E

NDNOTE
S#2

:n
a
u
f
r
a
ge
u
rbor
d

2014

 :
naufrageur bord

[]
,



,

.
, .
Endnotes


.

,

,
New folder(3).
.
;
,
name-dropping
. .




(
),

[3]

1. ,





,

..

Gilles
Dauv/Troploin
Thorie Communiste, .
Endnotes
(http://endnotes.
org.uk/issues/1).

Endnotes,
Dauv
TC


Blaumachen, ,
coghnorti Rioters.

.
, Endnotes
(
)

late 60s


.
Endnotes



(
)
(

Thorie Communiste).
Endnotes
,

( ,
,

),
:
.

,
Blaumachen
. ,
,

( )
,


,

[4]

,
(
)
.1
;
Endnotes

60
,

Adorno
,

1920 (Rubin,
),
( Neue Marx-Lektre,
).

, Endnotes
CSE2, SydneyKonstanz, ,
/
ISMT3,
Michael Heinrich
Ingo Elbe, Moishe Postone
(Krisis,
Exit) .. (
Uno Sekine,

).

, ;
ISMT:
-
4


. /

.5

[5]

2. Conference of
Socialists Economists,



70 80.
3.
International Symposium on Marxian
Theory,




.
4.

-
.
2
Dialectical Development versus Linear
Logic Arthur,
C.J. (2002). The New
Dialectic and Marxs
Capital. Leiden:
Brill,
Ingo Elbe
Between Marx, Marxism, and Marxisms
Ways of Reading
Marxs Theory.

5. R. Bellofiore & N.
Taylor (eds), (2004).
The Constitution of
Capital. Hampshire:
Palgrave Macmillan,
p. 24.
6.
,
Michael Heinrich, -

,


Elbe
,
1
Capitalism and
Marxism
Heinrich, M. (2012).
An Introduction to the
Three Volumes of Karl
Marxs Capital. New
York: Monthly Review,

Postone, M.
(1993). Time, Labor,
and Social Domination: A Reinterpretation of Marxs Critical
Theory. Cambridge:
Cambridge University
7.

, ,
.
,




(
: presents represents
Chris Arthur)




- .6
,
,


(
) . ,


, ,
:
,

,
,
(
)

.7
,
,
(-),

[6]

 .
, ,
(
,
, , ),


.
,
Endnotes

(


, Elbe8)


. ,

,

, .


( ),
,
.

(
)
( ) start-uppers.



.
,


: /
,
.

[7]

.
,



,

( )

.



Rubin,


(

,


. . Arthur,
C.J. (2002). The New
Dialectic and Marxs
Capital. Leiden: Brill,
p. 13 Gray, N.
(2010). Abstraction,
universality, money
and capital: the
capital-theory of
value. Philosophy
Society conference.
8. Elbe , I., .. , ,







( )


.
,


, ,

,

,



.



.
, ,

,

.


Endnotes,

.

,
()


Endnotes .
,
,


. O
(

, ,


,


...)
(


)9,




.
,
,

. ,

[8]

 :


; (-)

, ,
,

;
,
,

;


.

.. 1

.
.. 2

9:
Piet Mondrian 1919,
.

[9]

9.


, ..

(



)
-

(
,

).

; la
carte; . ,
,



21 .



Endnotes #2

[ 10 ]

1

,
,


.2
Endnotes

68.
, []
[] ,
,

(value-form theory)
, ,
.3

,
,
.

,
:


,
.
:
,


;

,

,

[ 11 ]

1.



,
DD
Felix Kosmoprolet.
2. , . (1978).
,
, .
:
, . 94,
. 32 [.

(...)].
3.



Chris Arthur, Werner
Bonefeld, Hans-Georg
Backhaus, Riccardo
Bellofiore, Michael
Eldred, Michael
Heinrich, Hans Jrgen
Krahl, Patrick Murray,
Moishe Postone,
Helmult Reichelt,
Geert Reuten, Ali
Shamsavari, Felton
Shortall, Tony Smith,
Michael Williams.

4. , . (1978).
,
, .
:
, . 93-94.
5. ,




,



.



Grundrisse,
Urtext, [
],


,







.
,

.4
,




1960.
,


,
.



,
. ,


.5

,

.
,
,


.
() ,



. ,


. ,
,

[ 12 ]


,

.
,


,

.
,



.


.
,

.
- -

,
(
),
,


. , ,

.
:
.
, ,





.

[ 13 ]

-


,

.
. Backhaus, H.-G.
(1980). On the Dialectics of the ValueForm. Thesis Eleven.
no 1: 94-120 Reichelt,
H. (1995). Why did
Marx Conceal his
Dialectical Method. In
Werner Bonefeld et al
(eds). Open Marxism
vol. 3. London: Pluto
Press.

6. Rubin, . I. (1972).
Essays on Marxs
Theory of Value.
Detroit: Black & Red,
p. 5.
7. .., p. 117. Riccardo Bellofiore



,


.
.
Bellofiore, R.
(2009). Rosa Luxemburg and the Critique
of Political Economy.
London: Routledge,
p. 6.

, -
,


.
, ,
,

.


Isaak Rubin.
1920,
[] ,
,

6,

. ,
,

7. , Rubin,
,
.


. ,
,




.
,
o

,

,

[ 14 ]

 .

,


,
.



1960
Rubin


.
, ,
,
,
.


, , ,
.8
,

,
.

.
60
70,

:

,


.

[ 15 ]

8.

.


,
.



,









.


.

 ,
, ,
,
.
,


.
-

.




.
,

.
70,

,


.

.

70,
80
90 ,


70,

.

[ 16 ]

 ,
,
,



.9



2 3 ,

.
20



(, )

(,
-
). ,


,
,

, ,
,
.

,
.


,
: ,
[ ]
(

[ 17 ]

9. , . (1990).
Grundrisse,

, . :
, . 369.

 ), [ ]

.
, ,
,
,


,


:
,
.
,

:
, , ,
,

.
,


,
,
-
. ,



,

,


.

(), ,

[ 18 ]

,



1968 .


,
[ ]

,

Grundrisse
( ).

60,
,

1844.
,

,


. ,

.
,

,
,
.
Grundrisse

.

,

()

[ 19 ]

10. Camatte, J.
(1998). Capital and
Community: the
Results of the Immediate Process of
Production and the
Economic Works
of Marx. London:
Unpopular Books.

Invariance Series
I no. 2 (1968).
11. Rosldolsky, R.
(1977). The Making
of Marxs Capital.
London: Pluto Press.

1968.
12. Camatte
Rosdolsky



:
--,
.
Camatte, J. (1998).
Capital and Community. London: Unpopular Books, p. 163.

.
Jacques Camatte Invariance
1968.


-

, Invariance
.
Camatte, Roger Dangeville,
Grundrisse

-
. Camatte
Invariance
.10
Camatte
-68

Rosdolsky The Making of Marxs Capital

.11


. Rosdolsky
Grundrisse,
Camatte
,
. Camatte
Rosdolsky,12
Rosdolsky Grundrisse
, Camatte

Grundrisse,
,
.
Camatte



.

[ 20 ]


,
--,
,

.
Camatte,


,
.13

Camatte,


60
70. , ,

,

.14 , Camatte
1972
:


,
, []
:

,

.
,

(
)

,

, ,

[ 21 ]

13.

Grundrisse

Negri. ,


Camatte. ,


, Communism
and Transition
Negri Marx
Beyond Marx (1978)

.
14.



Camatte :


,

,
. ,





... , .., p.
148, n. 19.

.
.
. ,
, ,


, .15

15. .., p. 165.

,
.
Grundrisse


.16
,
,

.


,
.
,

, []

.17
,
. ,
,

,




.18

16.
,
, . (2002).
.
: ,
. 63.

1969 Sur
LUltragauche.
17.

.

,

. , .
(1990). Grundrisse,


, .
: ,
. 541. Moishe

[ 22 ]

.


,
, ,
.
. ()


.

- ,

.


, -
.

,
:


, .
, -
, : 1) -
, [...]
,

.

(
-) ,
,
, .
: ,

. [...] (2) - ,
-, ,
[...].

[ 23 ]

Postone,





,



. . Postone, M.
(1993). Time, Labor
and Social Domination. Cambridge:
Cambridge University
Press.
18. , . (2002).
.
: ,
. 80.

19. , . (1990).
Grundrisse,

, . :
, . 217.
20. ,




.

21. , TC

.


.

,
, .
[]
,
, ,
, ,
,

,
,
,
.19

Thorie Communiste (TC),

70 -68
. TC



. ,
,

.
,


20,
/
.
TC
Grundrisse:







.

[ 24 ]


,
, ,
( )
,
. , TC,
Grundrisse,21

,

,
.22





.
1956,

.
,


.
( ),
( ),
(
)23.

,


.24

20

,

[ 25 ]

22. , . (1990).
Grundrisse,

, . :
, . 642.
23.

.
Heinrich, M. (2007).
Invaders from Marx.



. ,
98.

Iring Fetscher,

Reichelt
Postone. .
Marx
and Marxism (1971,
Freiburg: Herder and
Herder).
24.



,
, Essays
on Marxs Theory of
Value Rubin

.






.
25.

,
Chris
Arthur,

[
]


Darstellung,


[]
/. . Arthur,
C. (2005). Reply to
Critics. Historical

. 60,


.


,
.

, Tronti

Neue Marx-Lektre (
).
Neue Marx-Lektre

.


,
.25 ,



[] . ,

-


,

.


,

,
. ,
Kapitallogik,

[ 26 ]


Rubin . Neue Marx-Lektre


,
.

.
,


,
1*
,
,

.26

,

. ,

,
, Rudi Dutschke.
1966, ,
2

,

1* [...] anti-authoritarian
,
, (.
).



, ,
.

[ 27 ]

Materialism, 13.2,
p. 217. [...:





,
,

coghnorti,
,


. . http://
coghnorti.wordpress.
com/txts/kapitaltranslations/].
26.


Adorno







.

27. Dutschke, R.
(1966). Zur Literatur
des revolutionren
Sozialismus von
K. Marx bis in
die Gegenwart.
SDS-korrespondenz
sondernummer 1966.
28. Krahl

1970.




Konstitution und
Klassenkampf

. [...:


Historical Materialism,
. http://www.
historicalmaterialism.
org/book-series/
translation-of-krahl.

Krahl




4 online

.27 ,

,
(raison dtre)
( ,
-,
). ,
Die Linke (
)
.
Hans Jrgen Krahl,

SDS [ ],
Dutschke . Krahl
Adorno

,
Adorno
Krahl ,


.28
,
, ,


, Krahl Adorno
Hans-Georg Backhaus, Helmult Reichelt
Neue Marx-Lektre.
,



,

29
Adorno .

[ 28 ]


1918-1919.

, Sohn-Rethel,

,

:
[]


.30

,


[ ]
.

,
,


. ,

Adorno
50 60

.




,


.

[ 29 ]

Viewpoint, . http://
viewpointmag.
com/2014/10/30/
issue-4-the-state/].
29.

Willy Huhn,

SDS
.
Rote Kmpfer,

KAPD

1920, Huhn


1933/1934


,

: Der Etatismus
der Sozialdemokratie:
Zur Vorgeschichte
des Nazifaschismus.
,



.
30. :





,




. SohnRethel, A. (1978). Intellectual and Manual
Labour. New Jersey:
Humanities Press, p.
xii. .

Adorno: ,

,
,

. Adorno, T.
(2006).
. :
, . 13.
31.

60s

.



,
Backhaus.
Reichelt, Neue MarxLektre
1963, Backhaus,
,

.31

,
Adorno
, :
[] Adorno

,

,


,

,

(!)
.32

1968.
,
,
,
, :

[ 30 ]







.

,



,

.33
Neue Marx-Lektre


.34


-
1859

,
. ,

,

-
,
.
,
,

.35 Neue MarxLektre

,36
.

[ 31 ]

.
32. Reichelt, H.
(2008). Neue MarxLektre: Zur Kritik
sozialwissenschaftlicher Logik. Hamburg:
VSA-Verlag, p. 11.
33.
SDS
1968 ,


,

1968
-
.






K-Gruppen (

 K ).
34. . Heinrich, M.
(2009 ). Reconstruction or Deconstruction? Methodological
Controversies about
Value and Capital, and
New Insights from
the Critical Edition.
In R. Bellofiore & R.
Fineschi (eds). ReReading Marx: New
Perspectives after
the Critical Edition.
Hampshire: Palgrave
Macmillan.
35. . The
Moving Contradiction
2
Endnotes.
36. Grossman,
,
,








.

-
, ,

, ,
,

,
. Zur logischen
Struktur des Kapitalbegriffs bei Karl Marx [
], o Helmut
Reichelt ,
,
:

---- .37
,
: ..
.2*
2* [...]
,
. , . (1978). , , . : , . 84. sinnlich
bersinnlich (
, . (1991). ,
(1867) . : ,
. 74, ),

transcendent, perceptible and imperceptible,
abstract . Endnotes

Werner Bonefeld Reichelt, H. (2005). Social Reality
as Appearance: Some Notes on Marxs Conception of Reality.
In W. Bonefeld & K. Psychopedis (eds). Human Dignity. Social
Autonomy And The Critique Of Capitalism. Hampshire: Ashgate
Publishing, p. 31.

. , . , .

[ 32 ]

 ,
,


. ,
Reichelt:

,

. ,

.




.


, ,

-

. [...]



-- ,

. ,
,
.38
,
.
(1991), .., . 164-5, . 31,
Helmut Reichelt.
,

, Reichelt, H. (2005), .., . 31-32.

[ 33 ]

37. Reichelt, H.
(1970). Zur logischen
Struktur des Kapitalbegriffs bei Karl Marx.
Frankfurt: Suhrkamp
Verlag.


.
.
Chris Arthur,
Tony Smith Robert
Finelli
Historical Materialism
( 11.1, 15.2
17.1).
Michael Heinrich
Dieter Wolff




.
38. .., . 46-47.

39.


,


,





.

(
)




,




. . Heinrich,
M. (1996). Engels
Edition of the Third
Volume of Capital
and Marxs Original
Manuscript. Science
& Society, vol. 60, no.
4, pp. 452-466.

Camatte
- .
[ ]
,
,

,


,
. ,




, ,

, ,
.
;




,
.

,
2 3 ,
,

,39

, ,
, , ,
.40

,

[ 34 ]


,

.
(state-derivation
debate),41 ,


.42
,



.

,


.

,
,
60
,

.

,

. ,
,
,

:

.
Reichelt
Backhaus, Adorno
(conceptuality)

[ 35 ]

40. Rosdolsky



,




Lebowitz
Shortall,

.
41. [...]
State-derivation
debate



(


),

-
. ,



-


/
.
42.
,
. J. Holloway & S.
Picciotto (eds), (1978).
State and Capital:
A Marxist Debate.
Texas: University of
Texas Press K.
Held & A. Hill, (1993).
The Democratic State:
Critique of Bourgeois Sovereignty.
Mnchen: Gegenstandpunkt Verlag.



,
. O. Nachtwey
& T. ten Brink, (2008).
Lost in Transition:
the German WorldMarket Debate in the
1970s. Historical
Materialism, 16.1, pp
37- 70.
43. Sohn-Rethel, A.
(1970). Geistige und
krperliche Arbeit. Zur
Theorie gesellschaftlicher Synthesis.
Frankfurt: Suhrkamp.

Neue Marx-Lektre
.
Adorno

Sohn-Rethel
30.
1970
Sohn-Rethel Intellectual and Manual
Labour.43 Sohn-Rethel



,

.
Sohn-Rethel
,
,


. ,

,

,

,
(form-determined)
.


,



Rubin. 1




, ,

[ 36 ]

 [...]
,
.44



. ,


.





. ,


,

,
.


.
,

.


.

:

,
, ,
.
,
,

[ 37 ]

:
Sohn-Rethel, A.
(1978). Intellectual
and Manual Labour: A
Critique of Epistemology. New Jersey:
Humanities Press.
44. , . (1991).

,
(1867)
. :
, . 65.

45. , . (1989).
Grundrisse,

, . :
, . 69.
46. Heinrich, M.
(2007). Invaders from
Marx.


. ,
98.

47. Rancire, J.
(2003).

1844
.
Althusser, L.,
Balibar, ., Establet,
R., Macherey, P.,
Rancire, J., .
:
, . 149.
48. Colletti, L. (1979).
Marxism and Hegel.
London: Verso, p. 281.

,


.45
, ,


--. ,


: ,
, (generic) ,


.
,


() .
,

:
,

,
. ,
,
,
,


.46 , ,

,
.
,

,
,

[ 38 ]

 Grundrisse Essays
Rubin. ,
,
.


,
-
,
. ,


(
).47
-
Lucio Colletti48

Napoleoni49

. ,


70, Rubin .50
(Conference of
Socialist Economists),51
,
---Rubin
--()
() .

,
[] ,


.52
Reichelt
Backhaus,

53 Konstanz-Sydney,

[ 39 ]

49. . Bellofiore, R.
(April-May 1999). The
Value of Labour Value: the Italian Debate
on Marx, 1968-1976.
In the special English
edition of Rivista di
Politica Economica
IV-4-5V.
50. ,
,
Rubin

. Essays

(
)
1973, [ ]

. . Dumbadze
D. (2010). Sachliche
Vermittlung und soziale Form. I.I. Rubins
Rekonstruktion der
marxschen Theorie
des Warenfetischismus. In D. Dumbadze
& I. Elbe u.a. (Hrsg.)
Kritik der politischen
Philosophie Eigentum. Mnster:
Gesellsschaftsvertrag,
Staat II.
51. [...] -

 CSE


Capital & Class.
52.


Jairus
Banaji: From the
Commodity to Capital:
Hegels Dialectic in
Marxs Capital. In
Elson, D. (ed.), (1979).
Value: The Representation of Labour in
Capitalism. London:
CSE Books.
53. :
Eldred, M. (1984).
Critique of Competitive Freedom and the
Bourgeois-Democratic State: Outline
of a Form-Analytic
Extension of Marxs
Uncompleted System.
Copenhagen: Kurasje.
54. Arthur, C. (1998).
Engels, Logic and
History. In Bellofiore,
R. (ed.), Marxian Economics a Reappraisal: Essays on Volume
III of Capital, vol. 1,
London: Macmillan, p.
14.

.
,
,

.
(A-)



.

.
,


. o

.

,

.
, ,

.
Chris Arthur:
,



,


(,
). , ,

[ 40 ]



(
) .54
55

,
(
) ,
, .


.


-

.56
,
.
.
,
,
,
: .

,
,
.


,


.


. ,
,
.

[ 41 ]

55. Mike Rooke

Chris
Arthur



. .
Rooke, M. (May 2009).
Marxism, Value
and the Dialectic of
Labour. Critique, Vol.
37, No 2, pp. 201-216.
56.



(

[...]


,
)

,

.

,
,

 ,
.
[...:

, . (2012).

1844. : ,
. 92].
57.
(
Backhaus) . Eldred,
M. (1984). Preface to
Critique of Competitive Freedom and the
Bourgeois-Democratic State. Copenhagen:
Kurasje, pp. xlv-li.

: ( -)

.
;



1867

. ,
,
,

. ,
,
. ,

,

!
,
.

, ,

,

.57
,
(

)


. :

[ 42 ]

[]
,

,

.

(.
Kugelmann)58 ,


.59



.
,
,



.
,



. ,
. ,
(
) .


, ,


,
,

.60

[ 43 ]

58.

,
,


(
) Eldred



,

Sraffa
,



.
59. Eldred, M., ..,
pp. xlix-l.
60. . Berki, R.N.
(1984). Insight and
Vision: The Problem
of Communism in
Marxs Thought. London: JM Dent, chapter
5.

61.
Backhaus,
van
der Linden

Stefan Breuer
Krise der Revolutionstheorie (1977).
. Van der Linden,
M. (December 1997).
The Historical Limit
of Workers Protest:
Moishe Postone,
Krisis and the
Commodity Logic.
Review of Social History, vol. 42 no. 3, pp.
447-458.

,
. 70,


,

,
,

.61

19 .


.

,
,
.
, -
.

,

,
.
Krisis Exit!
(value-critique | wertkitik).
/
[], Moishe Postone,
70,

. Time, Labor and Social Domination

( )

( ).
, ,
Postone

[ 44 ]



,
-
.62

,

,

.

()

,

.
Werner Bonefeld, , ,


,
.63 ,
Neue Marx-Lektre


,

.

,
:
;




.

[ 45 ]

62. ,
Postone











,

, TC,

. ,


,

,



(ultra). Postone, M.
& Brennan, T. (2009).
Labor and the Logic
of Abstraction: an
interview. South

Atlantic Quarterly,
108:2, p. 319.
63. . .. Bonefeld,
W. (2004). On
Postones Courageous
but Unsuccessful
Attempt to Banish
the Class Antagonism. Historical
Materialism, 12.3.
64.

Sohn-Rethel,
Adorno
Alfred Schmidt

Grundrisse

.
. Eldred, M. & Roth,
M. (1980). Translators Introduction
to Dialectics of the
Value-Form. Thesis
Eleven, no. 1, p. 96.
65. . Reichelt, H.
(1982). From the
Frankfurt School to
Value-Form Analysis.
Thesis Eleven, no. 4,
p. 166.

.
Neue MarxLektre
.
Adorno
-
,

. , Adorno

,
.64 Neue Marx-Lektre
Adorno
,
,

. ,
Adorno

.65
,

, Neue MarxLektre
.
,
Neue Marx-Lektre
Adorno.

Backhaus Reichelt,
[]
,
Adorno,
,

.

.
Society (1965), Remarks on social

[ 46 ]

conflict today (1968)

; (1968) Adorno
( )

. Remarks,
Ursula Jaerisch,

,
[]
().
,

Adorno.
Adorno
Backhaus Neue
Marx-Lektre. Adorno
-
(prformiert)


.
Backhaus, Adorno

,
(Schein)
.66 ,
Backhaus Reichelt
,
Adorno ,
,
.
, Krahl
.

,67 Krahl


,
,
Reichelt
Backhaus. Krahl,

[ 47 ]

66.
Backhaus
Adorno
1962
Backhaus, H.-G.
(1997). Dialektik der
Wertform. Freiburg:
ca ira. [...:


Backhaus

https://
reificationofperson
sandpersonification
ofthings.wordpress.
com/2012/06/25/
adorno-1962seminar-on-marx/.
,



Historical
Materialism book
series]
67. Krahl, H.-J.
(2008). Konstitution
und Klassenkampf.
Zur historischen Dialektik von brgerlicher Emanzipation
und proletarischer
Revolution. Frankfurt:
Verlag Neue Kritik
[ -

 :


].

Neue Marx-Lektre.
Backhaus, Reichelt,
Heinrich,
,

.

,
Adorno Krahl
.

.

Adorno ( , ,
Krahl),
Adorno


,
. ,
Krahl,



.
,
.


,
, , .
-
.

,
,

:

[ 48 ]



. ,


.

.

.

68
,

,
69


, . ,


,
[]
,


(value-critics), .
Thorie Communiste
.
TC

.


.
TC


,
,

[ 49 ]

68. . The
Moving Contradiction
2
Endnotes.
69. , . (1990).
Grundrisse,

, . :
, . 538.

70. Thorie Communiste (2011).

;.
Blaumachen #5, .
118.
71.



Dauv TC

Endnotes.

.


,
.
TC

.70
,


.
TC,
2 3
.71




-.



.
,
,

,



. Franois Danel
:



,
(abstracted)

[ 50 ]

 ,
(
) (
).


:
,


. [...]

,
.




,
, [ ]


,
.




,
, ,
,
, ,
.72



,

.

.

[ 51 ]

72. Danel, F. (2003).

Introduction to Rupture dans la thorie
de la revolution:
Textes 1965-1975.
Marseille: Senonevero

 60
70
.
, :
-
, ,

.


.




. TC


,

.

.




: 1917, 1968 . ,


,


60. , Rubin


-.
,
,

,

[ 52 ]

 , .73
,


,

,
.
60 .

20 ,

[ ]

.


:

.
TC


. ,
,


, .
TC


-,
- ,

.
.



,

[ 53 ]

73. ,

Rubin



,
,



/ ,
[ ]







.





,




,

.





.

,

.


,


,
.

,


.

.

[ 54 ]

.[
.
.
.
]

.
[
.
.
.
]