51, : - 1995

( )
[1]

1.
,
.

, , , , , de
Croix (1983, . 30): , ,
( ), , ,
' '. ' ', Wertfreiheit',
".

,
,
. ()
.

2.

-
, 1776 dam Smith " "
1848 "O " Jo
Stuart Mill (Roll 1989, Rubin 1994).

, , . ,
""
( "" ),
( , -
- "" [2] ) .
.

,
. ( )
, "" , , : -
, )
)
18 .

Quesnay (1694-1774) : " " ( -

), " " ( , ) " " ( ). Turgot (1727-1781) -
.

 ( ) .

Adam Smith ,
, (
): .
. '
,
.

,
, . Smith
: ( ) , ,
, , (
-) .

. [3] ,

, ,
, (
), : , , (
.

To ( ) , "
" (...) (...)
,
" (Ricardo 1992, . 73). ,
Ricardo,
. ,
. , ( ) "
: , ".
( -
" " (Ricardo 1992, . 89). [4]

, ,
. 19 ,
( -
), ,
.

J.-B. Say (1767-1832) : )

( ) )
" ". ,
, () " " (, ,
"" (Rubin 1994
382 .).

" ": " " (
" "), "".
: . ( - )
" ", ()
"" "" () .

" " ,
"" . ,

 . (. Weeks 1989, . 12 .) - ( )
" " (, , . ..) "" ,
"" " " "". ()
( , ).

" " " "

.
,
. ()
(Hobbes, Machiavelli, Spinoza. ..) " " ,
: ""
" ". [5]

"" " "

, "" ""
, ( / ) ""

2. " "

" ". [6]

"" ( ""
) : ( , ..),
, , , [7]
.. "" (
" ") ("" , "" ... )
. [8] , '
("") ("" , "" ...). [9]

,
"", , . ' -
,
. , ,

.
: (
), "" "" (
) " ", .

, , " " " ",

" ".
" " ,
, " ":
( ) ,
. , "
", " " . , ..,
" " (, ""
) " " " ".

, " "
, ,
.

Max Weber,
. Weber : "
' ( ) ,
" (Weber 1947, . 177).

 : "" " " (Positiv privilegierte Besitzklassen)

"- " (Negativ privilegierte Besitzklassen). ")
(), ) , ) , )
( ), ) , ) , )
(Weber 1947, . 178). "- " : ") , )
(Deklassierte), ) , ) ''" (Weber 1947, . 177).

( , - -
), /
( , ),
. , - (
). , ,
(" "). [10] Weber , ,
( ) [11] ()
. ( M. Weber . Giddens 1984, . 2,
46-60.
: . 3, . 61-96 . 14-15, . 317-365).

. ""
,
, .
, - - "" .

3. [12]

(
" ") . Smith,
( ) "
o" (Smith 1981,IV.ix.28, . 674), -
. ,
.
[13] , ,
, "" ( ). (
Ricardo ),
(, , ) .

. [14] ""
.

, . , " "
,
.
:

) ,
. ,
, , -
:

" " " " ( )

, . , (
), , , . ,
, , .
,
.
, " ( 1989, . 78). [15]

. ,
, . ,
" , ,
" (Balibar 1986, . 620).
" ". [16] , ,
".

, ,
, ( )
, , ,

(. 1994). [17] ,

.

) ,
- (
), ( ). ,
, ""
, (.. ).

: 1)
, , ,
(, , ). 2)
", ,
() .

' .

: () .
, (
).

(
) . ,
, , .

, ,
( ),
. ,
, , :
,
, .

4.

(
) ( ),
' "" . [18]

,
( ), -
( ) .
: (
- -
) :
(
) ( ).

() ( ) (,
, ), '
.. ' )
.
:
,
( - , "
..)
. (
, -- ,
...) .
, "
", " " , , . [

, ,
. - ,
,
. , (, ..,
), :
- ( ) (
1989, . 283-314).

.
,
() . [20]

( ) .
() , ,
,
. [21]
( )
.
, . (. 1988 . 13
153). ,

.

5. ,

, , ,

 () . ,
, , (
) .

, .
a [22] ,
: - -
.
, , ... ,
( ),
.
, :

1. ,
,
.

) , )

.

) , ,
,
. : (
) , .

) (
- :
, ()
( ),
() .
() : , ( )
, -.

,
- . ,
, ,
: . (
1978, . 796 .)

, , ,
.
. ( ),
:

.
,
- ( ).

2. (,
, ) . " ".

 , - ( - ),
, .
: (
, ,

), ' ( ,
-, , - ).
,
:
.

, (
) () ,
:

* .. --
(, ..),

* , ( ,
, ...),

* - , .. .

(
) , ,
.

, , ,
(, , ) . ,
,
(). [23] " "
,
, . [24]

, , (
), ,
,
. , . (1981)
( ) ( ) ( )
,
. [25]

:
. ,
("")

 , .

, () , .
, ,
:
.
( 1975, . 203 ., V) ( ) : "
" - " "- ""
, (. 1993).

, , ,
[26] : "" ( ""
, ),
. , (, ,
""
"" . [27]

6. , "" .

" () (
), ,
: ( )
() () .
",
. (. Goldthorpe 1994).

, , ,
" ( ) -.. 19 -.. 1905 1917.
( " )
. , "
: , "
( ) . '
", .

. ,
, ,
( ) ( ) .

", " ( )
". , ,
" ". "
,
.

" "
1980 . .

" " (),

( ) . (

 " " . 1991 1991).

, " , ,
, , , " (J. Elster, "Makin
Sense of Marx", CUP, Cambridge 1983, . 5, 1991, . 61 [28] ) .
:

* , .
( , ),
. ,o
. , "
". (. 1991, . 68). [29]

* H , " , ,
.

"" " " ( " ,

) , , : 1)
, ()
( ) [30] , 2) ( )
, ( ).
:
"" (
-: " " Adam Smith), -
[31] - ,
.

, , " [32] ,
" .

" "" (
" ).

" . ,
", , " (1986). ,
"" "
" (. 147). , " ''
[ ] .
, ,
, " (. 155).

"
" "
" (. 157).

,
" (...) " (. 184), " (...)
(...) ". : "
" (. 305). , " " (. 183)
, ,
: " " (. 186)
" -" (. 191), " " (. 189).
: " " --

 " ", , (
) :
, "
, .

( 1993).
, ()
, ,
, ' .

- ,
.
, ,
, .
12 ,
9 , 3 .

, ""
, " " , :
,
. "" ,
, , ""
, ; ,
, ,
( , )
"" "".

,
. , , "
" ,
, "" .
" ",
, " .

. ,
, .

,
"-":
. , , ,
,
.

, (
, ), .
, - ,
() ,
- (), , ,
... [33] '
,
: () - .
, , - .
( ) :
, ...

 , , ( ) (
) . () ,
. , " "
,
( ) . .
, . , " . (. 2
.) [ ] ()
." ( 1993, . 111).

" " ,
. , , ,
" ", (.. ).
,
, .

, '
(, -, " " . Rubin 1994
. 197-208). , 17 18 ,
. Rubin (1994, . 201): "
- ' (, )

(, , ). ,
,
. ,
- ,
18 , ." (
. . 1978, . 424-425).

""
, " ",
1845. , ,
" ,
" (ngels, in: Marx-Engels 1976, . 238).

, ,
, . (. 1993, . 119,
Caire, n: Labica/Bensussan 1983, . 90 & 91). ,
(
-.. )
( -..
19 ).

, ,
. [34] , , "
(
)
. . ,
- - ,
.

( )

, : , 35, . 51-68, 1991.

, : O M / ",

, 1992.

lthusser, Louis & Balibar, Etienne: Das Kapital lesen", 2 , Rowohlt, Reinbeck/Hamburg, 1972.
Weber, Max: Grundriss der Sozialoekonomik", 2 , Tuebingen 1947.
Vester, Michael: Soziale Milieus, Klassenmentalitaeten und Solidaritaet, "Widerspruch", . 27, Juni

1994, . 132 .

Giddens, Antony: Die Klassenstruktur fortgeschrittener Gesellschaften", Suhrkamp 1984.

Goldhorpe, John H.: ,
1994.

, : ", , ...
Weeks, John: A Critique of Neoclassical Macroeconomics", MACMILLAN, London 1989.
, : - -
, . 2, . 78-125, 1991.

, /, /, /, : H
", , , 1994.
, : -- . , . 46, . 33-62, 1994.
Engels, Friedrich: Die Lage der arbeitenden Klasse in England", in: Marx-Engels-Werke, . 2, .

225-508.

: ", . 1987.
Caire, Guy: Arbeiter/Arbeiteraristokratie/Arbeiterbewegung, in: Labica/Bensussan (.):
. 85-96, rgument, Berlin 1986.

Kritisches Woerterbuch des Marxismus"

, : H . : ,
1993.

, . 69-1

M, : ", . 36, . 51-74, 1991.

, : " ", . 1, , , 1963.
, : " ", . 3, ,. , 1978.
, : ", , 1989.
, : -, ',

. 4, . 23-48, 1983.

, : -, ',
, : .

. 5, . 31-61, 1983.

", 1988.

, : "
, . 30, . 59-78, 1990.

".

, : . ", 4 , . , 1993.
, : ---, . 50,

. 13-32, 1995.

reau, Pierre-Francois: Marx und Spinoza", VSA 1978.

Balibar, Etienne: Klassen/lassenkampf", in: Labica/Bensussan (.): Kritisches Woerterbuch des
rgument, Berlin 1986.
, :

Marxismus" . 4, . 615-636,

"

 . 17, . 99-112, 1986.

, : , . 28, . 69 ., 1989.
, : .

", , 1991.

, : ",

, 1975.

Birnbaum, Pierre/Leca, Jean: Sur l' individualisme", Paris 1986

: " ( . , . . ), . , ...
, : ", 1975.
, : ", , 1981.
Ricardo, David: " ", , 1992.
Roll, Eric: A History of Economic Thought", Faber & Faber, London 1989.
Rubin, I. Isaac: ", . , 1994.
Smith, Adam: An Inquiry into the Nature and Causes of the Wealth of Nations", 2 , Libetry
Sombart, Werner: Der moderne Kapitalismus", 4 , Verlag von Duncker und Humblot,

Classics, Indianapolis 1981.

Muenchen & Leipzig, 1922.

, : ", , ...
Ste. Croix, G.E.M., de: The Class Struggle in the Ancient Greek World", Duckworth, London 1983.
Ste. Croix, G.E.M., de: Class in Marx's Conception of History, Ancient and Modern, New Left

Review, No

, : , " ,

. 8, 1984.

, : ", , ", ,

146, 1984, . 92-111.

1986.

, : , . 6, 1984, . 95 .
Heinrich, Michael: , Grundrisse" ". ,
, . 51, 1995.

X, : ", 2 , 1989.

[1] E .

[2] :
-, , , ,
. ,
, " ". ( .).

[3] " (...) , ,

,
.
,
" (David Ricardo, 1992, . 1).

[4] Carey,
, 1848 Ricardo " ,
, " ( Rubin 1994, . 416).

[5] " ,
(...) :
' (...) ,
" ( 1989, . 240-241). "
, - ,

 (...) , '
,
, , (...)"
( ..., . 45 61). ,
( ) "
", " ", - ( ,
- ), "- " ...
(. ..., 1992), (Mreau 1978, . 6, . 99 .).

[6] " , , '

, ' .
19. , Durkheim
" ( 1987, . 75).

[7] " " -

, ,
: .. "" , "", "", "" ""
. "", " " ("life
style") ... . .. Vester 1994.

[8] , "" , "" ...

. ,
, , :
" "
, " ,
(...) ' " ( ..., . 149)
, " "
" ' ' " (. .).

[9] " " . 1984.

[10] , Weber ( ") (

"),
", ". Weber,
" ( Weber ,
) . De Ste. Croix 1983, . 85 .

[11] Lenski, , . , "

" ( 1984, . 102). . 19

[12] ,
, , .. " ".
" " . (. 1995 ).

[13] , , , ...
.

[14] 52 . 3 : " ,
, ,
, ,
, ". , ,
: "

 , , ;" ( 1978,
1086-1087). '" . Balibar 1986, .
620 . 1994, . 46 .

[15] - , .. -,
, ""
, .

. 1994, . 47-51.
"" " " ( / 1991, . 281 .) "
( ) " (. 306).
,
" " (. 1984- 1984-).

[16] de Ste Croix (1984, . 100),

, ." de Ste Croix
, : '
, (...) (....) " (de Ste Croix 1984, . 99).
Althusser", , .

[17] ,
' " . 1975, . ', . 105 . de Ste Croix (1984, . 102):
, , (
) ,
".
") -
6 ( ,
").

[18] , ,
( ) (, "

).

[19] " ,
.
.
, ,
" ( 1963, . 761).

[20] " , ,
, , " ( 196
. 598). "
" . . Heinrich 1995. . Althusser/Balibar 19
1988, . 61-73.

[21] ( ),
( ), ,
.

[22] H , , , (
)
, .. ,
,
: .. 12, 10 7 ,
(.. , , , ...),

 ,
(, , ...),
, ..

[23] , - :
. ()
. (. 1975).

[24] " ' ' , managers ,

" ( 1978 . 488).

[25] "
, " ( 1981, . 255). ,
. 1975, . 114 ., 19.81, . 29.
. 1988 . 68 . 1990,
71 .

[26] ""
( ).
, "" ,
( 1991). , "
" (Balibar 1986), "" ( 1994)
,
.

[27] ,
() , 1930
.

[28] . (1991, . 61), ,

, , ( "" )
, . ,
- ( - ) ,
, , "" -
.

[29] H "" , ,
Sombart (1922, . 1093), "
" "
[]".

[30] . : Pierre Birnbaum/Jean Leca 1986, " J. El

A. Przeworski, . 60 ., 77 .

[31] " Jones , ,

. " (A. Przeworski, "Capitalism and Social Democracy", CUP, Cambridge 198
. 95. 1991 . 68).

[32] . E. M (1989, . 78): '

"

[33] , , . ,
(...) ,
[ - , ..]" ( .. 1994, . 96).

[34] , , ,
( ) .
(
), ,
. , "" () (, ,
..., . 1994) "" /
, .