GLOBAL ARBITRATION beni : REVIEW NO ICSIDPeayCOMMUNITY NEWS ICSID selects new assis Zac, Lebanese onl Chileon naticnat hos been revealed as he new criel counsel bf the Intemnehonal Centra or Settlement ofinvestment Sisputes in ‘Wasington. DC. Zs he rd with he onan Ie eiieny a ee Ao ne ttc "The ee a me ang ‘roe fmf apo Aft yor yt mn Pro dep meey cw of ICSD oy te ie spel el ‘lif hs yew leery se CSD, Tin peemed sapien oi eee {Soyo te Wend ik Ader “Fira "Te eibual desie aps seed ty alm ofthe Wo Bak Gap ging bec ofthe oma feos be ers opine ide anid ‘il psa in, Zn we ber of (Rowctand rome th Wl Bn Ira chief counsel ‘Cnfict Reon Spe an ie een fal bucks he Jin Pan, a th cron sition up ae Pohl Brows ‘Desig ad pes fhe We Da ‘sane Hap "Nesb cing Spang LP al nr msn en coe a 1StD who weed wh Zoya he ow {pet del shot noe a omer eto a aren ISIDS te of guage, Engh Pench Spo wl ain ‘eet kan eed Bn poe {3h ingot inthe ty wage {rcSID He he unr wa eof ‘heajeom co el whic ESD le ‘peted le hk he sper il SSD TER sex da gd appoint infin, He athe bit coum the ent op Test mans pve can eerie ‘ert dapat con and end nd Vita Ginn eau he Wold 2 ingen t bth CSD an he ribr"Heit expr adminis Se Seen Scerbl an indepen ark ada psd of he Teen Cet of asic wee th Ses a ty Tha Laseyacte QC. tare ot 20 ace Sees Chiba Zin ft chs ‘Sune sy od donate il nd ‘Shwe dsl and demented by 10 very faces yu ce eyo ‘Nate bol “hs Paice geal of CSD ‘Adminis Gel ety owing {hereto Pal Woon fm he ob pat fe Wo Bk Reber Zoeick ites bank peed hte so hat ofthe Aire Connell Zack ‘Us ata an vce inno de Gln ‘Sth Grup IID} Admins Cound rope the aap of aman {SnD ora fre omer Sec 5 omearGubuge be morning pe, tember cri eee pl alee Fry replaces Whitesell The ICC Intemational Court of ‘Atoision has appointed Jason Fy ‘Grit now rocrolory general Fret: ie Crd ce EP Pit ewe he fo pane he pen CHE aye pod fata pe "in Bech hod of et Chance [Du complonn aon ato he Cho esiu psinoere We conte sod tcc Aone Ane Witel, who teense genders yy Accndng SNTCC pon eke next ee pune Sadi pe Ste Menger & Fm Tt knows oy fom wo we hep for Now Zon, code hi a xen She Hey tl ce ‘way we He al Be a ery ces ‘Ninth Wie ‘sel Meeagh Moker Bare Co a [Now Zeend in 191 he foned Chl! Chane {mando ad ned othe Par ein 18 ‘ior af te High Cou 0 New Zend 0 otro the Soren Co of Egil and ‘Soe quo who wl pe ryt New ‘Zeland epracine on the 12s Cat rN ploy Shepp ier seron arnt Chord Chance sto New ther ani god ki Moke” He Fyeinany ye expvence tg fr hee NCC aeons mes hat ec he Pore ince fr ote eon Moree the tir seg 0 ‘i i tebe proces bg aed? thatthe Hendenon pina etme reo Se applied yee etna rama ering in he agen» povsonmauiing randy onder fo yee cae iting Abtetoo te sce of (ke prer oul see peo bar rehoe hers dope bed yo hl ‘ha uy could od hold ed he ‘cnt ret cna xr ban, Coteqeny tour poten exalt ‘aed ha he London eb wld be yw conde a th Henan pee See be hail ping soapy bers nach son hued bys maber of came Sef tpl Mal yd Comal Anon Bower, 1989, pg 3 worth fer cocode at i dob ee enderon pine ple to presi py om bing spe ao aus lig ‘ie oe attr aan ‘beet pocedig A conary e apprey ore elo inten, Sue Mew, 20) 36-3 nce om Arma ‘Nein oie But (9991) 3 DER 41) na Fis Siping Co Lal V70 Exe {i965 2 AN ER 9) Bri apes tg tht ein pe Aro do ee pore ‘he popton atthe Heaeon pcp pps mck came: Te Aral an Feats desons ue oly qtr fe the se fal proces tone of te Hendon prince cn be ported whol, tethers "oe if he Herder picgl wt be este) ee dial of Buk ping “sfdw FB eal let shoul he sen of exising othe ean icon tain rngingthe eng of eet epee hcaion igh wr omchow sg ‘herr wold Ye eed comer the ‘lami ear oe ining te ping ‘Af chim in atone and he weg (he bane ence to dc wheter hoe ‘ear hol be sce Ben ould we ‘Seah ae second atin we coed ty FBS ta eh ler sinh pee te previous wanda bythe Sy Id the pang of cam ben nce a be fearon — te len ving en ped nce ning mah ‘Sto the Go ed coe TP sone na aes ge te abe opted wh is pg of Can a sal woul wl th ame cal ea {te eat of bton ein New Yoo ater Anh by a New Yor riba Inactetace wi eperal pnspe it e je ira poeta mae coed ye lew eth NewYork lw Teak 9 New You mn apg penis fate Lie te mr sue and Fee jut in te US the cnn of New esata oe Lew Sean pen sen the pref ed, he ti fhe Reems een sf ana tht court judo se Sebel vor cena nd ob trated he one Seton Bf he Reece ‘oct he tse spl shoul py ‘guy aero cnt pen (Alto wey ati sec mtr one ome gop ee fon ‘aco Eh in he potty hrm nme wim nr ee ey oan rer Si ngs en snot ety ie seep unr Eng Ine The geen ule ging sue pretasion Wace ay ged emer fo a ‘iar cne ne em hep bee es ‘Sr il dg Fo tee rss (cum n cocron wih the aes of ie ‘top he Lenton isl eps Bighast peng of cin The mas ‘bien db mee eet, tod entre he png she noe aye ips pp nse Se Ena ec campe gene mig ‘be empang ssa cli pon ho ent they soanting Scene of ‘ue of cen stop But dh ot the aRES JUDICATA, Indeed making sack a upton woud be 2 than or oppaew cst of con eso Snr Eni The andrea erence itt onder the Reet heer [pet ceeds arom cope af the er hae facto ened oy ngith era “ha conc dena on pice ing ‘Mr cate when the proceso | Jen ae ppd he me ie thet Fa revel igh kha he Bigs psig eins eran oo which pvdes that lim peelson bac oe emotes my ther son a ght ce bees bout one rac ‘test oe el po Ste ep gr nn seen cert] ‘As enpine in comment th con of ‘ie etemen wen judges ned, tie cr ftenson al eerie ‘ial cn cna and igh open he Salpeter Th pr ‘rv goto White he Aeron fe hin’ as ee hy xn” “The atoer oh guesion od a 1 When i nl nyc ai ee pone ‘Sova ce af pif em ese ep Sayre mn ef ear (a ha nt a “sean gn se cai ne ei a at nd ce ‘von at nfs pe! Soncep coasting omen cl ot pre eke anced whore fer of le Sowing fo he eae Tein fa ne i cel ‘fees fe tpg (ae nt pi fr fc ‘he ean cher ching he er ‘hi rer expand ying win ts op at ol thereat rancon bobo cs of ome waar A xplaed a Comment (oven 2 Tiers are i ey Sta a gh me tw ne oa ‘inn te wre ucmmy op differences between the way that a London tribunal and a New York tribunal will apply the |doctrine of res judicat | | | ‘There are fundamental secion 2 fob ap ngpa ano whee ‘hi prec inode ah “Orr son a nt a it ‘Sy ar eB ee a nf a a ink [Foo nd pa ‘Avaya ml et ees esarcennnt Ait shoe empl hare, iit Sth deman fpf theres eeery ‘isin he oo to long 3 conn Se connected ef ence col Srey te ees sen ren hu ean wey lowe in US ce Fee Seve, The Bato No 33 (Ore 450 Organ Sup Ce 1985 wich be ae fn jojene a the pain’ contact cli te under the Rewer ts megene Seog tenga eons copy gon Sesimt concn peta Cals Pane Tiber Gp 9 F Sapp 249 (5 D NY 198 so Hak» Da, 105 F3445 Gel Ce 1957) ‘Aaphing te co crane oe Retna: emaon em la he {igs ey Big aston tre ve ut of hae action sce of Stent th pe ‘Reema Bias pongo chin would theo be bret mtn ne Algh Seton ica hone oery. ign Trecho cneat and ping ofc ‘om, cmon rec of opotie fe ‘igh emo ofthe eset od EBL ‘elle ge opie oe Digan ade une ‘Not ny we th vec gg ite ote oo Indice tthe sh ance me eg ye bah of con ad psig of ssi rl cents afte ging re he toe raph pty te he Nw Yor buat ‘tui fd eh Bp ston sing of ‘hed nthe nec peialy aut {nett oe and they merged i be ‘Smal al sed Aco on the sve recy the opie conto 1 th te Toe nd nd yous i ig ‘png of eon on te bse oct peo, The ptt ne dace einen ‘ewer the wy ht + Landon eal ad ‘New ork und wl ply the doin of epee nd st hoe donne a (be prs aremen proved at Bok, sbi ae rit Ne ‘econ of Vanda ed ot 0s wie eigng ct ofthe ham pelo of toe ce sd Grrr toc sa Pcp of jc pe at te plae of This reseed Lio Chan bet rv Me ene con Chamois lec nf ilk f atin! ‘com pe He te oi ‘Sn eit of Te lena Who Wh of (Cite Aisa nf wr a cela ‘Sipe Loi itl baton ‘He wo epi als Ed Malis ton Chon or stabANTISLITINUNCTIONS BERMUDA MAKES WAVES WITH IPOC DECISION It the English courts’ power to issue anti-suit injunctions to support arbitration is reduced, London could lose its edge in a key area of commercial law. report Nigel Rawding, partner, and Daniel Kalderimis, senior associate, of Freshfields Bruckhats Deringer ‘or Remco th eos ant Heian a Ws bf Jes aden Ferry ee Lor Ho ‘aed ht London mt lo erowel in Erpe in beach of aati geomet Che ‘hc hen) a fo one ‘nuneonenEnlnd nppor of ation ‘Pectin cn ag Incr RAS Rie Ada Sore © Or hE rons Co (21 Feb 207) eee Enrpen Cor of tee the ong ges: oe Saw ao oe ST ng tg pein oi fn inne ‘ei wet knoe he Eagan Cour of aie {ahh ae ton ucrend oapy cay ‘Regan #201) he els eer ‘ne nn ‘cummnced moter weber beck ‘fume scion semen Ge Guo Gli y sats (Ce C16 /2) 04) 1 Lid Rep 2, ae 9 Dacre 3) er 0 (ud at he pry ating eh Gent Cae 138/004 1 Leyes Rep 36, ie 39 A 209, in ie 2 Engh Cour of Apel in Teg Tg sl ore Ane (Em) La Nov Id re Coa [205 itn poi th ste of t- incone Insuppr fabian perenne Tid af Renton 4/301 Ta eh ‘whch tan pactone aly gre (i con ha Rome en ste ie Ga pedo Tp {Court fie Ge pe 39), Moree Cor cn or speted th Hoe | sta, peamaty berate he Caer un | Somme pct Ter (el Horner cores fe Tough “Bape fad or bn tne The |S te ung in Thug pr On Sinn ped ws kop ecw ‘nisin fice et 88. The availability or otherwise of anti-suie injunctions in England in support of arbitration agreements has attracted much attention in recent years {ke Eanopen Cor foie ds ane the ered quent the nem the ‘nba der the eng sper in HT, {tna none intoppot fbn ‘us hol owed the ape of Repton Ath sity of Eola aur oe ch nants wa pote cnet in Lond Poplin a ang vee meron ‘rare ten Hofinan onde rn 20) nt let a Epo ‘ay pe mt ng Seay sem tet Fa ee Sc oe Bp Cry a at rene doxma of en ‘Since ooh te ‘i Prem ook ede wd Spurs tn ee fii tmdeehfe oni de ‘Rages apa Tew se be ‘ea es rg ie ‘ie Een Cy ae ni ert eee Sirah ioc ae hg cee y ig i ee a ‘he IPOC decision ne jadgment ofthe rind Cour of Appeal (0n'35 Mach iyo moni afer the ‘eon nar Bama Crt ‘gpa nee jogs esrning tnnctors sd nde he wring sounded 1 Lord Hote he ay af competing srncon owl ch om Engng The ‘ection IPO Inet Cu aE O40 “CAM € LY Fo Gy Lad (Bermuda Coro pel Cv App Now 22 $i 3 of 206.28 Hac 37) Te hare ‘penn The POC dein ein he cont of a woe opt bg 209 ben ‘Baroni ncrornd TPO ough ae the omni os perce ate hel by Risinninperael CP Mable a Ronis ‘tt nant moe oe pet sie {ee Maps sok Th dpe be geceANTISUT INJUNCTIONS icon al gin iia ewe nerd pri ig any ‘Se dog es lag ch (Tae nnton preceding tb tc that both IPOC aed CEMoble were, ‘orang Rtn tl one pers AS Bek POC and CF abe ogee i ‘er Meza hace mee py 0 Ids ucol yen ley ‘eed ashe Megan zee, ech ring rb Selb were SEC Ruler and pond y Swe we Tn Al 30 IPO commence! hago Feerion scckig ose rhs onthe Meaon se (fed te Roan rg) aadonts amg ree ‘Suan ode Gon the Rin cer hat he Mepis ered eo. thothe Map sper be need ‘enon and epic al renee 9 CE Mabie Tne S006 CTE Mie pel the eae Spee Cor fit place 9 Jaton oer POC) fra pemazet sit ‘oadhe ein baw thatthe Rosin proceedings vec th tirana in any ere conan wou presi Gost yton tbe Roses {othe Bras coura ting he ae ee. [WFinect ee wa ard gee (Crab ty wa of elgrand LV Beane So uy un opon agreement wh IPOS. CE Ros nd the her 48 carn usc In 206 LY Fnmce meee» rote Sandia the Zaich bron) The Hon jae Rawey othe Berm Supreme Cour ged po anak Iauncon od deve n xpe il oo ‘Bebe of wheter the Raman precedes Stew commence a bes of be baron pecan The wa bld oer yee ‘Sperber 2 The prin ped har he {obs op wa ae downy Engi Cos o-Appe in Age Ch Gop ‘Martine St in Sp (Teil Cc’) [195] Log Low Rep 7 iho rane pracesing commenced ety in och fan wien emer roving “The main at of dua fi ance sw Geral ly mene th btn permensand9 + hte thee wa go eon to deine © Acco ce gue net ice ‘mon ie ene be an fstdng lS bw to he ape of ‘he abiaton dc the Mesos ema) Iwate 200 Rawal fised Peto nd Renata de Se ‘Ramon peeing mein bah of al IPOCS argument against |CT-Mobile was that, by electing to arbitrate ina seat and under a governing law chat |did not issue anti-suit injunctions, CT-Mobile had implicitly waived the right to seek such a remedy from a court which did susan bs opel th he TOC mpd a camo wha sso of aon agers eed {Bein i ered won ema Be cur i eine fo th {bate h pon of ese. ‘Rd en Coe pea zd “Refer ma sneer rot taf joa on ok fbn eb he i meetin BCS were [Since ert om Sup peta hi quinn ob ested in any dss found by eer ‘Mixon i one fo intanedion ne ‘Bahia dr: Pa Lined ena Tag Capo (Cason Sere Cour {B0,Cw App No | 20h, ne 298. Soe me dic den epee a hie ‘nus in ton exe judcion ae Uy tod ete Lengo in OT Lr ad © ‘Ma emo Lah Rep 170 (ne 3 ‘ep rey ae po Meaty at neon er ‘sje ee Sipenenr tat ep ree pane ony re sf i seg pnt ‘Semen Si ‘ita ee es we sera poi ta (Poe tga ta py ‘ipa ec ype “The Cau in OT A a one cancer ‘ath Engh lo gcd agree fou of gn mating the ie ction Seay ober Thee espe Engh by mjrcton of ate apermen or ‘eee on peor oso oe he Tngh story hee prs of ‘he ei of Dir Marca Celis do 2 oer Presa Aron Brig Rae 52) Die Mor Coli (The Ct of a Ned pnd “Be Ef Ct na to eat omar sda Bg Sosy i oe ‘sth Ber Cou of Appeal he Sense” whic the Con cone Ws ed dove bene odes nay ced, fhe hee tore rior rg the ctr ed pied (fg Pees Cl cin nd Inder ed 208, ps 8.39 Gv a fe rig sl (rte dt ee er (ied oteANTISUT INJUNCTIONS ‘nf tr pe ‘Tinlne e sr be dg mn fo, [adn ee, ea at hd "eye ean ea. eke he Berta Gost of Agen POC leting corel Richard Faker QC nb ted sre byte soy of erie face ns GE fe (99 1AC 119 wth vege he ing nae ae 3 shoe peso jricton bel ‘inc of oetpping cour preg tough POC warned tha th eum sro depend ith he Bera Coe ould [team le wold pce Sosy eit abet seatea _sitsnnceom in Stl eer Sesh Iw), Abe ha imply uted ght tare sch eed fom 3 court whch “Fhe Deals Come sal opener CE Motes coe spt by wae of he Fama tt be Brmods Co aa CT Mote eating cone Robe be Qcremphncl dat here we et sro ge “Fhejricnon co pnt chs ee onal rounds uch wear or ‘erst anu rum soe cone) {randy on soil gands ch ‘eheaono ve jon operen). seve bye Hoe of La te hos, ETON an Ter Gn 203 WHR Jor 18: Aktough er ren ofc ‘tay be appropri s brane {herr proceedings te et toy. te nore os comrade ‘incon, in eure whee dager ‘ould manly be an ndeqae ree “The Berm Cur of pp ed sith es QC ppc nd tha FLV Fiance leading cou Rich Millet 20) cone tlw pf 9) nee or eo ey tates ies ya ee (Dacre [78 Sy Ca 9p raion dee ont oe ge ‘gee iar yar ey ‘eye Syne ar He Ed Se eS 08 Sot ey ise ‘tt gm eof aio “et to rd te ei po ef ‘Teas po fone Stead snot | joo ct Pe apa at | state mre ga o | ‘rere a Et nd et Tht or eg oan cer {Foe cow aor 48 Newt ‘Soto ath te staf pa ‘The court can grant an injunction provided it has jurisdiction in personam ‘over che defendant. |Nowhere in the contract ‘cases or the books on ‘contract is it said that the Court must have a further interest in the resolution of the dispute itself “Toe Cau ofA ao emphasised eet ‘Gee tet te alending prceting (Comenson coy whch sl ge {© 1ny pce commence in eho 1 Lbiacon epetnes Gl 13) Indeed, Tecmingyontloked ndig Boe er lng Tn a ha Lae san ey ed Clan ig ie (ans 2 Lays baw sep 1020" fe Cols jand 0) URL pan 6 erLon Hinan As be Cou of Appel ence pr 8 “Ten Tt mys ‘eam Cori et epi meh ‘eon npc The ROC deco hs ce ped ber (2 te Pry Coo a eed ‘a Berm, By deciding tis ue define ‘ee th agi or ne) cous ae es {Shi word end wale o cin obo freemen bron end rao, ‘recommen bere GA Reet an perc wee Pal Micha, Gt Abita Revere 2 Te 2 ae 3305 fe ne eo ie er inog rn bot re ‘pee hema se ‘Siu cn ns te iene i fe Bp Cn ue eon on a no ‘he Be (hee wih pec ote Espen Cot of [her decom ne My comps ied ncn commen 2 Ips tn and wl ely testa ‘cmon, whe he Engh coors cue he ‘eo ofthe utigedge mew proce tren i wy Engh cos he hs porn ses of arom ere ng worn sbrsion cue mip te rece Al esate pow othe Eaopest Court afnce Wi ar at Lod | Holla come wee pent any os or Engh wim cea Yes oe fo al Endo ete mon we cies eyEXPERT WITNESSES EXPERT EVIDENCE The evolution of best practice ‘Modern arbitral practice has evolved techniques to improve the taking of testimony on technical issues. The result is new ways to put experts in a crucible, Richard Bamforth, partner, and Ned Beale, associate, of Olswang, and Andrew Grantham, managing director, of AlixPartners report iteration ie theee ese or comely Tengo the pve fee cane reine, imme fl icons — era fcr Ete tenon commerce steno thu nme oe be compere lays, ‘hac prc onal questions Indy Ko ange eee on ae pce. ‘scene recone ‘reno us a insolent wil en Ba foo they might be wc tt ption loess and psy oupe In ont fa pel am npr could ‘eed to rtp poconer che ‘ice ht bingo aed eon te exper These cea dese ‘ett experts oposite to in ieee ron eng exper {Senora rt nde fe {hcp ea of he re ‘Sond dene a pace in nernina [Mharon nd conte ow te Det ‘ther rove lows he fopon of thing it met cmon ta fm dfn ridesom Thine eens ie com hve eed ‘Beige pn proce er 0 {ply mares lence For cup schough | betel sens inthe UK an he US con ep opts wer heme When experts come to participate in an |international arbitration, |they will often find that |the requirements of the [process are different [.. land possibly tougher inporant iene: Englands Cel Proce Roles pnd hat expe ny poi ‘se court witha indepen opinion Bt {i foemon ther theo ap he ue Income th US Fede! Rs of Bene reget coe to aes he iyo the | Sper eee by pono othe Dar | “be comparion othe dierent gies su aed fer Supreme Coren. tevd on he pita pry ac (un-npen nde hy oe ay Strom ncn ey fe ops expert yee xan In oral nw yer yon gto ‘ep by be cour dete quent (ee Esper stance en wore 22 ‘apt curt ch tthe cheer Je no wl pre ene af Fry | ca ma Te pre fi do a ene Petr own exper eens arr ough the pr oul he he eptniy o mke ocean) ‘hevcnmteun ye parte hen the cer tone we banat bg tev when viewed a ate comme tae wang the ex of to el pen Thee Relw compas he ey pow reoiagio open ene of th nero ice ‘ 1 f ‘cn i fi | owen, ‘ fi n8: Of cause any attain me pares may ae0 vary me recede RsEXERT WnINeSst ‘ete {hows oni he ernst Bie on how bo ine ale “This epeily poparn Ai sn As, ‘ecco SID rere ae spay Uys ine Ht wt haat be_| woe hs et nected Mee {ery ons own exe eidoce oft The wal dine hat ach purty alm ospnd | Fle Gout and ined ily eed "CC ras equip sch te prmason on sy mater ncloding ta afte cou |e ceding blr th Now Sot Wales ofthe wien bie sgpanengsreape.sanaon owt fw expr rites, | Landon nme Cow Beco {ndthe UNCITRAL pd IIA aldo not Inher condone np es at new | naire by samba of ele ‘peo anting on pu appeimed espe tal est to we the ne The expert hae very | Anon Buogen a (Sthogh trues commen pacic nde bch such ns sce poston wl te hrpng | Ines Sts the New ouh We Zand ove Irene cn ng cfu ib | nn Cre BoP py ed es te eer ese tel aeeerces oe rip Ca dere crs ss fon eS ee iefcie sew Siivamnieapeamom sce | eae hr tn te sing comen tse as eg ea an faukcracnpartsmce ebaraee, orice een Ponte snmcn aren | ‘tenet ae usm tte inetea te | ‘mou ropa sn app Font fenh in otal ESN ena | Spee teeeetaes Souon wh aya mer SDN SE ecg kr a Spey wih kepeicrenen er” | Hot-tubbing is akin ccf at Sqorlebr simaety pderte s | Emutigaaeeoaaene ihn ieeinenon! beeen (tO having a meeting of | “act Skene Stacia pec ge iteng et | ore ence | aietiemenriefee amr ‘xp hie feSIDe nde eer Us pacer eXPETtS With an audience | Nvraeyonaesew inva pec Gren peton fees present, namely the | emmy ea ie Ginae aimee het rt—| y cdr ona cromaitncitigientecaae [tribunal and the lawyers | Syycuam.crer UUirnetn tearm tete | ind es mehemton yal recotson of evidence by experts arhow the d clients pers hee a he Co pope Seat my ding ataiae Que el he cc mie pon ting in Siom pth etn ow pee ‘hg een apr wit ence TEerN npn seat dan enrol yen Sain de aoe one ‘Sroreapue arech omen wen ba | of quodon and pend spr or hte Prenton af dons aerate a dbo 9 parser Extn ofl pri the expe 2 fae Bor the asec wht "The cate len oda sweep a end he ering ce ange ened nd pecs ethene port may od he eget frimene tis engerlnou reopet {stn or ference Dope Sabet fr crom-eramiaton rowland ne lenge te eee gui SBeerper il oGennaidaon make aval Arnberoimnmetre tne ben wed by |ecaue vr the wane ep owe ‘roeoton ate Hering. both urmarse shuns cain da rap fm ers | Dr lng Pw sigs sem in Secon aftr poet adden apes wiht lowing cra-camiaion Tie | London 58 Senter 20, ft opposng exe pre The ep echnuc re ceva hacen wch | Indes nha ct Sel pseoton ay be doe jot with lathe mart mre a apes ge ecg tae map tts cnencng ich oun Even whe he eiece preety nda leony ad ete ema | armor sly a ep tenon ree Cte exper aonebe ore wil ealabonte daring abe ctesooe hem aca ge dagbe | ae, ab a wees ep ‘s pepiion wth tee tem eo emuse tt” proces Te two met common uch e_| ble er uconng ‘es el ines ane ncrenngh | hang pe of expe sol Hg, ‘Wana onan. pec when "eo atoms ch PowePoe ero end wie of ft ha pia ‘ih seeing ae Rani nmap Tne en be ed yng “The erry 03 more soph sproach Th peach a lex gv evident pti gi swe scone ae it ‘o expr edenee hte bul pee to ere a9 sue poets ering a one sane oder lo or winee og se tous athe peeing oe conducted ecient, athe bund cna om te | beg pone dete by hs cow ted ete expnt of pecring ah ence | eapeine porno gues prey cet | exmiaon ‘Sproparsonseco the snsiaaupce One trprtevor he shed ok commen | Oftoune he ae 80 pose nde: Seyin which bum ace dry ping, | widin atasoe wher ee cmt, | For example tne ak whee wnt ot ine leon the eg of roestons Ths nombycowrcoon pute pec nen of ge ace oe, ‘common rare tah thw ck {Be futons of tc eden cul te ed rca aa wd by Engh Tecnology |e ing jth ether wien ve a cto {te Coniracion Court sine bts ben Aran fhe panel pach fred | Sf eet sons fon an compel ponies incre walt wreaceay, wom ineatgwr'treneonenong | wine mcm tthe opera atEXPERT WITNESSES Ahr cto ei cing» cher ‘re dm a {ul sho eal tan epee pong eo share pti oh ower ‘imtoo for ttn ddan eyo seco ii pre-eermaned line of nena emote Hy me coco, Again for ce parc pepe a epee Siegen es ehnche pocttr | foo hanger send he sl hes Posed Sey ye ral the teal wl wee western era ‘ber re heen, wen he bral {ara ccubom So ther a bes bene ‘Sate eionl sopping own abr on» i rbun flow tat coune of hee 33 cot poo fr he ies, ‘bog che pres could dc re ae ‘wrt bene and ein to Be ined rou opr fom a ak manage un the ceed craps he ‘eo hes pte peed peracetic Sep, ‘Spec nce the expense ected pode» oor etn ot the es tho gd ih “There sale how hat conde bead a cee at ven ete they Re xcanged eer mp The thor wl ere tgp a ew ng ‘hasbeen mandied Sch 4 meeting ould ao Used by deeper Be pres Be sone doce dt he caper dee se reat (Gr hey ae ea poi {ne cr). Deangao conse te a cnt hi ed a poe creosote ‘These pede a 2h to decide seatteion wits hey tech conten ‘out hoa he ang he oe ‘These days an expert in large scale international arbitration will be expected to engage with the issues from the very start | rhe ae an expereince incre! vl be apse 0 ‘ne whe om he ery ae i ‘hesapu tar onthe ech eee, hs ter opmion il ne the wey sce the ot ‘ed and eee ought Gom wou | crt smash gon itr pe -Sphicaedposentn, def ote os {Sarnsion fom the opposing yer an ako Sete hues dapat wis the buna ad Phe opaine pee ens nda egies the eager be ie he aby to eee ‘co ei © reo br Eng tore aon exc Howe mau dobre ‘egies fan epee en eh Shp pn iano aon Fer deiped and eae The International Who's ‘Who of Business Lawyers: ‘Using 11 years of independent research to create the authoritative review of the world’s leading private practice lawyers. 27 ine pac (Over 7,000 of te words leading lawyers Over 100 national Jurisdictions Over 1,100 detailed profesional biographies ally revised and ‘updated 2007 edition Price £270SECTION 1782 NEW APPROACH CREATES PARADOX FOR US PARTIES Recent decisions on section 1782 could put US companies at a disadvantage in international arbitration. Michael Nolan, partner, and Lesley Benn, associate, of Milbank Tweed Hadley & McCloy LLP in Washington, DC explain tuner scene United | ara ine ca prnty NBC, | Seton 172 a en cope evi Ses covery = dough 4 US| Conering the scary aco cearencs | 064 The preva lv wenn ay jul strteirzaiil fs in | Seaton eng tn nt he ten-nging | rocedig png ny cot ins reas wera bein ia hope dowing | coery of US bog ‘eye deen They wer raced recent fel cour Secon The mpetone | drac 182 26 USE § 1782 yen | i pause pene go ‘be cae he pow ob red fr the | npn ors proce ins Signo Tsar ‘lsloge of rene in tod szrion | essa anal toapey cy {hdl ie oregy td ct of penal pa | United Soe oun oe neces | Easy recive edings See StaTerweuetpecee | See eatsentiaaly inetemamamead [oaewcseia | inimeeas scan mature eteeceea” |e alpen cting | Secon nent Stan fy cece cecaaracn et ees cr atemceatencat =| Seteeaiera cyanate Coceemcacautrenye | ectaingcemaarermn | metitiee ere sei euseareumasticts | tenant counaeges| | tenes sroantence ‘Vienna. tn those atbiral proceedings. Rox Trading, | par: rejected that vow rising eo extend the ected ent = SrmeghteneSiacrsas eel Ora ab se ae ne iste Oa staircases |US.style discovery wax | Ssty giles mor irieoreacoreratices” [Considered wo beat | stem tscrrneemdistea ‘he bon and he ee cae ef Be f ‘outa ines shoe (188) respondent. Cor-Cola oppoted the ection 1782 | Odds with international — | This meaneshat private intentional arbition sepaton on ne govnd uc te nestor arbitration, Which was | “ils tevie ot rermton SE SATS ana [Viewed to be better off | itr tleee Ste Without having access to | Fact Cxunsinpe! wean inctnioa! tis yt naan wasn [SECtION 1782 ‘Shuman 0 2 9806 89, ‘he meng ofthat cao I bed gy 00 TB NAC he Sco Coc epee the Supreme Courts con ne Cop concern dat iene imepesin ono “About Mi Doves (need in etal lo). {2 cold ope e eines of he "Tae cour wee sere me sn et ecen a ‘ioe Spee Co a i than The Soa Cres le ectcy ‘hb pr te ps dl con cen Bog wo ihe ut ac i enc oe ‘The dns edit heen | one cory ale pbb he ‘Som pv ft pe Ct ‘wl rf a rin ge Find Ral of i Peer "Opening ot (oma at ee (Shoat pr eet oro the pe oc out by NBC {tint Ce ne ih nes royce | ec ey wold vnermne oe fe eas ‘Pein ed go Sodcne dna of steno, and het rere et fr ai, ea cone he meaning fee Ther pr yy ‘ep cote hth ogee poly “und i sete ent ae jam! | pte aah (NBC » Be Some pa nding fom» Second Ce den the ‘henley numet | 199). cour owe he ein ing Nine (icae low) eat eos a | fran remy set | ey mere ing eee wih wey tga od th clyde vet mera ps hace eipetine nd econ ‘Mel wns Net aso ded nce | orp en eo | sft ties por contaced i gn iu poy coment re | SSanvies he Uated Sc dary woeSECTION 1762 sorter ob at os ith he eye of ‘NBC the Unite Ss apes Ca conte theseton wer preted te Sopeeme Cure ie Cyne ee Bu (2 08 251 Ob. neh ofthe cor chose Siete scion 172 orate "dnaeaiy ‘So nd bor pir ting whetheseco HD egued nly atthe ude ng soap woul be abate er he i fe ‘cen ei pace wee he evece Sco th Supreme Corel he scion Cora here tn htt on the 2 ips alin. be whi eomnbie ‘ootpasn" Qa 25639 = tur dd vo ene te pre eonte onempon™ a ‘ostng bth he “acorn pnd” open Comming drone gee Th conc eed mon ther hing remap out Lb 258) Atop he ‘lao chon FED ot Teton Supe Court cour edo Pie lpenrod ot Eig a Congres wt fx Und Se cour so {stil proceedings ton 42 US 259, ‘The upene Couto bd etre letly Ue at rn i ong St rp cmc an pen ear Takg—areniontswshe |i ft Dic Co eon n Roe Sth Ou cou reeset bss |e cnt non pe eh {Dao ttn) geccictuty tcc |e Gome ager ssc Str Ora tae usa’ | ne pam nee jy iethaeefscan 42 |r atte Ry ‘Spec? UR copay our stpcn | cr neh ey ‘2Zonne sm wmony oto andro 78 dents ob ie mca stnn Cie Tea) |ops Noe mp ny vom ecchogoa pcontrdpmot ws |atedSuursemmen eee [Sxclonsmentom net Seated |S ogni nok on HE ee [glo tl ryan Toda sont |_| Ro eb ma nn fe tse xg ep rss on meen Een en US ‘Mime hinon eet ot [Scoey “urd emo beome e er wetted ene [seme Uae anion | "cnn wp cn con [eb Ryapan Reps flr pp | 78 ce re mln Sean Sipe ns TT GS lutte en non ie So od wey pn pa fos Us je ac eS OS py el ony mnths he ere Seaman nl aon mince ibn! yt tons ton chee niet cry oan Widespread access to. |fthtie'dcin rao she non veal ee 2 for parties |wsatmecuin comme’ we tion 1782 for parties Oey apn Con et Ts mene engaged in private Ss eae yoy rn ed international arbitration |{Kingessady pope could lead to significant [7 Seven ti nll imbalance between tame exhay pacer ya foreign parties and US Ragas gepieenh meee Picea ‘Set Fp Anas un of pi {ny incking rion wir red by we res per end of cnery SC mee oe a a here, ny itefere withthe way in which Sas trl wana pt Unreal io neg beer ae nthe oer ow ied ake |e i le pro as aon te mopene eon hp 07 Too |e ron Te des Swot eco as dg wes | US a cour doth pen ee Sones ap ning thon 2 celia cl on whee meaton fain enduce espana | opel oe Jewel ates, "The ce: Her eating econ 178 a the wake ft US Supreme Cou econ in | tere nee Ie! my xpd US dey count [The ope ofthe evidence gheing proces a |Fgn poctetings Tes paar at he ery (tetany eng deed comtns_|ysom std by eee ender omental abr A concer gue | sn exam what permis may be speed tas US dic nce over of | meal fin pre eet ot en {ee dy = conary to wit adobe pany Comming engine ean sic of aeaon, mney contd” commen orem = bt me er US ‘Speen Altbough tr concer me way Sone US compan seme ely lee te NAC denn 199, te msec tm oe ce inna comeesad Liane (Sly we es teCNGUGII ACT'S 10TH! ANNIVERSARY. LOOKING FOR FLAWS IN THE 1996 ACT A committee has asked thousands of interested parties to critique the English Arbitration ‘Act 1996. Bruce Harris, a well-known arbitrator who chaired the committee, summarises the feedback 1 1 racked expony well pi of Sinema ons ‘adit fom pres umber of ese and cba ik a ee 1h irl e wort ning doe bon theless sen operang by se who tae econ to wa ter py Fo “The UK gone a no nmon of a ae dy be UKE Commer Court ‘Coie ad ctw fn commie Commins wo eo we drool how No nda or manponer bd ht whch be omit igh pre Wels fo ‘staarDame Hl! Gran Qos eed» pesca tw pt Neal es he ‘Ten ed ne head ‘Clerc ea wit he Foe obeeemar earn Irene We ihr bine sic ae gots tte era cope testing nom pred ‘rom tbe ay pi fr ang tow na at ae wren ee ht pote, the ato ver Gord wey Coy Side innane ce plow tigi ee xpd“ whch Tah sans of manpove cog sero pte quo on te ot pyr ae a we opie wo el Ze ty oa ccs br who ‘Sv orn on ort Tt ben ‘ed oma my cer in of pope od orl lly oh ote (hed conned oer 229 aby oF ich we of tad rho xpi Se eo toon of ean in sme ‘cs wl ae po hk eda, Enormous agile pie oo ony ln seg up he sey eo ingot ‘alta end sdin pyc pmdsng Se hat repr Loct Lan ree fe Maca rks to Atha Mtr QU) he nero Dau Reson Cas ‘eound dogs na nmestecoue "Te come other yrs he cue oe wo pu the Bb At ope Fivag ened he tl or are inn etm tot 1996 Act ne made of it Fbrecptedhope emt mparare Thy tere quien of bin dering te rien (eng Kong eso ‘Sudo ind onder rd pee Kanne Kapone ‘Seneting te commis ght igh ne the 16 Act os coum a ee to ower once comprehended mgt pags be {ice Sow wel wheter ponders © ‘hesuney ough dae epee pon bull te masa er whe ube na old ‘aly or indeed whether hee mg be a aly ous wih rune eng ec we he “Tere wa sot pe free ht run shal hae ste per Met people seed err sa noe to (henge fice aay de vo cae {Scoued 0pr ceo 0 per ot cn "Now ofa be Deparment Come (DAC) wis eed i ‘hr becme the 196 Ay come ie ‘peso decided emi tat whee th goin {Thor pre ine ped pos oan Sem of ep rls ft ot ‘ly snow el cel dtr he ‘overt dh ution ae en prpredly bs nde he ery ent ha 5, ttre fay econ me ya toe ‘rd on om jcc ye oe, St fh a (rected a Then se in ‘otra wine prion skp of Src fh oe to mig ‘mn ip ae he yo igo St sie ‘he quson chert whee aa | Tint tie nec bec men ey ie ‘nan commen sts ine sey Ale be, vn ogo as Fe Se og td cond it he gon ‘Teonemaiy ws oe thw beet he earata work danagh ut commie ght ‘ifr 0 yeas wk wheter te pasos ‘Bold changed “Tg comin ete ne at sn cy een otc hang 00h te Bat pei rey secon ofthe rope wh cue ange al sgt any ew pra nent car he at a lee DAC clase ‘ied in peng 19 nd 18 of ery {95a rep The in ida cera pry suo nthe hoe of ana ough fo mented ether pers ck sf at ‘lg are neon dose of Ssamen} ‘Ofcows in mary stp cmckron tf epee ote seo eer sto gen of ert te coi am ‘Sie har DAC hs a et ore bow i ry one mas in sent ys A tring ee ot snes ore who ough the hol es usr FlaENGUSH ACT'S 101H ANRUVERSARY Sevtnet ao what hn i or eepon lees of int sac ‘gh hare hole ne ‘eile nce An of oan tepiion “Pa cero bein ioe sony ope ny stg cll ‘Sade Ay ean mat be ged ‘epcaon spline nan ech ‘thst tunkofeypoule casein ih Sere cuctt beam cpton 8 cone ‘conker sd wwe eon $e comson wold ae wb rad ‘epson bre enol ee ale Ina icc pe fon at hte rita imple sew ged pen sie unreal ceo ele “Tee Tol ea wise one pe ‘oti rane oul eo nt a lesan my comee opp oo se ‘ier ling oeay sung ich oc sae nner ot st lenge nod cbr pang te om gers ary aw fc ue oul cel te cura sont dein ‘emcee done ps "Whe then dd he ney hon? Na hu per cnt of spon ak Sat he ony of peling Sold ewe on "ho 15 pret hin th sol be ‘Boke snd he percent nk at heb ‘ppg on poof bw hal be caged “Thc percent pth een in he Ih topos ee gun oe ‘Do yank ut eter oben bol be nga Dae warn use Seo be bing 5 er cet of open ‘reve no chnge Al pp oe mee ‘Sipe and eth ong may of oor ‘Bipmeand connate pons ag ie ay 0 (5 pe. Nota he bo hugh at he bs se ping me psa ut he te Be heating lene appl sold be changed pnt opted oa eo ely ed Mboup nn ict cnion y Seeded ow who were camping cans mo a iy eee ny anes och pattie ane wn ner ais A the fe cond he om woud ely ‘prenio of wiped pound epton If there was an expectation that we would find real pressure for change, particularly in relation to the tests for obtaining leave to appeal under section 69 Cn he ier adi gh 9 a sbi he eee ring ae {ape to ot changed bay bere BPiiry neon he tc png ey ‘sgh rp along be Niro ‘ower detonate eng pe tn Ai of Lop {repre 98 19881 he ee penton nde 208 205, nee Fo under be 16 Ac hn ta ‘Bex pra enly 1 wren ord er on he ogg spe ner oe 1996 Ae pew page OX) Som eat deci in ceaelet ‘elanga more rigs ppch on ave {Ppa apiasontncond ot ee wet ‘bon ong theo dene Ot (eee ping snd omni wach poe {hereon of aieston ppc pod a or hc de ete me "fe fn) fart tt moo (he cane che po ef bene (ite aloenin he at to sprout cure ks sepsis eo Spa The fe that wet in 90 ae afr ning ene Secor ey cece ly eugene “Te ir orate dec som ‘atte ma ting sped su ne ale ence he ls nina nd ‘low thee ob oe ety dn fan ad nt bin rng wer ssn ON) teenth ee ot i he gua ne of eeepc ‘Niu Lol Dipak ape ht pic wine vot ws cop ye the 179 [Reino em leno sr ‘nee it ene the ne ‘Shay th unit st gel mae ty bebe ple at ie at of le twee no a roel (mal anpotnce van pear ade "Tee hie manors he roe raed gars an pt aey ‘Stel ges Bo when ok te ‘uranic and tr cone he nes ‘en rye ie on to rey re ome over bed sing NS ‘howpenn a oe pone ‘wha on igh xp um whe Soe tk Shean fe epee wth eres Fetching a nee roc a ‘hegig he ution en apg ie ‘item tn esp nly ‘won ae te nba ot be hana yen Ber en the he ‘See ot pea cra oo it ve ety eel ha te vel pinion ‘ped yh ey hgh appre oe ean or cies harcommended hee change be made spa ere gy ening teal tt ee he legson is bound DAC nd ed ‘epi conan copra trey nce Ha frie he Ln ene Aca fone ha of ‘Charette of Ani 9951998. Hee ‘mf he epaenAry Coie ht ‘ec te 19864DAMAGES AFTER ‘GOLDEN STRAIT WHAT PRICE ACCURACY? A recent Honse of Lords decision may be a recipe for delay in arbitrations concerning UK contract law, say Cy Benson, partner, and Nathalie Allen, associate, of Gibson Dunn & Cratcher LLP tena efcmontnt tk | The oc fal it aye | Oma pi tipi Cn [issctictinmddiminte |uaatoniayticomecsssnier_ | Suter ne ae ‘isu equa otiaen._| Sh pry tots ps er | teat tmp ech ‘to AOC atc tant wa pa | rentals ccc angs | lemma ened wet a a bo Sage 4Swe NO ARBII9 eF| cy ene ona Sne nt pas | aden bean pays bes nny Soins Se acaba ny | ne escort | cmoicbepnd meaner eee ‘sre dhurcend comic msn | wgy ue tnm Ade ect__| Spats pea comet de ‘ane Culs seu Copenen vA’ | Songun sw aroxierae res | Fenner haomes tt Tees Kai ni HPT URL 21% | potter mey ponaTe vel _| eps esp ag Sn fe icchaonms ced agen | Sen penpoy ommend sbenonfrtmach | ence ehen ew eeactsnd ey ch Foe oftadicsmein ac eswntoe tt | femmartg dapat ny” | sew sein tel ee eee ‘some ecg font | ema econ 25 fs | naan ee Tomaliermeicsonarhngk to | ponte anpoeta emma | tree hee ele span wn apo ey Seo py wth ne Srehy eae tein a Gn SScSicioa ewe aed es ‘Sieber get he cp Sey amped ow a Sow croc bok choir iinet tater ron wee ae ec | Simos fh ce eg a be Te-ADC Ae mt, eal aac Theatr des seh st Shear oyecs pide ntetena [11 the span of six months,| iywrsonr eas ne ne rmtinn sewed Gite ew” [two landmark decisions | tin! tant Spepriadnemaratedneniede have been issued ‘uot ah eo sctomrtnranecmme [addressing the value-date | [Som iticcmsn tt Genwimmectindlogersarse |for the quantification of | Sswantaansacuar setlist eisai |p Ce Mesias Molgyiwionldcmadareee” |damages a eon ett ee rag Eraromeruormmnifegiooged | “oe Howe oc he ia Sete postin ni he cp ad ‘toca ne thorn oa at Sintetune? Tae dnenqe ld | pg by Severin ecco | Sint oe ery ie oR hn fee ef ny ‘coh erndin yall ng Stowtwtaromy whoa sprrde’” | ein wer idiot view | apnea se Sites ash cue poe [oe 0Mecr ao hence row top | tages ea Sijcteetnewmmardenkestie’” |Taecmewedeninpriemgertardeam | Yurehetaranrgnseaeg Seiad oem Boudteinscdtccprcdtaemhte etn | Saori omna ate “chimney appach ou ound_| arte eon ery arb cons | epeng sh a in Cllr SmtTore te oe sti | Sinpeanctsoee ete | herein, Socicd shies ubieiolaetty | Soman career ach 8 as | Span Stmgineseowsyortmea conse’ | emurGha Tie gasn re toner’ | Tarte ay TSkgeinnang-imecctonne: |sacnvhckehatgeigised | Taogaticayee insect cn ce Howe a | ge aed oe ‘testo wom epg | cr een ciate!” | he amine," sid stecrrwmishne ic meade | apsoncronesny Semana oene | Sgsambenicn deen eete as Shome Biebe ao mecnirgon SSOHW inthe wr contaDAMAGES AFTER ‘GOLDEN STRAIT ul ape ugh be ae Sect by Lod Bigham, wo emp ae ies ofan pec ‘hone of Eng cmc ow 9 re ee SBejudgmet of end Marl Cin Hl Tin 190 [de es ht pare ace In the context of English commercial law the effect could be broad [...] What Golden Strait quite clearly does is create an incentive for delay si an be change yp breach vee (agente pice eta sd eva bo ered by eh be {Ee tenho he wae pot fr de ee ond rong seen fe ae sine Site he uel in ADC Aa Lin, Engadget bt anced he miderton of poe-rong ee te ‘Site fdge Bene onde Sich Dr ule the pr! a ADC. he Moe a Lona oo ad be caiman ‘ened the cima in Cer Sit ‘fed fom te sppcon ong ben ye, Gen Seat pps tn Eke’ «gl mgr ation mie ty poses eem ht Fry er (Pine thes red cee gE to wih ere "tft might hi decane on ervey eet when sng Engh low Bat he coment of Eg Cte li the fst olde ou ot seeped by ope of Be marty in Gin Srth contact pe of he corm ‘Sent fe carer or comme ‘So nor bese thas description” Sted ifneny ‘he olin Sa ce wl peat ae {he ane of dagen al omer rc ered by Engh And oop (Clr Sued tn set hat opted rol te ogni ee i ey ter nd oe’ va ter ‘Som! con hold ated ered ‘Shoe by atc ain ve be ‘end by ee etn 0 ender Fo enh tet hr thy he ncancy o * ico, what Cole Si quite Aoi cate nie or dl Behr ‘hoa te esctech evens ot ee Tt Cel eng a pong ‘sural ate the sy Frcaruch su pce eae to Shon ped ish Ak he ‘iia to dw op iia cee “i cpl aot be peor ‘jer chaie ors cane nth be The pry ‘Shigeo ener pertrnce eps te ‘Mhron While presage pending 28 ‘Seton ene jr sencunend ion sciow canbe cpg on + ‘ov at ahde changing th vin 3 07 ‘Be waud nati fet prtmance fe ‘Sct fr exae,by sang i onponte of ‘Senta oper whl ru). ‘ner Cr Si he pendent i yon wl yao ly he dl er ‘i leon Ani rhe ke of pert eth aon de ewer el ing {id inanes obec seer © Frei ig Shor of halenge? How sore Teoma em pce mi of ‘restate nc et bee Wo {he pinpoint at po eral oer thle euncy And rt heen oe ‘bh pout wa ing ey he “re a Pn Te vale eon and which he ant ‘Sache wb i came aon iin = See ped of Ge? Doe each cacy | Sat pocen made se pope Tek ie imagieton to coneoe of ty scene dye bE ‘Seapets eng cur whee ee hat itimpaan rhe endan ae Soe tbr nd pera cold ce. Mac siner ctacanso be eine A toy wu ay eo ts gic ey ihc sing wer high ai ‘eon unma Cvain crops pres gh enn ek smile exer re oF "tr wore eonequece os Fasilepen pre ie Son ‘ison on Bo on-set et ‘Eee to Ti dpe ey Spot pve doa wp na the set (end bthed wen ch onde ob flo Second by she azote very prrse ‘hgh be seedy te poles th (Cin recon be waned The search for'accuracy’ in damages calculations is laudable, but one might reasonably ask whether Golden Strait has the balance right ‘Ses on mph emo ake wheter (Gali Sar etter oe hele ht lingo sch ee (is adn bccn aenaoe rr, ‘epee ke espn we hepa ese coony Th acl 0 Phin of ocan eo rary perme Ico ee ed a eee Corie omc npg et em Cn Seth ponCLOBAL BRIEFING GERMANY: THE FAC ANNUAL SYMPOSIUM ‘he symposbm's meme wes “Avan inGermany 100 German er not Geran rough Kal von Ware pain {GSk.Goter Stockman & Kelegen in Dusselort. cng Dray Marenkov. cn ‘homey rom Calagne repo ‘ml Syponr on 8 Mach the at Ince Arbon Cente The tw tee, srr heer he Gena pl aed epee with er dap nd ee ‘ca dnc Geman seo abn “doe posible am or ee Dives eirmod Inti oping ete on Seno reno sao: dol el ort aching sede low ltke were! slop of be UNCTTTAL ade! Law by alae mb of ort teeny Aas Aconing vom Scie, ‘ihe pt te FCC LIA ak {he Gorman aon Aton I) er ‘pete ope Thomae ier of Heder In dhe not ey unleant pee per inpornce x pry ig stn, Ene Se of Lr Lr Gee & ‘deren be Land an Mary Cage tl PrcensinseCnoen ot 2th comet of hapa aaon ‘hehe ane 8D cpt er wee sel 0 ‘Stolen ong expr nes inane al nur a ea on pe ‘joy to te ew lef oe ‘aor for nds rer oped ee "he German Arbitaon Law Gene We of Bon Urey oped the Soe setn whch ated Gen ication we The aoton of he Mol Low {a Gormny in 198 hal eed feeshey ‘eligi In ato, German tae pray aoe an a nde 3g aber of eran abe, 2 Enda c nd Sett he ed "Wager on expiant ig © oul oe hse oar compete ee ‘ih respect oe jritions Vages pote conte ye peter, ‘thous ded th Fen Eo cr Swine hw wo siya ‘cole tees nly don how ‘sor i bon lw Aria Marin of hat Erin non opens war ol becate ‘fate nd whe Sad a fontat hd ape a Face, el de ad een coin clr Hae won oa ser ih alr wl eect Br terion. alum fr oxnpl ted eat tore ters eri tbe 198 Sg ‘pn enc oan oi, | "Th Began ny eed ann ‘dn tras cae Usa Proumaty sree reer te ‘deeen adn to be sled "in Howe en aed de mions he German tn i oped eh Mode Law Abou sone cone hd roel gemiely wel oer he ea | tuner not para tcoe or fogn we ‘Switeedand, dhe UK andthe US play bost Scahcpseteenmsesinas Secon ‘bol tenon oun cha A Seder ad the Nes Aig cote ‘ee ron bcos nds | fmporane mo stil poets noma ‘ninco eng tte ieee fy be nosed phenomenon pe y at cerging stron ation x ot he bias Sm hon tie i {nse wah ea onde a he | Comey te nse eer anaon ‘Alpe! dh Grn pte ee eer el mance el fan ‘te Acockig © Me Being oi & ‘Gr Gerrans eed ‘ha So Eph es Hobe id toe ‘erie sao ee, “Arama fy Syed lig of ater Ekng lg te sige Jeg rear at chance bi sod tess eae by German pcan and bron Bling sre wi ht sneamen, csappeed aes th Garman oer tender only on Cera procera en 14 Germ eg ere dete cater sn masa bon ka whic Isto dente hide ate ner fetal Heal weed Grn yes ‘oul mle re of lepone enters dagen we the Poca! nae need of recaig enghy Id opicned wren lone oe Seandvn wtonrs Hobi fo ane, sted tt Sannin abies ue ‘ee Geman comer ene ane tnd ce pacenon © re lo he Fer Tse motte he dager eigen peed pl Some of he German prspane ok is eppreaiy teres thre cl hon on Gorman poate sere ‘ar eegey pore ots atonon ‘Sonera Tac ae pomoting + ‘element ia wl ele nd Egon ed Germany’ arbi ar Ina ping ot of onlin ks A Marion say thers fd ing feo London in nratanl bon hee evr he ielence af Engh La inthe wo ln nk wth che USA ok sd che le Exec) and compared Ld et with Se owns Ger tution Dt a Posing creas in star ac DIS, riot dried he Sgr lemon” ‘pr bese te nto ea oe ‘Sie its vin he inttan gs beyond is mp cere agus ceed te of major erat nthe Gran ceo. In gene Mar de biel tha Se “hous German says icing” woul be of et help Bd» zen Geman speach ed nw def he sbton wo INVESTMENT TREATY ARBITRATION: DOES IT MATTER WHERE THE MONEY COMES FROM? The hbunalin Sipem v Banglades hat Sceapiea rscicton. manmew Welniget, poviner ond Mathew Page, csciote ot Fert Sth UP expr hy Amo ICID denon justin Sapo to on ane oe nod ‘edn ae an braGLOBAL BRIEFNG ioweenen wis nde CSIP Comenton, | oat Ending, Siem bought he proce | oath nnd Th bun red wi i, Thocuevasmesmpison chin wher an | ICID aston ni Bayh ealegst | sng tthe ihr aang otf te TO Itmnton! Chaser Commene el month eng urtwldaapson ashe | Aaa aon ety om he ives” et en edb te dome ors 6c aterton the ierce byte dome | fe he pp vew weal mean a the “Trent ope cues cou he non an eh anime oF | ss does conte oh noe dee concen 98) ere apes, | eC sear ad depedSupem ofthe sus _| sl) of he CSID Comet, wich he Wi Tonpumand de BigetchO8 Ge | swale to wana st eopion, | rl mt ne prepare scepter ThsNincal ceponson Peo bald |e bese fe bend nent ear ‘enue te sco fence covey al ftpcne sor prio arm con ound rman ely ed Bangs Baas | lone othe peraton he iad ‘ions Begdch Unk onc, ober jade concrete rope of | ed the dr ose et ou fhe Felina ele ein percent camer oder he bse sient ety “awa ene che prmctoweé Supe eanton adhe een fe to bes pate |” Tht apache one of ‘tomy nh ts trtneguniy cued ain dec fom vores ace | iment ine wth evinces uch ‘Spem nome encheTe cond ache nto _| 2 th ESID Coen (CSO Staten ce, CSOB pened» ered Pembgs seuss won ten | Rigen snmeat io depeting | lm 2 Sak Cole Compara Skit ‘Today ones Resonance, |e ng ote fade arsed ep of | Sab he Caen Conan Soma orenenhemery bookie be hehe fine putt the projet were eed bY_—_| sed th te dpe wu contre exe meer Sopem by my ofadonce paen fom he” | thi anering neh nein ‘Sipe erga rete the dpa to gue dt Siem never" sector | cold epee eos by CSO a cc wana ve 199) ana i Nowe ve eaten ‘Sait nt cnsrae nomen The {195th TOC ab sl ood ned The ISID ena mado arte any | tual howe sted tl "eine ojornticon domingo chilege | inparance he ecg fhe prec nds | shee Se arp cljon of be Sloe ‘Si rcicon On fe November 97, ited The ot soe ha ne ped Repu fry ee pt of anon ‘ever evened asco bre 4 | egret amon af cpa egy | wich ule ran vec” decd ha julein angle ein ce vocton of carey mat pore ao he couay in| camerng he whe conn amen oe SeiCC tetunit story's didvofn the coum cmp Inne) The | ce comer bese Saka undoing Fer Cro ofthe Soa fg of Dak neared eine ae y Ein | and i un prose CSOB me tate Tides aloed mao to mrs nl no ars um ed | sds CSOB geet he ler of 2 ‘tors tech the prey plan! | nae bat ete etd ae me mnnet | steed ne Sok kin fhe Sibeqany on 24 Nonenber 97. | ainwesment fd wth ged pan | he meng of espa vee Te Supe Cau ef angch suc nother noah xp of he fade seme” | Injncton wessng Sipe Foo pocsedng "This yproath 2 moored by he sing Soph, cots wienoson ChhsheICeafaeson Supen sds ten hor fhe ICSID Corwen a revo | ofigorment ht bn ea alot 0 (Biecton te fewobng acon m September ble ison cany n Hen Hl» idence bn coed wel {9% bain ApS fe Fs Cour ate gp fr eample he ha ord te | abled ponepe hme ihe an Sorts ig of Dia oaed eco. _| wt neler ta te ogo tend may | Rete ae of expoptaton = dat che role he sony ofthe foc em art ates meno meet | ICC sw o he igh erie ere ‘Shears juin among ote coded bene a apace tient | ete of bong exmpised On he goto of Chet id conde the pedis ssonene ey ‘Sheth jon hr he oa mop beta easement im Tneang whee Sie Made | wo med at ec ale by Spe orca amimvstmensuner ate 23 ofthe YeSID | wel etal be ple of contnng FNeerles,te {CC aia eibural | Caan ia uote on he ‘exponen une ile 5 of he ted died eens te pocediog tephra on jin Sn Names hate | iver Shot enh grounds te calenge fhe nono inne mgs te psa fot | Away Dae ped a Sipe Ibo in ICC aunt avian ce Semana (scorn of many ar er | chim coed an hae of pce ng Ba ‘ein rion ofthe Te cum ad teste af econome ae) xcenam dune, | fees “tafe ao wid (CC aed ng ‘Tine hadnt cour nd cous My Gi) an ment of ak nd)» orton | te ICID jurcon" The bun greed with So0s he (eC wand waded sn word holing. te hos se recaps Bing the cho of Dina sie ir rrstng hd beached or "Tad nae fr jem | etn pide seeps by Sie ‘ipuow,eocied Pocbungh upp Siem | of aemanng nce heat | fenton ofthe al coors dt ‘Sopenaion cfasand USH6 mln Gis eer ance othe ICSID Comenson t | contl fb [OC aban a with tan ‘met fom ave 19) ela te woud leone "etapa, | seep he ik of ach cou ering ‘eon money st arn he net ond Ghee oper lade eco dhe | Theil ee, hoes at is Ws {SStpum ia epoms ny 200 Peta | oeeacion othe eemson money the | Boe ott need ha le as elantpcton tt th igh Cont wy sa tel ICC sean. Appying aes hater here wor beac fhe ten Disco ft Saprine Courtef Bugis GS ato he wel opto te rk sent en ae feoercie the (CC pels sa Nine mors Seed to Soe al nade a ec ppg i i rt IhernApe sce pee out gem Und ale 26) oe {CID Cemenion aie nn eC wun erytopnd cen on che |r bao esi ta ‘esti edo y Ending new oreo | eceay dt the apt Sey ot of pata pe era a en ‘eaise"A torent ward co eer be | anmenet’Bangdeh oe ht ope Thier ad pn ‘Sa oor abe elie ‘dng ow ote IEC man ies Gon nk oy ae te Tw Ocuber S00 bene of he Bangs Gur aig om the ogi esment (a,c n wit ch ty aGLOBAL BRIEFING ee he pata wold nate he scary feet The ene mw cot. MIDDLE EAST: NEW RULES AND EVENTS GALORE DIFFERENTIATE 2007 Tha fetal of 2007 hot san an untuk ‘umoer of ofiaton conferences in Dua epors Philip Punwa,c Barser (of ATemimi & Company mn Dba! ‘Ationson Rok the Dab eons ‘tinnion Ge hve econ 3 iA (kre enaoning ten pled oe 3 Je “The mew als wl appt a ses eel lew wos fh cee bos of aero, Tete none ten Dubie pled tet a uneeenedmrierof aiaon ‘On2 and 25 Ap cre Feteon af. Common Eager (DIC) ide ICC hed jont cence eed Inco Craton Cums Reson of Deg Clo 10 dee ooh de Hat were aed yeni ‘oli andro cto ei fs nef ne neg deg wh ‘tion ess ud he yw sd hee Ein ctpe ten nate oper alton tnd ose An perp on ‘ements re eon “On 31 Api the lean Coane oe Commer itn ICON) andthe Dba {mcr ron Cee (DIAG) Eee of Atl Avan Spe nce on Pion, Miho Hoang etd Hermsan, ‘hned Rote and sed mene | TCA coma tgste wh nro trac: More than 00 dle Eos eth id ‘jhe Me Ee put ied Fallow by 0 ICCA coun mvang 001 May {ay nner The cue ene 30 ‘pec menor sven coun dat ook ‘honed usta Lebnse ch The URE Tram ha to cancel a il be Rong ee oD hare aie with [Retr tan Beg 29 Ap wh ah ell he hee Cael Norns n anon ‘ier eg one hing ls or od ‘be wt ve tse iit hare Erp ring bo ain he Me Exes by compan srl oe "The Deb tere Abiton Cone etd po an cure ne Apion is Engh n poner with Kags Clee Use The ph ga oe inlet of og Lf tne coun, Both ‘un ee ep ears nthe ‘ert dyer possonee Jur Pulao are th ope i Eat Sn bony Al smn Company of wick the woe ot enter The foul ue the Me Eat ape As ad Nov Are ‘aon A pn we praca ofthe TRE May Banu dg of Aber competing eve of ra imlementason of sis of the New Yer Comenton, te pups exchanged soe: el sort jc ning he True si of Nek Coonenon i utente Are nguge version othe the cleave implemenstion ft lr Sette oa the Comeaten wor si peed spon by a Present Thi mural led wdc of "Fhe UAE one te hereon sow rere is wba lepton, A Ga ot Foye now UAE Acton Loo heed {Soper 200 ape by he UNCITRAL onic tn he ex open ferment ced eae fom both Sat edrwe rb rv by 2 waking ‘be Me Ee and Europe The ld» pty he en ete oer Te UAES New Arenas Law isle ty the ode hey epee a 1200 ak lt be aes nD sn ‘het ao 207 pray he Data ‘Stag an 2019) pots contin oper. Destpmst Sgy ea of eng Dubos conor sand lain hme expe manta eh ‘tne of Sect aces a Sify pal the proven oe Spon by setaing MONEY COLUMN: 50- 50 SPLIT FALLS WITHIN ‘ACCEPTABLE MARGIN ‘aru cove conte not bono Neve magn ofesimaton’ on quant Inatansr o member st Cobo Checttngkn Be unary teicommonpce fr re fon v9 hi teria phe xy An CSD euler, homeo ely ected ‘ca ty Chi on imap sad whee tal jh "heii i de hat Cie soa inant donee ie MTD Baa {edie iny MTD Chie soe be Te approve vad he rect Iara aoetion I che bte 19%, MTD sought o develop a mee we ped commun oh of ‘Senigs Cle The poe led when the Chile goreaman deine oro he Shep MID thera bought cla {SS 1CSD cb under siete ty {id enourgel» ong ejection ta he ‘eh MID Teen sere th the ‘fee prec ly ser HED tad ery ”GLOBAL BRIEFING And igs Stes pes {nd Roig Orns Banco raed mote SENTD ne dard topo he ‘The ICSD al esing the poe ‘ima erwen MTD a Che 0 apna of 25 My 200 al Sl fn ot ma ke “ie i fe BF hr eh a "6 Cnn i re fon en en pny th, pe Sop eet aS ‘anisnapanpts e pr ao Se Fann The ICSI bal wo catty mrad by Inv ved tora expos torte 0-50 | ak al ea ob i ie ‘a alg ma ef ‘ear rt ‘Fon fase nen pe ‘Bee aay ok lp ‘it ay ene leh a mepntig nage fein Pty ‘so pnt be oie "py ue at (Bids em ‘Se mt cue ee (et sada ri i ‘th ed pre ‘yn oi (Por nnd eo a ‘ie eg a fe "Aran Chi ot sea of reves aboot he 80-50 ange econ row had on xo pound ne SID ‘atvance bough Ces caleage a ‘acy 09 a fig ha AD et tty ‘pln i er ene meh chee he ef oc aa ar er ae [hl pe uh BO eg oft mein Ce Sl eg mult comitiee James Caw Sara ‘Ordones Nowa ange Giber Gullame {presen de she FCS born ad Ire decied th damage cn ie The sant commie decid in a hehe had ne nd could nt pope hens th baal poe oe he “deine of comin i ne ‘Them the commie weve othe sea 50-30 aeabon explained dat inating tak Than aire ee ence 3 ue especily with pect sre ey “The Chi re Rape tw for 5080 gat (Bl Noel feo sg a ed Srmputon ech omy Ad ‘he tame commer deco eed NEW ZEALAND: PRIVATE APPEALS AVAILABLE SOON ‘Now 2eolond' netute hor unvoled fn otiraherspectic appease body 10 Stat lal ths yore. Tho new service wil Glow users o Koop he cosas iver. Compt Wesker pone ot Clow Waker explains “The Arbirtnan Medinr (tate of New Zesnd(AMINZ) bs are new Poco 0 ‘roe spp orm silo be rived ‘Seen conde ta gh ual ‘rn New Zan ison Act 185, {ns the igh Cone Barapa Dr the pb dora an nt be sony of “Tae aw spel roe sot ne ‘ede when th al wad wa ee by be spline Dang he pve seo! sy ‘pp Bed dct ptiod hn een eed, spay 0 ny arent a poder Perec in apt he bert to oe Upped erate nee ec esa ss appl ob pied a hoc by the AMIN Cau f beton The four pin eer eo thee meres Est 2 pn Temes se ane sty {Seldon sd mabe de oped {Say cei point eerie he Some is a is Te (hve he appa derail on he apo The ‘Tet Gnu athe eng wh ype ‘te Aton A 1968p tha my {supe reson Inch ces eb ty deo he no tt al tere hve ‘eh emnaed The wal opeibah aed ‘thew mt th eal fore In Row Zone wal pp ib roses ted awe io othe selma be wai Soh POLAND: PRIVATISATION U-TURNS CONTINUE ‘A Gipio over the Poth sugar ints Foard erin soystomaet ‘Wordyrat of Waray & Parnes onc mrembcrof Guba) Wirofon Review's GStofalbosr ‘Ae pen ne ru 10 apts in Pld ry ed om teint es Sach high number aad be nino concer “There bees hinge pont by eur ich asx ea se in ee in grein hres ne forte ne hte mnie ar eve yo ring» gen etc The cons ees (en which GAR hs pred in exter edn) Hoan wanton n Po oe |geseoned nd ese by pal opron inter we the opponent cee poe, seendo so cern a 0 ieGLOBAL BRIEFING ypeemens signed bythe preceding genre, ‘ein sate coe ene enters pe Recently, German agar company Nowtacker nde biel ovement ety The ey ‘nam fom a incomplete patton ‘of 1 te-owoed sp ener Ke rede ‘baying before the en Posh gornment ‘hanged 8 sp nds pinscion ste, owen a teed fn aoe, ‘tho fee fog iesment. Unde he eid see ahr than sng sate-owned efneres ‘to india investor legis die ‘ompsny~ Pols Caer SA sie podacton in he ba of Pt uit, of Poland sugar markt was shattered Too, Nezuche contol sod 8 per ene fhe ‘Glink and he der cour in Porn dmined 4 clin fo eer of shares ofthe ean, Ip Decerber 2005, Noiecke lek ‘tanya be coat of ateaton a Boies ‘thing foe competion in he amount Falmos 200 rion (his show ruth complete wanton). “The teary ha now ep the sin 05 Ap 27 eye ie ty lupe can be preted oa erin cout ‘ot mbitaton only fer degen ron ht truly ken place which in the opinien of the ‘carry ever da The wey therebe apes hacer ao egal round or the abc proceeding inated by Norah. "Nordecke fois parc agves tat is lve in Pld wa onsale atsining 2120 per cont mht share Wi prs 8 ‘er cent share. te sale ler onthe Ps market Nodeler si now to rece ‘expecta decion by Spring 2008. Ina cen dewlopmenta legit fom ter fhe green between de wes abd [Norducker contained provision wher che ‘rear eal eancel pegs sa cine sed witha ang the son Acorns ioe Nowdzucker’ ai, ‘Other yoicine ered de Norah deine ied yng eat tb malo in omgeaonso tb pracy 40 ion had pi th Eee we cary oe "Greeks lh nce, ‘Aan Hol a peste el Bah Sole won we dept anda he ener cour of etn yen he oleh govt fed dc amc of confi aig ce he ‘ape eteen Poland ema al sgn Ivete afer et or oa tat patton {siete duro unpre Adena the prs dope shows how the lagi 00 ‘chine lr, ning ht da ey oy ny ching nthe pine vincent ‘Tha smahing ery stroll comet SINGAPORE: NATURAL JUSTICE OBJECTIONS CORRALLED Shgopare’s oppeol cour soy aes ‘Shouse way of inertanng in frbtraton on natura jsfce rounds Tho cout notes ht pes are wore Ol he pros cons of ha process Soforcnanc. Nh She. Dariner of Wong Parnentip, toners ‘A cet con af th Snore Cr of sr pocen ding ht cours shold pot ‘Grd soe wk hx pce: gen Si Be & Cs Ph Li Fou Delp [Lal 007 ws aed doe 009 My ‘Pascua wad ow pkey of Cu ice sere dg ron ang Spore sn sce ram ir ti "Te eae Eon» Spa beeen + reper drops, Prune Deon, ‘went co aitason Fairmount let the aarti Freee snd ped ote High Cue st teeing nde ng tre be 8 Vecchi jae yee aa Soh Heng Tee pps sgn the decom to the High Cou “The mht ae om am pe re by Son Beng Tew comple cotton of Sipe She cnn rmant contact modelo andad ‘nf te Sagapr Insite Ache [rick and Concoeo Bung Conse Baring cnmcion So He Te spied seo eyes SB» these eds note 0 Sob Rng Te anes nd ton The he ey ‘coined Sob Benge} cpl ‘enti cera dt Sb Beng ecmnce bod and cined dg om tndke comet caning gaat Frmoue ‘ge fori terion ofthe covet Forount on he an! pce The rdw emit he oc eo the ‘Sond bythe wrong penn Athos ent iste cute bo we Sotteng ee as anplcting eck By he oral completion ft an tha tine fr be estornce othe poet te tn pesuding the High Gout ste he ‘el vedo te cy ee ‘ene it fd bene deprete typo pve x spe on ce a Daciion ‘The Cou of Apel aged wih be High Cert and on tt tee ad ben rach ofS he a pe Ay fn jst, helped ech il a ale ‘Be ctcome of the aed aoe die jue ‘ment phe ‘The Cau App oud woke oe ‘ale of mje bea erg the ‘Enon Soh Benge mended Semen f Clin aon slain okerGLOBAL BRIEFING. oot an them he aes moun. asic an abana fre a bee each | Zale Zea & Pers Boa) ote at Suh altng hc ofthe eon by ofthe rls fel jt in connect thn Lae American nou eum pinay the ateor mel hat he wee ee | anew by wc ig of uy ne ben | an ly wth ne Copan Freeuony Purmwun me ny and aly roused, Speen Sie teoghout the ocecings Te tear "Tague pry died wth he ek | “Reso Won (Vine Abn, Ri de inverted fc tht ne ad m sanonryeachs tach | J) chr olen pers aL een ate wich ware win se amBit_ crated or hat tt wath ling the a, | Area ge san on ea ei ning pom {© gin snoter chance vicar ns lngind | teach sci, | ccmpled sto, oy sop ‘Semen by Venera od Bobs 1 prjice even breach ‘ent poin ea fcor hat nt ily | hth governs wal wil om ‘Teal cou farher bal at so the | bee at thee toe fred prt | he HID comenton weeded Aes seta beihed he er rat juice | afte reening of cua The Court of | Yon melt he he of den ine hve ben ete the | Appeal deen make cle toa | uiprcedened He out ar overancn hou ndaece a eft on the | ure wil aunt sch ofl ice | molec iw ht tbe the otcome Inthe e.the terwor | pele ing ies ar Gagan abd ye are of eran ‘oor torte min cee nd "fo denen te Sco ies ‘hen wich sow ihe ctment ey iy ceric were nad rea becuse | he Singipore Court pasta appoach 9 | recon. Bola ha user enouned ‘ey tad tec sd mdlard by she wong |stats coin the teal | Se way Pence ime ioe hang renege | pots nent be arbre commer, | kw Manes (he nana Conte ‘ors hsdary ning od cc othe forte Reo) sd Jc Sar (OF Si Reet eww Sct Sl hn! ton ‘erect US CRYSTAL-BALL GAZING, | foe ne ton Sttonnishoutsbiteton IN NEW YORK oetuoor aeson oc cen Sebastion O'Meara leit in cit See a CAINUAWYER) atenced Macher = oe Profi & Wood LPs annul eratation eile pom jel de es woh This year's theme was ump the hI om ng ‘urea er whos goad een eee | LOOK tothe cyte Bot ‘nce ee fen ton he eto the itl pce wee dome | Opening ocr: Olnr Ar(Thicer | steamer fr exams CAFTA tcl fot ht tion | Pi & Wood ig te owt of ‘ler Arn ned if rcs ad note Posie hn ow nda aed nvr ot | baton in Lato Amerie adhered of | are hese maton eons o ‘pecing sd rong aren aft | sblaon cole ecuny lB fnt | Sam cert vag oa of treet ‘i posse joan poy oti __| ting te gacl ew om tht seding | "Ent rinse wi i xpon| ines ment cour speimry [on he pounce of een atition | prone medaun ehr hened tmae ‘ncn be ict wha od conc | Fr too tke io "cmb mode” Undying oly eo et "AixYioo ees Boks Deng | See ne atl pacers per omc st settee eens np | fom gn ton ete on sn efit seat pute | US pen pci nthe UR tos Nik Kastor dependent abit and ‘Selusonpocnto cei conmeca’ | wentaniay thre oon of chem | atrecyiningee BC wi raion ed + Thar atioten una piso | ome when Ge dec eke dame ar | nbn cud be it och a rc nwo at oe obj of ape, | the importance of ray cens ted be | tan een ‘change ion tee o in| raed eosae'n «mater omy porter | "The ec clad wih ly con on Sou an expo rdgese Hence | tect wana win sow al han | spe win sso ots Sd he ‘teu bout ne nay or meutety | pepe hos on eax pin aces | {he er cy Sega eae top te nisofeairdjesce ois | tte box counel tice conic ot esd pa ae Zeiecerycocuton bet weer |” The eatng count ia a Areen | Manes (ped ts fst sar ‘ro tetecnpureorruct wih he | fr stirsoe ten Soe core ix, | ofan, spe ys Ma Abr oe tstherhan conetn mk at pene tes | Alton ued a triage ene me ‘pgeced Cao Dar (Dery Anan) | ly hed by pa the deson “Te ape cou he sed ht be ours | eased it ai Amen gon tte conten wc ee tots eco wo ges dtd purty ascent. |e uke both Engi pgs it ant | be bee 3 age aon Sot eed Se ofc chery Having oped fr tarson | fala mith the veice anda eae by | fr cd pa fe le aha ‘are mnt be cen ohn sented tt hey |e lens alowing corre Ine” | Can Ferns Spa Ca Sern Cat oe oly ery heed right fecoune oe | who ne bth gait) ose ou he et | Advpui) poi out htm opie Pen oe Jost Hares Thacher Profit & Wood) gee, depen ont mow senor group oer Would Sherang ut een ine US yenthe- | non be ue dlp» Sie Pres pine Sect eral ner cn new en cone a ery be ed On cee prc Unter Singapore Aron Accand i‘ Incomveniene eading mlraonta lack | eed eon ope pe Inman Afasas Act he ours may set eewbere fr wron dcr Eardo nnn naceROUDTABLE TREATY ARBITRATION IN LATIN AMERICA Earlier this year, Global Arbitration Review convened a roundtable between arbitration specialists from Houston, Venezuela and Ecuador to discuss shifting governmental attitudes towards treaty arbitration, and what the future holds fot beer the cases fad againet Avgentina Have there B9en ony eons trom ne agente experience? tr eink ee are in to be conan etn Attia poly i oe iets dri th ration pose coat ae handed the ston hr won eos ff prea sun fH br a {esto fre sn pe a cat Shem macho pole b s nge poop ‘of deconmokes te ara een hd ‘cecal The ay abe of aero fe tose qcsons aot he pty ‘Slcingnepetons cfeay pple od (cng econ on vey srarsen oc “An her wl a eon in ome ot af he Arent son, Sey st ‘ody 0 =o artical eve a tha eripadece, | hak dueced te cae Ine sound the wl in tte eel ey Acie ink he aed ering nerpreaions of wey pcs wil ely [ere ths dy ee bw sows Prin fou Sv ya wo ave he ct ik i a lw enw it nod re edt tbe a na comiog ocr = ving sa npc bee ero ea whl Ie toogh crorinng ts mewn hat te Coun wl bento wl be sl ee though te concep es Issn emeng ce lw aan cerying et speedo Tt oy loan ery Shy pu dens cing fo ek lerrettor ofthe mine way poi la ‘you mee hen tg reat gn lsh ber ees hc ey ha common eye ed wk Row: Ante leon tt oe tipihed tar he porenmens ae Becoieg ‘oe ad me spied They arene esas wh pl prensa tha ot ‘Somme dghoat a Ani Coie he a it hy need to et rg sume soto do proper cach sd rp thnale Tho th tye ln ow odd ean hey ne hein ne pelo he yr: tnd. ft, ee en the proper ‘Bea oar iin ech ees md ‘ich ther Th pay bree oe US ae ‘cpu he oped steps se tol pes cope of deine ke Pa coun od the stores nts Soot ib eed wo tee hin, in nk lay goerment eck mo ‘ephaccated han ny on won ‘ay epee thy bn om the ry Bing ‘ery septs coe ot hom cee: eee epitctes arash ken onow hoyrow optacn rocgolaar fe rong Niro tetrama hor video aware na ow onde tng sed ety chins For csp ey Kw hwo ato eae lovoun abd ake hn wakes od wees ‘Then te ewer aes pera ci ‘ora chs tn won sen oh {oma before td hs oer, ‘Te ound oak pace bere ewe of olvih wheeal om ISD.ROUNDTARLE ‘ov hho in och ea ate Se ear geo ch peo ‘ny bo oreo br one ‘Ga topo meas ve ree es {2 Sreghourng oun er re a inert amc sowpany upon fhe ‘ace ely dha compet wl 00 Findon unentod the ri of chins May eo ee ete ‘er cosine the BITs in he ences cna Th Venerol eed he mponnce of bing aac by eras tr cat a the mneotitono (i cqmc wa coed sophie ong lt oa chin vn as Anes ag abo lee tora oc mun ofthe conpai wee Proteome ening t ‘Sin evry coony Congrats “Ten wold a aie tht he eens Shon not wth ne come ‘eo pene il be Pease 96 umn prtec of the high aout of Tad thon pcs Ea ate sce thera BE chenan,ConecoPhilps, son Mb a Fane ean Norway Se es apelin pet ace ew fon whch ron mpi) ‘Mint awe Hea een a cleiy Filophy and anes ey peered Srey eg to nk igh nel of pcan ha my eo Sloe love oe we Bee | tas Americ, nding ew i Aria sw hepenmcl lt Ande oe a | ew png te ye sephiseon,1ik eae And in xe oon ny cmon saton sucha png ey they feel the peste of pia opinion? Jc pct not res polo ek Fenda by i te Sunes Anzu: Ata farmer fice f he ‘een warm ot one roe hv yn ean a ‘Be potas sumtin he cam Boe ial he ct arama ou hve oom ts yan iy pol tna | fi So tae rd rene ‘And eth oie cvcered wih oni tis om tock cee pty dt ete ste oma oe ou charge aoe Sovtortht yr ae ae mig not be wel cm doce Tas poe tne the cert pono oe the eof cm eee ou doa wane be fhe pon pon frat = you do a ‘ben te smoun fam stan nit ok: Doel of ied a oul of Fron rues peeing pore Eihos cco ofa de posal of ea iy iy dan fe nes ‘Bint goed aio, prlay whl ‘Serle tht ou cero he oer ad eee concer sh cei of "hee oe ee ha ap Be ted by {acne goers and les oa 1 pl om dang wha the J tn Agent te te day je wor forthe vert ex Inet fhe Spee Cou, afro it otciy conse dong hy wal re ‘ated by he evrment cl Teaco fn hve ea henROUDTARE | stash racist sive cher TERS ‘Csr Cel ns Dank bp ante Habe 2 ink ow dos he ovement in by__|aoray api which ous mynd Hasan Ths nals rte sponng he agey swe yas mare roar opin tom ann Agents weve | pal for oes Ad hk ot aly. ‘mend ng dw of | Swe len $ihog goverment my cas wl Ie Teal ko wonder i coal Americ not cal td lng et hein th hte oe hoo tae hfe” | mio oumig hn webe™| nh ses ae en Semvoponr satan onton'toniy | hpeachin es on pla corneas dt omcig too hod Oe ‘Stil ma Pern ote | Eel singin wy an be eer ace rn i ais ‘What conic 40 esa ate ieee of ale 4, wtih was an exelent cxese a kit ry ear at ono Ect ety pms ing Shino me fn Splay btn bere jon seenmso.s pach eel appexcssnee “In Ecuador and Bolivia, | stm sl ip: The nw Re pote Shen: Compan Gee wit bee maton | forte poy of he wba ing te hie ines tunic mang. inning om | fOT eXample, or even (Stik friction wi emer stan mold nalennna cameo |Venezuels, where there is immer rence => SEPSIS EPs thinys are very differen. | Race esi yates Spipuga nomatn tne Anes Ove f Ty those countries there is| Ere heat cu warn bt Sudkcmgnedesecs [politcal eri |...] Counsel | sant eremaeteer sata SISRESGSMSTSITS have to understand that” | Sapasesse terrence drdsome poi ocs a eposnc Tay hr cae tke edn 0 ay hd at chat tne Bu in Bevo a Bais, or Javier Robalino | is ebay enrenched in Li Anetcan bigation ina rial | 1 dei ey Eran ars ey ingore Sromrner a aloet Coon hes | {ting om spine tat pot ‘ern {rerun le how te mend he er camp i ging be vey dca hare anying about ha roy Soon eng pce, a sowie mrching Ani siae nou, | ebielon proces fst hat Goud be Betmoxproteiy wh very seongexetine | ered To Make Governments mae | Cn wou tha estan al ech eee ae cord my fne | ling 1 sth cones ‘loon pe oie in ase Aces would tow opis ores mech +a. tex rented ring tp of poe wth he leseunieot cmp Hosni oni shou conder __| pole we hve en ing eo “hi owners ie cwsinio |_| cnt ce enn | ag i Een eh pate ooROUNDTABLE inher fon counes boot aw eset Sone mie poche be nar tee ICStD adi the eo cose adit ‘esi cea Tine ental pen he idee po ne wich anering {CSI heed set sd eng ane ee (C3 Ms, Jer Rol, Csr Crna ame Arsene Sab STE saz Anaoutn ge with Robes bt _| oben he ton we lene porte tenes pe poeon tiunccesOFeoue pain fom he other ringer cine tg the ney | Ro ik havea yor qusion Sieyon ely ne the tgensste 1S beeue | pry 5 20geu experince read | ip gel ye BIT he oie he oni cometary Soe you sele. | ore ost yr So nether won| If pn expected perp en ty te te or npr ‘nc tin rope sepa excel em Suna Akzo The ages might Be ‘score Bs re pie Sar ofthe me ogous ndeaen by Saget because pte | he nerd potent warned when | he gnc sin gol Row they Ip cn ieee pets But | hea tere ote ie ea fom te | ego by ema. ty nscale comic te eece ot, | Sut oc cvmone thi le hing | Tyo comply ape wi Dosk nd Toa ioe fein sno ne ee pa pi {Se in ee ofeach of he Cones Ninh nies woul be ebti tne ppl cel cnet ees che (iterate amen en ec cova ‘owe Neri May verse tok coudtp fe poms of ain Seely pound oy omcbiog ‘vc ISD ol LeAnne ‘Sits IT hewn te Neder on tities troceimiabo hve dole trace a 7 ‘And I think that Tiyan yee ed ovo woraateveamenttaateiteen_| wwe ought to perhaps fem hoped when they weresigneat They ere TreCO} rainy used seams 0s on ext sear se investment ies in chat Context | fame eaten mr jar wi the US bat 0 sri Epem conn ed " sume Anconsactam conionly sng _/28.4 Species of human SMinateerdaingegvrnocehcaces [rights” fe sing at {clr et tn sf erty Doak Bishop] af gexmata Bi ot ec C3 il nor FT Carcass ape anc of ery SUSE cre dng tt ry eee | ‘Sg! spe ee 8 1, mnt On cme hint ink enon | Staton tt nnn ote snd ‘Stags whch sid nee | Myshcory sec mat of he neo 4 | ce: Hon og aot HL ep te Ow SCELUEoc one Tiere | gun see noesly ee see pion | nop mrs te om wr err memetcss | feeleton barren tserins | ehh Somme fray ae icc Sioa ‘Tn New dy meter) Guege | Aer ronan Sor gerne do Dott su chk he one othe wand of | healed he psec oe price | nyt ae gi to hee at cosmid rveton ngage abe! na rene | tate ewig ofp con jres | coor pam wou be a nea pele {inet Bosna ed on nso | cate coun, by emanate posal | Tun hy male te Bs lp dt i rey impercn l ak hoh the Bs But ne 10 The 2 ects ero which dost‘Vern Tn, Jer Reina ah lat Car es Protas peopl wi ae Tha a he Shots ink ht wel be xe ‘Shey conchae san Area pn Sol eco anew Wl he increase in popualy of FAS mutlatara weatas uch ex CArTA have ‘On mpact on ternational erbirafont tog ieee ni the OECD stented 1 or ‘her and he energy carer ay © becoming {es nce ample sen ay ‘osnrmersptrn he comet of FTA bce of he te opporne a he ie te ne die rc th hey toed be hing ios BIT Sots mck eer july emeingit cerain ype of ip ‘out de oc et mare cra S01 ak Socks Syme oC FTA say eee fe dio FT te oe ppc. In this sizoct or wel rom the start of negotaing a 818 sar cou wr a iy sie wha ey In ed Bou changing Th coer cas ben thet xperee fhowi ow eat ey proce aes ne a pe Jere ochones pobre ther Proto ooo bee wl be aye ‘Tig with de pel tom, th econ, Isr nk ter ery ing st Ineo cones ns we ne Peet ‘eg copa rs haan a, stehar de UN ann gh con the US nd EU exe on baron ih and 1 Proprio eyecare het i aw te et ‘Fenton wich how ct ht dh wry pede tn pa ou had Slomate petro ater wens gore ROUDTAELE [peer eos Tei oly itn he sto fama ribs cor in Emp US sno ae we psp hl erent cin edt thensapeie ohana get bee ie righ of det sebo apeeth gorermen t ‘Qe kt hk at sd ching. Ba sping ack he ven at een, ened woogie 2 een cy theater Ameren Comma fiom Righe apna Arne ces Shhh ty oc ha se erpepion sf propery eran nese yn ihe "Tic a oye ra human ig ing in ett eT ete he ‘a hr cot ison Bu 1 ik oe of he port {eon which ot omething that en {Ste ame ene hte BITE Otay, ther th feral Cou of toe ‘en sighs cour wih certains ects incengy 2 wed of ong ‘pncrment serore Ad ik te ‘Svea porn bec eno iine [Scrnmena td bop gute oat [Nes roronil yin he ipo ink ewe pate ee whe the ergo ongh + plone pceion pace bay ee wae ‘Sout wa wa ging on wth ane A Jurce od woul tke mor dan ple of “Fem CSI ahitn te gremest set gy rec wh Oxi veo itha2 whole ingot on the ac poly prea counry aod he pc poacy of Thank you.CORPORATE COUNSEL Do you have any ext palces on here fo she rotation which es to "We do at ve ne pli on eer he ice aio othe a we pc her, ‘hor decom en to be een by he pri cen fn cont nd awed hgh comin with te ving le Tho prequites nade near of See cee nse te 1958 New rk ‘prt nti i pnd lees do Name: Andrew Clarke Age: 49 Company: ExxonMobil International Corporation —_|*We also maintain a Title: Assistant general central repository of legal counsel (Europe gas & memoranda and articles power marketing) on developments in nice rte methine sent tne [atbitration as well as on ekadramet mates Gta wien |r could have, matured into arbitration Where ci you taint ged wh bw ere om Cabri lr ad Competed ny ar ao Lon, tbe Coun or Legal Edin the lng Year fer er of ppp in Gray an ad Lino am, ang on cme od corps wrk so weed wih sme ler fonpans inthe US and UK bering | hich do you refer insttonal oro Natl Noch Set Lil n London a HHP, ow attheon How isis your company’s cunent | tor can be wry el dig ae tu iDicermaon com wher the sone | ded been ich enn efocblyo Spe in econo SH mon (pene mace eae, How erany member ofthe department | How do you communicate abtation| spacial th orm of work ‘ease to those wihin your company Seerlof cabot yen eripee who neod fo be aware of Ie nuances Ir sbiata proceeding fm ene 0 ot aiitaione Sine depen on he tect use tnd |e doh tn sel ap. One hoop the (her piste ee Bethe four | ie capertan wih ou lp eon [Morac acelin his es Myon | Wty in ur oie egras {tonite minh pert efny sine espent_| oer who enrol Knowle shone ‘rron ery pinay eee) | heroin er and he ing {les ng Se aM nd | cto ne nro Goll He pie, ouiatbmeneone (specific disputes that have, cf pat hen hy nein and et lnohage of ins ben pce hgh Be We tho matin ene mpotry fg ‘Macon 2 welt on ie pts the ha cal ave ted to brs and ee Ietecome sae ouce ofeach mer “hs me gull BexnMobi pa ‘ny wbjece rere oD dae Beebe fhe deity fo oon and he dtc ou neon ‘ay hw Gr or eet wrk sd te orp How has your thinking on managing (Seoutes volved over tna voor The nape ost pater ne “tote ee The connec wel ‘TN we bel nd compo whl dees ef hope on both he penton ‘nt an the pt etaon tain reap Ove sine Sapte eon ovate bre been ae gia prof ‘edison rte pb conor hat leo protecting ena ens Cnet one seen a gear roth sche ban tale our dang ov date (Grn ee of pte ager tn he sso) aod how much tots The ne Fereve manaenent of pre wheter ie fing ough be aur doagh wn, tec een more prnooned hee flor he cunged. Our hoe coven ve | style payin ies rats wou you meretere ave 12 ‘means who ws ew nat ol? (Gee manager egies» ton fi, ‘irom Come Spt a teow ey mein feud drone seal What quaitios moke @ goad exert course! fer nleriona bition? We ‘hey defrost‘CORPORATE COUN ‘Wl oe sede oul pose ll ie Ith bina ae chan Gn | eon one the elope of the ald Sibi | hey ro vn tects tet e seine ly er tend ‘foe Therapy i th seed ahd one trove the a ¢ other issues that tome oront te court, which may beled to affect Seren caeme er n dispute | Tetedurcesk Mamanirre eons deel dc not management relate to beading mea ee stat so caitccmodaniyaaie {the level of manpo Senge ranted pent coonanmewdcamedaire [it requires [...] and how | tayrslage ocbant td sad i rs wh a coop pn Sponge fone Jmuch it cost ’ what conan rsivtardotemoteo | peter ron trreuon on you 1S mse vin! wah wus You font youre 12 immer fwteisialards. | Accutire oft etoton | moe au wotnte sour “equecpeccne Forcing | det. bthere evng hat sees a Tengen cagcce | igh reedtobe owe aren you | tmp daca ndtommntao Spal inn neotsfetet ngs | Rann Saud be kopovect ica ake ceheg eaten prt Tianconad denetotrvacws goal | et Rp on ara COMPETITION Pins iy ‘The international journal of competition policy and equation ‘An annual subscription comprises 10 issues of the journal, including the special survey issue "Rating ‘NOW Enforcement’, plus "The HIRING, GCR100" survey supplement {and 10 special reports. Each issue offers: + Exclusive interviews with leading competition authority officials and ‘economists, providing insight into the development of policy worldwide + Briefings and comment on competition policy in over 50 countries + Indepth market analysis and country surveys For further information, please visit www.GlobalCompetitionReview.com/subscribe ‘email Subscriptions @GlobalCompetitionReview.com or telephone +44 20 7908 1185CONFERENCE DIARY laueusr Aisne Aen Moving. se ances lt — 5: Amma Cone exercises Ineo dt eu nee | Acadkeny on International lamer Negation and — Jame Opa Reali? louse [Comecn May Coens |Ariration Group Smpesiam icin 1s 1 waropean User Coane sympa hy — 2» Negotinting. Drsting, sansging neato Conic Resaion [asenbiy 2077 \CONFERENCE DIARY OCTOBER San Fat Mating ‘angen De Wahingo Cale ofa 12nd Ane Aine Leading Atte? Speposaay tm he Condo nero! Sion Jie Cotes \o:Prodact Labi Ligation in the Anomable fey Catenge of Gal Ligation Tadoe Congo U:TEIA Ade-Pse Ur Council Smposum Secor 18-9: WIPO Advan ‘Workshop on Domain Nase Diagn Reution Updteo0 Praccs and Precedent Treat 2: Abietion: A Conpont Viewpoint ice 29-99 Dispute Resouion Pee ‘bien in Lan Ares roe 7-8 Ltn matic Leading “Avinatn Symposia or ‘eon Jo Conc Revstaion ma aie To Atirion Workshop Count Symposia 2%: UCIA Young lntenatonal “Arbination Groop Symponn tite o Wild Basins La 25 Fhe Annual Late ion May 20, Gael nition Revie nk arn Aston 2 anh 6 Peebengee Ds TUNE 2008 ‘niversay a the New York Date Bes OCTOBER 2005 [O02 AN Boies Law Boron Ae