Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Vismay Shah (Hit and Run Case) (BMW Hit and Run Case) Sessions Court Judgment (Gujarati)
Vismay Shah (Hit and Run Case) (BMW Hit and Run Case) Sessions Court Judgment (Gujarati)
SC/41-2013
JUDGEMENT
NFB, TFZLB
ZHLP TFZLB
O[;, TFZLB
VJlW JP DFPlNP
zL ;ZSFZP
lJZ]wW
VFZF[5L
VFG\N
A\U,F[GL
AFH]DF\
8FJZ
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
2/273
UF[;F. Z]AZ] OZLIFN CSLST HFC[Z SZ[,4 T[ VG];FZ T[VF[ S,F[, BFT[
:JFDLGFZFI6
[DL:8ZDF\ VeIF; SZ[ K[P T[VF[GF lDT| lNG[X DOFEF. RF{WZL 4 pDZ JQF"
Z!4 W\WF[ J[5FZ4 ZC[JF;Lo V[q$ 4VFD|S]\H V[5F8"D[g84:8,L"U CF[l:58,
5F;[ 4 VG[ ALHF lDT| XLJD 5|[DX\SZ NJ[4 pDZ JQF" VFXZ[ Z5 4 ZC[JF;L
JLq5 ;FUZ V[5F8"D[g84 ;FZYL CF[8,GL ;FD[4 TYF ZFC], 3GxIFDEF.
58[,4pPJPZ! 4ZC[JF;L AL!(4 X]E,FE ;F[;FI8L4 ;tTFWFZ RFZZ:TF
5F;[4 VDNFJFNGFVF[ RFZ[I E[UF\ D/L TFZLB Z$qZqZ_!# GF ZF[H
ZFT|LGF GF,\NF SF[d5,[1FDF\ 45ZF[9F CFp;DF\ HDJF HJF DF8[ HJFG]\
GSSL SZ[,P T[VF[4 T[VF[GF lDT| ZFC],G]\ SFIG[8LS HLH[v!v;LALv
*!** G]\ R,FJTF CTF 4T[V[FGF 5FK/ lNG[X DOFEF. RF{WZL A[9[,F
CTFP T[VF[G]\ AHFH 5<;Z DF[8Z ;FIS, HLH[v!vV[OVFZv*!!G]\
ZFC], R,FJTF[ CTF[ 4VG[ T[ DF[8Z ;FIS, p5Z 5FK/ XLJD NJ[ A[9[,
CTF[P T[VF[ RFZ[I H6F\ 5Z[F9F CFp;DF\ HDL 4 5ZT 3[Z HJF
DF8[ JFCGF[ ,. GLS/[,P T[ ;DI[ ZFT|GF VFXZ[ ZFT|LGF 5F[6F AFZGF[
;DI YI[,F[ CTF[P
T[ ;DI[
Z:TF 5;FZ SZTL JBT[4 HHLh A\U,F[ RF[SL 4 UF[ZDF[ CF[8,GL AFH]YL
ALPV[DP 0A<I] SFZGF[ RF,S 5]Zh05[4 A[NZSFZL ZLT[ 5F[TFG]\ JFCG
R,FJL ,FJL4 VG[ 5<;Z AF.S RF,S ZFC],EF. VG[ DF[8Z ;FIS,
p5Z
5FK/
A[9[,
XLJDEF.G[
V[SND
DF[8Z
;FIS,
;FY[ V0O[8DF\ ,.4 VFXZ[ ;F[ SND N]Z AF.S ;FY[ 3;0L UI[,P VF
JBT[ ;NZL SFZ RF,S[ ALHF 56 JFCGF[G[ V0O[8DF\ ,LW[,FG]\ HF6JF
D/[,P D[F8Z ;FIS,G[ V0O[8D\F ,LWF AFN 4VF SFZ VD], 5F,"Z AFH]DF\
VFJ[,F O]85FYGF hF0 ;FY[ 8SZF.G[ pEL ZC[,LP
UF0LDF\YL V[S H6
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
3/273
pTZLG[ T[V[FG[[ cc;F[Z L ;F[Z L cc SCLG[ EFU[,4 H[G[ T[VF[ HF[I[YL VF[/BL
XS[P DF[8Z ;FIS, p5ZYL 50[, T[VF[GF A\gG[ lDT|F[G[ HF[TF\4 DFYFGF
EFU[ TYF XZLZGF EFU[ U\ELZ .HF YI[, VG[ ,F[CL GLS/T]\ CF[JFYL
4T[VF[GF lDT| lNG[XEF.V[ !_(G[ 8[,LOF[G SZL TFtSF,LS AF[,FJL
,LW[,L P A\gG[
DF8[ GHLSGL
CFHZ
ZFC],EF.
;LV[Rv!vV[. v)#&_
VFB[ VFB]\ 3;0FI[, CF[.4
CTF[P
H[ V[S;L0g8 SZL 4 UF0L D]SL EFUL UI[, CF[.4 T[GF lJZ]wW SFIN[;Z
YJF OZLIFN OZLIFNLV[ J:T|F5]Z 5F[P:8[P DF\ p5ZF[ST AFAT[
SZ[,P
Z*)4
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
4/273
;NZC]\
;AA ;NZC] ;FC[NG]\ lGJ[NG ,LW[, PAGFJ :Y/G]\ 5\RF[ s!f lNjIF\U
DG]EF. 58[, TYF sZfClQF", 5|JL6S]DFZ 9SZZGL CFHZLDF\ 5\RGFD\]
SZ[,4 VS:DFT DF\ ;\0F[JFI[, SFZG]\ 5\RF[ Z]AZ] 5\RGFD] SZL4 T[ SFZ S|[.G
YL J:T|F5]Z 5F[P:8[P GF S\d5Fpg0D\F ,. H. D]SFJ[,PT[DH ;NZC]\ SFZ
SAH[ SZ[, T[ ;AA D]NFDF, 5FJTL OF0[,4 AGFJ :Y/ 5F;[ VFJ[,
VD], 5F,"ZJF/F IF[U[XS]DFZ lJQ6]S]DFZ HF[XLG]\ lGJ[NG ,LW[,P
VS:DFTDF\ ;\0F[JFI[, JFCG AFAT[ VFZP8LPVF[P VDNFJFNG[ JFCGGL
IF\T|LS T5F;6L SZJF ;FZ]\ IFNL SZ[,P T[DH ALPV[DP 0A<I] SFZGF
DF,LSG\] GFD D[/JJF AFAT[ 56 VFZP8LPVF[P VDNFJFNG[ IFNL SZ[,P
T[DH 5;F[",L DF[8;" 4 Y,T[H VDNFJFNGFV[FG[ 5T| ,BL ;NZC\]
VS:DFTDF\ ;\0F[JFI[, ALPV[DP 0A<I] SFZ V\U[ DFlCTL DF\U[,PH[YL
;NZC]\
5/273
6/273
VlWSFZLV[ T5F;GF
V\T[
TFZLB
!5q$qZ_!# GF ZF[H
;AAG\] ZH] SZ[,P H[G[ D[HL:8[=8 SF[8"DF\ OF[HNFZL S[; G\AZ Z(Z&qZ_!#
YL GF[WJFDF \ VFJ[,P VFZF[5LG[ T5F;GF SFU/F[GL GS,F[ VF5L 4
T[VF[ T[VF[GF ARFJ ;FZ]\ ;ZSFZ ;CFIYL JSL,zLGL DNN D[/JJF
DF\U[ K[ S[ S[D T[ ;AA 5]KL BFTZL SZ[, PVFZF[5LV[ 5F[T[ 5F[TFGF
ARFJDF\ BFGUL JSL, ZF[SJF DF\UTF C[FJFG]\ H6FJ[,P T[ AFN TFZLB
(q5qZ_!# GF ZF[H SDL8, C]SD SZL ;[;g; S[F8"DF\ VFU/GL .g;FOL
SFI"JFCL YJF ;FZ\] DF[S,L VF5[, PH[G[ ;[;g; S[; G\AZ $!qZ_!# YL
GF[WJFDF\ VFJ[,P
s#f
OF[HNFZL
SZL4 T[ AFN
OZLIFN 51F[
7/273
VF\S
&
5|JL6S]DFZ
9SZ4
;FC[N
G\AZ
s5f **
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
8/273
*(
,FXG] (Z
Z!
ZZ
Z#
Z$
Z5
Z&
Z*
(( VG[
()
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
9/273
Z)
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
10/273
C\;FA[G
AFA]EF.
5\RF,
DNNGLX !_$
lGIFDS4V[OV[;V[, VDNFJFN 4 ;FC[N G\AZ s!$f
4VFZF[5L lJ:DIGF D[0LS, VF[lO;Z[ V[ST| SZ[,
GD]GFG] 5'yYSSZ6 SZJF ;FZ] DF[S,[, T[ 5'yYSSZ6
SZGFZ VlWSFZLGL H]AFGL
!!5
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
11/273
zL
; !Z$
12/273
!$$
!$5 VG[
!$&
!$)
!5_
;[Sg0
($q!#GL !5#
13/273
!&Z
(Z
!&#
!&$
s$P!f
!&&
!&(
VFZF[5L
T[ ;AAGL
VZHL
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
14/273
VF\S !#5
T[VF[V[ OF[H NFZL SFI"Z LTL VlWlGIDGL S,D #!! D]HA VZHL
VF5L
AFAT[
NL,L5EF.
JZJFEF.
.g8ZjI\]
,[GFZ
V[gSZ
VF\S
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
15/273
&
!)_
!)*
16/273
Z_)
Z!
ZZ
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
17/273
s(f
s)f
D]NFGP Z
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
18/273
X]\ OZLIFN 51F ;FlAT SZ[ K[ S[4 p5ZF[ST TFZLB[4 ;DI[ VG[
:Y/[ ;NZC] VZF[5L R,FJTF CTF T[ SFZ 5]Zh05[ A[NZSFZL
VG[ UO,TEZL ZLT[ C\SFZL 5|YD HHLH A\U,F[ RFZ Z:TF 5F;[
;FC[N DLT[X lSZ6EF. XFC ZC[JF;L ! 4 lN5SGUZ 5F,0L
VDNFJFN GFVF[ T[VF[GL SFZ
V[;[g8 G\AZ HLH[v!
vS[SI]v$)&_
GL
C\SFZL
VFJTF
CTF
T[VF[GL
SFZG[ VFZF[5LV[ 5F[TFGF CJF,FGL VG[ 5F[T[ R,FJTF CTF
T[ SFZYL 0FAL ;F.0GF 50BFGF EFU[ 5F[TFGL
SFZ
VY0FJ[, T[DH T[YL VFU/ ,1DL UF\9LIF ZY T|6 Z:TF5F;[
;FD[YL DFG;L ;S", TZOYL VFJT]\ 5<;Z DF[8Z ;FIS,
HLH[v!vV[OVFZ v*!! T|6 Z:TF ;S",YL ,F0 ;F[;FI8L
TZO J/TF T[G[ V0O[8[ ,. HF[ZYL 8SSZ DFZ[, H[YL DF8Z
;FIS, p5Z RF,S VG[ 5FK/ A[9[, .;DG[ 5\NZ O]8
CJFDF\ pK/[, VG[ GLR[ 58SFTF\ VS:DFTJF/L SFZYL -;0L
UI[, VG[ O]85FY 5F;[ VFJ[, hF0 ;FY[ 5F[TFGL SFZ
VY0FJL hF0 GDFJL NLW[, SFZG[ G]S;FG SZ[, T[DH
DF[8Z ;FIS,G[ 56 G]S;FG SZ[, T[ ZLT[ EFZTLI N\0
;\lCTFGL S,D $Z* D]HA ;HFG 5FT| U]gCF[ VFRZ[, K[ Pm
D]NFG $
\ o X]\ OZLIFN51F ;FlAT SZ[ K[ S[4
p5ZF[ST TFZLB[ VG[ ;DI[
:Y/[
VFZF[5LV[
5F[TFGF
CJF,FGL
SFZ
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
19/273
5]Zh05[
VG[
A[OLSZF.YL
A[NZSFZL
5]J"S
VG[
A[OFDZLT[ R,FJL 4 5F[TFGF S'tIYL ;FDL jIlSTG]\ D'tI]\
lG5HL XS[ T[JL HF6SFZL ;FY[ VG[ 8=FOLS CF[I T[JF HFC[ZZF[0
p5Z C\SFZL ,1DL UF\9LIF ZY T|6 Z:TF
5F;[ ;FD[YL
DFG;L ;S", TZOYL VFJT] 5<;Z DF[8Z ;FIS, HLH[v!
vV[OVFZ v*!! T|6 Z:TF ;S",YL ,F0 ;F[;FI8L TZO
J/TF T[G[ V0O[8[ ,. HF[ZYL 8SSZ DFZ[, H[YL DF8Z ;FIS,
p5Z RF,S VG[ 5FK/ A[9[, .;DG[ 5\NZ O]8 CJFDF\
pK/[, VG[ GLR[ 58SFTF\ VS:DFTJF/L SFZYL -;0L UI[,
DF[8Z ;FIS, RF,S ZFC], 3GxIFDEF. 58[, VG[ DF[8Z
;FIS, p5Z 5FK/ A[9[,
lXJD 5|[DX\SZ NJ[ G[ U\ELZ
.HFVF[ 5CF[RF0L H[YL :Y/ p5Z lXJD NJ[G]\ D'tI]TFP
Z5qZqZ_!# GF ZF[H lG5HFJ[, T[DH ;FZJFZ NZdIFG
DF[8Z ;FIS, RF,S .;D ZFC],G] D'tI]\ TFPZ*qZqZ_!# GF
ZF[H
lG5H[,
VFD
VFZ[F5LV[
;F5ZFW
DG]QIJWGF[ U]gCF[ VFRZL EFZTLI N\0 ;\lCTFGL S,D
#_$s5F8"vZf D]HA ;HFG[ 5FT| U]gCF[ VFRZ[, K[P m
D]NFG\ 5
s!_f
!
Z
#
$
5
X]\ C]SD m
s!!f
YL ZH] YI[,
S[ H[VF[
20/273
;FC[N4 ;FC[N
G\AZ !! 4OZLIFNL ,,LT U]%TF VG[ ;FC[N G\AZ !Z4 lNG[X DOFEF.
RF{WZLGF 5]ZFJFYL CF,GF[ AGFJ VDNFJFNDF\ HHLh A\U,F TZOYL 5|
[DR\NGUZ ZF[[0 p5Z VFJ[, ,1DL UF\9LIF ZY 5F;[ 4 ;\N[X 5|[; HJFGF 8G"
5F;[ AG[, CF[JFG]\ OZLIFN 51F[ ;FlAT SZ[, K[ PJW]DF\4 p5ZF[ST A\gG[
;FC[NGF 5]ZFJFYL H 4 CF,GF AGFJ ;DI[ AgG[ DZ6 HGFZFVF[ 5<;Z
DF[8Z ;FIS, p5Z DFG;L RFZ Z:TF TZOYL HTF CTF VG[ ;\N[X 5|[;
TZO 8G" ,[TF\ ;DI[ ;FD[YL V[8,[ S[ HHLh A\U,F TZOYL V[S ALPV[DP
0A<I] SFZ 5]Zh05[ VFJ[, VG[ AF.SG[ 8SSZ DFZTF\ CF,GF[ AGFJ
AG[, CF[JFG]\ 56 OZLIFN 51F ;FlAT SZ[, K[P JW]DF\ 4 p5ZF[ST A\gG[
;FC[NF[GF 5]ZFJF
D]HA
ZFC],
[,F VG[ GLR[ HDLG p5Z 58SFI[,F VG[ T[ SFZ6[ U\ELZ .HFVF[ YI[,
H[DF\ XLJD NJ[G[ CF[l:58,DF\ ,. HTF\ tIF\ DZ6 HFC[Z SZJFDF\ VFJ[,
HIFZ[ ZFC], 58[, ;FZJFZ NZdIFG TFPZ*qZqZ_!# GF ZF[H DZ6 5FD[, P
5]ZFJFGL ;FY[ ;FY[
D[0LS,
H[ XLJD NJ[GF
21/273
ZLT[ D'tI]\ YI[, CF[JFG]\ VG[ SFZ RF,SGF S'tI GF SFZ6[[ D'tI] lG5H[, CF[.
T[J]\ D'tI]\ CF[DL;F.0, 0[Y CF[JFG]\ OZLIFN 51F ;FlAT SZ[, K[ P
s!!P!f
G\AZ !! 4 OZLIFNL ,,LT U]%TF VG[ ;FC[N G\AZ !Z4 lNG[X DOFEF.
RF{WZL V[ CF,GF[ AGFJ HF[I[,F[ CF[JFG]\ A\gG[ ;FC[NF[GF[ 5]ZFJF[ K[P 5Z\T]\ SFZ
RF,S SF[6 CT]\] VYJF TF[ SFZRF,S CF,GF
VFZF[5L CF[JFGL
CSLST[ A\gG[ ;FC[NF[V[ OZLIFN 51FGF SYGG[ ;DY"G SZTF G CF[.4 lJD]B
HFC[Z SZL4 p,8T5F;
D]HA
OZLIFNL
AGFJ
;DI[
SFZRF,SG[
HF[I[,
CTF[ VG[ T[G[ VF[/BL XS[ T[D H6FJ[, CT]\P ;FY[ ;FY[ 5F[TFGF lJX[QF
lGJ[NGDF\ H6FjIF D]HA
ZF[H
5F[,L; ;D1F CFYZ YTF\4 CF,GF VFZF[5L H SFZ RF,S CF[JFG]\ VF[/BL
ATFJ[, CF[JFGL CSLST 5F[TFGF lGJ[NGDF\ H6FJ[, PT[ p5ZF\T VFZF[5LGL
VF[/B V\U[G]\ 5\RGFD]\
VG[ 5\RF[ Z]AZ] 56 OZLIFNLV[ CF,GF VFZF[5LG[ SFZ RF,S TZLS[ VF[/BL
ATFJ[, CTFP T[D KTF\ SF[8" Z]AZ] ;FC[N G\AZ !! OZLIFNLV[ ZH] SZ[,
5]ZFJF D]HA CF,GF VFZF[5L AGFJ ;DI[ SFZ RF,S CF[JFGL CSLSTF[ HF6L
A]hLG[ VFZF[5LG[ DNN SZJF DF8[ T[DH AGFJ ;DI[ CF,GF VFZF[5L GL SFZ
RF,S TZLS[GL VF[/B K]5FJTF CF[JFG]\ :5Q8 56[ O,LT YFI K[P VG[ T[YL
;FC[N G\AZ !! V[ SF[8" Z]AZ] BF[8L H]AFGL VF5[, CF[JFGF U]gCF ;\A\W[
;FC[N G\AZ !! OZLIFNL lJZ]wW SFI"JFCL SZJL HF[.V[P
s!!PZf
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
22/273
56[ O,LT YFI K[P JW]DF\ ;FC[N G\AZ !! OZLIFNL ,,LT U]%TF TYF ;FC[N
G\AZ !Z 4 lNG[X RF{WZL GF OF[HNFZL SFI"ZLTL VlWlGIDGL S,D !&$
VgJI[ lJwJFG D[HL:8[=8 ;D1F lGJ[NGF[ GF[WJFDF\ VFJ[,F CTF VG[ T[JF
lGJ[NGF[DF\ H6FJ[, CSLSTF[ 56 CF,GF VFZF[5L H
RF,S CF[JFGL CSLST HFC[Z SZ[, CTL VG[ T[D KTF\ T[GFYL lJZ]wWGL
CSLST SF[8" Z]AZ] H6FJL BF[8L H]AFGL VF5TF CF[JFG]\ :5Q856[ H6FI K[P
VG[ T[YL T[VF[GF lJZ]wW SF[8" Z]AZ] BF[8L H]AFGL VF5JF DF8[ SFI"JFCL
SZJL HF[.V[P
s!!P#f
p5ZF[ST A\gG[ ;FC[NF[ OZLIFN 51FGF SYGG[ ;DY"G VF5TF G CF[JF KTF\
OZLIFN 51F[
;\0F[JFI[, SFZGF RF,S CF,GF VFZF[5L CF[JFG]\ OZLIFN 51F[ ;FlAT SZ[,
K[ H[ ;FC[N G\AZ !# 4 5F[TFGL SFZ ,. AGFJJF/F ZF[0 p5ZYL 5;FZ YTF\
CTF VG[ CF,GF
H CF,GF
VG[ YF[0FS H VFU/ HTF\ CF,GF[ AGFJ AG[,F[ VG[ T[ ;DI[ SFZ RF,S
56 tIF\ VFJL UI[, CTF[ VG[ SFZDF\ H A[9F A[9F CF,GF[ AGFJ HF[I[,
CF[JFGF[ 5]ZFJF[ K[P JW]DF\ AGFJJF/L HuIFG\] VF\S *( GF 5\RGFDF D]HA
56 ;FC[N G\AZ !# GL SFZ AGFJ :Y/[ ZF[0GL 5lxRD AFH]V[ GHLSDF\
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
23/273
CF[JFG]\
VG[
T[JL
SFZGF
0FAL
AFH]V[
G]S;FG
YI[,F
HFC[Z YI[, CT]\ S[ 4 CF,GF AGFJGF YF[0FS H ;DI 5C[,F\ VgI V[S
SFZG[ 56 ALPV[DP 0A<I]
H[ ;DU| 5]ZFJF[ wIFGDF\ ,[TF\4 AGFJGF :Y/[ CF,GF ;FC[N G\AZ !#GL
CFHZL OZLIFN 51F ;FlAT SZ[, K[P VG[ ;FC[N G\AZ !# GFVF[V[ AGFJ
HF[I[,F[ CF[. SFZ RF,SGL VF[/B VU[ ;FC[N G\AZ !# GF 5]ZFJF p5Z S[F.
X\SF SZL XSFI T[D GYLP
s!!P5f
T[GF
ZHL:8[=XG
V\U[GF
SFU/F[
;LPV[RP v_!vV[.v)#&_
CF[JFG]\
D/L
VFJ[,F
YTF\4 T[GF XZLZ p5Z .HFVF[ CF[JFG]\ VF\S ($ GF 5\RGFDFYL 5]ZFJF[ K[P
H[ 5\RGFD]\ 5\RF[GL CFHZLDF\ 4 VFZF[5LGL XZLZ l:YlTG]\ 5\RGFD]\ SZJFDF\
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
24/273
VFJ[, CT\] VG[ T[JF 5\RGFDFGF 5\R ;FC[N HLT]EF. KUGEF. GFIL
;FC[N G\AZ !_ GF 5]ZFJF D]HA 56
VG[ VFZF[5LG[ 5F[TFG[ YI[, .HFVF[ V\U[ D[0LS, VF[lO;Z Z]AZ] lC:8=L
H6FJ[, T[ D]HA 56 CF,GF VS:DFTDF\ VFZF[5LG[ T[JL .HFVF[ YI[,
CF[JFGF[ D[0LS, VF[lO;ZGF[ 5]ZFJF[ K[PVFD CF,GF VS:DFT ;DI[4
VS:DFT DF\ ;\0F[JFI[,ALPV[DP 0A<I] SFZ CF,GF VFZF[5L R,FJTF CF[JFG]\
VG[ VS:DFT YTF\ VFZF[5LG[ XZLZ[ .HFVF[ YI[, CF[JFG]\ :5Q856[ O,LT
YFI K[P
s!!P*f
V[JL N,L,
VFZF[5LGL
5F[,L; ;D1F T5F; YI[,4 T[DH TALAL T5F; DF8[ 0F[S8Z 5F;[ ,.
UI[,F
VFZF[5LG[ WSS[ R-FJL VG[ B[RTF6 SZTF\ VFJL .HFVF[ YI[, CF[JFGL
CSLST[ ARFJ 51F[
25/273
OZLIFN
lS|DLG,
5|F[;LHZ
4VS:DFTDF\ ;\0F[JFI[,
S,D
JFCG
#!#
VgJI[GF
lGJ[NGDF\
5{SL SF[6
5F[TFGF RFZ
SFZ ,. UI[,
CT\]
T[ V\U[ VFZF[5LG[ RF[SS; VG[ ;RF[8 CSLST H6FJ[, GYLP JW]DF\ ZH]VFT
V[JL K[ S[ VS:DFTDF\ ;\0F[JFI[,
AGFJ ;DI[
T[JL SFZ SF[6 ,. UI[, CT\] VG[ SF[6 R,FJT\] CT]\ T[JL
VlWlGIDGL
HF[.V[
CSLSTF[
5Z\T]
S,D
!_&
VG[ ;RF[8
56
VFZF[5LV[ V[JF[ SF[. ARFJ ,LW[,F[ G CTF[ S[4 AGFJ ;DI[ 4 5F[TFGL
RF[SS; V[S 0=F.JZ ;NZ JFCG ,. UI[, CTF S[ R,FJTF CTF PVFD
VFZF[5LV[
VG[ VFZF[5LV[ 5F[TFGL lJX[QF HF6SFZL V\U[ SF[. 5]ZFJF[ ZH] SZ[, G CF[.
VFZF[5L lJZ]wW VG]DFG SZL XSFI P
26/273
[DR\NGUZ ZF[0 p5Z AG[,F[ CTF[ VG[ T[YL 5|[DR\NGUZ ZF[0YL VFZF[5L
5lZlRT C[FJFG]\ :5Q856[ O,LT YFI K[P
s!!P)f
JW]DF\4
56 ,1DL UF\9LIF ZY GF
SFZGL :
VF5[,F[P ;FY[ ;FY[ ALPV[DP 0A<I] SFZ GF 0L,Z 5;F[",L DF[8;" GF HGZ,
D[G[HZ GF 56 VS:DFTDF\ ;\0F[JFI[, SFZGF DF[0,GL ALPV[DP0A<I]
0[DF[ SFZ
VS:DFT
T[ V\UG
[ F[ VlE5|FI VF5[, CTF[P T[ H ZLT[ V[OPV[;PV[,P VlWSFZL V[ 56
ALPV[DP 0A<IP] SFZ G[ YI[, G]S;FG
H[ hF0
;FY[ 8SZFI[, VG[ pEL ZC[, T[ hF0GL 5lZl:YlT VG[ hF0G[ YI[,
G]S;FG
wIFG[ ,.
SFZGL :5L0
HGFZFVF[ CJFDF\ O\UF[/FTF\ 5\NZ[S O]8 pR[YL GLR[ 58SFI[,F VG[ T[YL
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
27/273
YI[,L U\EZL .HFVF[GF SFZ6[ D'tI] GL5H[,P VG[ T[YL T[J\] D'tI] ;F5ZFW
DG]QIJW U6FIP VG[ VFZF[5LV[ T[J]\ S'tI HF6SFZL ;FY[ SZ[, CF[.4
EFZTLI N\0 ;\lCTFGL S,D #_$s5F8"vZfD]HAGF[ U]gCF[AGTF[ CF[JFG]\
OZLIFN51F
9ZFJJF[
;FlAT
HF[.V[
SZ[,
POZLIFN
K[
51FGL
VG[
VFZF[5LG[
p5ZF[ST
N,L,F[
TS;LZJFG
DF8[
lJlJW
s!Zf
YI[,F[ GYLP T[YL T[JL CSLSTF[ ;FlAT SZJFDF\ OZLIFN 51F lGQO/ UI[,
K[ PJW]DF\ 4 V[JL ZH]VFT SZ[, K[ S[4 JFCGGL UlT JW] CF[JF DFT|YL
CF,GF[ U]gCF[ ;FlAT YTF[ CF[JFG]\ U6L XSFI GlCP SFZ6 S[ JFCGGL UlT
T[ U]gCF[ ;FlAT SZJF DF8[ DCtJG]\ GYLP VG[ T[ DF8[
H[ :Y/[ JFCG 4
H[ ZF[0 p5Z R,FJJFDF\ VFJ[, CF[I T[ :Y/GL ,F[SF,L8L T[DH ZF[0 p5ZGF
8=FOLSG[ wIFGDF\ ZFBLG[ lG6"I SZL XSFIP 5Z\T]\ AGFJJF/F ZF[0 p5Z ZFT|
LGF ;DI[ 8=FOLS ZC[TF[ CF[JF V\U[ OZLIFN 51F[ SF[. 5]ZFJF[ ZH] YI[,F[ GYL VG[
T[YL EFZTLI N\0 ;\lCTFGL S,D #_$s5F8"vZf ,FU] 5F0L XSFI T[D
GYLP
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
28/273
s!ZP!f
AGFJJF/F ZF[0 5SJFGYL 5|[DR\NGUZ ZF[0 ;LWF[ H ZF[0 K[P VG[ T[GF p5Z
SF[. J/F\S VFJ[,F[ GYLP 5Z\T]\ 0LJF.0ZYL HJF VFJJF DF8[GF A[ EFU
5F0[,F K[ P JW\]DF\4 ;\N[X 5|[; TZO J/JFGF[ Z:TF[ 4 AGFJJF/F ZF[[0 p5Z
V[S GFG]\ ;S", VFJ[ K[ P5Z\T]\ T[JF ;S",G[ OZLG[ HJFGF AN,[
DF[8Z
HGFZF
D'TSF[ 5F[T[ H 5F[TFG]\ JFCG R,FJJFDF\ A[NZSFZ CF[JFG]\ ;FlAT YFI K[P
s!ZPZf
wiFFGDF\
,[TF\
ALPV[DP0A<I]
SFZRF,S[
A|[S
DFZ[,
JW]DF\4
ARFJ
51F[
lJPWFPzLGL
ZH]VFT
YI[, CF[JFG]\
V[JL
K[
S[4
;FlAT YI[,
CF[JFG]\ DFGL ,.V[ TF[ 456 T[JL SFZ VFZF[5L H R,FJTF CTF T[ CSLST
OZLIFN 51F[ ;FlAT SZJL HF[.V[P ;FY[ ;FY[ SFZ RF,S TZLS[ VFZF[5L
5F[TFG]\ JFCG R,FJJFDF\ A[NZSFZ CF[JFG]\ 56 OZLIFN 51F[ ;FlAT SZJ]\
HZ]ZL K[ 5Z\T]\
SZJF DF8[
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
29/273
;FC[NF[ 4V[8, [S[ ;FC[N G\AZ !!4,,LT U]%TF VG[ ;FC[N G\AZ !Z lNG[X
RF{WZLGF 5]ZFJFG[ wIFGDF\ ,[TF\4 OZLIFN 51FG[ ;DY"G VF5TF GYL
VG[ T[YL ;FIF\lUS 5]ZFJFG[ ;DY"G D/T]\ GYLP VS:DFTDF\ ;\0F[JFI[,
SFZ CF,GF VFZF[5L R,FJTF CF[JFGF[ 5]ZFJF[ ZH] YI[,F[ GYLP T[YL VFZF[5LGL
SFZ RF,S TZLS[ VF[/B Y. XS[ GlCP T[DH T[JL SF[. VF[/B 5Z[0 56
VFZ[F5LGL ;FlAT Y. XS[, GYLP p5ZF[ST A\gG[ ;FC[NF[G[ OZLIFN 51F[ OZL
UI[, ;FC[N HFC[Z
OZLIFN
51F[
XFCGF[ 5]ZFJF[
ZH]
YI[,
;FC[N
G\AZ
!#
lDT[X
lSZ6EF.
wIFGDF\ ,[TF\
5]ZFJF[ X\SF:5N
AG[ K[ SFZ6 S[4 ;FC[N VFZF[5LG[ VUFpYL VF[/BTF CF[I T[JF[ S[F.
5]ZFJF[ GYLP VG[ T[YL HIFZ[ VFZF[5L ;FC[N DF8[ V5lZlRT
CF[. VG[
SZFJJFDF\
GF[ 5]ZFJF[
VFJ[,
GYLP
JW]DF\4
;FC[N
G\AZ
!#
VG[ T[YL T[JF ;FC[NGF 5]ZFJFDF\ X\SF p5l:YT YTL C[F.4 T[JF ;FC[NGF
5]ZFJF p5Z VFWFZ ZFBL XSFI GlC VG[ T[JF[ 5]ZFJF[ lJxJ;GLI U6L
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
30/273
UI[, K[P JW]DF\4 ARFJ 51F[ lJPWFPzL GL ZH]VFT V[JL K[ S[4 ;FC[N
G\AZ !! 4 OZLIFNL ,,LT U]%TF VG[ ;FC[N G\AZ !Z4 lNG[X RF{WZLG]\
OF[HNFZL SFI"ZLTL VlWlGIDGL S,D !&$ VgJI[ lGJ[NG GF[WJF DF8[GL
IFNL VF\S !&!4 !&_ GL wiFFGDF\ ,[TF\4 56 T[JL IFNL SIF" TFZLB
(qZqZ_!# GL K[P VG[ T[ IFNL SZL tIF\ ;]WL ;FC[N G\AZ !# 56
DCtJGF ;FC[N CF[.
T[J]\ H6FT]\
GYLP
NFX"lGS ;FC[N CF[T TF[4 ;FC[N G\AZ !! VG[ ;FC[N G\AZ !Z GL VF\S !&_
VG[ VF\S !&! GL IFNL SZL T[ ;FY[ ;FC[N G\AZ !# G]\ OF[HNFZL SFI"ZLTL
VlWlGIDGL S,D !&$ D]HA G]\ lGJ[NG GF[WJF T5F;GLX[
lJP
VlWlGIDGL S,D
!&$
56
DCtJGF[ 5]ZFJF[ U6L XSFI GlCP 5Z\T] T[GF[ p5IF[U ZH] YI[, DCtJGF
5]ZFJFGF ;DY"GDF\
V,AT ;FC[N G\AZ !! VG[ ;FC[N G\AZ !ZGFV[ 5F[T[ VFJ]\ SF[. lGJ[NG
lJP D[HL:8[=8 ;D1F GF[WJ[, CF[JFGL CSLSTGF[ .gSFZ SZ[,F[ K[ VG[ T[J]\
lGJ[NG ;FC[N[ ,BFjIF D]HA GF[WFI[, CF[JFGL CSLST ;FlAT SZJFDF\
OZLIFN51F lGQO/ UI[, K[P JW]DF\ ;FC[NF[G[ lJD]B HFC[Z SIF" AFN 56
OZLIFN 51F[ SZ[, p,8T5F; GF V\T[ 56 T[J]\ lGJ[NGDF\ H6FJ[, CSLSTF
V\U[ 56 lJZF[WFEF;
31/273
\s !ZP&f
,LW[,P
V\U[ 5F[,L;G[
5LPV[;PVF[P
GF
5]ZFJF
D]HA
AGFJ
G CTLP VFD 4 AGFJ V\U[ ;F{5|YD HF6 lNjI[X NJ[ GFDGL jIlSTV[ SZ[,
VG[ T5F;GLX[ :Y/ p5Z T[G]\ lGJ[NG GF[W[,
CF[I T[JF[ SF[. 5]ZFJF[ GYLP VG[ T[YL VF\S ($ GF 5\RGFDF D]HA H[ V[F/B
SZFJJFDF\ VFJ[, T[ ;FlAT YTL GYLP 5Z\T]\ 5F[,L;GF ATFJJFYL
VG[ 5F[,L;GF SC[JFYL T[JL VF[/B V\U[ BF[8]\ 5\RGFD\] pE\] SZJFDF\ VFJ[,
CF[JFG]\ H6FI K[ P SFZ6 S[4 T[JF 5\RGFDFGF 5\R ;FC[NF[ VG]S|D[ ;FC[N
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
32/273
CFHZ C[FI
T[JF[ SF[. 5]ZFJF[ GYLP V[8,[ S[ OZLIFNL T[ ;DI[ CFHZ C[FI T[JF[ SF[.
5]ZFJF[ GYLP
s!ZP*f
:5Q8
56[ H6FI K[ S[4 OZLIFNLV[ AGFJ ;DI[ SFZ HF[I[, G CTL4 SFZ SF/F
S,ZGL CTL T[J]\
UI[, G CT]\4 SFZ SF[6 R,FJT\] CT\]4 SFZ RF,S[ S[JF S50F\ 5C[Z[, CTF\ T[DH
SFZDF\ SF[6 SF[6 CTF T[ OZLIFNLG[ HF6JF D/[, G CF[JFG]\ H6FI K[P
JW]DF\ V[JL ZH]VFT SZ[, K[ S[4 T[ SFZ RF,SGL VF/B SZFJJF DF8[ 5F[,L;
5F;[ ;DI G CF[JFG]\ OZLIFN 51FG\] SYG GYLP T[D KTF\4 V[ShI]S[8LJ
D[HL:8[=8 5F;[ VF[/B 5Z[0 S[D SZFJJFDF\ VFJ[, GlC 4T[ V\U[ OZLIFN
51F[ SF[. B],F;F[ SZ[,F[ GYLP
s!ZP(f
jNFZF CF,GF VFZF[5LG[ CF,GFU]gCFDF\ BF[8L ZLT[ ;\0F[JL NLW[, CF[JFG]\ :5Q8
56[ H6FI K[ SFZ6 S[4 ;FC[N G\AZ Z# 5LPV[;PVF.P UF[;F. AGFJ AFN
5|YDJFZ AGFJGF :Y/[ UI[,F VG[ AGFJ :Y/[ 50[, SFZDF\ JLDFGF
SFU/F[ CTF H[ VFZF[5L lJ:DI XFCGF GFDGF CF[JFG]\ H6FI[, VG[ T[ SFZ
RF,S 56 lJ:DIXFC CF[JFG]\
VFD4 VFZF[5L 5S0FIF T[ 5C[,F\YL SFZ RF,S lJ:DI XFC CF[. 4T[ H
AGFJ JBT[ SFZ R,FJTF[ CF[JFGL WFZ6F SZL CF,GF U]gCFDF\5F[,L;
[ T5F; RF,] SZ[, CTLP5Z\T] T5F;GLXGL VF CSLSTF[ wIFGDF\ ,LW[, G
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
33/273
CTL S[ SFZ DF,LS SF[.56 C[FI T[ DCtJG]] GYLP 5Z\T] AGFJ ;DI[ SFZ
SF[GF SAHFDF\4 CTL VYJF TF[ SF[6 R,FJT\] CT]\ T[ VU[ 5F[,L;[ T5F;
SZJL HZ]ZL CT]\ VG[ T[ CSLST OZLIFN 51F[ ;FlAT S ZJFGL CF[I K[P
s!ZP)f
GFDNFZ
T{IFZ CTL
;FC[N
34/273
V\U[ OZLIFN51F 5F;[ ALHF[ SF[. 5]ZFJF[ GYLP JW]DF\ V[JL ZH]VFT SZ[,
K[ S[ OZLIFNL GL H[D H ;FC[N G\AZ !Z lNG[XEF. RF{WZLGF 5]ZFJF D]HA
56 SFZ RF,S SF[6 CT]\ T[ ;FC[NG[ BAZ G CTLP VG[ ,,LT U]%TF
;FY[ SF[. JFT YI[, CF[I T[ ;FC[NGF wIFGDF\ G CTLP 5Z\T] A[ lNJ;
5KL
;FC[NG[ HF6JF
D/[,
!ZGFG\]
56
lS|DLG,
5|F[;LHZ
SF[0GL
S,D
!&$
RF,S
!# GF
5]ZFJF D]HA
T[VF[ AGFJ :Y/[ VFJ[,F tIFZ[ A[ KF[SZF h5Fh5L SZTF CTF VG[ T[DF\YL
V[S KF[SZF[ EFUL UI[,FG]\ H6FJ[, K[P 5Z\T]\ ALHF SF[. ;FC[N VFJL
CSLST H6FJTF GYLP JW]DF\4 ;FC[N G\AZ !# AGFJGF :Y/[ VFjIF
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
35/273
tIFZ[ UF0LDF\ H A[;LG[ AGFJ HF[I[,FG]\ H6FJ[, K[P VG[ V[S EF. HDLG
p5Z 50[,F H[ DZL UI[,F CF[I T[D H6FI[, T[D KTF\ UF0LDF\YL pTZTF
GYL J/L4 5FKF VFU/
GHZ[ HF[I[,F[ P5Z\T]\ 4 T[JL SF[. CSLST 5F[TFGF 5F[,L; Z]AZ]GF lGJ[NGDF\
H6FJ[, GYLP JW]DF\ OZLIFN 51F[ ZH] YI[, 5]ZFJFG[ wIFG[ ,.X]\
TF[4AGFJGF
ALHF lNJ;[
CT\]P T[YL
;FC[N G\AZ !#
G[ T[JF[ OF[8F[ HF[.G[ CF,GF VFZF[5LG[ S[F8" Z]AZ] 5|YDJFZ VF[/BL ATFJ[,
CF[. T[JF[ 5]ZFJF[ lJxJ;GLI VG[ VFWFZE]T U6L XSFI GlCP JW]DF\
CF,GF ;FC[N Z]AZ] SFZ RF,SGL SF[. VF[/B 5Z[0 V[ShI]S[8LJ D[HL:8[=8
Z]AZ] S[ VFZF[5L CFHZ YI[,F tIFZ[ 5F[,L; :8[XGDF\ 56 SZFJJFDF\ VFJ[,
GYL VG[ T[YL 56 TFPZ*qZqZ_!# GF ZF[H HIFZ[ VFZF[5L CFHZ YI[,
T[ H lNJ;[ ;FC[N G\AZ !# 5F[,L; :8[XG[ UI[,F CTF VG[ T[D KTF\ CF,GF
;FC[N Z]AZ] SFZ RF,S TZLS[ CF,GF VFZF[5LGL VF[/B SZFJJFDF\ VFJ[, G
CTL P H[ TDFD 5]ZFJF[ wIFGDF\ ,[TF\4 CF,GF ;FC[NG[ OZLIFN 51F[ BF[8F
;FC[N TZLS[
;FC[NF[ p5Z VFWFZ ZFB[, K[ T[ 5{SL ;FC[N G\AZ !! 4 VG[ ;FC[N G\AZ !Z
OZLIFN51FGF S[;G[ ;DY"G SZTF GYLPVG[ T[JF ;FC[NF[GF 5]ZFJFYL
AGFJ ;DI[ CF,GF VFZF[5L SFZ R,FJTF CF[JFG]\
36/273
5F[TFGF lGJ[NGDF\ VFJL SF[. CSLST ,BFJ[, GYLP ;FY[ ;FY[ SFZ RF,S
SIF\ UI[,F[ T[J]\ 56 ;FC[N H6FJTF GYLP VFD ;FC[N G\AZ !# BZ[BZ
:Y/ p5Z AGFJ JBT[ CFHZ CF[T TF[4 VG[ SFZ RF,SG[ HF[I[, CTF[ TF[4SFZ
RF,SG[ AGFJ AFN SIF\ UI[,F[ T[ 56 HF[I[, CF[TP
s!ZP!Zf
YF[0FS ;DI VUFp 5F[TFGL SFZG[ 56 ALPV[DP0A<I] SFZ 0FAL ;F.0[ S|[;
SZ[, 5Z\T]\ T[ V\U[ V[8,[ S[4 ;FC[N G\AZ !# GFVF[V[ UF0LG[ SF[. G]S;FG
YI[, CF[I TF[ T[ V\U[G]\ SF[. 5\RGFD\] OZLIFN51F[ ZH] YI[, GYLP JW]DF\\
;FC[N G\AZ !#GF V[ UF0LG[ G]S;FG YI[, CF[JF V\U[ SF[. OZLIFN SZ[, CF[I
T[JF[ 56 SF[. 5]ZFJF[ GYLP VG[ T[ SFZ ;FC[NGL 5F[TFGL DF,LSLGL G CF[JFG]\]
B]N
;FC[N[
:JLSFZ[,
K[
VFD
;FC[N
G\AZ!#
GFV[
AGFJ
GHZ[ HF[I[,F[ CF[JFG]\ H6FJ[, K[P 5Z\T\]4 UF0LDF\YL SF[.G[ pTZTF\ HF[I[, CF[I
T[J]\ SF\. H6FJTF GYLP ;FY[ ;FY[ SFZ RF,SGL VF[/B Y. XS[ T[J]\ SF[.
J6"G SZL H6FJ[, GYLP VG[ ,,LT U]%TF ;FY[ SFZ RF,SG[ SF[. JFT
SZ[, CF[I T[J]\ 56 H6FJTF GYLP VFD ;FC[N G\AZ !#4 NFX"lGS ;FC[N
CF[JFG]\ OZLIFN 51FG]\ SYG K[ P KTF\ CF,GF AGFJGF DCtJGL CSLSTF[
;FC[N[ lGJ[NGDF\ H6FJ[, G C[FJFG]\ ARFJ 51F[ ;FlAT SZ[, K[P
VG[ T[YL ;FC[N G\AZ !# GF AGFJ ;DI[ AGFJ :Y/[ CFHZ CF[JFG]\ T[DH
VFZF[5LGL V[F/B V\U[GF[ 5]ZFJF[ X\SF:5N AG[ K[PVFD4 OZLIFN51F H[ T|6
NFX"lGS ;FC[NF[ p5Z VFWFZ ZFB[ K[ T[ T|6[I ;FC[NF[GF[ 5]ZFJF[ wIFGDF\ ,[TF\
AGFJ ;DI[ CF,GF VFZF[5L SFZRF,S C[FJFGL CSLST ;FlAT Y. XS[ T[D
GYLP
s!ZP!#f
TALAL
;FC[N
G\AZ
!(
GF
V[
SZ[,
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
CTL
37/273
VG[ T[VF[GF[ 5]ZFJF[ V[ lGQ6FTGF 5]ZFJF TZLS[ H DFT| wiFFG[ ,[JF[ HF[.V[P
JW]DF\ D[0LS, VF[lO;Z H6FJ[ T[ TDFD CSLSTF[ C\D[XF\ ;tI H CF[JFG]\
VG]DFG SZL XSFI GlCP
s!ZP!$f
JW]DF\
D[0LS,
VF[lO;ZGF
5]ZFJF
D]HA
VFZF[5LV[ 5F[TFG[ YI[,L .HFVF[ V\U[ lC:8=L VF5[, CTLP 5Z\T] lC:8=LDF\
H6FJ[, CSLSTF[G[ VgI 5]ZFJFYL ;DY"G D/J]\ HZ]ZL K[P OZLIFN 51F[ ZH]
YI[, VF\S !Z5GF S[; 5[5Z DF\ V[JL SF[. lC:8=LGL CSLSTF[ H6FJJFDF\
VFJ[, GYL VG[ T[YL D[0LS, VF[lO;ZGF T[JF 5]ZFJFG[ ;DY"G D/T]\ GYLP
5Z\T]\ lC:8=LYL H6FJ[, CSLSTF[ BF[8F[ 5]ZFJF[ pEF[ SZJF DF8[ ,B[, CF[JFG]\
H6FI K[P JW]DF\ ARFJ 51F[ lJPWFPzLGL ZH]VFT V[JL K[ S[4 D[0LS,
VF[lO;ZGF
N]BFJF[ YTF[ CTF[P 5Z\T]\ V[ZA[UGF SFZ6[ N]BFJF[ YTF[ CF[JFGF[ SF[. VlE5|FI
D[0LS, VF[lO;Z 5F;[ T5F;GLX[ VF\S !Z# GL IFNLYL DF\U[, G CTF[P
JW]DF\4 D[0LS, VF[lO;ZGF 5]ZFJF D]HA VFZF[5LG[ XZLZ p5Z 36F\
AWF\ :S|R
[ L; CTF P5Z\T]\ UF0LGF SFR T]8JFYL VFJL SF[. .HF YI[,
CF[JFGF[ D[0LS, VF[lO;ZGF[ S[F. VlE5|FI GYLP VG[ HF[ V[ZA[UGL
.d5[S8YL .HF YI[, CF[I TF[4 T[ .HFYL N]BFJF[ Y. XS[ 5Z\T] :S|[RL;
V[8,[ S[ 3;ZSF H[JL .HF G YFIP SFZ6 S[ V[ZA[U 5|F[8[SXG DF8[ H C[FI
K[ VG[ T[YL
Z[0L; A|FpG
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
38/273
,BL ;]WFZF[ SZJFDF\ VFJ[, CF[JFG]]\ :5Q856[ H6FI K[P SFZ6 S[ .HFGF
SFZ6[ Z[0 CF[I TF[ T[JL .HF TFHL V[8,[ S[ RF[JL; S,FSGL V\NZGL CF[I
VG[ T[JL .HF AGFJ ;DI[ YI[, G CF[JFG]\ U6L XSFI VG[ T[JF AGFJGF
;DI[ YI[, .HFVF[ V[8,[ S[ T[ .HFVF[ A[ T|6 lNJ; 5C[,F\GL CF[JFG]\
ATFJJF 5|ItG SZJFDF\ VFJ[, CF[JFG]\ H6FI K[P ;FY[ ;FY[ V[JL ZH]VFT
SZ[, K[ S[4 VFZF[5LG[
VlWlGIDGL S,D
VgJI[GF
B],F;F[ SZ[, K[P VG[ T[ D]HA VFZ[F5L HIFZ[ 5F[,L; :8[XGDF\ CFHZ YI[,F
tIFZ[ TYF TALAL T5F; SZFJJF DF8[ 0F[S8Z 5F;[ ,. UI[,F
T[ A\gG[ JBT[ A\gG[ :Y/[ DL0LIF VG[ 5a,LSGF DF6;F[ CFHZ CTF
VG[ T[VF[G[ WSS[ R-FJ[, 4 VG[ B[RTF6 YTF\4VFZF[5LG[ VFJL
.HFVF[ YI[,L CTLP JW]DF\ VFZF[5LG[ TALAL T5F; SZFJJF DF8[ ,. HGFZ
V[PV[;PVF.P EUJFGEF.
0[DF[ SFZ R,FJL4AGFJ ;DI[ ALPV[DP 0A<I]P SFZGL :5L0 V\U[ VlE5|FI
VF5GFZ 5;F[",L DF[8;"GF D[G[HZ 4 ;FC[N G\AZ !) GF 5]ZFJF D]HA 56
V[ZA[U SFZ RF,S VG[ D];FOZL SZTF DF6;F[GL
JW]DF\ ;FC[N G\AZ !) GF[ 5]ZFJF D]HA V[ZA[U B],JFYL H[ .HFVF[ YFI
T[ H .HFVF[ CF[I VG[ V[ZA[U B],L UIF AFN SF[. .HF G YFIP VFD
4V[ZA[UYL .HF YI[, CF[JFG]\ ;FlAT YT]\ GYLP
s!ZP!&f
JW]D\F ARFJ 51F[ V[JL ZH]VFT SZ[, K[ S[4 OZLIFN 51F D'TS
39/273
D'TS
5]ZFJFG[ wIFGDF\ ,[TF\4 AGFJ V\U[GL CSLSTF[ T[VF[G[ ;FC[N G\AZ !!4
OZLIFNL ,,LT U]%TFGF SC[JFYL HF6[, CF[JFG]\ H6FJ[, K[ P5Z\T] ;FC[N
G\AZ !!4,,LT U]%TFV[ T[JL S[F. CSLST H6FJ[, CF[I T[JF[ ;FC[N
G\AZ !!GF[ 5]ZFJF[ GYLP VFD p5ZF[ST A\gG[ ;FC[NF[GF[ 5]ZFJF[ VFZF[5L
lJZ]wWG]\ TCF[DT ;FlAT SZJF OZLIFN 51FG[ DNNZ]5 YFI T[D GYLP
s!ZP!*f
l;JFI A|S
[
;FC[N G\AZ Z_
40/273
VS:DFT ;DI[ JFCGGL :5L0 V\U[ ;FC[N G\AZ !& VFZP8LPVF[P VlWSFZL
4;FC[N G\AZ !*4 V[OV[;V[, VlWSFZL VG[ ;FC[N G\AZ !) 5;F[",L
DF[8;" GF D[GH
[ Z VG[ ;FC[N G\AZ Z_ V[OPV[;PV[,P VlWSFZL P VFD
RFZ[I VlWSFZLVF[V[ VF5[, VlE5|FI GF ZL5F[8"DF\ 56 T[VF[V[ VlE5|FI
S[JL ZLT[ VF5[,F[ T[ V\U[ SF[. SFZ6 H6FJJFDF\ VFJ[, GYL
VG[ HIFZ[ VlE5|FI V\U[
tIFZ[ lGQ6FTGF[ T[JF[ VlE5|FI S[ ZL5F[8"GL SF[. lSDT ZC[TL GYL VG[ T[JF
5]ZFJF p5Z VFWFZ ZFBL XSFI T[D GYLP
s!ZPZ_f
JFCGGL UlT
DIF"NF VU[ VF\S !!5 YL ZH] YI[, HFC[ZGFD]\ lGID D]HA 5|l;wW YI[,
C[FJFG]\ VG[ 5lA,LSGL HF6DF\ CF[JFG]\ ;FlAT SZJ]\ HZ]ZL K[ P5Z\T] T[JL
CSLST[ OZLIFN 51F[ 5]ZFJF[ ZH] SZ[,F[ GY PVG[ T[YL T[JF HFC[ZGFDF p5Z
VFWFZ ZFBL XSFI GlCP
s!ZPZ!f
ARFJ 51F[ lJPWFPzL GL ZH]VFT V[JL K[ S[4 OZLIFN 51F[ ZH] YI[,
ZH] SZJFDF\ VFJ[, GYL ;FY[ ;FY[ 0LPJLPVFZPG]\ SF[. 5ZL1F6 SZJFDF\
VFJ[, GYL VG[ T[YL T[JL ;LP0LP GF[ 5]ZFJF[ U|FCI ZFBL XSFI GlCP T[ H
ZLT[ ;FC[N G\AZ !) GF 5]ZFJF D]HA T[VF[V[ DF[AF.,DF\ Z[SF[0L"U SZ[,
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
41/273
VG[ ;L0LPT{IFZ SZ[, CTL 5Z\T]\ T[JF[ DF[AF., 56 OZLIFN 51F[ ZH]\
YI[,F[ GYLP T[ H ZLT[ HLP8LP5LPV[,P GL .g8ZjI]\GL
0LPJLP0L P ;FC[N
VFXLQF UHHZGF 5]ZFJF D]HA ;J"ZDF\ :8F[Z SZ[,F 0[8F p5ZYL AGFJFDF\
VFJ[, CTL PH[DF\ OZLIFN 51F[ ZH] YI[, VF\S !)_ GF ;8L"OLS[8 D]HA
[AF[Z[8ZL GF SF[d%I]8Z YL T{IFZ SZJFDF\ VFJ[, CTL 4 VG[ ;J"ZGF[ T[DF\ SF[.
p<,[B 56 SZ[,F[ GYLP JW]DF\4 VF\S !)_G]\ ;8L"OLS[8
TF !_q!
qZ_!5 GF ZF[H T{IFZ SZJFDF\ VFJ[, CF[JFG]\ H6FI K[ T[D KTF\4 T[JL
0LPJLP0L PVF\S !($ GF 5\RGFDFYL SAH[ SZ[, T[ 5\RGFDF JBT[ TFZLB
Z!q!qZ_!5 GF ZF[H VFJ]\ SF[. ;8L"OLS[8 VF5JFDF\ VFJ[, CF[I T[JF[ SF[.
p<,[B GYLP VG[ T[YL T[JL 0LPJLP0L PTFPZ!q!qZ_!5 GF ZF[H SAH[ SZ[,
T[ AFN TFP#_q!qZ_!5
VlWSFZLV[ D[/J[, K[P
G]\ ;8L"OLS[8
T5F;
GlCP T[ H ZLT[ ;FC[N G\AZ !* GF 5]ZFJF D]HA T[VF[V[ Z( OF[8F ,LW[,F CTF
H[ 0LHL8, S[D[ZFYL ,LW[, CTF 4 5Z\T]\ T[JF[ 0LHL8, S[D[ZF[ OZLIFN 51F[ ZH]
SZ[,F[ GYLP ;FY[ ;FY[ OF[8F[U|FOL SZGFZ OF[8F[U|FOZG[ 56 T5F;JFD\F VFJ[,F
GYL JW]DF\ p5ZF[ST TDFD .,[S8=F[GLS; 5]ZFJF V\U[ WL EFZTLI 5]Z FJF
VlWlGID GL S,D &5sALfs$f D]HA HZ]ZLIFTF[ ;\TF[QFFTL CF[I T[J]\
SF[. ;8LOLS[8 OZLIFN 51F[ ZH] YI[, GYL VG[ T[YL T[JF[ 5]ZFJF[ U|FCI ZFBL
XSFI GlCP
s!ZPZZf
42/273
H]NF DF6;F[ T|6 XLO8DF\ SFD SZ[ K[ VG[ ;J"ZGF 5F;J0"GL HF6SFZL
OST 8[SGLS, C[0G[ C[FI K[P HIFZ[ ;FC[N G\AZ #_ 4 8[SGLS, C[0 VFXLQF
UHHZ GF 5]ZFJF D]HA
U[ZCFHZLDF\
;J"ZGF[
p5IF[U
.DZHg;LDF\ 4 T[VF[GL
5F;J0"GL HF6SFZL 56 CF[I K[P VFD ;J"Z ;FY[ R[0F\ Y. XS[ T[D CF[JFGL
XSITF GSFZL XSFI T[D GYLP JW]DF\4 OZLIFN 51F[ ZH] YI[, .g8ZjI
V\U[GF ;FC[N G\AZ Z(4 V[gSZ NL,L5EF. JZJFEF. N[;F.GF 5]ZFJF
D]HA .g8ZjI\] NZdIFG ,,LT U]%TF X]\ AF[,[,F T[ ;FC[N G\AZ Z( GF
V[ H6FJ[, K[P5Z\T] ;FC[N G\AZ Z(GFG[ ,,LT U]%TFV[ X]\ AF[,[,F
T[ V\U[ SF[g8=F0LS8 SZ[,F GYLP JW]DF\ SF[. lJZ[FW YI[,F[ H GYL T[D
DFGL ,.V[ TF[456 T[J]\ .g8ZjI]
V[
VG[ T[GF[ p5IF[U SF[g8=F0LS8 YFI VYJF T[GF[ p5IF[U ;DY"G DF8[ H Y.
XS[P 5Z\T]\ T[G[ ;DY"G
YI[,F[ GYLP HIFZ[ ;FC[N G\AZ !! ,,LT U]%TF GF 5]ZFJF D]HA .g8ZjI]
GL CSLSTF[ GF[ S[F. SF[g8=F0LSXG ,[JFDF\ VFJ[, GYLP p5ZF[ST 5]ZFJF[ 56
VFWFZE]T VG[ lJxJ;GLI U6L XSFI GlCP
s!ZPZ#f
;FIS, R,FJTF CTF T[VF[GL A[NSFZL V\U[ SF[. H T5F; SZJFDF\ VFJ[,
GYLP JW]DF\ AGFJ ;DI[ A\gG[ 5{SL SF[.V[ C[<D[8 5C[Z[, CF[I T[JF[ SF[.
5]ZFJF[ OZLIFN 51F[ ZH] YI[,F[ GYLP 5Z\T] ;FC[N G\AZ !! GF V[ :JLSFZ[,
K[ S[4 T[VF[V[ C[<D[8 5C[Z[, G CTLP ;FY[ ;FY[ ;FC[N G\AZ !! VG[ ;FC[N
G\AZ !Z GF 5]ZFJF D]HA Z[F0 p5Z VFJ[, ;S", OZLG[ HD6L TZO
J/JFG]\ HZ]ZL
CF[JF KTF\
UI[,F G
CTF4VG[ ;LWF H HD6L AFH] 8G" ,. ZF\[U ;F.0[ UI[,F CTFP JW]DF\4 ZH]
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
43/273
YI[,F[ 5]ZFJF[ wIFGDF\ ,[TF\4 ALPV[DP 0A<I] SFZ ;LWF ZF[0 p5Z VFJTL
CTL4 VG[ T[GF RF,S[ A|[S DFZ[,FGF[ 5]ZFJF[ K[ P T[D KTF\ DF[8Z ;FIS,
RF,SGL A[NZSFZL
V\U[
GYL PJW]DF\4
O\LUZ l5|g8
,. ;NZC]\
SFZGF :8[IZLU VG[ NZJFHF p5ZGF OLUZ l5|g84 RFg; l5|g8 ,[J0FJJFDF\
VFJ[,F GYL S[4 T[G\] 5ZL1F6 SZJF ;FZ\] V[OPV[;PV[,PG[ DF[S,L VF5JFDF\
VFJ[, GYLP
5]ZFJF[ CF[JF KTF\ T5F;GLX[ T[JF[ 5]ZFJF[ V[ST| SZJFGF[ SF[. 5|ItG
SZ[,F[ GYLP JW]DF\ SFZ
RF,S
AGFJ :Y/[YL
EFUL UI[,
CF[JFGF[ 5]ZFJF[ K[P ;FY[ ;FY[ VFZF[5L lJ:DI XFCGL DF[AF., SF[, 0L8[.,
D[/JL T[GF p5ZYL 56 AGFJ ;DI[ VFZF[5L RF[SS; SIF\ CTF[ T[ V\U[
,F[S[XG D[/JL XSFI[, CF[TP 5Z\T]\ T[JF[ SF[. 5]ZFJF[ OZLIFN 51F[
ZH]
YI[,F[ GYLP JW]DF\ OZLIFN 51F[ ZH] YI[,F[ 5]ZFJF[ wIFGDF\ ,[TF\ AGFJ ;DI[
SFZ RF,S 5F[TFGL SFZ R,FJL VgIGL HL\NULG[ HF[BD YFI T[D CF[JFG]\
HF6SFZL SFZ RF,SG[ CF[JFGL CSLST ;FlAT SZJFDF\ OZLIFN 51F lGQO/
UI[, K[P H[ ;FlATLGF[ AF[HF[ OZLIFN 51F p5Z ZC[,F[ K[ VG[ T[YL T[JL
;FlATLGF[ AF[HF[
;\lCTFGL S,D #_$ s5F8"vZ f D]HA U]gCF[ ;FlAT SZJF DF8[ HZ]ZL TtJF[
;FlAT SZJFDF\ OZLIFN 51F lGQO/ UI[, K[ VG[ T[YL CF,GF VFZF[5L
lJZ]wWG]\ TCF[DT ;FlAT SZJFDF\ OZLIFN 51F lGQO/ UI[, CF[. 4
VFZF[5LG[ TS;LZJFG 9ZFJL XSFI GlC VG[ KF[0L D]SJF[ HF[.V[ PARFJ
51FGF lJPWFPzL GL p5ZF[ST N,L,F[ DF8[ lJlJW R]SFNFVF[ p5ZVFWFZ
ZFB[, K[ H[GL RRF" VFU/ p5Z SZ[, K[P
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
44/273
SFZ6F[P
D ]N FG\ !
s!#f
GL5HL
XS[
T[JL
HF6
;FY[
R,FJL
DZ6
HGFZFVF[G[
H[ V;,
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
45/273
;FC[N
G\A Z
s!!f
,,LT
U]% TFGF[
VF\S
)$
GF[ 5]ZFJF[ wIFGDF\ ,.X]\ TF[4 AGFJ TFZLB Z$qZqZ_!# GF ZF[H AG[,P
VG[ T[ JBT[ OZLIFNL 5F[T[4 lNG[X RF{WZL TYF lXJD NJ[ VG[ ZFC], 58[,
ZFT|LGF VFXZ[ !!q#_ JFU[GF ;]DFZ[ J:T|F5]Z ;\HLJGL CF[l:58, VFU/
E[UF\ YI[,P OZLIFNL
CFp;YL ZFT|LGF
VFXZ[ !Zq!5 JFU[ HHLh A\U,F[ ZF[0 HJF GLS/[,P T[ JBT[ OZLIFNG\]
5<;ZAF.S DZ6 HGFZ ZFC], 58[, R,FJTF CTF 4 VG[ T[GF p5Z XLJD
NJ[ A[9F CTFP HIFZ[
ZFC],G]\ SF.G[8LS
CTFPVG[ 5FK/ NLG[X RF{WZL A[9[, CTFP T[ ZLT[ JFCG ,. DFG;L ;S",YL
HHLh A\U,F[ TYF 5|[DR\NGUZ TZO HJF4 T[VF[G[
CT]\PT[ JBT[ OZLIFNL ZFC],YL T|6 RFZ O]8 5FK/ CTF VG[ T[VF[V[ T[VF[G]\
SF.G[8LS :,F[ SZL NLW[,P tIFZ[ ZFC],[ tIF\ 8G" ,. ,LW[, CTF[PT[JFDF\
HHLh A\U,F[ ZF[0 TZOYL
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
46/273
ZC[,P UF0LGL 8SSZ JFUTF\ OZLIFNLGF A\gG[ lDT|F[ DZ6 HGFZ XLJD
VG[ ZFC], N;5\NZ O]8 CJFDF\ pK/[,F VG[ HDLG p5Z 58SFI[,FPJW]DF\4
OZLIFNL V[ H6FJ[, K[ S[4 XLJD NJ[G[ DFYFDF\ B]A H ,F[CL GLS/T]\ CT]\
VG[ T[GL l:YlT U\ELZ CTLP T[YL OZLIFNL ;FY[GF lNG[X RF{WZLV[ !_( G[
OF[G SZL AF[,FJ[,4 tIF\ ALHF DF6;F[ 56 E[UF\ Y. UI[, CTF 4T[VF[GL
DNN DF\U[,L 56 T[VF[V[ SF[.V[ DNN SZ[,L GlCP OZLIFNLGF[ p5ZF[ST 5]ZFJF[
wIFGDF\ ,.X\] TF[4 DZ6 HGFZFVF[GF AF.SG[ 8SSZ DFIF" AFN OF[ZjCL,Z
UF0L VD], 5F,"Z 5F;[GF hF0
pEL ZC[,LP
VG[ 5<;Z AF.S 3;0FI[,PVG[ 5<;Z AF.S p5Z A[9[,F A\gG[ DZ6
HGFZF CJFDF\ N;YL 5\NZ O]8 pK/[,FP VG[ HDLG p5Z 58SFI[,FP DZ6
HGFZ XLJD NJ[ H[VF[G[ ;\HLJGL CF[l:58,DF\ ,. HTF\ tIF\ 0F[S8Z[ T[G[ D'T
HFC[Z SZ[,P H[ CSLST[ ARFJ 51F[ SF[. TSZFZ ,LW[, GYLP VFD4 OZLIFN
51FGF 5]ZFJF VG];FZ XLJD NJ[G]\ TYF ZFC], 58[,G]\ D'\tI]\ YI[, C[FJFG]\
O,LT YFI K[ P H[ OF[Z jCL,ZGL 8SSZGF SFZ6[ YI[, .HFVF[GF SFZ6[ YI[,
CF[JFG]\ O,LT YFI K[P OZLIFNLGL p5ZF[ST CSLSTG[ OZLIFNLV[ GF[WFJ[,
VF\S )5 GL OZLIFNDF\ H6FJ[, CSLSTF[YL ;DY"G D/[ K[P
s!&f
OZLIFNL ,,LT U]%TF SF.G[8LS CF[g0F *!** p5Z A[9[,F CTF VG[ T[
,,LT U]%TF R,FJTF CTFP ;NZC]\ SF.G[8LS ZFC], 58[,G\] CT]\P JW]DF\
;FC[N[ H6FJ[, K[ S[4 T[ RFZ[ lDT|F[
sOZLIFNLfTYF ZFC], 58[, VG[ XLJD NJ[ sA\gG[ DZ6 HGFZf GF,\NF
SF[d5,[1F4 GF:TF[ SZJF ZFT|LGF VFXZ[ ;F0F AFZ JFU[ UI[, CTFP XLJD
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
47/273
TYF ZFC], D[F8Z ;F.S, G\AZ *!! p5Z CTFP H[ DF[8Z ;FIS, ZFC],
R,FJTF[ CTF[ VG[ XLJD 5FK/ A[9[, CTF[P GF:TF[ SIF" AFN 3[Z HJF
GLS/[,P H[ ;\N[X5|[; HJF TZO UI[, VG[ tIF\ JrR[ 5|[DR\NGUZ T|6 Z:TF
VFJ[ K[ tIF\YL T[VF[G[ HD6L TZO ;\N[X 5|[; TZO J/JFG\] CT]P\ ZFC],GF
5<;Z VG[ ;FC[NGF SF.G[8LS JrR[ RFZ[S O]8G]\ V\TZ CT]\P H[DF\
ZFC],
5|[DR\NGUZ TZO HJF HD6L AFH] 8G" ,LW[, VG[ VG[ V[S OF[ZjCL,Z UF0L
VFJ[, VG[ T[6[ ZFC],GF 5<;ZG[ 8SSZ DFZ[,4 ZFC],G]\ AF.S VFXZ[ 5RF;
[S O]8 3;0FI[,PVG[ A\gG[
DFYFDF\ JW] .HF YTF\ DFYFDF\YL JW\] ,F[CL GLS/[, UI[, CT]\P VG[ ZFC],
A[EFG VJ:YFDF\ CTF[P JW]DF\ ;FC[NGF 5]ZFJF D]HA T[VF[V[ !_( AF[,FJ[,
VG[
A\gG[
lDT|F[G[
;\HLJGL
CF[l:58,
,.
UI[,FP
HIF\
XLJDG[ 0F[S8Z[ DZ6 HFC[Z SZ[,P PJW]DF\ ;FC[N[ V[J]\ 56 H6FJ[[, K[ S[4
VF SFZ SF/F S,ZGL CTLPVG[ AF.SG[ 8SSZ DFIF" AFN4
;FY[ VY0FI[,P H[ hF0 VD], 5F,"Z
;FC[N[ H6FJ[, K[ S[4 VF SFZ HHLh A\U,F
V[S hF0
JW]DF\
GLS/[,P VG[ T[ 5]Zh05[ VFJTL CTLP VFD AGFJ ;DI[ H[ SFZ[ DZ6
HGFZFVF[GF AF.SG[
8SSZ DFZ[,L
VG[ 5]Zh05[ VFJTL CF[JFGL CSLST ;FC[NGF 5]ZFJFYL O,LT YFI K[P
VFD4 CF,GF AGFJ DF\ ;FD[YL VFJTL SFZ[ 8SZZ
DFZ[, 4 DZ6
HGFZFVF[GF AF.SG[ 8SSZ DFZTF\ A\gG[ H6F\ CJFDF\ pK/L GLR[ 58SFI[,F
VG[ .HFVF[ YI[,L CF[JFG]\ :5Q856[ O,LT YFI K[P JW]DF\ T[JL SFZ
5]Zh05[ VFJTL CF[JFGF[ ;FC[NGF[ 5]ZFJF[ K[PVG[ T[YL DZ6 HGFZF
VF[G[ YI[,L .HFVF[GF SFZ6[ D'tI]\ YI[, C[FJFGL CSSLT TALAL 5]ZFJF
p5Z VFWFZ ZFBJF[ 50[ T[D K[P
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
48/273
s!*f
;F[,F ;LJL, CF[l:58,GF D[0 LS, VF[l O;Z ;FC[N G\A Z s!f 0F[S 8Z 4
NL,L5 5|E ]N F; 58[, G[ VF\S &Z YL T5F;[,F K[P H[ D[0LS, VF[lO;ZGF
5]ZFJF D]HA TFP Z5qZqZ_!# GF ZF[H ;F[,F ;LJL, CF[l:58,DF\ T[VF[ OZH
p5Z CTF tIFZ[ T[VF[V[ XLJD 5|[DX\SZ NJ[ GL ,FXG]\ XA 5ZL1F6 S,FS
&q__ JFU[ XZ] SZ[, VG[ S,FS *q#_JFU[ 5]Z\] SZ[, CT]\P D[0LS,
VF[lO;ZGF JW] 5]ZFJF VG];FZ T[ XA VFXZ[ Z5 JZ;GL p\DZGF VFXZFGF
5]Z]QFG]\ CT\]P VG[ T[6[ 5C[Z[, X8" VG[ a<I] S,ZG]\ HLg; ;L,[8LIF S,ZGL
R00L H[
OF8[,F CTF
VG[ DF8LGF
ZHS6F[ RF\8[,F CTFPXA XFZLZLS N=lQ8 ;FZF AF\WFG]\ CT]\4 XA 9\0]\ CT]\P
ZFIUZ DF[8L; 0[J,5LU :8[HD\F CT]P 5LPV[DP ,LJL0L8L 5FK/GF
EFU[ CTLP VF\BF[ A\W CTLP DF[\ A\W CT]\P RC[ZF p5Z ,F[CL RF[8[, CT]\P
GFSDF\YL GLS/[, ,F[CL U\9FI[, CT]\ A\gG[ SFGDF\YL ,F[CL GLS/L U\9FI[,
CT]\ P
s!)f
D[0LS,
VF[lO;ZGF
5]ZFJF
D]HA
XA
p5Z
AFCI
S|X .gHZL 0FAF 5UDF\ GLR[GF EFU[ 0FAL AFH]GF V[gS, HF[.g8
;]WL !Z25 ;[DLGF V[ZLIFDF\ CF0SF ;']WLGF p0F CF0SFGF 8LALIF
VG[ OI]aI],FGF O[SRZ ;FY[ B]<,F HF[. XSFTF CTF P5UGF 5FK/GF[
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
49/273
&
!_
GFGF phZ0F RC[ZF p5Z CTFP H[DF\ !2_P5 ;[DL GFS p5Z4
Z2! ;[DL 0FAF UF, p5Z 4 #2Z ;[DL HD6F UF, p5Z 4 !2_P5
;[DLp5ZGF CF[9 p5Z CTF[P
!!
Z2! ;[DL GF[ ,F, phZ0F[ HD6F 5U[ VG[ #2 Z ;[DL GF[ ,F,
phZ0F[ 0FAF 5U[ GLR[ 3]86GF EFU[ CTF[P
sZ_f
sZ_P!f
SFZ6[
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
50/273
VF[lO;ZGF p5ZF[ST 5]ZFJFGF ;DY"GDF\ VF\S &5 YL 5F[:8 DF[8"D GF[8 ZH]
YI[,L K[P VG[ T[ 5LPV[DP GF[8DF\ H6FJ[, CSLSTF[YL D[0LS, VF[lO;ZGF
5]ZFJFG[ ;DY"G D/[ K[P VG[ T[YL D[0LS, VF[lO;Z GF[ 5]ZFJF[ GlC DFGJFG[
SF[. SFZ6 GYLP
sZ_PZf
D[0LS, VF[lO;ZGF
5]ZFJF D]HA
H[ IS'T p5Z VF\TZLS .HFG[ ;\,uG CTL VG[ H[ ZLT[ AFCI .HF G\AZ sZf
VF\TZLS .HF D]HA CF0SFGF O[SRZ ;FY[ ;\,uG CTLP VG[ AFCI .HF G\AZ
s!_f D]HA GFGL GFGL .HFVF[ VF\TZLS .HFVF[ D]HA AFCI .HF G\AZ
sZf4 s)f4 s!_f VG[ VF\TZLS .HFDF\ DUH p5Z YI[, .HFVF[ VG[ IS'T
p5Z YI[,L .HFVF[ D]bI CTLP JW]DF\ D[0LS, VF[lO;ZGF 5]ZFJF D]HA
DZ6 HGFZG[ YI[,L .HFVF[ SF[. SFZ !!_ lSPDLP GL h05[ HTL CF[I
VG[ S[F.56
TF[ T[JF ;\HF[UF[DF\ VF 5|SFZGL .HF YJFGL XSITF ZC[ K[P DZ6
HGFZG[ YI[, AFCI VG[ VF\TZLS .HFVF[ GF SFZ6[ YI[, ZS:T|FJ GF
SFZ6[ VFWFTGF SFZ6[ S]NZTL ;\HF[UF[DF\ D'tI] DF8[ 5]ZTL .HFVF[ CTLP
sZ_P#f
5ZL1F6 SZGFZ D[0 LS, VF[l O;Z4 ;FC[N G\A ZsZf 0F[S 8Z 5|O ]< ,F
GFZ6EF. R\g N=J F0LIFG[ VF\S && YL T5F;[,F K[P H[ D[0LS,
VF[lO;ZGF 5]ZFJF D]HA TFZLB Z*qZqZ_!# GF ZF[H ;F[,F ;LJL,
CF[l:58, DF\ T[VF[V[ DZ6 HGFZ ZFC],GF XAG\] XA 5ZL1F6 S,FS
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
51/273
Zq$_ JFU[ XZ]\ SZ[, VG[ S,FS #q5_ JFU[ 5]Z] SZ[, PJW]DF\ D[0LS,
VF[lO;ZGF 5]ZFJF D]HA T[ 5]Z]QF jIlST4 ZZ JZ; VFXZFGL ,FX CTLP T[
CF[l:58,GF A[g0[0 VG[ ,[A,L\U ;FY[ D/[, CTLP JW]DF\ ;NZC]\ XA
p5Z XZLZ VS/F. HJFGF O[ZOFZ N[BFIF G CTFP T[DH 5LPV[DP
,LJL0L8L 56 HF[JF D/[, G CTLP XAGL VF\BF[ A\W CTL T[DH D[F\ B]<,
CT] \T[DF\YL YF[0L HLE ACFZ VFJTL CTLP
sZ!P!f
V\NZGFEFU[ CT]\P
#
0FAF CFY p5Z V[S %<FF:8Z SF0" CTF[P H[GL GLR[ VFBF
CFY p5Z U|[h V[Ah
|[ G VFBF CFY p5Z CTL T[GL ;F.h
VFXZ[ !$2Z ;[DL CTL T[GF ;FY[ 0FAF CFYD\F Z[0LI;
VG[ V<GFG]\ O[SRZ CT\]P
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
52/273
&
;[DL
!_
!!
!Z
!#
5[8GF
0FAL
;F.0
GLR[GF
EFU[
!2!
;[DL
G]\
!5
!&
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
53/273
!(
!)
Z_
Z!
sZ!PZf
D[0LS,
VF[lO;ZGF
5]ZFJF
D]HA
XAG[
T5F;TF\
DFYFGF
EFU[ :S, CI]D]8F[DF CT\] VG[ 5ZF.8, AF[G" HD6L ;F.0G]\ O[SRZ CT\]P
T[DH VFBF ;[ZLA|, V[ZLIFDF\ 0LOI]h V[RALV[R VG[ .0LV[R CTF
H[ ,UEU ;[ZLA|DGF AWF ,F[a;G[ SJZ SZTF CTFP KFTLGF
EFU[
0FAL
;F.0[
RF[YL
VG[
5F\RDL
5F\;/LG]
O[SRZ
CT]
O[O;FGF[ 50NF[ T]8[,F[ CTF[ T[DH O[O;F\ SgH[:8[0 CTFP O[O;F\ 4 CNIG]
VFJZ6 4 IS'T 4 l5TFXI 4 AZF[/4
CTFP
sZ!P#f
DF8[
,F[CL DF.S|
DF8[
5[g0LU
ZFB[,
CF[JFG]\
H6FJ[,
K[PJW]DF\
D[0LS,
54/273
DF.S|
.HFVF[ YTF\ T[DH T[GF SFZ6[ SF[d5,LS[XG YTF\ YI[, CT]\P VFD D[0LS,
VF[lO;ZGF p5ZF[ST 5]ZFJFG[ VF\S *# GL 5LPV[DP GF[8DF\ H6FJ[,
lJUTF[YL :5Q8 56[ ;DY"G D/[ K[P
sZ!P$f
SFZ6 VF5[, H[DF\ ;NZ jIlSTG]\ D'tI]\ VFBF XZLZ p5Z .HFVF[ YTF\ 4
T[DH T[ SFZ6[ SF[d%,LS[XG YI[, CTFP D[0LS, VF[lO;ZGF p5ZF[ST
5]ZFJFG[ VF\S *# GL 5F[Q8DF[8"D G[F8DF\ H6FJ[, lJUTF[YL :5Q856[
;DY"G D/[ K[P VFD4 D[0LS, VF[lO;ZGF[ 5]ZFJF[ GlC DFGJFG[ SF[. SFZ6
GYLP
sZ!P5f
DZ6
HGFZFVF[G[ YI[, AFCI .HF G\AZ s!Zf H[DF\ U|[h V[A|[hG H[ NXF"JT]\
CT]\ T[ 5|DF6[ SF[,D Z_ DF\ VF\TZLS .HFVF[ H[DF\ 0FAL AFH] 0FAL AFH]
RF[YL VG[ 5F\RDL 5F\;/LG] O[SRZ GL .HF PVG[ T[GF ;FY[ 5LPV[DP
GF[8GL .HF G\AZ sZ!f AFCI .HFVF[ G\AZ s!_f VG[ AFCI .HF G\AZ
s!&f VF\TZLS .HF SF[,D !) D\F .HF G\AZ sZf VG[ s#f ;FY[ ;\,uG
CTLP AFCI .HF G\AZ s!# f T[GF ;FY[ SF[,D Z! GL C[DF[5[Z[8LZLID
JF/L .HF ;\,uG SCL XSFIP VF\TZLS T5F; SF[,D
CLD[F8[DF H[ AFCI .HF GAZ s!&f VG[ s!_f
!)s!f :S,
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
55/273
&f4sZ_f VG[
D\TjI D]HA
DZ6
VG[ S[F.56 8] jCL,Z p5Z A[9[, RF,S VG[ 5FK/ A[9[, jIlST
;FY[ VY0FI TF[ 4 VG[ 5\NZ O]8 H[8,F pK/L VG[ GLR[ 50L 3;0FI
TF[ T[JF ;\HF[UF[D\F VF 5|SFZ GL .HF YJFGL XSITF ZC[,L K[P
sZZf
JFCG
NFX"GlS ;FC[N G\AZ s!!f VG[ s!Z f GF[ 5]ZFJF[ K[P VG[ T[YL A\gG[
;FC[NF[GF[
5]ZFJF[
V[S
;FY[
wIFGD\F
,[TF\
DZ6
HGFZF
VG[ GLR[ 58SFTF\ YI[, .HFVF[GF SFZ6[ DZ6 HGFZFVF[GF D'tI]\ YI[,
CF[JFG]\ :5Q8 56[ O,LT YFI K[P VG[ T[YL T[J]\ D'tI]\ JFCG RF,SGF
S'tIGF SFZ6[ YI[, CF[. VG[ JFCG RF,S
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
56/273
5]Zh05[
VS:DFT YI[, CF[. VG[ T[ SFZ6[ DZ6 HGFZFVF[G[ .HFVF[ .HFVF[ YTF\
D'tI]\ lG5H[, CF[JFG]\ ;FlAT YFI K[P VG[ T[YL T[ VS]NZTL ZLT[ YI[,
;F5ZFW D'tI] CF[JFG]\ ;FlAT YFI K[P
D]N F G\A Z sZf Y Ls$fP
sZ#f
U]gCF[
NFX"lGS
s!Zf
,,LTS]D FZ ZFH[X
lNG[X
DOFEF.
V[8,
CTF
VG[ T[V F[V [ CF,GF[ AGFJ HF[I [, CF[J FG]\ OZLIFN 51FG]\ SYG K [P
;FY[ ;FY[ T|LHF NFX"lGS
lDT[X
lSZ6EF. XFC S[ H[VF[ OZLIFN 51FGF SYG D]HA CF,GF AGFJ JBT[
5F[TFGF JFCG ;FY[ AGFJGF
57/273
;FY[ CTFP
VG[ HDLG[ T[VF[ ZFT|LGF VFXZ[ !Zq!5 JFU[ tIF\YL HHLh A\U,F ZF[0
TZO HJF GLS/[, POZLIFNLGF H6FjIF D]HA OZLIFNLG]\ 5<;Z AF.S
ZFC], R,FJTF[ CTF[ VG[ T[GF 5FK/ XLJD NJ[ A[9[, CTF[[4HIFZ[ ZFC], G]\
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
58/273
SF.G[8LS OZLIFNL R,FJTF CTF VG[ 5FK/ lNG[X RF{WZL A[9[, CTFP
JW]DF\ OZLIFNLV[ H6FJ[, K[ S[4 T[VF[ VF ZLT[ JFCG p5Z DFG;L ;S",
YL HHLh A\U,F[ TZO HTF\ CTFP VG[ 5|[DR\NGUZ T|6Z:TFV[ HD6L
AFH]V[ 8G" ,. ;\N[X 5|;[ TZO HJFG]\ CT]\P
5|[DR\NGUZ
T|6
Z:TFYL
;\N[X
5|[;
HJF
8G"
,LW[,
ZFC],[ 8G" ,.
,LW[, CTF[P T[JFDF\ HHLh A\U,F[ ZF[0 TZOYL V[S OF[ZjCL,Z UF0L
VFJ[, VG[ ZFC],GF AF.S 5<;ZG[ 8SSZ DFZ[,L P
H :8F[5 Y. UI[,P VF OF[Z jCL,Z UF0L 5<;ZG[ 8SSZ DFIF" AFN VD],
5F,"ZGL AFH]D\F VFJ[, hF0 ;FY[ VY0F. G[ pEL ZCL UI[,LP VF UF0LGL
8SSZ JFUTF\
A\gG[ lDT|F[
T[YL OZLIFNL T[GF A\gG[ lDT|F[ 5F;[ UI[, POZLIFNLGF H6FjIF D]HA
T[ T[GF lDT| XLJD NJ[ 5F;[ 5|YD UI[, VG[ HF[I]\ TF[ T[GF DFYFDF\YL AC]
H ,F[CL GLS/T]\ CT\] T[YL OZLIFNL UEZF. UI[,P T[ AFN
UI[,
ZFC],GL
l:YlT
U\ELZ
CTLP
T[
HF[.G[
T[ ZFC], 5F;[
OZLIFNLV[
T|6 Z:TF YL HD6L AFH]V[ ;\N[X 5|[; HJF GF[ Z:TF[ K[ tIF\ 8GL"U p5Z
H CF,GF[ VF AGFJ AG[, CF[JFG]\ H6FI K[P ;FY[ ;FY[ CF,GF AGFJDF\
HHLh A\U,F TZOYL
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
59/273
HGFZFVF[G[ AF.S p5Z 5|[DRNGUZ T|6 Z:TFYL ;\N[X 5|[; HJF HD6L
AFH]V[ 8G" ,LW[, CTF[ T[JFDF\ AF.SG[ 8SSZ DFZ[, CF[JFG]\ :5Q8 56[
O,LT YFI K[ CF,GF VS:DFTDF\ HHLh A\U,F[ TZOYL VFJTL SFZGF
RF,SGF S'tIYL CF,GF[ VS:DFTJF/F[ AGFJ AG[, CF[JFG]\ H6FI K[P
sZ#P5f
wIFGD\F ,[TF\4
OF[ZjCL,Z
UF0LGF RF,S[ 5<;Z AF.SG[ 8SSZ DFZ[, VG[ T[YL 5<;Z AF.S p5Z
A[9[,F OZLIFNLGF A\gG[ lDT|F[ V[8,[ S[ ZFC], 58[, VG[ XLJD NJ[ N;YL
5\NZ O]8 CJFDF\ pK/[,F4 VG[ HDLG p5Z 58SFI[,F VG[ T[ SFZ6[ XLJD
NJ[G[ DFYFDF\ .HFVF[ YI[, CF[JFG]\ VG[ ZFC],G[ 56 U\ELZ .HFVF[ YI[,
CF[JFG]\ :5Q856[ O,LT YFI K[P VFD SFZ RF,SGF S'tIGF
SFZ6[ A\gG[ .HF 5FDGFZFVF[G[ U\ELZ 5|SFZGL .HFVF[ YI[, CF[JFG]\ :5Q8
56[ O,LT YFI K[P
sZ#P&f
AGFJGF :Y/[4 AGFJ S[JL ZLT[ AgIF[ 4 SIF JFCGYL AgIF[ VG[
H[ AGFJ
s!Zf
;F[U\N
p5Z
T5F;JFDF\
VFJ[,F
K[P;FC[N
G\AZ
s!Zf
5F[T[ ,,LT U]%TF ;FY[ SF.G[8LS *!** p5Z A[9[, CTFP SF.G[8LS
ZFC], 58[,G]\ CT] H[ ,,LT U]%TF R,FJTF CTFP ;FC[N G\AZ s!Z f GF
VF[V[ JW]DF\ H6FJ[, K[ S[4 T[VF[ RFZ[I lDT|F[
,,LT
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
60/273
;FC[NG[ BAZ GYLP T[VF[ RFZ lDT|F[ CTF 4 H[DF\ T[VF[ 5F[T[4 ,,LT U]
%TF4 ZFC], 58[, VG[ XLJD NJ[
AHFH5<;Z AF.S
V[D A[ H6F\
H[ ZFC],
R,FJTF[ CTF[ VG[ XLJD 5FK/ A[9[, CTF[P JW]DF\ ;FC[NGF H6FjIF
D]HA GF:TF[ SZL ,LWF AFN 5F[6F AFZ YL AFZGF VZ;FDF\ 3Z TZO HJF
GLS/[,F 4 H[ ;[8[,F.8 5F[,L; RF[SL TZO UIF tIF\ JrR[ 5|[DR\NGUZ
8FJZ
J/JFG]\ CT]\P ZFC],GF 5<;Z VG[ T[VF[GF SF.G[8LS JrR[ RFZ[S O]8G]\
V\TZ CT]P ZFC], G]\ 5<;Z T[VF[GFYL RFZ[S O]8 VFU/ CT]P ZFC],[ 5|
[DR\NGUZ T|6 Z:TFJF/F ;S", 5C[,F\ HD6L AFH] 8G" ,LW[,F[ V[8,FDF\
V[S SFZ VFJ[,L VG[ T[ A\gG[G[ V0O[8DF\ ,LW[,FP ZFC],JF/]\ AF.S
VFXZ[ 5RF;[S O]8 H[8,]\ 3;0FI[,]\ VG[ T[VF[GF A\gG[ lDT|F[ VFXZ[ N;YL
5\NZ O]8 CJFDF\ pK/[,F 4 VG[ GLR[ 50[,FP T[YL ;FC[N[ 5F[T[ ,,LT HIF\
ZFC], VG[ XLJD 50[,F CTF tIF\ UI[,FP XLJDGF DFYFDF\YL AC]\ H ,F[CL
GLS/L UI[, CT]\ VG[ ZFC], A[EFG VJ:YFDF\ CTF[P V[8,FDF\ ,,LT[
;FC[NG[ !_( G[ OF[G SZJFG]\ SC[,]\ P T[YL ;FC[N[ !_( DF8[ OF[G SZ[,F[P
VG[ V[SFN DLGL8DF\ !_( VFJL UI[,LP
VG[
ZFC],G[
61/273
;FY[ H AGFJ JBT[ V[S H SF.G[8LS p5Z CTF VG[ H[ 5<;Z AF.S
OF[ZjCL,Z SFZYL VS:DFT YI[,F[ T[GFYL VFXZ[ RFZYL 5F\R O]8 N]Z CTF
VG[ T[VF[ A\gG[V[ CF,GF[ AGFJ HF[I[, C[FJFG]\ :5Q856[ O,LT YFI
K[P ;FY[ ;FY[ HIFZ[ A\gG[ DZ6 HGFZFVF[ 5<;Z AF.S
p5Z
5|[DR\NGUZ T|6 Z:TF YL HD6L AFH]V[ ;\N[X 5|[; HJFGF Z:TF TZO
8G" ,LW[, T[JFDF\ H SFZ VFJ[, VG[ A\gG[G[ V0O[8DF\ ,LW[, CF[JFG]\
H6FJ[, K[P ;FY[ ;FY[
AF.S
p5ZF[ST CSLST[ ZH] YI[, TDFD 5]ZFJFG[ ;\5]6"56[ ;DY"G D/[ K[P
Z$P
5|[DR\N
GUZ ZF[0 4 ,1DL UF\9LIF ZY ;FD[ HFC[Z ZF[0 p5Z VFJ[, HuIFG]\ 5\RGFD]\
SZJFDF\ VFJ[, CT\]P VG[ 5\RGFDFGL CSLSTF[ ;FlAT SZJF DF8[ OZLIFN
51F[ T[JF 5\RGFDFGF 5\R ;FC[N G\A Z s5f
62/273
DF[8Z ;FIS,GL 5C[,F\ ZF[0 p5Z ,F[CL 50[, CT]\P H[ JWFZ[ 5|DF6DF\ CT
VG[ BFAF[RLIF\ H[J\] CT]\P 5\R ;FC[N[ JW]DF\ H6FJ[, K[S[4 UF0LG[ XF[8" A|[S
DFZ[,FGF lGXFG ZF[0 p5Z N[BFTF\ CTFP H[
SIF 0F[SI]D[g8 CTF T[ ;FC[NG[ IFN G CT\] VG[ T[ 0F[SI]D[g8 JF\R[, CF[JFG\]\
H6FJ[, K[ P ;FY[ ;FY[ 5\R ;FC[N[ H6FJ[, K[ S[4
T[ 0F[SI]D[g8
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
63/273
DFG;L ;S", TZO HJFGF Z:TF p5Z VD], UF0"G ACFZ VS:DFTJF/L
HuIF VFJ[,L CTL H[ Z:TF[ 5|[DR\NGUZYL DFG;L ;S", TZO HJFGF[
Z:TF[ CTF[ ALHF[ Z:TF[
5|[DR\NGUZYL
VG[ T|LHF[ Z:TF[ ;\N[X 5|[; TZO HFI K[P 5\R ;FC[NGF p5ZF[ST 5]ZFJFG[
OZLIFN 51F[ ZH] YI[, VF\S *( GF 5\RGFDFYL ;\5]6"56[ ;DY"G D/[ K[P
VG[ T[YL 5\R ;FC[NGF[ 5]ZFJF[ TYF VF\S *( GF 5\RGFDFDF\ H6FJ[,
CSLS TF [
ZF[0 p5Z VD], UF0"G ACFZ AGFJJF/L HuIF VFJ[, CF[JFG]\ :5Q8
56[ O,LT YFI K[P JW]DF\ AGFJJF/F :Y/[ V[S ALPV[DP 0A<I]P
SFZ ;LPV[RP v_!vV[.v)#&_ VFU/GF EFU[ 8F[8, ,F[; Sg0LXGDF\
TYF 5<;Z DF[8Z ;FIS, HLH[v_!vV[OVFZv*!! 50[, CF[JFG]\ :
5Q856[ O,LT YFI K[P ;FY[ ;FY[ AF.S HIF\ 50[, CT] \TG
[ L GHLSDF\
ZF[0 p5Z ,F[CLG]\ BFAF[RLI]\ HF[JF D/[,FGF[ 5]ZFJF[ K[P VG[ T[YL :Y/
p5Z XLJDGF DFYFDF\YL 36]\ AW]\ ,F[CL GLS/L UI[, CF[JFGF OZLIFN51F[
;FC[N
5]ZFJFG[ ;DY"G D/[ K[P ;FY[ ;FY[ :Y/ p5Z VS:DFTDF\ ;\0F[JFI[,
SFZ 50[, CF[.4 VG[ VFU/GF[ EFU 8F[8, ,F[; CF[. 4 T[GFYL
CF,GF[ VS:DFT YI[,F[ CF[JFG]\ OZLIFNL
:Y/[ D/LVFJ[,
SFZ
;FY[ ;FY[ ;FC[N G\AZ s!!f OZLIFNL GF[ 5]ZFJF[ wIFGD\F ,.X]\ TF[4
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
64/273
SFZ lJX[ V[J]\ H6FJ[, K[S[4 AGFJ JBT[ VF SFZ hF0 ;FY[ VY0FI[,L
50[,L CTL P5Z\T] T[ ;DI[ OZLIFNLV[ VF SFZ wIFGYL HF[I[, G CTLP
VG[ 5FK/YL 5F[,L; DFZOT[ HF6JF D/[, S[ 4 SF/F S,ZGL SFZ
ALPV[DP 0A<I] CTL VG[ VF SFZGF[ G\AZ )#&_ H[JF[ CF[JFG]\
OZLIFNLG[ HF6JF D/[,]\P 5Z\T]\
K[P
VFD
SFZ
SF[GL
CTL
VG[
T[GF[
G\AZ
GUZ T|6 Z:TF YL ;\N[X 5|[; TZO HJFGF 8GL"U p5Z VD], 45F,"ZGL
ACFZ HFC[Z ZF[0 p5Z AG[, CF[JFG]\
65/273
Z5
AG[,
CF[JFG]\ H6FI K[P 5Z\T] T[ SFZGF RF,S SF[6 CTF T[ CSLST[ OZLIFN 51F[
NFX"l GS
;FC[N
U]% TF
;FC[N
G\A Z !! GF[ 5]ZFJF[ wIFGDF\ ,.X]\ TF[4 OZLIFNLV[ V[J]\ H6FJ[, K[ S[4
VF AGFJ AG[, tIFZ[ SFZ SF[6 R,FJT] CT]\ 4 T[6[ S[JF S50F\ 5C[Z[,F
CTF
H6FJ[, K[ S[4 SFZ h05YL VFJTL CTLP JW]DF\ V[J\] H6FJ[, K[ S[4 VF
SFZ hF0 ;FY[ VY0F. UIF AFN T[GF RF,SG]\ X]\ YI[, T[ RF,S TZO
OZLIFNLG]\ wIFG G CT\P] SFZ6 S[
T[GF
SFZDF\ S[8,F
DF6;F[ CTF T[ TZO OZLIFNLG]\ wIFG UI[, G CT]\P VG[ AGFJGF ALHF
lNJ;[ ;JFZ[ J:T|F5]Z 5F[P:8[P DF\ OZLIFNL UI[,F tIFZ[ VF ALPV[DP
0A<I] SFZ tIF\ 50[,L CTLP JW]DF\ OZLIFNLV[ V[J\] H6FJ[, K[ S[4 AGFJ
AFN T[ H ZFT|LGF VFXZ[ T|6S
[ JFU[ GF VZ;FDF\
OZLIFNLV[ V[J\]
HF6JF D/[, S[ 4VF SFZ lJ:DI GFDGF SF[. jIlST R,FJTF CTF
POZLIFNLV[ VF CSLST DL0LIF
OZLIFNLGF H6FjIF D]HA ALHF lNJ;[ T[VF[ J:T|F5]Z 5F[P:8[P DF\ UI[,
tIFZ[ VF ALPV[DP 0A<I] SFZ50[, CTL T[GF[ VFU/GF[ EFU 9F[SF. UI[,
CTF[ POZLIFNLGF[ p5ZF[ST 5]ZFJF[ wIFGDF\ ,[TF\4 VS:DFTD\F ;\0F[JFI[,
ALPV[DP 0A<I] SFZ GF RF,SG[ OZLIFNLV[ HF[I[, G CF[JFG]\ H6FI K[P
5Z\T] OZLIFNLGL OZLIFN DF\ H6FJ[,
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
66/273
OZLIFN GF[WGFZ ;FC[N G\A Z Z# GZ[g N=U LZL U]6 J\T ULZL UF[; F.GF
VF\S 5$ GF 5]ZFJFYL OZLIFNLGF p5ZF[ST CSLSTF[ OZLIFND\F ,BFJ[,
CF[JFG]\ :5Q8 56[ O,LT YFI K[P H[ 5F[,L; VlWSFZLGF 5]ZFJF D]HA
OZLIFNDF\ ,BFJ[,
CSLSTF[
OZLIFNLV[ ,BFJ[,
T[ D]HA
AZFAZ
VG[ BZL K[P JW]DF\ ;NZ 5F[,L; VlWSFZLGF 5]ZFJFDF\ H6FjIF D]HA
VF\S )5 GL OZLIFN OZLIFNLV[ T[VF[GF Z]AZ] GF[WFJ[, CTLP VFD4 VF\S )
5
GL
OZLIFNDF\
p5ZF[ST
CSLSTF[
B]N
OZLIFNLV[
,BFJ[,
C[FJFG]\ :5Q856[ O,LT YFI K[P;FY[ ;FY[ OZLIFN GF[WGFZ ;NZ 5F[,L;
VlWSFZL ;FC[N G\AZsZ#f GF
ZFT|LGF
S,FS !!P!5 JFU[GF ;]DFZ[ 5F[,L; :8[XG YL JWL" VFJ[, S[4 ;\HLJGL
CF[l:58,GF 0F[S8Z[
ZFC],G[ VtIFZ[ NJFBFG[ NFB, YI[, K[ VG[ XLJD DZ6 UI[, K[P
T[VF[ T[ JWL" VFWFZ[ ;\HLJGL CF[l:58, UI[,FP VG[ tIF\ XLJD DZ6
UI[, CF,TDF\ CT[F VG[ ZFC], GL l:YlT U\ELZ CTL VG[ T[GF lDT| ,,LT
ZFH[X
U]%TF
5F[,L; :8[XG[
HFT[
;\EF/[,P
VFD4
p5ZF[ST
5]ZFJF[
wIFGDF\
,[TF\4
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
67/273
J:T|F5]Z 5F[P:8[PDF\
U]gCF[ GF[WFJF DF8[ DF[S,TF\ CF,GF[ U]gCF[ GF[WGFZ 5LPV[; PVF[P ;FC[N
G\A Z sZ!fR]G L,F, ELBFEF. 58[, 4V[P V[; PVF.P VF\S !$
( GF 5]ZFJF D]HA TFPZ$qZqZ_!# GF ZF[H J:T|F5]Z 5F[P:8[PDF\ ;JFZGF
S,FS (q__ YL S,FS !Zq__ VG[
Z$q__ ;]WL 5LPV[;PVFZ[P TZLS[ OZH p5Z CTF tIFZ[ S,FS Zq__
TFZLB Z5qZqZ_!# GF ZF[H T[VF[GF 5F;[ OZLIFNL ,,LTS]DFZ ZFH[X U]
%TFV[
5LPV[;PVF.P
V[GPHLPUF[;F.
Z]AZ]
GF[WFJ[,
OZLIFN
U]gCF[ GF[WFJF ZL5F[8" ;FY[ DF[S,L VF5TF\ U]gCF[ NFB, SZL VF5[, CTF[
PVG[ T[ VFWFZ[ T[VF[V[ VF U]gCF[ NFB, SZ[,FGF[ 5]ZFJF[ K[PH[ U]gCFGL
V[OPVF.PVFZ P OZLIFN 51F[ VF\S !5_ YL TYF U]gCF V\U[ :8[XG 0FIZL
GL GF[W VF\S !$) YL ZH] SZ[, K[P V[OPVF.PVFZP VG[ :8[XG 0FIZL
DF\ U]gCF[ HFC[Z YIFGF[ ;DI D]HA
JFU[ CF,GF[ U]gCF[ HFC[Z YI[,P H[ V\U[ OZLIFNL ,,LT ZFH[X U]%TF
V[ 5LPV[;PVF.P V[GPHLP UF[;F. Z]AZ] OZLIFN GF[WFJ[, CF[JFG]\ :5Q8
56[ O,LT YFI K[P
Z&P
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
68/273
VG[ ;ZSFZL HuIF V[8,[ S[ SF[.S SR[ZLDF\ ,. UI[,F 5Z\T]\ T[ SR[ZL SIF\
CTL T[ OZLIFNLG[ IFN GYLP ;FY[ ;FY[ OZLIFNLV[ V[J\] H6FJ[, K[ S[
4AC]DF/L EJGDF\ VF SR[ZL ALHF S[ T|LHF DF/[
T[ JBT[
VFJ[, CTLP
56 CTFP tIF\
5F[,L;[
5F[,L;
lJ:DIG[
VF[/BL
OZLIFNLV[
lJ:DI
XS[P
VG[
TZLS[
SF[8"
VF[/BL
Z]AZ]
CFHZ
ATFJ[,
K[P
69/273
OZLIFNL J:T|F5]Z 5F[P:8[P UI[, HIF\ T[VF[G]\ lGJ[NG ,LW[, T[DH TFZLB
Z* GF ZF[H ;F\HGF 56 OZLIFNLG]\ lGJ[NG ,LW[, CT]P JW]DF\ OZLIFNLGF
H6FjIF D]HA VS:DFTGF ALHF lNJ;[
H[ lGJ[NG ,LW[,
ZF[H5F[,L;[
OZLIFNLG[
lJ:DI
XFC
ATFJ[,
Z]AZ]
lGJ[NGDF\
CSLSTF[
5F[TFGL
;CL
AZFAZ VG[
BZL
CF[JFG]\
CF[JFG]\
VG[
T[
H6FJ[,
lGJ[NGDF\
K[P
;FY[
,B[,L
;FY[
lJUTF[GF C:TF1FZ
OZLIFNLV[ 5F[TFGF
,BF6
OZLIFNLG]\
lGJ[NG
,[JFI[,
tIFZ[
,B[,
CT\]P
70/273
C:TF1FZDF\ ,BL T[DH T[GF GLR[ 5F[TFGL ;CL SZ[,L CF[JFG]\ H6FJ[, K[P
T[ VF\S )& GF ,BF6 D]HA
HI]0LxI,
OZLIFNLV[
D[HL:8[=84VDNFJFNsU|FdIfDLZHF5]ZGFVF[V[
OF[HNFZL
T[ D]HA
;FY[
K99F
KF[SZF[
cc
;F[Z L
VF.
JL,
DL:8[S
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
cc
71/273
UI[, V[8,[4
DF\
56[ O,LT YFI K[P JW]DF\4 OZLIFNLGF[ 5]ZFJF[ wIFGDF\ ,[TF\4 p5ZF[ST
lGJ[NG OZLIFNLGL .rKF lJZ]wW S[ SF[. NAF6YL ,[JFDF\ VFJ[, CF[I
T[JF[ OZLIFNLGF[ SF[. 5]ZFJF[ GYLP JW]DF\4 OZLIFNLV[ T[J]\ :5Q8 H6FJ[,
K[ S[4 T[ lGJ[NGDF\ ,BF6GL CSLSTF[ AZFAZ VG[ BZL K[P
VFD
!&$ VgJI[GF
72/273
K]5FJJF
SFZ6
S[4T[
lGJ[NGDF\
lGJ[NG
GF[WTF\
5C[,F\4
OZLIFNLV[
5F[TFGL
OZLIFND\F
H6FjIF
D]HA
JFCG
RF,SG[ HFI[, VG[ HF[I[YL VF[/BL XS[ T[D CF[JF KTF\ T[JL
CSLST[ VG[ OF[HNFZL SFI"ZLTL VlWlGIDGL S,D !&$ D]HAGF lGJ[NG
DF\ D[HL:8==[8 Z]AZ] GF[WFJ[,L CSLSTF[G[ ;DY"G VF5TF\ G CF[.
OZLIFN51F[ lJP V[P5LP5LPzLGL lJG\TLYL OZL UI[, HFC[Z SZL 4 OZLIFN
51F[
lJP
V[P5LP5LPzL
G[
p,8T5F;
SZJF
TS
VF5JFDF\
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
73/273
GL O]85FY p5Z SFZ VFJLG[ pEL ZC[, VG[ UF0LDF\YL V[S H6 pTZL
OZLIFNLG[ cc ;F[ZL ;F[ZLcc SCL EFU[, 4 T[G[ OZLIFNLV[ HF[I[, VG[T[YL
OZLIFNL VF[/BL XS[P JW]DF\ V[ CSLSTGF[ 56 OZLIFNLV[ .gSFZ SZ[,F[ K[
S[4
ALPV[DP0A<I]
RF,S
ALHF
56
JFCGF[G[
V0O[8DF\
,LW[,
C[FJFG]]
H[ CSLSTF[ ,BFJ[,
74/273
DCtJGL CSLSTF[ K]5FJJF 5|ItG SZTF CF[JFG]\ :5Q856[ O,LT YFI K[P
#!
VG];\WFG[
V[P5LP5LPzLV[p,8T5F;DF\
5]KTF\
CTF[ S[ S[D T[ bIF, GYLP 5Z\T]\ SF[.S SF[8" CTL 4VG[ T[ S[F8"DF\ HH ;FC[A
,[0L HH
;FC[A CTFP
OZLIFNLGL 5]K5ZK
VG[
AF[,FJL ;CL ,LW[,P VFD OZLIFN 51F[ ZH] YI[, VF\S )* GF lGJ[NG4
OF[HNFZL SFI"ZLTL VlWlGID !&$ VgJI[
HI]0LxI, D[HL:8[=8
75/273
#Z
5Z\T]\ 5FK/YL
5F[TFG[ HF6JF D/[, S[4 BZ[BZ VF lJ:DI XFC UF0L R,FJTF[ CTF[P cc
T[JL CSLST
"
76/273
TFPZ*qZqZ_!# GF ZF[H
5F[,L;[ T[VF[G]\ JW\] lGJ[NG ,LW[, CT]\ S[ S[D T[ T[VF[G[ IFN GYLP
;FC[N[ B],F;F[ SZTF\ H6FJ[, K[ S[ T[ lNJ;[ ZFC], D'tI] 5FD[, CTF[ T[YL
VFJ]\ lGJ[NG ,LW[, CT]\ S[ S[D T[ RF[SS; 56[ IFN GYLP 5Z\T]\ OZLIFNLV[
V[ CSLST :JLSFZ[, K[ S[ TFPZ*qZqZ_!# GF ZF[H ALPV[DP 0A<I]
SFZGF RF,SG[ 5F[,L; 5S0L ,FJ[, CTLP VG[ OZLIFNLV[ 5F[,L; :8[XG
DF\
T[G[
V[
CSLSTGF[
.gSFZ
GF lGJ[NGDF\
V[J] ,BFJ[, CT] S[ cc H[G[ HF[I[ C]\ RF[SS; SCL XS\] S[ VF V[ H jIlST
K[ S[ H[G[ TFPZ$qZqZ_!# GF ZF[H ALPV[DP 0A<I] SFZYL p5ZF[ST
VS:DFT SZL T[GL SFZDF\YL pTZL DG[ ;F[ZL ;F[ZL AF[,LG[ EFUL UI[,
CTF[4 T[GL ALPV[DP 0A<I] SFZ H[ T[ AGFJGF lNJ;[ !__ lSPDLP YL
56 JWFZ[
. //
,
.
".VFD p5ZF[ST
CSLST[F
OZLIFNLV[ 5F[TFGF
TFZLB
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
77/273
OZLIFNL4
SFZRF,SGL
VF[/B
V\U[
DCtJGL
CSLSTF[
78/273
ATFJ[, G CF[JFG]\ H6FJ[, K[P 5Z\T]\ T[JL VF[/B V\U[G]\ 5\RGFD] SZJFDF\
VFJ[, CT]\ S[ S[D T[ OZLIFNLG[ IFN GYLP
#&
TYF
YL 5\R
5\RGFDFGL
CSLSTF[G[ ;DY"G VF5TF GYL VG[ T[VF[GF 5]ZFJF D]HA T[VF[GL OST A[
;CLVF[ 5\RGFDFDF\ ,LW[, CF[JFG]\ O,LT YFI K[ 5Z\T]\ T[VF[GL CFHZLDF\
S[F. jIlSTGL VF[/B SZFJJFDF\ VFJ[, CF[. T[J]\ ;FC[N G\AZ * GF[ S[F.
5]ZFJF[ GYLP HIFZ[ ;FC[N G\AZ !_ HLT]EF. KUGEF. GFIL GF 5]ZFJFYL
5\RGFDFGL CSLSTF[ ;FlAT YFI K[P ;FC[N G\AZ !_ GF 5]ZFJF D]HA
TFPZ*qZqZ_!# GF ZF[H
5F[,L; :8[XG[ VFJF[P VG[ T[YL 5F[,L; :8[XGDF\ T[VF[ UI[,FP JW]D\F
;FC[N[ H6FJ[, K[S[4 5F[,L;[ ;FC[NG[ V[J]\ SC[, S[ V[S VS:DFTGF[ S[; K[P
T[G]\ 5\RGFD\] SZJFG\] K[P T[ JBT[ ALHF V[S 5\R 56 CTFP 5Z\T]\ T[VF[GF
GFDGL T[VF[G[ BAZ GYLP p5ZF[ST 5]ZFJFGL ;FY[ ;FY[ ;FC[N G\AZ *
VXF[S U,FHL 9FSF[Z GF[ 5]ZFJF[ wIFGD\F ,.X]\ TF[4 T[VF[V[ ;CL SZL
tIFZ[ ALHF 5\R HLT]EF. KUGEF. GFDGL jIlST 56 tIF\ CFHZ CTFP
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
79/273
VG[ GLR[ JFN/L S,ZG]]\ HLg; 5C[Z[, CT\] T[GF 0FAF CFYGL CY[/LDF\
JFU[,FG]\ lGXFG CT\] T[GF HD6F CFYGL SF[6L VG[ SF\0F JrR[ V\NZGF
EFU[ JFU[,FG]\ lGXFG CT\]P VG[ ALH]\ SF\. N[BFI[, GlCP tIFZAFN 5F[,L;[
;FC[N[ R[S SZ[,FG]\ 5\RGFD]\ SZ[, VG[ ;FC[NGL ;CL ,LWL CTLP H[ VF\S
($ VG[ (5GF 5\RGFDFDF\ ;CL CF[JFG\] H6FJ[, K[ P;FY[ ;FY[
;FC[N[ V[J]\ H6FJ[, K[S[4 T[VF[ 5\RF[4 5F[,L; T[DH lJ:DIEF. l;JFI
ALH]\ S[F. G CT\] lJ:DI XFCG[ H[ T[ JBT[ ;FC[N[ 5F[P:8[P DF\ HF[I[,
VG[ SF[8" Z]AZ] 56 ;FC[N[ VF[/BL ATFJ[, K[P VFD ;FC[N Z]AZ] GF
5\RGFDFGF p5ZF[ST 5]ZFJFG[ wIFGDF\ ,[TF\ ;FC[NGL CFHZLDF\ VFZF[5L
lJ:DI XFC GL XZLZ l:YlTG]\ 5\RGFD] SZJFDF\ VFJ[, CF[JFGL CSLST
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
80/273
T[DH VFZF[5LGF 0FAF CFYGL CY[/LDF\ JFU[,FG]\ lGXFG CT\] T[GF HD6F
CFYGL SF[6L VG[ SF\0F JrR[ V\NZGF EFU[ JFU[,FG]\ lGXFG CT]\P
VG[ T[ ZLT[ VFZF[5LG[ .HFVF[ YI[, CF[JFGF[ 5]ZFJF[ K[P H[ 5]ZFJF[ VF\S (5
GF 5\RGFDFDF\ H6FJ[, CSLSTF[YL ;DY"G D/[ K[P
#&P!
VFD4 VF\S
CSLSTYL 5\R ;FC[NGF 5]ZFJFYL ;FlAT YI[, K[P 5Z\T]\ VFZF[5LGL VF[/B
OZLIFNLGL CFHZLDF\ SZFJJFDF\ VFJ[, CF[I
H[ T5F;GLX Z]AZ]
GF
5[FP:8[PDF\
VFZF[5LG[
VF[/BL
AF[,FJL
ATFJ[,FG]\
5\RF[GF
5\RGFD]
,BFjIF
SZ[,P
D]HAG]\
H[
OZLIFNL
5\RGFDFDF\
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
81/273
CF[JFGF[ 5]ZFJF[ K[P H[GF lJZ]wW S[ B\0GSTF" SF[. 5]ZFJF[ VFZF[5L TZO[ ZH]
YI[,F[ GYLP ;FY[ ;FY[ T5F;GLXG[ VFZF[5L 5|tI[ SF[. jN[QFEFJ CF[I 4
VFZ[F5LG[ BF[8L ZLT[ ;\0F[JL N[JFDF\ VFJ[, C[FI T[JL CSLST ARFJ 51F
Z[S0" p5Z ,FJL XS[, GYLP T[JF ;\HF[UF[DF\ T5F;GLXGF[ p5ZF[ST
5]ZFJF[ GlC DFGJFG[ SF[. SFZ6 GYLP VFD OZLIFNL DFZOT[ VFZF[5L
lJ:DI XFCGL VF[/B SZFJJFDF\ VFJ[, CF[JFG]\ :5Q856[ O,LT YFI K[P
VG[ T[D KTF\ OZLIFNLGF H6FjIF D]HA
OZLIFNLV[
TFZLB
SZ[,L p,8T5F;
:58Q856[ :JLSFZ[, K[
S[4 OZLIFNLV[ OZLIFND\F ;CL SZL tIFZ[ VF AWF\ DF6;F[ tIF\ CFHZ CTFP
OZLIFNLV[ 5F[TFGL JW] p,8T5F; NZdIFG V[ CSLST :JLSFZ[, K[ S[4
OZLIFNDF\ ,B[, ,BF6 OZLIFNLV[ ,BFJ[, G CT]P OZLIFNLV[ :J[rKF
V[ H6FJ, K[ S[ 5F[,L;[ OZLIFNLGL 5]K5ZK SZ[,L CTL VG[ YF[0LJFZ
5KL T[VF[GL ;CL SZFJ[,L CTLP;FY[ ;FY[ V[ CSLST 56 :JLSFZ[, K[ S[
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
82/273
;FC[NGL
OZLIFNLV[ ,BFJ[, C[FJFGL CSLST T[DH T[DF\ ,B[, CSLSTF[ AZFAZ VG[
BZL CF[JFG]\ 56 H6FJ[, K[ PJW]DF\ p5ZF[ST 5]ZFJFG[ wIFGD\F ,[TF\ 4
OZLIFNGL CSLSTF[ VgI SF[.V[ ,BFJ[, CF[I T[J]\ OZLIFNL H6FJTF GYL
VG[ T[YL OZLIFND\F H6FJ[, CSLSTF[ VgI SF[. jIlSTV[ ,BFJ[, CF[I
T[J]\ DFGL XSFI T[D GYL P
#(
5C[Z[, G C[FJFG]\
VG[ T[D SZL A\gG[ D'TSF[V[ 56 A[NZSFZL ATFJ[, CF[JFGF[ ARFJ 51F[
ATFJJFGF[
5|ItG
SZ[,
K[
H[
V\U[
OZLIFNLGL
p,8T5F;
GF[ 5]ZFJF[ wIFGD\F ,.X]\ TF[4 OZLIFNLV[ H6FJ[, K[ S[ AGFJ ;DI[ ZFC],
VG[ XLJD[ C[<D[8 5C[Z[, CT]\ S[ S[D 4T[ V\U[ 5F[,L;[ T[VF[GL 5]K5ZK
SZ[, CTL S[ S[D T[ T[VF[G[ IFN GYLP JW]DF\ OZLIFNLV[ H6FJ[, K[S[4
AGFJ JBT[ ZFC], VG[ XLJD[ C[<D[8 5C[Z[, G CTLP JW]DF\
OZLIFNLV[ H6FJ[, K[S[4 DFG;LYL HHLh A\U,F[ HTF\ Z[F0 p5Z VFJ[,
0LJF.0Z VG[ 5|[DR\N GUZ T|6 Z:TF p5Z VFJ[, ;S", JrR[ B]<,L
HuIF VFJ[, CF[JF AFAT[ 5F[,L;[
TZOYL VFJGFZ
JFCGG[ SFIN[;Z ZLT[ HJ\] C[FI TF[ ;S", VG[ 0LJF.0Z JrR[ VFJ[, B]<,L
HuIF p5Z Y. HD6L AFH] HHLh A\U,F TZO H. XSFIP;FY[
;FY[ V[ CSLST :JLSFZ[, K[ S[4
;S", OZTF\ UF[/ J8FJL lGID D]HA ;\N[X 5|[; TZO H. XSFIP ;FY[;FY[
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
83/273
OZLIFNLGL p,8T5F; GF
A\gG[ D'TSF[ V[ C[<D[8 5C[Z[, G
CF[JFG]\] VG[ DFG;L ;S", J8FJLG[ UI[, G CTF 5Z\T] ZF[U ;F.0[ Y. ;\N[X
5|[; TZO HTF CF[JFG]\ H6FI K[ P
#)P
AGFJ
TFZLB
A\gG[ DZ6
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
84/273
T[ A\gG[ D'TSF[ CJFDF\ pK/[,F VG[ GLR[ HDLG p5Z 58SFTF\ U\ELZ
.HFVF[ YI[,L 4VG[ T[JL .HFVF[GF SFZ6[ D'tI]\ GL5H[,P H[ D'tI]\G]\
SFZ6
AGFJ ;DI[ CFHZ CTFP 5Z\T] ,,LTEF.G[ :Y/ p5Z SF[.GL ;FY[ JFT
YI[, CF[I TF[ T[ ;FC[NGF
;FC[N[ H6FJ[, K[ S[4 T[ ;DI[ ;FC[NG[ B]A VF3FT ,FU[,F[ CTF[ VG[ T[YL
UEZF. UI[,P
$_PZ
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
85/273
SFZDF\YL SF[.V[ pTZLG[ ,,LT U]%TF ;FY[ SF[. JFT SZ[, CF[I TF[ T[
;FC[NGF
VFD
;DI[ CF,GF VFZF[5L SFZ R,FJTF CF[JFGF[ SF[. RF[SS; VG[ :5Q8 5]ZFJF[
VF5TF GYLP 5Z\T] ;FC[NG[ 5FK/YL HF6JF D/[, T[J]\ :5Q8 56[ O,LT
YFI K[P VS:DFTDF\
$!
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
86/273
UIF CTF T[GF[ ;FC[NG[ bIF, GYLP JW]DF\ ;FC[N[ H6FJ[, K[ S[ 4AGFJGF
JL;YL 5rRL; lNJ;
JW]DF\ ;FC[NGF H6FjIF D]HA T[VF[G[ V[S H JFZ SF[8"DF\ ,FJ[, CTFP VG[
T[ lNJ;[ ;FC[N ;FY[ ,,LT U]%TF CTFP H[ S[F8"DF\ T[VF[G[ ,. UIF
T[ S[F8"DF\ 5C[,F\ ,,LT U]%TFGL 5]KTF; SZ[, VG[ ;FC[NG[ ACFZ A[;F0[,
CTF[P 5\NZ JL; DLGL8DF\ ,,LT ACFZ VFJ[, VG[ tIFZAFN ;FC[N V\NZ
UI[,P tIF\ VFJL V[S S[F8{" sCF,GL S[F8" H[JL H SF[8"f CTL VG[ V\NZ V[S
Z]DD\F ,. UIF CTFP tIF\ T[VF[GL
VG[ A\gG[GF ,BF6 V,U CTF VG[ V,U V,U ,BF6DF\ VDFZL
;CL ,LW[,P 5Z\T] ;FC[NGF H6FjIF D]HA T[ ,BF6 ;FC[N[ JF\R[, GlC4
5Z\T] ;CL SZ[, CTLP ;FC[NG[[ SF[8"GF Z[S0"DF\YL V[S SJZDF\YL SF-L V[S
lGJ[NG ATFJJFDF\ VFJTF\ T[DF\ ;FC[NGL ;CL CF[JFG]\ H6FJ[,
K[ VG[ T[ ;CL T[VF[ HIFZ[ DLZHF5]Z SF[8"DF\ VFJ[, tIFZ[ SZL CTL VG[
VF
,BF6
56
T[
K[P
T[
JBT[
;FC[NGL
5]KTF;
D[HL:8[=8 Z]AZ]
87/273
YTF\ 5C[,F \ ;FC[NGL 5]K5ZK YI[, CTL VG[ T[VF[V[ H[ CSLSTF[ H6FJ[,
CTL T[ H CSLSTF[ T[DF\ CF[JFG]\ B]N ;FC[N[ H6FJ[, K[PV,AT T[DF\ YF[0LS
lJUTF[ JWFZFGL CF[JFG]\ ;FC[N[ H6FJ[, K[PVG[ T[JLJWFZFGL lJUTF[ S.
K[ T[ V\U[ ;FC[N[ :5Q8TF SZ[, GYLP VFD4VF\S ))G]\ lGJ[NG DLZHF5]Z
SF[8"DF\ lJwJFG D[HL:8[=8
S[
:5Q8 56[
SF[G]\ CT]\
;LV[Rv_! vV[.v
SFZG[ UF[ZDF[ CF[8, ZF[0 TZOYL V[SND O], :5L0DF\ ,FJL 5<;Z DF[8Z
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
88/273
UF[ZDF[ CF[8,
VS:DFTDF ;\0F[JFI[,
SFZ
;FC[N G\AZ !Z GF
;FC[N[
VFXZ[ pPJPZ$ JZ;GF[ CTF[4 T[ V[S;L0g8 SZL UF0L D]SL EFUL UI[, K[
Pcc JW]DF\
ccVF
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
89/273
TFZLB Z5qZqZ_!# GF
VG[ ;FC[N[ 5F[TFGF lGJ[NGDF\ ,BFJ[, CT] P VFD p5ZF[ST CSLSTF[ ;FC[N
G\AZ !Z GF V[ TFPZ5qZqZ_!# GF ZF[H ,BFJ[, C[FJFGF[ lJZF[WFEF;
OZLIFN51F[ ;FlAT SZ[, K[P T[D KTF\ CF,GF ;FC[N[ p5ZF[ST CSLST S[ H[
VS:DFT SZGFZ SFZ RF,S G[ VS:DFT ;DI[ HF[JFGL TS D/L CF[JFGL
DCtJGL CSLST[ T[DH T[JF SFZ RF,SG[ ;FC[N G\AZ s!!f OZLIFNL
,,LT U]%TFG[ T[6[ ;F[ZL ;F[ZL SZL EFUL HTF\ GHLSDF\YL HF[I[, CF[[JFGL
DCtJGL CSLSTF[
K[P
$$
TFZLB !5q#qZ_!# GF
ZF[H DLZHF5]Z SF[8"DF\ VFJ[, CX[4 5Z\T] RF[SS; IFN GYLP V,AT
T[VF[G[ H[ S[F8"DF\ ,. UI[, T[ S[F8" DC[P K99F V[0LXG, RLO
HI]0LPD[HL ;FC[AGL S[F8" CTL S[ S[D T[ ;FC[NG[ RF[SS; IFN GYLP
JW]DF\ ;FC[N[ .gSFZ SZ[,F[ K[ VF\S !__ DF\ ;FC[NG[ H[[ ;DH6 VF5JFGL
CSLSTF[ H6FJ[, K[ T[JL ;DH6 ;FC[NG[ SF[8"DF\ VF5JFDF\ VFJ[, CTLP
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
90/273
;FC[NG[
ZC[JFGL ;]RGF VF5JFDF\ VFJ[,L CTL S[ S[D T[ ;FC[NG[ VtIFZ[ IFN GYLP
VF ;]RGF D]HA TFZLB Z!q#q!# GF ZF[H CFHZ ZC[,F[ S[ S[D
T[JF
5|xGGF HJFADF\ ;FC[N[ H6FJ[, K[S[ ;FC[N OST V[S H JFZ DLZHF5]Z
S[F8"DF\ CFHZ ZC[, CTFP ;FC[N[ JW]D\F4 H6FJ[, K[ S[4 VF\S !__ GF
,BF6DF\ 5C[,L H[ ;CL K[ T[ ;CL ;FC[N[ TFZLB !5q#q!# GF ZF[H
SZ[,L 5Z\T]\ ;FC[NG[ T[DF\ ,BFjIF D]HAGL SF[. ;DH VF5JFD\F VFJ[, G
CF[JFG]\ H6FJ[, K[PJW]DF\ ;FC[N[
:JLSFZ[, K[S[4
TFPZ!q#q!# GF
ZF[H ,,LT U]%TF ;FY[ ;FC[N DLZHF5]Z S[F8"DF\ VFJ[, CTFP JW]DF\ ;FC[N[
:JLSFZ[, K[ S[4 VF\S )) JF/\] lGJ[NG TFZLB Z!q#q!# GF ZF[H ,[JFDF\
VFJ[, CT\]P ;FC[N[ JW]DF\ :JLSFZ[, K[ S[[4 VF\S )) G]\ lGJ[NG ,LWF AFN4
VF\S !__ GF ,BF6DF\ ;FC[N[ 5F[TFGF C:TF1FZDF\
,BFI[, K[ T[
,BF6 SZL ;CL SZ[, CTLPJW]DF\ ;FC[N[ V[ CSLSTGF[ :JLSFZ SZ[,F[ K[ S[4
TFZLB Z!q#q!# GF ;FC[NGF VF\S )) GF lGJ[NGDF\ VS:DFTGL
lJUTF[ ,BFJ[, CTLP ;FC[N[ V[ CSLSTGF[
56 .gSFZ
SZ[,F[ K[ S[4
V\FS )) GF lGJ[NGDF\
,BFJ[, G C[FJFG]\
91/273
CX[P
;FC[N[
H[
V[daI],g;GF
V[daI],g;
A[
AF[,FJ[,
DF6;F[
T[
CTFP
V[daI],g;DF\
V[daI],g;
UI[,P
;FC[N[
JW]DF\
H6FJ[,
K[
S[4
ZFC],
T[VF[GL
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
92/273
;CLVF[ SIFZ[ VG[ SIF\ ,[JFDF\ VFJ[, CTL T[GL T[VF[G[ BAZ GYLP
JW]DF\
;FC[N[
VF lGJ[NG VF5TF\
lJxJ;GLITF p5Z X\SF Y. XS[ T[D T[J]\ ATFJJF ARFJ 51F[ 5|ItG
SZ[, C[FJFG]\ O,LT YFI K[P
$*
VG[ ZFC],G]\ 5<;Z VDFZFYL RFZ O]8 VFU/ CT]\ T[J]\ TFPZ5qZqZ_!#
GF S[ TFPZ*qZqZ_!# S[ SF[8" Z]AZ] GF lGJ[NGDF\ ,BFJ[, G CT]P VFD4
p5ZF[ST lGJ[NGDF\ ,BFJ[, G CF[JFGF DFT| SFZ6YL4HIFZ[ VS:DFT
V\U[GL CSLSTF[ ;FC[N H6FJTF CF[I tIFZ[ ;FC[N[ T[ AGFJ AGTF[ HF[I[,
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
93/273
SFZ6
AGFJ ;DI[ VG[ :Y/[ ;FC[N GHLSDF\ CF[JFG]\ :5Q8 56[ O,LT YFI K[P
$(
V[8,[ S[ ;F[ YL
JWFZ[ :5L0DF\ C[FI T[J]\ ,FU[,4]\ VG[ T[ SFZ ;FC[NGL UF0LGL 0FAL
AFH]YL VF[JZ8[S SZL VFU/GF 0FAL AFH]GF AF[G[8G[ S|[; SZL GLS/L
UI[,LP SFZGF[ S,Z 0FS"
;FC[NGF
5]ZFJF VG];FZ VF[{0F UF0"G VD], 5F,"Z 5F;[ T|6 Z:TF VFJ[, K[ tIF\
5CF[[R,
[ VG[ HF[I[, TF[ V[S AF.S O\UF[/F. 50[, CT]\ 4VG[ EF. ZF[0 p5Z
50[, CTF VG[ AC] ,F[CL GLS/[, CT]\P ;FC[NGF H6FjIF D]HA T[VF[G[
V[J]\ ,FU[, S[ T[ EF. HLJLT VJ:YFDF\ GlC CF[IP ALHL V[S jIlST VF
EF.YL N;YL 5\NZ O]8GF V\TZ[ ZF[[0 p5Z 50[, CTLP ;FC[NGF 5]ZFJF
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
94/273
VG];FZ T[VF[V[ VFU/ H. 0FAL AFH]V[ UF0L pEL ZFB[,P tIF\ A[ KF[SZF
h5Fh5L SZTF CTF T[ ;FC[N[ 5F[TFGL UF0LDF\YL HF[I[,P V[DF\YL V[S
KF[SZF[ NF[0LG[ EFUL UI[,F[P ;FC[NGF 5]ZFJF VG];FZ T[VF[ tIF\YL VFU/
H. DFG;L ;S", H. I] 8G" DFZL 5FKF VF AGFJ JF/L HuIFV[ VFJ[,F[P
V[8,F ;DIDF\ 36F\ AWF\ ,F[SF[ VFH]AFH]YL NF[0L VFJ[,F CTFP VG[ !_(
56 VFJL UI[, 4 VG[ T[DF\ A\gG[ H6F\G[ CF[l:58,DF\ ,. UI[,P
tIFZAFN A[ 5F\R DLGL8DF\ 5F[,L; 56 AGFJGF :Y/[ VFJL UI[,LP
VFD ;FC[NGF p5ZF[ST
SFZ ;FC[NGL SFZG[ 0FAL AFH]V[ VFU/GF EFU[ S|[; SZL VFU/ GLS/L
UI[, CTLP p5ZF[ST CSLST[ VF\S *(G]\ 5\RGFD]4 V[8,[ S[ AGFJJF/L
HuIFG]\ 5\RGFDFGL CSLSTF[ wIFGDF\ ,.X\] T[F4 AGFJ :Y/ V[8,
[ S[ RFZ Z:TF 5F;[ V[S V[;[g8 SFZ HLH[v! S[ SI] v$)&_ 50[, CF[JFG]\
VG[ T[GF VFU/GF 0FAL AFH]GF jCL, 5F;[ V[S,L;F[8F[ 50[, CF[JFG]\
VG[ T[G[ Z]l5IF 5\NZYL JL; CHFZG\] G]S;FG YI[,FG\] H6FI K[P VFD4
TFZLB Z5qZqZ_!# GF ZF[H ZFT|LGF S,FS $q#_ YL 5q!5 NZdIFG
U]gCFJF/L HuIFG]\ 5\RGFD] SZJFDF\ VFJ[, K[ tIFZ[ T[ AGFJGF :Y/
GHLS H
V[;[g8 SFZ HLH[v!S[SI] $)&_ 50[, CF[JFG]\ VG[ ;FC[N CFHZ CF[JFG]\
VG[ SFZG[ VFU/GF 0FAL AFH]GF 8FIZ GF p5ZGF EFU[ ,L;F[8F[ 50[,FG\]
VG[ SFZG[ G]S;FG SZ[,FG]\ H6FJ[, K[PH[ 5]ZFJFYL ;FC[NGF p5ZFS[T
5]ZFJFG[ ;DY"G D/[ K[P T[ H ZLT[ OZLIFNLV[ TFZLB Z5qZqZ_!# GF ZF[H
CF[l:58,DF\ OZLIFN 5F[,L; Z]AZ]
95/273
$)
5F;[ 5CF[R,
[
tIFZ[ VG[ HF[I]\ TF[4 V[S AF.S O\UF[/F. 50[, CT]\ VG[ EF. ZF[0 p5Z
50[, CTL VG[ AC] ,F[CL GLS/[, CT]\ 4 ALHL V[S jIlST VF EF.YL
N;YL 5\NZ O]8GF V\TZ[ ZF[[0 p5Z 50[, CTLP ;FC[NGF 5]ZFJF VG];FZ
T[VF[V[ VFU/ H. 0FAL AFH]V[ UF0L pEL ZFB[,P tIF\ A[ KF[SZF
h5Fh5L SZTF CTF T[ ;FC[N[ 5F[TFGL UF0LDF\YL HF[I[,P V[DF\YL V[S
KF[SZF[ NF[0LG[ EFUL UI[,F[P VFD H[ V[S KF[SZF[ UF0L D]SL EFUL UI[,
tIFZAFN ;FC[N tIF\YL VFU/ DFG;L RFZ Z:TFYL 5ZT
AGFJ :Y/
jIlST ;FY[
h5Fh5L
SZTF[ CF[JFG]\ VG[ EFUL UI[, CF[JFG\] :5Q856[ O,LT YFI K[P;FC[NGF
p5ZF[ST
5]ZFJFGL
;FY[
;FY[
OZLIFNDF\
H6FJ[,
p5ZF[ST
CSLSTF[ wIFGDF\ ,.X]\ TF[4 SFZDF\YL pTZGFZ jIlST VG[ CF,GF OZLIFNL
JrR[ h5Fh5L YI[, VG[ SFZ RF,S tIF\YL EFUL UI[, CF[JFG]\ H6FI
K[P
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
96/273
5_
JW]DF\4
;FC[N
SZ[,L P VG[ ALHF A[ T|6 5F[,L;4 VD], 5F,"Z 5F;[ VFJ[, hF0 DF\
ALPV[DP 0A<I]
HF[I[,
G\AZ !! OZLIFNL
VG[ ;FC[N
T[DH
VS:DFT SZGFZ SFZ VD], 5F,"Z 5F;[GF hF0 ;FY[ VY0FI[,L VG[ tIF\
pEL ZC[,P H[ p5ZYL VS:DFT AFN SFZ GHLSDF\ H hF0 ;FY[ VY0F.
pEL ZC[, CF[.4 ;FC[NG[
:JFEFlJS ZLT[ DFGL XSFI VG[ T[ ZLT[ UF0LGF[ G\AZ SCL XS[ P T[YL
;FC[N[ VF UF0LGF[ G\AZ HF[I[, CF[JFGF[ 5]ZFJF[ lJxJ;GLI H6FI K[P
JW]DF\ VF\S *( GF 5\RGFDF D]HA 56 :Y/ p5Z D/L VFJ[, VS:DFT
JF/L UF0L GF[ G\AZ ;LV[RP _!vV[.v)#&_ CF[JFGF[ 5]ZFJF[ K[P VFD
CF,GF[ VS:DFT ALPV[DP0A<I] SFZ G\AZ ;LV[RPv_!vV[.v)#&_
YL YI[, CF[JFGF[ ;FC[N GF 5]ZFJFG[4 VF\S )5 GL OZLIFNDF\ H6FJ[,
CSLSTF[ T[DH VF\S *( GF
CSLSTF[YL ;DY"G D/[ K[P
97/273
YI[, GYLP ;FY[ ;FY[ ALPV[DP 0A<I]\ SFZ G\AZ ;LV[RP v_!vV[.v )
#&_ YL VS:DFT YI[,F[ H G CF[JFG]\ VG[ ALHF SF[. JFCG YL VS:DFT
YI[, CF[JFGF[ ARFJ 51FGF[ SF[. ARFJ GYLP VFD CF,GF VS:DFT
;NZ ALPV[DP 0A<I] SFZ ;LV[RP v_!vV[.v)#&_ YL YI[, CF[JFG]\
OZLIFN 51F lGoX\S56[ ;FlAT SZ[, K[P
5!
VG[ ;FC[NG[ ;FY[ ZFBL :Y/ p5Z 5F[,L;[ lGJ[NG ,LW[, P T[ JBT[ V[S
KF[SZF[ HTF[ ZC[,F[ VG[ T[YL 5F[,L;[ ;FC[NG]\ VG[ V[S KF[SZFG]\ lGJ[NG
,LW[, PH[G]\ GFD ,,LT U]%TF CT]\P tIFZAFN 5F[,L;[ ALPV[DP 0A<I]
SFZDF\ T5F; SZ[,L 5Z\T]\ SF\. D/[, GlCP
;FC[NGF[ p5ZF[ST
5]ZFJF[ wIFGDF\ ,[TF\ 5F[,L;[ ALPV[DP 0A<I] SFZGL T5F; SZ[, 5Z\T]\
T[ ;DI[
SFZGF[ 5FK/GF[ NZJFHF[ BF[,L HF[TF\ T[DF\YL UF0LG[ ,UTF SFU/F[ D/[,P
VFD SFZDF\YL SF\. D/L VFJ[, G CT\] T[D SCL XSFI GlCP
JW]DF\
;FC[N[ H6FJ[, K[S[4 5F[T[ RF,L; 5RF; DL8Z N]Z CTF VG[ VF AGFJ
tIF\YL
HF[I[,F[P
[,FPH[ AF.SG[
T[
H[DF\
AF.S
ALPV[DP 0,aI]
p5ZGF
UF0LV[
A[
KF[SZF
pK/
UF0L
98/273
ALPV[DP
0A<I]SFZGF
RF,SG[
5S0JFDF\
VFJ[,
tIFZ[
5F[,L; :8[XG DF\ BAZ 50[,LP H[G] GFD NLG[X RF{WZL CF[JFG\]\ HF6[,P
H[ GFD 56 ,,LT U]%TFV[
SFZGF RF,SG[
;FC[N
CF,GF VFZF[5LG[
TZLS[
VF[/BL
5]ZFJF[
wIFGDF\ ,[TF\
ALPV[DP0A<I]
ATFJ[,
K[P
VFD
SFZGF
CF,GF;FC[NGF[
RF,S
p5ZF[ST
CF,GF[ AGFJ AGTF[ HF[I[, CF[JFG]\ :5Q856 O,LT YFI K[P VG[ T[YL
AGFJ AgIF AFN
;FY[ VY0F. pEL ZC[, T[GF SFZ RF,S[ ACFZ GLS/L OZLIFNL 5F;
[ VFJ[, VG[ ;FC[N[ tIF\YL AGFJ :Y/[ 5CF[R[, CF[I T[ :JFEFlJS K[P
VG[ T[YL SFZ RF,SG[ HF[JFGL CF,GF ;FC[NG[ TS D/[, CF[JFG]\ DFGL
XSFIP V,AT CF,GF ;FC[NGF[ p5ZF[ST 5]ZFJF D]HA
CF,GF
5F;[GF hF0 ;FY[ VY0F. pEL ZC[, VG[ T[ AFN T[GF RF,S pTZL EFUL
UI[, CF[JFGF[ CF,GF ;FC[NGF[ 5]ZFJF[ lJxJ;GLI VG[ VFWFZE]T H6FI
K[P
5Z
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
99/273
[ KF[SZFG[ 5S0[, CTF[ T[GF[ OF[8F[ 56 KF5FDF\ VFJTF[ CTF[ VG[ 8LP JLPDF\
56 ATFJTF CTFPp5ZF[ST 5]ZFJFG[
wIFGDF\ ,[TF\
SFZ
XS[ GlCP VG[ T[JL jIlSTG[ VF[/BJFDF\ E], YTL C[FJFGL XSITF ZC[,
CF[JFG]\ DFGL XSFI T[D GYLP JW]DF\ CF,GF ;FC[N Z]AZ] SFZ RF,S CF,GF
VFZF[5LGL VF[/B SZFJJFDF\ VFJ[, G CF[JF DFT|YL VFZF[5LGL VF[/B
V\U[ ;FC[NGF[ 5]ZFJF[ lJxJ;GLI VG[ VFWFZE]T GYL T[J]\ SCL XSFI
GlCP
5#
XFC
;FC[NGF
ALhG[;
V[;F[;LI[8[0
K[P
VF
100/273
VFZP;LP A]S S[ JLDF 5F[,L;LGL GS, 5F[,L;[ ;FC[N 5F;[ SIFZ[I DF\U[, G
CTLP JW]D\F ;FC[NGF p,8T5F;GF 5]ZFJF VG];FZ V[;[g8 SFZG[F DF,LS
;FC[N G C[FJFGL CSLST ;FC[N[ 5F[,L;G[ H6FJ[, CTLP JW]DF\ ;FC[NGF
5]ZFJF VG];FZ V[;[g8 SFZGF DF,LS ;\NL5EF. XFC K[ T[JL CSLST
;FC[N[ 5F[,L;G[ H6FJ[, G CTLP ;\NL5EF. XFC AF[5, sVDNFJFNf
GF ZCLX K[P ;\NL5EF. AGFJ VUFp V[S
CTF VG[ VFH[ 56
ALPV[DP 0A<I] SFZ[ T[VF[GL V[;[g8 SFZG[ 8SZFJL 0FAL AFH]V[ Ad5Z S|
[; SZ[, CF[JFGL CSLST BF[8L H6FJ[ K[ P JW]DF\ ;FC[NGF p,8T5F;GF
5]ZFJFDF\ H6FJ[, K[ S[4 H[ :Y/[ V[;[g8 SFZ GF Ad5ZG[ S|[; S[Z,
T[ RF[SS; HuIF ATFJJF 5F[,L;[ ;FC[NG[ SC[,]\P5Z\T]\ T[ :Y/JF/L
HuIFV[ SF[. 5\RGFD]\
:Y/[ SIF\YL VG[ SF[G[ D/LG[ VFJTF[ CTF[ T[ 5F[,L;[ ;FC[NG[ 5]K[, VG[
;FC[N[ T[ CSLST 5F[,L;G[ H6FJ[, 56 CTLPJW]DF\ ;FC[NGF 5]ZFJF
VG];FZ ;FC[N T[ ;DI[ VXF[S 5FG CFp;[ 5FG BFJF UI[, CTFPVF
VXF[S 5FG CFp;YL ;FC[NGF ZC[9F6 VFXZ[ VF9[S lS,F[DL8Z N]Z VFJ[,
K[PVFD p5ZF[ST CSLST wIFGDF\ ,[TF\ ;FC[N AGFJ :Y/[ CFHZ CF[JF
V\U[ S[ T[VF[GL SFZG[ ALPV[DP 0A<I] SFZ[ 0FAL AFH]V[ S|[; SZ[,
CF[JFGLCSLST[ X\SF p5l:YT Y. XS[ T[JL SF[. CSLST ARFJ 51F Z[S0"
p5Z ,FJL XS[, GYLP
5$P
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
101/273
H6FJ[, K[ S[4 ALPV[DP 0A<I]\ SFZGF RF,SG[ ZFT|[ :Y/ p5Z HF[I[,
CF[JFGL CSLST 5F[,L;G[ H6FJ[, CTL 5Z\T]\
T[ BAZ GYLP T[ H ZLT[
;FC[N[
5F[,L;[
,B[, S[ S[D
GF[ 5]ZFJF[ wIFGDF\ ,.X]\ TF[4 :JLSFZ[, K[ S[4 ;FC[N DLT[X lSZ6S]DFZ
XFC[ TFZLB Z5qZqZ_!# GF ZF[H lGJ[NGDF\ V[J]\ ,BFJ[, G CT] S[ cc C]\
RF,L; 5RF; O]8 N]Z CTF[ VG[ VF AGFJ D[ tIF\YL HFI[[, cc T[DH cc
ALPV[DP 0A<I] SFZGF RF,SG[ D[ ZFT|[ T[ :Y/ p5Z HF[I[,F[Pcc VFD
CF,GF ;FC[N G\AZ !# GF V[ RF,L; 5RF; O]8
N]ZYL AGFJ
HF[I[,F[ CF[JFGL CSLST[ lJZF[WFEF; ARFJ 51F ;FlAT SZ[, K[P 5Z\T]\
T[8,F DFT|YL CF,GF VS:DFTGF[ AGFJ AG[, CF[JFGL CSLST VG[ SFZ
RF,S SFZDF\YL EFUL UI[, CF[JFGL CSLST[ CF,GF ;FC[NGF 5]ZFJF p5Z
X\SF
SZL
XSFI
T[D
GYLP
SFZ6
S[
CF,GF
AGFJ
AFN
102/273
S[ :Y/ p5Z H SFZ RF,S CFHZ D/L VFJ[, CF[I T[JF[ S[F. 5]ZFJF[ GYLP T[
;\HF[UF[DF\ SFZRF,S SFZ D]SLG[ EFUL UI[, CF[JFGL CSLST[ T|6[
;FC[NF[GF[ 5]ZFJF[ lJxJ;GLI VG[ VFWFZE]T H6FI K[P
55
VUFp RRF" SIF" D]HA VG[ OZLIFN 51F[ ZH] YI[, VF\S (5 GF
5\RGFDF\ H6FJ[, CSLSTF[ T[DH ;FC[N G\AZ !_ GF[ HLT]EF. KUGEF.
GFIL
S[
Z*qZ qZ_!# GF
ZF[H ;F\HGF 5qZ_ JFU[ CF,GF VFZF[5L GL XFlZZLS T5F; DF8[ 5F[,L;
IFNL ;FY[ V[PV[;PVF.P EUJFGEF. APG\P &!!( GF VF[ ,. VFJ[,F
CTFP OZLIFN 51F[ T[ IFNL VF\S !Z# YL ZH] YI[, K[P
55P!
D[0LS,
VF[lO;ZzLV[
V\U[ lC:8=L 5]K[,4 T[F T[6[ H6FJ[, S[4 cc T[G[ Z[F0 VS;L0g8 T[GL SFZ
ALPV[DP 0A<I]]
H[
lC:8=L
D[0LS,
VF[lO;Z[ S[; 5[5;" DF\ GF[WL ,LW[,P VFD CF,GF VFZF[5LV[ D[0LS,
VF[lO;Z ;D1F 5F[TFG[ YI[, .HFVF[ V\U[ H[ CSLST HFC[Z SZ[, T[ D]HA
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
103/273
5lZ6FD ;FY[ SF[. lG:AT GYL P ;FY[ ;FY[ D[0LS, VF[lO;ZG[ CF,GF
VFZF[5L 5|tI[ S[F. jN[QFEFJ S[ V6AGFJ CF[I
lJZ]wW BF[8F[ 5]ZFJF[ pEF[ SZJF DF8[ RF[SS; SF[. SFZ6 CF[I T[JL CSLST
ARFJ 51F Z[S0" p5Z ,FJL XS[, GYLP T[JF ;\HF[UF[DF\ D[0LS, VF[lO;ZGF[
5]ZFJF[ GlC DFGJFG[ S[F. SFZ6 GYLP
55PZ
V[A|[hG CT]\]P
H[GL p5Z Z[0L; A|FpG S,ZGF[ :S[A CTF[P T[G[ U/FGF 5FK/GF
EFU[ N]BFJFGL OZLIFN CTL 5Z\T
\ ] SF[. .HFGF lGXFG H6FIF G
CTFPD[0LS, VF[lO;ZGF p5ZF[ST 5]ZFJFG[ wIFGDF\ ,[TF\ VFZF[5LGF XZLZ
p5Z .HFVF[GF lGXFG CTF4 VFZF[5LG[ V[ZA[U .d5[S8 GF SFZ6[ KFTL
p5Z N]BFJF[ YTF[ CTF[
N]BFJFGL OZLIFN
VG[ T[ H ZLT[
CTLP VFD
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
104/273
;JF"S.S, :5F.GGF
VF5[, CF[. T[JF 5]ZFJFYL CF,GF VFZF[5LG[ YI[, .HFVF[ VG[ VF5JFDF\
VFJ[, ;FZJFZ AFATGF 5]ZFJFDF\ SF[. OS" 50TF[ GYLP VG[ T[8,F DFT|YL
D[0LS, VF[lO;ZG[F p5ZF[ST 5]ZFJF[ lJxJ;GLI VG[ VFWFZE]T
a,0 ;[d5, ,LW]\ CT]\P H[G[ ;L, SZLG[ V[OPV[;PV[,P DF[S,L VF5[, CT]\P]
D[0LS, VF[lO;ZGF p5ZF[ST 5]ZFJFGF ;DY"GDF\ OZLIFN 51F[ VF\S !Z$
YL VF5[, ;8L"OLS[8 T[DH VF\S !Z5 YL S[; 5[5;" ZH] SZ[, K[P H[DF\
H6FJ[, CSLSTF[ wiFFGDF\ ,[TF\ p5ZF[ST 5]ZFJFG[ ;DY"G D/[ K[P
5&
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
105/273
VFJ[,P
5q#_JFU[
VFD
4TFPZ*qZqZ_!#
GF
ZF[H
;F\HGF
AFN VFZF[5LGF
5(
VG[ T[VF[V[ T5F;[,F tIFZ[ 5F[,L; 56 tIF\ CFHZ CTLP VFD VFZF[5LGL
TALAL T5F; D[0LS, VF[lO;Z[ 5F[,L;GL CFHZLDF\ SZ[, CF[JFG\] O,LT
YFI K[P JW]DF\ D[0LS, VF[lO;Z[ V[ CSLST :JLSFZ[, K[S[4 VF\S !Z5
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
106/273
H[
lC:8=L ,B[,
K[ T[ VFZF[5LV[ H HFT[ VF5[, CF[I T[JF[ SF[. :5Q8 p<,[B[ T[DF\ SZ[, GYLP
V[ JFTBZL K[ S[ VFZF[5LG[ ZF[0 V[S;L0g8DF\ .HF YIF CF[JFGL VFZF[5L V[
H H6FJ[, CF[I T[JF[ p<,[B ;FC[N[ ,B[, lC:8=LDF\ SZ[, GYLP VFD
D[0LS, VF[lO;ZGF H6FjIF D]HA CL:8=L VFZF[5LV[ HFT[ VF5[, CF[JFG]\
VG[ ZF[0 V[S;L0g8DF\ VFZF[5LG[ .HFVF[ YI[,
CF[JFGL CSLST
ARFJ 51F[ SZ[, K[P 5Z\T]\ p5ZF[ST CSLST[ D[0LS, VF[lO;ZGL p,8T5F;
NZdIFGGF
5]ZFJFG[
wiFFGDF\
,[TF\4
VFJF[
cc
XaNcc
XS[, GYLP V,AT VFJF[ pDZF[ S[ V[ZF[ SZLG[ p5ZF[ST XaN pD[ZJFDF\
VFJ[, CF[I tIF\ D[0LS, VF[lO;ZGL ;CL SZ[, G C[FJFG]\ H6FI K[P 5Z\T]
T[8,F DFT|YL D[0LS, VF[lO;Z[ 5F[T[ S[; 5[5;" DF\ 5FK/YL ;]WFZF[ SZL
GJL SF[. CSLST pD[ZJF 5|ItG SZ[, CF[I T[J]\ DFGL XSFI GlC PJ/L T[J]\
ATFJJF ARFJ 51F SF[. CSLST Z[S0" p5Z ,FJL XS[, GYLP
&_
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
107/273
AFH]V[ VFJ[, ;L8DF\ H[ SF[. jIlST A[9[, CF[I TF[ T[DG[ 56 VFJL
.HFVF[ YJFGL XSITF ZC[,L K[P ;FY[ ;FY[ V[ CSLST 56 :JLSFZ[,
K[ S[4 Z[0L; A|FpG .gHZL
;\DT
XaN 5FK/YL pD[ZL ;]WFZF[ SZJFGF[ 5|ItG D[0LS, VF[lO;Z[ SZ[, CF[I
T[JL SF[. CSLST ARFJ 51F Z[S0" p5Z ,FJL XS[, GYLP VG[ T[YL
VFZF[5LG[ YI[, .HFVF[ Z[0L; A|FpG CF[JFG]\ D[0LS, VF[lO;Z GF ;DU|
5]ZFJFYL ;FlAT YFI K[P
&!
;FC[N G\AZ !!
GF 5]ZFJF D]HA
TFZLB
T[VF[GF
VFJ[,F[PVG[
EF.
T[VF[V[
IF[U[XEF.
SC[,
NJ[GF[
S[4XLJDG[
OF[G
VS:DFT
;FC[N
p5Z
YI[,F[
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
K[P
108/273
VG[ T[G[ JFU[, K[P ;\HLJGL CF[l:58, VFJJF SC[,P ;FC[N ;\HLJGL
CF[l:58, UI[,P HIF\ VF.P;LPI] PDF\YL XLJDG[ :8[=RZ p5Z ACFZ ,FJTF
CTF VG[ S50\] VF[-F0[, CT]P VG[ tIF\ CFHZ DF6;F[V[ H6FJ[, S[ VF
TF[ D'tI]\ 5FD[, K[ P T[ JBT[ CF[l:58,DF\ ;FC[NGF EF. IF[U[X NJ[4
,,LT U]%TF4 VG[ lNG[X RF{WZL VG[ ALHF DF6;F[ 56 CFHZ CTFP
JW]DF\ ;FC[N[ CF[l:58,DF\ CFHZ ,,LT U]%TF VG[ lNG[X RF{WZLG[ 5]K[,
S[4 VF S[JL ZLT[ AG[, TF[ ,,LT U]%TF V[ ;FC[NG[ H6FJ[, S[4 cc GF,\NF
SF[d5,[1F YL T[ TYF NLG[X RF{WZL VG[ ZFC], TYF XLJD T[VF[GF 3Z TZO
J:T|F5]Z AFH] VFJTF CTF tIFZ[ 5|[DR\NGUZ S|F[; ZF[0 YL ,F0 ;F[;FI8L
TZO J/[, tIFZ[ V[S SFZ[ AF.S ZFC], R,FJTF[ CTF[ VG[ 5FK/ XLJD
A[9[, CTF[ T[G[ 8SSZ DFZ[,L VG[ A\gG[ H6F\
AF.S
p5ZYL
JW]\DF\4
JW]DF\
109/273
;FC[N[ AGFJ GHZ[ HF[I[, G CF[JFG]\ O,LT YFI K[P ;FY[ ;FY[ VS:DFTDF\
;\0F[JFI[, ALPV[DP 0A<I] SFZ SF[GL DF,LSL GL K[ T[ AFAT[ 5F[,L;
DFZOT[ HF6JF D/[, S[ T[ SFZ lJ:DI XFCGL CTLP VG[ T[ 5F[,L;
[
VFZF[5LG[
V8S
SZTF\
HF6JF
D/[,
CT]P
JW]DF\
CF,GF
VFZF[5LGF OF[8F
CF,GF AGFJDF\
K[S[ tIF\ ,,LT U]%TF 4 NLG[X RF{WZL VG[ ALHF 5a,LSGF DF6;F[ CFHZ
CTFP ;FC[NG[ ZFC],GL ;FZJFZ RF,TL CTL tIF\ ,. UI[,FP T[ ;DI[ ZFC],
EFGDF\ G CTF[ ;FC[N[ ZFC],GF[ RC[ZF[ HFI[, CTF[P VG[ ;FZJFZ RF,] CTL
T[YL ;FC[NG[ ACFZ DF[S,L NLW[, CTFP
110/273
&$
5|;FZ6 YI[, T[YL ;FC[N lJ:DI XFCG[ VF[/BTF YI[,P ;FC[N S[F8"
Z]AZ] VFZF[5LG[ V[F/BL ATFJ[, K[P
&5
&&
HGZ, D[G[HZ TZLS[ 5;F{",L DF[8;" DF\ OZH AHJFTF CTF4 CF, T[VF[
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
111/273
tIFZAFN
J:T|F5]Z
VG[
EFZTDF\
VFJ[ K[
112/273
D]HA
lS,F[DL8Z 5|lT S,FSGL h05 CTLP H[ SFI"JFCL SZ[, T[G\] DF[AF., p5Z
JL0LIF[Z[SF[0L"U SZ[, VG[ T[ AFN T[GL ;L0L AGFJL 5F[,L;G[ VF5[,
CTLP
&)
p5Z VG[ V[S :8[IZLU p5Z TYF A[ ;F.0[ VFU/ GF EFU[ VG[ AFSLGL
A[ V,U V,U 0FAL AFH] VG[ HD6L AFH]V[ O|g8 ;F.0[ VFJ[ K[P JW]DF\
;FC[NGF 5]ZFJF VG];FZ V[ZA[U S|[; ;[g;Z p5Z SFD SZTL CF[I K[P
VG[ S|[; ;[g;Z .d5[S8 VG[ :5L0 p5Z SFD SZ[ K[P ;FC[N[GF H6FjIF
D]HA H[8,L JWFZ[ .d5[S8 CF[I4 S[ H[8,L JWFZ[ :5L0 CF[I TF[4 V[8,L
V[ZA[U B],[ VG[ VF[KL :5L0 TYF WLDL .d5[S8 CF[I TF[ V[ZA[U
WLD[ B],[ K[P V[ZA[U S|[; ;[g;Z O|g8 DF\ ,FU[,F C[FI K[P VG[ V[ZA[U
JFCGRF,S VG[ 5[;[gHZGL ;[O8L DF8[ ZFBJFDDF\ VFJ[, CF[I K[P
*_
SFZ
T[VF[GF
VG];FZ
lJ:DI
VDLTEF.
XFCGF
113/273
*_P!
*_PZ
SZL
114/273
UF0LGF
jIJ;FIYL T[VF[ AFZ JZ;YL ;\S/FI[,F K[P VG[ OF[8F p5ZYL 8FIZGF
A|[S DFS" K[ S[ S[D T[JF[ SF[. VlE5|FI ;FC[N[ SF[. S[;DF\ VF5[,F[ GYLP
VG[VFJF[ VlE5|FI SF[. VlWSFZLV[ VF5[, C[FI TF[ T[VF[G[ HF6SFZL
GYLP JW]DF\ VFJF[ S[F. VlE5|FI VF5JF DF8[ ;FC[N SF[.G[ E,FD6
SZTF GYLP
*Z
TFP!q#qZ_!#
TFP!q#qZ_!#
GF ZF[H
115/273
JW]DF\
;FC[N[
H6FJ[,
K[
S[4
VF\S
!##
JF/L
T[ ;LP0LP
OF[8F H[JF
;LP0L D]HA
p5Z
N=lQ85FT YTF\ N=xIF[ D]HA HIFZ[ 0[DF[ SFZ !*#Z VFZV[D5L p5Z CTL
tIFZ[ SIF[ ULIZ CTF[ T[ N=lQ85FT YTF[ G CTF[ ;FC[N[ JW]DF\ H6FJ[, K[S[4
VF 0[DF[ SFZ 5F[T[ R,FJTF CTF VG[ AFH]DF\ T[V[FGL VF[lO;GF ZLDFA[G
A[9F CTFP JW]DF\ ;FC[N[ H6FJ[, K[ S[4 0[DF[ SFZGL SFDULZL
V[S;5|[ J[
;FC[N[ JW]DF\ H6FJ[, K[[ S[4R-TF -F[/FJ p5Z SFZ HTL C[FI
TF[ VFZV[D5L
CSLST :JLSFZ[, K[ S[4 SF[. SFZ6;Z SFZ V8SL HFI VG[ T[ ;DI[ 5U
V[S;L,[8Z p5Z CF[I VG[ V[S;L,[8Z NAF. HFI TF[ VFZPV[DP5LP JWFZ[
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
116/273
CF[. XS[P
*$PZ
*$P#
VD[ H[
wIFGDF\ ,[TF\
T[VF[V[ 0[DF[ SFZ ,. V[S;5|[ CF.J[ p5Z S[8,F VFZPV[DP5LP p5Z UF0LGL
h05 S[8,L CF[I T[ V\U[ HFT[ UF0L R,FJLG[ 8[:8 SZ[, CTF[ VG[ T[YL
;FC[NGF[ 5]ZFJF[ GlC DFGJFG[ SF[. SFZ6 GYLP JW]DF\ ;FC[NGF 5]ZFJFG[
VF\S !#Z YL ZH] YI[, T[VF[GF ZL5[F8"DF\ H6FJ[, CSLSTF[YL ;DY"G D/
[ K[P
*5
117/273
lGIFDS zL
p5ZF[ST D]NFDF,
5F;",G[ BF[,LG[ HF[TF\ T[DF\ V[S O|g8[S S\5GLGL AGFJ8GL TYF *__
V[DPALP GL S[5[;L8L WZFJTL V[S ;LP0LP CTLP H[G[ ZJFGUL GF[WDF\ DFS"
vV[cv VF5L J6"J[, VG[ lJEFUDF\
VF[/BFJ[,P ;NZC]\ GD]GF V[
GD]GF[ v V[ v VF5L
CTLP
;[Sg0G]\
V\U[G]\
5'yYSSZ6
SZJFDF\
VFJ[,
CT\]P
JW]DF\
VFJTL DF[8Z SFZ VG[ 8]jCL,ZG[ VY0FTL SFZGL J[,F[;L8L G]\ DF5G
SZJFDF\ VFJ[,P
V[ DF8[
5F[, ;]WLG]\ V\TZ DF5L T[DH JL0LIF[ OF.,GL O|[D Z[8G[ wIFG[ ,. SZJFDF\
VFJ[,P JW]DF\ ;FC[NGF 5]ZFJF VG];FZ 0LJF.0Z V[g0YL JrR[GF OLS;
5F[,G]\ DF5G SZJFYL
T[DH
;NZC]
p5Z
118/273
[,PVFSFDULZL lNJ;GF
S,FS
NZdIFG SZ[,P JW]DF\ ;FC[N[ H6FJ[, K[ S[4 p5ZF[ST 5wWlT jNFZF D/TL
h05
JFCGGL
JF:TJLS
h05
;FY[
D/TL
VFJTL
CF[JFG]\
5]ZFJFGF ;DY"GDF\ VF\S !$$ YL ZH] YI[, ZL5F[8" TYF H[ JL0LIF[ O|[D
S[%RZ SZ[, CTL T[ JL0LIF[ O|[D VG]S|D[ !_(4 !$5 VG[!$& YL ZH]
YI[, K[P VFD VF\S !$$ GF[ ZL5F[8" wiFG[ ,[TF\ ;FC[NGF 5]ZFJFG[ ;DY"G
D/[ K[P
*5P!
JW]DF\ ;FC[N[ H6FJ[, K[S[4 VFJ]\ JFCG ZF[[0 p5Z 5_ 5|lT S,FS
SL,F[DL8ZGL h05[ R,FJ[, VG[ H[ Z[SF[0L"U YI[, T[ VFWFZ[ GD]GF
V[ JF/L ;LP0LPDF\ AGFJJF/F N=\xIF[ Z[S0" YI[,F CTF T[ JL0LIF[ O|[D
p5ZYL VS:DFT JF/F JFCGGL VS:DFT ;DI[ S[8,L h05 CTL
T[ V\U[ 5F[TFGF[ VlE5|FI VF5[, K[ T[ GlC DFGJFG[ SF[. SFZ6 GYLP
JW]DF\ ;FC[N[ H6FJ[, K[S[4 VF SFZ jNFZF VS:DFT 5C[,F \SF[. A|[S
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
119/273
p5ZF[ST
;FC[N
ARFJ
51F[
SZ[,
p,8T5F;
NZdIFG
VG[ ;FC[N[
5F[TFGL
5'yYSSZ6GF
JW]DF\
H6FJ[,
K[
S[
T[VF[GL
SFDULZL
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
GL
120/273
lJUTF[ VG[ H[ OF.g0LU p5Z VFJ[,F T[GF SFZ6F[GL GF[W T[VF[GF 5F;
[ K[P JW]DF\ ;FC[NGF 5]ZFJF VG];FZ T[JL T[VF[GF 5F;[GL lJUTF[ ;FC[N[
VFHNLG ;]WL 5F[,L;G[ VF5[, GYL VG[ 5F[,L;[ ;FC[N 5F;[ DF\U[, G
CTLP JW]DF\ ;FC[N[ :JLSFZ[, K[ S[ VFJL lJUTF[ V,UYL 5F[TFGL 5F;
[ ZFB[, CF[JFGL GF[W VF\S !$$ GF ZL5F[8"DF\ SZ[, GYLP ;FC[N[ JW]DF\
H6FJ[, K[ S[ VF\S !$$4!$54 VG[ VF\S !$& JF/F SFU/F[ l;JFIG]\
H[ SF\. Z[S0" T{IFZ SZ[, CT]\ T[ 5F[,L;G[ VF5[, G CT]\ VG[ 5F[,L;[ T[J]\
SF[. Z[S0" ;FC[N 5F;[ DF\U[, 56 G CT\]PD]NFDF, ;LP0LP l;JFI VgiF
S[F. ;LP0LP 5F[,L;G[ VF5[, G CTLP
HL%;LSFZ JF/L
DF6;F[
56
CFHZ
CTFP
VF
0[DF[:8[=XGGL
SFDULZL
T[VF[GF
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
121/273
C T]\P
**PZ
5ZJFGUL D[/J[, CTL S[ S[D T[GL ;FC[NG[ BAZ G CTLP VFJL SFDLULZL
SZJF V\U[ HZ]ZL SFI"JFCL 5]ZL SZL ,[JFGL ;FC[N[ 5F[P.P J:T|F5]ZG[ SF[.
HF6 SZ[, G CTLP JW]DF\ ;FC[NGF H6FjIF D]HA 0[DF[:8[=XG JBT[ ;FC[N
HL%;LDF\ A[9F[ VG[ HL%;LDF\YL pTIF" V[ ;DIUF/F[ VFXZ[ V0WFYL
5F[6F S,FSGF[ YI[,P JW]DF\ ;FC[N[ H6FJ[, K[ S[4 HL%;LSFZGF
0[DF[:8[=XGGL SFDULZL V\U[GL
lJUTGF[ p<,[B
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
122/273
VF
;FC[N[ V[ CSLSTGF[ .gSFZ SZ[,F[ K[ S[4 DFS " s!f VG[ DFS" sZf JrR[ G]\
V\TZ !5 DL8Z CF[JFGL CSLST BF[8L H6FJ[ K[ ;FC[N[ V[ CSLSTGF[
.gSFZ SZ[,F[ K[ S[ DFS" s!f VG[ DFS" sZf JrR[G]\ V\TZ !5 DL8Z SZTF\
56 VF[K]\ \ CT]\PJW]DF\ ;FC[N[ V[ CSLST GF[ 56 .gSFZ SZ[,F[ K[ S[
DFS"
s! f VG[ DFS" sZf JrR[G]\ V\TZ !5 DL8Z SZTF\ VF[K\ ] CF[I TF[ UF0LGL :
5L0
56 DFS"s!f
0LJF.0Z
VG[ 5F[, ZFB[,F CTFP JW]DF\ ;FC[NGF H6FjIF D]HA JL0LIF[ ;LP0LP
HF[TF\ VF SFZ jNFZF VS:DFT 5C[,F\ SF[. A|[S DFZ[, CF[I T[JF SF[.
lRCGF[ HF[JF D/[, G CTFP
SF[. 5|
xGF[TZL SZJFDF\ VFJ[, G CTL VG[ T[YL ZL5F[8"DF\ T[JL CSLSTGF[ p<,[B
SZJFGL HZ]Z H6FI[, G CTLP JW]DF\ ;FC[NGF 5]ZFJF VG];FZ
A|[S
123/273
S[ AFZ O|[DF[G[ 8F.D ,F.G p5Z D]SL HF[TF\ JFCGGL :5L0DF\ SF[. GF[W
5FT| 38F0F[ HF[JF D/[, G CTF[ P ;FC[N[ V[ CSLST :JLSFZ[, K[ S[ SF[.
JFCGG[ A|[S DFZJFDF\ VFJ[ tIFZ[ JFCGGL 5FK/GL AFH]\V[ A|[S ,F.8
YFI K[ VG[ T[ ,F, C[FI K[P
*)
;FC[N[ V[ CSLST :JLSFZ[, K[S[ DFS" s!f VG[ DFS" sZf JrR[G]\ V\TZ
OLhLS,L DF5[, S[
ZL5[F8"DF\ SZ[, GYLP T[DH DFS" ! VG[ DFS" Z JrR[G]\ V\TZ ;LP0LPp5ZYL
GSSL Y. XS[ JW]DF\ ;FC[N H6FJ[ K[ S[ JrR[ HF[ SF[. GF[GVF[AH[S8
VFJTF[ CF[I VG[ T[J]\ DF5 VF56L 5F;[ C[FI TF[ H VFJ]\ V\TZG]\ DF5
GLS/L XS[P ;FC[N[ JW]DF\ H6FJ[, K[ S[ VFJ]\ DF5 SF-JF DF8[ ,FH"Z
0L:8g; VG[ ,FH"Z 8F.D CF[I TF[ JW]\ RF[SS; ZLT[ DF5 SF-L XSFIP;FC[N[
V[ CSLST :JLSFZ[, K[S[4 D]NFDF, DFS" V[ JF/L ;LP0LP DF\ ,FH"Z
0L:8g; VG[ ,FH"Z 8F.D JF/L AFAT VFJTL GYLP
(_
J8FJLG[
V[8,
[ S[ OZLG[ HJ]\ 50[P ;FC[N H6FJ[ K[ S[ 4 ,L,]\ ;LuG, RF,] CF[I tIFZ[ ;S",
OZLG[ G H.V[ TF[ RF,[ PVF S[;GF C[T]YL AGFJGF :Y/[ UI[,F[ tIFZ[ tIF\
VFJF SF[. ;LuG, GL O[;[,L8L G CTLP VS:DFTGF lNJ;[ VF ;LuG,GL
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
124/273
O[;[,L8L CTL S[ S[D T[ V\U[ 5F[,L;G[ 5]K[, G CT]P JW]DF\ ;FC[NGF 5]ZFJF
VG];FZ T[VF[V[
D[F8Z ;FIS, 8=FOLSGF lGID D]HA ;S", J8FJLG[ J/[, G CT]P ;LP0LP
HF[IF D]HA DF[8Z ;FIS, R,FJGFZ VG[ 5FK/ A[9[,[ jIlST V[ C[<D[8
5C[Z[, CTL S[ S[D T[ wIFGD\F VFJ[, G CT]\P VF D[F8Z ;FIS,JF/F ;S",
J8FJLG[ J/[, CF[T TF[ VFXZ[ S[8,F[ ;DI YFT T[ ;FC[N SCL XS[ GlC
JW]DF\ ;FC[NGF 5]ZFJF VG];FZ 4 DF[8Z ;FIS, ;S", J8FJL G[ J/[, CF[T
TF[ S[8,F[ ;DI YFT T[ GSSL SZJFG]\ HZ]ZL H6FI[, G CT]P
H[ HuIFV[ OF[ZjCL,Z VG[ 8]
VG[
DFS"s!fJF/F
0FAL
0LJF.0Z
TYF
T[
:Y/
DFS"sZf
JF/F[ JrR[GF[ OLS; 5F[, JrR[ S[8,]\ V\TZ CT]\ T[ DF5[, G CT]P T[DH4
UF\9LIF ZYJF/F ;L;L8LJL S[D[ZF YL VS:DFTJF/F :5F[8 JrR[G]\ V\TZ
56 DF5[, G CT]\P JW]DF\ ;FC[NGF 5]ZFJF VG];FZ SF[. JFCGGL :5L0
DF5JL CF[I TF[ :SL0DFS"YL4 Z0FZYL VG[ .gO|FZ[0 lSZ6F[GL ;L:8DYL
56 DF5L XSFIP JW]DF\ HIFZ[ HL%;LSFZYL 0[DF[:8[=XG SZ[, tIFZ[4
HF[ VS:DFTJF/]\ DF[8Z ;F.S, :Y/ p5ZG]\ ;S", J8FJLG[ J/[, CF[T TF[
4!!Z lS,F[DL8ZGL h05[ VFJTL SFZ 5;FZ Y. UI[, CF[T T[J]\ SF[.
0[DF[:8[=XG SZJFGL HZ]Z
0LJF.0Z 5F;[YL
J/JFGL HuIF VG[ ;S", J8FJLG[ UI[, CF[T TF[ T[ HuIF JrR[G\] V\TZ
56 DF5[, G CT]\ VG[ T[JL SF[. HZ]ZLIFT H6FI[, G CTLP ;FC[NGF JW]
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
125/273
5]ZFJF VG];FZ S], !Z JL0LIF[ O|[D p5Z VFWFZ ZFB[,F[ CTF[P H[ 5{SLGL
V[S JL0LIF[ O|[D
O|[DF[ 5F[,L;G[ VF5[,L G CTLP;FC[NGF JW] 5]ZFJF VG];FZ HF[ DFS" s!f
VG[ DFS" sZfJrR[G]\
V\TZ !5 DL8ZGF
lS,F[DL8Z
5|lTS,FS CF[IP
JW]DF\ ;FC[NGF 5]ZFJF VG];FZ VF\S !$& DF\ 0FAL AFH]V[ H[ 5|YD O|[D K[
T[ O|[D D]NFDF, GD]GFJF/L ;LP0LP 0L;%,[ SZTF\ O|[D G\AZs!f K[ VG[ T[
HF[TF\ T[DF\ 0FAL AFH]V[ SF[. 0LJF.0Z CF[I T[J]\ H6FT]] GYLP O|[D G\AZsZf
DF\ VS:DFTJF/L SFZ GF[ 5FK/GF[ EFU N[BFTF[ H GYL4 HIFZ[ VFU/GF
EFUGL ,F.8 RF,] CF[JFG]\ H6FI K[P 5|YD 5F\R O|[D HF[TF\ T[DF\
VS:DFTJF/L SFZGF[ 5FK/GF[ EFU N[BFTF[ G CF[. 4 5FK/GF
EFU[ SF[. ,F, ,F.8GF[ X[0 N[BFI K[ S[ S[D T[
G\AZs&f DF\ SFZGF[ 5FK/GF[ EFU N[BFI K[ VG[ 5FK/ ,F.8 RF,]
CF[JFG\]\ H6FI K[P;FC[N[ V[ CSLSTGF[ .gSFZ SZ[,F[ K[ S[ O|[D G\AZs&f DF\
5FK/ H[ ,F.8 RF,] CF[JFG]\ H6FI K[ T[ ,F.8GF[ X[0 VFKF[ ,F, K[P
JW]DF\ ;FC[NGF H6FjIF D]HA O|[D G\AZs*f DF\ 5FK/ H[ ,F.8 RF,]
K[ T[GF[ X[0 ,F, S,ZGF[ C[FJFG]\ H6FI K[P VG[ O|[D G\AZs(f DF\ T[
,F.8GF[ X[0 JW] ,F, YI[, C[FJFG]\ H6FI K[P O|[D G\AZs)f DF\ SFZGL
5FK/GF[ ,F.8GF[ X[0 O|[D G\AZs(f DF\ H6FI K[ T[GFYL VFKF[ ,F,
CF[JFG]\ H6FI K[P V[ JFT BZL K[S[ VF ;LP0LP DF\ P O|[D G\AZs!Z f
5KLGL O|[D G\AZs!$ f HF[TF\ H[DF\ 56 SFZGF 5FK/GF EFU[ ,F, ,F.8
N[BFI K[P T[ H ZLT[ O|[D G\AZs!5fYLs!(f;]WLGL O|[DF[DF\ 56 SFZGL
5FK/GL ,F.8GF[ ,F, X[0 N[BFI K[P VFD p5ZF[ST 5]ZFJF[ wIFGDF\ ,[TF\
AGFJ ;DI[ SFZGF[ 5FK/GL ,F8 RF,] CF[JFGF[ VG[ T[GF[ X[[0 ,F, CF[.
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
126/273
58[,
GF VF\S
G\A Z !(
T[DH
U]|5LU VG[ D[RL\U DF8[ VgI a,0 ;[d5, ,LW]\ CT]PVFD4 D[0LS,
VF[lO;ZzL V[ VFZF[5LGL XFlZZLS T5F; JBT[ ,F[CLGF GD]GF ,LW[, CTF
P p5ZF[ST 5]ZFJFGL ;FY[ ;FY[ OZLIFN 51F[ ZH] S[Z, VF\S 5! GF 5\RGFDF
G[ wIFG[ ,.X]\ TF[4 D[0LS, VF[lO;Z[ ,LW[, VFZF[5LGF ,F[CLGF A[ GD]GF
VFZF[5LV[ ,. HGFZ EUJFGEF.
GFVF[ V[ T[VF[V[ ,F[CLGF A[ GD]GF 5F[P:8[P DF\ 5\RF[GL CFHZLDF\ ZH] SZ[,P
H[ 5\RGFDFGL Z]V[ SAH[ SZ[,P H[ 5\RGFDFGF 5\R ;FC[N
HI\l TEF.
G8]E F.
G\A Z )
5]ZFJF D]HA
H[ ,F[CLGF GD]GF
T[ 5{SL V[S GD]GFG]\
127/273
,[JFDF\
VFJ[, CF[JFGF[ 5]ZFJF[ K[P V,AT T[JF 5\RGFDFGF 5\R ;FC[N G\A Z (
;]Z [X EF. 0FCIFEF. lT|J [N LV[ VF\S (& YL ;F[U\N p5Z 5]ZFJFYL
5\RGFDFGL CSLSTF[G[ ;DY"G D/T]G
\ YLP 5Z\T]\ T[J]\ 5\RGFD]\
H[ 5F[,L;
T5F;
NZdIFG
T[VF[
:Y/
p5Z
UI[,F
CTF
5]ZFJFYL5\RGFDFGL
CSLSTF[
;FlAT
YFI
JFCG ALPV[DP0A<I]SFZ
p5ZYL ,F[CLGF GD]GF ,[JFDF\ VFJ[, CF[JFG]\ :5Q8 56[ O,LT YFI K[P
(ZP
128/273
DF[S,[, CT]P
H[ 5F;", AL
ZL5F[8"
VF\S
!_5
;FY[
D[FS,[,
CTFPp5ZF[ST
GD]GF ;L
p5ZYL ,F[CLGF[ GD]GF[ ,[JFDF VFJ[, CTF[P T[DF\ 56 DFGJ Z]WLZ D/L
VFJ[, CF[JFGF[ ZL5F[8" K[P V,AT T[ GD]GFG\] U]|5 VlG6L"T ZC[TF\ T[G]\
U|]5 GSSL Y. XS[, G CT\]P
VFZF[5LG] ,F[CL
VFD4 p5ZFST
H[ VF\S (_
GF 5\RGFDF D]HA
;FC[N
ZD[XEF.
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
129/273
BLDHLEF. ZF9F[0[
5\RF[ Z]AZ]
G\A Z &
lNG[X EF.
BLDHLEF.ZF9F[0[
V1FZWFD
V[5F8"D[g8DF\
GLR[
,1DL UF\9LIFZY
GFD[ VFJ[,
K[P
;JFZ[ ;FT JFU[ W\WF[ XZ] SZ[ VG[ ZFT|GF GJ JFU[GF VZ;FDF\ N\S
] FG A\W
SZ[ K[P JW]DF\ ;FC[N[ H6FJ[, K[S[4 AGFJ VS:DFTGF[ AG[, P TFZLB
Z$qZqZ_!#GF
ZF[H
ZFT|LGF
VZ;FDF\
AG[,
CTF[
VG[
T[
;DI[ T[VF[ 5F[T[ 5F[TFGF 3[Z CTFP JW]DF\ ;FC[N[ H6FJ[, K[ S[4 ;FC[N
;JFZ[ ;F0F ;FT JFU[ ALHF lNJ;[ N]SFG p5Z VFJ[,F tIFZ[ T[VF[GF
N]SFGGF DF6;F[V[ T[VF[G[ JFT SZ[, S[ ;FD[ ZFT|[ V[S V[S;L0g8 YI[,
CTF[ VG[ T[YL N]SFGGF DF6;F[ UEZF.G[ ;]. UI[,F CTFP
JW]DF\
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
130/273
;FC[N[ H6FJ[, K[S[4 ;JFZ[ N]SFG[ ;FC[N VFJTF\ E6[,F U6[,F DF6;
U|FCS[ ;FC[NG[ SC[, S[ TDFZF S[D[ZFDF\ VFJL UI[, CX[ V[8,[ V[S;L0g8 G]\
VFJL UI[, CX[ P;FC[N[ JW]DF\ H6FJ[, K[ S[4 T[VF[G[ S[D[ZFDF\ BAZ 50TL
GYLP
T[YL T[ ,F[SF[
H[
;FC[NG[ ATFJ[, VG[ ;FC[NG[ V[J]\ N[BF0[, S[ HHLh A\U,F TZOYL V[S
SFZ DFG;L RFZ Z:TF TZO VFJTL CTL VG[ ;\N[X 5|[; TZO VFJTF
AF.S ;FY[ VF SFZ VY0FI[, tIFZAFN VF SFZ hF0 ;FY[ VY0FI[,
JW]DF\ ;FC[N[ H6FJ[, K[ S[4 AF.SJF/F O\UF[/FI[,F CF[JFG\] N[BFT]\ CT]\P
VFD4 ;FC[NGF p5ZF[ST 5]ZFJFG[ wIFG[ ,[TF\ 5F[TFGL N]SFG ACFZ
,UFJ[, ;L;L8LJL S[D[ZFGF O]8[HDF\ CF,GF VS:SDFTGF N=xiF[F Z[S0"
YI[, CF[JFG]\ O,LT YFI K[P ;FY[ ;FY[ S[D[ZFGF N=xIF[ ;FC[N[ HFT[ HFI[,
CF[JFG]\ 56 O,LT YFI K[P
(ZP#
VF5JL
HF[.V[P
T[VF[GF
;FY[
;LP0LP
p,8T5F; NZdIFG
:JLSFZ[, K[ S[4
;L0LP
131/273
GF[W 4 DFS" S[ lGXFG SZ[, G CTFP JW]DF\ ;FC[N[ H6FJ[, K[ S[4 5F[TFGL
N]SFGDF\ S[D[ZF S[8,F K[ T[ SCL XS[ GlCP ;FC[N[ :J[rKFV[ H6FJ[, K[S[4
VD], 5F,"Z ;FC[NGL N]SFG
;FC[N[ V[ CSLST :JLSFZ[, K[ S[4 5F[TFGL N]SFGYL VD], 5F,"Z N[BFI K[P
;FC[N[ V[ CSLST :JLSFZ[, K[ S[4 lJ:DI XFC SFZ R,FJTF CTF T[ BAZ
T[VF[G[ KF5FDF\ VFJTF ;DFRFZYL HF6JF D/[, CT\]P
T[DH lJ:DI
A\U,F TZO HTF\ Z:TF[ VFJ[, K[ VG[ tIF\YL ;\N[X 5|[; HTF\ JrR[ 8=FOLS
;S", VFJ[ K[P ;FC[N[ B],F;F[ SZTF\ H6FJ[, K[ S[4 tIF\ 8=FOLS ;LuG,
GYL 5Z\T\] Ad5
DFG;L ;S",YL HHLh A\U,F[ TZO HTF\ ;\N[X5|[; HJ\] CF[I TF[4JrR[ V[S
GFG\] ;S", VFJ[ K[P VG[ DFG;L ;S",YL VFJTF\ ;\N[X 5|[; HJ\] CF[I
TF[ GFG\] ;S", J8FJL OZLG[ HJ\] 50[P VFD4 AGFJGF :Y/[ V[S GFG\] ;S",
VFJ[, CF[JFGL CSLST
DF8[ T[ GFGF ;S",G[ OZLG[ HJ]\ 50T]\ CF[JFG]\ O,LT YFI K[P
(ZP&
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
132/273
XSFI
T[JL
5Z\T]\
0LPJLPVFZP
;LP0LPp5ZVFWFZ
R[S
ZFBLXSFI
SZJFDF\
VFJ[,
GlCP
V,AT
CF[.
CF,GF
;FC[N[ S[D[ZFDF\Z[S0" YI[, NxIF[ 5F[T[ HFT[ HFI[[,F K[P T[YL T[8,F 5]ZTF
;FC[NGF[ 5]ZFJF[ wIFGDF\ ,. XSFIP
(ZP*
XFC G[
G\A Z !&
YL lJHIS]D FZ
VlE5|FI VF5JF
5F;[ 5F[,L;
133/273
v)#&_
CTF[P
T[GF[
S,Z
U|[
S,Z
HFC[ZGFDF SZTF\
JW] :5L0DF\ CF[JFG]\ T[VF[G[ H6FI[,]\P VF JFCG D]bI DFU" p5Z RF,T] CT]
VG[ T[YL D]bI DFU" p5Z JFCG JW]DF\ JW] S[8,L UlTV[ R,FJL XSFI
T[ lJUT HFC[ZGFDFDF\YL HF[I[,LP ;FC[NGF 5]ZFJF VG];FZ HFC[ZGFDF
D]HA 4 OF[Z jCL,Z JFCG JW]DF\ JW]\ &_ 5|lTS,FS GL h05 YL R,FJL
XSFIP p5ZF[ST CSLSTF[ wIFGDF\
D/[,
T[ SFZ6 ;Z
134/273
p5ZF[ST
5]ZFJFG[
;DY"G
D/[
K[P
VG[;DU|
VF\S!!
5GF HFC[ZFGFDFYL lGIT SZ[, UlT SZTF\ JW] CF[JFGF[ 5]ZFJF[ K[P
($
ARFJ 51F[
SFDULZL SZ[ K[
YI[,F[ CTF[ T[ :Y/G]\ lGZL1F6 ;FC[N[ SZ[, G CT]\P ;FC[N[ JW]DF\ H6FJ[,
K[ S[4 ;FD]\ JFCG SI]\ CT]\ T[GF[ p<,[B T[VF[GFVF\S !!& GF ZL5F[8"DF\
SZ[,F[ GYLP ;FC[N[ JW]DF\ :JLSFZ[, K[ S[4
D]HA
135/273
VS:DFTGF VFXZ[ ;FT[S JZ; 5C[,F\G]\ K[P ;FC[N[ JW]DF\ H6FJ[, K[S[4
ALPV[DP0A<I] SFZ V[ lJN[XGL V[8,[ S[ .d5F[8["0 SFZ K[ T[ T[VF[ HF6[ K[
;FC[N[ V[ CSLST :JLSFZ[, K[ S[4 JQF" Z__& GL ;ZBFD6LDF\ JQF" Z_!_
YL Z_!Z DF\ lJN[XL JFCGF[ GL ;\bIF JW]\ VFJTL CF[JFG]\ T[VF[GL SR[ZLDF\
GF[WFI[, K[P ;FC[N[ JW]DF\ H6FJ[, K[ S[4 H[ ALPV[DP0A<I] SFZ CTL
T[ DF[0, G]\ JFCG EFZTDF\ RF[SS; SIF JZ;DF\ VFJJFGF XZ]\ YI[, T[GL
SF\. HF6SFZL GYLP V[ JFTBZL K[ S[4 N[XDF\ AG[, VG[ lJN[XYL VFIFT
YI[, JFCGF[GL GF[W6L H]NL H]NL H[ T[ VFZP8LPVF[P DF\ SR[ZLVF[ DF\ YFI
K[P JW]DF\ ;FC[N[ :JLSFZ[, K[S[4 lJN[XYL VFJT\F H]NL H]NL S\5GLGF
JFCGF[GF Jh"G ;DIF\TZ[ AN,FTF 56 CF[I K[P JW]DF\ ;FC[NGF 5]ZFJF
VG];FZ JQF" Z__& GL ;ZBFD6LDF\ JQF" Z_!_ YL Z_!Z VG[ Z_!# GF
JZ;F[DF\ Z[F0GL l:YlT JW] ;FZL YTL VFJ[, K[P ;FC[NGF 5]ZFJF VG];FZ
VF\S!!5YL ZH]SZ[, HFC[ZGFDF AFN GJ]\ SF[. HFC[ZGFD]\ UlT DIF"NF
V\U[ ACFZ 50[, K[ S[ S[D T[ ;FC[NGL HF6SFZLDF\ VFJ[, GYLP JW]DF\
;FC[NGF 5]ZFJF VG];FZ VF\S !!5G]\ HFC[ZGFD]\ 4 JFCGGF AN,FTF
JH"G4 Z:TFVF[GL YTL ;FZL l:YlT 4 JFCGGF[GL DCTD UlT DIF"NF
wIFGD\F ,[TF\ ;G[ Z_!# DF\ lGZY"S Y. UI[, CT\] S[ S[D T[ T[VF[ SCL
XS[ GlCP 5Z\T]\ VF\S
YI[,K[ T[GFYL JW] UlT DIF"NF GSSL Y. CF[I T[JL SF[. CSLST ARFJ
51F Z[S0" p5Z ,FJL XS[, GYLP
(5
VS:DFTDF\
DFZOT[ SZFJJFDF\ VFJ[, CF[JFG\] OZLIFN 51FG]\ SYG K[P H[ ;FlAT SZJF
DF8[ OZLIFN 51F[ ;FC[N G\A Z !*4 V[O PV[; PV[, P GF ;FIg8LOLS
VF[l O;Z
UF[l J\N HL
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
136/273
*)qZ_!# GF
T5F;
IFNL D/TF\ zL
VlWSFZL
G[
D/L4VS:DFTGF
JFCGF[GL
T5F;
5F[,L;
V;Z
:8[XGGF S\d5Fpg0D\F
.,[S8=LS
OF[8F[U|FOL SZFJ[,LP
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
137/273
ZL5F[8" T{iFFZ SZL 5F\R TFZLB ;]WLDF\ D[FS,L VF5X[ T[D H6FJ[,
P;FC[NGF JW] 5]ZFJF VG];FZ tIFZAFN TFZLB 5q#qZ_!# GF ZF[H
ZL5F[8" T{IFZ SZL J:T|F5]Z 5[FP:8[P G[ DF[S,L VF5[, H[ ZL5F[8" DF\ ;FC[N[
TYF zL V[P JLP lCUZFHLIFV[ T[JF ZL5F[8"DF\ ;CLVF[ SZ[,
H[ ZL5F[8"
JW]DF\
;FC[NGF
5]ZFJF
VG];FZ
T[VF[
VS:DFTJF/F
;FC[N[
5ZL1F6 SZ[,]\
H[DF\
Ad5ZGF JrR[GF EFUYL ;C[H 0FAL TZO GF EFU[ AFCI ,F, Z\U
W;F.G[ RF[8[,F[ CTF[P H[ ,F, Z\U DF[8Z;FIS,GF ,F, Z\U H[JF[ CTF[P
DF[8Z ;FIS,GL 0FAL AFH] G]\ 50BF 5Z VS:DFTGF lRCGF[ CTFP 0FAL
AFH]GF EFUGF[ ,[U UF0" J/L UI[, CTF[ VG[
EFU[ ,F, Z\U pB0[,F[ CTF[ VG[ 3;F.G[
RF[8,
[ F[ CTF[ H[ ALPV[DP 0A<I] SFZGF SF/F Z\UGF %,F:8LSGF Ad5ZGF
5F8L"S<; CTF PH[ OF[8F VG]S|D G\AZsZZf VG[ sZ$ f YL ZH] K[P VG]S|D
G\AZ sZ#f YL ZH] OF[8F[ HF[.G[ ;FC[N[ H6FJ[, K[ S[4 ALPV[D0A<I]
SFZGF Ad5ZGF[ OF[8F[ K[ T[DF\ AFCI ,F, Z\U 3;F.G[ RF[8[,F[ N[BFI K[P
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
138/273
(*
#5;[DL H[8,L
EFU
R[;L;
;BT
ZLT[
VY0F.
VG[
3;F.
CF[I
139/273
YIF[ CF[I T[YL .,[S8=LS AF[1FGF 5FIFG\] .8F[G]\ R6TZ T]8L UI[, CT\]P
ALPV[DP 0A<I] SFZGF AF[G[8 5Z AFCI ,L,F[ Z\U RF[8,
[ F[ CTF[P T5F;
VlWSFZLV[ H6FjIF D]HA 4 AFCI ,L,F[ Z\U hF0 5F;[ ,L,F Z\UGL
0:8ALG 50[, CTL T[GF[ CF[. XS[P
(*PZ
(*P#
H[ VG]S|D Z&
JW]DF\4
;FC[NGF
H6FjIF
VG];FZ
;DU|
A\gG[ JFCGF[ VG[ AGFJ :Y/G]\ hF0GL T5F; SZL ;FC[N[ VG[ V[P JLP
lCUZFHLIFV[ VC[JF, T{IFZ SZL 4 VlE5|FI VF5[, S[4 ALPV[DP 0A<I]
SFZGF VFU/GF Ad5Z JrR[YL 0FAL AFH] TZOGF[ EFU DF[8Z ;FIS,GL
0FAL
AFH]GL
5[8=F[,
8[gSJF/F
EFU
;FY[
8SZFI[,
K[P
VJ:YFDF\ UlTYL ZF[0GL O]85FYGF hF0 ;FY[ VY0FTF\ hF0 GDL UI[,
CT\] VG[ ALPV[DP 0A<I] SFZ hF0GF Y0 p5Z R-L UI[, PVFD4 ;FC[NMGF[
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
140/273
p5ZF[ST 5]ZFJF[ wIFGDF\ ,[TF\4 ;FC[N[ HFT[ A\gG[ JFCGF[G[ YI[, G]S;FG
TYF :Y/ p5ZGL 5lZl:YlT VG[ H[ hF0 ;FY[ SFZ VY0FI[, CTL T[GL
l:YlT VG[ T[G[
T[VF[ HF6TF GYLP VF\S !!( GL IFNL DF\ 0[%I]8L 0FIZ[S8ZzL ,B[,
K[ tIF\ 5C[,F\ SF[. VgI VF[lO;ZG[ ;\AF[WLG[ T[DGF[ CF[NF[ ,B[, CF[. XS[P
;FC[NGF H6FjIF D]HA T[VF[G[ VF IFNL D/L T[ 5C[,F\ V[OPV[;PV[,P
TZOYL
JFCGGL
I\FlT|S
RSF;6L
Y.
UI[,
CTL
S[
S[D4
VG[ V[ RSF;6L OZLIFN 51F VG[ 5F[,L;G[ DNNZ]5 YFI T[D G CTL
S[ S[D4 VG[ T[YL T[JL RSF;6LGL lJUTF[ K]5FJJFDF\ VFJ[, K[ S[ S[D4
T[ lJX[ ;FC[N SF\. SCL XS[ GlCP ;FC[N[ JW]DF\ H6FJ[, K[ S[4 VUFp SF[.
RSF;6L Y. CTL S[ S[D T[ T[VF[
SCL
XS[
GlCPJW]DF\
;FC[N
T[GFYL lJ5ZLT K[
H6FJ[
K[
S[
G]S;FG
S[ S[D
5FD[,
141/273
((P!
YL !&q$5 ;]WL CTF VG[ T[ JBT[ 8LDGF 5F\R[ ;eIF[ ;FY[ CTFP
5F[P:8[P H[ SFDULZL SZ[, T[G]\ S[F. 5\RGFD]\ SZJFDF\ VFJ[, G CT\]P ;FC[N[V[
CSLST :JLSFZ[, K[ S[4 OF[8F 5F0LG[ JFCGGL :5L0 GSSL SZJFGL K[ T[JL
S[F. IFNL 5F9JJFDF\ VFJ[, G CTLP ;FC[NGF JW] 5]ZFJFDF\ H6FjIF
D]HA T[VF[GF OZHSF/ NZdIFG UlT GSSL SZJF V\U[GF VFXZ[ N;[S
5|;\UF[ AG[, K[P V[OPV[;PV[,P SR[ZL GL H]NL H]NL SFDULZL
V\U[ V[OPV[;PV[,P TZOYL SF[. UF.0,F.g; AGFJJFDF\ VFJ[, GYLP
;FC[NGF H6FjIF D]HA T[VF[ UIF tIFZ[ VF A\gG[ JFCGF[ 5F[P:8[P GF
S\d5Fpg0D\F B]<,F 50[,F CTFP
((PZ
S[DLS, 5ZL1F6
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
142/273
VFH]AFH]DF\ SIF\ YI[, CTF[ V[8,]\ HF6[, CT]\P 5Z\T]\ RF[SS; SIF 5F[.g8
p5Z YI[, T[GL BAZ GYLP VG]S|D G\AZ sZ(f JF/F[ OF[8F[ HF[TF T[DF\
N[BFT]\ ;S", VG[ 0LJF.0Z JrR[ S[8,]\ V\TZ CX[ T[ RF[SS; 56[ SCL
XS[ GlC P
((P$
OF[8FDF\ N[BFTF
UF0LG[
B;[0L
H6FJ[, K[P
!!)
GF
VC[JF,DF\
,BJFG]\
HZ]Z
H6FI[,
GlCP
;FC[N[ V[ CSLST :JLSFZ[, K[ S[4 SFZGF 0FAL AFH]GF 8FIZF[GF S[F. OF[8F
,LW[, G CTFP VF SFZG[ T[VF[GF :8FO VG[ 5F[,L; :8FO[ B;[0[,
VG[ T[ ZLT[ 8FIZGL GLR[GL ;ZO[; HFI[,P ;FC[N[ V[ CSLST :JLSFZ[,
K[ S[4 VG]S|D G\AZ ( JF/F 8FIZ p5Z VFXZ[ V[SFN O]8
,F\AF[ SF/F[ 588F[ N[BFI K[ T[GF[ S[F. p<,[B VF\S !!) GF VC[JF,DF\
SZJFDF\ VFJ[,F[ GYLP T[ H ZLT[ VG]S|D G\AZ ) JF/F OF[8FDF\ 8FIZ p5Z
H[ SF/F[ 588F[ N[BFI K[ T[GF[ p<,[B VF\S !!) GF VC[JF,DF\ SZJFDF\
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
143/273
JW]DF\ ;FC[NGF
H6FjIF D]HA VFS !Z_YL ZH] YI[, VG]S|D G\AZ sZfJF/F OF[8F[ HF[.4
T[DF\ H[ AFCI ,F, Z\U RF[8[,FGF[ p<,[B K[ T[ SF[GF[ K[ T[GL GF[W VG]S|D
G\AZ sZf DF\ GYL ;FC[N H6FJ[ K[ S[4 VF AFCI ,F, Z\U DF[8Z ;FIS,GF[
CF[JFGF[
p<,[B
VG]S|D
G\AZ
sZ#f
JF/F
OF[8FDF\
SZ[,
K[P
;FC[N[ V[ CSLSTGF[ >gSFZ SZ[, K[ S[ VG]S|D G\AZ sZf JF/F OF[8FG[ VG]S|
D G\AZsZ#f JF/F OF[8F ;FY[ HF[0[, K[ T[ BF[8]\ H6FJ[ K[P
((P5
JW]DF\
V[OPV[;PV[,PVlWSFZLV[
p,8T5F;DF\
H6FJ[,
H6FJ[, GYL 4 T[J]\ ATFJJF ARFJ 51F[ 5|ItG SZ[, K[ 5Z\T]\ 5F[TFGF
5ZL1F6 VC[JF,DF\ S[JL ZLT[ 8FIZF[G]\ 5ZL1F6 SZ[, T[GL lJUTJFZ
lJ:T'T CSLSTF[
VF VC[JF,
Z]AZ]
D]HA
zL DFIFN[J L
144/273
VG[ tIFZAFN J:T|F5]Z 5F[,L; :8[XG TZOYL SF[. VFJ[, P VG[ T[VF[GF
58FJF/FG[ SC[TF\4 58FJF/FV[ lJwJFG D[HL:8[=8zL G[ 5]KJF VFJ[,F
S[
K[
TF[
T[VF[
SIFZ[
VFJ[
T[YL
5F[TFGF
X[0I]V,
,[JFG]\
G[
HF[.
T[DG[
;DHFJ[,
S[
ccTD[
H[
lGJ[NG
VF5JF
DFUF[ KF[ T[ DF8[ TD[ A\WFI[,F GYL VG[ HF[ VF lGJ[NG T[VF[ :J[rKFV[ 4
SF[.56 HFTGF NAF6 JUZ VF5JF DF\UTF CF[I VG[ TD[
H[ lGJ[NG
,BF6 ,BL T[VF[ A\gG[GL ;CLVF[ ,LW[, VG[ OZL TFZLB Z!q#q!# GF
ZF[H A5F[ZGF A[ JFU[ CFHZ ZC[JF ;DH VF5[,P
lJPD[HL:8[=8zLGF
TYF
VF\S !__ YL ZH] YI[, K[P JW]DF\ ;FC[N[ H6FJ[, K[ S[4 T[ ,BF6
JF\RLG[ A\gG[V[ T[VF[GF Z]AZ]\DF\ 5F[T v5F[TFGF ,BF6D\F ;CL SZ[, CTL P
()P!
VFD4 p5ZF[ST
CSLSTF[
S,D !&$ G]\ lGJ[NG GF[WTF\ 5C[,F\ SFINF D]HA H[ ;DH VF5JL HZ]ZL
K[ T[JL ;DH VF5JFDF\ VFJ[, CF[JFG\] :5Q856[ O,LT YFI K[P
()PZ
145/273
DF\UF[ KF[m cc T[VF[ A\gG[V[ CF 5F0[,LP T[YL ;FC[N ,,LT U]%TF G[ T[VF[V[
R[dAZD\F pEF ZFB[, VG[ ;FC[N lNG[X RF{WZLG[ SF[8" CFp;DF\
A[;JFGL ;]RGF VF5[,LP
()P#
:8[GF[
,,LT
T[
Z]AZ] SZ[, CTL VG[ T[GF GLR[ ;8L"OLS[8 ,BL T[VF[V[ 5F[TFGL ;CL
K[ T[ VF[/BL ATFJ[, K[P VF lGJ[NGD\F ,B[, CSLSTF[ ;FC[N[ ,BFjIF
D]HA AZFAZ VG[ BZL CF[JFG]\ H6FJ[, K[ P
()P$
,,LT
J\RFJ[,4
146/273
K[ H[DF\ ;FC[N lN[GX RF{WZLGL ;CL K[ H[ T[V[FGF Z]AZ] SZ[, CTL VG[ T[GF
GLR[ ;8L"OLS[8 ,BL T[VF[V[ 5F[TFGL ;CL SZ[,PVG[ VF lGJ[NGD\F ,B[,
CSLSTF[ ;FC[N[ ,BFjIF D]HA AZFAZ VG[ BZL CF[JFG]\ H6FJ[, K[ P
()P5
SF[d%I]8ZDF\YL
T[VF[GL ;CLVF[ T[VF[GF ,BF6DF\ ;CL ,LW[, CTL H[ VG]S|D[ VF\S )&
TYF VF\S !__YL ZH] YI[, ,BF6DF\ GLR[ H[ CFYYL ,B[, ,BF6
K[ T[ H K[ VG[ T[ GLR[ T[VF[GL ;CLVF[ K[P
()P&
)_
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
147/273
5a,LSGF A[ DF6;F[GL
p5ZF[ST
CSLSTF[
5]ZFJFYL :5Q8 56[ O,LT YFI K[P VG[ T[D KTF\ ;FC[N G\AZ !!
OZLIFNL ,,LT U]%TFV[ V[J]\ H6FJ[, K[ S[ 5F[T[ SF[. lGJ[NG ,BFJ[, G
CT\]P V,AT OZLIFNLV[ VFJL CSLST[ lJP V[P5LP5LPzLV[ SZ[,
p,8T5F;DF\ :JLSFZ[, K[ S[4cc . // [
VULIFZ JFU[
ccP T[D
KTF\ OZLIFNLV[ lJP V[P5LP5LPzLV[ SZ[, p,8T5F;DF\
.gSFZ SZ[,F[ K[ S[4 TFPZ!q#qZ_!# GF ZF[H
V[ CSLSTGF[
VF\S)* G]\
lGJ[NG
5|ItG SZ[,
CF[JFG] \ lJwJFG D[HL:8[=8 zLGF p5ZF[ST 5]ZFJFYL :5Q8 56[ O,LT YFI
K[P
)_PZ
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
148/273
:Y/[ UI[,F
VG[ ALPV[DP 0A<I] UF0LJF/F[ pTZLG[ 38GF :Y/[ VFJL VG[ ;F[ZL
;F[ZL SC[JF ,FU[,F[
;D1F
)_P5
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
149/273
H6FjIF D]HA T[VF[G[ V[S H JFZ SF[8"DF\ ,FJ[, CTFP VG[ T[ lNJ;[
;FC[N ;FY[ ,,LT U]%TF CTFP H[ S[F8"DF\ T[VF[G[
,. UIF T[ S[F8"DF\
5C[,F\ ,,LT U]%TFGL 5]KTF; SZ[, VG[ ;FC[NG[ ACFZ A[;F0[, CTF[P
5\NZ JL; DLGL8DF\ ,,LT ACFZ VFJ[, VG[ tIFZAFN ;FC[N V\NZ UI[,P
tIF\ VFJL V[S S[F8{" sCF,GL S[F8" H[JL H SF[8"f CTL VG[ V\NZ V[S
Z]DD\F ,. UIF CTFP tIF\ T[VF[GL
5]KTF;
SZ[,LP
AGFJ
V\U[GL
CSLSTF[
lGJ[NGD\FGL S[8,LS
lJwJFG D[HL:8[=8zLGL
lJP
;DH VF5[, S[
cc
VF5TF\ ;DI[ lJ5ZLT lGJ[NG VF5X[ TF[ T[DGF lJZ]wW SFG]GL SFI"JFCL
Y. XS[ K[ cc T[J]\ T[D6[ HFT[ GSSL SZ[, GlC45Z\T]\ OF[HNFZLSFI"ZLTL
VlWlGIDGL
S,D
!&$GL
HF[UJF.VF[DF\
H6FjIF
D]HA
V[ CSLST
:JLSFZ[, K[ S[4 p5ZF[ST H6FJ[, ;]RGFVF[ H[JF RF[SS; XaNF[ DF8[ SF[.
HF[UJF. OF[HNFZL SFI"ZLTL VlWlGIDGL S,D !&$ GL ;DU| S,DDF\
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
150/273
SIF\I
H6FJJFDF\
VFJ[,
GYLP
JW]DF\
lJwJFG
D[HL:8[=8
,[TF\ 4
OZLIFN
51FGF
SYG
D]HA
CF,GF
VFZF[5L
lJZ]wW
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
151/273
T[DH VFZF[5LGF
l5TF lJZ]wW CF,GF AGFJ V\U[ VFZF[5LG[ HF6L A]hLG[ VFzI VF5L
TYF 5F[,L; ;D1F BF[8\] lGJ[NG SZJF AN, .P5LPS[FPSP Z!Z4!*&4 TYF
!** D]HAGF U]gCFGL V[OVF.PVFZP ;[8[,F.8 5F[P:8[P VDNFJFNDF\ 4
U]gCF ZHLP G\AZ ;[Sg0 ($qZ_!# YL GF[WFI[, CTL P H[ CSLSTF[
;FlAT SZJF DF8[ ;[8 [, F.8 5F[P :8[P GF C[P SF[P ;FC[N G\A Z ZZ 4
VZ]6 S]D FZ GZCZL ,F[B \0 G
[ [ OZLIFN 51F[ VF\S !5! YL T5F;JFDF\
VFJ[,F K[P VG[ T[VF[V[ 5F[TFGF 5]ZFJF NZdiFFG p5ZF[ST A\gG[ U]gCFGL
V[OVF.VFZ VG]S|D[ VF\S !5Z VG[
5|DF6LT
GS,F[ CF[.4 5]ZFJFDF\ U|FCI K[ VG[ T[YL T[G[ SFIDL VF\S VF5JFDF\
VFJ[ K[ P
)ZP!
!5Z GL V[OVF.VFZ
152/273
NZdIFG
5|[DR\NGUZ ZF[04 p5Z VFJTF\ V[S SF/F S,ZGL ALPV[DP 0A<I] SFZ
G\AZ ;LV[Rv _!vV[.v)#&_ GF RF,S[ 5F[,L;GL HL5 HF[. 5F[TFGL
UF0L ZLJ;" ZO R,FJL ZF[0 p5ZGL V[S VF[8F[ZL1FFG[ 8SSZ DFZL EFUJF
,FU[,P H[G[ 5F[,L;[ 5S0L ,LW[,PT[ UF0L RF,S 4T[DH AFH]DF\ A[9[,
V[S .;D D/L VFJ[, P VG[ ;NZ .;DGF DF\[DF\YL NFZ]GL TLJ| JF;
VFJTL CTLP T[YL 5\RF[GF DF6;F[ AF[,FJL T[ .;DG\] GFD 9FD 5]KTF\
;NZ .;D[ 5F[TFG] GFD lJ:DI VDLT XFC4 DF\U<I ;F[;FI8L 4DSFG
G\AZ !#4 GC[ZGUZ 4;[8[,F.8 C[FJFG\] H6FJ[, VG[ ;NZ .;D[ NFZ]
5LW[,FGL TLJ| JF; VFJTL CF[.4T[VF[G[ NFZ] 5LJFGL 5F; 5ZDL8 DF\UTF\4
GlC C[FJFG\] H6FJ[, VG[ T[YL T[GL lJZ]wW OZLIFN GF[WFJ[, CTLP VFD4
VF\S !5Z GL
VS:DFT D\F ;\0JF[I[, JFCG ALV[D0A<I] SFZ NFZ] 5LG[ 5|[DR\NGUZ ZF[0
p5Z JFCG R,FJJJF AN, DF[PjCLPV[PSP !(5 D]HAGF[ U]gCF[ NFB,
YI[, CF[JFGF[ 5]ZFJF[ K[P
)ZPZ
sU|FdiF
fDLZHF5]ZGF
V[0LXG,
;LJL,
HH
153/273
VgJI[
5__qv GF[ N\04 VG[ N\0 G EZ[ TF[ T|6 lNJ;GL ;FNL S[NGL ;HF
EF[UJJFGF[ C]SD SZ[,F[ CTF[P p5ZF[ST R]SFNF VG[ ;HFGF C]SD lJZ]wW
VFZF[5LV[ SF[. p5,L VNF,TDF\ V5L, S[ ZLJLhG SZ[, CF[I4
T[JF[ VFZF[5L TZO[ S[F. 5]ZFJF[ ZH] YI[,F[ GYLP VFD4;NZ R]SFNF lJZ]wW
SF[. V5L, YI[, G CF[.4 lJP D[HLPzLGF[ ;NZ R]SFNF[ wIFGDF\ ,[TF\4
VFZF[5LV[ 5F[TFGF lJZ]wW GF[WFI[, V[DPJLPV[P S,D !(5 D]HAGF[ U]gCF[
SA], SZ[, VG[ T[YL VFZF[5LG[ ;1FD VNF,T[ ;HF SZ[, C[FJFG\] ;FlAT
YFI K[P H[ U]gCF D]HA VFZF[5LV[ NFZ] 5LG[ HFC[Z ZF[0 p5Z JFCG
C\SFZ[, CF[JFG]\ ;FlAT YI[,
56
154/273
)#P
GF
ZF[H
5F[P:8[PDF\
S,FS
TFZLB
Z_q__
YL
.gJ[:8LU[XG :SJF[0DF\
5F[T[ VF
V\U[ OZLIFN HFC[Z SZTF\ T[GL OZLIFN Z]AZ]GL ,LW[, VG[ U]gCF[ ZHL:80"
SZJF J:T|F5]Z 5F[P:8[P DF\ DF[S,[, PJW]DF\ T5F;GLXGF H6FjIF D]HA
VG[ U]gCF[ ZHL:80" Y. VFJTF\ T5F; T[VF[V[ ;\EF/[, VG[ ;\HLJGL
CF[l:58,DF\ XLJD DZ6 UI[, CF[. T[J]\ 0F[S8Z[ HFC[Z SZTF\ H[G]\ .gSJ[:8
5\RGFD]\ SZJFG]\ CF[. 4 5\RF[ Z]AZ] .gSJ[:8 EZL4 ,FXG[ 5LPV[DP DF8[
;F[,F ;LJL, CF[l:58, DF[S,L VF5[,P tIFZAFN AGFJ HuIF VF SFDGF
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
155/273
OZLIFNL ,,LTS]DFZ ATFJTF\ CF[.4 T[VF[G[ ;FY[ ZFBL 5\RF[ Z]AZ] AGFJ
HuIFV[ 5\RGFD]\ AGFJJF/L HuIFG]\ 5\RGFD] VF\S *( YL ZH] SZ[, K[P
H[ 5\RGFDFDF\
)$P!
A\gG[ 5\RF[V[ T5F;GLX Z]AZ] ;CL SZ[, CTL VG[ ;FC[N[ Z]AZ]56FGL ;CL
SZ[, CTLP H[ 5\RGFDFGL CSLST 5\RF[V[ ,BFJ[, 4 T[ D]HA ,B[,P
T[ D]HA AZFAZ VG[ BZL K[ PJW]DF\ T5F;GLX[ H6FJ[, K[S[4
D]NFDF,
OZLIFNL
;FC[N
G\AZ !! ,,LT ZFH[X U]%TFV[ T[VF[GF Z]AZ] OZLIFN GF[WFJ[, CTL H[GL
CSLSTF[ OZLIFNLV[ ,BFJ[, T[ D]HA ,B[, CTLP JW]DF\ ;FC[N
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
156/273
G\AZ !!
,,LT
H6FJ[, CTLP
5F[,L; :8[XGG[ OF[G SZL HF6 SZ[, CTLP V0WF S,FS DF\ J:T|F5]Z
5F[,L; :8[XGGL 5F[,L; VFJL UI[, CTLP VG[ T[VF[GL 5]K5ZK SZ[,L
CTLP ;FY[ ;FY[ VF\S )5 GL OZLIFGNDF\ OZLIFNLV[ 5F[TFGL ;CL CF[JFG]\
VF[/BL ATFJ[, K[PVFD TFPZ$qZqZ_!# GL ZFT|[ V[8,[ S[ TFP
Z5qZqZ_!# GF ZF[H S,FS !q!5 JFU[
CF,GF
T5F;GLX
Z]AZ]
OZLIFN
GF[WFJ[,
T5F;GLXGF
)$P$
)5
ARFJ
51F[
T5F;GLXGL
SZ[,
p,8T5F;
NZdIFG
157/273
T[VF[ ;\HLJGL
ALHLJFZ
tIF\
T5F;GLX[
JW]DF\
p,8T5F;
NZdIFG
H6FJ[,
K[
S[4
VF\S )5 GL
158/273
lJUTF[ VG];FZ
K[S[ T[VF[V[ S,FS Zq!5 JFU[ T5F; ;\EF/L CTLP VG[ S,FS Zq!5
JFU[ VF\S (! GF .gSJ[:8 5\RGFDFG]\ ,BF6 XZ\] SZL NLW[, CT]P
)5PZ
SZ[, ZL5F[8"DF\
A[
T[JF A[ JFCG
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
159/273
RF,SF[ 5{SL SF[GL S;]ZYL VS:DFT YJF 5FD[, CTF[ T[ T5F;GF[ lJQFI
AG[ K[P T5F;GLX[ JW]DF\ :JLSFZ[, K[ S[4 AGFJGF ALHF lNJ;GF
;JFZYL H N{lGS 5T|F[DF\
T[DH
T5F;GLX[
:JLSFZ[,
K[
S[4
ZF[0
p5ZG]\ ;S", J8FJLG[ GlC 5Z\T]\ ;S", 5C[,F\ J/L UI[, CF[JFG]\ H6FT]\
CT]P JW]DF\ ;FC[N[ H6FJ[, K[S[4
A[9[, .;DF[V[ C[<D[8 5C[Z[, CTL S[ S[D T[ lJX[ SF[. T5F; SZ[,L G
CTLP ;FC[NGF H6FjIF D]HA lGID D]HA C[<D[8 5C[ZJL OZHLIFT K[P
)5P5
JW]DF\4
;FC[NGF
p,8T5F;GF
5]ZFJFDF\
H6FjIF
D]HA
160/273
5\RGFD]\
SZJFG]\
T[DG[
HZ]ZL
H6FJ[,
GlCP
B],F;F[
SZTF\
SF[.
a,LgS;" ,UFJ[, CF[I TF[ T[GF[ p<,[B 5\RGFDFDF\ SZJF[ HF[.V[P JW]DF\
T5F;GLX[ H6FJ[, K[ S[4 AGFJ JF/F
;S", p5Z 8=FOLS ;LuG, S[ ZF[0 p5Z SF[. a,LgS;" G CTF VG[ T[YL
T[GF[ p<,[B 5\RGFDFDF\ SZ[,F[ GYLP T5F;GLX[ V[ CSLSTGF[ .gSFZ
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
161/273
OZLIFNLV[ SF[.
HF[TF\ SFR p5Z ,F[CL H[JF 0F3 N[BFI K[Pcc ,B[, K[ T[ T[JL
JW]DF\4T5F;GLX[
H6FJ[,
K[
S[4
T[VF[V[
U]HZGFZF
VFJF[
162/273
5\RF[
Z]AZ] 5\RGFD\]
AGFJ :Y/
T5F;GLX
.g;5[S 8Z4 J:T|F 5]Z 5F[, L; :8[X G GF VF[G [ VF\S !5& YL ;F[U\N
p5Z T5F;JFDF\ VFJ[,F K[P T5F;GLX[ JW]DF\ H6FJ[, K[ S[4 ;\I]ST
5F[PSDLxGZzL4
,,LT
U]%TFV[ AGFJ ;DI[ VFZF[5LG[ HF[I[, CF[. 4H[YL T[G]\ V[F/B 5\RGFD]
SZJF ;FZ]\ OZLIFNL ,,LT U]%TFG[ 5F[P:8[PDF\ AF[,FJ[, TYF A[ 5\RF[GF
DF6;F[G[ 5[FP:8[PDF\ AF[,FJL 5\RF[GF ,BFjIF D]HAG]\ OZLIFNL VFZF[5L G[
VF[/BL ATFJ[,FG]\ 5\RGFD] SZ[,P H[ 5\RGFD]\ OZLIFN 51F[ VF\S ($ YL
ZH] YI[, K[ H[DF\ A\gG[ 5\RF[V[ T[VF[GF Z]AZ]DF\ ;CLVF[ SZ[,VG[ 5\RGFD]\
5F[TFGF Z]AZ] YI[,
CF[.
163/273
OZLIFNL
YI[,
VFD
SZ[,P
T5F;GLXGF
Z]AZ]DF\ ;CLVF[ SZ[, CF[.4 T5F;GLX[ T[VF[GF Z]AZ] 5\RGFD] YI[, CF[. 4
T[YL T[VF[V[ 5F[TFGL ;CL SZ[, P p5ZF[ST 5]ZFJFGL ;FY[ ;FY[ VF\S (5
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
164/273
VFZF[5LG[
XZLZ
p5Z
.HFVF[
YI[,
CTL
T[
HF[TF\
EFU[
JFU[,FGF
lGXFG
CTFP
VFD VFZF[5LG[
SZ[,F[P H[ V;,
JW]DF\ T5F;GLX['
VFZF[5LG[ AGFJ ;DI[
VG[ VF<SF[CF[, 8[:8 DF8[
H6FJ[, K[S[4
VF U]gCFGF
,LW[,
165/273
5\RGFD] SZ[, V;, 5\RGFD]\ VF\S )!YL ZH] YI[, K[ H[DF\ A\gG[ 5\RF[V[
;FC[N Z]AZ]DF\ ;CLVF[ SZ[, ;NZC]\ 5\RGFD]\ T[VF[GF Z]AZ] YI[, K[P
p5ZF[ST VF\S )! GF 5\RGFDFGL CSLSTF[ 5\R ;FC[N HI\lTEF. G8]EF.
JFW[,Fs;FC[N G\AZ ) f GF 5]ZFJF VG\]';FZ V[S SJZ 5F[,L;JF/FV[ ZH]
SZ[, CT]\ VG[ T[ SJZ p5Z ,B[, CSLSTF[ 5\RGFDF DF\ ,BL ,LW[, CTL
VG[ SJZ SAH[ SZ[, CT]P\ VFD VFZF[5LGL TALAL T5F; NZdIFG D[0LS,
VF[lO;ZzL V[ ,LW[, ,F[CLGF GD]GF
)(
5F[TFGL
ALPV[DP0A<I]
SFZ
S,FS
GF
HF6JF ;FZ\]
V[OPV[;PV[,P
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
166/273
VDFZL :Y/5|T VF\S !#! YL ZH] YI[, K[ VF\S !#_GL IFNL D?IF
AN, 5;F[",L D[F8;"GF HJFANFZ VlWSFZLGL T[DF\ ;CL SZ[,LP JW]DF\
T5F;GLXGF 5]ZFJF VG];FZ 5;F[{,L D[F8;" jNFZF VF ALPV[DP 0A<I]GL
T5F;6LSZL VC[JF, ;LP0LP ;FY[ VF5[, T[ SFDD\F ;FD[, ZFB[, CTLP
H[ V;, VF\S !## YL ZH] YI[, K[ T[ H K[P VG[ 5;F[",LJF/FV[
:5L0
V\U[ T{IFZ SZ[, ZL5F[8" DF[S,FJ[, CTF[ H[ VF\S !#ZYL ZH] YI[, K[
p5ZF[ST 5]ZFJFGL ;FY[ ;FY[ VFZP8LPVF[P VlWSFZL ;FC[N G\AZ !_&
lJHI B[F0LNF; XFCGF 5]ZFJF D]HA VS:DFT DF\ ;\0F[JFI[,
JFCGG[ YI[, G]S;FG VG[ .d5[S8 V\U[ VF\S !*#YL VlE5|FI VF5[,
CTF[ TG[ H ZLT[ 5;F[",L DF[8;" GF D[G[HZ ;FC[N G\AZ !) O{h, IFS]A
D]G;L GF 5]ZFJF VG];FZ VS:DFTDF\
;\0F[JFI[,
SFZ
H[JL ALHL
VS:DFTDF\
T5F; SZL4 ;FY[ ;FY[ AGFJ :Y/GL T5F; SZL VF\S !!)GF[ ZL5F[8"
VF5[,F[ CF[JFGF[
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
167/273
5]ZFJF
D]HA
T[VF[V[
VFZF[5LGF
,F[CLGF
GD]GF[
TYF
VFZ[F5LGF
,F[CLDF\
VF<SF[CF[,GL
CFHZL
YI[, K[P
K[
S[
S[D
,1DL
!_!
5F[,L; SDLxGZzL G]
HFC[ZGFDFYL
SZJFDF\ VFJ[, CT\]P T[GL GS, Z[S0"DF\YL SF-L T5F;GF SFU/F[DF\ ZFBL
T[GL GS, VFZP8LPVF[P VlWSFZLG[ DF[S,[, CTL H[ HFC[ZGFDFGL GS,
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
168/273
!_$
VG[ VgI VlWSFZLVF[ VFJTF\ T[DG[ AGFJ :Y/ ATFJ[, VG[ HZ]ZL
A\NF[A:T VG[ jIJ:YF ;FRJ[,P p5ZF[ST 5]ZFJFGL ;FY[ ;FY[
T[VF[GF
;FY[
DNNGLX
lGIFDS
V[RP5LP
;\WJL
VFJ[,F
CF[JFGF[ 5]ZFJF[ K[P ;FY[ ;FY[ p,8T5F;GF 5]ZFJF NZdIFG ;FC[N G\AZ
Z_ GF VF[V[ H6FjIF D]HA T[VF[ HIFZ[ HL%;L SFZG]\ 0[DF[:8=[XG SZ[,
tIFZ[ 5F[,L; :8[XGGF ALHF DF6;F[ CFHZ CTFP
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
169/273
!_5
AGFJ JBT[
AGFJ AFN
5F[,L; S\g8[=F, Z]DG[ OF[G SZGFZ 0F[P lNjI[X NJ[ VG[ T[DGL ;FY[GF zL
lG,DEF. GF lGJ[NG ,LW[, PV,AT p5ZF[ST ;FC[NF[G[ OZLIFN 51F[
T5F;JFDF\ VFJ[,F GYLP
!_&
UI[,
tIFZ[
VFZF[5LGF
l5TF
0F[P
VDLT
XFC[ T[DG[ VG[ DL0LIFG[ VFZF[5L AFAT[ V,U V,U DFlCTL VF5[,
H[ DFlCTLGL BZF. SZJF ;FZ]\ ;\N[X gI]h R[G, VG[ U]HZFT ;DFRFZ
gI]h R[G,G[ 0F[P VDLT XFC[ TFPZ&qZq!# GF ZF[H VF5[, AF.8GL
;LP0LPVF5JF IFNL VF5[,LP H[ ;\NE[" ;\N[X R[G,GF ZL5F[8"Z zL DF{,LS
5|JL6EF. 58[,GF VF[V[ 0F[PVDLT XFC[ TFZLB Z&qZq!# GFZF[H T[DG[
VF5[, AF.8 GL ;LP0LP ZH] SZTF\ H[ T5F;GF SFU/F[DF\ ;FD[, ZFB[,P
V,AT4 VFJL SF[. ;L0LP OZLIFN 51F[ ZH] YI[, GYLP
JW]DF\ 4
lGJ[NG
,LW[,
H[YL
0F[P
VDLT
XFC[ VFZF[5LG[ VFXZF[ VF5[, VG[ 5F[,L; VG[ DL0LIFG[ BF[8L DFlCTL
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
170/273
!5# YL ZH]
JW]DF\ T5F;GLX[
VFZP8LPVF[P
GS,
T[VF[V[ D[/J[,
H[ OZLIFN
51F[ VF\S !&& YL ZH] YI[, K[P T5F;GLXGF 5]ZFJF D]HA VFZF[5L
lJZ]wW 5]ZTF 5]ZFJF H6FTF\ RFH"XL8 SZ[,P VG[ VFZF[5LG[ T[VF[V[ V8S
SZ[, CF[.4 VF[/BTF CF[. 4 VFZF[5LG[ SF[8" Z]AZ] VF[/BL ATFJ[, K[P
!_(
. //
,
. ". JW]DF\ T5F;GLX[ H6FJ[, K[ S[
4 TFPZ*qZq!# GF ZF[H VFZF[5L lJ:DI XFC CFHZ YTF\ T[GL VF[/B
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
171/273
OZLIFNL ,,LT U]%TFGL CFHZLDF\ SZFJ[, CTL VG[ T[ VF[/B V\U[G\] VF\S
($ G]\ 5\RGFD] SZ[, CT] VG[ OZLIFNL
CF[JFG]
:5Q856[
O,LT
YFI
K[P
;FY[
Z]AZ]
SZFJJFDF\ VFJ[,
CF[JFGF[ OZLIFN
CF,GF T5F;GLXGL
V[OPV[;PV[,P
172/273
U]%TF4
TFZLB
zL TF[DZ
;JFZGF ;F0F GJ JFU[ J:T|F5]Z 5F[P:8[P DF\ VFJ[,F CTFP T[ lNJ;[ ;JFZ[
VF9 JFU[ 5F[P:8[P DF\ VFJL UI[,F CTF zL TF[DZ T[ lNJ;[ ;F\H ;]WL
5F[P:8[PDF\ ZF[SFI[,FP
!!Z
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
173/273
;]WL
T[VF[
VFZF[5L
;FY[
CTFP
U]gCFGF[
VFZF[5L
CTF[ T[JL VF[/B T[VF[V[ VG[ TF[DZ ;FC[A[ DL0LIF ;D1F HFC[Z SZFJL
NLW[,]\ CT\]P
!!#
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
174/273
K[ S[4 S[F. VFZ[F5LGF XZLZ p5Z N[BL XSFI T[JL S[F. .HFGF
lGXFG S[ lRCGF[ CF[I TF[ T[GL GF[W VFZF[5LG[ V8S SZTF\ ;DI[ SZJL
HZ]ZL K[PVFJL GF[W VFZF[5LGF RC[ZF lGXFG5T|SDF\ SZJFGL CF[I K[P
;FC[N[ JW]DF\ H6FJ[, K[ S[4 RC[ZF lGXFG 5T|SDF\ VFJL GF[W SZTF\
5C[,F\ VFZF[5LGF XZLZ p5Z .HFGF SF[. lRCGF[ S[ ALHF SF[. GF[W 5FT|
lGXFG K[ S[ S[D T[ HF[J]\ 50[P JW]DF\ ;FC[N[ H6FJ[, K[S[4
RFH"XL8
;FY[ ZH] YI[, V;, RC[ZF lGXFG 5T|S ATFJJFDF\ VF[J[ K[ T[ HF[.G[
H6FJ[, K[ S[ T[DF\ T[VF[GL ;CL K[ VG[ T[DF\ lJUTF[ EZ[, K[P H[ ARFJ
51F[ VF\S !&( YL p,8T5F; NZdIFG ZH] YI[, K[P T5F;GLX[ JW]DF\
V[J] \:JLSFZ[, K[ S[ 4 VFZF[5LGL XFlZZLS T5F; SZGFZ
R[,FEF. 58[,
0F[P X{,[QF
;FC[N
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
175/273
H6FJ[
K[
S[
VFZP8LPVF[P
VF[lO;Z
VG[
V[OV[;V[,
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
176/273
VlWSFZLG[ SF[.
s5F8"vZ
fGF[
pDZ[F
SZL
NLW[,F[
CTF[P
V,AT
S,FS Zq#_ JFuIF 5KL ,BL ,LW[, CTF VG[ ;DI 5FK/YL ,BL
N[JFDF\ VFJ[, CTF[P
!!(
T[VF[G[
H[ lJUTF[
HF[.TL CTL
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
177/273
DF[8Z ;FIS,JF/F ;S", J8FJLG[ UI[, CF[T TF[ T[JF ;\HF[UF[DF\ SFZGL
UlT wIFGDF\ ,[TF\ VS:DFT lGJFZL XSFI[, CF[T S[ S[D T[ V\UG
[ F[ S[F.
VlE5|FI lGQ6FTF[ 5{SL SF[.GL 5F;[ DF\U[, G CTF[P JW]DF\ T5F;GLX[
H6FJ[, K[ S[4DF[8Z ;FIS, RF,S VG[ 5FK/ A[;GFZ[
5C[Z[JL
HZ]ZL
K[
VG[
5C[ZL
CF[I
TF[
C[<D[8
D[FPjCLPV[P
H6FJ[, K S
[ [4 VDNFJFN GF XC[ZL lJ:TFZ 5{SL S[8,F[S lJ:TFZ U|FdI
SF[8"GL CS]DTDF\ 56 VFJ[ K[P AGFJJF/L HuIF U|FdiF SF[8"GL CS]DTD\F
VFJT]\ CF[JFG]\ GF[8LOLS[XG T[V[FV[ H[FI[, K[P
!!(P!
VF\S
!!5 GF
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
178/273
VFZF[5L CF[JF DFT| SFZ6YL VFZF[5L lJZ]wW RFH"XL8 SZ[, K[P JW]D\F
T5F;GLX[ H6FJ[, K[ S[4 VFZF[5LGF RFg;l5|g8 sCFYGF OLUZl5|g8f
,LW[, CTFPJW]DF\ ;FC[N[ :JLSFZ[, K[ S[4
T5F;GF SFD[ ,LW[, CTFP
8[IZLU jCL,4 ULIZ S[ T[GF NZJFHF p5ZGF OL\UZ l5|g8 ,LW[, CTF
S[ S[D T[ T[VF[G[ VtIFZ[ IFN GYLP
!Z_
JW]DF\ T5F;GLX[
VZHL
VT|G
[ L SF[8[" GFD\H]Z SZTF\ 4VT|[GL
SF[8"GF C]SD lJZ}wW GFDNFZ CF.SF[8" DF\ :5[P lS|DLG, V[%,LS[XG G\AZ
5_!ZqZ_!$ VG[ 5_!#qZ_!$ GF SFD[ YI[, C]SD VG];FZ VT|[GL
S[F8"GF[ C]SD ZN SZL4 OF[HNFZL SFI"ZLTL VlWlGIDGL S,D !*#s(f
D]HA JW] T5F;
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
179/273
T5F;GLXG[ C]SD
;FC[NF[G[ T5F;L4
YIF AFN
p5ZGF 5]ZFJFDF\ H6FjIF D]HA T[VF[ U]HZFT 8[,LJLhG 5|FP ,LP DF\
R[G, C[0 TZLS[ Z__& YL Z_!! ;]WL 4 tIFZAFN ;G[ Z_!Z YL OZH
AHFJ[ K[P VF U]HZFT 8[,LJLhG 5|FP,LP A[ R[G,F[ s!f U]HZFT gI]h
R[G, Z__&YL VG[ sZf lGDF"6 gI]h R[G, Z_!$ YL R,FJ[ K[P JW]DF\
;FC[N[ H6F[J[, K[S[4 HL8L5LV[,GL VF[lO; XFCLAFUDF\4 ;CHFG\N
SF[d5,[1FDF\ GJDF DF/[ VFJ[, K[P VF A\gG[ R[G, RF[JL; S,FS RF,] ZC[
K[ 4H[DF\ ,F[SD\R H[JF SFI"S|D 56 ATFJJFDF\ VFJ[ K[ PVF
,F[SD\RGF[ SFI"S|D ;G[ Z__* YL XZ] SZ[, K[ P ,F[SD\RGF[ SFI"S|D
;F[DJFZYL XlGJFZ ;]WL ZF[H ZFTGF VF9 JFU[ VG[ ZL5L8 ZFTGF ;F0F
N; JFU[ VG[ ALHF lNJ;[ A5F[Z[ ;F0F T|6 JFU[ ZL5L8 SZJFDF\ VFJ[ K[P
!ZZP!
DZ6 HGFZ
XLJD
VG[ ZFC], GF l5TFG[ AF[,FJJF 5|ItG SZ[, CTF[P 5Z\T]\ ZFC],G]\ T[ lNJ;[
;JFZ[ H D'tI] YI[, CT]\ T[YL ZFC],GF l5TF VFJL XS[,F G CTFP 5Z\T4]
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
180/273
XLJDGF l5TF 5|[DX\SZEF. VFJ[,F CTFP T[DGL ;FY[ AGFJ GHZ[ HF[GFZ
,,LT U]%TF VFJ[, CTFP JW]DF\ ;FC[NGF H6FjIF D]HA T[VF[V[ T[VF[GF
V[gSZ NL,L5EF. N[;F.G[ ;]RGF VF5[, CTL S[ VF U[:8 ;FY[ cc 8F[S
XF[ cc SZJFGF[ K[P NL,L5EF.V[ VF A[ U[:8 ;FY[ 5|FYlDS RRF" SZ[,L
VG[ tIFZAFN :8]0LIF[DF\ ,. UI[, CTFP ;FC[NGF H6FjIF D]HA T[VF[
cc 8F[S XF[cc ;DI[ T[V[FGL R[dAZD\F CTFPVFD4 p5ZF[ST ;FC[NGF[ 5]ZFJF[
wIFGDF\ ,[TF\4 CF,GF VS:DFTGF S[;G[ wIFGDF\ ,. TFPZ*qZqZ_!#
GF ZF[H V[S 8F[S XF[ UF[9JJFG]\ VFIF[HG SZJFD\F VFJ[, VG[ T[DF\ V[gSZ
TZLS[ NL,L5EF. JZJFEF. N[;F.
,,LT
5]ZF[ YIF AFN H V[gSZ VG[ U[:8 :8]0LIF[DF\YL ACFZ VFJ[ K[P JW]DF\
;FC[N[ H6FJ[, K[ S[4 VFJF 5|F[U|FDG]\ ,F.J 8[,LSF:8 YFI K[P T[G]\
Z[SF[0L"U 5LP;LPVFZPs5|F[0SXG S\g8=[F, Z]Df DF\ YFI K[ VG[ tI\FYL ,F.J
8[,LSF:8 YFI K[P VF 5LP;LPVFZPDF\ Z[SF[0L"U YI[, 0[8F VF[KFDF\ VF[KF
5F\R JZ; ;]WL %,[ :8[XGDF\ ZFB[ K[P JW]DF\ ;FC[N[ H6FJ[, K[ S[4
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
181/273
VF
%,[ :8[XGGGF :8F[Z[H DF\YL 0LJL0L ZF.8 SZLG[ VF5[, CTLP CF, 56
VF cc 8F[S XF[cc GF[ VF[ZLHG, 0[8F %,[ :8[XGGF :8F[Z[H OL0DF\ K[P
JW]DF\ ;FC[NGF H6FjIF D]HA 5F[,L;G[ H[ 0LJL0L VF5[,L CTL
T[ VF\S !(5 TYF VF\S !(& YL ZH] YI[, 0LJL0L H[ 0LJL0LGF[ ;[8
5F[,L;G[ VF5[, CTF[ T[ VF[/BL ATFJ[, K[P
!ZZP#
VF ;8L"OLS[8DF\ T
[ [VF[GL TYF 8[SGLS, C[0 VFXLQFEF.
UHHZ[ ;CL SZ[, CTLP H[ ;8L"OLS[8 VF\S !)_YL ZH] K[ T[ T[VF[V[ VF5[,
CF[JFG]\ H6FJ[, K[ H[DF\ T[VF[GL S\5GLG]\ ,F[U[F ;FY[G]\ ;LSSF[ ,UFJ[, K[P
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
182/273
T[VF[V[
8LPJLP5|;FZ6 DFwID
TFZLB Z*q!qZ_!5 GF
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
183/273
AGFJJFDF\
VFJ[
TF[
0LJL0LGF
0[8F
R[0F\
JF/F
SC[JFI
;FC[N[ B],F;F[ SZTF\ H6FJ[, K[ S[4 ;J"Z ;FY[ R[[0F\ SZJF XSI H GYL4
SFZ6 S[ T[DF\ 5F;J0" C[FI K[ VG[ ;J"ZGF[ 0[8F ;]Z1FLT C[FI K[P ;J"ZGF
5F;J0"GL
HF6SFZL
VDFZF
8[SGLS,
C[0G[
CF[I
K[P
;FC[N
T[VF[GL SR[ZLDF\
VFJLG[ VFJF ;J"ZG[ ;FC[NGL CFHZLDF\ R[S SZ[, G CT]\P JW]DF\ ;FC[NGF
H6FjIF D]HA ;J"Z V[ SF[d%I]8Z ;FY[ ;\S/FI[, .,[S8=F[GLS ;FWG K[P
;J"Z 5L;LVFZ Z]DDF\ ZFBJFDF \ VFJ[ K[ HIF\ RFZ 5F\R DF6;F[ A[;
[ K[ VG[ lNJ; NZdIFG T|6 5F/LGF D/L S],AFZ 5\NZ DF6;F[ A[;[ K[P
JW]DF\ ;FC[N[ :JLSFZ[, K[ S[4 T[VF[GF 5|F[U|FD GF[ 0[8F ;J"ZDF\ ;\U|CLT
YFI K[P VG[ ;J"Z ZC[,F 5|FIDZL 0[8F p5ZYL 0LJL0L T{IFZ SZJFDF\
VFJ[, CTLP JW]DF\ ;FC[N[H6FJ[, K[ S[4 ;J"ZDF\ ZC[,L lJUTF[ ;FC[NGL
CFHZLDF\ HF[I[, G CTL JW]DF\ ;FC[N[ V[ CSLST :JLSFZ[, K[ S[4 ;J"ZDF\
ZC[,F 0[8F ;FY[ R[0F\ SZJFDF VFJ[ VG[ T[GF p5ZYL 0LJL0L AGFJJFDF\
VFJ[ TF[ T[ 0LJL0L GF 0[8F R[0F\ JF/F SC[JFI P;FC[N[ :5Q8TF SZTF\
H6FJ[, K[ S[ ;J"Z ;FY[ R[0F\ SZJF XSI GYLP SFZ6 S[ T[G[F 5F;J0"
CF[I K[P VG[ T[YL ;JZGF[ 0[8F ;]Zl1FT CF[I K[P ;J"ZGF[ 5F;J0" R[G, C[0
5F;[ CF[I K[P VG[ T[VF[GF l;JFI SF[. ;J"ZDF\YL SF[. HF6SFZL ,. XS[
GlC ;FC[N[ JW]DF\ H6FJ[, K[S[4 TFPZ!q!qZ_!5 GF ZF[H
5F[,L;
[ SZ[,L 5]K5ZK SZ[,L T[ S[8,F[ ;DI RF,[, T[ ;FC[NG[ IFN GYLP JW]DF\
;FC[N[ H6FJ[, K[ S[4
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
184/273
A[ 5\RF[ 56
JL0LIF[U|FOZ[ JL0LIF[U|FOL 56
SZ[,L CTLP JL0LIF[U|FOL ;DIGL N=lQ8V[ S[8,F[ ;DI RF,[, T[GF[ bIF,
GYLP ;FC[N[ JW]DF\ H6FJ[, K[ S[ 4 5\RGFDFG\]\ ,BF6 5\RF[ ,BFJTF CTF
VG[ ZF.8Z ,BTF CTFP VF ,BFT\] CT]\ tIFZ[ ;FC[N T[VF[GL R[dAZDF\
CTF[
5\RGFD\] T[VF[GL
51F[ VF\S !($ YL ZH] YI[, K[ P VG[ T[GF 5\R ;FC[N s ;FC[N G\A Z
Z&f lCDF\X ]\ NXZYEF. GFISG[ VF\S !(# YL T5F;JFDF\ VFJ[,F
K[P
TFZLB
Z!q!qZ_!5 GF ZF[H
185/273
5NDSF\TEF.
GFDGF
DF6;
CTF
P5NDSF\TEF.V[
A[
0LJL0L
T[
H[GF
V[gSZ
NL,L5EF.
JZJFEF.
,F[SD\RGF SFI"SD
N[;F.
CTF
R[G, DF\ gI]h V[gSZ TZLS[ K[<,F 5F\R JZ;YL GF[SZL SZ[ K[ U]HZFT
gI]h R[G,GL VF[lO; ;CHFG\N SF[d5,[1F4 :JFDLGFZFI6 D\lNZ ;FD[4
XFCLAFU VDNFJFN
R[G,DF\ Z__* YL
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
186/273
JFU[ HLJ\T 5|;FZLT SZJFDF\ VFJ[ K[P ZFT|LGF ;F0F N; JFU[ VG[ ALHF
lNJ;[ A5F[ZGF ;F0F T|6JFU[ 5]Go 5|;FZ6 SZJFDF\ VFJ[ K[P SZ\8
8F[5LSDF\ 38GF ;\A\WL H[ jIlST CF[I T[G[ VD[ AF[,FJLV[ KLV[P H[G[
T[VF[ U[:8 SC[ K[P
!Z$P!
XLJD lJX[
T[ XLJDGF l5TF
5|xGF[ 5]K,
[ F CTFP
AWF\
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
187/273
VG[ TD[ X]\ HF[I[,P T[GF HJFADF\ ,,LT U]%TFV[ H6FJ[,]\ S[ XLJD
3JFI[,F[ CTF[ VG[ ZFC],G[ 56 JFU[,]\ CT]P ;FC[NGF JW] 5]ZFJF VG];FZ
T[VF[V[ ,,LT U]%TFG[ 5]K[,]\ S[ :Y/ p5Z TDG[ SF[6[ DNN SZ[,L m
,,LT U]%TFV[ H6FJ[,]\ S[ SF[.V[ DNN SZ[,L G CTL4 ALPV[DP 0A<I]
hF0 ;FY[ VY0FI[,4 VD], 5F,"Z CT] tIF\ hF0 CT]\ T[GL
;FY[ VY0FI[,4 ALPV[DP 0A<I] DF\YL EF. lJ:DI VFJ[, VG[ ;F[ZL
;F[ZL SC[,4 T[ JBT[ T[VF[V[ lJ:DIG[ HF[I[,F[ P ;FC[NGF H6FjIF D]HA
T[VF[V[ ,,LT
CTF[P HJFADF\
,,LT
,,LT
CTF[ H[YL
JW]DF\
HJFADF\ ,,LT U]%TFV[ H6FJ[,]\ S[4 SF[. A\N]S D]SX[ S[ S[F.56 WDSL
D/X[
TF[ 56 C]\ GlC OZ]\P T[DG[ 5]K[,]\ S[ TD[ lJ:DIG[ VF[/B[,F[ mTF[
J6"G SZ[, CT]P ,,LT U]%TFV[ 4 lJ:DI[ X]\ 5C[Z[, CT]\ T[ H6FJ[,
VG[ T[GF[ O[;S8 IFN CF[JFG]\ H6FJ[, CT]\P
!Z$PZ
U]%TFFG]\ HL8L5LV[,
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
188/273
HF[I[, CTF[ H[ 5\NZ[S ;[Sg0 H[8,]\ ZF[SFI[, CTF[P VG[ T[ OZLIFNLG[ IFN
C[FJFG]\ OZLIFNLV[ HFC[Z SZ[, K[P
!Z5
CF[JFGL CSLST 56 ARFJ 51F Z[S0" p5Z ,FJL XS[, GYLP VG[ T[YL
;FC[N G\AZ Z( V[gSZ NL,L5EF. JZJFEF. V[ ;FC[N G\AZ !! 4
OZLIFNLV[
VG[ T[YL T[VF[GF[ T[JF[ 5]ZFJF[ GlC DFGJFG[ S[F. SFZ6 GYLP
T[JF[ 5]ZFJF[ wIFGDF\ ,[TF\
T[YL
GYL VG[ G[RZ, C[FI K[P VF SFI"S|D 5]ZF[ YIF AFN T[VF[V[ T[G]\ Z[SF[0L"U
HF[I[, G CT]\ 4 5Z\T]\ 5\NZ JL; lNJ; 5C[,F\ 4 5NDSF\TEF.V[ SC[, T[YL
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
189/273
;FC[N[
CF,GF ;FC[N[ VF\S !(& s D]NFDF, VF8L"S, G\AZ & JF/L f 0LJL0L
SF[8"GF SF[d%I]8Z lJEFUGF ,[58F[5 p5Z VF[5Z[8 SZL ATFJTF\
T[ HF[.G[ ;FC[N[ H6FJ[, K[
,F[SD\R GF[ SFI"S|D NZdIFG YI[, 5|F[U|FDG]\ Z[SF[0L"U K[P H[DF\ R[S;
X8"JF/F ,,LT U]%TF K[ VG[ ALHF U[:8 K[ T[ 5|[DX\SZEF. NJ[ K[
PJW]DF\ ;NZ ;FC[N
,F[SD\R SFI"S|DG]\ H[ Z[SF[0L"U YI[, T[GL ZL8G" :S|L%8 K[P ;FC[N G\AZ
Z( GF VF[V[ H[VF[G]\ .g8Z>jI\] ,LW\] CT\] T[DF\ ;FC[N G\AZ !!
OZLIFNL ,,LT U]%TF C[FJFG]\ :5Q856[ O,LT YFI K[P p5ZF[ST ;FC[N
G\AZ Z( GF VF[V[ H6FJ[, K[ S[ TFPZ#q!qZ_!5 GF ZF[H T[VF[G]\
J:T|F5]Z 5F[,L; lGJ[NG ,LW[, CT]\P
!Z*
DF\
5LPVF.P
ZF6F
;FC[A4
8F.5
SZGFZ
ZF.8Z
VG[ JL0LIF[ Z[SF[0L"U JF/F CTFP JW]DF\ ;FC[NGF H6FjIF D]HA T[VF[
5F[P:8[P DF\ UIF VG[ UIF AFN 5F\R ;FT DLGL8 5KL JL0LIF[ Z[SF[0L"U XZ\]
YI[, CT]\P T[DH T[VF[V[ 5[FP:8[P KF[0I\] T[GL VFXZ[ N;[S DLGL8 5C[,F\
JL0LIF[ Z[SF[0L"U A\W SZ[,]\P ZF.8Z SF[6 CTF T[G]\ GFD T[VF[ HF6TF GYLP
JW]DF\ ;FC[NGF H6FjIF D]HA ZF6F ;FC[A T[VF[G[ 5]KTF CTF4 VG[
T[VF[ HJFA VF5TF CTF VG[ ZF.8Z 8F.5 SZTF CTF PJW]DF\ ;FC[NGF
H6FjIF D]HA T[VF[G[ S[F. 0LJL0L 56 VF[5Z[8 SZL ATFJJFDF\ VFJ[,L
G CTLP T[DH ,F[SD\RGF 5|F[U|FDGL 0LJL0L 56 VF[5Z[8 SZL ATFJJFDF\
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
190/273
VFJ[,L G CTL PT[ H ZLT[ ,F[S D\R GF 5|F[U|FDGF Z[SF[0L"UGL ,B[, :S|L%8
56 5F[P :8[P DF\ ATFJJFDF\ VFJ[,L G CTL P
!Z*P!
8]0LIF[ p5Z 5CF[R[,F CTF VG[ VFXZ[ 5F[6F GJ vGJ ;]WL ZF[SFIF CTFP
T[VF[
0LJL0L
HF[.G[ R[S; JF/F X8" JF/L jIlST G[ ,,LT U]%TF TZLS[ VF[/BL
ATFJ[, K[ T[ jIlSTG[
,F[SD\RGF SFI"S|D
HF6DF\ GYLP
VG[ T[ l;JFI ,F[SD\R p5ZF\T SF[. 8F[S XF[ CF[I TF[ 56 V[gSZL\U SZ[ K[P
JW]DF\4 ;FC[NGF 5]ZFJF VG];FZ
V[gSZLUG]\ SFD
T[VF[
VG]EJYL
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
191/273
K[ T[VF[GF
,F[SD\RGF
DL0LIFYL
SFI"S|D
5C[,F\
8LPJLP
CSLSTF[
HF6[,L
VG[ 38GF :Y/GF N=xIF[ 8LJL p5Z 8[,LSF:8 YI[,F HF[I[,F CTFP
JW]DF\ ;FC[NH
[ 6FJ[, K[S[4 VF 38GFJF?FF AGFJGL 5F[,L; T5F; RF,]
K[ T[
:S|L%8 5|DF6[
SF[. ,B[,L
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
192/273
;FY[ ;FY[
:S|L%8 5|DF6[
T[VF[G[ 5|xGF[
T[GF
,,LT
!Z(P$
!Z(P5
,,LT
U]%TF V[ HJFA VF5[,F[ S[ VS:DFT YIF[ tIFZ[ T[VF[ AWF\ lDT|F[ ;FY[ H
CTFcc T[JL CSLST ,BFJ[, CTL S[ S[D T[ IFN GYL P
!Z(P&
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
193/273
ccD[ ,,LTU]%TFG[ 5]K[,]\ S[ 38GF :Y/[ X]\ YI[, VG[ TD[ X]\ HF[I[,4
HJFADF\
5]K5ZK
SZ[,
CTL
S[
S[D
T[
VtIFZ[
IFN
GYL
P;FC[N[ V[ CSLSTGF[ .gSFZ SZ[,F[ K[ S[4 T[VF[V[ 4 ,,LT U]%TF VG[ ALHF
H[ U[:8 CTF T[VF[V[ VG[ T[VF[GL ;\:YF TYF 5F[,L;[ E[UF\ D/L VFZF[5L
lJZ]wW BF[8F 5]ZFJF pEF SZJF DF8[ VF 5|F[U|FDGL lJUTF[ :S|L%8GF
DFwIDYL BF[8L pEL SZ[, K[P
!Z(P(
VFD p5ZF[ST
;FC[N[
T[DH
T[VF[V[ H[ HJFA[F
5NDSF\gTEF.
VZlJNGUZ4;FAZDTL
:S],
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
194/273
UF0LDF\
SF[d5,[1F DF\ 4
VG[
;FC[A[ ,LW[, CT]\ VG[ T[GL 5LPVF.P 5;"G, Z]DD\F JL0LIF[U|FOL SZ[,L
CTL PVF A\gG[ JL0LIF[U|FOLGL V,U V,U A[ ;LP0LP 4 NZ[SGF A[ ;[8DF\
ZF6F ;FC[AG[ VF5[, CTLP VF A\gG[ ;L0LP TFZLB Z(q!qZ_!5 GF
ZF[H ZF6F ;FC[AG[ T[V[FV[ HFT[ VF5[,L CTL PVF NZ[S SFDULZL AN,G]\
ZF6F ;FC[A[ T[V[FGF
Z!q!q!54
TFZLB P
lGJ[NG ,[JFIF CTFP JW]D\F ;FC[N[ T[VF[V[ VF5[, T|6 ;LP0LP VF[/BL
ATFJ[, K[ VG]S|D[ T|6[I
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
195/273
;L0L ,[58F[5 p5Z VF[5Z[8 SZL T[VF[G[ ATFJTF\ ;FC[NGF H6FjIF D]HA
T[
CF[JFGL
lTDLZ
H[
S[D[ZFYL
JL0LIF[U|FOL
SZ[,L
T[
S[D[ZFGF[
p5I[FU
196/273
NF[- S,FS H[JL JL0LIF[U|FOL SZ[,L CTLP 5Z\T] ;FY[ ;FY[ ;FC[N[ V[J]\
H6FJ[, K S
[ [4 JL0LIF[U|FOL DF8[GF[ SF[. ;DI S[D[ZFDF\ ;[8 SZ[,F[ G
CTF[P T[DH S[D[ZFDF\ 8F.D ;[8 SZ[,F[ G CF[.4 JL0LIF[U|FOLG]\ Z[SF[0L"U
HF[.G[4 T[ Z[SF[0L"U S[8,F JFU[ XZ] SZL4 S[8,F JFU[ 5]Z] SZ[, T[ SCL XSFI
GlCP
!#!
JW]DF\ ;FC[N[ H6FJ[, K[ S[4 VF\S !)& JF/L ;LP0LP ,[58F[5 DF\
VF[5Z[8 SZL ATFJJFDF\
T[
HF[.
SFZDF\YL ZFC],
197/273
p,8T5F;
NZdIFG
p5ZF[ST
tIFZAFN
;FC[N[
ZFC],
S[
cc
VG[
tIFZAFN
;NZC]
lJZ]wWGF[ S[ B\0GSTF" SF[. CSLST H6FJL CF[I T[J]\ DFGL XSFI T[D
GYLP
!#Z
lGJ[NG
,[JFT]\
CT]\
tIFZ[ ZF6F ;FC[A 5]KTF\ CTF VG[ lN,L5EF. HJFA VF5TF CTF VG[ T[
;F\E/L ZF.8Z SF[d%I]8Z p5Z 8F.5 SZTF CTFP ZF6F ;FC[A l;JFI ALH]\
SF[. 5]KT]\ G CT]\P VF H[ 5|xGF[TZL VG[ HJFA YTF\ CTF T[ D]HA SF[d%I]8Z
p5Z 8F.5 YT]\ CT]\ PVFD p5ZF[ST ;FC[NGF[ 5]ZFJF[ HF[.X] TF[ ;FC[N G\AZ
Z* VG[ Z(GF lGJ[NG ,[T\F ;DIG]\ T[DH ,F[SD\RGF SFI"S|DGL A[ 0LJL0L
5\RGFD] SZL SAH[ SZ[, T[GL JLOLIF[U|FOL SZ[, CF[JFG]\ :5Q856[ O,LT
YFI K[P
!##
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
198/273
V[OPV[;PV[,P UF\WLGUZDF\
0LJL0L ;FY[ H[ ZJFGUL GF[W VF5[, CTL T[GL :Y/5|T 4 VF\S Z_5 GL
5CF[R ;FY[ ZH] YI[, K[ T[ 5LPVF.P V[DPS[P ZF6FV[ T{IFZ SZ[,L CTL
VG[ T[DF\ T[VF[GL ;CL K[ T[GL :Y/5|T VF\S Z_& YL SFD[ ZH] YI[,
K[P ;FC[NGF H6FjIF D]HA 0LJL0L V[OPV[;PV[,PDF\ ;F[5[, T[ D]NFDF,
VF8L"S, G\AZ & JF/L 0LPJLP0LP H[ VF\S !(( JF/L CF[JFG\] H6FJ[, K[P
VFD p5ZF[ST ;FC[NGF 5]ZFJF VG];FZ VF\S Z_& GL ZJFGUL GF[W
VG[ VF\S Z_5GL 5CF[R ;FY[ VF\S !(( JF/L 0LJL0L V[OPV[;PV[,P
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
199/273
V[OV[;V[,
DF\
;FC[N G\A Z #_
8[SGLS,
C[0
TZLS[
K[<,F
JZ;YL
OZH
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
200/273
VF 5|F[U|FDGF Z[SF[0L"UGL
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
201/273
5NDSF\gTEF.V[ T[VF[GF
;NZ
;FC[N
G\AZ
Z)
GL
ARFJ
51F[
SZ[,
GL
202/273
GF ZF[H
CFHZ YI[,
VG[ T[G[ V8S SZJFDF\ VFJ[, CT[FP VFD VFZF[5LG[ V8S SIF" AFN
VFZF[5LGF[ OF[8F[ 8LJL DF\ 5|;FZLT YI[, C[FJF DFT| YL VFZF[5LG[ SF[.
5]J"U|C YTF[ CF[JFG]\ DFGL XSFI GlCP
!#$P*
T[VF[GL U[ZCFHZLDF\
CFHZ C[FI
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
203/273
tIF\ ;]WL ;J"ZGF[ p5IF[U T[VF[ SZ[ K[ ALHF S[F. SZL XS[ GlCPT[DH
T[VF[ CFHZ C[FI VG[ ALHF SFDDF\ CF[ITF[ T[VF[GF SC[JFYL :8FO GF ALHF
SF[. jIlST p5IF[U SZ[ K[P ;J"Z GF[ p5IF[U SZJF DF8[ 5F;J0" C[FI K[P
VF 5F;J0"GL ;FC[NG[ HF6 C[FI K[ 4T[ p5ZF\T T[VF[GF 5L;LVFZ
GF :8FOG[ 56 VF 5F;J0"GL HF6 C[FI K[P;FC[N[ V[ CSLST :JLSFZ[,
K[S[4
JW]]DF\ ;FC[N[ H6FJ[, K[S[4 V[0L8LU SZJ] V[8,[ S[4 SF[. Z[SF[0"
YI[, 5|F[U|FD DF\ SF5S]5 SZJL VG[ pD[ZJFGF[ ;DFJ[X Y. HFI K[P
;J"ZDF\ SF[. V[0L8LU G Y. XS[ OST :8F[Z YFIP JW]DF\ ;FC[NGF
H6FjIF D]HA
VFD4 p5ZF[ST 5|xG 5]KL ARFJ 51F V[J]\ ATFJJF 5|ItG SZ[, K[S[
,F[SD\R GF SFI"S|DGF 5[|FU|FDG]]\ \Z[SF[0L"U H[ ;J"ZDF\ :8F[Z SZ[, CT]\ T[
;J"ZGF[ 5F;J0" CF,GF ;FC[N 8[SGLS, C[0 l;JFI ALHF 5LP;LPVFZ P
:8FO DF6;F[ 5F;[ 56 CF[. T[ ;J"ZGF[ :8F[Z SZ[, 0[8F ;FY[ R[0F\
YJFGL XSITF ZC[, K[P 5Z\T]\ CF,GF ;FC[N l;JFI VgiF SF[. 5LP;LPVFZ
P :8FOGL jIlSTV[ 5F;J0"GF[ p5IF[U SZL ;J"ZGF[ 0[8F HF[I[, CF[I
S[ S[F. V[0L8LU SZ[, CF[I
JW]DF\ CF,GF ;FC[NGF 5]ZFJF D]HA 56 ;JZDF\ :8F[Z SZ[, 0[8FDF\ SF[.
V[0L8LU Y. XST] GYLP VFD p5ZF[ST ;DU| 5]ZFJF[ wIFGDF\ ,[TF\4
,F[SD\RGF SFI"S|DGF[ 0[8F ;J"ZDF\ :8F[Z YI[, CTF[ T[GF ;FY[ S[F. R[0F\
YI[, CF[I T[J]\ DFGL XSFI T[JF[ SF[. 5]ZFJF[ Z[S0" p5Z ARFJ 51F ,FJL
XS[, GYL P
!#$P!_
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
204/273
GAZ # GF VF[V[ VF\S !#5 VG[ !#& GL VZHLVF[ ;FY[ ZH] SZ[, VF\S
Z__ JF0L
T[ H[F.G[
;FC[N[ H6FJ[, K[
S[4
VF\S !(5
T[ H N=xIF[ VG[
;\JFNF[ VG[ T[JF V[S ;ZBF CF[. T[ ;L0L K[ P5Z\T]\ ;FC[N[ H6FJ[, K[ S[ 4
VF\S Z__ JF/L 0LJL0L SF[. 3GxIFDEF. DFWJ,F, 58[, GFDGL
jIlSTG[ VF5[, C[FI T[J]\ AG[, G CT\]P VFD OZLIFN 51F[ ;FC[N G\AZ
s#f 3GxIFDEF. DFWJ,F, 58[, GF VF[V[ VF\S !#5 VG[ VF\S !#&
GL VZHLVF[ ;FY[ ZH] SZ[, 0LJL0L CF,GF ;FC[N[ VF5[, CF[I T[J]\ H6FT\]
GYLP JW]DF\
NZdIFG V[gSZ NL,L5EF. N[;F. 5F[TFGF 5F;[ SFU/ p5Z GHZ GF\BTF
CF[I 4
VG[ ;\JFN RF,TF[ CF[I VG[ VG[ CFYDF\ 5[G C[FI T[J]\ VFBF
205/273
HF[TF\
VF\S !(5
VG[ VF\S !(& JF/L 0LJL0L 4 SF[d%I]8Z 0[8F p5ZYL T{IFZ SZJFDF
VFJ[, CF[JFG]\ H6FI K[P HIFZ[ ;FC[NGF 5]ZFJF D]HA 5|F[U|FDGF Z[SF[0L"U
0[8F ;J"ZDF\ :8F[Z SZ[, CTF[ P T[YL ;FC[N[ :5Q8TF SZ<TF\ H6FJ[, K[ S[4
;J"ZDF\YL 0[8F
0LJL0L
AGFJ[, CTLP
VG[ T[YL VF\S !)_ GF ;8L"OLS[8DF\ SF[d%I]8Z 0[8F p5ZYL ;L0LP T{IFZ
SZ[, CF[JFG]\ ,B[, T[ DFT| YL T[GF U]6NF[QF DF\ SF[. OS" 50TF[ GYLP
!#$P!Z
5F[,L;[
,FIA|[ZL
:8F[Z[HDF\YL
VDFZF
TFZLB
cc H[ 0LJL0L D[
R[G,
C[0
zL
CTFP
VG[ T[DF\YL
0LJL0L GF
A[ ;[8
CF,GF
;FC[N[ T{IFZ SZL4 R[G, C[0 5NDSF\gTEF.G[ VF5[, C[FJFG]\ O,LT YFI
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
206/273
K[P
!#$P!#
VFD
VG[ VF\S !(& YL ZH] YI[, 0LJL0L R[G,GF ;JZDF\ :8F[Z SZ[, 0[8F
p5ZYL S[
T{IFZ SZJFDF\ VFJ[, CTL T[ V\U[ lJZF[WFEF; H6FI K[P 5Z\T]\ T[8,F
DFT|YL CF,GF ;FC[NGF[ 5]ZFJF[ VlJxJ;GLI U6L XSFI GlCP
!#5
OZLIFN 51FGF SYG D]HA OZLIFN 51F[ ZH] YI[, VF\S !(&
JF/L
;FC[N G\A Z #Z
lGZH
VZlJ\N EF.
207/273
T[
!#5PZ
VFJ[, K[ TYF T[GL V\NZGL OF.,F[ ;FY[ SF[. K[0KF0 YI[, K[ S[ S[D T[G]\
5ZL1F6 SZ[, CT]\P JW]D\F ;FC[NGF H6FjIF D]HA VF 5ZL1F6 DF\ ;NZ
0LJL0L DFS" vV[cc V[S H ,[IZ DF\ ,BFI[, CTL H[YL T[GL V\NZ VgI
SF[. OF., V[S JBT ,BFIF 5KL OZLJFZ V[0L8 S[ 0L,L8 V[8,[ S[ S[F.
56 HFTGF ;]WFZF JWFZF YI[, G CTFPVFD p5ZF[ST ;FC[NGF 5]ZFJF
G[ wIFG[ ,[TF\4 DFS" V[ JF/L 0LJL0L VF\S !(& JF/L 0LJL0L DF\
SF[. ;]WFZF JWFZF YI[,F G CF[JFG]\ :5Q856[ O,LT YFI K[P
!#5P#
JW]D\F ;FIg8LOLS
H[DF\
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
208/273
OF.,DF\
GF[ p5IF[U SZ[,F[ CTF[P VF OF.,DF\ p5IF[UDF\ ,[JFI[, NZ[S JL0LIF[ T[GF
XZ] YIF VG[ 5]ZF[ YIF[ T[ JrR[ SF[.56 5|SFZGL K[0KF0 HF[JF D/[, G
CTLP ;FY[ ;FY[ VF OF.,DF\ H[ VF[0LIF[ CTL T[DF\ SF[.56 5|SFZGL
K[0KF0 HF[JF D/[, G CTL P VFD ;FC[NGF[ p5ZF[ST 5]ZFJF[ wIFGDF\ ,[TF\
GD]GFGL 0LJL0L ;FY[ S[F. ;]WFZF JWFZF YI[,F G CF[JFG]\ T[DH
0LJL0L DF\
56 5|SFZGF
K[0KF0 HF[JF D/[, G CF[JFG]\ :5Q8 56[ O,LT YFI K[P VFD GD]GFGL
0LJL0L VG[ T[DF\GL OF., ;FY[ SF[.56 5|SFZGF R[0F\ YI[, CF[I T[J]\
DFGL XSFI T[D GYLP
!#5P$
VF
H[ JL0LIF[DF H
\ [ VF[0LIF[ CTF[ T[GL 8=Fg:S|L%8 AGFJ[, CTLP T[ S],
5[.H !_ DF\ T{IFZ SZ[,L H[G[ V[G[1FZ cc V[ cc TZLS[ ZL5[F8" ;FY[ ;FD[,
SZ[, CTLP JW]DF\ ;FC[N[ T[ V[GF,L;L; 5]Z] YIF AFN VF 0LJL0L p5Z
V[GF,L;L; AN,G\]\ ;FC[N[ 5F[TFG] ;L, ,UFJ[,
TYF tIFZAFN
VF\S
;FC[NG[ ATFJL
4 ;\E/FjIF AFN
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
209/273
0LJL0LG] V[GF,L;L;
VF\S Z_) GL
lJEFUGF
0[%I]8L 0FIZ[S8ZG[ DF[S,L VF5[,F CTFP 5Z\T]\ SF[. 5[S SZ[,F G CTFP
;FY[ ;FY[ V[ CSLST :JLSFZ[, K[ S[4 ZL5[F8" VG[ 8=Fg:S|L%8 lJEFUGF
J0FG[ DF[S,L VF5[,F G CTFP
!#5P&
0LPV[GPV[P VG[
210/273
;FIg; SCL XSFI S[ S[D T[ T[VF[ SCL XS[ GlCP SF[d%I]8Z ;LP0LP
VG[ 0LPJLP0L PGF V[GF,L;L;
DF8[
V[OPV[;PV[,PDF\ VF[0LIF[ q
JW]\DF\
0LhL8,
V[FY[g8LS[XG DF8[ S[F. :8Fg00" D[Y0 N]lGIFDF\ G CF[JF ;FY[ T[VF[ ;\DT
GYLP 5Z\T]\ VFJL SF[. :8Fg00" D[Y0G]\ GFD T[VF[G[ IFN GYL P;FC[N[ :
5Q8TF SZTF\ H6FJ[, K[S[4
V[GF,L;L; DF8[
:8Fg00"
5|F[;LHZ
K[ P V,AT
DF8[
U6FI
JW]DF\ ;FC[N[
211/273
V[
p5ZF[ST 5]ZFJF G[
wIFGDF\ ,[TF\4
5F[TFGF
VF
XaNGF[ p5IF[U SZ[ K[P JW]DF\ cc 5LSRZ .G 5LSRZ ccGF[ VY" V[JF[ YFI
S[4 V[S 5LSRZ RF,T]\ CF[I T[DF\ 5[Z[Z, ALH] 5LSRZ 56 ATFJJFDF\
VFJT] CF[I K[ PHIFZ[ SF[. 0LJL0L DF\ V[GF[8[XG VG[ 5LSRZ .G 5LSRZ
CF[JFG]\ H6FI tIFZ[
SC[JFIPJW]D\F ;FC[N[
212/273
SF[. 5F[,L; VlWSFZL ;FY[ VF 0LJL0L V\U[ SF[. JFTRLT YI[, G CTL P
!#5P!_
,[IZ
HIFZ[ S,F[h SZL N[JFDF\ VFJ[, C[FI tIFZ[ VFJF ;]WFZF JWFZF Y.
XS[ GlCP JW]DF\ ;FC[N[ H6FJ[, K[ S[4
VlE5|FI :5Q8 SFZ6F[ ;FY[GF[ CF[JF[ HF[.V[ T[ ;FY[ T[VF[ ;\DT K[P
;FY[ ;FY[ V[ CSLST :JLSFZ[, K[ S[4 VlE5|FI DF8[ GF SIF SFZ6F[ CTF
T[ ZL5[F8"DF\ H6FJ[, GYLPJW]DF\ H6FJ[, K[ S[4 VlE5|FI p5Z VFJJF
DF8[GF SFZ6F[ V,UYL 5F[,L;G[ 56 DF[S,L VF5[,F GYLP
!#5P!!
SZ[, CF[JFG]\ ATFJJF DF8[ VF\S Z_) GL 8=Fg:S|L%8 DF\ SF[. p<,[B S[
5F[TFGL ;CL S[ CF[NF S[ 5F[T[ HFT[ T{IFZ SZ[, C[FJFG]\ ,B[, CF[JFG]\ SF\. H
H6FJ[, GYL ;FC[N[ JW]DF\ :JLSFZ[, K[ S[4 VF\S Z_( GF ZL5F[8"DF\ V[J]\
H6FJ[, GYL S[4 cc
V[S
H ,[IZ DF\ ,BFI[, CTL H[YL T[GL V\NZ VgI SF[. OF., V[S JBT
,BFIF 5KL OZLJFZ V[0L8 S[ 0L,L8 V[8,[ S[ S[F. 56 HFTGF ;]WFZF
JWFZF YI[, G CTF tIFZAFN VF 0LJL0L DF\ H[ JL0LIF[ OF., CTL T[G]\
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
213/273
SFD
TFZLB
ZZq!qZ_!5
GF
ZF[H
XZ]
SZ[,
CT]
VG[ 8]S0[ 8]S0[ T{IFZ SZTF CTF VG[ TFP#_ GF ZF[H 5]Z] SZ[,P 5Z\T]\ SIF
lNJ;[ S[8,F S,FS VF 8=Fg:S|L%8G]\ SFD SZ[, CT\] T[GL SF[. GF[W ZFB[, G
CTL P JW]DF\ 5F[T[ T{IFZ SZ[, 8=Fg:S|L%8DF\
T5F;[, 0LPJLP0LP GF
;\JFNF[ D]HA 36L E],F[ CF[. XS[ P ;FC[N[ :5Q8TF SZTF\ H6FJ[, K[S[4
;F\E/JFGL E],GF SFZ6[ VFJL E],F[ 8=Fg:S|L%8 DF\ CF[. XS[P
!#5P!#
JW]DF\
;FC[N[
V[
CSLST
:JLSFZ[,
K[S[4
TZLS[ VF5[,F[ GYL 56[ ;FIg8LOLS VF[lO;Z TZLS[ VF5[,F[ K[P VFD
p5ZF[ST ;FC[NGF[ ;DU| 5]ZFJF[ wIFGDF\ ,[TF\4 T[VF[V[ VF\S !(& JF/L
0LJL0L G]\ 5ZL1F6 SZ[, VG[ T[GF ;FY[ S[ T[GF V\NZ ZC[,L OF.,F[
;FY[ SF[. R[0F\ YI[, CF[I T[JL SF[. CSLST ARFJ 51F Z[S0" p5Z ,FJL
XS[, GYLP
!#&
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
214/273
JW]DF\
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
215/273
0LJL0L HF[TF\
5F[T[ ACFZ
TYF
SFZGF AGFJ
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
216/273
T[ D]HA HJFAF[
.g8ZjI]\GF
:Y/[ 5F[,L;
V[ 56 :JLSFZ[, K[ S[ 4
tIFZ[ DL0LIFGF S[8,FS DF6;F[4 tIF\ CFHZ CTF VG[ OZLIFNLG[ .g8ZjI]\
DF\ X]\ AF[,JFG\\] K[ T[ DL0LIFGF DF6;F[V[ 56 OZLIFNLG[ XLBJF0[,
CT]P ;FY[ ;FY[ V[ CSLST 56 :JLSFZ[, K[ S[ 5F[,L;JF/F
VG[ DL0LIFJF/FVF[V[ OZLIFNL G[ V[S SFU/p5Z ,B[, CT] T[ D]HA
AF[,JFG]\ CT] T[ D]HA XLBJF0[, CT]\P
OZLIFNLG[
X]\
GFDNFZ
;FC[N G\A Z ##
4 DI]Z wJHl;C
SZGFZ
lSXF[Z l;C
217/273
J:T|F5]Z
TYF
AFAT[
,F.J
JL0LIF[U|FOL SZLG[ 0LPJLP0LP SAH[ SZ[,P H[ 5{SL V[S 0LPJLP0L PG[ 5\RF[GL
CFHZLDF\ JL0LIF[U|FOLDF\ ;L, SZ[, VG[ ALHL 0LPJLP0LP
DF8[ V,U ZFB[, VG[ ;FY[ VFJ[, JL0LIF[U|FOZ
8=Fg:S|L%8
TLDLZEF.G[F 56
5F[,L;
SZ[,
TFZLB
Z#q!qZ_!5
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
GF
218/273
8=Fg:S|L%8 T{IFZ SIF" AN, ;CL SZ[,LP H[ 8=Fg;:S|L%8 VF\S Z!5 YL ZH]
SZ[, K[P JW]DF\ T5F;GLX[ H6FJ[, K[S[4 T[ H TFZLB Z*q!qZ_!5 GF
ZF[H HLP8LP5LPV[,PGF SD"RFZL
lGJ[NG ,LW[, CT]P\ T[
8[SGLXLIG
VFXLQFEF. UHHZG]\
lGJ[NG ,LW[,
H[ C[PSF[P ULZLXEF.
G[ Z]AZ] ,[JF DF8[ DF[S,[, CTFPT[VF[V[ C[P SF[P ULZLXEF.GF[ HJFA ,LW[,
CTF[P TFZLB #!q!qZ_!5 GF ZF[H GFDNFZ S[F8"DF\ SZ[, JW] T5F;
GF[ ZL5[F8" SZ[,F[P H[ VF\S !(_ YL ZH] YI[, K[[ PSAH[ SZ[, 0LJL0L
TFP#!q!qZ_!5 GF ZF[H RLO HI]0LPD[HLP S[F8"DF\ H[ C[P SF[P S[XZLl;C
GFY,l;C GF VF[V[
219/273
0LPJLP0LP T[VF[V[ SAH[ SZ[, CTL T[ CF[JFG] VG[ T[ 5{SL VF\S !(5
JF/L 0LPJLP0LP T[VFF[V[ T[VF[GF
5\RGFDF VG];FZ
5\RF[ Z]AZ] SAH[ SZ[, VG[ T[DF\GL V[S 0LPJLP0LP V[OPV[;PV[,P DF\
T[ 0LPJLP0LPGL H[gI]G[; T5F;JF VG[ 8=Fg;:S|L%8 D[/JJF ;FZ\] DF[S,L
VF5[, CTLPJW]D\F T[VF[GF 5F;[ ZFB[, 0LPJLP0LPGL T[VF[V[ 8=Fg;:S|L%8
T{IFZ SZ[, CTLP
!#*P$
p5ZF[ST
p,8T5F;GF[
T5F;GLXGL
5]ZFJF[
wIFGDF\
,[TF\4
ARFJ
51F[
SZ[,
T5F;GLX[
H6FJ[,
K[S[4
CF,GF[ AGFJ AgIF[ T[ lNJ;[ T[VF[ J:T|F5]Z 5F[P:8[P DF\ OZH AHFJTF[ G
CTFP JW]]DF\ H6FJ[, K[ S[4 T[VF[V[ lS|DLG, 5|F[;LHZ S[F0GL S,D !*#
s(f D]HA JW] T5F; SZTF\ 5C[,F\ CF,GF VF U]gCFGF VFUpGF T5F;
SZGFZVlWSFZL 5F;[YL T5F;GF SF[. SFU/F[ DF\U[,F G CTFP T[DH VF
JW] T5F; XZ] SZL tIFZYL VG[ S[F8"DF\ ZL5F[8" SIF[" tIF\ ;]WLGF
;DIUF/FGL S[; 0FIZL ZFB[, K[P;FC[N[ V[ CSLST :JLSFZ[, K[S[4 T5F;
NZdIFG GF[W[, ;FC[NF[GF lGJ[NGF[GL XaNXo CSLSTF[ S[; 0FIZLDF\ ,B[,
GYL PXaNXo lGJ[NGGL CSLSTF[ S[; 0FIZLDF\ GlC ,BJF DF8[ BF; S[F.
SFZ6 G CT]P
!#*P5
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
220/273
T{IFZ
SZFJ[,
CX[
T[GL
T[VF[G[
BAZ
CTLP
8[SGLXLIGGL
CFHZLDF\
T{IFZ
SZFJ[,
CTLP
ZLT[ VG[ SF[6[ T{IFZ SZ[,L CTL T[GL T[VF[G[ VFHNLG ;]WL BAZ GYLP
;FC[N H6FJ[ K[ S[ 0LJL0LGL SF[5LVF[ VFXLQFEF. UHHZ[ T{IFZ SZ[,L
CTL T[ T[VF[ HF6[ K[P VG[ T[JL HF6 TFZLB ZZq!qZ_!5 GF ZF[H
YI[,L CTLP ;FC[N VFXLQF UHHZ lGJ[NG TFZLB Z*q!qZ_!5 GF
ZF[H ,LW[, CT\]P 0LJL0L VFXLQFEF. UHHZ[ T{IFZ SZ[, C[FJFGL HF6
TFZLB ZZq!q!5 GF ZF[H 5NDSF\gTEF.V[ SZ[, CTLP 5Z\T]\ T[ lNJ;
[ 5NDSF\gTEF.G]\ JW]\ lGJ[NG T[VF[V[ ,LW[, G CT]P
!#*P*
CT]\P
VF
;8L"OLS[8
T{IFZ
SZJFG]\
T[VF[V[
SC[,
CT]\P
221/273
DCtJGF
A\gG[
T5F;GLX[ H6FJ[,
0LJL0L
HF[.
VG[
;F\E/[,
CTLPJW]DF\
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
222/273
p5ZYL
8=Fg:S|L%8
,,LT
S[ S[D m
!(5 JF/L H[
5F[TFGF 5F;[ ZFB[,L CTL T[ T[VF[G[ S[F. SJZDF\ 5[S SZL4 S[ ;L, SZL
VF5[, G CTL PV,AT T5F;GLX[ V[ CSLSTGF[ .gSFZ SZ[,F[ K[ S[4cc
lJ:DI S[;4TFPZ*qZq!#4 ,F[SD\R4__oZ(o## 4HL8L5LV[,40LJL0L
cc ,B[, CT] H[ VF\S !($ GF 5\RGFDF D]HA SAH[ SZ[, 0LJL0L
V[OPV[;PV[,P DF\ DF[S,[, G CTL P
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
223/273
!#(
CF,GF
U]gCFGL
T5F;
lGID
D]HA
SZ[,
K[P
Z!$!
SF\l TEF. SF,LNF; lJZ}w W U]H ZFT ZFHI GF S[;GF R]SFNF D]HA
NZ[S T5F;GLX[ T5F; 5]6" YIF 5KL T]ZT H VYJF RFH"XL8 ;FY[ ;L,
SJZDF\ ;\5]6" S[; 0FIZLGL
0FIZLGL
5|DF6LT GS, RFH"XL8 ;FY[ SF[8"DF\ ZH] YI[, G CTL 5Z\T] 4 CF,GF
S[;GL N,L,F[ GF TASS[ T5F;GLX[ S[; 0FIZL A\W SJZDF\ DC[P ;[;g;
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
224/273
CJ[4
OZLIFN
T5F;DF\ ZC[,
V[; ;L;L
51F[ T5F;GLX
VlWSFZLGL
U]g CFGL
;RF[8 5]ZFJF[ OZLIFN 51[F ZH] YI[, CF[I tIFZ[ U]gCFGL T5F;DF\ 4
T5F;GLX VlWSFZLYL ZCL UI[, SF[. BFDL q1FlT GF SFZ6 DFT|YL
OZLIFN 51FGF[ S[; lGQO/ HTF[ GYLP
!$_P!
JW]DF\4
U]gCFGL
OF[HNFZL
VG[ OZLIFN 51F[ ZH] YI[, 5]ZFJF VG[ VFZF[5LGF ARFJ p5ZYL U]gCF
DF\C[GL CSLSTF[GL ;FlATL D[/JL 4 T[JF D]NFGF[ lG6"I SZJFGF[ CF[I K[P
H[DF\ VFZF[5LGL lGNF["QFTF S[ U]G[UFZ
K[ HIFZ[ gIFI SZJFGF[ C[T] CF[I tIFZ[4 VFZF[5LG[ ;HF SZJF S[ > lGNF[ "QF
G[ Z1F6 VF5JF DF8[ 4 ;tI XF[WJF DF8[GL SFI"JFCL K[ BFDLVF[G[ CFJL
YJF N[JL HF[.V[ GlCP
!$_PZ
sZ_!Zf
225/273
VJ,F[SG SZ[, K[S[ SF[8" DFT| lGNF["QFG[ ;HF G YFI T[8,L DFT| OZH
AHFJJFGL GYL 5Z\T] U]G[UFZ K8SL G HFI T[ 56 wIFGDF\ ZFBJFG]\
K[ VG[ T[ A\gG[ gIFIFWLXGL HFC[Z OZHF[ K[P
!$!
J8FJLG[ UI[, CF[T TF[ SFZ 5;FZ Y. U. CF[T VYJF TF[ AGFJ G AGT
T[JL CSLSTF[V[ T5F;GLX[ T5F; SZ[, GYL P T[ H ZLT[ AGFJGF
:Y/[
Z[F0 p5Z A|[S DFIF"GF lGXFG HF[JF D/[, CTF 5Z\T]4 T[8,F DFT|YL
OZLIFN 51FGF S[;GF U]6NF[QFDF\ SF[. OS" 50TF[ GYL T[8,F DFT|YL
VFZF[5L lGN[F"QF C[FJFG]\ SCL XSFI GlCP
!$Z
OZLIFN
51F[
WL
5]Z FJF
VlWlGIDGL
S,D
!_&
p5ZGF[ ZH] YI[, F[ R]S FNFPs!f Z_!$ lS|D LG, ,F[ HG", 5FG
$_$* 4
R]SFNF
SFINFYL
V[J]\
YI[,
226/273
K[ 5Z\T]4 VFZF[5L B],F;F[ G SZ[ TF[4 VFZF[5LV[ U]gCF[ SZ[, K[ T[J]\ NXF"JTF[
DHA]T ;\IF[U U6FIPVFJF S[;DF\ WL 5]ZFJF VlWlGIDGLS,D!_&
,FU] 5F0L XSFIP H[ S,D D]HA 4 H[ CSLST SF[. jIlSTGL BF;
HF6SFZLDF\ CF[I4 T[JL CSLST ;FlAT SZJFGF[ AF[HF[ T[ jIlST p5Z
ZC[,F[ K[P
!$ZP!
lJZ]w W ;]J 6"G FdDF GF S[;GF R]SFNF D]HA OZLIFN 51F[ HIFZ[ VFZF[5L
U]gCFDF\ ;\0F[JFI[, CF[JFG]\ ;F\IF[lUS 5]ZFJF YL XSI C[FJFG]\ ATFJ[,
CF[I tIFZ[ HF[ VFZF[5L BF[8F[ ARFJ ,[ tIFZ[ T[JF[ BF[8F[ ARFJ G[ VFZF[5L
lJZ]wWGF[ JW] V[S ;F\IF[lUS 5]ZFJF TZLS[ ,. XSFIP VG[ WL EFZTLI
A\WFZ6 GF VF8L"S, Z_s#f G[ wIFGDF\ ,[TF\ 56
HIFZ[ VFZF[5L
5F[TFGL BF; HF6SFZL YL CSLSTF[ ;tI 56[ HFC[Z SZTF[ G C[FI tIFZ[
VFZ[F5LGL T[JL JT"6]S
GHZ V\NFH
SZJL
HIFZ[ VFZF[5L 5F[TFGL BF; HF6SFZL GL CSLT[ BF[8F[ ARFJ ,[TF[ CF[I
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
227/273
tIFZ[
5]ZFJF[ U6FIP
!$ZP#
S,D !_&
!$#
p5ZF[ST
R]SFNFVF[
wiFFGFDF\
,[TF\4
VS:DFTDF\;\0F[JFI[,
SF[8 "4 5FG Z!&$ 4 AF,SZFD lJZ]w W :8[8 VF[O I]P 5LP S[;GF
R]SFNF D]HA OF[HNFZL SFI"ZLTL VlWlGIDGL S,D !&$ VgJI[ H[
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
228/273
;{wW\FlTS :JT\TT
| F CF[I K[
5Z\T] BF[8F[ 5]ZFJF[ ZH] SZJFGF U]gCF GL SFI"JFCLGF EF[U[ T[JL :JT\T|TF
D/TL CF[I K[ JW]DF\ V[J]\ 9ZFJ[, K[ S[ T5F; SZGFZ VD,NFZ[ ;FC[NF[GF
lGJ[NGF[
GF[WFJ0FJ[, CF[I TF[ T[DF\ SF\. BF[8]\ GYL VG[ T[JF lGJ[NG GF[WFI[,
CF[JF DFT|GF SFZ6[ ;FC[NGF[ 5]ZFJF[ ZN SZL XSFI GlCP
!$5
p5ZF[S T
!
!)$&4 l5|JL SFpg;L, 5FG #(4 A|LHE]QF6 ;LW
Z
!)$)4 l5|JL SFpg;L, 5FG Z5*4
E]AF[GL XFC]
#
!)5!lS|DLG, ,F[ HG", 5FG!__$4sV[RP5LPf EFULlJZ]wW
SFpG
$
V[VF.VFZ !)&_V[;;LP45FG $)_lN<CL lJZ]wW ZFD
DGF[CZ ,F[CLIF\
5
V[VF.VFZ !)*Z V[;;LP4 5FG $&(ZFDlSXG;L3lJZ]wW
CZDLTSF{Z
&
lJP :8[8 GF S[;DF\ 9ZFJ[, K[S[4 lS|DLG, 5|F[;LHZ S[F0GL S,D !&$
VgJI[GF lGJ[NG VG[ SF[8" Z]AZ]GF
lGJ[NG
V[D A[ lGJ[NG
H[ lGJ[NG
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
229/273
JW]DF\4
GFDNFZ
DNF;
lGJ[NGGF[ p5IF[U DCtJGF 5]ZFJF TZLS[ SZL XSFI GlCP 5Z\T]\ T[JF
lGJ[NGF[ p5IF[U H[ ;FC[N[ lGJ[NG VF5[, CF[I T[GL p,8T5F; SZJF
VG[ T[GF 5lZ6FD :JZ]54 ;FC[NGF[ 5]ZFJF[ BF[8F[ K[ T[J]\ ATFJJF SZL
XSFIP JW]DF\ V[J]\ 9ZFJ[, K[ S[ ;FC[N[ 4 SF[8" ACFZ H[ SF\. H6FJ[,
K[ T[ ;tI H K[ T[J]\ :YFl5T Y. XS[ GlCP JW]DF\4 V[J]\ 9ZFJ[,
K[ S[
!$&
lJlWJT
ZLT[
,[JFI[,
CF[JFGF
VG]DFG
p5ZGF
230/273
5Z\T]\ ARFJ 51F[ ZH] YI[, !)&#sZf lS|D LG, ,F[ HG", 4
ZFD ;G[C L
lJZ]w W :8[8
S,D (_ DF\ H[
lGJ[NG
231/273
!$*
s5]Z FJFG]\ D]< IF\S G f p5ZGF s!f !)*# V[;;L;L lS|DLG, 5FG!
_$( 4SF,LZFD JZ]wW :8[8 VF[O lCDFR, 5|N[X PsZf !))! lS|DLG,
,F[ HG", 5FG !5 4 lN,FJZ C];[G DCDNEF. ,F,LJF,F lJZ]wW :8[8
VF[O U]HZFT
s#f
VFZF[5LV[ U]gCF[ SZ[, CF[JFGF TFZ6 p5Z SF[8" VFJL XS[ GlCP
!$*P!
!$*PZ
!$*P#
JW]DF\
YI[, K[S[
,FU6LVF[ 4 ;\J[NGFVF[ UD[ T[8,L DHA]T CF[I TF[ 564 SFINFGL SF[8"
DF\ T[G[ SF[. :YFG GYLP VFZF[5LG[ lGNF["QF 9ZFJJF[ S[ TS;LZJFG
9ZFJJF[ T[ ;FlAT YI[, 5]ZFJF p5Z VFWFZLT K[P
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
232/273
!$*P$
CF[I
OZLIFN51F[[
ZH]
YI[, F
5]Z FJFYL
lJ;\U TTF
qlJZF[W FEF; p5Z ZH] YI[, R]S FNFVF[ wIFGDF\ ,.X]\ TF[4 s!f
sZ_!Zf#4 ;]l5|D SF[8" S[;L;
lJZ]wW :8[8 VF[O 5lxRD A\UF/ R]SFNF[ wIFGDF\ ,[TF\4 V[J]\ 5|:YFl5T
YI[, S[4 SF[g8=F0LSXG lJ;\UTTF S[ VF[DLXG DCtJGF CF[JF HF[.V[P
5Z\T] GHLJL AFAT[ S[ 1F]<,S H6FTF SF[g8=F0LSXG
S[;GF CFN"G[
OZLIFN 51FGF
DFT|YL OZLIFN
;FC[NF[GF lGJ[NGGL ;FY[ ;FY[ H wIFGDF\ ,[J]\ HF[.V[P GlC S[4 ;FC[NGF
lGJ[NGGF[ VD]S H EFUP
!$(PZ
JW]DF\4
V[J]\
9ZFJ[,
K[
S[
5]ZFJFDF\
H6FTL
GHLJL
233/273
lJ;\U TTF
DCDN .SAF,
lS|DLG, f
lJZ]wW :8[8
5FG !#**
lGJ[NGDF\
H6FTF CF[I
V\U[ X\SF
VFWFZ ZFB[,
H[ 5]ZFJFG[
lJ;\UTTFYL DHA]T ;DY"G D/T\\] CT]\ T[YL GFDNFZ ;]l5|D SF[8[" 9ZFJ[,
K[ S[4 H[ ;FC[N H]NF H]NF ;DI[ H]NF H]NF lGJ[NG SZTF[ CF[I T[DF\ ;tI
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
234/273
wIFGDF\ ,[JF[
HF[.V[P
!5_
JW]DF\4 OZLIFN 51F[ CF[: 8F., JL8G[; ;AAGF R]S FNF VF[
wIFGDF\ ,.X]\ TF[4
pO["
5dDF
&
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
235/273
H]NF H]NF
;DI[ H]NF H]NF lGJ[NG SZTF[ CF[I T[JF ;FC[NMG[ ;tI ;FY[ lG:AT G
CF[I T[JF ;FC[NGF[ 5]ZFJF[ wIFGDF\ ,[TF\ SF[8[" SF/HL ZFBJL HF[.V[P
!5_PZ
!5!
lJZ]wW
:8[8
!&_
Z_!_
VF[O
VG[ SF[g8=F0LSXG
wIFGDF\ ,.
4 ;FC[N
BZ[BZ
VG[
!5!PZ
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
236/273
5]ZFJFGF[ H[8,F[ EFU 5]ZFJFDF\ U|FCI CF[I T[8,F[ 5]ZFJF[ OZLIFN 51F
S[ ARFJ 51F p5IF[UDF\ ,. XS[P
!5!P#
;DU| 5]ZFJF[ ZN
SZJF[ HF[.V[ GlCP 5Z\T] T[JF[ 5]ZFJF[ U|FCI K[ VG[ T[JF 5]ZFJFG[ ALHF
5]ZFJFYL ;DY"G D/T]
CF[I tIFZ[
ZFBL
!5Z
51F[ ZH] YI[,F 5]ZFJF DF\ H6FTF SF[g8=F0LSXG4 VF[DLXG VG[ CF[:8F.,
JL8G[;GF 5]ZFJFGF D]<IFSG AFAT[
wIFGDF\ ,[TF\4 CF,GF S[;DF\ ZH] YI[, 5]ZFJF D]HA 4 ;FC[N G\AZ !!
OZLIFNL ,,LT U]%TF VG[ ;FC[N G\AZ !Z NLG[X RF{WZLGFVF[4
VS:DFTDF\ ;\0F[JFI[, JFCG RF,SGL VF[/B
lS
|5|F[PSF[PSP !&$
lJD]B
YI[,
5|
[DR\NGUZ ZF[0 p5Z 4 ;\N[X 5|[; HJFGF Z:TFDF\ 8GL"U 5F;[ AG[,
CF[JFGL CSLST[ T[DH T[JF AGFJ JBT[ A\gG[ DZ6 HGFZFVF[ 5<;Z
D[F8Z AF.S p5Z HTF\ CF[JF GL CSLST[ VG[ T[ .;DF[V[ ALPV[DP 0A<I]
SFZ h05YL VFJL T[GF RF,S[ DF[8Z AF.SG[ 8SSZ DFZJFYL A\gG[ H6F\
CJFDF\
pK/L
VG[
HDLG
p5Z
58SFI[,FP
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
237/273
VG[ T[ SFZ6[ A\gG[G[ U\ELZ .HFVF[ YTF\4 D'tI]]\ lG5H[, C[FJFGL CSLST4
T[DH
OZLIFN 51F[ ZH] YI[, VFZF[5 LGL VF[/ B V\U [G F 5]Z FJF GF
S[; p5ZGF
5FG *_Z4
D]HA EFZT H[JF N[XDF\ HIF\ ,F[SF[ cc ,[X OF[D", VG[ DF[Z S[HI]V,cc
K[ tiFF\ S[F. ;FC[NG[ RFg; JL8G[; SC[JF[ T[ IF[uI H6FT]\ GYLP
JW]DF\ H[ jIlST HF6TL C[FI T[ 5lZlRT CF[I T[ HZ]ZL GYL VG[
;FC[N S[ H[ XZ]VFTDF\ VFZF[5LVF[GF GFD VF5L XS[, G CF[I T[ VFZF[5LG[
HF[I[YL VF[/BL XSTF[ CF[I VG[ C]D,F[ SZFGFZFVF[DF\ T[JF DF6;F[ CFHZ
CF[JFYL VF[/BL XS[ T[D CF[I T[JF ;\HF[UF[DF\
SZFJJFYL
SF[8" Z]AZ]
VFZF[5LGL VF[/B
VF[/B 5Z[0
GlC
AGTF[ GYLP
!5#P!
VFWFZE]T
K[ S[ S[D
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
238/273
!5$
ARFJ 51F[ ZH] YI[, VFZF[5 LGL VF[/ B V\U [G F 5]Z FJF GF
S[; p5ZGF R]S FNFP
!
!)*) lS|DLG, ,F[ HG", 5FG )!) SFGG lJZ]wW :8[8 VF[O
S[ZF,FP
Z
!))$ V[;;L;L lS|DLG, 5FG !*5! YgSFIG lJZ]wW :8[8VF[O
S[ZF,F
#
!))) V[;;L;L lS|DLG, 5FG #*( JLHIG lJZ]wW :8[8 VF[O
S[ZF,F
$
Z__# V[;;L;L lS|DLG, 5FG !Z$* D<BFG;L3 lJZ]wW :8[8
VF[O DwI5|N[X
5
Z_!# V[;;L;L lS|DLG, 5FG Z_(4VF[DF pO[" VF[D5|SFX
lJZ]wW
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
239/273
5]ZFJFGL SF[. lS\DT GYLP l;JFI S[4 ;FC[N Z]AZ] VFZF[5LGL VF[/B 5Z[0
VUFp SZFJ[, CF[I4 5Z\T] HIFZ[ VUFp SF[. VF[/B 5Z[0 YI[, G CF[I
tIFZ[ T[JF 5]ZFJF p5Z VFWFZ ZFBJF[ ;,FDT GYL VG[ T[YL T[JF 5]ZFJF
p5Z VFWFZ ZFBL XSFI GlCP
!5$P!
JW]DF\
lJHDGGF
S[;GF
R]SFNF
D]HA
VFZF[5LGF[
OF[8F[
;FC[NG[ ATFJ[, CF[I T[8,]\ H GlC 5Z\T] VFZF[5LGF[ OF[8F[ ;DFRFZ 5T| DF\
5|l;wW YI[, CTF[ T[JF ;\HF[UF[DF\ VF[/B 5Z[0 GF[ 5]ZFJF[ DFGL XSFI
GlCP
!5$PZ
JW]DF\
V[J]\
9ZFJ[,
K[
S[
SF[8"
Z]AZ]
VFZ[F5LGL
5Z[0 SZFJLG[ T[
lJxJL;GLITF
!55
lSZ6EF.
XFCGFVF[V[
VFZF[5LG[
S[F8"
Z]AZ]
4 T[ H
240/273
VF[JZ8[S SZ[, VG[ T[ ;DI[ ;FC[N GL SFZG[ 0FAL AFH]V[ Ad5ZGL p5Z
S|[X SZL GLS/L UI[, VG[ T[ JBT[ 56 T[ SFZ h05YL HTL CF[JFGF[
;FC[N G\AZ !# GF[ 5]ZFJF[ K[P VFD4 ;FC[N G\AZ!# GF 56 4 CF,GF H
VS:DFT DF\ ;\0F[JFI[, JFCGYL CF,GF VS:DFT GF YF[0FS H ;DI
5C[,F\ EF[U AG[, CTFP VG[ T[JF JFCGGL 5FK/ H ;FC[N G\AZ !#
VFJTF CTFP VG[ T[YL T]ZT H YF[0F ;DI AFN VS:DFTGF :Y/[ JFCG
RF,SG[ HF[JFGL TS D/[, CF[JFGF 5|;\U ;FY[ 4 T[VF[G[ 5F[TFG[ YF[0FS
H ;DI 5C[,F\
YI[,
HIFZ[ SF[. CSLST ;FY[ SF[. RF[SS; ;\NE" HF[0FI[, CF[I tIFZ[ T[JL
CSLSTF[ ,F\AF[ ;DI ;]WL IFN ZC[TL CF[I K[P VFD4 CF,GF ;FC[N GL
ALPV[DP 0A<I] SFZGF RF,SGL VF[/B ;FY[4 ;FC[NG[ 5F[TFG[ H
YF[0F ;DI 5C[,F\ YI[, 5|;\UGF[ ;\NE" HF[0FI[,F[ CTF[P T[YL ;FC[N G\AZ
!# GF[ ALPV[DP 0A<I] SFZGF RF,S TZLS[ CF,GF VFZF[5LGL VF[/B
V\U[GF 5]ZFJF DF\ 4 DFT| 5]ZFJF VlWlGIDGL S,D !# D]HA 8LPVF.P
5Z[0 SZFJ[, G C[FJF GF DFT| SFZ6;Z ;FC[N
G\ AZ !# GF
VlE5|F I
S[ VgI SF[.
VFJ[, G CF[I tIFZ[ T[J F lGQ6FT[ VF5[, VlE5|F I S[ ZL5F[8 "G LX]\
V;, Y. XS[ T[ p5ZGF o
!)(_ V[P VF.PVFZP ;]l 5|D SF[8 " 5FG 5#! 4D]Z FZL ,F,
lJZ]w W :8[8 V[F O DwI5|N [X PGF S[;DF\ 9ZFJ[, K[ S[ lGQ6FTGF[ VlE5|
FIDF\ T[GF VF5[,F SFZ6F[YL :JLSFZJF 5FT| K[ S[ S[D T[GL S;F[8L YJL
HF[.V[
JW]DF\
VG[
lG6"I
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
241/273
AF,]
GF
S[;DF\
V[J]\
WL
:8[8
5|:YFl5T
YI[,
G[ ALHF
5]ZFJFGL H[D H
D].JJF[ HF[.V[P
HIFZ[ VlE5|FIGF ;DY"G DF\ SFZ6F[ H6FJ[, CF[I tIFZ[ VG[ T[GF
SFZ6F[ BFTZLNFIS CF[I tIFZ[
5|F%T 0[8F
sDFlCTL f GF VFWFZ[
VG[
CF[I
TF[ SFZ6F[YL VlE5|FI :JLSFZL XSFI T[J]\ K[ S[ S[D T[ SF[8[" wIFG ZFBJ\]
HF[.V[P
!5&PZ
JW]DF\4
lGQ6FTGF[
:8[8
VF[O
lCDFR, 5|N [X lJZ]w W HI,FGF S[;GF R]SFNF p5Z HF[.X] TF[ T[DF\ V[J]\
5|:YFl5T YI[, K[ S[4 HIFZ[ lJ7FG JW] 0[J,5 YI[, CF[I VG[ ;\5]6"
CFI tIFZ[ BF[8F[
VlE5|FI
VFJJFG\]
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
242/273
HIFZ[ lJ7FG VF[K]\ 0[J,5 YI[, CF[I VG[ V5]6" CF[I tIFZ[ VlE5|FI
BF[8F[ CF[JFGL TS JWL HTL CF[I K[P
!5&P$
JW]DF\4
V[J]\
5|:YFl5T
YI[,
K[S[
lGQ6FT[
5Z\T] T[ ;,FCSFZ
D]NFDF\GHL
5|SFZGF lJ8G[;
R]SFNF
Z_!5s!f
V[; ;L;L
lS|D LG,
5FG
Z$4VGJZ5LJL
S[; L;
lS|D LG,
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
243/273
CF[I TF[
;L0L4JL;L0L4 RL%;
JU[Z[ S[;DF\ T[GL ;FY[ S,D &5 AL G] ;8L"OLS[8 T[JF ;LP0LP4 JL;L0L4
HIFZ[ SAH[ SZJFDF\ VFJ[, CF[I tIFZ[ T[JF ;8L"OLS[8 HF[0FI[,F CF[JF
HF[.V[P VG[ T[JF ;8L"OLS[8 lJGF ZH] YI[, CF[I tIFZ[ .,[S8=F[GLS;
Z[S0" ;[Sg0ZL 5]ZFJF[ U|FCI ZFBL XSFI GlCP
!5(
TYF 5]ZFJF
JU[Z[
H[JF[
.,[S8=F[GL;
Z[S0"GF[
5]ZFJF[
SFINFGL
GYL
P5Z\T]\
;FC[N
G\AZ
!)
5;F[",L
D[F8;"GF
D[G[HZ[ HF[T[ 0[DF[ SFZYL OF[8F GF VJ,F[SGF[GF[ 5]ZFJF[ S[F8" Z]AZ] ZH] SZ[,
K[
56 VS:DFTDF\ ;\0F[JFI[,
SFZG[ YI[, G]S;FG TYF T[GL .d5[S8 VG[ :Y/ p5Z H[ hF0 ;FY[ SFZ
VY0F.G[ pEL ZCL UI[, CTL T[ hF0GL l:YlT VG[ T[G[ YI[, G]S;FG
G]\ HFT lGZL1F6 SZL4 T[ V\U[GF[ 5]ZFJF[ S[F8" Z]AZ] ZH] SZ[, K[P JW]DF\4
lGQ6FTF[ V[ 5F[TFGF 5]ZFJFGF ;DY"GDF\ 5F[TFGF[ VlE5|FI 56 ZH]
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
244/273
SZ[,F[ K[P VG[ T[YL T[JF ;FC[NF[GF 5]ZFJFGL VJU6GF Y. XS[ T[D
GYLP JW]DF\4 ARFJ 51F[ ZH] YI[,F R]SFNFVF[YL 5|:YFl5T YI[,
l;wWF\T D]HA4 lGQ6FTGF VlE5|FI p5Z VFJJFGF
SFZ6F[
OZLIFN 51F[ ZH] YI[, 0F[S 8ZGF 5]Z FJF p5ZGF R]S FNFP
OZLIFN 51F[ TALAL T5F; ;DI[ 0F[S8Z Z]AZ] VFZF[5LV[ H6FJ[, lC:8=L
GF 5]ZFJF p5Z4
ZZ_4V[D PV[P V[g YF[G L lJZ]w W :8[8 VF[O S[Z F,FP GF S[;DF\ R]SFNF
D]HA T[JF S[;DF\4 VFZXF[5LGL TALAL
VFZF[5LV[ 5F[TFG[ YI[,
H6FJ[,
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
245/273
ARFJ 51F[ ZH] YI[, 0F[S 8ZGF 5]Z FJF S[ ALHF ;FC[N GF
5]Z FJFGL H[D H wIFG[ ,[J F HF[. V[ T[G F p5ZGF
s;]l 5|D SF[8 " S[; L; lS|D LG, f 5FG $$Z 4 DI]Z 5FGEF. XFC
lJZ]w W U]H ZFT ZFHI GF S[;GF[ R]SFNF[ wIFGDF\
!&!
HI]0LXLI,
l+SD pO[" l+SM ZJHLEF. 9FSMZ lJZ]wW U]HZFT ZFHIJF/F S[;GF[ R]SFNF[
wIFGDF\ ,[TF\4 VFZM5LV[ 0MS8Z Z]AZ] H[ CSLSTM U]gCFG[ ,UTL
SA],FT :JZ]5[ H6FJ[, CTL VG[ T[YL T[JL SA],FTG[ V[S:8=F
HI]0LXLI, SgO[XG U6FI S[ S[D T[ AFAT[ GFDNFZ U]HZFT CF.SM8["
V[J]\ GM\W[, K[ S[4 VFZM5LV[ 5MTFG]\ lGJ[NG TALAL T5F; NZdIFG
0MS8Z ;D1F SZ[, CT]\ VG[ T[YL T[ ;DI[ T[ 5M,L; S:80LDF\ CMJF KTF\
TALAL T5F; DF8[ 5M,L; IFNL ;FY[ 0MS8Z ;D1F ,. HJFDF\ VFJ[,
CTM4 T[8,F DF+YL VFZM5LG[ WFS4 ALS S[ V\UT 5|EFJ JrR[ V[S:8=F
HI]0LXLI, SgO[XG SZ[, CMJFG]\ SCL XSFI GCLP VG[ VFZM5LV[ SZ[,
lGJ[NG 0MS8Z ;D1F4 X]\ AG[, T[JF ;Z/ 5|xGGF\ HJFADF\ VF5[,
lGJ[NG U6L XSFIP5Z\T]\4 Z_!! s#f ;]l 5|D SM8" S[; L;4 (54
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
246/273
VG[
:5[XLI,
HHzLV[ 5MTFGF R]SFNFDF\ GM\W SZ[, K[ VG[ T[G[ ALHF 5]ZFJFYL ;DY"G
D/T]\ CT]\ T[JF ;\HMUMDF\ T[J]\ SgO[XG :J{rKLS CMJFG]\ U6L XSFIP
VG[ SM. EI4 ,F,R S[ 5|,MEG VF5[, CMJFGF\ 5ZL6FD[ SZ[, lGJ[NG
U6L XSFI GCLP V,AT4 p5ZMST R]SFNF D]HA 0MS8Z ;D1F
VFZM5LV[ TALAL T5F; NZdIFG U]gCFG[ ,UTL SA],FTGF\ :JZ]5DF\
SM. CSLSTM H6FJ[, CMI TM 56 T[G[ R]:T56[ V[S:8=F HI]0LXLI,
SgO[XG U6L XSFI GCLP VG[ T[G[ 5]ZFJFGM V[SDF+ EFU U6L XSFIP
H[ 5]ZFJFG[ VgI 5]ZFJFYL ;DY"G D/J]\ HZ]ZL K[P
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
247/273
!&Z
VFZF[5L
!&#
OZLIFN 51F[
V[PVF.PVFZP
ZH] YI[,
Z_!Z
V[; ;LP
#!_5
:8[8 slN<CLf
K[ T[JL ,F[SF[DF\ V;Z 50[ K[P H[YL ,F[SF[GF[ SF[8" p5ZYL lJxJF; p9L
HFI K[P
!&#P!
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
248/273
5F;[GFhF0 ;FY[ VY0F. UI[,P VG[ pEL ZCL UI[, CTLP JW]DF\ ;FC[N
G\AZ !! 4 OZLIFNLV[ 5F[TFGL VF\S )5 GL OZLIFN VG[VF\S )* GF lS|
DLG, 5|F[;LHZ S[F0 S,D !&$ VgJI[GFGJ[NGDF\ 56 H6FJ[, CT]
S[ SFZ RF,S T[GF 5F;[ VFJ[, VG[ ;F[ZL;F[ZL
H[G[ OZLIFNL HF[I[YL VF[/BL XS[P T[JF H DT,AG] lGJ[NG ;FC[N G\AZ
!Z GF VF[V[ ,BFJ[, CT] T[DKTF\ A\gG[ p5ZF[ST ;FC[NF[ V[ SFZ RF,SGL
VF[/B V\U[GF 5F[TFGF lGJ[NGF[YL lJD]B YI[, H[ CSLST p5ZF[ST
R]SFNFVF[ wIFGDF\ ,[TF\ VT|[GF S[;DF\ ;]RS AG[ K[P VFD4 p5ZF[ST
SFZ6F[;Z T[DH VUFp
OZLIFNL ,,LT U]%TF S[F8" Z]AZ] BF[8F[ 5]ZFJF[ ZH] SZTF CF[JFG]\ VT|[GL
SF[8"G[ H6FI K[ VG[ S[F8" Z]AZ] BF[8L H]AFGL VF5JF GF
U]gCFGL
SFI"JFCL SF[8"DF\ RF,TL CF[I tIFZ[ DCtJGF D]N[ SF[. 5|xGF[pEF G YFI
S[ 51FSFZFS[G[ 5]J"U|C YFI T[J]\ G AG[ T[G]\ 56 lDFl0IFV[ wIFG ZFBJ]\
HZ]ZL K[P
!&$
A\gG[ 51F[ ZH] YI[, V[P VF.PVFZP Z_!Z V[; ;LP 5FG #!_5
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
249/273
GF S[;GF[ R]SFNF[
TYF
.P5LPS[F PSP #_$ s5F8" Zf VG[ .P5LPS[F PSP #_$ sV[f JrR[G F
TOFJT p5ZGF R]S FNF ZH] SZ[, K[P s Z_!Z f!4 ;]l 5|D SF[8 "
S[; L;
lS|D LG,
DCFZFQ8=
!&$P!
p5ZF[ST
R]SFNFVF[DF\
5|:YFl5T
YI[,
K[S[4
.5LPS[FPSP
S[ SFI"NF[QF
:J{rKLS CF[TF[ GYL VG[ 5F[TFGF S'tI YL X]\ 5lZ6FD VFJX[ T[GL
HF6SFZL
GF U]gCF
DF8[ VFZF[5LV[ 5F[TFGF S'tI YL 4S[JF 5lZ6FD VFJL XS[ T[D K[ T[GL
HF6SFZL CF[JL HZ]ZL K[P
!&$PZ
JW]DF\4
K[ S[ VFZF[5LG[
;\HLJ
G\NFGF
S[;DF\
V[J]
EIF" S'tI
5|:YFl5T
SZ[,
VFJX[ T[GLHF6SFZL
!&$P#
JW]DF\ HIFZ[ JFCG RF,S .HF 5FDGFZ 4 EF[U AGGFZ G]\ X]\
YFI T[JL NZSFZ SIF" lJGF AGFJ :Y/[YL EFUL HFI T[JL EFUL HJFGL
JT"6]\S p5ZYL T[JF A[HJFANFZ EIF" S'tI G]\ X]\ 5lZ6FD VFJX[ T[JL
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
250/273
S'tI CF[I
HF6SFZL
CF[I
S[
45F[TFG]\
JFCGVlTXI
!&5
T[DH
4,1DL UF\9LIFZY
;FD[ HFC[Z ZF[0 p5Z AG[, CF[JFG]\ NFX"lGS ;FC[N OZLIFNL ,,LT
ZFH[XEF. U]%TF s;FC[N G\AZ !!f T[DH ;FC[N lNG[X DOFEF. RF{WZL
s;FC[N G\AZv!Zf GF 5]ZFJFYL :5Q856[ O,LT YFI K[P H[ ;FC[NF[GF
5]ZFJFYL DZGFZ ZFC], 3GxIFDEF. 58[, VG[
XLJD 5|[DX\SZ
NJ[ 5<;Z DF[8Z ;FIS, p5Z DFG;L RFZ Z:TFYL HHLh A\U,F[ ZF[[0
TZO HTF\ ZF[0 p5Z HTF CTF VG[ 5|[DR\NGUZ T|6 Z:TF p5Z HD6L
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
251/273
AFH]V[ 8G" ,. ;\N[X 5|[; TZO HJF 8G" ,[TF\ H4 HHLh A\U,F[ ZF[0
TZOYL V[S OF[Z jCL,Z SFZ VFJ[,L VG[ DZGFZFVF[GF AF.SG[ 8SSZ
DFZ[,L ;FC[N G\AZ s!!f
VG[ ;FC[N
G\AZs!Zf GF p5ZF[ST
VG[ 5\RGFDFGL
CSLSTF[ 5\R ;FC[N CQFL", 9SSZGF 5]ZFJFYL ;FlAT YFI K[P JW]DF\4
VF\S *( YL AGFJJF/L HuIFG]\ 5\RGFD]\ SZGFZ T5F;GLX ;FC[N G\AZ
Z#4 GZ[gN=ULZL UF[;F.4 5F[P;P.P
GF 5]ZFJFYL 56 VF\S *( GF
VS:DFTDF\
;\0F[JFI[,
HLH[v!vV[OVFZPv*!!
4p5Z
DZGFZ
ZFC],
3GxIFD
G\AZ
58[,
VG[ XLJD 5|[DX\SZ NJ[ HTF\ CF[JFGF[ 4 H[ AF.S DZGFZ ZFC], 3GxIFD
58[, R,FJTF CF[JFGF[ VG[
5FK/ A[9[,F
252/273
4 lNG[X DOFEF. RF{WZL GF[ 5]ZFJF[ K[P H[ 5<;Z AF.S ;FC[N G\AZ !!4
OZLIFNL ,,LT ZFH[XEF.
;FY[ VY0FI[,L
VG[ T[GF VFU/GF EFUG[ G]S;FG YI[, CF,TDF\ 50[, D/L VFJ[,
CF[JFGF[ 56 ;NZ ;FC[N G\AZ !! 4 OZLIFNL ,,LT ZFH[XEF. U]%TF
TYF ;FC[N G\AZ !Z4 lNG[XEF. DOFEF. RF{WZLGF[ 5]ZFJF[ K[P
H[
5]ZFJF[
wIFGDF\ ,[TF\4
0A<I]4
OF[ZjCL,Z SFZ
vV[.v )#&_ CF[JFGF[ 56 OZLIFN 51F[ ZH] YI[, p5ZF[ST ;DU| 5]ZFJF[
wiFFGDF\ ,[TF\ ;FlAT YFI K[P
!&*
5F;[GF
hF0 ;FY[ VY0FI[,L CF,TD\F 50[,L CTLP T[GL T5F; SZTF\ T[JL SFZ
GL JLDF 5F[,L;LGL GS, D/L VFJ[, CF[JFGF[ VF\S *( GF AGFJJF/L
HuIFGF 5\RGFDFGF[ 5]ZFJF[ K[P H[ 5]ZFJFG[ 5\R ;FC[N CQFL", 9SSZ ;FC[N
G\AZ s5fGF 5]ZFJFYL ;DY"G D/[ K[PVFD4
;NZC]\ VS:DFT
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
253/273
lNG[XEF. DOFEF.
SF[.
AFN
VS:DFTJF/L
SFZDF\YL
V[S
RF[JL;
,,LT U]%TF
H ZLT[
;FC[N
SC[TF[ VFJ[,F[ VG[ OZLIFNLGL GHLS UI[,F[P VG[ OZLIFNLG[ ;F[ZL ;F[ZL
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
254/273
SF[. CSLSTF[ ,BFJ[, G C[FJFG]\ H6FJ[, K[P ;FY[ ;FY[ 5F[T[ :Y/ p5Z
ALPV[DP 0A<I] SFZ RF,SG[ HF[I[, G CF[JFG]\ H6FJ[ K[P
VFD4
ALPV[DP 0A<I] SFZ RF,S V\U[ OZLIFNL ;FC[N G\AZ !!4 ,,LT U]
%TF VG[ ;FC[N G\AZ !Z4 lNG[X DOFEF. RF{WZLV[ CF,GF AGFJGL
DCtJGL CSLSTF[ K]5FJJF DF8[ VG[ ALPV[DP 0A<I] SFZ RF,SGL
VF[/B
;FC[N
VG[ T[JL ALPV[DP 0A<I] SFZ GF RF,S G[ CF,GF VFZF[5L TZLS[ SF[8"
Z]AZ] VF[/BL ATFJTF[
XFC GF[ 5]ZFJF[ K[P H[GF lJZ]wW S[ B\0GSTF" SF[. 5]ZFJF[ ARFJ 51F[ ZH]
YI[,F[ GYLP V,AT
lDT[X lSZ6EF.
:Y/[
255/273
AGFJ
;DI[ CFHZ CF[JF V\U[ ZH] YI[, 5]ZFJF[ X\SF:5N H6FTF[ GYLP SFZ6
S[ ;FC[N G\AZ s!#f GF T[JF 5]ZFJFG[ VF\S *( GF AGFJJF/L HuIFGF
5\RGFDF\ H6FJ[, CSLSTF[YL ;DY"G D/[ K[P H[ 5\RGFDF D]HA 56
AGFJ :Y/[
HLH[v!vS[SI] v$)&_ GL
VS:DFTJF/F RFZ Z:TF V[ 5lxRD AFH]V[ 50[, CF[JFG]\ VG[ T[GF 0FAL
AFH]
VFU/GF
CF[JFGF[
VG[
T[
8FIZGL
SFZG[
Z]FP
p5Z
,L;F[8F[
!54___qv
G]]\
50L
UI[,
G]S;FG
YI[,
CF[JFGF[ 5]ZFJF[ K[P ;FY[ ;FY[ ;FC[N G\AZ s!#f GF 5]ZFJF D]HA 56
CF,GF[ AGFJJF/F[ VS:DFT GF YF[0F ;DI 5C[,F\ H
5|[DR\NGUZ
ZF[0 p5Z ;NZ ALPV[DP 0A<I] SFZ RF,S[ ;FC[N G\AZ !# GL V[;[g8
SFZ G[ 0FAL AFH]V[ VF[JZ8[S SZTF\ 4 ;FC[N G\AZ !#GL UF0L VFU/GL
AFH]V[ AF[G8
[ G[ S|[; SZL GLS/L UI[, CF[JFGF[ 5]ZFJF[ K[P VFD ;FC[N
G\AZ s!#fGL UF0LG[ 56 CF,GF VS:DFTGF YF[0F ;DI 5C[,F\ H
CF,GF VS:DFT DF\ ;\0F[JFI[, ALPV[DP 0A<I] SFZYL G]S;FG YI[,
CF[JFGF[ 5]ZFJF[ K[P VF\S *(GF AGFJJF/L HuIFGF 5\RGFDFYL ;DY"G
D/[ K[P VFD ;FC[N G\AZ !# GL AGFJ :Y/[ CFHZL V\U[ X\SF
p5l:YT YFI T[D GYLP
!&)P!
CF,GF
VgJI[
5F[TFGF
GFD[ CF[JFG]\ :JLSFZ[, K[P V,AT VFZF[5LV[ SZ[, B],F;F D]HA TFZLB
Z$qZqZ_!# GF ZF[H ZFT|LGF VZ;FDF\ 5F[TFGL ALPV[DP 0A<I]\ SFZ
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
256/273
VS:DFTDF\ ;\0F[JFI[,
SFZ6
CF[JFG]\ H6FJL
VG[ JFCGF[ 3ZGF S\d5Fpg0DF\ 50L ZC[TF CF[. 4 H[G[ HZ]Z 50[ T[ jIlST 4
3ZGF\ VG[
T[VF[GF 0=F.JZF[G[
UF0L ,. HTF CTF VG[ AGFJGF lNJ;[ T[J]\ H AG[, CT]\ H[ VFZF[5LGF
ARFJDF\
VlWlGIDGL
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
257/273
VFZF[5LGF HD6F CFYGL SF[6L VG[ SF\0F JrR[ V\NZ GF EFU[ JFU[,FG]\
lGXFG CT]\P JW]\DF\ VFZF[5LGL TALAL T5F;
VFZF[5LG[
.HFVF[
YI[,
CF[JFGF[
5]ZFJF[
K[
H[
lGJ[NG
NZdIFG
V[JF[
B],F;F[
SZ[,
,F[SF[GL
EL0 CTL T[ 8F[/FV[ T[G[ WSS[ R-FJ[, CTF[ VG[ WSSF D]SSL SZL
B[\RTF6 SZ[, CTL VG[ T[YL JW] DFZ G 50[ T[ C[T]\ YL 5F[,L; :8[XGDF\
5F[T[ NF[0LG[ HTF\ ZC[,FP JW]DF\ V[JF[ B],F;F[ SZ[,F[ K[ S[4 5F[,L; :8[XG
GL V\NZ 56 ,F[SF[ VG[ DL0LIF SDL"VF[ GF[ 8F[/\] CT]\ VG[ T[ NZdIFG
WSSFD]SSL
V[JF[
B],F;F[
SZ[,F[
K[
S[4
;F\HGF
S,FS
5q#_
,F[SF[ VG[ DL0LIF SDL"VF[ CTF VG[ tIF\ 56 WSSF D]SSL Y. CTL
VG[ 0F[S8Z[ HIFZ[ T[VF[G[ T5F;[, tIFZ[ T[G[ .HFVF[GF[ bIF, VFJ[,F[P
T[YL 5F[T[
D]HA TFZLB
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
258/273
Z*qZqZ_!#GF
ZF[H
;JFZ[
GJ
JFU[
5F[T[
HIFZ[
J:T|F5]Z
5F[,L; :8[XGDF\ CFHZ YJF UI[,F tIFZ[ T[DH ;F\HGF 5F\R ;F0F 5F\R
GF VZ;FDF\ VFZF[5LG[ CF[l:58, ,. HJFDF\ VFJ[, tIFZ[ ;\bIFA\W ,F[SF[
VG[ DL0LIF SDL"VF[
YTF\
.HFVF[ YI[, T[ V\U[ VFZF[5L RF[SS; GYLP ;FY[ ;FY[ VFZF[5LV[ VFJL
CSLST[ SF[. ;FC[NG[ SF[. 5|xG 5]K[, GYL T[DH 0F[S8ZzL G[ VFJL SF[.
CSLST HFC[Z SZ[, G CTL4
H6FTF[ GYLP
!&)P#
JW]DF\4 ;FC[N
VFZF[5LV[ 4 T[VF[ Z]AZ] lC:8=L VF5TF\ H6FJ[, CT]\ S[4 VFZF[5LG[ ZF[0
V[S;L0g8T[GL
SFZ
ALPV[DP
0A<I]
;LV[RP_!vV[.v)#&_
R,FJTF CF[JFG]\
CF[JFG]\ :5Q856[ O,LT YFI K[P H[ D[0LS, VF[lO;Z T8:Y ;FC[N K[P
VG[ VFZ[F5L ;FY[ SF[. jN[QFEFJ S[ N]xDGFJ8 CF[[I T[JL SF[. CSLST
ARFJ 51F Z[S0" p5Z ,FJL XS[, GYLP ;FY[ ;FY[ VFZF[5LG[ BF[8L
ZLT[ U]gCFDF\ ;\0F[JL N[JF DF8[ D[0LS, VF[lO;ZG[ SF[. SFZ6 CF[I T[JL
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
259/273
CSLST 56 ARFJ 51F Z[S0" p5Z ,FJL XS[, GYLP T[JF ;\HF[[UF[DF\
D[0LS, VF[lO;ZGF[ p5ZF[ST 5]ZFJF[ GlC DFGJFG[ S[F. SFZ6 GYLP
!&)P$
JW]DF\4
VFD4
p5ZF[ST
;DU|
5]ZFJF[
wIFGDF\
,[TF\4
CT\]
VG[ SF[6 R,FJT\] CT]\ T[JL CSLST[ VFZF[5LV[ SF[. B],F;F[ SZ[,F[ GYL
VG[
T[YL
VFZF[5LG[
VFZF[5LG[ VS:DFT
YI[,
.HFVF[
wIFGDF\
,[TF\4
56
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
260/273
GF
ZF[H
;JFZGF
;F0F
VZ;FDF\
CFHZ
YI[,P
K[P
;FY[
;FY[
VS:DFT
AFN4
VS:DFTGF
:Y/[YL
T[JL
VFZF[5LGL
AF[HF[
BF;
HF6SFZLGL
CSLSTF[
;FlAT
VFZF[5L p5Z CF[JF KTF\ T[JL CSLSTF[ VFZF[5LV[ SF[. ;\TF[QF HGS
B],F;F[ SZ[,F[ GYL VG[ T[YL AGFJ ;DI[ VFZF[5L H JFCG R,FJTF
CF[JFG]\ VFZF[5L lJZ]wW 4 lJZ]wWG]\ VG]DFG
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
261/273
AGFJ ;DI[ JFCG C\SFZTF CTFP VG[ T[JF AGFJDF\ A[ I]JFG KF[SZFVF[
U\ELZ ZLT[ .HFU|:T CF,TDF\ ZF[0 p5Z 50[, CF[JF KTF\ VFZF[5L T[VF[GL
NZSFZ SIF" l;JFI tIFF\YL EFUL UI[, C[FJFG]\ :5Q8 56[ O,LT YFI K[P
VG[ T[YL AGFJ 5KL GF T]ZT GF ;DIDF\ 4 VFZF[5LGL JT"6]\S WL 5]ZFJF
VlWlGIDGL S,D ( D]HA wIFGDF\ ,. XSFI P
!*#
VFXZ[ ;F0F AFZGF VZ;FDF\ AG[,F[ CTF[P HIFZ[ VFZF[5L 5F[,L; ;D1F
TFZLB
Z*qZqZ_!#
GF
ZF[H
;JFZGF
VZ;FDF\
CFHZ
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
262/273
CSLST[ OZLIFN 51F[ ZH] YI[, 5]ZFJF[ wIFGDF\ ,.X]\ TF[4 CF,GF AGFJGF
NFX"lGS
;FC[NF[ K[P VG[ AGFJ ;DI[ T[DG]\ SF.G[8LS CF[g0F ,. T[DH 5<;Z
DF[8Z ;FIS,
VG[ XLJD 5|[DX\SZ NJ[ ;NZC] AF.S p5Z 5FK/ A[9[, CTF T[ DF[8Z
;FIS,YL OZLIFNL R,FJTF CTF T[ SF.G[8LS CF[g0F RFZ O]8 5FK/ CT]P
VFD JFCG S[JL UlTYL VFJT]\ CT]
A\gG[ NFX"lGS ;FC[NF[GF[ 5]ZFJF[ GlC DFGJFG[ SF[. SFZ6 GYLP ;FY[
;FY[ CF,GF AGFJGF YF[0F ;DI 5C[,F\ H HHLh A\U,F RFZ Z:TFYL
5|[DR\N GUZ ZF[[0 p5Z
;FC[N G\AZ !# GF VF[ 56 SFZ R,FJTF CF[.4 ZF[0 p5Z JFCGGL UlT
S[8,L CX[[ T[ V\U[GF[ 5]ZFJF[ 5F[TFGF SFZ R,FJJFGF VG]EJYL H6FJTF
CF[. 4JFCG S[8,L :5L0[ CX[ T[GF[ V\NFH AF\WL
JFCGGL UlT
V\U[GF[ 5]ZFJF[ ZH] SZTF CF[. T[JF[ T[VF[GF[ 5]ZFJF[ GlC DFGJFG[ SF[.
SFZ6 GYL P
!*$P!
VS:DFTDF\
;\0F[JFI[,
ALPV[DP
0A<I]
SFZGL
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
h05
263/273
T[VF[ AGFJ :Y/[ V[S 0[DF[ HL%;L SFZ 5_ lS,F[DL8ZGL h05[ R,FJL
T[GF[ JL0LIF[ Z[SF[0L"U SZL4 VG[ T[GL O|[DF[ GF ;DI VFWFZ[ ,1DL UF\9LIF
ZY GF ;L;L8LJL O]8[H GL
VS:DFTDF\ ;\0F[JFI[,
0FIuGF[ DXLG SG[S8 SZL VG[ ZL5F[8" HGZ[8 SZTF\ 5F[TFGF DF[AF.,
p5Z :S|LG XF[8 ,LW[, VG[ T[ p5ZYL T[VF[G[ V[J]\ H6FI[, CT\] S[4
UF0LDF\ VFJ[, V[ZA[UGL 5C[,L V[ZA[U !*#Z VFZP5LPV[DP p5Z S[|[X
YI[, CTLP VG[
VFZP5LPV[DP
T[JL H VG[ T[ H
V[S:5|[; CF.J[
p5Z
!*#Z
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
264/273
h05 !!_v!Z_
;FC[N[ 5F[T[ H HFT[ H 0[DF[:8[=XG SZ[, CT\]P JW]DF\ ALPV[DP 0A<I] SFZ GF
0L,ZGF HGZ, D[G[HZ K[P VG[ 5F[TFGF VG]EJ VFWFZ[ VG[ 5F[T[ SZ[,
0[D[F:8[=XG VFWFZ[ H6FJTF CF[. 4 ;FC[NGF[ 5]ZFJF[ lJxJ;GLI
VG[ VFWFZE]T H6FI K[P
!*5P!
!#
UF[lJNGL
AFA]HL
JF3[,FV[
5ZL1F6
SZ[,
;BT
ZLT[
AFH]V[ VW"JT]"/FSFZ[
hF0
;FY[
VY0FTF\
#5
;[DL
V\NZGL
H[ hF0
;FY[ VY0FI[, T[ hF0 GDL UI[, VG[ A[ DL8Z GL pRF. ;]WL KF,
pTZL
>hF0
!*&
SL,F[DL8Z
5|lT S,FSGL h05[ R,FJ[, CF[JFG]\ :5Q856[ O,LT YFI K[P JW]DF\
VFZP8LPVF[P VlWSFZL ;FC[N G\AZ !& 4 lJHI S]DFZ BF[0LNF; XFC GF
5]ZFJF D]HA VS:DFTDF\ ;\0F[JFI[,
265/273
SZTF\ JW] h05[ ;NZC] ALPV[DP0A<I] SFZ R,FJ[, CF[JFGF[ 5]ZFJF[ K[P
JW]DF\4 VDNFJFN XC[Z 5F[,L; SDLxGZ CS]DT
C[9/GF lJ:TFZDF\
VFJ[,F V[S;5|[; J[4 G[XG, CF.J[ VG[ :8[8 CF.J[ TYF VgI DFUF["
p5Z RF[SS; S[JF 5|SFZGF JFCGF[GL DCTD UlT
S[8,L CF[JL
HF[.V[ T[ DIF"NF GSSL SZT]\ HFC[ZGFD] 5F[,L; SDLxGZ[ HFC[Z SZ[, CT]P
H[ OZLIFN 51F[ VF\S !!5 YL ;NZC] HFC[ZGFD] ZH] SZ[, K[P T[ D]HA
V[S;5|[; J[ p5Z OF[ZjCL,Z GL DCTD UlT 5|lT
S,FSGF
!__
UlT 5|lT
HFC[Z SZ[,
T[J]\
JW]
UlTYL
VS:DFTDF\
;\0F[JFI[,
SFZ
VS:DFT
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
266/273
VFZF[5L H
VG[ T[JF AGFJJF/F ZF[0 p5Z ZC[TF 8=FOLS GL HF6SFZL CF[JF KTF\4
HFC[ZZF[0
R,FJ[, CF[JFG]\ ;FlAT YFI K[P VFD4 VFZF[5L VlTXI h05[ UF0L
R,FJL A[OFD56[ VG[ A[NZSFZL EIF" 5F[TFG]\ S'tI EIHGS 5|SFZG]\
C[FJFGL HF6SFZL ;FY[ VG[ T[JF S'tIYL D'tI[]\ YFI T[J]\ 5lZ6FD
VFJJFGL XSITF
C[FJFGL HF6SFZL
;FY[
VFZF[5LG[ HF6SFZL CTL S[ JW] h05 YL HFC[Z ZF[0 p5Z JFCG R,FJJFGF
5F[TFG]\ S'tI EIHGS CT\] VG[ HF6TF CTF S[ 5F[TFG]]\ JFCG S\g8=F[,
ACFZ HFI S[ S\g8=F[, G SZL XSFI T[F ;FD[ VFJTF JFCGG[ VY0FI
VYJF V0O[8DF\
VFJL HJFGL
U]gCF
JW]DF\4
VFZF[5LGF
S'tIYL
JFCGF[G[
G]S;FG
5CF[RF0L
267/273
!*(
VFD4 p5ZF[ST TDFD RRF" SIF" D]HA4 OZLIFN 51FP[ ZH] YI[,
5]ZFJF[ wIFGDF\ ,[TF\4 4 VFZF[5LV[ EFZTLI N\0 ;\lCTFGL S,D #_$
s5F8"vFFfD]HAGF[ 4 S,FS $Z* D]HAGF[ TYF WL D[F8Z jCLS,D V[S8
GL S,D !#$s!fsALf ;FY[ JF\RTF\ S,D !**4!($ D]HAGF lX1FF
5FT| U]gCF SZ[, C[FJFG]\ ;FlAT YFI K[ VG[ T[YL D]NF G\AZ Z YL $ GF
HJFA CSFZDF\ VF5JFDF\ VFJ[ K[ VG[ GLR[ D]HA C]SD SZJFDF\ VFJ[ K[P
C] S D
VFZF[5L
J[5FZ4
SFI"Z LTL
VlWlGIDGL
S,D
Z#5sZf
268/273
!*)
EF[U
VF[KFDF\ VF[KL S[4 T|6 JQF" ;]WLGL ;HF SZJFDF\ VFJ[ TF[ VFZF[5L p5,L
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
269/273
VNF,T ;D1F V[5|F[R SZL XS[P JW]D\F V[JL ZH]VFT SZ[,L K[ S[4
VFZ[F5LG[ JW] ;HF VG[ EF[U AGGFZFVF[G[ JW] J/TZ V5FJJFGL A\gG[
VFSZL ;HFVF[ V[S ;FY[ SZJL HF[.V[ GlCP JW]D\F V[JL ZH]VFT SZ[,L
K[ S[ VFZF[5LGF[ SF[. U]gCFlCT .lTCF; GYL VG[ I]JFG JIGF K[P
T[JF ;\HF[UF[DF\ VFZF[5LG[ VF[KFDF\ VF[KL ;HF SZJF VZH SZ[, K[P
!(_
OZLIFN 51F[
ZH]VFT V[JL K[ S[4 AGFJ ;DI[4 AGFJ AgIF AFN VFZF[5L V[ .HF
5FDGFZFVF[GL SF[. NZSFZ ,LW[, G CTL VG[ ;FZJFZ D/L ZC[ T[JF S[F.
5|ItGF[ SZ[,F G CTFP 5Z\T]\ :Y/ p5ZYLVFZF[5L EFUL UI[, CTF
T[ wIFGDF\
CTLP
VFZF[5LV[
OZLIFN
51F[
VUFp
JW]DF\
NFZ]
V[JL
5L
ZH]VFT
G[
SZ[,
K[
JFCG
JWTF\
HFI
K[P
VG[
CF,GF
U]gCFDF\A[
I]JFG
;HFGF
270/273
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
271/273
5|DF6[
!_4__4___v__
U6FX[ VG[ T[JL ZSD R]SJL VF5JF DF8[ VFZF[5L ;1FD CF[JFG]\ H6FI
K[P p5ZF[ST ;\HF[UF[DF\ ;HF V\U[ GLR[ D]HA C]SD SZJFDF\ VFJ[ K[P
C] S
!P
VFZF[5L
J[5FZ4
Z]l 5IF
5rRL;
CHFZGF[
N\0 4
Z]l5IF
!4___qvV\S[
Z]l5IF
V[S
CHFZGF[
N\04
VG[ HF[ VFZ[F5L N\0GL ZSD G EZ[ TF[ JW]\ V[S DlCGFGL ;FNL
S[NGL ;HF EF[UJJFGF[ VFYL C]SD SZJFDF\ VFJ[ K[P
#P
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
272/273
S,D $Z* D]HAGF U]gCF DF8[ V[S s!f JZ;GL ;FNL S[NGL
;HF VG[ Z]l5IF 54___qvV\S[ Z]l5IF 5F\R CHFZGF[ N\04 VG[ HF[
VFZ[F5L N\0GL ZSD G EZ[ TF[ JW]\ V[S DlCGFGL ;FNL S[NGL ;HF
EF[UJJFGF[ VFYL C]SD SZJFDF\ VFJ[ K[P
$P
5P
&P
VFZF[5L
SFRF
SFDGF
S[NL
TZLS[
H[,DF\
ZC[,
!_
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).
273/273
OF[HNFZL
SFI"ZLTL
VlWlGIDGL
S,D
#$$
VgJI[ XF[ SF[h GF[8L; VF5JF GF[ C]SD SZJFDF\ VFJ[ K[P
!!
VFZ[F5LG]\
;HF
JF[Z\8
EZL
4VD,JFZL
DF8[
;\A\WLT
s5LPV[D P 58[, f4
UICGJ00288
ALHF V[0LXG, ;[;g; HH
VDNFJFNsU|FdIf DLZHF5]Z4VDNFJFN P
/BVDESAI/PA/
SC No. 41/2013 State V/s Vishamay Amitbhai Shah IPC 279,427,304(ii),M.V.Act 177,184,134(b)(1).