Professional Documents
Culture Documents
H.street Revitalization Part1
H.street Revitalization Part1
E X E C UT IV E S U M M A RY
ii
1 I NT R O D U CT I O N
1.1 A Top Priority
1.2 Plan Goals & Objectives
1.3 Key Community Issues
1.4 Study Area
1.5 Planning Process
1
1
1
1
2
2
2 P L A N N I N G C O NT E XT
2.1 Strategic Location in City
2.2 Private Development
2.3 District Initiatives
4
4
5
6
3 M A R K ET C O N D IT I O N S
S U M M A RY
3.1 Methodology
3.2 Economic Overview
3.3 Market Analysis
8
8
8
8
4 R ET A I L E NV I R O N M E NT
4.1 Overview of Issues
4.2 Market Context
4.3 Retail Audit
11
11
11
13
5 C O N D IT I O N S A S S E S S M E NT
5.1 Land Use, Zoning & Development
5.2 Retail Environment
5.3 Traffic,Transit & Parking
5.4 Public Realm
16
16
22
23
28
6 C HA L L E N G E S &
O P P O RT U N IT I E S
6.1 Land Use, Zoning & Development
6.2 Retail Environment
6.3 Traffic,Transit & Parking
6.4 Public Realm
30
30
30
31
31
7 VISION &
PL A N F R A M E W O R K
7.1 Vision
7.2 Plan Framework
8 ST R AT E G I C D EV E L O P M E NT
P LA N
8.1 Development Program Overview
8.2 Strategic Development Plan by
District
8.3 Corridor-Wide Transportation
Improvements
9 I M P L E M E NT AT I O N
9.1 Land Use, Zoning & Development
9.2 Retail Environment
9.3 Traffic,Transit & Parking
9.4 Public Realm
50
50
51
52
52
A C K N OW L E D G E M E NT S
53
APPENDIX A M A R K ET A N A LY S I S
58
APPENDIX B M E R C H A NT A N D C O N S U M E R
S U RV EY S A N D S U M M A R I E S
74
32
32
33
APPENDIX C N O N - P R E F E R R E D ST R E ET
S E CT I O N A LT E R N AT IV E S
80
35
35
APPENDIX D E C O N O M I C D EV E L O P M E NT
I N C E NT IV E S I N
O U R N AT I O N S C A P IT A L
87
36
48
H S T R E E T N E S T R AT E G I C D E V E L O P M E N T P L A N
Gallaudet University
Trinidad
Near Northeast
Carver Langston
H Street NE
The White House
Stanton Park
Kingman
Union Station
RFK Stadium
E X E C UT IV E S U M M A RY
Purpose and Roles
The H Street NE Strategic Development Plan was developed
to guide community, private sector, and public agency actions
and investments in revitalizing this traditional neighborhood
corridor over the next ten years. Over 500 stakeholders
- including residents, merchants, property owners, District
agencies and investors - provided inputs on market analysis,
neighborhood assets, transportation objectives, and current
and proposed land uses, towards the development of this Plan.
Project Boundaries and Goals
The Project Area extends from North Capitol Street to 17th
Street NE, just beyond the Hechinger Mall. The Area extends
approximately 1.5 miles, comprising 13 blocks lined by a mixture of small local commercial establishments, some national
chains, local churches, significant vacant land, abandoned buildings and underutilized upper floors.
The challenge from the H Street communities to the District
was to produce a preferred mix of diverse uses and retail
goods and services. Community goals in this planning effort
are:
to provide vital information and expert recommendations
to help existing businesses grow and thrive on H Street NE;
to recommend a realistic strategy for encouraging the reuse
of the numerous vacant lots and storefronts on the corridor
to create a desirable mix of commercial offerings on the
corridor;
District of Columbia Office of Planning
theHOKPlanningGroup
Key Issues
H S T R E E T N E S T R AT E G I C D E V E L O P M E N T P L A N
ii
Retail Environment
Retail market analyses indicate that over the next 10 years, the
area will support approximately 300,000 square feet of retail
of the type and variety desired by local residents. While not
enough to fill all storefronts along the corridor, the projected
demand is strong enough to spark the revitalization of retailing
in the center of the corridor and complementary retail at
the western and eastern gateways. Ground floor spaces
outside the areas targeted for retail revitalization may include
professional offices, studio spaces, and residential uses.
H S T R E E T N E S T R AT E G I C D E V E L O P M E N T P L A N
iii
REGIONAL RETAIL
Regional Retail Anchor
NEIGHBORHOOD CORRIDOR
Office Anchor
Residential Concentration
W E S T E R N G A T E W A Y:
T H E H U B A N D U R B A N L IV I N G
C E NT R A L R ET A I L D I ST R I CT
A RT S & E NT E RT A I N M E NT
HECHINGER/
O L D S EA R S
W E ST E R N G AT E W AY
C E NT R A L R ET A I L D I ST R I CT
E A ST E R N G AT E W AY
T H E MA L L
District
Existing
Western
Gateway
688,000
83,000
458,000
1,063,000
Central Retail
303,000
81,000
178,000*
400,000
Arts &
Entertainment
299,000
42,000
166,000
423,000
The Mall
214,000
71,000**
285,000
1,504,000
206,000
873,000
2,171,000
Total
Total
* The estimate of new building area for the Central Retail District does not
assume redevelopment of the H Street Connection.
** The estimate of new building area for the Hechinger/Former Sears District
assumes the Former Sears site is developed with 45,000 square feet of retail
use.
Western Gateway
Use
Existing
Total
Retail
47,994
23,489
56,660
81,165
Office/
Commercial
414,122
29,188
100,810
485,744
Residential
86,665
633
409,557
495,589
Exempt
138,977
30,000
-108,977
Total (approx.)
688,000
83,000
458,000
1,063,000
theHOKPlanningGroup
H S T R E E T N E S T R AT E G I C D E V E L O P M E N T P L A N
iv
Existing
Retail
160,863
61,275
Total
168,421
Office/
Commercial
78,100
20,797
35,145
92,448
Residential
64,257
7,368
82,005
138,894
Total (approx.)
303,000
81,000
178,000
400,000
Use
Existing
Total
Retail
107,496
16,319
51,220
142,397
Office/
Commercial
109,942
15,271
43,270
137,941
Residential
81,902
10,246
71,085
142,741
Total (approx.)
299,000
42,000
166,000
423,000
Retail
213,854
71,500
285,354
Total (approx.)
214,000
71,000
285,000
There are two potential uses of the 5-acre former Sears site.
The first envisions a large format big box retailer, while the
other proposes 50 units per acre of residential development.
A large format retail use may help the District to retain retail
sales that currently leak out into surrounding jurisdictions,
and it might bring more people through the H Street
corridor therefore providing more visibility to local retailers.
Total
Use
Existing
Retail
213,854
36,146
250,000
250,000
250,000
214,000
286,000
500,000
Residential
Total (approx.)
Total
Use
Existing
Retail
213,854
63,400
277,254
Office/
Commercial
72,000
72,000
Residential
134,000
134,000
214,000
269,000
483,000
Total (approx.)
Use
Total
H S T R E E T N E S T R AT E G I C D E V E L O P M E N T P L A N
RETAIL DEVELOPMENT
Public Parking
Proposed parking initiatives include the following:
Full-Time Curb Parking - On-street parking should be permitted at all times along the corridor. Curbside parking
improves the pedestrian environment and helps establishes
an image of H Street as a neighborhood that is open for
business. The street section that the plan recommends
maintains the number of travel lanes (with reduced widths)
along the corridor.
Increased Off-Street Parking - Off-street parking must be
easy to access, distributed to be convenient to all the com-
mercial uses, and must be safe. The plan for providing offstreet parking is a combination of short-term and long-term
initiates and surface versus structured parking opportunities.
It is difficult for urban neighborhood retail areas such as this
to provide adequate parking, since the cost of the parking
structure is an unrealistic burden, the lot size is small and
there is a goal of preservation. The additional cost of parking can make it difficult for urban retail areas to compete
with their suburban counterparts. Therefore, the District
should consider the construction of parking structures
through the parking authority held by NCRC as municipal
projects or private/public partnerships., e.g. the new parking garage in Adams Morgan, or the parking districts used in
Bethesda and Silver Spring, Maryland.
Implementation
Land Use, Zoning & Redevelopment
First Projects. District efforts and resources should be
focused on the following as stage-setters for the Plans success:
Support Planning for Future of the Capitol Childrens Museum Site. This site represents one of the most
important development opportunities for the corridor and is
especially critical to further investment in the Western Gate-
H S T R E E T N E S T R AT E G I C D E V E L O P M E N T P L A N
vi
Hopscotch Bridge Improvements. The proposed redevelopment of the Union Station Air Rights suggests improvements to the western gateway via direct pedestrian access
and improved streetscape. For this and other developments
Public Realm
H S T R E E T N E S T R AT E G I C D E V E L O P M E N T P L A N
vii
1 I NT R O D U CT I O N
The H Street NE Strategic Development Plan constitutes a
redevelopment plan or a neighborhood development plan
area under subchapter I of Chapter 3 of Title 6 (Redevelopment Act).
H S T R E E T N E S T R AT E G I C D E V E L O P M E N T P L A N
Public Realm
Retail Environment
Diversification of the retail mix;
Strategies for marketing the corridor to new retail users;
Strategies for encouraging revitalization activities along the
corridor, i.e. tax increment financing district, HUB and Enterprise zone benefits, etc.;
Strategies for capacity building of corridor merchants and
property owners, i.e. Business Improvement Districts (BID)
or others; and
Small business incubators, cultivation of local entrepreneurs.
Transit,Traffic & Parking
Recommendations for transit enhancements, parking and
traffic/transportation management;
Allocation of R.O.W. to accommodate transit enhancements, parking, traffic flow and pedestrians; and
Office of Planning staff provided progress reports to stakeholder groups and organizations and solicited feedback during
numerous community meetings over the planning period.
H S T R E E T N E S T R AT E G I C D E V E L O P M E N T P L A N
ber 23, 2002. That evening the team reviewed the analysis
of existing conditions and initial design and development
concepts, and led a series of small group discussion sessions.
This was an opportunity for members of the planning team
to introduce the study and share initial observations concerning H Streets assets and issues and hear community concerns,
ideas and visions for the corridors future.
During the next two days of the charrette the team began the
design process and simultaneously held meetings with a variety of stakeholders, including merchants, residents, and property owners. The intense process allowed the information
received during the meetings to be fed directly to the design
team and incorporated into the design effort.
The charrette concluded with a large-scale public workshop
during which Mayor Anthony Williams offered a summary of
the Districts on-going work in the neighborhood and members of the design team presented the outcome of the design
effort and led a question-and-answer session with attendees.
Following the charrette the design team worked closely with
the Office of Planning to develop the recommendations contained in Strategic Development Plan. The Office of Planning
continued to provide the design team with community input
obtained from various meetings, emails and other communications. In addition, the Draft Strategic Development Plan was
presented at approximately ten individual neighborhood organization meetings throughout the H Street community.
H S T R E E T N E S T R AT E G I C D E V E L O P M E N T P L A N
Gallaudet University
Trinidad
Near Northeast
Carver Langston
H Street NE
The White House
Stanton Park
Union Station
Kingman
2 P L A N N I N G C O NT E XT
The combined effect of three factors H Streets strategic
location, critical mass of large-scale private investments in the
area, and public initiative to improve neighborhood livability
and economic vitality make this a perfect time to plan for
the corridors future.
2.1 Strategic Location in the City
The H Street corridor benefits greatly from its strategic location within the city and region. The corridor has served,
and continues to serve, both as a pedestrian-oriented retail
street and a vital regional link in the Districts transportation
(vehicular and transit) network. Striking a sustainable balance
between these interrelated rolesdestination and movement
corridoris among the central challenges of the current planning effort.
A District Destination
As historic photographs suggest and long-time residents and
property owners confirm, H Street in the mid 1900s both
before and after integration in 1954 was among the
Districts most lively, safe and attractive shopping destinations.
Residents from the surrounding neighborhoods known
today as the Near Northeast neighborhood to the north and
the Stanton Park and Linden neighborhoods to the South
could satisfy virtually all their needs for goods and services
along the corridor, as well as their desire for entertainment
RFK Stadium
H S T R E E T N E S T R AT E G I C D E V E L O P M E N T P L A N
H
Old Sears Site
Capitol Childrens Museum
Ma
Hechinger Mall
15th Street
13th Street
12th Street
11th Street
7th Street
6th Street
5th Street
H Street NE
14th Street
F
4th Street
3rd Street
2nd Street
E
B
ue
ven
dA
an
ryl
10th Street
BP/Amoco
8th Street
Eye Street NE
Bennin
g Road
G Street NE
Station Place
H S T R E E T N E S T R AT E G I C D E V E L O P M E N T P L A N
H S T R E E T N E S T R AT E G I C D E V E L O P M E N T P L A N
reStore DC
The Districts reStore DC program emphasizes 1) promoting
and marketing business districts; 2) improving the appearance and economic health of neighborhood business districts;
and 3) strengthening the internal capacity of District government agencies, along with organizations engaged in revitalization activity. The initiative emphasizes local entrepreneurial
opportunity, and the strengthening of partnerships among
the District government, civic and professional organizations,
residents, and business owners and managers to facilitate
commercial growth in every neighborhood. Elements of the
initiative are described below.
The DC Main Streets program consists of a comprehensive
package of technical and financial assistance for neighborhood business districts. The goal of the program is to establish and implement a continuous and comprehensive revitalization program in a range of local neighborhood business districts. Each program would be based on a proven
national model, The Main Street Four Point Approach: organization, economic restructuring, promotion, and design. H
Street NE was among the first five (5) commercial districts
designated as a DC Main Street and is in the early stages of
organizational development;
The Commercial District Technical Assistance Program (CDTAP) offers direct assistance to any commercial district in the
city, with grants awarded four times every year by the Office
of Deputy Mayor for Planning and Economic Development.
The CD-TAP is budgeted District-wide at $400,000. The
CD-TAP grants are for a maximum $25,000 each, and are
designed to assist short-term (30-90 day), highly visible projects or activities (merchant directories, special events, predevelopment studies, etc.). Business districts with specific
technical assistance needs could apply for matching funds to
procure technical assistance or advisory services related to a
specific revitalization activity or project(s). Local Main Street
program areas are ineligible to apply, as they receive comprehensive services and annual grants for 5 years. But other
local groups (i.e., merchant groups) are eligible. As such, CDTap may be available to provide assistance to H Street at a
level of $75,000 over 3-5 years;
The Commercial Property Acquisition and Development
Fund provides matching funds for non-profit organizations to acquire, redevelop, or build commercial properties
located anywhere in the District;
The Small Business Development Program assists businesses grow and prosper through opportunities for training, workshops, conferences, technical assistance, and access
to Capitol. This program component is funded at $1 million for fiscal year 2002; and
The Storefront Improvement Grants program offers storefront improvement grants to small business owners for the
enhancement of retail or commercial properties. The program is administered by the Department of Housing and
Community Development and the Office of Planning, partnering with local community organizations. The District will
grant 80% of the total costs of improvement projects and
the business owner is responsible to the remaining 20% of
the cost..
Strategic Neighborhood Investment Program (SNIP)
A targeted investment policy wherein priority District neighborhoods or locations receive a series of comprehensive
public actions or funds to complement and/or catalyze private sector investment.
Transit Enhancements
The District, with the Washington Metropolitan Area Transportation Authority (WMATA), is conducting assessments
of potential corridors and routes for enhancing the citys
mass transit network through the introduction of new
transit technologies including intelligent transportation systems, rapid bus transit, light rail transit or reestablishment of
trolleys. As indicated in the transportation section of this
report, early studies identify H Street as a candidate for such
improvements.
Transit-Oriented Development (TOD)
The Districts Transit-Oriented Development Program is a
smart growth planning strategy designed to leverage transit
investment to enhance existing neighborhood centers by
creating active and compact neighborhood development
opportunities.
Parking Demand Management
This District policy focuses on creating livable neighborhoods while supporting successful retail and residential
development through efficient management of parking
demand and resources that may include creative pricing
strategies, shared parking, municipal parking, shuttle and
transit programs, and flexible design
Housing and Economic Redevelopment
The retention and attraction of residents is a major component of the District of Columbias economic development
strategy. Over the next ten years the District seeks to capture another 100,000 new residents back to the city. The
Williams Administration has put in place several initiatives
aimed at increasing housing production and affordability to
accommodate this growth. These include the following:
Housing Act 2001. The housing initiative protects existing affordable housing, reduces displacement, converts
vacant and dilapidated buildings into new housing, and
promotes new housing for people of all incomes. The centerpiece of the housing initiative is the omnibus housing
legislation. The bill improves existing homeownership programs, creates new funding streams for affordable housing
preservation and production, provides greater protection
against displacement [HOW?], and offers new incentives
for homebuyers and developers to build and rehabilitate
housing. More information can be found on this initiative at
www.dcbiz.dc.gov/services/housing_initiative_2002a.shtm.
Home Again Initiative. The Districts Home Again Initiative is a program to convert vacant and abandoned buildings
into quality homes. Under the initiative, the District will gain
site control of vacant houses and sell them to developers
who will rehab them into housing. Its mixed income homeownership structure stipulates a minimum of 30% of the
homes sold will go to low income families. This Initiative will
focuses on empty lots and homes with no occupants.
New Neighborhoods. (from the Mayors Neighborhood 10: 10 Strategies for a Stronger Washington)
Several large sites - on former federally-controlled land like
St. Elizabeths Campus, on city-controlled properties such as
Public Reservation 13, and on large tracts of underutilized
land such as Mt. Vernon Triangle in Downtown Washington
- offer excellent opportunities to build new, mixed-use and
mixed-income communities without the displacement of
existing residents. Community planning efforts have begun in
several of these areas.
Comprehensive Plan Update Housing
Opportunity Areas.
The Office of Planning is in the process of updating
the Comprehensive Plan for the District of Columbia.
The current Comprehensive Plan does not recognize
the corridor as a Housing Opportunity Area. However,
this should be reconsidered in the update because the
corridor is capable of producing new, mixed use and mixed
income residential opportunities without displacing existing
residents. The revisions to the Comprehensive Plan are
expected to be complete by 2006.
H S T R E E T N E S T R AT E G I C D E V E L O P M E N T P L A N
The Washington metropolitan areas economy has experienced significant growth during the past decade, a trend
that is forecast to continue during the coming 20 years or
so.
Growth in the technology sector has been the primary
force driving demand for new office space in the region.
This sector has experienced downsizing due to a market
correction in relation to over-valued telecommunications
and e-businesses.
Nevertheless, we anticipate that, in the long-term, the
sector will continue to play a centrally important role in
regional economic growth.
Forecast employment growth in all sectors will fuel
demand for around 11.6 million square feet of additional
office space in the District to the year 2012.
H S T R E E T N E S T R AT E G I C D E V E L O P M E N T P L A N
(Square Feet)
2012
High
High
Low
Productivity
Productivity Productivity
(1)
Retail Category
GAFO (2)
181,000
91,000
160,000
Convenience (3)
108,000
54,000
94,000
Meals and Beverag
64,000
32,000
49,000
Total (4)
353,000
177,000
303,000
(1) Based on 2002 Mid-Atlantic sales per square foot averages from
International Council of Shopping Centers' Monthly Mall Merchandise Index.
2002
H S T R E E T N E S T R AT E G I C D E V E L O P M E N T P L A N
H S T R E E T N E S T R AT E G I C D E V E L O P M E N T P L A N
10
4 R ET A I L E NV I R O N M E NT
This section of the plan provides a summary of the planning teams analysis of the retail environment along H Street.
The text offers an assessment of conditions, an overview
of market forces affecting retailers, and a review of existing
retail offerings.
4.1 Overview of Issues
Retail trade areas are determined by evaluating the approximate geographic area from which a retailer can reasonably
draw customers. With this information, a calculation of a
target market for local-serving retailers can be estimated.
The assessment of a trade area for H Street is based on
four distinct factors:
H S T R E E T N E S T R AT E G I C D E V E L O P M E N T P L A N
11
Hechinger Mall
Union Station
Eastern Market
Competitive Supply
Throughout Washington, DC and the metropolitan area,
there are many neighborhoods with a specialty retail component. Within the District, Adams Morgan supports a
recognized variety of ethnic restaurants and nightclubs.
Georgetowns identity is tied to luxury merchandise, fashion,
boutique gifts and restaurants. Friendship Heights brand is
created by high-end fashion and jewelry, as well as urban big
box retail. Each of these neighborhoods occupy a unique
place in the citys retail market, but none of them serve as
direct competition to H Streets shops and restaurantsyet.
Retail neighborhoods evolve. Three of the best local examples of this evolution in progress are the U Street Corridor,
Downtowns F and 7th District and Columbia Heights. After
years of planning, identity creation, and redevelopment,
these three neighborhoods are reaching the midpoint of
their retail maturity. In the next few years, they will compete
in the same retail marketplace as Georgetown, Friendship
Heights, Old Town, Bethesda Row, and Dupont Circle.
H Street must first get back on its feet. Before the late
1950s or early 1960s, H Street was the second or third
highest grossing retail district in the city. Now, the initial
step is to recreate a neighborhood goods and services retail
district. The competitive supply for concentrated neighborhood goods and services type is evaluated by identifying and
investigating existing, established retail districts adjacent to H
Street.
The existing and established competition adjacent to H
Street has a definite impact on its retail potential. The
retail centers or districts that serve a concentrated base of
customers near H Street NE are the East End/Chinatown,
Pennsylvania Avenue/Eastern Market/Eighth Street, Hech-
H S T R E E T N E S T R AT E G I C D E V E L O P M E N T P L A N
12
salons
discount fashion stores
take out food establishments
grocery/convenience stores
dry cleaners/laundromats
discount stores
banking institutions
liquor stores
jewelry stores
auto parts stores
hardware/plumbing stores
drug stores
appliance store
record store
furnishing store
H S T R E E T N E S T R AT E G I C D E V E L O P M E N T P L A N
13
GRADE A RETAILERS
Criteria
Profitable
Sophisticated ownership/management
Demonstrated financial know-how
Employing a marketing strategy
Knowledgeable of customer base
Profitable
Knowledgeable of customer base
Could prosper with financial/operations assistance
Little profitability
Lacks basic information regarding business operations
Does not understand customer base or their needs
H S T R E E T N E S T R AT E G I C D E V E L O P M E N T P L A N
14
GRADE B+ RETAILERS
poor lighting;
the perception/reality of neighborhood crime;
loitering;
a deficiency of parking; and
lack of concentrated retail activity/vacant buildings.
H S T R E E T N E S T R AT E G I C D E V E L O P M E N T P L A N
15
H Street NE
H Street NE
5 C O N D IT I O N S A S S E S S M E NT
This section of the plan offers a summary of physical conditions along the corridor.
5.1 Land Use, Zoning & Development
This section presents a summary of findings from the teams
analysis of land use, zoning and development conditions along
H Street, including a review of the aspects of historic preservation and how it may impact development on the corridor.
The summary is organized around the following:
Land Area
H Street Frontage
Hechinger Mall & CVS/
Former Sears
Totals
sf
1,017,481
Area
avg sf
3,595
acres
23.4
666,812
222,271
15.3
1,684,293
5,889
38.7
Description
Hechinger Mall
CVS & Former Sears Site
Subtotal
Site Between 6th & 7th South Side
Capital Childrens Museum Site
H Street Connection Site
Site Between 2nd & 3rd South Side
Total
Area (sf)
373,627
293,185
666,812
109,351
104,756
87,052
34,444
1,002,415
H S T R E E T N E S T R AT E G I C D E V E L O P M E N T P L A N
16
L
RY
15th STREET NE
H STREET NE
MA
12th STREET NE
6th STREET NE
3rd STREET NE
N Capitol STREET
E
AV
ND
BENN
ING R
OAD
L
RY
15th STREET NE
H STREET NE
MA
12th STREET NE
6th STREET NE
3rd STREET NE
N Capitol STREET
E
AV
ND
BENN
ING R
OAD
E
AV
ND
15th STREET NE
H STREET NE
MA
12th STREET NE
6th STREET NE
3rd STREET NE
L
RY
BENN
ING R
OAD
NU
D
AN
E
AV
L
RY
following table.
Description
BP/Amoco Site
Murrys/Former Safeway Site
Auto Zone Site
Atlas Theater Site
H Street Self Store Site
Old McCrorys Site
District Library Site
H Street CDC Site
Total
15th STREET NE
H STREET NE
MA
12th STREET NE
6th STREET NE
3rd STREET NE
N Capitol STREET
NU
N Capitol STREET
NU
VACANT STOREFRONTS
NU
VACANT PARCELS
Area (sf)
49,052
38,628
33,435
28,950
26,725
13,725
10,800
9,813
221,757
Block
(Square)
0859
0982
1026
Description
Mid-Block Parcel (Parcel 0835)
1100 Block Southside (Parcel 0819)
Library Site (7 contiguous parcels)
Total
BENN
ING R
OAD
Land Use
Property tax records for H Street, including Hechinger Mall
and the CVS/Former Sears sites, show the predominant use
of parcels as a mix of retail, restaurant and entertainment uses.
Parcels with these uses account for approximately 45% of
the total land area along the corridor. Vacant parcels/parcels
with fully vacant buildings comprise 30% of the total land area.
Office uses rank second comprising approximately 15% of
total land area.
Use Category
Retail, Restaurant, & Entertainment
- Hechinger Mall and CVS Site
Retail, Restaurant, & Entertainment
- H Street Frontage
Vacant Parcel
Commercial Office
Public & Institutional
Vacant Building
Parking & Vehicle Sales
Residential
Total
Land Area
450,254
27%
240,927
14%
380,025
254,004
132,815
124,942
97,629
3,697
1,684,293
22%
15%
8%
8%
6%
> 0.01%
100%
H S T R E E T N E S T R AT E G I C D E V E L O P M E N T P L A N
17
EXISTING ZONING
NU
D
AN
E
AV
L
RY
MA
H STREET NE
BENN
Occupancy
Regulations.
Area
Occupied Storefronts
Vacant Storefronts
Total Storefront Space
Area
sf
Acres
380,025 8.72
1,304,268 29.94
1,684,293 38.66
sf
369,107
126,729
495,836
%
74%
26%
100%
%
22%
78%
100%
Note: Parcels includes H Street Frontage from 2nd Street to 15th Street as
well as the Hechinger Mall site and the CVS/Former Sears site.
Parcels
#
%
54
19%
232
81%
286 100%
Buildings
#
%
154
71%
64
29%
218
100%
Notes: Occupied Storefronts includes H Street frontage only; does not include
non-storefront buildings such as CCM, Library, churches, Hechinger Mall, &
CVS.
Occupancy of Parcels
Vacant Parcels
Occupied Parcels
Total Parcels
15th STREET NE
12th STREET NE
6th STREET NE
3rd STREET NE
N Capitol STREET
ING R
OAD
sf
532,681
159,166
691,847
%
77%
33%
100%
Buildings
#
%
95
53%
83
47%
178
100%
Note: Total occupied upper floor space includes occupied space in DOES,
CCM and Self Store buildings. Upper floors in these buildings accounts for
almost 400,000 square feet of occupied upper floor space.
Zoning
The majority of the corridor is zoned C-2. The eastern end
and Hechinger Mall areas are zoned C-3. These zones allow
both commercial and residential development. In addition,
small portions of the corridor are zoned C-M-1, a strictly
commercial zone, and R-4, a strictly residential zone. The
diagram attached indicates the zoning designation locations
and the chart below describes the amount of the land in
each zone as defined by the District of Columbia Municipal
Zone
District
Max.
Height
% Lot
Cover*
Rear
Yard
C-2-A
1.5
2.5
50
60%
15
C-2-B
1.5
3.5
65
80%
15
C-2-C
2.0
6.0
90
80%
15
C-3-A
2.5
4.0
65
75%
12**
C-M-1
3.0
N/A
40
N/A
12***
H S T R E E T N E S T R AT E G I C D E V E L O P M E N T P L A N
18
Individual Parcels
#
%
238
83
2
0.7
1
0.3
38
13
2
0.7
5
2
% of Total
Land Area
35%
7%
6%
49%
2%
0.5%
Capacity Analysis
Zone District
R-4
C-2-A
C-2-B
C-2-C
C-3-A (H St
Frontage)
C-3-A (Hech/Sears)
C-M-1
Total
Existing
Area (sf)
0
796,938
37,225
236,201
Allowable
Area (sf)
8,975
875,387
182,244
218,702
Underused
Area (sf)
8,975
578,449
145,019
-17,499
211,564
393,648
182,084
213,854
0
1.495,782
1,667,030
109,827
3,455,813
1,453,176
109,827
2,960,031
Historic Preservation
This subsection of the report presents a summary of
findings related to the preservation and adaptive reuse of
the corridors older, and potentially historically significant,
structures. The summary is organized around the following:
Preservation and Community Revitalization;
H S T R E E T N E S T R AT E G I C D E V E L O P M E N T P L A N
19
H S T R E E T N E S T R AT E G I C D E V E L O P M E N T P L A N
20
Historic Designations
Local DC Designation
Who
designates?
DC HPRB
What is the
Purpose?
Recognition
Protection of
Heritage.
May be eligible for
local tax credits.*
Design controls
through review of
changes by DC
HPRB.
Special
consideration
under the DC
Construction
Code.
Waivers of certain
zoningrequirements.
Exterior
alterations require
the approval of
the DC HPRB.
What are
the Benefits?
What
Constraints
are there on
Designated
Properties?
National Register
Designation
DC HPRB
recommends
NPS makes final
decision
Recognition.
H S T R E E T N E S T R AT E G I C D E V E L O P M E N T P L A N
21
Owners of designated historic properties can also obtain substantial tax benefits by donating a preservation easement to a
qualified charitable or government organization. A preservation easement is a voluntary legal arrangement that protects a
historic, archaeological or cultural resource by providing assurance to the owner that the propertys intrinsic historical value
will be preserved through subsequent ownership. When the
owner donates an easement to a charitable or governmental
organization, he can claim a charitable deduction on federal
income tax. In most cases an easement donor may deduct
the value of the easement, for up to 30% of the taxpayers
adjusted gross income, from federal taxes. The value of the
easement is based on the difference between the appraised
fair market value of the property prior to conveying an easement and its value with the easement restrictions in place.
Monetary
Value
Notes
$100,000
$20,000
$80,000
$200,000 Generally, the cost of
rehabilitation must exceed
the value of the building
portion.
$40,000 $200,000 x 20%
36%
$9,000
$25,000 x 36%
Under passive loss
exception of tax code
H S T R E E T N E S T R AT E G I C D E V E L O P M E N T P L A N
22
Eye Street NE
u
ven
dA
an
ryl
Ma
G Street NE
g Road
15th Street
14th Street
13th Street
12th Street
Bennin
11th Street
10th Street
8th Street
7th Street
6th Street
5th Street
4th Street
3rd Street
2nd Street
H Street NE
H Street NE
24,000 Vehicles Per Day
Benning Road
42,000 Vehicles Per Day
Delay &
Direction of
Travel
Total Delay
Northbound
Eastbound
Westbound
Total Delay
Northbound
Southbound
Eastbound
Westbound
H S T R E E T N E S T R AT E G I C D E V E L O P M E N T P L A N
23
44 SPACES
40 SPACES
46 SPACES
300-360 SPACES
585 SPACES
1,387+ SPACES
the Consultants with the data for calculating the LOS for the 5Road Intersection.)
As part of this revitalization effort, the H Street
redevelopment team is proposing to reconfigure the H Street/
Benning Road/Maryland Avenue/Florida Avenue intersection
to allow for landscaping opportunities at the corridors
eastern gateway. This reconfiguration is proposed primarily
for pedestrian safety and aesthetic reasons; however it should
also provide an opportunity to improve traffic conditions at
a primary commuter intersection. It is recommended that
the District Department of Transportation (DDOT) conduct
a traffic study in order to assess the traffic implications of any
geometric improvements
Parking Analysis
The H Street corridor currently contains both on-street and
off-street parking within the study area. On-street parking
is generally available along H Street during all times except
during the period of the predominant flow of commuter
traffic in the morning and in the evening. As a result of these
existing parking restrictions, several H Street business owners
have complained about the restrictions as hindering customer
access to the business locations during the restricted times.
On-street parking is generally restricted along H Street along
the north side of the street (along the westbound traffic side)
from 7:00 9:00 AM and on the south side of the street
(along the eastbound traffic side) during 4:00 6:30 PM. A
mix of metered (2-hour parking permitted Monday through
H S T R E E T N E S T R AT E G I C D E V E L O P M E N T P L A N
24
ROUTES
BUS TRANSIT
Routes 90, 92 &93
Routes X-3
Route 0-8
Eye Street NE
u
ven
dA
an
ryl
Ma
H Street NE
15th Street
14th Street
13th Street
12th Street
11th Street
10th Street
8th Street
7th Street
Route X-2
6th Street
5th Street
4th Street
3rd Street
2nd Street
Routes X-1
Bennin Route X8
g Road & X-3
Routes X-1,
X-2,
G Street NE
Route
D8
X1
X2
X3
90
92, 93
Origin
Washington
Hospital
Center
Minnesota
Avenue
Station
Minnesota
Avenue
Station
Minnesota
Avenue
Station
Anacostia
Metrorail
Station
Congress
Heights
Station
Destination
Weekday
Ridership
Avg # of
Riders per
Hour
Union
Station
5,002
51
State Dept
in Foggy
Bottom
1,684
46
Lafayette
Square
16,333
84
1,684
46
17,128
50
17,128
50
McLean
Gardens
NW
McLean
Gardens
NW
McLean
Gardens
NW
H S T R E E T N E S T R AT E G I C D E V E L O P M E N T P L A N
25
BICYCLE ROUTES
Bicycle Conditions
The following bicycle-related characteristics currently exist in
the study area, which affect the quality of the local bicycling
environment:
On-street parking is generally restricted along H Street
along the north side of the street (along the westbound
traffic side) during 7:00 9:00 AM and on the south side of
the street (along the eastbound traffic side) during 4:00 6:
30 PM;
Traffic volume along H Street is consistently heavy with
speeds that appear to be in excess of 35 mph;
There is limited room available between on-street parked
cars and the traffic lane for safe cycling;
Sidewalks along H Street are narrow (less than 6 feet in
some locations) and have heavy foot traffic;
Blocks are short, with frequent curb cuts and intersections,
which presents a cyclist with frequent potential vehicular
conflict locations;
Relatively heavy traffic volumes and confusing traffic
patterns at the H Street intersection with Benning Road,
Bladensburg Road, Florida Avenue, and Maryland Avenue,
are difficult for cyclists to negotiate; and
The Hopscotch Bridge, which has fast-moving traffic and
no curbside parking, provides the most direct street access
between the H Street corridor and Downtown. For
many bicyclists, the steep grade on the bridge is a factor
that is difficult to climb and can be dangerous to descend,
H S T R E E T N E S T R AT E G I C D E V E L O P M E N T P L A N
26
H S T R E E T N E S T R AT E G I C D E V E L O P M E N T P L A N
27
STREETSCAPE IMAGES
Turnpike, the early link between the District and the cities of
Annapolis and Bladensburg.
Over the years, as areas east of the District have grown,
the intersection has been reconfigured to serve increases
in commuter traffic, especially along Benning Road, one of
only 5 bridges across the Anacostia River. Over time, these
improvements have tended to favor vehicular rather than
pedestrian movements, making the intersection particularly
difficult to cross on foot. The current configuration, with its
lack of green space, areas for pedestrians, and streetscape
amenities, creates a significant barrier between the H Street,
the surrounding neighborhoods, and Hechinger Mall.
Fortunately, the LEnfant Plan provides a useful foundation for
thinking about potential improvements to the intersection.
As with other sites in the District where diagonal avenues
crossed, the intersection was shown on the LEnfant plan
as a hatched circle (please refer to illustration on page 14),
suggesting its potential for treatment as a special public place.
This potential is highlighted in the National Capitol Planning
Commissions recently adopted Monuments and Memorials
Plan. The Plan described the intersection as follows:
A potential commemorative feature at this location
could be incorporated within the existing and future site
conditions as the intersection of Maryland and Florida
Avenues is redesigned. The reconfigured space could provide
H S T R E E T N E S T R AT E G I C D E V E L O P M E N T P L A N
28
STREETSCAPE IMAGES
Streetscape Conditions
H S T R E E T N E S T R AT E G I C D E V E L O P M E N T P L A N
29
6 C H A L L E N G E S & O P P O RT U N IT I E S
The assessments summarized in previous sections of this
report were undertaken to help the planning team and community
1) understand issues affecting the vitality and attractiveness of
the corridor; and
2) identify opportunities which could serve as the foundation
for the plans development and implementation.
A summary of these challenges and opportunities follows.
6.1 Land Use, Zoning & Development
Challenges
The presence of vacant sites, storefronts, and whole buildings, along with the poor condition of many occupied buildings, contributes to perceptions of the area as unwelcoming
and unsafe. The use of solid security grates and unshielded
security lighting further reinforces perceptions of the corridor as a risky place for investment;
With the notable exception of a half dozen sites, the size
and depth of parcels limit their attractiveness to investment
and redevelopment. Typical modern commercial buildings,
especially office and mixed-use buildings, require a much
larger footprint than is possible on a small, shallow site;
The current pattern of ownershipsmall parcels in separate ownershiplimits opportunities for larger-scale (half
to whole block) preservation and redevelopment. The patterns makes it difficult to consolidate contiguous blocks of
land to support modern building requirements or encourage multi-building preservation and adaptive projects;
With minor exceptions, no formal controls or incentives
exist to ensure that the corridors historic buildings are preserved and that new buildings be designed to relate well to
their surroundings;
Many new buildings along the corridor follow a suburban
development model, with front or side rather than rear
yard parking, minimal storefront display space, signage
directed to automobile traffic rather than pedestrians, and
building materials and details out of step with the historic
context of the street and surrounding; and
Current zoning provisions tend to promote the development of single use buildings with suburban site configurations, such as the CVS and Auto Zone, over developments
such as mixed use buildings with ground floor retail, second
story office and 2-3 floors of apartments.
Opportunities
The proximity of the western end of the corridor to metro
stations at Union Station and New York Avenue (planned)
greatly increases the potential for new residential and
mixed-use development and the adaptive reuse of existing
buildings;
The presence of several large, mostly vacant sites under
single ownership (e.g. the former Sears site) offer important
development opportunities;
With financial assistance, guidelines, zoning changes, and off-
H S T R E E T N E S T R AT E G I C D E V E L O P M E N T P L A N
30
H S T R E E T N E S T R AT E G I C D E V E L O P M E N T P L A N
31
7 V I S I O N & P LA N F RA M EW O R K
This section of the report presents the communitys vision for
H Street and an introduction to the four focus areas around
which the Plans recommendations are organized.
7.1.Vision
Much of the discussion during public meetings and the design
charrette focused on the corridors colorful history and
special qualities. While some shared their concern about
current problems, many spoke of a brighter future. Diverse
stakeholders talked about the importance of making H
Street a safe and attractive place offering opportunities and
activities for the whole neighborhoodyoung and old, families
and singles, newcomers and old-timers. People spoke of the
importance of supporting existing businesses, creating new
opportunities for local entrepreneurs, and attracting new
investment. They talked about the importance of protecting
the streets character, promoting a unique sense of place, and
ensuring that new projects complement rather than detract
from the areas best qualities.
Emerging from these discussions was a shared vision for the
future of H Streeta vision of a great neighborhood shopping
street, serving resident needs, providing connections to the
larger City, and improving the livability of the surrounding
community. Elements of the vision follow.
H S T R E E T N E S T R AT E G I C D E V E L O P M E N T P L A N
32
REGIONAL RETAIL
Regional Retail Anchor
NEIGHBORHOOD CORRIDOR
Office Anchor
Residential Concentration
W E S T E R N G A T E W A Y:
T H E H U B A N D U R B A N L IV I N G
C E NT R A L R ET A I L D I ST R I CT
A RT S & E NT E RT A I N M E NT
HECHINGER/
O L D S EA R S
W E ST E R N G AT E W AY
C E NT R A L R ET A I L D I ST R I CT
E A ST E R N G AT E W AY
T H E MA L L
For each of the districts, the Plan offers land use, preservation,
H S T R E E T N E S T R AT E G I C D E V E L O P M E N T P L A N
33
H S T R E E T N E S T R AT E G I C D E V E L O P M E N T P L A N
34
8 ST R AT E G I C D EV E L O P M E NT P L A N
(Note: This amount projects the needs for the corridor, and may
be built up incrementally, beyond the ten year horizon.)
H S T R E E T N E S T R AT E G I C D E V E L O P M E N T P L A N
35
District
Existing
Western
Gateway
688,000
83,000
458,000
1,063,000
Central Retail
303,000
81,000
178,000*
400,000
Arts &
Entertainment
299,000
42,000
166,000
423,000
The Mall
214,000
71,000**
285,000
1,504,000
206,000
873,000
2,171,000
Total
Total
* The estimate of new building area for the Central Retail District does not
assume redevelopment of the H Street Connection.
** The estimate of new building area for the Hechinger/Former Sears District
assumes the Former Sears site is developed with 45,000 square feet of retail
use.
H S T R E E T N E S T R AT E G I C D E V E L O P M E N T P L A N
36
W E ST E R N G AT E W AY :
T H E H U B A N D U R B A N L IV I N G
Western Gateway:The Hub and Urban Living (North Capitol Street to 7th Street)
Overall Development Program Summary
Building Area (sf)
Removed
New
District
Existing
Western
Gateway
688,000
83,000
458,000
1,063,000
Central Retail
303,000
81,000
178,000*
400,000
Arts &
Entertainment
299,000
42,000
166,000
423,000
The Mall
214,000
71,000**
285,000
1,504,000
206,000
873,000
2,171,000
Total
Total
* The estimate of new building area for the Central Retail District does not
assume redevelopment of the H Street Connection.
** The estimate of new building area for the Hechinger/Former Sears District
assumes the Former Sears site is developed with 45,000 square feet of retail
use.
Use
Existing
Retail
47,994
23,489
56,660
81,165
Office/
Commercial
414,122
29,188
100,810
485,744
Residential
86,665
633
409,557
495,589
Exempt
138,977
30,000
-108,977
Total (approx.)
688,000
83,000
458,000
1,063,000
Total
Introduction
Development Program
H S T R E E T N E S T R AT E G I C D E V E L O P M E N T P L A N
37
D
A
H S T R E E T N E S T R AT E G I C D E V E L O P M E N T P L A N
38
HP
Currently, a local developer has preliminary plans for a mixeduse project on the entire block frontage. The developer is
currently seeking a larger partner in order to move the project forward. The developer is also an area stakeholder and is
committed to the appropriate design character and use for
this strategic site.
Preservation, Adaptive Reuse and Infill Development. The remaining blocks are appropriate for preservation,
adaptive reuse and selective redevelopment/infill development.
For the largest of the redevelopment sites, currently home to
the H Street CDC, the Plan calls for the removal of the existing one-story office building and the development of a new 34 story building with storefronts along H Street, residential or
office uses on the upper floors and parking off the alley. While
ground floor retail uses may not be possible in the near term
given market constraints, the new building should be designed
to accommodate retail or restaurant uses in the future.
Murrys Site Redevelopment (H) - The Plan recommends the Murrys site and parking lot be redeveloped to
create a new mixed use project incorporating residential
and/or office uses, an urban grocery store and a parking
structure designed to serve the development as well as
provide public parking for the corridor. It is estimated that
a new development could accommodate 300-350 parking spaces in a mid-block structure. Redevelopment plans
should include an analysis of the Blaire Schools historic
significance and adaptive reuse potential. The project should
result in the creation of new storefronts along H Street.
Loft Housing Adaptive Reuse (I) - The redevelopment
of the storage facility for loft-style apartments/condominium
H S T R E E T N E S T R AT E G I C D E V E L O P M E N T P L A N
39
C E NT R A L R ET A I L D I ST R I CT
District
Existing
Western
Gateway
688,000
83,000
458,000
1,063,000
Central Retail
303,000
81,000
178,000*
400,000
Arts &
Entertainment
299,000
42,000
166,000
423,000
The Mall
214,000
71,000**
285,000
1,504,000
206,000
873,000
2,171,000
Total
Total
* The estimate of new building area for the Central Retail District does not
assume redevelopment of the H Street Connection.
** The estimate of new building area for the Hechinger/Former Sears District
assumes the Former Sears site is developed with 45,000 square feet of retail
use.
Use
Existing
Retail
160,863
53,717
61,275
168,421
Office/
Commercial
78,100
20,797
35,145
92,448
Residential
64,257
7,368
82,005
138,894
Total (approx.)
303,000
81,000
178,000
400,000
Total
Introduction
Development Program
Plans for the Central Retail District recognize this areas long
history as the neighborhoods primary shopping destination.
The area around the intersection of 8th and H Streets
continues to benefit from its position as the corridors
100% cornerthe place where the transportation network
best supports retail activity. Several transportationrelated factorsthe crossing of high volume bus lines, the
passing of 24,000 vehicles per day, and foot traffic from the
neighborhoodmake this area attractive to a mix of local,
regional, and national retailers. Recent building renovations
and the low number vacant sites and storefronts are clear
signs of the areas viability as a retail destination.
H S T R E E T N E S T R AT E G I C D E V E L O P M E N T P L A N
40
A
AXONOMETRIC OF H STREET CONNECTION REDEVELOPMENT
B
C
C
REDEVELOPMENT PROPOSAL FOR H STREET CONNECTION
H S T R E E T N E S T R AT E G I C D E V E L O P M E N T P L A N
41
A RT S & E NT E RT A I N M E NT
District
Existing
Western
Gateway
688,000
83,000
458,000
1,063,000
Central Retail
303,000
81,000
178,000*
400,000
Arts &
Entertainment
299,000
42,000
166,000
423,000
The Mall
214,000
71,000**
285,000
1,504,000
206,000
873,000
2,171,000
Total
Total
* The estimate of new building area for the Central Retail District does not
assume redevelopment of the H Street Connection.
** The estimate of new building area for the Hechinger/Former Sears District
assumes the Former Sears site is developed with 45,000 square feet of retail
use.
Use
Existing
Retail
107,496
16,319
51,220
142,397
Office/
Commercial
109,942
15,271
43,270
137,941
Residential
81,902
10,246
71,085
142,741
Total (approx.)
299,000
42,000
166,000
423,000
Total
Development Program
Recommendations
H S T R E E T N E S T R AT E G I C D E V E L O P M E N T P L A N
42