Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Draft Philippines Report - Institutions and Policies On DRM and CCA - 30june2010
Draft Philippines Report - Institutions and Policies On DRM and CCA - 30june2010
Policy Landscapes
of Disaster Risk
Reduction and
Climate Change
Adaptation
In Asia and the
Pacific
PHILIPPI
NES
June 2010
(DRAFT)
PHILIPPINES
INSTITUTIONAL AND POLICY LANDSCAPES OF DISASTER
RISK REDUCTION AND
CLIMATE CHANGE ADAPTATION IN ASIA AND PACIFIC
SUMMARY
Development faces a growing threat from a changing climate particularly through
the impact of more extreme events. The Philippines has been considered as highly
vulnerable to current (i.e. natural disasters), as well as future climate-related risks.
The development goals of the country can be severely affected and a great number
of population and livelihoods can be at risk. Managing risks to development requires
the systematic integration of disaster risk management (DRM) and climate change
adaptation (CCA) in terms of project activities, coordination and financing
mechanisms. However, until now these agendas have evolved independently in
terms of institutions and policies.
Over the years, there have been several planning and development projects that
have addressed these issues. The outputs of these projects although substantial,
have not found their way into the scientific literature. As a result they have not been
cited in assessments such as those by the IPCC and thus failed to inform policy
making. This UN ISDR-ICRAF project tries to address those gaps in knowledge
transfer. This paper reviewed the initiatives of the Philippines on DRM and CCA and
assesses the progress of its integration to development planning.
30 June 2010
Significant program and strategy advances have been gained in strengthening DRM;
and pioneering steps, including key national policies and institutions for promoting
CCA. The recently approved policies on both DRM and CCA, and other adaptation
projects feature clear overlaps, including efforts to harmonize coordination
structures. From the review of the DRM and CCA institutional and policy landscapes
of the country, the study provides recommendations and immediate priorities for
the Philippines to facilitate effective integration of DRM and CCA into policies and
programs.
PROJECT BACKGROUND
It is being increasingly recognized that mainstreaming of an integrated approach to
CCA and DRR into key sectoral policies, such as agriculture and natural resource
management and urban development, is essential. Indeed, it is crucial for climate
change and disaster risk reduction initiatives to work in tandem and that synergies
between the two are further articulated. The need exists for a better exchange of
knowledge that will benefit of both disciplines experiences, in order to avoid
inappropriate adaptation practices and unsustainable policies.
In many Southeast Asian countries, poor and highly vulnerable sectors of the
population depend on natural resources for livelihoods. This is has given rise to
attempts to develop an ecosystems-based approach to CCA and DRR. Over the
years, there have been several planning and development projects that have
addressed these issues. The outputs of these projects although substantial, have
not found their way into the scientific literature. In many cases they have very
limited circulation. As a result they have not been cited in assessments such as
those by the IPCC and thus failed to inform policy making.
This project will address those gaps in knowledge transfer. Results will be available
to the concurrent investigations that are synthesizing national and regional CCADRR efforts and to IPCC as peer reviewed resource documents.
The project generally aims to provide research; writing and literature review to
compile a thorough review of relevant documentation, published and unpublished,
on the subject of climate change adaptation and the relationship to disaster risk
reduction in the Philippines. Specifically:
30 June 2010
30 June 2010
ACRONYMS
ADB
Asian Development Bank
ADPC
Asian Disaster Preparedness Center
APSEMO
Albay Public Safety and Emergency Management Office
AusAid
Australia Agency for International Development
BSWM
Bureau of Soils and Management
CAS
Country Assistance Strategy
CBDRM
Community-based Disaster Risk Management
CCA
Climate Change Adaptation
CIRCA
Center for Initiatives and Research on Climate Adaptation
CLUP
Comprehensive Land Use Plane
DA
Department of Agriculture
DENR
Department of Environment and Natural Resources
DepEd
Department of Education
DFID
Department for International Development
DILG
Department of Interior and Local Government
DIPECHO
European Commission Humanitarian Aid Department Disaster
Preparedness Program
DOE
Department of Energy
DOH
Department of Health
DPWH
Department of Public Works and Highways
DRR/M
Disaster Risk Reduction/Management
EC
European Commission
EU
European Union
EIA
Environmental Impact Assessment
EMB
Environmental Management Bureau
ENSO
El Nino Southern Oscillation
EWS
Early Warning System
GCM
Global Circulation Model
GEF
Global Environment Facility
GFDRR
Global Facility for Disaster Reduction and Recovery
GIS
Geographic Information System
GSIS
Government Service Insurance System
GTZ
German Technical Cooperation
HFA
Hyogo Framework of Action
IEC
Information, Education and Communication
IFRC
International Federation for Red Cross and Red Crescent Societies
INGO
International Non-government Organization
IPCC
Inter-governmental Panel on Climate Change
IRA
Internal Revenue Allotment
30 June 2010
UNCHR
UNFCCC
UNISDR
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Summary
Project Background
Acronyms
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
INTRODUCTION
DISASTER RISK MANAGEMENT IN THE PHILIPPINES
2.1
Policy Framework
2.2
Institutions working in DRR
2.3
Disaster management strategies
2.4
Key areas of progress and challenges
2.5
Good examples of DRR
CLIMATE CHANGE ADAPTATION INITIATIVES
3.1
Policy and Strategy Framework
3.2
Regional organizations working in CCA
3.3
Climate change adaptation activities in AP
3.4
The capacity of CCA in AP
3.5
Good examples of CCA
PROGRESS IN INTEGRATION OF CCA AND DRR
4.1
Overall gaps and needs
4.2
Current mechanisms and incentives
4.3
Current barriers to integration
CONCLUSIONS AND RECOMMENDATIONS
5.1
Conclusions
5.2
Recommendations
30 June 2010
References
Appendices
A. Disaster Risk Management Institutions
B. DRM Projects
C. Climate Change Adaptation Institutions
D. CCA Projects
E. Sectoral Initiatives and Key Issues
F. Annotated Bibliography
List of Boxes
Box
Box
Box
Box
Box
1
2
3
4
5
List of Figures
Figure 1 Overlap between Climate Change Adaptation and Disaster Risk Reduction
Figure 2 Number of people affected by natural disasters in the Philippines, 19722009
Figure 3 Total economic damages from natural disasters in Southeast Asia, 19702008
Figure 4 National government agencies working on DRR/M based on NDCC
Framework
Figure 5 National Framework Strategy on Climate Change
List of Tables
30 June 2010
30 June 2010
1. INTRODUCTION
Climate change has been dubbed the most serious threat facing humanity and the
last four decades have witnessed increased effort to understand the scientific
processes behind it, as well as identify the most sustainable measures for reversing
trends and adjusting to their consequences (Schipper, 2006). There is now a broad
consensus in the scientific community on the reality of human-induced climate
change. The Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) concluded in its
fourth assessment report (AR4) that it is 90 - 99 percent likely that the rise in global
atmospheric temperature since the mid-19th century has been caused by human
activities (IPCC, 2007). Among the predicted impacts associated with these rise in
temperature is the more frequent and powerful extreme climatic events, such as
storms, heat waves and hurricanes.
The Asia Pacific region suffers the most from extreme weather events and these will
likely increase with climate change. The Philippines, being an archipelagic country,
is highly vulnerable to climate-related hazards. Farmers have to cope with an
average of 20 tropical cyclones a year as well as recurring El Nio Southern
Oscillation (ENSO) events. Especially vulnerable are upland farmers who rely on
rainfall for water supply. The country is also characterized by several mountains /
hilly lands and is dominated by problem soils characterized by steep slopes and
fertility limitations.
It is increasingly being recognized that adaptation to climate change must be
considered as an integral element of development and poverty reduction efforts
(Burton et. al., 2006). The achievement of development goals is already jeopardized
by current and still intensifying level of disaster risks while vulnerability to these
hazards is also increasing due to poverty, urbanization, environmental degradation
and population growth (Oslo Policy Forum, 2008; DFID, 2003). At the World
Conference on Disaster Reduction, held in Kobe, Japan in 2005, climate change was
acknowledged as an underlying threat in relation to disasters in its outcome
strategy: the Hyogo Framework for Action (HFA) 2005-2015 (UNISDR, 2007). The
Philippine government adopted the HFA with the goal of substantially reducing
disaster losses by 2015 in terms of lives and social, economic and environmental
costs (GFDRR, undated).
30 June 2010
30 June 2010
Natural disasters and climate change present considerable challenges for poverty
reduction and sustainable development affecting a range of socio-economic
systems (IPCC, 2001 as cited by Thomalla, et.al., 2006). Since the late 1990s, there
has been increasing recognition of the need to mainstream disaster risk reduction
into development - that is to consider and address risks emanating from natural
hazards in medium-term strategic frameworks and institutional structures.
Increasing appreciation of the need to mainstream DRR into development was
formalized in January 2005 when the HFA 2005-2015 was adopted by the World
Conference on Disaster Reduction. Thus, a number of development organizations
have begun efforts to mainstream DRR into their work, undertaking various
institutional, policy and program changes (Benson and Twigg, 2007).
In the same line, adaptation to climate change has risen on the agendas of
researchers, practitioners, and decision-makers in a variety of fields (Mc Gray et.al.,
2007). This emerging consensus is driving the recognition that adaptation to climate
change must be considered as an integral element of development and poverty
reduction efforts (Burton et. al., 2006) and, more particularly, will need to facilitate
adaptation to the effects of climate change (Mc Gray et.al. 2007). The achievement
of development goals is already jeopardized by current and still intensifying level of
disaster risks while vulnerability to these hazards is also increasing due to poverty,
urbanization, environmental degradation and population growth (Oslo Policy Forum,
2008; DFID, 2003).
Adaptation to climate change is considered especially relevant for developing
countries, where societies are already struggling to meet the challenges posed by
existing climate variability (Yamin et al. 2005; Adger et al., 2003), and are therefore
expected to be the most adversely affected by climate change (McCarthy et al.,
10
30 June 2010
Figure 1. Overlap between CCA and DRR (Mitchell and van Aalst, 2008)
However, while reducing the risk of weather extremes is a substantial component of
managing climate risk and of the overlap between DRR and adaptation (Figure 1),
DRR does not equal adaptation, and effective disaster risk management in a
changing climate is more than business as usual (Mitchell and van Aalst, 2008).
11
30 June 2010
The Philippines is considered one of the most disaster-prone countries in the world
(Bildan, 2003; World Bank, 2005). The countrys exposure to disasters is to a
significant extent due to its geographical location and physical characteristics. It lies
along the Western Pacific Basin (a generator of climatic conditions such as
monsoons, thunderstorms, inter-tropical convergence zone (ITCZ), typhoons, among
others) making it a path of an average of 20 tropical cyclones annually, nine of
which makes a landfall. Climate risk includes exposure to super typhoons, and other
extreme weather, El Nio-related droughts, projected rainfall change and projected
temperature increase. The country is also vulnerable to the El Nio Southern
Oscillation (ENSO). ENSO-droughts have become much more frequent in the 1990s
(2-year average recurrence interval) compared to the 1970s and 1980s
(approximately 4-year interval). This year, the country is experiencing another ENSO
event. The Department of Agriculture (DA) estimates that the total agricultural
production losses under a mild El Nio scenario could reach P8.09 billion, and
P20.46 billion under a severe dry spell (Martin, 2010). Flooding is another hazard
facing the country due to rains brought about by typhoons and the monsoon.
The risk to human life from natural disasters in the Philippines has increased
dramatically over the past generation (PRB, 2006). From 1971 to 2000, natural
disasters killed about 34,000 people in the country, but from 1990 to 2000, natural
disasters killed or disrupted the lives of 35 million people (Figure 2). It is expected
that climate change will exacerbate existing stresses in the country (The Philippines
Initial National Communication, 1999). Recent studies in the Philippines showed
that water resources, natural ecosystems and local communities are vulnerable to
climate change (Lasco, et.al. 2008; Villamor and Boquiren 2008; Perez 2002a and
b).
12
Figure 2. Number of people affected by natural disasters in the Philippines, 19722009 (Source: UN ESCAP)
30 June 2010
Along with Southeast Asian countries such as Thailand and Indonesia, the
Philippines is among the lower middle income countries (GFDRR, undated). The high
risk due to the hazards above can affect long-term economic development and
foreign investments. Figure 3 shows the total amount of economic damages of
natural disasters in Southeast Asia from 1970 to 2008. Natural hazards are part and
parcel of the Philippine environment, but disasters happen because human
settlements, infrastructure, people and their economic activities are placed where
hazards happen. Costs of disaster impacts are borne by government, communities,
and individual households, thus threatening socio-economic development gains.
Thus, consideration of natural hazards and related risks in institutional programming
and policies may be critical in securing sustainable development in the longer term
and ensuring the effectiveness of organizations individual country strategies
(Benson and Twigg, 2007).
Figure 3. Total economic damages from natural disasters in Southeast Asia, 1970-
13
Policy Framework
Being vulnerable to various hazards, the Philippines have a long history of and a
rich experience in disaster management. It has developed an extensive institutional
structure for preparing for and responding to disasters.
2.1.1 Legal Basis and Organization
30 June 2010
The National Disaster Coordinating Council (NDCC) is the highest policy making
body and the focal organization for disaster management in the country. It was
established through the Presidential Decree (PD) 1566 in 1978. Its establishment led
to disaster coordination from the national to regional to the lowest government unit
(barangay). The basic function of NDCC is to advice the President on the status of
national disaster preparedness and management plans, and recommends the
declaration of state of calamity and the release of the national calamity fund,
together with the Regional Disaster Coordinating Councils and Local Disaster
Coordinating Council. The NDCC establishes the priorities in the allocation of funds,
services, and relief supplied and plays an advisory role to lower DCCs through the
Office of Civil Defense by issuing guidelines. The disaster coordinating councils is an
inter-institutional arrangement or collegial body consisting of 17 national
government agencies and one non-governmental organization, the Philippine
National Red Cross (PNRC). The NDCC utilizes the facilities and services of the Office
of Civil Defense (OCD) as its secretariat and executive arm. The NDCC issues
guidelines on emergency preparedness and disaster operations.
The national calamities and disaster preparedness plan, prepared by the NDCC in
1988 following the issuance of PD 1566, specifies that disaster coordinating councils
be established for national, regional, Metro Manila, provincial, city or municipal, and
barangay level. It detailed the composition and respective functions of all key
member agencies. The council is chaired by the Secretary of National Defense with
14 Department Secretaries, Chief of Staff of the Armed Forces of the Philippines
(AFP), Executive Director of the Philippine Red Cross, Chairman of the National
Economic and Development Authority (NEDA), and the Director-General of the
Philippine Information Agency (PIA) as members. All implementing plans shall be
documented and copies furnished to NDCC through the OCD. The OCD was given a
vital role in executing and monitoring the implementation of policies and programs
making its Administrator the NDCC Executive Officer, and in providing a secretariat
support to the NDCC. NDCC member agencies are responsible for carrying out
respective tasks and responsibilities, which include preparedness, mitigation,
response and rehabilitation. The NDCC is replicated at the sub-national local levels
referred to as the local DCCs with 17 regional, 80 provincial, 117 city and 1496
municipal councils. The local DCCs function substantially like their national
counterpart except that they operate and utilize their own resources at their
respective levels. Each disaster coordinating council shall maintain a disaster
operations center. However, until this time, not all local government units have a
14
30 June 2010
15
30 June 2010
16
30 June 2010
While the NDRMC would still be recommending the declaration and lifting of a state
of calamity, the LDRRMC may also make its own recommendation to the local
Sanggunian for immediate implementation. Once a state of calamity is declared,
various remedial measures to be undertaken by the member agencies have also
been defined by the law, such as the automatic imposition of price ceilings on basic
necessities and prime commodities by the president as provided in the Price Act.
The present calamity fund appropriated under the annual General Appropriations
Act would now be known as the National Disaster Risk Reduction and Management
Fund and it shall be used for disaster risk reduction or mitigation, prevention and
preparedness activities such as but not limited to training of personnel,
procurement of equipment, and capital expenditures.
It can also be utilized for relief, recovery, reconstruction and other work or services
in connection with natural or human-induced calamities, which may occur during
the budget year or those that occurred in the past two years from the budget year.
Of the amount appropriated for NDRRM Fund, thirty percent shall be allocated as
Quick Response Fund or standby fund for relief and recovery programs in order that
living conditions of people in communities or areas stricken by disasters, calamities,
17
a. Disaster Management
Coordination
Office of the Civil Defense (OCD)
30 June 2010
b. Research Institutions
Philippine Institute for
Development Studies; Klima/Manila
Observatory; Bicol University;
Economy and Environment
Program for Southeast Asia
(EEPSEA)
18
30 June 2010
19
30 June 2010
National agencies
Education. The DepEd has put DRR topics as part of the curricula for primary and
secondary public schools.
Science and technology. PAGASA and PHIVOLCS are the countrys warning agencies
under the DOST. Both are service institutes, as differentiated from purely research
and development institutes. PHIVOLCS operates and maintains a system of
monitoring for earthquake occurrences, tsunami detection, volcanic eruption while
PAGASA has one for weather, hydrological phenomena, and climate variability. The
Philippine Nuclear Research Institute (PNRI) looks after the issuance of advisories on
20
30 June 2010
Poverty alleviation. The countrys Social Reform and Poverty Alleviation Act (RA No.
8425) counts victims of calamities and disasters among the disadvantaged sectors
of Philippine society. The implementation of the Social Reform Policy is done by the
National Anti-Poverty Commission. A coordinating body under the Office of the
President, NAPC focuses on programs on poverty alleviation and resource
mobilization for the poor.
Public works and infrastructure. The Department of Public Works and Highways
(DPWH) prepares and identifies evacuation sites during emergencies; provides
warning on impending water releases from dams within its control; provides
transportation and communication facilities for disaster operations, and heavy and
light equipment for rescue and recovery operations. It also restores destroyed
public works, offices and other buildings. The relevant instruments are: (1) R.A.
6541 National Building Code of the Philippines (1972); (2) R.A. 1185 Fire Code of the
Philippines; and (3) the National Structural Code of the Philippines. The fifth edition
of the Structural Code (2001) introduces two important improvements: the nearfault criteria which gives a higher base shear for a building near a known active
fault compared to the same building at a remote location. And [] rewards
structures with more redundancy and alternative load paths.
Social welfare. The Department of Social Welfare and Development (DSWD) has
several functions that pertain mainly to relief and rehabilitation. Its pre-event
functions include the updating of the national relief and rehabilitation master plan in
coordination with other partner NGAs; technical assistance for capability building
preparedness, mitigation, relief and rehabilitation; linking and coordinating with
21
30 June 2010
22
30 June 2010
23
30 June 2010
UN
The UN Development Assistance Framework (UNDAF) is focused on the achievement
of MDGs and provides for a common strategic framework for the operational
activities of the UN system, setting out collective priorities and linking these outputs
and outcomes to individual UN agency country programs. One of the major
outcomes included in the current UNDAF is that by 2009, the capacity of
stakeholders shall be increased in order to protect and enhance the quality of the
environment and sustainably manage natural resources. Under this outcomes are
outputs to be delivered by UNICEF, UNDP, UNFDA, FAO, and WTTO such that the
environmental disaster management framework and disaster preparedness and
response plans, and natural disaster management team is better able to provide
emergency response services.
World Bank
The WB CAS provides the most comprehensive framework for disaster management
assistance for the country. Over the CAS period (2010-2012), the WB group will aim
to contribute to achieving more inclusive growth by supporting the Philippines to
reduce vulnerabilities by expanding and rationalizing the countrys social safety net,
improving DRM, piloting CCA measures and expanding mitigation programs, among
others. In addition to current commitments for development policy loans, the bank
will use development policy operations in support of DRM and in the context of a
strong reform program in government financial management. Under the strategic
objectives is the reduction of vulnerabilities which aims to support government
efforts top reduce vulnerabilities for a large part of the population.
In our review, it was apparent that development organization country programmes
are mostly aligned with national development and poverty reduction strategies
(MTPDP) and set out how they intend to contribute to the achievement of national
goals, it is essential that the next administration prioritize disaster risk reduction as
a critical development challenge. In addition, more participation from CSOs and
NGOs and the vulnerable communities to ensure that their interests are adequately
24
UNDP, AusAID
OXFAM-GB,
Development
Academy of the
Philippines (DAP) and
PDCC-Albay
1,3
ASEAN
ADPC/UNDP/ECHO
1,3
AusAID; UNDP;
PHILVOLCS, PAGASA;
MGB-DENR, NAMRIA
and the OCD
30 June 2010
HFA
Activit
y
Area(s
)
OCD-NDCC
25
ADB, UNDP
UN-ESCAP; UN-ECLAC;
UNDP
IBM International
Foundation (ERN
Sahana Philippines)
ADRC
WB
NEDA; DEPED
DENR; PHILVOLCS,
PAGASA
DepED
30 June 2010
United Architects
Philippines; Private
Sector Disaster
Management Network
AUSAID; UNDP;
PHILVOLCS, PAGASA:
MGB-DENR, NARMRIA
and the OCD
ECHO/ADPC
NDCC
UNDP
AusAID
26
European Commission
Humanitarian Aid
LGUs
DSWD
EC, BMZ
5
5
The following discussion focuses on key cases from strategies, actions, programs (as
enumerated above) and policies at the national, regional and provincial level to
highlight the areas of progress in accordance with the five priorities of the Hyogo
framework of Action (UN ISDR, 2007).
HFA Priority No. 1: Ensure that disaster risk reduction is a national and a local
priority with a strong institutional basis for implementation
National institutional and legislative frameworks
30 June 2010
The NDCC has been working towards decentralization of DRR in different levels of
government. The current legislation on DRR, PD 1566, has been under review since
amendments were proposed to the Philippine Congress ten years ago. PD 1566 does
not reflect a comprehensive approach to DRM being more response-oriented. As
DRM covers cross-cutting issues related to land use planning, gender, conflict,
multi-hazard approach, indigenous practices, regional differences, poverty
reduction, it is essential that coverage is comprehensive and specific articles in the
draft bill are harmonized with existing laws. Interestingly, the recently signed
PDRRMA adopts a DRR/M approach that is holistic, comprehensive, integrative and
proactive in lessening the socioeconomic and environmental impacts of disasters
including climate change, and promotes the involvement and participation of all
sectors and all stakeholders concerned from the national to the local level.
Since the HFA, various stakeholders have been actively pursuing DRR activities.
There is institutional commitment from various stakeholders towards recharging the
legal basis of DRR actions. This is shown by active advocacy undertaken by NDCC
and NGOs and the consensus is built as opportunities to dialogue increase. Related
laws and regulations pertaining to safety, mining, the building code, land
management, forestry, etc. are poorly enforced. These legal instruments have
conventionally been dealt with without due attention to their function and
contribution to reducing disaster risk and hazard vulnerability (Appendix E).
This countrys main instrument for socio-economic development, MTPDP 2004-2010
incorporates DRR issues and investment projects in different sectors dealing with
27
30 June 2010
Disaster risk reduction is also being integrated in national and local policy
development and planning processes. This commitment resulted towards the
drafting of "Strengthening Disaster Risk Reduction in the Philippines: Strategic
National Action Plan (SNAP) 2009-2019" as well as the "Strategic Plan on
Community-Based Disaster Risk Management (SP-CBDRM) 2007-2011." A series of
dialogues and consultations among stakeholders INGOs, NGOs, academe, and
government facilitated the planning process. Field experience of NGOs
complements the scientific knowledge of the science and technology institutions
and academe, and the practical skills and knowledge on post-disaster activities of
NDCC. The DRM field has grown to be inclusive of several other players from
development planning, housing, environment and disaster fields and thus
broadened the work of NDCC.
Just recently, the SNAP and its 18 priority programs and projects were adopted as
the government policy for DRR/M. The same Executive Order (888, approved 7 June
2010) enjoins the systematic institutionalization of DRR in all government agencies
and government owned and controlled corporations through: (1) integrating DRR
into policies and plans; (2) incorporation of DRR programs, projects and activities
into their budgets through the explicit recognition of budget lines for these projects
and activities that are appropriate for disaster mitigation and preparedness; (3)
participation in the 18 priority projects and programs of the SNAP; and (4)
cooperation with national/international NGOs and the private sector towards safer
28
30 June 2010
29
30 June 2010
Regional cooperation
Dialogue among NGOs and international donor agencies takes place through round
table discussions. Recently, the Philippines' Senate ratified the Association of
Southeast Asian Nations (ASEAN) Agreement on Disaster Management and
Emergency Response (AADMER), and with that the agreement is expected to enter
into force by the end of 2009. The ratification marks a significant highlight in
ASEAN's collective efforts to build a disaster-resilient community by the year 2015.
The agreement binds ASEAN member states into legal responsibilities to promote
regional cooperation and collaboration in reducing disaster losses and intensifying
joint emergency response to disasters in the ASEAN region. The Philippines actively
participates in ASEAN regional cooperation on risk reduction. This is mainly through
the joint disaster drill called ASEAN Regional Emergency Response Simulation
Exercise (ARDEX) held annually in a host ASEAN country and each with a different
disaster scenario. The exercise tests regional capacity to respond and render
humanitarian assistance using a different disaster scenario every year. In 2009,
ARDEX will be hosted by the Philippine Government. Also, the Philippines is a part
of the Partnerships for Disaster Reduction South East Asia. Now in its fourth phase,
30
HFA Priority No. 3: Use knowledge, innovation and education to build a culture of
safety and resilience at all levels
In early 2005, the NDCC implemented the Four Point Plan of Action on Disaster
Preparedness (4PPAP) which strengthens the DRM stance of the country and
enhances its disaster prevention strategies. This aims to increase public awareness
and involvement in measures put in place by the government to minimize the
impact of disasters in the future. This plan of action also provides direction to all
NDCC member-agencies in terms of the allocation of capacities, capabilities and
resources. Among the activities contained in NDCCs 4PPAP, notable is the
designation of July as the National Disaster Consciousness Month in order to
heighten public awareness on the importance of disaster prevention, mitigation and
preparedness through simultaneous nationwide earthquake drills, search and rescue
exercise, seminars, and the Gawad Kalasag award.
30 June 2010
Public awareness and information campaigns on disaster risks are being conducted
by NGOs, private and civic organizations and national and local government
agencies. For example, a component of the READY project is the IEC campaign in
which maps are disseminated to vulnerable communities. The Science and
Technology Information Institute (STII) under DOST produces articles and press
releases to the media. Film showings are also utilized by PHIVOLCS regularly and
PAGASA also conducts annual seminars on themes like disasters, ENSO and climate
change. The cyber world is starting to be utilized. Website such as CALAMIDAT.PH
and online learning programs such as the Online Natural Disaster Risk Management
program of the World Bank Institute and partners.
Schools are integrating DRR concepts in their curricula. The Department of
Education (DepEd) is working on including DRR in elementary and secondary
curricula. The teachers are also informed in DRR by including the concepts in
Teachers Education Curriculum. At present, education in DRR is still limited in scope
and education materials are still inadequate. NDCC and DepEd, in partnership with
ADPC, undertook a project to develop DRM modules for integration into the
secondary school curriculum. The module includes information on disaster
preparedness, prevention and mitigation of hazards and risks of natural events to
vulnerable communities and areas. Disaster awareness has formed part of the
learning core competencies under the Science and Social studies subjects in public
elementary and high schools.
Programs such as Hospital Preparedness for Emergencies (HOPE) under the Program
of Emergency Response (PEER) has been organized by NDCC, along with concerned
government agencies and supported by USAID.
31
30 June 2010
The government has implemented social development policies and plans such as
housing for informal settlers, livelihood projects and health care to reduce the
vulnerability of populations at risk. It is also currently working on the establishment
of a conditional cash transfer system that will help to cushion shocks experienced
by poor households. In the rural sector, crop insurance for palay and high value
crops and livestock insurance through the Philippine Crop Insurance Corporation
(PCIC) are available but many farmers do not subscribe or are not aware that such
insurance exist. In accordance with RA 656 which mandates all heads of
government office to secure from the General Insurance Fund all insurance covering
propertied and other insurable risks of natural and manmade disasters, Government
Service Insurance System (GSIS) called on all government agencies to insure
government properties.
Since the NDCC institutionalized the cluster approach through a circular issued in
2007, some significant DRR actions have been initiated. The cluster approach is
providing a forum for stakeholders sharing a specific concern called cluster (for
example, education) to be proactive in terms of all phases of DRM. Regular
meetings of a few clusters have thus created a continuum, increasing prospects for
DRR integration in the disaster cycle, including rehabilitation and recovery. The
Building Safe Learning Environments (BSLE) Project (June 2007-June 2008)
implemented by DepEd with funding support from UNICEF, Swedish and Dutch
governments, covers both structural and non-structural mitigation measures in
disaster-affected schools and daycare centers in four provinces.
Mainstreaming DRR in the infrastructure sector is being addressed by an ADPCNDCC project that incorporates risk impact assessment procedures before
construction of new roads and bridges. The DPWH has provided a venue for other
government agencies, professional organizations of civil engineers, and other
interest groups through a national workshop on MDRR in the infrastructure sector.
The DepEd also started a program on school building resistant to hazards, for
32
30 June 2010
33
30 June 2010
Albay along with the rest of Bicol Region is highly vulnerable to natural disasters
because of its geographical location. Located at the eastern Pacific seaboard, Albay
is especially vulnerable to tropical storms and cyclones, which bring destructive
winds, heavy rainfall and storm surges several times a year. Typhoons affecting the
province and the Philippines as a whole, form in the Pacific Ocean, and move in a
west-northwest direction, many times the wind intensifying to speeds of 200 kph.
Table 3 shows the affected population and damages caused by tropical cyclones
from 1994 to 2006 in Albay Province. Although there is no clear temporal trend on
the number of people affected and cost of damages, it is important to recognize the
high vulnerability of the province to typhoons. Human settlements living along the
coastlines are vulnerable to storm surges.
Similarly, houses located at
mountainsides with steep and unstable slopes are prone to landslides and
mudslides.
34
Typhoon Akang
Typhoon Gading
Typhoon Mameng
Typhoon Rosing
Typhoon Pining
Typhoon Loleng
Typhoon Sendang
Typhoon Reming
Typhoon Senyang
1
0
1
1
1
2
1
3
1
4
1
5
1
6
Typhoon Dindo
Typhoon Unding
Typhoon Yoyong
Active Low Pressure
ITCZ
Tropical Storm Caloy
Typhoon Milenyo
Typhoon Reming
TOTAL
Yea
r
199
4
199
4
199
5
199
5
199
7
199
8
199
9
200
0
200
0
200
4
200
4
200
4
200
5
200
6
200
6
200
6
Affected Population
Person Dea Injure Missin
s
d
d
g
18,036
47
112
1
Total
Damages
(US$)
2,211,904
6,799
1,546,644
10,126
1,588,884
440,372
44
20
11,991,106
1,800
836,956
201,834
6,754,448
1,122
2,444
27,547
12
7,188,989
22,882
91,111
33,892
5,038,046
1,744
942,094
18,372
10
1,124,229
19,062
3,099,983
47,065
2,207,708
698,460
14
176
1,060,87
5
604
1465
37,007,025
419
71,787,460
153,419,031
30 June 2010
Box 1. continued
Albay is the only province in Bicol that has an operational management office that
provides effective coordination of the various stakeholders towards promoting
efficient intervention on disaster preparedness and emergency response. The
35
30 June 2010
36
37
Risk assessments are also conducted with the help from national research
institutions and
Box 1. continued
foreign funders. Activities include risks and resource mapping, geostrategic
(relocation) and engineering (flood control and alternative routes) interventions; and
updating of the Comprehensive Land Use Plan (CLUP) with climate-related hazards
and vulnerabilities. Another feature that the government has pioneered is that all
provincial facilities and school buildings in the province are insured with the GSIS
and provides for universal health coverage which provides all households with
access even to private medical services during emergency situations.
Disaster Preparedness
The PGA maintains close coordination with warning agencies (e.g. PAGASA and
PHIVOLCS) and some DRR NGOs. Community-based warning and evacuation
planning is continuously being conducted. Institutional unit such as Albay Heath
Emergency Management (AHEM) is being organized and strengthened. Safe
Schools, Safe Hospitals and permanent safe evacuation centres are being built and
prepared. Validation survey of all school buildings for structural safety (design),
safety from hazards (location) and safety for health are conducted and watersanitation facilities to 700 school building are being provided. Rescue equipments
are being acquired and deployed as well as communication facilities. Education and
training are continuously conducted.
Response and Relief
Information boards (infoboards) for alerts and announcements are being installed in
areas most accessible to the public. Evacuation protocols are well-established
encouraging village-initiated evacuation. The provincial government also provides
funds for maintenance of evacuation centers and needs of evacuees. Pre-emptive
evacuation is considered as key response mechanism to achieve zero-casualty goal.
The province is declared as an open-city once a disaster strikes so as to facilitate
the flow of disaster relief. Demand-side relief was introduced in the premise that
cash is most flexible relief support and has pump priming effect.
30 June 2010
Rehabilitation
Damage and Disaster Assessment System (DDAS) is well-established process
refined over many cases of disasters. It is coordinated by APSEMO that leads an
interdepartmental team who coordinates with their national counterparts. Damage
assessment process uses Risk Mapping as its starting point, preparedness activities
and the pre-disaster warning phase and the emergency phase. Data gathering is
spread out and information analysis and dissemination is centralized.
Albays DRM initiatives essentially integrate risk reduction to its entire development
goals- MDG. Thus, as part of the overall development strategy, DRM becomes an
investment with huge economic returns in the long run. Like the PGA, local
governments assume primary mandate in the DRM effort as they are in the frontline
30 June 2010
38
Local officials can be champions in raising public awareness about DRR. They have
an important role to play in raising public awareness for DRR. Learning opportunities
through seminars, workshops, fora, field trips, among others, can be utilized. Good
practices on DRR can be shared so as to motivate and provide knowledge to make
DRM a priority in the local governments. DRR training courses, seminars, and
workshops (such as those that are organized by PAGASA and PHIVOLCS) should be
conducted for specific target groups and localities based on the hazards and
vulnerabilities. Training needs assessment for prioritized groups can also be
conducted.
Reducing underlying risk factors
Integrating DRR into natural and social support systems should be institutionalized.
Coping with disasters should be an important part of poverty alleviation programs
and environmental protection and conservation activities.
Although there have been actions on mainstreaming DRR in the construction of
roads and bridges, it should be highlighted that the key for a more successful
integration of DRR in construction is to include risk reduction measures in the
planning phase. Also, in building safety of schools, it is important to make sure that
the school building are resistant to hazards, particularly those that are serving as
evacuation centers.
Insurance and risk transfer options (and incentives) should be put in place . There
are very few financial institutions that provide emergency loans for poor and
affected families. The key players in the insurance industry and government
agencies should work on exploring risk transfer options. Micro-financing should be
explored wherein savings and insurance instruments could protect poor community
members who are most vulnerable to disasters through life insurance benefits, loan
redemption fund, and burial benefits.
Disaster preparedness
30 June 2010
39
3.
30 June 2010
The Philippine Climate Change Act of 2009 (RA 9729) was signed into law on 23
October 2009. The main content of RA 9729 is the creation of Climate Change
Commission (see Appendix C) which will incorporate climate change concepts in
policy and development plans, as well as receive funds and endowments to address
this problem. The law also provides for the formulation of the Framework Program
on Climate Change and National Climate Change Action Plan, aims that have
already been mentioned in previous legislations. Three commissioners assumed
office for a span of six years. A total of 23 government agencies, local government
units and representatives from the academe, business sector, and non-government
organizations (NGOs) will compose the bodys Advisory Board to ensure
accountability. The final Implementing Rules and Regulation (IRR) of the Climate
Change Act was signed by the President, and the new commissioners last January
18, 2010.
Since 2007, there is a significant rise in interest on climate change issues among
policy makers and government agencies. However, the countrys attempt to
address climate change begun in the early 1990s with the creation of the InterAgency Committee on Climate Change (IACCC). The IACCC is tasked to coordinate
various climate change-related activities, propose climate change policies and
prepare the Philippine position to the UNFCCC negotiations. Prior to that was the
formulation of the Philippine Strategy for Sustainable Development (PSSD) which led
to the official adoption of the Agenda 21 by formulating the Philippine Agenda 21
and the creation of the Philippine Council for Sustainable Development in 1992. The
country signed in June 1992 the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate
Change (UNFCCC) and ratified it on August 2, 1994. It also signed the Kyoto Protocol
on April 15, 1998 and ratified it on November 20, 2003 in order to participate in the
Clean Development Mechanism (CDM).
Prior to the creation of the PCCCA was the creation of the Presidential Task Force on
Climate Change (PTFCC) on February 20, 2007. PTFCC is tasked to address the issue
of climate change, mitigate its impact, and lead in adapting to these impacts. It is
composed of the DENR Secretary as chair, with the secretaries of Department of
Energy (DoE), DOST, DA and Department of Interiors and Local Government (DILG),
40
30 June 2010
41
30 June 2010
The NFSCC is committed towards ensuring and strengthening the adaptation of our
natural ecosystems and human communities to climate change. In the process, the
Framework aspires to chart a cleaner development path for the Philippines,
highlighting the mutually beneficial relationship between climate change mitigation
and adaptation. As a matter of principle, the Framework aggressively highlights the
critical aspect of adaptation meant to be translated to all levels of governance
alongside coordinating national efforts towards integrated ecosystem-based
management which shall ultimately render sectors climate-resilient.
42
30 June 2010
43
b. National Agencies
NEDA
Preparation of blueprint of
government programs (i.e. MTPDP)
Coordination of disaster
management measures during
emergency
Implementation of CC Adaptation
projects based on their sectoral
mandate, as stated in their names
30 June 2010
PAGASA, NAMRIA
Provision of weather information
c. Academic/ Research Institutions
UPLB; ICRAF; Klima/Manila Observatory
(ADMU); Bicol University; Economy and
Environment Program for Southeast
44
30 June 2010
Development Planning
A review of major development plans and policies (i.e the 2004-2010 Medium Term
Philippine Development Plan (MTPDP), the Philippines Millennium Development Goal
(MDG), and the Philippine Agenda 21 (PA 21) showed that (a) climate change
adaptation has not been mainstreamed in the Philippines; (b) whenever climate
change is recognized, the focus has been more of mitigation especially now with
rising interest in the CDM; and (c) because of the geographical location, there is
more emphasis on adaptation to risks associated with current climate-related
variability and extremes (e.g., tropical cyclones, floods, and landslides) (Lasco et al.,
2009). This showed that clearly, national decision makers do not yet see climate
change (adaptation) as a high priority issue in the context of national development
plans. This is primarily because national priorities are biased towards more pressing
concerns and the pervasive lack of awareness on the impacts of climate change to
sustainable development. However, there are massive investments on
infrastructure projects designed to adapt to climate-related hazards such as floods.
These projects could provide an entry point in integrating climate change
adaptation.
The recent MTPDP, 2004-2010 mid-term updating exercise shows additional
progress in the mainstreaming of climate change in decision-making. The latest
45
30 June 2010
The national government through the Department of Interior and Local Government
(DILG) has issued Memorandum Circulars (MCs) to alert LGUs about the need for
awareness-raising and capacity-building and to empower LGUs in autonomously
responding to climate change and preparing their adaptation plans. Among the
national government issuances are:
DILG-MC 2008-69 (Encouraging LCEs and Sanggunians to Implement
Climate Change Adaptation and Disaster Risk Reduction Measures);
DILG-MC 2008-123 (Mobilizing Local Actions to Address the Impacts of
Climate Change);
DILG-MC No. 2008-161 (November 3, 2008) (Trainers Training on Mobilizing
Actions to Address the Impacts of Climate Change);
DILG-MC No. 2009-21 amending MC No. 2008-123 to include the National
Movement of Young Legislators as one of the institutional partners in
Mobilizing Local Actions to Address the Impacts of Climate Change; and
DILG-MC 2009-73 (National Conference on Empowering LGUs to Clean the
Air and Address Climate Change Through Partnership).
Compliance with these memorandum circulars had been slow and limited. For
instance, as of April 2009, only four out of 17 regions have complied with these
circulars (APN-GCR, 2009).
In December 2009, the National Economic and Development Authority (NEDA) and
three University of the Philippines (UP) units recently signed memoranda of
agreement (MOA) to conduct programs and projects amounting to some P11 million
for climate change adaptation. Through the agreement, NEDA will tap the academic
46
30 June 2010
47
30 June 2010
48
30 June 2010
49
30 June 2010
50
30 June 2010
Box 3. Continued.
among others) local government planners and decision makers in many cases do
not have the luxury of being concerned about global change. It is important to find
ways to integrate climate change adaptation into sustainable development planning
in such a way that the policy makers will see climate change as an issue needing
immediate action. Therefore, key to any attempt to embed the climate change issue
at the local government level is the ability to answer the question: What does it
mean for my province, city, or town?
51
30 June 2010
3. Executing Programs
In August 2007, the provincial government resolved that environment (i.e. the
importance of environmental protection, conservation and management) should be
included in the curricula of all schools, colleges and universities in the province. A
series of capacity-building activities was conducted starting off with the Training of
Trainors to facilitate the mainstreaming of climate change adaptation in the
curricula of education. In partnership with DepEd, Commission on Higher Education
(CHED), Bicol University (BU) and private universities in the province, Albay initiated
various activities such as the
Box 3. Continued.
conduct of essay writing and poster making contests, viewing of documentaries and
conduct of seminars to propagate global warming awareness.
52
30 June 2010
Since the institutionalization of the APSEMO in 1994 and CIRCA in 2007, both have
staff that are dedicated and committed to disaster management and climate
change adaptation, respectively. However, there are limited interactions between
the staff of the two organizations (Daep, 2008) although some of the activities of
CIRCA are more on disaster risk management particularly with regards to
information dissemination and conduct of training and workshops on disaster
preparedness and risk reduction.
It is, however, important to note that mainstreaming climate change adaptation in
the day-to-day decision-making in LGUs may require considerable additional work
and wider responsibility thus, may require additional staff and time. Also, there is a
need to clarify and strengthen the links between climate change adaptation,
disaster risk management, and development. In addition, the activities, programs
and projects to be launched by new institutions like CIRCA should be made relevant
to or integrated with existing institutions like APSEMO, structures, procedures and
activities.
53
30 June 2010
With more than half of the total area of the Philippines at risk of natural disasters
making 81% of its population at risk, more local governments are likely to draw
lessons from the Albay initiatives and eventually from Iloilo and Palawan.
At the national level, climate change is slowly being integrated in different plans
and programs. However, the progress is slow. Although climate change has been
mentioned more frequently in the updated MTPDP, it continues to be narrowly
directed, being mentioned in only two chapters. Climate change proves to be a low
priority in terms of public resource allocation. Similarly, in terms of national laws,
Lasco et. al. (2007) found that few environmental laws address climate change
mitigation (i.e. Clean Air Act) and/or prescribe adaptation strategies to potential
impacts of climate change. In a study conducted by Lasco et. al. (2009), there was a
consensus (95 percent of the respondents) that mainstreaming climate change in
policies and programs is important and about 59 percent concurred that it has not
been mainstreamed in the country. The study concluded that climate change is still
seen as peripheral when compared to more pressing social issues such as poverty
54
30 June 2010
Key sectors (i.e. water, agriculture, forestry, coastal and marine, and health) of
Southeast Asian countries have made encouraging initiatives for climate change
adaptation. Below are the recommended priorities for these sectors.
In the water resources sector, the priority is to scale-up existing good practices of
water conservation and management, and apply more widely integrated water
management, including flood control and prevention schemes, irrigation
improvement, and demand-side management.
In the agriculture sector, the priority is to strengthen local adaptive capacity by
providing public goods and services, such as better information, research and
development on heat-resistant crop varieties and risk-sharing instruments such as
55
30 June 2010
Finally, there is also a need to nationally promote climate change issues, problems
and solutions to be translated into local context and with a language that people
can understand.
56
4.
4.1
Natural disasters and climate change affect various natural, economic, social, and
political activities and processes. Hence, these challenges need to be addresses in a
more holistic, integrative and participatory manner at all scales, on all political
levels and all sectors of society.
Historically, there are two separate communities of policy makers, practitioners, and
researchers working on DRR/M and CCA evident in the limited overlap in approach
and strategies, organizations and institutions, funding mechanisms (see Table 5)
and even in meetings and conferences, research methods and tools, and language.
Table 5. General characterization of the CCA and DRR/M communities in the country
Disaster Risk Management
30 June 2010
Approach
- Risk management
- Engineering and national sciencebased events and exposure
- Shift from reactive to proactive
approach
- Local scale
- Community-based
- Short-term (but increasingly longterm)
Risk management
Strong scientific basis
Vulnerability perspective
Multi-disciplinary approach
Global scale
Top-down
Long-term perspective
57
UNFCCC
IPCC
Academe and research
National and local NGOs
Strategies
-
UN ISDR
Hyogo Framework of Action
Disaster Framework
National DRR/M Framework (to be
adopted)
- SNAP
Major Policies
- Philippine Disaster Risk Reduction
and Management Act of 2010 (RA
10121), 27 May 2010
- Adopting SNAP and institutionalizing
DRR (EO 888), 7 June 2010
30 June 2010
Funding
- National Defense/ emergency
response (National Calamity Fund,
now the National DRR/M Fund)
- International Humanitarian Funding
- Multilateral Bank
- Bilateral Aid
The increasing political momentum due to the number of typhoons that ravaged the
country in the past four years, the overlapping objectives of DRM and CCA in
58
30 June 2010
The LGUs seem to be in the best position to implement DRM effectively. Local
champions are necessary to instill DRR and ensure DRM ownership particularly in
raising public awareness and instilling knowledge and capacity specific to the needs
of their constituents. Capacity building is deemed necessary particularly to LGUs. It
is also important to discover how existing capacities can be used to the full
advantage of the entire DRM community. However, financing mechanisms need to
be explored. Local internal resources are insufficient, thus resource mobilization is
needed.
Progress in terms of mainstreaming DRR in the country has been encouraging but
rather slow. There have been significant steps taken from both the national
government through its agencies, more particularly in the education and
infrastructure sector. Development organizations programming shows promise in
terms of mainstreaming DRR into their development work in hazard-prone countries
like the Philippines. Thus, it is necessary that the government makes DRR a priority
in its development agenda. It is also essential to put in place mechanisms and
processes through which stakeholders can contribute and participate within
appropriate legal mandates and institutional arrangements.
The newly signed PDRRM Law encourages the National DRRM Council, to be led by
the OCD, to coordinate with the Climate Change Commission in the development of
assessment tools on the existing and potential hazards and risks brought by climate
change to vulnerable areas and ecosystems as well as the formulation and
59
30 June 2010
60
4.2
This study assessed current efforts to address disaster risks and climate change in
the Philippines, focusing particularly on aspects that can help build the interlinkage/s between DRM and CCA. In this context, we tried to explore several key
components of climate proofing development including knowledge on climate risk
and vulnerability (i.e. information and communication), institutional capacity and
coordination, local government and community initiatives, and financing DRM and
CCA. Drawing from the review of institutional and policy initiatives on DRM and CCA,
Table 6 summarizes the principal mechanisms and incentives, and barriers that
shaped how integration progressed to date. These key points are expanded in the
sections that follow.
Table 6. Progress toward integration (incentives and barriers) of DRR/M and CCA in
the country
Existing Mechanisms/Incentives
30 June 2010
61
30 June 2010
62
30 June 2010
63
The cluster approach to DRM has further strengthened coordination across sectors
for disasters in the country. Disaster coordination is achieved largely through a
nested network of coordinating councils from national, provincial to municipal
levels. Coordination in relation to CCA is generally less well developed at present.
The creation of the Climate Change Commission is expected to clarify the roles and
responsibilities of the concerned government agencies; encourage participation
from different sectors i.e. private, NGOs, and research; and enhance coordination
among all stakeholders.
The capabilities of local government in DRM and CCA need to be strengthened. All
LGUs, particularly the most vulnerable ones, should have a dedicated office to
handle disaster management. This, however, entails cost. The coordination between
municipal, provincial, regional, and national preparedness and response
mechanisms should also be strengthened.
Progress toward climate change adaptation in government agencies depends on
political commitment and institutional capacity, reflected in robust policies and
strategies geared toward consideration of disaster risk reduction and long-term
changes in risk. Significant policy advances have been gained in strengthening
disaster risk management, including key national policies/strategies in the country.
However, having two separate institutional homes while sharing the same
objectives and same challenges, they fail to coordinate themselves. Thus, it is
crucial to emphasize the importance of integrating both DRR and CCA efforts
towards the common objective of reducing risk to development. This is to avoid
duplication of efforts, governance inefficiencies and even misunderstanding and
competition among various stakeholders.
Local government and community initiatives
30 June 2010
Efforts to forge greater capacity at the national scale have to be reflected by work
at the local scale to increase the ability of local institutions and communities to
cope with present and future risks from climatic hazards. Initiatives targeted at local
and community level in DRM are evident in the projects and programs supported by
donor organizations. More importantly, the LGUs, like that of the Province of Albay,
possess a unique role of bridging local and national scale activities in terms of
disaster coordination and CCA policies. These practices may also be used as vehicle
to raise awareness and spread the strategies to other LGUs.
Financing DRM and CCA
Financing for disaster risk reduction and climate change adaptation can come from
national budgets, international donors and private sector sources. Funding for DRM
is growing, as reflected by the increasing number of projects by several bilateral
donor organizations that have specific funding for DRR. CCA, on the other hand, is
slowly getting attention and more funding. Few bilateral organizations have
integrated their support for DRR and CCA. Many DRR/M projects are funded from
humanitarian aids, CCA on the other hand is typically funded out of environmental
64
30 June 2010
There is a need to further mobilize greater and more diverse sustainable sources of
financing that are nationally appropriate for climate change, especially in the
private sector. A number of bilateral and multilateral donor organizations have
integrated their support for DRM and CCA. Most CCA funding are typically contained
in environment-related projects. Several donors are also investing directly in
capacity building through NGOs and research networks.
65
5.
5.1
Conclusions
66
The Philippines has been considered as highly vulnerable to current (i.e. natural
disasters), as well as future climate-related risks. The country experiences an
average of eight to nine tropical cyclones making a landfall plus recurring floods and
landslides, periodic ENSO phenomenon, among others. Climate change is expected
to exacerbate existing stresses, thus the development goals of the country can be
severely affected by climate change and a great number of population and
livelihoods can be at risk.
Managing such risks to development requires the systematic integration of DRM and
CCA in terms of project activities, coordination and financing mechanisms. Progress
toward DRM and CCA in government agencies depends on political will and
institutional capacity, reflected in robust policies and strategies geared toward
consideration of short- and long- term climate risk to development. Significant
program and strategy advances have been gained in strengthening DRM; and
pioneering steps, including key national policies and institutions, for promoting CCA.
The recently approved policies on both DRM and CCA, and other adaptation projects
feature clear overlaps, including efforts to harmonize coordination structures.
However, progress in terms of integration of DRM and CCA in political agendas and
institutional priorities remains slow. Though significant policy advances have been
recently gained, the continuing perception that DRM and CCA are of less priority
hinders moves towards mainstreaming.
It is also important to point the significance of linking DRM and CCA activities and
integrate with poverty reduction activities and development objectives. Being both
a condition and determinant of vulnerability, poverty reduction should be an
essential component of reducing vulnerability to natural disasters and climate
change.
30 June 2010
The political momentum and leadership brought by several disasters for the last two
years tends to suffer from coordination conflicts, political instability, and short-term
political cycles. Long-term issues such as CCA may suffer from the threat of
unsustainable program and discontinuity of policies, therefore strengthening the
need for ownership. The promising role of local champions and units should be
emphasized and further supported by the national government.
5.2
Recommendations
Given the above realities on DRR and CCA policy and institutional landscapes in the
country, the following recommendations and immediate priorities for the Philippines
to integrating DRM and CCA into policies and programs are forwarded:
On knowledge on climate risk and vulnerability
Aggressive systematic knowledge generation and IEC campaign about DRM and
CCA is needed. More research to better understand the local and sectoral impacts of
climate change, climate variability and extreme, and disasters should be
undertaken. This needs documentation and organization of all climate chang,
variability and risk-related data and information in the country to properly identify
hazards and risks. Useful action may include steping up efforts in documenting
existing strategies and knowledge on adaptation to disasters, more research on
technical solutions and capacities to enhance adaptive capacity of vulnerable
communities and provide for sustainable livelihoods; and step up efforts to raise
public awareness and IEC campaigns. Such campaigns ought to be targeted to a
wider range of stakeholders such as the research and academe communities, policy
makers and civil society.
On institutional capacity and coordination
The cross-sectoral nature of natural disasters and climate change warrants a similar
approach to addressing the issue. A more integrative, participatory, and multistakeholder approach, as been highlighted in both Disaster Risk Reduction and
Management Act and Climate Change Act, should be implemented. This entails not
only increased policy dialogues but a more concerted and coordinated partnership
arrangements and stronger operational links for research and policy.
On local government and community initiatives
The local leaders can be champions, and LGUs seem to be in the best position to
implement DRM and CCA effectively. Local champions are necessary to instill DRR
and CCA and ensure ownership particularly in raising public awareness and instilling
knowledge and capacity specific to the needs of their constituents. Capacity
building is deemed necessary particularly to LGUs. It is also important to discover
how existing capacities can be used to the full advantage of the entire DRM
community. However, financing mechanisms need to be explored. Local internal
resources are insufficient, thus resource mobilization is needed.
30 June 2010
On financing
The implementation of the above recommendations and of other development plans
related to DRR and CCA may be hampered by inadequacy of funds and other
(human and material) resources. As such, more concerted efforts, together with the
all-important political will, ought to be devoted to establishing regular sources of
funds at local, national and even international levels, to finance climate changerelated initiatives
Finally, there is no one-size-fits-all solution to improving risk management strategies
of the country i.e. integration of DRR agenda into CCA structures, or vice versa. This
calls for the government to build and strengthen existing capacities. This will require
further dialogues between the DRM and CCA communities to identify existing
67
References
Adger, W.N., Huq, S., Brown, K., Conway, D., and M. Hulme. 2003. Adaptation to
climate change in the developing world. Progress in Development Studies 3,3 pp
179-195.
Albay Public Safety and Emergency Management Office (APSEMO), 2007. Summary
Report: Disaster Occurrences in the province of Albay, as of December 2006.
Provincial Disaster Operation Center, Legazpi City, Albay, Philippines.
Arguelles M. 2007. Albay inks MOU on disaster risk reduction with UK group.
Available from http://www.bicolmail.com/issue/2007august9/albay-inks.html
(Accessed on January 2008).
Benson, C. and J. Twigg. 2007. Tools for Mainstreaming Disaster Risk Reduction:
Guidance Notes for Development Organisations. The Provention Consortium.
Geneva, Switzerland.
Bildan, L., 2003. Disaster management in Southeast Asia: an overview. Asian
Disaster Preparedness Center. Bangkok, Thailand. Available from
http://www.adpc.net/pdr-sea/publications/11-DMSEA.pdf
Britton, N. 2009. The Links Between Disaster Risk Management and Climate Change
Adaptation. Asian Development Bank.
30 June 2010
68
Daep, C., 2008. Personal Communication. Albay Public Safety and Emergency
Management Office, Provincial Disaster Operation Center, Legazpi City, Albay,
Philippines. March 25, 2008.
DFID (Department for International Development), 2003. Adaptation to climate
change: making development disaster proof. Global and Local Environment Team,
Policy Division, DFID. Available from
http://www.climatevarg.org/essd/env/varg.nsf/42ec25f6537f5eff85256dab0048d8e9
/b603b3c185bee77485256dab0059aca8/$FILE/DFIDinfo_06.pdf (Accessed on
February 2008)
Ebi, K.L., N.D. Lewis and C. Corvalan. 2006. Climate Variability and Change and
Their Potential Health Effects in Small Island States: Information for Adaptation
Planning in the Health Sector. Environmental Health Perspectives, Vol. 114, No. 12,
pp. 1957-1963
Elvira, J., 2007. Personal Communication. Albay Public Safety and Emergency
Management Office, Provincial Disaster Operation Center, Legazpi City, Albay,
Philippines. March 25, 2008.
Emmanuel, K., 2005: Increasing destructiveness of tropical cyclones over the past
30 years. Nature,
436, 686-688.
Fernandez, A.L. and A.C. Javier. 2010. Midterm Review of the READY II Project.
United Nations Development Programme. Available at:
erc.undp.org/evaluationadmin/downloaddocument.html?docid=3575
Fortes and Jose, 2006. Report on Survey Results. Workshop on Financial Strategies
Managing
Economic Impact of Natural Disaster at the Macro-Meso-, Micro-Level. Manila,
Philippines. May 22-24, 2006.
Global Facility for Disaster Reduction and Recovery (GFDRR), undated. Disaster Risk
Management Programs for Priority Countries: East Asia and the Pacific. Accessed
online on 30 March 2010. Available at http://gfdrr.org/ctrydrmnotes/Philippines.pdf
30 June 2010
International Federation of Red Cross and Red Crescent Societies (IFRC). 2005.
World Disasters
Report 2005: Focus on information in disasters. IFRC, Geneva.
International Labor Organization (ILO). 2009. Climate change in Jabonga, Philippines
- the water is already rising. Accessed on 14 May 2009. Available from:
http://www.ilo.org/asia/info/public/features/lang--en/WCMS_114135/index.htm
Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC). 2007: Summary for
Policymakers. In: Climate Change 2007: Impacts, Adaptation and Vulnerability.
Contribution of Working Group II to the Fourth Assessment Report of the
Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, M.L. Parrt, O.F. Canziani, J.P. Palutikof,
69
30 June 2010
McGray, H., A. Hammill and R. Bradley, 2007: Weathering the Storm: Options for
Framing Adaptation and Development. World Resources Institute, Washington, DC,
USA, vi+57 pp. http://www.ccchina.gov.cn/WebSite/CCChina/UpFile/File239.pdf
Mitchell, T., and M. van Aalst. 2008. Convergence of Disaster Risk Reduction and
Climate Change Adaptation. Online. Accessed 4 June 2010. Available from:
http://www.preventionweb.net/files/7853_ConvergenceofDRRandCCA1.pdf
National Disaster Coordinating Council (NDCC). 2009. Strengthening Disaster Risk
Reduction in the Philippines: Strategic National Action Plan 2009-2019.
http://ndcc.gov.ph/
National Economic Development Authority (NEDA). 2007. Philippines Midterm
Progress Report on the Millennium Development Goals.
70
OBrien, G., OKeefe, P., Rose, J., and B. Wisner, 2006. Climate Change and Disaster
Management. Disasters, 2006, 30(1): 6480.
Oslo Policy Forum, 2008. Changing the Way We Develop: Dealing with Disasters and
Climate Change: report on the findings of the conference. Available from
http://www.oslopolicyforum.no/front.cfm (Accessed on April 2008)
Perez, R.T. 2002a. Assessment of Vulnerability and Adaptation to Climate Change in
the Philippine Coastal Resources Sectors. Presentation made at the Meeting on
Climate Change and National Development in the Philippines, held on November 8,
2002 at the Justitia Room, Ateneo Professional Schools, Rockwell Center, Makati
City, Philippines.
Perez, R.T. 2002b. Assessment of Vulnerability and Adaptation to Climate Change in
the Philippine Water Resources Sectors. Presentation made at the Meeting on
Climate Change and National Development in the Philippines, held on November 8,
2002 at the Justitia Room, Ateneo Professional Schools, Rockwell Center, Makati
City, Philippines.
Perez, R. T. undated. "Assessment of vulnerability and adaptation to climate change
in the Philippines coastal resources sector". Online. Accessed 5 May 2010. Available
at: http://www.survas.mdx.ac.uk/pdfs/3perez.pdf.
Population Reference Bureau (PRB), 2006. Making the Link in the Philippines:
Population, Health, and the Environment. Available from
http://www.prb.org/Publications/Datasheets/2006/MakingtheLinkinthePhilippinesANe
wPRBDatasheet.aspx (Accessed on 26 February 2008)
Provincial Planning and Development Office, 2007. Annual Investment Plan,
Provincial Government
of Albay, Philippines.
Provincial Planning and Development Office, 2007. Provincial Development
Investment Plan, Provincial Government of Albay, Philippines.
30 June 2010
Rangasa, M., 2008. Personal Communication. Albay Public Safety and Emergency
Management Office, Provincial Disaster Operation Center, Legazpi City, Albay,
Philippines. March 25, 2008.
Salceda, J. 2010. Albay: Zero Casualty in the Midst of Escalating Disasters. A
presentation on the First World Congress on Cities and Adaptation to Climate
Change. 28 May 2010, Bonn, Germany.
Schipper, L. and M. Pelling, 2006. Disaster risk, climate change and international
development: scope for, and challenges to, integration. Disasters 30(1): 19-38.
Available from http://www3.interscience.wiley.com/journal/118596602/issue
Serrano, S.R., 2009. Challenges and Opportunities for Philippine Agriculture in the
time of Climate Change, Looming Water Scarcity and Increasing Energy Costs.
71
30 June 2010
72
http://albaycirca.org/
http://www.emb.gov.ph/
http://ndcc.gov.ph/
http://neda.gov.ph/
http://www.philippines.embassy.gov.au/mnla/Ausaid.html
http://senate.gov.ph/
http://www.undp.org/
http://www.usaid.gov/locations/asia/countries/philippines/
30 June 2010
http://www.worldbank.org.ph/
73