CLASS Lees

NAME Barbara

DATE 2/25/2015

Graphic Organizer
Evaluation
As a review of a book, I felt that this sort of evaluation organizer best fit my needs. It
assisted me with breaking down what I liked about the book, and allowed me to
include information as evidence for each point.
Subject:

"The Hobbit, or There and Back Again", By J.R.R. Tolkien.

Criterion:

Successful / Unsuccessful
Reason:

Evidence:

Plot

Good plot, simple, easy to

understand, subplots give
depth

Pp 19-31 plot expd,

mention subs ch III, p 46,
chV, p 65, ch XIV p 209.

Criterion:

Successful / Unsuccessful
Reason:

Evidence:

Dialogue

Entertaining, funny at times,

heartening, or frightening, as
needed. Poems add to story.

Quote pg 11, para 1.

Page 63, para 2.
Page 255, final 2 para.

Criterion:

Successful / Unsuccessful
Reason:

Evidence:

Characterization

Both. Some chars only have

names, others characterized
perfectly in just a few lines.

Bilbo pg 24 last para,

Eaton para 4.
Elrond, pg 51

Criterion:

Successful / Unsuccessful
Reason:

Evidence:

Visualization

Middle Earth and its denizens

are brought to life throughout
the book.

Summarize ch 8. Eaton,
paragraph 3. Author's
illustrations only add 2 it

Criterion:

Successful / Unsuccessful
Reason:

Evidence:

Editing

Spelling, grammar fine

Tolkien was an Oxford

Don and assisted w/
writing dictionary.

Copyright by Holt, Rinehart and Winston. All rights reserved.