Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Student Perceptions and Experiences of Male and Female Professors: A Gender Bias
Student Perceptions and Experiences of Male and Female Professors: A Gender Bias
EDUC 364
Life As a College Student Mini Study
Final Project
Abstract
This study investigates relationship between gender and a students
perceptions of a male versus a female professor at Bucknell
University. A total of five interviews were conducted as well as 3
observations. The results shows that perceptions directly effect and
correlate with a students experiences with the gendered professor.
The study finds that male professors are preferred to female
professors by the undergraduate students. The faculty were assessed
based on the themesofperceivedeffectivenessandcompetenceof
theirprofessors,theclassroomatmosphere,andthepositiverelations
availablewiththeirprofessors.Ingeneralitwasestablishedthat
maleprofessorsoncampusrankedhigheronallthreeofthese
categoriesbythestudents.Implicationsofthesefindingsfor
universityteachersarediscussed.
Introduction
Bucknell University is a private liberal institution founded in 1846 in central
Lewisburg,Pennsylvania.Thisuniversityshistorylikemanyotherschoolshavebrought
ittotodaysmodernviewoftheworldandpeople.Society,althoughgrown,stillhas
stereotypesandviewsaboutgenderthatmaybemoredifficulttooutgrow.Thisresearch
specificallyfocusesongenderperceptionsinthehighereducationalrealm.Iresearch
Bucknell students behaviors and perceptions about male professors versus female
professors.Itcanbesaidthatfemaleprofessorshaveadifferentplaceonauniversitys
campus.
Aimsofthestudy
MyresearchisspecifictothestudentsandfacultyoftheBucknellcampus.Itis
herethatIfocusonthestudentsperceptionsofandbehaviorsaroundmaleprofessors
andhowthatisdifferentthanfemaleprofessors.Thisaninterestingbutdifficultquestion
toaskconsideringnoparticipantwantstoadmithisorherperceivedgenderstereotypes.
Although, their behaviors and attitudes about female and male professors reveal and
obviousdifferencesontheBucknellcampus.Thisstudyshowsthatalthoughstudents
willnotstatethattheyperceivetheirfemaleprofessorstobedifferentthantheirmale
professors,theirbehaviorsintheclassroomsranbythedifferentgendersrevealthat
Bucknellstudentstaketheirfemaleprofessorslessseriouslyandfeelalessofasenseof
dominanceandstructure.
LiteratureReview
consideredwhenevaluatingandperceivingaprofessor.Thisisimportanttotheanalysis
ofstudentperceptionsofmaleandfemaleprofessorshereatBucknellUniversitybecause
theyofferinsightastothedifferentlevelsgenderplaysoutintheclassroom.
Inanefforttobetterunderstandtheinfluenceofgenderstereotypicqualitieson
teacherevaluations,BasowandSilbergexploretheeffectofprofessorsextypingon
studentratingsofteachers.Theresearchconsistedofonlinequestionnairessubmittedand
completedby553menand527women.Thestudentswereaskedtoevaluatedprofessors
at their college. The results showed that male students rated female professors
significantlylespositiveratingsthantheygavetheirmaleprofessorsonalldependent
measures. Male students also rated female professors more negatively compared to
femalestudentsonscholarship,organization,enthusiasm,andoverallteachingability.
Although,femalestudentsdidratefemaleprofessorssignificantlymorenegativethan
theyratedmaleprofessorsoninstructorindividualstudentinteraction,enthusiasm,and
overallteachingability.Overall,resultssupportpredictionsthatprofessorsexinteracts
withstudentssexonstudentevaluationsofcollegeprofessors.Thisissimilartothe
resultshavefoundatBucknellUniversity,wherefemaleprofessorsareratedlowerthan
maleprofessors.Although,alltheprofessorswereratedatleastaverageoneachfactor,
sothefemaleprofessorsareperceivedaseffectiveteachers,despitebeingratedmore
negativelythanmaleprofessors.Becauseofgenderstereotypes,femaleprofessorsmay
beexpectedtobemoreaccessibleandwarm.Lessfavorableratingsofwomenaremost
likelytooccurwhenwomenareseenasnotfittinggenderstereotypes,inthiscaseby
participatinginasexatypicalprofession.
they attribute degree level with gender, this article does offer insight into how
undergraduatesstereotypeandperceiveprofessorsbasedongender.
To studythedifferences between the male studentsandthe femalestudents
perceptionofprofessors,TomkiewiczandBassresearchthestudentsprofessorsona
scalevariation.Thesubjectsareaskedtoranktheprofessorsonbothanegativeanda
positivescale.Itwasherethatadifferencederivedfromtheresultsduetothestudents
gender.Whilefemalesinthesampletendedtoviewuniversityprofessors,regardlessof
sex,asrelativelyhomogenous,malesdidnotagree.Malesindicatedthatwhilebothmale
and female professors are perceived as resembling professors in general, there is a
significantdifferencebetweenfemaleandmaleprofessors.Withinthediscussionofthe
research, it is determined that the business students have trouble accepting female
professorsandthatfemaleandmaleprofessorsareperceivedsomewhatdifferently.The
researchshowsthatthoseprofessorswhowereperceivedassuccorantandnurturingwere
femaleprofessorsandthesequalitieswerevaluedbyethestudents.Femaleprofessorsare
of course worthy of being university professors, but they are not male university
professors. This is further shown in the tables that distinguish the salary difference
betweenfemaleandmaleprofessors.AlthoughIdonothaveaccesstothesalariesofthe
professorshereatBucknellUniversity,myresearchhasshownthatthereareevident
differencesbetweenhowthestudentsperceivetheirmaleandfemaleprofessors.This
evendifferentiateswhenconsideringthegenderofthestudentsandhowtheyperceive
theirprofessors.
DataCollectionMethod
Thefollowingresultsanddatawerecollectedfrom4participants atBucknell
University.Usingindepthinterviews,thefollowingstudentparticipatedinrecordedone
ononeinterviewsansweringpreparedandfollowupquestionsabouttheirperceptions
andexperiencesaboutmaleandfemaleprofessorsontheBucknellcampus.Indepth
interviewswereusedbecausethisapproachcanbettergraspthestudentsexperiences
throughtheirnarrativesandselfreflections.Interviewsallowtheparticipanttoknowthe
purposeofthestudyandanswerthepreparedquestionsconcerningthetopicathand.The
interviewswereoneononeandtookplaceinvariousisolatedplacesaroundcampus.
Placedsuchasoffices,livingrooms,andisolatedplaces inthelibrary.Theisolation
allowsforquietnessandfortheparticipanttofeelcomfortable.Theparticipantswere
fourundergraduatestudentsofBucknellUniversity.The5interviewsconsistedoftwo
interviewswithmalestudents,includingafollowupwiththefirstinterviewee,andtwo
interviewswithfemalestudentssummingupto5totalinterviews.Ichosetointerview
students of both maledominated fields on campus and female dominated fields on
campus. These fields included political science, international relations, engineering,
education,sociology,andpsychology.Thisbroadenedtheexperienceseachstudenthad
withbothfemaleandmaleprofessors.Thequestionsforeachinterviewdiffered,butthe
themesdevelopedintowhateachstudentsexperiencesandperceptionswerewithamale
professorandfemaleprofessors?Doesthestudentpreferaprofessorofacertaingender;
describingexperienceswithbothmaleandfemaleprofessors;whatatypicalclassislike
withafemaleormaleprofessor;hastherebeenanynoticeabledifferencesbetweenmale
andfemaleprofessorsandtheirclassrooms;whataresomestereotypesassociatedwith
maleandfemaleprofessors;whatisthestudentsoverallevaluationorperceptionoftheir
maleandfemaleprofessorsandhowdotheydiffer?Observationswerealsoincludedin
theresearchmethodology.Therewereatotalofthreedirectparticipantobservations.I
observedtwoBucknellclassroomsranbyfemaleprofessorsandoneclassroomranbya
maleprofessor.Iparticipatedintheobservationsandmyfieldnotesconsistedofthe
environment,thestudents,therelationshipsbetweenthestudentsandtheprofessor,the
size and quality of the class, and the perceived differences between the female ran
classroomsandthemaleranclassroom.Themethodsallowedforenoughdatatomakean
analysisonthestudentsperceptionsandbehaviorsoffemaleversusmaleprofessorsat
BucknellUniversity.
DataAnalysisMethod
The field notes for the observations were hand written then organized for an
electronic copy. The in depth interviews were recorded by an audio recorder then
partiallytranscribedandcoded.Thefirstinterviewwascompletelytranscribedtostartthe
coding process. It was in the first interview that general themes came up such as
classroomexperience,genderstereotypes,andstudentprofessorrelationship.Thenext
fourinterviewswerecompletelyrecordedbutonlyimportantandsubstantialpiecesofthe
interview were transcribed and coded. The first codes were used to guide the next
interviewquestions.Thisledthestudytobecomefocusedonexperiencesandperceptions
ratherthangeneralstudentperceptionsoftheirprofessors.Itwasherethattheinterviews
becamemorenarrative.Theparticipantswereabletotellmorestoriesandsituationsin
which they observed differences between their experiences with male and female
professors.
DiscussionandFindings
TheoverallfindingsoftheresearchsuggestthatBucknellstudentsprefermale
professorstofemaleprofessors.Althoughtheparticipantswerereluctanttoblatantlystate
theirgenderpreferencesinprofessors,throughthenarrativesintheirinterviews,itwas
establishedthattheyhaveapreferenceforvariousreasons.Theinterviewswerecoded
and the dominant themes that kept resurfacing were the perceived effectiveness and
competence of their professors, the classroom atmosphere, and the positive relations
availablewiththeirprofessors.Theparticipants(studentA,studentB,studentC,and
studentD)describedtheirexperiencesintheclassroomandhowthateffectedtheway
theyperceivedtheirprofessorsincontextoftheirgender.
PerceivedEffectivenessandCompetence
Theparticipantswereabletousetheirexperiencestoexplainhowtheyperceived
their professor and their gender. The theme of effectiveness and competence was
somethingtheparticipantswarytotalkabout,butoncecomfortabletheywereableto
articulatetheiropinion.Theywereaskedwhotheirfavoriteprofessorwasandwhy.With
theexceptionofonestudent,theotherthreestudentshadafavoriteprofessorthatwasa
male. They generally said that an effective professor was one who, like student A
(politicalscienceandinternationalrelationsdoublemajor,male)said,knewwhatthey
wereteachingandhad[was]passionateabouttheirworkandthetopic.Thestudent
expectedthattheprofessortohavemasteredthesubjectandhaveadesiretoteachit.
Student C (education and psychology double major, female) also established that an
effectiveprofessorenjoywhattheyaretalkingabout.Whenaskedwhomwastheir
worstprofessorandwhy,thestudentscouldeasilypinpointdetailsandexperiencesthey
hadthatturnedthemofftothestyleofaprofessor.StudentD(sociologyandpsychology
doublemajor,female)explainedthatsheneverpreferredfemaleprofessorsbecauseshe
feelstheyaresodisorganized.WhenIaskedhertoexplainshetoldaboutanexperience
shehadwithseveralfemaleprofessors:
IdontknowwhybutIjustdontlikethem.ItmightbebecauseIamfemale
too,butIjustthinktheyarenteffectiveandverydisorganized.Ioncehada
professorwhowaseverywhere.Ifeltliketherewasnofluencyintheclass.She
wouldtellusonething,andthenwewouldgettestedonanother.Ireallythought
shewascrazy.Ithenhadanotherprofessor;Idontthinkshelikedme.Itwaslike
shehatedbeingwrong.Ithinkbecauseshesfemaleshefeltlikeshehadtotryto
beIguessmoremasculineintheclassroom.
Student D expressed that she felt female professors were not effective in the
classroom.Sheexpressedthattheclassroomneeds tobeorganizedandthatstudents
cannotbeexpectedtoread[theprofessors]mind.Iusedthisthemetoguidemyfollow
upinterviewwithstudentAagain.Iaskedwhatanineffectiveprofessorlookedlike,and
ifhehadeverhadone.HeexplainedthatatifattheendoftheweekIdontknowwhat
isgoingonintheclassroomandIsoughtouthelp,thenthatishowIknowtheyarenot
effective professors. When asked if gender has ever effected their perceptions of
competenceoreffectiveness,thestudentswerewarytogiveastraightanswer,butstudent
Dgaveinsightintothequestions.Shesaiditisnotfairtoassumeanythingabouta
professorbecauseofhisorhergender,butshecanunderstandwhysomeonewould.
Female are often stereotyped as being incompetent or less effective than males. She
explainedhowthisdatedbackinAmericanhistory,butherexperiences withfemale
professorshasledhertoquestiontheircredibility.Sheexplainsthatshehadafemale
professorswhowassooutofit,Iwonderedwhyshewasteachingacollegeclass.This
wasalsoseeninmyobservationsoftheclassroom.Iobservedaclassranbeafemale
professor.Theclassroomwassmallwithonly8otherwomen.Theprofessorattemptedto
givealecturewithdiscussion,butallofheropenendedquestionsweremetwithheads
down and silence. She tried to incorporate conversation but no one spoke, they just
copiedwhatshewaswritingontheboard,thenleft.Thewomenwerebeingdisrespectful
bynotansweringherquestionsandnotlookingherintheeyes.Somewereonthey
computers or phones and not giving he much attention. It is clear the students do
associategenderwithcompetenceandeffectiveness;thiseffectstheirbehaviorinthe
classroom.
Styleofteaching
Thereisalsoanaspectofhowtheclassroomsaretaught.Thestudentsassociated
theeffectivenessofteachingwiththestyleofteachingtheprofessorsused. StudentA
andStudentB(engineeringmajor,male)saidmostoftheirclasseswerelecturestyle
classes.Theyhavehadthealternatives,butpreferredlecturestoanythingbecausethey
preferredtojustreceivetheinformationandprocessitthemselves.Theysaidmostof
theirclassroomsranbymaleprofessorswerelecturestyleclasses.Thisshowedthemthat
theylovedtheirsubjectfieldandwerecompetentinthetopicenoughtospeakaboutitfor
solong.StudentDsaidthatmostwomenrandiscussiontypeclassrooms.Shedidnot
minddiscussiontypeclassrooms,butitwaseasytogetofftrack.Thismightexplainwhy
studentDbelieveclassroomsranbyfemaleprofessorsweresodisorganized.
ClassroomAtmosphere
In comparing female professor to male professors, the participants used the
classroomatmospheretoexplainthedifferencesintheirexperiences.StudentBexplains
hisexperienceinbothamaleandfemaleprofessorsclassroom:
BecauseIamanengineerIhaveclasswithalotofthesamepeoplesoitisthe
samegroupofstudentsbutIthinkweactdifferentlyinaclassroomranbya
woman.LastyearIhadaclassranbyafemaleandamale.Whenwewereinthe
classranbythefemalewewerealotmorerowdy.Shewouldtellustobequiet
and settle down, but we would just get crazy againIn the same group of
students,whenwewenttotheclassranbythemaleprofessor,wewerequietand
focuses.Wewereneverrowdyinthatclass.
StudentDsstoryclearlyexplainsthatalthoughthestudentswontsaythatthey
perceive their professors different based on gender it is clear that they treat them
differently.Thesamegroupofstudentstreatthefemaleprofessordifferentlythemthe
maleprofessor.Thisisbecausethestudentsdonottakethefemaleprofessorseriously.
Thereisanoveralldifferentclassroomenvironmentwhentheclassisranbyafemale
professor. I observed this in a class ran by a female professor. In this participant
observation,theteacherallowedthestudentstocomeinantalkandgetsettleddown
beforeshestarted.Theclassusuallystartedtwoorthreeminutesafterthescheduledtime.
Theclasswassetupinacirclefordiscussion.Shehadalreadyaskedtheclasstosettle
downaswegotstarted,butastudentwasstilltalkingtoanotherfromacrossthecircle.
Hesaidhehadsomethingtogivehim.Sheaskedhimtowaitanddoitafterclass.She
startedtalkingandhergotupandwalkedacrosstheclasstogivesomethingtotheother
student.Shehadtostoptalkingashewalkedacrosstheroom.Shesarcasticallyaskedif
thatwasthatimportant.Heshruggedandlaughed.Iperceivedthisasverydisrespectful.
It is evident that when the female is in front of the classroom there is a different
environmentthatallowsformorefreedomofthestudentstodoastheyplease.
StudentCexplainsthatsheprefersfemaleprofessorsbecausetheytendtobe
nicer.Sheexplainsthattheirclassroomsaremorewelcomingandthatastudentsisable
tospeaktheirmindsanddoastheyplease,knowingtheywillnotbejudged.Thisisa
wonderfulaspectofaclassroom,theproblemisthatthestudentsatBucknellUniversity
are taking advantage and allowing female stereotypes to cloud their perceptions and
behaviors.StudentAexplainshowhehasheardsuchstereotypesinconversationabout
femaleprofessors.Whendecidingwhatclassestotakehehasheard,yea,takethatclass,
shes easy and doesnt take attendance. Student A suggest that some students at
Bucknellperceiveaclasstobeeasierbecauseitisranbyafemaleprofessors,meaning
thatfemaleandmaleprofessorsteachdifferently.StudentAsexplanationisnotnewto
theearsofacollegestudentatBucknell.Professorsareconstantlyperceivedbytheir
gender. Student D explained how she chose classes for next semester based on the
professorsgender.Therewasthisclassthatwasofferedbybothafemaleandamale,I
chose the male because I prefer them. I focus better because their classes are more
organized.Itisperceivedthattheclassroomenvironmentofafemaleprofessorismore
laxncontrasttoamaleprofessorsclassroomenvironmentthatismorestructuredand
organized. The fact that Bucknell students perceive these things suggest that their
experiencesaretooreflectiveoftheirbeliefs.
PositiveRelationships
StudentAhasnothadmanyclasseswithfemaleprofessors,butprefersmalesto
female professors because he has made great connections with a few of the male
professorshehashad.Hisstoryissimilartotheotherstudentparticipants.Whenaskedin
theinterviewwhethertheyhavedevelopedrelationshipswithanyoftheirprofessors,
studentsBandDsaidyeswithmaleprofessors,whilestudentChasagreatrelationship
withafemaleprofessoroncampus.StudentBsayshehastwoprofessorshehasgreat
relationshipswith.Hesayshehadthemhisfreshmanyearandstillseesthemtothisday.
Hesaidtheyaremaleandwenttoofficehoursandreallygottoknowthem.Hesaysitis
easiertotalktomaleprofessors:
Theyareeasiertotalkto.ItmightbebecauseIamamaletoo,buttheyreally
careaboutmyexperienceintheclassandwhoIamTheyaskmequestions
aboutmyhomebackinCalifornia.IamnotsureifIwouldbesocomfortable
withafemaleprofessor.ItmightbebecauseIenjoyedtheirclasstoo.
ThreeoutofthefourstudentsIinterviewedsaidtheyhadbetterrelationshipswith
maleprofessorsandnotfemaleprofessors.StudentD,afemale,reportedhavingbetter
relationshipwithamaleprofessor.StudentDisalsointheclassIobservedranbyamale
professor.Itwasthatprofessorthatshesaidshehasagreatrelationshipwith.Sheisa
seniornowandexplainsthatshehadhimherfreshmanyearandreallyenjoyedtheclass.
Heenjoyedthesubjecthetaught,andthatwasthesubjectshehopedtofocusonfora
career.Shesaidheattemptedtomakeconnectionswithhisstudentsinclass,soshefelt
morecomfortabletalkingtohimoutofclass.Theseexperiences donotsuggestthat
femaleprofessorsarenotapproachable,buttheydoshedlightonwhysomestudentsare
more comfortable talking to and developing relationships with male professors over
femaleprofessors.Theserelationshipsarekeytotheperceptionsstudentsdevelopabout
professors. Positive relationships offer good experiences with a professor, which can
resultinthebreakingdownofgenderstereotypesandassumptions.
Conclusion
Thisstudyshowsapatternofgenderbiasthroughtheperceptionsandexperiences
Bucknellstudentshavehadwithbothmaleandfemaleprofessors.Studentspreferfemale
professorstomaleprofessorontheBucknellUniversitycampus.Itispossiblethatthe
studentsattributionsshowastereotypicalgenderbiasbecausemaleclassroom
instructorsareperceivedtooffermoreeffectivenessandcompetenceintheclassroom,a
betterclassroomatmosphere,andbetteravailabilityforpositiverelations.Whetherthere
isadifferencebetweentheperceptionsandexperiencesofmaleanfemaleprofessorsat
BucknellUniversitywasanalyzedandtheparticipantsandobservationsrevealthatthere
isagenderbiaspresent.Studentsprefermaleprofessors.Theseperceptionscanbe
changedbytheexperiencesandawarenessofferedoncampus.Thereneedstobemore
discussionongenderbiasandstereotypes.Itissimpletodatethembacktothelast
century,buttheyarepresenttoday,ontheBucknellcampus.Toopenupadiscussioncan
breakbarriersandallowspeopletolearnaboutothersexperiencesandperceptionsthat
maychallengetheirown.ItisherethatwewillfindthefutureofBucknellUniversity.
WorksCited
Basow, S., & Silberg, N. T. (1987). Student evaluations of college professors: are female
and male professors rated differently?. Journal Of Educational Psychology,
79308-314.
Feldman, Kenneth A. (1992) College Students' Views of Male and Female College
Teachers: Part I: Evidence from the Social Laboratory and Experiments. Springer,
Vol. 33, No. 3 (Jun., 1992), pp. 317-375
Miller, J., & Chamberlin, M. (2000). Women are teachers, men are professors: a study of
student perceptions. Teaching Sociology, 28(4), 283-298.
Tomkiewicz, J., & Bass, K. (2008). Differences between Male Students' and Female
Students' Perception of Professors. College Student Journal, 42(2), 422430.