التحوط

]fl{{{{v{j{
<]< <{{]<{j
.
<<
<
<< <
<<

!"# $

% & %
' ( ) ! '

'
' ( ) ! / . *
% $

-.
' / 0 /
4556232/2 :
. )
.# !789 2
/33
336, :

/33 :< '8
4556232/2 :
.
# > =!.
-
A! @& 9 !& ? % > =!.
.7 D( -! $ C B

@! 89
'66/ D
E $
< <
l^j]

< < K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K i
K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K {}{EF
K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K
K K K K K K K K K K K K K "! ##$
K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K )*&#('
K K K K K K K K K K K K K K +,-#./#0 1
K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K 23456
K K K K K K K K K K K K {^{{]<]{{]<l^{f{{{iEF
K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K 789:;
K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K <.#:;
K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K =!-#:;
K K K K K K K K K K K K K +#: 9?'>
K K K K K K K K K K K K K K {^{]<l^{{j{{]EF
K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K =3"-+&
K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K =3"7A1
K K K K K K K K K K K K K =3": B 4
K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K =+&3".
K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K =$+"(C
K K K K K K K K K K K K K +D50 102E
K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K GHI"JC02E
K K K K K K K K K K K K K <K 45=3"
K K K K K K K K K K K K K =3"!#LM!+3#

K K K K K K K K K K !QRDN$23#5&O#P,
K K K K K K K K K K K K +5P,IS#
K K K K K K K K K K K K K K -TU0 Q
K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K -/'I
K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K 7JS4
K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K N5BV#
K K K K K K K K K K K K K K NW&#H2D9X YJ
K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K +#N
K K K K K K K K K K K Z ".5GSI#$+-
K K K K K K K K K K K K =3"!#[5HV-+&'#
K K K K K K K K K K K K K K =3"+#-LH521
K K K K K K K K K K K B]8/#<^L2B
K K K K K K K K K =3": ^X5_5X `#
K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K NK;
K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K {{]<s{{{]EF
K K K K K K K K K K K K HI"JC_'^
K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K H521
K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K a *"#
K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K # &3N
K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K N+-&4
K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K bc0!"1
K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K +&&.#
K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K $!3#5$!d"C
K K K K K K K K K K K K K K +/+3Ce+,^$3#
K K K K K K K K K K K K +&&.#RD7f3#$3#+#g
K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K fI1$+-
K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K =3"
K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K {{]<{EF
K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K =CH&h Y;
K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K +,i=CH&
K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K SI#=CH&
K K K K K K K K K K K K K SI#WO=CH&
K K K K K K K K K K K K SI#WO=CH&d;
K K K K K K K K K K K K K GSI#$+-j+J 4
K K K K K K K K K K K K K SI#=CH&k,?
K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K =$+"(C
K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K =+&3".
K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K GSI#
l/#
K K K K K K K K K K K K K K $m#W-4
K K K K K K K K K K K K K N35LKn
K K K K K K K K K K K K =CH&_'ô+/I4
K K K K K K K K K K K K K K N$HU=5H;
K K K K K K K K K K K K K K {^]<{{{&]EF
K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K o-"#
K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K $",C!+J
K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K $",C5-#
K K K K K K K K K K K K K !lY9RDpS"#C
K K K K K K K K K K K K K K #$",C<J5
K K K K K K K K K K K +#2/8#+UqH&
K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K XK" #;2&
K K K K K K K K K K K K K 0H&"hr"#5X5-"#
K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K
s tu;2&
K K K K K K K K K K K K K D /!=CH&0 v;
K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K ,s#
K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K "#;2&
K K K K K K K K K K K K K wI"#5"#P,

K K K K K K K K K K K K K +#=A"/7 34
K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K &/;2&
K K K K K K K K K K K K =A"/' 4+A+4x
K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K Nyz
K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K Nyz=+&
K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K *"#
K K K K K K K K K K K K K +-S#[=+"1C
K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K {(
K K K K K K K K K K K v{j<{{{c<l]+_EF
K K K K K K K K K K K K K GHI"JCa *"#
K K K K K K K K K K K K K K +#7f 3#{|
K K K K K K K K K K K K K K -+&'#a *"#
K K K K K K K K K K K K K K yua *"#
K K K K K K K K K K K K K K Y5-"#a *"#
K K K K K K K K K K K 2f-#f/d#a *"#
K K K K K K K K K K K K K K G2J-"#a *"#
K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K ,$M
K K K K K K K K K K K K )#d#p'#[}<+&#
K K K K K K K K K K K 0;~$W(4<,$M
K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K [}<+&#
K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K 2f-#
K K K K K K K K K K K K K K [B!d# </4
K K K K K K K K K K K K <.#,'&4=2/.#
K K K K K K K K K K K K K N$H`
K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K 7.#
K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K -.#,7.#
K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K J/
K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K ,s#8&6
K K K K K K K K K K K-.#,7.#HI"J=3+&'4
K K K K K K K K K K K -.#,7.#^2f-#
K K K K K K K K K K G2J-"#a *"#^f"/#-+&
K K K K K K K K K K N$H+U=.
K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K v(
K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K {{i^{}EF
K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K +^{{]

< <i

=Cn B +# 2/8# &/ :', + +#= A"/' 4
s
K

D^fYU/$2"#5 *&#28-&*)^#!8
K28-Z2#)*&# =#5;B+#=A"/' 4R3&+5

8[ B!L K+9= 2*"# B PD Y [ 4 + +# D/I#5
+#N$HU+ ++#=.RDX !f3# [
B+#=A"/"Q8YL=."!.4#5Kc!D;BDe6/#
(g Y[ B5 KS" +#! # a *"# ;[ B 0u ^ 83+&'4
'# Z2 RD 3, B!M4 #= A"/ TU "Q + D/I#L
R/- 059 YE X; 2 !/+,5 K+#= 2_ 723"# V+!" [
m#,+!;5Yd#YEXL+#=$H88[ 4#+Y}=,
K++#D/I#&3".$ '"#

7 .#$ "y2# "! #â *"#0 1$2#5
v( + +# D/I# [ G# G2*"# A8/ 05/"# #5
+Q$2#j2J23L K84W.5D/I#V+!",-"795Yd#h /#
'"# +#; j1xJ!y$B!? h ? HI"J
KN$HU5a *"#++#=A"/BH2D

G +uh ? c !D;78L '4^$2# 78.4X;B5
J/ RD Pd1&#< A4 X; !y K+ D/I# NW. KV-
X;28- s./B5K$2#8"#5/4#NWd#$#+D ? 5+!-#
3 0n | +!-# 7848U 723"# P!"85 Pd1&# D2
KHI"J#NH /p29

K+L "#s#55

EF

< <{}{

C5 B5 &*v5 #g RD5 0 $ RD
.#5 NI#5 2!u
K2-,5
!"# ; K"! #5 G2+3"#"! # 2Q d{
E- 2+3"#= 5H9 ^ H'! /# B 7O#&L G2+3"#
^52&4 HI"JC5+#=,?'C5=&3"#XL+#=3" K,;5
+Y Y3#= C6 B Wd# Wd4 =3" X; !y K$.C B C
2, HHK
81 &, &#'5 8/ *"#, T-"4 = v9 -[ +J(95
=.!# H'! /# B 7O#&L "! # ; K B 2u5
N$H, -" 8+L += A"/ XL + +#
K+: .#7A1<L" C$ IJBY-4
[uB# K=3#5=52Y5=$H N 2Dh ? j#5/42J5
K+&'"# Z ". RD5 +v"# Z ". RD h ? &*) # !fJ 0V4 C
7l"/D ? $UTU[`0VC$m#h ? XL+v"#)+1B!L
Y$3HI"JC,K"H2Q*?5$
235f.5D5L
.Khan and Ahmed (2001), El-Gari (2003), IFSB (2005) :
G "

EF
=A"/5=5H; '4B#c3L55KNv-HI"JC=l/#,
RD$!5+&'"#V+1TUWl/"#V+1BqH&3/4+#
^ kS4 X5H HI"JC NS# 35 += .[= +"1
K3+&'"#YE^+#U[u2"4 5+D#+J2I
=5H95 8/ - 7# #5 J$ #
=3"v(2+3"#=5H9,Y$3,K"{5#!f+
2+3"##5+#P,+.+f#:5S#J$ #H2Q!yK+#
KGHI"JCH9RD#|;5P&YE^+#=A"/^8-Y5

8, 5KB!"1C5J #! D,HEhedgingFa *"#
KL4U5;"D?U/50S1^"<#2v3<S"R/-
-" 06 B#5 p2c 0 1 ;2&) +1 B 06U b/ +L
#BC2,GH48Y;
;
-L p2c3QWa *"#-&"f #,
8!JS45NHKTU
C !D +Y.Y N+u5 , GHI"JC a/# XL ;2&) +1 B
<L$5 VL u +[ 4 ^ !8 S+5 GH4 5 K BD S/4 X; B
: 9 $3" H28 0*S" XL ,3^ 5 K+["Y5 NS#
PL'#BP,[ !/# ?<#B!BLK<!"nN5|H2&5
,#

LK+M3#u/$
23
l/#
2uL KZ(; 8[ B $!3#5 $m#
/# 8[ B B!M ,$5

EF
!Q> [5^d!"NS#5VL* #G$5M#BRYH9

a/#, N$M# ; KN5d# 5 ,# +3*"# K# +
.+5 $m# B 2s - cH&"L + BD 3". 5 GHI"JC
0 &3' # -# H52u + -# 74 8,5 KD6
z
=CH& 0 v; ! $m#5 ,# X X; &O B ##5 Kh /!5
KHI"JC^D /!
GHI"JCa/#+#5.!QX5H,#0 I1B</,#7*"L
' X!M#,H I3+#5K,#a5X!M#,H I3 5
H I3,KD6D /!N35$m#(^28L'#-"#
K#<L/5=2_5<.#+0(B3+3ua/#+#5.!Q
B21RYH;TUI+345'&?m&/D5S4'_5KN5d#2+# "#
'_k&M# 3ML;XL #5K+f8Y/w"#$-"BXyXU5
S4 r $52, N5d# KN5d# 2# a/#, ',$ 0( B
BD S/4 C -i ,# 0 Iu + X!? ax6L K8? -45
5 N5d# 2+# 4 , I" VL u [ ,i a/#
K+S5N5d#2+# 4WX g^-PL23
=3" 5 E- N2f.#= 5H9 7; X; 2 ,3^
- -5 + BD IS4 8L K+3/# TU A"4
2+# 4$.m^W.4N$HU&I4X;TUGH5K3".
QX;#TUo?;K1"H$ RD7|B8V45N5d#
+#5 8!JS4 TU : .# +#} 3L5 GH ,# p28, #52" - TU

EF
= -= 5S4 = &., 8-K 4 TU GH !y $.
=&3"# 2V45 hS4$ +f8/# A+"/# K.-# 3"YC5
B=3" 0 11"=Y+&#5KN5d#[< 47|B5 HI"JC
KA+"/#2y4Z(;8[B+#=,?'C2V45+1Y

"! # #$
5 W<; -# , .*L P!.!# +# "! #
PHI"JC;
X;-5 KE+&Y9F P-#$CUb/$;
^ +,i!.5&###,U^NW&y+#5.P+
2V4^+#5.oDM"45K-#HI"J#$3"C5(#+3Q
3Q 2, 0 1 BD )*&#, &#'5 2f.# #
l/# B Z #
7+3# RD lLz < <K "# #2D5 # +!/"# NH / p29
K+-+&'#H$ 5+J(9

&'(# %
qH& 3L5 N$H +U =5H; '4 TU )*&# p28
J$ # 05/"45 K+ -# ^ 0H&"# 2D J5 HI"JC
W+#"#0 IS#0(BM3#
: ; v( +# : 9 ^ +#&= 3"# -". Yd# IS#
, 3"#= C2- 2V4 TU =Y+&# W45 K=!-#5 <.#5 789
KP#5.5PI"B22-#JWd 5?23-#0( *

EF
0V4 C5 =$|; +MJ 5 K+#= 3" +MJ 05/" )#d# IS#
X;TU=$2#W45 KHI"JC$|g58"+D50 102EBWd#
P, IS# , -v &., PHI"JC5 P+Y Y3#& ;
3D d{ +M3#
X# BD o" C # LKn P,5 GHI"JC a/# K
0V C c [ 23/# X; CU < #= 3" $"Y B 7O#,5 KN35
K,;IS#-".5KG+S/"#Z ".RD5Hy9Z ".RD!fJ
KHI"JC+1/#B=3"!#N2J/#5N2Au
X; P&5 B HI"JC oJ 05/" <,# IS#
^ > OWO; Y;CUGHI"JCa/#KY yB7O#, '_
BD S/4 C jYy XU5 84# H4 C # 3 h Y; B h Y 5 K.SY
WO5 # &3 P, V++!"# $+- IS# J/ !y KD5 0!D9
K+#<S"4#+fI1=5H9-,##x35# &3
W-5 - 22*"# R-.5 $m# +MJ 05/" _ IS#
h /!$m#X;IS#P&5KWd#$m#5W.+#$m#P,V++!"#+D ?
. PL'# 21; &. )+` Sv 8Y; 8+D m #H&
IS# 05/" !y K NHK5 VL u 4 TU GH X;5 (}
B$+-4P&5,.#IS#_'^$+-5$m#$+-P,J-#
31C
2".+G#~9#Kh ? !#+##B!?
KN$H+#=5H;5=A"/ '"#
B=A"/' 4 +#;5+#2/cqH&05/" ~H.#IS#
KU$ l/

EF
+=5H9BH2Dx35a *"#/J/<,.#IS#
2J5K+?0 IS#^j3&#qH&9^? #58/#
[}< +&#5 ,$M +"! # H 3D 7; =5H9 j
0;~ $ # ^ +# K,; j#5/4 !y 7.#5
K=!-#TUL?,2f-## +.#
KAf"Y7;5)*&#({B!M"Bd#IS#

#*) #+ ,
Yd#< +,$ ^ V+ m#, )*&# v; $2v
BWdy=2L;2J5K+3,#2-,+,-#./#H2D;2,7|
./#H2DUP1;8"-[5v#2;,,X!dD$ "y2# 4
CUv9_'<5X !M)+1BS"4+,-#./#X;<5K+,-#
J/5 -# ^ ; > M"34 +,-# ,"#L K{ 3,' j.+# 8Y;
NS#0IU 8/#^p2c5KV+m#RM"3m+*"#5
KX$2J!+m#5*?5N$&-,q$3#

-./0
B5N2D= /Z2RD=$ &4)*&#8/!M4#$}BWdy
D#YE^Pd1,5N4;<=J/5=3#B22-#0(
BK2+345+Up$I^P+S/45r(<5GHI"JCYE5

EF
<+^#= /.#rD78/=2L;By;$M*"-I#
KWd#,7cB 20 19
6;5 K$2"#5 *&# 28- ^ fV# B2 Y; !y
2;+&1KHD2+X!KHX(:$KHWN (v I(
x,MS4RD2;,,X!dDKH#,w(;!yK!+3#784J/
/&#,/V_2:$2!"9M;6;5K)*&#GV+v9
RD /&#, +Y Y3# N$H $". 32v |2 KH5 +!/"#
&"^N (#Y/"A; X;CU;C5K23/#784J5784l1
|U^j!#5= -$HIWL 4^NV+!"7H 8[RD/&#
KNW&y[$2,)*&#
./#N3,MS4G#GI+L$$ "y2#+ML#,w(;!y
HI"JC ;` Vy -,$9 $ 1 B!? 8+D +-"#5 )*&# V+
Py$ N (< +!E 0 v #5 VV-# 2&D -
KVy,
H2D2+JD5lYL)*&#^ #5&H 8EB7O#,5
Xy!LK'_5 8.#5w3/#B&#Gx-x-HL!Dl!y
N28DRD 8L#2D5Y.1U5T-4MLB 8L> vB+L
G2 RD7#8[ #v(8y/#!D;-iX;05.
5K4#
K+&.# TUGHcT-4 5
+
JYUP9# $

E F

< <{^{{]<]{{]<l^{f{{{i

H2D^58[B+#: 9&=34^ *HHK?23-#286

W4Y #5
y2#$55X5YU=y6$+8YLKZ(;8[B+#$ #
>,4 ; K)2u $"#~ ^ LU =C1 ry; d WO5 0"+,y
L?,: 98,v_=Y+&#+D02+L8,?'5+#: 9
-, =6 !+L -".Y KI"(C; 5 r_= I4 TU
= /.#0(=&3"#RD8"#CH5=!-#5<.#5789:;
K+?ND!_

234 5
dy; j*&v; 8Y; CU NHD +#D 789 : X; B 7O#,
VY [ 5H 6 ^ >,"# d EF # K? 23-# 0( ,?'
K+978#
0( B >,"#~ +J B!+L K>,"#~ +3# 3 B dy; b/
+JdZ(;:b/5K-f#3'# 5G$+-pC02-
.Partnoy (2003) :>
#4 36(-.EF
300
250
200
150
100
50
02/07/2005
02/01/2005
02/07/2004
02/01/2004
02/07/2003
02/01/2003
02/07/2002
02/01/2002
02/07/2001
02/01/2001
02/07/2000
02/01/2000
02/07/1999
02/01/1999
02/07/1998
02/01/1998
02/07/1997
02/01/1997
02/07/1996
02/01/1996
02/07/1995
02/01/1995
02/07/1994
02/01/1994
02/07/1993
02/01/1993
02/07/1992
02/01/1992
02/07/1991
02/01/1991
02/07/1990

02/01/1990
+978#VY [5H6^=&3"#WEF0
djindexes.comW$2I

ElowF !+J RYH;5 EhighF !+J RD; P, :S# 8+L K5A" #
9 H2-,
KJ$ #^2"7"+G# $+-5K/+-216!#
6!#!+JRYH;5!+JRD;P,:S#02->.17"#RD/,5
&./#,
LL
LL NxS# #5 :O! +3# , ./
#
9 h ! >.1 7" 7| K{ 02-& 5 KVY [ 5H 6
E:O! +3# , ./F !+J RYH;5 !+J RD; P, :S# 8+L K5A"
KE/.#0(052"#;
H2DF+? N202-
.Sornette (2003) :*!" * DI >
#4 36(-.EF
250
200
150
100
50
02/07/2005
02/01/2005
02/07/2004
02/01/2004
02/07/2003
02/01/2003
02/07/2002
02/01/2002
02/07/2001
02/01/2001
02/07/2000
02/01/2000
02/07/1999
02/01/1999
02/07/1998
02/01/1998
02/07/1997
02/01/1997
02/07/1996
02/01/1996
02/07/1995
02/01/1995
02/07/1994
02/01/1994
02/07/1993
02/01/1993
02/07/1992
02/01/1992
02/07/1991
02/01/1991
02/07/1990
02/01/1990
K$ ,2YgH$2Y"6^=&3"#WEF0
finance.yahoo.comW$2I

0( * N$ I, <S4$ 2J >,"# 02- X; EF # B ?55
NxS# SL K=/+-."# f5, Y$3 #u X3# f5;5 =/+-."#( 5;
NxS#^Xy!/+, {>,"#02-Xy
BCB#

-#(5;^ *Sb/K
K"!.5;+"J5SCXyU
VE
+978#K$ ,2Y;H$2Y"6>,"#02-EF#P&
02-<S4$23LKVY [5H6P,5/+,,"#l1# 8.,B5KM;
NxS# ^ TU
NxS# ^ B
K
#4 36(-.EF
300
250
200
150
100
50
02/07/2005
02/01/2005
02/07/2004
02/01/2004
02/07/2003
02/01/2003
02/07/2002
02/01/2002
02/07/2001
02/01/2001
02/07/2000
02/01/2000
02/07/1999
02/01/1999
02/07/1998
02/01/1998
02/07/1997
02/01/1997
02/07/1996
02/01/1996
02/07/1995
02/01/1995
02/07/1994
02/01/1994
02/07/1993
02/01/1993
02/07/1992
02/01/1992
02/07/1991
02/01/1991
02/07/1990

02/01/1990
+Y'r#78#V40Y/S#6^=&3"#WEF0
finance.yahoo.comW$2I

6 ^ >,"# 02- P& G# EF # B # l1 B !y
<S4$ 23L K+Y'r# : .# ^ y6 ry; d G# V4 0Y/S#
NxS# ^TU
NxS# ^B>,"#02-
K

9)#4 5
6 5 <.# VY [ 5H 6 ^ >,"# 02- EF # P&
J'# $HI5 05x&#! 4 <.# B D Y B D /" B!M"
E{F +D/I# XH- EF /+!d# XH- E6 B &./,F
KWO5E{F
*#E{F> &u
#4 36(-.EF
160
140
120
100
80
60
40
20
30/06/2005
31/12/2004
30/06/2004
31/12/2003
30/06/2003
31/12/2002
30/06/2002
31/12/2001
30/06/2001
31/12/2000
30/06/2000
31/12/1999
30/06/1999
31/12/1998
30/06/1998
31/12/1997
30/06/1997
31/12/1996
30/06/1996
31/12/1995
30/06/1995
31/12/1994
30/06/1994
31/12/1993
30/06/1993
31/12/1992
30/06/1992

31/12/1991
<.#VY [5H6^=&3"#WEF0
djindexes.comW$2I

k ",.#
+#&./#,6Wm4K5#
9 h !#P&5
d{ +? N2 h !n> .1 7"5 K{ 5 /+-# Wm"#
0(3"#v" hS4$C#B8l5K/.#^052"#;
H2D
RD|;5NW(9:-#>1TU#ZV-2J5K+?DD.!_
KNxS,#&J;2,=&3"#^NHV#B#kS/#$-;
NxS# ^ B >,"# 02- hS4$ # ? 5

RD02b/ +#5K
NxS# ^TU
KCS

#4 36(-.EF
180
160
140
120
100
80
60
40
20
29/06/2005
29/12/2004
29/06/2004
29/12/2003
29/06/2003
29/12/2002
29/06/2002
29/12/2001
29/06/2001
29/12/2000
29/06/2000
29/12/1999
29/06/1999
29/12/1998
29/06/1998
29/12/1997
29/06/1997
29/12/1996
29/06/1996
29/12/1995
29/06/1995
29/12/1994
29/06/1994
29/12/1993
29/06/1993
29/12/1992
29/06/1992
29/12/1991
29/06/1991
29/12/1990
29/06/1990

29/12/1989
$C52#b$ +Ye+6^=&3"#WEF0
nybot.comW$2I

6!#4 5
=!-# B
; $C52# - ^ >,"# 02- EF # P&
hK "45KENew York Board of TradeF$A"#b$ +Ye+6L5+#52#
E{F Y'r# +/E E{F P# EF 5$ +# P, .#
G. .# YS#5 E{F 2 .# Y5# E{F G2/# $C52#
KE{F
!+JRYH;5!+JRD;P,:S#8+LK5#
9h !#P&5
N2 2" h !n5 K{ 5 /+-# 02- :O# , ./
EF#B8l5KD.#$2RD=!-#:!; -4)+1+?
#4 36(-.EF
^
;>,"#02-,2J5K
2-,v(3"#NHK
K
NxS# ^,!/+,
NxS#

EF+/<
+#: 9&=^3"#

?

?

0@

VY [5H

K$ ,2YgH$2Y4

V40Y/L

<.#VY [5H

$C52#6
Wm"# 02-."1N AS#~+JK

5
P,Y$35
B/s+-#;2&4
K-.# ^+#

#4 3A%B
*5K8+#U$ +#: #>,"#=C2-EF052Ew
jYyNl#5KhS4$C5HHK#
-#C ? ,052EB
W&_##$6;!y=/+-."#k5;/Pz5PHI"JCB
!"
X ".Y,^HI"JC;"X5y0 ,D2J5 KB"YW,x+,p5-
Bernstein (1996), p. 329.
#4 36(-.EF
-#HI"JCX;P&423#W# 3,WO5+g:6|$y2-, 4Gg

U5
, YNVf[RDVfuV"+A+"oK [;KBlY/yNdy;&v;

(b/W# 3,v23L3,#52#/&#+f$fY5HI"JC^
K-##
l/#^
$H *".4 5 Nl# $5 o34 X; B D N2D b/
C; E- N2f.#= 5H9 7; Z21U 05/"/ //# K3".
K=3"5

Krugman (1999), p. 154.

Stiglitz (2003), p. 54.

J
E F

< <{^{]<l^{{j{{]

$ v86;B5+#0H&4TUp284H 3DEderivativesF=3"
+1/#B KEswapsF=M35EoptionsF=$+"(C5EfuturesF=+&3".
N$2[ dy9 p'# TU 3"/4 )+` 0H&4 7" X; xS l/#
+!-# S" X; N$2J J9 p'#< +'". +D5 Kc!"1 RD N$2J5
!Q ,333G#2f-#BN$2Jdy9p'# 2+S".!/+,+["Y
+3*"# + #= 3" X 4 X; lY xS m# c5 K
K<K 4^NH /NS#
^ EspeculationF LKn= 5H; 7; .SY jJ #= ^ 3" B#
4xX;BPI"5P&JBWdyJWd 5K+#: 9
P, 02E dy c5 K8+34 B C
2, N[ $H hS4$ B # RD
^ P+Y Y3# 5; PHI"JC B +#= 3"!# P?$-5 B2
K2+3"#D/I#
K,9 NVyJ/7|8!A15=3"-+&'# V[ ov5!+L
K#"#IS#8*!Lh ? !#+#;KP3S#lY=8[5

6-"EF
6-"(
#H&8"-+&',=3"X;P3S#BPI"lY=8[5S"4H4
+& RD K(} p'# . PL'# 21; ` )+1 Sv
#$2+S# a+"1C n ,.# +f# X&./[ XCg I 0d

!-#)+1B=3"W# 3, =3"!#B2K,;21;59
,# PL'# 219 +J .#! +3# ^ N$._ 2-4 )+1 Sv &-#
K(}p'#J .#
3Y 8, H C 8Y9 +3+31 #H& 2-4 C =3" XL &.# c5
.4 RD 7D9 O9 ^ 9 I"3 , :3"6C v9 +
X;2=+&3".: ^0d+&RDK23-#8Y2/D$-9=J5L
=2_e+ X;2##5 K[90 1&J8" .47"H 3-#B
contracts for
F =J5S#RDH 3D8Y,=3"p-4+Y',^+#
KEdifferences
v97+.45+3/#-Lp284#H 3-#X,2+y"#78B
X;TUN$6$2!yK=3"!#o-"#(^24C[92/D2J-"#
^ ;2&) +1 B (2 C E
d 789F +# : 9 ^ G$ S# 0H&"#
p 2J-"#{
U HA PL'# JD 8"YC SI# #H& o-4
6XU4+5K23-#N20 PL'#JD8+L!".4#=3"
K31C'3/#0 12V
Greenspan (1999).
Pilbeam (2005).
Financial Services Authority (2005); Swan (2000), p. 11.

3
6-"EF
Over-the-counter
Organized exchanges
350
300
250
200
150
100
50

199806
199812
199906
199912
200006
200012
200106
200112
200206
200212
200306
200312
200406
200412
200506
EF!l/5EF1 "S: 9=^3"!#+C!+3#WEF0

bis.orgW$2I

6-"2D,
!l/: 9W+#: 9BPD Y^ !D=3"0H&47"
EF # KEover-the-counterF 1 "S : 95 Eorganized
exchangesF
8l5KEnotional valueF=3"8,-"4#0 v#+#!+3#P&

BJ;Bj-S4$)+1=3":; 7Au<.#oDM"##B
jSDM48Y;G;X +4 Bdy;TU
^$C5HX +4
Bh YG; 1K5A" !/#5 K= / BJ;^ =|
KZ(9+#0 v9

.
K L
M !G %N
& =!O * 8 ) !8
P Q RAN > L
E
6-"EF
6-"4 E .
XL N2*"= C # ^ 23/#& J " +#= +fI1# 3L5
8, H # 4 B Wd, ry; =LKn B!? o/I4 #= -"#& .Y
end
F P+f8/# P-"& J B

2".4 =3" B { b/8L Ka *"#
B { Vyx4 !/+, +# WO =y# 5; =. 75 Eusers
GVy/&#3L55 KNW&#b /&#5+# =+&#5N!.#Z2#=-"#
P-"<7"4!l/WO=3"=^-"#BBJ;XLY9
K#h'3#$(P+f8Y
K+#= .5 b /&# B +J H2D ^ Vyx4 =3" : X; !y
!+3#BRD'+.4$b /,.XL23/#&J"3L L
=.X;TU=$2#W4!yKN2*"=C #=^3"!#+C
< -"4 #y 8L 8/+, !+L -"4 8Y y < : .# RD '+.4 #
."# = +,5 E=v$ &#F : 9 SY ^ bx45 !-# 6 SY
KEclearing housesF

(Futures)6(-")
)+`",|5N21 =Sv= G;+'[gH 3D=+&3".

7+.4RD:S4CB!M"4$52,[}H 3-#K+#: .#^c5248.
K|2*".e+6j.+#R/-8,5K&3".$4^NH2=Sv -
OCC (2005).
Bundsbank (2003), p. 37.
Group of Thirty (1997).
J
5
/
6-"EF
X; !y K$&"DC 8,

[g 23D 2s - 3S# ^ p5- 7.# 23-L
U$E=F#
28D/L5-Xy7.#23D0524
K+# 83L 8+D wY # a5# L5
-'# WO B <+& Xy
KM;|2*".H 3D2-4CR/-8,=+&3".L
P,5 # 3S# L5 052" 7.# P, X [ XJL 2[ B#
W2J-"#a56)+1B
+#d2u=+&3".
K=+&3".^B!d#W(47"!/+,7.#^B!d#+A-4ax6 K
:5S, ."# K C5 [9 0 1 2/D <+& 7+.4 > [5 K
<!; 5W("#5?S"#<23/,23YTU0548Y9$-9
KD6QRD

$-9:5S, ."#TUp284#d2u=+&3".!#!l/: 9
a/# ^ 2J N j.+#5 N(" &31 ^ =Y 7+."# X5H
^X,+#^j.;Y52$HIL5h /#B: 05;5KGHI"JC
Chicago Board of F
O+6^N$A"#e+j.;

D^K
: 9#2-,j#"47| K>m#=^+&3".!#!l/: 0 5;ETrade

=+&3".05247"K-#^5N2*"=C #BZ(;By;^+&3".
789 B $ I4 B y RD , .*L <.# RD +#
+#
KWO5=&3"#5=65=!-#5=2/.#5
.'

R.
Teweles and Jones (1987), p. 8.
www.cbot.com (12.2005).

4
6
6-"EF

(Options)6$"
F
e+6 +# +#
$ ,3 23-# ^ $+_ ax6 XL ;2&) +1 B
>'_ B, !D S+_ BD H$5 2J5 2J p5- 23D X ,-#L K22[
X ,-#B#K/ &J,-"#$JU/D?$E=F
$+"(Y;ov #+D:2IXy,$-9RDLKA!#
2".B
KEreal optionF3+31
^
Hx.; ^ -f6 Xy $-9 RD LKA!# =$+"(C
2"
2, < =$+"(C= 8 N2*"= C # ^ KGH+ D <,.# X3#
# $+"(
2" !y KD <"# X3# f5; ^ 789 $ 8
RD pS"## D <"# X3# oI"/ ^ Eput-call
parityF <+&# $+"(5
B Gx 3 Xy )+1 bYg N2f.# Eusury
lawsF ,# PY
789RD #$+(-+&7|Eput optionF H#$+(<!8;x3

KN2fS,?J+IuX 458.SY
^ $+"(C W-.4 m+v jS"y X; TU H52 =$+"(C 0524
=$+"(C052"# O+6: 8+L""L#8.SY/.#5
C52" # $+( &v; )+1 EChicago
Board of Options ExchangeF
.)
R

Al-Suwailem (1999).
Sullivan (2005).
Chance (1995).
. !%
R U7 ! D( C

3

J
6-"EF

DTU,!.#(423LEput optionF<+&#$+(;KNW&y[$2,
K+90: e+B3+JH,J$<

/+ ,+G
N$ v ^ D <"# X3# ^ $ 8 f5; / =3"= $|;
:S# Z25 8"+D5 0 1 02E B Wd# =$+"(C5 =+&3".
H 3-# X; RD w/ Xy X Y3#L KY YJ h /! $!3#5 X# P,5 8/+,
8Y;-.#:L.1 ."#U5P#2&#7+.48L;2I3C#}[
KY YJh /!X#B8Y9NLYWO
, H 3-# X'&, M34 +9 7yz B Wdy -[ 5
7yz Z21U jA 0d +& RD

D ^ KN2, 8845
W!y=3"B8SJ
R!.4!y=$+_5; =+&3". ^-"#X; ? ,ZYB
lY^,-4 : .#&=34~;RD8" .47"4#5NHD
XUK-#+.#<$-"N2D>&;B!?YU)+1
-#X Y3#
~/#NH-5
-#L#[`#52#[ [`-"#
$A"#= - y ` [ YU 7| :(95 B2#[ ` 5
De+'(2+y"#,$!3#B h /#& v;2J5KD5$!d"C5
PY 3# Z2*"4 ,
l/# <M C 8/# '.#5 N5d#5 [ #, x."4
www.cboe.com (3.2006) ; Sullivan (2005).

Kreitner (2000), p. 1103.
5
/
6-"EF
-#PY Jj&3Y.#W|4&.,5K .#RD &#55!.#

KX LKn8+L7*"#0 97Au<M: .#j*&v;5'#5
^
-#CX;CUoJ R/&"47yzyB4Y;B7O#,5
B Wdy ^5 K */# RD Xy D <"# X3# B 059 oI/#
3SI#^l/#G; /#$&"(TUA47yzjYy=Cu
RD/H5;LY23-#&I+L7+."#X2I3XL'#XyU5
K
,23-#&I+L$-9=J5LRD ."#7|B5-.#
$2vU RD 9 ~ #
s u =C5 N2D b/ jYy 2J5
B#X D$V=CuBWdy^$5o3Xy5=3"</<4
0( B =LKn BD /# : .#&= 34 B $M4 =eS# dy; Yy
W# 3,=3"RD~ #MD;21;D
^K=3"
X;52-4C#5=+&3".5 =$+_^ X -"B#C
C5-# e+6X S+M CKVS"J;,j+!!8 $!JX 4
, <LY O G; X 33 C 78Y; !y b8"C RD '# X -A
R!. +L X5[" B#! 3# K+!5 =A"/ RD X LKi -# RD
^CU|;!C5 ~ .WO5 fWO 8L 5OC5 #!J
KH&#^D$V#h'3#,83*#N2$|}
.Kreitner (2000), p. 1110 :)I

G V !7N!
Swan (2000), p. 219.
.V ! !7

Freeman (1993); Saber (1999b), pp. 201-202; Swan (2000), pp. 217, 245; Santos (2004).
Teweles and Jones (1987), p. 11.

4
6

6-"EF
V#VY [G/ ~mY #^p$I/E+f$ 2 ?uI-#^5

je6+D'4X;B W# 3,=3",-"# oI
^
K$!JR!.,"y^/#5
CUD<"#X3#0(=3"j-/+9=C #BWdy5
$- oJ X; jJ # $5 < 2,5 K
!". </ X;
0(B!l/: 9^8,-"#$JUX;TUo-M;2,=3"!#
oI"/ 2-, : 9! D 7+l/"# ~ # $2v; #= -"#
A8/$+-5;!D~;RD+/&+#<"#B#KB-#X3#
8[ B D5 $A"# P,5 8[ B $!3#5 X# P, :S
X;#/yK/"yG5$X Y3#r(21;#,I!yZ(;
!.# XL c5 KA8/ k,? X5H =5H9 < -"# J; X Y3#
XHD XI6 2J-4 L !l/ : 9 RD lY I"3 H 3-# 8,
0VCX Y3#XL7+."#2IJS"Y[<g#H&RD: 9$(
KNLYWO-r"-
Y Y3#oJ j/&4#+052# -, Î1M;5

D R"1 X Y3# L5 D / =+&3". jYy
d I SL K=3" B
U Y$ r"- /# !l/ : 9 ^ c52", P1
K: 9$(j{
Steinherr (2000), p. 151.
Freeman (1993); Santos (2004).
Kreitner (2000), ftn. 28.
.562540

3

J
5
6-"EF

HIJ"KF+G
b/8LKM;8+LX HI"JCo"(=3"^X +Y Y3#o"(!y5
78.47|B5NSyN$ I,0H&"##-L=5H;8Y;Z58/D<L2B
!D /&" oJ 5 KGHI"JC L# Z ". KV-45 +["Y< L$ ^
BYLHI"JCp9+DR?xX;5: .#NS,X /B#
K+#*I37|
|; B 2J/# oJ PHI"JC K,; B H2D o3 ,3^ 5
$5H&O23"/"yG#V/+yCf5;B5KGHI"JCH9=^LKn
W0 350;~$:^; PLKn
a/# $+4 RD D3L H Yy U $? PLKA!# X C 2J
H .SY GHI"JC a/#& v; U o" <? # B# KGHI"JC
A+"Y H&# ^ 0;~ $ /, &I 2/D K+#=LKn 5H RD D3L
K:S(,1!8XL /K#!-#+&Y[
^ , Y NVf[ RD Vfu +#g $ "y D P-& */, 2-,5
X 4&6;8Y,##8SI5+#: 9=^LKn23"/HI"JC
v I([ "=LKA!#[ 23/#5 K!?$!J= /K,
+#g 3 P1 ^5 K
- !y LKn= 5H; K,;5 7; 8Y9 =3"!#
YL+3+3u<.#v(a *"#O9EforwardsF0[} h +,+!,
.Financial Economists Roundtable (1994) :
G "
Keynes (1936), p. 159.
Allais (1993), p. 35.
/

4
6-"EF
!y K=2/.#5 789y +# :$5# &./#, H 3-#! +J ^

K8-/i$-9=6RD=LKnX;$3
K0!D95 0 0[$ TU 2-" , PHI"JC RD 23/# I"3 C5
^!d".86;5-#[^$R/O;Y|j+L,X$5WCK,;B5
B f+"5 23Y BD &/ B dy; ^ rD 23L K+9 789 :;
HI"J#5 8, P-"!# 4 J ,/J 8Y, 88&6 # +#= 3"
X; B =3" X; Z5 K# $2# +# *; 8Y,5 !D
N$ I# X;5 y : .#5 HI"JC= /!# 7A1 oDM4
K; 9 A"45N'(52&4+#
^=y#ZryZ21Ux+#U0/[y6X;2Z(;8[B5
0",yGU[+#'Y9,w"-,4y6"{N2*"=C #
^y#w/4K+9p$I7l-c v;7A1^: S4NW(95
<'M4 0",yGU[-,"#8"y6C5C8Y;

D34
B (g h Y G; C5 =3" : D/v ^ 5; =3" ^ N[",
K=LKn

9L ./6-"
"Y,3-"<K "##-L+58Y;=3"BDX -L2Z
+3Q B =y#5 =. B!"4 )+` GHI"JC a/#5 <K "#5
Allais (1993), p. 37.
Buffet (2002), pp. 13-15.
Partnoy (2003), p. 380.
36
3
3
6-"EF
+L$ Z ". 3 5 RD; NSy5 ML; N$ I, +["Y 8L2;
B p " G# h$V ## G2+3"# 0d5 K !D HI"J# ML;
<B#K0 IzB+Ly=+!yD$KBD-/2J0 Iz$-;=&34
RD $2J; B TU 83Y B w"# / =+&3". H [5
3 "Y Z ". <L$ 7| B5 EspeculatorsF X LKn 75 8!Q
RD!-4#RD/,=3"LKGHI"JC(#5 L#BRD;[$H
K+L?U/4C8/#<K 4
P-L2lY^8/#23-#Z ".RDSvjYyXU5=3"5
7| B5 RD j&m4 U =.5 =y# +["YU <L4 8/D
K+,iU+f8/#IzX "
K+*"#8SmZ(;Y[ TUX5W=3"!#B23"/B#

6-"!# MN! -#
+["Y< L$ ^ 78.4 8Y9 +,iU =3"!# +f8/# +Iu X, 0 3#
&/[W.4=3"jYy #*+*vX X;BGHI"JC(#7|B5
=3"7A1X;9<J5B#KN5d#/3+3ua/#</[TU
B J; B )+1 +? = /.# 0( = | B dy; oDM4
!y
^ X +4 B dy; TU
^ $C5H X +4
5 K3+3uHI"JC=D'JBh'JG;^H 8WO 5&
Spence (1997).
.LiPuma and Lee (2005) and Chorafas (2003), p. 144 :>
33
3
6-"EF
m# EF / ry9 VE , 3+3u HI"JC* I B !/#
GSI#YEX;-5K3,.#=+fI1+D024!y=LKn
a/#, w" ,i YE B Wd, ry; &v; =3" d{ G#
K234yRD+,iUj.+#+f8/#IzL+D5K3+3u
P,5 0H&4 P, IS4 #= 3" -+& # ^ &.#5
7Q# k, M#<MC0H&4-iIS#K3+3ua/#
0H&4 XU )+15 K4+M"3 3L55 4K W. C 7| B5 3+3u a/#
BRD;02- !/+.L3+3ua/#7Q#H +3#,&MYJ;
~5$03"Y#RD4x5K&!y<J # 5N5d# 02-
!y A"/ WO SI#= LKn 0 TU "/ 3+3u 0n B 0 9
KLKnY[&m#[$HhS4$N$5M#,#RD4x

!OP Q$-#/ (R#S
8L 8!Q RD $2J9 p'# TU 83Y 7" X, 0 3#; 5
N$23#P,5!Q^&O#P,G [:Lb/8LKj`GlYxL
!QÔ$Y;$ C=3"^pKnp'#LK#RD
/!?##$6;!y8!QRD-S#,$HJY;N$5M#,-CB#
XU W0J P1 #$2+S# +"1C n ,.# +f# X&./[ XCg
782# B# e#5; TU 3Y ~; RD !fJ " 1C /"$
XL 0u -+&',5 K8!Q RD N$23# 782# X; xS5 &O#
Greenspan (2002).
3J
6-"EF
^ &O# B PLKn B 2[ U N$5M#, 33Q

V C xLC
K8!QRDN$2JJ9Y y<!Q
23/#+Y}[uLpKnp'#?1(H2# 4=3"X;)+15
A+"/#X 45K# +.#w3Y&.,c!"1<+'".C!*"#-L242J
p- 5!QRD$vUdy9 N$2JJ9X;
p2c +3Y TU GH4 KEadverse
selectionF .-# 3"YC

-y !y5 K8!QRD$2J9p'#TU83Y 5=3"!#B-
moral
F +J(9 X6 8Y6 .-# 3"YC XL
5NS#w3Y5= -=5S48x-#: 9^/4Ehazard

K4+!y: 9RD#m#

/SJT#
0 v9+P,5P,IS#RD=3"S.L
34
0 v9 B 3" U =3", 8"+!.4 $5 &.# 5 K
#HI"JC$|}BTUGHIS#K8"+B!M"4C8/#
Ka *"#+5X 4X;02,'#$2I=3"-
w3Y 7| B5 = -= 5S4 IS# RD 4x 05;5
8+L pI"# RD 0u -+&', $2J; 0 v9 G# p'#L KNS#
X; X5H "*! 8L pKn p'# ; 84 ^ 7*"#5
R!.4 #= 3" # 0d K0 v9 3 pI"# RD N$23#
3X;/&#+"4# Ecredit default swapF ~LM3
6-"EF
KP"#= y6 &#O 5 (g p'# 83/5 2# P?x3~ LU
B7RDp-"#5P?x3-,"RD$2J;0u-+&',/&#B#5
RD N$2J J; EP"# y6F (} p'# -i 5 P"# y6
P?x33"Y^/DJ;/&#-iY;!y KP?x3^7*"#
0H&4 X; - 5 KL5- +J(9 5 78"-,"5
KSCTU8/hS4$CTU>J;5N'+.#BD2-,;8-i
~;$: =^; -=5S40 1NWd#=$2#,2y"4A+"/#
X; =$2# +!; jm, 2J5 K# RD 4x NS# w3Y5 0
78|`; 3# PHI"JC K,; B |d#

D , Y NVf[ j*/
oK [ 2y; 2J5 K0n ^ D P|| Z2 RD M+S".
2+3"#l/#P,NW&#N AS#RDNVfE,5KLB#21;V"+A+"
G#<J #P,5: .#NSy7|B5= -L 4xS4#HI"J#
K8fH;5: .#NSyS7|B5845S45= -Wdy|"
-i= -{|5: .#NSyxLRD!fJ=3"S.L5
xLC Xy U5 KNS# RD +& $|g G; B!M" C 3Y
M"3 0H&4 XL = -{| C RD NL " #H9
HI
K[$HhS4$7|B5$-9 45: .#H;0"(N$5M#,

Partnoy (2003), pp. 380-381.
.George Akerlof, Michael Spence, Joseph Stiglitz :'
Stiglitz (2001).
35
3/
3
6-"EF
UV+ O
B# K8.SY^ -TU8 Q-0 v9BDIL
N$?-,8+D0 IuÔ#&=+'#Bj.+#-.#
8+34iXL<!"nlY8[5BK.#=S/#,X 4&6;
0(B,BH [5-,(: HiUB#5K21RYH;TU
X9 5: .# <4C*IBXL#yXyU5K8,N["
B2VM"3: .# <4B#5K7c&./#,,#LB2V-
K8M+S5+34 5v9p2c^/5#52"
NW3S#052#^BL24X;0u8,8"/Wdy.#=S/#X;!y5
Î1!y+/#052#8/]<L2X;0u8,8"/XL+/#5
.SY'/5K+g:605H5+/+4#;05Hj,v;#+#=K9
B $ 8!E 8/# ^ B] <L2 )+1 21 # 2&# RD &'/
B84HKTUGH-TU"* L K+#: 9^P-"
KZ(;8[B8-K 4 58[

*%J
$ I#h Y;R",8&+y4NHDU5+3+3u0 v9BDILXU
8/!M"4#2f -#5&+y4X;-=3"^0u! y
$34 !y +3+3u 0 v9 8/!M"4 # 4 BD [ o" =5H9

34
6
6-"EF
^8L K,$59GVy/&#G+S/"#n MDW[ [&{#

B#5 K=3" ^ P-"& O$ .` YU 7" -/'I &+y4 3+3u
c v C Earbitrage
opportunitiesF +`# L K5, -4 &+yx#
=3": 9II0 9~5$X;-5 K3+3uHI"JC,

K["Ya/#,2",cvC?-&I4
$-;^(,5;,|4X;c#BDe6/#=LKnXU)+15
3+3u $!d"C L 0"( TU GH W|"# XL3+3u 0 v9
0 v9 BD 2", 3". 2f -#5 !# &+y4 B =Y =LKn X9
K+3+3u

2KT.
# h Y9 H521 b/ +L 0 v9 BD jISY U
/+- 2Y 3Sv
{U RD B4 =3" b/8L K8+D / B
3'##1RDB4WO5/+-y#Y!"fCo+/I"#RDZ(;5
X 4X;B=3"X;!yK# 5 NH2NxL0(b$ +Y/2^
=$+"(b/8LK+3+31 0 v;BN6&+#5Z(;=3"B3"
=$+"(CRD=$+"(5=$+"(CRD=+&3".5=+&3".RD
$-;=6RD8/#^2!"-4X;B&y=3"y5 KU
Tumpel-Gugerell (2003).
Saber (1999b), p. 122.

6-"EF
? 5 K+h Y;Bh YG;B!M"4X;X5H/+-:&=; 345;

K3+3uHI"JCBD2+-,=3"$ '"4X;B21G;TU
DBH +Jdy;5 2+3-4dy;0u-+&',3+3uHI"JCXU)+15
v_4BRD;=C2- !/4=3":; XLG2A"#
N$6 j3& #= +fI1 ? , # P&4 !y +3+3u 0 v9,
["Y h'3#> .1 RD CU 3*" C 0u -+&', !/# XU K8+#U
+#=LKnh'JTU3+3uh'3#BH$ 50 9~5$3"/4)+1
8,/"[B!BXy?-&I4H$ XL#: L5K"*&#
N2*"=C #&^9+#K5KY$ #$6;2J5 K2&#B
=C!"1B2VN3NVOh&6+#: #X/-#:UX;TU
+#: 9XLE /K#F$!3#=CI#L(Y;#5K|$#h J5
G# 3+3u HI"JC XL +D5 [$_ -# BD 8IL B C
KB!d#<L2+

Q/EW#
BDBV#ILW&y21TU&+3+3u0 v9BDNILXU
KN215 !-# X8[5 ! , XK" N5 BV#L K3+3u a/#
BV#ILXL=3"0(B7"0 v9BDILXyU5
TU GH IL X; !y5 KN2fS# 0( B 7" 3+3u a/# BD
Summers and Summers (1989); al-Yousef (2005), p. 83.

3

6-"EF
K8+DN2fS#oDM45X 2#oDM4TUGHBV#ILXL8SDM4
-=3"XLLM!+3#p-?; !"#S4-N2fS#X;!y5
3#X X;#2-,&O+#5K+["Yp-?;S4
K+#=35=LKn! /#N2D. -#K,;BN2fS,

QX(#I 3Y K
< /4^78.=3": ^LKn :'Yh.4XU 03 X;B!B
U *+*v X 2J 5 KP-"!# # +.# WL 45 2++Q5 : .#
B#5KNW&#H2D9X YJ &'"!y8M-,BD3".jYy
+#U &Y5K#BC2,oDM"42JXLa#RS"YU
H2D9X YJX, 0JP1HI"JC^, YNVf[RD Vfu5$g)+/+y
XL ',x X 4 X; TU +{ PLKn&= /4 jYy U WNW&#
#53*"C2J+f -#219+#3"RD2!"-G#X Y3#
KLKn>+O^+D ; ;<J #^X 2J<? #XL
["/"BC3".5;',xPLKn=LI4jYyU22Q5
X 3S" H X &J5 K$"# rD : 9< J5 0( B P&" , lY
^ +D jYy Wd, dy; k,x# H, A"4 +-# : 9 X; RD
^ +5#= 2/.# K;5
^ +g :6 K9 Xy 2J5 K?
P,k,#TUGH48"-+&',=3"5K+,m#: 9! ^$|g
Chapra (2004).
Arrow (1971), p. 24.
J
5
6-"EF
:52/v$+8YXy2J5KX, -I#B8,&/"#-iS": 9
: 9 A"4 X; B o+y TU ? , W E0"+,y
W4 Y #F a *"#
^XK" #RM"3BD2+-,215kRDW.45.SYC^NALS"
H2D9 X YJ&'"3".$&"DBC=3"!L K: 9
KNW&#
^ Eherding behaviorF <+'3# b Nl, p- # 2y 5
= -,'&4 -#BD !BD"/b .# K+#: 9
-#, k&44 C =$+8Y5 =D3L TU GH X; B5 +.S/# 0 +5
53".PLKnb $&"D-I#BYL #5K: .#+3+3u
##$6;!y+D ; ;<? #- X;TU>J;LKnX;-
K5$gPy

#Q
; ;<?5 ^HI"JC-X;BC8Y,=3"BDX -L2"
!21;.!LK(}pB3YRDI"348Y9+D
K+LvN$.(TUIz^GH4X;7|BBC5(}&.
|;$&"DC(^C+-"#X;TUX5W,3^B23"/B#
jYy U v( HI"JC' Y9L K# H9 RD SI#= CH&
=21 #P,',x=J-#B&6/4EleveragedFX!"fC,D L
Lowenstein (2000), p. 144; Partnoy (2003), p. 259.
Shiller (2000); Sornette (2003).
Slutz (2004), p. 186.
/

4
6-"EF
WORD|2J=21 # Z21U$+8Y-=J-#KHI"JC
-=J-#&LKN$8/N21 #,6&0I4RDB4 #R"1
K!#?Ddy;.SYjJ #^B#NSydy;HI"JC
N5d# XL N5d# N2# +,iU 'Y; HI"JC' Y9 jYy U5
=J-#BDe6/#+L?rX;BH-#0 19^+L?
dy;5 NSy dy; &I HI"JC X; #u ^ A+"/# X 45 K',x
K-Xg^$3"
+L?U N5| /4 C 8L Sv HI"JC' Y9 jYy U B#
CSI#=CH&RD7f3#HI"JCX;-5Ko-"#.`
k,4 &., e6/# +L? 0H-5 ri +L? N5d# B
- SI#= -"# X; M"3 5 KHI"JC= 21 # P, =J-#
K#Z ".RD$3"J;5('dy;HI"JC
b /&# B +J H2D ^ : .# Vy4 RD #2#= +fI1 X; !y
219 $+8Y G; X9 N +#D : .# -i +#= .5
B5P-"D !n:S(..40(B|$yTUGH+=.
=3": X;+-+&'#A+"/#LKW&y,N$._7A1oDM47|
BC2,: 9&=34NHK7|B58"+"S4BC2,V+y4TUGH4
K8M+S
:52/v p6; 2/-L K+# : 9< J5 C
U 2 A+"/# 5
$+ # v; 7A1 Xy5
^ $+8YC RD 0"+,y
W4 Y #
Steinherr (2000), pp. 190-193; Tickell (2000), p. 91.
J6
6-"EF
$C5H X +4 B dy; 8, -" #= 3"!# +C! +3#5 $C5H
2J G# W|"# +( a 3.# B -/ (2"# #$2+S# +"1C?'
XL #$2+S# +"1C #5. =I4 .`5 KHI"JC RD |2
XJoIY0(+#|$y; ;TUGHX;BXy:52/I#$+8Y
GHX;2[B!B;,'M:^; NAL:52/I#++.4X;5
N2D05H=HI"J,s2J-#0 1#?'>C 7JS4TU
f.( X; 7DV# XU *+*v +L KN2*"= C # HI"J # ^
05H HI"J, $ ?21 TU I4 2J , 23-# ^ K5A"4 C =3"
KN2*"=C #HI"J7A`8!y,

Z ")/HTJ#$
dy;CUSI#!lY95SI#=CH& XL&L?,5
W#5+,i!lY9BN
2!"- M-# 5; HS# b X; R/- .Y
lY GSI#
l/# K
NH2z+[$_ -#RDH!"DBdy;B(}b RDNW&y[$2,
+*v-#5B(},NW&y[$2,|" MDyXyU5KN5d#/&#
|)+1Efeedback loopF+.Dm431R!.YTUGHXL
7$52, 7 B# B(} b ., |4 0( B .SY RD M-# b

lYTU0 *"42J5 3".WOlYCU: .#&I4#,5K,X5|"
+(2# -#RD
l/#aSH!"DC&.,Echaotic systemFG ? L
Partnoy (2003), p. 261.
J
6-"EF
2y;2J5KEexogenous factorsF+[$_ -#Bdy;Eendogenous factorsF

KPd1&#5P#5.5r_BH2DR/-
^Wm4G;X;-8LSv=CH&8"-+&',=3"X;)+15K
8y: .#jYyU5KPL'#219N$.(TUN$5M#,GH+v9!+J
N$.(TUGHX;2,Cv9!+J^>,45;Wm4G;X;A+"/#L#y
.` !# ?-4 dy; =3" : .L KP-" B +J WO H2D
Ko-"#
v9!+J^S5;hS4$G;0d+&RD=+&3".SL
+*v WO B#5 K(} RD N$.(5 !219 `$ A. -.# 5;
+A-4 X; # K2J-"# 2/D
y B!d# +A-4 +L 7" G# 7.# &./#,
v(+L7.-=&34rihS"YC5PL'#hS"Y,!.B!d#
,3 B!d# +S", <S"/ GxL K/+- H521 B!? =&3"# jYy U
<S"/<f&#X;!yK-.#!+J^H52zSCr-S/5+A-"#
+L7.!+J^H52zhS4$Cri$52,hS"YC523B!d#&3,
H521B!?PL'#X;dB!d#+A-4X;G;K[90 12/D
`$X +!A1Xy!8-.#^Wm4G;XL=+&3".;^K/+-
KN$5M#,(}RDN$.(5!219
DeLong et al. (1990), Sornette (2003), Tumpel-Gugerell (2003), Mandelbrot and Hudson
J
(2004), Bennett (2004).
.R ! *7K % ' VI % !E % -"& = U 8! W

Al-Suwailem (1999), pp. 84-85.
J3
J
6-"EF
8.SY 8l4 Ecall option

d # $+"(F =$+"(C^ 5
^5K(#N$.(5PL'#219`$d!+v9-^Wm4G;X;)+1
hS"Y, !. Eemployee
stock optionF PS
!# 789 $+( XL ,3
d .SY ^ Xy XU5 78.# - hS4$ X9 o 5 y# PL'#
,$ A+"/# X "L o H; B.1 BD &#O "/ /# y# N$.(
K-PL'#
N5d# 2+# 4 BD #H& 2!D BD IS4 =3" XL ,3^ 5
8/#^GHVL uRD&|IS#X;&5K+["YNHK5
K=3"!#/-p29+3YTU
C N!".>`X &6;-=3" : .#SI#-+&'#K
X " MDG;:S(U=C!"1X;-5K: .#MD;P,8+LNH
SJ "X C:S(X;#5KSI#WO: 9^0u+Dry;
X5(} MD9 M; # ^ 78. , .*L +[$_ -# RD
,$ 721; N$.L KMD9 P, I ^ L/"#5 J/"#& .,
B(}* I jYy !y ry; N$._ 7A1 Xy !y5 Wm# N$5M#,
^ 0"+,y
W4 Y # :52/v $+8Y D 21; Xy 5 Kry; :S( B
7D5+#f.(B:52/I#RYD+5#=2/.#K;2-&LK
ry; 33*+#:52/I#2? /!# 8#, X5(}X LKn

v_ 781,$; +3Q 5; :52/I# $?U 7H I3 Xy 5 K/
Partnoy (2003), p. 260.
JJ
6-"EF
- # : .# SI# -+&'# 2y 5 KP#u ^ N215 A+"/#L

ry; :S(= C!"1 -i B(# `$ N$5M#, p N$.(
Kry;: .#7|B-i5

6-"!# </IW( %#

2".4X;B5a *"#
^2".4X;B)+1B=3"XU
$6;2J5K82"B8&1vH I3V+8"-+&^+#5LKn^
c !fH
2".4 C 2J +S =5H;5 =3" X; TU 5$g Py
5 K8, X53 ~/# B#5 N2 8YU K +S G; m#
2y45 K8M+SBC2,NHK^X !8. PLKnX;-
+*". B Wc 3, ,$59 GVy /&# B W[ [ &{ M; R/-
<K 4 TU p28 P,5 "` =/ 8"3+31 ^ #= 3SI# P, V++!"#
K3+3uHI"JC=+!DB!?H$
+"48Y9LKnTU8&1I,/=3"!#[5HV+v_B#5
2a *"#VL`Y$3,#VLuN J<5K=5H9B,xC#
LKnTU98,8"/a *"#=3"
2".4#=y#BWdy
2J5 KLKnf.(&.,=y#B !fJ$M4TU#ZH;2J5
2-,PLK X *&IPD$V 7l-X;52&W# 3,#BD78M-,rD
Lowenstein (2000), p. 174.
Saber (1999a), p. 111.
Arrow (2003).
Tumpel-Gugerell (2003).
.Bernstein (1996) and Partnoy (2003) :

G " >
J5
J/
J
J4
56
6-"EF
B&IX;SG J,#VL1XUKa *"#B 5;P"/

-L=3"$&"DBCYEB!LKLKnm#
2".4=3"
KN2

6-" #MI/,
C 8Y; CU a *"# j2" XU5 =3" X, 2+y"# 78 B
y^X#! y5=V"#B!M"4=3"H 3-LKB8.SY
+S/"#5 7+."#5 H9 d D /" RD G '/ YL
V"#
KU
5; N3#N 3#BDN3LNHDB!M"4=3"XL#TUL?,
K;5212/D4V"#B*"#
V"p'#+"4 #Eforce majeureF
2/Da *"#H 3D+#-L
2D.S2JKD: 9H284|$y5;
^ ,5#, 8Y H H2 +-4 j/D;5 ,5#! +J B +5$ jMS(
f. & +v; B!d". X; CU ,5# 2? a *"# B 7O#, K
=2/d Eflight to qualityF/}0 v9 $S#TUZH;1HL

7$52,K8/0 a *"#H 3DH4)+1+9 u
: # 2284 $+8Y d Xy G# 0"+,y
W4 Y # :52/v $ 24 ^
Chance (2003).
.Banks (2004) :
G " >
Steinherr (2000), pp. 89, 181.
5
5
53
6-"EF
^&"2Ja *"#W$8/"HS#;Î0 J21RD5KC

U+-#
K: #Hu?'>C=C1
+*". B B# NH2 2? a *"# =3"
2" B
a QY,{$9[5RDy62[ CKy2?a *"#
pI# XO$ , [ /, +f$ fY .+y XCg 0 3 !y
K/[9
marked to
F + 8!++34 7" !l/ : 9= ^ 3" XU )+15
X;-8L
y+D5;#<LHpyRDi)+Èmarket
CU a *"#! +J 8l4 C !/+, 05, C
5; 8" .4 7" f._ 5; ,$9
X X; i 2+S X +# a *"# 23D X; - 5 K23-# N2 0!"y,
w3Y#1^5 KNWIJWON2+Y}f._!QRDN$23#2+S".Z2#
KL2+3Q^S+23-#X;#m#L# +.#
- H521 B!? < -"# !!I 8"-+&', =3" X; !y
W|4dy9X 4&#O#5f$'#5;e[S;K3&.
8+D :2I =3" -i 5 K2? a *"# +YU $-" B!L
K'01'-"48/# *I#012+[!-4l8Y,+&"#


Sparks (2000).
:
G " > ) !N *! 9( YV 9 P!7 % )
! !N -! X?
.:V $

:!. )W % !GA# 'N !& (quotationspage.com; 12.2006
5
5J
55
5/
6-"EF
E] *#[9ME
: .# -i 5 EleverageF X!"fC RD !fJ 8"-+&', =3"
XCg##W!yHI"JC&=3"#,H285 !DHI"JC5+#
8"+#5.I"34C#u
^l/#X, I 8Lc5 KX&./[
Wo+M5K215_h'3#RD
DS"#
+e? C
!"1-!fH!EleveragingF Y!"fC< L#XU
$+8YTU8"/4=JS(B-,"". 5Echain reactionF.."#
B # GVy /&# 215 K# &J <? # +*I4 7" #
&J+!-#</W&y21TU<+'".23/#$2vNH52WO=+1v
KN2&I4X;
X " NHu 5; f$'#= Cu +#5. X; $3 8L # RD /,5
C= uXLZ(;N$&-,5 K
-#h'3#5_h'3#P,DK
CPLKnX;<J #5 K+#: 9^PLKn8/#"*!^4X;2,
#RD/,+`#k "5Sv: .#X9M-,78M-,BX `
!y = u8-L24#0 9` +!DLKn-iKSv
|$ G# .#| 9, X&./[ px-5 KV"+A+" oK [ ## W
BG#Emoral hazardFJ(9_',/Dr- 5 u(24
K('dy;GHI"JC ?<#-iX;Y6
Greenspan (2003).
Stiglitz (2002), p. 198.
Lowenstein (2000), p. 230.
5
54
/6
6-"EF

-# h'3# P,5 _ h'3# P, */# RD < K 4 XU
XU )+15 Kf._75,$9wI
lYY,0 3#+D:2I
X -. B#= .5 HL9 B $HI 2!".4 8/# = ^ u
J- /#5 PLKn L
l/# XL HI"JC /A"#
X;BC2&LKPLKn e#5;TU7 3Y2J78Y;xS B# $ 8!E
78/#^C&v;+["Y=.5HL9X LKn"*!
# HI"JC p-?, : S4 # PLKn X !*" B#
K8,/"[C$ 8!ER-.

6-"4 [Y/^/Y _#
PL'#21;.X;R/-Sv=CH&=3"X;B7O#,
K5."N$._5,#=C!"1X;-CX;CU(} `
=C!"1 X; RD =$+"(C5 =+&3".!# +fI1= $2# j#H 23L
J^NVy: .#X;TU<[&.# K,#=C!"1 Wd, : S4N$._
K+#UN$6j3&!y!M#+# =+&#5=.B
-[J)+1VY [5V +48,
J#4=$2#B
DN2=+&3".: ^NW&#N.!.# =+,21;Z2#>.1
=$2# +#U jv 4 2y4 f"/# jYy5 K
B 2", = /
B 215 / G; 0( pKA!# ,# 0!"1 k " X; B 3,.#
Stiglitz (2002), p. 209; Chorafas (2003), p. 135.
/
6-"EF
/+-/^,#X 33B# P, BY;XS#$235K-,$;

K+#""= /^H,,#+3Q78/k3L
v$ , =A $2, ! X [
J 23L =$+"(C H 3-# &./#,5
NS/=$+"(C,3-"EChicago Mercantile ExchangeF$A"# O+6
=8;5 K
= /.# EexpiredF +8"/ 45 EexercisedF
Y$3 Eout
of the moneyF !+3# N2JL +8"/= $+"(C& .Y X; f"/#
0H-5;TU 0H-4Ein the moneyF!+3# [&NS/=$+"(C,

!+J X5. =$+_ Gx +&#O X; G; K=$+"(C h ! B
vLX =$+"(C-f,X;- 5[90 12/D$+"(C
N$._= C!"1 X; P&4 f"/# K23-# B ,# Bx B ML;
=C!"1 p-?; || 0H-4 =$+"(C5 =+&3". : ^ ; B["!#
K=3":^; N!#(g2-,o+M 5,#

Q L5
wY .+ R"*L KN2fL G; B =3" X; -4 C 3,.# J/
!8+LJ.+5!_BDY #.W0J!y<L/#X;RDXg3#
=3"L KE N3&#F !8-SY B ry; !8]U5 ~/# <L/5 W&y 7|U
5N3,!.4.SYjJ #^8/#cH&4522*",!.4

2".4X;B 8LK[;B=2[5G#9p2cJ/48-i
Teweles and Jones (1987), pp. 319-320.

Summa (2003).
/
/3
6-"EF
K5$gPy##$6;!y84HKTUGH4X; B5+S^
h J #X5H!##-S#N$H5a *"#+3QBo+yWXU0.#L
GHI"JCa/#,N$M#=LKn^
K
+#=3"!#< #0!-"CB7O#,!fJ0V4CXU
X Y3# S# 2-4 jYy =$+"(C5 =+&3". X; TU N$6 j3& 2J5
&., 2Q 3/# XU K+# : 9 B V[ X}! /+,
-#
P,5 GHI"JC a/# # &3 N P, V+ $+- 5; m+v p"y
8D", $!3# +MJ X; 21 KY YJ D /!5 N$M#= /
P, V+{ m+v 2[ 4 C Y; B 7O# RD j1 2J jYy # !y 2++Q5
K/"yG5$Y Y3#0 3!y<K 4P,5N3
Ku8/p"CR-.4+#"#0 IS#

Arrow (2003).
Kreitner (2000), p. 1096.
/
/J
EF

< <{{]<s{{{]

W $E=F+!+4 B,
+6 "y / &J
WX_' ('
RD y "5 ,, 8-+& X; 2I3 -.# Gx X; 5 N$A"#('
C N$A"#L Y+1; . 2J Xy XU5KKK$A"# / 2, C 8L K# ^
K#yCUX 4
G# 8L &#, ~/# 0 y; B!M" G# .+ WYd#_' 5
K# $51
WXD YX;P&4N$&-#
KN5d#N2# 5A"/+3+3u=-5=CH&BDS/Ch Y K
WO SI#= CH&, -" 5 &#, 0 y; B!M" h Y K
KN5d#A"/
K+G#IS#Yd#h /#[Y5IS#^059h /#05/"/

./62/66/
*ÈF
IJ"KF[%^
'_X;e/+1? #B!L N$._h J50!"1Y,'_/LsDU
5h+M#5o"#0!#-4Y9+-# >ÔWO
X; $ ^3# v 2J , K"+!/45 0 S1 B -# 2I3 ^/
K3-#H I30S1$ vK,;B 5X!M#
h Y U3B+-#oJ WlY'_BoJ 5
B!M"4
8,;#?S#0!D9BWdyX;B7O#&L K8/
0J!y+-#NH I3WO8.SY^3XL3B$2J
-[5WY6[0J5E F R3"#Xg3#+D/#VY;W
B,
+6R/- ?5 KE uF 1BB2#^7+D
W# 3,$+!+4
K:RD7+3".WO3$2JRD[9W~/#-,0 J
3tY yLK*+*vX#42fL5!-#-S/$2JRD[9W+J #5
3?S#!-#X 2JB#5KY*[$5!-#MS#&& +L
> d#HHV+L[;5,| 2V3<+DrI#5K"3WOR/-MSL

V". !-# X9 B#5 !-# B H I3 35 -"# X9 C 3,
K-"#53!#
*
D( 8#
&? P )& ? ?
# U * *" $N \N# =!K !
.!789 !! #
&
.//J
.$N !

]/

.6230 #$ "
. !7N! 5256/6 %

*ÈF
ax6 8+L U5 !# -"#, 9 +D# I/# ^ +#5

-,4+#5.50+#5.!Q-/X!M#5K,#^X!M#
+#5."*! # ax6 X!M# ax6L K8/D 3". j.+#5 +t!#
S4G#X!M#,_WG &/#)2u0 #2 5+BDe6/#
P,XK" #3Q8Y9NH I3 +#5.L K,(95# &J RD83S#
GHI"JCa/#^LM!+3#+3*"#VL u [45=&[ #5: 3u
3+3ua/#-,4/NLKN!#-"# H I3+#B#
; K84 ^ L2 &I4 )+` 3". j.+#5 +!# -,4 8Y9 "/
K83S#h,$OY9+D?5-K L+BD3".X!M#
N5d# 2# G# GHI"JC a/#"&< 4 # # &3 NL
:L5KGHI"JCa/#,N$?8YLN5d#2# 4C#Np
KHI"JC^D /!45# &3NP,G [

I/,
X;X HI"JCb$25KBD !D+Y.YN+uS/4C
$",C5 !/#G$5?!QX;5 VL u+[ 4^78|;=
X
I @ ! R 9
)A ' ! ^ 9
R % )!$ 9
R
P * 9 :
.(/5) "& '$( .) !7#

#
.350 !
]20 !)* (+, -
(
.(/4) "& '$( .) !7#

# X

23/
&
./// -($
./
Arrow (1971), pp. 138, 143.
6

*ÈF
+-45$!d"Ck&d4X;BX;M;b$2<+!EB# K$HKC5
GHI"JC! /# G$5? p WPL !# X; - 5 K"Y
KGHI"JCa/#k&d5$?p5

2J 5$W +.S/#0 +^XL!8,3XL'#X5
1C ##5 KZ(; 8[ B '_ y5 $u5 8[ B Nm5
P"# WHL9BWdyZ2# b .#BP,3"PD Y h!"[X HI"JC
+IY+#Ny46!/+,Ny-P"# 3+|5LKN35
P'!/# B h!"[ W.S4 =C5 B 7O#,5 K8+L &O# RD 02
X; 2y B B# K)` 0V4 C +M3# X; CU b .# B BL/"
K!8+#U$_'D YP,50 +BPD /#BP,JDb/
-" !+L + -# ^ k, M# B PD Y ,3 ^ 25
B.+5 $!3#7Q58[BB!M,$5,#7QW,
X;BC#BRYH92u!Q
V".,#7*"L KZ(;8[
7Q ; K8, CU $HKC5 !/# 3*" C5 GHI"JC a/# 8/D S/
KGHI"JCa/#,N$M#!#</ 8L.+5$!3#
/#x6G#X!M#LK+t0 1VyxPD /#BP,:S#5
K+ BD 3". !Q 8L .+ ; & !y +, -"
$|}5 VL u 7f 8L +D#
19 7f Y y < :S# 5
"+!/45 0 S1 RD VSQ +, Yx3 L K#y HI"JC
Bernstein (1996), p. 328; Khler (2004).

Arrow (1971), pp. 22, 29; Shapira (1995), p. 11.

3
*ÈF
= &|ax6XL,3^5KN5d# /,^ && y&I4#,5

+3Q5,ia/# Nm5$[ ,#RD0 Iu[9+
'_ y P,5 Nm!# + P, XV4 $ d{ +L KLM! +3#
$3"C5 !/#3 5LM!+3#5N5d#/, !8/y[ 45
K-GHI"JC
3-" 0 + P, XK" # +3Q ^ +!# HI"JC S+ # P& 5
IL #5 X, X HI"JC px-5 K`# a/# NfH B!? ,
<? #-$Emoral hazardF+J(;TUGH4+BD
0 Iu,!.#X;!yKVL u0"(5IL/4&.,+DXy; ;
N$M#=LKn&OTUGHX!M#V".+&|& = J,#RD
0"(L K=3"^N$ v?5,v1 !yGHI"JCa/#RD
P,5 y P, #d XK" #> +O TU GH +, JD
YE^,3aLUTUGH+P&YEB21;âLLKNm5$
GH+=+MS4XK 4^+ I/D>+OX;2y5(}
K$.+#57JS4TU
+5P,J-#;$U^+-#j3&2J5
j$2JX 4.+5,#7*",8Y;!yKX!M#,_N2DJ0(B
K#P, ? ,=Vs+5D /!5# &3!#-#H52u
.+5 BD +!# 2 ,#L K# +L/ 45 GHI"JC! /#
"# Â
. =!
.Gates (1998) :> :!789 $! % & # *

.Camerer (1995), pp. 665-670 :
G " > .
% (endowment effect) &

*ÈF
&OB##5K0u-+&',XK"!5+BD!#2
K31CZ/!yz=CH&0 v;!.+5,#X X;
^$+!+4B,!8+#U$6;X#!BXD /#X5
C#+N$A"#,'&4LKIS#05;$ yw/#
5;SI#=CH&TUGH4#;KGHI"JCa/#8/DS/
IS#^Z/5K+BD3".8"3+31^8L&#,0y;
KSI#=CH&,JD6XU
H3#

b a'a"#
K8I+3452++QRD#C2#
2".EhedgingFa *"#'I
BN$._w+34 a *"#X,P"#P,5a *"#P,:SBb/5
< N$._ /A"# B] <LH 8L P"# ; ,# +YU BD 0K/"# 0(
22QX5H
-#R/-,'I
2".///# K,#+Y,S"1C
K3+&'4+S+y
2v3 < S" X $2J / 5 R/- 8, a *"#L
KYEB 06UX X;m&/C58L2;5+-#
LKp2c+3*"#2".=5H95;f #=^C68l4U
m# jYy XU5 8L .+5 $!3# B!M"4 2". f # jYy
X;cz+ #X; #5 K+ #$r4Cm#LKD58/NH
K8[9j2"#m#^/4N$?f"YTUMS4
Bodie and Merton (1998), pp. 224-225.
J
*ÈF
3+3ua/#7|B5+,k,$ +-#8/5
53+3ua/#,Yx3XyC &3X a *"#LKN5d#2#
=+,iU+3QB#,5KN5d#2+# "#K0H&4X X;B!M
K=3"8+#UGH4#LKn=+&^h J #X5H<K 4

# (-Q
8f ? ^ H2*" # 5 S"m $m# K# a5# 83S# 05/4
W!+La5#w"45K# &3Na56
K8/K*"#BCY; K
KNW.X 4X; K
KNH I3WOX 4X; K

2# 3+3ua/#
Kh /#BX 4X;
V". 059a#
##5 K 0!"1 X5H 0H&"#* I +3Q $-" )+` N5d#
5KS"m$m#X +# [u +#U D2423-# X X; 83S#ax6
K&!y+!#-,"#
wY2J5KMS/5;
+JN$._0!"1X X; M"3Yd#a#
0!"1 B J; / .# 0!"1 Xy h /! $m# X; RD 83S#
XyXU5 W0J P14$&D^
+6##$6;5 K4+!ybc
.54250 )W % '& ]52J/0

5
*ÈF
â#;|31CZ/5Kh J #+JN$._X;G;Y+1;.2J
K2+3"#HI"JC~$2BDHI"JCoJ V++{
GHI"JCa/#Bp2cLKP#59P#BD4Y)#d#a#
-,4 N jYy L K8V". # N +#5 2# #! +3#
KNH I3WO0u-+&',X ".LNW.jYy53+3ua/#

Q( .
N+-&4N$5?B!M"8/K*"#BCNX yax6XU
XL ? IS# ^ J/ B P&4 !y5 KN5d# 2# 3+3u a/#
B2VTUGH3+3u0H&"#BD7|B5+BD'_IL
K: 9?'>5
W83S# 8+!. # 5 H '_ RD ?5- XL&.# c5
D6
z$m#B8Y # h,D /B!d,X!M#RD?5-
D /M;8LC3"[95;BV#RD?5-#WlY5K&!y
<J5^[95X!M#XL&!y5Kw/#,
z,#B8Y9h,
7Q
V". ?5-, [9 03" 7*"L N215 !-# X8[5 9
7Q58/#^XK"$m#5,#L K#y?5-,X!M#03"
+ -# 0!y 2 6 B 5 (} 7Q
V". !21;
KJ/"#B8"!ID5
.JJ2J0 _!&! _!& VI
/
*ÈF
'_ -+& < { S" N +-&4 ax6 B -# oJ 5
!D $ IJ5 X.Y 8[ BD 4Y 5 #!"1
8S '_L K"3+315
P, '5 C5 2[ 4 C 5; 2[ 4 X; U N$._ XL CU5 K<J # f3`
$23, /3( 6 y YU W0!"1C5 HHx# +L 0 C X #L KB9
HHx# 2[ U5 KE 2D#F $23 2/D 6 y5 E !3#F
K+Y #f3u,1BDVA-#58E&.,G&#B#^0!"1C5
CT-4>#XUW0JP1B"/g=r#gp5-fV+S###$6;2J5
CU2[ CH
8S'_LKX #B+f -#S"Y2H/#-
KX+D9^2[ X;BC5X9^
K"#H&7"4X;$-"B!LG&#B#$(2[ C'_XyU5
=3"H 3D^ ?5 !y23/#,23/# -J55-L#H&47"!L
23-#^vXLP5."WO P? -#X9lY5 KG$A"# P"#H 3D5
Sv#H&5;&#,0 y;BX +L,3X5H23Y<LH TU8"/
KGHI"JC'vC.`
vL,HGHI"JC0n^BV#LK'#(} [# BV#5
BV#XLN$._h J50!"1-'_XyU5KN5d# 5,#+3Q
7fJ!y5N215!-#X8[53+3u!^8LK,#+3Q0!"1-
&OB#5KG&#B#^CU2[ 4C#= C!"1C;2&RD
God doesnt play dice; Pais (1982), p. 440.

.230 )W A8 % =!K8
4
.Arrow (1971), p. 134 :)W 0

7N
` )& ? B7 8
6
*ÈF
'_RD5BV#RDC3"?5-</B+-#oJ
KD6
!y5$m# Yd#5,# 059L
o+#"#1d+#: 3uRD?5-<$-"4CA+"/#5
KNH20!D;#5V5;Y,+Y Y3#w+(x# #y5$",C5 /#5
: 3u h ? B#5 X9 ^ 2[ 4 7+S $52, : 3u 8L
B=/5=D/I#5=&"5=S#5"# 5,-"4G#
#,8"!+JHHV4,R6"45;: 3u05V4X;X5H$_^2[ X;
; KX+D9 ^ 5 X9 ^ P, : 3u c &./#, $-4 L K&#O
K$_^# I15=C!"1C21; Bs+-4HA*!M5 R6"YL'_
--!"iX;BC5 $_<^RL/"5$-"
8S'_L
YU B p2c , B !8D!"[L 8D ? 5 : 3u p
K: 3u
K$_^2J-"#P12[ CG##^p v <+,>&#B5
^ 2[ , X+D9 ^ 2[ C "-+&', B2#5 BH # ^ p v L
jYyU$_^ NH [ X+D9<J/"C5RL/"C/# KX9
B V[ '5 ' $ v B N$ v 2+3 X9 H2z ov # 3,'
21; P-4 U Y9 2", $_ ^ 2[ ^/ 8L '_ ; KP-
K;'_
8S7|B0K5N$5M#,J&#RS"Y=C!"1C
.!a
. (J) '8 CVK R. 8 7

.$N DI A
! % *!
!& V V D( 9 L
V X? DI A
! )b% ?

.360 - ./
3
.J20 !.01 2

*ÈF
4T
+!",
5; N$._ 0!"1[ $2, -" S"m $m# a56 B Yd# a#
+LZ "G# _'D6h /!$m#X,83S#v2J5K:S(
N$&-#L K!8L (;!8&O;B; P,HH45;
2-#5H [ #p
RD024+Yd#5.#0!"1G5.N$._0!"1X;RD024T59
X; i N$._ 0!"1 X; M"3 B9 h !5 Kry; N$._ 0!"1 X;
KD6# &3NX "#.#0!"1BJ;X
^ -f# P3# p5 ^ $3# +#; < L " C a# 5
Eexpected
utilityF -J
" -S/ N2DJ 86; B5 Nv-= $2#
v15-S/!#-J "!+3#>.10(B$3#v "#7")+1

Xy S"# BD 34 C A+"/# jYy L K8D J5 0!"1 ^ -S/?>
.#= C!"1CB#m#P,V+C> 95KC
&3$3#
K+IY+# ##0d?5;5KN$._5;
NVf K S X; ^
;
d $C52, Ny4 w# Gx +IY+# SL
K S# 0!"1L N$H o+#4 0SOU xL < K$C5H X + $23
Ny"#6 B-S/!#-J "!+3#>.`5KX +^215 NVfE,
34C5EX +B ^X +?>v1F21 #G5.48Y;2
KC
&3#$JX +LS"#BD
Y;21TU2[+e?K S#0!"1X;3+31^/40u-+&',A+"/#
2+-&#7 #,-40u5+IY+#RD
2J$3LK0!"*.
.320

J
*ÈF

5;+Lb TU2IJ[ "CJ-#XLCU5 SfV#Y95
5K$E=F
.#2&DB,V-#$3!y#m#TU,
RD R/& C 7u X; M"34 # #, 05V C P3+# N2DJ X !M
RD
2J XL c5 K#m#[ # RD , 7 # BD
ML #
-"&1vX9 $m#ov5+D:2I5Y3-#b .#^/ .+
sm G# NVfE 7A*L KW&# NVfE 7A1 &., 2[ o+-? 0!"1,
N$._ 0!"1 X; B 7O#, !-# RD
2J# m5 w#
KK S#0!"1<X$3CO9

(()#
.#TUGH$3#XU0 3#<S".#0!"1&Oax6XU
C5 A+"/# 0 I1 TU &#O GH &.#L K+D 0 I*# & 5;
+3*", 3". C "-+&', &.# XU , K<'3#[ 5 RD #X X;
V
X; - 5 K<Y S"Y5 a5# 3Q B 2, C , &.
K&.#H [5<R"1!fJl4:S(
7|, '3Q 8Y;Bl#RDm#&>9-S,$ 7.5
Ky 4583DW/#0J!y#$5!+LT-4RDy "
0 Iu &#O GH &.#L K>&9, "JD5 y "# +!; 8l4 / B5
.//J
2// !%
>
]366 /
3/ !%/

5
.J20 !3/ -
4 , . +
/
Al-Suwailem (2002).

.40 !2 5 2 -
]33/6
3// !%

4
.(65) "& '$( .:? X

36
*ÈF
0 Iu
2D'(0VC, 0 Iu
2D0!"1S/C/#H I3
K [_'BJ "#y "#B2,C##5K1 [XyXU5!fJ
59+L/5N$.#&&&Ie/+1
2JL[$9_' XyU;
h !5 /D
2, +#5 >&9, (#
s! 3+3u ^ y "#L Kh#
K2+6#$3# B9
[x <J 4 [#L K
!"# BD H !z[ # V+ 5
>&; >+m# 2D [x <J 4 8L !"# ; ,&; H [ # # I1
-L N] [# X9 [# RD R/|;5 !"# T-4
c5 KH [5
-L X5H hH_ 95 7 # RD 7fJ 8L !"# p >&9
K>&9

$!-#/$!c"F
!8/+, :S# $ 5 K$!3# BD $!d"C V+{ # N2D3# 5
23"-h5^#o B !d".LK2f-#3Q5h5A/,3d#
:S(0!"1 X;3&.7- 8L3 ;K10!"1/RDm5
Kh5"*
JC2f-#$23sm B#A/#0!"1B ry;N$._5
&&X X;BC5N$.# && 2s -N$.#&#OGHG#$3#5
>&; BD R8/5 A/#5 .#( ;&> ,
5 K.#
K:S(5N$._
.40 -
(
0 ]3J/ . #
3
.%a!.
-!V '
K L# '!V *7K % W
3
*ÈF
N2D3#LK2D5&.#P,:S4C-J "-S/N2DJX;2,3^5
+Iu RD $3# 2!"-5 NVfE 7A1 < A+"/# 521 0!"1 k
3',jYy A+"/#0 v #+S+yTU$&"DN2D3#'-4C5K+f8/#
7++3"# 3-# 8+#U A # 3'# j.+# 5 K1 ,M,
; +A8/
B,y3L55K7WO&JPHI"JCBH3"YjYyc5784$J
^X5(}578,X LI"#3'#,HL97"8WXW4 ,5WY
p #WO#5Kv_78L2;c(BX 33#:'##
uB5; Hs [!-,&.yRDI12JXyXU#&CG#w#
KY;502-,78"-5;B(}DH#XyU5;R!D9

*-F d[$-#
P,V+{C&!yP3#p5^$3#C2+3"#+#9
P,V+{C3+3u^8Lc5K:S(+Dm5;A/#+Dm
HI"JC[<+&#OX;9<J5,K$!3#
8SP,5$!d"C
8S
S"h Y;P,$+"(X X;52-CP3#p5^$3#-fVE
G#~9 5N3 $+"(#+[ !/#m+I#L K+IY+#B
HI"JC qH& 4L/ < 5 KP3# p5 ^ $3# lY +D R/&4
=y#5 =. Z2# $3#= +#g <J5M;^/ YL
K0!D90[$5
Ben-Ner and Putterman (1998), p. 20.
.Jehle (1990), Varian (1992) :

G "
33
3
*ÈF
+/+3Cp5^$3#$2+S+y0 1=$HN2Dj[;23L
^"# 78- ,X -S,!.'_X5(C$2X;A+"/#jYy5
=23"Yc5 KA/# 3Q B3|RD Y +# +&.#f"/#5'(9
N3RD7f3# $3#2+3"#<^[<f#! /#=$2#
RD -5 K0!D9 D ^ $3#*> v9 -S#< J #^ / Y; j/+,5
W# 3,H$ SY"-[^$3#lY";$!+[#
<? # 8Y; RD N3 - TU +{ $+"(C= lY X; 7O$
P,X JS=$3#G"X;CUNp5^$3#C[ !/#
C 78YL ! Q 78+D P-" !/+&L KN3 P,5 ! Q
GHS"# DS##5z0(B=Wm"!#X &+A".75K2,;X53
7+3# P, ?S 0( B 8"- BD C
2, 8+D N'+.# 5; =Wm"
K$3#B-J "

(()#P 2e-#$-# #f
3S"X "#-J "-S/0(B-f#$3#N2DJ2-4YH$;U
K+#"#m+I#xJB!+L+qH&<
pi 0!"1[$2, i#u ^xi 0 A+"YTUGH a$3#X;xL
$3#S4B"#5 xi A+"/#B-S/ v( xi ) B"#K i = 1,..., n )+1
Shapira (1995), p. 120.

March (1994), p. 54.
3J
35
*ÈF
*[x 3Q C
&3 $3# X +# ax4 -J " -S/ N2DJ K c(a)
W+#"#
n
[1]
U (a ) = pi v( xi ) c(a ) 0
i =1

$C5H0H-4S",+IY+#Ny4,-"$3#XyU0d+&RD
XLK S#
2D016C5K S#01$C5HX +$23NVf[5215
W=Wm"
c = 1, x1 = 1,000,000 , x2 = 0 , p1 = 0.000001 , p2 = .999999 .

U (a) = 0 XL v( xi ) = xi )+`+'(-S/#HX;k+.&"#/?xLU5

K[]*[xRD/,C &37|B$3#&I5
=C!"1X 4)+`# &3=C!"1C2++34m&/A+"/#/A"#
3*"4#v/-#D !d{ S B"#K:S(=C!"1Bry;A/#
)+1 c !
S
D !n! /+, v( xi ) c 0 *[x 8+L
B!M""L +Yd# ; A/#= C1 B!M"4 T59 D !n K v( xi ) c < 0

WBy3QUC &3$3#2-K:S(=C1

n
[2]
U (a ) = pi v( xi ) c(a ) 0
i =1
[3]
p >p
i
iS
iS
*ÈF
K:S(= C!"1 B ry; A/#= C!"1 X 4 X; ax [] ^ 2+3#
B 2+3# XL +*I# 21 # G5. =C!"1C h ! XU )+15
[3'] pi > 0.5
WX +#"O+vNHDU
.
iS

GmG#2uTU$23NW&y8/#0 IuN2+-,f"/#H-&"7"#,5
K$!3# [ 5$+"(,w#

eJ,$

2"//KEmeanF,.uk "R!.RD+/&-J "-S/
B :S(5 A/#= C!"1C fI1< K "#, N6& v G $+-
7.34 #' 3/# Y, NHD p- 5 EmedianF k+ # R!. 0(
KG5.!8/yP!.JTU=C!"1CR/*/
EcontinuousFI"=-K "#!4:H;m+I,k+ #o-4B
~x f -#Wm"Bm!+3# k+ #2-K!yEdiscreteFIS/5
W#"#a#" ^.4#
[4]
prob( ~
x m) 0.5 and prob( ~
x m ) 0 .5

DeGroot (1986), p. 207.
3/
*ÈF
BD!8/21 #3C;ik+ #Y[RDfI1<K "#X;R/-

i$3#XLo-"#RD/,5KX&YEZ5."X;
VCB#
W*[x" ^.X;
[5]
U ( a ) = m a 0.

"/".YX;//!+L v( xi ) = xi )+`+'(-S/#HX;&!y/?xLU5
WX;1C#X+&#K x2 = 0 A+"/# D;+IY+#0d^k+ #X;
RDSvRD0 Iu0!"1X;R/- prob( ~x 0) = 0.999999 > 0.5
M;1C Ka#B059VE" ^. 5Bry;234RIJ;
G5. dy; 5; Sv RD 0 Iu 0!"1 X; G; prob( ~x 0) = 1 WX;

2DG;SI#0H-4#A+"/#^X33*"P#LK+*I#21 #
-S/XLk+ #A+"/#jYyU5K+IY+#B6RD0 Iu
5 KSI# B J; A+"/# X 45 $3# S4 IJY k+ # $3#
K#RD/,0 &3WO+IY+#Ny46$JX;-
45 # &3= _' C1 P, V++!"# B N2D3# 0( B5
.SYjJ #^5K-PHI"JC5P+Y Y3#jJs$;#+M3#5D /!
X;B#,5K83S#8+DwY#$m#+D#k, M#<S"48L
-L/# 0 1 p_ N ++M4 ^ W&y 21 TU N2D3# 78.4
K !/#5$3"CH284#45GHI"JCa/#

*ÈF
6-"
K K5A"4 &./, N$._ TU GH4 =3" ^ N[" X; X+, &
=3"^N["XLA/#=C!"1BWd,ry;&./#X;)+15
K
234L5# &3WO2-4
'_-5+5'_P,IS4=3"X;##/S?;U5
KD6# &3Na56^/4=3"X;-8L0H&"#BH I3
NW&y N 5 +!# -,4 j.+#5 NH I3 &I4 =3"! L
=+&3".</3S#=!<$J$52v&O+LKNW.j.+#5
K8"+D5
2D5=$+"(C5
^(g2-,o+M 8LSv#H&=3"X;$&"DC^Y(;U5
K#"#IS#&*)^# 5=5H97 34

.5J/// '8 8
3
E F

< <{{]<{

,'"5 K+M"#5 h2_ R/- M; B!M" 5 '_ Wm# ^ $m#
0 Iu0!"1X 2/DN$ v?5, h2_5'_ X+/-X
GmNVfE7A1X;CU+#-#B7O#&LKW&yNVfE7A15+J
=3$ v5+IY+#^0u! yNm^0 (2#sm5w#
^ 2+3"# $3#= lY A/4 G# $!3# [ 5 KS"
K&!yH-&"
TU l/#, GHS# $3# ^ $m# $+- 05/" ? IS# Xy !+L5
<K 4.`+f/d#=CH&^$m#$+-IS#05/"N[$H
+#!"1 #H& Y, $m# o-4 B $&"DC 8,5 KPL'# P, f"/#
=$&lY^/Dr- 5(}N$.(5PL'#21;,$8"A+"Y
< S" k,M# 5 KEzero-sum
gameF Sv N$& Y, Egame theoryF
N$H += A"/"' # ; d !y $m# +D# k, M#
K4+!y

./0

$g# hEF
6FI(i 5
Wh Y;||TU8Af"Y.`=CH&h Y;7+.34B
K+,i=CH& K
KSI#=CH& K
KSI#WO=CH& K

j6FI(
- X.5 - X` )+` PL'# I 8+L S"4 =CH& 5
+,i A+"/# XL N$._ 2 C J-# X; )+15 KE # lYF
KbxhS"YC #H&H I3&I7|B5p#NH I3
B9hS#dP1^#H&^Xd>5;XL EF#^5
f"/# d!+L .9 hS# ; +4x# .` !8/ # +,i f"/#
B#+#U#H&8"/"PDS#G;/+3XL'#7-C2J-"#2/DK+&.#
hS# #H& H I3 X + ##5 .#! 8/ y H I3
K,i
X +.L "J/ j3& G# k+ # $+- L5 XL'# pI4 U5
#" $,+d;3Q#H&-i5K,ihS#3Q O9
K2J-"#X52,+DYyML;01^!8/y-

$g# hEF
(7 ! )
( )

(+ +)
+,i=CH&WEF0

bx # X/-# y6 v( y$ H 3D +,i= CH& d; B5
-X`XL'#LKSv/f"/#X!."35!-#5 0^XL'#8+L
,ihS#
^VCY;1 K!fH:S4!8uI!L-X.5
&y!8/yX X;S,PL'#B#.#$23Z5."X;
K.#hS#RDM;&'/5K2J-"#&J-?5TUl/#,

TJ#6FI(
? !y (} N$. CU p 8+L . C #= CH& 5
PL'# hS"Y +YU 2[ 4 C =CH& B h /# ^ KEF # #
C=CH&X; -5K2,C5(}$M4!21;<S"YU,-
Kh /# ^ 0 (2#
2D "$, +d; RM"35 PL'# I
2
LCU5K23A+"/##8[ <J #=^CH&H [5$5&.#5
K#H&^0 (2#B_p'#</"CSL5-A+"/#jYy
$g# hEF
(7 ! )
(+ )

( +)
SI#=CH&WEF0

PL'#P,5."X X;
VCN$._5.#$23XL&!y5
[ B#K2J-"#&J!8/y<?5TUl/#,#H2*"U5
lY <[ P&4 !y5 K- !8DS"Y< /" )+` PL'# I L/4
$23Z5.")+`8"O+vNHDUBh /#B#H&G;XL=$&
)+1Sv8Y,8"+!.4=[/B5KPL'#B#N$._5,#
=CH& d; ?5; B5 KSI# PL'# #H& f"Y h ! X
$!3# #g A+"Y RD /, (# PL'# 21; <L2 )+1 $!3# SI#
K(}. !21;&.!LK+f -#
NVf[ RD 8L ;Bx # N$8= 3,. M; # ^ (25
RD 721; .y 8"A+"Y X9 Sv .L/ 8L > m 8"!+J !*"
N$8 &4 8Y y ^ u> -#; BD N$8= $& o"5 K+3&#> .1
*[$ *I5 -S/ = N$8 jYy XL KP$&" Z2# 83I45
N$&$&"DC8,&I45Bc-"#N$._r23LD6
$g# hEF
B =3,. B /+- D Y; /# R/d" c5 KSv j.+#5 +,iU
Wo_,H5KIY5;L15;o(^CU&CW# 3,7*"#!
D
NVfE W&.#5 K# :& WI/#5 +_ :& WLu5 , :&
=3,. c /d"C 8L K78/ VfS# c/5 X 3,." 8[ #
7| B 8Y;5 B$&" 2/D 8+!/4 #= $8 +!; TU <[ v I(
K23"# RD +,iU A+"/#& I"L > m 2/D +# N$._ -4
+!-#= 3,.y Z(; D Y; /d"C ^ 83S# -, (H; c5
Kh$#2IJ#*I3 5
^7.C)#|p0 (H=3,.^X x83S#$ 85
DLo+Mz0 (H5 KzR!.5KLUc//#NVfE!+J
$C5KzOU E2 2FPL'#N$.("A+"Y EF#^d#|
+# N$._= C!"1 B 2V Y9 N dy; 3,. -i X;
7|K!8$E=F7+3#B,5
+6$J!yP/x!#
$5 K.L/VL 1o-MzU8+L+Ox#B)2uH I3^/
P,M&#m3,.&I4C; 5zax6B* Xy
8, $Ody;N$&&I"LN$.#?Ddy; !8-iB#KPL'#
K$&"DC
.(/44) "& '$( .) !7#

# X

.46 J0 !/ ]4 /0 !

.32 / /30 !

.230 !

$g# hEF
!5 f"/#< K 45 N[ $H WX$&"D # $m# X; &5
3,.!#+#f"/#<K 4s+mz 0 (H XyLK4+!yXK"
+,iU f"Y 3 C ,3 ^ Y; CU SI# f"/# RD I"34 C )+`
; ; 5+&TUSvBN$&0 *"4,PL'#hS"Y,!.4
!+3# lY
z X# B =3,. R/d" U )2u5 K+D jYy
3/ +# N$._ r5 02-4 #5 8/!M"4 #= $8!# +,i
3/ 8Lz0 (H;K+,iTUSI#B4+!y&#O N$&
B; ;X "LP/xyRD$? 5+&.#TUSI#BN$&
G, SI# A+"/#> /"[ $m# 7Q B H I3 +#5 K[ #
RDN$.(8Y #SI#A+"/#5 K+,if"/#+3*",,6
K7*"#,T5;jYy-!8+DN$._j-J5L,3X5H!21;

TJ#XR6FI(
#! ^ y Sv Z(;5 +,iU A+"Y B!M"4 #= CH& 5
$M45 !21; hS"Y, 8"/4 2J5 PL'# hS"Y, 8"/4 2J #H&L KEF
K8?$-4!"Q5IL 4!"Q8LK(}
XL D6 D / SI#5 D6 # &3 +,i= CH& jYy U5
K!8/O9 P"A+"/#G;RDoJ " SI#WO=CH&RD7u
#H& XL PL'# H I3 5 O9 +,i A+"/# jYy L
U;KS"mW.+#$m#B#u^SI#A+"/#&I45D5
K#H&</G#Wd#$m#B2-48YLO9SI#A+"/#jYy
$g# hEF
(7 ! )
(+ )
(+ +)
SI#WO=CH&WEF0

TJ#XR6FI( c5
d9B5SI#WO=CH&B!?$2/<J #=^CH&dy;5
W#RD
G#5 D$V# o+#4 !*" D$V ^ h$V XL KD$V 23D K
o+#"# B $9> $ !*" C !/+, 5 HIu5 N295
X 2J 0 Iz5 K:S4C .` !8/+, 0 Iz XL'# 7."3 7| Ke+6
# o+#"# - X; h$V!# B; Wdy Xy XL K
+J X 2J5 Wdy
X 4 23L
+J Xy XU5 K`$ X +L 0 Iz B &+IY 0( B 8!Q
X; G;K (X +L 0 Iz B h$V +IY !+J B dy; D$V# o+#4
H I3 5 h$V5 $9> $ PL'# hS"Y TU GH4 2J D$V
B#5 Kh$V $M45 $9> $ hS"Y TU GH4 2J5 K2", -
.J34 J35 J624// 1 :R.
$g# hEF
W.+# $m# B X +L PL'# H I3 WO5 &#O [ W(9 0!"1C
KD6S"m
K I_^D$VX68Y6NJ.5
~;$ NyK X 4 X; ,$M ^ 0> $ ax6
+6 K[; c5K
I L ,#, NyV# 1U 0!"1 # B!M4 #5 ,# B 0
B WlY # -[5KNyV#< L2, 0> $ <S"/ !/+, 6 RD >$M
8LK-#<S"/C5A#>$<S"/+LA#!dUNJ.<^3X;
[ 0!"1 >$M hS"Y
2D5 0> $ hS"Y 0!"1 0!"1C
KW.+#$m#BX +L
KU ^ o" 2J #-E ^ -# XLK#-E 23D M; >&# B5K
DE B *". L >&9 B & G9 !" C 7| +D H 3-! -#
<S"/23L{&J!-#-#b4U5K!-#{
,a5-EUe+6
R/, U 5; y L 2[55 S1 U Y; RD 3S4 # !y / ; DE
VAD 7| /&# ^ h6 5; e+6 2i 7L /+- $2J S*LKy L {;5 kfu
!-, <S"Y 2J X +L /&# 7" 5; Su 7" X; DA# B!+L KpIYL
!-# -# ; U PL'# y hS"Y"! Q #-EL K,3 X5H -#
23-# H I3 Xy B#5K!" U -# N$.(5 DE hS"Y"! Q5
jYy c5 KW.+# $m# B 2s D5 (} 0!"1C S"O PL'# hS"Y
5l/L +S/u; K,/u5 +-L#5 +# B $ 8!E 2/D D5 #-E
./250 /9
$g# hEF
!y K$m# B #-E 52D ##5 !-# 7" U -# $M4 0!"1 TU
lY5
{&J-#!-,<S"/2JDEXyU#-E+#</
$&"DC 5 K-#$M45DEhS"YBD"/4#SI#A+"/#TU
XyUB#K23-#BH I35;#m#A+"/#jYyU+*v
c5KNVf[ 8L XL'# 8, <S"/ # +,i A+"/# #m# H I3
Ka#,/u5+-L#ax
? $ ,*I# Xy 23LK1v 0!"y& J !d#< +, # ? 5K
$M"+L S"4 Lg &+I4 2J !d# XL I# s52, &J !d# X -&" 78/D
W0J # /# Z;$ !LK# [; B I_ 78+L =dL Gx
I# 52, &J !d#< +&L K1v 52& R"1 !d# -&"4 L C L
hS"Y5 Gx $M4 7| B5 !d# o4 0!"1 X9 1S# $m# B Xy
Rv 7L KP-&" P, hK/"#5 I_< J5; Wdy Xy <f&#
o4 0!"1 -i I# 52,5 KI# 52, 2-, CU -+& C; 75 +D
<f&# WPL'# hS"Y 7| B5 !d# #m# X +L +J !d#
6 N!d# B o" C; 0u -+&', B!M C I# s52, B#5KGx5
KS"mW.+#$m#B 8Lo+-?0!"1/#
.)* $

& :R.
.6/
.64/ ! ]//J !./0 :

:>
6
.(4) -
(9 "& .

#
!G V :!N X

$g# hEF
E=F 2;
V+i G# X ,-#< +, M; >&#( ^ 25K
RM; U PL'# hS"Y P, HHx <+&# X; #5 K$ 8!E -/5$
Gx .(5 <+&# Rm#; U Gx N$.(5 <f&# hS"Y P,5 <+&# Gx
$m#B-X 4X;
V".CSI#A+"/#0!"1HB#KX ,-#
KPL'#*I3G#<+&# X ,-#<+,BH I3X9h /!
$m# B Gx N$.( 0!"1 Xy PL'# hS"Y H I3 Xy L
PL'# hS"Y Xy 5; SI# A+"/# H I3 Xy U ;KS"m W.+#
B e/+1 8L Efinancial optionsF +#= $+"(C ^ 0u! y $-"
$ 2;
0 J5 $ 8!E 0 J P, <!E B 8,5 K1S# $m#
K<+!ERD
H I3059L+#=$+"(CP,5X ,-#P,:S#P&"M;8,5
real
F 3+3u $+"(C R!. c5 XL'# , <S"/ G# 3+3u 0H&"#
hS"Y, !.4 C LKn5K-.# RD LKn H I3!L Yd#; KEoptions

##5 N$5M#, }( (Xy !21; ,$ XL 0u -+&', PL'#
$m# B X +L I"(C ; pxD, SI#= CH& B!? (2
#H&X ,-#LK&!y 3S# !< $J , $2v 5 h /!
KSv=CH&8L+#=$+"(C;SvWO

# P3,." B -, =3,. SI# WO =CH&( ^ 2 2J5 K
-L/#=$8/,BB!M"4=3,.X;#5KG &/#)2u/d"
.2660

$g# hEF
+,iU 3,. X 4 X; B #,5 & !y !"z N$._ ri
8,53,.B#YETUl/#0!"1b/0VCB#KP3,."!#
XyU+,iA+"/#P,HHx4XU3,.L KSv 3,.&I4$&"DC
K#$&"DC[4USI#A+"/#P,5-L/#N$8/, H I3
V+yx#X5Hc+,i!+3#Kr=3,.7+l/4+!;44/B5
K&#m5.L/5$K,U^m#&5#I/-#RD
f.BWdy^83S#p"(&M"3,.#d90(B5
$m#
8S ^ L"( +#5K(} -&# 8-/5 -&# V+i )+1
B!LKS"= CH& o++45<J # RD
8S V/4 ^ , "3+315
K E, 71 +,i A+"/#[ $ B5 </, 71 SI# A+"/#[ $
Ka/^/dy;a/+3Q^p"( 8L

HTJ#$mK .
2+3"#l/#K+f8/#8"I5#H&f"YRD&'/GSI#$+-
K8/#f"/#l/#,+#523-#YUP1-J "-S/RD2!"-4$3#
ex
F-J "-S/+#5Eex postF+f8/#f"/#RD&GSI#$+-L
$&"D,8/#f"/#$&"D,Sv=CH&=3"5$!3#X;&5KEante
/C;xS5KPL'## &3X 42JEexpected utilityF-J "-S/
8+L2[ #=Cu^3*"$-"#B#<J #5<J "P,$-4
)# 9( I
= ! )A !
& R % $ !. =!V ! ! ? )
CVK R. 8 R. . '& ?NW ?

-! @
! !.
!
7V
./2J0 !& 4
$
/ '8
3
$g# hEF
2,C#u^5K+e?=C!"1,NW&yVf[ B!M"4#5$m#
KB$&"DCP,+[x#B
a/# 7++34 ^ ~9 31# f"/# TU l/# X; $ C5
<J5 , <J " ~34 C +L#5 (#5 N5d#L KGHI"JC
LK-J "+#5+-S#f"/#,~L~3U+*v-#5K
-L
+-S# f"/#5 <J # $&"DC X + +[x#L B9 P, $-4 2[5
K-J "7+3#+#5
Nm W-
2" 0( B 2", $-"# / B! B B#
$+-8LK"J/j3&G#EmedianFk+ #$+-d-J "!+3#
N# f"/# /A" Y9 Eex
anteF fYU P1 23-# 7++3"# .Y9
K-J "5+-S#7+3#P,$-"#/A"7|B5EoutliersF

TJ#6FI(nB
PL'# -S/.` HI"JCm#,GSI#$+-O+vB!B
8; 83S# 2". G# k,M# B# K!8/ # 833Q =C!"15
7| #H& B P3# 5; #8E S"Y 234 5 C; +&'"#? ^ 5;5
XL'#7D #7"4X;BCSI##H&LK0H&"#0 I1+YU^l/#
2&DB, 86; # +3S# /D rD 5K8+#U 8"/" # A+"/#, 3&.
W# 3,X!M#RD?5-</DP1$E=FVV-#
Al-Suwailem (1999).

$g# hEF
TU -.# # B!?W[# [# 0 3 X; I C Y; Z4 C;
= S4 5; = { -.# X; BM# 7D #5K$!J5 $OKKK Y9 y #5 [;
7.4 8Y; # X !M 7D #5 K'D; o-M, 8/s!M X;
K7$2,,KKK,U8/!?J,U8/s!MX;
$ v f5 G$A"# P"#5 =3" H 3D RD WL'& `/ 5
B# Y; 3&. 7- B". Xy # G$A"# P"# SL K=/5 $!3#
#5K+DMN$.(&I48Y9P"#3+|56BD</"CH`>I
+D P"# B j-/"C Hu, >I+ B". X; 3&. y# j!D
jYy L KP"# & p-?; 0H-4 # -"#! +J . #, 8Y9
8+L 0 (2#& 3 B# _ p'# X9 #H& j-/"C S - A+"/#
=CH&p5K-PL'#I3QX;BC#H&X;7-L
I3Q8Y92",#8EjS"Y #523-/4X; B 8YL-L/#+,i
XL'#7DU#H&^0 (2#RDH;Xy8/#8EjS"YU,KPL'#
p92I42JG;S/X93*""#+,iA+"/#X;
K#H&{
UBD

# R"1 Efinancial
6$"
F
optionsF +#= $+"(C RD &'/ R/- 5
X;#5KX ,-#<+&# +#a5#f523-#v9 {j/!M4

$+"(#Gx5K-.#RD/5LKn PL'#pxD,23-#p2
./ 1

J
$g# hEF
v9 - <S4$ U CU # S/ C Ecall option

d # $+(F
5; $+"(C B] .( CU5 <+&# -5 # - P, :S# , #,5
KX ,-#
LKSYg$ y#8E k,?+&'", +!-#cGSI#2-&#M"5
5;$+"(CB]<LHS/+v9B]X;3&.7-$+"(CGxXy
Xy Y9 23-# ^ 0 (2#, ?$ <S4W B!d# X; <f&# 7D #5KX ,-#
23-# H I3 Xy L KX ,-#! +J B dy; B!d# hS4$ B ,W
KB!d# ,3 ? D B!M"4 jYy XU5 Sv &I4 3+3u ^ - XL
CY9$-9:5LRD ."#,8"/4X;TUH 3-#8,0u05##5
Kk&M#,vu! y+3YBPL'#*I

6(-")
RD N$ I# ^ 7"4 #EfuturesF =+&3". ^ ry; N$ I, 8l 5
^ ."# 7"4 ##5 -.# RD / H I3 B# < 5; 0 v;
H [55 K$-9= J5L rD E& !y =Cu B F 7D9 #m#
^ -? # X Y3# 88[5 # K9 ;&> K,; B Xy $ v -.#
TU =J59 B jJ5 ^ +9 7yz= E c5K=+&3". RD 7u
IS# ^ # & !y PL'# H I3 22*"# /# $&"(
B!d# +A-4 jx6 P1 lY 2s ; jYy + -# B# K)#d#
B!d#+A-4XLKN$M#=LKn&>#2#^/H <+&XyU
y
B2 #,B2 #;K-L/#+3+3u#H&{
U7|B5-.#',Gx
V
$g# hEF
!y $-9 :5L RD ."#, 8"/4 #= LKA!# 0n .S 8L
KSI##H&RD+,i#H&[B!d#+A-"LK
-Lvu
## 5; B2 #, B2 # 7Q ^ + -#! 1 8l4 / B5
7uXLKX53#rDh+D23-Y5w/#,H$5G###,
;K2J-"#<.#,3+3uhS"YCH I3X X;2,C0H&"#X;2y
!. &J 2J-"# P1 2[ C5 (, BH #H& 8L B2#, B2#
059 p'#) "*! +` X!M, X!? #H& 23-# H I3!LKhS"YC,
23D 8LK(} 02&# Yd# p'# "*! X; ,3 P#2&# 21;
+ H I3 +#5 =+&3". ^ 0u! y #H& H I3
^ <"# 8/ < S" 23-#< /!L K8, hS"YC H # +3+3u< .#
KX!M#RD?5-</5$m#7Q
2S X9 "< # KADU RD 26 B2#, B2#< /5
I-#= ^ 8 d +-S# 84$ I, 8l4 $ 23-# c +3+3u
RD Vfu +#g $ .YS# GHI"JC XU R"1 =+&3". 0( B
</ NW&y [$2, =+&3". ' > ^ c< L$ TU DH , Y NVf[
# B dy; jx6 + -#5KHI"JC, N$M#= LKn
+[ 4521RYH;TU=LKnw+34Y6B5yB!d#7+.4 5
K3+3u0H&"#{
U0(B+,iA+"/#2IJTU#H&
._!&! _!& VI : R.

Allais (1993), p. 36.
5
/
$g# hEF
H I3X9P#2&#+[4B!M"Y y<h/I"C23DK[##5
ax6, # RA" !y X!M# H +#5 h /I, -S# hS"YC
; -+, R!. M; K[5 K7.# BD h/I"C V+ G#! -#
3+3u0H&"# 2IJ $ 8 < B# P#2&# +[4 B!M"4 # 5 /2
7fH5;Lu ; B 5; [4 <f&# X y d +D ? BfJ5 =*[
#y B4 XU5 !1 2/D -.# X 4 )+` <+&v;5; !-#
>&#( ^ 25 K<+&Bs+-4#V/!-#
5HXUW #J##5
-L
)+` 8-+,5 <.# NK+1 78Y6 B $ < 7" Y9 2$ "# 23D M;
G# 3+3u 0H&"# NH$U 7| B5 !1 ["# 2/D -.# 0 I1 [x
KD6# &3--i
B2#( ^ 24 C 8Y; CU P#2&# +[4 B!M"4 8Y y < H 3-# 5
WB9h /!B2#,
BfJ 0( B !1 2/D # I1 5; <+& v9 <f&# b" K
K&!y+D ?
#1 ^
V"#C k3.5 23-# .S/ )+` <f&# BD X!M# S"Y K
K+S/u B X 23"5 +# # RD wY !y = 5; VA-#
8L K#" ^ ,| l , VA-#, k3. C YL B2# p 5
KX 2#B!?o/I4C##5X!M#X5H
V"#CB!M"4H 3-#
.0 <!79 VI R.

3JJ 36 330 e /< )* ; "& & ]6// -($
./ :R.
4
.J32J6
.V ! !7
6
./0 <!79 VI

J6 /30 e < )* ; "& & :L ! R >

$g# hEF
^/4 2/-#5 + XL ,.# a# +-+& A+"Y a# 5

KN$5M#,X!M#RS"Y!1!21Uj33QL#0mY

# `= +!D ^ (24 # p$I RD &'/ C 059 a#5
<.# NK+1 8Y6 B +#5 0!D9 d Z2I"4 C 8Y9 #,
23D :&'Y
2D P& 5 K!1 2/D <.# X 4 L 8, N["5
$A"#8r#=CH&RD7|B$I"J5+LI`RD2$ "#
=+!DRD$A"C23D:&'Y
2DP&!yK7WOX5H: .#;B
P, S"# WlY 7WO5 : .# ; P, S"# 5K.SY&.#p$I
+u< / Yd#5 +3+3u= CH& K E 059 7WO5 /+-#;
K ,#
^ (; P1 -? # X Y3# RD 3S# : S4 8l 5
!.# ;[ B 3+3u 0H&"# 2IJ RD #2# HI"JC Bf3# $&"DC
K#^/G#b2/D+#<+,5B2#,B2#B<//#P#2&#+[",

HTJ#?h*#
+D#k, M#" ^.45+3Y8+L3*"#=CH&^v9
C5 KPL'# I 3Q 8-i +,i A+"/# 8+L [x =CH& 8Y;
X9PL'#21;N$.(7|B531C-.#Wm40!"1#B</
.0 '> L

L

$g# hEF
NH I3 WO5 1 [#: L 5 23-# BD 3".5 IS/ N$._
K2",PL'#
RD0H&"#&I)+`D5H 3-#
2" B</CB#
$+-L KGSv WO f/d# Z ". RD Xy XU5 Sv h !n Z ".
^ TU l/#, +#5 !A : .# 5;
l/# TU l/#, 3*" 2J GSI#
K.*L23-#
8LEpyramid schemesFc .."##RDd9?5;B5
+IQ p28, bx w6 y X9 h !n) +1 B GSv
lY
M;p2c8,bxCBy5P31#PyxB=C !-#

l/#LK+Y2#=3&'#B,4U
cB+-#=3&'#5K+#5H5
-B!M4Uv(#y52&CHA23-#XyXU5GSvD !A
H I3 , -'J NH I3 WO -.# XL K(, 5; , A"/ 5;
0!"15 IQ C 2J5 IQ 2J 5 P#"# Pyx B =C !-#
&.YK5A"4P1^
c^P`#&.YK5A"4C)+`$HYc I1
c ."#X X;XU,OLKPyx#UBB_
KD6
z.+5$m#B
lY jYy # !y EbubblesF =D3S#= J5; ^ 52&4 +# : 95
TU0 *"42J: .#LK+f3"#+c!lY9WR!. 5Sv
78Y B,.#+E ,)+` VyN$HUX52,c
l/#&
.@!a & I '
V
Vandernat (2001) >
3
.J % 43J '8

&! !%Q O . 8 7 ?

Naturally occurring Ponzi schemes; Shiller (2000), pp. 64-67.
J
$g# hEF
KW(9 +E 8/] <L25 D3S# AS/4 TU 5 78+ B C5
HI"J#!8of53Q0;~$:; 5+#: 9X;B7O#,5
!lY; TU N$M#= LKn 0( B 0 *"4 C # 8!+l/4 m&/ Y; CU
KSv
+#<+,BD5&3#&J<+&#BD /#8Y!18l4/B5
0 Q </{ X; 8Y6 B k, M# XL Kk, M# B 5 2/D
+!+l/"#=e+c Y[u=2[5 &.#c5KGSv
lYTU: .#
B
yxJ 23L#TUL?,5 K+#: 9 ,J$5 k&M,R/-4#
KY$ #+9N$H^,.#+#K55P, 4!+[GHI"JC
!/+, K8'&?5=LKn+3"# +#: 9=^3SI#RD
$L
#52"0 v#!".G$ S#W-."#/TU+#g$ GHI"JCDH
RD c NHK TU DH !y K
+# 0( N215 N W-."#, S"yC5
!y =LKn B 2u5 +3"# NW&y [$2, [} h +&#5 =+&3".
2+y"#U5+#: 97+l/"#++IS"#J//H I3+#5K&
GSv
lYTUGH42J f/d#Z ".RDSI#WO=CH& X;RD
K/,7+l/"#<MUh !nZ ".RD
&#O8/H I3X;5SvWO=CH&8Y;h +&#
^-#v95
stu= -^v9Xyc5bxhS"YC5+,iA+"/#
^!yv9 BDp*/-i0H&"#RD;'2JB#K4+!y
Tobin (1987), Summers and Summers (1989).

Allais (1993), p. 36.
5
/
$g# hEF
22*"# +5 Y y ^ GSI# $+- +!; 8l4 / B5 K3,.#= Cu
</
K#( 2"# $23 22Q 7| B5
-# L2 BD 0H&"# p[ $H
KA+"/#

$g#X.
X;M"3!21;W$m#B$+-/2#X;23,.#J/0(B
S"m$m#X #:S(=C!"1K5A"4X;iA/#=C!"1
B[$;+,iA+"/#X 4X;M"3Yd#5K<,#IS#h ? 5
B$+-BP,J-#!LKIS#h ? 5SI#A+"/#
HS#,-" N$+-!LK(}!8/
y!3+3u^X$+-
&J-"N$+-X;!yK23-#^h !A-"GSI#$+-5
ex
F 2J-"#RD&4xf"/#,-"+LGSI#$+-;Eex anteF 2J-"#
HI"JCBDHI"JC,K"&!y"#5 KEpost
K-? #
8LSv#H&LGSI#$+-Bs7D;CUN$+-5
,$ M"34SI##H&LK!fH+*vWO-#B#5+#D
0!"1L !21;,$0!"1XyL(}N$.(5 PL'#21;
p'# +#D #H& X "L N$5M#, X + (} N$.(
#H&^0 (2#</"$+-XL'#
V"#UY;-5K_
#H&yj.+#B# KN$+-B!M"5
V".GSI#$+-L KSv
KSvWOX 42J,Sv8L+#D
$g# hEF
&3 B 2[5 L KSv +I1 TU 0545 GH4 +#-# B#
#H& SY B U .# vS# 2-". B 2[ +.L N$._ 0!"1
025 KSv !A
l/#& I+#+#4#H& 5; Sv#H&&I"#
0(B&#,0y;TUMS5GH+#-#0!"1X;RD
7*", + -# 44 X; &O B ##5 SI# f"/#
K-B9

YQ-[/Y MLp[
-f#'*= I -, +? "# B$+- B
2" B! B
KEgamblingF N3' I5 EspeculationF LKn' I v(
=C!"1 N+#D=$Jov #
2".X;BLKn'I!L
2" B!+L N3' I ; K,#= C!"1 B ry; 8+L N$._
&'/4LKnLKPL'#hS"Y,;!.4C#SI#=CH&ov #
SI#A+"/#0!"1B#SvWOv9=^CH&5;=$JRD
SI#=CH&,w"8LN3;K+,iA+"/# 0!"1 Bry;8+L
B Z J;5 w(; N3 XL +D5 K+,iU A+"Y G;
v; !"Q C #
KN313,52+8{1d{LKn!/+,LKn

6FI([%^r*J.
6F +#=CH&^h Y;22QB!B&RD/,
5;0H&"#v9+-,4X X;U C0H&"#_'^LKE
$g# hEF
^5 G$A"# P"# ^ 0u! y /D

3". Xy XL K#y X C
8L+3YBh YG;B!M"4C#=CH&B 56h +,
$!3#ov5+D'X;B5KPL'#hS"Y"!QCSv#H&
G#BYd#h /#
^+6+#U$6;G# 5.+5;
K&#,0y;TU8"/
0H&4 ;H I3B#lY++L2[ 4h /#(^25
8LK0 v95<.#RD=+&3".5=$+"(C^0u! y
G;X5H$-9:5LRD ."#RD=CuB^8"/4=3"
+ RD 23 & I4 H 3-# SL K& !y +!# 0H&4
Kc-,4j.+#5
U Lc<,4'_5+3Y 0H&"#BH I3XyU;
$m# B 059 K#y X C 5; O9 hS"YC 0!"1 X X;
B 5D60 &3WO1S#$m#B 8LYd#;KS"mW.+#
P!.3#BRDd95K,.#'vC.` LKY,ov X;
KSI#WO=CH&BD)2u2/D8"J/&
^ I !y Sv lY D !A
l/# - 2J $52, LKn5
)+1+c!lY9^0u! y5+#: 9=^D3S#=C1
8/#^$m#L K&!yN$._0!"1BWd,J;,#0!"1X
C5LM!+J2# CN5d#GSv<K 4TU5&#,0y;TUGH
, R/- X;5 N8' -# /D R8/4 X; &O +L K+["Y Z ". <L
K+Lh J #=C!"1354fHs+MD Y;22*",583S#
$g# hEF
, / 0

"/ =

(( /)
+

"/
(( = /)
>1, -$
-$
< >1, -$

-$
<$ =
(4&)
=
=CH&_'^h Y;WEF0

Q$IV6/I5
N$HU P, <! +# =5H; '4 ^ ~9 X " 3,.# W-
p B 3/, !.4 SI# WO =CH&L KN5d# 2+# 45
<K 4I#,3*"LPL'#hS"Y,.SYjJ #!^.48/#(}
=A"/' 4-7#"#IS#KN5d#2+# 4.SYjJ #^5
K+#3L5+#2/cR!.5;+#

E F

< <{^]<{{{&]
< <{{c<{{<

NH2-"=&/^
2".Efinancial engineeringF+#2/c'I
!"# 0 ^ KNW&y [$2, +#= 3", 3+I# $v 2J5 K/&" Y-
K#[u5D ? +!9lYdy;/D
8S"'

r"#
'"#57+!I"#8Y; +#2/8#j2J#=S-"#f5;B
K !"# y +D2,U 0 1 O+v5 N"& =+#g5 =5H9 +S/"#5
K2f-#NHK5o+#"#S( +#2/cBp2c5
K$",Xy#yXy #5 &/"#,JWO;"-+&',$",CB#
K# 28{5 $",C RD P-4 # :'#5 +#9 ' > XL #5
+# 2/c c <M X; i qH& b/ "! # &./#,5
Marshall and Bansal (1992).
Finnerty (1988, 1994).
Merton (1992).

3
#* sEF
qH& W8Y, +# 2/c o-4 .Y9 B Xy L #5 K8, k&M/45
KN"&+#0 1 '"#K#+#95
^ 8L$",C;K84DB2,C5+-#$34qH&L
K& !y $",C RD P-4 +#; b/ B# KN'+.# <?( WO .SY
GHH$5HU $",C+#;P,5$",CP,:S#RD&YBf5;B5
2I35 Elateral
thinkingF YE WS"# R!. 21; G#
Y,
8.5 $",C 2# X; Y6 B G# p # WO WS"# +#; #,
.SY Y; C +# 2/8# N]5 A+"Y $",CL K+#U 0 v #
K$2#
K=+#}5; =5H95;=A"/+#5 +# 0 uTUWo-"#5
P-"!#+-L*I5;+3+31[1TUv "# H I3X9
K$",# LM! +3# 2y 5 H 3-# B 23D 5; +44 H +#5
RD0+"1C5;!lY9RDpS"#C=C5BD+#2/cV+5
[14C5LM !+J2# 4C+l/#5+83S#+uLK+D#
19
^(2CX;$C5Kdy;C
l/#K5A"##5H,+-L
K"! #NH /+#2/c
8S

$"F! K
$3"C
2D5 K$3"C
2D B!M" W+m"#5 W+m"# B!M" $",C
^L2+#54#'C$",CX;-50u-+&',> OWO
de Bono (1970).
#* sEF
=+& 0H-4 !+3# jYy U5 KLM !+J 2+# "# +5 , K.SY
B <&/4 C $",C! +3L K, '5 H ! $",C X +.L $3"C
2D
jYy c5 K+,i HI"JC5 +# $|g B , 42s [ 5; ",O [$H
#5 GH-# WO $",C B /!M"4 7O#, H3"Y +#= 3"
K+&.#HI"JC$|g&.,

$"F/ #
2+34 0u -+&', 5 +Y.Y N+*# "
lY + -#
$",CBD3fDj.+#H +3#B#KNH2-"Y ^[ G&#b .#
$",CRDVSQH +3#X;TUW4=$2#LK+*I# -#$,
H +3#Xy+#=$",C$5VL u7;21;X;TUW4!yK+D)Q5
K+#'Y#+!+l/"#
jYy U v( +*v 5 $",# J - j.+# XU H +3#L
K&#NH-.#52c$2Ie/+18LW&(7+1X2#B#V/H +3#
Xg3#2y;2J5K,ih2,5$",#+#de+&#
234+-#L
H2[95,#R!D92+3"#23"Y5,2"#5S"# +!;RD N2D =g^
p2p #S#522A"#X;-C5K'/53-#HIXy #5
!+3# /,5 '(9 +*I45 3+3u p"C +5 , .SY ^
KLM
Leathers and Raines (2004).
Elster (2000).
Silber (1983).
J
5
/
#* sEF

!h3P tT"#F
pS"#C #$",CB9p2cX;PHI"JC-,Z
+3*", +Sy : .# +#g X, D/3# B <,Y oJ 5 K!lY9 RD
#5(,5;,: .#H;+-48LPY 3#;<!"n+L$5NS#
*[ R!. 5; 8+D pS"#C 0( B !lY9 0',U XL
K: .#NSyNH-"C7lY^78Eregulatory arbitrageF+l/#
3Q C # +#&# 5; O$S#! lY# &./#, *+*v # X 2J5
^!8$5HGH4+!+l/"#H +3#XL;2&)+1BB#KHI"J*I
IL, v_! lY9L KHI"JC = 3 S15 : 9 $3"
*I+3Q5B!d".!u$5? 50;~$Sy=&'"5
+&z 5; +Y Y3# f # 0( B !lY9 RD pS"#CL K-#

y2#$55X5YUy6$+8Y^ # M4!yNH !WOf"Y TUMS
K+#fMS#B 5
X "f"/#XL+-#
1;RD-J5pS"#CXyU5
D/3#5 X o-M YL +&.# HI"JC $|# L?, Y9 ; ;
H +3#B+D#
19jYyU5 K4+!yh5Z52
VL1 RD M3# +!D - 8+D pS"#C XL $",C RD <A4 #

8S B!? 3+31 $2/4 C +83S# +u X; 2y 5 K; $",C
K+#2/c
Miller (1986).
#* sEF

#$"F9K/
^C3?uI-#^0!D9N4;K,;21;y$Hx+, "y
W K= 5; $",C W# X /D # $",C 0 1 j. Y
&.#K<[x#5$ 2"#BY-4
+#+#D/I#X;TU#3^y$H
$",G;
234+#=2_RD/!+8=.X; Z!+L
j*&v; 8f!-# +# =2( 7234 B C
2,5 KD Z2 RD 0,
A+"/# X "# Z(9= . < 8"*I ["4 &#O +#= .
7;X;Z5KZ(9. .`4X9SvN$&
+!D 8Y, ! DK =3" Xy +?| d# H 3-# 0( =$",C
A+"Y5 K~A+L ~C 5; #$y Y ^ Gi +!D dy; j.+# 8/#
S B H, Y-4 +' - j*&v; D/I#= A"/ XL ##
K ."#, -v5+`#
R3&4X;.;K8.4X;D/I#B:|b/X;y$HZ
$2C"! ^ ." 8/# H [5 RD LQ X; 8/ )+1 !y
,m#X D2&5H2EX H3#D/I#,02&".4X; Yd#K$ 2"#5
&J$.C^N(gjYy)+1X2/#k ,+#: .#21 5
! 5;5.YL5. 5+Y;BX5[8[7|DP.
D/I#H5$&IX;)#d#K-#^+#Vy7;B&I"#8f+1U^
W2"# +!-,
3 B 7 Y X;5 B"&5 PD2& 78.SY; 7
Peter Drucker (1999).
#* sEF
+#059'#XL-#HI"JC"!^.Wm"#TUl/#,5 K:_
8.SYWm4X;UWB;21;Z D/I#;
R3&LK3+3u^$+(
W0 3#,
^&"yG##3y$H7"7| K7WO#,
3X;U5
$",#H -4X;
+#!M#+#=.!#=L2JjJ #X C2J
K2[("2+y"#,/#Z(;N
=. [4>&;21;#.S$03,"y jJ5TUl/#,5
B!M"03LK+=A"/5"! # 31CNW&#+#
$",# &I( $2I X X, "! # 1" S# N$6U
$",C ' > B# K+#= . H; KV- X; B G# ,i
~&, 2+3"#= A"/!# 2I4 NHDU H +#5 LM !+J 2# G#
Ko"

#* suI(
X3-" X/| KU $ l/ B +# 2/8# qH& -,$; 22Q B
K&/5stuW+A8/,XI"X/|5K"#5XK" #Wp29,

YL" #5(
8/-"+Y.YVL uo"P,XK" #; 2&BH I3
5,#+3*",-"+D!"[CI,-"5+I#I,
-#L KX5-"#, -" 5 .L/, -" W_ 0!D9, -"
#* sEF
VL u5 0 +5 =&O# o" P, XK" # +3Q ^ j* +
KkS45;aLUX5H#/$#j-?55
+`#VL u5: .#+#gRD2!"-4+#;#S.LX;2,3^
K2+3"#HI"JC=$2# "&<^5&348y7l--#
<+Y5-"#5W_VL uRD&I/8!"
s [-+yx6C2!/+,
P, XK" # p28". 8L HI"JC ; K+I# VL u 0SOU
Kd9 ?<#TUGHI"JCH9,0 v #8S 58,px-5P&YE
215+`#VL uRD
3X;BHI"J2[ C<J #)+1B
H!D!X&YEX8LK-!8/2,C,215W_VL uRDC5
jYyU5K(}BD!21,m".Cf'#P1/Ey#!5HI"JC
$52,
34 +`# WO =. XL $"YC -5 +`#= .
+ uWO=+#5~$2B d{ 8LKHI"JC^G [
KN2*"=C #=^+S".<+d| 5
=.0(B !8 HI"Jp2;+3QB!BY;-5
VL*LKN$HU+MJ#RDd9?5;B5K+`#WO=!l/5
K"`N3=+!DTUN$HU0 X;B 5LKn2# ,#
K8+L,#I/DS"YC2&#BRL"4+`#WO+#9B#
dF = -= 5S4 BD /# : .# NSy w3Y = X; !y
=+#g 0( B $[ 8[D $-" E+J(9 5 .-# $+"(C
-# #5*!L K2", = $2I =+#} X9 : .#
Hansman (1996).
6
#* sEF
RD /4 # 5 K

3D </"! $52 # TU GH4 8.SY : .#= +#,
TU34$C B 2,C,.SYZ ".RD81-IP-
lY Z ".
: .#= +#g BD /4 #= L Kp2c +3*"# RD; Z ".
81 TU v "# : .# Z ". B RD; Z ". B c5/4 i +-+&'#
K$[
d Y9 GHI"JC
l/#` ^ # WO a/# +!; 8l4 / B5
+&YE $|} D / 7| B5 `# a/# Z ". B RD; Z ".
2&#5 K+-+&'# 8"S+5 +'-4 5; : .# NSy 3YU X5H : .#= +#}
23/#5;+#+.#0(B u(2"#` #WOa/#
K8fH;RD&|2J,: .#NSy!fH7D2C(2"#5K 5
-#5 u(2"#[uw3/4$23,`#WOa/# $23,5
K+*v
0( B $[ 8"E- B C `# a/# BD /4 # 5
TU>J;## 5&!y$52#TUGHX98.SY: .#=+#g
^ u(2"#B2,CXy##5K8X;B C
2,7JSX;
IS#! & ^ y 3+31 "*! G# p'# X "# 8/#
C: .#MD9B!BXy&#B!d#!QBC2,5K)#d#
K2&#BE-`#WOa/#TU$+"(
> .A problem cannot be solved at the level it was created :)!!` D( D ?

.brainyquote.com (12.2006) :
G "
Chapra (2000), p. 25.

#* sEF
L5 jYy U E- +`#= 5H9 B +3"# - C 5

Y$3 W|"# NH52 l4 8"+!; < =5H9 B# K+D# k, M#
0 &J+`# WO =5H9XL+D#+1/#B5K+`#WO+#9,
P1 ^ Y5-"# P"# ^ # M" !y Bv- 83S#< + B
+Y5-"# +I#L K31C 4+ !y NH2-" H +3# +`#= 5H9< M
<K 4^ry;+#-L.SYjJ #^5+D#+1/#Bry;Y5B!M"4
K

+I("iv"#/Y/"#
TU34,=Dr"#5;=J2I#RDvJ+#`#WOa/#
hr"#BDo"X5-"#5KX5-"#5;0H&"hr"#0(B#BRD;
1X5HPL'#I<!yx+#H&4JD 8LX.15;z
69P,=J-#h Y;TUN$6m#c2+SB5K.L/5;
,"y^^ yBS+"?DG#7+.3"#L5Y.YM/#1.`
W <&.#=H-#
KEdependenceFH!"DC K
KEindependenceF03"C K
KEinter-dependenceF0H&"H!"DC K

Covey (1990).
3
#* sEF
T591^v(I5B(}RDH!"DC 059h /#
Yd# h /# K55 ; RD #D X )+1 X.Y! D B
BD /-5 H 3". X; 8+L # 1 5 03"C
dy9 1 ^ I 5 0H&" H!"DC) #d# h /# KB(}
3 X; B P3". 6; P, +#H&4 J-#& I4 )+1 AMY
K3,.#=J-#3+3*",HS/4CIB78/#
H!"DC J-L KGHI"JC a/# ^ 8,3 c |d# h Y9
B(} RD 2!"- p'# X )+1 z hr"#5 X.1 ,34
)+1 ?5- ,3 03"C 5 Yd# h /# Khr"# B 2+S".
)#d#h /#K(}p'#BD3".v_*"IBDpy)*&
Dr4j.+#J-#K0H&"hr"#5X5-"#,3 0H&"H!"DC 5
= -, P, <! 23" 1 , M ?5- C5 M
ByBD V+!"3".D Y ##&I45hr"#=-,5?5-
Kh /#TU3+3u[<^+D!"[C=J-#;~5KPD /#
B# 8; W # J ^ =J-# h Y; TU 7# Xg3# $6; 2J5
DS6C5 (C5+L<+,C
4X;&JB7y/JK$ 3SY; /g
JD_5hr"#5X.1BDS#5?5-<+&#LKEN3&#F
R,3# G "U5 X.15 02-#, XU W # J /5 K#H&"
G "U5 hr"# ! X.15 ?5- ! 02-#L KE */#F
Khr4C5M?5-L#H&"JDR,3#
Gintis et al. (2005).

#* sEF
8L=J-#Bh /# RD7fJY5-"#P"#X;31CZ/5
, K"{ P& 5 K=?5-> , B C5 =&c> , B +#
BD 8, HS/4 N$ I, +Y.Y= J-# o+ 4 B += A"/
K2+3"#=A"/

b wx5(
;2& K/ ?D M"3 3'/ .."# B# +A8/, I" ;2&
N2DJ5;IYjS#(UCUK E5u=-^v9X;RDw/
X;5 ;2&) +1 B Ns+( +Y.Y N'S# X; RD 7fJ 5 K+D6
'S#[= +"1C h&6U 8L2 !D +D!"[C5 +# =-"#
K+D55u8+Lv9Xy##5
-" !+L =z RD Vy h# X; 2i <"# 8/ <&""5
!+L=&[ #RD2y/#&#,0y;5,#y+`#=-,
# +#U $6; &.# K=J2I#5 NyV#y +`# WO =LI"#, -"
h#/A" J'LVL 18+#U<L24#0!D9X;B $
RD Vy , 8"$ ^ p'"# TU # MS e# 8+D 2+y"# NHK
&.,+`#=LI"#^0u! yK5A"4e#H521X+,58&84
-L2# VL u o-M4 2J #= LI"# ; K05 ,#' # VLu N J
KVL u^w3/#rA+#8+D2yh#XL=J2I#5=Dr"#y8+#U
.52530 1
1

J
.525/

5
#* sEF
RD8.SY[$2#,VyC5NyV#RDWdy2yXg3#2##5
3*+# , N$A"#5 .# RD <A C h# X9 +# K:K#5 0
K+D#=8+[ "#P,5'S#VL uP,XK" #
+#=-^/-#5$2#$ X X;M"34uN2DJ5
!yYy$;5565<+&#
1;+#5$m#5,#5=z0 v;
KN2D3# RD /, +*v 23-#L 8,/"[ U =z XL K<f6
K E}(5</$"!21;P-23D IX;$2[5U##5
+#2#VLK E,f3#;+#2#X+,VG#< /,f3#XL
Kv#L Y9
!.NfH X; RD 0248YLK#$",#~9uN2DJ5
+;N2D3#2-4##5KH25$ IYL
zpcH521C
K++#=A"/' 4578L^

*!6FI(+ y5
22QXLz=- +`#=-^$2#$ XyU5
X;!-#$J2J5Kh /!NfH22Q^2+SX +=-0 v;
5;,#WB;21;TU<[4 $+"(C= -^+D#=+8/7l-
X5K8ETU<[ 8L$m#;57l#TU<[ 8L,# ;K$m#
85 W # J !8/+, <5 G&# b .# ^ pC $5[ !
./ . ?$ :

G " >
/
#* sEF
$m#J/j3&2J5 KE>V19F C
8[ XyYUX.Y
/+, yx -#5 ,# _ ^ B TU / W/ ##5 +IS4
K$m#P,5

b#
K5!.# XH9 # RD j3S4 , ,# 7*",
HS/
P, IS4 8Y; ,# $ v ?5; d{ # 53# RD N2fS# 5
+Y 2 02-&IX;#RD4x5KN5d#2# 0H&"#P,5 !"#
^ +Y 2 XU )+15 K3+3u 4/# 02- BD
3".5
IS/
XL BV# $5 HA !/4 , 3+3u a/#= +M"3 <M C
l/#
R"13+3uHI"JC Bh;[$2,HHKC5 !/#(^4+Y 2
7|B&I45KX 2#8,L #8-BC[$HTUI45+Y 27JS"4
RD
+3| e&D5 HI"JC"! ^ . SVY fc X 2# RD 2f S#
K(2#
X 2L K .# RD +/#5 +D/I# 052#
^ +# vu 5
,L #$-"& 5$C5HX +4{TUI4
+#+9 u
B$+ Bdy;TUI"L X 2# o4S4;K$ l/Z2^
K /2f S#
.3/3 ./ %

.620 !)* 1 @(
4
.publicdebt.treas.gov (12.2006) :&E

& aN R8

6
#* sEF
5;2f S#&.YXLN2*"79=+fI1U.*&L+/#052#;
#84$HvBf ^NW3S#052#-&#K5A"4B2#2(R!.
!y K 3#(2#792L#7|B5&-I#!-#79$2Id{
RD3S/4h !X 2#2(RD+3L9N$3#05H:SYUh !K5A"
K8+/ +*I#D#
+3Q5 (2# NHV# 2D.
D X X; B C
2, !"# X; G;
+-Z ".$ 2"# &&5 +D e&DN2fS#
lY^&v;+L#
GHI"JCa/#&v;GHI"JCa/# H( !"#X X;B C
2,5
K !"#H(
^78.#LM!+3#BX X;xSv9"! ^#2fD5
k&M/ WO !/# < B#5 +3+3u= -"#5 0H&"# 0( B 83+3Q
XU LM! +3#& ^ +IY B Wd, ry; !"# 2fD &I +Y 2!#
X; B C
2, GHI"JC! /# ^ +&
D !"# -i 5 =2[5
5; , <? # +*I4 7" 0u -+&',5 K+,iU
D X
KX 2#N5jQ:/"(CX +HI"JC0XL(,
C5 ;VA" C V[ `#"! # - + -# X; 2 c5
< /[TU/&[W. !"#2fD&I#,53+3u0H&"#BDS/
"S+55 !"# -+& < S" 5 K0H&"# 2# # LM! +3#
+3+3u= CH&< +A45 +8.4 !"# B p2c Xy !L KHI"JC
World Bank (2005).

www.africaaction.org (12.2006).

#* sEF
^ +# c5 K+3+3u H 3-#5 h +&# -,4 + H 3-#"! ^ # Xy
^/ X9 ,# 2I3, Hn"! # *!" 23D + -#
$( 5X 2#7JS4TUGHY;!yKHI"JC"S+55 !"#-+&

23 "! #L K; GHI"JC a/# H28 N'+.# H521
K2# #LM!+3#<3L" X "#+Y 2 k&?^Rd+#}
T59L K3#[ ^ 9! +J5 <+&#[ ^ 9! +J P, :S# P&" 8,5
H3# P1^0H&"#LM!+3#<Lx48Y9D6# &3
KD6D /&I4##5!+3#B
:S#2+-,21TU&/D3".B2 #50H&"#<,"#B2 #P,:S#5
8.3Y5 ^<M+-+&'#+_LK+Y.#+_5+-+&'#+_P,
+_;KJ'#"YS"MD9H;/4B!M4#7.Ek, M#
"Y$&"DX5HoDM"45+f34 !/4,k, M#c<ML+Y.#
RDJ'#RDY.#
$ #"* A+"/#X 4##5KJ'#7.E
5K##-&4.SY
$ #b57.Eb8/#X 457.E>.1
RD *".45X 2#! /4WN2fS#
lY^+Y 2!#2X;B
8/# X ".L #y 9 b4 U5 KA"/= 21 #> .1 RD N5d#
U /# :2v5 KP/25 P/f2# W<+!E N$.(5 HI"JC 0*!?
K
s JTUWI4"&JDXLdyXU5,#W0J

Buckman (1997), p. 9.
.h?
*g? *" hV ) 'A! *
f g8
.(JJ)
(3J) "& '$( .'&!
C.! ) X

3

#* sEF
"#5(
W+#=A"/' 47G#9;2&P&"&0(B5
=+MS4P,+D ? =$&"DC <+I#=+MS"#P,"#YU
BD BV#= +MS"# 0VD ,#L K+3+3u N5d# 2+# 4 P,5 N5 BV#
'_5 BV# XU )+15 K'_, 3-"" # 0VD $m#! /+, N5d# 2+# 4
+ -# 44 X; &O B & !y N215 !-# X8[5
K-B97*",
BD#h'3#pTUGHN5d#2+# 4BDN5BV#IL5
=J-# -+& < 7A./ C5 </'I
IS# B#5 K3+3u h'3#
P,IS#3,o+#4-i 5!".X;BC##5HI"JC
NS# 5 9 IS# p2 J/ $"!, 2V"4 PD'3#
3+3uh'3# o+#"#<L2+G#XL8/#^5Ko+#"#S(5
K# 4 p-?; o+#"# X "5 +-S# N5d# $2I Y9
K2&#/PD'3#P,k,x#5"#3,

zJ"#/"#S
B#5 GHI"JC a/# RD H +J "-+&', S "#; 2&
TUW4=$2#X;&2J5K8MSX;C+["Y2V4X;8Y6BH +3#
^ . $52#, +/-= $2#5 KNS# B w3/4 H +3# y +# Y;
S(^78.4=.8?S4#H +3#X;RD2y4GHI"JCa/#
#* sEF
GHI"JCa/#<L2G# wI"#5 K+4 -5+f[o+#"#

a/# "/ 2++3"# B h Y 3+3u ^ X5J / X HI"JC $J !y
KHI"JC=21 #
KV-+3+3u0 v9BDILX;X5=3"BDX -L25
'_B#5K+["Y<LG#!-#7+.345wI"#Bh YY9NS#
!yG&#B#$(H [5</"5X9^CU2[ CH
8S
KwI/dy;23+3ua/#BDILX;-5K&
H +3#B2VL7|B5ry;,<J #B>xJC-wI"#L
<J # BD H-",C - 2A"#! /+, GHI"JC a/# RD +-S#
^/ 3+3u ^ 2A"#L KNWd# 42+3-4 8?S4 # H +3# B oS"#5
KD Y;21;X X;BDMLwI"#

#6D"*2 -.
# &3WOX ",#2I3,23/#,23/##H&XL"#;2&RD/,
+3+31I/DB!M"4X;i#H&XL+D50H&"#LM!+3#>+m#
3+3uI/-#H [5B#5KD6# &3X "#=2_5<L/5<.#y
SL KK A#+Ly&&+#Y;CU,#2I3,0H&"#*I#6Y y<
2I3,U5LM!+JG;2# 4C<L/5;<k+ 4B=CuBWdy
#H&&I"LK+83S#+u,+$4pD 50H&45; !"#
8"/#8.SYA+"/#TU8"/4C5Y !M8/#N$ v56# &3
North (1990).
J
#* sEF
+5 =2_5 <.# 0H&4 &I+L K+#= 3" 5; N2fS, 3# 8+#U
-,40H&45 !"#X X;BC2,05245 !"#-,4
a/# BK 345 0H&"# B p2c -4 XU +uL K0H&"#
GH48/#^8Y y<L2+ #5D &"<,"#-A"LGHI"JC
<+ B!M"4 8L 3+3u a/# BD 0H&45 !"# IL TU
K8/D)2u&#.+5,#RD&4x2S
P, 5; 3+3u5 N$ I# P, J-#! O &., /4 +u XU
YL(}RD23Xy!8LK2v35=[P,5;X !M5#
3S#, v( j.+# 5 K;2&) +1 B +u B oJ H2*+
=+&3".5=$+"(C,-"!+L,m#X Y3#=^2[5,
&z! lY, -" !+L 8.SY /4 !y K8/D )2u! & y
Xy #= y# B WO5 X5YU y6 K; ^ # 8 !y +#
0; h+?W(;5!lY9RDpS"#C^+;$5H+#&=D"#
KB!d".
J(9 2-&# +-? # PY 3# BD "< # V+ B#
&I YE X52, K=LI"#= ^ +/#5 2v3 ^ ;| d!" G#
p."DC5 0m"C' / -?( 1; &I45 5( /, <"#
N2D3#RD83S#S4c5K+#I>.1RD+fVEI3
0!D9 U W+*I#) 2u RD /, 2v3 $ 9 W+#
Partnoy (2003).
.324/
&
5
/
#* sEF
5K/.#5>"# IYBWO5 Z Yq#U5=+/#,

K2v35 f # P, 5; 3+3u5 N$ I# P, J-# - H2Q N2D3#
W+#2/8##"#;2&TUYH 35

(a*5(
<!u/4RD#C2#3S#0 v;^
2".&/'I
=2[5 U 7u RD NH I3* I 4x4 )+` S+"# 7u D
S17*"#B!u5$_!7Q-LK#+M"3-#
K$ov5+L2[5y7QB3*"4!u53-#
X )+`/H I3 p2c< 23-#/4 /&/,H5
!fB2,CY;-5K-B, 'A+"/#!f5&/23-#
215 S4 C N$ I#L K2v3 < f # L 45 X !M < #
$r4Cm#LKM;215SCm#5p2cX;!y#"/7 3"#
K-B9K[ B2,C,m#r"#S4C+ #X;!y+ #
Nr-#L$-"#2[5XL3+3u<$-"4# &32s -4N$ I#5
S#9,CY-5 2v3,Nr-#W+83S#N2D3#0 #2 5K3+3u,
Xs ;P&4XUB#Kc/!M"5Y-RD#HS#9X;v9L KY&5
KH I35R/-,e/+1Nr-#L23-#^/H I3X;5S#^/R/-
.(453) -
(9 "& .CI LK

.6/265/J 0$ $/ :

G " >
4

&
JJ0
A :> .. I
8 ) !" -I!V
36
.J52JJ6/
#* sEF
WP"1X;i#"/7 34XL#RD/,5
^ e/+1 l/+L # &3 jYy XL K"/ B m#5 p2c ^ l/# K
K0 &3WO2","/L# &3B4XU5K=[
C &3"/Xy*+*vjYyXL2J-"#^[=l/# K
K=[-[
V#CU5

XLK+#U0 v #2".f #^l/#[5D5p2cXyL
*+*v23-#X +L-+ #5m#+D5e/+13QD5jYy
m#LD5WO+ #B#D5p2cXyXU;KY !M56
/ >9BD)*&#5=[+*I4i,+ #$r4C
jYy!8!L2",D5WOm#jYyU;KD5m#0 v #
KE#lYFh5WOp2+*I4^G2BL+ #
/+t-#P,5#,#`P,Y$3#RDd9?5;B5
0 Iu50 ! 5p'#,#+3*"#p284`LKS"$ I,
,# X9 h5 PL2c y5 K+!-# 5 Yd# p'# -.# RD
N["5;hS"YC[9-.#RD0 IuX;!y$,h5p2
Kh52I3M; 8,
f # ^ l/# +#"# N '_L +D5 Kh5 ` B p2cL
^ (245 -.# 0 ! "! X; A+L Km# c N"[= 5
e#-.#{&J#V[}<+&#,2D5X C;i!yY!?

#* sEF

?(
B1
&
B1
B1 ?

.
: -C
D-
/
?1
- -C
D-
/
?1

B1
-
/

#"/7 341WEF0

- jL " L KB2#, B2#< +, 5; 2/D +# <+, ^ (2
KC
&3A"/X "L-+ #5p2c+D58+L3Qk, M#
dy;,3+!-#?u23/#WL 4 /+t-#Bp2cXL,3^5
WOB5K ., G ,#3#p2.SY p2c5K"^/
,# 7Q J/ U D5 5; *+*v p2c X X; 0 &3
j/!M4XU5D6# &3X 4X;BC/+t-#XL+D5KvMJ/
#* sEF
y X9 WO5 NK+u5 X!M#5 &3#[= U jL "5 -.#{

BD m4 C + # +D55 h5 p2c
2".4 C = [
Km#+D5
+S+yBDl/#m,.[$2D5V/_7u
1h#X;#WlY5
.SY 7*# X9 5 +!."# 5; +y"# 7*"#< < S/ L K`
mC#B#D55&+
-Y9
uXL,3^5K5[$
7*#XyLK*+,#+D#k, M#f5+!."#5+y"#[ >5BD
.SY 7*# Xy U B# +y"# +D# [= h&4
V# &+ .SY
K&+C1-[^,#[=UG2BL.[$

6D"* %. D.{
NS#5 +D# +J2I P, <! 8Y, += A"/ K"{
^ -# 2v3 3 G#" #; 2& B <&/4 +J2IL KHI"JC
/i G#& /; 2& 0( B NS# 3*"4 !/+, LM! +3# +3Q
!-#2/D!8wfI_KA"/WO$ I#^h J #=A"/
K+#=A"/' 4RD
K8/'/4#2&#'3YRD/, '"#=+A+4xo+/I4B
B X 4 5; E-# Y[ 5F # "/ B X 4 X; U 2&#L
WO 5; D5 X X; U "/5 KE'# Y[ 5F +!-#[= +"1
W||C
U '"#/X "LKh5
.! I!7 :>
3
#* sEF
Kh5WO"/Nyz K
Kh5"/ *"# K
K+-S#[=+"1C"&<4 K

Q|}
K
+# + D/I#< J5 ^ $ dy9 > 9 Nyz
A+LN2fS,3#"' > /XyLW.&#O^84L5
2+,?123YTU8"/4#+I#0(BN2fS,3# 2,BD)*&#

23 G2+3"# pI Xy U5 KpI!# " ^ / dy; ,3 +!-#
)+`8.SYA+"/#3Qm+v2iX;ipIL[9-H #
NH2N22-,/dy;+!-#pIB!M5pI!#23Y+!-#7.
K5
#8.SYA+"/#5, 'A+"/#22QS7"X;-4NyzL
j.+# EWO5;78;5;XH-F<k+ 47"7|G ,#"/833
A+"/# RD 8/# ^ 0 Iu Hn +!-# C5 pI!# C NH I3
5;+!-# B2Xy /dy;,3?u23/#/5, '
K/&#
^ D.#5 # 8.# V K,L K=+& c5 V c +A8/ 5
'"#5)*&#^jJ #528EBWd#9"'LK=A"/' 4
K<.# k+ 4 0( B 2+345 : .# ^ Af#= A"/ -," H ,
#* sEF
X &3 C !-# Xy U N23= A"/ 5$ X!? - $52, 5

K+WO=A"/

Q|}6(
W+A8/c=+&.#BWd#b/,3^B#
3+31C+6H +JH&I4+D#k, M#X;=+&.#05;K
=A"/, !-# D/J o-M 5 K8f$5 B HI"J! +J C5 8"Q
Bl $-&#5K2",&$56"! #-i5+
:5S# BD )*&#
2D5 '/5 3-# +'-4 M"3 -#,
V"#C X;
v MJ/ J/ o# 5 K ,#5 += A"/ P, +-S#
3-#0!DU5,2"#5S"#X$ -#/.#5>"# IY
X !M!# <,4 8L #; 5 E5 X !M, ; Nr-# - !y
K&!y+D23+#5
$rC8L Y+1;RS2J+D#2D 3#-,B!u jYyU5
8!D B 8!D -'J ",| !uL K2",! u H [5
2D xL
[ # , K
v; H [5 S/# $r 8, 8E +#5 88[ B 88[5
S"# -$ 8, 8E& I X; C 8- RD p-"#5 8/D )*&#
K8Y !MB+D#k, M#
=. ;
3fD5 e&D +D# k, M#& I4 Nyz^ 5 K
^-+&'#B5K+L?US4H,LM!+JG;3QCU+#
=A"/X "#+!-#RDS"#+#=.s!QX;#u
#* sEF
A+"/#8/#^3Q8Y;< ,#=A"/BSydy;N23+
K8.SY
E- 05Q5 2+3"# D/I# /4 2+3"#= A"/ XU )+15 K

V".4=A"/NyXLE#Â/4XU5F 8?;584
B 2V Ny
V". $52, 5 8.SY 95 =!# -"#
<,45 Z2vH8/#^+D/I#&I4)+` 2+3"#=A"/
K2+3"#D/I#
/4#=SY8/D/4dG ,#3# N23=A"/L
K#5245B2##52E[u5N2fS#=C2-Wm4dG ,#3#BD
NWm" N2fS#= 5H; Nyz N'M 8.SY += . 2 c5
Einterest
swapF N2fS# M35 a
*"#= 5H; Ny $52,

V".4 #
M;N'M8.SY+=.2!yK2+3"#D/I#^N2f.#
K8,3-"=A"/f5X 2#05245B2##52[=5H;Nyz
RD!f3#=A"/5=5H9B ',x l/BV[G ,#"/L
3# 58;5 l/[ 2+34#55KNH2$5S.L
5v/D5 l/=5H;fNyz+D/I#iN2fS,
!E, -,4 &I45 8"+I6 23S4 X, NH28 + D/I# -i
D/I#8/Y-4#=59yXL#,5K ,#D/I#
!"# X X; B C
2,5 K+ D/I# TU $52, 3"/" ,#
&I
+#-#8/Y-#HI"JC!=#u
K=cZ(;+*?o#
#* sEF
oI"/ ^ 2+3"# BD oJ "# += . -, =$J U5 K

^8.SY=2[55J/"#^j-J58fH&58"+I6RDS1'#
^M{#=.<.L/RDN$HJWOj*&v;5H52.
oI"/ôJ "#,X CK9B5_5K8"8YTU2+3"#+!D
K;&-#2D JW+m4RD!-#52&#B(gb .,,'#
B!?-##57| ,#D/I#8"-?5#&-#2D 3,0 &3#;
K23:S(,8+D
#58L+D#W-

&/WO2+3"#D/I#8234#=A"/<+X;-C&5
B#5 K8, 1; 8L 2[5 RY; B #? !uL "! #
Ny P,5 fH&5 "! # S.L <
" ~&"J P, :L
HI"J# MJ/ 8"S.L 2.i5 ,# l/ +D
34 G#~ 9
K

'"#
5;v/D-, Q7|D60 &3"/B2&#"* #,H I3
X; ,$M 23D ^ ax6 # # 0d K22[ "/ 0 v # #5 fV[;
!yK4+!y2J-"#2/DX X;BC2,!-#2,2-,07+.4X
B5Kdy;5;PA"/B22["/:3"6^+A+4xC+&'4B
N$[WB23DB3"$&"DB23D 8Lh/I"C23D#d;
.(36) "& @: .C.! )
:? I PA !b !GI
%
3
#* sEF
K!8/yBD8,HS/#4"/#7.#5
8,5K(g<H7|"/ Q0(BP"m+I#P4+&'4B5
yX 4B#0u-+&',5K=A"/B#I1C2+# 4B3'#
lY5# &3=A"/2&#'3YX9lYB#D6# &3 =A"/
K0 &3#,18/NW&y&.YX ".Luv9X;TU
+/+E= +K$ _ R!. +A8/ +&'4 0n ^ B! B5
v/D TU 2", # &3= A"/ +Q 7" )+1 KEgenetic
algorithmsF
0( B v/-# +y4 NHDU RD !-# 7| E=/+E d{F NH2
7"5KNH2W-L5vu=A"/7 347|2#0(B5 *"#
K/+-[$2,=A"/NH [^B.*"#&.Y0M"4X;TU3'#$4
&/ 0 1 '"# NH2-" =C ^ +/+E= +K$ _ j2" 2J5
K+#=A"/' 40^X}R"1&'48l!+L8/#

T#6<",F
+3+3u[= +"1C +Q5 p" RD 2!"-4 +A+4xC
=[+"1C ,A"C5 K7c &/= A"/ 7+!I4 RD !-# 7| !-#
N!". $H '" 8/ 5 K$",C5 h2, $2I !-#
C5KcK#+/S#5+/3"#+#9' 4RD!-#5!-#[=+"1C
dy;5Z52[dy;,3 ^8/#SX 42J+A+4xCX;$
S/4#2-,7|"/+&'42,^-S4X 4&#OS"#5K+["YU
Goldberg (1989), Holland (1995), Mitchell (1998).
33
#* sEF
#.B#K+#=A"/^NH"-2uS"#Z ".TUo+#"#
Z52[B!M47|B5: .#Bry;&.Y>'3"Â/4C5;$H&4
K2",N22E=A"/
+#= A"/ 5; =5H9 P,5 -S# +"1C P, k_ 7" Wdy
+"1CB##"/5;NH;3#LK=[+"1Ch&62".
23/#
2".+ #= 2_ 5; <.# U5 23/# RD 0 Iu +# -S#
H,3##'#+-S#[uH 3/#j.+L K8y"[9
0H&"#= +!D
{ U5 84# H4 C !"# ^ , ' H 3/#L K+5
p2c 0H&"#LK3+3u0H&"#{
+5 !"#Xy##5-S#
=[+"1C +&"# +5 "-+&', !"# Xy U5 K# +5 H !"#5
=&+44^pI0 (H
V". =[+"1C+&4RD!-#L+-S#
"+!-#XyLK+!-#8["#+3+3u=2_5<.#23<
8E<4&+44
rX;pI!#B!+L/+-=2(5;<#23/#
MX;+!-#"C)+`
d #,# `0(B-f&#
7|23/#RD0 I*#[1LK<J ^4[Uy7!",pITU
-i5+D#k, M#L5N6&0H&"#{ 7",0H&"#{
U
&.#5 KG2+3"#"! #B NSydy; ;2&)+1B "! #
K0H&"# 5 !"#Bp2c,6&&4$

#yBf2#
^#L 3, X HH2.#23/#"+!-#XyU5
+y8"O9U3S/+#23/#"$52,Bf2#LK ., B2^
Al-Jarhi (2002).
3
#* sEF

{ H2-" RD X X; pI!# B P"#u^ 5 $!d" 5;
H5;0H&"#+58/#^23/#LK++I#L50H&"#[=U
L 4 2/D B Y; - 5 K++# l/# L5 EveilF >A1
=[U +44 0( B 23/# BD W&y 21 TU /m"C K# +/3"#
>+m#?^p2c+3Q-I#BXy$5KN6&0H&"#+!D

,U f55 0I4C +/34 ^ fc
23"# XL
+# ; $5M# +/3"#
L50H&"#{
K#=+!-#{
U2[8.#BY;-2-,BDH 3-#
K+D#k, M#
HI"JC=+!-#^f.#23/#$5H$. +D2f.#C5
d^5 KEcash-less societyF23/#B+#(&3"."!<^n&I+5
23/#X9E#N23=A"/5;FN2fS,3#RD0 I*#R/-C<!"n
5v9 0H&"#,k&4"! #&I7|B5C3", '2-
7|B5#h'3#53+3uh'3#P,k,x#BKV-5K2f.#k!/#
!"# +D
3 G#; 2& .SY 5 K+["Y KV-5 NS#< L
!"# XU &3".L KN6& 0H&"#, !"# k,$ 5
K

Shiller (2003), pp. 73-75.
3J
#* sEF
~
0(BU$ l/B+#2/c--,IS#7
d;
23
H3# IS# K+#= A"/"' # /5 qH& K,; 22Q
KN$HU5a *"#0^+3+&'4

E F

< <v{j<{{{c<l]+_

r_pxD,YL#5GHI"JCa/#-+&BV[X;&
+# XU a *"# B p2cL K !Q X5H ,$ +3Q +*". B
S+ #)2u
8S 58+DN'+.#5 84$HUU5>/"[
Y[ N'+ ^ d!" 2+3"# D/I# 8[ 4 G# :K5 Kp$I
N2# = CH& RD SI#= CH&& O5 a *"# Y[ RD LKn
a *"# +3Q ^ A/4 =A"/5 =5H; 7+!I4 ^ XU G2*"#L KN5d#
K/5LKnNfHTUpA/4X;X5HN$HU5
!y 8S+/I4 B p2c 3Q X; B a *"# : N2D b/
W
KGHI"JCa *"# K
KY5-"#a *"# K
G2J-"#a *"# K

Nothing ventured, nothing gained. Bernstein (1996), p. 256.
Heffernan (1996), p. 163.

'"#6/I5EF
HIJ"KF"' #
< 2J-4 =&+44 ^ 0 (2#"' 4 C # a *"# +#; , H5
^ O# w# ,
3 HS/ a Q 8L a *"# 2I3, Z(; p;
$!d"C 0 v9 < /4 82J;5 +#9 K,;5 K> /"[
8[ ^ ML; r_ pxD, 5 KEdiversificationF
K
B!+L K"! #, -" !+L S" $ I, < /"# +&'4 B5
2+7.#P,5[}<+&#P,8lL< /4+=.!#
+f# N 3# S 5; 7M"# - [}< +&#L K!8/ y
2++QBKN2+-,5;' "0[g=H 3-#jYyUv(
+# .= H [ &I4 )+1 D /" < ^ 7 H 3D 0( B
+f#N 3#S5;7M"#LK+-.#X 2#523/#X 2#BlS
N 3# hS4$ ? - <.#! +J S X; !y <.#! +J hS4$
V".
!+3# RD LQ X; +# .!# B #,5 K23/# X 2# +f#
2++*"#< /"#o+ 4Bo+y31CZ/5K84$!d"5c v9+3+3u
K# +.#52f-#dZ(;

#2e -#~
P, |!"#
2D =y#5 =.!# N $HI 7; B
K=L5I5=HP,5;=, 'P,5=H [
'"#6/I5EF
&.#R",|!"#+3QRD=y#Q 3+3uh'3#^
Edirect-to-costumerF 6&< +&#5 Ejus-in-timeF G$ S#" Y d
Q!yK=L5I5=HP,N AS#w34#=+/3"#B 5
5; NH$ = . P,5 8/+, "# B h Y +3Q RD =.
Kf8/#'#,A"h;5Y5dy;#"Yk(&I+#N2+S".
=y65 p$I v( 2+3"# +#= . 2 ,3^ 5
NW&yN ALH [5RD;2!"-4)+1+3/#TUA"4G$A"#P"#
,#vL"S42JN AS#X;B7O#,5K=, '5=H [ P,
P"#5Vyp$IYUTUDHG# 5ry;2# 48Y;CU
KP"#= y# &./#, P"# NHDU TU5 p$I!# &./#, <fH # RD
NV8[9 0( B w3"4 # h'3# XL
- !y5
8L=3"!# 2V"$"YC.S2J5KHHK^,=&+4x#5
+#= . -[ B# KZ(; p ;TU 3/,
34
7|B5+#7f 3#y^0"(CB2V7|B5B2V"*!4
K+#5H5=3"B2V0!-"TUA4
S" 8m+I, y$ RD ;2&) +1 B
34 += .
TU S/4 #,5 P&YE P, |!"# +3Q ^ A/4 #, 5
!/#B$3"dy;+=. -i 5KRYH92u
Kp$I!#G2+3"#
Evans and Wuster (2000).
Kelley (1994), pp. 187-189.
Khan and Mirakhor (1987).

J
5
'"#6/I5EF

(%#"' #
Enatural hedgeF -+&'#a *"# WR!.,.#h /#^$2/5
S/,5;!-#SYBX "#c v;584V"#P,.L 4X; 5
3'/^<+&4y#jYyU0d+&RDK2++*"#W-."#3
84+!DBV[3Y8/!+L!-#2++QÔ45/+-!-,
S/, h'3# c !"# - X; 5; 3'/ SY ^ X "# I#=
B YE c o+#"#5 =H P, +L "# ^ #, A/"L !-#
=Y <L" .78;7++34NHDUh /#(^25K84+!D
Scandinavian Bank
F ^Y2/ /&# D ! "-L 5 84H [
+,$59!= -# B ., !s+3 /&# 0 ~;$ j-[ )+1 EGroup
=!-#SX;/&#h'"8,5K/&#0!D;-+&</"4
K+#=3"H 3D^0 (2#X5H

|x"' #
0 v92?a *"#
2".Edynamic hedgingFyua *"#
B lS /, #( B 7"5 K 5 +# :$595 789y #52"
833Q#8.SYA+"/#TU8"/43',84$HU7"X;RD, '0 v9
#3'#5K2",=3"H 3D^0 (2#X5H=3"H 3D
Steinherr (2000), pp. 29, 289; riskinstitute.ch (3.2006); americanbanker.com (3.2006).

Heffernan (1996), p. 194.
/

'"#6/I5EF
lSz - 0( B - H2*" )+1 =3" W-.4 c( B 7"
RDBo+yII"[<P&45 KEreplicating portfolioFcN/
synthetic
F $+"(C H 3D BD m4 +A8/ +# lS N$HU 0d +&
K: .#NSyw3Y=C1^N/lSz/,Bo+y5 Eoptions

v(VyYURD=-E-,!-45!".$ '4^hS#5
TU<5 RDj3&UGH42J3'#X;TUN$6$25 K,
|9 TU 6& WO , W 5 : .# $3" RD & W|"#
K8.SY=3"!#.#

/"#"' #
~;RD
34X;B,`#0nRD N$HUI"34C
K+`#+#9BY5dy;5NSydy;#X 2J5`$WO
, GW_ X.15 hr"# Y[ RD I"3 C `# WO a/#5
,#p284C+#H&4JDRD7fJ 5Y5-"#YE!+#2-"
< #$"YCB7O#,5KS"$ I,Y5-"#P"#^0u! y
C &.Y d Emutual
insuranceF #H&"# P"# X; CU G$A"# P"#
RD P"# f|5 d{ N2*"= C # SL KP"# D/v B 8, X8".
Slutz (2004).
.Francis (1991) :
G "
Bertsimas et al. (2001).
E.g Laboratory for Financial Engineering at MIT: lfe.mit.edu (12.2005).
Steinherr (2000).
4
6

3
'"#6/I5EF

l/#!"!"<y Kh !nB#H&4P4=.BDN$HI#N+u

; $3"C B +&.Y RD; [$2, Emutually
ownedF
+!# #H&"#
=$2#-&#3L L KEshareholder-ownedF!.+,Y$3

~L [('4jYy!.,y !$(HC=.BXL
jYy !/+, H+= +/+Y!d#( 5; ^ $(HC= . K; /|;
K+#H&4y !=.BK5A"4C&./#
83S# W 2/D D6 h / G$A"# P"# XL +D# +1/# B
X5-"# ;~ RD 7fJ Y5-"# P"#! /+, K$O 23D Y9 Bv-
Bj.+# JDX5-"#X;&2J5K:S4 8L#5,xC+#5
8/+,:S#$ 5K58,&6c,Mz?5-BC5zhr"#
X!? B Y5-"# P"# ^ 0H&"#L KX!M# S"Y? 5- P,5
I"3 , ?5- RD 7f3# G$A"# P"# ;~ d G# -"#
^
V"48[2[ C5MD9=yx6:52/v=H [ RD -"#
X5HMD9&JB$+"("+'m47"X;UVA-#5KVA-#X!M,8"
R/-S"/8,5KVA-#&./,B$M"!# /! -"#+S",5;
V#U
KD6h /!$m#7|B5Y5-"#P"#B?5-
v;H [ WOLKnI/DXLX!M#RD?5- S"YClY5
< K 4 NV+ 3 > 9 X; - 5 KY5-"# a *"#^
Hansman (1996).
Gowlnad (1994), Heffernan (1996), p. 294.

J
.C 7

'8 CVK R. 8 >
5
.J20 )W A8 % =!K8

:>
/
'"#6/I5EF
K=3"8/Y-4#LKn^=h J #X5HPyxP,8"+"S45
KLKn&f6, 4X;X5Hza *"#m+v8L
BD3".PyxX 4X;m&/8L2m+I#3Q#5
h J5 0!"1 :52/I# /A" )+` X $2J K" WO5 8M-,
j+"S4+YUjYy!yD /4dy;X yxXy!y5KN215-LHf.(
Kry;
h Y; R"6 B a *"# += .!# B # RD /,5
0( B 2f-# 5 X!"fC 5 =!-# d
N$HU ^ II" =8[ &J B $245 m# c /4 +Y5-4 H/v
c5 =. B h /# c o# 3"S4 + D/I#5 K
A#BD8+/mG#N$HU0^2&#>+OBY-4
K+D#zBWd#8, #2+3"#+#95=5H#

e#e*c#"' #
!"#SLK2f-#-"Y5-"#a *"#+3+&'"#$ I#B
j,| B2# 5 +!-# ^ BH / 0d +& RD [}< +&#,
U5K23-#N2/|;2f-#Wm4.`Wm"#<MX;BC523-#RM"3
!8Y; 0 !5 +!-# B y 2A+.L = / N2-# 2"{ !"# N2 jYy
S4S/423LK2f-#02--"K,;BNH2-"X?-"
2A+L<S442J5dS4BRD;S4<L2.SY+!-#2A+L !"#
RD|d2fDXyU5Kd2fDBJ;2fDRDI.SY0 !
'"#6/I5EF
!y '_ $HI B $2I d o+#"#5 (2# P, =5S"#L (2#
KHI"JC=Wm"<2f-#[ u/4/B5&
X9 +!-# ^ j,d# B2# $23 W+m4 B C 0u -+&',5
,3p'#*I^/Y;!y8[B+-#k,? J/
3'# L5 Y5-"# > # A# B #u ^ KZ(; 8[ B
K+#"#
G$52# k.3# $23 B 2V X; +!-# B!+L 2f-# 02- <S4$ U
LK#"^G##B2#$23+S,30 !!#-L2G#
$232VX;+!-#B!+L23-#^j&d2f-#: Ld2f-#<S4$
B3&"#UBNHV#7.17"X;RD&./#.`k.3#
B2# BV[H2BA-#u^+!-#LKpI!#"^B2#
+!-#B!+L2f-#02-SU,3^5K+A-"#,3+SX5H
$23 R3& )+` W("# ,3 NHK X5H &.` G$52# k.3# +S
K",|#B2#
<S4$ L WH2.# N2 RD 0u -+&', -/+ k.3# $23 W+m45
02-SU5H2.#N2jMS7|B5k.3#$23HK2f-#02-
23-# N2 X9 lY5 KH2.# N2 7| B =HK5 k.3# $23 S 2f-#
7"X;i!8+LW+m4G;XLPL'#P -Y X;ik.3#$235
5 K23-# YU P1 B
V"#C, +#5 2-"#[ U P1 ?x#,
j,|
V"#RD
34C8Y9Y5-"# >9RD!fJm+I#-i
#8[ P# 8 k.3# $235 23-# N2 -i W(9 XL CU5 W+m"#, S
'"#6/I5EF
W+m"#UB#Kh /!$m#Bm+I#-i7|B52J-"#P11L
K$m#RS"Y7|B5
V"#CRS"Y/+1^?x#,
pI P, 2f L X52, #H&" 5J TU 8"/4 +/!? m+I# 5
$23 +!-# 3 +!D pIL : .# 02- S L K+!-#5
$23 pI 3 +!-#L 2f-# 02- <S4$ U5 k.3# ^ +S"#
3# X9 lY5 Kv9 B2# 0( B 3# .4 7"5 KNHV#
KPL'###HDX 4X;B+&8/#K+Y5-4m+v8L2f LX52,
&I )+` +S"# $23 >.1 B : .# 02- S #1 SL
: .# 02- G5. v9 B2# < Yn 3# h ! RD 2f-#
?x#,#U5KPL'#I3Qm+I#LK+!-#+*v-#5
KD#$5z8/RS"Y&.G2J-4
V"#X5H/+1^

HK"#"' #
?5-H 3DRD!f3#a *"#=5H; G2J-"#a *"#,H I3
!"# H 3D K,, 3-" RD V+yx# 7"+5 K,# 8, H #
,$M 23-, ;2&/5 7.#5 [}< +&#5 ,$M H 3D 5 +
K+"! #H 3D~;Y9

$N
dy; $"# rD jYy5 y$ $ v B N$ v ,$M
P,5PDH P,J-#
;~+#5K$"Y$!d"C5 !"#+#;
'"#6/I5EF
0 ^ ; K$!d"C= ,.u, -" !+L + p$I +&#O

$} 3L5 8S/"4 # -+&'# lY +&'"# NH52 8L o+ "#
WBPD YB!M"4,$M5K+p$I^P-#
0;~$K
f3u>$MS(UB/4#Emoral hazardF+J(95K
K,$Mf"Y

B+!-#+Y!"fCN$H^2+3"#+#9XL0;~$;
$H7")+1WOB[/#+!-#V++{^+LyX "=y#h'J
-"f58"+5N/N$HUTUL?,= /N2-#+#7f 3#
B H2.# RD +!-# N$2J TU w X; 2, C +Y!"fC $2#5 K#,
V++{ ^ +Ly W- 5 KZ(9= Y!M# TU L?, 23/# 43L24
RD +J2"# B 2V S ,$M 23D XU , KWO B [/# +!-#
+&'4 U Y; - 5 KN$._ 0!"1C /&# -"# lY +!-#
KY!"fC"! #BML;5RD;X "/&#+`$XLJ2,W-

&#c#t%#<9(#
B+fV[5;+y0;~$2+X;0 !!#B!+L
234<5
.!# ,$M, !"#pI
2JLK)#|p'#[}<+&#0(
Khalil et al. (2002).

Al-Suwailem (2005b).

4
'"#6/I5EF
"I1 B &.Y <+& X; e/+1 L K84H [ ^ 6 23-# 7` &v;
#,5 K0;~ $ !+J 0H- [ B!d, E
d P4 y6F )#| p'#
G# VE B NHS"C .SY jJ #^ 5 0;~ $ 0 !< +'".
y6F)#d#p'#;K33*",$9^."<y$B,S"1
#B79K23YB!d#<LHX5Hy$I1b"2+S".48YLEP"#
B +Y 2 G; !*"4 C E>$MF !"# B N2+S". . X;
X; - 5 ,$M, 0V C .!# &./#, !"#L K+4x#
Kp9<+I3Qm+I#

+5$X
.9 $N
B# K,$M 23D *I# 0;~ $ 7+.4 ax6 X5 83S# $ 8
7+.4XL7|B50RD+#5!DRD23D,$MX;X5,/u
RD!f3# [ #y6 WlY5 K23-#*v ^6+#0;~$
^78y$5M;,/uV+i#5 ?1 0~;$8+L +#5X!"fC
K+S/u#
0;~$7+.4X5H,$M23D
rX;pI!#B#RD/,5
pI X!M, K#= 3SI#[ , +!-#
3 X; RD >$M!#
!-#8-+&7|WIJ[,<.#Gx)+` [ #y6$ORD
<+&# B] 7".5 N6& H$ !# # B] <L2, pI
3 # U5
.$!N - =
# )I :> .^ ) !" R !& 7 R )& !&
6
. !A

:>

.&L ! 7

'"#6/I5EF
2+Q m+I# KJ&#, S"5 ,# B "I1 >$M' -5
X )+` ,$M23D+&'4 2/DpIc -" 2J#+J(9
KPL'#: 31S$A"#N$52#1yRDhRDpI

<9(#
Bh Y;N2DB!M"23-#K$"Y++I#dy;21;[}<+&#
WK,;
K# +.# K
K2f-# K
K=!-# K

5 KE
d $C52#F NH2 !-, B!d# X X; [} h +&# ^ H"-
K iCU[9 h +&#^v I(B2## ++D4x
BKD6h / 5W("#<pv8Y9?1B!d,23/#X 2#0524
B 3 2J 5 N?1 < 5; X+D, G23/# B2#< +, B!
31C Z/ K+f [H +3#& ., NH52 l4 m+I# B# # +.#
KML;,E-Bo+y

.e < ) R

)* ; "& & )

3
'"#6/I5EF
e#
C5#^j,|B2#$23 X;TUlY[}<+&#^2f-# Kr4
5; ' " H 3-# ^ ? , 8l4 5 KNHV#, v( W+m4 K i
K !5NW&y2f-#Wm4=C!"1&I4)+1[9
[}< +&# ^ 2f-# E- +Y5-4 m+v TU N$6 & 2J5
<S4$UB2-L2G#G$52#5;G8# k.3#$23NHK7")+`
N2$I"(7|B5$23S/,B2#$23+S,32f-#02-
02-SUH2.#N222{,3k.3#$23+S#y5H2.#
WL ", !.4 8/# # B2# $23 ^ Wm4 C m+I# 5 K2f-#
,3 k.3# $23 W+m4 X; !y K2f-# 02- Wm4 B |" p'# # +.#
+#(m+I#-i 5K/+1^PL'#P,?x#,7"H2.#N2W+m4
K$m#5,#B
y$5[}<+&#P,<!E0(BE-M;B
^[gV[WPfV[BB!d#X ")+`$N/B2XyUv(
KA"/ # v; B -f6 + ^ d!" V[5 0;~ $ 'm B2
XyU5K:S4C.1,$9&^+IYBf2#"*.+ [5
B&.Y $&"DLB2^X !M,$22Q[}<+&#^Bf2#
KT5;>,BB2,$;
floating
F NWm"N2fS#,',$BML;-S#B2H,2f-#k,$5
HI"JCl/#^p5-BUK2+[X HI"JCL-&.#Einterest
.78! &! *N ) )%$ ) e!N '

'"#6/I5EF
<LxN2fS#SLGHI"JCH9,+.D'&4CUN2fS#X;
KGHI"JCH9[<4<LxN2fS#hS4$!/+,GHI"JCH9B.Q
N2fL RD I pI 5; Bf2# XL NWm" N2fS# ^ Y; - 5
-"YC ^ B2!# ,# L +L B.*"4 G# jJ # ^ MS/
+L<[xG#jJ #^-S42f DRDpII!/+,GHI"JC
^ L/"# KB2 ;
+`# L 0M"4 7| B5 GHI"JC H9
KN6&H9,'&42f-#XyUH [ WOI

<@E!c#9 *.
B!d#=Y 22Q0(B-# +.#52f-#E-B!B
NH2 !-, [}< +&# ^ B!d# X X; B C
2&L K&/ 3', [}
!-# L?, !4 +# 0 v; N2D B X +# B!d# < /4 B
=215 789 XH- d 23Y WO D6 # &3 C
v; , '
22Q7"5K052"#,3#0 v9BWO5;N$[b vH/I#
^#;$J50 !!#B!M#B!d##UB0 v9&.Y
B!d,-+, 7|d$C5HX +v;6B!M"4+!-#jYyLK+!-#
X + { #B!d#X +.L/BDN2 /,,[g
B!d##UB0;~$+IY KDBDZ2RD'.3$C5H
K[B!d#Bd!+L,#;
WPfV[BB!d#X "X;B$C52#,yB!d#X X;BC2,5
Yd# VE K0;~ $ 0H- 5 $C5H X + G5.5 $C52#, 059
'"#6/I5EF
=2155 <.#5 789y 052"# ,J 0 v; B X "5 ,# d

K 5b I#5H/I#
K5A"4#52"0 v9XU)+*LW215Xg^PL23Qm+I#5
2f.#G;#3L5 052"#,JB!d#X;-8LB!d##UB
B 8,5K+#0 v9BN215B!d#$&"D,Bv-83S#2/D
:^; 052"#,Jb vTUB!d# QB!y# +.#/
G;SC#B##^L v 0 v9X;B7O#,5K0
^ 0u! y 23Y +# 0 v9 0;$ X9 c524 RD H +J
B!M,$/4Ce/+15K[}<+&#-.#,7.#
K<+&#B]/[BD0;~$/[p"(C
=C2-^Wm4G;XL05,C5;W-.47"#52"0 v9XU)+15
2++Q 7" #,5 0 v9 $-; RD -/+ N2f.# 2f-#
XL [} B!d# ^ k3L ,# Y[ d{ 0 v9 XU )+15 K2f-#
B!d#=Y < /4XL8,5K>,"#BD2+-,l0 !0;$
8L K0;~ , $ ?X5H # +.#5 2f-# 2++*", !. [}
5 2f-# W.SY jJ # ^ B h Y; || -4 m+I#
K0;~$5# +.#
'"#6/I5EF
USD Index
DJ Comm Index
200
180
160
140
120
100
80
60
40
20
9/17/2005
7/17/2005
5/17/2005
3/17/2005
1/17/2005
9/17/2004
11/17/2004
7/17/2004
5/17/2004
3/17/2004
1/17/2004
9/17/2003
11/17/2003
7/17/2003
5/17/2003
3/17/2003
1/17/2003
9/17/2002
11/17/2002
7/17/2002
5/17/2002
3/17/2002
1/17/2002
9/17/2001
11/17/2001
EF<.#65EF$C52#6WEF0
djindexes.com and nybot.comW$2I

2++Q ^ =3" B dy; A/4 X; B m+I# X; TU N$6 $25
SX}R"1
LL/!LKC
UB!d#!+J5,2f-#
^<.#6<S4$!/+,Z(9!=-#6
; */,$C52#
$C52#RDN2fS#=C2-;KE#lYFBdy,8.SYNxS#
TU=J59BjJ5^jv5R"1NxS#* ^,jMS23L
Einterest-rate swapFN2fS#RDM3H 3DX;-5KBJ;
!/+,KZ(9!=-#;
5<.#;
$C52#!+J^$ 2"# -"#B4
BW&yV[ -X;<.#P,5$C52#P,[}B!d# </"#B
KSC
'"#6/I5EF
UZ(;+#0 v;5;<.,
V"#C0 &J/!+LB2,-" ;5
5; =y#L KG$A"#! D X2+5 Y -+& < L " # Xy
+&3".<.#-X;8/d05x&#RD8(H2!"-# =u
H2.#, 8+D
V"#C D B oS 5 43" 5; 05x&# B X "4
/, B!+L NH2-" $HI B 4HU 3 B2 Xy U5 K+&/[9! -#,
+3Q 8/# ^ A+"/# X "# $HI .` [} B!d#= Y
KB25Bf2#WPL'#*I
floating
F NWm" N2fS# B ML; <.# 0( B [} B!d# /,5
+.DJD !DGHI"JCH9,N2fS#JD X;B&Einterest

B2++QBI^J/"#KB25Bf2#IL/4TUGH
K,.#* /#RDB2#=Y < /40(

9)# %(.6)*#
<.#, '&4= 2/.# m+v W&y 21 TU & [} B!d# < /45
#52# 23/# :52/v ^ X d1, 81xJ # Ecommodity-linked
bondsF
2f L22Q7"=2/5 K+,m#Vyb /&#-,5#52#/&#5

!+JTUX d1&#W5KNH2< !+J0(BE-!5;Fc;$5;
P, L" # +3Q5 +/# 052# RD +Y 2 D o+S ^ =2/.#
.R $!N * !" P$ $

W !& $!N - ' N )& !&
Besley and Powell (1989), Bornesztein et al. (2004), Atta-Mensah (2004).
J
5
'"#6/I5EF
8"/4=2/.#XL+D#+1/#BB#K8(H$HI5P,58Y H
K&.1[}B!d# </4p23/,23YTU

Q$I _
2, 8YU K !"# -f6 m+v +LI ` 5; #, # `
2# 0H&"# P,5 !"# P, k,# RD 7fJ 2&# 5 N2fS, 3#
K&!yHI"JCqH&<S"4m+v##5N5d#
KM; N$HU m# ` +&'4 B </ b/ +# B#
P,k+ #X 4X;B"*!#N$23#{#+#.L
K|d#p9I8/#^3+3+3u#H&^
/+- !-, < HW" ^ $ . j&O$ U 0d +& RD
[" .L E$C52#F Nm !-, 84HU RD IQ P1 ^ E
d 5$ +#F
2J-"#jJ5P,5$ +#5$C52#P,pI#-p"(.
<.# HW" RD 2J-"# jJ5 pI# - X 23L KH2.# jJ5 P,5
K~9RD83 .45$-;H2Q55$ +#,3$C5H{, '
pI#-&I23Ld86; 2-,<.#B]H2jJ51UB#
KK5A"4N$._-"H$ ".-i 55$ +#$C5H{
currency
F [g pv H 3D 0( B u

234 2+3"# D/I#
KpI#-!*"#H2-"C82#+#.5;/,<Eforwards
23DXL$ L=!-#0H&"#X X;M"34pI#k,? XU)+15
23-, [} pI# H 7" X; 2&# KD6 Vf[ WO [} pI#
'"#6/I5EF
H$ ".!# 8-+& 7| 5$ +#, $s2I B <.# /&# Gx )+` <+&#
+z!" -, H$ ".5 $2I B # #H& 7"4 3'# 8,5 K$C52#,
KP"!-#P,pI#k+ #/&#"*!5
!"#P,2#WlY-S#<+&#P,5[}pI#P,2#5
*I 3Q +LI ` X; !y5 KL5- +LI< ^ ` +&# P,5
BV#X;&5KN$HU5a *"#*IM;3QX;B!+L !"#
K(}'&/!21;RD&'/!LN215!-#X8[5'_5
^0u! y"/3+3u a/#BD0V-7"C/a *"#B#
5K(}BD!21;S/C)+`4K ,G2+3"#a *"#= 5H;
2# a/#,N$HUk,$ 5+#UN$6j3&G#;2&<S"
&I"La *"#S4r3+3u0H&"#BLM!+3#-iN5d#
X;!y{ =3"^0u! ySvj.+#5+,iU8/#^#H&
&I"# !"#S4r0H&"#LM!+3#-i0H&"#"! <#H
HX;!yKp9<+I +3*",!.+,iU8/#^#H&
!y+#: 9 RD# ".4X;BLKn</#H&B!?a *"#
K3+3ua/#,N6&'&45-?(8-i,=3":^; 0u
WO < 5; XH- k+ 4 B ML; !-# 2++*"# m+I# 5
!+JG;3QC<.#8LK+=.-,3&'4!yNH I3
$ I# TU &#O GH 5 ,3 X5H S4 &I4 7| B5 LM
+!D-> 9X;#TUo?;K!"#5&3#k,? 0"(5
RD &4x 2S< + TU GH N5d# 2+# 4 BD N$HU IL
'"#6/I5EF
2[ C#BC2,5KA"/WO<.#+L?S"#<+#=3"
8/#^+!-#X "##H&B2",NH I3<.#k+ 4B</
dy; X "L HI"J# LM !+3# .SY jJ # ^ 335 N5d# N2#
K-NSydy;5+J2I
& # }[ B!d#= Y < /4 m, ` +&'4 B !y

V"#C, O C B2 +!-# X; & G9 L L K8/D )2u
<.# Gx )+` /&# k+ 4 B!+L Bf2# /4 #= Y ,
+!-#<.#<+&7|&/4#=Y .`B!d#,Bf2#B !"#
35 KP"8EP, =5S"#/&#"*!5&/4#=Y ,
^ LKn k&? B!M !y 3+3u a/# 0( B a *"# p2
K=3"^0u! y/D[$(+#5$

2)#
L v < ,3 ?1 23Y 7234 0( B !"# m+v 7.#
X !M D,3$ L !"#723",K"{m+I#5 K#[^
~;$ 5 # +.# W B PD Y B!M"4 8/# KB2^
K0
KM&J&J7.#BH<+,K^[ p_&.,/"L# +.#;

+6;K
-'#2D!+LK EX5+#5</RD$ 8!EL
'"#6/I5EF
2JX e#,#

2Da,M&J&J7.#BH<+,K[ ZWL+!+4B,
KB!M,$

3)+`GK 7.#0(B p_B5_ B!BB#
Y!M,22[7$2v,7.#BH<+&,O$UEBf2#F7.#>$
lY - G, <+&#, # !. 5 K059 7.#= Sv S/, <.#
,$ BD 8/# NfH B [5 ,# # $r X!M# 8L KY!M#
v9X;B$A"#:$59X YJ+Dw/WlYX!M#5 KB!M
H2.#BDJ$ #$2I</"5;d-4 #R"18/!M$A"#J$ #<f,X;
15<f&#X!?;2&!L KL #,W(9Gx
;
V"W(9<f&#XL
C5 $A"# PY 3# ^ p5- ;2& $2I RD h [#
2D ^ Gx
K7.#X HRD3+&'4B</2[
2J 8+L 7. -.#L K0;~ $ ^ 8l4 +3+3u B#
219$M#&.X;B<J "-.#BD7+."#jJ5-o"
M /# B2* I 3 NW&y [$2, B!d# S SL KPL'#
-#5K7+."#jJ5dB]BWd,ry;B!d,GxY9Bf2#*I
M /# Bf2#* I 3 +#D [$2, -.# hS4$ X; U +*v
K7+."#jJ5 N?u: .#B]BWd,J;B!d, h,Y9B2*I
XyG# XH .#^7.#m+vj3&2/D ? ,=85
.J2J63/4 !%
' !

/
.0 &
9

'"#6/I5EF
X.1 2/,!2*"TU ZH; 7M"#BY-

K+DS"B!d#|)-.#:LK5U+L7.+!y+S7")+`

)#2)#
B,
+6K[ RDwY3S#^m+vb/B#
<+!ERD$E=F S B,-#+!4 J;5 +!+4
<L2 Gx X; m+I# X !M5 K7+."# jJ5 : .# -., 7.# 5
P18"!+J0H-4!3#B+!y,3d0$ {0Bm&
WO8/# !+3#NH2!3#BD&+!#LK0$ {[90 1
0( B [9 0 1 2/D $23 22Q 7" 7| 2J-"# jJ5 $23 NH2
KN21 #-RD!+3#!.J5: .#BE
dB'#FN21 #-L-
[ # +!# XL d 0$ [9 jJ5 B'# - Xy L
K/ZD{8!+.4
hS4$L 7+."# jJ5 -.#&= 34 B PL'# y !Q m+I#
-.# S X; !y 8!+.4 [ # +!# S ri e/+1 -.#
"/G#$m#S"/7|B5PL'#I S"48,5K+!#hS4$ri
K(}>.1RDPL'#21;hS"YBD
*! @#) = & : )! !
.62/ 0 1
3
1/ /&
4
.-
L
(,333
' )I ]430 /9 ]62/4/ >
]33/2335/ -E "&
% !" & O U7 X? B8 8 l C
! )!&
.' '
L

0* :> .O CI L%
'
> !% ) :# DI <$ )
'4
.0 ? "/ /$
36
'"#6/I5EF
K*
WX?xDCU8+DH7.#m+I#5
H$5G#$237-#ax6^/5# 8+L7.+!yX; K
XK55
-+y^ o.+L6ô;BW/#)21^
K
-[;TU
-
71 ^ &I ,# X9 ,# B!M"4 R/-) +1 B m+I# X; K
K+L7.-^N2[ 4C5X !M

P, hV/# h J5 </ - 8, 7-# ax6L +L 7. +!, -" ;
/.##&J+D 024!y83S# IY+D 0245 KPL'#
Z(9)H19^H$5^/C[9RD)2u^w/#XLKN8'
#LKhV/#TUGHCX9 5'-#TU5N.+TU+["#B
^BhV/#GH4Cm+I,/D/m"CB;U$2322Q^0 3#
3!+3#,22*"#5K4#H I3L2+#$2322QU$5#
B7-N21 #-.L!+3#22Q2/DPL'#P,hVY/CUp2c
KGx!#8!+.4[ #+!#>.17"/5[90 12/D: .#
RD$I"JCXL$-9^1S#Wm"#^Y;RD26<J #5
0(HURD2"&!yPL'#P,hV/#GHG# $2322Q
KhV/# GH m#< / 7+."# 2/D : .# - .` 23-# RD 2-"#
.' '
L
' =!8! R.
3
.(563) "& '$( .CI LK
3
.' '
L
' R.
33
'"#6/I5EF
KRSC!yGH8"[21 5)d#K5U (2-"#B#5

-.#^Wd#Wm"##1^7+."#jJ5: .#-$&"DC &3XyL
p2c3!+3#,22*"#5KT5;>,B,#RS"YU+3# ^8L
+!# RD +f34 -/+ $-9> ^ ,4 G; X9 +A8/ 3',
7|B5PL'#?$3*"8,5",|PL'#P, 8+DS"! +3#R3&45
K!8/+,hV/#;&>S"/4

b#( 0
)+1 B C ,# B!M" C -.#, 7.#L ,# 8&, -" ;5
W#X+,5K3+3u)+1BC5N$ I#
23-# 8"/5 -5 23Y P, ?5- 9 8Y ^ -.#, 7.# XU K
#H& 5 K23Y ,3 23Y 7+.", +#5 Gx!# +L 7. 7+.",
K8+L$5CD5+3+31
7 .&3X;2,CY9B!M,C7.#>$5;GxXU K
#yXyU5K,,: .#^-+&X;&JY!?^(25C5;+L
< S"4#,5KR/-)+1B,#B-.#,7.#m+vB4
Gx )+1 83S# $ 8 V+i # #, # ` +v
/5 K3&. H25
- ,, [9, 8-+& 7| 23Y -.# pI
N215 P"m+I# B A+"/#L K23Y 8-+& 7| [ -.# Gx
K=_' P,+4x#^p"(C5! 8+L,#X!?[$H5
'"#6/I5EF
X;&2J5K.SY^L2+#+L7.-Gx-4XU K
K[c5K<"#2I3p(,8.SY^NH I3WON
E=F -L# D 2J5 +L -.# S"Y < 0u 7.#
<f&# G;] !8/ 215 7D ^ +#5 W# 3, # RD $
K-+,2 .S 6: .#o+y[Gx5
H 3-# ^ X#! y PL'# hS"Y, !. -.#, 7.# XU K

7.#< ^ f&# 5; B2L K# +L $-" G# ,# p +D#
&#O /!+.L : .#, Nr( #5 D/I# ; B Xy U -.#,
SLK[92/D2f.#: .#-BJ;-.,-.#RD0 Iu
0$ [92/D!3#B-X;/?xLU,.#0d
X; -5KC
$ dJ;-.,+D0 Iu/B2XL
P1^C$ {Z C &I4+L7.!#+-S#S"#
B25Bf2#By&I#,5KC
$ {Z !"#&Xy
,#< ^ /" B#5 KP#2&# /[ p"(& ., 23-# B -S"/
8L!219NHK5;,$G;XL7|B5P#2&#/[+L2*"G#
K(}RDw3Y5N$.(
BS"$ I,/+t-#y ,#+uBDo"m+I#XU K
C 2+# "# 8/+-,
2".4 X; B /+t-# ^ -.#L K [ +1Y
23Y 8-+, / [, -.# f6 HA +!-#L KX 2# B RI
-.#B2# "R"1523Y8-+&7|[,WO8x#
.4//3 ?9
3
'"#6/I5EF
-.#,7.#+L7.#23D^;KX 2#B360 &[N21 #

;r45B2#8"/-.#Gx"
HAY9 $-"XL
B 8/+-, 2# 4X;BC 7.# ^N21 #-.#X;-5KB2
K,#2fK8"!+JBdy;X 2#
7Au !fH -?( 8-i5 +Y 2 7A1 +f34 7l/ 7.# 23-L
$23RIJ;212[ LS"$ I,/+-#;^K-S#0H&"#
*v 2y :S# 5 KN21 # -.# B 2+# 4 B # X 2#
7 G#"! # 8/ < S"4 8Y9 -.#, 7.# m+v
$ I,/+t-#('2y!yK&!y3+3ua/#,2+35X 2#
h M(X5H+Y 2 5,#8.SYA+"/#TUGH48Y9S"
K3+3u0H&"#,a&MY5;
:$ "#K 0 3#LK:$ "#P,5-.#,7.#P,J-#&2y5 K
:$ "#SLK+*vWO-#B#-.#,7.#K 0 3#
V".
pBf!-.",23Y8-+&#[o#,-.#:$ "Gx
K(g p'#
[ / dy; <L25 p B 23/#& 3 8L K)#|
7.#^B2LK8.SYA+"/#B!M"# 1;; ;RD-.#,7.#5
[ / dy; <L25 7.#> $ p B 23/#& 3 -.#,
P"m+I#SLK7.#>#8!+.47"+#-.#<f, (gp'#
B#5 K(g p'#
[ / dy; <L25 p B 23Y B2& 3
Nr_;BB2XyUA+"/#BML,!.-.#,7.#
<L2+.L&!y : .#-BJ,-.#RD0 Iu<+'".5
'"#6/I5EF
KNHV#S"YC,# R/- #,S"/50;~$BJ;5; 5./]

:$ "#^$-"5d5;/J;<LH523Y&J2JB2X +L
K0u-+&',
:$ "#A+"YSYB!M"# 1;; ;RD-.#,7.#XyL
0 3#
V". :$ "# K 0 3# Xy 8/ ML; !. /#
0 3#
V". C -.#, 7.# K 0 3# B# -.#, 7.# K
K[ +!+4B,
+6 ZX;&OB##5K:$ "#K
K
[ V". C 059 K AL :$ "# 7*", # J < -.#, 7.#
K-#pYd#

)#2)# IJ"K6-(%.
^ H X; B G# $52# -.#, 7.# HI"JC! +3# P& 5
=y#{ X,PHI"JC-,1xJ#B5KGHI"JCa/#
78;$2vUX;=y#{ lY^p5-LK789$2vU0(B
X, 1 Y9 y# BD +& 6 '- 2J y#& J B N22[
#y#N$HUm".4##58"!+JBdy,N-.X 42Jy#0 v;
2-,X5!d".o"7|K !"#RD0 I*#8-+,5+L?U78;$2v,
N$.# ?D X *&I ##5 3*".4 dy; Xy 789 B] X; #
P, = -= 5S4 & 5 K+J .# 8"!+J S,
Ky#N$HUP,5B!d".
.460 /9 ]6426/J
/ .1 7
3J
'"#6/I5EF
Gg
U -[ ^ !"#;" K=$ +"xJ"^#5
d8"!+J!8;y#$2I4)+`!+3#,789$2vUX X;4
y#H;P&")+`/2-,789"
7"X;RD$C5Ho#;
7"5 K+3+3u!+3#TU>J;78.#-&I7|B5ML;,e/+1
2f.# 78.# - RD !+3# $23 !.J 0( B 789 H2D >."1
jJ #^578.#-SBX5!d".$M"C3'#8,5Ke/+1
K> 'jJ #"! ^#RD0 Iuy#B.SY
local F+H
3YR!.$2v-.#,7.#m+v
2"!y
B Y-4 jYy # N2*"= C #, NWmI# X2 -, SL KEcurrency
=H86$A"#=z-,$2v;
^HI"JC=-,
B +!y RD 0 Iu NH2 N2 2-, 8&1v 0 23Y =$C5H ,3
X.#P,#52"=H8#j*&v;#2-,KB!d#!+J0H-4
-'#
3'/^23/#BD2,
2".48-[5$2I^3d#lY
X;Bm+I#8L K/28,{#HI"JCK9o+S^7
+3+31 #H& 8Y; RD 02 5 <!"A!# -LY HI"J of5 3Q
KLM!+3#B+#(5;$ vj.+#5

.Myers (2001), p. 95 :>

Gates (1998), pp. 155-156.
.:!789 "E ) U 9 ? )& 7m ^ n! !o "E X? % >
35
3/
3
'"#6/I5EF
)#2)#[e#
^/#+L7.-34W&y,2+X;-.#,7.#B
X 4C2J[9 H 3-#^K`^0u! y2f-#j&d,3
2J #5 2f-#= C2- RD ;'4 #= Wm"# lY , O +v_
# 3'# B &J X + 2f-# u KPL'# y 8/ $M"
X;B!+LK+L7. </4 5[}<+&#2f-#1^j2"
WPfV[B+L7.X "
K0;~$2++*"#!+3#,H2V[ K
K: .#,k&42fDRD0 I*#+!#,H2V[ K
;K2f-#B50;~$Ba *"#P,<!EB8,5
# RD /,5 K& !y GK 7.# 0( B 8"E- B!+L # +.#
.`2f-#Wm450;~$J55# +.#P,<!7b v$2vUB
K: .#H;

HK"#"' #`[e"*#(
SI#WO=CH&m+vRD!fJG2J-"#a *"#3,.#+I#
>.1 RD PL'# 21; hS"Y"! 5 PL'# y hS"Y) "! +1
B!"C2J[}B!d# </45-.#,7.#^0d+&RDK(}
Bf2# ,$ A+"/# X "L .L/ $-, 0 v9 RD 0 Iu B B2
7u^SCSI#A+"/#0!"1HX;&2J5KB2>.1RD
'"#6/I5EF
U;K23-#B#m#H I3A+"/#X 4X;2,C,#H&</

K*+*vX 23-#XLPL'#hS"Y #m#Xy
N5d#2+# 4P,50H&4P,<!EÂ/4+I#XL#,5
=CH&jYy#5.*L0H&4RDI"34#=3"!#L(
3/4=3"X;#TUo?;K
v;PL'#hS"Y,!.4CSv
+I#;K!QRDN$2Jdy9N$5M#,+#B#5&O$dy9TU
X;TUlYB9P,<!iBTU3/4X;TU>J;8L+
!*" p'#L K 3Y H +#5 N5d# 2+# 4 0H&"# p2
$2J;-i 5N5d#2+# 4^!.RD$HJX X;i!#
K!QRD

Q$I V6)@
N$H II" =. H [5 '"4 D; 1x3 +I#
!yK)#|p'#[}<+&#m+v5;N$H`^0d+&RD
B7O#,5 Km#cOS"=.$52,'"Y5-"#a *"#X;
0^ !/#X;CU+$!d"C5 !"#=.^W&#! /#
P"#=y6H2-4B7O#,5K *,S+-?0VCN$HU
N$HU!4C5BH2h YRDI"348/#+
K8R/-,
N$HUHP,5N$HU^wI"#P,$-4b/+#5
2#8LK/D)2u&G#"#;2&0(B3+3u0H&"#^
'"#6/I5EF
+4x#5 N$H Z ". RD 7" wI"# B# H 3-# Z ". RD 7"
2 "! # X; !L K{ !"# ^ 0u! y +./"#5
ÎI"=.H [5<#$-"C53+3ua/#, !"#
KN$HU^0u#L"! #

y
m+vyKIS#^8?-"#+I#w#"#052E
=5H; '4Bo+y+? 4 p2c B#3".$H*".48/
<5KPL'#hS"Y,!.4#SI#WO=CH&$UB!?N$HU
#=5H#H521 +!D 2[ 4CY;CUh Y;7968Y y
KPL'#*I+3*"#p284#=CH&RD/, '4B

/I5EF '"#6
< EF+/
+va *"# +

gy '"#

Ka *"# GHI"JC
5i

D
< /"#

{| 3#7f +#

a *"# yu

a *"# -+&'#

Ka *"# Y5-"#

a *"# f/d#
Ka *"# G2J-"#

D
2f-#

~;$W(4<,$M~;$ 00_' J(9

p'#<+&# )#d#
~;$0 2f-#
["!h<<+&# y$
2f-#
< /4B!d#}[
`HN$
7.# y

~;$0# +.# 2f-#

=!-## +.# 2f-#
~;$0# +.# 2f-#
E F

< <{{i^{}

7O#,5K .#RD2+3"#D/I#5+D/I#2Qd{
0V4CXL2+3"#D/I#8"Dx(#D2&=5H9yB
^52&4+#=$+8YC5$ #5=&3"#LKI"(C;pxD,!fJ
$3"RD+&.#$|gX,3#Wd42+3"#=5H9X;!yKHHK
=5H9K8HI4#+-"#5+J(9M3#BDML: 9
&m#-8/#^8/#5X#5N3,.SYjJ #^5a *"#,!.4
KN5d#2+# 4>.1RD/!#
X5H,#+3Q <J #)+1BBCY;I"(C;o"C5
!Q
V".4#NH#5
2J,a5GHI"JC
23"#5 KN!Q
XU G2*"#L K8+345 k&M# !fJ M; [u B#5 K
=5H;7+!I4Bo+y5BPL'#BP,V++!"#Bo+y
N35X#=5H;TU0 *"4X;X5H!#A"/N$H
2
BD HS/VA-G&#3-#X;3,.#0 IS#B*?5&v;2J5
$
23G# 215 c1 #KM- -#v "X;
P,5N$HUP,"#5a&4$C #~;5KH /*#d9
~
EF

$RD!fJ+l/#LK{ !"#^X#! yN5d#"YU

+-+J4 =[U 5; +fV[ 0 1 H j.+#5 GHI"JC
l/# N21
KHI"JC!=#
! [/#$-7##5jYyJ$ #5
fH&7[x45$2.+!D=5H9d;<GHI"JCa/#^
~;$ !4 B S" h Y; E- +# =&+445 H 3D TU
!yK=!-#pvTUL?,2f-#5# +.#50
[}<+&#5,$M5L5-+H 3-#,I"j#5/4
P, <! # +!-# 0 u, +/O + -# X; P&4 2J5 K7.#5
K+D#+J2I5HI"JCNS#
=5H; , K[ +D6 1; j.+# 0u -+&', d9
dy;X X;R[$.TU&3".)*&#+[ 45h ? |1x3
K+D/I#2fDdy;5+["YU

.

+^{{]

#$IJ

7 3456 ()*"+, -./ 0 12 !" #$ %! &!' !
.#5885
B E("F D
B)C <>" ? ,+@ &$ A; :; <!; =!;
.#3OP8 7 3488 G$G& : H / &0 ,+@ I."J, KL /& MN/
,+@ / Q. E: ,+@ TUQ/ ? VW :/ +:Q QR + $!
.#5888 7 3453 $(:QA+@
-./ 0 12 $\" ] G1 ,
Z &[ ,
Z :[ :XA' XA :Y 777777
.#5883 7 3455 ()*"+,
()*"+, -./ 0 12 $\" ] G1 <>" ^J ? V_J 777777
.#5885 7 3456
:d' c (Q .#5885 b)!$I 3456 =^( `G' 1 2 aY[ 777777
.saaid.net/fatwa/f41.htm
,+@ e& \'( ,+@ UY_ f)g R>[ +(I :WQ/ %(" %(" 777777
.#5886 7 3454
?./ :U&/ ,+@ -./ hF E: hi/ E(I@ EA" VI B ] 777777
.#5884 7 3454 kI&! j& :YQ !+N
JQ p :Hedging in Islamic Finance ,+@ n$)" ? o" m$ l-( k./
.#588t/3/38 7 345t/35/58 ,+@ I."Jq D G1 r&'(L (;
0 12 V &/ G1 ER& $M vR :uQ."+q :Y k:Q
.#3OOO 7 3458 ()*"+, -./
$IJ
w"A
.#3Ot5 7 36O5 -&/ (I kz :)y V j& B' x : B' :)y

.#3OOP 7 343P )R& (I & B$: r,
! " #$% &!'
.#3OPO 7 348O Y (I k./ m$ l-(
()
:U&/ ) { : :)y
)% *&+ ,- . /$0 1& 234 54 67 8
.#5884 7 345| w$(:" ,+@
.V.I -&/ (I (zQ k: } :)y V &- m$(I~ B' :)y
'
.#3OOO f$}" Q -Y* (I A $ #1
9: ;<= > ?@4 A B C 4'
(I $A' ,+@ =N JL E(} 1(G (I B' :)y
E () . 3 D&
.#3OO5 7 3436 E_.
.#3OOP 7 343P ,+@ w"A/ )[ B' : B$: Y[
F$D +G . F : G
.#3OP4 7 3484 ,+@ v (I :2( B' :)y
FD 4 &
w$(:" ,+@ :U&/ : A'' =)*
/$0 G 6 H FA# . I0 J<& GK
.#5884 7 345|
.7 343| :2 "A _ G$G& : V )[ B' : B$: Y[
L$M A N0>
Y_ :)y 12 : V $} J B' :)y B$: m k(Q/ ."F 2D
4 O "< PAQR
.#3OP8 7 3488 } (I
.7 343t Bh (I z: ) B' x :
S&'G E 64 T%> U V$6 FW
.#3Ot5 7 36O5 = (I o(L (IY : V L B' (/ B$: :
()' 1=
.7 3455 :_ (I m $G :)y V )[ B' : B$: Y[
FX0 1=
.#3OP 7 348 w"A e ) :2( :
I 4 %A7 . 4 %Y
()*"+, -./ 0 12 k:Q : B'
% . :6 9Z
.#5888 7 3453
k} B' (I ./ x : B' :
E . 4 A0 A B H@[
.#3OOO 7 3458
$IJ
.#3OO4 ,+@ v (I ?Y m$(I~ B' : B$: U2

9N!Q
.#3Ot 7 36O Q! =[ E(I~ )[ B' : B$: Y[
\+< V$6
.#5888 7 3458 :2 "A <!; : Y&$
%A7 . ][ 1@
.#3OP| 7 348| ,+@ w"A/ kQ 2 B'
\ 9:#64 \& + -4
.#3OO6 7 3434 Y (I J(G :)y B' :
:6 ^M
.#3OP 7 348 ,+@ w"A/ L B$: R :)y
E>A_4 N` 1Y aD)
.#3OPP 7 348P ,+@ w"A/ L B$: R :)y
E>A_4 N` 1Y ;%.#3OO| 7 343| Q kI( (I k:&! B :
(b /$% Tc () *A8
.#3OO8 7 3488 n (I $^ <L :)y l$:.
% . de4 `
.7 343t m:L (I =) + B!; (U V $} J B' :)y B$: m
4
.#3O8 7 36O w"A e A! \ : V +:Y/ _ B' :)y B$: m
f4
.V.I w"A e ?Y m$(I~ B' : B$: U2
(C4 fI . C4h I) C4
.#3OO 7 343t :2 "A <!; : Y&$
j7 G (4HA \ 9:6
.#5888 7 3453 Y (I #,! : B' G$G& : B$: G
kh :6
.7 3455 k} B' (I n : V )[ B' : B$: Y[
I < :6
.#5888 7 3453 j& "A (I :J B' x : B$: l- .
.V.I (&/ "A +J B' :)y B : f
#> "G k4@ f#l
.#3Ot6 7 36O6 j& "A (I $} J B' :)y B$: m
\ 0 ] :
.7 3656 EI&! &\ B (. RL m B' H
kh I4:
.#5888 7 3458 w{ (I k* R B' :&+
%A7 . 4 G0
.#3OPt 7 348t + !+N k./ m$ l-(
#< m
.#3OPO 7 348O Q \ z :J B' x : B$: l-
n`
.#3OPP 7 348P ,+@ v (I :2( B' :)y
:# :
.V.I $(z" "A/ }(I x : V h c+ B' '~
@
.J_" rG0 $A' ,+@ =N JL E(}
6
.#3OO6 7 3436 Y (I k./ m$ l-(
# 4 0
$IJ
(*<3$IJ
Al-Jarhi, M. (2002) Transactions in Conventional and Islamic Economies, in H.
Ahmed, ed., Theoretical Foundations of Islamic Economics, Islamic Research
and Training Institute, Jeddah, Saudi Arabia.
Allais, M. (1993) The Monetary Conditions of an Economy of Markets, Islamic
Research and Training Institute, Jeddah, Saudi Arabia.
Al-Suwailem, S. (1999) Towards an Objective Measure of Gharar in Exchange,
Islamic Economic Studies, vol. 7, pp. 61-102. Web address: www.islamicfinance.net.
Al-Suwailem, S. (2002) Decision-making Under Uncertainty: An Islamic
Perspective, in M. Iqbal and D. Llewellyn, eds., Islamic Banking and Finance,
Edward Elgar, pp. 15-30.
Al-Suwailem, S. (2005a) Design of New Sukuk Products, presented at the First
International Islamic Financial Markets Conference, Bahrain, May 16-17.
Al-Suwailem, S. (2005b) Optimal Sharing Contracts: Properties and Evolution, in
M. Iqbal and T. Khan, eds., Financial Engineering and Islamic Contracts,
Palgrave McMillan.
Al-Yousef, Y. (2005) Speculative Capital: An Islamic View, presented at the 6th
International Conference on Islamic Economics and Finance, Jakarta, Indonesia,
November, 21-24.
Arrow, K. (1971) Essays in Risk Bearing, Markham Publishing Company.
Arrow, K. (2003), Interview, in Financial Engineering News, September/October
issue. Web address: www.fenews.com/fen33.
Ashkenas, R., D. Ulrich, T. Jick, and S. Kerr, eds. (2002) The Boundaryless
Organization, Jossey-Bass.
Atta-Mensah, J. (2004) Commodity-Linked Bonds: A Potential Means for LessDeveloped Countries to Raise Foreign Capital, Bank of Canada Working Paper
2004-20, Ontario.
Banks, E. (2004) The Credit Risk of Complex Derivatives, 3rd ed., Palgrave
McMillan.
Ben-Ner, A. and L. Putterman, eds. (1998) Economics, Values, and Organization,
Cambridge University Press.
$IJ
Bennett, P. (2004) Why Are Capital Markets Catastrophic, and Are They
Becoming More So? in Handbook of World Stock, Derivative and Commodity
Exchanges, Mondovision, U.K. www.exchange-handbook.co.uk.
Bernstein, P. (1996) Against the Gods, John Wiley & Sons.
Bertismas, D., L. Kogan, and A. Lo (2001) Hedging Derivative Securities and
Incomplete Markets: An -Arbitrage Approach, Operations Research, vol. 49,
pp. 372-397.
Besley, T. and A. Powell (1989) Commodity-Indexed Debt in International
Lending, World Bank PPR Working Papers Series 161, Washington, D.C.
Binmore, K. (1992) Fun and Games: A Text on Game Theory, D.C. Heath and Co.
Bodie, Z. and R. Merton (1998) Finance, Prentice Hall.
Borensztein, E., M. Chamon, O. Jeanne, P. Mauro, and J. Zettelmeyer (2004)
Sovereign Debt Structure for Crisis Prevention, IMF Occasional Paper 237,
Washington D.C.
Borna, S. and J. Lowry (1987) Gambling and Speculation, Journal of Business
Ethics, vol. 6, pp. 219-224.
Buckman, R. (1997) What You Really Need to Know about Cancer, Johns Hopkins
University Press.
Buffet, W. (2002) Chairmans Letter, in Annual Report, Berkshire Hathaway Inc.
Camerer, C. (1995) Individual Decision Making, in J. Hagel and A. Roth, eds.,
Handbook of Experimental Economics, Princeton University Press, pp. 587-704.
Chance, D. (1995) A Chronology of Derivatives, Derivatives Quarterly, vol. 2,
pp. 53-60.
Chance, D. (2003) Hedging, DerivaQuote, www.bus.lsu.edu/academics/finance/
faculty.
Chapra, M.U. (2000) The Future of Economics: An Islamic Perspective, The Islamic
Foundation.
Chapra, M.U. (2004) The Case Against Interest, presented at the International
Conference on Islamic Banking and Finance, Brunei, Jan. 5-7.
Chorafas, D. (2003) Alternative Investments and the Mismanagement of Risk,
Palgrave McMillan.
Covey, S. (1990) The Seven Habits of Highly Effective People, Simon and Suchster.
de Bono, E. (1970) Lateral Thinking: Creativity Step by Step, Harper & Row,
Publishers.
DeGroot, M. (1986) Probability and Statistics, 2nd ed., Addison-Wesley.
$IJ
DeLong, J.B., A. Shliefer, L.H. Summers, and R.J. Waldmann (1990) Positive
Feedback Investment Strategies and Destabilizing Rational Speculation,
Journal of Finance, vol. 45, pp. 379-395.
Deutsche Bundesbank (2003) Monthly Report, January.
Dodd, R. (2005) Providing Credit in Times of Crisis, Financial Policy Forum,
Derivatives Study Center, Washington, D.C. www.fiancialpolicy.org.
Drucker, P. (1999) Innovate or Die, The Economist, September 23.
El-Gari, M. (2003) Credit Risk in Islamic Banking and Finance, Islamic
Economics Studies, vol. 10, no. 2, pp. 1-25.
Elster, J. (2000) Ulysses Unbound: Studies in Rationality, Precommitment, and
Constraints, Cambridge University Press.
Evans, P. and T. Wurster (2000) Blown to Bits: How the New Economics of
Information Transforms Strategy, Harvard Business School.
Financial Economists Roundtable (1994) Statement on Derivatives Market and
Financial Risk, FER. www.stanford.edu/~wfsharpe/art/fer/fer.htm.
Financial Services Authority (2005) Glossary of Definitions, FSA.
Finnerty, J. (1988) Financial Engineering in Corporate Finance: An Overview,
Financial Management, vol. 17, pp. 14-33.
Finnerty, J. (1994) Financial Engineering, in P. Newman, M. Milgate and J.
Eatwell, eds., New Palgrave Dictionary of Money and Finance, McMillan
Press, vol. 2, pp. 56-63.
Francis, J.C. (1991) Investments: Analysis and Management, McGraw-Hill.
Freeman, R. (1993) Finding a Cure for Derivatives: The Market Cancer, The New
Federalist, September. members.tripod.com/~american_almanac/derives.htm.
Friedman, J. (1990) Game Theory with Applications to Economics, 2nd ed., Oxford
University Press.
Gates, J. (1998) The Ownership Solution: Toward a Shared Capitalism for the 21st
Century, Addison-Wesley.
Gigerenzer, G., P. Tedd, and the ABC Research Group (1999) Simple Heuristics
that Make Us Smart, Oxford University Press.
Gintis, H. (2000) Game Theory Evolving, Princeton University Press.
Gintis, H., S. Bowles, R. Boyd, and E. Fehr, eds. (2005) Moral Sentiments and
Material Incentives: The Foundations of Cooperation in Economic Life, MIT
Press.
$IJ
Goldberg, D. (1989) Genetic Algorithms in Search, Optimization, and Machine

Learning, Addison-Wesley.
Gowland, P. (1994) The Economics of Modern Banking, Edward Elgar.
Greenspan, A. (1999) Financial Derivatives, presented before the Futures Industry
Association, Boca Raton, Florida, March 19. Web
address:
www.federalreserve.gov/boarddocs/speeches/1999.
Greenspan, A. (2002) International Financial Risk Management, presented before
the Council on Foreign Relations, Washington, D.C., November 19. Web
address: www.federalreserve.gov/boarddocs/speeches/2002.
Greenspan, A. (2003) Corporate Governance, presented at the 2003 Conference on
Bank Structure and Competition, Chicago, Illinois, May, 8. Web address:
www.federalreserve.gov/boarddocs/speeches/2003.
Group of Thirty (1993) Derivatives: Practices and Principles, Washington, D.C.
Group of Thirty (1997) Global Institutions, National Supervision and Systemic Risk,
Washington, D.C.
Hansmann, H. (1996) The Ownership of Enterprise, Harvard University Press.
Heffernan, S. (1996) Modern Banking in Theory and Practice, John Wiley & Sons.
Hieronymus, T. (1977) Economics of Futures Trading, Commodity Research
Bureau, New York.
Holland, J. (1995) Hidden Order: How Adaptation Builds Complexity, Basic Books.
Iqbal, Z. (1999) Financial Engineering in Islamic Finance, Thunderbird
International Business Review, vol. 41, pp. 541-559.
Islamic Financial Services Board (IFSB), (2005) Guiding Principles of Risk
Management, Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia.
Jehle, G.A. (1991) Advanced Microeconomic Theory, Prentice Hall.
Kelley, K. (1994) Out of Control, Basic Books.
Keynes, J. (1936) The General Theory of Employment, Interest, and Money,
Harcourt Brace Jovanovich, Publishers.
Khalil, A., C. Rickwood, and V. Murinde (2002) Evidence on Agency-contractual
Problems in Mudharabah Financing Operations by Islamic Banks, in M. Iqbal
and D. Llewellyn, eds., Islamic Banking and Finance, Edward Elgar.
Khan, M. and A. Mirakhor, eds. (1987) Theoretical Studies in Islamic Banking and
Finance, Institute of Islamic Studies, Texas.
$IJ
Khan, T. and H. Ahmed (2001) Risk Management: An Analysis of Issues in Islamic

Financial Industry, Islamic Research and Training Institute, Jeddah, Saudi
Arabia.
Khler, H. (2004) Building Shared Prosperity in the Americas, presented at the
Special Summit of the Americas, Monterrey, January, 12. Web address:
www.imf.org/external/np/speeches/2004/011204.htm.
Kreitner, R. (2000) Speculation of Contract, or How Contract Law Stopped
Worrying and Learned to Love Risk, Columbia Law Review, vol. 100, May,
pp. 1096-1138.
Krugman, P. (1999) The Return to Depression Economics, W.W. Norton.
Leathers, C. and J.P. Raines (2004) The Schumpeterian Role of Financial
Innovations in the New Economys Business Cycle, Cambridge Journal of
Economics, vol. 28, pp. 667-681.
Lessard, D. (1986) The Management of International Trade Risks, The Geneva
Papers in Risk and Insurance, vol. 11, pp. 255-264.
LiPuma, E. and B. Lee (2005) Financial Derivatives and the Rise of Circulation,
Economy and Society, vol. 34, pp. 404-427.
Lowenstein, R. (2000) When Genius Failed: The Rise and Fall of Long Term
Capital Management, Random House.
MacCrimmon, K. and D. Wehrung (1986) Taking Risks: The Management of
Uncertainty, Free Press.
Mandelbrot, B. and R. Hudson (2004) The (Mis)Behavior of Markets: A Fractal
View of Risk, Ruin, and Return, Basic Books.
March, J. (1994) A Primer on Decision Making, Free Press.
Marshall, J. and V. Bansal (1992) Financial Engineering, New York Institute of
Finance.
Mason, S., R. Merton, A. Perold, and P. Tufano (1995) Cases in Financial
Engineering, Prentice Hall.
Merton, R. (1973) An Intertemporal Capital Asset Pricing Model, Econometrica,
vol. 41, pp. 867-887.
Merton, R. (1992) Financial Innovation and Economic Performance, Journal of
Applied Corporate Finance, vol. 4, pp. 12-22.
Milgrom, P. and J. Roberts (1992) Economics, Organization & Management,
Prentice Hall.
Miller, M. (1986) Financial Innovations: The Last Twenty Years and the Next,
Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis, vol. 21, pp. 459-471.
$IJ
Mitchell, M. (1998) An Introduction to Genetic Algorithms, MIT Press.

Myers, S. (2001) Capital Structure, Journal of Economic Perspectives, vol. 15, pp.
81-102.
North, D. (1990) Institutions, Institutional Change, and Economic Performance,
Cambridge University Press.
Obaidullah, M. (2005) Islamic Financial Services, King Abdul-Aziz University,
Jeddah, Saudi Arabia.
Office of Comptroller of the Currency (2005) OCC Bank Derivatives Report,
Second Quarter.
Pais, A. (1982) Subtle is the Lord: The Science and the Life of Albert Einstein,
Oxford University Press.
Partnoy, F. (1997) Financial Derivatives and the Costs of Regulatory Arbitrage,
Journal of Corporation Law, vol. 22, pp. 211-227.
Partnoy, F. (2003) Infectious Greed: How Deceit and Risk Corrupted the Financial
Markets, Henry Holt and Company.
Pilbeam, K. (2005) Finance and Financial Markets, 2nd ed., Palgrave McMillan.
Raines, J.P. and C. Leathers (1994) Financial Derivative Instruments and Social
Ethics, Journal of Business Ethics, vol. 13, pp. 197-204.
Saber, N. (1999a) Speculative Capital, vol. 1, Pearson Education Ltd.
Saber, N. (1999b) Speculative Capital & Derivatives, vol. 2, Pearson Education Ltd.
Santos, J. (2004) A History of Futures Trading in the United States, in R.
Whaples, ed., EH.Net Encyclopedia, www.eh.net.
Schelling, T. (1980) The Strategy of Conflict, Harvard University Press.
Shapira, Z. (1995) Risk Taking: A Managerial Perspective, Russell Sage
Foundation.
Shiller, R. (2000) Irrational Exuberance, Princeton University Press.
Shiller, R. (2003) The New Financial Order: Risk in the 21st Century, Princeton
University Press.
Silber, W. (1983) The Process of Financial Innovation, American Economic
Review, vol. 73, pp. 89-95.
Slutz, R. (2004) Should We Fear Derivatives? Journal of Economic Perspectives,
vol. 13, pp. 173-192.
Sobel, J. (2005) Interdependent Preferences and Reciprocity, Journal of Economic
Literature, vol. 43, pp. 392-436.
$IJ
Sornette, D. (2003) Why Stock Markets Crash: Critical Events in Complex Financial
Systems, Princeton University Press.
Sparks, D. (2000) Business Wont Hedge the Euro Away, BusinessWeek, at:
businessweek.com/2000/00_49/b3710177.htm.
Spence, D., ed., (1997) Introduction to Futures and Options, Futures and Options
Association, Woodhead Publishing Ltd.
Steinherr, A. (2000) Derivatives: The Wild Beast of Finance, John Wiley & Sons.
Stiglitz, J. (2001) Information and the Change in the Paradigm of Economics,
Prize Lecture. Web address: nobelprize.org/economics.
Stiglitz, J. (2002) Globalization and its Discontents, W.W. Norton & Co.
Stiglitz, J. (2003) Dealing with Debt: How to Reform Global Financial System,
Harvard International Review, pp. 54-59. Web address: hir.harvard.edu.
Sullivan, R. (2005) Why Options? at www.optionsxpress.com.
Summa, J. (2003) Do Option Sellers Have a Trading Edge? Investopedia, at:
www.investopedia.com.
Summers, L. and V. Summers (1989) When Financial Markets Work Too Well: A
Cautious Case for Securities Transaction Tax, Journal of Financial Services
Research, vol. 3, pp. 261-286.
Swan, E. (2000) Building Global Market: A 4000 Year History of Derivatives,
Kluwer Law International.
Teweles, R. and F. Jones (1987) Futures Game: Who Wins, Who Loses, and Why,
2nd ed., McGraw-Hill Book Company.
Tickell, A. (2000) Dangerous Derivatives: Controlling and Creating Risks in
International Money, Geoforum, vol. 31, pp. 87-99.
Tobin, J. (1978) A Proposal for International Monetary Reform, Eastern
Economic Journal, vol. 3, pp. 153-159.
Tumpel-Gugerell, G. (2003) The Volatility of Financial Markets, presented at the
Third International Financial Meeting in Madrid, July 1-2. Web address:
www.ecb.int.
Vander Nat, P. (2001) Analysis of Skybiz, at: www.mlmsurvivor.com/
skybiz_payplan.htm (02.2007).
Varian, H. (1992) Microeconomic Analysis, 3rd ed., W.W. Norton.
World Bank (2005) Indicators of Finance, series code [27].Web address:
unstats.un.org.
Wright, R. (2000) Nonzero: The Logic of Human Destiny, Pantheon Books.

التحوط

Uploaded by

Document Information

Copyright

Available Formats

Share this document

Share or Embed Document

Sharing Options

Did you find this document useful?

Is this content inappropriate?

Copyright:

Available Formats

التحوط

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

]fl{{{{v{j{

 !"# $

.7 D( -! $ C B

!Q> [5^d!"NS#5VL* #G$5M#BRYH9

.Sornette (2003) :*!" *  DI >

 NxS#   ^  B >,"# 02- hS4$ # ? 5

Wm"# 02-."1N AS#~+JK

-#HI"JCX;P&423#W# 3,WO5+g:6|$y2-, 4Gg

Krugman (1999), p. 154.

 EF!l/5EF1 "S: 9=^3"!#+C!+3#WEF0

8l5KEnotional valueF=3"8,-"4#0 v#+#!+3#P&

F P+f8/# P-"& J B

)+`",|5N21 =Sv= G;+'[gH 3D=+&3".

X; !y K$&"DC 8, 

: 9#2-,j#"47| K>m#=^+&3".!#!l/:  0 5;ETrade

parityF <+&# $+"(5

B Gx 3 Xy )+1 bYg N2f.# Eusury

lawsF ,# PY

789RD #$+(-+&7|Eput optionF H#$+(<!8;x3

C52" # $+( &v; )+1 EChicago

Board of Options ExchangeF

www.cboe.com (3.2006) ; Sullivan (2005).

-#PY Jj&3Y.#W|4&.,5K .#RD &#55!.#

.Kreitner (2000), p. 1110 :)I 

.V ! !7

V#VY [G/ ~mY #^p$I/E+f$ 2 ?uI-#^5

!y K=2/.#5 789y +# :$5# &./#, H 3-#!  +J ^ 

.LiPuma and Lee (2005) and Chorafas (2003), p. 144 :>

^ &O#  B PLKn B 2[  U N$5M#, 33Q

selectionF .-# 3"YC

F +J(9   X6 8Y6 .-# 3"YC  XL

5NS#w3Y5= -=5S48x-#: 9^/4Ehazard

Partnoy (2003), pp. 380-381.

.George Akerlof, Michael Spence, Joseph Stiglitz :'

Steinherr (2000), p. 101.

^8L K,$59GVy/&#G+S/"#n MDW[ [&{#

opportunitiesF +`# L K5, -4 &+yx# 

=3": 9II0 9~5$X;-5 K3+3uHI"JC,

? 5 K+h Y;Bh YG;B!M"4X;X5H/+-:&=; 345;

Summers and Summers (1989); al-Yousef (2005), p. 83.

2y;2J5KEexogenous factorsF+[$_ -#Bdy;Eendogenous factorsF

(2004), Bennett (2004).

.R ! *7K % ' VI % !E % -"& = U 8! W

8.SY  8l4 Ecall option  

!# 789 $+( XL ,3

ry; 33*+#:52/I#2? /!# 8#, X5(}X LKn

Partnoy (2003), p. 260.

- # : .# SI# -+&'# 2y 5 KP#u ^ N215 A+"/#L

.Bernstein (1996) and Partnoy (2003) :

B&IX;SG J,#VL1XUKa *"#B 5;P"/

=2/d Eflight to qualityF/}0 v9 $S#TUZH;1HL

^&"2Ja *"#W$8/"HS#;^I0 J21RD5KC

F +  8!++34 7" !l/ : 9= ^ 3" XU )+15

Steinherr (2003), p. 199.

Stiglitz (2002), p. 209; Chorafas (2003), p. 135.

/+-/^,#X 33B#  P, BY;XS#$235K-,$;

of the moneyF !+3# N2JL +8"/= $+"(C& .Y X; f"/#

0H-5;TU 0H-4Ein the moneyF!+3# [&NS/=$+"(C,

Teweles and Jones (1987), pp. 319-320.

./62/66/    

.6230 #$ "

. !7N! 5256/6 %

ax6 8+L U5 !# -"#, 9 +D# I/# ^ +#5

.(/5) " & '$( .) ! 7#

!"# $

.7 D( -! $ C B

!Q> [5^d!"NS#5VL* #G$5M#BRYH9

.Sornette (2003) :!" DI >

NxS# ^ B >,"# 02- hS4$ # ? 5

Wm"# 02-."1N AS#~+JK

-#HI"JCX;P&423#W# 3,WO5+g:6|$y2-, 4Gg

EF!l/5EF1 "S: 9=^3"!#+C!+3#WEF0

8l5KEnotional valueF=3"8,-"4#0 v#+#!+3#P&

F P+f8/# P-"& J B

)+`",|5N21 =Sv= G;+'[gH 3D=+&3".

X; !y K$&"DC 8,

: 9#2-,j#"47| K>m#=^+&3".!#!l/: 0 5;ETrade

parityF <+&# $+"(5

B Gx 3 Xy )+1 bYg N2f.# Eusury

lawsF ,# PY

789RD #$+(-+&7|Eput optionF H#$+(<!8;x3

C52" # $+( &v; )+1 EChicago

-#PY Jj&3Y.#W|4&.,5K .#RD &#55!.#

.Kreitner (2000), p. 1110 :)I

.V ! !7

V#VY [G/ ~mY #^p$I/E+f$ 2 ?uI-#^5

!y K=2/.#5 789y +# :$5# &./#, H 3-#! +J ^

.LiPuma and Lee (2005) and Chorafas (2003), p. 144 :>

^ &O# B PLKn B 2[ U N$5M#, 33Q

selectionF .-# 3"YC

F +J(9 X6 8Y6 .-# 3"YC XL

5NS#w3Y5= -=5S48x-#: 9^/4Ehazard

.George Akerlof, Michael Spence, Joseph Stiglitz :'

^8L K,$59GVy/&#G+S/"#n MDW[ [&{#

opportunitiesF +`# L K5, -4 &+yx#

=3": 9II0 9~5$X;-5 K3+3uHI"JC,

? 5 K+h Y;Bh YG;B!M"4X;X5H/+-:&=; 345;

2y;2J5KEexogenous factorsF+[$_ -#Bdy;Eendogenous factorsF

.R ! *7K % ' VI % !E % -"& = U 8! W

8.SY 8l4 Ecall option

!# 789 $+( XL ,3

ry; 33*+#:52/I#2? /!# 8#, X5(}X LKn

- # : .# SI# -+&'# 2y 5 KP#u ^ N215 A+"/#L

.Bernstein (1996) and Partnoy (2003) :

B&IX;SG J,#VL1XUKa *"#B 5;P"/

=2/d Eflight to qualityF/}0 v9 $S#TUZH;1HL

^&"2Ja *"#W$8/"HS#;^I0 J21RD5KC

F + 8!++34 7" !l/ : 9= ^ 3" XU )+15

/+-/^,#X 33B# P, BY;XS#$235K-,$;

of the moneyF !+3# N2JL +8"/= $+"(C& .Y X; f"/#

0H-5;TU 0H-4Ein the moneyF!+3# [&NS/=$+"(C,

./62/66/

.6230 #$ "

. !7N! 5256/6 %

ax6 8+L U5 !# -"#, 9 +D# I/# ^ +#5

.(/5) "& '$( .) !7#

.(/4) "& '$( .) !7#

= &|ax6XL,3^5KN5d# /,^ && y&I4#,5

.54250 )W % '& ]52J/0

.JJ2J0 _!&! _!& VI

.230 )W A8 % =!K8

.Arrow (1971), p. 134 :)W 0

.360 - ./

.J20 !.01 2

" -S/ N2DJ 86; B5 Nv-= $2#

v15-S/!#-J "!+3#>.10(B$3#v "#7")+1

.(65) "& '$( .:? X

.Jehle (1990), Varian (1992) :

U (a) = 0 XL v( xi ) = xi )+`+'(-S/#HX;k+.&"#/?xLU5

D !n! /+, v( xi ) c 0 *[x 8+L

B!M""L +Yd# ; A/#= C1 B!M"4 T59 D !n K v( xi ) c < 0

BD!8/21 #3C;ik+ #Y[RDfI1<K "#X;R/-

gameF Sv N$& Y, Egame theoryF

.(/44) "& '$( .) !7#

.46 J0 !/ ]4 /0 !

.32 / /30 !

.230 !

.J34 J35 J624// 1 :R.

.)* $

.64/ ! ]//J !./0 :

hS"Y, !.4 C LKn5K-.# RD LKn H I3!L Yd#; KEoptions

F-J "-S/+#5Eex postF+f8/#f"/#RD&GSI#$+-L

CVK R. 8 R. . '& ?NW ?

anteF fYU P1 23-# 7++3"# .Y9