Download as docx, pdf, or txt
Download as docx, pdf, or txt
You are on page 1of 2

TabithaYee

Fukao
Period1
Economics
26February,2015
AmericanSniperTrial:FormerMarineguiltyofmurder
OnTuesday,aformermarinenamedEddieRayRouthwasfound
guiltyofthe2013deathsofChrisKyleandhisfriendChadLittlefield.Chris
KylewasaformerNavySEALandtheauthorofAmericanSniper.
ChristianScienceMonitorwrites,Thetrialgrippedthecountrys
consciousness,inpartbecauseofthe$400millionworldwideboxoffice
takeofClintEastwoodscinematicprofileofMr.Kyle,oneofAmericas
mostproficientandefficientNavySEALsnipers.AmericanSniperwas
nominatedforsixAcademyAwards,includingbestpicture.AttheOscars
Sunday,itwonasoundeditingaward.OnFebruary2,2013,Routh
admittedtokillingKyleandLittlefieldatagunrange.Hewaspleaded
notguilty,becausehisattorneysandfamilymembersarguedthathe
suffersfrommentalillnesscausedbyPTSDandotherfactors.
Anissuethatisdebatedisthatin2013RouthsmotheraskedChris
KyletohelphersondealwithPTSD.Butonthedayofwhatwas
supposedtobetheirbonding,turnedintoadoublehomicide.Routhgave
severalversionsofhismotivesofkillingthetwomen.Allofthemfroma
sensethattheyweregoingtokillhim.ProsecutorsarguedthatRouthwas
bothparanoidandintoxicated.Thisrelatestoourclassbecausewe
learnedaboutcapitalpunishment.Whatifyouwereapartofthistrialas
amemberofthejury.Shouldwepleadmentallyillpeoplewhocommita
criminalact,notguilty?Ichosethisarticlebecauseofhowtheheated
debateofnotguiltybyreasonofinsanityisstillprevalentinthisworld
today.
Question:Shouldwepleadmentallyillpeoplewhocommitacriminal
act,notguilty?
notguiltybyreasonofinsanity

n.pleaincourtofapersonchargedwithacrimewhoadmitsthecriminalac
t,butwhoseattorneyclaimshe/shewassomentallydisturbedatthetimeof
thecrimethathe/shelackedthecapacitytohaveintendedtocommitacrime

You might also like