Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Efnd8120 Liu Inventing Girlhood Mla
Efnd8120 Liu Inventing Girlhood Mla
Efnd8120 Liu Inventing Girlhood Mla
American childrens literature was born in Europe in the eighteenth century with the
birth of the concept of childhood. Before this period, children were regarded to be
younger adults, wore similarly clothes and only read the Bible and related stories.
However, after this period, they were known to be different from adults and needed to
be treated separately. One of the significant changes related to the concept of
childhood appeared in reading materials for children: adults began to write books for
children. Those childrens books were written primarily for pleasure. Therefore we
regard childrens literature as embryonic in the eighteenth century;
I.
can be traced back to the eighteenth century. Before the modern concept of childhood
was constructed, children in the medieval ages had been regarded as the same as
adults: wearing smaller clothes of their parents and reading books such as the Bible.
There were not enough reading materials for children. Therefore, we consider the
appearance of childhood in Europe in the eighteenth century is remarkable in the
history of mankind.
Both the discourses of childhood and childrens literature experienced essential
changes since they were formed. According to Written for Children: an Outline of
English-Language Childrens Literature, after Rousseaus Emile was printed, aiming
at the beauty of children, some adults gradually came to accept the ideas that children
are innocent and tabula rasa. In addition, John Locke presented the idea that children
are noble savages, which meant that they have an uncivilized nature and beautiful
minds. In this period, the concept of innocent childhood was born.
Finally, I cite Perry Nodelmans The Pleasures of Childrens Literature as the
reason why scholars date the birth of childrens literature to the eighteenth century.
Before the eighteenth century, there had already been some books for children, but
many of those books had moral or religious purposes for children to read. In other
words, adults tried to indoctrinate children with the values that they cared about; they
cultivated children in adults manner. Nodelman mentions that the concepts of
childhood and childrens literature were actually invented by adults, which means that
it is adults that imagine what children are, so that they produce childrens books for
children. Consequently, there are two features that delineate childrens literature from
2
the former generations: books that are intentionally to be written for children and are
supposed to be read for pleasure. Since then, the functions of childrens books
changed, addressing childrens enjoyment. Nowadays, many highly recognized
children books feature hyperbolic imagination and amusement; we can see that
childhood and childrens literature in the eighteenth century influence our ideas in this
modern society.
After the concept of childhood was born in Europe, Americans absorbed the ideas
of childhood and childrens literature from the mainland Europe and also developed
their own. In fact, Americans differ from Europeans in races, cultures, religions,
social classes, and geography. Therefore, the perspectives of American childhood and
childrens literature show a wide variety depending on those factors. For example,
African American children were not allowed to read, so their childhood experiences
might be different from some literate White American children. In this case, American
childrens literature can be a tool to comprehend American culture and society.
To understand the relationship of American childhood and American
childrens literature, I refer to Gail Schmunk Murrays American Childrens Literature
and the Construction of Childhood, which chronologically categorizes childhood and
childrens literature in America. To be specific, The Little Women and Daddy-LongLegs demonstrate that American girls who attended schools were highly appreciated,
whereas The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn and The Adventures of Tom Sawyer
demonstrate that American boys self-education (adventure) was applauded. The
books provide a panoramic view on the development of American childrens
literature, with connections to American society and culture.
Nowadays, there exist more perspectives on childhood and childrens literature,
such as the gender role of girls in childrens books. For these reasons, I would like to
fill a gap in the discussion on American girlhood and American girls in American
childrens books, from their birth, growth, to their transformations. I consider that this
girlhood was invented by authors, for they elucidated some essences of girlhood that
concerned them, rather than conveyed the reality. First, the American childrens books
that I select here were written in America from the nineteenth century to the present,
and are representative American fictions. Second, I include books that are intended for
children as well as young adult readers (Daddy-Long-Legs and Are You There God?
Its Me, Margaret), for there are more cross-over books for them. In my argument,
from the nineteenth century to the present, the gender roles of girls have changed.
3
Before the 1970s, girls were described as conservative and passive. However, it was
after the 1970s that the gender role of girls exponentially changed, for girls are
described as aware of their gender and education.
From the nineteenth century to the 1970s, the gender role of girls improved in
many aspects. I select evidence from some representative American childrens books,
such as Little Women, Daddy-Long-Legs, The Adventure of Tom Sawyer, The
Adventure of Huckleberry Finn, The Wizard of Oz, and Are You There God? Its Me,
Margaret. They compose of elements from didactics purposes mixed with pleasure for
children, to pure reading pleasure for children as a core in the changes of time.
II.
representative of girls literature is Louisa May Alcotts The Little Women, which was
set during the period of the Civil War. Luisa May Alcott and her characters in The
Little Women portrayed womens situation during the Civil War. Both Alcott and the
four March sisters had suffered difficulties of economic shortage. They received
informal education at home; however, it was still difficult to find a job in America in
Alcotts construction in the story. The story begins when the father is absent due to the
Civil War, and the mother and the daughters follow the paths to be good women,
waiting for the father to come back. To be more specific in analysis, at first the female
protagonist Jo is portrayed as a boyish character: she thinks and acts independently.
However, at the end of the story, she surrenders to the mainstream values, becoming
an obedient wife. In my observation, Luisa May Alcott and her characters in The
Little Women establish a new paradigm for girls, for it elucidates the power of
education; education enlightens girls, and its purpose is to cultivate good mothers and
wives.
Finally, it comes to a contradiction: if we define that childrens literature is
intentionally to be written for children, and are supposed to be read for pleasure, yet
The Little Women, with didactic and religious purposes, is regard as an American
classic childrens book. Here I cite what Peter Hunt has said, It is arguably
impossible for a childrens book (especially one being read by a child) not to be
educational or influential in some way; it cannot help but reflect an ideology and, by
extension, didacticism All books must teach something (3). As for The Little Women,
4
this book was not originally written for children. It is an adult book that has been
embraced by high school and middle school teachers. Also, early literature for
children was very much intended to "teach" children how to behave. Therefore, it is
not surprising that Little Women is didactic. On the other hand, The Little Women
does arouse readers pleasures and childhood experiences, such as girls common
memories between sisters. The Little Women, the embryo of childrens literature,
demonstrates the ambivalent status between indoctrinating and entertaining children
in a book. For this reason, we can view that even though The Little Women seems to
more didactic than many contemporary childrens fictions, it is a bold and progressive
attempt of amusing children by Luisa May Alcott in her era.
III.
but also simultaneously envisions a world where, after graduation, girls should only
be obedient to husbands. For this reason, education is double-edged for women to
accomplish their dreams; women could dominate knowledge, but they might not be
able to fully dominate their business. It is a dilemma between the expansions and
limitations of womens education in the twentieth century. Therefore, we can see that
the gender role of girls in Daddy-Long-Legs in Websters invention were different
from that in The Little Women: girls dare to dream through college education but dare
not fulfill their dreams through college education. Therefore, the gender role of girls
in Daddy-Long-Legs is wider than that of The Little Women, but more conservative
than that in Are You There God? Its Me, Margaret. Daddy-Long-Legs is in a
transitional period of the gender role of girls in the history of American childrens
literature.
IV.
America. There are two representative American childrens books on American boys:
The Adventure of Tom Sawyer and The Adventure of Huckleberry Finn. We need to
pay heed to these two fictions for they do not represent the real life of American boys
in the nineteenth century, but rather some adults expectations for boys education. In
their perspective, while American girls were expected to be well-educated at home or
in school, American boys were appreciated if they dared to escape from formal
education. According to Mark Twain in the preface of The Adventure of Tom Sawyer,
Although my book is intended mainly for the entertainment of boys and girls, I hope
it will not be shunned by men and women on that account, for part of my plan has
been to try to pleasantly remind adults of what they once were themselves, and of how
they felt and thought and talked, and what queer enterprises they sometimes engaged
in. (Preface) The statement demonstrates that childhood experiences are the theme of
this book for both genders: childish tricks, truancy, and games constantly invoke
childhood memories. Furthermore, the author determined to entertain readers
regardless of their age and gender. Twain created a boys paradigm, yet appealed to
both mens and womens childhood experiences, welcoming women to engage in
boys adventures, which is the most fascinating part in discussing gender role in
American childrens books. We first turn to Murrays research, which points out that
6
boys have the right and power to be rebellious in Mark Twains classical childrens
books (72-6). Education for them, is not literacy education and curricula, but an
induction to their dispositions. When women read these boys stories, they might
crave for, or identify themselves as those boys, but they could not keep the abilities to
destroy and to rebuild as their male counterparts when they grew up.
Interestingly, Twain assumes that both men and women are insiders of these
boys adventures, in contrast with Alcott, who only targets girl readers. For me, it
seems like boys tales are more neutral, for those games and lies in boys tales could
remind adults of similar boyhood and girlhood experiences; however, girls tales have
their own limitations, because household stories such as having quarrels between
sisters did not evoke identification by masculine males in a separate spheres society.
That is, boys education can be viewed by girls, while girls education is only
provided for its single sex audience. As a consequence, boys education might be a
paradigm for both boys and girls, if there were not enough reading materials to
differentiate them. Therefore, the images of girls, in a certain field of literature in this
period, were invented to show more introvert images than those of boys.
V.
Girls as Explorers
The Wizard of Oz is an American fantasy illustrating a girl Dorothys adventure
when Americans explored their continent toward the west in the nineteenth and the
twentieth century. It was a period when Americans explored the pioneer West. In the
pioneer West, Baum created a story of a nation with commoners and an undaunted
heart toward unpredictability. The story begins when a tornado takes Dorothy out of
her home in Kansas to a land she has never been to. There she meets a scarecrow who
wants a brain, a woodman who needs a heart, and a lion who aspires to courage.
Looking for help to go back to her uncle and aunt, she leads three male partners
(without masculine characteristics) to the Emerald City (Murray 103). They start an
adventure of self-discovery, with the companionship of the others, realizing that it is
an internal rather than external search in the end. Dorothys silver shoes have already
had the power to send her back home, and the three partners have already had the
abilities to think, to love, and to defend.
into poison ivy and gets stung by wasps and bees and brings frogs and snakes home
and breaks everything he lays his hands on. He is fine.
Good! said the doctor. (111-2)
The depiction of Fern and Avery demonstrates a culture of separate spheres:
boys are necessarily wild and girls are of domesticity. In playing with animals, adults
react differently for their daughters and sons. They take boys playing animals for
granted, while regards girls talking with animals as a strange behavior. That is, the
norms that adults set for boys are not appropriate to apply to girls, for there are other
educational purposes for girls: girls are supposed to be domestic. To conclude,
Charlottes Web successfully narrates a story of a friendship between children and
animals; however, it inevitably presents a gender stereotype when describing a girl
nurturing her pig.
Finally, in the twentieth century, a period between childhood and adulthood
appeared: adolescence. According to Jeffrey P. Moran, with the help of scientific
methods, sexual science and adolescent studies became authoritative. Then after the
feminist movement in the 1970s, sex education becomes a necessity for children and
teenagers. In John Modells study, youth culture was formed during the twentieth
century. Teenagers shared the similar language usages, clothing styles, music, and
ideology. One of the most significant impacts was that teenagers influenced the
society and culture. In Are You There God? Its Me, Margaret, the author narrates a
story of teenage girls and adolescence. It is revolutionary in gender role and religion,
with the growth of the concept of adolescence.
Are You There God? Its Me, Margaret is a controversial book on teenagers,
revising our concepts of gender role and religion. The title of the book has already
portended that it challenges norms. Maryann N. Weidt quotes Richard Jacksons
saying, There is no comma before God, and there is a period after Margaret. There is
no comma before God because Judy [Blume] felt very strongly that there was no
distance between Margaret and God, and she wanted it in this kind of informal, rushed
way, the way people talk, the way people think (49). This indicates that Judy Blume
intended to overturn the relationship between people and religions, and the clashes
between teenagers and the mainstream cultures.
In the story, Margaret, a teenage girl, with her transformation in body, is in quest of
the secrets of sex and religion. Since Margaret was born into an interfaith family,
10
Conclusion
11
the essences of invented girlhood and the education for girls, which are broader fields
that deserve scholars to explore in the future.
Reference Cited
Alcott, Louisa May. The Little Women. Boston, MA: Robers Brothers, 1869.
Alkalay-Gut, Karen. If Mark Twain had a Sister: Gender Specific Values and
Structure in Daddy-Long-Legs. Journal of American Culture Vol. 16 Issue 4
(Winter 1993): 91-9.
Aris, Philippe. Centuries of Childhood: a Social History of Family Life. Trans. Robert
Badick. New York: Vintage, 1962.
Baum, L. Frank. The Wizard of Oz. New York: G. M. Hill Company, 1900.
---. Ozma of Oz. Chicago: The Reilly& Briton Co. Publishers, 1907, 1989.
Blume, Judy. Are You There God? Its Me, Margaret. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Dell, 1972.
Griffith, John. Charlottes Web: A Pigs Salvation. New York: Twayne, 1993.
Hunt, Peter. An Introduction to Childrens Literature. Oxford: Oxford University Press,
1994.
Murray, Gail S. American Childrens Literature and the Construction of Childhood.
New York: Twayne, 1998.
Nodelman, Perry and Mavis Reimer. The Pleasures of Childrens Literature. 3rd Ed.
New York: Allyn and Bacon, 2003.
Rollin, Lucy. The Reproduction of Mothering in Charlotte's Web. Children's
Literature Volume 18 (1990): 42-52.
Rousseau, Jean-Jacques. Emile. New York: D. Appleton, 1892, 1901.
Russett, Cynthia Eagle. Sexual Science: the Victorian Construction of Womanhood.
Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 1989.
Salmon, Edwatd. Juvenile Literature As It Is. London: H.J. Drane, 1888.
Scholten, Catherine M. Childbearing in American Society: 1650-1850. New York: New
York University Press, 1985.
Tompkins, Jane. Sensational Designs: the Cultural Work of American Fiction, 17901860. New York: Oxford, 1985.
Townsend, John Rowe. Written for Children: an Outline of English-Language
Childrens Literature. New York: J.B. Lippincott, 2003.
Twain, Mark. The Adventure of Tom Sawyer. New York: Charles L. Webster and
Company, 1876.
---. The Adventure of Huckleberry Finn. New York: Charles L. Webster and Company
13
1885.
Wagenknecht, Edward. Utopia Americana (Oz). Seattle, Washington: University of
Washington Chapbooks, 1929.
Webster, Jane. Daddy-Long-Legs. New York: The Century Co, 1912.
Wiedt, Maryann N. Presenting Judy Blume. Boston, MA: Twayne Publishers, 1990.
West, Elliott. Growing up with the Country: Childhood on the Far Western Frontier.
Albuquerque, New Mexico: University of New Mexico Press, 1989.
White, E.B. Charlotte's Web. New York: HarperCollins, 1980.
14