You are on page 1of 114

VENTASIS RATAS

SENOJO IR NAUJOJO STATYMO arba TESTAMENTO


su Vulgatos tekstu
Vert ir komentori pridjo
Kauno Arkivyskupas-Metropolitas Juozapas Skvireckas
TURINYS

Senojo
Testameto
knygos:

Naujojo
Testamento
knygos:

PIRMOJI
MAKABIEJ
KNYGA

Pradios

Mato

Ijimo

Morkaus

1 perskyrimas

Kunig

Luko

2 perskyrimas

Skaitli

Jono

3 perskyrimas

Atkartoto statymo

Apatal darbai

4 perskyrimas

Jozus

Rymieiams

5 perskyrimas

Teisj

1 Korintieiams

6 perskyrimas

Rutos

2 Korintieiams

7 perskyrimas

1 Samulio
1 Karali *
2 Samulio
2 Karali *
1 Karali
3 Karali *
2 Karali
4 Karali *
1 Kronik

Galatams

8 perskyrimas

Efezieiams

9 perskyrimas

Pilypieiams

10 perskyrimas

Kolosieiams

11 perskyrimas

1 Tesalonikieiams

12 perskyrimas

2 Tesalonikieiams

13 perskyrimas

1 Timotiejui

14 perskyrimas

2 Timotiejui

15 perskyrimas

Titui

16 perskyrimas

2 Kronik
Ezdro
Neemijo
Tobijo
Juditos
Esteros
1 Makabiej
2 Makabiej
Jobo
Psalmi
Patarli
Pamokslininkas
Giesmi giesm

Filemonui
ydams
Jokubo
1 Petro
2 Petro
1 Jono
2 Jono
3 Jono
Judo
Apreikimas

Iminties
Ekleziastikas
Izaijo
Jeremijo
Raudos
Baruko
Ezekilio
Danilio
Ozjo
Jolio
Amoso
Abdijo
Jonos
Mikjo
Naumo
Abakuko
Sofonijo
Agjo
Zakarijo
Malakijo

* Taip ios knygos vadinamos


1921 met leidime

vada

LD 2 4 2 %
HZdZ[b^c dgr`hl^ kZg]Zf^
.+ KZldnmbg ob^mZ ^g+ O^l*
mZf^gmh dgr` mZki^ ldbkbZfZ bgb Zib^ `Zk[bg`Zl bmbdbf r*
]ob^f HZdZ[b^cdgr`hfl+ Ihkl ] dhoZl ikb^ [^]b^orlm bk mZb
c ]ob^c bk Znmhkbnl) bk mbdleZl b m d^mnkb bfmf^b) ikZlebg*
g^ mZl iZml) mZbZn cb^]ob lncng* dnlb gnh @s]kh bk I^^fbch eZb*
`bZfhl oblZb mbgdZfZb) g^l ]Zer* d bdb FkblmZnl `bfbfnb) dnkb^
dZl) Zib^ dnk chl^ dZe[ZfZ dh* [^ HZdZ[b^c dgr` [m oblZb
g^ oblZb mZl iZml) bk chl ob^gZ g^bghfb+Nn`k b =Z[behghg^*
dbm lZoh mnkbgbn `^kZb iZibe]h+ eZblol r]Zb) oblZb b`bc b lZ*
HZdZ[b^cnfb [noh ikZfbgmZlmk^*  oh ebgdbfh c lmZ[f^e]rlm bk r*
bZlbl dngb`h HZmZmbch lgnl En* > fbhc^ lZoh ]Zn`nfhc^ bmbdbfb
]Zl+ F mZl oZk]Zl k^bdbZ) g^ ?b^onb) bZbi mZbi lnlbmoZkd KZ*
oblb ob^gZbi ZbdbgZ+ ?Zn`nfZ e^lmbghc^ oZ]hoZncZgm @s]knb bk
eZbdhlb mhl gnhfhgl) dZ] cbliZ* 7 I^^fbcnb) mb^lZ) mnkch bk mhebZn
]ZkrmZl b ZkZfZbdhh]bh fZj* c deZnlrmb i^kl) [^m`Zech `ro^gmb
jZ[Za bk k^bdbZ ieZdmnd) bk D lZoh l^gZbl ikhbZbl bk lmZmr*
mh]e cbl [nol ]nhmZl En]nb ]e  fZbl) oZe]hfb ob^mhc^ lZoh or*
ch ]klnfh bk gZklnfh dhohl^ ) kbZnlbhl mZkr[hl bkorkbZnlbcdn*
ikb^ lZoh mZnmhl le`cnl+ KZl* D gb`+ FZb <e^dlZg]kZl ?b]rlbl
dnb mZl iZml oZk]Zl [noh iZlZ* ln`kbho i^kl dZkZerlmbkch iZ*
obgmZl dbmb^fl lZoh mZnm `rgn* mb^l lm^b`mZ oZelmr[ [noh iZ]Z*
lb^fl En]h [khebZfl bk oblb^fl  ebgmZ  d^ebZl) KZe^lmbgZ) ZmlbkZ]nl
HZmZmbch ^bfrghl ZbgbZfl) ghkl D ob]nkrc^ mZkiKmhe^fb^c oZe]hfh
mZ ^bfrgZ) Zghm EnhsZih AeZob* <b`bimh bk N^e^nd Nrkbchl) ikb*
cZnl ebn]bcbfh) mnkcnlb <lfhgb^* deZnlr]ZfZ ob^gb^fl Zk dbmb^fl)
c iZoZk]+ I^ `ZgZ mh) HZdZ[b^* mnkch eZ[Zb ]Zn` d^gmmb8 r]Zfl
cZbl ikZ]mZ oZ]bgmb oblnl) dnkb^ 7 m^dh ]Z[Zk lnlb]nkmb ln ^e^gbs*
dhohch ikb^ Nrkbchl dZkZebnl ]e D fn) bk mZl lnlb]kbfZl ]Zn`^*
lZoh k^eb`bchl) ikhb bk eZblol) ebnb) riZ ]b]^lgbnhl^ fb^lmnhl^)
dnkb^ gnhfbZbdZgdbgZfbdkZncnbk dZbi E^knsZe) [noh mbdkZb Zebg*
fbkmbfb ebn]bch Zib^ lZoh mbdcbf+ `Zl+ Eb^ ikZ]ch lZobgmbl `kZbd

Turinys

.-)

H<F<=D@E FISBJN

\bobebsZ\bc) mZbZn ]ZgZb g^l^d


mnh) dZl chc^[noh`^kbZnlbZ+ KkZ*
]c gb^dn o^klmblZohl^gnl ikh*
bnl) cb^ f lZn) dZl `kZbd
\bobebsZ\bchc^ [noh g^`^kZ) dZl eZ*
[bZn iZmZbdZoh ibdmb^fl fhgb
`^b]nebZfl+ OZ mZdZ iZeb^m dZbi
KZe^lmbghc^ `ro^gZgbnl r]nl)
mZbi bk blbldeZb]bnlbnl dbmnhl^
dkZmnhl^ bk lnldZe] cnhl  lkh*
o^l bk iZkmbcZl+ Qb^gb iZlbebdh
`kb^mZb bmbdbfbl^gZfHhsllmZ*
mrfnb bk iZlbrfch `bebZ mor*
gl f^be^) dbmb rfbZb ebgdh ikb^
lo^mbf gZncnf bk g^ mbd g^lb*
Zebgh gnh lo^mbfmZnb) [^m ]Zk
[noh cb^fl rfb iZlibkmbl+ Kbk*
fb^cb `Zoh oZk] Zlb]) m^blbc)
fZe]bg`c) dbmnl ikZ]mZ oZ]bgmb
g^m^blbZblbZbl) [^]b^obZbl+ NniZ`h*
gcbfh [Zg`Z [noh mZbi `Zebg`Z)
dZ] lnlb]Zk mbdkZl iZohcnl mbd*
kZcZb k^eb`bcZb) bk ikZlb]ch gnh*
fb dhoZ) dnkbhc^ Zlb] oZ]Zb HZ*
dZ[b^cZb lmhch `bgmb k^eb`bchl bk m*
orgl+
/+ Kbkfhc^ HZdZ[b^c dgr`h*
c^ iZlZdhcZfZ Zib^ r] dho
ikb^ d^ebl Nrkbchl dZkZebnl) dn*
kbhc^ cb^) oZ]hoZncZgm HZmZmbcnbbk
mkbfl ch lgnfl) `rg lZoh mb*
dcbfh eZblo bk lZoh ihebmbgg^*
ikbdeZnlhfr[+ Onkbgbh Zmobe`bn
c `ZebfZ iZ]Zebgmb  d^mnkbl ldr*
kbnl+ KbkfZf^ %.) .} /) 4-& Zn*
mhkbnl) mknfiZb iZfbgcl <e^d*
lZg]kh ?b]bhch gn`Zecbfnl bk
ch oZelmr[liZlb]Zebgbf) bfZ ieZ*
bZb dZe[mb Zib^ o^gmoZ`bdnl
<gmbhdh @ib_Zgh f`bgbfnl iZ*
o^klmb r]nl iZ`hgbfbl) Zib^ ch
gnlbdZembfnl [ZgrbZb) E^knsZe^b
bk r] mZnmZb) dnkb iZl^dZ [n*
ohbmbdbfc r] lndbebfZlikb^
<gmbhd bk ch dZkZebdc ^bfr*
g+ <gmkZf^ ldrkbnc^ %0).}6)//&
mbdlebZb iZlZdhcZfZZib^En]h HZ*
dZ[b^cZnl o^bde) Zib^ ch dhoZl)

gn`Zecbfnl bk morgl moZkdrf+


Ok^bZl ldrkbnl iZo^lmZl ch [ kh *
ebh EhgZmZgho^bdlfZfl%6) /0 }
./) 21&) hd^mobkmZf^ % . 0 * . 3 )/ 1 & 
dZe[ZfZ Zib^mk^bhch HZmZmbch l*
gZnl Nbfhgh ]Zk[nl+ OZl ldr*
kbnl [Zb`bZfZl iZfbgcbfn) dZ]
Nbfhgh lgnl EhgZl DkdZgZl [n*
oh lZoh moh i]bgbl r] mZn*
mhl oZe]rf^+
<gmkhcb HZdZ[b^c dgr`Z g*
kZ ibkfhlbhl mlbgrl+ Eb ikZlb]^*
]Z ]ob^f eZbdZbl %.) . } /) .6&)
dnkbZbl KZe^lmbghl r]Zb dob^bZ
<b`bimh r]nl ]ZeroZnmb [Zgr*
bhl iZo^gmbgbfh o^gmc^+ Kh
eZbd ]nh]ZfZ ieZmb lZgmkZndZ
mnkbgbh i^gdb EZshgh Fbk^gb^*
bh dgr` Zib^ HZdZ[b^cnl+ Kbk*
fZf^ chl ldrkbnc^ %/ )/ - }.-) 6&
kZg]Zf^ bgb g^m b l^g^lgbh
eZbdh dZbi mZl) dnkbnh ikZlb]^]Z
ibkfhcb HZdZ[b^c dgr`Z) [m^gm)
Zib^ ob^g ord iZldnmbgbZbl N^*
e^ndh DQ f^mZbl) } Zib^ mh dZ*
kZebZnl g^iZordnl f`bgbf Zib*
iemb E^knsZel [Zgrb+ OhebZn
cZn iZlZdhcZfZ) dZbi bk ibkfhc^
HZd+ dgr`hc^) Zib^ <gmbhdh @ib*
_Zgh i^kl^dbhcbfnl bk En]h HZ*
dZ[b^cZnl dhoZl ikb^ c) bdb mh
dZkZebZnl fbkbZb+ <gmkZlbl ldr*
kbnl %.+-) .- } .2) 04& lnlb]^]Z
b bgb Zib^ En]h dhoZl ikb^
<gmbhd Q @niZmhk bk ?^f^mkb*
c Nhm^k) ibkfZbl mh dZkZebZnl
ob^iZmZobfh f^mZbl) dnkbhl [Zb*
`lb r] eZbfmn gn`Zecbfn bk
o^gml mZf gn`Zecbfnb iZfbg*
mb iZldrkbfn+ =Zb`]ZfZl dgr`
%.2) 05 } 1-& Znmhkbnl ZmlbikZ*
h ldZbmrmhcnl ]e chl _hkfhl+
bgb Zib^ dbm HZdZ[b^c) En]h
[kheb) o^bdlfnl bhc^dgr`hc^ob*
lZb gkZ+
0+
FZl rkZ iZkZl HZdZ[b^
c dgr`Zl) chdb bgb gkZ+ I^*
m^gdZ mZbZn Z[^chmb) dZ] mZb [n*

Turinys

H<F<=D@E FISBJN

430

oh r]Zb) eZ[Zb frecnlb^cb lZoh [noh [Zb`mhl kZrmb bk EZshgh
NAONR FL NSPQITX CIN ibkfhlbhl dgr`hl) g^l ch l^ [noh ]mZ b*
dgr`hl Znmhkbnl mnkch [mb KZ* gb Zib^ <kbmbhdh fbkm %.30 f+
e^lmbghl `ro^gmhcZl) g^ <b`bimh+ ibkf Fk+& bk mZbi iZm iZldnmbgbZb
KZe^lmbgZ cZf mZbi `^kZb bghfZ) ch c^ fbgbfb ordbZb Zgdlmro^lgb
dZ] cbl `Zech ZikZrmb ]Zn`r[l g^ dZbi En]h fbkmbl+
1+ Kbkfhcb HZdZ[b^c dgr`Z
g^m bk fZbZnlb fb^lm^eb ob^m+
MZ cbl lZoh o^bdZe r] dZe* ZibfZ 1/ f^m eZbdhmZki+ Ehl
[Z+ r]bdZ ch ZgmkZm [noh b* Znmhkbnl) `ro^gl mbdkbZnlbZb Eh*
 gh DkdZgh eZbdZbl bk iZfbgcl)
ghfZ Jkb`^gnb bk ]Zk o+ Eb^kh* u
fbgZl lZdhlb fZml ^[kZbd dgr*  dZ] mh dngb`Zbdbh ]Zk[Zb Zi*
` h l m^dlm+
b kZrmb chob^iZmZobfhf^mkZbnh*
D mh) dZ] dgr`hl Znmhkbnlln b l^ %.3) /1&) iZdbZ fbgm) dZ] bk
g^fZn iZlb`^kcbfn dZe[Z Zib^ o ch ZikZrmc r] o^bdc ]Zk*
khfg iZeZgdnf lZoh lcng* [nl cbl bk`b kZ]l iZiZlZdhmnl
`bgbgdZfl) k^bdm iZ]Zkrmb boZ* dhdbnhl^ ghkl ob^nhl^ ]hdn*
]Z) ch` cbl kZ ZgdlbZn g^dZbi f^gmnhl^) dnkb bmkZndZl bkiZml
Khfib^cnl [noh iZfl E^knsZ* ]nh]Z lZoh dgr`hc^%ie`+5)/0*}
e %35 f+ ibkf Fk+&+ D dbmhl in* .-) .5 bk d+&+ =^ mh)cbl iZml `Z*
ll dgr`Z g^`Zech [mb iZkZr* ech [mb ebn]rmhcZl DkdZgh moh
mZ ZgdlbZn dZbi .02 f+) g^l mbd Nbfhgh ]Zk[+ Oh]e gkZ kbf*
mZbl f^mZbl lZoh nonlbh moh mhl ikb^Zlmb^l Z[^chmb) dZ]ch iZ*
Nbfhgh HZdZ[b^cZnl ob^mhg lmh* iZlZdhmb ]ZerdZb ZmZmbgdZ mbdk^gr*
ch EhgZl DkdZgZl) dnkbh ]Zk[Zb) [+ F^ebZfZ `b mbd bhdb mhdb
dZ] bk eZ[Zb mknfiZb) dgr`hc^ cZn Z[^chgb ]e dZb dnkb ch iZk^bd*
iZfbgmb+ ?Zn`^ebl fZgh) dZ] m gnhfhgb Zib^ lo^mbfZl mZn*
dgr`ZiZkZrmZ ]Zk ikb^ `rohlmh c mZl) Zib^ <e^dlZg]kh ?b]bhch dZ*
dngb`Zbdbh `Zeohl) mh]e Zgdl* c kZerlml iZ]Zebgbf lZoh oZ]Zfl)
bZn g^dZbi .-3 f+ ibkf Fk+BkZb* . Zib^ khfgnl) Zib^ mZkbZf r]
dbdZl DHZd+ dgr`hl o^kmbfZl Zm* `bfbgrlm ln liZkmb^bZbl+ ?eibk*
lbkZ]hmbdkbZnlbZb$g^be`Zb mkndnl ih b fhch ]Zerdhk^bdmiZlZdrmb) dZ]
dgr`hl iZkZrfh) g^l r]Zb ^e^* c ZnmhkbZnl blbk^bdbfZl Zib^ <e^*
gblmZb rkZ c ikbflZoh dZghg dlZg]kh dZkZerlml iZ]Zebgbf
]ZkibkfZf^ bfmf^mrc^ ibkf Fk+ b k^bdm lnikZlmb g^Zib^iZldrkbf
<gmkhcb HZdZ[b^c dgr`Z iZkZ* oZ] dZkZebZbl) [^m Zib^ iZldrkb*
rmZ `kZbd dZe[Z) bk mZb g^ mbd = f cb^fl mZf mbdkhl o^bdbfhlkb*
mZ chl ]Zebl) dnkb rkZ EZshgh o^b* b mb^l dZkZerlmc^) dZl b mbdkc bk
dZeh lnmknfibgbfZl) [^m mZbi b Zghm dbm blmhkbd gnhfhgl rkZ
iZm Z[n]n c ikZ]^]Zgbn eZbdn) c ord+ F dgr`hc^ ldZbmhf^ Zib^
KbkfZf^ eZbd^ iZlZdrmZl bk ch b dbmn ]n ]Zerdn) gkZ mZb iZmb^l
iZkZrfh eZbdZl) [m^gm ./1 f+ ZnmhkbZnl gnhfhgl iZk^bdbfZl)
ibkf Fk+)mh]e bk oblZdgr`Z iZ* [^mmbd iZdZkmhcbfZl orkZonlb r*
kZrmZ mbdkbZnlbZb g^ ZgdlbZndZbi ] mZki^) g^ oblZb mbdk bgb
./1 f+ <gmkZl eZbdZl kZrmZl Zib^ lo^mbfZl Zebl+
<gmkhlbhl dgr`hl Znmhkbnl lZ*
ih [Zgrbhl ZioZerfh) ordn*
lbh .30 f+) [^m ]Zk ikb^ `rohl dhlb mbd lnmknfibgl EZshgh o^b*
En]h HZdZ[b^cZnl `Zeohl) mh]e dZe) [^ mh) ]Zk ikb]^]Z db^ghdb*
ibkf .3- f+ BZe mnhiZbn eZbdn mh kZrmnl ]n eZbdnl+ FZbi cbl

Turinys

431

H<F<=D@E FISBJN

rkZ Zmebdl lnmknfibgbfh ]Zk[) 7 gZb gnh mh) dZ] iZlZdhcZfb $g^
Zib^ mZb g^e^g`oZ dZl ghkl mbdkZ mb^ iZmrl) [^m mbd [^gm db^d iZ*
iZlZdrmb) g^l EZshgh o^bdZeh) ln gZl ordbZb+ MZlb iZ`ZebZn `Z*
dnkbnh k^bdm Zgmkhcb HZd+ dg+ b ch iZm^dmb cZn  EZshgh dgr`
er`bgmb) l^gZb g^[kZ+ FZ]Zg`b ch * D ob^gZl dbmZl ]ZerdZl) dnkl [noh
c^ kZg]Zf^ ieZb iZlZdhcbf ln  bghfZl Zk `bk]mZl b `Zg]) m\*
iZfbgcbfn oblhdb lfnedf^g) b ]e mZbi cbl mnkm [mb o^kmbgZ*
mZb dZb dZl fZgh) ch` mknfibgb* ) fZl bk blmhkbchc^+ <mldbknl ikb^*
fZl iZlbk^bdl riZ Zie^b]bfn  dZbmnl mbdlebZn `ZebfZ o^kmbgmb
dZb dnkb EZshgh dgr`hl ]Zeb)  mbd mrkbgcZgm iZm m^dlm+
dnkbhl ZnmhkbZnl mbdlenb g^mbdh) 
2+ Ihkl Z[b HZdZ[b^c dgr*
iZfbgmnl `b o^bdZe^ ]Zerdnl `Ze  `hl rkZ blmhkbdb o^bdZeZb) mZbZn
cbl rkZ lZoZbi gnob^ml+ HZgrmb > c ZnmhkbZb kZr]Zfb lb^d g^ m
mZbZn) dZ] lnmknfibgbfn [m iZm mbdle+ OZb iZlbkh]h b `ZgZ
[no bdkZbirmb iZmrl _ZdmZb) g* ldbkmbg`h c iZlZdhcbfh []h+
kZ iZ`kbg]h+ I^m^gdZ mZbi iZm Kbkfhchc^ dgr`hc^) mb^lZ) kZg]Z*
Z[^chmb) dZ] bk oblZl EZshgh o^b* f^ ob^gnk dbmnk ih^mbdblbk^b*
dZeZl blmhkbchl Zmobe`bn[noho^k* dbf) iZkZe^ebsfZbl bk^bdm Zl*
mZl ibegh iZlbmbdcbfh) g^l c^b [* f^g o^bdbfh Zib[]bgbf) [^m)
m [no dbmZbi) mZb dZf c Znmh* [^g]kZb bfZgm) chl Znmhkbnl) ikb*
kbnl [m Zilbfl ]Zk mknfibgmb+ lbeZbdr]ZfZl dkhgheh`bchl ^bebhl)
I^`Zech cbl mZbi iZm ]nhmb ln* kZh oblZb iZikZlmn []n Zib^
deZlmhm g^mbdk eZbd) g^l mhdb^ cZf bghfnl ordbnl) dZ] oe^l*
g^[m mnkc Zgh eZbdh ldZbmrmh* b gb^cb ldZbmrmhcZb `Zem lnbghmb)
. d rkZ ]Zk En]Zl HZdZ[b^cnl)
cZfl chdbhl o^kmr[l+
<gmkZcZb HZd+ dg+ bZg]b^g ]Z* c EhgZmZl) NbfhgZl r] k^eb`bcZb
 `bgmbbk mZnmhl eZblo^bZm`Znmb+ bnh
khfZ g^fZZ ikb^dZbm) bk g^ob* u
lb lnmbgdZ eZbdrmb c blmhkbgbn o^b* b Zmobe`bn cbl rkZ n oblnl ^g+
dZen+ Kkb^dZbmZb eb^bZ oblibkfZ Olm+ kZrmhcnl Zkmbf^lgbldbmb^fl
lm^[ndebg` ?b^oh lnm^bdm r* Zg eZbd iZ`hgb blmhkbchl kZr*
]Zfl iZ`Ze[ c dhohl^ lnikb^* mhcZfl+ FZ]Zg`b cbl [noh dZkmZl
Zbl+ D bnhlikb^dZbmnl m^gdZZm* lZoh k^eb`bchl bk morgl fremh*
lZdrmb iZdeZnlbfn7 Fh]e `b ?b^* cZl)mZb oblZf^ch iZlZdhcbf^ ]o^e*
oZl g^`Zech iZ]mb r]Zfl c dbZ ]b]^ebhk^eb`bg`nfh]oZlbZ) `Z*
dhohl^ ikb^ N^e^ndZbbnl ]e mb* ebgmb ZmZmbgdZfZb iZo^bdmb ldZbmrmh*
dcbfh) dZbi rkZ iZ]cl mZb mZn* cnl) [^m iZml Znmhkbnl lZoh cZnl*
mZb dbmZbl lngdbZbl chl `ro^gbfh f ZbdbZn g^bk^bdbZ+ BZe bnh
eZbdZbl; J c^b `Zech) mZb g^ `ZgZ ZnmhkbZnl gnlblmZmrfn k^bdm Zb*
mbd `bgrmb) [^m k^bdbZkh]rmb) dZ] dbgmbbkmZl ]ZerdZl) dZ]cbl)dZbcZf
mhdbhl lm^[ndebg`hl iZ`Ze[hl g^* m^gdZ Zmlbeb^imb Zib^ ?b^o %1)0-8
[noh lnm^bdmZ+ } OhebZn ]ZkhfZ /) 2-} 208 /) /.&) er` dZ] o^g`bZ
ikb^dZbm dgr`Zb ]emZkbZfmZki kZrmb ?b^oh Zk Qb^iZmb^l oZk])
chl bk ibkfhlbhl dgr`hl oikb^* iZlbm^gdbgZ `b ]Zg`Znl iZfbgcb*
mZkZobf iZlZdhcbfnhl^+ bZ k^b* fn bk mher`bZbl ihlZdbZbl+
QblZb dbmZbi ]Zkh Zgmkhlbhl
dbZ iZlm^[mb) dZ] oblnk ghkbfZ
eZbdrmb er`bZ`k^bZbl iZlZdhcbfZbl dgr`hl Znmhkbnl+ ?b^oh bk Qb^*
mhdbnhl) dnkb^ mhdb^ gkZ bk mh]e iZmb^l oZk]Zl iZl c lnmbgdZfZl
ldbkmnfZl iZlZdhcbf^iZk^bgZ]Z* eZ[Zb ]ZgZb+ M^eb`bcbg blmhkbchl

Turinys

H<F<=D@E FISBJN

inl ldZbmrmhcnb ikbf^gZfZ gnh*


eZm7 cbl mnkb bghmb) dZ] [^]b^orl*
m bk ibdmh]bZobfZb ?b^ohldZn*
]bZb [Zn]bZfb) dZ] fZe]Z bdeZn*
lhfZ) dZ] iZml ?b^oZl dhohcZ
]e lZoh o^gmc bk cnhl b`^e[b)
dZ] d^gmcbfZbl bmbdbfb^cbiZo^g*
mbgZfb) dZ] ]e d^gmcbf cb^ ln*
lbeZndl `ZnlZnl Zmer`bgbfh [^gm
dbmZf^ `ro^gbf^+ =^m obl loZk*
[bZnlbZ / HZd+ dg+ Znmhkbnb rkZ
E^knsZel [ZgrbZ bk dnemh ]Zer*
dZb+ =ZgrbZ rkZ ch iZlZdhcbfh
ob]nkrl+ Fgr`Z ikZ]^]ZfZ ]ob^f
eZbdZbl) dnkbZbl c ldZbmrmhcZb dob^*
bZfb ]ZeroZnmb [Zgrbhl iZo^g*
mbgbf^8 ibkfhcb dgr`hl ]Zebl ikZ*
]^]ZfZ iZlZdhcbfn Zib^ lm^[nd*
ebg` [Zgrbhl beZbdrf) Zgmkh*
cb Zib^ `klnlc [ZgrbZb iZohc)
Z[b [Zb`bZfhl ikZg^bfn Zib^
o^gb [ZgrbZb iZ`^k[mb iZ*
ldrkbf+ =ZgrbZZnmhkbnbmZbi eZ*
[Zb kib) dZ] cbl dh g^db^dob^gZ*
f^ ldbklg^erc^ ln iZ`Zk[Zc fb*
gb+}<mlbfbgnl) dZ] mnh f^mn)
dZb / HZd+ dgr`Z [noh kZhfZ)
<b`bimh r]Zb [noh iZlblmZm lZn
Zmldbk [Zgrb) ib`n lnikZlmb)
dZ] Znmhkbnl kZr]ZfZl `kZbdb*
dZb bk lZoh dgr` obl ibkfZ
ldbk]ZfZl r]Zfl ^e^gblmZfl <b*
`bim^) ghkch cb^fl ikbfbgmb riZ*

432

mbg` E^knsZel [Zgrbhl o^g*


mnf) iZZdbgmb) ch `  mZ [ZgrbZ
rkZ k^eb`bcbgl bk ihebmbgl obl
r] ob^gr[l \^gmkZl) dZ] cb k^b*
dbZ `^k[mb) eZgdrmb) oblnibkfZ `b
gb^dnhf^m chl g^nfbkmb+
3+
HZdZ[b^c dgr` gkZ r*
] [b[ebchc^) mh]e chl oZ]bgZfhl
]^nm^khdZghkbbgfbl+ FZmZebd=Z*
grbZ bkch c cZl oblnhf^m dZbi
c o+ MZmh ]Ze bk eZbdh cZl o+
?oZlbhl doimZbloo^bdZeZbl+ EZn
o+ Khobeh eZbd^ r]Zfl %..)02&
rkZ Zbdb Zebnsbc c / HZd+ 3).6+
//+ =Zgrbhl OoZb bk kZrmhcZb)
ikZ]^]Zgm gnh Zgmkhch bfmf^*
bh)gZn]hchlb chfbler`bZb ]ZgZb)
dZbi bk dbmhfbl ^g+ Olm+ dgr`h*
fbl+ N^gZf^ ehm+ DmZel o^kmbf^
chl rkZ [^gm gnh / bfmf^bh
ikZ]bhl+ Obd .3 bfmf^mrc^ikh*
m^lmZgmZb ikZ]ch g^[^]mb c  lZ*
oh [b[ebchl e^b]bgbnl) g^l mZbi]Z*
k r]Zb+ =^b [^gm r]Zb Ze^dlZg*
]kbcb^bZb mnkch cZl mnkmb lZoh
dZghg^ GRR o^kmbf^) g^l b m^g
i Zf cn h l dZmZebd =ZgrbZ+E^b
g^ Z[b]ob) mZb [^gm ibkfhcb mnk*
ch  [mb eZ[Zb o^kmbgZfZ bk KZe^l*
mbghc^) g^l eZ[Zb rfb chl ]Ze
r] blmhkbdZl Ae+ EnhsZiZl ZmiZ*
lZdhch lZoh kZmnhl^+

Turinys

=:36C AC:>FD >2492% A:C>@;: >F<FD:6;:


326@CF>&
<?G82&
'% pbO{ ^`VTWTXL^ []TPo DPWP`VLTrT`^% L! pbO{ RbaPYTXZ
^tWbR{ [LVT_wUTXL^# b[Lr 4Y_TZVZ 8[TQLYZ WLTVLT^%
6L[`_ ;% . @m _Z\mnf ^lm)
ihlmjnZf i^k\nllbm <e^qlZg]^k
Kabebiib HZ\^]h) jnb ikbfnl k^`*
gZobm bg BkZ^\bZ) ^`k^llnl ]^
m^kkZ>^mabf)?Zkbnf k^`^f K^k*
lZknf) ^m H^]hknf7 / \hglmbmnbm
ikZ^ebZ fnemZ) ^m h[mbgnbm hfgbnf
fngbmbhg^l) ^mbgm^k_^\bm k^`^lm^k*
kZ^) 0 ^m i^kmkZglbbm nljn^ Z] _b*
g^l m^kkZ^7 ^m Z\\^ibm lihebZfne* b

'% [P]^Vb]TXL^% . <mlbmbdh)


dZ] Kberih lgnl <e^dlZg]kZl
HZd^]hgb^mbl) dnkl ibkfZ dZkZebZ*
oh BkZbdbchc^) bcl b Febf
^fl bk lnfnl i^kl bk f^*
] dZkZeb ?Zkbc) / ]Zn` dhoh*
ch) iZf obl mobkmho^l bk n*
fn ^fl dZkZebnl+ 0Ebl gnch
bdb^fl iZdkZb bk iZf ]Zn*
`r[l mZnm `kh[+ ^f gnmbeh

.).34+ Ldmh\h` kdmhjndjn I\*


f\]d`e fitbjn nftmdpe` %.).  /)4-&
ipmj_jh\) fjfdjn ]pqj kmd`\notn
t_p npfdgdhj kmd` O`g`pf\ddpn+ d\
qdn kdmh\ f`gd\dn j_d\dn k\n\fjh\)
f\dk qdnjn mtop \gtn k\o`fj bm\dfp
q\g_dji %.). .-&) ojgd\p) f\dk) km\*
_epn f\m\gd\pod =iodjfpd Of\dnd\e\h)
t_p o\mk` \ondm\i_\ \okpjggd ipj
n\qj o\pojn kmjdp %.. .3&) f\dk o\n
f\m\gdpn \kdkgd\ F`mpu\gn ]\itd\
dm php\ _\pb`g t_p %.4  /6&)
f\dk \iom f\mo pkpjg\ hd`no dm k \*
no\oj d\ oqdmojq %0-1/&) f\dk edn dh\
m`df\g\pod) f\_ qdnd ej k\q\g_did\d
b\m]diop _d`q\ddpn) no\oj no\]pn ]\*
itdje` dm k`mn`fdje\ no\othpd dod*
fdhpn t_pn %10 34&+
%.).& 9 _X^fTa W eTf( Ldgtkj nipn
=g`fn\i_m\n) q\_di\h\n @d_tndn) ]*
_\h\n _qd_`dhod`n h`op) pqpn o*
qpd) km\_ej q\g_tod I\f`_jidejn f\*
m\gtno 003 h+ kdmh Gmdno\pn+ G\*
m\gd\pn q\m_\n i`d ej oqpd) i`d e\h
i`]pqj kmdk\dio\n) ]`o d odfmpdp
=g`fn\i_m\n opmej f\m\gd\pn q\g_d+
G\_\ibd edn ]pqj k\b\mnen n\qj
ipb\gedh\dn) k\on n\q` g\df =udejn
f\m\gdphd) btq`ij f\m\gd kmjd\dn dm

i`o n\qj hji`ojn` q\_dij n\q` f\*


\gdphd) o\d e\h g\]d\p i`f\dk ej o*
qpd odif\ kdmhj Cm\dfdejn f\m\gd\pn
q\m_\n+ my Bhef c\e` T((( Cm+ o+ d\
]`io fd`f npk\didjo\n dm j_dp oq\m*
f\ fdojfd+ Lm\nh  o\d\p o\ k\od+
Rpgb\ojn j_dn ce\` hy i`m\i_\ n\p
k\oqdmodidhj i`d bm+) i`d ntmdf\e\h`
q`modh`+  BXg\` ( G`odidp `h` km\*
_dje` ]pqj q\_di\h\ odf Gdkmj n\g\)
qgd\p bd qdnjn P\mk`hn emjn n\*
gjn dm ejn k\fm\d\d+ =g`fn\i_m\n
np f\mdpjh`i` k`mndfg d Apmjkjn
 =ude 001 h+ kdmh Gm+  G Xef  \e
eaTW( Jpj Gdmj g\dfp od`_qd o\pod
np_\m qd`i f\m\gtno+ Lgb+ no+
.+.0+.58 @\i+ 2)/5 dm f+ L\nfpodidn
k`mnp f\m\gdpn ]pqj @\mdepn EEE Gj_j*
h\i\n %00300- kdmh Gm+&+ =g`fn\i*
_m\n) k`mndfgn k`m Ag`nkjio\) nphp*
 kmd` i`_d_`gdj Cm\idfj pk`gdj Ido*
md_\oj q`_\h k`mnp f\mdpjh`i) k\*
nfpd _p ntfdp ipb\gej k\od @\mde+
doje` qd`oje` odfmd\pnd\d f\g]\h\
\kd` \iome ipb\gedh) qtfpn i`*
ojgd =m]`gn I`njkjo\hdeje` %00. h+&)
fpmn \od_\q =g`fn\i_mpd qdn\n mtop
\gdn+  %/& B TeT_\h f4 f\m\gd\pn qd`*
odidifpn) q\_pn+  %0& @^\ { X` f c T '

b

Turinys

;29% (# +T ((

.-.

mbmn]bgbl B^gmbnf7 ^m lbenbm m^kkZ ch ZdboZbs]hc^+ 1Ebl lnkbgdh ]Zn`
bg \hgli^\mn ^bnl+ 1 @m \hg`k^* c` bk eZ[Zb lmbikb dZkbnhf^g)
`Zobm obkmnm^f) ^m ^q^k\bmnf _hk* bk ch bk]bl Zndmbghlb bk iZlb]Z*
m^f gbfbl7 ^m ^qZemZmnf ^lm) ^m k inbdb+ 2 Ebl iZo^k` lZn mZnm
^e^oZmnf \hk ^bnl7 2 ^m h[mbgnbm Zebl bk oZe]honl) bk cb^ mnkch
k^`bhg^l B^gmbnf) ^m mrkZgghl7 fhdmb cZf fhd^lgbnl+ 3 Kh mh
^m _Z\mb lngm beeb bg mkb[nmnf) b cbl Zm`ne c iZmZe bk lnikZmh)dZ]
3 @m ihlm aZ^\ ]^\b]bmbg e^\* fbklbl+ 4 Ebl lnZnd lZoh r*
mnf) ^m \h`ghobm jnbZ fhk^k^mnk+ fbZnlbnl mZkgnl) dnkb^ [noh b*
4 @m oh\Zobm in^khl lnhl gh[b* Zndemb ]kZn` ln cnh gnh iZm cZn*
e^l) jnb l^\nf ^kZgm gnmkbmb Z bn* grlml) bk iZ]Zebgh lZoh dZkZerl*
o^gmnm^7 ^m ]boblbm beebl k^`gnf m ]Zk ikb^ lZoh `rohl `Zeohl+
lnnf) \nf Z]an\ obo^k^m+ 5 @m 5 <e^dlZg]kZl dZkZebZoh ]orebd
k^`gZobm <e^qZg]^k Zggbl ]nh]^* f^m bk fbk+ 6 Eh mZkgZb `Zohch
\bf) ^m fhkmnnl ^lm+ 6 @m h[mb* dZkZerlm) db^dob^gZl lZoh ob^mhc^+
gn^kngm in^kb^bnlk^`gnf) ngnl* .- EZf fbgbbl) cb^ oblb ]ch Zgm
jnbljn^ bg eh\h lnh7 .- ^m bfih* lZol dZkZebdnl oZbgbdnl) mZbi
ln^kngm hfg^l lb[b ]bZ]^fZmZ iZm c oZbdZb ih cc i^k ]Zn`^*
ihlm fhkm^f ^bnl) ^m _bebb ^hknf e f^m) bk iZlb]Zk ]Zn` [eh`n*
ihlm ^hl Zggbl fnembl) ^m fnemb* b f ^fc^+
ieb\ZmZ lngm fZeZ bg m^kkZ+
..
@m ^qbbm ^q ^blkZ]bq i^\* u
 .. D c bch gnh]fbg`ZZd*
\Zmkbq) <gmbh\anl beenlmkbl) _bebnl D gbl dZkZebZnl8 <gmbhdh lgnl <g*

e

^ e T y } \h # dfd Ei_de\d) fpmd n`ijqe` ]p* q\_pjojep+ In \pojmdpn f\g]\ \kd`
f\m\gtnon k\_\gdidh+ P\d\p edn i`*
qj g\dfjh\ `hn k\fm\dp+  > eb'
n\fj) f\_ =g`fn\i_m\n) k\q`n_\h\n
U\( =ijo n`ijqn dnojmdf k\n\fjedhj)
f\m\gtnon _\gdn n\qj f\mdpjh`in
=g`fn\i_m\n b\pnd\d \k_jq\ijen n\*
qj f\m`dqdpn dm _\m e\h k\d\h gdf q\_\hn) ]op k\nftmn epjn i`kmd*
\kd` .5-+--- o\g`iop %qdm _qd`ep hd* fg\pnjh\dn f\m\gd\dn+ G\m\gd\dn ed`
c\m_p gdop&+  Ehg\_b( A]m\duh\n) k\ndnf`g]) \ijo .- `+) k\otn+ Idid*
h\n doje` qd`oje` k\_\gdidh\n m`dfd\
fpmdj km\nh$ tm\ o\) f\_ id`f\n i`*
npkm\nod odf \kd` f\mdpjh`in q\_p
]`_mnj kmd`diodn =g`fn\i_mpd+  %1&
k\nftmdh \onfdmp kmjqdi^de f\m\*
<ThZ ]Z((( G\m* km\__\h\n =g`f*
gd\pn qd`odidif\dn dm q\g_jq\dn+ P\dk
n\i_m\n opmej \kd` 0-+--- knodidi*
fp+ dm 2--- m\do`gdp+ P f\mdpjh`i do\ did\ b\gd ]od kdbd\d np_`mdio\
np opj) f m\j fdod dnojmdf\d) dm ed
edn kmd` kmjbjn _\pbdij8 ]`o d odf*
epj g\]d\p odfodi\) f\_ tm\ n`i`ni
dpe _d_`gn f\mdpjh`in edn i`opmej+
Fd ]pqj i` od`f _d_`g nf\ddphd) fd`f p qdnpn fdopn k\n\fjedhpn \kd` =g`*
nodkmd n\qj k\ndmtdhp fjqjod dm fn\i_mj hdmo+  %.-& AT `  `\ehf(
I\f\]d`e fi+ \pojmdpn d\ i`n\fj)
_m\pnh`+  @e ]b  y\eW\f((( Cm+ o+ d*
o\dn j_d\dn km\nd_`_\ 1+ `+) j kj e f\_ k\nfdmod kmjqdi^de q\g_jq\d ]*
op k\ndnf`g]d8 f\m\gd\dn opje\p) f\dk
e\p k\hdio\n f\mdpjh`in b\pnp*
odf =g`fn\i_m\n ]pqj hdmn+ Gjg`d
h\n+ ;
 %3& G b gb 4 qd`k\o\qn _qt*
gdf h`op dm 5 hi opm_\h\n 0/ ]pqj btq\n e\pi\n =g`f\i_mj nipn)
q\_\d n\qn f\m\gd\dn i`q\_dij+ P\n
h`opn \hd\pn[[[ %4& G TWT_\ab((( Rd`*
k\ndnf`g]dh\n opmej qtfod odf \kd`
id n`ijqn dnojmdf\d hdid) f\_ =g`*
fn\i_m\n hdm_\h\n k\gdfn m\to 0-3 h+ G\n\i_m\n h q\_diodn I\*
o`no\h`io) fdod) f\_ fg\pnd\h\n) f\h f`_jidejn f\m\gdphd) =iodbji\n =ud*
ejn) Lojg`hd`epn =dbdkoj) O`g`pf\n
k\gd`fn n\qj kg\d q\gnot]) \on\*
fn d  q+IPd\P^j q`m{d \pnd\e \oi) >\]dgjidejn 7m Otmdejn dm Hdudh\^c\n
fdod qg+ f\_ odf \od_\qn n\qj d`_ Pm\fdejn %kgb+ @\i+ 5)5+//&+  zX'
L`m_df\d) o\dk dd nfdm_\h\n n\qj k\* E ea \]X4 tk\ Fp_eje`+

Turinys

.-/

H<F+ .)*./}.2

<gmbh\ab k^`bl) jnb _n^kZmMhfZ^


h[l^l7 ^m k^`gZobm bg Zggh \^g*
m^lbfh mkb`^lbfh l^imbfh k^`gb
BkZ^\hknf+ ./Dg ]b^[nl beebl ^qb*
^kngm ^qDlkZ^e _bebbbgbjnb ^m lnZl^*
kngm fnembl) ]b\^gm^l7 @Zfnl) ^m
]blihgZfnl m^lmZf^gmnf \nf
B^gmb[nl) jnZ^ \bk\Z ghl lngm7
jnbZ ^q jnhk^\^llbfnl Z[^bl)bg*
o^g^kngm ghl fnemZ fZeZ+ .0@m
[hgnl oblnl ^lm l^kfh bg h\nebl
^hknf+ .1 @m ]^lmbgZo^kngm Zebjnb
]^ ihineh) ^m Z[b^kngm Z] k^`^f7
^m ]^]bm beebl ihm^lmZm^f nm _Z\^*
k^gmbnlmbmbZfB^gmbnf+ .2@mZ^]b*
_b\Zo^kngm `rfgZlbnf bg e^khlh*
erfbl l^\ng]nf e^`^l IZmbhgnf7

mbhdZl NdZblmnlbl) dnkl [noh Mh*


fhc^ dZbmZl8 cbl ikZ]ch dZkZebZn*
mb bfmZl $_krl]^bfmrl l^imbgmZbl
`kZbdob^iZmZobfhf^mZbl+ ./Onh
f^mn kZ]hlb b DskZ^ebh g^]hk
fhgb) dnkb^ dZe[bgch ]Zn`^*
ebnb) lZdr]Zfb7 @bdbf^ bk iZ]Zkr*
dbf^ lZg]hk ln mZnmhfbl) dn*
kbhl rkZ Ziebgd fnl) g^l gnh mh
f^mh) dZbi f^l gnh c ZmlbmkZn*
df^) fnl lnmbdh ]Zn`g^eZbfb+
.0 Ob^ h]bZb iZlbkh] `^kb c
Zdrl^+ .1 FZb dnkb^ b mZnmhl iZ*
lbkrh bk gnch iZl dZkZeb8 mZlZb
]Zo cb^fl `Zebhl `ro^gmb iZ`h*
gb lmZmrfZbl+ .2Eb^ iZlblmZmE^*
knsZec^ fZgdmhl fhdrde) dZbi

I\f+ 1)4&) I`i`g\epn dm f+  ^ T _U \'


%..& @y ] 4 d qd`ij \pfd\p k\*
hdioe) ]o`io) O`g`pfj Jdf\oj* a ]b  WThZX_\h\( Lgb+ `h+ 10 1/ `+)
mdj+  9 a g\b^Tf J ^ T \fgh f\f4 =iodj* / I\f+ 1).0+++  G T W T el ^ \` X fT a W b '
fj EEE @d_djej nipn =iodjf\n ER e((( Pjfn npnd\modidh\n np nq`odh*
Akda\i\n+ =iodjf\n EEE qd`k\o\qj o\pd\dn ]pqj kmd`dib\n t_p no\ot*
//0 .54 h+ kdmh Gm+ Fdn opmej _p hpd %kgb+ EH .0)0/ dm 01).28 =of+
ni7 O`g`pf ER Bdgjk\ojm %.54  4+/++ +& dm _\pb e\p f\mop ]pqj e i`*
g\dhdp kmd`\nodn %Eu+ /5).28 0-).8 0.)
.42& dm =iodjf Of\dnoe+ do\n \i*
om\ndn ]pqj ipndpno\n Njhji f\dkj .8 F`m+ /).5)8 Au+ .4)/2+/58 kgb+ P`dn+
2+/.++ +8 ..)5+6&+ Pdfmjndjn bd kmd`\n*
f\do\n+ .46 h+ O`g`pf\n ER npbm*
dij n\qj ]mjgd =iodjf Of\dnoe d otn f\d fpmdp t_p ijmj \modiodn np
Njhjn) j ej qd`oji k\ndpio n\qj k\bjidhdn _\]\m ]pqj ojn) f\_ ed`hn
e\pi ni @`h`omdep) fpmn k\nfd\p ]pqj ipnd]j_n ep no\oth\n dm ej n\*
kj =iodjfj ER qd`k\o\qj f\dkj @`* fth\d8 ed` ]pqj k\hb g\dnq k\*
bjidp btq`idh dm odfejnd dq`ibnd
h`omdepn E Ojo`mdn+ O`g`pf\n ER ]p*
qj ipp_to\n Agdj_jmj) fpmn k\on k\id`fdidhj) fjfdpj fdojn o\pojn \ond*
hjf_\qj t_\hn p ep nfdmodibph+
no`ibnd k\q`mod n\p f\m\gd\pn njn*
* *  Dhf fh g\^b((( L\i\d\d f\g]ej t*
o+ P\d\p =iodjfpd Of\dnd\e\h k\*
qtfj dq\mtod Agdj_jm dm db\pod $n\p _\d dm F`m`hdej g\df\dn) 11).5+$  %.0&
A  T ^ l f X 4 _\pb`gdpd %./ `+& k\odfj+
d mjhip f\m\gd\pn o`dndp kmdk\d*
idh+  x \` gTf+++ O`g`pf\dd `m\  %.1& B T\ ^ h e\X \y gThgbf((( thd\p*
km\nd_`_\ ipj oj g\dfj) f\d O`g`pf\n ndn e o\mi` ]pqj F\uji\n+ Ru+ / I\f+
Jdf\ojmdn ]pqj ipb\gen =iodbji) 1)48 kgb+ gjn+ =io+ ./)28 >`gg+ dp_+ .).+
oj_g ipj . nk\gdp 0./ h+ kdmh Gm+  G T f  ^ T eT _\ 4 =iodjf+  < Ti
]\X` f Z T_\b f( Lm\_e f ijmn _\*
P\dbd .04 bm\dfp qd`k\o\qdhj h`*
o\d \o\odif\ .41 .42 h+ kdmh Gm+ mtod ]` f\m\gd\pn b\gdjedhj ed` ]pop
=iodjf\n bd Of\dnopndn qd`k\o\qj ]pq dodfdhe t_ k`mn`fdje\hd)
.41 .30 h+ kdmh Gm+  %./& K hb b\g i`o ipp_tod+ @\]\m id`f\n i`*
]`_mnj ed`hn kmd`diodn+ Q b\po\n
` Xgh( C\g e\p =iodjfj Of+ f\m\gd\*
d f\m\gd\pn o`dn`n F\uji\n phjf*
qdhj km\_dje` %kgb8 )/. `+&)  E X'
W b e  {` ba\( Cm+ ojg 'Te9 ibj  no\*
en i`o dho o\g`io %hdgdeji np
othj g\ptoje\d+ Pjfdpjn t_\d _\m qdmph gdop&+ Lgb+ , I\f+ 1)4+  > l '
q\_di_\qj >`gd\gdj q\df\dn) ]`i` >`gd iXag\ c TZba \ (((4 o\dfdiodn kmd` k\bj*
\ %kgb+ 0 G\m+ /.).-+.0&+ F q\_\d id no\othp dm kmjdp+  %.2&
]pqj Kidej ]mjgdn Fupn) fpmn kj \o* D Ta^ygbf ` b ^ l ^ _ 4 qd`o) k\nfdmo qd*
kpjgdhj q\_dijnd F\uji\n %kgb+ / njfd\h nkjmopd+ L\km\no\d o\d ]_\qj

Turinys

. H<F+ .) . 3 */ /

.3 ^m _^\^kngm lb[b ikZ^inmbZ) ^m k^*


m^lmZf^gmh lZg\mh)
^m bng\mb lngm IZmbhgb[nl) ^m o^*
gng]Zmb lngm nm _Z\^k^gm fZenf+

\^ll^kn gm Z

.4
@m iZkZmnf ^lm k^`gnf
\hgli^\mn<gmbh\ab) ^m \h^ibm k^`*
gZk^ bg m^kkZ <^`rimb nm k^`gZk^m
lni^k ]nh k^`gZ+ .5 @m bgmkZobm
bg <^`rimnf bg fnembmn]bg^ `kZ*
ob) bg \nkkb[nl) ^m ^e^iaZgmbl) ^m
^jnbmb[nl) ^m\hibhlZ gZobnf fne*
mbmn]bg^7 .6 ^m \hglmbmnbm [^eenf
Z]o^klnl Kmhe^fZ^nf k^`^f <^*
`rimb) ^m o^kbmnl ^lm Kmhe^*
fZ^nl Z _Z\b^ ^bnl) ^m _n`bm) ^m
\^\b]^kngm oneg^kZmb fnemb+ /- @m
\hfik^a^g]bm\bobmZm^l fngbmZl bg
O^kkZ <^`rimb7 ^m Z\\^ibm lihebZ
O^kkZ^ <^`rimb+ /. @m \hgo^kmbm
<gmbh\anl) ihlmjnZf i^k\nllbm
<^`rimnfbg\^gm^lbfh^m jnZ]kZ*
`^lbfh m^kmbh Zggh7 ^m Zl\^g]bmZ]
DlkZ^e) // ^m Zl\^g]bm e^khlherfZf
nd`i\ \kq`no\n mpdh\n np kmd`\ibd\dn
%kjmodf\dn&) bm\dp omj]`ndp) fpmd\h`
]pqj dkpjop f\h]\mdp) kdmd dm o+o+
Lgb+ / I\f+ 1)./+  %.3& @yf\{ T W ]b 
T c \c ]T h fgl ` b 4  k\nd_pj_\hd o\h odf*
m\d nf\p_d\d jk`m\^de\d) f\_ id`fp
i`ndnfdmop ipj k\bjidp+ G\_\ibd \kd*
ke\pnoth\n ]pqj n\i_jmjn np @d`qp
th %Lm\_+ .4)6+++&) o\d e\ dnd\_ed*
h\n ]pqj \dfd\pnd\n `ifg\n \onoj*
ndhj ipj q`iojndjn n\i_jmjn+  J h '
f\W]b((((  Cm+`D`pUdjgce\\qnpndmdj qd`ip
epibp np k\bjidhdn+  G T ef \W T i 4
k\_\m d n\qn ipj_hn q`mbpn+
Lgb+ 0 G\m+ /.)/-8 qu+ / I\f+ 1)../-+
%.4& J h fg\c e]f4  f\d =iodjfpd k\*
qtfj dq\mtod$ n\qj ]mjgdj O`g`pfj ER
ipp_toje Agdj_jm dm b\pod n\p d
Njhjn kmdk\didh+  < i\X] ^ T e T '
_l f} \ 4  Otmdejn dm =dbdkoj+  %.5&
A \ f  ]b(((  =iodjf\n Of+ ]pqj pkpj*
gn =dbdko omdn %\ijo f\d fpmdp) f`*
opmdn& f\mopn+ Ldmhe kpjgdh ]p*
qj k\nf`g]n$ d \ifnoj km\i\\n @\*
idgdn ..)//+++ =iom\n qtfj hdmpn
Gg`jk\om\d) =iodjfj Of+ n`n`md\d dm
Lojgjhd`e\pn R Of+ hji\d) q\g_d*
d\d =dbdko qd`oje` n\qj i`kdgi\h`*

E$
7

78

.-0

[noh iZ`hgb iZikhmrl) .- blb*


Z]ch lZoh ZibicZnlmrfh) Zmlmh*
ch gnh o^gmhlbhl lZg]hkhl) ln*
lb]ch ln i\`hgbfbl bk iZklb]Z*
o ]Zkrmb ibdmZ+
bg .4 <gmbhdZl) lnlmbikcl lZoh
dZkZerlmc^) ikZ]ch ghkmb dZkZ*
ebZnmb <b`bimh ^fc^) dZ] [m
]ob^c dZkZerlb dZkZebnl+ .5 Ebl
ch  <b`bim ln `Zebg`Z dZkbnh*
f^g^) ln dZkbdZbl o^bfZbl) ln
]kZf[ebZbl) ln kZbm^ebZbl bk ln ]b*
]^e^ eZbo ]Zn`r[^) .6 bk ikZ]ch
dZk ikb^ <b`bimh dZkZeb Kmhe^*
fb^c+ Kmhe^bgb^cnl gnlb`Zg]h ch
o^b]h bk iZ[`h8 bk ]Zn` ln^bl*
m noh+ /- Ebl iZf <b`bimh ^*
fc^ lnlmbikbgmnl fb^lmnl bk `Z*
oh <b`bimh ^fl `kh[+ /. Nn*
fnl <b`bim<gmbhdZl iZk`kh
bfmZl d^mnkbZl]^bfmbl mk^bZbl
f^mZbl) ih mh bch ikb^ DskZ^e
// bk Zmch  E^knsZe ln `Zebg`Z

jdj ni\pn Lojgjhd`e\pn RE Bdgjh`*


ojmdj+ Em \iom\ndn kpjgdh\n ]pqj @\*
idgdj k\nf`g]o\n %@\i+ ..)/2+++&+ =kd`
do \iome kpjgdh) qtfpn .4- h+
kdmh Gm+ d\ dm f\g]\h\+ =iodjfpd
Of+ ]pqj opjh`o k\qtf k\dhod qdn
=dbdko) dnftmpn =g`fn\i_mde+ Lgb+
/ I\f+ 1 )/ . /18 2).. /.+  Jh
WeT` U_\T\f(((  I\bi`udejn npo\modhd
=iodjfj Of+ oq\n =iodjf\n @d_tndn
]pqj k\nd\_en mjhi\hn i`]`g\d*
ftod _m\h]gdp dm _d_`nidj %g\dqtij8
]`o ojn o\dfjn8 npo\mod`n kpifop i`g\*
]\d ]pqj o`ndg\dfjh\+ Pj_g dm =iodj*
f\n Of+ qg ]pqj ndo\dnn _m\h]gdp dm
g\dq f\m\hn+  %.6& G gb_X` \X] (
P\d ]pqj Lojg`hd`e\pn RE Bdgjh`*
o^mdj ]mjgdn) mq\_di\h\n Bdnfjip dm
Aq`mb`op+ =iodjf\n ]pqj k\ndnf`g]n
ijmdn bmdiod  njno Bdgjh`ojm) ijmn
d odfme edn b`d_ =dbdkoj n\p+ 
%/.& G TeZ e{b y\` gTy(&(4  mp_`i .4h+ kdmh Gmdno\pn+  G e\Xy @m eT X_4
kmd` t_p \po+ Lm`o`fno\n o\h
tbdpd ]pqj o`ndgd\pe bdi\d o\mk F\*
ujij dm I`i`g\e\pn _g qtmd\pndjej
fpidbj qd`ojn8 opjn bdipn =iodjf\n
n\fnd g\dfn h\dop kmd` f\m\gdf
16

o+ MZmZl) m+ DQ+

Turinys

44-

. H<F+ .) / 0 * 0 -

bg fnembmn]bg^ `kZob+ /0 @mbgmkZobm dZkbnhf^g^+ /0 Ebl ch  o^gmr*
bg lZg\mb_b\Zmbhg^f \nf lni^k[bZ) de ln inbdr[^) iZf Zndlbg
^m Z\\^ibm ZemZk^ Znk^nf) ^m \Zg* Zemhkb) ob^lhl oZdb] ln oblZbl
]^eZ[knf enfbgbl) ^m ngbo^klZoZ* ch l krdZbl) iZ]mbgb ]nhg lmZe)
lZ ^bnl) ^m f^glZf ikhihlbmbhgbl) eb^cZfc Zndbg]nl)mZnk^l) Znd*
^m eb[ZmhkbZ) ^m iabZeZl) ^m fhkmZ* lbgbnl `klmnoebnl) n]Zg`)oZb*
kbheZ Znk^Z) ^m o^enf) ^m\hkhgZl) gbdnl)ZndlbgiZ`kZbgbf) [non*
^m hkgZf^gmnf Znk^nf) jnh] bg l [Zgrbhl ikb^Zdrc^) bk oblZ
_Z\b^ m^fieb ^kZm7 ^m \hffbgnbm lneZn+ /1 OZbi iZm cbl iZlbf
hfgbZ+ /1 @m Z\\^ibm Zk`^gmnf) lb]Z[k) Zndl) [kZg`bnl bg]nl)
^m Znknf) ^m oZlZ \hg\nibl\b[bebZ7 iZleimnl mnkmnl) dnkbnhl kZ]h)
^m Z\\^ibm ma^lZnkhl h\\nemhl) bk oblZ Zmfl iZkch  lZoh Ze+
jnhl bgo^gbm7 ^m ln[eZmbl hfgb*
[nl Z[bbm bg m^kkZf lnZf+
/2
@m _^\bm \Z^]^f ahfbgnf) /2 =^ mh) cbl iZ]Zk fhgb
^m eh\nmnl ^lm bg lni^k[bZ fZ`gZ+
n]rg^l
bk dZe[ch ln ]b]^e^inbdr[^+
/3 @m _Z\mnl^lm ieZg\mnl fZ`gnl /3 DskZ^erc^ bk oblhl^cob^mhl^db*
eh ]b]^ebl kZn]hcbfZl+
bg DlkZ^e) ^m bg hfgb Dg^h^h*
knf7
/4 ^m bg`^fn^kngm ikbg\bi^l) ^m /4 Fngb`ZbdbZb bk l^g^lgb^cb oZb*
mhch)
l^gbhk^l7
obk`bg^l) ^m bno^g^lbg_bkfZmb lngm7 f^k`Zbml bk cZngbdZbbZb lnf^g*
dch
^m li^\bhlbmZl fneb^knf bffnmZ*
mZ ^lm+
bk fhm^k `kZnfZl ]bg`h+
/5 Jfgbl fZkbmnl lnfilbm eZf^g* /5 Qblb orkZb f kZn]hmb)
mnf7
bk cZngZo^]l l]ch o^kd]Zfhl
^m jnZ^ l^]^[Zgm bg mahkh fZkb*
o^lmnob [nm^+
mZeb) en`^[Zgm7
/6 ^m \hffhmZ ^lm m^kkZ lni^k /6 Zebl ln]k^[ch ]e lZoh `r*
o^gmhc)
aZ[bmZgm^l bg ^Z)
^m ngbo^klZ ]hfnl DZ\h[ bg]nbm bk oblb Ehd[h gZfZb [noh Zi*
obedmb ln`]bgbfn+
\hg_nlbhg^f+
0- ?o^cb^fl f^mZfl ikZlebg*
0- @m ihlm ]nhl Zgghl ]b^*

q\g_d %kgb+ / I\f+ 2).2+++&8 d odf*


me bd mjhi k\`hdio\n dm kmd*
q`mno\n k\ndom\pfod d =dbdkoj edn ij*
mej dgd`od n\qj k\bd` \io t_p dm
dkgo\dn d e opmo\dn k\kdg_tod n\*
qj dopoepnd d_+  %/0& , k ] L U %
[ ^ R S p ,  d ]\itdjn qd_) d fpm q\gd\
]pqj `dod odf fpidb\hn+  / \ R Z P U u 
H S [ V Y P w ,  \pfnp \kom\pfo nhdgf\gp \g*
ojmd+  j ] P L Z V Z  m ] H R PK L &,  \pfndi
q\fd_ np n`kotidjhdn \fjhdn+ 
C H PU PR \ Z &  P\d opmej ]od h\g_dib
t_ _jq\ijn ]\itd\d+ + C P Z H 
Z \ S H \ m s &  Cm+ nD*dm` o+ t+ ipkg
\pfn ipj qdnp op _\gtfp) fpmd` ]p*

qj \kom\pfod \pfndi` nf\m_\8 _\gt*


fpn) k\_\mtopn d \pfnj) k\ndh qd*
npn+  %/1& = H Z S s W [ \ Z  [ \ Y [ \ Z &  Lgb+
I\o+ 0).-+++ 7 C P Z H  H [ s T q Z +++ =ijo /
I\f+ 2)/.+ =iodjf\n opjh`o dkgn
opmo` \kd` .5-- o\g`iop) f\n np_\mj
\mod /- hdgdejip gdo+  %/2& 0 L  [V $
Q P Z & & & ,  kdmh\ i`bp k\gdfj F`mpu\g+ Ru+
/ I\f+ 2).1+++  8 H S I s Q V ,  kdfoj_d\*
qj+ Lgb+ @\i7 ..)/503+  %/5&
C P Z P  ] ^ Y H P & 4 Y & 
$,n)n+*_m]8 e\pi\q`_dn+
 %/6& / W ] PSR [ P Z \ N s K P U P T \ ,  gtb f\_
k\on @d`q\n ]op epjn \kg`d_n+
%0-& 2 ] L Q P L T Z &&&  .35 h+ kdmh Gm+
}  C P Y k PU P U R p &  Fdn q\_dijnd =kjgjid*

Turinys

. H<F+ .) 0.}1-

44.

knf fblbm k^q ikbg\bi^f mkb[nmh* dnl) dZkZebnl iZlbngm cEn]h fb^*
knf bg \bobmZm^l Dn]Z)^m o^gbm D^* lmnl fhd^lb obkbgbgd) dnkl
knlZb^f \nf mnk[Z fZ`gZ+ 0. @m Zmch  E^knsZe ln ]b]^ebn [kbn+
eh\nmnl ^lm Z] ^hl o^k[Z iZ\b_b* 0. Ebl deZlmbg`Zb dZe[ch cb^flmZb*
\Z bg ]heh7^m \k^]b]^kngm^b+ 0/@m dbnl h]bnl) bk cb^ cZf mbdch+
bkknbm lni^k \bobmZm^f k^i^gm^) ^m 0/ KZldnb cbl fZb inhe fb^lm)
i^k\nllbm ^Zf ieZ`Z fZ`gZ) ^m iZ]Zk cZf ]b]bZnl lf` bk
i^k]b]bm ihinenf fnemnf ^q Dl* gnn] ]Zn` fhgb b DskZebh+
kZ^e+ 00 @m Z\\^ibm lihebZ \bobmZmbl7 00 Ebl Zibie fb^lm) iZ]^` c)
^m ln\\^g]bm ^Zf b`gb) ^m ]^lmkn* ln`kbho ch gZfnl bk ch lb^gZl
qbm ]hfhl ^bnl) ^m fnkhl ^bnl Ziebgdnb+ 01 Hhm^kbl bk oZbdnl
bg \bk\nbmn7 01 ^m \ZimboZl ]nq^* cbl blbo^] g^eZblog bk iZ*
kngm fneb^k^l7 ^m gZmhl) ^m i^\h* lbf lZn `ronebnl+ 02 KZldnb
kZ ihll^]^kngm+ 02 @m Z^]b_b\Zo^* cb^ Zio^] ?hob]h fb^lm ]b]^ebn
kngm \bobmZm^f ?Zob] fnkh fZ* bk lmbikbn fkn bk lmbikbZbl [hd*
`gh) ^m _bkfh) ^m mnkkb[nl _bkfbl) mZbl8 mZbi cbl iZlb]Zk c mobkmho+
^m _Z\mZ ^lm beebl bg Zk\^f7 03 ^m 0- Eb^ iZmZeibgh chc^ gnh]fbg`
ihln^kngm beeb\ `^gm^f i^\\Zmkb* `bfbg) g^]hk fhgb)bk cb^lb*
\^f obkhl bgbjnhl) ^m \hgoZen^* lmbikbghchc^) Zmlb`Z[^gh `bgde bk
kngm bg ^Z+ ^m ihln^kngm ZkfZ) fZblmh) lnkbgdh lZn E^knsZelb*
^m ^l\Zl) ^m \hg`k^`Zo^kngm lih* iel 04 bk lnlbdkho m^gZb8 b c
ebZ e^knlZe^f7 04 ^m k^ihln^kngm iZlb]Zk ]b]^eb lelmZb+
beeb\7 ^m _Z\mb lngm bgeZjn^nf fZ*
`gnf+
05
@m _Z\mnf ^lm ah\ Z] bglb* 05 D mh iZlb]Zk mrdhcbfob^*
mZ o^gmrdeZb
]bZl lZg\mb_b\Zmbhgb)
^m bg ]bZ[henf fZenf bg DlkZ^e7 bk ibdmZl ikb^bgbgdZl DskZ^ebnb+
06 ^m ^__n]^kngm lZg`nbg^fbggh* 06 Eb^ eb^ch g^dZem dkZnc Ziebgd
\^gm^f i^k \bk\nbmnf lZg\mb*
o^gmrde
_b\Zmbhgbl)
bk lnm^i c+
^m \hgmZfbgZo^kngm lZg\mb_b\Zmbh*
g^f+
1- @m _n`^kngm aZ[bmZmhk^lD^knlZ* 1- ?e c E^knsZel`ro^gmhcZb f
e^f ikhim^k ^hl)
[`mb8
epn+ Ru+ / I\f+ 2)/1+  < \WX_\h U e\h 7
npnd_`_\id d //--- hjid+ Em do
tbd kmd` t_pn _\m =iodjf\n kj
oj) f\d e\h ]pqj mjhi bmd`o\d p*
_m\pno\fjqjod kmd` =dbdko+ Fdn h\*
ojh\d ijmej g\]d\p ndnodkmdiod ]`io
Fp_eje`) qdn\d e n\p k\q`mb_\h\n+
 %02& < bi\Wb ` \Xfgh( @jqd_j hd`n*
o\n) \ijo / G\m+ 2)4 dm . Gmji+ ..)2
]pqj k\no\oto\n Odjij f\gi`gte`) F`*
mpu\gn kd`oq\f\mdpjn`+ I\f\]d`e bd
fitbjn` opj q\m_p q\_di\h\ ntm
k\no\oto\ \m npnodkmdio\ oqdmojq) fp*
md) ]_\h\ Odjij f\gi`gte` d kd`oq\*
f\mdpn ipj ]\itdjn) nojqej \pf*
d\p ejn+ Pjgd\p 1)04+3-8 2)218 4)3/8

e 4)008.-).. ]\itdjn f\gi`gdn) Ijmd*


$ e\) q\_di\h\n o\dk k\o Odjip) nfdmodip
o\d\p ipj oqdmojqn+  %03& EhbW'
 `\aZT& Z \` \a X4 f\m`dqdpn d nq`odh
\gd+
 E XWbe {` ba\4 no\othj
g\ptoje+ P\d ]pqj t_\d) k\h`op*
nd`ed n\qj no\oth+  %04& < \WX_\
f\ fgT \4 _\m t_\hn _\pb i`nh\bp*
hp+ @g ojn oqdmojqn hd`nopd ipjg\o
bmn k\qjepn) ]pqj k\qjedib\ \m]\
$ i`o qdn\d i`]`b\gdh\ `dod d ]\itd+
 @meTX_\h\( dm+ o+ _\m kmd_o\7 qd*
w
 npjh`o+  %06& A \ X  _\X]b((( E oqdmoj*
E qn b\gej k\nd`fod qdgtdjhdn `di\i*
dpn d ]\itd8 gd`_\hd fm\pe kmd`
q`iotfgjn opj k\dp e e\p npo`k*

Turinys

..)

( ;29% (# +(T,(

^m _Z\mZ ^lm aZ[bmZmbh ^qm^khknf) U cb obkmh lo^mbfc [no^bg^)


^m _Z\mZ ^lm ^qm^kZ l^fbgb lnh)  iZlb]Zk lo^mbfZ lZoh `bfbg^b)
bk chl oZbdZb iZebdh c+
^m gZmb ^bnl k^ebjn^kngm ^Zf+
1. NZg\mb_b\Zmbh ^bnl ]^lheZmZ ^lm 1. Ehl o^gmrdeZ [noh Zie^blmZ
dZbi mrkZb8
lb\nm lhebmn]h)
]b^l _^lmb ^bnl \hgo^klb lngm bg chl o^gml obkmh `^]nen)
chl ln[Zmhl iZcnhdZ)
en\mnf)
chl `Zk[bg`nfZl gb^dZbl+
lZ[[ZmZ ^bnl bg hiikh[kbnf)
ahghk^l ^bnl bg gbabenf+
1/ N^\ng]nf `ehkbZf ^bnl fnemb* 1/FZbi ]b]^ebl [nohchl `Zk[bg`n*
fZl)mZbiiZ]Zn`chchlg^`Zk[)
ieb\ZmZ ^lm b`ghfbgbZ ^bnl7
^m ln[ebfbmZl ^bnl \hgo^klZ ^lm bk chl dbegnfZl obkmh `^]nen+
bg en\mnf+
10
@m l\kbilbm k^q <gmbh\anl 10
Onhf^m dZkZebnl <gmbhdZl
hfgb k^`gh lnhnm^ll^mhfgblih* iZkZ oblZb lZoh dZkZerlm^b) dZ]
inenl) ngnl7 ^m k^ebgjn^k^m ngnl* oblb [m ob^gZ mZnmZ) bkdZ]db^d*
jnbljn^ e^`^f lnZf+ 11 @m \hg* ob^gZl iZf^lm lZoc lmZmrf+
l^gl^kngm hfg^l B^gm^l l^\ng* 1. Qblhl mZnmhl lnmbdh ln mnh
]nf o^k[nf k^`bl <gmbh\ab7 '102' ^m dZkZebZnl <gmbhdhlZdrfn8 12 mZbi
fnemb ^q DlkZ^e \hgl^gl^kngm l^k* iZm ]Zn` b DskZ^ebh iZlb]Zo ch
obmnmb ^bnl) ^m lZ\kb_b\Zo^kngm b]h* o^k`bcZb) Zndhch lmZ[Zfl bk lnm^*
ebl) ^m \hbgjnbgZo^kngm lZ[[Zmnf+ i ln[Zm+ 1= FZkZebnl Zmlbngm
13 @m fblbm k^q eb[khl i^k fZ* i^k iZlbngmbgbnl  E^knsZe  ob*
gnl gng\bhknf bg D^knlZe^f) ^m lnl En]h fb^lmnl bk kZm) dZ]
bg hfg^l \bobmZm^l Dn]Z7 nm l^* cb^ eZbdrmlb lo^mbfZeb lmZmrf)
jn^k^gmnk e^`^l B^gmbnf m^kkZ^) 14 n]kZnlm ]Zkrmb ?b^oh [Z*
14 ^m ikhab[^k^gm aheh\ZnlmZ) ^m grbhc^ ]^`bgZflbZl) dknobgZlbk
lZ\kb_b\bZ) ^m ieZ\Zmbhg^l _b^kb bg i^kfZe]Zobfh ZndZl 15bk dZ] n*
m^fieh ?^b) 15 ^m ikhab[^k^gm\^* ]kZnlm olmb ln[ZmZl) bk bdbe*
e^[kZkb lZ[[Zmnf) ^m ]b^l lhee^f* fb ]b^gZl+ 16 Ebl eb^i lnm^imb
g^l7 16 ^m bnllbm \hbgjnbgZkb lZg\* o^gmrde bk o^gm DskZ^ebh mZn*
mZ) ^m lZg\mnf ihinenf DlkZ^e+ m) 2- lZd lmZmrmbZndnknl) o^g*
2- @m bnllbmZ^]b_b\ZkbZkZl) ^m m^f* mrdeZl bk lmZ[nl) Zndhmb dbZneb^g
ieZ) ^m b]heZ) ^m bffheZkb \Zkg^l bk lnm^imnl `ronebnl) 2.iZebdmb lZ*
lnbeeZl) ^m i^\hkZ\hffngbZ) 2.^m oh oZbdnl g^ZibicZnlmrmnl) lnm^i*
k^ebgjn^k^ _bebhl lnhl bg\bk\nf\b* mb c lb^eZl oblhdbZbl g^oZknfZbl
O\qj+ Lgb+ 0 I\f+ 3)1+++  %1.& Lgb+
Pj]+ /)38 =h+ 5).-+  E \X^T\f(  Cm+ o+7
)id`fdidhp+
%10& B TW i\f\ Uhg i\Xa T gThgT( F\p
=g`fn\i_m\n @d_tndn f\m\gtnon nodk*
mph h\o kmjdp) f\g]jn) fpgomjn
npqd`ij_didh`8 edn odf i`ndbmd`] kmd`*
q\mojn+ =iodjf\n ijmd o k\o k\nd`fod
i`o kmd`q\mojn f`gdp+  f gT gl ` 4 n\*
qj m`gdbde+ Lgb+ / I\f+ 3).6+ N`*
gdbde\ odf k\n t_pn ]pqj bg\p_d\p*
nd\d npmdo\ np o\pot]`8 t_\d i`b\*
gej ]od f\mop dm dum\`gdo\dn dm no\]*

h`g_d\dn+  %12& A b  i Xe Z \]T \4 ojfd\h


_d`qp b\m]didhpd) fjfdj g\dfnd f\*
m\gdpn+  %13& J i Xg\` yT_\ 4 fpmd` bt*
q`ij qd`i\h` np t_\dn fm\o`+
%16& @e yiXa g(((4 kmdq`mnod t_pn i`*
ndg\dfthp n\fth \kd` npo`kopn _\*
gtfpn npndo`kod @d`qj \fdq\du_je` dm
k`m o npndo`kdh k\gd\pod ]pqpn q`i*
o @d`qj o\po\) oj_g dm t_\dn+
%2-& JhgXcghf((( Ijun no\oth\n f\d
fpmdpjn btqpgdpn g\df npo`ko\dn8 oj*
fdjn ]pqj fd\pgn) fpmd hn t *
_\hn ]pqj p_m\pno\ q\gbtod) o\dk

Turinys

E H,2! .) 2 / * 3 -

440

lhl) ^m \hbgjnbgZkb ZgbfZl^hknf bk gnh[h]hfbl) mZbi dZ] cb^ n*


bg hfgb[nl bffng]bl) ^mZ[hfb* fbkm lmZmrf bkiZd^blm oblnl
gZmbhgb[nl) bmZ nm h[ebobl\^k^gmnk ?b^oh lZdrfnl) 2/h c^b dZl g^*
e^`^f) ^m bffnmZk^gm hfg^l cnl* ]Zkrm) dZbi dZkZebZnl <gmbhdh
mb_b\Zmbhg^l ?^b+ 2/ @m jnb\nfjn^ [noh lZdrmZ) dZ] mnkm fbkm+
ghg _^\bll^gm l^\ng]nf o^k[nf
k^`bl <gmbh\ab) fhk^k^gmnk+
20 OZbi dZbi bZ b]lmrmZ) cbl
20 N^\ng]nf hfgbZ o^k[Z
aZ^\ l\kbilbm hfgb k^`gh lnh7 ^m iZkZ oblZb lZoh dZkZerlm^b bkiZ*
ikZ^ihlnbm ikbg\bi^l ihineh) jnb ldrk fhgfl obkbgbgd) dnkb^
aZ^\ _b^kb \h`^k^gm+ 21 @m bnll^* o^klm oblZ mZbi ordbgmb+ 21 Ob^
kngm \bobmZmb[nl en]Z lZ\kb_b\Zk^+ eb^i En]h fb^lmZfl ]Zkrmb Zn*
22 @m \hg`k^`Zmb lngm fnemb ]^ dZl+ 22 ?Zn`^ebl b mZnmhl) dnkb^
ihineh Z] ^hl) jnb]^k^ebjn^kZgm [noh iZf^mQb^iZmb^l lmZmrf)
e^`^f ?hfbgb7 ^m _^\^kngm fZeZ ikblb]ch ikb^ c bk ]ZkibdmZZ*
lni^k m^kkZf7 23 ^m ^__n`Zo^kngm erc^+ 23 Eb^ bldeZb] DskZ^ebh mZn*
ihinenf DlkZ^e bg Z[]bmbl) ^m bg m  gnhZebZl bk iZleimZl iZ[*
Z[l\hg]bmbl _n`bmbohknf eh\bl+
`eb ob^mZl+
24 ?b^ jnbgmZ]^\bfZ f^glbl
24 K^gdbh$+bdm dZle^oh fg^*
>Zle^n) jnbgmh ^m jnZ]kZ`^lbfh lbh ]b^g bfmZl d^mnkbZl ]^bf*
^m \^gm^lbfh Zggh Z^]b_b\Zobm k^q mbl i^gdmZbl f^mZbl dZkZebnl <g*
<gmbh\anl Z[hfbgZg]nf b]henf mbhdZl iZlmZmr]bgh iZlb[cZnkmbg
]^lheZmbhgbl lni^k ZemZk^ ?^b) ^m lngZbdbgbfh lmZ[ Zgm ?b^oh Ze*
i^k ngbo^klZl \bobmZm^l en]Z bg mhkbZnl) bk [noh iZlmZmrmZ Zndn*
\bk\nbmn Z^]b_b\Zo^kngm ZkZl7 25 ^m k oblnhl^ En]hfb^lmnhl^Ziebg*
Zgm^ bZgnZl ]hfhknf) ^m bg ieZ* dnb+ 35 OZbi iZm mb^l gZf ]nkb*
m^bl bg\^g]^[Zgm mankZ) ^m lZ\kb* fbl bk `Zmol^ ]^`bgh lfbedZenl
_b\Z[Zgm7 26 ^m eb[khl e^`bl ?^b bk ]Zk ZndZl8 26 ]^`bgh ?b^oh
\hf[nll^kngm b`gb) l\bg]^gm^l lmZmrfh dgr`Zl) cZl ln]kZldbnl)
^hl7 -- ^m Zin] jn^f\nfjn^ bg u 3- bk iZl d mbd kZl]Zoh Qb^iZ*

k\o dm \pfjod @d`qpd+  %2.& M T \^ h f((


Lgb+ / I\f+ 3)5+6+ >pqj m`df\g\pe\*
h\ dnd\_od n\i_jmjn np @d`qp t *
hn) opj k\dp \onfdmod epjn ipj @d`*
qj o\pojn+  JhgXcg\ ]  f \X _T f 4 qt *
m`nidpjndpn kmdq`mnod o\dk npndo`kod)
f\_ ed` e\pno) ejb o\n npndo`kdh\n
Rm\+ ipndf\godh\n @d`qj no\othpd+
%20& M\ey\a\a^( =ijo bm+ o+7 kmd`*
q\du_p+ Fd` opmej kmddmod) f\_
f\m\gd\pn n\fth\d ]o qdnpm od*
fngd\d qtfdi\hd+ | %21& Ah W b  ` \Xf'
gT` f( Em o\d ]pqj kmd`dib\ t_
no\othpd) fpmn kmdk\dij odf qd`i
\pf qd`o kmd` F`mpu\gn ]\itdjn+
Mm ( =of+ ./).0+  %22& G e\X ] 4 kmd`
f\m\gd\pn kmd`q\du_+ | %23& @y f^ _T \'
W ( Eodfdhd`ed @d`qj no\othpd t_\d
]pqj kmdq`mnod ]bod d n\qj btq`i\*
h qd`o dm ng\knotodn+  %24& G Xa '

^ \b _\^ g (((4 qd`i d k\nfpodid g\kfmd*


dj \m kdmh bmpj_dj hi+ _d`i .3O
h+ kdmh Gm+ P _d`i ]pqj km\_o\n
_\m]\n8 k\]\dbo\ e k`m .- _d`i+ Ru
3/ `dg+  G Tf\U]Th eg\a T((( G\d fpmd`
\dfdioje\d nke\) f\_ ]pqpnd k\no\*
oto\ Fpkdo`mdj no\opg\+ >`o dmdio
fjio`fnoj) m`dfo h\itod) f\_ qdmpe`
_`bdi\he \pf \gojmd\pn ]pqj _\*
]\m k\no\oto\n \pfpm\n) \io fpmdj
opmej ]od _`bdi\hjn \pfjn no\]\hn+
P o\d no\] \pfpm \pojmdpn dm q\*
_di\ _\gtfp g\]d\pnd\d k\nd]e\pmod*
ip) fpmdpj dm`dfd\h\n npi\dfdidh\n+
 : hib c TfgTgl gT((( Lgb+ / I\f) 3)
/ + + +   M \fhbfX( Pj j_dj im\ bm+
o+  %25& K \Xf aT`((( L\bjid kmj*
dp no\o kmd` _pm ng`ifnd no\op*
g\n =kjggdpd) D`mhdpd) @d\i\d) fpmd`
]pqj g\dfjhd i\hp dm hd`no bgj]*

Turinys

441

( ; 29 = ( = ? $ =

o^gb^[Zgmnk eb[kb m^lmZf^gmb ? h* D mb^l lZg]hkhl dgr` bk dZl eZb*


fbgb) ^m jnb\nfjn^ h[l^koZ[Zm  db Qb^iZmb^l lmZmrfh) m) ^b*
e^`^f ?hfbgb) l^\ng]nf ^]b\* u
 gZgm dZkZebZnl iZeb^ibfn) nfn*
mnf k^`bl mkn\b]Z[Zgm ^nf+ 3. Dg ]Zoh+ 3. Onk]Zfb `Zebhl cb^ mZb
obkmnm^ lnZ _Z\b^[Zgm aZ^\ ihin* ]Zk DskZ^ebh mZnmZb)dnkb kZl]Zoh*
eh DlkZ^e) jnb bgo^gb^[Zmnkbg hf* lb fb^lmnhl^) db^dob^g fg^l)
gb f^gl^ ^m f^gl^ bg \bobmZmb[nl+ -/ h ]ob]^bfm i^gdm fg^lbh
3/ @m jnbgmZ ^m ob`^lbfZ ]b^f^g* ]b^g cb^ Zndhch Zgm Zndnkh) iZ*
lbllZ\kb_b\Z[Zgm lni^kZkZf) jnZ^ lmZmrmh Zgm ZemhkbZnl+ _b0 Hhm^kb*
^kZm \hgmkZ ZemZk^+ 30 @m fneb^k^l) dl) dnkbhl ]nh]Zoh ZibicZnlmrmb
jnZ^ \bk\nf\b]^[Zgm beehl) mkn\b* lZoh oZbdnl) [noh nfnZfhl)
]Z[Zgmnk l^\ng]nf bnllnfk^`bl mZbi dZbi dZkZebZnl <gmbhdh [n*
<gmbh\ab) 31 ^m lnli^g]^[Zgmin* oh eb^imZ8 31 oZbdnl iZdZk]Zoh
^khl Z \^kob\b[nl i^k ngbo^klZl chf l Zgm dZdeh oblnhl^ c gZ*
]hfhl ^hknf7 ^m ^hl) jnb \bk\nf* fnhl^ bk nfn]Zoh mnhl) dnkb^
\b]^kZgm beehl) mkn\b]Z[Zgm+ 32 @m [noh cnhl ZibicZnlm+ 32 =^m ]Zn*
fnemb ]^ ihineh DlkZ^e ]^_bgb^kngm `^ebl b DskZ^ebh mZnmhlgnmZkiZ*
Zin] l^) nm ghgfZg]n\Zk^gm bf* mrl lZn g^oZe`rmb lnm^im ]Zerd
fng]Z7 ^m ^e^`^kngm fZ`bl fhkb) bk o^ebch `^kbZn fbkmb) dZbi lnlb*
jnZf \b[bl\hbgjnbgZkb bffng]bl7 m^imb g^oZkbZbl oZe`bZbl+ 33 Eb^g^*
33 ^m ghen^kngm bg_kbg`^k^ e^`^f ghkch lneZnrmb o^gmh ?b^oh
?^b lZg\mZf)^mmkn\b]Zmbln g m734 ^m lmZmrfh bk [noh nfnmb+ 34 GZ*
_Z\mZ ^lm bkZ fZ`gZ lni^k ihin* [Zb ]b]^e klmr[ [noh dbenlb
enf oZe]^+
Zgm mZnmhl+

M! ?L_L_TUZ T] UZ ^zY{ [L^T[]TPoTYTXL^ ]PWTRTUZ^


T] _L`_Z^ [P]^PVTZ_ZULX^%
(  [P]^Vb]TXL^% . Ohl^]b^*
6L[`_ ;;% . eg ]b^[nl beeblb
lnkk^qbm HZmaZmabZl _bebnl ehZggbl)
 ghl^ iZdbeh dngb`Zl b EhZkb[h
_bebb Nbf^hgbl) lZ\^k]hl ^q _bebbl 8 oZbdb E^knsZel) Nbfhgh lgZnl
DhZkb[ Z[ D^knlZe^f) ^m \h g l^ ] bm$ Ehgh lgnl HZmZmbcZl8 cbl `ro^*

d\dn+  %26& 2 L N P U V &$&  Op_m\nfth\n


dm _`bdidh\n ]pqj k\id`fdidhj `i*
fg\d+ J\dfdi_\hd no\othj fitb\n)
ijmej k\_\mtod) f\_ k\on no\oth\n
]pop phdmo\n+ E d\ k\odmd\h`) f\_
opj g\dfp) \ondm\_pn _\pb`gdpd m\op
dijqp) q`ioe) fitb ipjm\p nf\d*
dpn ]pqj thd\d k\_\pben+  %3.&
8 \ Y P  Y H Z K H ] V Z P &  =ijo bm+ o+7 fpmd`
]pqj m\i_\hd fpj ijmn ipndf\go+ 
8 PL R ] PL U H $ T s U L Z u ,  qd`i f\mo f\n
hipj) f\_ fdopn ipbn_diop+  %3/&
/ U [  H \ R \ Y V &&&  @\mt_\hd \pf\n \io
\pfpmj) k\no\otoj qdmpe` @d`qj \ g*
ojmd\pn) opj k\dp mj_) f\_ ojn \p*

fjn _\mjhjn i`]` t_p Rd`k\dpd+


=ijo bm+ o ojn \pfjn ]pqj _\mjhjn
f\n hipj) _qd_`dho k`ifo fd`f*
qd`ij hi`ndj _d`i) o+ t+ o k\d)
fpddje` kdmh ntfd @d`qj \gojmdpn
]pqj npo`ko\n+  %32& C L SP QV  N L Y P H \ &&&
LEb+ / I\f+ 3 dm 4 k`mnf+  %34&
9 H I H P K P K L S s &&&  =km\to\n k`mn`fdjed*
h\n ]pqj g\dfjh\n @d`qj ndno\ o\p*
o\d ]\pnh`+
/). 4-+ =iodjfj n\fth\hn qd`*
\d k\ndkmd`di\ I\o\ode\n %.//& dm
php\ no\]\hn \pfje\io t_) o\dk
k\o f\m\gd\pn k\ndpiodi %/0 /3&+ Fdn
np n\qdfd\dn k\]b\ d f\gipn) kj fj*

Turinys

. H<F+ /) / * 6

442

bg fhgm^ Hh]bg7 / ^m aZ[^[Zm 8 gh Hh]bgh dZeg^ /bk mnkch i^g*
_bebhl jnbgjn^) ehZgg^f) jnb\h`* 7 dbl lgnl7 Ehg)oZ]bgZfBZ]bn)
ghfbgZ[Zmnk JZ]]bl7 0 ^m Nbfh* 0 Nbfhg) oZ]bgZf Olbn) 1 En *
g^f) jnb \h`ghfbgZ[Zmnk OaZlb7 ])oZ]bgZf HZdZ[b^cnfb) 2 @e^*
1 ^m Dbb]Zf) jnb oh\Z[Zmnk HZ* ZsZk) oZ]bgZf <[Zkhgn) bk Eh*
\aZ[Z^nl7 2^m @e^ZsZknf)jnb\h`* gZmZg) oZ]bgZf <i_n+
ghfbgZ[Zmnk <[Zkhg7 ^m DhgZmaZg)
jnb \h`ghfbgZ[Zmnk <iianl+
3 Eb^ fZm ibdm^gr[^l) dhdbhl
3 Cb ob]^kngm fZeZ) jnZ^ _b^*
[Zgm bg ihineh Dn]Z) ^m bg D^* ]Zklb En]h mZnmhc^ bk E^knsZec^+
knlZe^f+
4 Dk HZmZmbcZl mZk7
4 @m ]bqbm HZmaZmabZl7
?^cZ fZg FZf Z `bfbZn)
QZ^ fbab) nm jnb] gZmnl lnf
ob]^k^ \hgmkbmbhg^f ihineb f^b) dZ] fZmrbZn lZoh mZnmhl lngZb*
dbgbf)
^m \hgmkbmbhg^f \bobmZmbl lZg\mZ^) o^gmhch fb^lmh lngZbdbgbf bk
l]bZn bZ)
^m l^]^k^ beeb\)
\nf ]Zmnk bg fZgb[nl bgbfb\h* dZb cbl Zmb]nh]ZfZl  g^ikb^m^*
knf;
eb kZgdZl;
5 NZg\mZ bg fZgn ^qmkZg^hknf 5 o^gmho iZm^dh  lo^mbfc
_Z\mZ lngm7
kZgdZl8
m^fienf ^bnl lb\nm ahfh b`gh ch [ZgrbZ rkZ er` g^`Zk[bg`Zl
[bebl+
fh`nl+
6 QZlZ `ehkbZ^ ^bnl \ZimboZ Z[* 6 Ehl `Zk[l bg]Zb b`Z[^gmb g^*
]n\mZ lngm7
eZblog8
mkn\b]Zmb lngml^g^l ^bnlbg ieZm^bl) chl l^g^ebZb nfnmb `Zmol^)
^m bno^g^l ^bnl \^\b]^kngm bg`eZ* bkchl cZngbdZbbZb noh g^ikb^*
]bh bgbfb\hknf+
m^ebh dZeZobcn+

fdj g\dfj ipo\md\ fjqjod dm np]\ojhdn)


km\_`_\ mdifod f\mdpjh`i` dm bmd*
i\ qdnpm n`ie @d`qj b\m]didhj ]*
_ %/415&+ L\n`in I\o\ode\n _pj*
_\ nkedhp n\qj niphn %16 31&)
k\nfdmd\ Odhji e qtm`nidpjep) Fp*
_ bd f\mdpjh`in q\_p %3243&+
%/).& K b f X  W \Xa bfX(  Lgb+ @\i+ ..)
01+ o G T ^ \_b 4  km\_ej q`dfod+  A b ' 
T e \U b + Ldmh\n d /1 @j$qd_j k\nfdm*
op fpidbp nftmd ]pqj Fj\md]j %.
Gmji) /1)4&+  @y AX e h m T _ f (  P\n fp*
idbp nftmdpn ]pqj fdgn d F`mpu\gn+
 J \` ba b+++ Bg+ Fpju\k\n I\o\odej
kmjn`i`g q\_di\ =nhjid`ephd) oj_g
dm ej \did\d q\_di\hd o\dk k\o =n*
hjid`e\dn+ G\d f\_\ I\o\ode\n q\_d*
i\h\n qtmd\pndpjep fpidbp) o\d\p
ojfn k\q\_didh\n i`opmd k\bmdi_j+
Pd`n\) qtmd\pndjej fpidbj k\m`dbjn
]pqj k\q`nojn I\o\odej nipd Fji*
opd) ]`o odf kj oj) f\d ]pqj hdmn

d

d

d

Kide\n EEE %/ I\f+ 1)01&) ej ]mjgdn F\*


uji\n ]pqj \okpjgn %/ I\f* 1).4&)
j Kide\n ER k\]bn+ ; D bW\a b4  i`*
ojgd @djnkjgd`n %Hd__jn& kmd` f`gdj)
fpmdpj `di\h\ d F`mpu\gn d Fjkk
%qu+ `h+ d7+)01&+  %/& M TW\aT` T
> TW{\h(  G od` I\o\odej ni k\q\*
_didh\d m`dfd\) i`qdn\d \dfp) C\*
_dn) m\nd) m`dfd\7 g\dhdib\ndn+  %0&
Kf\h(  P\n j_dn) m\nd) m`dfd\7 nh\m*
fpndn+  %1& D T ^T U\X]h ` \4  kg\fopfp+
 %2& 9 UTebah 4  k`mq`md\idp %`h+
3)13&+  9 cgh4 ]pfgdp) \ijo fdo) k\*
nfpodidp %qgd\pnd\d bdhpndp&+
%3& A \X (  =ijo bm+ o+7 edn+  %4&
< X]T ` Ta(  P\dk I\o\ode\n dm`dfd\
n\qj dm_d`n+ nf\pnh _g t_pn np*
odfpndp k`mn`fdjedhp+ Pjgd\p I\o\*
odej _`e\qdh\n dm`dfo\n `dghdn+ 
J W }\T h  J \V4  id`fj i`_\mtd\p+ 
%5& A b  U T{ a l }\T(  Oke\h\) f\_ dd\
qd`oje` ]\itdjn %bm+
;#8& opmop

Turinys

443

. H<F+ /) . - *. 6

.- LnZ^ `^glghg a^k^]bmZobmk^`*


gnf ^bnl)
^m ghg h[mbgnbm lihebZ ^bnl;
.. Jfgbl \hfihlbmbh ^bnl Z[*
eZmZ ^lm+
LnZ^ ^kZm eb[^kZ) _Z\mZ^lmZg\beeZ+
./ @m ^\\^lZg\mZghlmkZ) ^m ine*
\akbmn]h ghlmkZ)
^m \eZkbmZl ghlmkZ ]^lheZmZ ^lm)
^m \hbgjnbgZo^kngm ^Z B^gm^l+
.0 Lnh ^k`h gh[bl Z]an\ obo^k^;

.- Fnkb mZnmZ g^iZo^e]ch chl dZ*


kZerlml
bk g^f ch l `kh[bh;
.. QblZl chl iZinhbfZl ZmbfmZl8
mZ) dnkb [noh eZbloZ) iZlb]Zko^k*

)b+

./ mZb fnlo^gmho)fnl `kh*


bl
bk fl`Zk[bg`nfZl lngZbdbgmb8
iZ`hgrl cnhl lnm^i+
.0 OZb dZf `b fnfl ]Zk [`r
o^gmb;
.1 HZmZmbcZl ln lZoh lgnfbl
.1 @m l\b]bm o^lmbf^gmZ lnZ
HZmaZmabZl) ^m _bebb^bnl7 ^m hi^kn* i^kie lZoh ]kZ[nbnl) Zilbobe*
^kngm l^ \beb\bbl) ^m ieZgq^kngm dh Znmbgfbl bk eZ[Zb `^]ch+
oZe]^+
.2 E bZ Zmch dZkZebZnl <gmbh*
.2 @m o^g^kngm been\jnb fbllb
dh
lblmb^cb) dZ] ikbo^klm iZ[*
^kZgm Z k^`^ <gmbh\ah) nm \h`^*
k^gm ^hl) jnb \hg_n`^kZgm bg \b* `nlbnl c Hh]bgh fb^lm Zndhmb)
obmZm^f Hh]bg) bffheZk^) ^m Z\* ]^`bgmb lfbedZenlbk blbZ]mb ?b^*
\^g]^k^ mankZ) ^m Z e^`^ ?^b ]bl* oh lmZmrfh+ .3 ?Zn`^ebl b DskZ*
\^]^k^+ .3 @m fnemb ]^ ihinehDl* ^ebh mZnmhl lnmbdhbk ikblb]ch ikb^
kZ^e \hgl^gmb^gm^l Z\\^ll^kngm Z] c) [^m HZmZmbcZl ln lZoh lgn*
^hl7 l^] HZmaZmabZl) ^m _bebb ^bnl fbl iZlbebdh iZmoZkl+ .4Onhf^m
\hglmZgm^k lm^m^kngm+ .4@mk^lihg* Zmlbeb^i]Zfb Zmlblmb^cb lZd HZ*
]^gm^l jnb fbllb ^kZgm Z[ <gmbh* mZmbcnb7 On ibkfZlbl) rfbZnlbZl
\ah) ]bq^kngm HZmaZmabZ^7 Kkbg* bk ]b]bZnlbZl bmZf^ fb^lm^) `Z*
\^il ^m \eZkbllbfnl) ^m fZ`gnl ebg`Zl lZoh lgnfbl bk* [khebZbl8
^l bg aZ\ \bobmZm^) ^m hkgZmnl _b* .5 mZb`b ^bd bZ ibkfZl bk ]Zkrd)
ebbl) ^m _kZmkb[nl+ .5 @k`h Z\\^]^ dZl dZkZebZnllZdrmZ) dZbi rkZ iZ*
ikbhk) ^m _Z\ bnllnf k^`bl) lb\nm ]Zkbnlbhl oblhl mZnmhl) En]hfh*
_^\^kngm hfg^l B^gm^l) ^m obkb gl bk ebdnlb^cb E^knsZec^8 mZb mn
Dn]Z) ^m jnb k^fZgl^kngm bg D^* ln lZoh lgnfbl [lb mZki dZkZ*
knlZe^f7 ^m ^kbl mn) ^m _bebb mnbbg* ebZnl ikb^m^eb bk [lb Zi]hoZgh*
m^k Zfb\hl k^`bl) ^m Zfieb_b\Zmnl mZl Zndln) lb]Z[kn bk]Zn`^ebn]h*
Znkh) ^m Zk`^gmh) ^m fng^kb[nl oZg+ .0 =^m HZmZmbcZl ZmlZdr]Z*
fnembl+ ./ @mk^lihg]bmHZmaZmabZl) fZl mZk ]b]^ebn [Zeln7 Ihkl ob*
^m ]bqbm fZ`gZ oh\^7 @m lb hf* lhl mZnmhl deZnlh dZkZebZnl <g*
g^l B^gm^l k^`b <gmbh\ah h[^* mbhdh)mZbidZ]db^dob^gZliZlbmkZn*
]bngm) nm ]bl\^]Zm ngnljnbljn^Z dbZgnhmZkgZobfh lZoh mo lmZ*
l^kobmnm^ e^`bl iZmknf lnhknf) mrfnb bk lnmbgdZ ln ch iZebib*

]od o\po\ %bm+ e\b 7 &+  %.1& C T \f i T 4 ude&) f\_ ed` %btq`ioje\d& \pfjop+ 
%.3& : Xg D TgTg\]Tf('( Cm+ o+7 I\o\od*
opmej i`k\gd`no\n ]`io m`gdbde dm o\p*
7 e\n dm ej nin npndmdifj) o+ t + km\*
odi n\qdnojqt]+
%.2& , }\T  T g ]b +++ Cm+$ o+ omphkd\p7 _dje` odfd dmej) f\n _\mnd) k\nfpd
Em \oej e Ij_dij hd`no ipj f\m\* E bd opmej km\_od qdnd _m\pb` q`dfod+ 
gd\pn q`md\iod`ed d \okpjgdh %\kjno\* d %.4& : e b _\T \f 4 bdhdihdn+  %.5& = \^

Turinys

. H<F+ /) /-}0-

444

^m \hgl^gmbZmfZg]Zmbl ^ bn l7/-^`h fZbl) /- Z mZbZn) fZgh lglbk


#  _bebb f^b) #  O[J][N\ f^b h[^]b^* fZkbh[khebZb) f^l deZnlrlbf^f*
fnl e^`b iZmknf ghlmkhknf+ l mo lmZmrfh+ /. O^`ne ?b^*
/. ikhibmbnl lbm gh[bl ?^nl7 ghg oZl [gZ fnfl `Zbe^lmbg`Zl
^lm gh[bl nmbe^ k^ebgjn^k^ e^`^f) Hnfl g^gZn]bg`Z iZf^lmb lmZ*
^m bnlmbmbZl ?^b7 // ghg Zn]b^fnl mrf bk ?b^oh lZdrfnl+ // H^l
o^k[Z k^`bl <gmbh\ab) g^\ lZ\kb* g^deZnlrlbf^ dZkZebZnl <gmbhdh
_b\Z[bfnl mkZgl`k^]b^gm^l e^`bl h]b bk g^Zndhlbf^) i^k^g`*
ghlmkZ^ fZg]ZmZ) nm ^Zfnl Zem^* ]Zfb fl lmZmrfh lZdrfnl)*
dZ] ^bmnff dbmn d^ebn
kZ obZ+
/0
@m nm \^llZobm ehjnb o^k[Z /0
FZbi mbd cbl iZ[Zb`dZe[mb
aZ^\) Z\\^llbm jnb]Zf en]Z^nl bg bmnhl h]bnl) ikbch obl Zdr*
hfgbnf h\nebl lZ\kb_b\Zk^ b]hebl l^ ob^gZl r]Zl Zndhmb lmZ[Zfl
lni^k ZkZf bg \bobmZm^ Hh]bg) l^* Zgm Zndnkh Hh]bgh fb^lm^) dZbi
\ng]nf bnllnf k^`bl7 /1 ^m ob* [noh dZkZebZnl eb^imZ+ /1 OZb iZ*
]bm HZmaZmabZl) ^m ]henbm) ^m \hg* fZml HZmZmbcZl [noh ldZnlfh
mk^fn^kngm k^g^l ^bnl) ^m Z\\^g* lnbfmZl8 ch ob]nkbZb ln]k^[ch8 ch
lnl ^lm _nkhk ^bnl l^\ng]nf bn* gZklZl nlb]^` lneb` lmZmrfh
]b\bnf e^`bl) ^m bglbeb^gl mkn\b]Z* gnkh]rfn) bk ikbhdl cbl nfn*
obm ^nf lni^k ZkZf7 /2 l^] ^m  c Zgm Zndnkh+ /2 Onh iZbn
obknf) jn^f k^q <gmbh\anl fb* f^mn cbl nfn bkdZkZebZnl <g*
l^kZm) jnb \h`^[Zm bffheZk^) h\* mbhdh Zmlblm fh`) dnkl o^km
\b]bm bg bilh m^fihk^) ^m ZkZf Zndhmb) bk ln`kbho Zndnk+ /3Ebl
]^lmknqbm) /3 ^m s^eZmnl ^lm e^`^f) nhebZb ^e`lb ]e lmZmrfh) dZbi
lb\nm _^\bm Kabg^^l TZfkb _bebh dZ] [noh ]Zkl KbgZl NZehfbh
NZehfb+
lgnb TZfkbnb+
/4 @m ^q\eZfZobm HZmaZmabZl
/4 Kh mh HZmZmbcZl Znd ]b*
oh\^ fZ`gZ bg \bobmZm^) ]b\^gl7 ]^ebn [Zeln fb^lm^) lZdr]ZfZl7
Jfgbl) jnb s^enf aZ[^m e^`bl Qblb) dnkb^ mnkb nhenfh lmZmrfnb
lmZmn^gl m^lmZf^gmnf) ^q^Zm ihlm bk iZeZbdh lZg]hk) m^`ne b^bgZ
f^+ /5 @m _n`bm bil^) ^m _bebb ^bnl iZldnb fZg^+ /5 OZbicbl bkch l*
bg fhgm^l) ^m k^ebjn^kngm jnZ^* gl iZ[`h  dZegnl bk iZebdh ob*
\nfjn^ aZ[^[Zgm bg \bobmZm^+ lZ) d cb^ mnkch fb^lm^+ /6 Onh
/6 Ong\]^l\^g]^kngm fnemb jnZ^* iZbn f^mn bch  mrknl ]Zn`^*
k^gm^l bn]b\bnf) ^m bnlmbmbZf) bg ebl m) dnkb^ b^dhch m^blmnfh bk
]^l^kmnf7 0- ^m l^]^kngm b[b bilb) m^blr[l) 0- bk iZlbebdh m^gZb ln
^m _bebb ^hknf) ^m fneb^k^l ^hknf) lZoh oZbdZbl) ln fhghfbl bklZ*
^m i^\hkZ ^hknf7 jnhgbZf bgng* oh `ronebZbl) g^l cnhl [noh Zi*
]Zo^kngm lni^k ^hl fZeZ+
`nenlbhl g^eZbfl+
} \T 4 kmd` \pfpmj+  %/-& fgTgl ` b(
Cm+ o+7 n\i_jmjn %np @d`qp&+  %//.
9 ag\b^b {bW{\ \e((( =ijo bm+ o+7 =i*
odjfj j_dp) f\_ h`n \onojophh
ipj hn o\mi\qdhj @d`qpd d _`di
\m  f\dm+
%/1& A b  aTefTf'(([ =ijo bm+ o+7 edn
g`d_j q`dfod n\qj mnot]`d) f\dk ]p*
qj o`dndib\+  Jh_\Z fgTgl ` b aheb'

Wl` h( %no\oth` ]pqj n\fto\ ipp*


_tod opjn) fpmd` \pfje\ no\]\hn+ =of+
.0)36+  %/4& G \a Tf( Ru+ Of+ /2).0+
%/6& , gl eh f4  Fp_j otmph) `n\i*
d  q\f\mpn ipj Idmod`n emjn+ P`i
f\gipjn` ]pqj g\]\d _\pb pmq %kgb+
. G\m+ .0)3 dm /1)1&+  @X y ^ b ]b  gX\'
fh` b \e((( n\qj btq`idh` no`ibnd g\d*
ftodn no\oth` d\ftoj o`dnphj+

Turinys

445

. H<F+ /) 0 . *1 .

0.
@m k^gng\bZmnf lm obkbl k^* 0.
Onh mZkin dZkZebZnl fh
`bl) ^m ^q^k\bmnb) jnb ^kZm bg D^kn* gfl bk dZkbnhf^g^b) [nonlbZbE^*
lZe^f \bobmZm^ ?Zob]jnhgbZf ]bl* knsZec^ ?hob]h fb^lm^)[nohikZ*
\^llbll^gm obkb jnb]Zf) jnb ]bl* g^mZ) dZ] dZb dnkb^ fhgl) dn*
lbiZo^kngm fZg]Zmnf k^`bl bgeh* kb^ [noh iZgb^dbg dZkZebZnl lZ*
\Z h\\nemZ bg]^l^kmh) ^m Z[bbll^gm drf) bch  leZimZl ob^mZl mrkn*
ihlm beehl fnemb+ 0/ @m lmZmbf i^k* fhc^ bk dZ] ]Zn` dbm gnchiZ*
k^q^kngm Z] ^hl) ^m \hglmbmn^kngm ldnb cnhl+ 0/ bmb^ mnhcZn bch
Z]o^klnl ^hl ikZ^ebnfbg ]b^lZ[* ikb^ cnhl bk k^g`lb inemb cnhl
[Zmhknf) 00 ^m ]bq^kngm Z] ^hl7 ln[Zmhl ]b^g+ 00 Eb^ lZd cb^fl7
M^lblmbmbl ^m gng\ Z]an\; ^qbm^) <k ]Zk bk ]Z[Zk cl ikb^bglbml;
^m _Z\bm^ l^\ng]nfo^k[nf k^`bl D^bdbm^ bk ]Zkrdbm^) dZbidZkZebZnl
<gmbh\ab)^m obo^mbl+01 @m ]bq^kngm7 <gmbhdh lZdrmZ) bk cl bebdlbm^
Ihg ^qb[bfnl) g^jn^ _Z\b^fnl `rob+ 01 Ob^ ZmlZd7 I^b^blbf^bk
o^k[nf k^`bl) nm iheenZfnl ]b^f g^ordbglbf^ dZkZebZnlh]bh)f^l
lZ[[Zmhknf+ 52 @m \hg\bmZo^kngm g^lnm^ilbf^ ln[Zmhl ]b^ghl+
Z]o^klnl^hlikZ^ebnf+ 03 @m ghg 02 OZb`b Zgb^ ikZ]ch ikb^ cnhl
k^lihg]^kngm ^bl)g^\eZib]^ffb* dho+ 03 Eb^ g^ZmlZd Zgb^fl) g^*
l^kngm bg^hl)g^\hiibeZo^kngm eh* f^m  cnhl g Zdf^gl bk g^n*
\Z h\\nemZ) 04]b\^gm^l7 HhkbZfnk ]Zk leZim ob^m) 04 lZdr]Zfb7
hfg^l bg lbfieb\bmZm^ ghlmkZ7 ^m Hbkdbf^ oblb lZohg^dZemnf^8]Zg*
m^lm^l ^kngm lni^k ghl \Z^enf) `nl bk ^f [nl fnfl ebn]rmh*
^m m^kkZ) jnh] bgbnlm^i^k]bmbl ghl+ cZb) dZ] cl n]hm^ fnl g^m^blbg*
05 @m bgmne^kngm beebl [^eenf lZ[* `Zb+ 05 OZb`b Zgb^ dhohch ikb^
[Zmbl7 ^m fhkmnb lngm bilb) ^m nqh* cnhl ln[Zmhfbl) bkcb^noh ]kZn`
k^l ^hknf) ^m _bebb ^hknf) ^m i^* ln lZoh fhghfbl) lZoh oZbdZbl
\hkZ^hknf nljn^Z] fbee^ ZgbfZl bk lZoh `ronebZbl) oblh Zib^ md*
ahfbgnf+ 06 @m \h`ghobm HZmaZ* lmZgm Zlf^g+ 06NnbghcZib^mZb
mabZl) ^m Zfb\b ^bnl) ^m en\mnfaZ* HZmZmbcZl bk ch ikb^m^ebZb eZ[Zb c
[n^kngm lni^k ^hl oZe]^+ 1- @m]b* `^]ch+ 1- Eb^ dZe[ch ob^gZl db*
qbm obk ikhqbfh lnh7 Nb hfg^l mZf7 E^b oblb ]Zkrlbf^ mZbi) dZbi
_^\^kbfnl lb\nm _kZmk^l ghlmkb _^\^* iZ]Zk fl [khebZb) bk g^dhoh*
kngm) ^m ghg in`gZo^kbfnl Z]* lbf^ ikb^ iZ`hgbl ]e lZoh `r*
o^klnl `^gm^l ikh ZgbfZ[nl ghl* or[l bk lZohlmZmrfh) Zgb^`k^b*
mkbl) ^m bnlmb_b\Zmbhgb[nl ghlmkbl7 mZb bgZbdbgl fnl b Zeb^l+ 1.O h *
gng\ \bmbnl ]bli^k]^gm ghlZ m^k* ]e m ]b^g cb^ gnlblmZm bk lZd7
kZ+ 1. @m \h`bmZo^kngm bg ]b^ beeZ) Kkb^ db^dob^g) dnkl Zm^bl dhoh*
]b\^gm^l7 Jfgbl ahfh) jnb\nf* mb ikb^ fnl ln[Zmhl ]b^g) dh*
jn^ o^g^kbm Z] ghl bg [^eeh ]b^ ohlbf^ bk f^l bk g^fbklbf^ oblb)
%0.& < bi\Wb ` \XfgX4 oqdmojqe`) fp*
md ntm\d ]pqj k\no\o Odjij f\gi`+
 %01& J h UTgbf W \Xa bf( E`dod dm qt*
fdiod f\m\gd\pn j_ ed`hn ]pqj gtbp
np]\ojn npo`kdhpd) i`n np]\ojn _d`i
ed`hn ]pqj _\mjh\n k\ndgth\n+ P \*
d\p o\dk ed` ijmej k\n\ftod) f\_ ed`
g\dftndn i`k\ep_di\h\d @d`qj no\ot*
hj % dn qd`i\) \m k\i\pn k\ndgt*

h\n ]pn ed`hn k\_\mto\n np]\oje` \m


djfd ^+d`i&+  %03& E Xh{WTe((( J`*
pfdhj \fh`idhdn pmqp $g\ib+ 
%05& J hUTgb` \f( C\g d\ f\g]\h\ \kd`
o +k\d np]\ojn _d`i) i`n n\]]\o\
%kgpm+& g\]\d _\i\d q\moje\h\n qd`*
oje` n\]]\oph %ndib+&+ Ru+ / I\f+
])..+ Ijun no\oth\n id`fpm \d*
fd\d i`_m\p_ bdiodn$ np]\oje` ipj p*

Turinys

. H < F + /) 1 / * 2 -

446

lZ[[Zmhknf) in`g^fnl Z]o^klnl U dZbi fbk fnl [khebZb leZimhl^


^nf7 ^m ghg fhkb^fnk hfg^l)  ob^mhl^+
lb\nm fhkmnb lngm _kZmk^l ghlmkb
bg h\\nembl+
1/ Onhf^m lnlbkbgdh ikb^ c
1/ Ong\ \hg`k^`ZmZ ^lmZ] ^hl
lrgZ`h`Z <llb]Z^hknf _hkmbl ob* ]klnl DskZ^ebh [krl) <lb]Zb) oblb
kb[nl ^q DlkZ^e)hfgbl ohengmZkbnl nhel lmZmrfh eZbdrmhcZb+ 10 OZbi
bg e^`^7 10 ^m hfg^l) jnb _n`b^* iZm ikblb]ch ikb^ c oblb) dnkb^
[Zgm Z fZebl) Z]]bmb lngm Z]^hl) [`h gnh g^eZbfb) bk [noh cb^fl
^m _Z\mb lngm beebl Z]_bkfZf^gmnf+ iZlibkmbl+ 11 OZbi cb^ ln]Zk dZ*
11 @m \hee^`^kngm ^q^k\bmnf) ^m kbnhf^g bk lnfn gnlb]cebnl
i^k\nll^kngm i^\\Zmhk^l bg bkZ lZoh klmr[c^ bk g^]hknl fh*
lnZ) ^m obkhl bgbjnhl bg bg]b`gZ* g^l lZoh nlb]^`bf^8 bebdnlb^cb
mbhg^ lnZ7 ^m \^m^kb _n`^kngm Z] `b iZ[`h iZl iZ`hgbl) dZ] blb*
gZmbhg^l) nm ^oZ]^k^gm+ 15 @m \bk* `^e[m+ 12 HZmZmbcZl ln lZoh ikb^*
\nbobm HZmaZmabZl) ^m Zfb\b ^bnl) m^ebZbl ch oblnk) ln`kbho Zndn*
^m ]^lmknq^kngm ZkZl7 10 ^m \bk* knl) 13ZibicZnlm g^ZibicZnlmrmnl
\nf\b]^kngm in^khl bg\bk\nf\b* oZbdnl) db^d mbd kZ]h DskZ^ebh kb*
lhl jnhmjnhm bgo^g^kngm bg _b* [hl^) bk ^e`lb ]klbZb+ 14 Eb^ ob*
gb[nl DlkZ^e7^m bg_hkmbmn]bg^+ 14 @m chlb inbdr[l oZbdnl) bk c r`bZb
i^kl^\nmb lngm _bebhl lni^k[bZ^)^m mnkch iZlbl^dbfh+ 15lmZmrf cb^
ikhli^kZmnf ^lm hinl bg fZgb* boZ]Zoh b iZ`hgb `Zebhl bk b
[nl ^hknf7 15 ^m h[mbgn^kngm e^* dZkZeb kZgdhl bkg^e^b]h lb`Zemb
`^f ]^ fZgb[nl `^gmbnf) ^m ]^ gnlb]cebZfl+
fZgb[nl k^`nf7 ^mghg ]^]^kngm
\hkgn i^\\Zmhkb+
16
@m ZiikhibgjnZo^kngm ]b^l 16 <mcnl f^mnb fbkmb) HZmZmb*
HZmaZmabZ^ fhkb^g]b) ^m ]bqbm _b* cZl lZd lZoh lgnfl7?Z[Zkln*
ebbl lnbl7 Ing\\hg_hkmZmZ^lm ln* lmbikch inbdr[ bk ieZdbfZl) rkZ
i^k[bZ) ^m \Zlmb`Zmbh) ^m m^finl f^mZl lngZbdbgbfh) klmr[l bk
^o^klbhgbl) ^m bkZ bg]b`gZmbhgbl7 nlb]^`bfh+ 2- OZb`b ]Z[Zk) fZ*
2- Ing\ ^k`h) h _bebb) Z^fneZmhk^l gh lgl) [dbm^ nhel lmZmrfh
^lmhm^ e^`bl) ^m ]Zm^ ZgbfZl o^l* `rgcZb bk ]nhdbm^ lZoh `ror[^l
kpjgdhp bdifg\dn8 oj_g I\o\ode\n b\*
gej _pjod n\qd`nd`hn n\fthp %1.
`dg+& fjqjod o\dk k\o np]\ojn _d`i+
%1/& / Z P K H P&  A]m)+ J O H k P K P T $  k\*d
h\g_d`ed+ dod` odf npnd_ej np I\f\*
]d`e\dn) i`dnd\__\hd o\h odfmj n\*
q\m\ifdfphj8 oj_g) f\dk h\otndh`
`hd\p %4).0&) ed` b\gej opmod nfdm*
odib ipndno\othp* Lmd` I\f\]d`ep
_\m ]pqj kmdnd_e %10 `dg+& od`) fp*
md` i^*mej dq`ibod nq`odh\gdp q\m*
bdidhp+  %11& 6 k S P R \ Z P L Q P ,  \okpjggd\d)
fpmd` i`k\o`fj d I\o\odej f\mdpjh`*
in m\if\n+  %13& 3 S N s Z P  K Y p Z P H P&
=ijo f\d fpmdp \dfdiojep7 m`df\g`
i`o bmd`]_\qjn kmd`q\mojn) o+ t+ kmd*
q`mn_\qj _pjod \kdke\pnotod q\dfpn dm

opjn oqpn) fpmd` oj i`g\]\d ijmej+


 %14& = \ P R ^ I s Z  ] H P R \ Z ,  ntmpn 
%15& 6 k  R H Y H S P w &&&,  kg\odij k\b\m]\
no\othpd kmd` q\gd f\m\gd\pn qd`*
odidifp) fpmd` ijmej ed k\\gdiod dm
k\q`mnod id`fp+  ; \ Z P K s Q s S P H T Z ,  \o*
kpqpnd`hn t_\hn*
c
%16& / [ s Q \ Z  T L [ \ P  T P Y [ P ,  h\_\pb
E kj qd`i`mdp ^jqjn h`op+ | 2 H I H Y &&&
e I\o\odepd hdmo\io)8 o\pojn kmd`\d
c ]pqj kdgid kpdft]n) kdfod`ed q\mbg*
E ij o`dndpjndpn) ntm\d _ej k\no\ib)
E f\_ qdn\d npi\dfdiop o`jfm\ode8 ]`
d oj) _\m o`]`]pqj h\ojh\ dm @d`qj
 mnot] o\po\d) i`n F`mpu\g ]pqj
 kmd`p m\ifjn`+  %2-& uZ [ H [ ^ T V &
E no\oth\n ]pqj n\i_jmjn k\bmdi_\n

Turinys

45-

. H<F+ /) 2.* 32

bkZl ikh m^lmZf^gmh iZmknf o^l*


mkhknf) 5. ^mf^f^gmhm^ hi^knf
iZmknf) jnZ^ _^\^kngm bg`^g^kZ*
mbhgb[nl lnbl7 ^m Z\\bib^mbl `eh*
kbZf fZ`gZf) ^m ghf^g Z^m^k*
gnf+ 2/ <[kZaZf ghgg^ bg m^g*
mZmbhg^ bgo^gmnl ^lm _b]^ebl) ^mk^*
inmZmnf ^lm ^bZ] bnlmbmbZf; 20 Dh*
l^ia bg m^fihk^ Zg`nlmbZ^ lnZ^
\nlmh]bobm fZg]Zmnf) ^m _Z\mnl
^lm ]hfbgnl <^`rimb+ 21 Kabg^^l
iZm^k ghlm^k) s^eZg]h s^enf ?^b)
Z\\^ibm m^lmZf^gmnf lZ\^k]hmbb
Z^m^kgb+ 22 e^lnl ]nf bfie^obm
o^k[nf) _Z\mnl ^lm ]nq bg DlkZ^e+
25 >Ze^[) ]nf m^lmb_b\Zmnk bg ^\*
\e^lbZ) Z\\^ibm a^k^]bmZm^f+ 24?Z*
ob] bg lnZ fbl^kb\hk]bZ \hgl^\n*
mnl ^lm l^]^f k^`gb bg lZ^\neZ+
25 @ebZl) ]nf s^eZm s^enf e^`bl)
k^\^imnl ^lm bg \Z^enf+ 26 <gZgbZl
^m <sZkbZl ^m HblZ^e \k^]^gm^l)
eb[^kZmb lngm ]^ _eZffZ+ 3- ?Z*
gb^e bg lnZ lbfieb\bmZm^ eb[^kZmnl
^lm ]^ hk^ e^hgnf+ 3. @m bmZ \h *
`bmZm^ i^k `^g^kZmbhg^f) ^m `^g^*
kZmbhg^f7 jnbZ hfg^l jnb li^kZgm
bg$^nf ) ghg bg_bkfZgmnk+ 3/ @m Z
o^k[bl obkb i^\\Zmhkbl g^mbfn^kb*
mbl7 jnbZ `ehkbZ ^bnl lm^k\nl) ^m
o^kfbl ^lm7 30 ah]b^ ^qmheebmnk) ^m
\kZl ghg bgo^gb^mnk7jnbZ \hgo^k*
lnl ^lm bg m^kkZf lnZf) ^m \h`b*
mZmbh ^bnl i^kbbm+ 31 Qhl ^k`h _bebb
\hg_hkmZfbgb) ^m obkbebm^k Z`bm^ bg
e^`^7 jnbZ bg bilZ `ehkbhlb ^kbmbl+
32 @m ^\\^ Nbfhg _kZm^k o^lm^k)
l\bh jnh] obk \hglbebb ^lm7 bilnf

dm ngtb\+  %2.& 2 P K L S L  N H Y I L  P Y +++


ndbto\n i`h\mpn q\m_\n ]pn ed`hn
_d_`g b\m] %kgb+ / I\f+ 4 k`mnf+&+
[[ %2/& / Y  U L  T s N P U P T L ,  f\d =]m\*
jh\n ]pqj b\qn n\fth. k\\pfjod
n\qj ni+ Lgb* Lm\_+ .2)38d //)/+
%20& 7 \ V _ H W H Z &&&  Ru+ Lm\_+ 06)1.*1-+
}  = P U s H Z & & &  Ru+ Of+ /28.0+  %22&
7 V _ \ s , &  Ru+ E+ .4)68 Of+ .1)38 /4).58
Fju+ .)/ .-+  %23& 8 H Ss I H Z &&&  Ru+

n lZohmo lZg]hk8 2. Zmlbfbg**


dbm^ mo ]Zk[nl) dnkbnhl cb^rkZ
iZ]Zk lZoh dZkmhl^) bkcl eZbf*
lbm^ ]b]^e `Zk[ bk Zfbg oZk*
]+ 2/ <[kZhfZl Zk g^ f`bgb*
f^ [noh kZlmZl bmbdbfZl) bk mZb
[noh cZf ldZbmrmZ c m^blr[;
20 EnhsZiZllZoh lnliZn]bfhf^*
mn l^k`ch lZdrf bk iZlb]Zk
<b`bimh oZe]hoZl+ 21 Hl moZl
KbgZl)]^`]ZfZl nhenfn ]e ?b^*
oh)`Zoh Zfbghl dngb`rlml lZg*
]hk+ 22 Ehsn) ordbgl h]) iZ*
lb]Zk oZ]Zl DskZ^erc^+ 23 FZe[Z;k
ebn]r]ZfZl lnlbkbgdbf^) `Zoh*
moZbgrlm+ 24 ?hob]Zl lZoh `Zb*
e^lmbg`nfn eZbfch ZfbgZb dZkZ*
erlml lhlm+ 25 @ebcZl) ]^`]ZfZl*
lmZmrfh nhenfn) [noh iZbfmZl*
 ]Zg`+ 26 <gZgbcZl) <sZkbcZl bk
HblZebl mbdcbfn [noh b`^e[mb
b eb^ilghl+ 5- ?Zgb^ebl ]e lZoh
g^dZemnfh [noh b`^e[mZlb eb*
m gZlk+ 3. OZbi ZiloZklmrdbm^
dZkm ih dZkmhl) dZ] oblb) dnkb^
cnh mbdblb) g^lnlbeigcZ+ 3/ I^[b*
chdbm^ fh`Znl gnlb]cebh h*
]b) g^l ch `Zk[ feZl bkdbk*
fbgZb7 50 bZg]b^gcblZndmbgZfZl)
h krmhc ch g^[^kZg]ZfZ) g^l cbl
iZobkmhlZoh ]nedfblbk ch lnfZ*
grfZb ]bg`h+ 31 OZb`b cl) fZgh
lgl) [dbm^ ]kll bk ^e`dbml
dZbi orkZb ]e lmZmrfh)og^l cnh
cl [lbm^ `Zk[bg`b+ 32 mZb cl
[khebl NbfhgZl8 Z bgZn) dZ] cbl
iZmZkbf fh`nl8 deZnlrdbm^ ch
oblnhf^m) bk cbl [nl cnfl moZl+
Of* .1)38 Fju+ .1).1+  %24& 4 H PS L Z %
Pdfmd\p7 k\h\g_php+ =gdp*
ude\ d / G\m+ 4 +  %25& 3 SP QH Z &&& C _ &
1 G\m+ /)..8 0 G\m+ .5+ } ) %26& / U H % 
 @\i+ 0)2-+  %3-& 2 H U P%
U PPH Z &&& C _
H P Z &  C _ &  @\i+ 3)//+  %3/& : s k S H Z 
P Y & & & ,  k\qdmno\ hgp dm fdmhdi\dn)
f\dk f\_ ]i\ hjbpd hdmpn+  %30&
/ \ R k [ PU H T H Z &&&  Lgb+ Ln+ 03)028 5.)
d d 8  .12)18 Eu+ 33)/1+  %31& 0 v Z P [ L

[ P U N \ T \ &

Turinys

. H<F+ /) 3 3 * 0 )0

45.

Zn]bm^ l^fi^k) ^m bil^ ^kbm oh[bl 3B En]Zl HZe\Z[b^cnl) lmbiknl bk
iZm^k+ 33 @m en]Zl HZ\aZ[Z^nl ]klnl gnh iZm lZoh cZngrlml)
_hkmbl obkb[nl Z bno^gmnm^ lnZ) lbm m^[gb^ cnfl dZkbnhf^gl oZ]Zl
oh[bl ikbg\^il fbebmbZ^) ^m bil^ bk m^`ne o^]Z mZnm  dho+ 34Nn*
Z`^m [^eenf ihineb+ 34 @m Z]]n* kbgdbm^ ikb^ lZol oblnl) dnkb^ eZb*
\^mbl Z] ohl hfg^l_Z\mhk^le^`bl7 dhlb lmZmrfh) bk Zmd^krdbm^ ikb^*
^m obg]b\Zm^ obg]b\mZf ihineb o^l* Zfl n lZoh mZnm+ 35 <mlber`bg*
mkb+ 35 M^mkb[nbm^ k^mkb[nmbhg^f dbm^ iZ`hgbfl) d cb^ nlbi^eg)
B^gmb[nl) ^m bgm^g]bm^bg ikZ^\^i* bk bkdbm^ lmZmrfh lZdrf+
mnf e^`bl+ 36 @m [^g^]bqbm ^hl)^m 36 Kh mh cbl iZeZbfbgh cnhl bk
Ziihlbmnl^lm Z]iZmk^llnhl+ 4- @m gnch iZl lZoh monl+ 4-Hbk cbl
]^_ng\mnl ^lm Zggh \^gm^lbfh ^m bfmZl d^mnkbZl ]^bfmbl ^mZbl
jnZ]kZ`^lbfh l^qmh7 ^m l^inemnl f^mZblbk[noh lZoh lg iZeZb]h*
^lm Z _bebbl lnbl bg l^ine\akbliZ* mZllZoh modZinhl^Hh]bg^+ Eh
mknf lnhknf bg Hh]bg) ^m ieZg* kZn]hch oblZl DskZ^ebl ]b]bn `^*
q^kngm ^bnf hfgbl DlkZ^e ieZg\mn c ]nen+
fZ`gh+

(% <`OZ ?LVLMTPUL`^ OL]MLT%


aLO`^ T] ToaLO`ZUL

L! <`OL^ Y`RLWT 4Y_TZVZ


oaPY_tUy XTP^_t%

6L[`_ ;;;% . @m lnkk^qbm en*


]Zl) jnb oh\Z[Zmnk HZ\aZ[Z^nl
_bebnl ^bnl ikh ^h7 /^mZ]bnoZ[Zgm
^nf hfg^l _kZmk^l ^bnl7 ^m ngb*
o^klb) jnb l^ \hgbngq^kZgm iZmkb
^bnl) ^m ikZ^ebZ[Zgmnk ikZ^ebnf
DlkZ^e \nf eZ^mbmbZ+
0 @m ]beZmZobm `ehkbZf ihineh
lnh)
^m bg]nbm l^ ehkb\Zf lb\nm `b`Zl)
^m ln\\bgqbm l^ ZkfZ [^eeb\Z lnZ
bg ikZ^ebbl)
^m ikhm^`^[Zm \ZlmkZ `eZ]bh lnh+

)
[P]^Vb]TXL^%Y . Onhf^m
ch ob^mhc^ iZdbeh ch lgnl En]Zl)
oZ]bgZfZl HZdZ[b^cnfb+ / EZf
iZ]ch oblb ch [khebZb bk oblb) dn*
kb^ [noh lnlb]c ln ch mon8 cb^
ln ]bZn`lfn dhohch DskZ^ebh
dho+
0 Ebl iZ]Zn`bgh `Zk[ lZoh
mZnmZb)
obed]Zoh ZkoZbl dZbi fbebgZl)
lnlbcnhl]Zoh dZkbdZbl `bgdeZbl
dhohl^
bk lZoh dZeZobcn `rg lmhordeZl+

b\pndo` dodfdht]n @d`qj


k\\_o phjfndp+ LEb+ \pf+ 2.
`dd+  %33& A H \ [ p  u R V ] p &  =ijo bm+
o+7 o\pop fjq\n) o+ t+ o`fjqje\ kmd`
k\bjidn+  %36& = H Z  Z H ] V  [ s ] \ Z | Lgb+
Lm\_+ /2)58 02)/6 dm f+  %4-& : P Y s 
.33 h`o\dn kdmh Gm*)
Q PZ  k P T [ H Z &&&, 
om`ed`hn h`o\hn km\ngdifpn kj ]\*
itdjn npo`kdhj %.)/.&+  : V K PU L &
Lgb+ `h+ .0)/4+
0). 1)3.+ =iom\h` kdmhjn I\*
f\]d`e fitbjn[ nftmdpe` %0).6)//&
f\g]\h\ \kd` Fp_j I\f\]d`e\pn _\m*
]pn) qdnp kdmh\ \kd` ej g\dhdib\n

fjq\n kmd` =iodjfj q\_pn) kmd`


=kjgjide %0). ./&) kmd` O`mji %0)
.0/1&) kmd` Lojg`hd`e) Jdf\ijm
Em Cjmbde %0)/2 1)/2&) k\b\gd\p kmd`
Htude %1)/3 02&+ P\n fjq\d g\dh*
epn) Fp_pd k\ndn`f\ npbmod d F`mp*
u\g) \kq\gtod npo`ko ]\itd dm np*
nodkmdiod hd`no %1)033.&+
%0).& 7 V  ] PL [ V Q L &&&  Lgb+ / I\f+

N H Y I PU Z P ,

*+ #+$$ +

%0& 7 P Z  W H K H \ N P U V &&&  06 `dg+ tm\


mdohpjo\n
k\btmdh\n qdn Fp_j
ipq`dfop _\m]p+  8 H PW  T PS m PU H Z ,
f\dk f\mtbdn) i` f\dk k\km\n*

Turinys

45/

. H<F* 0) 1} .0

1 Nbfbebl _Z\mnl ^lm e^hgb bg hi^*  1 NZoh o^bdlfZbl cbl iZlb]ZkiZ*
kb[nl lnbl)


gZnl  ebm
^m lb\nm\Zmnenl e^hgbl kn`b^gl bg bk  cZngbdec ebm) dnkl dkbhdbZ
o^gZmbhg^+
f^]bh]ZfZl+
2 @m i^kl^jnnmnl^lm bgbjnhl i^k* 2 Ebl b^dh]Zoh [^]b^ob bk i^k*
l\knmZgl ^hl7
l^dbhch cnhl)
^m jnb \hgmnk[Z[Zgm ihinenf ]^`bgh eb^ilghfbl mnhl) dnkb^
]knflm ch mZnmhl kZfr[+
lnnf) ^hl ln\\^g]bm_eZffbl7
3 ^m k^inelb lngm bgbfb\b ^bnl ikZ^ 3 Eh  [bch]Zfb ch  g^ikb^m^ebZb [*
`h Zebg8
mbfhk^ ^bnl)
^m hfg^l hi^kZkbb bgbjnbmZmbl\hg* oblb ibdmZ]ZkbZb [noh b`l]bgmb)
mnk[Zmb lngm7
bk`^e[cbfZl [noh ordbgZfZl
ch kZgdZ+
^m ]bk^\mZ ^lm lZenl bgfZgn^bnl+
4 @m ^qZ\^k[Z[Zm k^`^l fnemhl)
4 Ebl ^ksbgh ]Zn`^e dZkZeb
^m eZ^mb_b\Z[Zm DZ\h[ bg hi^kb[nl bk lZoh ]Zk[Zbl ]bn`bgh Ehd[8
ch ZmlbfbgbfZl iZlbeb^dZ iZeZbfbg*
lnbl)
mZl i^k Zfbnl+
^m bg lZ^\nenf f^fhkbZ ^bnl bg
[^g^]b\mbhg^+
5 @m i^kZf[neZobm \bobmZm^l Dn]Z) 5 Ebl ch i^k En]h fb^lmnl) bgZb*
^m i^k]b]bm bfibhl ^q ^bl)
dbgh cnhl^ [^]b^obnl
^m Zo^kmbm bkZf Z[+ DlkZ^e+
bk gndk^bi klmr[ gnh DskZ^ebh+
6 @m ghfbgZmnl ^lm nljn^ Z]gh* 6 Oh]e ch oZk]Zl [noh fbgbfZl
obllbfnf m^kkZ^)
bdb ^fl iZdkZb)
bk cbl lnkbgdh gZgbnl+
^m \hg`k^`Zobm i^k^ngm^l+
Onhf^m <ihehgbcnl lnkbg*
.-
@m \hg`k^`Zobm <iheehgbnl .-
B^gm^l) ^m Z NZfZkbZ obkmnm^f dh iZ`hgbl bk b NZfZkbchl ]b]^*
fnemZf ^m fZ`gZf Z] [^eeZg]nf e bk `Zebg` dZkbnhf^g dhoZb
\hgmkZ DlkZ^e+ .. @m \h`ghobm en* ikb^ DsbZe+ .. NnbghclZib^ mZm
]Zl) ^m ^qbbm h[obZf beeb7 ^m i^k* En]Zl bch cZf ikb^Zbl) lnfn
\nllbm) ^m h\\b]bm beenf7 ^m\^\b]^* bk nfn c8 dkbmh ]Zn` ln^bl*
kngm oneg^kZmb fnemb) ^mk^ebjnb _n* m) dbmb iZ[`h+ ./ En]Zl iZf
`^kngm+ ./ ^m Z\\^ibm lihebZ ^hknf7 c `kh[) iZlbf mZbi iZm <ih*
^m `eZ]bnf <iheehgbb Z[lmnebm en* ehgbcZnl dZeZobc bk gZn]hchlb cnh
]Zl) ^m ^kZm in`gZgl bg^h hfgb* dhohl^ i^k oblZl lZoh ]b^gZl+
[nl ]b^[nl+
Nrkbchl dZkbnhf^gl obkb*
.0
@m Zn]bobm N^khg ikbg\^il .0
^q^k\bmnl NrkbZ^) jnh] \hg`k^`Z* gbgdZl N^khgZl) b`bk]l) dZ] En*
o\n f\m`dqdn+  %1& G Ta Tyh f  _\g( e f\odpjh`mdn qdmdidif\n O\h\mdeje`)
odfmd\pnd\d o\n k\o) fpmn h`o\d \ifn*
Hdo\n $ tm\ ]p_m\pn f\mtbdj q\du*
d\p) =iodjfj k\ndpno\n  F`mpu\g)
_\n+$ Lgb+ L m\_ + .3&35 Of+ ,-&,.5 Ku+
2).1+  %2& : XW \Xi \h 4 tk\ op t_) ]pqj k\nd`gbn np t_\dn g\]\d i`*
fpmd` ]pqj dnd\_e n\qj m`gdbdejn+ hjidf\d+ Ru+ \pf+ .)0-+++  %..&
Jh` hy \e((& Fp_j q`_\hd t_\d g\d*
 < XZ\ab((( Lgb+ `h+ .-)51+  %4&
hej fjq) fpmdje` o\mkd fdop pqj dm
< ThZX_ ^ T eT _\ 4 f\m\gd\pn k\q\_pj*
k\on =kjgjidepn+ Fj f\g\qde\n o`fjd
ojep) ep nfdmop qd`odidifp+  %5& I f'
gl U X 4 i`g\dh`n)) fpmdjn ]pqj mnot]n ipb\gojepd+
%.0& J Xeba Tf( =ijo Bg+ Fpju\kj
k\ndm`dfdh\n+ | %6& @^ \ { X` f c T '
O`mji\n ]pqn ?`g`ntmdejn f\mdpjh`*
^ eT y } \ 4 =udeje` dm i`o Njhje`+
in qdmdidif\n+ Fdn) f\dk dm =kjgj*
%.-& 9 cb_ba\]hf( Fdn ]pqj ntmp

Turinys

. H<F+ 0) .1}/1

450*

obm en]Zl \hg`k^`Zmbhg^f _b]^*


ebnf) ^m ^\\e^lbZf l^\nf) .1 ^m
Zbm7 $AZ\bZf fbab ghf^g) ^m `eh*
kb_b\Z[hk bg k^`gh) ^m ]^[^eeZ[h
en]Zf) ^m ^hl)jnb \nfbilh lngm)
jnbli^kg^[Zgm o^k[nfk^ ` bl +.2@m
ikZ^iZkZobm l^7^mZl\^g]^kngm\nf
^h \ZlmkZ bfibhknf _hkm^l Znqb*
ebZkbb nm _Z\^k^gm obg]b\mZf bg _b*
ebhl DlkZ^e+ .3 @m ZiikhibgjnZo^*
kngm nljn^ Z] =^mahkhg7 ^m ^qb*
obm en]Zl h[obZf beeb \nf iZn\bl+
.4 Pm Znm^f ob]^kngm ^q^k\bmnf
o^gb^gm^f lb[b h[obZf) ]bq^kngm
Dn]Z^7 Lnhfh]h ihm^kbfnl iZn*
\b in`gZk^ \hgmkZ fnembmn]bg^f
mZgmZf) ^m mZf _hkm^f) ^m ghl _Z*
mb`Zmb lnfnl b^bngbh ah]b^; .5 @m
Zbm en]Zl7 AZ\be^ ^lm \hg\en]bfne*
mhl bg fZgnl iZn\hknf7 ^m ghg
^lm ]b__^k^gmbZ bg \hgli^\mn ?^b
\Z^eb eb[^kZk^ bg fnembl) ^mbg iZn*
\bl7 .6 jnhgbZf ghg bg fnembmn]b*
g^ ^q^k\bmnl ob\mhkbZ [^eeb) l^]]^
\Z^eh _hkmbmn]h ^lm+ /- Dilb o^gb*
ngm Z]ghl bg fnembmn]bg^ \hgmn*
fZ\b) ^m lni^k[bZ nm ]bli^k]Zgm
ghl) ^m nqhk^l ghlmkZl) ^m _bebhl
ghlmkhl) ^m nm liheb^gmghl7 /.ghl
o^kh in`gZ[bfnl ikh ZgbfZ[nl
ghlmkbl) ^m e^`b[nl ghlmkbl7 // ^m
bil^ ?hfbgnl \hgm^k^m ^hl Zgm^
_Z\b^f ghlmkZf7 ohl Znm^f g^
mbfn^kbmbl ^hl+ /0 Pm \^llZobm Zn*
m^f ehjnb) bglbenbm bg ^hl ln[bmh7
^m \hgmkbmnl ^lm N^khg) ^m^q^k\b*
mnl ^bnl bg\hgli^\mnbilbnl7 /1^m
i^kl^\nmnl ^lm ^nf bg ]^l\^gln
=^mahkhg nljn^ bg \Zfinf) ^m
\^\b]^kngm ^q ^bl h\mbg`^gmb obkb)

b ]Zl lnkbgdl ikb^ lZol bmbdbf*


c [k bk ln^b`) .1 mZk7 `rlbn
lZn oZk]) b`Zkllbn dZkZerlmc^
bk gn`Zelbn En] bk oblnl ln cnh
^lZgbnl) dnkb^ gb^dbgZ dZkZebZnl
h]+ .2 Ebl ikblbk^g`) bk ln cnh
ch [^]b^ob dZkbnhf^g) `Zebg`b
iZ]ccZb) Zmd^krmb DskZ^ebh oZb*
dZfl+ .3 Eb^ Zmch bdb =^mahkhgnb)
h En]Zl bch cb^fl ikb^Zbl ln
g^]Zn`^ebn fhgb+ .4 =^m iZfZX+
m ^bgZgb cb^fl ikb^Zbl dZkbnh*
f^g) cb^ mZk En]nb7 FZbi f^l
g^`Znlbg`b `Zelbf^ dhohmb ikb^)
mZbi ]b]^e bk `Zebg` ]Zn`r[)
f^l) dnkb^ bZg]b^g ^lZf^ gn*
oZk`bgmb iZlgbgdh; .5 En]Zl mZk7
I^lngdn Zmb]nhmb ]Zn`^e  g^*
]Zn`^ebh kZgdZl) bk gkZ ldbkmnfh
]Zg`Znl ?b^oh ZdboZbs]hc^ b`^e*
[mb ]b]^ebn Zk fZn ldZbbnfb8
.6 g^l gn`ZecbfZl dZk^ g^iZk^b*
gZ gnh dZkbnhf^gl ]Zn`r[l)
[^m lmbikr[ Zm^bgZ b ]Zg`Znl+
/- Eb^ ^bgZ ikb^ fnl ln ZmdZdebZ
]Zn`r[^ bk ln inbdr[^ lngZbdbgmb
fl) fl fhg bk floZb*
d bk fl Zibiemb) /. f^l `b
dhohlbf^n lZoh `ror[ bk lZoh
lmZmrfnl8 //iZmlQb^iZmllnmkbgl
cnhl fl Zdrl^) mh]e cl g^*
[bchdbm^ c+ /0 Gbholbl dZe[mb)cbl
fZb inhe cnhl8 bk N^khgZl ln
lZoh dZkbnhf^g^ [noh lnmkbgmZl
ch ZdboZbs]hc^+ /1 En]Zl obchlb c
=^mahkhgh eZbmn bdb er`nfZb8 Z*

idepn) q`df kmd` npfdgpndpn t_pn


]` tk\odibj =iodjfj n\fthj+ Lgb+
/3 `dg+ ) %.3& 6 R P 0 L [ O V Y V U \ P&  Mm+ o+7
dfd >`ocjmjij g\dopd+  >`ocjmji\n
]pqj f\gipjn`) \kd` .2 fdgjh) d d\pm*
q\f\mdpn ipj F`mpu\gn %kgb+ Fju+ .-)
.-+++ . G\m+ .0).58 0 G\m+ 6).4&+ 
; \ ] H Y N PU [ P W H Z U PU R V &  C\g o\d ]pqj

k\nidifj _d`i\8 ]`o b\gej ]od) f\_


Fp_\n) g\]\d nfp]di_\hjn) i`]pqj k\*
ndhn n\qj f\mdpjh`i`d h\dnoj+ 
%g6& ; L Z  U \ N H S s Q P T H Z &&&  Lgb+ . G\m+
.4)1214+  %/0& 0 \ ] V  Z \ [ Y PU [ H Z &
Lpjgdh\n O`mjipd ]pqj i`odfo\n8 Fp*
_\n bd k\ndodf+j Rd`k\od`n k\b\g]\
%qu+ //& `dg+&+  %/1& 6R P S ^ N \ T H P&  EE*

Turinys

451

H<F+ 0) /0}0/

k^ebjnb Znm^f _n`^kngm bg m^kkZf mnhgb bfmZb c ork dkbmh) dbmb `b
Kabeblmabbf+
iZ[`h c ibeblmbf Ze+
/2 @ m \^\b]bm mbfhk Dn]Z^) Z\
/0
=Zbf bk b`lmbl En]h* bk
_kZmknf ^bnl) ^m _hkfb]h lni^k ch [kheb Zif oblZl mZnmZl Zi*
hfg^l `^gm^l bg \bk\nbmn ^hknf+ ebgdnb8 /3 ch oZk]Zl iZlb^ddZkZ*
/3 ^m i^ko^gbm Z] k^`^f ghf^g eb) bk oblhl mZnmhl iZlZdhchZib^
^bnl) ^m ]^ ikZ^ebbl Dn]Z^ gZkkZ* En]h dhoZl+
[Zgm hfg^l `^gm^l+
/4 Pm Zn]bobm Znm^f k^q <g*
/4 D`bk]l mnhl ]Zerdnl) dZ*
mbh\anl l^kfhg^l blmhl)bkZmnl^lm kZebnl <gmbhdZl eZ[Zb lnirdh+ Ebl
Zgbfh7 ^m fblbm) ^m \hg`k^`Zobm lbngm bk eb^i kbgdmb dZk^bobnlob*
^q^k\bmnfngbo^klb k^`gb lnb) \Zl* lhc^ lZoh dZkZerlmc^) eZ[Zb lmbi*
mkZ _hkmbZ oZe]^7 0/'5/6 ^m Zi^knbm Z^* kb dZkbnhf^g) /5 Zmb]Zk lZoh
kZkbnf lnnf) ^m ]^]bm lmbi^g]bZ b]bg) ]ZodZkbnhf^g^bZe`f^*
^q^k\bmnb bg Zggnf7 ^m fZg]Zobm mZfl bk eb^i cb^fl [mb ikb^ ob*
beeebl nm ^ll^gm iZkZmb Z] hfgbZ+ lZ dh ikblbk^g`nlb^fl+
/6
@m ob]bm jnh] ]^_^\bm i^\n* /6
=^m cbl iZfZm) dZ] ch b*
gbZ ]^ ma^lZnkbl lnbl) ^m mkb[nmZ 8 ]bgl^ mkdlmZ ibgb` bk dZ] Z*
k^`bhgbl fh]b\Z ikhim^k ]bll^g* 8 eb fhd^lbZb f^gdb ]e lnfbb*
lbhg^f) ^m ieZ`Zf) jnZf _^\bm bg  fh bk ]e Zehl) dnkb cbl [noh
m^kkZ) nm mhee^k^m e^`bmbfZ) jnZ^ b iZ]Zkl dkZm^) Zmbf]ZfZl [non*
^kZgmZ ikbfbl ]b^[nl7 0- ^m mbfnbm  lbnl gnh l^gbZnlb ]b^g lmZmr*
g^ ghg aZ[^k^m nm l^f^e ^m [bl) 8 fnl+ 0- Ebl f [bchmb g^mnklbl)
bg lnfimnl ^m ]hgZkbZ) jnZ^ ]^*  dZbi cZn [noh dZkm bk dbm) beZb*
]^kZm Zgm^ eZk`Z fZgn7 ^m Z[ng* u
 ]hfl bk ]hoZghfl) dnkbZl Zgdl*
]Zo^kZm lni^k k^`^l) jnb Zgm^^nf  bZn ]nh]Zoh ]nhlgbZ kZgdZ)mZbi
_n^kZgm+ 0. @m \hglm^kgZmnl ^kZm b dZ] ]nhlgnfn [noh i^kobkbcl
Zgbfh oZe]^) ^m \h`bmZobm bk^ bg 8 ibkf ch [nonlbnl dZkZebnl+ 0.Oh*
K^klb]^f) ^m Z\\bi^k^ mkb[nmZ k^*  ]e cbl [noh eZ[Zb lnlbkibgl bk
`bhgnf) ^m \hg`k^`Zk^ Zk`^gmnf gnmZk ^bmb  K^klbc iZbfmb Zg
fnemnf+
Zeb fhd^lbnl bk lnkbgdmb ]Zn`
ibgb`)
Ebl iZebdh Grsbc) fh`
0/
@m k^ebjnbm GrlbZf ahfb* 0/
g^f gh[be^f ]^ `^g^k^ k^`Zeb) dbenlb b dZkZebdhlbhl `bfbgl)

b\n >`ocjmjij g\do\n ]pqj qdnpjh`o g n\fth\d ej q\g_jhjhn o\pojhn ]p*
qj k\_\m _\pb nphddhj8 _\pb bt*
k\qjedib\n ]b\iod`hn) i`n edn qd`*
ojhdn g\]\d pjgdib\n+ Ru+ Fju+ .-) q`iojep ]pqj k\]b d n\qj qd`o)
fdod ng\knond) o\dk f\_ qdnpn hjf`n*
.-+..+ Pj_g O`mjij f\mdpjh`i i`*
b\gej kmd`diodn) dfd k\nd`f gtbph dpn npmdifod d e ]pqj g\]\d npifp+
\mod P\mk`hn emjn d kd`opn ipj >` oj) =iodjf\n ]pqj dijh\n f\dkj
Fjk`n+
hjbpn) fpmn kdidbp i`o _d_d\pndjhn
%/5& 9 _ZT ` XgT` f( P\dk =iodjf\n dg\d_jhn i`ndb\dg_\qj+  %0.& ,
G X e f \]T 4 kg\o`ni` oj j_dj km\nh`)
ijmejn k\odfmdiod n\p f\mdpjh`in d*
odfdht]7 ]`o ojn \gbjn phjfedhp fdo\dk n\f\io) d fm\opn \i\kpn Ap*
edn qdn\d dopodij n\qj e\p dm ]` oj km\oj) fpmd` opmej hjfod _pjfg Ot*
\kdopo d_+  G e\X i \fT ^ b (((4 e`d mde\d %kgb+ . I\f+ 3)23&+
%0/& @y ^ T eT _\y^ b f\b f Z\` \af( Lgb+
f\mo\dn npfdgop fdojn k\q`mbojn o\p*
/ I\f+ ..).) f\h` =iodjfj nin =i*
ojn+
odjf\n Apk\ojmdn q\_di\ Htude n\qj
%/6& D b ^ Xf}\T \ ` Xa^\((( =iodjfj

Turinys

. H<F+ 0) 0 0 *1 .

lni^k g^`hmbZ k^`bZ) Z _enfbg^


@niakZm^ nljn^ Z] _enf^g <^*
`rimb7 00 ^m nmgnmkbk^m <gmbh\anf
_bebnf lnnf) ]hg^\ k^]bk^m+ 01@m
mkZ]b]bm ^b f^]bnf ^q^k\bmnf) ^m
^e^iaZgmhl7 ^mfZg]Zobm ^b ]^ hf*
gb[nl) jnZ^ ohe^[Zm) ^m ]^ bgaZ*
[bmZgmb[nl Dn]Z^Zf) ^m D^knlZe^f7
02 ^m nm fbmm^k^m Z] ^hl ^q^k\bmnf
Z] \hgm^k^g]Zf) ^m ^qmbkiZg]Zf
obkmnm^f DlkZ^e) ^m k^ebjnbZl D^kn*
lZe^f) ^m Zn_^k^g]Zf f^fhkbZf
^hknf ]^ eh\h7 03 ^m nm \hglmb*
mn^k^m aZ[bmZmhk^l _bebhl Zeb^gb`^*
gZl bg hfgb[nl _bgb[nl ^hknf)
^m lhkm^ ]blmkb[n^k^mm^kkZf^hknf+
04 @m k^q Zllnfilbm iZkm^f
^q^k\bmnl k^lb]nb) ^m ^qbobmZ[<g*
mbh\abZ \bobmZm^ k^`gb lnb Zggh
\^gm^lbfh ^m jnZ]kZ`^lbfh l^i*
mbfh7 ^m mkZgl_k^mZobm @niakZm^f
_enf^g) ^m i^kZf[neZ[Zm lni^kbh*
k^l k^`bhg^l+
05@m ^e^`bmGrlbZl Kmhe^fZ^nf
_bebnf ?hkrfbgb) ^m Ib\Zghk^f)
^m Bhk`bZf) obkhl ihm^gm^l ^q
Zfb\bl k^`bl7 06 ^m fblbm \nf ^bl
+jnZ]kZ`bgmZ fbeebZobkhknf)^ml^i*
m^f fbebZ ^jnbmnf nm o^gbk^gmbg
m^kkZf Dn]Z) ^m ]bli^k]^k^gm ^Zf
l^\ng]nf o^k[nf k^`bl+ 1- @m
ikh\^ll^kngm \nf ngbo^klZ obkmn*
m^ lnZ) ^m o^g^kngm) ^m Ziieb\n^*
ngm @ffZnf bg m^kkZ  \Zfi^l*
kb+ 1. @m Zn]b^kngm f^k\Zmhk^l

452

kibgmbl dZkZerlml k^bdZeZbl gnh


@nikZmh nil bdb <b`bimh ni^b
00 bk Zndemb lZoh lgZnl <gmbh*
dh) bdb iZml ln`k+ 01 EZfcbliZ*
o^] inl dZkbnhf^gl bk ]kZf*
[ebnl) ]Zo cZf lZdrf Zib^ob*
lZ) dh ghkch) bk Zib^En]chl [^b
E^knsZel `ro^gmhcnl) 02 dZ] lb*
lm ikb^cnhl dZkbnhf^g lnmkbgmb
bk lngZbdbgmb DskZ^ebh `Zebhl bkE^*
knsZel eb^dZg) b]be]rmb c Zmlb*
fbgbfh b mhl ob^mhl) 03 dZ] Zi*
`ro^g]bgm oblhl^ c kb[hl^ lo^*
mbfZebnl bk [nkmZ iZ]Zebgm c
^f^l+
04 FZkZebnl8 `b iZlbf ebdnlb
dZkbnhf^gl ]Ze) bch b lZoh
dZkZerlml lhlmbgl <gmbhdbchl
bfmZl d^mnkbZl ]^bfmbl l^imbg*
mZbl f^mZbl) i^klbde i^k @nikZ*
mh ni bk ch i^k Zndm^lgblbZl
Zebl+
05 GrsbcZl bkbgdh b dZkZebZnl
ikb^m^eb `Zebg`nl orknl) ?hkbfb
gh lg Kmhe^fb^c) IbdZghk bk
Bhk`bc) 06 bk blbngm ln cZbld^*
mnkbZl ]^bfmbl mdlmZgb fh*
gb bk l^imrgbl mdlmZgbnl kZb*
m^eb ^bmb  En]h Ze bk chl ln*
gZbdbgmb) dZbi [noh dZkZebZnl
lZdrmZ+ 1- Ob^ bch ln oblZ lZ*
oh dZkbnhf^g^) Zmordh bk lnlmh*
ch ikb^ @fZnlh er`nfhc^+ 1.<g
Zeb ibkdebZb) b`bk] Zib^ cnhl)

bde\n ]pqj kmdotmn f\mdpjh`in q\*


_\n %/ I\f+ 5)6&+ Lojg`hd`epd b\g
]pqj _\m k\q`no\ o\modn np fdojhdn
o\pojhdn %kgb) / I\f+ .-)./+++&+ 
%06& B Xgh e\Tf WXy\` g\f((( P\d ]pqj ]`
b\gj _d_`g f\mdpjh`i) gtbdi\io e
np Fp_j fjqjojep nf\ddphd %. I\f+
0)06+++&+ Gdojfn f\mdpjh`in nf\ddpn+
( % #%%%
%05& G gb_X` \X ( Fdn ]pqj ?`g`* \ ipmj_to\n , I\f+ 5)6) b\g tm\ k`m*
m\diojep fg\_\+  %1-& G e\X = ` Th'
ntmdejn dm L`idfdejn qd`odidif\n) f\*
m\gd\pn =iodjfj g\]\d hbd\h\n fb ( @\]\m edn q\_di\nd =hp\n+ Rd`o\
%/ I\f+ 1)12+++ 5)5&+ Jdf\ijm\n$ ]pqj fjq\d d\ ]pqj i`h\d\p nq\m]d) f\dk
kdfo\n t_p kmd`didif\n8 %=iomjf\n b >`ocjmji`+  %1.& KTea( =ijo ntm+
dd g\]\d ]m\ibdij %. I\f+ 4)/3+++&+ Cjm* $ q`modhj dm Bg+ Fpju\k`7 fje k\idp+

bdhdi\ddp+  %00& O\qj faThf4 fpmn


_\m o`]`]pqj q\df\n+ Lgb+ . I\f+ .)
d d 8  4).1+
%04& x\` gTf(((4 .32 .31 h+ kdmh
Gm+  G Xe T h ^ ygXfa \ f\T f y T _\f 4 f\g*
ipjopn fm\opn \i\kpn Apkm\oj+ P\n
=iodjfj tbdn kg\d\p \km\to\n `h+

2-

Zq+ N\o\n) o+ ER+

Turinys

453

. H<F+ 0) 1/}15

k^`bhgnf ghf^g ^hknf7 ^mZ\\^* iZlbfeZ[Zb ]Zn`lb]Z[kh bkZnd*


i^kngm Zk`^gmnf) ^m Znknf fne* lh) mZbi iZm mZkg bk Zmch  lmh*
mnf oZe]^) ^m in^khl7^mo^g^kngm ordeZl ibkdmb c o^k`bc DskZ^ebh l*
bg \ZlmkZ nm Z\\bi^k^gm _bebhl Dl* g8 ikb^ c ikblb]ch Nrkbchl bk
kZ^e bg l^kohl) ^m Z]]bmb lngm Z] lo^mbf Zeb dZkbnhf^g+
^hl ^q^k\bmnl NrkbZ^) ^m m^kkZ^
Zeb^gb`^gZknf+
1/ @m ob]bm en]Zl) ^m _kZmk^l
1/ En]Zl bk ch [khebZb iZfZm)
^bnl) jnbZ fnembieb\ZmZ lngm fZeZ) dZ] g^eZbfl ]b]cZ bk dZ] dZ*
^m ^q^k\bmnl Ziieb\Z[Zgm Z] _bg^l kbnhf^g ZkmbgZlb  c kb[Zl8 cb^
^hknf7 ^m \h`gho^kngm o^k[Z k^* lnbghch mZbi iZm dZkZebZnl lZdr*
`bl) jnZ^ fZg]Zobm ihineh _Z\^* f) dnkbnh [noh eb^ibZfZ ikZn*
k^ bg bgm^kbmnf) ^m \hglnffZmbh* ]rmb bk lngZbdbgmb mZnm8 10 mh]e
g^f7 10 ^m ]bq^kngm ngnljnbljn^ cb^ dZe[ch ob^gb dbmb^fl7 KZd^e*
Z] ikhqbfnf lnnf7 @kb`Zfnl dbf^ lZoh iZ^fbgm mZnm bkdh*
]^b^\mbhg^f ihineb ghlmkb) ^m in* ohdbf^ n lZoh mZnm bk lZoh
`g^fnl ikh ihineh ghlmkh) ^m o^gmho^l+ 11 =krl lnlbkbgdh)
lZg\mbl g hlmkbl+11 @m \hg`k^`Zmnl dZ] [m iZlbk^g`l  dho) dZ]
^lm \hgo^gmnl nm ^ll^gmiZkZmb bg f^elmlb bk ikZrm iZlb`Zbecbfh
ikZ^ebnf7 ^m nm hkZk^gm)^m i^m^k^gm bk fZehgl+
fbl^kb\hk]bZf) ^m fbl^kZmbhg^l+
12
@m D^knlZe^f ghg aZ[bmZ[Z* 12
E^knsZe `b g^[noh `ro^*
mnk) l^] ^kZm lb\nm ]^l^kmnf7
gZfZ) [^m [noh er` mrknfZ8
ghg ^kZm jnbbg`k^]^k^mnk^m^`k^* b chloZbdg^[nohgob^gh)dnkl+
]^k^mnk ]^ gZmbl ^bnl7
^bm bk b^bm8
^m lZg\mnf \hg\ne\Z[Zmnk7
o^gmrdeZ [noh fbg]hfZ8
^m _bebb Zeb^gb`^gZknf^kZgmbg Zk\^) lo^mbfZebZb [noh iberc^8
m^g [noh iZ`hgb [no^bg8
b[b ^kZm aZ[bmZmbh B^gmbnf7
]bZn`lbfZl [noh ZmbfmZl b Eh *
^m Z[eZmZ ^lm ohenimZl Z DZ\h[)
d[h)
^m ]^_^\bm b[b mb[bZ) ^m \bmaZkZ+
bk g^[^lb`bk]ch m^gZb oZfs]bh
bk dZgdeb+
OZb`b cb^ lnlbkbgdh bk Zmch
13
@m \hg`k^`Zmb lngm) ^m o^* 15
g^kngm bg HZliaZ \hgmkZ e^knlZ*  HZli mb^l E^knsZe^) g^l HZl*
e^f7 jnbZ eh\nl hkZmbhgbl ^kZm bg ihc^ dbmZ]hl rkZ [nonlb fZe]hl
 4 O ]b^gcb^iZ*
3
HZliaZ Zgm^ bg DlkZ^e+ 14 @m b^* ob^mZ DskZ^ebnb+ 1
bngZo^kngm beeZ ]b^) ^m bg]n^kngm lgbgdZoh) Zilbobedh Znmbgfbl)
l^ \beb\bbl)^m\bg^k^f bfihln^kngm Zilb[k lZn `ZeoZl i^e^gZbl)i^k*
\Zibmb lnh7 ^m ]bl\b]^kngm o^lmb* 7 ie lZoh ]kZ[nbnl 15 bkbmb^l
f^gmZ lnZ7 15 ^m^qiZg]^kngm eb[* c  lmZmrfh dgr`Zl) dnkbhl^ iZ`h*
Otm k\ndodfedh\n g\dhod fjq ]p*
qj g\]\d _d_`gdn+ =ijo / I\f+ 5)..
Jdf\ijm\n ]pqj$ k\ndmtn k\m_\qd*
iod k\dhopn i`g\dnqi t_pn g\]\d
kdbd\ f\di\) 6- p qd`i o\g`io\+ 
G e\X \a c e\f\W ]b((( Lmd` f\mdpjh`*
in) \oepndjn d =iodjfdejn) _\m kmd*
nd_ej ntmp dm kdgdnodhp ]md\d+

%13& , D Tfc 4 _\]\m J`]d \hpd)


\kd` 4 fdgjh) d d\pmq\f\mdpn ipj F`*
mpu\gn+ Lgb+ P`dn+ /-).+++ .$ G \m+ 4)2+
E d\ e\p b\gdh\ b\i\ b`m\d h\otod
F`mpu\g+  %15& B h e\bfX c TZ ba l f(((
Lm\nh ` i`qdn\d \dfd+ C\gd ]od) f\_
_\]\m t_\d ]pqj dod`n q+ N\oj
`fu`mikgdjmdp) fpmn ntmp fjfdpj ijmn

Turinys

( ;29% *# + 0$,/

./.

khl e^`bl) ]^ jnb[nl l\knmZ[Zg* u


 grl lm^g`lb kZlmb lZoh lmZ[iZ*
mnk B ^gm^l lbfbebmn]bg^f lbfneZ* gZnf+ 16 Eb^ Zmlbg^ mZbi iZm
\akhknf lnhknf7 16 ^mZmmne^kngm dngb` iZinhZenl) ibkfhg^l bk
hkgZf^gmZ lZ\^k]hmZebZ) ^m ikbfb* ]^bfmbg^l) iZlbdob^m gZsZkb^cnl)
mbZl) ^m ]^\bfZl7 ^m lnl\bmZo^kngm dnkb^ [noh iZ[Zb` lZoh ]b^gZl)
IZsZkZ^hl) jnb bfie^o^kZgm ]b^l7 2- bk Zndlb ]b]^ebn [Zeln c ]Zg*
0- ^m \eZfZo^kngm oh\^fZ`gZ bg `) lZdr]Zfb7 F f^l ]Zkrlbf^
\Z^enf) ]b\^gm^l7 Lnb] _Z\b^fnl ln bmZbl bk dnk cnhlo^lbf^;2.OZ*
blmbl) ^m jnh ^hl ]n\^fnl; 2. ^m oh o^gmho lnfbg]bhmZ bk ln*
lZg\mZ mnZ \hg\ne\ZmZ lngm) ^m m^imZ) mZoh dngb`Zb `^]ne^ bk iZ*
\hgmZfbgZmZ lngm) ^m lZ\^k]hm^l ^fbgbf^+ 2/ mZb iZ`hgrl lnlb*
mnb _Z\mb lngm bg en\mnf) ^mbg an* kbgdh ikb^ fnl fl lngZbdbgmb8
fbebmZm^f+ 2/^m^\\^IZmbhg^l\hg* mn bgZb) d cb^ ikb^ fnl fZgh+
o^g^kngm Z]o^klnf ghl nm ghl 20 FZbi f^l `Zelbf^ cb^fl iZ*
]bli^k]Zgm7 mn l\bl jnZ^\h`bmZgm lbikb^bgmb) c^b mn) h ?b^o^) g^iZ*
bg ghl+ 20 Lnhfh]h ihm^kbfnl ]lb fnfl; 21 Dk cb^ f mkbfb*
ln[lblm^k^ Zgm^ _Z\b^f ^hknf) gb* mnhmb eZ[Zb ldZk]bZb mkbfbmZbl+
lb mn ?^nl Z]bno^l ghl; 21 @m
mn[bl ^q\eZfZo^kngm oh\^ fZ`gZ+
22
@m ihlm aZ^\ \hglmbmnbm en* 02
Kh mh En]Zl iZldrk mZnmZb
]Zl ]n\^l ihineb) mkb[nghl) ^m oZ]nl) mdlmZgmbgbgdnl) bfmbgbg*
\^gmnkbhg^l) ^m i^gmZ\hgmZk\ahl) dnl) i^gdbZl]^bfmbgbgdnl bk ]^*
^m ]^\nkbhg^l+ 23 @m ]bqbm abl)jnb bfmbgbgdnl+ 00 Ob^fl) dnkb^ [n*
Z^]b_b\Z[Zgm ]hfhl) ^m lihglZ* oh d mbd iZlblmZm gZfnl) o^]
[Zgm nqhk^l) ^mieZgmZ[Zgm obg^Zl) fhg) iZlblh]bg orgnh`rg) bk
^m _hkfb]hehlbl) nm k^]bk^gm ngnl* [Zbeb^lb^fl eb^i) ^b]ZfZl lmZmr*
jnbljn^ bg ]hfnf lnZf l^\ng* fn) db^dob^gZf `kmb  lZoh gZ*
]nf e^`^f+ 24 @m fho^kngm \Zl* fnl+ 24 KZldnb cbl iZdbeh b lZ*
mkZ) ^m \heeh\Zo^kngm Z] <nlmknf oh lmhordehl* bk lnlmhch ikb^
@ffZnf+ 25 @m Zbm en]Zl7 <\* . @fZnlh ib^m hg^+ 05 En]Zl mZ*
\bg`bfbgb) ^m ^lmhm^ _bebb ihm^gm^l)  k7 Kkblbk^g`dbm^ bk [dbm^ ]kll
]_p ]pqn did`fdio\n8 \ijo Rpgb\ojn)
ed` d`fje e\h` %b\g f`mp] k\q`dfn*
gpjn`& n\qj no\] k\i\phj8 \ijo
f\d fpmd bm\df+ m\ifm\d7 k\bjitn
e d`fje) f\_ d e\n o`ko n\qj _d`*
q\dd k\q`dfngpn %o\d ]po ]pqn _\m
_d_`nidn q`io fitb did`fdidh\n)
f\dk e np_`bdidh\n&+ Lgb+ 1 G\m+ .6)
.1) Eu+ 04).1+  %16& Bha\Z c T '
chbyT_hf(  Gpidbdfd _m\]pd\d b\g*
ej ]od i`dje\hd odf F`mpu\gn ]\*
itdje`) o\dk k\o kdmhjin dm _`dh*
odin odf o`i b\gej ]od \pfje\hjn+
=ondi`dh\n dq\m_dio _\gtf d I\n*
k) o\dnd e k\mj_th\n Rd`k\dpd)
opmej k\g`ifod ed) f\_ edn bmdio
t_pn d q+ hd`no) f\_ o`i ed` qg
g\dnq\d b\go \ogdfod n\qj m`gdbdejn
k\m`db\n+  E TmTe\X]hf(  Lgb+ Of+ 3)

.0+ G\_\ibd ]\itd\ ]pqj i`kmd`d*


i\h\) i\u\md`e\d i`b\gej \pfjod o`*
i\d n\qj \pfjn8+ Lgb+ =of+ 3)/+ P\d*
bd dm e k\ndmj_th\n I\nkje` opmd
np\_diod Rd`k\od`n b\dg`nodibph)
f\_ npo`dfo ed`hn b\gdht] \odo`nod
n\qj \_pn+  %21& A \ X  `  ge\` \'
ghbg\(((4  \pf_\hd n\qpjndpn d fjq+
Lgb+ Of+ .-)6+
%22& MTWhf(((  Lgb+ Of+ 0.).1+158
. G\m+ 5).18 1 G \m+ 6).+ Ldmhjn f\*
mdpjh`in _\gd`n) npnd_`_\idjn d
.2-- qtm) km+`\fdi nojej k\on Fp*
_\n) fdo\n nq\m]`ni`n _\gdn q`_ ej
]mjgd\d Odhji\n) Fji\n dm Fji\o\n
%. I\f+ 6)03 05&+  %23& B he\X Uh'
i b ^  g\^(((  Pjfn ]pqj no\othj k\*
o\mdh\n+ Ru+ =of+ /-)2 5+ |
 %24&
G T ^ \_b  \y fT i b fgb i l ^ _b f(  Fp_j f\mdpj*

Turinys

455

. H<F+ 0) 2 6 * 1 ) 3

^m ^lmhm^ iZkZmb bg fZg^) nm in*


`g^mbl Z]o^klnl IZmbhg^l aZl)
jnZ^ \hgo^g^kngm Z]o^klnl ghl
]bli^k]^k^ ghl) ^m lZg\mZ ghlmkZ7
26 jnhgbZf f^ebnl ^lm ghl fhkb
bg [^eeh) jnZf ob]^k^ fZeZ `^g*
mbl ghlmkZ^) ^m lZg\mhknf+ 3- Nb*
\nm Znm^f _n^kbm ohengmZl bg\Z^*
eh) lb\ _bZm+
6L[`_ DQ+ . @m Zllnfilbm
Bhk`bZl jnbgjn^ fbeebZ obkhknf)
^m fbee^ ^jnbm^l ^e^\mhl7 ^m fh*
o^kngm \ZlmkZ gh\m^ / nm Zi*
ieb\Zk^gm Z] \ZlmkZ En]Z^hknf)^m
i^k\nm^k^gm ^hl ln[bmh7 ^m _bebb)
jnb^kZgm ^qZk\^)^kZgm ceecl]n\^l+
-  @mZn]bobm en]Zl) ^m lnkk^qbmbi*
l^) ^m ihm^gm^l i^k\nm^k^ obkmnm^f
^q^k\bmnnf k^`bl) jnb ^kZgm bg
@ffZnf+ 1 <]an\ ^gbf ]bli^k*
lnl^kZm ^q^k\bmnl Z \Zlmkbl+ 2 @m
o^gbmBhk`bZl bg \ZlmkZ Dn]Z^ gh*
\mn) ^m g^fbg^f bgo^gbm) ^m jnZ^*
k^[Zm ^hl bg fhgmb[nl7 jnhgbZf
]bqbm7 An`bngm ab Z gh[bl+
3 @m \nf ]b^l _Z\mnl ^ll^m)
ZiiZknbm en]Zl bg \Zfih \nf mkb*
[nl fbeeb[nl obkhknf mZgmnf7jnb
m^`nf^gmZ) ^m `eZ]bhl ghg aZ[^*
[Zgm7 4 ^m ob]^kngm\ZlmkZB^gmbnf
oZeb]Z) ^m ehkb\Zmhl) ^m ^jnbmZmnl
bg \bk\nbmn ^hknf) ^m ab ]h\mbZ]

h`ie` ]pqj opjh`o 3--- hjid)


f\dk k\\dfe\ d odfng`nidj k\n\fjed*
hj / I\f+ 5).3,,(
%1).& > beZ \]Tf cTf\` ((( @d_djed
f\mdpjh`in $_\gdn) k\ndgdfj nojqtf*
gje`) f\di` q\_p ]pqj Jdf\ijm\n+ G\n
k\n\fje\h\ d\ 1).02) m`dfd\ k\gt*
bdiod np / I\f+ 5)/1+++ Cjmbde\n ]p*
qj kmdotmn f\mq`_tn %/ I\f+ 5)6&8
edn odfejnd Fp_\ dbn_dindn+ P \*
d\p Fp_\n b\pi\ did \kd` kmd`*
j nph\ith dm k\on ijmd kpgod i`od*
fo\d nojqtfg+ G\_\ibd Cjmbde\n dm
Fp_\n `d_\hd i`npndodif\) ed` opmej
`dod i` opj k\dp f`gdp+ L\gdfo\n np
f\mdpjh`i` Cjmbde\n ]pqj t_\hn
k\qjedib\n %.5 `+&) o\d\p edn k\nd*

orkZb8 [ndbm^ ikblbk^g` krmkrm


dhohmb ikb^ bmnhl iZ`hgbl) dn*
kb^ lnlbkbgdh ikb^ fnl lngZbdbgmb
fl bk fl o^gmhob) 26 g^l
`^kbZn fnfl fbkmb dhohc^) dZbi
fZmrmb fl mZnmhl bk o^gmhol
g^eZbf^l+ 3- Fhdb [nl oZebZ ]Zg*
`nc^) mZbi m^[gb^+

*  [P]^Vb]TXL^% . Bhk`bcZl
iZlbf i^gdbl mdlmZgbnl ork
bk mdlmZgmb kbgdmbgb kZbm^eb bk
iZebdh lmhorde gZdbZ) / dZ] n*
inem r] lmhorde bk lmZb`Z ln*
fnm cnhl8 fhgl b ibeb^l [n*
oh cb^fl oZ]hoZb+ 0 OZb b`bk]l
En]Zl) Zmlbde ln ]klbZnlbZbl)
dZ] ninem dZkZebZnl dZkbnhf^*
gl ]b]nf) dnkb [noh @fZnl^)
1 g^l mZ dZkbnhf^g ]Zkm^[^[n*
oh blbldbklbnl g^ lmhordehc^+
2 Bhk`bcZl) Zbcl gZdbZ  En]h
lmhorde bk gb^dh g^kZ]l)b^dh*
ch c dZegnhl^) lZdr]ZfZl7 bmb^
[`Z gnh fl+
3
?b^gZb bZnnl) En]Zl iZlb*
kh] er`nfhc^ mbdmZb ln mkbfbl
mdlmZgbZbl ork) g^mnkcnlbg^b
ldr]) g^b dZeZobc+ 4 FZb cb^iZ*
fZm lmbikb iZ`hgbdZkbnhf^g)
mnkcnlb Zkonl) bk Ziebgd c kZb*
m^ebnl) fhg^l bfhdbgmnl dhohmb)

om\pf+ f\d k\h\o) ejb ntm nojqtf*


g\ ]pqj k\dho\ dm Jdf\ijm\n nphp*
o\n #,+&,, `df&+  %/& z ` baf \y c \'
_\X f 4 b\g t_\d \okpjggd\d+  %0& Jh
W ef\Th f\T\f( =gdpude\ d 0)25+  %1&
K T  ^Te\h b` Xa ((( Cjmbdej f\mdpjh`*
in _\pbph\ _\m i`]pqj kdgi\d np*
dq\mfto\ nojqtfgje`) oj_g Fp_pd ]p*
qj g`ibqd\p e kpgod+  %O& : Z T 
ahb `f( G\_\ibd Fp_\n ]pqj np*
nojen e kd`opn ipj ntmp nojqtfgjn)
o\d o\ fmtkodhd Cjmbde\n ej dm d`fj)
) dm opj ]_p edn qdn ojgd\p om\pfd\nd
8 ipj n\qj _d_djndjn nojqtfgjn+

8
%3& EX\ ^T_Ti\] ( Cm+ o+ nf\dojh`
 _\m dpjn j_dpn7 f \ d k  e d `  ij* 
. me ^) o+ t+ ed` i`]pqj odif\h\d \k*

Turinys

. H<F+ 1) 5 * . 6

)*+

ikZ^ebnf+ 5 @m Zbm en]Zl obkbl)jnb 5 En]Zl mZk [nonlb^fl ln cnh
l^\nf ^kZgm7 I^ mbfn^kbmbl fnemb* orkZfl7 I^[bchdbm^ c ]Zn`r[l
mn]bg^f ^hknf) ^m bfi^mnf ^h* bk g^gnlb`ldbm^c inhebfh+ 6<m*
knf g^ _hkfb]^mbl+ 6 H^f^gmhm^ lbfbgdbm^) dZbi [noh b`^e[mb fn*
jnZebm^k lZeob _Z\mb lngm iZmk^l l moZb MZn]hghchc^ ckhc^) dZb
ghlmkb bg fZkb kn[kh) \nf l^* cnhl obchlb KZkZhgZl ln`Znlbg`Z
jn^k^mnk ^hl KaZkZh \nf ^q^k* dZkbnhf^g^+ .- Zndbfl ]Z[Zk 
\bmn fnemh+ .- @m gng\ \eZf^fnl ]Zg`) h Qb^iZml iZlb`Zbelf*
bg \Z^enf7 ^m fbl^k^[bmnk ghlmkb l8 cbl Zmlbfbgl fl mo lZg*
?hfbgnl)^m f^fhk ^kbmm^lmZf^g* ]hk bk lnmkbgl bm dZkbnhf^g
mb iZmknf ghlmkhknf) ^m \hgm^k^m bZg]b^g flZdboZbs]hc^+ ~ Onh*
^q^k\bmnf blmnf Zgm^ _Z\b^f ghl* f^m oblb iZ`hgrl bghl) dZ] rkZ
mkZf ah]b^7 .. ^m l\b^gm hfg^l DskZ^ebh `^e[mhcZl bk oZ]nhmhcZl+
`^gm^l jnbZ ^lm jnb k^]bfZm) ^m ./ No^mbfZebZb) iZde lZoh Zdbl
eb[^k^m DlkZ^e+ ./ @m ^e^oZo^kngm bk iZfZm cnhl Zm^bgZgbnl ikb^*
Zeb^gb`^gZ^ h\nehl lnhl) ^m ob]^* u
 Zbl) .0 bch b lmhordehl  dho)
kngm ^hl o^gb^gm^l ^q Z]o^klh+ [^m bk mb^) dnkb^ [noh ln En]n)
.0 @m ^qb^kngm ]^ \Zlmkbl bg ikZ^* lnmkbfbmZoh mkbfbmn+ .1 OZbi cb^ln*
ebnf) ^m mn[Z \^\bg^kngm ab) jnb lbmbdh+ KZ`hgrl [noh oblZb ln*
^kZgm \nf Dn]Z7 n @m \hg`k^llb fnmb bk [`h  er`nf+ .2 KZl*
lngm7 ^m \hgmkbmZ^ lngm >b^gm^l)^m dnmbgbZb dkbmh oblb ihdZeZobcn+ r*
_n`^kngm bg \Zfinf+ .2 Ihobllb* ]Zb obchlb cnhl bdb B^s^khgnb bk
fb Znm^f hfg^l \^\b]^kngm bg bdb D]nfchl) <shmh bk EZfgbchl
`eZ]bh) ^m i^kl^\nmb lngm ^hl nl* er`nf+ Fkbmh Zg bdb mkbc mdl*
jn^ B^s^khg)^m nljn^ bg\Zfihl mZgb ork+
D]nfZ^Z^) ^m <shmb) ^m DZfgbZ^7
^m \^\b]^kngm ^q beebl nljn^ Z] mkbZ
fbebZ obkhknf+
FZb En]Zl ln`kh ln dZ*
.3
@m k^o^klnl ^lm en]Zl) ^m .3
^q^k\bmnl ^bnl) l^jn^gl ^nf+ kbnhf^g^) dnkb chiZldnbc) .4cbl
.4 ?bqbmjn^Z] ihinenf7Ihg\hg* mZk mZnmZb7I^`^bldbm^ `kh[bh) g^l
\nibl\Zmbl lihebZ7 jnbZ[^eenf\hg* dhoZ ]Zk ikb^ fnl+ .N Bhk`bcZl
mkZ ghl ^lm) .5 ^m Bhk`bZl ^m ^q^k* bk ch dZkbnhf^g rkZ Zkmb fl
\bmnl ^bnl ikhi^ ghl bg fhgm^7 dZeg^8 [^m lfhdbm^ ]Z[Zk ]klbZb
l^] lmZm^ gng\ \hgmkZ bgbfb\hl) ikb^ fl g^ikb^m^ebnl bk gn`Z*
ghlmkhl) ^m ^qin`gZm^ ^hl) ^m ln* edbm^ cnhl) h iZldnb bflbm^ `kh*
f^mbl ihlm^Z lihebZ l^\nkb+ .6 @m [ [^ [Zbfl+ .6 ?Zk En]nb mZb
Z]an\ ehjn^gm^ Dn]Z aZ^\) ^\\^ m^[^dZe[Zgm) mZb iZlbkh] ob^gZ

bdifgpjod+ Fp_j 0--- ]pqj qd`i\ _\*


gdn ej qdnjn d f`opmd\n _\gdn k\nfdmn*
otojn f\mdpjh`in %/ I\f+ 5)/.&+ 
%5& A  W T h Z l U f( Otm f\mdpjh`in
Jdf\ijmj didje` n\gej ]od _\pbd\p
f\dk 1-+---+  %6& I T h W b a b ]b ]X ] '
eb]X((( Ru+ E+ .1)6+  %./& J i Xg\` '
y T _\T \4 ntm\d+ Ru+ / I\f+ 5)//+/0+ 
..2& @^ \ > XmXebah\( @\]\m7 P`g @`*
u`m) \kd` 4 fdgjh) d d\pmn q\f\*

mpn ipj Ah\pnj+  @W h ` ]b f4 d kd`*


opn ipj Fp_ejn+
 9 mbgb \e AT ` a \'
]b f 4  q\f\mpn ipj Fp_ejn) o qdn\n
q\m_dio\n qd`o\n ej _d_`gd f\mdpjh`*
in f`gd\d+ Rtodn o\dk ojgd b\gej odf
f\d fpmd` ]md\d) epj g\]d\p) f\_ Fp*
_pd m`dfej g\pfod k\ndmj_\io Cjmbdej+
#+3$ G T f\e b W  i\XaT WT_\f((( Cjm*
bde\n+ ]_\h\n ojn ipjhjin) f\_ Fp*
_\n opmej k\ndom\pfod d mtop ji`

Turinys

46-

' ? 4 = % *# (&h(/

ZiiZknbm iZkl jnZ^]Zf ikhlib* ]Zebl) ^bgZgmb gnh dZegh+ /- Bhk*
\b^gl ]^ fhgm^+ /- @m ob]bmB hk* `bcZl iZfZm) dZ] ch fhgl[n*
`bZl jnh]bg _n`Zf \hgo^klb lngm oh ikbo^klmb [`mb) bk dZ] lmhor*
lnb) ^m ln\\^g]^kngm \ZlmkZ7 _n* deZ [noh iZ]^`mZ) g^l ]fZb) dn*
fnl ^gbf) jnb ob]^[Zmnk) ]^\eZ* kb^ fZmlb) kh]) dZl [noh ord+
kZ[Zm jnh] _Z\mnf ^lm+ /. Lnb[nl /. OZb bor]) cb^ eZ[Zb gnlb`Zg*
beeb \hgli^\mbl mbfn^kngmoZe]^)Zl* ]h) g^l cb^ iZfZm mZbi iZmbk En*
ib\b^gm^l lbfne ^m en]Zf) ^m ^q^k* ] ln dZkbnhf^g^ er`nfhc^) ikb*
\bmnf bg \Zfih iZkZmnfZ] ikZ^* lbk^g`nl dhoZb) // bk oblb cb^ iZ*
ebnf+ ///
 @m _n`^kngm hfg^l bg [`h  lo^mbfZeb eZndnl+
0
\Zfinf Zeb^gb`^gZknf7
/0 Onhf^m En]Zl gnch ikb^
/0 ^m en]Zl$ k^o^klnl ^lm Z]
lihebZ \Zlmkhknf) ^m Z\\^i^kngm lmhorde`kh[bh) bkcb^ iZf ]Zn`
Znknf fnemnf) ^m Zk`^gmnf) ^m Zndlh) lb]Z[kh) bZdbgmh) ckbgl
arZ\bgmanf) ^m inkinkZf fZkb* inkinkhl) bk ]Zn` eh[bh+ /1 Bk*
gZf) ^m hi^l fZ`gZl+ /1 @m \hg* ]Zfb cb^ `b^]hch ]dhcbfh `b^l*
o^klb)arfgnf \Zg^[Zgm) ^m [^g^* f bk `Zk[bgh ?b^o ]Zg`nc^)dZ]
]b\^[Zgm ?^nf bg \Z^enf) jnh* cbl `^kZl) dZ] ch `Zbe^lmbg`nfZl
gbZf [hgnl ^lm) jnhgbZf bg lZ^* ZfbgZl+ /2 O ]b^g [noh or*
\nenf fbl^kb\hk]bZ ^bnl+ /0/
 @m_Z\* dbgmZl ]b]^ebl b`^e[cbfZl DskZ^*
3
mZ ^lm lZenl fZ`gZ bg DlkZ^e bg erc^+
]b^ beeZ+
Qblb `b lo^mbfZebZb) dnkb^
/3
Lnb\nfjn^ Znm^f Zeb^gb`^* /3
gZknf^oZl^kngm)o^g^kngm)^mgng* [noh bmkd)Zmch bk ikZg^ Gr*
\bZo^kngm GrlbZ^ ngbo^klZ) jnZ^ sbcnb) dZl [noh ord+ /4 OZb b*
Z\\b]^kZgm+ /4 Lnb[nl bee^ Zn]bmbl  `bk]l) cbl eZ[Zb gnlb`Zg]h bkgn*
\hglm^kgZmnl Zgbfh ]^_b\b^[Zm7 b lbfbg) g^l DskZ^erc^ ordhg^mZbi)
jnh] ghg jnZebZ ohenbm) mZebZ \hg* W dZbi cbl ghkch bk dZbi [noh lZ*
mb`^kngm bg DlkZ^e) ^m jnZebZ fZg* c dl dZkZebnl+
]Zobm k^q+
u
/N FbmZbl f^mZbl dhoZb ikb^
/5 @m l^jn^gmb Zggh \hg`k^* K
`Zobm GrlbZl obkhknf ^e^\mhknf c r]nl GrsbcZl lnkbgdh ^bZl ]^*
l^qZ`bgmZ fbeebZ)^m^jnbmnf jnbg* c bfmbl mdlmZgb kbgdmbgb ork
jn^ fbeebZ) nm ]^[^eeZk^m ^hl+ e bki^gdbl mdlmZgbnlkZbm^eb+ /6Eb^
/6 @mo^g^kngm bg Dn]Z^Zf) ^m \Zl* Zmch  En]c bk lnlmhch =^mah*
mkZ ihln^kngm bg =^mahkhg) ^m h\* b
^ l Z g bn l  d Z eg n l) ch  mZ  d kr i mbf b) mZ *
bZ n ) d Z b cbl m^ g Z b b^ d h ch  r ] n ) cb^ 
g ^ eZ n d mn  i n h ebf n  g n ` Z e ch  I bd Z g h k
b k  b l d e Z b ]  c h  [ k b n l +  d R % ((& ,  f i X '
g \ ` y T _ \  _T h ^ h f 4&   i b e b l m b f  N Z e b +
% / 0 &  _T ^ \a g b 4 m Z f l b Z b  f e r g h l  i n k *
i n k h l +  }  A e \a f  c h e c h e b f ( O Z  [ n *
o h  e Z b d h f Z  ` k Z b Z n l b Z +  }  C b U \b 4 b Z
[ n o h  bk eZ [ Z b k^ bd Z ebg `  r ] Z f l 
` b g d e  % /  H Z d +  5 ) / 4 & +  }  % / 1 &  B TW
] \ f  Z X e T f (( (  Q s +  K l +  . 0 2 +
% / 3 &  G e T a X y  C l m \ ]h \(  < g h m  /  H Z d +
5 ) 0 3 )  i Z l  G r s b b  Z m [ ` l  g ^ m  [ ^  i Z *  b

er ] h o  bk I bd Z g h k Z l 8 cbl ] Z [ Z k  [ n *
o l  lbmbd bg l) d Z ]  r ] Z b g ^ g n ` Z ebf b+
}  % / 4 &  : h i b  f T ^ X f + + +  Q s +  Z n d + . 0 ) 0 1  + +
% / 5 &  B \gT \f  ` X g T \f 4 . 3 2  f +  i b k f 
F k+ F Z ]  r ] Z b [ n o h  g ^ g n ` Z ebf b) d Z bi 
f Z g  I bd Z g h kZ l) G r s bcZ l  g ^ g h k ch 
m b d m b +  }  % / 6 &  ,  Ah W ]T ( O b d k b Z n  ` k + 
m +7  D ] n f c +  }  G r s b c Z l  Z m o ^ ] Z  l Z *
o h  d Z kbn h f ^ g  g ^  O Z ki ^ f bh  i Z c *
kbn ) d Z bi  ] Z k  Z g d l bZ n  N ^ k h g Z l ) i Z *
l d n b K mh e^ f b^ cn l ) I bd Z g h k Z l  bk B h k *
` bcZ l ) [ ^ m d ^ ebZ bl  Z g Z i n l  E h k ] Z g h  bk
H b k m b ^ l  c k h l   D ] n f c +  }  : Xg[ b '

Turinys

' > 2 < $ * " ) & # ) .

-/'

\nkkbm beebl en]Zl \nf ]^\^f fbeeb* khg^+ En]Zl lnmbdh cnhl ln ]^*
bfbZ mdlmZgb ork+
[nl obkbl+
FZb cb^ iZfZm `Zebg` dZ*
0-
@m ob]^kngm ^q^k\bmnf _hk* 0-
m^f) ^m hkZobm) ^m ]bqbm7 =^g^]b\* kbnhf^g) En]Zl f^e]lb bk Zd7
mnl ^l lZeoZmhk DlkZ^e) jnb \hgmkb* KZeZbfbgmZl ^lb) DskZ^ebh `^e[mh*
oblmb bfi^mnf ihm^gmbl bg fZgn cZn) mn) dnkl lnmkrg^b `Zebg`hch
l^kob mnb ?Zob]) ^m mkZ]b]blmb \Zl* c` lZoh mZkgh ?hob]h kZgdZ bk
mkZ Zeb^gb`^gZknf bg fZgn ehgZ* Zmb]Zo^b lo^mbfZeb lmhordeZl 
maZ^ _bebb NZne) ^m Zkfb`^kb ^bnl+ NZnebZnl lgZnlEhgZmh bk ch `bg*
0. >hg\en]^ ^q^k\bmnf blmnf bg deZg^bh kZgdZl+ 0. <mb]nhd mZbi
fZgn ihineb mnbDlkZ^e)^m\hg_ng* iZm bm dZkbnhf^g c mZoh DskZ*
]Zgmnk bg ^q^k\bmn lnh) ^m ^jnb* ^ebh mZnmhl kZgdZl8 m^[gZ cb^ ln*
mb[nl+ 0/ ?Z bebbl _hkfb]bg^f) ^m `]bgmb ln lZoh dZkbnhf^g^ bk
mZ[^_Z\ Zn]Z\bZf obkmnmbl ^hknf) kZbm^ebZbl+ 0/ oZkrd cb^fl [Zbfl
^m \hffho^Zgmnk\hgmkbmbhg^ lnZ+ bk gnlf^ed c c`hl ]kl) dZ]
00 ?^bb\^ beehl `eZ]bh ]beb`^gmbnf cb^ ln]k^[m ]e lZoh lngZbdbgb*
m^7 ^m \heeZn]^gm m^ hfg^l) jnb fh+ 00 Inmk^fd cnhl dZeZobcn m)
gho^kngm ghf^g mnnf bgarfgbl+ dnkb^ freb mZo^) bk m^`ne oblb) dn*
01
@m \hffbl^kngm ikZ^ebnf7
kb^ bgh mZoh oZk]) `Zk[bgZ mZo^
^m \^\b]^kngm ]^ ^q^k\bmn GrlbZ^ `b^lffbl+
jnbgjn^ fbebZ obkhknf+ 03 Qb]^gl
01
Kh mh cb^ ikZ]ch dho) bk
Znm^f GrlbZl _n`Zf lnhknf) ^m b Grsbch dZkbnhf^gl dkbmh i^g*
en]Z^hknf Zn]Z\bZf) ^mjnh]iZ* db mdlmZgbZb ork+ 02GrsbcZl) fZ*
kZmb lngm Znm obo^k^) Znmfhkb_hk* mr]ZfZl lZoc [`bf bk r]
mbm^k) Z[bbm <gmbh\abZf) ^m ^e^`bm ]kl) bk dZ] cb^ iZlbkr Zk `r*
fbebm^l) nm fnembieb\Zmb knklnl o^* ob [mb) Zk ]klbZb fbkmb) ln`kh
gbk^gm bg Dn]Z^Zf+
 <gmbhdbc bk kbgdhdZk^bobnl)dZ]
03
?bqbm Znm^f en]Zl) ^m _kZ*
]b]^lgbn ldZbbnfb oe Zm^bm 
mk^l ^bnl7 @\\^ \hgmkbmb lngm bgb* En]c+
fb\b ghlmkb7 Zl\^g]Zfnl gng\
03
Onhf^m En]Zl bk ch [khebZb
fng]Zk^ lZg\mZ)^m k^ghoZk^+ 04@m dZe[ch7 mZb fl g^ikb^m^ebZb
\hg`k^`Zmnl ^lm hfgbl ^q^k\bmnl) lnmkbgmb8 ^bdbf^ ]Z[Zk ZioZermb
^m Zl\^g]^kngm bg fhgm^f Nbhg+ o^gmrdehl bkchlZmgZncbgmb+ X O Z b*
0N @m ob]^kngm lZg\mb_b\Zmbhg^f `b oblZ dZkbnhf^g lnlbkbgdh) bk
]^l^kmZf) ^m ZemZk^ ikh_ZgZmnf) cb^ Zmch c Nbhgh dZeg+ 0N KZfZ*
^m ihkmZl ^qnlmZl) ^m bg Zmkbbl obk* m o^gmrde Zie^blm) Zemhkb ln*
`nemZ gZmZ lb\nm bg lZemn) o^e bg m^im) oZkmnl ln]^`bgmnl) Zn`Zg*
Q s + Z n d + 0 ). 3 +/ 1 + B k + m+ = ^ m l n *  ` ^ l g b  mZ n m^ eb ) d h d bh f bl  r i Z  [ n o h 
k h c ^ +  } * O Z b i  o Z ] b g h l b  l m b i k b  o b ^ m Z  e Z b d h f b  B Z e Z m b c h l )  K b s b ] b c h l  b k  F b e b * 
d Z eg n h l ^  i k b^  d ^ ebh ) d n k bn h  ^ bg Z f Z  b d bch l  ` r o ^ g mh cZ b+
% 0 3 &  A h W T f  \e  ] b  U e b _\T \(((  K e ` +  / 
E ^ k n s Z e l   @ [ k h g +  Q s +  E h s +  . 2 )2 5 8
< e Z d +  . - ) . } 2 8  5 ) 0 - } 0 3 )  }  9 ga Th ]\a g\(
/  F k h g + . . ). + G r s bcZ l ) Z i ^ b] Z f Z l  E n *
] c  Z i ebg d n b) ` Z e g h k ch  Z i ln i mb En *
< g h m  ` k +  m + 7 i Z o ^ g m b g m b +  }  % 0 4 &  t
J \b a b  ^ T _a (  H Z d Z [ +  d g r ` h l ^  N b h g h 
] h  d Z k bn h f ^ g  bk c  o bl  ln g Z bd bg mb+
% 0 - &  > T _\a Z b ]b (' 4  B h e c Z m h +  Q s +  .  d Z e g n  o Z ] b g Z f Z l  o ^ g m r d e h l  d Z e g Z l ) 
F Z k +  . 4 ) 2 - 8  . 1 ) . 0 +  }  % 0 2 &  I \a ^ b  ^ T ' b m Z b ` b  k r m b g  N b h g h  d Z e g h  ] Z e b l )  b P
e X \i \h f (  B k +  m +  d Z e [ Z f Z  Z i b ^  k b g d b f   % 0 5 &  J h Z e\T h gh f ^ T ` U T e \h f 4  l Z g ] e b n l ) 
l Z f ] r m h l  d Z k b n h f ^ g l  ` Z e  b  d Z k b g * b d Z f [ Z k b n l  b k  d n g b ` n  [ n m n l  o ^ g m h *

e b a X (

Turinys

46/

+ D 9 B (  *" ) / # * -

fhgmb[nl) ^m iZlmhiahkbZ ]bkn_Z+ bnl o^gmhkbnc^dkfnl) dZbifb*


06 @m l\b]^kngm o^lmbf^gmZ lnZ) ^m d^ bk dZegnhl^) bkln`kbZnmnl dZf*
ieZgq^kngm ieZg\mn fZ`gh)^m bf* [Zkbnl) 06 cb^ i^kie lZoh ]kZ*
ihln^kngm \bg^k^f lni^k \Zinm [nbnl) kZn]hch `kbZn]bZl kZn*
lnnf+ 1- ^m \^\b]^kngm bg _Z\b^f ]Zl) [k lZn Zgm `Zeohl i^e^*
lni^k m^kkZf) ^m ^q\eZfZo^kngm gnl) 1-iZkinheo^b]n Zgm ^fl)
mn[bl lb`ghknf) ^m \eZfZo^kngm mkbfbmZoh ^gde mkbfbmZbl bk Zn*
dlb c ]Zg`+
bg \Z^enf+
Onhf^mEn]Zl iZldrkork
1.
Ong\ hk]bgZobm en]Zl obkhl 1.
nm in`gZk^gm Z]o^klnl ^hl) jnb dhohmb ikb^ mnhl) dnkb^ [noh ib*
^kZgm bg Zk\^) ]hg^\^fng]Zk^gm erc^) bdb cb^ ZioZerl o^gmZl ob^*
lZg\mZ+ 1/@m^e^`bmlZ\^k]hm^l lbg^ mZl+ 1/ =^mh) cbl bkbgdh g^lnm^i*
fZ\neZ)ohengmZm^faZ[^gm^l bge^* m dngb`) nheb ?b^oh lmZmrfh
`^?^b7 10^m fng]Zo^kngm lZg\mZ eZbdrmhc+ 10 Ob^ ZioZe o^gmZl
^m mne^kngm eZib]^l \hgmZfbgZmbh* ob^mZl bk gng^ lnm^imnl Zdf^*
gbl bg eh\nf bffng]nf+ 11 @m gbl  g^oZkbob^m+ 11 En]Zl `Ze*
\h`bmZobm ]^ ZemZkb aheh\Znlmhknf) ohch Zib^ ]^`bgZfc Znd Zemh*
jnh] ikh_ZgZmnf ^kZm) jnb] ]^ kb) dnkl [noh lnm^imZl) dZl ln
^h _Z\^k^m+12 @m bg\b]bm beebl \hg* cnh k^bdm ]Zkrmb+ 12 Eb^fl Zmch
lbebnf [hgnf nm ]^lmkn^k^gm `^kZl lnfZgrfZl bZk]rmb c) dZ]
been]7 g^ _hkm^ beebl ^ll^m bg hi* dZkmZbl cbl g^[m cb^fl iZcnhdZ)
ikh[kbnf) jnbZ \hgmZfbgZo^kngm g^l iZ`hgrl [nohc lnm^i+ OZb*
been] B^gm^l) ^m ]^fhebmb lngm be* `b cb^ bZk] c 13 bk ln]ch Zd*
en]+ 13 @m k^ihln^kngm eZib]^l bg f^gbl mbgdZfhc^ ob^mhc^ [Zgr*
fhgm^ ]hfnl bg eh\h Zimh) jnh* bhl dZeg^) bdb Zm^bl ikZgZZl bk
Z]nljn^ o^gbk^m ikhia^mZ) ^m k^l* ]nhl Zib^ cnhlgnkh]rf+ 14 KZl*
ihg]^k^m ]^ ^bl+ 14 @mZ\\^i^kngm dnb cb^ f g^mZrmZdf^g)dZbi
eZib]^lbgm^`khl l^\ng]nfe^`^f) gnkh]h lmZmrfZl) bkiZlmZmgZn*
^m Z^]b_b\Zo^kngm ZemZk^ ghonf c Zemhkb) iZgZ  m) dhdl [n*
l^\ng]nf been]) jnh] _nbm ikbnl7 oh ibkfZ+ 15 Eb^ iZmZbl o^gmrd*

kbn h l^+ F  ] Z k [ n o h  i Z ebd  i Z ` h *


g r l ) mZb l n ` k bh o  cb^ f l  i Z eZ g d n l  r *
] Z b+ < i b^  o b^ g h  mh d bn  r ] n  g n l bd Z e*
m ebn  F Z ebl m^ g h  g n [ Z n ] bf  d Z e[ Z f Z  /
H Z d + 5 )0 0 8 mZ bi  i Z m ` kZ bd  Z ebg bg *
d Z l  o r k bZ n l bZ l  d n g b` Z l  H ^ g ^ eZ cn l 
[ n o h  i Z [ ` l + / H Z d + . . )/ 6 + }  %0 6 &
7 P L  W L Y W S s k s &&&  K e ` +  Z n d +  0 ) 1 4 +  }  % 1 - & 
S L U R P w  [ Y PT P[ H PZ &  Q s +  N d +  . - ) / +
% 1 . &  8 \ Y PL  I \ ] V  W PS ^ Q L & Q s +  Z n d + 
. )0 2 + E n ] Z l  g h k ch ) d Z ]  ch  i Z l d bk m Z l 
d Z k bn h f ^ g l  [ k r l  g ^ e^ blmn  ` n eZb b*
^bmb b i beb^ l bk i n emb ] bk [ Z g bn l  i kb^ 
g Z g r bh l  r ] n l + K e` + I ^ ^ f + 1 ). 3 +
K Z b f m b  i beb^ l  cbl  g  g ^ [ Z g ] 8 cb mn *
k ch  i Z lbebd mb i kb^ n  kZ g d h l ^  ] Z k / 0 
f ^ mn l + Q s + ^ f + . 0 )1 6 } 2 . + }  %1 0 &
; \ U L k s  Z \ [ L W [ \ Z &&& 
N n ` kbh o  lmZ[ 
Z n d n k )  c h  Z d f ^ g b l  c b ^  g n g ^  b g ^ *
o Z k b  o b ^ m )  ` Z e  b D g g h f h  l g  l e *

 g b )  d Z f ^  d b m Z ] h l  [ n o h  i Z l m Z m r m Z l 
 Z n d n k Z l  H h e h d n b  % 1  F Z k +  . 3 ) 0 8  / . ) 3 & +
= n o h  mZ bi  i Z m b Z k] r mb d bmb Z n d n kZ b)
e i Z l m Z m r m b  E ^ k n s Z e l  ` Z m o l ^  b k  Z b d *
m l ^  % /  H Z d +  . - ) / & +  }  % 1 3 &  @ Pv S s Q V 
7 H R T L U P Z &&&  N m Z [  Z n d n k Z l  [ n o h  i Z * 
l mZ mr mZ l  o bk n c^  ] ^ ` bg Z f c  Z n d  Z e*
mh k bZ n l ) mZ bi  bk cbl [ n o h  l n m^ i mZ l + F Z * 
U ] Z g ` b  m Z b Z n  c b l  [ n o h  i Z l m Z m r m Z l 
8 Q b ^ i Z b n b )  c h  Z d f ^ g r l  i Z e b ^ d Z f b 
l Z n ` bh c^  o b^ mh c^ + B Z e bk H Z eZ d bcn b
f bkn l r ] n  mZ n mh c^  ] Z k [ n o h  eZ n d bZ *
f Z  g Z n ch  ^ g + O l m+ i k Z g Z h  i Z l b*
b k h ] r f h  % i e ` +  G d +  4 ) . 3 8  E h g h  1 ) . 6 & +
P k bf h  bk mn f bf h  Z g mk h c^  T h k h [ Z [ *
b e b h  l m Z m r m h c ^  [ Z g r b h c ^  g ^ [ ^ [ n o h 8 
b g ^ [ ^ [ n o h  m Z b i  i Z m  b k  l Z g ] h k h l  l d k r * 
 k b b h l +  }  % 1 4 &  u Z [ H [ ^ T H Z &  Q s +  D +  / - ) 
b / 2 +  }  % 1 5 &  = H [ H PZ s  k ] L U [ ^ R S H ,  d Z l 
d [ n o h  l n ` Z ] b g m Z  o ^ g m h c ^  b k  o ^ g b Z n *

Turinys

' > 2 < $ *" * . d +-

-/)

1N ^m Z^]b_b\Zo^kngmlZg\mZ) ^mjnZ^ e bk dZl [noh [Zgrbhl ob]nc^)


48><, /97?7 ^kZgm bgmkbgl^\nl7 bk iZo^gmbgh [Zgrb [^b o^g*
^m ,0/07 ^mZmkbZlZg\mb_b\Zo^kngm+ mhkbnl+ 16 Eb^ iZ]Zk gZnc o^g*
16 @m _^\^kngm oZlZ lZg\mZ ghoZ) m bg] bk Zmg^  [ZgrboZ*
^m bgmne^kngm \Zg]^eZ[knf) ^m Ze* db]) lfbedZe Zemhkb bk lmZe+
mZk^ bg\^glhknf) ^m f^glZf bg 2- <gm ZemhkbZnl cb^ iZ]ch lfbe*
m^fienf+ 2- @m bg\^glnf ihln^* dZe bk n]^` b[nkbnl Zgm oZ*
kngm lni^k ZemZk^) ^m Z\\^g]^kngm db]l) dZ] cb^ ob^lm [Zgrbhc^+
en\^kgZl)jnZ^lni^k \Zg]^eZ[knf 2. <gm lmZeh cb^ iZ]ch ]nhg)
^kZgm) ^m en\^[Zgm bg m^fieh+ 2.' @m iZdZ[bgh n]Zg`Zl bk mZbi iZ[Zb*
ihln^kngm lni^k f^glZf iZg^l) ` oblnl ]Zk[nl) dnkbnhl [noh
^m Zii^g]^kngm o^eZ) ^m \hglnf* ikZ]c+
fZo^kngm hfgbZ hi^kZ) jnZ^ _^*
\^kZgm+
2/ @m Zgm^ fZmnmbgnf lnkk^*
2/
?ob]^bfm i^gdm ]^obgmh*
q^kngm jnbgmZ ^m ob`^lbfZ ]b^ ch fg^lbh %[m^gm dZle^oh f*
f^glbl ghgb %ab\ ^lm f^glbl >Z* g^lbh& ]b^g bfmZl d^mnkbZl ]^*
le^n& \^gm^lbfb jnZ]kZ`^lbfb h \* bfmbl ZmngmZbl f^mZbl cbl Zmlb*
mZob Zggb7 20 ^m h[mne^kngm lZ\kb* de]Zkg^bZnnl 20bk) dZbi lmZ*
_b\bnf l^\ng]nf e^`^f lni^k Ze* mrfZl k^bdZeZncZ) Zndhch ZndZl
mZk^aheh\Znlmhknf ghonf) jnh] Zgm gZnch ]^`bgZfc ZndZemh*
_^\^kngm+ 21 N^\ng]nf m^finl ^m kbZnl) dnk [noh iZlmZm+ 21 Onh
l^\ng]nf ]b^f) bg jnZ \hgmZfb* iZbn f^mn bk m iZb]b^g) dn*
gZo^kngm been] `^gm^l) bg bilZk^* kbhc^ iZ`hgrl [noh c lnm^i) cbl
ghoZmnf ^lm bg \Zgmb\bl) ^m \bmaZ* [noh ZmgZncbgmZl ln `b^lffbl)
kbl)^m\bgrkbl) ^m bg\rf[Zebl+ 22 @m ln dZgdefbl) ln Zkihfbl bkdbf*
\^\b]bm hfgbl ihinenl bg _Z\b^f) [heZbl+ 22 QblZmZnmZ iZkinheZgm
^m Z]hkZo^kngm) ^m [^g^]bq^kngm o^b]h8 cb^ `Zk[bgh bk ehobgh ]Zg*
bg \Z^enf^nf)jnbikhli^kZobm^bl+ `nc^ m) dnkl [noh cb^fl ]Zol
iZlbl^dbfh+
23
<emhkbZnl iZo^gmbgbf cb^
2- @m _^\^kngm ]^]b\Zmbhg^f
ZemZkbl ]b^[nl h\mh) ^mh[mne^kngm o^gm i^k ZmnhgbZl ]b^gZl bk
aheh\ZnlmZ \nf eZ^mbmbZ) ^m lZ\kb* Zndhch ]^`bgZflbZl ZndZl ln
_b\bnf lZenmZkbl) ^m eZn]bl+ 24 @m ]bZn`lfn) mZbi iZm ]dhcbfh bk
hkgZo^kngm _Z\b^f m^fieb\hkhgbl `rkbZnl Znd+ 24Eb^ iZinh [Z*
Znk^bl)^ml\nmnebl7 ^m ]^]b\Zo^kngm grbhl ikb^Zd Zndlh oZbgbdZbl
bh c^  [ Z g r bh l  ] Z er c^ ) _ o ^ g m c  ] Z e
[ n o h  ` k bg mb o blb ch l o ^ g mb ] Z er *
d Z b) o ^ g bZ n l bh cb i Z l bebd h  mn bZ +
K e ` +  /  H Z d +  / ) 1 } 5 +  }  G T yi Xa g\a b (((
K k Z l ebg d n l  er ` bZ b mk ^ cb^ f l  f ^ mZ f l 
i h  mh ) d Z bi  Z g m l ^ g h  ] ^ ` bg Z f c  Z n *
d  Z emh kbZ n l [ n o h  lr k  ln ] ^ ` bg mZ  i bk*
f n mbg  Z n d Z  lmZ [ Z f l) o e [ n o h  i Z *
Z n d h mZ  Z n d Z  mbd k Z cZ f  ? b^ o n b+ /  H Z d +
. - )0  f bg bf b ] o ^ cb f ^ mZ b ` Z e mZ  i k Z *
lf ^) d Z ]  i bkf Z bl f ^ mZ bl En ] Z l ] Z k
g ^ lmh o ch  mZ n mh l i kb^ Z d r c^ + / 2 
^ \f _X i  f g ^ l b h  ] b ^ g Z  [ n o h  ` k n h ] b h

i n l c^  . 3 2  f + i bkf  F k+ < i b^  g Z n *


c  ` b  o s + /  H Z d + . - )0 + }  %1 6 8
z i T ^ \W X 4  l ^ i m r g b h f b l  Z d h f b l +  }
% 2 . &  L { W T a Z T f 4 m b ^ l  o ^ g m c Z  b k  o ^ g *
bZ n lb cZ  [ Z g r bh l  ] Zebf b+
% 2 0 &  B T \c  f gT gl ` T f (((  Q s +  D +  / 6 ) 
/ 5 8  N d +  / 5 ) 0 +  }  % 2 1 &  J h  Z \X f ` ` \f (((
K e ` +  .  F k h g +  . 3 ) 1 / +  }  % 2 2 &  < T a Z h ]X 4
o ^ b ]  bk  k Z g d Z l  i Z d ^ e ] Z f b  b ] Z g ` +
% 2 4 &  J ^ l W X _\T \f (  O Z b  [ n o h  i Z o ^ g *
mbg bf h  ] h o Z g h l+ B Z e mb^ ld r ] ^ ebZ b [ n *
o h  b i kb^  Z mbf mh  ` k h [ bh  ] Z ebl+ } 
% 2 6 &  E h gT e yi f g\(((  K e ` +  /  H Z d +  . - ) 3 +

Turinys

.0+

. H<F+ 1) 25}2) .

ihkmZl) ^m iZlmhiahkbZ) ^m bfih* bk ldr]^ebZbl) iZo^gmbgh oZkmnl bk
ln^kngm ^bl bZgnZl+ 25 @m _Z\mZ dZf[Zkbnl bk lmZm cb^fl ]nkbl+
^lm eZ^mbmbZ bg ihineh fZ`gZ oZe* 25 OZnmhc^ [noh eZ[Zb ]b]^ebh
]^) ^m Zo^klnf ^lm hiikh[kbnf ]bZn`lfh) bk iZ`hgb iZgb^dZ
B^gmbnf+ 36 @m lmZmnbm en]Zl) ^m [noh ZmbmhebgmZ+ 26 En]Zl) ch [kh*
_kZmk^l ^bnl) ^m ngbo^klZ ^\\e^lbZ ebZb bk oblZl DskZ^ebh lnlbkbgdbfZl
DlkZ^e nm Z`Zmnk ]b^l ]^]b\Zmbhgbl gnmZk olmb ZemhkbZnl iZo^gmb*
ZemZkbl bg m^fihkb[nl lnblZ[ Zg* gbfh ]b^gZl lZoh eZbdn dZl f^*
gh bg Zggnf i^k ]b^l h\mh Z mZb i^k ZlmnhgbZl ]b^gZl gnh]ob*
jnbgmZ ^m ob`^lbfZ ]b^ f^glbl ]^bfm i^gdmhl dZle^oh fg^lbh
]b^ghllnebgdlfr[^bk]bZn`lfn+
>Zle^n) \nf eZ^mbmbZ ^m `Zn]bh+
3-
@m Z^]b_b\Zo^kngm bg m^fih* 3- Onh iZbn f^mn cb^ lnlmb*
k^ beeh fhgm^f Nbhg) ^m i^k \bk* ikbgh Nbhgh dZeg Ziebgdnb Znd*
\nbmnf fnkhl Zemhl) ^m mnkk^l _bk* mhfbl lb^ghfbl bk lmbikbZbl [hd*
fZl) g^jnZg]h o^gbk^gm B^gm^l) mZbl) dZ] oe g^Zm^bm iZ`hgrl
^m \hg\ne\Zk^gm ^nf lb\nm Zgm^Z bk g^lnfbg]bhm ch) dZbi dZ][n*
_^\^kngm+ 3
 .@m \heeh\Zobmbeeb\^q^k* oh iZ]Zk ZgdlbZn+ 3. Eb^iZlmZ*
\bmnf) nm l^koZk^gm ^nf) ^m fn* m m^gZb `ne l^k`mb ch bk lnlmb*
gbobm ^nf Z] \nlmh]b^g]Zf =^ma* ikbgh c `bgmb =^mlnkZb) dZ] mZnmZ
lnkZf) nm aZ[^k^m ihinenl fn* mnkm mobkmho mb^l D]nfcZ+
gbmbhg^f \hgmkZ _Z\b^f D]nfZ^Z^+

? 4bAJ 5 >F>?DBE>OM F J P J M  KLDB[ F>DH QIQMN`M N>ON>M!


0>KON :! . @m _Z\mnf ^lm) c
(  KBLMFQLDH >M! . FZbi mbd
nm Zn]b^kngm B^gm^l bg \bk\nbmn  iZ`hgrl Ziebgdnb b`bk]h)dZ] Zm*
jnbZ Z^]b_b\Zmnf ^lmZemZk^)^m lZg* 7 lmZmrmZ Zemhkbnl bk o^gmrdeZ) dZbi
\mnZkbnf lb\nm ikbnl) bkZmZ^ lngm 8 [noh ZgdlbZn) cb^ eZ[Zb lnirdh)

% 3 - &  @ PV U V  R H S U p ,  [ Z g r b h l  d Z b *
g + O Z bi  r ] Z b ] Z [ Z k  ` Z e ch  Z mebd mb
l Z o h  k ^ eb` bcbg ^ l  Z i ^ b` Z l ) g ^ d ebn ] h f b
l r k ) d n k b^  m^ [ ^ [ n o h  i ber c^ + Q b^ mh c^ 
i Z [ ` n lbh  o r kbZ n lbh ch  d n g b` h  H ^ g ^ *
bZ cZ n l  bk E Z s h g h  o r k bZ n l bh ch  d n g b` h 
i Z k ^ b` Z l  i k Z ] ch  ^ bmb Z k [ Z  J g bch * bbb
%/  H Z d +  1 )0 0 +++& l g n l  J g b cZ l  DQ ) Z k *
[ Z  o r kbZ n lbh ch  d n g b` h  i Z o Z ] n h mh cZ l
Z g m k Z l b l  d n g b ` Z l ~ + Q r k b Z n l b h c h  d n *
g b` h  ` Z k [  ] Z [ Z k  mn k ch  m^ d mb < l f h *
g b ^ c  ^ b f r g Z b +  }  % 3 . &  0 L [ Z \ Y H P &&&
[ PL Z  6 K \ T s Q H &  N r k Z b  [ n o h  l b o ^ k  
E n ] c  b D] n f ch l + E Z n  d bmZ ] h l  M h * 
[ h Z f Z l  [ n o h  ln lmbi kbg l = ^ mln k +
Q s +  Z n d +  / 6  ^ b e + 8 F k h g +  . . ) 4 +
2 ). } 3 5 + K Z l bk ^ b d n l  d Z bf r g r l m *
c^  ^ lZ g b c  mZ n m  g ^ i Z eZ g d n f n b r *
] Z f l) En ] Z l  d h o h cZ  i kb^  b] n f cb^ *
bn l  bk Z f h g bm n l  %. } 5 & 8 mn h  i Z bn

f ^ m n  c b l  b l b n g b Z  N b f h g  b B Z e b e b ^ * 
c  bk) i Z ebd l  E ^ k n s Z e c^  E n h s Z i  bk
< s Z k b c )  i Z m l  b ^ b g Z  d Z k b Z n m b   B Z e Z *
g ] h  eb %6 } . 6 &+ N bf h g Z l  g n ` Z eb ` Z *
ebbb^ cb^ b  i k b^ n l  %/ - } / 0 &) E n ] Z l  ` b
bk Eh g Z mZ l  ` Z eZ Z ] b^ bn l  %/ 1 } 2 1 &+ O n h 
mZ k i n  B h k ` bcZ l  g n ` Z eb E n h s Z i  bk
< s Z k bc  %2 2 } 3 / &+ N n ` k l  b B Z eZ *
Z ] h  Z eb^ l En ] Z l  i n h eZ  i b^m  b] n f *
bb^ bn l bk i Z bf Z  > a ^ [ k h g  bk < s h m 
%30} 35&+
% 2 ) . &  8 H PW  [PR  W H N V U ^ Z &&&  = Z g r *
bh l i Z o ^ g mbg bf Z l  bk d n emh  Z mg Z n cb*
g bf Z l g ^ ` Z e ch  i Zmbd mb i Z ` h g bf l 8 r *
] Z b Z mi n h e ebZ b d n k l m  c  g ^ Z i r d Z g m 
E n ] n b bk ch  Z e b g b g d Z f l  % /  H Z d +  .- )
. 2 &8 B h k ` bcZ l ) O bf h mb^ cn l  bk d bmb Z k *
mbf n  d k Z m n  o Z ] Z b bk o b^ mbg bg d Z b l m ^ g *
` lb Z mkZ lmb En ] n b d n h ] Z n ` bZ n lbZ 
i kb^ bg bg d n  %/  H Z d + . - ). 1 8 . / +/ &+ O h *

Turinys

' > 2 < $ +" (d '&

-/+

oZe]^7 /0
1 ^m \h`bmZ[Zgm mhee^k^ `^* / gnlblmZm bgZbdbgmb mnhl b Eh *
gnl DZ\h[) jnb ^kZgm bgm^k ^hl) d[h `bfbgl) dnkb^ [noh c mZk*
^m \h^i^kngm h\\b]^k^ ]^ ihin* i^) ikZ]ch nfnbgmb fhg^l bk
cnhl i^kl^dbhmb+
eh) ^m i^kl^jnb+
0 En]Zl dhohch ikb^ @sZoh
0 @m ]^[^eeZ[Zm en]Zl _bebhl
@lZn bg D]nfZ^Z) ^m^hl) jnb^kZgm lgnl D]nfchc^ bk mnhl) dnkb^
bg <\kZ[ZmaZg^7 jnbZ \bk\nfl^* [noh <dkZ[ZmZgc^) g^l cb^ eZbd
]^[Zgm DlkZ^ebmZl) ^m i^k\nllbm^hl Zilni bskZ^ebmnl) bk ln]Zo cb^fl
eZ[Zb ]b]^b lf`+
ieZ`Z fZ`gZ+
1 Ebl Zmlbfbg mZbi iZm ibdmn*
1 @m k^\hk]Zmnl ^lm fZebmbZf
_bebhknf =^Zg) jnb ^kZgm ihineh f =^Zgh oZbd) dnkb^ mZnmZb [n*
bg eZjn^nf) ^m bg l\Zg]Zenf) bg* oh lblmZb bk iZibdmbgbfZl) mrdh*
lb]bZgm^l ^b bg obZ+ 23 @m \hg\enlb ]Zfb chld^erc^+ 2Eb^ Zilnihcnhl
lngm Z[ ^h bg mnkkb[nl) ^m Ziieb* [hdmnhl^) Zi`ne cnhl) iZlf^k*
\nbm Z] ^hl) ^m ZgZma^fZmbsZobm d cnhl oblZb lngZbdbgmb bk ln]^*
^hl) ^m bg\^g]bm mnkk^l ^hknfb`* `bgh c [hdmnl ln oblZbl) dnkb^
kbb \nf hfgb[nl) jnb bg^bl^kZgm+ cnhl^ [noh+
3
@m mkZglbobm Z] _bebhl <f* - KZldnb cbl ch mhebZn ikb^
kghg) ^m bgo^gbm fZgnf _hkm^f) <fhgh lgnl) kZ]h lmbikb dZ*
^m ihinenf \hibhlnf) ^m Obf h* kbnhf^g) `Znlbg` mZnm bk c
ma^nf ]n\^fbilhknf7 4 ^m \hf* oZ] Obfhmb^c+ 4 Nn cZbl cbl ln*
fblbm \nf ^bl ikZ^ebZ fnemZ) ^m lbkf ]Zn`dZkmdhohl^8 cb^ [n*
\hgmkbmb lngm bg \hgli^\mn ^h* oh gn`Zemb) bkcbl lngZbdbnh cnhl+
knf) ^m i^k\nllbm ^hl7 5 ^m \^ibm 5 Kh mh cbl iZf BZs^kbh fb^*
BZs^k \bobmZm^f) ^m _bebZl ^bnl) ^m lm bk ch ]nm]^kbl bk ln`kh c En*
k^o^klnl ^lm bg Dn]Z^Zf+
]c+
6
@m \hg`k^`ZmZ^ lngm `^gm^l) 6
KZ`hgrl BZeZZ]^ lnlbkbgdh
jnZ^ lngm bg BZeZZ] Z]o^klnl ikb^ `ro^gnlbnl c iehm^ bskZ^*
elkZ^ebmZl) jnb ^kZgm bg _bgb[nl ^h* ebmnl) dZ] cnhl lngZbdbgm8 [^m b*
knf nm mhee^k^gm ^hl7 ^m _n`^kngm mb^ gn[`h  ?Zm^fZgh mobkmho
bg ?Zma^fZg fngbmbhg^f) .- ^m .- bk lbngm eZbd iZl En] bkch
] e En ] Z l  g n lblmZ m  i n emb mn h l i kb^ *
n l) d Z ]  n [ ` mn  n  Z d b  ` k l bZ g *
mb^ f l i Z o h cZ f l +
% 0 &  @ W h ` ]b ]X ( Q b l  i b k f Z  E n ] Z l 
i n h e  l ^ g n l  r ]  i kb^n l) b] n f cb^ *
bn l  % N d + / - ). 2 +++8 @ s + 0 2 ). 2  bk d +&+
< d kZ [ Z mZ g  [ n o h  d Z eg n h mZ l d kZ mZ l
i kb^ F n kd eb  %N d h ki bh g h & Z n d mn f h l)
m^ g ) d n k  [ Z b` bZ l b H bk mb^ l  c k Z  i b^ m 
h g ^ +  }  C T \^  T c f h c 4 g n h D Y Z m  c n h l 
n i n e ] b g ] Z o h +  }  < \W X _ f ` Z (  B k + 
m+ ] Z k  i k b ] m Z 7  i Z ^ f b g h  cn h l  bk  i Z *
f  c  ` kh [ +
% 1 &  : X T a b  i T \^ 4 d n k b ^  N ^ ] L U V
` Z e  m Z k i  b ] n f c b ^ b  b k $ Z f h g b m  b k r *
m n l  g n h  H b k m b ^ l  c n k h l +  }  % +& M \f T \
f h a T \^ \a g \(  @ [ k +  [ X ' V [ X e \ ` (
% 3 &  G e \ X y  9 ` b a b  f a f 4 Z g Z i n l
Eh k] Z g h + < f h g bmZ b [ n o h  mZ ki  d bmZ  

d h  i Z lblZ o bg  i eh mn l Z g Z i n l Eh k ] Z *
g h ) d Z b ] ^ bf ml  Ds kZ ^ ebh  ` bf bg b  [ n *
o h  b o ^ l m Z  c < l r k b c h l  g ^ e Z b l o Y % E^ k +
1 6 )0 &+ K Z l d n mbg bZ bl  eZ bd Z bl) [ ] Z f b
Z ebg bg d Z bl r ]  g ^ d ^ g bZ f h  o r kbZ n *
l bh ch  d n g b` h  EZ s h g h ) cb^  [ n o h  n *
i n h e  E^ k n s Z e  bk b n ]  g ^ f Z Z  ch l 
` r o ^ g m h c  % /  H Z d +  2 ) 2 + + + & +  }  K \` b '
g\X ] (  E b l  b Z  [ n o h  + d Z k Z e b Z n l  o b ^ m b * k 
e b g d Z l +  }  % 5 &  > T m X e \b ( B k +  m + 7  E Z * 
s ^ k b h +  Q s +  E 8+ . 0 ) / 1 + / 2 +  }  A b  W h ^ '
g X e \f 4 f b ^ l m ^ e b n l  b k  N h ] b n l )  d n k b ^ 
i kbd eZ n l  EZ s ^kbn b+
% 6 &  G T Z b a l f  > T _ T T W X  f h f \ e \ a ^ b (((
B Z eZ Z ] n  bZ  o Z ] bg Z f Z l  eZ [ Z b i eZ mn l
d k Z m Z l  Z g Z i n l  Eh k ] Z g h ) mh eb l b^ d bZ l 
c k r m n l  b k   b Z n k +  D l b l d e Z b ] b n l b n 
bZ  mZ ki  i Z ` h g b  r ]  [ n o h  g ^eZ [ Z b
] Z n ` +  }  < T gX ` T a b ( F Z f ^  [ n o h  m Z

Turinys

463

' > 2 < $ + " ''d '/

fbl^kngm ebmm^kZl Z] en]Zf) ^m _kZ* [khebnl) lZdr]Zfb7 Kkb^ fnlln*
mk^l ^bnl) ]b\^gm^l7 >hg`k^`ZmZ^ lbkbgdh b obl inlb iZ`hgrl)
lngm Z]o^klnf ghl `^gm^l i^k dZ] fnl bgZbdbgm+ .. Eb^ k^g`bZ*
\bk\nbmnf) nm ghl Zn_^kZgm7 .. ^m lb Zm^bmb bk iZbfmb oqdmojq) c dnkb
iZkZgm o^gbk^) ^m h\\niZk^ fngb* ln[`hf^8 c dZkbnhf^gl oZ*
mbhg^f) bg jnZf \hg_n`bfnl7 ^m ]Zl rkZ Obfhmb^cnl+ ./ OZb`bZm^bd
Obfhma^nl ^lm ]nq ^q^k\bmnl^h* ]Z[Zk bk `^e[d fnl b c kZg*
knf+ ./ Ing\ ^k`h o^gb)^m ^kbi^ dhl) g^l ]Zn`r[ fl dkbmh+
ghl ]^ fZgb[nl ^hknf) jnbZ \^* .0 Qblb fl [khebZb) `ro^gnlb^cb
\b]bm fnembmn]h ]^ gh[bl+ .0 @m On[bgh iehm^) nfnmb8 cb^ iZ*
hfg^l _kZmk^l ghlmkb) jnb ^kZgm f g^eZblog c iZbZl) oZbdnl bk
bg eh\bl On[bg) bgm^k_^\mb lngm7^m `kh[ bk gnn] m^gZb Zkmb mdl*
\ZimboZl ]nq^kngm nqhk^l ^hknf) mZgbh ork+ .1 ?Zk m^[^ldZbmZgm
^m gZmhl) ^mlihebZ) ^m i^k^f^kngm eZbd) mZb dbmb iZlbngmbgbZb Zmch
beeb\ _^k^ fbee^ obkhl+ .1 @m Z]an\ b BZebeb^chl i^kiemhfbl cnih*
^iblmheZ^ e^`^[Zgmnk) ^m ^\\^ Zebb fbl bk Zmg^ iZgZbbgb) .2 lZ*
gng\bb o^g^kngm ]^BZebeZ^Z \hg* dr]Zfb) dZ] ikb^ cnhl lnlbkbgd
l\bllbl mngb\bl) gng\bZgm^l l^\ng* fhgl b Kmhe^fZb]hl) b Obkh
]nf o^k[Z aZ^\7 .2]b\^gm^l \hg* bk Nb]hgh8 oblZ BZebeb^cZ ^lZgmb
o^gbll^ Z]o^klnf l^ ZKmhe^fZb* ibegZ lo^mbfZeb) dZ] fnl lngZb*
]Z) ^m Orkh) ^m Nb]hg^7 ^m k^ie^* dbgm+ .3 FZbi mbd En]Zl bk mZnmZ
mZ ^lm hfgbl BZebeZ^Z Zeb^gb`^gbl) b`bk]h bmnhl h]bnl) lnlbkbgdh
nm ghl \hglnfZgm+ .- PmZn]bobm ]b]^e ln^b`Z ZiloZklmrmb) d cb^
Znm^f en]Zl) ^m ihinenl) l^kfh* mnkm ]Zkrmb lZoh [khebZfl) [n*
g^l blmhl) \hgo^gbm ^\\e^lbZ fZ`* onlb^fl lb^eoZkm^ bk Zg fhgb
gZ \h`bmZk^ jnb] _Z\^k^gm _kZmkb* ninemb^fl+
[nl lnbl)jnb bgmkb[neZmbhg^ ^kZgm)
^m ^qin`gZ[Zgmnk Z[ ^bl+
Onhf^m En]Zl mZk lZoh
.4
?bqbmjn^ en]Zl Nbfhgb_kZ* .4
mkb lnh7 @eb`^ mb[b obkhl) ^m oZ]^) [khebnb Nbfhgnb7 KZlbkbgd lZn or*
^m eb[^kZ _kZmk^l mnhl bg BZebeZ^Z7 k) ^bd bk `^e[d lZoh [khebnlBZ*
^`h Znm^f) ^m _kZm^k f^nl DhgZ* ebechc^) Z `b bk fZgh [khebl Eh*
maZl b[bfnl bg BZeZZ]bmbf+ .N @m gZmZl ^blbf^ c BZeZZ]h Ze+ .NEbl
k^ebjnbm Dhl^ianf _bebnf TZ\aZ* iZebdh mZnmhl oZ]nl TZdZkbch l*
kbZ^) ^m <sZkbZf]n\^l ihineb\nf g EnhsZi bk <sZkbc ln ebdnlbZ
k^lb]nh ^q^k\bmn bg Dn]Z^Z Z]\n* dZkbnhf^g^ En]chc^ chl lZn`hmb
lmh]bZf7 .6 ^m ikZ^\^ibm beebl) ]b* .6 bk ]Zocb^fl mhdlZdrf7 =*
\^gl7 KkZ^^lmhm^ ihineh anb\7 ^m dbm^ bmhl mZnmhl obkbgbgdZbl bk
ghebm^ [^eenf \hffbmm^k^ Z]o^k* g^ikZ]dbm^ dhohl ikb^ iZ`hgbl)
ln lmbi kbg mZ  o b^ mZ ) mbd kZ b) g ^ bg h f Z +
< g h m  / 5  ^be+) cb m n k ch  [ mb g ^ eZ [ Z b
m h e b  g n h  = h l h k h +  }  % . . &  K \` b g \X ]h f (
< k  cbl [ n o h  mZ l  i Z m Z l f n h ) d n k l  i Z *
f bg mZ l  Z n d + 3  ^bd ) g ^ o bl Z b Z b d n + K e` +
/  H Z d +  . - )/ 1 +++8 . / ). 5 +++
% . 0 &  K h U \a b (
B Z e mZ  i Z mb o b^mZ ) d n kb d bmn k o Z ] b*
g Z f Z  O h [ n ) < kZ [ bch l  mr k n f h c^  i kb^
B Z eZ Z ] h  l b^ g h l + K e` * O ^ bl + . . )0 } 2 8

/  F Z k + . - )3 8 /  H Z d + . / ). 4 + }  %. 2 &
G g b _ X ` T \ W b f (  N ^ g h o l  y < d d h 
i kb^
O Z k i ^ f l  c kh l Z n d bZ n  F Z kf ^ ebh 
d Z e g +  Q Z +  O ^ b l +  . ) 0 . +  } b K \ e b  \e  J \ '
W b a b ( N ^ g b  K ^ g b d b c h l  f b ^ l m Z b +  }  Q b *
l Z  > T _ \ _ \ X ] T  X f T a g \(((  < g h m  ` k +  m + 7  b 
o bl h l  i Z ` h g b  B Z ebeb^ ch l+
% . N &  A h b m T c T  \e  9 m T e \ ] (  D  d b *
mn k g ^ bg h f b Z l f ^ g r l +

Turinys

. H<F+ 2) /-}/0

464

lnf `^gm^l) ]hg^\ k^o^kmZfnk+ bdb f^l ln`kbf^+ /- Nbfhgnb


/- @m iZkmbmb lngm Nbfhgb obkb mkbZ [noh iZldbkmZ mkrlmdlmZgbZb or*
fbeebZ) nm bk^m bgBZebeZ^Zf7 en]Z^ k) dZ] ^bm  BZebeb^c) En]nb
Znm^f h\mh fbeebZ bg BZeZZ]bmbf+ `b Zlmnhgb mdlmZgbZb c BZeZZ]+
NbfhgZl bch  BZebeb^cbk
/.
@m Z[bbm Nbfhg bg BZebeZ^* /.
Zf) ^m \hffblbm ikZ^ebZ fnemZ dhohch ]Zn` dZkm ikb^ iZ`h*
\nf `^gmb[nl7 ^m \hgmkbmZ^ lngm gbl8 iZ`hgrl ch ZdboZbs]hc^ [n*
`^gm^l Z _Z\b^ ^bnl) ^m i^kl^\n* oh lnmkbgmb) bk cbl obchlb cnhl bdb
mnl ^lm ^hl nljn^ Z] ihkmZf Kmhe^fZb]hl oZkm8 // Zib^ mkbl
// Kmhe^fZb]bl7 ^m \^\b]^kngm ]^ mdlmZgbnl iZ`hgb dkbmh) bk cbl
`^gmb[nl _^k^ mkbZ fbeebZ obkhknf) iZf c `kh[+ /0 KZldnb cbliZ*
^m Z\\^ibm lihebZ ^hknf) /
'0' ^m Zl* lbf ln lZobf mnhl) dnkb^ [n*
.
lnfilbm ^hl) jnb ^kZgm bg BZeb* oh BZebeb^chc^ bk <k[Zm^)ln ciZ*
eZ^Z) ^m bg <k[Zmbl \nfnqhkb[nl) bhfbl) oZbdZbl bk ln obln) dZl
^m gZmbl) ^m hfgb[nl) jnZ^ ^kZgm cb^fl ikbdeZnl) bk Zmlbo^] cnhl
beebl) ^m Z]nqbm bg en]Z^Zmg \nf ln ]b]^ebn ]bZn`lfn  En]c+
eZ^mbmbZ fZ`gZ+
En]Zl `b HZdZ[b^cnl bk ch
/1
@m en]Zl HZ\aZ[Z^nl8 ^m /1
DhgZmaZl _kZm^k ^bnl mkZglb^kngm [khebl EhgZmZl i^kch i^k Ehk]Z
Dhk]Zg^f) ^m Z[b^kngm obZf mkbnf g bk ch mkbl ]b^gZl mrkZbl+ /2Enhl
]b^knf i^k ]^l^kmnf+ /2'@m h\\nk* lnmbdh gZ[nmb^bZb bk ikbfcnhl
k^kngm ^bl IZ[nmaZ^b) ^m lnl\^* mZbdbZb+ Eb^ iZiZlZdhch cb^fl oblZ)
i^kngm ^hl iZ\b_b\^) ^m gZkkZo^* dZl [noh Zmlbmbd c [khebZflBZ*
kngm ^bl hfgbZ) jnZ^ Z\\b]^kZgm eZZ]h Zerc^) /%b bk dZ] ]Zn` c
_kZmkb[nl ^hknf bg BZeZZ]bmb]^) rkZ n]Zkrm =ZkZlhc^) =hlhk^)
/3 ^mjnbZ fnemb ^q ^bl \hfik^a^g* <ebfc^) FZlihk^) HZ`^m^ bk FZk*
lb lngm bg =ZkZlZ) ^m= hlhk) ^m bg gZbf^) dnkb^ oblb [noh lnlmbikbgmb
<ebfbl) ^m bg >Zlihk) ^m HZ`^ma) bk ]b]^eb fb^lmZb8 /4 dZ] bk dbmnh*
^m >ZkgZbf7 aZ^ hfg^l \bobmZm^l l^ BZeZZ]h Zeb^l fb^lmnhl^ rkZ
fngbmZ^) ^m fZ`gZ^+ /4 N^] ^m bg eZbdhfZ c n]Zkrm) dZ] krmhc
\^m^kbl \bobmZmb[nl BZeZZ]bmb]bl m^* gnmZkmZ ^bmb ln dZkbnhf^g^ ikb^
g^gmnk \hfik^a^glb) ^m bg \kZl* m fb^lm) iZbfmb cnhl bk ob^gZ
mbgnf \hglmbmn^kngm Z]fho^k^ ]b^gZ cnhl lngZbdbgmb+ /N Onhf^m
^q^k\bmnf \bobmZmb[nlabl) ^m \hf* En]Zl ln dZkbnhf^g^ fZb iZ*
ik^a^g]^k^) ^m mhee^k^ ^hl bgngZ
]b^+ /5 @m \hgo^kmbm en]Zl)^m^q^k*
\bmnl ^bnl) obZf bg ]^l^kmnf =h*
% / . &  @ ^ \ G g b _ X ` T \ W b f  i T e g ( < i *
` n emb bmh l r f bh l  mo bkmh o l ln  l Z o h
f Z Z  d Z k bn h f ^ g ^  N bf h g Z l  g ^ ` Z e ch +
*  % / 0 &  9 e U T gX ( E h  o b ^ m Z  g ^ b g h f Z + 
 % A W \ T (  O b d  b Z  c b ^  [ n o h  Z i *
lZ n ` h mb g n h  i Z ` h g b  d ^ kmh 8 H Z d Z *
[ b^ cZ f l  ` b cb^  ` Z e ch  [ mb i Z li bkmbl)
i Z ] Z n ` bg ] Z f b c  d Z k bn h f ^ g l  l d Z b b +
% / 2 &  E T U h g \X } \T \(  Q s +  K k Z ] +  / 2 ) . 0 +
O Z  [ Z lm g  mZ n m^e ] Z g bZ n  ` r o ^ g h
l^ g h o bg l D] n f ch l lh lmbg l K ^ mkh l
Z i r b b g d l ^ 8 [ ^ m  ] Z [ Z k  cb l n m b g d Z f Z  B Z *

u
u
D
D

E

e Z Z ] ^ +  }  % / 3 &  : T e T f b ] X &  : b f b e X (( ( 
B Z eZ Z ] h  Z eb^ l f b^ lmZ b+ E  o Z k] Z b
kZ h f b eZ [ Z b g ^ o b^ g h ] Z b) mh ] e g ^e^ g *
` o Z  ln l^d mb) d n kbn h l l ^ g h o l  f b^ l*
m n l  c b ^  Z m Z m b g d Z +  }  % / 5 &  ,  : b f b e b ( ((  B Z e 
] Z [ Z kmbg bl f b^lm^ ebl = n l k  i kb^ G ^ *
] h l  Z n d m n f h l + F Z ] Z g ` b  E n ] Z l  b
bmh l o b^ mh l i Z lb^d bZ  i ^ k o b^ g  g Zd m
? Z m ^ f ) mh ] e bk ? Z m ^ f h l  mo bkmh o )
b d n k bh l  r ] Z b Z n d l bY  i Z ` Z e[ h l 
%Z n d + 6 +. -  ^ bd &) mn k ch  [ mb g ^ eZ [ Z b
m h e b  g n h  = h l h k h +  }  % / 6 &  @ ^ \  g i \e g b '

Turinys

-/.

' > 2 < $ +" ( / d )/

lhk k^i^gm^) ^m h\\niZobm \bobmZ*


m^f7 ^m h\\b]bm hfg^f fZl\nenf
bg hk^ `eZ]bb) ^m Z\\^ibm hfgbZ
lihebZ ^hknf) ^m ln\\^g]bm ^Zf
b`gb+ /6 @m lnkk^q^kngmbg]^ gh\m^)
^m b[Zgm nljn^ Z] fngbmbhg^f+
0- @m _Z\mnf ^lm ]ben\neh) \nf
^e^oZll^gm h\nehl lnhl) ^\\^ ih*
inenl fnemnl) \nbnl ghg^kZmgn*
f^knl) ihkmZgm^l l\ZeZl) ^m fZ*
\abgZl nm \hfik^a^g]^k^gm fn*
gbmbhg^f) ^m ^qin`gZk^gm ^hl+
0. @m ob]bm en]Zl) jnbZ \h^ibm [^e*
enf) ^m \eZfhk [^eeb Zl\^g]bm Z]
\Z^enf lb\nm mn[Z) c^m \eZfhk
fZ`gnl ]^ \bobmZm^7 0/ ^m ]bqbm
^q^k\bmnb lnh7 Kn`gZm^ah]b^ ikh
_kZmkb[nl o^lmkbl+ 00 @m o^gbm mkb*
[nl hk]bgb[nl ihlm ^hl) ^m^q\eZ*
fZo^kngm mn[bl) ^m \eZfZo^kngm
bg hkZmbhg^+ 01 @m \h`gho^kngm
\ZlmkZ Obfhma^b jnbZ HZ\aZ[Z^nl
^lm) ^m k^_n`^kngm Z _Z\b^ ^bnl7^m
i^k\nll^kngm ^hl ieZ`Z fZ`gZ)
^m \^\b]^kngm ^q ^bl bg ]b^ beeZ
_^k^ h\mh fbeebZ obkhknf+ 02 @m
]bo^kmbm en]Zl bg HZliaZ) ^m ^q*
in`gZobm) ^m \^ibm ^Zf7 ^m h\\b*
]bm hfg^f fZl\nenf ^bnl) ^m
lnfilbm lihebZ ^bnl) ^m ln\\^g*
]bm ^Zf b`gb+ 03 Dg]^ i^kk^qbm) ^m
\^ibm >Zl[hg) ^m HZ`^ma) ^m =h*
lhk) ^m k^ebjnZl \bobmZm^l BZeZZ*
]bmb]bl+ 04 Khlm aZ^\ Znm^f o^k[Z
\hg`k^`Zobm Obfhma^nl ^q^k\bmnf
Zebnf) ^m\ZlmkZ ihlnbm\hgmkZ MZ*
iahg mkZgl mhkk^gm^f+ 05 @m fb*
lbm en]Zl li^\neZkb ^q^k\bmnf7 ^m
k^gng\bZo^kngm ^b) ]b\^gm^l7 LnbZ $
\hgo^g^kngm Z] ^nf hfg^l `^g*
m^l) jnZ^ bg \bk\nbmn ghlmkhlngm)
^q^k\bmnl fnemnl gbfbl7 06^m<kZ*

lndh  =hlhkh mrknf bk iZf


fb^lm+ Ebl nfn oblnl orkb*
dbnl dZeZobch Zf^gbfbl) iZf
obl c `kh[ bk ln]^`bgh fb^lm+
/6 D m^g cb^ iZdbeh gZdbZ bkgn*
ch bdb mobkmho^b+ 0- <nmZgm) iZ*
de lZoh Zdbl) mZb cb^ iZfZm
]Zn`r[ fhgb) dnkb^fl g^[n*
oh ldZbbZnl8 cb^g^ dhibZl bk
dZkh iZ[denl mobkmho^b iZbfmb
bk gn`Zemb r]Zfl+ 0. En]Zl) iZ*
fZml) dZ] dhoZikZlb]ch bk dZ]
dZkh ZndlfZl dreZ c ]Zg`dZbi
mkbfbmh `ZklZl bk `bk]blb ]b]^ebl
ZndlfZl b fb^lmh) 0/ mZk lZ*
oh dZkbnhf^g^b7 Fhohdbm^ bZg*
]b^g n lZoh [khebnl+00 Ebl inh*
e cnhl mkbfbl [kbZbl b niZdZ*
ebh8 [^ mh)r]Zbf mkbfbmnhmb mkb*
fbmZbl bk `ZklbZb Znd f^el]Z*
fb^l+ 01 Obfhmb^cZnl dZkbnhf^g
iZbgh) dZ] mZb [noh HZdZ[b^cnl)
bkf[`mb gnh c o^b]h8 r]Zb
ln]Zo cb^fl eZ[Zb ]b]^e lf`)
bk m ]b^g dkbmh b c Zib^ Zmnh*
gbl mdlmZgbnl ork+ 02 Kh mh
En]Zl iZlndh  HZli) inhe bk
iZf c) nfn oblnl chl or*
kbdbnl) iZf chl `kh[ bkln]^*
`bgh c) 03 D m^g cbl chmhebZn bk
iZf FZl[hg) HZ`^m) =hlh*
k bk dbmnl BZeZZ]h Zeb^l f b^l*
mnl+ 04 Kh m ordb Obfhmb^cnl
lnkbgdh dbm dZkbnhf^g bk ln*
lmhch mb^l MZihgn ZgZinl ni^ebh+
05 En]Zl blbngm Zibkmb mhl dZ*
kbnhf^gl) bk cZf [noh ikZg^mZ
bk iZlZdrmZ7 Kkb^ ch lnlbkbgdhob*
lhl mZnmhl) dnkbhl rkZ Ziebgd fnl)
eZ[Zb `Znlbg`Z dZkbnhf^g8 06cb^

] L P ,  b d b  ? Z m ^ f Z b +  }  % 0 2 &  ,  : H Z W p ,
b B Z e Z Z ] h  H Z l i +  Q s +  K k Z ] +  0 . ) 1 6 8 
O ^ b l +  . . ) / 6 +  }  % 0 3 &  B T f U b a ( B k +  m + 7 
> a Z li a h k+ O bd kbZ n lbZ b mZ l i Z m f b^ l*
m Z l )  d  b k  Z n d +  / 3  ^ b e +  }  % 0 4 &  A P L l 
I T c b a h 4 g ^ m h e b  g n h  < l m Z k h m h + 
En ] h

lnf
oh
gh
h f
En ]
c )

Turinys

n mZ l) O bf h mb^ cn l ln kbg d h  bZ  l Z *


d Z k bn h f ^ g l  ebd n bn l bk l n l mbi kb*
b Z  m Z e d b g b g d Z b l +  }  B W L S PV , C b ^ * 
Z d l h +  }  % 0 6 &  A \ X ` f  W Y P L k H P Z & I h k l 
Z l  ch  i Z ld n b l n f n m  O bf h mb^ *
[ ^m) g h k ] Z f Z l  i Z mbd kbg mb eZ bf *

' > 2 < $ + " * & d *,

-//!

[Zl \hg]nq^kngmbg Znqbebnflb[b) c  rkZ iZlblZf] lZn iZ`Ze[hg mZbi


^m \ZlmkZ ihln^kngm mkZglmhkk^g* c  iZm ZkZ[nl bk lnlmhchZgZinlni^*
m^f) iZkZmb Z] m^ o^gbk^ bg ikZ^* b ebh) ikblbk^g` Zm^bmb dhohmb ikb^
ebnf+ @m Z[bbm en]Zl h[obZf beebl+ u
 mZo^+ Onhf^m En]Zl gnch cb^fl
1- @m Zbm Obfhma^nl ikbg\bib[nl c  ikb^Zbl+ 1- Obfhmb^cnl `b mZklZ*
^q^k\bmnl lnb7 >nfZiikhibgjnZ* c oh dZkbnhf^gl oZ]Zfl7 FZb En*
o^kbm en]Zl) ^m ^q^k\bmnl ^bnl Z] c ]Zl bk ch dZkbnhf^g ikblbZkmbgl
mhkk^gm^f ZjnZ^7 lb mkZglb^kbm Z] c ikb^ ni^ebh oZg]^gl) c^bcbl i^k^bl
ghl ikbhk) ghg ihm^kbfnl lnlmb* ikb^ fl ibkfZl) f^l g^`Zelb*
g^k^ ^nf7 jnbZ ihm^gl ihm^kbmZ]* b f^ cZf iZlbikb^bgmb) g^lcbl [nl
o^klnf ghl+ 1. lb o^kh mbfn^kbm  lmbik^lgbln fnl+ 1.=^mc^b cbl [b*
mkZglbk^) ^m ihln^kbm \ZlmkZ ^qmkZ c chl i^k^bmb bk lnlmhl ZgZinl ni^*
_enf^g) mkZgl_k^m^fnl Z] ^hl) ^m c ebh) i^k^bdbf^ f^l ikb^c) bk f^l
ihm^kbfnl Z]o^klnl beenf+ 1/ Pm  [lbf^ `Zebg`^lgb n c+ 1/ OZb*
Znm^f ZiikhibgjnZobm en]Zl Z] `b dZbi mbd En]Zl ikblbZkmbgh ikb^
mhkk^gm^f ZjnZ^) lmZmnbm l\kb[Zl u
 ni^ebh oZg]^gl) cbl iZlmZmmZnmhl
ihineb l^\nl mhkk^gm^f) ^m fZg*  kZmbgbgdnl ikb^ ni^ebh bk ]Zo
]Zobm ^bl) ]b\^gl7 I^fbg^f ah* c cb^fl mhdlZdrf7 I^iZebdbm^ g
fbgnf k^ebjn^kbmbl7 l^] o^gbZgm . ob^gh fh`Znl) [^m m^`ne oblb ^b*
hfg^l bg ikZ^ebnf+ 10 @m mkZgl* c gZ  dho+ 10 Kh mh cbl i^kch i^k
_k^mZobm Z] beehl ikbhk) ^m hfgbl  oZg]^g ibkfZl bk oblZ mZnmZ iZ*
ihinenl ihlm ^nf) ^m \hgmkbmZ^ c ldnb c+ Qblb iZ`hgrl [noh ln*
lngm hfg^l `^gm^l Z_Z\b^ ^hknf) fnmb c ZdboZbs]hc^) iZf^m lZ*
^m ikhb^\^kngm ZkfZ lnZ) ^m _n* oh `bgdenl bk iZ[`h  o^gmrd*
`^kngm Z] _Zgnf) jnh] ^kZm bg e) [nonlb FZkgZbf^+ 11 =^m cbl
>ZkgZbf+ 11 @m h\\niZobm bilZf iZfm fb^lmbk ln]^`bgho^g*
\bobmZm^f) ^m _Zgnf ln\\^g]bmb`* mrde) ln oblZbl chc^ [nonlbZbl+
gb \nf hfgb[nl) jnb ^kZgm bg bi* OZbi FZkgZbfZl [noh gn`ZemZl
lh7 ^m hiik^llZ ^lm >ZkgZbf) ^m bk g^`Zech eZbdrmbl ikb^ En]+
ghg ihmnbm lnlmbg^k^ \hgmkZ _Z* 12 Onhf^m En]Zl lnkbgdh oblnl
\b^f Dn]Z^+ 12 @m \hg`k^`Zobm en* bskZ^ebmnl) [nonlbnl JZeZZ]^)gnh
]Zl ngbo^klhl DlkZ^ebmZl) jnb ^kZgm fZbZnlbh bdb ]b]bZnlbZf) ciZ*
bg JZeZZ]bmb]^) Z fbgbfh nljn^ bZl bk oZbdnl bk eZ[Zb ]b]^e dZ*
Z] fZqbfnf) ^m nqhk^l ^hknf) kbnhf^g) dZ] cb^ ^bm En]h Ze+
^m gZmhl) ^m ^q^k\bmnf fZ`gnf
oZe]^ nm o^gbk^gm bg m^kkZf en]Z+
13
@m o^g^kngm nljn^ @iakhg7 1= Eb^ Zmch bdb @_khgnb+ OZb
^m aZ^\ \bobmZl fZ`gZ bg bg`k^l* [noh ]b]^ebl fb^lmZl ikb^ cbfh
ln ihlbmZ) fngbmZ oZe]^) ^m ghg  Ze) eZ[Zb lnlmbikbgmZl) bk g^[n*
^kZm ]^\ebgZk^ Z[ ^Z ]^qm^kZ o^e oh `ZebfZ ch Zi^bmb g^b b ]^b*
cbf ) cbl i Z ] Z k  ebg d  bk Z i ch  O b *
f h mb^ cZ n l  d Z k bn h f ^ g ) bk mn h  [ ] n 
o e Z ml bkZ ] h  i kb^  c  d bmZ f ^  n i ^ebh 
d k Z g m ^ +  }  % 1 / &  A H \ [ V Z  Y H k [ P U P U R \ Z ,
o Z e] bg bg d n l) d n kb^ f l  [ n o h  i Z o ^ l mZ 
kbg d mb d Z k bn h f ^ g  bk ] Z k r mb c  l k Z *
n l + Q s + < md + / - )2 +++8 /  F k h g + / 3 ). . +
}  % 1 0 &  8 H Y U H P T L , < l m Z k h m a * F Z k g Z b k g +

K k Z ] + . 1 )2 8 < md + 6 )1 8 i e` + /  H Z d +  . / )
/ 3 +  }  % 1 2 &  0 \ ] \ Z P\ Z  4 H SH H K L , ` r o ^ *
g n l b n l  i Z ` h g b  m Z k i ^ +  } y 6 Y  ] H PR \ Z &
B k +  m+ ] Z k  i k b ] m Z 7  b k  c  e h [ +
% 1 3 &  3 MY V U \ P &  D  d b m n k  g ^ b g h f Z l 
f b^ l mZ l + Eh  o b^ mZ  mn k ch  [ mb o b^ g h *
c^  b mZ k i n d Z eg b ) i ^ k  d n k b  ch  d ^ *
e b Z l  b  F Z k g Z b f h   = ^ m l Z g  % 2 /  ^ be+&++

Turinys

*""

. H<F+ ' & ) ' '

lbgblmkZ) l^] i^k f^]bZf bm^k^kZm+


14 @m bg\enl^kngm l^ jnb ^kZgm bg
\bobmZm^) ^m h[lmknq^kngm ihkmZl
eZib]b[nl7 ^m fblbm Z] ^hl en]Zl
o^k[bl iZ\b_b\bl) 15 ]b\^gl7 OkZgl*
^Zfnl i^k m^kkZf o^lmkZf) nm
^Zfnl bg m^kkZf ghlmkZf7 ^m g^*
fh oh[bl gh\^[bm7 mZgmnf i^]b*
[nl mkZglb[bfnl+ @m ghe^[Zgm ^bl
Zi^kbk^+ 16@m ikZ^\^ibmen]ZlikZ^*
]b\Zk^ bg \Zlmkbl) nm Ziieb\Zk^gm
ngnljnbljn^ bg jnh ^kZm eh\h+
2- ^m Ziieb\n^kngm l^ obkb obkmnmbl7
^m hiin`gZobm \bobmZm^f beeZf mh*
mZ ]b^) ^m mhmZ gh\m^) ^m mkZ]bmZ ^lm
\bobmZl bg fZgn ^bnl7 2. ^m i^k^*
f^kngm hfg^f fZl\nenf bghk^
`eZ]bb) ^m ^kZ]b\Zobm ^Zf)^m Z\\^*
ibm lihebZ ^bnl) ^m mkZglbobm i^k
mhmZf \bobmZm^flni^k bgm^k_^\mhl+

g^l) g^b b dZbkl) g^l d^ebZl ch


ch ob]nkbn+ 14 =nonlb^cb fb^lm^
nlb]Zk bk Zidkho oZkmnlZdf^*
gbfbl+ En]Zl iZlbngm cb^fl mZb*
dhl h]bnl) lZdr]ZfZl7 G^bldb*
m^ i^k^bmb i^k lZoh Ze) dZ] f^l
`Zemnff ^bmbc flZe) bkgb^*
dZl g^iZ]Zkrl cnfl Zehl8 f^l
mbdmZb i^k^blbf^ ilmb+ =^m cb^g ^ *
ghkch cb^fl Zmb]Zkrmb+ 16 Onhf^m
En]Zleb^ild^e[mb lmhordehc^) dZ]
db^dob^gZl inem fb^lm mb^l mZ
ob^mZ) dnk cbl [noh+ 2- OnhcZndZ*
kbnhf^gl orkZb ikZ]ch Zkmbgmbl+
Ebl dhohch ikb^ m fb^lm obl
]b^g bk obl gZdm) bkfb^lmZl [n*
oh Zmb]nhmZl c ch kZgdZl+ 2. Eb^
bn] oblnl orkbdbnl dZeZobch
Zf^gbfbl+ Ebl ln`kbho c) iZ*
f ch `kh[ bk i^kch obl fb^l*
m i^k nfnmnhlbnl+
2/ Kh mhcb^ i^kch i^k Ehk]Z*
g ]b]^ec^ er`nfhc^mb^l =^mlZ*
gn+ 20En]ZlkZgdbhchZmlbeb^dZgbnl
bk obl d^eb ]klbgh mZnm) bdb cb^
Zmch  En]h Ze+ 21 OZbi cb^ Zm*
ch  Nbhgh dZeg ln ebgdlfr[^bk
]bZn`lfn bk Zndhch ]^`bgZf*
lbZl ZndZl) g^lgb^dZl c g^noh)
bdb ln`kh kZfr[c^+

2/ @m mkZgl`k^llb lngm Dhk]Z*


g^f bg \Zfih fZ`gh)\hgmkZ _Z*
\b^f =^malZg+ 20 @m ^kZm en]Zl
\hg`k^`Zgl ^qmk^fhl) ^m ^qahk*
mZ[Zmnk ihinenf i^k mhmZf obZf)
]hg^\ obgbk^gm bg m^kkZf Dn]Z7
21 ^mZl\^g]^kngmbg fhgm^f Nbhg
\nf eZ^mbmbZ) ^m `Zn]bh) ^m h[mn*
e^kngm aheh\ZnlmZ) jnh]g^fh ^q
^bl \^\b]bll^m ]hg^\ k^o^km^k^g*
mnk bg iZ\^+
22 @m bg ]b^[nl) jnb[nl ^kZm
22 Onh f^mn) dZb En]Zl bkEh*
en]Zl) ^m DhgZmaZl bg m^kkZ BZeZ* gZmZl [noh BZeZZ]h Zerc^) h ch
Z]) ^m Nbfhg _kZm^k ^bnl bg BZ* [khebl NbfhgZl BZebeb^chc^ mb^l
ebeZ^Z \hgmkZ _Z\b^f Kmhe^fZb]bl) Kmhe^f Zb]Z)23TZdZkbchlgnlEnh*
 %14& L {f\WTe( =ijo f\d fpmd
did %kgb+ , I\f+ ./)/4&) Htude\n d\
opmen i\hpn+ Fj \gdidif\d) ]` \]`*
ej) k\ndmkdij ipno\otod Aamjij bt*
q`iojepn kmd` t_pn+ G\_\ibd o\*
d\p o\n hd`no\n i`]pqj \ifnd\p
k\mj_n i`k\g\ifphj t_\hn) o\d
Fp_\n) g\dft_\hjn =of+ /-).-+++ ipmj*
_thj) ndgj Aamjij btq`ioje\hn o\d*
f) np \ondn\fdpnd\dn bd ipj ejn k\*
nd`gbd\ qdnp \i g\df ipjhphp+
%2/& K \Xf : XgfTah( @d_d\pnd\n d
@`f\kjgd`n hd`no d\kpn Fjm_\ij)

dijh\n _\m fdop q\m_p7 Ofdojkjgdn+


Pd`n epj Fjm_\i` tm\ i` qd`i\ ]m\no\+
Fjm_\ij ngidn d\ g\]\d kg\opn) odfm\
g\]\d _`mgdib\ gtbph\+  %20& I Ta '
^ \b ]b  T gf\_\X^Ta }\h f+++ Gjqjn` Fp_\n
noj_\qj qdn kmd`\fdp) _\]\m n\pbj
f\mdpjh`i`n pk\f\gte` ndgki`nidpj*
ndpn) f\_ i` qd`i\n e i`o+  %21&
_  J \ba b ^ T _a 4 e ]\itd k\_fjod
Rd`k\dpd p g\dhedhpn dm tk\odi*
b bgj]+  E \X^Tf ] a X{ h i b 4 d
o t_) fpmdpjn dq\_\qj d kmd`
m\if dm \ondq`_ e Fp_e+

Turinys

. H<F) 2) 23}32

/'(

23 Zn]bobm ehl^ianl TZ\aZkbZ^ _b* b  sZiZl bk dZkbnhf^gloZ]Zl <sZ*


 kbcZl b`bk]h Zib^ c iZlbl^dbfnl
ebnl) ^m <sZkbZl ikbg\^il obkmnmbl) u
k^l [^g^ `^lmZl) ^m ikZ^ebZ jnZ^ D bk ordnlbZl dhoZl) 24 bk cbl mZk7
_Z\mZ lngm) 24 ^m ]bqbm7 AZ\bZfnl c clb`rdbf^ bk f^l lZnoZk] bk^b*
^m bilb gh[bl ghf^g) ^m ^Zfnl dbf^ dhohmbikb^ ^lZgbnlZiebgd
in`gZk^ Z]o^klnl `^gm^l) jnZ^ D fnl iZ`hgbl+ 25 OZb`b cbl ]Zo
bg \bk\nbmn ghlmkh lngm+ 25@mikZ^* c  lZdrf mb^fl) dnkb^ [nohch dZ*
\^ibm abl) jnb ^kZgm bg ^q^k\bmn kbnhf^gc^) bk cb^bchikb^ EZf*
lnh) ^m Z[b^kngm DZfgbZf+ 26 @m b gbc+ 26 =^m cb^fl ikb^Zbl b*
^qbobm Bhk`bZl ]^ \bobmZm^) ^m obkb b ch b fb^lmh  dho Bhk`bcZl ln
^bnl h[obZfbeebl bg in`gZf+ 3-@m b lZoh fhgfbl+ 3- EnhsZiZl bk
_n`Zmb lngm ehl^ianl) ^m <sZkbZl <sZkbcZl [noh ikbo^klmb [`mb bdb
nljn^ bg _bg^l Dn]Z^Z^7 ^m \^\b* En]chl lb^g+ O ]b^g Zib^ ]n
]^kngm beeh ]b^ ]^ ihineh DlkZ^e 8 mdlmZgbn ork b DskZ^ebh dkb*
Z] ]nh fbeebZ obkb) ^m _Z\mZ ^lm mh) bk [noh ln]nhmZl ]b]^ebl lf*
_n`Z fZ`gZ bg ihineh7 3. jnbZ `bl mZnmZb) 3. g^l cb^ g^iZdeZnl
ghg Zn]b^kngm en]Zf) ^m _kZmk^l En]h bk ch [kheb bk fZg`Zelb
^bnl) ^qblmbfZgm^l _hkmbm^k l^ _Z\* ]klbZb iZlb^e`mb+ 3/ =^m cb^g^[n*
mnkhl+ -/ Dilb Znm^f ghg ^kZgm oh b Zbgbchl m ork)i^kdnkbnhl
]^ l^fbg^ obkhknf beehknf) i^k [noh ordbgmZl b`^e[cbfZl DskZ*
jnhl lZenl _Z\mZ^lmbgDlkZ^e+30@m ^erc^+ 30 Onh mZkin ` bc ] h  orkZb
obkb Dn]Z fZ`gb_b\Zmb lngm oZe]^ [noh eZ[Zb `bkbZfb oblh DskZ^ebh
bg \hgli^\mn hfgbl DlkZ^e) ^m`^g* ZdboZbs]hc^ bk obl iZ`hgb) dnk
mbnf hfgbnf n[b Zn]b^[Zmnkgh* mbdb`bkl]ZohZib^coZk]8 31ikb^
f^g ^hknf+ 31 @m \hgo^g^kngm c kbgd]Zohlb ln ]bZn`lfh *
dhcbfZbl+
Z] ^hl _ZnlmZ Z\\eZfZgm^l+
30 Kh mh En]Zl ln lZoh [kh*
32 @m ^qbobm en]Zl) ^m _kZmk^l
^bnl) ^m ^qin`gZ[Zgm _bebhl @lZn ebZbl bch bk dhohch ikb^ @sZoh
bg m^kkZ) jnZ^ Z] <nlmknf ^lm) lgnl Zerc^) ^lZgbhc^  ib^mnl8
^m i^k\nllbm >a^[khg ^m_bebZl^bnl7 cbl iZf >a^[khg bk ch]ndm^*
^m fnkhl ^bnl) ^mmnkk^l ln\\^g]bm kbl bk gn]^`bgh Ziebgdnbch lb^gZl
%23& Ah b m T c T f  \e((( 9 mTe\]Tf( Ru+
\pf+ .5 `dg+  %24& A \ f  gT e 4 Fpju\*
k\n V\f\mdepd+ Fd` h\ojh\d k\qt*
_ej k\ndn`fdhp Fp_pd dm ipo\m ej
i`]`fg\pntod+ Nkej ed`hn g\]d\p*
nd\d bmj]dn+  %25& A \ f  W T i ( Cm+ o+7
ed` _\q+  G e\Xy AT ` a \] ( Lgb+ \pf+
1).2+ Oom\]ji\n n\fj) f\_ bdifgpjop
qtmp nf\ddpn F\hideje` dm ejn \kt*
gdife` nd`fn 1-+---+  %26& > be'
Z \]T f( @p t_ q\_p b\g i i`h\i)
f\_ F\hideje` tm\ Cjmbde\n) fpmdj
f\mdf\ _mn\ ]pqj dijh\ qdnje`
Otije` %. I\f+ 0)05&+  %3/& A \ X 
aXUhib \y((( Fpjn q`_ kpdft] dm
bj_ph\n+ @d`q\n o`df dum\`gdo\hn
fjqjn` kmd` k\bjidn n\qj bgj]jn)
f\_ ed` b\gop bdiod n\qj m`gdbde) ]`o
i` o\h) f\_ ed` ndbtop e o\mk` _d*

_`gn b\gdjn+
 %30& Ah W b  ileT\((( Cm+
o+7 qtm\n %_mnpjgdn& Fp_\n dm ej
]mjgd\d+  %31& G e\X ] e\a ^ W T i b f\4
qdnjn Fp_ejn t_\d+
%32& = m T i b fahf4 d_phed`dpn)
fpmd` ]pqj ph kd`odi Fp_ejn
_\g+  ; [ XUeba ( H\]\d n`i\n) k\*
km\no\d D`]mjip q\_di\h\n) hd`no\n+
L\g`nodi _\gdi\io) edn ]pqj k\nfdm*
o\n Fp_j. bdhdi`d %Fju+ .2)218 kgb+
Lm\_+ .0)5&+ Lj >\]dgjij i`g\dnqn
t_\d ]pqj npbm ?c`]mji\i %J``h+
..)/2&) ]`o qgd\p ed` ]pqj d d\ d_p*
hed`d dq\mtod+ Fp_\n) npbmn
d C\g\\_j %.30 h+ kdmh Gm+& dm _\*
qn fd`f g\dfj k\ndgnod n\qj f\mdpj*
h`i`d) mtjnd f\md\pod kmd` d_ph*
ed`dpn dm kdgdnodhpn+  A b  W h ^ gXe\f4
?c`]mjij \ktgdife` ]pqpndpn hd`n*
2.

o+ MZmZl) m+ DQ+

Turinys

*"$

# 3,1! ' ((?( %

b`gb bg \bk\nbmn+ 53 @m fhobm\ZlmkZ


nm bk^m bg m^kkZf Zeb^gb`^gZknf)
^m i^kZf[neZ[Zm NZfZkbZf+ 34 Dg
]b^ beeZ \^\b]^kngm lZ\^k]hm^l bg
[^eeh) ]nf ohengm _hkmbm^k _Z\^k^)
]nf lbg^\hglbebh ^q^ngmbg ikZ^*
ebnf+ 35 @m ]^\ebgZobm en]Zl bg
<shmnf bg m^kkZf Zeb^gb`^gZknf)
^m ]bknbm ZkZl ^hknf) ^m l\neimb*
ebZ ]^hknf bilhknfln\\^g]bmb`*
gb7 ^m \^ibm lihebZ \bobmZmnf) ^m
k^o^klnl ^lm bg m^kkZf en]Z+
b

bk [hdmnl+ 33 Kh mh cbl iZdbehb


lZoh lmhordehl) dZ] ^bm c lo^*
mbfZeb dkZm) bk ch i^k NZfZ*
kbc+ 34 O ]b^g dkbmh dhohc^ dn*
gb`) dZb cb^ iZghkch iZkh]rmb
lZoh ]kl bk ch [^ Zmh]Zbkhl b
dho+ 35 En]Zl iZlndh c <shm
lo^mbfZeb dkZm^8 cbl bZk] c
Zndnknl) ln]^`bgh c ]b^oZbb
]khmnl iZo^bdlenl) iZf fb^l*
m `kh[ bk ln`kh  En]h Ze+

N! 4Y_TZVZ 8[TQLYZ XT]_T^% 4Y_TZVZ 8`[L_Z]TZ VL]L^


[]TPo <P]`cLWu%
6L[`_ QD+ . @m k^q <gmbh*
\anl i^kZf[neZ[Zm lni^kbhk^l k^*
`bhg^l) ^m Zn]bobm ^ll^ \bobmZm^f
@erfZb]^f bg K^klb]^ gh[bebllb*
fZf) ^m \hibhlZf bg Zk`^gmh)^m
Znkh) / m^fienfjn^ bg ^Z eh\n*
ie^l oZe]^7 ^m beeb\ o^eZfbgZ Zn*
k^Z) ^m ehkb\Z^) ^m l\nmZ) jnZ^ k^*
ebjnbm <e^qZg]^kKabebiib k^q HZ*
\^]h) jnb k^`gZobmikbfnlbgBkZ^*
\bZ+ 0 @m o^gbm) ^m jnZ^k^[Zm \Z*
i^k^ \bobmZm^f) ^m ]^ikZ^]Zkb ^Zf7
^m ghg ihmnbm) jnhgbZf bgghmnbm

,  [P]^Vb]TXL^% . FZkZebnl
<gmbhdZl ch i^k Zndm^lgblbZl
Zebl+ D`bk]l) dZ] K^klbchc^ rkZ
@ebfZb]hl fb^lmZl) eZ[Zb `Zklnl
bkmnkmbg`Zllb]Z[kn bk Zndln)/dZ]
cZf^ rkZ eZ[Zbmnkmbg`Z o^gmrdeZ)
dZ] chc^ rkZ Zndlbgbn]Zg`)
Zko bk ldr]) iZebdm HZd^]h*
gbchl dZkZebZnl Kberih lgZnl
<e^dlZg]kh) dnkl ibkfZl dZkZebZ*
oh BkZbdbchc^) 0 cbl gnch m^gZb)
) lm^g`lb iZbfmb fb^lm bk c Zib*
D iemb8 [^m cbl g^`Zech)g^l ch ln*

o`fpn dm nj_dpn+  %33& @ fi Xg\` '


yT_\h 4 d kdgdnodh+  G Xe J T` Te\](
O\h\mdejn q\m_\n d\ tm\ \dfd fg\d*
_\+ Fp_\n) `d_\h\n d ?c`]mjij 
=ujo %35 `+&) i`b\gej k\o`fod  ojgd
d\pme` `n\id O\h\mde+ O`ijqdidn
gjotidf\n q`modh\n) Bg+ Fpju\k\n) /
I\f+ ./)00 dm f+ o qd`o q\_di\ I\*
mdn\ %n`ijqe` I\m`n\+ _\]\m I \m\n&)
fpmd d odfme tm\ kmd` f`gdj d A]mj*
ij d =ujo+  %34& K  W\Xa4 km\*
`di\io kmj I\mdn) G\h` o`fj npnd*
m`hod np Cjmbdej f\mdpjh`i` %qu+ /
I\f+ ./)01&+
%35& , 9mbg( P\d kd*
gdnodh hd`no\n+ Lgb+ \pf+ 1).2+
3). 30+ =iodjfj tbdn kmd` Agd*
h\d_ e\h i`k\ndn`f\8 b\qn did
\kd` Fp_j ipb\gedhpn) edn npn`mb\ dm
hdmo\) dk\din n\qj k\_\mto\n i`*
o`dnt]`n t_\hn %.  .3&+ Idmpndj

=iodjfj qd`oji Htude\n k\nf`g]d\ f\*


m\gdphd ej ni =iodjf Apk\ojm)
fpmdj k\b\g]jn \pfd\nd ]`_d`qd\d t *
_\d %.4 0-&+ Otm\d ipb\gd Fp_ kmd`
>`ou\f\mjn %0.14& dm \kbpg\ ]\it*
djn dZeg %1521&+ G\m\gdpn k\_\*
mj np t_\dn o\df) ]`o ejn i`ndg\dfj
%2230&+
%3).& 9 a g\b ^ T f4 =iodjf\n Akda\*
i\n+ Ru+ \pf+ 0)04+ Lgb+ / I\f+ -)
/+++  G Xef \]b ]X l e T  X _\` T \W b f  ` \Xf'
gTf( Pjfn o`fnoj nf\doth\n fg\d_di*
b\n8 b`m`nidpjn` bm+ m\ifm\dpjn`
hd`no\n qdn\d i`q\m_de\h\n8 o`i
k\n\fto\7 tm\ Agdh\d_je`) L`mndeje`)
b\mnpn hd`no\n+ / I\f+ 6)/ im\ k\*
hdio\ i`d L`mndejn) i`d Agdh\d_jn)
odf k\n\fjh\n hd`noj q\m_\n7 L`m*
n`kjgdn+ Agdh\d_\ bd q\_dijnd \gdn)
i` hd`no\n) n`ijqn Ag\h\n+  %/&

D

Turinys

# 3,1! ( &? #$

DA<

l^kfh abl+ jnb ^kZgm bg \bobmZm^7 8 fZgrfZl [noh iZlb]Zkl bgh*
1 ^m \a f h e e X k X e h a g \a  ikZ^ebnf)^m fZl fb^lmh `ro^gmhcZfl+ 1 Eb^
_n`bm bg]^) ^m Z[bbm \nf mkblmbmbZ iZdbeh dhoZb) bk cbl mnkch b m^g
fZ`gZ) ^m k^o^klnl ^lm bg =Z[r* [`mb8 cbl iZlbmkZnd eZ[Zb gneb*
]l bk `kh  =Z[behgbc+
ehgbZf+
Onhf^m [noh Zmg^mZ cZf
2
@m o^gbm jnb gng\bZk^m ^b bg 2
K^klb]^) jnbZ _n`ZmZ lngm \ZlmkZ) bgbZ  K^klbc) dZ] ch dZkbnhf^g
jnZ^ ^kZgmbg m^kkZDn]Z7 6^m jnbZ [nonlbEn]h Zerc^) [noh ikbo^kl*
Z[bbm GrlbZl \nf obkmnm^ _hkmb bg mZ [`mb) B dZ] GrsbcZl ch ]b]^*
ikbfbl) ^m _n`Zmnl ^lm Z _Z\b^ Dn* el dZkbnhf^gl ikb^Zdrc^ bk[n*
]Z^hknf) ^m bgoZen^kngmZkfbl) ^m oh r] ikbo^klmZl [`mb) dZ] cb^
obkb[nl) ^m lihebbl fnembl) jnZ^ lnlmbikch `bgdeZbl) dZkbnhf^g^ bk
\^i^kngm ]^ \Zlmkbl) jnZ^ ^q\b* ]Zn`^ebn `kh[bh) dnk Zmf b
]^kngm7 4 ^m jnbZ ]bkn^kngm Z[h* lnfnmhl dZkbnhf^gl) 4 dZ] cb^
fbgZmbhg^f) jnZf Z^]b_b\Zo^kZm ln`kbho gnh[h]) dnkbcbl [noh
lni^k ZemZk^) jnh] ^kZm bg e^kn* iZlmZml Zgm ZemhkbZnl E^knsZec^)
lZe^f) ^m lZg\mb_b\Zmbhg^f) lb\nm bk Zio^] Zndmhfbl lb^ghfbl)
ikbnl) \bk\nf]^]^kngm fnkbl ^q* dZbi ibkfZ) o^gmrde bk ch fb^*
\^elbl) l^] ^m =^malnkZf \bobmZ* lm =^mlnk+
m^f lnZf+
<mlbmbdh) dZ] dZkZebnl) b`bk*
5
@m _Z\mnf ^lm nmZn]bobmk^q 5
l^kfhg^l blmhl) ^qiZobm) ^m \hf* ]l bmZl bgbZl) gnlb`Zg]h bk eZ*
fhmnl ^lm oZe]^7^m ]^\b]bm bg e^\* [Zb lnlbcZn]bgh8 cbl Zmlb`ne  iZ*
mnf) ^m bg\b]bm bg eZg`nhk^fikZ^ mZe bk b eb]^lbh lnlbk`h) g^l
mkblmbmbZ) jnbZ ghg _Z\mnf ^lm ^b g^mZbi cZf ordh) dZbi cbl fZg+
lb\nm \h`bmZ[Zm+ 6 @m ^kZmbeeb\ i^k 6 Ebl iZlbebdh m^gZb ]Zn` ]b^g)
]b^l fnemhl7 jnbZ k^ghoZmZ ^lm*bg g^l ]b]^ebl eb]^lrl iZlbk^bd]Z*
^h mkblmbmbZ fZ`gZ) ^m Zk[bmkZmnl oh cZf^ b gZnch) bkcbl mZklbfbk*
^lm l^ fhkb+
lbl+
Ebl iZlbZnd oblnl lZoh
.-
@m oh\Zobm hfg^l Zfb\hl .-
lnhl) ^m ]bqbm beebl7 M^\^llbm lhf* ikb^m^ebnl bkcb^fl mZk7 Hb^`Zl Zm*
gnl Z[ h\nebl f^bl) ^m \hg\b]b) lmhch gnh fZgh Zdb) cZnbnhl
^m \hkknb \hk]^ ikZ^ lheb\bmn]bg^7 ikble`mZl) bk fZgh bk]bl ]blmZ
.. ^m ]bqb bg\hk]^ f^h7 Dg jnZg* b lb^eoZkmh+ .. Oh]e Z mZkbZn
mZf mkb[neZmbhg^f ]^o^gb) ^m bg lZoh bk]rc^7 E dZbi ]b] lb^eoZk*
jnhl _en\mnl mkblmbmbZ^) bg jnZ m Z iZm^dZn bkdhdbhl^ gneb]b*
gng\ lnf7 jnb bn\ng]nl ^kZf) fh [Zg`hl^ ^ln ]Z[Zk Z) dnkl
^m ]be^\mnl bg ihm^lmZm^ f^Z 8 [noZn f^bebg`Zl bk frebfZl lZ*
.6 Ing\ o^kh k^fbgbl\hk fZeh* oh dZkZerlmc^ .0 =^m ]Z[Zk Z
Kheg\aZT yi X a gl ^ _T 4 @d\ijn q`iotf*
g\ %Bg+ Fpju\k\n) Fd`mji+ Lgb+ / I\f+
.).0&+  L{WTaZ( Qm+ o+ f\g]\h\
\kd`+ \kn\pbjn kmd`hji`n fjqje`8 d
Fp opje\p q\m_de\hd \mq\d dm nft*
_\d+  Bhef c\e` Tf((( Ru+ \pf+ .).
%k\\dfdidh&+  %1& , : TU\_ba \]T(
Cm+ o+7 d >\]dgji8 ]`o bm+ o+ im\
k\n\fto\) f\_ =iodjf\n ]o npbm*

n  >\]dgji8 edn odf ijmen o`i


qtfod+
%2& 9 gaXygT ]T`  { \a \T 4 Htudej k\*
ndpno\ did\ %qu+ \pf+ 0)0/.&+  %4&
E hbUbW( P\dk fitbjn \pojmdpn q\*
_di\ =iodjfj n\fthp k\no\oto \p*
fpm \io _`bdi\he \pf \gojmd\pn+
 A b  ` \Xfg : Xgfh e( >`onpm\ ]p*
qj i`]` Fp_ejn md]jn` %kgb+ \pf+ 1)

Turinys

/'+

( >2<& -$ (*%(0

knf) jnZ^ _^\b bg e^knlZe^f) ng*


]^ ^m Z[lmneb hfgbZ lihebZZnk^Z)
^m Zk`^gm^Z) jnZ^ ^kZgm bg ^Z) ^m
fblb Zn_^kk^ aZ[bmZgm^l Dn]Z^Zf
lbg^ \ZnlZ+ .0 >h`ghob ^k`hjnbZ
ikhim^k^Z bgo^g^kngm f^ fZeZbl*
mZ7 ^m ^\\^ i^k^h mkblmbmbZ fZ`gZ
bg m^kkZ Zeb^gZ+

Zmlbf^gn ibdm^gr[^l) dnkbZl ^ln


iZ]Zkl E^knsZec^) b dnk Z Zm*
fbZn) dZbi `kh[) obl[nonl ch *
c^ Zndl bk lb]Z[k bk dZ] ^ln
lbngml lngZbdbgmb [^ ikb^Zlmb^l
En]chl `ro^gmhcnl+ .0 OZb`b ]Z*
[Zk Z lnikZgmn) dZ]mh]e Zigr*
dh fZg^ bmhl g^eZbfl) bk mZb
Z gn ]b]^ebn eb]^lbn lo^mbfh*
c^ Zerc^+
.1
@m oh\Zobm Kabebiinf)ngnf .1
Kh mh cbl iZlbZnd ob^g
]^ Zfb\bl lnbl) ^mikZ^ihlnbm^nf lZoh ikb^m^eb) Kberi) iZldrk c
lni^k ngbo^klnf k^`gnf lnnf7 oblhl lZoh dZkZerlml obkbgbgdn
.2 ^m ]^]bm ^b ]bZ]^fZ) ^m lmheZf .2 bk iZ]Zo cZf lZoh oZbgbd)
lnZf) ^m Zgnenf) nm Z]]n\^k^m ZilbZnlm bk b^]) dZ] Zmlbo^lm
<gmbh\anf _bebnf lnnf) ^m gn* ch lg <gmbhd) Zndemc bkiZ*
mkbk^m ^nf) ^m k^`gZk^m+
bfm ob^iZmZobf+
.3 FZkZebnl <gmbhdZl fbk m^*
.3 @m fhkmnnl ^lm beeb\<gmbh*
\anl k^q Zggh \^gm^lbfh jnZ* gZb bfmZl d^mnkbZl ]^bfmbl ]^*
]kZ`^lbfh ghgh+
obgmZbl f^mZbl+
.4GrsbcZl) `Zol bgb) dZ] dZ*
.4 @m \h`ghobm GrlbZl) jnh*
gbZf fhkmnnl ^lm k^q) ^m \hglmb* kZebnl fbkl) lmZm dZkZebnfb ch
mnbm k^`gZk^ <gmbh\anf _bebnf lg <gmbhd) dnk cbl oblZb cZn*
^bnl)jn^f gnmkbobm Z]he^l\^gm^f7 g Zndech) bk ikZfbg c oZk]n
^m oh\Zobm ghf^g ^bnl @niZmhk+ @niZmhkbl+
.5 =nonlb^cb iberc^ n]Zk Ds*
.5 @m ab) jnb ^kZgm bg Zk\^)
\hg\enl^kZgm DlkZ^e bg \bk\nbmn kZ^e b obl inlb Ziebgd o^g*
lZg\mhknf7 ^m jnZ^k^[Zgm^blfZ* mrde bk lm^g`lb gnheZm ]Zkrmb
eZ l^fi^k) ^m _bkfZf^gmnf B^g* cb^fl ibdmZ bk lmbikbgmb iZ`hgbl+
mbnf+ .6 @m \h`bmZobm en]Zl ]bl* % .6 En]Zl gnlblmZmlngZbdbgmb cnhl
i^k]^k^ ^hl7 ^m \hgoh\Zobm ngb* c bk lnZnd obl mZnm c Zi`nemb+
3.&8 edn kmdfg\pn =iodjfpd8 ejn k\*
hdh\n dm npnodkmdidh\n ]pqj _d_`*
gdn f\m\gd\pn `d_dh\n+
%.0& J i Xg\` b]X yT _l ]X( =iodjf\n
opjh`o ]pqj L`mndejn hd`no` P\]e`)
o\mk Af]\o\ijn dm L`mn`kjgd`n+ Jjmn
m\ \gdn kmdfg\pn Otmde\d) ]`o ed ]p*
qj ipj ejn g\]\d ojgd8 =iodjf\n$ ]p*
qj  d\ \oqtfn \kdkgod q`iotf*
gjn) oj_g edn i`b\gej odfodn qd`ojn
btq`ioje ppje\pojn) dm qdn\ o\ \*
gdn e\h _\]\m mj_nd `n\iod nq`odh\+
%.1& G \_lc( =ijo+ / I\f+ 6)/6)
edn ]pqn =iodjfj kd`i]mjgdn+ G\m\*
gdpn ]pqj e k\nftmn n\qj qd`odidi*
fp Fp_d`eje`+ Lgb+ / I\f+ 2)//$ dm
6)/6+  %.2& @e { \X W 4 f\m\gdfe
\ionk\p_jn d`_+ P\dk =iodjf\n \o*
h \ifnd\p _pjopn b\gdjedhpn H t* E

udepd %\pf+ 0)0/+00&) fpmn b\g ]pqj


i`o`fn ej k\ndodfedhj _g km\g\d*
ho fjqp kmd` t_pn+  B TW T gf \'
iXfg((( Cm+ o+ b\gdh\ q`mnod o\dk7
f\_ edn epjn %f\m\gdfjn b\m]n `i*
fgpn& ipi`op =iodjfpd+
%.3& D \e gXaT\ y\` gTf(((4 P\]e`
.30 h+ kdmh Gm+ =kd` =iodjfj hdmo
k\n\fje\h\ _\m / I\f+ .). .4 dm /
I\f+ 6+./6+ Ru+ op qd`o k\\dfd*
idhpn+
%.4& A b  Ja((( =iodjf\n Apk\oj*
mdn ]pqj opjh`o _`qti`md %\ijo fd*
op) _qtgdfjn& h`o q\df\n+
%.5& : hihf\X]\ c\_l]X((( bpg\) ]p*
qpnd nodkmdje` kdgte` qdn\d i`ojgd ipj
t_ q`iotfgjn %qu+ \pf+ 02048 1+
1.&) b\gej q\mbdiod F`mpu\gn btq`i*
ojepn) tk\ f\d ed` `d_\qj  q`i*

Turinys

# 3,1! ( $ " % "

/',

o^klnf ihinenf) nm h[lb]^k^gm /- Eb^ lnlbkbgdh oblb ]kZn`) Zi*
^hl) /- @m \hgo^g^kngm lbfne) ^m `ne cnhl bfmZl i^gdbZl]^bf *
mZbl f^mZbl bk iZlb]bk[h lZn f^*
h [ l^] ^ kn g m ^ h l Zggh \^g m^lbf h
jnbgjnZ`^lbfh) ^m _^\^kngm [Zeb* mZfc bk Zi`neZfc dZkh ikb^*
lmZl) ^m fZ\abgZl+ /. @m ^qb^kngm mZbl+ /. Onhf^m dZb dnkb^ Zi`ne*
jnb]Zf ^q ^bl) jnb h[lb]^[Zgmnk7 mb^cb bmkdh) h ikb^ c ikblb]ch
^m Z]bngq^kngm l^ beebl Zebjnb bf* dZbo dnkb^ [^]b^obZb b DskZ^ebh+
ibb ^q DlkZ^e) // ^m Z[b^kngm Z] // bmb^ gnch iZl dZkZeb bk lZd7
k^`^f) ^m ]bq^kngm7 Lnhnljn^ Ddb dhe^b mn g^]Zkrlb m^blr[l bk
ghg _Z\bl bn]b\bnf) ^m obg]b\Zl g^d^krlbn fl[khebnl; /0H^l
_kZmk^l ghlmkhl; /0 Ihl ]^\k^ob* krhfl mZkgZnmb mZoh monb) ^e`*
fnl l^kobk^ iZmkb mnh) ^m Zf[n* mbl lneb` ch lZdrfZbl bk deZnlrmb
eZk^ bg ikZ^\^imbl ^bnl) ^m h[l^* ch iZeb^ibf8 /1 mh]e fl mZn*
jnb ^]b\mbl ^bnl7 /1 ^m _bebb ihineb mhl lgl Zebghlb gnh fl) bk
ghlmkb ikhim^k ah\ Zeb^gZ[Zgm l^ dZl mbd b flcb^fl iZm^d]Zoh)
Z gh[bl) ^m jnb\nfjn^ bgo^gb^* [noh nfnZfZl) bk fl moZb*
[Zgmnk ^q gh[bl) bgm^k_b\b^[Zgmnk) grlml [noh biebZfhl+ /2 Eb^
^m a^k^]bmZm^l ghlmkZ^]bkbib^[Zg* mb^l]Zoh kZgd g^ mbd ikb^ fl)
mnk+ /2 @m ghg Z]ghl mZgmnf^q* [^m bk ikb^ obl fl iehm) /3 bk
m^g]^kngm fZgnf) l^] ^m bg hf* mZb bZg]b^g cb^ Zi`neE^knsZel
g^l _bg^l ghlmkhl+ /3 @m ^\\^ Zi* ibe) dZ] c iZbfm) bk lnlmbikbgh
ieb\n^kngm ah]b^ Z]Zk\^f D^knlZ* =^mlnkhl mobkmho+ /4 E^b mn g^^blb
e^f h\\niZk^ ^Zf) ^m fngbmbh* `k^bmZb ikb^ cnhl) cb^ iZ]Zkrlibd*
g^f =^malnkZf fngb^kngm7 /4 ^m m^lgb dZbi bmb^ ]Zerd) bk mng^*
gblb ikZ^o^g^kbl ^hl o^eh\bnl)fZ* [^`Zelb c gn`Zemb+
bhkZ) jnZf aZ^\) _Z\b^gm) ^m ghg
ihm^kbl h[mbg^k^ ^hl+
/5 @m bkZmnl ^lm k^q) nm aZ^\
/5 OZb b`bk]l dZkZebnl irdh8
Zn]bobm7 ^m\hgoh\Zobm hfg^lZfb* cbl lnZnd oblnl lZoh ikb^m^ebnl)
\hl lnhl) ^m ikbg\bi^l ^q^k\bmnl lZoh dZkbnhf^gl oZ]nl bk kZbm^*
lnb) ^m ^hl) jnb lni^k ^jnbm^l eb obkbgbgdnl8 /6iZl c Zmch mZbi
^kZgm+ /6 N^] ^m ]^ k^`gbl Zebbl) iZm lZf]rmhl dZkbnhf^gl b db*
^m ]^ bglnebl fZkbmbfbl o^g^kngm m dZkZerlb bkb ckhl lZe+ 0-Eh
Z] ^nf^q^k\bmnl \hg]n\mbmbb+ 0-@m dZkbnhf^gl ldZbbnl [noh bf*
^kZm gnf^knl^q^k\bmnl ^bnl) \^g* mZl mdlmZgb ilmbgbgd) ]ob]^*
mnf fbeebZ i^]bmnf) ^m ob`bgmb fbe* bfm mdlmZgb kZbm^eb bk mkrl]^*
ebZ ^jnbmnf) ^m ^e^iaZgmb mkb`bgmZ* bfmrl ]n ]kZf[ebZbbfhdbgmb dh*
]nh) ]h\mb Z] ikZ^ebnf+
ohmb+
otfd\8 oj_g Fp_\n ipo\md\ hbdiod
e qdn\d ipndfm\otod dm \kbpg\ kdgd+ 
%/-& x \` gTf(((4 .3/ h+ kdmh+ Gm+ %kgb+
/ I\f+ .0).+++&  G T f\W \eU b  fTh(((
=ijo bm+ o+7 k\nd_\m n\p ktgdh)
]jfo h`o\hd`hn kmd`o\dn\hn k\*
no\otod+  %/.& 9 cZh_g\X]\ \yge^b(((
Jjmn kdgdn ]pqj \knpko\) o\d\p f\d
fpmd`hn ntm\hn k\ndn`f d ejn d*
omfod | %//& Df Ueb _\h f4 k\ndgdfp*
ndpn kdgte` ntmpn dm t_ \okpjggdpn+

%/2& G e\X i\f `f c_bg( P\dk _\*


mjh\ \gdpude\ d g\dhdib\n Fp_j fj*
q\n kmd` f\dhtipn+ Lgb+ \pf+ 2)0+++
 %/3e : Xgfh eb f( Ru+ \pf+ 4 `dg+
%/5& A \ f  fh yT h ^ + F\pij f\m\*
gd\pn q\m_p qdn\ _\m Htude\n+ Lmd`*
o`gd\dn d\ q\_di\hd th`nid`ed f\*
m\gd\pn k\o\me\d+%/6& @y ^\g ^ T e T '
_l f}\ 4 E I\jndjn =udejn+  @y ]h '
e b f  fT _ 4 d Gdkmj) Nj_j) Gm`ojn dm
fdo P\mk`hn emjn n\g+  %0-&

Turinys

*"(

# H<F+ ( %#?%)

Eb^$ Zmch i^k e]nfc) Zi*


0.
@m o^g^kngm i^kD]nfZ^Zf) 0.
^m Ziieb\n^kngm Z] =^malnkZf) ^m `ne =^mclnk) dhohch ]Zn`]b^g
in`gZo^kngm ]b^l fnemhl) ^m _^* bk iZlb]bk[h Zi`neZfc dZkh iZ*
\^kngm fZ\abgZl ^m ^qb^kngm) ^m [de8 [^m Zi`nemb^cb bch) ln]^*
ln\\^g]^kngm ^Zl b`gb) ^m in`gZ* `bgh cnhl bk dhohch _mnd\d+ X E n *
o^kngm obkbebm^k+ 0/' @m k^\^llbm en* ]Zl mnh mZkin iZlbmkZnd gnh ib*
]Zl Z[ Zk\^) ^m fhobm \ZlmkZ Z] eb^l bk iZ]Zk lZn lmhorde ikb^
=^masZ^aZkZf \hgmkZ \ZlmkZk^`bl+ =^msZdZkhlmb^l dZkZebZnl lmhordeZ+
00 @m lnkk^qbm k^q Zgm^ en\^f) ^m 00 <mlbdel ]Zk g^bZnnl dZkZ*
\hg\bmZobm ^q^k\bmnl bg bfi^mnf ebnl iZkZ`bgh dZkbnhf^g inemb
\hgmkZ obZf =^masZ^aZkZf7 ^m =^msZdZkhl d^ebn8 ch dZkbnhf^gl
\hfiZkZo^kngm l^ ^q^k\bmnl bg ]Zerl ikblbk^g` c dho bk lnmkb*
ikZ^ebnf) ^m mn[bl \^\bg^kngm701^m fbmZoh mkbfbmZbl+ 01 ?kZf[ebZfl
^e^iaZgmblhlm^g]^kngmlZg`nbg^f cb^ iZkh] orgnh`b bk fhk lng*
noZ^ ^m fhkb) Z] Z\n^g]hl ^hl dhl) dZ] iZ^ksbgm cnhl c dho+
bg ikZ^ebnf7 02 ^m ]bobl^kngm[^l* 02 Eb^ iZldbklm `ronebnl mZki e^*
mbZl i^k e^`bhg^l7 ^m Zlmbm^kngm `bhg) mZbi dZ] ikb^ db^dob^gh
lbg`nebl ^e^iaZgmbl fbee^ obkb bg ]kZf[ebh lmhoch mdlmZgmbl ork
ehkb\bl \hg\Zm^gZmbl) ^m `Ze^Z^Z^* `kZg]bgbgbZbl ZkoZbl bk oZkbgbZbl
k^Z^ bg \Zibmb[nl ^hknf7 ^mjnbg* ZefZbl Zgm lZoh `Zeo8 mZbi iZm
`^gmb ^jnbm^l hk]bgZmb ngb\nbjn^ i^gdb bfmZb kbgdmbgb kZbm^eb [n*
[^lmbZ^ ^e^\mb ^kZgm+ 03 Cb Zgm^ ohikbldbkmZikb^db^dob^gh`ronebh+
m^finln[b\nfjn^ ^kZm [^lmbZ) b[b 0- bmb^ cZn ZgdlbZn []Zoh ob*
^kZgm7 ^m jnh\nfjn^ b[Zm) b[Zgm) lnhf^m m^gZb) dnk []Zoh `ron*
^m ghg ]bl\^]^[ZgmZ[ ^Z+ 04N^] erl8 dnk mbd cbl ch) ch bk cb^ bk
^m mnkk^l eb`g^Z^ lni^k ^hl _bk* gnh ch g^Zmlmh]Zoh+ 04 =^mh) Zgm
fZ^ ikhm^`^gm^l lni^k lbg`neZl db^dob^gh `ronebh [noh ZilZn`Zb
[^lmbZl7 ^m lni^k ^Zl fZ\abgZ^7 lmbikl f^]bgbZb [hdmZb ln dZkh
] b  ^Te\h b` Xa f((( , I\f+ .0)/ ojn
f\mdpjh`in nf\dd\d ipmj_jhd omp*
kpod fdojfd`) b\g _goj) f\_ ed ej k`m*
ndnftmpn d _qd _\gd+
.0.& G Xe _W h ` ](((4 Fp_\n g\df
\kbpgn ntmp bpg F`mpu\gn kdgte`
%\pf+ /- `df&+ Ebdm_n) f\_ \o`di\
g\]\d _d_`g =iodjfj Apk\ojmdj f\mdpj*
h`i) Fp_\n m\bdi\ t_pn h\g_\pod
Rd`k\od k\b\g]jn) k\on bd k\ndom\pfd\
d F`mpu\gn np n\qj f\mdpjh`i`  Ij*
madi) d d\ pkpjg\ Apk\ojmdj f\*
mdpjh`in _\gd dm k\_\mj e\d i`h\*
\ ipjnojgdp+ Pj_g ntm\d i`_mno\
opje\p kpgod F`mpu\g) ]`o `di\ oj*
gd\p k\emdp) dfd k\nd`fd\ g_phe8
k`m g_phe bd \o`di\ kmd` >`onpmjn
dm e \kbpg\+ Lgb+ +/ I\f+ .0)6 .5+
dfd ntmp f\mdpjh`i k\nd`f >`onp*
m) Fp_\n npnfp]j _\m \kmkdiod ejn
bpg h\dnop) oj_g ed b\gej b\i\
dgb\d g\dftodn kmd` ntmpn dm i`o _\*
mtod kpjg\iod`hn _d_`gdp ipjnojgdp+

%0/& G e\X : X gm T ^ T e b f 4 h\_\pb kp*


nd\pf`ge` o\mk F`mpu\gn dm >`onp*
mjn+ E >`ou\f\mjn dfd >`onpm\d[b\*
gej ]od \kd` .0 fdgjh`omp+ Fp_\n
\oqtfj  d\ d Ij_dij) d fpmd ]pqj
k\ndod\pfn d F`mpu\gn+ =kd` Fp*
_j f\mdpjh`in qd`o ntm\d npdij*
ej d qd`ij d_\qdfj) q\m_p Nj_jfj
%qu+ / I\f+ .0)/.& dm) k\gdf_\hd h\*
 n\qj eb _\gd kmd` \kbpgojn >`o*
npmjn) np qdn\ fdo\ f\mdpjh`i` opj*
e\p km\_ej m`ibodn d fjq kmd` Fp*
_+  %01& MlahbZ\ \e ` be fha'
^ b f( @m\h]gd\d g\]\d hbno m\pbdi*
opn bm\gpn) ]`o) b\q e \ondb`mod)
phdmo n\qj eb8 dpj \oq`ep b\g
ed`hn kmd` k\o fjq odf k\mj_to\
m\p_jijn qtipjbd dm hjm npifjn
dm o\dk epjn odf `mudio\+  %03& 9 a^f'
}\Th((( @m\h]gd\d ]pqj d \ifnoj kmd*
km\odiod kmd` f\mdpjh`in _\gdp) o\dk
f\_ dmed`i`nd]\d_t_\qjdme i`]dej_\*
qj i`d f\m`dqd\d) i`d \mfgd\d+  %04&

Turinys

# H<F+ ( % * & )

*")

^b7 lni^k lbg`neZl obkb obkmnmblmkb*


`bgmZ ]nh) jnb in`gZ[Zgm ]^ln*
i^k7 ^m Dg]nl fZ`blm^k [^lmbZ^+
05 @m k^lb]nnf ^jnbmZmnf abg\ ^m
bg]^ lmZmnbm bg ]nZl iZkm^l)mn[bl
^q^k\bmnf \hffho^k^) ^m i^knk*
`^k^ \hglmbiZmhl bg e^`bhgb[nl
^bbnl+ 06 @m nm k^_nelbm lhe bg \er*
i^hl Znk^hl)^mZ^k^hl) k^lie^g]n*
^kngm fhgm^l Z[ ^bl) ^m k^lie^g*
]n^kngmlb\nm eZfiZ]^l b`gbl+ 1-
@m ]blmbg\mZ ^lmiZkl^q^k\bmnl k^*
`bli^kfhgm^l^q\^elhl)^mZebZi^k
eh\Z anfbebZ7 ^m b[Zgm\Znm^^m hk*
]bgZm^+ 1.' @m \hffho^[Zgmnkhf*
g^l bgaZ[bmZgm^l m^kkZf Z oh\^
fnembmn]bgbl) ^m bg\^lln mnk[Z^) ^m
\heeblbhg^ Zkfhknf7 ^kZm ^gbf
^q^k\bmnl fZ`gnl oZe]^) ^m_hkmbl+
1/ @m ZiikhibZobm en]Zl) ^m ^q^k*
\bmnl ^bnl bg ikZ^ebnf7 ^_\^\b]^*
kngm ]^ ^q^k\bmn k^`bl l^q\^gmb
obkb+ 10 @m ob]bm @e^ZsZk_bebnl NZn*
kZ ngZf ]^ [^lmbbl ehkb\ZmZf eh*
kb\bl k^`bl7 ^m ^kZm^fbg^gl lni^k
\^m^kZl [^lmbZl) ^m oblnf ^lm ^b
jnh] bg ^Z ^ll^m k^q7 11 ^m ]^*
]bm l^ nm eb[^kZk^m ihinenf ln*
nf) ^m Z\jnbk^k^m lb[b ghf^gZ^*
m^kgnf+ 12 @_ \n\nkkbmZ] ^ZfZn*
]Z\m^k bg f^]bh e^`bhgbl bgm^k_b*
\b^gl Z ]^qmkbl) ^m Z lbgblmkbl) ^m
\Z]^[Zgm Z[ ^h an\ Zmjn^ been\+
10 @m bobm ln[ i^]^l ^e^iaZgmbl)
^m lniihlnbml^ ^b) ^mh\\b]bm ^nf7
^m \^\b]bm bg m^kkZf lni^k bilnf)
^m fhkmnnl ^lm beeb\+ 14 @m ob]^g*

iZ[ndeZbl8 Zgm db^dob^gh [hdmh


[noh mkrl ]^bfmrl ]n ]kll or*
kZb) dnkb^ dhohch gnh obkZnl) bk
ob^gZl bg]Zl) `ronebh oZkhoZl+
05 Gbdnlb kZbmZkbc) iZ]Zebgmc ]n
[kbn) cbl iZlmZm ob^gZf^ bk db*
mZf^ hg^) dZ] mkbfbm `Zkln ldZ*
mbgm dZkbnhf^g bk kZ`bgm chl
dZkbdZl ^be^l lnlmZmrmZl fbgbZl+
06 NZne^b Ziob^mnl Zndlbgbnl bk
oZkbgbnl ldr]nl) lnb[h gnh c
dZegZb) bk cb^ [ebs`ch) dZbi eb^i*
lghc b[nkbZb+ 1- Qb^gZ dZkZ*
ebZnl dZkbnhf^gl ]Zebl ch iZ*
lbldbklbnl ZndmZbl dZegZbl) dbmZ
er`nfZ8 cb^ r`bZoh ZmlZk`bZb bk
moZkdbg`Zb+ 1. Qblb Zeb^l `ro^g*
mhcZb [noh b`l]bgmb mhl ]Zn`r*
[l kbdlfh) fbgbhl cbfh bk`bg*
de oZg`cbfh8 g^l mZb [noh eZ*
[Zb ]b]^e bk lmbikb dZkbnhf^g+
1/ En]Zl ln lZoh dZkbnhf^g^ ikb*
lbZkmbgh dhohmb) bk ^bbfmZbfh*
gb b dZkZebZnl dZkbnhf^gldkb*
mh+ 10 FZb NZnkhl lgnl @e^ZsZ*
kZl iZfZm ob^g`rone) Zi]^g`*
m dZkZebdZbl ZkoZbl) dnkl [noh
]b]^lgbl n oblnl dbmnl `ronebnl)
cZf iZlbkh]) dZ] Zgm ch [noh
dZkZebnl+ 11Ebl iZZndhch lZo^) dZ]
b`^e[m lZoh mZnm bk lb`rm lZn
Zfbg oZk]+ 10 ?klbZb cbl [`h
ikb^ ch [kbh ob]nkbn) nfnbg*
]ZfZl [nonlbnl ]^bgc^ bk dZb*
kc^) mZbi dZ] cb^ dkbmh gnh chob^*
ghg bk dbmhg inlg8 13 cbl [`h
mZki ]kZf[ebh dhc bk) lnlmhclih

4 el f W Xy\` gl f Wh( C\gd ]od) f\_ o\n


nf\ddpn fg\d_dib\n) i`n _m\h]gdj
]jfo`gte` ]pqj qd`ojn odf _qd`h \m
omdhn f\m`dqd\hn+ 0/ f\m`dqd\d b\*
gej ]od kmd` fd`fqd`ij _m\h]gdj)
f\_ qd`id fdopn k\q\_pjo ]jfo`gt*
e`+  %05& M \Xah` X \e ^ \gT ` X(((4 f\*
mdpjh`in nk\mipjn`+  %06& 9 h ^f\'
a \h f4 k\\pfnpjopn+ Pjfdpjn nft_pn
opm_\qj q\_\d dm k\ndthe f\m`d*
qd\d+  Jh{\Ub ahb ]h+++ Lj`odf\n
dndm`dfdh\n+  %1-& 9 gfTeZ\T\( Cm

o+7 _mndp dibnidp+  %1/& G e\f \T e'


g\ab ^ b i b g\4 _mnd\d dm h\d kpjg
f\mdpjh`in _\g+  %10& J Th ebf f'
ahf = _XT m T eT f( Pdfmd\p bm+ o+7 Ag`\*
u\m\n =p\m\i\n+  P\dbd edn ]pqj
I\o\odej nipn) q\_di\h\n =]\mj*
dh %. I\f+ /)2&) e\pi`nidn Fp_j ]mj*
gdn+  B TW Tag ]b  Uhib ^TeT_\h f(
Ag`\u\m\n odfejnd) f\_ e\h k\ndn`fn
phpod k\od f\m\gd dm opj ]_p k\*
_\mtod nphddh qdnje` f\mdpjh`i*
e` 8 ]`o \io k\kpjoj _m\h]gdj ]pqj

Turinys

5-5

. H<F+ 3) 1 5 *2 2

ml obkmnm^f k^`bl) ^m bfi^mnf  cnh) nfn c8 mZl ln`kbnoh Zgm
^q^k\bmnl ^bnl) ]bo^km^kngm l^ Z[ ) ^fl obknc^ chch) bk @e^ZsZkZl
^bl+
 m^gZb fbk+ 14 OZbZn r]Zb) fZ*
mr]Zfb dZkZebZnl c ` Z l  bk ch dZ*
kbnhf^gl lfZkdnf) iZlbmkZnd
gnh c+
15FZkZebZnl `b TJ[R^XVNWq ch
15 >ZlmkZ Znm^f k^`bl Zl\^g*
]^kngm \hgmkZ ^hl bg e^knlZe^f) ikb^ cnhl E^knsZel ebgd)bk mZdZ*
^m Ziieb\n^kngm \ZlmkZ k^`bl Z] kbnhf^g [noh lmZmhfZ lmhord*
en]Z^Zf) ^m fhgm^f Nbhg+ 16 @m ehl^ ikb^ En]c bk ikb^ Nbhgh
_^\bm iZ\^f \nf abl) jnb ^kZgm dZeg+ 16 Nn mZbl) dnkb^ [noh =^m*
bg =^malnkZ7 ^m ^qb^kngm ]^ \bob* lnkhc^) cbl iZ]Zk mZbd) bk cb^ b*
mZm^) jnbZ ghg ^kZgm ^bl b[b Zeb* ch  b fb^lmh) g^l m^gZb n]Zkrmb
f^gmZ \hg\enlbl) jnbZ lZ[[ZmZ cb^ g^[^mnkchfZblmh) dZ]Zg`b Z*
^kZgm m^kkZ^+ 2- @m \hfik^a^g]bm ebZb [noh ln[ZmZ+ 2-OZbi dZkZebnl
k^q =^malnkZf7 ^m \hglmbmnbm beeb\ iZf =^mlnk bk iZlmZm m^gZb
lZk`r[ ch l lZn`hmb+
\nlmh]bZf l^koZk^ ^Zf+
2.
@m \hgo^kmbm \ZlmkZ Z] eh* 2.
KZldnb cbl eZbd ]Zn` ]b^*
\nf lZg\mb_b\Zmbhgbl ]b^l fnemhl7 g Zi`nel o^gmc ob^m7 cbl iZ*
^m lmZmnbm beeb\ [ZeblmZl) ^m fZ\ab* lmZm m^gZb fmhf ikb^mZbl bk
gZl) ^m b`gbl bZ\neZ) ^m mhkf^gmZ fZbg) mZblrf n`gbZb f^lmb)
Z] eZib]^l bZ\mZg]hl) ^m lib\neZ) Zdf^gbfl bk b^mbfl) Znmno or*
^m l\hkibhl Z] fbmm^g]Zl lZ`bmmZl) erbhfl bk obeilmrgb+ 2/ OZbiiZm
^m _ng]b[neZ+ 2/ A^\^kngm Znm^f bk r]Zb iZlb]Zk dZkh iZ[de
^m bilb fZ\abgZl Z]o^klnlfZ\ab* ikb^ Zg ikb^mZblnl bk dhohch
gZl ^hknf) ^m in`gZo^kngm ]b^l ]Zn` ]b^g+ 20 =^m fb^lm^ g^[n*
fnemhl+ 20 @l\Z^Znm^fghg ^kZgm oh fZblmh) g^l [noh l^dfb f^*
bg \bobmZm^) ^h jnh] l^imbfnlZg* mZb) bk mb^ iZ`hgrl) dnkb^ [noheb*
gnl ^ll^m7 ^m jnb k^fZgl^kZgm bg d En]chc^) lnoZe` eb^dZgZl mh)
Dn]Z^Z ]^ B^gmb[nl) \hglnfil^* dZl [noh Zmb]mZ+ 21 OZbi o^gmh*
kZgm k^ebjnbZl ^hknf) jnZ^ k^ih* oc^ [noh ebd g^]Zn` fhgb)
lbmZ^ _n^kZgm+ 21 @m k^fZgl^kngm g^l cb^fl [noh Zmcl [Z]Zl) bk
bg lZg\mbl obkbiZn\b)jnhgbZf h[* cb^ blbldbklm) db^dob^gZl  lZoh
mbgn^kZm ^hl _Zf^l7 ^m ]bli^klb ob^m+
lngm ngnljnbljn^ bgeh\nf lnnf+
02
@m Zn]bobm GrlbZl jnh] Kab* 22 Onh mZkin GrsbcZl b`bk]h)
ebiinl) jn^f \hglmbmn^kZm k^q dZ] KberiZl) dnk dZkZebnl <gmbh*
odf k\km\nod f\m`dqd\d+  %14& K T}\Th 
{lWT\(((
Fp_\n m\i_\) f\_ ]pn d*
hdiodibd\p k\ndom\pfod oq\mfje`) i`*
bp _pjodn npi\dfdiod n\q` dm n\qpj*
ndpn ]` k\gtbdidhj nodkm`nid`hn nt*
m\hn+ Fdn k\ndom\pfd\ d F`mpu\g dm d
q`iotfgjn oqdmojq+ Otm\d `di\ k\*
nfpd dm \kbpg\ oqdmojq+
%15& G e\Xy Ah W ]T ( Jjmn ntm f\*
mdpjh`in _\gdn ]pqj k\gdfo\ kmd`
>`onpmjn) o\d\p thd $ejn _\pbph\
kmdnd\modij kmd` F`mpu\gn dm m`ibnd

fjqjod i` odf kmd` o qd`i qd`o)


]`o dm kmd` qdn Fp_ejn \ge+  %16&
: hib fh U T gT 4 np]\odid\d %\odgndj& h`*
o\d) fpmd\dn ]pqj p_m\pno\ f ijmn
nod \m ke\pod+ Lgb+ E+ /0).-+..8 Gpi+
/2). 48 /.)//8 =of+ .2).+++
%20& B he\X Uhib _\^ (((4 \onfdmd nt*
mdw f\mdpjh`in ]md\d+
%22& G \_l c Tf& ^he((( Ru+ \pf+ .1)
.2 `dg+ Eb`g]edh\n t_\hn \o`di\
i`odfo\d+ =iodjfj Akda\ij ej ni\pn
dm q\gnot]n bgj]ep k\nfdmo\n Ldgt*

Turinys

. H<F+ ( '(? (%

/'0

<gmbh\anl) \nf Z]an\ obo^k^m)nm


gnmkbk^m <gmbh\anf  _bebnf lnnf)
^m k^`gZk^m) 23 k^o^klnl ^ll^m Z
L`mnd_`)^m H^]bZ)^m ^q^k\bmnl jnb
Z[b^kZm \nf bilh) ^m jnbZ jnZ^*
k^[Zm lnl\bi^k^ k^`gb g^`hmbZ7
54 _^lmbgZobm bk^) ^m ]b\^k^ Z] k^*
`^f) ^m ]n\^l ^q^k\bmnl7 ?^_b\b*
fnl jnhmb]b^) ^m^l\Zgh[bl fh]b*
\Z ^lm) ^m eh\nl)jn^f h[lb]^fnl)
^lm fngbmnl)^m bg\nf[bmgh[blhk*
]bgZk^ ]^ k^`gh+ 2N Ing\ bmZjn^
]^fnl]^qmkZl ahfbgb[nlblmbl) ^m
_Z\bZfnl \nfbeebl iZ\^f) ^m \nf
hfgb`^gm^^hknf7 26^m\hglmbmnZ*
fnl beebl nm Zf[ne^gm bg e^`bmbfbl
lnbl lb\nm ikbnl) ikhim^k e^`bmbfZ
^gbf bilhknf) jnZ^ ]^li^qbfnl)
bkZmb lngm)^m _^\^kngm hfgbZ aZ^\+
m8w @m ieZ\nbm l^kfhbg \hgli^\mn
k^`bl) ^m ikbg\binf7 ^m fblbm Z]
^hl iZ\^f _Z\^k^7 ^m k^\^i^kngm
beeZf+ 3. @m bnkZobm beebl k^q) ^m
ikbg\bi^l7 ^m ^qb^kngm ]^ fngb*
mbhg^+
3/ @m bgmkZobmk^qfhgm^f Nbhg)
^m ob]bm fngbmbhg^f eh\b7 ^m knibm
\bmbnl bnkZf^gmnf) jnh] bnkZobm7
^m fZg]Zobm ]^lmkn^k^ fnknf bg

dZl) ]Zk `roZl m^[^[]ZfZl)[n*


oh iZldrkl Zndemb lZoh lg
<gmbhd bkob^iZmZnmb) 25 ln`kl
b K^klbchl bk H^]bchl ln dZkbnh*
f^g^) dnkb [noh ln cnh bcnlb)
bk dZ] cbl lm^g`bZlb iZbfmb dZkZ*
erlml k^bdZenl+ 24 Oh]e cbl iZlb*
ldn[bgh ^bmb bk lZdrmb dZkZebnb bk
dZkbnhf^gl oZ]Zfl7 H^l ^bgZ*
f^dZl]b^g lbeigrg) fZblmhfnfl
fZZ) ob^mZ) dnkb eZbdhf^ Zi`n*
e) lnlmbikbgmZ) [^ mh) f^l mnkbf^
kibgmbldZkZerlm^+ 25 OZb`b iZ]nh*
dbf^ ]Z[Zk bmb^fl fhgfl ]^*
bg^l) iZ]Zkrdbf^ mZbd lncZbl be*
ln oblZcmZnmZ 26bk e^bldbf^cb^fl
`ro^gmb lneb` c lmZmrfZbl) dZbi
l^gbZn8 g^l ]e lZoh lmZmrf)
dnkbnhl f^liZgb^dbghf^) cb^ir*
dh bk oblZ mZb iZ]Zk+ 3- OZl iZ*
lberfZl iZmbdh dZkZebnb bk oZ*
]Zfl8 cbl lbngm iZl cnhl mZbdhl
]Zkrmb) bk cb^ c ikbf+ 3. FZkZ*
ebnl bk oZ]Zb cb^fl ikblb^d) bkcb^
bch b mobkmhol+
3/ FZkZebnl) Zmcl  Nbhgh dZe*
g bk iZfZml ob^mhl lnlmbikbgb*
fnl)mnhcZn lneZniZ]Zkrm ikb^*
lZbd bk eb^i ln`kbZnmb lb^gZi*
ebgdnb+
J P NM %
-0
@m ]bl\^llbm _^lmbgZgm^k) ^m 30 Kh mh cbl ldn[bZb iZlbmkZn*
k^o^klnl ^lm <gmbh\abZf) ^m bgo^* d bk ln`kh  <gmbhdbc8 bZ cbl
gbm Kabebiinf ]hfbgZgm^f \bob* kZ]h Kberi oZe]Zgm fb^lm) dh*
mZmb7 ^m in`gZobm Z]o^klnl ^nf) ohch ikb^ c bk Zmf fb^lm+
^m h\\niZobm \bobmZm^f+
k\n bmeo\ d L`mndejn np f\mdpjh`* d g\dnq) ]`o i`ijmej npodfod) f\_ ed`
i`) fpmd  o`i ]pqj k\ndhn =i* opmo qdndf i`kmdfg\pnjht]+ Ot*
m bpg\ k\ndgdfj i` odf >`onpmje`)
odjf\n) dm km\_`_\ d`fjod n\qj o`d*
]`o dm k\dje` F`mpu\ge`) ejn kdgte`+
nd kmdk\didhj+ Htudepd o`if\ _\*
>\itdjn oqdmojqn nd`i\n ed` k\nd*
]\m nfp]diodn  Otmde) dm edn k\_\mj
mkdij ipbmd\pod+ L\d bd ]\itd\
np Fp_p o\df) kmdk\di_\h\n t*
ed` i`o k\b`m] \pfjhdn dm Fp_pd np*
_\hn m`gdbdi g\dnq+  %26& BT\c
o`df o\h odfm odopg+ Lgb+ / I\f+
fXa \T h 4 fjg`d =iodjf\n i`]pqj km\*
.0)/1+
_en fjqjn kmd` t_ m`gdbde+ 
%30& J hZe{b \ 9 a g\b^\]p Cm_\*
%3.& A \ X  \y ]b  \y gi\egbi f( Eedh\n
h\n Htude\n Lojg`h\d_je` opmej qd`*
d oqdmojqn ]pqj k\_\mtojn o\dfjn
\d k\ndo`dndiod _g k\_\mtojn o\dfjn
`ifg\n+
np t_\dn+ Ru+ / I\f+ .0)/2+
%3/& J h_Th{ cTWTelgT& c e \X f T \^ T +
Otm\d bmdij t_\hn odf m`gdbdi

Turinys

5.-

. H<F+ 4) .}4

O! pbO{ VZaZ^ []TPo 7PXP_]TU{ DZ_P]t%


0>KON :33! . <ggh \^gm^lb* u
-
[P]^Vb]TXL^% . bfmZl
fh jnbgjnZ`^lbfh ikbfh ^qbbm i^gdbZl C D SFJ PFO M FNJ FO J DP FO
?^f^mkbnl N^e^n\b _bebnl Z[ nk[^ N^e^ndh lgl ?^f^mkbcnl bor*
MhfZ) ^m Zl\^g]bm \nf iZn\bl dh b Mhfhl fb^lmh) Zmd^ebZoh
obkbl bg \bobmZm^f fZkbmbfZf) ^m ln g^]Zn`^ebn fhgb  iZckbh
k^`gZobm beeb\+ / @m _Z\mnf ^lm) nm fb^lm bk f Pm^gZb dZkZebZnmb+
bg`k^llnl ^lm ]hfnf k^`gb iZ* / <mlbmbdh) dZ]) cZf cnl  lZoh
mknf lnhknf)\hfik^a^g]bm^q^k* mo dZkZerlml gZfnl) dZkbnhf^*
\bmnl <gmbh\anf) ^m GrlbZf) nm g ln`Zoh <gmbhd bkGrsbc) dZ]
Z]]n\^k^gm ^hlZ] ^nf+ 0 @m k^l cnhl Zmo^lm iZl c+ 0 BZolZib^
^b bgghmnbm7 ^m Zbm7 Ihebm^ fbab hl* mZb bgb)7cbl mZk7 I^kh]rdbm^ fZg
m^g]^k^ _Z\b^f ^hknf+ 1 @m h\\b* c o^b]h+ 1 FZkbnhf^g nfn
]bm ^hl ^q^k\bmnl+ @m l^]bm ?^* cnh]n) bk ?^f^mkbcnl Zmlbl]hlZ*
f^mkbnl lni^k l^]^f k^`gb lnb7
oh dZkZerlml lhlmZg+
2 Onhf^m Zmch iZl c g^]hk
2 ^m o^g^kngm Z] ^nfobkb bgb*
jnb ^m bfibb ^q DlkZ^e7 ^m <e\bbgnl bk [^]b^ob fhgb b DskZ^ebh ln
]nq ^hknf) jnb ohe^[Zm _b^kb lZ* lZoh oZ]n <edbfn) dnkl ghkch
\^k]hl+ 3 @m Z\\nlZo^kngm ih* [mb dngb`Zl+ 3 Eb^ ldng] mZnm
inenf Zin] k^`^f) ]b\^gm^l7 K^k* dZkZebnb) lZdr]Zfb7 En]Zl bk ch
]b]bm en]Zl) \m _kZmk^l^bnl hfg^l [khebZb gnn] oblnl mZoh ikb^m^*
Zfb\hl mnhl) ^m ghl ]bli^klbm ]^ ebnl bk boZk fnl b fl Z*
m^kkZ ghlmkZ+ 4 Ing\ ^k`h fbmm^ eb^l+ 4 OZb`b ]Z[Zk lbld fh`)
obknf) \nb \k^]bl) nm ^Zm) ^m ob* cb dnkbZf mbdb) dZ] cbl ^bm bk iZfZ*
]^Zm ^qm^kfbgbnf hfg^) jnh] _^*  mrm obl lngZbdbgbf) dhd ZgZl

4).2-+ Otmdejn njno k\dh\ @`*


h`omdepn %.1&+ =gfdhj k\fpmnoto\n
edn ndpid\ kmd` t_pn >\fd_) fpmn
o\d\p Fp_j ipb\god i`no`ibd\ %2
/2&+ =ondpno\n fdo\n q\_\n) Jdf\ij*
m\n) _p f\mop Fp_j ipb\gdh\n dm k\on
i\ fjqje` %/314&+ Jpb\gedhpd
k\hdiod t_\d k\nfdmd\ h`odi q`i*
o %152-&+
%4).& x \` gTf(((4 .3. h+ kdmh Gm+
 J X_Xh ^ b  fahf < X` Xge\]hf( O`g`i*
do\n ER Bdgjk\ojmdn ]pqj qtm`nidn
=iodjfj Akda\ij ]mjgdn+ O`g`pfpd
hdmo\io) ej nipn @`h`omdepn ]pqj
g\dfjh\n f\dop Njhje`8 oj_g ej _*
_`d =iodjfpd Akda\ipd k\qtfj k\dhod
Otmdejn njno+ G\d =iodjf\n hdm)
@`h`omdepn) qdn _\m o`]`]_\h\n Nj*
hje`) q`gopd no`ibnd \ob\pod g\dnq+
G\_\ibd Njhjn n`i(\n \ondn\f np*
o`dfo e\h g`d_dh) edn) Ljgt]de\pn k\*
_`_\h\n) k\]bj ng\kd\ dm \oqtfj d
Otmde+ Fdn ]pqj opjh`o /0 h`op+
 , cT] e\b ` \Xfg( =ijo / I\f+ .1).)
 Pmdkjg+ Lm\_dje` f\mdpjh`in edn

opmej g\]\d h\\+ G\_\ibd o\d\p


Htude\n ]pqj Otmdeje` i`f`id\h\n)
o\d \kgdif @`h`omde km\_ej bm`dop
g\dfp mdifodn qdnd i`k\o`ifdiod`ed8 ed`
d_\q e\h Htude np e\pip =iodjfp)
fpmdpjn @`h`omdepn gd`k ipp_tod+
Lj fjfdj g\dfj e\h k\qtfj db\pod
n\p dm+d Njhjn n`i\oj f\m\gd\pn o`d*
ndp kmdk\didh+  %0& E XebW l ^\gX
`Ta((( G\n i`]pqj q`mo\n h\otod f\*
m\gd\pn q`d_ dm oj_g opmej hdmod)
o\h ]pqj p_`ibd\h\n q`d_\n+ Lgb+
no+ 4)5+
%2& 9 _^\` h) ^hef((( t_df\n ej
q\m_\n opmej ]od Agd\fdh\n+ Fdn
kmdfg\pn d =\mjij fdgpndp fpidb
`dhti\d+ =iodjfj Akda\ij g\df\dn
edn ]pqj kmdndo\dfn kmd` k\bjidp
kmjdp #, I\f+ .1)0& dm ijmej _\*
]\m db\pod n\p qtmd\pndjej fpidbj
o`dndp kmdk\didh+ pqpn qtmd\pnd\h
fpidbpd I`i`g\epd %/ I\f+ .0)0+++&)
e\h ojn o`dnn ]pqj kmdk\diojn =i*
odjfj Apk\ojmdj dm ej bgj]ej Htud*
j) ]`o dodfdhd no\othpd t_\d dfd

Turinys

. H<F+ 4) 5}.4

5..

\bm gh[bl) ^m k^`bhgb[nl k^`bl7 ^m iZ]Zk fnfl bk dZkZebZnl dkZ*
:?84,>9780=,74.9=04?=0>Z]bn* mZfl) bk dZ] gn[Znlm oblnl ch
ikb^m^ebnl bk ch iZ]ccnl+
mhk^l ^hknf+
5 FZkZebnl bkbgdhb lZoh ikb^*
5 @m ^e^`bm k^q ^q Zfb\bl lnbl
=Z\\ab]^f)jnb]hfbgZ[ZmnkmkZgl m^eb mZkih=Zdb]) dnkl [noh oZe*
_enf^g fZ`gnf bg k^`gh) ^m _b* ]hoZl ZgZinl nil) [noh dZkZ*
]^e^f k^`b7 ^m fblbm ^nf) 6 nmob* erlml ]b]bgZl bk bmbdbfZl dZ*
]^k^m ^qm^kfbgbnf) jnh] _^\bm en* kZebnb+ O cbl iZlbngm 6 iZfZmrmb
]Zl7 l^]^m <e\bfnf bfibnf \hg* En]h iZ]Zkrmh lngZbdbgbfh8 [^
lmbmnbm bg lZ\^k]hmbnf) ^m fZg]Z* mh) cbl iZldrk dngb`n [^]b^o <e*
obm ^b _Z\^k^ nembhg^f bg _bebhl Dl* dbbg bk iZo^] cZf Zmd^krmb Ds*
kZ^e+ .- @m lnkk^q^kngm) ^m o^g^* kZ^ebh oZbdZfl+ .- Eb^ iZdbeh) Zm*
kngm \nf ^q^k\bmn fZ`gh bg m^k* ch ln ]b]^e^ dZkbnhf^g^  En]h
kZf Dn]Z7 ^m fbl^kngm gng\bhl)^m Ze bk lbngm iZlbngmbgbnliZlEn *
eh\nmb lngm Z] en]Zf) ^m Z] _kZ* ] bk ch [khebnl dZe[mbl mZbdbZbl
mk^l ^bnl o^k[bl iZ\b_b\bl bg ]heh+ h]bZbl) mZbZn deZlmbg`Zb+ .. =^m
.. @m ghg bgm^g]^kngm l^kfhgb* mb^ g^bkch c h]b) g^l fZ*
[nl ^hknf7 ob]^kngm ^gbf jnbZ m) dZ] cb^ Zmchln ]b]^e^ dZkbnh*
f^g^+
o^g^kngm \nf ^q^k\bmn fZ`gh+
Onhf^m iZl <edbf bk =Z*
./
@m \hgo^g^kngmZ]<e\bfnf) ./
^m =Z\\ab]^f \hg`k^`Zmbh l\kb[Z* db] lnlbch kZmh bgho [krl
knf k^jnbk^k^ jnZ^ bnlmZ lngm7 b^dhmb) dZl m^blbg`Z+ .0 Kbkfb b
.0 ^m ikbfb) <llb]Z^b jnb ^kZgmbg DskZ^ebh oZbd) dnkb^ b^dhch c
_bebbl DlkZ^e) ^m ^qjnbk^[Zgm Z[ ^bl mZbdhl) [noh Zlb]Zb) Cg^l cb^ fZ*
iZ\^f+ .1 ?bq^kngm ^gbf7 Chfh g7 <mch <Zkhgh `bfbgl dngb*
lZ\^k]hl ]^ l^fbg^ <Zkhg o^gbm) `Zl) cbl fl g^ikb`Znl+ .2 Ebl
ghg ]^\bib^m ghl7 .2 ^m eh\nmnl dZe[ch cb^fl mZbdhl h]bnl bk
^lm \nf ^bl o^k[Z iZ\b_b\Z7 ^mbn* cb^fl ikblb^d) lZdr]ZfZl7 H^l
kZobm beebl) ]b\^gl7 Ihg bg_^k^fnl g^]Zkrlbf^ ibdmZ g^b cnfl) g^b
oh[bl fZenf) g^jn^ Zfb\bl o^l* cl ikb^m^ebZfl+ .3 Eb^mbdchcZf8
mkbl+ .3 @m \k^]b]^kngm ^b7 @m \hf* [^m cbl ln`Zoh c ^bZl ]^bfmbl
ik^a^g]bm ^q ^bl l^qZ`bgmZ obmhl) ork bk nfn cnhl ob^gZ ]b^*
^m h\\b]bm ^hl bg ngZ ]b^ l^\ng* gZ)Zghmh]b) dnkb^rkZiZkZrmb7
]nf o^k[nf) jnh] l\kbimnf ^lm7 .4 OZoh o^gmc dgnl bkc dkZn*
.4 >Zkg^l lZg\mhknf mnhknf) ^m ccb^ beb^chZiebgd E^knsZe) bk g*
lZg`nbg^f bilhknf ^__n]^kngm
bg \bk\nbmn D^knlZe^f) ^m ghg ^kZm

d\h g\dfpd qtmd\pndjej fpidbj o`dnd c


%.0& 6 L k R V Q V  Qw  [ H P R V Z ,  omjfj m\*
=gfdhpd i`kmdk\dij+  %3& 7 P L ,  t*
h\pn dm o\df\pn btq`idhj+  %.1&
_\d ntm \gdidif\d+
/ H Y V U V  N P T P U s Z  R \ U PN H Z &  Fdn i`]pqj
%5& 0 H R P K p $ R \ Y Z &&& ( Fdn ]pqj f\*  d ojn qtmd\pnde fpidb `dhtijn)
m\gd\pn qd`odidif\n kmjqdi^dejn` \i\* d fpmdjn \did\d opmej o`dnn k\q`g_od
kpn Apkm\oj+  %.-& A H PR PH PZ  m V %
qtmd\pndjej fpidbj k\m`db\n) ]`o o\m*
K m PH PZ $ [H n PH \  R SH Z [ PU N H P& 
P\dfjn dm _\hd`n np epj) f\d fpmd` kmdk\dij
g\dnqn k\\_\dn) fpmd i`h\i g\d* ed qtmd\pndpjep fpidbp8 ed` odfejnd
b\gndp m\hd\d dm g\dnq\d g\dftodn
ftodn) ed` no`ibnd m\nod n\p \gdidi*
f o\mk Fp_j kmd`o`gd) \nd_ dm N\* no\othj+  %.3& @ \ N H ] V  Qw  k L k P H Z &&&,
b\g opjn) fpmd` \ifnd\p ]pqj k\nd*
oj dijq+

Turinys

/()

' l 2 < $ -" '.d (+

jnb l^i^ebk^m+ '.45.6 @m bg\n[nbm mb* [noh) dZl cnhl iZeZb]hm+ .5 =Zb*
fhk) ^m mk^fhk bg hfg^f ihin* f bk b`lmbl Zif obl mZnm)
enf7 jnbZ ]bq^kngm7 Ihg ^lm o^* bk cb^ lZd7 IkZ iZl cnhl mb^lhl
kbmZl) ^mbn]b\bnf bg ^bl7 mkZgl`k^l* bk m^blr[l) g^l cb^ lneZn lnmZk*
lb lngm ^gbf \hglmbmnmnf) ^mbnl* m # &  % ! " ! & ) ( , $ ,  ikb^lZbd+
bnkZg]nf jnh] bnkZo^kngm+
.6
@m fhobm =Z\\ab]^l \ZlmkZ .6
Kh mh =Zdb]Zl iZlbmkZnd
Z[D^knlZe^f) ^m Ziieb\nbm bg =^ma* gnh E^knsZel bk iZ]Zk lmhorde
s^\aZ7 ^m fblbm) ^m \hfik^a^g* =^ms^dhc^+ Ebl lbngm bk ln`Zoh
]bm fnemhl ^q ^bl) jnb Z l^ ^__n* ]Zn` m) dnkb^ [noh gnh ch iZ*
`^kZgm) ^m jnhl]Zf ]^ ihineh [`) gnn] dZb dnkbnhl bmZn*
fZ\mZobm) ^m bg inm^nf fZ`gnf mhl bk f^m c ]b]^e nebg+ /- Z*
ikhb^\bm+ /-' @m \hffblbm k^`bhg^f e cbl iZo^] <edbfnb bkiZebdh ln
<e\bfh) ^m k^ebjnbm \nf ^h Znqb* cnh dZkbnhf^gl cZf iZ]mb+ KZml
ebnf bg Z]bnmhkbnf bilb+ @m Z[bbm `b =Zdb]Zl ln`kh iZl dZkZeb+
=Z\\ab]^l Z] k^`^f7
<edbfZl ]Zn` ]Zk lZoh
/.
^m lZmblZ`^[Zm <e\bfnl ikh /.
ikbg\biZmn lZ\^k]hmbb lnb+ // ^m orkbZnlbZb dngb`rlm^b iZeZbdrmb+
\hgo^g^kngm Z] ^nf hfg^l) jnb // Kkb^ ch lnlbkbgdh oblb) dnkb^
i^kmnk[Z[Zgm ihinenf lnnf) ^m ]knflm lZoh mZnmhl kZfr[)iZ*
h[mbgn^kngm m^kkZf Dn]Z) ^m _^\^* f lZoh oZe]bhg En]h Ze bk
kngm ieZ`Zf fZ`gZf bg DlkZ^e+ ]Zk ]Zn` ibdmh DskZ^erc^+ /0 En*
/0 @m ob]bmen]ZlhfgbZ fZeZ jnZ^ ]Zl) fZmr]ZfZl oblZ ibdmZ) dnk
_^\bm <e\bfnl)^m jnb\nf ^h^kZgm) ]Zk <edbfZl bk ln cn h [nonlb^cb
_bebblDlkZ^e)fnemh ienl jnZf B^g* DskZ^ebh oZbdZfl) ]Zn` ]Zn`bZn)
m^l) /1^m^qbbmbghfg^l_bg^l Dn]Z^* dZbi iZ`hgrl) /1 ch Ziebgd i^k
^Z bg \bk\nbmn) ^m _^\bm obg]b\mZf obl En]chl iehm bk d^kbch Zm*
bg obkhl ]^l^kmhk^l) ^m \^llZo^* inheebZfl) mZbi dZ] cb^ebholb c
kngm nemkZ ^qbk^ bg k^`bhg^f +/2Qb*  Ze+ /2<edbfZl`b)iZfZml) dZ]
]bm Znm^f <e\bfnl jnh] ikZ^oZ* En]Zl bk ln cnh [nonlb^cb) lmbi*
enbm en]Zl) ^m jnb \nf ^h ^kZgm7 k^lgb n c) bk lnikZml) dZ] g^*
^m \h`ghobm jnbZ ghg ihm^lm ln* `Zeb cb^fl iZlbikb^bgmb) ln`kh
lmbg^k^ ^hl) ^m k^`k^llnl ^lm Z] iZl dZkZeb bk Zildng] cnhl ]e
k^`^f) ^m Z\\nlZobm ^hl fnembl ]Zn`^ebh dZemr[b+
\kbfbgb[nl+

j_ _d_`nid\dn ej kmd`didif\dn+


%.4& K T i b yiXag](((4 \nd_+ Lgb+ Ln+
45)4+/+0+
%.6& : X gm X ^ b ]X 4 b\g \io f\gi`gdj
+ d\pm ipj F`mpu\gn) f\h` qgd\p
\ondm\_j F`mpu\gn kmd`hd`nodn >`*
_u`o\+  Ehb ]b  c T U Z 4 fpmd` ]pqj
qdmo ntm \gdidif\dn) ]`o npkm\o
=gfdhj dm >\fd_j fg\nodibph) bmd*
j kmd` n\qj odfedhj+  B T\ ^he\hbf
\y gT h gb f4 k\ndmj_dpndpn o\md\h\dn
qd`ojn btq`iojepn+  %/.& <V`Z W T ' )
e((( Em b`mpjep) dm nhpmop no`ibnd e
db\pod n\p qtmd\pndjej fpidbj o`d* 

ndp kmdk\didh+  %//& < eh` fg(((4


no`ibnd
\odom\pfod fpj_\pbd\pnd\
hjid ipj no\othj g\dfthj+ 
%/1& ]b  Tc_\a^((( Fp_j f\mdpjh`i
fjqjn` ]pqj npndgkiepnd8 \nd_\d ipj
ejn \ondnftm8 o\po\ ]pqj g\]\d ]\p*
bdio\+ P\dbd ijmn edn _\]\m i`b\gej
nojod d \oqdm fjq kmd` ntmpn) o\*
d\p edn i`ndgdjq k`mn`fdjen =gfdhj
k\ndpiodidpn dm kmdq`mo epjn k\ndgdfod
hd`no md]jn`+  %/2& J hZe{b cTf
^ T eT _\ 4 @`h`omde+ Ad_\h\n k\n f\*
m\gd) =gfdh\n ipi` e\h b\i\ _d*
_`gdp _jq\i+ Lgb+ / I\f+ .1)1 .-+

Turinys

. H<F+ 4) /3}00

/0 @m fblbm k^q Ib\Zghk^f)

/3

5.0

Onhf^m dZkZebnl lbngm ob^*

?8?7 ^q ikbg\bib[nl lnbl gh[b* 8 g lZoh dbegbZnlb oZ]) IbdZgh*

ebhkb[nl7 jnb ^kZm bgbfb\bmbZl ^q^k* k) dnkl [noh eZ[Zb g^ikb^m^ebg*
\^gl \hgmkZ DlkZ^e7 ^m fZg]Zobm ^b `Zl DskZ^ebnb) bk iZo^] cZf ln*
^o^km^k^ ihinenf+ /4 @mo^gbmIb* gZbdbgmb mZnm+ /4 IbdZghkZl Zmch
\Zghk bg e^knlZe^f \nf ^q^k\bmn  E^knsZe ln ]b]^e^ dZkbnhf^g^
fZ`gh) ^m fblbm Z] en]Zf ^m Z] bk lbngm iZl En] bk ch [khebnl
_kZmk^l ^bnl o^k[bl iZ\b_b\bl \nf ln mZbdbZbl h]bZbl) mZbZn deZl*
]heh) /5 ]b\^gl7 Ihg lbm in`gZ mbg`Zb) /5 lZdr]ZfZl7 O^g^[gb^
bgm^k f^ ^m ohl7 o^gbZf \nf ob* dhohl mZki fZgl bk mZki cl+
kbl iZn\bl) nm ob]^Zf _Z\b^l o^l* < Zm^blbn ln g^]Zn`^ebn ork mZb*
mkZl \nf iZ\^+ /6 @m o^gbm Z]en* dbZb iZfZmrmb cl o^b]+ /6 Ebl
]Zf) ^m lZenmZo^kngm l^ bgob\^f Zmch iZl En]) bkcb^iZlblo^bdbgh
iZ\b_b\^7 ^m ahlm^l iZkZmb ^kZgm kZ* mZbdbZb8 [^m ikb^Zb [noh ikblbk^g*
` gnmo^kmb En]+
i^k^ en]Zf+
0- @m bgghmnbm l^kfh Dn]Z^
0- bgbZ) dZ] cbl [noh Zmcl
jnhgbZf \nf ]heh o^g^kZm Z] iZl c ln orebnfb) iZlb^d En])
^nf7 ^m \hgm^kkbmnl ^lm Z[ ^h)^m mh]e [bch]ZfZl ch cbl g^[^ghk*
Zfiebnlghenbm ob]^k^ _Z\b^f ^bnl+ ch ]Zn`bZn ln cnh fZmrmbl+ 0. Ib*
0. @m \h`ghobm Ib\Zghk jnhgbZf dZghkZl lnikZmh) dZ] ch lnfZgr*
]^gn]Zmnf ^lm \hglbebnf ^bnl7 fZl Zmb]^g`mZl) bk bch dhohmb
^m ^qbobm h[obZf Dn]Z^ bg in`* ikb^ En] ikb^ FZiZklZeZfhl+
gZf bnqmZ >ZiaZklZeZfZ+ 0/ @m 0/ D IbdZghkh dZkbnhf^gl dkb*
\^\b]^kngm ]^ Ib\Zghkbl ^q^k\bmn mh Zib^ i^gdbl mdlmZgbnl ork)
_^k^ jnbgjn^ fbeebZ obkb) ^m _n`^* dbmb iZ[`h  ?hob]h fb^lm+
kngm bg \bobmZm^f ?Zob]+
00
@m ihlm aZ^\ o^k[Z Zl\^g* u
 00
Kh mordbIbdZghkZl Zm*
]bm Ib\Zghk bg fhgm^f Nbhg7 ^m Q ch c Nbhgh dZeg+ FZb dnkb^ mZn*
%/3& E \^Ta be( Fdn e\p ]pqj qd`*
i f\mo t_p nphpo\n %g I\f+ 0)
0O8 1)38 / I\f+ 5)6+++&+ =ijo / I\f+
.1)./) Jdf\ijm\n ]pqn _m\h]gdp qdm*
didif\n+ Bg+ Fpju\kj k\n\fjedhp)
edn ]pqn qd`i\n \modhd\pndp @`*
h`omde\pn kmd`o`gd+ C\gd ]od) f\_
Jdf\ijm\n) hdmpn =iodjfpd Akda\ipd)
k\qt__\h\n Htudepd ej o\fjn
Otmdeje`) ]pqj ipqtfn Njhji dm
d\ kmdnd_en kmd` @`h`omde\pn \gd*
idifp+  %/6& A \f  T g ]b  c Tf Ah W ((
Jdf\ijm\n ej  Fp_e np n\fthp
ipm\hdiod o fm\o) k\\gdi\io Fp*
_) dm ej \gdidifpn+ P\d\p ej f\*
mdpjh`i opmej ]od i`_d_`g8 oj_g
kj kdmhj e\h k\qtfpndj npndmhdhj
np Fp_j ]mjgdp Odhjip %/ I\f+ .1)
.3+++& Jdf\ijm\n no`ibnd b`mpjep np*
ndo\mod np Fp_p+ Otm k\ndpiodid\d f\g*
]ej Fp_pd k\d\h k\ndh\otod np Jd*
f\ijmp) fpmdj k\o\md\h\n edn i`o q`*
_ hji+ Jjmn Jdf\ijm\n _\m nph\*

dij n\qj f\mdpjh`i) Fp_\n o\d\p


i`qdn\d epj k\ndodfej dm g\dfnd \on\m*
bd\d+ Pjfd\ _\gtfp k\_odhd i`k\o`i*
fdio\n =gfdh\n qg qtfno\ k\n @`*
h`omde dm b\pi\ d ej n\fth Jd*
f\ijmpd npb\pod Fp_ dm \ob\]`iod 
=iodjfde %/ I\f+ .1)/3&+ Fp_\n np
n\qj \gdidifp ]mdp k\]b\ d f\gipn
%/ I\f+ .1)/5&+ Jdf\ijm\n) fpmn km\*
_dje` i`opmd _d_`gdj ijmj bmd`]odn
nh\mf`nid kmd`hjid kmd` Fp_) kj
_d_`nidj npndmhdhj np epj kmd` G\*
k\mn\g\hjn qg km\_`_\ ]\dnd\d i`*
fnod t_+
%0.& G e\X B T c T efT _T ` b f( Oke\*
h\) f\_ ejn qd`o\ ]pqj d kd`opn ipj
F`mpu\gn+  %0/& G Xa ^ \f g ^fgTa '
}\hf( Otm+ q`modh` dm f\d fpmdpjn`
 bm+ m\ifm\dpjn`7 k`ifdn dhopn+ C\g
dn nf\ddpn ]pn* odfm`nidn+  , <b'
Q
 M\Wb ` \Xfg 4 d F`mpu\gn kdg+

%00& , J \ba b ^ T _a 4 d ]\itdjn
 f\gi+ =iodjf\n Apk\ojmdn ]pqj gd`*

Turinys

5.1

. H<F+ 4) 0 1 *1 /

^qb^kngm ]^ lZ\^k]hmb[nl ihineb mhl dngb`Zb bch iZlo^bdbgmb ch


lZenmZk^ ^nf bg iZ\^) ^m ]^fhg* mZbdbZb bk8iZkh]rmb cZf]^`bgZf*
lmkZk^ ^baheh\ZnmhfZmZ)jnZ^h__^* c Znd) dnkbhl [noh ZndhcZfhl
k^[Zgmnk ikh k^`^+ 01 @m bkkb]^gl n dZkZeb+ 01 =^m cbl mrbh]Zfhl
lik^obm ^hl) ^m iheenbm7 ^m eh\n* iZgb^dbgh cnhl bk lnm^i8cbl dZe*
mnl ^lm lni^k[^) 02^m bnkZobm\nf [ch b]b]bZb 02 bk ikblb^d ln
bkZ) ]b\^gl7 Iblb mkZ]bmnl _n^kbm en* irdbn) lZdr]ZfZl7 E^b En]Zl ln
]Zl) ^m ^q^k\bmnl ^bnl bg fZgnl ch dZkbnhf^g^ g^[nl b]nhmZl 
f^Zl) \hgmbgnh \nf k^`k^llnl fZgh kZgdZl) mnhcZn) dZbi mbdlo^b*
_n^kh bg iZ\^)ln\\^g]Zf ]hfnf dZl ln`kbn)Z ln]^`bglbn bmnhl
blmZf+ @m ^qbbm \nf bkZ fZ`gZ+ gZfnl+ Dk cbl bch ln ]b]^e^kl*
03 @m bgmkZo^kngm lZ\^k]hm^l) ^m mr[^+ 03 Onhf^m dngb`Zb ch) Zmlb*
lm^m^kngm Zgm^ _Z\b^f ZemZkbl ^m lmhch mb^l Zemhkbnfbbk[ZgrbZ bk
m^fieb7 ^m _e^gm^l ]bq^kngm7 04 On o^kd]Zfb lZd7 04 On) Qb^iZmb^)
?hfbg^ ^e^`blmb ]hfnfblmZfZ] blbkbgdZb bmnhl gZfnl) dZ] cnh*
bgoh\Zg]nf ghf^g mnnf bg ^Z) l^ [m ZndbZfZlb mZoh oZk]h)
nm ^ll^m ]hfnl hkZmbhgbl ^m h[* dZ] mZb [m mZoh mZnmZb fZe]hl
l^\kZmbhgbl ihineh mnh) 05 _Z\obg* bk ikZrfh gZfZb+ 05 <md^krd
]b\mZf bg ahfbg^ blmh) ^m ^q^k* bmZf fh`nb bk ch dZkbnhf^g^b)
\bmn ^bnl) ^m\Z]Zgm bg `eZ]bh7 f ^* bkm^`ne cb^dkbgmZ ihdZeZobcn+ <mlb*
f^gmh [eZlia^fbZl ^hknf) ^m g^ fbgdc ibdmh]bZobfnlbkg^e^bld
]^]^kbl ^bl nm i^kfZg^Zgm+
cb^fl bebdmb lo^bdb^fl+
0/
@m ^qbbm Ib\Zghk Z[ D^knlZ* 06
IbdZghkZl bch b E^knsZ*
D^f) ^m \ZlmkZ Ziieb\nbmZ]=^mah* el bk iZlb]Zk lmhorde ikb^ =^m*
khg7 ^m h\\nkkbm beeb ^q^k\bmnl ahkhgh8 m^gZb iZlbmbdh c Nrkbchl
NrkbZ^+ 1- @m en]Zl Ziieb\nbm bg dZkbnhf^g+ 1- En]Zl lnlmhch
<]ZklZ \nf mkb[nl fbeeb[nl obkbl7 <]Zklhc^ ln mkbfbl mdlmZgbZbl
^m hkZobm en]Zl) ^m ]bqbm7 1. Lnb ork+ En]Zl f^e]lb bk dZe[ch7
fbllb ^kZgm Z k^`^ N^ggZ\a^kb[) 1. FZb dZkZebZnl N^gZd^kb[h Zm*
?hfbg^) jnbZ[eZlia^fZo^kngm m^) lblmb^cb ibdmh]bZoh mZn) Qb^*
^qbbm Zg`^enl) ^m i^k\nllbm ^q ^bl iZmb^) bch Zg`^eZl bk nfn
\^gmnf h\mh`bgmZjnbgjn^ fbeebZ7 cbfm ZmnhgbZl]^bfmbl i^gdbl
1/ lb\ \hgm^k^ ^q^k\bmnf blmnfbg mdlmZgbnl+ 1/ OZbi lnmkbgdbZg*
\hgli^\mn ghlmkh ah]b^7 ^m l\bZgm ]b^g fl ZdboZbs]hc^bm dZkbnh*
\^m^kb jnbZ fZe^ eh\nmnl ^lm ln* f^g8 m^`ne dbmb bgh) dZ] cbl ibd*
i^k lZg\mZ mnZ7 ^m bn]b\Z beenf mZb dZe[ch Zib^ mZoho^gm ob^m)
kn ipbmd\pod dj nd`i\n %3)0/&) oj_g
t_\d _\]\m i`]`b\gej ej bdiod+ Lgb+
. Au_mj 3).-8 F`m+ /6)4+  %02& E X'
Uhf( Cm+ o+7 i`]pn opje\p+  Jh Ze'
y\h((( mj_tod) f\_ o\d i`]pqj opd\n
bm\nth\n) edn gd`k npdhod qd`i t*
hd\pnde F`mpu\gn btq`iojep) fpmn
]pqj g\]\d dodfdh\n no\othpd) b\g
h\it_\h\n ipjhd\d ee ipp_tod %/
I\f+ 3).5+++8 4).+++&+ Rdnp b`m]d\h\n
n`idn i`k\ijmej k\nd_pjod ej k\nd*
otdjedhpd dm _g oj k\on ipndp_
%/ I\f+ .1)0413&+  @y]b ((( Otm\d

qdnp kdmh\ ipej d O\h\mdejn kmj*


qdi^de) f\h` ed` odfejnd npb\pnd
Fp_ np]\ojn _d`i+ Lj oj ed` k\*
npfj d >`ocjmji) f\h` epjn k\ndod*
fj d d\pmn \o`di\iod f\mdpjh`i+
 %04& D T_Wbf \e((( Lgb+ 0 G\m+ 5)/6+++
%06& G e\X : Xg[beba b((( Ru+ \pf+ 0)
.3 dm / I\f+ .2). 03+  %1-& 9 W Te'
fb ]X((( =ijo Bg+ Fpju\kj dm Apu`]d*
e\pn) ed ]pqpnd 0- q\mni \onop ipj
>`ocjmjij) Cjoijn f\dhtitnoe`+ 
%1.& B T\ ^TeT_\Th f((( Ru+ 1 G\m+ .6)028
Pj]+ .)/.8 Afgd+ 15/1+  %10& G eT'

Turinys

. H<F+ 4) 10}5) D

ND2

l^\ng]nf fZebmbZf beebnl) 10 @m bk m^bld c) bk]ZfZl ch ibdmnfh+

.9774=0<?8> 0A0<.4>?= ikZ^ebnf 10 FZkbnhf^gl ikZ]ch dhomkr*


10<14,/0.47, /40 f^glbl <]Zk7 ^m ebdmhc^ <]Zkh fg^lbh ]b^ghc^8

\hgmkbmZ lngm \ZlmkZ Ib\Zghkbl)^m IbdZghkh dZkbnhf^g [noh ln*


\^\b]bm bil^ ikbfnl bg ikZ^ebh+ mkbgmZ) bk cbl iZml dkbmh ibkfZl dh*
11 Pm Znm^f ob]bm ^q^k\bmnl ^bnl ohc^+ 11 FZbi mbd ch dZkbnhf^g
jnbZ \^\b]bll^m Ib\Zghk) ikhb^\^* iZfZm) dZ] IbdZghkZl dkbmh) cb^
kngm ZkfZ lnZ) ^m _n`^kngm7 12 ^m f^m lZoh `bgdenl bk f [`mb+
i^kl^\nmb lngm ^hl obZf ngbnl 12 r]Zb obchlb cnhl ob^ghl ]b^*
]b^b Z[ <]Zs^k nljn^jnh o^gbZ* ghl d^eb gnh <]Zs^kbh bdb ^bgZgm
mnk bg BZsZkZ) ^mmn[bl \^\bg^kngm c BZsZk bk mkbfbmZoh iZldnbcnhl
ihlm ^hl \nf lb`gb_b\Zmbhgb[nl7 mkbfbmZbl) ]nh]Zfb^gde+13fh*
1eb ^m ^qb^kngm ]^ hfgb[nl \Zlm^e* gl b En]chl lh]b Ziebgdnb
ebl en]Z^Z^ bg \bk\nbmn) ^m o^gmb* ch bk lfZkdbZb inhe cnhl bh*
eZ[Zgm ^hl \hkgb[nl) ^m \hgo^km^* g8 mb^ oe `klb  cnhl bk oblb
[Zgmnk bm^knf Z] ^hl) ^m \^\b]^* dkbmh ihdZeZobcn) mZbi dZ] g^ebdh
kngm hfg^l `eZ]bh) ^m ghg ^lm g ob^gh+
k^eb\mnl ^q ^bl g^\ ngnl+
14
@m Z\\^i^kngm lihebZ ^hknf 14
Eb^ iZlbf lZn c `kh[)
bg ikZ^]Zf7 ^m \Zinm Ib\Zghkbl gndbkmh IbdZghknb `Zeo bk ch]^
ZfinmZo^kngm) ^m ]^qm^bZf ^bnl) bg) dnkb [nohb]b]bZbbmb^ll)
jnZf ^qm^g]^kZm lni^k[^) ^mZmmn* Zmlbg^ bk iZdZ[bgh mb^lE^knsZe^+
e^kngm)^m lnli^g]^kngm \hgmkZ D^* 1N OZnmZ eZ[Zb ]bZn`lb bk ikZ*
knlZe^f+ 15 @m eZ^mZmnl ^lm ihin* e^b]h m ]b^g ]b]^ec^ ebgdlfr*
enl oZe]^) ^m ^`^kngm ]b^f beeZf [c^+ 16 =noh lZdrmZ olmb m
bg eZ^mbmbZ fZ`gZ+ 16 @m \hglmbmnbm ]b^g dZl f^mZb mkrebdmhc^ Z]Zkh
Z`b hfgb[nl Zggbl ]b^f blmZf fg^lbh ]b^ghc^+
m^kmbZ]^\bfZ ]b^ f^glbl <]Zk+
Kh mh En]h Zeblmnkch kZ*
2-
@m lbenbm m^kkZ Dn]Z ]b^l 2-
iZn\hl+
fr[l g^]Zn` ]b^g+

P! pbO{ ^LYOZ]L ^` CZXwYLT^%


6L[`_ G;;;% . @m Zn]bobm en*
]Zl ghf^g MhfZghknf) jnbZ
lngm ihm^gm^l obkb[nl) ^m Z\jnb^*
l\ngm Z] hfgbZ) jnZ^ ihlmneZg*
mnk Z[ ^bl7 ^m jnb\nfjn^ Z\\^l^*

. [P]^Vb]TXL^% . En]nb m^*


b dh b`bklmb Mhfg oZk]) dZ]
8 cb^ ^l `Zebg`b c`hfbl) ikbmZkb
b oblZf) dh b c ikZhfZ) dZ]
D cb^) lnc  ikb^m^erlm ln mZbl) dn*

W ]b  ^bi( Ldmhd km\_ej fjq t*


_\d+ / I\f+ .2)/2+  9 W Teb( Fdn \o\*
odif\ q\n\mdj k\]\db dm fjqj km\*
_d+  %12& Ehb 9 W TmXe\b( P\ k\od
qd`o\) fpmd \pf+ k\q\_dio\ =_\mn\+
%13& M_ Z e{f\((( Otm\d) h\ot_\hd)
f\_ ed` \knpk\hd) qg bmnd kmd`
q`e\idpn epjn t_pn+
%14& E h^\egb((( Lgb+ / I\f+ .2)0/+

5). 0/+ G\_\ibd Fp_\n ]pqj bdm*


_en \kd` mjhip f\mtbdfph
%. .3&) edn k`m n\qj k\ndpiodidpn k\*
_\mj np e\dn n\i_jm+
%O)g& Ah Wh \ gX^b((( Fp_\n) f\_ dm
ipb\g_\qj ntm f\mdpjh`i) b`m\d
npkm\oj) ejb edn i`opmd b\i\ eb) f\_
\kn\pbjop n\qj \gd`n i`kmdfg\pnj*
ht]+ J`h\\ ]pqj ojfdp t_) fp*

K

Turinys

5.3

# 3 ,1! * $ ? *

kngm Z] ^hl) lmZmn^kngm \nf ^bl  kb^  cnhl dk^bilb) bk dZ] cb^ `Z*
Zfb\bmbZl) ^m jnbZ lngm ihm^gm^l  ebg`b c`hfbl+ / Eb^ `bk]ch mZbi
obkb[nl+ / @mZn]b^kngm ikZ^ebZ ^h* d iZm Zib^ c dhoZlbk ]b]^ebnlo^bd*
 lfnl) Zmebdmnl BZeZmbchc^) dZbi cb^
knf) ^m obkmnm^l [hgZl) jnZl _^* u
\^kngm bg BZeZmbZ) jnbZ h[mbgn^* c gn`Zecbkikbo^kmfhdmb ]nh*
kngm ^hl) ^m ]nq^kngm ln[ mkb[n* de) 0 dZbi ]Zn` cb^ iZ]Zk DliZ*
mnf7 0 ^m jnZgmZ _^\^kngm bg k^* gbchl Zerc^) dZ] cb^ iZf lZoh
`bhg^ CbliZgbZ^) ^m jnh] bg ih* bgbhg m^g ^lZgbZl lb]Z[kh bkZnd*
m^lmZm^f k^]^`^kngm f^mZeeZ Zk* lh dZlrdeZl bk f oZe]rmb oblZl
 ob^mZl lZoh `n]knfn bk bmo^kf^8
`^gmb ^m Znkb) jnZ^ beeb\ lngm) ^m u
ihll^]^kngm hfg^f eh\nf \hg* c 1 dZ] cb^ gn`Zec eZ[Zb mheb gnh
lbebh lnh) ^m iZmb^gmbZ7 1 eh\Zjn^ c c [nonlbZl Zebl bk cnlbnlikb^
jnZ^ ehg`^ ^kZgm oZe]^ Z[ ^bl) cnhl gnh ^fl iZdkZb dZkZ*
^m k^`^l) jnb lni^ko^g^kZgm ^bl D ebl bk ln]Zo cb^fl ]b]^eblf*
Z[ ^qmk^fbl m^kkZ^) \hgmkbo^kngm) e `b) dbmb `b fhd cb^fl dZl f^*
^m i^k\nll^kngm ^hl ieZ`Z fZ`* E mZb ]nhde8 2 dZ]d^mb^bdZkZebnl
gZ7 \^m^kb Znm^f ]Zgm ^bl mkb[n* e Kberi bk K^klb^c) mZbi iZm dbmnl)
mnf hfgb[nl Zggbl7 2 ^m Kabebi* e dnkb^[nohiZdeikb^ cnhl `bgd*
inf ^m K^kl^g >^m^hknf k^`^f) enl) cb^ lnfn dhohc^ bk cnhl
^m \^m^khl) jnb Z]o^klnf ^hl Zk* gn`Zec) 3 dZ] <sbchl dZkZebnl
fZ mne^kZgm) \hgmkbo^kngm bg [^e* <gmbhdZl ?b]rlbl) dnkl clikb^
eh) ^m h[mbgn^kngm ^hl7 3 ^m <g* cnhl  dho ln bfmn ]ob]^bf*
mbh\anf fZ`gnf k^`^f <lbZ^) b bZ ]kZf[eb) ln kZbmZkbcZ) dZkb*
jnb ^bl in`gZf bgmne^kZm aZ[^gl dZbl o^bfZbl bk eZ[Zb ]b]^e^ dZ*
\^gmnfob`bgmb^e^iaZgmhl) ^m^jnb* kbnhf^g^)[nolc lnmkbgmZl) 4cb^
mZmnf) ^m \nkknl) ^m ^q^k\bmnf `b iZf c `ro bk iZldrk)dZ]
fZ`gnf oZe]^) \hgmkbmnf Z[ ^bl+ cbl iZml bk dnkb^ ih ch dZkZebZnl)
4 ^m jnbZ \^i^kngm ^nf obonf) fhdm ]b]^e^l iZ[Zn]Zl) dZ]
^m lmZmn^kngm ^b nm ]Zk^m bil^) ^m ]nhm dZbmnl bk dZl [noh gnlmZ*
jnb k^`gZk^gm ihlm bilnf) mkb[n* mrmZ) 5 [m^gm Dg]) H^] bk Gr*
mnf fZ`gnf) ^m ]Zk^m h[lb]^l) ] Zebl) mZb`b `^kbZnlbnl c dkZ*
^m \hglmbmnmnf) 5 ^mk^`bhg^f Dg* mnl8 cb^ cnhl b c iZf bk Zmb*
md` \oqdm\d ]pqj kmd`dibd Fp_j nd`*
fdh\hn8 fdod) f\dk kq_+ \nd_\d)[k\*
__\qj e\h odf _\gdhd8 oj_g Fp_\n
hbdi\ d`fjod k\b\g]jn nq`opm+ P\dk
`gb_\hjn edn \kndg`ifd\ np no\othj
m`df\g\qdh\dn %qu+ E+ /0)0/8 Eu+ 0-)
.0 dm f+&+  =pojmdpn d\ k\n\fje\)
f FQ_\n ]pqj bdm_en \kd` mjhipn+
Q o bdm_o _\gtf odfmph edn i`*
\on\fj+ F`d k\nd`fpnd`hn t_pn b\i*
_\hn \kd` mjhi f\mpn i`g\]\d _\pb
f b\gdh\ kmdfdod) o\d mjhi dodfd*
ht]n) i`k\qt_edhj dm fdo _jmt*
]d dbtmdh\n ojgd bm\p i`]pqj ip*
k`gito\n+  % / &  > T_T g\]b ]X( C\g ij*
mo\ k\n\ftod7 C\gdeje` %C\ggd\ ^dn*
\gkdi\&) _g fpmdjn d odfme om`d\*
h` dhoh`ote` kdmh Gm+ ]pqj g\]\d

nh\mfd\d f\pe\h\nd+  % 1 &  C T U T \ gb_\


ahb ]((( C\g f\mo\b`id`dpn dm fdopn+
 %2& B Xg\X}\ (((4 h\f`_jid`d+ @`*
h`om\pn EE nipn Ldgtk\n EEE ]pqj
.64 h+ kdmh Gm+ Bg\hdide\pn ipb\*
go\n kmd` Gdijf`a\gj+ L`mnepn ]p*
qj Ldgtkj EEE nipn %i\opm\gdn& dm k*
_didn8 edn ]pqj .34 h+ kdmh Gm+ Ljqdgj
Ahdgde\pn nphpo\n kmd` Ld_ijn+ 
%3& 9 m\]bf ^TeT_\h f((( Lj I\bi`udejn
o\dfjn .56 h+ kdmh+ Gm+ =iodjf\n op*
mej \od_pjod mjhi\hn qdn\n kmj*
qdi^de\n d q\f\mpn ipj P\pmj8 o\d\p
Otmdejn f\m\gd\d k\ndgdfj n\p =udejn
f\m\gd q\m_) b\g opj nph`odhp) f\_)
kmjb\d k\ndo\dfdpn) qg k\m`dfo n\*
qj n`ind\n o`dn`n+  % 4 &  G T `  ]\
Zli((( Fdn opmej qdn\d k\nd_pjod mj*

Turinys

. H<F+ 5) 6 * . 2

.'-

]hknf) ^m H^]hl) ^m Gr]hl) ]^


himbfbl k^`bhgb[nl ^hknf7 ^m Z\*
\^imZl ^Zl Z[ ^bl) ]^]^kngm @n*
f^gb k^`b7 6^mjnbZjnb ^kZgmZin]
C^eeZ]Zf) ohen^kngm bk^) ^m mhee^*
k^ ^hl7 ^m bgghmnbm l^kfh abl) .- ^m
fbl^kngm Z] ^hl ]n\^f ngnf) ^m
in`gZo^kngm \hgmkZ beehl) ^m \^\b*
]^kngm ^q ^bl fnemb) ^m \ZimboZl
]nq^kngm nqhk^l^hknf) ^m _bebhl)
^m ]bkbin^kngm ^hl) ^m m^kkZf ^h*
knf ihll^]^kngm) ^m ]^lmknq^kngm
fnkhl ^hknf) ^m bg l^kobmnm^f
beehl k^]^`^kngm nljn^ bg ang\
]b^f7 .. ^m k^lb]nZ k^`gZ) ^m bg*
lneZl) jnZ^ ZebjnZg]h k^lmbm^kZgm
beebl) ^qm^kfbgZo^kngm) ^m bg ihm^l*
mZm^f k^]^`^kngm+ ./ >nf Zfb*
\bl Znm^f lnbl) ^m jnb bg bilblk^*
jnb^f aZ[^[Zgm) \hgl^koZo^kngm
Zfb\bmbZf) ^m h[mbgn^kngm k^`gZ)
jnZ^ ^kZgmikhqbfZ)^mjnZ^^kZgm
ehg`^7 jnbZ jnb\nfjn^Zn]b^[Zgm
ghf^g ^hknf) mbf^[Zgm ^hl7
.0 jnb[nl o^kh o^ee^gm Znqbebh ^l*
l^ nm k^`gZk^gm) k^`gZ[Zgm7 jnhl
Znm^f o^ee^gm) k^`gh ]^mnk[Z[Zgm7
^m ^qZemZmb lngm oZe]^+ .1 @m bg
hfgb[nl blmbl g^fh ihkmZ[Zm]bZ*
]^fZ) g^\ bg]n^[Zmnk inkinkZ) nm
fZ`gb_b\Zk^mnk bg ^Z+ .2 @m jnbZ
\nkbZf _^\^kngm lb[b) ^m jnhmb]b^
\hglne^[Zgm mk^\^gmhlob`bgmb\hg*
lbebnf Z`^gm^l l^fi^k ]^ fnemb*
mn]bg^) nmjnZ^ ]b`gZ lngm)`^kZgm7

]Zo dZkZebnb @nf^gnb8 6dZ] @eZ*


]hl `ro^gmhcZb ghkc^bmb bk ln*
gZbdbgmb cnhl) [^m mZllnfZgrfZl
iZlb]Zkl cb^fl bghfZl8 .- cb^
lbngm ikb^ cnhl ob^g oZ]) dh*
ohc ikb^ Zgnhl) ]Zn` b Zg
dkbm) cb^ iZf g^eZblog ZgiZ*
bZl bk oZbdnl) Zibie Zgnhl)
f oZe]rmb c Ze) bZk] clb^*
gZl bk ikbo^km cnhl o^k`Znmb bdb
bZb ]b^gZb8 .. dZ] cb^ lngZbdbg
dbmZl dZkZerlm^l bk lZeZl) dnkbhl
dnhf^m ghkl cb^fl ikb^bghlb) bk
iZf lZoh oZe]bhg8 ./ lnlZoh
`b ikb^m^ebZbl bk mZbl) dnkb^cZbl lb*
mbdb) cb^ iZeZbdikb^m^erlm8dZ] cb^
ndZkbZo bk Zkmb bk mheb [nonlbZl
dZkZerlm^l) g^l dZl mbd b`bkl]Z*
ol c oZk]) c [bchcl8 .0 dZf
cb^ ghkc iZ]mb) dZ] dZkZebZnm)
mb^ dZkZebZo8 dnkbnhl `b ghkc)
mnhl bf^m b dZkZebZobfh) bk cb^
lb`bc eZ[Zb ]b]^e `Zeb8 .1 ikb^
oblh mh gb^dZl c g^g^bhcnl oZb*
gbdh) g obedl inkinkZ) dZ] mnh
]b]bnhmlb ikb^ dbmnl8 .2ch `  cb^
ln]Zk lZn mZkr[) deZnldZl]b^g
iZmZkbf mkbc bfm]ob]^bfmb^l)
dnkb^ gnheZm loZklm mZnmhl k^bdZ*
enl) dZ] cb]Zkrm) dZlo^kmZ) .3ch`
cb^ iZo^] dZlf^m oZe]rf ob^*
gZf fh`nb) dZ] cbl ob^iZmZnm

h`i h\gji`d+  %5& @aWh& `XW(((


d\ kmjqdi^de q\m_\d fg\d_dibd+ Ei*
_de\ id`fpjh`o i`kmdfg\pn =iodjfpd
@d_d\e\h) dm I`_dejn e\h i`m`df*
ej \od_pjod) \od_\q bd odf kmjqdi^d*
e\n d\kpn P\pmj+ Bmtbde) Itude)
Ht_de dm f+ b\qj Aph`i\n+  %6+.-.
= _TW bf((( Em dojn t_pn k\nd`fpndjn
didjn \kd` Cm\dfde ]pqj fg\d_dibjn+
 %..& JT_Tf((( O\m_dide) Od^dgde dm
fdo\n+  %./& G T _T \^  gT \^ 4 fjg`d
i`k\ndo\dft_\qj k\ojbd kmjb\ k\_\*
mtod d o \gd Njhjn kmjqdi^de\n+
Pj _\gtfj t_\d) ]` \]`ej) i`]pqj

bdm_e+  %.1& MT\a\^b((( R\didf\n


%f\mi\& dm kpmkpm\ ]pqj f\m\gdfjn
b\m]n `ifg\d+ G\_\ibd Njhjn
q\gnot]e` e i`opmej) qdn\ bd q\g*
_ n`i\o\n) Fp_pd mj_nd) f\_ mjh*
i\d im\ _d_`gd n\qdi\p_d\d dm oj_g
edn d`fjej np e\dn n\i_jmjn+  %.2&
K e\] y\` g W i \W Xy\` g\Xf( E odfme
n`i\ojmd ]pqj odf omtn dho\d+ O`*
i\o\n mdif_\qjnd i` f\n _d`i) ]`o odf*
o\d f\g`i_jn`) ijijn`) d_pjn` dm q`i*
o\_d`id\dn+ An\io m`df\gj) n`i\o ]pqj
b\gdh\ np\pfod dm fdojhdn _d`ijhdn+
Pd` i`odfngph\d k\mj_j) f\dk i`*
2/

q+ N\o\n) o+ ER+

Turinys

*#*

# 3 ,1! * #(? $%

.3 ^m \hffbmmngm ngb ahfbgb fZ* oblZb c ZebZb) ch ` oblbdeZnl ob^*
`blmkZmnf lnnf i^k lbg`nehlZg* gh bk g^l c mZki^ g^b mZkbfh))
ghl ]hfbgZkb ngbo^klZ^m^kkZ^lnE g^b iZor]h+
Z^) ^m hfg^lh[^]bngmngb)^mghg
^lm bgob]bZ) g^jn^s^enl bgm^k^hl+
.4
@m^e^`bm en]Zl @nihe^fnf) .49En]Zl bkbgdh Ehd[h l*
_bebnf DhZggbl) _bebb DZ\h[) ^m DZ * gZnlEhghlg @nihe^f bk@e^Z*
lhg^f) _bebnf @e^ZsZkb) ^m fblbm sZkh lgEZshgbkblbngm cn h l
^hl MhfZf \hglmbmn^k^ \nf beebl Mhfhg iZ]Zkrmb ln ZgZbl ikb^m^*
Zfb\bmbZf) ^m lh\b^mZm^f7 .0 ^m nm erlml bk]kZn`rlml) .NbkdZ] Zgb^
Zn_^kk^gm Z[ ^bl bn`nf BkZ^\h* boZ]nhm cnhl b BkZbd cng`h)
knf) jnbZ ob]^kngm jnh] bg l^k* g^l fZm) dZ] bmb^ lmnfbZ [ g T ' 
obmnm^f ik^f^k^gm k^`gnf DlkZ^e+ ebh dZkZerlm  o^k`ho+ .6Eb^b*
.6 @m Z[b^kngm MhfZf obZffne* + ordh Mhfhg bk Zmebd eZ[Zb be`
mZf oZe]^) ^m bgmkhb^kngm \nkbZf) d^ebhg)ch  mZkr[ bk mZk7 /-En*
^m ]bq^kngm7 /- en]ZlHZ\aZ[Z^nl) ]Zl HZkdZ[b^cnl) ch [khebZb bk r*
^m _kZmk^l ^bnl) ^m ihinenlDn]Z^* ] mZnmZ lbngm fnl iZl cnl iZ*
hknf fbl^kngm ghl Z] )ohl lmZ* ]Zkrmb ln cnfbl ]kZn`rlml bk mZb*
mn^k^ oh[bl\nf lh\b^mZm^f)^miZ* dhl) bkdZ]cl iZld^e[mnfm^ fnl
\^f) ^m \hgl\kb[^k^ ghl lh\bhl) lZoh lcng`bgbgdZbl bk ikb^m^ebZbl+
^m Zfb\hl o^lmkhl+ /. @m ieZ\nbm /. Ob^ h]bZb cb^fl iZmbdh+
l^kfh bg \hgli^\mn ^hknf+
//
@m ah\ k^l\kbimnf ^lm)jnh] //
mZb gnhkZZl mh) dcb^ iZ*
k^l\kbil^kngm bg mZ[nebl Z^k^bl)^m kZ Zgm oZkbgb e^gm bk Zmlbngm
fbl^kngm bg D^knlZe^f) nm ^ll^m  E^knsZe) dZ] [m mZbdhl bk l*
Zin] ^hl b[b f^fhkbZe^ iZ\bl)^m cng`hl iZfbgdeZl+ /0 MhfgZfl
lh\b^mZmbl+ /0 =@I @ NDO MJH<* bk r] mZnmZb ebgdbfZ `^khl deh*
IDN) ^m `^gmb en]Z^hknf bg fZkb) mb^l c kh c^$bk lZnlnfhc^ i^k Zf*
^m bg m^kkZ bg Z^m^kgnf7 `eZ]bnl* bnl8 dZeZobcZl bk g^ikb^m^ebl m[*
U 9 * S
+ b 
]pqj npg\df =iodjf Akda\aa+ ipj
_\pb did t_\d o`opmej \kd` Nj*
hjn q\gnot]n npoq\mfth+ Gitbjn pf\m\qd\hj =dbdkoj dm no`ibnd i`*
kmdg`dnod @`h`omde\pn \kdhod Otmdejn
\pojmdpn) _pj_\h\n nq`odh\n ipjhj*
i`n) e i`\odo\dnj+  %.3& M \XaT`  njno) f\_) `n\io f\m\gdphd e\pi\h
{` bZh\( E odfme ]pqj _p fjinpgp) =iodjfpd Apk\ojmdpd) db\po Otmdejn
]`o fd`fqd`i\n q`df n\qj nmdote` G\mj k\eb nph\didh+ @\]\m t*
\onfdm\d) oj_g ojgd `n\iod`hn b\gej _p ipndnfpi_dh\d ed`hn mj_nd b`m\
mj_todn) f\_ t m\  odf qd`i\n+  E eT kmjb\ em kmd`hji k\_d_diod n\qj
o\f dm b\gd mtopjn`) np_\m\io i\p*
]h gTecX((( Jpj\gt `n\iod`hn b\g*
e npif`it]d Otmdejn f\m\gdpd @`*
ej o\dk mj_todn) ijmn q\gnot]n qd_p*
e` ]pqj i`f\mo dm i`npodfdhp dm i`o h`oiepd+
%//& 9ag iTe\a\ _Xag((( =ijo Bg+
_d_`gdp q\d_+
%.4& Ab a b  fa = hcb_X` ( Fji\n Fpju\kj npo\mod`n jmdbdi\g\n mjhip
hdidh\n _g ej ipjk`gi o\po\d / kmjdp mo\n \io nf\dnoq\mdid g`i*
I\f+ 1)..+ Apkjg`hj q\m_p ]pqj 7 o opmen k\ndgdfod Njhje` dm odf ej
qd`i\n dnojmdf\n) m\n dm \kd` t_pn8 ipjm\\n ]pqn \oi`o\n$ F`mpu\gi+
]`o \m d\ f\g]\h\ \kd` o \nh`i)  %/0& I b` a T` f \e((( Opo\modn op*
npifp k\n\ftod+  AT m b a ( F\uji\n mej ]gdod k\m\to\ gjoti f\g]\+ Fd))
]` \]`ej) ]pqj dq`mno\ t_ f\g]ji)
b\g ]pqj fpidb\n+  %.6& @y i l ^ b  I b '
` ba 4 b\g km\_dje` .3- h+ kdmh Gm+ d t_ bd f\g]jn _m\pb np qdn\ +.
%.2/ h+ O`g`pf\dd `mjn&+ Njhi\d E I\f+ fitb\ ]pqj dq`mno\ bm\df
kdmh f`g`oj h`o %.35 h+ kdmh Gm+& E f\g]ji+ F\p od` q`modh\d opmej i`*

Turinys

. H<F+ 5) /1}0/

jn^ ^m ahlmbl ikh\ne lbm Z[ ^bl+


/1 Lnh] lb bglmbm^kbm [^eenf Mh*
fZgbl ikbnl) Znm hfgb[nl lh\bbl
^hknf bg hfgb ]hfbgZmbhg^ ^h*
knf7 /2Znqbebnf _^k^m `^gl Dn]Z^*
hknf) ikhnm m^finl ]b\mZo^kbm)
\hk]^ ie^gh7 /3 ^m ikZ^ebZgmb[nl
ghg ]Z[ngm) g^jn^ ln[fbgblmkZ*
[ngm mkbmb\nf) ZkfZ) i^\ngbZf)
gZo^l) lb\nm ieZ\nbm MhfZgbl7 ^m
\nlmh]b^gm fZg]ZmZ ^hknf) gbabe
Z[ ^bl Z\\bib^gm^l+ /4 Nbfbebm^kZn*
m^f ^m lb `^gmb en]Z^hknf ikbnl
Z\\b]^kbm [^eenf) Z]bnoZ[ngm Mh*
fZgb ^q Zgbfh) ikhnm ^bl m^f*
inl i^kfbl^kbm7 /5^mZ]bnoZgmb[nl
ghg ]Z[bmnk mkbmb\nf)ZkfZ) i^\n*
gbZ) gZo^l) lb\nm ieZ\nbm MhfZgbl7
^m \nlmh]b^gm fZg]ZmZ^hknf Z[l*
jn^ ]heh7 /6 l^\ng]nf aZ^\o^k*
[Z \hglmbmn^kngm MhfZgb ihineh
en]Z^hknf+ 0- Lnh] lb ihlmaZ^\
o^k[Z ab Znm beeb Z]]^k^) Znm ]^*
f^k^ Z] aZ^\ Zebjnb] ohen^kbgm)
_Z\b^gm^q ikhihlbmh lnh7 ^m jnZ^*
\nfjn^ Z]]b]^kbgm) o^e ]^fil^*
kbgm) kZmZ ^kngm+ 0. N^] ^m]^fZ*
ebl) jnZ^ ?^f^mkbnl k^q _^\bm bg
^hl) l\kbilbfnl ^b) ]b\^gm^l7 LnZ*
k^ `kZoZlmb bn`nf mnnf lni^k
Zfb\hl ghlmkhl) ^m lh\bhl En]Z^*
hl; 0/ Nb^k`hbm^knf Z]b^kbgm ghl)
Z]o^klnf m^ _Z\b^fnl beebl bn]b*
\bnf) ^m in`gZ[bfnl _^\nf fZkb
m^kkZjn^+

5.6

gZ mheb gnh c /1 E^b bdbemZgdl*


bZn dZkZl MhfgZfl Zk oblb^fl
c lcng`bgbgdZfl oblhc^ c oZe*
lmr[c^) /2 r] mZnmZ m^bdl iZ*
`Ze[hl ibegZ bk]bfb) dZbi eZbdZl
k^bdZeZnl8 /3 cb^ g^]nhl bk g^ikb*
lmZmbgl dhohcZgmb^fl cZo) `bg*
de) ibgb`) eZbo) mZbi dZbi iZmbg*
dZ MhfgZfl8 bkcb^ l^k`l c lZ*
drfnl) gb^dh b c g^`Zn]Zfb+
/4 OZbi iZm c^b bk r]Zfl Zmlbmbdl
ZgdlbZn dZkZl8 MhfgZb iZ]l
b bk]b^l) dZbi cb^fl Ziebgdr[l
e^bl8 /5 iZ]^]Zgmb^fl g^[nl ]nh*
]ZfZ cZo) `bgde) ibgb`) eZbo)
g^l mZbi iZmbgdZ MhfgZfl8 bkcb^
l^k`l c lZdrfnl [^ deZlmhl+
/6 Ohdb lnmZkmbl [noh iZ]ZkrmZ
Mhfg ln r] mZnmZ+ 0- J c^b
oebZn ob^gb Zk dbmb ghkl dghkl
ikb^ mhikb]mb Zk Zmbfmb) ]Zkrl ln*
lbmZk mZki lZol) bk d ghkl cb^
ikb]lZk Zmbfl) mnkl `Zebhl+0.=^m
bk Zib^ ibdmZ) dhdb dZkZebnl ?^*
f^mkbcnl iZ]Zk r]Zfl) f^l cZf
iZkZf^mhdbZblh]bZbl7 FZfmn
n]cZb lZoh lngd cng` fl
ikb^m^ebZfl bk lcng`bgbgdZfl r*
]Zfl; 0/ OZb`b) c^b cb^ oe dk^bi*
lbl  fnl) f^l ]Zkrlbf^ cb^fl
m^blr[ ikb^ mZo^ bk dhohlbf^
ikb^ mZo^ ckhc^ bk lZnlnfhc^+

h\\ k\f`dnod ejn dq\du_8 ]` oj) fgpjod dm dg\dftod n\qj f\mdpjh`i+
q`md\io i b\gej ]od npomphkdio\8  %/4& B T\c ]\X` f T c _\a ^ l U f _X\f(
Em mjhi\d \_\ t_\hn k\b\g]) e`d
oj_g d\ odfmd\pnd\d t m\  odf ejn op*
ed`hn o`fn f\md\pod) ]`o ojn k\b`g*
mditn) i` qdnd j_d\d+  %/1& I b ` '
aT` f( Cd+ o+7 Njh\d+  %/2& G \_aT oj n _\qdh\n k\m`dn ipj \kgdift]d+
y\eW \` \4 g\dftn Njhjn m`df\gpn qdn\d Njh\ b\g i`ijmd n\qn k`m_\pb np*
q\mtod+  %/5& G TW XW Ta g\X` f((( Em
gtbd\n n\qd`nd`hn) p\ %/3& A \ X  a X'
 do `dg+ b\gdh\ npkm\nod _q`ejk\d+
Whbf((( C\gdh\ npkm\nod _q`ejk\d8 fg* Q
Ru+ \pf+ /3 `dg+  %0-& < T el f fh'
dpn f\mpd) t_\d i`k\_n Njhjn kmd`*
f\gTe& o+ t+ b\gdhd`hn k\f`dodh\hn
\hn g\dq\dn) bdifg\dn dm o+o+) \m]\7 fg*
dpn f\mpd dm t_\hn k\_`_\io n\qj 7 opmn kmdo\mod qd`id dm fdod+  %0.+0/&
: Xg \e T c \X c\^gT((( do\n kmd`_\n i`*
f\mdpjh`i` mjhi\hn) mjhi\d i`*
_pjn o\d f\mdpjh`i`d bdifg) e\q dm ]pqj m\to\n  k\d npo\mod+ Fdn
m\nd odf j_dp ]pqj k\nf`g]o\n Fp*
o+o+) o+ t+ t_\d opmn k\otn \kbdi*

Turinys

/)'

( H<F+ +$  (T.

Q! <`OZ ?LVLMTPyL`^ XT]_T^%


6L[`_ ;H% . Dgm^k^Z nmZn]b*
/  [P]^Vb]TXL^% . Onh mZk*
obm ?^f^mkbnl jnbZ \^\b]bm Ib\Z* in ?^f^mkbcnl) b`bk]l) dZ] Ib*
ghk) ^m ^q^k\bmnl ^bnl f ikZ^ebh) dZghkZl bk ch dZkbnhf^g no
Ziihlnbm =Z\\ab]^f) ^m <e\bfnf dhohc^) gnmZk oe lblmb =Zdb]
knklnffbmm^k^ bg Dn]Z^Zf)^m]^q* bk <edbf  En]c bk ln cZbl ]^*
mknf \hbgn \nf beebl+ / @m Z[b^* bgc liZkg+ /Eb^ bch d^ebn) o^*
kngm obZf) jnZ^ ]n\bm bg BZe`Z* ]Zgbn  BZb`Ze) bk iZ]Zk lmh*
eZ) ^m \ZlmkZ ihln^kngm bg HZlZ* orde <k[^ehl HZlZehm^) iZf
ehma) jnZ^ ^lm bg <k[^eebl7 ^m h\* E c bk gnn] ]b]^e fhgb ldZb*
\niZo^kngm ^Zf) ^m i^k^f^kngm b+ 0 KbkfZf^ fg^lrc^ bfmZl
ZgbfZl ahfbgnf fnemZl+ 0 Dg i^gdbZl]^bfmbl Zgmk f^m cb^
f^gl^ ikbfh Zggb \^gm^lbfb ^m Zmch ln dZkbnhf^g^ ikb^ E^knsZ*
jnbgjnZ`^lbfb l^\ng]b Ziieb\n^* el8 1mZbZn ]ob]^bfm mdlmZgb
kngm ^q^k\bmnf Z] D^knlZe^f7 1 ^m fhgb ln ]ob^f mdlmZgbZbl
lnkk^q^kngm) ^m Z[b^kngm bg =^k^* c kZbm^eb iZdbeh bk gnch  =^kc+
Zf ob`bgmb fbeebZ obkhknf) ^m ]nh c
fbeebZ ^jnbmnf+
c
2 @m en]Zl ihln^kZm \ZlmkZ bg )
2E]Zl [noh iZlb]Zkl lmh*
GZblZ) ^m mkbZ fbeebZobkb ^e^\mb \nf orde GZblhc^8 ln cnh [noh mkrl
^h7 3 ^m ob]^kngm fnembmn]bg^f mdlmZgbZb kbgdmbgb ork+ 3 Eb^
^q^k\bmnl jnbZ fnemb lngm) ^m mb* iZfZm ]b]^e dZkbnhf^gl ]Zn*
fn^kngm oZe]^7 ^m fnemb ln[mkZ* `r[ bk eZ[Zb gnlb`Zg]h8 ]Zn`^*
q^kngm l^ ]^ \Zlmkbl) ^m ghg k^* ebl iZlbmkZnd b lmhordehl)bkebdh
fZgl^kngm ^q ^bl gblb h\mbg`^gmb cmbdZmnhgb bfmZb ork+ 4E]Zl)
obkb+ 4 @m ob]bm en]Zl jnh] ]^_en* iZfZml) dZ] ch dZkbnhf^g ln*
qbm ^q^k\bmnl lnnl) ^m[^eenf i^* mbkih bk dZ] dhoZ g^bo^g`bZfZ)
_j k\ndpiodid\hn) Fp_pd i`d k\djn np* ) hdioj Njhjn nkedhj8 [ kmd`diodn
o\mod`n) i`d ejn kmd`_j odfmd\pnd\d i`* $ o\dk \oqdm\d Njh\d edn i`]o _mnn+
o`fj npdijod) i`n ej k\ndpiodid\d  %/& @ > T\Z T_( C\db\g L\g`nod*
i`b\gej bm`do\d npbmod d n\qj g\]\d ije` tm\ i` qd`i\+ C\g d\ hdidh\
dgb`n f`gdjin) fpmd b\g onnd \mod o\) fpmd t m\   d\pm ipj =iodk\omd`n
kpnn h`o+ J`k\ndi\p_jej npo\modhd dm  d\pmn q\f\mpn ipj F`mpu\gn
dm t_p o\po\) i`n i`dgb\d ompfpn kj %qu+ Fju+ ./)/0&+  9 eUX_bf D TfT'
_bgX( @\]\m i`dijh qd`o q\m_\d+
Jdf\ijmj pqdhj @`h`omdepn km\_*
ej kmd` epjn i\pe f\m) fpmd\h`  %0& G \e` T` X ` a Xfl ]X y\` gTf(((
]pqj phpo\nd dm F_\n I\f\]d`epn .3- h+ kdmh Gm+) i` _\pbd\p) f\dk
_qd`h hi`nd\h km\ngdifpn kj Jd*
%qu+ `h+ 6).5&+
6). ,,( G\m\gdpn @`h`omdepn qg f\ijmj pqdhj+  %1& @ : Xe ] ( P\
qd`o\ opmej ]od i`ojgd ipj F`mp*
\ondpid\  Fp_e np f\mdpjh`i` > \*
u\gn+
fd_ dm =gfdh) kmd` fpmdpjn fjqj*
%O& C T \f b ]X(
F_\n ]pqj k\nd*
e\ F_\n+ Pje` fjqje` edn ipb\gdh\n
om\pfn d F`mpu\gn) ]`o fpmdje` qd`*
dm php\h\n8 qdn\ o\po\ ej m\p_\+
%6).& B TW E \^TabeTf((( Ru+ \pf+ oje` ]pqj H\dn\) odfm\d i`dijh\+ 
4)10+  : T^\W ((( Ru+ 4)5+++  < Xy\a] K el f g^fgTa}\T\((( @g g\]\d bm`doj
fc T e a 4 odfmd\pnd\d o f\mdpjh`i) ntm f\mdpjh`in \oqtfdhj F_\n
i`b\gej npmdifod _d_`nin f\mdpjh`*
fpmd nojqej q\dmdjn` qd`ojn` d kd`*
opn ipj =iodjfdejn dfd =dbdkoj in+ >` oj) ej fjqjn ]pqj b\qpndjn
kjgdodi \ionk\gq) oj_g _\pb \nd_
nd`i\d+ =]`ejin im\) f\_ @`*
h`omdepn i`]pqj b\qn 5)0. k\* + i`]`ijmej e\h k\_od %kgb+ . I\f+ 4)

Turinys

E H<F+ 6) 5 * . 3

5/.

knk`^[Zm ^nf) ^m \hg_kZ\mnl ^lm


\hk]^7 jnbZ ghg aZ[^[Zm m^finl
\hg`k^`Zg]b ^hl) ^m _dnnjgpopn
^lm+ 5 @m ]bqbm abl) jnb k^lb]nb
^kZgm7 Nnk`Zfnl) ^m ^Zfnl Z]Z]*
o^klZkbhl ghlmkhl) lb ihm^kbfnl
in`gZk^ Z]o^klnl ^hl+ 6 @mZo^k*
m^[Zgm ^nf) ]b\^gm^l7 Ihg ihm^*
kbfnl) l^] eb[^k^fnl ZgbfZlgh*
lmkZl fh]h) ^m k^o^kmZfnkZ] _kZ*
mk^l ghlmkhl) ^m mng\ in`gZ[bfnl
Z]o^klnl ^hl7 ghl Znm^f iZn\b
lnfnl+ .- @m Zbm en]Zl7 <[lbm bl*
mZf k^f _Z\^k^ nm _n`bZfnl Z[
^bl7 ^mlb ZiikhibZobm m^finl ghl*
mknf) fhkbZfnk bg obkmnm^ ikhi*
m^k _kZmk^l ghlmkhl) ^m ghg bg_^*
kZfnl \kbf^g `ehkbZ^ ghlmkZ^+
..
@m fhobm ^q^k\bmnl ]^
lmkbl) ^m lm^m^kngm beebl h[obZf7 ^m
]boblb lngm ^jnbm^l bg ]nZl iZk*
m^l) ^m _ng]b[neZkbb) ^m lZ`bmmZkbb
ikZ^b[Zgm ^q^k\bmnf) ^mikbfb \^k*
mZfbgbl hfg^l ihm^gm^l+ ./ =Z\*
\ab]^l Znm^f ^kZm bg ]^qmkh \hk*
gn) ^m ikhqbfZobm e^`bh ^q ]nZ*
[nl iZkmb[nl) ^m \eZfZ[Zgm mn[bl7
.0 ^q\eZfZo^kngm Znm^f^m ab) jnb
^kZgm ^q iZkm^ en]Z) ^mbZf bilb)
^m \hffhmZ^lm m^kkZ Zoh\^^q^k*
\bmnnf7 ^m \hffbllnf ^lm ikZ^*
ebnf Z fZg^ nljn^Z] o^li^kZf+
.1 @m ob]bm en]Zl) jnh]_bkfbhk^lm
iZkl ^q^k\bmnl =Z\\ab]bl bg ]^q*
mkbl) ^m\hgo^g^kngm \nf bilh hf*
g^l \hglmZgm^l \hk]^7 .2 ^m \hg*
mkbmZ ^lm ]^qm^kZ iZkl Z[ ^bl) ^m
i^kl^\nmnl ^lm^hlnljn^ Z] fhg*
m^f <shmb+ .6 @m jnb bg lbgblmkh
\hkgn ^kZgm) ob]^kngm jnh] \hg*

\Z* ..
Kkb^ dZkbnhf^g bch b
lmhordehl bk lnlmhch ikb^ cnhl8
kZbm^ebZb i^klbldrk  ]ob ]Zeb8 obei*
lmbgbgdZb bkdbeibgbgdZb ch dZkbnh*
f^gl ikb^Zdrc^ bk ibkfhl^ dh*
ohl ^bel^ [noh obl ]klbZnlb^*
cb+ ./ =Zdb]Zl [noh ]^bgbZcZf^
liZkg^8 dhohmhc ^bebZ Zkmbghlb b
Z[b^c hg) bk cb^ mkbfbmZoh mkb*
fbmZbl+ .0 Nnndh mZbi iZm bk mb^)
dnkb^ [noh En]h inlc^) mZbi dZ]
^f ]k^[ch gnh dZkbnhf^gb
Zndlfh8 ikZlb]ch dhoZ bk ml*
lb gnh krmh bdb oZdZknb+ .1 En]Zl
iZfZm) dZ] =Zdb]h dZkbnhf^gl
]Zebl ]^bgbZcZf^ hg^ [noh lmb*
ik^lg) bk oblb ]klbZnlb^cb lnlb*
kbgdh Ziebgd c8 .2 mZ ]^bgbhcb]Z*
ebl [noh c lnmkbgmZ) bk cbl obchlb
cnhl bdb <shmh dZegnb+ .3 =^m [n*
onlb^cb dZbkbZcZf^liZkg^) iZfZm)
dZ] ]^bgrlbl liZkgZl lnmkbgmZl)

./} . 1 & +  D k  b  m  0 - - - )  d n k b ^  [ n o h  l n 
E n ] n ) ] Z n ` n f Z  g ^ i k b m Z k  c h  d h o Z b 
] e i h ebm bg l  g ^ i k b d eZ n l h f r [ l  b k  m h *
] e i Z f ^ m  c +  }  % 5 &  7 L P  T L Z  N H S s %
Z P T L &&&  K Z m l  E n ] Z l  g ^ [ ^ i Z k h ] h  i Z l b *
m b d cb f h  Q b ^ i Z b n +  E b l  l m h l   d h o 
g ^  ] e mh ) d Z ]  Q b ^ i Z m l  r k Z  m Z bi  ] Z *
g Z b  cZ f $ i Z ] c l )  [ ^ m  f h ` Z n l )  i n h *

D n l b h   g n l b f b g b f )  ] k l Z + 
E b l  g h k b
g n ` Z e m b Z k [ Z  f b k m b 8  d Z bi  [ n l ) ? b^ *
o Z l  m^ g n e^ f bZ +
% . . &  ? H P[ L SPH P W L Y Z P Z R ^ Y s & & & ,  $ d Z *
k bn h f ^ g l  l i Z k g n  ] ^ g ` mb+ }  %. / & 8 V %
] V [ V Qw  L P S P H ,  _ Z e Z g ` Z +  }  % . 2 &  6R P / _ V %
[V  R H SU \ P&  B Z e  m Z b i  i Z o Z ] b g m Z  d n k b 
g h k l  Z n d m^ l g  o b^ mZ  En ] h  d Z eg n h l ^ )

eZ[Zb lnlbdkbfmh) g^l g^mnkcheZb*


dh c kbgdmb) bk gnlmhch ]klhl+
l Ebl mZk mb^fl) dnkb^ [noh ebd7
F^edbfl bk ^bdbf^ ikb^ fl
ikb^nl) c^b f^l `Zelbf^ dhohmb
ikb^ cnhl+ 6 Ob^ ZmdZe[bgch c)
lZdr]Zfb7 H^l g^`Zelbf^8 mh]e
`^e[dbf^ lZoh `ror[^l bk `k*
dbf^ ikb^ lZoh [kheb) h ih mh
dhohlbf^ ikb^ cnhl) g^l fl
fZZ mkZ+ .-En]Zl mZk7 <gZbi*
mhe f^l mZbi g^]Zkrlbf^) dZ] [`*
mnfbg gnh c E^b fl f^mZl
Zmch) fbkdbf^ ]klbZb n lZoh
[khebnl bk g^iZ^bldbf^ lZoh `Zk*
[l+

Turinys

5//

. H<F+ 6) . 4 */ 1

mkbmnf ^lm ]^qmknf \hkgn) ^m l^* inhe En] bk ln cnh [nonlbnlb
\nmb lngm ihlm en]Zf) ^m ^hl)jnb iZldhl+ .4' FhoZ iZlb]Zk lfZk*
\nf bilh ^kZgm) Z m^k`h7 .4 ^mbg* d^lg) bk ]Zn`^ebl dkbmh ln^blm
`kZoZmnf ^lm ikZ^ebnf) ^m \^\b]^* ob^g bk dbm mZki^+ .5 Fkbmh mZbi
kngm oneg^kZmb fnemb ^q abl) ^m ^q iZm En]Zl) dbmb `b iZ[`h+
beebl+ .5.
' @m en]Zl \^\b]bm) ^m \^m^kb
6
_n`^kngm+
.6
@m ehgZmaZl) ^m Nbfhg mne^* .6EhgZmZl bk NbfhgZl gng^
kngm en]Zf _kZmk^f lnnf) ^m l^* lZoh [khe En] bk iZeZb]hch cch
i^eb^kngm ^nf bg l^ine\akh iZ* moh dZi^ Hh]bgh fb^lm^+ 5-Qb*
mknf lnhknf bg \bobmZm^ Hh]bg7 lZ DskZ^ebh mZnmZ kZn]hch ch ]b*
/-@m _e^o^kngm ^nf hfgbl ihin* ]^ebn ]^cZobfn bk `^]ch ]Zn`
enl DlkZ^e ieZg\mn fZ`gh) ^m en* ]b^g8 /.cb^ lZd7 FZbi `b dkbmh
`^[Zgm]b^lfnemhl7 /.^m]bq^kngm7 dZkr`rl) dnkl `^e[ch DskZ^ebh
Lnhfh]h \^\b]bm ihm^gl) jnb lZe* mZnm
onf _Z\b^[Zm ihinenf DlkZ^e
//
@m \^m^kZ o^k[Z[^eehknfDn* // Fbmb En]h dho) ch Zmebdm
]Z^) ^m obkmnmnf) jnZl _^\bm) ^m ]b]b o^bdlf bk ch ]b]^gr[l
fZ`gbmn]bgbl ^bnl) ghg lngm ]^* ]ZerdZb g^ZikZrmb) g^l c [noh
l\kbimZ7 fnemZ ^gbf ^kZgm oZe]^) b eZ[Zb ]Zn`+

) % <ZYL_Z aPTV^XLT# L! <ZYL_Z VZaL []TPo 5LVTOt%


Hbknl En]nb Zmlbmbdh) dZ]
/0
@m _Z\mnf ^lm7 ihlm h[bmnf /0
Dn]Z^ ^f^kl^kngm bgbjnb bg hf* oblnhl^ DskZ^ebh iehmnhl^ iZlbkh*
gb[nl _bgb[nl DlkZ^e) ^m ^qhkmb ] g^]hk fhgb) bk iZdbeh ob*
lngm hfg^l) jnb hi^kZ[Zgmnk bgb* lb) dnkb^ ]Zk g^m^blr[+ /1 Ohl^
jnbmZm^f+ /1 Dg ]b^[nl beebl _Z\mZ ]b^ghl^ [noh eZ[Zb ]b]^ebl [Z]Zl)
^lm _Zf^l fZ`gZ oZe]^) ^m mkZ]b* bk oblZ c Zebl iZlb]Zo ln cZbl
]bm l^ =Z\\ab]b hfgbl k^`bh ^h* =Zdb]nb+ /2 =Zdb]Zl iZlbkbgdh

b  d n k bh l  [ n o h  ` Z ebf Z  f Z mr m b o bl Z 
i b e b l m b f  e r ` n f Z +  }  % . 5 &  B e \g b  g T \c 
c T g  A h W T f ( I ^ f Z bZ n ) d Z bi  ] o b] ^ *
b f m  d Z k m n  m^ d h ' E n ] n b  l m h m b  b f Z ^ l *
g ^ l  bk  ] b] ^ l g ^ l  d h o Z l  bk  bd b bZ f
eZ bd n b d h  g ^  o bl h l ^  m h l ^  d h o h l ^  cb l 
[ n o h  e Z b f m h cZ l +
% '/& D b W \a b  ` \X f g X (  Q s +  Z n d + / ). +
 % ('& > X _ U ] b  @ m e T _ \ b  g T h g T (  E n *
] Z l  d h o h ch  ] e  l Z o h  m Z n m h l  k ^ e b ` b c h l
%. H Z d +  0 ) . 5 + + + 8  1 ) / 1  b k  d + & )  ] e  m Z n *
m h l  o ^ g m r d e h l  E ^ k n s Z e c ^  %.  H Z d +
1 + 1 . ++ 
+ & 8  ch  k ^ eb` bg ` n f Z l  i Z l bk ^ b d 
mn h ) d Z ]  c b l  r i Z m b g ` n  [ n ] n  k i b g h l b 
d h o h c^  n o n l bZ bl  d Z k b Z b l  %/  H Z d + ./ )
0 6 ++ +& + O Z b` b  b  mbd k c  cb l  [ n o h  o ^ k *
m Z l  o bl h l  l Z o h  mZ n mh l  i Z ` Z k [ h l ) g h k l 
ch  i h ebmbg bZ b l b^ d bf Z b g ^  o bl n  [ n o h 
e r ` b Z b  i Z e Z b d h f b +  K e ` +  /  F Z k +  . ). 6 +

% / / &  B \g\ A h W b  ^ b i (((  K e ` +  0  F Z k + 


. . ) 1 . 8  . 1 )/ 6 +
6 ) / 0 } 40. K h  E n ] h  r ]  m Z n m h l 
o Z ] n  b k bg d mZ l  ch  [ k h ebl  E h g Z m Z l  i k Z *
] bh c^  r k Z  i k b o ^ k l m Z l  l e i m bl ) d Z ]  g ^ *
i Z m ^ d m n  b i k b ^ n  k Z g d Z l )  b k  Z m d ^ k r * 
c Z  l Z o h  g n n ] r mh  [ k h ebh  Eh g h  f bk mb)
i Z l d n b  l m h c Z  b d h o  i k b ^  = Z d b ] )  d n k l ) 
n o n l  < e d b f n b ) i Z l b m k Z n d b Z  b  E n ] *
ch l  %/ 0 } 2 4 & +
K k b^  l n ` k n l b = Z d b *
]  E h g Z m Z l  o e d h o h cZ ) bd b cZ f  i Z *
o r d l m Z  l n  mn h  N r k b ch l  d Z k Z ebZ n l  o Z *
b]
k n i Z ] Z k r mb mZ bd  %2 5 } 4 0 &+
%/ 0 & E X W b e  { ` b a \ 4 b l b Z ] cn *
l bn  l Z o h  k ^ e b ` b c h l  r ] + 
E b ^  o ebZ n 
[noh
Eh g Z mh 
b g Z bd bg mb
% 6 )4 0 &+ }
%/ 1 & M \f T  ]  y T _ \f 4 mb^  r ] Z b) d n k b^ 
bd b bZ f  eZ bd n b [ n o h  b mbd bf b l m Z m r *
J h  ] T \ f 4 l n  [ ^ ] b^ o bZ bl + }
f n b+

Turinys

( 3 ,1! 0#% ),T*,

.()

knf \nf ,03,3  /2#4 ^e^`bm =Z\* D fhg^l [^]b^obnl bk iZlmZm cnhl
\ab]^l obkhl bfibhl) ^m \hglmbmnbm Zeb^l oZe]hoZbl+ /3 Ob^ b^dhch bk
`jn _jhdijn 2)+,/.,3! /3 ^m ^q* m^bkZohlb Zib^ En]h ikb^m^ebnl bk
jnbk^[Zgm) ^mi^kl\knmZ[ZgmnkZfb* o^] cnhl iZl =Zdb]) dnkl d^k*
\h l Dn]Z^) ^m Z]]n\^[Zgm ^hl Z] bch cb^fl bk bc mrbhchlb+ /4 OZbi
=Z\\ab]^f) ^m obg]b\Z[Zmbg beehl) iZlb]Zk ]b]bl lb^eoZkmZl DskZ^erc^)
^m $been]^[Zm+ /4 A+m _Z\mZ ^lmmkb[n* dhdbh g^[noh gnh mh f^mh) gnh
eZmbh fZ`gZ bg DlkZ^e) jnZeblghg dnkbh g^[^fZmrmZ ikZgZh DskZ^*
_nbm ^q ]b^) jnZ ghg ^lm oblnl erc^+
ikhia^mZ bg DlkZ^e+
/5 @m \hg`k^`Zmb lngm hfg^l
/5 Onhf^m lnlbkbgdh oblb En*
Zfb\b Dn]Z^) ^m ]bq^kngm ehgZmaZ^7 ]h ikb^m^ebZb bk mZkEhgZmnb7 /6Inh
/6 @q jnh _kZm^k mnnl en]Zl ]^* mh f^mh) dZbi mZoh [khebl En]Zl
_ng\mnl ^lm) obk lbfbebl^bghg ^lm) fbk) g^[kZ er`Znl cZffh`Znl)
jnb ^q^Zm \hgmkZ bgbfb\hl ghl* dnkl ^bm ikb^ flg^ikb^m^ebnl)
mkhl) =Z\\ab]^f) ^m ^hl) jnb bgb* ikb^ =Zdb] bk mnhl) dnkb^ rkZ
fb\b lngm `^gmbl ghlmkZ^+ 0-Ing\ fl mZnmhl ikb^Zb+ 0- Oh]e mZb
bmZjn^ m^ah]b^ ^e^`bfnl ^ll^ikh f^l bZg]b^g bkbgdhf^ mZo^) dZ]
^h gh[bl bg ikbg\bi^f) ^m ]n\^f [mnf^b fnfl ch ob^mhc^ dngb*
Z] [^eeZg]nf [^eenf ghlmknf+ `Zbdmbl bkoZ]Zl dhohmbfl dh*
2. @m lnl\^ibm DhgZmaZl m^fihk^ ohfl+ 0. Onhf^m EhgZmZl iZf
beeh ikbg\biZmnf) ^m lnkk^qbm eh\h oZ]hoZobf bk lmhch lZoh [khebh
Dn]Z^ _kZmkbl lnb+
E]h ob^mhg+
0/
@m \h`ghobm =Z\\ab]^l) ^m 0/
OZb iZmrkl =Zdb]Zl b^dh*
jnZ^k^[Zm ^nf h\\b]^k^+ 00 @m ch ch nfnmb+ 00 =^m EhgZmZl) ch
\h`ghobm DhgZmaZl) ^m Nbfhg _kZ* [khebl NbfhgZl bkoblb ln cnh [n*
m^k ^bnl) ^m hfg^l) jnb \nf ^h onlb^cb) lnbghc Zib^mZb) iZ[`h
^kZgm7 ^m _n`^kngm bg ]^l^kmnf  O^dnhl mrknl bk lnlmhch ikb^
Oa^\nZ^) ^m \hgl^]^kngm Z] <liZkh ]nh[l oZg]^gl+ 01 =Z*
ZjnZfeZ\nl<liaZk( - . @m\h`ghobm db]Zl `Zoh Zib^ mZb bgb bk ln*
=Z\\ab]^l) ^m ]b^ lZ[[Zmhknfo^* [Zmhl ]b^g iZml ln oblZ lZoh
gbm bil^) ^m hfgbl ^q^k\bmnl ^bnl dZkbnhf^g^ Zmch  ZgZinl Ehk*
mkZgl Dhk]Zg^f+
]Zgh+
02
@m DhgZmaZl fblbm _kZmk^f 02
EhgZmZl [noh lbngml lZoh
lnnf ]n\^f ihineb) ^m kh`Zobm [khe mZnmhl oZ] bk ikZl lZoh

. / 2 & M T _W b i T \f 4 n o Z bs ] Z bl + }  %/ 4 &
< \W \ f  f \ X _ i T e g T f (  O b ^ )  d n k b ^  b d b  b h *
e^ b [ n o h  n h e l  l m Z m r f h  e Z b d r m h cZ b )
[ n o h  i Z l b] Z o  i Z ` h g bf l ) b k  g ^ m  i Z mb
E n ] ch l  Z ebl  k h ] l b l n l b] k Z n ` Z o n l 
l n  i k b^ Z bl ) g ^ l  cb  g ^ [ ^ ] Z o  r ] Z f l 
] ^ k e b Z n l +  }  E h b  g b  ` X g b (( (4  g n h  i k Z *
g Z h  H Z e Z d b c h  e Z b d n  % 1 2 -  f + i b k f 
F k +& +
% 0 0 &  G T U Z b  \ K X ^ h b f (( (  D  l n f n *
mh l  E ] h  d Z k bn h f ^ g l  [ n o h  ebd  eZ *
[ Z b  f Z Z  f h g b ) m h ] e  E h g Z m Z l  g ^ *
` Z e c h  l m h m b   Z m o b k  d h o + 
O ^d n hl
m r k n f Z  r k Z   i b ^ m n l  g n h  = ^ m e b ^ c Z n l

d

bd b H bk m b^ l  cn k Z b +
F n k b o b^ m Z  o Z ] b*
g Z f Z  < l i Z k n )  g k Z  b b g b .+ }  % 0 1 & 
: T ^ \ W T f  Z T i b (((  b m Z  ^ b e +  b Z  g ^ k ^ b d Z *
ebg ` Z + E b  i Z d Z k m h m Z  i h  m^ k i mh  i Z l Z *
d h cbf h  %0 2 } 1 /  ^ be+& ) b  d n k bh  i Z Z b *
d c Z )  d h ] e  = Z d b ] Z l  c h  b Z g Z i n l  E h k *
] Z g h + Q s +  1 0  ^ b e +
%0 2 & J T i b  U e b _\4 E h g  %0 5  ^ +& + } 
E T U h g \X } \h f (  Q s +  Z n d + 2 ) / 2 + < m l b f b g *
] Zf Zl
g Z [ n mb^ bn 
i Z eZ g d n f  r *
] Z f l ) E h g Z m Z l  i k Z  cn h l  i k b b f m b  i Z l 
l Z o ^  bk  i Z e Z b d r m b  r ]  eh [ ) mZ bi  i Z m 
f h m ^ k bl  b k  o Z b d n l 8 g Z [ n mb^ bn ) d n k b^ 
` r o ^ g h  mh eb n  mr k n f h l ) l r k  d Z *

Turinys

/)+

( ;29% 0# *-$++

IZ[nmaZ^hlZfb\hl lnhl)nm \hf*


fh]Zk^gm beebl ZiiZkZmnf lnnf)
jnb ^kZm \hibhlnl+ 03 @m ^qb^kngm
_bebb DZf[kb ^q HZ]Z[Z) ^m \hf*
ik^a^g]^kngm ehZgg^f) ^m hfgbZ)
jnZ^ aZ[^[Zm) ^m Z[b^kngmaZ[^g*
m^l ^Z+ 04 Khlm aZ^\o^k[Z) k^gng*
\bZmnf ^lm ehgZmaZ^) ^m Nbfhgb
_kZmkb ^bnl)jnbZ_bebb DZf[kb _Z\bngm
gnimbZl fZ`aZl) ^m ]n\ngm lihg*
lZf ^q HZ]Z[Z _bebZf ngbnl ]^
fZ`gbl ikbg\bib[nl >aZgZZg\nf
Zf[bmbhg^ fZ`gZ+ 05 @m k^\hk]Zmb
lngm lZg`nbgbl ehZggbl _kZmkbl lnb7
^m Zl\^g]^kngm) ^m Z[l\hg]^kngm
l^ ln[ m^`nf^gmh fhgmbl+ 06 @m
^e^oZo^kngm h\nehl lnhl) ^mob]^*
kngm7 ^m ^\\^ mnfnemnl) ^mZiiZkZ*
mnl fnemnl7^m lihglnl ikh\^llbm)
^m Zfb\b ^bnl) ^m _kZmk^l ^bnl h[*
obZf beebl \nf mrfiZgbl) ^m fn*
lb\bl) ^m Zkfbl fnembl+ 1- @m lnk*
k^q^kngm Z]^hl ^q bglb]bbl) ^mh\*
\b]^kngm ^hl) ^m \^\b]^kngm one*
g^kZmb fnemb) ^m k^lb]nb _n`^kngm
bg fhgm^l7 ^m Z\\^i^kngm hfgbZ
lihebZ ^hknf 71. ^m \hgo^klZ^lngm
gnimbZ^ bg en\mnf) ^m ohq fnlb*
\hknfbilhknf bgeZf^gmnf+ 1/@m
obg]b\Zo^kngm obg]b\mZf lZg`nb*
gbl _kZmkbl lnb7 ^m k^o^klb lngm Z]
kbiZf Dhk]Zgbl+
10 @m Zn]bobm=Z\\ab]^l) ^m o^*
gbm ]b^ lZ[[Zmhknfnljn^Z]hkZf
Dhk]Zgbl bg obkmnm^ fZ`gZ+ 11 @m
]bqbm Z] lnhl DhgZmaZl7 Nnk`Z*
fnl) ^m in`g^fnl \hgmkZ bgbfb*

ikb^m^ebnl IZ[nmb^bnl ikbbfmb iZl


lZo^ iZeZbdrmb ch eh[) dnkl[noh
eZ[Zb ]b]^ebl+ 03=^m EZf[kbh l*
gl b HZ]Z[hl bch) ln`Zoh
Ehg bk oblZ) d cbl mnkch) bkiZ*
lbf ln lZobf gnch lZn+ 04Kh
mh ordbh [noh ikZg^mZ EhgZmnb
bk ch [khebnb Nbfhgnb) dZ] EZf*
[kbh lgl d^ebZ ]b]^e^l o^lmn*
o^l bk o^]Z ln]b]^e^bdbef^ cZn*
gc b HZ]Z[hl) ob^g ]b]^eb
FZgZZgh dngb`Zbdb ]ndm^k+
05 Eb^ Zmlbfbg lZoh [khebh Ehgh
dkZnc) iZdbeh bk iZlblei dZegh
leirgl^+ 06Eb^iZde lZoh Zdbl
bk iZlbbkch8 mZb mkbndfZl bk
]b]^e bdbef8 cZngbdbl) ch ikb^*
m^ebZb bk ch `bfbgl ch Zgb^fl
ikb^Zbl ln [n[bgebZbl) fnsbdhl
ikb^mZblZbl bk ]Zn`^ebn `bgde+
1-Onhf^m cb^ inhe cnhl b mrdh*
cbfh ob^mhl bk nfn cnhl) mZbi
dZ] ]Zn` ln^blm dkbmh) h dbmb
iZ[`h  dZegnl8cb^ `b iZf ob*
l c `kh[+ 1. OZbi o^lmnol obk*
mh `^]ne bk c fnsbdhl `ZklZb
kZn]Z+1/ Eb^ d^krm^ Zmd^kbch lZ*
oh [khebh dkZnc bk ln`kh ikb^
Ehk]Zgh dkZgmh+

k bn h f ^ g  i Z l b^ d mb g ^ ` Z e ch ) mh ] e o b ^ *
m Z  e h [ b n b  i Z l  cn h l  [ n o h  l Z n ` b +  I Z * 
[ n m b^ bZ f l  l n m bd n l ) E h g Z m Z l  i Z o ^ ] 
l Z o h  [ k h ebn b Eh g n b g n ` Z [ ^ g mb i Z l 
g Z [ n m b^ bn l  eh [  b k  f h g ^ l 8 [ ^ m  i Z *
d ^ e c^  E Z f [ k b h  l g l  n i n h e  bk  o bl Z 
Z m f 8  E h g  ` b g n n ] + B Z o l  Z i b ^ 
m Z b  b g b )  E h g Z m Z l  l n  l Z o h  [ n k bn  g n *
c h  b Z g Z i n l  E h k ] Z g h  Z m d ^ k r m b  E Z f *
[ k b h  l g n f l + }  % 0 3 &  @ y  D T W T U b f (  N ^ *
g h o l  f b^ l mZ l  i k b^  M n [ ^ g h  ` bf bg l 
l b^ g h l + E Z f [ k bh  l g l  ` Z e [ n o h  Z k Z *

[  Z k  Z f h k b^ b  mZ n m^ e + }  % 0 4 & @y 
D T W T U b f ( B k + m + 7  b  I Z ] Z [ h mh + }  E Z n *

10 OZb b`bk]l =Zdb]Zl Zmch


ln[Zmhl ]b^g ln]b]^e^ dZkbnhf^*
g^ ikb^ Ehk]Zgh dkZgmh+ 11 Onh*
f^m EhgZmZlmZk lZob^lb^fl7 F^e*
dbfl bk dhohdbf^ ikb^ lZohg^*

g h cb  b  l Z o h  m o b d l  m n k c h  [ m b  Z m *
o ^ l m Z  m cZ n g b d b h  m o h  g Z f n l  H Z ] Z * 
[ h c^ +  }  B T a T T a b 4  i Z ` h g b )  ` Z e  Z f h *
k b ^ b +  }  % 0 6 &  < T h Z X _\h  Z \a ^ _ (  B b g *
d e n h m Z l  [ k r l  m n k ch  i Z ] b] bg m b o ^ l *
m n o b  b d b e f b g ` n f +
%1 0 & K T \ \y Z \e W f 4 d Z ]  E h g Z m Z l  ln 
l Z o h  [ k b n  r k Z  Z g Z i n l  E h k ] Z g h + Y } 
% 1 1 &  E X c e \ X g X _\ h f (  B k +  m + 7  b k  n  f n l n 
` r o r [ +  }  E X g T \c (((  b Z g ] b ^ g  f ^ l

Turinys

. H<F+ 6) 12}21

5/2

\hl ghlmkhl7 ghg ^lm ^gbbg ah]b^ ikb^m^ebnl)g^lbZg]b^g rkZ g^mZbi)


lb\nm a^kb) ^m gn]bnlm^kmbnl7 12^\* dZbi oZdZk bk noZdZk8 10 g^l mZb
^` ^gbf [^eenf ^q\_q`mnj) ZjnZ dhoZ ikb^ fnl) b ob^ghl `b bk
o^kh Dhk]Zgbl abg\ ^m bg]^) ^m kb* dbmhl inll Ehk]Zgh oZg]nh) [^
iZ^) ^m iZen]^;) ^m lZemnl7 ^m ghg mh i^edmZl dkZgmZl bkfbdZl)mZbi
^lm eh\nl ]bo^km^g]b+ 13 Ing\ ^k* dZ] gkZ dnk iZlbmkZndmb+ 13 OZb*
`h \eZfZm^ bg \Z^enf) nm eb[^k^* `bX]Z[Zk Zndbml  ]Zg`) dZ]
fbgb ]^ fZgn bgbfb\hknfo^lmkh* [mnfm^ boZ]nhmb b lZoh g^*
knf+ @m \hffbllnf ^lm [^eenf+ ikb^m^eb kZgdhl+ Dk ikZlb]ch dh*
14 @m ^qm^g]bm DhgZmaZl fZgnf oZ+ 14EhgZmZl bmb^l lZoh kZgd
lnZf) i^k\nm^k^ =Z\\ab]^f) ^m ]b* bmbdmb =Zdb]h) [^m mZlZb iZlbmkZn
o^kmbm Z[ ^h k^mkh7 15 ^m ]bllbebbm d Zm`Ze+ 15EhgZmZl bk [nonlb^cb
DhgZmaZl) ^m jnb \nf ^h ^kZgm bg ln cnh hdh %Ehk]Zg bk i^kieZn*
Dhk]Zg^f) ^m mkZglgZmZo^kngm Z] d Ehk]Zg Zg Zdrl^+ 16 D = Z*
^hl Dhk]Zg^f+ 16'@m \^\b]^kngm]^ db]h inll dkbmh m ]b^g mdl*
iZkm^=Z\\ab]bl ]b^ beeZ fbee^ obkb+ mZgmbl ork+
@m k^o^klb lngm bg D^knlZe^f)
Fbmb ln`kh  E^knsZe 26 bk
2- ^m Z^]b_b\Zo^kngm \bobmZm^l fn* iZlblmZmEn]chc^ lnlmbikbgm fb^*
gbmZl bg Dn]Z^Z)fngbmbhg^f)jnZ^ lm) mobkmhob ln Zndmhfbl lb^*
^kZm bg D^kb\ah) ^m bg <ffZnf) ghfbl) oZkmZbl bk ndZbbZbl E^*
^m bg =^mahkhg) ^m bg =^ma^e) ^m kbd^) @fZnl^) =^mahkhg^) =^mer*
OaZfgZmZ) ^m KaZkZ) ^m Oahih c^) OZfgZmhc^) KZkhc^ bk Ohi^+
fnkbl ^q\^elbl) ^m ihkmbl)^m l^kbl+ 2. Ebl iZebdh cnhl^ %`ne) dZ] iZ*
2. @m ihlnbm \nlmh]bZf bg ^bl) nm eZbdrm g^ikb^m^erlm ikb^ DskZ^e+
OZbi iZm cbl lnlmbikbgh =^mln*
bgbfb\bmbZl ^q^k\^k^gm bg DlkZ^e7
26 ^m fngbobm \bobmZm^f =^malnkZbg) khl fb^lm) JZsZk bk ibe) iZlmZ*
^m JZsZkZf) ^mZk\^f) ^m ihlnbm bg m cnhl^ dZkbnhf^gl bk Zikib*
^bl ZnqbebZ) ^mZiiZkZmnf ^l\Zknf7 gh fZblmn+ 202
'Zeb^l dngb`Zbdb
1
20 ^m Z\\^ibm _bebnl ikbg\binf k^* lgnl cbl iZf dZbmZbl bk eZbd
`bhgbl h[lb]^l) ^m ihlnbm ^hl bg cnhl [^eZblobZbl E^knsZel iberc^+
Zk\^ bg D^knlZe^f bg \nlmh]bZf+
bfmZl i^gdbZl]^bfmbl mk^*
21
@m Zggh \^gm^lbfhjnbgjnZ* 21
`^lbfh m^kmbh) f^gl^ l^\ng]h) bZbl f^mZbl ZgmkZf^ fg^lr*
^ l Z f ^  ] Z n `  ] b ] ^ l g b Z f ^  i Z o h cn c ^ ) 
d Z bi  Z g d l bZ n + }  %1 2 & E e T  ^ h e  c T '
f \g e T h ^ g \ (  = Z d b ] Z l  [ n o h  Z i l n i l  E h * 
g Z mh  [ n k b bk  i k bl i Z n ] l  i k b^  i ^ ed mh 
E h k ] Z g h  d k Z g m h +  E h g Z m Z l  f Z g ) d Z ] 
mh d bh l ^  Z i ebg d r [ l ^  cb l  ` Z eb d h o h mb bk
g ^ b k mb l n [ Z mh l  Z mbel bh + }  %1 3 & < T '
U T e  y T h ^ \ g f (((  K e ` +  Z n d + 0 ) 2 5 + }  % 1 4 & 
@ y g \ X f ( ((  K Z m l  = Z d b ] Z l  [ n o h  i b k f h l ^ 
d h o h m h c  ^ b e l ^  b k  Z k m b g h l b  i k b ^  E h * 
g Z mh ) m Z b Z n  m n k ch  i Z l bm k Z n d m b g n h 
ch  cZ n  b m b ^ l m h  d Z e Z o bch +
E h g Z m Z l  ch 
g ^ l b o ^ c Z )  [ ^ m  h d Z  l n  l Z o h  [ k b n  b
E h k ] Z g + N r k Z b  i eZ n d bZ g b  i ^ k  E h k *
] Z g  r ]  g ^ [ ^ f ` bg h  o r mbl +
% 1 6 &  B \g \(((4  l r k Z b +  }  % 2 - &  9 ` T h '
f X 4  @ f Z n l ^ +  K e ` +  Z n d + 1 ) . 2 +  }  _ \ X g X '

_ l ] X 4  b b Z n k  g n h  E ^ k n s Z e l )  i k b ^  d ^ *
e b h  b N Z f Z k b c  % K k Z ] +  . / ) 5 & +  }  % 2 / &

: X g f h e b f (((  K e ` +  Z n d + 1 ) / 6 +3 . +  }  > T '


m T e T (  Q s +  Z n d + 1 ). 2 + }
 G \_\(  Q s +  Z n d +
. )0 0 +
% 2 1 &  x \` g T f ((( 
= Z eZ g ] bh 
f g+
. 2 6  f + i b k f  F k +)  m Z b ` b  f ^ m Z f l  i k Z *
l e b g d n l  i h  E$ ] h  f b k m b ^ l +  }  M \W T h f 
y i X a g b e \ T h f ( (( 4  m  l b ^ g )  d n k b  l d r k 
d n g b`  o ^ g m h k b  g n h  b s k Z ^ e b m  o ^ g *
m h k bZ n l  %0  F Z k + 3 )0 3 8 /  F k h g + 1 )6 & +
O n h  l b^ g h l  l n ` k bh o bf n  < ed bf Z l  f Z *
mh f Z b g h k ch 
i Z g Z bd bg mb
l d bk mn f 
mZ k i  d n g b`  ` bf bg l  bk  bZ bi  cZ n  b s k Z *
^ ebm  bk  mn h  [ ] n  eZ [ bZ n  ^ e^ g bs n h m b
cn ] Z b s f +  }  G e T a T y  W T e U (  = Z g r *
b Z  [ n o h  i Z l m Z m r m Z  i k Z g Z  < ` ch  b k

Turinys

5/3

. H<F+ 6) 22}3/

ikZ^\^ibm <e\bfnl ]^lmknb fnkhl D c^ <edbfZl eb^i ln`kbZnmbob]Znl


]hfnl lZg\mZ^ bgm^kbhkbl) ^m ]^*  o^gmhkbZnl lb^g bk bZk]rmb ikZ*
lmknb hi^kZ ikhia^mZknf7 ^m\h^* gZ ]Zk[) bk cbl ikZ]ch `kbZn*
ibm ]^lmkn^k^+ 22 Dg m^fihk^ beeh D mb+ 22 Onh f^mn <edbfZl [noh
i^k\nllnl ^lm <e\bfnl7 ^m bfi^* e bmbdmZl bk ch lnfZgrfZb ln*
]bmZ lngm hi^kZ beebnl) ^m h\\en* mknd]rmb8 ch [nkgZ[noh lnbZn*
lnf ^lm hl ^bnl) ^m ]bllhenmnl imZ) cbl [noh lmZ[h bmbdmZl)
^lm iZkZerlb) g^\ nemkZ ihmnbm eh* g^[^`Zech ]Zn`bZn bmZkmb g
jnb o^k[nf) ^m fZg]Zk^ ]^ ]h* h]bh) g^b ]nhmb lZdrf Zib^
fh lnZ+ 2324' @m fhkmnnl ^lm <e\b* lZoh gZfnl+ 23 OZbi <edbfZlfb*
fnl bg m^fihk^ beeh \nf mhkf^g* b k mnh f^mn ]b]^ebnhl^ ldZnl*
fnhl^+
mh fZ`gh+
24
=Zdb]Zl) iZfZml) dZ] <edb*
24 @m ob]bm =Z\\ab]^l jnhgbZf
fhkmnnl ^lm <e\bfnl7^m k^o^klnl  fZl fbk) ln`kh iZl dZkZeb)
^lm Z] k^`^f) ^m lbenbm m^kkZZg* c bk Zebl mnkch ]o^cnl f^mnl Zmbe*
y
 bh+
gbl ]nh[nl+
25 =^m oblb g^]hkb^cb mZklb bk
25 @m \h`bmZo^kngm hfg^l bgb* b
jnb ]b\^gm^l7 @\\^ ehgZmaZl) ^m c lZd7 mZb EhgZmZlbk dnkb^ ln cnh
jnb \nf ^h lngm) bg lbe^gmbh aZ* c rkZ `ro^gZ kZfbZb [^ [Zbfl8mZb*
[bmZgm \hg_b]^gm^k7'gng\ ^k`h Z]*  `b Zmo^ldbf^ ]Z[Zk =Zdb]) bkcbl
]n\Zfnl =Z\\ab]^f) ^m \hfik^* c ln`Znl cnhloblnli^k ob^g gZdm)
a^g]^m ^hl hfg^l ngZ gh\m^+ c  26 Eb^ gnch bk mZbi cZf iZmZk+
26 @m Z[b^kngm) ^m \hglbebnf^b]^*  3- Ebl iZdbeh) dZ] Zm^bm ln ]b]^*
]^kngm+ ^h@m lnkk^qbm nm o^gbk^m D e^ dZkbnhf^g^8 [^ mh) cbl gnlbng*
\nf ^q^k\bmn fnemh7 ^m fblbm D m leZibZ eZbd lZoh l[kZfl
h\\nem^ ^iblmheZl lh\bbl lnbl) jnb En]chc^) dZ] cb^ ln`Znm EhgZm
^kZgm bg Dn]Z^Z) nm\hfik^a^g]^* c bk mnhl) dnkb^ ln cnh [noh8 [^m
 cb^ g^`Zech) g^l c lnfZgrfZl
k^gm ehgZmaZg) ^m ^hl) jnb \nf
^h ^kZgm7l^] ghg ihmn^kngm)jnbZ 7 iZlb]Zk Zgb^fl bghfZl+
bgghmnbm ^bl \hglbebnf ^hknf+
3.
@m Ziik^a^g]bm ]^ obkbl k^* 3. Ebl gnmok b Zeb^l fh*
`bhgbl) jnb ikbg\bi^l ^kZgm fZeb* gb) dnkb^ [noh lfhdleh oZ]Zb)
mbZ^) jnbgjnZ`bgmZ obkhl) ^m h\\b* i^gdbZl ]^bfmbl ork bk nfn*
]bm ^hl7 3/^ml^\^llbm ehgZmaZl) ^m  cnhl+ 3/ EhgZmZl) NbfhgZl bk
Nbfhg) ^m jnb \nf ^h ^kZgm bg . ln cnh[nonlb^cb iZlbmkZnd  =^m*
=^ma[^ll^g) jnZ^ ^lm bg ]^l^kmh7
T Z d Z k b c h  e Z b d Z b l  b k  c  k i ^ l g b n + < k 
b Z  m n k m Z  ` Z e o h c^  [ ^ m  d n k b r i Z m bg *
` Z  m  i k Z g Z n  Z m ebd m h  ] Z k [ h  ] Z ebl )
g ^ o b l Z b  Z b d n +  }  % 2 2 &  : h i b  \ y g \ ^ g T f (((
F Z ] Z g ` b < ed bf Z l  [ n o h  l mZ [ h  b mbd m Z l 
m n h  f ^ m n ) d Z b  c b l  d l b g h l b  ` k b Z n m b  [ Z *
g r b h l  o ^ g m h k b Z n l  l b ^ g )  m Z b   m 
c h  e b `  d g r ` h l  Z n m h k b n l  b k b  d Z b i  b
? b^ o h  l bn l m  [ Z n l f +
% 2 4 &  J h Z e { b (((  = Z d b ] n b )  [ ^  Z [ ^ c h )
m n k ch  i Z m bd mb < ed bf h  i Z l m Z g ` h l  i Z *
` h g bg mb E n ] c ) mZ bZ n  ` k m b i Z l  d Z *
k Z eb  c  i Z l d Z mbg h  mbd k bZ n l bZ b  g ^  o b^ g

< ed bf h  f bk mbl +
B Z e bZ  i Z l bk ^ b d 
M h f h l  l ^ g Z m h  eZ b d n  m Z d Z + Q s + Z n d +
5 ) 0 . +0 / + }  < i X ]h f  ` X g h f 4  b d b  . 2 4  f +
i bk f  F k +
%2 5 &
E X W b e \X ]\4 l r k  Z ebg bg d Z b
r ] Z b+
%3 . & A \ f  a h g i e 4 E h g Z m Z l + < g h m
d bmn  Z b d b g m h cn ) l r k Z b )  d n k b ^  [ n o h  g ^ *
i Z m^ g d bg mb) d Z ]  r ` bl  i k b^  E h g Z m 
i Z l bk h ]  g ^  mh d l  i b` n l  ] Z e r d Z l ) d Z bi 
d Z e [ b g ch 
Eh g Z mh 
i k b^ Z b+ }  %3 / &
: X gU X f X ( E h l  o b^ mZ  g ^ bg h f Z +
% 3 0 &  B h e \X  U h i b  \y  A h W ] b f (  = Z *

Turinys

. H<F+ 6) 30}4/

^m ^qmknqbm ]bknmZ ^bnl) ^m _bkfZ*


o^kngm ^Zf+
30 @m \h`ghobm =Z\\ab]^l) ^m
\hg`k^`Zobm ngbo^klZf fnembmn]b*
g^f lnZf7 ^m abl) jnb ]^en]Z^Z
^kZgm) ]^gng\bZobm+ 31@m o^gbm) ^m
\ZlmkZ ihlnbm]^lni^k=^ma[^Nl^g7
^m hiin`gZobm ^Zf ]b^l fnemhl)
^m _^\bm fZ\abgZl+ 32 @m k^ebjnbm
DhgZmaZl Nbfhg^f _kZmk^f lnnf
bg \bobmZm^) ^m ^qbbm bg k^`bhg^f)
^m o^gbm \nf gnf^kh) 33 ^m i^k*
\nllbm J]Zk^g) ^m _kZmk^l ^bnl) ^m
_bebhl KaZl^khg bg + mZ[^kgZ\nebl
bilhknf) ^m \h^ibm \Z^]^k^) ^m
\k^l\^k^ bg obkmnmb[nl+ 34Nbfhg
o^kh) ^m jnb \nf bilh ^kZgm) ^qb^*
kngm ]^ \bobmZm^) ^m ln\\^g]^kngm
fZ\abgZl) -5 ^m in`gZo^kngm \hg*
mkZ =Z\\ab]^f) ^m \hgmkbmnl ^lm
Z[ ^bl7 {m Z__ebq^kngm ^nf oZe]^)
jnhgbZf \hglbebnf ^bnl) ^m \hg*
`k^llnl ^bnl ^kZm bgZgbl+
36 @m bkZmnl \hgmkZ obkhl bgb*
jnhl) jnb ^b \hglbebnf ]^]^kZgm
nm o^gbk^m bg k^`bhg^f bilhknf)
fnemhl ^q ^bl h\\b]bm7bil^Znm^f
\h`bmZobm \nf k^ebjnbl Z[bk^ bg
k^`bhg^f lnZf+
4- @m \h`ghobm DhgZmaZl7^mfb*
lbm Z] ^nf e^`Zmhl \hfihg^k^
iZ\^f \nf bilh) ^m k^]]^k^ ^b
\ZimbobmZm^f+ 4. @m eb[^gm^k Z\\^*
ibm) ^m _^\bm l^\ng]nfo^k[Z^bnl)
^m bnkZobm l^ gbabe _Z\mnknf ^b
fZeb hfgb[nl ]b^[nl obmZ^ ^bnl+
4/@m k^]]b]bm^b\ZimbobmZm^f)jnZf
ikbnl ^kZm ikZ^]Zmnl ]^ m^kkkZ en*
]Z7 ^m \hgo^klnl Z[bbm bg m^kkZf

d b] Z l  i Z ] b] bg h  l Z o h  d Z k bn h f ^ g  r *
] Z b l )  E h g Z m h  i k b ^ Z b l +  }  %32& @ \  U L %
K PK L S P \  I v Y P \ ,  d n k b Z f  i Z o r d h  i Z e b d m b 
Z i ` n em  mo bk mh o  ] k Z n `  ln  Eh g Z mn + } 
% 3 3 &  < K H Y p &&&  F Z l  [ n o h  b Z  o Z k ] b c Z *
f b Z l f ^ g r l ) ] Z n ` bZ n  bg b  g k Z + } 
= Y H K s Q V  N H SH I ^ [ P & 
K k b^ n l ) d n k bZ bl 
k f l b l r k  d Z k bn h f ^ g ) E h g Z m Z l  g Z b*
d b g h )  l Z o h  ` b  [ k  ] b ] bg h ) d Z ]  l n  i Z *

*$)

[^l) ^lZgb mrknhl^) iZmZbl) dZl


[noh ln`kbZnmZ) bk lnlmbikbgh c+
30 OZb iZmrkl =Zdb]Zl lnkbg*
dh obl lZoh ]Zn`r[) ]Zo b*
gb mb^fl) dnkb^ [noh b En]chl)
31Zmch) iZlmZm lmhordeZndbZn
=^m[^ll) eZbd c Zi`nel ]Zn*
`^e ]b^g bk iZlb]Zk dZkh iZ*
[de+ 32=^m EhgZmZl) iZebdl lZ*
oh [khe Nbfhg fb^lm^) bch 
Ze bk ch ln g^]b]^ebn [kbn+
33 Ebl lnfn J]Zk bk ch [kh*
ebnl) KZlZkhgh lgnl c iZ]Zg`*
ml^ bk ikZ]ch `ZeZ[rmb bk Zn`mb
c`hfbl+ 34 NbfhgZl bk ln cnh [n*
onlb^cb bch bf b^lmh  bk iZ]^`
dZkh iZ[denl) 35 dhohch ikb^
=Zdb]) bk cbl [noh c lnmkbgmZl8
cb^ eZ[Zb c ikble`) g^l ch ln*
fZgrfZl bk inhebfZl [noh g^*
iZlbl^dl+
36 Onhf^m cbl) lnirdl Zgmm
g^]hk fhgb) dnkb^ [noh cZf
iZmZk Zm^bmb  c Ze) ]Zn`^e c
nfn) iZml `b gnmZk ln ebdn*
lbZbl `kmb  lZoh Ze+
4- OZb iZmrkl EhgZmZl lbngm
iZl c iZlbngmbgb ]Zkrmb ln cnh
mZbdhl bk `kbgmb cZf [^eZblob+
4. Ebl fb^en ghkn ikbf)& iZ]Zk)
dZbi mZlZb lZd bk ikblb^d g^]Z*
krlbl cZf gb^dh ibdmZ i^k oblZl
ch`ro^gbfh]b^gZl+ 4/ Khmhcblln*
`kbgh cZf [^eZblobnl) dnkbnhl
[noh ZgdlbZn iZfl b En]h

] b ] b g m h f b l  c ` h f b l  ^ b m  b i Z ` Z e [  n *
] Z k r mZ f  m o bk m h o c^  N bf h g n b+
%4.& 7 P Z  T PL S \  U V Y \ &&&  = Z d b ] n b  ] Z ) 
[ Z k  [ n o h  i Z mh ` bZ n  i Z ] Z k r mb [ ^ m d h *
d b  m Z b d ) g ^ ` n  i Z l b m k Z n d m b  [ ^  g b^ d h )
i k Z eZ bf cn l  d h o + }  %4 / & 0 L SH PZ %
] P\ Z &&&  = ^ e Z b l o b Z b  [ n o h  ` k b g m b )  m Z *
bZ n  i Z bf mb d Z bm Z bl  r ] Z b m n k ch  i Z *
l b e b d m b  E ^ k n s Z e l  i b e r c ^  % o s +  Z n d + 2 0

Turinys

/)/

( ;29% 0# .8T ('# ,

lnZf) ^m ghg Ziihlnbm Zfiebnl


o^gbk^ bg _bg^l ^bnl7
40 @m \^llZobm `eZ]bnl ^q Dl*
kZ^e7 ^m aZ[bmZobm DhgZmaZl bg
HZ\afZl)^m\h^ibmDhgZmaZlb[bcn*
]b\Zk^ ihinenf) ^m ^qm^kfbgZobm
bfibhl ^q DlkZ^e+

Zeb^l) oe ln`kh b lZoh Ze bk


]Zn`bZn g^[^ch  En]h kb[Zl+
40 OZbi dZeZobcZl iZlbZebgh b
DskZ^ebh+ EhgZmZl `ro^gh HZdf^)
dZf^ cbl ikZ]ch m^blmb mZnm8 bk
EhgZmZl bgZbdbgh [^]b^obnl b Ds*
kZ^ebh+

M!% <ZYL_L^ [LWLTVZ VL]LWT{ 4WPV^LYO]t%


6L[`_ H% . @m Zggh \^gm^lb* U '& [P]^Vb]TXL^% . bfmZl ^*
fh l^qZ`^lbfh Zl\^g]bm <e^qZg* D bZl]^bfmZbl f^mZbl iZdbeh <gmb*
]^k <gmbh\ab _bebnl) jnb \h`ghfb*  hdhlgnl<e^dlZg]kZl)ikZfbgmZl
gZmnl ^lm Ih[bebl7 ^m h\\niZobm c NdZblbnhcn) bk iZf Kmhe^fZb*
Kmhe^fZb]Zf7 ^m k^\^i^kngm ^nf) ]8 cbl [noh ikbbfmZl bk ikZ]ch
^m k^`gZobm beeb\+ / @m Zn]bobm ?^* m^gZb dZkZebZnmb+ / OZb b`bk]l dZ*
f^mkbnl k^q) ^m \hg`k^`Zobm ^q^k* kZebnl ?^f^mkbcnl lnkbgdh eZ[Zb
\bmnf \hibhlnf oZe]^) ^m ^qbobm `Znlbg` dZkbnhf^g bkbchcZf
ikb^Zbl  dho+
h[obZf beeb bg ikZ^ebnf+
?^f^mkbcnl lbngm EhgZmnb
0
@m fblbm ?^f^mkbnl ^iblmh* 0
eZf Z] ehgZmaZg o^k[bl iZ\b_b\bl) eZbd ln mZbdbZbl h]bZbl ch iZ*
nm fZ`gb_b\Zk^m ^nf+ 1 ?bqbm ^gbf7 `^k[mb+ 1 I^l cbllZd7 KZlbldn[bg*
<gmb\bi^fnl _Z\^k^ iZ\^f \nf dbf^ ]Zkrmb ln cnh mZbdZgdlbZn)
^h) ikbnljnZf _Z\bZm \nf <e^qZg* g^dZbi cbl iZ]Zkrl ln <e^dlZg*
]kh Z]o^klnf ghl7 2 k^\hk]Z[bmnk ]kn ikb^fnl+ 2I^l cbl Zmlbfbgl
^gbf hfgbnf fZehknf) jnZ^_^* oblZl ibdm^gr[^l) dnkbZl f^l iZ*

^ b e +  b k  ^ f + . - ) 3 & )  d n k b h c ^ )  m Z b i  i Z m ) 
d Z bi  bk  d bm h l ^  m o bk mh o l ^ ) i Z l bebd h  l r * 
k  ` n eh l +
% 4 0 &  8 H SH ] PQH Z  W H Z Pk H S P U V ,  d Z k Z l 
e b h o l b +  }  : H R T L ,  b b Z n k  g n h  E ^ *
k n s Z e l  Z g m = ^ g cZ f bg h  ` bf bg l  l b ^ *
g h l  %.  F Z k +  . 0 ) . / & +  }  A L P Z [ P  [ H \ [ p ,
d Z bi  d bm Z ] h l  l ^ g h o c^  D s k Z ^ e b h  O ^ b l *
c Z b +  }  6 k U H P R PU V ,  [ ^ g m  i k b o ^ k m  cn h l 
l e i mbl  bk  b l b Z ] mb l Z o h  i Z l bd l bg b*
f  i k b^  r ] n  k ^ eb` bc +
. - ). } 5 6 +  F b e n l  o Z b ] Z f l  ] e  N r k b * 
ch l  l h l mh  mZ k i  < e^ d l Z g ] k h  bk  ? ^ f ^ *
m k b cZ n l ) E h g Z m Z l  l m h c Z  < e^ d l Z g ] k h  i n *
l g  % . } . 4 & +
O Z l Z b  g n ` Z eb ? ^ f ^ mk b* 
c  b k  ] k Z n `  l n  l Z o h  n h o b n  K m h e ^ f b ^ * 
cn f b  A b e h f ^ m h k b n  i k b i Z l m Z  E h g Z m 
r ]  o r k b Z n l b n h cn  d n g b ` n  % . 5 } 3 3 & + 
F Z b ? ^ f ^ m k b cn l  I bd Z m h k bl  f ` bg Z  g n *
o ^ k l m b g n h  l h l m h  < e^ d l Z g ] k ) E h g Z *
m Z l  g n ` Z eb Z g h  d Z k bn h f ^ g l  o Z ] 
< i h e h g b c  b k  ] e m h  l n l b e Z n d b Z  b  < e ^ *

dlZg ] kh 
eZ [ Z b
] b] ^ e l 
i Z` Zk[ h l
%3 4 } 5 6 &+
% . - ). &  j PT [ H Z &&&  . 2 /  f + i b k f  F k + 
< e^ d l Z g ] kZ l  = Z eZ l 
}  / S L R Z H U K Y H Z & 
g^[noh
d Z k Z ebZ n l 
< g mbh d h 
l g n l +
< g h m bl mh k bd h  En l mbg h ) cb l  [ n o l  ^ *
f h l  d bef l +
= ] Z f Z l  mZ bZ n  i Z g Z *
n l  b < g m b h d  @ n i Z m h k b )  c b l  l Z d l b 
^ l l  ch  [ k h ebl  bk  < g mbh d h  @ i b_Z g h  l *
g l ) m h ] e  m n k l  m ^ b l l  Z n m b  N r k b c h l 
l h l m + M h f h l  l ^ g Z mZ l ) d n k l  i Z l bebd h 
g ^ i Z eZ g d n l  ch  i Z m b^ l  cZ n  i k bi Z bg mZ f 
N r k b c h l  d Z k Z e b n f b  ? ^ f ^ m k b cn b )  i Z l b *
g Z n ] h ch  < e^ d l Z g ] k n ) d Z ]  l n ] Z k r mn 
l n g d ^ g r [ b  ? ^ f ^ m k b cn b 7 cb l  l n m bd h
b k m b   < e ^ d l Z g ] k )  d Z b i  c  < g m b h d h 
l g ) b k  k f  c h  m ^ b l ^ l + 
I ^ l m^ [ mb*
g Z  mZ m ) d Z ]  bk  r ] Z b eZ bd  < e^ d l Z g ] k 
m b d k n  < g m b h d h  @ i b _ Z g h  l g n f b + O h d l 
i Z m o bl n  l bmbd bg bf Z l  [ n o h  N r k b ch c^ 
bk  H Z h ch c^  < s b ch c^ + < e^ d l Z g ] k Z l  l Z *
o h  f h g ^ mh l ^  o Z ] bg Z  l Z o ^  @ i b_ Z g n  }

Turinys

. H<F+ .-) 3} .3

5/6

^dhpn di `ph) `odi am\om`h `dpn) ]Zkf^ cZf) ch [khebnb bkch mZn*
^m bg `^gm^f ^bnl+ 3 @m ]^]bm ^b mZb+ 3 OZb`b cbl]Zo cZf `Zebkbgd*
ihm^lmZm^f \hg`k^`Zg]b ^q^k\b* mb dZkbnhf^g) ]bk[mb `bgdenl bk
mnf) ^m _Z[kb_b\Zk^ ZkfZ) ^m ^ll^ [mb ch lcng`bgbgdn)mZbi iZmeb^*
bilnf lh\bnf ^bnl7 ^m h[lb]^l) i Zmb]nhmb cZf dZbmnl)[nonlbnl
jnb ^kZgm bgZk\^) bnllbm mkZ]b ^b+
iberc^+
EhgZmZl Zmch c E^knsZe bk
4
@m o^gbm DhgZmaZl bg D^knlZ* 4
e^f) ^m e^`bm ^iblmheZl bg Zn]bmn i^kldZbm eZbd) `bk]bgm oblZb mZn*
hfgbl ihineb) ^m ^hknf) jnb bg mZb bk mb^fl) dnkb^ [noh iberc^+
Zk\^ ^kZgm+ 5 @m mbfn^kngm mbfhk^ 5 Ob^ eZ[Zb gnlb`Zg]h) dZb b`bk*
fZ`gh) jnhgbZf Zn]b^kngm jnh] ]h) dZ] dZkZebnl ]Zo cZf `Zeb
]^]bm ^b k^q ihm^lmZm^f \hg`k^* kbgdmb dZkbnhf^g+ 6EhgZmnb [noh
`Zg]b ^q^k\bmnf+ 6 @m mkZ]bmb lngm Zmb]nhmb dZbmZb) hcblZmb]Zocnhl
ehgZmaZ^ h[lb]^l) ^m k^]]b]bm^hl moZfl+ .- OZbi EhgZmZl `ro^gh
iZk^gmb[nl lnbl7 .- ^maZ[bmZobm Dh* E^knsZec^ bk f lmZmrmb [^b gZn*
gZmaZl bg e^knlZe^f) ^m \h^ibm Z^* cbgmb fb^lm+ ..Ebl eb^i ]Zk[bgbg*
]b_b\Zk^) ^m bgghoZk^ \bobmZm^f+ dZfl iZlmZmrmb fkh lb^gZlbkZi*
.. @m ]bqbm _Z\b^gmb[nl hi^kZ nm lnimb Nbhg Ziebgdnb d^mnkdZf*
^qlmkn^k^gmfnkhl^mfhgm^fNbhg ibZbl Zdf^gbfbl lnlmbikbgbfnb+
bg \bk\nbmn eZib]b[nl jnZ]kZmbl Z] Eb^ mZbi bk iZ]Zk+ ./ Onhf^m lo^*
fngbmbhg^f7 ^m bmZ _^\^kngm+ ./@m mbfZebZb) dnkb^ [noh =Zdb]h iZ*
_n`^kngm Zeb^gb`^gZ^) jnb ^kZgm lmZmrmhl^ mobkmhol^) iZ[`h .0bk
bg fngbmbhgb[nl) jnZl =Z\\ab]^l db^dob^gZl) iZebdllZoh ob^m) ln*
Z^]b_b\Zo^kZm7 .0 ^m k^ebjnbm ngnl* `kh  lZoh Ze+ .1ObdmZb =^mln*
jnbljn^ eh\nf lnnf) ^m Z[bbm bg khc^ ebdh dZb dnkb^ b m) dnkb^
m^kkZf lnZf7 .1mZgmnf bg =^ma* [noh iZf^m lmZmrf bk ?b^oh
lnkZ k^fZgl^kngm Zebjnb ^q abl) lZdrfnl) g^lmZb [nohcb^flikb^*
jnb k^ebjn^kZgm e^`^f) ^m ikZ^* `eZn]Z+
\^imZ ?^b) ^kZm ^gbf aZ^\ ^bl
Z] k^_n`bnf+
FZkZebnl <e^dlZg]kZl b`bk*
.2
@m Zn]bobm <e^qZg]^k k^q .2
ikhfbllZ) jnZ^ ikhfblbm ?^f^m* ]h Zib^ iZZ]nl) dnkbnhl [noh
kbnl ehgZmaZ^7 ^m gZkkZo^kngm ^b iZ]Zkl ?^f^mkbcnl EhgZmnb8 cZf
ikZ^ebZ) ^m obkmnm^l) jnZl bil^ iZiZlZdhmZ mZbi iZm Zib^ dhoZl
_^\bm) ^m _kZmk^l ^bnl) ^m eZ[hk^l) bk ]klbnl o^bdlfnl) dnkbnhl[n*
jnhl eZ[hkZo^kngm+.3 ^mZbmbInf * oh Zmebdl cbl bk ch [khebZb) bkZib^
jnb] bgo^gb^fnl Zebjn^f obknf oZk`nl)dnkbnhlcb^boZk`h+.3Onh*
N d Z bl bn h cn + }  F Z k Z ebZ n mb cb l  i k Z ] ch 
N b r k b ch l  f b ^ l m ^  K m h e ^ f Z b ] h c ^ )  d n k b 
cZ f  i Z o r d h  i Z bf mb l n  g ^ ] b] ^ e^  d Z *
k bn h f ^ g ^ +
% 3 &  J]haZ\a\a^( O Z b i  ? ^ f ^ m k b * 
cn l  i k bi Z bg h  E h g Z m  E n ] ch l  d n g b*
` Z bd bn ) m Z b Z n  i k bd eZ n l h f n  g n h  N r * 
k b c h l +  }  ^T\gh f((( K e ` +  Z n d +  6 )2 0 +
% 5 &  K \X  _TU T\((( N r k Z b  b k  r ] Z b  Z m * 
i n h e ebZ b ] Z [ Z k  i k Z ] ch  [ b ch m b  E h g Z m h 
d ^ k m h +  }  % . - &  > l i Xa b AX e h m T _ ]X 4
i Z e b d l  H Z d f +  Q s +  6 )4 0 +  }  Dheb

f\X a T f 4 E ^ k n s Z e c ^ +  }  9 cfhcg\ J \b'


a((( = Z g r b h l  d Z e g h  l n l m b i k b g b f Z b 
[ n o h  l n ` kbZ n mb N r k b ch l  d Z k Z ebZ n l  l Z *
d r f n +  K e ` +  3 ) 3 / +  }  % . / &  K i \egbi fX(((
K e ` +  6 )2 - } 2 / +
% . 2 &  @yZ \eW b  T c \X cT{TW h f &&&  ? ^ * 
f ^ m k b cZ n l  ^ e ` ^ l r l  i Z l d Z m bg h  < e^ d l Z g *
] k  b^ d h m b E h g Z m h  i Z eZ g d n f h + } 
% . 5 &  : eb _ Ab a T g ( b m n h  i Z o Z ] b g b f n 
< e^ d l Z g ] k Z l  i kbi Z l mZ  E h g Z m  g ^ *
i k bd eZ n l h f n  E n ] ch l  o Z e] h o n + < g h m
/ -  ^ +)  c b l  Z m l b n g m  E h g Z m n b  b k  o b k n c b *

Turinys

/*'

( ;29% ('# (.T)+

mZe^f; m gng\ _Z\b^fnl ^nf


Zfb\nf) ^m lh\bnf ghlmknf+ .4
@m l\kbilbm ^iblmheZf) ^m fblbm
^b l^\ng]nf aZ^\ o^k[Z) ]b\^gl7
.5 M@R<e^qZg]^k _kZmkb DhgZmaZ^
lZenm^f+ .6<n]bobfnl ]^m^ jnh]
obk ihm^gl lbl obkb[nl) ^m Zi*
mnl ^l nm lblZfb\nl ghlm^k7 /- ^m
gng\ \hglmbmnbfnl m^ah]b^lnf*
fnf lZ\^k]hm^f `^gmbl mnZ^)
^m nm Zfb\nl oh\^kbl k^`bl) %^m
fblbm ^b inkinkZf) ^m \hkhgZf
Znk^Zf& ^m jnZ^ ghlmkZ lngm
l^gmbZl gh[bl\nf) ^m \hgl^ko^l
Zfb\bmbZl Z] ghl+
/. @m bg]nbm l^ ehgZmaZllmheZ
lZg\mZ l^imbfh f^gl^) Zggh\^g*
m^lbfh l^qZ`^lbfh bg]b^ lhe^f*
gb l\^ghi^`bZ^7 ^m \hg`k^`Zobm
^q^k\bmnf) ^m_^\bm ZkfZ \hibhlZ+
// @m Zn]bobm ?^f^mkbnlo^k[Z
blmZ) ^m \hgmkblmZmnl ^lm gbfbl) ^m
Zbm7 /0 Lnb] ah\ _^\bfnl) jnh]
ikZ^h\\niZobm ghl <e^qZg]^kZi*
ik^a^g]^k^ Zfb\bmbZf en]Z^hknf
Z] fngbf^g lnb; /1 N\kb[Zf ^m
^`h beebl o^k[Z ]^ik^\ZmhkbZ) ^m

g bn l  d Z k Z e b d h l  ` Z k [ l  ^ g d e n l )  m n h 
g h k ] Z f Z l  i Z e^ g d mb cb  ] Z k  eZ [ bZ n  l Z *
o h  i n l g + }  % / - &  C ^ Y P H \ Z P \ V Q \  R \ %
U PN \ &  Q r k b Z n l b h c h  d n g b ` h  ` Z k [  i Z l 
r ] n l  [ n o h  i Z o ^ e] bf Z  b  m o n ) c b  g ^ *
[ n o h  l n m ^ bd bZ f Z  i Z k bg d bf n + I n h  N Z * 
] h d h  eZ bd n  m Z  ` Z k [  i k bd eZ n l  @ e ^ Z * 
s Z k h  ^ bf r g Z b bk  i Z l bebd h  ch c ^  bd b
f b k m b ^ l  J g b ch  D D D )  d n k b h  l g n l ) i Z l d n *
m b g b l  @ e ^ Z s Z k h  Z b g b l )  i Z [ ` h   < b ` b i * 
m + I n h  bh  f ^ mh  o r k bZ n l bh ch  d n g b` h 
i Z k ^ b ` h l  [ n o h  i Z k ] n h ] Z f h l + Y E Z s h * 
g Z l  ] ch  i Z l m Z g ` ) d Z ]  c b l  [ m  < g *
m b h d h  @ i b _ Z g h  l m Z m r m Z l  o r k b Z n l b n h cn 
d n g b` n  % /  H Z d + 1 )4 +++& + < ed bf Z l  [ n *
o h  i Z l d b k m Z l  < g m b h d h  @ n i Z m h k b h +  K D ` +
6 )2 3 + H b k n l  < e d b f n b ) o r k b Z n l b h c h  d n *
g b` h  o b ^ m Z  [ n o h  g ^ n bf m Z  4  f ^ mn l 
b k  2  f g ^ l bn l + E h g Z m Z l ) m b ^ l  l Z d Z g m )
g ^ m n k ch  m ^ b l l  m Z b  o b^ m Z b) [ ^ m) [ n ] Z *

f^m cbl mZk7 <k`b f^l kZlbf^ db*


m mhd ork; KZ]Zkrdbf^ ]Z[Zk
lZn b ch fl ikb^m^e bk lcng*
`bgbgd+ .4Ebl iZkZ bk gnlbngm
cZf eZbd) dnkbh mnkbgrl [noh
mhdl7 .5 FZkZebnl <e^dlZg]kZl
lo^bdbgZ [khe EhgZm+ .6H^l `bk*
]chf^ Zib^ mZo^) dZ] ^lb fh*
`nl `Zebg`Zl c`hfbl bk mbgdZfZl
[mb fl ikb^m^ebn8 /-mh]e f^l
lmZmhf^ bZg]b^g mZo^ orkbZn*
lbnhcn mZoh mZnmhl dngb`n) bk mn
mnkb oZ]bgmbl dZkZebZnl ikb^m^ebn
%mnh iZbn f^mn cbl Zmlbngm cZf
inkink bkZndlbg oZbgbd&) [d
fnfl bmbdbfZl fl k^bdZenhl^
bk iZeZbdrdfnfllZohikb^m^erlm+
/.EhgZmZl Zilbobedho^gmn Zi*
]Zkn l^imbgmZf^ fg^lrc^bfmZl
^bZl]^bfmZbl f^mZbl bdbefbg*
`hc^ KZ]Zg`b o^gmc^8 cbl kbg*
dh lZn dZkbnhf^g bk iZlb]Zk
]Zn` `bgde+
// D`bk]l Zib^ bmnhl ]Zer*
dnl) ?^f^mkbcnl eZ[Zb gneb]h bk
mZk7 /0 F bZf^l iZ]Zkf^)dZ]
<e^dlZg]kZl lnldn[h ibkf f*
l lb`rmb r] ikb^m^erlm; /1 KZ*
kZrlbn bk Z cb^fl ikZrfh h*
]bnl) Z]]ZfZl `Zk[bg` ob^m

$ f Z l  b  d n g b `  ` b f b g l  b k  g ^ [ ^ l Z g m 
 m ^ b l m h  i ] b g b h ) c b l  f Z g  ` Z e l  ] e 
 l Z o h  d b e f l  i k b b f m b  o r k b Z n l b h c h  d n *
g b` h  ` Z k [  b k  i Z k ^ b ` Z l +
% / . &  / W Z P] PSR V  k ] L U [ \  H W K H Y \ $&&,
o r k b Z n l b h ch  d n g b` h  k [ Z bl + O Z b  o r d h 
. 2 /  f + i b k f  F k +  l ^ i m b g m Z f ^  % m b k b h & 
f g ^ l r c^  K Z ] Z g ` b  o ^ g m c^ +
% / 0 &  / S L R Z H U K Y H Z  Z \ Z R \ I V &&&  E h g Z *
mZ l  g ^ [ n o h  Z i l b f l  i Z eZ bd r m b r i Z *
m b g ` n  [ ] n  ? ^ f ^ m k b c + 
< e^ d l Z g ] k Z l 
[ n o h  k h f g  ` e h [ h c^ )  l n  d n k b Z b l  r * 
) ] Z b  [ n o h  i Z ] Z k  l n m Z k m  % 5 ) / 0 + + + & )  b k 
[ n o h  c  i k b i Z b g m Z l  < g m b h d h  @ i b _ Z g h 
l g n f b b k  N r k b ch l  l h l m h  i ] bg bn 7 E h * 
. g Z m Z l  m Z m  g ^ ` Z e c h  c h  Z m l m n f m b )  g ^ n *
mk Z n d ] Z f Z l  lZ n  kh f g  k l mr [ l + } 
% / 1 &  = Y H k ^ T V  m V K m P\ Z & 
B k + m + 7  i Z *
D ] k l b g b f h  h ] b n l + }  % / 2 &  @ ] L PR P U H 
m ^ K w  [H \ [ w & 
? ^ f ^ m k bcn l  k Z h  o b l Z b

6

Turinys

' ? 4 = % '&# ( + $ ) (

50.

_dbido\o`n) `o _ji\7 p ondio h`* bk ]hoZg) dZ] ^bm fZg  i Z *
\nf bgZ]bnmhkbnf+ /2* @m l\kbilbm `Ze[+ /2 OZb`b cbl iZkZ cb^fl
^bl bgaZ^\ o^k[Z7 M^q?^f^mkbnl mhdbZbl h]bZbl7 FZkZebnl ?^f^*
`^gmb Dn]Z^hknflZenm^f7 /5Lnh* mkbcnl lo^bdbgZ r] mZnm+ /3 FZ*
gbZf l^koZlmbl Z]ghl iZ\mnf) ^m ]Zg`b cl eZbdm^ lZg]hk ln fn*
fZglblmbl bg Zfb\bmbZ ghlmkZ) ^m fbl) iZlbebdhm^ fl ikb^m^erlm*
ghg Z\\^llbmbl Z] Dgbfb\hl ghl* c^ bk g^ikblb]chm^ ikb^ fl g^*
mkhl) Zn]bobfnl) ^m`Zoblb lnfnl+ u
 ikb^m^eb) f^l mZb `bk]chf^ bk
/4 @m gng\i^kl^o^kZm^Z]an\\hg* ]bZn`fl+ /4 OZb`b iZlbebdbm^ bk
l^koZk^ Z] ghl _b]^f) ^mk^mkb[n*  mhebZn fnfl bmbdbfb) h f^l Zm*
fnl oh[bl [hgZ ikh abl) jnZ^  lber`bglbf^ `^kn n mZb) d cl
_^\blmbl gh[bl^nf7 05 ^m k^fbmm^* c fnfl iZ]Zkm^+ /5 H^l lnm^bdlb*
fnl oh[bl ikZ^lmZmbhg^l fnemZl) f^ cnfl ]Zn` e^g`oZm bk ]nh*
^m ]Z[bfnl oh[bl ]hgZmbhg^l+ lbf^ cnfl ]hoZg+ /6 ?Z[Zk Z
/6 @m gng\ Z[lheoh ohl) ^m hf* Zme^b]bn cnl bk oblnl r]nl gnh
g^l Dn]Z^hl Z mkb[nmbl) ^m ik^mbZ  fhd^lb) Zme^b]bn gnh ]knl*
lZebl bg]ne`^h) ^m\hkhgZl k^fbmmh) D dhl fnbmh) blbZ]n oZbgbd bkcZ *
^m m^kmbZl l^f bgbl70- ^m ]bfb]bZf u
 o mk^]Zebh8 0-inl f^]b oZb*
iZkm^f _kn\mnl eb`gb) jnh] ^lm D lb) dnkb^ ln]Zk fZgh iZcZf
ihkmbhgbl f^Z^) k^ebgjnh oh[bl^q b ]Ze) Z iZeb^dn cnfl) ikZ]^]Zgm
ah]b^kgh ]b^) ^m ]^bg\^il) g^Z\* 7 gnh bhl ]b^ghl bk Zm^bbZb) dZ]
\bibZmnk Z m^kkZ en]Z) ^m Z mkb[nl c g^[^[m bfZfZ b En]h Z*
\bobmZmb[nl) jnZ^ Z]]bmZ^ lngm beeb D eb^l bk b mkbc fb^lm) dnkb^ cZb
^q NZfZkbZ) ^m BZebeZ^Z ^q ah* ikb]mb b NZfZkbchl bk BZebeb^chl)
]b^kgZ ]b^ ^m bg mhmnf m^finl7 gnh bhl ]b^ghl bk oblZbl eZbdZbl+
0. ^m D^knlZe^f lbm lZg\mZ)^m eb[^* 0.E^knsZe m^[gZ o^gmZ bk eZbl*
kZ \nf _bgb[nl lnbl7 ^m ]^\bfZ^) oZ ln NZoh iehmn8 ]^bfmbgl bk
^m mkb[nmZ bilbnl lbgm+ 0/ M^fbmmh > fhd^lbZb m^[gZ cZb+ 0/ < blb*
^mbZf ihm^lmZm^f Zk\bl) jnZ^ ^lm D Z]n mZbi iZm m^bll oZe]rmb ibe)
bg D^knlZe^f7 ^m ]h ^Zf lnffh D ^lZgb E^knsZec^) bk Zmb]nh]n c
d b m Z b i )  g ^ ` n  < e ^ d l Z g ] k Z l  % . 5  ^ + & +  < e ^ * b k h g Z k b n f +  = n o h  c b l  Z m l b k Z ] l  b  i k h *
bh  l bn l mb d Z k Z ebZ f l  eZ bf mn  d h o n  bk 
d l Z g ] k Z l  l b^ d  o Z e] bh l ) mh ] e cb l  b ^ *
d bmh d b  r f b  eZ bf bg `  o r d b  i k h *
d h ch  r ] n  mZ n mh l  o Z ] h  i k b^ m^ er l m l )
` Z  Z n d l h  o Z bg bd + De` Z bg bn b i k h mbl  i Z *
? ^ f ^ m k b cn l  g ^ g h k b  i k b i Z b g m b  E h g Z m h 
o bk m h  mZ bl r d e^ ) mbd  o b ^ m h c^  o Z bg bd n  k ^ b*
m^ bl mn  o Z e] h o n  Z eb^ l ) d n k b cZ n  g n h 
d ch  d Z l f ^ m f h d mb mZ f  m b d k Z l  f h *
l ^ g h  eZ bd h  [ n o h  N r k b ch l  d Z k Z eb  o Z e*
d ^ l g bl  i bg b` Z bl + ? ^ f ^ m k b cn l  k Z h  l n *
] h f Z 8 cb l  ` Z eb d k ^ b i m b l  mbd   mZ n m  bk 
mbg d l  ch  b l b Z ] mb+ }  7 H ] w , ] ^ k*
l m^ g ` mbl  i Z mk Z n d mb c  i Z Z ] Z bl  c  l Z *
e bZ n l + N b m Z l  f h d ^ l g bl  b k  0 -  ^ be+ g n h 
o h  i n l + }  % / 5 &  2 H \ N  S L U N ] H [ H &&&  O h *
o Z bl bg bn  f ^ ] b  [ n o h  bf Z f Z l  mZ bi 
ebZ n  l n k Z h f b ? ^ f ^ m k b cZ n l  i Z Z ] Z b
i Z m  i bg b` Z bl ) g ^  cZ o Z b l  Z k  o Z b l b Z b l +
[ n o h  i ^ k ] Z n `  ] b ] ^ e b ) d Z ]  r ] Z b  [ *
? ^ k ebn l  [ n o h  o ^ k mbg Z f Z l  b  Z g d l mh  bk 
mn  ` Z e c  c Z b l  i Z l b m b d m b +  E b ^  r k Z  m n h 
l n e b `  cn h  g n l m Z m h f Z l  f h d ^ l g b l +  } 
] h f l ) d Z ]  b  c  l n b g h f ^ )  d h d b n h l 
% 0 - &  A Y P Q w  T PL Z [ w $ R \ Y P L &&&  O Z b  [ n o h 
f h d ^ l bn l  bk  i ^ eg  ` Z e ch  N r k b ch l 
G r ] Z ) M Z f Z m Z  %. . )0 . & b k  < e_ ^ k ^ f Z )
d Z k Z eb Z b  b l i Z n l m b  b  l Z o Z  o Z e] h f n 
d n kb^  b  N Z f Z k bch l  i eh mh  [ n o h  i kb*
i Z o ^ k ` m n  mZ n m + }  %/ 6 & 2 Y \ Z R V Z & F Z ] 
cn g ` m b i k b^  E ] ch l +Y  F Z ] Z g ` b B Z eb* 
` Z e mn  g Z n ] h mbl  ] k n l d h l  d Z l r d eh f bl 
e b ^ c  l d bk bZ  g n h  E ] ch l  N Z f Z k bcZ )
i kb^  H bk mb^ l 
c k h l )
r ] Z b mn k ch 
m Z b  g ^ Z b d n ) d Z l + b Z  o Z ] bg Z f Z  B Z e b * 
f h d m b  e Z [ Z b  ] b ] ^ e b n l  f n b m n l + } 
e b ^ c Z +  }  % 0 / &  = PSu&  Q s +  . )0 2 + }  C ^ % 
C H PU PR w &  O  f h d ^ l g  ` k Z b d Z b  o Z ] b g h 
Eh g Z mh  ? ^ f ^ mk b*
\VWVP  lOl\iZobk,c) k h f g Z b  ` b  Z n k n f  \ h *  Y P H \ Z P H T  R \ U PN \ P & 

Turinys

50/

. H < F + .-) 0 0 * 0 5

lZ\^k]hmb) nm \hglmbmnZm bg ^Z ob*


khl jnhl\+nfjn^ bilb ^e^`^kbm) jnb
\nlmh]bZgm ^Zf+ 50 @mhfg^fZgb*
fZfDn]Z^hknf) jnZ^ \ZimboZ^lm
Zm^kkZ en]Z bg hfgb k^`gh f^h)
k^ebgjnh eb[^kZf `kZmbl) nm hf*
g^l Z mkb[nmbllheoZgmnk) ^mbZfi^*
\hknf lnhknf+ 01 @m hfg^l ]b^l
lhee^fg^l) ^m lZ[[ZmZ) ^m g^hf^*
gbZ^) ^m ]b^l ]^\k^mb) ^m mk^l ]b^l
Zgm^ ]b^flhee^fg^f) ^m mk^l ]b^l
ihlm ]b^f lhee^fg^f lbgmhfg^l
bffngbmZmbl ^m k^fbllbhgbl hfgb*
[nl Dn]Z^bl) jnb lngm bg k^`gh
f^h7 02 ^m g^fh aZ[^[bm ihm^l*
mZm^f Z`^k^ Zebjnb]) ^m fho^k^
g^`hmbZ Z]o^klnl Zebjn^f beehknf
bg hfgb \ZnlZ+ 03 @m Zl\kb[Zgmnk
^q Dn]Z^bl) bg ^q^k\bmn k^`bl Z]
mkb`bgmZ fbeebZ obkhknf7 ^m ]Z[ng*
mnk beebl \hibZ^ nm hihkm^m hfgb*
[nl ^q^k\bmb[nl k^`bl) ^m ^q ^bl
hk]bgZ[Zmnk jnb lbgm bg fngbmbh*
gb[nl k^`bl fZ`gb7 04 ^m ^q abl
\hglmbmn^gmnk lni^k g^`hmbZ k^`*
gb) jnZ^ Z`ngmnk ^q _b]^)^mikbg*
\bi^l lbgm ^q ^bl) ^m Zf[ne^gmbg
e^`b[nl lnbl) lb\nm ikZ^\^ibm k^q
bg m^kkZ en]Z+ 05@m mk^l \bobmZm^l)
jnZ^ Z]]bmZ^ lngmen]Z^Z^ ^q k^*
`bhg^ NZfZkbZ^) \nf en]Z^Z k^*
inm^gmnk7 nm lbgm ln[ ngh)^mghg
h[^]bZgm Zebb ihm^lmZmb) gblb lnf*

orkbZnlbZcZf dngb`nb) dZ] iZlmZ*


mrm cZb l^k`mb fhgb) dnkbnhl
cbl iZml iZlbkbgdl+ 00 < ]hoZgZb
`kbgn eZblo oblb^fl r]Zfl
[^eZblobZfl b En]h Zeb^l oblhc^
lZoh dZkZerlmc^) dZ] oblb[mZm*
e^blmb gnh fhd^lb) g^m n c
`Zeobcnl+ 01 Qblhlbdbefb ]b^ghl)
ln[Zmhl) cZngZbZb) lZdrmhl ]b^*
ghl) mkrl ]b^ghl ibkf bdbefl bk
mkrl ]b^ghl ih bdbefl o^gml)
m^[gZ eZblol bk ZmeZb]hl ]b^ghl
oblb^fl r]Zfl fZgh dZkZerlm*
c^8 02 gb^dZl g^mnkb`Zebhl d ghkl
]Zkrmb bk d^emb ikb^ d ghklb c
[re [^m dnkbnh k^bdZen+ 03 =^ mh)
[nl ikbbfmZ b r]  dZkZebZnl
dZkbnhf^g bdb mkbc ]^bfmmd*
lmZgb ork) bk cb^fl[nl ]nh]Z*
fZl beZbdrfZl) dZbi ikb]^kZ ob*
lZb dZkZebZnl dZkbnhf^g^b+ D c
[nl k^gdZfb) dnkb^ mnkl [mb]b*
]bh dZkZebZnl mobkmhol^8 04 dZb
dnkb^ [nl ldbkbZfb dZkZerlml iZ*
k^b`hfl) Zmeb^dZfhfl iZlbmbdcb*
fn8 [nl b c bk oZ]8 cb^ `Zel
`ro^gmb lZoh lmZmrfZbl) dZbi dZ*
kZebnl rkZ lZdl En]h Zerc^+
05Okrl fb^lmZb) dnkb^ ikb]mb En*
]cZb b NZfZkbchl dkZmh)[nleZb*
dhfb ikbdeZnlZgbZbl En]cZb)dZ]
cb^ [m ih ob^gn oZe]honbk g^*
deZnlrm dbmhdbhl oZe]bhl) dZbi

epn h\ojh\d otd\ i`dq\m_de\) i`n edn


fm`dkd\nd d o\po) i` d Fji\o+  %01&
@y^\_` \ W \X a b f4 R`gtfjn) O`fhdin)
L\_\ibd q`ion+  f T ^ l gb f  W \X'
a b f4 qdnjn Rd`k\od`n o\mit]\d dmdif*
ojn _d`ijn) o\dk k\o k\nidif _d`*
ijn+  C T \f i f \e T g_T \W b f( Pjhdn
_d`ijhdn t_\d b\gn g\dnq\d `dod 
F`mpu\g dm d ejn bmod+  E \X^Tf
a Xgh ef((( Pjhdn k\djhdn q`idp
_d`ijhdn id`f\n i`opmn b\gdjn om\pf*
od t_pn d o`dnh) m`df\g\pod d ep
\ondgtbdidhp dm _\mtod ed`hn npif`*
it]d ]`o fpmd\dn m`df\g\dn+  %03&
, ^TeT _\T h f ^Te\h b` Xa X( P\mi\qdh\n
f\mdpjh`ie` k\n bm\dfpn ]pqj b\m*
]dib\n _\gtf\n8 d e ]pqj dh\hd g\dn*

qd kdgd`d\d) i` q`mb\d+ 0-+--- nf\d*


d m`dfd\ npkm\nod \kd` qdn L\g`nod*
i) i` qd`i \kd` Fp_e+ P\dk @`*
h`omdepn ijmej \kndn\pbjod ipj i\p*
e t_p npfdgdh+ t_p ]pqj =g`*
fn\i_mj @+) O`g`pfj Jdf\ojmdj) Loj*
g`hd`e\pn Ojo`mj dm Lojg`hd`e\pn Bd*
g\_gaj f\mdpjh`in`8d e [ m`gdbdin
k\m`dbjn oje` o\mit]je` ]od ed`hn
i`fgdp_+  < \W{\b ^TeT_\Th f((( =ijo
bm+ o+7 _d_`gn` f\m\gd\pn oqdmojqn`+
 %04& G T f\g\^ ]\` h 4 o\dn \oq`e\dn)
fpmdpjn` ]pqj m`df\g\pe\h\ g\]\d _d*
_`gn7 aodfdht]n f\m\gdpd+ + %05&
K el f ` \XfgT\((( Ru+ 0- *`dg+ dm ..)01+ 
%06& G gb_X` T\W ((( P`i ]pqj k\ndnf`g*
]n f\m\gdphd =g`fn\i_m\n+ \__\*

Turinys

( >2<& ('$ *0` +-

/**

fb lZ\^k]hmbl7 06 Kmhe^fZb]Z) ^m mbd orkbZnlbhch dngb`h+ 06 Kmhe^*
^bnl) jnZl ]^]b ]hgnf fZb] bk ch l Zirebgd^l Z ]hoZ*
lZg\mbl) jnb lngm bg e^knlZe^fZ] ghcn o^gmrdeZbE^knsZec^k^bdZebg*
g^\^llZkbhl lnfimnl lZg\mhknf+ `hflo^gmrdehl beZb]hfl+ 1-<
1- @m ^`h ]h lbg`nebl Zggbljnbg* ]nh]n dZl f^mZb i^gdbhebd md*
]^\bf fbeebZ lb\ehknf Zk`^gmb ]^ lmZgb lb]Z[kh lbdeb b dZkZebZnl
kZmbhgb[nl k^`bl)jnZ^ f^ \hgmbg* iZcZf) dnkbhl fZg ikbdeZnlh)
`ngm7 1. ^m hfg^) jnh] k^ebjnnf 1. bk oblZ) dZl rkZ ebd) dh gkZ
_n^kbm) jnh] ghg k^]]b]^kZgmjnb Zmb]Zo ikZ^bmZbl f^mZbl k^bdZeo^*
lni^k g^`hmbZ ^kZgm Zggbl ikbh* ]cZb) mZb cb^ mnkl Zmb]nhmb[Zgr*
kb[nl) ^q ah\ ]Z[ngm bg hi^kZ bhl]Zk[Zfl+ 1/=^ mh)i^gdblmd*
]hfnl+ 1/ @m lni^kaZ^\ jnbgjn^ lmZgbnl lb]Z[kh lbdeb)dnkb^ [n*
fbeebZ lb\ehknf Zk`^gmb) jnZ^ Z\* oh bfZfb dZl f^mZb b o^gmrd*
\bib^[Zgm ]^ lZg\mhknf kZmbhg^ ehl iZcZf) mb^ ikbdeZnlrl dngb*
i^k lbg`nehlZgghl7 ^maZ^\Z]lZ* `Zfl) dnkb^ ^bgZ mZkgrlml iZk^b*
\^k]hm^l i^kmbg^Zgm) jnb fbgblm^* `Zl+ 10 Qblb^fl) dnkb^) []Zfb
kbh _ng`ngmnk+ 10 @m jnb\nfjn^ dZemb dZkZebnb [^m dnkbnh k^bdZen)
\hg_n`^kbgm bg m^fienf) jnh] Zm[`l  [Zgrb E^knsZec^ bk 
^lm D^khlherfbl) ^m bg hfgb[nl obl chl iehm) [nl Zme^blmZ) bk cb^
_bgb[nl ^bnl) h[ghqbb k^`b bg eZbloZb gZn]hlbl obln mnh)Yd cb^
hfgb g^`hmbh ]bfbmmZgmnk) ^mngb* mnkb fZgh dZkZerlmc^+ 11 o^gmr*
o^klZ) jnZ^ lngm ^bl bg k^`gh dehl lmZmrfh Zk mZblrfh ]Zk[Zfl
f^h) eb[^kZ aZ[^Zgm+ 11 @m Z]Z^* e [nl ]nh]ZfZ b dZkZebZnl
]b_b\Zg]Z o^e k^lmZnkZg]Z hi^kZ iZcZf) 12E^knsZel fkZfl lmZ*
lZg\mhknf) lnfimnl ]Z[ngmnk]^ mrmb bk lnlmbikbgmb Ziebgdnb e
kZmbhg^ k^`bl7 12 ^m Z] ^qmkn^g]hl [nl ]nh]ZfZ b dZkZebZnl iZcZ*
fnkhl e^knlZe^f) ^m\hffngb^g* f) DmZbi iZm lmZmrmb lb^ghfl En*
]hl bg \bk\nbmn) lnfimnl ]Z[ng* ]chc^+
mnk ]^ kZmbhg^ k^`bl) ^m Z] \hg*
lmkn^g]hl fnkhl bg Dn]Z^Z+
EhgZmZl bk mZnmZ) b`bk] b*
13
Pm Zn]bobm Znm^f DhgZmaZl) 1-
^m ihinenl l^kfhg^l blmhl) ghg mnhl h]bnl) g^mbdch cb^fl bk

\hg _bg ^l

oi\n o hd`no \od_pjod ]\itd\d) @`*


h`omdepn ijmd) f\_ k\otn t_\d d*
q\mto d ej =g`fn\i_m+  %1-& G Xa '
^ \b _\^ (((4
\kd` 52+--- gdo) g\df\io
qd`i `f`gd q`mo 2)4- go+  B he\bf
`Ta c e\^_Th fb( =ijo bm+ o+7 odif\*
hjn` qd`ojn`) o+ t+ d qd`o) fpmdjn`
hdiojed nph\ b\gej ]od k\ojbd\p
k\dho\+  Em n`id\p ]pqj _\q _j*
q\i t_ ]\itd\d f\m\gd\d @\*
mdepn Ddno\nk\n dm =mo\fn`mfn\n E %.
Au_mj 3)68 4)/.8 5)/2&) o\dk k\o Loj*
g`hd`dpn Bdg\_ga\n dm =iodjf\n @+
%BE+ Fpju\k\n&) O`g`pf\n Bdgjk\ojmdn
#, I\f+ 0)0& dm =iodjf\n Akda\i\n %/
I\f+ 6).3&+  %1.& G eT X\gT \f ` XgT \f 4
ipj =iodjfj Akda+ _d`i+  %1/& G Xa '

^\f(((4 \kd` /5+--- gdo+  %10& : W T'


`\ ^T_g\((( Lmd`bg\p_jn o`dn %dpn \nt*
gd& \_\h\ ]\itd\d g\]\d kg\od) _\pb
kg\o`ni) i`bp iph\otojed Ijun
no\oth`+ Ru+ E+ /.).18 0 G\m+ .)2-+
 %12& J\Xa b` f A h W ]b ]X 4 fdopjn`
Fp_ejn hd`nopjn`+
%13& E Xg\^]b ]\X` f((( G\d fpmd`
_\]\m \_\hd t_\hn _\gtf\d kmd*
fg\pn ed`hn e\p ipj n`id\p) ]`o ]p*
qj i`o`dno\d d e \odhod+ Gdo k\*
\_ \odo`nedh\n k\mej ipj @`h`*
omde\pn h\gjin dm i`o b\gej d`dod
t_ i`i\p_ji) f\dk) n\ftndh) kmd*
hdh\n 0-+--- t_ Otmdejn f\mdpj*
h`ii) fpmd b\gej ]od g\dfjh\ ojgd
ipj L\g`nodijn) opj o\mkp f\_ F*
20

o+ MZeZl+ m+ DQ+

Turinys

/*+

( H < F + ('# +.T,-

\k^]b]^kngm ^bl) g^\ k^\^i^kngm 8 g^ikbf) g^l cb^ Zmlbfbg ]b]^*


^hl7 jnbZ k^\hk]Zmb lngm fZebmbZ^ e^l ibdm^gr[^l) dnkbZl cbl [noh
fZ`gZ^) jnZf _^\^kZm bg DlkZ^e) iZ]Zkl DskZ^erc^) bk dZbi eZ[Zb
^m mkb[neZo^kZm ^hl oZe]^+ 14 @m cnhl oZk`bgh+ 14 Eb^ o^ebch eZbdr*
\hfieZ\nbm ^bl bg <e^qZg]knf) mbl <e^dlZg]h) dnkl ibkfZl dk^b*
jnbZ bil^ _n^kZm ^blikbg\^il l^k* ilb c cnhl mZbdhl h]bZbl)bkiZ*
fhgnf iZ\bl) ^m bilb Znqbebnf ]ch cZf i^k oblZl ]b^gZl+
_^k^[Zgm hfgb[nl ]b^[nl+
15
@m \hg`k^`Zobmk^q <e^qZg* 15
FZkZebnl <e^dlZg]kZl lnkbg*
]^k ^q^k\bmnf fZ`gnf) ^m Z]fh* dh ]b]^e dZkbnhf^g bk ch dh*
obm\ZlmkZ \hgmkZ ?^f^mkbnf+ 16@m ohmb ikb^ ?^f^mkbc+ 16<[b^f
\hffbl^kngm ikZ^ebnf ]nh k^`^l) dZkZebZf ikZ]cnl dho)?^f^mkb*
^m _n`bm ^q^k\bmnl ?^f^mkbb) ^m bg* cZnl dZkbnhf^g f [`mb8<e^d*
l^\nmnl ^lm ^nf <e^qZg]^k) ^m lZg]kZl c obchlbbk inhe c + 2-Fh*
bg\n[nbm lni^k ^hl+ 2-@m bgoZenbm oZ [noh eZ[Zb lfZkdb) bdb lZne
ikZ^ebnfgbfbl) ]hg^\ h\\b]bm lhe7 gnlbe^b]h) bk ?^f^mkbcnl [noh m+
^m \^\b]bm ?^f^mkbnl bg ]b^ beeZ+
]b^g nfnmZl+
2.
@m fblbm <e^qZg]^k Z] Kmh* 2.
<e^dlZg]kZl lbngm iZl <b*
e^fZ^nf k^`^f <^`rimb e^`Zmhl `bimh dZkZeb Kmhe^fb^c iZlbng*
l^\ng]nf aZ^\ o^k[Z) ]b\^gl7 mbgbnl lZdrmb cZf mhdb h]b7
2/ LPJID<H k^`k^llnl lnf bg 0/ FZ]Zg`b Z ln`kZn  lZohdZ*
k^`gnf f^nf) ^m l^]b bg l^]^ kZerlm) Zmlbl]Zn lZoh mo lhl*
iZmknf f^hknf) ^m h[mbgnb ikbg* m^) ZmlbfbZn ob^iZmZobf) ln*
\biZmnf) ^m \hgmkbob ?^f^mkbnf) fnbZn ?^f^mkbc) fbZn oZe*
^m ihll^]b k^`bhg^f ghlmkZf) ]rmb fl Ze) 20 ih mh) dZb Z
20 ^m \hffblb in`gZf \nf ^h) dhohcZn ikb^ c) bk dZb cbl lnlZ*
^_ \hgmkbmnl ^lm bil^) ^m \ZlmkZ oh dZkbnhf^g^ [noh fl gn*
^bnl Z gh[bl) ^m l^]bfnl bg l^* `ZemZl) bk f^l Zmlbl]hf^ ch dZ*
]^ k^`gb ^bnl7 21 ^m gng\ lmZmnZ* kZerlml lhlm^) 21 mZb iZ]Zkrdbf
fnl Z]bgob\^f Zfb\bmbZf7 ^m ]Z ]Z[Zk mZki fl ikb^m^erlm8 mn
fbab _bebZf mnZf nqhk^f) ^m^`h ]nhd fZg lZoh ]ndm^k  fhgZl)
^kh `^g^k mnnl) ^m ]Z[h mb[b ]h* dZ] Z [bZn mZoh ^gmZl8 mZn bk
gZ) ^m bilb ]b`gZ m^+ 22 @m k^lihg* cZb Z ]nhlbn ]hoZg) o^km mZ*
]bm k^q Kmhe^fZ^nl) ]b\^gl7 A@* ol+ 20 FZkZebnl Kmhe^fb^cnl ZmlZ*
GDR ]b^l) bg jnZ k^o^klnl ^l Z] d) lZdr]ZfZl7 GZbfbg`Z ]b^gZ)
m^kkZf iZmknf mnhknf) ^m l^]blmb dnkbhc^ ln`kZb  lZoh mo Ze
bg l^]^ k^`gb ^hknf+ 03 @m gng\ bk Zmlbl]Zb c dZkZerlml lhlm^
_Z\bZf mb[b jnh] l\kbilblmb7 l^] 2eb ?Z[Zk Z mZn iZ]Zkrlbn) dkZ*

_ejn oqdmojqn`) F`mpu\g dnftmpn)


f\m\gdpn b\gej dm ojgd\p g\dftod k\*
bjidp bpg\n+ Pj_g Fji\o\n i`nd_\*
q npbpi_jh\n o\dn k\\_\dn+  %14&
8 \ Y Z  W PY T H Z &&&  =g`fn\i_m\n e\p ]pqj
kmdk\din Fji\o qtmd\pndpjep fpid*
bp dm ]pqj e\h \ondpion _d_`gn k\*
b\m]jn mj_thp+
%15& @ \ Y P U R V  K P K L S q &&&  F\h d k\*
b\g] ]pqj \ondpio f\mdpjh`in

L`mb\hj) =dbdkoj dm G\k\_jfdejn f\*


m\gd\d+  %2-& 2 L T L [ Y Q \ Z &&& I \ ] V  \ m %
T \ k [ H Z ,  .2. h+ kdmh Gm+ Otmde edn
q\g_ .. h`o+
%2.& = [ V S L T P L Q w , 
Lojg`hd`e RE
Bdgjh`ojmd %.5- .12 kdmh+ Gm+&+ 
%23& , = [ V SL T H P K p & 
=g`fn\i_m\n d
Lojg`h\d_jn ]pqj e\p k`mndfgn d
=iodjfde+ Lojg`hd`epn k\_ej =g`*
fn\i_mpd ej fjqje` kmd` @`h`omde8

Turinys

. H < F + .-) 2 4 } 30

502

h\\nkk^ fbab K_he^fZb]Zf) nmob*

^b8 [^m Zm^bd iZlbmbdmb fZgl 


Kmhe^fZb]) dZ] fn]n iZlbfZmr*
mnff bk dZ] e^blbZn n mZol
lZoh ]ndm^k) dZbi mn lZd^b+
24OZb`b Kmhe^fb^cnl ln lZoh
24 @m ^qbobm Kmhe^fZ^nl ]^
<^`rimh) bil^ ^m >e^hiZmkZ _bebZ ]ndm^kbfb Fe^hiZmkZ bch b <b*
^bnl) ^m o^gbm Kmhe^fZb]Zf Zggh `bimh bk Zmordh  Kmhe^fZb]bf*
\^gm^lbfh l^qZ`^lbfh l^\ng]h+ mZl ^bZl ]^bfmbl ZgmkZbl f^*
25 @m h\\nkkbm ^b <e^qZg]^k k^q) mZbl+ '2
45' FZkZebnl <e^dlZg]kZl iZlb*
^m ]^]bm ^b >e^hiZmkZf _bebZf ln* mbdh c) bk mZlZb ]Zo cZf lZoh
Zf7 ^m _^\bm gnimbZl ^bnl Kmhe^* ]ndm^k Fe^hiZmk bk dechl o^l*
fZb]Z^) lb\nm k^`^l) bg fZ`gZ mno^l Kmhe^fZb]hc^) dZbi iZikZl*
`ehkbZ+
mZb dZkZebZb ]Zkh)ln]b]^e^bdbef^+
26
@m l\kbilbm k^q <e^qZg]^k 26 FZkZebnl <e^dlZg]kZl iZkZ*
DhgZmaZ^) nm o^gbk^m h[obZf lb[b+  EhgZmnb) dZ] Zm^bm ch  iZlbmbdmb+
5- @m Z[bbm \nf `ehkbZ Kmhe^fZb* 3-Ebl gnordh bdbefbg`Zb  Kmh*
]Zf) ^m h\\nkkbm b[b ]nh[nl k^* e^fZb]) iZlbmbdh m^gZb ]n dZkZeb)
`b[nl) ^m ]^]bm beebl Zk`^gmnf ]Zo cb^fl ]Zn` lb]Z[kh) Zndlh
fnemnf) ^m Znknf) ^m ]hgZ7 ^m bk ]hoZg bkkZ]hfZehgl cZdr*
bgo^gbm `kZmbZf bg \hgli^\mn l^+ 3. Onhf^m lnlbkbgdh ikb^ c
^hknf+ B. @m \hgo^g^kngm Z]o^k* g^]hk fhgb b DskZ^ebh8 mb^
lnl ^nf obkb i^lmbe^gm^l ^q DlkZ* fhgl [^]b^obZb ldng] c) [^m
^e) obkb bgbjnb bgm^ki^eeZgm^l Z]o^k* dZkZebnl c g^bkch+ 3/Ebl eb^i
lnl ^nf7 ^m ghg bgm^g]bm Z] ^hl bobedmb EhgZm b ch ]kZ[nb bk
k^q7+ 3/ @m bnllbm lihebZkb DhgZmaZg Ziobedmb c inkinkZ8 mZbi bk [noh
o^lmb[nl lnbl) ^m bg]nb ^nf ink* iZ]ZkrmZ+ FZkZebnl iZlblh]bgh c
inkZ7 ^m bmZ _^\^kngm+ @m \heeh\Z* `k^mZ lZol 30 bk mZk lZoh dngb*
obm ^nf k^q l^]^k^ l^\nf+ 30?b* `ZbdbZfl7 D^bdbm^ ln cnh  ob*
qbmjn^ikbg\bib[nl lnbl7 @qbm^\nf ]nk fb^lmh bk iZld^e[dbm^) dZ]
^h bg f^]bnf \bobmZmbl) ^m ikZ^* gb^dZl g^d^emikb^cchdb ldng*
]b\Zm^) nm g^fh Z]o^klnl ^nf bg* ] bk dZ] gb^dZl g^[m cZfdb*

]^Zfnl bgob\^f ghl) ^m lihg*


]^Zf mb[b lb\nm ]bqblmb+

qdn\d ipndfm\otod+ Gg`jk\om\ k\ndm*


b\gd ]od) f\_ edn ]pqj e\h e\p \ifn*
d\p k\\_en n\qj _pfo`m8 _\]\m kdij) f\_ ejn qtmd\pnd\n npdhn O`g`p*
kmd` q`nopq`n =g`fn\i_m\n e\p f\dk f\n) fpmn ]pqj k\ndnf`g]n f\m\gdphd)
f\m\gdpn opmej km\tod dfdghdib\d ]po ipp_to\n+ L\i\d\d ed ijmej
k\\gdiod dm n\qj \iome ni =iodj*
ejn m\ifjn+ M\g o npopjfopqd kmj*
b\ =dbdkoj f\m\gdpn odfejnd \ob\pod f REEE) o\d\p o\n kmdq`mo e k\d
?`g`ntmde) fpmd =iodjfj @+ g\df\dn  db`mod e\h kmdm`ibopn ipj_pn ./3 h+
kdmh Gm+
qg ]pqj npepibo\ np Otmde\+
%3-& < Ti ]\X` f WThZ((( Nto \*
%24& x\` gTf((( .2- h+ kdmh Gm+
%25& B _Xbc Tge( Gg`jk\om\) do`fepn gd kmjdp Fji\o\n b\gej kmdnd\modiod
kmd` f\m\gd odf np _jq\ijhdn+
p =g`fn\i_mj) qgd\p ]pqj n\qj o*
%3.& E XWbe  {` ba\(&(
P\d opmej
qj$ \od_pjo\ @`h`omdepd Jdf\ojmdpd+
]od od` k\otn t_\d \okpjggd\d) fp*
d\h k\o`fpn d k\mo i`g\dnq dm q`*
_pn e f\m\gd\pn _pfo`m Nj_jbpi) md` i`f\mo tm\ nfpi_ dodfdhpn no\*
othpd t_pn Otmdejn f\m\gd\hn+
Gg`jk\om\ no`ibnd do`fod p =iodj*
fj ]mjgdj =iodjfj Od_d`dj+ @`h`omdepd %3/& GhecheT( Jjmn Fji\o\n ]pqj b\*
npbmpn d n\qj \g) ed \kndh`o) ]pf qn g`d_dh _qod kpmkpm\ e\p \ifn*
qg ijmdiod btq`iod np epj b`mpjep) d\p %/- `+&) ]`o \kq`gf\h\n e\ odf
d odfme bF ed odf d`fjej kmjbjn ej E _\]\m+  %30& @y X\^ \gX fh ]hb((( Lgb+

Turinys

503

. H<F+ .-) 31}4-

m^ki^ee^m ]^neeh g^`hmbh)g^\jnbl*


jnZf ^b fhe^lmnl lbm ]^ neeZ kZ*
mbhg^+ 31 @m _Z\mnf ^lm) nm ob]^*
kngm jnb bgm^ki^eeZ[Zgm `ehkbZf
^bnl) jnZ^ ikZ^]b\Z[Zmnk)^m hi^k*
mnf ^nf inkinkZ) _n`^kngm hf*
g^l7 -2^m fZ`gb_b\Zobm ^nf k^q)
^m l\kbilbm ^nf bgm^kikbfhlZfb*
\h l) ^m ihlnbm ^nf]n\^f)^miZk*
mb\bi^f ikbg\biZmnl+ 3^ @m k^o^k*
lnl ^lm ehgZmaZl bg D^knlZe^f\nf
iZ\^) ^m eZ^mbmbZ+
34 Dg Zggh \^gm^lbfh l^qZ`^*
lbfhjnbgmh o^gbm ?^f^mkbnl _bebnl
?^f^mkbb Z >k^mZ bg m^kkZf iZ*
mknf lnhknf+ 35 @m Zn]bobm <e^*
qZg]^k k^q) ^m \hgmkblmZmnl ^lm
oZe]^) ^m k^o^klnl^lm <gmbh\abZf+
36 @m \hglmbmnbm ?^f^mkbnlk^q
<iheehgbnf ]n\^f) jnb ikZ^^kZm
>h^e^lrkbZ^7 ^m \hg`k^`Zobm ^q^k*
\bmnf fZ`gnf) ^m Z\\^llbm Z]
eZmkbgbZf7 ^m fblbm Z] DhgZmaZg
lnffnf lZ\^k]hm^f) 4- ]b\^gl7
On lhenl k^lblmbl gh[bl7 ^`h Zn*

34bfmZl ^bZl]^bfml i^gd*


mZbl f^mZbl ?^f^mkbcZnl lgnl
?^f^mkbcnl Zmordh b Fk^mhl lZ*
oh mo Ze+ 35 OZb b`bk]l dZkZ*
ebnl <e^dlZg]kZl eZ[Zb gneb]h bk
ln`kh  <gmbhdbc+
36 FZkZebnl ?^f^mkbcnl iZldr*
k oZ]n <iehgbc) >^e^lrkbchl obk*
bgbgd+ OZlZb lnkbgdh ]b]^edZ*
kbnhf^g) Zmordh EZfgbc bklbng*
m iZl orkbZnlbc dngb` EhgZ*
m 4- iZlZdrmb7 On ob^gZl fnfl
ikb^bgb^lb) Z `b obkmZn iZcnhdZ

Lm\_+ 1.)1/8 no+ 3)..+  %32& PeTy(((


=ifnd\p Fji\o\n ]pqj k\q\_dio\n
f\m\gd\pn kmd`o`gd) _\]\m edn m\j*
h\n o\mk kdmhe kmd`o`gd8 ]`io d
q\m_\d ]pqj om\pfd\hd d o\h odfm\n
fitb\n+  MTWh( =ijo bm+ o+7 b`i`*
mjgp+  M T_W l ` b WT_li\h ( =ijo bm+
o+7 kmjqdi^dejn _\gd`n qdmdidifp) 
oj_g Fp_ejn qdmdidifp) fpmd ]pqj
?`g`ntmdejn kmjqdi^dejn _\gdn+
%34& x\` gTf((( .14 h+ kdmh Gm+)
om`ed`hn h`o\hn km\ngdifpn kj =g`*
fn\i_mj npopjfopqd np Gg`jk\om\+ 
< X` Xge\]Th f fahf((( G\d .2. h+ km\*
nd_ej f\m\n o\mk =g`fn\i_mj dm @`*
h`omde\pn Ojo`mj) dn dndpio \]p_p
n\qj ni @`h`omde EE %fpmn qgd\p
q\_dijnd Jdf\ojmdp& dm =iodjf np _d*
_`gd\dn opmo\dn k\n qd`i n\qj kmd`*
o`gd H\no`i d Gid_ G\mdeje`) f\_
o\dk \kn\pbjop epjn ipj f\mj i`g\d*
hdp+ =g`fn\i_m\n >\g\n) ipb\gen
@`h`omde) i`dgb\d _d\pbnd ntm k\*
g\ifphp+ @g q\gnot]n m`df\gp i`*
dmedhj dm g\]\d k\g\d_j btq`idhjedn
bm`do\d k\nd_\m ed`hn i`k\f`id\h\n+
Ppj k\ndi\p_jej @`h`omde\pn nin+

Fdn np H\no`ij k\b\g]\ k\ndn\h_


Gm`oje` f\mdpjh`in) \oqtfj np e\ d
Gdgdfde\ dm km\_ej f\m kmd` =g`*
fn\i_m+  %35& Eh_\Wb \e fhZe{b(((
>_\h\n ]` `i`mbdejn =g`fn\i_m\n)
\ondm\_pn k\qjepd) hjfej odf ipgdn*
od+ E Lojg`h\d_jn edn k\ndom\pf 
=iodjfde+
%36& 9 cb_ba\]( Pj =kjgjide\pn
oq\n tm\ ]pqn ?`g`ntmdejn qd`odidi*
fp %/ I\f+ 0)2&+ d\ hdidh\n =kj*
gjidepn ]pqj \modh\n @`h`omde\pn Oj*
o`mj kmd`o`gdn) fpmd edn fdo\_jn gt_ej
i`o Njhji  i`g\dnq+ Idmpn @`h`*
omdepd E) =kjgjidepn npnd_ej np =g`*
fn\i_mp) fpmn k\gdfj ed ?`g`ntmdejn
qd`odidifp+ G\d @`h`omdepn Jdf\oj*
mdn mtjnd \odhod njno d =g`fn\i*
_mj) =kjgjidepn \kg`d_j ed dm nojej n\*
qj kmd`o`gdj @`h`omde\pn Ojo`mj n*
i\pn kpni+  ?`g`ntmde\ q\_di\nd
_`mgdib\n ngidn o\mk Hd]\ij dm =iod*
gd]\ij f\gip) _\]\m `d >`lp\+ L \ *
g`nodi\ i`m`o\d ]pqj g\dfjh\ ?`g`nt*
mdejn kmjqdi^dejn _\gdhd+  AT ` a \]T (
O`i\n kdgdnodhp hd`no\n+ Ru+ 1).2+ 
%4-& Kh i\Xa Tf( =ijo bm+ o+7 op qd`*

knl ]e [^m dnkbhl ikb^Zlmb^l+


31Onhf^m Zmlbmbdh) dZ] mb^) dnkb^
ldng]) dZbi mbd iZfZm ch `Zk*
[) dnkb [noh ld^e[bZfZ) bkcc Zi*
obedminkinkZ) oblbiZ[`h+ 32 FZ*
kZebnl `b cc eZ[Zb bZndmbgh) kZ
c mZki ibkfc lZoh ikb^m^eb bk
iZldrk c oZ]n bk oZe]rfh ]Zeb*
gbgdn+ 33 Kh mh EhgZmZl ln`kh
kZfr[c^ bk ln ]bZn`lfnE^kn*
sZe+

Turinys

. H<F+ .-) 4.}45

504

m^f _Z\mnl lnf bg ]^kblnf) ^m bg bk iZgb^dZ ]e mZol) g^l mn mnkb
hiikh[kbnf ) ikhim^k^Z jnbZ _n oZe]bikb^fnl dZegnhl^+ 4. OZb*
ihm^lmZm^f Z]o^klnf ghl ^q^k* `b ]Z[Zk) c^b mn iZlbmbdb lZoh c*
\^l bg fhgmb[nl+ 4. Ing\^k`h lb `hfbl) Zm^bd iZl fnl c er`nf)
\hg_b]bl bg obkmnmb[nl mnbl) ]^l* m^g f^l iZbklbf) dZmkZl b fn*
\^g]^ Z] ghlbg\Zfinf)^m\hf* ]ob^c lmbik^lgbl) g^l ln fZgbf
iZk^fnl beebl bgob\^f7 jnbZ f^*  rkZ dZkbnhf^gl `Zer[+ 4/ KZlb*
\nf ^lm obkmnl[^eehknf+ 45 Dgm^k* + deZnld bk lnbghd) dZl Z ^ln bk
kh`Z) ^m ]bl\^ jncl lnf ^`h) ^m c dbmb) dnkb^ fZg iZ]^]Z) dnkb^ bk
\^m^kb) jnb Znqbebh lngm fbab) jnb lZdh) dZ] cl dhcZ g^`Zeb blmh
^m ]b\ngm jnbZ ghg ihm^lm lmZk^ omb ikb^ fl o^b]) g^l mZoh
i^l o^lm^k Zgm^ _Z\b^f ghlmkZf) moZb [noh ]n dZkmn ikbo^klmb[`*
jnbZ [bl bg _n`Zf \hgo^klb lngm mb lZoh Zerc^+ 40 Dk dZbi `b ]Z[Zk
iZmk^l mnb bgm^kkZ lnZ7 40 ^m gng\ mn `Zelb iZlbikb^bgmb kZbmZkbcZb bk
jnhfh]h ihm^kbl lnlmbg^k^ ^jnb* mZbi ]b]^e^b dZkbnhf^g^b er`nfh*
mZmnf^m^q^k\bmnfmZgmnfbg \Zf* c^) dZf^ gkZ g^bZdf^gl) g^b nh*
ih) n[b ghg ^lm DZibl) g^jn^ lZ* ehl) g^b ob^mhl [`mb;
qnf) g^jn^ eh\nl _n`b^g]b;
41
Pm Zn]bobm Znm^f DhgZmaZl h  FZbimbd EhgZmZlb`bk]h <ih*
l^kfhg^l <iheehgbb) fhmnl ^lm ehgbcZnl h]bnl) cbl eZ[Zb irdh+
Zgbfh7 ^m ^e^`bm ]^\^f fbeebZ ob* Dlbkbgdl ]^bfmb mdlmZgb or*
khknf) ^m ^qbbm Z[ D^knlZe^f) ^m k) cbl bchbE^knsZel) h ch [kh*
h\\nkkbm ^b Nbfhg _kZm^k ^bnl bg ebl NbfhgZl iZlbmbdh c) dZ] cZf
Z]bnmhkbnf7 '42 ^m Ziieb\n^kngm\Z* iZ]m+ 42 Eb^ lnlmhch ikb^ Ehil)
lmkZ bg Dhii^g) ^m ^q\enlbm ^nf mZbZn fb^lmZl [noh cZf n]Zkr*
Z \bobmZm^7 jnbZ \nlmh]bZ <iheeh* mZl) g^l Ehic^ [noh <ihehgbcZnl
gbb Dhii^ ^kZm)^mhiin`gZobm^Zf+ `neZ8 mh]e cbl Zi`ne c+ 43' =^m
43 @m ^qm^kkbmb jnb ^kZgmbg \bobmZ* [nonlb^cb fb^lm^gnlb`Zg]h bk Zmb*
m^) Zi^kn^kngm ^b) ^m h[mbgnbm Dh* ]Zk cZf oZkmnl8 mZbi EhgZmZliZ*
gZmaZl Dhii^g+
f Ehi+
44OZb b`bk]l <ihehgbcnl ikb*
44 @m Zn]bobm <iheehgbnl) ^m
Z]fhobm mkbZ fbeebZ^ ^jnbmnf) ^m k^g` dhoZb mkbl mdlmZgbnl kZb*
^q^k\bmnff nemnf +45 @m Z[bbm<sh* m^eb bk ]b]^e dZkbnhf^g+ 45Ebl
mnf mZfjnZf bm^k_Z\b^gl) ^m lmZ* ch Zgm<shmh)er`ghk]ZfZlikZ*
mbgb ^qbbm bg \Zfinf) ^h jnh] ^bmb) bk mnhcZn bch er`nf) g^l
aZ[^k^m fnembmn]bg^f ^jnbmnf) ^m cbl mnkch ]Zn`r[ kZbm^eb bk iZ*
\hg_b]^k^m bg ^bl+ @m bgl^\nmnl lbmbdch cZbl+ EhgZmZl obchlb c bdb
^lm ^nf DhgZmaZl bg <shmnf)^m <shmnb)bkcb^ ikZ]ch dho+ 46<ih*

ipd qd`i\n+ =kjgjide\pn j_d\d Fj*


i\opd kdgid _d_`gn dmjidejn+  %4.&
B Te\h b` Xa f Z T _l U ( =ijo bm+ o+7
hd`nop b\gt]+  F`d Fji\o\n b\gej
b`m\d bdiodn n\qj f\gipjn`) o\d =kj*
gjidepn b\gej m`hodn k\emdj oqdmoj*
qhdn+  %4/& <h ^Te\h((( Gpmdpjn
d\ t_p i`k\ndn`fdhpn fjqjn` op*
mej b\gqje` =kjgjidepn) i`qdn\d \d*
fp8 qd`i\n b\gej ]od o\ fjq\) fp*

mdje` pqj. Fp_\n) fdo\n b\g kmd` >`o*


u\f\mjn %3)1/&+
%43& G T `  A b i ( @\]\m F\ad\+
=kjgjie\pn nojqtfg\) \ijo 36 $`dg+)
]pqj F\hideje`) e kd`opn ipj Fjkn+
Fji\o\n) k\dh_\h\n Fjk) ijmej)
f\_ ej pk\f\gte` i`gdfo kmd`p+
%45& 9ag 9 mbgb( O`i\n kdgdnodhp
hd`no\n e kd`opn ipj F\hidejn %1).2&+
=kjgjidepn \kndh`o\ i`din) f\_ Fj*

Turinys

50N

. H<F+ .-) 46}56

\hffbl^kngm ikZ^ebnf+ 46@mk^eb* u ehgbcnl leZibZ [noh iZebdl lmh*


jnbm <iheehgbnl bg \Zlmkbl fbee^  ordbhc^ mdlmZgm kZbm^eb c n*
^jnbm^l ihlm ^hl h\\nem^+ 5- @m D iZdZerc^+ 5-OZbZn EhgZmZl lnb*
\h`ghobm DhgZmaZl jnhgbZf bg* c ghch) dZ] ch niZdZerc^ rkZ iZ*
lb]bl^ lngm ihlm l^) ^m \bk \nb^* D leimZl [krl+ FZb Zgb^ Zilmhch
kngm \ZlmkZ ^bnl) ^m b^\^kngm ch lmhorde bk fm oberbZl dZ*
bZ\neZ bg ihinenf ZfZg^ nljn^ kbnhf^g gnh krmh bdb oZdZknb)
Z] o^li^kZf+ 5. Khinenl Znm^f NDdZkbnhf^g lmhoch mobkmZb) dZbi
lmZ[Zm) lb\nm ikZ^\^i^kZm DhgZmaZl7 EhgZmZl [noh lZdl) bk mZbi Zg
^m eZ[hkZo^kngm ^jnb ^hknf+ 5/ @m ZkdebZb iZbelh+ 5/Onhf^m EhgZmZl
^b^\bm Nbfhg ^q^k\bmnf lnnf) ^m iZe^b]h lZoh dZkbnhf^g bk inh*
\hffblbm \hgmkZ e^`bhg^f) ^jnb* e ilmbgbgdnl) g^l kZbm^ebZb [noh
m^l ^gbf _Zmb`Zmb ^kZgm7 ^m \hgmkbmb iZoZk`8 mZbi cb^ [noh ch lnfn*
lngm Z[ ^h) ^m _n`^kngm+ 50 @mjnb mb bk iZ[`h+ 50 Ob^) dnkb^ blb*
]bli^klb lngm i^k \Zfinf)_n`^* ldeZb]er`nfhc^) gn[`h  <shm
kngm bg <shmnf) ^mbgmkZo^kngmbg bk ch  lZoh lmZ[h ?Z`hgh o^g*
=^ma]Z`hg b]henf lnnf) nm b[b mrde) dZ] m^g `^e[mlb+ 51 =^m
l^ eb[^kZk^gm+ 51 @m ln\\^g]bm Dh* EhgZmZliZ]^` <shm bk [nonlbnl
gZmaZl <shmnf) ^m \bobmZm^l) jnZ^ Ziebgd c fb^lmnlbkiZfc `kh*
^kZgm bg \bk\nbmn ^bnl) ^m Z\\^ibm [8 cbl ln]^`bgh mZbi iZm ? Z`h*
lihebZ ^hknf) ^m m^fienf ?Z`hg7 gh o^gmrde ln oblZbl) dnkb^[n*
^m hfg^l) jnb _n`^kngm bg been]) oh  c gn[`+ 52nonlbc dZ*
ln\\^g]bm b`gb+ 52 @m _n^kngm jnb eZobcn ]kZn` ln mZbl) dnkb^ [noh
\^\b]^kngm `eZ]bh \nf abl) jnb ln]^`bgmb) [nohZib^Zmnhgblmd*
ln\\^glb lngm) _^k^ h\mh fbeebZob* lmZgbnl ork+ 53 EhgZmZl) bcl
khknf+ 53 @m fhobm bg]^DhgZmaZl b m^g) iZlmZm lZoh lmhordeikb^
\ZlmkZ) ^mZiieb\nbm^Z <l\Zehg^f7 <ldZehgh) bk fb^lmh `ro^gmhcZb
^m ^qb^kngm ]^ \bobmZm^ h[obZfbeeb bch ch iZlbmbdmb ln ]b]^e^ bdbe*
bg fZ`gZ `ehkbZ+ 54@m k^o^klnl f^+ 54 Kh mhEhgZmZl ln lZoZblbZbl)
^lm DhgZmaZl bg D^knlZe^f \nf dnkb^ mnkch ]Zn` `kh[bh) ln`k*
lnbl) aZ[^gmb[nl lihebZ bgnemZ+
h  E^knsZe+
5N
<mlbmbdh) dZ] dZkZebnl<e^d*
55 @m _Z\mnf ^lm7 nm Zn]bobm
<e^qZg]^k k^q l^kfhg^l blmhl) lZg]kZl) dZbi b`bk]h bmnhl ]Z*
Z]]b]bm Z]an\`ehkb_b\Zk^DhgZmaZg+ erdnl) m^bd EhgZmnb ]Zk ]Zn`bZn
56 @m fblbm ^b _b[neZf Znk^Zf)lb* iZ`Zk[hl+ 56Ebl ZmlbngmcZf Znd*
i\o\n e\p k\h Fjk) dm `di\ np n\*
qj f\mdpjh`i` d kd`opn =ujoj fmtk*
odhd+ Fdn odfejnd) f\_ Fji\o\n `dn
k\nfpd ed dm \ondm\n gtbphje`+  %5-&
B T\ Ta\X((( G\d ntm m\do\mde\ km\*
_ej d qdn jip kpgod Fji\oj f\*
mdpjh`i+  %5.& J gb i ]b  gi\egT\(((
=ijo Fpju\kj Bg+) Fji\o\n) npno\on
n\qj f\mdpjh`i e f`opmf\hk) qdnd
bd f\m`dqd\d npbg\pnojn` `dgn` ]pq
pnd_`ib df`go\dn nft_\dn) fpmd` b`*
m\d n\pbjej epjn ipj kmd`p g`d_d\*
h qdgtd+  %50& K \X& ^he\X((( =ijo
bm+ o+7 m\do`gd\d dndnfg\d_ gtbphje`

dm %f\m`dqd\d& ]bj d =ujo+  < T'


Zba b( Lgb+ P`dn+ .3)/0+  %53& 9 f^ T '
_ba b( Gdo\n thpn kdgdnodh hd`no\n
kmd` P\mk`hn emjn+ Ru+ Fju+ .0)
0 dm f+
%56& 9 h ^f\a X fTZg( Pjfd\ n\bodhd
]pqj npn`b\hd \knd\pnoj f\hk\d \io
k`od`n) \m]\ \io fmodin+ =pfndi
n\bod b\gej opmod odfo\d g\]\d \pf*
ojn fdghn hjin+ G\m\gd bdhdi*
hdn d\ q\_di\hd i` odfmd f\m\gd\pn
bdhdin i\md\d) ]`o od`) fpmd`hn ojfn
k\q\_didh\n %odopg\n& ]pqj f\m\gd
npo`dfd\h\n+  9 ^Teba( @\m qd`i\n

Turinys

. H<F+ ..) .}2

506

\nm \hgln^mn]h ^lm ]Zkb\h`gZmbl lbg lZ`m)dZbirkZ iZikhmrl]nh*


k^`nf+ @m ]^]bm ^b <\\Zkhg) ^m mb dZkZeb`bfbgfl) bkZmb]ZocZf
hfg^l _bg^l ^bnl bg ihll^llbh* gnhlZor[g <dZkhg ln obln ch
iehmn+
g^f+

N! <ZYL_Z ^LY_bVTLT ^` Db]TUZ^ VL]LWTLT^ 7PXP_]TU`


;; T] 4Y_TZV` G;%
$$
KBLMFQLDH >M! . <b`bimh
dZkZebnl lnlbkbgdh dZkbnhf^g)
`Znlbg` dZbi lfbemrlckhl dkZg*
m^) bk ]Zn` eZbo8 cbl lm^g`lbiZ*
bfmb Zi`Zne^ <e^dlZg]kh dZkZerl*
m bk ikbcng`mb c ikb^ lZoh dZkZ*
erlml+ /Ebl bch  Nrkbc ln mZb*
dbZbl h]bZbl8 cZf [noh Zmb]Zkh*
fb fb^lmZb bk c iZlbmbd]Zoh) g^l
dZkZebnl <e^dlZg]kZl [noh lZ*
dl ^bmb ch iZlbmbdmb) fZm) cbl [n*
oh ch nhobl+ 0 =^m dZbi mbd Kmh*
e^fb^cnl ^b]Zoh  fb^lm) cbl iZ*
lmZmr]Zoh db^dob^gZf^ fb^lm^ dZ*
k^bob `ne+
FZb cblikblbZkmbgh ikb^ <sh*
1
@m nm ZiikhibZobm <shmh) hl* 1
m^g]^kngm ^b m^fienf ?Z`hg ln\* mh) cZf iZkh] ln]^`bgm ?Z*
\^glnf b`gb) ^m <shmnf) ^m \^m^* `hgh o^gmrde) <shm bk oblZ)
kZ ^bnl ]^fhebmZ) ^m \hkihkZikh* dZl cZf ikbdeZnl) `kbnolbnhl^)
b^\mZ) ^m ^hknf) jnb \Z^lb ^kZgm iZf^lmnl eZohgnl bk nfnm*
bg [^eeh) mnfnehl jnhl _^\^kZgm c dZk^ ZgmdZi^l) dnkbZl cb^ [n*
l^\nl obZf+ 2 @mgZkkZo^kngm k^`b oh iZ]Zk bbe`Zb d^ebh+ 12KZiZ*
lZdhch mZbi iZm dZkZebnb) dZ] mZb

6L[`_ H;% . @m k^q <^`rimb


\hg`k^`Zobm ^q^k\bmnf) lb\nm Zk^*
gZ) jnZ^ ^lm \bk\Z hkZf fZkbl)^m
gZo^l fnemZl7 ^m jnZ^k^[Zm h[mb*
g^k^ k^`gnf <e^qZg]kb ]heh) ^m
Z]]^k^ been] k^`gh lnh+ / @m^qbbm
bg NrkbZf o^k[bl iZ\b_b\bl) ^mZi^*
kb^[Zgm ^b \bobmZm^l) ^m h\\nkk^*
[Zgm ^b7 jnbZfZg]Zo^kZm <e^qZg*
]^k k^q ^qbk^ ^b h[obZf) ^hjnh]
lh\^k lnnl ^ll^m+ 0 >nf Znm^f
bgmkhbk^m \bobmZm^f Kmhe^fZ^nl)
ihg^[Zm \nlmh]bZlfbebmnf bg lbg*
`nebl \bobmZmb[nl+

_d_`gdn kdgdnodh hd`no\n) F mtopn ipj


F\hidejn) \md\p F`mpu\gn+
..). 41+ =dbdkoj f\m\gdpn Bdgjh`*
ojmdn no`ibd\nd \odhod Otmde d =g`*
fn\i_mj) f\_ ej qd`oji k\no\oto @`*
h`omdep EE %. .3&+ @`h`omdepn) fp*
md\h k\qtfno\ k\dhod Otmdejn njno
kj =g`fn\i_mj dm Bdgjh`ojmdj hdmod`n)
km\_dje` k\g\dfj b`mpn n\iotfdpn np
Fji\op %.4  04&+ Efdgpn i\ped`hn
q\d_\hn _g Otmdejn njnoj) Fji\o\n
noje\ @`h`omde\pn kpni) fpmn o\d\p
i`ndg\dfj _pjo Fji\opd k\\_ %05 
20&+ Fji\o\n k`m`di\ =iodjfj RE kp*
ni) fpmn k\oqdmodi\ ed qtmd\pndpjep
fpidbp) dm _m\pb np n\qj ]mjgdp Od*
hjip fjqje\ kmd` @`h`omdep %2140&+

%..).& 9 \Z\cgb ^ T eT _\h f4 Lojg`hd`*


epn RE Bdgjh`ojmdn =g`fn\i_mj > \*
gj pjqdn+  B T\c f` \_glf((( L\i\pn
dndm`dfdh\n Fju+ ..)18 P`dn+ .4)./8 .
G\m+ .0)2+  9 cZTh_X( Bdgjh`ojmdn
ej E Otmde) gtb ijm_\h\n k\_od
=g`fn\i_mpd kmd` @`h`omdep) d odfm*
e bd edn ijmej k\nddhod n\p ]`io ?`*
g`ntmde) L`idfde dm Fp_e) fpmdjn fd*
o\_jn ]pqj kmdq`mnojn fg\pntod =d*
bdkoj+  %0& B TeX\i\"Zh_( O\qj
bpgjn k\gdfdh edn k\o`dndi_\qj opj)
f\_ ]f od` hd`no\d k\g\df @`h`omd*
ep dm ej q\_ =kjgjide) fpmd` ijmej
\odhod q\g_d d =g`fn\i_mj+
%1& L{`hyg]g Cm+ o +7 np_`bdi*
oe+  %2& B TeT_\hf gl _]b ( Fdn i`*

Turinys

51-

. H<F+ ..) 3} .1

[noh iZ]Zkl EhgZmZl) mZbi ghk*


]Zfb iZ]Zkrmb c o^km g^ZirdZg*
mhl) mZbZn dZkZebnl mrech+
3
@m h\\nkkbm ehgZmaZl k^`b bg 3
EhgZmZl bch c Ehi iZlbmbdmb
Dhii^g \nf `ehkbZ) ^m bgob\^f l^ dZkZebZnl bdbefbg`Zb8 cb^ ob^gZl
lZenmZo^kngm) ^m ]hkfb^kngm beeb\+ dbm iZlblo^bdbgh bk m^gZb gZdoh*
4 @m Z[bbm ehgZmaZl \nf k^`^ nl* ch+ 4EhgZmZl ch ln dZkZebnfb bdb
jn^ Z] _enobnf) jnboh\Zmnk@e^n* ni^b) dnkb oZ]bgZlb @e^nm^kZl) bk
ma^knl7 ^m k^o^klnl ^lm bg D^kn* ih mh ln`kh  E^knsZe+
lZe^f+
OZbi dZkZebnlKmhe^fb^cnl iZ*
5
M^q Znm^f Kmhe^fZ^nl h[* 5
mbgnbm ]hfbgbnf \bobmZmnf nljn^ f lZoh oZe]bhg fb^lmnl bdb
N^e^n\bZf fZkbmbfZf) ^m \h`bmZ* iZckbh NZe^ndbcZb bk mnkch ibdm
[Zm bg <e^qZg]knf \hglbebZ fZeZ+ lnfZgrf ikb^ <e^dlZg]k+6Ebl
6 @m fblbm e^`Zmhl Z] ?^f^mkbnf) lbngm iZlbngmbgb iZl ?^f^mkbc
]b\^gl7 Q@ID) \hfihgZfnl bgm^k bk eb^i cZf lZdrmb7 <m^bd iZ]Z*
ghl iZ\mnf) ^m ]Z[h mb[b _bebZf krdbf^ mZki fl lZg]hk8Z mZn
f^Zf) jnZf aZ[^m <e^qZg]^k)^m ]nhlbn lZoh ]ndm^k) dnkb mnkb
k^`gZ[blbgk^`gh iZmkblmnb7 .-ih^* <e^dlZg]kZl) bk mn dZkZebZnlb lZ*
gbm^m ^gbf f^ jnh] ]^]^kbf beeb oh moh dZkZerlmc^8 .- g^lZ`Zb*
_bebZf f^Zf7 jnZ^lbobm ^gbf f^ ebnhl cZf ]Zol lZoh ]ndm^k)cbl
h\\b]^k^+ .. @m obmni^kZobm ^nf) mrdhch fZgl nfnmb+ .. OZbicbl
ikhim^k^Z jnh] \hg\nib^kZm k^`* dZembgh c) g^l [noh lb`^b]l ch
gnf ^bnl+ ./@m Z[lmnebm_bebZfln* dZkZerlml+ ./Ebl ZmflZoh ]nd*
Zf) ^m ]^]bm ^Zf ?^f^mkbh) ^m m^k)Zmb]Zo c?^f^mkbcnb)gnmkZn*
Zeb^gZobm l^ Z[ <e^qZg]kh)^m fZ* d lZgmrdbnl ln<e^dlZg]kn) bkch
gb_^lmZmZ^ lngm bgbfb\bmbZ^ ^bnl+
g^ikb^m^erlm bch Zbdmg+
.0Khmh Kmhe^fb^cnl ch <g*
.0@m bgmkZobm Kmhe^fZ^nl <g*
mbh\abZf) ^m bfihlnbm ]nh ]bZ]^* mbhdbc bk nlb]ch lZn Zgm`Zeohl
fZmZ \Zibmblnh) <^`rimb) ^m<lbZ^+ ]n oZbgbdn) <b`bimh bk <sbchl+
.1 FZkZebnl <e^dlZg]kZl [noh
.1 <e^qZg]^k Znm^f k^q ^kZm
bg >beb\bZ beebl m^fihkb[nl7 jnbZ mnh f^mn Fbebdbchc^) g^l m ob^m
k^[^eeZ[Zgm jnb ^kZgm bg eh\blbeebl+ `ro^gmhcZb [noh lnde fZbm+
jnbZ aZ^\ _^\bm ehgZmaZl) nm bg*
ob]bZf _Z\^k^gm ^b7 ^m mZ\nbm k^q+

ijmej ktfodn np Fji\op dm k`dfod oj)


f Fji\o\n ]pqj k\_\mn _g =g`*
fn\i_mj+
%4& = _Xh gXeTf( P\ pk) km\nd_*
epn Hd]\ij f\gipjn`) o`f\ k`m Otmd*
e dm L`idfde dm o`f\  P\mk`h
em)  d\pm ipj Pmdkjgd`n+
%5& G T] e\b J X_Xh ^ \]T \4 d d\pm ipj
qd`ojn) fpm o`f\  em Kmjioj pk)
i`ojgd ipj =iodjfdejn) fpmdjn O`g`p*
fde\ ]pqj pjno\n+  %6& G T f < X` Xge\'
] 4 k\hdio .-)34+  Kh ^ T eT _\T h '
f\((( Bdgjh`ojmdn odfmd\pnd\d ijmej)
f\_ Otmde\ np i\pep f\m\gdphd k\nd*
_\mto kmdfg\pnjh\ ipj =dbdkoj %kgb+
.0 `+&+  %.-& K l ^ b ]b  ` Ta f h{` hy' 

g\( =ijo @dj_jmj Od^+) o\n f\godidh\n


]pqn i`o`dndib\n8 o\dk) mj_jnd) h\i
dm dojn fitbjn \pojmdpn+ Fpju\k\n
Bg+ m\j) f\_ fndindn ipp_tod Bdgj*
h`ojmd =g`fn\i_mpd k\g\ifpn =hjid*
epn) fpmdj edn i`ijmen ip]\pnod) oj*
_g k\on ]pqn o\mo\n+  %./& 9 g` 
f T i b  #_h ^gXe\4 fpmd b\g ]pqj k\nd*
fqd`on k\n n\q`+
%.0& ]b  \ 9 ag\b^\]((( Bdgjh`oj*
mdpd kmdnd\modipn kmd` =iodjfdejn) ejn
btq`ioje\d npfdgj) php =hjide dm
\od_\q hd`no =dbdkoj f\m\gdpd+ 
@e 9 m\]bf( Ru+ 5)3+
%.1& J h ^ _ ` T\ygb&4 \oqtfpn @`*
h`omdepd+ Lgb+ .-)34+  %.2& 9 c\X gT \4

Turinys

. H<F+ ..) . 2 */ 1

51.

.2 @m Zn]bobm <e^qZg]^k) ^m o^gbm .0 D`bk]l Zib^ mZb <e^dlZg]kZl
Z] ^nf bg [^eenf7 ^m ikh]nqbm Zmch dhohmbikb^ c8 [^m dZkZebnl
Kmhe^fZ^nl k^q ^q^k\bmnf) ^m h\* Kmhe^fb^cnl iZcn]bghlZohdZkbnh*
\nkkbm ^b bg fZgnoZeb]Z) ^m _n`Z* f^g) iZlbmbdh cb ln lmbikbn [be*
obm ^nf+ .3 @m _n`bm <e^qZg]^k bg ]n bkikbo^kmc [`mb+ .%2 <e^dlZg*
<kZ[bZf) nm b[b ikhm^`^k^mnk7 k^q ]kZl iZ[`h c <kZ[bcb^dhmb lZn
Znm^f Kmhe^fZ^nl ^qZemZmnl ^lm+ `eh[hl8 dZkZebnl `b Kmhe^fb^cnl
.4 @m Z[lmnebm TZ[]b^e <kZ[l \Z* [nohgn`ZemhcZl+ .4 <kZ[Zl TZ[*
inm <e^qZg]kb8 ^m fblbm Kmhe^* ]bebl gndbkl]bgh <e^dlZg]knb`Ze*
fZ^h+ .5 @mk^qKmhe^fZ^nl fhkmn* o bk Zmlbngm c Kmhe^fb^cnb+
nl ^lm bg ]b^ m^kmbZ7 ^b jnb ^kZgm .5 Ok^b ]b^g fbk mZbi iZm dZ*
bg fngbmbhgb[nl) i^kb^kngm Z[ abl) kZebnl Kmhe^fb^cnl) [nonlb^cb `b
mobkmhol^nohgnh c `ro^gmhc+
jnb ^kZgm bgmkZ \ZlmkZ+
.-
@m k^`gZobm ?^f^mkbnlZggh .6OZbi bfmZl ^bZl ]^bfmbl
l^imbgmZbl f^mZbl f dZkZebZnmb
\^gm^lbfh l^qZ`^lbfh l^imbfh+
?^f^mkbcnl+
/-
Dg ]b^[nl beebl \hg`k^`Zobm /- Onh iZbn eZbdn EhgZmZlln*
DhgZmaZl ^hl) jnb^kZgm bg Dn]Z^Z) kbgdh [nonlbnl En]chc^) dZ] cb^
nm ^qin`gZk^gm Zk\^f) jnZ^ ^lm iZbfm E^knsZel ibe) bk cb^ iZ]Z*
bg e^knlZe^f7 ^m _^\^kngm \hgmkZ k ikb^ c ]Zn` dZkbd iZ[d*
^Zf fZ\abgZl fnemZl+ /. @mZ[b^* e+ /. =^m dZb dnkb^ g^]hkb fh*
kngm jnb]Zf jnb h]^kZgm `^gm^f gl) dnkb^ g^d^gm lZoh mZnmhl)
lnZf obkb bgbjnb Z] k^`^f ?^+* gnch iZl dZkZeb ?^f^mkbc bk
f^mkbf) ^m k^gng\bZo^kngm ^b cZf ikZg^) dZ] EhgZmZlZi`nel
jnh] DhgZmaZl h[lb]^k^m Zk\^f+ ibe+ //OZb b`bk]l) cbl lnirdh)
0/@m nm Zn]bobm) bkZmnl ^lm7 ^mlmZ* mnhcZn Zmordh  Kmhe^fZb]bkiZ*
mbfo^gbmZ] Kmhe^fZb]Zf)^ml\kbi* kZ EhgZmnb) dZ] cbl g^eZbdrm
lbm DhgZmaZ^ g^ h[lb]^k^m Zk\^f) Zi`nel ibeb^l) [^m dZ] ldn[bZb
l^] h\\nkk^k^m lb[b Z]\heehjnbnf Zm^bm iZlbdZe[mb ln cnh+
_^lmbgZmh+
FZbi mbdEhgZmZl mZb b`bk]h)
/0
Pm Zn]bobm Znm^f DhgZmaZl) /0
bnllbm h[lb]^k^7 ^m ^e^`bm ]^ l^* cbl eb^i mlmb Zi`nebf) blbkbgdh
gbhkb[nl DlkZ^e) ^m ]^ lZ\^k]hmb* d^e^m DskZ^ebh ork^lgbc bk dn*
[nl) ^m ]^]bm l^ i^kb\neh+ /1@m gb` bk ch  iZohc+ /1 Ebl iZlb*
Z\\^ibm Znknf) ^m Zk`^gmnf) ^m f Zndlh) lb]Z[kh) ]kZ[nb bk
\kd` bmnd\io k\qje d Bdgjh`ojmdj+
 %.3& G T U Z b  \ 9 eTU\]T( =ijo @dj*
_jmj k\n\fjedhj) ipb\go\n =g`fn\i*
_m\n ]bj np `ifd\dn dho\dn n\qj
\gdidif d =m\]dejn hd`no =] k\n
fpidb\dfo @djfg) k\n fpm edn ]pqj
k\ndpion n\qj h\ ni =iodjf+
>`o ej k\gt_jq o\mk` \ondm\_ ojfd)
fpmd`) npnddije np @`h`omdeph) k\*
ndmkdij) f\_ =g`fn\i_m\n ]o p*
hpo\n7 \m\]\n V\]_dgdn b\g ]pqj
fpmnotoje\n) \m qd`i\n d phpe+
 %.5& D \e((( G gb_X` \X]h f( Gjqje`
ej \mfgtn k\nd]\d_n _m\h]gdj dm ip* 

h`on f\m\gd+ * Jph`no\h ]pqpnd g\*


]\d np`dno\ b\gq\) o\dk f\_ edn f`*
opmd\n _d`i\n ]pqn ]` nhjin+ =o*
b\qpnd\h nhji dm ]`nd_d\pbd\i*
d\h _g \ondnojn =g`fn\i_mj b\gqjn
f\m\gdpd ]pqj _\mjh\ jk`m\^de\) fp*
mdjn h`op edn hdmn+
%.6& K T\c y\` gTf((( .12 h+ kdmh
Gm+
%/6& AX e h m T _ f  c\_\( Lgb+ .-)0/8
qu+ 1)1.8 3)/-+
%/0& ]b \ cTib] ( J`k\fg\pnt_\*
h\n f\m\gd\pn n\fthj) b\gej e _\m
g\]d\p ktfdiod+ G\_ dm ]pqj k\qj*

Turinys

51/

# > 2 < $  ## $'?%&

o^lm^f) ^m ZebZ q^gbZ fnemZ) ^m


Z[bbm Z] k^`^f Kmhe^fZb]Zmg) ^m
bgo^gbm`kZmbZf bg \hgli^\mn ^bnl+
/2 @m bgm^ki^eeZ[Zgm Z]o^klnl ^nf
jnb]Zf bgbjnb^q`^gm^ lnZ+ /3 @m
_^\bm ^b k^q lb\nm _^\^kZgm ^b) jnb
Zgm^ ^nf _n^kZgm7 ^m ^qZemZobm
^nf bg \hgli^\mn hfgbnf Zfb*
\hknf lnhknf) /4/5 ^m lmZmnbm ^b
ikbg\biZmnf lZ\^k]hmbb) ^m jnZ^*
\nfjn^ ZebZ aZ[nbm ikbnl ik^mbh*
lZ)^m _^\bm ^nf ikbg\bi^f Zfb\h*
knf+
/5 @m ihlmneZobm DhgZmaZl Zk^*
`^ nm bffng^f _Z\^k^m Dn]Z^Zf)
^m mk^l mhiZk\abZl) ^m NZfZkbZf)
^m \hg_bg^l ^bnl7 ^m ikhfblbm ^b
mZe^gmZ mk^\^gmZ+ /6 @m \hgl^glbm
k^q7$ ^m l\kbilbm DhgZmaZ^ ^iblmh*
eZl ]^ abl hfgb[nl) ang\ fh*
]nf \hgmbg^gm^l7 5- M@R ?^f^*
mkbnl _kZmkb DhgZmaZ^ lZenm^f) ^m
`^gmb En]Z^hknf+ 0. @q^fienf
^iblmheZ^) jnZf l\kbilbfnl GZl*
ma^gb iZk^gmbghlmkh ]^oh[bl)fb*
lbfnl Z] ohl nm l\bk^mbl7 0/ M^q
?^f^mkbnl GZlma^gb iZk^gmb lZen*
m^f+ 00 B^gmb Dn]Z^hknf Zfb\bl
ghlmkbl) ^m \hgl^koZgmb[nl jnZ^
bnlmZ lngm Zin] ghl) ]^\k^obfnl
[^g^_Z\^k^ ikhim^k [^gb`gbmZm^f
bilhknf) jnZf ^k`Zghl aZ[^gm+
01 NmZmnbfnl ^k`h beebl hfg^l _b*
g^l Dn]Z^Z^) ^m mk^l \bobmZm^l)Gr*
]Zg) ^m MZfZmaZg) jnZ^ Z]]bmZ^

c ]Zn` dbm ]hoZg) gnch iZl dZ*


kZeb  Kmhe^fZb] bk kZ]h fZeh*
gl ch ZdboZbs]hc^+ /2 FZb dnkb^
g^]hkb lZoh mZnmhl fhgl de
ikb^ c ldng]) /3 [^m dZkZebnl
iZ]Zk cZf mZbi) dZbi [noh ]Zk
ibkf ch [nonlb^cb) bk bZndmbgh c
obl lZoh ikb^m^eb ZdboZbs]hc^+
/4Ebl iZmobkmbgh cZf orkbZnlbc
dngb`rlm) mZbi iZm obl iZ`Zk[)
dnkb cbl mnkch ZgdlbZn)bk iZ]Z*
k b ch ob^g lZoh ibkfc ikb^*
m^eb+
/5 Onhf^m EhgZmZl ikZ dZkZ*
eb Zme^blmb gnh fhd^lb En]c)
mkbl Zildkbmbl)NZfZkbc bkchl Zir*
ebgd^l) bk iZZ]ch cZf mkbl bf*
mnl mZe^gm+ /6 FZkZebnl lnmbdh bk
iZkZ EhgZmnb Zib^ oblnl bmnhl
]ZerdnleZbdmhdbhmnkbgbh7 0-FZ*
kZebnl ?^f^mkbcnl lbngbZ lo^bdb*
gbf [khebnb EhgZmnb bk r]mZn*
mZb 0. H^l lbngbZf^ cnfl gnh*
kZ mh eZbdh) dnk f^l iZkZ*
f^ Zib^ cnl fl `bfbgZbbnb GZ*
lm^gnb) dZ] clbghmnfm^+ X F Z *
kZebnl ?^f^mkbcnl lZoh `bfbgZb*
bnb GZlm^gnb lbngbZ lo^bdbgbf
00r] mZnmZb) dnkb^ rkZ fl
ikb^m^ebZb bk eZbdhlb mh) dZl fnfl
m^blbg`Zb ikbdeZnlh) f^l gnmZkf^
]Zkrmb `^kZ ]ec iZeZgdnfh)dh*
d cb^ fnfl kh]h+ 013
 Oh]e f^l
4
iZo^]Zf^ cb^fl oblEn]chlieh*
m) mkbl fb^lmnl) Gr] bk MZfZm)

edib\ _\]\m `dod k\n f\m\gd) o\d\p


Fji\o\n k\ndodfej @d`qj k\b\g]\ dm
n\qj nph\iphp+  %/3& G \e`  ]b  Uh
i h f\X]\4 =g`fn\i_m\n >\g\n dm Lojg`*
hd`epn Bdgjh`ojmdn+ Lgb+ .-)3.32+
%/5& J T ` T e\] \e ]b f  T c l _\a ^ X f 4 b\g
omdn O\h\mdejn \knfmdodn) fpmdjn ]p*
qj kmd_ojn Fp_e\d+ Lgb+ 01 `+ dm
.-)0-+  Ke\f"& y\` ghf gT_Xa g( C\g o\d
opmej ]od i` h`odidn) ]`o qd`i\f\m*
odn hjf`nidn+  %0-& B TeT_\hf( Lgb+
.-).4+  %0.& CTfgXah\(
H\no`i\n
\ifnd\p bgj]jej @`h`omde) k\_ej
e\h k\ndn\h_tod f\mdpjh`i %qu+ .-)

34 dm k\\df+& dm k\dhod Otmdejn njn*


o+ =ondgtbdi_\h\n @`h`omdepn ]pqj
e\h npo`dfn qtmd\pndj n\qj kmd`o`gdj
b\m] dm k\nftmn ed ?`g`ntmdejn dm
L`idfdejn qd`odidifp+  %01& K e\f
` \Xfghf& C l W T((( Rpgb\oje` dg`dno\n
om`dj hd`noj q\m_\n7 =a`m`h\8 edn
b\g dq`mno\n j_dp7 n`lp`nom\md) fp*
mdj im\ bm+ o+ =a`m`h\ %b\g Aam`hj
hd`no`gdn) Fjij ..)21&) ]pqpnd) \ijo
Bg+ Fpju\kj) i`ojgd ipj >`ogdj+ H t *
_\ e kd`o\ mtopn ipj Fjkn) i`ojgd ipj
P\mk`hn emjn %. Gmji+ 5)./8 J``h+
..)02&+
N\h\o\) n`ijqe` N\h\o\

Turinys

. H<F+ ..) 02}06

510

lngm Dn]Z^Z^ ^q NZfZkbZ) ^m hf*


g^l \hg_bg^l ^Zknf l^jn^lmkZkb
hfgb[nl lZ\kb_b\Zgmb[nl bg D^kh*
lherfbl ikh abl) jnZ^Z[ ^bl ikbnl
Z\\bib^[Zm k^q i^k lbg`nehl Zg*
ghl) ^m ikh _kn\mb[nl m^kkZ^) ^m
ihfhknf+ 02 @m ZebZ) jnZ^Z]ghl
i^kmbg^[Zgm ]^\bfZknf) ^m mkb[n*
mhknf ^q ah\ m^fihk^ k^fbmmb*
fnl ^bl7 ^m Zk^Zl lZebgZknf) ^m
\hkhgZl) jnZ^ gh[bl ]^_^k^[Zg*
mnk) 0- hfgbZ bilbl \hg\^]bfnl7
^m gbabe ahknf bkkbmnf ^kbm ^q
ah\) ^m bg hfg^m^finl+ 04 Ing\
^k`h \nkZm^_Z\^k^ ahknf ^q^f*
ienf) ^m ]^mnk DhgZmaZ^)^m ihgZ*
mnk bg fhgm^ lZg\mh) bg eh\h \^*
e^[kb+

dnkb^ ikb]mb En]cZbb NZfZkbchl)


bk oblZl c Zirebgd^l gZn]hmbl ob*
lb^fl mb^fl) dnkb^ ZndhcZ E^kn*
sZec^) nnhm mh) d l^gbZn dZkZ*
ebnl bf]Zoh b c dZl f^mZb) bk
nnhm ^fl bk f^]b oZblb+
02 OZbi iZm gnh bh f^mh f^l Zm*
e^b]bZf^ cnhl gnh dbm ]Zerd)
dnkb^ fnfl ikbdeZnl) gnh ]^*
bfmbgb bk gnh fhd^lb) ]kZn`
ln ]knldhl dZlrde fnbmn bkoZb*
gbdZbl) dnkb^ [noh fnfl Zmg^Z*
fb+ 03QblZ mZb f^l Zmb]nh]Zf^
cb^fl) bk gb^dh b mh g^[nl iZ*
gZbdbgmZ gnh bhl ]b^ghl bkoblZbl
eZbdZbl+ 04 OZb`b ]Z[Zk iZlbkibg*
dbm^ iZ]Zkrmb bm ]Zerd gnhkZ*
) dnkl mnkb [mb Zmb]nhmZl Eh*
gZmnb bk iZ]mZl o^gmZcZf^ dZe*
g^ oblb^fl fZmhfhc^ ob^mhc^+
0N
@m ob]^gl ?^f^mkbnl k^q 05 FZkZebnl ?^f^mkbcnl) fZmr*
jnh] lbenbm m^kkZ bg \hgli^\mn ]ZfZl) dZ] oblZ Zebl [noh gnmb*
lnh) ^m gbabe ^b k^lblmbm) ]bfblbm enl ch ZdboZbs]hc^ bk dZ] gb^dZl
mhmnf ^q^k\bmnf lnnf) ngnf* cZf g^lbikb^bgZ) iZe^b]hobl lZ*
jn^fjn^ bg eh\nf lnnf) ^q\^i* oh dZkbnhf^g) db^dob^g  lZoh
mh i^k^`kbgh ^q^k\bmn) jn^f \hg* ob^m) bldrknl lo^mbfZebdZkbnh*
mkZqbm Z[ bglnebl B^gmbnf7 ^m bgb* f^g) dnkb cbl [noh lnkbgdl b
fb\b ^kZgm ^b hfg^l ^q^k\bmnl iZ* iZ`hgb lZe+ Onhf^m oblb ch m*
o dZkbnhf^gl [kbZb iZlb]Zk
mknf ^bnl+06
cZf g^ikb^m^ebZb+
06Okb_hgZl) dnkl ZgdlbZn [n*
06 Okriahg Znm^f ^kZm jnb]Zf
iZkmbnf <e^qZg]kb ikbnl7 ^m ob]bm oh ob^gZl b <e^dlZg]kh Zebgbg*
jnhgbZf hfgbl ^q^k\bmnl fnk* d) iZfZml) dZ] oblZ dZkbnhf^*
dhnjadh %. G\m+ .).&) qgd\p =mdh\*
oe\ %I\o+ /4).28 Fjij .6)00&) _\]\m
`m*N\h) Aam\dhj f\gipjn`) i`ojgd ipj
F`mpu\gn+  A X e h m T _ ]X 4 oj_g odf
t_\hn) i` n\h\mdoji\hn) i`n dod`
\pfj_\qj C\mdudhj f\gi`+  %02&
< eh f^bf ^ T fl ^ _ ( Pdfmd\p7 _mpnfjn
_pj]d+ Lgb+ \pf+ .-)/5) %03& M \fT gT\'
dod` k\\_\d Fji\opd i` o\dk kg\on)
f\dk @`h`omde\pn E k\_\mtod`ed kdmh
``md h`o %.-)/512&+ C\g f\d
fpmdjn g`ibq\ojn _\m ]pqj npo`dfojn
t_\hn) k\oqdmodi\io Fji\o qtmd\p*
ndpjep fpidbp+ >` oj) _\]\modidp Ot*
mdejn f\m\gdphd Fji\o\n b\g g\]d\p k\*
ndodfej dm oj_g g\]d\p q`modij f\_
dm h\`nidpn ej k\\_pn+

%05& G T_X\W b((( Idmpn =g`fn\i_mpd


dm Lojg`hd`epd+
%06& K e\Yb a T f( Pdfm\n ej q\m_\n
]pqj @dj_jo\n) Pmdajip edn ]pqj km\*
hdio\n qgd\p+ G\mdpjh`in q\_p edn
]pqj k\nfdmo\n =g`fn\i_mj >\gj+ L \*
h\on) f\_ Otmdejn btq`ioje\d) tk\
bd k\g`dnod`ed f\m`dqd\d) g\]\d i`k\*
o`ifdiod ipjhdp dm k\oqdmfpnd n\qj
f\m\gdphd) nph\i k\on nd`fod q\g*
_djn dm n\qj odfngpd k\nd`fod ijmej
k\ndi\p_jod h\p =g`fn\i_mj nip*
hd) fpmn ]pqj \pbdi\h\n k\n qd`i
=m\]dejn fpidb\dfod+ Pj fpidb\df*
dj q\m_\n o`fnopjn` m\jh\n g\]\d
i`qd`ij_\d+ @dj_jo\n q\_di\ ed F\h *
]gdfp) qpgb\o\ Ah\gfpgdp+  %16&

Turinys

511

. H<F+ ..) 1 - *1 5

fnkZ[Zm \hgmkZ ?^f^mkbnf) ^m U g fnkfZ ikb^ ?^f^mkbc) gn*


bobm Z] @fZe\an^e <kZ[^f) jnb ordh iZl ZkZ[ @fZedne) dnkl
gnmkb^[Zm <gmbh\anf _bebnf <e^* b Zndech <e^dlZg]kh lg<gmbhd)
qZg]kb7 1- ^m Zllb]^[Zm ^b) nm mkZ* 1- bk dZe[bgch cZf Zmb]nhmb clZn)
]^k^m ^nf bilb) nm k^`gZk^m eh\h dZ] cbl `Zem dZkZebZnmb lZoh m*
iZmkbl lnb7 ^m ^gng\bZobm ^b jnZg* oh ob^mhc^+ Ebl cZf iZiZlZdhch
mZ _^\bm ?^f^mkbnl) ^m bgbfb\bmbZl oblZ)d [noh iZ]Zkl ?^f^mkbcnl)
^q^k\bmnnf ^bnl Z]o^klnl beenf+ bk dZ] ch dZkbnhf^g chch g^Zi*
d^gm+ Ebl iZlbebdh m^gZb be` eZbd+
@m fZglbm b[b ]b^[nl fnembl+
1.
@m fblbm DhgZmaZl Z] ?^* 1. <gnh f^mn EhgZmZl lbngm
f^mkbnf k^`^f) nm ^bb\^k^m ^hl) iZl dZkZeb ?^f^mkbc) dZ] eb^i*
jnb bg Zk\^ ^kZgm bg e^knlZe^f) ^m c m b^bmb mb^fl) dnkb^ [noh E^kn*
jnb bg ikZ^lb]bbl ^kZgm7 jnbZ bf* sZel iberc^ bk mobkmhol^) g^l cb^
in`gZ[Zgm DlkZ^e+ 1/ @m fblbm ?^* nine]bgch DskZ^e+ 1/ ?^f^mkbcnl
f^mkbnl Z] DhgZmaZg) ]b\^gl7Ihg  `b lbngm iZlZdrmb EhgZmnb7 I^ mbd
aZ^\ mZgmnf _Z\bZf mb[b) ^m`^gmb  mZb Z iZ]Zkrlbn mZn bk mZoh mZn*
mnZ^) l^] `ehkbZ beenlmkZ[h m^) ^m c mZb) [^m iZZndmbglbn `Zk[^ mZo^
`^gm^f mnZf \nf _n^kbm hiihk* bk mZoh mZnm) dZbi mbd [nl iZmh*
mngnf+ 10 Ing\ ^k`h k^\m^ _^\^* `n+ 10 OZb`b mn ]Z[Zk`^kZb iZ]Z*
kbl) lb fbl^kbl bg Znqbebnf fbab krlb) c^b Zmlblb fZg iZ`Ze[hg
obkhl7 jnbZ ]bl\^llbm hfgbl ^q^k* fhgb) g^l oblZ fZgh dZkbnh*
f^g iZebdh fZg^+
\bmnl f^nl+
11
@m fblbm ^b DhgZmaZl mkbZfbe* 11 EhgZmZl gnlbngm cZf b <g*
ebZ obkhknf _hkmbnf <gmbh\abZf7 mbhdbc mkbl mdlmZgbnl ]klbor*
^m o^g^kngm Z] k^`^f) ^m ]^e^\* k+ Eb^ Zmch iZl dZkZeb) bk dZkZ*
mZmnl ^lm k^q bg Z]o^gmn ^hknf+ ebnl ]bZn`lbc Zmcbfn+ 12D[n*
12 @m \hgo^g^kngm jnb ^kZgm ]^ onlb fb^lm^ fhgb lnlbkbgdh
\bobmZm^) \^gmnf ob`bgmb fbeebZ ob* bfmZl ]ob]^bfm mdlmZgb bk
khknf) ^m ohe^[Zgm bgm^k_b\^k^ k^* ghkch nfnmb dZkZeb+ 13 FZkZ*
`^f+ 13 @m _n`bm k^q bg ZneZf7 ^m ebnl iZ[`h  kfnl8 fb^lmh `r*
h\\niZo^kngm jnb ^kZgm ]^ \bobmZ* o^gmhcZb iZf fb^lmh `Zmo^l bk
m^) bmbg^kZ \bobmZmbl) ^m \h^i^kngm ikZ]ch dhohmb+ 14 FZkZebnl iZlb
in`gZk^+ 14 @m oh\Zobm k^q Dn]Z^* Znd iZ`Ze[hg r]nl8 cb^ oblb
hl bg Znqbebnf) ^m \hgo^g^kngm ]kZn` lnlbkbgdh ikb^ ch) iZldnb
hfg^l lbfne Z] ^nf) ^m ]bli^k* oblb blbldbklm fb^lm^) 15 nfn
lb lngm hfg^l i^k\bobmZm^f7 15 ^m m ]b^g bfm mdlmZgb fh*
h\\b]^kngm ba beeZ ]b^ \^gmnf fbe* . gb) iZ]^` fb^lm)iZf m]b^*

@^ T _U \a ]b ]T` ( Ah\gfpgdn h\ojh\d


i`g\]\d ijmej odfod) f\_ Pmdoji\n
d odfme ijmd b\pod njno _q`e \m
f`oq`md h`o q\dfpd) j i` n\p+
%1.& AX e h m T _ f  c \_l ]X( Fji\o\n ]p*
qj gd`kn onod ojn kdgd`n \kbpgdh
%/0 `+&) ]`o k\dhod ejn e\h i`k\qt*
fj+  %10& G TZ T_U ba ( L\b\g]\ ]pqj
m`df\gdib\ kmd` h\dop f`gd\idpn
hd`nopn+

%12& Jhf\e\a^b y\` gTf((( =iodjfdej*


e` ]pq \kd` 1--+--- btq`ioje) oj*
_g dm kmdnd_epnd kmd` h\doj b\*
gej ]od g\]\d _\pb+  %15& L {` hy(((
@dj_jml k\n\fjedhp) @`h`omdepn gd`*
kn p_tod hjo`mdn dm q\dfpn) oj_g
phpoe nf\ddpn ]pqj g\]\d _d_`gdn)
gd\p_d`n ipjhji`) edn nd`fn dhoj
ofno\id+ @\pb pqj b\dnm`) i`n
@`h`omdepn _\qn n\fth _`bdiod
hd`no %Bg+ Fpju+&+ |

Turinys

. H<F+ D D ) 16}25

512

ebZ ahfbgnf) ^m ln\\^g]^kngm\b* g ]Zn` `kh[bh bk boZ]Zoh dZ*


obmZm^f) ^m \^i^kngm lihebZ fne* kZeb+ 16 Hb^lmh `ro^gmhcZb)iZfZ*
mZ bg ]b^ beeZ) ^m eb[^kZo^kngm k^* m) dZ] r]Zb iZf fb^lm) dZbi
`^f+ 16 @m ob]^kngm jnb ^kZgm ]^ ghkch) g^m^dh ]klhl bk Zndlb
\bobmZm^) jnh] h[mbgnbll^gm en]Z^b  dZkZeb fZe]Zn]Zfb bk lZdr]Z*
\bobmZm^f lb\nm ohe^[Zgm7 ^m bg_bk* fb7 2- KZ]nhd fnfl ]^bg bk
fZmb lngm f^gm^ lnZ) ^m \eZfZo^* m^lbebZncZ r]Zb dhohcikb^ fnl
kngm Z] k^`^f \nf ik^\b[nl) ]b* bk ikb^ fb^lm+ 2.Eb^ f^m lZoh
\^gm^l7 2- ?Z gh[bl ]^qmkZl) ^m `bgdenl bk iZ]Zk mZbd+ r]Zb lb*
\^ll^gm en]Z^b hiin`gZk^ ghl) ^m `bch `Zk[l dZkZebZnl ZdboZbs]hc^
\bobmZm^f+ 3. @m ikhb^\^kngm ZkfZ bk obl ch dZkZerlmc^ [nonlbc
lnZ) ^m _^\^kngm iZ\^f) ^m `ehkb* Zdrl^8 cb^ iZlb]Zk `Zkll dZkZ*
_b\Zmb lngm en]Z^b bg \hgli^\mn erlmc^ bk ln`kh  E^knsZe) mnk*
k^`bl) ^m bg \hgli^\mn hfgbnf) ]Zfb ]Zn` `kh[bh+
jnb ^kZgm bg k^`gh ^bnl) ^m gh*
fbgZmb lngm bg k^`gh7 ^m k^`k^llb
lngm bg D^knlZe^f aZ[^gm^l lih*
ebZ fnemZ+
2/
@m l^]bm ?^f^mkbnl k^q bg 2/ FZkZebnl ?^f^mkbcnl l]ch
l^]^ k^`gb lnb7 ^m lbenbm m^kkZ bg lZoh dZkZerlml lhlm^) bk oblZZ*
\hgli^\mn ^bnl+ 20 @m f^gmbmnl ebl [noh gnmbenl ch ZdboZbs]hc^+
^lm hfgbZ jnZ^\nfjn^ ]bqbm) ^m 20 =^m cbl blb`rg oblh) d [noh
Z[Zeb^gZobm l^ Z DhgZmaZ) ^m ghg lZdl) gnmheh gnh EhgZmh) g^Zm*
k^mkb[nbm ^b l^\ng]nf [^g^_b\bZ) lber`bgh cZf) g^bk]ZfZl `^kZ*
jnZ^ lb[b mkb[n^kZm) ^m o^qZ[Zm ]Zkrlb) dhdb mZlZb [noh cZf
iZ]Zkl) bk eZ[Zb c oZk`bgh+
^nf oZe]^+
21
Khlm aZ^\ Znm^f k^o^klnl 21 Kh mh ln`kh Okb_hgZl bk
^lm Okriahg) ^m <gmbh\anl \nf ln cnh <gmbhdZl) ]Zk fZZl oZb*
^h in^k Z]he^l\^gl) ^m k^`gZobm) dZl) dnkl f dZkZebZnmb bk nlb*
^m bfihlnbm lb[b ]bZ]^fZ+ 21 2 @m ]ch lZn oZbgbd+ 22 Kkb^ ch lnlb*
\hg`k^`Zmb lngm Z] ^nf hfg^l kbgdh oblZ dZkbnhf^g) dnkb [n*
^q^k\bmnl) jnhl ]bli^kl^kZm ?^* oh iZe^b]l ?^f^mkbcnl) bk dhoh*
f^mkbnl) ^m in`gZo^kngm \hgmkZ ch ikb^ c8 cbl [noh gn`ZemZl bk
^nf7 ^m+_n`bm) ^m m^k`Z o^kmbm+ 23' @m mnkch [`mb+ 23 Okb_hgZl Zmf
Z\\^ibm Okriahg [^lmbZl) ^m h[mb* ]kZf[ebnl bk iZf <gmbhdbc+
gnbm <gmbh\abZf7
24 Kh mh cZngZl <gmbhdZl iZ*
24 ^m l\kbilbm <gmbh\anl Z]h*
e^l\^gl DhgZmaZ^) ]b\^gl7 >hglmb* kZ EhgZmnbbZbl h]bZbl7 <iZ*
mnh mb[b lZ\^k]hmbnf)^m \hglmbmnh mobkmbgn mZn dngb`rlm bk ldbkbn
m^ lni^k jnZmmnhk \bobmZm^l) nmlbl c mZo^ d^mnkb fb^lm obkbgbgdn)
]^ Zfb\bl k^`bl+ 25 @m fblbm beeb e dZ] mn [mnf^b ob^gZl b dZkZ*
oZlZ Znk^Z bg fbgblm^kbnf) ^m ]^* D ebZnl ikb^m^eb+ 25=^ mh) cbl Zmlbng*

%21& 9 a g\b ^ T f4 =iodjf\n RE Pc`jn+


Ru+ 1- `dg+  %22& K h e]b UZg\( =ijo
Hdqde\pn) k\]bj d O`g`pfde) \ijo E k e +
Fpju\kj) d Gdgdfde+  %23& < eT` U_\hf4
fpmd\dn i\p_jejnd fjqje` @`h`omdepn+

Turinys

%24& B Xghe\4 omde \knfmdd) fp*


mdjn ]pqj kmd_ojn Fp_e\d d O\h\*
mdejn) dm _\m qd`ijn) b\g =f\mjij+ 
%25&) < i g\d checheT((( Ru+ .-)/-+56+
 %26& Eh"c K \eb e\U( Cm+ o+7 ipj

513

. H<F+ ..) 2 6 *3 3

]bm ^b ihm^lmZm^f [b[^g]b bg Zn* m cZf Zndlbgb bg] mZkgrlm^b)
kh) ^m ^ll^ bg inkinkZ) ^m aZ[^* ]Zo cZf e^b]bf `^kmb b Zndlh)
k^ _b[neZfZnk^Zf7 26 ^m Nbfhg^f ]omb inkinkZ bk g^bhmb Zndlbg
_kZmk^f ^bnl \hglmbmnbm ]n\^f Z lZ`m8 26ch `b [khe Nbfhg iZ*
m^kfbgbl Orkb nljn^ Z] _bg^l <^* ldrk oZ]n gnh Obkh kb[ bdb <b*
`bimh lb^gZb+
`rimb*
3-
@m ^qbbm ehgZmaZl) ^m i^kZf* 3- Onhf^m EhgZmZl bcl ch
[neZ[Zm mkZgl _enf^g \bobmZm^l7 ^m i^k fb^lmnl ZgZinl nil) h ikb^
\hg`k^`Zmnl ^lm Z] ^nf hfgbl ch lnlbkbgdhoblZ Nrkbchl dZkbnh*
^q^k\bmnl NrkbZ^ bg Znqbebnf) ^m f^g  iZ`Ze[+ FZb cbl Zmch 
o^gbm <l\Zehg^f) ^m h\\nkk^kngm <ldZehg) `ro^gmhcZb bchbfb^*
^b ahghkb_b\^ ]^ \bobmZm^+3. @mZ[bbm lmh ch iZlbmbdmb ln iZ`Zk[Z+ 3. D
bg]^ BZsZf7 ^m \hg\enl^kngm l^ bZ cbl gnch  BZs) [^m `Zsb^*
jnb ^kZgm BZsZ^7 ^m h[l^]bm ^Zf) bZb nlb]Zk8 mh]e cbl Zi`ne c)
^m ln\\^g]bm jnZ^ ^kZgm bg\bk\n* dZl `b [noh Ziebgd fb^lm) cbl
bmn \bobmZmbl) ^m ikZ^]Zmnl ^lm ^Z+ ]^`bgh bk ie+ 3/ Onhf^m`Zsb^*
3/ @m kh`Zo^kngm BZs^gl^l ehgZ* bZb ikZ EhgZm mZbdhl8 cbl ]Zo
maZg) ^m ]^]bm beebl ]^qm^kZf7 ^m cb^fl]^bg)iZfc lgnl dZb*
Z\\^ibm _bebhl ^hknf h[lb]^l) ^m mZbl bk gnlbngm cnhl  E^knsZe+
fblbm beehl bg D^knlZe^f7 ^mi^kZf* Kh mh cbl ch bbe`Zb i^k dkZm
[neZobm k^`bhg^f nljn^ ?ZfZl* bdb ?ZfZldnb+
\nf+
30 @m Zn]bobm ehgZmaZl jnh]
30 O^g EhgZmZl b`bk]h) dZ]
ikZ^oZkb\Zmb lngm ikbg\bi^l ?^* ?^f^mkbcZnl oZ]Zb ln `Znlbg`Z
f^mkbb bg >Z]^l) jnZ^ ^lm bg BZ* dZkbnhf^g^ o^bdbZ ikb^ c FZ]^*
ebeZ^Z) \nf ^q^k\bmn fnemh) ohe^g* l^) dnkl rkZ BZebeb^chc^) ghk]Z*
m^l ^nf k^fho^k^ Z g^`hmbh k^`* fb iZZebgmb c gnh dZkZerlmlk^b*
gb7 31 ^m h\\nkkbm beebl7 _kZmk^f Zn* dZe) 31 bk cbl ch ikb^ cnhl) iZ*
m^f lnnf Nbfhg^f k^ebjnbm bgmkZ ebdl lZoh [khe Nbfhg Zerc^+
ikhobg\bZf+
32 NbfhgZl Zi`ne =^mlnk)
32 @m Ziieb\nbm Nbfhg Z] =^ma*
lnkZf) ^m ^qin`gZ[Zm ^Zf ]b^* dhohch ikb^ c]Zn` ]b^g bk eZb*
[nl fnembl)^m \hg\enlbm^hl+ 3- @m d chl `ro^gmhcnl n]Zkrmnl+
ihlmneZo^kngm Z[ ^h ]^qmkZl Z\* 33 FZ]Zg`b cb^ ikZ c mZbdhl) mZb
\bi^k^) ^m ]^]bm beebl7 ^m ^b^\bm ^hl cbl cb^fl lnm^bd8cbl iZZebghcnhl
odmd`d g\dkop) o+ t+ ipj \pfoj f\g*
ij) fpmn tm\ dhop q\mni \onop ipj
Lojg`h\d_jn %Bg+ Fpju+&+  @^\ 9\'
Z\cgb f\Xa T \4 dfd Ndijfjmpmjn `g*=md
pk`gdpd+
%36& L cf4 Fjm_\ij+  J l e\]b f
^ T e\h b ` Xa 4 fpmd ]pqj @`h`omde\pn
k\g`dno\ dm ]pqj opj k\g`d_dhp i`*
k\o`ifdio\+  9 f^ T _b a 4 e\p d\kpn
Fjm_\ij+ Ru+ .-)42+53+  %3.& > TmT(
P\d qd`i\n d k`ifd _d_de kdgdnod*
h *hd`no) kd`o ji` kmd` f`gdj) fp*
mdpj ]pqj `di\h\ d Otmdejn d =dbdk*
o+  %3/& Ah  fahf ^T\gT\f& Cm+ o+7

_d_dip nin+  ]b  \y\_Z T\(((4 d


kd`oq\f\mdp d d\pmn mtopn+ @\h\n*
f\n ]pqj n`ijqn Otmdejn njnodi8
t_\hn ed id`fpjh`o i`kmdfg\pn+
%30& < X` Xge\]Th f i T W T \4 k\ndgdf
dodfdh\dn @`h`omdepd q\_\d+ Fd` h\*
ojh\d ]pqj i`k\o`ifdiod) f\h Fji\*
o\n ijmd fdodn d Otmdejn f\m\gtnon
m`df\gpn) dm ijmej kmdq`mnod dd bmod
d Fp_e+ G\_`n\n ]pqj d d\pmn q \ *
f\mpn ipj I`mjhj ``mj+ Lgb+ Fju+
./)//+  %31& x T _l ]X 4 Fp_eje`+
%32& : X gf T e b ]X ( Ru+ 1)/68 3)2-8 6)2/+
%34& G e\X > Xa Xm T eb  i Ta W Xa f4 kmd`

Turinys

. H<F+ ..) 34}./) .

*&)

bg]^) ^m \^ibm \bobmZm^f) ^m ihlnbm c b m^g) iZf fb^lm bk iZlmZm

 cZf^ `ne+
34 EhgZmZl bk ch dZkbnhf^g
34 @m DhgZmaZl) ^m \ZlmkZ ^bnl
Ziieb\n^kngm Z] ZjnZf B^g^lZk) D lnlmhch ikb^ B^g^sZkh oZg]^gl)
^m Zgm^ en\^f ob`beZo^kngmbg \Zf* $ h krmf^m ]Zk g^bZnnl iZlb^d
ih <lhk+ -5 @m^\\^ \ZlmkZ Zeb^gb* b <lhkh er`nf+ 35 mZb lo^mbfZ*
`^gZknf h\\nkk^[Zgm bg \Zfih) b eb dZkbnhf^g ch ikb^Zbl er`n*
^m m^g]^[Zgm ^b bglb]bZl bg fhg* 7 fhc) h dZegnhl^ cb^ [noh iZ
mb[nl7 bil^ Znm^f h\\nkkbm ^q Z]* . lei [k chmrdhmb8cbl`bchikb^
o^klh+ '356 Dglb]bZ^ o^kh^qlnkk^q^* 7 cnhl+ 36 Onhf^m iZleimb^cb iZdbeh
kngm ]^ eh\bl lnbl) ^m \hffbl^* b lZohob^mbkikZ]chd ho +4-Qb*
kngm ikZ^ebnf+ 4-@m _n`^kngm jnb  lb) dnkb^ [noh EhgZmh inlc^) iZ*
^kZgm ^q iZkm^ DhgZmaZ^ hfg^l)  [`h bk g^ebdhc gob^gh) mbd<[*
^m g^fh k^eb\mnl ^lm ^q ^bl) gblb lhehfbhlgnlHZmZmbcZlbk dZkbnh*
HZmaZmabZl _bebnl<[lhehfb) ^m en*  f^gl [kbh oZ]ZlFZeibh lgnl
]Zl _bebnl >Zeiab) ikbg\^il fbeb* u
 En]Zl+ 4. EhgZmZl i^kie lZoh
mbZ^ ^q^k\bmnl+ 4. @m l\b]bm DhgZ* ]kZ[nbnl) iZ[Zklm lZn Zgm `Ze*
maZl o^lmbf^gmZ lnZ)^mihlnbmm^k* ohl ^fb bk f^e]lb+ 4/ Kh mh
kZf bg \Zibm^ lnh) ^m hkZobm+ 4/@m EhgZmZl ln`kh dho ikb^cnhl
k^o^klnl ^lm DhgZmaZl Z] ^hl bg bk ikbo^km cnhl [`mb+ 40 OZb iZ*
ikZ^ebnf) ^m \hgo^kmbm ^hl bg _n*  fZm ch fhgl) dnkb^ [noh iZ*
`Zf) ^m in`gZo^kngm+ 40 @m ob]^*  [`) ln`kh ikb^ch)obchlb]kZn`
kngm jnb _n`b^[Zgm iZkmbl beebnl)^m ln cnh oblnl bdb FZ]^lnb  c
k^o^klb lngm Z] ^nf) ^m bgl^jn^* lmhorde) g^l cb^ gnch bdb m^gZb+
[Zgmnk \nf ^h hfg^l nljn^+>Z* 41 O ]b^g dkbmh b lo^mbfZeb
]^l Z] \ZlmkZ lnZ) ^m i^ko^g^* mkrl mdlmZgbZb ork) bk EhgZmZl
kngm nljn^ been\+ 41 @m\^\b]^kngm ln`kh  E^knsZe+
]^ Zeb^gb`^gbl bg ]b^ beeZ mkbZ fbe*
ebZ obkhknf7 ^m k^o^klnl ^lm Dh*
gZmaZl bg D^knlZe^f+

RW NJ Y[N\RMR^V$

O! DLYOZ]Z^ L_YL`UTYTXL^^` CZXwYLT^ T] D[L]_TPrTLT^


T] <ZYL_Z XT]_T^%
'( [P]^Vb]TXL^% . EhgZmZl)
6L[`_% H;; . @m ob]bm DhgZ* 
maZl jnbZ m^finl ^nf bnoZm) ^e^* c  fZmr]ZfZl) dZ] eZbdZl cZf iZmh*
?d`i`u\m`oj ``mj+  9 fbeb( P\d ]p*
qj Fjupn g\df\dn thd\pnd\n d\pmd*
in L\g`nodijn hd`no\n+ Ru+ Fju+ ..).
d7m f+ Fj qd`o\ _\]\m i`]`dijh\+
%35& JiXg\` yT_\ (((4 f\mdpjh`i) fp*
md\ @`h`omdepn ]pqj n\p k\ndgdfn
%05 `df&+  A \ f  Z \ ]b  c e\Xy ]h bf( %dm+
o+7 ed` bd ej kmd` ed %Fji\o&+
%36& G eT W ]b  ^ b i 4 kpg_\hd d pk\*
f\gdj+
 %4-& E X_\^b ] a i\Xab(((
Fji\oj f\m`dqd\d) fpmd` i`g\pf kpj*
gdhj d k\n\g) ipndb\i_j dm km\_ej

]bod+ Op Fji\op gdfj odf _p f\mdpj*


h`in q\_p b\g np qdn\d h\p f\*
m`dqd ]mdp+  %4/& J hZe{b  ^ bi T(((
G\d Fji\o\n) h\g_jn npnodkmdio\n)
_mnd\d kpjg kmd`pn) o\d k\h\o ej
k\]bpnd`ed f\m`dqd\d8 ed` bmdj dm k\*
_ej Fji\opd nphpod kmd`pn) j k\*
nfpd nphpopjndpn qdejnd+  %40& , ]
f gb i l ^ _ 4 fpmdje` ipb\god`ed b\gej
bdiodn+  A \ X  ah]b((( =ijo bm+ o+7 ed`
%t_\d& npnojej o`i\d+ Fji\o\n i`nd*
e\po b\gdn k\dhod ntm f\mdpjh`in
nojqtfg+

Turinys

.*.

' ? 4 = % '(# ( ( "

`bm obkhl) ^m fblbm ^hl MhfZf b `nl) bkbgdh ork bk lbngm cnhl
lmZmn^k^) ^m k^ghoZk^\nf^blZfb* K Mhfhg)lnlmbikbgmb bkZmgZncbgmbln
\bmbZf7 /^m Z] NiZkmbgmZl) ^m Z]
 MhfgZblikb^m^erlml+ / Ebl lbng*
ZebZ eh\Z fblbm ^iblmheZl l^\ng* . m mZbiiZmiZlNiZkmb^bnl bk cdbmZl
]nf ^Zf]^f _hkfZf7
 ob^mZl eZbd mhdbh iZm mnkbgbh+
0
^m Z[b^kngm MhfZf) ^m 8 bg* 0 Ob^ gnch Mhfhg) Zmch
mkZo^kngm \nkbZf) ^m ]bq^kngm7 eh* 8 mZkr[ bk mZk7 QrkbZnlbZldngb`Zl
gZmaZl lnffnl lZ\^k]hl) ^m`^gl b bk r] mZnmZ lbngm fnl ZmgZn*
Dn]Z^hknf fbl^kngm ghl) nm k^* D cbgmb ikb^m^erlml bk ]kZn`rlml)
ghoZk^fnl Zfb\bmbZf) ^m lh\b^* D dZbi [noh l^gbZn+ 1 MhfgZb]Z*
mZm^f l^\pk]nf ikblmbgnf+ 1 @m b o cb^fl eZbd lZob^lb^fl oZb*
]^]^kngm beebl ^iblmheZl Z] bilhl  kbhl^ ob^mhl^) dZ] iZer]m cnhl
i^k eh\Z) nm ]^]n\^k^gm ^hl bg $  En]h Ze kZfr[c^+
m^kkZf Dn]Z \nf iZ\^+
2
@m ah\ ^lm ^q^fienf ^ibl* 2
mZb gnhkZZl eZbdh) dhd
mheZknf) jnZl l\kbilbm DhgZmaZl EhgZmZliZkZNiZkmb^bZfl7 3Qr*
NiZkmbZmbl7 3 DJI<OC<N lnffnl 7 kbZnlbZl dngb`Zl EhgZmZl) mZnmhl
lZ\^k]hl) ^m l^gbhk^l `^gmbl) ^m ork^lgb^cb) dngb`Zb bk ebdnlbhcb r*
lZ\^k]hm^l) ^m k^ebjnnl ihinenl ] mZnmZ lbngbZ [khebZfl NiZk*
Dn]Z^hknf NiZkmbZmbl_kZmkb[nl lZ* mb^bZfl lo^bdbgbf+ 4 EZn l^gZb
enm^f+ 4DZfikb]^f fbllZ^ ^kZgm [noh ZmlblmZl orkbZnlbZf dngb*
^iblmheZ^ Z] JgbZf lnffnf lZ* `nb Jgbcnb eZbdZl <kbcZnl) dnkl
\^k]hm^f Z[ <kbh) jnb k^`gZ[Zm dZkZebZoh iZl cnl) dZ] cl fl
Zin] ohl) jnhgbZf ^lmbl _kZmk^l [khebZb) dZbi iZkh]h bZ iZm ikb*
ghlmkb) lb\nm k^l\kbimnf \hgmbg^m) ]^]ZfZl gnhkZZl+ 5 JgbcZl ikb*
jnh] ln[b^\mnf ^lm+ 5 @m lnl\^* f ln iZ`Zk[Zfh`)dnkl[n*
ibm JgbZl obknf) jnb fbllnl _n* oh ZmlblmZl) bk `Zoh eZbd) dn*
^kZm) \nf ahghk^7 ^m Z\\^ibm ^ib* kbZf^ [noh dZe[ZfZ Zib^ lZg]h*
lmheZl) bg jnb[nl lb`gb_b\Z[Zmnk k bk ikb^m^erlm+ 6 Ihkl f^l gb^*
]^ lh\b^mZm^) ^m Zfb\bmbZ+ 6 Ihl) dh b mh g^ikboZehf^) g^l iZ`nh*
\nf gneeh ahknf bg]b`^k^fnl) ]Zb mnkbf^ o^gmZl dgr`Zl)^lZg*
aZ[^gm^l lheZmbh lZg\mhl eb[khl) bZl fl kZgdhl^) ~ mZbZn o^*

. / ). } 2 1 +
E h g Z m Z l  Z mg Z n cbg Z  l Z g *
] h k  ln  kh f g Z bl  bk  l i Z k mb^ bZ bl 
% . } / 0 & ) o e d Z k b Z n cZ  l n  ? ^ f ^ m k b cZ n l 
DD  o Z ] Z b l  b k  l n l m b i k b g Z  E n ] c h l  f b ^ l *
mn l  %/ 1 } 0 5 &) i Z ` Z ebZ n ) i Z l b m b d c l  Z i *
` Z n ebg ` Z bl  O k bmh g h  i Z Z ] Z bl ) i Z m^ g d Z 
c  ch  k Z g d Z l  %0 6 } 2 1 &+
% . / ). & C ^ Y w & E n  o Z k ] Z b  ^ f bZ n  .3
^ b e + O h d b  i Z l bn g m bg bn  M h f h g  Z g d l *
b Z n  l bn g m  E n ] Z l  H Z d Z [ b ^ cn l  % 5 ). +++& +
}  % / &  = H Z  Z W H Y [ PL n P\ Z & N ^ g Z  b k  ` Z k l b 
l ^ g h o c^  g ^ ] b] ^ e  m Z n m Z ) d n k b E h g Z m h 
eZ b d Z b l  g ^ ] Z n `  [ ^ m n k ch  ` Z ebh l + N i Z k *
mb^ bn l  mn k ch  Z i eZ g d r mb mb^  i Z m r l  r *
]  i Z l bn g m bg bZ b) d n k b^  ch  M h f h g +
Q s + . 3  ^ +
% 0 &  t [ H Y ^ I p ,  b M h f h l  l ^ g Z m +  } 
8 H PW  I \ ] V  Z L U P H \ &  K e ` +  5 ) / / +  }  % 1 &

@ H ] PL Z P L T Z & N ^ g Z m Z l  ] Z o  e Z b d  M h *
f h l  o Z e] bg bg d Z f l  bk  M h f h l  d eZ n l bn *
l b^ f l  Z eb  d n g b` Z bd bZ f l +
%3 &  0 Y V SP H T Z , m h l  i Z b h l  d bef l 
f h g f l +  }  % 4 &  < U PQ\ P SH Pk R H Z  / Y P %
QH \ Z &
bg h f b m k r l  r ]  o r k b Z n l b ^ cb 
d n g b` Z b o Z k ] n  J g b cZ l + E  o b^ g Z l  < mb*
] Z n l  l g n l  J g b c Z l  D  % 0 / 0 } 0 - -  f +
i b k f +  F k + &  [ n o h  o r k b Z n l b n h cn  d n g b ` n 
< k b cZ n l  D e Z b d Z b l  % 0 - 6 } / 3 2 & +
O h ] e
< k b cZ n l  e Z b d Z l  ` Z e ch  [ mb cZ f  Z m *
l b l m Z l  m Z k i  0 - 6  b k  0 - -  f ^ m + }  ; \ V %
Y H k H Z &  Q s +  . 6  ^ + }  ; PL R V  Pk  [ V ,  g ^ b 
c l  i k b ^ m ^ e r l m l )  g ^ b  l Z g ] h k h l +  J g b * 
ch  D e Z b d Z b l  r ] Z b) [ ] Z f b < b` bi mh 
d Z k Z e b Z n l  ` e h [ h c^ )  c Z n m l b  ` Z g Z  ` ^ k Z b 
b k  g ^ b^ d h ch  l Z g ] h k  l n  l o ^ mbf h f bl 
mZ n mh f bl + }  j ] L U [H Z 
R U ^ N H Z &
EZ n

Turinys

. H<F+ ./) . - */ .

516

jnb lngm bg fZgb[nl ghlmkbl) D ercZf^ lblmb iZl cnl ZmgZncbgmb
.- fZenbfnl -,44)2) Z] ohl k^gh* D [kherlml bk ikb^m^erlml) dZ]dZk*
6%2) _kZm^kgbmZm^f) ^m Zfb\bmbZf)g^ mZbl g^iZlb]Zkrmnff cnfllo^mb*
_hkm^ Zeb^gb ^__b\bZfnk Z oh[bl7 fb8 g^l ]Zn` eZbdh rkZ ikZc)
fnemZ ^gbf m^fihkZ mkZglb^kngm) dZbi cllbngmm^iZl fnl+ .. OZb*
^q jnh fblblmbl Z] ghl+ .. Ihl `b f^l oblnhf^m [^ iZebZn[hl
^k`h bg hfgb m^fihk^ lbg^ bg* bdbefb ]b^ghfbl bk dbmhfbl) dn*
m^kfbllbhg^ bg ]b^[nl lhee^fgb* kbhl^ k^bdbZ) Zmlbf^gZf^ cnl Zn*
[nl) ^m \^m^kbl) jnb[nl hihkm^m) dhl^) dnkbZl ZndhcZf^) bkZi^b`h*
f^fhk^l lnfnl o^lmkb bg lZ\kb* l^) dZbi ikb]^kZ bk ikbmbgdZ Zmlb*
_b\bbl) jnZ^ h__^kbfnl) ^m bgh[l^k* fbgmb [khebnl+ ./Oh]e f^l ]bZn*
oZmbhgb[nl) lb\nm _Zl ^lm) ^m ]^* `bZfl cl `Zk[^+ .0 Hnl `b b
\^m f^fbgbll^ _kZmknf+ ./ GZ^mZ* oblnkbmbdh]Zn` lb^eoZkm bk]Zn`
fnkbmZjn^]^ `ehkbZo^lmkZ+ .0Ihl dho) bk ^lZgmb^cb Ziebgd fnl dZ*
Znm^f \bk\nf]^]^kngm fnemZ^ mkb* kZebZb dhohch ikb^fnl+ .1 OZbZn
[neZmbhg^l) ^m fnemZ ikZ^ebZ) ^m mhl^ dhohl^ f^l g^ghkchf^ Zi*
bfin`gZo^kngm ghl k^`^l) jnb lngdbgmb cl)gdbm fl ]kZn*
lngm bg \bk\nbmn ghlmkh+ .1 Ihenb* ` bk ikb^m^eb) .2 g^l f^l mnk*
fnl ^k`h oh[bl fhe^lmb ^ll^)g^* chf^ iZ`Ze[hl b ]Zg`Znl8 f^l
jn^\^m^kbllh\bbl)^m Zfb\blghlmkbl [nohf^ b`^e[mb) hflg^ikb^*
bg abl ikZ^ebbl7 .2 aZ[nbfnl ^gbf m^ebZb+ [noh iZ^fbgmb+ .- ?Z[Zk
]^\Z^eh Znqbebnf) ^m eb[^kZmb ln* f^lbkbgdhf^<gmbhdh lg In*
fnl ghl) ^m anfbebZmb lngm bgbfb* f^gbc bk EZshgh lg <gmbiZm^kb
\bghlmkb+ .3 @e^`bfnl bmZjn^ In* bk lbngmf^ iZl MhfgnlZmgZn*
f^gbnf <gmbh\ab_bebnf)^m<gmbiZ* cbgmb l^gbZn [nonlbhl lncZbl ikb^*
mk^f DZlhgbl _bebnf) ^m fblbfnlZ] m^erlml bk ]kZn`rlml+ .4 Eb^fl
MhfZghl k^ghoZk^ \nf ^bl Zfb* f^l iZo^]f^ Zm^bmb mZbi iZm iZl
\bmbZf) ^m lh\b^mZm^f ikblmbgZf+ cnl cl iZlo^bdbgmb bk Zmb]nhmb
.4 HZg]Zobfnl bmZjn^ ^bl nm o^* cnfl fleZbd Zib^ fl [kh*
gbZgm ^mbZf Z] ohl) ^m lZenm^gm erlml ZmgZncbgbf+ .5 ?Z[Zk cl
ohl7 ^m k^]]Zgm oh[bl ^iblmheZl `^kZb iZ]Zkrlbm^) ]nh]Zfb fnfl
ghlmkZl ]^ bgghoZmbhg^ _kZm^kgb* lZoh ZmlZdrf+
mZmbl ghlmkZ^+ .5 @m gng\ [^g^_Z*
\b^mbl k^lihg]^gm^l gh[blZ] aZ^\+
.6
@m ah\ ^lm k^l\kbimnf ^ib* .6
InhkZZl eZbdh) dnk <kb*
lmheZknf) jnh] fbl^kZm JgbZ^7 cnl [noh Zmlbngml Jgbcnb) [noh
/- <kbnl) k^q NiZkmbZmZknf JgbZ^ . mhdl7 /-NiZkmb^bdZkZebnl <kbcnl
lZ\^k]hmb fZ`gh lZenm^f+ /. Dg* orkbZnlbZf dngb`nb Jgbcnb lbng*

Z g n h  eZ bd n  r ] Z b m n k ch  o ^ g mn  d g r *
`  k bg d bg  % d Z g h g &)8 d h d l  [ n o h  m Z l 
k b g d b g r l )  i Z Z b d c Z  b  /  H Z d +  / ). 0 +. 1 +
O h l  d g r ` h l  [ n o h  cb ^ f l  eZ [ Z b o ^ g *
m h l )  m b d k h l  i Z ` n h ] h l  Z e m b g b l +  }  % ''&
6 Y  R P[ V T P Z , l n [ Z m h f bl ) cZ n g Z b h  ] b^ *
g h f bl + }  / W L P N V Z L & B k + m + 7  f Z e ] h l ^ +
Q n e ` Z m h l  h ] b l 7  h [ l ^ k o Z m b h g b [ n l  m b *  c
d k b Z n b Z b  r k Z  i ^ k k Z b g m h c n  d e Z b ] Z )  K
o b ^ m h c^ 7 h [ l ^ \ k Z m bh g b[ n l + }  %. / & 7 v %  F

Z \  N H Y I L , e Z bf bg ` Z  [ d e^ +

Q bl Z b d b*
m h d  ] Z [ Z k  [ n o h  r ] n  [ d e ) c b ^  m n *
k c h  ] Z n `  l b ^ e o Z k m +  }  % . 0 &  / W SPU R 
T \ Z &&&  K e ` +  2  i ^ k l d +  }  % . 1 &  ; L U V Y s %
Q V T L  H W Z \ U R PU [ P&&&  g ^ i k Z f ^  c l 
B k Z b*
i Z ` Z e [ h l +  }  % . 3 &  ; \ T L U P Q w + ++ 
d b d b i Z l bn g mbg bn  o Z k ] Z b i Z k h ] h ) d Z ] 
c b ^  m n k ch  f h d mb ` k Z bd n  d Z e[ + E Z * 
s h g Z l  ` Z e [ n o h  m Z l ) d n k  E n ] Z l  l bn g m 
M h f h g  % 5 ). 4 & +

o + M Z m Z l )  m +  D Q +

21

Turinys

.+&

' ? 4 = % '(# ((h )&

o^gmnf ^lm bgl\kbimnkZ ]^ NiZk* bZ lo^bdbgbf+ /. <mkZlmZ ob^gZ*
mbZmbl) ^m Dn]Z^bl) jnhgbZf lngm f^ kZm^ Zib^ NiZkmb^bnl bk r*
_kZmk^l) ^m jnh] lngm ]^ `^g^k^ ]nl) dZ] cb^ ^l [khebZb bkdZ]^l
<[kZaZf+ // @m gng\ ^q jnh b <[kZhfh `bfbgl+ 2/ ?Z[Zk)
aZ^\ \h`ghobfnl)[^g^_Z\bmbll\kb* dZb f^l mZb lnbghchf^)cl `^kZb
[^gm^l gh[bl]^iZ\^o^lmkZ7/0N^] iZ]Zkrlbm^)iZkZr]Zfbfnfl Zib^
^m ghl k^l\kbilbfnl oh[bl7 K^* lZoheZbf+ /0 =^m bkf^loecnfl
\hkZ ghlmkZ ^m ihll^llbhg^l gh* kZhf^+ Hl`ronebZbbkfleh*
lmkZ^) o^lmkZ^ lngm7 ^m o^lmkZ^) [bl rkZ cl) bk clb^cb rkZ fl+
ghlmkZ^7 fZg]Zobfnl bmZjn^ aZ^\ OZb`b f^l iZo^]f^ ]nhmb cnfl
gng\bZkb oh[bl+
Zib^ mZb bgb+
/1
@m Zn]bobm DhgZmaZl jnh* /1
Onh mZkin EhgZmZl b`bk]h
gbZf k^`k^llb lngm ikbg\bi^l ?^* dZ] ?^f^mkbcZnl oZ]Zb ln`kh
f^mkbb \nf ^q^k\bmn fnemh lnikZ ln ]Zn``Znlbg`^lg^) dZbi ibkfZ)
jnZf ikbnl) in`gZk^ Z]o^klnl dZkbnhf^g^ dhohmb ikb^ c+ /2 Ebl
^nf) /2 ^m ^qbbm Z[ D^knlZe^f) ^m bch b E^knsZel bk lnmbdh cnhl
h\\nkkbm ^bl bg <fZmabm^ k^`bhg^7 <fZmb^l Zerc^) g^l g^]Zo cb^fl
ghg ^gbf ]^]^kZm ^bl liZmbnf nm eZbdh ^bmb  lZoh Ze+ /3 KZlblmb
bg`k^]^k^gmnkk^`bhg^f ^ bn l+/3@m  lmhorde oZe`Zb)ln`kh bk ikZ*
fblbm li^\neZmhk^l bg \ZlmkZ ^h* g^) dZ] cb^ gnlblmZm inemb c
knf7 ^m k^o^klb k^gng\bZo^kngm gZdbZ+ /4 NZne^b gnlbe^b]nl) EhgZ*
jnh] \hglmbmnngm lni^ko^gbk^ beebl mZl lZd lZob^lb^fl [n]mb bkg^*
gh\m^+ /4 >nf h\\b]bll^m Znm^f iZ]^]Zgm `bgde [mb ikblbk^g`n*
lhe) ikZ^\^ibm DhgZmaZl lnbl ob`b* lb^fl  dho i^k obl gZdm8 [^
eZk^) ^m ^ll^ bg Zkfbl iZkZmhlZ] mh) cbl iZlmZm lZk` Ziebgd lmh*
in`gZf mhmZgh\m^) ^mihlnbm\nl* orde+ /5 Kkb^Zb b`bk]h) dZ] Eh *
mh]^l i^k \bk\nbmnf \Zlmkhknf+ gZmZl ln lZoZblbZbl rkZ ikblbk^g*
/5 @m Zn]b^kngm Z]o^klZkbb jnh] `l dhohmb8 cb^ gnlb`Zg]h bk iZ*
iZkZmnl ^lm DhgZmaZl \nf lnbl bg [`h lZoh bk]rc^ bk n]^` n`*
[^eeh7 ^m mbfn^kngm) ^m _hkfb]Z* gbZdnknl lZoh lmhordehc^+ /6 Eh *
o^kngm bg \hk]^ lnh7 ^m Z\\^g]^* gZmZl `b bk ln cnh [nonlb^cb mZ
kngm _h\hl bg \Zlmkbl lnbl+ /6 Dh* g^iZmfbch bdb krmnb) g^l cb^ fZm
gZmaZlZnm^f) ^mjnb\nf ^h ^kZgm) ]^`Zgbnl n`gbZdnknl+ 5- EhgZmZl
ghg \h`gho^kngm nljn^ fZg^7 obchlb cnhl) [^m g^iZobch) g^l cb^
ob]^[Zgm Znm^f enfbgZkbZ Zk]^g* [noh i^kc @e^nm^kh ni+
mbZ) 0- ^m l^\nmnl^lm^hl DhgZmaZl) +
^m ghg \hfik^a^g]bm ^hl7 mkZgl* 8
b^kZgm ^gbf _enf^g @e^nma^knf+ c
% / . &  M \XaT` X eT ygX( 
F h d l [noh
m Z l  k Z m Z l ) o b l Z b  g ^ bg h f Z + F Z ]  l i Z k * 
m b ^ b Z b  [ m  [ n o  < [ k Z h f h  Z bg bZ b) g *
k Z  ch d b n  k h ] r f + 
O Z bZ n  mZ l  k Z *
m Z l  [ n o h  f Z mh f Z b mbd bg l  [ ^ g m < kb*
cZ n l  eZ bd n  l i Z k mb^ bn l ) d Z ]  cb ^  r ] n 
[ k h ebZ b+ O h d b i Z m g n h f h g  [ n o h  l n *
l b] Z k bn l b i h  < k bcZ n l  eZ b d h  bk  r ] 
e b Z n ] r c ^  % /  H Z d +  2 ) 6 & +  }  % / 0 &  D Tfh
Zlih _\T\ \e((( B Z e  m Z b  i Z m Z k e b g b l  b *
l b k ^ b d bf Z l ) d n k bn h  Z ] Z f Z  o bl h d ^ *
kbh i Z  i Z ` Z e[ Z +

% / 1 &  < X` Xge\]Th f i TW T\(((4  m b ^  i Z *


m r l ) i k b^  d n k bn h l  E h g Z mn b cZ n  m^ d h 
d h o h mb F Z ] ^ l ^ +
Q s +  . . )3 0 +++ }  % / 2 & 
9 ` Tg\Xf4  @ f Z m h )  d n k l  [ n o h  i k b ^  b Z n *
k b g l  K Z e ^ l m b g h l  l b ^ g h l +  }  % / 5 &  L {'
W X Z  hZa\T^hehf4  d n k b n h l  m n h cZ n
l e Z i b Z  i Z e b d h +  }  % 0 - &  = _Xh gXeb hc(
Q s +  . . )4 +
O Z  n i  [ n o h  l b^ g Z  mZ k i 
K ^ g b d b c h l  b k  N r k b c h l 8  b m b d k c  ` b  N r * 
k b c  E h g Z m Z l  ln  l Z o h  d Z k bn h f ^ g ^  g ^ *
g h k ch  ^ bmb+

Turinys

. HF+ ()) 0.}06

52.

0. @m ]bo^kmbm DhgZmaZl Z] "2%7


&)3 15, 6/'%.452 $%&%(%), )4

0. D m^g EhgZmZl iZlndh ikb^


ZkZ[nl) dnkb^ oZ]bghlb sZ[Z]b^*
i^k\nllbm ^hl) ^m Z\\^ibm lih* bZbl) lnfn cnhl bk iZf c
ebZ ^hknf+ 0. /0 @m bngqbm) ^m o^gbm `kh[b+ 0/ KZldnb cbl iZdbeh) Zmor*
?ZfZl\nf) ^m i^kZf[neZ[Zm /-7 dh  ?ZfZld bk ch i^k obl Zg
.)- k^`bhg^f beeZf+
dkZm+
00
Nbfhg Znm^f ^qbbm) ^mo^gbm 00
NbfhgZl `b bch bk Zmch
nljn^ Z] <l\Zehg^f) ^m Z] ikh* bdb <ldZehgnb bk bdb Zkmbf mobk*
qbfZ ikZ^lb]bZ7 ^m ]^\ebgZobm bg mhob) iZlndh  Ehi bk iZfc)
Dhii^g) ^m h\\niZobm ^Zf %01' Zn* 01 g^l cbl [noh `bk]cl) dZ] cb^
]bobm ^gbf jnh] o^ee^gm ikZ^lb* ghkZmb]nhmb mobkmho ?^f^mkbcZnl
]bnf mkZ]^k^ iZkmb[nl ?^f^mkbb& ZebgbgdZfl8 m^gZb cbl iZlmZm lZk*
^m ihlnbm b[b \nlmh]^l nm \nlmh* `r[ chl lZn`hmb+
]bk^gm ^Zf+
02
@m k^o^klnl ^lm DhgZmaZl) 02
Nn`kl EhgZmZl lnZnd
^m \hgoh\Zobm l^gbhk^l ihineb) ^m mZnmhl ork^lgbnhlbnl bk gnlblmZm
\h`bmZobm\nf ^bl Z^]b_b\Zk^ ikZ^* ln cZbl iZlmZmrmb mobkmhob En]ch*
lb]bZ bg en]Z^Z)03 ^m Z^]b_b\Zk^ c^) 03 mZblrmb lb^gZl E^knsZec^) b*
fnkhl bg e^knlZe^f) ^m ^qZemZk^ o^lmb Zndm fk mZki ibeb^l bk
Zembmn]bg^ffZ`gZfbgm^k f^]bnf fb^lmh) dZ] c Zmldbkm gnh fb^*
Zk\bl ^m \bobmZmbl) nm l^iZkZk^m^Zf lmh) dZ] cb [m iZmb ob^gZ bkdZ]
Z \bobmZm^) nm ^ll^m bilZ lbg`neZ* m^g g^[^[m `ZebfZ g^b ibkdmb&
kbm^k) ^m g^jn^ ^fZgm)g^jn^o^g* g^b iZk]nhmb+ 04 OZb`b cb^ lnlbkbg*
]Zgm+ 04 @m \hgo^g^kngm) nm Z^]b* dh lmZmrmb fb^lmh+ OnhmZkin f*
_b\Zk^gm \bobmZm^f7 ^m \^\b]bm fn* kZl) dnkl [noh ikb^ ni^ebh lZn*
knl) jnb ^kZm lni^k mhkk^gm^f Z[ em^db hg^) gn`kbnoh) bk EhgZmZl
hkmn lhebl) ^m k^iZkZobm ^nf) jnb iZlmZm c8 cbl oZ]bghlb FZi^m^mZ+
oh\Zmnk >Zia^m^maZ7 05 ^m Nbfhg 05 NbfhgZl iZlmZm <]bZ] N^_^*
Z^]b_b\Zobm <]bZ]Z bg N^ia^eZ) ^m ehc^ bk c lnlmbikbgh8cbl lmZmoZk*
fngbobm ^Zf) ^m bfihlnbm ihkmZl) mnl bk ndZbbnl+
^m l^kZl+
06 @m \nf \h`bmZll^m Okriahg
06 Onh f^mn OkbmhgZl [noh
k^`gZk^ <lbZ^) ^m Zllnf^k^ ]bZ* gnmZkl dZkZebZnmb <sbchc^) iZlbbf*
]^fZ) ^m ^qm^g]^k^ fZgnf bg mb lZn oZbgbd bk bmb^lmb kZgd
% 0 . &  E H I H K P L n P \ Z &
N i cZ f Z ) d Z ] 
mZ  mZ n m^ e  ` r o ^ g n l b g ^ mh eb g n h  ? Z *
f Z l d h ) m ^ g ) d n k  r k Z  o b ^ m Z ) + ] Z [ Z k  o Z *
] b g Z f Z  T ^ [ ] b g b + }  % 0 / &  r QV  W L Y  ] P %
Z H b,  l d e Z b ] r ] Z f Z l  ? ^ f ^ m k b c Z n l  Z e b *
g bg d n l +
% 0 0 &  @ PT V U H Z  N P &&&  N b f h g Z l  [ n o h 
< g mbh d h  i Z l d bk m Z l  o Z ] n  bmn h l ^  f b^ l *
mn h l ^ ) d n k b^  [ n o h  i Z l b l Z d  n  ? ^ *
f ^ m k b cb +  K e ` +  . . )2 6 + }  7 V W q &  O  f b ^ l *
m  cZ n  Z g d l bZ n  [ n o h  i Z f l  E h g Z *
m Z l +  Q s +  . - )4 2 +
% 0 3 &  / \ R k [ p  T v Y p &&&  < g m b h d h  @ n * 
i Z mh kbh  l Z d r f n 
E^ k n s Z e l 
l b^ g h l
] Z ebl  [ n o h  g n ` k bZ n mZ +
Eh g Z mZ l  g h kb
Z m l m Z m r m b )  d Z l  [ n o h  l n ` k b Z n m Z )  b k  e Z [ Z b D

Z n d mZ  l b^ g Z  Z ml d bk mb f b^ l m  g n h  l r * 
g  ` n eh l  i b e r c^ )  d Z ]  i Z l n g d bg mn  ` n *
eZ b f Z bl mh  ` Z o bf + }  %0 4 & = Y PL  \ W L %
S P V ,  i k b ^  F ^ ] k h g h  l e g b h +  }  8 H W L [ L [ H &
B k + > a Z _ ^ g Z m a Z +
B Z e mZ bi  o Z ] bg h l b
[ h d m Z l ) Z k  Z m l d bk Z  l b^ g h l  ] Z ebl + } 
% 0 5 &  / K P H K p  @ L M L S V Q L &  Q s +  . @ s ] k h 
/ ) 0 0 8  I ^ ^ f + 4 )0 4 +
O Z b [ n o h  l o Z k [ b
o b ^ m Z  ` b g m b  g n h  l r k  i n h eb f n  i Z c *
k bh  er ` n f Z b mZ k i  Eh i l  bk  B Z s h l +
N r k bch l 
% 0 6 &  8 H YH SPH \ [ P / _ P QV Q L & 
d Z k Z eb Z b  m n k ch  bk  < s b ch l  d Z k Z eb  o Z k *
] + K e ` +  . . ). 0 + }  6 k [ PL Z [ P Y H U R p &&&  O k b * 
_h g Z l  b  m bd k c  mk n i n mb o ebZ n  g n *
n ]  < g m b h d  Q b +  Q s +  . 0 )0 . + }  % 1 - & 
, 0 L [ Z H U p &  K e ` +  2 )0 / +

Turinys

.+(

' 3,1! '(" * & d */

<gmbh\anf k^`^f7 1- mbf^gl g^ ikb^ dZkZeb <gmbhd+ 1- =bch]Z*
_hkm^ ghg i^kfbmm^k^m ^nf DhgZ* fZl) dZ] EhgZmZl ch g^lndebn]r*
maZl) l^] in`gZk^mZ]o^klnl ^nf) m bk g^dhohm ikb^ c) cbl b^dh*
jnZ^k^[Zm \hfik^a^g]^k^ ^nf) ch ikh`hl ln`Znmb c bk nfnmb+
^m h\\b]^k^+ @m ^qnk`^gl Z[bbmbg KZdbel cbl gnch  =^mlZg+
=^malZg+
EhgZmZl bch ikb^ cc lnd^
1.
@m ^qbobm DhgZmaZl h[obZf 1.
bebb \nf jnZ]kZ`bgmZ fbeeb[nl ob* mnkbhfbl ]^bfmbfbl mdlmZgb
khknf ^e^\mhknf bg ikZ^ebnf) ^m kbgdmbgb ork c dho bk Zmch c
o^gbm =^malZg+ 1/@mob]bmOkriahg =^mlZg+ 1/ OkbmhgZl)iZfZml)dZ]
jnbZ o^gbm DhgZmaZl \nf ^q^k* EhgZmZl Zmch ln `Znlbg`Z dZkbnh*
\bmn fnemh nm ^qm^g]^k^m bg ^nf f^g^ bmb^lmb ikb^ c kZgdhl) iZ*
fZgnl) mbfnbm+ 10 @m ^q\^ibm ^nf [`h8 10 cbl ikbf c ln iZ`Zk*
\nf ahghk^) ^m\hff^g]Zobm^nf [Z) ikblmZm c oblb^fl lZoh i b ^ *
hfgb[nl Zfb\bl lnbl) ^m ]^]bm ^b m^ebZfl) ]Zo cZf ]hoZg) lZd
fng^kZ7 ^m ikZ^\^ibm ^q^k\bmb[nl lZoh dZkbnhf^g^b deZnlrmb ch dZbi
lnbl nm h[^]bk^gm ^b) lb\nm lb[b+ lZol 11 bk mZk EhgZmnb7 FZf `b
11 @m ]bqbm DhgZmaZ^7 Pm jnb] o^* mn oZk`bgZb oblnl bmnhl fhg^l)
qZlmb ngbo^klnf ihinenf) \nf dZ] mZki fn]ob^c gkZ dZkh;
[^eenf gh[bl ghg lbm; 12' @m gng\ 12 OZb`b lbld ]Z[Zkcnhl  c gZ*
k^fbmm^ ^hl bg ]hfhl lnZl7 ^eb`^ fnl) iZlbkbgd lZn g^]Zn` ork)
Znm^f mb[b obkhl iZn\hl) jnb m^* dZ] cb^ [m ln mZobf) bk ^bd ln
\nf lbgm) ^m o^gb f^\nf Kmhe^* fZgbf  Kmhe^fZb]8 Z mZn Zmb*
fZb]Zf) ^m mkZ]Zf ^Zf mb[b) ^m ]nhlbn c bk dbmZl mobkmho^l) dZ*
k^ebjnZ ikZ^lb]bZ) ^m ^q^k\bmnf)^m kbnhf^g bk oblnl k^bdZe obkb*
ngbo^klhl ikZ^ihlbmhl g^`hmbb) ^m gbgdnl bk Zilb`kl ^blbn lZn)
\hgo^klnl Z[b[h7 ikhim^k^Z ^gbf g^l mh]e Z ZmcZn+
o^gb+
13 Ebl mbdch cZf) iZ]Zk)dZbi
13 @m \k^]b]bm ^b) ^m _^\bm lb\nm
]bqbm7 ^m ]bfblbm^q^k\bmnf) ^mZ[b^* ZgZl [nohiZlZdl) bk iZe^b]h dZ*
kngm bg m^kkZf Dn]Z+ 14 M^mbgnbm kbnhf^g) dZ] cb `km  En]h
Znm^f l^\nf mkbZ fbeebZ obkhknf7 Ze+ 14 Nn lZobf cbl iZebdh mkbl
^q jnb[nl k^fblbm bg BZebeZ^Zf mdlmZgbnl ork8 b c ]n mdl*
]nh fbeebZ) fbee^ Znm^f o^g^kngm mZgbn gnlbngm  BZebeb^c) mdl*
\nf ^h+ 15 Pm Znm^fbgmkZobm Kmh* mZgmbl `b ch ln cnh+ 15 =^m dZbi
e^fZb]ZfDhgZmaZl\eZnl^kngmihk* mbd EhgZmZl ch  Kmhe^fZb])`r*
mZl \bobmZmblKmhe^f^gl^l7 ^m \hf* o^gmhcZb n]Zk fb^lmh oZkmnl bk
ik^a^g]^kngm ^nf7 ^m hfg^l) jnb ln`Zoh c) oblnl `b) dnkb^ [noh
\nf ^h bgmkZo^kZgm) `eZ]bh bgm^k* c ]kZn` ln cnh)cb^ nfn dZ*
eZobcn+
_^\^kngm+
Okb_hgZl iZlbngm dZkbnh*
16
@mfblbm Okriahg^q^k\bmnf) 16
^m ^jnbm^lbg BZebeZ^Zf) ^mbg\Zf* f^g bk kZbmZkbc  BZebeb^c bk

% 1 / &  6k [ P L Z [ P &&&  < g h m + ` k +  m + 7  % O k b _ h * 


g Z l & b mb^ l mb i kb^  cb  % E h g Z m &  k Z g *
d  [ b c h c h +  }  % 1 2 &  / [ PK \ V Z P\  Qw  PY  R P% 
\ PZ &&&  E Z n  ? ^ f ^ m k b cn l  D  [ n o h  i Z Z ] ^ * 
c l  E h g Z m n b  K m h e ^ f Z b ]  %i e` + . - )0 6 & +

]

F bmh l  bZ  f bg bf h l  m o bk mh o l  [ n o h  h k b^
 O Z k i ^ f l  c k h l  b d b  E h i ^ b +
.
% 1 6 &  2 P K L Sq  S ^ N \ T p , 
@ s ] k^ eh g h
8 l e g +  }  = H S ^ K V ] p ,  mn  / - - - ) d n k b n h l
b E h g Z m Z l  [ n o h  i Z e b d l  B Z e b e b ^ c h c ^ +  }

Turinys

# 3,2! #$ '">#% %

520

inf fZ`gnf nm i^k]^k^gm hf* 8 ]b]^e er`nf bn]rmb obl Eh*

8E==9/9=698,43,0! 2-<m 4)4\nf $ 8,>9 :,6B/9@F! 2- =^m cb^) `Zo


.9289@4==08> jnbZ \hfik^a^glnl c bgb) dZ] EhgZmZlln`ZnmZl bkdZ]

^lm DhgZmaZl) ^m i^kbbm) ^m hfg^l) c cbl bk oblb ln cnh [nonlb^cb noh)
jnb \nf ^h ^kZgm) ahkmZmb lngm D iZ]klbgh ob^gb dbmnl bkbchikb*
l^f^mbilhl) ^m ^qb^kngm iZkZmb bg  lbk^g`  dho+ 2. Ob^) dnkb^cnhl
ikZ^ebnf+ 2-'3. \ _  ob]^gm^l ab) jnb c obchlb) iZfZm) dZ] cb^ ghkb dhohmb
bgl^\nmb _n^kZgm) jnbZ ikh ZgbfZ b ]elZoh`ror[l) ln`kh+ 2/OZbi
k^l ^lm beebl) k^o^klb lngm7 3/ beeb c cb^ oblb iZkch kZfbZb  En]h Ze+
Znm^f o^g^kngm hfg^l \nf iZ* Q Eb^ eZ[Zb kZn]hchEhgZmh bk m)dn*
\^ bg m^kkZf En]Z+ @m ieZgq^kngm c kb^ ln cnh [noh) bk DskZ^ebl`^]*
DhgZmaZg) ^m ^hl) jnb \nf bilh c ch ]b]^ebn `^]nen)
_n^kZgm) oZe]^7 ^m enqbm DlkZ^e en* .
\mn fZ`gh+
L
20
@m jnZ^lb^kngm hfg^l`^g* b
20 Qblhl mZnmhl) [nonlbhl Zi
m^l) jnZ^ ^kZgm bg \bk\nbmn ^hknf) c ebgd cnhl) mrdhch lngZbdbgmb c)
\hgm^k^k^ ^hl+ ]bq^kngm ^gbf7 D g^l cb^ lZd7 21 Eb^ g^mnkb dngb*
21 IhgaZ[^gm ikbg\bi^f) ^m Z]bn* . `Zbdbh bk iZ]cch) mZb`b ]Z[Zk
oZgm^f7 gng\ ^k`h ^qin`g^fnl c  dhohdbf^ ikb^ cnhl bk b]be]rdb*
beehl) ^m mheeZfnl ]^ ahfbgb[nl ) f^ b fhgb mZkih c Zmlbfbgb*
f^fhkbZf ^hknf+
7 f+

)% DTXZYZ OL]MLT# L! DTXZYL^ []LOPOLaLOZaL`_T_L`_LT%


6L[`_ H;;;% . @m Zn]bobm Nb*
') [P]^Vb]TXL^% . Onh mZk*
fhg jnh] \hg`k^`Zobm Okriahg in NbfhgZl b`bk]h) ch `  Okbmh*
^q^k\bmnf \hibhlnf nm o^gbk^m gZl lnkbgdh `Znlbg` dZkbnhf^*
bg m^kkZf Dn]Z) ^m Zmm^k^k^m ^Zf+ g) dZ] ^bm  En]h Ze bk cgZb*
/
Qb]^gl jnbZ bg mk^fhk^ ih*
dbgm+
inenl ^lm) ^m bg mbfhk^) Zl\^g]bm
/ HZmr]ZfZl) dZ] mZnmZ [noh
e^knlZe^f) ^m \hg`k^`Zobm ihin* ZibfmZ b`lbh bk [Zbfl) cbl iZ*
enf7 0 ^m Z]ahkmZgl ]bqbm7 Qhl l\b* dbeh  E^knsZe bk lnkbgdh mZnm+
mbl jnZgmZ ^`h) ^m _kZmk^l f^b)^m 0 ?klbg]ZfZl c cbllZd7 El b*
]hfnl iZmkbl f^b _^\bfnl ikh ghm^) dhdbZl ]b]^e^l dhoZl dhoh*
e^`b[nl) ^m ikh lZg\mblikZ^ebZ) ^m b cZf^ Z) fZgh [khebZb bk fZgh
% 2 - &  8 H K  QPZ  m \ ] V & 
O Z  bg bZ  [ n o h
g ^ mbd k Z ) g ^ l  E h g Z m Z l  ] Z k  g ^ [ n o h  n *
f n m Z l +  K e ` +  . 0 ). / +. 2 +
%2 1 & = H K s Q s Q V , mZ ed bg bg d h + < [ n ] n )
O k b m h g Z l  b k  ? ^ f ^ m k b cn l )  d n k b ^  ] Z [ Z k
o Z k l b  ] e N r k b c h l  l h l m h ) [ n o h  r *
] Z f l  g ^ i Z eZ g d n l +
. 0 ). } . 1 )1 6 + N b f h g Z l )  l m h c l  l Z o h
[ k h ebh  o b^ mh g ) o ^ emn b f ` bg Z  bb b o Z *
] n h m b + E h g Z m Z l  n f n Z f Z l  ] k Z n l  l n
l Z o h  l g n f bl  %. 0 ). } / 1 & +
N bf h g Z l
i Z l m Z mh  n o n l bZ f  Eh g Z mn b i Z f bg d e
%/ 2 } 0 - &+
E b l  l m h cZ  ? ^ f ^ m k b cZ n l  bb

i n l g  %0 . } 1 - & ) i Z bf Z  B Z s  [ ^ b E ^ *
k n s Z e l  i beb b k  i Z l d bk b Z  l Z o h  l g 
E h g  d Z k bn h f ^ g l  o Z ] n  %1 . } 2 1 &+ ? ^ *
f ^ m k b cn b  D D  i Z m ^ d n l  b i Z k m  g ^ e Z b l o ) 
r ] Z b  ` r o ^ g Z  k Z f r [ c ^  % . 1 ).  }  . 2 & +
N bf h g Z l  Z mg Z n cbg Z  l Z g ] h k  ln  l i Z k *
mb^ bZ bl  bk  k h f g Z bl  %. 3 } / 1 Z & ) r ] n 
` b mZ n mZ  o b^ n  ] h d n f ^ g mn  i Z l d ^ e[ bZ 
N bf h g h  bk  d bmn  H Z d Z [ b^ cn  g n h i ^ eg n l 
mZ n mZ b %/ 1 [ } 1 6 &+
% . 0 ) / &  / W PT [ H  P k N p Z n P V &&& 
Eh g Z mh 
l n ` Z o bf Z l  [ n o h  ] b] ^ ebl  l f ` bl  o bl Z b
D m Z n m Z b 8  c h  g ^ m ^ d n l )  m Z n m Z  ` Z e c h  l n l b *

Turinys

521

. H<F+ .0) 1} .2

Zg`nlmbZl jnZe^l ob]bfnl7 1 ah* moh gZfZb ]e lmZmrf bk ]e
knf `kZmbZ i^kb^kngm _kZmk^l f^b o^gmrdehl bk dhdb fZmf^ ln*
hfg^l ikhim^k DlkZ^e) ^m k^eb\mnl liZn]bf+ 1 ?e mhnoh oblb fZ*
lnf^`h lhenl+ 2 @mgng\ ghg fb* gh [khebZb n DskZ^e) bk ebdZn Z
ab \hgmbg`Zm iZk\^k^ ZgbfZ^f^Z^ ob^gZl+ 3 Dk ]Z[Zk lZn`hd) ?b^o^)
bghfgbm^fihk^mkb[neZmbhgbl7 ghg dZ] Z `ZbebZnl lZoh `ror[l
^gbf f^ebhk lnf _kZmkb[nl f^bl+ obl bm lb^eoZkmh$ eZbd g^l Z
0  Qbg]b\Z[h
bmZjn^ `^gm^f f^* g^`^k^lgbl n lZoh [khebnl+ 3OZb*
Zf) ^m lZg\mZ gZmhl jnhjn^ gh* `b Z d^krlbn n lZoh mZnm bk
lmkhl) ^m nqhk^l7 jnbZ \hg`k^`Z* o^gmrde) mZbi iZm n fl oZb*
mZ^ lngm ngbo^klZ^ `^gm^l \hgm^* dnl bk iZbZl) g^l oblhl mZnmhl
k^k^ ghl bgbfb\bmbZ^ `kZmbZ+ 4@m lnlbkbgdh lnmkbgmb fl) oZ]nh*
Z\\^glnl ^lm libkbmnl ihineb lb* ]Zfb^l g^ikb^m^erlm^+ 4 OZnmhl
fne nm Zn]bobm l^kfhg^l blmhl7 ]oZlbZ nlb]^`) dZbi mbdcb b`bk*
5 ^m k^lihg]^kngm oh\^ fZ`gZ]b* ]h bmnhl h]bnl) 5 bk cb^ ZmlZ*
\^gm^l7 On ^l]nqghlm^k eh\h Dn* d `Zklbn [Zeln) mZk]Zfb7 On f*
]Z^) ^m DhgZmaZ^ _kZmkbl mnb7 6.-' in* l oZ]Zl En]h bk lZoh [khebhEh*
`gZ ikZ^ebnf ghlmknf7 ^m hfgbZ) gZmh ob^mhc^8 6 dhohd fl dho)
jnZ^\nfjn^ ]bq^kbl gh[bl) _Z\b^* h f^l ]Zkrlbf^ oblZ) d mbd mn
fnl+
fnfl lZdrlb+
.-
@m \hg`k^`Zgl hfg^l ob* .-
Onhf^m kbgd]ZfZl oblnl
khl [^eeZmhk^l)Z\\^e^kZobm\hglnf* orknl dhohmhcnl) cbl iZlbldn[bgh
fZk^ ngbo^klhl fnkhl e^knlZe^f) [Zb`mb oblZl E^knsZel lb^gZl bk
^m fngbobm ^Zf bg `rkh+ .. @m fb* lnlmbikbgh c Ziebgdnb+ .. Kh mh
lbm ehgZmaZg _beebnf <[lZehfb ^m cbl lbngm <[lZehfbh lg EhgZ*
\nf ^h ^q^k\bmnf ghonfbg Dhi* m bk ln cnh gZnchl dZkbnhf^gl
i^g) ^m ^b^\mbl abl) jnb ^kZgm bg  Ehi) dnkl) boZkl chl `ro^g*
mhcnl) iZml m^gZb iZlbebdh+
^Z) k^fZglbm beeb\ bil^+
./
@m fhobm Okriahg Z Kmhe^* ./
Onh mZkin OkbmhgZl bch
fZb]Z \nf ^q^k\bmnfnemh) nmo^* ln ]b]^e^ dZkbnhf^g^ b Kmhe^*
gbk^m bg m^kkZf Dn]Z) ^m DhgZmaZl fZb]hl) dZ] ^bm  En]hZe+ =n*
\nf ^h bg\nlmh]bZ+ .0Nbfhg Zn* oh ln cnh bk EhgZmZl dZbi dZeb*
m^fZiieb\nbm bg <]]nl \hgmkZ _Z* grl+ .0 NbfhgZl lnlmhch <]]nl^
\b^f \Zfib+ .1 @m nm \h`ghobm mb^l er`nfZ+ .1 FZbi mbd Okb_hgZl
Okriahg jnbZ lnkk^qbm Nbfhg eh* iZmrk) dZ] lZoh [khebh EhgZmh
\h _kZmkbl lnb bhgZmaZ^7 ^m jnbZ ob^mhc^ iZdbeh NbfhgZl bk k^g`bZ*
\hffbllnknl ^ll^m \nf ^hikZ^* lb dhohmb ikb^ c) cbl lbngm iZl
ebnf) fblbm Z]^nfe^`Zmhl) .2]b* c iZlbngmbgb) .0 dZ] lZdrm7 ?e
e Z n d m b  ] b ] ^ e b  g ^ e Z b f b ) m h ] e  b b  [ b *
c h c h  O k b m h g h +  y}  % 1 &  C \^ T h  T y  i \Xa T f(((
N bf h g Z l ) d Z bi  bk  d bm b r ] Z b) f Z g )
d Z ]  l n ` Z n mZ l  E h g Z m Z l  [ n o h  cZ n  g n *
n ] r m Z l +  }  % 5 &  K h  ` f  i T W T f (((  O n h
i Z bn  N bf h g Z l  [ n o h  mZ n mh l  l n l bk bg *
d b f h  i k b i Z b g m Z l  b k  o r k b Z n l b n h cn  d n *
g b ` n  % i e ` +  . 0 )0 3  b k  . 1 ) 0 2 & +
% . - &  : T \Z g\ i \f T f (((  K e ` +  . / )0 3 + }
% ## &  9 U T f T _b ` \b  fa(  Q b ^ g Z l  < [ Z *
l Z e h f b h  l g n l  r k Z  i Z f b g m Z l  . . )4 - +

E h g Z m Z l  ` Z e [ n o h  Z g m k Z l  mh  i Z mb^ l 
B r*
< [ l Z e h f b h  l g n l + }  @y i T e f ((( 
o ^ g n l bZ bl  E h i c^  i Z ` h g bf bl  g ^ [ n o h 
` Z ebf Z  i Z l bmbd mb) mh ] e cb ^  o bl Z b b o Z *
k h f b  b  f b ^ l m h  b k  c  o b ^ m h c ^  Z i ` r o ^ g *
] bg Z f b r ] Z b+
% . / &  B T _\a l f 4  m h ] e  ] Z k  m ^ [ ^ [ n o h 
` r o Z l  % i e ` +  . / )2 - & + }  % . 0 &  9 W W h fX(
B k +  m + 7  < ] b ] Z ) m Z  i Z m b  o b ^ m Z )  d Z b i  b k 
. / )0 5 + }  % . 2 &  < _ c\a \Z ((( 
Eh g Z mZ l 
D [ n o h  Z i l b f l  f h d m b  d Z b  d n k b n h l

Turinys

. H<F+ .0) . 3 */ 1

522

\^kbl7 Kkh Zk`^gmh) jnh] ]^[^[Zm


_kZm^k mnnl ehgZmaZl bg N PFLKD NDX
`bl) ikhim^k g^`hmbZ) jnZ^ aZ[nbm)
]^mbgnbfnl ^nf+ .3@m gng\ fbm*
m^ Zk`^gmb mZe^gmZ \^gmnf)^m]nhl
_bebhl ^bnl h[lb]^l)nm ghg ]bfbl*
lnl _n`bZm Z gh[bl) ^m k^fbmm^*
fnl ^nf+ .4 @m \h`ghobm Nbfhg
jnbZ \nf ]hehehjn^k^mnk l^\nf)
bnllbm mZf^g ]ZkbZk`^gmnf)^min*
^khl7 g^ bgbfb\bmbZf fZ`gZf ln*
f^k^m Z] ihinenf DlkZ^e) ]b\^g*
m^f7 .5 LnbZ ghg fblbm ^b Zk`^g*
mnf) ^m in^khl) ikhim^k^Z i^kbbm+
.6 @m fblbm in^khl) ^m \^gmnf mZ*
e^gmZ7 ^m f^gmbmnl ^lm) ^m ghg ]b*
fblbm ehgZmaZg+

ibgb`) dnkbnhl mZoh [khebl EhgZ*


P O [noh ldhebg`Zl dZkZebZnl b*
]nb) ]e k^bdZe) dnkbnhl cbl mnk*
ch) f^l lneZbdf^ c+ )3 <mlbld
]Z[Zk bfm mZe^gm lb]Z[kh bk ]n
ch lg dZbmZbl)dZ] iZe^blmZl g^*
iZ[`m gnh fl) bk f^l `k*
bglbf^ c+ .4 NbfhgZl lnikZmh)
dZ] cbl cZf dZe[Z Zi`Znebg`Zb)
mZbZn eb^i ]nhmb lb]Z[kh bk oZb*
dnl) dZ] g^gnlbi^egrm lZn ]b*
]^el g^ZirdZgmhl b DskZ^ebhmZn*
mhlinll)dnkb[m lZdbnlb7 .5FZ*
]Zg`b g^lbngm cZf ibgb`bkoZb*
d) mh]e cbl noh+ .6 OZb`b cblb*
lbngm oZbdnl bk bfmmZe^gm8[^m
OkbmhgZl g^lbeZbd h]bh bk g^*
iZe^b]h EhgZmh+
Kh mh Okb_hgZl Zmch  Ze
/-
@m ihlm aZ^\ o^gbmOkriahg /-
bgmkZ k^`bhg^f)nm \hgm^k^k^m^Zf7 chl gZbdbgmb+ Eb^chZiebgdbgbn d^*
^m `rkZo^kngm i^kobZf) jnZ^ ]n* ebn) dnkbnh ^bgZfZ  <]hk8 mZbi
\bm <]hk7 ^mNbfhg)^m \ZlmkZ ^bnl iZm NbfhgZlln lZoh dZkbnhf^g^
Zf[neZ[Zgm bghfg^feh\nfjnh* ch oblZlob^mZl) dnk mbdZgb^ ch+
\nfjn^ b[Zgm+ /. Lnb Znm^f bg /. =nonlb^cb iberc^ lbngm iZl Okb*
Zk\^ ^kZgm) fbl^kngm Z] Okriah* _hg iZlbngmbgb) dZ] iZlbldn[bg*
g^f e^`Zmhl) nm _^lmbgZk^m o^gbk^ m Zm^bmb i^k mrknf bk Zmlblm
i^k ]^l^kmnf) ^m fbmm^k^m beebl Zeb* cb^fl fZblmh+ //Okb_hgZl ikbk^g*
fhgbZl+ // @m iZkZobm Okriahg ` obl kZbmZkbc) dZ] Zm^bm miZ*
hfg^f ^jnbmZmnf) nm o^gbk^m beeZ b gZdm8 [^m [noh eZ[Zb ]Zn`
gh\m^7 ^kZm Znm^f gbq fnemZ oZe* lgb^`h) bk cb^ g^Zmch  JZeZZ]h
]^) ^m ghg o^gbm bg JZeZZ]bmbf+ Ze+ /0 KkblbZkmbgl ikb^=ZldZfZ*
/0 @m \nf ZiikhibgjnZll^m =Zl* gh) cbl nfn m^gZb EhgZm bkch
\ZfZg) h\\b]bm ehgZmaZg) ^m _bebhl lgnl+ /1 Kh mh Okb_hgZl Zilb`k*
^bnl beeb\+ /1 @m \hgo^kmbm Okriahg)  bk gnch lZoh Ze+
^m Z[bbm bg m^kkZf lnZf+

f h d ^ l bn l  ? ^ f ^ m k b cn b 8 d Z b b m Z l  [ n *
o h  i Z Z e b g m Z l )  c b l  g ^ [ ^ ` Z e ch  m Z b  i Z *
] Z k r mb+
= ^ m  O k b _ h g Z l  b Z  g Z n ] h cZ l b
f ^ e n ) d Z ]  i Z m ^ b l b g m  l Z o h  i Z l b ^ e ` b *
f + O b d k Z  E h g Z m h  l n f b f h  i k b ^ Z l m b l 
g n k h ] r m Z  . / )1 - + }  % . 4 &  B h e \ U g  f T '
^ \h f \(((  E ^ b  N b f h g Z l  [ m  Z m l b l Z d l 
i Z m^ g d bg mb O k bmh g h  k ^ bd Z eZ o bf ) r ] 
mZ n m Z  [ m  ` Z e cn l b d Z em bg mb N bf h g )
[ d  cb l  g h k l  i Z l bg Z n ] h mb l Z o h  [ kh ebh 
g ^ eZ bf ^ ) d Z ]  ` Z e m  i Z bf mb ch  o b^ m +
% / - &  , 9 W b e (  H b ^ l m ^ e b l  i k b ^  E n *
] c h l  i b ^ m  l b ^ g h l +  Q s +  /  F k h g +  . . )6 +
 ,  i \ f T f  i \ X g T f (((  N b f h g Z l  f Z m h *

f Z b g h k ch  g ^ e^ bl mb O k bmh g n b l bo ^ k mb


 E n ] c h l  l b ^ g Z l +  O k b _ h g Z l )  d Z b i  l ^ *
g bZ n  d b m b  l r k  o Z ] Z b %1 )1 6  b k  3 )0 . &)
[ Z g ] h  i Z l b^ d mb E n ] c  b  D ] n f ch l +} 
%/ . & : h i h f \X ]\ c \_l ]X 4 cb ^  bZ  [ n o h 
Z i l n i mb %. / )0 3 &+ }  G X e  g l e h ` 4 i ^ k 
O ^ d n h l  mr k n f ) mZ k i  E^ k n s Z e l  bk 
H b k m b ^ l  c k h l  % /  F k h g +  / - ) / - & +  }  % / / & 
@ e  ] \ f  a X T g ] b ' (  B k + m + 7  c b l  g ^ Z m ch 
%  E ^ k n s Z e & )  [ ^ m  i Z d b e h  b k  Z m o r d h  
B Z eZ Z ] h  Z e+ }  O Z bi  O k bmh g Z l  b l b*
Z ] ch  l Z o h  l n f Z g r f h  i n em b E ^ k n *
s Z e + }  %/ 0 & G e \X  : T f ^ T ` T a b 4 B Z eZ *
Z ] h  Z e r c ^ +  }  A b a T g  \ e ((( 
B k + m +7

Turinys

52

. H<F+ .0) /2}01

/2
@m fblbm Nbfhg) ^m Z\\^ibm /2
Onhf^m NbfhgZl gnlbngml*
hllZ DhgZmaZ^ _kZmkbl lnb) ^m l^* iZf lZoh [khebh EhgZmh dZnenl
i^ebobm)^Z bg Hh]bg \bobmZm^ iZ* bk iZeZb]hch cnhl ch mo fb^lm^
mknf ^bnl+ /3 @m ieZgq^kngm ^nf Hh]bg^+ /3QblZl DskZ^ebl kZn]hch
hfgbl DlkZ^e ieZg\mn fZ`gh) ^m ch ]b]^ebn kZn]hcbfn bk `^]chch
enq^kngm ^nf ]b^l fnemhl+
]Zn`^eb ]b^g+
NbfhgZl iZlmZm Zgm lZoh
/4
@m Z^]b_b\Zobm Nbfhg lni^k /4
l^ine\aknf iZmkbl lnb ^m _kZmknf moh bk lZoh [kheb dZih b mheh
lnhknf Z^]b_b\bnf Zemnf obln)DZ* fZmhf Zndm iZlmZm b iergh
ib]^ i\bbmh k^mkh ^m Zgm^7 /5 @m Zdf^gl niZdZerc^ bk ikb^Zdrc^++
lmZmnbm l^im^f irkZfb]Zl) ngZf /5 =^ mh) cbl iZlmZm l^imrgbZl ib*
\hgmkZ ngZf iZmkb ^m fZmkb) ^m kZfb]^l ob^g mb^l dbmZ lZoh m*
jnZmmnhk_kZmkb[nl /6^m abl\bk\nf* onb)fhmbgZb bk d^mnkb^fl [khebZfl+
ihlnbm \henfgZl fZ`gZl7 ^m ln* /6<iebgd cZl cbl iZlmZm ]b]^eb
i^k \henfgZlZkfZ) Z] f^fhkbZf ne) h Zgm ne iZ]ch `bgde
Z^m^kgZf7 ^m bnqmZ ZkfZ gZo^l ZfbgZb ZmfbgbZb)`k^mZ`bgde[n*
l\neimZl) jnZ^ ob]^k^gmnk Z[hf* oh kZbrm eZbo) dZ] cb^[mfZ*
gb[nl gZob`Zgmb[nl fZk^+ 0- Ch\ mhfb oblb^fl) dnkb^ ieZndbZ ckZ+
^lm l^ine\aknf) jnh] _^\bm bgH h* 0- OZl dZih iZfbgdeZl) dnk cbl
]bg) nljn^ bg ang\ ]b^f+
iZlmZmHh]bg^)rkZ bdb bZb ]b^gZb+
0. Okriahg Znm^f \nf bm^k
0.
OkbmhgZl) []ZfZld^ebhgc^
_Z\^k^m \nf <gmbh\ah k^`^ Z]h* ln cZngn dZkZebnfb <gmbhdn) deZ*
e^l\^gm^) ]heh h\\b]bm ^nf+ 0/ @m lmbg`Zb nfn cc+ 0/ Ebl f dZ*
k^`gZobm eh\h ^bnl) ^m bfihlnbm kZebZnmb ch  ob^mhc^ bk nlb]ch lZn
lb[b ]bZ]^fZ <lbZ^) ^m _^\bm ieZ* <sbchl oZbgbd) bk cbliZ]Zk ]Zn`
`Zf fZ`gZf bg m^kkZ+
ibdmZ Zerc^+
00 Onh mZkin NbfhgZl ZmlmZm
00 @m Z^]b_b\Zobm NbfhgikZ^lb*
]bZ Dn]Z^Z^) fngb^gl ^Z mnkkb[nl En]chl mobkmho^l) lnlmbikbg]ZfZl
^q\^elbl) ^m fnkbl fZ`gbl) ^m ihk* cZl ZndmZbl [hdmZbl) ]b]^efbl
mbl) ^m l^kbl7 ^m ihlnbm Zebf^gmZ lb^ghfbl) oZkmZbl bk ndZbbZbl|
bk Zm`Z[^gh  mobkmho^l fZblmh+
bg fngbmbhgb[nl+
01 NbfhgZl bkbgdh mZbi iZm
01 @m ^e^`bm Nbfhg obkhl) ^m
fblbm Z] ?^f^mkbnf k^`^fnm_Z*  fhgb bk lbngm cnhl iZl dZkZ*
b g h k l  b  m b d k c  c b l  o r d h  r f b Z b  o *
E h g Z m ) bk  cb l  [ n o h  m^ g  i Z eZ b] h mZ l +
e b Z n ) [ m ^ g m )  d Z b  ? ^ f ^ m k b c n l  [ n o h  i k Z *
% / 2 &  D b W \a X ( M m (  . )4 - +
] c l  l Z o h  r `  i k b ^  f ^ ] n l  % . 1 ) . ++ +& + 
% / 5 &  J X c g l a \ T f (((  N ^ i m b g m c  [ n o h 
i Z l d r k l  i Z m l  l Z n +  }  % / 6 &  C T \i &
< g h m O b m h  G b o b cZ n l ) O k b m h g Z l  l Z d l )
^ T W (((  G Z b o  Z m o Z b s ] Z b  m n k c h  i k b f b g m b 
` r ] r m h cn b  i Z ] Z k r m b  ] ^ bf m b^ l  f ^ m 
< g mbh d n b Z bs ] h l  h i ^ k Z \ b c )  mZ bi ) d Z ] 
n d Z k bZ o bf  Eh i l ) b  d n k bh l  r ] Z f l 
[ n o h  Z m o b k Z l  d ^ e b Z l  b c k  % i e ` +  . / ) 0 0 & + 
o Z b d Z l  m n k c h  f b k m b +  }  % 0 / &  9 m \ ]b f 
i T \a \^ (  K e ` +  5 )3 + }  < T h Z  c \ ^ g T 4  l Z *
H h ] bg h  f b^ l m^ ebl  ` Z g Z  m h eb g n h  cn *
o h  b mo bk d bf n  bk  g n h eZ mbg f bl  d h o h *
k h l 8 ] b] ^ ebl  cZ f ^  i Z l m Z m r m Z l  i Z f bg *
f bl ) r i Z  i k b^  [ n o n l bh  d Z k Z ebZ n l )
d e Z l  ` Z e ch  [ mb b^ d  mb^ d  f Z mh f Z l 
Z ebg bg d n l +
i eZ n d bZ g m b^ f l  c k Z ) [ ^ m g ^  ch  l f n ed *
%0 1 & G T f  ^ T e T _\  < X ` X g e \] 4 d n k l )
f ^ g h l + }  % 0 - &  @ ^ \  y \ T \  W \ X a T \ 4  b d b 
O k bmh g n b l b` Z e cn l  < g mbh d bch c^ ) [ n o h 
m Z f  f ^ m n b ) d n k b n h  [ n o h  i Z k Z r m Z  .
i Z l b m k Z n d l  b o Z e l m r [ l  i Z l b ^ g )  ` Z e  
H Z d + d g r ` Z +
k r m  i k h o b g \ b cZ l + }  G _ y \^ T i \` T \( O k b *
% 0 . &  L { ` h y  ?((( N k r r c ^  l n  E h *
mh g Z l  [ n o h  o bl n  i bk f Z  g ^ m^ bl mZ b i Z *
g Z mh  g n n ] r f n  bZ  i Z m f bg bf Z l  bk 
l bl Z o bg l  N r k b ch l  l h l m 8 mh ] e N bf h *
cZ n g h  d Z k Z e b Z n l  < g m b h d h  g n n ] r f Z l )

Turinys

. H<F* .0) 02}10

524

BDBDP k^fbllbhg^f k^`bhgb7 jnbZ eb ?^kg^mkbc) dZ] cbl lnm^bdm


BPQO hfg^l Okriahgbl i^k ]bk^i* e^g`oZm ZebZb) g^l oblb Okb_hgh

mbhg^f _n^kZgm `^lmb+ 02 @m ?^*


f^mkbnl k^q Z] o^k[Z blmZ k^lihg*
]bm ^b) ^m l\kbilbm^iblmheZf mZe^f7
03 M@R ?^f^mkbnl Nbfhgb lnf*
fh lZ\^k]hmb) ^m Zfb\h k^`nf) ^m
l^gbhkb[nl) ^m B^gmb Dn]Z^hknf
lZenm^f+ 04 >hkhgZf Znk^Zf) ^m
[Za^f) jnZf fblblmbl) lnl\^ib*
fnl7 ^m iZkZmb lnfnl _Z\^k^ oh*
[bl\nf iZ\^f fZ`gZf) ^m l\kb*
[^k^ ikZ^ihlbmbl k^`bl k^fbmm^k^
oh[bl jnZ^ bg]nelbfnl+ 05 LnZ^*
\nfjn^ ^gbf \hglmbmnbfnl) oh*
[bl \hglmZgm+ Hngbmbhg^l) jnZl
Z^]b_b\Zlmbl) oh[bl lbg m+06 M^fbmmb*
fnl jnhjn^ b`ghkZgmbZl) ^m i^\*
\ZmZ nljn^ bg ah]b^kgnf ]b^f)
^m \hkhgZf) jnZf ]^[^[Zmbl7 ^m
lbjnb] Zebn] ^kZm mkb[nmZkbnf bg
e^knlZe^f)bZfghg lbmmkb[nmZkbnf+
1- @m lb jnb ^q oh[bl Zimb lngm
\hgl\kb[b bgm^k ghlmkhl) \hgl\kb*
[Zgmnk) ^m lbm bgm^k ghl iZq+
1. <ggh \^gm^lbfh l^imnZ`^*
lbfh Z[eZmnf ^lm bn`nf B^gmbnf
Z[ DlkZ^e+ 1/ @m \h^ibm ihinenl
DlkZ^e l\kb[^k^ bg mZ[nebl) ^m `^l*
mbl in[eb\bl) Zggh ikbfh ln[ Nb*
fhg^ lnffh lZ\^k]hm^) fZ`gh
]n\^) ^m ikbg\bi^ Dn]Z^hknf+
10 Dg ]b^[nl beebl Ziieb\nbm Nb*
fhg Z] BZsZf) ^m \bk\nf]^]bm
^Zf \Zlmkbl) ^m _^\bm fZ\abgZl) ^m

g Z l  g h k b  l n l b ] m b  l n  ? ^ f ^ m k b cn f b ) 
i k b ^  d n k  Z g d l b Z n  d h o h c h  % i e ` + e m )
3 0 ++ +& + E b l  i k Z h Y  c  i Z m o bk m bg m b Z g d l *
bZ n  l n m^ bd mZ l  E n ] cZ b e^ g ` o Z mZ l  % e m )
/ 5 + +  + & +  }  % 0 2 &  < X ` X g e \ ] h f  T g f T ^ ( ((  ? ^ *
f ^ m k bcn l  i Z l bl d n [ bg h  i Z m ^ g d bg m b N b *
f h g h  i k Z r f ) g ^ l  ] Z [ Z k  l cn g ` b*
g b g d Z l  [ n o h  cZ f  e Z [ Z b  k ^ b d Z e b g ` Z l +  } 
% 0 3 &  G e \ X g X _ \ h \ (  K e ` +  . - ) . 3 +. 6 + 4 2 8  . . )/ 4 
b k  d + }  % 0 4 &  G T _ ` X 4  ] Z b e b Z b  b  Z n d l h 
i Z ] Z k r m  i Z e f l  Z d +  K e ` +  / H Z d + 
. 1 )1 + }  G \_a h 4  i Z l m h o b +

o^bdlfZb[noh iebdZobfZb+02FZ*
kZebnl ?^f^mkbcnlZmlZd cZfmnhl
h]bnl bk iZkZmhdeZbd703FZ*
kZebnl ?^f^mkbcnl orkbZnlbZf dn*
gb`nb bk dZkZeb ikb^m^ebnb Nbfh*
gnb) ork^lgb^lb^fl bk r] mZnmZb
lbngbZlo^bdbgbf+ 04 <ndlbgoZb*
gbd bk iZef) dnkb cl lbngmm^)
f^l `Zohf^8 f^l ^lZf^ iZlbkr*
 iZ]Zkrmb ln cnfbl ibeg mZbd
bk iZkZrmb dZkZebZnl obkbgbgdZfl)
dZ] iZ]Zkrmcnfl e^g`oZmZl) dn*
kbZl f^l lnm^bdf^+ 05 I^l oblZ)
d f^l gnmZkf^) iZlbeb^dZ cnfl
`Zebhc^8mobkmhol) dnkbZl iZlmZmm^)
m^[gb^ cnfl+ 06 H^l Zme^b]bZf^
mZbi iZm gnlb^g`bfnl bk gnlbdZe*
mbfnl bdb bZb ]b^gZb) bk oZbgbd)
dnk cl mnkchm^ ]nhmb8 bk c^b ]Zk
dZl dbmZ [noh Zi]mZ fhd^lbZbl
E^knsZec^) m^`ne cZn g^[gZ eZb*
dhfZ Zi]mZ+ 1- c^b dZb dnkb^ c*
l mbgdZ [mb ikbbfmZbl Q fl
dZkbnhf^g)m^[gb^ ikbbfmb) bk m^*
[gZ mZki fl mZbdZ+
1.
bfmZl l^imrgbZl ]^bfmZbl
f^mZbl iZ`hgb cng`Zl[noh gn*
bfmZl gnh DskZ^ebh+ 1/DskZ^ebh mZn*
mZ ikZ]ch kZrmb e^gmhl^ bk ob^*
nhl^ kZmnhl^7 KbkfZbl orkbZn*
lbhch dngb`h)]b]bhch oZ]hbk r*
] dngb`Zbdbh Nbfhgh f^mZbl+
10 <gnh f^mn NbfhgZl gn*
ch ikb^ BZshl bk Zilnih c dZ*
kbnhf^g^8 cbl iZlb]Zk dZkh iZ*
% 1 . &  x \` g T f (((  . 1 /  f + i bk k k g  F k +  } 
A h a Z T f  U h i b  a h \` g T f (  I h k l  E n ] c Z  b k 
mh ebZ n  i Z l bebd h  N r k b ch l  o Z el m r [ l  ] Z *
ebl ) [ ^ m  cb  ] Z [ Z k  m n k ch  ] Z n ` bZ n  l Z o Z *
kZ g d b d n f h  bk  g ^ [ ^ [ n o h  l r k  l e^ ` bZ *
f Z+
%1 0 & G e \X  > T m b f ( O bd k bZ n 7 i k b^ 
B Z s Z k h l +
K e ` +  . 1 ) 4 +0 1 + }  B T e b  c T '
U ^ _ 4 r i Z m b g `  g ^ l ^ g Z b ? ^ f ^ m k b cZ n l 
K h ebh k d ^ mh  l n ` Z eo h m  [ h d m  Z g m m ^ *
d bg b ) d n k bh  i Z ` Z e[ Z  [ n o h  i k Z f n *
Z f h l  Z i ` n emh  f b^ l mh  l b^ g h l + B k +

Turinys

525

. H<F+ 00)' 11}2.

 [nde) ikblbZkmbgh ikb^ fb^lmh)


Ziieb\nbm Z] \bobmZm^f) ^m i^k\nl* u
lbm mnkk^f ngZf) ^m \hfik^a^g* inhe ob^g [hdm bk iZf c+
]bm ^Zf+ 11 @m^kni^kZgm jnb ^kZgm 7 11 Ob^) dnkb^ [noh dZkh iZ[de^)
bgmkZ fZ\abgZf bg \bobmZm^f7 ^m b lbo^k c fb^lm) bk fb^lm^ iZlb*
_Z\mnl ^lm fhmnl fZ`gnl bg \b* ]Zk ]b]^ebl lncn]bfZl+ 12 Onh*
obmZm^+ 13 @mZl\^g]^kngmjnb ^kZgm f^m fb^lmh `ro^gmhcZb ln iZbh*
bg \bobmZm^ \nf nqhkb[nl) ^m _bebbl fbl bk oZbdZbl ndhih Zgmlb^ghl)
lnikZ fnknf l\bllbl mngb\bl lnbl) b i^kie lZoh cniZl)bk Znd`Zk*
^m \eZfZo^kngm oh\^ fZ`gZ) ih* 7 lbn[Zeln)ikZr]Zfb Nbfhg ]nh*
lmneZgm^l Z Nbfhg^ ]^qmkZl lb[b  mb cb^fl ]^bg8 13 cb^ lZd7 I^Zm*
]Zkb) 13 ^m ]bq^kngm7 Ihg gh[bl c lber`bgd fnfl) bk]ZfZl f*
k^]]Zl l^\nng]nf fZebmbZl ghl* D l ibdmnfh) [^m lZoh `Zbe^lmbg*
mkZl) l^] l^\ng]nf fbl^kb\hk]bZl c `nkgh+ 14 KZe^gdmZl NbfhgZl g^*
mnZl+ 14 @m_e^qnl Nbfhg ghg ]^* [^dhohch ikb^cnhl) mZbZn cbl b*
[^eeZobm ^hl7^b^\bm mZf^g ^hl ]^ oZk cnhl b fb^lmh bk boZe gZ*
\bobmZm^)^mfng]ZobmZ^]^l)bg jnb* fnl) dnkbnhl^ [noh lmZ[8ih mh
[nl _n^kZgm lbfneZ\kZ) ^m mng\ cbl ch c c ln `b^lffbl)`Zk[bg*
bgmkZobmbg ^Zf \nf arfgbl [^* ]ZfZl Qb^iZm+ 15 KZZebglbch
g^]b\^gl ?hfbgnf715 ^m ^b^\mZZ[ oblhd g^oZknf) cbl Zi`ro^g]b*
^Z hfgbbffng]bmbZ) \heeh\Zobm bg gh cZf^ fhgb) dnkb^ eZbdlb
^Z obkhl) jnb e^`^f _Z\^k^gm7 ^m lmZmrfh8cbl lnlmbikbgh c bkiZ]Z*
fngbobm ^Zf) ^m _^\bm lb[b aZ[b* k cZf^ lZn [lmbg+
mZmbhg^f+
16
Lnb Znm^f ^kZgm bg Zk\^ D^*16 =nonlb^fl E^knsZel iberc^
knlZe^f) ikhab[^[Zgmnk ^`k^]b ^m c g^[noh e^b]bZfZ b^bmb bk ^bmb 
bg`k^]b k^`bhg^f) ^m ^f^k^) Z\ Ze) ibkdmb bk iZk]nhmb) mh]e cb^
o^g]^k^7 ^m ^lnkb^kngm oZe]^) ^m d^gm ]b]^e [Z]) bk ]Zn`c n*
fnemb ^q ^bl _Zf^i^kb^kngm) 2-^m oh [Z]n+ 2- Onhf^m cb^ Zndlb 
\eZfZo^kngm Z] Nbfhg^fnm ]^q* Nbfhg) dZ] ]nhm cb^fl ]^bg)
mkZl Z\\bi^k^gm7 ^m ]^]bm beebl7 ^m bk cbl lnmbdh8 cbl bf^m cnhl b
^b^\bm ^hl bg]^) ^m fng]Zobm Zk*  m^g bk ZioZe ibe gnh lnm^ibf+
\^f Z \hgmZfbgZmbhgb[nl7 2. ^m  2. Eb^ ch  c ]ob]^bfm mk^b
 Zgmkhch fg^lbh ]b^g bfmZl
bgmkZo^kngm bg ^Zf m^kmbZ ^m ob`^*
lbfZ ]b^ l^\ng]b f^glbl) Zggh l^imrgbZl ]^bfmbl ibkfZbl f^mZbl
\^gm^lbfh l^imnZ`^lbfh ikbfh ln ]dhcbfh `b^lffbl) iZefb
\nf eZn]^) ^m kZfbl iZefZknf) Zdhfbl) Zkihfbl bk dbf[heZbl)
^m \bgrkbl) ^m \rf[Zebl) ^m gZ[ebl) dZgdefbl) bfgZbl bk `b^lffbl)
^m arfgbl) ^m \Zgmb\bl) jnbZ \hg* g^l [noh bgZbdbgmZl ]b]^ebl g^*

c b l  o Z ] b g h l b  ^ , bk 7h R mm) f b ^ l m h  f c Z l )  b k ^ b o b n  [ k b n b 8  b  b Z  c b ^ f l  [ n o h  g ^ *
ln g d n  i Z m ^ d m b Z g m Z i ` n emh  f b^ l mh  l b^ *
< g h m ? bh ] h k h  N b \ +) ch  h g n  be` bl  [ n *
g h l  b k  l b o ^ k m b   i Z m  f b ^ l m +  }  % 1 4 & 
o l  1 2  f Z l m Z b )  Z n d m b l  6 -  f Z l m ) m ^ *
A \ f  \y i T e (((  N b f h g Z l  i Z ] Z k  b  B Z s Z * 
d bg bZ b ` b [ n o  5 f Z l m Z b l  Z n d mb+ N b f h *
k h l  r ]  f b^ l m 8 i Z l d n b cb l  Z mb] Z o 
g Z l  [ n o h ) [ ^  Z [ ^ c h )  i Z l b ] b k [ l  l Z n 
oc  l Z o h  l g n b E h g n b %2 1  ^ +& +
] Z n `  f Z ^ l g  l b^ g  f c + }  %1 1 &
% 1 6 &  E XU h i b  _X \W { \T ` T (((  ` n e Z  [ n *
B h e\X U h i b  ^ T e b  c T U ^ _X (((  ? b ] ^ e b l 
o h  Z i l n i m Z  b  o b l  h g n + K e ` +  . / )0 3 +
f b^ l mh  f cZ l  [ n o h  g ^ m ] ^ o r g bZ bl 
Z n d m Z b l )  d n k b n h l ^  [ n o h  o b ^ m h l  Z n * * }  % 2 . &  < i \W Xy\` g(((4  ` ^ ` n l  f g ^ * 
g ^ l r c ^  . 1 .  f + i b k f  F k +  }  G T\` gT& y T '
g Z f b^ f l  mZ bl r f Z f l  bk  g ^ f Z Z f  d Z *

Turinys

& I=G+ .0) 2 / *. 1 ) 1

526

mkbmnl ^lm bgbfb\nl fZ`gnl ^q Dl* c ikb^m^ebl b DskZ^ebh+ 2/ Eb^ lZd
kZ^e+ 2/@m \hglmbmnbm nm hfgb[nl b olmb mZl ]b^gZl dZl f^mZb ln
Zggbl Z`^k^gmnk ]b^l ab\nf eZ^* c ]bZn`lfn+
mbmbZ+
20 @m fngbobm fhgm^f m^fieb)
20 =Zgrbhl dZeg `k^mZ ibeb^l
jnb ^kZm l^\nl Zk\^f) ^m aZ[bmZ* cbl lnlmbikbgh bk`ro^gh m^gZbiZml
obm b[b bil^) ^m jnb \nf ^h^kZgm+ u
 ln lZoZblbZbl+
21@m ob]bm Nbfhg DhZgg^f _beb*
21 NbfhgZl) fZmr]ZfZl) dZ]
nf lnnf) jnh] _hkmbl ikZ^ebb obk ch  lgnl EhgZl [noh ]klnldh*
^ll^m7 ^m ihlnbm ^nf ]n\^f obk* o orkZl) iZldrkc oblhl dZkbnh*
mnmnf ngbo^klZknf7 ^maZ[bmZobm bg f^gl oZ]n) bk cbl `ro^gh BZsZ*
BZsZkbl+
khc^+
6L[`_ H;G% . <ggh \^gm^lb*
'*
[P]^Vb]TXL^% . bfmZ
fh l^imnZ`^lbfh l^\ng]h \hg* l^imrgbZl ]^bfmbl ZgmkZblf^mZbl
`k^`Zobm k^q ?^f^mkbnl ^q^k\bmnf F dZkZebnl ?^f^mkbcnl lnkbgdh lZ*
lnnf) ^m Z[bbm bg H^]bZf Z] \hg* D oh dZkbnhf^g bk gnch  f^]
mkZa^g]Z lb[b ZnqbebZ) nm ^qin`* b Ze b^dhmb lZn iZ`Ze[hl)dZ]dh*
gZk^mOkriahg^f+ / @mZn]bobm<k* ohm ikb^ Okbmhg+ / K^klbchl bk
lZ\^l k^q K^klb]bl) ^m H^]bZ^) H^]bchl dZkZebnl <klZdZl) b`bk*
jnbZ bgmkZobm ?^f^mkbnl \hg_bg^l ]l) dZ] ?^f^mkbcnl ch  ch kb*
lnhl) ^m fblbm ngnf ]^ ikbg\b* [Zl)iZlbngmob^g lZoh dngb`Zbd*
ib[nl lnbl nm \hfik^a^g]^k^m D m ln`Znmb ch  `roh bk Zmo^lmb ch
^nf obonf) ^mZ]]n\^k^m ^nf Z] iZl lZo^+ 0 OZlZb Zmcl lnfn
l^+ 0 @m Z[bbm) ^m i^k\nllbm \ZlmkZ ?^f^mkbcZnl dZkbnhf^g) ln`Zoh
?^f^mkbb7 ^m \hfik^a^g]bm ^nf) c bk Zmo^] cb iZl <klZd) dnkl
^m ]nqbm ^nf Z] <klZ\^f) ^m ih* f^m c  dZecbf+
lnbm ^nf bg \nlmh]bZf+
1
@m lbenbm hfgbl m^kkZ Dn]Z
D
1 K^k oblZl Nbfhgh ]b^gZlob*
c lZ E]h Zebl mnkch kZfr[l8
hfgb[nl ]b^[nl Nbfhgbl)
 cbl b^dhch lZoh mZnmhl `^khol)
^m jnZ^lbobm [hgZ `^gmb lnZ^7
^m ieZ\nbm beebl ihm^lmZl ^bnl)
u
 bk ch oZe]bZ [^b ch `Zk[
^m `ehkbZ ^bnl hfgb[nl ]b^[nl+ b iZmbdh cb^fl obl eZbd+
^ b ` \f ( O Z b  [ n o h  ] bZ n ` l f h  ^ g d eZ l +
K e ` +  /  H Z d +  . - ) 4 8  E h g h  . / ). 0 + }  < \'
W X _\f  a X c e \X g X _\f 4 eZ [ Z b d r k cn l b  r *
] Z f l  l r k  b` n eZ  i Z b h c^  E ^ k n s Z e c^ +
}  % 2 / &  B T f  ` X g T \(  F Z ]  m Z  o ^ g m 
[ mn  [ n o n l b o ^ g bZ f Z  eZ [ Z b  be` Z b)
kh ] r f  g k Z +
% 2 0 &  : T { a l } \ b f  ^ T _ a (((  O Z b i  ] Z *
[ Z k  E ^ k n s Z e c^  Z m l bk Z ] h  ] o b m o bk m h o l )
N bf h g h  i Z l m Z m r m h cb ) d n k b h c^  c b l  i Z m l 
` r o ^ g h ) b k  b  l r k b Z mbf mh cb+
%2 1 & A b a T f 4 d n k l  [ n o h  i k Z f bg mZ l 
Dkd Z g n +
% . 1 ) . &  x \ ` g T f (((4  . 1 -  f + i b k f + F k +

 , ` X W  y T _ \X y ^ b g \ f T h  c T Z T _U b f (
K Z k mZ b [ n o h  i Z f Z n  i Z f  o bl Z l  N r * 
k b ch l  i k h o b g \ b cZ l  Z g Z i n l  @ n i k Z m h  g ^ m
b d b  D g ] n b + K b k f Z l  ? ^ f ^ m k b c Z n l  m b d l *

eZ l  [ n o h  Z ml bbf mb m Z l  n ` k h [ mZ l  i kh *
o b g \ bcZ l ) d n k b  ` r o ^ g mh c  ] Z ebl  [ n o h 
g ^ i Z m ^ g d bg m Z  g Z n cZ b l  o Z e] h o Z bl ) Z g m k Z l 
` b m b d l eZ l  [ n o h  b  Z ml bbf m  i k h o bg \ b*
c  l n k bg d mb ] b] ^ e  d Z k bn h f ^ g ) d n k bh l 
i Z ` Z e[ Z  m b d ch l b  g n ` Z e mb O k b_ h g + } 
%/ & 9 e f T ^ T f ( O Z b  [ ^ g ] k Z l  o bl  i Z k *
mn  d Z k Z e b  o Z k ] Z l +  O Z l  d Z k Z e b n l )  Z i b ^ 
d n k b b Z  d Z e[ Z f Z ) [ n o h  < k l Z d Z l  Q D)
eZ [ bZ n  bg h f Z l  H b m k b] Z m h  D % . 3 1 } . 0 6 
f + i b k f  F k +&  o Z k ] n +  E b l  o Z ] b g Z f Z l 
K ^ k l b ch l  bk  H ^ ] bch l  d Z k Z ebn f b) g ^ l 
cb l  m Z l  Z e b l  [ n o h  i Z f l + }  %0 & K T '
f T \  T g ] f ( ((  ? ^ f ^ m k b c n b  d Z k Z l  i k b ^ 
< k l Z d  i k Z ] bh c^  l ^ d l b+ < g h m bl m h *
k bd h  E n l mbg h  %0 3 ). &) cb l  i Z m ^ d l  g ^ *
eZ bl o g  Z i ` Z n e^ ) d Z b  cZ n  [ n o h  m Z k b Z *
f Z l b ln  i k b^ n  Z i b^  m Z bd h l  i Z ] Z k r *

Turinys

53-

. H < F + .1) 2 * . 0

2 @m \nf hfgb `ehkbZ lnZ Z\\^*c 2 Qbl lZoh `Zk[ cbl ]Zk iZ]b*
ibm ehii^g bg ihkmnf)
]bgh) iZbf]ZfZl Ehi) dZ] bchl
^m _^\bm bgmkhbmnf bg bglnebl fZ*
[m nhlmZl)
mZbi cbl iZ]Zk bcbf  ckhllZ*
kbl+
eZl+
5 @m ]beZmZobm _bg^l `^gmbl lnZ^) 5 Ebl ikZieZmbgh lZoh mZnmhl kb[Zl
bk lb`Zech Zerc^+
^m h[mbgnbm k^`bhg^f+
4 @m\hg`k^`Zobm \ZimbobmZm^ffne* 7 4 Ebl lnkbgdh ]Zn` [^eZblob)
iZf BZsZk) =^mlnk bk ibe)
mZf)
^m ]hfbgZmnl^lmBZsZkZ^) ^m=^ma*  iZZebgh b chl g^oZknfnl)
bk g^[noh dZl cZf ikb^bgmlb+
lnkZ^) ^m Zk\b7
^m Z[lmnebm bffng]bmbZl ^q ^Z)
^m ghg ^kZm jnb k^lblm^k^m ^b+
5 @m ngnljnbljn^ \he^[Zm m^kkZf b 5 Fb^dob^gZl ]bk[h lZoh^f kZ*
fr[c^8
lnZf \nf iZ\^7
^m m^kkZ Dn]Z ]Z[Zm_kn\mnl lnhl) En]h Zebl ]Zo lZoh ]^kebZnl)
^m eb`gZ\Zfihknf _kn\mnf lnnf+ bk eZnd f^]bZb lZoh oZblb+
6 N^gbhk^l bg ieZm^bl l^]^[Zgm 6 Qrk^lgb^cb l]]Zoh oblb Zbdm*
l^ bk mZklb Zib^ Zeb^l `^kho8
hfg^l) ^m ]^ [hgbl m^kkZ^ mkZ\mZ*
[Zgm)
cZngbdZbbZb Zilbobed]Zoh `Zk[l
bk dZkh Zi]ZkZbl+
^m bno^g^l bg]n^[Zgm l^ `ehkbZf)
^m lmheZl [^eeb+
.- @m \bobmZmb[nl mkb[n^[Zm Zebfh* .- Hb^lmZfl cbl mb^d fZblmh
bk ]Zk b c lnlmbikbgm ob^m)
gbZl)
mZbi
dZ] ch oZk]Zl [noh fbgbfZl
^m \hglmbmn^[Zm ^Zl nm ^ll^gmoZ*
ln iZ`Zk[Z
lZ fngbmbhgbl
jnhZ]nljn^ ghfbgZmnf ^lm gh* bdb ^fl iZdkZb+
f^g `ehkbZ^ ^bnl
nljn^ Z] ^qmk^fnf m^kkZ^+
..Ebl iZ]Zk mZbd Zerc^)
.. A^\bm iZ\^f lni^k m^kkZf)
^m eZ^mZmnl^lm DlkZ^e eZ^mbmbZ fZ`* bk DskZ^ebl mnkch ]b]^ebh ]bZn`*
lfh+
gZ+
./ @m l^]bm ngnljnbljn^ ln[ obm^ ./ Fb^dob^gZl l]chih lZohorg*
f^]bn bk ih lZoh _r`f^]bn)
lnZ) ^m ln[ _b\neg^Z lnZ7
bk g^[noh) dZl cnhl `l]bgm+
^m ghg ^kZm jnb ^hl m^kk^k^m+
.0 ?^_^\bm bfin`gZgl ^hl lni^k .0O) dnkb^ dhoh]Zoh ikb^ cnhl)
g^[^[noh Zgm ^fl8
m^kkZf7
k^`^l \hgmkbmb lngm bg]b^[nl beebl+ dZkZebZb eZghl^ ]b^ghl^ [noh ln*
mkbdmb+
f +  N n ` Z n m  ? ^ f ^ m k b cn )  d n k b h  ) d Z *
k b n h f ^ g ) o Z ] h  g ^ m ^ d n l b )  [ n o h  b *
l d e Z b ] r m Z )  < k l Z d Z l  i Z l b m r b h cb f n b X  e b ^ *
i  o ^ ] b h m b  b  o b ^ g h  f b ^ l m h  b d b m )  o b *
l b^ f l  k h ] Z g m ) [ ^ m  ` k ^ b m Z b  i Z d ^ bm l 
l Z o h  g n l b l m Z m r f )  ^ e ` l b  l n  cn h  e Z *
[ Z b f h g b d Z b) ] Z o  cZ f  l Z o h  ] n d *
m ^ k  % Z k  ` b f b g Z b m &  M h ] h ` n g   f h *
g Z l  b k  Z i ` r o ^ g ] bg h  D k d Z g b ch c^ + ? o r *

ebdZb f^m ikZlebgdnl) ?^f^mkbcnl Zm*


`Zoh eZblo bk lhlm+

% 3 &  @y ]\` T  \ ]h eb f(((  Q s +  . 0 )/ 6 + } 


% 4 &  > T m T e T (  Q s +  . 0 81 0 + }  : Xgfh e (  Q s + 
. . )3 2 + }  % . - &  J h fg\c e\a gh  i \X g 4  Z i *
k i bg ] Z f Z l  ` bg d eZ bl  bk  d bmh f bl  ` r *
g b f h l b  i k b ^ f h g f b l +  9}   '(  B \X ^ i \X '
a T f  f W ]b (((  M Z f r [ l  b k  e Z b f l  o Z b s *
] Z l  m Z b d h l  f ^ m n +
K e` + 0  F Z k + 1 )/ 2 8
H b d + 1 + 1 8  Z d +  0 ) . - +

Turinys

. H<F+ .1) . 1 */ /

53.

.1 @m \hg_bkfZobm hfg^l anfbe^l .1Ebl lnlmbikbgh oblnl lZoh Zeb^l
lbeignhlbnl)
ihineb lnb)
[n]kbZb lZn`hch lmZmrf
^m e^`^f ^qjnblbobm)
^m Z[lmnebm hfg^f bgbjnnf^mfZ* bk lngZbdbgh oblnl g^m^blbnhlbnl
enf7
bk ibdmnhlbnl+
.0 lZg\mZ `bhkb_b\Zobm)
.2 Ebl iZinh o^gmho
^m fnembieb\Zobm oZlZ lZg\mhknf+ bkiZ]Zn`bgho^gmrdehlkZdZg]nl+
.%b @m Zn]bmnf ^lm MhfZ^jnbZ
.3
FZb Mhfhc^ [noh `ZnmZb
]^_ng\mnl ^ll^m DhgZmaZl7 ^m nl* gbZ) dZ] EhgZmZl fbkl) bk cb iZ*
jn^ bg NiZkmbZmZl7 ^m \hgmkblmZmb lb^d NiZkmb^bnl) cb^ eZ[Zb eb]*
lngm oZe]^+ .4 Pm Zn]b^kngm Zn* ch+ .4 D`bk] `b) dZ] ch ob^mhc^
m^f jnh] Nbfhg _kZm^k ^bnl _Z\* iZlmhch orkbZnlbnhcn dngb`n ch
mnl ^ll^m lnffnl lZ\^k]hl eh\h [khebl NbfhgZl bk dZ] cbl oZe]h
^bnl) ^m bil^ h[mbg^k^mhfg^f k^* obl Ze bk chl fb^lmnl) .5 cb^ iZ*
`bhg^f) ^m\bobmZm^lbg ^Z8 .5 l\kbi* kZ cZf Zgm oZkbgb e^gm) dZ]
l^kngm Z] ^nf bg mZ[nebl Z^k^bl) mZbi ZmgZncbgm ikb^m^erlmbk ]kZn*
nm k^ghoZk^gm Zfb\bmbZl) ^m lh\b^* `rlm) dnkb [noh iZ]Zk ln ch
mZm^f jnZf _^\^kZgm \nf en]Z) [khebZbl En]n bkEhgZmn+ .6Ehl[n*
^m \nf DhgZmaZ _kZmkb[nl^bn l+.6@m oh ldZbmrmhl lnlbkbgdbfh ZdboZbs*
e^\mZ^ lngm bg \hgli^\mn ^\\e^lbZ^ ]hc^ E^knsZec^+
bg D^knlZe^f+
u
@mah\ ^q^fienf^iblmheZknf) c
mZb liZkmb^b Zmlblmhch eZb*
jnZlNiZkmbZmZ^fbl^kngm7 /-NK<M* b dh gnhkZZl+ /- NiZkmb^b dngb*
OD<IJMPH ikbg\bi^l) ^m \bobmZ* 8 `ZbdbZb bkfb^lmZborkbZnlbZf dn*
m^l) Nbfhgb NZ\^k]hmb fZ`gh) ^m . gb`nb Nbfhgnb) ork^lgb^lb^fl)dn*
l^gbhkb[nl) ^m lZ\^k]hmb[nl)^mk^* c gb`Zfl bk dbmb^fl lZoh [khebZfl
ebjnh ihineh Dn]Z^hknf) _kZmkb* b r] mZnmhl fhgfl lbngbZ
[nl) lZenm^f+ /. G^`Zmb) jnbfbllb c lo^bdbgbf+ /. KZlbngmbgbZb) dnkb^
lngm Z] ihinenf ghlmknf) gg* c [noh Zmlblmb iZl fl mZnm)
\bZo^kngm gh[bl ]^ o^lmkZ `ehkbZ) L fnfl ikZg^ Zib^ cl `Zk[)
^m ahghk^) Z\ eZ^mbmbZ7 ^m `Zoblb eho bk ]bZn`lf+ H^l ]bZn*
lnfnl bg bgmkhbmn ^hknf+ // @m `fl c Zmcbfn) //bk mZb) dZl
l\kbilbfnl jnZ^ Z[ ^bl ^kZgm ]b* c [noh iZlZdrmZ mZnmhl lnlbkbg*
\mZ bg \hg\bebblihineb)lb\7 Inf^* dbf^) f^l nkZf^ mZbi7 r]
gbnl <gmbh\ab) ^m <gmbiZm^k DZlh* iZlbngmbgbZb <gmbhdh lgnl In*
gbl _bebnl) e^`Zmb Dn]Z^hknf) o^* f^gbcnl bk EZshgh lgnl <gmbiZ*
%.3& B T\ I b` b]X((( =pojmdpn) f\g*
]_\h\n \kd` Odhjij b\m]) hdid e\p
d\ npo\md \oi\pedidh np nq`odhj*
hdn \gdhdn+ G\dk ojn npo\motn ]pqj
\oi\pediojn) k\\dfe\ d ojgdh`nidj
k\n\fjedhj+ Njhi\d dm nk\mod`d\d
npdijej \kd` Fji\oj hdmo dm \kd` o\d)
f\_Odhji\n nojejejqd`oji) dOdhjij
k\ndpiodidp) \kd` fpmdpjn f\g]\ /1 `+
L `m opjn k\ndpiodidpn ed` _\q k\g\i*
fp \on\fth+ Ok\mod`d \on\fth\n
_pj_\h\n opje\p /-/0 `df) mjh*
ip ojgd\p .2).3 /1+

%/-& J cTeg\X}\  ^ha \ZT\^y}\T\((( L \*


nfpodidn Ok\mojn f\m\gdpn Hdfpmbj n*
ipn L`gjkn\n ]pqj hdmn /.. h+ kdmh
Gm+) k\nfpodidn q\g_jq\n ]pqj J\]dn)
phpo\n .6/ h+ kdmh Gm+ Lj e
nk\mod`d\d ]pqj q\g_jhd `ajm %g$*kjkjd&)
fpmd` d\ bm+ o+ q\_di\hd \m^cjio\dn
%0k*,jq*nv&+  D \XfgT\( C`md\p bm+ o+7
hd`no\n+  %//& B Tf ] Uhib c T f T '
^ l gT  gThgbf((( =ijo bm+ o+7 f\n e
]pqj k\n\fto\) h`n k\m\h` o\pojn
ipo\mdhpjn` %qd`pjn` h`om\dpjn`&
o\dk+  E ` X a \]hf((( L\ndpiodid\d od`

Turinys

53/

. H<F+ .1) /0}/5

g^kngm Z] ghl) k^ghoZgm^lgh[bl* m^kbl Zmch iZl fnl ZmgZncbgmbln


\nf Zfb\bmbZf ikblmbgZf+ /0 @m fnfbl l^ghl ikb^m^erlml+ /0 OZn*
ieZ\nbm ihineh ^q\bi^k^ obkhl`eh* mZb iZmbdh ikbbfmb fhg^l `Zk[bg*
kbhl^) ^m ihg^k^ ^q^fienf l^k* `Zb bk iZ]mb c h]b gnhkZ
fhgnf ^hknf bg l^`k^`Zmbl ih* riZmbg`hl^ mZnmhl dgr`hl^) dZ]
ineb eb[kbl) nm lbm Z] f^fhkbZf [m NiZkmb^b mZnmZb Zmlbfbgb*
ihineh NiZkmbZmZknf+ @q^fienf fZl+ bh `b ]Zerdh gnhkZ f^l
Znm^f ahknf l\kbilbfnl Nbfhgb lbngbZf^ orkbZnlbZf dngb`nb Nb*
fhgnb+
fZ`gh lZ\^k]hmb+
/1
Khlm aZ^\ Znm^f fblbm Nb* /1
Kh mh NbfhgZl gnlbngm
fhg Inmg^gbnf MhfZf) aZ[^g* Inf^gbc Mhfhg ln ]b]^ebn Znd*
m^f \eri^nf Znk^nf fZ`gnf) lbgbn ldr]n) lo^kbZgbn mdlmZgm
ihg]h fgZknf fbee^) Z]lmZmn^g* fbg) iZ]Zkrmb ln cZbl lcng`hl+
]Zf \nf ^bl lh\b^mZm^f+
>nf Znm^f Zn]bll^m ihinenl
Mhfhl mZnmZ) b`bk]nl /2 b*
MhfZgnl /2 l^kfhg^l blmhl) ]bq^* mnhl ]Zerdnl) mZk7 FZbi f^l iZ*
kngm7 LnZf `kZmbZknf Z\mbhg^f ]dhlbf^ Nbfhgnb bk ch lgnfl;
k^]]^fnl Nbfhgb) ^m _bebbl ^bnl; /3 I^l cbl boZ]Zoh lZoh [khebnl
/3 M^lmbmnbm ^gbf bil^ _kZmk^l lnhl) bk bgZbdbgh b DskZ^ebh ch g^ikb^*
^m ^qin`gZobm bgbfb\hl DlkZ^e Z[ m^ebnl) Eb^ iZmobkmbgh ibeg ch eZb*
^bl) ^m lmZmn^kngm ^b eb[^kmZm^f)^m lo bk mZb iZkZ ZgmoZkbgb e^g*
]^l\kbil^kngm bg mZ[neblZ^k^bl) ^m m) dnkbZl cb^ iZ]ch Zgm neNbh*
ihln^kngmbgmbmneblbgfhgm^ Nbhg+ gh dZeg^+
/4
@m ah\^lm ^q^fienf l\kbi* /4 mZb mh kZmh gnhkZZl7 <*
mnkZ^8 J>O<Q<]^\bfZ]b^f^g* mnhgbhebdm ^enebh fg^lbh ]b^g
lbl @enb) Zggh \^gm^lbfh l^imnZ* bfmZl l^imrgbZl ]^bfmbl ZgmkZbl
`^lbfh l^\ng]h) Zggh m^kmbhln[ f^mZbl) mk^bZblbZbl orkbZnlbhchdn*
Nbfhg^ lZ\^k]hm^ fZ`ghbg <lZ* gb`h Nbfhgh f^mZbl <lZkZferc^
kZf^e) /5 bg \hgo^gmn fZ`gh lZ* /5]b]^ebZf^ dngb`) mZnmhl dngb*
k\otn) fpmdpjn ]pqj dndpion Fji\*
o\n ./).3+
%/1& G b  gb((( G\d fpmd` \dfdioje\d
nke\) f\_ d\ \pojmdpn f\g]\ \kd`
k\ndpiodh Jph`ide\pn Njhji \iom
f\mo) ]`o o\d i`odfodi\+ j_d\d c b
gb d\ t m\  odf k`medhj ajmhpg) g\d*
fj ed` i`ipmj_j+  J ^ l W h & fi Xe\T a '
}\h((( P\d ]pqj _jq\i\ mjhi\hn+
G\_ nft_\n ]op nqmn .--- hdi)
npifp odfod) i`n qd`i\ ntmdd hdi\
nqm e\p 31/ b m+8 o\o j_d nq`md\i*
dp m`dfop dg`dnod) o\dk f\dk ej im\
ntm+ q`modh` dm im\ mjhip \on\ft*
h`+ .2).5+ H\df\io hdi kdidbdidp qd`*
i`op) nft_\n ]pqj q`mo\n \mod 0--+---
gdop %\ijo fdop) kpn od`f&+
I b` bf( Pj j_dj im\ bm+ o+) dm
edn d\ i`m`df\gdib\n) i`n f\g]\h\ i`
\kd` Njhjn) ]`o \kd` t_p o\pojn np*
no\oto dm qd`\d k\nf`g]o _jfph`i*
o \kd` Odhjij ipjk`gipn n\qj o\po\d+

Pjfdp btmd\pn dm k\b\m]jn _jfph`i*


o b\gdh\ m\nod dm k\n fdo\n n`ijqn
o\po\n+  %/2& x\ghbf W T _l ^ h f 4 f\n
k\n\fto\ .3m/0 `dg+  %/3& E Xf ]\f(((
Pmphk\ Odhjij dm ej `dhtijn ipj*
k`gip t_ o\po\d n\iom\pf\+ =ijo
bm+ o+7 i`n edn fjqjej) edn dm ej ]mjgd\d
dm ej oqj i\h\d8 ed` npi\dfdij Eum\*
`gdj i`kmd`o`gdpn dm k\odfmdij ej g\dn*
q+ Em ed` k\m\ op _\gtfp \ondhdid*
h \io nf\dnoq\mdid g`io dm k\_ej
e\n \io pgp Odjij f\gi`+ Rpgb\ojn
j_d\d7 fgTghXehag X\ _\UXegTgX` & m`d*
fd\ npkm\nod i` \kd` o\pojn kmdk\dio
dm k\oqdmodio tk\odib g\dnq %kq_+)
ipj hjf`ndp) hpdop dm o+o+& Odhj*
ipd) ]`o \kd` g\dnq Odhjij dm ej ]mj*
gdp k\odfmdio Eum\`gdj o\po\d8 o\po\
bd o k\odfmdidh m\  btmd\pn _j*
fph`io+
%/4& 9 yghba\b_\^g((( I\_\pb kdm*
hjn` mpbnej hi`ndj _d`ijn` %kgb+

Turinys

. H<F+ .1) /6}02

530

\^k]hmnf) ^m ihineb) ^m ikbg\binf


k^`bhgbl) gh*
mZ _Z\mZ lngm aZ^\7 LnhgbZf _k^*
jn^gm^k _Z\mZ lngm ikZ^ebZ bg k^*
`bhg^ ghlmkZ+ /0 NbfhgZnm^fHZ*
maZmabZ^ _bebnl ^q _bebbl eZkb[) ^m
_kZmk^l ^bnl ]^]^kngm l^ i^kb\neh)
^m k^lmbm^kngm Z]o^klZkbbl `^gmbl
lnZ^) nm lmZk^gm lZg\mZ bilhknf)
^m e^q7 ^m `ehkbZ fZ`gZ `ehkb_b\Z*
o^kngm `^gm^f lnZf+ 0n @m \hg*
`k^`Zobm DhgZmaZl `^gm^f lnZf)
^m _Z\mnl ^lm beebl lZ\^k]hl fZ`*
gnl) ^m Ziihlbmnl ^lm Z] ihin*
enf lnnf+ 0. @m ohen^kngmbgbfb*
\b ^hknf \Ze\Zk^) ^m Zmm^k^k^ k^*
`bhg^f bilhknf) ^m ^qm^g]^k^
fZgnl bg lZg\mZ ^hknf+ 0/ Ong\
k^lmbmbm Nbfhg) ^m in`gZobm ikh
`^gm^ lnZ) ^m ^kh`Zobm i^\ngbZl
fnemZl) ^m ZkfZobm obkhl obkmnmbl
`^gmbl lnZ^) ^m ]^]bm beebl lmbi^g*
]bZ7 00 ^m fngbobm \bobmZm^l Dn]Z^*
Z^) ^m =^malnkZf) jnZ^ ^kZm bg _b*
gb[nl Dn]Z^Z^)n[b ^kZgm ZkfZ ah*
lmbnf Zgm^Z7 ^m ihlnbm beeb\ ikZ^*
lb]bnfobkhlen]Z^hl+ 01@mDhii^g
fngbobm) jnZ^^kZmZ] fZk^7^m BZ*
sZkZf) jnZ^^lmbg _bgb[nl<shmb)bg
jnZahlm^lZgm^ZaZ[bmZ[Zgm)^m\he*
eh\Zobm beeb\ en]Z^hl7 ^m jnZ^\nf*
jn^ZimZ^kZgmZ]\hkk^imbhg^f^h*
knf)ihlnbmbg ^ bl +02 @mob]bmihin*
enlZ\mnf Nbfhgbl)^m`ehkbZf) jn*
Zf \h`bmZ[Zm _Z\^k^ `^gmb lnZ^)^m
ihln^kngm ^nf ]n\^f lnnf) ^m
ikbg\bi^f lZ\^k]hmnf) ^h jnh]
bil^_^\^kZm aZ^\hfgbZ) ^m bnlmbmb*

`Zbdb bk Zeb^l ork^lgbc ln*


lbkbgdbf^ mZb dZl [noh iZk^bdmZ7
FZ]Zg`b fl Zerc^ ]ZgZb [*
]ZohXdho) /5 mZb HZmZmbch b EZ*
kb[h oZbd lgnl NbfhgZl bk ch
[khebZb lmZm lZo^ c iZohc) iZlb*
ikb^bgh lZoh mZnmhl ikb^Zfl)
dZ] `Zem bebdmb c o^gmrdeZ bk
lmZmrfZl) bk cb^ eZbfch lZoh
mZnmZb ]b]^el `Zk[l+ 0-EhgZmZl
lnkbgdh lZoh mZnm) iZmZih cb^fl
orkbZnlbnhcn dngb`n bk [noh iZ*
eZb]hmZl ln lZoh mZnmZ+ 0. FZb c
g^ikb^m^ebZb ghkch lnfbg]bhmb bk
lnmkbgmb c Ze bk bmb^lmb kZgdZl
ikb^ c o^gmrde) 0/ mnhf^m Nb*
fhgZl iZlbikb^bgh bk dhohch n
lZoh mZnm8 cbl be^b]h ]Zn` ibgb*
`) Zi`bgdeZoh ]klbnl lZoh mZn*
mhl orknl bk fhdch cb^fl Ze`+
00Ebl lnlmbikbghEn]chlfb^lmnlbk
=^mlnk En]chl iZdkZmc^) dZf^
ZgdlbZn [noh g^ikb^m^eb `bgdeZb)
bk iZlmZm m^gZb r] dZk^bob `n*
e+ 01Ebl lnlmbikbgh Ehi ikb^ c*
khl bk BZsZk <shmh iZdkZmc^)
dZf^ ZgdlbZn `ro^gh g^ikb^m^*
ebZb) bk Zi`ro^g]bgh m^gZb r]nl)
bk cbl Zikibgh mnhl fb^lmnl ob*
ln) dh mbd k^bdch cb^fl `bgmb+
02OZnmZ fZm Nbfhgh o^bde bk
`Zk[) dnkb cbl [noh lnfZgl
`rmb lZoh mZnmZb8 cb^ lmZm c lZ*
oh oZ]n bk orkbZnlbnhcn dngb`n)
g^l cbl oblZ mZb [noh iZ]Zkl)b*
eZbd lZoh mZnmZb m^blr[ bk bmb*
dbfr[ bk oblZbi lm^g`lb bZnd*
mbgmb lZoh mZnm+ 03Eh  ]b^ghl^ ob*

J``h+ 3).2& .1- h+ kdmh Gm+ Agpgdn


7 `o\n t_ h`o hipj+  9 fT'
eT ` _l ]X( Cm+ o+7 O\m\hgte`+  Ok*
e\h\) f\_ o\dk q\_dijnd t_ o\pojn
npndmdifdh qd`o\ F`mpu\ge`+ Gdod
\dfdioje\d h\ij) f\_ . I\f+ fi+
q`moe\n d bm\df f\g] oj j_dj i`*
npkm\on8 `]m+ o+ b\gej ]od U T 'V[ T '
VTe"T` "=_& o+ t+ @d`qj o\pojn fd`h`)
oj_g7 _d_d\e\h` ]\itdjn q`ioj*

mdpe`8 \m]\ yTe"T` "=_& o+ t+ @d`qj o\p*


ojn fpidb\dfodn8 o\d e\p ]o Odhjij
odopgj _\gdn+  %/6& @y A T e \U b 4 \m]\
Fj\md]j+ Ru+ . Gmji+ /1)48 kgb+ . I\f+
/).+  %0-& Jhe\a^b fT i b (((4 nojej
o\pojn kmd`\fte`) h e\d q\_jq\p*
od+  %0/&+9 c Z\a ^_Tib((( Lgb+ .0).-+++
 %00& : Xgfh e ( P\d ]pqj tk\ nq\m*
]d qd`o\ F`mpu\g`d bdiod %1)/68 ..)32&+
 %01& A b i  Ge\X ] ebf( Lgb+ ./)00 dm

`^gmbl) ^m l^gbhknf 

Turinys

531

. H<F+ .1) 03}10

Zf) ^m _b]^f) jnZf \hgl^koZobm b lZ `^kZb l^dlb) cZf oZ]hoZncZgm)
`^gmblnZ^)^m^qjnblbobmhfgbfh]h c mZbi dZ] [noh iZZebgmb b c
^qZemZk^ ihinenf lnnf+ 03 @m bg Zeb^l iZ`hgrl) mZbi iZm mb^) dnkb^
]b^[nl ^bnl ikhli^kZmnf lm bg 8 [noh ?hob]h fb^lm^ E^knsZec^)
fZgb[nl ^bnl) nm mhee^k^gmnk `^g*  iberc^) b dnk cb^ b^b]Zoh) lnm^i*
m^l ]^ k^`bhg^ bilhknf) ^m jnb . ]Zoh oblZ) dZl [noh Ziebgd o^g*
bg \bobmZm^ ?Zob] ^kZgm bg D^knlZ* * mrdb) bk ]Zkr]Zoh ]b]^e gnhlmh*
e^f bg Zk\^) ]^ jnZ ikh\^]^[Zgm) b Dc chl mrknfnb+ 04 Ebl iZlmZm ch *
^m \hgmZfbgZ[Zgm hfgbZ) jnZ^bg c^ r] orknl ZebZb bk fb^lmnb
\bk\nbmn lZg\mhknf lngm) ^m bg_^* lZn`hmb bk iZ]Zk Zndm^lg^l E^*
k^[Zgm ieZ`Zf fZ`gZf \ZlmbmZmb7 knsZel lb^gZl+ 05 FZkZebnl ?^f^*
04 ^m \heeh\Zobm bg ^Z obkhl En]Z^* mkbcnl iZmobkmbgh cZf orkbZnlbc
hl Z] mnmZf^gmnf k^`bhgbl) ^m dngb`rlm8 06mh bk]ZfZl cbliZ*
\bobmZmbl) ^m ^qZemZobm fnkhl D^kn* ]Zk lZn b ch  ikb^m^e bk iZZnd*
lZe^f+ 05 @m k^q?^f^mkbnl lmZmnbm mbgh c ]b]^e^ `Zk[^+ 1- I^l cbl
beeb lnffnf lZ\^k]hmbnf+ 06 N^* [noh `bk]cl) dZ] r]Zb [noh
\ng]nf aZ^\ _^\bm ^nf Zfb\nf khfg oZ]bgZfb ikb^m^ebZbl) l*
lnnf) ^m `ehkb_b\Zobm ^nf `ehkbZ cng`bgbgdZbl bk [khebZbl) bk dZ]cb^
fZ`gZ+ 1- <n]bobm ^gbf jnh]Zi* [noh ikbfNbfhgh iZlbngmbgbnl
i^eeZmb lngmDn]Z^bZ MhfZgblZfb* `Zk[bg`Zb) 1. bk ch`r]Zb bk c dn*
\b) ^m lh\bb) ^m _kZmk^l) ^m jnbZ ln* gb`Zb [noh gnlblmZm) dZ] cbl [*
l\^i^kngm e^`Zmhl Nbfhgbl `eh* m c oZ]Zl bk orkbZnlbZl dngb`Zl
kbhl^7 1. ^m jnbZ Dn]Z^b) ^m lZ\^k* oblb^fl eZbdZfl) bdb dbel bmbdbfZl
]hm^l ^hknf \hgl^gl^kngm ^nf ikZgZZl) 1/ bk dZ] cbl [m cb^fl
^ll^ ]n\^f lnnf) ^m lnffnf oZ]Zl)dZ] kibgmlb o^gmhofbl)
lZ\^k]hm^f bg Z^m^kgnf) ]hg^\ dZ] ldbkm obkbgbgdnl oblb^fl c
lnk`Zm ikhia^mZ _b]^ebl7 1/^m nm k^bdZeZfl) ZebZb) `bgdeZfl bk`n*
lbm lni^k ^hl ]nq) ^m nm\nkZ^l* ehfl) 10dZ] cbl kibgmlb o^gmh*
l^m beeb ikh lZg\mbl) ^m nm \hglmb* ofbl) dZ] [m obl deZnlhfZl)
mn^k^m ikZ^ihlbmhl lni^k hi^kZ dZ] ch oZk]n [m kZhfb oblb
^hknf) ^m lni^k k^`bhg^f)^m ln* gnmZkbfZb Zerc^) bk dZ] cbl obed*
i^k ZkfZ) ^m lni^kikZ^lb]bZ7 10^m m inkinkZ bk Zndln8 11 dZ] gb^*
\nkZ lbm beeb ]^ lZg\mbl7 ^m nm Zn*
.0)/6+  > TmTe( Lgb+ .0)10+  9 mbgb E hti\ i`o`fj n\qj o`dnd F`mpu\ge`+
P \ \kgdift] _\]\m k\nf\odij t_pn
c T ^ e T y g ]X ( =ujoj kgjo\n ]pqj g\]\d
k\m`dfod n\qj ipndno\oth _g q t *
_d_`gdn) o\dk f\_ edn b\gej nd`fod b\*
i\ ojgd ipj =ujoj ]pqpnd C\u\m+ md\pndjn fpidbtnon) dm ed` k\ndn\f
 %1-& I b` a((( Lgb+ .3/1 `dg+  p kmdk\didh k\q`g_odijn qtmd\p*
ndjn fpidbtnon Odhjij `dhti\d) dfd
%1.& B TW  ]\f Ug(((4 dm ej \did\d+ L \ *
fdgn km\i\\n) fpmn b\gn k\\dfdiod)
nfpodidn o`dnop f`gdp k\nd`fn q t *
md\pnde fpidbtno ]pqj Kide\n EEE b`m\d \m i`b`m\d ed` ]pqj k\_\m+ 
%/ I\f+ 0).&+ Fd \ono\o =iodjf\n Akd* @yg\^\` Tf c eT a T yT f( P\po\ n`i\d i`*
a\i\n .41 h+ kdmh Gm+ dm k\m_\q ej ]`opmej km\i\) ]`o e\d ]pqj dij*
h\) f\_ _\m fdgn km\i\\n %kgb+ I\g+
qd`o ej ]mjgdpd F\ujipd+ Kidej n*
1)2&) fpmn f\g]n @d`qj q\m_p+ Efd
ipn Kide\n ER) f\d ej oq\n ]pqj ip*
p_to\n @\aie`) k\]bj d =dbdko) ej \oedhpd qtmd\pndjn fpidbtnon kmd*
k\didh\n Odhjij `dhti\d opmej
k\no\o H`jiojkjgte` ]\itd %o\d
]pqj kmd`dib\ no\othpd) =of+ ./)2&) ]od g\dfjh\n kmjqdujmdidp+  %1/&
ej o`i\d qtmd\pndjej fpidbj k\m`db\n M\ey\a\a^hf i\f\X` f ] W T eU T ` f4 f\n
d fpidb dm g`qdo dm fpmdpjn _\m]pn
dm opj k\dp edn _m\pb np n\qj `d*

Turinys

. H<F+ .1) 11}.2) .

]bZmnk Z[ hfgb[nl) ^m l\kb[Zgmnk


kg ghfbg^ ^bnl hfg^l \hgl\kbi*
mbhg^l bg k^`bhg^7 ^m nm hi^kbZmnk
inkinkZ) ^mZn kh711 ^mg^eb\^Zmneeb
^q ihineh) ^m^qlZ\^k]hmb[nlbkkb*
mnf _Z\^k^ Zebjnb]ahknf) ^m \hg*
mkZ]b\^k^ abl)jnZ^Z[ ^h]b\ngmnk)
Znm \hgoh\Zk^ \hgo^gmnf bg k^*
`bhg^ lbg^bilh7^mo^lmbkb inkinkZ)
^m nmb _b[neZ Znk^Z+ 12 jnb Znm^f
_^\^kbm ^qmkZ aZ^\) Znm bkkbmnf
_^\^kbm Zebjnb] ahknf) k^nl ^kbm+13
@m \hfieZ\nbm hfgb ihineh lmZ*
mn^k^ Nbfhg^f) ^m _Z\^k^ l^\ng*
]nfo^k[Z blmZ+ 14 @m lnl\^ibmNb*
fhg) ^mieZ\nbm^bnmlnffhlZ\^k*
]hmbh _ng`^k^mnk) ^m^ll^m ]nq) ^m
ikbg\^il `^gmbl Dn]Z^hknf) ^m
lZ\^k]hmnf) ^mikZ^^ll^mhfgb[nl+
15 @m l\kbimnkZf blmZf ]bq^*
kngm ihg^k^ bg mZ[nebl Z^k^bl) ^m
ihg^k^ ^Zlbg i^kb[hehlZg\mhknf)
bg eh\h \^e^[kb7 16 ^q^fienf Zn*
m^f ^hknf ihg^k^ bg Z^kZkbh)nm
aZ[^Zm Nbfhg) ^m _bebb ^bnl+

N32

dZf b mZnmhl bk bdngb` g^[*


m oZebZ gb^dn o^klmb[^m d b b*
m ]Zerd bk ikb^mZkZnmb mZf)dZl
ch lZdhfZ) Zk lnZndmb lnlbkbgdb*
f Zerc^ [^ch) Zilbobedmb inkin*
kZ bk g^bhmb Zndlbg lZ`m812dZl
`b ]Zkrm d ikb^bg`Zb)Zk dgb^*
dn o^klm) mZl [nl gnlbdZemebl
13QblZb mZnmZb iZmbdh mZbi lmZmrmb
Nbfhg bk ]Zkrmb mZbi) dZbi iZlZ*
drmZ+ 14 NbfhgZl ikbf bk lnmb*
dh [mb orkbZnlbnhcn dngb`n) r*
] mZnmhl bk dngb` oZ]n bk dn*
gb`Zbdbn bk obl obkbgbgdn+

1N
=^ mh) cb^ lZd kmb bm
gnmZkbf oZkbgl^ e^gmhl^ bk iZ*
]mb o^gmrdehl neikb^Zg`rc^ob*
lb^fl fZmhfhc^ ob^mhc^) 16 h ch
gnhkZ iZ]mb  b]bg) dZ] cbl
[m Nbfhgnb bk ch lgnfl+

M! DTXZYZ ^LY_bVTLT ^` 4Y_TZV` G;; DTOTPrT`%


'+ [P]^Vb]TXL^% . ?^f^mkb*
6L[`_HG% . @m fblbm k^q<g* 8
mbh\anl _bebnl ?^f^mkbb ^iblmheZl cZnl lgl dZkZebnl <gmbhdZl Zm*
Z[ bglnebl fZkbl Nbfhgb lZ\^k]h* lbngm b ckhl lZe orkbZnlbZf
%.2).& < X` Xge\]Th f4 @`h`omde\pn
c` d + k\o\mi\qdhpn opmej \ogdfod ]\* d
itdje`+  %14& MTWh \e ^ha\ZT\^y}\h( Ojo`mj) d fpmdj njno \oh =g`fn\i*
Cm+ 0ok\m,e4]8q+^p odq\k,mn) f\mdpjh`in _m\n %.-)2-&+ do\n =iodjf\n) q\_d*
q\_\n %b`i`mjg\n& dm o\pojn qdmdidi* i\h\n Od_d`dp) i`n ]pqn d\pfg*
o\n Od_e`) ]pqj odfm\n ]mjgdn @`h`*
f\n %fpidb\dfodn&+
omde\pn EE) fpmn ]pqj k\o`fn d k\mo
%15& G e\X T a Z l ]X4 b\gd ]od) f\_
i`g\dnq %.1)0&+ d\h f\m\gdpd `n\io
dum\`gdo q`iojmdpe`+ +
.2). .3).-+ >pqpndj i`g\dnqe` @`* i`g\dnqe`) ej o`dnd kmd` Pmdoji ]p*
h`omde\pn ]mjgdn =iodjf\n REE Od_d`* qj noje bdiod ej q\_\d) =iodjf\n bd
odn k\dh\ q\g_d\ Otmdeje` dm m\j REE fg\d_djej d qd`ijn qd`ojn d fdo)
+kmd`o`gdf m\o Odhjipd %.2). .1&+ i`n i qd`i\n Otmdejn hd`no\n) ]dej*
Odhjij k\ndpiodid\d \oi`\ e\h d N j* _\h\n Pmdojij) i`d_mnj Fj kmddhod+
hjn k\g\if g\df %.2).2 /1&+ =i* C\qn did \kd` n\qj ]mjgdj i`g\dnq
odjf\n) Odhjij k\_`_\h\n) ipb\gen dm ej hjijn Gg`jk\omjn fqd`d\h\n)
n\qj kmd` Pmdoji) ipndbmd\ ipj =iodjf\n mtjnd nd`fod Otmdejn njnoj)
Odhjij dm ndpid\ n\qj q\_ G`i* ijm_\h\n bd k\odfmdiod n\p d \ifnoj
Odhjij k\b\g]) k\m\ e\h m\o np
_`]d`ep kmd` t_pn %.2)/21 . & o\*
d\p Odhjij nin Fji\n Em Fp_\n k\\_\dn) f\dk nke\h\) d Nj_j n\*
gjn+  %/& B TeT_\hf( =iodjf\n e\p
G`i_`]d`e ipb\gd %.3). .-&+
22

q+ N\o\n) o+ ER+

Turinys

/--

# 3,1! #' $? #"

r] mZnmhl dngb`nb bk dngb`Zbd*


bnb Nbfhgnb bk oblZb mZnmZb eZb*
d) /dnkbh mnkbgrl [noh mhdl7 FZ*
kZebnl <gmbhdZl orkbZnlbZf dngb*
`nb Nbfhgnb bk r] mZnmZb lbng*
bZ lo^bdbgbf+ 0 FZ]Zg`b g^]h*
kebZb iZlblZobgh fl mo dZ*
kZerlm) Z `b ghkbn Zmlbbfmb dZkZ*
erlm bk iZ]Zkrmb c oe mhdb)dZbi+
[noh ibkfZ) mZb Z lnlbkbgdZn
`Znlbg` dZkbnhf^g bk iZlblmZmr*
]bgZn dZkbd eZbo+ 1< ghkbn
Zm^bmb  Ze) Zmd^krmb mb^fl) dnkb^
lngZbdbgh fl Ze bk dnkb^ ln*
`kbho ]Zn` fb^lm fZgh dZkZ*
erlmc^+ 2OZb`b ]Z[Zk Z iZmobkmb*
gn mZn oblZl fhd^lb e^g`oZmZl))
dnkbZl rkZ lnm^bd mZn ibkf fZ*
gl oblb dZkZebZb) bkoblZldbmZl]h*
oZgZl) dnkbZl cb^mZn iZ]Zk+ 3<
e^b]bn mZn fnmb lZonl ibgb`nl
mZoh Zerc^+ 4E^knsZe mnkb [mb
o^gmZ bk eZbloZ+ Qblb iZ]bk[mb^cb)
`bgdeZb bk mZoh iZlmZmrmhl mobkmh*
ol) dnkbZl mn eZbdZb) m^iZlbeb^dZ)
mZn+ 5 Qblhl ]nhdel) dnkbhl ikb*
deZnlh dZkZebnb bk ikbdeZnlrl dZ*
kZebnb gnh bh f^mh bk oblZbl eZb*
dZbl) mZn Zme^b]bZfhl+ 6 FZb `b
f^l Zmlbbflbf^ lZoh dZkZerlm)
f^l bZndmbglbf^ eZ[Zb ]b]^e^
`Zk[^ mZo^) mZoh mZnm bk [Zgr*
b) mZbi dZ] cl `Zk[ iZlbk^bd
oblhc^ ^fc^+
bfmZl l^imrgbZl ]^bfmb
.-
<ggh \^gm^lbfh l^imnZ`^* .-
lbfh jnZkmh ^qbbm <gmbh\anl bg d^mobkmZbl f^mZbl <gmbhdZl bch 
m^kkZf iZmknf lnhknf) ^m \hg* lZoh mo Ze) bk ikb^ ch lnlbkbg*
o^g^kngm Z] ^nf hfg^l ^q^k\b* dh oblb dZkbnhf^gl [kbZb) mZbi
mnl) bmZ nm iZn\bk^eb\mb ^ll^gm \nf dZ] ln Okbmhgn ebdh mbd g^]Zn`
mb) ^m ikbg\bib `^gmbl en]Z^hknf)
^m ngbo^klZ^ `^gmb7 / ^m ^kZgm \hg*
mbg^gm^l ang\ fh]nf7 M@R <g*
mbh\anl Nbfhgb lZ\^k]hmbfZ`gh)
^m `^gmb en]Z^hknf lZenm^f+
0 LnhgbZf jnb]^f i^lmbe^gm^lh[*
mbgn^kngm k^`gnf iZmknf ghlmkh*
knf) oheh Znm^f obg]b\Zk^ k^`*
gnf) ^m k^lmbmn^k^ been] lb\nm ^kZm
Zgm^Z7^m^e^\mZf_^\bfnembmn]bg^f
^q^k\bmnl) ^m _^\b gZo^l [^eeb\Zl+
1 Qheh Znm^f ikh\^]^k^ i^k k^*
`bhg^f nm ne\bl\Zkbg k^`gh f^h+
2 Ing\ ^k`h lmZmnh mb[b hfg^l
h[eZmbhg^l) jnZl k^fbl^kngm mb[b
Zgm^ f^ hfg^l k^`^l) ^m jnZ^*
\nfjn^ ZebZ ]hgZ k^fbl^kngm mb*
[b7 3 ^m i^kfbmmh mb[b _Z\^k^ i^k*
\nllnkZf ikhikbb gnfblfZmbl bg
k^`bhg^ mnZ7 4 D^knlZe^f Znm^f
lZg\mZf ^ll^) ^m eb[^kZf7 ^m hf*
gbZ ZkfZ) jnZ^ _Z[kb\ZmZ lngm) ^m
ikZ^lb]bZ) jnZ^ \hglmknqblmb)jnZ^
m^g^l) fZg^Zgm mb[b+ 5 @m hfg^
]^[bmnf k^`bl7 ^m jnZ^ _nmnkZ
lngm k^`b) ^q ah\) ^m bg mhmnf
m^finl k^fbmmngmnk mb[b+ 6>nf
Znm^f h[mbgn^kbfnl k^`gnf gh*
lmknf) `ehkb_b\Z[bfnl m^) ^m `^g*
m^f mnZf)^m m^fienf `ehkbZfZ`*
gZ bmZ nm fZgb_^lm^mnk `ehkbZ o^*
lmkZ bg ngbo^klZ m^kkZ+.-

g\df n\q` f\m\gdphd) ijmn edn _\m


i`]pqj ifd`ij kmdk\dio\n+  M l'
e\Thf\T` ((( Cm+ o+7 qtmd\pnd\h fpidbpd
dm fpidb\dfdpd Odhjipd dm t_p o\p*
o\d+  %0& E XW be_\T\( Lgb+ .-)3.+ P\dk
d\ =iodjf\n+ q\_di\ qdnp kdmh\ P md*
oji dm Idomd_\o %.0).6+/-8 .1+/&+ 
%3& Dhyg\ fT i b  c\a\Zhf( P\d ]pqj
qdn\d i\pe\ o`dn) npo`dfd\h\ Odhjipd+

e O\qp kdidbp f\gdh\n ]pqj g\dfjh\n


8 qdndfjn i`kmdfg\pnjht]n th`+ 
 %4& AXeh m T _((( Lgb+ .-)0. .1)00+ 
d %5& M \fbf Wh b^_f((( Lgb++ .0)06+
e
%.-&$ x\` gTf(((4 .05 h+ kdmh Gm+ 
d @ y ]b 4 d O`g`pfdejn) fpm edn ]pqj np*
w nd_en np Gg`jk\om\+  M\f\ ^Te\h b'
E ` Xaf((( Pmdoji\n ]pqj k\nd_\mn qd**
E nd`hn i`]`k\f`\d\h\n+ P\d dijej

Turinys

. H<F+ .2) . . */ .

534

Okriahg^+ .. @m bgl^\nmnl^lm^nf  fhgb+ .. FZkZebnl <gmbhdZl c


<gmbh\anl k^q) ^m o^gbm ?hkZf . obchlb) h cbl [`]ZfZl iZckbnZm*
_n`b^gl i^k fZkbmbfZf7 ./l\b^[Zm ordh  ?hk) ./ g^l cbl fZm)dZ]
^gbf jnh] \hg`k^`ZmZ lngm fZ* cb [noh Zigbdnlbhl g^eZbfl bk
eZ bg ^nf) ^m k^ebjnbm ^nf ^q^k* dZ] dZkbnhf^g [noh cc iZebdnlb+
\bmnl+ .0 @m Ziieb\nbm <gmbh\anl ) .0<gmbhdZl lnlmhch mb^l ?hkZ ln
lni^k ?hkZf \nf \^gmnf ob`bgmb  bfmn ]ob]^bfbZ mdlmZgb dh*
fbeeb[nl obkhknf [^eeb`^kZmhknf) ohmhc ilmbgbgd bk ZlmnhgbZbl
^m h\mh fbeeb[nl ^jnbmnf7 .1 ^m mdlmZgbZbl kZbm^eb+ .1EblZilnih
\bk\nbobm \bobmZm^f) ^m gZo^l ZfZ* fb^lm) bk eZboZb ikblbZkmbgh b c*
kb Z\\^ll^kngm7 ^m o^qZ[Zgm \bob* khl inll+ Eb^ liZn] fb^lm b
mZm^f Z m^kkZ) ^m fZkb) ^m g^fb* lZnlnfhl bk b ckhl) bk gb^dZf
g^f lbg^[Zgm bg`k^]b) o^e ^`k^]b+ g^e^b]h g^b ^bmb g^b b^bmb+
Onh mZkin Zmordh b Mh*
.2
Q^gbm Znm^f Inf^gbnl) ^m 02
jnb \nf ^h _n^kZgm) Z[nk[^ Mh* fhl fb^lmh Inf^gbcnl bk lncnh
fZ) aZ[^gm^l ^iblmheZl k^`b[nl) [nonlb^cb ln eZbdZbl dZkZebZfl bk
^b7 k^`bhgb[nl l\kbimZl) bg jnb[nl Zebfl) dnkbnhl^mZbdZl [noh iZ*
\hgmbg^[Zgmnk aZ^\7 .3 GP>DPN kZrmZ7 .3 Mhfg dhglneZl GP*
\hglne MhfZghknf) Kmhe^fZ^h >DEPNlbngbZ lo^bdbgbf dZkZebnb
k^`b lZenm^f+ .4 G^`ZmbDn]Z^hknf Kmhe^fb^cnb+ .4KZl fnl [noh Zm*
o^g^kngm Z] ghl Zfb\bghlmkb) k^* c l^ghl ikb^m^brlml bk ]kZn`rl*
ghoZgm^l ikblmbgZf Zfb\bmbZf) ^m ml ZmgZncbgmb r] iZlbngmbgbZb)
lh\b^mZm^f) fbllb Z Nbfhg^ ikbg* fl ikb^m^ebZb)ZmlblmborkbZnlbh*
\bi^NZ\^k]hmnf)^m ihineh Dn]Z^* ch dngb`h Nbfhgh bk r] mZn*
hknf+ .5 <mmne^kngm Znm^f ^m \er* mhl+ .5Eb^ mZbi iZm Zmg^ bk Znd*
i^nf Znk^nf fgZknf fbee^+ lbg mdlmZgbh fbgldr]+ .6OZb*
.6 KeZ\nbm bmZjn^ gh[bl l\kb[^k^ `b fnfl iZmbdh iZkZrmb dZkZ*
k^`b[nl) ^m k^`bhgb[nl nm ghg bg* ebZfl bk Zebfl) dZ] g^]Zkrm
_^kZgm beebl fZeZ) g^jn^ bfin`* cb^fl ibdmZ bk g^dZkbZnm ikb^
g^gm ^hl) ^m \bobmZm^l ^hknf) ^m cnhl) g^b ikb^ c fb^lmnl) g^b
k^`bhg^l ^hknf7 ^m nm ghg _^kZgm ikb^ c dkZmnl) bk dZ] g^iZ]m
Znqbebnf in`gZgmb[nl Z]o^klnl mb^fl) dnkb^ ikb^ cnhl dhohcZ+
^hl+ /-Qblnf Znm^f^lm gh[blZ\* /- H^l fb^en ghkn ikbff^ b
\bi^k^ Z[^bl\eri^nf+ /. Nbjnb ^k* c ldr]+ /. OZb`b c^b dnkb^ g^]h*
`h i^lmbe^gm^lk^_n`^kngm]^k^`bh* kebZb Zm[`h b c Zeb^l iZl cnl)
=iodjf\n dm opj i\p_jejnd+  %gg&
0 s N K H T H Z ,
d L`idfdejn %Fpju\k\n
BE+&+  , 2 V Y w &  O`ijqn f\i\id`d
hd`no\n kmd` P\mk`hn emjn) i`ojgd
ipj G\mhgdj f\gij+ Pj hd`noj kgj*
o\n 0 G\m+ 1).. q\_di\nd J`a\o*@jm+
%.2& ; \ T L U P Q \ Z &  Lgb+ .1)/1+  %.3&
9 \ J PQ \ Z &  C\g kdmh f\mo fjinpgp n*
gdifo\n .06 h+ kdmh Gm+ Hp^dpn ?\g*
idpn Ldnj+ @m\pb np epj \iompjep fji*
npgp ]pqj I\m^pn Ljkdgdpn H\`i\n+
}  = [ V S L T P L Q \ P ,  =dbdkoj f\m\gdpd L oj*
g`hd`epd REE Bdnfjipd %Aq`mb`opd EE&)
fpmn) hdmpn ej ]mjgdpd Bdgjh`ojipd)

qd`k\o\qj _\m /6 h`opn %.13 ..4


kdmh Gm+&+ @pj_\h\n d\ odf qd`ij
ojfdj g\dfj ipjm\\n) i`n qdnd fdod
]pqj d ed k\i\n %kgb+ // `+&+  %.5&
A v R Z [ H U n PV  T PU \ &&& 
?d\[ i`n\fjh\)
f\_ nft_\n ]op nqmn ofno\io hd*
i8 od`f hdi edn ]pqj q`mo\n %kgb+
.1)/1&+  %.6& : \ T Z  W H [ PR V &&&  Ppj
k\dp mjhi\d kmdndh k\m`db m`d*
f\g` bdiod t_ o\po+  %/.& / [ I s N V 
Pk  Qw  k H S PL Z &&&  L\i\d o`dn b\qj q*
gd\p Amj_\n d ^d`njmd\pn =pbpnoj
kmd` qdnpn k\]bpndpn d Njhjn q\g*
not] t_pn+

Turinys

*(*

# 3,1! #' $ $ $ )

g^ bilhknf Z] ohl) mkZ]bm^ ^hl Zmb]nhdbm^ cnhl orkbZnlbZf dngb*
Nbfhgb ikbg\bib lZ\^k]hmnf) nm `nb Nbfhgnb) dZ] cnhl gn[Znlm)
obg]b\^m bg ^hl l^\ng]nf e^`^f ^b]ZfZl lZoh lmZmrfn+
lnZf+
//
CZ^\ Z^]^f l\kbimZ lngm //
Ohdb iZm ]Zerd [noh iZ
?^f^mkbh k^`b) ^m <mmZeh) ^m <kbZ* kZrmZ dZkZebnb ?^f^mkbcnb) <mZenb)
kZmab) ^m <klZ\b) /0 ^m bg hfg^l <kbZkZmnb) <klZdnb /0 bkoblnl dkZ*
k^`bhg^l7 ^m GZfilZ\h) ^m NiZkmbZ* mnl7 c GZfilZd) NiZkmb^bZfl) c
mbl) ^m bg ?^enf) ^m bg Hrg]nf) ?^e)  Hbg])  Nbdbhg)  FZkb*
^m bg Nb\rhg^f) ^m bg >ZkbZf) ^m c)  Zf) c KZfibebc)  Gbdbc) 
bg NZfnf) ^m bg KZfiarebZf) ^m <ebdZkgZl)  Fh)  Nb])  <kZ*
bg Gr\bZf) ^m bg <eb\ZkgZllnf)^m ])  Mh])  KZle)  Bhkmbg) 
bg >hh) ^m bg Nb]^g) ^m bg <kZ* Bgb])  Fbik bk  Fbk^g+ /1 E
]hg) ^m bg Mah]nf) ^m bg KaZl^* `b gnhkZ cb^Zmlbngm orkbZnlbZf
eb]^f) ^m bg BhkmrgZf) ^m Bgb* dngb`nb Nbfhgnb bk r] mZnmZb+
]nf) ^m >riknf) ^m >rk^g^g+
/1 @q^fienf Znm^f^hknf l\kbi*
l^kngm Nbfhgb ikbg\bib lZ\^k]h*
mnf) ^m ihineh Dn]Z^hknf+
/2
<gmbh\anl Znm^fk^q Ziieb* /2 FZkZebnl <gmbhdZl Zi`ne
\nbm \ZlmkZ bg ?hkZf l^\ng]h) ?hk cZn Zgmk ]b^g) gnheZm c
Z]fho^gl ^b l^fi^k fZgnl) ^m b ine]ZfZl bk lmZmr]ZfZl dZkhiZ*
fZ\abgZl _Z\b^gl7 ^m \hg\enlbm [denl8 cbl n]Zk Okb_hg) dZ]
mZlZb g^b^bm+
Okriahg^f) g^ ikh\^]^k^m+
/-
@m fblbmZ] ^nf Nbfhg]nh /3 NbfhgZl Zmlbngm cZf iZ*
fbeebZ obkhknf ^e^\mhknf bg Zn* `Ze[hg ]n mdlmZgbnkbgdmbgbor*
qbebnf) ^m Zk`^gmnf) ^mZnknf) ^m k) lb]Z[kh) Zndlh bk]Zn` `bgde+
oZlZ \hibhlZ7 /4 ^m ghenbm ^Z Z\* /4 =^m mZlZb g^ghkch ikbbfmb+ Ebl
\bi^k^) l^] knibm hfgbZ) jnZ^ iZ\* iZo^km gb^dn oblZ) d ZgdlbZn
mnl ^lm \nf ^h Zgm^Z) ^m Zeb^gZ* [noh ln cnh lnmZkl) bk gnlb`k*
 gnh ch+
obm l^ Z[ ^h+

%//& < X` Xge\]h \4 Otmdejn f\m\gdpd


@`h`omdepd EE) fpmn b\g _\m opj h`op
i`]pqj k\o`fn d k\mo i`g\dnq+ 
9 gT^ 4 L`mb\hj f\m\gdpd =o\gpd EE8
=o\g\n EEE km\_ej qd`k\o\pod i`
\ifnd\p) f\dk .05+ h+  9 e\TeTgh \4
G\k\_jfdejn f\m\gdpd =md\m\opd R
%.3/ .0. kdmh Gm+&+  9 efT^h \4 k\m*
o f\m\gdpd =mn\fpd %qu+ \pf+ .1)/&+
 %/0& , C T ` c fT ^ ( H\hkn\f\n Id*
udejn hd`no\n8 ]`o bm+ o+ d\ tm\ fd*
o\n q\m_\n7 O\hkn\h\n) fpmdj qd`o\
i`dijh\+  J cT eg\X}\T ` f( Ru+ ./)4+
 , < X_( I\d\pnd\ Gdfg\_p n\g\+
 , D \aW4 k\emdj hd`no\n G\mdejn
kmjqdi^deje`+  , J \^\ba ( Rd`i\n
nq\m]`nide L`gjkji`nj hd`no) d q\*
f\mpn ipj Gjmdioj+ + B be\]( I\j*
ndjn =udejn kmjqdi^de\ kd`oq\f\mdp k\*

emte`+ Rtmd\pnd\n ejn hd`no\n =gd*


f\mi\n\n+  xT` ((( \h\n) Gj\n)
Nj_\n* Gdkm\n n\g q\m_\d+ L\hkdgde\
dm Hdfde\ I\+ =udejn kmjqdi^de q\m*
_\d+ Od_)L\ngdn)Cid_\n hd`no\dI\+
=udeje`) Cjmodi\ Gm`ojn n\gje`) =m\*
_\n L`idfdeje` kmd` Ag`po`mj pkn)
Gdm`i Hd]dejn hd`no\n =amdfje`+
%/2& 9 age W\Xa( G\dk odf hd`n*
o\n ]pqj \knpko\n d qdnpm) =iodjf\n
e\p \iom _d`i km\_ej \modiod n\qj
f\mdpjh`i kmd` hd`noj %kgb+ .0+.1 `+&+
%/3& J \` ba Tf Tgf\hag((( Bg+ Fpj*
u\kj k\n\fjedhp) Odhjij ndpid\h
k\b\g] =iodjf\n km\_dje` kmddh_\*
qn np i`h\p _d\pbnhp) ]`o \knp*
kn e\p ]b\io n\qj kmd` Pmdaji)
edn k\ndepio\ b\gn k\ndodfod n\qj e*
bjhdn) \onophd\ i\pe Odhjij \ondn*

Turinys

. H<F+ .2) / 5 *0 2

/-0

/N
@m fblbm Z] ^nf <ma^gh* /5
Kh mh cbl Zmlbngm iZl cob^*
[bnf ngnf ]^ Zfb\bl lnbl) nm g lZoh ikb^m^e) <m^gh[bc)lncnh
mkZ\mZk^m \nf bilh) ]b\^gl7 Qhl ]^kmbl bk iZlZdrmb7 EleZbdhm^iZ*
m^g^mbl Dhii^g) ^m BZsZkZf)^m Zk* f fZgh dZkZerlml fb^lmnl Eh*
\^f) jnZ^ ^lm bg D^knlZe^f) \bob* i) BZsZkbk ibe E^knsZec^+ /6E
mZm^l k^`gb f^b7 /6_bg^l^Zknf ]^* iehmnl cl lngZbdbghm^) iZ]Zkm^
lheZlmbl) ^m _^\blmbl ieZ`Zf fZ`* ]Zn` Zehl Zerc^ bk iZlbfm^
gZf bgm^kkZ) ^m ]hfbgZmb^lmbl i^k ]Zn`fZghdZkZerlmlob^m+0-OZb*
eh\Z fnemZ bg k^`gh f ^h+0-Ing\ `b ]Z[Zk Zmb]nhdbm^ fb^lmnl) dn*
^k`h mkZ]bm^ \bobmZm^l) jnZl h\\n* knhl ^lZm^ iZf) bk fhd^lbnl
iZlmbl) ^m mkb[nmZ eh\hknf) bg jnb* b m ob^m) dnkbZl cl oZe]m^
[nl ]hfbgZmb ^lmbl ^qmkZ _bg^l Dn* g^ En]chl lb^ghl^+ 0. J c^b g^)
]Z^Z^+ 0.Nbg Znm^f) ]Zm^ ikh beebl mZb ]nhdbm^ n cnhl i^gdbl bf*
jnbg`^gmZ mZe^gmZ Zk`^gmb) ^m ^q* mnl mZe^gm lb]Z[kh bk dbmnl i^g*
m^kfbgbb) jnh] ^qm^kfbgZlmbl) ^m dbl bfmnl mZe^gm lb]Z[kh n c*
mkb[nmhknf \bobmZmnf ZebZ mZe^gmZ l iZ]Zkrmnl lngZbdbgbfnl bk n
jnbg`^gmZ7 lbg Znm^f) o^gb^fnl) fb^lm fhd^lbnl8dbmZbi f^lZm^b*
^m ^qin`gZ[bfnl ohl+ 0/@m o^gbm lbf^bk dhohlbf^ ikb^ cnl+ 0/OZb*
<ma^gh[bnl Zfb\nl k^`bl bg e^kn* `b dZkZebZnl ikb^m^ebl <m^gh[bcnl
lZe^f) ^m ob]bm `ehkbZf Nbfhgbl) Zmordh  E^knsZe8 cbl iZfZm Nb*
^m \eZkbmZm^f bg Znkh) ^m Zk`^gmh) fhgh `Zk[bg`nf) Zndlh bk lb*
^m ZiiZkZmnf \hibhlnf7 ^m h[* ]Z[kh [ebs`cbf bk ]b]^e inh*
lmninbm7 ^m k^mnebm ^b o^k[ZM^`bl+ gnf) bk [noh gnlm^[bgmZl8cblikZ*
g^ cZf dZkZebZnl h]bnl+
00
@m k^lihg]bm ^bNbfhg)^m]b* 00 EZf ZmlZdr]ZfZl NbfhgZl
qbm^b7I^jn^Zeb^gZfm^kkZflnfi* mZk7 No^mbfhl ^fl f^l g^n*
lbfnl) g^jn^ Zeb^gZ ]^mbg^fnl7 ff bk g^eZbdhf^ iZf mh) dZl
l^] a^k^]bmZm^f iZmknf ghlmkh* lo^mbfZ) mbdmZb fl mo iZebdb*
knf)jnZ^bgbnlm^ Z[ bgbfb\bl ghl* f) dnkl fl g^ikb^m^eb dnk
mkbl Zebjnhm^fihk^ ihll^llZ ^lm+ eZbd [noh g^m^blbg`Zb oZe]hfZl+
01 Ihlo^kh m^finl aZ[^gm^l)obg* 01 @lZgm `b iZmh`bZf f^mnb) f^l
]b\Zfnl a^k^]bmZm^f iZmknf gh* lm^g`bZfl Zmlbbfmb fl moiZ*
12' F ]e Ehil bk BZsZ*
lmkhknf+ 02 IZf ]^ Dhii^) ^mBZ* ebdbf+ 0
sZkZjnZ^ ^qihlmneZl) bilb _Z\b^* khl) dnkb mn k^bdZeZncb) mZbchl iZ*
[Zgm bg ihinehieZ`Zf fZ`gZf) bhl ]Zk ]Zn` Zehl mZnmhc^ bk
^m bg k^`bhg^ ghlmkZ7 ahknkg ]Z* fl Zerc^8 mZbZn n cZl f^l
o k\b\g] dm) k\i\d\d f\dk _\m fdod
Otmdejn f\m\gd\d) \onddh\ qdnpn n\qj
k\\_pn+
%/5& A f  _T\^ b gX((( G\m\gdpn k`m n\*
qj k\ndpiodi _\mj t_\hn _d_`gdp
kmd`f\dop) npodif\ _\m k\gdfod k\d
Fp_e q\g_tod Odhjipd) ]`o m`df\g\p*
e\ bmdiod k\nfpodid\dn g\df\dn t_
\ob\popn hd`nopn dm =iodjfj[Akda\ij
k\no\oto kdgd F`mpu\ge`) ndgj epjn
]m\ibd\d dkdmfod dm bmnj f\mp+ 
%0.& K T_Xa g(
t_ o\g`io\n ]pqj

q`mo\n \kd` .4+--- gdo+


 %0/& 9 h^fb
\e((( =ijo bm+ o+7 o\pmd nkdio %m`kj*
ndojmdph ^\gd^ph& np \pfndid\dn dm nd*
_\]mdid\dn di_\dn dm b\pndib +o\mi
_\pbt]+ Lgb+ ..)25+
%00& JiXg\` bf((( Odhji\n \on\fj
m\hd\d dm b\i\ d_d_d\d+  %02& K Th '
g b ]X 4 t_\hn+ Ppjn hd`nopn Odhj*
i\n q\g_j f\mj o`dnhdn+ =ogtbdidhj
p epjn b\gej m`df\g\pod =iodjf\n) f\d
m\ Odhjipd k\\_ g\df) ]`o dm
_\]\m edn npodif\ k\hjfod) fd`f m\i*
_\ o`dndib\+

Turinys

54-

. H<F+ .3) 03}.4) 0

fnl mZe^gmZ \^gmnf+ @m ghg k^*


lihg]bm ^b <ma^gh[bnl o^k[nf+
03 M^o^klnl Znm^f \nf bkZ Z] k^*
`^f) k^gng\bZobm ^b o^k[Z blmZ) ^m
`ehkbZf Nbfhgbl)^mngbo^klZ)jnZ^
ob]bm) ^m bkZmnl ^lm k^q bkZ fZ`gZ+

]nhlbf^ bfm mZe^gm+ <m^gh[b*


cnl g^ZmlZd cZf g h]bh+ 0-Ebl
ibdmZl ln`kh iZl dZkZeb) ikZ*
g^ cZf bmnhl h]bnl bk Zib^
Nbfhgh `Zk[bg`nf bk oblZ) d
[noh fZml8 mnhf^m dZkZebnl eZ*
[Zb irdh+
Onh mZkin Okb_hgZl iZ[`h
04
Okriahg Znm^f _n`bm gZob 04
bgJkmahlbZ]Z+ 0
 5 @m \hglmbmnbmk^q eZbon  Jkmhsbc+ 05 Kh mh dZkZebnl
4
>^g]^[Z^nf ]n\^f fZkbmbfnf) iZldrk iZckbh oZ]n F^g]^[b^c
^m ^q^k\bmnf i^]bmnf ^m^jnbmnf bk ]ZocZf ilmbgbgd bk kZbm^eb+
]^]bm beeb+ 06' @m fZg]Zobm beeb fh* 06 Ebl eb^i cZf ^bmb ln dZkbnhf^*
o^k^ \ZlmkZ \hgmkZ _Z\b^f Dn]Z^* g^ ikb^ En]c) lZd cZf lnlmb*
Z^7 ^m fZg]Zobm ^b Z^]b_b\Zk^ B^* ikbgmb B^]hk) n]Zkrmb fb^lmh
]hk^f) ^m h[lmkn^k^ ihkmZl \bob* oZkmnl bk dhohmb ikb^ mZnm+ FZ*
mZmbl) ^m ]^[^eeZk^ ihinenf+ M^q kZebnl `b obchlb Okb_hg+
Znm^f i^kl^jn^[Zmnk Okriahg^f+
1-
@mi^ko^gbm>^g]^[Z^nlDZf* 1- F^g^]^[b^cnl Zmordh EZf*
gbZf) ^m \h^ibm bkkbmZk^ ie^[^f) gbc bk ikZ]ch ^ksbgmb mZnm) gZb*
^m \hg\ne\Zk^ en]Z^Zf) ^m \Zimb* dbgmb En]c) `Zn]rmb fhg^l bk
oZk^ ihinenf) ^m bgm^k_b\^k^) ^m nfnbgmb) bk lmbikbgmb B^]hk+
Z^]b_b\Zk^ B^]hk^f+ 1. @m \heeh* 1.Ebl iZlmZm m^gZb kZbm^eb bk dZ*
\Zobm beeb\ ^jnbm^l) ^m ^q^k\bmnf7 kbnhf^gl) dZ] b^b]Zfb oZbdbh*
nm ^`k^llb i^kZf[neZk^gm obZf m En]chl d^ebZbl) mZbi dZbi [n*
en]Z^Z^) lb\nm \hglmbmnbm ^b k^q+
oh cZf lZdl dZkZebnl+
6L[`_ HG;% . @mZl\^g]bmeh*
', [P]^Vb]TXL^% .EhgZl Zm*
Zgg^l ]^ BZsZkbl)^m gng\bZobmNb* ordh b BZsZkhl bk ikZg^ lZ*
fhgb iZmkb lnh jnZ^ _^\bm >^g* oh monb Nbfhgnb) d F^g]^[b^*
]^[Z^nl bg ihineh bilhknf+ /@m cnl ]Zk ikb^ c mZnm+ /Onhf^m
oh\Zobm Nbfhg ]nhl _bebhl l^gbh* NbfhgZl iZlbZnd]n ork^lgbnh*
k^l) en]Zf) $^ m DhZg^f) ^m Zbm cn lg En] bk Ehg bkcb^fl mZ*
beebl7 @`h) ^m _kZmk^l f^b) ^m ]h* k7 <) fZgh [khebZb bk fZgh m*
fnl iZmkbl f^b ^qin`gZobfnl oh gZfZb dhohchf^ ikb^ DskZ^*
ahlm^l DlkZ^e Z[ Z]he^l\^gmbZ nl* ebh ikb^nl gnh iZm cZngrlml bdb
jn^ bg ang\ ]b^f7 ^m ikhli^kZ* bZb ]b^gZb) bk d^e^m lrdb iZlb*
mnf ^lm bg fZgb[nl ghlmkbl eb[^* l^d fl kZgdhfbl boZ]nhmb Ds*
kZk^ DlkZ^e Zebjnhmb^l+ 0 Ing\ Zn* kZ^e+ 0 ?Z[Zk `b Z iZl^gZn) mh*
m^f l^gnb) l^] ^lmhm^ eh\h f^h) ]e cl [dbm^ fZgh ob^mhc^ bk

%04& CT\ih  F egbm\]( Pmdojipd)


ijmn edn ]pqj d qdn kpnd \knpko\n
@jmje`) k\qtfj domfod dm k\nd`fod
Kmojude) L`idfdejn pjno) d d\pm
ipj Pmdkjgd`n) i`ojgd ipj ojn qd`ojn)
fpm do`f\ d em Ag`po`m\n+ G\m\gdpn
qdejnd Pmdaji ojgd\p dm php ed =k\*
heje`) ,f\h` Pmdaji\n ]pqj p\p*
bn %Fpju\k\n Bg+&+ G`i_`]d`epn ]p*
qj k\gdfo\n Otmdejn k\emdj qd`odidi*

fp+  %06& > XW be( Cm+ o+7 G`_mji)


%kgb+ .3)6&+ Fdn opmej ]od i`ojgd ipj
F\hidejn) b\g _\]\modin G\omjn qd`*
oje`+
%1-& AT ` a \] ( Lgb+ .-)36+
%.3).& @y > T m T eb f4 f\h` Fji\n
btq`ij %.0)21&+ C\u\m\ ?PQJ i`g\*
]\d ojgd ipj F\hidejn dm G`_mjij+ 
%/& <h ileXfa \h b]h ( Fdn opmej _\m
om`d ni I\o\ode %.1 `+&+  %0&

Turinys

. H<F+ .3) 1}.-

54.

^m _kZmk^l f^b) ^m ^`k^llb in`gZ*


m^ ikh `^gm^ ghlmkZ7 Znqbebnf o^*
kh ]^ \Z^eh oh[bl\nf lbm+ 1 @m
^e^`bm ]^ k^`bhg^ ob`bgmb fbeebZ
obkhknf [^eeb`^kZmhknf) ^m ^jnb*
m^l8 ^m ikh_^\mb lngm Z] >^g]^*
[Z^nf7 ^m ]hkfb^kngm bg Hh]bg+
2 @m lnkk^q^kngmfZg^)^mZ[b^*
kngm bg \Zfinf7 ^m ^\\^ ^q^k\b*
mnl \hibhlnl bg h[obZf beebl i^*
]b_nf) ^m ^jnbmnf) ^m _enobnl mhk*
k^gl ^kZm bgm^k f^]bnf bilhknf+
5 @m Z]fhobm \ZlmkZ \hgmkZ_Z\b^f
^hknfbil^) ^m ihinenl ^bnl) ^mob*
]bm ihinenf mk^ib]Zgm^f Z]mkZgl*
_k^mZg]nf mhkk^gm^f) ^m mkZgl*
_k^mZobm ikbfnl7 ^m ob]^kngm ^nf
obkb) ^m mkZglb^kngmihlm ^nf+ 4 @m
]boblbm ihinenf) ^m ^jnbm^l bgf^*
]bh i^]bmnf7 ^kZm Znm^f ^jnbmZ*
mnl Z]o^klZkbhknf \hibhlnl gb*
fbl+ 5 @m ^q\eZfZo^kngm lZ\kblmn*
[bl) ^m bg _n`Zf \hgo^klnl ^lm
>^g]^[Z^nl) ^m \ZlmkZ ^bnl7 ^m\^*
\b]^kngm^q ^bl fnemb oneg^kZmb7 k^*
lb]nb Znm^f bg fngbmbhg^f _n`^*
kngm+ 6 Ong\ oneg^kZmnl ^lm en*
]Zl _kZm^k DhZggbl7 DhZgg^l Zn*
m^f bgl^\nmnl ^lm ^hl) ]hg^\ o^*
gbm >^]khg^f) jnZf Z^]b_b\Zobm7
.- ^m _n`^kngm nljn^ Z] mnkk^l)
jnZ^ ^kZgm bg Z`kbl <shmb) ^m ln\*
\^g]bm ^Zl b`gb+ @m \^\b]^kngm^q
beebl ]nh fbeebZ obkhknf) ^mk^o^k*
lnl ^lm bg en]Z^Zf bg iZ\^+

fZgh [khebZb) bk bcdhohdbm^ n


fl mZnm8 ]Zg`Znl `b iZ`Ze[Z
m^[gb^ ln cnfbl 1 Onhf^m E b l 
lnlbkbgdh b Zeb^l ]ob]^bfmmd*
lmZgb ork dhohmhc bk kZbm^eb+
bmb^ bch ikb^ F^g]^[b^c bk
gZdohch Hh]bg^+
2<mlbde krmf^m cb^ ch c er*
`nf+ mZb cb^fl ikb^Zbl ch`Zn*
lbg`Z dZkbnhf^g ilmbgbgd bk
kZbm^eb8 mZbZn mZki c [noh ni^*
ebl+ 3 Onhf^m cbl ln oblZ lZoh dZ*
kbnhf^g^ lnlmhch mb^l ZgZbl bk)
fZmr]ZfZl lZoh fhg^l [bcZgm
[kblmb i^k ni^e) iZml i^k[kb]h
ibkfZl+ KZfZm c) orkZbi^k[kb]h
iZldnb+ 4 Ebl iZ]Zebgh lZoh dZ*
kbnhf^g bk iZlmZm kZbm^ebnl mZki
ilmbgbgd8 ikb^ `b kZbmZkbcZ [n*
oh eZ[Zb `Znlbg`Z+ 5 Ebl lnmkbfb*
mZoh o^gmZbl mkbfbmZbl) bk F^g]^*
[b^cnl ln lZoh dZkbnhf^g^ [noh
ikbo^klmZl [`mb8]Zn` c dkbmh ln*
^blm) dbmb `b iZ[`h  mobkmho+
6 Onhf^m [noh ln^blmZl Ehgh
[kheblEn]Zl8 [^m EhgZl obchlbcnhl)
bdb Zmordh  F^]khg) dnk ZgZl
[noh lnlmbikbgl+ .-Kh mh cb^ [*
` h c [hdmnl) [nonlbnl<shmh eZn*
dnhl^8 mZbZn cbl cnhl iZ]^`+
Fkbmh b Zg ]n mdlmZgbn ork)
bk cbl kZfbZb ln`kh  En]c+

P V K s S  Qv Z  I v R P [ L &&&  =ijo bm+ o + 7 epn


%@d`qj& h\gji` `n\o` \hd\pn nodk*
mphje`) oj_g nojfdo` h\ij dm h\ij
]mjgdj qd`oji dm de+++  %1& : V K P %
U L ,  I\f\]d`e oqdfe` %kgb+ /).8
.0)/2&+
%2& B W L SPZ &  C\g p\_d Np]di+  %3&
A \ V T L [  Q P Z ,  Fji\n) fpmn ]pqj Odhj*
ij k\nfdmo\n qdnjn f\mdpjh`in q\*
_p %.0)20&+  %5& @ \ [ Y PT P[ H ] V  k ] L U %
[ H PZ &&&  Ru+ Of+ .-)6+  , [ ] P Y [ V ] q ,  
G`_mji %C`_jm&+  % 6 &  / U H Z ,  G`i*
_`]d`epn+  % . - &  , I V R k [ \ Z &&&  O \mbt*

]jn dm kd`h`i ]jfo`gd\d) d fpmd


]pqj q\gbjh\nd) \m f\mo\dn i`ndh\oj
\o`di\id kmd` dm pkpjgdf+  7 \ V Z 
W H K L N s &  =ijo bm+ o+7 Fji\n k\_`bn
=ujoj hd`no) fpmd e\p \ifnd\p ]p*
qj qd`i f\mo np_`bdin Fji\o\n+
Lgb+ .-)51+
.3).. /1+ Odhji\n _m\pb np n\qj
niphdn Fp_p dm I\o\odep ipp_jh\n
n\qj `ioj Lojg`hd`e\pn %.. .4&+ O\*
qj oqj Odhjij qd`o k\dh\ Fji\n
Emf\i\n %.5;/1&+

Turinys

54/

. H<F+ .3) . . *. 0

N! DTXZYZ XT]_T^% <ZYL^ ;]VLYL^%

..
@m Kmhe^fZ^nl _bebnl <[h[b ..
<[h[h lgnl Kmhe^fb^cn
\hglmbmnmnl ^kZm ]nqbg \ZfihD^* [noh iZlmZmrmZl oZ]n E^kbdh er*
kb\ah) ^m aZ[^[Zm Zk`^gmnf) ^m Zn* `nfhc^8 cbl mnkch ]Zn` Zndlh bk
knf fnemnf+ ./@kZm ^gbf `^g^k lb]Z[kh) ./ g^l [noh orkbZnlbhch
lnffb lZ\^k]hmbl+ .0 @m ^qZemZ* dngb`h ^gmZl+ .0 Eh bk]bl delb7
mnf ^lm \hk ^bnl) ^m ohe^[Zm h[* c inbdr[8 cbl iZghkchiZbfmblZn
mbg^k^ k^`bhg^f) ^m\h`bmZ[Zm ]h* Ze bk `Zeohch) dZbi deZlmZ `Ze*
enf Z]o^klnl Nbfhg^f) ^m _bebhl m iZZebgmb Nbfhg bk ch lgnl+
^bnl) nm mhee^k^m ^hl+
NbfhgZl`b)eZgdr]ZfZlfb^
.1
Nbfhg Znm^f) i^kZf[neZgl .1
\bobmZm^l) jnZ^ ^kZgm bg k^`bhg^ lmnl) [nonlbnl En]chl Zerc^) bk
Dn]Z^Z^) ^m lheb\bmn]bg^f `^k^gl cZbl kibg]Zfhl) Zmordh iZml ln
^Zknf) ]^l\^g]bm bg D^kb\ah bil^) lZoh lgnfbl HZmZmbcn bk En]n 
^m HZmaZmabZl _bebnl ^bnl) ^m en* E^kbd bfmZl l^imrgbZl ]^bfmbl
]Zl) Zggh \^gm^lbfh l^imnZ`^lb* l^imbgmZbl f^mZbl ob^gnhebdmZf^
fh l^imbfh) f^gl^ ng]^\bfh7 fg^lrc^) mZb rkZ lZ[Zmh fg^lr*
ab\ ^lm f^glbl NZ[Zma+ .2 @m lnl* c^+ .0 <[h[h lgnl ikbf cnhl
\^ibm ^hl _bebnl <[h[b bg fngb* deZlmbg`Zb mobkmhoec^) oZ]bgZfh*
mbng\neZf) jnZ^ oh\Zmnk ?h\a) c^ ?hdn) dnkb cbl [noh iZlmZml))
\nf ]heh) jnZf Z^]b_b\Zobm7^m_^* bk bde cb^fl ]b]^e ihdre8 mZ*
\bm ^bl \hgobobnffZ`gnf) ^m Z[* bZncbl mnkch iZleil m^gZb fh*
l\hg]bm beeb\ obkhl+ .3@m \nf bg^* gb+ .3Nbfhgnb bk ch lgnfl `*
[kbZmnl ^ll^m Nbfhg) ^m _bebb ^bnl) knl) Kmhe^fb^cnl ln lZoZblbZbl iZ*
lnkk^qbm Kmhe^fZ^nl \nf lnbl) ^m dbeh) iZlbf lZoh `bgdenl) ch
lnfil^kngm ZkfZ lnZ) ^m bgmkZo^*  ihdrebh ob^m bk nfn c) ]n
kngm bg \hgobobnf) ^m h\\b]^kngm ch lg bk d^e^m chmZkg+ .4 OZbi
^nf) ^m ]nhl _bebhl^bnl) ^m jnhl* cbl iZ]Zk ]b]^e gb^drlm DskZ^*
]Zfin^khl^bnl+ .4 @m _^\bm ]^\^i* erc^ bk Zmlber`bgh ibdmn n `^kZ+
mbhg^f fZ`gZf bg DlkZ^e) ^m k^]*
]b]bm fZeZ ikh [hgbl+
8 8 .5 Kmhe^fb^cnl iZkZ Zib^ mZb
.5
@m l\kbilbm aZ^\ Kmhe^fZ^nl)
 dZkZebnb bk gnlbngm iZl c) dZ]
^m fblbm k^`b nm fbmm^k^m ^b ^q^k* u
%..& 9 UbUb fahf G gb_X` \X]hf(((
=kd` do \nh`i _\pbd\p did fd*
opm i`m\i_\h`+ Cm\dfdf\n ej q\m*
_\n g`d_d\ h\itod) f\_ edn k\on \m
ej bdhdi ]pqj g\]d\p gdif kmd` bm\d*
fp kmjd+ Fdn ]pqj opmodib\n) i`n
b\gej q`nod k\od`n qtmd\pndjej fpid*
bj _pfo`md) dm b\g _\m g\]d\p km\gj]j
d k`gij) fpm opmej _pjod e\h k\*
q`nojn k\m`dbjn+ Odhji\n) k\ndodf*
_\h\n epj f\dk n\qj `iop) ]pqj ed
k\nftmn nq\m]djn qd`ojn F`mdfj gt*
bphje` qdmdidifp8 Lojg`hd`epn b\g
opmej n`mbod Fjm_\ij ]m\no\n+ Odhj*
ij d\pfodio\n edn \ondhjfej e\h
]e\pmd\pndj id`fj i`_fdibphp+ Fdn

ndb`d_ ]od qdnjn Fp_ejn fpidb\df*


dp dm oj_g nph\i ipp_tod qdn
Odhjij `dhti+
%.1& C Ta ^l W T` Tf((( O\qj n`i\oqn)
i`dm_\h\n) Odhji\n k\on g\if qd*
n\n n\q` f\m\gtnon qd`o\n dm ejhdn
mkdijnd+  x \` gTf(((4 R\n\mdj hi`*
nte` .02 h+ kdmh Gm+  %.2& < b^h 4
b\g oje` qd`oje`) f\h` _\]\m tm\ =di*
@pf+  %.3& ]Z eh f(((4 f\d q\gbt_\hd
dm b`m_\hd ]pqj k\nd_\m gdifnh`nid
dm h\d\p \on\mbn+  L {` hy ]\4 b\d
dm
 k\on _\gtq\p_\h\n p_tin`+
%.5& B TeT_\h \4 =iodjfpd Od_d`dpd*
B TW gT\c ]\f Tg\Whbf\f((( Lojg`hd`epn)
km\t_\h\n f\mdpjh`in) k\nd\_\

Turinys

. H<F+ .3) .6}/1

540

^bmnf bg Znqbebnf) ^m mkZ]^k^m ^b


^m \bobmZm^l ^hknf) ^m
mkb[nmZ+ .6 @m fblbm Zebhl bg BZ*
sZkZf mhee^k^ DhZgg^f7 ^m mkb[n*
gbl fblbm ^iblmheZl)nmo^gbk^gm Z]
l^) ^m ]Zk^m ^bl Zk`^gmnf) ^m Zn*
knf) ^m ]hgZ+ /- @m Zebhl fblbm
h\\niZk^ D^knlZe^f) ^m fhgm^f
m^fieb+

Zmlblm cZf  iZ`Ze[ dZkbnhf^*


gl) dZ] mZbicbl Zmb]nhlblcZfZ*
e) chlfb^lmnl bk f hd^lbnl+.6 Fb*
mnl cbl gnlbngm  BZsZk gnn*
]rmbEhgh bk gnlbngm eZbd md*
lmZgmbgbgdZfl) dZ] cb^ Zm^bm iZl
c) dZ] cbl ]nhlbl cb^fl lb]Z[kh)
Zndlh bk ]hoZg+ /- Fbmnl oe cbl
gnlbngm iZbfmb E^knsZel bk [Z*
grbhl dZegh+
/.
@mikZ^\nkk^gljnb]Zf) gng* /.
=^m ob^gZl fh`nlZgdlb
\bZobm ehZggb bg BZsZkZ) jnbZ i^* Zmordl ikZg^ Ehgnb BZsZkhc^)
kbbm iZm^k ^bnl) ^m _kZmk^l ^bnl) ^m dZ] ch moZl bk ch [khebZb noh)bk
jnbZ fblbm m^ jnhjn^ bgm^k_b\b+ dZ] ZgZl rkZ blbngml mZbi iZm
// Pm Zn]bobm Znm^f) o^a^f^gm^k mZol nfnmb+ // FZbi mbd cbl mZb
^qiZobm7 ^m \hfik^a^g]bm obkhl) b`bk]h) eZ[Zb gnlb`Zg]h) gnmok
jnb o^g^kZgm i^k]^k^ ^nf) ^mh\*  mnhl orknl) dnkb^ [noh Zmc ch
\b]bm ^hl7 \h`ghobm ^gbf jnbZ b gnn]rmb) bk nfn cnhl)g^l cbl
jnZ^k^[Zgm ^nf i^k]^k^+
bghch) dZ]cb^ mrdhch chgnn]rmb+
/0
@m \^m^kZ l^kfhgnf DhZg* /0
Fbmb Ehgh ]Zk[Zb) ch dZkZb) c
gbl) ^m [^eehknf ^bnl) ^m [hgZknf ]kll r`bZb) dnkbnhl cbl [n]kbZb
obkmnmnf) jnb[nl _hkmbm^k `^llbm) Zmebdh) iZlmZmrfZl lb^g) dnkbZl
^m Z^]b_b\bb fnkhknf) jnhl ^qmkn* cbl bo^]) bk oblZl ch o^bdbfZl)
qbm) ^m k^knf `^lmZknf ^bnl7 /1 ^\* /1 mZb mZb rkZ ZikZrmZ ch dngb*
\^ aZ^\ l\kbimZ lngm bg eb[kh ]b^* `rlml ]b^g dgr`hc^) gnh mh
knf lZ\^k]hmbb ^bnl) ^q jnh _Z\* f^mh) dZb cbl ih lZoh moh
mnl ikbg\^il lZ\^k]hmnf ihlm iZ* lmhchorkbZnlbnhcndngb`n+
mk^f lnnf+

k^`bhg^f )

\od_pjod =iodjfpd qdn \g np ejn o`f e\p kdmh\dn h`o\dn f\md\pod kmd`
hd`no\dn) i`\]`ej_\h\n) f\_ f\m\gdpn =iodjf Od_d`o) fpmn ]pqj \kbpgn
k\gdfn d\ e k\o n\qj qd`odidifp) \m ' F`mpu\g) o\d\p kj b\i\ dgbjn fjqjn
q\g_jqp+ Ijf`nd\d bm+ o+ i`hdidhd+ npodfn k\_\mtod np Fjip o\df+ R*
 %.6& , > T m T eT 4 f\h` Fji\n btq`* gd\p Fjipd k\qtf i`o _\m km\kgnod+
ij %.0)21&+  %/-& : T { a l }\b f ^ T _a b 4 Fp_ejn md]\n+ Op Fjij Emf\ij hdm*
d fpmdj ]pqj k\_\mto\ odfm\ oqdm* odhd km\nd_ej I\f\]d`e `dhtijn
ojq+
gpbdh\n+ Fj \did\d i`]pqj k\q`g_*
%/0+/1& B \g\ Ab a b  W TeUT\((( . I\f+ e I\f\]d`e b\]php) k\ndthej bj*
fitb\ ]\dbd\h\ k\n\fjedhp \kd` Od* _php) fjqjej o\mk n\qn _g q\g_djn
hjij hdmo dm g\dhdib Fjij Emf\ij dm 30 h+ kdmh Gm+ k\ndfqd`o o`dnep
dndb`g]edh+ Fjij dnojmdejn \pojmdpn dm o\mkdidifp n\qj ]tgje` Ljhkep+
i`_pj_\) i`n edn k\on odfmd\pnd\d bt* P\n\d \oej np Njhjn g`bdji\dn) k\*
q`ij oj fpidb\dfdj g\df\dn) o\d\p h eb\ F`mpu\g) dm f`gdjgdf\d h`op
edn ipmj_j ejn \godidpn) ]o`io) h`o* km\ngdifpn t_\hn ]pqj kmdh`no\
m\dpn) fpmd`) _`e\) dfd hn _d`i Amj_j _di\node\) dfd k\b\gd\p Pdo\n 4-
i`dgdfj+ =ijo Fpju\kj BH) Emf\i\n h+ kj Gm+ npbmdjq F`mpu\g dm \h*
qd`k\o\qn 0. h`opn dm \ogdfn b\i\ di\d k\i\dfdij Fp_ejn i`kmdfg\pnj*
_\pb b\m]dib _\m]+ Rdn kdmh\ e\h  ht]+

Turinys

You might also like