Broms v's Hansen Methods - Laterally Loaded Pile

Unchecked!

(Cohesionless soils only)

Foundation Dia (m) =
Embedment (m) =
Soil angle of friction (deg) =
Soil density (kN/m3) =

1.05
4.6
30
18

Mu (kNm)= 1300
Hu (kN)= 26
Stability Factor= 1.3

(included in Mu & Hu)

Top Down (F1)

Depth
(m)
0
0.23
0.46
0.69
0.92
1.15
1.38
1.61
1.84
2.07
2.3
2.53
2.76
2.99
3.22
3.45
3.68
3.91
4.14
4.37
4.6

Kq
5.03
5.25
5.46
5.67
5.88
6.09
6.30
6.51
6.72
6.93
7.15
7.36
7.57
7.78
7.99
8.20
8.41
8.62
8.83
9.05
9.26

Pz
pz.D Ave Pz.D Seg area Agg area
(kN)
(kN)
(kPa) (kN/m) (kN/m)
0
22
45
70
97
126
157
189
223
258
296
335
376
419
463
509
557
607
658
711
766

0
23
47
74
102
132
164
198
234
271
311
352
395
440
486
535
585
637
691
747
805

11
35
61
88
117
148
181
216
253
291
331
373
417
463
510
560
611
664
719
776

3
8
14
20
27
34
42
50
58
67
76
86
96
106
117
129
141
153
165
178

3
11
25
45
72
106
148
197
255
322
399
484
580
687
804
933
1074
1226
1392
1570

Mom
area
(kNm)
0
3
8
16
28
43
62
86
114
146
184
227
276
331
392
459
533
615
704
800

Bottom Up (F2)

A/M area
(kNm)

ZF1

0
3
11
27
55
99
161
247
360
506
690
917
1193
1524
1915
2374
2908
3523
4227
5027

0.12
0.29
0.45
0.61
0.77
0.93
1.09
1.25
1.41
1.57
1.73
1.89
2.06
2.22
2.38
2.54
2.71
2.87
3.04
3.20

Seg area Agg area

(kN)
(kN)
3
8
14
20
27
34
42
50
58
67
76
86
96
106
117
129
141
153
165
178

1570
1568
1560
1546
1525
1498
1464
1423
1373
1315
1248
1172
1086
990
883
766
637
497
344
178

Mom
area
(kNm)
0
3
8
16
28
43
62
86
114
146
184
227
276
331
392
459
533
615
704
800

A/M area
(kNm)

ZF2

5027
5027
5024
5016
5000
4972
4928
4866
4780
4667
4521
4337
4110
3834
3503
3112
2653
2119
1504
800

3.20
3.21
3.22
3.25
3.28
3.32
3.37
3.42
3.48
3.55
3.62
3.70
3.78
3.87
3.97
4.06
4.16
4.27
4.37
4.49

Adopt
F1= 860
F2= 834
ZF1= 2.46
ZF2= 4.02

Mu= F2*ZF2 - F1*ZF1

= 1237
approx = 1300
Compare Hansen depth of >4.6m with Broms of 4.36m

271080676.xls

Z v's Pz

05/22/2015

06:38:49

ie for these conditions, Hansen more conservative.

271080676.xls

Z v's Pz

05/22/2015

06:38:49

Interpolate F1 & F2+Hu Value

F1

F2+Hu

F1

F2+Hu

F1

F2+Hu

3
11
25
45
72
106
148
197
255
322
399
484
580
687
804
933
1074
1226
1392
1570

1596
1594
1586
1572
1551
1524
1490
1449
1399
1341
1274
1198
1112
1016
909
792
663
523
370
204

804
933

909
792

804
817
830
843
856
869
882
894
907
920
933

909
898
886
874
862
851
839
827
815
804
792

271080676.xls

Z v's Pz

Equilibrium
Point

0.0
0.1
0.2
0.3
0.4
0.5
0.6
0.7
0.8
0.9
1.0

F1

F2+Hu

F1

F2+Hu

P(s)

856
869

862
851

856
857
858
860
861
862
863
865
866
867
869

862
861
860
859
858
857
855
854
853
852
851

0
37
75
112
149
186
224
261
298
335
373
410
447
484
522
559
596
633
671
708
745

Equilibrium
Point

Equilibrium
Point
P(s) values from
Caisson for plotting

05/22/2015

06:38:49

271080676.xls

Z v's Pz

05/22/2015

06:38:49

Broms v's Hansen Methods

5
4.5
4
3.5

Depth, Z

3
2.5
2
1.5

Hansen
Broms

1
0.5
0
0

100

200

300
400
500 (Pz, kPa)
600
Ult Lateral
Soil
Resistance

700

800

900