Professional Documents
Culture Documents
167 - Vodic Za Primenu Clana 6 Ekljp - Prvo Izdanje 2003
167 - Vodic Za Primenu Clana 6 Ekljp - Prvo Izdanje 2003
0L^OMHQMDL]QHWDXRYRMSXEOLNDFLMLVXVWDYRYLDXWRUDLQHSRYODaH
RGJRYRUQRVW6DYHWD(YURSH2QLVHQHPRJXVPDWUDWL]YDQLaQLP
WXPDaHQMHPNRMHREDYH]XMHGUCDYHXJRYRUQLFHRUJDQH6DYHWD
(YURSHLGUXJHRUJDQHXVWDQRYOMHQHQDRVQRYX(YURSVNH
NRQYHQFLMHROMXGVNLPSUDYLPD
35$92 1$
35$9,A12
68?(1-(
9RGLa ]D SULPHQX
aODQD (YURSVNH NRQYHQFLMH
R OMXGVNLP SUDYLPD
3ULUXaQLN R OMXGVNLP SUDYLPD EU
6DYHW (YURSH
%HRJUDG
$XWRUL
1XDOD 0ROH L &DWKDULQD +DUE\
,]GDYDa
6DYHW (YURSH
.DQFHODULMD X %HRJUDGX
9XND .DUDGCL`D %HRJUDG
7HO
ZZZFRHLQW
=D L]GDYDaD
-RUJHQ *UXQQHW
8UHGQLFL L]GDQMD QD VUSVNRP MH]LNX
7DWMDQD 3DSL`
9ODGDQ -RNVLPRYL`
/HNWRU L NRUHNWRU
-DVPLQD $OLEHJRYL`
7LUDC
SULPHUDND
,6%1
3ULSUHPD L ^WDPSD
'RVLMH %HRJUDG
6DGUCDM
6DGUCDM
8YRG
892'
6YUKDRYRJSULUXaQLNDMHGDSRPRJQHVXGLMDPDQDVYLP
QLYRLPD NDNR EL ELOL VLJXUQL GD VX SRVWXSFL X NRMLPD RQL
SUHGVHGDYDMX YR_HQL X VDJODVQRVWL V REDYH]DPD SR aODQX
(YURSVNHNRQYHQFLMHR OMXGVNLP SUDYLPD
3ULUXaQLNMHSRGHOMHQQDGHORYHRGNRMLKVHVYDNLEDYL
UD]OLaLWLP DVSHNWRP JDUDQWLMD VDGUCDQLK X WRP aODQX
3UYLGHRVDGUCLRS^WLXYRGXSULQFLSHaODQDRGNRMLK
VH YHOLNL EURM YH` RJOHGD X GRPD`LP ]DNRQLPD L SUDYQRM
SUDNVL 0H_XWLP QHNL DVSHNWL YU^HQMD VXGVNH IXQNFLMH PRJX
SUHGVWDYOMDWLSUREOHPHVXGLMLaLMDMHGXCQRVWGDRVLJXUDSR^WR
YDQMH VWDQGDUGD L] .RQYHQFLMH
]D^WLWHSULYDWQRJCLYRWDVWUDQDNDLOLXPHULNRMDMH
SRPL^OMHQMXVXGDQXCQRSRWUHEQDXSRVHEQLPRNRO
QRVWLPD NDGDEL MDYQRVW PRJOD GD QD^NRGLLQWHUHVL
PD SUDYGH
6YDNR NR MH RSWXCHQ ]D NULYLaQR GHOR VPDWUD`H VH
QHYLQLP VYH GRN VH QH GRNDCH QMHJRYD NULYLFD QD
RVQRYX ]DNRQD
6YDNR NR MH RSWXCHQ ]D NULYLaQR GHOR LPD VOHGH`D
PLQLPDOQD SUDYD
D GD X QDMNUD`HP URNX SRGUREQR L QD MH]LNX NRML
UD]XPHEXGHREDYH^WHQRSULURGLLUD]OR]LPD]D
RSWXCEX SURWLY QMHJD
E GD LPD GRYROMQR YUHPHQD L PRJX`QRVWL ]D SULS
UHPDQMH RGEUDQH
F GD VH EUDQL OLaQR LOL SXWHP EUDQLRFD NRJD VDP
L]DEHUHLOLDNRQHPDGRYROMQRVUHGVWDYDGDSODWL
]DSUDYQXSRPR`GDRYXSRPR`GRELMHEHVSODWQR
NDGD LQWHUHVL SUDYGH WR ]DKWHYDMX
G GDLVSLWXMHVYHGRNHSURWLYVHEHLOLGDSRVWLJQHGD
VH RQL LVSLWDMX L GD VH REH]EHGL SULVXVWYR L VDV
OX^DQMH VYHGRND X QMHJRYX NRULVW SRG XVORYLPD
NRML YDCH ]D RQH NRML VYHGRaHSURWLY QMHJD
H GDGRELMHEHVSODWQXSRPR`SUHYRGLRFDDNRQHUD]X
PHLOLQHJRYRULMH]LNNRMLVHXSRWUHEOMDYDQDVXGX
.DR ^WR VH PRCH YLGHWL L] JRUH QDYHGHQRJ WHNVWD aODQ
MHPaL SUDYR QD SUDYLaQR L MDYQR VX_HQMH NRG RGUH_LYDQMD
JUD_DQVNLK SUDYD L REDYH]D SRMHGLQFD LOL RVQRYDQRVWL ELOR
NDNYHRSWXCEHSURWLYQMHJD6XGDSUHWRJD.RPLVLMDWXPDaL
RYXRGUHGEXGRVWD^LURNR]DVQLYDMX`LWRQDQMHQRMIXQGDPHQ
WDOQRMYDCQRVWL]DIXQNFLRQLVDQMHGHPRNUDWLMH8VOXaDMX'HO
FRXUW SURWLY %HOJLMH 6XG MH ]DNOMXaLR GD
8YRG
3RVWDYOMDVHLSLWDQMH^WDVXGLMDWUHEDGDXUDGLXVOXaDMX
NDGD VH WXCLODF QH SRMDYL QD UDVSUDYL $NR VXGLMD SUHVXGL
VDPR QD RVQRYX aLQMHQLFD L] VSLVD WXCLRFD WR QH SUHGVWDYOMD
GLUHNWQR NU^HQMH .RQYHQFLMH DOL SUHGVWDYOMD QH]DGRYROMDYD
MX`XSUDNVX LPRCH GRYHVWL GR VOHGH`LK SUREOHPD
1D SULPHU GD OL MH RGEUDQD LPDOD XYLG X VYH GHORYH
VSLVD" 6XGLMD PRUD SURYHULWL GD OL MH RSWXCHQL GHWDOMQR RED
YH^WHQ R RSWXCEL SURWLY QMHJDQMH 6XGLMD WDNR_H PRUD GD
REDYHVWL RGEUDQX GR NRMLK MH ]DNOMXaDND RQRQD GR^DR QD
RVQRYX VSLVD WXCLRFD 2YR MH QDURaLWR ELWQR DNR VX RYL
]DNOMXaFL RG NOMXaQRJ ]QDaDMD NRG RGOXaLYDQMD NDNR EL VH
RVWDYLOD PRJX`QRVW SRGQR^HQMD DUJXPHQWD X YH]L VD L]YR
_HQMHP]DNOMXaDND6OXaDM3OLVVLHUL6DVVLSURWLY)UDQFXVNH
MHSULPHURYRJDRaHPXJRYRULPR8RYRPVOXaDMXSRGQRVLRFL
VXELOLRSWXCHQL]DGHORNULYLaQRJEDQNURWVWYDo5DVSUDYDSUHG
NULYLaQLP VXGRP ELOD MH RJUDQLaHQD QD RYR GHOR D SR CDOEL
WXCLRFD XSX`HQRM CDOEHQRP VXGX SRGQRVLRFL QLVX QL X MHGQRM
ID]L RSWXCHQL RG VWUDQH VXGVNLK YODVWL GD VX SRPDJDOL LOL
SRGVWLFDOLo NULYLaQR EDQNURWVWYR
(YURSVNL VXG ]D OMXGVND SUDYD VPDWUDR MH GD SRGQRVLRFL
QLVX ]QDOL GD CDOEHQL VXG PRCH GD LK RVXGL L QD SRPDJDQMH L
SRGVWLFDQMH NULYLaQRJ EDQNURWVWYD 7DNR_H 6XG MH SULPHWLR GD
VH GHOR SRPDJDQMD L SRGVWLFDQMDNULYLaQRJEDQNURWVWYDUD]OLNR
YDOR RG GHOD NULYLaQRJ EDQNURWVWYD QH VDPR SRVWHSHQXXNOMX
aHQRVWLVWUDQHNDR^WRMHYODGDWYUGLOD6XGX6WUD]EXUXVPDWUDR
MH GD MH CDOEHQL VXG NRULVWH`L SUDYR NRMH VDVYLP L]YHVQR LPD
GD SUHNYDOLILNXMH aLQMHQLFH QDG NRMLPD LPD MXULVGLNFLMX WUHEDR
GD GR]YROL RGEUDQL PRJX`QRVW GD NRULVWL VYRMD SUDYD SR WRP
SLWDQMXQDSUDNWLaDQLGHORWYRUDQQDaLQDQDURaLWRXSUDYRYUHPH
6XG MH ]DNOMXaLR GD VH UDGL R NU^HQMX aODQD VW WDa D L E
.RQYHQFLMHSUDYRGDRGPDKEXGHREDYH^WHQRRSWXCELLGDLPD
GRYROMQR YUHPHQD L PRJX`QRVWL GD SULSUHPL RGEUDQX X]HWRJ
]DMHGQRVRS^WLPSUDYRPQDSUDYLaQRVX_HQMHSRaODQXVW
3UREOHPL RGJRYRUQRVWL VXGLMH QDVWDMX L NDGDLPD LQGL
FLMD GD MH RSWXCHQL ELR PDOWUHWLUDQ WRNRP SULWYRUD SUH
VX_HQMD6XGVPDWUDGDDNRQHNROLFHRSUDYGDQRWYUGLGDVX
JD SROLFLMD LOL GUXJD VOXCEHQD OLFD R]ELOMQR PDOWUHWLUDOL aODQ
X]HW ]DMHGQR V RS^WRP REDYH]RP GUCDYH GD SR aODQX
VYDNRP RVLJXUD X RNYLUX VYRMH MXULVGLNFLMH SUDYD L VORERGH
JDUDQWRYDQH .RQYHQFLMRP LPSOLFLWQR ]DKWHYD L VSURYR_HQMH
GHORWYRUQH]YDQLaQHLVWUDJH2YDLVWUDJDPRUDLPDWL]DUH]XO
WDW RWNULYDQMH L NDCQMDYDQMH RQLK NRML VX RGJRYRUQL ]D WDNYR
PDOWUHWLUDQMH$NRWRQLMHVOXaDM]DEUDQDPXaHQMDNRMDMHRG
VX^WLQVNH YDCQRVWL ELOD EL QHGHORWYRUQD X SUDNVL L VOXCEHQD
OLFD PRJOD EL SUR`L QHNDCQMHQD ]ERJ ]ORXSRWUHEH SUDYD RQLK
NRML VX SRG QMLKRYRP NRQWURORP 7DNR_H 6XG MH X VOXaDMX
6HOPRXQLSURWLY)UDQFXVNHVPDWUDRGDDNRMHRVREDSULWYR
UHQDXGREURP]GUDYVWYHQRPVWDQMXDXWUHQXWNXSX^WDQMDVH
XVWDQRYHSRYUHGHGUCDYDPRUDGDSUXCL]DGRYROMDYDMX`HRE
MD^QMHQMH QD NRML MH QDaLQ GR^OR GR RYLK SRYUHGD 8 VOXaDMX
GDWDNYRREMD^QMHQMHL]RVWDQHVDVYLPMHMDVQRGDVHSRVWDYOMD
SLWDQMHSUDYDSRaODQX7UHEDLPDWLXYLGXLREDYH]HGUCDYH
SUHPDGUXJLPPH_XQDURGQLPLQVWUXPHQWLPDNDR^WRMH.RQ
YHQFLMD 81 SURWLY PXaHQMD GUXJLK VYLUHSLK L QHKXPDQLK LOL
SRQLCDYDMX`LK ND]QL LOL SRVWXSDND 3UHPD RYRM .RQYHQFLML
VYDND GUCDYD MH L]PH_X RVWDORJ REDYH]QD GD SUHGX]HPH
GHORWYRUQH ]DNRQRGDYQH DGPLQLVWUDWLYQH VXGVNH LOL GUXJH
PHUHNDNRELVSUHaLODPXaHQMHQDWHULWRULMLXVYRMRMQDGOHCQR
VWL 1H SRVWRML PRJX`QRVWGHURJDFLMH RYH RGUHGEH
6XGLMD RGUH_XMH SULKYDWOMLYRVW GRND]D 2QRQD PRUD
GD SULPHQMXMH =DNRQ R NULYLaQRP SRVWXSNX X VNODGX VD VXG
VNRP SUDNVRP NRMH SURLVWLaH L] .RQYHQFLMH 3LWDQMD SRSXW
SROLFLMVNLKGRX^QLNDLOLDJHQDWDSURYRNDWRUDo]DKWHYDSRVHE
QX SDCQMX LVWR NDR L SLWDQMH SULNULYDQMD LQIRUPDFLMD X FLOMX
GUCDYQH EH]EHGQRVWL
6XGLMD WDNR_HPRUDGD RPRJX`L RGJRYDUDMX`H XVOX
JH SUHYR_HQMD YLGL SRJODYOMH
5DGL REH]EH_HQMD SR^WRYDQMD SUHWSRVWDYNH QHYLQR
VWLVXGLMDPRUDGDL]GDRGJRYDUDMX`LQDORJNDNRELVHL]EHJOR
^WHWQRL]YH^WDYDQMHXPHGLMLPD0H_XWLPXPHVWRGDSRWSXQR
LVNOMXaLSULVXVWYRPHGLMDVXGLMDWUHEDMDVQRGDVWDYLGR]QDQMD
QRYLQDULPD^WDMHWRRaHPXPRJXLOLQHPRJXGDL]YH^WDYDMX
YLGL YL^HR RYRP SLWDQMX X SRJODYOMX
, QD NUDMX VXGLMD PRCH LPDWL ]DGXCHQMD L X YH]L V
L]YU^HQMHP SUHVXGH 'UCDYD LPD RGJRYRUQRVW GD REH]EHGL
GDVHSUHVXGHL]YU^DYDMX$NRQLMHGQRGUXJROLFHXQXWDUVXG
VNRJVLVWHPDQHPDRYXSRVHEQXRGJRYRUQRVWRQGDRQDRVWDMH
QD VXGLML
3UHPDWRPHNDNRVXRYRSUDYRLOLREDYH]DRGUH_HQLX
GRPD`HP SUDYX QLMH RGOXaXMX`H 2YD VPHUQLFD MH QDURaLWR
YDCQDXVOXaDMHYLPD NRMLXNOMXaXMXRGQRVHL]PH_XSRMHGLQFD
L GUCDYH 8 WDNYRM VLWXDFLML 6XG MH ]DNOMXaLR GD QLMH RG
OXaXMX`H GD OL MH MDYQD YODVW X SLWDQMX SRVWXSLOD NDR SULYDWQR
OLFHLOLYU^H`LMDYQDRYOD^`HQMD.OMXaQDVWYDUGDOLMHaODQ
SULPHQOMLY LOL QH MH GD OL MH LVKRG SRVWXSND RGOXaXMX`L ]D
SULYDWQD SUDYD L REDYH]H
'UXJRVYDNLXQLIRUPQLHYURSVNLNRQFHSWSULURGHRYRJ
SUDYD WUHED X]HWL X RE]LU
7UH`H 6XG VPDWUD GD aDN LDNR MH NRQFHSW JUD_DQVNLK
SUDYD L REDYH]D DXWRQRPDQ ]DNRQL GUCDYH X SLWDQMX QLVX
QHYDCQL8VOXaDMX.QLJSURWLY651HPDaNH6XGMH]DNOMXaLRGD
'D OL VH QHNR SUDYR PRCH X]HWL ]D JUD_DQVNR X
]QDaHQMXNRMHPXGDMH.RQYHQFLMDPRUDVHRGUH_LYDWLSR]L
YDQMHP QD PDWHULMDOQX VWUDQX L SRVOHGLFH NRMH SURL]LOD]H L]
WRJ SUDYD r D QH QD QMHJRYX SUDYQX NODVLILNDFLMX r X GR
PD`HPSUDYQRPVLVWHPXGUCDYHXSLWDQMX
8VOXaDMX2VPDQSURWLY8MHGLQMHQRJ.UDOMHYVWYD6XG
MH ]DNOMXaLR GD NDGD QHNR RS^WH SUDYR SRVWRML X GRPD`HP
VLVWHPX GUCDYD XJRYRUQLFD QH PRCH L]EHJDYDWL SULPHQX JD
UDQWLMD SUDYLaQRJ VX_HQMD SR aODQX DNR QMHQL VXGRYL QH
XYDCH RYR SUDYRX QHNRP RGUH_HQRP VOXaDMX
.DR ^WR MH YH` UHaHQR 6XG VH SULNORQLR SULVWXSX GD
RGOXaXMH XYHN QD RVQRYX SRVHEQLK RNROQRVWL VYDNRJ SRMHGL
QDaQRJVOXaDMD8GDOMHPWHNVWXVOHGHSULPHULNRMLSRPL^OMH
QMX6XGD XNOMXaXMX SLWDQMD JUD_DQVNRJ SUDYD LOLREDYH]H
JUD_DQVND,PRYLQDMHMHGQRRGSUDYDJGH6XGVPD
WUDGDVHaODQPRCHSULPHQLWL*DUDQWLMDSUDYLaQRJ
SRVWXSND SULPHQMXMH VH QD ID]H X SRVWXSNX HNVSUR
SULMDFLMH NRQVROLGDFLMH L SODQLUDQMD NDR L SRVWXSNH
XYH]LGRELMDQMDJUD_HYLQVNLKGR]YRODLGUXJLKGR]
YROD]DQHNUHWQLQHNRMHLPDMXGLUHNWQHSRVOHGLFHSR
SUDYR YODVQL^WYD X RGQRVX QD LPRYLQX X SLWDQMX
NDR L QD SRVWXSNH JGH MH LVKRG YH]DQ ]D NRUL^`HQMH
LOLXCLYDQMH LPRYLQH
AODQ WDNR_H REXKYDWD SUDYR QD XaHVWYRYDQMH X
NRPHUFLMDOQRMDNWLYQRVWL2YLVOXaDMHYLXNOMXaXMXXV
NUD`LYDQMHGR]YROH]DWRaHQMHDONRKRODGR]YROX]D
UDG NOLQLNH LOL L]GDYDQMH GR]YROH ]D UDG SULYDWQH
^NROH 3UDYR QD SULYDWQX SUDNVX X PHGLFLQL LOL
SUDYXMH WDNR_H REXKYD`HQR aODQRP
6XG WDNR_H VPDWUD GD VH aODQ SULPHQMXMH L QD
SRVWXSNH R SUDYLPD L REDYH]DPD L] REODVWL SRUR
GLaQRJSUDYD1DSULPHURGOXNHRGRGHOMLYDQMXVWD
9LGL QSU 6SRUURQJ L /QQURWK SURWLY >YHGVNH VHSWHPEDU
3RLVVSURWLY$XVWULMHDSULO%RGHQSURWLY>YHGVNHRNWR
EDU +NDQVVRQ L 6WXUHVVRQ SURWLY >YHGVNH IHEUXDU
0DWV -DFREVVRQ SURWLY >YHGVNH MXQ L 5XL]0DWHRV SURWLY
>SDQLMHVHSWHPEDU
1SU 2HUODPDQV SURWLY +RODQGLMH QRYHPEDU L 'H *HRIIUH
GH OD 3UDGHOOH SURWLY )UDQFXVNH GHFHPEDU
7UH7UDNWUHU SURWLY>YHGVNH MXO
.QLJ SURWLY65 1HPDaNH MXQ
-RUGHEUR)RXQGDWLRQSURWLY>YHGVNHPDUW,]YH^WDM.RPLVLMH
'5
.QLJ SURWLY 65 1HPDaNH MXQ L + SURWLY %HOJLMH
QRYHPEDU
UDYQRPSRVWXSNXLOLNULYLaQRPSRVWXSNX3ULPH
QMXMH VH L QD SRVWXSNH X NRMLPD SRVWRML ]DKWHY ]D
QDNQDGX ^WHWH ]ERJ QH]DNRQLWRJ GUCDQMD X ]DWYRUX
SUHPD aODQX VW QDNRQ RVORED_DMX`H SUHVXGH X
NULYLaQRP SRVWXSNX 3UDYR QD SRYUD`DM QRYFD
SOD`HQRJ QD LPH SRUH]D MH WDNR_H SRNULYD aODQ
3RMHGLQDaQR SUDYR QD SR^WRYDQMH XJOHGD RG GUXJRJ
SULYDWQRJOLFDWDNR_HVHVPDWUDJUD_DQVNLPSUDYRP
, QD NUDMX6XGVPDWUDGDDNRLVKRGXXVWDYQRSUDY
QRP LOL MDYQRSUDYQRP SRVWXSNX PRCH ELWL RGOXaXMX`L
]D JUD_DQVND SUDYD L REDYH]H RQGD VH aODQRP
JDUDQWXMHSUDYLaQR VX_HQMX L X RYLP SRVWXSFLPD
UDRQD SURWLY 3RUWXJDOLMH MXO L; SURWLY )UDQFXVNH PDUW
0RUHLUDGH $]HYHGR SURWLY 3RUWXJDOLMH RNWREDU
*HRULJLDGLVSURWLY *UaNH PDM
1DWLRQDO 3URYLQFLRQDO %XLOGLQJ 6RFLHW\ SURWLY 8MHGLQMHQRJ .UD
OMHYVWYD VHSWHPEDU
9LGLQSU)D\HGSURWLY8MHGLQMHQRJ.UDOMHYVWYDVHSWHPEDU
5XL]0DWHRV SURWLY>SDQLMHVHSWHPEDU
'5
EU
6UELMD L &UQD *RUD 6O OLVW 6&* EU VDYH]QL ]DNRQL L] REODVWL
NRMH QLVX X QDGOHCQRVWL GUCDYQH ]DMHGQLFH SULPHQMXMX VH NDR RS^WL
DNWLGUCDYDaODQLFDGRNLKQMLKRYLQDGOHCQLRUJDQLQHVWDYHYDQVQDJH
RVLP X GHORYLPD X NRMLPD VX X VXSURWQRVWL V 8VWDYQRP SRYHOMRP L
L]X]HY X REODVWLPD JGH YH` SRVWRML ]DNRQRGDYVWYR UHSXEOLNH aODQLFH
aO VW =DNRQLN R NULYLaQRP SRVWXSNX =DNRQ R SDUQLaQRP
SRVWXSNXL=DNRQRYDQSDUQLaQRPSRVWXSNXVX]QDaLVDGDRS^WLSUDYQL
DNWL NRML VH SULPHQMXMX X UHSXEOLNDPD aODQLFDPD ,VWL MH VOXaDM L VD GROH
SRPHQXWLP =DNRQRPRSULYUHGQLPSUHVWXSLPD=DNRQRPRSUHNU^DMLPD
L .ULYLaQLP]DNRQRP 65-
6OOLVW 65- EU
6OOLVW 6&* EU
LOL NDGD
SRVWRML VLWXDFLMD X NRMRM MH RVXPQMLaHQL NRMD ELWQR
XWLaHQDQMHJRYSRORCDM
ODFSULKYDWLRSRQXGX]DSULMDWHOMVNRSRUDYQDQMH6XGX6WDU]
EXUX MH L SRUHG WRJD VPDWUDR GD SURWLY SRGQRVLRFD SRVWRML
NULYLaQD RSWXCED
8WHNVWXNRMLVOHGLQDYH^`HVHMR^QHNROLNRSULPHUD^WD
aLQLMHGQXRSWXCEXo
.DGDMHL]GDWQDORJ]DKDS^HQMH]ERJNULYLaQRJGHOD
NDGDMHOLFH]YDQLaQRREDYH^WHQRGDVHYRGLNULYLaQL
SRVWXSDN
NDGD LVWUDCQL RUJDQL ]D FDULQVNH SUHN^DMH ]DKWHYDMX
RG OLFD GD SUHGRaL GRND]H L ]DPU]QH VYRM EDQNRYQL
UDaXQ
NDGDMHOLFHLPHQRYDORDGYRNDWDQDNRQ^WRMHWXCLODF
SRNUHQXR SRVWXSDN QD RVQRYX SROLFLMVNRJ L]YH^WDMD
SURWLY QMHJD
2YGHVXUHOHYDQWQHWULVWYDULNODVLILNDFLMDSRGRPD`HP
]DNRQX SULURGD GHODL SULURGD L R^WULQD ND]QH
'RPD`D NODVLILNDFLMD
$NRMHRSWXCEDNODVLILNRYDQDNDRNULYLaQDXGRPD`HP
]DNRQX WXCHQH GUCDYH aODQ VH DXWRPDWVNL SULPHQMXMH QD
SRVWXSDN D UD]PDWUDQMD QDYHGHQD X GDOMHP WHNVWX QH`H VH
SULPHQLWL0H_XWLPDNRRSWXCEDQLMHNODVLILNRYDQDNDRNUL
YLaQDWRQH`HELWLRGOXaXMX`H]DSULPHQXJDUDQWLMDSUDYLaQRJ
VX_HQMD SR aODQX $NR EL WRELORVOXaDMGUCDYHXJRYRUQLFH
EL PRJOH GD L]EHJQX SULPHQX JDUDQWLMH SUDYLaQRJ VX_HQMD
WDNR ^WR EL GHNULPLQDOL]RYDOH LOL SUHNYDOLILNRYDOH NULYLaQD
GHOD6XGMHWRL]QHRXVOXaDMX(QJHOLRVWDOLSURWLY+RODQGLMH
.DGD EL GUCDYH XJRYRUQLFH PRJOH SUHPD VYRMRM GLV
NUHFLML GD NODVLILNXMX QHNR GHOR NDR SUHNU^DM XPHVWR NDR
NULYLaQRGHORLOLSRNUHQXSUHNU^DMQLSRVWXSDNSURWLYL]YU^LR
FDPH^RYLWRJGHODoDQHNULYLaQLXWRPVOXaDMXELSULPHQD
VX^WLQVNLK RGUHGEL aODQRYD L ELOD SRGUH_HQD QMLKRYRM
VXYHUHQRM YROML 2YR ^LURNR WXPDaHQMH EL PRJOR GRYHVWL GR
LVKRGDNRMLVXQHNRPSDWLELOQLVDVYUKRPLFLOMHP.RQYHQFLMH
3ULURGD GHOD
2YRXNOMXaXMHGYDSRGNULWHULMXPD$rRELPSUHNU^HQH
QRUPH L % rVYUKXND]QH
$ r 2ELP SUHNU^HQH QRUPH
$NRVHQRUPDXSLWDQMXSULPHQMXMHVDPRQDRJUDQLaHQX
JUXSXOMXGLNDR^WRMHQDSULPHUQHNDSURIHVLMDWRELLQGLFL
(QJHOLRVWDOL SURWLY +RODQGLMH MXQ VWDY
UDORGDVHUDGLRGLVFLSOLQVNRMDQHNULYLaQRMQRUPL0H_XWLP
DNRQRUPDLPDRS^WHGHMVWYRRQGDMHRQDYHURYDWQRNULYLaQD
SUHPDaODQX8VOXaDMX:HEHUSURWLY>YDMFDUVNHSRGQRVLODF
MH SRGQHR NULYLaQX WXCEX ]ERJ NOHYHWH L RGUCDR NRQIHUHQFLMX
]D^WDPSXNDNRELREDYHVWLRMDYQRVWRVYRMRMWXCEL1RYaDQR
MHNDCQMHQ]ERJRPHWDQMDWDMQRVWLLVWUDJH3RGQRVLODFVHCDOLR
QD NU^HQMH aODQD MHU MH QMHJRYD CDOED QD SUHVXGX RGEDaHQD
D GD QLMH RGUCDQD MDYQD UDVSUDYD 8 RYRP VOXaDMX ]DGDWDN
6XGDMHELRGDGRQHVHRGOXNXGDOLVHUDGLORRNULYLaQRPGHOX
L 6XG MH ]DX]HR VOHGH`L VWDY
'LVFLSOLQVNHPHUHVXXJODYQRPSRVWDYOMHQHNDNRELVH
REH]EHGLORGDSULSDGQLFLRGUH_HQLKJUXSDSR^WXMXRGUH_HQD
SUDYLODSRQD^DQMD1DGDOMHXYH`LQLGUCDYDXJRYRUQLFDRE
MDYOMLYDQMH LQIRUPDFLMD X YH]L V LVWUDJRP NRMD MH X WRNX
SUHGVWDYOMDGHORNRMHMHXQHVNODGXVWLPSUDYLOLPDLNRMHMH
NDCQMLYRQDRVQRYXQL]DUD]OLaLWLKRGUHGEL/LFDNRMDVXYL^H
RG RVWDOLK REDYH]QD GD aXYDMX SRYHUOMLYRVW LVWUDJH VXGLMH
DGYRNDWL L VYL RQL NRML VX XVNR SRYH]DQLVDIXQNFLRQLVDQMHP
VXGRYDXWDNYRPVOXaDMXSRGOHCXQH]DYLVQRRGELORNDNYLK
NULYLaQLKVDQNFLMDGLVLSOLQVNLPND]QDPD]ERJSULURGHVYRMH
SURIHVLMH6WUDQHXSRVWXSNXVGUXJHVWUDQHXaHVWYXMXXWRP
SRVWXSNX VDPR NDR RVREH NRMH SRGOHCX MXULVGLNFLML VXGRYD
WH SUHPD WRPH QH SRWSDGDMX SRG GLVFLSOLQVNX VIHUX XQXWDU
VXGVNRJ VLVWHPD 0H_XWLP NDNR aODQ SRWHQFLMDOQR SR
JD_D FHOR VWDQRYLQL^WYR GHOR NRMH RQ GHILQL^H L NRMLP SUR
SLVXMHND]QHQHVDQNFLMHMHVWHNULYLaQRoSUHPDGUXJRPNUL
WHULMXPX
,VWRWDNRQLXVOXaDMX'HPLFROLSURWLY0DOWHSRVWXSDN
SRNUHQXWSURWLYQRYLQDUD]ERJNU^HQMDSULYLOHJRYDQRJVWDWXVD
MHUMHREMDYLRR^WDUNULWLaNLaODQDNRGYDaODQDSDUODPHQWD
QLMH VPDWUDQ SLWDQMHP LQWHUQH SDUDODPHQWDUQH GLVFLSOLQH
MHU VH UHOHYDQWQD RGUHGED SRWHQFLMDOQR RGQRVLOD QD VYH
OMXGH
0H_XWLPXVOXaDMX5DYQVERUJSURWLY>YHGVNH6XGMH
SULPHWLR GD VX VH L]UHaHQH QRYaDQH ND]QH RGQRVLOH QD L]MDYH
NRMHMHSRGQRVLODFGDRXVYRMVWYXVWUDQHXVXGVNRPSRVWXSNX
7DPHUDSRVWRMLGDELVHRVLJXUDORSR^WRYDQMHVXGVNLKSURFH
GXUD WH MH VYRMVWYHQLMD GLVFLSOLQVNRM PHUL QHJR NULYLaQRM RS
WXCEL 3UHPD WRPH aODQ RYGH QLMH ELR SULPHQOMLY
% r 6YUKD ND]QH
8VOXaDMX%HQKDPSURWLY8MHGLQMHQRJ.UDOMHYVWYD 6XG
MH VPDWUDR GD WDPR JGH MH OL^DYDQMH VORERGH X SLWDQMX
LQWHUHVL SUDYGH XSULQFLSX ]DKWHYDMXSUDYQR ]DVWXSDQMHo
8 VOXaDMX&DPSEHOO L)HOO SURWLY 8MHGLQMHQRJ .UDOMHY
VWYD6XGMHL]MDYLRGDJXELWDNVPDQMHQMDND]QH]DVNRURWUL
6XG MH VPDWUDR GD GXCLQD ]DWYRUVNH ND]QH RG GYD GDQD QLMH
GRYROMQD GD EL VH LVWD VPDWUDOD NULYLaQRP ND]QRP
3UHWQMD ]DWYRUVNRP ND]QRP PRCH WDNR_H GRYHVWL GR
SULPHQH aODQD 8 VOXaDMX (QJHO L RVWDOL SURWLY +RODQGLMH
aLQMHQLFD GD MH MHGDQ RG SRGQRVLODFD SUHGVWDYNH QD NUDMX L
GRELR ND]QX NRMD QLMH ELOD OL^DYDQMH VORERGH QLMH XWLFDOR QD
RFHQX6XGDNDGDNRQDaQLLVKRGQLMHPRJDRXPDQMLWLYDCQRVW
RQRJD^WR MH LQLFLMDOQR ELOR X RSDVQRVWL
.DGD NRQNUHWQD ND]QD QLMH ]DWYRUVND LOL SUHWQMD ]DWYR
URPQHJRQRYaDQDND]QD6XGX]LPDXUD]PDWUDQMHGDOLVH
UDGL R PDWHULMDOQRM QDNQDGL ^WHWH LOL MH RQD X VX^WLQL ND]QD
NRMRP VH RGYUD`D RG SRQRYOMHQRJ NULYLaQRJ GHOD 6DPR X
RYRP GUXJRP VOXaDMX VPDWUD VH GD RYDNYD ND]QD VSDGD X
NULYLaQX VIHUX
X.RPSDWLELOQRVWMXJRVORYHQVNRJ]DNRQRGDYVWYDVRGUHGEDPD(YURS
VNHNRQYHQFLMHROMXGVNLPSUDYLPD6DYHW(YURSH%HRJUDGVWU
.ULYLaQD GHOD
3ULYUHGQL SUHVWXSL
3ULYUHGQLSUHVWXSLVXVSHFLILaQDYUVWDGHODNRMXSR]QDMX
MR^VDPRQHNH]HPOMHELY^H6)5-3ULYUHGQLSUHVWXSLXSUDY
QRPVLVWHPX6UELMHL&UQH*RUHSUHGVWDYOMDMXSRYUHGHSUDYLOD
RSULYUHGQRPLILQDQVLMVNRPSRVORYDQMXNRMHSURX]URNXMXLOL
PRJXGDSURX]URNXMXWHCHSRVOHGLFHNRMHVXRGUH_HQH]DNR
QRP LOL XUHGERP 2QL SUHGVWDYOMDMX ODN^H SRYUHGH RG NUL
YLaQLK GHODDWHCHRG SUHNU^DMD
2ELaQRVXRYDNYDGHODRGUH_HQDELORQRUPDPDJUD_DQ
VNRJ LOL XSUDYQRJ SUDYD ELOR NRGHNVLPD SRVORYQH HWLNH LOL
XNROLNRWH^NRPRJXXJUR]LWLQRUPDODQHNRQRPVNLCLYRWRQGD
QRUPDPDNULYLaQRJSUDYD.RGQDVQL^WDRGWRJDQLMHVOXaDM
YH` VH R SULYUHGQLP SUHNU^DMLPD RGOXaXMH X SRVHEQRP SRV
WXSNXSUHGYL_HQRP=DNRQRPRSULYUHGQLPSUHVWXSLPDGRN
VH VDPR QHNH RGUHGEH =.3 SULPHQMXMX 2 RYLP GHOLPD RG
OXaXMX SRVHEQLSULYUHGQLVXGRYL
3UHG(YURSVNLPVXGRPELVHPQRJLSULYUHGQLSUHVWXSL
SUHPDYUORYLVRNLPQRYaDQLPND]QDPDNDRLR]ELOMQRVW]D^WLW
QLKPHUDNRMHLKSUDWHVPDWUDOL]DNULYLaQDGHOD6WRJDELVYH
JDUDQWLMH NRMH aODQ SUXCD PRUDOH GD VH SULPHQMXMX L X
SRVWXSNX RNR SULYUHGQLK SUHNU^DMD ,DNR VDP =DNRQ R SULY
UHGQLPSUHVWXSLPDSUHGYL_DSULPHQXRGUH_HQLKRGUHGEL=.3RQH
QLVXGRYROMQHGDSUXCHSRWSXQX]D^WLWXSUHGYL_HQXaODQRP
=DWRMHQHRSKRGQRL]YU^LWLUHIRUPXGHODSUDYQRJVLVWH
PD NRML VH RGQRVL QD SULYUHGQH SUHNU^DMH QDURaLWR YRGH`L
UDaXQD R GHNULPLQL]DFLMLGHUHJXODFLML RGUH_HQLK GHOD L XNOMXaLYD
,G VWU
6OOLVW 6)5-EU 6OOLVW65-
6XSUDIXVQRWD
QMXRVWDWNDREODVWLNRMHSULYUHGQLSUHNU^DMLSRNULYDMXXREODVW
NULYLaQRJLWRGHODNRMDWH^NRXJURCDYDMXQRUPDODQHNRQRP
VNLCLYRWDRQGDLJUD_DQVNRJLXSUDYQRJSUDYDRVWDODGHOD
NRMDXJURCDYDMX HNRQRPVNL CLYRW
-DYQDUDVSUDYDMHRELaQRSRWUHEQDNDNRELVH]DGRYROMLOL
]DKWHYLaODQDVWSUHGVXGRYLPDSUYRJVWHSHQDLOLMHGLQRJ
$[HQ SURWLY65 1HPDaNH GHFHPEDU VWDY
VWHSHQD0H_XWLPXWHKQLaNLPVWYDULPDMDYQDUDVSUDYDVHQH
PRUD XYHN ]DKWHYDWL
$NR VH MDYQD UDVSUDYD QH RGUCL QD SUYRM LQVWDQFL WR
PRCH ELWL LVSUDYOMHQR RGUCDYDQMHP MDYQH UDVSUDYH QD YL^RM
LQVWDQFL 0H_XWLP DNR CDOEHQL VXG QH UD]PDWUD PHULWXP
VOXaDMD LOL QLMH PHURGDYDQ GD VH EDYL VYLP DVSHNWLPD NRQN
UHWQHPDWHULMHWDGDSRVWRMLNU^HQMHaODQD8VOXaDMX'LHQQHW
SURWLY )UDQFXVNH 6XG MH VPDWUDR GD WR ^WR QLMH RGUCDQD
MDYQD UDVSUDYD SUHG SUHNU^DMQLP RUJDQRP QLMH LVSUDYOMHQR
aLQMHQLFRP GD MH CDOEHQR PHGLFLQVNR WHOR RGUCDOR VYRMX UDV
SUDYXMDYQRMHUVHRQRQHVPDWUDVXGVNLPRUJDQRPNRMLLPD
QDGOHCQRVWDSRVHEQRQHPDRYOD^`HQMHGDSURFHQMXMHGDOLMH
ND]QDXSLWDQMXSURSRUFLRQDOQDNU^HQMXGXCQRVWL3RWUHEQLVX
L]X]HWQL UD]OR]L GD EL VH RSUDYGDOR ]D^WR QLMH ELOR MDYQH
UDVSUDYHXNROLNRRQDQLMHRGUCDQDQDSUYRVWHSHQRMLQVWDQFL
3UDYR QD MDYQX UDVSUDYX RELaQR XNOMXaXMH SUDYR QD
URaL^WHSUHWUHVXNROLNR QH SRVWRMH L]X]HWQH RNROQRVWL
1HSRVWRMLRS^WL]DKWHY]DURaL^WHPSUHWUHVRPSUHGCDO
EHQLPVXGRP1DSULPHUXVOXaDMX$[HQSURWLY651HPDaNH
6XG MH VPDWUDR GD X NULYLaQLP VOXaDMHYLPD URaLVWH QLMH ELOR
SRWUHEQR NDGD MH CDOEHQL VXG RGEDFLR CDOEX VDPR QD RVQRYX
SUDYD 0H_XWLP NDGD CDOEHQL VXG PRUD GD UD]PDWUD L aLQMH
QLFH L SUDYR L NDGD RGOXaXMH R SLWDQMX NULYLFH LOL QHYLQRVWL
RSWXCHQRJ URaL^WH MH QHRSKRGQR 6PDWUD VH GD MH X SDU
QLaQLPSRVWXSFLPDURaL^WHSRCDOELQHSRWUHEQR8VOXaDMX.
6FKXOOHU=UDJJHQMXQVWDYrSUDYRSRGQRVLRFDQDLQYD
OLGVNX SHQ]LMX
'LHQQHWSURWLY )UDQFXVNH VHSWHPEDU VWDY
6WDOOLQJHUL .XVR SURWLY$XVWULMH DSULO VWDY
)LVFKHUSURWLY $XWULMH DSULO VWDY
$[HQ SURWLY65 1HPDaNH GHFHPEDU VWDY
(NEDWDQLSURWLY >YHGVNH PDMVWDY r
SURWLY>YDMFDUVNHSRGQRVLODFMHYRGLRGXJRWUDMDQSRVWXSDN
V MHGQRP ILUPRP V NRMRP MH XJRYRULR QDGRJUDGQMX NX`H
3UYRVWHSHQLVXGMHSUHVXGLRSURWLYSRGQRVLRFDXNRULVWILUPH
L CDOEHQL VXG MH SRWYUGLR RYX SUHVXGX 3RGQRVLODF VH ]DWLP
CDOLR )HGHUDOQRP VXGX NRML MH RGELR CDOEX EH] ]DND]LYDQMD
UDVSUDYH L QLMH WUDCLRSLVDQL SRGQHVDN
.RPLVLMD MH ]DX]HOD VOHGH`L VWDY
1DGDOMHSRSLWDQMXWXCEHSRGQRVLRFDGDVXGLMH)HGH
UDOQRJ VXGD QLVX YH`DOH L JODVDOH MDYQR R QMHJRYRM CDOEL X
SDUQLaQRP SRVWXSNX .RPLVLMD SULPH`XMH GD WDNYR SUDYR
QLMHSUHGYL_HQR.RQYHQFLMRP
8YH]LVRYLPSLWDQMHPYLGLSRJODYOMHSRGQDVORYRP
3UDYLaQDUDVSUDYDrSUDYRQDUDVSUDYXXSULVXVWYXRSWXCHQRJ
8L]YHVQLPVOXaDMHYLPDSRGQRVLODFPRCHGDVHRGUHNQH
VYRJSUDYDQDMDYQXUDVSUDYX8VOXaDMX+NDQVVRQL6WXUHV
VRQ SURWLY >YHGVNH6XGMH L]QHR VOHGH`H
-DVQRMHGDQLVORYRQLGXKRYHRGUHGEHQHVSUHaDYD
QHNROLFHGDVHRGUHNQHSRVRSVWYHQRMYROMLL]ULaLWRLOLSUH`XWQR
VYRJ SUDYD QD MDYQX UDVSUDYX 0H_XWLP RGULFDQMH PRUD
ELWLQHRSR]LYRLQHVPHELWLXVXSURWQRVWLVELORNRMLPYDCQLP
MDYQLPLQWHUHVRP
$OEHUW L /H &RPSWH SURWLY %HOJLMH IHEUXDU VWDY L +
EHQRJYRMQRJVXGDMHUMHSUHVXGDQDGUXJLQDaLQELODGRVWXS
QD MDYQRVWL SRJRWRYR ^WR VH XYHN PRJOD ]DWUDCLWL NRSLMD
SUHVXGHRGVHNUHWDULMDWDVXGDDELODMHLREMDYOMHQDLXVOXCEH
QRM]ELUFL SUHVXGD RYRJ VXGD
6YLSRPHQXWLVOXaDMHYLRGQRVHVHQDSUHVXGHVSUHWUHVD
QDYL^LPLQVWDQFDPDXRNYLUXVXGVNRJVLVWHPDL6XGMHVPD
WUDR GD QLMH ELOR QLNDNYRJ NU^HQMD 0H_XWLP X VOXaDMHYLPD
:HUQHU SURWLY $XVWULMHL 6]XFV SURWLY $XVWULMH JGH QL
SUYRVWHSHQLLVXGRYLQLCDOEHQLQLVXMDYQRL]UHNOLSUHVXGXQLWL
VXLQWHJUDOQLWHNVWRYLQMLKRYLKSUHVXGDELOLRWYRUHQL]DMDYQRVW
XVHNUHWDULMDWLPDRYLKVXGRYDDSULVWXSMHELRRJUDQLaHQVDPR
RVREDPD VD]DNRQVNL RSUDYGDQLP LQWHUHVRPo6XG MH VPDW
UDR GD VH UDGL R NU^HQMX aODQD
6XGMHWDNR_HVPDWUDRNU^HQMHLXVOXaDMX&DPSEHOOL
)HOO SURWLY 8MHGLQMHQRJ .UDOMHYVWYD ]DWR ^WR X UDVSUDYL X
SUHNU^DMQRPSRVWXSNXX]DWYRUX,QVSHNFLMVNLRGERUQLMHVYRMX
RGOXNX SURJODVLR MDYQR L QLMH SUHGX]HR NRUDNH GD EXGH GRV
WXSQD MDYQRVWL
8VNODGXVSUDYLORPGDMHL]SRVWXSDNDSUHPDPDOROHW
QLFLPD LVNOMXaHQD MDYQRVW =.3SUHGYL_DGDMH]DREMDYOMLYD
QMH WRND SRVWXSDND NDR L GRQHWH RGOXNH QHRSKRGQD RGOXND
VXGD aO VW 1L X MHGQRP VOXaDMX QLMH GRSX^WHQR
REMDYOMLYDQMHLPHQDPDOROHWQLNDLGUXJLKSRGDWDNDQDRVQRYX
NRMLKELVHPRJOR]DNOMXaLWLRNRPHMHUHaaOVW=33
R RYRPHQH VDGUCL SRVHEQHRGUHGEH
,DNR WHNVW .RQYHQFLMH QH SUHGYL_D L]X]HWNH RG SUDYLOD
GD VH SUHVXGD PRUD L]UH`L MDYQR 6XG MH X YL^H QDYUDWD QDJ
ODVLRGDRYXRGUHGEXQHWUHEDEXNYDOQRSULPHQMLYDWL1DLPH
MDYQRVWL]ULFDQMDSUHVXGHWUHEDSURFHQMLYDWLVRE]LURPQDSR
VHEQH RNROQRVWL VOXaDMD NDR L WRJD GD OL MH WR X VNODGX V
SUHGPHWRP L VYUKRP aODQD VW WM REH]EH_LYDQMHP SUD
YLaQRJVX_HQMD$NRQHELSRVWRMDOLL]X]HFLRGREDYH]QRJ
MDYQRJ L]ULFDQMD SUHVXGH VYUKD RYRJ aODQD NRML RPRJX`DYD
LVNOMXaLYDQMH MDYQRVWL NDGD WR L]PH_X RVWDORJ ]DKWHYDMX LQ
WHUHVL PDOROHWQLND LOL ]D^WLWD SULYDWQRJ CLYRWD VWUDQDND L LQWH
UHVL]D^WLWHSUDYGHXUDVSUDYLSUHGVXGRPQHELELODLVSXQMH
QD
'DNOHPRCHVH]DNOMXaLWLGDMHSUDYR6UELMHL&UQH*RUH
SRWRPSLWDQMXL]X]HWDNDRGMDYQRJL]ULFDQMDSUHVXGHXVNODGX
V HYURSVNLP VWDQGDUGLPD
6XWWHU SURWLY >YDMFDUVNH IHEUXDU VWDY 8 SRVWXSFLPD V
9LGL 6FRSHOOLWL SURWLY ,WDOLMH QRYHPEDU VWDY L% SURWLY
6XGMHXVYRMRMVXGVNRMSUDNVLXVSRVWDYLRSULQFLSGDVH
XRFHQMLYDQMXGDOLVHGXCLQDYUHPHQVNRJURNDPRCHVPDWUDWL
UD]XPQRP X]LPDMXX RE]LU VOHGH`L IDNWRULVORCHQRVWVOXaDMD
SRQD^DQMH SRGQRVLRFD SRQD^DQMH VXGVNLK L XSUDYQLK RUJDQD
GUCDYH NDR LNDNYR MH SUDYRX SLWDQMX]DSRGQRVLRFD
6XG X]LPD X RE]LU SRVHEQH RNROQRVWL SUHGPHWD L QLMH
RGUHGLRQHNLDSVROXWQLYUHPHQVNLRNYLUXNRPHELWUHEDORGD
WUDMH SRVWXSDN 3RQHNDG 6XG SUH GDMH VYHXNXSQX SURFHQX
QHJR GDVH GLUHNWQR SR]LYD QD JRUH SRPHQXWH NULWHULMXPH
6ORCHQRVW VOXaDMD
6YL DVSHNWL VOXaDMD VX UHOHYDQWQL X SURFHQL QMHJRYH
VORCHQRVWL6ORCHQRVWPRCHELWLXYH]LVDaLQMHQLFDPDMHGQDNR
NDR L X YH]L SUDYQLK SLWDQMD 6XG SULSLVXMH YDCQRVW QSU
SULURGLaLQMHQLFDNRMHWUHEDXVWDQRYLWLEURMXRSWXCHQLKOLFD
LVYHGRNDHOHPHQWXLQRVWUDQRVWL YH]L VOXaDMD VRVWDOLP
VOXaDMHYLPD NDR L LQWHUYHQFLML GUXJLK OLFD X SURVWXSNX
6OXaDM NRML MH YHRPD VORCHQ PRCH SRQHNDG RSUDYGDWL
GXJRWUDMDQ SRVWXSDN 1D SULPHU X VOXaDMX %RGGDHUW SURWLY
9LGL QSU%XFKKRO]SURWLY65 1HPDaNH PDMVWDY
9LGL.DWWH.OLWVFKHGHOD*UDQJHSURWLY,WDOLMHRNWREDUVWDY
JGH SUHGPHW LPD YDCQH SRVOHGLFH SR GRPD`X VXGVNX SUDNVX L
HNROR^NH ]DNRQH
7ULJJLDQLSURWLY ,WDOLMH IHEUXDU VWDY
$QJHOXFFLSURWLY,WDOLMHIHEUXDUVWDYL$QGUHXFFLSURWLY
,WDOLMH IHEUXDUVWDY
9LGL QSU0DQ]RQL SURWLY ,WDOLMHIHEUXDUVWDY
'LDQDSURWLY ,WDOLMH IHEUXDU VWDY
0DQLHUL SURWLY ,WDOLMH IHEUXDUVWDY
%HOJLMH^HVWJRGLQDLWULPHVHFDQLVXVPDWUDQLQHUD]XPQLP
]DWR ^WR VH RYDM VOXaDM RGQRVL QD YUOR WH^NX LVWUDJX XELVWYD L
SDUDOHOQR RGYLMDQMH GYD SRVWXSND 0H_XWLP aDN L X YUOR
VORCHQLPVOXaDMHYLPDPRCHGR`LGRQHRSUDYGDQRJRGODJDQMD
8 VOXaDMX )HUDQWHOOL L 6DQWDQJHOR SURWLY ,WDOLMH 6XG MH
VPDWUDR GD ^HVQDHVW JRGLQD SUHGVWDYOMD QHUD]XPDQ URN X
VOXaDMX YUOR VORCHQRJ L WH^NRJ VX_HQMH R XELVWYX NRMH MH
XNOMXaLYDORRVHWOMLYHSUREOHPHMHUVHUDGLORRPDOROHWQLFLPD
3RQD^DQMH SRGQRVLRFD
$NR MH SRGQRVLODF X]URN ND^QMHQMD RYR `H VLJXUQR
RVODELWL QMHJRYX WXCEX 6XGD 0H_XWLP QH PRCH VH QD SRG
QRVLRaHYX ^WHWX X]HWL ^WR MH X SRWSXQRVWL NRULVWLROD VYH SUR
FHGXUDOQHPRJX`QRVWLNRMHVWRMHRGEUDQLQDUDVSRODJDQMX2G
SRGQRVLRFD VH QH ]DKWHYD WR DNWLYQR VDUD_XMH X XEU]DYDQMX
SRVWXSND NRML EL PRJDR GRYHVWL GR QMHJRYHQMHQH RVXGH
8NROLNR SRGQRVLODF QDVWRML GD XEU]D SRVWXSDN WR `H VHX]HWL
X QMHJRYX NRULVW DOL XODJDQMH ]DKWHYD GD VH SRVWXSDN XEU]D
QH PRUD GDEXGH ELWQR
6XGMHXVOXaDMX8QLRQ$OLPHQWDULD6DQGHUV6$SURWLY
>SDQLMH L]MDYLR GD MH GXCQRVW SRGQRVLRFD VDPR GD SRNDCH
UHYQRVWXSUHGX]LPDQMXNRUDNDNRMLVX]DQMHJDUHOHYDQWQLGDVH
X]GUCL RG WDNWLNH RGODJDQMD L GD LVNRULVWL RQR ^WR MH X GRPHQX
GRPD`HJSUDYDGR]YROMHQRXVPLVOXVNUD`LYDQMDSRVWXSNDo
3RQD^DQMH YODVWL
.DGVHRGUH_XMHGDOLMHSR^WRYDQDJDUDQWLMDUD]XPQRJ
URNDX]LPDMXVHVDPRND^QMHQMDNRMDVHPRJXSULSLVDWLGUCDYL
'UCDYD MH RGJRYRUQD ]D VYD ND^QMHQMD NRMD VX SURX]URNRYDOL
XSUDYQL LOL VXGVNL RUJDQL YODVWL
8UD]PDWUDQMXGXCLQHSRVWXSND6XGMHYRGLRUDaXQDR
SULQFLSX LVSUDYQRJ GRQR^HQMD VXGVNLK RGOXND WM GD OL VX
GRPD`L VXGRYL UH^DYDOL GRVWDYOMHQH SUHGPHWH X VNODGX VD
VYRMLP REDYH]DPD 2GOXNH NRMH VH RGQRVH QD RGODJDQMH
]ERJSRVHEQLKUD]ORJDLOLSULNXSOMDQMDGRND]DPRJXVWRJDELWL
RG QHNH YDCQRVWL 8 VOXaDMX(ZLQJ SURWLY 8MHGLQMHQRJ .UD
OMHYVWYDVSDMDQMHWULVOXaDMDNRMHMHSURGXCLORVX_HQMHQLMH
LQFKRSURWLY3RUWXJDOLMHMXOL%XFKKRO]SURWLY651HPDaNH
PDM
=LPPHUPDQ L 6WHLQHUSURWLY>YDMFDUVNH MXO VWDY
,QWHUHV SRGQRVLRFD
^WD SRGQRVLODF PRCH GD GRELMHL]JXEL
=ERJ WRJD ^WR VH LQWHUHV SRGQRVLRFD X]LPD X RE]LU
SULOLNRP RFHQMLYDQMD GD OL MH JDUDQWLMD UD]XPQRJ URND ]DGR
YROMHQD RaHNXMH VH GD VH NULYLaQL SRVWXSFL XRS^WH UH^DYDMX
EUCH RG JUD_DQVNLK SRJRWRYR NDGD MH RNULYOMHQD RVRED X
SULWYRUX SUH VX_HQMD =DKWHY ]D UD]XPQLP URNRP SR aODQX
XVNR MH SRYH]DQ VD ]DKWHYRP UD]XPQRJ URND SR aODQX VW
6XG MH REMDVQLR GD `H XNROLNR GR_H GR QHSRWUHEQRJ
SURGXCHQMD VXGVNRJ SRVWXSND SULWYRU SUH VX_HQMD ELWL QH]D
NRQLW 1DLPH QH PRCH VH VPDWUDWL GD MH SULWYRU X VNODGX VD
aODQRPVWDNRYUHPHQMHJRYRJWUDMDQMDQLMHYL^HUD]XP
9LGLQSU0LODVLSURWLY,WDOLMHMXQVWDYL8QLRQ$OLPHQ
AODQ VW X UHOHYDQWQLP GHORYLPD SURSLVXMH GD 6YDNR NR MH
XKDS^HQLOLOL^HQVORERGHVKRGQRRGUHGEDPDVWDYDFRYRJaODQDEL`H
EH] RGODJDQMD L]YHGHQ SUHG VXGLMX LOL GUXJR VOXCEHQR OLFH ]DNRQRP
RGUH_HQR GD REDYOMD VXGVNH IXQNFLMH L LPD`H SUDYR GD PX VH VXGL X
UD]XPQRP URNX LOLGDEXGH SX^WHQQDVORERGXGRVX_HQMDo
1H]DYLVQRVW
2ELaQRVHVPDWUDGDVXVXGRYLQH]DYLVQLLRGGRPD`LK
VXGLMD VH UHWNR ]DKWHYDGD RGOXaXMXGDOLMHQHNLVXGQH]DYL
VDQL]X]HYXVLWXDFLMDPDNDGDVHRGQMLKWUDCLGDUD]PDWUDMX
RGOXNHYDQVXGVNLKWHOD.DGDWHODNRMDQLVXVXGRYLYU^HIXQN
FLMH NRMH VX RGOXaXMX`H ]D SLWDQMD OMXGVNLK SUDYD LOL RSWXCEL
]D NULYLaQD GHOD RQGD WD WHOD PRUDMX SR^WRYDWL ]DKWHYH ]D
QH]DYLVQR^`X L QHSULVWUDVQRVWL
.DGDRGOXaXMHGDOLMHQHNLVXGQH]DYLVDQ(YURSVNLVXG
X]LPD X UD]PDWUDQMH VOHGH`H
QDaLQ SRVWDYOMDQMD QMHJRYLK aODQRYD
WUDMDQMHPDQGDWD
SRVWRMDQMH JDUDQWLMD SURWLY VSROMQRJ SULWLVNDL
SLWDQMHGD OLWR WHOR RGDMH XWLVDNQH]DYLVQRVWL
9LGL QSU &DPSEHOO L )HOO SURWLY 8MHGLQMHQRJ .UDOMHYVWYD MXQ
VWDY
6XGX6WUD]EXUXVPDWUDGDVXGPRUDELWLQH]DYLVDQLRG
L]YU^QH YODVWL L RG VXSURWVWDYOMHQLK VWUDQD
6DVWDY L SRVWDYOMHQMH
6XG PRUDGDLPDSUDYRGDGRQRVLREDYH]XMX`HRGOXNH
NRMHQHPRCHPHQMDWLYDQVXGVNDYODVW6PDWUDVHGDYRMQL
VXGRYL L GUXJD YRMQD GLVFLSOLQVND WHOD PRJX GD EXGX X WRP
&DPSEHOOL)HOOSURWLY8MHGLQMHQRJ.UDOMHYVWYD MXQVWDY
%HOLORV SURWLY>YDMFDUVNH DSULOVWDYRYL r
9LGLQSU)LQGOD\SURWLY8MHGLQMHQRJ.UDOMHYVWYDIHEUXDUVWDY
1HSULVWUDVQRVW
8 VOXaDMX3LHUVDFN SURWLY %HOJLMH6XG MH ]DNOMXaLRGD
GRNQHSULVWUDVQRVWRELaQR]QDaLRGVXVWYRSUHGUDVXGD
LOLQDNORQRVWLQMHQRSRVWRMDQMHSUHPDaODQXVW.RQYHQ
FLMH PRCH VH LVSLWDWL QD UD]OLaLWH QDaLQH 8 WRP NRQWHNVWX
PRCHVH QDSUDYLWL UD]OLNDL]PH_XVXEMHNWLYQRJSULVWXSD NR
MLP VH RGUH_XMH OLaQR XYHUHQMH RGUH_HQRJ VXGLMH X GDWRP
VOXaDMX L REMHNWLYQRJ SULVWXSD NRML XWYU_XMH GD OL MH RQ
SRQXGLR JDUDQWLMH GRYROMQH GD VH LVNOMXaL VYDND OHJLWLPQD
VXPQMDXWRPSRJOHGX
'DELVHGRND]DODVXEMHNWLYQDQHSULVWUDQRVW6XG]DK
WHYD GRND]H NRQNUHWQH SULVWUDVQRVWL /LaQD QHSULVWUDVQRVW UH
GRYQR SRVWDYOMHQRJ VXGLMH VH SUHWSRVWDYOMD VYH GRN VH QH
GRNDCHVXSURWQR2YRMHYUORELWQDSUHWSRVWDYNDLXSUDNVL
MHYUORWH^NRGRND]DWLOLaQXSULVWUDVQRVW1LMHGDQWDNDY]DKWHY
QLMH QLNDGD ELR XVSH^DQ SUHG 6XGRP X 6WUD]EXUX EH]RE]LUD
QD aHVWHCDOEH
.DGD MH UHa R REMHNWLYQRP SULVWXSX 6XG MH X VOXaDMX
)H\ SURWLY $XVWULMHL]MDYLR GD
X RNYLUX REMHNWLYQRJ SULVWXSD PRUD VH RGUHGLWL GD OL
MH SRWSXQR RGYRMHQR RG OLaRJ SRQD^DQMD VXGLMH ELOR GRND
&DPSEHOO L)HOO MXQ VWDY
3LHUVDFNSURWLY %HOJLMH RNWREDU VWDY
+DXVFKLOGW SURWLY'DQVNHPDM VWDY
]LYLKaLQMHQLFDNRMHPRJXGRYHVWLGRVXPQMHXQMHJRYXQHS
ULVWUDVQRVW8RYRPSRJOHGXaDNLXWLVDNPRCHLPDWLL]YHVQX
YDCQRVW 2QR ^WR MH RYGH YDCQR MHVWH SRYHUHQMH NRMH VXGRYL
XGHPRNUDWVNRPGUX^WYXPRUDMXXOLYDWLMDYQRVWLLQDMYL^HRG
VYHJD NDGD VX X SLWDQMX NULYLaQL SRVWXSFL NRMH XOLYDMX VD
PRPRNULYOMHQRP2YRSRGUD]XPHYDGDNRGRGOXaLYDQMDGD
OL X QHNRP NRQNUHWQRP VOXaDMX SRVWRML RSUDYGDQ UD]ORJ ]D
VWUDK GD RGUH_HQL VXGLMD QLMHQHSULVWUDVDQ VWDY RNULYOMHQRJ
MH YDCDQ DOL QH L RGOXaXMX`L 2GOXaXMX`H MH GD OL VH WDNDY
VWUDKPRCHVPDWUDWDLREMHNWYQRRSUDYGDQLP
6XG MH VDVYLP MDVQR VWDYLR GR ]QDQMD GD VH VYDNL
VXGLMD]DNRMHJSRVWRMLRSUDYGDQUD]ORJ]DVXPQMXGDQLMH
QHSULVWUDVDQ PRUD SRYX`L
3RVWRMDQMH GRPD`LK SURFHGXUD NRMLPD VH REH]EH_XMH
QHSULVWUDVQRVW MH WDNR_H UHOHYDQWQR ,DNR .RQYHQFLMD QH SUR
SLVXMH L]ULaLWR GD PRUDMX SRVWRMDWL PHKDQL]PL SRPR`X NRMLK
VWUDQH X SRVWXSNX PRJX SRVWDYOMDWL SLWDQMH QHSULVWUDVQRVWL
YHURYDWQRMHGD`HVHUH`LGDSRVWRMLNU^HQMHaODQDDNRWDNYL
PHKDQL]PLQHSRVWRMH$NRRSWXCHQLSRVWDYLSLWDQMHQHSUL
VWUDVQRVWL RQGD VH RQR PRUD LVSLWDWL L]X]HY DNR QLMH
RaLJOHGQR EH]LNDNYH RVQRYHo
2YR SLWDQMH VH QDMaH^`H SRVWDYOMDOR SUHG VXGRYLPD X
6WUD]EXUX X NRQWHNVWX UDVL]PD 2ED RYD SULQFLSD L]QHWD X
VOXaDMHYLPDXGDOMHPWHNVWXMHGQDNRVHSULPHQMXMXLQDRVWDOH
YUVWH SUHGUDVXGD LOL QHSULVWUDVQRVWL
8 VOXaDMX 5HPOL SURWLY )UDQFXVNH WUH`D VWUDQD MH
aXODMHGQRJRGSRURWQLNDNDNRNDCH>WDYL^HMDVDPUDVLVWDo
'RPD`LVXGMHRGOXaLRGDQHPRCHIRUPDOQRX]LPDWLXRE]LU
GRJD_DMH NRML VX VH QDYRGQR GRJRGLOL EH] QMHJRYRJSULVX
VWYDo (YURSVNL VXG MH SULPHWLRGD GRPD`L VXGQLMHQL^WDXUDGLR
GDELSURYHULRQHSULVWUDVQRVWLWLPHMHOL^LRSRGQRVLRFDSUHGVWDYNH
PRJX`QRVWL GD LVSUDYL VLWXDFLMX NRMD MH ELOD X VXSURWQRVWL VD
]DKWHYLPDL].RQYHQFLMH6XGMHVWRJDQD^DRNU^HQMHaODQD
.DGDMHGRPD`LVXGRaLJOHGQRVSURYHRVWYDUQXLVWUD
JX QDYRGD R SULVWUDVQRVWL L ]DNOMXaLR GD MH VSRUQR VX_HQMH
ELOR SUDYLaQR (YURSVNL VXG `H QHUDGR GRYRGLWL X SLWDQMH
QMHJRY]DNOMXaDN8VOXaDMX*UHJRU\SURWLY8MHGLQMHQRJ.UD
OMHYVWYD VXGLMLMHGRVWDYOMHQDSLVPHQDSRUXNDRGSRURWHX
NRMRM MH SLVDOR 3RURWD SRND]XMH ]QDNH UDVQH QHWUSHOMLYRVWL
3UYL aODQ EL WUHEDR ELWL LVNOMXaHQo 6XGLMD MH RYX SRUXNX
SRND]DR WXCLRFX L RGEUDQL 7DNR_H RSRPHQXR MH SRURWX GD
VXGLRVOXaDMXQDRVQRYXGRND]DLGDLVNOMXaLVYDNXSUHGUDVX
GX 6XG X 6WUD]EXUX MH VPDWUDR GD MH RYR GRYROMQR X VPLVOX
aODQD6PDWUDRMHELWQLP^WRDGYRNDWRGEUDQHQLMH]DKWHYDR
UDVSX^WDQMH SRURWH QLWL MH RG QMLK WUDCLR GD VH L]MDVQH MDYQR
SUHG VXGRP GD OL PRJX GD QDVWDYH L GRQHVX SUHVXGX ]DVQR
YDQX VDPR QD GRND]LPD 6XGLMD NRML MH VXGLR GDR MH VDVYLP
MDVQX GHWDOMQX L REDYH]XMX`X L]MDYX NRMRP QDODCH SRURWL GD
L]JODYDL]EDFHELORNDNYHSULPLVOLLOLSUHGUDVXGHRYHLOLRQH
YUVWHo 6XG MH QD^DR VOHGH`H X SRUH_HQMX VD VOXaDMHP5HPOL
SURWLY )UDQFXVNH
8 RYRP VOXaDMX VXGLMH VX SURSXVWLOH GD UHDJXMX QD
RSWXCEX GD MH QHNR aXR GD QHLGHQWLILNRYDQL SRURWQLN L]MDY
OMXMHGDMHUDVLVWD8NRQNUHWQRPVOXaDMXVXGLMDMHELRVXRaHQ
VDQDYRGLPDRUDVLVWLaNLPSUHGUDVXGDPDSRURWH]DNRMHVH
LDNRVXELOHQHMDVQHLQHSUHFL]QHQLMHPRJORUH`LGDVXEH]
RVQRYD8GDWLPRNROQRVWLPDRQMHSUHGX]HRGRYROMQHNRUD
*UHJRU\ SURWLY 8MHGLQMHQRJ.UDOMHYVWYDIHEUXDU
9H`LQDVOXaDMHYDL]VXGVNHSUDNVHXYH]LVDQHSULVWUDVQR^`X
RGQRVLVHQDVLWXDFLMHNDGDVXGLMDLPDUD]OLaLWHSURFHGXUDOQHXORJH
XWRNXSRVWXSND8VOXaDMX3LHUVDFNSURWLY%HOJLMHVXGLMDNRML
MH VXGLR X SRVWXSNX SURWLY SRGQRVLRFD SUHGVWDYNH ELR MH SUH
WRJDaODQRGVHNDNRMLMHYU^LRLVWUDJXPVOXaDMXLSRGQHRWXCEX
SURWLY QMHJD 6XG MH QD^DR GD VH UDGL R NU^HQMX aODQD
8VOXaDMX+DXVFKLOGWSURWLY'DQVNH6XGMHXVWDQRYLR
NU^HQMHNDGDMHSUHGVHGDYDMX`LVXGLMDRGOXaLYDRRSULWYRUXSUH
VX_HQMD2YRMHLPDORLSRVHEQXNDUDNWHULVWLNXGDVHRQGHYHW
SXWD RGOXaXMX`L R SURGXCHWNX SULWYRUD SR]YDR QDL]X]HWQR
MDNX VXPQMXo X NULYLFX SRGQRVLRFD 6XG MH VPDWUDR GD MH
UD]OLND L]PH_X RYDNYRJ L UH^DYDQMD WRJ SLWDQMD QD VX_HQMX
EH]QDaDMQDLGDMHVWUDKSRGQRVLRFDSUHGVWDYNHELRREMHNWLYQR
RSUDYGDQ
-R^MHGDQSULPHUSUHGVWDYOMDVOXaDM)HUUDQWHOOLL6DQWDQ
JHOR SURWLY ,WDOLMH X NRMHP MH 6XG VPDWUDR GD VH UDGL R
NU^HQMX aODQD NDGD MH SUHGVHGDYDMX`L VXGLMD X CDOEHQRP
VXGX RGOXaLYDR R UDQLMRM SUHVXGL VDXaHVQLND 2YD SUHVXGD VH
QDPQRJRPHVWDSR]LYDODQDSRGQRVLRFHSUHGVWDYNHLQMLKRYR
XaH^`HXRYRPVOXaDMX1DGDOMHSUHVXGDCDOEHQRJVXGDNRMRP
VHSRGQRVLRFLRVX_XMXQDYRGLEURMQHL]YRGHL]UDQLMLKSUHVXGD
SURWLYVDXaHVQLNDSRGQRVLRFD6XGX6WD]EXUXQD^DRMHGDVX
RYH RNROQRVWL SRGUCDOH VXPQMX SRGQRVLRFD X QHSULVWUDVQRVW
CDOEHQRJ VXGD
6OXaDM2EHUVFKOLFNEUSURWLY$XVWULMHRGQRVLVHQD
SRVWXSDNSUHGCDOEHQLPVXGRPXNRMHPVXXaHVWYRYDOLWURMLFD
VXGLMD NRML VX WDNR_H UDQLMH ELOL XNOMXaHQL X RGOXNX SUYRVWH
SHQRJ VXGD (YURSVNL VXG MH VPDWUDR GD RYR SUHGVWDYOMD
NU^HQMH SUDYD QD QHSULVWUDVDQ VXG
8 VOXaDMX 'H +DDQ SURWLY +RODQGLMH VXGLMD NRML
MH SUHGVHGDYDR X CDOEHQRP VXGX PRUDR MH RGOXaLYDWL R
SUHVXGLNRMXMHVDPGRQHR(YURSVNLVXGMHVPDWUDRGDMH
RSUDYGDQ VWUDK SRGQRVLODFD X YH]L REMHNWLYQH QHSULVWUDV
QRVWL SUHGVHGDYDMX`HJ VXGLMH L XVWDQRYLR GD VH UDGL R
NU^HQMX aODQD
)HUUDQWHOOL SURWLY,WDOLMH DXJXVW
2EHUVFKOLFN EU SURWLY $XVWULMH PDM
'H +DDQSURWLY +RODQGLMH DXJXVW
8MHGQRPQHWDNRGDYQRPVOXaDMXSURWLY>YDMFDUVNH
6XG MH XVWDQRYLR NU^HQMH aODQD VW X VOXaDMX NDGD MH
SRGQRVLODF SUHGVWDYNH XaHVWYRYDR X SRVWXSNX SUHG VXGRP
NRML MH ELR VDVWDYOMHQ RG SHW VXGLMD 'YRMLFD RG QMLK VX ELOL
KRQRUDUQH VXGLMH NRMH VX SUHGVWDYOMDOH GUXJX VWUDQX X RGYR
MHQRP SRVWXSNX LVWRJ SRGQRVLRFD (YURSVNL VXG MH VPDWUDR
GD VH ]DNRQRGDYVWYR L SUDNVD XVWDQRYH KRQRUDUQLK VXGLMD
PRCH XRS^WH VPDWUDWL NRPSDWLELOQRP VD aODQRP PH_XWLP
RQR ^WR MH ELOR ELWQR MHVWH QDaLQ QD NRML VH SRVWXSDN YRGL X
WRNYRP VOXaDMX ,DNR QLMH SRVWRMDOD QLNDNYDPDWHULMDOQDYH]D
L]PH_XSRGQRVLRaHYRJVOXaDMDLRGYRMHQRJSRVWXSNDXNRMHP
VX GYD DGYRNDWD QDVWXSLOL X VYRMVWYX SUDYQLK ]DVWXSQLND UD
GLOR VH R YUHPHQVNRP SUHNODSDQMX 3RGQRVLODF MH SUHPD
WRPHLPDRUD]ORJD]D]DEULQXWRVWGD`HVXGLMDQDVWDYLWLLGDOMH
GD JD VPDWUD ]D VXSURWQX VWUDQX L RYDNYD VLWXDFLMD MH PRJOD
GRYHVWL GR RSUDYGDQRJ VWUDKRYDQMD GD VXGLMD QH SULVWXSD
VOXaDMX V GXCQRP QHSULVWUDVQR^`X
6DPD aLQMHQLFD GD MH VXGLMD SUHWKRGQR LPDR YH]H V
SRGQRVLRFHP SUHGVWDYNH QLMH VDPD SR VHEL GRYROMQD GD EL
SUHGVWDYOMDOD NU^HQMH aODQD VW 3RWUHEQH VX SRVHEQH ND
UDNWHULVWLNHSRSXWRQLKRSLVDQLKXJRUHQDYHGHQLPVOXaDMHYL
PD NRMH LGX SUHNRVXGLMLQH XSX`HQRVWL X VOXaDM
3RQRYOMHQL SUHWUHV
2GULFDQMH
6XGQLMHMDVQRRGUHGLRXNRMRMPHULVHRNULYOMHQLPRCH
RGUH`L VYRJ SUDYD QD QH]DYLVDQ L QHSULVWUDVDQ VXG (YURSVNL
VXG MH ]DNOMXaLR GD X PHUL X NRMRM MH WR RGULFDQMH PRJX`H
RQR PRUD ELWL L RJUDQLaHQR L GD PRUD SRVWRMDWL PLQLPXP
JDUDQWLMDNRMHQH]DYLVHVDPRRGVWUDQD2GULFDQMHPRUDELWL
QHRSR]LYR6WUDQHPRUDMXELWLVYHVQHVXPQMLXQHSULVWUDVQRVW
LPDWL PRJX`QRVW GD WDNYR SLWDQMH SRVWDYH L L]UD]LWL VYRMH
RGREUDYDQMH X YH]L VDVWDYD VXGD 6DPR SURSX^WDQMH GD VH
XORCLSULJRYRUQLMHGRYROMQRGDNRQVWLWXL^HRGULFDQMH6XG
MH ]DNOMXaLR X VOXaDMX 3IHLIIHU L 3ODQNL SURWLY $XVWULMH GD
SURSX^WDQMHXODJDQMDSULJRYRUDQDGYRMLFXVXGLMDNRMLVXSUHW
KRGQR ELOL LVWUDCQH VXGLMH L WLPH ELOL GLVNYDOLILNRYDQL GD
XaHVWYXMXNDRVXGLMHQLMHELRGRYROMDQNDNRELVHLVWLX]HR]D
RGULFDQMH8VOXaDMX2EHUVFKOLFNEUSURWLY$XVWULMHVXGLMD
NRMLMHSUHGVHGDYDRCDOEHQLPVXGRPXaHVWYRYDRMHXUDQLMHP
SRVWXSNX L SUHPD =DNRQX R NULYLaQRP SRVWXSNX QLMH PRJDR
ELWLXNOMXaHQXRYDMSRVWXSDN3RGQRVLODFQLMHRVSRUDYDRSUL
VXVWYRVXGLMHDOLQLMHELRXSX`HQGDVXLGUXJDGYRMLFDVXGLMD
ELODQDVOLaDQQDaLQGLNYDOLILNRYDQD(YURSVNLVXGMHQD^DRGD
VHRQ QLMH RGUHNDR VYRJ SUDYD QD QHSULVWUDVDQ VXG
8VWDQRYOMHQ ]DNRQRP
8YH]LVD]DKWHYRPGDVXGEXGHXVSRVWDYOMHQ]DNRQRP
.RPLVLMD MH XVOXaDMX=DQG SURWLY $XVWULMH]DNOMXaLODGD
&LOM L VYUKD RGUHGEH aODQX VW NRMRP VH ]DKWHYD
GDVXGRYLEXGXXVSRVWDYOMHQL]DNRQRPoMHVXGDRUJDQL]D
3IHLIIHUL3ODQNLSURWLY $XVWULMH IHEUXDU
2EHUVFKOLFN EU SURWLY $XVWULMH PDM
RVQRYDQ
'R ]DNOMXaHQMD UDGD QD RYRP SULUXaQLNX 8SUDYQL VXG X 6UELML QLMH
RVQRYDQ
6OOLVW 5&*EU
'R]DNOMXaHQMDUDGDQDRYRPSULUXaQLNX$SHODFLRQLVXGX&UQRM*RUL
WDNR_HQLMHRVQRYDQ
'R ]DNOMXaHQMD UDGD QD RYRP SULUXaQLNX 8SUDYQL VXG X &UQRM *RUL
WDNR_HQLMHRVQRYDQ
7R VX GHOD ]D NRMD VH PRCH L]UH`L ND]QD ]DWYRUD RG SHWQDHVW JRGLQD
LOL WHCDND]QD
2VLPXVSRURYLPDL]DXWRUVNRJSUDYD]D^WLWHSURQDOD]DNDLWHKQLaNLK
XQDSUH_HQMDX]RUDNDPRGHODCLJRYDLOLJHRJUDIVNLKR]QDNDSRUHNOD
=DNRQD R VXGLMDPD 56 aO VW 8VWDYD &UQH *RUH L
aO VW =DNRQ RVXGRYLPD 5&*
=DNRQL R VXGRYLPD UHSXEOLND SURNODPXMX QH]DYLVQRVW
VXGVNH YODVWL aO =DNRQD R XUH_HQMX VXGRYD 56 aO
=DNRQD RVXGRYLPD 5&*
2YLP ]DNRQLPD MH WDNR_H ]DEUDQMHQ XWLFDM QD VXG aO
=DNRQD R XUH_HQMX VXGRYD 56 aO VW =DNRQD R VXGR
YLPD 5&*
,]ERU VXGLMD
YU^HQMHVXGLMVNHIXQNFLMHNDGDWUDMQRL]JXELUDGQXVSRVREQRVW
]DYU^HQMHVYRMHIXQNFLMHLOLNDGDMHQHVWUXaQRLQHVDYHVQRREDYOMD
aOVW8VWDYD6UELMHaOVW8VWDYD&UQH*RUH
6USVNL=DNRQRVXGLMDPDSRQDYOMDRVQRYH]DSUHVWDQDN
VXGLMVNH IXQNFLMH SUHFL]LUDMX`L GD VXGLML SUHVWDMH UDGQL YHN
NDGQDYU^LJRGLQDCLYRWDLOLJRGLQDVWDCDaOVW
2YDM ]DNRQ WDNR_H RGUH_XMH GD VXGLMD QHVDYHVQR YU^L VYRMX
GXCQRVW DNR RGXJRYODaL UH^DYDQMH SUHGPHWD ]DQHPDUXMH UR
NRYH X SRVWXSNX LOL L]UDGL RGOXND LOL QD GUXJL QDaLQ SRVWXSD
SURWLYQR PHULOLPD NRMH RGUHGL9UKRYQL VXG 6UELMH LOL QDVWDYL
VDDNWLYQRVWLPDNRMHVXQHVSRMLYHVDQMHJRYRPIXQNFLMRPaO
VW L 1HVWUXaQLP VH VPDWUD QHGRYROMQR XVSH^QR
YU^HQMHVXGLMVNHGXCQRVWLSUHPDPHULOX9UKRYQRJVXGD6UEL
MHaOVW9HOLNRSHUVRQDOQRYH`HNRMHVHXVWDQRY
OMDYD X 9UKRYQRP VXGX 6UELMH XWYU_XMH QDYU^HQMH UDGQRJ
YHND VXGLMH L XWYU_XMH UD]ORJH ]D UD]UH^HQMH aO VW
3RVWXSDN ]D UD]UH^HQMH SRNUH`X SUHGVHGQLN VXGD SUHGVHGQLN
QHSRVUHGQR YL^HJ VXGD L SUHGVHGQLN 9UKRYQRJ VXGD 6UELMH
RGQ 9HOLNR SHUVRQDOQR YH`H DNR MH X SLWDQMX SUHGVHGQLN
9UKRYQRJ VXGD 6UELMH aO VW L $NR X URNX RG
GDQD RG SRNUHWDQMD SRVWXSND 9HOLNR SHUVRQDOQR YH`H QH RG
OXaL R UD]ORJX ]D UD]UH^HQMH RGOXNX GRQRVL 2S^WD VHGQLFD
9UKRYQRJ VXGD X QDUHGQRP URNX RG GDQD aO VW
8 WRP VOXaDMX aODQRYLPD 9HOLNRJ SHUVRQDOQRJ YH`D SUHVWDMH
PDQGDW aO VW 2GPDK SR SULMHPX RGOXNH 9HOLNRJ
SHUVRQDOQRJ YH`D SUHGVHGQLN 9UKRYQRJ VXGD 6UELMH RED
YH^WDYD 1DURGQX VNXS^WLQX NRMD UD]UH^DYD VXGLMX aO VW
L VW
2YDPHULODNRMDMHUDQLMHL]GDYDRPLQLVWDUSUDYGHDVDGDEL9UKRYQL
VXGWUHEDORGDVDaLQLQRYDSUHPDQRYRMVLVWHPDWL]DFLMLVXGRYDVDGUCH
RULMHQWDFLRQX QRUPXSUHPDNRMRM VHSURFHQMXMH HILNDVQRVW L VWUXaQRVW
VXGLMD
3UHPDFUQRJRUVNRP=DNRQXRVXGRYLPDVXGLMLSUHVWDMH
VXGLMVND IXQNFLMD RGQ UD]UH^DYD VH GXCQRVWL NDGD 8VWDY WR
SUHGYL_D aO VW L VW 2EUD]ORCHQX LQLFLMDWLYX ]D
UD]UH^HQMH SRGQRVL SUHGVHGQLN VXGD SUHGVHGQLN QHSRVUHGQR
YL^HJ VXGD SUHGVHGQLN 9UKRYQRJ VXGD 6UELMH QDMPDQMH WUL
aODQD6XGVNRJVDYMHWD'LVFLSOLQVNRYLMH`HLPLQLVWDUSUDY
GH aO VW $NR XWYUGL GD LPD RVQRYD ]D YR_HQMH
SRVWXSND ]D UD]UH^HQMH 6DYMHW L] UHGRYD VYRMLK aODQRYD IRU
PLUD NRPLVLMX ]D LVSLWLYDQMH XVORYD ]D UD]UH^HQMH aO VW
2VYRPUDGXNRPLVLMDXURNXRGGDQDSRGQRVLL]YH^WDM
6DYMHWXaOVW3UHGORJ]DUD]UH^HQMHPRUDVHGRVWDYLWL
6NXS^WLQLXURNXRGGDQDRGSRGQR^HQMDLQLFLMDWLYH,QLFL
MDWLYD ]DVWDUHYD DNR SURWHNQX WUL JRGLQH RG GDQD QDYRGQRJ
GRJD_DMD QD NRML VH LQLFLMDWLYD SR]LYD aO
8VWDYQD SRYHOMD SUHGYL_DGDVXGLMH6XGD6UELMHL&UQH
*RUH QH PRJX ELWL UD]UH^HQL SUH LVWHND YUHPHQD QD NRMH VX
ELUDQLRVLPXVOXaDMHYLPDRGUH_HQLP]DNRQRPaOVW
'R]DNOMXaHQMDUDGDQDRYRPSULUXaQLNX]DNRQR6XGX6UELMH
L &UQH *RUH QLMH GRQHW LDNR =DNRQ R VSURYR_HQMX 8VWDYQH
SRYHOMH SUHGYL_D GD `H RQ ELWL GRQHW X URNX RG GDQD RG
L]ERUD SUHGVHGQLND GUCDYQH ]DMHGQLFH NRML MH L]DEUDQ MR^
PDUWD
2VWDOH JDUDQWLMH QHSULVWUDVQRVWL L QH]DYLVQRVWL
R GLVFLSOLQVNRMRGJRYRUQRVWL VXGLMH
SUHGPHWDVXGLMLLRGJRYRUQRVWSUHGVHGQLNDVXGDDNRVH=DNRQ
X WRPVPLVOX NU^L aO r
6USVNL =DNRQ R XUH_HQMX VXGRYD VDPR SUHGYL_D GD
VXGLMD SULPD SUHGPHWH QH]DYLVQR RG OLaQRVWL VWUDQDND L RNRO
QRVWLSUDYQHVWYDUL6XGLMDGRELMDSUHGPHWHXVNODGXVD6XG
VNLP SRVORYQLNRP QD RVQRYX UHGRVOHGD XWYU_HQRJ ]D VYDNX
NDOHQGDUVNXJRGLQXLVNOMXaLYRQDRVQRYXR]QDNHLEURMDSUHG
PHWD aO VW L
6XGLMH SRURWQLFL
,]X]H`H
8NULYLaQRPLSDUQLaQRPSRVWXSNXSRVWRMHVOLaQLRVQRYL
]D L]X]H`H VXGLMH L VXGLMH SRURWQLND NRML VH XJODYQRP VYRGH
QDVXNRELQWHUHVDLOLGDVXXGRQR^HQMXRGOXNHXWRPVOXaDMX
YH` QD QHNL QDaLQ XaHVWYRYDOL YLGL EOLCH aO =.3 L aO
=33
7DNR_H VOLaQD VX SUDYLOD SRVWXSND X VOXaDMX L]X]H`D
1DLPH aLP VH VD]QD ]D UD]ORJH L]X]H`D VXGLMD LOL VXGLMD
SRURWQLN MH GXCDQ GD REXVWDYL UDG QD SUHGPHWX L REDYHVWL R
WRPH SUHGVHGQLND VXGD aO VW =.3 aO VW =33
,]X]H`H PRJX WUDCLWL VWUDQNH LOL EUDQLODF GR SRaHWNDJODYQRJ
SUHWUHVD RGQRVQR X SDUQLaQRP SRVWXSNX QDMNDVQLMH GR
]DYU^HWND UDVSUDYH RGQ GR GRQR^HQMD RGOXNH DNR UDVSUDYH
QLMH ELOR LOL aLP VD]QDMX ]D UD]ORJ L]X]H`D aO VW L
=.3 aO VW L =33 2 L]X]H`X RGOXaXMH SUHGVHGQLN
VXGD aO =.3 aO =33
=DNOMXaDN
3ULVWXS VXGX
AODQ QH VDGUCL L]ULaLWX JDUDQFLMX SUDYD QD SULVWXS
VXGXDOL(YURSVNLVXGVPDWUDGDRYDMaODQVYDNRPHRVLJXUDYD
SUDYR GD ELOR NRML SUDYQL ]DKWHY X YH]L VYRMLK JUD_DQVNLK
SUDYDLREDYH]DL]QHVHSUHGVXG3UDYRQDVXGXJUD_HQRMHX
aODQ D SUDYR SULVWXSD WM SUDYR QD SRNUHWDQMH SRVWXSND QD
VXGX X JUD_DQVNLP SLWDQMLPD SUHGVWDYOMD VDPR MHGDQ RG DV
SHNDWD
(YURSVNLVXGVPDWUDRMHXVOXaDMX*ROGHUSURWLY8MHGL
QMHQRJ .UDOMHYVWYDGD
NDGD EL VH aODQ VW VKYDWLR NDR GD VH RGQRVL
LVNOMXaLYRQDYR_HQMHSDUQLFHNRMXMHYH`VXGSRYHRGUCDYD
XJRYRUQLFD EL PRJOD EH] NU^HQMH RYRJ VWDYD GD VH UH^L
VYRMLKVXGRYDLOLLPRGX]PHMXULVGLNFLMXXRGUH_HQRMNDWHJR
ULMLJUD_DQVNLKSDUQLFDLSRYHULLKRUJDQLPDNRMLVX]DYLVQL
RGYODGH3RPL^OMHQMX6XGDELORELQHUHDOQRGDaODQVW
GHWDOMQRRSLVXMHSURFHGXUDOQHJDUDQFLMHNRMHVXQDUDVSR
ODJDQMX VWUDQDPD X VXGVNRP SRVWXSNX D QH GD SUYR ]D^WLWL
RQR ^WR ]DSUDYR RPRJX`DYD NRULVW RG WLK JDUDQFLMD WM SUL
VWXSVXGX3UDYLaQHMDYQHLHNVSHGLWLYQHNDUDNWHULVWLNHVXG
VNRJ SRVWXSND QHPDMX QLNDNYX YUHGQRVW DNR QHPD VXGVNRJ
SRVWXSND
0H_XWLPSUDYRSULVWXSDVXGXQLMHDSVROXWQRSUDYR
8 VOXaDMX*ROGHU SURWLY 8MHGLQMHQRJ .UDOMHYVWYD6XG X QDV
WDYNXNDCHGDVDPDQMHJRYDSULURGD]DKWHYDUHJXOLVDQMHNRMH
PRCHYDULUDWLSRYUHPHQXLPHVWX]DYLVQRRGSRWUHEDLUHVXUVD
]DMHGQLFHLSRMHGLQFDRGVWUDQHGUCDYHLDNRWDNYRUHJXOLVDQMH
QH VPH QLNDGD ELWLQD ^WHWX VX^WLQH RYRJ SUDYD QLWL X VXSURW
QRVWL VGUXJLP SUDYLPD SURSLVDQLP.RQYHQFLMRP
6XGMHXVYRMRMVXGVNRMSUDNVLMR^XVWDQRYLRGDMHVYDNR
RJUDQLaHQMH NRPSDWLELOQR VD aODQRP VDPR
DNR MH X FLOMX NRML MH RSUDYGDQ]DNRQRP
L
DNR SRVWRML UD]XPQR SURSRUFLRQDODQ RGQRV L]PH_X
VUHGVWDYD NRMD VX NRUL^`HQD L FLOMD NRML VH CHOL SRV
WL`L
8 VOXaDMX *ROGHU SURWLY 8MHGLQMHQRJ .UDOMHYVWYD UDGL
VH R ]DWYRUHQLNX NRPH QLMH GDWD GR]YROD GD NRQWDNWLUD VYRJ
DGYRNDWDNDNRELSRGQHRWXCEX]ERJNOHYHWHSURWLYMHGQRJRG
OLFD]DSRVOHQRJX]DWYRUX6XGMHVPDWUDRGDRYRSUHGVWDYOMD
NU^HQMH aODQD r SUDYR QD SULVWXS VXGX PRUD QH VDPR
SRVWRMDWLQHJRPRUDELWLLGHORWYRUQR6XGMHWDNR_HVPDWUDR
*ROGHUSURWLY 8MHGLQMHQRJ .UDOMHYVWYD IHEUXDU VWDY
$VKLQJGDQH SURWLY8MHGLQMHQRJ .UDOMHYVWYD PDMVWDY
r
0 SURWLY8MHGLQMHQRJ.UDOMHYVWYD '5
&DQHD NDWROLaNDFUNYDSURWLY *UaNHGHFHPEDU
3KLOLVSURWLY*UaNH DXJXVW
6XGMHVPDWUDRGDSRGQRVLODFXRYRPVOXaDMXQLMHLPDOD
GHORWYRUQR SUDYR QD SULVWXS 9LVRNRP VXGX NDNR EL ]DWUDCLOD
VXGVNR UH^HQMH R RGYDMDQMX RG VXSUXJD
3UDYR SULVWXSD VXGX PRCH SRQHNDG ELWL SUHNU^HQR DNR
SRVWRMLLPXQLWHWNRMLVSUHaDYDSRNUHWDQMHSRVWXSND8VOXaDMX
2VPDQ SURWLY 8MHGLQMHQRJ .UDOMHYVWYD NRML VH RGQRVL QD
SROLWLNX MDYQRJ LPXQLWHWD X VOXaDMX WXCEH ]ERJ QHKDWD SURWLY
SROLFLMH NRMD MH GHORYDOD X FLOMX LVWUDJH LOL SUHYHQFLMH 6XG MH
VPDWUDR GD VH FLOM SUDYLOD R L]X]H`X PRCH SULKYDWLWL NDR
OHJLWLPDQ]DWR^WRMHELRXVPHUHQNDRGUCDYDQMXGHORWYRUQRVWL
SROLFLMH X VSUHaDYDQMX QHUHGD L ]ORaLQD 1R LSDN SULPHQD
RYRJ SUDYLODEH]GDOMHJSUHLVSLWLYDQMD^WDMHELRMDYQLLQWHUHV
RPRJX`LOR MH GD VH SROLFLML GD QHRJUDQLaHQ LPXQLWHW ]D SRV
WXSNHLSURSXVWHSULOLNRPLVWUDJHLVX]ELMDQMDNULPLQDOD^WRMH
GRYHOR GR QHRSUDYGDQRJ RJUDQLaHQMD SUDYD SRMHGLQFD GD PRCH
]DKWHYDWLGDVHRGOXaXMHRPHULWXPXWXCEHXVOXaDMHYLPDNRML
WR ]DVOXCXMX (YURSVNL VXG MH VWRJD QD^DR NU^HQMH aODQD
0H_XWLP X VOXaDMX $VKLQJGDQH SURWLY 8MHGLQMHQRJ
.UDOMHYVWYD NRML VH RGQRVL QD LPXQLWHW JDUDQWRYDQ ]DNR
QRP NRMLP VH ]DEUDQMXMH PHQWDOQR REROHOLP SDFLMHQWLPD SR
NUHWDQMH JUD_DQVNH SDUQLFH SURWLY ]GUDYVWYHQLK UDGQLND LOL
RUJDQDYODVWLEH]SUDYDCDOEH]ERJQHSR^WHQMDLOLQHDGHNYDWQH
$LUH\ SURWLY,UVNH RNWREDU VWDY
2VPDQSURWLY 8MHGLQMHQRJ .UDOMHYVWYD RNWREDU
$VKLQJGDQH SURWLY8MHGLQMHQRJ .UDOMHYVWYD PDM
EULJH6XGMH]DNOMXaLRGDQDPHWQXWHUHVWULNFLMHXRYRP VOXaDMX
NRMH VX RJUDQLaDYDOH VYDNX RGJRYRUQRVW QDGOHCQLK RUJDQD
QLVXELOHQD^WHWXVDPHVX^WLQHSUDYDSRGQRVLRFDQDVXGQLWL
VX SUHNRUDaLOH SULQFLS SURSRUFLRQDOQRVWL 6XG MH QDGDOMH QD^DR
GD MH SRGQRVLODF PRJDR SRYHVWLSRVWXSDN ]ERJ QHKDWD
(YURSVNL VXG `H WDNR_H QD`L NU^HQMH SUDYD QD SULVWXS
VXGX NDGD GRPD`L VXG QHPDSXQX MXULVGLNFLMX QDG aLQMHQL
FDPD L SUDYQLP SLWDQMLPD SUHGPHWD X NRMHP VXGL 3ULOLNRP
RFHQMLYDQMD GD OL VH UDGLOR R NU^HQMX 6XG X]LPD X RE]LU
SULURGX VSRUD GD OL VXG PRCH aDN L VD RJUDQLaHQRP QDG
OHCQR^`X QD RGJRYDUDMX`L QDaLQ SUHLVSLWDWL VSRUQD SLWDQMD
QDaLQQDNRMLVHGR^ORGRNRQNUHWQHRGOXNHNDRLVDPVDGUCDM
VSRUDXNOMXaXMX`LCHOMHQH L VWYDUQH RVQRYH ]D SRNUHWDQMHSR
VWXSND RGQRVQR CDOEH
8 VOXaDMX %U\DQ SURWLY 8MHGLQMHQRJ .UDOMHYVWYD UD
GLORVHRL]YU^HQMXRGOXNHXVOXaDMXQHSR^WRYDQMDXUEDQLVWLaNH
GR]YROH(YURSVNLVXGMH]DNOMXaLRGDLDNRMHCDOED9LVRNRP
VXGX ELOD VYHGHQD QD SLWDQMD SULPHQH PDWHULMDOQRJ SUDYD WH
MH SUHPD WRPH QMHJRYD MXULVGLNFLMD QDG aLQMHQLFDPD ELOD
RJUDQLaHQD RYR LSDN QLMH ELOR GRYROMQR GD VH X]PH NDR
NU^HQMH aODQD 6XG MH LVWDNDR SRVHEDQ NDUDNWHU XUEDQLVWLaNRJ
SODQLUDQMD^WRVHVPDWUDORWLSLaQLPSULPHURPGLVNUHFLRQHRGOXNH
QDGOHCQLK YODVWL X UHJXOLVDQMX SRQD^DQMD JUD_DQD =DNOMXaHQR MH
VWRJDGDMHGHORNUXJSUHLVSLWLYDQMDSUHG9LVRNLPVXGRPGRYROMDQ
0H_XWLP X VOXaDMX 9DVLOHVFX SURWLY 5XPXQLMH 6XG
MHXVWDQRYLRGDVHUDGLRNU^HQMXaODQDNDGDGRPD`LVXGRYL
QLVXLPDOLMXULVGLNFLMXGDLVSLWXMX]DKWHY]DUHVWLWXFLMXLPRYL
QHNRMDMHELODNRQILVNRYDQDXNRPXQLVWLaNRPUHCLPX6XGMH
SULKYDWLR WXPDaHQMH GRPD`HJ SURFHGXUDOQRJ SUDYD NRMH MH
SRQXGLR 9UKRYQL VXG 5XPXQLMH NRML MH SUHVXGLR GD ]DSUDYR
%U\DQ SURWLY8MHGLQMHQRJ.UDOMHYVWYD QRYHPEDU VWDY
9DVLOHVFXSURWLY 5XPXQLMH PDM
3ULVXVWYRYDQMH X SRVWXSNX
(YURSVNLVXGVPDWUDGDRNULYOMHQLXNULYLaQRPSRVWXS
NXPRUDSULVXVWYRYDWLVX_HQMX6YUKDLFLOMaODQDVWL
FH SUHWSRVWDYOMDMX SULVXVWYR RNULYOMHQRJ
(NEDWDQLSURWLY >YHGVNH PDMVWDY
VLRFLQLVXELOLXVWDQMXGDSULVXVWYXMXSRVOH^WUDMNDJOD_X.RPLVLMDMH
PH_XWLP QDJODVLOD GD VX ELOL SULVXWQLDGYRNDWLSRGQRVLRFD
3RLWULPRO SURWLY )UDQFXVNHQRYHPEDU
9LGLQSU3HOODGRDKSURWLY+RODQGLMHVHSWHPEDUJGHMH6XG
QD^DR NU^HQMHaODQD VW LaODQD VW F
)& %SURWLY,WDOLMH DXJXVW
XRVLJXUDYDQMXSUDYDRGEUDQHELODGHORWYRUQDDNRVHVX_HQMH
QDVWDYLOR EH] GDOMLK NRUDND NRML EL UD]MDVQLOL QMHJRY SRORCDM
3UDYR OLFD GD EXGH SULVXWQR X CDOEHQRP SRVWXSNX
]DYLVL RG SULURGH L GHORNUXJD UDVSUDYH (YURSVNL VXG VPDWUD
GD QLMH WROLNR ELWQR SULVXVWYR RNULYOMHQRJ QD UDVSUDYL NROLNR
MHELWQRSULVXVWYRQDVX_HQMX$NRCDOEHQLVXGVDPRUD]PDWUD
SLWDQMD PDWHULMDOQRJ SUDYD UDVSUDYD X SULVXVWYX RNULYOMHQRJ
QLMHQXCQD6LWXDFLMDMHPH_XWLPGUXJDaLMDDNRVHCDOEHQLVXG
EDYLLUD]PDWUDQMHPaLQMHQLFD6XG`HX]HWLXUD]PDWUDQMHNRG
RGOXaLYDQMD GD OL RNULYOMHQL LPD SUDYR SULVXVWYD NDNDY MH
QMHJRYQMHQ LQWHUHV L SRWUHEX CDOEHQRJ VXGD ]D SULVXVWYRP
RNULYOMHQRJ UDGL XWYU_LYDQMD aLQMHQLFD
8 VOXaDMX .UHP]RZ SURWLY $XVWULMH SRGQRVLODF MH
LVNOMXaHQL]UDVSUDYHRSUDYQLPSLWDQMLPD6XGMHVPDWUDRGD
QMHJRYRSULVXVWYRQLMHELORXVORYOMHQRaODQRPVWLOLVW
F MHU MH QMHJRY DGYRNDW ELR SULVXWDQ L PRJDR MH X QMHJRYH
LPH L]QRVLWL DUJXPHQWH 0H_XWLP 6XG MH QD^DR GD VH UDGL R
NU^HQMX DNR MH SRGQRVLODF LVNOMXaHQ V UDVSUDYH X CDOEHQRP
SRVWXSNXQDSUHVXGXNRMDMHXNOMXaLYDODSRYH`DQMHND]QHQD
GRCLYRWQX ND]QX ]DWYRUD L VOXCHQMH ND]QH X VSHFLMDOQRP ]DW
YRUXNDRLRGOXaLYDQMHRPRWLYX]ORaLQD^WRSRURWDQLMHELOD
XVWDQMXGDXaLQL(YURSVNLVXGMHVPDWUDRGDSR^WRVXSURFHQD
NDUDNWHUDSRGQRVLRFDQMHJRYRVWDQMHVYHVWLLPRWLYDFLMDELOLELWQL
]DSRVWXSDNDVDPLQWHUHVSRGQRVLRFDELRYUORYHOLNLRQMHWUHEDR
GDSULVXVWYXMHLXaHVWYXMHMHGQDNRNDRLQMHJRYDGYRNDW
3UDYR 6UELMH L &UQH *RUH
3RYHOMRPROMXGVNLPSUDYLPDVHJDUDQWXMHGDVYDNRNR
MH GRVWLCDQ VXGX LOL GUXJRP RUJDQX QDGOHCQRP GD YRGL SRV
WXSDN QH PRCH VH ND]QLWL DNR PX QLMH ELOR RPRJX`HQR GD
.UHP]RZ SURWLY$XVWULMHVHSWHPEDU
EXGH VDVOX^DQ L GD VH EUDQL aO 8VWDY 6UELMH VDGUCL VOLaQX
RGUHGEXGRN8VWDY&UQH*RUHQHVDGUCLRGUHGEHRRYRPSLWDQMX
=.3 GHWDOMQLMH RGUH_XMH SULVXVWYR RSWXCHQRJ GD SULVX
VWYXMH JODYQRP SUHWUHVX L VDPR L]X]HWQR GRSX^WD VX_HQMHLQ
DEVHQWLD
r
L]YHVWLSUHGVWDYOMDL]UD]LPSOLNDFLMDQDRVQRYX]GUDYRJUD]X
PDNDGDRNULYOMHQLSURSXVWLGDGQHGXCQRREMD^QMHQMHVYRMLK
SRVWXSDND LOL SRQD^DQMD %LOR MH GRYROMQR JDUDQFLMD GD VH
LVSR^WXMHSUDYLaQRVWDRS^WLWHUHWGRND]LYDQMDELRMHQDRSWXCEL
NRMDMHPRUDODELWL]DVQRYDQDQDSULPDIDFLHaLQMHQLFDPDSUH
QHJR ^WR VH SRVUHGQR PRJOR GR`L GR ]DNOMXaDND QD RVQRYX
`XWDQMD
0H_XWLP X VOXaDMX &RQGURQ SURWLY 8MHGLQMHQRJ .UD
OMHYVWYD 6XG MH VPDWUDR GD VXGLMD PRUD LVSUDYQR XSXWLWL
SRURWX NDGD RGOXaXMH GD OL `H GRQHWL QHJDWLYDQ ]DNOMXaDN
QD RVQRYX `XWDQMD SRGQRVLRFD NDNR QH EL GR^OR GR NU^HQMD
aODQD
3UDYR 6UELMH L &UQH *RUH
3RYHOMDROMXGVNLPSUDYLPDVDGUCLRGUHGEXGDQLNRQH
PRUDGDVYHGRaLSURWLYVDPRJVHEHLOLGDSUL]QDNULYLFXoaO
VW 8VWDYL UHSXEOLND QH VDGUCH RYDNYX HNVSOLFLWQX
RGUHGEXR]DEUDQLVDPRRSWXCLYDQMD,SDNREDUHSXEOLaNDXV
WDYD]DEUDQMXMXVYDNRQDVLOMHLVYDNRL]QX_LYDQMHLVND]DRG
QRVQRSR^WRYDQMHOMXGVNRJGRVWRMDQVWYDLOLaQRVWLXNULYLaQRP
L VYDNRP GUXJRP SRVWXSNX aO 8VWDYD 6UELMH L aO
8VWDYD &UQH *RUH
=.3 SUXCD PRJX`QRVW RNULYOMHQRP GD VH EUDQL `XWD
QMHPLL]ULaLWRSURSLVXMHGDVHRGOXNDVXGDQHPRCH]DVQLYDWL
QD LVND]X RNULYOMHQRJ DNR RQ QLMH ELR SRXaHQ R VYRP SUDYX
GD VH EUDQL `XWDQMHP 3UH SUYRJ VDVOX^DQMD RNULYOMHQL PRUD
ELWL REDYH^WHQ R SUDYX GD X]PH EUDQLRFD NDR L GD EUDQLODF
PRCH SULVXVWYRYDWL QMHJRYRP VDVOX^DQMX aO VW L L
aO VW
&RQGURQ SURWLY8MHGLQMHQRJ .UDOMHYVWYD PDM
SULORCHQHXVSLVX8RYRPNRQWHNVWXSRVHEQDYDCQRVWVH
GDMH XWLVNX SUDYLaQRVWLX YR_HQMX VOXaDMD
2YLSULQFLSLSULPHQMXMXVHLQDNULYLaQHLQDJUD_DQVNH
SRVWXSNH
8NULYLaQLPVOXaDMHYLPDRQLVHSUHNODSDMXVDQHNRPRG
SRVHEQLKJDUDQWLMDL]aODQDVWDOLQLVXLRJUDQLaHQLVDPR
QD WH DVSHNWH SRVWXSND 1D SULPHU X VOXaDMX%QLVFK SURWLY
$XVWULMH6XGMHVPDWUDRGDDNRVXGVNRPYH^WDNXNRMHJMH
LPHQRYDODRGEUDQDQLVXSUXCHQHLVWHSRJRGQRVWLNDRLRQRPH
NRMHJ MH LPHQRYDOD RSWXCED LOL VXG SRVWRML NU^HQMH aODQD
VW
1DGDOMHXVOXaDMX-HVSHUVSURWLY%HOJLMH.RPLVLMDMH
VPDWUDODGDSULQFLSMHGQDNRVWLVWUDQDX]HW]DMHGQRVDaODQRP
VW E QDPH`HREDYH]XWXCLOD^WYX LLVWUDCQLP RUJDQLPD
GD L]QHVX VDY PDWHULMDO NRMLP UDVSRODCX LOL LP PRCH ELWL
QDUDVSRODJDQMXDNRMLELPRJDRSRPR`LRNULYOMHQRPGD
VHRVORERGLNULYLFHLOLSRVWLJQHVPDQMHQMHND]QH2YDMSULQ
FLSSUR^LUXMHVHLQDPDWHULMDONRMLELPRJDRQDUX^LWLNUHGLEL
OLWHW VYHGRND RSWXCEH 8 VOXaDMX )RXFKHU SURWLY )UDQFXV
NH 6XG MH VPDWUDR GD aLQMHQLFD ^WR RSWXCHQRP NRML MH
CHOHR VDP VHEH GD ]DVWXSD QLMH RSWXCED GR]YROLOD XYLG X
VXGVNHVSLVHQLNRSLMHGRNXPHQDWDNRMLVXELOLXQMLPDWHVH
SUHPD WRPH QLMH PRJDR DGHNYDWQR SULSUHPLWL ]D RGEUDQX
SUHGVWDYOMD NU^HQMH SULQFLSD MHGQDNRVWL VWUDQD X VNODGX VD
aODQRP VW
8JUD_DQVNLPSRVWXSFLPDaODQXRGUH_HQLPRNROQR
VWLPD]DKWHYDGDVWUDQHXQDNUVQRLVSLWXMXVYHGRNH3ULQFLS
MHGQDNRVWLVWUDQDMHSUHNU^HQLNDGDMHMHGQRMVWUDQLXVNUD`HQD
PRJX`QRVW GD RGJRYRUL QD SLVPHQH SRGQHVNH NRMH MH GR
PD`HPVXGXSRGQHRMDYQLSUDYREUDQLODF8VOXaDMX'RPER
%HKHHU % 9 SURWLY +RODQGLMH SRGQRVLODF NRPSDQLMD V
RJUDQLaHQRP RGJRYRUQR^`X SRYHOD MH SRVWXSDN SURWLY MHGQH
EDQNH NDNR EL GRND]DOD GD MH SRVWRMDR XVPHQL VSRUD]XP
L]PH_X QMH L RYH EDQNH R GDYDQMX RGUH_HQLK NUHGLWQLK
RODN^LFD6DPRGYHRVREHSULVXVWYRYDOHVXVDVWDQNXQDNRMHP
MH RYDM VSRUD]XP QDYRGQR SRVWLJQXW MHGQD RG QMLK LVSUHG
SRGQRVLRFD D GUXJD LVSUHG EDQNH 0H_XWLP GRPD`L VXG MH
GR]YROLRVDVOX^DQMHXVYRMVWYXVYHGRNDVDPRMHGQRJOLFDWM
SUHGVWDYQLND EDQNH .RPSDQLMDSRGQRVLODF QLMH PRJODSR]
YDWLOLFHNRMHMHSUHGVWDYOMDODEDQNXMHUJDMHVXGLGHQWLILNR
YDR VD VDPLP SRGQRVLRFHP RGQRVQR NRPSDQLMRP
(YURSVNL VXG MH PH_XWLP QD^DR GD VX X NRQNUHWQLP
SUHJRYRULPDXaHVWYRYDODGYDSUHGVWDYQLNDNRMLVXELOLUDYQR
SUDYQLLRYOD^`HQLGDQDVWXSDMXVYDNRLVSUHGVYRMHVWUDQHWDNR
GD MH ELOR WH^NR VKYDWLWL ]D^WR RERMLFD QLVX PRJOL GDWL VYRMH
LVND]H7LPHMHNRPSDQLMDSRGQRVLODFVWDYOMHQDXQHSRYROMQLML
SRORCDMXRGQRVXQDEDQNX^WRMHSUHGVWDYOMDORNU^HQMHaODQD
VW
0H_XWLPXVOXaDMX$QNHUOSURWLY>YDMFDUVNH6XGMH
VPDWUDRGDQHPDNU^HQMDaODQDVW2YDMVOXaDMVHWDNR_H
RGQRVL L QD SR]LYDQMH VYHGRND D SRGQRVLODF VH CDOLR GD
RGELMDQMHVXGDGDGR]YROLQMHJRYRMVXSUX]LGDSRG]DNOHWYRP
JRYRJSUDYDQDRSWXCQLSRVWXSDN2YRSUDYRQDJOD^DYD6XG
]QDaLOR MH PRJX`QRVW ]D REH VWUDQH X SRVWXSNX GD EXGX
XSR]QDWHLGDPRJXGDYDWLVYRMHNRPHQWDUHQDVYHGRND]HLOL
SULPHGEH NRMH VX XNOMXaHQH X VSLV 3UHPD WRPH UDGLOR VH R
NU^HQMX aODQD VW
3UDYR 6UELMH L &UQH *RUH
3UDYRQDRGEUDQXJDUDQWRYDQRMH3RYHOMRPROMXGVNLP
SUDYLPDaOVWNDRLXVWDYLPDUHSXEOLNDaOVW
8VWDYD 6UELMH aO VW 8VWDYD &UQH *RUH 'HWDOMQLMD
UD]UDGD RYH JDUDQWLMH VDGUCDQD MH X =.3
1D SUYRP VDVOX^DQMX LVWUDCQL VXGLMD MH REDYH]DQ GD
RPRJX`L RNULYOMHQRP GD VH X QHRPHWDQRP L]ODJDQMX L]MDVQL
R VYLP RNROQRVWLPD NRMH JD WHUHWH L GD L]QHVH VYH aLQMHQLFH
NRMH PX VOXCH ]D RGEUDQX ,VWR YDCL L ]D RVXPQMLaHQRJ NRML
VHVDVOX^DYD SUH SRaHWND LVWUDJH
=.3SURSLVXMHGDVHRNULYOMHQRPPRUDRPRJX`LWLGDVH
L]MDVQL R VYLP aLQMHQLFDPD L GRND]LPD NRML JD WHUHWH L GD
L]QHVH VYH aLQMHQLFH L GRND]H NRML PX LGX X NRULVW
6DVOX^DQMX VYHGRND PRJX SULVXVWYRYDWL RNULYOMHQL L
QMHJRY EUDQLODF 7DNR_H SUDYR VWUDQNH GD X SRVWXSNX
SUHGX]LPD VYH UDGQMH NRMH PRCH SUHGX]LPDWL SURWLYQD
VWUDQDLSUDYRVWUDQNHGDSUHGODCHSULEDYOMDQMHLL]YR_HQMH
GRND]D]DGRYROMHQRMHLWRNRPL]YR_HQMDGUXJLKLVWUDCQLK
UDGQML
5DGLHILNDVQLMHJSRVWXSNDLLQWHUHVDRGEUDQH=.3RPR
JX`XMH L SULVXVWYR MDYQRJ WXCLRFD SULOLNRP VDVOX^DQMD RNULY
OMHQRJ 6DVOX^DQMH YH^WDND SUHGYL_HQR MH NDNR X SUHGNUL
YLaQRP SRVWXSNX WDNR L WRNRP JODYQRJSUHWUHVD
YLGL.RPSDWLELOQRVWMXJRVORYHQVNRJSUDYDVDRGUHGEDPD(YURSVNHNRQ
YHQFLMHR OMXGVNLPSUDYLPD 6DYHW (YURSH%HRJUDG VWU
6OJODVQLN 56EU
6OJODVQLN 56EU
7SURWLY8MHGLQMHQRJ.UDOMHYVWYDL9SURWLY8MHGLQMHQRJ.UDOMHYVWYD
GUCDYDPDXJRYRUQLFDPDXYH]LPLQLPDOQHVWDURVQHGRELNDGD
VH QHNR OLFH PRCH VPDWUDWL NULYLaQR RGJRYRUQLP NDR L GD
SULSLVLYDQMH NULYLaQH RGJRYRUQRVWL SRGQRVLRFLPD QLMH VDPR
SR VHELGRYHOR GR NU^HQMD aODQD 6XG X QDVWDYNX NDCH
6XGVHPH_XWLPVODCHVD.RPLVLMRPGDMHQHRSKRGQR
GDGHWHNRMHMHRSWXCHQR]DQHNRGHOREXGHSURFHVXLUDQRQD
QDaLQNRMLXSRWSXQRVWLX]LPDXRE]LUQMHJRYXVWDURVWVWHSHQ
]UHORVWLLLQWHOHNWXDOQXLHPRFLRQDOQXVSRVREQRVWNDRNRUDNH
NRML VX SUHGX]HWL X SUDYFX SRGL]DQMD QMHJRYH VSRVREQRVWL
UD]XPHYDQMDLXaH^`DXSRVWXSNX,]RYRJDVOHGLGDMHNDGD
MH UHa R POD_HP PDOROHWQLNX RSWXCHQRP ]D WH^NR NULYLaQR
GHOR NRMH SULYODaL YHOLNX SDCQMX PHGLMD L MDYQRVWL QXCQR
YRGLWLVX_HQMHQDQDaLQNRML`HPDNVLPDOQRVPDQMLWLQMHJRYR
LOLQMHQRRVH`DQMH]DVWUD^HQRVWL
6XGMHVWRJD]DNOMXaLRGDSRGQRVLODFQLMHELRXVWDQMX
GDXaHVWYXMHXNULYLaQRPSRVWXSNXNRMLVHYRGLRSURWLYQMHJD
LGDPXMHELORXVNUD`HQRSUDYRQDSUDYLaQRVX_HQMHL]aODQD
VW
8VOXaDMX6LQJKL+XVVDLQSURWLY8MHGLQMHQRJ.UDOMHY
3ULKYDWOMLYRVW GRND]D
3ULKYDWOMLYRVW GRND]D
JRP]ERJUDVWXUDQMDKHURLQD8QMHJRYRMNX`LEH]QMHJRYRJ
]QDQMD SULMDWHOMHYRJ SRVWDYOMHQ MH XUH_DM ]D SULVOX^NLYDQMH
3ROLFLMD MH VQLPLOD QD WUDNX UD]JRYRU L]PH_X SRGQRVLRFD L
QMHJRYRJ SULMDWHOMD X NRMHP SRGQRVLODF NDCH GD MH ELR XN
OMXaHQXNULMXPaDUHQMHGURJH8KDS^HQMHLRSWXCHQLQDNUDMX
RVX_HQ ]ERJ NULMXPaDUHQMD GURJH
3UHG (YURSVNLP VXGRP RQVHCDOLRQDNU^HQMDaODQD
SUDYD QD SR^WRYDQMH SULYDWQRJ CLYRWD L aODQD 6XG MH XVWD
QRYLR NU^HQMH aODQD MHU QLMH SRVWRMDR QLNDNDY ]DNRQVNL
VLVWHP NRMLP VH RGREUDYD NRUL^`HQMH XUH_DMD ]D SULVOX^NLYD
QMH ,DNR MH SUD`HQMH PRJOR ELWL X VNODGX VD XSXWVWYLPD 0L
QLVWDUVWYD XQXWUD^QMLK SRVORYD 6XG MH VPDWUDR GD VH LVWD QH
PRJX VPDWUDWL ]D SUDYQR REDYH]XMX`H QLWL VX ELOH GLUHNWQR
GRVWXSQHMDYQRVWL1DWDMQDaLQRYDXSXWVWYDQLVXLPDODND
UDNWHU ]DNRQDo ^WR ]DKWHYD aODQ GD EL QHNR PH^DQMH ELOR
RSUDYGDQR 8 YH]L QDYRGD SR aODQX 6XG MH SULPHWLR GD MH
SRGQRVLODFLPDRGRYROMQRSULOLNDGDRVSRULVDPXDXWHQWLaQRVW
VQLPOMHQRJ PDWHULMDOD NDR L NRUL^`HQMH PHWRGD 3RGQRVLODF
QLMHRVSRUDYDRDXWHQWLaQRVWDOLMHVWHXSRWUHEXPHWRGDALQMH
QLFDGDQLMHXVSHRNDNRMH6XGQDJODVLRQLMHXWLFDODQDRFHQX
6XGD (YURSVNL VXG MH QD^DR GD NRUL^`HQMH PDWHULMDOD NRML MH
GRELMHQ NU^HQMHP aODQD QLMH X VXSURWQRVWL VD ]DKWHYLPD R
SUDYLaQRVWL VDGUCDQLP X aODQX
2QR R aHPX 6XG MR^ QLMH RGOXaLYDR MHVWH GD OL GRND]L
NRML GRELMHQL NU^HQMHP GRPD`HJ SUDYD L NRML aLQH MHGLQH LOL
JODYQHGRND]HRNULYLFLQHNRJOLFDSUHGVWDYOMDMXNU^HQMHaODQD
.RQYHQFLMH
.RUL^`HQMH DJHQWD SURYRNDWRUDo MH GUXJD VWYDU
6OXaDM 7HL[HLUR GH &DVWUR SURWLY 3RUWXJDOLMH RGQRVL VH QD
7HL[HLURGH &DVWURSURWLY3RUWXJDOLMH MXQ
GYD SROLFDMFD QD WDMQRP ]DGDWNX NRML VX SUL^OL OLFX RVXP
QMLaHQRP ]D PDQMH ]QDaDMQR UDVWXUDQMH GURJH NDNR EL RG
QMHJD GRELOL KHURLQ 6 SRGQRVLRFHP MH XVSRVWDYOMHQ NRQWDNW
SUHNR GUXJRJ OLFD L RQ VH VORCLR GD `H LP QDEDYLWL KHURLQ
+HURLQ MH QDEDYLR SUHNR WUH`HJ OLFD 8KDS^HQ MH NDGD MH
LVSRUXaLYDR GURJX SROLFDMFLPD
3RGQRVLRFVHCDOLRGDQLMHLPDRSUDYLaQRVX_HQMHMHUMH
ELR QDYHGHQ FLYLOQRP RGH`RP SROLFDMDFD QD GHOR ]D NRMH MH
NDVQLMH RVX_HQ 6XG MH LVWDNDR GD QMHJRY ]DGDWDN QLMH RG
OXaLYDQMH GD OL VX LVND]L VYHGRND LVSUDYQR SULKYD`HQL NDR
GRND]L QHJR YL^H GD RGOXaXMH GD OL MH SRVWXSDN X FHOLQL
XNOMXaXMX`L L QDaLQ QD NRML VX GRND]L GRELMHQL ELR SUDYLaDQ
6XG MH SULPHWLR GD NRUL^`HQMH WDMQLK DJHQDWD PRUD ELWL SRG
UHVWULNFLMDPD L GD PRUDMX SRVWRMDWL JDUDQWLMH aDN L X VOXaDMH
YLPD NDGD VH UDGL R ERUEL SURWLY WUJRYLQH GURJRP 2S^WL
]DKWHYL R SUDYLaQRVWL XJUD_HQL X aODQ SULPHQMXMX VH QD
SRVWXSNH]DVYHYUVWHNULYLaQLKGHODRGQDMGLUHNWQLMLKGRRQLK
QDMVORCHQLMLK -DYQL LQWHUHV ERUEH SURWLY NULPLQDOD QH PRCH
RSUDYGDWLNRUL^`HQMHGRND]DNRMLVXGRELMHQLNDRUH]XOWDWSR
OLFLMVNRJ SRGVWLFDQMD
6XGMHELRPL^OMHQMDGDVHXRYRPVOXaDMXGYDSROLFDMFD
QLVX RJUDQLaLOD QD LVWUDJX R NULYLaQRM XOR]L SRGQRVLRFD X
MHGQRP SDVLYQRPVYRMVWYXQHJRVXXWLFDODQDQMHJDNDNREL
JD QDYHOL GD SRaLQL NULYLaQR GHOR 6XG MH WDNR_H SULPHWLR GD
VXGRPD`LVXGRYLXVYRMLPRGOXNDPDQDYHOLGDMHSRGQRVLODF
YH` UDQLMH ELRRVX_LYDQ XJODYQRP QD RVQRYX LVND]D RYD GYD
SROLFDMFD
6XGMHVWRJD]DNOMXaLRGDMHSRVWXSDNSROLFDMDFDL]D^DR
L]RNYLUDGR]YROMHQRJWDMQLPDJHQWLPDMHUVXL]YU^LOLSRGVWLFDM
QDNULYLaQRGHORLQLMHELORQLaHJD^WRELVXJHULVDORGDELRQR
ELOR L SRaLQMHQR EH] QMLKRYH LQWHUYHQFLMH 3UHPD WRPH UDGLOR
VHR NU^HQMX aODQD VW
3ULKYDWOMLYRVW GRND]D
'RRUVRQSURWLY+RODQGLMH6XGMHL]MDYLRSULQFLSLSUDYLaQRJ
VX_HQMD WDNR_H ]DKWHYDMX GD X RGJRYDUDMX`LP VOXaDMHYLPD
LQWHUHVL RGEUDQH EXGX X UDYQRWHCL VD LQWHUHVLPD VYHGRND LOL
CUWDYD NRML VX SR]YDQL GD VYHGRaHo 8 RYRP VOXaDMX SR
OLFLMDMHXFLOMXDNFLMHSURWLYWUJRYLQHGURJRPX$PVWHUGDPX
SULNXSLOD VHULMH IRWRJUDILMD RVRED RVXPQMLaHQLK GD VX WUJRYFL
GURJRP 3ROLFLMD MH GRELOD LQIRUPDFLMX GD MH SRGQRVLODF XN
OMXaHQ X WUJRYLQX GURJRP D QMHJRYX IRWRJUDILMX VX SRND]DOL
L]YHVQRP EURMX QDUNRPDQD NRML VX L]MDYLOL GD JD SUHSR]QDMX
L GD RQ SURGDMH GURJX -HGDQ EURM QMLK MH RVWDR DQRQLPDQ
3RGQRVLODF MH XKDS^HQ L NDVQLMH RVX_HQ ]D WUJRYLQX GUR
JRP
3RGQRVLODFVHCDOLRGDMHX]LPDQMHVDVOX^DYDQMHLRVOD
QMDQMHQDLVND]HQHNLKVYHGRNDWRNRPSRVWXSNDNRMLVHYRGLR
SURWLY QMHJD SUHNU^LOR SUDYD RGEUDQH X VPLVOX aODQD 2Q MH
QDJODVLRGDMHLVWUDCQLVXGLMDWRNRPSRVWXSNDSUHGSUYRVWHSH
QLP VXGRP LVSLWLYDR GYD DQRQLPQD VYHGRND EH] SULVXVWYD
QMHJRYRJ DGYRNDWD
(YURSVNL VXG MH LVWDNDR GD NRUL^`HQMH DQRQLPQLK VYH
GRND QD VX_HQMX PRCH SRVWDYLWL SLWDQMHSR .RQYHQFLML NDR L
GDPRUDMXSRVWRMDWLPHUHNRMLPD`HVHXVSRVWDYLWLUDYQRWHCD
WMRVLJXUDWLSUDYDRGEUDQH6XGMHSULPHWLRGDMHWHVYHGRNH
X CDOEHQRM ID]L X SULVXVWYX DGYRNDWD RGEUDQH LVSLWLYDR LV
WUDCQL VXGLMD NRML MH ]QDR QMLKRY LGHQWLWHW $GYRNDW MH LPDR
SULOLNX GD VYHGRFLPD SRVWDYOMD SLWDQMD ]D NRMD MH VPDWUDR GD
VX X LQWHUHVX RGEUDQH XNROLNR RQD QH EL GRYHOD GR UD]RWNUL
YDQMD QMLKRYRJ LGHQWLWHWD L QD VYD WD SLWDQMD GDWL VX L RGJR
YRUL 6XG MH WDNR_H SULPHWLR GD GRPD`L VXG QLMH ]DVQLYDR
VYRMH ]DNOMXaNH QD VYHGRaHQMX DQRQLPQLK VYHGRND WH SUHPD
WRPH QLMH QLQD^DR NU^HQMH aODQD
'RRUVRQSURWLY +RODQGLMH IHEUXDUVWDY
3ULKYDWOMLYRVW GRND]D
R RYRPSUHGPHWXYLGL XSRJODYOMXNRMHVOHGL
3ULKYDWOMLYRVW GRND]D
3ULNULYHQRJLVOHGQLNDRGUH_XMHPLQLVWDUXQXWUD^QMLKSR
VORYDLOLOLFHNRMHRQRYODVWL,VOHGQLNPRCHELWLOLFH]DSRVOHQR
X GUCDYQLP RUJDQLPD aO QM VW L
.DGD MH UHa R SULKYDWOMLYRVWL GRND]D =.3 RGREUDYD
XSRWUHEXLVND]DLREDYH^WHQMDNRMHMHWXCLODFSULNXSLRXSUHW
NULYLaQRPSRVWXSNXNDRGRND]DXNULYLaQRPSRVWXSNXDOLVH
RGOXND QH PRCH ]DVQLYDWL VDPR QD QMLPD aO M $NR VH
SRGDFL SULNXSOMHQL QD JRUH RSLVDQL QDaLQ QH RGQRVH QD NUL
YLaQRGHORRUJDQL]RYDQRJNULPLQDODRQLVHQHPRJXNRULVWLWL
X SRVWXSNX ]D QHNR GUXJR NULYLaQR GHOR aO Q VW
7DNR_H SULNULYHQL LVOHGQLN QH VPH ]DEUDQMHQR L NDCQMLYR
SRGVWLFDWL QD L]YU^HQMH NULYLaQLK GHOD aO QM VW
.RMLSRVWXSFLPRJXELWL XVXSURWQRVWLVSUHWSRVWDYNRPQHYLQRVWL"
.RMLSRVWXSFLPRJXELWLXVXSURWQRVWLVSUHWSRVWDYNRPQHYLQRVWL"
SURWLY8MHGLQMHQRJ.UDOMHYVWYD.RPLVLMDMHVPDWUDODQHSULK
YDWOMLYRPSUHWSRVWDYNXGDMHGDQaRYMHN]DNRMHJMHGRND]DQR
GD MH CLYHR VD LOL NRQWUROLVDR SURVWLWXWNX CLYL RG QHPRUDOQR
VWHaHQH ]DUDGH 8 VOXaDMX 6DODELDNX SURWLY )UDQFXVNH
SRGQRVLODFMHSUHX]HRLVSRUXNXQDWRYDUHQRJNDPLRQD]DNRML
VH SRND]DOR GD VDGUCL GURJX L SUHWSRVWDYND MH ELOD GD MH ELR
RGJRYRUDQ (YURSVNL VXG MH PH_XWLP VPDWUDR GD QLMH ELOR
NU^HQMD SR^WR VX GRPD`L VXGRYL RVWDYLOL VORERGX SURFHQH L
REUDWLOLSDCQMXQDaLQMHQLFHXVOXaDMXLSRQL^WLOLMHGQXSUHVXGX
AODQ VW SULPHQMXMH VH QD NULYLaQH SRVWXSNH X
FHOLQL D NRPHQWDUL VXGLMD R RNRQaDQMX SRVWXSND LOL R RVOR
ED_DMX`RMSUHVXGLSUHGVWDYOMDMXNU^HQMHRGUHGEHRSUHWSRVWDY
FL QHYLQRVWL 8VOXaDMX0LQHOOLSURWLY >YDMFDUVNHNULYLaQR
JRQMHQMH SRGQRVLRFD MH REXVWDYOMHQR ]ERJ LVWHND ]DNRQVNRJ
URND 0H_XWLP GRPD`L VXG MH QDORCLR GD RQ PRUD SODWLWL
MHGDQGHRWUR^NRYDNULYLaQRJSRVWXSNDNDRLRG^WHWXQDYRGQRM
CUWYL NDR GD VH QLMH UDGLOR R SULYUHPHQRM REXVWDYL L GD `H
SRGQRVLODF YHURYDWQR ELWL RVX_HQ 3UHPD WRPH UDGLOR VH R
NU^HQMX aODQD VW MHU MH SUHVXGD GRPD`HJ VXGD ELOD
QHNRPSDWLELOQD V SUHWSRVWDYNRP QHYLQRVWL
1LVXVDPRVXGRYLREDYH]QLSRSULQFLSXSUHWSRVWDYNHR
QHYLQRVWL QHJR VX WR L GUCDYQL RUJDQL 8 VOXaDMX$OOHQHW GH
5LEHPRQW SURWLY )UDQFXVNH QD SRGQRVLRFD MH GRN MH ELR
X SROLFLMVNRP SULWYRUX XND]DR YL^L SROLFLMVNL VOXCEHQLN QD
NRQIHUHQFLML ]D ^WDPSX NDR QDSRGVWUHNDaD XELVWYD(YURSVNL
VXG MH VPDWUDR GD VH aODQ VW SULPHQMXMH L QD GUXJH
VOXCEHQH RUJDQH RVLP VXGVNLK NDGD MH SRGQRVLODFRNULYOMHQ
]D NULYLaQR GHORo ,]MDYD R NULYLFL NRMX MH GDR SROLFDMDF ELOD
MH EH] LNDNYH NYDOLILNDFLMH LOL UH]HUYH L QDYHOD MH MDYQRVW GD
SRYHUXMH X NULYLFX SRGQRVLRFD SUH QHJR ^WR MH R aLQMHQLFDPD
RGOXaLYDR QDGOHCQL VXG 2YR MH X]HWR NDR NU^HQMH SULQFLSD
SUHWSRVWDYNH R QHYLQRVWL L QLMH LVSUDYOMHQR aLQMHQLFRP GD MH
SRGQRVLRFDNDVQLMHRVORERGLRVXGLMD]ERJQHGRVWDWNDGRND]D
3UHWSRVWDYND QHYLQRVWL PRUD ELWL MHGQDNR SRGUCDYDQD
QDNRQ RVORED_DMX`H SUHVXGH NDR L SUH VX_HQMD (YURSVNL VXG
MH QD^DR X VOXaDMX 6HNDQLQD SURWLY $XVWULMH GD YL^H QLMH
SULKYDWOMLYRGDVHGRPD`LVXGRYLRVODQMDMXQDVXPQMHXSRJ
OHGX NULYLFH QHNRJ SRGQRVLRFD QDNRQ ^WR MH RVORED_DMX`D
SUHVXGD SRVWDOD NRQDaQD
>WD]QDaLSUDYRQDEU]RLUD]XPOMLYRREDYH^WDYDQMHRRSWXCEDPD
%LWQR MH GD GHOR ]D NRMH MH QHNR OLFH RVX_HQR EXGH
LVWR RQR ]D NRMH MH L RSWXCHQR 8 VOXaDMX 3OLVVLHU L 6DVVL
SURWLY )UDQFXVNH RNULYOMHQL MH ELR RSWXCHQ VDPR ]ERJ
NULYLaQRJ EDQNURWD D RVX_HQ MH ]ERJ ]DYHUH X SULSUHPDQMX
NULYLaQRJ EDQNURWD 6XG MH VPDWUDR GD SR^WR VH UDGL R UD]
OLaLWLPHOHPHQWLPDGYDGHODRYRSUHGVWDYOMDNU^HQMH.RQYHQFLMH
>WD VX RGJRYDUDMX`H YUHPH L XVORYL SUHPD aODQX VW E"
9LGL QSU $OEHUW L /H &RPSWH SURWLY %HOJLMH IHEUXDU L ;
>WD VX RGJRYDUDMX`H YUHPH L XVORYL SUHPD aODQX VW E"
0OOHUSURWLY>YDMFDUVNHRGQRVLVHQDSULWYRUOLFDNRMDVX
NYDOLILNRYDQD NDR L]X]HWQR RSDVQL ]DWYRUHQLFL L NRML VX ELOL
RSWXCHQL ]D WH^ND GHOD WHURUL]PD 6OXaDMQL VXGLMD MH RGUHGLR
GD QH PRJX LPDWL SUDYQH SRVHWH WUL QHGHOMH L X WRP SHULRGX
PRJOL VX VH VDPR GRSLVLYDWL VD VYRMLP DGYRNDWLPD SRG VXG
VNLPQDG]RURP.DGDVXRGREUHQHSRVHWHDGYRNDWDYL^HQLVX
ELOLSRGQDG]RURP.RPLVLMDQLMHVPDWUDODGDRYRSUHGVWDYOMD
NU^HQMD aODQD VW E 8 GUXJLP VOXaDMHYLPD .RPLVLMD QLMH
XVWDQRYLODNU^HQMHNDGDMHSRGQRVLODFELRVPH^WHQXVDPLFXL
NDGD PX MH QD RJUDQLaHQR YUHPH ]DEUDQMHQR NRPXQLFLUDQMH
VD DGYRNDWRP ]DWR ^WR MH X GUXJR YUHPH LPDR PRJX`QRVW
WDNYRJ NRPXQLFLUDQMD 8 VOXaDMX .XUXS SURWLY 'DQVNH
QLMH XVWDQRYOMHQR NU^HQMH NDGD MH DGYRNDW RGEUDQH ELR SRG
REDYH]RPGDQHRWNULMHLGHQWLWHWQHNLKVYHGRNDVYRPNOLMHQWX
2YR QLMH ELOD UHVWULNFLMD NRMD MH XWLFDOD QD SUDYR SRGQRVLRFD
GD SULSUHPL VYRMX RGEUDQX X PHUL GD MH PRJOD SUHGVWDYOMDWL
NU^HQMH aODQD VW ELOL G
6YDND UHVWULNFLMD PH_XWLP PRUD ELWL VWULNWQR QHRS
KRGQD LPRUD ELWLSURSRUFLRQDOQD XVWDQRYOMHQLP UL]LFLPD
3UDYRQDNRPXQLFLUDQMHVDDGYRNDWRPWDNR_HXNOMXaXMH
L SUDYR QD SUHSLVNX SXWHP SLVDPD 9HaLQD RYLK VOXaDMHYD
LVSLWLYDQD MH SR aODQX .RQYHQFLMH SUDYR QD SR^WRYDQMH
SUHSLVNH NDR L SR aODQX VW E 8 VOXaDMX 'RPHQLFKLQL
SURWLY ,WDOLMH 6XG MH VPDWUDR GD NRQWUROD XSUDYH ]DWYRUD
QDGSLVPLPDNRMHMHSRGQRVLODFVODRVYRPDGYRNDWXSUHGVWD
YOMDNU^HQMHLaODQDLaODQDVWEQDURaLWR]ERJND^QMHQMD
X VODQMX MHGQRJ RGQMHJRYLK SLVDPD DGYRNDWX
.UFKHUL0OOHU SURWLY>YDMFDUVNH'5
9LGL QSU%RQ]L SURWLY>YDMFDUVNH '5
.XUXS SURWLY 'DQVNH '5
'RPHQLFKLQL SURWLY,WDOLMH QRYHPEDU
.RPLVLMD MHGRGDODGDVHRYRSUDYRRJUDQLaDYDQDRQH
XVORYH NRML SRPDCX LOLPRJX SRPR`L XRGEUDQL
2YDM SULQFLS X SUDNVL LPD SULOLaQR XVNR WXPDaHQMH 8
JRUHSRPHQXWRPVOXaDMX-HVSHUVSURWLY%HOJLMHSRGQRVLODFMH
QDYHR GD QLMH LPDR SULVWXS SRVHEQRM GRNXPHQWDFLML NRMX MH
SRVHGRYDRMDYQLWXCLODF.RPLVLMDMHXVWDQRYLODLDNRMHQDJ
ODVLOD GD EL RGELMDQMH SULVWXSD ELOR NU^HQMH aODQD VW E
-HVSHUVSURWLY%HOJLMH '5
>WD VX RGJRYDUDMX`H YUHPH L XVORYL SUHPD aODQX VW E"
XNROLNR VDGUCL ELOR ^WD ^WR EL PX RPRJX`LOR GD VH RVORERGL
RSWXCEH LOL VPDQML VYRMX ND]QX GD SRGQRVLODF QLMH SRGQHR
QLNDNYH GRND]H GD VH X RYRM GRNXPHQWDFLML QDOD]LOR ELOR ^WD
RG]QDaDMDL.RPLVLMDQLMHELODVSUHPQDSUHWSRVWDYLWLGDYODGD
QLMH LVSR^WRYDODVYRMH REDYH]H
1DGDOMH 6XG MH WDNR_H VPDWUDR GD MHGQD GUCDYD PRCH
RJUDQLaLWLSULVWXSVXGVNRPVSLVXDGYRNDWXRSWXCHQRJ2J
UDQLaHQMDQDRWNULYDQMHGRND]DSRGQRVLRFDVXSULKYDWOMLYDDNR
SRVWRML MDN UD]ORJ X VYUKX VSURYR_HQMD SUDYGH aDN LDNR VH
WYUGL GD VX GRND]L ]QDaDMQL ]DRGEUDQX
SUHNLQHVX_HQMHLRVLJXUDGRYROMQRYUHPHQD]DSULSUHPXRG
EUDQH DNR MH SUR^LUHQMH RSWXCEH SULKYD`HQR ]D NULYLaQR GHOR
NRMH MH RSWXCHQL XaLQLR X WRNX JODYQRJ SUHWUHVD LOL ]D UDQLMH
XaLQMHQRGHORNRMHMHRWNULYHQR]DYUHPHJODYQRJSUHWUHVDaO
VW
=.3 SURSLVXMH GD VHRNULYOMHQRP PRUD RPRJX`LWL GD
VH L]MDVQL R VYLP aLQMHQLFDPD L GRND]LPD NRML JD WHUHWH L GD
L]QHVH VYH aLQMHQLFH L GRND]H NRML PX LGX X NRULVWoaOVW
2YDQDaHOQDRGUHGEDMHLVWLP]DNRQRPUD]UD_HQDLRNULY
OMHQRP VH RPRJX`DYD GD UD]PDWUD VSLVH GD SULVXVWYXMH LV
WUDCQLPUDGQMDPDGDMHSUHGORJHLVWUDCQRPVXGLML]DL]YR_HQMH
LVWUDCQLK UDGQML X RGUH_HQLP VOXaDMHYLPD UD]JOHGD VSLVH L]
LVWUDJHSUHGODCHL]YR_HQMHQRYLKGRND]DNRPXQLFLUDVDVYR
MLP EUDQLRFHP LWG
>WDVDGUCLSUDYRQD]DVWXSDQMHLSUDYQXSRPR`SUHPDaODQXVWF"
>WDVDGUCLSUDYRQD]DVWXSDQMHLSUDYQXSRPR`SUHPDaODQXVWF"
>WDVDGUCLSUDYRQD]DVWXSDQMHLSUDYQXSRPR`SUHPDaODQXVWF"
%DUEHU0HVVHJXL-DEDUGRSURWLY>SDQLMHGHFHPEDUVWDY
8QWHUSHUWLQJHUSURWLY $XVWULMH QRYHPEDU
9LGL WDNR_H SRJODYOMH
)HUUDQWHOOL L6DQWDQJHOR SURWLY,WDOLMH DXJXVW
(YURSVNL VXG MH QD^DR NU^HQMH aODQD VW G MHU VX
GRND]L R LGHQWLWHWX ELOL LVNOMXaLYR RVQRYD SR NRMRM MH SRGQR
VLODF RVX_HQ
.DRRS^WHSUDYLORVWUDKRGRVYHWHNRMLPVHRSUDYGDYD
NRUL^`HQMH GRND]D L] GUXJH UXNH QH PRUD ELWL SRYH]DQ VD
%ULFPRQW SURWLY%HOJLMH MXO VWDY
6DLGL SURWLY )UDQFXVNHVHSWHPEDUVWDY
QHNRPNRQNUHWQRPSUHWQMRPRSWXCHQRJ(YURSVNLVXGMHVPDWUDR
XVOXaDMX'RRUVRQSURWLY+RODQGLMHGDLDNRSRGQRVLODFQLMH
QLNDGD SUHWLR GYRMLFL VYHGRND WUJRYFL GURJRP YUOR aHVWR NRULVWH
SUHWQMHLOLNRQNUHWQRQDVLOMHSURWLYOLFDNRMDVYHGRaHSURWLYQMLK
'DOMLSUREOHPXYH]LDQRQLPQLKVYHGRNDOHCLXaLQMHQLFL
GDRGEUDQDQHPRCHRVSRUDYDWLNUHGLELOLWHWVYHGRND(YURSVNL
VXG MH X VOXaDMX.RVWRYVNLSURWLY +RODQGLMHL]MDYLR GD
$NR RGEUDQD QLMH XSR]QDWD V LGHQWLWHWRP RVREH NRMX
WUDCL GD LVSLWD X WRP VOXaDMX RQD MH OL^HQD NRQNUHWQLK PR
JX`QRVWL GD SRNDCH GD WD RVRED LPD SUHGUDVXGD GD MH
QHSRX]GDQDLOLQHSULMDWHOMVNLQDVWURMHQD6YHGRaHQMHLOLGUX
JHL]MDYHNRMHRSWXCXMXRNULYOMHQRJPRJXELWLSODQLUDQRQHLVWLQLWH
LOLMHGQRVWDYQRSRJUH^QHLWH^NRGD`HRGEUDQDELWLXVWDQMX
GD WR L]QHVH QD YLGHOR DNR QHPD LQIRUPDFLMX NRMD MRM RPR
JX`DYD GD SURYHUL SRX]GDQRVW RVREH NRMD GDMH LVND] LOL GD
RVSRULQMHQNUHGLELOLWHW2SDVQRVWLNRMHLGXX]RYDNYXVLWXD
FLMXVXVDVYLPRaLJOHGQH
3RVWXSFL]DXVSRVWDYOMDQMHSURWLYWHCHSRWUHEQL]DRVLJX
UDYDQMH SUDYLaQRVWL VX_HQMD YDULUDMX RG VOXaDMD GR VOXaDMD
%LWQLIDNWRULWUHEDGDXNOMXaHGDOLMHRNULYOMHQLLOLQMHJRYQMHQ
DGYRNDW ELR SULVXWDQ SULOLNRP LVSLWLYDQMD VYHGRND GD OL MH
RQRQD PRJDR SRVWDYOMDWL SLWDQMD L GD OL MH VXGLMD QD VX_HQMX
ELR XSR]QDW V LGHQWLWHWRP VYHGRND (YURSVNL VXG X VOXaDMX
9DQ 0HFKHOHQ L RVWDOL SURWLY +RODQGLMHSULPHWLR MHVOHGH`H
9RGH`LUDaXQDRPHVWXNRMHSUDYRQDSUDYLaQRVSUR
YR_HQMH SUDYGH LPD X GHPRNUDWVNRP GUX^WYX VYH PHUH NR
MLPDVHRJUDQLaDYDSUDYRRGEUDQHPRUDMXELWLVWURJRQHRS
KRGQH$NRMHGRYROMQDPDQMHUHVWULNWLYQDPHUDRQGDVHWD
PHUDPRUDSULPHQLWL
'RRUVRQSURWLY +RODQGLMH IHEUXDUVWDY
.RVWRYVNL SURWLY+RODQGLMH QRYHPEDU VWDY
9DQ 0HFKHOHQLRVWDOL SURWLY+RODQGLMH PDUWVWDY
>WD XNOMXaXMH SUDYR QD WXPDaD SUHPD aODQX VW H"
>WD XNOMXaXMH SUDYR QD WXPDaD SUHPD aODQX VW H"
YDRPDWHUQMLMH]LNSRGQRVLRFD6XGMHQD^DRGDSRPR`WUHED
ELWL WDNYD GD RPRJX`DYD SRGQRVLRFX GD VH XSR]QD VD
VOXaDMHPSURWLYQMHJDLGDVHEUDQLXJODYQRPWDNR^WR`HELWL
X VWDQMX GD SUHG VXGRP L]QHVH VYRMX YHU]LMX GRJD_DMDo
2EDYH]D QDGOHCQLK YODVWL QH RJUDQLaDYD VH VDPR QD
SRVWDYOMDQMH WXPDaD QHJR VH WDNR_H PRCH SUR^LULWL L QD SUR
YR_HQMH MHGQRJ VWHSHQD NRQWUROH QDG WDaQR^`X WXPDaHQMD
XNROLNRVXREDYH^WHQL GD SRVWRML SRWUHED ]D WLP
3UDYR QD WXPDaD MH VKYD`HQR GD VH SULPHQMXMH L X
VOXaDMX JOXYLK OLFD JGH MH QRUPDOQD PHWRGD NRPXQLFLUDQMD
SXWHP ]QDNRYD
8 VOXaDMX ]WUN SURWLY 65 1HPDaNH NRML VH EDYL
PDWHULMRP ^WD SUHGVWDYOMD NULYLaQX RSWXCEX SLWDQMH GD OL MH
NRQNUHWQRGHORELORNULYLaQDRSWXCEDLOLQHQDVWDORMH]DWR^WR
VX QHPDaNH YODVWL CHOHOH QDWHUDWL SRGQRVLRFD GD SODWL XVOXJH
WXPDaD
VW 8VWDY &UQH *RUH RYR SUDYR JDUDQWXMH VDPR SUL
SDGQLFLPD QDFLRQDOQLK L HWQLaNLK JUXSD X SRVWXSNX SUHG GU
CDYQLP RUJDQLPD D QH JDUDQWXMH SUDYR VYDNRJ QD XSRWUHEX
VYRJ MH]LND SUHG VXGRP LOL X GUXJLP SRVWXSFLPD NRMH YRGH
GUCDYQL RUJDQL aO
=DNRQLN R NULYLaQRP SRVWXSNX JDUDQWXMH VWUDQNDPD
VYHGRFLPD L GUXJLP XaHVQLFLPD X SRVWXSNX SUDYR GD NRULVWH
VYRMMH]LNXWRNXaLWDYRJSRVWXSND$NRVHSRVWXSDNQHYRGL
QD MH]LNX QDYHGHQLK OLFD VXG MH REDYH]DQ GD LK REDYHVWL R
QMLKRYRPSUDYXQDSUHYR_HQMHaOVWL2GWRJSUDYD
OLFH X SLWDQMX PRCH RGXVWDWL DNR JRYRUL MH]LN QD NRPH VH
SRVWXSDNYRGL2YRVHMHGQDNRSULPHQMXMHQDGUCDYOMDQH6&*
L VWUDQFH 6XG PRUD XQHWL X ]DSLVQLN GD MH WDNYD LQIRUPDFLMD
SUXCHQD NDR L L]MDYX OLFD X YH]L V WLP $NR VXG WR QH XaLQL
LOL DNR QH GR]YROL OLFX GD QD SUHWUHVX NRULVWL VYRM MH]LN
RGQRVQR GD SUDWL WRN VX_HQMD QD VYRP MH]LNX SRVWRML ELWQD
SRYUHGDRGUHGDEDNULYLaQRJSRVWXSNDNRMDMHMHGDQRGUD]ORJD
]D SRELMDQMH SUHVXGH CDOERP aO W L aO VW W
=.3WDNR_HSUHGYL_DGDVHPRUDREH]EHGLWLSUHYRGL]MDYD
L LVSUDYD NDR L GUXJLK SLVDQLK GRND]D
2YDM ]DNRQLN SRYHULR MH SUHYR_HQMH WXPDaX ^WR ]QDaL GD
GUXJLXaHVQLFLXSRVWXSNXQHPRJXELWLNRUL^`HQLNDRWXPDaL
.DGDVXXSLWDQMXWUR^NRYLWXPDaD=.3NDRSRYOD^`HQD
OLFD X VPLVOX RVORER_HQMD WUR^NRYD QDYRGL SULSDGQLNH QDFLR
QDOQLKPDQMLQDDOLQHLGUXJDOLFDNRMDQHJRYRUHLOLQHUD]XPHMX
MH]LN SRVWXSND ^WR MH UHVWULNWLYQLMD RGUHGED RG aODQD VW
.RQYHQFLMH 3LWDQMH NRMH VH QDPH`H NDR SUREOHP RGQRVL VH QD
WUR^NRYH WXPDaD 1DLPH =.3 MHGLQR SUHGYL_D GD VH WUR^NRYL
SUHYRGDQDMH]LNHQDFLRQDOQLKPDQMLQDQH`HQDSOD`LYDWLRGOLFD
RG NRMLK VH SUHPD RGUHGEDPD RYRJ ]DNRQLND ]DKWHYD GD SODWH
WUR^NRYHNULYLaQRJSRVWXSNDaOVW