map wars
Google, Nokia,
Tomtom
Mobile payments
eBay, Square,
Groupon, Alibaba,
Tencent, Monitise
Amazon, Apple,
Google, Facebook,
VeriFone
Mobile
ecosystems
Apple, Google
Alibaba, Baidu,
Huawei, Jolla,
Microsoft, Mozilla,
Tencent, Easou,
Ubuntu, UCweb
Tax avoidance
Internet of
Things
Amazon, Apple,
eBay, Google,
Facebook, Renren
Google, Facebook,
Apple, Microsoft,
Huawei
www.researchcm.com 34
July 2013
(Vol. III)
Outlook
Global B2C e-commerce sales hit $1.04tn in 2012, up 22% on 2011, according to eMarketer. In 2013, they are expected to grow by 17% to
$1.22tn. The US accounts for 32%, China 14% and Japan 10% of the global total. But China is catching up fast. Whilst the US and
Japanese markets are expected to grow this year by 12% and 7% respectively, Chinas will grow by 65%.
In our last TMT Trends report (CM Research, 24 September 2012) we concluded that profits would gravitate towards the leading internet
ecosystems Apple, Amazon and Google in the west and Baidu, Tencent and Alibaba (whenever it listed) in China. Now the story has
moved on. There are far more entrants offering competing internet ecosystems and there is certainly room for five or six ecosystems to coexist in each market. Investors should watch Huawei, Jolla, Microsoft, Mozilla, Opera, Qihoo 360, Tizen, Ubuntu, UCweb and Yahoo.
Internet (e-commerce): Cumulative 5 year share price performance
1500%
1300%
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012
2013
1100%
900%
700%
500%
300%
100%
100%
www.researchcm.com 35
July 2013
(Vol. III)
Outlook: The fortunes of social media companies have been mixed. With so many unproven business models lining up for
IPO, investors should do their homework before investing.
Theme
Whats happening?
Leaders
Laggards
Crowd-funding
Kickstarter,
Lending club,
Wonga
New social
sharing models
Waze, Yelp,
TripAdvisor,
Pinterest, Instagram,
Tumblr, Foursquare
Wearable
connected
devices
Apple, Google
Microsoft, Yahoo,
Facebook
Internet TV
Apple, Google,
Microsoft, Fanhattan,
Roku, Boxee
Facebook, Twitter,
Yahoo, Tencent,
Sina, Renren
Virtual
currencies
Alibaba, Amazon,
eBay, Facebook,
Monitise, Square,
Tencent, Bitcoin
Data privacy
Apple, Google,
Facebook, Twitter,
Groupon, Microsoft,
Linked In
www.researchcm.com 36
July 2013
(Vol. III)
Outlook
A year ago, many analysts including us expressed concern that the big social networks would have trouble moving to mobile. Smaller
screens, fewer keyboard strokes and shorter attention spans made it harder to monetize mobile social networkers. By Q1 2013, those
concerns had evaporated as Facebook and Google both saw mobile ad revenues rise steeply. Facebook reported that 30% of its revenue
base that quarter had come from mobile.
But now we have bigger concerns.
The world has 2.8bn internet users, half of whom already use social media, according to eMarketer. The next billion internet users will likely
be poorer, less literate and live in conflict zones. Most will use social media and most will do so via mobile. What these users will want of
social networks will differ markedly from the wants of their current user base. The nature of social networks is such that they are constantly
under threat from the next big thing. Current threats include virtual currencies, crowd-funding, wearable devices, internet TV and, of course,
regulators. We expect high volatility over the next 12 months in the social media sector as these trends unfold, taking some of the
established leaders by surprise.
Social networks: Cumulative 1-year share price performance
Note: Social networks simply havent been around for long enough for us to show 5 year share price performance data
250%
200%
2012
2013
Gree
Groupon
150%
100%
50%
0%
50%
100%
Baidu
Demand
Media
DeNa
Mail.Ru
Mixi
Netease
NHN
Renren
Shutterfly
Sina
Youku
Tudou
www.researchcm.com 37
July 2013
(Vol. III)
Advertising
Dominant theme: As advertising expenditure moves away from TV towards mobile, advertisers fortunes will be tied ever
more closely to the technology platforms that control internet TV and mobile advertising. With respect to internet TV, a winning
platform has not yet emerged. But with respect to mobile advertising, Google already commands over half the global market.
Outlook: Traditional advertisers probably have about a year before disruptive forces in the TV advertising market hit them.
Theme
Whats happening?
Leaders
Laggards
Digital marketing
Targets: Marketo,
Constant Contact
Demand Media
Groupon, inContact
Millennial Media
Moneysupermarket
Responsys
Acquirers: Dentsu,
Havas, Interpublic,
Publicis, WPP
Internet TV
Dentsu, Havas,
Interpublic, Omnicom,
Publicis, WPP
Software
ecosystems
Dentsu, Havas,
Interpublic, Omnicom,
Publicis, WPP
Mobile Internet
Google, Facebook,
Twitter, Millennial
Media
Media buying
agencies
www.researchcm.com 38
July 2013
(Vol. III)
Outlook
For the last decade a third of advertising revenues have come from TV broadcasting. In 2012, the TV advertising market was worth $200m,
double the internet advertising market. If you believe the TV industry is about to be hit by a new wave of disruptive technologies
spearheaded by Apple and Google, then expect the advertising industry to undergo a bumpy ride. Apple, Google and Microsoft will almost
certainly integrate their existing mobile operating systems and ad platforms with their forthcoming internet TV offerings. Without regulatory
intervention, they will suck the profits out of the TV advertising industry as they have done in so many other old media industries. Simply
generating a third of their revenues from digital marketing services will not be enough to secure WPP, Havas and Publicis future because
those digital market services will be sold to a duopoly of advertising platforms who will dictate pricing terms.
More broadly, it is interesting to note from the chart below that many new media digital marketing companies have not done much better
than the traditional media advertising agencies they have supposedly usurped. .
Advertising: Cumulative 5 year share price performance
250%
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012
2013
200%
150%
100%
50%
0%
50%
100%
www.researchcm.com 39
July 2013
(Vol. III)
Dominant theme: Broadcasters are resisting the integration of live TV into the internet TV offerings of Apple, Google and
Microsoft. Their hope is that an independent platform like FanTV will emerge that gives them more control.
Outlook: In the short term, the price of popular content is likely to be bid up as technology companies keen to get into the
internet TV hardware game realise that success is as much to do with access to licenced content as it is to do with great
technology.
Theme
Whats happening?
Leaders
Laggards
Third screens
Fanhattan, Apple,
Google, Microsoft, LG
Cisco, Ericsson, Intel,
Pace, TiVo, Roku,
Netflix, Amazon,
Samsung, LG, Sony
HTML 5
BSkyB, CBS,
Comcast, Disney,
Discovery, Lions
Gate, News Corp,
Time Warner,
Viacom, Zee
www.researchcm.com 40
July 2013
(Vol. III)
Outlook
The clumsy smart TVs sold today are just the precursor for what is to come. True internet TV will allow the customer to access any
content live sports, broadcast TV, catch-up TV or on-demand programming through a single electronic programming guide (EPG)
without the latency one gets today. But we are still in the very early stages of this technology cycle streamed TV content still represents
less than 2% of the pay-TV market.
Internet TV offers big prizes. At $200bn, the TV advertising market is still double the size of the internet advertising market. Soon your
smartphone or tablet will be the second or third screen used to control your television. Apple, Google and Microsoft are well positioned to
win in this market. Several other players Cisco, Intel, Ericsson, Sony, Samsung, LG, BT, Netflix, Facebook and Amazon are lining up to
play too. Start-ups like Zeebox and Fanhattan offer platforms that are independent of Apple or Google and so appeal to the broadcasters.
But their products will never sell in the high street unless they include access to a wide range of content. So in the short term owners of
popular content will remain in the driving seat.
Film and Television: Cumulative 5 year share price performance
300%
250%
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012
2013
200%
150%
100%
50%
0%
50%
100%
www.researchcm.com 41
July 2013
(Vol. III)
Publishing
Dominant theme: Like the music industry before it, the publishing industry finds itself outmanoeuvred by the internet.
Outlook: Whilst DMGT has shown how smart management can turn around an incumbent in a declining industry, the overall
outlook for publishers remains bleak.
Theme
Whats happening?
Leaders
Laggards
Business
turnaround
models
DMGT, Pearson
Googles digital
library
Hachette (Lagardere),
HarperCollins (News Corp),
Macmillan (Holtzbrinck),
Simon & Schuster (CBS),
Penguin (Pearson)
Apples eBook
anti-trust case
Amazon
Apple
Hachette (Lagardere),
HarperCollins (News Corp),
Macmillan (Holtzbrinck),
Simon & Schuster (CBS),
Penguin (Pearson)
www.researchcm.com 42
July 2013
(Vol. III)
Outlook
The publishing sector is in the thralls of a downward spiral. Take the global newspaper market. It has shrunk by 14% since 2005 because
of the internet. Yet by end 2012, the industry had only managed to convert 0.5% of its circulation revenues to digital format. Magazine
publishing tells a similar story. With books, things are even worse. In the US and Europe over 15% of book sales are digital and 90% of the
market is cornered by Amazon. Moreover, the big five book publishers have all reached a settlement with the US Department of Justice on
a price fixing scam originally engineered by Apple.
Daily Mail & General Trust and Pearson stand out as two companies that have braved this new world and come out on top. Each has a
focused digital strategy and each is leaving its traditional print publishing businesses to die. But they are exceptions to the rule. For now,
we expect more carnage in the publishing sector.
Publishing: Cumulative 5 year share price performance
150%
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012
2013
100%
50%
0%
50%
100%
www.researchcm.com 43
July 2013
(Vol. III)
www.researchcm.com 44
July 2013
(Vol. III)
www.researchcm.com 45
July 2013
(Vol. III)
Dominant theme: The optimum business model is one that combines in-house content with in-house distribution. But the
weakness in these cable and satellite ecosystems is the lack of a common software platform.
Outlook: Apple, Google and others are using software to enter these tightly guarded ecosystems. One day they will succeed.
Theme
Whats happening?
Leaders
Laggards
Content-filled
walled gardens
BSkyB, Comcast
Software
Apple, Google,
Microsoft, Sony,
Samsung, Fanhattan
Dual screening
Amazon, Apple,
Facebook, Google,
Netflix, Zeebox,
Fanhattan
IPTV
BT, PCCW,
Chunghwa Telecom,
SingTel, Korea
Telecom, Verizon
www.researchcm.com 46
July 2013
(Vol. III)
Outlook
Many cable and satellite operators realised several years ago that they would become dumb pipes unless they built integrated ecosystems
that packaged in-house content with their distribution platform. But the missing element from most cable ecosystems is software. Industry
outsiders are looking to exploit this weakness and invade the pay-TV market by developing internet TV software that is as user friendly as
current electronic programming guides (EPGs).
Technology companies like Apple and Google are further down the line in terms of developing TV operating systems. But the missing
element of their internet ecosystems is content, especially live TV content.
Both industries can help each other fill in the gaps in their business model, but neither is likely to let the other into their domain. For cable
and satellite operators, the best strategy appears to be to acquire technology platforms built by start-ups like Fanhattan and stream their
content to connected TVs via web-based apps. Comcast and BskyB are investing in such technologies. The cable and satellite operators
have a hell of a fight ahead of them, but they are more prepared than the telecom operators ever were and some of them might even win.
Cable & satellite operators: Cumulative 5 year share price performance
200%
150%
100%
50%
0%
50%
100%
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012
2013
www.researchcm.com 47
July 2013
(Vol. III)
Telecom Operators
Dominant theme: The Internet of Things, mobile payments, Big Data, software defined networks, internet TV and cloud
services all present potential new revenue streams for operators as voice, messaging and internet access revenues decline.
Outlook: As long as operators sit on the regulated side of the internet, they are unlikely to substantially increase profits.
Theme
Whats happening?
Leaders
Laggards
Internet of
Things
Regulation
Situation fluid:
Regulators all over
the world are
debating net
neutrality, data
privacy, internet
censorship
Mobile payments
Software defined
networks (SDNs)
Most telecom
operators
www.researchcm.com 48
July 2013
(Vol. III)
Outlook
Voice and messaging revenues have peaked for many operators. Indeed, instant messaging apps like WhatsApp which now has 250m
users is destroying operators messaging revenues faster than anyone expected only a year ago. Internet access services are becoming
less profitable because data traffic is rising at a rate of 100% per annum prompting higher capex, but competition and regulatory controls
make it difficult for operators to raise prices in line with higher investment costs. If operators do not find new revenue streams soon, their
profitability levels will decline rapidly, especially in mobile.
Operator strategies on how to combat this decline differ: BT is trying to move into the TV market with its live sports channels. AT&T,
Verizon, PCCW and many others are doing the same. SK Telecom has been the most active operator in the world in selling OTT services
such as mobile TV and online games over its advanced LTE network. Telefonica, Verizon and China Telecom are moving into cloud
services. China Mobile is investing in a platform supporting the Internet of Things but is also using its political clout to force internet
companies like Tencent (whose WeChat service generates a lot of network traffic) to pay more.
North American telecom operators: Cumulative 5 year share price performance
60%
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012
2013
40%
20%
0%
20%
40%
60%
80%
100%
AT&T
CenturyLink
Clearwire
FrontierComms
Level3
RogersComms
SprintNextel
Telus
USCellular
Verizon
Windstream
www.researchcm.com 49
July 2013
(Vol. III)
150%
2009
2010
2011
2012
2013
100%
50%
0%
50%
100%
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012
2013
100%
50%
0%
50%
100%
www.researchcm.com 50
July 2013
(Vol. III)
Q2
2013
Q1
2013
Q4
2012
StratasysacquiresMakerBot(3Dprinting)
GannettacquiresBelo(TVbroadcasting)
GoogleacquiresWaze(Crowdsourcedtrafficnavigationsoftware)
Salesforce.comacquiresExactTarget(Cloudmarketingsoftware)
SprintacquiresClearwire(Telecomoperators)
CiscoacquiresJouleX(Energymanagemnetsoftwarefordatacentres)
SoftbankacquiresSprintNextel(Telecomoperators)
IBMacquiresSoftlayer(Webhostingandcloudinfrastructure)
BainCapitalandGoldenGateCapitalacquiresBMCSoftware(Software
YahooacquiresTumblr(Shortformbloggingwithpictures)
IntelacquiresStonesoftOyj(internetsecuritynetworkfirewall)
BaiduacquiresPPS(internetvideoprovider)
CiscoacquiresUbiquisys(smallcells)
EricssonacquiresMicrosoft'sMediaroomIPTVbusiness(IPTV)
AmazonacquiresGoodreads(Bookreviewsite)
LibertyGlobalacquiresVirginMedia(Cableoperators)
GoogleacquiresChannelIntelligence(ecommercetracking)
IBMacquiresStarAnalytics(Softwareanalytics)
OracleacquiresAcmePacket(Sessionbordercontrol)
CiscoacquiresIntucell(Softwaredefinednetworks)
BelkinacquiresLinksys(Networkinggear)
ArrisacquiresMotoHome(TVsettopboxes)
NielsonacquiresArbitron(Digitalratings)
AdtranacquiresNokiaSiemensBroadbandAccessbusiness(Telecom
WindstreamacquiresPaetec(Telecomoperators)
OracleacquiresEloqua(Cloudmarketingplatform)
0
10
15
20
Acquisitionprice(US$bn)
25
30
www.researchcm.com 51
July 2013
(Vol. III)
Global Mergers and Acquisitions in Technology, Media and Telecoms: Two year transaction history (cont.)
Q4
2012
Q3
2012
Q2
2012
RedPrairieacquiresJDASoftware(Applicationsoftware(supplychain
PricelineacquiresKayak(Onlinetravel)
CiscoacquiresCaridien(Networktrafficmanagementsoftware)
CiscoacquiresMeraki(Cloudnetworking)
VerintSystemsacquiresComverseTech(cybersecurity)
IBMacquiresKenexa(HRsoftware)
CarlyleacquiresGettyImages(Distributorofstockphotosandvideos)
AT&TacquiresNextWave(wirelessspectrum)
ZayoacquiresAbovenet(Telecomoperators)
ConsolidatedCommsacquiresSurewest(Telecomoperators)
CiscoacquiresCloupia(Datacentresoftware)
OracleacquiresInvolver(Socialmediamarketing)
CicsoacquiresNDS(Videoandcontentdeliverysolutions)
GoogleacquiresFrommers(travelguides)
OracleacquiresXsigo(datacentrenetworkingvirutalisation)
GoogleacquiresWildfire(socialmediaadsolutionsprovider)
AppleacquiresAuthentec(FingerprintID,mobilepayments)
VmwareacquiresNicira(Networkefficiency)
DentsuacquiresAegis(Advertising)
SonyacquiresGaikai(Cloudgaming)
OracleacquiresCollectiveIntellect(Cloudbasedsocialintelligence)
MicrosoftacquiresYammer(Socialmedia)
LamResearchacquiresNovellus(Semiconductorequipmentmaker)
AgilentTechacquiresDakoDenmark(Lifesciencediagnosticstools)
Salesforce.comacquiresBuddyMedia(socialmedia)
DellacquiresQuestSoftware(Softwaremanagement)
FacebookacquiresKarma(Socialmediaapp)
OracleacquiresVitrue(Socialmarketingplatform)
0
2
3
4
Acquisitionprice(US$bn)
www.researchcm.com 52
July 2013
(Vol. III)
Global Mergers and Acquisitions in Technology, Media and Telecoms: Two year transaction history (cont.)
Q2
2012
Q1
2012
Q4
2011
LinkedInacquiresSlideshare(Socialmedia)
SAPacquiresAriba(ecommerce(enterprisesoftwareforprocurement))
StratasysacquiresObjet(3Dprinting)
FacebookacquiresInstagram(Photosharingservice)
WesternDigitalacquiresVivitiTech(formerlyHitachiGlobalStorage
Zayoacquires360networks(Telecomoperators)
YouKuacquiresTudou(onlinevideosite)
OracleacquiresTaleo(HRsoftware)
SingTelacquiresamobee(providerofmobileadvertisingservicesto
3DSystemsacquiresZCorp(3Dprinting)
AT&TacquiresSpectrumfromQualcomm(mobilespectrum)
AppleacquiresAnobitTechnologies(Flashmemorymaker)
SeagateacquiresSamsungElectronicsHardDisk(Harddiskdrives)
VerizonacquiresAWSspectrumfromComcast,TimeWarnerCableand
SAPacquiresSuccessFactors(OnlineHRsoftware)
BlinkxacquiresPrimeVisibilityMedia(Digitaladvertising)
HuaweiacquiresHuaweiSymantecJV(50%)(Cybersecuritysoftware)
OracleacquiresRightNow(Cloudcomputing)
PermiraacquiresGenesys(Callcentreservices)
SKTelecomsacquiresHynix(21%)(Chipmanufacturing)
BroadcomacquiresNetlogic(Wirelesschips)
IBMacquiresAlgorithmics(Riskmanagementsoftwareforbanks)
HPacquiresAutonomy(Searchengine)
GoogleacquiresMotorolaMobility(Technologypatents)
Apple,RIM,MicrosoftacquiresNortelNetworks(Technologypatents)
TeradataacquiresAsterData(Dataanalysissoftware)
VodafoneacquiresVodafoneEssar(33%)(telecomconsolidation)
HTCacquiresS3Graphics(Mobilephonepatents)
eBayacquiresZong(Mobilepayments)
0
6
8
10
Acquisitionprice(US$bn)
12
14
www.researchcm.com 53
July 2013
(Vol. III)
Our clients:
Asset managers
Family offices
Industry executives
Consultancy houses
Governments
Technology, Media
& Telecoms
Thematic
Research
Strategy
Forward
thinking
www.researchcm.com 54
July 2013
(Vol. III)
Cyber-security: Evidence from the insurance industry indicates that the cyber-security sector could be the most undervalued sector in the global technology
space.
Robotics: 2012 was a pivotal year for the robot industry. As the market for industrial robots began to flat line, growth in the market for service robots is on
course to take off. Our report looks at who's who in robotics, how this industry will develop and how investors should play this theme.
3D printing: The 3D printing technology cycle will change how we design, manufacture and repair virtually everything we use today from medical devices to
aircraft parts. It could be as disruptive to the manufacturing sector as the internet was to retailing. This report looks at who's who in 3D printing and who's
impacted.
Indian IT Services: Since 2004, India's IT services sector has been growing at a compound annual growth rate of 22%. This year that growth is expected to
slow to 11%. Most analysts think this is a temporary blip. We believe a series of emerging trends make it something more worrying. Indian IT services are
overvalued.
Apples valuation: We look at why Apple shares have declined 35% since their peak and why we believe they are a Buy again.
Top 10 Tech Predictions for 2013: This report sets out ten predictions in the world of technology, media and telecoms for 2013, together with their
investment implications.
Internet regulation: A geopolitical fault line is forming that will pit emerging markets like Russia and China against the USA. The catalyst is a dispute over the
regulation of the internet. Will the balance of power in the internet sector shift from US internet companies to national telecom operators?
Tips from a Forensic Accountant: In the wake of the HP/Autonomy accounting scandal, how do investors protect themselves from the risk of accounting
fraud? We provide a forensic accountant's ten-point checklist on what to look for.
UK tech stocks to watch: Four UK technology companies that may be going places.
Chinese social media: How will China's booming social media sector - including heavyweights such as Tencent, Sina, Renren and Baidu - perform if the
incoming political regime clamps down on censorship?
Big Data beginners' guide: Ten things investors need to know about Big Data as an investment theme.
Smartphone sector trends: We identify 10 emerging trends in the smartphone sector and devise a scorecard system to rank the major players.
Facebook overvalued: Why Facebook is too expensive?
The Cloud: How will the shift from the PC generation to the Cloud generation impact the major players in the global technology sector?
Big Data: How will Big Data impact the major players in the global technology, media and telecom sectors?
Mobile Payments: Mobile payments will take off soon, but investors should be careful which technology platform they invest in.
Internet advertising: Google is undervalued and Baidu is overvalued.
Future of Wireless (Vol. II): A mobile bandwidth shortage is coming. This will change the pricing equilibrium dynamics of the internet, forcing regulators to
intervene. LTE, spectrum auctions, software defined networks and new internet pricing models are all potential solutions.
Future of Wireless (Vol. I): The mobile internet is at a watershed. Several technology cycles are now unravelling simultaneously.
www.researchcm.com 55
(Vol. III)
July 2013
About CM Research
CM Research is an independent research provider with a blue chip list of institutional clients. We analyse emerging trends in the technology, media and telecom
sectors and develop them into global investment themes, highlighting the winners and losers. At a time when many of our competitors have had their reputations mired
by conflicts of interest, we fiercely guard our independence. Our business model is based on independence, exclusivity and experience. CM Research is a member of
the European Association of Independent Research Providers (EuroIRP). CM Research is authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority.
Contact CM Research
Cyrus Mewawalla
cyrus@researchcm.com
www.researchcm.com
22 Upper Grosvenor Street, London W1K 7PE, UK
+44 20 3393 3866
Important Disclosures
This document is issued by CM Research (CMR) solely for our clients. This document may not be reproduced, redistributed or passed to any other person in whole or in part for any purpose without our written consent. This document is
provided for information purposes only and should not be regarded as an offer, solicitation, invitation, inducement or recommendation relating to the subscription, purchase or sale of any security or other financial instrument. This document
does not constitute, and should not be interpreted as, investment advice. It is accordingly recommended that you should seek independent advice from a suitably qualified professional advisor before taking any decisions in relation to the
investments detailed herein. All expressions of opinions and estimates constitute a judgement and, unless otherwise stated, are those of the author and the research department of CMR only, and are subject to change without notice. CMR is
under no obligation to update the information contained herein. Whilst CMR has taken all reasonable care to ensure that the information contained in this document is not untrue or misleading at the time of publication, CMR cannot guarantee
its accuracy or completeness, and you should not act on it without first independently verifying its contents. This document is not guaranteed to be a complete statement or summary of any securities, markets, reports or developments referred
to herein. No representation or warranty either expressed or implied is made, nor responsibility of any kind is accepted, by CMR, its directors, officers, employees or analysts either as to the accuracy or completeness of any information
contained in this document nor should it be relied on as such. No liability whatsoever is accepted by CMR, its directors, officers, employees or analysts for any loss, whether direct or consequential, arising whether directly or indirectly as a
result of the recipient acting on the content of this document, including, without limitation, lost profits arising from the use of this document or any of its contents. This document is provided with the understanding that CMR is not acting in a
fiduciary capacity and it is not a personal recommendation to you. Investing in securities entails risks. Past performance is not necessarily a guide to future performance. The value of and the income produced by products may fluctuate, so
that an investor may get back less than he invested. Investments in the entities and/or the securities or other financial instruments referred to are not suitable for all investors and this document should not be relied upon in substitution for the
exercise of independent judgment in relation to any such investment. The stated price of any securities mentioned herein will generally be the closing price at the end of any of the three business days immediately prior to the publication date
on this document. This stated price is not a representation that any transaction can be effected at this price. The material in this document is not intended for distribution or use outside the United Kingdom. This material is not directed at you if
CMR is prohibited or restricted by any legislation or regulation in any jurisdiction from making it available to you. CMR and its analysts are remunerated for providing investment research to professional investors, corporations, other research
institutions and consultancy houses. CMR, its directors, officers, employees and clients may have or take positions in the securities or entities mentioned in this document. Any of these circumstances could create, or be perceived as creating,
conflicts of interest. CMR analysts are not censored in any way and are free to express their personal opinions. As a result, CMR may have issued other documents that are inconsistent with and reach different conclusions from, the
information contained in this document. Those documents reflect the different assumptions, views and analytical methods of their authors. No director, officer or employee of CMR is on the board of directors of any company referenced herein
and no one at any such referenced company is on the board of directors of CMR. CM Research is a trading name of CHM Research Limited. CHM Research Limited is registered in England, under company No. 07251947 and registered
address Amaris, Hill Close, Harrow-on-the-Hill, Middlesex HA1 3PQ, United Kingdom. CHM Research Limited is authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority (Firm Reference Number: 579360).
CHM Research Limited 2013. This document, including the text and graphics, is subject to copyright protection under English law and, through international treaties, other countries. No part of the contents or materials available in this
document may be reproduced, licensed, sold, hired, published, transmitted, modified, adapted, publicly displayed, broadcast or otherwise made available in any way without the prior written permission of CHM Research Limited. All rights
reserved.
Analysts Certification
The analysts involved in the production of this document hereby certify that the views expressed in this document accurately reflect their personal views about the securities mentioned herein. The analysts point out that they may buy, sell or
already have taken positions in the securities, and related financial instruments, mentioned in this document.
www.researchcm.com 56