STATE COMPTROLLER
STATE OF NEW YORK.
In the Matter of the Claim of
MICHAEL MESSINA, by his mother and Legal Guardian
RENEE M. CHANDLER,
NOTICE OF CLAIM
~Against-
‘THE STATE OF NEW YORK,
Defendant,
X
‘TO: COMPTROLLER OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK
PLEASE TAKE NOTICE that the claimant herein hereby makes claim
and demands against the STATE OF NEW YORK as follows:
THE NAME AND POST OFFICE ADDRESS OF THE CLAIMANT AND OF HIS
ATTORNEY IS:
Claimant
Michael Messina
23 Loudon Parkway
Albany, New York 12211
BY HIS MOTHER AS LEGAL GUARDIAN
Renee Chandler
23 Loudon Parkway
Albany, New York 12211
Altorney
Gerstman, Schwartz, & Malito LLP
Bradley Gerstman, Esq.
1399 Franklin Avenue
Suite 200
Garden City, New York 11530
516.880.8170THE NATURE OF THE CLAIM:
Michael Messina is a nineteen year old young man and has severe mental
health issues. He has been diagnosed with bipolar disorder, learning disabilities,
is on medication for ADHD, and has other impairments. Michael’s mother and
family members repeatedly requested help from the State, County of Albany, and
‘Towa of Colonie for his needs and continuously called State, County and Town
agents requesting services. The State, County and Town neglected and failed to
provide services for Michael or come to his aid. ‘The State, ‘County and Town
noglected to help Michael despite knowledge of his severe psychiatric condition,
special needs, and urgent circumstances.
In October of 2014, Michael’s mother became increasingly concerned
about her son, due to his exhibiting signs of severe depression, At this time,
Michael’s mother attempted to contact the Mobile Crisis Team of the Albany
County Department of Mental Health, which told her that they could do nothing
about the situation. Michael’s mother then contacted the Parsons Family Service
and the Colonie Outreach Center, but was unable to receive any help. In
November, she attempted to contact Albeny County Department of Mental Health
directly, but was told that they were not accepting new patients and were unable
to help. Without the proper help, Michael’s mental health further deteriorated.
On December 26, 2014, knowing Michael’s mental health issues,
members of the New York State Police Department, Town of Colonie Police
Department, and the Town of Bethlehem Police Department egregiously and
viciously violated the most fundamental civil and constitutional rights of Claimant
by chasing him and then shooting him, despite several less violent altematives.
‘The police shot him in the body as they chased him down an embankinent and
through a stream. They then failed to inform Michael’s mother, Renee Chandler,
and told her that Michael had been in a car accident. They concealed from
Michael’s mother the fact that they had shot Michael and that he was in critical
condition,
The authorities were on notice of Michael’s conditions, knew that he was
suicidal, and knew of his mental health status and that he had been hospitalized
more than six times related to several suicide attempts, Michael believed that if
he committed suicide that he would go to hell, so, on December 26, 2014, he
wanted to do “cop suicide,” a commonly known action to get the police to kill
you, Michael's mother communicated all of Michael's conditions to the
‘authorities during the chase and the authorities were already aware of his diseases
and illness,
‘The mental health service providers, Colonie Outreach Center, Mobile
Crisis Team of the Albany County Department of Mental Health, Parsons Family
Services, Albany County Department of Mental Health, The Office of People
with Developmental Disabilities, the State Education Department, the Town ofColonie Police Department, the Town of Bethlehem Police Department, and the
New York State Police Department committed the following offenses against
Michael Messina, which include, but are in no way limited to: Negligence, Failure
to provide services, False Arrest, False Imprisonment, Battery and Assault by the
use of excessive force, violation of the Claimant's right to be free from
‘unreasonable search and seizure under Article 1, Section 12 of the Constitution of
the State of New York and the Fourth Amendment of the Constitution of the
United States, violation of the Claimant’s civil rights and his equal protection
rights under Article 1, Section 11 of the Constitution of the State of New York
and the Fourteenth Amendment of the Constitution of the United States, violation
of the Claimant’s Miranda rights against compelled self-incrimination under the
Fifth Amendment and to counsel under the Fifth and Sixth Amendments of the
Constitution of the United States, violation of the Claimant's right to counsel
under the Sixth Amendment to the Constitution of the United States and the
Constitution of the State of New York, ‘Negligent Infliction of Emotional Distress,
and Intentional Infliction of Emotional Distress, Also, the same actors committed
offenses against Renee Chandler by failing to care for Michael, exacerbated his
‘mental health issues, caused dangerous situations by chasing Michael knowing his
‘mental health issues, by failing to provide services, by shooting her son and
failing to inform het, by failing to listen to her when she informed the authorities
during the chase,
THE TIME WHEN, THE PLACE WHERE AND THE MANNER IN WHICH THE
CLAIM AROSE:
‘The above-mentioned acts against Michael Messina occurred prior to and
on or about December 26, 2014, and could have been prevented had he gotten the
proper services. On December 26, 2014, at or around approximately 6:30 pm
Michael, known to police authorities as someone with lifelong severe mental
health issues, emotional disturbances, depression, PTSD, and learning disabilities,
set out to commit “suicide by cop.” He was chased, while driving his car, by the
local authorities, including police from the Town of Bethlchem, and by state
troopers throughout several different towns and cities and then they stopped
following him as the chase entered into the City of Albany. If they had continued
pursuit and followed up with helping Michael, the tragic shooting would never
have taken place, At some time later, the chase resumed in the Town of Colonie,
and it ended in Schenectady County with the police shooting Michael in the
abdomen. During the chase, Michael’s mother Renee Chandler, spoke with Police
and informed them that Michael has severe mental health issues, diagnosed as
bipolar disorder, emotional disturbances, PTSD, along with learning disabilities,
which they also already knew. ‘The Police let the chase continue for hours, and
stopped and restarted the chase allowing Michael to get into further problems and
more danger. Then the police continued to chase Michael with more and more
police cars and helicopters causing Michael to go even further into a mental
health breakdown. The nature and manner of the misconduct, brutality, criminal‘cts and violations of the constitutional rights of Michael Messina has been
thorougiily articulated in Paragraph 2.
Aer the shooting, the police attempted to cover up their behavior by
coming into claimant's home and confiscating claimant's cellphones, laptop, xbox
games and exercise equipment.
THE ITEMS OF DAMAGE AND INJURIES CLAIMED ARE:
Michael Messina’s damages are that he was shot in the body end sustained
severe and life threatening injuries; his mental health issues have worsened and
hhaye been exacerbated; he has sustained severe personal injuries, including severe
shock to his nervous system and certain internal injuries, and he has been caused
to sustain and suffer severe, painful, and permanent injuries, severe pain, agony
and discomfort, mental anguish, psychological trauma resulting in nervousness,
anxiety, fear, sleeplessness, and nightmares; humiliation, degradation, and shame;
impairment and damage to his personal reputation and character as a result
thereof, and has been caused to seek medical care in the future for said injuries;
thas been caused to abstain from his usual and daily activities, as well as having
become obligated to pay for medical care presently as well asin the future,
Michael has remained in the hospital where the bullet is lodged deep in his spine
that cannot be removed because it is so close to his vital organs.
AMOUNT DEMANDED:
Claimant is hereby demanding $10,000,000,00 (TEN MILLION
DOLLARS) for the damages to Claimant caused solely by the defendants and the
State of New York.
The claim and demand is hereby presented for adjustment and payment,